Title: S1 Bonus: Car Gonzalez Thriller Crypto After Dark Crossover Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Car Gonzalez, host of the Thriller Crypto podcast (Thriller After Dark crossover) Published: 2019-02-02 Duration: 1:43:58 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2019-02-03_car_gonzalez_bitcoin_takeover_podcast_.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2019-02-03_car_gonzalez_bitcoin_takeover_podcast_.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:46] Car Gonzalez: Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to our first ever Thriller After Dark. Today we have Vlad Costea. [00:00:54] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's fine. [00:00:57] Car Gonzalez: I'm sorry, Vlad. I know you pushed me on your last name and one day I'll get it. Thanks for coming on the show. [00:01:03] Vlad Costea: It doesn't matter. I had John Carvalho on my show, on the podcast, which I'm about to release next week. And I called him Carvalho because it's C-R... L-V-H-O. But it's supposed to be pronounced as Carvalho and he told me after the show and I was very upset because I didn't know that. So... It happens. [00:01:27] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, I'm sorry. [00:01:29] Vlad Costea: Don't worry, it's part of being European, I guess. And not coming or not having origins from a country which is English-speaking, so this is bound to happen. [00:01:44] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, I love your first name though, Vlad. It has a nice solid ring to it. It's very strong. [00:01:51] Vlad Costea: It has one syllable. And it actually means strong. [00:01:56] Car Gonzalez: Does it really? Oh, wow. It feels strong. I love it. [00:01:59] Vlad Costea: It comes from Old Slavic and "Volod" in Old Russian means power. And Vlad means something like a prince or ruler of the land or something. [00:02:12] Car Gonzalez: Nice. Well, let's talk crypto. That's why we're here, right? [00:02:18] Vlad Costea: Yeah, let's talk crypto. [00:02:19] Car Gonzalez: Their way of calling stuff out, right? When I look to crypto websites and journalists, you guys do a really good job of investigating this stuff like you did on this one. There's really great articles you guys are just covering there at Crypto Insider. And your work is phenomenal. [00:02:41] Vlad Costea: Well, thank you. I try. That's what I get paid for. I guess we all try to do well in our jobs. [00:02:49] Car Gonzalez: Yeah. And one quick point. I will say that podcasts, for me, what I've come to realize, a lot of people listen to podcasts. And the type of demo that you get for podcasts, people, you know, they say that people that listen to podcasts tend to have college degrees or are professionals in the workspace or they make this amount of money. There's all these statistics for them. None of that matters, right? But you actually spread the message better through podcasts. And when that reaches, and I've seen it happen multiple times with our podcast, we start covering something that no one's talking about. [00:03:33] Car Gonzalez: Another podcast picks it up. A bigger podcast picks it up. And then that reaches, you know, crypto YouTube or that reaches, you know, or it's informed by y'all, the journalists. I take so much information from journalists on a daily basis. When it comes to presenting the news or presenting any stuff whatsoever, I'm always reading up on every single website and trying to learn as much as I can in the brief amount of time I have before I air. And I feel like it's our job, it's our duty to do this because no one's going to talk about it. [00:04:12] Car Gonzalez: I feel like crypto YouTube is just a reiteration of itself. If you go on there, a lot of them just talk about themselves, or they talk about stuff that everybody else is talking about. It's very reverbish. Like, no one's... There's nothing new, you know, that's going on there. Every once in a while, somebody will surprise you and deliver something new, and those are the people that I really enjoy because they're actually bringing something new to light. [00:04:32] Car Gonzalez: But for the most part, crypto YouTube just, it's a reverberation. They're all talking about the same things. Crypto Twitter, meme central, right? And crypto Reddit, it's so hard to... You can find some good stuff there, but it's so hard to get your point across. But stuff can be examined there and good stuff can come out of there, but most of the time it's very hostile, right? [00:05:02] Car Gonzalez: But I will say for certain that if it starts with us, like if we don't start talking about this, other people in this space won't talk about it. Crypto Twitter won't make those memes. You have to police the space yourself. You have to do your due diligence and just do what's right. I don't know. I'm going to get off my soapbox, but that's just how I feel. What do you think, Vlad? [00:05:23] Vlad Costea: I think the best way to police the crypto space is to remind people about the core values of Bitcoin and tell them what it's all about. As it's not just the speculative aspect that some people see when they trade and they say, "This hasn't gone up more than 5% in the last week, so I'm not going to invest in it." That's not a wrong perspective to have in hindsight. Maybe that it's healthy for people who trade to think about it in these terms. And it's helpful for the industry at large to have traders. [00:06:02] Vlad Costea: They bring money and they are the ones who actually ensure that there is a volume which gets traded on a daily basis, so they are useful. But Bitcoin is about decentralization, being sovereign on your own funds, having the freedom to run your own node and participate in the network. A lot of people are not aware, but when you run a node, you actually have voting power. So whenever somebody tries to impose new rules on the network, and I guess the most dangerous consensus change can be about the 21 million supply. [00:06:45] Vlad Costea: And some people have actually run analysis and very extensive mathematical hypotheses, and they figured out that miners are actually better off with a larger supply and fewer halvings of the supply. So if somebody actually changed to make it maybe 40 million bitcoins, there would be much more profitability for the miners. And it's in their best interest to try to change the rules. But when you run a node, you're actually countering any maneuver by a miner to do that. And you're disincentivizing people from trying to launch attacks. The more nodes you have, the more consensus you're going to have about the fixed supply and the block size and all the other rules. [00:07:42] Vlad Costea: So in a sense, that's one of the values of Bitcoin. And then there's the idea that it's immutable and it's unconfiscatable. There is no central authority to tell you where to store it, what to do with it. Nobody can take it away from you. That's just the beauty of being in charge of your own money. And if you want to participate in the mining process, you can just do it. You just buy a mining rig and you do it. Maybe you're not going to be as successful. [00:08:15] Vlad Costea: As people who do it on the industrial scale. But it's still possible, whereas in ERC20 tokens or in proof of stake, it's all about just being a participant. And in some proof of stake systems, you get coins according to how much you already own. And that's also going to be Ethereum 2.0. So it's in a sense an oligarchy where the richer people only get richer. Whereas in Bitcoin, it's always about the system of changing elites to mine the coin and maybe run out of business, just like Bitmain is doing right now. [00:08:59] Vlad Costea: They're doing very poorly. They're having a bad performance. Their Antminers are not selling like they used to. So they're going to leave much more space for other companies to step in and do the same kind of work. Or maybe that one day we will all end up having our own mining rigs in our homes. And that's going to be the ultimate level of decentralization. It's really interesting. And when China bans mining, you're going to see how the mining rigs get moved. And then you have the Blockstream Satellite, which allows anyone to synchronize the blockchain without internet connection with just a mesh antenna and a laptop. [00:09:44] Vlad Costea: And that's also a way to actually participate in the consensus and potentially do mining in places which have no internet access, like in the middle of the desert. [00:09:58] Vlad Costea: So there's a lot going on. When you think of other projects, you don't have this kind of investment. You don't have the same smart developers who even think about short radio waves using these small antennas or radio transmitters to relay information about the blockchain so it can synchronize without any restrictions for governments. Because in the Cold War you had short radio waves which were sent across borders by countries to bypass all the Cold War protocols and restrictions and send messages across, like in the Soviet Union. And that's very brilliant. [00:10:46] Vlad Costea: When you think about nowadays about the Chinese firewall, that can be bypassed by radio waves which can be intercepted, they can be distorted. But the nature of the signal cannot be changed, and that's essential. And those are just a few of the qualities that Bitcoin has and no other project is going to have anytime soon. So if you think about all these ideas, maybe that you should not invest in something else and you should be skeptical about the five-year or the 10-year prospect of any other project. Maybe I'm not a financial advisor. [00:11:34] Car Gonzalez: Yeah. All great points, you know. Bitcoin, Bitcoin to me, I really believe it can change the world and it's one of those things that when you discover about it, when you learn about it, you really understand that there's no one that's in control of just the entire network of it. I feel like these days, I mean, if you look at the dollar, for Christ's sake, we're at like $20 trillion. The dollar is the global reserve currency. At some point, that's gonna just blow up in everybody's faces. [00:12:21] Car Gonzalez: There is no other exit but Bitcoin. Like, I'm not a person that agrees with... I'm a person who believes in using Bitcoin and purchasing it with fiat and either, you know, giving it away to somebody or outright paying with it in any way I can. There's absolutely no way would I ever sell Bitcoin for fiat. I'm just not going to do that. Like, and I think it took me... It didn't take me that long to discover like the possibilities that were with Bitcoin and just participating in the network itself and transacting on it. [00:13:03] Car Gonzalez: I think people lose sight of it being an actual cryptocurrency. They try to use it as a store of value. And that's cool. To each their own. You get whatever you want out of Bitcoin. But I think the killer feature of it all is it's the only decentralized currency in the entire world that we all view as having value. I mean, and it has its own payment rail. Like, it's going to get better with time. It doesn't make any sense for you not to throw fiat into Bitcoin because that fiat's going to be worthless. [00:13:35] Car Gonzalez: When everything breaks. I don't know, maybe I'm a doom and gloomer, but I'm just a big believer in Bitcoin being another currency in the world that people will just use. It'll probably take years or it'll probably take a product as big as the iPhone, but we'll need that singular product for the crypto space. It'll come. It'll probably take that type of product for the crypto space or for Bitcoin or for whatever currency, but it's going to happen. And when that happens, people aren't going to not use cryptocurrencies. [00:14:12] Car Gonzalez: They're gonna use them. This is how the future is. I don't know, I'm just bullish on cryptocurrency just in general. I'm a fan of the technology. Don't get me wrong, like I love looking at every project and diving into it and learning about it and seeing all the cool stuff that it's going to do or has potential to do. But when it comes to Bitcoin, that one just has my heart. There's nothing... In my mind, that comes close to a currency like Bitcoin. [00:14:45] Car Gonzalez: Like at all. Yeah, you can use Ethereum, you can use Litecoin, other stuff for payments and stuff like that. And it's great for stuff like that or for transferring. You know, like today we just gave out some Litecoin on our show, just to give it out. But Bitcoin is one, I give that out too, but Bitcoin is one that I'm like, I'd much rather pay with it than turn it back to fiat. I just don't see the point of it. But I know people like to, you know, they want to see that Bitcoin go to 20,000 or whatever. [00:15:19] Car Gonzalez: And then they want to sell it for fiat. And I'm like, that's ridiculous. Why would you sell it for fiat? Like, go out and use it with that value priced in. I don't know. Maybe I'm just naive, I guess. I don't know. [00:15:36] Vlad Costea: I was actually having this conversation on Twitter with Peter Todd, who is a developer for Bitcoin Core, and he is a very brilliant person. And he said at one point that he believes that we need cash. And I agree with him in the sense that you need the kind of money which is fungible and is private. If the two of us exchange a dollar bill, nobody's going to know where it went and what happened to it. While with Bitcoin, at this point, before any kind of privacy upgrades... [00:16:13] Vlad Costea: You don't have any kind of privacy at all. You can actually check on the blockchain and see every transaction. And the best you can do is use Wasabi Wallet to merge your coins and they appear in a stacked number of transactions which are hard to trace. So this is just an obfuscation which is temporary. At this point, it's not fungible. [00:16:38] Vlad Costea: And up to the point when we can have the privacy which allows us to not distinguish between the coins which were minted last week and the ones which were used on the Silk Road, then we're not going to really have a valuable or a functional Bitcoin in the true sense that it's ready for the real world. And up to that point, at least up to that point, we need fiat money and we need cash, because with credit cards, it's so easy to check every transaction and the banks have absolute control over how you use it and how much you withdraw from your account. [00:17:22] Vlad Costea: And they have daily limits of how much you can withdraw. And sometimes they ask you to fill in forms and explain why you want to take away money from your account, because it makes no sense to them. [00:17:38] Vlad Costea: Why would you want to take cash? And you can just pay with your credit card anywhere. But that's a slippery slope with the cashless society or what they call it. And I agreed with Peter Todd that Bitcoin is much more like the kind of collectible which is scarce and valuable and cannot be confiscated. And it exists on the internet just because cryptography allows it to not be confiscated. And if it was a physical product, it would get seized by governments and confiscated and we would not be able to have this. [00:18:19] Vlad Costea: So this didn't happen until the internet age and the age when cryptography got developed, just because we did not have the means. But it doesn't mean at the same time that we are witnessing another product which tries to bring the dream of banks of removing cash and replacing it with electronic transactions. Bitcoin is not really electronic cash, even though it says in the white paper "electronic cash system." It's much more of a valuable asset, which is much more akin to gold, and works more as a commodity at this point. [00:19:02] Vlad Costea: And with the Lightning Network, which is more private than the main chain, you're going to have quicker and cheaper transactions, even at the micro level. So the bottom line of all this long argument is that we actually need cash. And not Bitcoin Cash, but Bitcoin needs cash. [00:19:26] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, no, yeah, I just, you know, call me a spook or whatever, tinfoil hat, but I just don't think cash... Are you talking, when you say cash, are you talking about like US dollar or are you just talking about any type of cash? [00:19:41] Vlad Costea: Any type of cash which is not highly inflationary and for which you can do exchanges. Like you meet somebody and you say, "I'm going to give you one Bitcoin and you're going to give me in cash the equivalent, $3,500." And you're going to agree and this is a fair exchange. So this is better than going to exchanges and taking money away, because you expose your personal data. You go through that whole KYC/AML process. And even if you're not a bad actor, you want some privacy. [00:20:20] Vlad Costea: You don't want everyone to know what you're doing. You don't want the bank to have a complete record of your activity. That's actually Orwellian. And when you demand for privacy, you actually care about the freedom of our society. I think there's so much more at stake than maybe the $10 that you spend on something which you find shameful, like, you know, a porn subscription or something. You've paid for one month of membership on... Tell me a name of a porn site. Razors or something. I can't think of anything. [00:21:00] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, you can't think of one. I can't think of one off the top of my head. [00:21:04] Vlad Costea: But you want to pay for that. [00:21:06] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, I see what you're saying. [00:21:08] Vlad Costea: And you want privacy. And that's a fundamental human right, theoretically. But the credit card company can actually track down and see to which company you've sent the money. Yeah, that's dangerous for our democracies and for our political systems. As we're going to get to the point where... Actually, I think we got to that point where banks are extensions of the states. And they provide full documentation about you and what you do on request. [00:21:40] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, 100%, they do that. [00:21:42] Vlad Costea: So if they want to extend that and make it even more authoritative and controlling, they can actually check every transaction and make sure they can use any kind of argument like to avoid terrorist funding. They are going to use this. The public is going to eat it up and say we are doing this for our own protection, because the times are so dangerous and we want to be protected. And that's a slippery slope in itself, as the state turns us into potential criminals, instead of actually looking for the exception within this large group, they turn us all into potential criminals. [00:22:29] Vlad Costea: And to me, that's not the kind of world that I want to live in. And I don't think life is worth living in a place where you cannot have any kind of privacy. And that's also one of the reasons why we need cash, because that's from where I started. Because cash is not tracked. It doesn't leave marks. Maybe it leaves like fingerprints at most. Other than that, you're not sure if the dollar bill in your pocket was owned by Pablo Escobar at some point. [00:23:09] Vlad Costea: There is no way for you to know that and there is no way the government actually cares. It doesn't. [00:23:17] Car Gonzalez: Yeah. Yeah, I want privacy. You know, I think privacy is important. I just think at this point, you just got to realize that you're already being tracked, right? So even if you wanted to, you know, avoid getting hacked or even trying to hide your identity or your real identity or something like that, no, people can find out who you are. They can find out where you live. They can do all these things. The government can do it right now, if they wanted to, right? But I ultimately think that the more we move into this kind of, how do you say that? Orwellian? How do you say that guy's last name? Orwell, George Orwell, so [00:24:14] Vlad Costea: it's Orwellian. [00:24:16] Car Gonzalez: Orwellian. I have trouble pronouncing stuff. So when you go into that kind of future, I feel like, I mean, you're battling a behemoth, right? It's almost you're being forced to live in public. And that's good and bad because you get rid of people from being pieces of shit, right? To each other, and maybe the world becomes better. But at the same time, you're ruled by a government that wants to make you even less, more stupid and even more misinformed and, you know, so that goes on. [00:24:56] Car Gonzalez: Or you can battle them and ultimately fight every day to keep your privacy. Man, I hope in the future there's somewhere in between, right, where we could have some things be private and some things be public. But at this point, who knows, man? It's definitely something. I do believe in privacy. I think that we should fight for it. But I also see the other side. I'm kind of torn. I don't know. This is my state of mind these days when it comes to everything. I see two sides and I'm almost caught in the middle, to where I just don't even want to pick a side. [00:25:34] Car Gonzalez: I'm like, well, how do we know which side's gonna win? But I want to play both sides, because I see both sides being important in the future, or maybe one side has one thing that's great about it the other side doesn't. And yeah, I don't know, maybe I'm the only person that thinks like that, but... Yeah, that's kind of my logic behind it. [00:25:55] Vlad Costea: Unfortunately, I come from a country which used to be totalitarian until 30 years ago. We had a dictator, we had a system which was... they called it communist. It wasn't, in the theoretical sense, when you read Karl Marx, it was not really like that. But it was terrible for personal freedom. And if you just said a joke against the dictator, you could just be taken away to a forced labor camp. [00:26:22] Car Gonzalez: And where is that at? [00:26:24] Vlad Costea: I'm Romanian, so the country is called Romania. We were not part of the USSR, which means that we had some kind of autonomy. But at the same time, when a decision was made in Russia, about something, in Moscow more precisely, we had to follow the orders. And there was only one instance when we didn't follow, and that was pretty bad for the country in hindsight, and we have lost some economic means to actually support our day-to-day trades. It was in 1968 when USSR invaded Czechoslovakia, and we refused to actually participate [unclear: with Red Army]. And anyway, I diverged too much. I got sidetracked by the idea, but... [00:27:28] Vlad Costea: It's terrible to live in a world where the government is almighty and knows everything about you. And the American system that you live in was built on the idea of power controls power. It's all about checks and balances. I know that James Madison was obsessed with the idea. And he did not like the British monarchy and the parliamentary system. And that's one of the reasons why you have the president who is held accountable by the Congress. You have these checks and balances which are supposed to constantly create conflict, and when conflict is present, then you know you're not going to have any kind of dictatorship. [00:28:18] Vlad Costea: You're going to have this balance which keeps the society moving forward. And you can never really control. The more you control, the more unpopular you're going to become. And it's all cyclic. It has worked for you for over 200 years. It has influenced the rest of the world. You have no idea how many countries are emulating a similar system. But at the same time, with the internet and everything that goes on electronically, they have the means to store everything about you. [00:28:58] Vlad Costea: And you have many potential bad actors who may not be governmental. Maybe you can assume that you have the secret services and they work in your benefit and do the best to make sure that you're safe, but that's just an assumption. You can never be sure what they actually do. [00:29:13] Car Gonzalez: No one checks them, yeah. [00:29:15] Vlad Costea: But you never know how many intermediaries are in this process. And if the people who actually are employed by the government to take care of you are honest about it, how can you actually check? How can you actually be sure that you're not having your data mishandled, or if you try to run for president in, say, 20 years, you're going to get blackmailed with the shit you said on the internet. We are a whole new generation which gets exposed to this huge risk. [00:29:52] Vlad Costea: And I may be like an angel on the internet and say all the popular stuff and never get into fights, but they can actually access my microphone when it's not turned on, and they can listen to me during my moments when I'm alone, or they can check my webcam and see what I'm doing in my room. They can access my phone. They have complete control over my remote means of communication. [00:30:24] Vlad Costea: And that's why we had the cypherpunk movement in the 1980s in the United States, with people who basically said that privacy is supreme, and it's much more important to have your data private than to be compliant with the laws. That's why they were punks. But they liked cryptography and that's what made them cypher. And through their work, we got inventions like end-to-end encryption. And that's why when you send a message in Signal or WhatsApp, theoretically speaking, unless somebody else has the key for your conversation, there is no way somebody can actually intercept your communication, and you can be sure that no bad actors are involved. [00:31:12] Vlad Costea: And then you had people like Julian Assange, or Assange, I'm not sure how you call him, who for a number of years has been running WikiLeaks and has been exposing governments of the world in their attempts to be abusive. Yeah, and then you had people like David Chaum, who invented DigiCash. And it was the first attempt to actually create a system of digital cash which was encrypted. [00:31:43] Vlad Costea: And then all this series of cypherpunks like Adam Back, who invented Proof of Work as a way of using computing power to prevent spam on the emails. And then you had Wei Dai, who tried to make B-Money, which is similar to the idea of Bitcoin, but did not have all these elements added to it to make it complete. And I guess the closest attempt was Nick Szabo's, who had Bit Gold. And 90% of it was very similar to Satoshi Nakamoto's invention. Right. And he's not even mentioned in the white paper. [00:32:26] Vlad Costea: But anyway, he brought us many innovations from cryptography all the way to the idea of running smart contracts. And I know that in the early days of Ethereum, he was even participating and advising them and giving public talks. I guess this was in 2015 or something. You can still find the lecture on YouTube. [00:32:50] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, Vitalik always brings up Nick all the time. He thinks... I've heard him say that he thinks he's Satoshi, or that would be his first guess. [00:33:02] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's also mine, because why would not Satoshi mention Nick Szabo if he took so many ideas from him? So he mentions everybody else but not Nick Szabo. Plus the whole scenario about going silent all throughout the time when Satoshi was active. [00:33:22] Car Gonzalez: Did you ever see the interview with Nick and Tim Ferriss? There's a podcast and you hear Nick talk about Bit Gold, and he said, "Yeah, first we came up with Bitcoin," or he goes, "I'm sorry, Bit Gold." Like there's this whole like 30 second kind of clip where he's talking to Ferriss and he literally says Bitcoin, but he means Bit Gold. And Tim didn't catch him on it, but he corrects himself. And it's kind of like, wow. Like, is that...? Like, I don't know. [00:34:06] Car Gonzalez: But it's definitely... I know there's been some kind of like actual... Wasn't there some kind of like a penmanship tied to him as well too? I think the CIA was able to run some study that was covered, I guess, maybe in Wired or some tech magazine, that was able to find out that the way he wrote on the internet was very similar to what he was doing. I don't know if I have that right or not, but there's just a lot of different things that you brought up. [00:34:41] Vlad Costea: I don't think that podcast reveals anything. Did you listen to it? Yeah, it makes a lot of sense for him to think about the invention which works and which he mentioned in his articles, as opposed to what he came up with prior to that. So it's the term that you use more generally. So sometimes I confuse in my mind, maybe it's because I'm not a native in English, but I say Lightning instead of Litecoin. [00:35:09] Car Gonzalez: Oh, okay. [00:35:10] Vlad Costea: They both have the "light" in their names, and sometimes I mess it up in my mind. And when I have to say Lightning and Litecoin, it's like mind-blowing. It takes some extra effort. I have to think about it. [00:35:27] Car Gonzalez: Maybe that's what happened with him. I don't know. Just some things that are just curious about his background and stuff in regards to that. He's one of the smartest guys I've ever had the chance to... Have you talked to him? [00:35:43] Vlad Costea: A bit, but in tweets, like exchanging some ideas from time to time. I tried to message him twice. He doesn't respond to DMs. I don't even try. So when I see that he doesn't reply, I say, "Okay, just leave him alone." He's a cypherpunk. He likes privacy. So whatever it is that I'm asking him is just unimportant. He writes all these great articles. He has a brilliant mind and all this knowledge in so many fields. [00:36:15] Vlad Costea: I feel in many ways, and I feel sorry that I mentioned Richard Heart in the same sentence, but Richard Heart tries to be him and have knowledge from all these fields. The only difference is that one is overly public and tries to build a persona and a character, while the other is trying to hide away as much as he can. And he only goes to... I think last year and this year he went to a few conferences and made talks about... Usually he likes to present public scalability as an important issue, and how we can actually achieve it. [00:36:58] Vlad Costea: The premise of scalability as a social element is that we live as humans in this world with limited resources. And we actually have to find ways to coexist, to share all the resources that we have, and make sure that we are peaceful, and that we get to create societies which allow for us to discover new means, and maybe research projects that help us move on, and maybe create something that our minds right now cannot even conceive. But for that we need to trust each other. [00:37:35] Car Gonzalez: Something that creates for everybody to thrive together, right? [00:37:41] Vlad Costea: Exactly. Yeah. And he says that trust is the element which keeps us together, and that trust scales very poorly, and you can only trust a small number of people at one time. And there are many other strangers with whom you have to interact. And one of the ways through which you trust people is money, as it's an objective and the kind of object which everybody agrees that has value. And you trust in the value of that object. So if you want to do the trade, you have to trust the person for a limited amount of time that they're going to be honest. [00:38:31] Vlad Costea: And money is actually an element which helped us develop as a civilization and expand beyond what we see on our daily basis. It enabled some people to have the kind of lifestyle which allowed them to travel from town to town to sell products. They were early merchants, bringing goods from other places and selling them. And this was essential to stepping out of our comfort zone before we had the internet. And now we need to re-understand and try to analyze once again what it is that makes us evolve as a civilization, and adjust our understanding of trust accordingly to make sure that we move on. And this brief presentation that I made about public, not public, social scalability is actually a bad presentation of Nick Szabo's ideas. But if you get to read the articles, they are so much more in-depth and so revealing and mind-blowing. You're going to just... [00:39:51] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, like you telling me about it right now, I'm just like, wow, like, it's such a different approach to figuring out the world's problems. And he's able to do that in his own way, and from what you describe right now, it almost seems like he's constructed something that would probably work. Does he say anything other than just money as a form of trust? [00:40:19] Vlad Costea: Oh, he says a lot of stuff. He even has researches about the NASA projects, and sometimes I wonder how does he have time to read about that? He even has a nice comparison with NASA's Moon landing and the exploration that the Chinese empire was doing around the same time when Portugal was exploring the world. [00:40:48] Vlad Costea: Portugal was actually doing it for trade purposes and to seize resources and establish colonies, while China was doing it just for the vanity of the Emperor. And each time a ship was going to Africa, for example, a ship from China, they would just ask everybody to praise the greatness of the Chinese emperor and spread the word about it. But it was never something practical. It was just propaganda, which maybe the locals were not perceiving as such, were not really understanding, so it wasn't really working, but it was just the vanity. [00:41:29] Vlad Costea: And he said that the moon landing from 1969 was just a vanity act which didn't really help humanity find something useful. It was just about getting there and showing to the entire world that a man can actually land and walk on the moon, and that was it. It was a lot of taxpayers' money which was spent on the project, but they didn't do much research. Right. I guess at the time it was just about the Cold War and trying to prove that you have the superior technology and you are the greater world power. [00:42:11] Vlad Costea: When USSR were the first to send a man in space in 1960, it took the United States quite some time to catch up and develop a space program which was competitive, and I guess that was about it. But now I guess they got much more pragmatic with small... what's their... what do you call them in English? I can come up with the Romanian term. Satellite? Satellites, but those that collect rocks. [00:42:41] Car Gonzalez: You're talking about like... The only thing that comes to mind right now, off the top of my head, is Voyagers. [00:42:50] Vlad Costea: Yeah, Voyagers. The ones that actually go beyond what we can see on telescopes and take pictures. Collect all sorts of minerals and maybe test the quality of the atmosphere. And yeah, they're just basically all information. [00:43:09] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, just robots that they send out there just to do, yeah, all the navigation and experiments on the device itself. That's fascinating stuff. I didn't realize he did all of that. I didn't realize he researched all that. That's fascinating. [00:43:27] Vlad Costea: Yeah, he has a background in computer science, and he got into cryptography, and then he got into money and went all the way to the history of money and the first forms, how people were making exchanges, and what this actually means. As in, they were using colorful shells in the beginning. That's what he found. And they evolved all the way to gold, which was maybe the greatest of all discoveries, as gold was and still is the kind of metal that you can melt into smaller pieces, and is not wasteful. Is actually... [00:44:13] Vlad Costea: Demanding in terms of manpower, it takes a lot of effort to mine and take gold out of mines. So when you have it's actually a sign that you made an effort, as opposed to using something else which was easier to find. And people had much more, were more willing to give you their maybe agriculture products or dairy products for gold, as they knew that it was not just shiny. It was hard to get. It was scarce. That was the whole point. And when you look at Bitcoin right now, it has so many elements of that evolution of money. [00:45:00] Vlad Costea: And it actually figured out very well how people think, and how... I guess the innovation is not in the cryptography itself, but in the way it solved this issue of how do you make people agree on a protocol. How do you make them run the same program at the same time, and not diverge and not argue, and accept that it's more profitable to actually be part of the group than to try to attack. [00:45:38] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, I really think that, you know, these days, with all the infighting, especially during this crypto winter... But I just feel like the infighting with Bitcoin maximalists and all these other cryptocurrency camps is, I don't know, it's just reached a threshold where it's almost made me just ignore it at this point. Just because I'm a firm believer that a lot of these projects, whether they went out or not in the next cycle, or, you know, whether they change the world, or whether they are able to accomplish what they set out to accomplish... [00:46:21] Car Gonzalez: You know, there's going to be some that are going to surprise us. And I think to only think that Bitcoin is going to be the only project that survives in long term, it just doesn't make sense to me. I can see it surviving as a currency long term, but to think it's going to be the only blockchain project or, you know, whatever you want to call this next generation of the internet, Web3 or whatever... Yeah, it's just not gonna... I just don't see it being the only project that sustains or envelops everything, or engulfs everything. It's just too... To me, it's always going to be currency, I guess. What do you think? [00:47:09] Vlad Costea: Well, the maximalist point of view in this regard is that all these technologies which happen to appear in altcoins will eventually end up in Bitcoin. And the altcoins are actually small-scale experiments to see how the technology works. And then they get to put it on a sidechain or find workarounds to not hard fork the main chain and implement it. At this point, the most important aspect of it is to not try to impose anything. That's one of the approaches that the developers are... [00:47:53] Vlad Costea: Using right now. And that's why we don't have full-scale SegWit adoption, even though it's convenient to be able to have bigger blocks when necessary. It's just not agreed upon by all the participants and that's perfectly fine. They're going to have Schnorr signatures, which allow for greater scalability and more privacy. They're going to have some other upgrades which enable more privacy. And not everybody is going to want to use them. But they want to maintain the compatibility of the network, to make sure that the coins of those who have not upgraded are still... [00:48:40] Vlad Costea: On the same chain and can still be used. And Satoshi can come back at any point and still be able to claim his coins. That's a good point, which has to remain applicable. Whereas in the case of Ethereum, you have the whole network which has to run the protocol upgrade or else they're going to be part of a hard fork which is not acknowledged by the Ethereum Foundation. So it's not going to be worth anything in the long term. They are centralized in decision making. And what I don't like about it is how sometimes they just get together in a room and they decide, "How about we delay that part?" [00:49:31] Vlad Costea: "And we establish that and we don't follow precisely the roadmap and we do this first and that part later." And they say, "Okay, let's do it." And then the whole network has to adapt. So as a protocol or as the world computer, what they like to call it's not really decentralized and it's hard for me to think of ways to which it's going to change. That's what the big problem is, that you can't even run a node at this point and it got to the level where you need industrial type of hardware to be able to run a full node and synchronize with the rest of the network. [00:50:15] Vlad Costea: You had all the ICOs and all these dApps which were pretty bad, but they were deployed on the blockchain. And when you look at them now, they're not working anymore. I doubt any decentralized application has too many users. And maybe the best kind of decentralized applications are the decentralized exchanges, which allow you to do quick swaps between different cryptocurrencies, and that's nice. But that also has to evolve some way and get better. And maybe it will get better with Ethereum 2.0, but I don't think it's going to be as decentralized. And as long as there is a foundation to make decisions, then... Oh, it's difficult. [00:51:06] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, I come from the mindset of when I look at Ethereum, people look at it for its price and they want to chase the price down. I don't see it that way. I don't look at the price and feel like, okay, this is going to dictate everything I do. I'm sure Vitalik is not looking at that price right now and wondering, "Oh, how can I make it go to 20x or whatever?" I'm sure that's not on his mind anymore. [00:51:36] Car Gonzalez: At this point, he's just trying to create some cool shit. Like, and sometimes that requires, you know, a centralized group of people to make those strides in that direction. And I personally think that there's a lot of developers out there that just want to create on Ethereum. They want to be a part of that ecosystem. There's a reason why, you know, guys coming out of college right now, you know, software devs or whatever, they're not looking at the iOS platform and wanting to create, you know, the next Flappy Bird. [00:52:17] Car Gonzalez: Like, they want to create on Ethereum because it's cool. Like, it's the coolest thing in crypto when it comes to technology right now. A lot of people don't want to hear that. Bitcoin maximalists don't want to hear that. And I totally get it. But I really can see both sides. I can totally see the other side of things and look at it. And if you look at it as a currency, you're not going to be impressed by it. I don't look at it as a currency. I look at it as a project, as a continuing project. And this is where all the developers are going. At a certain point, Bitcoin just became too... [00:53:02] Car Gonzalez: Just too important in a way, you know, it almost became its own worst enemy because it became worth too much. And it's good. It's good that that happened. We needed an OG. We needed something that would solidify the space, that would keep it stable, and Bitcoin is that, and it can be that. I'm a firm believer in the current Bitcoin as a currency. Yeah, it can have store value, but I look at it as a currency. But when it comes to Ethereum, I don't see any other project in the top 10 that gets people excited like Ethereum. [00:53:43] Car Gonzalez: This is why we have this next wave. People like to think, oh, it's ICOs and stuff like that. And it is to a certain extent, but it's more because of the scammers came on board. They saw an opportunity to make millions overnight and they did. And they learned about Ethereum, what they needed to learn. They picked the very best programmer they could find in the 10-mile radius, and they created, you know, an ICO token. But the people that I talk to, the people that want to create cool stuff, like they're going to Ethereum because it's cool. [00:54:13] Car Gonzalez: And it brought in a wave of developers. It brought in a wave of technologists that would have never entered the space if it wasn't for Ethereum. I don't think it gets enough credit for that. I'm not saying Ethereum's gonna be worth $1,400, you know, here in the next year or anything like that, I wouldn't predict that or even make a guess for that, but I will say that Ethereum as a blockchain project is very important here in the short term. I look at something like EOS. You know, we can go back and forth on why it's so centralized, but it's another... You talk to some devs in the space and they're excited about EOS. [00:54:54] Car Gonzalez: Because, you know, these people that are coming from that background, they don't mind centralization because they're used to it. We're used to working on parallel systems all day in our day jobs. When we see something like Ethereum or EOS, it doesn't necessarily scare us off. But to a Bitcoin maximalist, somebody who's not a technologist or maybe is a, you know, cypherpunk or has these ideals, you know, staked to the ground, yeah, I could totally see how they can look at that and be like, "Get away!" [00:55:32] Car Gonzalez: "You're ruining the space." I can see it. I see it both ways. I really do. I'm just of the mindset that there's a need for both of them. But I don't know. I'm definitely one of the few people that think that. I don't look at any cryptocurrency project right now and I'm just disgusted by it. I mean, Bitcoin SV, I would say, is downright disgusting how it happened. You're in the top 10, but, you know, we researched Tether. That looks very shaky. I wouldn't use it personally. [00:56:11] Car Gonzalez: One that I want to do some more research on is Tezos. I find it very fascinating how it's growing as a community right now. Slowly but surely, it's growing and you're starting to see these little pop-ups everywhere. Like here in Austin, a Tezos meetup group has kind of spawned out of nowhere. I'm like, that's interesting. It wasn't there, you know, two months ago. It's only been Ethereum meetups, meetup groups. But here's a Tezos meetup group showing up here in Austin. It's like, that's interesting, right? [00:56:42] Car Gonzalez: So like these little things, these little pockets of community, I find very interesting because it tells you a sign of where the space is going and it shows you exactly what's being worked on or what people are excited about. And you go to these meetups, Vlad, and you come to realize that these are just kids coming out of college and they're excited about Ethereum or they're excited about EOS and they can't explain why, but they are, you know? [00:57:11] Vlad Costea: But yeah, in this industry, I think something that Ethereum and EOS did very right is to finance independent groups of developers. And they had this budget. They received a lot of money. Ethereum was the first ever ICO. No, it wasn't the first ever ICO, but it was the biggest ICO of its time. And they had a lot of money to pay people who are interested in getting in and learning the programming language and working on their roadmap and their different projects. And right now you have sharding, you have the Raiden Network. [00:57:54] Vlad Costea: You have Plasma and all these other projects which are being worked on at the same time. And it's not clear which one will make it to the main chain first, but they are funding brilliant minds who come into the space and actually try to bring their input and leave their footprints on the protocol. And that's something which even the Bitcoiners admire. And I spoke to Giacomo Zucco, who is an Italian Bitcoiner who started the B Foundation last fall. And he told me that this is the part which Ethereum did best. [00:58:35] Vlad Costea: In terms of attracting developers and using their money to actually help small teams get involved. Whereas Bitcoin, being so decentralized and relying on the community, never really had a budget for PR and for developments. All the developers are actually funded by the community and those who make donations to them. Or maybe they got in so early that they don't need to work anymore, but they do it just because they like it and they want to protect their own bitcoins that they own. And also EOS was the biggest ICO of 2018 and 2017. [00:59:21] Vlad Costea: It took a whole year to raise the money. And they got a lot of Ethereum, and even if they don't do anything, I think they can afford to be in the top 10 for another couple of years just because they have so much money to keep themselves on top and sell their Ethereum tokens. But it makes sense for young graduates in computer science to get into these projects, as they find the kind of job which is exciting, both financially and in terms of feeling like they contribute to something new and exciting. [01:00:04] Vlad Costea: Of course, they're not going to work or pursue jobs at Google or Apple or some kind of big corporation which limits their potential. It's all about people. If you're very brilliant and you try to be creative, then you're always going to look for the new industries and try to find a proper job to use all of your talents. And that can be found in both Ethereum and EOS, and unfortunately not so much in Bitcoin, as the circle of developers is pretty narrow and it's hard to get in. [01:00:49] Vlad Costea: You have to be very smart and you have to be able to support yourself in the first place. And only then, after you make a name for yourself and people actually respect you within the community, you're going to get donations from those who are interested. But in the case of projects which are more centralized in terms of management, if you come up with a good idea or you just seem willing to work on their ideas and improve upon them, then it's more likely for you to get a well-paying job. [01:01:27] Vlad Costea: And I guess it brings a greater satisfaction. And about your points on Tezos, if you speak to the people from Crypto Insider, I guess you'll find a couple of very ardent proponents of Tezos. And I think that's what's so beautiful about our core group of journalists. It's that we have so many different opinions on projects. And I'm more towards Bitcoin and, like, Litecoin, and I'm slightly skeptical towards Ethereum, but I try to educate myself about it. But then you have people who like Tezos and Tron and all these new projects which came last year. [01:02:17] Vlad Costea: And I think about it and say, "Okay, this is fascinating." At least we have this plurality of opinions and you can always turn to somebody and learn something new. And I guess somebody from Crypto Insider also has started writing for a website which he calls Tezos Insider, and it's all about Tezos. He's trying to build a community around it. [01:02:42] Car Gonzalez: Cool. [01:02:43] Vlad Costea: His name is Nathan. [01:02:45] Car Gonzalez: Interesting. [01:02:46] Vlad Costea: So he's very interested in this side of the business, and he thinks that baking is the new mining, and he will tell you why it's such a brilliant innovation. [01:03:01] Car Gonzalez: Interesting. I need to read up on Tezos. So that's one of my things that I'm going to have to do here fairly soon, just because I haven't checked into it. But you start seeing these pockets develop around everywhere, like you're talking about, Tezos Insider. That's interesting to me, and I keep seeing more and more kind of community growing out. I'm not sure if that's organic or if it's kind of where it's coming from, because I haven't done the research on it, but when it comes from an organic place, it's a beautiful thing. [01:03:32] Car Gonzalez: It really is. So hard growing a community. So hard. But when you can grow one, it's a beautiful thing because you have a lot of people working towards the same goals. And that doesn't have to be cryptocurrency goals or anything like that. I just mean, like, you know, going out into your neighborhood and just being a part of the community that you're in there. Like, most people don't realize this, but if you download, there's a Meetup app on most devices, I think iOS, Android, whatever else there is, and you can download a Meetup app and you can attend different crypto meetups in your area. [01:04:15] Car Gonzalez: And you'd be surprised, you'll find some Bitcoin meetups, you'll find some Ethereum. I just recently saw Tezos pop up and, yeah, it's really cool. And then you start hanging out with people in real life and you start realizing, like, oh, wow, they're actually excited. And you learn, like you said, you learn something new about a project. You're like, wow, they're actually excited about this, you know, and they tell you why and why they got into it and you start realizing, like, oh, wow. [01:04:42] Car Gonzalez: This might be something. Tron, when we review Tron, Tron was one where, you know, to me, I haven't looked at it since about a year now at this point, but when I looked at it initially, there was all that kind of swirl going on about their white paper being plagiarized. And then there was also Justin Sun, and he's notorious for, you know, being a marketeer. And I think the only thing that I can look at Tron and see with clear eyes these days... [01:05:18] Car Gonzalez: I don't know if you've noticed this, but once they built that conference, Night of TRON here in 2019, and they paid CoinDesk and they paid Cointelegraph and a couple other big media publications to come to that event, because it was an event in San Francisco. Once they did that, they kind of got the green light from that media publication, and now they're on board with rolling Tron stories. And to me, that's a very strong tell of how media publications are just as... how do you say this? [01:05:56] Car Gonzalez: Are just as to blame for some of these projects that either are not what they say they are, or, you know, they didn't do their due diligence and investigate further, or they just turned the other way, you know? [01:06:13] Car Gonzalez: So I don't know if you've noticed stuff like that, but I've come to realize that that happened here over the past month here in the space. Because we look at the space, I look at this thing every day. There's not nothing that I'm not seeing here show up. But that's why I like y'all's site. Y'all clearly have a lot of different people working on a lot of different stuff and, yeah, so it's good. It's refreshing. There needs to be a balance of sorts. [01:06:46] Vlad Costea: Yeah, sometimes we disagree. But at the same time, I trust their judgments, and it's not up to me to trust. I'm not the boss. I'm not running the business. But when I look at it and I actually say, you know, this guy is smart, and he's looking into this project which maybe I don't like, but I can at least read about it and educate myself and understand that there's something beyond my day-to-day readings. And maybe that sometimes we get stuck in bubbles and only... [01:07:21] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, that's the worst thing. Yeah. [01:07:23] Vlad Costea: Only see some points of view and only hear some opinions. And that can be dangerous for our mental health. And it's always useful to learn something new, even though you disagree with it, because you understand and you develop arguments, and you begin to realize that there's something bigger than what you know. [01:07:48] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, and it's not even that... [01:07:49] Vlad Costea: Should also apply to politics. [01:07:51] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, it's not even... yeah, that too. Like, you know, when it comes to politics, I don't bring it up in the podcast because I'm not a politician. I think if I told people my views on politics, they would run away scared, because I, like, I'll bring it up now, but I honestly think the world can run itself. Like, I don't think we need these people with power to tell us what to do. I think at a certain time, maybe back in whatever late ages it was, but I think at this point, we all can take care of ourselves. [01:08:24] Car Gonzalez: Like, we're all pretty adult about things, right? So I just am not a believer in centralized government at this point. I think just let everybody do their jobs. Like, this thing can run on its own. That's just how I feel. Now, when it comes to military and all that stuff, I have no idea because I don't know how any of that works. So this is why I don't bring up politics, because I don't know how that stuff works. I just stick with my cryptocurrency lane. But yeah. Anything else you want to bring up or talk about? [01:08:56] Vlad Costea: You know, I feel sorry that we started talking about Bitcoin Hex and we had that long discussion about it, and in a way that we wasted time discussing something which is useless, as opposed to presenting ideas which can be useful to the audience to grow intellectually and help us exchange ideas. If this is a selfish exchange and nobody's going to listen to us, I still feel like I've learned something new from you and I've heard different opinions. You told me about all the Ethereum and the Tezos meetings and gatherings there in Texas. So you have given me an insight that there is something beyond what I see on Twitter. [01:09:43] Car Gonzalez: Oh, for sure. Yeah, I think I'm so lucky. I realize this, and I'm grateful for it, being here in Austin, because this is a growing, thriving tech community. People are vacating San Francisco and they're heading to Austin in droves every week. Here where I work at, we get applications from people, you know, trying to work here in Austin or work for us. I do, I'm a system administrator by day. That's what I do during the day, like, manage servers, all that kind of stuff. A lot of people that I talk to at work, there's maybe four or five of us that are into cryptocurrency. [01:10:22] Car Gonzalez: Everybody else just laughs at us. All they know is Bitcoin. And these are tech guys. Like, these are guys that, you know, can set up an entire server rack and have it in four different offices spanning Houston, Dallas, Corpus, you know, and these are guys who are in the space, and they think Bitcoin is Monopoly money. So this is why I think my perspective is unique, because most people don't. And this is in Austin. [01:10:56] Car Gonzalez: Like, this is one of the biggest growing, fastest-growing tech spaces, you know, in the US, and most people don't realize, like, these are people I work with every day and they're very smart and they know their shit. So if they're not on board yet, who probably should be on board, right? We have a long way to go. And when I talk to the younger community of developers, I come to see that they're just excited about Ethereum. They think Bitcoin's cool, but they're excited about Ethereum. And you go to conferences and stuff and all you hear is Bitcoin, Bitcoin, Bitcoin, Bitcoin. [01:11:43] Car Gonzalez: But people are excited about Ethereum. It's because it's onboarding all these new people, you know, that can come from tech backgrounds that necessarily would have never got into cryptocurrency because they think Bitcoin is Monopoly money. Which I, you know, I used to argue with them, but at a certain point I stopped arguing with them. And then Bitcoin went to 20,000, and all of a sudden people want to know how to buy Bitcoin. So let's go ask Car how to buy Bitcoin. But at that point, of course, I'm going to help them. [01:12:14] Car Gonzalez: But at the same time, it's one of those things where, like, you're bitten by what you see, or you're informed by what you see, but you're bitten by what you don't know. And a lot of this stuff, you know, no matter how many times I look at it and reread it and study it just never sticks, right? Or sometimes it's just so hard to gather all this information and come out with a concrete argument or anything like that. And sometimes it's just best to let the people that are in the know or well informed or know what they're talking about discuss this stuff and just listen. And that's why I was more than happy to listen to you talk about Bitcoin and Litecoin and educate me on that, because clearly you know a lot about that subject. [01:13:07] Vlad Costea: Oh, I don't think I know a lot. [01:13:09] Car Gonzalez: I think you do. [01:13:10] Vlad Costea: I do interviews with other people and I have my mind blown all the time. I learn something new and I try to understand their perspective and where they come from. And I realize that the beauty of this whole... I'm not sure if it's an industry or if it's a business, but this whole community is that we all bring our life experiences and we all bring our skills into the game. And the way we perceive something which is just code and is just computer science is so different. [01:13:48] Vlad Costea: At core, I am a political scientist. I went to university and did political science, and then comparative politics and political philosophy. So none of this really has anything to do with the underlying code of Bitcoin. But when you look at the way the actors behave, you can think that they are politicians. And when you find out that there used to be a foundation for Bitcoin, and it's still active but it's not influential anymore, then you're going to realize that, hey, you have influencers in this field who matter more than the others. [01:14:27] Vlad Costea: And it's them who actually create the narrative, and it's them who... maybe manipulate is a strong word, but according to their actions, you actually get the feeling of the market and understand where this is heading. And you actually mentioned that there are a lot of people interested in Ethereum, and it's thanks to these people that we had the 2017 bull run. Otherwise, nobody in the West wakes up in bed and says, you know... except for the hardcore libertarians, but nobody except for them wakes up one morning and says, "You know what I need in my life? [01:15:11] Vlad Costea: Sound money. I hate the money that I have in my pocket. It's not good anymore. It's inflationary. I'm not going to buy gold. I'm not going to buy jewelry or something like art, which is expected to go up in price. I'm going to buy something which has the most qualities of sound money and has the potential to grow." [01:15:33] Car Gonzalez: Gosh, speaking my language now. [01:15:35] Vlad Costea: Nobody really does this, but the people who do this don't have access to Bitcoin, and that's a problem, because you have... [01:15:44] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, I know. Yeah. [01:15:46] Vlad Costea: You have all these unfortunate citizens of the world who live under regimes which oppress them and do not allow them to have financial freedom and all the liberties that we have from an economic point of view. And they are the ones who need Bitcoin, but they cannot acquire it. At the same time, we had many happy stories about people fleeing Venezuela. And it was thanks to the fact that they received some Bitcoin and were able to book a flight to the United States that they were able to actually get away from that oppressive regime. [01:16:23] Vlad Costea: And that's impressive in itself, but we only have small-scale examples. What we need is a larger adoption. And I guess you just gave me the idea to write an article about how Bitcoin supports maybe democracy. It is not necessarily the agenda of the United States of America in terms of foreign policy, because obviously nobody would want Venezuela to thrive when it's under embargo. But it's a way of bringing more financial freedom, which in itself is something which brings justice to the world. [01:16:58] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, most definitely. [01:17:00] Vlad Costea: No politician can come to you and say, "I'm going to take away your money. [01:17:12] Vlad Costea: From now on, you're going to be poor." That's not going to happen anymore, unless they resort to torture or something which makes you give away all the details about where you hold your cryptocurrencies, then we actually hold and stand a chance against governments to raise our voices and make our demands. And say, "From now on, I don't want you to do this, and I want you to respect more of my rights, and I want you to be more accountable with the tax money that I pay." And that's something very important because up to this point, we were just paying taxes without ever caring. [01:17:55] Vlad Costea: And it was just deducted from our income. I'm not sure if it's the same in the United States because you have to file. [01:18:02] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, it's still deducted. Like, I get deducted so much in taxes. It's ridiculous. And none of it's going to be due when we want it to go to. Sorry. What was that? [01:18:12] Vlad Costea: When you get employed for the first time, for example, you don't ask questions. You're not really wondering why is this amount of money going to the state from what I earn. You just take it for granted. [01:18:25] Vlad Costea: You say, "This is the amount that I receive at the end of the month, and this is the one that I get to spend, so I don't care about everything else." But when you think about it, there's all this shady side of the government where it's funding. And when you think about the United States, you have the Guantanamo prisons and all the spying operations and the military, which sometimes you have entire navy units just sailing on international waters, trying to just collect information about Chinese ships and all that sort of crazy stuff. [01:19:08] Vlad Costea: And you have planes which fly above countries trying to detect radio signals or communications which cannot be intercepted by satellite. So you have all these operations about which you don't know, that maybe you wouldn't really want to finance with your own money. But the government actually justifies by telling you that you're funding public education, healthcare, and bridges and roads and railroads and everything that you agree on. But you get taxed actually for the stuff that otherwise you would not agree on. And I guess that's the kind of power that cryptocurrencies and Bitcoin give us. [01:19:54] Car Gonzalez: It's interesting that you say that. Totally agree on all those points. Like, I've come to the point now in my life where I realized, and this podcast has helped me too to realize it, but I've come to the point in my life where I can't rely on my government anymore to do anything. I have to do it myself. So when it comes to wanting to see something change in the world, I start with myself and I start with the people around me first. And I'm a big believer in that this year. [01:20:26] Car Gonzalez: Like a big believer. Like, if I want the world to be more friendly, I need to be more friendly. If I want the world to, you know, pick up trash and not, you know, leave a mess behind or cut people off in traffic or, you know, I need to do these things. I need to be the change I want to see every day. If I don't want to see people suffer on the streets, I have to be the one that says, "Hey, let me buy you something to eat here at this next gas stop. [01:20:59] Car Gonzalez: I'll be right back." I need to do that. It's not responsibility. I don't... It's not even about the government at that point. It's just about being a great human being, right? Like being the best human being you can be, and I've come to the point where I realized that that's just the way I need to live my life going forward. And it took me a very long time to understand that because in my 20s I was very selfish. And here in my early 30s, I realized like, I really need to be the change that I want to see if I really believe in what cryptocurrency can bring to the world. [01:21:33] Car Gonzalez: Because I used to look at the world very bleak. Like, we're not going to be around in the near future. But when I think of what you just said about cryptocurrency and about Bitcoin especially, I realized that we can check out, like we don't have to go with the way things are. We don't have to abide by anybody else's rules. And Bitcoin has that kind of power. And, you know, it's one of the reasons why I always say buy Bitcoin and save the world, because it truly can save the world. If you really break it down like you did just now. So. [01:22:07] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's the whole point. You have a currency which is neutral from a political point of view. Nobody can confiscate it. Nobody has inflationary control over it. It's all run by code, and you have to trust the cryptography, which... Even I, even though I don't know code, I can review the GitHub repository and see what's in there, and I can check every line of code. And a lot of people have done it. And one of the ideas which I have about Bitcoin is that Satoshi's wallet is the guarantee that the system works. [01:22:47] Vlad Costea: Because if there was a backdoor or if there was a hack, then somebody would steal the 1 million bitcoins and sell them on an exchange and then announce that it's over. [01:22:57] Car Gonzalez: It's a fair point. Yeah, it's interesting. [01:23:00] Vlad Costea: But as long as it's there, we know that it's still working and it's still safe. And if 1 million coins can be stored in one wallet about which everybody knows, then we are a lot safer. I don't own even... I own less than one Bitcoin, to be honest. Yeah. So I'm trying to accumulate. [01:23:22] Car Gonzalez: It's one of those... Yeah, of course. It's one of those things where I think you're exactly right. That's true. I never thought of it that way. But yeah, I think having his wallet, you know, out in public and having it never moved, it kind of shows that he's willing to fall on the sword. I mean, if he was going to ever sell, he should have sold at $20,000. But that just proves to everybody paying attention that no, this isn't about selling for fiat. That's one thing that drives me crazy about some of these big influencers in the space that are maximalists, or they quote unquote call themselves maximalists, but they're actually fiat maximalists, right? [01:24:04] Car Gonzalez: Like they want Bitcoin to go up in value, but they don't necessarily want to pay with Bitcoin, or they want to cash out to fiat because, you know, that's the cool thing to do. It's completely the opposite. I know everybody has to live their own way. But if you're a true, true Bitcoin maximalist like they say they are, they would most definitely pay with Bitcoin or accept Bitcoin. The only person that comes to mind that is a crypto maximalist that I could think of is Kenn Bosak. [01:24:35] Car Gonzalez: That guy lives and breathes crypto. Like he pays everything with crypto. And when he has to use fiat, he stamps his fiat with crypto on it. Guy has cryptocurrency tattoos all over. Like he's the only one in this space that I know for a fact, because I've hung out with him places, and this guy lives and breathes crypto, like through and through. And there's not many people like that. So when I see somebody who's a Bitcoin maximalist, I'm like, "How much of a maximalist are you? [01:25:02] Car Gonzalez: To what point?" Because I've seen the tipping point with Ken. You know, it's almost like it's cool these days for everybody to call themselves Bitcoin maximalists because they want to appear that, you know, they've been in the space for a while, or they joined the bandwagon or something, but they don't want to actually follow through with what it means to be an actual maximalist. [01:25:26] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but maximalist used to be a derogatory term, which was invented by Vitalik. [01:25:31] Car Gonzalez: Yeah. [01:25:32] Vlad Costea: So he wrote an article, I think in 2014, to classify the different types of Bitcoiners, and he called the hardcore ones maximalists. And after that, they got offended initially and they said, "This is just wrong and this is stupid." But some of them have embraced the label in an ironic way. And then the irony was gone with the new wave of people who came in. [01:25:57] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, that's funny, right? [01:25:59] Vlad Costea: People call themselves maximalists without knowing the origin of the term. [01:26:03] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, it's like, yeah, yeah. [01:26:05] Vlad Costea: It's like people call themselves idiots in the future and say, "I'm an idiot," but in their slang, it means that they are actually knowledgeable and smart. And then somebody old comes to them and says, "You know what idiot used to mean back in my day?" Yeah. But it's like they say, a year in crypto is like 10 years in real life. [01:26:32] Car Gonzalez: Yeah, dude, for real, right? Gosh, man. Like... Yeah, every day I feel like I look at this every day and it almost, like, I definitely am appreciative because I've learned so much about the financial systems that I never had a clue before. I understand how the world works in much better ways than I ever knew. It's made me more financially sound. It's actually, you know, done great things to me, just like being financially sound at this point in my life, where it's made me value saving. [01:27:13] Car Gonzalez: And that's all because of Bitcoin, right? And other cryptocurrencies, but yeah, it's amazing how you get in this for one reason and, you know, three years later, four years later, you're completely night and day from where you were. Yeah, I think I saw Heidi, she's a blockchain chick, she said, I forget what quote she did, but she basically said the same thing. Like, you come in, Bitcoin is that sneak drug that you come into thinking you're going to get rich, and then you come out the other side and realize that you're even poorer or something like that, but more knowledgeable of how the world really works or something like that. [01:27:57] Car Gonzalez: I forget what that quote was, but it's true. [01:28:01] Vlad Costea: Makes sense. But anyway, I think about 30 minutes ago you wanted to end it, and then I added something else, and I can hear how your voice is cracking and you're getting more tired in your responses. And this is actually a paradox because the sun has shown in here. [01:28:21] Car Gonzalez: That's awesome. [01:28:22] Vlad Costea: And I feel like I'm becoming more energetic. And at the same time... [01:28:26] Car Gonzalez: You are, and I love it. [01:28:28] Vlad Costea: Now it's past midnight where you live, and you probably have work tomorrow. [01:28:34] Car Gonzalez: 1:30 a.m. 1:30 a.m. Honestly, no, I'm actually off on Saturdays and Sundays, which is good because it took me a really long time in my life to finally have weekends off. But yeah, thanks so much for coming on the show, Vlad. Really appreciate all the work you're doing in this space. I'm gonna put all your links in the show notes so people can follow you. Make sure you guys check out CryptoInsider.com and also check out Vlad. Follow him on Twitter. What's your Twitter handle? [01:29:03] Vlad Costea: It's TheVladCostea. T-H-E-V-L-A-D-C-O-S-T-E-A. I should change it to something shorter. But just so you know, this is going to be a bonus episode of the first season of the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. [01:29:20] Car Gonzalez: Yeah. Tell us about that real quick. Tell us about what you got brewing with all that stuff. I'm interested because I love listening to new Bitcoin, and you're very knowledgeable. So, tell me. [01:29:31] Vlad Costea: So I just talk about Bitcoin with random people I meet who are interesting, and they have something to add about the political or economic or maybe philosophical or even anthropological dimension of Bitcoin. It's all about trying to find all these facets of what this new invention stands for and how it can change the world that we live in. It's not really fixed by the rules of daily news and what we have right now in terms of consensus protocols, but more about what it can be and what our society is going to look like if we have a type of currency that nobody can control. [01:30:14] Vlad Costea: It's just like gold, but it's digital and protected by cryptography. So that brings a lot of possibilities and a lot of limitations for the governments to oppress us. It gives us the kind of power that we never really had in the face of entities which actually possess the entire military power and the means of communication and the means of information and everything that we are never ever going to take over. But we get to have our independence from a financial point of view. And money makes the world go round. [01:30:55] Vlad Costea: And at the end of the day, they're going to turn to us to finance their operations. And if we hold our funds and they cannot be confiscated, then we are going to have a greater power in the face of governments. I guess essentially that's the kind of topic which I discuss with different guests. But according to their backgrounds and their knowledge and their interests, we sidetrack and talk about different aspects and dimensions of the same discussion. And it's fascinating to see how you can ask the same question. [01:31:32] Vlad Costea: Many times and get a different answer, even though you would expect to have some kind of similarity somewhere. But it's not there. And different people see the same project in different ways. And that's the most fascinating part. Yeah, I'm going to launch the entire first season consisting of 10 canonical episodes and some bonus features, including this one, next week, which is the second week of February. And it's all going to contain discussions which are pretty long. I spoke to some people and they told me that their podcasts are about 30 minutes long. [01:32:16] Vlad Costea: Or they are edited and contain maybe breaks and commercials and stuff. I'm not going to have any of these, at least not in the first season. I haven't even proven anything to the world yet. Another aspect I'm going to have is that I'm going to add an individual QR code to each participant. You can donate Bitcoin, and half of what I make is going to go to the guest. So if anybody donates any Bitcoin for this particular discussion that we're having, then you're going to get half of it. [01:32:52] Car Gonzalez: Aww, dude. It's such a great idea. Why have I never thought of that? [01:32:58] Vlad Costea: It's a great way to make people promote it. So it incentivizes them to talk about it and try to make people listen. But it's also to reward the time that you know, you spent precious time that you could be using to make some money right now. But you're not. You're doing this podcast. So why don't you get, if there's any money that is made from it, you deserve to get a portion of it. Because you have your input and you have brought many people to listen to this. And it's your time, it's your effort. And I guess that's worth something. Some people may say otherwise, but... [01:33:37] Car Gonzalez: I'm just a very giving person, just in general, of my time, of everything. So yeah. And plus, this is something I just love doing. And I don't think I'm special at all. I just love doing it and I would do it anyway. And I just happen to live in the age of the internet so I can release it to everybody else. And some people like what I do and some people don't. Cool if you do, cool if you don't, but we have our own Patreon because that's all there is right now, unfortunately, and they haven't banned me yet, so... [01:34:13] Car Gonzalez: We'll stick with them, and people can donate to our, you know, be a patron if they want to. And that's pretty much what everything gets paid for, with that and with my earnings from work here, my day job. So I'm grateful. Grateful for the life I have. Very grateful. [01:34:31] Vlad Costea: And we get to do what we like, and that's what matters the most. [01:34:35] Car Gonzalez: Exactly. Yeah. Well, thank you so much for coming on our very first Thriller After Dark. I hope this is one of many. I feel like it is. Are you ever traveling to the US or do you mostly stay in Europe? [01:34:50] Vlad Costea: You know, the kind of money that I'm making right now, I guess I would have to save a month's worth to be able to get a plane ticket to the United States. And I have to get visas because it's much more difficult these days. But I would love to visit. And actually, you are from Dallas, Texas. No, not Dallas, Austin. And we actually have, you know, it's due to the media, but we have this bad impression of Southerners with your accents and your cowboy hat. Your mannerisms. [01:35:24] Car Gonzalez: No, Austin is the only place where that doesn't exist in the South, in Texas. In the southern states, Austin is the only place. There's a couple other cities, but in Texas, the only cool place you're going to find is Austin. I guarantee it. [01:35:40] Vlad Costea: But I actually have had very nice interactions with Southerners. They were very nice and polite and knowledgeable. And even though some of them have like that strong accent, it's still comprehensible. Still easier for me to talk to a Texan than it is to talk to somebody from Scotland or something. [01:36:02] Car Gonzalez: Interesting. Well, I appreciate that. Yeah, if you're ever in Austin, dude, we'll hang out. You can stay here if you want. We have our own place here, so extra bedroom, whatever. And then, yeah, man, I want to get to Europe at some point, either this year or next year. We're starting to get invited to some of the bigger conferences in the space, which is good because I get to say the same things that I say right now, but now in person to the people that are making some of the biggest projects. [01:36:40] Car Gonzalez: And that's not going to happen forever because I think probably here in the next five to ten years, I feel like crypto is going to get so big that people like me are going to get squashed out. But right now I get to have fun. So if I'm ever in Europe, in your neck of the woods, I'll definitely hit you up. [01:36:59] Vlad Costea: Sure, I would love to join you. So, I don't think I got your name. You told me the name of your show. [01:37:05] Car Gonzalez: Car. Car. C-A-R. [01:37:09] Vlad Costea: Yeah. Is that your first name? C-A-R, Car? [01:37:13] Car Gonzalez: No, my real name... I only tell this story on the very first episode of the podcast, but I'll say it for you. My first name is Carlos, but I go by Car because growing up, a lot of my relatives didn't speak English because they're either Mexican or they only speak Spanish. So they would say "Car." And so growing up, my friends started calling me Car. My family calls me Car. Went my whole life. Either known as Car or Los or C-Los, but most of the time it's Car. And that's why I go by Car. [01:37:53] Vlad Costea: But it's simpler. It has one syllable. It's easy to pronounce, easy to remember. [01:37:58] Car Gonzalez: And there's so many Carlos Gonzalezes out there that at this point, it's such a common name here in Texas, Carlos Gonzalez, that you'll never find me. There's so many of us and we all look alike. But if you look for Car Gonzalez, you'll definitely find me. Don't look for Carlos Gonzalez. Yeah, but yeah, I tell that story in the very first episode because people often say like, "Why do you call yourself that?" I'm like, "I don't call myself that, that's what I've always been called." [01:38:31] Car Gonzalez: If you really want to know the story, go listen to the first episode. That's what I tell them. Okay. Yeah, so people just call me Car. Now when I go to conferences, it's like, "Hey, Car, Car, Car." [01:38:40] Vlad Costea: If I ever want to go to South by Southwest, I'm going to crash at your place. [01:38:46] Car Gonzalez: Dude, we're going this year. Dude, 100% you can crash at my place. Like, we actually got punched in, dude. This is how I know crypto is being taken seriously, Vlad, because we actually got punched in as a cryptocurrency podcast, South by Southwest. And that has never happened before. Never happened before. Would have never happened. I've been applying for the past two years at this point. This is going to be the third year. Finally got in. It's a $1,700 ticket. Like, never happened. [01:39:19] Car Gonzalez: And now I get to ask David Schwartz, the CTO of Ripple, face to face, why his Ripple project is very centralized. You see, so like that's why, like it's surprising to me that crypto has come so far, and when I see stuff like that I'm like, wow, like it's finally taking off, like we're actually getting taken more seriously now. And that's why I'm very bullish on what you're doing with Crypto Insider and your work. As, yeah, it's growing, and there's only going to be a few people. [01:39:54] Car Gonzalez: I feel like right now, that are going to come out on the right side of crypto history. And it's the people that were like me and you that were speaking the truth about, you know, scam projects like Bitcoin Hex and calling them out. And in 10 years, when they look back at our work, they're going to be like, "No, that guy's been calling people out since the beginning," you know, this, and now he's working for this. Or, you know, you play the long game and that's always a smart game to play. And most people play the short game. That's why I feel bad for Richard Heart. He's playing the short game. That's just not smart. [01:40:27] Vlad Costea: But it's the games that Satoshi taught us to play, by incentivizing us to be honest players. [01:40:32] Car Gonzalez: Exactly. Yeah. [01:40:34] Vlad Costea: We should all be grateful to this pseudonymous person with a Japanese name, whom I think is very American. And when I think of Bitcoin, it's very, very American. It's like the culmination of the whole cypherpunk movement, which is 100% American. [01:40:54] Car Gonzalez: You think so? Wow. I don't know. [01:40:58] Vlad Costea: And how Hal Finney was the first person to receive a transaction and he's American? [01:41:03] Car Gonzalez: I don't know. I don't know. That's interesting. Definitely something we have to dive into for our second act of After Dark. Yeah, but thanks so much for coming on. I really appreciate it. And to all your listeners out there, you guys want to hear more of me ramble about stupidity. I promise that I keep a very concise format when it comes to our shows, Thriller News, Thriller Crypto, and Thriller Coin Talk. We strictly... I tell you every episode, it's not financial advice. Like, I let you know when I'm accidentally either spreading FUD. We have disclaimers all over the show, so... [01:41:49] Car Gonzalez: You know when you're getting fed my line of BS, and this is why I want to create an After Dark, because we don't have a show where I could just be uncensored, uncut. You can finally understand who I am as a person. So. [01:42:04] Vlad Costea: Oh, you should also add that. Sorry, you should also add a disclaimer to say that my opinions are my own and do not reflect whatever Crypto Insider might think. [01:42:14] Car Gonzalez: I will add that at the front of the podcast. Yeah, I will just do that for you. Yeah. Definitely. And for yourself too as well. For both of us. I can't afford to be sued. [01:42:27] Vlad Costea: Me neither. And I guess somebody as narcissistic as Richard Heart would do it. [01:42:33] Car Gonzalez: So do you want to cut that out or no? I'm totally cool cutting the whole first Richard Heart part. We can cut that out. [01:42:42] Vlad Costea: I think we had such a great discussion. I'm not sure how coherent I was because I woke up in the process. So it was an interesting, entire process of, I was groggy at first and trying to figure out what I was trying to say. But now I'm more energetic and active and you're slowly fading and feeling sleepy, which I'm glad about. [01:43:04] Car Gonzalez: And I laugh when I get sleepy too. That's the funny thing. Yeah, so do you want to leave it in or do you want to cut it? Either way, I'm cool with it. I don't care. [01:43:14] Vlad Costea: We have spoken about it during the other part of the show, so I guess it makes sense to leave it. I stand by my words. I hope I didn't say anything wrong and if I did get facts wrong, I'm going to correct it. [01:43:30] Car Gonzalez: It's uncut, it's uncensored. I'm not apologizing for any of it. I will say though, like Vlad said, this is not, you know, any way affiliated with Crypto Insider. This is no way affiliated with my employer either. And this is not financial advice. But yeah. Anyways, I think that's it. All right. This has been a Thriller After Dark. See you next time. Bye. Okay, I'm gonna cut it there. ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio crossover recorded as the first episode of Car Gonzalez's Thriller After Dark, with Vlad as the guest, in English (Vlad non-native), late night in Austin; no sponsor reads. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 7 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (139 chunks) and 32 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 3 of 3 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Guest A relabelled Car Gonzalez; split merged interjections (Vlad's "It doesn't matter", Car's "Yeah, I'm sorry", "I / love it", "Nice. Well, let's talk crypto", "Well, thank you"); fixed Costea, C-R...L-V-H-O, investigating, reiteration, Ethereum, Litecoin, Antminers, Cold War, payment rail, paying, point, mathematical hypotheses, a miner; removed "Episode:" hallucination and restored dropped speech from second ASR/re-check; Fixed "need money"→"fiat money", Electable→collectible, Aurelian→Orwellian, "Orwell, Georgia"→George Orwell, David Tom→David Chaum, Silk Road, "Where are we?"→[unclear: Red Army]; removed "Thank you." and "The End" by Vlad Costea hallucinations; split Car/Vlad interjections (porn site exchange, "And where is that at?", "No one checks them, yeah", "Yeah, no,"); moved "Unfortunately" to Vlad; Guest A → Car Gonzalez; Wei Dai/Bit Gold/Tim Ferriss/Nick Szabo fixed; "Telebeloci" → scalability; "Yarda calls" → the articles; shells, early merchants, "if he took" fixed; split Car's interjections ("Oh, okay", "Something that creates...", "Have you talked to him?") and Vlad's "Yeah, Voyagers"; removed stutters "Well, Well, the the maximalist maximalist"; "It was cars" marked unclear; Fixed SegWit/Schnorr, "Crossover" mishearing → "claim his coins. That's", B Foundation, ardent, "ICO token", Bitcoin SV (removed "Baby"), "downright disgusting", "build a community"; labelled turns (Vlad / Car Gonzalez), split Car's "Cool"/"Interesting" interjections per audio re-check; removed stutters; Speaker labels Guest A → Car Gonzalez; "Tesla" → Tezos; "Nitron" → Night of TRON; "Bitcoin tax" → Bitcoin Hex; "Carr" → Car; "policies" → qualities; restored "Monopoly money", "entire server rack", "so different"; split Car interjections ("I think you do", "Gosh, speaking my language now", "Yeah, I know", "Yeah, most definitely") and Vlad's short lines; removed fillers/stutters and "And that's all there is to it" mishearing; Speaker repairs (Car interjections split out at 01:18:02, 01:22:57, 01:25:31, 01:25:57, 01:26:03, 01:23:22; Car's turn start fixed incl. "1:30 a.m."); fixed Kenn Bosak, maximalist(s), TheVladCostea, facets, "caring", "unless they resort", "stamps", "idiot", "Car Gonzalez" labels; restored "So I'm trying to accumulate" from re-check; removed false "I'm not sure if"; "the sun has" garbled kept as unclear; Speakers relabelled Guest A→Car Gonzalez; split merged interjections (Exactly. Yeah; You think so; Car/C-A-R exchange; Hal Finney question). Fixed half (not "the top"), Southerners, comprehensible, hit you up, Los/C-Los, Carlos Gonzalez, Bitcoin Hex, Richard Heart, Satoshi, Crypto Insider, "you should also add that". Removed stray "Thank you"/"Bye", laugh tag, doubled-word artifacts.