Title: S8 E6: Lazy Ninja on Hacking Hardware Wallets Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Lazy Ninja (@FreedomIsntSafe), hardware wallet security researcher known for disclosing vulnerabilities in the BitBox02 and Coldcard Mk3 Published: 2021-04-18 Duration: 2:21:18 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2021-04-18_btctkvr_s8_e6_lazy_ninja.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2021-04-18_btctkvr_s8_e6_lazy_ninja.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:29] Vlad Costea: This episode is sponsored by Vaultoro. Keep on listening and you will find out more about how you can buy allocated gold when the Bitcoin bull run reaches its peak. This way you don't have to deal with infinitely inflationary fiat or banks that freeze your account. Also, note that trading involves risks and the information presented is not financial advice. This episode is also sponsored by Wasabi Wallet. Go to wasabiwallet.io, download Wasabi for your OS, and significantly boost your network level and transaction privacy. [00:01:40] Vlad Costea: Hello there and welcome to Season 8, Episode 6 of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is Lazy Ninja, also known as @FreedomIsntSafe on Twitter. And he's best known in the space for hacking hardware wallets such as the BitBox02 and more recently the Coldcard Mk3. And I don't know, you either like him or you hate him. But you cannot, you know, honestly and objectively hate him because he makes everyone's security a lot better and he discloses all of the findings that he makes to the manufacturers. So he's not like he's trying to steal your coins, not that I'm aware of. But it's not like I would trust him with my hardware wallets, to hand them to him for a day or something. So hi, Mr. Ninja. [00:02:32] Lazy Ninja: Hey Vlad, how's it going? I'm a little hurt you think people hate me. I thought everybody loved me out there. [00:02:39] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I don't know. Depends on who you ask. [00:02:42] Lazy Ninja: I think JW might hate me now. [00:02:46] Vlad Costea: He does, but he hates kind of everyone who's into hardware wallets except for the Blockstream people, because he thinks that the Jade is okay. [00:02:54] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, we can talk about that. [00:02:58] Vlad Costea: Yeah, we should, because there's a lot that has changed since we last spoke, and that was in December 2019. The landscape has changed. We have many more devices. We have a new project, which is trying to develop a truly open source secure chip. And that's Tropic Square. That's owned by SatoshiLabs, which also does the Trezor project. And you have also made further disclosures. I don't even know where to begin. So you get to choose the first topic. [00:03:28] Lazy Ninja: Oh, man, putting it right on me. Yeah, so let me talk about the Tropic Square with the Trezor guys. I actually think that's a really, I'm really excited about that project. It's just I'm a little hesitant if they can actually pull it off. I mean, it's a really huge undertaking to develop a piece of silicon like that as a relatively small company. Especially, you know, a security oriented piece. So I'm really excited to see where they go here. Have you seen any sort of estimated like prototype dates yet? I haven't paid close enough attention to see how far they are along. [00:04:09] Vlad Costea: Yeah, they said December 2022, so next year or 2023 early on. They are expected to release the first version of the chip with a new Trezor. That's the plan. [00:04:23] Lazy Ninja: Okay, that'll be cool. So I'm going to throw out one of my recommendations if they're listening, or you can forward it. So I like this really simple feature on hardware wallets, well, just on any sort of microcontroller, because one of the big things that people get concerned about is supply chain type of attacks on your hardware wallet. And even the amount of trust you have to have in a vendor when you receive the hardware wallet, because they may have code that's open source. And this isn't Trezor or anything. [00:04:54] Lazy Ninja: This is just everybody in the industry. You get a piece of hardware, and there's an open source Git repo that says, "Hey, here's our project. Here's how it works. We have deterministic builds. You can build, you can do all this stuff." But when you get that device, you don't actually know what code's on there. The devices are typically locked in such a way you have no idea what's on there. They can tell you they're using this open source repository, but the manufacturer could have put something else on there, or some intermediate in the supply chain could have loaded on potentially some different image, and you just don't know. [00:05:33] Lazy Ninja: So one cool feature would be, and I know some higher end devices do have this, but I would love a chip-level native way to get a hash of the image on the chip. Now, there's a couple tricks there, like there's going to be some random data that has to be excluded and things like that. There's some sort of seeds or something like that for random number generators, but I think it'd be really cool to have a way to use a chip-level API to get a hash of the image that's on there. [00:06:09] Lazy Ninja: So it just gives you sort of another way to mitigate any type of sort of screwing around by a manufacturer or some sort of supply chain attack. Now, verifying something like that in hardware, probably not every user is capable of that, but typically a simple JTAG programmer for one of these chips is actually not very expensive and really easy to hook up, so a lot more people would be able to verify things like that. And it could just prevent some sort of attack from becoming widespread in an ecosystem. [00:06:45] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I have seen something very similar with the BitBox02, which has the anti-klepto verification system. And also, I was very impressed by the first steps that you take with the Cobo Vault. I'm not sure if you got your hands on that one, but it has, I think, the best packaging I've ever seen of any hardware wallet, with lots of tamper-proof layers and stickers and carton boxes that can be opened in a very specific way, so that once you open them you cannot put them back together. I very much like that, and I like the fact that you register your device in a way that makes sure that it was not registered before by scanning a QR with the serial number. [00:07:32] Vlad Costea: I don't like that it's centralized. So basically you're telling Cobo that you have registered the device, but at the same time it gives you the guarantee that nobody has ever activated it before. So you're the first owner of that specific piece of hardware. And if it was possible to do it in a very trustless and decentralized way, I would very much like that. [00:07:55] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I did get my hands on a Cobo Vault. They sent me one. I did do some, I don't know if you saw it, I did do some review of it last year. And I did catch a couple bugs. Not super high priority bugs, but a couple interesting ones on the Cobo Vault. But I actually did really like that they had the programmatic method to sort of verify the device's authenticity. So this, again, goes to sort of that anti-supply chain attack thing. [00:08:25] Lazy Ninja: Which is, hey, you get a device, how do you know this really came off of the Cobo Vault manufacturing line and somebody didn't just throw a clone of it in a box that's going to steal your coins? Well, you can do a... I actually didn't look at the exact mechanism they use, but I'm sure they use some sort of, you know, private key in the secure element and then a signature on that, and their back end just verifies that that's actually a device that came off of their manufacturing line. [00:08:55] Lazy Ninja: And I think that's a really nice feature to have on the device. And in general, I thought the Cobo Vault was, you know, a well-done professional wallet. You know, I'm sort of a sucker for user interface. I think good user interfaces help encourage people to use best security practices. Because as the interface deteriorates, you tend to use shorter PINs, shorter passphrases, because it's more painful. And so I do really like the higher end user interface on the device. [00:09:30] Vlad Costea: Oh, you have mentioned something very delicate there, the passphrase. As most people I have interviewed during this season were pretty much against the idea of a passphrase because they said people are so terrible with remembering passwords. And for example, I think Charles Guillemet of Ledger told me that they get lots of emails with people asking if they can get their passphrases. [00:09:54] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, you're probably, yeah, there's probably... It's a tough thing for most people to get used to, the significance of a passphrase. And when you have a truly self-sovereign currency, you know, there's nobody to remember your passphrase for you. There's no necessary backups. But I really do think passphrase is an important security layer in hardware wallets and just the usage of your Bitcoin in general. I know. [00:10:28] Vlad Costea: Oh, I agree with that. And there are so many ways to store it. You can write it down, you can put it on a piece of metal, and there are so many alternatives for that. [00:10:38] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, there are. I try to think where I want to go with this, because Trezor sort of went the route in not immediately rushing in a secure element chip, and just proposing to just only rely on the passphrase to provide physical security, shall we say. Basically, the passphrase isn't stored on the device, so if somebody steals your device, the only way to access your funds is to break your passphrase. [00:11:09] Lazy Ninja: And I guess in general, I mean, there is a user issue there where I don't know if it's user-friendly for everybody to rely on a passphrase, but I sort of view it as something you need to learn, because I do think passphrases are very important. They sort of give you the ability to have a single-sig device that's effectively a multisig device. You know, you can make your passphrase as strong or as weak as you want. [00:11:42] Lazy Ninja: You can use it just sort of to have wallet derivatives, so you have your spending wallet and you can just have the passphrase for that be "spend" and your cold wallet can just be "cold" or whatever. [00:11:59] Lazy Ninja: But I think it's much better to have a strong passphrase and then also store that separate, so you effectively have a two-of-two multisig on your seed or with your hardware wallet. [00:12:16] Vlad Costea: I'm very much a fan of passphrases. I mean, what a lot of people don't understand is that the 24 words that you get as part of your seed phrase are part of a BIP39 dictionary, which consists of, I think, 4096 words, if I'm not mistaken, or 2048, one of these two. Anyway, you can put the passphrase to be any word or combination of words and letters that you want. So it doesn't have to be one of those. It's not recommended to be one of those. So you can put like a regular password on your device and it's encrypted, it protects it. [00:12:54] Vlad Costea: Nobody who gets physical access to it can actually steal your coins unless they figure out your passphrase, and that's going to be very difficult if you make it long and you put extra special characters and stuff. [00:13:09] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, totally agree. I think having a strong passphrase is important for all Bitcoiners for sure. [00:13:18] Vlad Costea: Okay, so let's get to this discussion that I have been wanting to have in regards to this secure chip that you find in the BitBox02, in the Coldcard, in the Foundation Devices Passport. It's the ATECC608A or 608B. You have dealt with it when you hacked the Coldcard. I think they changed the version of the chip because of you, or because of a security disclosure that you have made. And how safe is it? What do you think about it? Is it really open source? What is open source about it? [00:13:55] Vlad Costea: Or what is general purpose? Because I suppose that's what it actually is, as opposed to open source. It's more like easy to source, easy to purchase by yourself and build your own device. [00:14:07] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, so a lot of things, well, a few things have changed about the chip. So originally the datasheet used to be public, and so that was sort of a big thing. Everybody liked the datasheet was just public, so it was very easy for anybody to look at it. The company has since made the datasheet NDA. But there are other versions of the chip where basically 90% of the datasheet is still public. So there's sort of this weird thing going on there where you can still get the datasheet in a very slightly redacted way. [00:14:41] Lazy Ninja: You can get most of it. So that's really good. You know, it's really good to just be able to have more eyes, you know, more people be able to sort of review what the chip is doing. But the manufacturer has an open source library that can talk to the chip. So anybody can go get the manufacturer's open source library and communicate with the chip and use the chip and do things with it. And you can just go on to your standard electronics website and, you know, a popular case is Digi-Key. [00:15:14] Lazy Ninja: And anybody without any special permission can just order these chips and stick them in a socket and use the manufacturer's library and just communicate with them. So they're sort of in this middle ground where there's some NDA stuff, some restricted stuff, but anybody can go get one of these chips and play with it and mess around with it with an open source library. [00:15:38] Vlad Costea: Okay, so how would you describe the difference between the chip? It's kind of the same. It has the same serial number, but it's still different. The one that you find in BitBox02 and Coldcard. And why did Coldcard change it, by the way? [00:15:53] Lazy Ninja: Okay, so let's go a little bit deeper on what the chip does too. This specific chip is a little different. In the Ledger device, Ledger has a secure microcontroller as their secure element. So it's a device that they write code on. So they put code on there, they do stuff. It looks just like any microcontroller. Well, not just like, there's subtle differences, but it looks like a microcontroller that you use to do other things, but it has additional security features to help protect memory against attacks, and different crypto hardware accelerators and things like that, but in general it looks like a microcontroller. [00:16:37] Lazy Ninja: The chip used in the Coldcard and the BitBox is a fixed function device. So the Coldcard and the BitBox guys can't put any code that executes onto the secure element they're using. It is just a storage mechanism with crypto engines for doing computations on keys and other cryptographic material it's storing. So it's not running any code, it's not doing anything you can't see. Well, you pass it a command. You say, "Hey, crypto chip, take one of the secrets that you store and hash it with this value and then give me the result." [00:17:20] Lazy Ninja: So the actual hashing it does is out of your sight, you can't see what's happening. But you can see what the Coldcard passed to the chip and you can see what the chip returned and it's all sort of exposed. So again, that's sort of an intermediate where you can't see that it's implementing the hash algorithm correctly. But you can see the inputs and the results. And it gives you a lot of... One of the interesting things is it prevents the user of the chip from messing up in a way that you can't see. So in the case of the Ledger secure element, they could have code on that chip that breaks something and causes a security vulnerability. And in the case of the 608 used on the Coldcard and the BitBox, they could use the chip in an insecure way. But it's public for everybody to see that they're using it in an insecure way. [00:18:28] Lazy Ninja: Does that make sense? [00:18:29] Vlad Costea: It does. It does. But I was actually curious to know about the variation of the 608 chip, because there is A, there's B. You mentioned that some of them are relying on NDAs and some of them still have publicly available libraries. [00:18:46] Lazy Ninja: Yep, so the company has a different version of the chip called a TrustFLEX, so it's a 608 TrustFLEX. And if you search online for that version of the chip, there is a full data sheet available that is slightly redacted from the absolute full one, but it has almost everything most people would need. There's that, and then going from the A to the B. So when Ledger had their original disclosure on the laser fault vulnerability on the 508 chip that the Coldcard Mk2 and Mk1 were originally using, they indicated, or it was indicated, that the 608 may also be vulnerable. And at that same time, the manufacturer didn't just release a 508A or a 508B. They released a 608B and made the 608A and 508A not recommended for new designs. So it sort of indicated to me and others that the 608 is vulnerable to the same or similar attack that the 508 was. [00:20:10] Vlad Costea: Okay, so what was the change that occurred after you have made the latest disclosure to the Coldcard? [00:20:19] Lazy Ninja: So the change on the 608 or the change on the Coldcard? [00:20:25] Vlad Costea: I guess both, you can mention them. [00:20:27] Lazy Ninja: So I'm not specifically aware of exactly what changed in the chip in the 608A to the 608B, but I know that they changed something to minimize a vulnerability to attack. And then in the Coldcard, so if we can just back, I'll back up and say what I found. So I started talking about how the way the chip is used is public. And so what I ultimately found with the Coldcard was when they were... the Coldcard had added actually a really nice feature to prevent the... [00:21:11] Lazy Ninja: They wanted to make it if, like, let's say the secure element was completely backdoored, and an attacker could know every value in the secure element. In the Mk2 version of the Coldcard, this would allow an attacker to directly steal your seed and spend your money if he could recover a passphrase. In the Mk3, they added an additional feature to encrypt the secret with an encryption key that only the MCU knows. So if the secure element fails, you still can rely on the MCU to protect your seed. [00:21:56] Lazy Ninja: However, when the Ledger vulnerability was announced, I'm like, oh, wow, this, because I really wasn't expecting the secure element to ever have a publicly disclosed vulnerability. And so when that was announced, it made me sort of suspicious that hey, maybe I should really look at how Coldcard did this, because it's possible there could be something with the 608 and this could be a real attack. And so I started looking carefully at how the Coldcard was doing all their communication with the secure element. And I discovered that they were correctly protecting the seed phrase with that encryption key in the MCU. [00:22:38] Lazy Ninja: But they forgot to protect the PIN login to the device in the same way. And so basically, rather than just stealing the seed like you could on the Mk2, on the Mk3, I could steal the PIN login. And then, which allowed me to actually replace it with my own login, and then be able to log into the device by exploiting that vulnerability that a lab discovered on the 608. [00:23:14] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I saw that video which you posted on Twitter like last month or something. [00:23:19] Lazy Ninja: Yeah. [00:23:19] Vlad Costea: And this was prior to the disclosure that you have made to Coldcard. So you're honest about the vulnerability, you helped them improve on the situation. But it was still interesting to see that stop motion animation kind of video where you remove the chip, you put it back together, and it was like a story that you were telling about how you can replace the PIN number with one of your own by doing some minimal electronic modding to the device. [00:23:51] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, so there's a significant... So I basically outsourced... I found a lab that had an attack on the 608 that I believe was the same attack that was used on the 508. And I sent the chip to the lab, and the lab returned me the chip and some of the values and some of the slots on the chip. So that's sort of the hard work. So I didn't actually do some of the hard work on this attack. [00:24:23] Lazy Ninja: But once I had that information, because of the vulnerability in how they were using the PIN slot on the device, it allowed me to take that information and then put my own PIN right onto the secure element without the the microcontroller having any knowledge of it. And so now I can just set the PIN to whatever I want, and then I can just log into the device normally. And now if there's a passphrase, that still protects the funds on the device, but it does give me access to the seed of the device. [00:25:02] Vlad Costea: Vaultoro, and that's V-A-U-L-T like a gold vault and O-R-O, oro, which is Spanish for gold, is a gold and Bitcoin exchange, which offers instant swaps between hard money to over 31,000 customers from more than 95 countries. Vaultoro has offered Swiss privacy and security since 2015. Furthermore, the gold you purchase is your legal property, secured in your name, so even if something happens to Vaultoro, even liquidators could not touch your gold. If you want to become the custodian of your own gold bars, you can request to have them delivered to you, or simply trade them back to Bitcoin on the dip. [00:25:53] Vlad Costea: Register for free in only 30 seconds and start trading only with hard money. Please keep in mind that all trading involves risks. This is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions. When you are using Wasabi Wallet, your internet connection gets routed through the Tor network by default. This means that you get better privacy while using Bitcoin. Download it today at wasabiwallet.io. Yeah, when we discussed about setting up this interview, you made a list of thoughts or topics that you want to discuss. And one of them was, and I quote right now, "my new hardware wallet bug." What's that? [00:26:47] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, well, that was the Coldcard one. So the Coldcard PIN replacement attack. [00:26:54] Vlad Costea: Okay, I was expecting something different, but I'm not disappointed because this is still major. [00:26:59] Lazy Ninja: Yeah. I wish I had another one. I'm still a little too lazy to come up with vulnerabilities that fast, but I'll keep working on it here for you. [00:27:08] Vlad Costea: I mean, it's part of your name, you're the Lazy Ninja. [00:27:12] Lazy Ninja: I try to live up to it. [00:27:14] Vlad Costea: Exactly. You never disappoint. [00:27:17] Lazy Ninja: Good. [00:27:19] Vlad Costea: Okay, so then let's get to the topic which is of most interest for HWWeatherman: air-gapped PC vs. hardware wallet. [00:27:29] Lazy Ninja: Oh yeah, yeah, this topic has frustrated me in a similar way that the Wasabi-Samourai topic has frustrated many others, including me. [00:27:43] Vlad Costea: Oh, just so you know, this show is sponsored by Wasabi. [00:27:48] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, so the Wasabi-Samourai debate was very frustrating because I always feel I'm not getting enough information to really understand the details. And I have to embarrassingly admit, you know, I don't know everything, right? I haven't really dug deep into the CoinJoin mechanisms to understand all the details, so I rely on podcasts and people talking about it and just, you know, just sort of the companies' docs online to try to figure it out. And there was just never good information on it. And so I do primarily use Wasabi. [00:28:28] Lazy Ninja: But at the same time, I do sort of see some of what the Samourai guys are trying to do, but it just feels like a frustrating debate where it's not really the trade-offs, it becomes more personal and angry and it's sort of annoying. And I saw sort of the same thing happening with air-gapped PC vs. hardware wallet. And I wanted to try to add my understanding of things to it to let people be able to make decisions based on information rather than just based on people's reputations or their emotion at the time. So that's one of the things I wanted to try to do. [00:29:15] Lazy Ninja: Now, if I can actually do this in a way that helps people, I don't know, but let me try to talk about it. So there's this view that... Well, how do I start? What is an air-gapped PC? What does that mean? Well, generally to most people, it means it's a PC that you disconnect from the internet. Okay, well, that's great. But, you know, how did you get all that software onto your PC that's running? [00:29:50] Lazy Ninja: Well, I downloaded that from the internet. Oh, okay, well, how do you know if you trust this giant operating system and all the hundreds or thousands of programs or separate projects included within that operating system? I don't know, right? But I'm not going to connect it to the internet, so it's safe. Well, it's not, because when you did that initial download, so let's say, you know, everybody's favorite's Ubuntu, you know, that's sort of the reference thing for when you're doing an air-gapped PC or something like that. [00:30:28] Lazy Ninja: If you go to their website and you download an image off their website, you're establishing trust in whoever's maintaining that image and all the different packages of software that they include in that image. Any one of those packages of software could have something malicious. So immediately, as soon as you do that, you've now trusted hundreds, maybe thousands of different people and repositories of code to not be malicious, including the fact that where you download it from could actually serve you up a malicious version just occasionally. Like, occasionally it just gives you a malicious version of Ubuntu. [00:31:06] Lazy Ninja: Where in the hardware wallet world, sure, we talked about this earlier. When you get a hardware wallet shipped to you, there's supply chain risks. Somebody could have replaced it. Somebody could have done something to it. But because the hardware wallet is so much simpler, there is actually hope that a user could detect a change or something not being right. And like I talked about earlier, there are some mechanisms that you can add hardware functions to these chips that allow users to verify more directly what's on the chip. [00:31:38] Lazy Ninja: And bypass trusting the manufacturer. You have all these same problems when you create a PC that's going to run Bitcoin and sign transactions, and the problems are even 10x because you're running such much more complicated software on much more complicated hardware. So if you're starting with an untrusted image on your air gap PC, people often think, "Well, it's okay, you know, even if the code on my PC is malicious in some way, I'm going to disconnect it from the internet, and so now the malicious person can't get my seed off the PC," right? [00:32:21] Lazy Ninja: So maybe they totally got something on there, but now they can't get my seed off. Well, you know, they can corrupt the random number generator on your device and do things like that that allow them to then remotely steal your funds. Let's say that you have some check on that PC, sort of like the Coldcard does, where it shows you progressive hashes of how it calculated the entropy it's using for the seed. Let's say you have that same thing on your air gap PC so you can verify that... [00:32:55] Lazy Ninja: You're actually using a random seed. Well, maybe they're just generating bad receive addresses. Okay, well, let's ignore all that. Let's say you can verify your receive addresses and everything. You know, all the addresses are good. Well, there's really advanced attacks, and actually, I love this attack. This is from... I don't know if he was the original creator of it or if he saw it, but Stepan at Specter Desktop. He posted an article, I think it was in December 2019 or something like that, where he described what I found to be just an absolutely terrifying attack because it can cross any air gap. [00:33:40] Lazy Ninja: It can export information from any device over any type of air gap when considering Bitcoin devices, at least at this time. And so he described a method. So in Bitcoin, when you sign a transaction, you know, we look at that as the signature is sort of a random process where some random data is generated, and that allows you to then verify the transaction was hashed properly and all the correct data went into it later. But what people don't often think about is... Well, I mean, I gave it away there. [00:34:20] Lazy Ninja: The signatures currently aren't deterministic. They do have some random numbers included in the signature. So every time you sign the same piece of data, you get a different signature. So if you take the same Bitcoin transaction and you sign it repeatedly, every time you sign it, at least with current implementations, you're going to get a different signature. And what an attacker can do in that case is they can just keep signing a transaction over and over again until one of the bytes of that signature matches, say, your seed. [00:35:01] Lazy Ninja: So, say we're going to always make byte zero of the signature match a specific byte of your seed. So we'll just randomly keep signing and signing the data over and over again until we get byte zero to be 05. And then you send that transaction out. Then the next time you sign something, the attacker is going to keep signing over and over and over again until byte zero of your signature is the next byte in the seed, say byte, you know, 11, something along those lines. And it gives him the ability to export not only your seed, but your passphrase and any information he would like off of the device. [00:35:45] Lazy Ninja: Now, the attack we're describing here is slow and requires signing lots of transactions. But this attack can be carried out over a long period of time and ultimately pull out any information you want. And this attack is much easier to do on a PC, but you can also do this attack on a hardware wallet. And it's just sort of a terrifying attack, where if you're running untrusted code on any device, they have the ability to do all sorts of terrible things. [00:36:19] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, that's one of the reasons why I read somewhere that it's a good idea to keep your hardware wallet, even if it's air-gapped, inside of a Faraday cage or Faraday bag. And I know that's like extra layer paranoid, but I have read about attacks that can be done to radio waves and all sorts of, you know, Bluetooth connections and everything that can be exploited in a device to just extract information. [00:36:48] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, for sure. And all these attacks, it's sort of interesting because all these same attacks are possible on both hardware wallets and on air gap PCs. And what you find, if you think about this more, is an air gap PC is no different than a hardware wallet. There's just differences in complexity. An air gap PC certain people like because you get to buy that and people don't know you're using it for Bitcoin. And that's probably the only benefit, in my opinion, is you can go get an air gap or just a regular laptop. [00:37:27] Lazy Ninja: And nobody knows you're going to use that for doing Bitcoin stuff. Whereas if you go buy a hardware wallet, now your name and mailing address end up in some database, as we saw previously, and those databases can be hacked and breached, and all of a sudden somebody knows you have Bitcoin. And typically, if you're buying a hardware wallet, you have a significant amount of Bitcoin that could be worth pursuing. So there is 100% a danger there in leaking that personal information. But you have to weigh... [00:37:58] Lazy Ninja: All the risks that you have when you do this stuff. So you can't just focus on this one risk of, "Hey, somebody's going to know I own Bitcoin. We have to do everything I can to stop, to not order a hardware wallet because I don't want anybody to find out I own Bitcoin." There are a thousand other things you do in a day that could leak to people that you own Bitcoin. You know, buying a hardware wallet is not the only thing. And you probably made a mistake... [00:38:29] Lazy Ninja: On one of those other things. So to hyperfocus on just this one thing is sort of not being mentally honest with yourself. And it isn't... I mean, like I said, you getting an air gap PC to prevent that is a reasonable thing to do, but there are other risks, because that PC comes with a level of complexity that is impossible for you to verify that what you're running on there is authentic and doing what you expect. And so you have this trade-off on the other side that causes, you know, I believe, a lot more risk than the risk of somebody knowing you own Bitcoin because you bought a hardware wallet. [00:39:15] Vlad Costea: Right, and I recall that Luke Dashjr recommends some sort of computer that's ridiculously expensive, like five thousand dollars or something for the least expensive model. And it's based on an open source architecture. It's called RISC-V or something like that. [00:39:36] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, it's RISC-V. [00:39:38] Vlad Costea: Oh, so you actually call it a "risk"? [00:39:42] Lazy Ninja: I believe that's what you're referring to, yep. It's an open source core. It's gaining some traction, for sure. [00:39:52] Vlad Costea: Okay, but is that less vulnerable if you're making that kind of investment in a very expensive and open source computer? [00:40:03] Lazy Ninja: I don't think so. I think with... When you have a complex... Well, I'd have to see exactly what he's referring to, but if we're talking about some sort of PC level device, that device comes with lots of complexity. And that complexity prevents you from verifying things to a high degree. Now, with a hardware wallet, you can't verify everything, but you can verify things to a higher degree than you can with a PC of any type. [00:40:42] Vlad Costea: Mm-hmm. It's interesting. I suppose it's not very much different from... Actually, it's very much different from an open source point of view, but it's not very much different from the Apple M1, which is their new series of processors, which are also ARM-based and may have lots of applications that are incompatible. So I suppose if there are fewer applications that are compatible, you also have fewer attacks from the previous generation of processors, like the x86 platform. [00:41:18] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I think I really sort of hate that view. It's sort of security by obscurity thinking, where, hey, there's just not much stuff for this platform, so I'm decreasing my attack window. But you're also decreasing the number of people that have the ability to review, study, and look at, and the number of people that want to review, study, and look at, just because you're using a platform that isn't widely used. I'm still a big believer in using widely used, highly reviewed platforms, just generally. [00:41:53] Vlad Costea: I suppose that's why you like the Trezor, and it's the one that you recommend the most, according to the previous interview that we have made. [00:42:01] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, the Trezor is a great device. They work hard to keep it secure, and they ship a whole lot of devices. So I generally stick with mainstream hardware wallets. I'm not 100% bound to a Trezor, but I do like that they're a major wallet. They make a significant amount of money. You know, some people downplay money. We could probably get into the open source, closed source thing too. But money is very important for companies producing hardware and software. It gives them the incentive to keep their products secure and well-running, and it also gives them the resources to do that. [00:42:42] Lazy Ninja: You know, sometimes if you're not making any money on something... That was actually one of my criticisms of the Specter device at the time, or the Specter DIY, is like, well, how are you going to make money on this when you're selling a development kit? Because money is what pays for things to be fixed and what gives people a big incentive to fix these things. [00:43:13] Vlad Costea: Right. I also remember that one. It did not really catch on. Like, it's still very obscure, but Specter has one of the most popular multisig solutions. And I suppose this is the debate that we should be having right now. Is it worth it for the average user to do a multisig? And at the same time, I also include in this debate the Shamir backup that you can do with Shamir Secret Sharing. That's also an alternative for you to have some of the benefits of the multisig. [00:43:47] Vlad Costea: But only for yourself, so you don't need different signatures, and it's also more private, because you don't know which parts were used for the signature, as opposed to the multisig, where you can see on the public blockchain. [00:44:01] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I'm generally an anti-multisig guy. I'm really sort of an outlier there. So that'll get some people to hate me, because I'm not a fan of multisig. I just think most people think they're getting more out of a multisig in Bitcoin than they actually are. So people talk about sort of, you know, geographic distribution of key material in relation to multisig. And you can have a single-sig that has that, because you can take a 24-word seed and divide it into 12 and 12. [00:44:40] Lazy Ninja: Now, you can't do that again. So you can't divide a 12-word seed. But you can take a 24-word and divide it into 12 and 12. Or you can take your 24-word and your passphrase and divide them, and you can store them in separate locations. So you effectively have a geographically distributed storage. And let's say you want to accommodate... Let's say, well, what if I lose a key? Well, you can get through that, you can get around that with redundancy and backups. [00:45:10] Lazy Ninja: So let's say you have a 24-word seed and your passphrase. You store them in separate locations. You're like, well, what if this location becomes compromised and I lose access to it because, for some reason, or a fire burns my house down, and I had it on paper, so now it's burned up? Well, you can have a backup. So let's say you store your passphrase in your house on paper. Well, maybe you can have another version of your passphrase stamped on metal and buried in your parents' backyard... [00:45:45] Lazy Ninja: Or whatever it is. So if your house burns down, you now can go to your parents' backyard to recover your passphrase. These aren't specific things like, "Hey, do it this way," or I'm just sort of giving concepts here that people can think about. So I don't... People often propose multisig for situations like that, but I think single-sig and just sort of redundancy in your backup and dividing your passphrase from your seed can give you about 90% of what you get through a multisig, and without the extra complexity. So with multisig, there... [00:46:29] Lazy Ninja: So you do get one thing out of a true multisig that you don't get out of my single-sig with divided material. And that is you get true immunity to an exploit on your single device. So this sort of goes back to our air-gapped PC and trusting that or not. Is if you... Let's see, how do I phrase this? [00:46:57] Lazy Ninja: If you can't 100% trust your device, right? You never know if that random number generator can truly be tested. But you do a true multisig where you use multiple devices. You have a two-device multisig where maybe you use a PC for one part of it and you use a Coldcard for another. And an attacker would basically have to exploit both to be able to steal your funds. That is a significant benefit of a multi-device multisig. But like I said, there's a trade-off with complexity. [00:47:34] Lazy Ninja: Like, multisig is sort of new. It's not... Well, it's not new. I mean, it's been around forever, but widespread usage of it is sort of new. If you're going to do a multisig, there's more material to back up. You have to back up both public keys, and technically, the actual script that those public keys are in. And there's not standard ways to back that up. You know, you can sure put it on a piece of electronics, but I really am partial to just having things on metal. [00:48:05] Lazy Ninja: You know, and having things almost like a pirate treasure. You know, if somebody finds these pieces of metal of mine in 100 years, they're going to be able to claim the funds on it. As soon as you start talking about putting redeem scripts on USB drives and things like that, I just get a little uneasy. And I just don't have a lot of confidence that you can effectively have enough redundancy and safety in something like that over a long period of time. Yeah, I am really, I think single-sig... [00:48:40] Lazy Ninja: Oh, one other thing here too. Another thing, so the multi-device multisig, you can get some guarantees with single-sig by using multiple devices to just sort of validate your addresses. So maybe I use my Trezor to set it up, and I just check the addresses that the Trezor is telling me are available and I check a few things with it. And then I use my Coldcard to set up my wallet and I just verify a few things, that all the addresses are coming up like they're supposed to be. [00:49:14] Lazy Ninja: Now, a sophisticated attack can potentially work around those things. But you get a little bit of multi-device protections, making the attacker have to be a little bit more sophisticated in whatever hack he put on those devices. But yeah, for me, I don't think multisig is easy enough, because of both the backup and also because just support on multiple different hardware wallets is just not as straightforward and easy to do for people. So, in general, I don't recommend multi-device multisig for most people. But it truly does mitigate firmware bugs and malicious code on a single device, though. [00:50:04] Ad voiceover: Hey, psst, hey, what's your plan for the next Bitcoin top? [00:50:13] Vlad Costea: Unless you need the money to purchase something, you probably should not touch infinitely inflationary fiat. Check out Vaultoro and figure out to which extent hard money like gold and silver can help you preserve your purchasing power. You will be able to get back into Bitcoin as soon as the price hits a new bottom, and you will not be subjected to the arbitrary, inflation-driven volatility of fiat or fiat-backed coins. Obviously, this is not financial advice, and you should understand that all trading involves risks. Wasabi Wallet connects to your full Bitcoin node, and if you're not running one, it downloads block filters anonymously via Tor. [00:51:04] Vlad Costea: In either case, you're getting excellent privacy. Download the software today at wasabiwallet.io. Yeah, when I talk to manufacturers or representatives of hardware wallet companies, they usually tell me that multisigs are very good and they might just be the silver bullet for security, but the only issue is that there are no proper standards, and they also expect Schnorr signatures to make them more private on the public blockchain. But other than this, they just tell you that it's really great. And part of me thinks that this is, you know, it's their best interest to recommend multisig as the default setup, which gets recommended by, for example, Specter, is that you use multiple brands of hardware wallets. [00:51:57] Vlad Costea: So you're going to have a reason to buy a Ledger, to buy a Trezor, to buy a Coldcard, so you set up your two-out-of-three multisig setup. So this is kind of in the best interest of all hardware wallet manufacturers to recommend that you do multisigs. Why I don't think I like it too much is that you pay high fees on the blockchain when you make a spend, when you send a transaction. So, I don't know, I just think it's not scalable, and I've seen people do ridiculous amounts of signatures out of... [00:52:34] Vlad Costea: The total, so like 15 out of 17, that's not going to be very inexpensive to move on the base layer. Which, by the way, I just checked right now. So today is the 16th of April. The fees are about 200... I call them bit cents. I don't call them sats because I'm running my own agenda. You said you would not participate in it. You don't have to. But it's still, you know, it's kind of worrying to know that you pay about $17 for the next block. It's still not as bad as it was in 2017, but we should migrate to the Lightning Network and sidechains at this point. [00:53:16] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I originally, when it was proposed, was a bits guy, but I have succumbed to everybody else's opinion, it's sats, and I'm not willing to sacrifice my social capital to push bits. [00:53:32] Vlad Costea: You have been around for long enough to know that bits used to be the standard. I'm trying to bring it back. [00:53:41] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I know. I don't think you're going to make fetch happen, as they say. But I did want to jump back to one thing too, Vlad, on the air-gapped and multisig. So Yeti Cold is sort of the common battle between the hardware wallet, the Yeti Cold solution, between the air-gapped PC versus hardware wallet. And I started looking into the Yeti Cold strategy a little bit more, and I don't think it does what most people think it does. So let me sort of break that down too. [00:54:25] Lazy Ninja: And we sort of just got into this with single-sig, multisig, multi-device multisig. What the Yeti Cold proposes right now is, Yeti Cold is a single air-gapped PC multisig. At least the best I can tell, correct me if I'm wrong. So it's an N of 7 or 5 of 7, whatever, multisig, but everything, all those keys and actions, are done on a single air-gapped PC. So if I'm able to get malware onto that PC... [00:55:15] Lazy Ninja: I still corrupt all seven of those keys. So, but that's not the end of the world, right? So the strategy isn't protecting you against software, malicious software or bugs. So it's not giving you a multi-device multisig. What the Yeti Cold strategy gives you is sort of robustness in that you have multiple keys, right? So I have all these keys. So if I put them on... So I think their instructions say, you know, you burn them onto CDs, right? And then you go put those CDs in different places, or even the same place. [00:55:53] Lazy Ninja: You know, let's say there's some fire or some events that cause some of those CDs not to work. Well, now you have other CDs and you can bring them all together and you can still spend your funds. So it gives you sort of robustness against failure of the media that you're storing on, which is fine, that's important. But I don't think it makes sense, because doing that large multisig like that adds a lot of complexity and expense, like you said. And additionally, you can just take a single-sig and just have redundant backups... [00:56:32] Lazy Ninja: Of your key material and your passphrase. So you can withstand tornadoes and floods and theft, because of redundancy and then a little bit of splitting, right? So 12-12 and a passphrase, as I said, was the maximum you could split it to. And so the solution just doesn't really... I don't really see a lot of value in the Yeti Cold solution, even though I don't think it's a fundamental error. I just think you can achieve what they do in an easier way without the complexity... Using a single-sig. If you're not going to do multi-device multisig, then I don't really understand any benefit of doing a multisig when you have a single owner of something. [00:57:27] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's reasonable. I know people who make fun of Yeti Cold for the sole reason that it recommends that you use CDs, but at the same time, I think that's kind of brilliant, as the fewer units, you know, it's going back to that security through obscurity debate. And as far as I know, you have people down at the NSA and the CIA who still use floppy disks, just because you don't find many devices to read them anymore. So I will not criticize Yeti Cold for the CDs. [00:57:58] Lazy Ninja: CDs actually have very high reliability. You know, you're sort of physically burning a little discoloration into the surface of that CD. And I don't know if it's all CDs, I got to look it up, but I was looking it up one time and CDs had like lifetimes, you know, like 100, 200-year stability, assuming they're in a roughly stable environment. Like, they actually had very good data retention characteristics versus something like an SD card, or, you know, a USB flash stick using... [00:58:40] Lazy Ninja: NAND flash, or different types of storage technology like that. So, I mean, a CD in that context actually has very good robustness and life. But like I said earlier, so I like the CD from that, but I think you can do even better by putting your seed and your passphrase on metal plates. And then you have even a higher level. Now, when you have a seven-signature multisig, it's just such a huge amount of material, it's impractical to put it onto metal plates. [00:59:19] Lazy Ninja: But in the case of single-sig with a passphrase, it is just trivial to put that information onto metal plates, and it just gives you such a high level of robustness against all sorts of issues. You know, you go bury it in the ground. You can literally go bury your Bitcoin in the ground like a pirate treasure. And if humanity is wiped out here and there's no heirs of yours that know how to recover your Bitcoin, in a few hundred years, somebody might come digging around in your property and find your metal plates and be able to recover your Bitcoin, just like a pirate treasure lost at sea. [00:59:58] Lazy Ninja: And that thought, to me, is just so cool, because people think about Bitcoin as this electronic thing, but it really does have some physicality when you can put this stuff on plates that would allow your coin to be recoverable forever, or at least as long as the digital part of the Bitcoin network can survive. The record of UTXOs. [01:00:24] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's kind of insane. I remember during a presentation by Adam Back that he mentioned how he still owns some eCash from back in the day. You know, cypherpunks were transacting Chaumian eCash from the DigiCash corporation in '96 or something. [01:00:41] Lazy Ninja: Oh, that's really cool, I hadn't heard that. [01:00:44] Vlad Costea: He still has some of these coins from '96 stored on CDs, and they're more like collector's items by now. [01:00:54] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, no, that's really cool. [01:00:56] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but I'm fairly sure that Bitcoin is going to outlive... Actually, I think it already has, in terms of usability, and there's a lot more Bitcoin out there and there are a lot more users, and, you know, being able to become some sort of pirate by burying your metal plates in a time capsule, that's kind of cool. [01:01:21] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I totally think, and the... The record of UTXOs, it's really not that much data, right? That data can be put onto not CDs, but maybe other types of... I think they have like gold plates where they can like encode stuff too, but you can take a record of all Bitcoin, put it onto some gold disc and put that in space. And, you know, that will live forever. I mean, obviously, the record continues to be updated, right? But you can have sort of these intermediate snapshots of the state of the blockchain that live forever. [01:02:08] Lazy Ninja: And then some future civilization can agree upon, you know, when the Earth is absorbed by the Sun in a billion years, but we have these, you know, these records of the current state of the Bitcoin chain, you know, some floating around Mars or something like that. Some future civilization can then go through what they find there and agree on the most recent state they can detect and continue Bitcoin, you know, on from where we last left off and... I don't know, something like that. That's sort of crazy talk, but... [01:02:44] Vlad Costea: Cool, now do that with Ethereum. [01:02:47] Lazy Ninja: Er, what's that? [01:02:48] Vlad Costea: Now do that with Ethereum. [01:02:50] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, that's right, yeah. *laughs* [01:02:55] Vlad Costea: Okay, so we have talked about air gap versus hardware wallets. We have talked about your security disclosures and issues that you found in the Coldcard. We spoke about multisig versus single-sig. You made a brief mention of CoinJoins there. Do you want to elaborate on that? [01:03:17] Lazy Ninja: I think I determined I just don't know enough to even talk about it. Like, I thought I wanted to talk about CoinJoins, but it's just amazing. When you start going down these Bitcoin rabbit holes, you think, oh, okay, I'm going to go figure this out and, you know, help sort of people think about this. I just sort of realized I just don't know enough about what's going on to talk intelligently about it. So, I don't know. I think we'd pass on the CoinJoins. It's funny how these just subtle incentives and implementations in CoinJoin, you know, can be sort of a big deal in how... [01:03:57] Lazy Ninja: How the ultimate security of your coins progress. You know, Samourai basically has incentives that you have a smaller mix, but then it has strong incentives so that people tend to remix more, so your anonymity set, in theory, can continue to grow and doesn't become static and decay. Whereas Wasabi generally just does one very large mix, such that you can handle a little bit of degradation of your anonymity set, but, and people do remix in Wasabi too, but it's just not strongly incentivized. It's just such interesting trade-offs. I don't know if I'm advanced enough to really provide people too much direction on it, though. [01:04:50] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I've spoken to people from Wasabi. I think I've had... Actually, I did have both of them. I had nopara73, who is the lead developer and creator, and also had Max Hillebrand, who also works on development, but works mostly as a spokesperson most of the times. And he's very eloquent and he explains it in a way that also has some sort of ideological weight to it. He explains to you why it's important, why we are in the middle of a war and blah blah blah. Yeah, yeah. [01:05:25] Vlad Costea: He makes it... I don't know, he has his way of presenting it, but... I don't know, I'm not in very good terms with the Samourai people. They enjoy trolling me and making fun of me. They even have a meme about some sort of plush toy crying and they say that's me. [01:05:46] Lazy Ninja: Ha ha ha. Yup, yup, they are really aggressive like that, for sure. [01:05:52] Vlad Costea: I wish, you know, I wish them all the best and I appreciate the fact that they're trying to make mixes better. I haven't seen any merit to it and I think that their marketing is pretty dishonest in terms of explaining how they should use. For example, new users are going to download the Android wallet on their phones, and they're going to think that they are a lot more secure than everyone else, when in reality they rely on the back end of Samourai. And also there are, you know, rumors that Samourai is running some sort of chain analysis company. [01:06:29] Vlad Costea: This can be, you know, FUD. I'm not going to put that out as a fact. But at the same time, I feel like they should push more for people to run their full nodes. I know that the full nodes in the Samourai context are called Dojos. [01:06:41] Lazy Ninja: Yup. [01:06:42] Vlad Costea: And they are slightly adjusted to fit their CoinJoin purposes. I feel like there should be more promotion for that. If there was, I would be a lot happier and less critical of what they do. They also claim that 80% of their users are also running Dojos and I don't know if that's true. It's very hard to verify. [01:07:11] Lazy Ninja: I mean, it's a growing pains thing, right? I mean, they released, they worked hard and released Dojo and people can do it, you know. They're not making it hard. They're trying to make it easy and then it takes... There's just adoption phases and usability phases. So, I'm not really going to beat them up for that. You know, I use, you know, my phone wallet is a Samourai Wallet, so that is what I use on my phone when I'm doing stuff, making small purchases or things like that. [01:07:43] Lazy Ninja: And I have used Whirlpool a little bit and just sort of played around with it. Except I haven't used it for a really long time. And when I used it, the liquidity was pretty low. So my remixes were taking a ridiculous long amount of time. Maybe I had some sort of error or something like that, but yeah, but I find their strategy in Whirlpool a very good strategy. But yeah, I just think these trade-offs are sort of very subtle and, like I said, I'm by far not an expert on this. [01:08:17] Lazy Ninja: It's just, I'm just sort of a pleb opinion on most of this right now, but... I don't know, we'll see how this works out. I do love learning about these things more and I'm going to keep trying to dig into CoinJoin more and maybe I'll have some more researched opinions I can give you later. [01:08:36] Vlad Costea: And if you don't like either and you don't trust that they're honest about their CoinJoins, you can use JoinMarket. And you can coordinate your own CoinJoins there, so you don't have to trust someone who is in the middle coordinating your CoinJoins. You can become the coordinator. You can get the fees from the coordination. So that can be a good way to make some Bitcoin, if there is enough liquidity on the platform. But at the same time, you know, this is part of the sponsorship plug, but you don't have to do CoinJoins to use Wasabi. [01:09:09] Vlad Costea: And I think for beginners who don't know how to run their full nodes, the fact that it downloads block filters and it runs Tor in the background and, you know, that happens without you knowing anything, without having to figure out anything. It's on your computer, you just open it works just like that. It makes UTXO management easy and you don't have to think about it. And that's why I like it. That's why I pitched them the idea that they should sponsor me, because I'm their shill, even if they don't sponsor me. [01:09:42] Vlad Costea: And that's all I had to say about this topic. You don't have to do CoinJoins. That's optional. It's up to you. Just choose whatever you think works. [01:09:50] Lazy Ninja: I'm going to do one more PSA on this. So whoever is listening, just don't get scared away from doing CoinJoins with one implementation or another. You should be CoinJoining. So I have... Well, I was going to say all, but I don't think they all are. I have some KYC exchange coins sitting there still, but I have CoinJoined most of my coins and it will be all once I'm done messing around with a little bit of stuff on the exchange that I'm doing. [01:10:24] Lazy Ninja: And, you know, say you take the argument that Wasabi's anonymity sets decays, whatever. Just do the CoinJoin one time. They're not that expensive. And you can use another CoinJoin implementation before you go to spend or something like that. You know, or just use Whirlpool. If you like Whirlpool, use Whirlpool. All these implementations provide you a great deal of security over nothing. So it provides a good disconnect in your transaction graph, no matter which method you use. I really would recommend anybody, don't kill yourself picking the exact perfect method. Guys, just pick one that you like, the easiest one for you, and CoinJoin your coins. [01:11:08] Vlad Costea: Vaultoro has a 100% track record with fully audited and insured gold bullion that are secured in a top-tier tax-free Swiss vaulting facility. It also features a generous affiliate program, OTC trading, a physical delivery and pickup, or trade back to Bitcoin in seconds. Register for free and check out the ways in which you can trade hard money and preserve your wealth. And if you want to help this show, sign up using the vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover link that you can also find in the description. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice. [01:11:56] Vlad Costea: All trading involves risks, and you are responsible for your own decisions. Wasabi Wallet's innovative CoinJoins will make your bitcoins more fungible. So if you accumulate more than 0.1 BTC, you can mix it with other users to remove all traces about their whereabouts. So it's like putting multiple fingerprints on your dollar bills, and it becomes impossible to determine the last few owners of the money. Download Wasabi Wallet today and start CoinJoining! I remember interviewing Trace Mayer in December 2019, and this was like a month before he exposed himself as a shill for MimbleWimble Coin. [01:12:42] Vlad Costea: And he was trying to FUD CoinJoins, telling me that he sat through the trial of Ross Ulbricht, and he understood that the Fed and the federal government has very sophisticated ways of detecting your Bitcoin activity. So CoinJoins not only that are useless, that was his conclusion, but also make your otherwise pure coins catch something nasty, like coins that might have been stolen from exchanges that are blacklisted somewhere, and basically make it harder for you to get on exchanges and ever sell them, and blacklist you from lots of places. [01:13:22] Vlad Costea: So his point was that Bitcoin is more fungible if you only trade with clean coins, if that makes any sense. But that's not how fungibility works. And the more we see the MicroStrategies of the world buying Bitcoin, and those are going to be KYC'd forever because they are publicly traded US companies and they have to put those coins under their balance sheets. So they're not going to let go of these coins without a contract, so it means that wherever these coins go, even if they are held forever, which I doubt... [01:13:59] Vlad Costea: They're going to be under someone's ownership and that's going to be public. And the more coins, more Bitcoin gets bought by these companies, the fewer coins are going to be out there in the wild, not KYC'd. So that's very much worrying. It worries me. It keeps me up at night thinking about it. And I think that we should all CoinJoin as a norm and make it acceptable so that exchanges can no longer reject it. Because if it's still a niche activity and we don't care much about fungibility and we say, "Yeah, but, you know, these coins that I received are most likely from newly mined blocks..." [01:14:38] Vlad Costea: And the coins that were minted possibly in 2011 are mostly associated with the Silk Road. I mean, that's not going to help Bitcoin become a truly fungible currency. I'm happy that we have the Lightning Network where it doesn't matter. Nobody cares. But still, you know, you might have miners who reject some transactions, especially in the USA. It keeps me up at night, okay? [01:15:06] Lazy Ninja: I think that Trace's advice is terrible because, yeah, there's no... So, it may be true. You can add the concept of some taint to your coins if they're CoinJoined. It's true, but it's not true, right? So some companies could interpret that as some sort of, you know, taint on your coins. But to me, who cares? Oh, hey, this exchange isn't going to let me deposit my coins to sell them. Well, that's a freaking good thing, man. That's a forced hodl. That's the best thing. Make it as hard for me as possible to sell my coins. [01:15:40] Lazy Ninja: But in the long run, I see CoinJoin implementations and methods improving that is going to basically make this concept of tainted coins and things like that just impossible. So even if the current methods, you know, provides, you know, so if I do my CoinJoin and other inputs in that CoinJoin are some thief, then everybody assumes, well, here's a set of outputs that could be owned by the thief and I just happened to get lumped into that. Well, you know, so be it, right? You know, eventually we're going to come up with methods that are going to be stronger and more hiding. [01:16:26] Lazy Ninja: If nothing else, you can continue to remix those coins until they're so far away from that original, quote-unquote, taint that it's just too ridiculous for any coin analysis people to try to link them together. You know, I see there's no reason to not mix coins that you're holding. [01:16:52] Vlad Costea: Right, so let's get to the part where I ask you about your personal, you know, your Lazy Ninja recommendation for having a secure way of storing your bitcoins. [01:17:05] Lazy Ninja: So, this is, man, this is actually a hard one because I don't know if I'm perfect in the way that I'm personally storing everything. I'm trying to continuously upgrade my personal method, but, you know, my number one recommendation is single-sig, metal, 24-word seed, metal plates, passphrase also on metal. And I think the number one way people lose coins, more so than any hacks that have ever occurred, is they lose their coins. They lose access to them. They lose the seed. They forget how... [01:17:50] Lazy Ninja: Where they put it, they forget something like that. So I think, and also, some people forget that they could personally themselves die and their heirs somehow need to recover their coins. And so making sure that, you know, your spouse or your parents or your relatives have some mechanism of making a recovery when you die is really important. I think it's very easy to sort of forget about that. I was in some short periods of time where I had strategies that if I had died in that period of time, I don't know that my family would have been able to recover it. [01:18:38] Lazy Ninja: And as I'm sort of doing these things, you know, moving money around and changing strategies and doing stuff, that's sort of in the back of my head, and it almost, it just makes me sick to my stomach to think that I could mess this up. So since I've had those sort of worries and feelings, I've tried to make it much easier for family and friends. And I even think about, you know, what if my whole family's on an airplane and the airplane crashes? We all die. Can my... [01:19:06] Lazy Ninja: My parents or siblings or whatever somehow recover these funds? And I really think that's important for all Bitcoiners to really go through that. This isn't just money to buy Lambos with for you. This is generational money that you're trying to create and protect, and you need to be very careful and disciplined about it. So overly complex, fancy schemes, you know, I have one key buried in my backyard, and then at this tree in the park, I buried another key, and there's a map. You know, you can do things like that, but you... [01:19:48] Lazy Ninja: You're more likely you're going to lose your coins than you're going to protect them from something. So I think simpler setups with metal storage and redundancy. So you have metal storage of your seed and your passphrase, and then maybe a redundant metal storage of the seed and the passphrase. And maybe split, so your parents have the seed, you know, at their house and your sibling has the passphrase at their house, or some sort of splitting like that. I think strategies like that are sort of the best for people, but you just have to be so careful to not shoot yourself in the foot and do something overly complicated and lose your money. [01:20:38] Lazy Ninja: I started down that road. I'm still sort of halfway. I have a backup of stuff that will help my wife recover things. And one of the things I wanted to do is, I wanted to have this backup encrypted. And so I'm like, okay, if I die, you need to decrypt this backup, and then you can figure things out from there. And that is a very challenging concept for her. Like, I haven't been able to really make her comfortable enough with doing a recovery that way that I feel comfortable enough about it. [01:21:16] Lazy Ninja: And so I just left this recovery thing sort of unencrypted right now, and I'm just continuing to work with her to see if I can get her to that comfort level. But I'm more terrified of her not being able to, or my heirs not being able to recover this if I die or we die, than I am of sort of an imminent theft issue. So, for me, it's just a continually sort of growing, personally, in how I do this. But my number one recommendation is don't overcomplicate it. [01:21:56] Lazy Ninja: Remember, you can die. There can be natural tornadoes, earthquakes, floods. All sorts of things can come into play. But 90% of the time, it's not going to be a fancy hack on your device that's going to steal your money. [01:22:19] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but at the same time, this is my personal advice. Don't go to Casa and hand them your keys and say, you know, this is safe. I don't care. Take care of it. [01:22:31] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, it's... So personally, I haven't done that. However, I am sort of on the edge of schemes like that where you have some sort of custodial help. I'm probably not going to end up going one of those routes. But I'm trying to make sure that there's a mechanism for recovery in all cases. And it actually is really hard to go through all the cases. And like I said, losing them is probably the number one way your coins disappear, not getting hacked. [01:23:10] Lazy Ninja: I don't fault people for doing a, I guess it's not custodial, but a partnership custodianship, where, you know, it's a multisig where they hold one key. You know, scenarios like that are possible, but I don't know. Like I said, I'm sort of even a pleb on this stuff as well. I'm just a guy trying to figure this out and make sure I don't lose my coins. [01:23:41] Vlad Costea: No, we all are. It's not like there is a definitive way of getting this right. This is actually the hardest part. You think that if you buy a product by some sort of company, like a hardware wallet, it will help you mitigate all the risks and take care of all the possible issues. But in reality, you can complicate it for yourself if you're technically inclined. But as you said, you have to think about what happens if you die. And that's when it gets very difficult because you can either accept that you die with your coins, which I'm not going to judge, I guess it's fine. [01:24:19] Vlad Costea: It's a favor to all of us. It's like a donation to the rest of the network, and everyone else's coins are going to be more valuable as a consequence. But at the same time, I suppose all of us have someone that we care about. So we have to consider this, but don't turn that person into, you know, a single point of failure or something. Don't go to someone who might just divorce you and steal your coins. [01:24:48] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, it's so tough, Vlad. I wish I could give people better advice, but it's, you know, be careful. You know, another sort of interesting side note down this path too is, you know, hardware wallets versus your metal backup. Most people aren't getting the value, so let me back up one. So one of the big things hardware wallets try to do, or a hardware wallet specifically like the Coldcard or something that has the secure element, is they try to give you a short passphrase that gives you strong protection of a seed, right? So ultimately the hardware wallet has your seed, and they want to give you a short passphrase that is... [01:25:40] Lazy Ninja: Artificially made as strong as a seed. You know, they either do that through rate limiting, right? So there's some mechanisms to prevent you from trying PINs and passwords very fast, or attempt limiting. There's a mechanism to prevent you from trying a bunch of attempts, and if you do try a bunch of attempts, it just locks you out and you're toast. But if you have a backup setup where your seed is stored, say, in your office. Say you have your seed plate sitting in your office, and you have your hardware wallet there, too. [01:26:18] Lazy Ninja: With its PIN and all that stuff. The PIN on your hardware wallet is basically doing nothing, because your seed is also stored in your house, in your office, in the same place. So you're really not getting any benefit out of that protection from your hardware wallet. And in actuality, you know, you could just wipe your hardware wallet and not worry about it, and just set your hardware wallet up from the seed the next time you want to use it. [01:26:44] Lazy Ninja: But if you really want to get the best benefit out of a hardware wallet, you need, you know, semi-geographic distribution, right? Your seed words need to either not be at your house, or they need to be in a place that requires time to access, you know, whether it's buried in your backyard or whether it's just physically in a safety deposit box that takes a couple hours to go to. [01:27:10] Lazy Ninja: If you have a setup like that, then the PIN on your hardware wallet really provides something more useful, because it provides you fast access, right? It doesn't take you five hours to go get your seed plates and then recover. You can just type in your PIN. Yet at the same time, if an attacker recovers your hardware wallet, it's still very difficult for him to get your seeds out of that thing, because the PIN really presents a strong barrier, since the plates aren't in the same spot. [01:27:49] Lazy Ninja: But I think a lot of people have hardware wallets. They put the PIN on it. They put their plates in the next drawer next to it. And they are all excited about having this strong PIN on here, when in reality, the plates are sitting right next to it. [01:28:06] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, that's easy to attack. You know, we like to think that strong cryptography will help us solve problems. But if we keep the decryption key very close to the device that's encrypted, then it doesn't help in any way. It's just placebo. It helps us sleep well at night. But at gunpoint, if someone comes in and says, "Open this for me," it's going to be so easy, and you're going to crack. You might think you don't care, and you are going to be a hard negotiator, but you don't know that until it happens. [01:28:41] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, that's very true. The wrench attack is also something to concern about, but I never want people to be overly worried about the people coming to your house thing, because that absolutely can happen. But, you know, that's something that is a very, and you should have some preparation for an event like that. But that is the rare thing that's going to happen. The most probable things that are going to happen is you're going to have your seed plates stored in a drawer. Your spouse doesn't really know about them. And they're going to clean the house and throw it all in the garbage. And you come home and everything got thrown away. [01:29:19] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, same if you live in mom's basement. [01:29:23] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, and in that case, that's where you need to have redundancy in your backups and things like that. So if somebody accidentally throws it away, loses it, I mean, you can have dramatic things like house burned down, floods and tornadoes. But really, it could be simple things like somebody, you know, doesn't recognize what this thing is and just chucks it in the garbage and it's gone. You know, I think that's a common way people will lose funds. So just covering the simple things, just redundancy in your backups... And robustness of those backups so they can't be easily destroyed by, you know, humidity, water, fire, even. I think it's really important. [01:30:04] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so speaking of spouses, you have two questions from @HodlWave on Twitter. And he wants to know if your wife is still hilariously oblivious about your Bitcoin holdings. [01:30:16] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, so I know he loved following this when I was doing some posts about this, so... I gotta remember when I first posted. I think it was probably right when we were getting ready to break the 2017 high, I made a post. And this actually sort of leads into this whole thing. My wife is, you know, love her to death. She has very high time preference. So when we... If we have money, you know, she always has something she wants to spend it on. So, you know, a long time ago when I first started buying Bitcoin, I ran it by her. [01:30:54] Lazy Ninja: "Hey, you know, I want to get some of this." And she's like, "Oh, OK," you know. And then I've really not talked to her about it very much since. So at the time, probably for the last, you know, four years, she has no concept, no even thought of the dollar value that's now present in our Bitcoin holdings. So she has absolutely no clue. She thinks it's like nothing. And so I put out a post that said, you know, when is she going to finally ask me about what our holdings are? [01:31:32] Lazy Ninja: What price? And so we kept ticking through the prices and we blew by 50k, still no ask. But then finally, she busted me. So I think I'll call the bet at 60k. So I didn't resist talking about Bitcoin at all. Like, I still talk about Bitcoin. So I didn't completely... So I knew eventually one of those times it should be like, "Hey, I remember we used to have some of that. How much do we have?" So she actually did finally sort of ask me about it. [01:32:05] Lazy Ninja: But, so I think I'm going to call the bet at 60k. And it was sort of funny. So I'm like, okay, this is how it works. And, you know, this is what we have. And it was sort of funny because I don't have a crazy stack. I beat myself up all the time for not having stacked harder. But, you know, we did pretty good. You know, we did pretty good. And so when I finally told her about it, she was completely unimpressed. [01:32:39] Lazy Ninja: And I'm like, wait a minute, this is a good chunk of money. How can you be unimpressed with this? What the? It was like super anticlimactic. She's like, "Huh, huh." But I did make it very clear, I was throwing out some sort of statements like, "Well, you can't actually spend this. You can't spend it." You know, just some blanket statements like there's some technical reason you can't spend it, you have to keep it. [01:33:06] Lazy Ninja: But I think I have her convinced that this is money not to be spent for a long time, so she hasn't pressured me to go buy new boats and cars and stuff like that yet. But the reason I was so relieved to finally sort of get this over with, which is really stupid, I mean, you just think about the conversation we just had, is she didn't have any idea of the value that was there. So what happened if I died? How hard would she work to try to figure out, you know, how to recover our Bitcoin? Like it was... And it was really bothering me. [01:33:46] Lazy Ninja: Like, I had some other sort of, you know, I had some friends that sort of had an idea and would have sort of clued her in. There's something there that she needs to figure out. But without her knowing about that in detail, it was really a huge threat to my hold. It just, it was really sort of scary, so I'm glad I got her on the same page now. And, you know, she sees, she now knows where things are and roughly how it works and how to recover and... [01:34:21] Lazy Ninja: But, you know, this isn't something she does day to day, so I sort of have to keep practicing with her occasionally to make sure she stays up to speed. But yeah, I called the bet at 60k. She found out. [01:34:34] Vlad Costea: I'm happy it did not end up like in the TV show Breaking Bad, when Skyler finds out about Walter's activities and she's like, "Oh, I'm loaded. Look at this wall of money that I just kept on stacking." [01:34:48] Lazy Ninja: Yup, yup, that's exactly what I didn't want to happen. But yeah, no, it turned out pretty good. And yeah, like I said, she's not pushing me to spend it. So I was really worried, like, she would be pushing me to spend it to the point we'd end up getting divorced. You know, like, I was really concerned about how that was going to go down. But yeah, I think we're in good shape now. All has been revealed and she has some understanding of how to collect it. I think we're in good shape. [01:35:20] Vlad Costea: Unless, you know, she decides to collect it without letting you know. But I hope you don't end up there. [01:35:27] Lazy Ninja: I hope not. I hope not. At least I'll have... Well... Yeah, yeah, yeah. [01:35:33] Vlad Costea: Didn't you tweet once about... I'm not sure if you have a son or not, so this might be like me mixing up information in my head, but your rather young son calling his mother Karen or something while watching TV. [01:35:51] Lazy Ninja: I, you know what, I think I might have tweeted. So that definitely has happened. My kids are big into calling people names, calling people Karens, so it makes me sort of happy that my kids are on the same page as me with all this stuff. Yeah, I think I did tweet that. That's funny you remember that. Sort of funny what people remember from your tweets, you know, when you don't even hardly remember them. [01:36:18] Vlad Costea: Exactly. I know you because you hack hardware wallets, and because you tweet stuff about your kids and your wife. [01:36:29] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I actually got to close out that bet on the wife finding out on Twitter. I got to post something about that still. [01:36:36] Vlad Costea: Okay, so HodlWave actually has a real question. Can you discuss steps hardware wallet companies can take to let customers program microcontrollers in a trust-minimized way? For example, JTAG. The biggest issue he sees with hardware wallets is having to trust what's going on in the microcontroller. [01:36:57] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I'm 100% on the same page with that. See, the thing is, I'm sort of, you know, in that industry, so it seems pretty easy for me. But it actually is pretty easy. Like, it is not terribly hard for a normie to buy a generic programming tool and program one of these microcontrollers, and I really think hardware wallet manufacturers should encourage it more. So it's actually pretty, I think it's pretty easy to do with the Trezor. So in full disclosure, I actually haven't done it with the Trezor. [01:37:36] Lazy Ninja: But there is what I believe is the JTAG programming header just sitting on their PCB, and it looks like it's, you know, very easy to connect to. So, seemingly, it's easy enough. You just pop your case open and program it, and then you, with near 100% certainty, know what code is actually on that device. And again, this wouldn't be something like everybody does, but if we can make it easy enough for enough people to do it, I think it really helps. So one of the devices that it gets trickier on is like the Coldcard. [01:38:10] Lazy Ninja: So the Coldcard has a shared secret that's programmed into the microcontroller memory and the secure element memory at production for them. So it's not as easy as somebody can just... So once the device has gone through production, you can't just sort of plug it in and just program with JTAG just sort of mindlessly, as easily. But you can do it. So I think if they just sort of... I think they could set it up so you order a special version of their device that hasn't had the secure element programmed and locked. [01:38:54] Lazy Ninja: You could, just as easily as the Trezor, they could expose a programming header that would allow you to program the device. Now, there's a couple extra steps in programming where the secure element would have to be set up as well. But it's really sort of relatively simple stuff that could be potentially scripted, so I think... Or actually, what I'd probably do is, I think you could probably load two programs on there. So you load one program onto your Coldcard that sort of sets up the secure element and then remembers some of the secrets, maybe programs the secrets into the flash. [01:39:35] Lazy Ninja: And then you go in and you program your real code or something like that. So I think Coldcard could do it too. But it does get a little bit harder when you have multiple chips that have some shared information across them. But an additional, though, like I sort of talked about earlier when we were talking about the Tropic Square, I think an additional mitigation that makes it less necessary for the full programming to happen is for to have a chip, a native chip hashing mechanism that will hash the image on the chip through, like, a JTAG connector. [01:40:14] Lazy Ninja: So you, maybe it's hard to program your Coldcard yourself, but you can plug into the JTAG and you can actually command the chip to return a hash of the data in it without having to program it. And then all you're trusting is, you don't have to trust the manufacturer of the hardware wallet at all. You're only trusting the chip manufacturer's hardware to work correctly. [01:40:41] Lazy Ninja: And that actually might be... Now, the STM part that's on there, I don't think has any capabilities like that, so that would have to be a new part. But going forward, I think things like that, having those hardware hash readout mechanisms in microcontrollers, would be useful. So if the Trezor Tropic Square comes out, you know, maybe everybody starts standardizing on using that device, and if that device includes some sort of, you know, hash readout of the contents, that could be very helpful to everybody. In addition, those that are even more paranoid could actually compile and program themselves as well. [01:41:25] Vlad Costea: Right, so one final remark that I want to make is that during this season, I spoke about the Tropic Square project with all the guests. And I think Zach Herbert of Passport, what's the company called? Foundation Devices. Foundation Devices. And also there was Lawrence Nahum of Blockstream, who is also responsible for the Jade, told me basically the same stuff: that it's very hard for you to verify a secure chip, which, even if it's open source, gets shipped to you, unless you have a microscope and you have the technical inclinations to do all the verifications, because software and hardware are very different in their nature. [01:42:11] Vlad Costea: It's a lot easier to audit software as opposed to hardware. So even if the chip is open source and is verifiable and has all of the qualities that are ideal, you can still have mess-ups at the factory. [01:42:29] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, you certainly can. And that's one of the reasons why the Coldcard did that additional layer. Basically, my PIN replacement is sort of an example of not a malicious, not something malicious in the secure element, but something that was able to be exploited in the secure element, ultimately caused a break in the wallet. But you can use architectures that mostly prevent that. So if you, when you're designing a system, if you just assume the attacker knows everything in the secure element, you still want your system to be secure, at least as secure as that microcontroller can make it. [01:43:14] Lazy Ninja: You just don't want a single point of failure. You don't want, "Hey, if somebody knows this, then they know everything." You want them to have to know, break it. It's sort of the same concept as a multi-device multisig. So in the case of, like, the Coldcard using and the BitBox using the 608, if they design it properly, even an attacker that knows everything in the 608, it still doesn't break the device. They still have to know everything in the microcontroller. [01:43:44] Lazy Ninja: And in the case of the Coldcard, they had made a small error here, but they have corrected that error, right? So it's actually like a one line of code fix. That's how easy it is to correct, but it's simply, "Hey, in the hash, when we're calculating this, we have to include a secret in the microcontroller, not just secrets only on the secure element." [01:44:07] Vlad Costea: Mm-hmm. [01:44:08] Lazy Ninja: Did I go off on a tangent there? I sort of lost track where I was going there. Sorry. [01:44:11] Vlad Costea: No, it's fine. I'm actually happy that we got this covered and we explained all the details and all the facets. [01:44:20] Lazy Ninja: Did you want to talk about the Foundation Devices device at all? I have a few comments about that. [01:44:24] Vlad Costea: Oh, you should. They promised they would send me a device, so I didn't get my hands on it yet. [01:44:32] Lazy Ninja: It's sort of interesting how that turned into some drama there too, and ultimately led to Coldcard changing their licensing. But it sort of... so then everybody's accusing Coldcard of not being open source now, because they changed their licensing so that you couldn't sell something. You couldn't sell it commercially. So it was all sort of a really interesting deal, but in general, the Passport device, I was happy with the change the Passport device made to the Coldcard, because one of my complaints about the Coldcard is the UI. [01:45:16] Lazy Ninja: Like, I think having a responsive, fast user interface is very important. And I said this at the beginning, because I think having a responsive, fast interface encourages you to use long PINs and long passphrases. And I just find it really important. Additionally, I think adding that QR code read and scanning capability is also a very nice add-on as well. So the macro changes they made to do just those two things, I actually think are really good changes. And so that sort of makes me happy that the Coldcard source was open sourced and they made those changes, because I like those changes. [01:46:06] Lazy Ninja: But at the same time, I thought it was sort of weird. At least, I haven't watched all the interviews with the guys from Foundation, but at least in the couple times I saw comments and stuff about it, they made it, like, one comment was, "We were inspired by the Coldcard." They just seemed to sort of be trying not to disclose that they used the Coldcard software. And the guys actually, to me, seemed like great guys, but it just came off really weird how that was being put out when we all sort of knew what it was. [01:46:48] Lazy Ninja: And I don't think they did anything wrong. I think they used the software, they made substantive architecture advances on what the software does. I don't think there's anything to be embarrassed about or ashamed of. I think it was exactly what this type of stuff was meant for. So it was just sort of this weird thing going on for a while. [01:47:14] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, they still don't call it a clone if you ask them. Like, "Yeah, we were inspired by the BitBox02 and the Coldcard and the Trezor." And it's likely that they took code from all sides. But I think the issue is that they are selling a more expensive device. So it's like $400. It's like twice as much as any other competitor. So it's very hard when you deal with a marketing department and they're trying to say that this is really great, to admit that there are devices that are very similar and cost twice as little as your newly launched device on the market. [01:47:53] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, it's sort of, yeah, it's interesting. I think everything they did is legit. You know, they added, you know, I think they probably put the STM, the Cortex-M7, ST has an M7, down, so they put down a higher speed processor. I actually haven't got my device yet, so I'm not 100% sure. But they put down a higher speed processor, I assume. And you know, they put in the camera module and that stuff. So those things have cost to them, right? There's costs there. [01:48:17] Lazy Ninja: There's development costs. And it will be interesting to see how the market works it out. But now the licensing battle between Coinkite and them is going to be sort of interesting to see how it plays out. And here's the sort of interesting thing: I'm pretty much fine with Coinkite making the change to their license on the Coldcard to make it... Basically, now they're... I'm not a licensing expert on this stuff, but basically now their license says, it's open source, you can see it, you can use it, you can take a wallet and you can do whatever you want with it, you can sell your wallet. [01:49:00] Lazy Ninja: But you can't take our code and make your own wallet and sell that as a business. But that's going forward from the point they made that licensing change. So it will be... and Coldcard has since added some really nice features, like they've added the 24th word autocomplete feature, which I actually really love. I absolutely love that feature. It just makes picking your own seed a lot easier. So I love the 24th word chooser feature. But now the Foundation Devices device can't just take that code and import that code. [01:49:50] Lazy Ninja: They have to write it from scratch, so to say. Now, they can take the concept and they can be like, "Hey, that's a good concept," and then they can write the same thing from scratch, sure. But it sort of creates this incentive now that they're going to have to be on almost a different innovation path from the Coldcard. So they're going to have to sort of come up with more of their own ideas. And maybe that's better for the ecosystem anyway, rather than having just one device follow the other devices and pull in some of the profits. [01:50:24] Lazy Ninja: They now have to start innovating on a slightly different path. And now one thing I wasn't clear on, I don't know if you heard: did Foundation Devices also change their licensing? [01:50:36] Vlad Costea: I have no idea about that, but I'm very much a fan of Trezor's approach, and they never changed anything, even though they had quite a fight, you know, at the time when the KeepKey came out. It looked a lot better. It had a larger screen. It looked more premium and felt more premium. But at the same time, they stuck to their open source ethic, and they understood that basically, when somebody else copies your code and your design, and also the hardware possibly, and sells it, they're going to be accountable for all the issues that get discovered by the users. [01:51:16] Vlad Costea: And all of these issues are going to be released as open source fixes. So this goes back to their design. So if they find anything useful in what the others are doing, they're going to harden their security. And I think this, with copying something and keeping your licenses free, also improves on the incentives for your code to get verified by other developers. If they know that they can sell it, then they're going to take a better look at it and see if they can make a business out of it. [01:51:47] Vlad Costea: And I think this is all part of this whole open source industry. And to have, you know, devices that start out as copies of something else and they're open source, and then they change the code and they rewrite everything so that they can close source to the point that you cannot sell it, especially if you're a company like Coinkite, which has a bad history with paying bounties. And there were people who discovered issues, and I think it was the charlatan from BitBox02, it was also benma, also from BitBox02. [01:52:22] Vlad Costea: And who else was it? It was that guy who is supposedly very young and has found issues, Saleem? Yeah, Saleem or something, yeah. Saleem, yeah, he also never got any kind of reward for his work, and when he found some sort of vulnerability like a year ago, he refused to disclose it to Coldcard, specifically because he knew that they treated him badly and he never made any money out of working with them. So if you have that kind of system in place, and you only rely on some sort of audit for which you paid, and you don't give bounties to open source researchers and hackers and, you know, white hat hackers, and you still close source part of the incentives, I mean, that's a bad sign, even though the product is excellent. You still need to incentivize people to look at your code and scrutinize it and harden it in time. [01:53:22] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I think, so I did get paid. I did get paid a bounty for this bug I found, just full disclosure there. So I know Coinkite has paid bounties. They're just a little bit more picky about it. So they didn't like the BitBox one, because the BitBox guys are, you know, doing it for their own publicity. And I'm not even faulting them for that. That's fine. And so Coinkite just doesn't want to pay their competitor, and I think that's... I'm actually okay with that. [01:54:05] Lazy Ninja: I know the charlatan. I think I know one of his issues. And I actually might agree, there's at least one of the issues that he reported that I'm aware of that I think he probably should have been paid for. I don't remember the details on Saleem's. But it's hard though when you're on the hardware wallet side, because all of us hackers, we think everything we find is really important and a big deal. And on the hardware wallet manufacturer side, they view things differently lots of times. [01:54:53] Lazy Ninja: So when you report a bug that you thought is the biggest thing in the world, without denying that the bug's there, they may just think, "Yeah, it's there, but it's just not that big a deal because nobody can exploit it. So, you know, we're not going to pay a bunch of money we could use to be developing more product with for something that's obscure." Now, there's a fine line there, because you want to encourage people to review your product. And if I made more money from finding vulnerabilities, I would spend more time doing it. You know, right now, it's almost sort of just for fun. [01:55:36] Lazy Ninja: Like, I just sort of do it to get, you know, some Twitter cred and attention, and it's just sort of fun to do. It's not my career, but if wallets paid significantly more, I would spend a whole lot more time doing this. So there is this trade-off that you need to have enough incentive to get enough eyes on your products. [01:56:01] Lazy Ninja: But you can't have too much, because you don't want your product... There's always going to be bugs, and if you're giving away tons of your company's income for bugs that are obscure or not critical, then it's going to put you at a deficit in the development of product. But at the same time, if you're not giving out enough, then people aren't going to look. So I think there's sort of this fine line to walk between paying everything and every person that comes in, and not paying anybody, but... [01:56:40] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, like I said, I got paid. And Bitcoin's since went up a whole bunch, so basically I got paid a lot more than I got paid originally, now that we're sitting at 60k. So yeah, I don't know, it's a really sort of interesting situation. [01:57:02] Vlad Costea: Oh, sorry, sorry, sorry, I was muted and I did not even realize it, but I recorded on my side. So I was saying that I'm all for the Coldcard and I want it to succeed as a device, but I believe that they should improve their system to incentivize people to look at their code. And I know that they pay for independent private audits, for example. And that was something that NVK told me when he was on the show. I know that he will never get on it again. [01:57:29] Vlad Costea: He blocked me everywhere. I don't mind it. But at the same time, you know, I believe that sometimes users or people who just play around with hardware wallets can find issues about which security experts would not have ever thought. So it's important to pay attention to these vulnerabilities that get disclosed and reward them, because otherwise, what's the incentive for you to report it honestly and disclose it to them and work with them to fix it, when you can exploit it and you can steal a lot of Bitcoin from people? [01:58:05] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, I mean, that's really the true incentive game theory trade-off that needs to be made, is, you know, every hacker, or security researcher, I'll call myself... You know what, and I actually make this... I'm not going to steal people's money, but I do make this trade-off sometimes, you know: what if I find something, rather than disclosing it, what if I just advertise on my website that I can unlock your wallet? "Hey, I can unlock the Coldcard Mk3," right? And I'll make a person, like, prove their identity or KYC themselves so that I know it's not stolen, but I can help them out. [01:58:52] Lazy Ninja: It would be very infrequent I would get somebody. But when I did get somebody, that person would potentially pay me a lot of money because they're going to be very desperate, right? I mean, I could get, you know, five-figure number potentially to unlock somebody's wallet, because, you know, one of their backups is gone and this is all they have and they need it unlocked. So it's, now that's a theoretical payoff, maybe nobody ever calls me, versus an immediate payoff if I go report the bug and turn it in. [01:59:30] Lazy Ninja: And now, people may call the first path I outlined there, maybe they call that unethical. But I think it's sort of a gray area, right? If you don't disclose it, but you just sort of keep it there and you actually are helping people out and you monetize that knowledge a different way. It's something to consider from the hardware wallet manufacturer perspective. If they want to incentivize people like me, they have to pay enough that it's not worth my time to try to monetize this knowledge some other way. [02:00:07] Lazy Ninja: So there's sort of a balance there, you know. I obviously get additional value out of, you know, putting it on Twitter and getting more followers or whatever like that. And so there has to be this balance in how much is that worth to somebody in general versus how much you pay or don't pay for these things. I think it is a tricky balance. You know, I obviously always think these things should be paid more, more should be paid, but I understand when there's pushback. [02:00:36] Vlad Costea: Yeah, anyway, I want to ask you one last question, and this is almost two hours long. I suppose it exceeds most people's patience to listen to something. [02:00:47] Lazy Ninja: We can say anything now, Vlad, because nobody's listening right now. We can say anything we want. [02:00:50] Vlad Costea: Exactly. But what about the Lazy Ninja Academy? You sign up with $1,000 and you teach them everything they need to know about Bitcoin. They buy some Bitcoin and they call you again in four years. How does that work? [02:01:06] Lazy Ninja: So that was my poke at Pomp and everybody getting pissed at him for doing his week-long $1,000, or two or three week-long $1,000 academy on teaching everything you want to know about crypto. And it's just sort of the point. It's good to understand things, but the first thing you need to understand, you just buy and hold it. And then you start doing your research later. So that was just my little poke at him. [02:01:43] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I've actually been involved without my consent or my prior knowledge in one of these situations, where some Romanian [unclear: quote-unquote influencer] asked if I want to do an interview, and the interview turned out to be one of his masterclasses in crypto. So like, the whole concept was that he would interview people who are more knowledgeable than him on certain aspects and ask specific questions, and that was supposed to be part of his class to students. So he was making money out of it and I had no idea about it. Never got paid. [02:02:17] Lazy Ninja: Oh, that's really interesting. Yeah, there's all sorts of semi-scammers out there trying to amplify their knowledge through using other people. [02:02:30] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's why I don't go on many interviews anymore. At least not during this bull market. I think it's all crazy. You can make money off of anything, basically. I think right now the name of the coin is more important than the fundamentals or anything. If it sounds like Bitcoin, people are going to buy it. You can watch Bitcoin Diamond pumping even though there is no development to it. There is no future to that coin. It's crazy. [02:02:57] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, it's complete insanity. I can't understand how people can just throw so much, well, maybe they aren't throwing that much money, but how, you know, how things are pumping as much as they are that have absolutely no value. They're just jokes. [02:03:13] Vlad Costea: Yeah, money printer go brrr, so people have disposable income to dump, and others may be laundering money with shady altcoins. [02:03:24] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, yup. I don't know, we'll see here. I'm really excited, you know, about Taproot coming out and then the DLCs getting sort of developed more, so I really hope that starts getting played out here more in the future. I think Bitcoin will start appearing to be a lot more capable than most people thought was possible here soon, so hopefully that'll put a few of these other altcoins down. [02:03:57] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, this feels like 2017, doesn't it? We have, this is April, we have Taproot, which is just like SegWit. It has been discussed for such a long time. We're gonna have a speedy activation, just like there was the UASF movement in 2017. [02:04:15] Lazy Ninja: Yep, for sure. [02:04:17] Vlad Costea: We're just missing a major contention in the scaling way. I think that was solved. But we still have Ethereum claiming to flip, and possibly Bitcoin at some point, with their new buzzwords. [02:04:32] Lazy Ninja: Ultrasound money, Vlad. It's ultrasound money. [02:04:35] Vlad Costea: NFTs are the new ICOs. [02:04:39] Lazy Ninja: NFTs, ridiculous. And then yeah, Ethereum hard forks and puts down all the exchanges the other day. Ultrasound. Ultra down money. Ultra down money. [02:04:49] Vlad Costea: Actually, it pumped. That's why it's so irrational. Nobody cares anymore. [02:04:55] Lazy Ninja: I know, it's like, well, because nobody can sell, so they can only... I don't know. It is actually completely irrational. I don't understand it. I feel so confident, like, here's another funny little tidbit: so my co-workers, you know, everybody's just into talking about, hey, about this stock, this stock's up, this, you know, they just talk about it all the time. And I just sit here holding my Bitcoin and I feel like the conservative investor in the office. Like I see everybody just, "Hey, this stock's gonna be up 50% tomorrow. [02:05:28] Lazy Ninja: Hey, it did go up 50%. Should I get out? Oh, I'm gonna get out. I'm gonna get into something else now." And I just sit here with my Bitcoin and do nothing with it. And that's the conservative, safe investment in today's world. [02:05:43] Vlad Costea: Crazy, right? You wouldn't think. It sounds a lot riskier, but I think it performs a lot better than stonks on the long term. [02:05:52] Lazy Ninja: Yep. [02:05:53] Vlad Costea: Not financial advice. Don't listen to me, I'm a bad trader. I got wrecked. *laughs* [02:06:01] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, man, there's been... I've done some stupid things in the market and gotten wrecked myself, so I feel like that's probably helping me hold better. Because, like in the 2008 crash, I thought I was going to be smart and I was going to throw a whole bunch of money in with leverage and, you know, a short, short with leverage, and this thing is going to crash and I'm going to make a bunch of money. And I went and tried to do it, but the problem was the amount of leverage I had. [02:06:43] Lazy Ninja: It caused the swings in my portfolio to be too big, it basically scared me out, so I ended up losing a whole bunch of money in like 20 minutes, some short, tiny, short period of time. And so I'm like, I just can't handle this anymore. Punch out, lost a ton of money. And had I just stayed in the whole day, like my plan was, at that short position, I would have made like 10x that amount of money, because the market tried to recover and I lost a ton of money and then it just completely shit the bed and fell apart. [02:07:20] Lazy Ninja: And that moment was sort of a really learning moment for me. I'm like, you can't predict this. You don't know what's going on. So since then, I've never really aggressively traded. I still dabbled a little bit, but basically, I didn't trade after that because I felt so stupid after losing all that money trying to time the market. [02:07:49] Vlad Costea: Right. Anyway, I think I ran out of questions for you for now, which is unfortunate because you're a goldmine. [02:07:58] Lazy Ninja: Well, something. [02:08:00] Vlad Costea: You are something. And you remind people constantly that freedom isn't safe on Twitter. [02:08:09] Lazy Ninja: I never realized how true that was going to feel when I first made that handle. It feels scarily true in today's age. [02:08:20] Vlad Costea: It has kind of a different meaning if you think about it. [02:08:25] Lazy Ninja: It does. It's almost like I picked it recently, but it was picked a long time ago, but it's scarily true. Like, I just cannot believe where we ended up today, how quickly people caved, giving up all their... giving up freedoms for safety. But I mean, I've always sort of knew people do that, but just the speed at which it happened, and even actually knowing people that I thought were freedom-loving people just absolutely cave to the virus hysteria and want to lock everybody down. [02:09:03] Vlad Costea: I know some of those people too, but at the same time I make fun of them for being betas and they don't talk to me anymore. So whatever. I very much remember that you are calling out Karens and you are saying that basically everything is possible nowadays because we have a society of Karens. And by Karens, I mean people who feel morally obliged to disclose everything to the state, and their moral compass relies on just playing by the rules that get changed all the time and being on what they perceive as the right side. So they don't have like moral compass that relies on principles or something which is universal and doesn't change over time. [02:09:46] Vlad Costea: They just do whatever they get told on television or mainstream media, whichever channel they consume. And they're going to just go all the way and feel entitled and feel like they are doing everything that is right and correct and for the better, I don't know, for the future of humanity or whatever, I don't know what they think. Maybe they treat this like they're earning more likes on Twitter or something like that. [02:10:19] Lazy Ninja: The mindset is strange to me. I actually have a friend that... It's sort of interesting, he's very against all this. He's angry about it, he thinks the whole mask thing is dumb. And, you know, we're totally sort of on the same page in that respect. But at the same time, I think this is almost sort of, let's see, what is it? Almost sort of the... I can't think of it. Basically, people are using his morals against him. [02:10:59] Lazy Ninja: So even though he's extremely against all this stuff, he's such a believer in law and order that because the mask thing is a rule in a pseudo-official way, he wears his mask religiously. Like, every place he's supposed to, all the time, and at the same time he'll complain and say this is ridiculous and stupid and we shouldn't be doing this. And yet he is one of the prime examples of best practices in mask wearing. [02:11:37] Lazy Ninja: And again, it's just because he believes, you know, law and order, we follow the rules, you know, that whole thing, but when the other side is making arbitrary rules and effectively using them against you can't be the guy that's just blindly following the rules. There's a time to sort of stand up and say these rules are not just. [02:12:08] Vlad Costea: No, absolutely. People do that all the time. It depends where you are. [02:12:12] Lazy Ninja: I was, I almost started wearing my mask to be left alone. But I got so angry about this whole Corona hysteria situation that I just didn't give a shit anymore. Like, it just got me so angry. I wanted to be confronted about it because I was so upset. And I can see if I didn't get to that level, and most people aren't. So, like right now, when I go to stores, like, we'll use Home Depot as an example. [02:12:46] Lazy Ninja: Surfer Jim likes to post stuff about this too. Home Depot doesn't enforce mask mandate at all. They say nothing to you. It's countrywide. I don't know what their policy officially is, but they don't say a word. They never hassle you about it at all. So I never even think about wearing my mask when I go in there. I go in there, no mask, no problem. But when I go in that store, there's 100 people in there. There's not a single person, not a single one person, not wearing a mask. [02:13:20] Lazy Ninja: And I know, I mean, these are people that aren't mask people typically at Home Depot. Some are, but, you know, sort of the typical guy that's not going to be. Most of them are doing just what you said you're doing, Vlad. They just don't want to be hassled. They're like, I'm just going to put this on. I don't like this. I just don't want to be hassled. I just want to get my stuff and get out of here. And I think for a lot of things, that's a... [02:13:45] Lazy Ninja: An okay opinion to have, but I think we have reached the point now where we need to start making the governments feel they can't feel like they have this much control over us. We need more people to be pushing back as much as they can, to demonstrate to the governments that they can't just keep ratcheting up these controls, because they're emboldened by this when they look out and they just make these orders and they see everybody comply. Even people that don't want to comply, comply just because they don't want to be hassled. [02:14:17] Lazy Ninja: It emboldens them for the next time. So I really think everybody should make an effort to not wear it. Now, when somebody tells me to wear my mask, most of the time, I don't make a scene. Like, so Costco is another place I go. They're sort of big on masks. If somebody tells me to put a mask on there, which they do often, I'll take a mask out, pull it up over my nose, and then as soon as that person walks away, I take it off again. [02:14:46] Lazy Ninja: Right, so one of those things. Like, I don't cause a scene with a specific person, right? Because it's their choice, right? They can just kick me out of the store if they want. But I'm trying to make an impression on all the other shoppers there. Hey, I want all the shoppers there to see this guy without a mask. Some of them will get pissed off and, you know, think I'm killing everybody. But there's a lot of other people, like you, Vlad, that, you know, are just wearing it because they don't want to be hassled. [02:15:13] Lazy Ninja: And it gives those people encouragement and pushes a few of them to also take those masks off and help stop this insanity. [02:15:27] Vlad Costea: I mean, I live in a country where there's a lot of police. And if you walk on the street, it's very likely that the police is going to see you and stop you and give you like a very expensive fine, which is worth like five monthly salaries worth. So we live under that kind of situation where you cave just because you don't want to get into trouble. [02:15:50] Lazy Ninja: I think you should push it as far as you can, though. Like, because how many police, like, let's say you have your little neck gaiter thing on, but have it on, but just have it, you know, on your chin, right? They're not going to, well, I don't know for you, maybe they will, you know. In that situation, they're going to be like, "Hey, just pull it up," right? Because if you're walking around no mask at all, they're going to get all fired up and go after you. [02:16:14] Lazy Ninja: But if it's just down, they may or may not say something. You know, you have to sort of find that minimum level that you can get away with. That, you know, maybe you have to... So I go to the gym, so my gym, they're sort of like my friend. They originally sent out emails against all this lockdowns and masks and stuff. But at the same time, when you're at the gym, they enforce it like a bunch of Nazis. Like, if you take it off for a second... [02:16:44] Lazy Ninja: They're on you telling you to put your mask on. It's insane. Pisses me off beyond nothing. But what I did is I switched to wearing a face shield. So a face shield is okay. So I look ridiculous at the gym, but it's another signal to everybody how ridiculous this whole situation is, because everybody knows a face shield doesn't do shit, right? I'm breathing the air, I'm coughing, everything I have is just going right out under my face shield. But everybody knows a face shield is okay, so they can't say anything to me. [02:17:23] Lazy Ninja: So I think in every situation you have to find what's the most you can do to try to put a thorn in the side of the people making these rules, right? I can't do the no-mask thing. I get kicked out of my gym. I'm not going to be able to work out anymore. You know, maybe I can find a new gym, but I'm just going to try to do as much as I can at the gym, give them a hard enough time as I can to just sort of make my point. [02:17:48] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and I very much respect you for that, and I appreciate that you're trying. I'm not going to ask you in which state you're doing this because it's irrelevant. We should all be doing this regardless. And thank you for giving us all an example and inspiration. Anyway, this has been excessively long for a podcast, but I'm surely glad that we talked and we had all of these conversations. [02:18:20] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, it was good talking to you, Vlad. [02:18:21] Vlad Costea: Okay, so maybe next year I can get you again and possibly talk about... Maybe if there is a new secure element that gets launched with the Trezor or something like that, we can talk about it. Maybe you can find some issues with that. [02:18:40] Lazy Ninja: Yeah, that is going to be super exciting. I'm actually really excited for that, to have such a deep level of documentation of the functionality of the Tropic Square device that's going to be coming out. It'll be really fun to investigate that further. [02:18:55] Vlad Costea: And by next year, we will also have a better understanding of how the Jade and the Passport work, because we have talked about them today, but we did not actually have an informed impression that's based on empirical experience and just meddling with them. And there's a lot of time for further hacks to happen. I'm counting on you to find more security issues. [02:19:20] Lazy Ninja: Pressure's on now. [02:19:22] Vlad Costea: Pressure's on. And I hope that next time we do the interview, we're not going to be mandated by the government to wear a mask while we do it in our own homes. [02:19:38] Lazy Ninja: I find it unlikely. I think we'll still be mandated to wear masks, but we could hope not. [02:19:44] Vlad Costea: Okay, Mr. Lazy Ninja. So thank you very much, and I very much appreciate this. [02:19:51] Lazy Ninja: Okay, good talking to you, Vlad. We'll see you, man. [02:19:53] Vlad Costea: Vaultoro has a 100% track record with fully audited and insured gold bullion that are secured in a top-tier, tax-free Swiss vaulting facility. It also features a generous affiliate program, OTC trading, physical delivery and pickup, or trade back to Bitcoin in seconds. Register for free and check out the ways in which you can trade hard money and preserve your wealth. And if you want to help this show, sign up using the vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover link that you can also find in the description. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice. [02:20:40] Vlad Costea: All trading involves risks, and you are responsible for your own decisions. Wasabi Wallet's innovative CoinJoins will make your bitcoins more fungible. So if you accumulate more than 0.1 BTC, you can mix it with other users to remove all traces about their whereabouts. So it's like putting multiple fingerprints on your dollar bills, and it becomes impossible to determine the last few owners of the money. Download Wasabi Wallet today and start coinjoining. ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio interview in English, recorded on 16 April 2021, with sponsor segments for Vaultoro and Wasabi Wallet read by Vlad (plus a short 'psst' ad voiceover) at the start, middle and end. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 10 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (189 chunks) and 27 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 2 of 2 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021", stray "Thank you." and "Episode:"; fixed Vaultoro, @FreedomIsntSafe, BitBox02, Coldcard Mk3, Blockstream Jade, SatoshiLabs, anti-klepto, Cobo Vault, Charles Guillemet, ATECC608A, single-sig/multisig, PINs, decentralized (per second ASR), Digi-Key; restored "one of my recommendations", "Yeah, we can talk about that"; moved "I know" to Lazy Ninja; Fixed Coldcard/BitBox/BitBox02/Mk2/Mk3/TrustFLEX/Vaultoro/HWWeatherman/Samourai/PIN/passphrase spellings; "seat"→seed, "site"→sight, "at storing"→it's storing, "doubt"→download, "he could recover"; removed hallucination "This is a video that was"; moved "I mean, it's part" and "Oh, just so you know, this" to Vlad with interpolated timestamps; labelled 00:15:14 continuation as Lazy Ninja; Fixed Stepan at Specter Desktop (from "Step in. at Spectre Desktop.com"), Luke Dashjr, RISC-V, Coldcard, Specter DIY, multisig/single-sig, seat→seed, "hardware wall"→wallet; "security by obscurity" kept; attributed unlabelled continuations to Lazy Ninja and the M1 question to Vlad; removed fillers/throat-clear; Split ad voiceover ("psst") from Lazy Ninja; fixed Vaultoro, Coldcard, Specter, Yeti Cold, multisig/single-sig (MalteSig, SignalSig), passphrase, NAND flash, burning, Chaumian eCash, sats; removed stray dots; moved "So, I will not criticize Yeti Cold for the CDs" to Vlad and "Oh, that's really" to Lazy Ninja; restored "you go bury it in the ground" from other engines; marked "North signatures" as [unclear: Schnorr]; Removed "Thank you for watching. See you next time. Bye." hallucination; fixed Samourai, nopara73, Max Hillebrand, chain analysis, JoinMarket, runs Tor, Vaultoro/vaultoro.com, MimbleWimble Coin, MicroStrategies, Coldcard, multisig, CoinJoin spellings, plush toy, "ever sell them", "beat them up"; moved "I mean, it's a" to Lazy Ninja, "I wish, you" to Vlad's turn per context, split out Lazy Ninja's "Yup" interjection in Vlad's Dojo turn; Restored "passphrase also on metal" and "are sort of the best" (ASR "Oh."); fixed CoinJoin, multisig, single-sig, Coldcard, PIN, "imminent theft", "hardware wallet", "people coming to your house", "seed plates"; Vlad's "Yeah, we all are" → "No, we all are" per second ASR; split a long monologue paragraph at 01:26:44; removed fillers and stutters; Restored all raw timestamps with explicit speaker labels; fixed @HodlWave (incl. "Hacking Hardware Wallets"/"HuddleWave" mishearings), Coldcard, BitBox, Tropic Square (was "Trappist Square"), Skyler, multisig, PIN; "love her to death", "stacked harder", "rather young son", "might have tweeted", "I think Zach Herbert", "qualities that are ideal"; removed fillers/stutters only, no hallucinations in this window; Kept all raw timestamps and replaced "(same speaker continues)" with speaker names; moved "Did you"/"Oh, you" across the 01:44:20/01:44:24 boundaries; normalized Coldcard/Mk3/Coinkite/BitBox02/benma/Saleem/Foundation Devices; "Okay"→"Hey" per Qwen; "twice as least"→"twice as little"; re