Title: S16 E28: Proof of Work Alliance with Charles Chong, Summer Meng & Spencer Yang Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Charles Chong and Spencer Yang (Fractal Bitcoin; Proof of Work Alliance), Summer Meng (@SummerMeng21; CEO of Bitmars, ASIC miner supplier) Published: 2025-05-31 Duration: 1:21:34 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2025-05-31_s16_e28_proof_of_work_alliance_with_charles_chong_summer_meng_spencer_yang_-_31.05.2025_12.57.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2025-05-31_s16_e28_proof_of_work_alliance_with_charles_chong_summer_meng_spencer_yang_-_31.05.2025_12.57.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Base: local Whisper medium.en transcript with automatic speaker diarization, reconciled against a full local small.en (int16, VAD) re-transcription with word timestamps; paragraphs re-segmented on the small.en word timings and fully read through, with a three-way comparison (draft vs small.en vs YouTube auto-captions of the livestream) over the whole episode (207 disagreement spots reviewed, about 70 fixes, including the intro and sponsor read rebuilt from the small.en and caption text). 25 doubtful stretches were checked against short audio clips re-transcribed locally with medium.en (int16, VAD), including the sats/vB fee passage at 00:52:10, the OP_RETURN / CTV / CSFS / OP_CAT and signet passage at 01:02:01, the Ordinals fee figure at 01:04:08, the stablecoin-on-BRC-20 passage at 01:09:06, the Pizza Day challenge and the closing handles. Speaker turns were checked with a full-episode local speaker-embedding scan (four reference voices, 1.5 s windows at 0.75 s hop) and short turns re-attributed where the scan or the audio was unambiguous. Sponsor reads (SideShift, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News, Hodling.ch, LayerTwo Labs, NoOnes.com) are read live by Vlad. Names and jargon were checked against the title, the feed, the PoW Alliance launch announcement and the web: Proof of Work Alliance (PoWA), Fractal Bitcoin, Blockspace Force, Bitmars, F2Pool, SpiderPool, ElphaPex, Fortitude Mining / Foundry, Psy Protocol, ETC (Ethereum Classic), iPollo, StandardHash, BIT / bit.com, merge mining, blind merged mining, drivechains, OP_RETURN, CTV, CSFS, OP_CAT, BRC-20, Runes, Ordinals, DOG•GO•TO•THE•MOON, Kraken, Tron, Pizza Day. Light clean verbatim: ums, false starts and stutters removed; the guests' non-native phrasing kept. Intro music omitted. Remaining doubtful words are marked [unclear: best guess]. ================================================================================ [00:00:48] Vlad Costea: Hello there, and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 28. This episode is sponsored by SideShift, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News, Hodling.ch, LayerTwo Labs, and NoOnes.com, and we are live to present something special for Pizza Day, actually. It's a launch which was under embargo. I found out about it, and I basically turned what was supposed to be an article into a podcast. And I want to thank the participants who are here today for joining on such a short notice. We have Summer Meng. We have Charles Chong. I hope I don't mispronounce your last names, and I apologize in advance. And we also have Spencer... and is it Tang? Is that how I pronounce it, Spencer? [00:01:37] Spencer Yang: Yeah, Spencer Yang will be good. [00:01:39] Vlad Costea: And they are here to represent Fractal Bitcoin and also Bitmars, which are mining companies. And much more than this, there is like an alliance of 11 mining companies, which, starting today, is going to work together to push research in the field of proof of work, which seems to be marginalized in this phase of the market. It seems like proof of stake is more fashionable. The amount of proof of work projects is much smaller than it used to be. And it's good to see these initiatives. So it's good to have you on the show. Welcome. [00:02:16] Vlad Costea: Okay, so let's establish some sort of order or you can join whenever you want. But my first question is, what is this alliance about and how did you come to it? [00:02:29] Charles Chong: Yeah, I think Vlad, like you mentioned earlier, I think these days Proof of Work isn't as fashionable anymore. But I think we have to be reminded that with the birth of Bitcoin, Proof of Work was the first widely adopted consensus mechanism out there. And then in the early days, any blockchain protocols that launched Proof of Work was the primary choice for them. I think these days we are lucky to see even one new Proof of Work chain launch in a year. So I think let's dive into why is that so. [00:03:00] Charles Chong: I think the primary reason is it's very hard to bootstrap a Proof of Work network. You need buy-in from miners from day one. And it's not just them buying your tokens, it's them investing in capex in buying their machines and then having a long-term view that this is the project that they want to support. But besides the miners, you also need support from mining pools as well and potentially even machine manufacturers if you are going the ASIC route. But then on the other hand, if you don't go the ASIC route and you were thinking, hey, I'm going to go with some algorithms that use a GPU, I think you will face an even larger hurdle getting the miners to mine it because all the miners have their sites built for ASICs. [00:03:43] Charles Chong: So the power draw, the form factor, the shoebox mining form factor, you won't be able to get miners to mine your coin. So again, which is why given the difficulty in bootstrapping this Proof of Work networks, we see a lot of other protocols choosing Proof of Stake or other alternatives today. So which is why we came together and formed the Proof of Work Alliance because we deeply believe that proof of work does offer superior security and also decentralization that many seems to have forgotten. So we formed this Proof of Work Alliance with 11 founding members here and then we have a very diverse representation in terms of geographic regions but also the types of players in the ecosystem. [00:04:26] Charles Chong: We have mining pools, miners, machine manufacturers, service providers and also different proof of work protocols here. So again, the goal here is to grow the proof of work ecosystem as a whole. [00:04:42] Vlad Costea: Spencer, I guess you wanted to jump in. [00:04:46] Spencer Yang: Yeah, happy to chime in a little bit. I think to build on what Charles mentioned, I think when we first spoke to the various founding members and also other industry participants, we realized that there's just a, I would say, lack of focus on this particular area. And I think a lot of times in the Bitcoin community and in the crypto community, there's a bit of a stigma against alliances because it kind of like also, some people say that, hey, this is like, are you deciding things behind closed doors? [00:05:17] Spencer Yang: And so on. I think ultimately the vision and why we started this is really so that we can encourage more open collaboration, more research and a lot of the research, the learnings and so on, we wanted to essentially have the avenue to have these publications be public from day one and develop open source projects and tools together. And I think as what we have mentioned as well, it's really interesting in this space. I mean, Bitcoin since 2009 has been popularized, I guess, over the past couple of years. [00:05:48] Spencer Yang: And I think in recent years, it's almost like, we've almost forgotten about the underlying consensus, the underlying technology, and a lot of these coordination efforts. We definitely have seen probably that the companies go public because they're mining companies and Bitcoin mining companies. But I think from a research perspective, there's been a lack of attention and focus. And we think that over here is an opportunity definitely for more collaboration and more thoughts. But yeah, really excited to be on this podcast to share a little bit more of our thinking. [00:06:16] Spencer Yang: And I think at the end of the day, each Alliance member, whether it's a founding member or whether it's a future members, all have different views and opinions. And I think that's what makes an Alliance awesome. It's this [unclear: mural], but also very, I guess we are tied together by a mission, but at the same time, everyone has their own interest. And that's really the beauty of decentralization and the beauty of crypto economic systems as well. [00:06:41] Vlad Costea: Summer. [00:06:45] Summer Meng: Yes, I agree. So when Charles just mentioned about it, I really liked the idea of the PoW Alliance because it's like, I think it's really good to build this platform and then to unite people in the industry to work together. I mean, like today we all face the same challenges, but we all stand alone and work alone by ourselves. For example, you can see that many suppliers and manufacturers are from China, but it's like maybe there are some different reasons because of maybe language barriers and maybe cultural difference that prevent us from connecting and communicating more with the community. [00:07:27] Summer Meng: So I really think that that's the meaning of like a Proof of Work Alliance that unites people together. And then we gather together to exchange insights, to share knowledge like this. I always think that's like people is always about people, you know? So it's really good that you build this and the platform to bring us together is like, I think each of us like a [unclear: drop of the ocean]. So we gather together, we can build greater things together and also a greater future. So I'm happy to be part of it. [00:08:03] Vlad Costea: Yeah. So you mentioned that there are 11 founding members of this Proof of Work Alliance. Who are the others? Because unfortunately this was set up in a very short amount of time. I wish I could have all 11 companies represented here, but we shouldn't forget about them because they're also a significant part of this. [00:08:23] Charles Chong: Yeah. So let me share who are the members today. And again, we are launching today with 11, but we welcome new members to join. This is just our initial group. Let's launch this and then continue to get more members to join. So in terms of the members, from mining pool perspective, we have F2Pool and SpiderPool. And then from hardware perspective, obviously we have Summer from Bitmars here and also ElphaPex. And then in terms of mining company, we have Fortitude Mining, which is a spin-off from Foundry. [00:08:56] Charles Chong: And then in terms of PoW protocols, we have Fractal, we have Psy Protocol and ETC. Oh, and also for hardware, we also have iPollo as well. And then from a cloud mining service provider, we have StandardHash and also bit.com crypto exchange. [00:09:21] Vlad Costea: Interesting. So let me ask you this because it's been a rough few years. We have had an initiative from Greenpeace, which was trying to get Bitcoin to change its consensus and mining mechanism. It was called make the code green or something like that. And there was a stigma until the moment BlackRock started investing in Bitcoin. There was a lot of stigma concerning proof of work and they were saying, well, it's boiling the oceans. Well, it consumes more electricity than the state of, I don't know, I think it was Denmark. [00:09:55] Vlad Costea: It is wasteful because it creates a lot of, how should I put it, defective hardware that cannot be used for anything else once it's damaged and cannot be used to mine anymore. There are a lot of these narratives that Bitcoin and proof of work mining in general is causing a lot of damage to the environment. My question for you is, how do you respond when you deal with these allegations? [00:10:26] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I think the first thing is that when it comes to proof of work, it's really about incentives, right? As with most things. I think a lot of things that powers today's infrastructure, whether it's AI, whether it's crypto economics, is really based on, I guess, something that's fundamental and that's demand. And I think demand from Bitcoin also, from a crypto perspective, is real. People do need an electronic peer-to-peer, electronic currency. And I think that's what we have created as an industry that is awesome and is well celebrated. [00:10:59] Spencer Yang: And then if you look at other industries like the AI industry as well, there's a lot of people using chatbots, ChatGPT, or image recognition, video generators, and whatsoever. And I think that productive output is what we humans really want. And I think the usage of energy, resources, and time attention to be able to power that demand, I think that's very, very important. And then I can take a further step back and look at where the Bitcoin mining industry is today from a usage of power perspective. [00:11:28] Spencer Yang: I totally agree with you, right? That from a usage of power perspective, we are at the, maybe like fourth times that of what Singapore consumes on a daily basis, right? That is awesome, but also kind of scary for many people, right? Especially as you mentioned, some of the Greenpeace advocates and whatnot. I think it's actually quite reassuring for me to know as well that many of the miners and the mining community have actually been using very, very sustainable and also renewable sources of electricity to power Bitcoin mining today. [00:11:57] Spencer Yang: So I think if you look at this report by Cambridge University, those recently published, it was mentioned that about 40%, 40 to 50% of energy that is used for Bitcoin mining today is actually from sustainable as well as renewable sources. And I think that's very encouraging. We would definitely see that energy numbers go, I guess the percentage go up and the world also recognize the problem of fossil fuels and so on and transition to more sustainable and renewable sources as well. I think that's what we want to see, right? [00:12:24] Spencer Yang: And I think as long as we keep driving demand, I think supply and, you know, with the industry efforts we'll definitely catch up based on that. [00:12:34] Charles Chong: Yeah. I think just to jump on Spencer's point, I think the running joke in the industry is always Bitcoin mining uses less electricity than Christmas lights. So should we ban Christmas lights, right? So I think at the high level, the usage of electricity power is correlated to the GDP of a country. So energy usage by itself, it's not bad. It's about what, is it a good use of that power? So if you think about, is it a good use of power to secure the Bitcoin network? I think many of us would agree that yes, it is. [00:13:08] Charles Chong: But also I think the other thing to keep in mind is Bitcoin miners are the most price sensitive electricity power users. So they go for the cheapest power and what are the cheapest power? It's renewable. It's your hydro, your solar, your wind farm, which is why we saw Marathon, MARA, they went up and purchased a wind farm. They did not go out and purchase a gas turbine or any other fuel sources out there. And then also a lot of miners have been going for stranded gas. Again, this stranded gas, if you burn there, it's even more damaging to the environment. [00:13:46] Charles Chong: So I think Bitcoin mining is helping the environment in a lot of ways. I think the other thing that we should note as well is how it stabilize the grid. I think most people don't understand that the role that Bitcoin miners play in stabilizing the grid, supporting demand response programs, I think those are great benefit to the power grid and environment as well. [00:14:15] Vlad Costea: I was wondering if Summer wants to add something. [00:14:19] Summer Meng: No, I don't have much to add at this point, I think they already covered pretty much. But it's like from our clients, we can see that a lot of Bitcoin mining actually already has renewable energy, for example, Nordic countries, even in Texas is the same. So a lot of mining is actually already helping to stabilize more energy. [00:14:42] Vlad Costea: So when you said Spencer, that AI farms are also a thing right now, I was actually thinking, do you think that the rise of these large language models and their popularization for generating answers and images and stuff like this has helped the proof of work industry by legitimizing it and saying, you know, there's actually good ways for you to consume electricity? Or do you think it's been detrimental because you're competing for the same electricity that's being produced? And maybe you're also competing for hardware. [00:15:18] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I've been away with my thoughts over here, and I think I actually love to hear from Charles and also from Summer what their thoughts about, you know, like the infrastructure side of things set up and whatnot, right, for AI, versus, you know, like Bitcoin mining and proof of work. But overall, my thesis has always been that it's really about productive usage, right? And I think AI has, you know, I think if you notice right now, there's an AI race between, you know, countries, between companies, between, you know, there's so many individuals, right? [00:15:48] Spencer Yang: I think recently, just yesterday or the day before, OpenAI announced that they're acquiring Jony Ive, who's the, you know, previously the head of design for Apple's company. And essentially, I mean, some people, some critics said that it is just an expensive acqui-hire, right, of 6.5 billion. Some people say that it's a real thing, and I think we're going to have like devices, but if you think about it actually places OpenAI in a competition between them, as well as maybe Apple and maybe Google with Android devices and whatnot. [00:16:16] Spencer Yang: And I think it's very, very fascinating, right? It's super fascinating to see that our hardware is also being the [unclear: battlefront]. But fundamentally, a lot of these models rely on centralized infrastructure because it's just more efficient, right? For example, if you and I actually have a desktop PC or a desktop device to run AI models, I don't think that we'll be able to scale as well as that of centralized service. But at the same time, we actually see a lot of privacy advocates do that. I think it's actually a little bit similar to crypto, right, where traditional finance is a very centralized sort of infrastructure, right? [00:16:47] Spencer Yang: But at the same time, when we look at, you know, the distributed ledger of Bitcoin, that everyone is verifying and so on, it's actually decentralized around the world, right? But of course, in order to get some level of efficiency, it's also helpful to centralize some of these, you know, sort of like, you know, ASICs, you know, infrastructure in certain zones, but it's not to the point where everyone in the network is relying on their one infrastructure or one location, right? There's so many sites around the world, and I think that's the beauty of it, right? [00:17:15] Spencer Yang: And I think that's similar to AI as well. So there's definitely some similar patterns where some areas are a little bit more centralized as is necessary, but for the most part, we are really striving for that decentralization across the board. [00:17:28] Charles Chong: Yeah, I think if you look at traditional data centers, traditional data centers have been around for quite some time and they have been pulling quite a bit of power as well, but we don't see the same kind of headline back then. I think Bitcoin mining was drawing a lot more headline. I think that was the [unclear: FUD stage], so that's where we got a lot of negative headlines. And I, some of them, when I read them, I think many of them were inaccurate and factually wrong as well. [00:17:56] Charles Chong: So I think that was just an attack against Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies in general. But I think these days with AI data centers, we do see some headlines around AI data centers as well. I think it's for two primary reasons. I think it's just the growth of the AI data centers. I think the traditional data centers, it took a long time to grow over time, so the impact wasn't felt right away, but I think there's so much power going to AI data centers. But I think the other reason is the power density. [00:18:27] Charles Chong: So in the traditional data center world, a rack probably pulls like 10 kilowatt of capacity, whereas today with your H100s, H200s, one rack can pull up to 100, 200 kilowatt. So it's like 10 times more than the previous racks. So I think the power density is what's drawing headline as well. And then as we know, a Bitcoin miner, one single Bitcoin miner draws 3.5 kilowatt, which is quite a lot, but I think it's somewhere in the middle between the traditional data centers and the AI data centers. [00:18:57] Charles Chong: So again, back then with the traditional data centers, they built 10, 20 megawatts sites, but with Bitcoin mining and AI data centers, you are hearing 200, 500 megawatts, which is why again, it's drawing all these headlines. [00:19:16] Vlad Costea: Right. So when I read about your alliance, I've also remembered about a moment in 2021, I think, so four years ago, when Elon Musk accepted Bitcoin for payments on the Tesla store. So you could actually buy a brand new car using your Bitcoin. And then a couple of weeks later, he said, well, you know, most of Bitcoin mining is damaging to the environment and therefore I'm going to remove Bitcoin as a method to pay and I'm not going to add it until it's sustainable enough. And what happened afterwards is that Michael Saylor and a bunch of other North Americans from Marathon, from what's the other big one? [00:20:00] Vlad Costea: Foundry, they decided to establish what is today called the North American Bitcoin Alliance. And they joined that organization and it seemed like a lot of mining centralization happening because at the time, mining had migrated from being mostly Chinese -centric to being mostly USA -centric, it was like this moment of transition, and it seemed very weird. And now you're making a new alliance and I want to ask you, do you believe that these alliances are making anything more centralized or if there is a greater chance to have pools agreeing with each other to maybe reorganize the blockchain or do stuff like this to get the 51% majority? [00:20:53] Charles Chong: Yeah, I can take that. I think we have to separate, so between, I think there's two levels here. At the bottom level, I think each member company or each company in this space have their own economic interest, whereas at the higher level they have the interest of Bitcoin and the network in general. So I think we have to understand that that's these two levels. So when we talk about potentially members colluding, again, I think each company operates so that they are protecting their own economic interest and not sacrificing their own economic interest. [00:21:31] Charles Chong: So I think when we form this alliance, we do want it to be neutral, which is why instead of just saying, hey, let's form a mining pool alliance or let's form a hardware manufacturer alliance. So we decided to form a PoW alliance where we invite members from all these different verticals. Again, that way we can stay even more neutral because now every member has a say and no member in each of this vertical would like collusion in other verticals. [00:22:00] Spencer Yang: 100%. I would say that I think overall collusion is bad for crypto. I think it sometimes naturally forms because of certain shared interests and whatnot. I think that's something that I generally do not like because what happens is that it definitely creates the, I guess it creates distrust and it creates, and I think crypto is one of those ecosystems, whether it's Bitcoin and so on, where essentially we have decentralized ownership, we have decentralized, you know, I guess, setups and so on, essentially with code to allow us to not have to trust each other, but to also be able to coordinate with. [00:22:36] Spencer Yang: And I think that that's why, you know, sometimes it's helpful to have some level of like, you know, social communities and whatnot, but I think that when it comes to the alliance, right, the, any, and I think there's two points here, right? One is about the risks and the other party for the rewards, right? But I think from a risk perspective, I think having a very, very diverse group of participants, I think it really helps to essentially have everyone's views to be considered, right? And usually when that happens, then there's no real incentive for some level of collusion. [00:23:05] Spencer Yang: And it really helps to reduce the risk. So anything, anyone can also kind of sound out if they see anything fishy, anything weird. I think it's really on every single member to essentially make sure that their interests are protected, right. And have a seat at the table. And then the second thing about this is the reward, right? I think what's the benefit of everyone and a lot of these key participants involved is so that, you know, as we challenge the ideas, a lot of things that maybe doesn't make sense from a higher level perspective for everyone can be essentially refuted or, you know, can be, I guess, you know, I guess spoken about, right. [00:23:40] Spencer Yang: So there's a little bit more representation. It's almost like, you know, when it comes to the U S presidential elections, you have polls and polls of like, you know, and I think today both actually pretty accurate, but of course we've seen in recent elections, maybe that's a really bad example because in previous elections, you know, the polls have been quite bad at telling the truth sometimes, right. But it's a little bit like a poll, right. I think it's probably the easy way to say it, but we shouldn't trust polls, right. [00:24:02] Spencer Yang: But at the same time, I think polls are still useful and which is why we use them today. So I think that's kind of how I think about an alliance in general. [00:24:12] Charles Chong: And I think I just want to add one more point. I think, so Bitcoin is decentralized governance, but there is some sort of social coordination as well. Just like we see Bitcoin Core developers talking to each other, we need some sort of a coordination layer. And in terms of mining, I think one example I can give here is Stratum V2. So Stratum V2 is an idea that's been around for like a very long time, but then to actually implement it, you actually need social coordination among different players. [00:24:41] Charles Chong: It now becomes a chicken and egg problem. Do hardware manufacturers enable it first, or do mining pools need to support it first? So this is where, and then if it's only one mining pools or do all mining pools need to support it at the same time. So again, it becomes like a social coordination problem as well. [00:24:59] Vlad Costea: Now, another big issue that I see sometimes in mining, I mean, not sometimes, pretty much all the time, is that you have two or three companies which manufacture most of the ASIC chips. And you just have Bitmain and the other big one is Avalon, if I'm not mistaken. And of course, I also have this one, which I've received from the husband of summer, Christian. I want to thank him on live video because he sent me this. It's made by Braiins. It's a tiny home miner that also displays the price at the same time. [00:25:36] Vlad Costea: It's like $300. It's cheaper than a Blockclock and actually mines. But once again, it's optimized for low noise and efficiency. It's not industrial scale. It cannot compete with an actual Antminer or something serious. But I do know that mining chips or ASICs for mining Bitcoin are just a small percentage of chip manufacturing. And it's been like this for many years. We have heard rumors about maybe Intel or AMD or Samsung and all of these large companies getting into the business of producing ASIC chips for mining. [00:26:14] Vlad Costea: As far as I'm aware, they haven't. And my question for you is how do you get more competition into this space? Because it seems like there is sort of an oligopoly of only a few players and everyone's buying the miners from them. Most of the time they're not in stock. You have to find very good deals. Sometimes you get them used. But that's another old issue with Bitmain because they were sending used miners sometimes. Is there any way to mitigate this, to generate more competition? [00:26:52] Charles Chong: I'll tackle this and then Summer can go after me. So I think Bitcoin mining is still pretty new. I would say like the ASIC mining space is still not that mature. So I think if you look at when ASIC was first released and then after that we are seeing great improvements in terms of ASIC efficiency because they are using better chips and then better designs. So huge improvement. And because of that, the R&D needed for it's very high. The early players invest tons of R&D into improving their ASIC design, so which is why we see it's hard for new players to enter the space back then. [00:27:36] Charles Chong: But I think we are starting to see that change these days because now most ASIC machines are already using the latest chips, the three nanometer chips out there. And so we don't see as much improvement anymore. And then SHA-256 has been around for a long time. So again, there's more expertise in the space on how to manufacture these chips. So which is why you saw a couple of open source projects, Bitaxe, that you mentioned earlier. They were able to do this with low R&D budget. [00:28:06] Charles Chong: But then also we are seeing new players enter the space. So Auradine based in the US is obviously a big contender these days. And then we are also seeing other folks at Chain Reaction. And also I believe Block, Core Scientific and Epic are working on their own mining machines too. So I think we are seeing more decentralization happening these days. I think a lot of these newer players, their machines are not proven or better tested as much yet. So still optimistic to see them grabbing market share. [00:28:37] Charles Chong: Yeah, Summer feel free to chime in. [00:28:40] Summer Meng: Yes, I think ASIC mining manufacturing is like extremely capital-intensive and complex. So it's like chip design and long R&D cycles and also like large upfront investment and there is no guarantee of success. So it is hard, you know, it is hard. But like Charles just mentioned, I think nowadays we have like other players also enter into this game. For example, like Auradine just mentioned, they already have miners produced. And also we know that a bunch of companies are already like testing them. So, and also like recently Bitdeer also released the SEALMINER. So it's like there are people entering. [00:29:21] Summer Meng: So we hope to see like more people to manufacture more miners and also there are like competition. It will help the ecosystem to be better also. [00:29:35] Vlad Costea: I'm not sure if Spencer took a break or his camera died, but I was thinking if he wants to chime in to say something. [00:29:47] Vlad Costea: Anyway, we'll move on. Maybe he's going to come back and mention it. What I do also want to include in our conversation. Oh, he said he's going to be right back. I lost my train of thought. Oh yeah. So what I do want to include in our conversation is the fact that there are still coins out there which are chasing this maybe chimera. I don't know. Maybe it's an illusion because they have to hard fork all the time, but they're trying to stay ASIC resistant. And ASIC resistance means that they want to stick to maybe what Satoshi Nakamoto thought was going to happen. [00:30:26] Vlad Costea: That every computer that joins the network is going to mine with their CPU. And he was not aware that there's going to be mining pools, that there's going to be GPUs and then FPGAs and then ASICs. I guess he didn't see this coming. Or if he stuck around for long enough, maybe he would be more of a fan of hard forking just to preserve this vision. Of every user being able to mine. What do you think about this approach? Because obviously you're dealing with the business side of it and the larger industrial scale. [00:30:59] Vlad Costea: Do you think it's healthy to have this sort of mining? Does it make it more decentralized? Or once again, is it just a waste of time? [00:31:13] Charles Chong: I think it's super hard to make something ASIC resistant unless it's fully randomized. I think in the early days, the approach is to adopt algorithms that are more memory heavy. But even so, a lot of those coins that were planning to become ASIC resistant, eventually that's an ASIC available as long as there's enough economic incentive and enough time for it. I think for mining, it's always going to be hard if you just want to focus on retail miners and mining for everyone. Partly because there's always an economy of scale, but also where your power is. [00:31:55] Charles Chong: So if you're located in the middle of Chicago, it doesn't make a lot of sense to mine there versus if you're in upstate New York. So I think the power cost is a big factor as well. And also, how many retails can you actually get? I think even in Bitcoin mining today, I think retail is probably comprised of like 5% of the entire network. But then if you look at the number of retail miners involved, there's probably a lot of them. But all of them added together is probably smaller than one single public mining company. [00:32:30] Charles Chong: So I think that's always going to be a challenge as well. [00:32:35] Spencer Yang: I do agree with that overall thesis, which is that I think at the end of the day, when it comes to designing a successful proof-of-work network, I think that's also the beauty of the proof-of-work alliance because the members collectively have seen a lot of things happen in the industry. So for example, if I come into the Bitcoin space today, what I would do is I'll ask my friends who are in Bitcoin, hey, how can I buy Bitcoin? And then they will give me the answer, maybe Coinbase, Binance, whatsoever. [00:32:58] Spencer Yang: And it's like, for example, if I were to come into the space today and I want to, let's say I'm a relatively new project and I want to essentially work on something in the proof-of-work space, whether it's to mine Bitcoin or to build miners or to do something. I think the question really is, there's a lot of history and there's a lot more research that has been done over the past couple of years, a lot of experiments that's done. So many coins have launched, so many projects have launched, so many miners and mining firms have come and went. [00:33:23] Spencer Yang: So I think at the end of the day, when it comes to an alliance, that's also the beauty of it, where a lot of the members have this experience and shared experience to essentially share ideas. But into a question about ASIC resistance, I think it's very interesting. Today is Bitcoin Pizza Day. So Laszlo, if you look at history, Laszlo actually was one of the first people to design a program, I think, to allow you to use GPUs to mine Bitcoin. And I think Satoshi Nakamoto actually may or may not have actually emailed Laszlo in saying, hey, I actually thought this will be a little bit further out than today. [00:33:55] Spencer Yang: So I think maybe Laszlo, I speculate, and maybe Laszlo felt a little bit guilty about like, you know, accelerating the path of like, you know, CPU to GPU mining for Bitcoin even back in the day. And that's why also he received a lot of Bitcoin from that and, you know, he bought pizza with that as a way of giving back to the community. But yeah, hey, any other day, I think it's net good, right? When you have a saturation of sorts, you know, a step change and so on. [00:34:19] Spencer Yang: As long as people know and people can verify that on chain, because what happened, right, if you have a new ASIC that is more powerful, people can verify that you actually are mining at a higher efficiency and effectiveness. And then they will catch up, right? They will also do certain things, right? Because I think this is what we see even in the AI industry as well, where any manufacturer of, like, you know, GPUs and so on that are very, very strong. When that happens, then other countries, other providers will also catch up. [00:34:49] Spencer Yang: So I think that's also really interesting, right? Where at the end of the day, you know, we are all just following Moore's law, right? And the cost of these are, and also effectiveness is just really exponentially going up. So costs are going down and effectiveness is going up. [00:35:07] Vlad Costea: Do you see a moment when the adoption is going to be so high that everyone's going to purchase a tiny miner and use it as a lottery ticket, but the numbers of these miners is going to be so great that they're going to be able to compete with the large mining pools? [00:35:22] Spencer Yang: I'd say it's a thought experiment, right? I've never thought about it that way, but let's say hypothetically, if you pose that question, I would say that I think it's always, so like many developing countries and many countries in today, right? Even developed countries, right? Like in the US and so on, you know, people actually still subscribe to the [unclear: lottery] because at the end of the day, everyone wants a dream of essentially, you know, having a small chance, a very, very small chance, but a chance to essentially change their lives, right? [00:35:47] Spencer Yang: And I think in some ways, if you actually were to be successfully able to mine on Bitcoin today with, let's say, maybe, you know, Vlad, the miner that you have in the, in the shelf, right? If you're able to do that, then, you know, that's, that's definitely, that's definitely amazing, right? So I definitely think that it's a possibility as long as these devices and these things are stable and whatnot. I definitely think it's stable, but that being said, should that be the norm? I do not know, and I do not think so at least for today, right? [00:36:17] Spencer Yang: Because at the end of the day, we want some level of stability, right? And consistency. And I think a lot of the larger mining operations around the world provides a level of stability and security overall. [00:36:30] Charles Chong: Yeah, I'm just, I'm just looking at Bitaxe hashrate, right? I think if I'm not mistaken, it's about one terahash. So in comparison, Marathon has 60 exahash, so that's 60, 60 million Bitaxes that you need people to buy. So, yeah, so I don't think it's gonna really surpass some of these large institutional miners, but at the end of the day, I think it's a, it's a good effort. I think anything we can do to decentralize and get people being active participants versus just a passive investor, I think that does help. [00:37:07] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but if you want to stay bullish on this narrative, you can say, well, Germany has 80, 80 million people. So if every person in Germany is going to acquire an ASIC miner and they put that in their home, they can compete with a large mining pool. I do hope it's going to happen. I don't think it will happen. But once again, someone who is much smarter than me told me that every heater that you use during winter is basically a wasteful piece that could have been mining Bitcoin instead. [00:37:41] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I agree with that thesis, right? And who knows, right? Let's say, for example, we have a zombie apocalypse, right? And then all the power, all the centralized power stations go out of business. The 60 million people in Germany, I think would be able to power the network. [00:38:02] Vlad Costea: Your alliance in the press release says that it's trying to nurture innovation in the proof of work field. And I was wondering, what is the innovation that you're trying to improve? Is it about improving the hardware? Is it about making current hardware more efficient? So by optimizing the software or is it just about business and social relations? [00:38:31] Charles Chong: I think it's all of the above. So again, we have members from different verticals. So different verticals do have certain focus areas, but other folks may be less interested in the other verticals, but it all affects everyone. So I'm just going to throw out a couple of examples. So earlier you mentioned heat recapture. So again, that's an idea that's been thrown around for quite some time. So we have to understand why is that still not a big thing? We do see miners adopting it and some manufacturers playing with that idea. [00:39:02] Charles Chong: But why is that not prevalent enough? Is it because of miner adoption? Where are the constraints? So I think those are some of the things we try to address. But then also, if you think about at the pool level or protocol level. So for example, there's a lot of conversations about non-standard transactions, like should that be included? But also MEV, right? So again, MEV has been a thing in Ethereum for a long time and then it briefly appeared in the Bitcoin world during the Ordinals time. [00:39:30] Charles Chong: But again, that's something that isn't discussed too much in the space. So we hope to get everyone involved to further discuss this kind of topics. [00:39:41] Vlad Costea: Just a second. There's a storm that started outside. I need to close the window. So sorry. [00:39:52] Vlad Costea: OK, I'm back. So let's talk about innovation in the proof of work field, because. If I guess if you're not working in the proof of work field, you're going to say that there was no innovation whatsoever. It's just hardware following Moore's law. And there isn't much stuff going on since maybe AsicBoost, which was a controversial topic in 2016, 17. [00:40:27] Spencer Yang: Happy to share some possible thinking over here. Yeah, I think when it comes to the proof of work side of things, definitely, you know, when it comes to Bitcoin and established network at Bitcoin. I think when it comes to that, the ability for hardware manufacturers and so on to adapt and to be able to innovate, I think was very important. And I think that forms a chunk of innovation happening in the space from a monetary perspective and also from an investment perspective. So definitely we recognize that that is the case on the Bitcoin side. [00:40:59] Spencer Yang: But I think when you look at the broader proof of work ecosystem and also cryptocurrency ecosystem, there's a lot of other ideas and proposals that are being formed. I think at the end of the day, the [unclear: festival] of innovation is really important because when there's more innovation, there's more people trying new things, then it helps to also increase the assurance and the security of Bitcoin, and also help to increase the consensus around Bitcoin as well, to hey, the mechanism is actually very sound. And I think that's been what happened over the past couple of years. [00:41:31] Spencer Yang: And I think will continue to happen, I think, with everyone's efforts. There's definitely some talk about quantum computing and quantum resistance, I think, in the broader technology space that I think is impactful to do more research on. And I think that could affect Bitcoin as well. There's definitely a lot of talk about how blockchain and Bitcoin rewards for miners is actually reducing. So any innovations, any protocols that supports merge mining, AuxPoW, I think would be beneficial to the Bitcoin miners because it increases the revenue for miners as well. [00:42:04] Spencer Yang: Any innovations for even improving the efficiency of home miners or heating or other alternative sources. There's actually a bathhouse in New York that uses Bitcoin mining to help to heat the sauna in some ways. And I think a lot of these little micro innovations is also important to see and maybe even have some, maybe hypothetically, for example, to validate this. Maybe an entrepreneur, a very crazy idea, an entrepreneur can come up with a bathhouse network that essentially uses a certain type of device that essentially uses bathhouses or whatever as a proof of work, just to experiment. [00:42:41] Spencer Yang: No one is trying to take over Bitcoin with those kinds of efforts. But I think it's just really to increase the efficacy and also discovery of innovation such that we can increase the conversations. I think that's really some of the things just to highlight. And I'm curious as well, Summer and Charles, if you're seeing a lot of other ideas that could come up as well. [00:43:07] Vlad Costea: Yeah. So I also want to ask you about merge mining because you have mentioned it and it's a very interesting topic. Why do you believe that chains today choose to use proof of stake or maybe launch with their own individual mining algorithm as opposed to just becoming merged mine with something which is more established, has its own infrastructure, has its own security model, provides all the primitives for a successful network already. So why do you believe merged mining is not more popular than it is today? [00:43:44] Charles Chong: Yeah. Let me take a step at this. So I think the benefit merge mining offers is to solve the bootstrap problem that I mentioned earlier, which is getting miners involved. If you are just merged mining with, let's say SHA-256, then you do have an existing number of miners that are willing to merge mine it. But I think the downside of merged mining, especially in the early days, is as a miner, when I see someone say, hey, you can merge mine this specific coin, as a miner, I view that as free money. [00:44:17] Charles Chong: I am not familiar with the protocol. I'm not committed to your protocol. I'll just mine it and sell it. So it does create that huge sell pressure for that protocol itself. So unless you do build up some engagement consensus. So I think that's one of the reasons why protocols do not go for merged mining. I think the other piece is also to remember, even if miners are committed to your project and is bullish on your project, do remember that unlike proof of stake, the miners do have external electricity costs that they do have to cover. [00:44:54] Charles Chong: So it does create those additional sell pressure as well. [00:45:01] Spencer Yang: I think there's definitely pros and cons of merged mining versus the other mechanisms. So I think Charles mentioned a few of these really interesting and very important takeaways that I think we've seen play out in the market. Speaking about proof of stake a little bit, I think part of the reason why proof of stake is also extremely popular is because it definitely rewards holders. It rewards holders to essentially lock up their tokens for a period of time. And of course, delegated to certain infrastructure providers to essentially validate. [00:45:36] Spencer Yang: And I think if the network value is actually not significant, then the validators are actually loss-making in that sense. But we've seen actually a lot of validators kind of adopt a hybrid business model, but it's not just about making sure that they're profitable and running these operations from a fees perspective. For example, they charge a 3%, like a 4% validator fee or whatsoever. It's not just that, but they also are potentially investors in network as well. So they have almost like a hybrid way of thinking about things where they're investing in network and also validating. [00:46:03] Spencer Yang: So they're both a holder as well as a service provider of validator services. So I think that model has worked. And because also if you look at all these networks, the developers have a lot more control. So I think the proof of stake networks actually really favors developers. It really favors developers and holders, but it doesn't really favor the pure play validator operators. And also the reason why you see a lot of these validators, whether it's like QuickNode or, sorry, like Figment, Coinbase or whatsoever, they also end up holding and investing in these tokens as well. [00:46:37] Spencer Yang: So it's almost like they have no choice but to do so. And I think that's just the nature of proof of stake networks. And I think that has worked for Ethereum, that has worked for some of these other ones, but there's also a lot of criticism against that model because of that. And if you look at the mining side of things compared to that model, I think a lot of miners, as Charles mentioned earlier, they do not actually need, with merge mining, to believe in your project. [00:47:03] Spencer Yang: They're not forced to have to hold the tokens for the project. So I think that's a pro, but also a con at the same time. Because the bad thing of that, the downside of that is that the developers and the holders feel like they're now antagonistic to the miners. So I think that's the alignment issue that sometimes can happen if you design the mechanism in a really bad way. The other risk that I've seen people sort of do highlight is that, let's say for example, you are a coin that's just launched or a project that's just launched and you are a merge mining mechanism using SHA-256, right? [00:47:35] Spencer Yang: That's a Bitcoin. And hypothetically, if you are only, if 100% of the block rewards are going to merge mined, I think the issue is that if one of the mining pools or the two, or some of the miners integrate with your project and the others don't, then you actually do have centralization to those parties that actually have integrated with you. So the key here is almost like an all or nothing kind of situation where you actually really want your project. A successful merge mining project has to essentially have most of the mining pools and most of the miners to be interested. [00:48:11] Spencer Yang: Otherwise you actually have some level of centralization risk over here. What you mentioned earlier, there's like 51% attack, reorg, if this and so on. And you really don't want that, right? As a developer, as a project founder, which is also the reason why perhaps there's some workarounds and some people have designed innovations around that. [00:48:30] Vlad Costea: I'm happy I hit the nail with this question because it's obviously something that you researched. I'm curious what you think about blind merged mining, which is introduced with BIP 300 and BIP 301, a proposal that's championed by one of the show's sponsors, LayerTwo Labs. They're trying to bring drivechains to Bitcoin. It's a way basically to enable miners to create merge-mined sidechains. So they will be able to provide, for example, Ethereum and Zcash and Namecoin and whatever features on individual sidechains. And at the same time, the miners also collect transaction fees from these chains. [00:49:09] Vlad Costea: And I was wondering if you guys looked into that and what do you think about it? [00:49:16] Spencer Yang: Definitely not the drivechain expert over here, but from what I've understood, there's definitely some pros and cons with the proposal, right? I think that's the two risks that I would just highlight. And I think definitely there's a lot of rewards, as you mentioned. So rewards really come from being able to have a lot more connectivity, a lot more developer environments, a lot more protocols, a lot more ideas back to Bitcoin. I think that's really amazing. And I think the thesis of that is something that I absolutely advocate for, right? [00:49:42] Spencer Yang: That you actually have a lot of these more networks and have Bitcoin as a center and have all of these networks essentially surround itself and provide rewards and have some level of incentive mechanism with Bitcoin. So the idea of it is definitely something that I'm a huge advocate for. There's definitely some risks with these proposals, right? One of the risks could be, you know, miners' software bloat. The software that miners need to run may be bloated, right, because a lot of these things. And I think that can be... [00:50:07] Spencer Yang: That is [unclear: consensus-breaking], that actually requires changing Bitcoin software, Bitcoin Core. I think there's some of these risks over there, right? And obviously there may be updates to the proposal that I haven't seen, that I'm not super sure about. But I think anything that requires Bitcoin miners and the software layer, Bitcoin Core, to change, I think is usually quite controversial. And the community, I think, feels like there may be spam or that unnecessary. So it's definitely a bit of that conversations and controversy over there. The other thing is that the other risk as well is that definitely having interrelations with Bitcoin is very, very helpful. [00:50:48] Spencer Yang: But if we have entire dependence on Bitcoin, that may or may not be a good thing as well. So I'm a little bit unsure about that personally. I haven't, of course, dived into the economic theory of that or a lot of the implications of that. But I think definitely there's some things that we have to consider in terms of like, hey, are we actually having too much dependence such that there's a good effect on the entire system. So, yeah, I think a lot of these things definitely requires a bit more careful, I guess, consideration and also proposals. [00:51:19] Spencer Yang: But I think personally for me, at least, like I definitely think the idea of having a lot more interconnectivity to Bitcoin is awesome. [00:51:30] Vlad Costea: Charles, Summer, do you have any opinions on drivechains? [00:51:41] Charles Chong: No, I'm good. I don't have too much to add over there. [00:51:48] Vlad Costea: It tends to be controversial sometimes, but I do think it's basically the ultimate idea to put everything on Bitcoin. I'm not aware of anything else which is this ambitious in its scope and also tries to solve the miners rewards issue, which I think we're going to see in a few halving cycles. [00:52:10] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I think a lot of Bitcoiners are adequately concerned about the block rewards going to like near zero and essentially having to be sustained by fees. Right. Over the past two years, we've seen a lot of innovations on the utility of Bitcoin block space that has also drove up fees to sometimes even a thousand sats per vB per block. Specifically a few examples, right? One is when people are rushing to mint BRC-20s, ordinals, runes, and so on. And also when people are rushing to get into the cap of Babylon staking, that I saw a Babylon Bitcoin staking protocol for the phase one, cap one, where they had this mechanism and game theory. [00:52:51] Spencer Yang: Basically at the end of the day, the Bitcoin block space is almost like a racetrack or whatsoever. When you design certain goals and games and rules and people want to race on that, then of course you have a race condition. And then there's incentives and there's also fee rate changes and whatnot. I think these are essentially, I mean, this is a design, right? It's permissionless, so anyone is able to do that. And if the participants are not economically incentivized in the long term or mid term, then they will stop doing such activities. [00:53:20] Spencer Yang: So it naturally plays itself out. And I think that's interesting. But I do think that over time there will be a lot more innovations happening. And I think we've seen a lot of companies and projects and protocols already start to be very innovative in how they think about essentially adding value to Bitcoin from block rewards or from fees and so on. So definitely optimistic, but of course we have to have more innovation acceptance as well in the community. [00:53:51] Vlad Costea: What do you think about the ongoing OP_RETURN debate with Bitcoiners disagreeing whether or not they should increase the capacity of the OP_RETURN function, which enables some users to add more data to the Bitcoin blockchain without bloating the UTXO set? [00:54:06] Vlad Costea: Is it bullish for Bitcoin? Is it good for minor rewards or do you think it's just a fad and ultimately we're going to end up with the same empty mempool? [00:54:15] Spencer Yang: Yeah, personally for me, I don't really have a very strong opinion about it just because I think we, I think for myself, I think we are essentially quite neutral in how we look at Bitcoin development. We really want to support all actors. And sometimes that means [unclear: not taking a side], not really having a very strong opinion about some of these issues. I think there is also like a very large group and even in politics, and like in the country politics, there's a very large group of the silent majority. [00:54:47] Spencer Yang: It's actually quite neutral and just kind of want to see more innovation or less innovation at the same time. So I think that's kind of a, but of course the debate online has been very polarizing, right? Between the different camps, you know, with one camp, if I were to recall, I think the debate really started because I think of a presentation that was done at the OP_NEXT event. [00:55:10] Vlad Costea: You know, sometime before that, it was a pull request on the Bitcoin Core GitHub repository. It was forwarded by Peter Todd, but it was on behalf of another core developer named Antoine. And it was about a company that's called Citrea, which is also a sponsor of the show, by the way. And what they're trying to do is basically add data as zero knowledge proofs that they're going to verify against their ZK rollup, which they're building on Bitcoin. And if they had a larger capacity on OP_RETURN, they would be able to put the data without increasing the UTXO set, which is stored in RAM memory, not hard drives. [00:55:50] Vlad Costea: So they made this request to make it, I guess, more lightweight for nodes to take this data. But it reignited like a decade old debate because this debate has been had in 2014 or something with Counterparty and Omni at the time. And I think it went way too far, way too far. It's a nothing burger, mostly. [00:56:17] Spencer Yang: Yeah. I do feel like it's really interesting that people have very strong opinions that they hold very strongly. And that's the case of Bitcoin, right? And I think we've been navigating the Bitcoin space for a while, and we know that this is very important. I think what I do like about this incident, at least, is that people are very passionate about their beliefs, right? Whether it's the OP_RETURN, the pro-OP_RETURN camp or the other camp and so on. I think both sides have valid arguments from their perspective, right? [00:56:50] Spencer Yang: About preserving the status quo versus some of the changes that encourage projects, including Citrea. I think Citrea has mentioned a lot in this particular debate, but it's really like any project, right? You can replace any other project and they could make the same request. So I would say it's just one of those situations where everyone has their point of view. And I think that's really what, coming back a little bit to what the Proof of Work Alliance in general is about as well, right? I think we want to be open to encourage the difference of opinions as well. [00:57:27] Spencer Yang: If members have different opinions on certain issues, I think it's good, right? It just shows that a lot of these discourse can then be published online for people to view, request, and I think form this social consensus, or maybe no social consensus at all, right? And just have it as it is, right? So with the OP_RETURN issue, I'm actually really curious what the outcome is going to be. Because status quo is basically one camp winning, right? And making changes is a difference to the other camp. [00:57:55] Spencer Yang: So I'm really curious what the situation is going to be. [00:58:00] Spencer Yang: What is your prediction, Vlad, between the two [unclear: sides] here? [00:58:05] Vlad Costea: Well, it seems to be like the technical consensus is that it makes no sense to keep the OP_RETURN limit the way that it is right now. Because mining pools are already including full blocks only with inscriptions or any sort of data. Marathon Holdings has their own service, which is called Slipstream, if I'm not mistaken. And they can do this without actually using Bitcoin, without adhering to the rules of the Bitcoin network. So you're not going to be aware that this data is going to get added into blocks anyway. [00:58:43] Vlad Costea: You're just going to see it when it gets added. And in a way, if you're lifting the limit, you're just enabling all the actors to be honest and to publish the data. And then every user can choose for themselves if they want to store that or if they believe it's not something that they want on their node. But I think there's too much, how should I put it? The conversation is too emotional and not rational enough. And I think that Bitcoin has much better goals to accomplish. And the fact that we're getting stuck with this conversation instead of talking about how can we help builders with CTV or CSFS, which is cross function, signature, whatever, is saddening for me because I realize, well, if we can't move the conversation forward to talk about what the builders need from Bitcoin to bring more applications to make it more useful, then I guess we're going to get ossified. [00:59:46] Vlad Costea: And I'm not sure what you think about ossification, but to me, it feels like this technology has not really reached its potential. And if Bitcoin gets ossified, it just means that we're opening the gates for Ethereum to be useful, for Litecoin to be useful. So we're going to have a multi-chain world, even though some people will try to deny this and say, well, they're shitcoins, blah, blah, blah. They're going to be useful because people want to build stuff. [01:00:14] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I can take a step at this one, Vlad. I think I feel the same way in many regards. And I think at the same time, I also have different, I wear different hats, right? So I think at the end of the day, I think it's helpful for us to also define ourselves, not just based on one point of view, right? I think my, that's a very, very strong point of view for me because I've been, the reason why I came into crypto was because of the innovation, because I'm an entrepreneur and I'm also a builder, right? [01:00:38] Spencer Yang: So it really saddens me a little bit when, you know, people feel like Bitcoin should stop innovating. When, you know, people feel like, Hey, nothing should be built on Bitcoin. We should just transfer it between institutions around the world, between governments and so on, and just use it to store all of our pension funds. Right. And then maybe 30 years later, we think about it when we die. Right. I think that saddens me a little bit, if that is the vision for Bitcoin. And I may, I may cry a little bit about it at night, if that is the case. [01:01:03] Spencer Yang: Right. But I think at the same time, maybe that's okay. I would say like a part of me feels like, Hey, if that is the case, perhaps that is what we have achieved as an industry and maybe everything else are just funding games. Right. If that is the case, then maybe that's okay. Right. I think we have created a lasting legacy already. So a part of me is that, okay, I guess that is sad, but it's also okay in some regards, right. But at the same time as an individual or as you know, like if you're building a startup, should you accept that status quo or you accept that fate and not try to innovate at all. [01:01:34] Spencer Yang: I don't think you should accept it. Right. You should also keep trying to build and make meaningful, you know, sort of contributions. Right. And I think that's why, you know, a lot of these debates, whether it's OP_RETURN, CTV and CSFS, or OP_CAT and so on, I think it's interesting in that sense where it creates the opportunity for builders to actually demonstrate what they can do. Right. There's definitely the concerns of the, from a security perspective, which is why I think it's good that the maintainers are being more cautious in how to view this. [01:02:01] Spencer Yang: But at the same time, I think builders, it's also on builders, right, to show the world what can be done with these protocols. And we haven't yet seen some real applications that is very interesting. with OP_RETURN, CTV, CSFS and, you know, OP_CAT and so on. That's very, very good. Right. So I would encourage you actually more builders to build more applications, right. on Signet, on devnet and so on to essentially try it out, right. And show the world what is possible. And, you know, I think if, even when that use cases and a lot of those things happen, then, you know, it's almost inevitable, right. [01:02:28] Spencer Yang: In, in that regard. So that's definitely what I hope to see. Yeah. I think from a Proof of Work Alliance perspective, we definitely have, you know, like set up participants in a network that are, you know, like protocols. And I think these protocols, like fractal specifically on our end for all side or many others, I think they have like the ecosystem of builders, right. So I think it's also on us to try to encourage the builders to try things. We have a lot of these, sort of like implementations and just show the way, right. [01:02:54] Spencer Yang: And if those use cases become very important, then that could add to the conversation. What [unclear: Fractal] and many other builders have done, then it's awesome. Right. So I think that's what I do believe about it. That being said, I would say that there's a lot of other, you know, projects that have just been okay with ossification and innovate around that. That's also possible, right. I would say like, that's definitely not ideal, but it's also possible. I think that's what you mentioned with many other chains, a multi-chain world, right. [01:03:23] Vlad Costea: As miners, what's your opinion on ordinal inscriptions? Because for a while they brought some very high fees on Bitcoin, which I think were beneficial for keeping many of these businesses more profitable. [01:03:41] Charles Chong: Yeah. I think from talking to miners, I think most miners love it. I think it's, it was unexpected. So it wasn't built into their modeling and everything. And so I think most miners loved it. Yeah. I think, I think yeah. [01:03:58] Spencer Yang: [unclear: Your volumes are a little bit lower then.] I guess like if you mentioned, right, like they didn't build into their modeling, right. But after they exploded, I'm sure they will put it into their modeling. Right. So what is the take on the street? Yeah. [01:04:08] Charles Chong: Yeah. I think, I think most miners have been in this game for such a long time. They understood the volatility of it. So I don't think they looked at it in terms of, Hey, this is going to last for more than six months or a year. Again, maybe it will come back, but I think it still hasn't stood the test of time yet. I think one of the stats I saw was the total fees that were paid out from Ordinals was more than $200 million. [01:04:37] Charles Chong: So that's definitely a huge revenue for the miners. [01:04:41] Spencer Yang: Yeah. And that's not including the value of the, some of these projects, right. But I would say the counterpoint to that is also like a lot of the exchanges and the liquidity venues are like not ready for it. So like what we have observed as well is that many times they're almost like resistant to it. Right. And they think that Bitcoin innovation is not real in this regard. Right. And I think in some ways that's also the issue, I think with the, with what we have observed, like the Bitcoin community sometimes is quite anti-spam, you know, anti-altcoins and so on. [01:05:09] Spencer Yang: And I think that has also dampened a little bit of the spirits of innovators in that regard. So it's like a [unclear: double slope], right. And also at the same time, we've seen you know, many of the exchanges don't really want to support Bitcoin protocols, right. Even though there's a very robust set of APIs that's available to support runes, ordinals, BRC-20s and so on. And as a result, like, you know, even like this DOG•GO•TO•THE•MOON on Runes, they essentially bridged their token over to Solana. [01:05:34] Spencer Yang: And then now they're potentially added to the roadmap for Kraken, right. As was recently announced. But I do believe, and please, Kraken, feel free to correct me on this podcast or on tweets or whatever, if you're integrating the Runes standard, right. I don't think they are. I think they're just integrating the Solana standard, which is kind of sad. That Bitcoin innovation has to be on other chains to be listed on these exchanges. [01:06:01] Vlad Costea: It was the same, I think, four years ago during the NFT mania, when all of these assets that were historical and created on Bitcoin, they had to be tokenized and wrapped on Ethereum to be sold on OpenSea, because that's where the liquidity was. It wasn't the Bitcoiners who were paying for it. It was the Ethereum people who had the money to pay for this stuff. So, yeah, it's a bit unfortunate that the infrastructure that's being built for these markets is not always happening on Bitcoin. Also with Polymarket, it's a bit saddening because prediction markets have been such a big talking point in Bitcoin for a decade. [01:06:37] Vlad Costea: And now it's happening on Ethereum. [01:06:42] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I think in some ways, maybe the origin or the originator of the ideas doesn't have to be the one you actually bring into practice. Sometimes that happens, right. It's like sometimes a lot of ideas are stuck in the research circles and then it takes a company like Google or whatever to implement. But I really don't like that reference. I really don't think Bitcoin is like the citadel of just like nothing gets done. I really don't think that's the intention as well. [01:07:09] Vlad Costea: I took a look at gas fees right now and on Ethereum it's 61 cents to send USDT. On Tron it's $7.51 to send USDT. And the Bitcoin fees right now are 31 cents. And the networks that I mentioned are proof of stake. They don't contribute to any proof of work company as far as I'm aware. They're not supporting innovation in the field of proof of work. And it's a bit, how should I put it, feels defeating when you realize that people are willing to pay $7 to send a transaction on Tron, but they don't value Bitcoin block space as much and they don't want to make transactions. [01:07:50] Vlad Costea: And do you believe this is detrimental to the adoption of Bitcoin and to proof of work in general? Or do you believe it's just a phase and it's going to change? [01:08:02] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I do have some like loose opinions about like some weak opinions about stablecoins in general, right. I think for me, my point of view is that I think stablecoins were started really as just a necessary part of the Bitcoin community because of the unfriendliness of banks, right, towards Bitcoin. So a lot of people, a lot of Bitcoiners used USDT back in the day that was on Omni, which is essentially like a Bitcoin layer two, right. Maybe they wanted the earlier Bitcoin layer to essentially send USDT to each other and it's verified. [01:08:35] Spencer Yang: So I think over the last couple of years, we've seen that to really change quite a little bit where maybe like as banks become more open to crypto and so on, USDT just became more of a, almost like a financial settlement kind of layer. And definitely there's a lot of innovations happening at the stablecoin layer, right. But I think like, I actually see no reason why Bitcoin network shouldn't have stablecoins on it, right. We've seen some recent advancements where like Tether announced that they wanted to do Taproot Assets support with Lightning and whatnot. [01:09:06] Spencer Yang: And technically speaking, even if Tether were to, or like USDC were to actually launch a version of their token on like BRC-20 standard or Runes standard today, they're actually able to. There is a mint and burn mechanism in BRC-20 that allows them to actually mint stablecoins. And so, and if you think about it, if that's the case, if the current [unclear: typical vB fee] is like 30 cents, then that actually means that if they actually do that, someone's sending, if I were to send stablecoin to you on Bitcoin network, it's actually faster and cheaper. [01:09:40] Spencer Yang: Maybe it's not faster, but it's definitely cheaper than on Tron. So maybe that should be a choice that we should be giving to users, right. Yeah, but that's one part of it. And the other part is I think we'll see what happens in the US when it comes to the GENIUS Act, whether the regulation is actually good or not for stablecoins, because that actually helps to create a more of a framework. And in some ways I prefer always low or light regulation and have the entrepreneurs and the builders kind of dictate what it is. [01:10:08] Spencer Yang: But at the same time, I also do understand the hesitancy of some of the banks when it comes to, you know, the stablecoin side of things. So, you know, maybe that actually helps them to accept, you know, a lot of these payments a little bit more. So overall, you know, I do think first of all, that Bitcoin should have stablecoins on it, right. And I think it's possible and it's already here. It's just whether or not these providers are investing the time and infrastructure to do so. [01:10:33] Spencer Yang: And number two, I definitely think that stablecoins are. In the past, it's almost like a necessity. But these days, the necessity is a bit different, right? It's more about the relationships with traditional finance. It's more important. [01:10:49] Vlad Costea: I want to ask each one of you how you're celebrating pizza day. And I have this box here. It's an important Bitcoin moment when Laszlo Hanyecz, 15 years ago, he sold 10,000 Bitcoin for two pizzas. But before that, please allow me to plug the rest of the sponsors that I haven't mentioned as much. So I have been telling you for months that when you get paid in stablecoins, it's a good idea to use SideShift to convert that to Bitcoin or free market money. If you did that today, we're at an all time high of $111,111 USD, 111,111. [01:11:26] Vlad Costea: So if you have been doing that, I guess I was right. If you do believe that this is the top, you can also use SideShift for converting BTC back to USDT if you're into that. I'm not going to judge if you're a bear, but I do believe we're going to go higher from here. So check out SideShift.ai for these swaps without registration. There is also Hodling.ch, which specializes in self-custody. So if you want to learn more about how to set up your multisig because you have a lot of Bitcoin or because you're part of a company that's going to acquire Bitcoin, go to Hodling.ch and access their consultancy for self-custody. [01:12:09] Vlad Costea: I think that's the best way to put it. There's also NoOnes.com, which is a peer-to-peer marketplace for the global south. They have a lot of users from Africa and the Middle East. And the CEO, Ray Youssef, believes in this vision of bringing adoption where it really makes a difference. So if you do want to provide some liquidity to these markets, check out NoOnes.com. And last but not least, Bitcoin.com News, which right now Bitcoin.com used to be green. They used to be for Bitcoin Cash. [01:12:39] Vlad Costea: Now they did this U-turn. They're BTC only. They changed their logo. It's orange. They have news that is only about BTC. They understand the difference between BTC and BCH. It's really a miracle. Seven years ago you would not believe that this was going to happen. And they have pretty good news articles. And it was my idea to promote them because it seems like they're on the good side of history now. So check out Bitcoin.com News. They have some good journalism. And now I'm going to start with Summer because she's the shyest one who has spoken the least during this interview. [01:13:15] Vlad Costea: Tell us more about how you're celebrating pizza day. [01:13:23] Vlad Costea: You're muted. [01:13:28] Summer Meng: Sorry, I always forget that. So I think we are going to order a pizza for sure. And if we can tip the delivery guy in sats, that will be amazing. And then also [unclear: explain] to a friend about what Bitcoin really stands for. That's our plan for today. How to celebrate it. I like your t-shirt with the pizza. [01:13:48] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I actually got this from a French fashion house. It's called [unclear: Maison Lachie]. They're making fashion for nerds. And yeah, I didn't pay for this, but it's like 600 euro. But they basically sent it to me to wear it. Nice. [01:14:06] Spencer Yang: That is the best t-shirt for today. Yeah, I'm not sure if it's a long sleeve t-shirt or a t-shirt, but it looks amazing. [01:14:13] Vlad Costea: It's a good excuse, you know, to wear this. I usually don't have a proper occasion for it. I just wear it. But today it's a proper justification. So how do you guys celebrate pizza day? [01:14:27] Spencer Yang: Yeah, on our end, you know, I've just eaten a pizza in under, I think, two minutes. I took a stab at the New York pizza because I'm in New York right now. And so I got this like one dollar pizza that's like massive. And then I did a video of myself doing that. And then on the Fractal Bitcoin side, we have this like one minute pizza challenge, where anyone is invited to submit a video, you know, like tweet at us, you know, because we have a tweet, you know, just like a retweet or reply to the tweet with like a one minute video of [unclear: yourself eating] pizza. [01:14:58] Spencer Yang: So a lot of our friends and our team members actually has done that recently from all across the world. So it's really nice to see. [01:15:06] Charles Chong: So that's what I did as well. So a one minute pizza challenge to see how much we can eat in a minute. I know Spencer got a two minute exception, but yeah, it's supposed to be a one minute challenge. [01:15:19] Vlad Costea: Yeah, take that, Saifedean. [01:15:21] Vlad Costea: Saifedean is this guy who advocates for only eating steak. And today we're eating pizza, so we're not sorry for it. [01:15:35] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I think it's worth celebrating, right? The industry deserves to celebrate. You know, we've been [unclear: beaten a little bit] here and there as an industry. A lot of people. And I think the coordination layer is definitely difficult to navigate. But I think it's moments like these that helps to remind us why we're here. Right. And I think that's pretty awesome. [01:15:53] Vlad Costea: Yeah. There's someone in the chat who asked about the Fractal Bitcoin token. They want to know about the team. What do you think about the price action of your coin since launch? Do you have any comment on that? [01:16:11] Spencer Yang: In general, I don't really comment on price itself. Right. But I think specifically, you know, when it comes to launching any projects in the space, you know, even like Bitcoin, right, it's going to be a volatility. Volatility is definitely something that is, you know, it's a feature. It's not really a bug. It's really a feature. And I think at the end of the day, it's really down to demand and supply. So usually when demand is higher, you know, like, you know, even when projects, especially proof of work projects. [01:16:37] Spencer Yang: But when they launch initially, the demand is very, very high at the beginning. Right. And that actually changes and creates a sort of this artificial price level that is very, very high. Because the initial supply of proof of work networks is a lot lower at the beginning. And then over time, it actually becomes a lot more stable. Right. So even for Bitcoin itself, right. You know, like when you first started, there was a relatively low awareness at the beginning. So the demand was not like, you know, like a hundred million people buying Bitcoin. [01:17:05] Spencer Yang: Right. If that is the case, I think Bitcoin would have started maybe at a million dollars instead of at what it was. But I think over time, you know, as attention and as adoption goes, that's awesome. So I think that's also a challenge for our proof of work projects where the initial demand might be too high. Right now, in the crypto ecosystem, I think maybe one of the issues to address as well is that a lot of the projects are essentially tailored for the proof of stake networks. [01:17:32] Spencer Yang: Right. Where initial demand is actually going to be a lot higher. And then they are able, because the project somehow has very high control of the supply of the tokens, they are able to then release a lot more of the supply into the market and then manage the price levels. Right. I think that's not a benefit of something that proof of work projects have. So that's something that I think we should also maybe do a bit more research as an alliance for, to understand better on how, you know, maybe there's ways for the ecosystem to have better price discovery around proof of work projects as well. [01:18:07] Spencer Yang: Yeah, definitely work to do there. [01:18:11] Vlad Costea: There's also Bcash in the chat and he says, where's the Bcash representation? [01:18:19] Spencer Yang: Yeah, I think like what Charles mentioned earlier, the Proof of Work Alliance is definitely an alliance that every ecosystem provider is welcome to participate in. So yeah, anyone can apply on the website and then the founding members and also the team members will then review and also, you know, engage accordingly. [01:18:41] Charles Chong: Yeah, I'll do a plug here. Our website is www.powalliance.com. [01:18:47] Vlad Costea: I was going to ask you about that, but before I got to mention that XMRE said "need some keto carnivore pizza for all of the maxis." But I want to ask each one of you, where can people find you and follow your projects? [01:19:05] Spencer Yang: So you want to go first? [01:19:13] Summer Meng: So you can follow me on Twitter. My Twitter is SummerMeng21. And also you can follow me on LinkedIn. You can find me by Summer Meng also. [01:19:25] Spencer Yang: I got to ask why 21? Is it because of the 21 million of Bitcoin? [01:19:33] Summer Meng: Yes, yes, yes. But I just mentioned it at the very beginning. Yes, it is. [01:19:40] Vlad Costea: I don't think that was recorded, but yeah, it's useful to know. And it's SummerMeng, M-E-N-G, right? Yes, yes, yes. [01:19:50] Spencer Yang: Awesome. Yeah, you can find me on Twitter at Spencer Yang and also on Twitter at Fractal Bitcoin and also at Blockspace Force. So, you know, I don't think we talk about Blockspace Force much, but essentially we are just a small family office, you know, for the partners. And really, our goal is really to work on anything that is Bitcoin and Proof-of-Work related and be very, very helpful to the industry in the long term. [01:20:21] Charles Chong: For me, I'm part of the Fractal and Blockspace Force team. You can find me on Twitter, Charles Chong. [01:20:27] Vlad Costea: OK, thank you very much. We agreed for one hour. I guess we went for a bit longer. I appreciate your time. I appreciate your dedication. Good luck with the Proof of Work Alliance. I look forward to your announcements to see what's new in the space. Once again, it's exciting that Proof-of-Work is getting more love in an industry that seems to shift away from it. And what else? If you have been listening up to this point, type P-O-W-A in the comments and that's how we're going to know that you have been listening to all of this interview. [01:21:05] Vlad Costea: It's like a secret code for the listeners. Just in case. I don't know. I'm just testing to see who's listening to this. And thank you very much. I'll see you in the next one. And thanks to the sponsors once again. NoOnes.com, Hodling.ch, SideShift.ai, Citrea.xyz, Bitcoin.com News and LayerTwo Labs. Bye and I'll see you next week. Thank you. Thank you.