Title: S6 E10: Shilling Lightning to the Moon with John Carvalho Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): John Carvalho, Bitcoin/Lightning business developer (ex-Bitrefill) and circular-economy advocate Published: 2020-10-08 Duration: 1:00:01 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2020-10-08_s6_e10_john_carvalho_shilling_lightning_to_the_moon.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2020-10-08_s6_e10_john_carvalho_shilling_lightning_to_the_moon.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:00] John Carvalho: Alright, good morning, Vlad. Good night, Rolo. [00:00:03] Vlad Costea: Buona giornata, as we say. Yes, buona [00:00:05] John Carvalho: giornata. Giornata. [00:00:09] Vlad Costea: This might be a livestream, but it's going to end up in Season 6, Episode 10 of Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. And I gave this a subtitle. [00:00:16] John Carvalho: Oh, the pressure's on. [00:00:18] Vlad Costea: Oh, yeah. It's shilling Lightning to the moon. [00:00:23] John Carvalho: Shilling Lightning to the moon. Well, you know, I'm not really like as prominently... [00:00:29] Vlad Costea: No, no, no, you're the business developer that nobody asked for. Yes, I'm asking for you today. [00:00:36] John Carvalho: Okay, well, I'll let you lead the show then. Go ahead. [00:00:39] Vlad Costea: Okay, so let me start with a personal anecdote because I suppose that's what gets people involved in conversations. So I haven't run a Lightning node in months. And I've only used these custodial Lightning services like BlueWallet, without connecting to my node. I just thought, okay, it's a small amount, I don't care. But I know I should, but I just didn't find the right time to do it. And I don't want to do it just on my computer. I want to do it permanently by purchasing a Raspberry Pi and running one of those full nodes all the time. I've been just lazy and I didn't do it. So how about you convince me today on why I should start running it right now as opposed to waiting for the blocks to fill when it's already too late to start opening channels for cheap. [00:01:34] John Carvalho: Yeah, that's tough. I'm not sure. I think you should. I definitely support Lightning and I definitely think it will be used by a lot of people. But as far as like, it's not the same thing, in my opinion, to put on people to say, "Oh, you need to run a Lightning node the same way you need to run a Bitcoin node." Like, you definitely should have a Bitcoin node. But the situations where you're using Lightning, you know, are mostly like hot wallet kind of situations. And so I think that's why people are generally more tolerant of the custodial wallets and like kind of in-between setups like Neutrino and things like this, because you're not really going to be keeping your cold storage Bitcoin in your Lightning wallet. [00:02:17] John Carvalho: This is supposed to be hot Bitcoin that's moving around, right? And then the kind of user that's going to be running a Lightning node most commonly is probably someone that's trying to be part of the infrastructure. And so, like, I don't think we need to have, like, people that, I don't know, are just kind of Bitcoin enthusiasts or spending, you know, maybe 50 bucks a month of their Bitcoin. They don't need to be people trying to learn how to optimize their channel routes and, you know, determine what the best nodes to connect to are and try to see if they can cheese 15 bucks of fees, you know, out of their node. It's not really a good fit. [00:02:56] John Carvalho: And so I think that, like, you know, I don't think what you're describing is laziness. I think you're just describing that you don't have incentive, and I don't know that that will change until it's just something that you don't have to think about. I think that will be once more of the Lightning implementations have better mobile compatibility. Like, right now, there's not really c-lightning support in mobile, and so that isn't really represented. Whereas LND, you know, supports Neutrino, and you can get a better kind of trade-off by doing that. But even that isn't really that prevalent in wallets. So I think it's kind of a long answer to your question. I don't think you should worry about it too much. [00:03:35] John Carvalho: I think that it's better to understand Lightning, better to be an enthusiast of the applications that are possible and being built now than it is to participate in the consensus of Lightning, because it's not really a thing. [00:03:50] Vlad Costea: I think right now the two incentives to run a full Lightning node are to collect fees, and that can be a nice way of not necessarily making money, but at least covering the costs, the electricity costs of keeping the node running all the time, hoping that maybe at some point in the future that's going to accrue more value. And the other one concerns the decentralization of the network. I don't necessarily agree with the idea that there's going to be like five or six companies that have invested a lot early on in Lightning, and they're going to be like the oligopolies of this ecosystem. And I know that there's going to be a lot of stuff that's getting built on top of Lightning. So there's going to be layer 3, layer 4, and so on. And I think, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it's better if there are more nodes and there are more individual nodes that are running Lightning. [00:04:52] John Carvalho: I can't tell you're wrong. It's not a correct me if I'm wrong thing. It's a little bit of prediction, a little bit of theory. We could both be wrong, but I don't agree with you. I don't think that it's a good notion to promote that people are going to make money off of routing, like small people. I think it is actually going to be a business-oriented role. And then there actually is no need for someone to participate altruistically to contribute to the decentralization of the Lightning Network. [00:05:25] John Carvalho: That's not a thing either. I understand why people would kind of extend from Bitcoin theory and try to apply that to Lightning. But this is actually what the biggest advantage of Lightning is: it allows us to leverage centralization trustlessly. The worst that somebody can do to you is basically be a nuisance, you know, by being unreliable and stopping to, you know, provide the services that you've been expecting. But the formation of the Lightning Network, I don't know, I put a tweet out recently that somebody else had made, and it showed like the kind of largest nodes that had the biggest channels and like how many channels each of them had. [00:06:04] John Carvalho: And it was maybe 15, 20 nodes at most. And really, we're talking about maybe four or five nodes that are actually very significant. I should have them memorized, but, you know, for example, it's like Bitfinex, ACINQ, and Bitrefill are some of the major ones. And that's because those are actually ones that have economic activity and people having actual users. It's like, think of it like forming an organism. Like, the arteries are going to form, then the veins and capillaries and such. And so, you know, like most people are just going to be capillaries. [00:06:36] John Carvalho: They're just going to be on the outside and trying to get tapped into the biggest vein they can so they can reach anybody they need to reach. And so that's not something like a centralization concept you have to worry about. Yeah, if it was only one major node and everybody was connected to it's probably a problem because that ultimately is just one service provider that everybody relies on. But the difference with... When we move to a more decentralized paradigm for everything, we're just getting used to it with Bitcoin and now Lightning. [00:07:08] John Carvalho: But people want to do a lot of this kind of thing with changing how the internet works, identity, all these Web3 concepts, etc. And they're going to have to get used to this, that the idea isn't that the network will totally reform in how it looks and who is a major player. It's that it will become open competition. And so anybody can participate and kind of move the network away should they have incentive to move away. So like, I don't know, I say to people, the decentralized Twitter that people want to talk about, it's going to look just like Twitter looks right now. [00:07:44] John Carvalho: Twitter will be the biggest service provider because they're the best at scaling, the best at serving tweets and small kind of things. They know how to make sure they can get the same data all over the world. And initially, they'll be the biggest one. But what will happen is tweets will be able to leave Twitter, and other people will be able to serve different user experiences and different kind of paradigms of how this kind of Twitter infrastructure works. And so eventually, if other people are doing it better or more locally, more efficiently, you know, then people can just migrate away from Twitter. But, you know, it is a competition, and the same thing is happening on Lightning. It's an open competition for ordering transactions onto the base layer. [00:08:28] Vlad Costea: Right. I can think of, yeah, like five or six big businesses that operate the biggest nodes. But luckily, Lightning is permissionless, unlike the Liquid sidechain, where you require the permission of one of the federation members to onboard and to leave that sidechain. With Lightning, you can do whatever you want whenever you want to. So I suppose you're right in the sense that neither of us is wrong. And if there were enough individuals to run nodes, the network could benefit and could build this auxiliary infrastructure. I suppose if businesses like Bitfinex and Bitrefill and ACINQ are the arteries and the stuff that helps the blood flow into the system, I suppose there could be a lot of skin in the game, and I know I've used a bad pun, but whatever. [00:09:26] John Carvalho: Well, yeah, I mean, like I said, I think maybe where you're right is that, you know, contributing to the decentralization by altruistically, you know, spinning up a node and providing liquidity, it will be more that way in the later stages. And so the reason why I maybe think it's a mistake to think that way now isn't that you're wrong. It's that it's not important right now. It will be important later when there are many more use cases and many more types of people using the Lightning Network. [00:09:55] John Carvalho: And you want to have sort of fragmented, fractal, you know, sub-networks where people are doing things that only matter to them and not other people. Kind of like how I mentioned with the smaller network of large nodes. They also, before Wumbo was officially supported, they were kind of breaking network consensus to support large channels forming a sub-network. And you'll see a lot of different kinds of sub-networks, I think, over time. And that will turn into this kind of more fractal future that we kind of have to move towards if we want things to be efficient on layers. [00:10:33] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I suppose I agree with you. But at the same time, the reason why I'm FOMOing on the idea of running a node is that at some point in the future, it might not be sustainable from an opening channel cost point of view. So I should start running a node right now and open channels while the blocks are not full and while the fees are acceptable in terms of costs. That's reasonable. If people actually need Lightning and they're going to move to it will be because the blocks are full, and by that time it's going to be a lot more expensive to start running a full node. [00:11:16] John Carvalho: I mean, I think that's reasonable, but I think that it's kind of an overstatement in that it's not going to catch you by surprise, right? It's not going to be that one day you're going to wake up and it's going to cost $500 to make a channel. You're going to see it coming, you know. So maybe you'll start making channels at $5 instead of at $2 or whatever because you have this concern. But right now, it still hasn't been high enough to incentivize you, right? Or disincentivize, you know, the behavior that you've been doing so far. [00:11:46] John Carvalho: So I don't think it'll sneak up on you. I do think that some people are thinking the way you're talking about, though. Like, a lot of people are wondering what that node LNbig is doing with opening tons of channels all over the place since the beginning of the Lightning Network. It could just be that they maybe have a model of... Maybe they've really modeled out the future in a way they're really confident, and they just think, "One day everybody's going to want to buy these channels off of us. One day, you know, we're going to have so much access and so much..." They may have some kind of theory behind it. I don't know. But that would be in line with kind of what you're saying, I think. I just don't think it'll sneak up on anybody. I think you'll have a chance, you know? [00:12:21] Vlad Costea: I have a very technical question up next, and it concerns something that I was supposed to write about for Bitcoin Magazine last year. And essentially, Aaron just took me out of it because it's kind of complicated, it's a delicate topic. I'm not sure if it was solved since last year. It's about routing. And I know there are lots of teams working on different routing systems. And they want to allow the network to be as decentralized as possible without incentivizing just big nodes that have been around since day one. [00:12:58] Vlad Costea: And that's a big problem, especially in Romania, because when you run a Lightning node here, you're not collecting any routing fees, because these routing fees are based on proximity, and you're not really routing payments if you're just one node in... I suppose there are like 50 in Romania right now. [00:13:16] John Carvalho: Okay, it has nothing to do with geographic proximity. [00:13:21] Vlad Costea: Okay, go on. [00:13:22] John Carvalho: Yeah, but I think you... I'd like you to finish your question. You said it was a technical question. [00:13:27] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so where did routing get throughout the last year? [00:13:34] John Carvalho: So when I talk about proximity, it's not about geographic proximity. It's more about actual topography of economic proximity. So this is a digital realm we're talking about. These nodes don't care what country you're in. They're not going to not route with you because of, like, you know, 100 milliseconds of latency. They're going to route with you based off of who you're connected to and what kind of liquidity you have balanced in your channels. So basically, they're just looking for a path, and if you can be that path digitally, they don't care where you are in the world. So it's nothing. Romania isn't limiting us. [00:14:11] John Carvalho: It's more our knowledge of which nodes to get in the middle of so we can be taxing traffic. And so automatically you can kind of guess that this is actually... that the attitude is an inefficiency. You know, to say, "I'm going to put myself in the middle and tax it," that's not providing a service, right? So you have to actually naturally have a position. [00:14:35] John Carvalho: You have to be somewhere that a lot of people want to send money through or to for a reason. And this is why Bitrefill and Bitfinex and such, and wallets actually are another big one, are the most kind of routed nodes, because they have the actual most people really sending money between each other to those places. You can't just shove yourself in. And this is why I don't like the whole farming fees thing. Now, I will say that in the future, in use cases, including use cases I want to help cultivate with the business I'm starting, I think it will become more true. [00:15:07] John Carvalho: I think someday you will be able to plug in your Lightning node or some kind of home server, set your resources into how much you want to publicly provide and just kind of install some machine learning kind of bots and things like this and kind of farm the network by providing, you know, bandwidth or storage or relaying, you know, these kinds of things. But we're kind of a little bit far off from that. And then to answer the routing part of your question, you can probably guess what I'll say because it's in line with everything else I've been saying. [00:15:39] John Carvalho: I actually think that, now, I'm not an engineer, so I'm probably going to sound ignorant to them, but I think that there's a little bit too much focus on advanced routing problems. I guess maybe they'll take a long time to solve and we'll be happy they're in place when we need them. But if you take what I've been saying about centralization being kind of okay on Lightning, as long as it doesn't get out of hand, the routing actually never is that complex. [00:16:05] John Carvalho: And so things like multi-path payments, what they do is they say, "Oh, I want to take a network that, the direct route that I'm trying to take, there isn't enough liquidity. So I'm going to take all these other routes and I'm going to move, I'm going to rebalance the whole entire network just because the direct route doesn't have liquidity." And so you're basically kind of, it's like a leeching kind of behavior. And I actually think it will become an inefficiency. Like in the end, you want to be connected to the people that are going to get your money to where it goes. [00:16:38] John Carvalho: You don't want to be looking for all these obscure connections to be able to route things. Now, I'm going to be wrong in some senses because eventually the network will be super huge, and maybe somebody wants to send really large payments in an unusual direction. [00:16:53] John Carvalho: But generally, that's like an optimization. These are edge cases. Most of the time for the foreseeable future, Lightning doesn't need that kind of advanced routing. Now, you could make arguments in the sense of like privacy and other things like this, so that the way there are kind of different peers or different behavior for, you know, people that are snooping on the network to analyze and assess. And maybe these routing things can affect that. Like trampoline payments is one, and this is like this kind of way of sending a payment into a zone and you kind of have to hope that it hops into another zone. And so it's just a different approach to routing that maybe will provide different trade-offs for privacy and such. Christian Decker would be someone to talk better about that. [00:17:39] John Carvalho: I think he's the one working on that. But I hope that answers your question. [00:17:43] Vlad Costea: Yeah. So yesterday I've listened to your talk with Sergej, and he referred to Lightning as a gun that's on the shelf or something like that, because it's ready, it's functional, but it's not used at its potential. Not many people are having economic activity on Lightning. So why do you think that is? Because last year we were speaking in Berlin. I think it was exactly one year ago. And everyone was much more optimistic about Lightning. But the events that happened in the last year just prove that there is not much demand for Lightning. [00:18:22] John Carvalho: So I'm going to be a little bit theoretical and critical in my answer. I don't know how right I am, but I actually think it's a culture problem, is one of the biggest problems. The culture in Bitcoin, you know, of this number go up, maximalism kind of getting dumbed down from what I think it actually is derived from. It's turned into this kind of culture where we hate the shitcoins because they're fake innovation, and we love Bitcoin because it's the only real coin and it's going to go up and everybody knows it and that's it. And this leads to, like, you know, this extends into the whole culture of what investment, where investment money goes, what products get built, what products people conceive of to be built, and everything gets biased towards finance. [00:19:10] John Carvalho: And so you see companies like, you know, I don't want to rag on them, but, you know, the easiest example, Blockstream. Like, they were kind of like the great white hope of Bitcoiners. You know, we wanted to think, okay, these guys are going to make all the cool shit, right? Like, they're going to save Bitcoin, they're going to make the future true that we all want. In a lot of ways they still are that and do that. But their actual products and the things that they put effort into, and this is just a natural incentive structure, have bias towards finance products. [00:19:45] John Carvalho: And so now you have things like Liquid, you have things like providing services, like they have these partnerships with, you know, these finance things, you know, ICE and such, and ways to provide data. And then Liquid is supposed to be about providing arbitrage opportunities, and you have this federation of all these big exchanges, and it's like, where is the cypherpunk? Where is the, you know, the Bitcoininess? And, you know, I'm being unfair because they do have, you know, Lightning research they do, and core development they sponsor and things like this. [00:20:16] John Carvalho: But Lightning kind of, you know, I did my best to hype it and let people try to open their imaginations of that. There's really a lot more possible now because of this kind of instant paradigm, this peer-to-peer paradigm. [00:20:30] John Carvalho: And mostly it turned out to be a few games, which I think will end up being cool eventually, and feeding chickens and talking about routing and making wallets. But where is the consumer stuff? Where is the, you know, publishing stuff, the Web3 stuff? Where is all of the stuff that is not finance? You know, and I'll use that as a plug again for the company I'm working on. Basically, we're trying to focus on all the things that are not finance, and so we'll make a number of products in that direction. [00:21:05] John Carvalho: And so Sergej is kind of right, but it's also maybe his responsibility to make that not true anymore. And this goes into the conversation about, you know, you saw recently me trying to get back on guilting exchanges to add Lightning. Even exchanges don't even understand why it's important to add Lightning. They just think of it as strictly about the fees. And so they're saying, "Oh, we'll wait until fees are high and then we'll, you know, hire a Lightning guy and we'll support Lightning." But if the exchanges are the arteries economically, then if they don't support Bitcoin upgrades, how are they supposed to be... [00:21:46] John Carvalho: Like, how is there supposed to be a framework for product designers and builders to look at and say, "Oh, how can I, what can I do with this?" And you need that infrastructure there. [00:22:00] John Carvalho: You need to know that all the exchanges will be there and their customers will be there to be able to access whatever you're building on Lightning. If you don't have the exchanges supporting it, then you're basically trying to compete with that instead of, you know, synergize with it. And so this is kind of what I explained to Jesse when I was trying to argue the case to him, that their support is important and Bitfinex's support is important because of the opportunities that they're kind of delaying by not supporting it. [00:22:30] John Carvalho: And, you know, the next DeFi or the better DeFi or something could be, you know, a year away or could be three months away. And that's really up to people like Kraken and infrastructure. And so I'll go back to what I started with and say, I think it's a culture problem. I think that Bitcoiners need to get smarter and they need to get more creative and they need to stop thinking that Bitcoin is here just to get them rich by this asymmetric kind of information they think they have. [00:23:01] Vlad Costea: I think also the narrative of digital gold has played a role in this mindset. You see people all the time buying Bitcoin on Cash App mostly and posting screenshots and writing captions such as, "These sats are mine forever. Nobody will ever touch them. I have strong hands. Nobody will ever get them." Blah, blah. That's how you know it's not true. You don't really understand how economics work and you need to have liquidity for businesses and for the entire ecosystem to develop. You can't just expect people to buy into Bitcoin at some point in the future unless you develop some sort of economy around it. [00:23:40] Vlad Costea: You need to give them lots of reasons, except for number go up, to get into it. Yeah, and one of it is very important and is the one that gets me and keeps me in. And it's the one about censorship resistance and about hedging against inflation and stuff like that. But you also need to build a parallel economy, or you call it a circular economy because you're a circular economist, so... [00:24:08] John Carvalho: I call it both. I think that it starts as a parallel economy and it only succeeds because that economy is circular. We are going to have to do something outside of the system and separate. We are going to have to build a new kind of digital area for people to kind of play in and build in. And if people don't start thinking that way, it's going to be much harder and it's going to take much longer. And I just think that the finance stuff is kind of like, all right, we have enough people caring about that. Let's see what else we can do. [00:24:38] Vlad Costea: But Lightning at the same time is a network that's agnostic to the type of currency. So, theoretically speaking, you could build this kind of economy on Litecoin and Monero and, I don't know, just use it. [00:24:53] John Carvalho: Well, no, it's not about Lightning only. Lightning is just a way of dealing with this key pair structure that has this token inside of it. It's about Bitcoin, is the reason. If we're going to build a whole new economy on the internet, what better network do we have than Bitcoin? Like, it's got the most use, it's the safest, it's the most secure, it's the most censorship resistant. Like, if we're going to go in here and kind of cause a digital revolution, it has to be Bitcoin. There's not really any other option. [00:25:25] Vlad Costea: Oh, I can agree with that, but at the same time, you need to show people how it's done. And they need to understand that there should be this type of economy, and I suppose people in Litecoin would be much more open into embracing Lightning, even though they have no incentive. They have empty blocks right now. [00:25:46] John Carvalho: That assumes that there are actually people of Litecoin. I don't think there are. I think that the only people of Litecoin are the people that think that they can get this kind of sneaky upside, by investing in silver instead of gold. And that's all they really care about. There's not any kind of community or movement or special thing. They're just thinking, "Okay, what can we do to seem relevant so that we can continue to be like the B team store of value?" And that's actually not the worst thing in the world, I'll be honest with you. [00:26:18] John Carvalho: I've done a lot of thinking about modeling the future of Bitcoin and the scalability of it. If we want it to be for everybody, it really does get complicated. And we might actually need to have, and it's evidenced already by how many we have, for non-speculative reasons, we might need to have tier two blockchains. I don't know if they're feasible because of how mining works and how attackable they may be if they get too large. But it might be hard to do absolutely everything on Bitcoin. We might actually need to have a second tier of lower security. [00:26:55] John Carvalho: And that's been evidenced by when fees went really high, all of a sudden altcoins actually had a use case. It was like, oh, I can move my crypto in these exchanges because they also support these altcoins and I can save on fees and then convert again when I get back on the exchange. It was kind of like a hack to deal with things, but there they were. Altcoins finally had an argument, you know. [00:27:19] Vlad Costea: I suppose. I remember December 2017 and all that mania about getting on exchanges, and you were not even able to create accounts on Binance at the time. It just hit a bottleneck. I'm not sure if we're going to see that very soon, except for that DeFi degeneracy, which I don't really get. [00:27:45] John Carvalho: Yeah, everybody keeps saying the fees will go up, and they have been kind of going up slowly. And I do wonder, you know, how often and for how long we will get these kind of, oh, the blocks are actually full and fees are actually significantly high. Like, this is annoying. I don't know when we'll get that again for sure. It could be that we've installed enough valves on Bitcoin where it'll be like fees on chain will get kind of higher than normal and fees on Lightning will get kind of higher than normal, and it will just kind of go like this, you know, like stair step up. [00:28:20] John Carvalho: I realize you're recording this for your podcast, so I can't use my hands. It'll kind of stair step up and maybe never reach, you know, full blocks for any consistent amount of time because we have these valves that people will kind of leak out into that will be cheaper, you know. [00:28:36] Vlad Costea: You know, after the halving, it seemed like the blocks were full for like a month. And it was very difficult to get any transaction in a block without paying a lot more in terms of fees. So if you're broadcasting a one sat per byte transaction, you'd have had to wait like a month to get it confirmed. So it seemed like there was something happening there, but I suppose it could have been just miners spamming the mempool just to... It could be the same thing with Ethereum right now. [00:29:15] John Carvalho: I actually think that's probably a good theory of what happened in 2017. Like the fees were, the fee portion of the block reward was pretty significant. I don't know, it was like more than one Bitcoin, two Bitcoin, while Bitcoin was at like $15,000, $20,000, right? And so these are significant amounts of fees. And if you had miners, you know, if say these miners did have, you know, half the network, you can start doing some formulas to determine, like, if I start spamming my own fees, you know, if I make transactions and I start, you know, raising the fee rate in the mempool, can I get everybody else to pay? [00:29:55] John Carvalho: And how much will I lose if I don't mine my own block? But if you mine your own block, you get your own fees back, right? So if there's too much centralization, you can kind of hack the network to just raise the fees. And I think that may have been part of the phenomenon back then. I think it may be harder now, a lot more miners, a lot more places, but Ethereum, maybe not. Like, I would suspect that Ethereum mining is probably very centralized, you know, if it's anything like their node network. And the miners probably do have the same kind of advantages to be able to do those kinds of things by like, you know... [00:30:32] John Carvalho: Hell, if I was a miner, I would design DeFi, I would say. Like, let me find a way to trap all these people in this thing where they think they're going to realize this inefficiency that is worth making 10%, but then I'm going to charge them 11% in fees just to be able to have access, and they're not going to realize it until they get out that they actually had a loss, even though the trade was profitable. And that's a nice little kind of hack that they can do on people. I don't know if it's true, though. [00:30:59] Vlad Costea: It might be. Thankfully, we got rid of Bitmain, and they're not a big player in Bitcoin anymore, and they got rekt supporting BCH, which was, I guess, the decision that led to their downfall. I think they're not even the biggest ASIC manufacturer right now. [00:31:20] John Carvalho: I don't know, man. I don't believe any of the stories I hear about Chinese mining because, like, one, I don't know if I could believe them if they said things themselves, just by the nature of the way they did business historically in Bitcoin. And then all of the news coming out is like, you know, second, third, fourth hand from people that, like, I don't really know why I should trust them either. And so, like, these stories about the Bitmain IPO and, you know, Micree Zhan trying to take over with Jihan. [00:31:50] John Carvalho: Like, it all just seems like made-up drama that I could never care about unless I was on the ground there with them, you know, and part of it and skin in the game. Like, I just think it's like, I don't know, soap operas for Bitcoiners. [00:32:04] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but that's a very good indicator that we are in the middle of a bull market, when you see China FUD. [00:32:11] John Carvalho: Maybe, maybe, we'll see. [00:32:11] Vlad Costea: If they ban Bitcoin, then it means that we are in the middle of a bull market. [00:32:15] John Carvalho: And three-letter agencies going after exchanges is a good kickoff for bull markets as well, like closing Silk Road, things like this. And so maybe these BitMEX arrests and charges from the CFTC are like, we'll get our last nice dip and kind of move steady up from here. But I don't know. Part of me also wishes that we don't get a new high on this cycle. [00:32:45] Vlad Costea: Okay, so let me ask you a more direct question, and you don't have to answer it honestly, but what did you buy lately with Lightning? Did you make any economic purchases? [00:32:56] John Carvalho: I'm trying to think what I played with. LN Markets is probably the most recent thing. I know those guys and I helped connect them. Ryan Gentry, now he's at Lightning Labs, formerly at Multicoin Capital. He was talking to them about me and I told them I thought they were cool. And so we kind of helped connect them with some investors and they ended up getting some funding. And so I've been paying close attention to them, partly because I think that they could probably eat BitMEX's lunch, at least on the retail trader side. [00:33:29] John Carvalho: And I want to see if, like, they can be a better, you know, type of exchange where maybe they'll very early on realize, like, creating use cases for, you know, more self-sovereign types of accounts and maybe, you know, DLCs and having some kind of more decentralized aspects to what they do, since they're kind of starting with Lightning. And it's just really cool to be able to, like, log in with your... You know, you just scan something with your phone, you're logged in. You want to make a trade, you scan a QR code, and now the trade is open. [00:33:52] John Carvalho: Like, I don't know, it just feels like a much cooler user experience to me. I don't know if other people will like it, but that's probably the last thing I used Lightning for. I want to say Lightnite, but they didn't have me. I won't pay the prices that they charge for skins in that system, and it seems like it still needs some time to get ready, but the game seems like it could be cool, and I was a big Dota player for a while, and I liked collecting the skins on that, so I'm looking forward to having that kind of paradigm, but I'm not really willing to use Liquid and such, so I'll wait till RGB is ready. [00:34:42] Vlad Costea: Oh, so speaking of Lightnite, I suppose you're in... I forget his name because it's so early. What's the name of the creator? [00:34:51] John Carvalho: Oh, I don't know their names by heart. I don't know. If you said it, I would say... [00:34:56] Vlad Costea: On the podcast. Yeah, he's Spanish, so I know what he looks like. I don't remember the name. I'm very sorry. Honestly, so is he Spanish or Brazilian? [00:35:06] John Carvalho: I think that, no, he's Spanish. He's Spanish. Yeah. No, I didn't follow them that closely. I probably should follow the Lightning gaming side of the world more closely. I've been starting to. I installed Bitcoin Bounce to start playing with that, and actually played Lightning for the first time recently. [00:35:23] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I just remembered, Carlos Roldan. I think you were on his podcast recently, right? [00:35:29] John Carvalho: No. [00:35:30] Vlad Costea: You were not? [00:35:31] John Carvalho: I don't think so. [00:35:32] Vlad Costea: Because I know that he was having lots of high-profile guests and I don't know, I just thought... [00:35:37] John Carvalho: I'm not high-profile, I just troll high-profile people. [00:35:41] Vlad Costea: Right. But he seems very enthusiastic about his clone of Fortnite. And it's going to be interesting to see how the market reacts and how gamers in general react to this type of game which incentivizes them to play more and shoot more enemies. [00:36:01] John Carvalho: I mean, I think that competitive gaming, like betting, tournaments, this kind of thing is another side of Bitcoin and Lightning that could be cool, like actually having real money at stake. We'll probably hit some roadblocks with the legalities of this. Like, in other words, it isn't our bright idea. I'm sure many, many game companies before wanted people to be able to use real money to do things. And so there'll be some kind of probably roadblocks there that we're kind of conveniently ignoring. But I'm not the one working in the gaming field, so it's not my problem. But it could be interesting if they can figure out how to do it. Yeah. [00:36:39] Vlad Costea: I've actually pitched the idea of Lightning monetization in game and allowing people to earn and spend Lightning Bitcoin in games to John Romero, who is one of the creators of Doom and Wolfenstein and Quake. I got to talk to him and he was like, "There is a reason why companies use proprietary virtual currencies, because they control them. They don't care about supply and inflation. It just works." And gamers have gotten used to it and he didn't see any kind of value in it. He didn't believe that it has any kind of potential. [00:37:16] Vlad Costea: It might have some users in third world country markets where they basically make enough satoshis for them to turn it into a job, possibly. And I suppose we are seeing that with Bitcoin Bounce, which is a mobile game where if you collect lots of tickets, you earn some satoshis every day. [00:37:42] John Carvalho: Yeah, I mean, I do think that, you know, in places where, you know, the money is worth a lot more, that you definitely see these use cases and these types of users. I know that, like, for example, Stakwork is doing these kind of micro-task job things with their website. And they have their, I don't know if it's public, so I probably shouldn't talk about it, but they have other projects they're doing in kind of these poorer areas that are giving them, you know, access to these kind of micro jobs, and it's much more meaningful in some areas than others. So maybe that's something I wanted to say earlier when you were talking, I forgot what the topic was, but... [00:38:24] John Carvalho: With number go up, I always like to remind people, it's like, yes, maybe Bitcoin will be at $100,000, but what if a hamburger costs $10,000? It's not just about number go up. You have to think about what the actual situation will be when that number is up, and if your buying power is actually what you expected. [00:38:46] Vlad Costea: I suppose a lot of people disregard what inflation actually means and how it impacts the price of goods and services. So they think, "Oh yeah, it's going to go to one million," but what does that mean for the rest of the economy? Is your purchasing power going to be comparable to the same one that you have right now, just because the market has adjusted in terms of prices? [00:39:12] John Carvalho: This is like what I'm worried will be like the big lie of number go up, that, you know, if you really think abstractly well enough, the odds are what you're going to come out with is what you just said, that your buying power right now, your place in society right now will probably be pretty similar as society progresses on its current path. The asymmetric kind of trade on Bitcoin is just becoming much smaller and smaller, you know. And if all you're relying on is inflation, well, if everybody else knows too, you're just going to be in the same rank in the economic world as you are now, potentially. [00:39:52] John Carvalho: You may have some advantage, but I just really do not like this culture of thinking that I can sit around and wait for me to get rich while other people do things, if I just hold Bitcoin. [00:40:05] Vlad Costea: I suppose that was the case a few years ago, but we're not sure if it's applicable. It takes a lot more money to get Bitcoin from 10K to 100K than it took it to get from 1K to 10K. [00:40:19] John Carvalho: So, exactly. [00:40:20] Vlad Costea: I find it silly when people look at graphs and models and, you know, stuff like stock-to-flow, and they say every four years it's going 10x, and it has been doing this and there's a pattern and there certainly must be something there because it's in the protocol. It's the pumponomics. [00:40:39] John Carvalho: That's the problem, is if we keep indoctrinating this perspective with every entrant, then we'll kind of manifest it, right? Like, everybody will, you know, sell sometime in year two or three, and everybody will buy sometime in year four or one, and then every cycle everybody will try to catch the wave, and there will be no waves. And I worry about, like, some kind of, like, you know, post-Bitcoin depression or something because so many people believing in this and then never being able to catch the ride, never being able to catch that dragon. And, you know, I don't want to be negative. [00:41:17] John Carvalho: I think Bitcoin still has some nice pumps left. I just think it's exactly what you said. To 10x from 10,000 to 100,000 or 100,000 and up, it gets very, very difficult. It may require actual hyperinflation, and that's not actually a good thing. [00:41:37] Vlad Costea: I don't think that's something that we should desire. A lot of people just... I don't want to give any names, but they look at the world and they say, "I can't wait for this to burn so I get rich." [00:41:50] John Carvalho: Yeah, I think that it's hard to not to think that way sometimes, but I do try to think that way. I try to think, okay, like, if people are getting hurt, then it's a bad thing and we have to think about maybe ways to not have that be how things happen. [00:42:05] Vlad Costea: Yeah, we're such soy boys, according to the ones who post pictures of themselves pissing and stacking sats. [00:42:14] John Carvalho: I don't know, it's not soy boy to care about, like, the survival of humanity. Ultimately, that's what we're talking about here. You know, like, yes, we're all competing, but we're also all cooperating. We're trying to advance, you know, either society in the abstract and culture in the abstract, or just genetics in general and survive as a species. And that's about being adaptable. It's not about, you know, killing all the competition. [00:42:40] Vlad Costea: There's also the theory of how societies work, because if you end up being the wealthiest in your community, and everyone else is just broke off of their fiat holdings, then they're going to come for you. It's not like you are in some sort of void or some sort of imaginary citadel where you have established yourself among other Bitcoiners. Now, I can argue why that's a bad idea too, and it's some sort of utopian society that just can't scale and can't work. [00:43:12] Vlad Costea: But if you're the wealthiest and you don't provide any kind of incentives for them to come to you and respect you and protect you, they're going to come for you and just steal whatever you have. You can't just be the wealthiest in a community. And I can understand that neighborhoods get established according to the degree of wealth. So some people just live in nicer neighborhoods and they move according to their net worth and their income. [00:43:41] Vlad Costea: But, you know, if the world gets to hyperinflation and there's just a handful of us that hold a lot of Bitcoin, I don't, but maybe these people actually do and they're not lying when they post screenshots on Twitter about holding hundreds of Bitcoins. [00:43:59] Vlad Costea: If they end up being the wealthiest, then they're going to be targeted a lot, so they should start worrying about it and lower their... What's the name of that? LARPing. Yeah. Lower their LARPing activity. [00:44:16] John Carvalho: Well, I like to say that, and I'll say this a lot more in the future, that consensus is mutual. And what that means is it transcends any system. So, like, if you and I agree on something, we don't need to agree about it on the Bitcoin layer for it to be true. We just need to mutually observe to each other that we agree on it. [00:44:38] John Carvalho: And if you scale this out to any concept and any concern, you know, any issue, then that means that what can happen is exactly what you described: that the law can be that this is how things are, this is what's enforced by the people that are given permission to be violent, and then it can still be totally overturned by a majority, whether the law changes or not. Like, they can just come and they can walk into the White House and lynch the president, and, you know, the military can do it, you know, enough quantity of people can do it. Like, there is no law. There's only kind of civilization. [00:45:15] John Carvalho: And so if people want to have these kind of utopian futures of citadels or, you know, this peaceful harmony of economy, then you have to... This actually is a cultural revolution. You have to basically train humans to kind of cooperate and value meritocracy and fairness and competition, and teach them about things like evolution and how this all is just, you know, kind of an echo of... It's just an echo of, like, the law of thermodynamics, basically. Like, everything we do is about reproduction and about the competition for reproduction, and it's just all science. [00:45:55] John Carvalho: And we're all just behaving like weirdos when we kind of ignore these things. And it's perversion of reality to, like, really dive into, like, abstract concepts or, like, weird issues, you know, like these kind of moral corners of the mind. In the end, like, all that really matters is that as a human race, we progress and get more and more adaptable, so that way we can survive anything that ever happens to us. [00:46:24] Vlad Costea: For all the crap that governments get for debasing currencies and being too authoritarian, it's a wonder and it's a miracle that we don't kill each other on the streets, and that we have gotten to the level where we respect each other and we have a system of incentives. And we can agree not to do something harmful to somebody else because it has greater consequences upon us. And we can agree that we should have an honest living and try to work eight hours a day, five days a week, to preserve our status or to climb the social ladder and acquire something that we desire. [00:47:02] Vlad Costea: I mean, it's so easy naturally to think in terms of "I'm stronger than that person. I can beat them up. I can take whatever I want. Why can't I just do that?" And the fact that it doesn't happen, I think that's a miracle. And the fact that we think that we can reinvent society just based on sound money, I think that's silly. People are going to go back to some of their primal tendencies. [00:47:30] John Carvalho: Well, like, violence is always an option. That's the problem. It's like there actually is a meat space. You can't just put everything on paper. You can't put everything in the computer, because at some point somebody can just come along and knock you in the head. You have the wrench attack, whatever way you want to look at it. So, yeah, I don't know. I think that we're social creatures and that's where we've evolved to be social creatures for a reason. And I think it's so we don't just constantly kill each other, because then we'd all be dead. [00:48:02] John Carvalho: Like, we need a quantity of us to continue being able to have the situation where we can safely, like, raise a family alone, you know? Like, there are these structures we have to maintain to be able to move forward. And I think in the end that, you know, markets are efficient in the biological sense, in the environment sense, but maybe not so much in the, you know, the finance sense or the abstractions, you know, areas of what we create. [00:48:34] Vlad Costea: I think we got a bit sidetracked. [00:48:36] John Carvalho: Yeah. So, I like to talk about that stuff. And thinking that way is, like, I think what Bitcoiners are missing. That's why they don't have the culture to stop talking about finance. That's how we started talking about this. Like, they need to think about, like, what's actually going on underneath and why any of this even matters. [00:48:57] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and I suppose a lot more people should read Eric Voskuil's crypto economics book, which is free, as opposed to purchasing Saifedean's book, which costs money. [00:49:08] John Carvalho: I would agree with this. It is a chore to read his work. It is a chore to talk to him. But he's one of the people I respect the most in the space. And, you know, he's quiet and a lot of people don't even know he exists. But I like to think of, like, if I ever want to write a white paper or have some kind of theory and actually document it and write it out, I would think of him as like the main boss. Like, I need to get him to say this is interesting and relevant. [00:49:34] John Carvalho: And if I can do that, then I know, like, I have total confidence and nobody could ever shake me. I don't know that I'll ever have that kind of thing to present to him or that he'd ever, you know, bless it. But that's kind of how I look at him. Whereas, like, Saifedean, I think he was kind of in the right place at the right time. [00:49:53] John Carvalho: He was the first person to take the time to document, you know, concepts of Bitcoin maximalism and why. But he didn't really properly define it or articulate it. And he kind of went off, he riffed a bit too much on what he thinks this is related to. And so it makes it harder to digest for some people, and it makes it easier to digest for some people. And both of those kinds of people are, like, they're having a little bit too much, allowing for a little bit too much ignorance, in my opinion, to support the ideas so loosely connected. [00:50:30] Vlad Costea: I think I've heard Chris DeRose, and I know you dislike Chris, but he spoke about 50-page libertarians who only read some very basic concepts and then LARP all about it on social media. And then you have 1000-page libertarians, who actually read Mises and understand how human action works and why people behave in certain ways in terms of economics and how markets work, and they are much more nuanced in their presentation, as opposed to the people who, I suppose, just read The Bitcoin Standard and think they have it all figured out about life, society, and economics and markets. [00:51:09] Vlad Costea: They're the 50-page libertarians, and I suppose The Bitcoin Standard reads much more like a tabloid in some parts and tends to be sensationalistic and distort some facts and just present them for the sake of strengthening the argument, but not for scientific purpose, which actually analyzes events objectively. Like the argument against John Maynard Keynes is that he was a sexual libertine, and for his time that was somehow immoral and terrible. [00:51:49] John Carvalho: I mean, so first I'll say I respect Chris DeRose's mind. I don't respect his application of his learnings, of his determinations that he makes from the things he learns. But he knows a lot of things and he understands them in very interesting ways. I just think he applies them in sort of a narcissistic way that makes me feel like there's, like, I don't know, like no hope. And it's kind of a depressing way of looking at life. [00:52:14] John Carvalho: And when I think that there are other approaches that he kind of ignores and neglects that are viable, that are much more, you know, proactive and progressive. But I do find myself always circling back. Like, you know, I'll test, you know, people on Twitter in a certain way or float certain ideas, and then I'll see how they respond, and I'm just, like, so disappointed, and I'm like, "Why do people... Why are they so lazy? Why are they so quick to, you know, be defensive or not want to learn or adjust their thinking?" [00:52:46] John Carvalho: And I just, I very often come back to Chris DeRose and things he's said, and sometimes even I'm like, "Now I understand why he said that." Like, it wasn't just about [unclear: I remember that. "He died."] Yeah. Like, and it's happened to me more than once, like, where I was very judgmental of the reason that he was saying a thing. But I still maintain that even though he has said things that I've later learned were correct, the way he applied them was always, in my opinion, wrong. Like, to just really be very judgmental about people and really cutting off certain ideas of that there had any actual purpose at all. He just wants everything to be meaningless, and that's not really something I can get on board with. [00:53:23] Vlad Costea: I think somewhere down the line something went wrong with him, because he was so optimistic and he actually understood Bitcoin a lot better than most people. And he was doing the most popular podcast at the time. [00:53:36] John Carvalho: I mean, I know some of the stories. There were personal things and non-Bitcoin things that I think affected things. And so we probably shouldn't get into that. I would just say, yeah, everybody should go and watch the 2017, I believe it was, 2016 Bitcoin Uncensoreds, because that's like the most legendary Bitcoin content you can find, in my opinion. And I feel proud to have been involved with a few of the episodes and a few of the antics. I don't think we'll ever have that again, but it was definitely a fun time. [00:54:10] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, just like Bitcoin Car Talk, which was huge at the time. [00:54:14] John Carvalho: Yeah, then he turned into an asshole too. [00:54:18] Vlad Costea: And they're friends, so there must be a pattern there. But anyway, I see that Carol is here, so I'm going to try to make you say something sensational. And I'm going to ask you, why are you a better business developer than Elizabeth Stark? [00:54:36] John Carvalho: Well, I don't think she's a business developer, so that's one quick thing I'll say. Well, I mean, she's the CEO of a lab, right? And I would doubt even she herself would be the one she sends out to, you know, go and try to make business connections and these kinds of things. I think she's been very focused on trying to, like, get the team and vision together for the company. And I don't want to criticize Elizabeth Stark in her role in Lightning Labs. I think that she's done a great job. [00:55:20] John Carvalho: I think that everybody has done a bad job at business development for Lightning. And you could say, you know, if you were asked the question, "Whose job is it to be business developer for Lightning?" it would be easy to point at her or Lightning Labs, but really, you know, Ryan Gentry is in that role, and I think he's awesome, and he's trying to do that for Lightning Labs now. I don't know. I could criticize maybe, again, Blockstream for being not necessarily very good at business development for Lightning, because they obviously have put more effort into business development for Liquid. And that's maybe the better criticism about Lightning and Blockstream. It's not that they don't support Lightning and they don't support cypherpunk stuff. [00:55:57] John Carvalho: It's that on the product and business development side, the resources are being poured into Liquid and other things. And why would I be better? I think the only advantage I have in business development, and I have noticed in the past, while at Bitrefill and since leaving Bitrefill too, that I do have a little knack for aspects of business development, it's that I just don't give a shit. I will say what I think is true and what is the way, and I can model the way I think things should be, and I can very quickly retort and argue when people want to inject doubt into a conversation. [00:56:34] John Carvalho: It's just having a good abstract understanding of things and first principles of things. And so when people are ready to talk business and business development, then I have answers, I have arguments, and that helps. And I'm also... I mentioned this in the interview I did with Sergej yesterday: you have to be willing to hold people publicly accountable, because people are inclined to want to hide or make excuses sometimes or delay or ignore things. And sometimes the only way I've been able to get a business meeting with certain people is if I piss them off on Twitter. And it's really weird, and I hate that it's that way. [00:57:22] John Carvalho: But maybe it's just a lack of business connections on my own part, and this is my only option left. I don't know. But, you know, I have definitely gotten some very, very interesting business development calls just by scrutinizing people publicly. And so I think that with Lightning, if I was to call myself a good or better business development someone, it would go back to, you know, what we started the conversation with, my views on Bitcoin and not being just about number go up and money, and trying to see what all the other possible products are and other possible partnerships are that you can create, especially not just between one business but between multiple businesses, and trying to, like, find good fits. And that's kind of what I've been doing lately behind the scenes: trying to set up kind of three-way bootstrapping partnerships with the products that I'm building and other businesses. [00:58:21] Vlad Costea: Okay, so to summarize this exclusive online episode that we have done: Lightning is ready. It has most of development done. To run a node, the incentives are low right now, but it doesn't mean that you shouldn't. And the culture of Bitcoin prevents Lightning from blossoming, because if too many people HODL, they don't really exchange goods and services for Bitcoin, which is detrimental to the Bitcoin economy. And we spoke a little too much about culture, we gossiped a bit about Chris DeRose, and you criticized Blockstream like three times. And what else? [00:59:03] John Carvalho: Well, I may not word all of the things that way. I would guess it's probably a fair summary. [00:59:10] Vlad Costea: Okay, so thank you very much, John, for doing this. You're the only person to ever get on the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast twice. And I also want to get you next season, when I want to do something that's only about non-Bitcoin stuff, just to discuss hobbies and what people do outside of Bitcoin. I think that's going to be successful, hopefully. [00:59:34] John Carvalho: Anytime. You're the only pseudo-philosophical person that I've ever enjoyed talking to. I typically hate talking to philosopher types, because they always want to talk about bullshit. And I always enjoy our conversations. So anytime, I'll be happy to. [00:59:50] Vlad Costea: I enjoy being a pseudo-philosopher, so yeah. All right, so I'm going to hand this off to Carol. Carol, thanks again. ================================================================================ Production notes: A remote video livestream recorded in the morning (Vlad in Romania) and hosted by a third party, 'Carol' (also greeted at the start as 'Rolo'), who is handed back the stream at the end; the conversation is in English with no music intro and no sponsor reads. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 4 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (79 chunks) and 36 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 1 of 1 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Replaced guest label with John Carvalho; fixed greeting "Buona giornata" and re-split turns at 00:00:16-00:00:39 and 00:13:16; removed hallucination "This is a production of the U.S. Department of State" and "Thank you" merge artifact; restored dropped speech (00:02:17, 00:03:00-00:03:35, 00:05:25, 00:06:04 nodes list, 00:07:28-00:08:01 Twitter, 00:11:46 LNbig, 00:13:49 liquidity, 00:14:50); fixed Lightning node, BlueWallet, ACINQ, Wumbo, LNbig, c-lightning, Liquid, FOMOing, "blocks to fill", "accrue", "routing get"; removed doubled-word echoes; Guest label replaced with John Carvalho; restored dropped text (focus on advanced routing, trade-offs for privacy, Liquid, consumer/Web3 passage, "how is there supposed to be a framework", "information they think they have", "mania", "that's actually not"); fixed Sergej, Cash App, sats, shitcoins, altcoins, Lightning capitalisation; removed stray "Thank you."; corrected "just use it", "my best to hype it"; Guest label replaced with John Carvalho; removed hallucinations ("This is a podcast about the future of Bitcoin", "video made by a friend" line restored to "But I'm not the one working in the gaming field", "Robert Leonard" x2); restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (Ethereum mining passage, LN Markets UX passage, Stakwork micro jobs, "catch that dragon"); fixed LN Markets, Multicoin Capital, Lightnite, Micree Zhan, Jihan, BitMEX, Stakwork, Carlos Roldan, Lightning monetization; re-split turns at 00:32:11, 00:34:56, 00:35:05, 00:35:29-41, 00:40:19; Guest label replaced with John Carvalho; removed hallucinated "This is a podcast about the world of Bitcoin..." and "I'm going to ask you a question"; restored dropped speech (lynch the president, 00:45:20-00:46:23 passage, 00:52:14-00:53:23 passage, partnerships ending) from second ASR/re-check; fixed sats, LARPing, Voskuil, Saifedean, Chris DeRose, Blockstream, Bitrefill, HODL, Sergej, cypherpunk; "he turned"/"they're friends" per re-check; final "All right... Carol" reassigned to Vlad; split long monologues.