S15 E62: Josh Swihart & Kris Nuttycombe on Zcash & Privacy
Search this conversation
0:44Vlad CosteaHello there, and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 15, Episode 62, and we're going to be talking about Zcash. But before that, I got to mention the sponsors. It's a special episode because Cake Wallet just started sponsoring the show. And as always, we have SideShift, we have Hodling.ch and LayerTwo Labs. The guests today are the CEO of the Electric Coin Company, which is one of the companies that works on Zcash development, and his name is Josh Swihart. And also a Zcash core developer whose name is Kris.
1:19And his name on Twitter is actually nuttycom, but it's Nuttycombe that is his last name. And they are doing some cryptographic magic with zero-knowledge proofs, and there's a lot of interesting stuff to discuss in this episode. So thank you for joining.
1:37Josh SwihartGreat to be here. Thanks, Vlad.
1:38Vlad CosteaI'm super excited for this one. Let's go into Zcash right now, because I think that a lot of people reacted to the existence of this episode, and most of them are maximalists. And the way in which they react is, you know, why do you still care about Zcash? Because it's a failure, it's a shitcoin, it's been around for eight years now, and what's the point? You know, it hasn't gone up, because apparently the metric to measure the success of something is just the price. So what's happening with it, and why would you say that it's not a shitcoin?
2:12Josh SwihartOh, gosh. Well, I mean, from the beginning, right, and the maxis know this too, right? Satoshi's kind of belief was that having pseudonymity would be sufficient for privacy, without kind of recognizing all of the capabilities that would be developed to be able to tag and trace. And very famously stated that if he could figure out how to get zero knowledge to work on Bitcoin, it would be better. And so it was kind of a challenge, right? So zero knowledge was theoretical math.
2:46It's like you have a... it was a kind of a mechanism for proving math statements, but there was like no practical application of it. I think many people weren't sure there would ever be a kind of a practical application of it. And so it was really a challenge when Satoshi laid that down to a number of academics, to figure out how to add zero knowledge to Bitcoin. So that's what they did, and figured out how to do it, forked, you know, went to the Bitcoin Core team and suggested that they found a solution.
3:21And Bitcoin Core, probably rightly so, said, like, the cryptography is too novel, right? At the time, it was just too computationally intensive to create a proof. It just wouldn't work at scale. And we had something called the trusted setup, which people were skittish about. So Zcash kind of launched as this grand experiment, saying, can we add encryption to Bitcoin and make this work? And then at some point, you know, maybe the Bitcoin Core team kind of comes back and says, OK, now the cryptography's been proven, we'll add this to Bitcoin. Now, they've taken two radically different paths, right, these two projects.
3:57And so the narrative of Bitcoin went from peer-to-peer electronic cash to digital gold. And we've continued to focus on the, you know, the core where this all started, which was peer-to-peer electronic cash. So, like, digital gold, you're treating it as a store of value asset, and we now have the financialization with all the ETFs and all that kind of stuff, which, great. I mean, the number go up and people get rich and all that kind of stuff. But that's not what we're here to build. We're here to build tools for financial freedom, allow people to transact peer-to-peer. So that's what our focus has been. I don't think people realize how hard doing that zero-knowledge work is, and how much time and effort it's taken to get it performant, right?
4:50So I mentioned at the beginning, it was like too computationally intense to be able to use at scale. And then we've since had some other cryptographic breakthroughs that allow for it to be, you know, used on mobile devices or hardware devices or things like that. And then, you know, most recently, or within the last couple years, getting rid of this thing called trusted setup, which was another massive cryptographic breakthrough that came from our core team. And I think now we're starting to, like, build capabilities on top of the stack that are really going to allow it to scale for payments.
5:26So it's just... yeah, eight years ago, and it's just a ton of work and a ton of breakthroughs and things that have been happening, maybe kind of outside of the crypto casino.
5:39Kris NuttycombeYeah. And, you know, we still don't really, in widespread adoption, we don't have cash for the internet, right? It's not something that exists. And you can't have cash for the internet on a system where, you know, your bank balance is connected when you buy anything, right? You've got to have privacy and unlinkability from one transaction to the next for us to actually have cash for the internet. So, like Josh said, it's been a long road of technological developments. And just now, I think, with the end of the trusted setup, with the breakthroughs that are going to enable recursive zero-knowledge proving, there are now options for how to build this out at scale, to really make that thing that we want, which is cash.
6:35You know, cash online, where anybody can go and start, you know, build something without having to go to a bank and, you know, get a credit card processor, and, you know, enable people to just transact truly freely between each other.
6:55Vlad CosteaI think many of my friends got radicalized sometime in 2018, after they saw the whole ICO market go down, and they saw that many of the altcoins that they expected to become the next Bitcoin did not become the next Bitcoin. And that's when they lost interest in projects, you know, and they put everything in the same basket and they said, these are all shitcoins. But they have no idea how far Zcash has come and how much interesting stuff was built in the meantime. I remember when I met Amir Taaki at a conference two years ago, he was always telling me, Zcash, man, there's that Halo 2 mixing pool that's very powerful, and I want to use that in my, what's it called, DarkFi project, and stuff like this.
7:38And I was thinking, you know, this guy, he was always avant-garde. He was always paying attention to the new stuff that's out there. He doesn't really seem interested in looking in the past. And there's also the situation with T-addresses and Z-addresses. Because when Zcash came out, I guess the computation required to have these shielded transactions was too powerful, was too intense for the software and the hardware at the time. So it was only possible to have confidential transactions on your computer, on software that was running a node, as far as I know. And most transactions on Zcash in the beginning were not the shielded ones, because the computation and the calculations that were required were maybe too much for a mobile wallet or stuff like that. But you have managed to pull it off now. You have the unified addresses, you have confidentiality even on a wallet, or something very light like Zashi that you can download on your phone.
8:39And most people are not aware how much work it takes to get from just having mostly open, verifiable transactions on the blockchain, just like Bitcoin, to having everything private by default.
8:54Josh SwihartYeah, it is a lot of work. I mean, the T-address, the transparent address, is both a blessing and a curse, right? So, you know, when it was launched, you know, the decision was made by other people, not here, to support the T-addresses. They're basically Bitcoin-style transactions or addresses. And just because it's a UTXO model, it was super easy for exchanges to onboard and to list. You know, we knew that was going to be a long road, because, you know, to create a proof, one, yeah, it just didn't work at scale.
9:28And then you're going to have to make modifications to HSMs and things like that in order to be able to support the curve. So it allowed for kind of wide adoption and distribution of tokens, and all of the things that kind of happened there, recognizing that it was going to take some years to really solve some of the really kind of hard problems with the cryptography and getting it performant. But it's also a curse, right? Because it's the, you know, widespread perception that it's not private by default. You know, that meme's been kind of thrown around a lot, and you've seen just the volume of transparent transactions versus shielded transactions, which has made sense historically.
10:09Because again, like, you didn't even have shielded transactions available on mobile devices, where a lot of people want to use this stuff. So, you know, I think we've still got a road ahead to make those transparent addresses obsolete, so nobody wants to use them, and it's just kind of Z-addresses or unified addresses that are used everywhere and just completely pervasive. And hopefully we can get that. You know, there's people that love them still, and kind of argue that they're necessary for kind of regulatory concerns, which is actually not a completely true story.
10:46Like, folks like Gemini support sending to a shielded address, and NYDFS is fine with that, the regulator in New York. But I think it's going to take a little bit of time to get that fully flipped. But we'll get there.
11:02Kris NuttycombeYeah, I think that one of the things that's probably underappreciated is that because the cryptography was so novel at, you know, the launch of Zcash, I think that having the transparent pool available also as, essentially, as a fallback in the case that there were problems with the cryptography, you know, it was an engineering decision that made sense at the time. And, you know, now we have much greater capabilities with respect to, say, you know, viewing keys, that you can share a viewing key for your wallet with relatively fine-grained permissions. There are finer-grained techniques of sharing information about a specific transaction that have been written up and documented.
11:49And so I think that the time is coming where, like Josh said, where transparent transactions, transparent addresses will just be obsolete. But they've been important in getting us to where we are now.
12:09Vlad CosteaI think a misconception about Zcash has been that these transparent addresses existed for reasons which concern getting listed on exchanges and being fine with regulators and stuff like this, when in fact it was just that zero-knowledge proofs at the time were not optimized well enough to be able to function across all wallets.
12:30Kris NuttycombeIt's not just that. I mean, Zcash was the first production deployment of zero-knowledge proofs. And, you know, now you see them everywhere. You see them all over the place in the Ethereum ecosystem. That all builds on the work that the engineers at ECC and Zcash Foundation did to make zero-knowledge proofs practical. So at the time that Zcash was launched, it was truly an experiment. You know, we didn't really know whether it was going to work, and there's been a lot of maturation in the past eight years.
13:07Vlad CosteaIt's also fascinating to me, the way in which Zcash was created, you know, because you have something like Monero, and we can get to that too. But the story, or the origin story of Monero, is that there was this obscure guy who got together a team of developers. The community disagreed with him, they forked off, and they went from BitMonero to Monero at one point. So it's like a history of conflict. That's where they started and that's what they nurtured. But in the case of Zcash, it was basically, let's get the smartest people in the industry, put them together and build this very great project.
13:45And the first ceremony, I'm fascinated by that, mostly also because I own this, which is Peter Todd's compute node. I think it should say here...
13:58Josh SwihartYeah, it's amazing. It's amazing that you have that.
14:00Vlad CosteaIt's one of the six computers that was used to generate the trusted setup for the first version of Zcash, and I bought this from Peter, and I'm proud to own it. And it mostly has non-electronic parts from his laptop, so he destroyed the CPU and everything that was relevant for generating that hash, which he has. And there is like a 20-something-page blog post that he made at the time, that basically he put the laptop in a Faraday cage in the back seat of his car.
14:29And he drove across Canada with internet coming only from his mobile phone, and he was doing the computation, writing the data on DVDs to make sure that it's all air-gapped. And then they got together in the desert and they destroyed their computers. It's a very beautiful story, and sophisticated. I think Peter Todd has an issue with the fact that there was only one software implementation that everyone used, and he believed there's not enough audit for that. And I know that there was a second ceremony after that one, when there was a major network upgrade, and it had like 60 participants.
15:06And I don't think that was the last one. So it's like Zcash keeps reinventing itself and trying to fix its previous issues, but at the same time, the price does not really reflect this. And I don't know why. It's like people stopped caring. The all-time high was briefly after the launch, and after that, it seems like the interest for this is diminishing.
15:29Josh SwihartWell, so there's a couple things, and there's actually... and you can look at the price charts and where some of this stuff happened, so that kind of history. But yeah, so there were two ceremonies, the initial one with six. And actually, I would love to get Edward Snowden's computer. He's got that for sale somewhere. So Ed Snowden was part of that. Nobody knew who each other was, or, you know, who else was participating in it. The Radiolab has covered Zooko's part in it, Zooko as a participant, so that episode has gotten a lot of views. It's a lot of fun. That created something called Sprout, right? That was the initial shielded pool, that was kind of really not performant.
16:06The next one was the Powers of Tau, and that one was with Sapling. And Sapling really kind of still had trusted setup, obviously, but it ensured, you know, the ability to create proofs on smaller devices with less compute. And then Orchard, which is the most recent one, is based on Halo 2 and doesn't require any trusted setup. And Halo 2 has the ability to do recursive proofs, which we may introduce here in the future, and stuff like that that Kris alluded to.
16:43But the price... like, one, an interesting thing happened, like, back way back in 2018, and I think it was actually pretty devastating. So, you know, Zcash is Equihash, and it's when the ASIC miners came online. So there were a couple of them. You know, I think the Antminer was the first, Bitmain, that came online. And there was a conversation with the community about whether or not we'd change the parameters so that... and I think Monero did this, right? They changed the parameters so that it couldn't be mined by ASICs.
17:19The tragedy in that is that there were, you know, hobbyists and people that were earning ZEC all around the world using their machines. And, like, I keep meeting them. Like, you know, I show up at events or things like that, and it's like, oh, I used to mine Zcash back in the day, when I could. And then when ASICs hit, the community really decided, through, like, a voting mechanism the foundation hosted, decided to not change the parameters.
17:48Personally, looking at it in hindsight, I think it was a mistake. I wish they had. But we just saw so many people in the community drop off, or drop interest, at that time. And you can see that drop when that happened. So the ASIC miners, I don't think... you know, some of them, I know, because I know some of them have held tokens and are big believers. But a lot of them were like, look, we just convert to yuan, or we convert to Bitcoin, because they're in it for the money.
18:25And I think a lot of the hobbyists and those other folks that were mining it back at the time weren't applying as much sell pressure. And then you have, you know, you have kind of these weird timing events, where we have the same tokenomics as Bitcoin. So just a massive amount of new tokens being generated in the first four years, at a time when the market was really frothy. And so you had this kind of inverse relationship between the amount of tokens that were coming into the market and the rest of the market, with maybe less inventory available.
18:57So it's some weird stuff like that, that I think probably had a net negative effect on price. But it hasn't... you know, in my opinion, it's way undervalued for the technology that's there and what it does and what we're building with it. So we'll see. I mean, this is only... the story is, we're still, you know, infants, I think, in this whole thing.
19:24Kris NuttycombeYeah, I mean, the other thing that I will say is that the user experience has, you know... it's been a long time in developing a good user experience for using ZEC. And I think that we're just now really getting to a point where it's usable enough that we can really onboard a broader variety of users, and not just the most hardcore. You know, one of the things that's, I think, vitally important is some of the wallet integrations we're doing, like Zashi is working on. We have an active integration with Coinbase, so you can buy ZEC directly to the Zashi wallet.
20:09We have an upcoming integration that's in testing right now with Flexa, that allows you to spend your ZEC, you know, when you go to buy a burrito or whatever, and those kinds of things. You know, that takes it out of the, you know, purely crypto world. And we're starting to get the ability to, you know, have average people get ZEC, self-custody and use it, and preserve their privacy in a meaningful fashion. So we really are making progress towards that cash for the internet that doesn't really exist yet anywhere else.
20:48Vlad CosteaYeah, there is quite a lot to unpack from here, but I got to present two of the ads for today's episode. Let's start with the newcomer, which is Cake Wallet. By the way, I messaged Vik, the CEO of Cake Wallet, before this interview and asked him, you know, there's a history between Cake Wallet and Zcash. Do you guys still want to add Zcash to Cake Wallet? And he said he's open to it, he's interested. And he said hello to you guys, because he seems to know you in some capacity.
21:19They're very cool. And anyway, Cake Wallet is the first wallet to integrate silent payments for Bitcoin, which are cool for receiving multiple transactions. If you want to get a donation address or something like that, you can just put your silent payment address, and it will be much harder to figure out how many transactions and how much money you received into that address. And also, they have swapping features, they have buying features, they let you use ChatGPT with privacy by paying only for every prompt that you're making with the coins that you have in your wallet.
21:55And all around, it's pretty cool. They have Monero, which I think has been their first coin. They have Litecoin with MimbleWimble, and that's pretty good for swapping, for maintaining your privacy. So check it out. It's a pretty good Bitcoin wallet also. And for the people who say, oh, I don't want to download it because it has all of these coins or whatever, you can just not set up a wallet with them. So it's a non-custodial wallet that you set up yourself with the settings and the coins that you want.
22:26And it's very cool. Download it today. And also, SideShift.ai is the number one swapping service. They have a lot of liquidity, a lot of trading pairs. And if someone ever pays you in stablecoins, and this is not financial advice, but it's freedom advice, swap that CBDC wannabe for free market money of your choice. You can get Bitcoin, you can get Litecoin, you can get whatever you want. You can even get Jeo Boden, which is a meme coin, which, to be fair, is much fairer than stablecoins. So if you're into that, check out SideShift.ai.
23:02Not available in the US, if I recall correctly. And they don't have Zcash, I guess, for reasons which concern their legal team or whatever. But I do recall they had Zcash at one point. But they're cool, so check them out.
23:17So let's start with the gossip. There was this attempt four years ago or something to add Zcash to Cake Wallet, and it seems like they got canceled or something. They were pressured into not adding Zcash. But I don't know exactly what happened. But I hope that today's climate is much more reasonable, especially since Monero is going to get this full-chain... I forget the name.
23:46So basically, it's something that they take from Zcash to increase the anonymity set that they do in their ring signatures today, which only has like 17 decoys. And they're going to use the entire chain as deniability for transactions, which is a lot more interesting. And they took that from Zcash. And I think it's beautiful to know that this project, which has been toxic towards Zcash for years, and has built its reputation by being toxic towards it and slamming it and saying it sucks, is now taking something from it and taking lessons from it.
24:28Josh SwihartYeah, I mean, they've used some ZK stuff in the past. So this, I think it's... how do you pronounce this? You know, kayabaNerve. Like, he's... I think he's building that. Is it the membership proofs? Is that what that is? Yeah, so that's awesome. I mean, the thing is, right, is like the people behind the Zcash project, like, it's not... it's, yeah, it's a community, and tribal, but it's not so tribal, like, we wouldn't want another project that is bringing freedom to the world to be damaged, or, you know... I mean, we're all, like, we're rooting for the best tools available. And to the extent that, you know, we built the stuff that we're building on Zcash, we're building, you know, on top of the work of previous, you know, people and generations and mathematicians. And likewise, you know, again, like, as big believers in FOSS, that other people being able to use kind of innovation that's invented here to make their projects better, to deliver more freedom to more people.
25:33Kris NuttycombeAwesome. I mean, the thing that always gets me about the, you know, a lot of the heat that Zcash has gotten from the Monero community, is that I think it's important for everybody to realize this is not a zero-sum game, right? This is not a situation where, you know, it's only possible for one project to win, and in order to win, they've got to trash everybody else. You know, the crypto, you know, the internet cash possibilities right now just represent such a tiny fraction.
26:05I mean, compared to fiat, you know, all of crypto is tiny, and the crypto that's private is tinier still. And the more adoption that we get of privacy-preserving, you know, cash for the internet, the better it is for everyone. And so, you know, we are happy. You know, we've collaborated with kayabaNerve, we've collaborated with the Penumbra folks. In fact, recently, you know, Penumbra hired ECC developers to do an audit of Penumbra code. And I think that this sort of meme that it's a zero-sum game, that, you know, you can only win by another person losing, is just... it's ridiculous.
26:51You know, we're much more all at risk from regulation, from, you know, the powers that be that would like to have visibility everywhere. And, you know, the more that we can stand together, the better off everybody is.
27:08Vlad CosteaBut at the same time, in the entire privacy space, you see this dichotomy which ends up in flame wars on the internet. Basically, you look at CalyxOS and GrapheneOS, which are operating systems for mobile phones, and you're going to see that they're fighting all the time. You look at CoinJoin implementations for Bitcoin, you're going to see that there used to be Samourai and Wasabi, and they're always fighting, always saying, you know, I'm technically better. Yeah, but you're generating this toxic change. But no, look, you have an issue with your Dojo implementation. Always throwing punches at each other like this. And it's pretty much the same with Zcash and Monero.
27:54Kris NuttycombeThere's some of that which is, you know, honest competition, and there are technical differences. And, you know, the size of ring signatures versus the anonymity set that you get with Zcash is, you know... there's a technical difference there, and it's fine to discuss those. I think that what's more toxic is the sort of bad-faith, you know, trashing of competing projects. You know, there's a lot of that that goes on too.
28:22Josh SwihartI mean, look, we think Zcash is the best option for electronic cash. Like, hands down, like, no competition. And that's totally fine, right? Like, other people can trash it or whatever. But that's why we work on it. That's why we choose to work on what we're working on, because we think it's the best option for that. Other people that have their own opinions, whatever. We're not going to do, you know, ad hominem kind of attacks on folks. I think it's awesome they have their own opinion. They're going to, like, beat us, run faster, fine. But, you know, I don't think that the Zcash community historically has been, you know, adversarial as it relates to kind of toxic kind of attacks.
29:07Vlad CosteaI think the first time when I read about zero-knowledge proofs was because of Zcash. And then I went back and I discovered that Sergio Demian Lerner started learning cryptography from a book by a man named Bruce Schneier, and there's a section in that book that's called Zero-Knowledge Proofs. And this was back in the early '90s. A book about applied cryptography from the early '90s was describing zero-knowledge proofs, but in a very theoretical way. And I'm not aware of any other project before Zcash that actually spent a lot of time and money working on this idea and trying to make it work in practice.
29:46Because it requires a lot of computation, and it needs a lot of efficiency to work at scale. And what you guys have been able to do, and I'm going to flatter you a bit here, basically, I think Zcash is the most influential project right now, because you have the zero-knowledge rollups that are being built on Bitcoin and Ethereum. It seems like Ethereum is taking more lessons than Bitcoin when it comes to learning from what Zcash has built. And what else? There's also the sidechain that Paul Sztorc is trying to build with drivechains, and that's going to be, if it happens, and I hope it happens, that's going to be a Zcash sidechain with privacy by default.
30:33So he did not choose Monero for this one, he chose Zcash. And to me, that's very interesting. And by the way, LayerTwo Labs are also sponsoring this podcast, and I'm a fan of drivechains. Check out Paul Sztorc's proposal for Core Untouched Soft Forks. I think that's an interesting concept that he's trying to bring to Bitcoin. And if there was a sidechain for every cool use case, I think scaling and privacy and fungibility would get solved more easily. But it seems like there's opposition to this. Anyway, how would you respond to the fact that Zcash is so influential?
31:12Josh SwihartI mean, at the time, right, when the initial, you know, Zerocash paper was developed... I mean, again, like Kris mentioned, there was no practical application. You know, somebody that had taken it beyond kind of theoretical into a practical application. And there were some really difficult things to be figured out, right? So one, like, it had to be non-interactive. So that's where we get the SNARKs, where, because you have a, you know, public chain, and everybody needs to be able to participate without back and forth between actors. Like, figuring out all that math and making that work, which is why we had to have trusted setup.
31:51You know, solving those problems and figuring out those trade-offs and saying, OK, we're going to launch this big experiment, when you had, I don't know, maybe two dozen people around the world that understood how to spell ZK. You know, it was just really hard. And then now, as more and more has been built, you know, whether it's like the Tornado Cash folks or anybody else, that, you know, being able to take the innovation and the work that's been done, learn it, expand upon it, grow it, find more applications for it, for things like rollups.
32:22And now it's proliferating. It's just... it's the best option for privacy and encryption, you know, available anywhere. So it's not a surprise that people are using it. But again, like, it's taken a lot of time for people to get educated and learn and figure out how to practically apply it.
32:42Kris NuttycombeYeah, there's been, I think, an interaction between... you know, for a long time, you just had the theory there. Once you had a practical implementation, I think it was actually possible to learn a lot faster, right? So a lot of the breakthroughs that have been made by the Zcash engineering team have been as a consequence of, OK, once you implement this in practice, just that act of doing the implementation, you learn so much that you can then sort of see what the next theoretical advance can be, right?
33:20That's how we went from Sprout, which required minutes on high-end machines to do proofs, to Sapling, which requires seconds on mobile phones. And that's how we went from, you know, Sapling, which still required a trusted setup for zk-SNARKs, to, you know, Sean Bowe's revelations about how to get rid of the trusted setup and create Halo 2. And, you know, now we have this foundation where that continuing process of each step of implementation provides new insights into how to further improve. Just, you know, as the use explodes across the ecosystem, more and more people are having those insights. It's pushing forward the theory.
34:09Vlad CosteaDo you guys ever get concerned that this is so avant-garde, and there are so few people around the world who understand how this works, that there might be some bug that breaks everything, that someone's going to discover just because there are not too many competent eyes looking at the code?
34:30Kris NuttycombeI mean, I'd say that that's always a worry in cryptography, right? Over and over again, you know, you've had cryptographic schemes that ended up having flaws discovered. But at the same time, the more people you have with that level of understanding, right? You know, the folks who are building out the zkEVMs, you know, the folks who are building out the ZK rollups, all of those folks now are gaining that insight into the fundamental mathematics by, you know, working with these every day, that, you know, I think that we're developing more and more confidence. We're getting better and better proofs of correctness and of security.
35:12And, you know, that's something that the Zcash team has been relentless about through all of our upgrades, is proofs of security. You know, there is a formal proof of security for the Halo 2 protocol. And that's something, I think, a lot of the other groups using ZK maybe, you know, are not quite as tightly wrapped. But we put a lot of effort into, you know, creating those formal proofs, making certain that this is secure.
35:41Josh SwihartYeah, maybe two things to add. One is, there is risk, right? As you get, like, some of these tools, you kind of move up higher orders of abstraction in terms of what people are building. And so they're just continuing to build on other people's stuff, and they don't necessarily kind of understand what's happening further down the stack. And so that becomes a risk, is that you get this great kind of proliferation of ZK tools, and people are using ZK but not digging too far down. And we've seen the implications even with Zcash.
36:10So, you know, back when the Sprout, which is that first pool, that first kind of non-performant pool, there was a bug in the underlying math. And it was in the paper, it was buried in the paper. And if somebody had discovered that bug, it would have allowed them to counterfeit Zcash, to create new Zcash without being detected. So when that was discovered, it was actually discovered by an ECC cryptographer and engineer, and, you know, it was fixed in Sapling. But that was like... that didn't come out in the software. That came out of him, like, going back and reviewing the underlying cryptography at a very detailed level. And so, you know, already then, when that bug came out, like, we had to go through a disclosure process and notify all these projects that we knew were using the same cryptography, but that were building on top without having checked all the way back down to the bottom.
37:06So I would say that there is that risk, but there's also tremendous incentive, right? Because this is money. People are incented to figure out how to hack it and how to steal, right? And how to, you know, break these things. And so it's not just this kind of science project that sits at a university that nobody really looks at. There's real money at stake. And so there's a little bit of a Lindy effect here, right? Where the longer it continues to live without kind of any breach of that security, the stronger... the more confidence that we can have that the underlying cryptography is solid.
37:43Vlad CosteaI think to this day, when you present to a Bitcoiner the idea of privacy, their main concern and their main criticism is going to be that someone might exploit some sort of inflation bug, and the rest of the network is not going to be aware that there are more than 21 million Bitcoin.
38:00And somehow they seem to be complacent with the fact that institutions can sell paper Bitcoin to effectively inflate that 21 million cap by selling something which is not guaranteed by a UTXO. So do you believe that zero-knowledge proofs offer some sort of certainty compared to the stuff that's in Monero?
38:28Kris NuttycombeThat's a tough question. I mean, I think that... I don't think that the decoy approach of Monero gives you necessarily more certainty. And as we've said, you know, with their full-chain membership proofs, they are moving towards a Zcash model. So I think that it's, as much as anything, like Josh has mentioned, just the maturity of ZK tech gives us that confidence, and the fact that there's been this feedback loop, right? Where there have been now, you know, academics that have gone back and looked at these upgraded protocols and done proofs of security for them. So we sort of get it from both ends, right?
39:18We get both the engineering confidence of, OK, we have this implementation, it's being attacked, but nobody's been able to break it. And we have the theory that shows that, you know, given a correct implementation, this is not breakable.
39:38Vlad CosteaSomething else that's interesting to me is that it seems like Zcash, even though it started as this experiment to improve Bitcoin, is being embraced much more by the Ethereum community. And maybe you can make a case and say that the account model, account system that Ethereum is using, is an Orwellian nightmare, and they need privacy much more. And they also need zero-knowledge proofs for compressing data and having more scalability for the kind of stuff that they want to do. But at the same time, you have stuff like ZK-STARKs, which are being built by StarkWare.
40:15And I did hear some of their fans claiming that those STARKs are going to make Zcash obsolete by virtue of being on a network that has more users.
40:28Josh SwihartYeah, I mean, like, as far as I know, and full disclosure, I mean, ECC was an early investor in StarkWare, and we still are. It hasn't been like a competitive product. Like, the intention with what Eli... and because Eli, you know, Eli, the founder, is one of the Zcash founding scientists, Eli Ben-Sasson. And great guy, great project. You know, they had really been working on things like scalability, hadn't really been focused on things like privacy. And, you know, I don't know.
41:12And it's also kind of very centralized, right? The way that they work, you've got to run those servers, the StarkWare... you've got to run on the StarkWare servers. So as they, you know, roll this out more and more, great. Again, like Kris was saying, it's not a zero-sum game.
41:29And I don't think... but I haven't seen them trying to push for STARKs as internet cash or electronic cash, private cash either. I haven't seen that kind of use case come out of what they're really focused on.
41:48Kris NuttycombeMy answer to the question of, you know, is this going to obsolete Zcash, is it's really hard to obsolete something that is continuing to evolve and innovate. And, you know, that's what you're seeing with Zcash on an ongoing basis, you know, over its lifetime, and that's not slowing down at all. So yeah, you can try to... you can compete, for sure, and that competition is great. But the notion that it's going to make something that's a moving target obsolete doesn't make sense to me.
42:23Vlad CosteaDo you guys ever feel frustrated when you realize that some random meme coin like dogwifhat or whatever is getting more market action than Zcash? And that one is just something that takes five minutes to create on Solana, whereas Zcash takes actual research and development and years to improve. And it seems like markets care much more about these meme coins, which once again take no effort, and they maybe have community, though... OK, I'm not going to make this allegation, but there's a lot of insider trading in that, and you have a lot of people manipulating these markets. But in the case of Zcash, in spite of this price speculation, there is some actual technology, and there's stuff that's being used by other projects like Bitcoin and Ethereum.
43:13And there is some legitimacy to this. Even outside of the field of cryptocurrency, you have zero knowledge being developed much more as an element in the field of mathematics. And maybe that this is owed to the contributions that Zcash has made. But in spite of all this, it's like the market doesn't care. So why do you think this is happening?
43:37Josh SwihartLike, it's like... well, that kind of focus is kind of bunk for me, right? So it's a different use case. So somebody wants to create a... they want to try to create a token and build a community around it and pump it up so they can dump it on somebody else, right? That's a use case. So, for what we're doing, we're trying to change the world, right? We're like at this complete inflection point. I was sharing, like, I was sharing last week at a different thing...
44:08Like, this is a Gutenberg moment for money and the democratization of money, right? So Gutenberg, with the printing press, changed everything, where the church held all the knowledge and nobody had access to information, couldn't disseminate information, because it was managed by a power. And now we have this thing called fiat, which are managed by these powers, and that are used and abused around the world to kind of continue to beat down other countries, to surveil their citizens, and to inflate as they want to inflate or whatever, to try to manipulate, do their own kind of manipulation of the markets.
44:43And what we're building, what we have now the ability to do, through, you know, thank you, Bitcoin, and thank you, Satoshi, right, for kind of opening this up and creating this Gutenberg moment, is that we have the ability to disseminate... disseminate, you know, money, and democratize money. But the problem with it is that we need to be able to do this anonymously or pseudonymously, in such a way that protects our privacy, right?
45:07So even with, you know, with the printing press, you could put something down and you put your name on it, and then everybody knows who you are. And then you potentially are attacked and are at risk of powers coming at you. So we needed the ability to be able to print and do things without that. So you have, like, you know, the founding fathers of the US, or you have Benjamin Franklin, or, you know, folks like that, that put out things without putting their name on it, that allowed for information and ideas to be disseminated using this great new technology.
45:40And that's where we are. Like, you think about what you want to work on for your life. Like, you have so many hours in your life, so much time you can give, so much energy, so much brainpower you can give, and what you can give to the world. You can say, like, I'm going to work on dogwifhats, because, like, I'm going to make just a buttload of money or whatever. Or you can say, we're going to be part of something that is fundamentally changing things forever, for the next generation.
46:03There's like... OK, I can look at the price chart and I can say the market doesn't care, but the world will care, and it's going to care. And it may take, I don't know, maybe just months, it may take weeks, who knows, after this US election, or months or years or decades. I don't know. But like, no regrets on spending my time and energy on this, 100%.
46:29Vlad CosteaI was going to ask, no reaction from Kris. Maybe you're trading dogwifhat, or whatever that's called.
46:36Kris NuttycombeNo, I mean, so I see those projects, unfortunately, as driven by the same sort of zero-sum mindset, where it's like, I can make a bunch of money by taking it from somebody else. It's fundamentally something I'm not interested in. I don't even really pay attention, because I think that cash for the internet and, you know, the ability for anybody to build a service online and, you know, create new economies, is where it's actually at, in terms of, you know, the future of this whole space.
47:12I don't see the zero-sum... you know, maybe it's working right now, but I don't think it's really... like, it's not building anything to last, right? It's building, you know, somebody the opportunity to make a, you know, make a buck, but then they've left nothing behind. You can't have an economy, you can't build an economy on transparent coins. And I think that that's where it's at, is building that new economy, building new ways of working together.
47:48You know, having projects... you know, we've got DAOs now in the Ethereum ecosystem, but they're not fully decentralized, right? They have treasuries and whatnot, and, you know, all of the movement of funds is traceable and so forth. We are in the early days of the implications of internet cash. We haven't really started yet. And, you know, some of the functionality... I think it's great to have experiments. And it's great that the tools exist, that, you know, somebody can in five minutes build a meme coin on Solana or whatever, and, you know, get it out there to people.
48:35Building those tools is great. The individual projects, if they don't have that larger view, that longer-term vision, I think they're just zero-sum.
48:48Vlad CosteaSometimes I think about versions of the future, right? Because there are people who claim that everything is going to be divided by the 21 million Bitcoin, because for some reason that one project is going to be the only one that survives, and the only form of money that humanity will use. And then you have this idea that maybe you're going to have Bitcoin, you're going to have Ethereum, you're going to have Zcash, you're going to have Monero, maybe Litecoin and a bunch of others that are going to survive by virtue of having the Lindy effect and having market adoption and brand recognition. And they're going to encapsulate all of the features that they see competitive and useful for themselves. But we're not going to have 21 million coins, we're going to have like 300 million or something.
49:35Kris NuttycombeYou know, when we talk about, like, the crypto ecosystems, right? If you think about natural ecosystems, monocultures fail, right? Monocultures always have weak spots. And so the sign of a healthy ecosystem that can actually respond to shocks is having diversity, variety, competition, ability to exchange. Like, it's not merely, you know, just something that happens. You know, it's not whether somebody wants it or not. It's absolutely critical for success to have diversity.
50:23Josh SwihartLike, we wouldn't have zero knowledge, right? Because Zcash wouldn't have existed if we would have had a monoculture just on Bitcoin, and that was the only option, the only thing available. Innovation happens all over the place, and it's going to happen in different contexts. It's like saying there's going to be, like, we're going to have one book, and it's going to be the Bible, and nobody's going to write anything else or have any other kind of thoughts or ideas or any kind of innovation. Yeah, people are going to create stuff that's just garbage, right? You're going to have that long tail of things. Stuff is going to live, some things are going to live longer, some things are going to die. That's part of, you know, just kind of natural selection or whatever. That stuff's going to happen. And it's great. And to Kris's point, it's healthy, and we need it. Just generally as people, it's like...
51:05Vlad CosteaYeah. But why would you say that Zcash is in a good position to survive and make it through all of this noise? Because before Zcash, you had a bunch of other privacy coins. There was even Zerocoin, which is basically a sibling of Zcash, and nowadays I think they rebranded. After Zcash, you had a bunch of clones and projects with different parameters that are trying to basically flex on your past failures and say, we never had a trusted setup. I think there's one that's called Pirate Chain or something.
51:38And that one is saying, you know, we're basically Zcash without the trusted setup, and we never had a trusted setup, we never had a foundation, we never had...
51:45Kris NuttycombePirate Chain had a trusted setup. They used the same... they used the Sapling parameters.
51:50Josh SwihartYeah, what they didn't have is transparent. They've been shielded-only, I think, since. But we've had... I mean, yeah, everybody, like, people... it's open source. People can fork the code, they can build whatever they want to build, like Pirate Chain or whatever. They can try different experiments, YWallet, or not YWallet, Ycash, fork the Zcash chain and try to implement some different rules. And some people are still in that community and doing that thing, and I hope they continue to innovate, but it has never really kind of gotten any kind of mainstream attention. Why is Zcash going to, you know, be better, or last? I don't know. We're working to make it an option for people, because we believe we have kind of, you know, the best base of technology. And we've got a group of people in this community, a group of developers, and folks like Kris, who work on this stuff day and night to continue to evolve it.
52:41It's not a ghost chain, right? There's a significant amount of innovation and active development that's being done.
52:47But, like, people might choose... like, they don't want to... you know, they're going to opt for something else? Then fine, then we're doing something wrong, right? This is, in some ways, it is a competition and survival of the fittest, and we'll continue to be at the forefront of this stuff as long as we can. But ultimately, it's up to... right, it's just up to people and what they want to choose. If people want to choose something else, then, you know, then maybe we should focus on something else, right? The endgame is about, you know, electronic cash and economic freedom. This kind of tribalism with the other projects just isn't as important.
53:33Kris NuttycombeYeah, I mean, I think the important thing is to really see where the innovation is coming from, and, you know, who's copying it. So, you know, we see Monero adopting Zcash tech, right? And, you know, I hope that they're going to go with the, you know, trustless approach of Halo 2, or something evolved from Halo 2. But, you know, these innovations have come from within Zcash, and it's not like we're stopped, right? Right now, we just had a Zcash birthday celebration, day before yesterday, online. And the amount of just stuff that's happening across the Zcash ecosystem, so many projects. You know, we've got Zcash Shielded Assets that are, you know, at this point almost fully developed for release in Network Upgrade 7, which is going to be our next network upgrade, next year.
54:28Sean Bowe is now working on Zcash scalability. And, you know, this is the fellow who came up with Halo 2. They're, you know, brightest minds in the industry, still pushing forward on problems that the whole industry has. So there's nothing irrelevant that the Zcash community is working on, and we're just growing.
54:57Vlad CosteaYeah, I think the risk that you're facing when you're moving forward all the time and you're pushing the boundaries of what the technology can do is that you don't really create a religion around a certain type of technology, right? You're not trying to say, oh, this is perfect because this creator left us with this technology, and therefore we're going to be using it until the end of time. And I deal with this a lot, because Bitcoin maximalism used to be about taking whatever is interesting from the cryptocurrency industry and adding that to Bitcoin.
55:30Of course, they're going to say, you know, Bitcoin is too big, we can't gamble with people's money, we can't add features if they're not properly tested. And that was the case with SegWit, that was the case with the Lightning Network. They tested everything on Litecoin, and then they decided that it's safe enough for Bitcoin. But it seems like the culture has moved to a point where people say, if it was not built by this group of people, then it's a shitcoin, scamming technology, and we should avoid that at all costs because it's horrible.
56:04It's not about technological merits. It's just about creating a cult and trying to establish hierarchies and saying that these people are better than the others, and therefore you should only care about what they think and disregard everything else. But I think this sort of culture, which I don't think is going to last too long, because Bitcoin maximalism can only survive in its current form for as long as there is some technological edge to back it up. For a while, maybe the Lightning Network made Bitcoin look avant-garde and cool and high-tech, but now that it's becoming centralized and it's losing much of its capital, both in terms of coins locked in the protocol and investments in it...
56:49I think there's going to be like a wake-up moment where people realize, yeah, we need to get that technological edge somehow. We need to bring the builders back. We need to have maybe... I know that StarkWare was working on ways to bring their STARKs to Bitcoin, and I think that's a pretty big deal. And then you have people like Robin Linus, who created BitVM, who's also working on something that's for enabling shielded transactions on Bitcoin, on a ZK rollup. And I think that's still pretty cool, and a lot of it is owed to the existence of Zcash.
57:26And if you ask the average maximalist what they think about Zcash, they're going to say, you know, they have this foundation and they have the Electric Coin Company, and they take a percentage of the honest miners' revenue, and they're scamming, and they're paying for Zooko's groceries, which I think was a meme for a while that was perpetuated by the Monero people, mostly. And they have so much hateful stuff to say, but they disregard all the cool stuff that's being built.
57:55Because of course, it's very different culturally from Bitcoin. The miners are paying a fee to the developers and to the foundation and so on and so. But they don't see that people, you know, miners sign up to this social contract where this is happening, and it's all voluntary. And there is some actual cool stuff that's being built. I don't know, I just ranted about stuff.
58:21Kris NuttycombeYeah, I think that... I think that observing that it's a social contract, right? So yeah, in Bitcoin, and in, you know, lots of other coins, the founding social contract was, you know, the miners get all of the new issuance. But, you know, the observation, I think, early on in the development of Zcash was, well, we don't want to do a huge pre-mine, because there are ethical problems with that, because it's a one-time shot, right? You don't have the option over time for people to opt out of that pre-mine, right?
59:01But you have the option on an ongoing basis for, you know, if miners say, well, you know, this isn't worth it, I don't think that the value that we're getting from the development funding is sufficient, then, you know, they can go elsewhere. This is competition. This is part of a healthy ecosystem, right? It's just a different philosophy. You know, we have just gone through a governance process to authorize another year, starting in November, of development funding. You know, the continuing 20% of issuance going to development funding. But I think we made a significant step forward there.
59:44Whereas in the past, that development funding went to the Zcash Foundation, Electric Coin Company and Zcash Community Grants, for the next year, there's still a slice going to Zcash Community Grants, but the remainder of that development funding is going into a pool that we are going to have... it's not going to be under the control of a single entity. In the future, it's going to be under the control of a community governance process that's still being argued about, but, you know, attempting to decentralize. And this has been, again, a process, right?
1:00:24The first four years of Zcash's existence, those block rewards went to a relatively small pool of individuals and organizations. Then the following four years, you know, our next halving is just in a little bit less than a month here, that was split between three entities. One of which was, you know, doing small or large grants. That's what's resulted in the development of, for example, Zcash Shielded Assets. It's resulted in a lot of wallet development. Then you have the Zcash Foundation getting a slice. They've been responsible for the development of the second node implementation, Zebrad, which is what we're now interested in moving the entire network over to.
1:01:08And the Electric Coin Company, which has been responsible for all of these innovations in zero-knowledge proving, and maintaining the zcashd node implementation that was derived from Bitcoin. So, you know, that was a stage of decentralization. We are now going into another stage of decentralization, and I expect that also to continue.
1:01:32Vlad CosteaYeah, and it's not a scam if it's transparent, you know, when people know what they sign up for. And it's part of the social contract, and the users agree, or they can exit. I don't know why there's this culture about it. Because, of course, Bitcoin is pure from this point of view. But how much research has Bitcoin, or how much research did Bitcoin miners actually fund over the years? Not that much. And if you look at the amount of research that Blockstream has put out over the last decade, once again, it's not that much.
1:02:06And they get, you know, a lot of praise, and they're held in high regard. But at the end of the day, they're going to look at what Zcash is doing and try to come up with ways to bring this to Bitcoin. And something which comes up in conversations when I tell people that Bitcoin needs privacy, they basically tell me, I withdraw my coins from this exchange to my non-custodial wallet address, which may come from a hardware wallet, and how does anyone know that the address belongs to me?
1:02:36They're going to say, you know, it's just some random address, it has no previous history, it just has these funds. There's some deniability involved. It could be someone else, and whatever. I don't care, it's good enough for me.
1:02:51Kris NuttycombeDo you want to take this one, Josh, or do you want me to? Go ahead, go ahead. So, OK, let's start with... well, it's not a random address. It's the address that you withdrew to from the exchange, right? So the exchange, who presumably knows something about you, knows that address. And then any counterparty that you send a transaction to in the future can see, oh, well, those coins came from this address, which came from this exchange. So now your counterparty knows the exchange knows who that address belongs to.
1:03:24And also, you know, you may have... you know, you may have ordered something online, or who knows what. That counterparty may know something about you. Then the next person that they send it on to can make that same connection.
1:03:38You may get change back to a new address, but then when you make another spend, that spend gets linked in. If you spend some of that change, well, then that change address is no longer disconnected from you. All of that history is so incredibly linkable. If any one individual, and all the individuals or organizations that you've interacted with with your wallet, has your identity, or has something that ties back to your identity, has your IP address, right, then they can find you, right?
1:04:16You are traceable. You are known. This notion that pseudonymity in the Bitcoin sense... Bitcoin is the best surveillance coin ever invented, right? It is the best currency for surveillance. You get more privacy from transacting through your bank than you do when transacting with Bitcoin. Because, you know, if I go... like, there's a coffee shop in Boulder that accepts Zcash. If I go and I pay for coffee with Zcash, you know, that coffee shop doesn't even know my address. They don't know who the payment came from, right? They see nothing of my history.
1:04:49If I pay them with Bitcoin, they can see how much Bitcoin I hold, right, via the traceability. And they can see who else I transact with. This is one of the things when I talk about having an economy needing to be based on privacy. Can you imagine a business trying to use Bitcoin in its everyday operations? Their entire supply chain, how much they pay to vendors, all of that being public information. And then the vendors can see what other vendors they're interacting with. The vendors can collude.
1:05:24The vendors can, you know, decide to undercut one another, or collude with someone to take advantage, right? There's no way that you can build an economy when all of that history is public.
1:05:43Josh SwihartSo there's also... there's also a fungibility issue, right? So, and it's kind of unintended associations. So you may be, you know, two degrees of separation away from somebody that's done something nefarious, and all of a sudden you're caught up in it, right? You have, like, no control, because, like, when law enforcement is going after and doing that study, they're taking a look at all those linkages and all that kind of stuff. And so all of a sudden, then your information graph is exposed to a whole other set of actors who may be looking at something, and you just have no control, right? Because, again, of all the linkages. So you lose that fungibility. I think it's another huge problem.
1:06:22Vlad CosteaYeah. The way in which I describe it usually, with Bitcoin privacy, is that it's degrading over time. Even if you follow the best practices, let's say that you mine the coins yourself, and they have no past. They just come from this coinbase reward, and you make payments. You don't know when the person who's going to receive the payment from you is going to get raided by the feds, and they're going to have to reveal to the feds everyone who sent coins to them, and identify all the inputs that sent coins to their addresses.
1:06:57So it's only a matter of time until your transactions are going to get de-anonymized, even if you're following the best practices. And it's sort of the same with your phone number, right? Maybe you get a new phone number. You say, I'm not going to give this away to people, I'm just going to give it to people I trust. But then someone you trust is going to share your number with someone else, who's going to share it with someone else. And next thing you know, you're going to find it on the internet, and you're not going to know exactly how that ended up there.
1:07:25So you're relying on this social layer of keeping secrets, and that can only degrade over time. And you can also make mistakes yourself. You can share the xpub with a third-party service, and that one has information about all the addresses that you generated, all the transactions that you've made, and it's a nightmare.
1:07:47Josh SwihartYeah, well said.
1:07:49Vlad CosteaDo you have any comments on this?
1:07:51Kris NuttycombeLike, no... yeah, no, I mean, I guess the only comment that I would say is that this... when we do development work, design work on Zcash, it is perpetually with an adversarial view, right? And every part of our infrastructure... for example, you know, we have a big write-up on the kinds of attacks, and what parties gain access to what information, if you use a light client wallet to, you know, scan the chain, connecting to a light client server, right? And if you take that adversarial view of, like, OK, what possibly can be used to link my information, right? If I create a transaction and I send it to a light wallet server, and I don't send it over Tor, right?
1:08:49Well, then the fact that my IP address has created a Zcash transaction is something that's leaked. So what are we doing? Well, we're making it possible to submit transactions to light client servers over Tor. We recently integrated... it took us a long time to integrate the feature of just figuring out what your ZEC is worth in fiat, because we didn't want to just have your wallet talk directly to an exchange and reveal that, you know, your IP address is interested in the price of Zcash, right?
1:09:26So instead, we contact a mix of different data sources over Tor, and take a median of those data sources, so that your identity, you know, just of your IP address's interest in Zcash, is not leaked to those counterparties who, you know, we don't know who they're interacting with, who they're collaborating with. Every step of the way, there are possible leaks. And the worst thing is when leaking information can be tied back to publicly visible stuff on an immutable blockchain, right? Because then it's forever, you know?
1:10:08Transactions on Bitcoin are forever. They are public forever. And any information that's ever correlated, into the distant future, with one of those transactions, that correlation is permanently public information.
1:10:25Vlad CosteaBut what about the transactions that happened on the transparent side of Zcash? You basically have this data that's been stored about these transactions, and once they get transferred to a shielded or a unified address, would you say that the history gets somehow erased, and you're not able to trace back to the initial transactions that were being made?
1:10:50Kris NuttycombeSo there's some nuance here. The way to obtain... and this is actually not specific to Zcash, but the way to obtain true privacy is to store your wealth in private, right? And to avoid... so if I send, you know, 3.14159 ZEC from the transparent pool to the shielded pool, and then I send that exact same amount out, minus a fee, like, you know, a few hours or days later, someone can look at those amounts and say, oh, well, you know, this is probably the same funds. And people trying to just use the shielded pool as a pass-through don't actually gain benefits of privacy.
1:11:34And this is true whether, you know, if you use Monero, and, you know, you interact with an exchange or something like that and get an identifiable amount, and then interact with a counterparty and use that same identifiable amount, then those two transactions can be viewed as linked. But the key is that if I store my wealth shielded, then whenever I spend from it, that value is unlinked from any public information. Because when I shielded it, I put those funds in a place where the source of those funds cannot be discovered by anyone based upon information on the chain. And where, if I don't explicitly provide information that links, if I haven't, you know, shared a viewing key or something like that with someone that allows someone to see what was received by a shielded address, then that history is permanently unlinked.
1:12:44Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess it would have been much nicer if you started with a setup where everything is private by default. But even under the current circumstances, it's much better than what Bitcoin has, and it's only going to get better from here. And how would you respond to this idea that Bitcoin privacy is going to happen on second layers, and the base layer can just stay this open ledger where you can see every transaction ever? And you can also do some blockchain analysis to associate some addresses with real names.
1:13:19Kris NuttycombeI mean, I guess it depends upon how those second layers are implemented, like what their rules are, who has information on those second layers, and then how they settle against the main chain, right? This is technology, right? There are lots of possibilities out there. You know, I think that Zcash has implemented the best privacy that's possible to have on the internet with money today. That doesn't mean that that can't be recreated. But yeah, the question of how does it settle back against the main chain is critically important when you're talking about layer two solutions. And also, who are the layer two providers, and what can they see?
1:14:07Josh SwihartYeah, I'm skeptical anyway. I mean, the layer 2 experiment right now is on Ethereum. It's kind of a mess. But, I mean, we'll see. We're going to continue to build scalable privacy on L1 with Zcash.
1:14:21Kris NuttycombeYeah, we are, you know, going the other direction in some sense, where, you know, with the advent of Zcash Shielded Assets, you know, things can move the other direction, right? You can have zBTC, right? You can have Bitcoin that gets bridged to Zcash and stored and transacted privately. So maybe the evolution goes the other way around, right? Where instead of Bitcoin gaining privacy, privacy gains Bitcoin.
1:14:51Vlad CosteaI mean, that would be pretty funny, given the situation where WBTC is the largest layer two for Bitcoin right now, and it's orders of magnitude bigger than Lightning and Liquid and everything else. It would be funny if people who cared about privacy would wrap their BTC on Zcash, transact it there, and return to the base layer only when they need it. It's sort of funny how this turned out to be, especially since Bitcoin had this first-mover advantage. It could integrate everything. But along the way, some people decided to become complacent and just pursue narratives and institutional adoption.
1:15:29And that's when I got triggered. And I'm happy I do this podcast and I interview people like you guys, because I get different perspectives of what this could have been and what this can actually turn into. Because I see a lot of potential in Zcash. I told you, I think it's the most influential project right now, and it's also maybe the most underrated. Maybe Grin is also underrated, and it's something that deserves more love. But Zcash definitely has received a lot of attention from the people who are into privacy.
1:16:03And a lot of people are trying to bring Zcash-level privacy to their money, internet money projects, so congratulations for that. But how do you respond to this criticism that there are only two or three teams that work on Zcash and receive grants, and maybe it's not decentralized enough? And maybe that you're going to need more people to work on the protocol to eliminate this maybe double point of failure.
1:16:30Josh SwihartYeah, I agree. I mean, I don't know what to say. We're growing, and it's decentralizing. So there's a new organization called Shielded Labs that spun up, which is, I think, Swiss-based, that, you know, Zooko is now head of product at. Jason McGee, the executive director, CEO. And they're working on it. They're completely funded by third parties, through donations. So that, you know, that was this year. So you have that kind of organization that's now participating. You have folks like QEDIT. So QEDIT is building the Zcash Shielded Assets that we've been talking about. And that kind of capability of some independent third parties that are building, you know, additional light wallets or additional infrastructure to be able to support things.
1:17:16So Kris mentioned the birthday. We're just seeing, you know, folks across the community, around the world, more and more people come in. Again, like, early days, ZK is really hard. Like, so few people understood it. Like, to build on it was incredibly difficult. And so it required a very dedicated kind of focus, highly qualified team, you know, to kind of work on the core primitives. But this is changing, and the community is kind of in the middle of a good growth spurt in terms of new actors and new participants.
1:17:55Vlad CosteaI know that you said you have about one hour for this interview, and I want to ask you if you have time for some questions from the audience, or we should end this here.
1:18:06Josh SwihartI can go.
1:18:07Kris NuttycombeYeah, I can go.
1:18:09Vlad CosteaOK. The last ad that I present before asking you the questions is for Hodling.ch, which is the service that helps you with your self-custody. If you hold Zcash, they can also help you. Basically, what they do is advise you on how to set up your multisig, or how to keep your backup. I also did an interview with them, so you can learn some free lessons. But if you're part of a company that's going to acquire Bitcoin or Zcash or Ethereum or whatever, and you don't know how to share the keys and how to set this up in a way that's fair and eliminates points of failure, then you got to reach out to them. It's Hodling.ch, and you also benefit from that Swiss privacy. So check them out.
1:18:49I have a question from Toasty Joe, who says, can you ask them if the recursive ZKP theory that ebfull, which is Sean Bowe, discovered a few years ago has been implemented, if it's even on the roadmap? I know they already have the trustless ZKP pool deployed, but to really scale, doesn't the recursion need to be there too?
1:19:16Kris NuttycombeSo, yeah, so Sean Bowe has, you know... he is now fully working on scalability, and I'm pretty confident that the recursive proving is going to be part of that. So not implemented yet in Zcash, partially just due to resource constraints. But I see that coming.
1:19:44Vlad CosteaThere is Marius, who says something about Zcash being a hedge against quantum computers, and wants to know more about quantum resistance for Zcash.
1:19:56Josh SwihartThis one...
1:19:57Kris NuttycombeYeah, go ahead.
1:19:59Josh SwihartNo, I was going to say, like, if we have quantum computers break cryptography, like, generally, I'll say, right, we've got bigger, much bigger problems, right? Because it's going to break everything. It's going to break the internet. But as it relates to, like, long-term privacy, there's... like everything, it depends. So because with... and correct me if I step out of line here, Kris, but with the proofs, like, information isn't encrypted and published on the chain. It's using encryption to create a zero-knowledge proof that can be verified by other parties.
1:20:34So that transaction history and that kind of stuff, you know, isn't out there. Now, there's a memo field, and there's a memo field that you can use within Zcash that is encrypted. So there... and then again, like with everything, like, there's other things kind of around Zcash where we need post-quantum crypto. That's for Daira-Emma, who's on the team here at ECC. That's something that he's been looking at and will continue to look at. So it's imperative we get that kind of figured out. But your privacy, in terms of your transaction, will be protected.
1:21:16Kris NuttycombeYeah, the... right now, and, you know, there may be nuance to this, but Zcash is post-quantum resistant for the note encryption, so long as someone doesn't know the address that the note was sent to. So if you know that a specific transaction was sent to a specific address, we don't have full post-quantum privacy. But that's not information that's revealed on the chain. And so as a consequence, you know, by default, there's a good measure of resistance there.
1:22:04Vlad CosteaYeah, we also have a question about switching to proof of stake. There is someone in the chat who is confused about mining. And I do recall, and this is something I respect, Slush Pool, which was the first mining pool ever for Bitcoin, also supported Zcash, and has supported Zcash until transitioning into Braiins. And I know that Slush is good friends with Zooko, and basically Slush got into Bitcoin because of Zooko. There's a lot of history there. Zooko was one of the first people to write about Bitcoin, maybe a few days after it launched, and he described it as Chaumian eCash in a decentralized way.
1:22:44So it seems like there's a lot of Bitcoin history with the Zcash project, and a lot of intention to improve Bitcoin. But what's up with this move to proof of stake?
1:22:56Josh SwihartIt's a proposal. It's a proposal that has momentum, and I think broad support in the ecosystem. The proposal is not a full-up move to proof of stake. It's a hybrid proof of work, proof of stake, using something called Crosslink. And basically, Shielded Labs, which is a net new organization that Zooko's at right now... the work was initially done, the research on Crosslink was done at ECC, by Daira-Emma and Nate Wilcox. But now Shielded Labs is taking that on to do that design.
1:23:34Their first plan is to create a prototype. And so I would expect that prototype to be, you know, hopefully out within the next 12 months or so. But yeah, that would be a hybrid model between proof of stake and proof of work, not a full switchover to proof of stake, at least not right away.
1:23:58Kris NuttycombePart of the idea behind that transition is to actually increase the security. So, you know, Zooko's talked about this a bunch, where, with the hybrid model, someone attempting to attack the chain would have to subvert both the proof of stake and proof of work parts in order to execute, like, a 51% attack... or, it's not a 51% attack at that point, but it's an attack that would allow you to rewrite history. You'd have to subvert both protocols at once, which is harder than subverting one or the other individually.
1:24:38Josh SwihartYeah, we have, with proof of work, right, there's a risk of miner centralization. That's true with Zcash today. So it's like ViaBTC, I think, has got about 60% of the hash. And so that, you know, this... and it allows for other participants, for people to earn yield. There's, like, a demand within the ecosystem. People want to earn yield on their ZEC. So it's a mechanism to do that while securing the network as well.
1:25:06Vlad CosteaYeah, to me it's interesting that all of these proof-of-work coins, not all of them, but most of them, are moving to proof of stake in some capacity. Some of them want to be hybrids. Others just figure out that mining is not exactly the best way for them to go forward. And some of them are concerned that a malevolent entity can acquire a majority of hash rate some way and compromise the state of the network.
1:25:33Kris NuttycombeThere's the hash rate argument, but I also think that there's an underrated regulatory argument. I think that there's enough... so, you know, I move in some spaces where there's a strong anti-crypto sentiment, and a lot of that is about environmental costs. And I think that there are a lot of folks who are interested in trying to regulate proof of work out of existence. So I think that that's just broadly a risk that is maybe underrated by the pure proof-of-work chains.
1:26:09Vlad CosteaYes, but at the same time, I can argue that proof of work is the fairest way to acquire coins, because you can use something that you already have, which is electricity and some sort of computing gear, and not purchase the coins from someone who already owns them. So you're not...
1:26:29Kris NuttycombeIdeally, that's true. I think that with the degree of miner centralization that you see today, particularly in Bitcoin, you can't just use something that you already have, right? And the... you know, there are economies of scale in proof-of-work mining that, I think, make it, you know, much cheaper for a large-scale miner, who can co-locate somewhere that has cheap electricity and get volume discounts on hardware. It has a lot of advantages, and that's a centralizing force, not a decentralizing one.
1:27:08Vlad CosteaYeah, I agree with that. It seems like Monero, for example, is struggling very much to keep up its philosophy to be ASIC-resistant, and they will have to hard fork many times, probably, to be able to do this. Whereas Zcash seems to be open to proof of stake. I'm not sure if entirely, or it's going to be a hybrid. But I do admire people who have been mining Zcash, and they kept this alive, because I think what you built is very important for the entire ecosystem and for humanity, for the aspirations of having cypherpunk money in general.
1:27:48But Bitcoin, basically, I love it so much, but at the same time, I'm aware that if we don't add any sort of privacy and we keep increasing the adoption of it, we're going to end up with a situation where we create our own prison cell, and we defend it because we know that we built it and we have contributed to its adoption. But at the same time, we are putting ourselves in danger all the time by using it. And the only way in which we can mitigate this that's not technical... so if we don't modify Bitcoin to add privacy, the only way in which we can make it acceptable to use it and not have any sort of repercussions is to play the political game.
1:28:33And make sure that we're buying politicians, or we're becoming ourselves the politicians, and we change the laws and we create a system where it's very favorable for Bitcoin. But since you can see everything, you can't really establish norms and say, you should not look at the blockchain, or you should not do this and that because it's immoral, or it's against the religion, or whatever. Someone's going to look, you know. I remember when Sergio Lerner came up with the Patoshi theory, and I read that it's on the Bitcointalk forums. And you can see that people were telling him, don't do that.
1:29:08You're not supposed to look at Satoshi's coins. That's a sacred place, you know. You're destroying something that has existed for such a long time, which is the assumption of fungibility, by daring to look at something where we did not dare to look previously. And it's sort of insane, but some people still believe that they can create Bitcoin adoption by establishing a religion. And to me, it's very stupid. And I'm happy that these experiments exist, to bring something that's compatible with Bitcoin, hopefully in the future, to fix the problems which human politics will never fix.
1:29:50Also, I got to thank the 900... how much is it? 950 people who have watched this on the livestream, most of them on Twitter. Thank you, guys. And thank you, guys, on YouTube. And to everyone on... oh, there's another question. OK, to everyone listening now, you have one last chance to ask a question, so do your best right now. Make sure it's something that wasn't asked before. And also, thanks to the sponsors. So it's SideShift.ai, it's Cake Wallet, who are new with this episode, it's LayerTwo Labs, and it's Hodling.ch. Thank you all for supporting the show. And now I got to ask this question from the chat, which is, does Zcash need something like a Michael Saylor figure?
1:30:38Josh SwihartOh, dear Lord. Like, you know, the Michael Saylor that says you should, like, you know, get rid of self-custody and keep it all in regulated entities, right? Like, I don't think Michael Saylor... so Michael Saylor has, obviously, you know, by buying a bunch of Bitcoin and helping the price go up, and enriching himself with that, you know, he's both, you know, made himself a kind of a mini cult leader, and also a target. And also, who knows, you know, folks like that can be captured in all kinds of different ways. Like, this is not what we're trying to build.
1:31:25Vlad CosteaNo, I think he's the one who's capturing people. I very much believe he is the CIA, and that's my conspiracy theory. But basically, the HQ of MicroStrategy is like 10 minutes away from the CIA HQ. And he went to high school at West Point, and he tried to be a military pilot. I mean, there's no way you can start a company after having that background without collaborating with Secret Service.
1:31:52Josh SwihartYeah. So we don't need to welcome that kind of potential capture. We're going to build great tech, and build a great community, and hope the community carries it forward. But, you know, we don't need a savior figure, I don't think, in the Zcash ecosystem. I don't think anybody...
1:32:15Vlad CosteaThe person who asked the question basically added right now that he means a bullish mouthpiece, someone who buys a lot of coins and talks about it all the time on every podcast. I mean, it wouldn't hurt.
1:32:27Josh SwihartIt's great if they do. Like, you know, I'm aware... like, there are... I'm aware of Zcash whales, you know, the kind of billionaires that are behind the scenes, some of which have gone public, and you can see their tweets and things like that, and others that are choosing to remain private. And I would love for them to get up and speak and do that kind of thing, but they don't want to, right? It's their right. It's a right to privacy. So do we need that? It's great when it happens, because it gives credibility and they have, like, broad reach. But, you know, that just... yeah, it helps in terms of awareness, but we're here to build electronic cash, so I'm not as concerned about that.
1:33:16Vlad CosteaOK, I think I ran out of questions. I don't know, I have an issue with pronouncing words today, which is a shame, really, because I spent so much time looking at Zcash and I'm excited about it still. I bought some. I don't own too much of it, but maybe I should own more. People in the chat were discussing price, saying that this interview might just pump the price. Maybe someone is trading against our statements, which is funny, but that's not why we're doing this.
1:33:46And I guess all of us in this call are thinking long-term, and I just want to thank you for it. So thank you very much, Josh. Thank you very much, Kris. I admire your work and the pragmatism through which you're doing it, and the fact that, you know, you're not bending the knee to either people who say we should have no privacy, or people who say that nothing except for Bitcoin should exist. So thank you very much.
1:34:13Josh SwihartThank you, Vlad, and thanks for being so open in these kind of conversations, and for hosting us. This has been great.
1:34:18Kris NuttycombeYeah, this has been great. And yeah, just going to keep at it.
1:34:22Vlad CosteaAlso, how can people follow you, but not in a creepy way, where they follow you home and they see what you're doing?
1:34:30Josh SwihartYeah, so there's a Zcash Twitter handle. It's still relatively young. We had to get it donated from somebody that was sitting on it for a long time. So there's that, @zcash. There's @ElectricCoinCo. There's a Zcash Foundation Twitter, I can't remember what their Twitter handle is. You can follow them as well. And then, you know, we're working on this wallet, this user-friendly wallet, which is intended to really kind of be the platform for using ZEC, and that's Zashi. And so you can follow @zashi. So there's a few ways there. I'm at... Josh... I'm @jswihart. Oh, there's the Zashi wallet. I'm @jswihart. Kris, what's your...
1:35:14Kris NuttycombeI'm nuttycom on Twitter.
1:35:20Vlad CosteaYeah. To everyone listening to this, please follow them and keep up with whatever Zcash is doing, because it's not just interesting, it's useful. And a lot of projects are paying attention, and you're going to see a lot of zero-knowledge proofs being added to the space in the coming years. And if you want to know where it all comes from, look at Zcash. And also, none of this is financial advice. If you don't want to buy Zcash, you hate it, and you think this mining setup is scammy, and you think Zooko is a scammer himself and he shouldn't have left Bitcoin, and you're still butthurt about something that happened eight years ago or something, you don't have to do anything.
1:36:00I hope this information was useful to you. And I want to thank all of the almost 1,000 people who listened to this on livestream. Thank you very much. Any closing remark? Let's say something funny. So if you listened up to this point, write something in the comments, like Zashi or whatever. Or download the wallet, give it a try. It's actually really good. It's impressive. Oh, someone sent me a transaction. Oh, nice. Awesome. Oh, he called me a retardio, and he sent 0.00069.
1:36:40Josh SwihartNice. Well, you got trolled through the Zashi wallet. I think that's a first.
1:36:45Kris NuttycombeYeah. Hey, you know, at least there's an economic cost to it, right? You know, there's a degree of spam resistance, although fees are pretty cheap, so you can probably...
1:36:58Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if you can see this, but he put like a pointing emoji and a clown emoji and called me a retardio. It's horrible. It's at your own expense, friend. OK, thank you, guys.