Covert ASICBoost and SegWit
In April 2017 Gregory Maxwell proposed a soft fork (never given a BIP number) to block the covert form of ASICBoost, a mining shortcut he said was built into a major manufacturer’s chips and that SegWit would interfere with.
Gregory Maxwell
Covert ASICBoost gave its user a hidden edge worth up to $100 million a year and a reason to block protocol upgrades such as SegWit.
Bitmain
It said it had tested ASICBoost on testnet but never used it on mainnet, demanded proof, and called Maxwell’s maths incorrect.
It tied the SegWit standoff to a patent-protected mining edge, which made a technical fight look like a commercial one.
Maxwell’s soft fork was not deployed. SegWit activated in August 2017. Overt ASICBoost (version rolling) later shipped in miner firmware, and in 2018 AntPool was reported to have mined a block with it.
- 5 Apr 2017Maxwell posts the proposal to bitcoin-dev. [1] [2]
- Apr 2017Bitmain denies using ASICBoost on mainnet. [1] [2]
- Aug 2017SegWit activates. [1]
- 2018AntPool reported to mine block 540,032 with AsicBoost. [1]
“Reverse engineering of a particular mining chip has demonstrated conclusively that ASICBOOST has been implemented in hardware.”
bitcoin-dev · 5 Apr 2017 · source
“the protocol interactions of the covert method can block the implementation of virtuous improvements such as segregated witness.”
bitcoin-dev · 5 Apr 2017 · source
“Bitmain has tested ASICBOOST on the Testnet but has never used ASICBOOST on the mainnet as implied in Gregory Maxwell’s proposal.”
secondary source: statement as quoted on Bitcoin Stack Exchange (and CoinGeek); Bitmain’s own blog post could not be fetched · Apr 2017 · source
“This has not been confirmed.”
Bitcointalk · Apr 2017 · source