Title: S1 E5: Matt B on Bitcoin in Ireland and New Zealand, Satoshi Nakamoto Conspiracies, and More Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Matt B, Bitcoin journalist (Bitcoin Magazine, formerly Crypto Insider), Irishman living in New Zealand Published: 2019-02-06 Duration: 2:17:45 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2019-02-03_matt_b_bitcoin_takeover_podcast.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2019-02-03_matt_b_bitcoin_takeover_podcast.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:27] Vlad Costea: Hello and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I'm Vlad and my guest today is Matt B. And that's a B as in Bitcoin. And I'm not sure whether or not I should call him Matt Bitcoin, but at the same time I know that he's a fellow writer. He also writes for Bitcoin Magazine. He used to write for Crypto Insider. And I guess we have a lot in common, and there is one specific article about doing off-chain Bitcoin transactions that I ripped off from him and I'm not sure if he's aware of it, but anyway, hello Matt. [00:01:30] Matt B: Thanks for having me. [00:01:32] Vlad Costea: Hi, it's good to have you and I'm happy that I get to have the opinion of a fellow writer. I'm not sure if you consider yourself to be a journalist, but you're definitely a writer. And we can talk about this incredible technology which got only bigger despite of the market movements, got only bigger after we saw the communities agreeing on the paths of scaling. Are you still there? [00:02:05] Matt B: Yeah, yeah, sorry. Yeah. [00:02:08] Vlad Costea: I just took a break. I wasn't sure if you want to go on and say that you agree with me or whatever. This is very informal, so we don't have anything planned. Just so you know, if you're listening this. [00:02:21] Matt B: I agree with you on the scaling thing. I mean, I think 2017, that was one of the big events, kind of the rift between big blocks and off-chain scaling. Yeah, I like kind of secondary solutions. There's a lot there to write about. [00:02:44] Vlad Costea: I guess I also appreciate the fact that even big blockers have seen how terrible it can be when they disagree about bigger blocks, like we saw the hash war in late 2018. [00:03:01] Matt B: Yeah, that hash war was really quite anticlimactic. I was expecting a lot bigger, more of a scuffle. [00:03:12] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but it was still some kind of show-off on behalf of both sides, and they were both trying to come out as victors and pretending to hold the true vision of Satoshi, and one of them ended up being called Satoshi's Vision, and it was actually funny to see them disagree about increasing the block size to a certain limit. [00:03:40] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, aren't they talking about terabyte blocks? [00:03:44] Vlad Costea: No, that's on the roadmap. I guess right now they have 64 megabytes. I should check it out though. But I know that they have bigger blocks than Bitcoin Cash, like ABC. And they are planning to have terabyte blocks and they pretend to be the government and enterprise-friendly version of Bitcoin. [00:04:08] Matt B: Yeah, I mean... [00:04:10] Vlad Costea: Which is hilarious if you read the tweets of Craig Wright. And I cannot do it directly. I had to follow one of the bots which actually retweet whatever he posts. And if you follow him, he's obsessed with patents while pretending to be Satoshi. [00:04:29] Matt B: Yeah, it's weird. He talks a lot of nonsense. I see him apply kind of definitions to things that literally no one else holds. It's entertaining though. My feed's been quite boring since he blocked me sometime last year. But as you say, this bot kind of lets you into his mind. [00:04:58] Vlad Costea: So was it funny for you to see how, for the first time ever, the ABC side of Bitcoin Cash was saying that it's actually important to run your own node? And they had this disagreement about whether or not it's important to run a node. They were trying to win the consensus war, and they required, in spite of all the hashing power, they also required nodes to be their voters. To me it was quite ironic. [00:05:28] Matt B: Poetic justice. [00:05:30] Vlad Costea: Poetic justice. [00:05:33] Matt B: I like the way you put it. Yeah, nodes are like the backbone of Bitcoin. I mean, if you want to have, I mean, what is it with Bitcoin? I don't even know what it's called. Bitcoin ABC now is 32 gigabytes, is it? [00:05:47] Vlad Costea: No, it's megabytes. How can it be 32 gigabytes? [00:05:50] Matt B: Sorry. Megabytes. But that's quite a strain on your node. I mean, my normal Bitcoin node has a terabyte hard drive attached to it. And you're downloading, what, between like one and 2.4 megabytes every 10 minutes. I'm not going to have to replace that for a couple years anyways. But once you start bringing in these bigger blocks, you drive the price up of running a node, which kind of rules out other people from using them. [00:06:30] Vlad Costea: Right, let's just forget about the BCH side of the debate and focus on the really good stuff that's actually going to be around here in five years. And you right now, you're Irish, right? And you're fortunate and lucky enough to have traveled all the way to New Zealand. So you get the best of both worlds and I guess you can give us the perspective on what it's like to be a Bitcoin hodler in both countries and whether or not you can actually use it as a mean of exchange to pay for restaurants, or maybe go to a hotel and pay with Bitcoin. Or maybe purchase items online. [00:07:17] Matt B: Yeah, I use Bitrefill quite a lot. That's a fantastic service. You can get Uber Eats vouchers, Uber vouchers, phone top-ups. So that's quite convenient. I mean, you know, you kind of have this exaggerated belief that Bitcoiners just kind of hold the Bitcoin, don't spend it under any circumstances. I kind of disagree with that, to be honest. I mean, I think the, like a parable, the message you want to take from that is just be responsible with your finances. But I think Bitcoin should be spent to an extent, of course, then you want to hold some of it long-term. But yeah, aside from internet purchases, I have trouble spending it. What about yourself? Because you're paid in Bitcoin as well. [00:08:21] Vlad Costea: That's an interesting disclosure, and I may or may not be paid in Bitcoin. I don't know. That's my job with the Romanian fiscal authority. But anyway, it's a nightmare for recording taxes. We have this company, which is called Bitcoin Romania, and it's not quite the most originally named company out there. But they have ATMs. So basically in every supermarket around the country which has an agreement with them and has this terminal to pay your bills, you can actually pay your bills with Bitcoin or Ethereum. And you can also purchase crypto. [00:09:04] Vlad Costea: Like only Bitcoin and Ethereum. You can purchase them directly from that terminal, which is also used to pay bills, and you would just insert banknotes. Yeah. So it's interesting in this regard, but of course they have their premium price for these services. You pay about 10% more when buying Bitcoin. [00:09:31] Vlad Costea: And they also have a few ATMs from which you can withdraw cash if you have Bitcoin, but they have an interest rate of about 7 to 8%, which I guess you don't mind if you bought maybe at $100 and you sell it right now, but if you get paid in Bitcoin, you actually have to wait for a 7% increase so you break even and you don't actually lose money. [00:10:01] Vlad Costea: But it's still there. It's an interesting service. It's good to have it there. It's reassuring in a sense that you don't need to rely on people on LocalBitcoins to actually help you have some fiat if you get paid only in Bitcoin. And also, you have some shops, like electronic stores which accept Bitcoin, but it's not directly, it's through payment processors. We also have some restaurants and some hotels, but they also use payment processors. So in this regard, nobody really takes the coins. They just take their fiat after somebody hodls and buys the coins that you send them. Do you have anything similar in New Zealand? [00:10:58] Matt B: Literally nothing. Not that I can think of, anyways. I'm not in the biggest city. I don't know, maybe somewhere like Auckland may have them. But I don't think... No, I've never used it for anything other than online purchases. [00:11:23] Vlad Costea: What about Ireland? Ireland? [00:11:28] Matt B: No, again, nothing. You know, I don't think I've ever spent bitcoins in a physical location. [00:11:39] Vlad Costea: This is actually interesting. How come an Eastern European country has such a... I don't know, has this type of enthusiasm about it? It's strange to me. And also we have John Carvalho, the Bitcoin Error Log, who lives in Romania. It was crazy when I found out about it. So when he had all that Bcash debate with Roger Ver, he was actually in his apartment from Romania. [00:12:12] Matt B: Yeah, does he run a meetup there as well? [00:12:16] Vlad Costea: Yeah, he meets people every week, but I never go there just because I have this crazy schedule, so I have to work. So yeah, I wish I could go to these meetups just to see what the community looks like and what kind of people actually participate. But at the same time, I was happy to meet him in person once. And I guess he'd be very happy to hear that you use Bitrefill now that he works for them. And I think I'm going to interview him for the same podcast this week. So that's a nice coincidence. [00:13:00] Matt B: Yeah, no, I used to run a meetup in Ireland. We had massive turnout of, I think it was four people one night. That was kind of a highlight. [00:13:13] Vlad Costea: Really? I mean, how do you explain this lack of interest? Do you have such a low inflation rate or do you have such a high trust in banks and institutions that people don't care? [00:13:26] Matt B: Yeah, far from it. I mean, the one in Dublin is massive. I'm from the north, so I don't know, I'm just gonna put it down as a small city. The meetup group itself had quite a lot of people join, but not a lot of them showed up. But yeah, if I go back, I'd like to pick it up again. [00:13:51] Vlad Costea: So are you from the north of Ireland or from Northern Ireland? [00:13:57] Matt B: From the north. Well, northern, both, I suppose. Right on the border. [00:14:04] Vlad Costea: Okay. I guess that's an important distinction to make, as you are part of the European Union. [00:14:15] Matt B: Yeah, for the moment. [00:14:17] Vlad Costea: For the moment, yeah. But you know, in Romania it's interesting that so many people have gotten into Bitcoin, and at first it was all about computer scientists. And I can think about one guy who is said to own about 600,000 bitcoins. He's considered to be one of the biggest whales. And he never sold anything. And you know, you think about this small country in Eastern Europe and you ask yourself, okay, what is so special about it? Why so many of us have gotten into it? Do you have any theories? [00:15:03] Vlad Costea: I think we have a bad experience with communism and maybe a low trust in institutions, but at the same time, I know that in France, they have the same case with low trust in politicians and institutions. I guess they like a bigger state. At the same time, they are okay with everything being public and subsidized by their taxes. Whereas in Romania we have an increasing wave of libertarianism, in the sense that people begin to question the efficiency of the public system, which is basically inherited from the old regime. [00:15:47] Vlad Costea: We have the old generation which could not conceive how anything can be private, because they lived under a totalitarian regime. So naturally, the next institutions after the revolution were not changed so much and their structure is still public and we pay taxes so they get funded. But when you see that you have a high percentage of corruption, and you actually have to bribe your doctor to make sure that he doesn't cripple you during a surgery... It's not like that anymore. It used to be a lot worse, but... [00:16:24] Vlad Costea: In some parts, you still have to give some kind of bribe, just to be sure that they pay attention to you and treat you in a nice way. Even though you're paying for the services through your taxes, and all of us, when we file our tax returns and we declare our revenues, we have to pay for the medical system, for the whole administration apparatus, also for public education. And if you want to go private, it's not like you can opt out and say, "I'm not going to pay for the state services and I want to go private." [00:17:06] Vlad Costea: You just pay for the state services and use extra money to go private. So I guess this is why we got more interested in Bitcoin. [00:17:16] Matt B: Yeah, because I think Bitcoin, if widely adopted, could have quite a knock-on effect on tax systems in general. But it would have to be a lot more opt-in. [00:17:29] Vlad Costea: At the same time, Bitcoin is not very fungible. So I'm not sure if there are communities who are supportive of Monero or even Zcash to some extent. I've never met them, but I suppose that these people who own large amounts of Bitcoin might also like Monero. [00:17:51] Matt B: Yeah, I like... No, I consider myself kind of in the school of Bitcoin maximalism. But I like Monero a lot. I think it fills a use case that Bitcoin doesn't yet. Same with kind of the Mimblewimble implementations. But 2019 definitely seems primed for being the year Bitcoin becomes more private. I mean, you've got all these kind of CoinJoin implementations, got Pay to Endpoint, Schnorr. But I'm not sure that will be... I don't see that on the horizon, not for another couple years anyways. But the Lightning Network even... I think the privacy concerns... It's going to become a lot harder for, you know, agencies to kind of track the source of funds. [00:18:50] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but at the same time, I recently found out that there are some companies which specialize in analyzing Bitcoin addresses, and they associate your internet traffic, which they can get from the ISPs, from your internet providers, with the Bitcoin addresses that you look for. So if I check for a specific public key on blockchain.info, then it's going to show up in my browsing history and they can automatically associate that with maybe a Bitcoin wallet that I hold. I never really put too much thought into this, but this can be done easily. [00:19:37] Vlad Costea: So if you're not using onion routing, and if you're not very cautious and use wallets like Wasabi and Samourai, it's pretty easy to determine which address you're actually interested in, from where you get your money, and you can do all that kind of analysis and track your funds. [00:20:01] Matt B: Mm-hmm. The block explorer I like to recommend is oxt.me. And that's, I think, Samourai own it. That's a good one. Because as you say, blockchain.info, if you're waiting on a payment and you're constantly refreshing the page, they're going to obviously associate that IP and cluster the address with that IP address. Yeah, I mean, that's kind of the importance of running a node as well, right? If you're using a custodial wallet, Bloom filters, they're kind of designed to mask which UTXOs you're looking to see. But you're still able to kind of narrow down or like cluster the addresses. And we have Neutrino now, which is slightly more private. [00:21:04] Vlad Costea: Sure, but these solutions are not very accessible to those who get in. And I guess it's the same case as Zcash, which some people just buy from exchanges and they think that every transaction that they're making is actually private when it's actually not. And private transactions are more expensive and slower and you have to opt in for the private transactions. And a lot of people can get confused in the process. I guess it's the same with Bitcoin transactions, which make your transaction both fungible and private. You actually have to do some research, you have to own the proper means, you have to run your own node. [00:21:53] Vlad Costea: There is a list of requirements that you need to fulfill in order to be sure of the privacy of your coins. [00:22:04] Matt B: Yeah, that is the problem with opt-in privacy. The other one is that you have quite small anonymity set. I mean, if only a fraction of Bitcoin users are, say, using CoinJoin, you know, you have a fairly small pool of addresses to analyze. So, I mean, I think it's important that, you know, everyone starts to use CoinJoin or other kind of similar schemes. The more the merrier. Makes it more difficult for these blockchain analysis companies and such. [00:22:47] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I sometimes suspect that these companies are funded by government money. Because otherwise, who would actually care about what you're doing? Or maybe quantum computing companies which can't wait to try to crack down SHA-256, and they will associate your public key and try to crack down the encryption. That's insane. It will take maybe two more decades, at least that's what I heard. I'm not sure. I'm not a specialist in the field of quantum computing. [00:23:26] Matt B: I remember seeing a theory a while back that Satoshi, the addresses with a million Bitcoin, they're basically there as bait, so that, I think, something like the NSA can see as soon as someone's cracked quantum computing. [00:23:46] Vlad Costea: That's interesting. [00:23:48] Matt B: I mean, it's up there with the whole "Satoshi's an alien." You get some credible theories. [00:23:56] Vlad Costea: You have a favorite one? [00:23:59] Matt B: I think that one has to be my top one. I think the Craig Wright Satoshi one is quite taking quite a few liberties. [00:24:17] Vlad Costea: I think two of my favorite ones are that Satoshi is a time traveler, or that he's the first artificial intelligence to develop software in a very successful way. But at the same time, you also have the NSA theories, like Satoshi means intelligence and Nakamoto means central, if you do this very rough and maybe free translation and you take into account some word roots in Japanese. And you come up with this and say, "Okay, so it's an experiment by the CIA." And you have these cryptographers who are brought together and they had to develop Bitcoin. [00:25:09] Vlad Costea: And they deployed it out there in the open. And then what? What's the purpose of this? They're trying to replace the US dollar. They're trying to run an experiment on human greed. I've heard so many theories about it. I thought that, okay, this might be a legit theory and maybe that the NSA or the CIA had all the money in the world and all the manpower to create something like Bitcoin. But you can't really find a proper answer for the question why. Nothing really makes sense. [00:25:45] Matt B: There was an interview with a DEA agent a while ago and he said Bitcoin was great for, you know, assisting them with drug crimes because it is just a permanent record of transactions versus, you know, cash. It's a lot easier to track. [00:26:07] Vlad Costea: Actually, if the entire world was to adopt Bitcoin in its current form, and we gave up on cash, I think our financial situation would be quite Orwellian, because it becomes very easy to track down payments. They're all just written on the ledger. You just have to make the proper associations with the IP address and maybe do some, what's it called, social engineering, and you're all set to find out everything about everyone. [00:26:44] Matt B: Absolutely. I think this idea of transitioning to a cashless society, it's quite dangerous, at least at the moment. I don't think the software is really ready yet. Cash gives you some assurances you don't get with cryptocurrency. [00:27:05] Vlad Costea: I know it sounds crazy when I say it, but since I got into Bitcoin, I've started to appreciate cash much more. Because it gives me the privacy of not leaving any traces. I just go to the shop and I pay with cash. That's so much more convenient. [00:27:20] Matt B: Yeah, absolutely. [00:27:22] Vlad Costea: I see all my friends paying with their credit cards and they brag about getting some kind of special gifts back from the bank and some kind of benefits. But I just like cash. For Bitcoin, I see the value proposition as being the kind of asset or valuable item that nobody can confiscate from you. [00:27:50] Vlad Costea: I think the store of value part is much more important than the mean of exchange. Because you can always do something with a centralized system, which is faster, more scalable, more secure, easier to fix if bugs are identified. Whereas Bitcoin should always be secure and should always provide a medium for you to store your value securely and in a way that you can trust. And you don't have to trust an institution, you just have to trust the underlying cryptography. [00:28:27] Matt B: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I mean, when I got into Bitcoin, I didn't give too much thought to, you know, the financial ecosystem. Didn't really have a problem with fiat currencies. And of course, the more you read... I'd never heard of Austrian economics before I got into Bitcoin. It kind of starts to make you question fiat currency, and the more you kind of look into Bitcoin, the more it kind of makes you question that even more. It's like a positive feedback loop and then... Before you know it, you're in the Austrian camp. [00:29:06] Vlad Costea: So what is your background, if you never heard of Austrian economics? [00:29:11] Matt B: I did law at university. I mean, I got interested in Bitcoin in high school. I didn't really, you know, fall down the rabbit hole straight away. Yeah, no, Austrian economics, must have only stumbled across that two or three years ago. [00:29:35] Vlad Costea: Oh, so are you younger than I am? [00:29:37] Matt B: 22. [00:29:38] Vlad Costea: Oh, so you're very young. I'll be 27 next month. [00:29:42] Matt B: Alright. So yeah, I'm a lot younger. [00:29:45] Vlad Costea: You're a lot younger. When I was 22, it was the first time I heard about Bitcoin, and it was mostly jokes about people owning Bitcoin and being broke. And that was in 2014, it was during the crash. [00:30:11] Vlad Costea: I didn't know much about it. I started reading, I've lost interest because I was doing political science. I have a master in political science and comparative politics. And I just read an article from, I think it was Washington Post or Financial Times or whatever, Wall Street Journal, doesn't matter. It was about Bitcoin and how the whole libertarian dream came to an end and how it's all a scam, a Ponzi scheme. At the time, I guess it was a popular media narrative to call it a Ponzi or a pyramid scheme. [00:30:55] Vlad Costea: I just read that and I said to myself, "I'll move on. I can live without ever knowing much about it." But as time passed and it recovered, and I even had at one point... I was an exchange student in Paris in 2015, and I had to do a presentation assigned by the professor on blockchain and Bitcoin. And at the time, I just did it, you know, how you do all the school chores. Chores, not course. It's just an obligation. You learn the bare minimum, you make that PowerPoint presentation and then move on with your life. [00:31:36] Vlad Costea: But to this day, I still regret that. You know, I had all the information. I had the opportunity to learn much more and to get on Bitcointalk and maybe, I don't know, buy one Bitcoin because it was only $100 at the time. But I didn't. [00:31:59] Matt B: Yeah, I sold my first Bitcoin when I made like $10 profit. So I'm doing pretty great with my stuff. [00:32:07] Vlad Costea: Same. But you shouldn't feel bad. It's still a profit. [00:32:11] Matt B: Yeah. [00:32:14] Vlad Costea: I mean, economically speaking, at least you didn't get wrecked. So, what should I ask you? You're 22 and you got into law. And did you graduate in law? [00:32:34] Matt B: Yeah, bachelor's degree. Yeah, it doesn't particularly appeal to me to follow a career in law. I'll go back and do my master's, but I might do it in software development. I code on the side. Yeah. Law's not that interesting. [00:33:05] Vlad Costea: Well, if you ask me, it's very interesting. And you had people like Nick Szabo who got into law just to better understand how contracts work, so he can develop his theory on smart contracts. So I guess it's required as a skill to be able to juggle with the laws of governments and then understand how the governance of blockchain works. And I guess you also have a fellow Romanian, Vlad Zamfir from Ethereum, and he spends a lot of time talking about governance, and he's in charge of his version of Casper proof of stake. [00:33:46] Vlad Costea: I'm not sure if he has any background whatsoever in law, but if he had, I guess he would understand slightly better how blockchains should work. [00:33:59] Matt B: Yeah, that's the thing. I mean, I really don't think... I mean, you do get kind of pseudo blockchains that aren't really, you know, decentralized enough to resist, you know, state actors. I mean, I think that's the beauty of Bitcoin. You're not going to shut that down with any kind of legal, you know, any bills, legislation. You could try, but I don't think it would have much of an impact. [00:34:29] Vlad Costea: I also know that governments at this point are willing to cooperate and talk to people who can advise them on proper policies regarding cryptocurrencies. Because it's very easy for them to at least try to ban them, or declare that they're all securities and they should be taxed accordingly. But the outcome is not as they hope for. And I guess you've learned in law school that you have a literal law and you have the spirit of the law. So you have the intention and the literal application of each law. [00:35:12] Vlad Costea: And even though you have good intentions and you think that it's going to work that way, you're going to end up with a very poor application unless you understand the whole picture. And then there's also the issue of over-legislation: when you try too hard to legislate and you specify each condition as parts of the law, then you're going to have a lot of trouble with people just bypassing. But I guess it's different in Ireland. You have a common law system inherited from Great Britain, right? [00:35:49] Matt B: I actually studied UK law. I studied it in Scotland. That's common law. Yes, yes. Yeah, quite similar. [00:36:05] Vlad Costea: I did some civil law. Romania has taken the French model of institutions. Back in the beginning of the 20th century, everybody used to speak French instead of English, and it was our main cultural influence. Anyway, that's a new relevant detail for our discussion. Do you know of any Bitcoin regulations in Ireland or in New Zealand? [00:36:39] Matt B: I think just other than the tax law. I mean, it's a nightmare getting paid in Bitcoin. You need to record everything anytime you sell. But at least, you know, we're in a bear market, so most of the time it's a slight loss. And... They're not overly harsh on, you know, banning that or whatever. [00:37:04] Vlad Costea: Here in Romania, there is no piece of legislation to mention Bitcoin at this point. None whatsoever. Nothing on blockchain, nothing on cryptocurrencies. They just have something on digital currencies, which are M-Pesa and some other digital currencies which are used as tokens by some companies to ease transactions. But they don't have to do with ERC-20 tokens or anything related to crypto. [00:37:40] Matt B: Yeah, do you remember, in, I think it was 2014, 2013, maybe, the EU looked really pumped to kind of go and, you know, provide good legislation, assemble task forces and everything. But it really looks like things are stalling in that regard. [00:38:00] Vlad Costea: Yeah, how do you deal with something over which you have no control? And if you were to try to control it, you would actually threaten your provisions on private property, and you would actually turn your government into something questionably democratic. So it's code. If you were to ban Bitcoin, you'd have to ban other types of code. [00:38:26] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, there's that idea. [00:38:29] Vlad Costea: Point your finger on one specific feature in that code which doesn't comply to your legislative system. So it's difficult. You can only say that the assets resulting from that code are actually money. [00:38:48] Vlad Costea: But at the same time, I don't think governments want to acknowledge Bitcoin as money. That would be a way for them to prepare the ground for a big loss, because as soon as they acknowledge that it's a currency which they tax, then the next step would be for citizens to begin to trust that currency. They're going to say, "Okay, so my government acknowledges Bitcoin as a currency, which means that I can buy it and hold it, having complete trust in the wisdom of my government, which said that it's safe." [00:39:23] Vlad Costea: And that's a big difference. Up to this point, they can only point their fingers and say, "That's a scam. That's going to collapse. That's going to fall. There's no future for it. Beware of investing in such a thing. Don't touch it. Trust our central banks." So they have this authority of shaping the narrative, creating the news, but they cannot control anything about Bitcoin. I guess that's the beauty of it. There's a clear divide. I guess the governors of central banks are very much aware of what's going on. [00:40:05] Vlad Costea: But they don't want to rush up until the moment when they have to legitimize something which is not issued by their central bank, is not part of any international agreement, and cannot be controlled in a way that favors their policies. [00:40:25] Matt B: That's a very good point. I mean, as soon as your government starts saying, you know, don't buy Bitcoin, that's your buy signal. [00:40:39] Vlad Costea: Yes, sure. I remember back in early 2018, we had the governor of the Romanian Central Bank, who made a media press conference to announce that Bitcoin has collapsed in price and we should all be aware of the fact that it's a bad investment. And instead, we can invest in state assets, which give a guaranteed 5% return after a determined number of years, or we can make bank deposits, which don't really give a big return anymore. But that's only the financial aspect. That's only for people who only care about putting in $10 and getting $20. [00:41:27] Vlad Costea: If you take a look and you're interested in property, and actually having something which cannot be confiscated, then that's a better use case than the speculative aspect. I guess everybody gets into Bitcoin for the promise of making a profit. You see it as an investment at first, and then I guess that through the market cycles, you get wrecked. And once you get wrecked, you either take your money and leave, or you begin to read about it and get informed and try to understand what's going on. And it's then that you actually realize that there's so much more to it than you initially thought. [00:42:15] Vlad Costea: And that's why I also have a good idea or a good opinion about all these other projects which people call shitcoins. I think I like Litecoin and Ethereum Classic and Monero, because I consider them to be gateway drugs to Bitcoin. You buy them because they're cheap. You learn how to use them through wallets and all these applications. But at some point you actually realize that the real deal is actually Bitcoin. And their communities are also supportive of Bitcoin. They say, "Okay, we have this specific use case. [00:43:01] Vlad Costea: We promise to do this." But Charlie Lee himself tells you to buy a whole Bitcoin before investing in Litecoin, and that's quite something. That's a benefit for the entire community, which I guess some Bitcoin maximalists fail to understand. [00:43:21] Matt B: Yeah, I'm one of them. I think as a gateway, I mean, one that I do like, kind of, is Ethereum Classic. It has an interesting kind of philosophical alignment with Bitcoin. Again, Monero does something Bitcoin doesn't really do at the moment. Litecoin is just... It just seems a bit pointless to me. Like, I understand what you're saying about gateway drugs, but with that market cap, I don't think you can justify it. I mean, its whole value proposition, you know, you get a block every, what, 2.5 minutes, faster transactions. That's done now. I mean, you have the Lightning Network. A lot of people working on that. [00:44:09] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but I give it like two more years at least until the Lightning Network becomes more user-friendly and gets beyond this bubble or echo chamber of enthusiasts. You only have a few people who are actually interested in Lightning, and then an entire sector or an entire group, which is very large, of people who just want to max out their investment. And when you want to max out your investment, you look at Bitcoin and you see that one unit right now is 4.5K, I'm not sure what it's worth. [00:44:48] Vlad Costea: I don't check CoinMarketCap anymore on a daily basis. But if you see Litecoin, you see that it's about 30 bucks and you say, okay, I'm going to buy this. It used to be 300 something dollars. Maybe I buy this and I hold it for a while, and I will get 10x on my investment, which I guess is a decent and not out of ordinary thought to have if you believe in the technology. But once you get into this environment, you can either fall into the rabbit hole and join the community and see what they think about the industry and learn something more than that. [00:45:31] Vlad Costea: Or you can just be a speculator. And I think the first group of people actually benefit and get into Bitcoin, and that benefits the group of Bitcoiners at large. Well, the latter may make some money, or may just get wrecked and spread some bad rumors and back up the bad reputation that cryptocurrencies have. [00:46:05] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, I do have a softer spot for Litecoin. I mean, because they deployed SegWit first, didn't they? I used to kind of justify it as like a testbed for innovation on Bitcoin. I think it does more harm than it does good. I mean, if you say someone goes to buy Litecoin because it's $30, what's to stop them then from going to, you know, this pre-mined token, owners control 80% of the supply, that's only 50 cents? I think it's important to kind of distinguish Bitcoin from the rest of them. Unless the others have kind of specific use cases, again, like privacy. [00:46:57] Vlad Costea: I think that's a good point. I'm not sure if I have a counter argument right now. Because if you get on Coinbase, you can find lots of shitcoins these days. You can find 0x, which I'm not sure what it even does or what its value proposition is. It's like an ERC-20 token which centralizes other ERC-20 tokens. [00:47:22] Matt B: Yeah, I've come across... what is it? It does like decentralized exchanges or something. I mean, you can do that without a token. It's a shame because you see a lot of good businesses, I think, that could work without a token. It's just oddly coincidental that blockchain technology is, you know, so disruptive, whatever, when it also makes its founders millions, billions sometimes, of dollars before they even produce a product. Like, a lot of this stuff can be done without a blockchain. [00:47:59] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I hear that opinion a lot. And some people like to justify the use of blockchain just for the lack of censorship. They can resist to a certain degree the idea of censorship. And maybe some app developers like the idea of having their work stored on many nodes, and I don't know why anyone would ever care enough to censor their app, but whatever. [00:48:31] Matt B: There was quite an interesting thread by Preston Byrne, I think it was yesterday or the day before, on how Ethereum basically runs on Infura's servers. I mean, most people talking about censorship resistance is just them launching a token on top of Ethereum. Does that not kind of make Ethereum your central point of failure that you're trying to avoid? [00:49:00] Vlad Costea: I mean, I don't like Ethereum for a very specific reason: that when they hard fork, it doesn't take much until all the nodes update to the new version, which means it's very centralized in its governance. They had that infamous DAO hard fork, which ended up backing up the investors instead of sticking with immutability. And I guess that's why I like the classic side of Ethereum. And also you can have like three or four people gathering in the same room and they decide, "How about we delay this upgrade and we put something else instead?" and they say, "Oh, brilliant idea, let's do it." [00:49:48] Vlad Costea: And the fact that you have so much power invested in just a few people makes it what I like to call an oligarchy. And that's going to become even more prevalent as soon as they switch to proof of stake, and they're going to inflate their supply according to how much coins everybody owns. [00:50:16] Matt B: Yeah, I think it will be interesting to see how this Constantinople hard fork plays out. I mean, will it be contentious? I've not looked too much at the, you know, the two sides of it, but Ethereum just seems to be quite... Their whole community seems to be very optimistic about proof of stake. But I agree with you, it's a plutocracy. You're not putting any kind of skin in the game. You see, miners, they can rise and fall. Like, if you look, a good few years ago, GHash.io at one point, I think, was 51% of the Bitcoin hash power. [00:51:00] Matt B: They're not really in the picture anymore. Because mining requires that you constantly stay on top of developments, ASIC chips. It requires that, you know, you burn money essentially. And you don't get that with proof of stake. You're reusing the same lottery tickets. So rich get richer. [00:51:26] Vlad Costea: Yeah. I guess that's the economic model and the security model of Ethereum. And that's why I like Bitcoin, because it's a system of elites which can crumble at any point. We've seen Bitmain just collapse in a matter of months due to sticking with Bitcoin Cash against all the warnings, and also doing some bad investments with the ASICs and not being able to keep up with the competition. And we see them close down offices and dumping thousands of ASICs and throwing them, and we see pictures, and I'm not sure how many of them are just propaganda by those who oppose their dominance. But it's clear that you have a giant which is slowly fading away from the scene, and we're going to witness some other entity which... [00:52:27] Vlad Costea: May or may not get the same amount of influence, but this is the beauty of a free market, which mining through the proof of work consensus algorithm creates. It's all about being there, doing the kind of work that is required. And if you manage to be profitable, you're going to be around for a long time. If you take some kind of risk, there is always somebody to replace this same kind of work and rise up to the scene. That's not something that you will ever see in proof of stake. [00:53:02] Vlad Costea: In proof of stake, it's all about how many coins you own. You keep your node running, and you just receive a fixed amount according to... Not a fixed amount, a fixed percentage according to how much you already own. That only perpetuates the same system. It's not like you can expect any kind of change. Unless somebody gets hacked, or if they suddenly decide to make big donations to spread adoption. [00:53:35] Matt B: Yeah. I mean, I'd like to see a consensus mechanism that doesn't consume so much electricity, but so far nothing's manifested itself. I don't think proof of stake is the answer. [00:53:50] Vlad Costea: I mean, I've also seen how EOS, or EOS, I'm still not sure how they choose to pronounce it, they have that system of a few oligarchs who decide and vote all the time. They are block producers and they are basically the governors of this entire network. I guess it's an interesting experiment, which doesn't deserve all the attention and all the money that it has. But that's not up to me to decide or up to somebody else. I guess in the long term it's just the market and the technology that will determine whoever becomes the victor and resists on the market for another ten to five years. [00:54:42] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, stuff like EOS, I think that makes perfect sense for businesses. You don't really need censorship resistance for your supply chain. EOS, so like something like that, or like even Blockstream's Liquid, where you just have a couple of validators. I think definitely why they needed to raise billions of dollars is kind of beyond me. [00:55:11] Vlad Costea: Well, they need it for marketing. They need it to keep the price up all the time so they can burn as much EOS as they can just to stay in the top 10 and hopefully remain relevant for a longer time. But you don't see that in Bitcoin. Or do we? I guess we see miners who decide to inflate or maybe pump the price, just so they max out their investments. It's in their best interest to keep the price at a level of profitability, so that they never really do it at a loss, which makes a lot of economic sense. [00:56:05] Vlad Costea: But that's a long stretch to affirm that it's thanks to the miners that we have a support area, which is right at the threshold of global mining profitability. That's not up to me to state and I'm not sure how it works. I still don't trust technical analysis. I think most of it is bogus and it's made up by people who need Twitter followers and want to sell their private Telegram channels. [00:56:38] Matt B: Yeah. Yeah, I've never really traded, but yeah, don't really think technical analysis is something that applies to, you know, cryptocurrencies, tokens. I could be wrong. I mean, some people seem to swear by it. [00:57:01] Vlad Costea: No, I'm not very sure if... I almost broke into Romanian. It's hard for me to think in two languages. But I'm not very sure how the price works, but I'm not in this for the price specifically. And I'm looking forward to the developments in Bitcoin over the next five to ten years. I know that it will be around. I know that governments will strongly oppose it. I'm actually intrigued to see that rumor about Russia getting into Bitcoin as a reserve currency and as a way to bypass all the restrictions and the embargoes that are in terms of trading. What do you think about that? [00:57:54] Matt B: I was thinking about this one earlier. You see, if a country adopts it as a reserve currency, I think it's only a matter of time before they start issuing like Bitcoin tokens and inflating the supply of those. But yeah, no, it's interesting. I mean, if Russia adopts it will definitely get villainized. I mean, look at Gab.com. All of a sudden, Bitcoin's become this currency for Nazis in the media. It was the same with the Silk Road: currency for drug dealers, ransomware, currency for hackers, so on, so forth. I think these are going to keep coming. [00:58:41] Matt B: I didn't used to think an ETF would be a good thing, but someone made quite an interesting point where if you have kind of big shot investors investing in Bitcoin, even if it is with a financial instrument that's not directly holding your private keys, you kind of make it more difficult for the government to have an unfavourable stance when it comes to legislating it, because so many of your citizens are now holding this asset. [00:59:19] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's a further legitimation in this sense. But I guess an ETF also leads to a lot more price speculation. It leads to a lot of uninformed investors who suddenly become interested and they get the wrong idea of what Bitcoin should be. [00:59:41] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, I think different people will always have different threat models. I mean, I fully believe some people will go through their whole lives using Bitcoin and never holding their private keys. I think some people won't even be interested in technology itself, just trade speculatively. I think what's important is that you can always run your node, you can always transact without having your payment interrupted. And that option will always be there, I think. [01:00:12] Vlad Costea: Yeah. I guess these people should, before judging and before posting sensational headlines about what Bitcoin is, maybe they should look into the writings of Tim May, who wrote the Cyphernomicon. And in the first page, he describes the cypherpunk ethos, which says that to them, it's much more important to retain privacy than to become accountable to authorities. So if criminals begin to use their technology, then just so be it. They don't care much about it. Their purpose is to attain a high degree of privacy and not to become friendly to the governments and create loopholes and allow state agencies to monitor the activity. [01:01:06] Vlad Costea: Privacy comes first, then compliance with laws comes later. And that's where Bitcoin comes from. It comes from a world where it doesn't really matter who you are and what you want to do with the protocol. The consensus within that's written in code actually incentivizes actors to be honest, and you have much more to win if you play by the rules than otherwise. I guess that's the innovation of Bitcoin in itself. It solves this interesting military problem in a way that has helped it survive for 10 years now, and it keeps afloat and alive lots of altcoins which basically use the same core principles. [01:02:01] Matt B: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I mean, I'm ashamed to say I used to kind of tend towards positivism on the legal side, where a law is only as valid as the government upholding it. But I think Bitcoin is kind of like a lot more in line with almost like a natural law, where you assert your right to privacy, freedom of association, and there's nothing anyone can do about it. [01:02:33] Matt B: You know, it's your right. It's kind of like a social contract that you have when you start to transact on Bitcoin. It's the same thing with encryption. You mentioned Tim May's stuff, the Crypto Anarchist Manifesto. There's some of the points in that, they ring true today. I mean, this thing was written, what, 30 years ago? In the late 80s, I think. Yeah. [01:03:10] Vlad Costea: I think, you know, when I don't write about cryptocurrencies, I also try to finish a PhD in political philosophy. And in terms of philosophy, you have these schools of thought. There's the positive school of thought regarding human nature, which says that we as rational beings are actually innately good, and we have the best of intentions. And it's not that we are born bad. We actually have very good intentions. And when we drift away from this idea, it's usually due to greed, but that's the exception. So being a bad actor is actually the exception to the rule. Whereas there's the negative school of thought, which I guess is embodied by... [01:04:07] Vlad Costea: Wait, I have this. I don't remember his name. So he wrote The Leviathan. Hobbes? Thomas Hobbes, yeah. I wanted to say Edmund Burke, but that's somebody else and that's a different school. Thomas Hobbes. He is the embodiment of this idea that we are all evil and we are all wild. We are just animals who wait for a greater authority to give them rules and tame them and show them how to live. Because otherwise, you know, you have that famous quote about being nasty, brutish and short in terms of our lives. [01:04:52] Vlad Costea: And that's also the school of thought which many of my professors in the political science school abide to, and they explain to us that it's a good idea to have regulations, to legislate, to make sure that everybody acts according to the law. But in this regard, I think I'm closer to the idea of a social contract, which was written by Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Which, in a nutshell... It's a lot more complex than this, obviously. But he believes that we have reached a certain point in human evolution and development where we can be much more educated than just animals. [01:05:41] Vlad Costea: So in a state of law, in a state of nature, we can actually use our education and all the years of civilization that we've had to construct something that we think is better, as opposed to turn into our primal selves. [01:06:02] Matt B: Yeah, I actually strongly, strongly disagree with the idea of a social contract. I mean, you're born into something. I mean, I don't recall signing any of these documents in the womb. Like, I wouldn't... I don't know if I consider myself voluntary, voluntarist, but I think insofar as, you know, government systems, you should have a lot more of a right to kind of opt in, as opposed to being, you know, forced. [01:06:50] Vlad Costea: That's something I agree with, but at the same time it should be accompanied by what you said, a voluntarist action, not just the theory of it. You have to understand that no government is perfect, and ours is pretty flawed and messed up in many ways. But there are still people who shouldn't just be left to die. You have these people who are born with great disabilities, and that's not really... I guess it's cruel to resort to social Darwinism and just say, "Okay, if they're not fit, then they should die." [01:07:35] Vlad Costea: We have to find a system through which we allow them to keep on getting proper medication and whatever else they need. I'm not saying it should be done through taxation or through states. Actually, I tend to believe in small communities as they discuss and they can figure out what they actually need, as opposed to a bigger institution which governs over a larger number of people. I like the idea of an assembly or a federation of small villages. They don't have to be literal villages when you think about it, but you know, a few neighborhoods and blocks just making decisions for themselves and using the technology that we have nowadays to propagate these decisions to a higher level. [01:08:31] Vlad Costea: And tell the representatives up there what to do and how to act. I guess that would be interesting, but at the same time we're not properly educated. I'm not sure. I'm pretty sure it's better in Ireland and New Zealand. But in Romania, you have 3% of the GDP being given to public education, and the public education is what most of us get. [01:09:02] Matt B: Yeah, no, I agree with you completely. I think we're on the same page. In principle, I think the whole "taxation is theft" is, you know, correct. You're paying your taxes to avoid getting thrown in jail. At the same time, I really have no problem paying towards healthcare, education. Yeah, so I mean, I'm for like taxation of some description, but it should be more, well, voluntary. I know that like hardcore libertarians, they just flat out refuse, which is, you know, fair enough. But I think there's a middle ground to be struck there. [01:09:56] Vlad Costea: I remember a Twitter post by Erik Voorhees. And you know, he is this hardcore libertarian. At least in discourse, because in practice he pays his taxes and does all that compliance stuff. But he said that taxation was made so that you pay for the services that you don't want to pay. Because otherwise, you could just say, "I want to pay for education and healthcare by myself. I'm okay with it. It's a good idea. [01:10:31] Vlad Costea: I want us as a society to grow and develop and each generation to inherit what we develop and we research and we discover in our lifetimes. So that's a good idea. I want to pay for it." But through taxation, you actually pay for the salaries of your representatives, administrative costs, the army, secret services. There's a lot there that governments do. [01:11:07] Matt B: Mm-hmm. [01:11:08] Vlad Costea: If we knew about all the stuff that they do, I guess we would have either another revolution, or we would hold them accountable and we would ask for a greater transparency. You see it in the movies and I guess it's inspired from real life. When you have CIA agents who have unlimited budget and they just give them as much money as they need in their undercover operations, just to make the operation succeed. And maybe you can argue that it's for the greater good, but it's still taxpayers' money. [01:11:48] Matt B: Yeah, I'm reading The Snowden Files by Luke Harding at the moment. And it's insane. There's just this massive network of just all these government agencies. People didn't even really, well, they didn't really know what was going on in them. So you have to question the ethics of a system that makes you fund these things that are just used, you know, for mass surveillance, which is a violation of the Constitution. [01:12:21] Vlad Costea: Yeah, forget about it, you know. If the government doesn't respect the Constitution, and when I speak of the government, it's about the institutions as bodies, not as individual politicians and actors. If it infringes your rights, then it's much more legitimate and there's very little that you can do about it. It's just like in the case of the Middle Ages when you had the sovereign king who had these Machiavellic ideas of governing. And the laws were for everybody but the king. I guess it's the same with modern governments. [01:13:07] Vlad Costea: They can infringe and they can break any laws. There's no limit to what they can really do. And even though you vote and you delegate your will to a representative, it's not always like that. And it's not like their promises during the electoral campaign cover everything that they're going to do. They just cover the popular topics. And you usually end up with lots of disappointments and broken promises or extra pieces of legislation which affect your life that you never agreed on. [01:13:51] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, I see a lot of merit in, you know, the kind of libertarian ideology of sacred contract rights, property rights, non-aggression principles being like the overarching kind of law, kind of having like a minimized government, kind of having that idea of self-sovereignty. [01:14:22] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but at the same time, we have to be aware that this whole idea of libertarianism is only for the fortunate few who are smart enough to deal with their problems in their lives and are also fit to work. As I constantly see people complain here in Romania about the amount of work that they do and how the state doesn't do anything to help them. They expect, I guess this is inherited from the old regime, but they expect the government to step in and cover every aspect of their lives. [01:15:05] Vlad Costea: I remember I had a conversation with my geography teacher from high school. And he was like, "Oh, it's so terrible with your generation, because back in my day, you had the government to give you a job immediately after graduation. And you're actually forced to have a job. Nobody was unemployed. If you're unemployed, then you're in jail, but even if you are in jail, you're still forced to do some kind of labor for the community. So it was still work." And he told me that I'm so unfortunate to be part of this generation. [01:15:40] Vlad Costea: And it was hard for me to explain to him that actually the beauty of this political landscape is actually the freedom to pursue what you like, to try new stuff, to realize that you don't like something and then switch to something else and constantly strive to improve yourself and find meaning in what you do. That's not something that they care about. It's all about stability and having a long-term prospect, which I guess our generation doesn't value as much. Anyway, I have no idea how we drifted so much from Bitcoin to this. It was all about libertarianism. [01:16:29] Matt B: Well, I'll tie it back into Bitcoin. I think the beauty of the system is that, you know, it's so apolitical. Like, you have people trying to tie in their politics, their philosophies, when really it's just like a nihilist void. Everyone in Bitcoin acts for themselves. Which in turn, and some people think this is a bad thing, but it makes it very, very difficult to change the protocol by achieving consensus. So, I mean, everyone acts in their own interest. If everyone agrees that a change could be made which benefits themselves, it will go through. [01:17:14] Vlad Costea: You know what I was thinking just now? And it's not like it's very spontaneous. I've actually given it a more extensive thought, but didn't have anybody to discuss it with. It's about socialists and the fact that not enough of them are into Bitcoin. You mostly see libertarian carnivore people brag with their big steaks and talk about Austrian economics. But at the same time you have this niche of socialists who don't like banks, don't like the financial system, are very critical of many aspects of economics. [01:17:59] Vlad Costea: And they find, or at least they have the opportunity to embrace this kind of technology, which is ideologically agnostic. And it doesn't really care about their biases and about how they view the economy. It just gives them the opportunity to hold the assets in a way that cannot be censored. And that maybe grants them the chance to have that revolution that they dream about, in which the workers seize the means of production. [01:18:35] Vlad Costea: But if you take the right things of Karl Marx, then you take ideas like alienation from labor, and owning the means of production, and the class division between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. I think Bitcoin provides a very nice environment to satisfy some of your ideological needs as a socialist. [01:19:06] Matt B: Yeah, I'm sure. I've not given it too much thought actually. I'd like to see a good analysis of that. Because, I mean, it's not particularly left-wing or right-wing. Like, one size kind of fits all. [01:19:25] Vlad Costea: I think I just gave myself a good idea for an article. [01:19:28] Matt B: Yeah, I'd be interested in reading that. [01:19:30] Vlad Costea: And at least I know somebody would actually read it. You know what it's like when you write something and it gets published and you see that you get maybe a thousand views, but you don't know anybody who reads it, and there is no way you can have a discussion on it. It's just this strange kind of feeling which you have, that you work a lot and you do a lot of research. And at the end of the day, you have no idea if it matters, if somebody actually cares about your work. [01:20:10] Matt B: Yeah. Yeah, normally I like to tweet my articles and then obviously you see who's retweeting, who's liking, you kind of get an idea. I really like it because we transitioned from the Crypto Insider domain to Medium. I must say I like it a lot better. Obviously, it was like a bigger, a wider community that might frequent Medium and then just see your article listed. And then you get obviously your analytics tools, quite a good way of interacting with the author, highlighting stuff. [01:20:52] Vlad Costea: Sure, but how often do you actually get feedback from somebody who tells you, "Oh, I enjoyed reading this," or you get questions about some points that you've made, and you get to have a proper debate? [01:21:05] Matt B: Yeah, I had Craig Wright comment on one of them a couple weeks ago. It was definitely a highlight of my writing career. [01:21:14] Vlad Costea: I was never so fortunate. But in terms of liking on Twitter and retweeting, sometimes I see stuff from very smart people like Nick Szabo. And I read parts of it. It's not like I really understand it, but I like it anyway, because I feel like I've learned something, maybe just a bit from it. It's not like I have the whole picture and I understand the context or every bit of the specific lingo which they use. But it's still a reason for me to like it. And I'm not sure if he interprets it as, "Hey, look, somebody else is as brilliant as I am to actually understand this." [01:22:04] Matt B: Yeah, yeah, I know what you mean. I mean, sometimes I just like stuff to bookmark it. Yeah, I mean, even if there's a concept I don't understand completely, I'll still give it a like on Twitter, like, show my support. [01:22:25] Vlad Costea: But you know, I'm so much into this and I've got so much time that I spend writing about Bitcoin-related topics, that last night I had a dream about explaining to a friend about Mimblewimble. [01:22:45] Matt B: It's really weird you say that because I had a dream, it must have been a couple months ago, that I was hanging out with Voldemort. And he was talking about Mimblewimble, because obviously that's a spell from Harry Potter. Yeah, sometimes I'll get like cryptocurrency dreams and they're just so weird. [01:23:02] Vlad Costea: Obviously, you get many more dreams than I do. [01:23:06] Matt B: Yeah, I've had one or two in my time, where you have Twitter personalities showing up that you've never met. I probably spend too much time on Twitter. [01:23:17] Vlad Costea: So what kind of dreams did you have? Which crypto personalities? [01:23:24] Matt B: I think Crypto Cobain was in one of them. Yeah. That was one of the more notable ones. I think one of the authors for Brave New Coin was in one. But like some of these people I've never interacted with. [01:23:51] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's insane. We spend so much time that even our dreams get occupied by these people. [01:24:04] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, I think it's probably the best way to broaden your knowledge of cryptocurrencies, writing about it. These are topics you would never really broach until you decide, "I'm going to sit down and write an article about this." [01:24:24] Vlad Costea: But do you see yourself taking the step into software development? [01:24:29] Matt B: I'd like to. I've built a couple of Bitcoin-related tools that are up on GitHub. One was for, like, steganography, where you hide either signed transactions or private keys in photos. It's undetectable. I wrote another one where you could transmit transactions over radio. [01:24:55] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, that's the one I ripped off. [01:24:58] Matt B: Oh, right. Yeah, so I mean, I was inspired by, like, Elaine Ou and Nick Szabo's presentation at Scaling Bitcoin, I think it was last year or the year before. Yeah, no, I like the kind of code. I started mining recently, just like a small USB miner farm. But I feel like I've learned a lot about the software. I'll definitely continue to write. I like writing. I would like to transition into serious development. [01:25:39] Vlad Costea: I don't think I'm very good at coding. So, I don't see myself doing anything else but writing. As in, I can maybe run nodes and test different miner software, even though I don't have a powerful system to actually do something with it. But I don't see myself transitioning to something which doesn't involve a simple user interface and uses too much coding. I remember in high school I was terrible at mathematics, but very good at literature and stuff that actually used the narrative and described into words. I guess my abstract thinking is much more limited than my colleagues'. [01:26:31] Vlad Costea: Who can't actually describe something into words, but they have a better understanding of symbols in mathematics and they just do it faster. And it's fascinating that our brains are wired in different ways and we can actually collaborate and give the best of our work and the most efficient way through which we can add value to something. [01:27:05] Matt B: Ah, for sure. I mean, I work with some, like a client, and they're mostly software devs. And they do like cryptography stuff that I can't even... You know, I can't even wrap my head around the basics of, but they're terrible at explaining it. [01:27:23] Vlad Costea: And that's why, I guess, us people who are good with words will always be required. [01:27:30] Matt B: Yeah. [01:27:32] Vlad Costea: Unless we sell ICOs, which is the most terrible way of using our natural skills. [01:27:44] Matt B: Yeah. There's been quite a lot of, you know, attention on that on Twitter the past month or so. [01:27:53] Vlad Costea: Yeah, with paid endorsers and influencers. [01:27:58] Matt B: Yeah. I mean, some of them seem to have cropped up out of nowhere. I think it's fine if you know, if you let people know that it's sponsored. I mean, you have to make a living. I think it's pretty unethical to not say anything. [01:28:16] Vlad Costea: But I think it becomes obvious at one point: how many projects can you actually get interested in and support? Yeah, like how much is humanly possible to read on and say, "This is so legit, I like it so much." It's the John McAfee effect, I guess. He had the coin of the week or something. [01:28:42] Matt B: What was it he charged? It was something like $250,000 per tweet. I mean, I'd love to get to that level, but... [01:28:53] Vlad Costea: That guy is insane. I have no respect for him whatsoever. I don't really understand why people hold him in such high regards and say he's this kind of shameless god who can say whatever he wants and do whatever he wants. I have really no respect for that. I think he's a bad actor and he's a bad representation for what Bitcoiners should be portrayed as. [01:29:22] Matt B: To be honest, I wouldn't see him so much of a Bitcoiner. Like, I periodically go through the people I'm following on Twitter and just kind of cut out. I mean, I've cut out a lot of, you know, people who talk about tokens and cryptocurrencies other than kind of Bitcoin and privacy coins. And I find it makes my feed a lot better. I see what I want to see. [01:29:47] Vlad Costea: Sure, but you will always have this enthusiastic crowd of people who make private Telegram channels and do this bogus technical analysis, and pretend to know and have insider info on some kind of project, and then run pump and dump schemes. I don't think these are going to go away unless we get regulations which classify some cryptocurrency projects as securities, or bonds or commodities or whatever. [01:30:25] Matt B: Yeah, I think we've got another... I think we've got a long time until, you know, one currency wins out. [01:30:37] Vlad Costea: Yeah, there are people like... what's his name? It doesn't matter. It doesn't matter what his name is, but he used to sell Binance accounts when signing up to Binance was limited in December 2017. You basically have the people who sell shovels and pickaxes to people who are after the gold rush. Yeah, that's good entrepreneurship. But it's still bad in terms of ethics, as you're fueling the kind of behavior which makes this whole... I'm not sure if I should call it business, but this whole activity or field, it gives it a bad name. Yeah. [01:31:35] Matt B: Yeah, it'll take a while to go away. I mean, on the bright side, you know, the bear market seems to have a lot less paid groups than back in November, December. [01:31:49] Vlad Costea: But I guess once we see the same kind of rise once again, we're going to get back to the scam projects. We're going to get back to the paid Telegram groups. And even though the Lightning Network makes the use case of many altcoins and shitcoins redundant, we're still going to see people who are hopeful that this project, which got launched in 2019, is going to be the next Bitcoin for whatever reason, because it has this extra feature which makes it easy to market in a way. [01:32:28] Matt B: Yeah. I mean, because scalability was kind of the big narrative for why our coin is better than Bitcoin last year or the year before. But now that people are kind of beginning to appreciate that you need off-chain stuff, you know, whether it's IPFS, some other form of storage, or, you know, like a microtransaction layer, I don't think we're going to see that as a big marketing ploy, you know, with the next wave of projects. Like security token projects kind of seem to be, or they seemed to be maybe four or five months ago, taking off. [01:33:11] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and right now they speak about STOs as opposed to ICOs. [01:33:17] Matt B: I think my favorite was a token generation event, to try and separate themselves from the stigma of doing ICOs in some cases. [01:33:28] Vlad Costea: That's a very bad name, token generation event. I guess they could come up with something more imaginative. [01:33:40] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, it's quite obviously an attempt to distance yourself from ICOs when really you're doing exactly the same thing. At least be upfront about it. Yeah, it's a shame because ICOs are, you know, on paper, a good way of crowdfunding a project. But I mean, so many have just jumped on the bandwagon of either promising completely unrealistic products... [01:34:17] Vlad Costea: Oh, come on. I guess you're calling them unrealistic in a very diplomatic and nice way. Because I received a proposition from somebody, and I have no restraint to call it batshit crazy. It was about tokenizing the gifts that corporations make for their employees. And they would say that corporations buy their employees millions of dollars worth of Christmas gifts, and most of the times they don't like it. And then you have this token which is supposed to replace the gifts that corporations make, as if all of a sudden they'll say, "Oh, it's a good idea to give them this token as opposed to give them money." [01:35:08] Matt B: Yeah, like, I mean, too many people come in with the idea that they're going to have a thriving ecosystem based around their own private currency. Like, I mean, let's be honest. If, you know, some of these products do materialize, you're not going to take your Bitcoin wallet, wait for it to clear on an exchange, swap it for the token you need to use this particular service and then send it over to the smart contract. You're just going to want to do that directly. I think what will happen is these tokens will kind of just be integrated into the back end. [01:35:45] Matt B: Yeah. I mean, there's one I'm still trying to figure out here. I'm sure you're seeing your inbox just gets flooded with people wanting you to write about their project. One of them was for a drone taxi company or something, but on the blockchain. It has all the buzzwords. [01:36:10] Vlad Costea: Yeah, like every single one. Go on. Sorry for interrupting. [01:36:18] Matt B: No, it's absurd what you get away with. I mean, the SEC seems to be picking up the pace when it comes to, you know, hunting down some of these founders, but it's far too slow. [01:36:36] Vlad Costea: I think the crazy part about the idea which I described about gifts and corporations is that they actually had this very academic white paper, which looked nice. They had lots of references with data from The Economist regarding how much companies spend on a yearly basis to make these gifts. So, in a sense, I guess they were trying to legitimize the project through an existing market which has a very large capital and a lot of room to actually capitalize on it. But it's insane to think that anyone would use your stupid token. [01:37:22] Vlad Costea: As opposed to giving money. So you can actually negotiate with your employer and say, "I don't want to get the gift. Just give me the equivalent in US dollars." And I guess in five cases out of ten, you'd get a positive response. They would just agree and say, "Okay, if you don't want the gift, we're not going to buy it for you." But to use a token for all this, and then what? What do you do with the token? You get paid in it and you exchange it for Bitcoin, or? Do they actually set up a shop of themselves from which you can buy whatever you like? That's also insane. [01:38:06] Matt B: That seems to be the kind of promise for a lot of them, is that they have all these partnerships with companies that will accept the token. I mean, that's just unrealistic. If I'm running a business, I'm going to want you to pay me in something that will hold value. It makes no sense to have like a whole market or economy of fluctuating value on these tokens. [01:38:37] Vlad Costea: I think we should get back to Bitcoin and have one last topic as we're approaching the two-hour mark for the podcast. What is your view on hyperbitcoinization? [01:38:52] Matt B: I think we should still be treating Bitcoin as an experiment. That said, I think the financial system is like headed down a bad path. And I think Bitcoin certainly, more so than other cryptocurrencies, has the best chance of replacing fiat currency. I don't think any other currency could do it. I think it was Hal Finney who said that if something tops Bitcoin, then you're never going to have any faith in that as, you know, the money, because anything could go ahead and do it again. [01:39:44] Matt B: I think hyperbitcoinization is definitely possible. I think it's gonna take a while. And then obviously, if the financial system takes a sudden downturn, I think that's when it occurs. What about yourself? [01:40:11] Vlad Costea: I think it would be useful at this stage to define what we understand by hyperbitcoinization, as some people seem to refer to it as that moment when Bitcoin replaces fiat currencies, or other people use a more loose term in which they just think about a wider adoption, where you have an equal situation where you can pay with Bitcoin or you can pay with your credit card or you can pay with fiat. So, it's either about adoption or about replacement. I've heard both of them. I'm not sure which is the official narrative that people think about. [01:41:01] Matt B: I think the best post is on the Nakamoto Institute. Sorry, two seconds. I'm just trying to find it here. It's by Daniel Krawisz. I think that's what I take to understand as hyperbitcoinization. I'll send you the link. So, I mean, obviously, the term itself is meant to come from hyperinflation. So once a currency starts to fail, all of a sudden you'll get Bitcoin as a more trusted store of value. [01:42:04] Vlad Costea: Sure, but does that imply a complete replacement of fiat currencies through Bitcoin, or does it imply just having an alternative which makes much more sense from an economic perspective? [01:42:21] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, I don't know if it would be like suddenly people just snap the switch. Presumably, if your currency was just plummeting day by day, they keep printing more, you would want to exit that system as soon as possible. [01:42:44] Matt B: I mean, I think there were kind of reports that that was happening in Venezuela, wasn't there? At one point, maybe three months ago. I don't know if it still holds true. But if you bought Bitcoin at the top by this point, I mean, the top obviously was in December, January was it, and then it just started a downhill trajectory, the bolivar actually did worse. So even if you were holding Bitcoin through those losses, you would still have more purchasing power. [01:43:19] Vlad Costea: I guess this makes a lot of sense. And this fits into my theory that hyperbitcoinization will actually happen from the states or the governments that need it, not from the ones which benefit from a more or less transparent financial policy, like European states, like the United States of America. The free world will be the last to embrace Bitcoin to a greater extent, because we don't really see the point in it. We don't really need it. It's not like... I guess we can have another big financial crisis. [01:44:02] Vlad Costea: And we can see another case with bailouts and where central banks print a lot of money to save the system. But at the same time, I think our trust in the authorities as democratic states is greater than in the case of dictatorships, where they actually try to get away. So their mindset actually is to integrate into a system which works better in their interest, whereas democracies actually give us this false sense of security and trustworthiness, which is harder to escape. [01:44:48] Matt B: Yeah, a friend and I are actually working on a series of articles about this. I think Bitcoin ground zero will kind of be in nations where the government is clearly failing. Like, I mean, if Bitcoin disappears tomorrow, it's not gonna majorly affect me. I mean, I'll probably start investing in gold. Like beyond the kind of slight frustration that we're still stuck with fiat currencies, you know, there's no major inconvenience to me. But if you look at, you know, a country under oppression where your funds get kind of taken from you, whether through inflation or physical confiscation, I think that's where we'll see the value of Bitcoin. [01:45:37] Vlad Costea: At the same time, you also see how these countries which actually need Bitcoin, like Venezuela and Palestine and Taiwan, and I guess there's a list of countries which are not recognized by the United Nations, so the mandate of intervening with the policies, or at least the degree of the embargo, doesn't really allow for a type of international cooperation to help the central bank recover. But these people are not really the ones who can afford to buy Bitcoin. The denominations of their currencies in US dollars are very poor. [01:46:29] Vlad Costea: They can only get small amounts and it's very difficult for them to get any, sometimes due to the political regimes which they have and some restrictions to their access to the internet. Because at the end of the day, the amount of Bitcoin that you have, or the degree to which you can get involved into Bitcoin, is proportional with internet freedom and the extent to which you can access an exchange, or you can trust, or you can safely access LocalBitcoins or whatever website you want to use to acquire some amount. [01:47:12] Vlad Costea: And you have to trust in a financial system to actually wire the money when you get into Bitcoin. I guess it's very difficult if you live in a dictatorship, as you have to sneak out and do this in a way which can be interpreted as breaking the law, being illegal. And I definitely wouldn't want to live in that side of the world. And I guess both of us are very fortunate. [01:47:45] Matt B: Yeah, for sure. I mean, I think there's two main priorities in developing nations. The first being obviously, you know, user experience, user interface. Even today, the less technically adept really will have a hard time using Bitcoin. So if you do want adoption in developing nations, you need to really make it as simple as possible. Another thing I think is quite important, I mean, you mentioned M-Pesa there earlier. Having that kind of network of accessibility where you can pay in cash, like in M-Pesa agents or whatever, and then just get, just as easy as you can get top-up, get Bitcoin. And Beautyon is working on a thing called Azteco. Danny Brewster is working on FastBitcoins, where you go into a physical location, you pay cash, and then you get this top-up. I think that's very important, especially if we're to avoid KYC and all that in the long run. [01:49:03] Vlad Costea: I guess at least in some countries you have these ATMs from which you can buy Bitcoin. And if the amounts are negligible and it's less than, say, $1,000, you don't need a national ID when purchasing. So you can do it with small amounts repeatedly to buy larger amounts, but at the same time you pay a lot in fees, so it's not very convenient from this point of view. Yeah. And I guess ATMs also have surveillance cameras and stuff, so if they want to see who bought or withdrew money, they can actually see the recording. [01:49:53] Matt B: Yeah, I mean it depends how much you're willing to pay to... I mean, LocalBitcoins is pretty decent if you want to exchange cash. The Bisq network is another one worth keeping an eye on. I've never had much luck with liquidity in my area, but we really should be striving to make peer-to-peer channels, you know, more accessible, so that you don't end up with exchanges kind of being the only on-ramps, off-ramps. [01:50:28] Vlad Costea: Definitely. And I've heard of people who had their funds frozen, or they had to provide more documentation when trying to withdraw their coins. Even though they fulfilled the first wave of KYC, they had to send out many more documents, and then they were only allowed to take out parts of their coins, like one Bitcoin per day. [01:51:00] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, I think the funniest, I mean it wasn't funny, it was quite sad, kind of point where we come full circle was when Coinbase started banning transactions to certain addresses. I mean, exchanges, they're not like cypherpunks, they're businesses. They have a lot of obligations, especially when you're trading fiat for coins. I mean, others, you have them in kind of questionable jurisdictions. You're just trading altcoins, Bitcoin. But yeah, they're not here for the same reasons everyone else is. [01:51:46] Vlad Costea: I guess they are a convenient gateway. It's easy to acquire something on Coinbase. It's easy to withdraw from Coinbase, even though it's completely KYC and you have no privacy and you don't really own your own coins, as you don't have access to the keys. At least not as far as I know. I never tried Coinbase. It's banned in Romania. I said banned, as in they don't have service here. So you can create an account, but you cannot buy anything, as they don't have any kind of agreements with local authorities, so they don't operate. [01:52:34] Vlad Costea: I guess you can do it with a VPN, but you still get stuck with your bank account, as they don't take your card unless it's from a different country. But it's for the better, I guess. The only one that I've used to buy Bitcoins from is Bitstamp. [01:52:58] Matt B: Oh yeah, it's the European one, isn't it? [01:53:00] Vlad Costea: Mm-hmm. And I've had a decent experience, nothing to complain about. I think I've also tried Kraken at one point. [01:53:15] Matt B: Yeah, I don't think I've ever paid in fiat to an exchange to get Bitcoins. Any time I've done it, I've either been paid, used an ATM, or got them off LocalBitcoins, which I think is really, again, what we should be striving for. [01:53:40] Vlad Costea: Yeah. I guess my issue with LocalBitcoins is that you actually have to trust an individual that they're going to be honest. And I remember reading that even Steve Wozniak, the co-founder of Apple, got ripped off. [01:54:04] Matt B: Yeah, I don't think I've ever had a bad experience with it. I don't use it that often. Yeah, I think, again, I've never used Bisq, but I've heard fantastic reports. [01:54:26] Vlad Costea: You know what else I want to ask you about? We spoke of Coinbase, and I've had an interview with Charlie Lee in December, and he said something which made me think about it: that it's actually much more secure to hold your coins on Coinbase or an exchange which never got hacked than to actually hold them on your computer, which might be filled with malware and lots of tracking software. And unless you're an opsec expert who knows how to wipe their devices and knows exactly what to do, it's safer to be on exchanges, even though that's so anti-cypherpunk, and it's fully KYC and it's custodian and everything that we should get rid of. [01:55:20] Matt B: I agree with it to an extent. I mean, obviously, the gold standard is something like the Glacier Protocol, where you just completely air-gap a computer. I use hardware wallets. I have three or four of them, keep them, so kind of trying to split my funds between them. Keep some back in Ireland. But I mean, if, say, my girlfriend wanted to keep funds and I wasn't there kind of making sure she was correctly storing them on like a hardware wallet, her funds would obviously be safer on an exchange. [01:56:07] Matt B: As you say, you just don't know if you've got some kind of malware. I mean, because cyber criminals get creative with this kind of thing. So again, there's a certain demographic that just want to kind of gamble, speculate on the markets. They're better off keeping their coins on exchange. I think you should strive, once you buy in, to kind of learn about, you know, safely securing your coins in a self-sovereign manner. [01:56:43] Vlad Costea: I think this is one of the biggest issues with Bitcoin at large, as a lot of people get scared when they hear about self-sovereignty, and they just ask, "So, where do I keep this? To whom should I hand them to be actually in a situation where I can legally hold them there and I can hold them accountable in case something goes wrong?" It's the same as being afraid of holding your money under your mattress. [01:57:18] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, it's a paradigm shift. I recently lost some funds because I forgot my hidden wallet password. It wasn't an obscene amount, but even I consider myself adept at managing my funds. Like, accidents like that happen. Like, self-sovereignty definitely isn't for everyone. It should be, but it is quite a shift away from custodial services that we've gotten so used to, bank accounts and all that. [01:58:01] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and it's so convenient to just show up at the desk with your national ID, and that's your key card to basically do anything to your account, as they just identify you and say, "Oh, you're that guy, and you forgot your PIN number for the credit card, it's fine. We can change it for you." [01:58:20] Matt B: Yeah, something I'd like to see kind of evolve would be, there's a lot of companies working on like self-sovereign identities, where you use zero-knowledge proofs to prove your identity. I think that could be good. I'm not too sure if anyone's kind of launched a product yet. [01:58:45] Vlad Costea: It definitely sounds interesting, and I guess it's very Chaumian in this regard. It's similar to what David Chaum wanted to do in the 90s with money. [01:59:00] Matt B: Yeah, like I think money is a... I think it's very important that that's kind of decentralized. A lot of projects, you know, it's kind of questionable whether what you're looking for is decentralization. But like identities, marketplaces, things like that should be, you know, censorship-resistant. You should have kind of complete management of your keys or your identity. [01:59:32] Vlad Costea: You spoke before about hardware wallets, and you said that you own a few. Do you actually choose to trust Trezor or Ledger? I guess that's a big debate in this regard. [01:59:45] Matt B: Well, that's the thing. I have one from each company. I have a BitBox as well. Yeah, it is a risky take, isn't it? I think, hypothetically, they could be planning like an exit scam where they go and just wipe your funds one day. I tried a thing with Electrum Wallet, which is quite interesting, where you build like a multisig address, where you need two of three hardware wallets to sign a transaction, enabling you to spend the funds from that address. But, I mean, that kind of scares me. [02:00:34] Matt B: I'd hate to lock up my funds and not have access to them, so for now just spread them out, keep some in a software wallet. Air gapping would probably be the best, but I haven't got around to that yet. What do you use yourself? [02:00:58] Vlad Costea: I have a Ledger. And I've seen that wallet.fail presentation which took place on the Christmas week of 2018. And in many ways it really scared me to see how easily you can tamper with these devices and how far you can actually go to manipulate the hardware. And in the case of a Trezor, they actually managed to find the right kind of cryptographic input to make it reveal the seed keys, as well as the private key, which is insane. [02:01:45] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think in the case of the Ledger, like the amount of effort you'd have to put in to stealing someone's keys is quite high. Do you not need to be sitting in the room with them? [02:02:01] Vlad Costea: In all of these cases, you need physical access. [02:02:07] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, I suppose it depends on your threat model whether that's something you're okay with. [02:02:14] Vlad Costea: In the case of the Ledger, they actually installed a version of Snake, and they played the Snake video game on it. [02:02:26] Matt B: I think if it was me, if someone came into my house with a baseball bat and said, "Give me your wallet," I'd give them access to, you know, one of the wallets. I think all these devices have hidden partitions now, where it's a device that you hold a tiny, tiny amount on, and so if someone does kind of ever start torturing you can just give them that. Yeah, I doubt I could mitigate a physical attack. [02:03:03] Vlad Costea: That's actually something which I think about often when people come to me and they say, "I've actually memorized my seed keys and I know my private key." And I tell, I just tell them, what if somebody tortures you? What if they try to extract that kind of information from you? What if you talk in your sleep? [02:03:30] Matt B: I did an interesting interview with... It wasn't pertaining to cryptocurrency so much, with a smuggler, crypto anarchist. He basically developed software for if you're traveling through, you know, border security checkpoints, if you're being tortured, you have a device stored at your home you connect to. And you encrypt the data with a specific set of keys that expire unless you extend them. So if you're being tortured, all you need to do is wait out that time, and then you can give the attacker the key. And they can verify that at one point this key did work. [02:04:16] Matt B: But that it no longer does. So there's really nothing they can do about it. They might just choose to kill you then, but... Interesting, like, versus, it's not as much plausible deniability, like you're being completely open with the people. [02:04:34] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but you're taking a lot of liberties with this approach, as in, you assume that you can measure time and you can know precisely when you can reveal the information and when it gets changed. Yeah, I mean, [unclear: I don't mean when it gets altered], that you can actually count time. [02:04:55] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, obviously you can set a short time, but it just depends on how long you can withstand being waterboarded. [02:05:05] Vlad Costea: It's still an interesting approach to it. But I think, I'm not sure how, but if I think hard about it, I guess this can be improved. It's the same, I'm not sure if you're aware of Estonia's electoral system. [02:05:28] Matt B: They have the... Are you talking about the e-residency thing? [02:05:32] Vlad Costea: They have e-voting, which means that they have, I think, a two-day period of time in which you can vote. And you can cast your vote with the same ID number from your national ID as many times as you want, and it's only the final vote that counts. So, if somebody tortures you and makes you vote in a certain way, and then they let you go, you can actually go home and vote however you want. It's also a way of removing bribery and stuff like that, because it becomes redundant. [02:06:12] Vlad Costea: If you pay somebody to vote in a certain way, unless they do it in the last minute before it closes, there is actually no point to try to pay them to do something because you have no guarantee that it will be final. I'm not sure which part of this can be implemented to the idea of getting tortured to reveal your private key. Because at this point, the private key is not dynamic, it's the same. There is no way you can change it unless you switch to a different wallet. [02:06:52] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, like, fundamentally, it's very, very difficult to design like a duress-proof system. Yeah, I mean, your options are basically plausible deniability, or, like, smuggler software, making it impossible for you to actually recover the secrets yourself. [02:07:20] Vlad Costea: I mean, I guess you know much more about security than I do. And in some regards I tend to be pretty ignorant, but I don't hold large amounts. I don't even have a full BTC and I don't care. I don't think anyone cares about myself and that's the kind of ignorance which strengthens the power of hackers sometimes. [02:07:46] Matt B: Yeah, did anyone listen? I actually lost all my Bitcoin last night. It was quite sad. [02:07:55] Vlad Costea: So you lost all your Bitcoin, is that what you just said? [02:07:59] Matt B: Yeah, all my Bitcoin, I have nothing. [02:08:02] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, in a boating accident or something. [02:08:06] Matt B: Yeah, exactly. [02:08:09] Vlad Costea: You just lost the keys. Your house was flooded and the paper on which you had written down your keys was actually on the floor. [02:08:21] Matt B: Yeah, you know, it happens. So I'm back to square one. [02:08:27] Vlad Costea: Yeah, we gotta know how to start from scratch. And we love this cryptography invention with money so much that we are willing to buy from scratch once again. [02:08:43] Matt B: Yep, in it for the tech. [02:08:45] Vlad Costea: In it for the tech. I guess that this is the ultimate proof that you care so much about the tech that you lose everything and then get back in just because you like it so much. [02:08:59] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, look at all the people from Mt. Gox that lost all their money and they came back. Like, I'm not sure if at that point I would just give up. [02:09:14] Vlad Costea: I mean, it's a centralized service that we are speaking of. So it makes sense for them to care much more about Bitcoin as sound money than about Mt. Gox as the website which held all the registers on this MySQL database. [02:09:37] Matt B: It's true. But yeah, if I got wrecked around the time and I had my coins stolen, I'd be very upset. [02:09:49] Vlad Costea: I guess if the same happened to Binance or Coinbase, or what are the biggest exchanges? [02:09:59] Matt B: Yeah, I think Binance would be the top one at the moment. As far as I know, you can... It's like, I can't remember, was it Nick Carter who coined the term altcoin casinos? Where you don't have fiat transfers, so you have less liabilities. Yeah, I'm waiting for like... There's a lot of money on these things and that's your problem, really, with centralized systems. Sooner or later, someone smarter than you is going to want to come in, take it, and they'll probably succeed unless you have, you know, the best security in the world. [02:10:50] Vlad Costea: Did you ever use one of these decentralized exchanges? [02:10:56] Matt B: No. I think some of them are pretty popular. Radar Relay, I think I wrote about it a while ago. No, have you? [02:11:08] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I've actually used CryptoBridge at one point. Somebody sent me a shitcoin and I had no intention of keeping it, so I decided to exchange it to Bitcoin. And there was only one way to do it, through one of the decentralized exchanges. So I did use it, but sometimes I remember that I left some satoshis in there, as I couldn't transfer everything. There was the fee portion, and then I don't know, for some strange reason, I still had some satoshis left in there. [02:11:45] Vlad Costea: And sometimes I wonder in the case of a hyperbitcoinization, when I lose access to that decentralized exchange, yeah, that could be worth a lot, and that's how these decentralized exchanges can get very rich, even though I'm not sure if they can seize these funds if they are truly decentralized. So it's just a way of increasing the deflation effect on the supply. [02:12:23] Matt B: Yeah, I mean, I think one of the upsides of the decentralized exchanges is that you do own your private key. But in the same breath, and of course, you can trade any token really that isn't listed. But, you know, if the token's not listed anywhere, is it really that good? I mean, what was the process like? Was there a lot of liquidity? [02:12:50] Vlad Costea: I don't really recall. I just know that I received like 10,000 units of a shitcoin, which was worth like 50 bucks at that time. And I just exchanged it into Bitcoin and then transferred it to my wallet. It was as basic as can be. I even looked to see if they support any other big cryptocurrencies. And I was surprised to see that there was no Ethereum and no Ethereum Classic. I'm not sure why. Aren't some of these decentralized exchanges built on Ethereum? [02:13:34] Matt B: Yeah, I've seen quite a few, you know, obviously, you use the token of the people who created it. I think because obviously ERC20 tokens would be a lot easier to trade, I'd imagine, given that they're both on the same blockchain. [02:13:56] Vlad Costea: Yeah, everybody wants to print their own money. Are you still in there? [02:14:08] Matt B: Sorry? [02:14:09] Vlad Costea: There was this extended moment of silence. Oh, sorry. And I actually thought that this was disconnected or something. I'm not sure if I have anything else to ask you at this point. We had a pretty lengthy discussion. [02:14:30] Matt B: We did. Was that two and a half hours? [02:14:33] Vlad Costea: Oh, yeah. Almost. And I feel a bit tired. It's almost two in the morning or two at night. I'm not sure how I should label it. But it's 2 a.m. And my neighbors must have listened to this whole conversation. On my end, because I'm using headphones, there is no way they could have heard you. They probably think I'm insane and I talk to myself in English at night. And Matt B, it was incredible to have you. I'm happy that we had all these discussions which range from regulation and law all the way to our preferences for hardware wallets and decentralized exchanges and hyperbitcoinization and whatnot. [02:15:28] Matt B: Yeah, thank you for having me. Pleasure being part of the first season. [02:15:33] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, and just a spoiler, I'm going to have some really big names in the second season, as I want this first season to have 10 episodes. And the system is that whoever books a spot will get one. But I have a couple of very big names who are willing to do podcast interviews in late February and early March. And I guess by then I will begin the second season. [02:16:05] Vlad Costea: So, yeah, I guess there's a lot of growth potential and it's endearing and it makes me really happy to see that people are interested to just talk about their interest in Bitcoin and get featured and appear on the Bitcoin Takeover. To me, it means a lot, and I know that this is a project which is in its infancy, but I hope there's an audience for this. [02:16:36] Vlad Costea: For all the scam information out there and all the malevolent articles and YouTube videos trying to make you invest in the equivalent of the next BitConnect, I hope we also get to have lots of productive discussions which actually help people or maybe give them an insight on something they wouldn't have thought about otherwise. [02:17:02] Vlad Costea: So yeah, this is the end of the show. I'm Vlad. You've been listening to Matt B. And you can follow him on Twitter at... let me check your... yeah. It's Mattoshin. M-A-T-T-O-S-H-I-N. And he has a picture of Kim Jong-un, the dictator of North Korea. Actually, it's him [unclear: wearing a mask], but that's easy to identify if you think of Kim Jong. And that's it. Bye. [02:17:43] Matt B: Thank you very much. ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio/video call recorded late at night (about 2 a.m. in Romania), in English (host is a non-native speaker), with a short music intro and no sponsor reads. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 8 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (184 chunks) and 49 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 5 of 5 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "Thanks for watching/subscribe" hallucinations, ♪, doubled-word loops, "*sniff*", "Boom", "Thank you."; fixed off-chain, big blocks, hash war, BCH, terabyte hard drive, strain on your node, running a node, phone top-ups, parable, LocalBitcoins, hodls, Bitcoin Error Log, Bcash, Roger Ver, patents; relabelled Guest A as Matt B; reassigned "Poetic justice" exchange, "I just took a break" (kept Vlad per raw), "Do you have any theories?" to Vlad; split long 00:09:04 paragraph; Relabelled Guest A as Matt B; fixed Schnorr, Lightning Network, CoinJoin, Samourai, UTXOs, Neutrino, blockchain.info, oxt.me, Craig Wright, Bitcointalk, Ponzi, Vlad Zamfir, proof of stake, opt-in, wrecked; removed "Thank you for watching..." hallucination at 00:32:20 and "Bye-bye"; split interjections ("Yeah, absolutely", "22.", "Alright") into Matt turns; restored "did you graduate in law", "I code on the side", "Austrian camp" from second ASR/re-check; Relabelled Guest A as Matt B; split Matt's "Yeah, I mean, there's that idea" out of Vlad's turn; removed "Thank you for watching..." (00:40:24), "Thanks for watching" (00:43:59), "Adios", "WEDS"; fixed Ethereum Classic, SegWit, Infura, Preston Byrne, Constantinople hard fork, GHash.io, hash power, ASICs, stalling, sticking, throwing, scene, 80%, fail to understand, ERC-20, Bitcoin (not Bitpoint); Removed "Thanks for watching/Subscribe" insertions, ":D", "Matt Boulol", doubled words; fixed EOS (EIF), Tim May/Cyphernomicon, Hobbes, innately good, schools of thought, Romanian (mania), "ours is" (Endowors), "states" (faith), "to avoid" (that boy), voluntary (Bolter), afloat, citizens holding asset (garbled tail restored from second ASR), "somebody gets hacked, or if"; relabelled Guest A as Matt B and made Vlad continuation labels explicit; added Matt's "Yeah" at 00:53:35; Removed "Thanks for watching/subscribe", "U.S. Department of State", "Translink", "Matt B:" label, *snort*/*sniff* and doubled words; Guest A → Matt B; fixed Erik Voorhees, discourse, Luke Harding, Austrian economics, carnivore/steaks, Crypto Cobain, Elaine Ou, Mimblewimble, Crypto Insider/Medium, Scaling Bitcoin; split out Matt's "Mm-hmm" and "Yeah, I'd be interested in reading that" and Vlad's "that's the one I ripped off"; restored "property rights", "lot there that governments do", "in which", "one size kind of fits all"; Removed hallucinations ("*knock knock* Bye", "End of the video", "Thank you", subscribe loops); fixed sell ICOs, paid endorsers/influencers, Hal Finney, Daniel Krawisz, hyperinflation, purchasing power, marketing ploy, buzzwords, hunting down founders, through Bitcoin; split Matt/Vlad interjections; "good entrepreneurship" is a best guess for "good, Audrey"; Guest A relabelled Matt B; fixed Bisq, Bitstamp, Kraken, Beautyon/Azteco (unclear), M-Pesa, opsec, anti-cypherpunk, self-sovereign, Chaumian/David Chaum, multisig, two of three, Trezor, Ledger, wallet.fail, BitBox, funds (phones), filled with malware, censorship-resistant; re