Title: S17 E40: Richard Werner & Amir Taaki on Economics, CBDCs & Cypherpunk Tech Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Richard Werner (economist, author of Princes of the Yen) and Amir Taaki (DarkFi founder, early Bitcoin Core developer); recorded live as the final panel of Mallorca Blockchain Days, with audience questions Published: 2026-08-29 Duration: 1:23:56 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2026-08-29_s17_e40_richard_werner_amir_taaki_on_economics_anarchy_crypto.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2026-08-29_s17_e40_richard_werner_amir_taaki_on_economics_anarchy_crypto.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. local faster-whisper medium.en first pass with speaker diarization, corrected by hand against the audio with YouTube captions and the show notes. Details in the production notes at the end. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:48] Vlad Costea: Thank you for waiting for this to happen. It's really unprecedented and cool that Chris has let me do this. Basically, this is Mallorca Blockchain Days, the final panel, but also Bitcoin Takeover Podcast season 17 episode 33 or 34 [sic; it was published as S17 E40], I think, by the time I publish it. So it's a crossover. You're going to be able to listen to this on Spotify and other places. We have dual microphones, one for the camera and one for the speakers. And we are here with Richard Werner, world famous economist. Author of Princes of the Yen, which is a best selling book. [00:01:21] Vlad Costea: If you don't have it, you should be ashamed of yourself. Seriously. Oh, and this is also in front of a live audience. So it's going to be even more fun. And Amir Taaki, world famous anarchist, creator of the first BIP in Bitcoin, one of the first five Bitcoin Core developers, and also founder of DarkFi nowadays. And yeah, we're going to talk about what we have been discussing. Richard Werner has some very interesting stories about David Ricardo and economics since then, most of it which has been deductive as opposed to inductive. And Amir is always ready to give us a manifesto. So let's get started. Well, what do you want to talk about? [00:02:02] Amir Taaki: Okay, I can start. Okay, so you've got a critique of like the Austrian economics, but counterposing that, you've got your own proposal for a paradigm of decentralized banking and economic prosperity. So can you give an overview of that first? And then also, how will that look like in our lives? I guess also there's a historical precedent, etc. [00:02:39] Richard Werner: Great, thanks very much. Thank you. There's several levels, three I can see. First is the analysis level. And what Vlad, what you mentioned in my talk, I talked about this fake approach, this fake economics, which is, you know, it's an approach that was used to deceive us, as Joan Robinson quite correctly warned us. Early on, you've got to study that type of economics, not to get answers, they're not going to give you answers, but so you won't be deceived by it. And so starting with that, the approach of analysis, then moving on to, well, once we have the correct analysis, what can we do? [00:03:26] Richard Werner: What should things look like? What can we expect? And then the third level is, okay, that's nice, but how do we get there? All right, so starting with the approach. So we've been fed, spoon-fed as economics, has been essentially a charlatanism, a fraudulent approach that sounds logical, or uses math, so must be very clever, and oh, it is quite complex, so I better leave it to these experts. Right, so in other words, you know, they've been selling us something, but when you actually analyze it is, it's false and it's empty. [00:04:14] Richard Werner: Why? Because it's based on just made-up stuff from start to finish. It's this deductive, hypothetical, axiomatic approach where you start with axioms, which are things that you claim to know for sure, so you never have to check whether they're true, and if you did check, you'd find out they're not true, and then you add assumptions that you will admit are not true. And then you build your theoretical model, which is just fictional stuff, and it happens to come to the conclusions that, oh, actually are quite convenient, and that really you wanted to come to, and that's why you chose those assumptions, axioms, and approach in the first place. [00:04:53] Richard Werner: So that's wholly unscientific. It explains why, as I said yesterday, there was no progress in economics, and that's increasingly being recognized, and that's a good thing, because until recently, economists would not admit that, but it's now on the record by mainstream economists that this type of mainstream economics, neoclassical mainstream economics, and actually also the related schools, which is all equilibrium economics, that includes Austrian economics, has not actually made any real progress in a long time, a century, two centuries, since David Ricardo set out on this trail to sell us something that is actually very misleading. [00:05:42] Richard Werner: But it's clearly been used to push particular approaches, particular policies, especially when it comes to the monetary and financial system. David Ricardo himself, you know, after he died, his tract on the central bank was published, in which he argues that actually we should just abolish all banks and only have the Bank of England, which happens to coincide, in terms of the message, with the Karl Marxists, you know, communist manifesto. There should only be one central bank. So it's interesting, isn't it, how, you know, a key capitalist, so to speak. But what... [00:06:23] Vlad Costea: What about Hamilton, who was a fan of central banks? [00:06:25] Richard Werner: Oh, there's many other fans of central banks, particularly when you're on the payroll of the same people, you know. I mean, Karl Marx's uncle was the guy who founded Philips in the Netherlands, and he was, you know, also in touch with the financial elite. But in his work, you know, banking analysis is really underdeveloped, just like with Ricardo, where it's just non-existence, as in modern economics. So, but what is the alternative? Well, we need scientific economics, that's what I call it, which is, well, it seems to be radical, but actually, it's nothing radical about this idea, because in every other discipline, we can work scientifically. [00:07:13] Richard Werner: So not the deductive, hypothetic, axiomatic approach, but the inductive approach, where you work empirically based, fact based. In other words, any theory and model that is presented should have been developed on the basis of empirical facts. Now, say that in economics, and it's, oh, that's radical, that's revolutionary. That's not how they operate. But of course, there are some people that operate this way. I've operated this way throughout my career. Historically, there was a bunch of economists in Germany who did that, known as the German Historical School. [00:07:51] Richard Werner: Because if you work empirically, your data is always from the past. The data is never from the future. So it's going to be historical. That's, you know, why it was called the Historical School. And that's the approach that was actually very influential, studied by the Japanese. It's very influential in East Asia. Japan introduced this approach and its policy implications in the territories it controlled, including Northeast China, Korea, and Taiwan. And then Lee Kuan Yew in Singapore saw this and also adopted it. Post-war Japan continued, and all these territories continued as much as they could. [00:08:30] Richard Werner: And then China overall adopted it under Deng Xiaoping. So it's an empirical based approach, as Deng Xiaoping said. Let's look at the facts and do what works empirically. So, you know, that's, in many ways, that's common sense, but it's also scientific. And that's how you make progress. So what does this mean in terms of actual concrete policies and how would society be shaped by that? Well, here's another fundamental principle which is empirically demonstrated and was found empirically and was found to be very valuable. That's the principle of decentralization, known as the subsidiarity principle. [00:09:14] Richard Werner: It was actually the Prussian king who decided that's it. That's the principle we need to enshrine in our laws in the constitution of Prussia. And they did. I think the first time it was 1812. This comes from the army. Now, why the army? Prussian army? Well, an army is an organization of humans. And actually any organization of humans, whether later you look at companies or society in general or earlier you could look at religious organizations. So, you know, an organization of humans you have to think about how do we organize, how they interact, right? And in the army of course it can be quite vital particularly when a small country like Prussia, Prussia was tiny, surrounded by big powerful states and they needed to survive. [00:10:02] Richard Werner: They had battles to fight and so is really important to survive and have an effective mechanism of organizing the people that were there. And they realized, okay, we need to train people well and to be trained and able to function well as, you know, in an army, but also there's certain principles we can identify about how when people work best, namely when they have the right incentives. Now we know communism failed and one reason is this enormous centralization. The central planners believing we can plan everything and it'll be more efficient, yes, in theory. The deductive approach says, oh, in theory the central planner can plan everything so effectively. [00:10:48] Richard Werner: Wonderful. Well, reality is different. Things change, particularly in the fog of war when you're talking about rapid changes on the battlefield. And so the Prussian king realized, no, you've to give your officer on the ground at the front maximum ability to make their own decisions, maximum freedom to decide things for themselves. So you have, you know, within the military uses of goals we want to achieve. We need to move in this direction or we can't give up this bridge or we can't give up this territory, whatever. But how you do it, the well-trained officers and their people on the ground could decide on their own. And that meant they could react much quicker because the situation changes and now they have to operate very differently to achieve the same goal. [00:11:39] Richard Werner: And it turned out this was very, very effective. And this subsidiarity principle. Later there'd been studies, because this was then obviously adopted by the German army when there was the small Germany, Deutsches Reich, unite in 1871, you know, big parts left out, so that's where it was the small German solution, and then First World War and also Second World War, so these military studies by Americans, French researchers, all sorts of researchers, they compared for example the German army versus the British army in the First World War and then the German army versus the Soviet or German army versus the American army in the Italian theater, as they say. [00:12:24] Richard Werner: And each time it was very clear, they were outnumbered usually and were much more effective. It's not about who won the war. It's about, you know, military effectiveness and efficiency. And it's clear that this principle of decentralization, empowering the local people to make their own decision how to do things, is very effective, efficient, but also motivationally far superior. Because there's nothing worse than, say, the British in the First World War. They have these instructions to do, to achieve a certain thing, but exactly how they're supposed to do it. And the battlefield already changed, and it didn't make sense. You still had to do it. That's, of course, why communism failed. You know, the demotivation of people was just enormous. [00:13:09] Richard Werner: So that's a key principle, decentralization. Now that needs to be implemented in society on every level. And it can be done, partly we've seen it, so that the successful high growth economies have all implemented this. Of course, a central area where economic decisions are made that are very influential is money. The creation and allocation of money, which in our institutional reality nowadays and for the last, well, several centuries has been in the banking system. So if you have many many small local banks that make local decisions, these are the officers on the ground that can look at what the battlefield looks like and then make decisions, is far superior to central planning say two or three big banks or even just one central bank deciding everything. [00:14:07] Richard Werner: And then also you could say well this Cantillon effect likewise will be applied and you see if you've got one central bank of course as you know that is who's closest to that the elites will benefit, and then it takes a while until you reach a society. But if you've got a very decentralized system with, say, Germany in the 1920s, 25,000 banks, small local banks, village banks, community banks, regional banks, savings banks, credit unions. You've got local decisions all the time. And the Cantillon effect is right there to the local small firm. Right there, immediately. You see, and you cut out the big fat centralizing central planners and their friends. [00:14:54] Richard Werner: So that's also another concrete example. And of course, you know, this needs to be implemented in many ways, but in the monetary area it's very clear that this is very, very important. And then the question is do we get there to a place where we can have a society that is better designed and that's where actually I've got some questions for you as well. You know, you mentioned, you know, questions for you. Okay. You mentioned the DAO, and of course this is an organizational, it is a way to organize things and decisions and so on. And if you look at Europe now, I mean, Europe is in dire straits. [00:15:43] Richard Werner: It's going downhill fast. Some countries faster than others going downhill like Germany. People are leaving record bankruptcies. We've got three years of negative GDP growth. The last time was 1933, but we had this. But it doesn't look like things are going to be turned around. Yes, they're going to ramp up military production. Well, great. That's... Europeans need it. Exactly. That's not exactly helpful because that's wasteful production. So you're going to tie up more resources on stuff that's going to be blown up. Fantastic. So, and of course they're getting much more intrusive now, controls are being increased as the situation deteriorates, more people are leaving and companies are moving abroad and money is being sent abroad and we'll see what happens to the Soviet Union. [00:16:34] Richard Werner: They'll tighten up restrictions, there's exit taxes. But now they want to, even criticizing now politicians in Germany is a criminal offense. It's going to be, you know, you either get huge fines or people get imprisoned. And I mean, or there's the other method now from the European Commission sanctions because they thought, oh, this works well on Russians just totally, you know, just because this guy's Russian, he now can't do anything and his cards don't work and he can't use his account. That worked so well. Let's use it on Europeans. And they have been using it on the Swiss senior former government official retired living in Belgium because he criticized, you know, European policies, but now also German journalists are being sanctioned. [00:17:21] Richard Werner: And so this continues, chat control. So it looks pretty bad. How on earth can we actually change anything, for example, in Europe? Obviously, you know, many people decide this is hopeless. We need to look for a safe place. You know, a new territory, a new location that's not controlled by these bad people, centralizers, central planners, control freaks that have not delivered performance and yet want to be in charge. Well, as far as Europe is concerned, the biggest problem, I see two big problems. Germany and then this EU construct. And I can be very very brief. The problem is Germany is not a sovereign state. [00:18:08] Richard Werner: It is still occupied. The Occupation Statutes are effectively still on the books, partly via later NATO rights, but partly literally from 1945. There's no peace treaty. The Constitution is suspended. We only have a basic law which is for occupied territories. We're still an enemy country in the UN charter, and the CIA can do anything there in Germany, according to the Occupation Statutes, which is why they love it, and they've used it. And then the CIA came up with the idea, well, how can we, because what they're doing is illegal in America, they're still doing it, but it's illegal, whereas what they're doing is legal in Germany, according to the Occupation Statutes, they can do essentially anything. [00:18:54] Richard Werner: So, how can we extend our control over the rest of Europe? And they came up with this construct, the European Union. And if you look it up, all the original founding fathers of Europe, you know, Schuman, Spaak, and most importantly Jean Monnet, all these people were CIA agents. That has been declassified by the CIA after 50 years. It's been out since, yeah, '97. And that's how it happened. It was the CIA plan. And that explains this puzzle. Why can so-called democratic countries give up their sovereignty to a structure that's clearly undemocratic? [00:19:42] Richard Werner: The EU is clearly undemocratic. There's no doubt about it. So why are we supporting it? I mean, it's always been a big puzzle. How could this happen? Well, because the CIA wanted an undemocratic structure, and they were jealous of the Soviet Union, KGB having so much power, and that's what they copied. It is the continuation of the Soviet Union, which officially was a democracy. Look, we have a parliament. There was a Soviet parliament, but it had no power because there were no lawmakers there. They could only receive instructions. They could delay a little bit the vote and have some debates, but they were rubber-stamp parliament. That's what they copied in Europe, so the so-called European Parliament is not a parliament. They're not lawmakers. They have no power to initiate legislation, which is extraordinary. [00:20:32] Richard Werner: Of course, they won't tell you that because they're so highly paid. This is the bribe to, you know, there's some good guys in there, but nobody points this out because they're so happy having this very high salary tax-free when all the laws are made in Brussels by the European Commission. So we have this horrible power structure in Europe that's undemocratic and how do we make changes? Well one I think is awareness. Make more people aware. And of course that's why they're fighting what they call misinformation, disinformation. All the truth, you know, coming out needs to be censored, canceled. Well, I don't think they're going to succeed. They're working on it. They're trying. So we have to also come up with ways in which we can spread the truth, continue to spread the truth, even in territories where there's massive censorship and suppression. [00:21:31] Richard Werner: Informing people on a personal level, wherever you can. They haven't quite been able to control that. So awareness is very, very important. And then initiatives, concrete things we can do. And it's connected to the DAO construct you mentioned earlier, perhaps for later discussion. You know, I'm thinking what can be done, for example, in my country, which is still, in Germany, which is still foreign-occupied. [00:22:00] Richard Werner: And you see, the authors of this basic law for the occupied territory of the so-called Federal Republic of Germany included an article, Article 146, which I think they gave us as the sort of, you know, hopefully these guys can do something with it later, which says that this basic law will become invalid if and when the German people gather a constitutional assembly and give themselves a constitution at that moment we can be free and we can say all the foreign occupation needs to get out and we can have direct democracy because we've seen in the last few decades how so-called representative democracy has really deteriorated because it's clearly a system that can be abused by just bribing these politicians And then we don't get, people don't get the result that's good for them. [00:23:01] Richard Werner: What's the technological, I mean we've got a lot of tech-savvy people in this room, what's the technological justification for having a representative nowadays? The Greeks, the classical Greeks, have played through all the different forms of running a country, from monarchy and dictatorship to oligarchy and aristocracy and tyranny, all sorts, and various forms of democracy. And they had direct democracy with direct voting. And one of the best forms they concluded was when you actually just randomly select people. They will be better because they'll be less corrupt and have limited terms. But in any case, whether we go for a system like that, which, you know, probably wouldn't be the worst idea. [00:23:55] Richard Werner: It's important that everyone can contribute and this can be done. We have the technology. We can use DarkFi to give everyone a vote and vote on everything. Why do we need representatives? You could justify it 150 years ago. People had to take the cart and horse and go to the big city and so representatives assemble and they talk for the whole country. Okay but nowadays what's the justification? What is the justification that we need to give up our voice and somebody else speaks for us and actually turns out, no, they don't speak for us. There's no more justification. And we have the technology. Of course, the challenge is, if there is a system for voting that'll be introduced. Everyone can vote and be the democratic voice, the sovereign voice that we are. [00:24:48] Richard Werner: We can seize our sovereignty directly. Well, of course, this will be attacked and people will try to manipulate this. Of course, it has to be safe. It has to be a system that cannot be manipulated. And this is a technical challenge, but in principle my views can be done. So I would say that's the sort of direction we should go. So decentralization needs to be implemented and we need to work on the political steps to make changes. There are concrete steps that can be done. And while we're doing all this, I think in the current system we can also work, and so I've been working on establishing small banks, local banks, helping small banks to stay independent because of course the centralizers have been forcing them to merge. [00:25:35] Richard Werner: Under the ECB, 6,000 banks have disappeared in those 26 years, and these are all the small local banks. So now fewer and fewer small firm loans are being given. System is getting worse and worse, getting ever more concentrated. So I'm doing my contribution in holding against that, but yeah, we need more concerted action. So yeah, it's good to discuss these issues. [00:26:00] Amir Taaki: [unclear: I just need that one.] So there will be, so what's the ideal end point or like how will society look economically? How will that affect things politically, socially? Yeah, and what would be the structure, how would that look like in people's daily lives as well? I guess you're saying that also people will be involved in managing their lives, that... They have to actually be active as well in the affairs of their community. Maybe there'd be a restructuring away from big cities. How do you see the Europe should be? [00:26:55] Richard Werner: Thank you. First of all, on the sort of the participatory democracy, Switzerland is a good example. And it's quite normal in Switzerland to have, I don't know, every two, three months a referendum on something. And they are involved, they take it seriously, they get pamphlets from usually both sides, yes and no. And they then put down their decision and that actually is influential. Of course there have been ways in which sometimes that's overruled in the sense that they hold another vote on the same thing the way they all try to like the EU they try to make you vote again and again until you vote the right way but in principle, the Swiss system, which is, you know, fairly reasonably old system, works quite well. [00:27:46] Richard Werner: That's low-tech with paper. And so, actually, that's always a fallback. We can do that. But of course, with technology, one could speed it up and one could have non-stop referendums, basically. Or every, I don't know, every Friday morning, we're just going to vote. We're going to be the government. Everyone is the government and we're going to decide on what's going to happen. Of course, there have to be mechanisms, there have to be agendas and maybe subcommittees that can be, you know, where you can maybe be more active than others, where you have less interest. There's ways to organize this. It can be done in principle. Okay, what is the thing to aspire to here? What's the thing to look forward to here? I think what has to be, what people have to realize is that one of the secrets in economics that they don't want you to know is that we can have massive prosperity. [00:28:42] Richard Werner: We can have abundance. You know, this false economics. One of the lies is, I mean, this is the economics of scarcity, of rationing, of austerity. And that's what they've driven home. And whenever you make a suggestion, well, there's no resources. But of course, we all saw it when there are certain events that suit the bigwigs and the elites and the powerful people. Then resources are not an issue. Like in 2020, massive spending on complete unnecessary nonsense, or wars obviously, and other sudden campaigns where suddenly billions and billions are spent, as if there's no tomorrow and there's no restriction. [00:29:28] Richard Werner: But we're always told there's scarcity. Well the truth is, every country in the world can have 15% economic growth, just the way the high growth economies have demonstrated for decades. It can be done and that creates a society where more people have more opportunities. Young people are motivated because you move up faster, you can really, you know, you can actually use your talents, you can do something, you can make a difference. There is no limit to human ingenuity and therefore to economic growth. We can have very high growth and we should demand it even now from our politicians. Because it's a lie when they say oh this can't be done and no we have to have you know declining growth is all we can do. [00:30:15] Richard Werner: We need to have zero growth that's another nonsense you know we don't need to have zero growth or de-growth because economic growth is a statistical fiction it's a measure of wealth and prosperity but it's not you know a law of nature of thermodynamics quite quite the opposite Because if you use the laws of thermodynamics, then it's quite obvious there is no growth. So whenever you talk about growth, you're not talking about physics, where there are limits. You're talking about something else. And in that domain that you're talking about, economic growth, there are essentially no limits. Of course, there are practical limits. You know, it's probably no point talking about 20% growth or 30% growth, which is also possible. [00:31:03] Richard Werner: But you do get into, you know, certain difficulties. I think it's fair enough just to say we can have 10-15% growth, because that has been demonstrated. Again and again by high-growth economies has been done and can be done so we can have prosperity for everyone so that we can afford then also to have free medical treatment for everyone and the sort of society that most people want and certainly in Europe have been you know quite happy with this but we're being told oh that's increasingly not possible and we have to cut this we have cut that, you need to work harder, you need to retire later, and end end end. This is a lie, it's not true. So, yeah, does that answer your question? [00:31:51] Amir Taaki: Yeah, okay. So basically there's, you have this idea of disaggregated credit and there, and then basically there's two forms of credit. There's like credit, there's zero sum. It doesn't, it's non-productive, it doesn't do anything. But there's like, there's actually credit that leads to economic growth. And then... Business investment credit. Yeah, business investment credit. And also you want to have this largely under the control of local communities. So why not also, why not instead of one currency, why not have like multiple currencies, kind of like bonds. [00:32:40] Amir Taaki: I don't know if you know this idea of like medieval municipal bonds that were issued by the municipality for local construction projects. Why are these ideas not more popular? We've seen in cryptocurrency people issuing tokens for many things, memes on the internet, etc. But we haven't seen them used for productive purposes as well. Like businesses, they can issue cryptocurrency token as a bond, etc. So why, why is that, why do we, why do we need a single central currency? [00:33:24] Richard Werner: Thank you very much. Excellent question. And the answer is, yeah, we don't need a single central currency. I believe it's good to have competition. It should be freed up, local communities should be allowed to issue their own currency. Of course in many countries it's, well, Switzerland, [unclear: leads to that] is possible under tokens, which now have their legal status, but in other places it is sort of an issue. You have to play games with what you call it and what it's allowed to do. So in order not to be accused of issuing an alternative currency, in my view that should be deregulated. [00:34:10] Richard Werner: Why does there have to be a monopoly? There doesn't have to be a monopoly. The principle of decentralization essentially is in line with also having variety. And that let market forces determine which one is more successful more popular people will will decide and yes I think the great historical examples where communities issued their own money their own financial instruments they borrowed money of course you know borrowing money is one thing issuing money is even better more powerful potentially because if you do it the right way because you're creating new purchasing power. Key example there, of course, is the famous example of Wörgl, the North Tyrolean town in today's Austria in the Great Depression. [00:35:05] Richard Werner: The mayor of the town was aware of, you know, of money creation, the monetary system. And he watched how Germany, Austria fell into the Great Depression, 1932, 1933, 20%, 25% unemployment, and this mayor quite correctly thought, well this is crazy, in my town we've got all this unemployment, I've got work to do, we've got to repair that bridge, here's a public building that needs to be repaired, we need to build a new road here, we've got so much work to do, and these people are unemployed. That's crazy. I'm just going to employ them. And he employed them and essentially issued receipts for work done for the community. [00:35:52] Richard Werner: His wife was running a grocery shop and he told you have to accept those receipts as money for payment. And she goes, well, okay, but I have to get my supplies for some from the farmers. We have to tell the farmers, these people, it says they've worked for the community. How can you say no? Okay, okay. And essentially, it was very simple, but everyone knew, okay, the mayor signed them, and these people did work for the community. Of course, we'll accept this. And so, and you could then also pay local taxes with this, and what happened was that by the end of the year, Wörgl, while being surrounded by the Great Depression in Germany and Austria, had full employment. And it became a matter of international attention. [00:36:41] Richard Werner: Yale professor Irving Fisher sent his PhD research around to see this and write it up. It was then in American newspapers, of course that's the moment where the central planners decided okay well this shouldn't get out of hand. The neighboring towns started to do the same thing, you see. So then the Austrian Central Bank contacted the mayor and with their lawyer they threatened him that there would be prosecution against him if he didn't immediately stop it for forgery of currency and issuing currency. Basically, he was made out to be the criminal. He stopped. [00:37:27] Richard Werner: So Wörgl went back into the Great Depression, people started to be unemployed again, and the central planners were happy. Which proves many points including that the central planners of course are not interested in what's good for the people very clearly. They're interested in their power monopoly and we should do the opposite and yes local places should issue money. By the There is also a very old form of money that was very important in England under the Normans under the Norman Exchequer which is the split tally, the tally stick split into two in German, Kerbholz, and there's this German expression, if you've done a lot of bad things, you've got something on your, you've got a lot of notches on your tally stick, basically. [00:38:13] Richard Werner: "Der hat was auf dem Kerbholz." That comes from this system which used to measure debt, or, as in the Norman application to England, it was actually a receipt for taxes paid. And it was money creation. The government could issue new tally sticks, more receipts of taxes paid if you sold something to the government. So it was a non-interest public money. And there were two keys. You have the short and the long one when you split the tally. And the long one was the foil, which was kept in the Royal Treasury. And the one circulating was the stock, which is where stocks and shares comes from and then stock from stock stick, okay. [00:39:02] Richard Werner: And then if, because when you split the wood, it's got an imprint like a fingerprint, you know, the grain of the wood. So it's unique. It's forgery proof. You've got a public key and a private key. It worked really well. There was prosperity. Norman England was very prosperous. And that can also be replicated. It could always be the fallback because we could just issue tally sticks. [00:39:27] Richard Werner: They're made from hazelwood, which is like a weed, and you know you put the notches in for the number you keep one in the central place or the local central place and then that can be the money, that can be the local money. So there's many ways and of course we saw this in the Great Depression, not just Wörgl, but other towns issued their paper money, their instruments, which is suppressed by the central bankers, but there's no good reason and history is now clear when we look back that should be open for people to use and for local communities to use for their prosperity. [00:40:09] Amir Taaki: So in Switzerland they have like lots of little cantons and in our canton I remember the economic minister, which I know, he found out that there was like this scammy crypto group and they were trying to like recruit local people and it's like a ponzi. So then he went there and he kind of went to shut it down and I was talking to him about it and he says that he kind of like he has all these tools that he can use so I guess also in this in this vision of disaggregated local credit for productive business purposes that the issuance of the credit is actually subject to the local polity. [00:41:00] Amir Taaki: So it's not, it's like a social force, it's utilised. By the community in a kind of strategic way. [00:41:10] Richard Werner: I think so, exactly. And so that's one way to organize it. And it can also be done through a DAO, you know, and voting there. And there should be, and there can be variety and different overlapping systems. You can be part of several communities. Why not? But certainly it's good if there's also a physical geographical community as we've seen in well just this year particularly when there's, you know, sanctions, boycotts involved, disruption of transport and so on. Entire regions getting blackmailed or cut off potentially from necessary inputs. [00:41:58] Richard Werner: It does help to have a community and that can be organized. With its own currency, whether it's called a currency or not. And of course, if one has a community bank, that's very helpful. The Wörgl experiment, by the way, party, of course, was also so successful because it was backed by the local bank. So the local Raiffeisen Bank in Wörgl, they made a statement that, yes, the mayor has actually got this much money with us. And we're backing this, we see no problem with this. And then, so some people who thought, oh, is this gonna work and so on, they felt, okay, the local bank is backing it. [00:42:46] Richard Werner: Because the local bank can back anything. It could back also a gold-based system, a Bitcoin-based system that can be in parallel. It can run a tally stick system. It's probably not a bad idea to have also written records if there's an EMP and all the electronics is down. No one should be prepared for all these things. [00:43:08] Amir Taaki: Yeah, so I know this story, but you might say it's wrong, which you should tell me if it's wrong, that the British Central Bank, it was actually started because the government was bankrupt in their war with Spain. And then they used that as a way to raise money so they can start building ships. And so what about the degree of centralisation exists in economy? Because you gave this example of like the Prussian versus British thing. But from what I understand is that Prussia or Germany is typically a land army. They invest a lot in their standing military, which is it's like less. [00:44:01] Amir Taaki: It's literally, it's like a question of like labour and conscription and military training. Whereas the English were like a thalassocratic sea power, which I think it comes from, is it Carl Schmitt, and therefore to be a sea power you need to have shipbuilding and you know that requires coordination between like a lot of experts and strategic planning and stuff. So some would argue that that modality of economy like necessitates a degree of centralization more so than like another type and that they're like actually constrained geographically as well by that. [00:44:56] Richard Werner: Well I mean I can see how that played into it and may well be a reason why you know England was was moving in that direction. Of course the founding of the Bank of England was the single most important reason, and that was after a foreign invasion, when, you know, the last successful foreign invasion and occupation of Britain was in 1688. Although, you wouldn't really know it when you read English textbooks, because the descendants of that ruling elite are still in charge. So, of course, it's sort of written out of the history textbooks. When I was a student, a foreign student in England, I was told, you Germans tried to invade England, but you didn't succeed. Last time we were successfully invaded it was 1066. [00:45:46] Richard Werner: Wrong in many ways because you know Germany never wants to invade England and of course the last successful invasion was 1688 very successful the Armada was multiple times the size of the Spanish Armada which never landed and history textbooks spent a lot of space on but it did land and it did drive the king out and London was fully Dutch occupied it was the fleet from from the Netherlands and they brought their low-ranking Dutch aristocrat and made him king in England. And ever since, no British monarch has been in power, has been foreigners who've been the monarchs. The last British dynasty was the Stuarts. And that's because they steadfastly refused to allow the creation of the Bank of England. [00:46:32] Richard Werner: Charles I refused it. Civil War was staged, regime changed, and he was decapitated. And secondly, then, at Charles II, he refused, he died under strange circumstances which are linked to the creation of the Bank of England. And then his brother, James II, was driven abroad by this foreign invasion. And then finally, they could set up the Bank of England, 100% privately owned, for-profit central bank. And of course it was created, it was no secret, it was created to make war and fund war abroad. So certainly that connection is also there, central planning and warfare. [00:47:20] Richard Werner: And of course, yes, Britain was staging ground for then the creation of this empire for which the British people are often blamed. But it was literally that financial clique that decided, well, that's a great starting point now to expand beyond the shores of the British Isles, which is what happened. And then of course that was further exploitation of these various countries in an economic mechanism I explained partly yesterday. So money has been at the core of what's been happening in history really. But it's an interesting comparison. So the seafaring countries, of course America in many ways took over from Britain versus the continental powers. [00:48:08] Richard Werner: And there's this well-known British geopolitics writer, Mackinder, and he pointed out that what's important for these seafaring nations who dominate the seas is Central Asia needs to be controlled, needs to be under their control. And that has led to this strategic goal to always make sure that Russia and Germany don't collaborate. They mustn't collaborate because Britain will be out. Likewise in Asia, China and Japan must never collaborate. You know otherwise who needs America and the Pacific. So that's been the source of a lot of conflict and is also linked to then what happened later with you know in the Middle East because because the First World War was partly about the prevention of building the construction of the planned Berlin-Baghdad-Basra railway which would have directly circumvented the British dominance of the seas by having a direct railroad from Berlin to the Gulf. [00:49:22] Richard Werner: Baghdad, Basra, Ottoman Empire being an ally. And that was clearly that sort of central Asian collaboration that Mackinder was also warning about. So that had been prevented from a British viewpoint. They decided, well, we have to make war in Germany. But likewise, this is now happening, of course, in China, because the Belt and Road Initiative is just that. It is about having land connections. There's also a sea road, of course, as well, but that's a separate story. But certainly the land connection, the infrastructure investment, the bombing of Iran. [00:50:04] Richard Werner: Actually, I've got a Substack on this rwerner.substack.com, where I look into this, you know, US-Israel campaign on Iran. And they did bomb these recently built bridges that are part of the Belt and Road connection to China. China is trying to do what Germany then tried to do, make sure there's resource transportation, communication links, infrastructure links, to make sure China will always get the resources and also then can export. And of course you can also use for troop movements. [00:50:42] Richard Werner: So it's a big threat for a sea power, because it's much faster, much cheaper, more effective, and therefore, yes, it looks like the sea powers always want to stop that. [00:50:57] Richard Werner: And so it looks to me like ultimately the real goal here in this war against Iran is actually China. Even the war against Russia, ultimately the ultimate goal, I think, is China because it's done what Germany did by 1912. It's thoroughly overtaken economically Britain Germany you know at that time and China has overtaken the US in almost every respect. And that's something, you know, these elites who've been using the U.S. As their main staging ground, well, certainly want to fight against now. So in many ways history is repeating itself, I fear. [00:51:44] Vlad Costea: [unclear: Oh, you're going to go?] Okay, so since this is also an episode of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast I will have to bribe you to plug my sponsors and I see that some of you are low on energy so let me provide an incentive. We have a world class economist and the world class cryptographer and cypherpunk here. Think of the best question you can ask them and the best question gets $100 in Bitcoin, Monero, or Zcash, it's your choice. It's from my sponsor Cake Wallet, they do this. And you also get $100 each for participating in this panel. So you have to download Cake Wallet. So they're gonna have to vote basically which one was the best question that they received from the audience. So yeah, this is your incentive to participate. Check out Cake Wallet. Also check out LayerTwo Labs. They're building the drivechain and they're gonna launch eCash next month. [00:52:36] Vlad Costea: Ad voiceover: Trade without limits. Trade without surveillance. Trade without friction on orangerock.com. Embrace the future today. Forget about the centralized custodial exchanges and go to Orange Rock to find all the trading pairs, all the swapping and all the liquidity that you need to never KYC again. OrangeRock.com. [00:53:12] Vlad Costea: Check out Braiins which is a rental service for mining. So if you want to mine Bitcoin with gears that you don't have you can basically rent it from... It's called hashpower.braiins with a double i dot com. And I also need to plug SideShift, which is the place where you swap your stablecoins for sound money. You shouldn't hold stablecoins, they can be confiscated. So make sure that you swap them for something which cannot be taken away from you. And the URL is SideShift, which is S-I-D-E-S-H-I-F-T dot A-I. [00:53:51] Vlad Costea: Thank you for letting me plug my sponsors. I hope that you're thinking about good questions right now. I'm gonna let you ask them. I'll start with a question. I don't know what that sound is. I'll start with a question. What do you think is the most important event of the last year that happened in economics and privacy? Because we meet each other every year and there's a lot that's happening in between and we would I would love to hear your review of what's been happening. [unclear: Bueno.] So you want to go to your, with your field of expertise. [00:54:30] Amir Taaki: Right. I think is the breakthroughs that are kind of happening with FHE, IO, Indistinguishability Obfuscation, which is related to Project Tachyon, which Zcash is doing. I think just like from just like a usability perspective like having to sync a wallet that you haven't opened for ages by scanning all these notes they're like you have to have this counter of like 30,000 blocks but now potentially we could like get rid of that like, solve a big impediment. [00:55:16] Amir Taaki: A second thing is the Zcash hack that happened, which is quite bad in terms of because, you know, they're trying to sell Zcash as sovereign money. It sucks. That happened to them. I don't think it's personally a big deal as much as people make out to be, but obviously it's bad from a narrative perspective. But it is quite interesting how AI can be used to find new bugs, but also has brought potentially the costs down of formal verification, which means that by formally verifying ZK code, we can guarantee that certain invariants are respected. [00:56:02] Amir Taaki: Which means that we bridge the gap that has typically existed between transparent systems which are auditable and anonymous crypto systems which have an issue with auditing the supply. So if we bridge that gap I think it's kind of like it solves the issue so that's really exciting. There's a lot more possible with anonymous crypto systems but I think those two are like very like achievable low-hanging fruit that will be kind of done, you know. That sounds good. [00:56:37] Richard Werner: That's sort of on the bright side. From my perspective, looking at the dark side, I think it's, and being European, it's what the EU has been concocting and implementing and is tightening up, which is its total controls, its total digital controls, Digital Services Act, the Digital, what is called Media Freedom Act or whatever. These are all Orwellian names, obviously. It's not about media freedom at all. And now we've got the Chat Control, where they're legalising what of course has been going on already, [unclear: philosophic], they're reading everything we're producing digitally, but now it's legal and they can store it and they will store it and so on. [00:57:26] Richard Werner: It's this digital prison that's being built and the preparation, of course, [unclear: I wouldn't even see there's another]... Yeah, I'm sure in the last year, you know, they're now through that hurdle, now we're in the final phase and they want to roll it out. I think when... [unclear: Okay, that's a bit macro for me.] Of course, that's, that's really... [00:57:48] Amir Taaki: Yeah, I'm a bit dense like that. [00:57:50] Richard Werner: In many ways, because CBDC is... What is CBDC? What's the new thing about it? It's not digital bank currency that's new. So the BDC, bank digital currency, we've had for far for century. It's the C, the central bank digital currency that's new. Central banks didn't used to do this they deal only with banks in the past and the banks deal with us but now they want to it's the umpire in the game saying I want to play and I want to score goals and they the bank regulator is now going to compete against the bank. CBDC is a direct account at the central bank and that will drive banks out of business. The best way to launch is to create a banking crisis. [00:58:36] Richard Werner: They have been working on this by creating this real estate bubble in Germany that started in 2009, peaked in 2022, is now in a deflation and slow collapse phase. And so probably the timing might work out in one or two years time with a banking crisis, then offer CBDCs and people would just move the money there. [00:58:59] Richard Werner: Then you let perhaps let a bank fail or two and then suddenly the ECB will announce oh well we have to increase the amount of money that people are allowed to hold in CBDCs of course you know people have asked us to increase this now and so of course ultimately all the money will go into CBDC the banks will lose all their deposits and that's how you shut down the banking system or you've introduced the Soviet system where there's only one bank the central that's one way another where we're heading at the moment that's what they're planning. The central planners want to be the only banks in town. [00:59:45] Richard Werner: At the same time we said that, if we set up banks and make sure they're stable, and have depositors who will stick to them and they will not pull out the money, because they know where the bank has lent money in the local community, and they haven't done the games with speculation, then these banks will be much more valuable. They'll be super valuable because there won't be many of those around So that's why I think it's still the right thing to set up new banks at this stage. [01:00:18] Vlad Costea: What's really beautiful about your answers is that they're complementary because on one hand we have the CBDC Which is accelerating in Europe and on the other hand we have much better verification of zero knowledge proofs for decentralized currencies which means that someone with a wallet in their pocket I mean a wallet on their phone in their pocket is going to be able to synchronize without any major privacy trade-offs. Like, they're not gonna leak information about their device to the rest of the network, which is pretty cool. It's kind of like the holy grail of being able to have the Swiss bank in your pocket. And it's really beautiful. Once again, I guess Chris was not here when I said it, when I announced it. $100 for the best question from the audience. [01:01:05] Vlad Costea: We have one. So, who goes first? [01:01:09] Amir Taaki: I think he had his hand first. [01:01:11] Vlad Costea: Okay, you have to hold both microphones, thank you. [01:01:21] Audience member: So, if I remember correctly, in your talk you mentioned that we should demand our politicians to allow maximum growth. I'm wondering how does a politician, someone sitting and just observing, create economic growth? Okay, yeah. [01:01:46] Richard Werner: Yeah, that is a good question. Thank you very much. The concrete way, so we're talking about politicians that are in power and, you know, can pass laws. So the thing to do would be to pass laws that deregulate the creation of community banks that lend to small firms. By abolishing the need for a banking license and saying that they will be allowed on a registration basis you just need to meet the minimum requirement which should be reasonably low perhaps capital of a hundred thousand euros or perhaps one million even but not higher and you meet these criteria there's a list and then this is a bank. You're now allowed to receive deposits. [01:02:43] Richard Werner: And these banks, they are specialized in lending to small firms. You will get a boom in the creation of banks and a boom in small firms. Now, in all the high growth periods of the successful countries, this actually coincided. You know, in America, when America had high economic growth as an emerging market, it was the free banking era. You had thousands of new banks being created. England in this high growth era had thousands of banks, Scotland as well. Scotland had a free banking era and of course in Germany they created, I mentioned earlier, peaking in 1920 up to 25,000 banks and that was the high growth era just until the First World War or even including the First World war. [01:03:37] Richard Werner: And so that's one way by facilitating the creation of community banks lending to small firms. Also of course the politicians should reclaim their influence on this in general. Bank regulation shouldn't be outsourced to some central planner who doesn't care and is not accountable to the voting public. I mean, that's been a big mistake. And of course, any country that's joined the eurozone has lost monetary sovereignty that should also be reversed. As we said, it's good to have different currencies, local currencies, but each country should have its own currency, of course, because that is sovereignty and that's decision-making power that politicians have given up and they thought it's a great idea to [unclear: give this up]. [01:04:28] Richard Werner: It's quite ludicrous. So yes, in some ways they've given up too much of their power, they should reclaim it, but there are still even currently things they can do. [01:04:42] Audience member: So to a certain extent, it's erasing this thing... [01:04:48] Vlad Costea: [unclear: Still again.] [01:04:50] Audience member: So if I understood correctly, in essence, it's erasing, removing the things they've previously done. So deregulating means going back to the previous point before their intervention. So less intervention. Is that quite of the direction you're pointing to? Like Mises? Because Mises was very in favor of free market self-regulating. [01:05:24] Richard Werner: You could argue it is a form of intervention when you intervene to allow the facilitate the creation of particular banks or you could call it a deregulation at the moment it would be a deregulation so it depends on your starting point for Europe would probably be deregulation but you could also call it a form of industrial policy. Namely, favouring the creation of small local banks that lend to small firms, because you know that that will then result in job creation and will empower entrepreneurs and strengthen the middle class. So even when one says, hey, let's have deregulation and just free markets and let's sit back and do nothing. [01:06:10] Richard Werner: It depends on the starting point. You know, if you did that under certain circumstances, some countries, it's not going to be pretty. So sometimes one needs to do something to then allow a more level playing field and more competition. [01:06:27] Vlad Costea: We have another question here. [01:06:33] Audience member: Yeah, so my question is for Richard. I heard you saying that the Soviet Union collapsed because of, like, demoralization. You use another word, I forgot which one, but like, apathy or something like that. So I wanted to ask, do you think that the current system might fall the same way because of apathy and what would you say was the tipping point in the Soviet Union? Because it was like almighty and then in less than five years it collapsed. So what would you say was the tipping point? [01:07:11] Richard Werner: Yes, so I take this as two questions. So one is the sort of the structural causal reason why collapse and that's I think that's what I was talking about. It's not a system where people are motivated that you know you have to follow a central planner down to the dot on the I even when it made no sense of everyone was so demotivated by having to do nonsensical jobs basically this is the central banking sorry central planning problem. Still the system you know has infrastructure has command structure has mechanisms for enforcement And therefore they can be in power for a long time. [01:08:01] Richard Werner: I think it's a separate question. Why did it suddenly collapse? And that is actually a very interesting question. And I don't claim to have an answer I can be 100% sure of. But my suspicion is that it's the same reason why Syria fell just like that. Which was, I was quite shocked, you know, before there was more than 10 years of warfare. You know, foreigners coming in and establishing militias and so-called rebels and fighting the government. And then you had even foreign countries, Russia, supporting the government. [01:08:47] Richard Werner: But it's been going on for a long time. But then suddenly, just within sort of two days or one day, the government was gone, Assad was gone and everything had changed. And that reminded me of something else, another situation, which was of course in 1918, when Germany was persuaded to sign an armistice with Britain in particular, and Germany dissolved its army, and the government fell just like this. Well of course Britain continued to fight, so then it was announced Germany had lost the war. Well it was an armistice, the troops were, foreign troops were far from any German territory. [01:09:37] Richard Werner: So the war was not actually lost by Germany, but the government just was gone and essentially the then victors could impose anything they wanted and so then there was a new constitution and all these Weimar Republic things were going on but it happened very quickly it's just like that. Just like in Syria and just like in the Soviet Union. Perhaps you took slightly longer in the Soviet Union but it was also quite sudden. So what happens in these circumstances? I think, I mean, my guess is, having encountered Secret Service and how they operate, that there's been a whole bunch of agents inside the system and they were activated. [01:10:24] Richard Werner: Sleepers, you know, now is the time, okay, it's your time. And we're toppling the government, here's what you need to do. I think it was the case in the Soviet Union. I remember when I met Mikhail Gorbachev, was in Oxford, when he came to give a speech at Oxford. He was invited by B'nai B'rith. Interesting. Okay, that was after the Soviet Union suddenly collapsed. And of course he was a figure in this but some people thought he was he was a great hero so yeah sorry a traitor. Yeah, some people say traitor now. So these views could change. But there seem to be, suddenly there's a mechanism that we still need to study and understand which can be applied to various countries and suddenly the whole government disappears and there's regime change from the inside. [01:11:26] Richard Werner: And it can be if you have a lot of agents inside. I mean, when it happened in Germany in 1918, because I'm from Bavaria. Bavaria became in was it was it even November 1918 or December 1918 became the first country outside the Soviet Union where a Soviet government was established. Munich was the location now of the first Soviet government outside the Soviet Union. Wow it didn't last very long but you know how do these things happen? That's quite interesting. It happens with local agents you know being active and doing stuff. [01:12:07] Vlad Costea: Any other question for the $100 prize? If there's no other question, we'll have to vote which one of the two is going to get the prize or we split it. It's your choice. [01:12:20] Amir Taaki: I like this answer. I was pretty interested about the Soviet Union and Syria. I'm writing it to my friend now about that. [01:12:28] Vlad Costea: Okay, we have a vote from Amir. What about you, Mr. Werner? [01:12:33] Richard Werner: They were good questions, both of them, sorry, and... [01:12:38] Amir Taaki: But if you want them to split you have to vote for him to balance out, otherwise... [01:12:43] Richard Werner: Yeah I think they're both good questions I'm yeah finding it difficult to say which one is better maybe I'll just I'll be neutral so Amir's vote prevails. I'll just join Amir. Yeah. [01:12:58] Vlad Costea: Congratulations you just won $100 from Cake Wallet. Thanks for sponsoring. Oh my god, is there nobody else? This is a Bitcoin conference, so I do have to ask in closing, what do you think about Bitcoin nowadays? Because I've asked you the same question every year and there is a lot that happens every year and you get new information and new events happen. And to both of you, what do you think about Bitcoin these days? [01:13:29] Richard Werner: My view is the same as it has been, which is I think there'll be another big run-up in the price of Bitcoin and also other alt currencies. I think it serves a purpose. I think there is an important community that overall is probably still growing and I think it will you know have it stay back in the spotlight in the future. [01:14:08] Amir Taaki: What do you think crypto does well and what does it do badly? [01:14:13] Richard Werner: And what's your answer to the question also? [01:14:17] Vlad Costea: He wants it to go to zero, right? [01:14:19] Amir Taaki: I think yeah I mean I think I think okay so basically Bitcoin it doesn't have any large stakeholder that has like an interest in like giving leadership to direct it so it's so all the technical initiatives are very like unambitious in Bitcoin and Bitcoin lacks any like overarching strategic goal. So the way that Bitcoin gets like spread is through basically you know like people like Michael Saylor or these figureheads promulgating Bitcoin propaganda, certain economic ideologies, etc, which are very easy for people to cop onto. [01:15:18] Amir Taaki: They provide simplistic narrative, you know, Bitcoin to the moon, you know, to X number, you know, if blah, blah, you know, very easy explanation for things. And that's why like you know Bitcoin has a very like kind of proletariat vibe in the community compared to other crypto currencies. [01:15:40] Amir Taaki: Unfortunately because of that it become very captured and it have and it gain a stranglehold is still ideological which is maybe better than something else like Solana or other ecosystem so but the thing is it has a stranglehold and it kind of because of this how it's captured it is it's like very tied to the interests of the political system. So it's like, oh, Trump's going to print more money, okay, Bitcoin is going to go up. [01:16:16] Amir Taaki: Whereas, and so then basically every cycle, because the cryptocurrency market is tied to Bitcoin, then the interests of like cryptocurrency, cypherpunk become tied to the interests of like the US, the money printing, and so everybody just kind of waits for Trump to turn on the money tap so the crypto market can boom again. So it kind of like inhibits us in a certain way and crypto is meant to be a safe haven asset we're still waiting for that thesis to be kind of proven so which is related to my question you know I was kind of okay well that's that was my question what does crypto do well, what does it do badly? [01:17:06] Richard Werner: I think, just, well, from my perspective Bitcoin could well what it doesn't do so well, and where it could, well, there's room for improvement, is just transactional use, make it easier to use it for transactions and thereby increasing transactions and acceptance. And, you know, I think it's doable. That's one area where an initiative, I think, would be quite welcome. What it has been good at is an asset that you hold that everyone can can get even in countries where otherwise you know you can't, you're not allowed to hold foreign currency or anything or you've got a high inflation it gives people access to that alternative asset that's not related to your local central bank's policy so but what's missing is this sort of transactional use to a great extent I would say these points. [01:18:13] Vlad Costea: Okay, are there any other questions for them? Yeah, of course, Amir, [unclear: I'm your husband]. [01:18:19] Amir Taaki: And what do you think about crypto and geopolitics? Have you any thoughts about that? Bitcoin as a proxy for Trump-US sentiment. Did you also hear about Bitcoin potentially being used by Iran in the Strait of Hormuz? Any thoughts on that? [01:18:40] Richard Werner: Actually, I did hear that. I think I saw an announcement that, you know, with the shipping fee now being imposed by Iran that it can be paid in these and these currencies and Bitcoin I think they did say that so yeah the Trump campaign and then Trump you know they set up their own altcoin as a sort of get rich quick scheme it seems which doesn't look great really but there are, sort of, in terms of politics, there are countries as we know you know like El Salvador, where Bitcoin has been quite popular, has been favored by policy. And that's, it's interesting to see, because I always like diversity and I also like diversity in government policy. [01:19:29] Richard Werner: And that's great that there are countries where the leadership is very interested in that. You mentioned another country. So I think that's good. Well, you're going to be active. But anyway, so perhaps we need to see more of that. Hopefully other countries will also think well why not we have some diversification I can see the central planners in the central banks not liking it and then that's really a test of how much they're under control of their local central bank or otherwise. [01:20:06] Amir Taaki: Oh interesting yeah because that's something I actually know from one country that they want to do with cryptocurrency, the main, the people in the central bank are kind of retarded and they're trying to block it. But other people in the government are in favour of it. So... Yeah, that's a classic. And that's because it takes power away from them. That's why. Yeah. [01:20:34] Richard Werner: It's competition. It is not under their control. And potentially it can make them look bad. So, particularly when they're creating inflation. So then, yeah, they don't like it. But in principle central planners don't like all these alternatives Gold is an alternative even cash, even though it's issued by them they prefer You know that as we know they're all moving to towards digital currencies faster some faster than others, but the paper money Is superior for us, but from their perspective isn't it's not as good as digital money because with digital money they've got all these powers of control, intervention, monitoring, the data they see, who does what, which they don't see with cash. [01:21:25] Richard Werner: So, and that's, of course, why cash is getting suppressed. The EU is getting increasingly restrictive about what's allowed to do with cash, which seems crazy when you think about it, because it's still legal tender. But suddenly, you're supposed to be some kind of semi criminal if you make a transaction in cash. We shouldn't put up with that, really. I mean, Europeans have been far too patient and sort of happy to endure all that nonsense. We need to stand up and say, well, cash is legal tender, so no limit. No limit, thank you. Why should there be a limit on it? And then gold, in [unclear: some] countries, has made it very hard now to acquire gold without showing your passport and giving all the details, right? That maximum amount you're allowed to buy without giving your personal documentation has been lowered step by step and so on. [01:22:28] Richard Werner: So it's all these measures against competing instruments, which gives us an insight in what they intend to do with CBDCs. It's going to be a totalitarian nightmare. Otherwise, it wouldn't be a problem to have alternatives. They don't want alternatives to exist and competition to exist. [01:22:53] Vlad Costea: Thank you very much, I'm being told that this has to end. Is there dinner at six or something? [unclear: I'll make...] Okay, Chris will make an announcement, thank you very much, round of applause for Dr. Richard Werner and Amir Taaki. [01:23:13] Amir Taaki: Oh, yeah, I didn't even get through all of them, but [unclear: you can see all my notes]. ================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with speaker diarization for the first ~9 minutes; from 00:09:13 to the end the text was rebuilt from local medium.en re-transcriptions of overlapping ~64 s audio clips (int16, name/jargon prompt), with per-word speaker labels from the diarization plus a full-episode local speaker-embedding scan (three reference voices: Vlad, Richard Werner, Amir Taaki). Where clip windows overlapped, the duplicated text was removed (00:18:54 "It's been out since, yeah, '97" and Amir's 00:26:37 question had each appeared twice). The result was compared word by word against a full local small.en pass (int16, VAD, word timestamps) and the YouTube auto-captions (aligned to the audio); every disagreement was reviewed, and 13 doubtful stretches were re-checked with fresh medium.en clip transcriptions without a prompt. Text dropped by the clip pass was restored where small.en and the YouTube captions agree: Richard's "Well, I don't think they're going to succeed. They're working on it. They're trying." (00:20:32 paragraph), Amir's "...very tied to the interests of the political system. So it's like, oh, Trump's going to print more money ... so the crypto market can boom again" (01:15:18 paragraph; the raw text had a stray "Yeah, I think so" there), Richard's "gold, in some countries, has made it very hard now to acquire gold without showing your passport ... That maximum amount you're allowed to buy" (01:21:25 paragraph), and the closing "round of applause for Dr. Richard Werner and Amir Taaki" (01:22:53) plus Amir's "Oh, yeah, I didn't even get through all of them" (01:23:13; a hallucinated "Music you" was removed). Other fixes: "Chat Control" (was "Fran Corroll", 00:56:37 paragraph), "15%/20%/30%/10-15% growth", "25% unemployment", "100% privately owned" Bank of England, "dominance of the seas", "he pointed out", "Central Asia needs to be controlled", "the ultimate goal, I think, is China", "certainly want to fight", "rwerner.substack.com, where I look into this", "money creation", "Lee Kuan Yew in Singapore", "this false economics", "certain invariants are respected", "Amir's vote prevails. I'll just join Amir", "B'nai B'rith" (Gorbachev's Oxford speech), "Like Mises?", "where it could, well, there's room for improvement, is just transactional use", "in the Strait of Hormuz", and the Kerbholz saying "Der hat was auf dem Kerbholz". Speaker turns fixed include 00:06:23 (Vlad's "What about Hamilton...?"), 00:51:44 (Richard's "I fear" vs Vlad's sponsor segment), 01:01:21 (the audience member's question starts at "So, if I remember correctly", not Vlad), 01:04:42-01:04:50 (the second audience question starts at "So to a certain extent", which the raw text had given to Richard as "So Kiva Suralik's 10"), 01:17:06 and 01:23:13. The Orange Rock spot (00:52:36-00:53:12) is a pre-recorded ad and is labelled "Ad voiceover" (the raw text had split it between Vlad and an audience member); Vlad reads the other sponsors himself (Cake Wallet, which also funded the $100 best-question prize, LayerTwo Labs/eCash, Braiins Hashpower at hashpower.braiins.com, SideShift at sideshift.ai). Names and jargon were checked against the title, the feed keywords and the web: Mallorca Blockchain Days, Princes of the Yen, Joan Robinson, David Ricardo, Karl Marx, Philips, German Historical School, Lee Kuan Yew, Deng Xiaoping, subsidiarity principle, Prussian army, Cantillon effect, ECB, Occupation Statutes, Basic Law (Grundgesetz) Article 146, Schuman, Spaak, Jean Monnet, Digital Services Act, Media Freedom Act, Chat Control, CBDC, Wörgl, Irving Fisher, Raiffeisen, Norman Exchequer, tally sticks (Kerbholz; stock and foil), Carl Schmitt, thalassocracy, 1688 Dutch invasion, the Stuarts, Charles I/II, James II, Mackinder, Berlin-Baghdad-Basra railway, Belt and Road, Gorbachev, B'nai B'rith, Bavarian Soviet Republic, Syria/Assad, DarkFi, DAO, FHE, indistinguishability obfuscation, Project Tachyon, Zcash, formal verification, ZK, Michael Saylor, Solana, El Salvador, Strait of Hormuz, Ludwig von Mises. Notes: Vlad calls it "season 17 episode 33 or 34" (marked [sic]; it was published as S17 E40). Intro music (0:00-0:48) is omitted. Remaining doubtful words are marked [unclear: ...]; these include Amir's "I just need that one" (00:26:00, probably about a microphone), Werner's "Switzerland, [unclear: leads to that] is possible under tokens", the word after "going on already" (00:56:37 paragraph; every pass hears "philosophic"), a crosstalk stretch at 00:57:26, "[unclear: give this up]" (01:03:37 paragraph; heard "kick"/"keep"/"give"), and Vlad's aside to Amir at 01:18:13.