CTV: the covenant that keeps knocking
OP_CHECKTEMPLATEVERIFY (BIP 119, Jeremy Rubin): an output can commit to the exact transaction that spends it — vaults, congestion control, channel factories, cheaper DLCs.
For · Rubin, the 2025 open-letter signers, the 2026 activation client
Simple, non-recursive, well-understood and reviewed for years. Activate it, or say clearly why not.
Sceptics
Not flexible or generic enough, little real experimentation (Optech's summary of criticisms); worries that activation is being pushed without broad consensus.
Three activation pushes: a 2022 Speedy Trial proposal, a July 2025 open letter signed by 66 people, and a 2026 activation client signalling on bit 5 (90%, 30 Mar 2026 – 30 Mar 2027, min height 1,001,952).
Still Draft. In difficulty period 484 the signalling monitor counted 0 of 920 blocks (0.00%) on 20 Nov 2026. Its successor-style rival BIP 446 (TEMPLATEHASH) arrived in 2026.
- 6 Jan 2020BIP 119 (CTV) is assigned. [1]
- 17 Apr 2022Jeremy Rubin publishes “7 Theses on a next step for BIP-119”, floating a Speedy Trial. [1] [2]
- 2 May 2022After the backlash, Rubin posts “On The Drama”. [1]
- 9 Jun 2025An open letter asks Bitcoin Core to review and integrate CTV + CSFS. [1] [2]
- 17 Jun 2025Antoine Poinsot says the letter puts political pressure on Core. [1]
- Feb 2026A CTV activation client is published, signalling on bit 5. [1] [2]
“I still do not know exactly what happened and why.”
bitcoin-dev · 2 May 2022 · source
“We believe that the best next step for bitcoin would be to activate OP_CHECKTEMPLATEVERIFY (CTV, BIP-119) and OP_CHECKSIGFROMSTACK (CSFS, BIP-348).”
bitcoin-dev (posted by James O’Beirne) · 9 Jun 2025 · source
“Instead of addressing minor objections to the design of the operations and working on demonstrating (real) use cases, the champion chose the route of political pressure on the Bitcoin Core project.”
bitcoin-dev · 17 Jun 2025 · source
“In changing Bitcoin, the process matters as much as the outcome.”
bitcoin-dev · 17 Jun 2025 · source
“Ctv finished in... 2019 ?”
X · 9 Nov 2026 · source
- S17 E38: Vlad on Jeremy Rubin's 2022 Speedy Trial attempt for CTV▶ listen at 7:53timestamp transcript-derived, pending a listen
- S17 E38: Keagan McClelland — CTV “used to be called OP_SECURE_THE_BAG”▶ listen at 10:17timestamp transcript-derived, pending a listen
- S16 E23: James O'Beirne on CTV and MEV▶ listen at 5:34timestamp transcript-derived, pending a listen
- S17 E22: Vlad on CTV's earlier name, Secure the Bag▶ listen at 3:26timestamp transcript-derived, pending a listen