Title: S3 E6: Gigi on Bitcoin as a Living Organism Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Gigi, Austrian Bitcoiner, author of 21lessons.com and curator of bitcoin-resources.com Published: 2019-07-30 Duration: 2:10:26 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2019-07-30_bitcoin_takeover_s3_e6_gigi_on_bitcoin_as_a_living_organism.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2019-07-30_bitcoin_takeover_s3_e6_gigi_on_bitcoin_as_a_living_organism.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:27] Vlad Costea: Hello and welcome to the sixth episode of the third season of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is Gigi, who is an Austrian Bitcoiner, who is the founder of 21lessons.com, a website where he wrote 21 chapters about various aspects of Bitcoin, and also bitcoin-resources.com, where he wrote... He actually accumulated some sources from where people can learn more about Bitcoin, which is interesting. I just took a look and feel like I have already learned something new. And Gigi, whom you can follow on Twitter @dergigi, D-E-R-G-I-G-I, is also passionate about the theory of Bitcoin being a living organism, which was first, I guess, formulated by Ralph Merkle. [00:01:38] Vlad Costea: So we have quite a lot to discuss. Hello, Gigi. [00:01:41] Gigi: Hey, Vlad. Thanks for having me. [00:01:43] Vlad Costea: I'm happy that we get to have this kind of spontaneous discussions in which we don't have any prior plan, and we just have some common points which may be of interest for us. [00:01:59] Gigi: Yeah, let's see where this goes. I'm really happy to be here and I'm excited about, you know, where this conversation will end up. It's always fun to talk about Bitcoin. At least for me it is. [00:02:14] Vlad Costea: Okay, so usually the first question has to do with the reasons behind getting into Bitcoin. Because I guess you have to be either a libertarian or some kind of anarchist or kind of crazy to get into this and believe that it has any chances against all the odds posed by governments worldwide. [00:02:34] Gigi: Yeah, I think it's true. Full disclosure, I'm not, I wasn't a libertarian before Bitcoin. So maybe the last criteria is fitting for me. Maybe I'm a little bit crazy to go into this full time. But yeah, here I am now, and it was a very long process for me. So it took me a couple of years actually to not ignore Bitcoin, and then it took me a couple of years to actually understand it in a way so that it can't be ignored anymore. I think it's, yeah, I think it's a similar story for many people. But I also think that once you kind of understand it deeply enough, there's no going back in a way. I think just trying to forget what you have learned and going back to believing in fiat money, for example, is not really doable. [00:03:37] Gigi: It's like once you learn that Santa Claus isn't real, then going back to the previous state and just believing in Santa Claus again is really, really hard to do. [00:03:45] Vlad Costea: It's like Plato's cave. Once you get out and you get back into the cave and talk to the people who are still chained against the wall watching the projections made by the fire, they're not going to believe you. They're going to say, "Oh, you're just crazy," or "You just went outside and probably saw what we have seen here, and you have gone insane because of the sunlight." And there has to be some kind of explanation why you came up with such crazy ideas. But I agree. Sometimes I think, what if Bitcoin went away tomorrow? [00:04:20] Vlad Costea: What am I going to do with my life? Because it's hard for me to get back to trusting the government and believing that change in politics can happen by voting out certain politicians and voting in new ones. I mean, I have come to realize that it's all part of the system. [00:04:39] Vlad Costea: It doesn't matter if they're right wing, left wing, centrists, they all preserve the same system, and by their ability to, you know, change every four years or five years depending on the kind of laws that you have in your country, they actually preserve the state, and the state never gets any smaller regardless of what they promise. And at the end of the day, they just take away more of your freedoms and liberties. And that's an essential reason why I have decided to stick to Bitcoin. [00:05:11] Vlad Costea: I guess at first I was in just because the currency of my country, which is not euro like in your case, has a higher inflation rate, and the amount of money which I was making was losing value quickly over time. So it was a bad idea to store my money in the local currency, the national one. So I looked for alternatives, and you can either get dollars and euros, or you can look for something which looks much more promising if you look on the long-term charts and you see, whoa, those gains, man. [00:05:47] Gigi: Yeah, right. Orange coin number go up, right? That's what draws most people in. Yeah. And I think that's also very important. I think price is one of the most important metrics. But I, in general, I stopped caring about the price in a way, which is really healthy for me. I mean, there was a time, I think everyone had a time where you're up at two in the morning and checking the price every 30 seconds. That's really unhealthy. So I kind of forced myself to just ignore it. [00:06:18] Gigi: And yeah, I've been ignoring it now since, I think, since the beginning of the bear market almost. So it's been quite a while since I didn't give a damn about price and uninstalled all trackers and all other apps that will tell me the price. Because you will be notified by Bitcoin Twitter and other sources, like other information sources, anyway if something crazy happens with the price, so that's good enough for me. But the question you ask, or the question you ask yourself, what would you do if Bitcoin went away tomorrow, I think that's a very interesting question. [00:06:52] Gigi: I come from a technology background, so I'd probably still be working in software. Before I went into Bitcoin, I had a big interest in, yeah, free software in the open source meaning of the word, like free, libre, open source software. [00:07:12] Gigi: And so I probably, yeah, work on doing that full time, which is kind of hard. It's, yeah, it has a similar tragedy of the commons. I don't think it's that hard in a way to do Bitcoin full time, but I believe that doing Bitcoin properly full time, like without any shitcoinery or without any... I'll just say, if you really want to earn money in a very honest way in Bitcoin, it's not as easy as people might think, I believe. But it's definitely doable. [00:07:50] Vlad Costea: Well, "Everyone's a Scammer," according to an article written by Michael Goldstein. Everybody wants to take your bitcoins, and you're going to find lots of reasons to ask people to give you bitcoins, just like, you know, donating to this podcast, which I guess makes me a scammer. [00:08:07] Gigi: Exactly. [00:08:08] Vlad Costea: But if somebody donates to this podcast, you're going to get 50%, which also makes you a scammer. And from the 50% which I get, I'm going to give half to the Ross Ulbricht Foundation to give him a second chance, maybe in front of the US judiciary. So I guess that also makes him a scammer, but that's not really news. [00:08:31] Gigi: That's why he's in prison, right? No, I'm just kidding. Yeah, that's a great article. Like, "Everyone's a Scammer" is, I think, one of the... I wouldn't say it's one of the best articles, I don't know, it's just a mind-blowing article because he kind of is right. Why would you part with any of your hard-earned satoshis if Bitcoin continues to increase in value and if hyperbitcoinization is a real possibility? So yeah, everyone who wants to scam you out of your satoshis by whatever way is a scammer. Yeah, it's a funny thought. [00:09:10] Gigi: I think it's right in a way, but I already... You know, for example, I bought several hardware wallets with Bitcoin just for privacy reasons as well. And I just recently, just out of curiosity, I signed up for Saifedean's course and I paid that in Bitcoin as well, because I was traveling when I was paying it, and it was in a way the most convenient thing for me to do, to just pay in Bitcoin. So it's really hard to hold on to your bitcoins in a way. [00:09:45] Gigi: John Carvalho, Bitcoin Error Log, said this very well. He said that bitcoins want to be free. And so it's really hard not to spend them or lose them or get hacked and so on. So yeah, it's funny how different this is in a way. In the real world, I think it's easier to hold on to things and just stash it away. And I think people are getting better with stashing away the coins. And if you are really serious about it, you can also just time lock it away. It's very hard to spend. [00:10:21] Vlad Costea: Right. I mean, the temptation of just thinking about, okay, so I have, let's say, 0.1 Bitcoin, which today means $1,000. And you see the new iPhone XS2 or something coming out, and you're going to say, "Oh my God, it has so many interesting features, and I'm going to be such a cool kid when people see me taking calls on that cool iPhone." And I can also use an emoji. Do you know what an emoji is? I can also use an emoji to post funny stuff on Bitcoin Twitter, and [00:10:56] Gigi: Yeah, you can impersonate a shitcoin. You can select the poop emoji and just impersonate any shitcoin you want. So that's fun. [00:11:06] Vlad Costea: Impress the ladies like Katoshi. [00:11:08] Gigi: Yeah, exactly. [00:11:09] Vlad Costea: You know, Katosi or Katoshi, I'm not sure what you call her. [00:11:14] Gigi: No, I don't know. I don't follow too many of the crypto ladies. I know there are some out there. I guess she's one of those. [00:11:23] Vlad Costea: Yeah, she's one of the smarter ones, as opposed to... I'm not going to tell any names. I don't want to make anyone feel offended. But there's that lady, I think it's Altcoin Whisperer, who just draws stuff by hand and says why XRP is going to $10,000. [00:11:39] Gigi: Great. [00:11:40] Vlad Costea: I'm not sure if you saw her videos, but they're equally hilarious as they are dumb. You just look at it's like the lowest denominator of entertainment possible. But you just watch it like it's a guilty pleasure. You know it's all bogus. You know you're wasting your time by watching it, but still you watch it just because you want to see how ridiculous it can get. [00:12:08] Gigi: Yeah, XRP and Ripple are two of the three words I've blocked on Twitter, so I don't see any of that content, luckily. [00:12:14] Vlad Costea: Oh, yeah. Good job, man. [00:12:16] Gigi: I can recommend to everyone to just do a little bit of curation in the online world. It will help you to stay sane. But you know, it's what you said also with the iPhone. I think that's one of the main positive benefits that Bitcoin has generally, and it also had on me, that people are getting serious again about saving. So, you know, Saifedean talks a lot about the concept of time preference and how sound money will lower your time preference, so you will save more and save into the future and think about future generations as well, like think about the kids and think about the grandkids and so on. [00:12:58] Gigi: And I think you see that on Bitcoin Twitter already, that people say their goal is to save like five Bitcoin because they have three kids. [00:13:12] Gigi: And so it's one Bitcoin for every kid and like two for their retirement or something. And it's really interesting to see that. And I think the biggest hurdle to adoption still is that Bitcoin is so extremely different, like since it's, yeah, it's completely digital and it lives in the digital realm. It's just very, very different than any physical thing we had before. Like people got really good with just taking care of their jewelry and of their gold coins or what have you, and also, you know, just your wallet, not your Bitcoin wallet, the normal, regular fiat shitcoin wallet that you have in your pocket. [00:13:50] Gigi: People are really good of taking care of that in a way. I mean, you don't lose your wallet every day, but as a counterexample to that, I'm pretty sure everyone forgets a password like once a week at least or so, or uses the wrong email address, or, you know, fucks something up in the digital world in a way. [00:14:18] Gigi: And I think, yeah, we need to get better with that. And I want to focus my future career in a way on helping to create a world where everyone kind of knows not only how to behave in the digital realm, but where you also have the tools so that it's not as easy to lose your private keys, for example, or also where it's not that easy to just be stupid about security. Because, again, I think in the physical world, everyone kind of knows to close the door and lock the door and also lock your car and don't leave any money laying around in your car, because someone will see it in passing and just smash in your windows and they will steal your money. [00:15:06] Gigi: And I think in the digital realm, we have still a lot of work to do there, let's put it like that. [00:15:12] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I agree with you. But you are Austrian, Right? So have you heard about the Austrian School of Economy before getting into Bitcoin? [00:15:23] Gigi: I haven't actually. So I'm now, I'm Austrian both by birth and now in spirit as well. And that's also something that's really fascinating for me. And one of my 21 lessons is actually about financial ignorance. And, you know, my experience was, I mean, I had a pretty good education, I would say, but still, I didn't learn anything about money or economics. [00:16:00] Gigi: Like, I even had some courses on economics, but you kind of learn stupid stuff in those courses. I mean, it's not really helpful. And how money works and why things have value and, for example, why gold was used as money and so on and so forth. I just, yeah, like all the other people around me, never gave a second thought about how it is that we ended up in a world where this particular paper has this kind of money, and if another number is on the paper, it has like 100 times the value. [00:16:41] Gigi: And it's very enlightening to learn the history of money and the history of how certain rare metals evolved into money. And I think it's essential to understanding Bitcoin in a way, because if you don't understand all the properties of money and why gold was superior compared to all other forms of money, then you won't understand why Bitcoin is superior to all other shitcoins, for example. [00:17:11] Vlad Costea: Right. And it kind of blows my mind to know that your government, even though it had some of... It was built on the intellectual work of some of the most brilliant economists of this world, does not teach the students about at least some of the famous people who laid the foundations of the Austrian School of Economics. It's like they don't want you to know. They don't want you to discover. And even in my case, I did political science, which has an essential component and has some essential one-on-one classes in economics. [00:17:47] Vlad Costea: And I had two professors, one who was doing macroeconomics and basic stuff like David Ricardo and Adam Smith. But she tended to be much more on the side of the World Bank and teaching us how economics works in there. And there was another one who was much more about economic thought, and he was about 60 years old, used to work at the National Bank, like the Central Bank of Romania. And there was one time, and I recall it and haven't forgotten it, when he asked us, "Did you know that money used to be backed by gold?" [00:18:24] Vlad Costea: And the dollars that people were having until not so long ago were actually, or could be exchanged at any time for a fixed amount of gold. And I guess I was 21 or 22 at the time. I was in my third year, was about to graduate, and up until that point, I never knew about that and never had the kind of thought which made me ask, "Why does this piece of paper have any kind of value? And why does the gold, not the gold, the coin, which costs much more to produce and is made of metal... Why is that worthless, and it's not even worth picking up from the ground when you see it?" [00:19:07] Gigi: Yeah, I think most people don't know those things. I mean, you need to have studied something that relates to that. And even if you studied economics, most people don't know this because, yeah, it's just money in general is just completely unquestioned. And it just... People behave like it always existed and it always was that way. And, for example, Brady on the Citizen Bitcoin podcast, if I'm not mistaken, he always says that everyone is a default Keynesian, and I think that's profoundly true. [00:19:40] Gigi: Like, everyone behaves as if the current world we're living in is the way it always has been and the way it always will be. That just there is some very mighty figure, almost like a king, like, you know, the government prints the money and it says it's... That's the reason why it has value, and that is the reason why it has value, you know. It's just by fiat, like, "I say it is like that, so it is like that." And yeah, that is a very, very novel development, and I think it can't work for very long. I mean, a lot of goldbugs say that the fiat money is bound to collapse. [00:20:25] Gigi: And they say that since a couple of decades already. So it seems like the governments are able to keep up the charade for way longer than people have thought. And now Bitcoiners say that everything will have to, like everything has to go to shit very soon. And I'm not sure if that's true, because, yeah, it seems like governments are really good at keeping up the charade of fiat money. But anyway, I think that Bitcoin will succeed very, very quickly. In a way, I'm way more optimistic than most people on Bitcoin Twitter. [00:20:58] Gigi: I'm more aligned with the likes of Bitcoin Tina and the hyperbullish crowd, because I already lived through, yeah, two exponential revolutions in a way, depending on how you want to look at it. But I lived through the rise of the internet and I lived through the rise of mobile computing, and both were way, way, way quicker than I ever thought. And I always, you know, I was always interested in that stuff. And in a way, I studied exponential technologies, and Bitcoin is an exponential technology built upon exponential technologies. [00:21:34] Gigi: And that's why I think it will happen very, very quickly. I mean, it can happen very, very quickly. I think everyone knows that. But I'm kind of convinced that it will happen in the next nine years. So, yeah, Bitcoin is a little bit more than 10 years old now, like 10 and a half years. And I think the next nine years will be just extremely crazy. And it doesn't need the collapse of fiat money to succeed, because the, yeah, the collapse of weak fiat currency will happen on its own. [00:22:02] Gigi: Just like with the internet revolution, I see the internet in a way as a system that just eats up information. And the parallel is that I see Bitcoin as a digital organism, like a system that eats up value. And we have seen what happens if the internet starts to eat up the kind of information your business relies on. [00:22:28] Gigi: Like we saw it with the record label industry, we saw it with movies, we saw it with publishing and newspapers, and we saw it with books, and we saw it with brick and mortar stores. I mean, as soon as Amazon went into selling goods online, I don't even want to know how high the percentage of small shops is that had to close because of that. And I think the same will happen in the world of value with Bitcoin. And I think, yeah, we don't need any catastrophic events, or I don't think we need another economic crisis necessarily for Bitcoin to succeed. I think it will accelerate it, and I think it will happen anyway. Like, we will have a next, yeah, 2008 financial crisis. [00:23:21] Gigi: But I don't... Yeah, I'm way more optimistic than some people. Like, I don't think we need a doomsday economic collapse scenario for Bitcoin to succeed. [00:23:34] Vlad Costea: I think that that kind of doomsday would be useful, but at the same time, millions of people would get stuck in this state in which they have no idea what's going on, and they have no idea how to buy Bitcoin anyway, except for getting on some kind of exchange, which is the wrong way of approaching it. So I think that the adoption process is going to be much slower in the case of Bitcoin, just because we need to educate people. And that's why we need longer bear markets after the bull market happens, so that people who bought at the top have enough time to educate themselves about how this works. [00:24:13] Vlad Costea: And start running their own node. As the technologies which you have mentioned, like the internet and mobile technology, can afford to have a greater degree of centralization, with companies which offer services, and users can remain ignorant of everything taking place behind the curtain. They don't care about the code. They don't care about audits. They don't care whether or not it's open source. But in the case of Bitcoin, which is open-source software, you want as many people as possible to run their own nodes. Otherwise, it's going to rely too much on big business in order to operate. [00:24:52] Vlad Costea: And that's the kind of vision which, I guess, the signers or the signees, the signers of the New York Agreement back in 2017 had. And their idea of Bitcoin adoption was all about making companies accept Bitcoin payments with a third party like BitPay. And they would brag about how much adoption they have spread, when in reality, no business was actually taking bitcoins. They would have an automatic process to convert to fiat. We need to make people understand why Bitcoin has value, as opposed to just always comparing to the price in dollars. [00:25:33] Vlad Costea: And allowing people to remain ignorant and use SPV wallets and light wallets on their phones. And there's nothing wrong with them as long as you connect them to a full node. [00:25:47] Gigi: Yeah, I mean, that's a good point in a way. I tend to be more optimistic, and I think that adoption will happen, or at least can happen, very quickly. And there are so many ways right now, like so many companies that are working on adoption. I mean, in the US, for example, you have Lolli, which is a cashback service. So you just shop normally using their app, and whatever you buy, you will get a certain percentage back in Bitcoin. We don't have that in Europe yet, at least not that I'm aware. But this will definitely help with adoption. So, I mean, there are similar services not related to Bitcoin which just do saving, you know, like it rounds up to the closest full unit value, like it rounds up to the next dollar value or to the next euro value, and it puts whatever is rounded up in a savings account, and you just... [00:26:41] Gigi: Have some savings that you maybe can go on a short holiday once a year or something. And I think similar services for Bitcoin are very, very important, and I think they, yeah, they will spring up all over the place. In Australia, there is Amber by Alex Waltz that does this as well. And then suddenly you will have Bitcoin, and you will start saving in Bitcoin. And as soon as people have skin in the game, they usually educate themselves at least a little bit about this kind of weird thing that they have, like that the weird nerd friend recommended to install and use. [00:27:22] Gigi: And I think, yeah, what you said about the problems of adoption, and people don't have an idea of how to buy Bitcoin, and buying it via an exchange is not the right way to do it. I completely agree, but I also think that exchanges are necessary, and they are some kind of Bitcoin bank in a way, and are a necessary evil. And I really like the idea that every Bitcoiner has to be kind of the steward of his close friends or of the community around him or her. And so if you just have friends that are interested in it or interested in buying Bitcoin, just, yeah, sell them some satoshis for like 20 bucks or something. I mean, it's super easy to do, and if you're a Bitcoiner, then you kind of have a way of stacking sats anyway. So I would encourage everyone to think about doing that, because it really helps with decentralization as well. [00:28:27] Gigi: And I think that's... Yeah, there are ways around the problems you mentioned before. [00:28:33] Vlad Costea: Now, usually I tell people to install Wasabi Wallet because it's also private and it's very easy to use. They basically nailed it in terms of interface. [00:28:45] Gigi: Yeah, I agree. It's really easy to use. I mean, it's an advanced tool, you know, it's like a power user wallet, but it's really nice to see what's actually happening under the hood, in a way, because you have full control over all your coins, and you have coin selection, and of course you have mixing as well. So it's a very good advice, especially if someone has to buy the bitcoins on an exchange, and then you can at least mix them in Wasabi and put them into cold storage if you want. [00:29:20] Gigi: I also like Samourai, and I know that, you know, there was a lot of infighting going on Twitter last week or two weeks ago, when it was, in the last couple of days anyway. And I think both are fighting the good fight. Like, both Wasabi Wallet and Samourai Wallet are, yeah, doing some excellent work to make sure that Bitcoin, yeah, stays private, or at least semi-private, and also stays fungible on the network level. And yeah, they're doing good things. And Samourai Wallet for Android is an excellent mobile wallet as well. [00:29:57] Gigi: So I personally use Wasabi on the desktop and Samourai for mobile, and recommend my friends to use that as well. But again, yeah, I mean, I agree with you that there's still a lot to be done in terms of adoption. But I think in the short run, in a way, we could live with companies and exchanges and some other services being kind of the hubs of adoption. [00:30:24] Gigi: And those who are interested in this kind of stuff, they will also manage to educate themselves and maybe run their own node, and at least be, you know, at least come as far that they have ownership of their own keys. Because, as we all know, if it's not your keys, then it's not your Bitcoin. And those are all important things to know. But maybe if I can go on a slight tangent there, it's also really, really, really hard to understand and really hard to do the stuff you mentioned beforehand, when you learned about money and that money was actually backed by gold. [00:31:07] Gigi: I think a lot of young people need to learn this aspect of Bitcoin. Young people, they know their way around the digital world and the digital realm, but they don't really know too much about money. And I think for the older generation, it's the other way around. They maybe know more about money and the history of money and why gold has value and so on and so forth. Because it's not too long ago that money was backed by gold or you could exchange your bills for gold still. [00:31:46] Gigi: What I'm getting at is that Bitcoin is such a strange beast in a way, because it lives in the digital realm. And I think about it a lot because it's seriously hard to understand. I'm talking as someone who actually understands a thing or two about the digital realm. But everything is so different. It's just an alien realm. I mean, you can try to explain it with analogies, but these analogies will always fall short. For example, you can say that your private key, like your private key is your Bitcoin, but that's not exactly true. [00:32:24] Gigi: You know, it's way more complicated than that. You see, if I'm at your house, for example, and you leave me in a room with a couple of your gold coins for five minutes, that's probably not a big deal. You can come back after a couple of minutes and you see that your coins are still there and they're not in my pocket. So all is good. So we're really good with things like this in the physical world because we evolved to deal with things like that. But we have not evolved to deal with valuable stuff in the digital realm. [00:32:57] Gigi: To go back to that example, if you leave me in a room with the private keys to your Bitcoin wallet, like if it's the little card or the piece of paper which contains the seed phrase, then you're basically screwed already. I mean, I can take a picture, I have your coins. If I'm really good, I can memorize what's on the card and I have your coins. Or I take another piece of paper and copy them by hand and I have your coins. Sure, there is always ways around that. [00:33:24] Gigi: I mean, you can add an additional passphrase, which is stored separately and so on, but that's not my point. My point is that we're not used to dealing with magic like that. And I think that's one of the hard problems to solve. And that's also, like, the focus of my writing in a way, is that I want to make sure that people know that this stuff is truly magical because it's so different, and I truly think that it's just a different beast. And of course, you know, magic can be dangerous. So I think it's important to frame it in that way. [00:34:04] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I agree. It's different and difficult. And I have no idea how I can explain to somebody good practices to secure their keys if they have a lot of guests and if they happen to invite over people who are knowledgeable in terms of Bitcoin. And this is a big issue also with Bitcoin meetups, because you make friends with people who are into it and have common interests. But you don't want to invite them over to your house because obviously they can find out creative ways of looking for your private key while you are just going to the bathroom or preparing, fixing a drink in the kitchen or something. [00:34:51] Vlad Costea: And I have also heard John Carvalho talk about the issue of people following you, because you never know when you leave this kind of meetup and they follow you home, and then they know where you live and they can kidnap you. They can do lots of crazy stuff. We're not prepared for this. And it's such a small phenomenon that people are not aware to protect themselves from it. You don't have communities which actually care about who follows you home, because the most they can do, according to what they think, is steal stuff from your house. [00:35:32] Vlad Costea: But it's not like they can steal your life savings, which you might be storing in Bitcoin, because usually people don't have a lot of money in their houses, because they store their money in banks. In the case of exchanges, which are bona fide exchanges, banks for cryptocurrencies, and in our specific case, Bitcoin, it can be a bad idea to store them for multiple reasons, as I don't think you have any kind of backing by the government. [00:36:06] Vlad Costea: And I think at some point I heard that Coinbase is backed to a certain limit, like $1,000 per account, if it happens that Coinbase gets hacked and you're going to get a reimbursement. And also... [00:36:21] Vlad Costea: It's a lot easier, I guess, to exploit some kind of security issue in an exchange than to rob a bank. And if you rob a bank, you're going to rob a local one, which doesn't have a lot of money. But if you get into the servers of an exchange, then you have access to a lot more money than you can probably launder throughout your entire life. Actually, that's a big issue now that I think about it. If you're a hacker and you get access to all the coins on Binance, let's say, you're probably better off just taking one Bitcoin or something, because otherwise it's going to be a nightmare. [00:37:03] Gigi: Yeah, I don't remember who wrote the article, but I think there was an analysis done on, I think it was actually the Binance hack. It was called like "The Very Patient Binance Hacker" or something like that. And yeah, that's a good point. I mean, if you manage to get your hands on a large amount of coins, then you will have to be patient, because there is just no way to exchange all the coins at once currently. And yeah, I mean, you're probably better off being patient and waiting for the value to go up anyway. [00:37:44] Gigi: But yeah, what you said about physical security is absolutely true and also scary. And also, yeah, I think we will see that more and more, and I think we will have to reintroduce what we learned in the physical world, in a way. I'm just not sure if it will be banks and also safe deposit boxes and so on. Because, as I said, things just work differently. I mean, if you put your seed phrase in a safe deposit box, if someone who works at the bank just looks into the safe deposit box, then your stuff is already gone. [00:38:27] Gigi: You know what I mean? Even though the stuff is still there, like the card is still in the safe deposit box. So, I mean, more modern cryptographic solutions to the problem would be to set up multi-signature solutions. But, of course, that's not easy to do. It's also not easy to choose the correct multi-signature protocols in a way. Like how many keys do you actually need? And how many keys of those will you need to unlock your Bitcoin? And I mean, the most popular currently, I guess, is two out of three multi-signature. [00:39:05] Gigi: But then again, there comes the question, who do you give the custody of your keys? I mean, is it just friends or family? Or do you use like a custody service? I mean, those services are popping up left and right currently. And the problem remains that it will create a honeypot of keys, you know. And I know JW Weatherman, who, I mean, people have differing opinions about him, but I think a lot of the stuff he says is true, or at least going in the right direction. [00:39:37] Gigi: And he says that he doesn't think that, because like custodians of keys, even if it's multi-signature, it's not the best idea because you create this kind of honeypot. And it might be better to just put one of the keys in an envelope and hand it to your lawyer, for example, because they are obliged to take care of it and take custody of that and so on and so forth. [00:40:07] Gigi: I mean, I'm not an expert in these matters, but I think it's interesting and it's a fascinating topic. And anyone who is interested in this kind of stuff, I also recommend going through Jameson Lopp's list of physical assaults on Bitcoiners, because, yeah, it will help you to stay vigilant and maybe also a little bit paranoid. I mean, I've never thought about, you know, people following home from meetups and so on, because I haven't been to many meetups yet and also not to too many conferences. [00:40:42] Gigi: But since I'm kind of in Bitcoin full time now, I plan to visit more conferences, and I think it will also be more difficult to stay anonymous or at least pseudonymous, because so far I haven't doxxed myself too hard yet. I mean, as you said, I'm from Austria. Okay, that's kind of doxxing myself a little bit, but I'm usually traveling a lot and I've been all over the place, and the other thing that people know about me is my Twitter handle and that's basically it. [00:41:18] Gigi: But if you go to a conference, at least you dox your face, so people take pictures of you and they see you, they know how you look. And it's kind of hard to stay anonymous for long or pseudonymous for long. And I know that other people have this kind of problem, and some people even decide to stay completely in the online world for that reason and just don't go to any meetups and don't go to any conferences. But I think it's also important to meet people in real life in a way and, yeah, work with them in a more serious fashion. I don't know what to do about that, to be honest. [00:42:01] Vlad Costea: It's not an easy issue to fix, as I don't think we have had anything similar in our history. [00:42:09] Gigi: Yeah, again, it's kind of a weird new world. Marty Bent always says Bitcoin is like the expanding universe and we try to discover new bits and pieces of this expanding universe every day. And I think that's really true. Yeah, Bitcoin, since the beginning, it kind of took on a life of its own. And you can also see that since the narratives around Bitcoin have changed, and also people that worked in Bitcoin or with Bitcoin very early on still had, at least from our point of view now, a really bad and wrong understanding of Bitcoin. And yeah, I think that's what keeps it very interesting and fascinating, because I think what we currently think we know about Bitcoin will be very different in five to ten years. [00:43:09] Gigi: And that's a very exciting thought. [00:43:14] Vlad Costea: But at the same time, we should not be expecting for Bitcoin to change too much in the next five to ten years. Maybe that we're going to have Schnorr signatures and the Lightning Network is going to be bigger. Maybe that we're going to have a layer three for tokens. [00:43:31] Gigi: Yeah, of course. But that's not what I mean. Because Bitcoin hasn't changed technically too much, and still the narrative shifted quite a bit. And that's, I mean, for example, the easiest example to go to is that even Andreas Antonopoulos talked about it's instant and it's free, you know, like transactions are instant and free. And that's simply not true. It was just that Bitcoin hasn't accrued too much value at this point in time for transaction fees having a meaningful value. And people are saying the same thing now about the Lightning Network, for example. [00:44:09] Gigi: And I think people should be really cautious about that, because even though the transaction fees are in the satoshi or millisatoshi area, it has happened before and it might happen again. And currently fees are very low on the base chain as well. But, you know, if something approximating hyperbitcoinization truly does happen, then, yeah, people will cry like a lot of tears for every transaction they made because they paid transaction fees, and it might have been an unnecessary transaction and so on and so forth. [00:44:44] Gigi: So I think even if Bitcoin doesn't change on the technical level, like if we stay on the same git commit for the next 10 years, and the only thing that changes is that 2 billion people are using it, things will be very different and the narratives will be very different. You know what I mean? [00:45:07] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. [00:45:10] Gigi: And I really like the metaphor of thinking about the Bitcoin base chain as like container ships in a way. And I think we will see that more and more, that a lot of stuff will happen on Lightning Network and other layers and everything kind of consolidates back to the base chain. I mean, that's also the general idea, but I think that as time progresses and Bitcoin eats up more and more value and more people and more companies and maybe nation states will start to use it, that block space on the base chain will become so extremely scarce that, first of all, transaction fees will rise by a lot. [00:45:57] Gigi: So I'm not concerned about Bitcoin security by any stretch of the imagination, because I think moving stuff on the main chain will be just very, very expensive. And also I think that the space on the blockchain will be used extremely efficiently. We will do an insane amount of batching. We will do all kinds of crazy things with Taproot and Schnorr and everything that's to come. And I think we will see the narrative shift again in a way, and Bitcoin will truly become a global settlement layer for something that we nowadays call banks, but it will probably be different entities. [00:46:42] Gigi: So that's how I think about it currently, at least. I'm sure I'll think about it differently in a year from now, but that's where I'm at right now. [00:46:54] Vlad Costea: That's the beauty of it, because if I read something which I wrote maybe a year ago or a couple of years ago about Bitcoin, then I'm going to think that it's rather juvenile and underdeveloped in terms of the complexities that you have to deal with. And I guess that next year I'm going to read again my articles which I currently work on, and I'm going to be disappointed and say, "Okay, so was I really this naive?" [00:47:26] Gigi: But that's good. That's a good thing to happen because it means that you're learning and that you're growing. And in the software world, for example, there is also the same principle. And people say that if you look at your old code and you're not ashamed, then you're doing something wrong, because you learn something new every day. And your understanding of everything will evolve in such a fashion that every code you've written two years ago, you look at it and you will be ashamed in a way. [00:47:58] Gigi: And I think it's similar here, that as long as you're learning, then your understanding of the whole system will evolve. And if you look back at it and it's a little bit naive, then I would say that's a good thing, because you learned a lot. [00:48:12] Vlad Costea: So let's talk about that Ralph Merkle theory, of which you have also decided to, or about which you have decided to talk about in the upcoming Bitcoin Takeover book. And it's about Bitcoin as a living organism, right? [00:48:29] Gigi: Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So I have like five or so articles I'm currently working on and I'm really bad at finishing them. And one of them is, yeah, looking at Bitcoin as a living organism. I haven't decided on the title yet, but maybe this will be the title. And I really like the work that Brandon Quittem has done as well, because he looked at Bitcoin also as a living organism, and he chose the analogy of the mycelial network, which is the mushroom fungi network that underlies the tiny mushrooms you actually see bursting through the ground. [00:49:15] Gigi: And he says that Bitcoin is the mycelium, which is underground and shifts nutrients from place to place, and also helps the forest grow, and helps to provide chemicals and nutrients and other things in the forest, and it breaks down dead branches and dead leaves and dead insects and so on and so forth. And as you said, Ralph Merkle was the first one who said that Bitcoin is a living organism. [00:49:48] Gigi: And the passage, it was actually a paper on DAOs, so on decentralized autonomous organisms. And DAOs have a really bad reputation because of Ethereum now, because the first big DAO that was launched in Ethereum, yeah, had a big bug in it, and it led to the fork of Ethereum into Ethereum and Ethereum Classic. And yeah, so it was a huge shit show. But I still think that DAOs are a neat idea, and Ralph Merkle did so as well in this paper. And I really like the analogy of Bitcoin as a living organism because I think it's kind of profoundly true. [00:50:30] Gigi: And I also know that people said the same thing about the internet in a way. They didn't necessarily say that it's a living organism, but they made analogies to it, analogies to the brain, for example, and they said it's like a global mind and the global brain and so on and so forth. But I also think that this is kind of true, you know, it kind of is. It behaves like a hive mind in a way, and you can see that manifest in all kinds of phenomena. [00:51:00] Gigi: I mean, I think Wikipedia is undoubtedly the knowledge base of the hive mind in a way. And you can also see various reactions globally that you would otherwise only see in biological systems. Like, I mean, we can bring it back to Bitcoin as well, because that's also something I will write about. Or, I mean, I have already written about it, I just haven't published it yet. But we saw it a lot with the toxicity of Bitcoin maximalists, and in a way, I see Bitcoin maximalists as the white blood cells, the immune system of Bitcoin. I mean, it's only one part of the immune system, obviously, but they act as agents that speak up whenever Bitcoin is attacked. [00:51:50] Gigi: But as in biological systems, you can also have autoimmune diseases. And what happens there is that your immune system attacks yourself, like the immune system attacks the living organism itself, even though nothing is really wrong. And I think we saw that a lot on Twitter. I mean, maybe not a lot, but we see it from time to time that the hive mind overreacts and people get attacked for almost no reason, and the mob will come after you even though you haven't really done anything wrong, I would say. And I think it kind of helps to explain certain phenomena to look at it through this kind of lens. And yeah, another example would be that usually living systems have multiple systems that kind of do the same thing in a way. Like, you have a natural redundancy. [00:52:46] Gigi: And for example, we have two circulatory systems. We have one that circulates blood, one that circulates the lymph. I don't know how to say it in English. Yeah, lymph. It's probably lymphatic fluid. And we also have a respiratory system and so on. And I think it's fascinating to see Bitcoin evolve and the same thing happening there in a way, because Bitcoin is, in a way, decoupling from the internet. I mean, not really, but at least there is the potential that it decouples from the internet if it needs to. And you see that with all kinds of projects now. I mean, people are working on mesh networks like never before, because now suddenly you kind of need it. [00:53:36] Gigi: You know what I mean? And you also have Bitcoin transactions broadcast via radio, for example. And you also have Bitcoin transactions broadcast via satellite, of course. And I think we will see those developments continue, and this is similar to what is happening under certain circumstances in biological organisms. So I think it's a nice way to think about Bitcoin. [00:54:06] Vlad Costea: I have heard people compare Bitcoin to an artificial intelligence. I have heard people call Bitcoin some kind of alien technology or the invention of a time traveler. So I guess your biological analogy makes a lot more sense than a lot of the crazy stuff which I get to hear or read. [00:54:28] Gigi: Yeah, I mean, it's very easy to go overboard with the analogy or go really crazy, you know. I mean, I know the theory that Satoshi was a time-traveling AI and went back in time to invent Bitcoin so that the machines have something to, you know, take over the world in an even more serious fashion, because they now can easily do economic activities autonomously and so on. I mean, it's fun, but it's not very realistic or not very helpful, except for, you know, maybe a future science fiction book. But I think some analogies are really very, very helpful. [00:55:03] Gigi: And I mean, the biggest analogies we, for Bitcoin we had so far is, it's digital gold. And I think that's very helpful to think about it, but it's only helpful to an extent. I mean, you kind of have to know why gold is valuable and so on and so forth. But people kind of know that gold is valuable, even if they don't really know the reasons. They kind of get it, that, yeah, if you have a bar of gold at home, then that's a good thing. [00:55:35] Gigi: And the second one I really like is that it's free speech money, because people also kind of know what this is about, especially if you're embedded in the online world a little bit and you realize that people are getting deplatformed and censored left and right. [00:55:52] Gigi: I mean, there are so many YouTubers that just get demonetized or deplatformed, and people are getting banned from Twitter and Facebook and all the other big platforms. So if you ever ran into that problem or experienced it yourself, then you kind of know the idea behind free speech money. And I think those two things, like those two analogies, they really help to think about Bitcoin in a proper way, because on the one hand it's really valuable, like gold, and it has reasons, very good reasons, why it's so valuable. I mean, it's the store of value proposition and so on and so forth. And on the other hand, the free speech money is really about the censorship resistance of Bitcoin. [00:56:36] Gigi: Like, it's virtually uncensorable, the way it's set up. And this is by design. And understanding that, I mean, it's a very nice entry point down the rabbit hole, because understanding why Bitcoin is censorship resistant, it leads you to understanding almost all of Bitcoin, like almost everything apart from the value proposition of absolute scarcity and the stock-to-flow ratio, which is important for that. But in terms of decentralization and in terms of how the system is set up so that it operates without any central point of failure, free speech money is a really good analogy. [00:57:14] Gigi: And I think to loop it back to the organism thing, I think if you look at Bitcoin as a decentralized organism, like Brandon Quittem called it, if you look at it as a living organism in a way, like life itself, which is very decentralized, I think that's a very useful analogy because, I mean, take ants, for example. Not one entity in the world controls ants. And I think, you know, thinking about it in that way is really helpful, because it doesn't matter if the US or China bans ants, you know. I mean, they will be there. [00:57:55] Gigi: They will be in their country and they will do their thing. And in the same way, Bitcoin is really unkillable in a way. And Bitcoin will continue to do its thing, whether you ban it or not. [00:58:06] Vlad Costea: Yeah, one of the arguments which I usually have with a friend of mine who is a gold bug, he likes to say that if all exchanges get shut down, then it's going to be worthless, which means that nobody's going to transact Bitcoin anymore. And I tell him that no, people will keep on doing it and develop a black market, maybe on Tor or something, on some kind of onion website. Because there's only so much that governments can censor. And at the same time, there are so many creative ways on the internet, or maybe through mesh radio, ham radio antennas, to broadcast transactions and create alternative markets. [00:58:48] Vlad Costea: And up to this point, exchanges, as banks, are only convenient for maybe newbies or for people trying to maximize their investments by trading shitcoins to buy more Bitcoins because, you know, everyone's a scammer. But at some point in the future, I reckon that exchanges will get shut down and the regulations will get harsher, as governments realize that the ground is slipping and the quicksand is pulling their fiat money down. People are realizing the potential of Bitcoin, and they do not want to have something which they cannot control. It makes a lot of sense. [00:59:29] Vlad Costea: If I was a central banker, I would talk against Bitcoin all the time. I would be the equivalent of Nouriel Roubini, I guess, because my whole future and my whole career and financial stability relies on the preservation of the system which brought me to this very privileged status. So in terms of incentives, it makes a lot of sense for people to defend what they already have and try to deter others from creating the kind of future which takes away their status and puts them in a situation where they have to start from scratch and prove themselves once again. [01:00:12] Vlad Costea: But then again, it's not true, because if you have a lot of money, then you can also buy a lot of Bitcoin right now and load up on bags just in case. [01:00:21] Gigi: Exactly. Yeah, I was about to say that. What you're saying is true, but I think it's even more complicated. Like, from a game-theoretical point of view, it's more complicated, because if you're a really smart government, then you would benefit in adopting Bitcoin as quickly as possible if you actually realize what this thing is, and if you actually realize that the sand on which you're standing is, you know, turning into quicksand, as you said. And I think we saw the same thing during the time of the prohibition, for example. [01:00:54] Gigi: Like, if you want to outlaw brewing beer or making wine or, yeah, making vodka or schnapps or whatever, you can do that, but it's really hard to enforce. And if you're actually truly smart about it, you introduce taxes on those kinds of goods, and then you're way better off. And we see it happening, the same thing now with the "quote-unquote" war on drugs, or at least war on marijuana. I mean, in the US, those states that legalized marijuana, they have a booming industry, and it's good for the state. Like, it's good for the government as well. [01:01:30] Gigi: And I think if you realize that Bitcoin is actually a contender to your power and to the power of central banks and to your ability to print money, I think outlawing it and fighting it is in a way the worst strategy you can pursue. [01:01:46] Gigi: And I think we already see this kind of realization maybe around the world, I don't know, but at least in the US, in the congressional hearings that happened the last couple of weeks, and also the hearings in the House of Representatives, there are some politicians already that kind of get it, and they at least realize what Bitcoin is and what the potential of Bitcoin is. And they're not talking about outlawing Bitcoin. I mean, some of them are, but they haven't understood a thing. And my opinion about it is: yes, you can outlaw Bitcoin, but it will only hurt yourself. It won't hurt Bitcoin. [01:02:25] Gigi: And that's, again, I think, very helpful to think about it as a global organism that lives on the internet, because, okay, maybe you can outlaw it, but It effectively will not outlaw it in your country. People will still use it, just like people still brew beer at home. I mean, you don't need much to brew beer, to just create alcohol. It's very easy to do. And also using Bitcoin is very easy to do in a way. I mean, if you know what you're doing, but it's the same for brewing beer. You need any access to the internet. And as you said, you can go over Tor and nobody will ever know that you had anything to do with Bitcoin. [01:03:10] Gigi: But it's even more complicated than that because it can be even easier. I mean, you flip a coin a couple of times and you have a private key and you can just generate addresses out of that by hand if you have to and tell people your addresses and they can send Bitcoin to you. So it's not even bound to any type of technology in a way. It's way more beautiful in that and it's way more resilient than just, you know, people say that, what if the government shuts down all electricity, for example? Or what if you don't have access to a computer? [01:03:44] Gigi: It doesn't matter for Bitcoin. You can still have access to it in a way. And I think, again, if you're really smart about it as a government, you try to be the first one to adopt Bitcoin in a really big and meaningful way. Just like, for example, the Nordic countries in Europe, they were the first ones to adopt broadband in a really serious way. And we saw a lot of technological innovation happening there because people just had excellent access to the internet there and a lot of new industries were spawned and so on and so forth. So I agree in spirit with what you're saying, but I think the execution is way more complicated because, as I said, if you decide to ban Bitcoin, then I think you're only hurting yourself. [01:04:29] Vlad Costea: Also, sometimes I think about this kind of scenario where it's illegal to mine Bitcoin and we all run... So let's say that these big plants where they put together mining rigs... Actually, they're not called plants, but... Wait, I forgot the word for it. It's like a conglomeration of miners. A pool. Okay, it was so easy. So we no longer have pools. So we're going to run from our computers the mining rigs, like on our laptop on Tor, there's going to be millions of users just being on Tor mining Bitcoin. [01:05:12] Vlad Costea: And that would be like the ultimate decentralization, because if governments decide that, you know, it's wasteful to use energy to mine Bitcoin in these industrial facilities, then people will do it from their own homes and there's going to be just as much hash power. And there will be no way to determine, maybe except for the amount of data which gets sent. But then again, the blocks are only one megabyte in size. So that will not make much of a difference. You might as well download porn from torrents so they don't get suspicious. [01:05:47] Gigi: Yeah, I think there is a lot to unpack here actually. But I think what you said in essence is absolutely right because, again, it comes back to enforceability. Just like if you want to stop everyone from brewing beer in your country, you will have to surveil, like perfectly surveil everyone all the time, because people are able to, you know, piss in a cup and take some, I don't know what, sugar and use that to create alcohol. And people do all the time in prison. You know what I mean? [01:06:28] Gigi: And it's the same with Bitcoin. It's really, really hard to enforce any ban of Bitcoin. And like you said, also with mining, you can mine. Mining actually is the only thing where you can be perfectly anonymous in Bitcoin, because you can, in theory, set up a mining facility or just set up a small mining rig, put it somewhere where there is excess energy or where there's any energy. And it doesn't have to be on the grid. So it's not something... I mean, you can go to a waterfall, for God's sake, or to any river and generate electricity there with a small device and plug in your mining rig there, even if it's just small. [01:07:09] Gigi: If you're big enough, you can just mine Bitcoin on your own. And if you're small, you can join a mining pool. And also, there's development on all fronts, with BetterHash and other mining protocol developments, you can be perfectly anonymous and get Bitcoins that way. So there's literally no way of stopping people from doing that other than a perfect authoritarian surveillance state, which, I mean, you know, I know some people argue we're living in, but I'm not as pessimistic about it. And you would have to have total control over your population, and the closest to total control we currently have is China, and arguably North Korea. [01:07:52] Gigi: And North Korea arguably is buying bitcoins. I mean, not the population is, but, you know, the leaders are. And in China they tried to ban Bitcoin, I don't know, I lost count, probably 50 times, and they never really succeeded. I mean, people are still using Bitcoin in China, and I mean, you can probably land in prison or worse there, and people still do because it's almost impossible to enforce. [01:08:21] Gigi: And yeah, I tend to be very optimistic, and I think that the people running the proper governments, quote unquote "proper," of the world, they're probably way smarter than most people give them credit for. [01:08:36] Gigi: And I think in the European Union and also in the US and also in other developed countries, we will see more and more parties and more and more politicians push for the adoption of Bitcoin in a meaningful way. Like at least, at least don't do any stupid and unnecessary regulation. [01:08:58] Gigi: And I think we've seen that in the last 10 years, that a lot of countries were quite friendly to Bitcoin businesses, and you can already see that those countries that were friendly in regulatory and also friendly in terms of taxation, a lot of businesses were spawned there, and I think we will see continual worldwide competition of governments. As also was outlined in The Sovereign Individual, maybe, I know a lot of Bitcoiners have read that, governments will have to compete for citizens and governments will also have to compete for companies in a way, and I think Bitcoin helps with that, because it's a global phenomenon. And if the country you were born in isn't happy with you creating a Bitcoin business, then you will just pack your stuff, move to another country. [01:09:57] Gigi: It's very easy nowadays, I would say, and start your business there. [01:10:02] Vlad Costea: Right. Also, I was thinking as you're talking about this situation where we get maybe a political party which is friendly to Bitcoin at the European Parliament level, or independent politicians among Bitcoiners here in Europe who run for office and make sure to preserve the legislation at a reasonable level. Do you think that's feasible in any way? Or do you think it's just a good idea to be passive and let them be clueless and not understand what's going on? [01:10:34] Gigi: I think it's already happening and I think nobody has any power over that in a way that you could even say we will have to keep politicians clueless. First of all, there is no "we" really. And second of all, I think a lot of politicians are interested in Bitcoin for whatever reason. I mean, for the same bunch of reasons that people on Bitcoin Twitter are interested in it. And I think we see that happening already. I think there are a bunch of Bitcoiners in politics. And I think this will continue to increase. [01:11:09] Gigi: I mean, it's like saying 20 years ago, "Should we stop politicians from using the internet, and do you think there are any nerds that use the internet in politics?" I think it's the same all over again. It will just happen naturally, and people will see why Bitcoin is useful, and they will start to adopt it, and they will start to use it. They will start to save in it. They will start to understand it. [01:11:31] Gigi: And there is just, yeah, no way of stopping the adoption in that way, because I truly believe that it's virtually impossible to kill Bitcoin at this point. I mean, I know that's a bold statement and I'm not like ultra bullish and optimistic, because I also think that attacks will continue to happen. And I think that we're, I've said this before, I think we're still living in peacetime. I think that big attacks will come. And I also think that government-sponsored or government-motivated attacks will come and maybe also, you know, other big players like big banks or even a conglomeration of banks will try to attack or undermine Bitcoin. [01:12:18] Gigi: And I think we have happened, like we had plenty of attacks in the past, but I think even bigger attacks will come. And yeah, I mean, there are a lot of attack vectors and a lot of things that can go wrong in a way. And I'm not only talking about physical attacks. As we've seen, one of the biggest attacks on Bitcoin was the social one with, yeah, SegWit2x and the push from the industry side to change the consensus mechanism or the consensus rules of Bitcoin in a hard fork way. [01:12:50] Gigi: And I think, yeah, we will have to be very vigilant and we will have to, in a way, stick to our guns and make sure that Bitcoin stays true to its essence and Bitcoin stays decentralized and uncorruptible. But as it is now, like, having said all of that, I'm very, very optimistic that Bitcoin can't be killed, also because it has a very good track record and I think it's way more resilient than most people think. I thought about it a lot and as I'm saying this, I'm still trying to work out all of my thoughts and I'm trying to write about that as well. [01:13:38] Gigi: But once you go through the thought exercise of trying to kill Bitcoin, you kind of realize how hard it truly is. And there are also many, many ways how Bitcoin can recover even if it's a near catastrophic event. Like, it's insane how resilient the whole system is. And I mean, that's by design, but still it's very surprising how resilient it is. [01:14:02] Vlad Costea: What is it like to be a Bitcoiner there in Austria? Do you know people who are also into Bitcoin, or do you have places where you can go and maybe buy lunch or grab a beer or get some kind of accommodation like an Airbnb or a hotel room? I'm asking because I have seen this kind of experiment being conducted worldwide. And some places where you'd expect to be a lot of adoption actually have a lot of skepticism, even Silicon Valley, where it's more likely for people to ask you for some kind of shitcoin, which is basically an ERC-20 token that was printed specifically for that business to make discounts, like, you know, tokenization. It's more likely to be able to pay in that than in Bitcoin. [01:14:55] Gigi: Yeah, that's a really good question. I'm not sure if I have a good answer for that. The main reason is that... There are multiple reasons in a way. I recently moved, so I'm really out of the way now. So I don't talk to anyone about Bitcoin except for my girlfriend. And you know, that's limited to like 10 minutes a day. Otherwise, she wouldn't be my girlfriend anymore, probably. But I have a bunch of people which I got into Bitcoin actually. And I sometimes meet them or sometimes talk to them. [01:15:30] Gigi: And yeah, I mean, to be honest, the last probably two or three years, it was one of the main topics we talked about. And they're really interested, and all of them are, you know, kind of nerds with a computer science background and so on and so forth. But I actually don't know too many Austrian Bitcoiners because, like, 90 plus percent of my waking hours I am in cyberspace and not in meat space. So it doesn't really matter where I am in the world. [01:16:06] Gigi: I talk to the same people, listen to the same people and write with the same people wherever I am, and all of them are, you know, cartoon avatars on Twitter mostly. So it's really interesting from that point of view as well. I know that there is a Bitcoin scene in Austria, and a lot of people also go to Switzerland because Switzerland is a hotbed for Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. I would say especially other cryptocurrencies. I mean, there's a lot of shitcoinery going on in Switzerland. But I don't know. [01:16:43] Gigi: I think, again, to come back to how it was with the internet, I really think that in a couple of years, you probably won't need meetups anymore. There was a time where the internet just got started where, yeah, you would have meetups in the same way, but everything went so quickly that it wouldn't make sense to meet with a group of people that use the internet. You know what I mean? It would be kind of weird. Like, it's weird to think about that now. [01:17:19] Gigi: I mean, you have special interest groups, and I think we will see the same thing happening in Bitcoin. And I think it kind of is already happening. I mean, you have those people that are really keen on understanding the economics of Bitcoin, And they will, yeah, be reading Mises and Rothbard and other Austrian economists, and they will be deep into the Austrian economic side of things. You will have some tech guys that are really keen on developing some tiny part of Bitcoin further. Maybe you have some Bitcoin Core developers that develop on the base chain. Maybe you have a group of people that are dealing just with privacy issues, like you have now with the Wasabi and Samurai guys. And I know there are plenty of other people working on other CoinJoin and mixing and privacy technologies. [01:18:10] Gigi: And you will also have, you know, second and third layer developers. And I'm pretty sure there will be huge communities building around that. And again, I think it's already happening. You have Lightning workshops and Lightning hack days, and you have meetups that are specifically just for Lightning developers. And so I think depending on where you are in life and where you're coming from, like if you're a tech guy, you're probably most interested in Lightning. If you come from an economy background, then you're most interested probably in the value proposition of Bitcoin and the monetary and economic aspects of it, and the second and third layer effects, like the second and third order effects of what would happen to the global economy if Bitcoin really becomes the new gold standard. [01:19:06] Gigi: And if we're living in the world of the Bitcoin standard, what would the second order effects of hyperbitcoinization be, and so on and so forth. So I think it will get more specialized as adoption increases and more people care about Bitcoin. That was a very long answer, and the short answer would be: I don't know how it is to be Bitcoin in Austria. I just know how it is to be a Bitcoin on Twitter. [01:19:30] Vlad Costea: Oh, okay. I also don't have anybody in real life to talk about Bitcoin. And usually when people talk about their work, I just think of something else, passively sitting there thinking of, okay, if I start talking about my job, then it's going to get difficult and nasty, and they're going to roll their eyes and say, "Oh, you think you know it all and have it all figured out about money and how the financial system works? So shut up. Just enjoy life while you still can," which is a good point, because honestly, you can't just postpone everything in your life under the principle of low time preference and say, "I'm not going to spend anything, I'm not going to make friends who don't think like I do," because that's terrible. [01:20:24] Gigi: Yeah, that's terrible indeed. [01:20:26] Vlad Costea: And we should learn from each other. [01:20:28] Gigi: Yeah, definitely. [01:20:29] Vlad Costea: I openly agree that I might be wrong about stuff that I think and stuff that I say, because in the past some people have proven to me that the strong opinions which I had turned out to be wrong. And I guess until my 25th birthday, I thought there wasn't anything in this world that you could do without a government. But I guess there was this huge awakening in 2016 when you had lots of political events which pointed to the opposite direction. [01:21:06] Vlad Costea: And when you don't like what's going on, even, I don't care if you like Trump or not or what your view is on the European Parliament, I have realized that as long as you have this functional democracy where your freedom, like your basic liberties, are preserved, you're better off without the state. And you can actually live without social security, you can actually live without anything that your state provides to you, granted that you can pay for it. [01:21:39] Vlad Costea: And once you realize that you have a free market out there which awaits for your participation, and you can actually contribute to a smaller economy which is not distorted by the government, or is distorted because it could have been bigger, but is in many ways purer, and people have a greater incentive to be honest, because they know that their reputation is everything that they got. It's not like they have any kind of institution owned by the state to back their claims and provide that social component which makes people trust it. [01:22:18] Vlad Costea: A lot of people go to a hospital just because they know that it's owned by the government and it offers services which are based on their medical insurance. But I went throughout the past year to private clinics whenever I needed anything. [01:22:36] Vlad Costea: And I've actually paid less than I would have if I opted in for the government's social security system for health insurance, because I only paid when I needed it. I didn't pay like a fixed percentage of the income. [01:22:54] Gigi: Yeah, I mean, those are such hard problems, and it's so difficult to talk about them because in a way, I agree with what you're saying, but I also come from a country where we have a working social security system, and we have kind of a safety net which you can fall into whenever life cuts you off at the knees, you know. And I think that's a very good thing to have. But as you said before, the state and systems like it, they don't tend to get smaller. [01:23:29] Gigi: So there is always the problem that once you have such a system in place, that it grows and grows and it becomes very inefficient. And what started as a very nice idea, which is... I mean, you will always have some people that for whatever reason are not able to make money or are not able to make any meaningful amount of money so that they can live properly and have the basic needs met. I mean, you will always have like 10 to 20% of the population. [01:24:01] Gigi: You will always have disabled people, you will always have people that are so low in IQ, and I'm not saying that IQ is everything there is to it, but you will have people that will have just difficulties to do the most basic things, even though they are not mentally challenged in another way. And so I'm very pro private hospitals and competition, and I'm very against government intervention. I mean, obviously, since I think everyone who has been in Bitcoin for a long while kind of realizes that historically central planning and government intervention is just a catastrophe. [01:24:59] Gigi: But the problem remains that you will always have a certain percentage of the population that you will need to take care of. And I also know, I mean, there are arguments that the free market can take care of that. But I've just been to the US for three months, and I'm not convinced that the US did a great job of that in a way. I mean, I've been in San Francisco, for example, as well. And I mean, you know, again, it's a complicated issue, and I don't claim to have the answers, or I don't even claim to exactly know what I'm talking about. [01:25:36] Gigi: It's just, coming from Europe, I was stunned about the level of poverty in the US and also the just amount of homeless people, for example, in San Francisco, but in other places as well. I'm not convinced that removing all safety nets in a way is the best idea. But again, I actually don't really know what I'm talking about. It's just as someone from a functioning country with a functioning social security net, it's interesting to see how it is in other countries. And in Austria and also in Germany and generally in Central Europe, we kind of have... I'm not sure if it's the best of both worlds, but we at least have both worlds. [01:26:32] Gigi: If you can afford a private clinic and if you can afford private health care, then you get that, and you will get better service and you'll get better doctors and you have lower waiting times and so on and so forth. You just get better treatment in general. But the treatment that everyone gets is really, really good as well. And even if you're living on the street, you can go to any hospital and you will be taken care of. And in the US, for example, I mean, just if for whatever reason you currently don't have any income and you break your foot, it can be a death sentence in a way. [01:27:08] Gigi: And it can be both economically and also physically, because maybe the hospital just isn't able to take care of you. And yeah, I mean, all of those are very difficult questions. But before I go deeper into that, I thought it was really funny what you said, that you don't have any real life friends in a way to talk about Bitcoin. And I'm currently in a way in a similar situation, because I just recently moved. But I think there's also always a way to talk about Bitcoin, because it touches so many things. And you can talk about Bitcoin even without talking about Bitcoin. [01:27:52] Gigi: And I just recently had a conversation with a gentleman who was probably like 60 years old, and he was complaining that just the money doesn't hold its value, you know. He just was complaining that everything gets expensive all the time, and he remembers a time where, you know, a certain amount of euros bought you that, and now you don't even get like one tenth of it, and so on and so forth. And in a way, what he was doing was talking about one aspect of a problem that Bitcoin solves. And I talked to him for like an hour or so without ever mentioning Bitcoin. [01:28:26] Gigi: I was just really curious about his experience and how he sees those things without knowing anything about Bitcoin or Austrian economics. And it's, yeah, I think there are ways to talk about Bitcoin with almost anyone. And the other thing you touched on, which I thought also is interesting for Bitcoin and the thing we talked about before with staying anonymous and pseudonymous: you said that once you are in a free market competition environment, your reputation matters a lot. And once you move away from government dictate, then all you have in a way is your reputation. [01:29:05] Gigi: And I think that's also really cool in the Bitcoin world, because, I mean, we're having this conversation right now, and all I have is my reputation, because you don't know my background, really. You don't even know my name, and all you have is my Twitter handle. And I think that's so cool to see in Bitcoin, that all kinds of people are taken seriously, whether they have a PhD or some other background, or whether they are a stupid cartoon character on Twitter. [01:29:36] Gigi: And I think that gives me... In a way, that gives me a lot of hope about humanity, because people are really good at figuring out where the value is in a way. And I think that's something to be cherished. And that's also one of the main reasons why I decided to not dox myself just yet. I want to stay anonymous as long as I can. But yeah, it will be hard. [01:30:03] Vlad Costea: Okay, so let me get back to the idea of nationalized healthcare. I have nothing against it, and I guess if I was to talk trash about it, I would be hypocritical, because during the first years of my life I went to the hospital and never worried when I broke my arm whether or not I should be paying, because I just presented my ID, and my parents were working, and I was a teenager, and that was enough information to not get asked for any kind of money. But at the same time, when you have this system where everybody pays taxes for some services, you'll also have the money which is collected through taxes spent on stuff that nobody really agrees on, because this only gets bigger. And this is just my theory. I guess it could be flawed and it might not be like this. [01:31:00] Vlad Costea: But if you went to local communities and you had the mayors, for example, organize and say, "Let's collect this percentage of the income to maybe fund the hospital and give free education to our children, and not make any kind of discrimination between them, and give them a free meal while they're at school," I guess people would agree, and they would say, "Okay, I agree, if I'm wealthier, to give out more money to help that poor family, because they deserve a better chance, and my child must grow in this kind of environment where we are solitary with each other and we are charitable." [01:31:42] Vlad Costea: But if the mayor went on and said, "Let's collect money for mass surveillance and for military activity and whatever nasty stuff the governments do," then nobody would want to give them money. And that's why taxation is in place: to fund all the operations on which we don't agree, and pay for all the increased politicians' salaries which we don't like, and pay for their drivers. Here in Romania, they have special pensions, like they get 500 euro a month if they were drivers of famous politicians, or if they were mayors and stuff like that, which is insane. [01:32:24] Vlad Costea: Why do you have that? Why do I have, as a taxpayer, to support so many special pensions for war generals and for a lot of people who maybe own confidential information about famous figures? And they are basically bribing them to retire early and get free money from hardworking people, just so they don't reveal the kind of information that they know. That's something very nasty. And once you get into military research and all kinds of stuff that governments do to surveil us, then you're going to realize that it would be a good idea to reduce the size of the governments, just to teach them a lesson. [01:33:08] Vlad Costea: Because they exist just because we as people have agreed that they have authority. And we vote every four years, which means that we legitimize the system and we think that it works and that can bring the kind of change that we want. But how many times does that actually happen? You even have radicals who get voted into office. I'm not sure if you know about Hannah Arendt, who is a famous political scientist. [01:33:30] Gigi: I know her by name at least. Yeah. [01:33:32] Vlad Costea: Yeah, she said that the revolutionaries of today will be the conservatives of tomorrow once they win the elections. It's always this cycle where you say and do anything to get to power as a politician. But once you get power, you realize that it's not that easy. There's only so much you can do. [01:34:05] Gigi: That's true. I mean, again, there's so much to unpack here. I mean, the statement by Hannah Arendt is profoundly true, I think, but I think it's even true without any politics. I think all the revolutionaries in a way are young and the older you get, the more conservative you get. And I think there are good reasons for that in a way. But that's beside the point. Of course, related to the election cycles, I mean, that's one of the problems in politics, right? That you kind of... Your time preference is only on the horizon of four years. [01:34:44] Gigi: If you're lucky, it's maybe eight years, but it's a couple of years. It's not like seven generations. There's the seven generation principle, which I really like, that every decision you take and in general the kind of life you live, it should be geared towards creating a world that will take into account the next seven generations, not just your life. And politicians are on the opposite end of the spectrum. As you said, they only, first of all, they only care about the election. So there will be a lot of lies and then they'll get elected and then they will care about the length of the term, which is, you know, everything from two to eight years, something like that. [01:35:24] Gigi: It depends. So everything is true, but still it remains that those are really, really hard problems. And I mean, governance in general is a really hard problem. [01:35:38] Gigi: As I said, I'm not a big fan of the military, but the research money that went into the military in the 50s brought us the internet. So I'm kind of a fan of that. And you never know what comes out of it. And you kind of have to fund research and you also have to fund fundamental research like physics and other stuff. And the government pays for that as well, for like a big part of it. And there are always things that a lot of people maybe don't think it's a good idea to spend money on, but maybe in reality it is a good thing to spend money on. [01:36:18] Gigi: That I don't know. You know, I mean, those are very hairy subjects and we could talk about, yeah, if it's better to have a group of experts or if it's better to just have the knowledge of the masses in a way. So all of that is baked into the problem of governments, and it's a really hard problem. And I think we will see that in Bitcoin as well. Like, is it more important to work on privacy and fungibility or is it more important to work on decentralization? [01:36:51] Gigi: Is it more important to work on layer 2 solutions or is it more important to squeeze every bit of available room out of the base layer? And those are also, you know, in principle dealing with the same question, like is it more important to spend money on healthcare or is it more important to spend money on education? All of it is kind of important, but resources are limited. And, you know, I realized that the free market approach tends to be the most efficient in a way. [01:37:23] Gigi: And I think we see that also in Bitcoin, that people are working on everything all the time. And if something becomes more important, then people are working on that. And so again, I agree with you. I'm just saying that it's a really, really, really hard problem. And as you said before, once such a system is in place, like a system to collect taxes, for example, it only tends to grow. It doesn't tend to shrink. And it's funny because I used to be a big proponent of universal basic income because my background is in technology and I still believe that, but I just don't know what to do about it. [01:38:00] Gigi: I still believe that more and more jobs will be automated and I think that the coming wave of automation and artificial intelligence systems will make a lot of people obsolete. Not the people obsolete, but a lot of jobs in a way obsolete. And I think that people aren't aware of that. You have many people that are studying to become a radiologist, for example, and already we have AI systems that are way better radiologists than the best radiologists that we have in the world. And so starting your career as a radiologist right now, which you will complete your education in like 10 years or something... [01:38:41] Gigi: It's a really stupid idea because you will probably be done with your education and out of a job. And yeah, we see that all over the place and people don't really realize that. And once fully autonomous cars hit, for example, then everyone will switch to that. I mean, it just makes economical sense and a lot of people will be out of a job. And just re-educating these people, like a truck driver that drove trucks for 50 years, that's really hard to do. I would say it's almost impossible to do. And in the US, I mean, the Yang Gang and Andrew Yang, he proposes to provide everyone with a universal basic income and everyone will get like a thousand bucks a month, something like that. [01:39:22] Gigi: And the funny thing about that is that the same thing happens. Just like once you have a state, it tends to grow bigger. And once you have taxes, they tend to grow bigger. And once you have a universal basic income, people will vote for these politicians that will give them more money. So once you have something like that in place, I'm pretty sure Yang would win again. And the freedom dividend wouldn't be a thousand bucks, but probably a thousand five hundred. And if you will run for office telling everyone that, okay, the freedom dividend is now over and you used to get one thousand five hundred dollars just for the fun of it, and now you won't get anything anymore because if you're like me, then I will cancel that. [01:40:05] Gigi: I mean, it's obvious that this is not going to happen. So I think, again, this will produce something that will just spiral out of control. And of course, it would hyperinflate the currency as well. And it's funny because you wouldn't be able to do that with Bitcoin. I mean, you would be able to do it in theory, but since supply is strictly limited, it would kind of find a balance and it would behave in a way as if this wouldn't exist. Because, you know, if everyone would get the same share of bitcoins automatically just by right of birth, then it would be like everyone is getting nothing, you know what I mean? [01:40:40] Gigi: It would just subtract out of the global economic equation in a way. And yeah, those are fun things to think about. But again, all of these are really hard problems, and I don't exactly know what to do about it. I think, however, that Bitcoin in general will help to have a positive impact for all of those kind of problems. [01:41:08] Vlad Costea: I agree, and also, instead of replacing jobs with machines, you can just reinvent jobs. For example, the truck driver can be the person in charge of making sure that the system works well. They can monitor the truck from a distance in front of their computer, and they're responsible for whatever happens. Because I guess no matter how advanced the technology gets, you're still going to need somebody to account, because our legal systems are built according to this situation in which somebody has to be guilty for... [01:41:44] Gigi: Yeah, I mean, that's true, but it's a problem of scale. And we saw that in agriculture. And it's also, I mean, I agree completely. And I mean, we don't have to look far. I mean, look at some of the Bitcoiners. They reinvented themselves and they invented jobs out of nothing. And you can also point to Instagram models and YouTubers and streamers and professional computer players and so on. But it's a problem of rate of change and scale. Like, I think since all of these are exponential technologies, it can happen really quickly and people are not good at adjusting with quick change. [01:42:22] Gigi: And also, it's true what you said about the truck driver, but then you will have one truck driver, like one person who used to be a truck driver in charge of a fleet of, I don't know, a hundred trucks or a thousand trucks, whatever makes sense. And what do you do with the rest of those? And it's also, you know, the larger your set of skills is, the easier it is to reinvent yourself and invent new jobs. But if you are very, very specialized and are suddenly out of a job, it's really, really hard. And I think a lot of drivers are really specialized and they just know how to drive in a way. [01:43:02] Gigi: And I don't mean that in a derogatory way. I mean, I don't think that any job is easy. So you kind of have to know what you're doing and you need a lot of experience and you have a lot of responsibility. But I think it's a hard problem. And I'd be surprised if the optimists about that are right, and I would be surprised that a lot of new jobs will spring up and people will migrate to these jobs. Or, yeah, I would be very surprised if all of this has a... [01:43:40] Gigi: Good outcome, because the way I see it is that the younger generation doesn't make as much money as the older generation for a multitude of reasons. And I think that's also why Bitcoin is very attractive to young people, because young people inherently realize that in a way. I mean, my father, for example, we were a family of five and he was able to support everyone with one job in a way. And it would be almost impossible for me to do that and buy a car and buy a house on the side, you know what I mean? [01:44:09] Gigi: And so a lot of people our age realize that their possibility nowadays is not to do what their father and the grandfather did, which is work a lot and save a lot of money in the conventional way, but you probably have a better chance to bet on Bitcoin. And I think a lot of people in our generation already made this bet and it paid off extremely well. And they are reinventing themselves as, yeah, you know, Bitcoiners, call them what you want. And they're doing new things and they are also providing value back to everyone. [01:44:50] Gigi: For example, Jack Mallers, the Mallers family, they were in very early and now Jack is creating the Zap wallet, for example, and it's an excellent wallet, and I think it will generate a lot of value. And he, yeah, makes good use of the money he earned by investing in Bitcoin early. So I think we will see that over and over again. But still, again, a final note on the automation and stuff, which I think will come in the next like 10, 20 years. I'm not sure if the new jobs that will spring up will be enough. [01:45:32] Gigi: And I think that things can get really bad, especially if you combine it with a potential global catastrophe like we had with the financial crisis. And, you know, I think 2008 was just a taste of what is to come. I think the potential is here in the global economic landscape that things get really, really bad. And yeah, I mean, everyone who saw recent videos and photos of Venezuela, a country where the financial system doesn't work anymore, where money just breaks, it's not a pretty sight. So again, Bitcoin is a hedge for that as well. But I really hope that at least globally speaking, it will be a smooth transition and not an apocalyptic, bad transition. [01:46:24] Vlad Costea: Also, you mentioned something about the previous generation making money a lot easier. I think another reason for our generation, and I'm not sure how old you are, I'm 27. I guess you're a little older than me, but it doesn't matter. I don't want you to dox yourself. But our generation doesn't want to inherit the debt of our parents and grandparents, as they basically built this financial system where they made themselves rich on the short term, but we have to pay back for the loans which the government got from the World Bank and stuff like that. [01:47:00] Vlad Costea: And this translates in a lower purchase power, and basically, I guess my generation here in Romania is in this kind of modern slavery where we, if we want to get a house like our parents did, then we have to work for 30 plus years to pay back the loan. Whereas they could pay back for the house in about five years and then get a car and stuff like that. That's no longer possible. The price of real estate has increased disproportionately with the incomes, and there's no way for us to actually have the same living standards or move away from our parents' house when we turn 18 and basically embrace our liberty as citizens. [01:47:49] Vlad Costea: That's not as realistic as it used to be. You can still struggle, but you're going to be struggling for a longer time before you make it. In their case, they would struggle for a few months and then get a good job and from that point on, just make a lot more money. Money up to that point, I guess, was not as inflationary. Well, it depends on the country where you come from, but do you have this discussion in Austria that the currency before the euro was less inflationary and you did not have to carry the debt weight of countries like Greece? [01:48:26] Gigi: Yeah, we have these discussions sometimes. I mean, it generally loops back just to inflation. It used to be called the Austrian Schilling and it's just funny to look back. I remember, I bought my first beer in Schilling, for example. So I kind of know what things used to cost and it's insane to look back and, not adjusting for inflation, looking back, yeah, how the actual purchasing power changed. And we have these kind of conversations, but like, I'm in my mid-thirties now and all of my friends are getting married, having kids, or having their third kid, and they're all getting loans and buying houses. [01:49:24] Gigi: And I think what you said is profoundly true and it's even worse. I would even go as far as to say, except if you're really, really lucky, you have almost no way of paying back your house in full. And I'm saying that because I talked to an architect a while ago. Yeah, it's a friend of my girlfriend actually, so she has two kids now and a husband and she just got a loan, a huge loan, and they bought a house. And she knows how the house is built and she knows all the properties of all the walls and of all the substance the house is made of. [01:50:11] Gigi: And her loan runs for 35 years. And some of the substances that are built, like they used to build the house, they have a shelf time of 30 years. So the house will be, you know, in a way, garbage after 30 years, but the loan runs for 35 years. So, you know what I mean? You don't even pay back your house in full. Before you even paid back your house, it already needs to be renovated in a very big way because the substance of the house is already bound to collapse in a way. [01:50:47] Gigi: So it's a fiat house. It's a fiat house paid by fiat money and with horrible conditions to work the loan, and all of this assumes that both parents can work their current jobs for the next 35 years. And I think that's the thing that's most unrealistic about it. And also it assumes that there will be no other financial crisis or other economic collapse. And I think also that is quite unrealistic. And so I think it's even worse than most people think because no matter what you do, thinking that you will be doing the same thing, earning the same salary, that even adjusted for inflation for the next 35 years, I think that's just insane. [01:51:32] Gigi: Just look back 35 years, like 80% of the jobs or, I don't know, at least from my group of friends that I have, they didn't exist. I mean, the world is so different than it was 30 years ago. It's kind of insane to think about it. And that's, yeah, again, it's a hard question. I don't know what to do about it. I would just say that one of the best things someone in this kind of situation can do is stay as flexible as you can. Be aware that things are happening in the world and be prepared to move maybe if you have to and just, yeah, stay flexible also in terms of what you do and what kind of education you choose. [01:52:17] Gigi: So the more skill sets you have, the better, I would say. [01:52:22] Vlad Costea: I'm really happy when I get to discuss these topics with other people from Europe, because here in Romania, we like to point our fingers to Western European countries and say they had it figured out. They know what to do. It works. And in our case, it doesn't, and it's always the fault of somebody else. And we like to put the blame on people. But now that I realize that it's basically the same kind of situation and we're all screwed to pretty much the same extent, I'm not sure if I should feel more comfortable with the situation or feel much more enraged that there is no escape from this. [01:53:07] Gigi: Yeah, that's a good point. Not sure if you should be happy about it or sad about it, that everything's bad. No, I mean, it kind of works, you know, I mean, in Central Europe in general, everything still kind of works. And that's, you know, to put it mildly, I think we're living in absolutely amazing times. And I've said it at some podcasts before, and I also recommended this book. It's called "The Better Angels of Our Nature" and the subtitle of it is "How Violence Has Declined in the World." [01:53:40] Gigi: But apart from violence, I think we're living in the best times historically, despite the catastrophe of fiat money. So I truly believe what Saifedean is saying, that if we manage to revert to a gold standard, we will have a second Renaissance and a second Belle Époque, like the time where we were on the gold standard. It was one of the most, I'm about to say preposterous, but that's the wrong word. Prosperous. That's it. The most prosperous time in history. And I think if we manage to convert to a Bitcoin standard, we will have something approximating a second Renaissance. But again, I think that in general, everyone is having the same problems and just by happenstance and luck of history... [01:54:38] Gigi: I'm born in Austria and you're born in Romania and so I'm in general better off than you are just for historical and geopolitical reasons. But still, I think when you talk to people, everyone kind of realizes that things are a little bit crazy and it feels like it can't work for much longer. The systems that are currently in place, they feel very brittle as well. And I think, again, 2008, the economic crisis, it was one tiny taste of what can happen and I think we were very, very lucky that it didn't get worse. And I believe, I think it's almost obvious to me, since governments in general, and the central banks of the world in general, they didn't do anything to course correct. [01:55:34] Gigi: They only made things worse. So similar crises are about to happen and yeah, I'm not sure what will happen after that because maybe some governments and some countries are quick enough to adopt sane policies and the people that can afford will flock to those countries and those jurisdictions. But maybe it will be something completely different than what I can think of. For example, is that something like a parallel economy and a parallel system will evolve, and I think we just see that online. I mean, for example, also in terms of... [01:56:17] Gigi: Creative work, you know, just look at all the creative works that are generated online and circulated purely online. I mean, that really is a parallel world, like niche videos and niche works of art that are created. It's unthinkable that this would have happened in the real world, quote unquote. And I think similar things can happen in the economy as well. And I think we already see that happening. I think that's also so fascinating about Bitcoin, is that everything is happening all the time at the same time. [01:56:50] Gigi: People talk about the three properties of money in Bitcoin and I think Bitcoin is evolving at such a fast rate that people use it as a store of value, as a medium of exchange, and as a unit of account at the same time, but it's not the same set of people. Like traders will use it as a unit of account, because if you trade shitcoins, then the only thing that counts is how much Bitcoin you have. A lot of people use it as a store of value because especially if the value of... [01:57:21] Gigi: Like the government currency you happen to have to use is inflating or even hyperinflating. And I myself use it as a store of value, even though the euro is kind of fine, but just the obvious relative strength of Bitcoin over just a couple of years makes me prefer Bitcoin as a store of value to the euro. And of course, there are many things that you can only get online by using Bitcoin as a medium of exchange. So all of this is happening at the same time. [01:57:57] Gigi: And I think, yeah, it's already happening with a parallel economy as well. Like there are some people that, for example, for God's sakes, they create Twitter banners for people and they're paid in Bitcoin. And not only Twitter banners for people, but Twitter banners for Bitcoin people. So we already kind of have a very weird parallel economy where people will work for Bitcoin, are getting paid in Bitcoin, and they pay goods and services in Bitcoin. And maybe that's one way out of global catastrophe in a way, that the parallel economy is big enough so that it doesn't really matter what happens with the rest of the world. [01:58:39] Gigi: And I think we saw that, for example, with the death of newspapers and other publications, it doesn't really matter, like, at all. Everyone is getting the news online and just the way you consume information has changed so drastically that I couldn't care less if some Austrian newspaper runs out of money and goes bankrupt. It really doesn't matter to me at all. [01:59:02] Gigi: And I think a lot of people in my generation would say the same. And I think it's the same also for cable news and cable TV and so on. It wouldn't really matter if they go away. The world has moved on. And maybe the same can happen with Bitcoin and money and the economy as a whole. [01:59:20] Vlad Costea: Well, I partially disagree with mediums disappearing because sometimes it's useful to have something physically because you know it cannot be altered, it's there no matter what. And in some situations you can see how certain individuals, whom I don't want to sue me, can alter their identity and existence and business record for the sake of making certain claims. And then they go to court and in some jurisdictions, the Wayback Machine is not considered to be any kind of irrefutable proof, so they do not accept it. So when it's digitized, you know that somebody has to store it. [02:00:07] Vlad Costea: And in order for the information to be intact, you have to really trust the custodian of the information. We have gatekeepers of the information whom we should trust that they do not alter arbitrarily the data. And I guess there are ways. You are into computer science, so I guess you know ways in which this can be done through advanced encryption and stuff. But also, once it's on paper, you know that it can be saved into archives and, I don't know, it's just harder to forge. [02:00:41] Gigi: But are you saying that as a response to my comment of media going away and like, for example, the New York Times going away and you need something like the New York Times because it has a certain authority and you can trust the information in it? [02:00:55] Vlad Costea: Oh, I don't mean it like that because I agree that the news can be garbage both online and on paper, if we talk about authority. It's just for historic purposes to store events, and make sure that maybe leaders of the future, who may or may not be dictators, don't come back and say, "How about we change that event?" Like in Orwell's 1984. It's so much easier to do it online with data than it is with paper that exists in storage. Maybe you can hide away the paper, but... [02:01:35] Gigi: Yeah, that is very, very true. And again, it's a hard problem to solve. And I mean, I think there are ways around it. And I think Bitcoin solves this problem perfectly. It's really, really hard to change something which is anchored in the blockchain, and I think we already have services that do that beautifully, where you can create a proof of existence or timestamps, for example. I think Peter Todd developed that. And so you can take any arbitrary data and create a cryptographic proof and put that proof into, like, anchor it in the Bitcoin blockchain, so it can't be altered, like the result of this cryptographic proof. [02:02:18] Gigi: Can't be altered after the fact, but it's not perfect and it's complicated to understand and people are not used to it and so on and so forth. And I completely agree that changing a past printed issue of The New York Times, for example, is extremely hard as compared to changing digital information that's stored somewhere centrally and so on. But yeah, I don't know. [02:02:52] Gigi: I'm kind of optimistic, because I think people are very adaptable, and I think that loops back to what I was trying to say at the very beginning, that the digital realm is just so very different than the physical one. And what you say is profoundly true, that digital information is, in general, not to be trusted in a way, because everyone can change it so easily. You just flip some bits and something is different, and you can, like, doctor almost every image and so on and so forth. But I think the more the world moves into a digital realm, we'll get better of, yeah... [02:03:25] Gigi: Getting used to this weird digital realm and also creating tools like OpenTimestamps that provide solutions to some of those issues. And I think the root problem of what you described is in essence a problem of centralization. And even in the digital world, you can have a meaningful amount of decentralization and then things are really hard to change in a way. But I agree, it's a hard problem. [02:03:59] Vlad Costea: I like to think that the stuff you can touch is much more reliable than anything else. But I also have this theory on Bitcoin that it only exists on the internet because it's the only way in which it cannot be censored. Otherwise it would be like a commodity or something that you trade and is supposed to be complementary to gold. And I think that ultimately Bitcoin will move past the internet and transcend into some other medium. Maybe, yeah, radio and satellites. That's the future. [02:04:38] Gigi: Yeah, I think... Oh man, I could talk about it for probably another two hours because that's one of the things I think about the most, probably. Bitcoin is so extremely weird because it's pure information. And I think the reason why Bitcoin is currently living, like the Bitcoin organism in a way is currently living on the internet, is because the internet is the best breeding ground, because it's a system that is really, really good at disseminating information. That's what the internet does. [02:05:05] Gigi: I completely agree with you. As soon as we have something else that is even better at disseminating information, then Bitcoin would migrate to that medium. And I think it already does in places where it has to, like where the internet is censored or where you are forced to use mesh networks and other things. But I quickly want to comment on what you said with, for you, it's everything that you can touch is more real in a way. And I think that's a very large hurdle to overcome for almost all people. [02:05:41] Gigi: And the way I like to think about it, because I'm not sure if it's true, and how durable Bitcoin really is, is yet to be seen. I mean, it's really young, it's like 10 and a half years old. But we have other systems that are pure information that have survived for thousands of years, for example the Bible and other texts. And it doesn't matter if the original medium where the text was stored is gone. As long as the text lives on, the thing lives on. [02:06:16] Gigi: And I think Bitcoin is similar to that. At least in my frame of mind, it is like that. So it doesn't matter if we have something different than the current computers, like the current Turing machines. It doesn't matter if we have something else than the internet. [02:06:33] Gigi: If the internet goes away and is replaced by something else, it wouldn't matter for Bitcoin. And also, if, for example, languages change all the time, like over thousands of years, but if we don't speak English anymore, it wouldn't really matter for Bitcoin. We would use another vocabulary for our seed phrases, and underlying all of it is just pure information. It's just bits, it's just zeros and ones, and you can represent this information in all kinds of languages. So I think, again, I think that Bitcoin is way more resilient than most people think. [02:07:05] Gigi: I think it could survive all of that. It could survive the death of the English language. It could survive the death of the internet. As long as we still have some kind of way to transmit information efficiently, Bitcoin will still live on, and it would also survive the death or the replacement of all the computers, all the mining hardware, everything we have, because we could always, I mean, for God's sake, you could even mine Bitcoin by hand if you're motivated enough, and with the difficulty adjustment, it would even make sense. So Bitcoin is very resilient. [02:07:39] Vlad Costea: Let's make a deal. How about if this is the kind of topic about which you can talk for two hours or so, how about you write about two or three pages about it for the Bitcoin Takeover book? And this may have served as a teaser for what's about to come. [02:07:54] Gigi: Yeah, why not? I'll take you up on that. I can't promise you... [02:08:00] Vlad Costea: You can just call it something like Bitcoin Beyond the Internet. [02:08:03] Gigi: I can't promise you when I will be done with it because historically I'm really, really slow with finishing articles. But yeah, sure. [02:08:17] Vlad Costea: Okay, this has been a very productive discussion and I'm not sure if I have any more questions at this point because I guess we have talked for over two hours and we're both hungry and tired. It's almost midnight here. [02:08:31] Gigi: Yeah. Yeah. I'll let you sleep then. And that was a great conversation. Thanks for having me. That was a lot of fun. [02:08:39] Vlad Costea: Thank you, Gigi. And this was incredible, actually. You never know what you get, but in the Bitcoin space, you always get extraordinary people who have all these interesting opinions. And even though a lot of people may call this a cult where we, say, form an echo chamber and create this sort of uniform opinions, but the more I talk to people, the more I discover that they know stuff which I have never heard about. And it gets uniformized, what do you call that word? I'm too tired. [02:09:12] Gigi: But as a last comment, I would be in favor of fully embracing the cult idea and form a Bitcoin religion because it would be way easier on everyone's taxes. And maybe we will be enough people to actually do that one day in the future. [02:09:30] Vlad Costea: Right. Well, I don't know about that, but yeah, I try to stay away from the cult narrative because I try to pose as a regular person who got into this for very rational reasons and is part of the community to learn and not to get brainwashed by some kind of weird cult. And I never bought any Bitcoin-specific merchandise. I don't wear it in public. I try to be as normal as possible just to stay sane and not get, you know, taken too far. [02:10:04] Gigi: That's also very good opsec, so I encourage everyone to do that. [02:10:09] Vlad Costea: Yeah, makes a lot of sense. So thank you, I'll post this tomorrow, just so you know. [02:10:16] Gigi: Thanks again for having me. That was great. Have a good night. [02:10:20] Vlad Costea: You too. Gute Nacht. [02:10:22] Gigi: Ja, gute Nacht, Vlad. ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio/video call recorded late in the evening, in English between non-native speakers (Romanian host, Austrian guest), opening with a short music intro and no sponsor reads. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 9 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (173 chunks) and 48 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 5 of 5 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed ♪, "Thank you for having me.", stray "Foundation."/"Bye."; normalized "Gigi Dorn"; restored dropped speech (00:02:34 gap, Ross Ulbricht Foundation passage, scammer line) from second ASR/Scribe; fixed @dergigi, Everyone's a Scammer, Bitcoin Error Log, Saifedean, tragedy of the commons, counterexample, fiat shitcoin wallet; split interjections (Gigi "Hey, Vlad", "Exactly", "Yeah, exactly", "Great"; Vlad "Oh, you're..."; Vlad's closing line); Removed hallucinations ("Gigi, you're on the right track", "Gigi Gigi", "I think that's a great question", "Thank you"); restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (00:19:50 "king-like... government prints", 00:22 "value. And we have seen what happens if", 00:23 crisis lines, 00:26 savings services, 00:27 exchanges passage, 00:29-00:30 Samourai/fungible passage); fixed Brady/Citizen Bitcoin, Keynesian, Lolli, Alex Waltz, Samourai Wallet, Bitcoiners, fiat money, stacking sats, one-on-one; split long monologues; Restored dropped speech (magic passage 00:33:24, "in the right direction" 00:39:37, "physical security" line, fee passage before 00:44:19) from second ASR/Scribe; removed hallucinations "Thank you.", "Gigi, you're on the right.", repeated "know, for a long time", "it's a good idea"; fixed seed phrase, Jameson Lopp, Marty Bent, Bitcoin base chain, Coinbase, "better off", safe deposit box, "talking as someone"; moved "Yeah, I don't remember who wrote the" to Gigi; Fixed Brandon Quittem, Ralph Merkle, Bitcoin maximalists, Nouriel Roubini, "dead branches/insects", "ants"; restored dropped speech (DAO passage, attacked/redundancy, lymph, YouTubers, prohibition, ants) from second ASR/Scribe; removed hallucinations "Gigi, you're on the right track", "Thank you", "I'm sure you all know the reasons", stray "- Yeah. - Great."; removed trailing "doesn't" to match next window; Labelled continuation paragraphs as Gigi/Vlad; removed hallucinations ("Episode:", "Gigi, you're on the right track", "Gigi, what do you think?", "doing Bitcoin?" loop); restored dropped speech at 01:07:09 tail, 01:08:21 and 01:11:09 from second ASR/re-check; fixed Alahash→BetterHash, Segway2x→SegWit2x, felt→thought exercise, inside the space→in cyberspace, attack factors→vectors, respond→were spawned, debt→that, The Sovereign Individual; Vlad's "Yeah." moved to Gigi; Removed hallucinations (episode title, "Thank you for watching...", doubled words, "Gigi, you're on the right", "Thank you", "Gigi, what's your take on Bitcoin?", "Gigi has been"); restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (Lightning/economy sentence, "That was a very long answer...", Vlad's 01:30 gap, "move away from"); split 01:20:24 exchanges (Gigi "Yeah, that's terrible indeed", "Yeah, definitely"); fixed Bitcoin Core, Lightning, CoinJoin, Austria (not Australia), war generals, Mises/Rothbard, taken seriously; Split Gigi's "I know her by name at least" interjection from Vlad's turn; removed "Gigi on Bitcoin as a Living Organism" hallucination and doubled words; rest