Title: S1 E7: Avi Rosten on John Stuart Mill, Getting Into Bitcoin, and Meeting David Chaum Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Avi Rosten, managing editor of CryptoGlobe, political science graduate of the London School of Economics Published: 2019-02-06 Duration: 1:24:52 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2019-02-04_avi_rosten_bitcoin_takeover_podcast_.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2019-02-04_avi_rosten_bitcoin_takeover_podcast_.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:49] Vlad Costea: Hello and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I'm Vlad, and today my guest is Avi Rosten, who is a good friend of mine. We used to work together at CryptoGlobe. I think right now he is one of the editors, if not the editor-in-chief, I'm not sure about that, but he is my second favorite person after John Medley at CryptoGlobe. And I know that Avi also graduated from the London School of Economics, which I guess is the third most prestigious institution in the United Kingdom. [00:01:27] Vlad Costea: After Oxford and Cambridge. And he has a degree in political science and a master in political philosophy, I think. But I'll leave it to Avi to describe himself and say hello to you. So, hi, Avi. [00:01:44] Avi Rosten: Hi, Vlad, thanks for having me on. Yeah, so I'll just give a brief summary. Vlad got it nearly 100% correct. So I'm a managing editor of CryptoGlobe.com, which is a crypto news site. He's right about my degrees, except my master's actually in philosophy generally, so I didn't actually do too much political philosophy. Although I didn't realize that when I got into it, because the Bristol course, University of Bristol, was quite philosophy of science focused. But we did do a little bit of moral and political philosophy as well. Yeah, so I'm just excited to be here. [00:02:24] Vlad Costea: So Avi, how did you get into Bitcoin? Of all the stuff in this world that you can become interested in and embrace, why was it Bitcoin? [00:02:34] Avi Rosten: I guess it's quite a familiar story. So I think I probably first heard about it in about 2013, when I was at university, but I really didn't look into it a lot. I mean, to be honest, embarrassingly, I thought it was going to probably end in a bit of a disaster. I thought this is some crazy darknet illegal money that's, you know, connected to the Silk Road, and it's being used by criminals. I kind of bought into the media narrative on it, and I didn't think about it too much more afterwards. [00:03:07] Avi Rosten: I'd occasionally see an article saying something like "Bitcoin hit $1,000" or something. I remember the Mt. Gox incident, but I didn't really get into it that much or read about it much, or really understand what it was, other than it was some kind of new digital currency. In, I think it was about 2015 or 2016, I watched a documentary on Netflix about the dark web. And then that got into the whole Ross Ulbricht saga, the use of Bitcoin there, and that got me a bit more interested in, but still I wasn't committed enough to, you know, really read a lot about it. I read a few articles, I think I remember reading some of the CoinDesk intros into it. [00:03:50] Avi Rosten: But again, I still had an incredibly superficial knowledge of it, and I wasn't, you know, that interested in it. Kind of saw it in the news occasionally. In 2016, the end of 2016, I came on the verge of buying Bitcoin at about $1,000, I think it was. I'd signed up and everything, I can't remember which, I think it was Coinbase or one of them, and I was on the verge of buying Bitcoin. I thought, "No way, it's $1,000 now, there's no way it's going to go up from here." [00:04:16] Avi Rosten: Which I regretted massively, come November 2017. But I'd say when I really got into it and why I got into it was more for a lot of people's reasons. I was just astonished by where it was going in terms of price in the latter half of 2017, and then I started to read more about it. [00:04:30] Avi Rosten: I started to buy some Bitcoin and Litecoin, and a few other, and Ether, in the latter half of 2017. I started to read more about it progressively. And then, I suppose it was December, January, February, I started to really read a lot more about Bitcoin, about mining, about the ideas behind it. Read the white paper, and then I read it again, and I still... [00:05:00] Avi Rosten: Don't fully understand it, but getting there. And then in April, I applied to CryptoGlobe to be a freelance writer, and then one thing led to another, and now I'm, you know, fully down the rabbit hole of crypto, and I'm managing editor at CryptoGlobe. I'm realizing the more I get into it, I feel like the less I know, but it's been an enjoyable ride so far. [00:05:26] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but that's the beauty of it. At first you study like for a month. I think that's the usual process. When you first discover Bitcoin, you get obsessed. And you start reading and researching and you ask yourself questions, and you stumble upon lots of conspiracy theories about who Satoshi is. And I guess that's the first stage of involvement when you're trying to figure out who is behind this massive phenomenon. After that point, you think that you know, but then you get on to Bitcoin Talk or Reddit or Crypto Twitter. [00:06:02] Vlad Costea: And that's where it gets complicated, when you realize that there are so many people who know so much more than you do and have a profound understanding. And there are so many points of view from which you can perceive Bitcoin. Depending on your background, you can actually see it as something else, and that's actually fascinating. And the more you actually read into it, you realize that you don't know anything and you're only scratching the surface. And I've had this conversation with Udi. I think his last name is Wertheimer. [00:06:40] Vlad Costea: I don't want to mispronounce it, but he is a developer. And he told me that he still considers himself to be a noob in terms of understanding Bitcoin, even though he is a developer and has that perspective of somebody who can actually program. [00:06:59] Avi Rosten: That's quite depressing. If Udi considers himself a noob, then I'm like the ultra noob. [00:07:05] Vlad Costea: Yeah, we both are, and we have backgrounds which are pretty divergent. But at the same time, I like to think that through this podcast, we can actually present something which is different from what we usually get in terms of narrative and in terms of understanding. And I guess the next question which I should be asking you is, does your interest in Bitcoin come from your political views? Were you rather more libertarian? [00:07:37] Avi Rosten: Yeah, so I'm after, you know, spending quite a lot of time studying, obviously, political philosophy in my undergrad, which is I think the thing that I enjoyed the most in political science. I did quite a lot of international relations as well, and I was more interested in the philosophical stuff. So yeah, I think there is definitely a draw to that. I mean, I'm not going to pretend that I was drawn into the world of Bitcoin, you know, purely or even largely by ideological motivations, but the more I read about it, the more that resonated with me. I mean, I was, in terms of libertarianism, I was, I think, the philosopher in my undergraduate studies that I was most keen on and most interested by and studied the most in depth was John Stuart Mill. [00:08:23] Avi Rosten: And his, you know, it's his famous essay On Liberty, one of kind of the founding texts of, I guess, political libertarianism, and that definitely appealed to me. I'm still quite a, I suppose, wavering person when it comes to political ideology, having studied it at university. And, you know, seeing, for example, with John Stuart Mill, there's a famous point of contention between his famous two essays, which are On Liberty and Utilitarianism, and there are often conflicts between the two political ideologies. [00:09:01] Avi Rosten: So I find it hard to necessarily box myself into one ideology completely. So I wouldn't necessarily describe myself as, you know, out and out a libertarian, although I do have very strong sympathies with the libertarian ideology, and I think definitely that aspect of Bitcoin I find very appealing. [00:09:20] Avi Rosten: And also empowering. I think it's, you know, has the potential to be politically and economically empowering, and I do find that very interesting. What I'm more suspicious of, and what I'm suspicious of generally when it comes to ideas and ideologies, is when people take them to an extreme degree. When people, you know, I see sometimes on Crypto Twitter the extreme libertarianism, which in some ways to me often resembles faith. And I don't mean faith, I'm not using that in a derogatory sense, but I mean faith without reason. So the markets will solve everything. [00:09:59] Avi Rosten: We have no need for governments. Economic freedom is absolute. That kind of stuff I'm a little more suspicious about. But I do definitely identify with a lot of the libertarian streaks within Bitcoin and the crypto movement more broadly. [00:10:20] Vlad Costea: I guess I was also influenced by John Stuart Mill. We had a class in the first year. I think this was back in 2011 or 2012 when I was in my first year of university. And we had this class about political thought, which started from Plato and Aristotle and went all the way to more modern thinkers like Max Weber. [00:10:38] Avi Rosten: Yeah. [00:10:39] Vlad Costea: And when we started to study John Stuart Mill, and the professor was outlining some ideas on the board, it was as if somebody was mentioning some thoughts that I already had before, but in a more concise and educated manner. It was as if somebody was organizing some of the thoughts which I already have, so maybe... [00:11:14] Avi Rosten: Yeah, that's always a good sign, yeah. [00:11:16] Vlad Costea: That the fact that I got into Bitcoin is just based on my natural or educated opinions of society and politics. That should be an interesting study to undergo if somebody ever wants to conduct that. [00:11:37] Avi Rosten: Yeah, it would be, definitely. I do think that I'm sure some philosophers might be listening and wondering whether John Stuart Mill has a direct relationship to kind of economic libertarianism, as opposed to kind of ideological or intellectual liberalism, which I think is what he's more famous for. But I mention that more because that's where I first got exposed to the ideas, you know, early on, of liberty. [00:12:05] Avi Rosten: I think an interesting area that's now developing, which is obviously very directly related to John Stuart Mill and his ideas of freedom of speech, is this controversy surrounding payment platforms. And that's something that I actually am very interested in terms of crypto and Bitcoin, is the way that now you've seen with Patreon and other payment platforms... With Bitcoin and crypto more broadly acting as a kind of bastion of, a potential bastion of free speech. That's something that does interest me and I do feel more strongly about. Yeah, so that is something that I think is something I could identify with more strongly. How do you feel about that? [00:12:57] Vlad Costea: I believe that money in itself is a way of expressing oneself, so it is speech in this regard. The way you actually spend your money tells a lot about what you do and what you are interested in and what kind of person you are. And that's why I can see the point of having privacy, which you have with cash to a certain extent, that you go, you walk into a store, you pay up in cash, and maybe the salesperson will see your face and remember your voice and the clothes that you're wearing. [00:13:33] Vlad Costea: Maybe they will not remember what you're buying because they have hundreds of customers every day. But with electronic commerce and the way in which packages get delivered to your door by ordering online, it's a lot more delicate, because the companies tend to store the data and use it in ways that you may not be aware of, and change their terms of service, maybe in a transparent way. You get emails, you get notified, but you just don't have the time to read about it. And I guess it makes a lot of sense to look for more private ways in which we can actually have the equivalent of walking into a store and spending your money. [00:14:17] Vlad Costea: We want the money to be fungible, and we want our personal data to be revealed to the slightest degree possible. [00:14:26] Avi Rosten: Hmm. [00:14:27] Vlad Costea: Otherwise, we're just going to turn into this big police state or world government, which collaborates and has all the data stored in places that can be accessed at any point. And to me, that's depressing. And that's one of the criticisms that I have in regards to Bitcoin, that it's not private enough to allow you to transact. And I think at the same time you have these privacy coins, which do not have the same network effect and are harder to use. And I guess it would be useful to implement sidechains in Bitcoin, but that's a long discussion, with confidential transactions or potentially Mimblewimble, which seems to be all the rage right now. [00:15:18] Vlad Costea: Everybody talks about it and how it's minimalistic, takes up the smallest amounts of block space and is actually fungible. That's interesting. But right now I'm looking into alternatives for Patreon, like Bitbacker, and I'm sure there are a dozen more which emerged just to please people like Jordan Peterson, who announced that he would leave Patreon and join some other platform. I guess at that point, they just started this wave of free developments, and everybody was trying to come up with the ultimate solution to make up for the features of Patreon and provide something useful which uses Bitcoin. [00:16:08] Vlad Costea: And it'll be interesting in the next year to see how we move on to these lesser centralized means of making payments and how we can actually use smart contracts to replace that system which Patreon had to pay up every month, a fixed amount of money according to your backers. [00:16:34] Avi Rosten: Yeah, it's definitely interesting. I followed quite closely the Dave Rubin, Jordan Peterson, and others' exit from Patreon, because I've been following Jordan Peterson for a while. And it was interesting because I think some people misinterpreted, or some people could misinterpret it, why they were doing it. It's not because they themselves, as I mentioned many times, had any, you know, Patreon objecting to the content on their platforms. It was more as a consequence of the... I suppose it was an idealistic thing, but also the idea that what could happen if we as content creators allow a payment provider to police what we say, regardless of whether what we say is objectionable or not. [00:17:10] Avi Rosten: I think what they were saying is the principle of the idea of giving the rights of censorship to payment processors, and in some cases even banks. Like there was an incident with Mastercard, I think, that so Patreon deferred and said actually it's Mastercard who told us that we can't process certain people's payments. [00:17:47] Avi Rosten: That's what's worrying to them and I think worrying to me. And to take it back to your first question, that's an example where my political philosophies actually do have real-world ramifications, is where it actually translates into curtailments of freedom of speech. And obviously it's difficult because people see platforms like Gab, which was used by the... I can't remember his name, but the terrorist who shot a lot of people at the synagogue in Pittsburgh. I think it was Pittsburgh. [00:18:30] Avi Rosten: That shooting was obviously publicized on Gab, and therefore it gets this association with, I think, freedom of speech platforms become almost inextricably linked to far-right or extremist ideologies. But I think there's a danger in making that connection and therefore saying, "Well, these platforms just exist to harbor those people." Because they can exist to harbor people who, for whatever reason, payment processors find their opinions unpalatable, but that doesn't necessarily mean that those opinions are, you know, extremist or... [00:19:08] Avi Rosten: Problematic in any way. It's just the principle of: why should the payment processors define what we find palatable? And I think that's the point where I see my kind of political persuasions, or at least philosophical persuasions, translating into real life. [00:19:29] Vlad Costea: I think I agree with the Gab standpoint that our society doesn't need some kind of policing in regards to speech. And if anything, we need more speech to actually encounter and be able to debate the opinions which maybe are not appealing to us. In the end, it's about facing the reality and the truth and stop denying the fact that people with different opinions exist. And I guess our civilization was shaped by this concept of conflict of ideas. I don't think consensus in one single direction was ever good for us. [00:20:14] Vlad Costea: And I guess Max Weber was the one who defined this standpoint that civilization... and I think it was in the Protestant Work Ethic, the conflict of ideas which were prevalent in Christianity were actually a driving force behind emerging the capitalist system and the Industrial Revolution. [00:20:40] Avi Rosten: Yeah, it's interesting. I mean, that's where John Stuart Mill comes in, obviously, with the idea of the free competition of ideas. And I understand, as in when it comes to these issues, I understand the more, I suppose, what's become the left-wing position now, or the more authoritarian position of, "Well, you're giving air, you're giving voice to people who have extreme and, you know, abhorrent opinions." But at the same time, the point of John Stuart Mill and the others was not that having a free platform for entirely free speech doesn't have its dangers. [00:21:18] Avi Rosten: It's just that the dangers of policing it outweigh the dangers of not policing it. And that's the important point. And it's a point that Jordan Peterson makes, which is that you say, "Well, we need to have some kind of vetting and policing of the speech, otherwise it gives reign to people who have abhorrent opinions, who might be inciting violence, who might be inciting other things." But the question is, well, who decides it? Will you decide it? Does the government decide it? Does the company decide it? Is it done by majority? [00:21:45] Avi Rosten: Is it done by people, by the outrage mob on Twitter? Who decides it? And I think the point, at least the way I read it and what I took from it, from John Stuart Mill and others, was that the point of freedom of speech is that no one decides it, and therefore the dangers that are inherent in that outweigh the dangers of authoritarian policing of speech. And I think that's where I see platforms like Gab, even if they give voice to far extreme, far-right views. [00:22:19] Avi Rosten: They have an important role to play, because they don't police anything. It's interesting actually as well, I think people pointed out at the time... We wrote an article on CryptoGlobe about this. One of our writers pointed out that Twitter and Facebook also had posts from this shooter, and no one was calling for Twitter and Facebook's payment processes to be undone, which I think is a point that wasn't mentioned enough. [00:22:45] Vlad Costea: And I also think that Gab had a bad reputation prior to that unfortunate event, as it was portrayed by the New York Times and maybe other left-wing publications as the place where neo-Nazis gather. Not neo-Nazis, but at least the alt-right. I'm not sure what kind of term they used, but it was just portrayed to people reading the New York Times, and I guess they have a pretty wide audience, as the place where all the toxicity and all the negative phenomena that go on in our society actually blossom, and that's where it all comes from. And it's perpetual with social media and the internet. [00:23:31] Vlad Costea: I think it was Reddit at some point where they blamed all the racist memes coming from Reddit. And then it was 4chan, and it was also [unclear: Hidden Lol], but that's a different website. I guess people will always find comfort in anonymity and try to express their darker side of humor. But we shouldn't, as journalists or as professionals, we shouldn't legitimize these opinions by giving them a label and trying to create panic. I guess that's what sells at the end of the day, and that's what gets the clicks. [00:24:09] Vlad Costea: But when you make it popular and bring it onto the mainstream discussion scene, that's dangerous, and that's how you create divisive opinions, and that's how you make people argue. And today, if you check out the news, it's about a Native American who was or was not, depends on which version of the same events you actually take into consideration, bullied by kids wearing "Make America Great Again" hats. I'm not sure if you saw that, but... [00:24:36] Avi Rosten: Mm. I haven't seen that actually. [00:24:39] Vlad Costea: It's a prime example of how our biases can actually change narratives. And I guess the beauty of it, the beauty of Bitcoin as a mean of exchange, is that you actually get to express yourself regardless of what you think. It's rooted in what Tim May wrote in the Cyphernomicon when he said that privacy is much more important than compliance to laws. And it's also rooted in the philosophy of positivism, which says that human beings are not inherently bad. It's just the exception that makes them bad. In the largest majorities, people are actually good-willing and good in nature. [00:25:29] Vlad Costea: It's not like we should legitimize our police states by the fact that 1% of people are criminals, making the assumption that all of us can be criminals. Because that's insane, and that meddles with our liberty. [00:25:49] Avi Rosten: So just to make it... so are you... so the reason you mentioned this, I just saw the news story with these Native American boys. What was your point precisely? Are you saying that the fact that those kind of, you know, people exist who, you know, most people find abhorrent, means that we shouldn't therefore censor the rest, or even them, as a result? Is that your... I'm just trying to isolate what you mean by that. [00:26:17] Vlad Costea: No, it was just a contemporary case of how media shapes our biases and how actually we don't really debate, and that's what Gab is great for. It encourages anyone to sign up and you can have opposing views. You just get there and you see all the controversial opinions being voiced and you can talk about it. But on Twitter and Facebook, it's also divisive. It's all about taking sides and trying to find arguments against the other one. It's tribalism in a nutshell. [00:26:55] Avi Rosten: Yeah. Interesting. I think what interests me about Gab is that, and it might be that at first the platform becomes a gathering place for those people, but that might just be a function of the fact that it's a very small platform now, so those that are forced onto it will make up most of its initial audience. And perhaps as the censorship of the much bigger platforms becomes greater, more and more people who, you know, we might consider less extreme and more quote-unquote mainstream, will gravitate towards it, and it won't just become the sole province of... [00:27:38] Avi Rosten: Of those kind of people. It will become a much broader church, for want of a better word. But I think that perhaps the reason why it started in that way was because those people are the first wave of people to be forced off other platforms. But if, as many suspect, platforms like Twitter and Facebook, etc. become more censorious, you will see a migration of far more palatable people like Jordan Peterson and Dave Rubin, who I still think is very much a liberal, moving to other platforms because they feel ideologically concerned about... The censorship that is coming. [00:28:26] Vlad Costea: And the more people join Gab, the more popular Bitcoin gets, because it has become the default way in which you can donate to the platform. And I can see how in the future they can even implement a system to transfer money through the Lightning Network on Gab, and that will be really sweet and a great, great example which provides more adoption for Bitcoin. And I guess the beauty of Bitcoin at the end of the day, from a political point of view, is that it's completely neutral. [00:29:02] Vlad Costea: It doesn't care what you think. It doesn't care what you do. You're going to have your money transferred, and it's up to us as good-willing citizens to report bad behavior. It's not up to the payments processor itself, or the mean of making the exchange, to decide who is a bad actor. It's up to us to figure out and discover and take charge of the situations in our lives. [00:29:34] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I agree. And I also think that I'm quite cynical about the motivations of companies like Mastercard and Patreon when they shut down people that they view as unacceptable. I very much think that it's driven by an expected profit calculation. So it's not driven by the fact that they care deeply about these opinions and are trying to shut them down. It's more driven by an expectation that the audience, the media, or certain very vocal groups on platforms like Twitter, etc., will shout them into oblivion and affect their profits. [00:30:09] Avi Rosten: And I think it's quite cynically driven by an expectation of what will damage their brand reputation, and possibly an expectation that's actually incorrect. It might be that they're reacting to a small demographic of their customer base, or the, you know, the world at large, but that has a disproportionately loud voice. So the kind of people I'm thinking of is kind of the outrage culture that exists on Twitter. That demographic, which I strongly suspect is far more vocal than its numbers, might lead companies to make calculations based on that demographic, when in reality the vast majority of people aren't as bothered by the opinions that they censor, or would rather have a platform that's open. [00:31:06] Avi Rosten: In fact, so it could be that they're actually, you know, shooting themselves in the foot as well, even if it's supposed to be a profit-driven calculation. [00:31:18] Vlad Costea: I remember when I was in Paris at Sciences Po, and I guess this is the part in which I brag about my academic credentials. But I was there and I had a class with a young lady professor whose name is Julia Cagé, and interestingly, she's the wife of Thomas Piketty, who is one of the most influential economists of the left. And she gave us a lecture about media biases and bubbles, and how on social media it's so easy to actually isolate yourself in your comfort zone of views. [00:31:58] Vlad Costea: So you never actually get to see what the other side says. And even with televisions and newspapers, it has become so easy to just find opinions which appeal to the ideas which you already have, so that you don't ever get an opposing view. And whenever it strikes you in real life that somebody else disagrees with you, it's a lot harsher than it used to be. You don't accept as easily. You just think that they're dumb or that they're misinformed or that they should read the same books as you do. And this is part of why we have these conflicts nowadays. [00:32:41] Vlad Costea: Back in the newspapers' days, when people would walk to a store and buy the newspaper, you had greater chances to meet somebody who had opposing views and there was much more room for debates. But when you can just stay in your room and read the news online and check the sources which you like, and find only the opinions which you find appealing, I guess it's more shocking when you find somebody who disagrees with you, even though that's natural. And we should be taught at an early age that we're different and we are shaped to have different views of the world. [00:33:17] Vlad Costea: That's just part of our nature. To me, it's insane. And I think, at least I hope that Bitcoin will bring so much more discourse and an increase in debates that we have as societies which pretend to be evolved from what we used to have 2,000 years ago, when actually people used to debate much more than today. And echo chambers are dangerous. That's the bottom line of my part of the speech. [00:33:50] Avi Rosten: Yeah, no, I agree with you. I think that's, I noticed it myself, you know, you watch two or three videos on YouTube and then suddenly the YouTube algorithm calculates, "Well, this guy is right of center, or this guy is left of center." Or, and then you're suddenly bombarded for the rest of your life with the same, say, six or seven people or kinds of videos, and then you get more and more entrenched in that bubble. And it could be, interestingly, as you were saying, that that could be what's driving some of the payment processors' decisions. [00:34:26] Avi Rosten: Is that they think, let's say that Silicon Valley, you know, is generally considered to be quite left of center. Let's say you have an exec there at one of the payment processors or companies like Twitter, and they, because of the nature of the algorithms on the platforms they use, they only see, say, things which are left of center, and they are in this, you know, almost this algorithmically generated bubble of videos and tweets and people they follow. They might come to believe that that is the dominant narrative or that is the vast majority of people in the West believe that. [00:35:06] Avi Rosten: And therefore, if they're thinking from a purely, not even an ideological place, but from a profit-driven place, "If I have X person on my platform, I am alienating the vast majority of my audience, and I will make less money," they will act upon that. And so it could be that the very nature of the platforms themselves is driving the censorship, which I think is quite an interesting and worrying thought. [00:35:34] Avi Rosten: And I think it's important as well for those who are right of center, or more libertarian, to realize that they too are the victims of those same algorithms and that their opinions are conditioned by the same phenomenon. I definitely myself have realized, you know, who I think I am, slightly right of center, that I've lived for the last X number of years, because of YouTube and other platforms, very much in an ideological bubble chamber, and it's important to draw yourself out of it. You know, every once in a while I'll watch a Noam Chomsky video just to kind of throw a spanner in the works, because otherwise I feel like there's a danger of becoming ideologically, you know, cut off from the other people. And I hope that things like Bitcoin and other currencies, you know, as you said, give people an ability to move outside of their immediate ideological comfort zone. [00:36:39] Vlad Costea: I mean, it was the same maybe in the 20th century. I'm thinking of the baby boomers in the United States who had their communities made up according to their wealth. So you had neighbors who probably voted the same because they were subject to the same tax policies. And to them it was all about following their economic interests. But it wasn't as if you were not meeting physically anybody who was outside your community and was different and had opposing views. And all these social movements from the 60s and the 70s were all about free speech and allowing anyone to voice their opinions. [00:37:22] Vlad Costea: And promoting much more of the minority views. And right now it's all about converging some kind of universal view on everything, in which you're not even allowed to assume that they have a certain gender or that they come from a certain place, or you're not allowed to mention some physical traits because it's offensive. I think this is a major step back from what we used to aim for. [00:37:57] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I agree. I think, I mean, I do buy into the idea that the left is no longer liberal, although... And I think that there is a... I'm not one of these conspiracy theorists who thinks that, you know, there's this cabal of left-leaning people who are trying to stranglehold the whole media. But I do think that there is a right-left imbalance in a lot of the media. And I think that there is a problem in that elements of the left, or what some people would describe as the hard left, have become a lot more vocal and powerful than elements of other parts of the left. [00:38:39] Avi Rosten: And you see this, people who have historically always been on the left decrying this, people like Bill Maher, who I've noticed talk about this a lot, the American chat show host, and others. And I think, as someone who I do believe in a lot of, you know, quote unquote liberal ideas in terms of free speech and things, I think it's important that we don't go down the path of, as you said, like a universal accepted set of political ideologies on the left or right. [00:39:14] Avi Rosten: I see the same problems to some extent on the right as well, which is, as an example, if you were to say in certain right circles, "I think global warming is a really big problem," or climate change more broadly, you get the same kind, sometimes get the same kind of derision and eye rolling and pushing away as you might on the left if you say something that isn't part of the accepted canon of beliefs. And I think you're right that this factionalism and, as you said, the kind of universalism of ideology is very dangerous. [00:39:54] Avi Rosten: And I know it's interesting, I read an article of yours the other day about communists and Marxists and socialists, and why they might come into Bitcoin. I thought you made a good point, which is that it's important for a community that's trying to be, or for a currency, or an ideal like Bitcoin, that's trying to become more global, that it's not a province of, you know, extreme libertarians or one particular political movement. I think that's a really good point, that it's important that we have a diversity of opinion, a diversity of thought in this new crypto world, because it can seem quite alienating, I think. [00:40:35] Avi Rosten: I think a lot of people who are, let's say, left of center might look on crypto Twitter and think, "Oh my gosh, it's a bunch of hard right libertarian crypto bros, and I don't want to get involved in that." And that's not helpful to the cause. [00:40:50] Vlad Costea: Yeah, exactly. Or they're going to say that it's the currency for the Silk Road or for funding WikiLeaks, which has lost a lot of support from the left after being biased towards Donald Trump and the 2016 campaign. And maybe that they associate Bitcoin with Gab and they're going to say this is not for me, even though they don't really understand that the protocol or the currency itself is neutral. And if some people have a certain ideological bias and they hold larger amounts, that shouldn't discourage you from actually using the protocol. [00:41:28] Vlad Costea: If, say, the wealthiest 1% of the world are maybe on the right side of the debate, that doesn't mean that we shouldn't use money. But if we stopped using their money, I guess it would lose value and that would make all the wealth they own worthless, so that's also an interesting point. [00:41:51] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I think, I do think it is a bit problematic, it can be a bit daunting to people who might feel politically outside of it. And that, I mean, that associationism, I don't know if that's a word, but that idea of, "Well, that X thing is used by Y demographic, therefore it supports Y's opinions," is very problematic. And as you said, Bitcoin itself is a completely neutral protocol. It has no opinions. It has no politics. It has no ideology. It's just a technical instrument. [00:42:28] Avi Rosten: And therefore, I think it's important that we don't... We risk alienating a lot of people because people make what I think is a fallacious argument: "Well, if Bitcoin is used by Silk Road, X, therefore Bitcoin itself has those leanings," is very problematic. I mean, you see it with people who follow people's ideas: "Well, if person X is mainly followed by demographic Y, therefore person X supports demographic Y's opinions," and that's very problematic. And that's a much easier case to make with Bitcoin, which isn't even a person, it's just a... [00:43:05] Avi Rosten: It's not even... It's an inanimate thing. So I think it's important to educate people that they can use Bitcoin in the way that they want to use it, not the way that the majority of the people, or a lot of the people who are perceived as using it, might use it or think about it. [00:43:25] Vlad Costea: In this world of libertarians and Bitcoiners who are carnivores and, you know, these communities which seem to be very similar in their nature, I actually appreciate Jackson Palmer, who, beyond inventing Dogecoin, which was a joke of his, which he doesn't want to be associated with anymore, he had a lot of contributions and ideas to make the space better. And I know that he had that website, Are We Decentralized Yet, which presented the state of the most important cryptocurrencies and showed how actually we don't really have many nodes running the protocol. And it's a small percentage of big wallets owning the largest amount of coins. [00:44:20] Vlad Costea: And all these criticisms are useful in order for us to have a broader view on what's going on and try to decentralize in the true sense. [00:44:33] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I agree, and I think that it's important to have people like him in the space, because I'm very keen on diversity of thought. I think that's really, really important, and it goes back to what we were saying earlier about John Stuart Mill. Diversity of thought is what drives society and intellectual society forward. And I think it's really important that you have people who are, you know, left of center or just different from the majority who talk. It's funny you mentioned the carnivore thing. I have noticed that. [00:45:04] Avi Rosten: I'm really not quite sure why Bitcoin has been associated, or crypto has been associated, with people who are pro-carnivorous diets. Perhaps it's a kind of reaction to veganism. I don't know. Why do you think that is? [00:45:21] Vlad Costea: I've had this discussion in another episode of this podcast, and it's been explained to me that it comes from a Nick Szabo article about meat being an important element of human evolution. And that it's easier in these days to trust meat that it's good than in the case of vegetables, which can be genetically modified. And if you have high quality meat, which comes from the kind of animals that you hunt down, and are not enhanced by growth hormones and whatever, it's actually much easier to trust that you're having healthy food. [00:46:02] Vlad Costea: But I guess it was taken to the kind of extreme which maybe is interesting to observe. But I'm a vegetarian, and I watch them, and I think to myself, "Okay, I used to eat meat until about two years ago, and I know for a fact that having too much meat and having every meal consisting of meat is bad. And you get a lot of cholesterol, and you get fatter." And I guess the whole idea of a diet is to have it balanced. Just like in politics, it's good to have ideas from all the sides. [00:46:42] Vlad Costea: And make up something which is round and open to new ideas. I guess that's part of being a good human being, and that's what I read in Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics. It's the point he makes about virtues being actually the middle ground between being too good and being terrible as a person. You should never go to extremes with anything. [00:47:09] Avi Rosten: Yeah, the golden mean. [00:47:10] Vlad Costea: Not speech, not... [00:47:11] Avi Rosten: Yeah. [00:47:12] Vlad Costea: Maximalism, even though I believe that Bitcoin should be the ultimate cryptocurrency, and it's the king of this movement, and it's the one which deserves to be the most developed, just because it has the largest adoption rate. [00:47:28] Vlad Costea: It's the most decentralized. The fact that it has an anonymous or at least pseudonymous founder helps the whole cause move forward. But at the same time, I don't think we should be, and I don't want to offend anyone who will probably come to this podcast, but we shouldn't be close-minded to something which comes and can be used at least from the points of view of new ideas, even though the implementation is terrible. And I'm thinking right now of Beam, which is an implementation of the Mimblewimble protocol. [00:48:10] Vlad Costea: It's terrible because it has founders' rewards. But at the same time, it can push the development of software further. And even if it fails, we're going to have an open-sourced code which can be used for something else. And there's a lot of value in that. And a lot of people seem to dismiss this and only trust like a bunch, a dozen of developers who work on a certain project. But there's a whole world of ideas out there which just can't wait to show up and come our way and bring something new to the table. [00:48:48] Vlad Costea: And maybe most of these ideas will end up being developed into Bitcoin. And that's the beauty of it. We should not go to extremes. [00:49:00] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I agree. I mean, as I've learned more and more about crypto, although I'm by no means knowledgeable enough at all, the more I learn, I have kind of moved towards the Bitcoin maximalism end of the spectrum, mainly because I just see the number of, you know, ridiculous failed ICOs, and I see the problems with a lot of the other cryptocurrencies. But at the same time, I think it's almost, as we were saying earlier, it's another manifestation of that kind of ideological entrenchment to say, "Oh, well, because everything that's been an alternative to Bitcoin so far hasn't been great, therefore, Bitcoin is the only thing that will be perfect forever." [00:49:43] Avi Rosten: And I think that's too closed. I mean, it strikes me as being a little too closed-minded and a little intellectually suspicious, because it's a bit of a fallacy of, I suppose you'd call it a fallacy of induction, that because everything thus far has been not great, therefore any new protocol that comes along, any new altcoin that comes along, or new blockchain that comes along is just going to be, by definition, a failure. And I think that, yeah, it's important to be open-minded about the new approach. Although I have to say, I've often, when it comes to new projects, my patience or, I suppose, enthusiasm gets... It's harder to muster enthusiasm for a new white paper or a new project. [00:50:28] Avi Rosten: Because there's just been such a ridiculous number. I mean, I feel like 2018 for me was just like reading about so many different things, and it led to a little bit of, I suppose, exhaustion with new ideas, which is why it's sometimes easy to just go, "Well, let's just go back to Bitcoin and stick with that." But that's not necessarily an intellectually viable position. Just because you're, you know, you're tired or exhausted or fed up of lots of bad projects, that doesn't necessarily mean that there won't come along another cryptocurrency or blockchain or coin that is, you know, viable in its own right. [00:51:08] Vlad Costea: I remember we went together to the London Blockchain Summit back in June 2018. [00:51:15] Avi Rosten: Yeah. [00:51:16] Vlad Costea: And there were a bunch of really terrible projects out there being presented by people who were being overly positive about what ERC-20 tokens can actually do. And I remember I didn't have the patience to listen to anyone. They would try to pitch me their ideas, and I would just tell them, "I actually don't have money to invest. I'm a poor journalist." [00:51:44] Avi Rosten: Yeah, it's hard. I think, I also think that the effect for those outside the space or who are casually interested in the space has been quite damaging. You know, most of the people I know, you know, outside the space, who've come across it, or even bought a bit, some cryptos, or bought some things, now they're just completely switched off because all the altcoins they bought in the latter half of 2017 are now worthless and haven't produced anything or have dropped 10x in value. And there's been collateral damage there even to Bitcoin. [00:52:23] Avi Rosten: They just view it all as this one negative lump. And I think so many of these smaller altcoins that people might have invested in have just switched them off from the space entirely, which is a problem. And I think that, I don't know, what do you think? Do you think that the ICO bull run crazy period of 2017 and '18 was net negative for the space? I'm interested in that question, whether it was a net bad thing, because it brought a lot of people in, but at the same time, it burned a lot of people, and a lot of people lost a lot of money. [00:52:55] Avi Rosten: And the media had a field day making fun of all this collapse. And, you know, and that's not to mention, you know, the hundreds of scams and outright frauds and thefts and hacks. What do you think about the kind of period of 2017-18 as a kind of net? Do you think, would you say it was a net positive or a net negative? [00:53:16] Vlad Costea: I think it was a slight net negative, in the sense that I can see some positive outcomes out of it. I know that people have developed the kind of unrealistic expectations about what blockchains should be or what they can be used for. And I guess we still see these distorted ideas about what they can do by putting it on the blockchain, without asking in a critical way the question, "Why does this need a blockchain?" But it brought so many different people into the industry, if we can call it an industry, and we have developers who have gotten into legitimate projects, and we had investors who maybe discovered Bitcoin and understood it better, because at one point it's inevitable. [00:54:12] Vlad Costea: You first get drawn into this scam project, which promises to do a lot, but in the end, it just crashes down and burns and makes people lose their money. But while you're at it, you actually get to learn a little something. If you got into, let's say, BitConnect, which is the lowest denominator of investments that you could have made, at least you know about Bitcoin. And I guess BitConnect was shaped in a way that was similar to Bitcoin's. It was a fork of it, if I'm not mistaken. [00:54:50] Vlad Costea: It was a fork from the Genesis block, which used a similar protocol. And it gave people the chance to learn how to use wallets, how to use the private key, how to use the public key, how to make transactions. And if they actually have the patience, they can switch to Bitcoin. I think that the main problem with Bitcoin is that it only appeals to a small number of people who already have a predisposition, from an ideological point of view, to embrace it. At least it has been so far, as only libertarians and people who longed for the gold standard. [00:55:33] Vlad Costea: And maybe some computer scientists who saw the potential of the protocol. Those were the ones who got into Bitcoin. And then there came a wave of speculative investors, and a lot of them withdrew. We see some promises from institutions that want to get in, but we don't have anything tangible or concrete. But there's a lot of positive outcomes coming from people who buy into scam coins and later on discover Bitcoin. Otherwise, if there wasn't for that promise that they would annex their investments, and they would learn at their own expense that... [00:56:16] Vlad Costea: They invested in a scam project. If they have any patience after that, they're going to discover Bitcoin. And that's an extension, that's a way of attracting a larger number of people who get in being greedy, and then maybe realize something which they haven't, or wake up from this eternal slumber of fiat money and government. [00:56:41] Avi Rosten: The dogmatic slumber of... [00:56:42] Vlad Costea: Yeah. [00:56:43] Avi Rosten: Yeah. I wonder though whether... Yeah, I think I'd agree with you that there has been a slight net negative, because I think for every one person that, you know, bought BitConnect or some other scam coin and then went down the rabbit hole and ended up at Bitcoin and became a crypto enthusiast, there might have been, for every one of those, there might have been 10 who bought a scam coin, or not even necessarily a scam coin, but just an altcoin, even a top 10 altcoin, bought it at X price in November 2017, watched it collapse. [00:57:17] Avi Rosten: Tenfold, and now is completely switched off for a very long time. So I wonder whether that hype and craze and all the... Even those which are legitimate or at least of questionable legitimacy, whether they've actually switched off a whole wave of people to Bitcoin and other legitimate projects because they were so burnt by the experience. That's what concerns me. And I see that with people that I, you know, I was talking to in autumn of 2017, who are now just completely switched off and don't want to know about it. [00:57:51] Avi Rosten: And it's like their net experience of cryptocurrency and the whole of the blockchain world is, "I invested $10,000 and it's now worth $800." And that's their just experience. And that's an incredibly negative one, obviously, and I think that that's a real problem, at least for now. [00:58:11] Vlad Costea: At least I hope they ask themselves whether there is something beyond the speculative investment part, and what their investment actually means beyond the idea that at some point in the future they would sell and get more fiat. And I was about to mention that we are in the middle of a change of narrative. As so far, Bitcoin has only appealed to a small group, but now that we see platforms like Patreon and PayPal just closing down accounts based on ideological divergent views, we're going to see many more people joining Bitcoin just because they want to express themselves freely. [00:58:54] Vlad Costea: And this is a radical change in narrative, and it's something that a lot more people need. So far it has been about having unconfiscable money, and some people don't care about that just because their governments never took their money away, and they have lived for most of their lives in liberal governments which allowed them to store their money safely and without any issues, except for maybe inflation. But now we're seeing people who want to use their free speech and maybe fund projects which are banned from major platforms. [00:59:34] Vlad Costea: And they're going to get into Bitcoin, they're going to learn more about it. And this is going to be another big wave of individual adoption, because at the end of the day, institutions are just looking to maximize their investments. I'm not sure if they see the potential in holding bitcoins for, say, 20 years. I guess they will just sell off at the new all-time high and enjoy the profits which they made from other people who bought on the long term, but that's fine. In the end, it will be about those who... [01:00:12] Vlad Costea: Dream and make happen an alternative mean of exchange, which with itself brings a parallel economy, which people will use to express their freedom, and they will not be willing to do any trade-offs anymore in terms of privacy and in terms of intervention with the way they spend their money. [01:00:39] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I think you're right. I think what you're saying about the free speech opening up Bitcoin to a whole new audience, I think the Jordan Peterson and Dave Rubin and others incident has actually exposed a lot of people who probably hadn't heard of it, because they have huge followings, and others like Brett Weinstein and Eric Weinstein, who have exposed now another wave of people to crypto as something more than just, "Oh, check out this thing I can buy on Coinbase and triple my money on." They've now exposed it to a more actual, you know, use case of crypto rather than just as a speculative instrument. But I agree with you that I think the banks and institutions, of course, are just coming aboard... [01:01:23] Avi Rosten: Because it's a new uncorrelated asset. So they're seeing it as another way of making money, but that still again brings more people on board. So I do think that that's probably a positive, it's a net positive. [01:01:39] Vlad Costea: How do you see governments reacting? You're in England right now. What is the policy in regards to Bitcoin? Does it get taxed? Can you actually spend it in shops or hotels or restaurants? [01:01:52] Avi Rosten: So in terms of the government, I mean, I covered a story recently on the FCA, the Financial Conduct Authority, which is the UK's financial regulator, and the UK government, they set up a Cryptoassets Taskforce, which was tasked with their approach to it. I think, talking to our CFO and a few others, I'm not an accountant and I'm not a regulator, but I'm not a lawyer, so I, disclaimers. But I think the approach he characterized it as is cautious but not negative. So they are keen to foster innovation and growth, but they also are aware that people have been scammed out a lot of money. There is an interesting thing that the Cryptoassets Taskforce published towards the end of last year, which was about crypto derivatives. It's possible they might ban, outright ban crypto derivatives in the UK. [01:02:53] Avi Rosten: So things... So there's something called a CFD, which is a Europe-only thing, a contract for difference, which is a kind of derivative which have been trading in the UK, as well as, you know, other options, etc. But they are potentially going to ban them in terms of... But I think generally, I'm not, again, I'm really not an expert on this, but I think that there is a, I think it's not, I don't think it's hostile approach. There could be an interesting twist in the tail because of Brexit and economic problems thereof. [01:03:27] Avi Rosten: That could, I don't know, this might be completely naive, but it could be that as a result of that they might look, as other jurisdictions have done, to crypto and blockchain as a means of securing alternative, you know, other kinds of investment. Like, obviously, it's nowhere near as extreme as Malta or other, you know, tax havens, where they basically, you know, said, "Do what you want here, because we want your investment." I wonder whether, if Brexit goes as badly as some people think it will, whether that will open up a bit, but that might be completely speculative. [01:04:04] Avi Rosten: In terms of payment and spending, in a word, no. It's really not that common. I occasionally see a Bitcoin ATM. There's actually a Bitcoin ATM quite near where I live. That's quite a rarity. And in terms of accepting Bitcoin, I've never come across a shop here. I mean, you have to really go out of your way to find them. And it's not something that is common at all. So yeah, I don't think that we're anywhere near the level, we're very far away from the level where people start accepting it, merchant-wise. And in terms of the regulatory environment, I think, from what I can tell, it's not that different from, say, the US or other places, although in 2019, as I said, the FCA and the government are publishing more guidance on how they want to regulate this space. [01:05:09] Vlad Costea: To me, it's actually interesting that when I find out about government policies in regards to Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies, they tend to treat them as commodities or as securities or anything else but money. They refuse to acknowledge that they can be money, because this would be a major defeat on their side. It would be like saying, "You can also use this made-up coin which exists on the internet as an alternative to our solution with central banking." And that, to my limited knowledge, hasn't happened so far. [01:05:50] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I think the UK, in this report, the Cryptoassets Taskforce, they had a classification system where they don't really acknowledge it as money. I'm just getting it up. They actually have, I think they have three categories of how they categorize crypto assets. And as I remember, I'm just getting it up on my computer, but yeah, they have three classes, and I don't think any of them, as I recall, actually are currency. Yeah, so they have three categorizations. [01:06:45] Avi Rosten: They call them exchange tokens, security tokens, and utility tokens. So this is actually one of the FCA's senior figures, I think, who was on the Cryptoassets Taskforce, responded to the government's report on it. And he interestingly said, when he was kind of offering a taxonomy of crypto assets, he said, "In my opinion, none of them are actually..." He says, "Exchange tokens, which are often referred to incorrectly, in my view, as cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin, Litecoin, and equivalent." So according to their categorization, they have exchange tokens, security tokens, and utility tokens, and even what he calls exchange tokens, so Bitcoin, Litecoin, et cetera, don't... He says, "We do not believe that they constitute money or currency." [01:07:36] Avi Rosten: So they clearly don't even see, you know, Bitcoin, or Litecoin or others, which are the most currency-like of a lot of the crypto assets, they don't view them actually as currencies. They view them as exchange tokens. And they have other things, security tokens, which, well, you know, things like STOs, and then utility tokens, which they would, you know, view as probably a lot of the ERC-20 tokens and others. So yeah, even so, the government in the UK clearly doesn't, or the FCA at least is unwilling to call them, to treat them as currencies. [01:08:15] Vlad Costea: Now, that's interesting, and it's going to be fascinating to watch how the narrative changes and how they realize that if people use Bitcoin as money, they're going to change their policies. And if they're going to acknowledge Bitcoin as a currency, maybe they're going to have either more restrictions on how you can use it or spend it, which is insane, but I guess it relies on good faith and reporting whoever uses it, or maybe using some kind of Orwellian system which tracks your IP and looks for your internet activity to see if you're using crypto wallets. [01:09:00] Vlad Costea: But these can be easily bypassed by people who are a little bit knowledgeable of security measures. So, will governments eventually allow you to pay taxes in Bitcoin without actually using payment processors? Are we going to see a world in which you no longer need foreign exchange, and the by-default currency when you travel is Bitcoin, and you can use it as a currency in local ATMs to withdraw some cash in the local currency? That's something that I really want to see, and it's going to be interesting if they actually implement it. [01:09:43] Vlad Costea: But at the same time, I can see how the banks, which have been the most influential financial institutions for centuries, are becoming defensive. And I guess they will make fiat so much more accessible and easy to use that you'll have no other reason to use Bitcoin other than censorship resistance and the idea that you are autonomous and you can hold your own money. So it will only fuel these two rather narrow niches of people who want to be in charge of their own money and who don't want to be censored when they make transactions. [01:10:33] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I really have no idea where it's going to go. I'm open to all kinds of possibilities. What I'm quite confident of, although I may be wrong, is that Bitcoin has some place in the future of money. Whether it will become the global reserve currency or a fringe asset, as it somewhat is now, I have no idea, but I'm relatively confident that it's around, it will be around for some time to come, but I could be wrong. [01:11:06] Vlad Costea: Okay, Avi, so people have been listening to you for over an hour now, and we didn't get to say how you can be contacted. How can people reach you and write you messages or read your articles? You have to mention that. [01:11:23] Avi Rosten: Sure, so I am on Twitter @avi_rosten, R-O-S-T-E-N. The website is cryptoglobe.com. You can email me at arosten@cryptoglobe.com or info@cryptoglobe.com. Yeah, so cryptoglobe.com is really the way to get in touch. Keep a lookout for our articles, because other than just rolling news, which we try and get quite quickly towards, we have some original research we publish. We did an interesting analysis recently on crypto news trends, which I wrote, which you might be interested in checking out. And we have some opinion pieces, some interviews, which are original interviews, so I think, yeah, keep an eye on us. And yeah, you can get in touch with me via Twitter or email. [01:12:12] Vlad Costea: Oh wait, I still have a question for you. [01:12:14] Avi Rosten: Oh sure. [01:12:15] Vlad Costea: You mentioned interviews, and I recall that you interviewed David Chaum. [01:12:19] Avi Rosten: Yeah, that's right, yeah. [01:12:21] Vlad Costea: The original developer of digital cash. [01:12:26] Avi Rosten: That's right. My friend referred to him as the O-est of all Gs. [01:12:30] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah. [01:12:33] Avi Rosten: So yeah, he was very interesting. Yeah, it was interesting talking to him, to talk to someone who's been around for so long. I mean, he's been thinking about these problems since before I was born. So it was quite a privilege to talk to him. We spoke, I mean, you can read the interview on the site, but we spoke at length about the origins of the movement, what he sees as the function of cryptocurrencies, where he thinks the current crop of crypto assets are going wrong in terms of transaction processes and other things. [01:13:05] Avi Rosten: Although he didn't explicitly say this, he did, I think he did at least... He wasn't keen to come down on any one side in the kind of store of value versus medium of exchange debate. He did, in my opinion, quite strongly indicate that crypto assets, at least as they are now, are not being used enough, anywhere near as enough as a medium of exchange, and there is a problem to be addressed there in terms of transaction speeds and, you know, the amount the networks can process. And I think the way he envisioned cryptocurrencies in the 80s and 90s, with things like eCash and DigiCash and other things that he that he started, was more as a, you know, a means of payment. And I think he said so in the interview, that he's, you know, unsatisfied with the way that the current crop of crypto assets are not fulfilling that role. Although he didn't say explicitly that he doesn't think Bitcoin could reach that. [01:14:10] Avi Rosten: He didn't really comment on whether Bitcoin could do that. I mean, partly, I think, because he's got his new Elixxir platform, which is launched. But yeah, it was fascinating to hear from someone who's been, you know, thinking about this for a very long time. [01:14:25] Vlad Costea: Did you actually meet him in person or was it a Skype interview? [01:14:29] Avi Rosten: No, it was actually a physical interview. We met in London. He was in London for a conference, so we met at the end of August on the rooftop of a hotel, which was very cool. [01:14:43] Vlad Costea: I'm so jealous right now. [01:14:45] Avi Rosten: Fanboyish, yeah. I know, it was really... [01:14:47] Vlad Costea: You're going to tell me that you also met Nick Szabo when he came to London. I'm going to be so jealous. [01:14:54] Avi Rosten: No, if only. [01:14:55] Vlad Costea: I will stop this interview. But I heard that John Medley has met him. [01:14:59] Avi Rosten: Oh yeah, very possibly. I don't know. It's very difficult to get an interview with him, as far as I can tell. And no, I'd love to. That would be really like a dream come true. I Skyped John McAfee, which was cool. Although I'd love to meet him in person. [01:15:19] Vlad Costea: He's running for president. [01:15:21] Avi Rosten: I know, it's great. I think it's going to be an interesting presidential campaign again. Although he's not running for the Libertarian candidate as he was last time. He's doing it as an independent, if I'm correct? [01:15:36] Vlad Costea: Well, he has all the money to do it, so... [01:15:38] Avi Rosten: Yeah. [01:15:39] Vlad Costea: He had that coin of the week campaign to fund his campaign. [01:15:44] Avi Rosten: It'd be interesting. It'd be good. I wonder if he'll, you know, sometimes these news programs always have some kind of wild card on there for balance or for, you know, just out of interest. I wonder if he'll make it onto like any CNN debates with like Elizabeth Warren and Donald Trump. It'll be hilarious if he makes it onto the news somehow, and, you know, here are the two mainstream candidates, and here's John McAfee running with his whale pictures. [01:16:13] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, and that status he posted on Twitter about having sex with whales. What a guy. [01:16:20] Avi Rosten: I mean, he definitely will be the only presidential candidate to have posted a picture of that. Although it'd be amazing if you could have a presidential candidate who is crazier and more outlandish than Trump. That would be a real achievement. [01:16:36] Vlad Costea: Also, he would be the only presidential candidate to have his dick on the line. [01:16:42] Avi Rosten: Yes, exactly. That's true. That's another accolade I'm sure he'll talk about. [01:16:48] Vlad Costea: Unless Bitcoin hits a certain threshold. I'm not sure what his prediction was. [01:16:52] Avi Rosten: It was a million dollars by 2020, so he's got... [01:16:57] Vlad Costea: That's insane. [01:16:58] Avi Rosten: He's got a year. We actually did an article on CryptoGlobe about, in about, at the end of November, early December. So we took about 10 or 12 of the top Bitcoin predictions from earlier in the year and drawing a graph of how high Bitcoin will have to rise in order for them to be true. So like things like Arthur Hayes predicting $50,000 in May, and others predicting $100,000, which was a bit mad, looking back on it at the time. [01:17:32] Vlad Costea: We are certainly living interesting times, which sometimes are funny, sometimes are just plain depressing. But you can never get bored on the internet and you can never get bored in the world of Bitcoin, thanks to people like John McAfee and all the crazy and wild ones who do stuff and give us reasons to write stories, reports. Like John Carvalho, who told me, "Well, we should do this interview." And I prepared questions for a proper interview. And then prior to recording the interview, he told me, "You know, I actually challenged Roger Ver to a fight for the Bitcoin.com domain." [01:18:11] Avi Rosten: Amazing. I saw that. Yeah, I saw that in the news. Yeah. [01:18:13] Vlad Costea: I was blown away. Like, what? Who does that? This sounds like schoolyard stuff. And I guess John will get mad at me if he listens to this, because I have an interview with him later today. But anyway, that's insane. That's very crypto-ish, very akin to the Bitcoin community. [01:18:35] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I agree. I think it's definitely not a boring industry to work in. And the other thing that others have pointed out to me is that in normal financial industries... You know, CryptoGlobe, we're a small site. I have no history. No one knows who I am. I can, because of the way crypto works, I can have access to people like David Chaum and John McAfee, which is very cool. In normal finance, if you want to interview Lloyd Blankfein, formerly of Goldman Sachs, or Peter Thiel, the chances of you speaking to those people are next to none if you're not The Wall Street Journal or CNBC or whoever. [01:19:10] Avi Rosten: So I think that is really actually a real positive, the fact that the industry is the way it is, that we can get to talk to people who are very high up in the industry and very well known. You don't have to be some massive financial or mainstream outlet in order to gain access to them. [01:19:26] Vlad Costea: I think it was the same in the '60s or in the early days of television, when you'd have a job at the BBC and talk to John Lennon just because you were there. [01:19:38] Avi Rosten: Yeah, that's true. That would be good. Yeah. [01:19:41] Vlad Costea: And the more the industry grows and diversifies, the harder it gets to actually reach the people who are influential or important for our culture. So I guess that's why we build our own idols and our own icons in each field. And then as every industry diversifies, they create their own personalities, even though they are copycats or not as interesting as the originals. We all need people to report about. That's the bottom line. [01:20:15] Avi Rosten: For sure, yeah. [01:20:17] Vlad Costea: So, I'm not sure if I have any more questions for you, Avi. [01:20:23] Avi Rosten: Cool, it's been great talking to you, Vlad, and I think this is the first podcast I've ever been on. So I hope I didn't sound like a rambling idiot, because it's hard to sometimes crystallize your thoughts verbally, but... [01:20:38] Vlad Costea: You know what I witnessed and I noticed from doing these podcasts? That I can ask the same questions to people and talk about the very same topics and end up having different discussions. And yeah, that's very interesting. The beauty of doing this. [01:20:54] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I hope I just... It's always a bit daunting when, you know, usually when you're having a conversation you're aware that you're not paying as much attention to what you're saying, so I hope I didn't say something very stupid or illogical. [01:21:08] Vlad Costea: No, it was actually interesting and I'm happy that we got to discuss about John Stuart Mill and freedom of speech. And then we moved on to more crypto stuff, more Bitcoin-ish topics, more mainstream Bitcoin-ish topics which get tackled at least more frequently and in a more regular way. But it's fascinating that we get to do something and have the kind of discussion which doesn't get out there very often. And I don't think academia is ready to embrace Bitcoin yet. They still, I think most of academia in the West, at least, is left wing. [01:21:50] Vlad Costea: They see something like Bitcoin as the exact opposite of what they stand for. And yeah, they can either turn it into the enemy of their ideology or not mention it at all. [01:22:07] Avi Rosten: Yeah, I think it's going to take a while. [01:22:13] Vlad Costea: But thank you for this conversation and this will get published on the Bitcoin Takeover website, which is bitcoin-takeover.com. And that's going to be a part of the whole season, which I deploy all at once. [01:22:24] Avi Rosten: Oh, great. [01:22:25] Vlad Costea: Ten episodes on the same day, so it can be binge-listened. The idea which I had was to just have 10 people in each season and not make any distinction between who they are, how big they are. It's all about the ideas. And maybe then I will have a couple of big names every season. [01:22:49] Vlad Costea: But at the same time, I also want to promote people who have original takes on what Bitcoin is and how they perceive it in relation to world politics and maybe even the Bitcoin politics themselves, because if you have a background in politics or political science, you see a lot of politics in Bitcoin and how people deal with stuff like the scaling debate and how protocols are deployed, soft forks and everything. And then there's the whole campaigning which they do to promote a narrative for what Bitcoin should be. That's a lot of politics in it. [01:23:28] Vlad Costea: Yeah, be aware of it. And if we actually care and we want it to be a reserve currency for the world, we have to preserve at least the idea of a fixed market capital, a fixed supply, not market capital, a fixed supply of 21 million. I think that's the biggest social attack that can happen to the currency itself. You cannot shut down miners or nodes. They will find new ways to move their equipment somewhere else. [01:23:52] Vlad Costea: But with the 21 million supply, that's something that you can change by changing the consensus and making the nodes run a different version which adjusts the supply. And I guess it's in the interest of miners, it's in the interests of socialists, and people who feel like that supply is not enough or is unfairly distributed, and they want to print more money. And if we actually want to make Bitcoin get a valuable position in world finance, we need to defend as much as we can the fundamental ideas. But I got sidetracked once again. [01:24:43] Avi Rosten: Yeah. Well, great. It's been great. Thanks very much for having me. [01:24:47] Vlad Costea: Goodbye, Avi. Thanks a lot. Have a good one. ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote two-person conversation in English (host Romanian, guest British), recorded in early 2019 with a short music intro; no genuine sponsor reads are present, and the sponsor-like phrases in the transcript are hallucinations. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 6 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (113 chunks) and 41 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 3 of 3 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed hallucinations (♪ The End, "I'm going to start with the first question...", "This is a very interesting topic", "I'm a big fan of the Bitcoin era", "I'm a bit of a fan of Bitcoin..."), restoring the real speech from the second ASR and the audio re-check. Fixed speaker labels (Guest A → Avi Rosten; "Hi, Avi" given to Vlad). Split out interjections ("Yeah." and "Yeah, that's always a good sign" as Avi, "Hmm." as Avi). Fixed names and terms: CryptoGlobe, Udi Wertheimer, CoinDesk, Mt. Gox, Mimblewimble, "developing", "takes up", "free developments", "On Liberty"/"Utilitarianism". Restored dropped text ("committed enough...", "come November 2017...", "box myself... appealing"); Labelled Guest A as Avi Rosten; removed "This is a very interesting topic" (x4), "Thank you"/"Thank you for watching. See you next time. Bye!" hallucinations and doubled words; restored dropped text from audio re-check (other left-wing publications/neo-Nazis/alt-right, "I think it was Pittsburgh", "customer base... loud voice"); fixed payment processors, shooter, reign, meddles, Cyphernomicon, Protestant Work Ethic, Julia Cagé, "for want of a better word"; split out Avi's "I haven't seen that actually" interjection; Removed hallucinations ("Bitcoin Academy" ad at 00:35:04, fake "David Chaum" intro at 00:40:14, "Thank you." at 00:42:28, "I'm going to go back to"); relabelled Guest A/"David Chaum" as Avi Rosten; restored dropped words from second ASR (right of center/libertarian, "movement", "argument", "Churchill" read as chat show host); fixed Noam Chomsky, John Stuart Mill, Nick Szabo, carnivore, payment processors, WikiLeaks, Are We Decentralized Yet; split Vlad's turn at ~00:43:25; Fixed Nicomachean Ethics, virtues, Beam, founders' rewards, fiat, "triple my money"; removed hallucinations ("This episode is brought to you...", "Thank you for watching...", "This is a special episode...", stray "Thank you."), restored dropped text from Qwen/Scribe; split interjections (golden mean, Yeah) to Avi; relabelled Guest A as Avi Rosten and fixed 00:46:42–00:48:48 and 00:56:16 boundary attribution; Relabelled Guest A as Avi Rosten; split merged interjections (Oh sure, Yeah that's right, Oh yeah, I'm so jealous, Fanboyish, No if only, Yeah, He's running for president, Oh yeah whale status, That's insane); removed hallucinations ("I'm going to go back to the topic...", "Boom.", "Thank you.", "OIMO" → "or email"); restored dropped text from Qwen/Scribe (innovation and growth, taxonomy quote); fixed Cryptoassets Taskforce, regulator, STOs, ERC-20, cryptoglobe.com, Elixxir, Nick Szabo, "very possibly", "tail", "fuel"; "Westwood Wells" kept as unclear guess; Fixed CryptoGlobe, David Chaum, Roger Ver ("challenged Roger Ver to a fight"), "moved on"; kept Inabal as unclear; relabelled Guest A as Avi Rosten; split merged interjections ("For sure, yeah", "Cool, it's been great..." boundary, "Oh, great.", "Goodbye, Avi." to Vlad); split long monologues.