Title: S16 E47: Max Hillebrand on White Noise & Private Messaging on Nostr Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Max Hillebrand (Wasabi Wallet / zkSNACKs privacy builder; White Noise and the Marmot protocol for private messaging on Nostr; 8th appearance) Published: 2025-10-03 Duration: 4:02:36 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2025-10-03_s16_e47_max_hillebrand_on_white_noise_private_messaging_on_nostr.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2025-10-03_s16_e47_max_hillebrand_on_white_noise_private_messaging_on_nostr.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. local faster-whisper medium.en first pass with speaker diarization, corrected by hand against the audio with YouTube captions and the show notes. Details in the production notes at the end. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:47] Vlad Costea: Hello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 47. We are close to an all-time high in the case of the Bitcoin price. And the guest today is a cypherpunk, is a privacy advocate, is someone who is joining the show for the eighth time, which should be on some sort of record. I think you're maybe the first or second most featured guest in the history of the podcast. This is also your second time this season. The previous time you joined with Rockstar Dev to talk about some Bitcoin stuff. [00:01:21] Vlad Costea: You, sir, are Max Hillebrand, former CEO of Wasabi Wallet, someone who has been involved in Bitcoin privacy for a long time, and someone who today is working on something that's called White Noise, a protocol for messaging on top of Nostr, which is not private, but you're doing something with end-to-end encryption, which I really like. And I think it's an invention that comes at the right time because in Europe we're going to have chat control and privacy around the world seems to be getting worse at pretty much every level. So it's good to have you, Max, and it's really good to hear that you're doing something cool. [00:02:01] Max Hillebrand: Thanks a lot for the invite. Always happy to chat. I'd be also curious on what's the cumulative amount of hours that we talked on the show. It would also be interesting to see that rank because there's some long shows that might blow out some of the shorter ones. [00:02:16] Vlad Costea: I can do some math while you're talking so I do need to get you talking about something and then I'll pop in and say hey Max has been on the show for 40 hours or something. I don't know if it's 40. It's just a rough estimate but I was so happy to hear that you're working on something because after Wasabi Wallet shut down I became kind of sad because I realized that it's sort of the end of an era. It used to be cool to build private Bitcoin stuff. Now it's not so safe anymore. [00:02:45] Vlad Costea: We saw what happened with the Tornado Cash developers. We saw what happened with the Samourai guys who were not even released under the new administration which is supposedly pro-crypto but at the same time they don't seem to like privacy and you didn't give up on the fight. [00:03:07] Max Hillebrand: Yeah it will be a lot worse let's put it like that. You know cypherpunks have always had difficulties on this front since the very beginning and even before the cypherpunks officially started. So this is an aspect that just has to be dealt with and of course you have to strategize but ultimately I think we're on a very great direction and we're building pretty open source software easy to use by anyone who would like to and giving the end user control over their data and their property in a way that they can just do their thing. [00:03:49] Max Hillebrand: It's a very powerful societal project and of course Bitcoin had huge success and on Nostr as well. I think Nostr is a really interesting addition to the freedom tech toolkit and now let's chat a bit more about it. [00:04:11] Vlad Costea: Yeah so Nostr stands for Notes and Other Stuff Relayed through Relays — transmitted by Relays okay. And it's pretty cool because it was built by a bunch of Bitcoiners. This was in a time when there was heavy censorship on Twitter and you could get basically banned or deplatformed for expressing political views and it was fiatjaf it was Ben Arc interestingly fiatjaf is a radical how should I put it so he is a right-wing libertarian and Ben Arc is a left-wing anarchist it's very interesting that the two of them could get together and build this and they also had help from Melvin Carvalho and Rockstar Dev I think was also there and coincidentally I was one of the first 20-30 users or something on something that was called branle it was the first browser implementation that was built by fiatjaf. [00:05:17] Vlad Costea: I ran that for like 30 minutes I played with it I followed some people and then I forgot about it and lost my npub and nsec. I was thinking that it's getting stored in my browser passwords it did not and then I came back like two years later with a new account which I still have it's a pretty cool concept for social media. [00:05:37] Max Hillebrand: Same experience for me but that's a cool thing right. You can just create throwaway accounts totally fine if you lose some nsecs who cares this isn't money this is just data you know it's not as critical as Bitcoin stuff which is quite refreshing actually. [00:05:52] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah of course but at the same time you have to admit that you get followers and if you create a new account it's going to be difficult to get to the same audience that you built especially since it's decentralized and sometimes if you're not on the same relay with some people your feed is going to be different like you need to strategize how you're going to reach these people and especially if they also change their public keys which is the npub it's going to become difficult to reach them so it's still chaotic and there's also no recovery process like once you lost your keys they're gone forever. [00:06:30] Max Hillebrand: Yeah Nostr is a really simplistic protocol right it's like the first NIP is like two pages printed out it's tiny but it just introduces cool new foundational building blocks and a lot of things can be done from that but it leaves a lot of things unanswered I like things of okay which relays do we choose or like how do we recover into different keys and to some extent it's good that's left out of scope from Nostr just because it makes it much easier to get started and because Nostr is built in an architecture where new standards can easily be added I think we're not limited to just one standardized document we have a whole suite of them there's hundreds of probably thousands of NIPs different types of standards on how to use these building blocks in a more nuanced way and ultimately I think in the long run this is not really much that the end user will have to deal with this is more likely that applications are handling a lot of this out of the box by default and you know maybe asking users for certain nuances in his preferences to make sure the software does a good job so ultimately this is for developers more tricky like it's very easy to get going with a new Nostr project like it's great to have a hacky proof of concept over hackathon or just a weekend but then to really have something that's production ready stable works at scale works reliably on different devices in different settings etc there's a lot more edge cases that need to be handled than the bare bone protocol would let you believe you know believe it initially so that's you know a strength and a potential downside for Nostr which we just have to deal with and I think devs are dealing with it really nicely like the progress of most Nostr apps has been insane in the last couple years a lot of the concerns that were addressed initially are totally resolved and well that's great yeah. [00:08:37] Vlad Costea: I always thought it's interesting because it aims to create a decentralized social network but people figured out that they can do so much more with the same accounts with the same infrastructure they do file storage and based on the file storage they build applications like Instagram or TikTok or whatever to be able to navigate and they also use it for live streaming they use it for a lot of interesting use cases to be honest and I do have to ask this because this is a Bitcoin podcast and maybe it doesn't seem very intuitive to some people listening like how does this relate to Bitcoin. [00:09:20] Max Hillebrand: I guess it's related in the spirit of Bitcoin first and foremost and that's in part because it was created by Bitcoiners right the people you said that were there at the beginning are basically all Bitcoiners and so there are some similarities like it uses the same cryptographic functions right Schnorr signatures hash functions etc it's but it's also a bit kind of different to in the sense that with Bitcoin we have one implementation basically and that is how we stay in consensus and we all run basically the same amount of code and Nostr is much more different that we start with standards right. [00:10:00] Max Hillebrand: We create a clear standard that a wallet or a client either supports or not so there's some differences in the standardization process BIPs and NIPs are both chaotic NIPs even more so than BIPs so it's a different kind of consensus finding architecture and then the philosophy also goes that with both Bitcoin and Nostr you create your own identity self-sovereignly right and in Bitcoin if you want to get paid you just flip a coin get a private key get a public key and get an address and give it to someone right. [00:10:36] Max Hillebrand: You don't have to sign up to receive money and that's a superpower of Bitcoin of course that extends to sending the money as well and same with Nostr where you can flip a coin get a private key get a public key and hola that's your identity and now you can start creating messages and signing off with your private key in such a way that other people can see it right. So for example you can pick your own username avatar website link bio whatever and create a kind 0 event but that can extend to public posts likes reactions replies of all the other use cases that you mentioned another really cool one is Zap Store right. [00:11:21] Max Hillebrand: So this is a way that where developers can publish their applications simply by signing in a short message and putting that on a couple relays and that enables to have a delivery of applications of software and updates without having huge gatekeepers like Google or Apple taking weeks or months to review and ultimately reject really cool software projects that should be out there in the hands of users so Nostr has these fundamental building blocks of self-created self-identified users and cryptographic signatures to authenticate them and therefore you can duplicate the content as well this is one of the early quotes of Satoshi right that or at least referenced him probably it was said earlier but information is easy to spread and hard to stifle and so just like with Bitcoin blocks we can relay those blocks to hundreds or thousands of different nodes and duplicate the transaction history we can do the same in Nostr right. [00:12:22] Max Hillebrand: We can send our events to multiple servers and each event just like a Bitcoin block or a Bitcoin transaction is standalone you don't need any outside source to verify it you can check for yourself that yes this is accurate this wasn't changed that this was authorized or signed etc that has proof of work on it so those types of philosophies and tech are quite similar but yeah money is not directly related at the core of Nostr it can be added on top and it's you can easily add your Lightning address or any payment invoice in your profile event and then people can send you money either just directly to your address or in such a way that the receiver publishes a note proclaiming that he got paid by that sender and so you can have a public receipt for payments being made in case you want to attribute yourself with some of these payments and so not Bitcoin can be used inside of Nostr and Nostr can be useful for Bitcoin applications but they're two different protocols on the stack. [00:13:32] Vlad Costea: Yeah we actually have a topical question from the chat and I'm happy that we got this from kevin he says are there any hardware wallets for Nostr private keys like a ledger plugin or so and my answer at least maybe you have a different one max is that there's one from LNbits it's on shop.lnbits.com you can buy it for like twenty dollars or something and it's called the Nostr remote signing device yeah. [00:14:02] Max Hillebrand: Exactly this is a cool option so maybe for a bit of background on this in Nostr if you want to you know create events and publish something you need to know the private key or the software that he's using needs to know the private key the naive way of doing that is to copy and paste or type in your 12 words your private key your nsec and then this client can sign messages on your behalf but if you're trying hundreds of different clients from random developers that might be malicious you don't really want to give every software your private key just like that so cool thing is we can leverage Bitcoin tech and adjust it slightly such that we have one application or one hardware that has the private key and all other applications or clients have to request and find like a request for signature to the device and the device checks it signs it and returns the signed event for the other clients to send it ultimately to the network and this way the private key stays in only one environment and hasn't doesn't have to be spread so yeah the LNbits a hardware signer is really cool it's a small micro computer doesn't have a secure element but you can put your private key in there and then differently to a hardware wallet it actually connects to Wi-Fi and it connects to Nostr relays and then you can for example on your phone via QR codes basically exchange public keys between your phone and this hardware device and now your phone can send requests to your device and you know ask for signatures and there's some permission management handled the cool thing is you don't actually have to get a dedicated device for this there's additional ways that you can use the similar ways for example a browser extension nos2x would be one example where you put your private key in a browser extension and then each website that you visit just asks for the browser extension for this entry also on Android or ios both so android has the application called amber on iOS I think there's Nostore or something and I guess both of these or all of these are signing applications that keep your private key and then inside the operating system pass around the signing requests and signed results so this way you could get a really cheap Android phone but install the amber application and connect it to the internet and put that in your drawer somewhere on a charger and you basically have a mini server at home that has your private keys with no other applications installed and that should be you know secure enough. [00:16:47] Vlad Costea: Yeah there are lots of opportunities and options for you to secure your nsec and make sure that you're not gonna lose it because it was very hilarious in the early days when people were just getting bootstrapped and having their first experience they were posting their private key and telling other people to follow them and then other people were accessing their accounts and posting something funny and then they would be like oh no my account is compromised I have to make a new one and at this point I think if you have something for what you want to get followers and something that you want to hold on the long term and keep for yourself it's a good idea to have a good backup of your nsec if you want to type it as you said for all sorts of services then it's a good idea to have one of these signing devices which are like 20 I think on LNbits but if you want to keep your nsec which is your private key in cold storage then something that I did was to take one of these Cryptosteel capsules and put all the letters of my nsec inside of it and seal it and put it away somewhere and this is how I know I'm not gonna lose it and yeah it's much better than writing on paper because it's hard to destroy and if you buy Cryptosteel use promo code BTCTKVR for a 10% discount they're not sponsoring the show but I love their products and they're true OGs they were the first ones to make this. [00:18:22] Max Hillebrand: Yep well one cool device by the way that is in a similar regard is the Seed Hammer and it's a steel engraver 3d printable do-it-yourself open source hardware with a small PCB board where you can with NFC transfer some data that you want to engrave and it gets engraved in steel to be basically indestructible the cool thing is this is a robot doing the repetitive task of writing down and engraving this and you can also engrave QR codes which is super cool so yeah steel backups are awesome and both Bitcoin and Nostr have them that's another cool similarity. [00:19:04] Vlad Costea: Yeah you gotta back up your nsec or else you're gonna lose your account that's how Nostr works and I don't think it will ever be different unless we get to custodians or something but that's just handing someone else access to your account just in case you need to recover it which is not secure. [00:19:23] Max Hillebrand: One cool thing you can do is that you already have a Bitcoin private key somewhere backed up you can simply derive a sub key different types of standards and then use that for your Nostr thing right. So you as long as you have access to your Bitcoin private keys you would have access to your Nostr keys as well. [00:19:42] Vlad Costea: Well yeah but doesn't that just so you're gonna be pasting your private key into some sort of encryption software right that's a bit risky right. [00:19:52] Max Hillebrand: Well no that if someone will find your Nostr private key they could not get to the Bitcoin private keys I mean kind of actually depends how you do it there's many different standards that you can use for this like HD wallets, XOR, BIP-85 etc a lot of different trade-offs that you can design this that's the cool thing with this tech is there's so many different ways that you could apply them it really is a huge box of tools and you can build whatever you want with it you just have to make sure that what you're building does actually what you think it does you know that's the difficult part but once that review is done we can build some really cool robust solutions with this just takes time and the thing is that Nostr is such a diverse ecosystem and same with Bitcoin that we have really cool ideas that are very much not equally distributed you know some applications are super advanced in one specific topic and solve a problem perfectly and others simply have ignored that problem and don't have a solution at all right. [00:20:57] Max Hillebrand: So oftentimes people complain about how Nostr is not good enough at doing a certain thing actually they're complaining about that specific Nostr client that just sucks in that particular area but the cool thing is you can try another Nostr client who specializes in solving this specific use case you know and then you're done like one great example is searching for usernames and I don't know you type in jack or some other famous account and you will see a thousand jack usernames pop up with all the same profile picture and bio and so you're not sure which one to pick right that's a huge problem with many Nostr clients go to npub.world that's a search engine with a proper web of trust algorithm and type in you know whatever famous account you want and there's only one result right and it will be the correct one at least in most cases because it's a quite sophisticated algorithm not you know that's which really helps with this particular problem right now we have a great solution to this but other Nostr clients would have to implement this would also be good if Nostr relays implement this but because this is such a diverse and multiplayer ecosystem it's hard to have a consistent experience with things like this so you need to know a bit what different clients are good for but that's just the same as with the internet you know don't expect that one website that does everything perfectly you go to different websites for different things and I think it will be the same with Nostr. [00:22:30] Vlad Costea: I did not realize this because I don't spend too much time on Nostr to my real shame but I went to npub.world and I typed my name and there were just five or six people named vlad and I basically recognized my profile from the profile picture and I have 2616 followers which is insane and I'm followed by Edward Snowden which I had no idea man this is so cool. Martti Malmi, look. [00:22:58] Max Hillebrand: Yeah. And the cool thing is that like this following number of 2000 whatever people is really high quality followers right there is no kind of sock puppet or ephemeral account here if you would look up your pub key in I don't know Nostr.band for example you could probably find 10 000 followers there right but most of them are just kind of fake accounts that don't really have high reputation now some might not be some might just be really casual users that haven't built enough reputation yet so again right very different ways to calculate something that seems as simple as how many people are following you if you zoom in that's actually really not a hard not an easy question to answer at all stuff like this gets really hard if you look at it so we just have different solutions and you kind of embrace the chaos. [00:23:53] Vlad Costea: Yeah I do have to ask you about White Noise which is your application for private messaging on top of Nostr but before that let me present a couple of ads it's been 20 something minutes first of all which one should I pick let's pick the one that's gonna surprise you the most max Bitcoin.com News really good news I don't think they covered Nostr. [00:24:16] Max Hillebrand: That's not really a surprise you know. [00:24:18] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah you are already here this season but now they're orange like you can actually see you go to news.Bitcoin.com you see that the Bitcoin logo is not green anymore it's orange and they have some pretty good coverage of news from parts of the world about what you don't usually hear and they also cover gold and silver and other markets which are remotely connected to Bitcoin and it can be useful for you to understand market trends or see what's happening in the world it's pretty good so check it out news.Bitcoin.com and there's also NoOnes.com which is a peer-to-peer marketplace created by Ray Youssef who is known for Paxful and Ray likes this idea of onboarding the global south like he's if you've ever watched WWE and you watched all of these super macho characters very muscular and they talk like this all the time and they're fighting the forces of evil next week on pay-per-view then you're gonna love Ray and his mission to get people from Africa from the Middle East from South America to onboard the Bitcoin economy and if you choose to trade there under p2p exchange you're gonna be dealing with most likely people from Nigeria or some Middle Eastern country but if you choose their spot exchange the liquidity is gonna go to these people too so check it out it's NoOnes, which is n-o-o-n-e-s.com and now Max tell me about White Noise what is that. [00:25:55] Max Hillebrand: Yeah so far most of what we talked about with Nostr was about publicly facing events right where anyone can download the note and see what was written on it and that's super powerful for a bunch of use cases that are great that we can satisfy them now but there is another huge sector of useful tools that require more privacy right where the outside observers like some random person on the internet cannot just read the messages that are being sent between users and Ben Arc made the first attempt very early on in Nostr to encrypt some messages in the events and he kind of fucked up it was like a very simplistic way of doing it and there were some theoretical attacks that you could actually leak private key material and so some kind of cryptographic don't roll your own crypto is the summary of that and also it was revealing metadata of who is sending this encrypted message and who is receiving this encrypted message and plus it only really worked for two people talking to each other so groups weren't really supported so thankfully Nostr is a collection of protocols so we can simply upgrade and that's what we did and NIP-44 came next which actually addressed that a lot of the cryptographic concerns and that's a security audited protocol is still quite simple but it gets the details right and that fixes encryption basically and alongside that we introduced something called gift wraps which basically means that the sender of a message still authenticates himself to the receiver by signing an inner event but then he wraps this with another layer of encryption and a another signature from an ephemeral key which cannot be like which is just a random number and nobody knows who's who's sent this message now so the receiver is still known because his public key is addressed in the event but the sender is not which is great still no group supported right. [00:28:00] Max Hillebrand: So if you would want to talk to multiple groups you need to create five different events one for each receiver of the message and that of course takes some computation time which is still rather affordable but yeah it gets difficult if we get into hundreds or more people and another really interesting downside is that you could lie selectively to a couple to one person in a group all right. [00:28:27] Max Hillebrand: So let's say we have a group of five people I send you know let's go to the steakhouse to four of them and I tell the other guy hey we're meeting at the vegetarian restaurant and then you know we have a party without the guy so this is one of the issues with the current approaches and another design trade-off currently is that these messages are all decryptable if you have the nsec right the main user identity whoever has this can decrypt all of these messages so we're reusing our keys which is a big no-no in Bitcoin and address reuse isn't great it's also not so great for private sensitive information because key materials can leak especially in a setting of Nostr where they are exposed to users they write it on a piece of paper the cleaning lady can pick it up right or some hacker gets access to their computer somehow you so it would be better if we have a system where if the nsec the private key leaks all the messages in the past or future are cannot really be decrypted and so this would be an extra level of security which for some application we really want for other applications it's actually great that you can recover your messages if you have only one static private key and so these are not mutually exclusive they're they're they're they're just another set of tools in and we can apply it in different types of designs so yeah ultimately the quest was to have a really strong encryption scheme for Nostr for sensitive private messaging and this is ultimately what White Noise is all about at first we looked at a really old encryption scheme called Off-the-Record which does some basic key rotation so it makes it not possible to read future messages if you compromise one key but this was later majorly upgraded by the Signal protocol so the Signal app has actually an academic paper behind it called the Signal protocol which you could implement and there's an open source library for it etc a really great stuff I can highly speak well of it because we already used it in WabiSabi by the way the Wasabi 2.0 protocol used cryptography that was first announced in the Signal protocol paper and then we looked into could we get this into Nostr the signal is still this what's known as a pairwise encryption scheme meaning you send one message encrypted to each member of the group and it's kind of a hack on top of a hack to some extent or rather like a standard that has evolved for a long time and things like multi-device support right that people have a phone and a laptop is not really natively supported by the system so it kind of had to be hacked on top etc so there are some downsides to this and in the meantime the next evolution of encrypted messaging was initiated with the IETF with the Internet Engineering Task Force agency a standard making body of engineers and gray beard wizards who very slowly come up with really good standards like you know TLS and SSH etc and they have now specified what's known as the Messaging Layer Security protocol, MLS and this is a way that a group of people can come up with a shared secret that hundred people together each know the same private key that they can use to decrypt a message which means we no longer have to encrypt messages to individual people we just have encrypt messages to the one key of the group and everyone can decrypt it and on top of that if we want to kick out people there's a smart algorithm to do this efficiently in such a way that we can scale the group to the millions or even more of participants and on top of that we get multi-device supports out of the box plus the key rotation etc the double ratchet encryption is done you know securely with not just security audits but mathematical proofs of integrity which is quite nice yeah so far to MLS I mean I've been rambling for a while so I guess, Vlad, you have any questions so far about all of this. [00:32:59] Vlad Costea: No I think that's super cool but it's also a bit ironic right because Nostr is not private there is nothing about the activity on Nostr not even your dms are 100 private if someone has your npub I think they can see to whom you're sending dms right. [00:33:16] Max Hillebrand: Exactly you don't even need to know private key material in order to see who is messaging whom when and how often right crazy scary actually I mean it's all right for some use cases it's deadly for other use cases right yeah. [00:33:33] Vlad Costea: It's really funny because you can take anyone's profile which you open and then you copy their npub and then you paste that no you don't paste anything you just check the messages and you see who they have messaged yeah. [00:33:48] Max Hillebrand: Yeah this is something by the way that relays can also enforce a little bit like you could upload your direct messages to a relay that promises to have a policy that it only someone who proves that he knows the private key that can decrypt this message is allowed to download the event and these are known as inbox relays and again one of the new standards where we later addressed one of these big issues in a kind of trust-based way right if the relay operator is to be trusted if he doesn't get hacked etc then you could be sure that your private messages will not be able to be downloaded by someone who doesn't know your private key so that's a benefit of course not that many people use it but those that do they get some all right security assumptions I guess equally to what we see in the legacy world right now I'd like Twitter could easily the Twitter admin could easily tell everyone who not just whom you're messaging when but also what the content of these messages is right. [00:34:55] Max Hillebrand: So the content is encrypted in any case and with trusted relays the these this metadata as well of course it would be even better if we have a cryptographically secure way of having private conversations with zero metadata leakage where we don't have to trust the server administrator or any other third party to keep this secret right and so that's ultimately I think what's missing in the toolkit of Nostr privacy tech and I think we have a like beautiful solution for it so this MLS protocol basically defines as I said just how to get this key that we the private key that we share among users to decrypt our messages how to we rotate this key frequently right such that we don't such that if one key leaks only a part of the messages get decrypted by the adversary but he cannot read all future messages and we could rotate with every message by the way and then but it leaves out of scope a couple important things for example the data delivery layer right. [00:36:00] Max Hillebrand: So how do messages encrypted messages actually get transferred between users right it's out of scope it can be a centralized system where there's just one server that keeps the messages it can be like some pure peer-to-peer stuff like bluetooth or BitTorrent or whatever or the way Nostr does it but it could be relays with a WebSocket standardized interface and so we use Nostr as the data delivery layer which gives us ease of implementation because it's just WebSockets but it also gives us the run the redundancy of there's thousands of relays available it's so easy to run your own relay either on a server or at home or on your phone right and then we can even with some extra work get to full peer-to-peer if every client just has a relay and we somehow have a bluetooth connection or whatever so it's a an easy way to start with and easy to upgrade in the future to a more sophisticated setup but so Nostr gives us message delivery for basically free like super easy to implement and the second thing that's out of scope for MLS is the authentication service and the authentication service basically says that this username like this user identity is using this private key to sign or this public key rather to sign messages with right. [00:37:21] Max Hillebrand: So we tie an identity to cryptographic key material that the MLS state machine requires to add people to a group such that they can decrypt the messages and there's one really interesting caveat here and that's mentioned in the MLS paper that the authentication service is a trusted entity right and mainly this is designed that for example google is your authentication and service and so your Google account is your identity and the Google corporation somehow signs off of a public key that you use for your actual messages and so the issue is here that this authentication service can issue false credentials where the adversary knows the private key but the authentication service affirms or attests that this public key is belonging to the user and in such a way an adversary could gain access to a group and read all of the messages and so on so Nostr fixes this as well by a really genius way of simply saying that every end user is his own authentication service and the authentication service is the nsec the private key of the user and he attests in a Nostr event that this is the new public key that I'm using for my group messages please add this key to the groups so we kind of create this the sub key category so your nsec is your master key and that uses the Schnorr signature scheme like elliptic curve digital signatures but then we create a new set of keys for every client or every device that you are running this encrypted messaging on and you sign off the keys so basically create this key package event which has its unique kind number says you know versioning etc and with that you attest for yourself that hey I exist and I can receive encrypted messaging through the set of keys and the cool thing is that you can rotate these keys frequently and you can these are just ephemeral keys as long as you remember them somehow you can you can you know create as many as you want and you can also delete them after a while right and if you've not made any backups then nobody can actually decrypt these welcome events because their private key was destroyed with some trust assumptions of course but still interesting tool in the toolkit yeah. [00:39:44] Max Hillebrand: And so with this we can now start to create groups so you know Vlad created his key package I created my key package and now I can initiate a new group that does some MLS magic in the background and we do some Nostr magic on top but then ultimately I can send an invite to Vlad's key package private key saying that hey I've created this new group you can join it if you want and Vlad can accept this request to join a group and now he's part of this group meaning two people together now have found out the same private key that they can use to encrypt and decrypt messages with so with this we can we can start writing and we can create message or application events basically application messages I think they're called in the protocol which are Nostr events that have a Nostr event inside as a payload so for example this could be I think it's kind 7 for chat message and it could also be a reaction or a reply or a blog post or a zap you know whatever Nostr event you want to send to the group we now encrypt that with our private with the MLS private key for this group and we can put this encrypted payload into actually we encrypted again with the Nostr way of encrypting stuff so we have a double layer of encryption and now we can put this encrypted payload in a new Nostr event sign it with an ephemeral key and we tag the group id in this event and this gets put on relays so I would have done this process and Vlad, who's listening on this relay for new events that have the group id tag I would get notified would get the event downloaded and he can decrypt the double layers first the NIP-44 encryption and second the MLS encryption and he would actually see the private message that I sent him but all that the relay sees is that some anonymous group with an unknown number of members has received a message and it doesn't know how many people are in the group or what was said or who is talking to whom or how old this group is and all of this metadata is completely obfuscated and so the relay is trusted with any of the privacy guarantees he's only trusted with being available to receive and send messages right events and that's a quite cool design. [00:42:17] Vlad Costea: I just want to say that I'm really happy that MLS now stands for something more meaningful than Major League Soccer but on a more serious note you have a question from Tom Dwyer who says is White Noise kind of how Diffie-Hellman handshakes work please could you expand how it can scale to millions without becoming unwise unwieldy. [00:42:43] Max Hillebrand: Unwieldy yep yes so we do use Diffie-Hellman key exchanges basically what it is that Vlad has a private key I have a private key and of course we each have the corresponding public key right now if Vlad gives me his public key I can tweak it with my private key to get a shared secret and Vlad can take my public key and tweak it with his private key and he will basically get the same shared secret so this is a way that two people who have a private public key pair that only exchange public keys can derive a private key that both of them know and so it's a shared key generation algorithm basically beautiful tech really cool cypherpunk history so we use this in part of the protocol but I guess the main innovation is that Diffie-Hellman key exchanges only work between two public keys what we want is to have it among a million keys and so the way that MLS does key generation is different than how Diffie-Hellman does it I won't go too much into the details because it gets crazy complex very quick so read the rfcs probably for more detail but ultimately okay fuck it I will go deep this is the takeover podcast we can go down rabbit holes so okay we have a group of people now we're going to build a tree of keys where imagine the leaves of the tree at the bottom are the individual private public keys of our users devices and we're gonna build a binary tree upwards right where we always take two of the bottom parts and they combine to one until we eventually have a root of the tree yeah the cat's gonna get the cryptography now that's gonna be good and now but it's this is not a hash based Merkle tree or it's not a hierarchical deterministic based tree the so it's a bit different to what we're used to in Bitcoin land but what it is that each node in the path up to the tree are actually ephemeral private public key pairs that were generated and so the group states is among other things this is this binary tree of a bunch of private public key keys but it's such that any one member of the group only knows the private key of the nodes that are in the tree higher up and everyone knows all the public keys of all the nodes but you only know the private key of the path upwards okay why is this important maybe I should have started with the why first if we have this shared secret that we encrypt to and a million people are in the group well the benefit is we only have to encrypt the message once and everyone can decrypt it right. [00:45:44] Max Hillebrand: So that's already great for scalability but the issue is what if we want to kick out one person out of our 1 million sized group then we need to send a new private key to all the 999 000 other people and that can be computationally expensive so we want to scale that and the way that we do it is that instead of you know one person who kicks out the other person right he creates a new private key that we're now going to all use for our messaging but instead of having to send this private key to everyone what he does is he sends the private key to the public encrypted to the public keys of those nodes in the tree that the adversary that is being kicked out does not know anymore and okay that's probably where the details will stop but ultimately what this means in computer science speak is that we get O(log n) scaling meaning if we want to kick out one person out of like a group with the size of a million I don't know the exact number but it's probably something like we only need to 13 messages right. [00:47:00] Max Hillebrand: So we reduce it from 1 million down to something as tiny as 13 and that means it's much more efficient to kick people out of the group that is the main scalability benefit that MLS has achieved that it's very efficient to add or remove people even if the group is very large and with some tweaks to the protocol even with a super large group of millions of people to join a group takes only a couple milliseconds of computation so it's a really nicely scalable efficient protocol and that's why we use it so it is a bit related to Diffie-Hellman key exchanges but because of this binary tree structure of private public key pairs that's where we get the scalability together with the fact that we're. [00:47:50] Vlad Costea: Gonna be super long but I hope Tom Dwyer got his answer and you also gave some interesting details about how this technically works and I apologize in advance for those of you who don't know how Nostr works honestly I'm also learning a lot right now but it does sound like you're doing something which is useful and significant in a place where basically privacy was an afterthought for Nostr and I checked out the website of White Noise and I did see that right now you have to basically it's one application that's available on TestFlight for ios and also android for two different app stores. [00:48:37] Max Hillebrand: Yeah exactly maybe a bit to the to the history right. So we've started I don't know a year and a half ago probably with finally tackling this problem properly looking into Off-the-Record signal and eventually finding MLS and then brainstorming of how can we make a bridge a wrapper between MLS and Nostr and so we came up with a decent solution and we started hacking on it and found a bunch of ways to improve it until eventually we wrote a chat app that kind of looks like Signal or Telegram but that implements all of this magic under the hood right. [00:49:15] Max Hillebrand: So first we designed the protocol and then we said okay let's create a flagship application where we can test if this actually works for real right and where people can play around with it and so we released White Noise of like middle of july or something 2025 and so it's quite recent that this is actually shipped and of course the first versions were buggy as hell and didn't work at all so but by now I think version 1.0.4 we have quite a nice yeah stable interface where messages actually get delivered a group creation is still kind of a mess but one-on-ones are working quite nicely now so but the important part of this is that we want to stick to the philosophy of Nostr meaning that it's a protocol that's open where it's easy to implement it where it's easy to write your own tool chain with it or use an existing library and then to create an application that is in consensus with the others such that we you know get this benefit of the network effect and that goes for a new application right people who just want to write a new Nostr app from scratch but especially this is for existing applications who want to upgrade to a more secure messaging scheme and so we're very much chatting with basically well not every but with a lot of the builders in the space you know Primal, Damus, Amethyst, Coracle, Iris you know a lot of the cool projects are really wanting to have such a toolkit available to build more secure messaging into their existing clients and then the awesome thing is that we would have a interoperable standard where primal users can write Amethyst users and have a group together with iris users and I don't know talk about you know marketplace events at a really sophisticated interoperable private communication standard and so in order to do this and actually Vlad this is like a major announcement basically being announced for the first time live on this pod we're we're we're announcing a new protocol that describes exactly this middleware between Nostr and MLS right and so it's called Marmot m-a-r-m-o-t the Marmot protocol you know what a Marmot is. [00:51:38] Vlad Costea: Yeah I know what kind of animal that is I think there's another word for it head what's it called probably some latin word and no yeah but it's something they're really cute animals groundhog I think. Is that a groundhog really oh you see that and I'm even learning some new stuff groundhog versus Marmot let's see I'm curious now there are any actual differences so a groundhog is a type of Marmot is like the family of animals but yeah. [00:52:16] Max Hillebrand: Oh that's great nice so that's another connection and yeah so it's a it's a new protocol it tries to be quite similar to the philosophy of Nostr or specifically Cashu and its specification, the NUTs they're really easy to understand really you know concisely written and do one thing really well and so we published five new MIPs, Marmot Implementation Possibilities which go from you know the things like key package creation to group instantiation and all the metadata that you need to a group like the name of a group the group avatar which is encrypted of course the group description and so on and then members of course and then how to add members to a group and how to send messages in this group and then how to rotate private keys in the group or how to add or remove members afterwards and finally also how to send encrypted media inside the group such that we have to forward and post compromise secrecy but on top of that we use blossom for a distributed media upload right. [00:53:32] Max Hillebrand: So you should be able to send even larger files encrypted and private among a group in some cool ways yeah the that's the Marmot protocol fresh out of the oven. [00:53:46] Vlad Costea: I didn't know so I interacted with Ben Arc and fiatjaf and they told me that they're trying to rebrand Nostr to move on from the ostrich mascot to capybaras of all animals capybaras and they're super cute like they're fat and you can find GIFs of them slapping their belly and now I see that you're using a Marmot is this part of the trend or something to use these tiny rodents well. [00:54:13] Max Hillebrand: Let's see maybe there's a grand conspiracy maybe someone is hijacking Nostr. [00:54:19] Vlad Costea: Well I don't know if there's any hijacking it's just that this branding decision because before this everyone was trying to do something with ostriches. [00:54:29] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I guess animal mascots are a good thing right. We have the honey badger we have the ostrich oh we have a Marmot I guess food is good too right there's NUTs, there's Cashu so like I guess we're decent on branding not maybe that creative but it's hard to come up with good names you know you better just pick one that's good enough and get it over with. [00:54:53] Vlad Costea: Right. So if it's an exotic food it's for privacy if it's some sort of animal that chews wood then it's supposed to be for social networking and messaging is there a rule to this. [00:55:09] Max Hillebrand: Maybe each other will be revealed later on all the pieces come together mystery. [00:55:17] Vlad Costea: I'm spending my time right now looking at pictures of marmots and they're so cute. [00:55:22] Max Hillebrand: They're quite cute right like your girlfriend will like it which is I think an important part of branding especially for protocols you know is it is it cute shouldn't be too dangerous looking I think. [00:55:36] Vlad Costea: Are you implying that there's anything dangerous about it and you're trying to make the image cuter so that people don't figure out what's beneath the surface. [00:55:47] Max Hillebrand: Yeah that's probably not a bad idea one of the many strategic choices that can be taken for wise freedom tech builders yeah but the cool thing is so we have a very easy to understand protocol it doesn't have test vectors yet so and it's currently in review so please go through like you can read it as a layman and you'll probably get it but if you know a thing or two about specification work and you want to help us make sure that this is solid we took a lot of inspiration of BIPs and like Taproot's versioning, or like the NUTs and NIPs and all of the other spec work that was done, like BOLTs as well let's see it's not as yeah like we're we'll get to hopefully some stable version of this in a couple weeks or months but in the meantime we have kind of decoupled all of the back-end logic that we did to implement what is basically the Marmot protocol and we put that into MDK, the Marmot Development Kit so you can see that at mdk.build is I think the website that should redirect to GitHub mdk.build and yeah you then hopefully soon I think we'll or we already do have language bindings from rust to flutter and dart but there should be typescript and you know probably all the other languages that you would like we can do language bindings for that we're also working on another implementation in typescript natively still you know early work so there's basically I guess three libraries that we're currently using right there is the rust Nostr library that just handles all of the regular Nostr stuff then the is the OpenMLS library which is the library that handles all the crazy cryptography of MLS it's not easy to re-implement this from scratch so you probably don't want to do that and just use an existing implementation even though there are multiple to choose from I think there's two in Rust one in c one in c++ and one was started in typescript as well so thankfully we don't have to actively work on the typescript MLS library because that's hard but we'll we'll definitely contribute to it and then the Marmot library so to say is the glue between the Nostr library and the MLS library and so this part we will be maintaining in other languages as well so to you know have whatever Nostr typescript library together with the MLS typescript library and then the Marmot typescript implementation for a library that brings these two things together so hopefully it will be easy for newer existing developers to add encrypted Nostr communication in their app and then just see what they can build with it because it's super flexible like all we provide you is an encrypted envelope and what you put in inside the envelope is totally up to you and it should work out of the box with basically any Nostr kind number so whatever you want to have you can basically build it with this in a private secure scalable way. [00:59:11] Vlad Costea: I just put on the screen the GitHub that presents the Marmot protocol it's in the GitHub repository of Parres HQ, and Parres appears to be some sort of organization that's also working on building Marmot White Noise not Marmot and there's this guy Jeff G who seems to be the main developer anyway you have a description here that says the Marmot protocol is a messaging protocol that specifies how to do efficient end-to-end encrypted group messaging using Nostr's decentralized identity and relay network combined with the MLS protocol and as you scroll you find arguments as to why you should use Marmot security overview protocol specifications and the warning that all of this is experimental and some mentions about proposals to improve this projects using Marmot and this White Noise and White Noise Flutter and how to contribute pretty cool I gotta be honest. [01:00:18] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I really like this kind of standardization approach and I wish we've we would have done more like that for Wasabi and or specifically WabiSabi and even though we had the academic paper and some Bitcoin mailing list posts etc and of course a bunch of stuff on GitHub it was it was not really specified per se kind of similar to Bitcoin like Bitcoin kind of failed with this as well Satoshi just wrote a client and that is the standard now and there is no real spec driven development which makes it really hard for alternative clients to come out and to flourish and so I don't want to make that mistake again and so we're leaning heavily into writing first a specification right then a library so that other people can implement apps with the specification and then finally we build an app that uses the library and the specification mainly such that we can improve those two things right. [01:01:17] Max Hillebrand: We're kind of dogfooding it and testing this dev tooling ourselves to make sure that it works and it's easy and well architectured etc but then also to show hey what's possible with this and to have a user facing application that gets people excited and that ends up hopefully being used and that's White Noise right. So this is kind of a flagship application where we will definitely keep working on this for a long time and try to make it not only intuitive and just work by default out of the box one of the other crucial learnings I had in Wasabi if it's not the default it doesn't matter right. [01:01:59] Max Hillebrand: We need to be hardcore private by default and it's really hard to build so we want to make sure that's possible but then also to make it really like pretty we have a amazing ux designer who's working on some really sleek awesome designs that's not boring it's that's actually a bit of a new take on how messengers could look not too invasive but yeah stay tuned in one of the next releases we'll have some cool ui updates and yeah fun project. [01:02:30] Vlad Costea: Yeah I can tell you're really enjoying this so I really want to ask you about the user experience of dealing with this but before that let me plug some more ads and I think the ads can be also presented as questions to you like what do you think about the particular topic because for example Layer 2 Labs is building the Drivechains and they're very ready for a more serious proposal not just a theoretical bip but also an actual implementation you can download the software from layer2labs.com slash download they have sidechains for ethereum for Zcash for namecoin and also something for a prediction market and a big block sidechain which is prunable so basically you have the scalability without having to store all the data and once again it's optional so today's node runners don't have the burden to store any of that it can be stored voluntarily if you choose to be part of that and it does require the BIP 300 soft fork and that leads to some conditions in which miners will be able to create these sidechains I was curious if you took a look at Drivechains and what's your opinion. [01:03:49] Max Hillebrand: You know that's the sad thing if you keep the same sponsor for too long is that we keep talking about it on multiple of the shows right. So yeah but for people interested there's already exactly it changes but there's no history to it which is nice right. So people can go back to earlier episodes but no I like the idea of sidechains in general I appreciate that a two-way peg is a really fucking hard problem and Drivechains is a very early solution in like a quite interesting design space I wouldn't call it like cryptographically secure like you know like zero knowledge proofs or cryptography it's more like cryptodynamically secure a little bit like Bitcoin right. [01:04:37] Max Hillebrand: So where you have to make some assumptions like the majority of miners are honest in order to have actual security and that's that's not as great as a pure cryptographic solution to the problem so I think I'm quite bullish on actual zero knowledge proofs and how they could be used for sidechain pegouts and specifically for this I'm really bullish on the Great Script Restoration and that recently had a BIP published as well that goes into how to actually re-enable a bunch of opcodes that could get us a lot of the kind of second layer flexibility that we would need and I bring this up because I'm actually not sure if Drivechains would be possible with a Great Script Restoration BIP. [01:05:27] Vlad Costea: They are but with some limitations meaning that you can have a the miners create the sidechains but with BIP 300 you have some protections meaning that every 13 000 blocks you can exit so there's this unilateral or bilateral contract with unilateral exit and also you have a situation where a majority of nodes can unlock the stolen funds if the miners choose to be evil and steal but this is not applicable in the case of covenants or OP_CAT or something which enables this to happen so you can make it happen but you're not gonna have protection for the users to the same degree interesting which is even more optimistic than what we have with BIP 300 and if we do get the Great Script Restoration and we're gonna get I think ctv is bundled something like OP_CAT is bundled a lot of cool stuff can be built and I do like the idea that the free market is going to basically choose which one of these solutions is the best one and the users will basically put their money wherever they think they find the best features with the least amount of security trade-offs. [01:06:48] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I'd like my view here really is kind of that of the toolbox which I mentioned way too often I had this conversation but it's nice to have more stuff available and of course there's a big trade-off of can a lot of harm be done with this and that gets quite technically specific right. [01:07:07] Max Hillebrand: I guess with Bitcoin it's mainly about block verification time like can you craft a valid Bitcoin block that takes 30 minutes to validate and if yes then you've broken the network right because you just keep producing blocks that take longer than 10 minutes to verify details of course in this attack right but stuff like this has to be avoided that's in part why I like Great Script Restoration because it builds on top of this and really solves it I think seriously I don't know about the details of it if it's if it's actually a finally good approach but it seems good to me and then we have more things to try and people can put their money in it or not and maybe they lose some and maybe not but that's already kind of the case where people put money into addresses and yeah those addresses can be unspendable that's already now the case that has always been the case right. So we just push that responsibility to the end user. [01:08:07] Vlad Costea: Yeah I do like the idea of enabling some of these opcodes and we can see that for example liquid and Bitcoin Cash and also bsv they enabled them and if there's any concern about their security you can actually make some money breaking these chains so good luck I think which is very funny Bitcoin Cash right now is building a zk roll up so they want to scale on an l2 and that's very ironic because they started out as this project that said now we want to do everything on chain we don't need layer. [01:08:42] Max Hillebrand: Twos. Yeah I mean like layers make makes sense and especially considering the amount of research and advancement that was made like Lightning progress has been stunning like it's gotten much more robust now and you know zero knowledge roll ups and there's a whole collection of classes of ways of doing this oftentimes they just reduced to a trusted federation and but yeah there's a lot of different ways of doing it now no you know ark and statechains etc are newer approaches that are also very promising so yeah I think we're on a really good track in terms of scalability of Bitcoin there's so many variant solutions that yeah we can we can figure that out. [01:09:34] Vlad Costea: Yeah. And there's also as a sponsor of this show Citrea which is gonna launch in a month or two and basically the premise is that if you like ethereum and what it's doing you're gonna love Citrea because it brings all the features on a much more robust base layer with fewer trade-offs if you hate ethereum you're sort of going to like Citrea because it has the Bitcoin security it uses the same money supply it doesn't have its own token and it basically unlocks use cases that today you don't have on Bitcoin I think the end game for them is to get liquidity from wrapped Bitcoin WBTC which is custodied by BitGo and wrapped as an ERC-20 token on ethereum and I think there's like a hundred thousand Bitcoin on it or more and if they're able to unlock even ten percent of that it's much larger than lightning today and the reality is that people want to do DeFi they want to use some of pseudo banking services in a rather decentralized way and yeah. [01:10:47] Max Hillebrand: Yeah no they'd like this these types of custodian like custodians won't really go away and like transactional service providers etc won't really go away or like second layer operators won't go away right these are useful tools that can be used no but it's not okay exactly but it is a second layer operator right like the thing with these second zk rollups often is that they're centralized to some extent right. [01:11:17] Max Hillebrand: I'm not exactly sure how this is in detail with Citrea but there are operating nodes that can be you know that if taken down would lead to certain you know conditions extra delays or whatever but even that is quite heavy research and development right the like sidechain papers from 10 years ago were quite more trusted than what we have now so yeah I'm really bullish on Citrea and others because I do think that we have solved blockchain privacy to good enough extent with WabiSabi there's still many improvements that can be done there but ultimately we have a great solution now the question is how do we get scalable privacy in higher layers as well because then you just CoinJoin into you know your second layer transaction CoinJoin into a Lightning channel or splice your Lightning channels or deposit into a Fedimint or some zk rollup or whatever and with this we I have a good combination of tools by the way I need to stretch a bit so I'll turn off my camera but we'll keep rolling it's. [01:12:33] Vlad Costea: All good max last but not least I got a plug SideShift which is this place where you can swap something that you have or something that you're about to receive for something that you really want the classic example is if someone wants to hold on to that it's a bull market not financial advice but you should not hold on to that but actual technical advice stable coins are not really sovereign which means that the issuer can decide that your address is blacklisted and then you're not able to send to anyone so to prevent any of these problems you can swap your stable coins like USDT usdc whatever on SideShift for Bitcoin the fees are pretty low they have pretty good liquidity and unfortunately they're not available in the us without some sort of tools that you can use but I'm not gonna tell you exactly what and how but it's a really cool tool and I think it really lives up to the spirit that I think the first service of its kind was called ShapeShift and SideShift is sort of the torch bearer for this they are the largest right now and they have a lot of pairs so if you're into meme coins you can also swap for that but I don't recommend it and yeah the url is SideShift which is SideShift.ai and check it out. [01:14:09] Max Hillebrand: Atomic swaps are really cool and you know you can also do partially blind atomic swaps which are nice so I'm not even sure if they do atomic swaps or if it's a trusted swap but even if it's in a trusted environment you can make it such that one side the service provider cannot spy on its users which is really nice so look into partially blind atomic swap cool cryptography. [01:14:34] Vlad Costea: No it's not atomic unfortunately and they were also the first exchange to support Lightning and the first major one to drop Lightning when the volumes started to decrease and they realized it makes no sense to maintain anymore so yeah but they support liquid on the other hand they're a member of the federation if you have fun stuck on the liquid side chain and you don't want to deal with one of the federation members for the pegout you can actually use SideShift to swap between L-BTC and btc that's another use case yeah anyway I hope you enjoy stretching and. [01:15:20] Max Hillebrand: Especially in like the zero knowledge or like the side chain environments you know all the Drivechains and ZK rollups eCash mints whatever they can all be nicely connected via either custodial trusted swaps or via non-custodial swaps like Lightning so I think for this in the long run lightning will be the very interesting connecting tissue between these systems just because it's a network for routing swaps and that's ultimately what it is so. [01:15:57] Vlad Costea: Yeah you're right. I think especially if you're gonna have all of these islands you need bridges that connect them and the bridges are gonna be exchanges that don't KYC you and that let you instantly swap just by pasting addresses and sending funds to some address of course there's a little bit of trust involved like these services promise to do something they do need to have some sort of reputation system or recommendation because they can screw you either by not sending the funds or by taking a larger fee than they say that they're taking and transactions are final there isn't much that you can do but it's important for these services to build a reputation in the game and have a user base and scale their operation but you're right. [01:16:51] Vlad Costea: We're gonna have this year a lot of services coming to Bitcoin I'm not sure about Alpen Labs when they're launching I think they discovered something new and cool which is called garbled circuits and they're gonna spend more time to cook their service because of that but once we do have all of these zk roll-ups and sidechains and services on Bitcoin there's gonna be a need for you to get in and out of them without having to deal with the internal mechanisms of pegging in and pegging out and the easiest way is to swap of course there's a fee involved and you're not gonna get the whole amount. [01:17:37] Max Hillebrand: Yeah exactly but it's really encouraging that there's so much progress that you really have to ask yourself when do we ship and probably shipping earlier is a good idea if you can afford to you know make breaking changes later on which probably is fine too I think we're a bit too fearful of breaking changes just because it's such a big deal for Bitcoin but for higher order stuff or from us related stuff it's not really that much of an issue to break changes occasionally like people just update their stuff that's all right by we you mean White Noise right no I mean like anyone right like for example Alpen Labs they decided not to ship they're aborting the v2 version of it and they're now going to be in version 3 the garbled circuits yeah idea which you know takes more time to build etc of course wasting more time to finalize an implementation that you could ship of something that you know will be obsolete soon is kind of painful there's like this difference in philosophy of doing it right for the first release or just shipping something hacky I personally really like the mantra or at least I think it's funny of we deliver shippable intermediaries and so they're they're they're shippable right they're not great they're kind of shit but they're they're intermediaries you know so there will be something better and you know at least we delivered something better than nothing so you can always improve later on. [01:19:08] Vlad Costea: Yeah I agree with this especially since this is a layer two it doesn't require user consensus or whatever it's more centralized by design you can upgrade it and bring updates to it if necessary but at the same time I also see that there is a race for users right because I'm not sure how many of the lightning users are going to be switching to Alpen or Citrea maybe that the kind of applications that they offer is out of scope for that kind of audience but I think that they're going to be racing to get users from Solana and from ethereum and I do believe that whichever one of them comes out first with a good service is gonna build the network effect and become sort of like the xerox you know the one that gets compared or the one that becomes the reference point for everything else that comes out after that point and I think two years ago after we have discovered how to put zero knowledge proofs on the Bitcoin chain for verification a lot of these l2 projects emerged I think at one point there was a website with more than 100 projects that were listed as zk roll-up proposals right now I think we only have two or three of them which are serious and are going to ship what they promised but it's exciting it's exciting to see developers coming from ethereum back to Bitcoin it's exciting to see younger people getting interested in how to do stuff that previously was considered to be impossible and here I think the best example is BitVM. [01:20:54] Vlad Costea: Robin Linus, this german guy he realized how to do a virtual machine on Bitcoin and it was hacky but it was good enough and it was good enough for people to figure out how to do stuff and come up with new ideas or try to refine stuff that was built on ethereum in an even hackier way and the most important part and something that I'm trying to do with my podcast is to get people to accept and embrace innovation because if you're stuck in this very conservative mindset where you consider that Bitcoin is final and everything else is a shitcoin and you should not try new stuff not only that you're missing out but you're sort of preventing the community as a whole with your voice from embracing something that can be useful for them and can lead to a much more interesting future for Bitcoin because I like to think about this a lot the clock is ticking for the mining revenue and it's gonna be crucial maybe in eight years or something for the miners to collect a lot of fees and so far I think we failed to create useful use cases on the base layer for Bitcoin the fact that right now you can get transactions with a fee that's lower than one Satoshi per v-byte is proof that we sort of failed and most of the transactions happen elsewhere and a lot of Bitcoin transactions happen on other chains too and I think that's a problem because it's less secure and it gives people the impression that they're dealing with the same robustness of Bitcoin so if we can bring that on Bitcoin layers I think we're gonna have this cosmos of various small projects that interact with each other and maybe there's gonna be direct swaps so that you can move your coins across and we can also find a way for the miners to get paid what's your take on this max. [01:23:05] Max Hillebrand: But I'm bullish in general on kind of human ingenuity and finding solutions to these very difficult problems and ultimately engineering larger sets of use cases for any specific technology or layer thereof and so the I guess one of the questions is also what's your ultimate goal that you're going for like what are you maximizing for and I don't think that Bitcoin is a good enough answer for that like it's too narrow like Bitcoin is a huge project of course but optimizing and doing only Bitcoin stuff I think is not wise because there's other problems that need to be addressed a little more broader focus point like for example freedom maximizing for freedom tech is I think more interesting it is a lot more work because now we not only have to fix the money we've have to fix all of the other stuff as well where people interfere with human freedom and dignity but that means we can do more good and interesting projects so that's why I'm quite happy to work a bit more on because it is a critical part of the intersection of what we have to do in order to get the next level of human freedom manifested in code and just expands the amount of options and ultimately we just have to build these systems resilient enough so that they survive long enough and that people continue to contribute to them and expand these ideas and further engineer better trade-offs and eventually the tools will be so goddamn good and we can ship them to 8 billion people with a click and then yeah the cypherpunk future has arrived. [01:25:04] Vlad Costea: Yeah I'm super excited about this and I also follow other chains which I don't think are scammy because they're building something that is useful for Bitcoin for example today and I made a promise on Twitter I said that if my tweet gets 50 likes I'm gonna do the Zcash pump dance because Zcash if you don't know was supposed to be the Zerocash soft fork for Bitcoin back in 2013 basically bring zero knowledge cryptography to make Bitcoin fungible and make Bitcoin transactions private it was not accepted at the time I think Peter Todd was one of the biggest critics and he said that it has this trusted setup which is not desirable for Bitcoin in hindsight it was a good idea but Bitcoiners sort of lost focus because Zcash evolved they got rid of the trusted setup they made it more scalable now it works on mobile too and it's everything that they promised they would ship with the paper and so much more they're gonna make it scalable and today's Zcash went to like 95 dollars and it was like 40 yesterday I'm not sure exactly 40 50 and I promised on Twitter that I'm gonna make the Zcash pump dance and it's like this is Zcash pump because I'm pumping my muscles my flexing my bicep and Zcash is almost 100. [01:26:30] Max Hillebrand: Yeah, not bad. Not bad. [01:26:34] Vlad Costea: I'm gonna ask someone to clip this. This is the Zcash pump dance. [01:26:46] Max Hillebrand: A lot of research and development happening there like the original version of Zcash was shit compared to what it is now I think so I think it's a good idea that Bitcoin has waited with implementing this because there were a lot of vulnerabilities in the early Zcash design so just recently there was a massive increase in block size with probably malicious attack. [01:27:06] Vlad Costea: No that was like five years ago. [01:27:09] Max Hillebrand: Already damn time flies but yeah like if problems like these do exist for these more complex technologies and they need to be engineered very carefully and that takes time and there's a huge risk with that and you know if Zcash fails that's not so bad of a thing as if Bitcoin would fail so we need to be very careful with upgrading things to Bitcoin for example what you can very easily do is quote-unquote easily is to do a Zcash sidechain or a Drivechain or whatever and Paul is working on exactly that's a really great idea of getting similar technology to Bitcoin and Liquid does similar things right confidential transactions what is in monero. [01:27:55] Vlad Costea: And I think and they're not exactly they're not great no ring signature is also not scalable they're all tech monero is trying to replace. [01:28:08] Max Hillebrand: Exactly right. So that's that's the thing this these tech it was definitely an improvement to Bitcoin but it was not a substantial enough improvement considering all of the downsides include one of the downsides including you know changing Bitcoin in the first place but then also scaling downsides etc right like doing things like Lightning Network wasn't really possible on the narrow like system or yeah so like this these are all things to be considered this is still very early research and development so cryptographic systems break very easily in their early days old well-reviewed cryptographic systems are probably good but it's not a surprise when a crypto system breaks because of some mathematical insight or some other attack factor that just wasn't considered and even if you have something like mathematical proof you know that of course is a good thing to have but ultimately there were systems that did have a mathematical proof that turned out to be still insecure because the proof didn't cover all of the security assumptions that it should have and so this is just really hard and we cannot afford to change Bitcoin often and we can change Bitcoin in a way that would make it way worse and so this is really hard and we better do it right and I think the early versions of Monero or Zcash were definitely not worth it the most recent edition of research is really encouraging and we get a lot of these benefits already with something like the Great Script Restoration and like we can finally multiply numbers in Bitcoin script Who knew? [01:29:53] Max Hillebrand: But that's actually quite essential for a lot of zk proofs so this will already be would be already a really interesting step to improve or to get some of the features that zk cryptography etc allows us with not such an invasive change but of course it doesn't touch things like the amounts or input output relations so having something that's you know has a proper zk proof for all of this stuff and maybe going a bit in the direction to what DarkFi is doing or you know full membership set proofs etc are interesting right but then there are other solutions like for example client-side validation and rgb or shielded csv that are complete different design thinking for a global consensus system with a lot of interesting benefits right. [01:30:45] Max Hillebrand: So maybe going in this direction is more interesting than actually putting zk proofs on chain but again like they're kind of different tools that can be used for different reasons it's really difficult to predict how this will actually play out I think it's just worth to keep building the tools that we think might be useful and we see in a couple years how far we've come and what we can do at that point. [01:31:15] Vlad Costea: Now my point is to at least pay attention to what these projects are doing because they were supposed to come to Bitcoin monero was never supposed to be Bitcoin compatible it has its own code base which is called CryptoNote and it was reactionary to Bitcoin it's actually trying to compete with it but Zcash was made by the first guy to write a blog post about Bitcoin and who also replied to Satoshi a few times and one of the co-authors of the sidechains paper by blockstream and a bunch of early Bitcoiners who are very heavy into cryptography and they're still collaborating to improve this and the purpose of it has always been to enable Bitcoin to have privacy ironically it was ethereum that funded most of it over the last few years and they reaped the rewards sort of by making their own zk roll-up and making Tornado Cash and railgun and all of these tools that could not be possible without the research that Zcash has done and now we have the zk roll-ups which are also coming to Bitcoin but they're optimistically verified zk roll-ups because we don't have all the tools that ethereum has and where I'm getting right now is that these zk roll-ups are not optimized for privacy they use zk for data compression to basically minimize the footprint of the transaction data and it could be very cool for example if someone built Tornado Cash on Citrea that could be very interesting like just the fork of Tornado Cash put it on Citrea and see if there's any usage but at the same time at the base layer if Bitcoin had privacy we would not have all of this conversation about what is spam and what is not what is a good transaction and which is a good transaction and who should be filtered and so on because ideally miners should not be able to discriminate and the mempool should not be able to discriminate either based on the person sending or the ip address or the address coming from Bitcoin so I do believe that in order for Bitcoin to become censorship resistant it does need to become private at the base layer and if we don't get that it's just gonna get more political as we go on with people claiming that Bitcoin should not be used in this way or not in the other way or that these transactions are more important than the others because over the last 16 years people figured out different ways in which they can use Bitcoin and all of them pay transaction fees to miners but some of them are like OpenTimestamps or using Counterparty assets with OP_RETURN or inserting data with multi-sigs that's another way to do it and it just gets crazy the kind of conversations that I saw over the last few months in Bitcoin are just surreal I could never imagine that we're gonna get here and the only way in which we actually can fix these concerns is to have some sort of privacy. [01:34:39] Max Hillebrand: Yeah but this is where I'm quite bullish because I think we do have opt-in privacy with WabiSabi and that's a very much good enough approach for making input output ownership private no sure it's not mandatory it's opt-in and so more like Zcash early days than monero but that's all right hard-forking is just crazy to even consider in the Bitcoin design space and then again we have good second layer of privacy and we have I think a good outlook for future changes to Bitcoin that will make the creation of second layer systems more private there we and then if you would really want to do the data minimization to the maximum you go with an architecture like shielded csv and all that the chain needs to have is an accumulator static size that commits to all of the double spending protection basically and all the input output script logic signature verification etc all of this is simply done client side as really like in a way better privacy trade-off than even monero right or Zcash so yeah the thing is there is many ways to do this with different things and that's just really hard and so I don't think that people are stopped ever working on this or researching this it's just that it's really difficult as a computer science problem standalone and then specifically in its integration to Bitcoin just because Bitcoin is such a complex beast with so many different nuances that have to be considered where things are just not feasible that other where for example in shitcoins it is but it seems to be quite natural that there was a lot of this research and development being applied in shitcoin land because there the bar is simply lower and that's good right. [01:36:46] Max Hillebrand: We have some experimentation a bunch of stuff failed something succeeded some things were made a lot better and eventually we get to a point where we have a solution that can be applied to Bitcoin in a in a good enough way that there's a chance of making this doable and it might not be anytime soon but we're I think in no rush especially because there are I guess short-term solutions like Wasabi still available. [01:37:19] Vlad Costea: Max is there any reason why your camera is not on right now I'm just asking because there's someone in the chat who said who is the guest and you also have an interesting question as the former I shouldn't say former ceo I should say ceo of the extinct or the former company that was Wasabi and this guy arthur_pug says hey max I vividly recall your first appearance on Mad Bitcoins I have a question for you did I mess up by mixing half my coins all exchanges I use in the uk will not accept them. [01:38:02] Max Hillebrand: Yeah that's certainly an issue right that's certain exchanges can see transaction history in Bitcoin and make decisions based on that ultimately there's probably best to just respect the wishes of that organization and stop doing business with them there are alternative solutions and that's probably the best and it also gives an economic signal to the markets that okay if you don't respect user privacy you just cut less business so that would be my personal strategy. [01:38:41] Vlad Costea: Well but there are workarounds because if you're dealing with an exchange that accepts Lightning Network you can transfer your funds to a lightning wallet like Breez or Phoenix and you open a Lightning channel with your funds you send your coins to the exchange via Lightning and I think binance and coinbase and kraken support Lightning and you deposit the coins and they're not gonna ask any questions about the whereabouts because there is no on-chain footprint you open the Lightning channel you're gonna be able to send the coins via Lightning and that's it if they support liquid I think you can do the same you peg in your coins into the liquid sidechain but there is a smaller network effect with liquid and there's also permanent on-chain footprint which is not ideal another way to do it which is classic and is more time consuming and also resource consuming is to just clean your UTXOs by creating deniability which means you send the UTXO from the mix to another wallet and you pay a certain fee and then you wait a few days you send to another wallet back and forth and you pay maybe a different fee so it looks weird to anyone observing and you don't establish any pattern and people are going to be confused if they look they're not going to be sure if it was a payment if it was a self-transfer and I think if you do this like six or seven times with every UTXO you're fine because there is enough deniability the idea is to just not do it on the same day or over the same week or have a pattern which obviously gives away that it was you doing this and I do recognize that this is stupid and it should not be like this but if you're gonna play by the rules I think there's stupid blockchain analysis filters are gonna believe that your coins are fine after you do a few of these steps another way is for you to swap into something else like litecoin or whatever and get on exchanges because litecoin is super spread like you can find it on every exchange and I don't think they're gonna ask any question and you can actually peg your coins into MWEB on litecoin which is Mimblewimble extension block and then peg out to the exchange and they're not gonna ask any question because it just looks like you're a whale and you sent from that one so there are some workarounds all of them have their trade-offs it's just as you said it's this social consensus which sort of tells these business operators that they are fine with accepting coins from this sort of transaction and the other ones are not accepted which is really bad. [01:41:41] Max Hillebrand: Yeah but you know this is a big market Bitcoin is a huge ecosystem right now so just look for alternatives and they do exist in many ways right as we keep saying here there's so much technology out there's so many service provider out there do your own research figure it out there's a way. [01:42:00] Vlad Costea: Yeah but did it ever happen to you that you sent your CoinJoined Bitcoin to some exchange and it was not accepted? No not personally I know this is confidential but how do you manage to live on Bitcoin especially if your Bitcoin is CoinJoin like what's your approach? [01:42:27] Max Hillebrand: Well basically just use Bitcoin when whenever possible right and cash is a good fiat bridge right if needed but yeah ultimately that is the main way and like I like to stick with friends ultimately precious sats should go to serious people right and people that you like and I think that if you're if you actually hold Bitcoin you're on the easy side of the trade because everyone wants to have more Bitcoin and it's yeah harder to get Bitcoin than I think it is to get rid of Bitcoin just because demand is higher than supply so yeah go to your local meetup make some friends meet people who want to stack sats and you know give them sats and they will do stuff for you it's quite useful how money functions it's the most universal medium of exchange right. You can literally get people to do whatever for money put that on a t-shirt you can literally get. [01:43:37] Vlad Costea: People to do whatever for money This is Jerry, by the way yeah cute one you. [01:43:53] Max Hillebrand: Could have some you know Bitcoin private keys stacked in the nfc tag. [01:44:01] Vlad Costea: He's pressing keys oh he locked my computer I hope we're still live streaming my god such a bad. [01:44:09] Max Hillebrand: Boy a little bit of keys is always good yeah. [01:44:19] Vlad Costea: I had to type my password I'm happy we're still alive and he boosted also the volume in my headphones ah such a naughty boy just with two touches he locked my laptop and he increased the volume. [01:44:33] Max Hillebrand: Quite sophisticated hacker. [01:44:35] Vlad Costea: Yeah also arthur_pug says that Bitrefill accepts mixed coins Yeah, they should. [01:44:47] Max Hillebrand: I don't know most providers do and again if you find someone that doesn't just move on they're idiots anyway like that's that's the thing like where you spend your money is a very powerful action that you can take and then it's something that you can choose wisely you can put your money to systems where that are not useful to you or hinder human flourishing in general or just you use you spend your money at places that actually help you and respect your assets what. [01:45:23] Vlad Costea: I find interesting is that my experience with exchanges was that they asked for such an unreasonable amounts of documents that I gave up I was like okay just close my account I don't care anymore they wanted payment statements for the last five years and I was like why first of all why should I have payment statements from like five years ago secondly why not even my bank asked for this information not even my government asked for this information what's wrong with you it's just too much I'm like okay you put your passport you put your driver's license proof of residence whatever and then they're like okay send us a letter from your bank or whatever fine bank statement okay fine and then they want payment statements it's just ridiculous yeah. [01:46:16] Max Hillebrand: Yeah again you don't have to use them man like even bank accounts are totally optional both for individuals and for businesses so we have cyberspace money now guys you can use it's a thing though. [01:46:35] Vlad Costea: Oh you're a very interesting case max I remember I met you in 2019 you came to Romania I think that was your first long travel and before that you posted a picture in which you cut your credit card and you said you're gonna live without a bank. [01:46:50] Max Hillebrand: It was actually a debit card I never had a credit card in my life actually so but yeah I quit all my bank accounts. [01:46:57] Vlad Costea: Is that still the case like after six years you still have no bank account. [01:46:57] Max Hillebrand: Yep, yep. [01:46:57] Vlad Costea: Which is funny because it's really I don't want to talk too much about your life but I think you were a banker at some point. [01:47:13] Max Hillebrand: Yeah in the belly of the beast and when the contract ended and the last paycheck came in that was then full-time freedom tech so and you know I've met people who quit their bank account in 2012 and live on Bitcoin only so this is this has always been possible might be difficult you know but it got so much easier you know there are legit merchants that will really sell you any reasonable product with great rates, you know and so yeah. And Bitcoin also gives you access to international markets you can easily work with someone in another country because the payment doesn't care and so for most services or goods you can do international search for businesses that will help you and the world is a big place you know. [01:48:13] Vlad Costea: Yeah but at the same time I gotta ask you because if I'm not mistaken you're somewhere in europe right no actually no on a latin american trip oh funny because there is a war on cash in europe right and for lots of payments you can't you have daily limits or you have spending limits for certain items like for example you can't buy a car with cash not anymore in the european union they made it so that anything more expensive than 2 000 euro or something has to go through a bank you can't buy a house I'm not sure if you can rent without a bank account it depends on the landlord but it's definitely interesting that they're having this war on cash where on one hand they're trying to make it difficult for you to make payments and on the other hand they're trying to push banks as something that is essential for your daily economic life and there are certain cities around europe where even paying with cash is a challenge like I had euro in amsterdam in cash and they were looking at me like okay so what do you want to do with that why don't you pay with card like everyone else. [01:49:29] Max Hillebrand: Yeah well I mean you'll probably still find places to take it and if not just go to a different city right but ultimately I will believe that there's an end to cash when they stop printing it but they're still printing so much of it and I don't see that changing anytime soon like they've added of course the existing digital part of the base money supplier at the central bank reserves that already exists CBDCs are also coming but I don't think that they will come at the expense of cash I think cash will continue to be around or for some time cash is not perfectly private either by the way right they have serial numbers and they're definitely being checked and most cash goes back to the bank quite quickly so there's still some information that they can analyze there and that they do but ultimately cash is interesting especially because it is natural base money right it is not the liability of someone else it is a thing in and of itself and you have full ownership over it as soon as you have basically and that is analogous to gold or to Bitcoin in the fiat world right. [01:50:42] Max Hillebrand: So it is the highest quality fiat asset and it also comes with the least amount of additional money expansion as soon as you put your cash into a bank they turn around and loan it at a factor of a thousand right. So they create new money m1 on top of the base money that you just deposited right. So that's inflation unit if you put your cash into the bank you're you are creating additional money or rather you're giving the bank the ability to create additional money and that's inflation right. [01:51:16] Max Hillebrand: So you're starting the cantillon effect you're actively transferring wealth from those who received the newly created money later to those who received it first right and you are one of them but the bank very much more so and yeah so that's a good thing right. So if you if you do require to hold your wealth in fiat just for ethical reasons as well as strategic I would much rather prefer cash than a bank. [01:51:44] Vlad Costea: That makes a lot of sense but then again in lots of countries in europe you have limits for how much you can spend and the only way you can actually benefit from these goods because you can't buy a car or house is to rent which if you're holding Bitcoin is a pretty good decision on the long term I think. [01:52:08] Max Hillebrand: Yeah getting a house buying a house with anything like I think Bitcoin gold or cash in europe I'm not sure if that's true but I've heard that the notary will have to send a notification to every financial authority in every country of europe to announce that you have made this transaction and so I think it is possible it's just barely done and comes with a bunch of additional headaches that needs to be dealt with one of the many reasons why real estate is a shitcoin so there's not many reasons why you would want to buy you know many houses you just need shelter and that can be done in other ways as well so yeah consider that and again the whenever there is a lot of local oppression you always have the option to leave and in many cases that's probably the right decision if you want to optimize for freedom which is not what you want to which might not be what you want to optimize for. [01:53:09] Vlad Costea: Yeah makes a lot of sense I gotta ask you max oh there's also a comment still from arthur I don't think we answered to his question because it was did I mess up mixing half my bitcoins did he mess up or was it a good choice oh I think. [01:53:27] Max Hillebrand: It's a it's a good choice again it comes with benefits and it comes with downsides but yeah I think the fact that without taking care of your privacy on chain that if just this public knowledge when and how much and from whom you received money and when and how long you held on to it and went into whom you're spending it like that's scary information to just put out there in the public so I think protecting against that comes with a huge benefit in and of itself and then yeah there might be some downsides like some business not wanting to work with you okay since there are plenty of alternatives that's not really that big of a deal I think personal protection should be valued quite highly so I guess yeah you wait in other words you did fuck up should have coined joint the entire amount but you only protect yourself halfway right. [01:54:26] Vlad Costea: What do you think about these btc backed loans I think there is a company called firefish which specializes in that in europe you give them your Bitcoin they give you a loan which is usually 50 of what your Bitcoin is worth and you're supposed to pay that back in I guess six months 12 months 24 months 18 it's up to you how long but the idea is that at a certain date according to the contract you're supposed to have I don't think this works without a bank account by the way you're supposed to have the exact amount that you borrowed in your bank account and if you don't you're going to lose your Bitcoin collateral have you heard about this and by the way for the listeners if you want to try that I'm not saying you should but if you do want to try that you can use promo code BTCTKVR for a discount on your fee. [01:55:20] Max Hillebrand: And Bitcoin is very interesting collateral right because it's internationally liquid without any additional markup or it's very fungible right like houses are very bad in this regard they're very dependent on location and cash flow etc occupancy rate the quality of the housing etc it's much more difficult to analyze the actual the actual saleableness of real estate if you want to give that as a collateral for a loan because you want to have a saleable collateral is in the case that the payer defaults you want to rather quickly get the money back that's what the collateral is for so Bitcoin is way better for that it also comes with many privacy upsides because if you don't need to know the physical address because it's not a house and because it is internationally sellable without any personal liability claims etc you don't technically need to have you know identity associated with this it's just a bearer instrument that can be put in some sort of smart contract that then results in the release of liquidity and if that for example is in let's say Tether and you could even do it in an atomic way and so there's a trustless exchange for the collateral and the actual fiat liquidity the credit line that was taken so yeah it's a really interesting toolkit credit is very useful economically speaking and we need to have like we need to have credit in order to produce something someone has to give money upfront right and that and that's either the owner of the business right equity holders or it's debt, someone who gives cash in exchange for a percentage return in the future with a predefined payback right and so these are different structures and how we can define credit but we need that to produce and so it's very necessary that the Bitcoin economy builds credit systems and Bitcoin collateralized loans is one such form of credit it's quite a naive and simplistic form like there's way more sophisticated banking and finance applications that we could do with Bitcoin but yeah we this is a good first step let's start forward. [01:57:48] Vlad Costea: Yeah but my question to you is would you do something like this or you think it's better to sell because the mantra of all of this system is that you should never sell your Bitcoin you take a loan and of course I don't recommend this it's just the way some people do it when they have to pay back the loan they take another loan with another side of their Bitcoin stack and this is a way for them to access fiat without paying taxes because loans are not taxed and they just keep on doing this to take another loan to pay off the one that they previously took let's say that you have two bitcoins and you take a loan against your first Bitcoin and then to pay that back you take another loan against that Bitcoin and you just keep this going because you unlock the first one and you access liquidity until maybe one day you're gonna have enough money to pay it back but once again it's risky because in a bear market you're sort of screwed and you have to yeah you're basically. [01:58:47] Max Hillebrand: Putting leverage on your personal balance sheet and that you know is an option to do it's not necessary most people don't do it but like I guess well I guess many people do have a credit line right. So it just depends on your general financial stability so to say I guess what's important to be capital positive right to earn more sats than you spend every month I guess that's important if you're if you're not stack increases that's a good thing right and maybe you'll get there if you add some leverage and therefore risk in your portfolio you know maybe it's worth it maybe not but I think the just basic I guess the equivalent of dollar-cost average on the other side after hyperbitcoinization is just to earn more sats than you spend right and then you accumulate a small sat amount every month and this whole life is right people don't really leverage up their salary you can you know and if you know what you're doing you can do that in a very risk managed way where complete default is quite unlikely but yeah you need to know what you're doing it's not really something I focus on that much I know a bit about it since the banking days. [02:00:18] Vlad Costea: I was gonna see this that basically I woke up the banker inside you. [02:00:23] Max Hillebrand: Yeah but I have so much ptsd from that I'd rather stay away from it building freedom tech is much more healthy. [02:00:33] Vlad Costea: So do you believe that basically selling some of the Bitcoin that you have is much better than taking fiat against it. [02:00:43] Max Hillebrand: I mean it just really depends if it's better or not. [02:00:48] Vlad Costea: There are some people in the space who virtue-signal about never having sold any Bitcoin and I'm just trying to prove a point here yeah I mean that's. [02:00:57] Max Hillebrand: That just means you've you've not really showed value to anyone else yet right by giving them some Bitcoin it. [02:01:05] Vlad Costea: Also means that you have so much. [02:01:06] Max Hillebrand: Fiat if you never had to sell any Bitcoin yeah exactly yep so yeah it's worth it to just you know analyze it as a balance sheet somehow right like what's what's my total wealth and where do I have my wealth in what type of assets and Bitcoin is of course a good category to put it in there yeah that is useful tool if you know what you're doing but it doesn't have to be used so keeping it simple is probably the least headache approach which I think is worth optimizing that's that's what I like Bitcoin for that's what money is for right money is there to decrease the uneasiness that we perceive and we're uneasy because we don't know what food we want to eat tomorrow at what time and so that's why instead of pre-ordering a pizza at that time we keep cash in the wallet because then we can go to any restaurant and buy a steak instead an hour later and so the optionality is useful and is simple and that's what money affords us and now for the first time we have base money experience in cyberspace with Bitcoin and so that's very special and you can use that and sure it's a bit different than using like dollars cash or whatever but it's better in many ways to. [02:02:40] Vlad Costea: Come back to the original topic which I think we sort of diverged too much from it if someone was to onboard Nostr today and they're listening to this maybe that they haven't heard of it before and they want to try it what do you think is the best setup and which one is maybe most compatible with what you're doing with White Noise. [02:03:03] Max Hillebrand: Yeah so I'll give the easy answer first and then we go down a deep rabbit hole with the actual way how to do it so the easy answer is just to get primal and primal is the website primal.net and it's an app on iOS android and there you can easily create a new account you'll find some interesting people whom to follow and you can set your profile pic and bio and whatever and you can connect it to a wallet which is custodial but at least that you know easily works for even newcomers who haven't heard anything about Bitcoin and you're basically set up with reading and creating short posts and long blog posts and watch some live streams and you know send money and other stuff but that's a good easy way of doing it now if you want to be serious about it get a new phone get a Google Pixel like nine or ten put GrapheneOS on it then install Zap Store which is a Nostr based app store and from there you can install a VPN or Tor, like Orbot and secure connection that way and then install amber which is an app which to generate your private keys and to store it and to make it accessible either via the android signer specification or via the bunker remote signer specification and yeah so you set up your keys there and then you install citrine is an application that spins up your own Nostr relay and so that you actually keep all of your events in this dedicated app and other applications can pull your events locally so that even if you're online you can see the events that you have in your own relay really powerful basically turns your phone into a full node or you have a designer and the relay and ultimately a client all installed together so the client would be amethyst that's a super powerful Nostr client has an insane amount of features way more than primal by the way so definitely check it out if you haven't yet and so with this you can do a bunch of things you know discover new nodes have communities there messaging marketplaces yeah a bunch of different stuff that can be explored also you could install pokey which is an application for notifications so here you can specify for what type of Nostr events do you want to be notified good to check that out as well Yakihonne is another really interesting client that has quite a lot of features so that's that's one worth checking out there's now also a Damus client one of the early Nostr clients on iOS is now also available on Android with a complete rework of the code super interesting approach yeah what other interesting apps are there to be checked out there is Wavlake which is a music player basically for built on top of Nostr where you can easily share the music that you're listening to and find new artists or watch live streams and Tunestr is another of these yeah many really cool ideas to look through there's Nostr.net I believe has a list of awesome Nostr clients and relays so you can browse through and you will find probably over a thousand of applications that are somehow using the Nostr protocol now and you would just browse through and see what's interesting to you and then you try it out they're all over the place on web desktop ios androids that kind of whatever. [02:07:01] Vlad Costea: Yeah usually when it comes to stuff like this you explain how people can get a phone from Google which is the pixel and you recommended the nine or the ten and to get GrapheneOS I mean that's the ideal setup if you have a weekend to do that and some disposable money to invest in that but usually I think the best approach is to use the phone that you already have and you dip your toes into this software and you understand how it works and if you want to get serious about it yeah it's good to have like a dedicated device that lets you use all the applications and everything but I think for starters something like damus or primal or even Iris by Martti Malmi it's really good yeah it's a good place to start and then if you really like it and you want to take it seriously then maybe you should consider investing more money into it but it's the same with nodes right because people say well if you want to run a node then maybe you should buy this device and connect it to your router and keep it on all the time and like no just use the computer that you have with a pruned node five gigabytes is more than enough it's something that you most likely have sync the node understand how it works play with it for a bit see what it can do and if you want to get serious about it like there's no reason to run a 24-7 node unless you're running an electrum server or you're on the Lightning Network and you want to keep your channels open there is absolutely no reason and the computer that you have is most likely more than enough. [02:08:43] Max Hillebrand: Yeah no that's that's a very good point right. So it there's a lot of ways of doing it starting out easy is probably recommended and the rabbit hole goes deep so I haven't found the end yet so if you want to you can definitely keep exploring this for a long time and that's just really interesting because you can also nicely build your own applications if you're a developer especially then it's really developer friendly but also if you're just a vibe coder and you don't even write code but you can talk to an llm there's shakespeare.diy which is a nice web interface to write a prompt to an llm that then in like 10 minutes or so creates you a website that is a Nostr client that does whatever you want it to do and there's some really cool projects coming out of even some you know noob tools like that but if you actually know what you're doing then you can do quite impressive stuff. [02:09:49] Vlad Costea: Yeah I do see a lot of these vibe coded applications blossoming sometimes they're good because you don't really need to be a skilled coder you just need a good idea and there are lots of open source libraries that can serve your purpose not necessarily in the best way but in a good enough way I can think of very smart people who know how to code but don't have any good ideas and then there are creative people who say well maybe someone should build this and now you can actually try to do it yourself you just ask an llm how you can do it and then you ask it to guide you step by step in doing it break it down in maybe one hour per day or whatever amount of time you have and then make it happen in a couple of weeks it's interesting and. [02:10:42] Max Hillebrand: We should also even though the basic protocol is very simplistic and by now we have hundreds of different nips and sub protocols and so a lot of the things that you want to do have already been solved which is really interesting so you get a lot of things for free I'd like I don't know in the White Noise example right if we want to people to have their username and password not a username password like the username and profile picture like automatically just magically import as soon as you log in with your private key and this type of things that we don't have to worry about okay how are we going to handle this part of the code base it's just the standard way it's implemented in the library you just call the basic function and display it in the ui and that's it but that also goes to more architectural things like for example that the user actually has his own private key and attests to certain events via signature you know that's such a foundational building block that it literally closed that huge backdoor in MLS where the authentication service is trusted because of that architecture of Nostr we can so easily close this security hole by putting that responsibility to the user who is you know by definition not compromise in what we're building that's a really cool solution that saves us so much headache and it's very easy to do or message delivery and it's there's really many different and difficult ways on how to get your message stored for the long run but just putting them via WebSockets on a relay is really simple or another of these standards is blossom we haven't talked about that yet it's a really cool standard where you can instead of Nostr is based on json messages so it's just text which works for many things but it doesn't work well for larger files like pictures or pdfs or sounds music right this just means that we need another protocol to solve that and blossom is basically that it's a very simple protocol where you can upload a file to a server and the file will be addressed by its hash so instead of having a it's being addressed by use a file name it is just a hash of the file meaning it's very easy to see that this is the actual file that we're looking for and it hasn't been tampered with but you get metadata similar to Nostr where you can put a file name and the author of this you know like the person via signature as well in the metadata fields and that can then be used together with Nostr very nicely so this for example we use in Marmot and in MLS with for encrypting and uploading images either for example for the group avatar or for messages that contain images or speech recordings etc so blossom solves this very nicely in with similar trade-offs to Nostr that the content is signed and hash addressed and therefore it can be replicated across multiple servers and there's a standard interface of how to talk to these servers and you can easily run one yourself even on the phone if you want and that is a really powerful architecture that works easily for any dev but then in the long run can be made really robust and resilient so yeah Nostr is really cool to work with. [02:14:38] Vlad Costea: Is there anything about White Noise that you haven't mentioned yet. [02:14:45] Max Hillebrand: I guess just to highlight again that this is all about creating a library and good dev tooling or for it so we're working really closely with people who want to add an encrypted Nostr experience to their existing clients so if you're not one of the people that we talk to but you have a cool Nostr client reach out and let's have a chat on what you need for that to work out and yeah I'm really thankful for all the positive feedback that we are getting from existing developers like a lot of people really want to see this tech and deploy it in their clients and so hopefully soon we can deliver a library that's good enough for that to actually be done in production processes is really nicely shaping up so if you want to test early just go to whitenoise.app — no, whitenoise.chat and there you can download it or also Zap Store just search for White Noise there and it will be signed released by us and yeah try around with it to break it and tell us how to make it better we have a couple cool ideas on what's to come because it's nice to have a messenger app where we can really natively integrate Bitcoin and freedom tech into the OS, right or into the app itself so messenger with an integrated wallet or where it's also possible to make public posts for example and that leverages all the benefits of Nostr and not just in White Noise but also in others like for example the marketplaces and nip I think very interesting but of course deserves a very high standard of security for the messages and for example you would want to have just a private marketplace in the neighborhood right where you don't want anyone to see what exactly is being offered here unless you're living in that neighborhood or a part of any other group that you would want with Marmot it's easily possible to encrypt any type of Nostr event and that's just a kicker that's that makes this so much more useful than just and just the chatter because Nostr really is much more about all the other stuff than about social media and I think Marmot is much more about the other stuff than just chat messages like chat is super crucial and we definitely need to have that so this is kind of the priority but there is many other use cases that really deserve to take a look at. [02:17:33] Vlad Costea: Yeah so the important question right now is when is this coming out like what you have right now is a testnet version TestFlight for ios I think it's still in beta if I'm not mistaken. [02:17:50] Max Hillebrand: Yeah so if the app is out already on TestFlight on iOS and on Android only on Zap Store basically or GitHub well you can also get it on Obtainium or a couple other stores but not yet in the official google play store because releasing applications in the legacy app stores is just a mess so yeah that's the way to get it and the libraries are of course and the code for White Noise is of course open source so you can check out the mdk is the Marmot development kit where which we use inside White Noise it depends on rust Nostr as well so the back end logic is entirely written in Rust and for White Noise the front end is written in flutter so that's kind of what we're optimizing for at the moment but we're looking to make sure that this works with Kotlin, TypeScript and any other programming language that people would want to use so yeah there's this is out already it's a deliverable intermediary as I said earlier it's quite shit a lot of things don't work yet but we have really cool progress and by the end of the year or so it should be a really compelling actual usable solution for sending messages and then and one of the cool things also that it allows is that it's very easy to create a second identity or a second account that's over for example signal or WhatsApp kind of limits you to one account per application with White Noise that's that's not the case so the app is kind of designed to have multiple accounts that each have their own separate database that each might have their own tor or vpn connection and it's nicely self-contained and therefore we yeah you know make it easy for people who have organizations or just multiple projects to manage and that will hopefully be quite interesting. [02:20:01] Vlad Costea: Yeah I do have to ask you as the ceo of Wasabi and the company went down a couple of years ago but I still have to ask you what's happening with Wasabi right now it's an open source project and is it still getting funded is it still being maintained and developed do coin joints still work or is it just a non-custodial wallet that you can use. [02:20:29] Max Hillebrand: Yeah so I was never the ceo of Wasabi because Wasabi is just code right it's a GitHub repo but we had a company called zkSNACKs and that was there to run a coordinator and to pay for research and development for Wasabi but that was open source from the very beginning and so eventually we decided to shut down our coordinator and the company so we had to unfortunately stop paying for the researchers and developers and cryptographers and you know marketing people and awesome individuals which is sad but due to the open nature of the codes it's all there and people are continually working on it improving it and people are using it and so there's multiple CoinJoin coordinators available which interestingly use Nostr to announce themselves to the network Nostr is a really good discovery layer and so technically there is a new Nostr event that a coordinator can create which has the kind number whatever for CoinJoin coordination announcement that specifies the protocol that is being used and the url or onion address where the coordinator is reachable and that is signed by a private key and the private key can have some web of trust right like from a reputable account that has followers or that you know gets engagement on his posts so this tech is used to yeah find out who are the coordinators available and yeah conjoin works with large liquidity is especially so I think the volumes are continuously is like even larger than when we were running the coordinator back in the days yeah. [02:22:25] Vlad Costea: I did interview Kruw, who is running the largest coordinator right now and I've also interviewed Lucas Ontivero and marnix was it marnix I had a lot of. [02:22:38] Max Hillebrand: The Wasabi crew I think nopara as well a couple times. [02:22:42] Vlad Costea: No I mean since the company zkSNACKs went down I did have this interview these interviews because there were two of them and it was interesting to learn about how the project is going to continue as an open source project but it's also useful to hear it directly from you because you're responsible for many of the operations that were taking place and you are coordinating a lot of the activity concerning development and also the business strategy yeah. [02:23:20] Max Hillebrand: And it's a really cool project and continues to do some good stuff yeah but you know I like working on Wasabi for like seven years or something like this so it's nice to work on something else as well especially because I consider that again we have a really good enough solution with Wasabi you know can be improved in many ways but there's more urgent problems that need to be addressed and I think Nostr addresses a lot of the urgent problems but one of the foundational problems that Nostr has is that it's only public data right. [02:24:03] Max Hillebrand: So to really have a proper private data protocol on top of Nostr is I think quite critical as a building block for many other applications on top and so yeah let's let's see where Marmot goes I'm really excited for it and the progress there is really encouraging as well and yeah it's not as it's not really a that difficult of a protocol or approach at least at first glance if you dig deeper it will probably get quite complicated eventually especially the MLS specification but there's two official documents here there's RFC 9420 which is the IETF standard for the entire cryptography etc that the MLS protocol uses that was like the introductory paper or specification that was published probably in 2021 or something maybe a bit later and then later there was RFC 9420 or something which is the MLS architecture specification this is more a high level on okay how does the system actually get put together more of an overview that references to the earlier document both of them are really interesting to read I would definitely recommend to start with the architecture doc both of them are just mountainously long you know I always admired the early cypherpunks of writing like a short two paragraph email and just in that announcing and explaining and like grooving an insane crazy idea like I don't know blind signatures or something so like cypherpunks were really dense like not much blabber or extra fuss but I can or like the IETF is not so with the standards the first document is like 170 pages and so it's really long and several and full of math and code and difficult to read and the others another 80 pages or so these are not short BIPs or something like these are quite hard documents to read or sophisticated or detailed at least so really implementing this from scratch and reviewing it is really difficult and I guess that's the downside right this complexity is tough right a simpler system would be interesting but a simpler system doesn't solve all of the problems that we needed to solve kind of yeah I'm still curious if MLS is actually the right choice for this in the long run but at the moment I think it's a quite good option to pursue you further yeah. [02:26:57] Vlad Costea: You're working on a lot of stuff I do like your consistency and your work ethic when it comes to privacy and I'm happy that you found a way to bring privacy into a place that traditionally is very open and transparent and in a bad way and what else do I want to ask about this just a second that there was a question that basically stems from your previous statement eluded my mind it will come anything in the chat no just someone who was complaining that he cannot see you on YouTube but that then I guess the feed sort of updated it was from when you turned your camera off okay you. [02:27:49] Max Hillebrand: Yeah oh there's another really interesting oh yeah I've also remembered still going okay cool it's called NoDNS it's kind of fresh out of the oven and it's basically a way to put a dns record inside the Nostr event and so that ultimately we don't have to go to centralized dns registrars but we can just check signatures on friend that we get from Nostr relays so this is another really interesting step where we basically have a public key addressed ip registrar system or any of the other tricks that dns can do nicely integrated into Nostr like a really simple idea to just combine these two protocols and then really interesting things are possible now but this and this is just one of the many really cool projects in the space. [02:28:47] Vlad Costea: Yeah so my question was concerning or was about funding and the fact that with open source software it's very hard to fund stuff in the case of Wasabi it was actually simple you're running a coordinator it was the largest of its kind people were paying fees for that and the company was able to keep going and hire developers and everything that was necessary in order to make the project successful but with White Noise and the Marmot protocol it's not as straightforward like how are you guys going to make money off of this yeah. [02:29:25] Max Hillebrand: Like the short part of it is grants are extremely helpful I grant open source projects to get some basic funding early on in the research and development phase oh yeah that's that's really good that there's many organizations like OpenSats, HRF etc that do some funding or actually quite a lot of funding or for these projects including White Noise which is nice but I think in the long run in the past business models in cyberspace really had issues because there was no secure money system so making transactions from the user to the service provider was really difficult and then the solution to that was to somehow have a business to business deal where you get a lot of money and that subsidizes the development for a client-facing application so advertisement is one of the obvious ways to do that and a big company pays you a lot of money to change what clients are seeing and then you know that incentivizes everyone to work on it and get paid the good thing is the surprise we have digital money now we can make money transactions in cyberspace and we can make them programmatically right. [02:30:42] Max Hillebrand: We can literally write code that spends Bitcoin under whatever condition we want right it's not a like global consensus smart contract that's on the Bitcoin blockchain but if you have a software that has a Bitcoin private key or you know a lightning LNURL withdrawal key or some Cashu eCash or whatever access to send one of the many ways that you can spend Bitcoin since that is just software we can write ways to move the money to wherever we want so if you are working on a software that has a way to send Bitcoin natively integrated already then you can really just write the code that moves the money from the user to you right in the company or whatever and the software will do that right. [02:31:33] Max Hillebrand: So now of course you need to you know make this official and terms and conditions and contracts etc and tell the user that you're doing a and hopefully choosing something that is a reasonable amount a fee to be taken right because it will of course affect if people will end up using the software or not but if the software is really great and the fee that you're charging automatically is considered and not too much then you will have a lot of users and you know earn the money from each of the user and be able to then invest that money into hiring more developers and researchers etc the good thing is that this nicely grows with the adoption of your tool because if you have a software that nobody is using or like a couple hundred people are using then you probably shouldn't spend a lot of money on building that software right because it doesn't do that much good in the world but later on when you keep slowly improving that software and eventually thousands tens of thousands millions of people start using that software now all of a sudden it makes much more sense to put more capital into creating this tool because more depends on it and then in this case once you get a small fee from any user that means that at the beginning you don't earn much so you're naturally just not over investing in something that might turn out to be a bad idea but if it turns out to be a good idea and people like it and people use it then you should naturally make enough money to hire a team to build out the software to a larger extent so yeah Bitcoin is an absolute gift to I guess digital entrepreneurs who have software products because now we literally can you know write how the user's money is moving and then that makes designing a sustainable business model that does not depend on advertisement much more feasible so one of the great ways that we would do that not always does it but that's how something else will do it is for example to say hey whenever you make a zap on Nostr by default I don't know five percent gets sent extra to the developers but then there's a setting where if the user is annoyed with sending five percent he can turn it all the way to zero and so it's an opt-in donation basically but on the other hand the slider should go to infinity meaning you set it to eight hundred percent and if someone's clicks to zap for ten thousand sats then an additional eighty thousand sats gets sent to the developer and why not if the user really loves the application and is happy to support the projects then make it possible and easy and intuitive and convenient without many clicks to actually send money from the user to the builder right and as long as that it's done in a good design and with you know ethical announcement and consent of the user and this is a yeah super exciting way of doing it. [02:35:02] Vlad Costea: Yeah as long as you have a way to opt out it's fine because if you don't it's basically a tax. You know what we think about what we think about taxes in this part of the world. [02:35:15] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I mean it really depends on the details but ultimately this is just a one offering of a one specific person right there's alternatives that you could go to you're not required to use that service and so it's different than an actual state-level tax but I get your point of course right and it's just it's again another design tool that can be used in whatever way right. [02:35:40] Max Hillebrand: You could have a mandates that the use of the service requires a payment that makes sense in a lot of application or if you wouldn't have this you would have issues with spam or denial of services or whatever but then on the other hand you can have in other problems you can design it such that the user can opt out of it and literally set it to zero and maybe you punish him with an like sad emoji in the notification like telling him that all the developer will not have his pizza after the end of the hard days of work and pull on his heartstrings a bit to maybe change his decision or not there's a large design in how you could build a software tool with this. [02:36:29] Vlad Costea: There is Tom Dwyer in the chat he wants us to wrestle in mud with this topic anything on Core and Knots. [02:36:41] Max Hillebrand: I think Bitcoin would benefit greatly if it would have a standard a standard first driven development rather than implementation first development if we would have a clear protocol that defines what a valid Bitcoin block is ultimately how we would get into consensus and we would have multiple implementations of it that would lead to I think more innovation and more use cases being satisfied in a secure way of course there's a lot of nuances here but ultimately I think that would be a core solution to this problem yeah but it's a big problem to create a Bitcoin node it's a really difficult thing it's difficult and there are many decisions where you could argue either way and that's just trade-offs all the way down it's hard to do it's hard to change Bitcoin I'm really curious how this will affect future changes to Bitcoin's consensus rules simply because seemingly with SegWit and Taproot things were introduced in a in a consensus change that later a large amount of or a substantial amount of individuals are not happy with the consequences that led to but specifically a large increase in UTXO set size and the bloating and kind of abuse of the witness discount which originally was designed to incentivize the consolidation of the UTXO set but now evidently led to the like I don't know 3x or 4x increase of it in just a couple years so this these unintended consequences are important to consider right and just add to the complexity of working on Bitcoin so yeah it's chaos and really difficult and nobody really knows exactly how to do it and that's just yeah it's the reality of the system so if you are not up for rough consensus which is rough in like the tough sense you know sometimes you get an elbow to the face then yeah this is probably not for you but the good thing is you don't really have to be that much involved like your Bitcoin node will continue to work for a long time most likely so yeah if you want to delve into the details of it yeah sure it's interesting so if I would have to choose between Core and Knots I would probably say the Bitcoin I— [02:39:24] Vlad Costea: Was gonna ask you if you're gonna run version 30 of Bitcoin Core like because I will I gotta tell you I will it's part of the philosophy that enables stuff like Citrea to function efficiently and I do think it's a net benefit. [02:39:44] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I'm in generally rather slow with updating my Bitcoin node plus at the moment I don't really have an important node to run this with right this used to be different with Wasabi Wallet, right like the zkSNACKs node was a very economically powerful node because it produced block filters for a large amount of users with a large amount of Bitcoin and in that case the decision is a very difficult one actually right because there's good arguments on both sides and you will have users who follow both arguments of this right. [02:40:24] Max Hillebrand: So there will be some disaster waiting to happen ultimately interestingly the zkSNACKs backend was running Bitcoin knots for a long time already before this whole drama started mainly because knots is a more configurable implementation and does things that we needed it to do that core was not able to do and where it's where we tried to make changes to Bitcoin Core to get it to work for us but those changes were rejected ultimately while with Bitcoin Core they some of the things that we needed were was merged and so we could more easier use it I know there these are different things that you consider when you're choosing implementation of an old but yeah building a wallet back end is a very different use case than just running a personal node my decision now is not as important on this as it used to be yeah. [02:41:28] Vlad Costea: You're super diplomatic about it's just that to me when someone comes up to you and says well you should run the software because if you don't people are gonna inscribe bad stuff on your node and you're gonna go to jail I mean that's really silly and it's anti the kind of Bitcoin to which I subscribe and it's this permissionless technology that anyone can use however they want as long as they pay their fee it's none of my business how they use it and if my node stores it's encoded in the Bitcoin language to put it like this so it's not like a jpeg that you double click by opening your node files it's something which is encoded if you want to basically transform every Bitcoin transaction into a jpeg you can actually do that there's an online tool for it and it's just gonna be some random stuff that gets generated from it but my point right now is that Bitcoin should be kept permissionless and you should not come with this sort of attack against people using Bitcoin in ways that you don't like by appealing to the worst of extremes and saying well they're gonna inscribe csam or whatever it is that they're talking about and then it's become illegal to run a node and there's gonna be legal consequences I don't like it I think it's the lowest point of debate and that kind of stuff already is on your node if you search hard enough their argument is that it's gonna be easier for them to do it like they can already inscribe it and get the SegWit discount there's nothing really stopping them. [02:43:19] Max Hillebrand: Yeah well I mean there can be things to at least reduce it right filters like objectively work right a larger amount of transactions follow filter policy specifically because Bitcoin is mainly one implementation right or at least the filter is called the mempool. [02:43:37] Vlad Costea: It's not for the blockchain so you may filter it but then you're gonna have it on your node anyway because it gets mined. [02:43:47] Max Hillebrand: Yeah that's that's true right but still it this and other things make that most that many people do follow the filter policy right and like the size of OP_RETURNs was usually around the limit that the filter policy was sent and of course right there's also consensus rules right like if you're not free to put a transaction on chain that has an invalid signature all right that's that's that's not how you do it right. [02:44:16] Max Hillebrand: So when designing a protocol we inherently have to be opinionated with what is valid and what is invalid and so and Bitcoin is very opinionated in a very a bunch of weird ways I'd like script for example as a complete shit show or like the different hashing ways that like the different hash types or for transaction sighashes etc so there's a lot of things that we define in a protocol that makes any communication with it invalid that goes for any protocol right. [02:44:50] Max Hillebrand: So we have to consider on what should be these parameters and it's important to talk about them right and to make sure that they're correct because they have consequences right. We can absolutely change parameters in Bitcoin on the like consensus level filter level or just implementation level that would have drastic consequences to the network and kill it right. So these types of changes absolutely do exist if this OP_RETURN thing is one of them probably not but it definitely is still controversial enough to actually consider it carefully because but. [02:45:26] Vlad Costea: That's like the part of the Bitcoin block that you can prune from your the OP_RETURN it's not permanent if honestly if you really want to put bad stuff on the blockchain you can use the STAMPS protocol because that one is unprunable it's permanent you can put whatever it is that you want you're gonna pay a lot more for it but it's possible yeah. [02:45:48] Max Hillebrand: And I guess then here the knots camp argument would the strongman argument would be that these transactions should be filtered out as well right it's not just the OP_RETURN that has to be enforced but ideally we would have strong filters mempool filters for any transaction that is clearly malicious even though consensus value if. [02:46:10] Vlad Costea: You do that you're just pushing services like MARA's Slipstream where you basically go and you pay for your transaction to get mined and you're not fixing anything you're just moving these transactions in a way that they're not visible for the mempool and Bitcoin participants don't know that they're happening and you're gonna have private agreements between the person sending the transaction and the miner and there's not gonna be any mempool record of it. [02:46:36] Max Hillebrand: Yeah the I guess the argument would be that the like network peer-to-peer network-based disincentive and narrative would just make it that it would be much less used as if there were no narrative against it and no filter policy against it right. So since it is undesirable it is better to put some ways some things in the way of it which will deter at least some people from using it right even though that a very determined attacker would still be able to utilize it a lower level attacker would not and that's a that's a fine threat vector model right it's if you it's good to have defenses that work against some form of adversaries if you would only use defenses that work against the most powerful of adversaries you would not use any defenses right because yeah someone with a space laser can kill you okay cool but still someone with a knife at least you can defend against that guy and for example so you should just because someone might have a space laser somewhere doesn't mean that you should stop defending yourself against the guy with a knife and yeah. [02:47:58] Vlad Costea: I don't like these metaphors at all like people think well it's graffiti on the walls it's jewelry made out of gold it's this and that I just don't like them because they're not realistic what's really happening is that you have a transaction that pays the transaction fee and then there's someone who says well this is not a standard transaction I don't like the way in which this is constructed and I don't want this in my mempool but mempool doesn't mean node storage and there's always someone because Bitcoin is permissionless in the sense that there's an incentive for someone else to pick up your transaction even if you're censored and there's an incentive for a miner to take your transaction fee to put that transaction in the blockchain and then you're gonna store it anyway the most you can do is to just prune your node and just leave archival node storage to people who are willing to do it I can understand the case for that there's already so I think back in 2010 or 2011 there was someone who was putting WikiLeaks documents that were classified on the Bitcoin blockchain and that's already on your full archival node if you're storing it you can argue that in some jurisdictions that's illegal content but it's not in plain text that's what you need to understand it's not in something that you can just double click it's encoded and in order to be able to decipher what's in there you need a specific piece of software and not all of these are encoded the same way it's not like you can just get a software you put the blockchain on top and you uncover everything else that's been buried in there over the years and once again I do believe that Bitcoin should be permissionless if we can establish like a social layer a high council of priests or whatever who decide what is holy and what is a sin then we're just gonna end up in a slippery slope where it's gonna get worse and these people are gonna try to leverage their influence to do much more to this to the point where nation states are gonna step in and regulate even harder than this consortium can actually do regulate at the social level and it's just harmful for Bitcoin as a project like just because you have a few exceptions it's the same as and what I hate metaphors once again but it's like the gun debate where you say well let's just ban guns and let's get people to hand their guns all it takes is just one person one bad person to have one and all of these efforts are pointless you can't actually make policy according to the exception to the rule because you're always gonna have exceptions which bypass every kind of rule that you can imagine and you're you're just restricting everyone else from. [02:51:07] Max Hillebrand: Enjoying their liberty you can however adjust kind of the cost for it right there's certainly ways that are quite cheap to enforce to put a substantial cost on things right like ultimately would be a hard fork or like a you know consensus rule change but it can be on other layers as well it's the it's a useful tool that I think we should use to make sure that the Bitcoin system in the long run survives. [02:51:37] Vlad Costea: But once again if you make it more expensive then they will just go to the miners will make sure that it's cheaper than it actually costs with the filters that increase the price so you're opening up the free market for alternatives and if the base layer solution if the blockchain is not the cheapest option then you just make them go to the miners. [02:52:00] Max Hillebrand: Well I'm not sure if minor centralization and this issue is that much linked other than you know larger UTXO set size increases the requirement like the hardware requirement for running a node but that's not usually the bottleneck cost for mine anyway so I think things like you know block template selection for each miner is much more important or you know be that DATUM or Stratum V2 but also things like Braidpool for example right there's new much more decentralized pooling solutions or like what is it called Hashcash? [02:52:40] Max Hillebrand: No, not Hashcash — eCash yeah like this Bitcoin mining pool that pays out with eCash tokens etc but there's quite a lot of innovation on decreasing certain yeah trust assumptions with a pool operator and that will do much more for the decentralization of Bitcoin mining than I think any transactional policy would and so it's I think the issue here is again that Bitcoin is so complex and so multifaceted that it's difficult to consider all of the aspects in any one of these debates and there's just a lot of new ones here. [02:53:23] Vlad Costea: I just think that censorship in general is a slippery slope that ends up to much worse policy and the situation that we have is honestly not that bad and people are stubborn about upgrading their four gigabyte of ram raspberry pies I don't know it I'm not gonna comment on it I just want to say that this is a roadblock I see this as a distraction from what Bitcoin actually needs we still don't have a lot of stuff which can be enabled with the Great Script Restoration or OP_CAT or OP_CTV basically anything at this point I don't even care anymore just let the builders create stuff that's useful as opposed to trying to police what is nice and what is not. [02:54:12] Max Hillebrand: Yeah would be nice right but it's hard and also like we have to consider that there's actual like malicious participations or participators in this right. So it's difficult to come to consensus with such a large group especially when there are adversaries among us so I know I guess it's just patience and keep building and things will probably be fine. [02:54:40] Vlad Costea: Yeah. And I also suspect that a lot of the class of 2021 was educated by the school of Michael Saylor and Bitcoin University and all of these channels that basically are not technical they are dogmatic in the way that they approach Bitcoin but they're not technically right. [02:54:59] Vlad Costea: So when there's something that technically challenges their world view and the way in which they understand what Bitcoin is they end up being an alert and feeling confused and they see this as some sort of attack and instead of rationalizing it in technical terms and saying well this is the way in which a permissionless global computer network actually functions and you're going to have this whether you like it or not they try to do it they try to ensure that they basically play the politics game and they create a hierarchy of what is right and what is virtuous and what is horrible which is ridiculous because you can't really enforce it Bitcoin was built with this kind of censorship resistance in mind and the more you try to filter out stuff I guess the more you incentivize another type of market to emerge and I honestly think it's better to see from the mempool what's gonna be in the next Bitcoin blocks than to push users to try to find workarounds to go to a pool that maybe mines two or three blocks per day and that's good enough for them because they're not in a hurry. [02:56:21] Max Hillebrand: Yeah. And you know I think the ultimate goal here would be to have policy and consensus be aligned right be the same the thing is we introduced policy as such or because consensus rules were too permissive and would cause Bitcoin nodes to crash that was the original idea of it and now with further just improvement in the architecture of Bitcoin etc some of these are no longer as required so the question is do we do we like loosen the consensus rules or do we tighten them or do we tighten like do we give away some restrictions or add more you and that's that's more of an interesting debate I like which in which ways should we eventually adjust such that these such a consensus in policy is the same and then since changing consensus is quite hard there's a big amount of evidence that had to be brought forward proving that this is a good idea. [02:57:32] Vlad Costea: As someone who sometimes likes to call himself a libertarian I don't like telling other people what they should do with their money and I'm not gonna tell them well you should not draw on your dollar bill or whatever or you should not build origami out of your hundred euro bill it's the way you conduct business and it's consensual at the same time so if you accept something it means you understand the trade-offs but enforcing unfortunately with this with this mind. [02:58:05] Max Hillebrand: Like you just can't be a protocol designer right because that's by definition what protocol designers do and so if we're talking about how should the protocol be designed then we do have to mess with how people are about to use or not use the system this makes Bitcoin inherently a human affair or any protocol right and it's that's just it's difficult yeah. [02:58:31] Vlad Costea: But you can agree with the fact that all quote-unquote non-monetary use cases for Bitcoin are monetary because they pay a fee and it's just base units Satoshi is represented in a certain way to have a different meaning at the social level so ordinals or all these inscriptions BRC-20s whatever they are just Bitcoin units they're not something else it's just that they receive a different human meaning just like colored coins. [02:59:07] Max Hillebrand: Yep and again if we had a better design for Bitcoin such that not everyone would have to verify every transaction of everyone else then we wouldn't even have this argument and so I hope that in the long run we'll find a way to change base layer such that these types of arguments become obsolete and we can focus on some new discussions. [02:59:32] Vlad Costea: Yeah but that's gonna require a hard fork if we're ever gonna transition out of this phase where everyone's validating everything. [02:59:42] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I mean a lot of things can be done in soft fork so I guess it depends on the details but yeah hard forks also I think are not that much of a big deal like or and I guess I should say that any fork is a is a really big deal soft forks are just a little bit safer but only if majority of miners agrees and that's when soft forks are secure so you can absolutely have insecure soft forks or evil soft forks that change even fundamental things like the 21 million supply etc yeah. [03:00:20] Vlad Costea: That proposal by Peter Todd is actually for a soft fork and you can do demurrage or tail emission using that and I hope we don't go there I think honestly that's just an exercise in showing what's basically the looming threat that the miners can activate if we don't find use cases for Bitcoin so that the miners get paid yeah that's definitely interesting to consider. [03:00:51] Max Hillebrand: And I'm curious what type of similar attacks or such come out of Nostr in you know the longer term future because I'm sure that a lot of the design decisions are quite controversial and can be done in other ways that might be better so I'm very curious to see how the Nostr consensus layer will and governance layer I guess will evolve differently or similarly to Bitcoin. [03:01:18] Vlad Costea: Max where can people follow you these days I know you're not on Twitter anymore and you're on Nostr you're on GitHub and basically how can people keep up with what you're building with the White Noise protocol and the Marmot one and basically keep up with the latest versions of these applications. [03:01:41] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I'm personally only on Nostr so find me at max@towardsliberty.com and yeah you'll find White Noise in your Nostr or Twitter as well so just subscribe there to get notified of changes and try out all right White Noise it's a cool app and especially if you want to talk about implementing Marmot MLS into your Nostr client then reach out and let's have a chat. [03:02:16] Vlad Costea: Tom Dwyer said thanks for the mud wrestle it was beautiful heart emoji well thank you for listening tom this was definitely interesting and challenging at the same time and I also have to mention that while we were talking I mentioned like a couple of hours ago that Zcash hit 95 now it's 120 it feels like Bitcoin of years ago when it was just going up violently in one day so I guess I do have to do the Zcash pump dance once again 120 bucks is really something it was 50 yesterday it's insane so Zcash pump dance my girlfriend said she doesn't want to look at this because it's silly oh she doesn't want to miss this okay 120 bucks it's insane this could have been on Bitcoin by the way but we decided we don't want it more straight yeah more like a z anyway this was enough for the show thank you very much max thanks to the sponsors once again Bitcoin.com News you're. [03:03:32] Max Hillebrand: Kicking me out already. [03:03:33] Vlad Costea: Oh you want to stay for longer I definitely can but I was thinking that we sort of ran out of topics if you want to discuss something else I'm here yeah. [03:03:47] Max Hillebrand: We did talk about a lot of stuff already okay yeah so time to get kicked out. [03:03:55] Vlad Costea: Oh no I don't want to be the guy who kicks max out but I gotta tell you that during our interview so in the beginning you asked me how much time did you spend on the podcast and I did the math it was 791 hours excluding this interview which is another three hours oh sorry 791 minutes which adds up to 13.18 hours so if we add the 13 the three hours that you spent it's going to be 16 hours in total that you spent talking or participating in the Bitcoin Takeover podcast because you were also part of a couple of duos one with the CEO of ShopinBit and also with rockstar dev and there was another one which was a lot of fun from 2020 during the pandemic at Paralelni Polis which nowadays isn't called that anymore and it was sort of a panel with Alekos Filini Peter Todd and Jonas Nick. [03:05:05] Max Hillebrand: Yeah good old days. [03:05:07] Vlad Costea: You remember that one. [03:05:09] Max Hillebrand: Yep oh it's nice and I'm I really like these long-form podcasts that also stick around for the long term because you see nice progression of the project center people so that's it's really good that you're doing it so thanks for all the hours of hanging out with me it was fun. [03:05:30] Vlad Costea: Man it's always nice to have you and I'm always fascinated with how much you're learning I get jealous sometimes I'm like this guy he's into cryptography and he's so deep in the rabbit hole and he understands much better than me how Nostr works it makes me jealous that competitive side of me really wants to step up my game. [03:05:56] Max Hillebrand: Yes, do it. Nostr needs you know but the cool thing is like if you would ask me on the details I don't know anything about the cryptography right like you don't really need to know details of programming or mathematics to get the gist of this yeah I'm quite happy in this kind of medium place where I'm not really a developer or cryptographer or anything like that but I know roughly how the building blocks work and then you can do cool stuff with that's already super interesting it's a cool hobby to learn more there and it's a very deep rabbit hole so you're not going to run out of interesting questions to ask or tools to explore which is really fun. [03:06:46] Vlad Costea: Also want to say that we had more than 1000 views on Twitter during this live stream and I know that you're not there anymore so it happened without the support of your tweets from your account which right now maybe I guess doesn't exist anymore and on YouTube maybe we had like a hundred it's gonna grow over the days when people find the time to watch. [03:07:10] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I never watch live streams. [03:07:12] Vlad Costea: I will timestamp this also. [03:07:14] Max Hillebrand: I'm not that type of guy it needs to be much faster than just two people talking in regular speed that's too boring. [03:07:24] Vlad Costea: 3x. You can actually process information at 3x yeah. [03:07:30] Max Hillebrand: It's like I was surprised of how much of a like skill this actually is and how much you can expand it like you know I started at just 1.2 or something and that felt crazy. [03:07:43] Vlad Costea: 1.5 to 2 depending on how fast the people are talking. [03:07:47] Max Hillebrand: Yeah it's a shame that most applications limited to 1.5 or 2 because you can actually get a lot out of 3x as well make sure it takes some training and but it works and it's crazy like you actually save like days months of your life just by speeding up your content accumulation so definitely encourage people to try that out. [03:08:15] Vlad Costea: Do the voices sound funny like chipmunks or something when they're at 3x. [03:08:22] Max Hillebrand: They definitely sound different but it's not like you don't change the pitch or anything I think at least maybe they do but yeah it's you get used to it that's in part why I don't like any live shows because people sound so different than I'm used to them anything. [03:08:44] Vlad Costea: Else that you want to share max. [03:08:50] Max Hillebrand: Yeah let's see there's there is an interesting new protocol for making recurring payments on the blockchain which is really interesting with an interesting design trade-off that so the sender of the money he commits upfront to hey I want to make 10 payments once a month to this receiver of this Bitcoin amount and the receiver acknowledges that so there's like a two-person setup back and forth but then the sender can go completely offline and not come back anymore and the receiver instead comes online and can claim the money whenever he wants right to spend it into a wallet that only he controls but if the sender wants to cancel this recurring payments he comes back online and he broadcasts a pre-signed transaction that takes the outstanding coins back and so if after I don't know four months of payment he wants to stop paying and so he can claim the other six UTXO on chain back to his own wallet with some potentially time locked penalty it's a really interesting new idea for making recurring payments with this interesting design choice that after setup the sender can be offline which is contrary to things like Nostr Wallet Connect or even BOLT 12 recurring payments where the sender have to come back online but yeah the receiver has to claim the money and this is blockchain only so no lightning or stuff it would work on liquid or other blockchain like second layer systems but doing it on Lightning would probably be tricky eCash would work as well they're just a clever use of Tapscript and different hash locks and multisigs and timeouts so that's the Angor protocol, angor.io kind of its first application is for fundraising and so in founders can put their project up on Nostr and describe you know what it is about and people can then commit money to the time stages that the receiver has specified and you can do this for donations or maybe even salaries but primarily for equity as well and so if you have some like SAFE contracts or a startup then you can do delivery of Bitcoin in exchange for an equity contract in legacy fiat world so quite a useful tool and a nice combination of Bitcoin and Nostr. [03:11:45] Vlad Costea: Yeah I gotta give credit to Tom Dwyer for sticking around he said usually listens at 1.5 speed and I look him up and he's actually a phd in automotive engineering and he has been in Bitcoin for more than a decade really impressive I'm always proud to see the quality of the listeners and he seems to also have pictures from some event where thomas hunt was speaking so I guess he was watching the World Crypto Network which means I have one of the best audiences ever so thank you very much for being around tom now on the protocol that you described which was called angor something like this yeah exactly angor dot io dot io it sounds exactly like something that I said last week that Bitcoin doesn't have because recurring payments has been sort of a challenge to do on Bitcoin like to be able to pay someone on the same day of every month and maybe also have extra conditions like make sure that the on-chain transaction fees are low and also maybe have an oracle for price so that you pay an amount of Bitcoin which is equivalent to a price in fiat that's interesting but ultimately it leads to address reuse so I think it's more interesting if you have someone's xpub and you derive a different address for every transaction it's a bit more complex but I think it does require or it is some sort of smart contract right. [03:13:40] Max Hillebrand: Yeah a very basic form of smart contracts based on Bitcoin script and Bitcoin script for all intents and purposes is limited to signature checks and then they're for multi signatures as well and hash locks and time locks that's basically the three things that you can do in Bitcoin script and you know lightning is based on that multisig yeah. [03:14:08] Max Hillebrand: And Angor as well and yeah so no changes required to Bitcoin if it works right now on mainnet which is cool like a lot of that's the thing right a lot of the problems can be addressed on higher levels like not on the Bitcoin consensus layer not even a policy layer but just that a wallet layer and like the same with coin joints we don't need to change the Bitcoin protocol to fix privacy we just need to fix wallet implementations to support an additional protocol that fixes Bitcoin's privacy and I think with this sort of approach we can really solve a lot of issues yeah. [03:15:00] Vlad Costea: I agree but sometimes with Bitcoin script it's not necessarily the most efficient or elegant way it's just a hacky way of doing stuff yeah. [03:15:11] Max Hillebrand: Yeah that's like Great Script Restoration like I'm I've been massively bullish on this for a long time because like if we do just OP_CAT or something like this it's like a patch on a shitty system that doesn't really solve it the Great Script Restoration would be a an actual quite foundational solution to the problem while still being manageable you know something like Simplicity or Lisp or whatever might be another solution to it but that's such a huge change that it will be difficult all things considered something like Great Script Restoration is actually quite narrowly scoped and has a quite simple solution to slightly amend the existing scripts to securely enable more opcodes and then you know add a bunch of opcodes to actually get a holistic programming language back that's not crippled yeah that's really encouraging yeah. [03:16:14] Vlad Costea: And it's called restoration because these opcodes used to be part of the original Bitcoin but Satoshi turned them off at one point because he had a certain concern about the network which is no longer applicable this is something that we need to understand like something like OP_CAT Satoshi was afraid that people are just gonna do OP_CAT, OP_CAT, OP_CAT, OP_CAT until they DDoS nodes they shut them down they make them run out of capacity but now we have limits that were put in place with Tapscript so that they cannot exceed a certain amount of data size. [03:16:56] Max Hillebrand: And the Great Script Restoration actually adds an additional check to these called the varops budget as you can read it's one of the three new BIPs that are being proposed by Rusty Russell and basically each opcode gets a certain amount of compute points and if a transaction before you execute the script your nodes checks which opcodes are in the script and sums up the computation points let's say and if a transaction exceeds a certain number of points then it's simply invalid and you don't look at it and then you wouldn't be caught in the huge computational loop that if you would have executed the script and so it's a quite simple approach I think but it seems to work. [03:17:53] Vlad Costea: You know I did have Andrew Poelstra and he spoke about simplicity which has been in development for like a decade and they finally released it on liquid but he did say that it's too big of a change for Bitcoin and maybe that the Great Script Restoration is something that we can agree on and activate because there are so many developers like my job is to interview developers mostly and there are so many frustrated developers that I interviewed that said well we have this for example StarkWare right they have some very cool cryptographic protocols that actually can build interesting stuff for Bitcoin like instant node synchronization with zk proofs or and well you can argue that if. [03:18:43] Max Hillebrand: Quite basic requests they're like guys please just let us multiply numbers you know. [03:18:48] Vlad Costea: Yeah so OP_CAT is basically a way if you have in excel abc on one row and you have one two three on the second row OP_CAT is something that basically takes them and puts them together and says abc one two three it's not even multiplication that's another opcode so it's something that puts two strings of data together. [03:19:11] Max Hillebrand: The zk verifiers some of them work only with hashes and for that OP_CAT would be a good enough fix but others require multiplication and so that's why OP_CAT alone would not be sufficient it would help a little bit but we would still need more hacks and so that's in part why I like the Great Script Restoration because it bundles a lot of things together there's OP_CAT but there's also multiplication and there's also some transaction introspection as well and these are the three things that are really missing for much more expressive smart contracts on Bitcoin and that will be quite influential not just for kind of holding structures right like your savings like vaults etc but also for payment systems like Lightning or other second layer solutions with zero knowledge magic and such anyway. [03:20:12] Vlad Costea: I really like the branding of a Great Script Restoration like if you said well I want OP_CAT and then you had the taproot wizard saying yeah OP_CAT is great and then suddenly you had the average pleb saying well it enables these cameras to build stuff that I don't like but if you have something which is like a toolbox like general purpose and it's wrapped in this nice package and you call it the Great Script Restoration and you explain that it's actually useful to have something like let's say decentralized market makers or even decentralized exchanges or stuff that today cannot exist on Bitcoin without any sort of trusted service I mean this is the cypherpunk vision right this is what we're trying to do we're trying to make as much to build as many tools that require no trusted third parties or at least minimize trust with the stuff that we're building and of course this goes against the interest of exchanges use cases of base money yeah of course some exchanges are not going to be happy because they offer services that compete with something like this that's why for example in Lightning Network there was never much emphasis on atomic swaps even though that's one of the most powerful features that you can have basically lightning can be a bridge across chains and you can have lightning on liquid you can have lightning on Bitcoin and then you can make instant swaps without any of the intermediaries or federation members that's one use case that still is very challenging today and I do like very much this branding of the Great Script Restoration I want to get back on topic it's not one specific opcode it's not something that needs a champion to push and follow this political process it's like a toolbox that can be used for anyone to build something that is useful that increases the utility of Bitcoin and welcomes builders because I think this is very important I went this year to two ethereum conferences one in amsterdam and the other one where was it oh in Prague, and I did see that the builder spirit the hacker spirit is much more powerful in that community they have hackathons they have prizes they have sponsors who give a lot of money for these developers who are building stuff there was nobody who was telling them well I don't like this and I'm not gonna run this on my node or something like this everyone seemed to be on the same page saying we do need to have more applications you're gonna build them on layer twos which is fine because they don't need to be as robust or decentralized as the base layer and I very much enjoyed that builder spirit and the fact that there is openness to competition and Bitcoin sort of we agreed that lightning is the one and true solution and everything else should not exist or is inferior or a waste of time and I think it's detrimental to a lot of the stuff that has been built over the years and having this dismissive attitude towards anyone trying to make Bitcoin more useful or trying to circumvent one of the trade-offs that you have on the Bitcoin base layer is one of the worst parts of this toxicity which was initially made to keep scammers away like the very obvious ones but it grew to the point where you're excluding good actors who are trying to build something which is a net positive for everyone and I also think that the reason why Bitcoin trades at 117 000 right now isn't just speculation isn't just the store of value narrative it's the problem promise that this can become the future of money one day and the currency of the internet something that anyone can send to anyone else around the world without a trusted third party this is why I got into Bitcoin and this is what I think makes it valuable as opposed to just another stock just another commodity or brand name or something that's cool to have in your portfolio yeah. [03:24:58] Max Hillebrand: I agree it's all about the money that's a pretty important problem to solve but I think to a large extent we have solved it and so this means that we can move on to other things as well and one of them that we haven't talked about yet actually it's just other forms of private contracts and so there are numerous contracts that you can make between two people specifically about kind of a debt relationship and so one of these old type of contracts are known as bills of exchange they're they're basically credit line for business who is trading with each other and so like let's say I don't know, Vlad is producing cows and I'm a butcher and I want to get the cows but I don't have the cash yet I don't have Bitcoin yet but I know that I will get Bitcoin from my customers once I you know butcher the cow and sell it so instead of paying Vlad in sats directly I create a contract that says I will pay him the sats in three months and after or after I do the work and so since Vlad and I know each other for what was it 14 hours there's already a high amount of trust between us it's always like yeah sure I'll take your credit line you're probably good for it in the future and so I get the cow he gets a paper contract and I butcher it and so on and sell it to my customers so I start to make some sense but in the meantime he actually I don't know needs another tractor for the farm and so there's a tractor producer who sell who wants who sells the tractor and he's like hey I can also pay you in this contract because this contract will be you know paid for sats in two months time or whatever and so the tractor producer checks if he thinks that I'm you know trustworthy or credit worthy right if I will pay back or if Vlad is going to pay back if I don't and if he accepts this risk right he can accept this credit or this contract in exchange for the tractor or whatever other product Vlad is buying and so this is a transferable contract for future payment to the person who is who is at the tip of this contract change basically so very old type of business contract economically quite sound it's like peer-to-peer credit line without a bank basically and works locally this is great to bootstrap an economy actually for more deeper production stages than just I don't know selling t-shirts or something but like you know this is all actual machinery etc it's fine and stuff and this is also possible to express via cryptography so you don't need to have a paper contract for this anymore in international courts they all accept electronic signatures now so we can use specifically Nostr and to create this contract with the parameters and sign it off with our cryptographic keys and therefore have a proof of acceptance of this contract right with a key that might have web of trust on it and other reputation and so and also it allows us to transfer the contract to others and so there's a full software etc written for this now already it uses Bitcoin as the unit of account or this bill of exchange contract in a wallet that transfers ownership of this to others and yeah really interesting system. [03:29:19] Vlad Costea: Well you basically described credit and leverage. [03:29:27] Max Hillebrand: There's a little bit of nuance here because what we usually think of as credit is you go to the bank right and you walk out of the bank after signing a contract you walk out with a bag of cash right. So this is this is different right. You in this example I don't walk out with a bag of cash I walk out with a cow and so the there is a good being transferred it's not just money being created and given to someone it's just a basically a legal structure for a delayed payment for a good or service ultimately and so this is just like hey bro I'll pay you in three months but it's a bit more structured and legally enforceable if you have a certain structure like you know born to it. [03:30:18] Vlad Costea: Right but you do need to put up some collateral or something because in the event that you don't pay someone has to. [03:30:27] Max Hillebrand: Yeah in this system there is no collateral right. So this also makes it quite unique it's not that you have Bitcoin as collateral as we earlier talked about here this is an un-collateralized loan ultimately or like not ultimately like roughly saying so this means that if I you know I don't know I don't end up selling the cut meat and it goes bad and I haven't made any money and I know I don't have cash to pay you then you can take me to court and a judge will look at the contract and say yes you signed this contract and you now have to give him I don't know sell your car and give him the cash right. [03:31:18] Max Hillebrand: So this is where the legacy system comes in because it is a proper contract right and these are enforceable in courts etc and the interesting thing is if the contract was passed on like let's say Vlad gave the contract to the tractor producer and now I don't pay the tractor producer then the tractor producer can either take me to court and try to get the money back but he also can go and take Vlad to court because Vlad is part of the liability chain and because he did receive that contract early on and when he passed it over it was under the like legal assumption that in the case of the default of the original payer he will be liable for that payment and so you would have to give him the take me to court and get the stuff back but so this basically means if you are offered a bill of exchange that has been signed and accepted by 20 different people the likelihood that you will get your money back is quite high especially if you know these people and their actual businesses with cash flows etc this is a very easily enforceable contract so there's some protections here but it's not a cash reserve in Bitcoin yeah. [03:32:49] Vlad Costea: I understand that it sounds like early 20th century or even 19th century finance in the way in which farmers were dealing with sometimes bankers sometimes just people providing them a service because farmers they reap their crops that basically they have a specific time of the month which is usually september when they collect everything and they sell and it's the end of the agriculture year and then they start over the next year so they do need to have some sort of line of credit or ability to feed themselves and be able to afford all the seeds and everything else that they need to make agriculture for another year and I think it still works like this to people who basically lend their crops of land to farmers and they don't take payments until the farmers make money and they have sort of a verbal or legal agreement in which they get paid a certain amount per year but that amount only gets paid after the end of the agriculture cycle. [03:34:10] Max Hillebrand: Exactly it's a very common contract in like real industry business like raw materials or farming or machinery like something with deeper production stages this is not really something that end users are facing with no this is more for larger companies and they used to handle a massive amount of value you know like millions of dollars worth of contract size it's quite common here for international trade etc yeah this is quite a standardized international contract with like international conventions etc that's that's standardized yeah. [03:34:57] Vlad Costea: It's interesting because it predates the fiat times when you go to a bank they create the money out of nothing and then you're supposed to pay it back. [03:35:10] Max Hillebrand: Exactly this is quite different and so economic like austrian economically speaking this is this much more sound is much more like rational backing because if you go to a bank and you withdraw cash they literally print it either digitally like digitally and just keep the cash and end up with 10 times as much money or capital under control so this is like money creation out of thin air but with bills of exchange we can only create this contract if there is a cow if Vlad hasn't produced a cow yet and he isn't actually giving it to me then this whole system doesn't make sense because I can only make money if I have the cow, right the payback is somewhat conditional that I will make money in the further production of this resource and so there's a natural limitation to how much credit money will be expanded so there it will add some flexibility in the available of money supply but not base money but credit money so to say and but that is still limited to the actual productivity of the people who are trading actual resources for these credit instruments. [03:36:36] Vlad Costea: Have you gotten into farming max like you sound as if you're really into cows and agriculture. [03:36:47] Max Hillebrand: I mean like occasionally but not substantially though I travel too much for actually having a proper farm but being in nature is always good. [03:37:03] Vlad Costea: I was thinking that this is the reason why you moved to south america to get into farming live like in the good old days have you learned any spanish. [03:37:14] Max Hillebrand: Yeah sure thankfully spanish is quite easy to pick up yeah asian languages are way more alien like the switch from german or english to spanish it's all quite similar in its structure. [03:37:41] Vlad Costea: Yeah logical structure and some words that come from latin and exist in english also I'm not sure about german how many latin words you have. [03:37:54] Max Hillebrand: Quite a lot. [03:37:55] Vlad Costea: I'd say but I'm yeah I'm not language experts so what else do you want to talk about max do. [03:38:08] Max Hillebrand: They have other cool tech startup meetup it's really good to see different places flourishing to different extents but there's some really huge meetup communities around the globe which is really impressive and that's usually just a couple guys getting together and organizing a bit I think that comes with a lot of reports so consider doing that dear listeners so. [03:38:44] Vlad Costea: Is this some sort of recommendation that I should start a meetup or are you saying that you are attending meetups and you're thinking about starting your own well if. [03:38:56] Max Hillebrand: Kind of if I should like preach what I practiced it's that you should trick other people into starting a meetup because it's hell of a lot of work if other people do it that's that's better but yeah no it's good to make sure that there is some actual physical connection with people to yeah meet people get new ideas and make something happen. [03:39:32] Vlad Costea: I think about this a lot sometimes but then again there are some trade-offs like I very much enjoy walking down the street being a complete stranger and stuff like this I want people to point to me and say that's the Bitcoin guy yeah. [03:39:50] Max Hillebrand: That's true wear a mask no but I mean it's like you can you can still be quite private even though you go to could go to these meetups right. You don't have to be on stage or anything and actually coming in a different outfit or like hairstyle or wearing a hat and sunglasses actually makes quite a substantial difference and since we're all kind of weirdos in Bitcoin probably nobody will really care if you become a bit obscured. [03:40:25] Vlad Costea: Also I would have to adjust my whole way of thinking because for me Bitcoin is an english activity right and if I have to translate into my mother tongue it's difficult to process or even come up with the right words to describe like I do have to do a lot of thinking just to translate in a way that actually makes sense because it's easy to speak in english but it doesn't mean that the other people will understand and you have to have the right way to approach it. [03:41:03] Max Hillebrand: Yeah but that just means that you haven't gone to enough romanian Bitcoin meetups because then you will learn quickly they. [03:41:10] Vlad Costea: Just use the english terms and I think that it basically keeps away a lot of people it's intimidating. [03:41:19] Max Hillebrand: Yeah that definitely makes sense to do if possible both for like meetups and software as well I think translations is quite important. [03:41:31] Vlad Costea: I did translate a book and it was an interesting experience to work with one of the largest publishers in my country and to see how they expect stuff like I've learned a lot just from looking at their edits and stuff like this I understand much better how they operate but it was a lot of work with no actual benefit like I have no social benefit from it nobody knows who I am in my country and also I never got paid for it because they wanted to pay me like a very small amount not even enough to cover monthly rent and I was like this is really insulting if this is what you pay your writers please take this amount and pay it to the next guy so he can actually eat I offered to volunteer for it yeah the crazy things Bitcoiners too yeah but I would not do it again if I do it again I want actual percentage of sales even if it's not a lot I just feel like I have some skin in the game because it felt like three months of work and then I don't care too much about the project they published it I was excited we had a stupid launch on a zoom call because it was during the pandemic it was the most disappointing moment right because you imagine okay I'm an author right now I'm published by this publishing house they have all of these libraries around the country bookstores and then instead of inviting you to a bookstore you're supposed to sit in your room the same room where I worked on the translation and say hi I'm the guy who did the translation and the answer to questions it was really weird yeah like there was no sense of gratification from it. [03:43:39] Max Hillebrand: Yeah that's often the case of you work hard on it and then the thing happens and it's just a thing I think you continue doing your stuff. [03:43:55] Vlad Costea: What podcasts do you listen to max you said you listen on 3x that means you have some extra time to listen to some more right. [03:44:06] Max Hillebrand: Exactly yeah the Bitcoin Takeover podcast have you heard of that one. [03:44:14] Vlad Costea: I hear that the guy's sort of an asshole who has opinions on everything and he's not pure enough you know he's sort of a shit but otherwise nice guy. [03:44:30] Max Hillebrand: Optech podcast is really good too like the weekly Optech newsletter already is great actually there's a podcast that does text to speech for these the newsletter and just as a like robot reading of the text itself and then Optech crew comes together once a week for human conversation with the people involved in those subjects so that's always very interesting to learn more what else Daniel Prince, Once Bitten interesting channel I really like what Danny Knowles did with What Bitcoin Did so there are it's good that there's some good conversations there again yeah I rarely listen to everything of any single podcast just the good bits and pieces plus a bunch of others I mean it's a long list. [03:45:34] Vlad Costea: Do you only listen to podcasts about Bitcoin or do you explore other topics too. [03:45:42] Max Hillebrand: Well definitely other topics as well audiobooks as well are a big part and recently also reading a bit more fiction I haven't done that in a while there's some good cypherpunk fiction and historical accounts etc that are interesting to read one cool book is the art of not being governed I forgot the name of the author but he's basically this is a historical account of the a large area in Southeast Asia where there's a very large population that is has successfully evaded state control for thousands of years by some strategic choices like the location where they are up in the valley or not planting obviously taxable crops like rice patties but rather root vegetables like potatoes and carrots etc and hunting and which is harder to tax plus having more of an oral tradition rather than a written one to prevent anyone from kind of finding the paper trail and learning about the wealth of someone they're really interesting of how ancient people have used tools and strategies and technologies to live a freer life and that's I think always a fascinating topic to learn more about. [03:47:26] Vlad Costea: Yeah I do remember you had a very cool podcast Join the Wasabi Cause and of course this was after World Crypto Network with which you were affiliated for a while and I was always jealous because you were getting such good guests and developers I couldn't talk to at the time I was like oh man this guy's so good. [03:47:53] Max Hillebrand: Yeah that's the best part about the podcast right. You get to talk to cool people because if like if as a regular pleb you know not even a podcaster right someone like that when you talk to like an interesting person who's somewhat famous online and you're like hey I want to talk to you for like two hours just by myself like in a cafe or whatever right. You wanna you wanna have a talk like no go away but if you say hey I'm from a podcast and I'd like to invite you to the show present your ideas to my audience and then all of a sudden people are like yeah sure let's let's do it so you have a really easy excuse to talk to really interesting people even if your audience is like 10 people listening right but you at least have a great conversation with someone. [03:48:51] Vlad Costea: I do like to think that the this is very good practice for presenting your ideas later on maybe to an investor maybe to some tv station or somewhere where maybe that your time is more limited and after you spend a lot of time explaining something and you do it a lot of times on different shows or with different people you become much better and more efficient at doing it so I think there's a selfishness that goes both ways with podcasts you as the host have the benefit that you get ideas from people and sometimes they spend thousands of hours thinking and researching the stuff that you get in a couple of hours which is amazing really like it's incredible how much good information you can get and from the perspective of the guests there's also this benefit that they get to practice their pitch and they get to understand it's a survey so they can see if their discourse works with an audience and if there's any clear result if they say they're the CEO of something or the marketing person of something and they're selling a product and then after they make some appearances they can measure to see if there's any impact on this or what kind of messaging works so I think it's a good exchange of course if it's one-on-one you have to be a very important person to actually score that kind of interaction with someone but once again in this space something that it this took me a long time to realize I think it's not just this space in particular but there are a lot of guys who are relatively wealthy and they don't have like big accounts or whatever but my point is that it doesn't matter how many listeners or views or whatever you have it's all about who they are like if you are religious or something you can go back to jesus christ and say you know he only had 12 followers and they are some of the best followers he could have and they preached his word and it became into this huge religious religion but even in the case of podcasts which are not as powerful as organized religion it's important to have good followers and the kind of person that you are will attract or turn away a lot of people like there are people who turn they tune into your show one time and they see what kind of person you are and what kind of stuff you talk about and maybe that they're not gonna find that interesting and they will say well screw this guy he's an asshole he talks about shitcoins or whatever but by choosing to talk about a topic or not talking about another one and the words that you choose to describe something are going to attract a certain kind of people and you're the one really who builds an audience and I also so that there's this culture in Bitcoin which is live by the sword die by the sword they do like to slay their heroes and say well this guy is great but now I disagree with him and therefore let's destroy his reputation I try to stay away from that I try to not vilify anyone I try to not judge anyone too harshly I believe in free will and free markets and everyone can do whatever they want and there are consequences all the time but I'm not the one who should apply them I'm not a judge or something but I do believe that if you act in a certain way you're going to attract people just like yourself and then you're gonna end up having a very cool audience and very smart people listening to you I'm blown away every time I get feedback from people and then I look them up and I'm like oh my god this guy is a researcher or is a developer who's working on something very cool sometimes I get messages from people like robin linus and he says hey man I really enjoyed your interview with let's see Liam Eagen or something I think this is the best part and it's not about once again the amount of episodes that I published which got more than let's say 20 000 downloads within the first year I can count them I think on one hand but it's not about these numbers it's all about within these maybe 1000 people who download an episode every week maybe 10 or 20 of them are very interesting and it's these people who really matter and are going to make a difference and make an impact based on the information that you delivered and the information shouldn't just be educational you know there's this aura and there's this mantra in Bitcoin that you should listen to 40 hours of podcasts every week it shouldn't be just for knowing stuff the stuff that you learn should push you into building something or supporting something investing into something making good change making a difference in the world around you I think that's very beautiful and I hope that people who listen to you talking about your White Noise protocol and Marmot they're gonna take an interest they're gonna donate they're gonna test the software they're gonna provide feedback maybe build something alongside the team that's already working on it I think this is how you measure success it's not just looking at your stats and be like oh I got a million views but who are these people who have watched like are they really making an impact are they making a difference long run. [03:54:56] Max Hillebrand: That's that is always the interesting part of who's listening and I was always surprised by the quality of those as well that's ultimately why we do it. [03:55:15] Vlad Costea: Anything else you want to mention max we are inching the four-hour mark so it's your choice if we continue or we wrap it up. [03:55:26] Max Hillebrand: Yeah I will have to get some food and that would be quite noisy so it's probably best to cut it off here and come back again and then we'll have another session and crack the 21-hour mark. [03:55:40] Vlad Costea: You want to go for 21 hours. [03:55:43] Max Hillebrand: Well in cumulative which would only would be like a casual. [03:55:47] Vlad Costea: Oh my god my girlfriend heard that and she's like no you can't go for 21 hours she wants to have dinner. [03:55:57] Max Hillebrand: Oh yeah you just have to incorporate dinner quietly thank. [03:56:04] Vlad Costea: You very much max for everything that you do for all of your input for all the research and all the work that you do I think you have a special gift of getting involved in projects like you have a good vision right when you got involved in Wasabi it was not obvious that it's gonna succeed and then you just kept going at one point you even became ceo of zkSNACKs even though you started out as just a small contributor and I do hope that White Noise is gonna become as popular as some of today's messaging apps like maybe not as popular signal because you need jack dorsey to endorse it or something which I hope will happen but yeah I hope it's gonna be in installed on a lot of phones and people are gonna understand the importance of having private communication that is also hard to stop hard to censor. [03:57:01] Max Hillebrand: Yeah okay thank you so much for having me I'll see you next time you yeah definitely that's that's the goal but ultimately it's even more about having more than just one client implement this tech and if we have a broadly distributed network of different developers and clients and interfaces and use cases that are all interoperable with each other that would be a really cool vision and use case because I think that's just a superpower of the existing Nostr stack and to get a similar experience for the private part of it that is important so yeah I hope we can get there but that's what the protocol is set for us for so yeah Marmot protocol and the MDK, Marmot Development Kit — mdk.org yeah or mdk.build that will lead you to the GitHub repos and check out whitenoise.chat and if you like it tell your friends use it tell us how to make it better and build your own stuff don't just listen to podcasts also get some other stuff done we need more freedom tech builders for sure. [03:58:24] Vlad Costea: Yeah. And now with vibe coding all it takes is one good idea of course if you're trying to build something that was never built before it's gonna be more challenging and you're gonna need a software engineer and engineering should not be understated like you should have the best way to accomplish something not just the way but sometimes it's enough just to put something out there and have a proof of concept and people will think it's cool and then if it's open source they will contribute if it's not open source you'll have to pay them. [03:58:58] Vlad Costea: To contribute but my point is that all it takes is one good idea and a good way to describe it because that's also important if you just say well I want private communication well what kind of private communication well text communication fine you want it to be an application you want it to be like a website or whatever there are lots of steps that you have to go and you also have to define what is going to stay private like is it the messages is it the metadata is it the IP addresses which once again is part of the metadata and what are you going to optimize for do you want to optimize for fast communication or do you want to optimize for maximum privacy for example like what's it called the Nym VPN which can use a normal vpn connection that uses WireGuard or can go for the mixnet which is slower but more private and there are lots of. [04:00:10] Max Hillebrand: Mixnets were actually designed for delivering emails right. So it's quite similar for the chat messaging use case and it should work very good actually good thing is also that Nym is nicely developed in Rust and with a good library that we could integrate it natively because White Noise will be quite similar in the sense of Tor management or network-level identity management it's quite important if you if you want to make sure that you nobody knows that you're in these two groups at the same time then using different network level identities to request the WebSocket with the group id in the search query with a new Tor identity or Nym mixnet path and that requires some fine-grained control of the anonymity network provider by the application itself so yeah we did it with Tor and Wasabi and we'll probably do it also with Tor in White Noise but Nym is also an additional or alternative way of doing it and of course it would work outside of the application itself if you run Nym as a VPN that will work already today out of the box okay. [04:01:33] Vlad Costea: Max thank you very much for your time and your insights good luck with White Noise and Marmot and to everyone who has been listening to this follow him on Nostr and check out the GitHub repo for both White Noise and Marmot and I guess I'll see you in the next session max I'm not sure if you were aiming for the Amir Taaki record which is seven hours 20 minutes but I do appreciate that you stuck around for long. [04:02:01] Max Hillebrand: Yeah we'll definitely crack that at some point not today but it will come. [04:02:06] Vlad Costea: Yeah just tell me beforehand so I can eat and be super ready. [04:02:13] Max Hillebrand: Exactly. You need to prep for that one or just multitask it now that's another option thank you very much it was a fun one see you on the next one bye. ================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with speaker diarization (Guest A -> Max Hillebrand). Reconciled against YouTube auto-captions (zcash-documentary S16E47.plain/.timed/.en.vtt, ~+22 s offset for intro music; bitcoin-forks-research S16E47 clean / .en.vtt), feed show-notes chapters, bitcoin-forks-research/findings/S16E47.md, and zcash-documentary/findings/S16E47.md. No Whisper re-clips — asr_worker held RAM on S16E46 Val Venis (~5.1 GB available, below the 6 GB threshold; avoided starving the live ASR job). Opening Whisper loop ("Season 16, Episode 47/48" repeated) restored from YT captions. Speaker turns repaired from context + YT >> flips; orphan continuation paragraphs inherit speaker; mid-sentence splits fixed. Names/jargon checked against title, feed chapters, web, and second opinions: Max Hillebrand / towardsliberty.com, White Noise / Marmot / MDK / MIPs / OpenMLS / NIP-44 / gift wraps, Nostr / NIPs / npub / nsec / fiatjaf / Ben Arc / Melvin Carvalho / Rockstar Dev / branle / Martti Malmi / Iris, LNBits / nos2x / Amber / Nostore / Cryptosteel / Seed Hammer, npub.world / nostr.band / Zap Store, Schnorr signatures, Tornado Cash / Samourai / Wasabi / WabiSabi / zkSNACKs / Kruw / Lucas Ontivero / nopara73, Primal / Damus / Amethyst / Coracle / Citrine / Pokey / Yakihonne / Wavlake / Tunestr / Blossom / Cashu / NUTs / GrapheneOS / Orbot / Obtainium / shakespeare.diy, MLS / Diffie-Hellman / O(log n) / double ratchet / IETF / RFC 9420 / NoDNS, Citrea / SideShift / ShapeShift / Layer 2 Labs / Drivechains / BIP 300 / Alpen Labs / BitVM / Robin Linus / BitGo / WBTC, Zcash / Zerocash / Peter Todd / Paul Sztorc / Liquid / Monero / CryptoNote / Railgun / DarkFi / shielded CSV / RGB / Litecoin MWEB / Mimblewimble, Core v30 / Knots / SegWit / Taproot / OP_RETURN / STAMPS / MARA Slipstream / DATUM / Stratum V2 / Braidpool / CSAM debate, Great Script Restoration / OP_CAT / CTV / Rusty Russell / varops / Andrew Poelstra / Simplicity / StarkWare, Angor / Tapscript / BOLT 12 / Nostr Wallet Connect / xpub / SAFE contracts, bills of exchange, Parres HQ / Jeff G, OpenSats / HRF, Nym mixnet / Tor / WireGuard, Bitcoin Optech / Once Bitten / Daniel Prince / Danny Knowles / What Bitcoin Did / The Art of Not Being Governed, ShopInBit / Paralelni Polis / Alekos Filini / Jonas Nick / Liam Eagen / Amir Taaki, Bitcoin.com News / NoOnes / Ray Youssef / Paxful / Firefish / Bitrefill / Breez / Phoenix / Edward Snowden / Tom Dwyer. Light clean verbatim: ums, false starts and stutters removed; factual slips kept as spoken. Intro music omitted. Remaining doubtful words marked [unclear: ...].