Title: S16 E40: Cory Klippsten on Bitcoin Culture & Maximalism Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Cory Klippsten (CEO of Swan Bitcoin; strategic and marketing adviser to the Sequans BTC treasury company) Published: 2025-08-22 (two-part episode: Part 1 recorded live and streamed on YouTube on 2025-08-18, Part 2 a few days later; both parts are in this audio file, Part 2 starts at about 01:01:52) Duration: 2:22:21 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2025-08-22_s16_e40_cory_klippsten_on_bitcoin_culture_maximalism.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2025-08-22_s16_e40_cory_klippsten_on_bitcoin_culture_maximalism.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with speaker diarization (Guest A -> Cory Klippsten). Reconciled with a word-level diff against the YouTube auto-captions of the two livestream parts (zcash-documentary S16E40p1/p2 .en.vtt, aligned at about -16 s for Part 1 and +1:00:40 for Part 2), with the bitcoin-forks-research S16E40 tiny.en transcript and the two findings/S16E40.md notes as third opinions. About 110 disagreements on names, words or speaker turns were re-checked against the audio with short local faster-whisper small.en clip re-transcriptions (the live pipeline was diarizing S16E39 at the same time, so no larger model was loaded). Speaker turns were verified with a local TitaNet speaker-embedding scan (Vlad vs Cory reference voices, 0.5 s hops) over about 55 doubtful stretches. That repaired the many quick back-and-forth exchanges that diarization had merged or split a few words late: "Love it", the Breedlove / Natalie Brunell plugs, the "Would you rather own 3,000 plus Bitcoins" exchange, the EOS / Block.one vs Strategy debate (including Vlad's dropped "to buy 140,000 Bitcoin and then establish a treasury" and his "No, I don't" and "It's not zero, they're still top 100" lines), the Litecoin Foundation / Bitcoin Foundation exchange, the pinned-tweet exchange, "100%, it's pretty niche", "Yep, exactly", "33", "Vlad's face" (was "block space"), the ASCII pronunciation, "mine your own coins" (Vlad's, was "wind" and given to Cory), BitInstant / Charlie Shrem, Tim Ferriss, the Bryan Johnson / AC/DC / Peter Thiel longevity banter, "Growing", the wrap-up and the goodbyes. An ASR repetition at 02:01:21 (Cory's "So if you're scamming and you have false marketing promises" repeated) was replaced with what the audio says ("So I have an idea, by the way, for you..."). The dropped "Hello there and welcome to" openings of both parts were restored. Names and jargon were checked against the title, the feed.xml show notes and keywords, the S17E34 Cory Klippsten final, and the web: Cory Klippsten (Vlad's on-air pronunciation attempts "Klippsten, or Klipstein" kept as spoken), Swan Bitcoin / Swan Vault / Swan private clients / Bitcoiner Jobs / Bitlist.com / Specter (Specter Solutions, Moritz Wietersheim) / Vijay Boyapati / Rearden Code / Coincover / BitGo, Yan Pritzker (Inventing Bitcoin), Citizen Bitcoin, Stefan Livera, Robert Breedlove (What Is Money, the Saylor series), Natalie Brunell (Hard Money), Give Bitcoin, Do Kwon / Luna / UST / Anchor Protocol, Alex Mashinsky / Celsius, Sam Bankman-Fried, BlockFi / Voyager, Jim Cramer, "scambling", SideShift.ai, Andreessen / Chris Dixon / Union Square Ventures / Kik and the Kin token, BlockCon, Jimmy Song (his and Tone Vays' show), Sequans (S-E-Q-U-A-N-S) / Wes Cummins / Applied Digital / Qualcomm, leveraged Bitcoin equities (LBEs) / mNAV / PIPE / Nakamoto (KDLY) / Pompliano's ProCap / Jeff Park / Capital B / Metaplanet / Smarter Web / Empery Digital (Volcon, Ryan Lane), EOS / Block.one / Bullish, Strategy / MicroStrategy / MSTR and the Stride, Strife, Stretch and Strike preferreds, Michael Saylor, Joe Lubin / Ethereum Foundation / ConsenSys, Dan Loeb / Citron Research (heard as "Citrix"), Charlie Lee / Litecoin Foundation, OP_CAT / OP_RETURN / opcodes, Gresham's law, Braintree / Venmo / First Data / Chase Paymentech, NoOnes / Ray Youssef, Bitcoin.com News, Paul Sztorc / drivechains / BIP 300 and 301 / LayerTwo Labs / Signet / Namecoin, Citrea / Alpen / ZK rollups, Ark / Ark Labs / Arkade / Tiero / BitVM / Robin Linus / Burak, Kaspa / Yonatan Sompolinsky, Vitalik Buterin, Samson Mow, Counterparty / Mastercoin / Omni / Tether / Peter Todd / BitShares / NXT, Bitcoin Knots / Jameson Lopp / Giacomo Zucco / Adam Back, ordinals and stamps, Len Sassaman / Dan Kaminsky, Uniswap, Allen Farrington and Big Al (Only the Strong Survive), The Rise and Rise of Bitcoin / Daniel Mross / Mike Caldwell / Casascius coins / Gavin Andresen / Nick Spanos / Mark Karpeles / Eric Voorhees / PorcFest / Winklevii, Nick Szabo / Naval / Tim Ferriss / Unenumerated / God protocols, Larry Fink / WEF / Milei, DeaterBob ("Awyee", @GHOSTawyeeBOB) / American HODL / Hodlonaut / Citadel21, FOMO21 / Neil Jacobs, BTCheads, BLOCKv / Reeve Collins / Craig Sellars / Eric (Pulier), CryptoGlobe, Bryan Johnson, Peter Thiel, Max Keiser, River / Unchained / Fold / Strike / Casa / Fidelity / Cash App / Lightspark, Lyn Alden, Udi Wertheimer. Kept as heard by every pass: "my first prick in the crypto bubble" and "Thanks, Bob" (marked unclear). Light clean verbatim; intro music omitted. Remaining doubtful words are marked [unclear: ...]. ================================================================================ [00:00:50] Vlad Costea: Hello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 40, and we are live with Cory Klippsten. Klippsten, or Klipstein. Klippsten, yeah. Klippsten. Klippsten. It's not easy for me to pronounce. It's quite a mouthful. And you are the CEO of Swan and also an advisor to some BTCs, which are not bitcoins, but Bitcoin treasury companies. And we are here to discuss Bitcoin maximalism. [00:01:16] Cory Klippsten: Love it. It's great to be here, Vlad. It's great to see you. Been obviously a fan and occasional sparring partner with you over the years and a big fan of the show and glad to be here. [00:01:28] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's a lot of fun because I think your company, so I'm going to start with the good side of it, and then I'm going to dive into the bad side, which is the reason of our sparring. So I do appreciate the fact that you spent a lot of money to promote self-custody. And Swan Bitcoin has provided a lot of education, even made the book of your co-founder Yan Pritzker available for free on your website. And people could read that. And I also appreciated that you were supporting podcasters very early on, like you were one of the first CEOs to see value in people creating content about Bitcoin. [00:02:08] Vlad Costea: And I guess Citizen Bitcoin got elevated because of it. It was also Stefan Livera. And maybe there are others, but I don't remember their names. [00:02:17] Cory Klippsten: Don't forget Breedlove. We produced What Is Money for the first year, including the Saylor series. [00:02:23] Vlad Costea: Oh, man, I would rather forget that one. [00:02:28] Cory Klippsten: Don't forget Natalie Brunell. We did the first two years of Natalie's show, Hard Money. [00:02:35] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and honestly, I don't know exactly how you managed to convince people to buy Bitcoin from you when they could get it much cheaper from Kraken or Coinbase or whatever. I mean, they could get more satoshis for their dollar. [00:02:52] Cory Klippsten: You know, it's interesting. A lot of those, first of all, if you're in the apps for any of those, you're going to get destroyed. And Swan was always way cheaper than those. And you have to remember when we launched Give Bitcoin, which was the very first product in 2019, we were at 1% and all the apps were at like 2% or 3% and had egregious spreads. And so people just started, this was the genesis of Swan was in November, December, the vast majority of the volume of the gifting was people buying for themselves because it was better fees than they could get anywhere else. [00:03:23] Cory Klippsten: And then, you know, I think just people want a noise-free experience and they don't want to, you know, log into Coinbase or Binance and have Bitcoin be the 14th thing listed on the homepage and have all these scams promoted all the time. And so where I think you really win is, you know, people that want to obviously support Bitcoin financial services and Bitcoin only education, but you also have a lot of people that just don't want to deal with the noise. And then you have to also remember, like we've always skewed very kind of high net worth. [00:03:54] Cory Klippsten: And so it's people that actually want to talk a lot about Bitcoin as they think about how much to buy. So it's not as much for people that are just doing, you know, $20 buys or $100 buys or something. This is people buying hundreds of thousands of dollars or millions of dollars worth of Bitcoin. And, you know, the story we always hear from our Swan private reps is like 90, 95% of their calls are just about Bitcoin. You know, it's not about our products and services. [00:04:17] Cory Klippsten: It's mostly people wanting to ask the questions that they have, which of course they'd have to do 40 hours of podcasts a week in their ear to get all of their answers. They'd have to listen to everything, but if they have somebody they can actually talk to and just hit the, you know, the two or three or 10 questions that they have, they have a Bitcoin guy or a Bitcoin gal that they can actually talk to. And then the customer service team is insane. I mean, these are people that have been in Bitcoin, you know, six years, 10 years, 12 years. [00:04:42] Cory Klippsten: And so they actually know all the cold wallets and they go through like ridiculous troubleshooting and saving people's coins and stopping people from getting scammed. So like, I think a big part of, you know, moving to your store of value, being a bearer asset, that's something that people aren't used to when we used to always just kind of trust companies to hold our shit for us. You want to know that somebody has your back. And so that's, you know, what Swan provides. [00:05:07] Vlad Costea: Right. So let's backtrack a bit and go to the fact that you mentioned that you wanted to keep people away from scams. What is a scam? [00:05:17] Cory Klippsten: I mean, it's something that misrepresents what it's actually selling. So I think that's probably the cleanest definition. And I've, I've talked about this a million different ways, but you know, I don't, obviously when I went really hard at crypto scams and like, you know, 2020 to 23, let's say, which is when it was actually important to do so it's not as important anymore since the launch of the ETFs and now mainstream media and regulators and finance basically separate Bitcoin from non Bitcoin crypto. So it's just, it's kind of the last battle at this point, but for that four or five year stretch, you know, when we launched, there was very little Bitcoin signal. [00:05:55] Cory Klippsten: It was, it was a subset of crypto and all the noise was coming from the VCs with a hundred billion dollars of venture capital marketing for altcoin scams, lying about Bitcoin, trying to promote their coins or their tokens or whatever. And it sucks people in and makes them waste years before they get to, you know, basically either a Bitcoin only or a Bitcoin dominant strategy. And so that really was the opportunity was that it really filled a void in the market. And as you know, you know, we were kind of first with the most on that message and now there's like a massive industry on that, but we were there first. [00:06:27] Cory Klippsten: And so I think that really was kind of the Genesis and what carried us forward and made us a pretty big company in those first few years. [00:06:35] Vlad Costea: Right. But I want some more specific like, can you present examples of scams? I know that you busted Celsius, which is a company that was obviously running shady stuff in the background. And— [00:06:48] Cory Klippsten: Well, so this is one way to — and maybe this is bringing it home. So when I, when I spent a lot of time on that in the last, you know, shitcoin bubble what was interesting is a lot of people thought I would just be like shitcoin PI, like shitcoin private investigator, and would send me scams all the time in my DMs. But I didn't care at all, unless it actually directly affected Bitcoin. You can't go attacking like every scam all over the world all the time. [00:07:13] Cory Klippsten: Like nobody has time for that. But if somebody was specifically doing something contrary to Bitcoin, like, so it started with Luna and started with Do Kwon and his Bitcoin treasury. And it started with him, you know, duping some of the dumber Bitcoin influencers into having him on their pod and them saying like, you know, Luna and Bitcoin hand in hand, and it's great shitcoins are going to have Bitcoin treasuries. And it was like, you look at this thing and it only took me, you know, 45 minutes on a Friday night in March of 2022 to dig in enough to see that this was actually a real Ponzi scheme. [00:07:43] Cory Klippsten: It actually was going to come collapse and go to zero. And I put that out. I think if I recall, it was March 24th of 2022 that I said, Luna and UST are both going to zero and it's inevitable, obviously went bankrupt less than two months later. You know, but that was because it was specifically talking about Bitcoin and I didn't have Mashinsky in my sights. Like I knew about him. I knew he was kind of a scumbag and he was lying and using, you know, the, using the lingo or the definitions of the banking industry and saying, you know, deposits and, you know, banks don't have your best interest. [00:08:14] Cory Klippsten: Give, give me your coins instead and all this kind of stuff. And, you know, just all kinds of lies about everything basically all the time, but I didn't care until it directly affected Bitcoin. But when he started coming out right in the wake of the Luna collapse, so it was that, what was that May 12th, 13th, 14th, he started going on YouTube and it started showing up on Twitter. And he was saying that Bitcoiners are responsible for 30% of coins being lost and you should instead send your coins to Celsius because I'll keep them safe for you. [00:08:45] Cory Klippsten: That cued to me, which was by the way, right on the back of him, you know, he thought he was bragging, but in my view, he was admitting that they had just escaped with $500 million of user assets and pulled it out of Anchor Protocol, which was the other half of the Luna Ponzi over the weekend, right before Luna went belly up. And it's like, you are way out on the risk curve in an actual Ponzi that even I, who am not like a crypto guy, like I was able to divine without even being in that industry, that this was a real Ponzi scheme two months ago, how do you have half a billion dollars of your users assets in an actual Ponzi scheme, like you scumbag. [00:09:21] Cory Klippsten: And so it was very obvious to me that he was sucking up Bitcoin deposits specifically to fill a hole. Like he didn't actually have, he didn't actually have the user assets that he claimed and that's why he was trying to recruit coins. So then it went hard at him. And that kind of just directly rolled into, you know, into June, which is when Jim Cramer and a bunch of other dummies from TradFi were calling Sam Bankman-Fried the JPMorgan of crypto. And do you remember when in June, July, he was making bids for the failed CeFi lenders and was trying to buy them out. [00:09:50] Cory Klippsten: And all I needed to know to know he was full of shit is that didn't make sense. All you need to know is that Voyager had, you know negative equity and negative brand equity. So BlockFi, Voyager, Celsius, the companies he was trying to buy clearly had less than zero value and he was offering hundreds of millions for them, which meant he had something to hide or some other weird reason to be doing that. And so you should call bullshit on that. And so that's when I started tweeting out basically every day, don't trust Sam Bankman-Fried and then started making up nicknames and calling. [00:10:22] Cory Klippsten: Well, it was Don't Kwon, [unclear: Mascamsky] and Scam Bankster-Fraud was the nickname that I gave him, but those were really the big three that I spent a lot of time on in 2022. I don't really care that much about the definition of a scam if it doesn't like directly affect Bitcoin. And I don't think many people spend a lot of time on, you know, MoonDog, Elon, CumRocket coins. If they're Bitcoiners like it just doesn't really matter. Those are little pump-and-dump schemes and you know, they suck and it's not quite gambling and it's not quite a full scam. [00:10:57] Cory Klippsten: What I'll tell you, and I put this out interestingly, I published the definition of a new portmanteau, which is a combination of two words that makes a new word actually on election day, I made up a new word called scambling, which is combination of scamming and gambling. And then I held off actually had written a post about it kind of explained what actually means and why it's relevant. I held off and then actually posted it on inauguration day. At the beginning of this year and kind of explaining this era that we're in and basically the difference. [00:11:26] Cory Klippsten: And so this has been the defense of the crypto people for a long time is that, Hey, humans are going to gamble and it's just like casinos, but it's not when you're in casino, it's regulated and you know what the house's take is, you know, on certain games, it's about even on certain games, it's 2% certain games, it might be 6%, but if it's opaque, what the split of the pie is and the insiders know things that you don't and it, and they're not telling you what the game is. [00:11:51] Cory Klippsten: A lot of these crypto scams, these pump and dump schemes are actually, you know, the house, the insiders, the VCs and the founders, and kind of the early pump groups at the inner circle of these Telegram groups, Signal groups, WhatsApp chats, whatever, you know, they're taking 50%, 80%, 90% of the upside. And so you might think that you're just gambling and having fun and, you know, playing the numbers or betting on sports or whatever, but you're not, you're actually playing like a dramatically negative sum game. [00:12:19] Vlad Costea: Right, here's a piece of Bitcoin Takeover Podcast lore back in 2019, after I had launched the first season of the show, I went to a conference in Paris, where I met Alex Mashinsky at the time he was fresh off of, no, it was like a couple of years after his ICO. But anyway, he had a lot of money, you could tell that he had a large booth and he was saying, you know, you should put your coins on Celsius and you're gonna earn like 10% a year or whatever he was promising. [00:12:48] Vlad Costea: And he came up to me and he said, you know, I really enjoy your podcast. And I was like, really? Like, are you aware of that? And he said, Yeah, of course, if you ever need money, or you need anything, just come to me. And basically, that was the first offer I ever got for podcast sponsorship from Alex Mashinsky was the CEO of Celsius. The reason why I never went back to him was that I could never so I didn't know it runs like a Ponzi scheme, I had no idea that they're not liquid. [00:13:14] Vlad Costea: All I knew was that it goes against what I promote with my podcast, which is self-custody. And I was like, this sort of defeats the purpose. So I'm just gonna pass on it. And just maybe better offers will come along. And speaking of, SideShift.ai is the place where you can swap your stablecoins for BTC. So if someone offers to pay in stablecoins, and you don't want to hold on to that, because it's a bull market, you just send out an address from SideShift, and you put your BTC address there. [00:13:42] Vlad Costea: And there's gonna be a swap that sends your BTC directly to your self-custody address. Check it out today at SideShift.ai. And also, I don't think they're available in the US. But I guess you know how to use a VPN, not financial advice or anything. But anyway, moving on. [00:14:02] Cory Klippsten: That's a crazy story. So interestingly, I met Mashinsky in person, the exact same day that I got my first prick in the crypto bubble. I don't know if you know my story, but I had been in Silicon Valley for a long time, basically in that ecosystem, just advising and advising startups, cutting angel checks, stuff like that. And I got interested in Bitcoin and crypto with the big price run up in the spring of 2017. I think I bought my first Bitcoins in May of 17 or something like that. [00:14:38] Cory Klippsten: And but my entire professional network, including very credible people, right. I'm like, you know, had always been going to Andreessen events and, you know, reading their blogs. And I thought Chris Dixon was a genius and all this stuff. And so, and Union Square Ventures, which was, you know, big in Coinbase, and they were doing all these [unclear: friction] tokens, and I think they had the Kik— was it Kik and Kin? Do you remember, there's like a failed social network that launched a token, I think it was Kik, and they had the Kin token. [00:15:04] Cory Klippsten: So they did a big ICO. And then also you're in LA and like, it's just a kind of crypto, crypto, crypto, very little Bitcoin. And so it wasn't until it was, it was called BlockCon and it was at the air museum at the Santa Monica airport. And that was when I met Jimmy Song for the first time. And it was the first time I'd actually met a Bitcoiner. I had only been around crypto people from May through, I think it was like October 30th or 31st or something in 2017. [00:15:35] Cory Klippsten: And that was the, and it was really interesting cause I saw this one person who was basically just looking around at everybody else at the conference with complete disgust. Like you could just tell on his face that he kind of hated everybody. And I found that attractive. So I went and talked to him and got to know a little bit about his perspective. And that's when I found his and Tone's show and started watching YouTube here and there. And that was my winter of actually learning about Bitcoin and watching everything from Andreas and starting to find the few Bitcoin podcasts that were out back then. [00:16:05] Cory Klippsten: And it wasn't until it was probably like March of 2018 when I was like, Oh, okay. Bitcoin is the only thing that matters here. [00:16:14] Vlad Costea: At the time when you met him, was Jimmy Song wearing the hat or was it before the hat era? [00:16:19] Cory Klippsten: Yeah. He had a cowboy hat on. [00:16:23] Vlad Costea: Yeah. People say that he was much nicer before the hat era. [00:16:29] Cory Klippsten: So yeah, I met Mashinsky that day and I think he gave a pitch for his ICO cause he was still selling it and he just made my skin crawl. I just, I knew I didn't like him from that moment, but I didn't think about him again until the blow up started happening in early 22. I didn't like, I wasn't tracking them. [00:16:47] Vlad Costea: But let me ask you this and maybe that it's too personal or too early to ask this question, but there's this Bitcoin treasury management company that's called Sequans, S-E-Q-U-A-N-S, which bought 3,000 BTC in July, which was last month. And they're the 22nd largest publicly traded corporate Bitcoin holder. Basically what happened is that they announced that they will be buying BTC. Their stock went up like three, four times. And then it was like the classic pump and dump pattern right now. [00:17:20] Vlad Costea: The stock price is even lower than before they started buying BTC. And I got to ask you, how is this any different from a basic shitcoin, a pump and dump? [00:17:31] Cory Klippsten: Well, would you rather own 3,000 plus Bitcoins or not? [00:17:36] Vlad Costea: Oh, yeah. [00:17:38] Cory Klippsten: Okay. So I would too. So, I mean that now is like the floor for the valuation of that company. You know, the dynamics of these, and this is, this is something that we'll see. We'll see what happens as some of these other companies that were started like that, whether it was an existing company like Sequans, which, you know, at one point had a billion dollar valuation and very promising IP. And they sold a bunch of IP last year, I think for $200 or $300 million to Qualcomm, you know, so basically like there's a, there's an operating business there still, and they were still sitting on, you know, $50 million of cash, but their market cap was like 50 million. [00:18:14] Cory Klippsten: So basically the market is valuing the business at essentially the cash value. And so basically one of their board members is a guy named Wes Cummins, who's the CEO of Applied Digital, which has been in and out of Bitcoin mining for a long time. They still have some Bitcoin mining though. They're mostly AI HPC at this point, but he's a big Bitcoin believer. And so he got in the ear of the CEO and the board and convinced them to try this. And basically like it was either, you know, basically return the cash or just kind of like sell it off and shut it down. [00:18:43] Cory Klippsten: But one of the keys to the long-term health of a Bitcoin treasury company is actually having at least a small operating business like MicroStrategy does. One, because there are quite a few indices and funds that require you to have an operating business if you're going to be included, which means passive flows over the years to come. And then the other one is you actually get a better credit rating because you at least have some cash flow and some cash on hand to be able to service some of the debt, which is a big point. [00:19:10] Cory Klippsten: Like these, these things, I don't call them — the acronym BTC is already taken — which, you know, you may or may not know that I call them leveraged Bitcoin equities, or LBEs, even though Saylor and his squad and some of the others try to stay away from the word leverage. In my view, the only advantage over the long-term that a company has over an individual is the fact that it can access cheap credit. And so you can actually use leverage in a fairly responsible way, and you can access capital markets, your weighted average cost of capital to raise money for a decent sized public company, like North of a billion dollars or something on one of the major New York, you know, New York stock exchange or NASDAQ, your weighted average cost of capital is going to be like 12 to 15%. [00:19:50] Cory Klippsten: And if Bitcoin's CAGR is higher than that over time, that presents an arbitrage. So that's really all that's going on here, is you're basically playing something out over the next, you know, five to 15, 20 years or something like that. And buying, you know, borrowing cheap and buying the hardest asset known to man with it. As far as our relationship with Sequans, we're basically like the strategic and marketing advisor. We also do the, you know, advise on the custody and security and liquidity. So all the purchases and those programs, and, you know, we're heavily involved in considering, you know, when and how to do share buybacks and all kinds of things like that. [00:20:23] Cory Klippsten: So you know, we signed that contract after the deal was done. So we were brought in after they structured the way to bring in the money, which was pretty much through a convert and a PIPE. So a PIPE is a private investment in the public equity. It's the same way that the BTC Magazine Nakamoto, KDLY was funded the same way with a, with a big PIPE. [00:20:50] Cory Klippsten: Pompliano's thing. I forget what it's called that Jeff Park recently joined that was funded through a PIPE. And what we're seeing with Sequans is, interestingly, the fully diluted share count post the financing. So after the PIPE, the convert, and the warrants associated with the deal is about 300 million shares in that first week or two, there was still only the 25 million shares outstanding. So basically that's like, what is 25 out of, so it's like 8% of the post close float was trading at the time. [00:21:26] Cory Klippsten: So that wasn't institutions and it wasn't the people that actually invested in the deal selling the shares. It was existing shareholders and traders that had bought in hoping that it was going to go up. So interestingly, it was actually, you know, probably retail front running institutions pumping it up and it got to like 4x mNAV, as they say, or multiple of net asset value. So it was trading for, you know, I think the net asset value is, you know, somewhere around like a buck 32 or a buck 35 or something like that. [00:21:54] Cory Klippsten: So if you actually just take the Bitcoin only and map that to the shares, it's something like a dollar 32 and it traded up to, you know, five bucks or something like that, which is, you know, similar to where Capital B in France is trading, or that Metaplanet used to trade for, like six or seven x. Nakamoto right now, again, because the PIPE hasn't unlocked and only 1.2% of the post merger, when it actually goes live in the PIPE shares unlock what's trading right now for Nakamoto is only 1.2% of the total shares. [00:22:28] Cory Klippsten: And so it can whip saw around and move all over the place, but the mNAV for that stock is, you know, 10 to 12. So it's being valued for like 10 to 12 X what it's Bitcoin holdings actually are. And, you know, so Sequans didn't actually get up that high and it was very thinly traded and like nobody, by definition, nobody has a big bag of Sequans that they picked up at like five bucks. It's just traders that were speculating and hoping it would go up. [00:22:57] Cory Klippsten: And so then when the shares unlocked for the PIPE, and again, this is, this is, you know, right now a Sequans story, cause it was the first one of these PIPE deals that actually unlocked. And the other ones that did it similar have not unlocked yet. So we'll see what happens to them. Basically the, you know, there's been a lot of pressure on the stock with some of those early people saying like, Oh, Hey, the stock actually came down. I think when the shares unlocked, the stock was a buck 42 on that day and they had bought at a buck 40. [00:23:25] Cory Klippsten: So they didn't have this profit that they had hoped for. And, you know, I think the, if I were structuring this deal, there's a new one that came out recently called Empery, which has taken over, I think it was like an e-bike company or something, called Volcon. It's a guy named Ryan Matthew Lane. I haven't talked to him yet or met him, but from what I can see from their filings, I think the way that they've structured it, is much healthier and would be the way that I would advise future companies to do this, which is basically their investors have a long lockup period and they have vesting of their shares over time. [00:23:59] Cory Klippsten: So they're much more aligned basically with long-term at least not having like a, you know, that pump and dump mechanism. That's just kind of inherent and having all the PIPE shares unlocked on the same day. I think that's probably a bad deal structure. And it's what Sequans happened to do to launch with their bankers. And, you know, we're doing everything that we can obviously, and being very strategic and putting out our plans on what to do next. But, you know, I think when the PIPE sellers are done and moved on to the next trade, that's when you'll see the mNAV start to expand a bit and that's when we'll start raising capital again, aiming for that 12 to 15% weighted average cost of capital across equity and debt. [00:24:39] Cory Klippsten: And, you know, I believe that capital raised at those levels with that kind of cost of capital is wildly accretive to a public company that can put it all into Bitcoin. Cause I expect Bitcoin to grow at a faster rate than that. [00:24:53] Vlad Costea: Right. But going back to first principles, I'm still having a hard time wrapping my head around how this is different from EOS running an ICO to buy 140,000 Bitcoin and then establish a treasury. But an— [00:25:06] Cory Klippsten: EOS token holder, an EOS token holder gets no claims on the Bitcoin. And there's nothing transparent about it. Like you, as an EOS holder, don't get any of those Bitcoins. [00:25:15] Vlad Costea: Also, you were saying that if I buy a stock in one of these treasury companies, actually can redeem the stock for Bitcoin? [00:25:21] Cory Klippsten: No, no, no, but you own, you have title to their assets. So MicroStrategy, or Strategy as they're called now, like as a shareholder, you can't redeem it for Bitcoin, but they can't sell the Bitcoin out from under you without you having like plenty of advanced notice of that and being able to get out if you want to. They have to be completely transparent. Block.one sold a bunch of EOS tokens and put it into Bitcoin, but that Bitcoin is there's no claim on that for EOS token holders. [00:25:51] Vlad Costea: Yeah. But you can swap the EOS for Bitcoin, which is a lot faster than you can actually sell stock to buy some of the Bitcoin that's being held in reserves. [00:26:02] Cory Klippsten: No, that's not true. I mean, you can, you can sell stock anytime you want in a brokerage account and buy Bitcoin right away if you want to. [00:26:10] Vlad Costea: Well, my point still stands. I don't really understand how this is fundamentally different. It's just that maybe it's nicer from a legal point of view. [00:26:17] Cory Klippsten: Hold on. Let me repeat it for the third time. If a shitcoin treasury company. So if, like, a— I'm sorry. If a shitcoin company like Block.one launches a shitcoin like EOS and you buy EOS, and Block.one is a separate thing that now has dollars and they can put it into Bitcoin or whatever you as an EOS token holder have no claim on their Bitcoin. If Strategy buys Bitcoin with money that you used to buy Stride or Strife or Stretch or Strike or MSTR, you have a claim on their Bitcoin. [00:26:57] Cory Klippsten: You own a piece of it. Very different night and day. [00:27:05] Vlad Costea: Okay. But still, I think it's just a fundraising way to buy more Bitcoin in both cases. [00:27:16] Cory Klippsten: Yeah. Except that the Bitcoin that Strategy is buying is going to the stockholders of Strategy. Whereas the sales of a shitcoin, like Luna that Do Kwon was doing was going to like Luna foundation, which did not have any obligation to distribute that to Luna holders. And it's the same thing with something like EOS, you know, or if Ethereum Foundation or ConsenSys started stacking a lot of Bitcoin, that's not you as an Ethereum holder, as an ether holder have no claim on the Bitcoin that Joe Lubin owns. None. [00:27:50] Cory Klippsten: You don't have a claim on any of the Ethereum that Joe Lubin owns either. [00:27:54] Vlad Costea: So if the stockholders— [00:27:56] Cory Klippsten: All of the Bitcoin that Saylor has stacked, all of the 600,000 plus Bitcoins that Saylor has stacked for Strategy, all of the shareholders own that Bitcoin. [00:28:06] Vlad Costea: So you're saying that the shareholders can actually vote for the company to sell that Bitcoin? [00:28:12] Cory Klippsten: They could. [00:28:18] Cory Klippsten: They're unlikely to succeed because most people don't want them to sell the Bitcoin. [00:28:24] Vlad Costea: Sure. But you can still DDoS them, like get a bunch of people buy shares just so that they can sell their reserves. [00:28:32] Cory Klippsten: By the way. So, you know, so let's talk about, like, activist investing. So I think if you have a poorly managed Bitcoin treasury company or what I would call a leveraged Bitcoin equity, and you have one that just like over time, just underperforms, it's very likely you'll see activist investors like Dan Loeb or some of the short sellers, like, you know, Citron Research, some of these guys like actually come in and actually target that stock and try to unlock the Bitcoin. So this is something that I think is inevitable in a bear market. [00:29:03] Cory Klippsten: When you see mNAV compression, there will be some of these leveraged Bitcoin equity companies that actually suck at it and have gotten over leveraged and start to look like shit. And people actually start to pore through their filings and see that, Oh my God, you know, they're paying 2% per year to some advisor or the executive salaries are, you know, even worse than Bitcoin miners. And these guys are making 50 million a year or something like that. And it'll get attacked, and yes, they'll take over the board and they'll buy a bunch of shares and they'll unlock the value just like private equity firms do. [00:29:32] Cory Klippsten: And they'll take it over for the value of the Bitcoin. Cause if it's trading at like, you know, 75 cents on the dollar, or I guess, you know, 0.75 Bitcoins per Bitcoin, then you fire everybody and you take over the Bitcoin stack and that's, that's a discount. So you already see people talking about doing this and expecting that this will happen. And I think that's just inevitable at some point. [00:29:55] Vlad Costea: So does this make the strategy of EOS much better? Because it's less likely for them to be forced to sell the BTC reserves that they have. [00:30:06] Cory Klippsten: It has nothing to do with EOS. It has nothing to do with the shitcoin. It's two separate things. There's a shitcoin and there's a company that created it called Block.one that has all the Bitcoin. And again, the EOS token holders have no claims on the Bitcoin, unlike holders of MSTR that the holders of MSTR own all the Bitcoin. [00:30:25] Vlad Costea: Yeah. And that's exactly what I'm saying. Since they have no claim, the company can just HODL indefinitely without any pressure from anyone. [00:30:38] Cory Klippsten: Okay. What's your point? Do you own a, do you own stock in Block.one? It's a private company. [00:30:43] Vlad Costea: No, I don't. [00:30:44] Cory Klippsten: Okay. So it's completely irrelevant and orthogonal to the discussion of, like, an EOS holder. Like, EOS token holders have no rights to the Bitcoin. [00:30:53] Vlad Costea: Well, it is, because the value proposition is that the company behind the EOS project is actually holding a bunch of Bitcoin. And they also have a settlement with the SEC. So they're going to use this to leverage the fact that their token is valuable. [00:31:04] Cory Klippsten: They abandoned it years ago. They abandoned it years ago and it went to basically zero in Bitcoin terms. They don't care about it at all. [00:31:09] Vlad Costea: It's not zero. They're still top 100 in CoinMarketCap. [00:31:13] Cory Klippsten: Oh my God, that's so bad. And, you know, they move on to the next thing, right? They move on to a Bullish IPO or something like that. [00:31:27] Vlad Costea: I was just trying to challenge this logically, not legally. I understand that you are tied to certain definitions. It's just that, to me, it means— [00:31:35] Cory Klippsten: No, it's not definitions. This is first principles, Vlad, and it's not. It's actually not. There is no gray area here. You have no claim to the revenue of a company that creates a shitcoin if you hold the shitcoin. If you own shares, you have a claim to the revenue and assets. [00:31:53] Vlad Costea: Right, but you're not investing in the company because it doesn't have a stock. As you said, it's private. [00:31:56] Cory Klippsten: It's completely different. So you don't have any claim to the Luna Foundation's Bitcoins. If you hold Luna, you have no claim to the Ethereum Foundation's Ethereum or Bitcoin or stablecoins because you hold Ether. And you have no claim to Charlie Lee's Litecoins if you hold Litecoin. [00:32:20] Vlad Costea: What Litecoins? He sold them. [00:32:24] Cory Klippsten: I know, but when he had it, you had no claim to it just because you held Litecoin. With stocks, it's very different. The stockholders own all the assets of the company. [00:32:29] Vlad Costea: Would you say that Litecoin is a company and Charlie is the CEO or something? [00:32:35] Cory Klippsten: I think there was a Litecoin Foundation or something, right? [00:32:38] Vlad Costea: There is, yeah. [00:32:39] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, so the point is, like, if there was a foundation and it has assets— [00:32:41] Vlad Costea: There's still a Bitcoin Foundation and [unclear: Brock Pierce] is still president of the board or something. [00:32:48] Cory Klippsten: Right, and you have, as a Bitcoin holder, you have no claims to the assets of a Bitcoin Foundation. [00:32:55] Vlad Costea: But that's not the point. [00:32:58] Cory Klippsten: It absolutely is, because as a Strategy holder, as a stockholder of Strategy, you own your same percentage share that you have of the company is the percentage that you have to a claim to their assets and revenues. [00:33:14] Vlad Costea: I still would rather buy Litecoin. [00:33:18] Cory Klippsten: I'd rather buy Bitcoin. [00:33:21] Vlad Costea: Sure, but if I had to choose between Litecoin and MicroStrategies— [00:33:24] Cory Klippsten: Let's move on, because, I mean, look, we've said this six ways from Sunday, and I think the audience can see the truth in what I've said. But what I will say, which I think is probably the key point, is something, I think it's my pinned tweet right now. And by the way, I should go on BTC Takeover and retweet this, because I said I would when you started. Where are you, Vlad? There it is. [00:33:47] Vlad Costea: No, it's on my personal account. It's my pinned post. [00:33:49] Cory Klippsten: Oh, it's on your personal, okay. All right, hold on one sec, let me retweet this for everybody. There we go. Oh, we're debating Bitcoin maximalism. I thought we were going to do that in part two. I don't know. Anyway, so this is something that we, I love it. So this is, I think, the key, and I think it's my pinned tweet right now, so if you want to click over to it and check it out. [00:34:14] Cory Klippsten: None of these treasury companies make a dent. And what I always say, and you may have heard me say, but it's been something I've been saying since 2019, what we're in it for at Swan is doing the best thing to the nearest of our ability to figure out what that is. And I spend a lot of time trying to figure out what that is. I always do the best thing for Bitcoin and Bitcoiners. And I am only interested in that if it's actually impactful and if you actually do something that's meaningful. [00:34:41] Cory Klippsten: And obviously we've been able to do that with education and scam fighting and serving 150,000 clients or something like that. When it comes to these leveraged Bitcoin equities, it's only meaningful if you're sucking in tens of billions of dollars of institutional capital. I personally have very little interest in attracting retail investors for Bitcoin treasury companies or leveraged Bitcoin equities. They will do it, and there's nothing you can do to stop them. And even our own clients are going to pile into some of these things. And a lot of them talk about MicroStrategy and ask about it all the time. [00:35:15] Cory Klippsten: And all I can do for those ones that are inevitably going to do it anyway is say like, hey, just make sure at least 80% of your Bitcoin inflected portfolio is like 1x long real Bitcoin in cold storage. And I can't stop you from the rest. And if you get lucky and you find one of these popcorn alt stonks and get lucky on Smarter Web or Metaplanet or something, please pile the profits into Bitcoin, which is not dissimilar from what I used to say to crypto traders. [00:35:40] Cory Klippsten: It was like, I can't stop you from trading these shitcoins, but if you make money, at least store your value in Bitcoin. I think it's kind of similar. But nothing makes a difference for Bitcoin and Bitcoiners unless you actually hit institutional scale and you start sucking up this capital from institutional portfolio managers and fixed income managers the way that Strategy is. So nobody else is even close. Nobody else is even remotely close to it. I think maybe Metaplanet is second with like 20,000 coins of the ones that I would call actually leveraged Bitcoin equities, where their real stated explicit goal is to increment Bitcoin per share. [00:36:15] Cory Klippsten: You know, there's only like 10 or 12 legitimate attempts at this going on right now. So that, you know, BTC treasuries or BitcoinTreasuries.net has all of the companies that have some Bitcoin on their balance sheet. But there's a big difference from like Tesla, GameStop, Trump and, you know, these companies that just have some Bitcoin on their balance sheet versus the ones that are actively trying to play that arbitrage that I was talking about, accessing capital markets for a cheap cost of capital to put it into Bitcoin that has a much higher CAGR. [00:36:44] Cory Klippsten: It's arbing that 25% versus that 12% that is the goal of these things. And it really doesn't make a difference unless you hit institutional scale. So that's why I'm involved in helping out Sequans because I think they can hit institutional scale. And I think we proved that by getting out of the gate with, you know, what was it, 384 million for the first buy. And then the company started plowing their own cash into it from their own balance sheet. And, you know, obviously we have lots of plans that we've talked about to get to a lot more Bitcoin in the coming years. [00:37:15] Vlad Costea: Right. So let me use or take advantage of the fact that you retweeted this and your audience has tuned in. And I'm going to explain exactly why I would rather buy Litecoin or hell, let me say I would rather buy Bitcoin Cash, let me take it to that extreme, than hold MicroStrategy. And let's break it down, okay? Your only metric for measuring this is just potential for making more US dollars, which maybe is meritorious in some way. But can I actually sell MicroStrategy outside of office hours? [00:37:49] Vlad Costea: Like, can I sell MicroStrategy on a Sunday when all the institutions are closed? No. Can I self-custody MicroStrategy? No, I cannot. Can I hold MicroStrategy without putting my name out there? Maybe I can use a proxy or something or a broker, but still, no, I can own Litecoin or Bitcoin Cash privately. Is it possible for MicroStrategy to dilute their shares by basically creating inflation? Yes, it is. Is it possible for Litecoin to get more than 84 million coins? I don't think so. It's very difficult. You need a large consensus for that and a hard fork. [00:38:24] Vlad Costea: It's going to be a shit show. It's much easier for humans to decide politics within a company than for something for which people actually run nodes and has been around for like 14 years and running nonstop and took a lot of beatings and is still here. So the way in which you rationalize your investment thesis has more to do with potentially making you more US dollars or Bitcoins or whatever it is that you're trying to acquire than extending your freedoms. And you can argue that you're more free when you have more money, but at the same time, you are more subjected to nation state pressures. [00:39:01] Vlad Costea: And maybe that you as an American are less concerned than I am as a Romanian about your privacy, about your freedom of transactions, about your ability to engage in peer-to-peer trades. But I very much care about this. And honestly, I see a lot of value in Litecoin. I see a lot of value even in Bitcoin Cash because it's experimenting with opcodes that still are controversial on Bitcoin, like OP_CAT or whatever. Bitcoin Cash has it. I see value in Monero, Zcash. [00:39:30] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, but you wouldn't hold Litecoin over Bitcoin, though, right? Like, why would you hold Litecoin instead of Bitcoin? [00:39:38] Vlad Costea: Well, because it's the closest implementation to the Bitcoin whitepaper, which is peer-to-peer electronic cash. Like it's meant to be used for payments, not to be held. [00:39:48] Cory Klippsten: Right. So you don't need that much in a hot wallet or a mobile wallet or whatever to be able to use it for payments. It's not a long term store of value that competes with its closest cousin, which would be Bitcoin. So if you're going to hold something for a long time, it's obviously going to be Bitcoin, not Litecoin or Bcash. [00:40:05] Vlad Costea: Well, but this is about using. It's not about speculating on the long term that their price is going to go up. [00:40:10] Cory Klippsten: Not speculating, saving. It's not speculating, it's saving. And then I'd also go back to your first kind of little jab there. I mean, the denominator is Bitcoin. So unless you expect MicroStrategy to outpace Bitcoin as a small percentage of your portfolio, that should be, you know, denominated in Bitcoin, or at least you should be thinking about it in terms of Bitcoin as your unit of account for your long term savings or your long term investing portfolio. You really shouldn't be in anything unless it has a good risk reward trade off versus Bitcoin. [00:40:42] Cory Klippsten: Unless it's like a passion thing or something that you get use out of, like you want to raise your family in a house or something like that. You know, so it's two different things. There's investing and there's payments. And the payments narrative is basically where a huge swath of this whole industry, you know, basically got off on like cart before the horse. And this was Roger and this was the Bcash movement. And it continues to be something that I think people get confused about to this day, although thankfully it's probably one tenth the number by percentage that get confused about it today. [00:41:13] Cory Klippsten: But it's putting MOE before SOV, so medium of exchange before store of value. And they work in concert together. And obviously there's a lot more need for [unclear: censorship-resistant payments] in areas of the world outside of the West. That's just a fact. And that's why I think you see a lot of the better Bitcoin wallet experiences created outside of the USA, because nobody really needs to spend Bitcoin unless they're kind of a hobbyist or a zealot or just kind of want to do it for fun. You just don't need it in the West. [00:41:44] Cory Klippsten: You can just pay with a card everywhere. And so it's just two different things. [00:41:49] Vlad Costea: Well, I can argue that you do need it. Even Satoshi rationalized it by saying, well, people need to pay for porn. This is an actual thread on Bitcointalk from 2010 when someone asked, why would you want to use Bitcoin for payments? And Satoshi said there are sensitive situations where you want to pay for something that you don't want your bank or your family members or whoever else has access to your bank accounts to know what you're paying for. And that's a legitimate use case. [00:42:17] Cory Klippsten: 100%. It's pretty niche, but yeah, it exists. [00:42:19] Vlad Costea: Online services, domains, like there are lots of reasons why you should be paying with your Bitcoin. And I can also argue, like you're framing this narrative where you're saying that people who wanted to use Bitcoin for payments were putting the cart before the horse, but at the same time, the adoption in terms of payment for BTC is much lower than it was 10 years ago. 10 years ago, we had Dell, we had Expedia, we had Microsoft, we had Steam, we had a bunch of companies that accepted Bitcoin, and it was quite fashionable for companies to say that they're accepting Bitcoin. [00:42:52] Vlad Costea: Now it's not anymore. Now they're just hoarding it. [00:42:56] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, it's because there were a lot of people out there evangelizing for it, and they had some level of success, but those companies gave up on it because there were no volumes and there was no economic case for doing it. So it really is kind of, the medium of exchange is pretty irrelevant. What matters is what is the payer, the person, what are they storing in value before they pay, and what is the recipient storing their value in after they receive it? That's what's really important. And, you know, I have some background in payments, thankfully, and actually like used to do payment studies for private equity firms and worked on, like, [unclear: I can] First Data and Chase Paymentech and all this shit. [00:43:30] Cory Klippsten: This is, I don't know, 17, 18 years ago, I was around in Chicago when Braintree started and they bought Venmo and sold to PayPal and all that stuff. So I've been following this for, you know, basically since the dawn of the internet, or at least the consumer web. And, you know, it's so easy to change from the currency in my account to the currency that the merchant wants to receive. I don't have to think about it at all. I just went to London for three or four days and I don't, I didn't even get a pound. [00:44:02] Cory Klippsten: I didn't even pick up a note at all. I just paid in dollars everywhere and they receive pounds everywhere. It just is not a problem. And yeah, I mean, maybe I would go jump through some hoops with VPNs and, you know, an altcoin or Bitcoin or Lightning or something like that if there was something like important for me to keep secret, but those tools are available to me and I can choose to do that if I want to. [00:44:27] Vlad Costea: Well, right. You're presenting the exact same example that Jimmy Song was like seven, eight years ago, but— [00:44:34] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, it seems like a really old dated argument, doesn't it? [00:44:38] Vlad Costea: Well, he was explaining it through the lens of Gresham's law, not just convenience. And he was saying that he was earning credit card points or whatever. Oh, he's gone. I hope he's going to come back. His internet was a bit unstable. Until then, let me plug NoOnes.com, which is a peer-to-peer exchange for people who want to engage in trade with the global south. So if you're not like Cory, who is very much into storing value and you want to support the economy that's trying to build parallel systems and is trying to escape oppressive regimes, then you get on NoOnes and you can sell your gift cards. [00:45:18] Vlad Costea: You can sell your coins to a spot exchange. You can get a debit card for spending your coins with Visa if you're into that. But the point is that all of this liquidity that you're providing to the exchange is going to end up empowering people from Africa, from the Middle East, from Latin America who are in dire needs of some BTC or some XMR or some LTC or whatever you may have to escape the tyranny of their everyday places and also the hyperinflation to which they are subjected. [00:45:50] Vlad Costea: CEO of NoOnes is Ray Youssef and you can find the URL. It's NoOnes.com. Check it out. I see that Cory still hasn't come back, so I wish I would plug the ad for Bitcoin.com News while he was watching or listening because I do want to see his reaction to this. Let me see what happened to him. [00:46:18] Vlad Costea: He's back. [00:46:27] Vlad Costea: Hey, Cory. [00:46:29] Cory Klippsten: Hey. All right, I guess we'll finish this on, it's not letting me in. [00:46:35] Vlad Costea: You're in. I guess you don't have video for the last four or five minutes. Your video froze and then you dropped out. I'm not sure what happened. [00:46:49] Vlad Costea: Hello. [00:46:59] Vlad Costea: Check. All right. Two, three, four. [00:47:03] Cory Klippsten: I'm not seeing the video. [00:47:05] Vlad Costea: Me neither. [00:47:06] Cory Klippsten: Oh, there we go. Can you, can you bounce my laptop from it? Cause my laptop doesn't like the connection anymore. So we can just finish on the, on the phone. [00:47:16] Vlad Costea: Sure. Okay. [00:47:21] Vlad Costea: We're still live. I plugged one of the ads and I wanted to plug another one, but I do want to see your reaction because Bitcoin.com News has recently went BTC and orange. Like if you go to news.bitcoin.com, you're going to see that they don't tell you that BCH is faster and has quicker confirmation times. And they have a lot of news about BTC seems like they adapted to the trends of the market. [00:47:52] Cory Klippsten: I mean, it's a media company. They got to make money. They have decent coverage by the way. Sometimes they have good articles. [00:48:01] Vlad Costea: Yeah. I'm the one who reached out to them and said, you know, you guys are different. Like maybe I should tell my audience about it. [00:48:11] Cory Klippsten: I've had a nice, pleasant DM conversations with Roger over the years here and there. [00:48:16] Vlad Costea: I don't think he owns it anymore. Maybe he owns the domain, but he doesn't own it. [00:48:20] Cory Klippsten: Oh, really? So he went to somebody else and he just leases it to them or something? [00:48:27] Vlad Costea: Because there was someone else who was CEO and they have a different management. Even the BCH people are unhappy with the new management. [00:48:39] Cory Klippsten: Sure. Yeah. It was the last, last thing they had was the domain to show [unclear: for their coin]. [00:48:48] Vlad Costea: Oh, they still, they still have devs and they're building stuff, which is interesting. Even BCH is building layer twos right now with ZK rollups. [00:48:59] Cory Klippsten: Yeah. Well, I mean, that's, that's always been kind of the bull case for altcoins is that at least if they come up with some tech that's interesting that you can port over to Bitcoin, then it wasn't completely useless. [00:49:11] Vlad Costea: I was going to get to this because when I said, we're going to talk about Bitcoin maximalism, I was going to present this case, like Litecoin actually tested SegWit and the Lightning network for Bitcoin 2017. [00:49:28] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, they can be useful testnets. I think if they, if they didn't exist, I think you would just have a bunch of tooling created and basically have like, you know, I mean a lot more focus on Bitcoin testnets so that they could experiment with the same thing. I don't think you necessarily need altcoins for that, but it is a nice function that they serve given that they're there. [00:49:44] Vlad Costea: But on testnets, let's assume that we're going to have perfectly functional testnets. How are you going to see if there's market demand for anything or how are you going to get newbies to try it out? [00:49:52] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, makes sense. [00:49:53] Vlad Costea: Testnets are just for devs and even the devs are too lazy to try it, but if there's some money there, like even for bounties, you can put something on Litecoin or Bitcoin Cash and say, let's see if anyone can break it. If they can, they're going to make a bunch of money. [00:50:14] Cory Klippsten: Wouldn't the counterpoint be to just do like, do it on a sidechain or something like that still has value accumulating and circulating through it? [00:50:23] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but the sidechain is going to have BTC, right? [00:50:26] Cory Klippsten: Yep, exactly. [00:50:28] Vlad Costea: So do you want to give BTC as the bounty or do you want to let the Litecoin people figure it out? [00:50:36] Cory Klippsten: Again, it's free to the Bitcoiner to let them experiment with things and test things. And you know, that is, look, things that are net negative always have a ledger and it's very rare that they're 100% con. There's often some pros as well. Like I'll give you the entire, all of crypto and you know, all these, you know, Wharton blockchain certifications and MIT shitcoin lectures and all this kind of stuff that's been going on for the last 15 years. Like they're going to make incremental improvements to financial IT. [00:51:09] Cory Klippsten: You can't put a hundred billion dollars in like a hundred thousand devs and 10 years into something and not have some interesting things come out of it. It's just not going to accrue value to their tokens in the long run. So it's just, it's not, it's not going to compete with Bitcoin for store of value and moneyness. It doesn't mean that nothing will ever come from throwing tons of money and tons of brains at problems. And they'll just shift it, right? Like once, once they, I mean, they're already calling. [00:51:40] Cory Klippsten: Private databases with sequencers that existed before Bitcoin, they're calling that blockchain, right? At all these companies. And it's because there's a bunch of VPs of innovation that did a blockchain course and brought blockchain to the office. And they have to call it that, otherwise they look stupid. [00:52:00] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I actually got some reactions from [unclear: Yello] and a bunch of the people from the meme factory. [00:52:07] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, what's up, Yello? Yello and I are neighbors right now, because I'm in Istanbul. [00:52:13] Vlad Costea: Really? I thought he was Greek. [00:52:15] Cory Klippsten: I know, we're neighbors. [00:52:18] Vlad Costea: Oh, I get it. I was thinking that he's in Istanbul too. Let me ask you something. So you only have three more minutes and then you have to jump in another call. [00:52:28] Cory Klippsten: I do, yeah. [00:52:30] Vlad Costea: Before you go, and we established that there's going to be a second part, what do you think about drivechains and the ZK rollups like Citrea? They're coming to Bitcoin. [00:52:41] Cory Klippsten: So I'm not sure that drivechains are coming to Bitcoin. I found the promoters of drivechain to be extremely disingenuous, Paul in particular. And I've spent a lot of one-on-one time going back and forth with him, but he's just not really a, in my view, is not a high integrity, honest actor. That's okay. I think he's really believed in something. I do believe that he thinks that he's right. And I think he's just kind of using the tools of debate and discourse in a disingenuous way that doesn't really serve the audience. [00:53:13] Cory Klippsten: I don't personally care, but I just don't think it serves the audience. I haven't seen anything about drivechains actually coming to Bitcoin. As far as ZK rollups, they'll probably figure it out at some point. I don't anticipate that they won't. And I think that they'll find ways to do it without having to make dramatic changes to the code. I don't think you'll need any kind of major upgrades to Bitcoin to be able to do a lot of these things. I think the pace of development that you're seeing with Ark, that you're seeing with BitVM and just like, you know, I don't even get time to dig in deep, but when somebody that I consider very high signal, like Robin, you know, I'll see a tweet from him, you know, once a month. [00:53:53] Cory Klippsten: That's like basically, holy shit, even I didn't think it was going to be this good, you know? And I am pretty close to the Ark Labs team that's doing Arkade with Tiero and Alex and that crew. And like so much of the stuff is emergent. And like, once you open the box and start digging around and start poking around, there's all these things that you didn't even know you were going to be able to benefit from. And so just making the tools available and then letting a thousand flowers bloom and, you know, with Arkade coming out and letting a bunch of devs get their hands on it and, you know, build on that infrastructure layer, like I'm super bullish. [00:54:25] Cory Klippsten: And I just think the main thing, like, it's so funny because the biggest problem with, you know, shitcoin trading and shitcoin pumping is time preference. It's just very low time pref— or very high time preference. It's trying to like get rich now versus over the long run with Bitcoin. And I see Bitcoin just broadly as very much the same problem. There's a bunch of people that want to be able to do things today that don't realize that it takes like 50 to 80 years to roll out a new monetary system and like fucking give it a second. [00:54:53] Cory Klippsten: You don't have to solve every single problem today. If you think that you need to fix Bitcoin in some major way or like jam something through, I would just say you probably don't believe nearly enough in human innovation. [00:55:06] Vlad Costea: Right. But I can also make the case that if you think it will be only Bitcoin and we're going to have this utopian world where everything is divided by the 21 million coins, you're also slightly delusional. I mean, there's competition. [00:55:21] Cory Klippsten: You must have read my post this morning. I posted something for you early this morning, Central European Time, which is I love the meme, everything divided by 21 million, but it's actually just a meme and it's not true. It's, you know, it's the denominator, but of course there will be plenty of other assets and not just Bitcoin. We'll just measure it in terms of Bitcoin and we'll say that building is worth, you know, 35 Bitcoins or something like that because it's big. [00:55:47] Vlad Costea: That's fair. [00:55:48] Cory Klippsten: Doesn't mean there aren't going to be buildings. [00:55:49] Vlad Costea: I feel so sorry that you told me you only have one hour because I feel like at this point we got to somewhere where we can agree with each other and also make a case where we agree and where we disagree. [00:56:02] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, absolutely. No, we'll pick it up. I can probably do it even, maybe even later this week before heading back to LA. I leave for sometime in the next two weeks. I'm not supposed to say specifically when I'm in the air, but sometime in the next few weeks I'll be going back to Los Angeles. But no, I definitely want to do a part two and I think we'll wax philosophical on all kinds of different topics. It'll be fun. [00:56:26] Vlad Costea: Okay. Thank you very much, Cory. Thanks to everyone who tuned in. It was not the best hour for us to do this, but there was some activity in the chat. [00:56:36] Cory Klippsten: Thanks, Vlad. Appreciate you. [00:56:38] Vlad Costea: Someone said, "I understand nothing." I'm just going to read some comments. Thank you, Cory. [00:56:43] Cory Klippsten: Okay. Bye, Vlad. [00:56:44] Vlad Costea: [unclear: Unknown] said, "Vlad understands nothing. He needs to read a book or two." Well, which ones? You tell me. You tell me which books I should read and you're going to be surprised whether or not I read them. There's also Kiev.KAS who says, "Here we go again." [00:57:00] Vlad Costea: And he put a kite emoji. And TheRed7 says, "Nice talk. These issues need fleshing out." I do agree. [00:57:11] Vlad Costea: TheKingIsComing says, "Which is easier to transfer to your wallet, your claim in Bitcoin or your tokens in EOS? You can talk about saving only in retrospect." Yeah, you're super right with this. [00:57:25] Vlad Costea: And Rockstar Bitches with a Z at the end says, "What the fuck is this interview? The interviewer is just being confrontational." It's called a debate, friend. [00:57:38] Vlad Costea: And also Dollar Crypto said, "You're interviewing Cory, the founder and CEO of Swan, a custodial dark box which raises hundreds of millions from VCs that want a return. So isn't it as risky as Celsius was?" No, because they don't custody funds. So, yeah. [00:58:02] Vlad Costea: Thanks for tuning in, [unclear: Bodhi]. There's going to be a second part, apparently, as Cory confirmed. Later this week, we're going to find a commonly convenient time and come back to this. Until then, I got to thank the sponsors. I didn't get to plug LayerTwo Labs, which is building the drivechain, but I did inquire. I did beg the question to Cory to see what he thinks about it. But if you do want to test it to make your own opinion, go to layer2labs.com slash download. [00:58:31] Vlad Costea: And you have the Drivechain launcher for macOS, for Linux and for Windows. And you can install the software, run it on the Bitcoin Signet. And you're going to be able to see how the Zcash sidechain works, how the Ethereum sidechain works, the Namecoin sort of sidechain works. And also there's a prediction market and there's the big block sidechain that's prunable. It's interesting. I think this idea deserves to be tested. And if you're a nerd and you have a couple of hours this weekend, you can try it out. [00:59:07] Vlad Costea: And there's also Citrea, which is building the first optimistically verified ZK rollup on Bitcoin. And they're going to be launching later this year without any sort of covenant soft fork. We sort of touched upon this with Cory, but he believed that these projects are going to be needing some sort of opcode to be able to deploy. It seems like they were able to figure out workarounds so they don't have to activate CTV or OP_CAT or whatever. And Citrea is going to be bringing a lot of these sort of banking services, but not with a company, with a protocol. [00:59:46] Vlad Costea: So you can verify the code, you can set your own terms, you can get loans against your Bitcoin and stuff like this, which previously was only available on Ethereum or Solana or all of these other blockchains. So these were the sponsors. Once again, thank you. Bitcoin.com News and LayerTwo Labs and NoOnes.com and SideShift.ai and Citrea. If you guys have any more questions, you can leave them in the comments and I'm going to read them to Cory next time. So maybe for Spotify, I will save this one and publish both parts at the same time. [01:00:23] Vlad Costea: So if you're listening on Spotify, maybe you're from the future. And what else? Is there any comment? There's just lol in the chat. Thank you guys for listening. I will see you in part two and also tune in on Thursday when I'll be interviewing the founder of Kaspa, or Kaspa. I'm not sure how you correctly pronounce that, which is a fair-launched and pretty interesting proof of work blockchain from which maybe Bitcoin can learn something. That's going to be the reason of this interview. And I hope you guys are going to be there to listen. [01:01:00] Vlad Costea: Don't forget to subscribe. Don't forget to like this episode and I will see you in the next one. [01:01:54] Vlad Costea: Hello there and welcome to part two of Season 16, Episode 40 of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. We are back with Cory Klippsten and we are going to discuss the topic which we promised we were going to discuss in the previous part, but we didn't get to it, which is Bitcoin maximalism. Let's try to define this, Cory. [01:02:12] Cory Klippsten: All right. Well, look, I'm obviously we're going to both talk on this and I think that's probably what people want to hear. I'm going to do one thing and just let me see if I can just get my AirPods to be the mic so that everybody has higher quality. [01:02:30] Cory Klippsten: So, look, I'll probably first lead off, especially for folks that are that are relatively newer to the space, just acknowledging that I and most people that I hang out with in the Bitcoin space just call ourselves Bitcoiners. And that maximalist was created as a term as an epithet by Vitalik Buterin in an effort to slander Bitcoiners and try to make them seem closed minded or something like that. And so I kind of reject the term and the diminutive. So when you hear somebody say maxi, it's actually a diminutive of an epithet. [01:03:07] Cory Klippsten: And that's why you usually see shitcoiners saying it louder than Bitcoiners. It's because it actually is intended as kind of a slander. That said, just like with all kinds of other folks that have been targeted by slander, if somebody wants to adopt it and flip the meaning and say, yeah, sure, whatever, I'll just adopt that. You see lots of people in various communities historically just go ahead and adopt pejoratives as kind of terms of endearment or solidarity or something like that and just like take away the power. [01:03:42] Cory Klippsten: From the slander, and I think you've obviously seen that and you see Samson putting out toxic maximalism hats as early as like 2018 or something like that and maybe 2019. And so you've seen people kind of say, yeah, whatever, I'm a Bitcoin maxi. I personally don't use the word and I just want to make sure people know where it actually comes from. [01:04:02] Vlad Costea: Well, before maximalism, which comes from that 2014 article by Vitalik, it was called like an umbrella term. So people were referring to one coin to rule them all. And this was something that you could find on Bitcointalk and it was also one chain to rule them all. And this goes back to the Bitcoin 2.0 discussions that started sometime around 2012, 2013. And at one point there was a competition of protocols to see which one is going to do tokens and stocks and bonds and whatever on the Bitcoin blockchain. [01:04:38] Vlad Costea: We had Counterparty, which I can argue is super Bitcoin maximalist that came out in January of 2014. They burned like a thousand Bitcoin or something to create their own token on Bitcoin, which precedes the ordinals and everything that we have nowadays. And they created something which basically uses OP_RETURN to put data inside Bitcoin transactions. And it basically marks those coins as having a different meaning as opposed to just being normal Bitcoin. And then we had Mastercoin, which got rebranded as Omni. At one point, Peter Todd was the chief scientist of Mastercoin. [01:05:18] Vlad Costea: And that one, I think the greatest merit that it had was to issue Tether on it and bootstrap this craze, which nowadays has more volume than Bitcoin. [01:05:30] Cory Klippsten: I think it was also the first ICO, if I recall. [01:05:34] Vlad Costea: Mastercoin, yeah, exactly. And then there were a bunch of other ideas like BitShares and Ethereum and NXT, all of which tried to move the activity on another chain which does something else. And if you look back like 12 years ago, you would not guess that Ethereum was going to turn out to be the winner because it was just this weird Canadian teenager and a bunch of friends. And NXT, for example, looked a lot more professional and Mastercoin also looked a lot more professional, like people with gray hair and experience in programming. [01:06:12] Vlad Costea: It's crazy how it turned out. But we got to this phase where we have to distinguish between Bitcoin maximalism with a capital B, which means this network is going to incorporate every use case and Bitcoin maximalism with a lowercase B, which means that we're going to have 21 million coins and an entire economy that's denominated in this. [01:06:34] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, so I think the lowercase B, as you just defined it, I see people adopting the term monetary maximalism or Bitcoin, I'm a Bitcoin monetary maximalist. And so Bitcoin basically is the dominant or, you know, will be the last store of value standing. And I think that's, that's probably where most of the mainstream Bitcoin influencers will stop. I think probably in large part because their technical expertise and sort of confidence in forecasting what might happen with, you know, decentralization, decentralized networks in the future, probably they don't have the ability to make prognostications of what might happen with the capital B maximalism. [01:07:22] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I do see two very different trends, which I guess go back to Ethereum and Bitcoin 2.0. Basically, you have people trying to create other chains that incorporate Bitcoin so that you lock your BTC on chain, on the Bitcoin blockchain and tokenize it on another chain, which has another token of its own. Or there are people trying to build sidechains and rollups and stuff on top of the Bitcoin network to avoid having a token of its own. And it seems like there is a constant battle between the two camps trying to basically provide utility to BTC as the currency, not Bitcoin as the network necessarily. [01:08:07] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, I guess you would have to say, you know, and this comes down to like, what is the actual definition of a layer two, and I think a true layer two is when you have unilateral withdrawal. So if you don't have to trust anybody to withdraw and anything short of that is, you know, a scam or a sidechain, basically. And so, you know, as far as I can tell, the only functioning layer twos today are Lightning and Ark, and maybe there will be some BitVM things before too long that also would qualify for being real layer twos. [01:08:38] Cory Klippsten: But pretty much, I mean, I've never heard of anything else that I would say actually qualifies to be a real layer two. [01:08:46] Vlad Costea: Well, I would be curious to know what you think about ZK rollups like Citrea and Alpen, because at this point, you mentioned in our previous conversation that they need some sort of opcodes to function. They figured out workarounds to not require that anymore, and I think they're going to launch later this year. The way in which they're going to operate is to use Bitcoin, the network as a data availability layer, which means that they're going to put large chunks of transaction data. But on the other hand, they're going to provide functionality, which is very similar with what Ethereum offers, and people will be able to borrow to do all sorts of advanced DeFi stuff on Bitcoin. [01:09:32] Vlad Costea: And on one hand, it pays the Bitcoin miners because it takes block space, and it also provides extra features to Bitcoin. On the other hand, it's not what most people want to see Bitcoin become, and there is like a huge flame war nowadays between people who want to filter out this kind of data on Bitcoin. [01:09:54] Cory Klippsten: I mean, what you described, and this is, so I'm going just on what you said over the last 45 seconds or so, doesn't offend me whatsoever. That's pretty cool. I mean, I'm not going to vouch for the project, and I don't know if they have a shitcoin. I don't know what else their plans are, whatever. I'm not close to the Citrea debate and haven't seen much of that flame war in my feed. But I'm vaguely aware that there's a project called Citrea, and I think it sparked a little bit of, it sparked some debate like two months ago, because there was something that they thought might be helpful to them. [01:10:31] Cory Klippsten: And basically Core said, well, we're going to turn this thing on. And people rightly or wrongly assumed that they were doing it because it was going to be helpful to that project. And they kind of protested and said, no, it really wasn't because of us. We just kind of pointed out that this thing is something that we're probably going to use. And anyway, so I don't know, it seemed it seemed kind of arcane and like not that impactful. So I didn't dive deep on it. [01:10:57] Vlad Costea: Yeah, the conversation was about increasing the OP_RETURN size, which previously was limited by Core developers, I think in 2014 to 40 bytes. And basically by making this larger, it would make Citrea function more efficiently. Because there are other ways to embed data into Bitcoin, which are less efficient, and they also bloat the UTXO set, which is stored in the RAM memory. Which is more expensive than storage, and most nodes cannot upgrade so fast, or as fast as that's getting bloated. So they basically said, we want to use this, which does not require more RAM from nodes, but we need more space for it. [01:11:40] Vlad Costea: And it's not just Citrea, it's also Alpen. I think Citrea got the blame because it was in the center of the conversation in the mailing list, and Jameson Lopp is an investor and sort of sparked a very heated debate because people had the wrong expectations from Jameson to be a monk or something and not invest in anything, except for BTC. [01:12:06] Cory Klippsten: Maybe. Yeah, I mean, that could be it. Maybe it's just because when they were talking about the OP_RETURN increase, they were name dropping that particular project. So it's probably going to draw some heat no matter what, right or wrong. [01:12:19] Vlad Costea: But at the same time, people became paranoid regarding Core, and now we see a renaissance of Bitcoin Knots, which is basically a copy of Core with just a few changed parameters, and it's being maintained by only one guy who lost 200 BTC. Admittedly, he lost 200 BTC. [01:12:39] Cory Klippsten: It's just, I'm not going to take the other side of that debate. I don't agree with a lot of it, and a lot of the people that I think have their heart and mind in the right place and have been bastions of signal are on both sides of that. I don't think there's anybody that is actively involved in discussions around all this stuff that is right more often than Giacomo. And so, you know, that's one thing, but then, you know, Adam is generally right about things, and he's saying some things that seem a little bit flip and a little bit simplistic lately, and it's what it is. [01:13:15] Cory Klippsten: I don't know, I think we'll just, we'll see it play out. And I think Bitcoin's incentives are strong enough to carry it through, regardless of how it shakes out. I don't think that all this kind of recent stuff was sparked by Citrea, though, it seems like it was, yeah, it was much more around, you know, ordinals and stamps and kind of just continuing to try to include as much data as possible by some people in blocks versus some people wanting to kind of, you know, I guess, essentially through mostly social pressure, it turns out, keep spam out of the blockchain. [01:13:52] Cory Klippsten: Because there's not a lot you can do about it if somebody really, really, really wants to put, you know, pictures on Bitcoin, like there's always a way to do it. [01:14:01] Vlad Costea: Well, the only way to filter is by using the free market mechanisms, which is to price them out. So it becomes unaffordable for them to do this right now. They're doing it because they understood that block space is super cheap. And even I put a picture of my face on the Bitcoin blockchain. If you're listening to this, it's on your node pleb. So deal with it. Cope. There's nothing you can do about it. [01:14:28] Cory Klippsten: There are probably worse things on your node than Vlad's face. [01:14:32] Vlad Costea: Most likely, yeah. And it's not since the ordinal inscriptions that they merged. This was possible since the early days, like 2011, 2012, someone put like the WikiLeaks documents on Bitcoin. And there was also an ASCII, is that how you pronounce it? A-S-C-I-I? [01:14:52] Cory Klippsten: ASCII. I usually say ASCII. [01:14:55] Vlad Costea: ASCII portrait of Len Sassaman, which was inscribed by Dan Kaminsky, who unfortunately passed but was a genius back in his day. He was talking about scaling Bitcoin and most of the conversations that happened many years later. And this was in 2011 or something, very ahead of his time. And we have to understand there's nothing new about this whole conversation. It's just that there are more users who are passionate about Bitcoin. And I gotta blame you, Cory, partially, because the kind of education that Swan provided gave them the kind of reassurance to make some absolute statements about something that they don't understand completely. [01:15:40] Cory Klippsten: What is an example of an absolute statement that you attribute to Swan popularizing? [01:15:48] Vlad Costea: Well, it goes back to this whole Bitcoin does not have a blockchain campaign, right? Which said, well, Bitcoin has a time chain and it's sacred and the blockchain industry is something else. I did see that emerging from the Bitcoin Cafe spaces. And a lot of people believe that. [01:16:07] Cory Klippsten: So this is like, so I think probably talking past each other a little bit would be my guess because I think when we say things like Bitcoin, not crypto or Bitcoin, not blockchain, I mean, first of all, we weren't the people to popularize either of those. Also, don't forget spaces would be like opened up by us and hosted by us. But, you know, there's tons of people on stage, there's usually eight to 12 speakers and we don't vouch for everything that gets said in a space like that. [01:16:34] Cory Klippsten: I don't even vouch for everything that employees of Swan or contractors of Swan say. Like we have a free speech policy and they can say whatever the hell they want. Like we're all just trying to figure it out, right? So I can only really vouch for like what I say. I do bear responsibility for what comes out from the Swan handle and often scold the team if they put out something that I don't like or that I think is over the line or is like, you know, a little bit too much of like a pump or something like that. [01:17:01] Cory Klippsten: So I definitely pull that back quite often and kind of sculpt and mold what comes out from the Swan handle, Swan YouTube as well. So kind of like our official channels, but not the employees, not our advisors, not our board members, not our contractors, not any of our podcasters. Like it's kind of just a vibe of who we align with. And, you know, it's extremely rare that I'll actually like get in touch with somebody and say like, you know, that's pretty rough. I wish you wouldn't say stuff like that. [01:17:29] Cory Klippsten: That's probably twice a year or something. So, you know, it's the marketing term and the way that people interpret like what crypto is. My main goal from like, you know, getting into the space heavily and becoming Bitcoin only in 2018 and starting what became Swan in 2019 was to separate Bitcoin from crypto and make sure that they were seen as being very distinct and that Bitcoin wasn't something that was just sitting under as one of the cryptos, that it was actually something that was a very unique and different asset than the 30 million altcoins, which are all much more centralized other than a few or whatever. [01:18:10] Cory Klippsten: And obviously there's exceptions to the rule, but, you know, for the most part, they're kind of insider pump and dump games, the vast majority of them, or they're things where if you actually play it out from a game theory perspective, they'll just get more and more centralized over time and eventually end up, you know, just being basically like privatized. And it's natural because there's so many of these, you know, degree programs at the universities with the blockchain certifications and people talking about crypto, crypto, blockchain, blockchain. Of course, even as these things, as they get, you know, spread into companies or whatever, and essentially become glorified databases and sequencers with private keys, but not decentralized, not decentralized networks, they will still use the terms crypto and blockchain, and everybody will get to, you know, chalk up a win because some VP of innovation brought blockchain into JP Morgan or something like that. [01:19:04] Cory Klippsten: But it really doesn't have anything to do with decentralized networks and state free money, which is by far the most important thing that's going on in this entire space is sort of rewriting the base layer of society and how we coordinate economic activity and progress, which is what Bitcoin is doing. I think the bull case for all the rest of crypto blockchain is at best incremental improvements to financial IT. That's what they're going for. You know, update the system is like making settlement time slightly faster, you know, cutting out some accounting nonsense, you know, it's just things like that. [01:19:42] Cory Klippsten: It's maybe being able to tokenize and digitize some assets that haven't had that happen before. It's not that they couldn't, there really wasn't demand enough to push it over the edge, but maybe it's slightly easier to tokenize real estate or tokenize certain debt instruments or whatever. It'll happen now because it's slightly easier because of all the investment that's come into like crypto blockchain departments at the banks. [01:20:07] Vlad Costea: Well, I can argue there's a bit more like something which I wish there was on Bitcoin and there is on Ethereum is Uniswap, which is this decentralized way to swap between assets. I think that's really useful and interesting. And they also have automated market makers and stuff like this. [01:20:25] Cory Klippsten: So let's pick at that for a sec. So people today want to trade these crypto assets in as much as there is a lasting use for any of these. And this is kind of probably pretty well explained in Only the Strong Survive by Allen Farrington and Big Al. It's basically like that non-Bitcoin crypto overall is a negative sum game because less money comes out of it than goes in. And so if you believe like I do that over the long run, all of the non-Bitcoin crypto tokens go to zero in Bitcoin terms, which I believe will happen over the coming years. [01:21:06] Cory Klippsten: And we've seen that time and time again that out of 30 million altcoins, only two have ever had a second all-time high in Bitcoin terms. Only two. Out of all of them. So Ripple was slightly higher in 2017 than it was in 2013 in Bitcoin terms, and Doge got the Elon pump in 21, where it went higher than it was in 2017. No other altcoin has ever had a second all-time high in Bitcoin terms. So when you think about Bitcoin dominance, what people don't realize is that there's survivorship bias in the index of the cryptos. [01:21:40] Cory Klippsten: So that 35%, if it's 65-35, that 35% this year is a completely different 35% than it was eight years ago or 12 years ago. Bitcoin's dominance against the coins from back then is going to be like 95 or 99%. And so I think that's what people miss is like, you know, you keep on adding more and more altcoins and their share against Bitcoin, each of them individually keeps on dropping. But because there's so many of them, and because you're basically including the market cap of the ones that are currently pumping before they dump, they're at the top of the Empire State Building before they take the fast trip down, it makes it look like crypto is a thing. [01:22:20] Vlad Costea: Well, yeah, but the point is not to make more US dollars, but to be able to do stuff without signing up to KYC exchanges, without giving information to your government about what you're doing, being able to mine your own coins in your basement with the computer that you already have, and exchanging that for a currency that is more useful. [01:22:32] Cory Klippsten: I hear you. If those assets, if those assets are only going to be shitcoins, there's not really anything useful being done there in the long run. I agree for people that want to trade and want to own a bunch of different shitcoins and like are playing like, you know, DeFi games and basically being little hedge fund managers or crypto asset managers or whatever, they're able to do cool shit, totally get that. [01:23:03] Cory Klippsten: But if you're actually going to play this out and it's going to be real world assets, so it's going to be actual assets and essentially asset-backed tokens that actually have lasting value beyond just declining towards zero in Bitcoin terms forever, which is what all the shitcoins do. Then it's going to be adjudicated in meatspace. And then it unfortunately is going to require KYC and all kinds of other shit. So you're just not going to be able to like trade fractionalized real estate stocks, dollars, euros, all that stuff using DeFi. [01:23:39] Cory Klippsten: That doesn't mean that you shouldn't experiment with this and they won't get ported over. And I think, you know, triple ledger accounting is very attractive for settlement and all this kind of other stuff. But just understand like all it's good for today. And I can't I've never seen anybody make a case for why all this DeFi stuff will ever be useful for real world assets. So it's basically only useful for trading shitcoins and farming yield on shitcoins. [01:24:05] Vlad Costea: Well, I can present you a very compelling argument in the fact that my girlfriend is from Iran. They don't have access to any of the financial services, even if they do want to KYC to any exchange out there, they're not allowed to use it. And the way in which they onboard this economy is to either mine something or claim airdrops, which they're swapping into something like BTC or ETH or whatever it is that they can use in a daily economy. So for them, it's not about making more U.S. Dollars for them. It's actually about being able to have some money that the government cannot take away from them and being able to maybe buy a plane ticket to move into another country. So I can argue that your point of view is valid for like 300 million people out of 8 billion. But the rest of the world has to deal with this reality. I mean, OK, 300 million in the U.S., maybe 300 million in Europe, and the rest of the world has to still cope with some sort of authoritarianism or a situation where they need free money and not free as in airdrops, free as in they can use without permission from their governments. [01:25:14] Cory Klippsten: For sure. Yeah. And I think that is look again, there are there are temporary pros and cons to everything. And what I'm generally talking about when I'm working toward is like, where are we going to be decades or 100 or 200 years from now? And basically working on that foundation and trying to put my effort on the thing that matters the most. But again, like it's pretty cushy living in Los Angeles and working with, you know, mostly a U.S. Client base. And I totally, totally acknowledge that, just like I acknowledge that I, you know, I there's conflict in let's just take stablecoins, for instance. [01:25:57] Cory Klippsten: So in one respect, it's really kind of gross to be trying to extend dollar hegemony as long as possible and to become basically all of crypto. All the money is basically made on stablecoins at this point, and they're becoming an arm of the U.S. State and Treasury and Fed. Right. And that's just been completely co-opted and it's all the same people working on everything and they have lobbyists and they've paid off all the politicians. And like, you know, basically stablecoins are just an arm of the U.S. Government now. On the other hand, I don't know what the 2024 stats, but I got the 23 stats for Turkey where I am right now talking to you. And four percent of Turkish GDP in 2023 bought USD stablecoins. Four percent. So it's clearly serving a need for people. The market is speaking in Argentina, it's speaking here in Turkey, it's speaking in lots of places around the world that they want to hold dollars. And this is making it easier for them to access dollars than it is through exchange windows or through local banks that have all kinds of different regulations. [01:27:05] Cory Klippsten: And they've just been kind of able to kind of sneak in the side door and make dollars available to people where they weren't previously available. And I'm not in favor of blocking people or stopping people from buying what they want to make their financial lives for them and their families better. I'm a huge fan of them being able to do that. And I'm a huge fan of your girlfriend being able to do whatever she can to serve her needs. So it's just kind of, you know, you're often talking in our conversations last time and today about things right now. [01:27:43] Cory Klippsten: Whereas I'm very focused on an ultimate goal and building blocks that get us to where I think the world is going 10, 20 years from now. And again, I very readily admit that's somewhat because of the luxury of living where I do and serving the client base that we do. [01:28:05] Vlad Costea: Right. But at the same time, in order for these people to get access to USDT, they do need to exchange some fiat somehow. And then some countries, they cannot even do that. So how do they get access to any kind of Bitcoin or USDT or whatever? In some cases, they mine Bitcoin, but that's becoming increasingly harder for someone who just lives in their home and has a normal computer. It is more compelling to mine Monero or something, but even that one takes a long time. [01:28:37] Cory Klippsten: But now you're just talking about like, how do you make money? And so you could also do like Upwork or Fiverr, just like work remotely or something like that. [01:28:44] Vlad Costea: But that requires a bank account or something, access to basic financial services. [01:28:49] Cory Klippsten: Not necessarily. Lots of them will send stablecoins or Bitcoin too. You can get paid in Bitcoin by all kinds of remote work. [01:28:57] Vlad Costea: Well, not on Upwork, I think. [01:29:00] Cory Klippsten: Probably not Upwork, but I mean, there's stuff out there. I mean, I just— [01:29:06] Vlad Costea: [unclear: You can see] Bitcoiner Jobs, which is a website that you started with Swan. [01:29:09] Cory Klippsten: Bitcoiner Jobs. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But Bitcoiner Jobs is not, unfortunately, just jobs that pay in Bitcoin. Although lots of them do. It's actually a job board for the Bitcoin industry. We do have another one that we started building. I don't know if the domain is still up. It might be, but we haven't put much effort into it, but we built Bitlist and still own the domain. Yeah. And we were running it for a couple of years. And that was basically like all kinds of things for sale. [01:29:43] Cory Klippsten: Mostly services for sale in Bitcoin. Interestingly, I bought that domain. Did you ever see The Rise and Rise of Bitcoin? It's on Amazon and it came out in like 2014. It's the best, right? Yeah. So I— what was the guy's name? I'm blanking on his name, but I bought the domain from the main guy. The guy that was like mining Bitcoin in his basement. [01:30:06] Vlad Costea: Oh, that's so cool. [01:30:08] Cory Klippsten: Yeah. Yeah. He's been squatting on bitlist.com for ages and we snagged it. I hope to do something with it again soon. [01:30:16] Vlad Costea: If you have his email or something, I would love to reach out to him, get him on the show, because there are so many cool stories to tell. That guy was mining from his basement on a bunch of machines before ASICs. He had GPU rigs. [01:30:31] Cory Klippsten: Yeah. And it's like him and it was his girlfriend or his wife and like his brother is in it. And yeah, they just kind of, I mean, it's a pretty wide ranging documentary with a lot of people, but they use him as kind of like the central, you know, central character throughout it. Yeah. I'll look it up and see if he's game to chat with you. [01:30:47] Vlad Costea: And everyone listening to this should check out The Rise and Rise of Bitcoin. It's also on YouTube for free, so you don't have to pay for Amazon, basically. You're gonna see a lot of the OGs because this guy goes into the home of Mike Caldwell, who was making the Casascius coins. He goes, he [unclear: doxxes] Gavin Andresen, who at the time was the maintainer of the Bitcoin project and was the main figure of the whole movement. He was going on podcasts and promoting Bitcoin. Really amazing. Like, you can see so many great names. [01:31:20] Vlad Costea: Also, what's his name? Nick Spanos, the first guy to create a market on Wall Street for Bitcoins. [01:31:26] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, I met up with that guy a couple times. He's got hella stories. It was Daniel Mross. M-R-O-S-S was the guy. Yeah, Karpelès is in that documentary, too. Yeah, it is pretty wild. [01:31:44] Vlad Costea: It's really amazing to think how far these people have made it. At least some of them. There's also Vitalik. You can see Vitalik presenting his magazine to Eric Voorhees. It was at PorcFest 2014 or something, when they met for the first time. [01:32:03] Vlad Costea: BitInstant, Charlie Shrem. [01:32:04] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, the Winklevii were around back then, trying to fund it. [01:32:16] Vlad Costea: You know, and this goes back to the whole conversation about Bitcoin maximalism and Bitcoin only. Because there used to be a time when Bitcoin only was basically the only choice. Like, there was nothing else interesting. Everyone was a Bitcoiner. Everyone was part of this big family. And then I guess somewhere during the scaling debate, the community sort of split. And we had people who wanted to do tokens in DeFi and they went to Ethereum. And I guess there were lots of forks or sub-communities that emerged from that. [01:32:52] Vlad Costea: Nowadays it's more divided than ever. [01:32:56] Cory Klippsten: Maybe. I don't know. It doesn't feel more divided than ever to me. And I don't think I've been in Bitcoin as long as you. I came in, obviously, in 2017. But it felt like peak division was when there was $100 billion of altcoin VC funding going into altcoins. And they were deliberately lying about Bitcoin to try to pump their coins. And I feel like the, you know, basically like slandering Bitcoin and lying about Bitcoin to try to pump your coin is something we don't see anymore. And it's why I don't really care to fight the last battle. [01:33:29] Cory Klippsten: And you don't see me getting in flame wars with shitcoiners anymore. I honestly really don't care. Bitcoin is doing its thing. Bitcoin is separated from crypto in the minds of the market, the media, regulators, asset managers. It's just kind of obvious that it's a separate thing and then there's all non-Bitcoin crypto. And I think that's enough. I don't think most Bitcoiners really care much. Not to mention that obviously lots of Bitcoiners are techy and actually like to stay on top of developments in tech, even if it comes from the crypto world. [01:34:08] Cory Klippsten: And it's like we talked about the last time a few days ago. Like it's silly to think that with tens of thousands of developers and more than $100 billion going into it, that there won't be some interesting, cool tech developments coming out of an industry. Even if you dislike the tokens, it's impossible that some good things won't come out of it. There's probably cool things in encryption. And obviously, I think we talked about SegWit being [unclear: trialed] on Litecoin and there's all kinds of things that you like to track. [01:34:37] Cory Klippsten: I'm aware that Bcash tries and maybe some of it's cool and gets adopted by Bitcoin someday. So it's not like there aren't good things that come out of this. It's not even an argument for me. It's really just a conclusion that I look at the empirical evidence of, let's say 30 million total, but that includes all the meme coins. But let's call it 20 to 30,000 actual attempts at layer one networks and their tokens all go to zero in Bitcoin terms over time. And other than two, Ripple, a scam, and Doge, a joke, are the only ones to ever have a second all time high. [01:35:18] Cory Klippsten: So it's from an economic perspective and where to spend my time. And I'm not an engineer. And so I just don't really have any time to spend on altcoins unless somebody influential. And this basically, I think this was a Szabo thing that I picked up and it was basically, God, it would be really embarrassing. It was actually Naval. I mixed it up because they had that great podcast where Nick Szabo went on— [01:35:47] Vlad Costea: Tim Ferriss, yeah. [01:35:49] Cory Klippsten: Tim Ferriss from 2017. Tim Ferriss in, like, 2017. It's like two hours, 34 minutes. It's a great show. And Tim Ferriss basically brought Naval on to translate some of the things that Nick was saying so that Tim could understand them and go deeper. So it's a great conversation. It used to be one of my top links that I sent to people in my early days. And I think it was in that conversation that it was something like, you only need to combat influential ignorance. And so if somebody is saying something ignorant about Bitcoin or whatever, and it's not actually influential, you can kind of ignore it and don't have to pick up the shield and the spear and fight that fight. [01:36:25] Cory Klippsten: It's basically only if it actually is having impact and it's kind of like really hitting your radar, like your customers or your clients or whatever are asking about it. And then you might have to actually dive in and refute the bullshit. And there's very little lately that rises to that level where I actually have like noise rising up and becoming a problem where I have to actually dig in and take something down. It's just super infrequent. And so that's why I say I don't really see the divide being nearly as strong as it was in the last battle. [01:37:01] Cory Klippsten: It seems like that kind of ended, probably ended with the launch of the ETFs, honestly. That's kind of when, I mean, there's a whole other can of worms with Larry Fink now taking over the WEF. He's the new chairman, which is kind of really creepy and gross. And I think there's a lot of cracks in the folks that have been leading the charge on Bitcoin, whether it's Milei or El Salvador's new permanent autocracy and kind of on and on, you know, slay your heroes. But yeah, there's a lot of chinks in the armor of some of the recent folks in the vanguard of Bitcoin for sure. [01:37:39] Vlad Costea: Vanguard, pun intended. [01:37:42] Cory Klippsten: Good point. High fidelity here, the signal from Vlad. [01:37:48] Vlad Costea: Nice one. Anyway, what you just said about noise sounds more like a Naval kind of quote. I don't think Nick Szabo is concerned too much about dispelling FUD or something like this. Honestly, if you read his articles, which are on his blog, that's called Unenumerated, they're really amazing. Like this guy is thinking about space exploration, is thinking about why we still digest milk, is thinking about a lot of interesting questions about law and also technology. And back in the 90s, he had this concept of the God protocol, which basically meant that you had something like a watch where you look at a watch or a clock and you don't disagree with the time because everyone basically syncs according to that mechanism that tells you what time it is. [01:38:49] Vlad Costea: And he wanted to create something similar for money and for enforcing law. Like this objective oracle to which everyone can look up and say, well, this is pointing to me that this is true and this is not in this situation. Like very ahead of his time, very smart, not much of a coder, but a visionary. And I think what's happening today with Bitcoin and also Ethereum, in which he was involved early on, is trying to get to that point of God protocols. It's just that the technology doesn't scale as greatly as we would wish. [01:39:28] Vlad Costea: And also the average person does not understand the value in this. And we have an obsolete legal and political system, which maybe we're going to replace, maybe not. I'm not sure if I'm a conservative in this regard. Anyway, check out Nick Szabo. And where was I going with this God protocols, Nick Szabo? [01:39:51] Vlad Costea: I was going to go back to Bitcoin maximalism somehow, but I don't remember what the point was. [01:39:56] Cory Klippsten: I have a question for you, if you want to go off on a tangent. Do you have a good definition for Bitcoin minimalism? [01:40:07] Vlad Costea: Not really. Like minimalism, it just means like you're trying to minimize something. What are you minimizing, your involvement? [01:40:14] Cory Klippsten: No, I mean, there's a handle that's always on all my threads that, you know, actually often says very smart things. And I don't know what their actual handle is, but their name is BTC minimalist. And I've seen it in some people's profiles that they say Bitcoin minimalist. And I don't know what it means. [01:40:33] Vlad Costea: I think it's Bitcoin and nothing else. And that's what minimalist means. Like you don't need anything else except for Bitcoin. [01:40:39] Cory Klippsten: So you see it as kind of like a play on maximalism, but similar. [01:40:44] Vlad Costea: It's pretty smart. I got to give him credit for it because minimalism and lifestyle means that you don't need much. [01:40:54] Vlad Costea: Maximalism is... For example, in art, it means that you're going to cover your whole house in paintings and find purpose for every tiny spot. Also in architecture, maximalism is what you see in Paris, mostly, or Vienna, or Florence. It's using every piece of space to make something beautiful in it. But anyway, the point that I was trying to make relates to Bitcoin as Linux. It's something that I think about a lot. It's something that was being used back in the early days to say, well, Bitcoin is going to be the main monetary network and people will use Bitcoin without even knowing that they're using Bitcoin. [01:41:37] Vlad Costea: Basically, every transaction will be settled using Bitcoin technology, but people will still think that they're using their local currencies, which is similar with how we're using the Internet today, because we have a Windows machine and we're accessing a website which runs on Linux. [01:41:57] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, that's interesting. [01:42:02] Cory Klippsten: Look, I think in the end, there will be a time when basically Bitcoin is global money that all humans use. I think it actually is kind of a terminal monopoly and maybe outside of a few remaining lockdown autocracies that have capital flight rules and people can't immigrate and things like that. I do think we'll actually get there and it will replace the dollar and the euro and the yen and all the other major currencies. I think it's going to take a long time. My earliest prediction for that is probably like 2080. [01:42:41] Cory Klippsten: And I think it's more likely that it's next century. [01:42:45] Vlad Costea: So not in our lifetime. [01:42:51] Cory Klippsten: We might make it, bro. You have a good shot. Aren't you like early 30s or something? [01:42:57] Vlad Costea: 33. [01:42:58] Cory Klippsten: 33. Yeah, you have a better shot than me. I got 14 years on you. [01:43:03] Vlad Costea: I'm not very optimistic about this. Like I know some people work on making lives much longer. It's just that I feel like our relevance in this world is very limited. So if you make your life longer, it's not like you're going to come up with genius ideas. I think you have like maybe 20 years when you can make a difference and then you become a rent seeker. That's what I've seen. [01:43:29] Cory Klippsten: You become a life enjoyer. Like this incredible gift that we have to be on this spinning rock and actually be sentient and be able to have family members and friends to enjoy. Yeah, you best take advantage of that incredible gift. [01:43:43] Vlad Costea: Sure, but I think in Bitcoin, everything is accelerated. I think before Bitcoin, all of these market cycles were taking maybe a generation and people were seeing a huge bull market and a massive bear maybe in 60 years. But now we see this every four years. And you also see this in developers and you see how people who were in Bitcoin like 10 years ago have given up on their ideals from 10 years ago. And then you see the new generation of developers like Robin Linus, whom you mentioned in the previous part. [01:44:15] Vlad Costea: He comes along and says, what do you mean you cannot do this? Like here's how you can. And I think it's beautiful that you always have this hungry, youthful energy, someone looking for validation and trying to do something great as opposed to having someone like Peter Todd who gave up. And right now he's shilling Solana meme coins on his account for 5K. [01:44:41] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, yeah, it is wild. And it's interesting too, just like, just having, sparking an idea and maybe not even coding it can be enough to spark something totally new, right? It was Burak, right here in Turkey who came up with the idea for Ark and he's not even involved in it, he moved on to something else. But off it goes with multiple competing companies, you know, shipping wallets and doing cool shit. And all it took was, you know, the initial idea and saying, guys, this is actually possible. [01:45:14] Cory Klippsten: And then people said, oh my God, yeah, and ran with it. So look, I don't want to be ever short human innovation. We have lots of ideas coming from all kinds of disparate sources for sure. [01:45:28] Vlad Costea: But going back to the idea of Bitcoin as Linux, this can also mean that Bitcoin is a code base that anyone can copy and spin off their own network with different parameters and maybe cut some features, add some other features, then launch their own coin and see what the market thinks about it. And maybe that from a financial point of view, this can be referred to as degeneracy or shitcoinery or whatever. But on the long term, if there is anything interesting here, there is nothing that's stopping Bitcoin developers from looking at it and saying, well, this is sort of a major breakthrough. [01:46:03] Vlad Costea: Like we did not think this can happen. This has actual users who want this to happen. Maybe we can incorporate this into Bitcoin. [01:46:12] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, look, it's the, that's the bull case for shitcoinery, right? Is that, well, I guess that's the, that's the moral case for shitcoining. Is that something good will actually come of this, even though the token value doesn't last in the long run. And, you know, because it can rise in its early adoption phases and if you're early, you can catch that pump and potentially profit and then have more Bitcoin than you otherwise would. And before it dumps, like that's, that's something lots of people will always participate in. [01:46:45] Cory Klippsten: So again, we talked about the fact that almost nothing, very few things out there are purely 100% negative. You know, even things that are net negative often have some positive things in the pro column or some positive externalities or something like that. So, you know, and very few things that we consider super good, like Bitcoin even, have nothing in the con column. There will be massive disruption at a societal level, economic level, all kinds of things as Bitcoin continues to rise and sort of make the relative value of other asset classes decline. [01:47:21] Cory Klippsten: That's going to cause massive disruption in the opportunity and all kinds of different things. So, you know, very few things are 100% positive or negative. [01:47:31] Vlad Costea: At the same time, if you spend a couple of days reading forums in the Linux community, you're going to see that they hate each other. And whenever someone comes along and raises funding or because most of them are radical leftists, they're very idealistic about their own work and they see something evil in the concept of making money, but they do need to pay bills. So whenever someone forks a code base and launches a commercial version of Linux and they're able to sell it to some government or whatever. [01:48:00] Vlad Costea: They get angry at them and they're like, no, you're not supposed to use it like this. But at the same time on the plus side, these people who are purchasing commercial licenses for Linux are going to need support. And the only people who can provide support are actually the radical left developers who built the code base and are capable to offer consultancy. So they actually make a living because of the people who are able to sell it. And I think in Bitcoin, it's sort of similar, like we're angry at the shitcoiners for being able to ICO and do stuff like this. [01:48:34] Vlad Costea: But then we see that the exchanges that enabled this are also funding Bitcoin developers to do stuff. [01:48:42] Cory Klippsten: Well, don't forget, I mean, people are just kind of angry about monetization in general and capitalism often. Even in Bitcoin, people hate podcasters, they hate conference organizers, they hate financial services companies. They hate wallet makers. Like there's always always a reason to hate somebody or accuse them of monetizing around Bitcoin. It'll always be there. [01:49:08] Vlad Costea: I remember at the peak of this craze, there was that guy, DeaterBob, or Awyee, A-W-Y-E-E. [01:49:15] Cory Klippsten: Awyee DeaterBob and his famous argument that got recorded with American HODL. [01:49:23] Vlad Costea: Ah, he sits by the pool all day. I get it. But my point is that when Hodlonaut launched his project, which is Citadel21, it's this magazine where he was inviting people to write. He was like, so what's your motive for this? Are you trying to make a profit? Are you trying to make money off of this? Are you milking your reputation or whatever to make more money? And I was like, what's wrong with that? It's not like releasing a product that people want and making them subscribe to it is evil. [01:49:57] Cory Klippsten: Look, I'll give an example, like a FOMO21 shop, you know, Neil Jacobs' Bitcoin clothing store, right? Like it's, he's just so responsive. If I want, if I want something on a shirt, he'll just put it on there and it'll be available for sale like five minutes later and I can just buy it. So I can just be like, I want, you know, a swan and in the middle of a sun shirt and, you know, he ran it through some AI and came up with a design and now I have tank tops. [01:50:26] Cory Klippsten: Like, it's awesome. Do I care that I probably slightly overpaid for a tank top and paid 29 bucks? Not really, because he did a service for me and it got delivered to my house a few days later, you know? So should I be mad at him for making Bitcoin related merchandise available? No, thank you for putting in the effort and creating a store and making that really easy for me so I don't have to do it myself. [01:50:51] Vlad Costea: You seem to believe that Bitcoin will be in this price discovery phase for a long time and it's gonna take a while until markets get built for Bitcoin as a unit of exchange and also unit of account. When do you think we're seriously gonna see Bitcoin being used as money as opposed to just speculation? [01:51:12] Cory Klippsten: So look, it's already used as money quite a lot. It's used as a currency, right? Medium of exchange quite a lot, but it depends on the use case. So I pay a lot of Swan contractors in Bitcoin around the world and we pay for services and vendors here and there in Bitcoin. Sometimes I settle something in Bitcoin, you know, for conference or something like that. So like, selectively, we already use it, especially for international payments. One thing that I thought, so in monetary theory, that's generally, you know, kind of rationally understood and accepted by most folks in the Bitcoin space. [01:51:49] Cory Klippsten: You know, you've seen the chart of like the development of a new money along its stages and it goes from like collectible to store of value to medium of exchange to unit of account. You know, one of the interesting things that seems to be happening right now is like, there's a lot of people and obviously a lot of companies that are going SoV to UoA next. So they're thinking about their unit of account. You know, Bitcoin is the denominator straight from store of value. I've had a, I've had a framework around medium of exchange, at least in the West and not for just edge use cases that you're going to need to see at least a million dollars a coin, possibly $2 million a coin. [01:52:34] Cory Klippsten: So like somewhere between 20 and 40 trillion market cap before you actually see spending takeoff in the West. So I think we're a ways off. I think it's something that actually takes off in the 2030s. I posted, you know, I probably posted in 2020 or 21 for the first time that, you know, it was my expectation that you'll be able to purchase most goods and services around the world, denominated in satoshis by 2035. So that was, that's only 10 years from now. And I think for a long time, that will be, you know, multiple price tags. [01:53:07] Cory Klippsten: So it'll be like, you know, just like you're at the, you know, an airport or, you know, in a tourist place and they'll have the price and in, you know, euros and pounds. But I think you'll have the Satoshi price as well, at checkout in lots of places, or at least a toggle where you can, you know, switch currencies between dollars and satoshis or euros and satoshis something like that. [01:53:32] Cory Klippsten: It's roughly five years since I had that first forecast of saying like 2035, that feels like the earliest edge for that. Like, I think that would be a wildly bullish case if in 10 years, that's true. Cause that's a really high bar to say, like, you know, most goods and services around the world will also be priced in satoshis. That feels really aggressive given what I'm seeing. It seems like we're just still so early in the adoption of Bitcoin as a store of value. And like, it's just, this bull market in particular just doesn't seem to have much retail participation. [01:54:10] Cory Klippsten: There's not that many new faces, not that many new people. You know, the institutional adoption of Bitcoin is good in some ways. And frankly, just inevitable the way it happened, which kind of came part and parcel with almost pure alignment with the political right in the United States. And kind of Trumpism, I think has been like a massive turnoff for mainstream media, which generally skews super left and, you know, probably half the population that just got kind of really turned off by all the crypto grift that came along with it. [01:54:48] Cory Klippsten: And the fact that the election cycle, you know, pretty much was paid for by non Bitcoin crypto money. And that's where all, that's where all the, that's where all the, obviously the legislative activity ever since Trump took office has all been around crypto and stablecoins and like nothing has gotten done around Bitcoin. And that's not surprising, what will make a difference, you know, which I don't expect until the next decade, sometime in the 2030s and probably earliest, something like 2035 would be the repeal of cap gains tax on Bitcoin. [01:55:22] Cory Klippsten: But you're not going to see that until there's until it's wildly popular to do so. So there needs to be a lot more individual Bitcoiners that care about that, where that's a voting issue and where they are like clamoring for it and where it's broadly popular. If you tried to repeal cap gains tax on Bitcoin today completely in the United States, it would be wildly unpopular because it would be seen as just serving the interests of Trump aligned, you know, technocrat people who got lucky. Like it's just like the mainstream narrative around Bitcoin is nowhere close to where it needs to be. [01:55:57] Vlad Costea: Well, yeah, we can play this political game, but we also have until then some options and I'm not saying you should use them. I'm just saying you can use them to transact with privacy, the kind of privacy that makes any kind of reporting very difficult. And the state will have no idea that a transaction happened in the first place. Yeah, [01:56:19] Cory Klippsten: and you can do that. You can do that, obviously, with Bitcoin today with Lightning and lots of people do and they're not reporting their transactions and nobody's going to come after them. Like you're just you're not going to get audited overspending Bitcoin, at least on everyday things. It's just not going to happen. And that's basically how most Bitcoiners operate if they choose to spend Bitcoin in the West. That's how they operate. Nobody's really reporting those as sales and paying cap gains tax on that. They're only doing it if they're selling like a rather large chunk and, you know, have to buy a kid's college tuition or buy a car or something like that, then they're reporting it. [01:56:55] Vlad Costea: Let me ask you something which is possibly controversial, and it starts from a very basic example. If you go to BTCheads.com, you're going to find my collection of cards which I deployed on Bitcoin as ordinals and also counterparty tokens. Am I a shitcoiner if I pay the Bitcoin miners and I put this data on Bitcoin and expect people to also pay Bitcoin for it? Or is it better to move it to Solana, which doesn't pay the Bitcoin miners, competes on the market with BTC, the token, and also increases the network effect of something else, which is not Bitcoin? [01:57:35] Vlad Costea: Like, which one is the worst? Because you can also argue that Solana at least doesn't put data on Bitcoin and keeps it only for monetary transactions. [01:57:46] Cory Klippsten: Well, first, I don't think that NFTs are shitcoins. [01:57:52] Cory Klippsten: So you may be surprised by that. But I really don't have any problem with digital art. Where I went after the whole NFT scam complex in 2021 was because they basically did find and replace on all their pitch decks and their tweets and their podcasts and just replaced blockchain with NFT. And so it was all the false marketing claims that came along with so many of the NFT projects claiming that all this, you know, basically, like 2017-18 blockchain ICO era marketing narratives were like being attached to these NFTs and saying that they were going to do all these things around royalties and, you know, etc, etc. [01:58:30] Cory Klippsten: And it was all bullshit. And so that's where I kind of just call them out for being I don't I don't like pump and dump scams, but that's like a mild displeasure because they exist all over the place inside and outside of crypto. But I think the, you know, in as much as I still had a bit of bite left in me for all the scam crypto blockchain, DeFi, NFT, VCs and founders pumping false narratives to like pump their coins, you know, and in as much as that was like accruing to Ethereum or Solana or whatever. [01:59:01] Cory Klippsten: Like, I had a mild displeasure based on that. But I actually don't have any, any kind of moral or economic issue with digital art. And I totally understand why people would want to actually own a digital signature proving that they have the original one that the artist intended to be the one of the one of one like, I think that is natural. I don't have any. And it's not for me, but like I've always understood, at least I am a believer in the maybe it's a fiction, maybe it's not. [01:59:33] Cory Klippsten: But I am a believer in the concept of a unique piece of digital art, even if it is just like a signature that corresponds to something that can easily be right clicked and saved. And I've always thought that since 2017 when I first came into the space, a lot of people probably don't know that the first thing I ever did in crypto was consult to BLOCKv, which was one of the very first NFT platforms, which I started in like November of 2017 and did for a couple of months, just helping them figure out what to do with all their money after their ICO. [02:00:07] Cory Klippsten: I spent a couple months helping Eric and Reeve Collins, who was the creator of Tether and Craig Sellars was there as like a CTO board member, something like that. He was one of the creators of Tether as well. So they were all in LA and they had just done this ICO for BLOCKv and had a ton of money. And that was like my first paycheck in the space. I had just been consulting and advising and cutting angel checks into startups since leaving Google in 2013. [02:00:36] Cory Klippsten: And that was my first dipping the toe in the water. And actually doing something in the space was for BLOCKv. And it was NFTs. And I believed in digital art then and it still makes sense to me now. And I don't think it's shitcoining. I just don't like scams. So if you're scamming and you have false marketing promises, well, that's a problem in any industry. It's not unique to NFTs. [02:01:00] Vlad Costea: My first job in the space was writing articles for $15 a piece for a website that is no longer around, but it was called CryptoGlobe, and they paid in Bitcoin and I haven't spent it, and I think overall it was a pretty nice paycheck. But— [02:01:21] Cory Klippsten: So I have an idea, by the way, for you, for— we were just talking about longevity, and I forgot to make this joke, but I feel like you could slick your hair back a little bit and basically, like, whiten your skin a bit. So you need to be more pale and you could probably, you could probably be Bryan Johnson for Halloween. [02:01:39] Vlad Costea: Bryan Johnson? [02:01:40] Cory Klippsten: Bryan Johnson. [02:01:41] Vlad Costea: The guy from AC/DC? [02:01:42] Cory Klippsten: No, the guy that's trying to live to be like a million years old. He started Braintree. [02:01:48] Vlad Costea: Oh, no. [02:01:50] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, you know who I'm talking about, the vampire guy in LA. [02:01:53] Vlad Costea: He looks very creepy. [02:01:55] Cory Klippsten: He looks very creepy. He's got like very, very thin translucent skin and like doesn't like sun and stuff. He's like the anti-[unclear: Steven Lucca]. [02:02:03] Vlad Costea: Isn't he the guy who takes blood from his son or something? [02:02:06] Cory Klippsten: I don't think so. But I hope not. [02:02:11] Vlad Costea: No, but this trend comes from Peter Thiel, who allegedly takes younger blood and puts that into his system. [02:02:22] Cory Klippsten: There's supposedly a lot of Silicon Valley guys doing that, trying to get the blood of Stanford swimmers. Anyway, creepy. [02:02:31] Vlad Costea: I was going to ask you since I guess we're heading towards the end of the interview, you said you only have one hour and I do have to ask you how is Swan doing? Because last year you had a very unfortunate moment when you had to lay off a lot of people and it seemed like the end was close. But I guess you guys are rebounding or— [02:02:53] Cory Klippsten: Growing. I mean, we're fine. We're yeah, we're, we've been growing all year. Really had a, had a pretty bang up year and we'll finish like pretty, pretty aggressively profitable on the year, which is great. But yeah, I mean, it was basically, and this is all in court filings. There's no, no real secret here, but basically Tether and some of their executives like conspired with a couple of my mining executives to steal the mining business. So they stole all the documents and stole a bunch of our IP and like walked out the door and set up a shell company as a competitor and basically just walked the business out the door. [02:03:27] Cory Klippsten: So, you know, that was, that was a big hit and that was a lot of our revenue and expected revenue. So we had been investing a lot in the financial services business and had to stop that basically had to stop, stop spending at the clip that we were kind of immediately. So that was what happened last July, July, August, I guess. But anyway, we rebounded, we continue to pursue our rights and our unfortunate loss in multiple jurisdictions around the world, trying to hunt them down and get our fair value for what they took. [02:04:00] Cory Klippsten: But, you know, that usually takes a while in court. [02:04:05] Vlad Costea: I remember Swan was super cool in Bitcoin circles, even Max Keiser had a referral link. I don't have one, but I got to ask you, why should people still use Swan? Like what is special about it compared to something like, let's say River Financial, which I think is very similar. [02:04:23] Cory Klippsten: Yeah, I think, I think on the services end, you know, each of each of the Bitcoin financial services companies in the US have a slightly different array of services. So I'd say like Unchained, Fold, probably Strike, River and Swan have been the five that have, have kind of made it and are going to be around. At least for the foreseeable future. We all like, we have, we have retirement accounts and Unchained has them, the other three don't, we have multisig and Unchained has multisig, the other three don't. [02:04:59] Cory Klippsten: So it kind of just depends on, kind of just depends on like which company you want to be served by. And that's kind of depends on how you align with, you know, our values and our salespeople. Obviously, we were the first one with a sales team, nobody had ever had like a proper private client services, you know, sales team in the Bitcoin space until we did. And we kind of built that model. And lots of people have kind of copied it since, but we still have the biggest one and do the most business through it. [02:05:31] Cory Klippsten: You know, but we talked about a few days ago when we chatted, you know, why people use Swan. I really think it comes down to wanting to have a personal relationship or something that's so new to so many people, especially high net worth folks that are used to talking to you like a financial advisor or just having like a lot of support from companies that they use. Like they just don't feel well-served by popping onto a crypto exchange and being bombarded with marketing messages for all the altcoins and not having somebody to talk to and just kind of feeling like, you know, just an account number. [02:06:05] Cory Klippsten: And so having, you know, a really rock solid customer service team, and then obviously for all our private clients also having a sales rep that they can just hit up on like WhatsApp or call anytime, makes a huge difference. And again, we also mentioned like, you know, mostly what they want to talk about is Bitcoin itself, like these are not these conversations that they have are about life and family and their plans and how to think about the trade offs between, you know, like think about like one spouse that's pretty orange pilled. [02:06:33] Cory Klippsten: And the other one doesn't know anything about, about hard wallets and self-custody and trying to figure out where they want to be on the spectrum. So like, as an example, you know, we've got both self-custody, which is probably 75 to 80% of the Bitcoin that's ever been sold through Swan has been taken off platform into self-custody. We have a two-of-three multisig called Swan Vault, which is client has two keys. We have one as a backup. And then we also have on the far end of the spectrum, what I would call like the fourth stop is full custody in third party custody, almost all with BitGo. [02:07:10] Cory Klippsten: And we're building and hope to have it out, you know, early next year, basically the third stop, which would be a Swan and client, basically client has one key in the Swan app that's a biometric and then two other institutions. It'll probably be Coincover and BitGo we'll have the other keys. So it's basically multi-institutional multi-jurisdictional tri-party custody. And interestingly, that's probably going to be, I think the most popular one for a lot of family offices and like high net worth families. They actually don't want to be responsible for two keys. [02:07:45] Cory Klippsten: They only want one key, but they want to make sure that it's more than one counterparty that they, that basically two large regulated companies would have to collude to move their coins. And then being in different jurisdictions makes that extremely unlikely. So it's things like that. Like that's the type of thing that you're just not going to see a Coinbase actually take on and actually try to solve for their clients. So— [02:08:10] Vlad Costea: But it does sound like Casa, like you guys are trying to compete with what Casa are doing right now. Except that their multisig is three-of-five. [02:08:18] Cory Klippsten: Yeah. Again, so like that's, that's in one, one product set, but what we're basically building is like all of the products and services that one might need around Bitcoin as an asset class, which is much more like Fidelity. So Casa does something kind of narrow. They don't have much brokerage. They don't have retirement accounts. Like there's all these things they don't have. We work on having everything from, you know, we'll have Bitcoin interest on dollar accounts. We have a credit card coming out with Bitcoin rewards. We have asset-backed loans today. [02:08:49] Cory Klippsten: Brokerage savings accounts, retirement accounts, four flavors of custody. You know, you just kind of want to have everything that somebody might need getting into Bitcoin and be able to guide them toward the array of products and services that fit what their goals are and what their kind of, what their risk model is, what they're scared of. [02:09:11] Vlad Costea: Interesting. It's nice that you're exploring new ways to expand your business and you're also using Bitcoin more. Did you consider becoming your own custodian, like having a proper exchange or is it just more convenient for you to use a third party? [02:09:30] Cory Klippsten: So we have, and I think that you'll see as, as we plan to build a large Bitcoin treasury and, you know, have that with Swan, whether we merge into somebody or launch it ourselves. You'll probably see us replace the OTC desks with ourselves being on both sides of the trade so that it's still a brokerage model, not an exchange model. Exchange means you actually have an order book. So Cash App is a broker, but Cash App is actually selling and buying Bitcoin from their own accounts. [02:10:01] Cory Klippsten: They're facing their users on those trades. We don't do that today, nor do, nor do any of the others, nor do Fold, Strike, River, Unchained. Like nobody is, everybody's using OTC desks and matching orders as they come in, nobody's trading their own stack. We do want to trade our own stack eventually, but there's no rush. And right now we don't have the size to be able to do that because the orders that come in are like too big for us to handle. But hopefully over time, when we have a bigger Bitcoin balance sheet, we will actually face our users on trades and be able to claw back. [02:10:33] Cory Klippsten: I mean, it's not, it's not a lot. You're talking probably like, depending on the volatility, something between like seven and 20 bps on average, like 0.07 to 0.2% that we have to pay out to OTC desks. So it's not a huge savings, but I do want to have all that control. And then the other question is basically like licensing. So for asset-backed loans today, we only do what's called commercial size loans and it's different by state. So some states, anything above 25,000 is commercial. [02:11:04] Cory Klippsten: Other states, anything above 50,000 and then some states, anything above a hundred thousand is considered commercial. And that means you don't need a lending specific money transmission license in that state. We made the decision that we are only going to do a hundred thousand plus. So that's all we do. Obviously there's a ton of retail that wants to have lower amounts, but you know, you need like a lot of scale and a lot of marketing to make it worth doing because there's not that much money in it for us to do small loans. [02:11:35] Cory Klippsten: Plus it comes with all the licensing costs and time probably take, you know, two years to get all the licenses that we'd need to go sub hundred, sub 50, sub-25K. So it's not something that we're interested in right now. We're just doing larger ones, which is the same approach that you see with Strike. Strike only does a commercial asset-backed loans. I think, I don't think they have small ones. So it's just, it's just going to take a while. Like there's always something new that we can add. [02:12:03] Cory Klippsten: I mean, we built Lightning at Swan back in like 21, 22, like it functions, but we don't have MTLs. And so we don't make it available to customers, but because our withdrawals are all batched into a single, you know, we basically do a withdrawal like once an hour, once every two hours or once every four hours or something like that, you know, nobody pays anything. Anyway, we've never had withdrawal fees. So like, because we're not some massive exchange like Binance or something where, you know, maybe you need to pay Lightspark to do Lightning withdrawals or something like that. [02:12:33] Cory Klippsten: It's just not something that people ask for. Nobody's asking us for a Lightning withdrawal because they have never paid for a withdrawal from Swan ever in all of our history. [02:12:43] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's cool. I've also remembered that two or three years ago, I read the news about Swan purchasing a company that's called Specter, which is operating a hardware wallet, which is a hundred percent open source. And also they have their own multisig system. [02:13:00] Cory Klippsten: Yeah. Yeah. So we've obviously continued to help the Specter Association, you know, run on its own and the team came in and did an amazing job. I think two of, two of the original Specter guys still work at Swan. And then we've helped stand up the Specter Association, which is, you know, basically completely operating separately and we still leverage all their code and tech. And that's how you do the, like the trustless recovery for Swan Vault is still all built on Specter and integrated with Specter. [02:13:29] Cory Klippsten: So very supportive kind of in the ecosystem, but, you know, completely controls its own destiny outside of us. Maybe, I gotta check. Possibly Yan's like an advisor. I should probably check, but, you know, that's always been kind of the Moritz show, Moritz Wietersheim and some of his friends, mostly in Europe working on Specter. And yeah, I mean, it's one of the most respected and most flexible desktop hardware multisig solutions out there. And yeah, I'm really glad that it's kind of the basis of what we built with Swan Vault. [02:14:08] Vlad Costea: Yeah. That was going to be my follow-up question. If you're going to be using the technology that you basically purchased with Specter to back up your own multisig system. [02:14:19] Cory Klippsten: Yep. That is exactly how it works. I mean, we built Swan Vault fresh from the ground up with a lot of the know-how from that team. We also had both Vijay Boyapati and Rearden Code on the team for the two years that we built Vault. So they obviously contributed a ton and helped make it awesome. So that was, that was a big heavy lift now kind of in maintenance mode and just adding features. The team is probably like three or four, but for a couple of years there, it was like seven people. [02:14:51] Vlad Costea: To wrap this up and get back on topic. I'm going to ask you to name a few examples of good Bitcoin maximalism and a few bad examples of Bitcoin maximalism. [02:15:05] Cory Klippsten: All right. Look, I generally am a fan of like knowing what you know and knowing what you don't know and don't act confident if you are in the gray area or in the red area. So if I see somebody speaking with an air of complete confidence, they better fucking be right. I'm like, I find it just repulsive to have like really arrogant ignorance is really repulsive to me. And so I think that's probably my litmus test in general. So when I see in your terms, you know, what I would just say, like being a Bitcoiner and talking about Bitcoin or Bitcoin maximalism for you. [02:15:54] Cory Klippsten: I like people that know their shit. And when they're in the gray area, they're asking questions or maybe poking or like clearly marking something as opinion. This probably comes from my, you know, my early experience as a journalist. That was, that was my training. That was what I did in high school. It's what I did in college. And I was a really shitty local NBC TV reporter 25 years ago in the U.S. Before I got into tech. So, you know, I'm all about objectivity and, you know, kind of old school, professional journalism, nothing like what we see today for the most part. [02:16:30] Cory Klippsten: But so that's probably it. So I think, you know, some of the smarter and more polite people like an Allen Farrington or Lyn Alden are probably like my favorite examples of maximalism and as much as that exists. And then I think someone that has fun with the edges and is right, basically always and is also incredibly smart is probably Giacomo Zucco. So I think, you know, those, some combination of those three are like my spirit animal for maximalism. And then I think there's just a lot of noise. [02:17:06] Cory Klippsten: Like there are, there are just a lot of people just out there, you know, kind of trumpeting things that they don't quite understand. And because they don't necessarily understand where the line is between like what they know, cause they, and what they, you know, maybe they're overstepping. You know, even, even when I engaged here and there around, you know, ordinals and, you know, NFTs and all kinds of things around CTV and everything, like, you'll just see, you can go back and, you know, search my handle for different buzzwords like CTV or whatever. [02:17:41] Cory Klippsten: Like you'll see me asking questions, you'll see me poking and it may even be that there's like a bias to my question, but it's still a question. And I can't come out and state something and pretend that I'm being objective and factual if I don't understand it. And I don't know. So, you know, I use that, I use that demarcation line for, I try to use that demarcation line for everything that I post publicly and everything that I say publicly. But if I'm stating something as fact, you can be damn sure I believe it to be a fact and that I've done my homework. [02:18:15] Cory Klippsten: Otherwise I would be asking a question or adding a bunch of caveats there. [02:18:21] Vlad Costea: But in our previous conversation, you said that you don't like Paul Sztorc, [unclear: creator of] drivechains. And honestly, to me, that's a good example of Bitcoin maximalism because he's trying to bring everything to the network. [02:18:34] Cory Klippsten: As I told you that was based on personal experience and my belief that he is not a, not a high integrity actor with the ways that he tries to get what he wants. I find him to be relatively just kind of deceitful and moves the goalposts and arguments and basically just kind of uses the tools of kind of what I often denigrate as junior varsity debate tactics, the kind of ways that like Udi Wertheimer argues things where he shifts goalposts and is not a genuine actor when he argues things. [02:19:08] Cory Klippsten: I find it very similar. So it's not a technical argument and I don't really give a shit about drivechains other than, you know, I don't find his arguments convincing. And as much as I spent some time two years ago looking at BIP 300 and 301 and talking to him quite a bit on, I think mostly Telegram or Signal, we were going back and forth for a couple of weeks. Maybe we spoke live once and I just didn't find his arguments convincing. And most of the people that I tend to look to for signal have shat all over it. [02:19:37] Cory Klippsten: And so it's just kind of like maybe if it rears its ugly head and like, as I, as I said before, if it rises up from the noise and gets to be to some point where I have to take a Friday night and spend another hour going into it, I will until then I just don't care. [02:19:51] Vlad Costea: Well, there's code right now. So if you, if you want to try that out, it's on layer2labs.com slash download. He has basically every drivechain for Ethereum, Zcash, whatever he wants to bring to Bitcoin, you can run it on the testnet. So it's not just a conversation of what you can do. It's actual code. [02:20:12] Cory Klippsten: There you go. Well, that's a nice message for your audience. I will not be doing that. I don't do that sort of thing, but let me know— [02:20:19] Vlad Costea: It's computer software. You know, that's the way I see a lot of this stuff. Like it costs you maybe 10 minutes to download the wallet and see what you can do with this and make your own opinion. [02:20:29] Cory Klippsten: Cool. Well, let me know next time we chat after you experiment with it. [02:20:37] Vlad Costea: Sure. Okay, Cory, thank you very much. [02:20:40] Cory Klippsten: All right, man, I should wrap. Yeah, I'm glad we could go over this. This worked out great and it was awesome to see you again. And let's not let it be like five years before we talk again. [02:20:49] Vlad Costea: Sure. Whenever you have some product launch or something interesting or spicy to say, you're welcome on the show. [02:20:56] Cory Klippsten: Yeah. Well, I will say the one the one fun thing, which is probably relevant for you and your, probably, your [unclear: Euro-skewed] audience is that Swan is going international in the next couple of months. So we'll have a waitlist up pretty soon and we'll be serving something like 60 to 80 countries very soon. So really excited to get beyond the U.S. Borders. It'll be private clients only, unfortunately. So it's kind of a, you know, rather large customers thing, but at least it'll be nice to get back and serve the globe since our media goes worldwide and Twitter goes worldwide and YouTube goes worldwide. [02:21:31] Cory Klippsten: It should be a lot of fun. [02:21:33] Vlad Costea: Best of luck with that. [02:21:35] Cory Klippsten: Thank you. Appreciate it. [02:21:36] Vlad Costea: Thanks to everyone who tuned in for this one. More than two thousand people did, which is cool. [02:21:42] Cory Klippsten: That's awesome, man. Well, continued success and appreciate the time. Thanks, [unclear: Bob]. [02:21:47] Vlad Costea: Bye, Cory. [02:21:49] Cory Klippsten: Bye. [unclear: You saw what?] [02:21:58] Vlad Costea: Oh, he said something. Anyway, thank you very much to everyone who tuned in. Thank you to the sponsors. Once again, SideShift, LayerTwo Labs, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News, NoOnes.com. And I hope I didn't forget anyone. Thank you very much. I'll see you in the next one where I will interview the creator of Kaspa, Yonatan.