Title: S8 E7: Lixin Liu on the Cobo Vault Hardware Wallet Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Lixin Liu, Head of Hardware at Cobo and creator of the Cobo Vault air-gapped hardware wallet Published: 2021-04-23 Duration: 1:56:17 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2021-04-23_btctkvr_s8_e7_lixin_liu_on_cobo_vault_hardware_wallet.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2021-04-23_btctkvr_s8_e7_lixin_liu_on_cobo_vault_hardware_wallet.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:29] Ad voiceover: This episode is sponsored by Vaultoro. Keep on listening and you will find out more about how you can buy allocated gold when the Bitcoin bull run reaches its peak. This way you don't have to deal with infinitely inflationary fiat or banks that freeze your account. Also, note that trading involves risks and the information presented is not financial advice. This episode is also sponsored by Wasabi Wallet. Go to wasabiwallet.io, download Wasabi for your OS and significantly boost your network level and transaction privacy. [00:01:39] Vlad Costea: Hi there and welcome to Season 8, Episode 7 of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is Lixin Liu, who is the CEO of Cobo, a company that used to be very well known in China for manufacturing hardware wallets specifically for the needs of the miners in the area. And those were hardware wallets that were made very sturdy to withstand all of the natural hazards. But last year we have had a conversation on this podcast and he mentioned that he was ready to create a new unit that would fit the needs of the Westerners and become more of a commercial and more affordable product. It's called the Cobo Vault. Today it's out there, you can buy it, I think in two or three versions. There is a classic one, there's a Pro one, and there's also... [00:02:35] Vlad Costea: Another one that's more expensive. I guess Lixin can explain to us how that works. And I'm happy to have Lixin because it's an interesting product. If you go on the YouTube page of Bitcoin Takeover, you can find my unboxing of the hardware wallet. And let me just tell you, Lixin, that I think it has the best packaging I've ever seen of any hardware wallet. So many layers that you take out and they are tamper-proof and it just proves that you take this supply chain attack scenario very seriously. [00:03:05] Lixin Liu: [unclear: Thank you.] [00:03:12] Vlad Costea: Okay, that was a brief answer after my introduction. So what was the initial reception and feedback like after you released the Cobo Vault? [00:03:24] Lixin Liu: Okay, first I want to correct some tiny mistakes. I'm not the CEO of Cobo. Actually, Cobo is a, you can call Cobo as a full stack wallet company here in China. And we have centralized wallet and also the hardware wallet, Cobo Vault. And in Cobo, I'm the head of hardware in Cobo. So I'm leading the team to developing the hardware wallet and also introducing the hardware wallet to the community. So my title is not CEO, but the head of hardware. But it's okay. [00:04:03] Vlad Costea: But you're also the creator of the Cobo Vault, so the hardware wallet was your baby. [00:04:08] Lixin Liu: Yeah, that's true. That's true. That's true. Okay, back to your question. You asked what feedback we got from the community for the second generation, right? [00:04:20] Vlad Costea: Mm-hmm. [00:04:21] Lixin Liu: Okay, I think we've got some pretty good feedbacks. One thing I'm really proud of is that before we designed the second generation Cobo Vault, which is Cobo Vault Pro and Cobo Vault Essential, before we designed that, we had some, we call it design principles or design thinking in the product. For example, we think that user experience is part of the security. [00:04:58] Lixin Liu: Because human error is the biggest reason for Bitcoin loss. So we think that currently the hardware wallets on the market, they don't have really, they have tiny screens or tiny buttons, which is really bad for user experience. And with bad user experience, people will make human error to lose their Bitcoin. So the first thing in our design thinking was that we think it's really important to give people a big touchscreen, so that everything will be displayed very clearly. And also, because people are really used to their mobile phones, so they will get used to the touchscreens very easily. [00:05:45] Lixin Liu: That is a big aspect, big advantage of Cobo Vault. We designed it to avoid some, not attack surface, but to lower the possibility for human error. That's the first thing and we got really good feedback from the community. The second thing is we took the legacy of the first generation of Cobo Vault. We utilize the QR code to do unsigned and signed information transmission. [00:06:19] Lixin Liu: Basically, there are three advantages of the QR code interaction. The first thing is it's totally air-gapped, because you don't need to connect your hardware wallet into a laptop, which may have some malicious code or malicious software on it. That's the first thing. So the QR code creates the 100% air-gapping. It's safer. The second thing for QR code is, as it uses QR code to do the data transmission, so everything getting in and out of your hardware wallet is auditable, so you can use any third-party software wallet. [00:07:04] Lixin Liu: Not software wallet. Third-party QR code scanner to scan the QR codes to see what's information in there. So this kind of transparency gives people more confidence about, okay, there's no malicious code getting into the hardware wallet and also your private keys are not getting out of your hardware wallet. So the QR code brings transparency here and make everything auditable, verifiable. The third thing for QR code is, QR code is easier, is better, or it has better compatibility than the USB or Bluetooth connection. [00:07:53] Lixin Liu: Because you just need to scan with your camera, either it's camera on your mobile phone, the camera on Cobo Vault or the camera on your laptop. So it has much better compatibility than USB and Bluetooth. There are many errors if you connect your hardware through USB or Bluetooth to your laptop. That's the third thing. Yeah, that is mainly the biggest advantages of the Cobo Vault. So we designed it and the community accepted it. Another thing we got some really good feedback is about multi-signature. [00:08:33] Lixin Liu: We did some PSBT multi-signature with Coldcard. And also both Coldcard and Cobo Vault can take the record of other co-signers' xpub in the hardware wallet, so the hardware wallet can verify an unsigned multi-signature transaction is legit or not legit. So this is a big step. I think this is a big step for the security multisig setup. So I think for all this we designed before we launched the product and I think those stuff are all accepted by the community and we received some really good feedback from them. [00:09:20] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, and there's been a lot happening and I did notice and part of me feels bad because you sent me the hardware wallet about a week after it came out. [00:09:30] Lixin Liu: It's okay. [00:09:31] Vlad Costea: I think I was the first one to report that it comes out in the West. So I think I put out one of the first articles out there about the Cobo Vault. And I'm happy that you have had a degree of success and also you have received some acknowledgement for what the device can do in multisig setups and in compatibility with other devices that may have been more popular prior on Western markets. [00:10:03] Lixin Liu: Yes. [00:10:04] Vlad Costea: So what would you say is the target audience of the Cobo? Because it was rather obscure a year ago. Nobody had heard of it in, you know, Europe and America. [00:10:14] Lixin Liu: Yes. Actually, as I said in our last conversation last year, in the first place, we were designing hardware wallet mainly for miners in China. But after, and that was also a bear market, so when we were trying to explore the Chinese market, we feel that there are very few people in China, they do hodling. So most people in China, they just do trading and they put most of their bitcoins in exchanges. [00:10:56] Lixin Liu: And I have to say that Chinese community is less educated, like Western community. Very few people like you, like Vlad, like you, talking about security, talking about how to safely store your Bitcoin or how to safely store your recovery phrase, this kind of stuff. So very few Chinese people talking about that. So we feel it was really hard to sell people a hardware wallet here in China. It just feels like you are selling a pair of shoes to some people who never wear a pair of shoes. [00:11:39] Lixin Liu: So for the second generation, we did, in 2019, I went to Bitcoin 2019 conference in San Francisco and I met a lot of Western, a lot of US Bitcoiners there and I talked to them. I feel that we should pivot our targeted market from China to Western countries. And that's why for our second generation we started to talk to the community and listen to people's requirements and get their feedback to iterate our product. So this is mainly the change. I think it's basically because in China, people mostly do trading, but in the US and the European countries, a lot of people are hodling and take Bitcoin as a very serious investment or, yeah, very serious holding, I think. [00:12:41] Vlad Costea: Oh, I'm not sure if this is, you know, fair to say that we are a lot more educated, as maybe the sales for hardware wallets are a lot better in the West. But at the same time, I know a lot of people who don't really care about security and keep their coins on exchanges and only think in terms of how many dollars they can make. So to them, they're just stocks or something. They don't think in terms of financial sovereignty. They don't see the advantages. They just look at something like CoinMarketCap and see how much every coin has gone up in price. [00:13:21] Lixin Liu: Correct. Yeah. [00:13:22] Vlad Costea: So I suppose that also applies in the West, even though there are some exchanges, like the only one that I can think about right now is ShapeShift, which allows you to connect with your hardware wallet and be the owner of your own keys while you trade with them through an exchange. That's not the case with most of the exchanges and that's pretty terrible. But it's good to have this kind of security. [00:13:51] Vlad Costea: And I think that there is this sort of rejuvenating of purchases in hardware wallets for two reasons. First of all, there are more institutions that get in, and they don't like to keep their coins with custodians, so they set up multisigs most likely. And secondly, it's specifically multisigs that have become more popular. And the recommendation when you do multisigs with hardware wallets is to use different brands, so they have a different setup and user interface and everything. They just, I think it's harder for hackers to get into all of them. [00:14:34] Vlad Costea: I think that's the rationale. If they are all the same, you're a lot easier to hack and attack than using different brands of hardware wallets. And this gives consumers an incentive to buy one of each. [00:14:50] Lixin Liu: Yes. [00:14:51] Vlad Costea: So let me actually ask you a question because so far I have only made statements. [00:14:56] Lixin Liu: It's okay, yeah. [00:14:58] Vlad Costea: So how is the Cobo third-party wallet support? Do you know of any software wallets that work just as well as the official Cobo application or even extend the features? [00:15:16] Lixin Liu: Okay. Actually, thanks to PSBT, which is defined by BIP 174, we are compatible with all the PSBT software wallets. I think most of the users are using Cobo Vault with BlueWallet for single-sig, and also using Cobo Vault with Specter and also Sparrow for multi-signature. Some people are using Cobo Vault with Wasabi, but Wasabi doesn't support QR code scanning, so you have to use the microSD card to do, just like Coldcard, to use the microSD card to transit the unsigned and signed message between Wasabi and the Cobo Vault. [00:16:03] Lixin Liu: And also there are some very new software wallets rising in the market. I think, for example, Nunchuk. Nunchuk is also a multisig software wallet and we're also compatible with them. And also for other wallets, I'm not sure we should call it wallets, just like BTCPay Server. We're also compatible with BTCPay Server. So I think, thanks to, I think this is the best part of Bitcoin community. There are always some people there in Bitcoin community to set up standards like PSBT. So it's really easy for cooperation between hardware wallet and software wallet. Yeah, this is the thing. Yeah. [00:17:00] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so you have mentioned that you have PSBT and you have the camera for scanning QR codes and also an SD card slot. So why did you choose these ways of sending transactions? And I think at this point the hardware wallet market is getting very interesting as you have newcomers, new players like the Blockstream Jade and like the Passport devices, the Foundation Devices Passport, and they also choose different features. They also add a camera. They also have PSBT, I think. And what is it about these features that makes them more convenient or more secure? [00:17:41] Lixin Liu: I think because it's all about attack surface. I always say that to our user and also to the community that there is no absolute security, there is only relative security. So if we compare QR code to something like USB or Bluetooth, first, the QR code is not a continuous connectivity. So if you connect your hardware wallet to a laptop with USB or Bluetooth, the first thing is the information getting in and out of the device, you cannot see that. [00:18:23] Lixin Liu: You cannot verify that. We always say that "don't trust, verify," but you cannot verify, for a newbie user, you cannot easily verify what's getting in and out of your hardware wallet. But with something like QR code or microSD card, everything is clear. You can see everything. I think that's a huge difference. And also, just like I said, the USB or the Bluetooth are continuous connectivity, which brings a larger attack surface for hackers to hack your hardware wallet. But if we compare, I think, like Passport and the Cobo Vault, we both support microSD card and QR code. [00:19:13] Lixin Liu: Here the QR code is much more convenient than microSD card, but sometimes for the PSBT transactions, the unsigned or the signed messages are really huge. So then the QR code may need like tens of QR codes or even 100 QR codes to convey all the message. Then the QR code cannot fit into those scenarios, especially when you have a lot of UTXOs, and also you use PSBT, which will make the transaction bigger. So then we introduced the microSD card into these kind of scenarios. Yeah, and this is the security model and why we're using these two methods to do the data transmission. [00:20:07] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so I should correct myself in regards to the Jade, because while it has a camera to scan QR codes, it also uses Bluetooth and USB. [00:20:15] Lixin Liu: Yes. I think for Jade, they still need to update the firmware to get the camera running. If I recall correctly, currently you cannot use Jade with a camera. [00:20:30] Vlad Costea: I mean, you're lucky if you have one because they are very hard to find. Yeah. I wanted to get my hands on one to try it, but it's impossible. Was Cobo affected by this chip shortage? Like, can you find stocks of everything that you need to produce in order to ship the units? [00:20:57] Lixin Liu: Yes, yes. Actually, we are suffering from that. I think in last year our manufacturing lead time was about 45 to 60 days, and now the lead time becomes over 90 days. Right now, almost all the Cobo Vaults around all the warehouses around the world are sold out. We only have like tens of Cobo Vault Pro available in the US warehouse now. And we're doing manufacturing now and we're suffering a lot from that. Even though we're from China, we're also suffering from that. [00:21:39] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I've heard that every company except for Apple has issues with sourcing chips. [00:21:44] Lixin Liu: Yes, yes. And also the manufacturing cost. If we compare the manufacturing cost back to 2018, I think the manufacturing cost is three times more than the cost in 2018. You cannot imagine. Three times. Not 30%, but three times. [00:22:09] Vlad Costea: Does it have anything to do with the inflation that we have had? [00:22:13] Lixin Liu: Of course, definitely. Definitely. [00:22:18] Vlad Costea: Okay, because, you know, when you watch the news, people try to find all sorts of excuses, like they keep stuff for too long in docks and it takes a longer time for ships to arrive in certain docks. So that's why they're priced higher. I don't know if that makes any sense. It doesn't make much sense to me. You know, inflation is a better explanation, but they're looking into all sorts of excuses as to why prices have increased. [00:22:55] Lixin Liu: I think the price increase, for example, I'm not sure what's the situation there in your country. In China right now even the hard drives are becoming more and more expensive. And all of this because of the mining industry exploding. So I think mining industry is heavily impacted the normal electricity supply chain right now. [00:23:33] Vlad Costea: It's interesting how it's not much different from the West, where I don't think you can find a good video card nowadays, because miners have gotten a hold on the supply chains. And I personally happen to know a guy on Twitter and I make fun of him sometimes because he has the latest cards and the latest chips, and I'm like, "You know, because of you gamers cannot play the latest video games, because you scoop all of these video cards when they come out, use them for mining." [00:24:04] Lixin Liu: Yeah, the video cards are really expensive here in China right now. And even on the second-hand purchasing platforms, the second-hand video cards are even more expensive than the first hand, but the first hand is out of stock. [00:24:28] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so I have mentioned chips and you have also made comments about the expenses involved in making them. Cobo is one of the few companies, possibly the only one that I'm aware of in the hardware wallet market, that makes its own chips, both the microcontroller and the secure chip element. [00:24:50] Lixin Liu: Oh, so here I want to correct you a little bit. For the microcontroller, we're using a chip manufactured in Taiwan. We're not manufacturing that by ourselves. And for the secure element, we are writing the firmware of the secure element by ourselves. So we open source the firmware of the secure element, but we haven't manufactured the secure element itself. We're also sourcing from third-party companies for those secure elements. [00:25:23] Vlad Costea: I remember I was looking, I've actually opened GitHub right now. There was this schematic of... [00:25:30] Lixin Liu: Yeah, the schematic is the circuit design of the main board. It's not about the schematic of the secure element or the schematic of the microcontroller. It's different. [00:25:48] Vlad Costea: Okay. Because they are named something Cobo. So I assume that because their name is Cobo something, then they are made by your company. [00:26:00] Lixin Liu: No, no, no, it's not made by our company. We put the name as Cobo just as a placeholder, because if we disclose the manufacturer of the secure element or the microcontroller, then it will bring some attack surface for the product, because very, very hardcore hackers may do like some social engineering on the developers of the chips, this kind of thing. It's very low possibility, but to try to avoid that, we just replace the original manufacturer name into Cobo. But I just want to clarify, we're not making those chips. [00:26:42] Vlad Costea: Okay, I thought you were one of these companies that was building everything in-house. So I assume that there is no way to build your own Cobo Vault if you want to. [00:26:55] Lixin Liu: Nope. Currently, no. But that is also one goal that we're going to try to achieve in maybe 2021 or 2022. We're going to make our product more open source. And also we're going to make it possible for our users to build their own Cobo Vault by themselves, purchasing all the electricity components and everything on the electricity store or something. [00:27:33] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so I see that you have called the secure element the Cobo Vault secure element, just this. There is no other name for it. And that's why I assume that you are the manufacturer of the chip. [00:27:45] Lixin Liu: Sorry for the confusion. [00:27:50] Vlad Costea: It's fine. But I was thinking that everyone knows what Trezor has in it, and you can even build one for yourself. So I suppose... I don't know, I guess you will get there in 2021 or 2022 in terms of open sourcing. But that's kind of nice, you know, to be able to build your own. And I guess this goes back to what Coldcard has done in terms of licensing. Because we can argue that sometimes, so let's say that you're Trezor, the fact that you have KeepKey, which is a copy of it. I don't think KeepKey does anything new in terms of firmware. [00:28:33] Vlad Costea: It's kind of the same. It has the same components. It just has a nicer screen. But the fact that the KeepKey existed and it sold units made it solve some issues that maybe Trezor could not find by themselves. So there's this open source approach to improving security, which means that if somebody else takes your code and uses it and finds issues in it, they're going to fix it, and you're also going to benefit from their fix. This goes all the way back. And I was thinking, how can Cobo contribute to this ecosystem? [00:29:12] Lixin Liu: Contributing... Actually, we open source... The first thing we open source, the most important thing we open source, is the firmware of the secure element. So I think this is the first time for the community seeing some code in the secure element. This is the first thing we do for the community. And also we're closely talking to white hat hackers like Lazy Ninja, and also some other guys in the community to improve our code. And also, for example, last year there was an attack called fee attack, which means the software wallet can trigger the user to sign a single transaction twice, and then the user may send his transaction with a very high fee. So this is called fee attack. And we also proposed our solution to the fee attack, and at the end, both Coldcard and us were implementing some very similar solutions to avoid that fee attack. [00:30:36] Lixin Liu: So I think we are, to be very fair, we are closely working with the community to not only improve our code, but also trying to close some attack surface of other hardware wallets. [00:30:54] Ad voiceover: Vaultoro, and that's V-A-U-L-T, like a gold vault, and O-R-O, Oro, which is Spanish for gold, is a gold and Bitcoin exchange which offers instant swaps between hard money to over 31,000 customers from more than 95 countries. Vaultoro has offered Swiss privacy and security since 2015. Furthermore, the gold you purchase is your legal property, secured in your name, so even if something happens to Vaultoro, even liquidators could not touch your gold. If you want to become the custodian of your own gold bars, you can request to have them delivered to you, or simply trade them back to Bitcoin on the dip. [00:31:45] Ad voiceover: Register for free in only 30 seconds and start trading only with hard money. Please keep in mind that all trading involves risks. This is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions. When you are using Wasabi Wallet, your internet connection gets routed through the Tor network by default. This means that you get better privacy while using Bitcoin. Download it today at wasabiwallet.io. [00:32:21] Vlad Costea: That's fair. So I have asked Zach Herbert, who is designing... He doesn't call it a clone. He says it's more of a device that's inspired by the Coldcard. But anyway, he's doing the Passport. And I've asked him on a scale from 1 to 10 how open source is his device, and he said something like 8.5 or something. How would you rate the Cobo? Where is it at? [00:32:47] Lixin Liu: I think if we take some benchmark, so from 1 to 10, right? Yeah. I think if we take... Because I think everyone, even though Trezor, they are attacked by Kraken Security Labs and other labs, but we still cannot deny that Trezor is the most open source hardware wallet in the market now, and there is no secure element in Trezor. But for Trezor, there are still some unreleased code, which is done by the manufacturer of the chip or something like that. So I think if we take Trezor as score of 9, for Coldcard, I think it would be like 8 or 8.5. [00:33:36] Lixin Liu: I haven't dived into the Foundation Devices Passport, so I cannot have a score for that. But for Ledger, I think it would be around five, because Ledger only open source the apps on the hardware wallet, but nothing about the secure element and other stuff. For us, I think we cannot be as high as Trezor or Coldcard, but we are around maybe 7 or 7.5, and we're going to improve that. [00:34:11] Vlad Costea: Okay, I'm actually putting out an Excel file with ratings in terms of open sourcing and stuff like that. Maybe by the end of this season, I can put out a guide with pros and cons of every device. Hopefully, it will help someone decide what kind of hardware wallet they want. [00:34:29] Lixin Liu: Yeah, to be honest, we're not the most open source one. But what I can say is that we have open sourced everything we can open source. This is what we have done. And also we are the first hardware wallet that open sourced the firmware of the secure element, and also we're the first hardware wallet that opened the auditing report of the product. [00:34:58] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's actually interesting because yesterday I found a hardware wallet. I'm not sure if I should mention its name or something, but I called them out on Twitter because they are selling pre-order items. So they are selling them for like $400 or something. So I looked into their GitHub to figure out what kind of device it is, and they haven't published any line of code. [00:35:24] Lixin Liu: Okay. [00:35:25] Vlad Costea: And I thought it was interesting because they are targeting, you know, possibly they're a clone, because they have a very small team of three people and only one of them is a coder. So I don't think that they have revolutionized any kind of security. [00:35:45] Lixin Liu: Okay. Okay, set up. [00:35:47] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but at the same time they are targeting some shitcoins. Like, they know that those shitcoins are not going to get listed by Ledger or Trezor or some other big manufacturer. So they go to them and they're like, "How about we offer you this kind of support and you're going to give us money, possibly." Or you're going to make... Or you're going to endorse the product to your community, because that also happens. [00:36:13] Lixin Liu: Oh, really? [00:36:15] Vlad Costea: Okay, so yeah, if I see that... They become popular in this very small community and then they sell devices, even though maybe those people have no idea what to expect or what is actually the standard in the industry for security. And they only buy it because it supports their shitcoin that they're holding. And I think that it doesn't matter if they're not Bitcoiners. I think everyone deserves to be held accountable to the standards of this industry and open source the code to at least know what that is, what it's trying to do, to be sure that they're not trying to steal the coins of the users. [00:36:55] Lixin Liu: Yes, actually, I also received tons of requests to support the coins that are not listing on Ledger or Trezor. I'm receiving tons of requests like this, but not only am I a Bitcoiner, but also I'm a business owner. As a business owner, I still cannot agree with this kind of strategy. Because for hardware wallet, you always need to build trust with the community. And you have to do the... I always say that the biggest competency of the hardware wallet is time. [00:37:37] Lixin Liu: It's not your secure element. It's not your big screen or something. It's time. You've been in the industry for a long time and you've been talking to the community for a long time. You are doing something with a long-term mindset rather than doing something in a very short-term mindset. If you do shitcoins like that, maybe the project will fail in three months. So then, as a hardware wallet, you need to last very, very long and you need to put like three years at least, three years, six years or five years plan in your head, rather than supporting some projects or shitcoins that may only last for several months. [00:38:23] Lixin Liu: So, for me, I'm a Bitcoiner, I don't agree with that. Also, I'm a business owner, I cannot agree with that. [00:38:32] Vlad Costea: I don't know, people are trying to make money off of something. It's likely that they forked the code from some other device, they found some design that they could use for their purpose and put the code on it. They ordered the units and then they sell them. They brand them and they make a quick buck. I suppose that's how it works. [00:38:55] Lixin Liu: Yeah. I think they cannot... Their founders don't want to get on some podcast. They just want to hide behind the curtain and make money and run away. [00:39:08] Vlad Costea: It's not really like that. They actually have some endorsements from people on YouTube. [00:39:12] Lixin Liu: Oh, really? [00:39:13] Vlad Costea: Yeah. But I think that these are paid because most of them are. You know, there's that channel Altcoin Daily on YouTube. And someone who does daily, they are technical analysis videos. [00:39:27] Vlad Costea: So they get a lot of traction, but at the same time, I don't think any of the people who endorse them actually work in security, and there is no actual security audit because, you know, if you don't publish the code and you claim that it's under NDAs and stuff like that, at least you need to provide an audit by an institution or a third party of sorts that has an expertise in the field to prove to your users that you take security seriously. Otherwise, you know... [00:39:57] Vlad Costea: They try to act like they're Ledger and they're not allowed to disclose anything, but even Ledger, when they launched, if I recall correctly, and it was called BTChip, they still had a lot of documentation and they explained how it works and what it does. There was a lot of honesty back in the day and we should expect everyone to respect the same standards. [00:40:27] Lixin Liu: Yes, correct. [00:40:30] Vlad Costea: So what I'm about to ask you right now is, you have different versions of the Cobo Vault on your website. [00:40:35] Lixin Liu: Yes. [00:40:36] Vlad Costea: And maybe it can get confusing at some point in terms of choosing which one to buy. So what's the difference between the Cobo Vault Essential, the Cobo Vault Pro, and there's also the other one, which is 400 and something dollars? [00:40:55] Lixin Liu: Yeah. Actually, the most expensive one is Cobo Vault Ultimate. That is our first-generation Cobo Vault, and it is designed for the miners. Miners in China. As I explained in our last interview, the miners here in China, they all work in the most isolated places. And those places have very extreme weather. So the hardware wallet for them need to be not only security but also very robust. So that is the Cobo Vault Ultimate. And currently, we don't have any inventory for Cobo Vault Ultimate, but people are still asking for the most expensive one. [00:41:41] Lixin Liu: For Cobo Vault Pro and Cobo Vault Essential, those are our second generation Cobo Vault, which is our main product selling right now. But those two products are designed with different purposes or different scenarios. To be a little bit deeper, for Cobo Vault Pro, it's designed for people who use hardware wallet more frequently. And for Cobo Vault Essential, that is designed for hodlers who may touch their hardware wallet maybe once a month or once every other month, this kind of frequency. Based on the user scenario, we have this design difference. [00:42:35] Lixin Liu: Mainly there are three differences. The first one is the Cobo Vault Pro comes with a rechargeable battery. Because, by the way, both of them can support rechargeable lithium batteries and also AAA batteries. But if you are a low-frequency user of the hardware wallet, like you touch your hardware wallet every other month, then the rechargeable lithium battery will have corrosion and be failed easily, because lithium battery is designed that you should use it every week at least. So for Cobo Vault Essential, it doesn't have the rechargeable battery. [00:43:19] Lixin Liu: For Cobo Vault Pro, it comes with the rechargeable battery, and both of them have the AAA battery case. So even if you are a Cobo Vault Pro user and if your rechargeable battery fails, you can still use the AAA battery to turn on the device to move your Bitcoin. That's the first difference. The second difference is still based on the scenario. We think that for Cobo Vault Pro users, because they use Cobo Vault more frequently, so they may need to transfer their Bitcoin more frequently. So we designed a fingerprint sensor. [00:43:59] Lixin Liu: So it makes it a little bit easier for them to not type in a long password into the hardware wallet to authenticate the transaction. Cobo Vault Essential, because we designed it for people who are not using it very often, so we didn't have the fingerprint sensor on Cobo Vault Essential. That's the second difference. The third difference is that because we designed the Cobo Vault Pro for more frequent use, which means that you may use it in an airport or you may use it not in your office or at your home. [00:44:40] Lixin Liu: So there's a higher possibility that the Cobo Vault Pro, if you use it out of your office or out of your home, it will get stolen. So then we have the self-destruct mechanism introduced into the product, which is if a hacker stole your Cobo Vault Pro, and if they try to disassemble the device to perform a side-channel attack, then the self-destruct mechanism will be triggered, so your private keys and other sensitive information will be all erased from the device. So these are the main three differences. [00:45:22] Lixin Liu: The first is the rechargeable battery. The second is the fingerprint sensor. The third is the self-destruct mechanism. And both of them can use the same firmware, which means you can use exactly the same firmware either for Cobo Vault Pro or for the Essential. You can use the Bitcoin-only firmware and you can use all the software features. There are only like three hardware differences on these two devices, based on their design, the difference of the design for the user scenario. [00:45:57] Vlad Costea: So the one that you sent me and the one that I unboxed on video is the Pro version, because it has the separate battery. It has the fingerprint scanner. [00:46:07] Lixin Liu: Yeah, yeah, that's true. And we also got some complaints from the community that they told us that we should ask more people to do some reviews of the Cobo Vault Essential. [00:46:20] Vlad Costea: Oh, right. Yeah, it makes a lot of sense. I suppose people want to buy the more affordable one. [00:46:27] Lixin Liu: Yeah, especially for some people. Like, I also have some friends, when the bull market comes, they may not touch their hardware wallet, or they may not transfer their Bitcoin for like two years or even three years. For those people, something like if you use a Ledger Nano X, the built-in lithium battery will definitely fail. And we also take these kind of scenarios into consideration so that both Cobo Vault Pro and Cobo Vault Essential support AAA battery to turn on the device to move your Bitcoin. [00:47:09] Vlad Costea: Also, something that I want to ask you is, does the Cobo use code from the Android Open Source Project? Because the keyboard looks very familiar and feels just like an Android phone. And that's a pro, by the way, because I think I have had the fastest verification of the 24-word seed phrase on the Cobo. For example, if I use the Ledger, it would take me like 30 minutes to do that, because it's slow and you have to type every letter carefully, and it only has two buttons. But it was such a familiar interface. I did not have to get adjusted to learn something new. It felt like something that I do every day. [00:47:55] Lixin Liu: Yes. You're right, we also disclosed this information on our Twitter and also on GitHub, that we built the Cobo Vault based on Android system. So it's like Android system plus a secure element. And we did it on Android system... One big reason is that, you know, if we build something from scratch, which means there's no mature tooling or mature stuff for us to reuse, then it will take us maybe three years to launch the hardware wallet. So we mainly use Android. The first reason, I cannot deny that, is we wanted to launch the product quicker. [00:48:44] Lixin Liu: And also considering our open source level, and also we're using QR code to transmit all the sensitive info, we feel that Android is not a very huge disadvantage of the product right now, but we're also changing that. We're removing the Android layer to make it more open source, as I said previously. But also using Android brings some advantage. For example, if we use Android layer, then we don't need to reuse the code from Trezor. You know that if all the hardware wallets reuse the code from Trezor, which is a huge risk. [00:49:31] Lixin Liu: It's just like everyone's building a tower with the same base, which is really dangerous. If there's some risk in the base, then every tower will collapse. So that's one advantage we got from using Android. But as I said, we are also trying to make it more open source. We think open source is more important. So we're also removing Android layer. And maybe we'll launch that new product in late 2021 or 2022. [00:50:09] Vlad Costea: I look forward to it. [00:50:11] Ad voiceover: Hey, psst, hey! What's your plan for the next Bitcoin top? Unless you need the money to purchase something, you probably should not touch infinitely inflationary fiat. Check out Vaultoro and figure out to which extent hard money like gold and silver can help you preserve your purchasing power. You will be able to get back into Bitcoin as soon as the price hits a new bottom, and you will not be subjected to the arbitrary inflation-driven volatility of fiat or fiat-backed coins. Obviously, this is not financial advice, and you should understand that all trading involves risks. [00:51:00] Ad voiceover: Wasabi Wallet connects to your full Bitcoin node, and if you're not running one, it downloads block filters anonymously via Tor. In either case, you're getting excellent privacy. Download the software today at wasabiwallet.io. [00:51:14] Vlad Costea: So this is the part of the interview where I'm going to ask you to compare the Cobo Vault with other popular hardware wallets on the market. And everyone gets these questions. I feel like I have already asked them last time, but even though the questions might be the same today, I think that the answers have changed a bit, because there's a lot that has happened in this dynamic space of hardware wallets. So first of all, how does the Cobo compare to the Trezor Model T right now? And what do you think that the Trezor Model T does well, but the Cobo might do better? [00:52:02] Lixin Liu: I think I really respect Trezor guys. And I think Trezor T is the second best hardware wallet currently on the market for user experience. As I said previously, user experience is really, really important to lower the possibility of human error to protect people's Bitcoin. So that is part that I think Trezor T is doing very well. And also, one thing I really respect is, I really respect Trezor is that Trezor T has a huge improvement compared to the first generation of Trezor. But actually, to be very honest, I don't think Ledger Nano X has huge, huge improvements compared to Ledger Nano S. [00:52:58] Lixin Liu: So, I think, and also Trezor Model T has some improvements like you can type your passwords on the device itself rather than you... [00:53:08] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, that's the biggest feature. Yeah. [00:53:12] Lixin Liu: That's the biggest feature. But also I'm expecting more from Trezor T, Trezor Model T. For example, I'm expecting they can leverage the microSD card slot, so that if people want to do some 100% air-gapped signing, they can do with the microSD card. And also I'm expecting Trezor to do better on multi-signature. Currently, Trezor is stateless design, which means Trezor cannot store any information other than the private keys. So this opens some attack surface for multisig, because for multisig, it's better to store the xpub of other co-signers so that you can reconstruct the multi-signature on the device itself. [00:54:09] Lixin Liu: So that when the Trezor sees an unsigned multi-signature transaction, the Trezor can verify everything is legit. So this is what I'm expecting from Trezor. And also these are the advantages of Cobo Vault compared to Trezor, like the microSD card, air-gapping, and also multisig support. But I think Trezor Suite is doing great, very great. [00:54:38] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I also expect from them to improve their native wallet. I think they have made an important step with moving from the web wallet to Trezor Suite. But it still needs a lot of features to get added. And I've checked the roadmap. They even plan to add CoinJoins. And I hope that's going to happen sooner than later. [00:55:00] Lixin Liu: That would be really nice. [00:55:06] Vlad Costea: Okay, so I think you have mentioned very briefly the Ledger in terms of not improving much since the Nano S with the X. But what do you like about it? What do you think it does very well? And what does the Cobo do better? [00:55:23] Lixin Liu: I think Ledger is also... Even though Ledger doesn't improve too much from Ledger Nano S to Ledger Nano X, but I still think Ledger is a very respectful player in the market now. Especially the Ledger Donjon. I'm not sure you know their security lab, which is called Ledger Donjon. And Ledger Donjon has done a lot of very, very great experiments and explorations for improving the security of the whole industry. To be very honest, if we see Ledger Donjon is also a product of Ledger, and I love Ledger Donjon the most. [00:56:15] Vlad Costea: So what does the Cobo do better than Ledger? [00:56:18] Lixin Liu: I think our products are designed with different assumptions or with different design thinking. We think that user experience is important. We think that air-gapping is important. And we think compatibility is really important, and we think that transparency for the unsigned and signed messages is really important. I think you cannot say that it's better or something like that. We're just design products based on different assumptions. [00:56:54] Vlad Costea: Oh, but you can mention at least that you have a better typing experience. [00:56:58] Lixin Liu: Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah, definitely, definitely. [00:57:02] Vlad Costea: Actually, the whole UX, I prefer Cobo over Ledger. [00:57:06] Lixin Liu: Yeah, and also here one thing I think it's barely mentioned in the market, which is I don't think... I think a lot of devices, like your mobile phone, are using four digits or six digits PINs to protect your information. I think this should not be applied to hardware wallets, because if it's only like four digits or six digits PIN, it's really, it's much easier to brute force that PIN. So I think for every hardware wallet, it should allow something like 10 digits or 16 digits or even 24 digits. [00:57:50] Lixin Liu: Numbers plus characters plus symbols, to use that password, that PIN to protect your sensitive information. So if we take that into consideration, I think the experience of typing is really important. [00:58:08] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, I very much agree with that. But I suppose in the case of Cobo, you can even get away with drawing a pattern, just like on every Android device. When you unlock the screen, you can use one of these patterns and you can make them as complicated as you want. [00:58:27] Lixin Liu: Yes. [00:58:28] Vlad Costea: Most of the times hackers, when they try to get around that, they try the simplest ideas, like an L or something like that. [00:58:36] Lixin Liu: Yes. But one thing I want to mention here is that you cannot use that pattern to authenticate a transaction. You can use that pattern to unlock Cobo Vault to check out the addresses or something to receive Bitcoin. But if you wanted to send Bitcoin, to use Cobo Vault to sign a transaction, the signing cannot be authorized by the pattern lock. [00:59:06] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but in other devices, you cannot authorize transactions with the PIN either. So the PIN is just like an extra step to protect you from hackers. [00:59:16] Lixin Liu: Yeah. My point is that PIN is not strong enough, because it's really easy to get brute force attack. And for all the hardware wallets, they need complicated passwords. [00:59:33] Vlad Costea: So what about the BitBox02 and Foundation Devices Passport? Did you get to look into them? [00:59:42] Lixin Liu: For Foundation Passport, I'm not sure they have shipped or not. I think I checked that two weeks ago, I think. I only saw one review video on YouTube. I'm not sure I can say too much about that because it's still lack of information and I haven't put my hands on that yet. [01:00:12] Vlad Costea: And the BitBox02. [01:00:14] Lixin Liu: BitBox02. I think BitBox02, one product strategy I like the most is that they are offering a dedicated Bitcoin-only device, other than a multi-coin device. And right now, what we're doing is that we offer multi-coin firmware and also Bitcoin firmware. I think we should learn from them that maybe one day we should launch a dedicated Bitcoin-only device rather than ask our user to upgrade their multi-coin firmware into Bitcoin-only firmware. [01:00:59] Vlad Costea: I was about to ask you, does Cobo have a bounty program? So, for example, if I were to learn how to hack hardware wallets and I discovered something that's wrong in the software. [01:01:11] Lixin Liu: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Actually, I've been asked for that question for several times by some Twitter DMs with some white hat hackers. And currently we don't have that, but we're working on that. Hopefully we'll release that in June, or maybe in May, but I think the latest by June we'll release our bounty program. [01:01:39] Vlad Costea: I'm always happy when I get announcements. [01:01:42] Lixin Liu: Thank you. [01:01:45] Vlad Costea: So you said that you got your hands on the Blockstream Jade, or was that a wrong impression of mine? [01:01:53] Lixin Liu: Oh, no, I haven't got my hands on Blockstream Jade, because I'm waiting for their QR code scanning function. I think when they have... I'm not sure. To be very honest, I don't know what's the... I mean, I don't know how important Blockstream Jade is, how important it is in the whole strategy of Blockstream, because I'm also keeping an eye on the product and I didn't see they're very actively updating the firmware and everything else. I'm not sure they're... To be very honest, I think if you have a camera and when you release the product, it cannot scan the QR code, then it's a... [01:02:41] Lixin Liu: Semi-finished. It's a semi-finished product. I'm not sure why they release this product in such a status. I'm not sure about that. Maybe they're doing some tests for the market to see how many devices can be sold with the first batch or something. So I'm still waiting. I'm waiting for their QR code scanning function. [01:03:06] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I think their hardware wallet, the Jade, is more of an extension to the software wallet that they have had for years. It was called... [01:03:13] Lixin Liu: Yeah, Green Wallet. [01:03:15] Vlad Costea: GreenAddress first, and now it's Blockstream Green. [01:03:19] Lixin Liu: Yeah. And also, I think they're also trying to use the hardware wallet to promote the idea of their sidechain, I think. [01:03:33] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it can be useful for that because their wallet, Blockstream Green, is the one that you can use to store Liquid assets. [01:03:40] Lixin Liu: Yes. [01:03:41] Vlad Costea: So I suppose that's possibly the biggest draw about the Jade, something that it's exclusive to what they do. And I think the Jade is kind of like the Ledger Nano X, but without the secure element chip, because it has Bluetooth and I think it's kind of similar. That's the impression that I got from it. I didn't put my hands on it ever because it's so hard to find, but I checked the documentation and description. And it seems to me like they're trying to replicate the Ledger Nano X with the Bluetooth connection. [01:04:17] Lixin Liu: Yeah, and Jade has a really good price point. I think it's 49 or 39 bucks, I think. [01:04:27] Vlad Costea: I've also suspected them that they just picked some sort of device that's general purpose and they repurposed it with software for their wallet, because that would explain why they have so many... You know, they have the camera, they have the Bluetooth connection, they have USB. I'm not sure if they have an SD card. I don't recall that. [01:04:50] Lixin Liu: I don't think so. I don't think they have a microSD card slot. I'm not sure about that. According to my understanding, there are no existing device currently in the market that you can easily transformed into a hardware wallet. Yeah, I'm not sure about that. [01:05:15] Vlad Costea: I mean, you can get an Arduino board and turn it into a hardware wallet, or a Raspberry Pi. [01:05:21] Lixin Liu: Yeah, yeah, definitely. [01:05:24] Vlad Costea: So I think they got some of these stock units, because at that price point, $40, I don't think there was much hardware research and development. I think they went for something general purpose that they picked up on the market. [01:05:40] Lixin Liu: To be very honest, for Trezor and for, like for the Trezor One, I think for Trezor One, it's possible if you optimize your manufacturing very well, your supply chain very well, it's possible to sell Trezor One at the price of 39 bucks. It's possible, because I know this kind of shit about manufacturing and the supply chain. [01:06:12] Vlad Costea: Okay. So I hope that possibly, if it gets successful, it can bring the prices down, so we get a Trezor and a Ledger for cheaper. [01:06:23] Lixin Liu: Yeah, definitely, definitely. We're also trying to optimize... [01:06:25] Vlad Costea: I don't think the Ledger, because they're going to say that they have that secure chip, which is their main selling point. But Trezor One, for example, I think it can be more inexpensive. I think that the Trezor tax right now, so why it's more expensive than it should be, is because they were the ones that worked on the code and they spent a lot of time and money on research. [01:06:56] Lixin Liu: Yes, yes. [01:06:58] Vlad Costea: So that's their claim to actually overpricing a bit their devices. [01:07:03] Lixin Liu: Correct. [01:07:05] Vlad Costea: So what I was about to ask you next is that, you know, there are lots of hardware wallets that try to do something similar with the Cobo Vault, and some of them, I think they're called SafePal, and also... What's the other one? There's one that's called Ellipal. [01:07:28] Lixin Liu: Yeah, Ellipal, that's one. [01:07:31] Vlad Costea: Okay, Ellipal. I've seen it mentioned a few times. And they both try to be cold storage, air-gapped kind of electronic devices. I didn't get my hands on them. I almost got an Ellipal, but I could not buy it. I could not actually claim it because I had some shipping issues and they did not let me take it, which was weird. I think they destroyed it. [01:07:58] Lixin Liu: Okay, sorry, you were kind of broken. Would you repeat your question? [01:08:04] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I'm always broken, so... What's your take on stuff like SafePal and Ellipal and other cold storage electronic devices? [01:08:14] Lixin Liu: Okay. To be very honest, I still put most of my time into Ledger, Trezor, and Coldcard. I haven't put too much time on other hardware wallets. For SafePal, I looked into... I have a SafePal in my office and I looked into the product a bit. I feel, actually I feel really, really strange about the product, because they say that they are 100% air-gapped on their website, but it's very strange that it asks people to connect the SafePal to their laptop with the USB... Cable to do firmware upgrade. I just feel this is kind of strange or awkward. [01:09:08] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, that's why I asked, because you're going to call it strange and awkward. I'm gonna call it dishonest marketing. [01:09:15] Lixin Liu: Okay, okay, you're straightforward. [01:09:18] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so maybe that you as the representative of a company, you're trying to be nice and diplomatic, but I'm not going to be, because that device gets promoted by Binance and has possibly some partnerships going on. But at the same time, it's not honest about what it does. And that's a big problem. I appreciate when people are open. For example, you acknowledged, you said, "We are not entirely open source. We're trying to be more open source and disclose more about our code," which I think is fine. [01:09:49] Vlad Costea: You're honest about what you do. But when you say, "Oh yeah, this is an air-gapped device," but if you want to add more shitcoins to it or get some updates for security patches, connect it to your USB... [01:10:05] Lixin Liu: Yeah. That's really, yeah, you can see that's dishonest marketing. Yeah, but the first time I saw that, I feel really, really, really, really awkward. And for Ellipal, I think the first time I saw the Ledger Donjon report on Ellipal, I was really, really surprised that they also claim that they don't have Bluetooth, but Ledger Donjon disassembled the device and found a Bluetooth module on the device. I think that is ridiculous. That is, I call it dishonest marketing. For SafePal, it's kind of slippery. [01:10:54] Lixin Liu: I don't know how to say that's 100% dishonest, but for Ellipal, that's definitely dishonest, because you claim that you don't have a Bluetooth module and then a security lab disassembles your product and then they found a Bluetooth module on your device. That is unacceptable. [01:11:16] Vlad Costea: Oh, it's actually funny. I'm looking right now at the Ellipal report from the Ledger Donjon research department and they actually found that they have a Wi-Fi that can be activated. [01:11:31] Lixin Liu: Yes, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, they have everything. It's like... except that they don't use it, so... [01:11:36] Vlad Costea: Yeah. In their case, I think it applies much more that they just bought some sort of circuit, some board, and they purposed it for having a hardware wallet, and they sold it as such. Yeah, they didn't spend too much time removing possibly the components that could become attack vectors and were not planning to use. And the only argument, I'm looking at the Ellipal website right now, all that they're saying is that, you know, Ledger has looked at our old device, because we have Ellipal EC01 and the Ellipal Titan, and they're like, "With the Titan, it's impossible." [01:12:21] Lixin Liu: Yes. [01:12:24] Ad voiceover: Anyway, Vaultoro has a 100% track record with fully audited and insured gold bullion that are secured in a top-tier, tax-free Swiss vaulting facility. It also features a generous affiliate program, OTC trading, physical delivery and pickup, or trade back to Bitcoin in seconds. Register for free and check out the ways in which you can trade hard money and preserve your wealth. And if you want to help this show, sign up using the vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover link that you can also find in the description. [01:13:11] Ad voiceover: Keep in mind that this is not financial advice. All trading involves risks, and you are responsible for your own decisions. Wasabi Wallet's innovative CoinJoins will make your bitcoins more fungible. So if you accumulate more than 0.1 BTC, you can mix it with other users to remove all traces about their whereabouts. So it's like putting multiple fingerprints on your dollar bills, and it becomes impossible to determine the last few owners of the money. Download Wasabi Wallet today and start CoinJoining! [01:13:45] Vlad Costea: Let's move on. Something that I would like to mention at this point is that I find it interesting that you are the hardware wallet representative who is on best terms with NVK of Coldcard. Like, you guys seem to be friends. [01:14:07] Lixin Liu: Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's true. That's true. [01:14:11] Vlad Costea: And I don't think anyone else in this business can say the same. [01:14:18] Lixin Liu: Yeah, because, to be very honest, I don't see Coldcard, Trezor or Ledger as our quote-unquote competitor. Because we think that we're aligned together to be against the hackers to protect people's Bitcoin. And that's why I said that I'm expecting something from Trezor, I'm expecting they get improved. If I have the mindset that Trezor is my competitor, I won't say that. I will say that, okay, Trezor, you just stay the same status and never improve. That's the best situation for my product. [01:15:03] Lixin Liu: So my mindset is not that. My mindset is that we should stay together to build a defense line to defend against all the hackers. And that's why I really like the integration with Coldcard to do multisig, and we both keep each other's co-signers' xpub in the device so that we can fully verify whether the unsigned multisig transaction is legit or not. So yeah, I talked to NVK privately on Telegram about these kind of security thinkings, about helping each other to improve each other's product. Yeah, I think we're friends and we talk frequently. [01:15:55] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's interesting because you can also use the Cobo just like a Coldcard and use the SD card. And if I were to choose between the interfaces of the two, I would choose the Cobo because it's more familiar. It doesn't feel like it's an effort for me to use it. Whereas with a Coldcard, you need to have a learning curve. And if you don't use it for a few months and then grab it once again to, I don't know, play with it or something, it feels kind of strange and it's kind of laggy when you scroll. [01:16:29] Vlad Costea: You're never sure if you typed your PIN correctly, for example, because after you press the button, there's a delay. You have to wait like a second until you see the input on the screen. [01:16:42] Lixin Liu: Yes, yes. One feedback I got from my friend about Coldcard, I'm not sure he's a typical one, but he told me that if he doesn't touch his Coldcard for like one or two months, he may forget how to use it. He may spend some time to get familiar with it again and use Coldcard to transfer his Bitcoin. This is very interesting. [01:17:09] Vlad Costea: Well, I can confirm that. [01:17:10] Lixin Liu: Oh, really? [01:17:11] Vlad Costea: I haven't used it, so I think I dusted it off after a year or something. And it took me a long time to figure out, you know, to access a wallet, to recover and stuff like that. I mean, it was not as straightforward as I would have wanted. I've actually had to watch a YouTube video and look at the documentation to not do something wrong with it. Because it always feels like you can mess something up when you use it. At least that's my anxiety. [01:17:45] Lixin Liu: Yeah, that's also why we put user experience at the top of the important aspects of a hardware wallet. Because you should not make people anxious about using the product. Then the people will make mistakes, which is really dangerous. So again, I think user experience is very important, and I'm also sure that NVK is improving Coldcard user experience. But as you know, the COVID is slowing everything down. So I'm not sure they can release a new product in the near future, but I really expect them to improve the user experience. [01:18:33] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I mean, I suppose if NVK was to listen to what I said earlier, he would tell me that possibly if I have this kind of complaint, I'm not part of the target audience for the Coldcard and I'm not technical enough. Which I guess is fair. But, you know, I just wish it was a little friendlier. [01:18:56] Lixin Liu: Yeah, yeah, definitely. Again, I think Trezor T, if we don't take Cobo Vault into consideration, Trezor T is the most user-friendly hardware wallet currently. [01:19:11] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and it's only because they have the kind of interface that you have used before and use every day of your life on a mobile phone. [01:19:18] Lixin Liu: Yes, yes, that's true. [01:19:21] Vlad Costea: So you don't have to think about it. You grab it and you use it. [01:19:25] Lixin Liu: Yeah, yeah, people are familiar with touchscreens. [01:19:29] Vlad Costea: Also with buttons, if it's well done. [01:19:31] Lixin Liu: Yeah. Correct. [01:19:33] Vlad Costea: So, something, I'm not sure if this is on the list of questions that I sent you, but I have made a claim when unboxing and reviewing the Cobo Vault. There is that step where, first of all, let me describe what's happening there. You have your device in the box. First of all, you have a layer of plastic that you remove. And then you have a layer of carton that has a seal on both sides. And after you remove that carton seal, it can no longer be put back like before. [01:20:10] Vlad Costea: And then you have two different boxes inside. One contains the device and the other one contains the accessories. The one containing the device also has a seal on it. And after you remove it, you remove the sticker. It says something else on the backside of the sticker, like tampered or something like that, or void. I think that's the word that's on it. [01:20:32] Lixin Liu: Void, void, void, yeah. [01:20:34] Vlad Costea: It says void, so you know that after that step, someone has messed with your device if it says void. And after you open it, you still have a sticker on your screen. So unless you remove this sticker, you're not going to be able to use it or see what's on the screen. And that's an extra layer of security. And after that, even after you boot it up, you have to log on the Cobo website and scan a QR code. And that's a way of verifying that the device was not registered before. [01:21:06] Lixin Liu: Actually, that's not to verify the product is not registered. That's verifying that the secure element is working properly. Because at the back end of the website is Amazon's cloud HSM, which is their cloud hardware security module. You can take that as a server-style secure element on the cloud of Amazon. So the backend of the website is the Amazon service. And we have preloaded private keys and public keys in the secure element of the Cobo Vault and also into the Amazon's web cloud HSM service. [01:21:57] Lixin Liu: HSM stands for Hardware Security Module. And when you scan the QR code, it's doing two times of cryptographic calculation. And then you see something on your device, you type that thing into the website, and the website will verify that with the HSM, so that to make sure that your secure element is working properly. Because, for example, if people do a supply chain attack, they will send you a device that looks exactly the same like Cobo Vault, but doesn't have the secure element. And then you will use that device to generate your recovery phrase, and then the recovery phrase is not fully randomized, which is really dangerous. To avoid this kind of supply chain attack, we use this mechanism to make sure that the secure element in your device is working properly. [01:22:59] Vlad Costea: Okay, so Cobo will not get any kind of information that the device has been activated. [01:23:05] Lixin Liu: No, it's not activating. That is not activating. [01:23:10] Vlad Costea: Okay, this was a useful clarification, as I might have misunderstood what that step does when you scan a QR code on your computer screen with the camera. [01:23:19] Lixin Liu: Yeah, that is for preventing supply chain attacks. [01:23:28] Vlad Costea: Okay, and also you corrected me when I assumed that when you first install the Cobo mobile application on your phone, and you scan a QR code, that's the public key that's going to be read by your Cobo Vault. So it's not getting your xpub. [01:23:48] Lixin Liu: Yes, actually the xpub is getting from your Cobo Vault to your Cobo Vault companion app. But the xpub is not in our server. So the xpub is getting into the app so that you can use the app to generate a new address without the Cobo Vault. That's why we put the xpub into the app. But we didn't transfer the xpub into our backend server. We only transfer the fingerprint of the wallet into our backend server and use that fingerprint as an identifier of your wallet, rather than other wallet companies, which mostly use the xpub as the backend identifier of your wallet. [01:24:40] Lixin Liu: So the dangerous part of knowing your xpub is that even though one day you don't use the Cobo Vault companion app, you use other third-party apps, if we have your xpub in our server, we will actually know all your Bitcoin addresses. So if you change the recovery phrase and transfer the Bitcoin into the new wallet, it's okay. If you are still using the old wallet, then if we have the xpub, we will know all your addresses and all your transactions. That's really dangerous. So we didn't do that. So we only put the fingerprint of the wallet into our server. [01:25:31] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's useful to know, and I was once again wrong with my assumption that you get the xpub. [01:25:38] Lixin Liu: It's okay, it's okay. I think it's also complicated and different hardware wallets, they took different implementations. It's okay. [01:25:48] Vlad Costea: Right, something else that I noticed about the Cobo Vault is that it's the second hardware wallet device on the market to add Shamir backups and also have multisig support. And the only other device that does this is the Trezor Model T. [01:26:04] Lixin Liu: Yes. [01:26:05] Vlad Costea: So what do you think about Shamir backups and how would you compare them to multisigs? [01:26:13] Lixin Liu: I think these two features, they are not like competing with each other, but they are enhancing security with each other. I don't see any conflicts between Shamir backup and multi-signature. I think you can use either of them or you can use both of them simultaneously. For example, we wrote an article about why we think that the Shamir backup is really important. Because before the Shamir backup, most people, they just simply replicate their recovery phrase and put in different places. [01:26:56] Lixin Liu: This is also dangerous because this avoids the possibility that, for example, if you have only one single copy of your recovery phrase and then your house get collapsed or your house get flooded and the recovery phrase got damaged. [01:27:16] Lixin Liu: So if you replicate them and put into different geographic places, that only lower the possibility for the recovery phrase got destroyed by natural disasters. But that also increased the possibility that your recovery phrase will get stolen. That's really simple, right? Have one place, put one recovery phrase. Then you replicate them and put into five different places. The possibility of getting stolen is increased. So actually, personally, I don't quite agree with the solution that replicate your recovery phrase and put it into different locations. But I do agree with the Shamir backup, which means if you put... [01:28:08] Lixin Liu: Your recovery phrase in New York and then it's stolen, and then your Bitcoin is still safe. And another thing I really, really like about Shamir backup is that by the SLIP-39 implementation, there are two kinds of Shamir backup you can choose, which is 20 words version and 33 words version. I usually recommend our users to use the 20 words implementation because if, like, if you build a 3 of 5 Shamir backup, you have five sets of recovery phrase with 20 words. [01:28:56] Lixin Liu: And what you can do is that you can extend those 20 words into a 24 words available recovery phrase. And you can put some small Bitcoin into that 24 words recovery phrase. And then, for example, you can put this 24 recovery phrase in your friend's place. And if he open your, like, metal storage and check out the recovery phrase of 24 words, he may move the 24 words recovery phrase. So it's like a honeypot. You can turn one piece of the Shamir backup into a honeypot. [01:29:36] Lixin Liu: To make sure that your set is not tampered or is not recovered by someone else. And when you got all the Shamir backups by yourself, you always know that I only choose the first 20 words and put them into a Cobo Vault or a Trezor T to turn that into a valid wallet, which put most of your Bitcoin in it. I'm not sure I'm explaining myself very well. [01:30:07] Vlad Costea: No, it's fine. Just in case you're listening to this and you have no idea what a Shamir backup is, it's basically a way of taking your 12 or 24 word seed phrase and splitting it in as many parts as you want. So instead of having just one sequence of words which helps you recover the wallet, which can be a security threat depending on where you are and what you do, you can have, I think, up to 20 on the Trezor Model T. I'm not sure what the limit is on the Cobo. [01:30:42] Lixin Liu: Yeah, we're the same implementation as Trezor. So we... [01:30:46] Vlad Costea: Okay, so you can have... [01:30:47] Lixin Liu: Yeah. [01:30:49] Vlad Costea: You can have up to 20 parts that you create. And let's say that you do a setup of three out of five. I think that's the most common one. So you create five parts of your private key. And in order to recover your wallet, you're going to need to input three of these five parts. So even if you lose two of them, you can still recover your funds. This helps you, I think, with some sort of geographic distribution, if you want to take your parts in different places, like in the cartoons Dragon Ball Z or something. [01:31:24] Vlad Costea: So you source them. But at the same time, it can also be dangerous if you lose too many parts. So you need to be cautious. Maybe that you can keep in your house one or two of them and have, let's say that you have a five of seven or something, and you need five to recover your funds. Maybe that you can keep three in your house and put two others in different places, if you're into that. The idea is to make it as hard as possible to lose your coins. [01:31:58] Vlad Costea: So you have to figure out if you need that kind of setup. And it's only available, surprisingly, in the Trezor Model T and in the Cobo Vault. It makes you wonder why other hardware wallet manufacturers don't really use this. [01:32:16] Lixin Liu: I heard that Coldcard is going to implement Shamir backup in the near future. But I think they won't implement the SLIP-39. [01:32:31] Vlad Costea: They won't implement it. [01:32:33] Lixin Liu: They won't. They will have another standard, I think. [01:32:36] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, makes a lot of sense because they kind of hate Trezor and they try to change their code base to not include anything from them. [01:32:45] Lixin Liu: Yeah, by the way, I haven't confirmed this message with NVK. I just heard from someone else. I'm not sure. I also don't know the ETA of that feature or something. I just heard that they are going to implement that and I haven't confirmed with NVK. [01:33:03] Vlad Costea: Yeah, don't worry about it. It's not like anyone will take it as some sort of announcement. But you know, it's still strange that Ledger, for example, for all of their focus on security, they only rely on their chip and they say it's enough for everyone. It can be simple if you think about it. It can be simple for people to just have the 24 words and that's it. They rely on the security of the chip. But I guess if you want more, you go for the Trezor Model T or the Cobo Vault. Because on top of this Shamir's secret sharing, you can also do a multisig, so it gets a lot more complicated. [01:33:44] Lixin Liu: Yeah. [01:33:45] Vlad Costea: You can have like Shamir backups of every signature in a multisig setup. [01:33:50] Lixin Liu: Yes. [01:33:51] Vlad Costea: And that's kind of mind-blowingly complex. I don't recommend you to do that with your money because you're gonna end up having a hard time figuring out what you're supposed to do. [01:34:01] Lixin Liu: Yeah. [01:34:02] Vlad Costea: But it's possible. [01:34:06] Lixin Liu: Yeah, actually, I always tell our users that don't make it overcomplicated. Don't shoot yourself. If you make everything too complicated, you may mess the whole thing up. Just pick some solution that is suitable for yourself, that you can manage, some solution that you can manage. [01:34:32] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and you know, I tell people to start small. Like sometimes, even if they need to move a small amount of coins, or I tell them not to move anything at all. If you bought your hardware wallet to move your coins from the exchange, maybe you can keep them for a couple more weeks on the exchange until you get familiar with the device and you set up your first wallet, and you figure out the interface and you understand how it works. And you start using it after you feel comfortable with the interface. [01:35:06] Lixin Liu: Yes, correct. [01:35:08] Vlad Costea: But then again, this is in Cobo's advantage because you have kind of the most familiar interface of all other hardware wallets, as it's based on Android, so... [01:35:18] Lixin Liu: Yes, yes. [01:35:19] Vlad Costea: Billions of users use something similar every day. [01:35:24] Lixin Liu: Yes, yes. Again, if we think that maybe one day billions of people will start using Bitcoin, as a hardware wallet, we have to take human error in, and not only human error, but also user experience into consideration. [01:35:46] Vlad Costea: I also want to ask you something about all of these people on Twitter who spend all day scaring people away from buying hardware wallets, and they say they should not, because they're going to end up on some list that's made by the hardware wallet company. [01:36:02] Vlad Costea: They present the issue of Ledger and their security with the marketing database, which I guess is going to be the next topic, but let's forget about this for now. So you have JW Weatherman, who's going to tell you that you should do a multisig on your own computer, which is general purpose. Nobody knows that you're using it for Bitcoin and stuff like that. I've had people like Lazy Ninja explain that there's a greater attack surface on general-purpose hardware that's more complex and has more... [01:36:38] Vlad Costea: Issues that you don't really understand, and having a device that only does one task and is very simple and basic in its design can actually help you improve your security. So why do you think that people should still use hardware wallets? [01:36:56] Lixin Liu: Because actually, I think the solution like Yeticold, it's not a bad solution. I always say that there's no bad solution on this planet. There's only solution that is whether it's suitable for you. So one thing I find really terrifying is that once I enter a... What's the app called? Chat room, classroom, sorry. [01:37:30] Vlad Costea: Oh, okay. Clubhouse. [01:37:32] Lixin Liu: Clubhouse. Yeah, once I enter a Clubhouse chatting room held by JW, and he was answering a lot of questions about setting up a multisig by general-purpose computer for some noobs. Because I can tell that from the questions that those are purely noobs. And if you are recommending the Yeticold solution to some hardcore Bitcoiners with tech background, I think it's okay. It's okay for them to use that, and I'm kind of sure they won't shoot themselves. [01:38:12] Lixin Liu: But if you're recommending that complicated solution to noobs, I think that's really terrifying because, as I said, we have to take user experience into consideration. So if your solution is too complicated to, for example, you need like two hours to set it up, or you need to buy two laptops and you need all the command line tools to activate the multisig, that's really, really dangerous for a noob. And also, as your solution is hard to set up, there are also other possibilities that they will get stuck in the middle way. [01:39:01] Lixin Liu: And if you offer a solution, and I'm quite sure that JW doesn't have too much time to do customer service to help people out if they get stuck in the middle. Again, I think it's not a solution for average users, but if you are a hardcore Bitcoiner with tech background, maybe you can try it, and maybe you can use it as an enhancement for the current multi-signature setup. It's okay. [01:39:37] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I mean, I have had this debate before, and it all comes down to the fact that the only trade-off is that you order a device from a company and you're going to end up on a list, and there are going to be third parties. So even if your marketing database is perfect and there is not going to be any kind of leak ever, there are still people who deliver and keep some sort of records of what they delivered, where they got it from, and where they shipped it. [01:40:09] Vlad Costea: And that can be a point of failure, I guess. And they're going to know that you have ordered some Bitcoin-specific hardware, so they should assume that you are into Bitcoin, so that can turn you into a target, possibly. But I like to think that if more people start ordering hardware wallets and it becomes the norm rather than the exception, then this might go away and it might be less of a threat. I don't know how you regard it. [01:40:47] Lixin Liu: Sorry, I didn't hear you clearly. Would you repeat your question? [01:40:51] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so what's your take on this situation? [01:40:56] Lixin Liu: Sorry, what situation? I'm sorry. [01:41:00] Vlad Costea: The one about this. [01:41:03] Lixin Liu: I'm very sorry. [01:41:04] Vlad Costea: I guess we have different internet connections and stuff. But so I came from this conclusion that there's a trade-off when you buy hardware wallets, and it's about having your shipping information stored somewhere, and it doesn't necessarily have to be the manufacturer of the device, but also the people who ship the device to you. [01:41:28] Lixin Liu: Yes. [01:41:29] Vlad Costea: So is there any way to mitigate this, or do you think that we should normalize it and make more people order hardware wallets until the point where it's so... Basic that nobody cares anymore. [01:41:43] Lixin Liu: Ah, I see your point. I think first, I think every hardware wallet vendor should have their data retention policy. For example, for us, we delete all the shipping information that is older than six months. And we set the period at six months because it's usually a period of time that people may raise some dispute or a chargeback from the credit card company. So it's usually the max time for these credit card companies are like six months. So we set the time at six months to delete all the information. And we also ask our logistics vendor to delete all the information within... [01:42:31] Lixin Liu: 120 days. And also we offer another solution for users that if you have received the Cobo Vault and you don't have any dispute or you don't have any chargeback requests for us, then you can send us an email and give us your order number, and then we will delete your information immediately. So this is our data retention policy, and I think Trezor and Coldcard are both implementing this policy, similar policies. I think this is the first thing that hardware wallet companies should do. [01:43:12] Lixin Liu: The second thing I think hardware wallet companies do is enhancing the supply chain attack protections, like what we have used for web authentication. And then I think if hardware wallet company has enhanced the protection for supply chain attack, then it's possible to sell hardware wallet offline. For example, in some... maybe in Best Buy or something, some big stores like that. But one thing must be fulfilled is that the hardware wallet company should have strong protections against supply chain attacks. [01:44:00] Lixin Liu: Otherwise, you cannot sell it in Walmart or Best Buy. And in those, if everything's okay, the supply chain attack is prevented, and then people can buy those hardware wallets offline with cash. That's also another solution. And also another solution is just like you said, I think with more and more people ordering hardware wallets, then it's very hard to find who is the whale user or something. [01:44:35] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I think in Ledger's case, because I suppose they are the ones that made us more aware of this risk. Their biggest problem is that they do business in France, and France has stricter policies in regards to data retention. They have to store data for a longer time. They have had terrorist attacks and stuff like that. [01:44:57] Lixin Liu: Yeah, I have checked their... I don't remember, it's the privacy policy or their sales terms. They need to keep the information for 10 years. [01:45:09] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and that's why Trezor, which is in the Czech Republic, has a different policy and can actually encrypt and delete your data on request. And after a while, I think they delete it by themselves. And you also delete after six months, as you said. [01:45:24] Lixin Liu: Yes. [01:45:26] Vlad Costea: So it's good to consider this kind of situation. But in regards to what you mentioned before with hardware wallets possibly getting sold in physical stores like Best Buy, I think we need to educate these stores in regards to returns, because there might be people who buy the hardware wallet, they compromise it and they return it, they claim it's broken. [01:45:53] Vlad Costea: And sometimes these companies don't really care and they sell it once again, even though they get a report that it's broken. I've had this issue with buying refurbished items that are actually in a very terrible condition, so they should not be sold at all, but somehow they didn't care and they put them out for sale after someone returned them. [01:46:16] Lixin Liu: Correct. Correct. [01:46:18] Vlad Costea: So I think that's the biggest issue, and there are even national laws in lots of countries, consumer rights, that oblige you to accept, to return the money to the customer. So if the device can no longer be sold, then that's kind of a business risk that you're taking when you promote this model where every device should only be used once and only... actually not once, but only by one user. [01:46:49] Lixin Liu: Yes. I think the education is not only for the users, but also for other players like reseller or distributor or even the logistics vendors, I think. [01:47:06] Vlad Costea: Yeah, there's a lot of work that needs to be done. And right now, I think the best way to buy a hardware wallet is to order it directly from the manufacturer. It's not very convenient because most of the times you pay for the shipping and it's not cheap, you know. [01:47:20] Lixin Liu: Yes. [01:47:22] Vlad Costea: There are only like four or five countries in the world where they make hardware wallets, actually good ones, because you can find clones all over the place. But if you want to get a good one, you have to rely on France or on Czech Republic or on China or on Canada or Switzerland. These are the five countries that I would say manufacture decent products that are worth your money and worth of your consideration. Yeah, so it's not very convenient. You could get a physical store where you can buy, but it's not as secure at this point. [01:48:01] Lixin Liu: Yeah, actually, one thing just came into my mind. If we imagine that with more and more people adopting Bitcoin and everyone's owning Bitcoin... Right now, the Bitcoin conference, I mean, Bitcoin 2019, 2020, and this year the Bitcoin conference will happen in Miami. Imagine that we have a world tour of this kind of Bitcoin conference, and we pick one big city every month and go there to meet people there and to talk to the Bitcoiners there. And also hardware wallet manufacturers like us will go to the conference and sell our product directly to the end user with cash. [01:48:44] Lixin Liu: I think that is the safest way to buy hardware wallet. And maybe the coronavirus is over and maybe Bitcoin goes to 100K US dollars price, and more and more people adopting it. Maybe we can have this kind of thing happen. [01:49:05] Vlad Costea: Oh yes, you know, I can only hope that it's going to be over and we're going to have conferences like in 2019. Yeah, actually in 2018 and 2019, I picked up hardware wallets at conferences because they had booths where you could go. So I picked up my Ledger Nano S and my BitBox02 from conferences. [01:49:33] Lixin Liu: Mm-hmm. [01:49:35] Vlad Costea: So that's useful when you can do it. [01:49:37] Lixin Liu: Yes, yes. But one thing I should remind you, that if you receive a free hardware wallet from someone, you should be careful with that. [01:49:46] Vlad Costea: Oh, not necessarily when you mean like a review unit like the one you sent to me, but regular people when they get a free hardware wallet from someone, like a giveaway or a friend who says, "Oh, so I heard you started buying Bitcoin. Why don't you use this one? It will improve your security." [01:50:06] Lixin Liu: Yes, that's kind of dangerous. [01:50:10] Vlad Costea: I can tell you that when I was like 14, I had a friend who came to my house and we were playing an MMO, one of these online RPGs like World of Warcraft or something, and he installed a keylogger in my computer when I was away. [01:50:28] Lixin Liu: Oh, really? [01:50:29] Vlad Costea: And he stole my items. [01:50:32] Lixin Liu: That's terrible. [01:50:33] Vlad Costea: So I've learned my lesson there. [01:50:35] Lixin Liu: Okay, it's evil maid attack. [01:50:39] Vlad Costea: Exactly, it was someone I trusted and he came into my house and was like, "Oh, why don't I steal this guy's items in-game?" [01:50:46] Lixin Liu: Okay. Okay. [01:50:48] Vlad Costea: And it sucked. And I've learned my lesson there. Like, you should not trust anyone, even if they're your best friends. If they have the right incentive, they're going to steal from you. It's not like everyone is as nice as they claim or they're going to be always nice, even if you know them for years. [01:51:06] Lixin Liu: Yeah, if you're dealing with your Bitcoin, you should be really paranoid. You'd better be very paranoid. [01:51:18] Vlad Costea: Right, so I'm not sure if I have any more questions except for what's next for Cobo? What do you think is going to get launched or published in the next months? [01:51:30] Lixin Liu: Okay. Yeah, I think we're going to have a very exciting Q2 and Q3. Right now we are integrating with Caravan, and also we're integrating with Casa. And also we have hired more developers, so we're working on a more open source, dedicated Bitcoin-only device, which removes the Android layer and is more open source, and also takes other legacies from our current devices, like QR code scanning, microSD card, PSBT compatibility. Yeah, and also big touch screen, this kind of thing. Yeah. So this is something. So I think for the integration with Caravan and Casa, it will happen around... [01:52:25] Lixin Liu: Q3 by latest. And also Q4 or early next year, we may release the dedicated Bitcoin-only device. And also we are keeping an eye on Taproot. So once Taproot is ready, we will implement that, maybe, I think, earlier than other hardware wallets. [01:52:50] Vlad Costea: That sounds very ambitious. So I'm happy that you have so much going on. [01:52:55] Lixin Liu: Yeah, yeah, we have a lot of good stuff going on. [01:53:00] Vlad Costea: Okay, so thank you very much, Lixin. I'm glad that we talked once again. And I'm glad that since last year there was so much to talk about, like so much has happened. We didn't even get into multisigs and that's a huge rabbit hole. [01:53:15] Lixin Liu: Yeah, 2020 is the year of multisig. I'm really glad that we're part of that. [01:53:24] Vlad Costea: So I really look forward to doing a similar interview next year and possibly finding out what you have been up to and stuff like what's new in the security market. I feel like it's kind of very experimental yet, even though it's sturdy and secure for your funds. There is a lot of stuff that's still being brought into the space, and there are lots of new ideas that come every year. [01:53:53] Vlad Costea: And all of this benefits our security and makes every device... even if somebody launches something new and it's exclusive to their device, being open source or at least allowing everyone to get inspired from it means that everyone else's security is going to get better. And when somebody like a white hat hacker, like Lazy Ninja, finds something like a big issue in a device, everyone is going to pay attention, and they're going to fix it to make sure that it will not be the case with their device. So I'm very happy that I get to interview people from this space. It's very exciting. It's a huge and monumental rabbit hole to get into. And I very much appreciate your time and explaining what the Cobo does. [01:54:46] Vlad Costea: And I like your work with the Cobo, so keep it up. [01:54:49] Lixin Liu: Thank you. Thank you so much. Thank you for your time. [01:54:52] Ad voiceover: Vaultoro has a 100% track record with fully audited and insured gold bullion that are secured in a top-tier, tax-free Swiss vaulting facility. It also features a generous affiliate program, OTC trading, physical delivery and pickup, or trade back to Bitcoin in seconds. Register for free and check out the ways in which you can trade hard money and preserve your wealth. And if you want to help this show, sign up using the vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover link that you can also find in the description. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice. [01:55:39] Ad voiceover: All trading involves risks, and you are responsible for your own decisions. Wasabi Wallet's innovative CoinJoins will make your bitcoins more fungible. So if you accumulate more than 0.1 BTC, you can mix it with other users to remove all traces about their whereabouts. So it's like putting multiple fingerprints on your dollar bills, and it becomes impossible to determine the last few owners of the money. Download Wasabi Wallet today and start CoinJoining! ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio/video interview in English (guest is a non-native speaker in China, with occasional connection drop-outs), opening with a music jingle and including recorded and host-read sponsor segments for Vaultoro and Wasabi Wallet. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 7 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (155 chunks) and 52 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 1 of 1 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021", stray "Thank you." and "Mmmm" run; labelled sponsor reads as Ad voiceover; Cobo/Cobo Vault, Vaultoro, Coldcard, xpub, Specter, BlueWallet, Nunchuk, BTCPay Server, BIP 174, CoinMarketCap, ShapeShift, hodling, air-gapping, Vlad fixed; restored dropped "But" and "there is only" via second ASR; speaker repairs at 00:03:05, 00:04:03, 00:10:08 (Vlad), 00:17:35 (Vlad), plus short interjections split out; Fixed Cobo Vault/PSBT/KeepKey/Coldcard/Trezor/Kraken Security Labs/Vaultoro spellings; "fee attack", "45 to 60 days", "certain docks", "firmware", "hardware wallet" restored; removed doubled-word artifacts; moved "to benefit from their fix... ecosystem" to Vlad and split Lixin's answer; split "Yes. I think for", "Sorry for the confusion", "Okay" turns; ads relabelled Ad voiceover; Speaker repairs (Vlad's lines at 00:35:47, 00:36:09, 00:36:52, 00:38:51, 00:39:22; Lixin's "Oh, really?"); CoboBot/CoboVault/Kobo→Cobo Vault/Cobo, Voltoro→Vaultoro, BTC chip→BTChip, hodlers, "make money and run away"; restored dropped ad text (Vaultoro, Wasabi block filters via Tor) from second ASR and labelled Ad voiceover; removed stray "Yes. Thank Yes."; Fixed Trezor/Trezor Model T/Trezor Suite, Ledger Donjon, Blockstream Jade, GreenAddress, SafePal, Ellipal, Cobo Vault, xpub, PIN, pattern lock, air-gapped; restored "should not" (Shun dats); split turns misattributed (Vlad's Ellipal remark at 01:07:41, Lixin's "sorry, you were kind of broken", "Yes"/"Correct" interjections, Green Wallet exchange); Fixed Ellipal/SafePal/Ledger Donjon/Coldcard/NVK/Cobo Vault/xpub names; removed "Thank you for watching" hallucination; ad segments relabelled Ad voiceover; repaired speaker boundaries (01:12:02 Vlad, 01:14:03 Vlad, 01:16:30 PIN line Vlad, 01:17:07 confirm/really, short interjections split); Fixed Shamir/SLIP-39/multisig/xpub/NVK/Yeticold/JW Weatherman/Cobo Vault/recovery phrase/seed phrase/friend's/tampered/noobs/three; removed "Thank you for watching... Bye" hallucinations; reassigned 01:36:02 question to Vlad, Clubhouse prompt, interjections, and Lixin's "Sorry, I didn't hear you" and "I'm very sorry" lines; Fixed Cobo Vault, Trezor (Prezor), Coldcard, Caravan, PSBT, Taproot, Vaultoro, World of Warcraft, keylogger; ASR fixes (Walmart or Best Buy, world tour, "by latest", "other legacies"); removed "Thank you for watching" hallucination; reassigned turns (01:41:40 Vlad, 01:49:24 and 01:54:12 Vlad, Lixin's short interjections split out); ads labelled Ad voiceover.