Title: S16 E6: Super Testnet on Monero vs Lightning Network Privacy Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Super Testnet (pseudonymous Bitcoin developer and educator; supertestnet.org, super_testnet on Twitter; argues the Lightning Network is more private than Monero) Published: 2025-02-04 (recorded live) Duration: 2:29:39 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2025-02-04_s16_e6_super_testnet_on_monero_vs_lightning_network_privacy_-_04.02.2025_20.16.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2025-02-04_s16_e6_super_testnet_on_monero_vs_lightning_network_privacy_-_04.02.2025_20.16.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Base: local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with automatic speaker diarization, reconciled word-by-word against the YouTube auto-captions of the same livestream (local copy S16E6.en.vtt, read-only; offset about +1 s throughout), with about 1,250 differences in the first pass and 1,325 in a re-check after editing; the non-filler ones were reviewed. Doubtful or missing stretches were re-transcribed locally from the published mp3 with faster-whisper (small.en, plus medium.en on 3 clips; int16, 2 threads), 140 short clips totalling about 57 minutes. Restored from the audio: Super Testnet's opening answer on single-channel vs. multi-route privacy (00:13:56), the end of the drivechain answer (00:38:53), the BitVM/SHA-256 Merkle-tree sidechain passage (01:22:23, where the base had a looped duplicate sentence), the whole Taproot/BitVM "that's where the money is" answer (01:24:00, missing from the base), the pool-model explanation of Tornado Cash (01:25:34-01:26:09), the prediction-market lead-in (02:07:38), the LaBitConf answer (02:16:36), and the closing social links (02:27:56). Removed hallucinated text not in the audio: a second "So I'm really surprised..." sentence (01:22), "That's what I found" (02:03:31), "are the ones that are really cool" (02:08:31) and a trailing "Transcribed by otter.ai". Speakers: about 60 turn boundaries repaired (e.g. 00:01:31, 00:02:12, 00:13:05, 00:28:41, 00:37:12, 00:43:19, 00:48:26-00:48:32, 00:57:09-00:57:23, 01:02:02, 01:19:57, 01:20:30, 01:31:38-01:31:52, 01:32:51-01:35:05, 01:37:26, 01:40:02-01:41:05, 01:41:34-01:41:49, 01:52:10, 02:08:12, 02:09:52-02:11:09, 02:14:05-02:14:37, 02:19:01-02:19:52, 02:21:25, 02:22:14-02:22:45, 02:23:39, 02:24:31, 02:25:29, 02:26:04-02:26:36, 02:27:33-02:27:56, 02:28:59). Sponsor reads (SideShift.ai, NoOnes, Hodling.ch) are read live by Vlad and labelled Vlad Costea, as in other finals of this season. Chat comments that Vlad reads aloud are in quotation marks. Names and jargon were checked against the title, the show notes and the web: Citrea (was Citreya/Cetreya/Satreya) and its co-founder Orkun, LayerTwo Labs (was Clear2Labs), NoOnes (Ray Youssef, CivKit), Hodling.ch, SideShift.ai (was Sightshift), Paul Sztorc, drivechains / BIP 300, Core Untouched Soft Fork, BitVM, SHA-256, Taproot, rollups, Robin Linus, Liam Eagen, Jonas (Blockstream), Alpen Labs, StarkWare, Luke Parker and full-chain membership proofs ("Oops! All Decoys", Cap'n Crunch), ring signatures, stealth / one-time addresses, view keys, xpub, Dandelion++, Chainalysis (leaked Monero-tracing video, Chainalysis KYT, OFAC), CipherTrace, MorphToken, FixedFloat, ChangeNOW, Cake Wallet, Monerujo (was MoneroJ), Sybil attacks, Tony Giorgio, Ride The Lightning, LND, Core Lightning / c-lightning (Rusty), Eclair / ACINQ (was Async), Electrum (ThomasV), LDK, Mutiny Wallet, Phoenix / phoenixd, Umbrel, Start9, Clark Moody's dashboard, BOLT 11 / BOLT 12, Justin from ShockNet, ecash mints, Mint Market Cap / bitcoinmints.com, state chains / Mercury Layer, Title Transfer App, Faucet Generator, Testnet Launcher, Nostr / NIP-99 classified listings, Shopstr (was Shopster/Shoxter), Amethyst, zaps, Nostr Wallet Connect, XMR Bazaar, OpenBazaar, Boltz Exchange, Liquid, Rootstock, RoboSats, Bisq, Vexl, Taproot Assets / Taro, Tornado Cash, CoinJoin, Wasabi, Samourai, Predyx, Polymarket, MoneroTopia, bitcoin++ Floripa (was "for Repo"/"Florida") and btc++ Austin, btcplusplus.dev, SatsConf, LaBitConf, Bitcoin 2025 (Las Vegas), Adopting Bitcoin, Guadalajara, Chevrolet Monte Carlo, Maseratis, Flipper Zero, piccalilli. Speakers' own slips (e.g. "mainnet" for Tor, "205 countries") were kept as said. 0:00-0:48 is intro music. Spots that could not be confirmed are marked [unclear: best guess] (24 marks). ================================================================================ [00:00:48] Vlad Costea: Hello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 6. We are live with Super Testnet. And this episode is sponsored by LayerTwo Labs, Citrea, NoOnes, Hodling.ch and SideShift.ai. No joke, I'm going to ask you about Citrea. Okay, great. And the reason why we decided to do this is that you recently put a listing on a dark web market. You're selling chocolates or cookies or something in exchange for Bitcoin on the Lightning Network. Is that correct? [00:01:21] Super Testnet: I'm not selling them. I found someone who was selling them on a darknet market and I was like, oh, wow, there's a darknet market that accepts Lightning. And so I posted it. [00:01:31] Vlad Costea: So, yeah, your claim is that Lightning is more private than Monero. And that's sort of the reason why we decided to do this. [00:01:39] Super Testnet: Yes. And thank you for having me on. It's an honor to be on your podcast and I admire what you do. [00:01:44] Vlad Costea: The honor is on my side, sir. So let's start with this. What is private about the Lightning Network? You have sender privacy, you have receiver privacy, you have network level privacy and you have amounts privacy. Which one of these does Lightning have? [00:02:02] Super Testnet: It has aspects of all four. I think the one it's the worst at is amount privacy and then it's really good at the other ones. [00:02:12] Vlad Costea: Can we do a further analysis? Because as far as I know, Lightning has pretty good sender privacy, which is exactly what Bitcoin on-chain doesn't have. When you send Bitcoin on-chain, you can see how many coins the sender has in their UTXO. Unless you send from a CoinJoin, but that's a bit more complicated to pull out, or pull off. But in the case of Lightning, you get sender privacy, which is pretty good. When, you know, humble brag, when I sold Bitcoin to buy my Lexus, I actually used the Lightning Network on Kraken because I was thinking that I don't want their blockchain analysis, whatever, to flag my coins if I used CoinJoins in the past. [00:02:52] And the fact that I sent from the Lightning Network gave me, you know, much better both privacy and also it didn't let me deal with blockchain analysis. So that's pretty sweet about Lightning. [00:03:06] Super Testnet: One of the ways that it does that is by encrypting a lot of the information. So when your node picks a route to say, I want to pay Kraken, you have to find a path along the Lightning Network that you're going to pay Bob and Bob is going to pay Carol and Carol's going to pay Dave and Dave's going to pay Kraken. And that route, we use onion encryption, similar to Tor, to make it so that Bob only knows that someone on this side is paying someone on this side, but he doesn't know who. [00:03:38] And then Carol only knows that someone on this side is paying someone on this side and so forth. So you get all the way to Kraken, and they just know, Dave, Dave forwarded this payment to us, but we don't know who the actual sender was. So it's really good at hiding the sender by, you know, by these layers of encryption, similar to how the onion router does it. [00:03:58] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's a very good way to compare it with onion routing. I think that's also the source of inspiration for the routing design in Lightning. On the other hand, when you do send someone an invoice, they're going to be able to see what type of wallet you're using and a lot of stuff, including the amount that you're requesting. So it's not very private for the person sending out an invoice. Whereas in the case of Bitcoin on-chain, if you send a new address that you generate from your wallet, there's gonna be no way for the sender to know that it's really your address or where it comes from. [00:04:35] Super Testnet: I think that Lightning invoices have better privacy than Monero stealth addresses. Would you like me to tell you why? [00:04:42] Vlad Costea: Oh, that's a big claim. Go on. [00:04:44] Super Testnet: Yeah. So in, in both Monero stealth address and in a Lightning invoice, there's a pubkey. But this pubkey in Lightning is only used for communication. It's used for signing messages, but not for receiving money. And in Monero, the public key is only used to derive the actual public key that you're going to send the money to. But the consequence of this is that on Monero, the sender can see exactly what address that they sent the money to be like the one where the money ended up, because they derived that from the public key in the Monero address or in the in the, the public, I think they call it a public address. [00:05:25] In Lightning, it's different, you don't actually send money to the public key that's just used for communication, you're sending it, you know, in this encrypted route, and you don't actually see the last hop, you don't see what HTLC it's going into, or how that HTLC gets resolved. You don't see what address is involved. So if someone is like, subpoenaing you for information, and they want to know what address did you send this money to, you can honestly say on Lightning, I don't even know, even if I kept logs, I wouldn't have that information. [00:05:53] Whereas with Monero, you know, a lot of the ways that they track this, they go to like MorphToken or, or FixedFloat. And they're like, what, what is the actual address that you send the money to because the sender knows in Monero, and you just don't on Lightning. [00:06:07] Vlad Costea: I do get this point that there's less information that gets stored on your wallet side, because that's what this is about. On Monero, you are able to see to whom you have sent the transactions. Maybe that's an outside observer who's watching the blockchain will not know. But if they get access to your wallet, they're going to be able to see your history of transactions. And also, in the case of Monero, you can give up on the privacy. Especially I know that in the Monero GUI wallet that you run on desktop, you can choose to make your transaction transparent and reveal the amounts or reveal some information. [00:06:45] You can also export a history of your transactions. If you want to reveal that to someone. So privacy is on by default in Monero. But your wallet knows what you're doing. And you also store that information. So if you really want to have good privacy, you have to use disposable wallets and just move money around across different wallets. You're saying that Lightning does not store that information. [00:07:11] Super Testnet: It's not just that it doesn't store it. You actually don't know. You don't know what the channel is that your recipient has with this counterparty. You don't know what channel that that money is going into. And you don't know what HTLC it's going into. You're just saying I want to go to this node. And if the node you selected has any channel with that person, they'll just pick whichever one they want to use. You, as the sender, don't get to see that information. So you have less information from a Lightning invoice about where the money actually went than you get from a Monero public address. [00:07:45] Vlad Costea: Right. But there's more to it because, for example, if you want to send large amounts, you don't get too much deniability in Lightning because there is not much liquidity. Last time I checked, it was 5000 Bitcoin or something, which is the total amount of coins that are locked into this layer. If you're a whale or something, you're probably better off using Monero. [00:08:08] Super Testnet: I'm not sure that that's... I'm not sure. I've not checked how many nodes have enough liquidity to forward, let's say, a two-Bitcoin payment for $200,000. But what I'm thinking is, if you did send $200,000 through the Lightning Network, I think that it would probably go through. And the routing nodes along the path would still have onion encryption that prevents them from knowing who the sender was. And they also have onion encryption preventing them from knowing who the recipient is. So yeah, is it really bad to send a large amount over the Lightning Network? [00:08:49] You might have to try several times to do it. But once you find a route, then the routing nodes along that path still don't know who the sender is or who the recipient is. [00:08:58] Vlad Costea: What about the amount? Because when you're opening the channel, and let's assume it's a two Bitcoin channel that you're opening with someone, that's pretty visible. It can be observed. You can see it on 1ML.com or something, one of these Lightning Network explorers. I think also on mempool.space, I'm not sure if they have that feature. So it's clear that the liquidity went on the Lightning Network. But is it possible with Lightning transactions for an outside observer to know that two Bitcoins are being transferred? [00:09:32] Super Testnet: No, it's not possible for an outside observer. Only the people on the route would know any information about the amount, because amounts aren't gossiped on the Lightning Network. They're only exchanged between the nodes that are along the route. And even there, this is one reason why I said the part that the Lightning Network gets it worst on is amount privacy. But even there, I think it does really good. Because for one thing, it's not broadcast, like in the Lightning, in Lightning Network transactions. Your transactions are not part of the gossip network. [00:10:05] You're just the only people who know about your transaction are the people on the route. And secondly, we have what's it called, multipath payments. And if you do a multipath payment, which is built into a lot of, most wallets now, it splits up the amount into smaller chunks, and then sends them along different paths to the recipient. And we do this on the Lightning Network. In fact, wallets have an incentive to do this, because smaller amounts tend to go through more easily. So you get fewer payment failures if you split up the amount and send it over multiple paths. [00:10:39] But that also means that any routing node who sees a payment doesn't know if the amount there is the full amount being paid or just a shard of the amount. So like, in addition to not broadcasting the amounts, we also make it so that the routing nodes don't know the full amount, they only get a lower bound, they know he sent, you know, if $50 flows through their routing node, the routing node knows at least $50 was sent. But it might be, you know, five sets of 50 that he, you know, he split up a $250 payment into five sets of 50. [00:11:09] And you just don't know as a routing node if he did that. [00:11:13] Vlad Costea: Right. You have this concept in the Lightning Network of private channels, are they really good for privacy? Or what's the purpose of them? [00:11:24] Super Testnet: No, I don't think they're really good for privacy, you can find, there are ways to find someone's private channel, or at least, if they're not using Taproot, there's ways to find their private channel. If they're using Taproot, then it gets harder. The, and by the way, LND recently added Taproot channels, like they did last year. And a lot of the mobile wallets support it now, which is great. But what's the purpose, you asked? And the purpose is that to make a distinction between nodes who are routing and nodes who are not. [00:11:56] If you're a routing node, you advertise your, you can anyway, advertise your channels and say, you should connect to me, look at all these different destinations I'm connected to, here are my fee rates, and you're kind of advertising. And so they publish that information. If you're a user and you're on a smartphone, maybe you don't want to route, probably you don't, aren't able to because like your phone's in your pocket most of the time and not sending messages. So you make, you don't need to have your channels announced, you don't need to advertise yourself as offering a service, because you're not. [00:12:32] So then they make these channels that aren't announced on the gossip network. But that doesn't make them private. So in early Lightning, they called them private channels. And what's his name, Tony Giorgio, pounded into everyone's head, you can still see them on the blockchain, they're not private. So and he's right, they're just not announced on the gossip network. But they're still on the blockchain. So you can see them. [00:12:55] Vlad Costea: Right. So what is their purpose more exactly? Because they are called private. [00:13:00] Super Testnet: Some people call them private. But let me echo Tony Giorgio here and say they... [00:13:05] Vlad Costea: I remember when I was using Ride The Lightning, which is this wallet, and I was using it to manage channels on my LND node. It had this feature when I was opening a channel to tick a box that said open a private channel. [00:13:19] Super Testnet: Well, it's it's a it's a misnomer and someone should do a pull request and change it to an unannounced channel. The purpose is to say is to not say, here's my channel, you can route through me, like you're not advertising that service. So you're so you don't make that announcement on the gossip network. But that's the only difference is they're not announced on the gossip network. They're still visible on the blockchain and you can still find them. [00:13:42] Vlad Costea: On the Lightning Network, which scenario is more private, let's say that I open a channel with you, and I only send to you? Or is it more private if I open channels with more people and I have more routes? [00:13:56] Super Testnet: There's less trust. Well, I don't know, that's the thing. If you just open a channel to me and then do all of your transactions directly with me, I still don't know if you're... I still don't know who the sender is, because it might be you, or you might be routing a payment from someone who I can't see, from, yeah, from just some other user. And I don't know if you're doing that or not. I could make an assumption and say, well, he doesn't have public channels. So he's probably not a router and therefore he probably is a sender. But not all routing nodes do have public channels. You can still route with private chan... well, now I'm doing it, with unannounced channels. So yeah, I don't I wouldn't I don't know which one's more private. [00:14:40] And I guess that's part of the point is, because of the Lightning Network discloses so little information to the recipient and to routing nodes. It's difficult to determine whether it's more private to use zero routing nodes or to use many. Either way, the recipient can't tell. [00:14:56] Vlad Costea: Right. So on the Monero side, how would you describe that this works when, let's say Alice sends coins to Bob? What's happening there? On Monero? Yeah. [00:15:07] Super Testnet: Yeah, when when Alice constructs a transaction to send to Bob, she looks through the blockchain, and she, I want to say randomly, but it's not quite a random algorithm, she uses an algorithm to pick a set of decoys. And these are similar to how we do CoinJoins in Bitcoin, except it's non-interactive in Monero, which is awesome, by the way. I really like the Monero tech on non-interactive decoys. But you pick a bunch of people from the blockchain, and you say, it's typically 16, or it's 15 plus the real plus you, you pick 15 people, and then you say, one of these people is sending the money in this transaction, I'm listing them all in my transaction as possible senders. [00:15:48] And you create something called a ring signature. Ring signature takes a list of public keys and creates a signature such that you know, one of the people, one of the pubkeys in that list signed it, but you don't know which one. And that's what Monero uses to sign their transaction. So you can see either Alice, Bob, Carol, or Dave, of 16 people, one of them sent the money. But we don't know. So that's how Monero protects sender privacy. It does best on amount privacy, where it actually encrypts the information. [00:16:20] So what I was just describing is not encryption, but obscure obscurity, which is good, it's like obscurity is good, but in my opinion, encryption is better. So it doesn't encrypt the sender, but it does encrypt the amount and it uses a really cool encryption standard that has a property called perfect blinding, which means even like even if they cracked the encryption algorithm, they still wouldn't know the amounts in the in the in the encoded in a in a Monero transaction, which is great. With one exception, the fee, the fee is public in Monero transactions, the fee paid, and you might think, well, that doesn't matter. [00:16:56] But it's used to fingerprint wallets and to identify exchanges and other... Like, if you watch this, the Chainalysis... released a video, they didn't release it, it leaked, a video last year, in which they disclose how they trace Monero transactions, and they spend a considerable portion of it talking about how they use the fee to identify whether someone is an exchange because they tend to use larger fees, or a regular user because they tend to use the default fee. Or they like have agreements with certain exchanges that they have to like share information, and they use that information as well. [00:17:26] But the fee tells them a lot about what kind of user is using Monero. And so it's not in my opinion, it's not good that Monero publishes the fee, they should in my opinion, or I like systems that encrypts the entire amount and not leave a little bit of it unencrypted. Lightning, by the way, encrypts the full amount, including the fees. So routing nodes do not know the fee you paid, they only know the fee you paid them, but they don't know the fee you paid for the full transaction. [00:17:53] And then lastly, is the recipient. And in a Monero transaction, when you create a when you create a Monero transaction, you use a stealth address, which is what I was describing earlier, and you get someone's public key, and you don't send money to that public key, you derive another public key from it. And you send money to that. And then you with your transaction, you include information that the recipient can use to, to figure out what how to spend from that public key from the public key you actually send the money to. [00:18:21] They also make make have a rule in Monero, I don't think it's a consensus rule, but it's, it's a wallet, like everyone does this, where if two transactions get sent to the same address, the same, like, they call them one time addresses, the ones you derive from the public address, if two transactions get sent to that the wallet will ignore the second one, and it will only acknowledge the first transaction, which is great, because that means no one ever sends like, no one ever reuses addresses on Monero, because their wallet wouldn't even show they received it, which which I really like that. [00:18:53] And I want I like to do stuff like that, too. So thank you, Monero for making good privacy tech. [00:19:00] Vlad Costea: That's interesting. I want to also explore this side of network level privacy, because in the case of Lightning, you have nodes which are associated with IP addresses. And in the case of Monero, you have Dandelion++, which was actually a proposal for Bitcoin to dissociate transactions from IP addresses and nodes. And you can also put Tor on top. In the case of Lightning, you can optionally use Tor for your node, but that only slows down your transactions, makes you less likely to route. And it only makes it useful for yourself in some cases, but can also lead to failed payments. [00:19:44] Super Testnet: There are some downsides to using Tor. And I am glad to see, if you go to Clark Moody's Bitcoin dashboard, something like 70% of routing nodes on the Lightning Network use Tor anyway. Which I think is wonderful. Some might say, well, no wonder payments fail. 70% of the routing nodes are using Tor. But that's the situation. I think that's largely because of Umbrels. I think people set up, they buy an Umbrel or a Start9 machine or one of these nodes in a box, and they default to, most of them default to running your node on Tor. [00:20:21] Actually, one interesting thing, when you're setting up LND, it does not default to doing it on mainnet, or on clearnet, I mean, to using IPv4 or IPv6. In fact, you have to choose, like there's no default set. When you try to set up a routing node, you have to say in your configuration file whether you want it to be on Tor or on clearnet and specify that. I really like that. It seems that most routing nodes choose to do it over Tor. Yeah, Dandelion++ is a great technology in Monero, and I don't know why Bitcoin wallets haven't adopted it. [00:20:58] Because you totally can. It's not even a consensus rule change. Your wallet can just start doing it, and then you have it. And we don't even have to worry about writing the code, because it's already out there. Monero wallets have it. So just copy-paste, cheat, and that would be great. I don't know why no wallets are doing that. I forget what your question is. Did I answer your question? I don't think I did. Partially. [00:21:22] Vlad Costea: In the case of the Lightning Network... [00:21:24] Super Testnet: Network-level privacy. [00:21:25] Vlad Costea: Yeah. Is there any way to associate transactions with a certain IP address? [00:21:31] Super Testnet: No, or at least not unless you're a routing node and you happen to know who the sender is. In the Lightning Network, you don't gossip your IP address or your Tor address unless you're a routing node. I mentioned earlier that when you're setting up a routing node, you have to set it to be on mainnet or clearnet. When you do that, you start advertising. You start saying, here are my channels, you should route through me, I'm connected to all these people. If you just set up a node, if you set up Electrum or you set up LND or Phoenix or something, it's not going to tell people your IP address. [00:22:03] It doesn't use gossip because it's not needed. You're not routing any transactions, you're not advertising that service. So people like to say, you know, a Lightning invoice doxes your IP address. It doesn't. Unless you're a routing node. If you're a routing node, then it doxes your IP address. But if you're not, if you're just a user, then it doesn't. That's pretty cool. Another aspect of network-level privacy is that on the Lightning Network, when you're sending a transaction, every interaction between you and the routes along the path is encrypted. [00:22:36] We use onion encryption. I encrypt a layer for, well, I guess I start with the last guy, I encrypt a layer for him, and then I wrap that in a layer for the next hop back, and I wrap that in a layer for the next hop back. There's all these layers of encryption that make every single interaction encrypted on the Lightning Network. Other networks don't do this. On Bitcoin, when I interact with my peers, it's not encrypted. The traffic is in plain text. And on Monero as well, when you interact with your peers, when you send transactions, you send them in plain text. [00:23:07] So there is no peer-to-peer traffic encryption on Monero, and there is in Lightning. And I just thought I'd like to mention that. [00:23:17] Vlad Costea: Yeah. I guess in the case of Monero, it's much more difficult. So there is no condition that your node is a routing one or not. You have much better network-level privacy by default, thanks to Dandelion. You don't even have to use Tor, but if you add Tor on top, it's going to be much more private. [00:23:39] Super Testnet: I think it's a really good idea to use Tor. In the Chainalysis video that I mentioned earlier... Can we put the link to the Chainalysis video in the show notes? I'll send it to you. [00:23:48] Vlad Costea: Yeah. I think it was taken down a bunch of times, so it's hard to keep track of where that is. If you have it, that's pretty cool. [00:23:55] Super Testnet: I have a link that has been working for the last two weeks or so. In that video, they go over how they do traffic analysis after the Dandelion upgrade was implemented. And they said all of our assumptions about traffic analysis get much weaker after 20... if, if trans... for transactions that were broadcasted after 2020. However, there's one thing that is different here, or there's one thing to note, which is that wallets like Cake Wallet and Monerujo don't do what a lot of Bitcoin wallets do, which is pretend to be a node and then use the peer-to-peer connection to broadcast your transactions. [00:24:33] Most of them use something called remote procedure call, which means they ask some website. Yeah, RPC calls. And they ask some website and say, you do transactions for Monero, right? Here's the raw hex of my transaction. Please broadcast this to the network. And when you do that, you're not getting the protections of Dandelion because that only applies at the peer-to-peer level and not at the remote procedure call level. So in the Chainalysis video, about a third of the transactions that they click on were sent by people who just were using a wallet that went to one of the servers owned by Chainalysis or partnered with Chainalysis and broadcasted it there. [00:25:12] So yeah, Dandelion is great, but in order to do that, you have to run your own node because wallets don't do it. They could, they could, each wallet could pretend to be a peer and then send the transactions over the peer-to-peer level, and then they would get the Dandelion protection, but they're not doing that. I don't know why. But yeah, so if you want the Dandelion stuff, you have to run your own node or wait till a developer implements a wallet that does it on mobile. [00:25:38] And you also, I think you should use Tor because although Dandelion tries to protect your IP address, if a lot of the nodes are listening for these things, they could, with some probability, they could get, yes, they could figure out, I don't know, I don't want to say that. I wanted to say with some probability they could figure it out, but I'm not sure that's true, so I don't want to finish there. I will just say I think it's better if you use Tor. Although on the, on the GitHub for Monero, if you enable the Tor option, the GitHub says it's not used for relaying transactions. [00:26:09] It's only used for a couple of things and it doesn't use them for relaying transactions, which is interesting. I don't know why they don't do that. You'd have to like use a separate Tor implementation than the one that's integrated into Monero if you wanted to actually relay transactions encrypted because for some reason it doesn't do that and I haven't read the rationale. [00:26:30] Vlad Costea: Last year we have seen a lot of these ecash mints and federations that use ecash, which gives you much better privacy at the expense of control over your own keys or custody. And you're going to have to trust some custodian that he's going to be honest and you're going to be able to trade within, not trade, you know, send and receive inside of that federation with pretty good privacy. Would you say that it's a net benefit for privacy and how does that privacy of ecash compare to that of Monero? [00:27:08] Super Testnet: It depends. It's sometimes a benefit. So I personally don't like to put a significant amount of money on custodial solutions. I don't mind having a couple bucks on there, but when I get to about $20 worth of value and then I'm like, I don't want to have that money on a custodian. I want to withdraw it to my own self custody. Sometimes I call this candy bar money. I don't care if my candy bar money is custody. So I will do that for like Nostr apps or something. [00:27:37] But yeah, for me, it's more important that I take control of the custody of my coins whenever it's a significant amount of money. But you didn't ask about whether I prefer custody. You asked what are the privacy advantages of doing this. And the privacy advantage of using an ecash mint is similar to the privacy advantage of using something like Tornado Cash on Monero, or Tornado Cash on Ethereum, where the pool that has aggregated all the user funds does not disclose when a payment is made. It does not disclose who in the group made the payment. [00:28:10] You only know it was somebody in this pool. Similar with an ecash mint, if the ecash mint sends out a payment to somewhere, you don't know, and even the mint operator doesn't know which member of the mint sent the money. You just know it's somebody in that group sent the money. So that's the privacy advantage. And depending on the size of the mint and how many users it has, it might be bigger than the anonymity set that you currently get with Monero. Because Monero's current ring signature size is 16. [00:28:38] You have 16 people who are in your transaction with you. [00:28:41] Vlad Costea: Your transaction plus 15 decoys, right? [00:28:44] Super Testnet: Yeah, well, your [unclear: TXO] plus 16 decoys, 15 decoys. But with a mint, it depends on how many people there are. And yeah, I don't know how many users mints have. So I don't know what the benefit you get there is. It's hard to say. I suspect that the bigger mints, or the ones with a lot of liquidity on them, probably have more than 15 users. And so then you'd be getting a bigger anonymity set. But I don't know. At least I don't think they disclose how many people are using them. [00:29:18] I don't even know if they know how many people are using them. Yeah, because they could count the number of deposits, but each deposit could... some of the deposits are going to be by the same user, so they wouldn't even know how many users they have. [00:29:30] Vlad Costea: I'm aware that you've had a debate with Luke Parker, who is right now working on full-chain membership proofs on Monero, and that one is going to increase the anonymity set to correspond to basically the whole chain. It will not be only 16 transactions in that ring. [00:29:51] Super Testnet: It will be the whole chain. I told him that he should call it Oops! All Decoys, because there's that cereal, the Cap'n Crunch cereal, where it's Oops! All Berries, instead of having the golden corn pieces. I was like, you should call it Oops! All Decoys. That would be a much catchier name. I don't know. I think it sounds like a wonderful piece of technology. Luke Parker, who is smarter than me, and implemented it, or I don't think he implemented it, or I think he made like a prototype or something. [00:30:20] He seems to be really confident that it does what it says, and it makes it so that you can't tell which member of the Monero pubkey set spent this money. If that's true, that's great. I would love to reanalyze this debate and see which which has better privacy after full-chain membership proofs get implemented. I haven't seen any criticism of it. I haven't [unclear: heard it] intuitively. It sounds like a great thing. So yeah, I just I look forward to seeing how it works once it's developed. [00:30:52] And tried it out on testnet, and then on mainnet, and more eyes are on it. I would love to see, I would love to learn more about full-chain membership proofs. It sounds awesome. [00:31:01] Vlad Costea: Once it's tried on testnet, it's gonna be tried on Super Testnet. [00:31:06] Super Testnet: Maybe by then I'll have a Monero clone that you could try it on. I do have my own Bitcoin testnet that you can try Bitcoin apps on, but I don't have a Monero on it. Well, I doubt I will, because I just find working on Bitcoin more interesting. One thing I thought of when I was at the gym today is that the idea of full-chain membership proofs is to make it so that you can't distinguish whether the sender is, which of the Monero users the sender is. [00:31:31] And I tried to wonder, is there another way to accomplish that? Because we don't have zero knowledge. Well, we don't have the same zero knowledge proof technology in Bitcoin that you guys have in Monero, or that the Monero people have in Monero. But we do have some things. And I tried to think, what would we do to make it so that you couldn't distinguish whether the sender is who the sender is? And what I thought of was, what I keep coming back to, is the Lightning Network. [00:31:56] In the Lightning Network, we encrypt the sender, and so any routing node on the route, he just sees an encrypted blob, so he doesn't know who the sender is. And that encrypted blob could have been made by anyone who has a Lightning wallet. So do encrypted senders count as full-chain membership proofs? I imagine Luke Parker swinging an axe right now and saying, definitely not, it's totally different. But yeah, Luke, do a post and tell us why. Why is that different? I'd love to learn. [00:32:29] Vlad Costea: You mentioned zero knowledge proofs. I also want to ask you why you compared Lightning with Monero and not with Zcash, because that one has much more advanced cryptography. It already has what Monero is trying to accomplish with full-chain membership proofs. It just has fewer users. [00:32:48] Super Testnet: Maybe my next post will be comparing Zcash to Monero, but I don't know why I chose to go with Monero in my comparison post rather than Zcash. But they might have a lot to do with the fact, it's like subconsciously, I was like, well, it's more useful to win over the Monero users, because there's more of them than there are Zcash users. I don't know, I didn't think about Zcash when I made the post. [00:33:12] Vlad Costea: I guess you also wanted to dunk on the fact that most of the transactions on dark web markets are being made with Monero, and you wanted to prove that Lightning can also be used for that. You can provide a couple of links to attest that there are some listings on some dark web markets of non-illegal stuff that's being sold for Bitcoin using the Lightning Network. Why do you think there are not more of these listings? What do you think is the roadblock? [00:33:45] Super Testnet: I suspect it is the barrier to entry for the Lightning Network. In order to set up a Monero node, well, you don't even need a Monero node. In order to set up a Monero wallet, you just download a wallet and you're off and running. And so I think that makes it really a lot easier on darknet market developers. Whereas for Lightning, there's an extra step. You have to download a wallet and you have to set up channels. So I suspect it's that extra step. And then, yeah, then on users, users also have those two steps. [00:34:18] Every user not only has to, like, it might be fine for a developer team to say, okay, we downloaded a wallet and then we set up a channel. That, you know, took us an afternoon. But if each of your users has to spend an afternoon setting up their wallet in order to pay you, maybe that's the reason. I wonder if the reason why darknet markets, more of them use Monero or I don't even know if that's true. I wonder if more darknet markets would use Lightning if it was as easy to set up for both users and developers as Monero is. [00:34:50] So that's one of the things that I work on is making it easier to use the Lightning Network. [00:34:55] Vlad Costea: If you look at XMR Bazaar, which is what I used, and it's not a darknet market, it's just a market that has lots of listings and a lot of them are from Europe and US. You find a lot of crap. I bought a Nintendo 64 using that. I thought it was it was super cool that I could do that. And I felt a bit sorry that there's not a Bitcoin equivalent that has lots of listings, you know, because there was OpenBazaar. There was [unclear: Plebeian Market] at one point, which was something where you could sell your stuff. [00:35:28] It was sort of like eBay. But I'm not aware of something that has a lot of listings nowadays. [00:35:33] Super Testnet: I will send you a link. The one that I found that I think they were, they were like chocolates with, with Monero, I almost said Monero, chocolates with marijuana in them. That's the link I just sent you is the darknet market I found where people were doing that. And it looks to me like it has a lot of listings. So check that one out. And all of those listings support the Lightning Network. [00:35:58] Vlad Costea: Now let me open the Tor browser and check it out. In the meantime, while this loads, because Tor is slow, I got to tell you about SideShift, which is this place where you can trade the various shitcoins that you can get from airdrops or whatever. If someone sends you something, don't say no, just take it from them and swap it for the kind of free market money that you actually want to hold on SideShift. They have a lot of liquidity, they have pretty low fees. If someone gives you for your birthday some Trump tokens from the meme coin because they take pride in owning that, you don't have to tell them what you really think. [00:36:36] You can just accept that and swap it for Bitcoin on SideShift. You can actually do that. Or if someone offers to pay you in USDT, it's a bull market, man. Don't hold on to stablecoins. I mean, not financial advice, but you're probably better off buying Bitcoin with that. So check out SideShift.ai. And also, I got to ask you about LayerTwo Labs and drivechains because people from their Telegram chat are watching right now. And they want to know what's your latest opinion of what Paul is doing with all of that? What's it called? Core Untouched Soft Fork? [00:37:12] Super Testnet: Yeah, the Core Untouched Soft Fork. I like it. So my take is that Paul has observed that one of the reasons why miners haven't activated BIP 300 yet, I suspect, I think he suspects too, is because they don't want to use Paul's fork of Bitcoin Core. Because then it probably wouldn't get as good and as often of security updates as Bitcoin Core does. And so I think miners basically are just like, we just want to use whatever everyone else is using and whatever one gets frequent security updates and has a lot of developer focus. [00:37:54] And that's just not Paul's software. It's him and his team working on it and no one else, at least as far as I'm aware. So I think he came up with this idea of saying, well, what if we could make it so that you could implement drivechains without touching Bitcoin Core? And I think that's a brilliant idea. So what he does is he makes it so that if the miner runs this, this non... with this, this software to the side, this Core Untouched Soft Fork software, they will reject transactions that violate the BIP 300 rules. [00:38:25] And from the mempool, and they will invalidate blocks that don't follow the BIP 300 rules by just calling the invalidate block command and by having a new mempool filtering policy. And by doing that, you make it so that you don't have to you don't have to change Bitcoin Core, you can still as a miner run Bitcoin Core, you can still get the frequent security updates. So you get all this good stuff that Bitcoin Core has, but you can also activate drivechains on the side. And I think that's great. [00:38:53] I hope it's a success, and let's get drivechains happening. That'd be great. [00:39:03] Vlad Costea: Yeah, last year, I think you came up or maybe it wasn't you. But I did see this from you that you can basically do drivechains with covenants. It's not ideal, you're removing some of the protections that are provided to users, but miners can do that. [00:39:21] Super Testnet: Miners... The nice thing about soft forks is, well, a nice thing about soft forks is that every one we've ever done, with some caveats around SegWit, was done by miners. Miners implemented... They didn't implement the code. Miners chose to run the code and reject the blocks that didn't follow the new rules after, you know, 90% of them or so signaled that they were ready to do it. And I didn't think they could do that with BIP 300. They could just start signaling, we're going to start invalidating blocks after, you know, block whatever, that don't follow the new BIP 300 rules. [00:39:54] And they could do that even if without, like, without getting permission from anyone. I just think, through what I talked about earlier, they just don't want to run separate software and then not have frequent updates and good developer teams on them. I forget, I meandered from your question, oh, could you do them with covenants? Probably, you probably can do them with covenants. I suspect you can actually, you can probably do drivechains without covenants, as long as miners are willing to enforce a variable length time lock, which I think you could do variable length time locks using like, by using like a counter, I think you could use a counter and you increment it by like revealing hashes and stuff like we do in BitVM. [00:40:39] I think there's probably a way to do drivechains without a soft fork at all. But it still requires miners to run special software. And so somebody has to write it and then convince them to do it. And you know, Paul's taking on that fight. You can probably do them with covenants. Most things are possible if you think about it for a really long time and have smart people work on it. But yeah, Paul is one of the smart people and he's working on it. So thank you, Paul. [00:41:08] Vlad Costea: What do you think about ossification? Do you think it's going to happen if we get that strategic reserve from the US? [00:41:17] Super Testnet: I think it already happened. I don't think Bitcoin will ever see a soft fork again, or a hard fork. And I think it's ossified. If you want my opinion on ossification, I think it sucks. But ossification means you stop fixing problems. And that seems to be what has happened in Bitcoin. So I don't like that. And I would like to see more. I would like to see de-ossification and more fixes and improvements in the consensus rules. [00:41:51] Vlad Costea: Now, that's a very nice answer. But someone who is on the side of ossification and possibly a spook is going to say, yeah, you're just trying to get paid because you have solutions for problems that they don't consider actually exist. And they'll say Bitcoin is already perfect and you're just a dev who's trying to get a paycheck. [00:42:10] Super Testnet: Well, they're not wrong about the latter. I am trying to get a paycheck. So you caught me. I don't think there's anything wrong with trying to get a paycheck, but I also think there's no such thing as perfection in software. I don't think it's attainable. And so anyone who says Bitcoin is perfect, I think they're wrong. I think there's things we can do to fix it. [00:42:35] Vlad Costea: What do you think about these ZK roll-ups? This podcast is also sponsored by Citrea and they are doing the equivalent of Optimism on Ethereum with their ZK roll-up, which you're going to argue that is not a true ZK roll-up because it doesn't use BitVM. I think I've heard you argue that before. [00:42:57] Super Testnet: Well, you can have a true roll-up, I mean, none of the Ethereum roll-ups use BitVM either. And so you don't have to use BitVM to be a true roll-up. I don't remember my thoughts on Citrea's blockchain thing. I remember having thoughts about it, but I don't remember what they are. I do remember thinking Citrea is a scam. So I could, I could rail about that for a little bit if you want. If you want. [00:43:19] Vlad Costea: But I also got Liam Eagen to talk about it and he said, you know, it's actually honest as long as it doesn't claim to be what it's not. And of course, it's not everything that you expect it to be yet, but maybe if we get a covenant, it's going to be much better. [00:43:37] Super Testnet: Yeah, I don't, I have very little recollection of, I haven't thought about them in probably six months now. I don't remember what my thoughts were. So I just remember having a negative opinion about them, but I don't remember why. [00:43:49] Vlad Costea: But you did concede at one point and you said, you know, Orkun is not a scammer or something. [00:43:54] Super Testnet: I did. I did. Yeah. So we, I had a podcast with the guy from [unclear: Citrea, Orkun], where I laid out my reasons why I think they're a scam. And mostly it had to do with their website saying that they did things that they hadn't done and saying they were the first to do things they were not the first to do. And he very carefully showed me that if you parsed the sentences just right, they didn't say those things. And the reason I'm being vague here is because I don't remember the details anymore. [00:44:27] It was kind of, it was a long time ago and I haven't thought about it since. After that event, Robin Linus contacted me and he gave me additional reasons to think they were a scam. And I don't know if I was fully persuaded or I don't, I don't have a good feeling about Citrea. And I don't, I don't remember what his reasons were and I also don't remember what my reasons were. I do remember thinking that he answered my reasons sufficiently, but I still [unclear: had a good] opinion of them and that's about as much as I can remember. [00:44:59] So I apologize for that. I didn't know we were going to talk about Citrea, otherwise I would have gathered my thoughts more. [00:45:04] Vlad Costea: No, it's all good. What they're trying to do, I think it's pretty interesting because they want to bring these DeFi applications to Bitcoin. They want to be a layer where you can put your Bitcoin as collateral to issue stable coins and basically get a loan in the style of Celsius or BlockFi without the company, without the middleman. [00:45:25] Super Testnet: So I remember part of it now. One of the things that they claimed in their white paper, not the white paper, but on their website and when I declared them a scam, one of the things they claimed was we have executed the first zero knowledge proof roll up on Bitcoin, or we have launched the first zero knowledge proof roll up on Bitcoin. And all they had done at the time was made one transaction, and this transaction, it didn't contain, it contained like a proof that one block existed of another blockchain. [00:46:00] And I said, what they made, they made the blockchain using like Ethereum software, EVM software, they created a zero knowledge proof, they validated the zero knowledge proof off of Bitcoin, and then they just included on Bitcoin, like the text of the, you know, it's valid or something like that. And I remember saying at the time, this is not launching a zero knowledge proof roll up on Bitcoin. Your website says it is, but it's not. And I believe Orkun's answer to that was, how many blocks do you need to count as a blockchain? [00:46:33] And I had to concede only one. It was like, well, we did one block and we showed that it worked on Bitcoin. So that counts. [00:46:40] Vlad Costea: Okay, so it's semantics at this point. [00:46:43] Super Testnet: Well, but I don't... Yeah, technically, I guess you could say they did what they technically said, but it's just the way it's worded, it makes it sound like you can use it. And it's more like they did something that you could do at a hackathon or something like you could have made, you could have validated a zero knowledge proof off of Bitcoin on a weekend and then publish the proof on Bitcoin and done that for a hackathon project. And then they raised millions of dollars off this stuff. [00:47:07] And I was just like, this is not a usable product. This is just like, look that we know how zero knowledge proofs work. And so I thought they were raising money off of essentially a lie. But he said, look, if you look very carefully, we only claim to do a blockchain and a blockchain only requires one block. And there was this whole, yeah, I don't like, I don't have good feelings about Citrea, but that is as much clarity as you're going to get on it because my memories on the subject are very vague. [00:47:38] Vlad Costea: No, it's fine. I also remember Robin Linus's objections. He was unhappy that they did not accomplish too much and they raised a lot of money. I think this was his concern. Maybe he was a bit jealous because I think honestly, I think Robin did a pretty good job. He could have raised a lot of money, but he chose to do a Ph.D. instead and push the research further. I respect that. [00:48:02] Super Testnet: Yeah, I think it might be jealousy. And that might be what's motivating me, too. I might have been sitting there and in my subconscious little lizard mind, it was saying I could have made a zero knowledge proof off of Bitcoin and then posted it on Bitcoin and raised a million dollars. But that's like unethical. And so I wouldn't do that, but they did it. And so then I got mad at them. But maybe it's also just jealousy. I'm like, I should have gotten the million dollars or something like that. [00:48:26] Vlad Costea: It was more than that. [00:48:29] Super Testnet: Yeah, well, still, the principle is, I don't... [00:48:32] Vlad Costea: We're still poor, it's fine. Yeah. It's fine. There are some comments in the chat and I feel sorry for ignoring this. I did put on the screen for a little while Shopify, not Shopify, Shopstr, and this one has some listings and we're gonna talk about that. But before that, let's get to the comments in the chat. Because I think some of them are interesting and I don't want these guys to go away. I don't feel... I don't want them to feel like they're getting ignored. So there is Max Wonderland, who said, "Good evening, gentlemen." Good evening, Max. You can see them on YouTube if you want, and if you want to read along, myself. "With Lightning Network, one of the problems is most people use custodial Lightning, which defeats the whole purpose and creates big players. That get a lot of information about the funds in the network moving around." By the way, "the stream is pretty laggy with little cutoffs from the sound." I don't know if that's only me. I don't know. "Also, transactions through Lightning can fail. Also, opening channels is very expensive. [00:49:40] One of the reasons why most people seem to use custodial." "Yes, ring signatures are the weakest link at the moment in XMR, but that gets fixed soon with full-chain membership proofs." I think we went through this. "Sorry, but what is he talking about? [unclear: Wallets] always send the transaction to a node. It's either your own node or someone else's, like Cake. So every transaction is secured by Dandelion." This is his claim about our talk about network-level privacy. And he also says, "Chainalysis runs own nodes and proxies disguised as valid nodes. [00:50:14] That's how they are able to link transactions to IPs of the real sender." [00:50:22] Super Testnet: Yeah, I agree with the last sentence that that is one of the ways that they do it. But you know, after Dandelion came into effect, you need like you need to surround the node and know that he like, I have some kind of confidence he doesn't have any other connections to any other nodes. It's like a Sybil attack in order to get around Dandelion. But the other thing, you said every, every node either talks... or every wallet either talks to its own node or to someone else's node. [00:50:47] And therefore, they're all protected by Dandelion, not if it's a Chainalysis node. If it's if you connect directly to a Chainalysis node, and not not through the peer to peer network, but through their RPC call, give them the hex, the raw hex of your transaction, as a lot of these wallets do, you're not getting the protections of Dandelion because they they know then you're not using the peer to peer network, you're using effectively a website or you know, web server somewhere to talk to communicate. [00:51:13] And so you're not getting the protections of Dandelion. Dandelion is only run by nodes. And it's not run by these wallet programs, who don't accept incoming, they don't accept inbound connections, they don't even have a static IP address or onion address. They're off most of the times they don't, they don't route. They don't relay transactions. And if that's the one connecting to the RPC call, then they have very high confidence that it's that it's that it's the actual sender, and not, you know, some Dandelion node. So yeah, that's just, I disagree, very... I disagree with the sentence where you said, it either connects to your own node or someone else's node. [00:51:53] Well, I don't disagree with that. But it misses the point, which is that there's two ways to connect to a node, either the peer to peer way, where you where you either are a peer or pretend to be a peer, or there's the RPC way. And that way is leaks a lot of information. So I don't think, well, it should do that. And I don't think they need to, I think the wallets can implement the part of the peer to peer protocol necessary to look like a to look like a Dandelion. [00:52:17] It looks like something that supports Dandelion. And I just don't think they have. [00:52:22] Vlad Costea: There's also another comment by [unclear: Inigo Arehula], I think, I hope I'm not mispronouncing. And he or she says, "LSP plus KYC will remove all the privacy for most people on the Lightning Network." LSP meaning Lightning service provider, for those who don't know. [00:52:38] Super Testnet: Yeah, I don't think that's true either. There's two, there's two groups of people who use LSPs: there's users and there's routing nodes. And the LSP can't distinguish whether you're a just a regular end user or you're a routing node. So if you are sending a transaction, and you're using an LSP, they don't know if you're the sender, or if you're a routing node. And that is really good for your privacy, because they don't know who the sender is. But the other... Someone mentioned earlier, everybody's using custodians on the Lightning Network. [00:53:09] Well, I don't think everyone is I, I don't think everyone's using custodians on the Lightning Network. Those who choose to do so are compromising their privacy, because the sender of the transaction knows who the sender is, and who the amount is, and what the amount is. They don't know who the they don't know what address is receiving the transaction, which is, you know, a good thing that is, in my opinion, better than what Monero offers. But they still know who the sender is, who the amount is. [00:53:39] So if you're using a custodian, you're not getting good privacy from that custodian. And I recommend not doing that anymore. If you're looking for good, well, I recommend, let's say, don't do that if you're looking for good privacy. What I should say is, you should look for good privacy. And therefore, you should not use a custodian. Because then you're only getting recipient privacy. You're, you're... Of the three categories, sender privacy, amount privacy and recipient privacy, you're only getting recipient privacy. And it's better if you get, you know, all three, by running your own node, or by using one of these, you know, phone wallets. [00:54:14] Vlad Costea: I have this phone wallet, it's Phoenix. And right now it's connecting to Tor and then a Lightning peer and an Electrum server. And it's also uploading payments to a cloud. I'm not sure exactly which cloud if it's my account or somebody else's, or if it's encrypted. But is this really private, I connect to Tor first, then there is a Lightning peer, which I'm not sure if it's random, or it's a predetermined one. And then Electrum server, which likewise, I'm not sure if it's randomized. [00:54:46] Super Testnet: Looking at that, I would say when you when you send a transaction using the setup you have there, you get good receiver privacy, because Lightning has better receiver privacy than Monero does. You have no amount privacy. Because even though you're constructing the transaction that you're sending across the Lightning Network, the way that the Phoenix project in particular works, you send your Lightning transaction to Phoenix, the entire thing, you don't do shards, like like a node does, you send the entire thing to Phoenix, and then you say, please find a route to, to the recipients node. [00:55:22] So you're not getting any amount privacy there, they know that you're not using shards, because they've designed the wallet so that you don't use shards. I'll take this opportunity to say Phoenix, you should implement multipath payments in like constructed by the sender, that would be good, because that would protect them protect more amount information. And then they don't know, if you're using Tor consistently on Phoenix, then I don't think they know your IP address, which is good for your sender privacy. I don't I imagine, however, that even if you are using Tor, there's probably the fingerprinting that they can do on your wallet. [00:56:01] I don't I don't know enough about how operating systems, if they have other ways of getting information to this to the provider of an app, other than the built-in network connection used inside the app. I imagine there's probably a backdoor that like Android or iOS can use to send information about you, even if you're using Tor inside the app, because the rest of your phone's not using Tor and your phone still knows you're using Phoenix. So there's I imagine there's a backdoor way for them to find out who you are, as the sender of that wallet, even when you're using Tor. [00:56:36] And so you're only get receiver privacy, if that's true. If they've designed the wallet in such a way that they don't have information about you, if you're using Tor, then you'd also have good sender privacy. So yes on the receiver privacy, zero amount privacy. I don't know on sender privacy. [00:56:53] Vlad Costea: On the Monero side, the equivalent is the view key, right? And this is their big talk. Just like there's talk about the xpub in the case of Bitcoin, Monero people talk about the view key. [00:57:09] Super Testnet: Okay, I don't... Do you want me to talk about my thoughts on view keys? [00:57:14] Vlad Costea: Well, what I want you to tell me is what can someone know by storing your view key? And what types of wallets do that? [00:57:23] Super Testnet: I don't know which types of wallets do that. A well designed wallet would not disclose your view key to your wallet provider or to anyone. It would keep it only visible to you. If someone has your view key, they can view all incoming transactions and view the amounts. [00:57:50] And well, and because Monero doesn't encrypt a sender, you'd also get the list of 16 possible senders, but it wouldn't say which one was the, was the real one. So you just know the amounts and you'd know the recipient. And you still get good sen... you still get decent sender privacy even if someone has your view key on Monero. [00:58:08] Vlad Costea: So basically, having someone's view key turns Monero into Bitcoin? [00:58:14] Super Testnet: I think well, I think there's an I think there's a caveat there. I believe there is some information. I forget what it is. I was looking up view keys once and I was really surprised to find out that they don't tell you everything. There's, there's some piece of information that... Oh, it's probably, it's probably the sender. It's probably just that they don't get the sender information. So no, it doesn't turn it into Bitcoin. Because in Bitcoin, unless you're using a CoinJoin, and you're using the base layer, you do get the sender every time. [00:58:40] Whereas with, well, and also, yeah, there's the caveats, but on Monero, you don't. So it doesn't turn it... So even if someone has your view key, it's still better than Bitcoin base layer for privacy. [00:58:51] Vlad Costea: I appreciate the honesty, the way that you're breaking down these, I really appreciate the nuances. There's also Inigo in the chat who says I see Lightning as something that has potential to be private theoretically, but with real world limitations, I really do not see how it can be achieved. I don't know what real-world limitations means. [00:59:12] Super Testnet: Well, it's I think, if I had to, if I wanted to say a similar sentence, I would say there's no plug and play solution for privacy on the Lightning Network. If you want to set up a private Lightning Network node and get decent privacy out of it, or if you want to use Lightning, rather, and get decent privacy out of it, you have to do things like download a node, set it up, configure it to use Tor, open channels, and manage your liquidity. And that's like five things. [00:59:44] And that then you'd, I think you'd have decent privacy in that case, as long as you didn't make any mistakes, like accidentally forgetting to use Tor one time, and then you just leak everything. And I think, so what he said was, because of real-world limitations, it's impossible to get good privacy on Lightning. I don't think it's impossible. And I don't, I don't think real... Those, you know, those are the five things you have to watch for. And I don't think it's an insurmountable task. So you can do it. [01:00:12] You can, you could have a really, you can have really good privacy on your Lightning node. Some Monero people that I argue with online say it's different with Monero. You can get really good privacy on Monero by just, you know, downloading Cake Wallet or downloading Monerujo. I don't think it's true. I don't think you get, well, you get decent privacy. I don't think you get as good a privacy as you get by setting it up on Lightning Network. In order to get decent privacy on Monero, I think you have to run your own node, as otherwise you're making remote procedure calls, and people can find out the IP address of the sender. [01:00:44] And you have to use Tor. I think I think you have to use Tor in order to use Monero privately, because although Dandelion helps, it doesn't protect you if you're if all the nodes you're connected to are Sybils, or even if most of them are Sybils. And we know from the videos released by Chainalysis and CipherTrace that they are both running, that chain analysis companies are running nodes and gathering IP addresses from users, they show it in their video. So in order to prevent that, in order to prevent them from getting your IP address, it's important that you use your own node, you're not using RPC calls, and you run, you use it over Tor, so that even if they, even if you do, even if they are Sybilling you, they don't get your real IP address, they only get your Tor address. [01:01:24] So that's two things like on Monero in order to have decent privacy, you have to run your own node and you have to use Tor. And as long as you're going through the trouble of doing that setup, why not do the Lightning setup and get better privacy? Like if you're if you need serious privacy, Lightning offers it in a better way than Monero does. Oh, and like with Lightning, you also have to make sure you never make a mistake. Like if you accidentally forget to do it on Tor sometime, that might be the time that they get you. [01:01:49] So yeah, it's just you have to be constant and vigilant about your privacy stuff. And there's just I don't think there's a plug and play solution for that. [01:01:56] Vlad Costea: Wait, who is they? Who did, you say that's where they... [01:02:02] Super Testnet: Oh, the Chainalysis. That's where Chainalysis gets you. [01:02:05] Vlad Costea: Okay, so that's the "they." [01:02:08] Super Testnet: Yeah, the "they" is Chainalysis and CipherTrace and other analytics companies. [01:02:12] Vlad Costea: I'm gonna put this article on the screen. It's the lowest hanging fruit, right? It's this article published in 2021. That's titled "Chainalysis Launches Support for Lightning Network as Layer 2 Payment Protocols Gain Popularity." And my question for you is, what can they know? And what can they see? What does the support really mean? [01:02:34] Super Testnet: Yeah, if you read the article, they tell you what they can what they what they're doing in there. And they're offering something called... Man, can you, can you send me the link in here so I can look it up? They say exactly what they know about this. [01:02:50] Vlad Costea: Can I send it to you on Telegram? Yes. Do you have it for desktop? Because I don't want to mess up what's on the screen. So, super. I did that a couple of times during the stream. I apologize. [01:03:03] And here I see the link. [01:03:10] For people watching, I put this on the screen, and we can basically read together. [01:03:17] There's the "What is the Lightning Network?" section. There is the "How popular is it?" section. [01:03:29] Super Testnet: Okay, so what they offer is a transaction monitoring solution for the Lightning Network. Specifically Chainalysis KYT. "They will be able to use KYT to monitor their Lightning Network transactions, screen for risky activity and gain valuable insights." So if you if you look up this term Chainalysis KYT, they define what that is on other parts of their website. And it's specifically OFAC compliance. So whenever an exchange is sending money to a user, like you're withdrawing your money from an exchange, they have to take the address you give and check whether that address is on the OFAC sanction list. [01:04:08] And they call this product, whereby you can send them the address and they will check if it's on the OFAC list for you. They call that Chainalysis KYT. So what they do what they can do with the Lightning Network is take the take the invoice that the that the person wants to withdraw with and get the pubkey from it and check if that pubkey is on the OFAC list. Also important to note, these public keys don't receive money. They're only used for communication. So it's even a silly thing that they do this. [01:04:41] But yeah, that's what they can do. It's not tracing the transaction. They're just checking if the pubkey listed in the Lightning invoice that you give them is on the OFAC list or not. It's a pass fail. So that's that's what they say. That's why they [unclear: need] to say that the exchange is able to monitor their transactions, not the user's transactions. They don't know where the where the funds are coming from on the Lightning Network. They don't, they aren't able to trace Lightning [unclear: payments] and don't plan to be able to. [01:05:10] They can only give a pass fail when the exchange is sending out a transaction to a Lightning invoice and say is the pubkey listed in this in this invoice on the OFAC list. So that's what they're doing. [01:05:24] Vlad Costea: I think it was useful to ask because I guess someone from the chat is going to ask this anyway and put the link and say, gotcha, you know, Chainalysis is on this, so they must know much more than you're saying. [01:05:38] Super Testnet: I have a gotcha, which is if you go if you go the reverse direction and say, what does Chainalysis know about Monero in the video that I mentioned earlier and that we're going to put in the show notes. Actually, I will send you the link right now so that I don't forget. In this video, they specifically say at the end, you should not use our tool on your own. You should hire us. You should hire us to run the tool for you. We will do the Monero tracing for you and we will find out where the where the funds came from and where they were sent. [01:06:06] So here's the here's the link to the video. It's in the last 30 seconds that he does this in case you want to play it. But Monero, or, Chainalysis actively advertises that they have a Monero tracing tool that can identify the source of funds and where they flow on the network. They don't offer that for the Lightning Network. They just say we only offer Chainalysis KYT and that's know your transaction, not know your customer's transaction. [unclear: All it does is say], is there a pubkey on the OFAC list or not? That's not tracing the transaction. [01:06:39] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I guess I'm going to put this in the description. Everyone can watch this and everyone should watch this because you get to understand how they operate. I guess the reason why they wanted this to get removed and they did not want this to be publicly available and someone leaked it is that it reveals the way that they approach it and the way that they think about it. It's sort of a paper tiger in some regards, like I think it was overblown when it came out. People said, ha, you know, they know how to de-anonymize Monero transactions. [01:07:12] But there's also there's always this caveat of the user input error when they're sending a transaction and they're using the wrong tool or they're making some mistakes. [01:07:24] Super Testnet: Yeah, that, the... So what I find really interesting in the, in the... From about like 30 minutes onward, he shows their block explorer. He shows the block explorer that they use. It's like a custom Monero block explorer they've made with information gathered from like FixedFloat and MorphToken and ChangeNOW and other exchanges that cooperate with Chainalysis. They give them information about their transactions and then they can filter those out when they're used as decoys. They can say, they used the user transaction that we know came from ChangeNOW as a decoy. [01:07:58] And so we can ask ChangeNOW. Did you make this transaction? And if they say no, then we know that's a decoy and they can eliminate it. So they have all this information that's like off chain data that they use to eliminate decoys from Monero transactions. But using that data, it's incredible how much information they get. They go clicking around and they're like, okay, so the guy starts at this transaction started at I think it was MorphToken. MorphToken sent it to his Monero address, we can identify the change that went back to MorphToken because they told us this is our address. [01:08:27] We can identify the real recipient right here. Then we watch for him to show up in the next transaction. So he clicks the address and it shows up in the list of all the transactions that it's been seen in on Monero. And he's like, okay, so we can see from here it showed up as a decoy and all these things, but they were able to identify that it was a decoy using their off chain information. And he's like, okay, so here's the real transaction where he actually sent it and he sent it into. [01:08:53] He goes through a list, it's like he sent it to this place, or he sent some of it to this place, and then this is the change. He keeps sticking to the change. Eventually, the person sent it to a wallet, I assume a phone wallet. And the reason I assume that is because the last transaction that he shows in this video is one that used a remote procedure call. It used a remote procedure call and the guy wasn't using a VPN, to contact a Chainalysis node. And he sent it to I think it was a merchant, he sent money to some merchant, probably like Bitrefill, or I don't know if they take Monero, some merchant that does Monero things. [01:09:28] And he said, okay, so he sent the money to this merchant, to this merchant. And we were able to trace the transaction from MorphToken all the way to here. But when he made this transaction, he used he used like he used the remote procedure call, and he didn't use a VPN. So we knew his IP address. And we could trace that all the way back to where he got the money from. So, where he bought the Monero. So it's really impressive, like they actually do a full trace of a transaction, showing all the steps they do and how they eliminate the decoys. [01:09:56] Yeah, it's like people will say it's overblown, they can't really trace Monero. But if you watch the video, they trace Monero. That's what they do. And then he advertised, like, so if you want to do this, don't just buy the, don't just buy our block explorer, hire us, because we know how, we're the experts, we have all the off chain data, and we know how to actually do it. So yeah, you could, they can, they can and do and advertise that they trace Monero, but they don't do it for Lightning. They don't, they don't even advertise that they can trace Lightning. [01:10:23] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's interesting. But to me, it sounds a bit like the claims that they were making with Wasabi or Samourai CoinJoins, right? When it was mostly address reuse, that was the fault of the user, or sending to, you know, buying coins from exchanges, CoinJoining, and then sending to another exchange and then saying, you know, we can actually de-anonymize this, but they don't look at the part that actually adds privacy. They just look at the outputs and see where they go. [01:10:55] Super Testnet: The nice thing is, if if the guy was using the Lightning Network, instead of Monero, they wouldn't have a blockchain to look at, to start with, because the transactions are not published on the Lightning Network. So in order to get a transaction graph, they would have to subpoena every Lightning node that might have been in in the route of the guy who they're, you know, trying to find out about and say, you have to give us every information about every IP address that connected to you. [01:11:20] Great. If the guy's using Tor or a VPN, then just like with Monero, they wouldn't get any information from about that. But then the next thing is, they don't see the sender. So even if they get all of the logs from the from the from routing nodes, even if they were able to subpoena all of them and get all this information, they still wouldn't know the sender or the recipient because that's encrypted. It's not it doesn't show up in the routing nodes. So good luck Chainalysis. [01:11:45] Good luck trying to find him. On Monero, you've got a blockchain and you've got off chain data that you can use to eliminate decoys. You don't have that on Lightning. So do your best. But yeah, I think it would have been safer if he was using Lightning than if he used Monero. [01:12:00] Vlad Costea: That's very useful information. And I'm only saying this because I want to push myself to actually do it. So I'm gonna say it in public. I'm planning to do a conference about privacy here in Romania, later this year, maybe around Halloween. And I would love to see you on stage. I know that for you, maybe six months means a long time and you're gonna move on to something else. And you're gonna have maybe different ideas that you come up with. Because it's very hard to keep up with what you're doing. [01:12:27] But I would love to host you to have you on stage to talk about this stuff and reveal what you can do with the Lightning Network. What are the limitations of it? What you can do with Monero? Maybe you're gonna have time to look into Zcash. [01:12:42] Super Testnet: I'd love to. I'm in. Let's make it a thing. [01:12:45] Vlad Costea: So don't make plans for Halloween this year. I think that's a good time. I just need to find some sponsors or something. But speaking of sponsors, I have... [01:12:57] Super Testnet: Privacy in the Dark conference. I don't know, something like that. Some Halloween theme. [01:13:01] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that can be cool. But I was also thinking, I mean, it's still in a very nascent phase. I don't know what it's gonna turn out to be. But I was also thinking of this approach where maybe you have privacy advocates on one stage that's live streamed and then blockchain analysis companies on the other stage on day one. And they do their presentations where they say, you know, we have good privacy, but wait, we can trace that. And then on the second day, you actually have panels and you get them to debate and you get this confrontation where maybe some people like that, maybe some don't. [01:13:34] I don't know. I have to ask around to see if there's any interest in this. But I haven't seen anything like this. Usually conferences are one sided. They are more bullish on something and they say, you know, our tool is great. You should use this and that. I don't know. Maybe I'm just weird and I should stick to what works as opposed to coming up with wacky ideas. [01:13:57] Super Testnet: Two things. Be careful doing it around Halloween, because that's also when there's a lot more spooks. And the other thing, second thing, if full-chain membership proofs get implemented on Monero, it's supposed to allow for something called, well, an easier way to do something called transaction chaining. And from the Monero people I've talked to, it'll be a lot easier to build a payment channel network on Monero once they have that. So I'd really like to see, you know, hopefully we'll have, you know, they say that like this year we might, it might be the year we get, the Monero people get full chain membership proofs. [01:14:36] I hope so. And then somebody start working on making a payment channel network. Wouldn't it be cool to compare the Monero payment channel network with the Bitcoin payment channel network and see which one has better privacy? [01:14:46] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that should be fun. I guess we could also get full-chain membership proofs in Bitcoin. But I don't think there's going to be consensus for this, because I remember I was at MoneroTopia last year in November in Mexico, and they were explaining the trade off saying that it's going to be even less scalable with full chain membership proofs and transaction fees are going to go up. So people should expect to pay more for their privacy. But the consensus within that community is that privacy is most important, so they don't care about anything else. [01:15:21] Super Testnet: Great. And could we get full-chain membership proofs in Bitcoin? Does encrypting the sender count, in your opinion? [01:15:31] Vlad Costea: Well, that would be very nice, at least in relation to the miners, because they should not be able to see what's in the transaction. You're going to eliminate the situation where they can censor, or they can do whatever people describe as MEV. [01:15:48] Super Testnet: I don't know that it's the exact same thing to say I encrypted the sender and therefore it's a full chain membership proof. In fact, I think that's definitely not true. But I think they have the same effect, which is if you have an encrypted blob, anybody on the network could have created that blob. So if that's just as good as full chain membership proofs, then remember, on Lightning, we do encrypt the sender. So do we already have full chain membership proofs in Bitcoin? I look forward to... I hereby ask Luke Parker to please write an article saying why they're different. [01:16:21] Vlad Costea: There's [unclear: Arthur Pugh] in the chat and he said, "Did I miss discussion of $140 billion USDT coming to Lightning? Thanks for a fascinating guest." Is that coming to Lightning? I think it was called Taro at one point, or Taproot Assets. [01:16:39] Super Testnet: I'm not familiar. Did he say $140 billion dollars? [unclear: That's a specific number.] It's not dollars, it's USDT. Well, yeah, USDT, Lightning. I'm going to Google that, see if I can find anything. I see that one hour ago, CoinDesk published an article saying that it's, saying it's happening. So that's news to me. Well, I think stablecoins are dumb. So I don't recommend using them. They are tied to a currency that inherently goes down in value, like it's designed to. But yeah, do your own research and make your own decisions. [01:17:17] Vlad Costea: Yeah, think about all of this cool cypherpunk tech that we built just to be able to transact dollars. It's disappointing. [01:17:30] Super Testnet: It is. It is disappointing. But the sad thing is, I think by volume, Tether, not Bitcoin, but Tether does the most volume in all of cryptocurrency. Um... And that's sad, you know, it's sad. But somehow, what I want to do, part of my mission is to find all these people who love Tether and persuade them that Bitcoin is better than Tether. So, yeah, that's all you can do, is say, well, here's why I think Bitcoin is better. [01:18:05] Vlad Costea: We have a question in the chat about Monero. How do nodes validate a transaction if they cannot see anything? [01:18:14] Super Testnet: Well, they can see some stuff. The only thing that's actually encrypted in a Monero transaction is the amount. The sender list is obfuscation, not encryption. And the recipient is, well, it's just a pubkey. So it's not encrypted at all. Yeah, so it's a one time pubkey, or they call it one time, even though it shows up again as a sender later. Yeah, so what can they know, they can validate that information, they can validate that, that stuff is true. So the only thing they have to validate that's like hard to validate is, is the encrypted part, which is the amount, by the way, remember, not the full amount, they leave the fee unencrypted. [01:18:52] And for that, they have something called zero knowledge proofs. And you'd have to get Luke, or someone who actually knows how zero-knowledge proofs on there work, to explain how they work. But it has something to do with, there's like a formula in mathematics, where you can where you can prove that the sum of all x's is equal to this, the, I don't know what the opposite of sum is that if you add together all the negatives, and you get a large negative number, that large negative number, you can prove that it cancels out with the large positive number from the sum of all inputs. [01:19:23] And that's, that's how they use that algorithm. But the cool thing is that it in doing so, you don't reveal the amounts, you just know that they sum to the correct value, which is supposed to be zero in Monero's case, you're supposed to prove that there are no extra amounts, like every all the amounts are all the amounts of the inputs are accounted for, even though you don't know what they are in the outputs. So that's something that's it has something to do with zero knowledge proofs. [01:19:49] And since I don't know how they work, I can't detail more than just saying it has something to do with this mathematical algorithm. [01:19:57] Vlad Costea: What do you think about these zero-knowledge rollups that are coming to Bitcoin, including shielded client side validation? That's something on which Robin Linus is working. And also it's Jonas from Blockstream and Liam Eagen. I've had all three of them to promote the paper at the time. And there's also the one by StarkWare. There's also, what else is there? The one by Alpen Labs. Do you think that they bring privacy? Or is it just about bringing Ethereum features to Bitcoin? [01:20:30] Super Testnet: The latter, but that, it's... So most of these people have connections with the BitVM stuff that I... And that's why I kind of have some familiarity with it. Because I, because I was... How do I restart? I want to restart that sentence. A lot of this, a lot of the companies who are building roll ups on Bitcoin have connections with the BitVM community. [01:20:57] And the I've always liked roll ups from when they first came out on Ethereum. I thought, this seems like a cool idea. I'm still impressed with roll ups. I think I think they're pretty cool. Most of them seem to have a bridge model, that are a federated bridge model, to get from Ethereum onto the rollup. And I don't think you need to do that on Ethereum. I think there's, I think there's better ways to do it. So I don't, I don't know why the ones... I imagine the ones that don't use a federated roll up are more expensive, and that's why they're less popular. [01:21:31] But roll up technology is I think it's cool. It's like you, all the, all these activities happening over on the sidechain, or on this rollup. And then you only post a small chunk of that data, a proof of what happened, onto the, on the base layer. I think that's great. So I want I want stuff like that for Bitcoin. And I'm glad that there are people trying to bring it over to Bitcoin. When I talk to these people... I think it would be really, not easy... [01:21:56] I think that we could have had a sidechain, a sidechain based on BitVM, about six months after BitVM came out. As soon as, like, within a couple of weeks after BitVM came out, somebody implemented SHA-256. And I think that's all you need to build a sidechain. I think you just, you just need to do SHA-256, then make a tree, a what's-it-called, a Merkle tree of all the people, of all the addresses that have money on this, on this sidechain. [01:22:23] And you post the proof of it on Bitcoin and use BitVM to validate that someone who's withdrawing really has a leaf in this tree. I think that's all you need to do. Like, it's just a SHA-256 and a Merkle tree. So I'm really surprised that we didn't have one six months after BitVM came out, because I think I could do that as a hackathon project and raise a million dollars, like I was talking about earlier. But that doesn't... So I've asked the BitVM teams, because there's like 15 people working on, 15 companies working on BitVM now, why they haven't done this, like done the easy thing and just make a sidechain using a Merkle tree and SHA-256. And all of them said the same thing. They said, because that's not what the investors want. The investors want Ethereum. They want us to have DeFi like Ethereum does. And if we just do a SHA-256 Merkle tree, it would only be useful for peer-to-peer payments, and not for, you know, escrows and whatever else they're doing in DeFi land. And so I'm just like upset with the whole BitVM ecosystem, because they're, they're, instead of doing what I think is the cool thing, which is just make something that scales Bitcoin better, and, and do it... [01:23:29] They're going after this whole Ethereum stuff, which I think is pointless and, and unnecessary. And sad, all these smart people chasing Ethereum. Yeah, I don't know what to say other than that. [01:23:45] Vlad Costea: Well, there are people calling this a Trojan horse, just like they call USDT a Trojan horse, and supposedly the T in USDT stands for the Trojan horse. Or at least that's what they tell themselves when they look in the mirror. [01:24:00] Super Testnet: Yeah, I, yeah, it's, I don't know, it's really weird. It's how much flexibility in Bitcoin scripting was unlocked by Taproot, and I don't think anybody at the time knew that you could do this stuff with Taproot. Yeah, once BitVM came out, I think the door was pretty much knocked open, and you can do anything on Bitcoin that you can do on any other chain, because you can emulate any other chain on Bitcoin, which is what these rollup teams are doing. They're emulating Ethereum. So yeah, it's kind of stupid that that's the one they chose to go for. Of all the blockchains, why Ethereum? And the answer is, well, that's what the investors wanted. That's where the money is. [01:24:42] Vlad Costea: Well, there's a bit more to that, because there is sort of, I mean, I remember for the last eight years that there were attempts to build a better Ethereum. It's just that this one has most applications, most contracts, most developers, and it's just easy to port applications. You don't have to reinvent the wheel, even though the wheel is broken. [01:25:03] Super Testnet: Well, I do like Tornado Cash. So there's, there's a few contracts on Ethereum that I find really interesting. And one of them is Tornado Cash. So if these BitVM teams succeed at making an Ethereum clone that, you know, settles on Bitcoin, at least I will take comfort in the fact that I can, that we have, that we have Tornado Cash now on Bitcoin. So that would be good, or at least that settles to Bitcoin. [01:25:30] Vlad Costea: How is Tornado Cash different from a CoinJoin? [01:25:34] Super Testnet: Well, it's a pool model. So in a CoinJoin, you're using a transaction model where you have, you know, let's say, 15 people decide to do a CoinJoin together. They make a single transaction where they list all the outputs they want, and they randomize them, and that's great. You get one private transaction. In a pool model, you deposit coins into the pool, and you can leave them there. Like, they just sit there in a Bitcoin or in an Ethereum address for however long you're in the pool for. And when you decide to leave, or when you decide to make a transaction, you just deduct from your balance in the pool. [01:26:09] But the advantage of this is only you know what your balance in the pool is. You have to prove, using zero-knowledge proofs, like how Monero does for the amounts, you have to prove that you have a balance in this pool, and that the amount you're sending out is less than your current balance. But that's all you get. You don't prove which person in the pool you are. And so that's great. Like, it's really wonderful. It's like a constant CoinJoin. And it's also non-interactive, is the other thing. In a CoinJoin, if you want to do a constant CoinJoin, you can, by just doing it in every block. You can join a CoinJoin in every block, but it costs money. [01:26:48] And it's interactive, you have to keep a server or some wallet running on your desktop that's constantly joining these CoinJoins. With Tornado Cash, it's non-interactive, you put your money into the pool, you turn off your device, you can even do it on a phone, you walk away, you come back a month later, just open it up, and your money's still there. Because it can't be spent unless you have the proof, and only you have the proof. So then you then you withdraw. Well, it's technically a withdrawal whenever you spend. [01:27:15] But you just you just send it to wherever you want to send it. And it works. So I really like that model. And some of, some of my reasons... If you, if you guys want to look into this, search my Twitter profile. I've come, I've recently come up with a way to do a coin pool on Bitcoin. That has a lot of the same properties as Tornado Cash. So look into that I'm hoping to release a demo video soon. And I'm also going over how to make it at bitcoin++ Floripa. [01:27:42] So if you go to btcplusplus.dev, the word plus is spelled out, B-T-C-P-L-U-S-P-L-U-S dot dev, you can go to, even register for the conference in Floripa, Brazil, where I will show how to do a coin pool on Bitcoin, because I figured out how to do it. And it's not as good as Tornado Cash, but it's still got a lot of cool privacy properties. You should check it out. [01:28:09] Vlad Costea: Now I just became excited about btc++. I might come, I don't know. It depends on whether or not my girlfriend gets a visa. It's more difficult for her, but we'll see. [01:28:21] Super Testnet: Oh, yeah. Cool. Cool. Yeah, I look forward to possibly seeing you there. [01:28:27] Vlad Costea: I got invited by Lisa to moderate something. I'm not sure exactly what, but that could be fun. [01:28:35] Super Testnet: Did that answer your question, though? You said, how is, how is Tornado Cash different from a CoinJoin? [01:28:41] Vlad Costea: Yes. Okay, so it's non-interactive. You can switch it off. You just put your money in a pool. And I think that's really cool. [01:28:50] Super Testnet: Yeah, me too. So if these BitVM people get us that, I'll be happy, even though I won't be happy that they had to implement all of Ethereum to do it. [01:29:03] Vlad Costea: I like you so much. No homo. Anyway. [01:29:09] Super Testnet: I like you too. Slight homo. No, I'm just kidding. [01:29:13] Vlad Costea: I'm going to put the, what's it called? The [unclear: Shop Freely] one? Shopstr. The Shopstr window on the screen, because you're going to present what's happening here. There are some listings. This is sort of a darknet market, right? And there's stuff that's being sold for Bitcoin. [01:29:33] Super Testnet: There's stuff that's being sold for Bitcoin. So what this is, are you familiar with, of course you're familiar with Nostr. You announced this podcast on Nostr. Nostr came out, I don't know, four years ago or something, three years ago. And one of the specifications that was quickly created for making posts on Nostr was classified ads. So if you go to, if, if anyone's a developer and you search for Nostr Implementation Possibility 99, or NIP-99, it's classified ads. And anyone can post to Nostr relays, you know, a listing of something that they have for sale. [01:30:09] And you give it a title, you give it a picture, you give it a price. And this website, this Shopstr website, just on, on Tor, it pulls down this data from a bunch of Nostr relays, five Nostr relays, and then displays it in a pretty fashion. And payments are made using the Lightning Network. So that's been not quite baked into Nostr, but very closely, most of the early Nostr developers, including the creator of Nostr, were also Lightning developers. There's like a lot of coworking that happened there. And a lot of the stuff that happens on Nostr is using Lightning Network, including these classified ads. [01:30:49] So that's why this particular DNM, all it, all it is doing is just pulling classified ads from Nostr and then displaying them and giving you a button for having items in your cart and purchasing them. But yeah, to me, it qualifies as a darknet market. And if you scroll a little while, you can also see people, some prior examples that I've given of this, people will say it's not a darknet market unless there's drugs on it. And I think that's stupid, because there's a lot of stuff on darknet markets, not just drugs. [01:31:19] But yeah, some people are on Shopstr selling drugs, which is a thing. Don't do drugs. But yeah, they're doing it. So there is a darknet market that has drugs, and it uses the Lightning Network for payments. And this is it. This is the one that I know of. [01:31:38] Vlad Costea: Oh, you can buy hardware wallets, but I would never buy a hardware wallet from these guys. I saw that there's a banana art. There's an Atari 2600 with a controller that looks tempting. [01:31:52] Super Testnet: Yeah, another thing to be aware of, there's no escrow on these things. You just send the money directly, effectively. It's not the same as a zap, but it's similar to zaps. They have their own way of doing Lightning payments. But it goes directly to the recipient. There's no custodian. Well, actually, most of them are using an ecash mint. But yeah, it depends on which mint you're using, because you can run your own mint. Most, I assume most of this stuff is custodied, but the custodial services that are using it do not offer escrow services. [01:32:28] And consequently, if you buy a banana taped to a wall, and then you send him the money, and he doesn't send you a banana taped to a wall, all you can do is leave him a bad review. You don't get your money back. So be aware of that. Oh, I found the one, I found the listing that has drugs. I will post it in your Telegram so you can see. [01:32:51] Vlad Costea: Under which category is it? [01:32:53] Super Testnet: I don't know, let me check. I just scrolled until I found it. [01:32:58] Vlad Costea: How do you see the categories? [01:33:03] Super Testnet: The listing page doesn't show what categories it has. I could probably find out. Let me look it up by means of... Maybe it's miscellaneous. It could be. I think the categories are in the listing from Nostr, so I could look it up that way. But I'll have to refresh the page and get all listings that mention this. Okay, got that. Here's the response. [01:33:31] Vlad Costea: Okay, take that back. This is a lot like XMR Bazaar. [01:33:35] Super Testnet: There you go. He's learning, he's learning stuff. No, I'm not... Maybe I can get it from another relay. I would have to look into it to find out what category it's under, but I just sent you the link. [01:33:50] Vlad Costea: No, it's fine. I pasted the link, it's just that Tor is being Tor. I need to search for a new circuit. Make it load. Come on. I believe in you. It's just not loading. [01:34:13] Vlad Costea: Well... Can you tell me what it's called and I can search for it? [01:34:17] Super Testnet: Yeah, I... or I could a second ago. I think it... It had the word hash in it. I don't know, I saw it for like three seconds. [unclear: Chocolate hash rounds by Colin CZ]. They look like Reese's Pieces, and apparently they had marijuana in them. So, that's a thing. [01:34:38] Vlad Costea: I don't know. I'm on a diet. You seem to be going to the gym too. [01:34:44] Super Testnet: Yeah, and I also don't do drugs, so... [01:34:49] Vlad Costea: Me neither. [01:34:51] Super Testnet: There's a guy selling homemade piccalilli, and I had to look it up because I was like, that's probably a drug. And no, it's not. It's just a [unclear: plant]. [01:34:59] Vlad Costea: But this guy is also selling his Canon camera. [01:35:05] Super Testnet: There you go. So, yeah, it's like XMR Bazaar, but it's on Tor. Well, this instance is on Tor. There's another instance that's not on Tor, so you can also browse it on clearnet. It's also built into Amethyst. If you have the Amethyst app on Android, it also displays classified ads from across the Nostrverse. So, you can do that too. [01:35:31] Vlad Costea: So, Shopstr. Check it out. It's pretty cool. You can find Google Pixel phones, a Kindle Paperwhite 1 for 50 euro. Not bad. [01:35:42] Super Testnet: I'm thinking about making something to show off how you can use Lightning on darknet markets, but my darknet market would only sell Bibles. So, I was going to call it Harknet Market, because the angels in the Bible always say hark. They say hark? Yeah, it means listen in old English. It's like, listen, then they say something. Hark. [01:36:09] Vlad Costea: [unclear: You can buy an] iPhone 15 Pro Max with 1 million satoshis from Spain. How much is that in today's money? It's like $1,000? [01:36:20] Does it look worth $1,000 to you? Not really. Maybe I would pay $800, but I'm not sure when the listing was made and what the price was. That's part of the problem when you denominate in Bitcoin. It becomes more expensive and gets out of control. [01:36:40] Super Testnet: You can always just... You can edit your listings. These are all replaceable Nostr events, so you can edit it, change the price, and then repost it. You can also denominate in US dollars on Shopstr listings or in any other currency. [01:36:55] Vlad Costea: But I think I met the Shopstr guys in Nashville. They had a booth. It's just that I was ignorant. I did not realize it. For some reason it just went over my head. I actually won something in the raffle. Wait, I think I have it here. [01:37:13] Super Testnet: I convinced the Shopstr guys to make a significant privacy improvement, which is, originally on Shopstr, you had to sign in in order to buy stuff. Cool, a Flipper Zero. You want to tell us about your Flipper Zero? [01:37:26] Vlad Costea: I've never used it really, but I do have it. There you go. And I think it's illegal in some countries. I don't know about that. I just got it from their contest. [01:37:42] Super Testnet: So originally on Shopstr, you had to sign in in order to buy stuff. So if you clicked buy now or you added something to your cart, it would be like, you have to log in to do that behavior. And that's stupid. And I told them, why do you make the buyer log in? All he's going to do is send a message to the seller containing where to send the item and his money. You could just spin up a public key for him, you know, in the background and send the message using that public key. [01:38:11] And then he wouldn't have to give away his real identity or his, you know, Nostr identity to use to use the shop. And so they implemented that. And a few months later, Shopstr came out again. Now you don't need to sign in in order to buy stuff, which I think is a big privacy improvement. So yay for privacy. [01:38:29] Vlad Costea: Yeah, there's a lot of cool stuff happening and I'm not even aware of it. Thank you for telling me about this. Oh, there's someone selling a Lambo. I think it has no price. It has no details. Just one picture. [01:38:44] Super Testnet: Don't trust, verify. He's probably not selling a Lambo. [01:38:50] Vlad Costea: And it's silver. Like, who would buy a silver Lambo? You got to buy it orange if you're going to spend Bitcoin on it, right? I mean, I don't think I'll ever get to the point where I'm like, oh, OK, let's buy Lambo. But who knows? [01:39:07] Super Testnet: I bought a Monte Carlo once. Does that count as getting to that point? [01:39:12] Vlad Costea: A what? A Monte Carlo? What's a Monte Carlo? [01:39:15] Super Testnet: It's a muscle car. It looks cool. [01:39:17] Vlad Costea: Oh, let me look that up. Monte Carlo car. Is it one word or two words? Oh, Chevrolet Monte Carlo. OK. [01:39:30] Super Testnet: Yeah, it's two words. So I got one of those once and I felt cool. I was like, I've got a cool looking car. [01:39:40] Vlad Costea: You don't find something like this in Europe. It's not environmental enough. And people don't like it. They don't import something like this. It was probably never sold here anyway. But it's named after a city there. Sure. I don't think Paris Hilton was born in Europe and she's named after a city, too. [01:40:02] Super Testnet: But you guys have, what's it called? Maseratis or whatever. The, the, the car that's made by the fancy Italian guy. [01:40:10] Vlad Costea: Ferrari. You guys have Ferrari and Pagani and even fancier stuff, and Lamborghini. [01:40:17] Super Testnet: Yeah, like you're saying you don't have, you don't... No one would import a fancy car. Well, you don't need to import them because you make them right there. [01:40:23] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but this is a Chevy. I think it's much more affordable than a Ferrari or Porsche. [01:40:30] Super Testnet: Well, it was very affordable. I can admit to that. I felt rich, though, because it looks cool. [01:40:38] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's a muscle car. So what was the gas mileage on this one? [01:40:44] Super Testnet: 22 miles per gallon. Well, but that's, I have to convert that to metric for you. MPG to what is it? KPM, I think, is what you guys... [01:40:52] Vlad Costea: Okay, let me... Liters per kilometer. [01:40:55] Super Testnet: Yeah. [01:40:56] Vlad Costea: Liters per 100 kilometers. That's how we measure. [01:41:01] Super Testnet: 10, 10.7 liters per 100. [01:41:05] Vlad Costea: 10.7. That's what the Internet tells me. I've seen much worse, honestly. I expected that, given that it's a muscle car to do like 15, 20. [01:41:20] Super Testnet: Yeah, well, it was a muscle car for mass adoption, so they throttled the engine speed on it. They put a six cylinder engine in there, and then if you revved it, it would just cap at a certain point. You couldn't rev past that. [01:41:34] Vlad Costea: Seems like you had a pretty wild youth, man. Did the girls like it? [01:41:41] Super Testnet: I never, I never asked. [01:41:43] Vlad Costea: You don't have to ask. You just know. [01:41:46] Super Testnet: Well, they didn't tell me then. [01:41:49] Vlad Costea: Oh, that's good. If there were at least girls and they never mentioned it, that's good. I got to mention two more sponsors and then I'll ask more questions about liking network and privacy. So check out NoOnes. They recently got hacked. That's a good way to introduce them. They lost some Solana from their bridge, and they're going to make the customers even. [01:42:19] And the message from them actually is to not keep your coins on exchanges unless you're planning to immediately exchange that. But what NoOnes is, is this peer-to-peer marketplace that is trying to empower people from what Ray Youssef, the CEO, calls the Global South. And I think they do that mostly with gift cards, because these are most liquid. It's what everyone wants. They're buying them. Everyone gets a cut. And if you want to participate in this economy, check out NoOnes. I think it also started out... [01:42:56] It's interesting because it started out as CivKit, which was built on Nostr. And now it's a standalone marketplace. [01:43:06] And there's also Hodling.ch, which is a service from Switzerland. They help you with self custody. If you have a lot of Bitcoin and have no idea how to manage it in order to avoid $5 wrench attacks, or you're part of a company that's planning to buy Bitcoin and you don't know how to manage the setup to have a quorum and maybe to avoid having an annoying CTO stealing everything. Then you can contact these guys and they're going to provide all the consultation and all of the good advice about how you can set up, whether or not you should be using hardware wallets, how you should use multisig and all of that. [01:43:45] So check out Hodling.ch. And recently they also added a service for coin recovery. So if you lost part of your seed phrase, they might be able to brute force that. Or if you give them some details, they might help you recover your coins. Of course, there's a cut that they're going to take for that. It will not be a free service, but I guess it's better than losing coins forever. So check out Hodling.ch. Anyway, let's talk about exciting Lightning stuff, because it seems like what's really news these days is that they're getting USDT on it. [01:44:21] I remember initially that Lightning was going to be this bridge across blockchains. It was going to enable atomic swaps. It was going to make exchanges obsolete. It was going to have much better privacy. What happened to that? [01:44:41] Super Testnet: It's well, it's not entirely false. There are two other, like, Rootstock uses it and so does Boltz Exchange, or I mean, so does Liquid. And you can use Boltz Exchange to swap between those places using the Lightning Network. So it is bridging between three different chains: Bitcoin, Liquid and Rootstock. So there's that. The other thing is it's going to kill exchanges. Well, I guess we're still in progress. There's two exchanges that use Lightning now, or I mean, two exchange killers that use Lightning, RoboSats and Bisq. So you can do your fiat on and off ramping through those and use the Lightning Network. [01:45:27] But I guess you're not like, even if I give you examples of the things you described being things, I think you're wondering why aren't they popular? Is that what you're wondering? [01:45:41] Vlad Costea: It's not just popularity, but also investing and building at least usable applications, you know, because it's still pretty complicated. And if it's not complicated, you have to use services like Boltz that take a cut. And that that was not the purpose of it. Right. It was supposed to be easy for you to swap assets. [01:46:05] Super Testnet: Yeah. Well, I think RoboSats is easy. So give that a try. You can swap assets using using RoboSats. And I think it's really easy. Bisq is, Bisq also has Lightning, but I don't think it's as easy. I have not had a successful Lightning trade on Bisq since they added it. But good on you for adding it, Bisq. Do it better, I guess. RoboSats got it figured out. Yeah, I don't I don't know. I guess I think that most people most people don't care about their privacy until they get burned. [01:46:46] And that's when they start caring. So I think that as long as it is easier to go on, you know, Kraken or Coinbase or whatever, and to get your bitcoins there, people aren't going to use the, the, the people aren't going to use private solutions if they're not as easy, except if they've been burned. Like the people who do are, you know, people who either got censored by an exchange somehow or, you know, they're like you and me, or me anyway, who just think it's cool. So I do it anyway. [01:47:18] Yeah, but there's just not many people like that. There's not many people who particularly care about their privacy. And, and so, you know, you don't see a lot of people going through extra hoops in order to do something privately. I don't know what to say about it other than it's sad. And I tried to change that by encouraging people to use the, to use stuff like, to use RoboSats specifically. [01:47:40] Vlad Costea: Yeah. I just want to mention this. I'm not sure if it's legally advisable or something, but when I sold my Bitcoin to buy the car, I decided to do it by the book. So I KYC'd to Kraken. I went through every step. I sold to my bank account. I reported to my bank account and now they want to shut down my account potentially. And they want information that I don't have, like where did I get the Bitcoin from? And this is a requirement that entered, part of an EU regulation. [01:48:13] That started this year. And when I bought the Bitcoin eight years ago, there was no such regulation. It's really stupid. And I didn't buy it from an exchange that's KYC. So I can't prove anything. I could, I could also mine it or get it as a gift or donation. It's very hard to prove anything, but I wanted to do everything by the book. But if I maintained my cypherpunk mindset and I just sold it on Bisq or I met someone on Vexl and I got a bag of money and then I went to the bank and deposited this to the bank and told them, you know, I'm a male prostitute. [01:48:50] I'm an OnlyFans model. I don't know. I sleep with your manager. [01:48:54] Super Testnet: [unclear: That's a good section of the video.] [01:48:56] Vlad Costea: Exactly. I, I sleep with your bank's manager. What can you do? I got paid hush money or something. They would be like, okay, fine. I would tell them, you know, I play poker with rich people. They would just shrug it off and say, yeah, that's fine. It doesn't matter. You can deposit into the bank. But since my transaction was associated with Kraken, they asked me all sorts of questions and also Kraken were assholes too. They asked me a lot of questions, which I'm not going to answer. [01:49:25] Just fuck them. Let, let them close my account. [01:49:31] Super Testnet: Yeah. I, do you need... If you, why would you deposit the... If you got a bag of money from Vexl, from someone on Vexl, why would you deposit it at the bank? Why not walk over directly to the guy who has the car and say, here's your $100,000 or whatever it is? [01:49:47] Vlad Costea: Because it was much more than the... Oh, you said $100,000. No, it was much cheaper than that. But in Romania, which is part of the European Union, we have a limit of 2,000 euro. So anything above 2,000 euro has to go through a bank. The guy, if he sees a bag of money, he would never accept that. He's going to ask me to go to a bank. [01:50:11] Super Testnet: I recommend finding a new country. That one sounds like it has terrible laws for financial privacy. [01:50:15] Vlad Costea: It does. It really does. Like if I want to buy a laptop that's more expensive than 2,000 euro... And I save every month for two years. Let's say I save 100 euro. For two years, that's 2,400. I still have to put that in a bank. If I want to buy what I want. [01:50:34] Super Testnet: Well, there's 180-some, there's like 205 countries, I think, at last count by the UN. So pick one of those and maybe one of the ones that doesn't make you do that. In the US, you can buy cars for cash. [01:50:48] Vlad Costea: You can also do that here if it's less than 2,000 euro. [01:50:52] Super Testnet: That sounded like I was saying go to the US. I don't think you should go to the US. The US has other laws that are really bad, but at least they can do that one. That's a thing. [01:51:01] Vlad Costea: I don't know how long this is going to last. It just feels like it became more intrusive. I mean, I'm a big fan of the open market of the European Union. I'm a big fan of countries collaborating. But at this point, just having these regulations that come from Brussels and they are not. I don't know. I'm not sure if they're justified. Maybe that they concern problems that they have in Brussels and they're out of touch with the reality somewhere else. It's really messed up. Like getting an email from my bank. [01:51:36] I've been their customer since I was 16 years old. And they said, you know, we want to check if you're participating in money laundering or terrorist financing. And I was like, really? You really let that part in when you sent me that email? Like, I don't know. It sucks. And I tried to do everything by the book and I tried to be as transparent as possible. And if I wasn't and I lied to them, it would be much better. And that's what is really ironic about the situation. [01:52:10] Super Testnet: Well, leaving is always an option. So that's my, that's my... If you wanted, if you asked for advice, which you didn't, I would tell you: leave. [01:52:25] Vlad Costea: How do you manage it? Like, there are legends about yourself that you live in a tent or something and you just travel around the world and never stay for longer than a week anywhere. [01:52:37] Super Testnet: Well, I did live in a tent for a year, I think, I lived in a tent for a year. But I'm not living in a tent now. I'm living at a hostel. And I've been in Guadalajara, Mexico since July, however many months that is. So off and on I travel, I go I still travel all over the place to frequent conferences and stuff. So I'm often gone for weeks at a time. But I keep going back to Guadalajara. And I really like it here. [01:53:02] So you should, you should come to Guadalajara. It's great. [01:53:06] Vlad Costea: I should learn Spanish. [01:53:08] Super Testnet: Yeah, I don't speak it very well either. But you can get by. [01:53:15] Vlad Costea: Coming back to the topic of Lightning, there's something I really wanted to ask you but forgot. You have lots of implementations, maybe not lots of them, maybe a handful, you have LND, which is the most popular, you have Core Lightning, which was supposed to be big, but it never took off. You have the one by ACINQ, that's called Eclair. And I think that one is being used by Phoenix. For the wallet, you have one by Electrum, which I think is remotely based on ACINQ's implementation. And you also have LDK, which is Lightning Development Kit. [01:53:50] And I'm not sure how used that one is. But are there any differences in them in terms of privacy? Because that's the topic that we are tackling in this episode. [01:54:02] Super Testnet: That's a good question. I've never thought about it, about different privacy implications of different ones. The only possibly useful thought I have on that is the guys from Mutiny Wallet were very focused on building a privacy first Lightning wallet. And they used LDK. So I don't know if they did that just because they're Rust developers. Actually, that's probably why they did is because they're Rust developers and it's written in Rust. But it might have been because they were like, this one's the best for privacy. I don't know, you have to ask them because I really, I don't know which one's the best for privacy. [01:54:40] I think of those, a different thing that is not your question at all is which one's the easiest to use. And I think it's Electrum. Because with Electrum, you go to electrum.org and click download, and you get something that looks like an application that you can use. And with the other ones, if you, they don't, they don't even have websites. You have to go to like their GitHubs to find the download link. Well, they have websites, but not where you can just download the software. And when you download it and get like a zip file, and you have to unzip it and then find the binaries and then know what to do with the binary. [01:55:11] So yeah, Electrum is the only one that is just like you, you double click the icon and a Lightning wallet pops up. And it's got a full implementation of the Lightning Network in there. So I really like that one. [01:55:23] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and ThomasV is so proud of it. [01:55:26] Super Testnet: I've met him a couple of times. You said you think it's based on ACINQ. I thought he wrote the entire thing in Python from scratch. Like, that's what I thought he was so proud... Why he's so proud of it is because he wrote the entire, you know, he followed, he implemented all the BOLT specs himself in Python, which is not even, not even... Like, that's, that's insane to do that. That's like the stuff I do with JavaScript, he's doing it with Python. [01:55:50] Vlad Costea: That's also possible. Maybe I don't know, maybe I misunderstood. I did interview him like three or four years ago about this. So that's what I remember from what he told me with trampoline routing and stuff like this. But maybe he wrote it from scratch. [01:56:08] Super Testnet: Yeah, I think his implementation and Eclair are the only ones that support... Well, I don't think that's true anymore. I was about to say that the only ones that support trampoline routing. But I Yeah, I think the other ones have added it now. I'd have to check. Sorry, I can't. Yeah, sorry. I don't know the answer to that. [01:56:28] Vlad Costea: No, it's all good. There's someone in the chat who's also asking something that I've been meaning to say. What about BOLT 12? Because this one has been a major talking point in the Lightning space. I remember, who was it, from Core Lightning, or at the time it was c-lightning, was blaming LND for not working on it. Rusty, yeah, I think it was Rusty. What about BOLT 12? It was supposed to give you much better privacy and also allow you to have multiple reusable, multiple-time reusable addresses or something. [01:57:08] Super Testnet: Yeah it definitely gives you a reusable address and that is pretty useful and I think, well, there's already been implementations of that before and they were really popular, and now this one's out and it's also having some popularity. That I think is the real kicker. I'm not sure that it really does improve your privacy all that much. So earlier, that, I think it was this year, early, or early... Very recently, within the last six months, I was at another conference and they had a hackathon and as part of a hackathon, I decided to make an atomic swap tool that would swap between a BOLT 11 payment and a BOLT 12 payment so that if your wallet didn't support BOLT 12, you could still do it. [01:57:49] One of the things that BOLT 12 is supposed to be really good at is hiding the recipient information. And when I looked into it, I was like, oh, great, then I shouldn't see a public key in there, because that's the only recipient information in a Lightning invoice, is your public key. But there is one. Like, I decoded a BOLT 12 invoice and there's, there's a pubkey in there, and I was like, huh, that's, that's strange. And in what sense is it hiding the recipient's information then? [01:58:13] Because if you still have a pubkey, then, you know, Chainalysis could still like plug that into their OFAC thing and do a pass-fail on whether it's on the OFAC list. And once again, the public key is only used for information, no money gets sent to it, it's only used for communication, no money gets sent to it. But the thing that they say when I like talk to people about this is it's not that it hides your pubkey, it's that it hides your network, network string. [01:58:41] So on the Lightning Network, you have a network string, which is either Tor or an IPv4 or an IPv6 address that specifies where your node is on the network. And they say if you use BOLT 12, then someone they can see your pubkey, but they don't know what node you're on on the network. But that's already true of BOLT 11 unless you're a routing node. If you're a routing node, then you then you're saying here I am on the network, come connect to me. But if you're not a routing node, you don't disclose your your nodes, your connection string anyway, even in your invoice. [01:59:10] So what exactly privacy benefit is there to BOLT 12? It's not... It still has a public key in there. And they say, well, it doesn't reveal your connection string, but you'd only reveal your connection string if you're a routing node anyway, in which case you're doing it, you're gossiping it, you're publishing it. So what... I don't understand the privacy gain anymore. Justin from ShockNet has been, he's one of the guys on Twitter I'm friends with, and he's been criticizing BOLT 12 for like making false claims for a long time, not BOLT 12, but the developers behind it for making false claims. [01:59:41] And I'm, I don't agree with him on all of this stuff about BOLT 12. But after after doing a hackathon project with it, I was like, I don't I don't really think it does improve your your recipient privacy on the Lightning Network. I think BOLT 11 has really good recipient privacy. And, and BOLT 12 is just it doesn't do it. It doesn't do what it says on the tin. So sorry, but it does... It does do the reusable thing, which is which is nice. I really like that aspect of it. [02:00:09] So it's nice to have a reusable string. [02:00:14] Vlad Costea: Let me ask you a few more personal questions. What do you work on these days? What keeps you busy? [02:00:21] Super Testnet: This month, I've been working on my coin pool implementation. And so that's that's what's been keeping me busy this month. What was it last month? I recently made something called Mint Market Cap, which is I wanted to find out how much money is on ecash mints, and they don't disclose that information. So what I did was I got, I got the top 25 from bitcoinmints.com. And then I queried each one for an invoice. And then I use their invoice to get their node public key. [02:00:57] And since these are routing nodes, I knew that they were advertising their their node on the on the network. So I looked up their node on the network, and found how much money they have in capacity. And then I made Mint Market Cap, which shows a list of all the amount of money that they have in total capacity. And then if you assume that the amount of money that they have is divided 50-50 between money on their side and money that's available for outgoing, then you can get an estimate of how much money is on ecash mints, which I thought was kind of neat because they don't disclose that but I figured out a way to get data. [02:01:35] It's probably not good data. Someone pointed out that a lot of the mints are using Strike and using phoenixd, the Phoenix implementation for desktops, as their back end. And so I'm including like hundreds of [unclear: Bitcoins] that are probably just used by Strike and phoenixd. And then they're not used for ecash. So the numbers are probably way off. But they are numbers. So I made that. Um, let me just go I can go to my GitHub repo and find out what I was working on last month. [02:02:06] I forget. I'm working on new projects all the time. So. So it changes. And now my internet's slow. Are you still able to hear me okay? [02:02:18] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I'm able to hear you. I guess there were some people who complained that maybe there were moments when the audio cuts out. I'm not, not sure about that. I did not experience it. [02:02:29] Super Testnet: Oh, I made something called Title Transfer App. So I did a lot of work on state chains recently or last month. And state chains are another really cool privacy tool in Bitcoin that I worked on. And I thought it would be cool if, in addition to using a state chain to transfer Bitcoin around, it would be cool if you could list any item that you have, like a banana, or I don't know, whatever this is, you could list this, you make a title for it. And you just say, I hereby certify that I have, you know, this thing. [02:03:03] And if I transfer this title to you, using a state chain, then you get the same chain of signatures that that a state chain gives for Bitcoin. Only this would be for a physical item or for a digital item. So I made Title Transfer App, so that you can just sell things using the same state chain model that I, that we, that some people use with Bitcoin. So that's that was a neat thing. I also came up with a way to I found a way to make it so that a state chain can't rob you. [02:03:31] Which is the current implementation of state chains, called Mercury Layer. And it's possible for them to [unclear: assist a prior]... If somebody sends you coins on a state chain, the state chain entity is responsible for preventing double spends or preventing the person from taking their money back. And if he's malicious, he can allow a double spend. But I figured out a way to make it so that even if he does that you still get you still get all your money out like you don't you don't get robbed. [02:03:57] And I call that insured state chains. So I wrote up a specification for it. And then I made a video at Adopting Bitcoin on how this protocol works. And I thought I would implement it. But then I think while I was working on the state chains thing, I figured out how to do a coin pool. Then I got distracted by that. And I've been working on that ever since. So I've left my insured state chain thing to do some other time. I've been doing a lot of stuff with Nostr Wallet Connect. [02:04:26] Nostr Wallet Connect is a protocol for communicating with wallets using the Nostr protocol. Or, yeah, it's a protocol for using another protocol. That's that's true. But yeah, it's it lets you basically DM your wallet, direct message your wallet or command and say like, send money to this person or receive money from that person. And it's nice because then you can have your phone, your wallet, in your pocket. And you don't have to pull it out, you just send it a command by hitting a button on your keyboard, and it'll it'll just do the thing. [02:04:55] So I've I made some tools, I made a couple of wallets that supported it. And I made like an interface and I made a testing tools, the developers can test their stuff against that. So that's what I was working on. Last month, I made something called Faucet Generator, I got mad about all these Bitcoin testnet faucets that keep on shutting down. They, they keep on like... Like, the Mempool recently launched one, but they put a rate, they put a requirement that you have to sign in with your GitHub account in order to get coins from their faucet, which I thought was stupid. [02:05:30] And a bunch of the other ones made it so that you can only withdraw like 2,000 sats from them, which is really difficult for a developer to do anything if he only has 2,000, you know, testnet sats. So I made my own faucet called Faucet Generator, where you can spin up a faucet that just has a normal send button and and a balance and a Bitcoin address for you to load it with. But the nice thing is you can generate them on the fly. So if you want to if you want to give someone their own testnet faucet, you can create one that's empty, and then send money from your faucet to theirs, and then just give them the link. [02:06:03] And now they've got a faucet with no rate limits, and no one else knows about it. So I made that that was kind of fun to make Faucet Generator. [02:06:13] What did I get? I made a test, I made my own testnet. I should have called it Super's Testnet, because there's a misnaming opportunity, but I just called it Testnet Launcher. So this I got mad at this one, because well, it's actually the same issue that led me to make the Faucet Generator, I couldn't get, I couldn't get testnet coins from the faucets. And I was like, well, I'll just make my own testnet. Where I could generate coins, just by clicking a button. And then and that and so I did, I made my own testnet that understands the rules of Bitcoin script. [02:06:45] And it uses the same transaction validity rules as Bitcoin. But you can just generate coins by clicking a button that generates 50 coins every time you click it. And so then you have no need for for faucet, you could you just you just make your own coins and and use my testnet. So there's that. Is that enough? I work on stuff all the time. And it's just, I'm constantly changing to new projects. So it's hard to say when you want me to stop. [02:07:11] Vlad Costea: I have no idea what enough even means in this context. Like there's a lot that you're doing. You're all over the place. I think state chains are super underrated. I did interview the guys from Mercury Layer a few times. And of course, most of the stuff that they said went over my head because I don't really understand how it works. But it's really cool. It's like this layer where you transfer UTXO ownership. [02:07:38] Super Testnet: You transfer the private key, which is a really strange idea. It sounds awful, but it's so magical. After, after I make, after I finish my coin pool implementation, I want to make a prediction market. And so I figured out a way to do a... I think I figured out a way to do a prediction market on Bitcoin. Some of my ideas, I have to, I have to implement them to see if they work. And this is, I think, I'm pretty sure this one will work, but it's pretty cool and it'll be really hard to build. But yeah, I think I figured out a way to do a prediction market similar to Predyx, or what's that one that's on Ethereum that everyone uses? [02:08:12] Vlad Costea: Polymarket? [02:08:13] Super Testnet: Polymarket. Yeah, I figured out a way to make something like Polymarket, but make it work on Bitcoin without needing a soft fork. And the only new trust assumption is the same one Polymarket has, which is that Oracle honesty. If the, if the oracle who says, you know, the Packers beat the Saints, lies, then you can lose money that way. [02:08:31] But that's the only new trust assumption added. Whereas other methods of adding prediction markets on Bitcoin, they usually have custody. So I figured out a way to do it without custody, unless you count the oracle as a kind of custodian, because you can just, you know, send the money to the wrong person. And that's kind of what a custodian does. Yeah, so that's something. But the reason I bring that up is because it relies on the fact that with a state chain, you can transfer ownership of a private key in a secure way. [02:09:01] And so what I do is I make it so that that private key is the recipient of coins that have not yet been sent, but they can be sent depending on the outcome of an oracle's, you know, thing. So that allows you to have to have coins that will be yours, if you win the if you win the, you know, the if you if you guess correctly on the prediction market, but because these coins aren't in the address yet, and it's a state chain address, you can transfer that before as long as it's before the event has occurred, you can transfer ownership of that private key to other people. [02:09:34] And thus sell your, you know, your rights to take away money if, if you got the, if you guessed correctly on the outcome of the event. So that's, that's a prediction market. So I want to make that and that uses state chains. I don't know, it's just so it's just so much to build. I mean, you want to see? Am I able to share my screen and you guys would actually see it on here? [02:09:52] Vlad Costea: You should be able to. [02:09:54] Super Testnet: Okay, I'm going to show you my list, my backlog of projects. [02:10:00] I get like five ideas a day. And some of them if they're if they're a good idea, I write them down. So let me show my screen. Can you see it? You see a document here? [02:10:11] Vlad Costea: I see it now. Just let me adjust for the live stream video. Because I basically cut your portrait [unclear: to show people]. Okay, so this is like a Google Doc. [02:10:27] Super Testnet: It's a Google Doc I have called project ideas or to do list. And it is eight pages of different ideas I've had. For Bitcoin and software that I can make. And you know, each of these things someday, that one's a really long idea. You know, some one day I will make each of these things. We'll see but I get I get ideas much faster than I can create them. So I'm up to 49 ideas in my backlog right now. And just it's just a constant flood of ideas. [02:11:00] So yeah, I'm always moving on to new projects. [02:11:04] Vlad Costea: Well, that's a good problem to have. [02:11:06] Super Testnet: Yeah, I love it. I wouldn't have it any other way. [02:11:09] Vlad Costea: I know a bunch of guys in the space who are riffing on the same idea for almost a decade. And it's getting stale. It's getting boring. So it's, it's really refreshing to have people like you always come up with something new and different, not necessarily new, but different. Like, I'm pretty sure Paul Sztorc, he has been the guy who tried to bring prediction markets to Bitcoin for longer than a decade. [02:11:40] I'm not sure exactly why he hasn't, but I'm pretty sure he would be interested to hear your idea. [02:11:46] Super Testnet: Yeah, I think he wanted... He wanted, he wanted to build drivechains so that he could build a prediction market. And I don't think he thinks that I suspect if I shared my idea with him of doing it with the state chain. He would I think he would be like, this is stupid. If you don't, he would probably say if you're not paying miners to run this project for you, then miners will kill it. They will they will refuse to mine the transactions or something. And then that's why we need to do it on drivechains. [02:12:19] That's what I suspect Paul would say if I if I told him about my idea. Just be like, well, if it doesn't pay miners, it's a dumb idea. [02:12:25] Vlad Costea: Well, I hope he listens. And he's gonna give you feedback. I was also going to ask you about your music career because there is something related to that going on. You have a handful of songs that I've listened to. I think my favorite is your cover of La Bamba, but adapted to the Bitcoin context. You changed the... [02:12:45] Super Testnet: That one's your favorite? That was my first one. And I was just lying in bed one day. And I thought of I thought I was I think I was listening to the song. And I was like, oh, that'd be funny if I changed it to Bitcoin. So I'm just sitting in my bed, I just put my earphones up to my mouth and started singing and I recorded myself and released it as a song as a single. And that launched my music career, which currently spans five, I think, five songs. [02:13:11] And one concert, I did a concert in Brazil. At, what, SatsConf. So that was fun. Yeah. Perhaps more will come. But I've been so I've been so focused on coding lately. I haven't even... Well, I have thought of a couple new songs. Maybe I should record those. I thought of "Lightning Network killed Monero's use case. Lightning Network killed Monero's use case. Encryption on the monetary base." And then I would do, you know, I only came up with that part, but I need to write lyrics for all the all the verses. [02:13:51] That would be fun. [02:13:53] Vlad Costea: I think it sounds better if it's "Lightning has killed Monero's use case," because it has the same cadence. You know? If you say "Lightning Network killed it," it's too much, too many syllables. [02:14:05] Super Testnet: It is too many syllables, but I don't... Putting it in the perfect tense there is also strange to my ears. I don't know. It certainly needs workshopping. So I only have those those two lines. But but yeah, I sang that for some of the guys at the co-working space here and they thought it was hilarious. [02:14:30] Vlad Costea: So where can people find you over the next few months? Which conferences are you attending? What are you going to speak about? [02:14:37] Super Testnet: Well, I'm going to bitcoin++ Floripa, and I will be talking there about my coin pool implementation. I'm hoping to do a demo of it of the software, and then an explanation of how it works. And then we'll do a live coding session where we'll actually make the core functionality together. And I'm hoping wallet developers will come and learn how to do this, so we can integrate coin pools into Bitcoin wallets. So they offer a number of advantages over, including over the Lightning Network. They're faster. A coin pool is faster than the Lightning Network because you don't have any routing. [02:15:11] You don't have to do pathfinding on a coin pool. It's cheaper because inside the pool, all transactions are free. Whereas on Lightning fees are low, but they you they're still there. And so the coin pool you can have absolutely free transactions. Yeah, it's also, I... Mine is asynchronous. So you can you can send coins to somebody without needing them to give you something first. So in Bitcoin, normally someone has to give you their Bitcoin address, or they have to give you a Lightning invoice for you to send them money. On mine, you create, like, a packet of money for them, and you send it to them. [02:15:45] And then they can redeem it on this coin pool, which is great. I really that's my favorite thing about it is the asynchronicity. So that, that's what I'm going to be talking about there. And I will explain how that works, doing the demo, and then we'll do a live coding session. The next one that I'm supposed to be at is in May. And I have not confirmed my attendance at it yet. But there are two conferences that want me to go to them in May. One of them is called Bitcoin 2025. [02:16:14] And it's in Las Vegas. And the other one is in Austin, Texas, and it's a bitcoin++. So I'll probably go to both of them. But I haven't yet confirmed my attendance. I don't know the rest of the ones I'll be going to. There's one in Argentina that I'd like to go to. [02:16:31] Vlad Costea: I would like to go to SatsConf again, my favorite. LaBitConf in Argentina, or something else? [02:16:36] Super Testnet: Well, I want to go to that too, but there, there is another... There's supposed to be another one. The guy, the guy who started LaBitConf wants to do another one now, at least he told me he did, because he said that he was upset that LaBitConf now does other altcoins. It's like Bitcoin plus a bunch of other stuff. So he wants to make a new conference that is once again Bitcoin only. And I think, like, it's easier to do that now. [02:17:03] Maybe for, like, for a few years there, it was really hard to be Bitcoin only, but now it's easier again. So he wants to do that. And he invited me to be a speaker at that. But I haven't heard anything else. And I think he said it was going to be in April. So I think I would know something by now. Yeah, so that might not happen. That's as far out as I've planned. And I haven't even finished finalizing my plans for May. I don't like to plan more than three months in advance. [02:17:26] So that's why I haven't confirmed my attendance for those May conferences yet, because I want to wait till February. [02:17:33] Vlad Costea: When you travel to so many conferences and you have commitments to do presentations, and I guess you also try to open some sort of school where you're teaching some basic stuff about how to use Bitcoin from the command line and construct transactions and stuff. When do you have time to actually do work when you have all of these other commitments? [02:17:56] Super Testnet: Well, I haven't done the workshops since November. I stopped in December because of holidays, and then I just haven't restarted again. So that has taken one load of work off the table. And as for the conferences, I'm almost always doing a workshop at a conference. And so it's still work. Like for me to prepare for the conference, I have to make the software that I'm going to present. And so it's still work. [unclear: Yeah, it facilitates.] Rarely do I have a deadline on my projects. The only time I have a deadline is when I have something that I'm supposed to present at a conference. [02:18:31] And that's, that's nice. There are benefits to having deadlines. Like they motivate you to get work done, even when you don't want to work on it. Which is hard for me, because normally, I just do whatever I want. And if I don't want to work on something, I'm just like, nah, I'm not going to do it. But if I told someone I will do this for your, for your conference, then I kind of feel more obligated. [02:18:52] Vlad Costea: Oh, you, you still have a lot of energy, which I admire. Like, the cadence with which you speak and the enthusiasm, they speak for themselves. [02:19:01] Super Testnet: Thank you. [02:19:02] Vlad Costea: And you lost some weight. Congratulations on that. [02:19:05] Super Testnet: Thank you. I'm glad you noticed. I've been going to the gym daily since December 30, doing two hours swimming. And I cut down my calorie intake to 1300 a day, and it's having an effect. Check it out. Check it out. I'm thinner than I was. Not thin yet, but I'm thinner. So it's coming along. [02:19:26] Vlad Costea: Yeah. It's good to see how many people in Bitcoin are improving their lives, even in small ways, you know, because it's so easy to forget about yourself and just focus on work. I've actually gained weight since the last time, but I'm not sure if it's fat or muscle, because I go to the gym, but I don't do cardio. So yeah. Anyway... [02:19:46] Super Testnet: Swimming counts as cardio, right? [02:19:48] Vlad Costea: What counts as cardio? Swimming? [02:19:50] Super Testnet: Swimming. Yeah. It's a pretty good workout. [02:19:52] Vlad Costea: I should try that. It's just that it's winter here, so it's not very nice, especially when you have long hair, but that's long hair people problems. [02:20:07] I feel sorry for asking you this so late into the episode, but I've turned this into sort of a habit. Maybe I'll just make a compilation of people answering this question. But what do you think about increasing the block size of Bitcoin at any point for the purpose of just making it easier for people to onboard layer twos in a non-custodial way? Like we have much faster internet than we did in 2017. Bandwidth is cheaper. Storage is cheaper. For the same amount of money that you would spend on, let's say, a one-terabyte SSD back in 2017... [02:20:42] Now you get a four-terabyte one. So do you think there is ever a point where it makes sense to do that? Or do you think we're stuck... I guess we're culturally in love with having these small blocks, and even if there's demand for it, it will never happen because it requires a hard fork. [02:21:02] Super Testnet: Well, I think you can do it with a soft fork. So we managed to fit a block size increase or to get a block size increase into Bitcoin when we did SegWit, and we increased it by 4x at the time. I would like to do that again and increase it by 16x. Let's do a 16x soft fork block size increase. [02:21:25] Vlad Costea: 128 megabytes? [02:21:26] Super Testnet: Sure. Create a new witness field and call it witness two. And you can put stuff in there. And because it's a soft fork, it's opt-in. If you don't want the block size increase, just keep running the old software and you won't see whatever's in witness two. [02:21:43] So that's my proposal. And one thing I think that would be good for is inscriptions. You put your inscriptions in witness two, and then people who want them can just have that extra data there. And people who don't will just not download the new software. And then more people get what they want. So that's my, yeah, I'm in favor of a block size increase, but I want to do it as another soft fork like we did with SegWit. [02:22:10] Vlad Costea: So basically to have another witness side where you put this data? [02:22:14] Super Testnet: Yeah, you can put any data you want. But I imagine it would be, well actually inscriptions aren't really popular anymore. Maybe this idea would have been more popular if I'd said it two years ago. But yeah, I'm saying it now. [02:22:29] Vlad Costea: Okay, but is this prunable? [02:22:31] Super Testnet: Yeah, you just don't download the witness two data. [02:22:37] Vlad Costea: So would you say that these transactions are less valuable than the other ones because they're going to get stored by a smaller amount of nodes? [02:22:45] Super Testnet: I would say they're less valuable. But if you apply the subjective theory of value, my opinion on something's value doesn't matter. It's just whether the market thinks this stuff is valuable that determines its monetary price. So if somebody put something in witness two that people wanted to buy, that would be valuable to those people. And then you just let the market decide. I'm all for giving people options. I'm really glad that options exist. And whenever there are fewer options, I want to make more of them. [02:23:25] Vlad Costea: That's beautiful. You should put that on a t-shirt, but like make it shorter so it's easy to read. [02:23:32] Super Testnet: Options are good. [02:23:33] Vlad Costea: Options are good. You should sell that in your shop or something. Put it on Shopstr. [02:23:39] Super Testnet: Yeah, I could. When I was doing my workshops, I was selling them on Shopstr. I think I was the only educator with a DNM for workshops, to buy my workshops on a darknet market. [02:23:54] Vlad Costea: Well, that's the way it should be, right? You should not know who your students are and you should not know where the money comes from. [02:24:01] Super Testnet: I also [unclear: noted] that all of my workshops were also available for free. So if you go to my website, you can still buy a workshop, but every link says you either click here to buy it for I think it's $5 per workshop or click here to get it for free. Then it just takes you to the YouTube link. It's the exact same thing. If you buy it, all it does is send you a YouTube link. [02:24:23] Vlad Costea: You're just circumventing this idea that people will pirate this and put it on torrents. So you're like, well, why bother? Just get it from my source. [02:24:31] Super Testnet: No, I thought it would be funny to have something that says like, you can buy this or you can get the exact same thing for free right here. I thought it'd be funny and sometimes humor motivates me to do things. But there's a second reason, which is that I like information to be free. I want people to take my workshops even if they can't afford them. So I made them only $5 apiece so that more people could afford them. And I was just like, why don't I just make them available for free for anyone who can't afford it? [02:24:59] So that's what I did. And so any of your listeners, if you want to do a workshop, go to my website, supertestnet.org. You can find them there and you can click either the button that sends me $5 or you can click the button that gives them to you for free. [02:25:12] Vlad Costea: Super Testnet, I'm a huge fan of your work. I recommend people to follow you. It's super underscore testnet on Twitter. And I think it's super space testnet on Nostr. I'm not sure about that, but that's how you get tagged when I type your name. Where else do you have a presence? [02:25:29] Super Testnet: supertestnet.org. That's my website and you can find all the links there. On YouTube, I'm [unclear: High Level Bitcoin] and I release demo videos of my latest software there. On Telegram, I'm supertestnet, all one word. So it's weird. On Nostr, there's a space. On Telegram, there's nothing separating the two words. And on Twitter, there's an underscore, different on every platform. That's good marketing. What else? I don't remember what else. Let me go check my website and see what else I've got. [02:26:01] Vlad Costea: Do you ever ask people for money? [02:26:04] Super Testnet: Well, I sell stuff for money. [02:26:06] Vlad Costea: No, that's not what I mean, because people can create fake accounts with the underscore on Telegram or something and pretend it's you and ask for money, you know? That actually happened to me with someone who used the one instead of the L in my name. I think I reported them. [02:26:25] Super Testnet: I don't think I have enough followers for that yet. I think they start targeting you when you get like 15,000 followers, and I feel like I've got like 8,000. [02:26:32] Vlad Costea: No, that's not how it works. [02:26:34] Super Testnet: Oh, okay. What's their metric then? [02:26:36] Vlad Costea: I do have my suspicions because this happened to me twice and one time they actually were able to extract some money from someone. But I think they come to conferences and they observe, you know, they look at you and they see who you're interacting with and who really trusts you because the guy who actually got scammed and sent money, and I feel humbled... You know, I realized, okay, this guy trusted me this much that he was going to send money without asking questions, without even calling me or something. [02:27:08] But that guy, I mean, I only hang out with him at conferences. We don't interact on Twitter or anything. So I guess it's social engineering, in a way, so that they look, they see, oh, this guy looks popular. Look, he's talking to this guy. Maybe that he's rich. I'm just going to pretend that I'm him and see where this goes because there was no way to connect the two of us, the guy who got scammed and myself. [02:27:33] Super Testnet: Just to make it clear for everyone, if I ever want any money, what I'll do is I will pretend to be Vlad. And then I will ask you to send Vlad money. [02:27:41] Vlad Costea: Exactly. [02:27:42] Super Testnet: So if someone does that, it's me, and you can send, you can feel free knowing it's... Not, just kidding. [02:27:48] Vlad Costea: Make me rich. [02:27:52] Super Testnet: There you go. [02:27:54] Vlad Costea: Did you find your sources? [02:27:56] Super Testnet: Oh, yeah, it's the ones I gave. It was my Telegram, my Twitter, my Nostr and my YouTube. So they're also, if you just go to supertestnet.org and click Social, they're listed all right there. [02:28:10] Vlad Costea: Right. And you've asked me directly, and I will do this, to put the Chainalysis video in the description. Thank you. I also put your social links. [02:28:23] Super Testnet: Anything, anything else? Or is that, is that a wrap? Is that a wrap-up? Any more questions from the audience? [02:28:28] Vlad Costea: [unclear: To my real shame], I don't have any questions of myself. And there's someone who just said in the chat, "I'm tinkering with BDK tonight." I'm not sure... What BDK is: Bitcoin Development Kit. [02:28:39] Super Testnet: Yeah, that's what it is. I haven't tinkered with it. But I think it's sounds good. I like developer kits. Or actually, I don't use developer kits. But I think they're, they're great for people who like them. So good on you. Try it out. Let me know what you think. I didn't, I don't know why you'd let me know. I don't have anything to do with it. But in case you want to let me know. [02:28:59] Vlad Costea: Thank you to the 1,400 people who watched this on live stream. It's really cool. I hope it was 1,400, because Twitter reports, I guess everyone who joins but doesn't count who actually stays. So those are the people who clicked. I'm not sure if they stayed, but I do hope that they did. And also thanks to the sponsors once again: LayerTwo Labs, Citrea, SideShift.ai, NoOnes and Hodling. Thank you, Super Testnet, for your time and everything that you do. I love your energy and I love your projects and I look forward to seeing you in person at some conference. [02:29:35] See you soon. Bye bye everybody.