Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S16 E33 / Transcript
Transcript · S16 E33 · 1:29:22 · 9 Jul 2025

S16 E33: Liz Steininger on Least Authority & Auditing Open Source Software

With Liz Steininger. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:30Vlad CosteaHello there, and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 33. This episode is sponsored by SideShift, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News, Edge Wallet, LayerTwo Labs, NoOnes.com and Hodling.ch. And we are live with Liz Steininger. That's the correct way of saying it. And she's the CEO of Least Authority, a company which has a bunch of products, which are basically constructed around the idea of security and privacy. And they also do a lot of auditing in the space. As far as I know, they have conducted more than 100 audits of open source projects in the crypto space and Bitcoin related stuff. And the company was also started by Zooko, which I thought was interesting. But I got to ask you, Liz, before I let you introduce yourself further, isn't this a bit ironic that something that's called Least Authority has a CEO?

1:43Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah, you're not the first person to bring that up to me. And actually, that's something that I even thought about when I was going to take the job. So yeah, it's fun. I think that when you have a company like ours, where kind of our mission and how we all work together as a team, we don't see it the same kind of hierarchy as perhaps like the regular corporate with the CEO. So and I guess that in our own way, we look at authority even differently within the company.

2:19But out of a necessity, yeah, there has to be some level of authority, because that's how companies work and how they interact with the rest of the world. So yeah, we try to try to find a balance there, that to have some structure and some leadership, but without it being authoritarian, I guess.

2:38Vlad CosteaBefore this interview, I tried to do my homework, and I stumbled upon some literature on least authority. There is a paper by Nick Szabo, I'm not sure if you are familiar with the work of Nick Szabo, but he published that in 1995. And he tried to basically define what least authority is about, like the philosophy of this principle. And also he dated it back to some writings by James Madison. I thought that was very interesting. It's one of the founding American principles to have the kind of power which is more symbolic than it is coercive.

3:17Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah. I mean, for me personally, the idea that individuals especially have autonomy and freedom and choice over what they do is incredibly important. So yeah, the idea of minimizing authority and thinking of authority more from a perspective of what's necessary as opposed to what's wanted, for example, because people like power. I think that that's like the approach of what's a necessity here and what's for the better of us collectively, etc, is a nice way to think of it. But I don't know that paper, actually, which is sad. And now I'm going to note to read it.

4:01Vlad CosteaYeah, I think Nick Szabo inspired Zooko quite a lot because they used to work together at DigiCash in the 90s. He was much older, I think. Szabo was like 35 or something at the time. And he was working on his own digital money project, which was called BitGold, which was like 90% of what Bitcoin is today, which is very fascinating.

4:32Liz SteiningerYeah, and I was in a different space of tech at the time. But when did you say the paper came out?

4:39Vlad Costea1995.

4:40Liz SteiningerYeah, okay. Yeah, I was just learning tech.

4:44Vlad CosteaI was three years old.

4:47Liz SteiningerI was a little older, for sure. I was still I was using tech by that age a lot. But yeah, I wasn't quite into that, like level of tech yet. I was still trying to understand how it all worked. I think I was about 15. So.

5:01Vlad CosteaRight. So what's your background?

5:05Liz SteiningerWith tech, or...?

5:06Vlad CosteaYeah, let's stick with tech.

5:08Liz SteiningerSure. Yeah, I mean, I got introduced to I mean, technology has been something I love. And the internet was pretty fundamental to like, when I was growing up, and how that just changed everything. So this I, you know, being connected to people around the world was pretty interesting. I got into like, more of the regular kind of tech space. And then I got found my way into like, more towards open source, which was that that also shifted things for me that felt more like home in terms of like my beliefs about how people should function together and how we approach technology.

5:45And then luckily, I also ended up in the like, security space with tech, more on the side of looking at open source tools that help with secure communication, circumvention technologies, things like that. And

6:00Vlad CosteaAs I fix my camera, keep going. I forgot to plug the power source.

6:07Liz SteiningerOh, no worries. Yeah, so um, yeah, so then I got into secure comms and like circumvention tech and like that really got me to the side of privacy. Prior to that, I was much more on the on the on the kind of other side of the spectrum with transparency. And so, you know, going from this like transparency side, not just open source, but like, freedom of information, etc. And making sure information was accessible to like large populations to then go on the privacy side was really interesting for me.

6:37And I think that that has helped me to understand this kind of the two spaces and how we balance them in tech a little bit better having gone to both sides. And so yeah, I've been on the privacy side and the security side for a while now, about 10 years.

6:56Vlad CosteaOkay, I should be back now. Anyway, I was going to ask you, why do you say that open source inspired you and made you feel closer to technology? Because in some ways, it feels counterintuitive. And some of the first technology that we use, and in my case, it was Windows and a PC that use the IBM architecture that was not open source at all.

7:21Liz SteiningerYeah, true, true. I mean, yeah, that's been an interesting thing with the history of technology, like, and what we use. It's not all open source, by any means, and hasn't been. Yeah, I think what I like about open source is just this idea that, first of all, it's the idea that people can connect and collaborate together on different levels, it can be impromptu, it can be organized, that there's just more of this kind of openness to connecting with people on the same topic. That is, if things are all good, you're back.

7:57If everything's closed and proprietary, then, you know, seeking out that kind of connection is much, it's a different kind of thing that you have to do. It's a different interaction that you have with people. And so it was that part. And then it's also this idea of independent verification, and how that enables autonomy for anybody who wants to double check the technology that they're interacting with. And so it's that part of like, yeah, just really that openness side of it that allows for, I think, really interesting magic to happen with technology that otherwise is very difficult to achieve whenever everything's closed.

8:35Vlad CosteaAt the same time, so in this Bitcoin space, we like to say don't trust verify a lot, because the code is open source. And sometimes developers appeal to the fact that maybe tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people have run their software. And they also assume a degree of verification. And auditing firms and companies that are conducting this sort of verification are regarded sort of like mammoths, right? Because we say, well, why do you need auditing if anyone can audit? And they will say, why do you need to appeal to someone's authority and say that these people are experts when anyone can be an expert?

9:18Liz SteiningerYeah, I think so you're asking like, how do you how do I think about that kind of concept of anybody can be an expert versus the experts?

9:28Vlad CosteaNo, basically, I'm questioning the legitimacy of companies like least authority in a space where hypothetically, everyone can verify the code.

9:39Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah. I mean, I think hypothetical and the hypothetical versus the reality of it and the practicalness of it is where there's space for businesses like us. But it should be that hypothetically, anybody could go verify this, you know, verify the software and stuff like that, especially the open source. I mean, we can also talk about us verifying closed source software, which is something that anyone can't do. They need to have the special access and be, you know, permitted, et cetera. But on the open source side, yeah, I think it should be that hypothetically, anybody could.

10:13The reality is that people don't all want to put forth the effort to do that. And so I think that that's where you need to have some trusted, like, I hate, yeah, the word trust is very difficult, but you need to have some parties that you're willing to, you know, believe a bit. But you still, but again, we also, you know, we take it also to the step of publishing the reports. I think that that's also very important to publish the work so that there's accountability basically at every step along the way.

10:41And so that, again, that that helps people better rely on the information or this like, okay, I don't need to read the whole thing right now, but I know that I could if I wanted to. And the same thing with the code that, you know, not everybody's going to sit down and write every piece of software, but can we distribute that kind of work in different ways and still hold people accountable? So, yeah, I just think that there, yeah, there's space between the hypothetical and the reality of everybody doing it for there to be business for convenience.

11:13Yeah.

11:13Vlad CosteaSince you've become CEO of Least Authority, do you recall any moments when you found something surprisingly bad in places you did not expect and you reported that?

11:26Liz SteiningerOh, like when we're auditing stuff? Sure. Yeah, we found some really surprising things for sure. For sure. But this is where it's nice that we get hired by the teams who want us to do the auditing, you know, so they want us to find the problems and tell them before somebody else finds them. So, yeah, that's also, again, a nice position to be in value wise, is that, you know, we're helping people who want help.

11:55Vlad CosteaSo for context, just to give the listeners a better understanding of what Least Authority is about, who are some of the clients that came to Least Authority and requested audits?

12:08Liz SteiningerOh, so many over the years. Yeah, we've done, I think, about 300 audits now, close to 300. I think we're close to breaking 300. But, yeah, over the years, I mean, we've done audits even as far back in 2018 with Zcash after they split out of Least Authority and we were no longer connected. We did audits for them all the way up. I mean, we've looked at MetaMask, we've been hired by the Ethereum Foundation. We've done stuff in the Stacks ecosystem, Filecoin, Polygon, of course, in the like other projects within the Bitcoin ecosystem, too.

12:48Tezos, I can keep going.

12:51Vlad CosteaI also saw that you audited the code for the Keystone hardware wallet.

12:57Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah, right now we are the Zcash ecosystem security lead. And for that role, we get to look at multiple Zcash projects, like with, you know, basically projects that are related to Zcash in the ecosystem. So yeah, that was one of them, I believe.

13:21Vlad CosteaIn my interview with Zooko, I think he mentioned, and it's a pretty long one, it takes about six hours to dive into that massive information. He mentioned something that Least Authority was able to basically predict that something like the DAO hack from 2016 could happen.

13:41Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah, that was back, yeah, back, it was, I think it was like about 2015. The team did the incentive analysis for Ethereum. And yeah, there was things like that found. Of course, it wasn't known. I mean, like you can recognize, like we can recognize that there's potential for particular types of vulnerabilities, but we can't predict in the future how people are going to exploit them. But yeah, to theorize that something like that could happen, definitely that came up in that report. And it's linked to from our website if people want to read it.

14:17Vlad CosteaSo how does it feel when you basically say that something can happen and the situation does not get addressed? And then you watch it happen?

14:28Liz SteiningerYeah, that's probably one of the downsides of the work we do. Because again, all of us who work, like I'm not the auditor of myself, but all of us who work towards this end of helping people further secure their software and systems, we do it because we want to do it, not just because we're getting paid to do it, but because we want to, and because we believe that it actually helps as a purpose to it. And so then to have that work not avoid something it was trying to avoid, like not prevent something it was trying to help, yeah, it's probably one of the downsides to the work that we do.

15:07So that does happen occasionally. Luckily, it doesn't happen as often as it could.

15:15Vlad CosteaBut is this some sort of acknowledgement that you did a good job when you realized that, you know, you discovered something theoretical, you realize that happened in practice and it should feel, I don't know, rewarding? You're like, yeah, I didn't waste my time on this. I actually discovered something before it happened.

15:36Liz SteiningerYeah, I mean, this is again, the hard part about security, because like we don't get in the security business because we want to be proven right, like in that sense, you know, we get into it because we want to help. And a lot of the work that we do, we never know if it was successful because, you know, it's hard to prove that you prevented something from happening. And so we don't get to see that. Yeah, but I think this idea of like, oh, I told you so, is that rewarding?

16:07I don't know. I guess it depends on what kind of reaction. I think in some cases, you know, we don't want to be the ones saying, I told you so, because we want them to, but I guess if people, I guess there are some cases, maybe our work wasn't taken seriously or something. And then that I told you so feeling, I guess it does come a little bit. But like I said, it's not a preferred feeling.

16:37Vlad CosteaI've been asking people about audits and sometimes I get the answer that the software changes so fast that if they do an audit and they're going to get a rating or something, it's not conclusive for what the final product is going to be like. And this is why some projects avoid doing audits or altogether, but others do it. But at the same time, they have maybe a small change, maybe a few lines of code that sort of change the assumptions for their security and might even lead to situations that were not part of the analysis.

17:17So when do you think is a good time to do an audit for any kind of open source project?

17:25Liz SteiningerYeah, unfortunately, it depends. I mean, I think if you have a target set of features and functionality for your product, like if you have that set in mind, and it's very clear and you're going to get there, then yeah, wait until you get there and do the audit. If your roadmap is such that you're going to launch prior to that, like with like a lesser set of features and functions, and then you're you can also plan those kinds of the initial comprehensive audit where we look at everything at the base, and then you can plan like diff audits, like looking at what actually changed and figuring it out.

18:01But it also depends on how you're building stuff as to whether the whole thing needs to be re-audited or if you're building certain features and functions and components in a more modular way, et cetera. So then there's just, you know, that limits the scope of where things could be impacted. Other teams, yeah, other teams, we definitely see teams who have less of a clear roadmap and, you know, they're maybe, you know, not like their roadmap, they're building as maybe their users desire stuff or as the market needs change, et cetera, and they're trying to be more flexible.

18:34Then, yeah, I mean, I think that there's still ways that you can get audits that are both like practical, affordable, and reasonable given the circumstances, but it also depends on who's relying on your code and your system. So if it's billions of dollars, then maybe it's worth getting some audits, even if you're going to have to have stuff re-audited. But if it's just, you know, people's like pocket money for play and it's not a lot, then, yeah, wait, what's the need?

19:08Vlad CosteaBut I gotta ask you, how does it work with liability? Like maybe that you do the audit and you don't discover something and I'm not only talking about least authority, I'm talking about any auditor and then something unforeseen is happening. And did you vouch for the system that it's good enough or secure and then you have to basically pay or how does it work?

19:34Liz SteiningerNow, unfortunately, security just can't work that like that. Whether it be like physical security or the security of a code base or any type of security, this idea that something is 100% secure and that that can be guaranteed is false. It's like, I mean, you can even think about it like with your apartment or your car or something like that. If somebody said like this car is impossible to break into, I 100% guarantee you. Would you believe that? I mean, of course not.

20:01Vlad CosteaDo you remember that demonstration by Elon Musk when he tried to show that the window of his Cybertruck is not going to break and he broke it?

20:11Liz SteiningerYeah, I remember that. But that's a great example. Yeah, I mean, this this idea that like, somebody can guarantee you 100% like that it's 100% secure is false. It's not real. That's not possible. And, you know, I also think that that's one that reflects how, I don't know, ingenious humans are that like, we we will always find a way around, like, if somebody tells us we can't do something, or if something's like, you know, this is perfect, and you can't break into it, somebody's going to be like, I want to figure out how.

20:42And they will. And that's what's really lovely about the other side is that, you know, as humans, we're always trying to figure out how to break things and do things differently, etc. And that's really cool. But we have to realize that when it comes to security, that's going to be the case. And so, yeah, there is no such thing as guarantee. And so that has to be written into how the industry functions. And so not just us, like any auditing team or any security team, like, we have to add to a certain level of professional responsibility to do a good job at what we do, but we can't be expected to not make to not miss something.

21:15I think, but again, it's like this kind of what's the industry standard professional level of responsibility that you can expect. And that is easier and more established industries. Like, yeah, like car security, for example. Like how keys are handled and stuff like that. I don't know if it's the best example here, but like within the crypto space, it's been a little bit more challenging that like this idea of like security norms and stuff and expectations and stuff. It takes some time for those to settle as the new things, new innovations and technologies changing, etc.

21:54But yeah, we're not expected to do 100% guarantees for sure. And you should be suspicious if anyone tells you that you're certified secure.

22:04Vlad CosteaYeah. And even if you design the perfect security system, you can still route around it at the social level. So yeah, you can just do some social engineering and route around that complicated cryptography and get some other human being to act in a way that destroys the system or at least grants you access inside.

22:27Liz SteiningerYeah, it's just like passwords. You can follow all of those recommendations when you're creating that login to like make sure that you have a special character and a number and that it's like 16, like, you know, whatever, that you can follow all those recommendations. But if you put it on a post it note on next to your computer, what good is the strong password? So yeah, security. Security is just not that simple that, you know, even if we manage to find all the vulnerabilities in the code, there could still be another way.

22:56Vlad CosteaAnd a lot of these situations in our industry were exchange hacks, where maybe that the exchanges themselves were audited and secure and the funds were fine. But all it took was someone to SIM swap some employee and get access from the inside.

23:12Liz SteiningerYeah. Yeah, unfortunately.

23:17Vlad CosteaOr maybe just befriend someone like I remember there was this, I think it was in 2021 with the Pfizer leaks that that's what they call them. Like everything was being kept like everything about that process was being kept very secretly. I don't know how I should describe it better. And there was this investigation journalist who basically got someone to confess during a date, like just someone working for that company, having a casual conversation about what's happening at work. And that's how a lot of the information got leaked.

23:57Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah. Yeah, it's not surprising.

24:02Vlad CosteaSo if you want to route around very secure environments, sometimes all it takes is just find the right person who's weak. And that's the weakest link.

24:13Liz SteiningerFor sure. Good advice. I mean, it's good advice to people who want to protect against that.

24:20Vlad CosteaSure. And watch out for what kind of information you're telling your family members and see how reliable they are, because maybe your mom is talking too much to her friends or something. And her friends have sons who are not very friendly. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Anyway, I'm going to plug a couple of ads and then I want to get back to least authority because I feel like we haven't covered everything about the vision and the mission of the project. But I still wanted to leave the first part to some information which people might find interesting about auditing in general.

24:59And I guess most of my sponsors are open source. Let me pick one of them. LayerTwo Labs, they're building sidechains for Bitcoin. And all they need to deploy is BIP 300, which you can read on the page on the Bitcoin core project GitHub. And basically, if this one comes to Bitcoin, we're going to get a Zcash sidechain and Ethereum sidechain, basically all of the stuff that least authority has audited over the years, but using BTC, the token on the sidechain, which is secured by the Bitcoin miners, you can check out the software today at layertwolabs.com/download.

25:42And I think right now it runs on the Bitcoin signet. And there's also Citrea, which is trying to bring ZK rollups, which is something that was built by Ethereum thanks to Zcash, which once again, were both audited by least authority. And they are trying to bring this to Bitcoin. Now they're on the Bitcoin testnet, and they're expected to launch later this year. And basically, what Citrea is doing is to bring some extra financial applications that Bitcoin currently does not have, and enable builders to also bring some applications from Ethereum on top of the Bitcoin base layer.

26:23And the way in which they do it is by inscribing some zero knowledge proofs into the Bitcoin blockchain that they use for verification purposes. It's very interesting. It's ambitious. And you can already test the software today at citrea.xyz. And they have, I think, an application that you can download for pretty much every operating system. And there's also Edge Wallet, which is once again, an open source software wallet, which I don't think was audited by least authority, at least not yet. But they do have support for assets, which were audited by least authority.

27:01And they function on the principle that they try to not store any kind of information that can link to the user. So everything is encrypted on your device. It has easy access to pretty much everything. And it's like a built in exchange in which you can swap between assets. So if someone sends you a coin that you don't like, you can actually use the built in swapping features to get the coin that you want without KYC. And they also have a duress mode, which is good for security.

27:33If someone is watching you unlock your wallet or someone at the airport asks you to unlock your wallet, you can type a different pin and you're going to get another screen which shows that you have zero balance. And you can just say, Oh, I downloaded this because a friend told me to. But in reality, you're traveling with like a million dollars in Bitcoin. Anyway, it's pretty cool. You can download this for free at edge.app. And thanks, guys, for sponsoring the show. Now let's go back to least authority.

28:05Not that I haven't plugged them already during the sponsor presentation. But so your assistant or I don't know exactly what he does. But he made a list of talking points, which I find slightly offensive, as if I don't know what I should talk about. But at the same time, I also find it useful because sometimes it basically it helps me ask questions. That I wouldn't think about. And he mentioned that we should explore least authority as a principle with reducing centralized control, increasing user sovereignty and designing cryptographic systems with minimal trust assumptions.

28:45What is this about? And how does least authority the company apply this?

28:51Liz SteiningerYeah, so this is the I think early on, you mentioned that we have some products and this is the direction that we go when we do our open our own development activities like open source development is looking to really minimize the need for things like personal information. So because, you know, the more personal information, then it's reliance on the service, et cetera, rely on minimize like centralization. Yeah, that kind of stuff and making sure that the systems are privacy respecting for sure. So, yeah, I can talk a bit more about those.

29:27Vlad CosteaI see that on your website, you have three products, which are PrivateStorage, ZKAPs, and Winden.

29:36Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah. So PrivateStorage for that one, that's that's live. And yeah, you can go sign up for it. It's like a consumer app. So for individuals to go use, and it's low cost. But yeah, basically, as a client side application, and that client side application, it'll, it doesn't use username or password, there's not personal information needed to like sign up for an account or anything like that. You have to do some personal information for making the payments, but we use ZKAPs, the ones that you mentioned, the zero knowledge access passes, we use basically zero knowledge proofs to ensure that the payment information that we get from people doesn't get connected to their usage of the storage service.

30:20So that there's clear privacy and the use of the storage service. But yeah, with PrivateStorage, like I was saying, it's a client-side application, so you get to keep things, the user has full control of what's happening with the software on their local machine. And it does client-side encryption and sharding of the data. And so the data that gets stored with our servers is basically sharded ciphertext. And so we can't put the shards back together and we can't decrypt them. And so you don't have to trust the PrivateStorage service at all.

30:59Or the servers that we use or anything like that. And so that's PrivateStorage. And the zero knowledge access passes, ZKAPs that you mentioned, those aren't really a standalone product. I wish they were, but they aren't quite. But that's what we created. And there's a white paper about it. It's a technique based on Privacy Pass. But yeah, basically using these zero knowledge proofs to allow people to disconnect or make sure that the information isn't connected, I should say, between the payment step and the usage of the storage service.

31:33And then Winden is a spinoff from, it uses something called Magic Wormhole, which is basically a way to send files. So it's a file transfer protocol. And Winden, it's winden.app. You can go to the website and that's free to use. And it's just a way to send files between two machines. It's free and there's no personal information required to use it. So you don't have to use an email address, set up an account. You don't have to give a phone number or anything like that. So you could basically use it anonymously with another person or another device to send files.

32:11So, yeah, again, minimizing the trust needed.

32:15Vlad CosteaSo what this sounds like to me is that you have a private Google Drive and a private WeTransfer.

32:23Liz SteiningerYeah.

32:24Vlad CosteaAnd basically something that dissociates between the payer and the payee so that you don't know what they actually bought.

32:35Liz SteiningerWell, the payment step, for sure. So like in the case of PrivateStorage, you buy storage time from us. So we know who bought storage time from us because we got that, you know, we had to, as a business, we know who bought it from us. Unless they bought it with, actually, we don't know all the people who bought storage time. Actually, there are ways. You can buy it with cash with a proxy store that's online. You can pay them cash to buy storage time. And so then we definitely don't know who you are because it was through a reseller, for example.

33:05It's basically a reselling program that you can use cash with. So, yeah, so there's ways that we don't know everybody who bought storage time. But if we happen to know that you bought storage time with a credit card, whether or not you use that storage time or when you use that storage time, we never have any idea. So you could basically give that storage time to someone else or something like that or resell it, I guess, if you wanted to. It's not super easy to do that stuff, but you could and we wouldn't know, basically.

33:38So then we know that people are using our service, but we just can't connect it to who bought the storage time.

33:45Vlad CosteaIs it open source?

33:48Liz SteiningerYeah. Yeah, all of it.

33:51Vlad CosteaSo basically anyone can create their own version of PrivateStorage and maybe accept Bitcoin or Zcash or whatever for payments to basically not run this as a business, but more like a protocol.

34:07Liz SteiningerOh, you mean, ah, yeah. What do you mean? Like a protocol to prevent like for just buying storage time?

34:15Vlad CosteaTo sort of decentralize from having a company in the middle.

34:21Liz SteiningerYeah. Yeah. I mean, like our job as the company with PrivateStorage is more around the kind of the so it's more around the hosting and management of the storage servers than anything else. And just so, yeah, you can basically take the code base and also PrivateStorage is built off of a code base called Tahoe-LAFS, Tahoe-LAFS, which is, you know, open source, old school.

34:50Vlad CosteaYeah, Least Authority File System.

34:52Liz SteiningerYeah, exactly. That's the LAFs part. And not named after the... I don't think it's really meant to attach to the company. It's just meaning the principle of least authority. Yeah. So that's all open source. So, yeah, you and your friends. And the wonderful thing about Tahoe-LAFS is that it can be used as like client server model or it can be used as like a P2P model. So you don't necessarily have to have storage servers that are different from the client machines that are, you know, like syncing or whatever the data.

35:27So, yeah, syncing the data with each other. So you could, you and a bunch of friends could all install Tahoe-LAFS inside of your own P2P network and, you know, store on each other's machines, etc. And you would still get the client-side encryption and sharding and everything because that's in that. But not everybody wants to do that work. So, you know, the kind of business part with PrivateStorage is more of the convenience that there's, you know, a managed cloud that's operated on your behalf, like operated for you.

36:00And you don't have to worry about like server uptime, etc. and server access. So.

36:08Vlad CosteaSo your ZKAPs are built for the purpose of providing privacy to the person paying with credit card, I guess. That's kind of the goal for this.

36:21Liz SteiningerYeah, for the payment types that don't provide you privacy. Yeah.

36:27Vlad CosteaBut can you think of ways in which this can be used for something else?

36:31Liz SteiningerOh, for sure. That's why I do wish that ZKAPs was a standalone product because it could be used for all kinds of other services. Basically any service where the service provider doesn't have a fundamental need to know your identity. Yeah, we shouldn't be. But there's so many things out there, like so many services out there that we give identifying information to the provider just purely for the payment part, not for any other purpose. Like, for example, like electricity, I think, VPN. You know, there's all kinds of things where they don't really need to know who you are to provide you the service.

37:07So. But the reason they do is because you have to set up an account and you have to give them information so that they can manage the accounting side of stuff. So like payment side of stuff. So

37:21Vlad CosteaI think that Nym, the mixnet, mentioned that they're using something similar for allowing their customers. Or is it ZKAPs that they're using?

37:31Liz SteiningerNo, I don't think they I mean, I haven't spoken to them about it or look deeply in what they're using. But I did see that they've since added something like that. We did like the ZKAP stuff that we've done is based on Privacy Pass, which is something that was started with Cloudflare and Tor. And it's yeah, so it's all kind of yeah, you know how open source works. And that's how it should work like that, like somebody builds something, somebody's like, oh, that's a really cool thing.

38:01But I want it to be slightly different for this other use case. And so then they adapt it for a different use case, like in the case of like Cloudflare and Tor. Like, you know, they had a very particular like use case for that they needed to develop privacy pass for. And then, yeah, our use case was pretty different, but that we could use the same concept and some of the some of the code too.

38:24Vlad CosteaYeah, it's really cool. Yeah, I mean, it's very similar. And I can understand why Zooko would want to build something like this, because it's similar with what Digicash was trying to do. Basically, create a way for credit card payments on the Internet to be anonymous. Of course, it's not as powerful as that, but it's a pretty good second best to that. If you want to pay with your credit card on the Internet, you call it ZKAPs. But it's something which a lot of companies should look into.

38:59Liz SteiningerYeah, I agree. I mean, it comes back to this whole value system about like privacy for users and privacy for individuals to be able. And this idea that I want to control when I share certain information with people. And a lot of the tech that we interact with right now doesn't have respect for people's privacy at every level. But, you know, for us, it was this concept of like, OK, we are offering this wonderful PrivateStorage, like where we are people, you know, where they don't have to trust the servers that they're giving their sharded encrypted data to, but they're giving us data when they're paying us.

39:35So if we want to operate a business in line with our values, how can we, you know, prevent that information from being linked by us? And I think that I wish more businesses would ask themselves, like, do we really need this information? But unfortunately, the tech industry, you know, what, a couple of decades ago went down the path of more data, you know, collecting personal data, how it holds value, et cetera. And yeah, luckily, that's starting to the tide has been changing, but there's still a ways to go.

40:05Vlad CosteaAnd also Winden, which is W-I-N-D-E-N, is a very good one to remember, because a lot of times I run into this issue of I want to send a large file, Telegram will not allow it. WhatsApp has even lower limits. Gmail is horrible. I think they're limited. Still like 25 megabytes unless you want to buy more storage from Google. Yeah. And you have all of these services that promise to not store your files, but most likely do. Yeah. Because you're not paying them anything for it.

40:36And this one basically is a Winden. What it does is that it lets you send large files between two peers. And I know that back in the day, we used to set up FTP for sending files to each other, and that was not encrypted. That was not anonymous in any way. So you could have almost no privacy. Maybe the only privacy is that only you and the person receiving the data knew the exact FTP address. But maybe someone else could get involved in the middle. Yeah. And for a while it was fashionable to use torrents for this kind of stuff.

41:15I don't know what happened to torrents. They're not as popular anymore, but they're not quite a solution for sending between two peers. They're more like a way to disperse data around the Internet to make everything more censorship resistant and harder to take down. But Winden sounds very cool. It's actually something that I've been searching for.

41:38Liz SteiningerYeah. And we got funded with grants, basically, to get it to the point it is now. I think there should be some information on that Winden.app website where it says we got EU funding to build it. It's not monetized by us right now. We just maintain it. But it's not too expensive to maintain. So for that, it's a really nice tool. We found that one really popular use case is just sending something between your laptop and your phone, for example.

42:13We did a poll, but most of the people I talked to, too. You usually maybe send an email or you have to use a cloud drive or something like that when you just want to put a file between two devices. You don't really always need to store it on the cloud. You just want to send it. And people don't really like to plug their devices together anymore. We all want stuff to be wireless. And so, yeah, it's really great for that. And then there's other cases like you need to send personal documents to a service provider like a lawyer, an accountant or something like that, healthcare docs.

42:50I mean, some of those, the bigger businesses have their own systems to manage, like document management systems. But if it's just like your freelance lawyer and you or something like that, those could be good cases where you could avoid email. And so avoiding the use of a third party tool that will store your sensitive file. Yeah, because if it sits in your email inbox, then if your inbox is hacked, then somebody has access to it, et cetera. And the whole service provider does, too. Whereas, yeah, with Winden, it's kind of ephemeral.

43:26But right now, both devices have to be online at the same time to receive it because it's not being stored.

43:30Vlad CosteaRight. So it says that Winden is end to end encrypted, which is beautiful, but also that is identity free. I'm not sure what this means. It says further that meaning that senders and receivers don't need to know each other's identity to use it. So how does the person know where they're receiving from?

43:53Liz SteiningerWell, I mean, I guess it depends on your use case of when you don't want to know that person. But yeah, you could send them. Basically, it's this human readable code that you can give them. And so you could send that via another communication platform, be it anonymous or not. Or you could, you know, speak it to somebody. It's supposed to be speakable was the human readable part, too, so that you could say it over the phone or if you're in person together. You can also just like show them visually the code in person and so that they don't have to write it down anywhere.

44:25So there's no record of basically then that also allows you to have no record of the exchange of a file between two parties. And because there's no personal data being gathered by us, like phone number, there's no phone. Like you don't need to have your phone number added, like with some tools you do. You don't need to have an account set up or anything like that. You don't need to use your email address, anything. So we have no idea whose file was sent when and to who.

44:52And that's nice.

44:55Vlad CosteaIt's really beautiful. Yeah. I should try this with my friend.

45:01Liz SteiningerYeah. Yeah, we we hope to be able to add more like more features and expand on it in the future. But at the moment, unfortunately, we haven't been able to get another grant to do more to it. But so if anyone out there wants to work with us on it, let us know. Otherwise, it's open source. So people are also welcome to fork and do as they please. Yeah.

45:24Vlad CosteaAre there any other products that are in development or products that used to be supported by least authority but have been discontinued?

45:35Liz SteiningerNo, I don't think so. There's I should say on Winden, there's another app. There's also a mobile app version of it. It's called Destiny, though. Again, different grant. So it has a different name, but it's still this magic wormhole protocol allowing you to send files. So yeah, there is also mobile apps version of it, too, because Winden is just a web app.

46:01Vlad CosteaOh, I did find this on your website. So it's listed under Community Matters. It's called Destiny. And it says it's an open source file transfer application that does not reveal identities.

46:14Liz SteiningerYeah. And we received another grant to work on that. And we're still maintaining it okay. But I do think at some point in time, these kinds of things we won't be able to maintain forever without figuring out additional funding approaches for them because they're not monetized. Like Winden and Destiny are not monetized at all at this point. But this is a bigger problem within the open source industry.

46:39Vlad CosteaExactly. Like how do you make money? Yeah.

46:43Liz SteiningerYeah. I mean, we could rely on donations from people, but that has its challenges, as you know. And then we're not opposed to that kind of model, but it just comes with its own set of challenges. You can't have any kind of predictability of the donations that are coming in for these services. So the support for them ongoing is difficult. Grants, going from grant to grant, grant makers usually, grant givers usually want to see some sort of shiny new thing, like shiny new feature, et cetera. But just maintaining open source stuff that people like, it's not that exciting.

47:24But teams like ours are happy to do that kind of stuff. We also have to pay rent and stuff like that.

47:33Vlad CosteaI got to say that I use a lot of open source software. So for this podcast right now, for the live stream, I use something that's called OBS, which is Open Broadcast Software. Nice. And this one is being supported by a bunch of companies, basically, which are using the software for their own products. And I also use something that's called Podcast Generator to put the audio file and basically generate an RSS feed that gets grabbed by Spotify and Apple Podcasts. And so I think it has some tradeoffs because it's not as authoritative as something which is owned by Spotify or something.

48:16Maybe it affects discoverability or whatever, but I do like it a lot.

48:21Liz SteiningerYeah, I mean, that kind of model where you have larger companies that are utilizing the software for their own needs, maybe, you know, therefore profiting off of use of that software and therefore then supporting the software. Like, you know, it sounds like they've got like a set of people doing that. Like that model, that works. Yeah, that works too. But, you know, all models have their tradeoffs for sure. And you have to have enough of those kinds of companies using the software. Unfortunately, I think things like Winden haven't been.

48:55Like, just the way that it's modeled for consumers, I don't see large companies wanting to come in and like support it. But, I don't know, surprise me if you would disagree. Anyone can reach out to us and let us know. But yeah, it's definitely been a bit of a challenge for us because we see that there's a clear need for individuals to use this kind of software. But yeah, what's the right kind of model to have it supported? I mean, another one possibly is like freemium or something like that, where the lower tier of service is free and the higher tiers are paid.

49:29But yeah, we just didn't get to implementing any of that.

49:33Vlad CosteaI see that something else on the website of Least Authority is called HRO Cloud. It's also listed under Community Matters, and it stands for Human Rights Organization's Cloud. And I guess it's very similar with PrivateStorage.

49:51Liz SteiningerIt is basically PrivateStorage, but a version where it's not paid. It's instead based on like qualifications. And that's also where the flexibility of the ZKAPs approach came in for us, that we can basically issue storage time based on proof of payment, which is what we do for PrivateStorage. But in this case, we issued storage time tokens for proof of qualification. So proof of being a human rights organization. We are going to have to shut down HRO Cloud again due to the grant that we had that was funding that ended a long time ago, and we maintained it a little bit longer.

50:31But yeah, but it is essentially PrivateStorage, just unpaid, for those orgs.

50:38Vlad CosteaI see that you also have something very funny, which is called the MoonMath Manual. Yeah. And it's a resource for anyone interested in understanding and unlocking the potential of zk-SNARKs from beginners to experts.

50:51Liz SteiningerYeah.

50:53Vlad CosteaSo how did this come about?

50:54Liz SteiningerYeah, if you can't tell from our conversation so far between the history of Zcash and like our general, like, you know, working on ZKAPs and stuff like that, we like zero knowledge proofs, and we have a lot of experience with them. And so, yeah, our, you know, our team decided that it would be good to, yeah, basically write a manual about how zk-SNARKs in particular work. But yeah, this idea is zero knowledge proofs. It started out with one of our team members, Mirco, he was doing some workshops with like pen and paper kind of explanations with the cryptography behind ZK, and he did that workshop, and it was just a success with people.

51:34And it was just this idea that, you know, how do we make, how zero knowledge proofs like the math and stuff accessible to more people? Like, you know, we were talking earlier about how, you know, this idea that hypothetically anybody could audit software. And, you know, hypothetically anybody can learn how to work with zero knowledge proofs. And, you know, how could, like, so we decided to do like a manual that helps more people have access to this kind of knowledge. Of course you wouldn't necessarily want to do like something super advanced without doing maybe more studying, maybe getting a degree or something like that with like, but, you know, also regular developers need like, and you know, yeah, regular people who are interested in this tech need to have some sort of manual too.

52:19So it's kind of like a textbook for regular people to read about how ZK works.

52:28Vlad CosteaYeah, it's really cool. I'm browsing through it right now, and I wish I found it sooner. Like, I've learned about this from so many spread around resources, like it was disorganized, it's actually pretty cool. But how did the name Moon Math come around?

52:44Liz SteiningerI think, I think it comes from one point Vitalik called the ZKP stuff, like, it's like, it's like Moon Math, because it seems like magic, and it seems like kind of out there, but it's real and it works. So, yeah, that's, it's an older name. I think it's from probably, I don't know, six years ago or something. I don't know how long it's been, five, four. But yeah, I think there was a blog post or something about it that could be called Moon Math.

53:14Vlad CosteaI want to ask you more about privacy and the protocols that you're building, and to which extent you're getting in trouble with legal authorities or whatever, investigations, and to which extent you have the data that they're asking for. But before that, let me plug all the sponsors of the show. Okay. So, SideShift.ai is the place where you can swap pretty much everything for whatever it is that you like. So, for example, if someone wants to pay you in stable coins, and honestly, why would you want to hold onto that trusted CBDC?

53:47You can basically send them your Bitcoin address. I mean, by them I mean SideShift, and the person wanting to send you stable coins will send their stable coins, and then you get your BTC to the address that you want. And they have a lot of trading pairs, a lot of liquidity, and they're even integrated with the sponsor that I previously mentioned, which is Edge Wallet, among lots of other integrations like Trezor, and I think also Ledger, and a bunch of others. So check them out. SideShift.ai is the website, and I think they do a pretty good job with this.

54:24They're an exchange which does not require mandatory signup. So I think that's pretty cool. Also, there is Bitcoin.com news, which is a news website that has gotten much better over the years, and I appreciate it for the fact that it shows and covers a lot of news from around the world. For example, I just opened their page and I found a headline that says Belarus proposes introduction of digital currencies to BRICS settlement layer system. So basically, it's not as US-centric as other websites, and I can get a much broader view of what's happening with the Bitcoin industry from Bitcoin.com news, and they used to be green because they were supporting Bitcoin Cash, the fork of Bitcoin which has big blocks.

55:13Now they are orange, and you can see that for yourself when you go to news.bitcoin.com. Hodling.ch is also a very interesting business because they specialize in self-custody, and they're based in Switzerland. So if you're Bitcoin whale or you're part of a company that's about to buy Bitcoin, you go to them and they're going to explain to you to which extent you need to use hardware wallets or multi-sig setups or something complicated at all. They tailor the solution according to the needs of the customer, and they also give you the privacy that comes with a Swiss company.

55:52Also, if you lost part of your seed phrase for recovering your funds and you don't know how you can access your coins, they can help you with that by trying to brute force the seed phrase, but I think it only works if you lost less than four words. But anyway, it's worth a try, and of course they charge a fee for that, and their website is Hodling.ch. And last but not least, there's NoOnes, which is a peer-to-peer exchange that aims to empower the global south, and their CEO, Ray Youssef, is very adamant about this vision of allowing citizens of the third world to join this peer-to-peer economy.

56:32If you want to provide liquidity to this peer-to-peer economy, you can trade on NoOnes.com.

56:41And something else that's interesting is that they have a debit card for spending if you're into that, and also they have a spot exchange where you can basically trade whatever coin you have for some other coin that you want. And of course they specialize in gift cards because it seems like it's a very hot commodity that is very much appreciated in the global south and is being used to swap around to get access to cash. So NoOnes.com, check it out. And now let's get to the uncomfortable question, Liz, which is about law enforcement and the fact that they are nosy sometimes, and the fact that with zero knowledge proofs, sometimes you might not have the information that they seek.

57:30Liz SteiningerYeah, well, I think that that's one of the keys to designing systems with the use of zero knowledge proofs and like privacy tech and like other privacy tech is that it's really important to like, you know, design it in a way for all parties involved who have some different interests, but mostly, I mean, I think it's just fundamentally giving like the control or as much control as possible to the individual user. But yeah, I don't know. The interests are not always at odds with each other.

58:06Vlad CosteaI don't know if it's at odds with each other, but I do know that over the years regulations have gotten ridiculous and using something which does not store the information is much more efficient.

58:20Liz SteiningerYeah, so if we don't collect certain data, then we don't need to be prompted to share that data, for example. And so we always ask ourselves, like, what do we have to collect? Like, what are we legally responsible to collect? And what do we, if we don't need to collect it for some other regulation or purpose, then let's not.

58:44Vlad CosteaI used to deal with some privacy companies in the Bitcoin space, and they were based on the British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands, and all sorts of places where they were trying to basically stay away from the European Union, from the U.S., from the NSA as much as they could. And least authority is based in Germany, as far as I know. Yeah. So how does that work? How are you able to operate from Germany?

59:11Liz SteiningerYeah, I mean, I guess it really depends on what particularly use case or data you're talking about, because it really just depends on what we have to collect and what we don't have to collect. But we definitely try to minimize what we collect or just not collect anything unless we have to.

59:33Vlad CosteaHow do you see the privacy market right now? Do you think it's booming? There's more demand for it than before, or is it constant over the years?

59:43Liz SteiningerThe privacy industry, I mean, like privacy tech and like its popularity, I mean, it's definitely changed. When I first, like back in 2013, I remember like the Snowden revelations and this idea of like surveillance and stuff was just so new to everybody. But at least like thinking about like, you know, Americans and Europeans, I mean, yeah, Europeans had some indication of it. I wasn't in Europe back in 2013, but some indication of it. I mean, that's where GDPR came from. So trying to, you know, control like the levels of data, personal data that was collected about people and minimize that, I think is a really good move.

1:00:27I mean, again, I understand people's like. Some people don't like regulations and overregulation is like maybe not good, but having a regulation to tell tech companies to not collect as much personal data seems helpful at this point, because it's helped to keep in check some of the big tech companies that are just collecting data, you know, like, yeah, way too much data about us as individuals. And we don't really have a way to fight back against that without something like GDPR. So, yeah, from that angle, it's nice to be a company in Germany because we've got things like the data protection regulations here and then the German ones are good, too.

1:01:05And those help the, you know, the rights of individuals when it comes to going up against big tech.

1:01:13Vlad CosteaI think I saw some sort of advertisement at one point on YouTube, if I'm not mistaken, for WhatsApp. And they were saying that their private platform because they do have end to end encryption for the messages, but they have no privacy for the metadata, which is who is sending to whom and when. And I think there is a lot of data that can come from this. Do you see any application of zero knowledge proofs for this particular use case? And do you believe that maybe in the next decade, we're going to have the large players in this messaging space or social media adopt this zero knowledge proof technology?

1:01:56Liz SteiningerI mean, yeah, I think that, yeah, I'll answer first the adoption thing. There are so many different potential uses for zero knowledge proofs when you're trying to control like what data gets shared at what point. So this idea that you can prove that you have something, that you know something without actually sharing the data itself is so valuable from a business perspective, like, you know, individual privacy rights aside, like just coming to like businesses and confidentiality and wanting to interact like with other companies, but not share your data, like the like the cooperation between companies, etc.

1:02:29There are so many use cases for that. So for sure, big tech, everybody, I think a lot of tech companies and other people will start to need zero knowledge proofs or will recognize what the zero knowledge proofs can provide to them and how to integrate them into systems. And some of them probably already are doing a lot with them. I think Google just talked about something with the wallet or something with zero knowledge proofs, but I'm not so up to date on that news. But then, yeah, I guess the first part of your question, though, was about like individuals and their privacy rights with the tech.

1:03:09Vlad CosteaYeah, sort of, because, for example, right now, I'm subscribed to the Apple service, like what's it called, Apple Plus or whatever, and with that, I also get sort of a VPN. And also I get private logins. Honey, I can just give you the cable. You don't have to get in front of the camera. Anyway, yes, you are on camera. It becomes sort of a standard across the industry when you have Apple promising to offer better privacy and also integrating some services natively without even having to think about it.

1:03:45And something else that they have is, I don't know what they call it, but it's like email masking, where they generate sub addresses for your email address for every service so that they don't know exactly who you are. I think that's also cool.

1:04:02Liz SteiningerYeah, it is. Yeah. So then, yeah, I mean, those are great examples of how the tech industry is advancing when it comes to privacy tech. I mean, I don't know if they're perfect examples. I don't know specifically the problems with those ones, but just in general, this idea that consumers are demanding and more interested in these kinds of privacy features, whether or not they're legitimate or they're going as far as they need to is the next important question. But I do like to see the increase of demand in companies trying to offer stuff.

1:04:33Vlad CosteaI also got to ask you about Least Authority. Are most of the customers related to Zcash and Bitcoin and the cryptocurrency space, or do you also audit code for open source projects which are unrelated?

1:04:49Liz SteiningerYou mean like non-crypto projects or crypto in the previous sense of the word as in cryptography? Yeah, we get some requests for that, but not as much as I would like to see. I think it's a funding challenge because when it comes to like cryptos and cryptocurrency and the blockchain Web3 space, like there's funding. So people are building things and people are then also able to get supported. And there's like the transfer of value that the kind of connection to like quote money is what makes it like more of a necessity or more prioritized.

1:05:30They get audits, like the kind of open source crypto cryptography type projects. We see some of them, but a lot of them end up getting audits through different support mechanisms because again, they have the funding challenges that we talked about earlier. And so like there's different orgs out there that will basically do third party funding of audits. And so they go more that route. And at least there's those offerings out there now. Back when I was at Open Tech Fund a while back, that was still pretty more new that audits were being funded for these kind of open source projects, but more so it's happening.

1:06:12Vlad CosteaIt seems like nowadays we have this sub branch of computer science and software development, which is called vibe coding. And this just means that some people are telling a large language model exactly what it is that they want to build. And they're going to get recommendations based on open source projects which are available and do something similar and can be pieced together to fulfill a greater goal. But it's not necessarily true that these open source projects are the best ones or the most efficient ones or even secure.

1:06:52And sometimes when I see that people are vibe coding, I'm just thinking that auditors are going to get rich. I was curious if you actually saw a spike of activity or demand since vibe coding became a thing.

1:07:10Liz SteiningerNo, we haven't seen like a spike yet. I mean, it's definitely now a new area that's happening for sure. And there are kind of different angles on this too, that there are people who are vibe coding. And depending on what they're doing, what kind of audit they need and what kind of independent verification basically that they need of what they're producing with AI together. Yeah, I think we'll see more of that for sure. Whether or not that's big business, I mean, I agree with you, these things should be audited. Because if people can't, if anything by themselves, so this is where I think just regular programmers can help out.

1:07:50Just with the quality assurance, not just even the security check, but the quality check on what are we getting when we vibe code. Are we getting something, like what's the kind of quality standard there? And then of course, security should be thought about too. But yeah, I'm not sure how that market will really form because a lot of people are doing this for fun, right? And so do you want to go hire somebody to audit something that you just did for fun? I mean, you didn't bother to hire programmers to build it in the first place.

1:08:19So are you going to hire a service provider to audit it? I don't know.

1:08:22Vlad CosteaIn the land of Ethereum and Solana, you have a bunch of people who build smart contracts using vibe coding. Oh, yeah. Which means that they're just copying something that already exists and might not be the best design for that. I mean, it's very hard to assess. It's up to the language model to pick something. And then the person will just think it's the best option that they have. And I think that whoever audits these smart contracts, which are designed for the purpose of making money at the end of the day, is going to end up making a lot of money.

1:08:59Liz SteiningerYeah, if it's smart... I was thinking about like just vibe coding, like an app for yourself, like as an individual or like, you know, small company or something just like, hey, we just want this little app, like a web app or something. But if you're talking about like, yeah, vibe coding for smart contracts and then trying to manage money, then, yeah, there's probably a different level of value there and getting the security audit than there would be.

1:09:23Vlad CosteaDoes Least Authority deal with smart contracts too on Ethereum, or is it just zero-knowledge stuff?

1:09:29Liz SteiningerNo, no, no, we do all kinds of audits. We've done plenty of smart contract audits, for sure.

1:09:36Vlad CosteaWhat is a project that you would like to see for Least Authority, like a significant audit that maybe is like a dream project?

1:09:47Liz SteiningerOh, you know what? We like, yeah, we really enjoy new applications with advanced cryptography. So ZKP, but also new applications with like FHE. And that's the other one that comes to mind. Of course, MPC, like we've done a lot with multi-party computation with wallets already, but if people have like kind of new combinations of advanced cryptography and new, like stringing these together, combining them different ways. I think lattice is another cryptography thing that I've heard of the team talk about that they would like to do more of.

1:10:28So, yeah, I mean, yeah, anything that's like new. New applications with cryptography are super interesting for us, and they're nice. They're like a kind of good challenge for us because we've done so many of those over the years that, you know, you get practiced at looking at new stuff. And it's a different kind of learning, but it's fun.

1:10:47Vlad CosteaLeast Authority has previously audited the Zcash code, and Zcash is built on top of the Bitcoin code. Yeah. And I was wondering if this indirectly was an audit of the whole Bitcoin codebase.

1:11:02Liz SteiningerOh, that's an interesting question, and I don't have a good answer for that. I mean, I would, it wouldn't be much for somebody to look at the Zcash report and to then see, do any of the issues found translate to the Bitcoin codebase? It's a good question. I don't have the answer right now, but I will definitely pose that to the team afterwards.

1:11:25Vlad CosteaBecause basically Zcash is the Zerocash protocol applied to the Bitcoin design. Yeah. But I guess that the audit was mostly for the ZK side of things.

1:11:41Liz SteiningerSo long ago. That was 2018. I haven't read that report in years. But yeah, that would be really interesting to look back. I can report back to you later. Like look back at the report. We might, we might already, somebody already might know the answer on the team. But off the top of my head, I don't know right now. I'm sorry.

1:12:04Vlad CosteaOkay. Is there anything that Least Authority is doing that's really interesting and you feel like I haven't asked you about it?

1:12:13Liz SteiningerOh, I mean, you covered a lot of what we're doing with like the way we talked about like PrivateStorage and Winden and Zcaps and everything, and even the moon math manual you got. So you're very thorough on our website. I mean, I think, I think one thing we didn't talk much about that I would like to see more in the industry is kind of the next, the next level with the security, like with the approach to audits and how we are handling security within the industry.

1:12:43And like for us, like one important thing along the lines of open source is this idea of publishing reports. About half of our work ends up getting published, not all of it. And we still encourage like our clients to publish reports. Of course, there's sometimes good reasons why the reports don't get published. But I would love to see more public across the industry, more audit reports getting published. And I would, it would be really great to see what as an industry we can do with all that data too, and how we can make that data more accessible for users.

1:13:15So like we audit all these tools, but if you're a regular user and you're just like, yeah, can you read, like there's different levels of problems going from like a PDF audit report to, you know, the end user who's trying to make an educated decision about like which crypto products they're interacting with. And there's no reason why we can't connect those two, you know. So all this data about security vulnerabilities and how they've been fixed, like so there's a vulnerability side and then there's the fixed side.

1:13:46And like how those could be, you know, analyzed, like collected and analyzed for the, you know, kind of learning of the industry. And then also how could those like these kind of, okay, this protocol, this, you know, smart contract, this wallet, you know, they've not only got audited, but they did all these fixes. And then how do you like kind of communicate that to the consumer in a more effective way? That's where I'd really love to see more progress in the industry. And it's, yeah, it's been kind of stalled, like we don't see too much.

1:14:20I think you mentioned earlier, like getting scored, like a security score. I think that's the closest, like in that direction that we've gone, but the security score is just not enough.

1:14:32Vlad CosteaWait, so the way in which this works is that you get contracted privately and you submit the report also privately and it's up to the contractor to publish it?

1:14:44Liz SteiningerYeah, I mean, we get hired to do an audit for a team and then it's up to the team whether or not the results of our work get published. Yeah.

1:14:54Vlad CosteaIt's a bit disappointing given that this is all open source, but I can understand why, because they might be concerned that some people exploit some issue before the team gets to fix it first?

1:15:09Liz SteiningerWell, we don't publish reports until the team has an opportunity to fix stuff. So we don't publish initial audit reports. Occasionally a team will, and that's not a good idea. That's the final audit report after things have been addressed. So one valid reason for not publishing a report is that you don't intend to fix the things that we found. And so then, yeah, you wouldn't want to publish that report, because then we're just telling the world some vulnerabilities. But that's problematic for another reason, which is that you should be fixing the vulnerabilities that have been reported to you.

1:15:40But sometimes there is a legitimate reason to not do it if you're going to replace the system, if you're going to completely recode it. Because, you know, we found some significant vulnerabilities, and then the team says, okay, we need to totally redo this. So then that makes sense as to why the audit report wouldn't get published. But otherwise, yeah, I mean, it would be good to have more of them published.

1:16:04Vlad CosteaSo what happens if, let's say, that you're in the middle of an audit and someone else finds an exploit that you are about to report? Like, is there going to be suspicion that the team auditing has exploited the bug?

1:16:21Liz SteiningerNo, we communicate pretty quickly to the client team if we're starting to find something. So hopefully we would be able to, I mean, yeah, basically talk about it before. And then it also depends on if the system is live or not. Like, if the codebase we're looking at is live in production or if it's, you know, pre-launch. So if it's pre-launch, then there's less of a risk for that kind of thing, obviously. But if it's already live, then yeah. But as soon as we find stuff during a review, we're chatting about it usually with the team.

1:16:54And then we, you know, format that into a full issue that goes into the report.

1:17:02Vlad CosteaIt says on your website that you have 295 plus completed security audits. That's why we said 300.

1:17:08Liz SteiningerYeah, we're close to 300, yeah.

1:17:11Vlad CosteaAnd 150 plus security audit clients, and half of your clients are returning customers, which I think is nice.

1:17:19Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah, it is nice to get to work with teams again. So there's some really great teams in the industry who are taking security seriously, and that's nice. But yeah, it'd be great to see more of the audit reports by the entire industry out there, like by all parties getting, all those getting published. And then, like I said, more analysis and sharing of that information with people.

1:17:43Vlad CosteaWhich auditing firms would you say are competing currently with Least Authority?

1:17:49Liz SteiningerIt depends on the project. It depends on the potential client that we're working with. So like there are some auditing firms that focus only on smart contracts, so they would compete with us on those, but not on like protocols. And there's other firms that are specializing in like cryptography or ZK or something. So, yeah, it just depends.

1:18:10Vlad CosteaI guess most of the competent developers in the space have built their own auditing firms. That pays off pretty well. I think Sergio Lerner, the person who is behind the study that's called Patoshi, and he is the first person to say that Satoshi Nakamoto might have mined 1 million Bitcoin. He also had something called Coinfirm that was auditing. I think it's Coinfirm. Let me double check.

1:18:46But it seems like it was acquired.

1:18:50Liz SteiningerYeah, a lot changes over the years. We do try to like keep, like we try to keep like some awareness of like the other teams that are doing similar work to us. And, you know, some relationships and stuff there, but it's definitely challenging over the years because firms kind of come and go.

1:19:11Vlad CosteaAnd it's pretty remarkable that you have been around for such a long time, honestly. This space is changing so much.

1:19:19Liz SteiningerYeah, yeah. Well, there's good years and bad years for everyone.

1:19:26Vlad CosteaIs there anything else that I didn't ask you about, but you really wanted me to for the purpose of this interview?

1:19:34Liz SteiningerOh, gosh, I can't think of it. But it's been great talking to you about all these topics. We could talk for five more hours, but not today, I guess.

1:19:45Vlad CosteaYeah, you told me you have a couple of hours for this. And for correctness purposes, I got to say that the name of Sergio Lerner's company is Coinspect, not Coinfirm. Coinfirm is a blockchain analysis firm, so it was a pretty bad mistake on my behalf. It's Coinspect. And it says that Coinspect was used by Zcash to audit the internal code base and its forks.

1:20:12Liz SteiningerYeah, well, Zcash has also been around for a long time now. I mean, our audit was in 2018 that we did, and then our more recent audits of things while we've been the ecosystem security lead has only been the last couple of years. So that's a long time. I mean, you probably talked about that with Zooko, I'm assuming, about how long they've been around, too.

1:20:34Vlad CosteaWell, yeah. I mean, Zerocash was published in 2013 by a bunch of researchers. And it took them three years to launch an altcoin, basically, because they were hoping that they were going to add this to Bitcoin.

1:20:50Liz SteiningerYeah. Do you think we ever will?

1:20:53Vlad CosteaI sure hope so. That's why I'm still going.

1:20:56Liz SteiningerThat's why you're still going?

1:20:58Vlad CosteaI think this technology has matured a lot. And it's much closer to the initial expectations. And it sort of exceeds the initial expectations. And if we actually don't use it, I guess that's how the entire world loses, you know, because you have such good research in this field, and then it's not being used for the purpose of improving the industry. And you just have small islands of projects that choose to use a certain type of technology, which is exciting, but not the end goal.

1:21:33Liz SteiningerYeah. Yeah, it's just, you know, in some ways, it feels like we've been doing this for a long time, because we have been, but in other ways, it feels like we're still just so early in all of this, that, you know, it's a long game, that, you know, technology, like, advancement and adoption just takes time. I try to stay grounded by thinking back to, like, the early days of the internet. And what was it, Gopher? And then, like, how that, you know, changed over the years to what it is now, where, like, the idea of being unconnected from the internet is, like, so crazy.

1:22:08It's like being without running water.

1:22:12Vlad CosteaI know, I spent, like, three days without a phone, because I had issues with the screen and I serviced it. And it felt like I was actually handicapped. I couldn't use maps. I couldn't access my calendar on the go. I couldn't check my messages. I had to basically be home and check my computer. It's great. I mean, I remember reading paper maps, and now, like, I still,

1:22:37Liz SteiningerI mean, I learned how to do that. And I still can't imagine being without a maps program on my phone. And, yeah, we've come so far. But it's taken a while, too, you know, to go from those early days. And when, you know, people were saying, like, about, like, e-commerce, like, people didn't believe e-commerce was going to be a thing. And so, yeah, and here we are now. And e-commerce is definitely a thing. I mean, we don't even call it e-commerce anymore. It's such a thing to buy things online that we don't even really, like, differentiate anymore what it is.

1:23:08And, yeah, I think that when it comes to, like, the cool crypto space and this idea of, like, digital money and privacy and stuff, I mean, privacy is a slightly different conversation. But when it comes to the idea of, like, yeah, like, the transfer of value digitally, we are just at the beginning, it seems. And, yeah, privacy, to me, is a necessity. So I think with time we will all discover that if we really want to see mass adoption on this tech, then privacy has to be front and center.

1:23:42Vlad CosteaJust for the record, what was your first computer?

1:23:46Liz SteiningerWell, the computer I was around or I recall using.

1:23:50Vlad CosteaI don't know. The first computer you had in your home.

1:23:54Liz SteiningerOh, it was one of those, like, I only, I didn't, I don't remember using it, but I sold, like, 20 of them on eBay when I was older. But we had these, like, magnetic tape drive computers. I don't know what those are called. I forget what they're called. But then we definitely had a Commodore 64 and, like, Atari's. Atari is the first one I remember, though. And then, like, a PC and the first laptops, I got to use one of those. I remember playing chess on, like, chess and solitaire were all you could really play game-wise on the early laptops.

1:24:28Vlad CosteaWhat was your first laptop then? Do you know the exact brand and model? Or what kind of software it was running? I'm actually curious.

1:24:39Liz SteiningerOh, I'd have to look it up. It's been, like, it's been, like, 10 years at least since I even thought about the name of it. But, yeah, I forget the name of those laptops, but I remember using them when I was, like, it was, it had to have been in, like, 92. So I don't know what, like, but they were heavy and thick and they were expensive enough that I didn't get my own. You know, it was before people started getting their own laptops. I think that was closer to, like, what, like 98 or something when people started getting their own laptops.

1:25:10Or there probably wasn't even much laptops. It was probably still mostly desktops. So, was it, like, the X85 or something like that? I don't know. I'll look it up.

1:25:23Vlad CosteaX85 laptop. Let's see.

1:25:26Liz SteiningerIf we can Google while we're on the show, I can quickly Google it. Search for it. Laptop.

1:25:34Vlad CosteaNo, I find some sort of keyboard.

1:25:39Liz SteiningerSo I'm totally off on that. But there are, like, I see ThinkPads going back. But I don't think, I don't know if it was a laptop, if it was a Thinkpad.

1:25:50Vlad CosteaSo maybe it was made by IBM or something. One company that was building computers in the 90s and I don't see it around anymore is Compaq. Yeah. It was pretty huge.

1:26:04Liz SteiningerYeah, that name sounds familiar, too.

1:26:06Vlad CosteaAnd Fujitsu Siemens. That was also pretty big. Yeah, but I would have to, yeah, I would have to double check what that was. Anyway, the reason why I asked you this is that usually I have, like, a special phrase or a couple of words that I ask people to write in the comments to prove that they listened until the end of the episode. So I asked you about your first computer or something, hoping that I'm going to get a brand and a model, but you can see whatever.

1:26:38Liz SteiningerI just don't remember. I'm sorry. I remember using AOL.

1:26:44Vlad CosteaAOL. That's a pretty good message to write in the comments.

1:26:49Liz SteiningerYeah, I think AOL was that before your time. It seems I'm older. I don't know if you were using AOL or if it was, like, out of fashion by the time you were at a computer.

1:26:59Vlad CosteaI started out with IRC, I think. Yeah. And then Yahoo Messenger. It was pretty big in my country. Yeah. And my American friends were using MSN.

1:27:13Liz SteiningerYeah, I think that's a little bit late. AOL. I remember that. Oh, and yeah. Early memories of using computers were also that little turtle that you, like, gave it directions, but I also don't remember what that program was called. The little turtle that you told it to, like, go search. It was, like, early programming or, like, I don't know, games. Anyway.

1:27:37Vlad CosteaI actually think that's on a Raspberry Pi OS and you have something like that. It's called Scratch or whatever.

1:27:44Liz SteiningerOh, Scratch, though. Scratch is different. Scratch is, like, an app for, like, it teaches you the basics of programming without writing code.

1:27:53Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly.

1:27:55Liz SteiningerYeah. No, this was, like, you coded to tell a turtle where to go. But it wasn't, like, yeah, anyway. Again, I was young. I just remember using it. I don't remember the names of this stuff. But I remember using AOL, so there you can use AOL.

1:28:12Vlad CosteaYeah, type AOL in the comments. And if there's any one product that you should try after listening to this and you don't have to pay anything for it, it's Winden. Check it out.

1:28:23Liz SteiningerThat's your favorite?

1:28:25Vlad CosteaIt's my favorite because I've been searching for something like this for a long time.

1:28:31Liz SteiningerNice. Well, if you have any, like, feedback for us at any time about it or tips or anything or any ideas for what to do with it in the future, let us know.

1:28:41Vlad CosteaI can also write pull requests on GitHub, right?

1:28:44Liz SteiningerYeah. Yeah. Yeah, it's all open source, so you can contribute to.

1:28:52Vlad CosteaThank you very much, Liz.

1:28:53Liz SteiningerYeah, thanks for having me. It's been fun to chat, and I feel like I've learned a lot of new stuff over the last couple of hours.

1:29:01Vlad CosteaAwesome. And best of luck with the auditing. It's going to be a big business in the era of vibe coding, I'm telling you.

1:29:08Liz SteiningerGood to know. Well, yeah, if you have any, if you want to give us advice on how you think that that should be marketed, let us know.

1:29:17Vlad CosteaOK, thank you very much, and I'll see you in the next one.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00