Title: S2 E2: Udi Wertheimer on Being a Bitcoiner Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Udi Wertheimer, Bitcoin developer and member of the Bitcoin Embassy community in Tel Aviv, Israel Published: 2019-06-29 Duration: 1:40:59 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2019-06-29_udi_wertheimer.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2019-06-29_udi_wertheimer.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:01] Vlad Costea: Hello and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover. I am Vlad and today my guest is Udi Wertheimer, who until very recently used to call himself a Bitcoin noob. But we all know that he is a good developer and a very competent one and a big Bitcoin enthusiast who participates in many events that take place in Israel and not only his own country. And he is a participant at the Bitcoin Embassy, which is a very interesting way of putting it. To call something an embassy of something, that bears a political meaning, right? [00:00:41] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, I guess. I guess that the Bitcoin Embassy in Tel Aviv, in Israel, is kind of this open community, open source thing. It's not, you know, it's not code, but we call it open source because everyone can join, everyone can help direct where we're going with this, and it's been running since long before I started, you know, getting excited about Bitcoin. It's been going on for years now. It's really great place with great people. It's like it's a physical location, but also, you know, a lot of events that the embassy is doing. [00:01:20] Udi Wertheimer: Like the recent Bitcoin party we had in Tel Aviv, which was, I think, hosted over a thousand guests. And also the full node workshop that we recently did, which was... We had people come over with, like, you know, all the PCs, all PC boxes or laptops, and we helped them install Linux for the first time, so it was the first time they used Linux. And we helped them install full nodes with Lightning and with Electrum Personal Server and a whole host of things. And they came out with full nodes that they can and do actually use. [00:01:59] Udi Wertheimer: So it was a lot of fun and it was very interesting too. So yeah, a lot of great events with the Bitcoin Embassy. [00:02:06] Vlad Costea: But of all the places in the world where you could have these exciting Bitcoin-related events, why do you think it's Israel? What is so special about your country? Is there like some kind of national policy which encourages new innovations and technology? [00:02:23] Udi Wertheimer: I mean, for sure, yeah, there's a very significant tech industry in Israel and in Tel Aviv and in Israel in general. And, you know, first of all, it's not just Israel. I know of multiple Bitcoin embassies around the world. We're not like directly connected, but I would say inspired from each other. Besides from that, I think that Israel has a significant tech community. It also has, you know, like a strong ideological community. So a lot of people who are interested in Bitcoin in Israel are, I find, maybe more ideological than usually in many other parts in the world. [00:03:17] Udi Wertheimer: So this is something that maybe sometimes surprises people. People feel very strongly about how they view Bitcoin and, you know, the role that they think Bitcoin has in the world. I'm not sure why that is that way, but it's cool. I like it. [00:03:37] Vlad Costea: I also know that you recently had a conference in Tel Aviv, which was very special in the sense that it defied the trend of having blockchain-related conferences and it was only about Bitcoin. And to this extent, you actually had Nick Szabo and David Chaum invited as guests who had panels and spoke. And I know that Alena Vranova and Aaron van Wirdum of Bitcoin Magazine were part of the same panel. And also you had your own panel, right? [00:04:11] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah, so we were very happy to have those people that you mentioned and we were also very happy that, you know, it was a Bitcoin conference and not a blockchain conference. I think that we're seeing more of this, I think, everywhere in the world right now because a lot of the blockchain scams and frauds are kind of disappearing now because the money's gone, right? So what's left is the more, you know, down to earth stuff and more technically competent stuff and the more ideological stuff too. [00:04:41] Udi Wertheimer: So yeah, I'm definitely happy that we're going back to the roots. And yeah, we had like great panels and great talks there. And I participated in a panel that was more about kind of the Bitcoin community, both in Israel and outside of Israel, and how we see it, which was interesting. We also have the Scaling Bitcoin conference coming to Tel Aviv in September. Scaling Bitcoin is a very well-known, famous technical conference that's been running for years now and it's coming to Tel Aviv in September. [00:05:21] Udi Wertheimer: So we're super excited about that. It's going to be, you know, very great event and a great opportunity both for, you know, the Tel Aviv community to get to know more of the international stuff and also for people from around the world to get to know the Tel Aviv community, which is really great. So yeah, we're very happy about that. [00:05:40] Vlad Costea: So given the nature and the history of Scaling Bitcoin debates, you think that this year it will be about the block size, but instead of increasing it will be about decreasing it, as proposed for the first time by Luke Dashjr? [00:05:57] Udi Wertheimer: Well, so the Scaling Bitcoin conference started as this kind of venue to try to get to some agreement about the block size debate. I guess this is what it was in the first years. Kind of. I was less involved back then, so I'm not sure. But these days it's just, you know, it's still called Scaling Bitcoin, but mostly it's just a technical conference that is not only about scaling, but pretty much about everything. And it's trying to not be, you know, a political thing or a debate thing, but more, you know, researchers that can come and talk about their ideas and proposal and about their work. [00:06:41] Udi Wertheimer: And then they have a few workshops where people can kind of, you know, discuss some of the ideas, but it's not really about debates or making decisions. There are no decisions that can be taken in a conference. It's just, you know, it's a way for researchers and technical people to get together and to see what people are working on. That's the main idea of it. [00:07:07] Vlad Costea: I guess it's always interesting when researchers and developers get together and present ideas that maybe will never become part of the official protocol. They will never be implemented in Bitcoin Core, but they still prove to be useful in terms of inspiring others what to approach next and what to get involved in. At the same time, I think that it's not really these events that cause controversies, but it's the media, and maybe I'm part of the problem right now because I work for a media outlet. We tend to magnify these discussions and make them be something which grows out of proportions. [00:07:50] Vlad Costea: I think it was recently the case with a Satoshi Roundtable discussion where somebody mentioned something about the block size or the supply, either of those two, and then it was a huge outrage. [00:08:06] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, I think it was the supply thing. I wasn't there, so, you know, I don't know what was actually said, but I think the most important takeaway is that it doesn't matter what was actually said. You know, people are allowed to get together and speak and have ideas. People are also allowed to have bad ideas, like inflating the supply. I think it's a very bad idea, but it's inconsequential. People can talk about it and there's no reason to get mad about it. If I remember correctly, it was just, you know, a few people were sitting around at dinner or something like that. [00:08:44] Udi Wertheimer: And someone brought up, like, you know, an interesting subject to discuss, and it got completely out of proportion, you know, on social media and on news and so on. So yeah, I think it's, you know, it's a lot of noise about really nothing. [00:09:05] Vlad Costea: Much ado about nothing, as Shakespeare would say. But do you think that it's healthy for this discussion to be held in a more organized way? And maybe that controversy is part of the immune system of Bitcoin? [00:09:22] Udi Wertheimer: Oh yeah, I mean, yeah, one thing that I tend to say a lot in debates about the idea of inflating the supply is that, you know, when someone brings this idea up, usually people are getting very angry about it. That's a good thing. The fact that people are getting angry about it is a good thing. The only reason that the Bitcoin supply can't be inflated is because the community protects it like nothing else. So it's definitely the most protected feature and property of Bitcoin and that's the way it should be. [00:10:00] Udi Wertheimer: If it wasn't that way, then I don't think there was any reason to be interested in Bitcoin at all. So, you know, I don't know what the best inflation policy is, quote unquote, but it is what it is. And the important feature about Bitcoin is that it cannot change. Maybe it would have been better if it was set in another way in the beginning, but it was set the way that it was. And the biggest feature about it is that it cannot change. So, yeah, we should be very happy that people are getting mad about this. [00:10:30] Udi Wertheimer: I think it's a great thing. That being said, you know, discussion is always good, and I can understand why some people looking at this do not understand immediately, especially people who are not necessarily in Bitcoin. Maybe they don't understand immediately why this is important. It's fine and important to discuss. And it's also important that people kind of retaliate about it. I think it's not, you know, it's not a bad thing. It's great. [00:11:00] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I want to get back for a minute to Israel and ask you something which I usually ask all the guests. What is it like to live with Bitcoin in Israel? Can you actually get paid in Bitcoin and make a decent living and actually make payments with it? I think I've read a recent article in Bitcoin Magazine, and one of their writers tried to live with Bitcoin in San Francisco. And he actually discovered that there are far less merchants who accept Bitcoin now than there were in 2014. And I'm not sure if that's just a Silicon Valley trend or it's worldwide that merchants start to lose faith in Bitcoin, one way or the other. [00:11:50] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, so let's see. So the first question is, do people actually get paid with Bitcoin? So, you know, I sometimes get paid with Bitcoin, but maybe that's because I kind of work in the field, so whenever I work with a client, they usually already know what Bitcoin is and they're probably doing something with Bitcoin, so it's natural and makes sense for them to pay with Bitcoin. I'm not sure if someone is doing any kind of regular people work, which is not someone who is crazy like me, then I don't know if it's as popular for people to accept Bitcoin, but I know it happens. You know, I know people who kind of really live off just Bitcoin, you know, they get paid with Bitcoin for whatever they do. [00:12:44] Udi Wertheimer: And they try to, you know, not have a bank account and use Bitcoin only. And, you know, they do have to sometimes, like, buy the local currency, which is the Israeli shekels, because of course not everyone accepts Bitcoin as payments for anything. A lot of people do not. Most people do not. So yeah, people do have to sometimes convert to fiat currency. But, you know, it's, one, it's doable. And two, I think it's fine. You know, I don't recall who it was with. [00:13:22] Udi Wertheimer: I had a recent kind of argument with someone about this. You know, it makes sense that people, you know, you can't... Being only Bitcoin doesn't mean that you have to eat your own Bitcoins and wear your own Bitcoins. You will probably have to convert them to other things like food and like clothes and, you know, a house. So you can't just live with just your Bitcoin, and if on the way you have to convert them to fiat, that makes sense too. You know, a lot of people are like kind of digital nomads, right? [00:13:56] Udi Wertheimer: And they, you know, move from country to country, so if someone has US dollars, maybe they won't accept it where they go to and they will have to convert it to the local currency. It doesn't mean that their dollars are not money, right? So yeah, there's this community of Bitcoiners that will accept Bitcoin as payment with each other. And there are some businesses that will accept Bitcoin payments. And if not, then you'll have to convert to another currency first. That's fine. [00:14:30] Udi Wertheimer: So yeah, most people don't. Most people have Bitcoin as some sort of an investment and also have a bank account. If they get paid with Bitcoin, they convert most of it to fiat, or maybe they don't get paid with Bitcoin at all. You have all kinds of things. [00:14:49] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I've actually had this conversation. It wasn't really a conversation, but a tweet exchange with Peter Todd. And we came to this agreement that actually Bitcoin needs fiat to exist. And you need to do quick swaps as a very good way to retain privacy and fungibility. As when you purchase something with Bitcoin, you inevitably leave traces and people know that you have used it and they can trace your IP, they can look to the public keys that you posted and maybe look for some links. So it's easy to tell that it was you who bought something. [00:15:30] Vlad Costea: But when you exchange with somebody in fiat, you bypass all that KYC/AML requirements. So it's useful to do this kind of local Bitcoin meetings, and maybe if somebody wants to buy, you can do a quick swap in fiat and then you just go to the grocery store, which maybe doesn't even accept credit cards. And you just buy whatever you need. And then if you want, you can buy back. This is useful for communities to exist and have these exchanges. [00:15:58] Vlad Costea: And also it's useful for fiat to continue to exist as opposed to Bitcoin, as it's highly inflationary, and we need to have this type of antagonist all the time so that we can point out to the flaws in monetary policy and know what to avoid on one hand, but also points at the enemy. That always works in any type of ideology or establishment. You need like an antagonist. Superman needs Lex Luthor, Bitcoin needs fiat. [00:16:36] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, you walk around with an ugly friend so that you can look better. [00:16:41] Vlad Costea: Exactly, that's why hot chicks have a fat friend. Not that there's anything wrong with being fat, and I don't want to get all that backlash, but it's something that happens. [00:16:53] Udi Wertheimer: Maybe, maybe. I mean, the thing about privacy, that's interesting because, I mean, yeah, it's definitely just paying with cold hard cash is probably more private than paying with Bitcoin in most cases. But, you know, things are getting better and it's becoming simpler to use Bitcoin privately lately, at least to some degree of privacy. Lightning is pretty great for that. When I make Bitcoin payments, I actually find using Lightning like a ton of fun, and also, you know, it kind of makes me feel easier about using Bitcoin because I know that it's not registered forever on some ledger that everyone can look at. [00:17:44] Udi Wertheimer: You know, not that I have anything in particular to hide, but it's just nicer to know that not everyone in the world can know, you know, what I like to eat and, you know, so on. So that's nice. With Lightning, you get much better privacy properties usually. And while it's still early and there are probably some, you know, vulnerabilities that could be used to de-anonymize people, you know, it's going to get better. So I'm very optimistic about that. I'm not sure that people will have to use cash to to get meaningful privacy when using Bitcoin. [00:18:20] Vlad Costea: Yeah, you're right about the increased privacy that we are seeing. But I've had John Carvalho in the first season of the podcast and he explained to me, I'm not sure if it was in the podcast or in the conversation that we had after, but he explained to me that there is no way for Bitcoin to ever become fungible, because every unit that gets issued through mining bears a certain timestamp, so you know where it comes from and when it was created. And for instance, Coinbase becomes an enemy of Bitcoin and decides that they will stop accepting any Bitcoin that was issued before, say, 2014, and associate every Bitcoin before that with Silk Road. They can actually do that and censor you. [00:19:10] Udi Wertheimer: Well, I mean, there's some truth to that, but it's not as easy as I think some people sometimes make it up to be. You know, if Coinbase just wanted to say, "All bitcoins mined before 2014 are invalid or we won't accept them," they're probably not going to be able to do that without getting a lot of false positives, right? So they would have a lot of coins that they won't be able to tell. Because the way, you know, the way Bitcoin works, you have coins sometimes merging and splitting. [00:19:45] Udi Wertheimer: So it's hard to tell, you know, it's not just a straight line there. Sometimes coins are merged with other, or sometimes coins split. So it's hard to find, you know, this coin was mined in so and so, because it's not exactly how it works. One way to think about it is that in one transaction, all bitcoins are fungible. So let's say you make one transaction. This is actually something that I read in an article by Chris Belcher, which is, I never thought about it like this before. [00:20:21] Udi Wertheimer: So if you have a transaction and you have multiple inputs going into this transaction and multiple outputs going out of the transaction, the bitcoins in the transaction, they're fungible, you can't differentiate them. So, you know, let's say three people put coins in a transaction. Or maybe you're the only one who put coins in the transaction, but you used multiple inputs of yours. And coins are going out to four different people. So there's no way to know which one got which. It's completely fungible inside the transaction. [00:20:54] Udi Wertheimer: So that means that you can take old coins and new coins and, you know, mix them together and there's no way to tell who got which. So either, if you're, you know, if you're trying to like ban all coins before 2014, then either you're going to get a lot of false positives, like a ton, or you just can't do it. So, and it's, you know, it's a very arbitrary rule, right? Probably no one will try to do that, but it's going to be hard, yeah. [00:21:29] Vlad Costea: So it can be better. Yeah, when you put it like this, it makes a lot of sense. And yeah, it's difficult to implement, but it's still feasible. And somebody out there, if they want to be bad actors in the space and play cops, they can do it, I guess. [00:21:50] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah, I mean, yeah, and we already see people doing it, right? We already see how, you know, Coinbase used to sometimes ban accounts because they received coins that look like they might have come from dark markets. They can't know for sure, but look like they might have come from dark markets. Or maybe someone bought coins and sent them to a gambling site, or what looks like a gambling site, so they closed their account. So yeah, those are things that they sometimes do. [00:22:18] Udi Wertheimer: But if people are more careful and use, you know, services like Wasabi and JoinMarket and a whole host of other things you can do, really, then you can make the heuristics that companies like Coinbase use a lot less efficient, to the point that either they can't, you know, they can't ban you, or they will just ban so many people on false positives that they will have to stop. [00:22:48] Udi Wertheimer: And it seems like, you know, when you talk to people at companies like, you know, blockchain analysis companies like Chainalysis and others that analyze transactions and give this information to exchanges like Coinbase, so when you talk with people at companies like this, they will usually tell you that when someone uses something like Wasabi or any privacy tool, they will, you know, they will not even try to figure out what's going on. You know, maybe they will just say this is suspicious because this person used Wasabi, so it's suspicious, but they're not going to try to figure out what actually happened because it's too hard for them and they have lower-hanging fruit. [00:23:32] Udi Wertheimer: So they're just, you know, they're just going to leave it alone, at least for now. So it's a pretty good tool for people if they want to avoid, you know, getting blamed for things they didn't do. So yeah. [00:23:48] Vlad Costea: So would you recommend everybody to use Wasabi Wallet to CoinJoin their Bitcoin? [00:23:55] Udi Wertheimer: So here's the thing. If you use Wasabi, you know, let's say you go on an exchange, you bought some Bitcoins, then you sent them into Wasabi and you mixed your coins. The exchange you bought your coins at will probably be able to tell that you mixed them later. And one day, if you want to sell the coins on an exchange, on a regulated exchange, they might be asking you some questions. They might ask, why did you mix the coins? Why didn't you just hold them and send them on? And that might be a problem. [00:24:30] Udi Wertheimer: Although, you know, there's no legal case I'm aware of anyone who said, "No, you're not allowed to mix your coins," or, "This is money laundering," or whatever. So I'm not a lawyer, I'm not an accountant, but it feels like to me that if you're able to keep records for yourself, right, and you can show that what you've done is legitimate and you didn't do anything wrong, then when the time comes that you want to sell your coins, you'll be fine if you're able to prove that you didn't do anything wrong. So, you know, in that case, you shouldn't be worried about mixing your coins. [00:25:11] Udi Wertheimer: I think it should be fine. Of course, I can't promise. But the thing is, the more people who do that, you know, the more people who protect their privacy, and the more it becomes common, then the harder it becomes for regulators to say it's wrong and it's something that people are not allowed to do, because if everyone does that, you know, you can't say that it's illegal. So I'm kind of optimistic about it. [00:25:40] Udi Wertheimer: The reason to use Wasabi is not, you know, I wouldn't recommend that someone who wants to do any criminal activity would use Wasabi, because I don't recommend doing criminal activity, and also I'm not sure that it can protect you from a very determined adversary. But if all you want to do is to keep your privacy from your friends, from your family, from people around you, from the businesses that you interact with, you know, if you're a business and you're using Bitcoin, you probably want to keep privacy as, you know, as commercial secrets. [00:26:11] Udi Wertheimer: You don't want everyone to know who you're doing business with and when and with what amounts and so on. It's very natural to want to have some privacy. So I don't think it's doing anything wrong. And yeah, I think that while people should be responsible and understand what they're doing, I do think that it's a very good solution for many of the privacy problems in Bitcoin, and that, yeah, people should definitely very seriously consider using Wasabi for their coins. [00:26:41] Vlad Costea: What I usually think about it is that we are like in the days when people were sending telegrams and the telegrams were not private in any way. You could just read what's written on them, and sometimes, to have some kind of privacy, the senders would use some kind of coded language that only the recipient was able to understand. But when they maybe standardized to letters, and they were sending letters which were enclosed and protected by an envelope that nobody could open, there was also a seal of some sort, then nobody was really asking questions in terms of what do they have to hide. So if everybody uses privacy, then it becomes the norm. And if that's the norm, then you're not going to have special assumptions that the people using it are criminals, and you're going to develop means that allow you to discern from all the huge amounts of transactions and tell which ones are actually malevolent among them. [00:27:51] Udi Wertheimer: Yes, definitely, I fully agree. And actually, you know, if people do not take care about, you know, privacy hygiene right now, then it's actually worse than sending like an open telegram, because, you know, it's not just the carrier who can read your letters, it's like everyone. So even someone who wasn't anywhere around it can still see what you've done. So it's obviously a very, very bad setting, and I think it should be extremely obvious that people would want to get their privacy back, and that there's no way that you can say that people who want some privacy from the people around them are criminals. [00:28:41] Udi Wertheimer: You just want some very basic privacy about how you manage your financials. And people deserve that. So I think that everyone can understand that. I think that regulators can understand that. I think that authorities can understand that. It's very reasonable, in my opinion. [00:28:58] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and privacy is essential for us to actually fulfill the purpose of Bitcoin. I know a lot of people who think that it should always be open and you should be able to track all the transactions and that's a feature. But as we know, Bitcoin comes from a long line of cypherpunk inventions. And part of the cypherpunk ethos, at least the way it was presented by Tim May and the Cyphernomicon, it was that privacy comes first and is the most essential of all the purposes of anything related to the cypherpunk culture, and if you have to choose between compliance with laws and privacy in itself, then you're going to choose privacy even when you defend criminals. [00:29:47] Vlad Costea: I think that's, in a nutshell, what Tim May wrote. And if Satoshi was a cypherpunk, and I like to think that he was, then maybe he envisioned some kind of system which was also meant to be private. And if we were able, throughout time, to find other ways to make it more private, then he left it to us. Then I guess that's a legitimate use. But the idea of Bitcoin goes hand in hand sometimes with the concept, which was actually invented by banks, of cashless society, a society where you no longer have to use cash and you have it all digitized. [00:30:27] Vlad Costea: And I guess this vision is much more fitting with all the ICO, STO, tokenized market or whatever. [00:30:33] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah. [00:30:34] Vlad Costea: And it's terrible when Bitcoin gets mixed and stuck in the same narrative with these inventions, which clearly serve a different purpose and are actually a way of digitizing something which is physical. While Bitcoin is a different animal, or I don't know how to describe it. [00:30:56] Udi Wertheimer: Oh yeah, I agree. I mean, you know, the real meaning of cashless society and having all financial activity digital is that people want to use that to track the way that people use money. It's not about convenience, it's not about security, it's not about any of these things. It's not even a secret, right? That's like kind of the intended announced goal when governments talk about cashless society. They don't want people using cash because they think, you know, it's too private and too anonymous. So yeah, I think that, you know, at least most Bitcoiners I know, that's not something that they want, right? [00:31:42] Udi Wertheimer: They definitely want Bitcoin to retain privacy and to allow people to interact privately with each other. I think it's very important. And yeah, I mean, I don't know about the Satoshi part. You know, the interesting thing about the white paper, he left like a pretty small section about privacy. I think it was very short. And he basically said, "Yeah, there might be some privacy problems, so you should generate a new address every time and that's it." And it wasn't very well thought out. [00:32:20] Udi Wertheimer: You know, it's true that people should use a new address every time and not reuse addresses, but that's not enough for privacy, and the white paper doesn't really go into any of that. So, you know, I'm not sure what Satoshi thought, but the nice thing is that it really doesn't matter what Satoshi thought. You know, he's not here anymore. And even if he was, Bitcoin is not Satoshi's. It belongs to everyone. So yeah, I think it will do what the community wants it to do. So yeah. [00:32:51] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and the whole idea of a cashless society, at least in my understanding, is very Orwellian. As you have a third party which knows all the time where you spend your money, where you go, what you do, what time you're awake, what your preferences are. That's terrible. [00:33:09] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah, I fully agree. I hope Bitcoin can save us. [00:33:13] Vlad Costea: That's also my expectation, that maybe us Bitcoiners can actually establish a different kind of paradigm which opposes this idea that banks have. And it's very convenient for banks to know everything about you and profile you and know where you go and what you spend your money on. And it's also terrible that nowadays we are seeing this state of, what should I call it, institutionalization for Bitcoin, where you have nation states and you have businesses that become payment processors and all sorts of businesses which ask for your personal details whenever you make a payment. [00:33:58] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah. [00:33:59] Vlad Costea: You can maybe mine Bitcoin right now and you get the coins in a private way that nobody really knows that they belong to you, or you can buy them from a miner or something and avoid exchanges. [00:34:18] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah. [00:34:19] Vlad Costea: But sooner or later, if you use your Bitcoin to purchase, then they're going to associate the transaction with your wallet. [00:34:29] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, and I mentioned before the article from Chris Belcher. He's a developer who was involved in JoinMarket, which is a privacy solution that is using CoinJoin, which is related to Wasabi. So it's another project, but it uses similar technologies. And he also built Electrum Personal Server, which allows people to use Electrum in a more private way. So he knows his stuff. And he just released a very long article on the Bitcoin Wiki that he just titled Privacy. [00:35:07] Udi Wertheimer: And there's a ton of information there on different attacks that people can do on, you know, on privacy of users and mistakes that people can do that will leak data and also ways that people can kind of protect themselves. And it goes, you know, very much in depth into this idea of exchanges that can de-anonymize users and how people will be forced to use them. But also, you know, Bitcoin was okay before there were exchanges at all, right? So people still traded Bitcoin, you know, on IRC channels and face-to-face and so on. So it's possible, right? And I believe people will continue doing that. [00:35:59] Udi Wertheimer: And if it becomes harder to get Bitcoin in a privacy-respecting way through exchanges, then I expect that more people will try other ways to get Bitcoin, and that's fine. [00:36:14] Udi Wertheimer: I heard Peter Todd mention once that cash is important because, you know, if things like exchanges are getting hostile to your privacy, then you will want to use cash to get Bitcoin. And if governments completely eradicate cash, then that's going to be hard. And that's true. I think Bitcoin, you know, the Bitcoin economy does, in a way, depend on the existence of cash in the world. I think that's definitely important. So yeah, we kind of need it. And I hope, though, that, you know, just the kind of, you know, the Bitcoin community kind of presents an alternative to the traditional financial industry. [00:36:57] Udi Wertheimer: And I hope that just the existence of the alternative, if it manages to survive and if it sticks so long and still works years from now, then I hope just the existence of this alternative will kind of, you know, make it harder for governments and so on to be very hostile, because they'll know if people, you know, if you get tired of it, they'll just move completely to Bitcoin, which offers an alternative. [00:37:28] Udi Wertheimer: So sometimes just the existence of an alternative, even if the alternative isn't perfect or even the alternative is difficult to use, just the existence of it can help making the traditional stuff more easier to bear. So yeah, I hope that's a good outcome, I think, in my opinion, if this happens. [00:37:50] Vlad Costea: Do you ever stop and wonder at night, what if we are the bad guys, or we are on the wrong side of history? [00:38:00] Udi Wertheimer: Doesn't everyone? Yeah, I mean, you can make that case. But, you know, that's probably something you could make the case about everything. I don't know. I really don't feel that way. You know, I think that again it's mostly the alternative thing that drives me. I think that we deserve it to ourselves and to, you know, humanity, to our children and to our families, we owe it to keep Bitcoin alive because it can be used as an alternative if things go wrong. And if things don't go wrong, you know, and if it's proven that we're just overzealous about something that doesn't matter, then it's fine. [00:38:49] Udi Wertheimer: It's not that bad. The worst thing someone could say is that we wasted our time and efforts. But I think that the risk that things do go bad is important enough for us to keep Bitcoin going as this alternative. I think it's very important. I think that there are a lot of times in history where if people were able to, you know, grab their Bitcoins and run away from the government, that could have been very useful. And it's unfortunate that it wasn't possible for some people in the past. So, yeah, I think that just this alone makes everything worth it, in my opinion. [00:39:27] Vlad Costea: I think my current understanding of Bitcoin, because maybe it's also the case with you, but from time to time I realize that I don't agree with what I used to think. But right now, I see it more as a collectible than as a currency. And I think of it like it's one of these rare items that maybe are very old and they become much more valuable in time the more you hold them and they are in good condition. And in this case, I guess, good condition means that it's not associated with some kind of Silk Road business. [00:40:06] Vlad Costea: But then again, there is no way for you to really know this. And I guess the checks go five steps back in terms of transactions or something. [00:40:18] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, some number, yeah. [00:40:21] Vlad Costea: Anyway, I don't think that Bitcoin right now is the peer-to-peer electronic cash that maybe the Bitcoin Cash side tries to emphasize on, or Satoshi's vision or whatever. And I think that the store of value component is essential. And the main purpose of Bitcoin should be to deliver the kind of transactions that cannot be censored or stopped by the government. That's the whole purpose. Otherwise, it's just PayPal 2.0. [00:40:55] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah. So yeah, first of all, I definitely agree that, you know, my personal view on Bitcoin changed a lot over the years and I think a lot of people share that. That's sort of what I meant when I was calling myself a Bitcoin noob. Because I think it's important to realize that we don't know everything and it's very likely that our perception will change and that we will learn new things. So we should embrace that. And in that way, I think we're all noobs. But, you know, the way I understand Bitcoin is that it is what it is. [00:41:40] Udi Wertheimer: Its main feature is that it's very difficult, if not impossible, to change. And that's, you know, its main distinguishing property as a digital asset. Other digital assets are trivial to change. Bitcoin is extremely difficult to change. So that's what makes it special. And because that's what it is, it's very likely that we will think some things and over time we will realize that we were wrong and we won't be able to change Bitcoin because we had another idea. It is what it is and it's going to continue being what it is. [00:42:15] Udi Wertheimer: And the best we can do is to try to find uses for what it is, and to help it stick along. So yeah, I fully agree with you that as a store of value and as something that is censorship-resistant, this is like the special, useful things that it can do that other assets aren't guaranteed to be able to do in the future. And that's probably what we should focus on, because this is what, you know, what it's good at. Shouldn't be trying to make it things that it's not. [00:42:48] Udi Wertheimer: And I still want people to be able to use Bitcoin as a mean of payment for small things. And I hope that things like Lightning and other stuff too will help with that. But yeah, that's why I very, very strongly object to any attempt to change Bitcoin at its base layer just to support something that it's not, you know, it's never going to be great at. You know, Bitcoin is never going to be as great as Venmo for sending money to your friend. It can't, you know, it's never going to be as good as that. [00:43:24] Udi Wertheimer: It's as fast, as cheap, and so on. So that's not what we should try to compete on, in my idea. [00:43:35] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and also, I think I know this by reading the articles of Nick Szabo on the history of money, and he also has a very interesting one on the history of non-governmental currencies. I think it's a mere coincidence that Bitcoin happens to be a non-aligned currency at the same time when we have all this influx of virtual currencies. And it's also maybe a confusion that some people have in their minds, that they associate e-currency or digital currency with Bitcoin, which is a cryptocurrency. [00:44:12] Vlad Costea: And these concepts are very different. And would you elaborate and explain why they're different? I even have a friend who works at the OECD, and I hope that she's not listening, but she told me a year ago that she's very interested in virtual currencies like Bitcoin for money laundering purposes. And that's what the kind of task that she was assigned. And I told her, "Oh, no, I don't think you should look into Bitcoin at this point if you want to discover money laundering and crime activities. It's more likely that you find these in Monero and Zcash and privacy coins, which actually allow you to remain anonymous." [00:44:58] Udi Wertheimer: Well, it's more likely that you can find it in Fortnite than you're going to find it in many of these other cryptocurrencies. People will use whatever is available for them for money laundering and so on. You know, they will use the financial corridors that are available and they don't care about the technicalities of it. They only care about getting away with it and getting the most value out of it. So it's not necessarily going to be Bitcoin or Monero, Zcash. Usually it's not because, you know, it's not that easy to liquidate. [00:45:39] Udi Wertheimer: Obviously, the smaller coins aren't very easy to liquidate and it's not that easy to move around. So, yeah, people use a lot of methods to launder money, you know, gift cards and, you know, a whole host of payment methods. And I don't think that Bitcoin ranks very high on that list at all, or all cryptocurrencies. There's a lot of FUD, but I'm not sure that's the first thing that people should be worried about. It's one of the things for sure, but I really don't think it's anywhere near being the first thing that people should be worried about if they're worried about money laundering. [00:46:18] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, and also, you know, if we bring up something like Fortnite, so yeah, I think a lot of people kind of confuse, you know, if they're outside of the Bitcoin community, then they kind of confuse Bitcoin with things like in-game currencies and things like Farmville and Fortnite in modern days. It sounds like it's the same, right? You have points that are some kind of a coin and you can buy things with them. It sounds like for an outsider, it sounds like it's the same thing. [00:46:51] Udi Wertheimer: And it couldn't be more different, right? It almost has nothing in common with those things. So, yeah, I think that, you know, the mainstream has a long time before they truly understand what Bitcoin is. We don't fully understand what Bitcoin is, so I think the mainstream has a long time before they get it. And it's fine. You know, I think that... I actually tweeted about it recently. I think that a lot of people are very concerned about making Bitcoin or cryptocurrencies easier to use for the mainstream. [00:47:26] Udi Wertheimer: I feel like it's kind of this bag holder mentality that you want to pass the bag on to someone new. And you want to, you know, as fast as possible, make it easy for as much people as possible to come in so that you can sell your bags for a high price. And I don't care about that at all, actually. I'm fine if it takes a long time. I think that, you know, the mainstream will show up when they need us. When they need Bitcoin, they will show up. [00:47:54] Udi Wertheimer: Until then, you know, it's just speculation, and there's no use making things simpler if people don't need it. So when they will need it, and I do believe that many people will need it in the future, then they will come to us. And our job is to survive until that happens. That's, you know, that's the goal. And to survive, we need to strengthen, you know, the internal Bitcoin community to make sure that people understand how, you know, how to make the most of their Bitcoins, how to keep it strong, how to use full nodes instead of some custodial wallet, and to make sure that, you know, the network of Bitcoin is strong, the network effects are strong, and that Bitcoin stays as it is and isn't changed by outside forces until, you know, until it can be of greater service for the rest of the people of the world. I think this is the best thing we could do. [00:48:53] Udi Wertheimer: So that's what I'm focused on, what I care about. [00:48:56] Vlad Costea: Do you think that we are wrong? I mean, we as a whole community, and I know that this is a very divisive term, as some people believe themselves to be just independent actors who sometimes happen to agree with some people, but generally disagree with most people. But it doesn't matter what you refer to. Generally, this is about the whole narrative that used to be prevalent in Bitcoin, that we don't need banks and we reject this whole financial system. And then we have this part of the Bitcoiners who are very anxious and can't wait for one of the ETFs to get approved and see it as the next logical step in terms of adoption. [00:49:45] Vlad Costea: But I think to them it's more like an expectation to dump their bags on somebody. So if it becomes very easy for people to buy Bitcoin... But I'm not sure if they will actually hold the coins with ETFs. It's just like... What would you call it, like a bond or something? [00:50:05] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, so that's an interesting question because I think there are a lot of, you know, kind of factions and a lot of kind of ideas of people about Bitcoin. And many people bought Bitcoin and other digital assets only as a speculative vehicle. And they don't intend to stick around very long. And they just want to liquidate it and move on to something else. And they hope to, you know, make as much profit as possible while doing that. And that's fine. I mean, that's not a use case that anyone should be against. [00:50:42] Udi Wertheimer: But, you know, it is what it is, but it's not very helpful or very interesting ideologically, right? So, you know, it's understandable if someone wants the ETF to pass through because they think it will allow them to sell their Bitcoins for a high price. But again, in the grand scheme of things, I don't think it matters that much. So, you know, one of these days, we will have an ETF. I don't think it will be this year, but maybe it might be in one year, in two years, in five years, but at some point it's probably going to happen. [00:51:26] Udi Wertheimer: So whatever, right? People who hold Bitcoin long term, I don't think they care about it that much. You know, it is what it is. I do think that it makes sense for some people to want to have exposure to Bitcoin, even if they're not Bitcoiners themselves, right? They don't care about ideology. They don't care about any of this stuff. They just think that, you know, enough of other people care about it that eventually the Bitcoin price will go up, and they want to have exposure to that. But they don't care about anything else, and that's fine. I mean, that's perfectly fine. [00:52:05] Udi Wertheimer: If people think that and want that, you know, go ahead. So an ETF is a good tool for them. And at the end of the day, it doesn't matter what we think, right? It's going to happen, you know. If there's demand, it's going to happen. If there's no demand, then it's not going to happen, and that's it. You know, that's the nice thing about Bitcoin, that people can do whatever they want with it, and it doesn't matter what people on Twitter think, right? That's the great thing. So, yeah, I'm ambivalent about it, but I'm happy that people can do whatever they want. That's useful. What do you think about it? [00:52:36] Vlad Costea: I don't know. I'm torn when it comes to it. On one hand, I can understand that there is a lot of expectation, or there are lots of expectations regarding the price action. And there are lots of miners who are very self-interested and can't wait to actually make some money from their activity. I know that some of them are running at a loss at this price today. Some of them have shut down their operations. And they probably expect every opportunity for more money to come into the space. [00:53:13] Vlad Costea: And it's not going to happen until the mainstream media picks up stories about new highs in terms of price. So it's a vicious cycle which comes down to price, even though a lot of us like to say that we don't care about the price. The adoption itself depends on how well the price action is doing. And it's also... Have you seen that graph with... I think it's called the dick... whatever. Decline. Decline. Yeah. It shows the expectation according to John McAfee's prediction? [00:53:51] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah, yeah. It doesn't look very good for him right now. [00:53:56] Vlad Costea: No, it doesn't, but he's trying to run for president. And part of me thinks that he wants to get on stage and tell people to buy Bitcoin on national television so he saves his own dick. [00:54:12] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, I don't think he's going to follow through on that either way. I'm pretty sure he's not. [00:54:19] Vlad Costea: Yeah. [00:54:21] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, you know, I wouldn't say that people... You know, I know people sometimes say that they don't care about price. I guess saying we don't care about it is kind of exaggerated. It's not that I don't care about it's just that short term, if we have like six months where the price goes crazy, I don't think it changes a lot, you know. I care about the long term more than I do about the short term when it comes to Bitcoin. And yeah, you know, whatever temporary price movements and craziness we get, I don't think it's that interesting. [00:54:57] Udi Wertheimer: Then again, you know, we shouldn't reject price action and speculators as something that is bad. It's not bad. One, it's natural, and two, it's useful because, you know, if you don't have speculators that buy Bitcoin and hold it, then Bitcoin won't have a price. Obviously, that's true for most type of assets. So you need these kind of people to do this, and it's perfectly fine, and this is how economies work. So, you know, it's perfectly normal. We shouldn't try to reject it in some way. So yeah, you know, it'll be fine. I don't care that much about the ETF personally. I guess we'll get there at some point. I don't know. [00:55:47] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but I think the essential part, and this is where the division comes in, is that we don't want to let the speculators take over and have their way implemented on the protocol itself, as it was the case with bigger blocks. I mean, two megabytes, it's not such a big deal. We have had two megabytes with SegWit. In theory, it doesn't sound that bad. SegWit2x wasn't such a bad idea in itself, but it was about dividing the community and setting a precedent. And when you increase the block size, you have done it and you have a precedent, and you can come back next year and say, "Oh, it wasn't enough. [00:56:32] Vlad Costea: How about we double it?" And then it turns into a vicious cycle where the average user will be unable to run a node, and it will be only the miners who do it. And they take over the network, and it's all about what they want to do. [00:56:49] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah. And you know, it's also about risk assessment. I think it's not inconceivable that we would have to hard fork for some reason someday, maybe to make things better and maybe because of some emergency. It's not inconceivable that this will sometime happen. But you have to weigh the risks, you know, and in something like raising the block size to double the size, it's just, you know, the benefits here are really unclear. You know, we didn't do it and we're just fine right now, right? And if we'll have to raise the block size at some later point, fine. [00:57:33] Udi Wertheimer: But it doesn't look like it was ever very urgent. And I think it's a very good thing that we didn't raise the block size just because we had like a month or two of non-standard activity. You know, so if we would do all that just for two months, that would be very wrong, and there are real risks involved, not just for bugs and vulnerabilities, like they actually had bugs, serious bugs in the SegWit2x implementation. But it's not just that. It's also, you know, when you do something like that, you pretty much guarantee that there's going to be a fork and a split and that there's going to be a drama around it. [00:58:14] Udi Wertheimer: And it's usually not worth it. I'm not saying it's never going to be worth it, but it's usually not going to be worth it. In this case, it certainly wasn't worth it. And as you say, you know, you don't want to set the precedent where over every little thing we risk everything. So yeah, it made me very optimistic about Bitcoin when SegWit2x got rejected. I think it was a very good thing. It said a lot about Bitcoin's resilience and I'm definitely very happy about it. So yeah. [00:58:49] Vlad Costea: You know what I like the most about Bitcoin? I think the earliest vision of the commercial internet that we have now, the World Wide Web, which was created by Sir Tim Berners-Lee at the CERN, was that everybody would be able to run their own server and store their own information and actually own it physically. Probably. And that never happened. And in order for the Internet to scale, they had to give up and create these centralized industrial complexes, which host your emails, host your data, and you basically pay them to do your work. [00:59:29] Vlad Costea: And that's not something we allowed to happen with Bitcoin. We still like the idea that people should run their own nodes to validate their transactions, but also help the network. And I also like the idea of proof of work where anybody can participate into mining and you have giants like Bitmain, which seemed impossible to take on a couple of years ago, but right now they are collapsing and they leave the room for somebody else to step in and do the same, which is incredible. That's not something that you're going to see in proof of stake. [01:00:05] Udi Wertheimer: Oh, yeah. [01:00:06] Vlad Costea: And in proof of stake, you just have the rich getting richer all the time just because they are rich. Yeah, some people accept it just on grounds that it's friendlier with the environment or it requires... [01:00:16] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, until something breaks. Until something breaks and then everyone becomes poor. But yeah. [01:00:24] Vlad Costea: Yeah, exactly. There's more central control in these entities, but I like this uncompromising nature of Bitcoin. And just so you know, today my Casa node has arrived and I haven't opened it yet because I want to film the unboxing and everything. [01:00:40] Udi Wertheimer: Oh, nice. [01:00:41] Vlad Costea: And I'm very excited just with the idea that I will be able to simultaneously with one device run my full Bitcoin node and run a Lightning node and open channels. That's incredible to know. [01:00:55] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, it's a lot of fun. It's a fun little device. And it's, you know, I think it introduced a lot of people to running their own nodes. So it's really awesome. Yeah. They did a pretty good job, especially on the software side. The hardware is pretty basic. At some point you'll probably want to replace it with something else, but that's longer down the road. But the software is great, it's very friendly and it really helps people get on board, which is really nice. [01:01:30] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I guess that's what it's all about right now. User experience and helping anybody to be able to become sovereign. [01:01:39] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah. One of the great things is that I think it really helps the conversation around it. So it's not necessarily, in my opinion, that running a node is that difficult or impossible, but people didn't even understand a) that it's an option, b) why you should be doing it and what are you risking if you're not doing it. That's something that people didn't used to talk about, I don't know, even a year ago. So, I mean, some people talked about it, but I think that a lot of the community was oblivious to the idea. [01:02:13] Udi Wertheimer: And these days we see a lot more people talking about it and figuring out ways to make it easier and to educate people on why it's important, which is, you know, a very big deal because once you understand why you have to do it and why it's helpful for you as a user, you're much more likely to go through the difficulties of setting things up, which are not terrible. [01:02:42] Udi Wertheimer: You know, it's doable. You just need to do it. So you need to understand why it's important. And in 2017 and 2018 and the crazy bull run that we had, a lot of people joined and had no idea how Bitcoin works and what it does and what it enables them to do and what's expected of them in order to make the best of it. You know, you don't just buy Bitcoin and send it to some mobile phone wallet and you're fine. [01:03:14] Udi Wertheimer: You know, you need to know how to keep your sovereignty, as you say. It's not necessarily trivial, and it usually requires some level of understanding. People have to get involved and understand what's going on. So yeah, I think Casa and other products like it really help people to kind of understand that this is even a thing that they should pay attention to. That's awesome, I think. [01:03:41] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I think it's incredible, but the price tag so far is kind of high. I'm not sure if a person buying $100 worth of Bitcoin will be interested in running their own node, which costs $300, or even buying a hardware wallet, which costs about the same amount that they own in Bitcoin. [01:04:03] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, I fully agree with you. There are cheaper solutions. So there's Pierre Rochard's Node Launcher, which is great. You know, it's this small, simple little tool that just makes every scary little thing about running a node kind of disappear. It kind of holds your hand and follows you through the process and helps you do whatever you need to do with the hardware that you already have. And make it look much less scary than it used to. So, you know, people can do it with whatever they already own, which is awesome. [01:04:42] Udi Wertheimer: And yeah, you know, if someone buys $5 of Bitcoin, maybe the first thing he's going to learn about is not full nodes. But then again, you know, I think if you want to get into Bitcoin, it's important to understand that your journey doesn't end when you transfer some money to Coinbase. Your journey just maybe starts there and hopefully it starts before there with you researching about what Bitcoin is, how it works and how it helps people like yourself and other people. [01:05:17] Udi Wertheimer: And along the way, hopefully you understand the very important role that full nodes have, and that owning a full node has on independence of the users. So, you know, I don't know if it's the first thing people learn about, but it definitely should be one of the earliest things. [01:05:38] Udi Wertheimer: And hopefully, when a user finishes the research and they reach a conclusion that Bitcoin is a good fit for them and it's useful for them, and that they want to make, maybe they want to make a more serious financial commitment over time maybe, then they hopefully definitely will consider how they fit a full node into their strategy and into their use of Bitcoin. [01:06:06] Udi Wertheimer: It's very important. It helps to learn too and helps to understand what Bitcoin is, and also as an investment, right? You should understand your investments. So, you know, it's helpful in any way imaginable, I think. [01:06:19] Vlad Costea: I also think that when you want to run your own node, it's useful to have a separate device. Okay, it's convenient to have it on your everyday computer, but it takes up a lot of space on your disk. [01:06:34] Udi Wertheimer: It doesn't have to. I mean, you can set it up to pruning and then, you know, we're talking about around five gigs of space, which is, I think, maintainable on most laptops. [01:06:49] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but if you want to be really useful to the network, then you should be running a full node. [01:06:57] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, so, okay, so here's the thing. So when we're talking about why you should run a full node, one of the reasons that people bring up is to use bandwidth to support the network and to send blocks to new users. So if someone joins and starts their own full node, then you keep all of the old blocks and you can send it to them. I don't think it's that important. First of all, I don't think we should depend on volunteers to do that. And happily, we don't have to because bandwidth is pretty cheap. [01:07:35] Udi Wertheimer: You know, if you want to get a server on Amazon that does this, it's going to cost you like, I don't know, $10 a month and you can serve a lot of users this way. So it's not really a problem. And you don't have trust issues there. It's not a problem to let Amazon and other companies run that because there are no trust issues involved, because every user validates everything when they get it. So it's okay. What's more important for end users, the reason I think end users should run full nodes, is not voluntary. [01:08:08] Udi Wertheimer: It's not about volunteering your bandwidth. It's about keeping your own funds safe. So if you buy Bitcoin from an exchange and you get it, you send it to yourself, your own wallet, you want to know that you were actually sent Bitcoins. You want to know that they actually sent it and that they didn't cheat you. And if you buy it from someone that you don't know on the street, you want to know they didn't cheat you and so on. If you receive Bitcoin payments because you offer services or products in return for Bitcoin payments, then you want to know that your clients paid you with real Bitcoins. [01:08:46] Udi Wertheimer: And the only way you can do that in a way that is independent and secure and that respects your privacy is by running your own full node. All the other ways, they leak privacy information and they basically trust someone else. So, and that's kind of what we want to avoid. [01:09:07] Udi Wertheimer: So, and I think the worst thing is that most people don't understand that they're trusting someone else and they don't even take it into account and they don't mitigate the risk that comes with it. You know, they think that the bitcoins are just magically there and they don't even look into protecting themselves. So if you use a full node, you don't have to worry about any of that. And it's also great for respecting privacy, because you don't have to query outside servers and ask them how many bitcoins you received. [01:09:40] Udi Wertheimer: You just ask your own full node, so no one knows what addresses you care about. Full node is a much better experience for Bitcoiners, both in safety and in privacy. That's why I think people should use it. The bandwidth part, I think it's less important. It's nice. If you can do it's great. But it's less important. So if the reason you're not running a full node is because you don't have space, then, you know, by all means, run a pruned node and only keep like the last five gigs. And that's fine. That's much better than not running one at all, for sure. [01:10:18] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and I guess disk space is pretty accessible these days. Anyone can find five gigabytes. [01:10:25] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah, five gigs is, I think, very reasonable. You still have to download the whole thing at the first time, but you don't have to keep it, so it's better. [01:10:37] Vlad Costea: I just realized I was checking Twitter while you're talking and noticed that there was a massive hack in Coinomi, which is a cryptocurrency wallet which supports multiple assets. And they were sending the seed phrases of your private key to Google API, and they suspect that some kind of employee from Google has stolen the money from some users of the Coinomi wallet. And I think this is terrible. We have all these wallet services that you can download on your phone. [01:11:15] Vlad Costea: And they are very convenient, very easy to use. You just download them and they generate a wallet and you send your funds to them. You believe that they are really secure and trusted and you're just fine. [01:11:30] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah. [01:11:31] Vlad Costea: And then, I guess they have one way or another to make some money. [01:11:39] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, it's, you know, Coinomi, first of all, Coinomi is not even an open-source wallet, which I think should be a huge, huge warning sign to anyone. You know, if your wallet isn't open source, I don't understand how you can use it. Because being open source means that other people can audit and review the code and hopefully find some of the bugs, not all of them, some of the bugs that are surely in there. And also it means that people can't hide terrible things on purpose. [01:12:14] Udi Wertheimer: You know, they can't just... If they do something wrong, it will be there and everyone will be able to see it. So, and Coinomi isn't open source. Some other wallets are also not open source. And I think if your wallet is not open source, it's dead on arrival. Don't use it for whatever reason. I don't care if it's easier, if it's prettier, whatever. Don't do it to yourself because you're basically trusting someone else. And why would you give those people your trust? Do you know them? [01:12:43] Udi Wertheimer: Are they your friends? Why would you trust them at all? You're not paying them. So why are you trusting them? On what basis are you trusting them? You're not even a customer. So that's one thing. What happened in particular here, and I think it's desktop only and not the mobile version, but I'm not sure. They use, I think they use Java on the desktop for some things. And they used some Java framework which automatically submitted anything that's on a text form, on a form that you type into. [01:13:21] Udi Wertheimer: It was submitted to the spellcheck APIs of Google. So, because it's just the default of the framework that if you have a form, then probably what you're typing is, I don't know, something that you're going to send someone, so you're going to want to have a spellcheck on it. And this is the default and the developers of Coinomi didn't turn off the default, because obviously in a, you know, where you type your seed, you don't want this to be spell checked, obviously. And they just forgot to turn it off. [01:13:54] Udi Wertheimer: And, you know, if this was open source, then maybe someone would have noticed it before. But also, it's just, you know, it's very sad that they missed this. It's not something that you should miss, it's something that you should take a lot more seriously. You know, it's kind of disappointing. But it's only true when a user would input their own seed into the wallet. So if you just create the seed and didn't restore it, you know, you create a seed, write it on a paper and keep it in your safe, then you should never type it and then it should never happen. [01:14:33] Udi Wertheimer: But if you restore the seed into Coinomi, then it probably happened to you. And then at that stage, it was sent to Google for spell checking. And if it was sent to Google, you can assume that it is probably in the logs, you know, the logs that Google servers keep. And probably some Google employees or contractors have access to that. Maybe, you know, some external people who are somehow involved with the spellcheck program have some access to that. So it's possible that someone affiliated with Google in some way might have found this and used this to steal the funds. [01:15:12] Udi Wertheimer: One thing that's particularly disappointing though, in my opinion, is the way that this bug was disclosed, the way it was announced to the public. There was this person who apparently used Coinomi and he claims that the funds that he has were stolen this way, and then he looked into what could be happening and found this bug. [01:15:34] Udi Wertheimer: So first of all, you can't be sure what exactly happened there, but that's what he claims, and then he started to discuss it with Coinomi, and he wanted Coinomi to pay for the funds that he lost, and they did not agree. And he kind of threatened them that if they don't agree, he will publish the details about the bug, and that's what he did. Which is, you know, if he really lost funds, then I can understand why someone would be annoyed about it, but you need to also think about the people who are affected except for you, except from you. [01:16:07] Udi Wertheimer: You know, if you publish this bug and everyone hears about it, then, you know, let's say someone is an ex-employee in Google and he was just fired last week, but he still has all the logs on his laptop. So now that he's hearing about it, he's going to search through the logs that he still has to find the private keys and steal them. And if the disclosure was, you know, submitted more responsibly, then, you know, probably some people would be saved from losing their funds because they would have time to move funds before the details were exposed. So this is kind of unfortunate. [01:16:42] Udi Wertheimer: And I hope that people don't take example from this. This is not the way to disclose a bug. You know, you don't want to run off to Twitter and Reddit and whatever and scream the details of the vulnerability before people have a chance to try to protect themselves. You should first warn the people that might be using Coinomi, that they can, you know, that they move their funds, and only later expose the actual details. [01:17:08] Udi Wertheimer: And it's too bad that not Coinomi and not the person who discovered this did it in a responsible way, which is very unfortunate. I hope that people don't lose money because of this. [01:17:21] Vlad Costea: And when you think about it, there are so many wallet options that are not Coinomi. You have Jaxx and Exodus and lots of options that are not open source, and there is no way for you to check or to be able to tell if they are very secure. You just rely on the reputation of a company which claims that they have never had incidents. [01:17:47] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, there are quite a lot of closed source wallets. And if someone's listening to this and you have a closed source wallet, please stop using it. You know, tell the developers of that wallet that you only use open source wallets, and move to an open source wallet until they, you know, until they comply. Because it's just not secure. It's just not safe, and it's not worth it just because it maybe supports a few more coins or because it's a little prettier. It's not worth to lose your money over this. So yeah, I hope people use this as a warning sign. [01:18:25] Vlad Costea: So what kind of wallets would you recommend? As in, you can name a few for both desktop and mobile wallets. [01:18:33] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, so if you really want to do things right, we just talked about using your own full node. So you can use your own full node as a wallet. It's not the most friendly and some things like backing it up are a little difficult. It's going to get better, because in future versions of Bitcoin Core, you're going to be able to use your hardware wallets like Trezor and Ledger and connect them to Bitcoin Core. So you get the best of both worlds. You have private keys protected by an easy to use hardware wallet while you use Bitcoin Core as the software, which respects your privacy and, you know, respects your security too. [01:19:16] Udi Wertheimer: So that's a good option if you're like very advanced. If not, then I think that Electrum is a pretty good wallet. You know, it has a very good reputation. It's open source. It's been around for a very long time. It has great features, but it's not too difficult to use. And you can use it, you know, both as a software wallet or you can connect your Trezor and Ledger, whatever, and then you get hardware wallet security. So it's great. It's available on Android too and also on desktop. [01:19:52] Udi Wertheimer: And one great thing about it is that you can connect it to your full node. So if you have a full node running on, you know, a Raspberry Pi at home, and you have Electrum on your Android device or on your laptop, then you can connect the two, so your Electrum client uses your full node for privacy and for security. So I think that's the best of both worlds. It's still a little difficult to set up, but you only have to set it up once, and once you do, you have like a very, very robust solution. So yeah, I think it's a great way to use a wallet, and that's what we helped people do with the full node workshop that we did in the Bitcoin Embassy in Tel Aviv last week that we spoke about in the beginning. [01:20:37] Udi Wertheimer: So yeah, that's definitely the best setup I think for most users, if they're willing to do the configuration bit that is one time. [01:20:47] Vlad Costea: What about mobile wallets? Because I know that probably the most popular version or implementation is the Samourai Wallet, which is only available on Android. [01:20:59] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah. [01:21:01] Vlad Costea: But what if you have an iPhone? [01:21:05] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, so Samourai is pretty good on Android. Electrum is also great on Android. Both of them are good wallets. For iOS, there are less great options, unfortunately, right now. Well, I don't know, I think there's Edge Wallet, which is open source and supports a few coins, and it can also connect to Electrum servers if you want. So it's not bad. I think there's also, well, there's GreenAddress by Blockstream, which is a whole other thing because it's also a multisig wallet, so it's a little bit more complicated. [01:21:50] Udi Wertheimer: And I think they're working on new versions for Android and iOS. So the current versions are not very friendly, but the new ones should be better. But yeah, iOS is not as great with regards to wallet options as Android is. Another option is to use a Lightning wallet. So you can use something like Zap on mobile, and if you do that, it supports both Lightning and also normal Bitcoin transactions. So it's also a little difficult to set up because you have to have a node at home that you connect to. [01:22:28] Udi Wertheimer: But once you have it, you can kind of manage everything from the Zap mobile wallet and you get both normal Bitcoin transactions and Lightning transactions. So, maybe a nice trade-off. [01:22:42] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's kind of ironic when you think about it, because Android is more susceptible to get malware and get infected than the iOS device, and it has many more points of failure in terms of you can connect an SD card to hack the software, and it's much easier to meddle with the operating system. Whereas in the case of iPhones, I know that they even had that issue with the FBI, which was unable to crack the security without the assistance of the company. So I guess as a device in itself, the iPhone is more secure to store your private keys. But the App Store is less friendly with these applications. It's more authoritarian, to call it so. [01:23:33] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah, it's true. I'm not sure that's the reason though. You know, in the past, Apple would not allow Bitcoin apps in the App Store, but that was a long time ago. I mean, they've been allowing Bitcoin wallets for years now. It's just that not, you know, not a lot of developers necessarily picked up the gauntlet. There are some apps available, but I think Android has better wallet apps right now. I know that Samourai is working on an iOS version, so that should be great once it's out. [01:24:10] Udi Wertheimer: Electrum, unfortunately, I don't think anyone is working on an iOS version for it. So yeah, but hopefully with time iPhone users get some options too. I mean, they have options right now, don't get me wrong. I just think Android has better wallets. [01:24:31] Vlad Costea: You know, I'm actually thinking right now, and it's a thought that I have been having for more than a year, I guess. You look at these cryptocurrency projects, and you see, actually Bitcoin projects, and you see how they get a lot of funding and there's a lot of money flowing into the space. But it doesn't really look like people invest too much in user experiences and promotion and, you know, stuff like this which makes products friendlier and more accessible. [01:25:06] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, and I think it makes sense because it's not that easy to make money that way. You know, if you just make a wallet and make it very friendly and it's open source and you release it, how are you going to make money off of that? So, I mean, you know, during the bull run of 2017, people had, you know, like, ShapeShift integration inside the wallet, so they got some affiliate fees when people converted between coins, but that's not sustainable. I don't think people are going to continuously switch between coins multiple times a day for this to be a very profitable strategy for wallet makers. [01:25:53] Udi Wertheimer: So, you know, it's not very clear how people make money from wallet development. I'm actually, you know, I'm optimistic about what Casa is doing, because they're trying to make a commercial product they can charge people for in order to use in their mobile devices. And that, you know, I think that makes a lot of sense. If you want to keep your coins safe and you're not very technical and you want an easy way to do it, then you pay some company to do it, and you should want to pay them, because if you pay someone and you're their client, then you can expect to get a better service than someone who gives it away for free. [01:26:35] Udi Wertheimer: Because then you're the product, right? So if you want to protect significant funds, you probably want to pay someone to protect you. So I think that's an interesting model. I'm optimistic about it. And there's also the open source model, which, you know, most of the times doesn't produce the most user-friendly software, maybe because developers, you know, they want to solve the problem, and then after the problem is solved, they're less interested usually in making it look nice. [01:27:03] Udi Wertheimer: But whatever the reason may be, you have the open source product, so if that's what you want, and you want something that doesn't cost you money but requires you to be more involved, then you can use that. And if you want someone else to do it for you, then you have options to pay for the service, and I think this makes a lot of sense too. So I think that if we get a good ecosystem that combines both these options, then we'll be in a very good place. So yeah, I hope that this is where we're going, hopefully. [01:27:39] Vlad Costea: I think we should get to a slightly more political discussion. And I should ask you where you see Bitcoin 10 years from now in relation to governments of the world. Do you think that they will be more, I don't know, open and friendly about Bitcoin or will they become oppressive and protective of their own currency and see Bitcoin as a threat? [01:28:04] Udi Wertheimer: I don't know. I don't like making predictions. I really don't know. It could go either way, I guess. I think some people believe that Bitcoin is like this huge threat to governments. I don't see it exactly that way. I think I see it more as a competition than a threat. You know, people might choose to use Bitcoin instead of fiat currency for some things. And maybe some people may choose to use it for all things, but, you know, it's not going to replace it. And having a competition is going to improve the way that governments work. [01:28:47] Udi Wertheimer: You know, it's not that people aren't going to pay taxes anymore. But, you know, governments will have to offer better return for taxes that people pay, for example, because they know that people who will be very dedicated might be able to avoid it. And also, governments will have to offer better financial services and support better financial services by the open market, and support competition in the banking sector, because otherwise, again, Bitcoin could take away a lot of their business. So, yeah, I see it more as a competition than a threat. [01:29:34] Udi Wertheimer: And I hope that most governments will see it that way too. Obviously, not all of them. I think that, you know, if a government is on the verge of complete shutdown and complete, you know, something like Venezuela and so on, then maybe they will push back more because it's kind of a survival thing. Hopefully it won't happen globally, but only in a contained manner. And then, you know, I think it can be very useful to people who live in countries that are on the verge of bankruptcy. [01:30:15] Udi Wertheimer: And for other countries, it can be also useful because people will have an alternative and they'll have a competition to choose from. I don't think that we'll see Bitcoin make governments disappear. I don't want to even call it optimistic. I don't think this is an optimistic scenario. But, you know, whatever it is, I don't think we'll get there. But I don't know. I'm not in the business of making predictions. I have no idea. So, yeah. [01:30:43] Vlad Costea: When I usually think of Bitcoin, I see it as an invention of decades of discoveries in cryptography and computer science, which all took place in the United States of America. So I regard Bitcoin as an American invention generally, regardless of what nationality Satoshi had. If you look at the references that he had in the white paper, then you're going to find Ralph Merkle and Hal Finney. And I don't think... I think Adam Back is British, but nevertheless, he comes from that school of thought, and also Wei Dai with his b-money. [01:31:24] Vlad Costea: He also went to, I think it was George Washington University or something. So he's American. Okay. If you look at Bitcoin and the way it works right now in world politics, you can say that it works against the agenda of the United States in terms of international affairs, and you see how people find ways to finance maybe Venezuela, which is under embargo by the United States, and they find ways to send money to North Korea or to Palestine or to all these countries which the United States is not in very good terms with. [01:32:08] Vlad Costea: And it makes you wonder at some point, like, if this is just the kind of world that we live in, where you have a few world powers which control everything and make use of their leverage, then are we actually helping Russia or China by using Bitcoin instead of the US dollar? [01:32:30] Udi Wertheimer: I mean, that's one way to look at it. Another way to look at it would be that it's also helping the United States realize that the times are changing and it's time to adapt. And the earlier the US government realized that, it's probably going to be better for that government and for the people who live there. So, yeah. You know, it's not necessarily a bad thing to, you know, kind of shake someone and tell them, "Listen, the reality around you is changing." So, yeah, I think it can be helpful. [01:33:07] Udi Wertheimer: And I think that, again, offering some alternative to someone's point of view can help them and not just bring them down. It depends on how you choose to handle that. And I'm not American, but I'm, you know, somewhat optimistic about the ability of the United States to adapt and to, you know, make the best of any situation. So, yeah, could be good. Could be a good thing for everyone involved. Depends on how you react to it, I think. [01:33:43] Vlad Costea: Usually that's what I also think, that by my personal involvement in Bitcoin and refusing to work as much with the government, I make it become more accountable and more friendly towards dialogue. Whereas before the invention of Bitcoin, they were holding a monopoly in terms of finances. So when you have an option and there's competition, it's usually very good and healthy. [01:34:10] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, yeah, I agree. Yeah, let's hope. [01:34:17] Vlad Costea: We can hope. It's terrible when you think about it and you realize that you might be helping the kind of actors that you don't like. [01:34:30] Udi Wertheimer: Well, I mean, when you're using cash, are you helping actors that you don't like? I mean, I don't know, when you're using Twitter, are you helping actors that you don't like? Because, you know, some governments use Twitter to try to affect perception. So do you think that by using Twitter too, you're helping them? I don't think so. You know, all of these things are tools that we all use. And I do think, you know, what do we stand for, right? [01:35:06] Udi Wertheimer: As a society, as a community, what do we stand for? What are we trying to do? I mean, we could shut everything down and then we wouldn't be helping anyone else, but I don't think this is what we want. So I think what we want, I think what I want, is to, you know, to have the options and to make the best use of them and to have them available for people for good. You know, and if you want to do that, you have to make it available to everyone. [01:35:36] Udi Wertheimer: That's just how it works. And then the question becomes, are we able to use it for good more than we're able to use it for, you know, not good? And that's an open question, I guess, but I'm optimistic. I'm optimistic about it, and I think that, you know, the benefits that we can have from this open financial community is much better than, or much more important than, the way that some people may use it for criminal activities and so on. Because, you know, criminals will do criminal activity. [01:36:16] Udi Wertheimer: It's not because of Bitcoin. You know, they'll do it because that's the line of work that they chose for themselves and they make it work, so that's what they do. And, you know, I don't think we should limit ourselves and limit the way that we were able to transact with each other just because maybe sometimes people will use it for other things. You know, that's just how the world works. It's on us to show that you can do good with those things. That's the, yes, that's the point. [01:36:52] Vlad Costea: I completely agree, and I think that it's our responsibility as individuals acting in this large-scale economic experiment to portray the good side and what can actually be done in a very ethical way of improving what we have and bringing something which is beneficial to the current financial system. But we should not allow that side, which involves Lambo bros and people who want to go to the moon and criminals and everybody who portrays a very distorted image of what it's all about, take over the narrative. And even though the media loves these people and they love presenting the exceptions and portraying them as the rule. [01:37:47] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah. I mean, I guess one of the nice things about Bitcoin is that we don't get to allow or disallow anything. You know, people will be attracted to whatever they want to, and the media will write about whatever it wants to, and that's fine, and Bitcoin should be able to support all of the possible use cases, even if I personally don't like some of them. I do think that it's important Bitcoin supports all use cases. I mean, I do agree with you that we should, you know, show more of the more interesting and unique things we can do with Bitcoin, as opposed to just betting on shitcoins and on penny stocks on CoinMarketCap. [01:38:31] Udi Wertheimer: That's for sure. That being said, you know, with things like money laundering and people buying drugs or whatever, I don't think we should take too much of an effort of kind of fighting this narrative, because it's just such a small thing. Money laundering and terror financing with Bitcoin is probably very, very, very small, very insignificant in the global scale compared to people using cash or just using wire transfers or whatever. So it's mostly FUD, at least at this point. So, I don't think we should pay too much attention to that. Some people like to generate FUD and that's fine. We shouldn't waste too much time on that, I think. [01:39:24] Vlad Costea: And I think it's useful to have these positive expectations and thoughts. As a way of ending this interview, yeah, we have been speaking for over an hour and a half, and that's more than a lot of people will be willing to listen to, according to my experience. [01:39:40] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, for sure. [01:39:42] Vlad Costea: But I'm very happy that we had to do these kinds of discussions, and I don't think we had much of a debate, just because we agree on so many issues. [01:39:56] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, we agree on too many stuff, too much stuff. [01:39:59] Vlad Costea: That's dangerous. That's a problem. [01:40:04] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, but it was a great talk. So really, thanks for having me. [01:40:08] Vlad Costea: Thank you very much. Can you please tell the audience who is still listening at this point how they can follow you and maybe get in touch? [01:40:17] Udi Wertheimer: Yeah, so the best way to follow me is on Twitter. It's just @UdiWertheimer on Twitter, and hopefully you'll have a link somewhere, because I shouldn't try to spell it out. And yeah, my DMs, my direct messages are open. I don't check very frequently, but they're open. So if you have something very important to say to me in private, you can try that. That's it. [01:40:42] Vlad Costea: Really great, so thank you for joining this. And I look forward to listening to it when it's finally published. [01:40:51] Udi Wertheimer: Great, thank you. Thanks so much. [01:40:54] Vlad Costea: So, talk to you later. Bye. [01:40:56] Udi Wertheimer: Bye. ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote one-on-one audio/video call in English between host Vlad Costea and guest Udi Wertheimer (a non-native English speaker), with no music intro or sponsor reads in the transcript. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 7 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (134 chunks) and 32 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 1 of 1 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Fixed names (Udi Wertheimer, Nick Szabo, David Chaum, Aaron van Wirdum, Luke Dashjr, Electrum Personal Server, Bitcoin embassies, Satoshi Roundtable); removed "Udi Revealed", "you know, money" loop, "Thank you", "per capita"; restored dropped "That being said, discussion is always good" at 00:10:30 from re-check; fixed "own country", "live off", "can't just live", "makes sense too", "debates or making decisions"; removed misattributed "Oh, yeah" in Vlad's turn; Restored dropped "legal case" sentence and "So I'm kind of optimistic about it" from second ASR/re-check; removed hallucinations "As always, thanks for watching", "Udi Revealed.", "Sanyam Bhutani:" label; fixed walk around, straight line, Chris Belcher, JoinMarket, Wasabi Wallet, CoinJoin, retain, amounts, who you're doing business with; repaired Vlad/Udi boundary "Yeah," at 00:21:50; split long monologues; Removed "Udi Reve/Revealed" artifacts and "Thank you for your question... mic" hallucination (restored Udi's real end of turn at 00:43:24 from Scribe/Qwen); Cyphernomicon, money (Mari), JoinMarket, Silk Road, "non-aligned" per Qwen; split Udi interjections (Yeah; I fully agree, I hope Bitcoin can save us; some number) out of Vlad's turns; removed trailing "you"; Fixed 00:44:12 speaker (Vlad continues question); removed hallucinations "Thank you for joining us... first question" and "Osama Bin-", relabelled "Udi Reve" turn to Udi Wertheimer; restored dropped words from second ASR/Scribe ("the world", "to survive, we need to strengthen, you know, the internal", "But they don't care about anything else..."); repaired split turns (Vlad/Udi "Yeah, so", "about it?"), fixed "GEEs"→"these", "follow through", "he's not", "more than I do about", SegWit/SegWit2x, FUD; Removed hallucinations ("Udi Reve: Thanks for joining us", "As always, thanks for watching", "Thank you for having me", repeated "Udi Revealed"); fixed SegWit2x, Casa, Pierre Rochard, full node (was "phone number"/"Fulno"), "bull run", "running one at all", "multiple assets"; restored dropped speech at 01:02:13 and 01:08:56 from other engines; split interjections (Oh, yeah / Oh, nice / Yeah) and repaired mid-sentence speaker boundaries; relabelled Udi Reve as Udi Wertheimer; Fixed "Coinomi is an open source" to "isn't open source"; Koinomi→Coinomi, Samurai→Samourai Wallet, green address→GreenAddress, Zapp→Zap, Kasa→Casa, shapeshift→ShapeShift, work development→wallet development, one apps→wallet apps, walls→best of both worlds; restored dropped speech at 01:14:58, 01:16:32, 01:20:10 (replacing podcast-title hallucination) and 01:22:42–01:23:00 from second ASR/re-check; removed "Udi Revealed" loops; split Udi's "Yeah." interjection out of Vlad's 01:20:47 turn and removed misattributed "Yeah." at 01:23:00; Restored dropped speech at 01:27:15 and "political"; "in soil"→Venezuela, Ralph Merkle, Wei Dai, b-money, shitcoins, FUD ("fun"); removed "Udi Revealed" and "As a Bitcoin expert..." hallucinations; split interjections (Udi "Yea