Title: S8 E9: Ben Arc on Bowser Wallet, LNBits & Open Source Podcast: Bitcoin Takeover Podcast (host: Vlad Costea) Guest(s): Ben Arc, open source hobbyist, creator of the Bowser hardware wallet and lead developer of LNbits Published: 2021-05-14 Duration: 2:23:27 Episode URL: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/?name=2021-05-14_s8_e9_ben_arc_on_bowser_wallet__lnbits__open_source.mp3 Audio: https://bitcoin-takeover.com/audio/media/2021-05-14_s8_e9_ben_arc_on_bowser_wallet__lnbits__open_source.mp3 Transcript: CORRECTED. Whisper-Large-V3 first pass with speaker diarization, corrected with Claude Opus 5.5 against two independent re-transcriptions of the audio (Qwen3-ASR full pass; ElevenLabs Scribe v3 on doubtful passages) and the show notes; automatic consistency checks. Format: Clean verbatim (v2): fillers (um, uh), stutters and false starts removed; wording, meaning and order unchanged. Each paragraph starts with [hh:mm:ss] (its start time in the episode audio) and the speaker's full name; times of paragraphs split out of long monologues are interpolated (within a few seconds). [unclear: ...] marks words that cannot be made out from the audio. ================================================================================ [00:00:29] Vlad Costea: This episode is sponsored by Vaultoro. Keep on listening and you will find out more about how you can buy allocated gold when the Bitcoin bull run reaches its peak. This way you don't have to deal with infinitely inflationary fiat or banks that freeze your account. Also, note that trading involves risks and the information presented is not financial advice. This episode is also sponsored by Wasabi Wallet. Go to wasabiwallet.io, download Wasabi for your OS and significantly boost your network level and transaction privacy. [00:01:39] Vlad Costea: Hello there and welcome to Season 8, Episode 9 of the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is a Bitcoin hobbyist, and that's what he calls himself. Even though he's a hardware geek, he's an open source software geek, he has worked on the development of lots of cool projects like LNbits and he has created lots of small open source projects and has contributed to lots of projects. But in the context of Season 8, he has also developed the Bowser hardware wallet, which is an open source device, which looks just like a video game device. [00:02:14] Vlad Costea: It actually looks like something like Tetris and Mario, but it's called Bowser, which is the villain from Super Mario Brothers. And beyond all of that nice video game interface, you actually have a functional hardware wallet. And all of that is open source and you can download it from GitHub. You can fork it. You can modify it. I guess you can also sell it. By the way, Ben, why are you not selling it? [00:02:41] Ben Arc: Well, I mean, it's something to take. If I start pursuing commercial ventures, then it will take time away from the free and open source and the educational stuff, which I'm kind of more passionate about. So, you know, I have other means of income, so I don't need to pursue that specifically, and if I do, then it'll just eat up a load of time of mine. I did have the idea of, you know, I mean, it's a great opportunity for someone out there: buy a bunch of these devices and then pre-flash them. [00:03:15] Ben Arc: And then, you know, sell them. Maybe not the hardware wallets, but some of my other projects, you could kind of pre-flash them and just sell them on as, you know, a device which you've flashed the code on, so somebody doesn't have to download the Arduino IDE and install these libraries and do it themselves. That could be something someone out there could pursue, and then you could put it in a nice little box or something, and, you know, I would encourage someone to do that. But for me personally, I haven't got time. [00:03:45] Vlad Costea: Basically you're too busy working on open source stuff. [00:03:49] Ben Arc: Yeah, I mean, I find it's one of the hardest things with this, because I like, you know, making something and then putting it out there and then other people joining in and contributing, and then the process of people building something together, you know, like something like LNbits, for example. But the problem is that all of these projects require some maintaining. So before you know it, any day you have spare to be able to do some computer hacking and play around with this Bitcoin stuff, you spend your whole time maintaining your older projects and not building new stuff, so that can be quite hard to balance. Which is why I kind of usually keep a lot of my stuff in beta until I think it's been tested enough for it to come out of beta, just to say, look, you know, if it breaks, it's not my fault. [00:04:42] Ben Arc: On that note, yesterday I took Bowser out of beta just because it'd been around for a while, people have played around with it. There were a couple of bugs and teething issues when it was in beta, but now it feels, you know, it works. And as long as you use the versions of the libraries which I specify in the repo, and the version of Electrum which I used as well, because, you know, they could change something and then suddenly it won't work. [00:05:06] Ben Arc: Then it should, it will always work. And I feel confident enough to put some of my own, you know, satoshis on there, so I thought I'd take it out of beta and then people could use it, because it's a useful device. Shall I explain what it is exactly? [00:05:25] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I was actually about to ask you if you have written all the code for it, or you took some parts from the Trezor libraries or something else that's open source. [00:05:33] Ben Arc: No. So, well, I'll tell you how this hardware wallet... Because obviously I've done a few projects, hardware projects like point of sales and different sorts of devices, like little devices for, you know, pay a bit of Bitcoin and you get something to turn on or whatever. But the hardware wallet branch of the work I've been doing really started in the San Francisco Bitcoin conference in 2019. There wasn't a hack space at the Bitcoin conference, and I was always used to it, because in Europe, a lot of the conferences here, you know, are sort of hack-centric. [00:06:13] Ben Arc: So we tend to have like a little space you can sit down with your computer and build stuff. And, you know, birds of a feather, you have all the free and open source developers start clumping together and fiddling around and exchanging code and exchanging ideas. And I find that a very productive environment, just to be around people and ask them questions. And, you know, as he's introduced me, I am a hobbyist, you know, I'm not a computer scientist. I haven't got a computer scientist background. [00:06:39] Ben Arc: This is something which I've just kind of picked up over the past couple of years. Well, I went to the Bitcoin 2019 conference and there wasn't a hack space. So I put a couple of tables together, I just made a little hack space, and I had a bunch of these point of sale kits which I was giving out. So it was like, you know, a little ESP32 microcontroller, which are about three dollars, and then a little screen, like an e-paper screen, and a cheap little keypad as well. So the whole kit was probably like $15, or yeah, I think it was about $15. [00:07:12] Ben Arc: So I had about 100 of those and I was just sitting down with people and showing them how to put these things together and how you could, you know, input a number and then generate an invoice, and someone could pay an invoice. You can make this little cheap point of sale unit. And Stepan Snigirev, he came over, and, you know, obviously he's into very similar stuff. He's into little microcontrollers and trying to get these microcontrollers to interact with Bitcoin. [00:07:37] Ben Arc: And we were talking, and obviously his thing is the Specter hardware wallet. So he was very keen on playing with the microcontrollers I had, to see if we could try and make a very rudimentary hardware wallet. So we started with a watch-only hardware wallet, just with one of these little ESP32 microcontrollers. So we could, you know, put in a master public key, and then we could generate new addresses from it and then get those addresses to display on, well, the serial monitor to begin with, but then eventually we had a display on the e-paper. [00:08:11] Ben Arc: So that's kind of a cool little device. You know, you could turn it on, it would generate an address and then show it as a QR code on the e-paper, but you could then unplug it and it would stay on the e-paper. So it's kind of useful for something, I'm not sure. So anyway, we were kind of hanging out and we were hacking away together. Obviously he's a wizard, so I was instantly in awe of his skills and trying to pick his brains. So, yeah, and he was super excited about the idea of making really cheap hardware wallets. [00:08:42] Ben Arc: So over time, after the conference, he put together uBitcoin, which is an Arduino library you can use for these microcontrollers, in which you can generate a mnemonic and a private key and a public key, and then, you know, put in a master public key and generate addresses and do all that stuff. And, you know, then later on, he added the ability to sign a partially signed Bitcoin transaction. So you could generate a partially signed Bitcoin transaction and send it to one of these devices and sign it. [00:09:20] Ben Arc: All this, I guess, being informed by Specter. I mean, I'm not sure if he uses uBitcoin. I imagine he does use uBitcoin on Specter, but... So that was great, watching that library develop. And then as that library developed, you know, it meant my little hardware wallet could do more and more things. [00:09:38] Ben Arc: It's kind of interesting, actually, because it was very serendipitous, that conference, because on that hack table as well, a guy called Ken Sedgwick came over and he was really into the little point of sale device I was making, the little Lightning point of sale device, and I gave him a kit and he tried to give me money. I was like, "No, no, no, take it," you know. I didn't realize who he was, but he's this old school, you know, cryptographer who's good friends with Christopher Allen, who's pretty important in the space and works a lot with Blockchain Commons. [00:10:13] Ben Arc: Anyway, so I think about six months after the conference, they released something called LetheKit, which uses the same hardware as my point of sale, except it's like a tool for crypto stuff. [00:10:25] Ben Arc: So you can like sign stuff and generate keys and do all those sorts of things. So within those couple of days, you know, this idea of these DIY hardware wallets proliferating and becoming more commonplace within Bitcoin kind of fanned out just from a couple of us, which was pretty nice to see. But I think my frustration was, you know, when you work with these small microcontrollers, you realize how cheap they are. Even more advanced ones with secure chips and the sorts of things you would find in a marketplace hardware wallet. [00:11:01] Ben Arc: It's cheap. It's all cheap electronics. But hardware wallets seem quite expensive, and a lot of people are just put off by that, you know, $80 price tag which you get on a conventional traditional hardware wallet. And that's a real shame, because a hardware wallet is, I think, the best way to store your Bitcoin. You've got your backup seed and then you've got your hardware wallet, which is something you can access, and, you know, it's not quite a hot wallet, it's something which is offline, but you can sign transactions. It's not quite as hard as taking a paper wallet or something chiseled in stone and then trying to restore it. [00:11:35] Ben Arc: I just think it's a very safe way to store your Bitcoin for the majority of people, and easy enough for the majority of people to kind of get their heads around managing. So I very much encourage the use of hardware wallets, but the price tag has always kind of frustrated me. I thought, this is cheap electronics. And also, one of the biggest attack vectors, which no one really talks about, is the supply chain attack. You know, these hardware wallets are coming out of factories. [00:12:04] Ben Arc: They know they're making Bitcoin hardware wallets where probably a significant amount of wealth is going to be stored. I mean, obviously, they have checks and processes in the manufacturing to make sure that somebody hasn't put some malicious bit of hardware or software on the device, but it's not that hard to sneak a couple of devices into a factory, into the production line, and then put them out there. So, you know, when someone generates addresses, you could have it, every ten addresses or something, maybe generate an address from your own hidden master public key, which would then mean you'd just be sending Bitcoin to somebody else's address. [00:12:44] Ben Arc: So supply chain attacks kind of scared me. And then obviously Stepan had been working a lot with multisig as well. So the idea of having, you know, obviously these marketplace hardware wallets do have these secure chips, which are great, and they've done a lot more research on actually encrypting your private key on the device, so it's harder to pull off the device. But then they are susceptible to this supply chain attack. So the ideal scenario in my mind would be that you'd have a traditional hardware like a Trezor, and then, you know, you'd also have a non-traditional off-the-shelf device which you can multisig with. [00:13:27] Ben Arc: And then I think that's a really nice security model. So, I've been very excited to see the work Stepan Snigirev is doing, and a lot of this is off the back of his work. And in fact, he also inspired Justin Moon's BitBoy as well. I think he worked with Justin Moon on the BitBoy device, which was a hardware wallet, but it was a, what's the word? Well, it doesn't actually store your private key. You need to enter your mnemonic before you can use it. [00:13:55] Ben Arc: Watch-only? No, it's not watch-only. It's like it doesn't store your keys. You have to, when you turn it on, you have to enter your mnemonic and then you can, you know, do your wallet functions. Anyway, whatever the term or word is, I'm sure there's a lot of your audience who are going to be shouting now at the podcast. But yeah, so it's been great to be part of the journey of watching these DIY hardware wallets becoming more commonplace. And then also people... Because I think... [00:14:24] Ben Arc: So a lot of my work, I remember there was like an Andreas interview where he was talking about, you know, the future of IoT, and he was saying that if we live in a world where Amazon, Google control all these companies, corporations control all this hardware and we're at their whim, then that'll suck. Whereas if people can learn to take control of this hardware and program them and develop them and understand how they're working and manage them themselves, then that could be quite a good future to go into. [00:14:55] Ben Arc: And I think it's true with all hardware, you know, with your node, with your hardware wallet. If you understand what's happening, you know, behind the scenes, and if you understand what's happening in the code, and like, you know, these microcontrollers, they... [00:15:16] Ben Arc: Just because of the nature of what they're, very limited in processing power, they have a limited amount of code on there, and you can go through. If you really wanted to, you could go through the Bowser wallet and you could go through the libraries, and it would take you like, you know, half a day to code review all the code and make sure there's nothing malicious in there. Even somebody with fairly novice development skills could flick through the code and see that there's nothing malicious. [00:15:44] Ben Arc: So yeah, people taking control of their own hardware and learning to use their own hardware is important. And it's obviously something which we always encourage in Bitcoin and the Bitcoin space. So, you know, the idea is just to extend that into Bitcoin hardware wallets as well, I suppose. [00:16:00] Vlad Costea: It's really interesting to see that there is this open source approach, and there is this approach that's very affordable for anyone. But at the same time, I don't blame people for buying hardware wallets, because it takes a lot of research and you need to know what you're doing if you're building your own. [00:16:17] Ben Arc: Yeah, absolutely. The way I said it, and I think in my original tweet when I first, so I first brought it out in June last year, and I think the original tweet when I put it out is just like, you know, building a Bitcoin hardware wallet is a bit like building a lightsaber. You don't need to do it unless you want to become a Jedi, you know? [00:16:36] Vlad Costea: Yeah, that's very true actually, except that lightsabers can be passed on, and that's a terrible idea with hardware wallets. You're supposed to have your own. It's like a toothbrush. But let me ask you more about the Bowser hardware wallet, because it looks interesting. You play a game of Tetris on the screen at first. That's, I guess, the screensaver or something, but it's actually interactive, so you can actually play Tetris on it. And it has a background from Super Mario Bros. And after that you insert your PIN. And you're supposed to be using the Morse code? That's insane. [00:17:18] Ben Arc: I mean, with, you know, these off-the-shelf components and building these things yourself, you can do whatever the fuck you want. Like, I like Morse code, so I want a PIN where I can put Morse code in. There's a gazillion different ways you could put the PIN in. In fact, there was someone, when I tweeted out yesterday, I think it was, about the Bowser wallet, someone in the thread said, oh, you know, someone could be listening and they'll be able to decipher the Morse code you're inputting with the buttons. [00:17:44] Ben Arc: And it's like, yeah, sure, you know, someone could be looking over your shoulder when you're putting your PIN in on your Trezor wallet. There's like a spectrum of options. What's cool about the Bowser is if you're not happy with the way in which you input the PIN, you could change it. So the actual device I'm using, again, it's an ESP32, but it's packaged in a nice little box, which is the M5Stack. They do a really good job of just packaging it all together with a little battery. [00:18:08] Ben Arc: It's got a little screen, it's got three little buttons, and it's got your microcontroller all packaged in a nice little, you know, nice-looking box. Well, there's an extension to that package called the FACES kit. And with this FACES kit, you can actually have, you know, the bottom part a Game Boy controller, you know, with the little D-pad and the two little buttons. So one way I was thinking, you know, if you added that, then obviously it would probably make more sense, because you would see the Tetris Mario thing and then it would also be on a Game Boy. [00:18:39] Ben Arc: Would look like a Game Boy. And you could actually enter your PIN as a combo on your D-pad. That could be pretty good fun. Obviously, it'd have to not be too complicated, so you'd be able to recreate it, because if you don't, then you're in danger of losing your funds if you can't recreate your PIN. But yeah, that could be one way, or another way. So the Bowser wallet, the way it air gaps and the way you sign partially signed Bitcoin transactions is through an SD card. [00:19:07] Ben Arc: On the SD card, there's a text file called bowser.txt. You just open it up, and say if you want to sign a transaction, you write "sign" in capitals, space, and then you just paste the partially signed Bitcoin transaction in, plop it into the Bowser hardware wallet, and then go to the sign transaction menu item, you click on it and then you sign the transaction, and then it saves the signed transaction back in the SD card. So everything kind of goes through the SD card. [00:19:33] Ben Arc: So you could, if you wanted to, you know, fork the Bowser wallet and you could input your PIN via the SD card. You know, you could add an extra command. So "PIN" in capitals, space, and then the PIN for the device. I think the idea with this one is, you know, it's not the most secure device, because the ESP32 has Wi-Fi and Bluetooth on. Not all times, obviously, you have to enable it, but it's there. So generally, you know, you want a lot less modules in a hardware wallet, and like your Trezor, for example, doesn't have like a Wi-Fi module or a Bluetooth module. [00:20:11] Ben Arc: But, you know, it's that spectrum of hardware wallets. You know, someone might want a covert way of storing their bitcoins on a hardware wallet while they're, you know, fleeing Syria and walking through Europe, and they want a little device. If anyone sees it, then they can just say, "Oh yeah, it's just for playing a game, you know, I like Tetris, whatever." And they're like, "Oh, cool, Tetris. Oh, with Mario, that's a bit weird." And you're like, "Yeah, you know, we've got it from, you know, China. I don't know." [00:20:33] Ben Arc: But then you've got this secret hardware wallet hidden behind the game. So that was kind of the original concept for having it behind this game thing: it's kind of a covert way of carrying your Bitcoin. It doesn't look like a hardware wallet. So, you know, a couple of years ago, I was traveling to lots of conferences. [00:20:55] Ben Arc: And I was always very conscious, if I had a hardware wallet on me, that if I was to get my things searched, all my electronics searched, it looks like a Bitcoin hardware wallet. You know, the Trezor looks like, and it doesn't look like anything else. You have to sort of explain then what a Bitcoin hardware wallet is, and yeah, so it's not something I feel comfortable carrying. Whereas this little M5Stack thing, you know, I feel comfortable carrying that in my pocket and getting on a plane with it and sitting there playing Tetris. [00:21:22] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, that's very good for what we like to call OPSEC. And I was looking right now at the GitHub. I can see that there are three contributors to the project. You are obviously the main one. And then there is Stepan Snigirev. Is that how you pronounce his name? I never know. [00:21:40] Ben Arc: And I'm always too embarrassed to ask. I think I'm embarrassed to ask because I've actually asked him a few times and he's told me how to pronounce it, and then I've just forgotten. So yeah, Snigirev. I think he needs to change his name to Stepan Spector. That's a cooler name. [00:21:55] Vlad Costea: And there's also Rachel Bryan. [00:21:57] Ben Arc: Yeah, yeah. I think she just contributed a couple of typos, actually. I don't think she contributed any code or anything. I think it was more on the readme side. So yeah, I mean, it's not really got that many. You know, contributors are always very welcome in all of these projects. Please hop in, you know, download the code, and if you see anything which could be improved, then contribute. That's the nature of free open source, isn't it? And fork as well. And, you know, change the game or change the way in which you can enter the PIN. It's not particularly hard. And, you know, so M5Stack, they've got another device called an M5Stick, and that's got a smaller screen on, and it hasn't got an SD card, so... [00:22:43] Ben Arc: You would probably have to send partially signed Bitcoin transactions to sign over a cable, like through the serial. But you could, you know, you could Google all that stuff, and over a weekend you could figure out how to port the Bowser wallet onto the M5Stick. Probably get rid of the game thing, but, you know, just have it as like a hardware, like a SeedSigner type, you know, so I think SeedSigner are doing a sort of similar device. Or you could just, you know, go into the Bowser wallet and then find the uBitcoin, the functions which I'm using to call uBitcoin functions. [00:23:20] Ben Arc: And then you could just use those to create your own hardware wallet on a device. And maybe you could buy a secure module as well to store your private key too on, or some sort of, I think there's some ESP32s or other microcontrollers out there which have secure elements built into them. You could port it to RISC-V, you could get a RISC-V microcontroller. They're a bit more limited and trickier to work with, but you could do it, and then just take those functions across. [00:23:54] Ben Arc: So this is the idea of free open source, and this is why it wins eventually, because you can just use the work of others and then build on top of it. That's all we're all doing, just using the work of others and building on top of it. You know, Stepan's uBitcoin library is, you know, the Bitcoin Core libraries, made by Pieter Wuille and whoever else, slimmed down for what we needed to do in an Arduino, you know. So, yeah, we're all building on top of each other's work. And that's why, ultimately, free and open source always wins. [00:24:25] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so I was about to ask you, how much does it cost to buy the parts for the Bowser wallet? How long does it take you to put it together and put the code on it? And do you see this as becoming a business to someone? You said you're not interested in selling it, but would anyone be able to just take your project and sell it? [00:24:46] Ben Arc: Yeah, there's a bunch of little projects I've made where people have, like there was a sweet machine I made pretty early on with a microcontroller and an e-paper thing, which could spit out sweets, and someone started making those and selling them. And you know, the parts were pretty cheap, they're like $40 or something. I think they're selling for like $200. I think they sold a few, you know. Yeah, there's a bunch of little hardware projects people have then taken on and made into little cottage industry businesses, and great, you know, go for it. [00:25:20] Ben Arc: The M5Stack costs, I think, for like $40, I think, not really expensive. You can buy cheaper alternatives, but you would then need to, you know, port everything across. The M5Stack is a really nice little unit. It's got a little battery in as well, which is nice. So, yeah, it's about $40 if you buy the FACES kit, the M5Stack FACES kit, that's really good. And that gives you the option as well. So one of my other projects is the LNPoS, formerly known as the Quickening, which is a point of sale, Bitcoin Lightning point of sale terminal, which interacts with your funding source. [00:25:58] Ben Arc: In fact, LNPoS just interacts with LNbits because you can run LNbits on top of anything, and you can use that to generate an invoice and show an invoice on the little screen, and then somebody can pay it. And then once it's paid, it then says completed, and you can use it. In fact, that device, the POS I made with the M5Stack, that was running in Room 77 in Berlin for like a year and a half or something, and it was doing like good traffic. And you know, it worked. It kept going, it didn't break. The hardware didn't break, the software didn't break. [00:26:25] Ben Arc: And what's great about the M5Stack FACES kit, which is the one where you get the extra modules you can click on to make the little point of sale terminal, is it also comes with a charging dock, a magnetic charging dock, which you can just stick on something metal, and then you can just plop the point of sale in, and to pull it out, nice and easy, you don't have to unplug it or anything, and it's just charged then, and you can use it in your bar or cafe. [00:26:54] Ben Arc: But the original, I should probably cover this, which I haven't really covered. I always think about the bar owner or the cafe owner who wants to accept Bitcoin, and they want, you know, they want like a device, a permanent device, dumb device, which they can use to receive Bitcoin payments on, for example. Or they want, you know, a cheap hardware wallet which they could have Lightning payments be concatenated and then looped out onto this hardware wallet, onto an on-chain address. Because a lot of cafe owners, you know, if they're accepting Bitcoin, they don't want to cash out to fiat. They just want to like build up a little personal stash on the side, you know, tax-free. [00:27:41] Ben Arc: And that could be a nice solution for that. So I'm often thinking about the real-world use cases. And in fact, there's nothing better than getting these devices out there in the real world and people actually using them in real bars and cafes. A friend of mine sent me a picture. He was in like a random bar in South America somewhere, and they had one of these little M5Stack point of sale devices, and they were running my code, you know, to accept Bitcoin payments. And I was like... Because obviously, with it being free and open source, unless someone's got an issue, you generally don't know people are using your stuff. [00:28:18] Ben Arc: And in fact, the less sometimes you hear from people, the more reliable your hardware or your software is. So you've no idea how many people out there in the world are using whatever you've made. So it's great to kind of get feedback and hear that people are actually using it in the real world. And then what you find is that if you actually speak to people using it in the real world, in real brick and mortar, then you get great feedback, which you can then use to improve your project. [00:28:49] Ben Arc: And that's, you know, again, what I want with the Bowser. I want it to go out there into the real world. And then maybe enough people complain about the Morse code way to input your PIN that maybe we find a different way of inputting the PIN. Or maybe someone forks it and then does that, you know, maybe if there's enough demand there. So, yeah, contribute where you can. And actually, yeah, if you want to take the project and then turn it into a little cottage industry, you know, sell them on your site or whatever, then that's contributing, because it's putting the devices in more hands of people, and then they're going to give feedback. [00:29:28] Ben Arc: And then, you know, that then informs the project. So go ahead. [00:29:32] Vlad Costea: So, how much does it cost to put one together? [00:29:35] Ben Arc: Yeah, it's like $40 for the M5Stack. Just the M5Stack without the FACES kit thing, that's $40. And then the Arduino IDE is, you know, free and open source. There are other ways of flashing these devices. There's the ESP-IDF. So Jade Wallet... I brought out Bowser Wallet last year in April, I think, but Jade Wallet uses the M5Stack as well. I was kind of annoyed at Blockstream for that because they... [00:30:06] Ben Arc: When they launched it, they said it was secure, and that's wrong. It's not secure. It's an off-the-shelf microcontroller. It's got no secure element in it. You can make it pretty secure, but it's not secure like a hardware wallet, so you shouldn't really refer to it as secure. It's secure in different ways that we've already spoken about. But yeah, so that base device is $40, and then the Arduino IDE is free. Just install the libraries. Install the Arduino IDE, there's details of this on the repo. [00:30:39] Ben Arc: Install the ESP32 boards in the Arduino IDE and then install the libraries. Again, there's details and there's also a YouTube tutorial on how to do these things. And then just upload, plug the thing into your computer, upload the code onto it, and yes, that's it's running. And then you just interact with it with an SD card. One thing to note, actually, is we found if you go over a 32 gigabyte SD card, the device, I don't think it can recognize it's like too big for it. [00:31:11] Ben Arc: So keep an eye on that. But there's a few people who said some SD cards work and some SD cards don't. The SD cards I've used have all worked perfectly, but I've only ever used like small ones I've had lying around, like 32 gigabytes or less. So that's something to note. And in fact, the other thing to note as well is that the partially signed Bitcoin transactions are made using Electrum Wallet. So you basically make a watch-only wallet on Electrum for your Bitcoin wallet. [00:31:39] Ben Arc: And then you say you want to send funds somewhere, that generates a PSBT. And then you put the PSBT on the SD card and then you put that in the Bowser Wallet, sign on the Bowser Wallet, and then you just, you know... What's it called? Then you transmit it through some online service. There's plenty of them out there. And currently, it's using Electrum 3.3.8, I think, because the newer Electrums, the 4.0 whatevers, they changed the way in which they make the PSBTs, so we still need to go in and make the Bowser Wallet parse the new PSBTs which Electrum do. But I mean, you know, it doesn't really matter if you're using 3.3.8. There's no security flaws or anything there. It's just really because of the way they changed the PSBTs. But in version 1.01 of Bowser Wallet, the next thing we'll do is make sure that it parses those new Electrum PSBTs as well. [00:32:51] Vlad Costea: Vaultoro, and that's V-A-U-L-T, like a gold vault, and O-R-O, oro, which is Spanish for gold, is a gold and Bitcoin exchange which offers instant swaps between hard money to over 31,000 customers from more than 95 countries. Vaultoro has offered Swiss privacy and security since 2015. Furthermore, the gold you purchase is your legal property, secured in your name, so even if something happens to Vaultoro, even liquidators could not touch your gold. If you want to become the custodian of your own gold bars, you can request to have them delivered to you, or simply trade them back to Bitcoin on the dip. [00:33:34] Vlad Costea: Register for free in only 30 seconds and start trading only with hard money. Please keep in mind that all trading involves risks. This is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions. When you are using Wasabi Wallet, your internet connection gets routed through the Tor network by default. This means that you get better privacy while using Bitcoin. Download it today at wasabiwallet.io. [00:34:02] Vlad Costea: Yeah, so let me unpack a bit because you said lots of interesting stuff in the last 20 minutes. And I want to start with the fact that you mentioned that you can create the Bowser wallet in the enclosure of the Game Boy. So you can use a much more complex way of input to type your PIN or whatever you use. And it would be funny if a lot of people use the Konami code, like up, up, down, down, left, right, left, right, B, A, Start. [00:34:35] Ben Arc: That's what I was thinking. I was thinking you need to be careful, because we've got all these, like, you know, cheats in our head. You know, our muscle memory is there, isn't it? So that's the thing which most people would go to. They would put in some sort of combo they would remember from their childhood. So you'd have to be careful not to do that, because that'd be a pretty easy thing to hack. [00:34:59] Vlad Costea: Also, on the Bowser wallet, I can see, I've just zoomed in on the screen, and I can see that you have one, two, three, four, five, six options. Once you activate it, you have display pub key. So I suppose this is for the purpose of receiving funds. [00:35:15] Ben Arc: Yeah, yeah. I mean, the video you're looking at is the first version I made. I was super excited and it was during lockdown last year. I think it was like May or something, and as soon as I'd made it, I made that video and put it out there, and then the next couple of days I sort of tidied it up a bit. So I think the same options are there now. They might be renamed, so instead of show pub key, I think it's show address, because that makes more sense. [00:35:48] Ben Arc: Yeah, I think also, when you put in a PSBT, you'll probably see in that video, it literally displays the whole PSBT on the device. Whereas in the new version, it parses it and it says, you know, do you want to send X amount for the fee of, you know, more like you would expect your hardware wallet to say before you click, yeah, I'll sign that. [00:36:10] Vlad Costea: Yeah, it's actually interesting. You have sort of like a PSBT machine which only does part of the signing. You're supposed to take your SD card, put it inside of your SD port in your computer, and also sign the other side of it on Electrum to validate the transaction. So from this point of view, it's very interesting. It's kind of like a lightweight version of the Coldcard or the BitBox02, because both of them can use PSBT. Also, the Cobo Vault. [00:36:49] Ben Arc: Yeah, I think people working on these hardware, particularly the DIY hardware wallets, PSBTs is the way forward. The only thing which kind of sucks about the PSBTs is the size of that blob of data, so it makes it very hard to put it in a QR code and display it on a screen. So, for example, you can get plenty of these microcontrollers, get little cameras for them, or you can get a QR code scanner. I think actually the BitBoy by Justin Moon uses a QR code scanner. There's a nice one on the market, I think it's like $20, and it's pretty easy to plug into your ESP, into your M5Stack. [00:37:25] Ben Arc: And then use that to... so you could technically display the PSBT in Electrum, you know, the unsigned one, and then you could scan it with your hardware wallet using a QR code scanner. It's a bit like a barcode scanner you see in a shop or something. [00:37:44] Ben Arc: It's like a red light goes "bloop" and then it scans the QR code. And then you could sign on the device and then show the QR code of the signed transaction on the device, which you could then scan and transmit. But the problem is with these PSBTs is that, particularly if you have like, you know, if your transaction's quite complicated, then that QR code can be pretty big and you'll struggle to display it on one of these little screens. Or you'll be able to display it, but then only you know, 20% of phones will be able to actually read it. [00:38:18] Ben Arc: Which is, this is something which I've struggled with the whole time with a lot of these projects, is trying to make sure that all phones, even your cheapest... It's about, you know, banking the unbanked, doesn't it? You want people with a cheap $30 Android phone to be able to interact with these devices and use them. You don't want for one of the dependencies to be for you to have like the high-end Samsung or iPhone to be able to scan these QR codes. So yeah, that's one of the things which sucks about the PSBTs. [00:38:51] Ben Arc: Some of the work which has been done on that, actually, and pushed by Specter a lot, I think Specter even may have it now, which is the animated QR codes. Blockchain Commons... is it Blockchain Commons? I don't think that's the right name. I think it's like... Yeah, no, it's Commons. They've written a bunch of papers trying to push this idea of animated QR codes. So that would be where you take bits of the data and you just split it up into, say, four little QR codes, and then your device will scan the four QR codes and then stick those bits of data back together into a blob. [00:39:25] Ben Arc: That would be great, because then that would mean that you could use a really cheap device with a really crappy little screen and then you could, you know, transmit a big partially signed Bitcoin transaction just through QR code. That'd be super useful. So yeah, so that's hopefully something which gets pushed more. I think so. I think I need to look into Specter, but I think Specter have started adopting and started using, or they're going to, or they've been researching the animated QR codes. [00:39:58] Vlad Costea: You know, you have mentioned that the M5Stack that you use to build your own Bowser wallet costs about $40, but that's what Blockstream sells the Jade for. So I was actually curious, how do they actually make money out of this? [00:40:13] Ben Arc: I don't think they do. I think Blockstream's biggest issue... You know, I like Blockstream. They do a lot of good work. But sometimes I feel like there's something technocratic and almost vanguard about the operation. Because obviously you've got these very gifted developers, and often with very gifted developers, they make it hard. They make it harder for people to run their software and hardware. This is why I love Stepan, because his libraries are very clear, very succinct, concise. You can read them. You can understand them, like uBitcoin, which I use for the Bowser wallet. [00:40:53] Ben Arc: And in fact, I use another one of his libraries, embit, for LNbits, for the watch-only extension in LNbits, which we'll talk about in a moment actually. They're just really easy to use libraries, where, like uBitcoin, for example, that's designed to be used with the Arduino IDE and PlatformIO. Now, the Jade wallet, it is a free and open source hardware wallet you can use for your Liquid tokens, made by Blockstream, but you need to use the ESP-IDF. [00:41:29] Ben Arc: So Espressif, the manufacturer of these little microcontrollers, they have their own IDE, which is called ESP, and then you operate it through a terminal, and it's far more complicated to use for your common user. And actually, if you can get it to work and use it, then it's even harder to, like, you know, change the code and adapt the code. You have to download your own IDE and then installing libraries is a little bit trickier. [00:41:53] Ben Arc: And there's no reason that they couldn't have made Jade on, you know, for the Arduino IDE or for something like PlatformIO, which is another IDE you can use with these Arduino things. The only reason they didn't is it's almost like they're trying to make it inaccessible. So I think that kind of attitude early on, it frustrated me, because I love the idea of Liquid and Liquid tokens. But there was no nurturing of a hacker community, of a maker hacker community. [00:42:19] Ben Arc: So if you look at Lightning and how popular and successful Lightning's development has been, I think it's partly because everyone in it was super excited and they wanted to try to make everything as easy as possible for people to play around with and to build things on. [00:42:35] Ben Arc: And you know, you had these Lightning hack days, which Fulmo and the German lot organized, where they would have lots of great talks and they would be really encouraging and nurturing to people. I mean, that's where, you know, I kind of was probably first encouraged to start building stuff, by Christian Rotzoll and Fulmo Jeff. So they were great spaces to learn. And it's beyond me why Blockstream hasn't organized similar events for Liquid and for building on Liquid. [00:43:05] Ben Arc: It's a bit like, you know, Simplicity. You read the documentation for Simplicity and it's just crazy. You can't even imagine... You know, very well accomplished computer scientists struggle to understand just the docs, let alone the actual software. And it's called Simplicity as well. I don't like that barrier to entry which they sometimes put in place. Anyway, because of that barrier to entry, there just wasn't a hardware wallet for Liquid tokens. Specter has now added it. And now, so they had to make a hardware wallet so people could start playing, when they had their Liquid tokens they could have some sort of hardware wallet to put them on. [00:43:44] Ben Arc: So hopefully we'll see now more and more adoption and those barriers to entry will, you know, erode a little bit, because they've had a good amount of success with this Jade wallet and people are excited about it. So they'll see that there are people out there who really want to get involved and they want to build things, and that they'll kind of, yeah, dissolve that barrier to entry a little bit. But that's... I think, sorry, to answer your question, I think they're not making any money on the Jade wallet. [00:44:11] Ben Arc: They just want to get those wallets out there, because then it means people will play with Liquid, and then they'll also have an easy way of storing their Liquid tokens in a secure-ish way. It could also be that they've bought, wholesaled a bunch of them, so they've got in contact with M5Stack directly and they've managed to buy, I don't know, a thousand or ten thousand of these things for like $20 or something. That could also be a possibility. But I think it's more about they just need a hardware wallet out there for people to be able to play around with Liquid. [00:44:43] Vlad Costea: Interesting. [00:44:44] Ben Arc: Because they had too many barriers to entry to begin with. [00:44:47] Vlad Costea: Yeah, I also want to get back to something you said earlier and ask you a question about it, because I remember when we were in Berlin at the Lightning Conference, and that's when I first met you in person. Actually, no, it wasn't. Or was it? [00:44:59] Ben Arc: Yeah, I think it was. I was pretty drunk. [00:45:02] Vlad Costea: No, wait. I also met you in Romania, but... [00:45:07] Ben Arc: That was afterwards, I think. [00:45:10] Vlad Costea: It doesn't matter. The timeline doesn't matter. But I became aware of your work because you were handing out stamps that you could use for banknotes, for fiat money. [00:45:21] Ben Arc: Oh yeah. [00:45:22] Vlad Costea: I still have one of those. And I also looked at what you were doing at the time, building stuff. And you were upstairs at the hackers area, where you were building and talking with others. And later on, I remember we went to Room 77. [00:45:36] Ben Arc: Yeah, correct. [00:45:37] Vlad Costea: And I remember that when you were paying for beer and you were using the Lightning Network, because that was the most popular way of paying for beer in that specific bar, they had these small devices that looked just like the Bowser wallet. [00:45:57] Ben Arc: That's it. That's the device I was talking about before. That's my point of sale, which I made. [00:46:01] Vlad Costea: So they were using your open source work? [00:46:05] Ben Arc: Yeah, they were using my open source point of sale, yeah. Which was developed off the back of... It's quite cool. It gives me goosebumps. So Room 77 is a very iconic and important Bitcoin bar. It's where the first phone wallet, Bitcoin phone wallet, was created. And it was created in Room 77 because they were fed up with taking their laptops to the bar to pay for beer. So they made a phone wallet, Bitcoin wallet, you know, back in 2011 or 12, whenever it was, so they didn't have to take their laptops to the bar, which I just think is amazing. [00:46:36] Ben Arc: So for them also then to have what would be the first free and open source Bitcoin point of sale terminal, dedicated point of sale terminal, you know, which has existed, for them to then be using that, and it's my thing which I made, I think it always gives me goosebumps to think of. And all the work I did and continue to do actually is off the back of the Lightning hack days, which all that lot organized, because, like I said, they were so encouraging. [00:47:02] Ben Arc: Like, you went to one of those hack days, and, you know, I was a teacher. I was originally a teacher, and I just kind of did a little bit of coding on the side, so my skills were very limited. And it was fairly obvious that my skills were limited if you looked at, you know, at one of these events, if you were to look at any of the code I was trying to write. But they were so supporting and nurturing and encouraging, and there wasn't any of that "Oh, you shouldn't be doing this because you don't know what you're doing" type attitude. [00:47:32] Ben Arc: It was like, "You should continue hacking away at this and then, you know, learn and ask people questions, and you'll be able to develop something which is useful." So it's a great lesson for anyone else out there who's in that position where they could either encourage or belittle someone: encourage them, because they'll make something cool. And it's one of the best ways you can have an impact in life, I suppose. But then also in Bitcoin, is to just encourage and make things easy for people to use, and encourage them to use it, and then encourage them to build their own stuff, because they'll go off and they'll just, you know, create things. [00:48:10] Ben Arc: So yeah, that was great. That point of sale was... And in fact, I think at that event, I don't think I had any... I think my phone was dead or something. Yeah, my phone died. I didn't have any battery on my phone. And it was this big event, there's loads of people there using my point of sale, but I couldn't actually pay for a beer with my phone, because my phone had died. So I had to ask someone, I was like, "Can I please can I give you some money? I'll use your phone to buy a beer, because I can't miss out on this. [00:48:44] Ben Arc: Everyone else is using my point of sale except me." But that was... So Jörg, who runs Room 77, he's an old school crypto guy, cypherpunk, Jörg Platzer. And he was into cypherpunk stuff before Bitcoin existed. So I always have a huge amount of respect for anyone like that, like the Adam Backs of this world, because there was no monetary value, you know, then. I don't know if I'd be in Bitcoin if it weren't for its monetary value. I don't think any of us can say we would be or not. [00:49:15] Ben Arc: So I've got a huge amount of respect for him. He informed so much of what I've been building, just from the feedback of actually using this stuff in the wild. [00:49:24] Vlad Costea: Which is insane when you think about it. [00:49:27] Ben Arc: Yeah, it's great. And in fact, like LNbits, which is another project I've worked on, a lot of that was informed from Room 77. Like, Jörg will hate me for saying this, but he was accepting all these transactions, these Lightning transactions for beer. And then he accepted so many, you know, instead of it just being building his personal stash, you know, for the books, he couldn't play that card anymore. So he was like, "I need to pay taxes." But then the problem is he couldn't identify on his node which transactions were for beer and then which are just other sorts of transactions. So he couldn't... [00:50:01] Ben Arc: It's really fiddly to go through and then, you know, take all the transactions and pay his taxes for the beer he sold. So he wanted something where, you know, he could just export transactions out to a CSV and then put it into QuickBooks or whatever. So part of the original concept for LNbits was just a bit of middleware between you and your node. Sorry, between the point of sale and your node, which you could then have a button on and you could export CSV. [00:50:29] Ben Arc: So you could send, you know, funds from a point of sale through a bit of middleware and the middleware would just log the sales and then you could just export CSV. So again, you know, like I wouldn't have thought of that because I'm not a bar owner or a cafe owner. I wouldn't have thought how useful it would be just to have that simple functionality. It's a super simple functionality, and one of the cornerstones and building blocks of the original LNbits implementation. [00:50:56] Vlad Costea: That's a very interesting story. And it's really fascinating to figure out how these open source projects come into existence. Because initially they start, or they attempt to solve a very simple problem which actually exists and there's a demand for it. And then you start adding lots of stuff. And the reason why I will be using LNbits is that during the Bitcoin Takeover Radio broadcast, I'll do some sort of faucet, so people will be able to scan a code with their phones every amount of minutes that I'm not going to disclose, because you can milk it if you know how to do it. [00:51:35] Vlad Costea: And you can do that and grab some money just because you're listening to the broadcast at the right time. So I think that's really cool. And the idea that you started from trying to solve the accounting for a bar just makes it even cooler. [00:51:53] Ben Arc: Yeah, I mean, there was a bunch of... I mean, they just needed to be like a WordPress type thing for Lightning wallets. The developers out there will cringe when I say that because obviously they all hate WordPress. But, you know, WordPress is successful because you start with a simple blog and then you can just use all these plugins and extensions to extend it in different directions, whatever direction you need to use it for. And LNbits is just kind of similar, really. Like you start with a very simple wallet, which are easy to generate, and you can have multiple accounts. And it's easy to plug in. [00:52:28] Ben Arc: It's got API keys. Each wallet's got its own API key. So you can plug in your point of sale or whatever into it, or your software, whatever. But then there's also all these extensions, so you can build it into different directions. Like for you, for example, you want a faucet. And then there's a new extension I'm working on called Streamer Copilot, which allows you to have, you know, a QR code on the screen when you're doing a stream, and then people pay it and then you can like trigger animations and things. [00:52:58] Ben Arc: Which I know there's a lot of like legacy finance type streamer platforms which allow that, where you can do a payment and then trigger stuff to happen on the screen. But we haven't really got anything in Bitcoin, and it makes perfect sense for Bitcoin. Like you say, for that like interaction, you know, like... I thought of a way of putting this before, you know, like a... what's it called when you have in Lightning channels? One-way channels. Bidirectional, yes. Like, bidirectional interaction between viewer or consumer and then producer, which you can do with Lightning. [00:53:30] Ben Arc: So, you know, pay some Lightning and then have something happen. So, yeah. So you may want to build out in that direction, or maybe, you know, at the weekend, then you go to a farmer's market and you could use the offline shop, you know, extension. And what's great about LNbits is obviously you can run it on your own node as well, so you're not using some sort of custodial service. So yeah, there was a whole bunch of different things which LNbits needed to be. [00:53:58] Ben Arc: But yeah, it all starts from real world problems. And it's actually really interesting. Like, I've met quite a lot of very, very gifted, talented developers who could knock out projects, you know, in a few hours, like useful projects we would all find useful in a few hours. And then you say, "Why don't you build something?" "I can't really think of anything to build." And it's because they're not kind of out there having their software, or, you know, or I don't know, out there getting their hands dirty in the real world. [00:54:32] Ben Arc: They're limited on just the amount of ideas they can have. So they've got all the skills, but then they haven't... You know, they're kind of waiting for divine inspiration to happen. And I think with anything you can't do that. If you look at any, you know, successful artist or musician or anyone, anyone who produces something, it's not by sitting there and then, you know, you have this divine, God blesses you with some great inspired idea, which you then go and make. It's a series of real-world interactions where you hit a roadblock or a problem and then you have to solve that problem by building something. [00:55:08] Ben Arc: And then, you know, when you build that thing, there's something else you need to build to do something else. And ideas breed from other ideas. So yeah, I encourage people to just kind of like get out there, start. Even if you don't want to develop on LNbits, you take LNbits and then go run it in some cafe or something, because we have a point of sale extension, which is really neat. And then get feedback, and then maybe there'll be something in that feedback which could then inform you to build a different piece of software. I don't know. But yeah, you've got to kind of get your hands dirty, you know. [00:55:46] Vlad Costea: Yeah, and also let's get back to hardware wallets, because that's the main topic of this season. I'm very happy that we got into LNbits because... [00:55:52] Ben Arc: Ooh, before we start. So one of the other extensions... Ah, this is exciting. So I actually made a bounty, and Stepan's claimed the bounty, which is great, because you know the code's going to be good. So the watch-only extension. My dream of that, you know, that real world business owner of the cafe or the bar or something, is they have an LNbits which they're doing point of sale transactions on. Maybe with one of these point of sale terminals, but probably just with the LNbits extension for point of sale. [00:56:25] Ben Arc: And then those Satoshi transactions, Lightning transactions, they get a certain, you know, say when they get $200 or $300, it gets looped out onto an on-chain address. So I think the ideal scenario would be if you had like a $10 hardware wallet, you know, cheap microcontroller, off-the-shelf hardware wallet, where you could sign a transaction to spend funds. And then you have, you know, LNbits could be a custodial LNbits, like, you know, you could be running, for example... or don't use LNbits.com, because we're always breaking that, but someone else could be running it. [00:57:00] Ben Arc: And then you literally just give that to the cashier and say, "Look, okay, you can accept Bitcoin transactions. The risk is $300. I might steal, you know, but whenever it gets $300, it'll just loop out to this hardware wallet, and then the Bitcoin's yours. You know, you've got it in cold storage, and you can send it to an exchange if you want to cash out whenever." And then over time say, "Hey, have you thought about running your own LNbits install? You could run your own LNbits on a VPS." You know, you can even have a little cheap, a little light Lightning node running as well, and then you can kind of encourage self-sovereignty and autonomy. [00:57:47] Ben Arc: But for onboarding, just giving someone like a $10 hard... Like, that's so cheap. I could literally give that to a bunch of cafe owners around here and say, "Here's a hardware wallet. Your Bitcoin will go on there. Use this LNbits install." And then, you know, so that's the kind of thing which I'm working towards. And in order to be able to do that and have it all happen in LNbits, the watch-only extension... Currently, you just put a master public key in and you can generate addresses. But we're going to be adding functionality that you can generate a partially signed Bitcoin transaction in that extension and then send that to your hardware wallet, sign it, and then broadcast it from the extension as well. [00:58:17] Ben Arc: So the watch-only extension. So in fact, with LNbits, you'll be able to interact with your hardware wallet, plus loop out, because we need to... well, that's another extension we need to make, is the looping out bit, but there's a bunch of options for that. And then loop out to like a cheap hardware wallet. I think that'd be like such a nice onboarding experience for a cafe or a bar or something out there. [00:58:45] Vlad Costea: Hey, psst, hey. What's your plan for the next Bitcoin top? Unless you need the money to purchase something, you probably should not touch infinitely inflationary fiat. Check out Vaultoro and figure out to which extent hard money like gold and silver can help you preserve your purchasing power. You will be able to get back into Bitcoin as soon as the price hits a new bottom, and you will not be subjected to the arbitrary, inflation-driven volatility of fiat or fiat-backed coins. Obviously, this is not financial advice, and you should understand that all trading involves risks. Wasabi Wallet connects to your full Bitcoin node, and if you're not running one, it downloads block filters anonymously via Tor. [00:59:40] Vlad Costea: In either case, you're getting excellent privacy. Download the software today at wasabiwallet.io. I agree. Like, we need a lot more simple solutions to accept payments. Because in most cases, I think it would be ideal if they ran their own nodes on location. But before they get to that point, they need to get some sort of gateway drug, something that's inexpensive and it's easy to use. Plus, you know, something that only requires the waiter or the waitress to go to the table and just leave that and say "You can pay this," just like they do with the bill. [01:00:23] Vlad Costea: It's a lot more traditional as opposed to asking them, "Could you please come to the bar and scan this QR code on the screen?" It's more elegant. And if you use these inexpensive small devices, I can see them being very practical and being basically a gateway drug towards making people in cafes run nodes and, you know, cafe owners run nodes and validate their own transactions. But they need to start somewhere to figure out that they need to be using this, and there's enough demand and it gets popular. I mean, these electronic devices can get trendy quite fast, and customers can enjoy using them. So I can see sort of a snowball effect happening with them. [01:01:08] Ben Arc: I mean, yeah, so you could use the point of sale thing, or you could... There is just TPoS, which is a nice LNbits extension, which generates a shareable point of sale terminal, which you can just use in a phone. And you can just give that to your bar staff and they can just use it on the phone. But it looks like a point of sale terminal, and you input your fiat amount. So it takes fiat. So your staff don't need to be trained in the ways of Satoshis. They're just, you know, inputting a fiat amount and some Bitcoin, and scanning it and paying for their coffee in Bitcoin. Yeah, no, it's something I'm... [01:01:38] Ben Arc: That's the kind of thing which I'm working towards. And you can incentivize the autonomy and the self-sovereignty and them running their own nodes in a way which is good business. So you could charge a percent. You know, you run your own LNbits install on your node. You go to your local cafe with one of these hardware wallets. You say, "Look, we can make this thing. You know, you use this LNbits, use this point of sale terminal, your funds go in here, and then when they hit $300, they go into this hardware wallet. I'm going to charge you 3% for every transaction. [01:02:09] Ben Arc: But if you run this stuff yourself, which I can show you to do for a small fee maybe, then you won't be charged anything." If you run your own node, you won't have to... you can lose that 3%, you don't have to charge anything. I think there's a big case for that. And someone had mentioned something really interesting. Actually, I'm going to go off topic, so I'm not going to mention it. [01:02:27] Vlad Costea: No, go on. Let's get back to our thoughts. [01:02:29] Ben Arc: No, someone mentioned, because I was thinking about the Strike stuff. [01:02:35] Ben Arc: Everyone in America gets excited about Strike. But to me, I didn't really find it exciting. So I'm like, well, you know. I think in the US they have really shitty legacy payment networks, so paying in shops for stuff just always kind of sucks, and Strike makes all that a lot quicker and whatever. And I don't really see the use case for it here, like we have decent tap and pay, you know, whatever. But someone said about fees, so you know, all business owners, when you're using a legacy, you know, payment system, you get your one or two percent fee, which businesses have to incur. But with Strike, you won't have to do that. [01:03:13] Ben Arc: So you'll be able, but you'll be also able to use a lot of these legacy payment systems and hardware. So I really liked the idea of it being incentivized by getting rid of fees. It's just, you know, it's more profit, isn't it? If you're taking, in fact, for a business, for like a cafe, like all their profit is taken through point of sale interactions. And if there's 2% coming off every transaction, then that's 2% eating into their profits, which is a huge amount, even for a small cafe. [01:03:46] Ben Arc: So if they can get rid of that, then brilliant. And I think it's something which they'll be happy and encouraged to do. I did also think for onboarding, you could offer... You say, look, we'll have a Bitcoin meetup here, you know, buy this hardware wallet off me for 50 quid, even though it only cost me, you know, five dollars or whatever off AliExpress. Buy this hardware off me for fifty dollars and this LNbits package. We'll have a Bitcoin meetup here. The first $50 goes to me to pay me back, and then after that the hardware is yours and the software is yours to use, but I'll charge you 1% for a transaction on it. However, there are these ways where you don't have to pay this 1% if you run it yourself. I certainly want to see more of that kind of, like, I don't know, for Bitcoiners to go out there and earn some satoshis by running little businesses like that, little onboarding schemes. [01:04:43] Vlad Costea: I was actually about to ask you how you make money from open source software, but I guess part of what you've mentioned in the last few minutes is kind of part of the answer, I think. [01:04:53] Ben Arc: Yeah, I mean, the other would be consultancy, people building, you know, maybe there's an extension they want built specifically for their own business, and they don't want it to be a public extension. They just want something built. They're not going to share the code, but they're going to use LNbits as their back end, and they're going to add this extension on. It could be, like, an estate agent, for example, or, you know, a whole bunch of different things. And maybe they would just want their own little private extension. Who better to build that than the people who actually make the software? So there's that kind of, like, you know, consultancy work you get for it. [01:05:33] Ben Arc: There's also proprietary models. Say for something like LNbits, I think LNbits.com, we keep it purposely unstable and dick about on it and, like, test all the cutting edge stuff on it and break it regularly, so people don't put funds on there, because people are naughty and they always put too much money on there. They shouldn't, because it's not a stable, reliable service. It's my node. I could run away with all the funds. There's nothing to stop me doing that. So we don't want people putting too much money on there. [01:06:01] Ben Arc: So it's okay if, you know... At the moment I think it's broken. I need to fix it. We've been playing around with the Spark wallet and some crazy async stuff, and we've managed to break it again. But what was I saying? Where am I? Oh yeah, there is a case for LNbits.com, and I think this probably makes sense to become a reliable service. But in order to become a reliable service, I think it would need to become a business. It would need to have some sort of revenue model where, you know, it could employ someone to maintain the server, to keep the node balanced with channels, to do all the stuff which I can't bother doing, to make it a reliable service. [01:06:42] Ben Arc: And then also, you know, maybe LNbits.com has an extension for cashing out to fiat, you know, a bank transfer or using some sort of exchange or something. I don't know. Or maybe you could have some sponsored extensions, which maybe are only on LNbits.com. So I think there is a case. And that happens a lot in free and open source, where you'll have a commercial arm, and then you'll have that then informs and helps build and stakes bounties, for example, for the free and open source software for everyone else to run. And I think LNbits.com is probably ripe for that. So I will be trying to seek... I don't know. That's why I wanted to get to the Miami Bitcoin Conference, to try and find some capital to be able to make that a reliable service. Because I think that will benefit a lot of people if LNbits.com was like a reliable, always on, not having a dick about on it type service. [01:07:35] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah. So let's get back to hardware wallets for now. And I'm going to... Sorry. Yeah, it's kind of the topic of this season. I'm really sorry that I'm stopping you from talking more about LNbits. [01:07:46] Ben Arc: No, stop me. I'll just go ahead and ramble on here. I tend to ramble on anyway. [01:07:51] Vlad Costea: That's your main gig right now, and I understand that. But I actually got very interested in the Bowser wallet because it's very, very special when you think about it. It has very good intentions, it has very good OPSEC, it has a great form factor. It can just pass as a video game console, a portable one. But I was about to ask you what you think about other hardware wallets that you buy off the market, so commercial solutions, and what was your experience with them? [01:08:24] Ben Arc: I think there's great hardware wallets out there. Maybe on a deeper security level, I know that often we have in Bitcoin, we hold a lot of Bitcoin projects and businesses to very high esteem, and we kind of evangelize, not evangelize, we almost become indoctrinated by software and hardware to a point, because we're so passionate about Bitcoin, we transfer that passion onto hardware and software projects. And then we struggle to see flaws in them. [01:08:55] Ben Arc: And then often you'll have some PhD students, computer scientists, doing a study on the actual security flaws in marketplace hardware wallets. And then, you know, if you read some of those reports, they're quite terrifying. Like, you know, you'll have your hardware wallet transmitting, you know, something you can listen to, and it'll be like just by the, I don't know, the capacitance of one pin or something, you can actually listen to your private key being sent around the device. [01:09:30] Ben Arc: There's all sorts of these weird little hardware [unclear: flaws]. But I think generally these hardware wallets have come along well. I've always been a big fan of Trezor. I've used a Trezor, you know, since they started, I think since they did their Kickstarter, and I've always been very excited by their project and the work they've done. And I've done that, you know, I apply all that love for Bitcoin onto Trezor, and, you know, I look at this thing and I'm just in love with this device, you know. But yeah, so I struggle to look at it with a critical eye, let's say. [01:10:00] Ben Arc: I've used other hardware wallets, and then, you know, I find that they all have benefits. What I really like about the Trezor is, you know, my dad can use it. My 88-year-old dad can see the PIN on the Trezor and then he can input it into his computer. So I think it's very, very simple. [01:10:27] Ben Arc: You haven't got to fiddle around with SD cards and stuff. I know some people who are passionate about their Coldcard wallet, you know, I think their Coldcard is the best thing since sliced bread, but that's the only thing they've ever used. And they've done the same thing, they've applied all their passion for Bitcoin onto this bought piece of hardware. The original Coldcards, I really didn't like the keypads, and the keypads kind of scared me, if they were to fail. I don't know. [01:10:52] Ben Arc: And then also, obviously, you can, I don't know, use a UV light or something to see which keys are being pressed on the keypad, and that could be like a security trade-off. But yeah, I mean, I know people who absolutely swear by these Coldcard wallets. And then BitBox, I've played around with the BitBox. I like the fact it's really small and it kind of looks like a USB stick, so it's a little bit easier to hide. [01:11:17] Vlad Costea: The first generation one or the 02? [01:11:21] Ben Arc: I'm not sure. I think it's the first generation one I got. I got it sent to me by Stadicus. I really like Stadicus. I think he does amazing work. If it weren't for him, like, you know, the RaspiBlitz and all these Raspberry Pi based nodes out there, they all have Stadicus to thank, because he was the guy who did the original RaspiBolt tutorial, which a lot of these projects are based on and are forked from in one way or another. So I really like his work and also his approach to Bitcoin. I think it's very healthy, and hardware as well. So I admire him. I didn't like the form factor of the BitBox, the first one. I didn't like that scrolling thing you had to do with your PIN. I thought my dad couldn't use that, you know. [01:12:05] Vlad Costea: Oh, so you actually received the second one, actually, if it had scrolling. [01:12:12] Ben Arc: I think so. [01:12:13] Vlad Costea: It had touch inputs on the side. [01:12:15] Ben Arc: Yeah. [01:12:16] Vlad Costea: And gestures that you're supposed to touch two points at the same time to validate. [01:12:22] Ben Arc: Yeah, all that stuff, all that touch stuff, I think it was just too confusing for, you know, for some people. So I kind of use my, you know, my elderly parents as my benchmark. If they could use a piece of hardware... I don't think they could use the Coldcard. I don't think they could use the BitBox. They can use the Trezor. I'm not sure about the Ledger. I've never really played around with the Ledger. [01:12:44] Vlad Costea: Okay, but wait. You mentioned that your parents can use the Trezor, but is it the One model or is it the Model T? [01:12:53] Ben Arc: Ah, that's true. Yeah, it's the original one. Yeah, it's the one where you put the PIN in. [01:12:57] Vlad Costea: Okay, so the PIN on the screen is actually a lot more difficult than the touchscreen on the Model T. So it's impressive that your parents can play with the original, which displays a scrambled keyboard on your screen and you're supposed to just click on the corresponding letters. [01:13:14] Ben Arc: Yeah. Yeah, I like that. I think it's, I mean, obviously it's a bit disorientating, because you spent your whole life looking at keypads which make sense, but having all these numbers sort of scrambled around on the screen doesn't make sense, you know, to your brain. But yeah, they can use that. Maybe with those other hardware wallets, I'm, you know, I'm biased, because that's the one I've used. I've used the Trezor, like I said. But yeah, maybe they could use a Coldcard and start playing around with SD cards. [01:13:45] Ben Arc: I don't think they'd be able to use a Bowser wallet, for example. But it's not really marketed at those, I suppose. In fact, I should probably apply that same logic to my own projects and make a... And in fact, I will have to do that for the cafe owner. You know, for the cafe owner who's sort of interested in Bitcoin, I'll have to apply that really simple to use logic. And I think that it's probably like a SeedSigner type scenario where you have like a wire... [01:14:12] Ben Arc: And then, you know, I don't want to plug LNbits again, but they use like the watch-only extension in LNbits. And then they can just, you know, send a PSBT through the wire to the device and then sign it. And then maybe you're under the assumption that the device isn't going to be used for, you know, hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of Bitcoin. Maybe just like, you know, the max, maybe like ten thousand dollars worth of Bitcoin. Maybe you could have some sort of disclaimer on there or something. But yeah, I like very simple to use hardware, software and easy to access hardware, software, both for use and also development. So. [01:14:52] Vlad Costea: Yeah, something about which I have been talking during the last three episodes or something was the fact that if you have a very simple user interface in your hardware wallet, then this incentivizes you to use a longer password that makes you comfortable with setting a longer password. And I suppose when you have this situation with the Morse code, it doesn't really incentivize that, it makes you put like a four-digit PIN or something. [01:15:19] Ben Arc: Yeah, that's true. And then someone could be listening in to decode it. But you know, I like Morse code. I thought it's fun. The issue is, I know I've got three buttons, it's not touchscreen. And I'm like, well, how do I input a range of characters? So it can be numbers or letters. [01:15:36] Vlad Costea: But that's what the BitBox02 has done. So I'm sorry to interrupt, but they have three columns with touch sensors, which are working just like buttons. So you have all the letters of the alphabet divided in three different sections. So you have, for example, A to F on the left, G to S in the center, and T to Z on the right. So if you want to select the letter B, then you're supposed to press left once and then from another grouping of letters, you just select the next one. [01:16:11] Ben Arc: I'm gonna steal that. I'm gonna have that in the new Bowser. That makes perfect sense. [01:16:15] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, and this defeats that UV scanning that you mentioned for the Coldcard, because you touch all the surfaces when you select a letter, so that it's very hard to figure out which letter you have actually pressed. [01:16:31] Ben Arc: Yeah, that is nice. That is nice. That is something which Bowser wallet could do then. Yeah, with just the three buttons. That's a good idea. We should fork it and have a similar input. How do you say "next"? So you've got the three buttons, how do you then say "next character"? I suppose you're just clicking into a character, clicking it, and then it goes to the next character. [01:16:51] Vlad Costea: Yes, or you can maybe do some sort of confirmation by pressing two buttons at the same time. [01:17:00] Ben Arc: Oh yeah, that would work. [01:17:01] Vlad Costea: That's something that Ledger does. [01:17:03] Ben Arc: Yeah, M5Stack has a, in the M5Stack library, there's a double button press thing. Yeah, that's a great idea. I'm gonna look into that one. [01:17:13] Vlad Costea: You should ask Stadicus, because I suppose it was part of his contribution to it. [01:17:20] Ben Arc: I'll give him props. This is something I'm really keen on. There's a great free and open source software license called, it's the DBAD license, which is "Don't Be a Dick." And you can apply it to your software and it's like, yeah, you can use this, you can use this hardware, you can use the software, whatever, just don't be a dick. Like if you make another project off it and then people like that, give me some props, you know. If you make loads of money, then, you know, chuck a little bit of money my way. Just don't be a dick. [01:17:45] Ben Arc: And I think as we're all building and working on top of, this is what Git's great for actually, is you can look through a Git repo and you can see who's contributed where, you can look at the libraries and then see who's contributed to those libraries, and then you can easily accredit people. [01:18:03] Ben Arc: Because after all, all this is computer science, isn't it? And if you look at it in science, scientists will often, if they write a paper, then they have to credit people, don't they, through their references. And it's expected that there'll be references in there, and you have to give them props. And I think a lot of people building free and open source stuff, maybe, I don't know, maybe they're coming from a different angle, but they don't give enough props and recognition to the shoulders of the people they're standing on. So, yes, most definitely, if I had that functionality, I'll be giving my props to Stadicus and all their great work at BitBox. [01:18:43] Vlad Costea: So, have you heard about what Coldcard has done in a similar situation? [01:18:47] Ben Arc: No. [01:18:48] Vlad Costea: So basically, they forked part of the MicroPython code from Trezor, because I suppose every hardware wallet out there copies to some extent what the Trezor does. But they never credited them. See? They just tried to promote their product as if it's something entirely new, and they wrote everything from scratch, and when they got called out for it, they started migrating to their own code. So right now they changed it. And they also changed it because somebody has forked the Coldcard into a new device. [01:19:25] Vlad Costea: And they were not happy with the fact that others can copy them and sell something which maybe fixes some issues with the Coldcard before they get to fix it themselves. And right now they have changed their license. It's no longer MIT. It's some sort of special kind of license which allows the code to be viewed and copied and stuff like that, but you cannot sell it commercially. [01:19:51] Ben Arc: Yeah, no, that's lame. That's lame. You see that kind of behavior. Umbrel is a great project. And it's very easy for onboarding people onto LNbits because you've got one click on the store in Umbrel. But they've been a bit naughty recently with their GUI. I think Christian Rotzoll, he's really impressed with their user interface. And he's like, "Great, I'm going to try and use that on the Blitz. Brilliant." And then when he tried to, they put up a whole bunch of, they blocked him and the license, they applied a different license, so you can't actually use the UI, which makes the whole project not free and open source. [01:20:26] Ben Arc: It's an ego thing and a vanity thing, I think. And it's also like, for example, this podcast, you know, when I came on, you know, and you're like, "Wow, you've made this amazing device. Well done, you." It's kind of hard for me to then turn around and say, "Well, you know, most of it's uBitcoin, really. It's Stepan's work. And I'm just applying it to this small device and then using his library." It's quite hard as a human being. It's quite hard not to take that praise and just say, "Yeah, man, I'm a genius. [01:20:57] Ben Arc: Well done, me." But the problem with the not giving recognition thing and then acting as if you're just some sort of superhuman wizard is it then makes everything look harder for other people. They're like, "Well, I can't do that because this is why," you know. I always sort of try and chastise myself a lot. And I'll try and talk myself down a lot because I'm like, well, if you act like this kind of like wizard developer, which people should have all this respect for and admiration for, then they're going to look at you and think, "Well, I can't do what they're doing because, you know, what they're doing is well beyond me." [01:21:35] Ben Arc: When really the person who's acting with that big ego and is getting that big vanity boost, really they're just working off the backs of other people. It's bad that Coldcard did that, because actually Trezor's got a lot of respect in the space, and them using a Trezor library that would... And, you know, giving recognition and thanking Trezor for that, you know, maybe they could have just said, "Oh, yeah, sorry, we just sort of missed out in there. We just sort of missed out. We didn't think to credit them." I would be more likely to try a Coldcard. [01:22:10] Ben Arc: I'd be like, well, they're using the Trezor's library, which we know is secure and has been tried and tested, rather than writing their own thing. So yeah, it's like a vanity trip thing. People, they don't want to give credit to the people whose work they're working on top of, because they want to take all that praise and admiration for themselves. Which is, yeah, it's just like a hang-up, which I'm sure people will get over as, you know, humanity becomes more familiar with tools like Git, which gives recognition to the people whose software you forked. [01:22:44] Vlad Costea: I very much agree. But I think in the case of Coldcard it was a lot more complicated, because in the beginning they gave credit and at some point they removed it for whatever reason. And they started getting called out for it. They started blocking everyone who was calling them out for it, including myself. I tried to invite them to this podcast. They have a product that is fairly popular, but they did not seem to be interested because they haven't replied to my email. [01:23:15] Vlad Costea: So I don't know what I should say. I'm not trying to be mean here, but in this open source space, if you want to earn everyone's trust, you have to be as transparent and as open about what you're doing as possible. [01:23:28] Ben Arc: Absolutely. And if you try and hoodwink your customers or your users, then that's not really the spirit of free and open source. And you don't want to be using any hardware wallet which isn't free and open source. And if you can't trust that they're going to be very open about which libraries they're using and where they've got them from and things, then you stay away from that hardware wallet. [01:23:55] Vlad Costea: Now, let me tell you that there is this hardware wallet project that's about to launch. It's called Engrave. And I'm not advertising them, I'm actually calling them out. Like whenever I remember about it, I just tweet to them, "Hey, when are you going to publish the code in your GitHub?" Because they marketed the device. There are like three guys from France or Belgium who are working on this, and only one of them is admittedly working in security. So it's likely that their product is a fork of something else. [01:24:25] Vlad Costea: But they refuse to publish any of their code. And I was like, how is anyone supposed to trust that your device is not going to steal their coins? You need to be open about it. You need to publish the code and just earn everyone's trust. And if you claim that it's all patented and you have signed NDAs and you're using whatever sophisticated security chip, then you're supposed to publish a third-party independent security audit, so that people are reassured that this institution, which has no incentive to lie to us, is certifying that your device is secure. But they are still going on with their pre-sale, so you can still order it today. [01:25:04] Vlad Costea: I don't recommend it. I think it's terrible, but at the same time I feel like it's our responsibility when we find these situations to call them out and explain to them, you know, in this industry, we have these standards for honesty and transparency. And if you don't respect these standards, we should call you out, we should discourage people from buying your product, because you're taking advantage of a legacy fiat kind of thinking where people don't know what kind of code goes into their iPhones, so they don't possibly expect, when they start buying their first bitcoins, to also look into the code of the device that they will be using for management and storage. [01:25:49] Vlad Costea: So, I don't know, it's a double-edged sword. So on one hand, you also need to educate newcomers into having expectations for open source software. And on the other hand, you also have to hold all manufacturers to very high standards and explain to them to which market standards they have to abide. But at the same time, and this is the last remark that I'm making, some of these hardware wallet projects tend to support some shitcoins that nobody else supports. So there's this hot shitcoin like, I don't know, like SHIB or something, which got created last week. [01:26:25] Vlad Costea: And there is no hardware wallet that supports it. And then there's one very small manufacturer who's gonna be like, "Yeah, I'm going to support it." And this means that on the short term, they're going to gain the sympathy of maybe 10,000 people who are investing in it. So it means that they're going to sell some units just because of it. So that's how it works. They fork the code from something else like Trezor or BitBox, or they can no longer do it with Coldcards, so Trezor and BitBox are the only ones reliable. [01:26:57] Vlad Costea: From which you can fork the code. And then they sell devices that exclusively are marketed to support some sort of shitcoin, and whoever buys that shitcoin and thinks it's worthy to hold it on the long term outside of exchanges is going to buy their device. And there's a market for this. [01:27:17] Ben Arc: I mean, it's not something which I was entirely aware of, but absolutely, it makes sense, doesn't it? And I guess that is the freedom of free and open source. You know, if you want to get your... Nicolas Dorier is always good at this with BTCPay, because obviously that's used by a lot of shitcoins. I think like their biggest contributor, or financial contributor in donations, I'm pretty sure it's the Bcash Foundation or something. Anyway, but they always just say, "Yeah, we do Bitcoin, you fork, you do whatever you want, you know." [01:27:51] Ben Arc: "It's your free software, do whatever you want with it." And I think that's the right attitude to have. So yeah, it kind of sucks that they're using our cool Bitcoin software for their shitty shitcoins. But at least, you know, those sheep will be nice and safe and people aren't going to lose them. I feel your pain on calling projects out. [01:28:12] Ben Arc: So a project which kind of annoyed me from the beginning, just because it drew... so it took advantage, but it drew upon, you know, what I was talking about before, that passion which a lot of Bitcoiners have. We want Bitcoin projects to succeed and we get excited about these decentralized technologies and things. And I had a very similar experience with Locha Mesh from the Bitcoin Venezuela lot. [01:28:37] Ben Arc: Early on, you know, I was like, "Yeah, cool, mesh networks, great. Bitcoin, great," tick, tick. But there were a lot of lofty promises that they were going to build this, they were going to build that. And I hadn't really seen any evidence that any of these promises were being fulfilled. And there was a pre-order for these devices. And again, you know, I know hardware and it's not that expensive, but they were selling these devices for like $300, I think, or $500 for three. And people were pre-ordering them. [01:29:09] Ben Arc: And I just said like, you know, when are these things going to be shipped to the people who've paid for the pre-order? It felt like a Kickstarter scam, you know, loads of big, lofty promises, not much going on in the repos, not much kind of actual experimentation and, I don't know, evidence that things were being built. And one of the things I asked was like, "Okay, you're getting all these pre-orders for this. You say it's a completely free and open source project. How much money have you made? Like, where's that money gone?" And they've not once been able to clarify that. [01:29:43] Ben Arc: So far nobody's received any of these devices and they kept kicking the can down the road. They had a company which were, I think, supposed to be manufacturing these devices, and then that company folded in January this year. And then everyone related to the Locha Mesh project very publicly said, "I no longer have anything to do with this company." So it kind of felt like a legal move. But it's annoying when you have, you know, it's a bit like one of those white papers for some shitty shitcoin ICO. [01:30:14] Ben Arc: Some techno babble nonsense, some mechanism for people to try and get money from other people. And they use all the terminology and they use all these complicated mathematical diagrams and things, and it's all to try and technobabble someone into parting with their wealth for that project. And I had that impression with the Locha Mesh lot. And sometimes I think people, particularly with pre-sales where they have something they want to make, you had this a lot on Kickstarter, they get a lot of positive reinforcement. [01:30:54] Ben Arc: They get a lot of incentive from people saying, "Oh, you know, you're making this cool thing. I'm super excited about your project. You know, here's my money. Please take my money. I'm looking forward to this project being made." And then, before they know it, they just make bigger and bigger promises until they're never going to be able to meet these promises. And they kind of just end up becoming, maybe not intentionally, they end up kind of becoming scammers. [01:31:18] Ben Arc: I would be very wary of those three people you're talking about, though, who are making a hardware wallet where you can't actually audit the code, and that's just crazy. I don't know why anyone would fall for that. But that's what's frustrating, is that we have all these good standards which people use, open source standards for publishing code and for explaining what's happening in the code or in the hardware. [01:31:43] Ben Arc: And then a company like that is kind of taking advantage of the whole scene, you know, the whole Bitcoin environment, to pitch their product from the same, you know, the same space as those actual, you know, legitimate projects. But yeah, no, Locha Mesh is very similar, and you know, it's still going and they're still saying they're going to deliver on these devices. And you know, I know they have built some software, but I still don't know of one person who's actually ever ran that software or hardware. [01:32:14] Ben Arc: So yeah, I found I got a lot of flak for just mentioning the fact that it may in fact be you know, smoke and mirrors, and it might be turning into a scam as a project. I got a lot of flak from Bitcoiners just for criticizing it, just for dissenting on it. And again, it's going back to that original thing I said before about how we apply a lot of passion and interest and enthusiasm onto these projects, and sometimes we struggle to apply a critical view to them. Did you find that with the hardware wallet? Those three people who are refusing to release the code. Did you find that from general Bitcoiners you got flak, or were they supportive of your criticisms? [01:32:59] Vlad Costea: I feel like nobody really cared. So their target audience is not made out of hardcore Bitcoiners. So the people who bought that device most likely expected to hold shitcoins. They don't run nodes, they don't care about self-validation, they don't care about open source. You know, shitcoins are very centralized and there's a reason why we call them shitcoins. Not because we're some crazy maximalists who only see one coin. It's because, honestly, they don't care much about decentralization, and they're just money grab projects. [01:33:38] Ben Arc: So, yeah. That's what I'm saying, you know, they're pitching their projects. They're using all the good publicity that Bitcoin has for being open source, decentralized, and they're pitching their product as similar to Bitcoin or, you know, a competitor to Bitcoin, and they're saying it has all the same, you know, elements that Bitcoin has. And then a lot of people fall for that. They look at these white papers and think, "Oh, that looks complicated. It looks like it's been written by an actual scientist. I'm going to trust this project and give them my life savings." [01:34:08] Vlad Costea: You know what's insane about that hardware wallet? It's backed by one of the guys who was cited in the Bitcoin white paper. [01:34:17] Ben Arc: Why, Adam Back or...? [01:34:19] Vlad Costea: No, no, no. Let me mention his name exactly. Just give me a moment. So he is the second reference, but I think there are three people mentioned in it. So he is J.J. Quisquater or something, something like that. [01:34:38] Ben Arc: Was he mentioned in the Bitcoin white paper? In the references of the Bitcoin white paper, is he? [01:34:43] Vlad Costea: He's part of the second reference. So there's H. Massias and X.S. Avila, and J.J. Quisquater. He's French. And the paper is called "Design of a Secure Timestamping Service with Minimal Trust Requirements." So this guy is actually endorsing that hardware wallet because apparently it's made in France or Belgium. It's part of their French-speaking world, so I suppose he was excited to have something which most likely competes philosophically with the Ledger. [01:35:20] Vlad Costea: But even the Ledger is a lot more transparent, so even if they cannot open source the parts which deal with the secure element, the wallet parts and the interface parts and everything else is open source, and they also conduct third-party security audits, and they try to be as honest as they can under their limitations. [01:35:42] Ben Arc: I mean, money. I'm sure he's getting some money for it, and maybe he needs money at the moment. It is kind of like sad when these OG cypherpunk types or cryptographers end up on shitcoins like Zooko, Zcash. [01:36:00] Vlad Costea: What's the deal with Zooko, by the way? Because you have been around for a longer time, and I know that Zooko back in 2009 was one of the first people to write about Bitcoin, and he was so hardcore and excited about it. And then he started Zcash just because he wanted privacy. But now he brags about Zcash being endorsed by Chainalysis. [01:36:22] Ben Arc: Yeah, no, it's the same as Vitalik, isn't it? Like a lot of these people, they're Bitcoiners and they love Bitcoin, but they're impatient. I think it just comes down to patience. They're impatient for some functionality, so they rush through foundations which aren't, you know, sturdy. And it's that whole house built on sand scenario. So they can build whatever, and then... and yeah. So all this stuff will eventually come to Bitcoin, and similar functionality will come to Bitcoin, but you've got to be patient, because that's how good development happens. [01:37:01] Ben Arc: But no, Zooko was in cypherpunk threads, you know, years before Bitcoin. He was very active in the community, and yeah, he got excited about, what is it, zk-SNARKs, and then wanted to implement something with them, which is why he came up with Zcash. But then, it's a good project. It's just the founders thing. It's the founders reward and then extending the founders reward and all that nonsense. It just soiled it. Because I know Peter Todd was involved early on. [01:37:40] Ben Arc: There were those videos where they had to come up with the first big number, you know, to base the first Zcash block off or something, I don't know. And Peter Todd and Zooko, they were like up on some mountain somewhere with some air-gapped laptop generating this big number and then destroying the laptops, so it couldn't be replicated or something, and burning them in a fire, and they published all these pictures of this process. So yeah, there are some pretty cool people involved in it, and this is why he got excited. I mean, the same reason he got excited about Bitcoin, he got excited about Zcash. [01:38:15] Ben Arc: But then, because they become you know, the leaders, don't they? Again, it's vanity, you know, like Vitalik, for example, he has so many people around him praising him and saying Ethereum's amazing. But I mean, I think behind closed doors, Vitalik's still a Bitcoiner. And he wishes the best for Bitcoin. And as soon as some of the functionality which is on Ethereum comes to Bitcoin, or is as easy to implement as it is on Ethereum, it becomes easy in Bitcoin, he'll be back. And I think that'll be a good thing. I want them all to come back. [01:38:48] Ben Arc: Bring them all back. Bring Zooko back. Bring Vitalik back. But yeah, it's hard when they're promoting a project which is competing with Bitcoin for them to then say, "Oh, no, Bitcoin's still great," you know. Which is why I suppose, you know, your FluffyPony types, the people who don't go that way, who say, "This is a project for a different use case, but obviously I still adore Bitcoin and Bitcoin is the world to me," then you kind of give them a little bit more slack. [01:39:21] Vlad Costea: You know, FluffyPony is actually a lot more reasonable. And he even went on record to say that Monero doesn't scale. [01:39:32] Ben Arc: It doesn't. I mean, they have to hard fork every three minutes, or whatever it is, every six months to keep it ASIC proof. So no, it doesn't scale at all. But it's useful for people when they want to have private transactions, and you can't have private transactions at the moment on Bitcoin unless you do tumbling. But if you do tumbling, then you could find yourself in a whole heap of trouble, because, sorry, coin mixing. You find yourself in a whole heap of trouble. So we need, you know, Bitcoin to be truly fungible and private one day. [01:40:03] Ben Arc: But for those who are too impatient and they need that functionality now, then you have Monero. There, go use it. Or, yeah, I don't know, maybe do some coin mixing. But, yeah, a lot of it's just patience. We've just got to wait for these things because Bitcoin one day will be... In order for Bitcoin to work, it'll have to be completely private and fungible. [01:40:25] Vlad Costea: How do you regard the privacy on the Lightning Network? [01:40:28] Ben Arc: I mean, it's better, isn't it, in lots of ways to Bitcoin, because you haven't got a blockchain that you can... I mean, obviously you have your original opening, closing transaction to get liquidity on Lightning, but then once it's on Lightning, no one can tell where the hell it is, that liquidity. And so yeah, no, it's... I want to see more and more people using Lightning for that exact purpose. In fact, Bitcoin transactions in general, there should be a lot of data packed into them. So rather than it just being just for its energy footprint, you know, it's a lot of energy for Bitcoin. [01:41:10] Ben Arc: It's cool that I can send a transaction to you in Bitcoin on chain, but I do think that that novelty will one day, you know, people won't be doing that anymore. A single Bitcoin transaction will have a lot of data packed into it. It'll have thousands of transactions on Lightning. It'll have crazy scripts which are being run through things like Taproot. It won't just be a dumb sending of value from one person to another. If that's what you want, then we need incredibly big blocks. And yeah, so no, Lightning transactions, they do come with, in some ways, better privacy than Bitcoin. [01:41:52] Vlad Costea: Oh yeah, I like to compare the privacy of Lightning with the privacy of Tor, even if it's not comparable. And Tor is a centralized project. [01:42:02] Ben Arc: Yeah, no, it's... I mean, everyone who works on Lightning Network, we get super excited. It has its flaws, it has its things which it's going to struggle with, like keeping the network decentralized, the node network. And then it's, you know, it's the unknowns, whether there's an unknown critical bug. I don't think there is, but within Lightning, which could cause some issues. But there's a whole heap of things we can do with it, I think, which will attract a lot of the shitcoiners to Lightning. So a lot of the shitcoiners, they like trying to get yield on their Ethereum, don't they? [01:42:38] Ben Arc: They like their money to work for them and to give them a percentage of interest. I think all that becomes more possible on something like Lightning because it's a hot wallet, and this is what you're having with the, you know, the Lightning Labs liquidity pools. And there's no reason that liquidity which you have in your wallet couldn't be, you know, lubricating the wheels of the economy and being used for something else, being lent out to businesses or whatever else. [01:43:08] Ben Arc: And it can be done in a way where your funds are secure, which is what you have with the liquidity pools with Lightning Labs. So I want to see more of that, like, ability to get yield. And then also, I mean, I think this idea that people are going to be able to make a living on fees on their Lightning node is a complete waste of time, because it's a race to the bottom fee-wise. And ultimately, if the Lightning Network can't be supported on altruism, then... [01:43:34] Ben Arc: It can't exist. So I think running a node, you know, you're not going to make a living off fees. You'll be able to make maybe a little bit of money on the side, but it's a lot of work currently to manage those channels. So hopefully that'll become easier, but I do think there'll be yield to be had by freeing up your Bitcoin in Lightning Network to do other stuff. But in a way which is, you know, secure, that you won't lose your funds. [01:44:00] Ben Arc: Or if you do, then you'd only securely lose, you know, a very small percentage which you're willing to risk or something. And I think that will bring in a lot of footfall from some of those other projects out there. [01:44:11] Vlad Costea: I very much agree with you because I'm running my own node and have been doing this for almost one month. Even though I started experimenting with Lightning in 2018, I was not consistent, so I would open... I think I got the Casa node and I kept it on for about a couple of weeks because I thought it sucked, and it was using such a terrible configuration for what it was aiming to do. And it was slow and noisy and I just hated it and I gave up for a while. [01:44:47] Vlad Costea: And I think right now that I use the RaspiBlitz, it's so much better. And also the hardware has moved a step forward, and I think that this four gigabyte infrastructure is very good and is nearly instant. It's kind of insane that you pay like 70 dollars for this tiny computer which can do so much. And what I know right now is that I'm part of this group which is called Rings of Fire. And we're trying basically to build rings on the Lightning Network with our individual nodes, so that we connect channels to each other in a ring kind of situation to create more routes. [01:45:30] Vlad Costea: And this is also meant to reduce the fees because we said we would altruistically run our nodes and support the network. So basically, we're trying to challenge LNBIG and Bitrefill and Wallet of Satoshi and BlueWallet and all of the big Lightning companies that right now have increased the fees. So if you're trying to make a transaction on the Lightning Network with BlueWallet, you're going to pay an amount which is still less than a one sat per byte transaction on the base layer. But it's still... [01:46:06] Vlad Costea: It's no longer one sat. That's what I'm trying to say. Because I suppose they have provided a very sturdy and reliable infrastructure and haven't made much money out of it. And right now they're trying, at least during this bull market, to make more money. But we're trying to compete with them and provide cheaper fees and better routes to get from point A to point B. [01:46:30] Vlad Costea: And what I can tell you is that even though I'm part of this network and we are trying to build better routing and decentralize the network at the same time, because that's a very important aspect if you ask me, even though all of this is going on, I have only collected like, I think, 30 satoshis in one month. So one every day. It's not much. So this will never pay for the electricity bill. This will never pay for the on-chain transactions that I've made to open the channels. This will never pay for the rebalancing that I might do along the way. But I still love it, and I'm happy with it. [01:47:12] Vlad Costea: And I'm gonna let it run because I know that I'm helping decentralize the Lightning Network, and I encourage more people to do this. [01:47:20] Ben Arc: Yeah, no, absolutely. I mean, we're still very early on and, you know, as payment splitting... So you won't be so limited on routes your payment can take, because it can break up into smaller pieces. Because that was always the big argument for fees. There will be some people who still make large transactions, and you're like, "Well, okay, payment splitting gets rid of that, doesn't it?" So it's consistently a race to the bottom. Like you say, these companies have invested a lot and they've babbled on in meetings with VCs, or justifying it to themselves, that one day they'll be able to run these services and they'll be able to make all this easy money from fees. [01:48:01] Ben Arc: But it's constantly that you're always competing with the cheapest routes. And that's a great project. I didn't know about that project, about this Ring of Fire thing. That's fantastic. But there will, you know, if Bitcoin and Lightning works, there'll be big companies, you know, your Walmart or your Amazon will have their node. And they're not going to charge you fees for using their node. They'll just want your liquidity to move through their node. And that's the bit which kind of worries me about decentralization, is that it's a race to the bottom, but there might be some big players which come in and just offer insane... [01:48:38] Ben Arc: But I mean, it just ultimately doesn't matter, I suppose, because you can just go around them, or you can just exclude them from your routes if they start messing about. And they will still be competing with each other, but yeah, it's going to always be a race to the bottom fee-wise. And there's this little window now where people like LNBIG, they can kind of hold the network hostage and say, "Well, okay, we've got the biggest routes, you know, you have to use us, and we have some sort of monopoly, so we can charge more." [01:49:12] Ben Arc: But that just gets eroded by people like you, and then by the technology, by payment splitting, as well. So yeah, it's... But in saying that, I do think there will be yield to be had on Lightning, but I don't think it will be through fees. It'll be through your Bitcoin being loaned out in some liquidity pool in some crazy, cryptographically secure, funky way. [01:49:35] Vlad Costea: Mm-hmm. Okay, Ben, so I'm not sure if I have any more questions about hardware wallets right now. This is kind of an inside joke because more than half of this episode it was not about hardware wallets, but I'm happy that we talked about all of this stuff. This is almost two hours long, so most people will not get to this point to hear us ramble. [01:49:59] Ben Arc: Oh, that's cool, so we can do anything now. We can just sing a song. [01:50:01] Vlad Costea: Exactly. We should sing "Don't Stand So Close to Me." [01:50:05] Ben Arc: Something to look forward to before we close out is that update to the watch-only extension in LNbits, which will make it compatible with the Bowser Wallet and then all the other cheaper, smaller hardware wallets, which fork away from the Bowser Wallet on different microcontrollers. All those will be possible. And also, you know, anything which uses PSBTs. This is why PSBTs are absolutely outstanding, by the way, and people working on these DIY, free and open source hardware wallets are super excited about them, because it just makes it very easy to, what do you like, you know, multisigging and to make things cross-compatible with each other. [01:50:49] Ben Arc: You just have this standard which we can all use. So yeah, sorry, rambling again. So the thing to look forward to is the update to the watch-only extension, which Stepan says he's going to be working on this week. Basically, he's writing the function for the PSBT, and then I'm going to implement, you know, the GUI, the UI stuff in the actual extension for it. So that's something to look forward to. Plus, yep, fork Bowser Wallet and add your own function, even if it's stupid stuff like, you know, change the names of the menus or something, or just change the colors of the menu items. [01:51:30] Ben Arc: It's very easy to go in and just see where it says, you know, green and change it to red. That's where the term hacking originates, you know, from developers and computer programmers back in the 1970s, 80s, when they were literally hacking away at a keyboard, just trying to get computers to do different things, you know. Take a bit of code and you just hack into it. And that's where the word hacking comes from, the phrase hacking. So do that. I very much encourage that. Fork it, play around with it. [01:51:55] Ben Arc: Anyone out there who's got more skills, or they've already played around with these microcontrollers, then yeah, fork it, improve it if you can, or make different versions of it. I'm very much going to look into your idea, Vlad, of ripping off the BitBox way in which you enter your PIN. It's great, and I'll make sure to give Stadicus props for that. Everyone should look forward to that watch-only extension update, which should be coming out in the next couple of weeks, I guess. [01:52:25] Vlad Costea: Actually, I do have a question for you. How can I get my hands on one of these Bowser wallets? Is there any way I can buy one from you? You know. [01:52:34] Ben Arc: No, just, I mean, you've got the Arduino IDE installed, have you? No? Dude, it's so easy. Go to Arduino.com, go to their IDE. It's free and open source. Just download and install it on your computer. And then, in fact, so uBitcoin, which is the library I'm using for the Bitcoin stuff, you can download. So there's a, you know, in the menu on the Arduino IDE, I think you go to like Tools and then, you know, Library, Install Library, and then you can just search uBitcoin there and you can install it from there. [01:53:06] Ben Arc: And in fact, you can do the same with the M5Stack. It's very easy to do. You're talking half an hour. You've got your, or less than that, 20 minutes. You've got your software set up and then you just plug in your M5Stack. And then you just click on the little upload button and it uploads onto the M5Stack. So don't be scared of it. [01:53:26] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but I'm still going to need to acquire the hardware and disable that Bluetooth and Wi-Fi and everything. [01:53:33] Ben Arc: No, no, no, all that's to say, it's just not enabled in the software. So the hardware, you just go on, you know, Amazon or AliExpress or whatever your time preference/price sweet point is, and then buy one of these M5Stacks. Go for the gray one. I haven't used, and there's a new one actually called the M5Stack 2, I think. I haven't used that yet, but the one which is basically on the GitHub, the repo. Just go buy one of those, just off the shelf. You know, you don't, that's the point, you don't want to buy it from me. I could inject my malicious code into it. Buy it off the shelf, install your Arduino IDE and the libraries, take you 20 minutes. [01:54:12] Ben Arc: Flash it, boom, half an hour, you've got a hardware wallet. And you can verify the code, it's all there. It's really, honestly, don't be worried, don't be scared of it. Just go buy an M5Stack. They're cool. There's a whole bunch of other projects you can make with these things as well. Once you've made a hardware wallet, you could do all sorts with it. One of the other projects I've got with the exact same hardware is a payment module. [01:54:40] Ben Arc: So you can put two wires in it. It's got these little holes which you can put two wires in. And then you can attach that to an LED or something electronic. And it shows a Lightning invoice. You pay it, and then it turns that thing on for a certain amount of time, and you can specify how much time you want it to turn the thing on. So you can retrofit pretty much anything to accept Bitcoin over Lightning using that same bit of hardware. So yeah, just buy it off the shelf and then... [01:55:07] Ben Arc: Download the software and run it. Okay? You can do it. It's not as, you know, the idea is it's designed for hobbyists and, you know, people just playing around with these hardware. I used to teach it in school to kids, like to 12-year-olds, so you should be able to do it. [01:55:31] Vlad Costea: No pressure there, but I still want to do a video about it and show it off just because it's so cool. I just want to play that game of Bowser Tetris. [01:55:40] Ben Arc: Yeah. I wanted to put another game on there. I wanted to put like, there's a Flappy Birds game, which I wanted to put on there as well. So you had like a choice of games. It's a bit like an emulator, and actually make it like a fun little... When they're saying that, I suppose you don't want to incentivize people just actually playing around with these things all the time just as games, and then also using them as their hardware wallets. [01:56:02] Vlad Costea: Yeah, plus you add a lot more attack surface, I think. [01:56:04] Ben Arc: Yeah, yeah, yeah, I get the... I mean, if you're going to buy one, it might be worth buying the FACES kit because that is really nice. It's like 60, 70, but it comes with like, you know, different keypads and stuff you can attach to, and it comes with the charging dock, so you can make that point of sale device. You can do a lot more with it. And I think I will probably bring out a version of the Bowser Wallet which uses the gamepad to input your security PIN. Just, yeah, don't... [01:56:30] Ben Arc: It's funny, isn't it, those cheats? I always think of Doom cheats like IDDQD, IDK. They're just like embedded in my brain. I can't get rid of them, and they're constantly asking to be used as passwords. And I'm like, no, don't use that as a password, because plenty of people use these cheat codes as passwords. But yeah, what was I saying? I think I was rambling again. Yeah, get the M5Stack base model or the FACES kit, and then start building. It's not hard. [01:57:03] Vlad Costea: Okay, and one last question, actually. I know that this has been very long, but where does one begin with open source development? Let's say that I want to get involved. Where can I start if I don't know any coding at all? [01:57:16] Ben Arc: Well, it's that original concept of hacking, isn't it? So you get one of these devices and just do that, just change the color of the menus. It's very rewarding to, you know, change a word or maybe even a line of code as you progress and then have something different happen on the hardware or the software. It was a steep learning curve for me because I didn't have any... I mean, I taught what we call design and technology in this country, so there was a sort of an electronics component of it. This is where I played around with the Arduino IDE. [01:57:45] Ben Arc: But I'd done very... it was like turning on an LED for a few seconds and turning it off again. There wasn't anything complex. And when I first wanted to make the sweet machine, where it showed a Lightning invoice on an e-paper screen from a microcontroller, which was communicating to a node, just getting that QR code to show on that e-paper, it took me months. Months of just hitting my head against a brick wall, until eventually I managed to get that QR code to show on the e-paper. And I was super excited. So I really didn't know what I was doing. And I look back at my code of some of those projects and I'm like, oh God, that was terrible. And since then I've gone in and refactored them. [01:58:34] Ben Arc: But, you know, Bitcoin is full of very enthusiastic people who will totally help you. There's all these Telegram groups for people building things. You can hop in on and ask questions. When, you know, when Stepan was sat down with me at Bitcoin 2019 in San Francisco, my skills back then were still very limited, and he's incredibly, you know, thinking back, he's incredibly patient with me as I'm asking stupid questions. You know, what's a float? What's an integer or something? Something which would just make anyone who actually develops things completely cringe. [01:59:08] Ben Arc: You should know what this is. So yeah, don't be afraid to ask questions. Don't be afraid to, you know, be the dumbest in the room, and then just hack away, do the hacking thing. Take it, change it a little bit, and then you'll think, oh, I could change this, I could make the font bigger, I could, you know, get it to display this. Oh, I might try and get it to do this. Oh, I'll tell you what, it would be cool if I got it to... You know, if you hadn't have told me that idea about the BitBox thing, that would have been a pretty easy thing for you to implement, and a nice little contribution. [01:59:38] Ben Arc: And you could have figured that one out, you know. After a little while you'd be like, "Okay, I can get things on the screen, I can press this button and trigger this thing to happen. Okay, I can have a similar PIN input to the BitBox." [01:59:53] Vlad Costea: Okay, I very much appreciate your answer, and basically it all comes down to wanting to do something as opposed to just thinking about it. You just have to take action. [02:00:05] Ben Arc: Yeah. Direct action. That's what it's all about. That's what Bitcoin is, in fact, direct action in an anarchist sense. [02:00:13] Vlad Costea: Okay, Ben, I think I'm gonna invite you in the next season when we're going to discuss philosophy and the different philosophies involved in Bitcoin. And I know that you call yourself a socialist, which is very, I don't know, antagonistic in this space. A lot of people will judge you and be like, "Oh, you're everything that's wrong in the world," and blah, blah. [02:00:36] Ben Arc: Yeah, this is the biggest... So like, I think I pretty... because I was, you know, my handle was BTC Socialist on Twitter for ages, and I think it muted and blocked me into a corner. So that's why I changed, because I think my projects, my hardware and software projects, were suffering. That's why I changed my name to Ben Arc on Twitter. But I still think I'm blocked and muted by a lot of people. But man, it's, you know, to me, it's free and open source software, copyleft, from each according to his ability, to each according to his need. [02:01:11] Ben Arc: It's very socialist. I can see how other people, say with Bitcoin, for example, you know, express it as just being about extreme property rights, in a libertarian sort of, American-centric, libertarian, more right-leaning kind of way, Austrian economics way. But, you know, when you talk about decentralizing the means of production and control over technologies and over production, that's Bitcoin, isn't it? We don't have a CEO of Bitcoin. We don't have a CEO of LNbits. We don't have a CEO of BTCPay Server, or... [02:01:47] Ben Arc: We... These are free and open source pieces of software, and we're decentralizing the way in which we produce them. So I think, yeah, obviously we'll cover all this on that next season. But to me, it's just, I don't think that the way humans produce things... I don't think we're at the end of history, and that capitalism is the be-all and end-all. I do believe that it can be decentralized. Obviously not through the heavy hand of state, because as we've seen, that has been bad, but there are many ways in which you can decentralize production, such as cooperatives, for example, which are all socialist ways of decentralizing production. [02:02:22] Ben Arc: So yeah, when I call myself socialist, I'm sort of the left-leaning anarchist socialist. But yeah, it would be a pleasure to come onto that. And thanks for mentioning that at the end of this podcast. So, you know, all those hardcore Rothbardians out there, they didn't... you didn't introduce me as Ben, BTC Socialist, because they would have just turned the podcast off. [02:02:43] Vlad Costea: I actually didn't consider this, but I'll take it more as a joke, because I feel like we should not judge people according to their beliefs, but more according to what they do. [02:02:53] Ben Arc: It's interesting as well, like, I find that people... such as, you know, you're Romanian, aren't you? So you've experienced the heavy hand of quote-unquote socialism. And, you know, like Stepan, for example, he's Russian, and crikey, you know. [02:03:14] Ben Arc: But I find that Europeans generally don't care so much. They're like, you know, they're more interested in your point of view, but I feel like with American Bitcoiners in particular, there's this amygdala, immediate "oh my God, you know, you're the devil" type response, which isn't very healthy, I don't think, for discourse and the dialectic. Whereas I think Europeans, they're just, you know, like, they don't really care. They're just like, okay, well, you're making cool hardware, and if I don't agree with your political ideology... But then you can also debate and discuss these things openly without being kind of really attacked. [02:03:55] Ben Arc: I think it's kind of like a binary... Yeah, I'm rabbiting on again, but I think it's kind of more of a binary thinking between good and evil, right, wrong, which you have maybe in the US. I suppose it's to do with the Cold War, probably, and being told that your way of producing things was better than the other people's way of producing things, which it was, because obviously the state was heavily involved. But yeah, I think everything should be debated, discussed, and there should be a dialectic, because that's how People progress and people eventually get more liberty, is through exchange of ideas and not just blanking, just not just, you know, trying to smother concepts. So yeah, but yeah, I'll be happy to come on to that podcast. It'd be great. [02:04:41] Vlad Costea: Oh, yeah. And I suppose that what you explained there can be summarized by Chris DeRose's argument that there are 50-page libertarians and there are 1000-page libertarians. So I suppose it's very easy to just have a very nice summary which encapsulates some ideas and puts them together and makes you resonate with these ideas and think that you're on board with it, even though you don't understand the more complex and nuanced arguments. [02:05:17] Ben Arc: It's all nuanced. So if you go, you know, research libertarian, go to Wikipedia, you'll see on that second paragraph that libertarianism was a leftist tradition up until the sort of 60s, 70s, when it was co-opted by Rothbard and Milton Friedman and the likes of that. So similar with anarchism as well, it's all from the left. But these things were then used by people with a different political view. But it's amazing how many libertarians I meet who don't know that. And you're like... and they'll argue with you, and you'll just be like, "Okay, go change the Wikipedia article if that's what you think." And then the article doesn't change. So I'm assuming that, you know, it's historically accurate. To me, it all goes back to Joseph Proudhon: "Property is theft. Property is liberty." [02:06:12] Ben Arc: It's nuanced. It's complicated. It's not black or white. It's both theft and liberty. In order for you to have property over means of production and over resources, often theft has been involved. But then in saying that, you know, you need to be able to own your home and your tools of production and whatever else. But for some reason, and he was obviously the world's first anarchist, but for some reason that's a kind of complicated concept for people to get their heads around. It's either, you know, property is truly righteous and brilliant and fantastic, or it's evil and... [02:06:45] Ben Arc: You know, we should all be, I don't know, wearing the same outfits and no one should own anything. But they don't think about the nuance and the grey zones. And they should. So yeah, Wikipedia, libertarian. [02:07:00] Vlad Costea: I'm actually looking at it right now, and yeah, a lot of it has started from France, and there were a lot of left-wingers. Because I think in the classical definition, you had the left, which was advocating for less state intervention and more people self-governance, whereas the right-wingers were more in favor of the king or whatever was the authority at the time. But in time, this has lost its meaning, and in the 20th century, you had the right-wingers who found themselves wanting more liberty. So they wanted less state intervention, whereas the left started adding all of these ideas of welfare and state intervention that the state should provide. [02:07:43] Ben Arc: So, well, liberty, liberty. So again, like liberty, let's just ramble, it's all right. Liberty. So, you know, you're not allowed to own another human as a slave. So your liberty has been affected, that you're not allowed to do that thing because it's bad, okay? So the idea is, if you have multiple people, and they're all seeking liberty, there are times where mutual aid, where pooling resources creates more liberty for people, but it is at the trade-off of one individual's liberty. [02:08:16] Ben Arc: And so, yes, pursue liberty, of course, but also understand that that there are certain freedoms which you are not allowed because, or, you know, it's better that you don't have, because then more people can have liberty, if that makes sense. So it's the idea of pooling resources for a health service or an educational system, for example, and that enables more people to have liberty. But then those people who are then having to pay the taxes for that thing, they feel that their liberty is being infringed upon by having to pay the taxes for the thing. [02:08:56] Ben Arc: That's kind of a very statist example, but, you know, it's what we're kind of used to with socialism now in this current era. So it's liberty, fraternity, isn't it, equality. So it's: can you have liberty without peership, without working together, and without acknowledgement of other people? I don't think you can. I think you can have like self-isolation, but I don't think you can have actual liberty. Hegel did a great bit on this. So the Hegelian dialectic of, you know, you have a master, it's called the master-slave Hegelian dialectic, where you have two consciousnesses which meet each other. And then there's a struggle for power, and then one overpowers the other. One becomes the master, one becomes the slave. [02:09:45] Ben Arc: And then as time wears on, the master realizes that their material world is actually being shaped by the slave, because the master is telling the slave what to do. So that frustrates the master, and the master has to belittle the slave and make the slave feel bad about himself and not allow the slave to realize how much power they have over the master by the fact that they're, in fact, you know, shaping that world. So what you end up with is you end up with neither the slave nor the master having liberty, because the master's relying upon the slave, and in a way the slave is being forced to do these things by the master. And the only way you can really end up with liberty is by there being a dialectic and a synthesis, and then the master and the slave becoming peers. But then how do you find peership? [02:10:38] Ben Arc: Well, do you force it through state? Well, obviously that's not really worked, has it? But do you do it through cooperatives? Maybe cooperatives where, you know, you don't have a Jeff Bezos. You have a clever piece of computer code which is managed and operated by the participants of that cooperative, in a free and open source way. And I think Lightning and Bitcoin and all that stuff makes those kind of scenarios easier and more likely to happen. But when we talk about liberty, you can't just say, you know, anything which is in the pursuit of liberty is good, because it's not true. You know, you haven't got the freedom to just go kill someone in the street. [02:11:15] Ben Arc: You know, your liberty is being curtailed. If your child tries to run across the road, you'll stop them because you don't want them to get run over. Your liberty's curtailed there. So it's just not true that, you know... And sometimes, yeah, more people have access to liberty when we practice mutual aid. [02:11:36] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but it's all about, you know, the conversation gets nuanced when it gets to how we provide mutual aid. [02:11:42] Ben Arc: Oh, absolutely. [02:11:43] Vlad Costea: It's all about how you provide it. And that makes all the difference in political discourse. Anyway, I feel like this was a nice tease for what we're going to be doing like in a couple of weeks after I finish this season. [02:11:58] Ben Arc: So I love the seasons. I love the way you do these seasons, so somebody can listen to a whole season on a subject like hardware wallets, for example. It's a really nice way to... Have you had Stepan Snigirev on here then? [02:12:12] Vlad Costea: No, I haven't. I should, right? [02:12:15] Ben Arc: Yeah, you really should. [02:12:17] Vlad Costea: But I'm not acquainted with his work, so this is the first time when I hear about him during my interview with you, so I wouldn't really know what to ask him. [02:12:27] Ben Arc: I'd ask him about Specter, Specter wallet, and DIY wallets. Ask him about uBitcoin, his libraries. Yeah, you've got plenty to ask him. I mean, he'll just talk as well. He's been on some other podcasts, and for people who are less informed than you are on hardware wallets. I'll ask him... I'll try, I'll ask him to come on, because he's great. And, you know, we're all stood on his shoulders when it comes to building these DIY hardware wallets. [02:12:57] Vlad Costea: Okay, I appreciate it. If you could connect me, that would be great. [02:13:01] Ben Arc: Yep. I'm looking forward to listening to it. [02:13:04] Vlad Costea: So it's also a selfish reason. [02:13:06] Ben Arc: Yeah, of course. Self-interest, that's what it's all about. [02:13:09] Vlad Costea: Exactly. So thank you very much, Ben. This was really great. And it went on for longer than I expected, but all of it was great. So it's very hard to keep up with you because you come out with all of these ideas that you present in a very fast way. Maybe that your accent also takes some time for my brain to process. [02:13:32] Ben Arc: I'm also a rambler and I sort of slur a little bit. And yeah, I'll take that on board and I will actually try and talk a little bit slower. [02:13:40] Vlad Costea: But you're a brilliant guy, let me tell you this. [02:13:43] Ben Arc: No, I'm a hobbyist. Just a hobbyist. [02:13:45] Vlad Costea: Exactly. A brilliant hobbyist. You know, it's very hard to keep up with you and I find myself getting challenged and I love this. It's just that it makes me feel like I'm learning something new. [02:13:56] Ben Arc: Cool. Thanks, man. Well, I love the stuff you do, so continue doing it. [02:14:01] Vlad Costea: Thank you. And say hello to Thomas from me, because he didn't want to be on my radio broadcast. He felt like it's competition and he doesn't want to engage. [02:14:12] Ben Arc: Ah, he's just lazy. Yeah, no, he's just being lazy. Yeah, maybe if you do a series, a season 10 on NFTs, get Thomas on, because he's the NFT OG at the moment. [02:14:22] Vlad Costea: Really? [02:14:23] Ben Arc: Yeah, he made these things called Curio Cards way early on, and I think it was like the first. Yeah, I mean, obviously there's been lots of examples of NFTs, but yeah, he was pretty important in that space. It was funny because he gave up on it all. He made these things which he thought were cool, and then nobody cared. [02:14:48] Ben Arc: And then he gave up on it. And then all these people started writing articles. They started discovering this card series he'd made, and they started writing articles on it. And he was like, "What the hell?" And then suddenly this NFT thing blew up. And he was like, "Oh, right, okay, now the world cottons on. When I was enthusiastic about it, no one cared. Now I don't care, everyone cares." So it's quite funny. [02:15:05] Vlad Costea: I think it feels the same when you're David Chaum and somebody invents Bitcoin and for years nobody cared about your cryptography and all of a sudden your ideas end up becoming so successful. [02:15:16] Ben Arc: Yeah, exactly. It must be frustrating. But at least we give him props, eh? Oh, yeah. That's the important bit. Props to Chaum. Cheers, man. [02:15:25] Vlad Costea: I actually did an interview with him in 2019. He was nicer than you'd expect. [02:15:31] Ben Arc: Did you really? Wow, I'm going to check that out. He seems like a nice bloke. Yeah, he looks like a normal human being from what I've seen in his talks and things. [02:15:45] Vlad Costea: He's nice, but at the same time, I felt like... He's a fan of Bitcoin and he also likes Monero because I think Monero is closer to what he was trying to do with eCash. He didn't care much about the monetary value and sound money, so he had no ideological weight added to his project, so I think Monero is closer to his idea. [02:16:08] Ben Arc: I see. That's interesting. Yeah, I'll dig that out and have a listen. [02:16:12] Vlad Costea: Anyway, I felt like an idiot all the way through. I felt like I wanted to talk with him, but at the same time when I finally got to talk with him and do an interview, I had no idea what to ask him. [02:16:22] Ben Arc: Oh, I've done that before, don't worry. I think we've all done that before. [02:16:25] Vlad Costea: It was just a selfish thought that I wanted to talk to David Chaum. But when I got in front of him and I was about to start the interview, I felt like an idiot. [02:16:37] Ben Arc: Yeah. Yeah, I've had similar experiences in the past. I'm sure if you did it now, you would have a lot more to say. [02:16:43] Vlad Costea: Yeah, but that's what happens all the time, right? You meet some person and you have this opportunity to do an interview. And then you feel like you blew it and you reflect on it and you already know the next day how you would have improved it if you put more thought into it. But I don't know, it's just how it goes. [02:17:06] Ben Arc: Yeah, you'll get another chance with Chaum, don't worry. [02:17:08] Vlad Costea: I hope so. [02:17:09] Ben Arc: I'm sure. [02:17:10] Vlad Costea: Okay, Ben. So I hope I also get another chance with you in the next season, and I'll talk to you later. [02:17:17] Ben Arc: Yeah, cheers, man. Nice speaking with you. Cheers. [02:17:20] Vlad Costea: You can follow Ben at BenArcBTC, I think, on Twitter. Is that what your name is? [02:17:26] Ben Arc: No, it's arcbtc. @arcbtc, yeah. And then I think it's the same for the GitHub stuff too. And there is a World Crypto Network playlist. So if you go on YouTube for my BTC IoT stuff, you'll actually see, I didn't even talk about this, but I should have because we're talking about hardware wallets, you'll see those original hardware wallet projects on there. So the reason it's called the Bowser wallet is because the original one was called the Goomba. And I had this Mario theme. And then I had the little guy with the, you know, the little turtle guy with the throwing the axes. [02:18:00] Ben Arc: He was like the next generation of Goomba. Like Goomba was just a watch-only. And then the little guy with the axes, he was the watch-only with the e-paper display. So then Bowser's like, you know, the big boss. [02:18:12] Vlad Costea: Makes sense. Makes sense. I think the name of the hammer one is Hammer Bro or something. [02:18:17] Ben Arc: Yeah, it's something like that. Yeah, it's something like Hammer Bro. Yeah, maybe Mini. I can't remember. But yeah, he's on there. Oh, no, I've lost it. [02:18:27] Vlad Costea: But if you have a Nintendo Switch and you play video games, I have a Telegram channel for that, for Mario Kart. [02:18:33] Ben Arc: I daren't. No, I daren't. I love computer games, but they destroy me. There's some things I can't go near: marijuana, computer games. It just sucks my life out of me, and I just play them, I just do it consistently, constantly. And yeah, I have to stay away from them. But I'm loving the development of Bitcoin and Lightning stuff in computer games at the moment, particularly Zebedee. So if anyone's going to BTC Miami, if you're able to get there, go check out. They're going to have a huge e-gaming event, part of the conference, and Zebedee are doing some great stuff. [02:19:06] Ben Arc: And what's great about them as well is that they're not trying to make new computer games, like shitty Bitcoin games with Bitcoin in. They're just taking popular computer games and then putting Bitcoin in them, you know, your CS:GO and your Minecraft and whatever else, and that's great. So I look forward to, you know, because these kids, if they can, I don't know, go on Call of Duty and kill a bunch of people and earn some sats, then they're gonna love it. [02:19:34] Vlad Costea: Kind of a terrible incentive, right? You get money for killing people. [02:19:37] Ben Arc: Yeah. But to me, there's always people bringing out all these Bitcoin games. This is the last thing we'll talk about. And those people bringing out these Bitcoin computer games, and I just thought, just take like Quake or something. Like, I just want to pay a thousand sats to join a game, and like 20 people play, and then whoever wins gets, you know, the 20,000 sats. That's all I want. I don't want any complicated, fancy schmancy stuff. I particularly don't want some game which is like built around the fact that it's got Bitcoin in it, because it's probably going to be not very good. [02:20:09] Ben Arc: You know, I want a popular, well-tested, good game, like a Fortnite or something, but the ability to just kill people and then earn sats for killing. That'd be great. And Zebedee seems to figure that one out, and they're working on that. So looking forward to that. [02:20:24] Vlad Costea: Yeah, there's also Lightnite, which is a clone of Fortnite that's built around Bitcoin, but it was built from scratch. It took longer than expected to ship. And I'm not sure if it's so great. I haven't tried it, to be honest. [02:20:39] Ben Arc: Yeah, it's always, this is what I'm talking about, see. It's a shame because it's just, you know, the Quake one, for example, there's Quake.js and you can run Quake in a browser, and it'd be pretty easy just to implement some Bitcoin Lightning payments into it, you know, to join in a match, and then when you win, you get the Bitcoin. But nobody's done it. [02:21:01] Vlad Costea: Plus, I think that Quake was open sourced by John Carmack, or at least the engine for it. [02:21:06] Ben Arc: Exactly. Yeah. And it's just like you could just quickly have a quick game, kill some people. Brilliant. Yeah. Anyway, so yeah, I'm very much looking forward, because I think Bitcoin over Lightning Network is going to revolutionize computer games. It's honestly, it adds a whole extra layer. Just like, you know, streaming content, like yourself, like you said, with adding a faucet to your podcasts, or a video streamer, like having things trigger when someone makes a payment, an instant payment. It just is going to revolutionize that as well. [02:21:44] Ben Arc: It will have a huge impact on computer games. So I'm really looking forward to it happening. Hopefully these computer games won't, they're not going to go all shitcoiny. That is also the other danger, I guess. [02:21:53] Vlad Costea: Okay, Ben. [02:21:54] Ben Arc: Yeah, it's just going to keep going unless we stop. Right, bye. [02:21:58] Vlad Costea: Bye. See you soon. [02:22:00] Ben Arc: Cheers. [02:22:02] Vlad Costea: Vaultoro has a 100% track record with fully audited and insured gold bullion that are secured in a top-tier, tax-free Swiss vaulting facility. It also features a generous affiliate program, OTC trading, physical delivery and pickup, or trade back to Bitcoin in seconds. Register for free and check out the ways in which you can trade hard money and preserve your wealth. And if you want to help this show, sign up using the vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover link that you can also find in the description. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice. [02:22:50] Vlad Costea: All trading involves risks and you are responsible for your own decisions. Wasabi Wallet's innovative CoinJoins will make your bitcoins more fungible. So if you accumulate more than 0.1 BTC, you can mix it with other users to remove all traces about their whereabouts. So it's like putting multiple fingerprints on your dollar bills, and it becomes impossible to determine the last few owners of the money. Download Wasabi Wallet today and start CoinJoining! ================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio/video interview in English, opened by a music intro and sponsor reads for Vaultoro and Wasabi Wallet, with further sponsor reads mid-episode and at the end. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 12 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (192 chunks) and 32 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 3 of 3 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021" and stray "Thank you."; Vaultoro, LNbits, Stepan Snigirev, uBitcoin, Ken Sedgwick, Blockchain Commons, Specter, ESP32 fixed; restored dropped "But in the context of Season 8, he has also developed", "too busy", "now/in beta" from second ASR; re-split turns at 00:02:41, 00:03:42, 00:05:25 per plan; "added the ability" (not "you had"); removed fillers/repetitions; Guest A → Ben Arc; split Vlad/Ben turns (16:17 "Yeah, absolutely", 21:40 "know.", 21:55 Rachel Bryan question); fixed Stepan Snigirev, BitBoy, Trezor, M5Stack/M5Stick, FACES kit, D-pad, ESP32, uBitcoin, SeedSigner, RISC-V, Pieter Wuille, Bitcoin Core, "browser"→Bowser, "toothbrush", "free open source", "Watch-only"; split long monologues; Speaker labels Guest A→Ben Arc; split Vlad's "So, how much does it cost" question at 00:29:32 and Vlad's interview resumption after ads; restored Vaultoro intro (V-A-U-L-T, oro) via audio re-check, fixed "The first gold"/Voltoro→Vaultoro; fixed M5Stack, FACES kit, LNPoS, LNbits, PSBT (from PSPT), Electrum 3.3.8/4.0, parse (pass), Coldcard, Cobo Vault, BitBoy, ESP, ESP-IDF, "spit out sweets", "port", "reliable", "point of sale"; removed fillers and stray "you"; Speakers: Guest A → Ben Arc; split Vlad/Ben turns at 00:40:13, 00:44:43, 00:44:59, 00:45:21, 00:45:36, 00:45:57, 00:49:24. Fixed PSBT, Specter, Blockchain Commons, blob, embit, LNbits, uBitcoin, PlatformIO, ESP-IDF, Espressif, Blockstream, operation, Simplicity, Fulmo Jeff, Christian Rotzoll, Jörg Platzer, Room 77; restored dropped text ("high-end Samsung or iPhone", "encouraging and there wasn't any of that", "they had to make a hardware wallet so people could start playing"); "O'Fedipa" marked unclear; filler/repetitions removed; Guest A relabelled Ben Arc; LNBits/LM bits/Alan Bitts → LNbits, Steppen → Stepan, TPOS → TPoS, Voltoro → Vaultoro; removed "The video is available on the YouTube channel. The link is in the description." hallucination and restored dropped speech (VPS/light node/$10 hardware wallet) from Scribe/Qwen; "cafe" → "cashier", removed garbled "but you can't accept Bitcoin"; ad start "Hey, psst..." split to Vlad; removed stray "Thank you."; split Vlad's "No, go on" interjection and Ben's "Yeah, it's great"-style turn starts; Fixed LNbits/LNbits.com, Strike (vs Stripe), Coldcard, BitBox, Trezor, Stadicus, RaspiBlitz/RaspiBolt, SeedSigner, PIN, form factor; restored "hide", "esteem", "incur", "88-year-old" via second ASR; resplit Vlad/Ben turns at 01:07:35-01:07:51, 01:11:17, 01:12:05-01:12:16, 01:12:44, 01:12:57; labelled Guest A as Ben Arc; split long monologues; Fixed LNbits, PSBT, Stadicus, Christian Rotzoll, Umbrel, Coldcard, BitBox, Trezor's, M5Stack, Bowser; removed "Thanks for watching! Please subscribe..." hallucination and UV/that doublings; repaired speaker splits (Ledger line, Stadicus question, "No" answer, "Absolutely" by Ben, "software you forked" to Ben); removed "subjugator" garble; Speaker repairs: 01:26:57 is Vlad's continuat