Title: S2 E3: Igor Artamonov on Bitcoin's Competitive Advantage Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Igor Artamonov, former lead developer of ETCDEV (Ethereum Classic) and developer of the Emerald wallet Published: 2019-06-29 Duration: 1:17:26 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2019-06-29_igor_artomonov.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2019-06-29_igor_artomonov.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:29] Vlad Costea: Hello and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover. I am Vlad and this episode's guest is Igor Artamonov, or Artamonov, who used to be the lead developer of ETCDEV, and is a person who is very much involved in development and the research involved in blockchains. And it's interesting that it was under his lead that a project, an altcoin like Ethereum Classic, ended up getting or learning as many lessons from Bitcoin as it was possible. And as you can see today, ETC ended up having a fixed supply, just like Bitcoin. [00:01:26] Vlad Costea: It started having a different mining reward, just like Bitcoin. And to some extent, it's interesting to see how a project which started as something else ended up getting as close as possible as Bitcoin, respecting the ideas of immutability and decentralization. So I'm really happy to have you, Igor, and I'm looking forward to hearing more responses from you on the topic. [00:01:52] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, yeah, hi, Vlad. Thank you for having me. Yeah, thank you for nice words about my work on ETC. Yeah, I'll be happy to answer all the questions. So yeah, let's start. [00:02:10] Vlad Costea: So usually when I speak to ETC people, they say that they are also Bitcoiners and they like the values of Bitcoin, but ETC has more of an extension, which allows for smart contracts, Turing-complete functions. So what do you see are the similarities between ETC and Bitcoin, both in terms of protocol and in terms of community? [00:02:37] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, that's a good question. And there's two parts actually, as you say, the community and technology. I wouldn't agree that community actually has many people from Bitcoin. I think it's a separate community. It's not Bitcoin people. We have more Ethereum people than Bitcoin people. Because it's not about money, it's about smart contracts, decentralized applications and so on. But from a technology perspective, speaking about blockchain itself and why we use blockchain, we have a lot of similarities on this level. So we are more close to Bitcoin vision about immutability, decentralization and so on, rather than the ETH view on the technology side. And that's how the initial community of ETC was formed. So basically we disagreed with the Ethereum Foundation decision on bailout or hard fork transaction reversal, because we believe in immutability. And community just followed the original chain at that moment. And here we are, we have Ethereum Classic. [00:04:03] Vlad Costea: Yeah, while we were having the preliminary discussion prior to this interview, you told me that you research blockchains, and since this is a Bitcoin-specific show, you said that Bitcoin is in a very privileged position as opposed to other projects. And what do you think are the advantages that Bitcoin has right now over other projects? [00:04:29] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, so you mean my talk, my articles about decentralization? And I think that all blockchains are far from being fully decentralized, but Bitcoin is the most close, and it's because of many aspects. So I was speaking about different factors such as foundation, single team, and concentration of development, mining and everything. So Bitcoin is much better than any other. And I think it's, yeah, just historically, it happened this way, because it had a long time to develop technology, and nobody thought basically about any centralization at that moment. [00:05:22] Igor Artamonov: It was just some ideas, implementation, some ideas. Others try to make it much faster, and to make it faster you need some concentration of power, of decision-making process. So all other blockchains are centralized just because they want to compete with Bitcoin. But the main decentralization vehicle of Bitcoin, I think, is its community. It's different opinions, different views in community, and all these fights is actually good for Bitcoin. I mean, people say it's a community, so there is toxic, which I disagree. It just, you know, nobody has enough power to make a decision, so that, and people are looking for best decision. [00:06:16] Igor Artamonov: If everyone would agree on the same decision, you don't need blockchain at all. That's the whole point of blockchain, that it will work even if you hate each other. You can still transfer bitcoins between you and your worst enemy. And yeah, it will work in the same way as if you're friends. So if you already agree on everything, why don't you send a bank transfer or PayPal or anything else? So that's the whole point of blockchain, to fight. And so they built it led to this community that disagrees with everything. [00:07:01] Igor Artamonov: Community fights any changes that can break something, damage in some way Bitcoin. So they tried to protect this in different principles, including immutability and decentralization and so on. We don't see anything like that in the other blockchains. When Ethereum Classic started, actually, we had a similar community. We had a lot of heated debates about everything. So I believed that it would be a second blockchain, decentralized blockchain, with community that makes final decision. And community is, you know, it's some broad, some, just some people, so you can't control it. And the community is the final decision maker. It makes blockchain decentralized, in my opinion. [00:08:12] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. And one other argument that I heard about Bitcoin's superiority is that the enthusiasts were there even when it was worth nothing. They were developing for it, they were creating wallets, and they were trying to make sense out of it. In a time when there was no VC funding, there was no way to actually see the potential of this. It wasn't so obvious that it was actually digital gold. There was no ideology constructed around it. It was just people who are technical and they were trying to figure out what they can make out of this invention of Satoshi. [00:08:54] Vlad Costea: And that's why it's unique and it's going to have people who work for it regardless of the price action. Whereas in the case of other altcoins, which seemed promising in the beginning and they received a lot of money, you can see how interest diminishes as the price goes down. That's not something that really happens in Bitcoin development. It's there no matter what, and I guess the fact that some companies which do centralize maybe the development, like Blockstream, when they release the satellite and they try to open source everything and encourage young developers to enter the space by reviewing the code or by forking the applications into something that they can find useful. [00:09:41] Vlad Costea: That's something that's unique to the Bitcoin culture, and maybe other altcoins didn't have this kind of start. [00:09:50] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, yeah, I agree with that. It happened basically because Bitcoin has much, much more time for developing all these open source, all technologies, ideas. And as I said before, other blockchains are trying to work faster and it leads to centralization. And people are working not for idea, because for idea you can work really fast. I mean, you will work as maybe 10 developers, because you'll be more focused on your ideas, but still you're not going to have enough time for that compared to companies that can hire, you know, 10 developers, 100 developers to do the same. [00:10:40] Igor Artamonov: Organized process. So it's hard to compete with them. But yeah, I believe that people who focus on their ideas and beliefs and working towards some goal they see, maybe only them see it's better for blockchain, for decentralized blockchain, and it leads to the current position of Bitcoin. It has some forks, you know, and none of them is much decentralized and has some, you know, core principles, ideas, vision, independent from blockchain, driven by community or by developers or something. So they... It's much harder for them to develop something similar, this open infrastructure around blockchain. [00:11:45] Igor Artamonov: Not necessarily wallets, open source code, but some, you know, a way how anyone can participate, can join community, do something useful and leave at any moment. [00:11:57] Vlad Costea: Yeah, right. Also, there is the argument about Bitcoin having the immaculate conception, as you had the completely decentralized project with no pre-mines, and I guess very few other projects can claim to have such a development early on. I think even Ethereum had a big pre-mine. And now ETH, the Ethereum Foundation side, has some issues with the monetary policy, where they allow the supply to increase to a greater extent than it was initially planned. And that's not something that is going to happen to Bitcoin, as the people who hold on to it and the people who mine it understand that it has value specifically because they agree with the initial rules. [00:12:48] Igor Artamonov: Mhm, yeah. I agree, I think that a cryptocurrency shouldn't have any pre-mine. It changed, just from the start, the distribution of power. I mean, you can mine, but you have the same rights as others. So initial developers of Bitcoin, they kind of pre-mined because they're the only ones who know how to do that, and they just used this chance to pre-mine. But it's acceptable because they believed in the future of technology, so they started to use their computer power to mine Bitcoin. [00:13:35] Igor Artamonov: But it wasn't like, you know, as some other altcoins just put in genesis block distribution of coins, like it happened in Ethereum when they distributed almost 70% of all circulating coins to some initial investors and team and so on, foundation. That's, I don't know, it's just too much. It's crazy. [00:14:06] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and you said that the initial developers of Bitcoin were also the earliest miners and maybe that they had this kind of unfair advantage. But at the time they had no idea it would even reach $1 per Bitcoin. So when Laszlo Hanyecz, I'm not sure how you pronounce his name, but once he ordered pizzas with Bitcoin, he actually gave it value, as opposed to just thinking, "Okay, we have these coins which you can get by running this client. And what can you do with them? Well, we can establish a market, but what can you actually buy?" [00:14:47] Vlad Costea: And it was very philosophical in this regard in the early days, when even Satoshi was trying to explain how Bitcoin can be used. So it's very different right now. Like, maybe that Grin is the latest pure project which doesn't have a pre-mine and tries to be as fair as possible. And even the developers of Grin have difficulties trying to break even with their finances. But even in its case, there was a lot of... it just entered the market in a point where there's a lot of investors. [00:15:25] Vlad Costea: And there's a lot of speculation. And you could see within the first few days that it went to $10 or something. Whereas in the case of Bitcoin, it took like five years to get to $10. [00:15:39] Igor Artamonov: I don't know actually how... I think longer. How many years? I don't know. But yeah, you're right about Grin. They're doing everything right, I think. No pre-mine, no foundation, no these public figures, leaders, CEO, distributed team, everything is just right. But they attracted some venture investors or just investors, I don't know, who mined, who bought some coins. And I don't think it's a problem, because we live in a different time now, not Bitcoin. Now everyone understands the value of this digitalized coin. So they got the price, the value just from first days and that's fine. It's not a problem, I think. So everyone sees this value in this development and it will help the technology. [00:16:47] Vlad Costea: Right, and I think it's so unique to have this phenomenon which comes apparently out of nowhere, depends on where you stand. If you just look at the financial crisis, you're going to say, "Okay, Bitcoin is the response to that." But if you look at the history of cypherpunks and all the other attempts to create something like Bitcoin, you'll see that maybe b-money by Wei Dai was close to Bitcoin, and also Nick Szabo's Bit Gold was also very similar. So it comes from a long tradition of innovation which happened in the United States maybe since the 1970s or something. [00:17:28] Vlad Costea: And maybe Bitcoin is not as cypherpunk as, let's say, Monero, as the ideal of cypherpunks was to have privacy, as opposed to sound money. But it's still the invention that sparked all of this phenomenon and everything that we call today the blockchain industry or the crypto market. There would be none of this without Bitcoin, and there was no way to predict that this would actually happen in the first years. [00:17:58] Vlad Costea: So I guess that's what also makes it unique. But beyond the historic value, it's interesting that the most brilliant of developers, or at least the most committed of them, have stuck to Bitcoin as opposed to migrating to other VC-funded projects which might have paid them a little better. Hmm. [00:18:27] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, that's an interesting moment about developers. So we talked about this, about believing in ideas, or just working and having a job. It's two different ways of doing something. And when you believe in something, I think you're just going to be more effective for reaching your goals, if you know what you're doing, if you understand your goals. And probably for Bitcoin it worked well. But, yeah, unfortunately, it's a problem because not everyone can afford that. Most likely people can work just on their weekends or evenings, you know, steal time from family. It slows down development of a project. Definitely. [00:19:36] Igor Artamonov: That's why it took so much time, so long for Bitcoin to reach current state. I don't know, but it still allows it to be more focused. And for other blockchains, I don't know. There's some comparison. I'm writing a book about the difference between cars and horses. So, with a car you can reach your final destination much faster and you can control everything, you know, and all this, you know, ways to control the car and speed and so on. But if you have any problems, I don't know. [00:20:25] Igor Artamonov: Basically, you drive, for example, right? You can't drive a car, right? Because you're going to crash it. But if you use a horse, maybe it's slow, but it's going to... I know it's going to, how it's called? It moves you to the destination basically in any state. So it's maybe less effective, but you're going to reach your goal anyway. So that could be applied to all these different ways of organizing development in blockchain. One side is developers who maybe not have enough time, but trying to reach their goals. Another one is they don't have any goal, but just sitting in some office all day and developing what they say to do. [00:21:29] Vlad Costea: Yeah, also, I remember when I read one of your blog posts about your work on ETC, you said that you developed the infrastructure which allowed a lot of exchanges to make millions of dollars by implementing the code that you wrote. And what's perplexing to me in this, I guess we can call it an industry, is that some parties make millions of dollars, maybe billions, and they don't invest back in the protocols. So you have very unfriendly interfaces. The wallets sometimes are hard to figure out by newbies. And while some companies make a lot of money and they bring a lot of investors, they don't put enough into development. [00:22:18] Vlad Costea: They don't put enough to hire the amount of developers required to fulfill a roadmap. Maybe in the case of Bitcoin, it's much more privileged, as they have many more parties which are interested in financing the developers. But in the case of other projects which may bring something that is interesting for Bitcoin, as we know that sidechains are actually a viable solution to scalability, and I guess you were also working on, what were they called? Arbitrum. They were the sidechains which were scaling Ethereum. And if they ended up being created, I guess that would have been a very interesting comparison to make between ETH's sharding and proof of stake and Casper and whatnot, and on the other hand, to have a protocol which actually preserves its proof of work. [00:23:22] Igor Artamonov: So I didn't really get the question. So was it about the exchanges giving back or about scalability solutions? [00:23:33] Vlad Costea: I mean, we can talk either. [00:23:39] Igor Artamonov: Okay, so about exchanges. I don't know, they're probably the only business currently on blockchain. And they make money, definitely make money. Some of them are giving back to developing teams. Maybe there is just... we don't have any organized process, probably, and it's really unclear for all parties how we can collaborate on working on technology. I see some donations from exchanges. Not very big, just small amounts usually. We didn't have much for ETCDEV. We didn't have anything actually. And we talked to some exchange about that, you know, everyone considered ETCDEV as a, I don't know, profitable business, probably. Nobody thought that we just, you know, volunteering for blockchain. For blockchain. [00:25:02] Igor Artamonov: So nobody even thought that they can donate any money to development, and we didn't ask, at least for the first couple of years. So when we contacted exchanges... Yeah, you know, there is another thing actually. We have a lot of these altcoins or ICOs which has a lot of money, like tens of millions, and they want to be listed on exchange and they actually offer money to exchanges. Like, "We're going to pay you and you're going to list us and we're going to give you a manager who is going to answer any questions and everything, everything, to help you with technology." [00:25:48] Igor Artamonov: So many of exchanges actually think that a cryptocurrency will pay them for integration, not opposite. And I received a lot of requests, such requests from different exchanges, from businesses. "Yeah, why you wouldn't pay us for integration of Ethereum Classic in our product, or in our wallet, exchange, or we're not going to integrate it." Nobody thought that we don't have any money for that stuff. So in this situation, asking for money, it looks strange at least for most of them. Like, basically, everyone is paying us, why should we pay you? [00:26:34] Igor Artamonov: It's not how it was, you know, state of things in cryptocurrencies. Only Bitcoin was widely accepted as something decentralized, so nobody expected that Satoshi would pay some exchange to list it on that exchange. [00:26:52] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but this is not just about Satoshi. And I can even think of the case of Bitcoin, where the only viable solution that they found for financing developers was to establish companies like Blockstream or get the developers... Do you hear me now? [00:27:19] Igor Artamonov: Oh, yeah, I hear you. [00:27:21] Vlad Costea: Okay, well... This was embarrassing. [00:27:24] Igor Artamonov: On your side. [00:27:27] Vlad Costea: I think so. I suspect it might be the microphone cable or something. I switched to a different microphone right now. But let me know if it stops. Throughout the episode, did you hear me well? [00:27:42] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, yeah, I heard you well. [00:27:44] Vlad Costea: Okay, so there's that problem part which has to be cut from the final version. Otherwise, the question was about the centralization of funding developers, as in you have decentralized protocols, but the only model which was proven to work was where you have companies like Blockstream, which hire many of the developers, or you have MIT or other academic institutions that can afford to finance this kind of research. And we didn't yet develop the kind of culture where you say, "Let's give away a small percentage of our personal profits that we have made in this particular cryptocurrency, like Bitcoin," so that we can finance the development. It's not really decentralized in the sense that the users are financing it and have a say in the protocol. And in my book, it's much more dangerous to create companies that have too much control. I guess you have the experience with ETC Labs or other entities that try to take over. [00:28:58] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, I actually think that in Bitcoin space we have many companies now working on Bitcoin, so I don't think Blockstream... They are a leading development company, but I don't think they control or can change direction of Bitcoin development. And I believe it's the right path. I mean, I don't think that giving some donations from companies will ever work. And we don't have such examples in other industries, I mean, they are developing something open source that will work on donations. [00:29:51] Igor Artamonov: It usually works in kind of different way, opposite way, like companies hire someone inside the company, work in the office and everything, but works on some open source product which is utilized by that business. So many banks and many internet companies hire such people, and most of the current popular open source projects are developed by these people who getting paid for that work by some company who is interested in results. So it could work for blockchain space as well. And I see it's... [00:30:48] Igor Artamonov: It changes in a similar way in the blockchain space. I see that companies are getting interested in hiring people, exchanges, to work not only on their product, but on some products for industry itself. So, I think there is a good trend for that. [00:31:10] Vlad Costea: Right, but I guess it's easy to draw comparisons to other open source projects that we have, like Linux or Debian or other, you know, open source operating systems, or maybe office solutions or whatnot. But at the same time, these products are not in themselves currencies that have a market value. They actually gain value by becoming useful. And in the case of Bitcoin, you have an asset which has a market valuation. It's very clear how much you're making by investing in its development. [00:31:54] Igor Artamonov: Maybe it's easier, maybe it's more clear how to play the thing for blockchain, for cryptocurrencies. But still speaking about business, they make money in some... They own business operations, not on cryptocurrency, something existing, something that just works. So it's still the same way as it was, as it's sponsored by other companies. So they make money on working on some product, even if it's currency. Their profits made from operations. And it's maybe easier for some, you know, smart contract blockchains to distribute these earnings to developers, probably. [00:32:50] Igor Artamonov: And so we even have some blockchains, some cryptocurrencies, these developer fees, you know, if you create, if you send something, part of it goes to developers. It still needs some centralization, but yeah, it's probably closest to what we're talking about, distributing parts of your income to developers. But it's not necessarily in transfer. It could be different business, right? It could be authorization. Blockchain is really good for identities authorization. It's not necessarily related to currency itself. But you still make money by doing that, like notary services, whatever. [00:33:47] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's actually interesting because I remember reading a tweet by Vitalik Buterin, where he was speaking of imposing some kind of taxation of one Dai for every wallet developer. And it's interesting that when you first started with cryptocurrencies, you basically oppose anything which is centralized and which is planned in this way, and this kind of imposed socialism that you have on a protocol or on an open source project. And the counter for that kind of measure is that you can easily just fork the project and remove that taxation. [00:34:31] Vlad Costea: And the users are going to migrate onto the project which is economically best for their interests. So if they dislike that kind of taxation, they're going to just not use the wallet which uses it. In the case of Bitcoin and maybe in the case of Ethereum Classic, you have this mindset that you have to basically resort to donations. It's all about the open market and trying to demonstrate your value to everybody out there and trying to prove to them why it's important to invest in you. Maybe there is a different way. [00:35:11] Vlad Costea: It would be much more decentralized if users agreed to make small contributions which kept the projects afloat, as there would be no individual pressure or corporate pressure on the developers. And we have the precedent of SegWit2x with current Bitcoin Core developers who more or less were silent about helping the development or reviewing the code, just because they were in good terms with people who are behind the New York Agreement. So they just went on and they made sure that if that project happens, at least it has a proper review. [00:35:52] Igor Artamonov: Mm-hmm. Yeah, if you think about the wallets, it's actually a big problem. So right now I switched to work on wallets and integration infrastructure. And it's, yeah, it's a big problem for wallet developers because everything is expected to be open source, everything is expected to be free, and the users are not going to, I don't know, pay some fees as they do, as they pay to bets, right? But I still believe that... [00:36:34] Igor Artamonov: That the only way to develop blockchain or something is, so first of all, make technology useful for some businesses and for yourself, and then build on top of this. So you becoming a leader of that market because you know technology, you can leverage technology, not because you have some advantage, technological advantage, but you have experience advantage, so you know how to use the technology in the right way. So you can do something better than others and use that advantage to build your business, something profitable for your company. [00:37:13] Igor Artamonov: That's probably a way to work on blockchain. And that's basically what I want to do currently with my new business. And I forgot the third part, about SegWit2x. About SegWit2x. Yeah, I don't know, it's weird, I think it's a political topic. And I'm not really familiar with SegWit. I was looking at this. I was very busy with Ethereum Classic just before, at that moment. So I was looking from that side, what's going to happen with SegWit2x. And I didn't really have any opinion. But for me, it showed actually how community is important for Bitcoin. So community basically decided. So it was, you know, kind of, it wasn't about increasing block size, I think. [00:38:18] Igor Artamonov: It was about taking control of Bitcoin. If some corporates can get control of it or community is to control it. So community won and we still have the same Bitcoin. [00:38:39] Vlad Costea: Right. Usually people agree that in 10 years from now we're still going to have Bitcoin as it's the most decentralized, the most developed project that we currently have. And there seems to be a recurring trend which says that altcoins are going to get drained and eventually disappear. Just like the altcoins that we had back in 2012, like Peercoin, like... I guess I can name a few more, but nobody talks about them anymore. There was also Namecoin. Who knows anything about Namecoin in 2019? It's a dead project. [00:39:19] Vlad Costea: And many of the projects that we have right now, and I can speculate, I guess, about EOS and maybe Tron, which are mostly about marketing, but don't really deliver anything special. They're not going to be as big 10 years from now. Maybe they will disappear. And the market will just converge towards maybe two or three projects. And do you believe that we're going to have sound money, a smart contracts platform, and maybe a privacy coin or something in this line? [00:39:56] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, I don't think we're going to have many cryptocurrencies. There's just no reason for that. Maybe some, you know, corporate coins, it makes sense probably for some, I don't know, some online game, something like that. Just optimized for some business or maybe country-specific coins like that, maybe some stablecoins. [00:40:23] Igor Artamonov: I don't know, coins associated, tied to some stocks, some businesses, that also makes sense. But as a currency, as a global cryptocurrency, we're going to have one or two, maybe three of them. So probably Bitcoin as digital gold. Maybe some privacy coin. I'm not sure which one. I believe in Grin. There is also competing Zcash and Monero. I don't know which one is going to win, but I think that we need privacy, private coins. And actually, I think we need it more than Bitcoin. So Bitcoin is really good for holding, for savings. [00:41:14] Igor Artamonov: But for daily operations, we have Lightning Network, but it still lacks some things that we usually expect and lacks privacy. Maybe we're going to have some sidechain or payment channel on top of Bitcoin with privacy enabled. Maybe Bitcoin will adopt some privacy. And it will change everything. Or maybe we're going to have a cryptocurrency just for privacy, for daily operations, when you just pay for something to... [00:41:52] Igor Artamonov: Your friends, shop online and you don't want to share your, you know, your account information and your history of payments as you do right now with digital payments on Bitcoin. And maybe we need some blockchain. I'm not sure about cryptocurrency, but we probably need some blockchain for running decentralized applications, kind of smart contracts. But not smart contracts as Ethereum is developing for digital finance, for money, basically, their forms. I'm thinking about smart contracts for making agreements, not even between people, but between applications in some decentralized way. [00:42:39] Igor Artamonov: Some applications that can live just in blockchain and can be used from blockchain, for autonomous applications. So we probably need such kind of blockchain as well. And I don't see any blockchain that can fill this niche right now. Well, Ethereum probably is the closest one, but it lacks a lot of features, and they focus on digital finance, on ICOs, on money, and everything, just, you know, changing the direction in the wrong way, I think. But, I mean, they have a different opinion, obviously. [00:43:21] Vlad Costea: Right. It's still difficult to predict anything as the market dynamics just prove to us how hard it is to make any predictions at all. But the constant that we have had in the last maybe 7-8 years has been that Bitcoin has been the king. It was the number one cryptocurrency and there's the largest amount of trust which people put into it. And the other two which were available throughout the years were Litecoin and XRP. And they have been in the top three for a long time. And then Ethereum came in 2000... When was it launched? 2015? [00:44:03] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, about that, I think. I mean, at least at the time, I think I read about it in some '14, maybe, I'm not sure right now, but in 2014 I started to get interested in that and making some experiments, but you know, it was just basically ideas at that moment, it was just murmurs. So I'm not sure when they launched. But by the end of 2015, they already had something, as I remember. Yeah, because, yeah, I was playing with this technology already. [00:44:37] Vlad Costea: Right, so you had these projects which have been prominent in the space and they all delivered something unique in their own respect, maybe except for Litecoin, which is a carbon copy of Bitcoin, right now trying to implement confidential transactions. But other than that, it served no purpose until maybe 2017. But that's not the topic of this discussion. And it's difficult at this point, I guess, to step in and provide something so different and so groundbreaking that it's going to turn all heads. [00:45:13] Vlad Costea: Maybe Grin managed to steal some attention. But it's hard to imagine how it's going to grow in the future. And some people already speculate that since so many Blockstream people are involved with Grin development, it might just end up becoming a sidechain for Bitcoin at some point. [00:45:34] Igor Artamonov: I don't know. Yeah, I hope, I hope Grin will be one of the leading blockchains in the future. [00:45:47] Igor Artamonov: I can say something to this, actually. And as we work on, so, okay, I can say we are working on the cryptocurrency wallet, kind of wallet, I wouldn't call it wallet. But yes, it's Emerald, Emerald Wallet currently. And the cryptocurrency that we are considering to use, to give our users access to, so it's Ethereum, Ethereum ETC, but just because of historical reasons, and Bitcoin, Lightning, and Grin. And also we're thinking about some stablecoins. I'm not sure which one. Because I believe stablecoins are important as well. Let's give some safety to people. Not everyone... so, I mean, if we expect that people will use it on a daily basis, they're not, you know, hoping for future. It's much easier to think in local currencies for most of the people rather than in bitcoins, which, you know, is pretty volatile, volatile, and everything. [00:47:08] Igor Artamonov: So, let's say, technology that I believe in is Bitcoin, Lightning and Grin. [00:47:19] Vlad Costea: Really? So you lost all faith in Ethereum? [00:47:25] Igor Artamonov: I don't know. I'm looking where it's going to, but I think it's... any, I mean, ETC or ETH, they're losing their position, I think. And I'm not quite sure where Ethereum is moving to. Ethereum 2.0 and everything. It's going to be different. And it has unclear perspectives for me. So we are supporting it in our wallet and in our infrastructure right now. But I'm not sure that it will stay the same in, I don't know, in a couple of years. Because a lot of things have changed, and... [00:48:18] Igor Artamonov: A lot of problems in Ethereum, scalability problems and everything, which is unclear how it can be solved. But now, I don't see 2.0 as a scalability solution as well, so... [00:48:34] Vlad Costea: No, it's insane how it went with CryptoKitties, which basically filled the blocks and made the network too congested and proved the limitations of the protocol and all the scalability plans. And it pushed the entire development team to find something urgent to scale. And so far, they even at some point discouraged developers from deploying decentralized applications on the blockchain. And they said, "Why don't you use the testnet or try to migrate to some other platform?" And they lost a lot to protocols like EOS, I guess. And like... Tron, but I'm not sure how many developers actually work for Tron. [00:49:21] Vlad Costea: But you lose a lot when you start with maybe too many promises about becoming a world computer, about allowing every decentralized application to run on your blockchain. And then, not even the Ethereum Foundation runs an archival node, which contains every transaction occurring on the blockchain since its inception. [00:49:49] Igor Artamonov: So, archive node is actually different. It's not the same as Bitcoin. So there are basically three modes on Ethereum. So you have a light node, you have full node with all history, with all transactions, and archive node with additional information from the transactions, like what exactly happened. So transaction can contain, you know, smart contract calls and all changes related to that call. An archive node, it's basically archives of changes during smart contract execution, which could be a lot of changes. Yeah, it requires a lot of resources. [00:50:32] Igor Artamonov: It requires an SSD drive, and I can run it on my server. I have enough space for archive node of Ethereum Classic, but for Ethereum it's just too much. So everyone has to rely on full node. I mean, for most of the businesses and most of users, you don't need archive node. You have enough information in full node. But if you need some additional security or you need extra information like block explorer, and I'm running block explorer for Ethereum Classic currently, you need to have archive node for that. [00:51:16] Igor Artamonov: There is no other way. So it's, yeah, it's expensive. And changing to Ethereum 2.0, you still need to have the archive node of all subchains or shards, so it doesn't change anything for business anyway. [00:51:43] Vlad Costea: Right. It's still difficult, though, as the technology is young and people with different backgrounds step in and try to project their various visions onto the project. And even in the case of Bitcoin, it was the same with Mike Hearn and Jeff Garzik, and maybe even Gavin Andresen, when they were basically the leaders of the protocol and they were the most important and influential developers involved. They would think... I remember BIP 101, issued by Gavin Andresen, which proposed to increase the block size according to Moore's Law, and basically double the block size according to a determined amount of time. [00:52:32] Vlad Costea: And it actually took people to realize that it's hard to synchronize the blockchain and it's hard to make everybody update to the latest version. And even right now when you look at the nodes being deployed on the Bitcoin network, you see that very few of them actually use the latest version. And it takes a few months until they converge towards something on which they agree that is the good version. It took more than two years to adopt SegWit. So they realized, I guess, in time that hard forks are difficult, and Ethereum, I guess, has learned a few hard lessons about hard forking too often. [00:53:16] Vlad Costea: As I remember, the last time ETH had a hard fork, they had some issues and they delayed it a few times. I think it was called Constantinople. [00:53:26] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, yeah, right. Yeah. But they, so yeah, they delayed it once, actually, for like a month. But it wasn't because of some adoption from miners or from users, because, you know, Ethereum is more centralized than Bitcoin. And they jumped from just 10% of network to 40% of network in one day. Almost a third of the network upgraded in one day, or maybe not. I don't know how exactly it happened, but it turns out the Ethereum Foundation or someone has some power to say, "Users, you have to upgrade today." [00:54:18] Igor Artamonov: But later they found a bug in the hard fork and they downgraded again in one day from 50% to the same 10%. People downgraded in one day. Yeah, downgrade is different actually. It's some coordination to avoid failure. Everyone understands the dangers of that. So everyone wants to upgrade to avoid any losses. But upgrade is usually a slow process. People are upgrading their machine slowly and it takes months and months, especially for Bitcoin. And we came to that in Ethereum Classic as well. [00:55:07] Igor Artamonov: It was really hard to convince people, miners, exchanges, to upgrade their software. A lot of communications, emails, 99% of emails are just ignored. I mean, we just don't have any contacts in some exchanges, so we just found, you know, ticket form or email somewhere on the website and trying to contact them, and I guess nobody reads these emails. [00:55:37] Vlad Costea: Right. It's never easy with these protocols and with communication and working with people who have different expectations of everything. But anyway, I was about to ask you about your personal influences and your cypherpunk idols, maybe? I guess the previous generation of developers was not involved in any way in this blockchain movement, but they were trying to invent something which eventually converged and materialized into Bitcoin. So, do you have any favorite authors like Tim May or Nick Szabo, which you read with great pleasure? [00:56:21] Igor Artamonov: You know, I definitely have. I don't know, I don't think I should prioritize them or tell some specific names or something like that. I don't know if I need someone or something. I'm not sure. [00:56:44] Vlad Costea: About titles. Okay. Usually, I enjoy reading stuff that was published maybe 20, 30 years ago. I remember reading something from David Chaum, which was mind-blowing. He was so ahead of his time. And his vision ended up being applied into something that works maybe three decades later, but that's very impressive. Yeah. By the way, what do you think of David Chaum's Elixxir project? [00:57:21] Igor Artamonov: I'm not quite sure what I can say. I'm not sure actually I read it. [00:57:33] Vlad Costea: Don't bother to look it up, but it's still interesting to see somebody return after a few decades of silence and say, "Hey, I'm launching a new project." And he promises scalability and decentralization and privacy all at the same time. [00:57:50] Igor Artamonov: Okay, yeah, I'll take a look. [00:57:54] Vlad Costea: Yeah, some people say it's a scam and that he's trying to capitalize because he hasn't made any money from all the stuff that he published. And right now he's back trying to ride the wave of the blockchain. But, you know, you shouldn't underestimate somebody who is obviously very brilliant and, as the godfather of all cryptocurrencies, has been around for longer than anyone else. [00:58:23] Igor Artamonov: Okay, okay. [00:58:24] Vlad Costea: The only issue that he had was that you had to sign up to become a node and run the network. And they had very high system requirements. So you actually needed to know a lot about running network and infrastructure. And you needed to have very powerful systems, and then you went to complete, to fulfill a KYC form and tell what's your name, where you're based and how much you're planning to run the node. And that's so anti-cypherpunk. [00:59:01] Igor Artamonov: That's interesting. I didn't hear about that. [00:59:05] Vlad Costea: Yeah. You're a developer, I guess. You as a developer, you have better stuff to do as opposed to reading the news. [00:59:14] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, maybe. I don't know. Yeah, I wasn't following news and everything, I don't know, since the hype, for more than a year, for almost two years, all this, you know, crazy things. I was just missing what's going on, like what's the point of all these things happening, a lot of new projects and everything, everything mostly meaningless. I stopped to go to any meetups or anything because it was filled with just people who was asking questions like, yeah, what kind of shitcoin to buy to earn a lot of money. Crazy times. [01:00:07] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I guess that's also a discussion that we should be having. As in, we have different waves of adoption, and at first it was just geeks and nerds and maybe Austrian economists who saw the potential in Bitcoin. And then you had another wave of libertarians who also trusted the economic side and the technical side, but also saw their opportunity to make some money. And maybe this wave consists of people who became billionaires, like Barry Silbert and Eric Voorhees and others. And then you had this whole speculation wave, which coincided maybe with the ICO bubble. [01:00:54] Vlad Costea: And you had people just stepping in, finding out about projects that went maybe 1000x in a few months, and they were just looking for a great opportunity to maximize their investment. [01:01:07] Igor Artamonov: I'm not sure which group I belong to actually, because I was interested in technology and only in technology since... I don't know when I learned about Bitcoin many years ago. [01:01:21] Igor Artamonov: I didn't think about economics aspect. It was, you know, nice technology, cool ideas, how it works and everything. I mean, I just didn't think about buying, investing, something like that. I did that, I bought some bitcoins, but not as an investment, but to play with technology, to develop something and, you know, spend some way, I mean, transferring, writing code to lose money and everything. But yeah, I was talking to people, to my friends as developers. So I'm like, "Yeah, look at this, it's Bitcoin, it's a cool new technology." [01:02:12] Igor Artamonov: And yeah, nobody believed me at that point, I think. But then a lot of people contacted me like two years ago, in 2017: "Oh yeah, you told me about Bitcoin many years ago and I saw the news. That's really cool. Thanks. But why you didn't tell me more about that many years before?" Yeah. That's funny. I wish I would think about the economic aspect, investment aspect of Bitcoin many years ago. [01:02:47] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's always like this: you regret not discovering stuff earlier. [01:02:51] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, I discovered it, but I discovered it as a technology, you know. I even bought some mining stuff, but I didn't even took this money from mining pool. It wasn't a point for me. It was like the whole point was to look, yeah, what, how it works, like how it can't be stopped and so on. [01:03:17] Vlad Costea: To me, it was a different process because I was discouraged from getting into it. I remember in 2014, I was 22, and I read about Bitcoin in the Wall Street Journal. And I was in a political science department, which tends to be kind of left-wing and tells you about the virtues of central banking and how it works and why it's a good idea to actually have high inflation. But not very, you know, not hyperinflation, but it's a good idea to have inflationary currencies and why the gold standard was a bad experiment. [01:03:56] Vlad Costea: And after I have been brainwashed with all these ideas, I didn't really feel like getting into Bitcoin, and it wasn't until I started making my own money and I started seeing how the tax money gets wasted and how you actually wish that you didn't finance corrupt politicians. And you wanted to have much more leverage on how society works. As in, you get a job and you pay taxes by default. And then you stop and think, "Okay, so one-third of my income is going into financing all these operations." [01:04:34] Vlad Costea: Are they any good? Are they efficient? And then you realize that the only kind of leveraging what kind of stuff happens with your money is by voting every four years. And that's not very effective because you choose between some options which are predetermined to preserve the current system. You're going to see some changes, but not very significant changes. So, I actually became much more libertarian and that's when I actually got into Bitcoin. But it was, in my case, a long process. I was too young, I was too foolish to actually get into it. [01:05:15] Vlad Costea: I didn't even have money. I was too young. I was still in university. But I'm happy that I got here. Maybe it took me too long to get in early 2017, like full time. But I'm satisfied, and I don't think I would take any other path right now. [01:05:37] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, I think the same applies to me. Something similar, I think. [01:05:45] Vlad Costea: So, when was it that you discovered Bitcoin and what was it so special about it? What intrigued you? I understand that it was the technical side, but what were you thinking that you can do with it? [01:05:58] Igor Artamonov: I don't remember the exact time. I just read somewhere. I think I read some articles, something like that. I didn't read the white paper for, I don't know, few months, maybe a year. So yeah, I just started to think about what it allows, right? To avoid any central party, any bank or any company, and communicate directly with other people and send money and change everything technically. [01:06:41] Igor Artamonov: And also, money is a power, it's another side of power. So, if you're taking money from people who, you know, traditionally have this power, they, you know, they have to work, actually, for their money. Otherwise they will lose it. And I don't know, that was interesting for me. But more interesting was this brilliant way how it works, how it was designed, that it can't be broken by anyone. And so I can't say I was spending much time on Bitcoin. No, I was working on other projects. [01:07:33] Igor Artamonov: That was mostly something decentralized or security related. That's probably how I found some articles about Bitcoin. And so I didn't have time for it, but I kept thinking about it and mentioning it to other people: "Did you hear about Bitcoin? What guys are doing, this and this?" I didn't think it, I don't know, involved in some multi-billion project at that time. And slowly and slowly I was reading more and more about that. And I think it was mostly, I don't know, 2014, 2015, maybe 2013, about these years. [01:08:25] Vlad Costea: Yeah, usually when people get into Bitcoin, they use their backgrounds to project what they expect to do with it. When you have people from medical science getting into Bitcoin, they think it's some kind of way to finance in a more fair way and distributed way medical research, maybe, or hospitals. If you come from a politics side, just like me, I did political science, I was thinking of blockchain voting. And in the meantime, I discovered that it's a terrible idea and it should not be attempted. [01:09:03] Vlad Costea: Just like online voting, which can be manipulated, blockchain voting can have flaws. And the only certain way in which we can be sure that it was voted in a specific way and nobody can interfere with it is with the paper ballot, as everything else can be subject to manipulation to some extent. But I ask just because, as a developer, as a coder, I think you had some kind of ideals about Bitcoin and what it can become if you get to that point where you can actually work in it. [01:09:44] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, I was thinking about technology side, right? So I was working with distributed systems or databases. And you have such thing called CAP theorem: if you work in some distributed system, which means it should be partition tolerant, you should choose between availability and consistency and so on. That makes a lot of problems for developing because you have to make this choice, and with Bitcoin, the technology made it just so much different. [01:10:25] Igor Artamonov: I'm not even sure this theorem can be applied here because... anyway, it's a hard topic, but anyway, so that's how I got interested in this. Like looking how distributed system solves this problem of consistency of some agreements between parties in a fully distributed and partition tolerant way. It was a very unusual solution and brilliant ideas, a lot of ideas tied together and it was working. And it was clear that nothing can stop it from working. [01:11:11] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's interesting. That's the kind of perspective that I could never have had. And part of me sometimes feels sorry for not trying harder with mathematics in high school. But nonetheless, I guess we can all bring contributions to the space and to Bitcoin, no matter where we come from and our skill set. And I've seen even artists. I'm not sure if you know Brekkie von Bitcoin or CryptoBrekkie on Twitter. And he keeps on making interesting art pieces, which are about Bitcoin. And he makes a lot of money out of it. [01:11:52] Vlad Costea: And it's interesting. Okay, you can actually project your skills towards Bitcoin. You have Naomi Brockwell, who is a filmmaker and a singer-artist, and she made some music videos in which she is the Bitcoin girl. And that was a hit. And it just proved that there is room for people to migrate into this community and ecosystem and do this part of advocacy, of promoting what it is. And I guess this is the last part that we can do as a conversation for this podcast, as we have been running for over an hour. [01:12:30] Vlad Costea: And there is a very big disconnect between this whole propaganda about what any cryptocurrency is... It happens to Bitcoin when some people say, "Oh, it doesn't need any development because Satoshi was this time-traveling alien who made it perfect from the beginning, and it's like a rock, it never changes." And you enter into this ideological phase where people project some kind of ideal into what Bitcoin is and what Satoshi is. And then you have the developer side, which sometimes can go way too far with proposals or ideas about what can be changed. [01:13:13] Vlad Costea: And in this regard, maybe we can give Luke Dashjr as an example, because he proposed to soft fork Bitcoin and reduce the block size, which proved to be unpopular and probably will never be accomplished. But you get to a certain point where you think too much of improvements as a developer, and most of the times they're not really practical and they don't really stand water in a free market. So, yeah, the question is about the disconnect between promoters and people who build the narratives and the ideologies, and the actual developers who know what's going on. [01:13:57] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, I agree, there is actually a big disconnect. It's clear for a developer that most people don't realize how technology works. I mean, they have questions or, you know, just looking on press, on Twitter and everything. People really misunderstand everything. But I think it's just temporary. Not even a problem, but just this situation when people pay too much attention to technology itself, not to what technology brings. Right, like internet in, I believe, in the 80s and 90s was... I mean, people were probably asking the same questions about protocols, TCP/IP, HTTP, whatever. [01:14:50] Igor Artamonov: Now, nobody thinks about it because they think about applications, about websites, mobile applications that use this technology, and nobody cares how it was implemented. But the technologies, the protocols of the internet are still evolving. A lot of people are still working on adding new features to core protocols of the internet. [01:15:16] Igor Artamonov: So we're changing this core protocol TCP/IP from version 4 to version 6. And that's a process of change that it takes, it took already many years, and it's unclear when it's going to be finished because it's really hard to change the protocol behind the internet. But still, there's a lot of work to improve this technology and there will be a lot of work to improve Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency in the following decades. But at some point people will start talking about applications, not about protocol. [01:15:57] Igor Artamonov: About things they actually use. And developers will continue to talk about protocols. And right now we have this just small community and everything is mixed and everyone is just talking to each other in the same way, trying to find the same language, and it's just confusing everyone. [01:16:21] Vlad Costea: Right, and that's why I'm happy that I got to interview you as a developer. As many of the people who code say that, you know, coders write code and that's what they should do. They should not represent anyone's point of view. They should not project their expectations and philosophical views of the protocol. But at the same time, you end up having a lot of misinformation circulating. And it's useful to actually have somebody who understands what's going on and tells us to level our expectations to a realistic degree. [01:16:59] Vlad Costea: So thank you very much. I hope you succeed in all of your projects. And I look forward to seeing if you're right about Grin as the next big thing. [01:17:08] Igor Artamonov: Okay, thank you. [01:17:10] Vlad Costea: And maybe we can have another interview. Who knows? [01:17:17] Igor Artamonov: Yeah, sure, it would be really cool. [01:17:20] Vlad Costea: Okay, thank you very much. [01:17:22] Igor Artamonov: Okay, thank you. Thanks for your time. [01:17:24] Vlad Costea: Bye. Bye. ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio/video call in English (guest is a non-native speaker), with a short music intro, a brief microphone glitch around 00:27, and no sponsor reads. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 4 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (104 chunks) and 45 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 2 of 2 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed intro music/"© BF-WATCH TV 2021" and stray "Thank you." insertions; split Igor's greeting from Vlad's 00:01:26 turn (Lott→Vlad); fixed ETCDEV, ETC, Ethereum Foundation, hard fork, immutability, Ethereum Classic, decentralized/decentralization (from "industrialized/realized"), Blockstream, pre-mine, genesis block, Laszlo Hanyecz, Grin, Turing-complete, cypherpunks, b-money/Wei Dai, Bit Gold, 1970s (from "19th century - Seven Seas"), unfair advantage, initial rules; cleaned duplicated "I I mean, mean" stutter using audio re-check; Removed "Thanks for watching"/"Thank you"/"Bye" hallucinations, the "Mmmm" run, the 00:31:33 and 00:25:02 inserted sentences; restored Vlad's dropped Linux/Debian line and "we can talk either" attribution; split the 00:27:22 and 00:27:42 speaker changes; fixed ETCDEV, Ethereum Classic, Blockstream, one Dai, precedent of SegWit2x, proof of work, sharding, funding developers, "Plasma" (marked unclear), notary services, "third part"; Removed hallucinations (thanks-for-watching, COVID, "market shareholder", "very important asset", "project's success", stray Thank you/Bye); restored dropped text (SegWit2x intro, Grin development/sidechain, Mike Hearn/Jeff Garzik/Gavin Andresen); fixed SegWit2x, Ethereum Classic, Peercoin, Grin, CryptoKitties, Emerald Wallet, archive node, Ethereum Foundation, hard fork, BIP 101, Gavin Andresen, drained/dead, percentages; Replaced "(same speaker continues)" with speaker names and kept all raw timestamps. Fixed names and jargon: David Chaum, Elixxir, Brekkie von Bitcoin/CryptoBrekkie, Luke Dashjr, Grin, KYC, cypherpunk. Removed hallucinations: stray "Thank you", "Thanks for watching", the Bitcoin.com/Support line, "following is a video", "Yat Fani Vat", "Alright, boss". Restored dropped speech from the second ASR: the medical research/voting passage, the websites/internet protocols passage and the CAP theorem sentence. Fixed 2000→2017 and "20 years ago"→"many years ago". Speaker repairs: "Okay, okay", "That's interesting", "You're a developer" and the closing "Okay, thank you" moved to the correct speakers.