2023–2026 ·
Ordinals: the BIP that never got a number
What it proposed
Casey Rodarmor’s “Ordinal Numbers” pull request (#1408, January 2023) asked for a BIP number for a scheme that gives every satoshi a serial number.
Casey Rodarmor and supporters
A BIP documents a standard people use; it is not an endorsement, so being controversial is no reason to refuse a number.
VS
Opponents, incl. Luke Dashjr
Numbering sats harms fungibility and encourages spam. The standard should live in its own repository, like Lightning’s BOLTs or SatoshiLabs’ SLIPs.
Why it blew up
It turned the BIP editors’ merge button into a vote on inscriptions, and the pull request sat open for more than three years.
Outcome
On 4 March 2026 BIP editor Kanzure rejected the pull request, declined to assign a number and closed it.
Timeline
- 20 Jan 2023Pull request #1408 opened. [1]
- 14 Feb 2023Luke Dashjr calls it within scope but urges withdrawal. [1]
- 6 Dec 2025Rodarmor notes the PR has been open nearly three years. [1]
- 4 Mar 2026Rejected and closed without a number. [1]
In their own words
“An accepted BIP does not indicate endorsement by the BIP repo maintainers, Bitcoin Core, or the larger Bitcoin community.”
GitHub, PR #1408 · source
“Seems within scope to me, even if ultimately rejected by the community.”
GitHub, PR #1408 · 14 Feb 2023 · source
“Though since this is essentially an attack on Bitcoin, I would encourage the author to withdraw it and abandon it entirely.”
GitHub, PR #1408 (edit) · 14 Feb 2023 · source
“I don't think this should be a BIP, but rather it should be managed separately like BOLTs for lightning, EIPs for Ethereum, and SLIPs for Satoshi Labs proposals.”
GitHub, PR #1408 · source
“Numbering satoshis is an attack on bitcoin in several ways, including by damaging fungibility, encouraging spam, and encouraging scamming.”
GitHub, PR #1408 · 15 Jan 2025 · source
“I am rejecting this proposal to merge Ordinals into the BIP repository and will not be assigning a number.”
GitHub, PR #1408 · 4 Mar 2026 · source
In the Bitcoin Takeover Wiki