Snapshot forks vs chain splits
Why some “forks” share Bitcoin's history and others only copy its balances, and why it matters for claiming coins.
The wiki's angle: whether a fork kept Bitcoin's history decides what holding at a fork block meant — a key in a wallet, or a row in an exchange's database.[2][6]
Chain splits
In a chain split the new coin keeps Bitcoin's blocks up to the fork. The Bitcoin Top README puts it this way: “It shares the same transaction history with Bitcoin until it starts branching”[1]. The 2019 fork reviewer tested such coins by importing “all the shared pre-fork blockchain data” and swapping in his Bitcoin Core wallet.dat[2].
Snapshot forks
The same list marks four coins as “snapshot fork (no shared pre-fork blockchain history)”: Bitcoin CBC, Bitcoin Pizza, Bitcoin 2 and Bitcoin Private[2]. For Bitcoin 2 it quotes the plan that “the blockchain data will be pruned from over 150 GB to around 2 GB”[2]. Bitcoin Private's README describes it as “a fork of Zclassic, merging in a snapshotted UTXO set of Bitcoin”[3]. BitcoinCash Zero went further and announced snapshots of four chains at once[4].
Exchange snapshots
Some forks handed the snapshot to exchanges. Bitcoin Pay said “EXX.COM And OURDAX.COM A snapshot has been given first”[5]. Smart Bitcoin listed exchanges that had “agreed to take snapshot” for it[6]. Bitcoin Ore issued its first coins only “to users of these four exchanges at block height of 501949”[7]. New Bitcoin called itself a snapshot fork (“快照分叉”) at block 501225[8].
References
- primaryBitcoin Top README, GitHub bitcointop/bitcointop [archived]
- secondary“My list of 43(+3) reviewed Bitcoin forks”, Bitcointalk topic 2777849 (last update 26 Feb 2019) [archived]
- primaryBTCPrivate/BitcoinPrivate-legacy README (GitHub) [archived]
- primaryBitcoinCash Zero, “[ANN] [NEW] [FORK] BitcoinCash Zero $BCZ - 2019, January the 4th”, Bitcointalk topic 5086626 (18 Dec 2018) [archived]
- primaryBitcoin Pay website, btceasypay.com (Wayback Machine copy, 1 Feb 2018)
- primarySmart Bitcoin website, smartbitcoin.one (Wayback Machine copy, 21 May 2018)
- primaryBitcoin Ore website, bitcoinore.org (Wayback Machine copy, 20 Feb 2018)
- primaryNew Bitcoin (新比特币) website, newbitcoin.org (Wayback Machine copy, 4 Mar 2018)