Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S16 E36 / Transcript
Transcript · S16 E36 · 1:57:33 · 2 Aug 2025

S16 E36: Maud Bannwart & Cheng Wang on Alephium, Proof of Less Work & Bitcoin

With Maud Bannwart, Cheng Wang. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:46Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 36. We are live with Cheng Wang and Maud Bannwart, if I pronounced that correctly. And this episode is sponsored by Citrea, LayerTwo Labs, SideShift, Edge Wallet, Bitcoin.com News, Noones.com, and I think that's it. It's really good to have you guys because I met you last year in Frankfurt if I'm not mistaken, and I was intrigued by this concept of proof of less work and the way in which this basically consumes less energy while still remaining proof of work.

1:21And as far as I know, Alephium, which is your project, is like a mix between proof of work and proof of stake. No, no, sorry. I misworded that. It's like a combination of Bitcoin and Ethereum. It takes Taproot and you also have UTXOs, which Ethereum doesn't, but tries to fulfill the functions of Ethereum with Bitcoin technology. And I think it's very interesting and it's proof of work. And that's why I decided to get you on to learn more.

1:54Maud BannwartAwesome. Thank you. Thank you for having us.

1:58Vlad CosteaOkay. So where do we start? Like, how did you come up with the idea for this project? Also for everyone out there, none of this is financial advice. We're not telling you to buy anything unless you really want to buy it and you are sold on the concept. So why would you build this as opposed to working with, let's say, Ethereum Classic, which is also proof of work?

2:23Cheng WangMaybe I can start it. Yeah. So it all started with a very technical problem. It's called the scalability of blockchain. I think back in 2016, the Ethereum Foundation, they started to invest heavily into this scaling solution for Ethereum. They wanted to go sharding, which was considered to be the most permanent way to scale a blockchain. Basically, you can have multiple blockchains running in parallel instead of just having one blockchain. They invested a lot of resources and research into the problem and did not find a good solution.

3:04I was quite intrigued by the problem as well. My background was computer science and consensus research, and I'm very obsessed with challenges. So I started to look into this problem and then I managed to find a very good design to target this problem. It's way simpler and much easier to put this into implementation. Then I started to work on this with a team of engineers. And then we got the prototype and then we started to get more people to work on the projects. So that was the beginning.

3:50And then we have a very long evolution of the projects. We started with just doing scaling and then we got DeFi, basically, like, bring DeFi to the UTXO of Bitcoin. And we have proof of less work to mitigate the energy consumption issue. We have a new virtual machine, new programming languages. So all in all, it's full of new innovations. So that was the key of the project.

4:29Vlad CosteaRight, so you're saying that this started from the Ethereum initiative to find better scaling solutions, which means you probably started from the technology of Ethereum, which is EVM. No, you didn't.

4:43Maud BannwartAnd Alephium was always, I mean, maybe here I'm wrong, but meaning I think it was always Cheng's approach to scale proof of work in UTXO. The sharding is much nicer to the sharding actually on proof of work in UTXO. But maybe that part of the history, I don't know, maybe you did start looking first at the account model Cheng.

5:10Cheng WangYes, so actually I first heard about Bitcoin. And then in 2015, I got an email from the Ethereum Foundation. They read my research paper. They invited me to talk about my research. So I kind of delved into Ethereum a bit earlier than Bitcoin, even though I know Bitcoin a bit earlier. So I understand the account model and the EVM a bit back then. So I know kind of the weakness or the drawback of these models pretty well. And then when I was researching the scalability issue, I kind of started to look more into the Bitcoin approach.

5:58And then I somehow, like someday I got the idea that maybe the UTXO model could be a good way to solve the scalability issue. And then I started to look in that direction and then I managed to find a way to leverage that. So that was the kind of the full story. Somehow I know Bitcoin first time, but I delved into Ethereum like earlier than Bitcoin. And then I managed to leverage Bitcoin a bit more. So it's kind of both are quite important.

6:31Vlad CosteaYeah, but you're going to find Ethereum people defending the account model saying that it is so much better. You don't have to spend any transaction fees managing your UTXOs. It's just there. You receive it to your address and it's much like a bank account, maybe. And still, when you built Alephium, you decided to go for UTXOs. And what is the advantage or how would you describe the reason why you decided to go for UTXOs as opposed to accounts?

7:05Cheng WangYeah, so account model is definitely much more flexible and also has some other advantages like in some cases the fees is a bit cheaper because you don't need to manage the UTXOs manually, right? But UTXO has its own advantage as well. Like the biggest one is the immutability. So you have the UTXO, you cannot really change it, right? So it's very secure. And also in computer science, immutability is a very important property for scaling. You won't have race conditions if you have multiple processes to try to use the same UTXO because it's immutable, you can use it, you know that it's going to stay the same.

7:59So that was the key for scaling. So you see that both have pros and cons, right? So the tricky part is how to leverage both to solve the issues and at the same time try to retain all of the flexibility of the account model. So we managed to find a way to do that.

8:26So basically for applications, you have two states. One state is the assets. It's basically the state for the cryptocurrency, like the balance of users, right? And the second type of state is the application state. For example, it's the price of the trading pair. Both are actually quite different. So the approach we found is that we use the UTXO model for the assets. So it's like Bitcoin. We use Bitcoin for all of the coins, all of the tokens. And then we have states for applications. For that, we use the account model.

9:10It's kind of a way, we kind of combine the both approaches. And in the end, we get the advantage of both. For the assets, we get the security of UTXO, get the scalability of UTXO model. And for the dApp stuff, we still have mutable states. So we can build all kinds of applications on top of it. So, yeah, that's it.

9:39Vlad CosteaWould you say that having multiple UTXOs per wallet is also good for privacy?

9:48Cheng WangYeah, privacy. So there are a lot of big advantages of UTXO model. I was mainly talking about scalability. So definitely there are some good things about privacy as well. Especially you can use UTXO to build a mix network. And with account model, you can also build different types of privacy stuff. They come with different trade-offs. But in general, I feel like UTXO model is much more simple for the security side. For privacy, definitely you can do a lot of things. However, if you want to do more advanced stuff, sometimes you probably need to also need a little bit more mutable states like the account model.

10:45But for UTXO, you can still do very unique and quite advanced privacy stuff.

10:55Vlad CosteaYeah, so you mentioned scalability a few times. And what I learned from the Blockstream side of the story is that blockchains don't scale. So what are you guys doing or how do you make it scale?

11:09Cheng WangYeah, so of course, if you compare to the Web 2, the traditional distributed system, of course there is an overhead that if you try to scale the blockchain, because anyway, you are going to run many full nodes in the network. And full nodes, they have to communicate with each other. So definitely this is much more expensive than if you run the service on one or two servers. But still, even if you assume that you run on a very large scale network, you can still do a lot of optimizations.

11:52For example, if you reduce the block time of Bitcoin to five minutes per block, then you basically scale the throughput by two times. And the security won't be impacted. The overhead is that all of the full nodes on the network, they are going to basically handle twice the amount of the transactions if all of the blocks are full. So it's like a lot of trade-offs. You basically trade-off a little bit of the computation or networking for quite a bit more transactions.

12:31Of course, for Bitcoin, you can reduce the block time a lot. You can even increase the block size a little bit. But there's a limit, right? And then when you cross a set of the limits, you have to leverage some of the more advanced stuff like sharding. Then you have multiple blockchains. You can also try to optimize the network layer, optimize execution stuff. There could be a lot of things that could be done. Basically, what we do is we propose a new algorithm so that we can run the execution in parallel.

13:16So if your full nodes have multiple processes, you can do a lot of executions in parallel. And for Bitcoin, for example, or for Ethereum right now, you cannot do this. That was kind of why you can still scale it, even though we know that the blockchain cannot really scale that much. And also, it depends on the assumption.

13:44For Bitcoin, it tries to be very lightweight, very efficient, right? So it assumes that the full nodes can run on very cheap computers, right? But for Ethereum, for Solana, for example, they are very different. Actually, full nodes have to run on much more powerful servers, right? So it's really about what type of machines you want to target. So if you target very powerful servers, you can go much higher throughput, much higher performance. So it's really about what the network is going to target. And then you can do a lot of optimizations based on this kind of performance target.

14:33Vlad CosteaRight, but running multiple blockchain shards in parallel requires some sort of coordination between them. And my question is, you know, on the surface, you can argue that having multiple shards is decentralizing, but having to coordinate them is also centralizing. So how do you keep this decentralized? Because it's a very delicate balancing problem, I think.

14:59Cheng WangYeah, I think you're quite correct, quite to the point. So definitely has trade-offs. Pretty much like in Web2. Web2, you have a lot of sharding stuff, right? For example, you have a web service that's, for example, for the Google Meet or for Twitter services. When you have too many users, you have to scale it and then you have to kind of divide the users into different groups. And then for each group, you host them in a dedicated server, right? So this is sharding. And this has a cost.

15:33The cost is that it's not as efficient as you have a single server where you can just do all the queries in the single server. And with multiple servers, you have to do the dispatching stuff for the users, for the service. So it's pretty much like this in blockchain. If you have multiple shards, then you're going to have some service to do the coordination, to dispatch the transactions, to synchronize all of the states of the different shards and make sure that there's no double spending.

16:11So this was actually one of the core parts of our BlockFlow algorithm. So we found a way to kind of resolve the conflicts in the blockchain and found a way to select the right forks for different blockchains. And then we leverage proof-of-work to ensure that the whole network keeps advancing, keeps producing blocks without breaking the consensus. And the guarantee of safety is pretty much like Bitcoin. Basically, you calculate the accumulated work from different blockchains, you aggregate them, and then you compare which DAG has the most amount of work.

17:02So the only difference from Bitcoin is, in Bitcoin you only compare the accumulated work of the chain, but in our case, we have a DAG chain. So you have to compare the sum of the work from the DAG. So that was it.

17:24Vlad CosteaJust for those who might not know, what's a DAG? D-A-G, right?

17:28Cheng WangYeah, so DAG is a directed acyclic graph. So blockchain is a chain of blocks, right? You have a block that follows one, follows another. In DAG, it's a graph, you have multiple chains and then all of the blocks have dependencies. It's like a network, more like a network instead of just a chain. That's why we call it BlockFlow, it's a flow, it's not a blockchain. This is a very common mathematical structure and it has very good properties. You don't have loops in the structure which prevents you from having some weird transaction relationship.

18:19It's quite common, actually in Bitcoin you have this as well. In Bitcoin mempool, you have a DAG data structure to maintain the relationship of all of the transactions based on the input and output. So one transaction could use the input from multiple different transactions, right? And then from this you get the dependencies between transactions and then you can build a graph based on that. And this graph has great properties like DAG, you don't have loops in it. And with that you can apply very efficient graph optimizations so you can have a very efficient mempool.

19:04As we all know, when the network is very congested, mempool has to be very efficient, otherwise the network can be, the transactions are very hard to manage. So that overhead has to be managed well and DAG was really a great data structure for that. So it's the same for blockchain, we have that as well. If you have to improve the throughput of the blockchain a lot, you have multiple blockchains. You have many, many very fast blocks and you have to use this efficient data structure to handle that.

19:36Vlad CosteaRight, so the way in which Alephium scales is with parallel blockchains, which are basically sharded. But my follow-up question is, what happens if one of these shards falls behind in terms of synchronization, or maybe that they get shut down or they get attacked or something like this? Does the chain still function, or what is the number of shards that need to get down for the chain to basically shut down?

20:05Cheng WangSo for all of the blockchains, you have the assumption that 51% of the nodes are honest. So if you have this assumption, there will always be hash rate that is mining on all of the blockchains, then you are guaranteed that you have enough hash rates to make progress. And for proof of work, actually, it favors liveness over safety. So it means that block production is usually guaranteed. You always have the hash rate to find the new blocks. The more tricky part is the safety.

20:42So no double spending is a more tricky question for proof of work. That was another issue. If you have honest hash rate mining on the blockchain, the tricky part is the double spending. And that was guaranteed by the algorithm.

21:01Vlad CosteaYeah, it's also, so you made a very interesting statement there about basically reducing the block time of Bitcoin. And to a lot of Bitcoiners, this is so blasphemous, they're so, how should I put it, religious about the 10 minute block time that they think that anything less than this is centralizing, even though I think Litecoin proves that even with 20% of that, which means 2.5 minute blocks, you still have pretty good decentralization. But my follow up question is, because I know that Alephium generates new blocks very fast, isn't this centralizing in the sense that there are parts of the world where people cannot validate because they don't have fast enough internet to participate in the consensus?

21:48Cheng WangSo yeah, this is definitely has a lot of trade-offs. So I personally, for Bitcoin, I think Bitcoin, the purpose of Bitcoin is digital, to me, is digital gold. It's not really for, to me, it's not really for retail users to use it. So I personally think that one megabyte and also 10 minute block time is great for Bitcoin. And even if they reduce it by, for example, by half or increase the block size by twice, I personally don't think it changes much. So to me, it's never going to be an application chain.

22:29So I personally feel like it's pretty good that Bitcoin stays as one megabyte block and stays at 10 minutes block time. And Bitcoin is so unique, nothing else is the same as Bitcoin. But for blockchain like Alephium, we are so different from Bitcoin in terms of application, in terms of product-market fit. We have to focus more on the utility, on the application side. So we have to support smart contracts, we have to support the apps. So for that user experience is much more important. So we have to balance a bit the design to make the users feel happy and to feel more user friendly.

23:20So they would like to use us. So we have to make some trade-offs here. So definitely, short block time is more important.

23:31However, because it's sharding, so actually throughput can be higher with heavy optimizations. So you can do a lot of parallelization with this new tech. But of course, it's much more expensive than running Bitcoin full nodes. But it's still much more efficient than Aptos or Solana or Ethereum right now, because of our algorithms and also we did a lot of optimization at the virtual machine level. And our virtual machine so far is much faster than EVM and also SVM.

24:10Vlad CosteaI was going to ask you about this, because you mentioned that Ethereum and Solana require more powerful computers to run a full node. What kind of computer is good enough for Alephium? Can you actually walk into a computer store and buy a laptop or something and it's just going to work with the chain or should you go for industrial grade computers?

24:33Cheng WangSo far it's quite good. You can run it with Raspberry Pi.

24:40So right now the main issue is the storage growth is very, very fast right now if you compare with Bitcoin, every day the storage increases by, I think, by two gigabytes on average right now. So it's a storage that is growing very fast, CPU wise it's quite okay right now. So if you have Raspberry Pi with enough storage, it should be pretty sufficient to run a full node to validate all of the transactions.

25:14Vlad CosteaBut is the blockchain prunable in the sense that you can only store a small amount of data? Or is that not recommended for your sharded setup?

25:26Cheng WangSo we on this part, we are pretty much like Ethereum. We can do some pruning, but we cannot really compress it to like 10 blocks etc. Of course, we can do a bit more further optimizations, but it's not really the priority right now because we have so many, we still have a long, very long to-do list. For pruning we can, like right now disk is quite cheap, right? So I personally feel like it's much more, it's probably better that we focus on other issues right now than just to try to prune the full node as much as possible.

26:14Because those other features may attract more users to that. And if we try to spend more effort on pruning the blockchain a bit more, I feel like it's going to delay the other tasks we are working on right now. That's kind of the roadmap we have.

26:40Vlad CosteaI want to get into Taproot, but before that let me plug a couple of ads. The first one is for Bitcoin.com News, which is actually one of the places where I read about Alephium last year, when I think it was Kaspa and Alephium that were the most profitable coins to mine. And this was before you guys got ASICs.

27:05Maud BannwartASICs arrived on the network in April 2024. Started with home miners, with Goldshell. Then we had a very busy day in July where Bitmain then announced kind of the more industrial ASICs. And on the same day, just an hour later, then we had also IceRiver, who announced their ASICs as well. So it's been around a year that the big ASICs are on Alephium and a little bit over a year since from the start.

27:41Vlad CosteaI think there was a news story at one point about someone who went to a hotel room with a bunch of miners and made like $5,000 or something or more. Anyway, it's a lot of fun when you discover that proof of work still has innovation. And one of my sponsors is Bitcoin.com News. So check them out. Sometimes you're going to stumble upon something that you're not going to find on Bitcoin Magazine or other websites. And right now they're orange, which means that they know the difference between Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin, because many years ago, many moons ago, Bitcoin.com was the place that was saying don't buy BTC because BCH is faster.

28:21Now, it seems like the market has taught them the difference.

28:28And also another sponsor that I want to plug right now is Edge Wallet, which is really cool because you have basically a built in exchange that you can use without any kind of KYC. If someone, for example, wants to send you some, let's say, Dash, which actually happened to me, someone came up to me in person and said, hey, Vlad, do you have a Dash wallet? I set that up in like 10 seconds in Edge Wallet, and then I was able to swap it very fast into BTC without even thinking about what's happening in the background.

28:59And that's very cool. It doesn't have KYC and also has a duress mode. So if you're ever asked by someone to unlock your wallet, let's say at an airport or someone wants to kidnap you because you're in France, you basically type that secondary pin and that's going to show a wallet where you either have zero funds if you don't deposit anything, or you can just put like five dollars and be like, oh, I only have this. It's pretty cool and it's free to download. So go to edge.app and you're going to find Edge Wallet for you to download.

29:33And now let's talk about Taproot, which seems to be a very interesting choice, right, for smart contracting and scripting. Like of all the Ethereum stuff you could find, you decided to settle with Taproot. And why is that?

29:51Cheng WangSo Taproot, I did not really dive too much into it. I know the high-level concepts. I used to dive deep into it, but then I somehow now not really familiar with the details anymore. It's pretty much like the Lightning Network. I spent a lot of time on it, understand details, and after one or a few months I clearly forgot about the underlying details. But Taproot for me is basically an advanced way to spend transactions or spend UTXOs. You can construct a tree of conditions for each UTXO and then you can have more flexible ways to spend the transactions, spend the UTXOs.

30:42And with this you can first have more scalability, you can also have more privacy, it has a lot of advantages with that. So for example you can also have a more efficient multisig with that. So that was my understanding of it.

31:01Vlad CosteaOkay, so what is it being used for right now in Alephium?

31:07Cheng WangSo in Alephium we don't really have Taproot because we have kind of, we use the account model for the dapp stuff, so we can use smart contracts for very advanced stuff like multisig. Of course you can do something similar to Taproot as well, but you don't really need to have these tree structures, you can actually implement them with smart contracts. So it's a bit like Bitcoin's pay to script hash, you can have scripts, you hash it, the Taproot you can see is a specific type of script.

31:53And in our case because we have our own virtual machine which is more powerful than the Bitcoin virtual machine. Bitcoin actually has a virtual machine as well, but it is very minimal with very simple instructions so you do very limited stuff. But in our case our virtual machine and the script system is much more advanced, you can do pretty much everything, you can simulate Taproot in our virtual machine. So you can have it if you want to do it, but because we have the support of account model for the states, you don't really need to have those kind of hacky solutions like Bitcoin.

32:34So Taproot is a hack solution for Bitcoin specifically, in general, for Ethereum, for Solana or for Alephium, we don't really need to hack that, we can have native support as long as you can write the smart contracts. So that in our case is a bit different.

32:56Vlad CosteaRight, let me ask you about the mining part which I think is very interesting because the whole industry, 90% of it right now is proof of stake. For a while it was sort of a political concern that these projects might get labeled as unregistered securities or something, now it seems like the political climate is more favorable, so a lot of projects decided to stay or launch in a proof of stake kind of setup. But you guys decided that you want to be proof of work and you want to use the BLAKE3 algorithm, which if I'm not mistaken is not unique to Alephium.

33:35And what else? You have a network of miners and you also mentioned you have two ASIC manufacturers. How does this work and what are the advantages to being proof of work?

33:51Cheng WangI'm not sure if you, Maud, want to start or you want me to start.

33:53Maud BannwartYeah. I mean, I can speak. I think Cheng has already mentioned that the benefit of proof of work, it's also the most robust consensus algorithm today to ensure decentralization, also lightweight node and many other reasons why proof of work was the right choice for Alephium from the get-go. Alephium started as a GPU mineable coin, so in the beginning at the start of the network actually for the first two and a half years it was mined with GPU. We didn't really have an FPGA period. There was some FPGA but other networks usually will go through like a GPU period, then you have the FPGA era and for the chain that are ASIC friendly you eventually end up in the ASIC zone.

34:44So for us it happened a lot faster than what we expected, we were really surprised. I think right now there are four manufacturers who offer ASICs with three being the most known and there's really a range of ASICs from again like what they call home miners. So this is ASICs that you could have at home because they will work if you plug them in a normal plug. From a sound and noise perspective it is somewhat okay and then you have the really, I call them industrial ASICs in my head, this is how I categorize them because they are the ones you can't plug at home.

35:18You need the industrial kind of electric plug, you also cannot hear yourself if this is turned on, so you need to have like special infrastructure to basically plug them in. So that's a little bit on the history of ASICs and how it's been for Alephium since the launch. Also, you haven't asked, but a lot of people have a question around why did you choose to be ASIC friendly because to some extent it's a choice, there are some proof of work chain that decide that they don't want to be ASIC friendly.

36:02I think there's two points and Cheng you can add to this because at the end this was also your choice but I think it was two things. First you can never really be ASIC proof, you're ASIC resistant but never proof so to maintain that ASIC resistance this is something that is costly and this is something you have to maintain through time. But more importantly ASICs remain the fastest way and the best way to increase the hash rate and secure the network. You also have a component of loyalty to some extent because ASICs are made for a specific algorithm so you mentioned that we use BLAKE3.

36:48We are one of the very few chain to use BLAKE3, I think there was another one but they might have changed. I feel like there was a chain called Iron Fish that was using BLAKE3 but I could be remembering it wrong. I feel there was a second chain, I don't know if they still use it today but in any case because we were one of the few chain to use BLAKE3 and there was no ASIC miner for BLAKE3 the manufacturer had to develop a custom miner custom chip to mine specifically BLAKE3 which means that the Alephium ASICs cannot be used to mine anything other than Alephium and so you have a little bit you have less risk of a miner hopping off your chain than for example you have with GPU as well.

37:37Cheng WangYeah, I want to add a bit, like, why proof of work is great for Alephium. Like right now, I think, if we see this from the user perspective, they don't really care about if it's run by proof of work or proof of stake, right? For users, they mostly care about the user experience of the apps. But if we look from some very technical perspective, actually proof of work is very great for us, because it's much easier to scale with proof of work. Like, our sharding algorithm is much, much simpler than the one we originally wanted to do, because we use proof of work. We don't need to manage the validators on the blockchain, so you don't need to distribute the validators to different blockchains, right? And this is way, way more simple to deal with for sharding, because proof of work is more stateless.

38:43And another thing is performance, because for proof of work we don't need to synchronize all of the validators, so the complexity of the network and the computation is less. You don't need to broadcast all the signatures from the validators to the whole network, yeah, and you don't need to aggregate them. And this actually means that the theoretical throughput upper bound, or the TPS or latency upper bound, could be higher for proof-of-work blockchains, if it's done well. So yeah, so here we don't talk about politics stuff, we don't talk about environmental stuff, we only see this from a very technical standpoint: we can still have some particular, specific advantages. And if we push that to the extreme, I believe proof-of-work blockchains could compete with, or even go beyond, the current performance of those very high-performance proof-of-stake blockchains.

39:48Vlad CosteaRight, but I swear I heard some people from the Ethereum camp a few years ago arguing that you can't do DeFi without proof of stake, that proof of work would be too resource intensive and there would be orphaned blocks and hard-to-reach consensus with fast block times. And yet, what's your block time with Alephium and your proof of work?

40:11Cheng WangSo right now we have 8-second block time. To reduce it further, you definitely are going to need to have new techniques. You can have layer 2 solutions for that, you can have sequencer solutions for that. You basically use the proof of work for settlement, and then for the shorter block times you need other techniques. But I don't think that it's really the main bottleneck for DeFi because you use proof of work. You definitely can find ways to go for that. I feel like ultimately for DeFi, what you would like to have is short block time.

41:00You have high throughput, you can host a large amount of users. As long as you can do that, then it's okay. So what I was saying, like, you can actually achieve higher throughput with proof of work, because the overhead of the consensus is much lower. But of course you have the issues. It's a trade-off. You have the issues of higher uncle rates, higher orphan block rates. You have to deal with that, you have to find ways. But for proof of stake, you also have their own issues, different trade-offs.

41:37Like, the overhead is higher, the complexity of the consensus is much higher. Like, it took so many years to, you know, to have the proof-of-stake algorithm in production, and still they are not really happy with it. They're still doing a lot of improvements to that. So, different trade-offs.

42:01Vlad CosteaIt's also interesting how the market reacted to Ethereum going proof of stake. It seems like the value of the token has gone down, or at least the perceived value. When they were proof of work, maybe they had a greater network of GPU miners who were interested in transacting. Right now, all of that is gone. Interestingly, it hasn't gone to Ethereum Classic as expected. That chain hasn't really taken off. But yeah, like, do you believe that there's more value in proof of work?

42:36Cheng WangThat's a very interesting topic. I personally feel like it doesn't really... So, Ethereum Classic, I don't feel like it will change much whether Ethereum goes to proof of stake or Ethereum sticks to proof of work. It does not really change much, because basically the core team of the Ethereum Foundation won't work on Ethereum Classic. Then there will not be so many developers to focus on that, and then the chain cannot really grow. So in the end, for the chain to thrive, you have to have a very good community to grow it, right?

43:14Usually it is driven by the core foundation in the early days, and if you don't have that, you know, whether it's proof of work or it's proof of stake, it cannot grow. And then regarding Ether switching from proof of work to proof of stake, it's very hard to really reason about this, but I personally feel like we can speculate on it. To me, it's like proof of stake definitely has the issue of, like, rich people get richer. When you are a whale of the Ethereum network, you basically do staking, right? And then you just get a lot of high yields every year.

43:58You don't really need to work hard. But with proof of work it's quite different. You have the coin and then you have the inflation; you don't get the passive yields, but it means they have to invest actively, right, to increase the value of the tokens. So that has kind of the positive side if you stick with proof of work. And also, somehow, I'm not sure if it's a coincidence or if it's related to the consensus algorithm, somehow the price movement of Ethereum after proof of stake did not really go as well as Bitcoin, right?

44:38Yeah. Not sure how much is related, but there might be some relation in that.

44:48Vlad CosteaRight. Alephium is proof of work right now. You can get one of these ASICs. I'm not sure if it's profitable anymore to mine with your GPU. But at the same time, you guys did not have a purely fair launch. You still had some sort of pre-mine. And I want to ask you, why did you have that? Why was it necessary, and what happened to it?

45:09Cheng WangSo this actually is... Maud, do you want to answer first, or as you wish?

45:16Maud BannwartI mean, I think, you know, fair launch is a broad term, and what people put into fair launch is very different things depending on who you speak to. You know, Alephium, when Cheng worked on the project, we needed funds for the initial development of the project. So as part of the growth of the project, with the genesis block there were allocations that were minted for specific purposes. There was an allocation for sale, there was an allocation for the treasury, and there was an allocation for the ecosystem. Those allocations still exist and are being used to fund the development of the project. This is something that really allowed Alephium to build without the pressure of relying on third-party funding, because this is also very risky.

46:06It has happened to other proof-of-work networks, where they became, at the end, more centralized because they were taken over by the third party that was financing them. There was a smaller network where somebody came with a lot of machines, mined pretty much all the chain, and basically said, you have to run the project like this and we will fund you. And so at the end of the day they became dependent on a third party, and someone in the end took over the network through this. So there's trade-offs to both approaches here.

46:45It was about... We're not miners, so we don't mine. So for us it was about having the financial stability to kick-start the project, to build without being subject to third-party influence, because we could remain independent and continue to develop the project. And maybe, Cheng, you can give a little bit more background.

47:09Cheng WangYeah, I think it depends on the scale of the project. If you just fork the Bitcoin codebase, you know, change a few things and launch a new blockchain, definitely you can go fair launch. Of course, in this case there will usually be a lot of insiders who mine the coins in the very early days, and then try to push the project, or try to get it into marketing, or go to market when the mining is kind of stable. But if you build, you know, a brand new blockchain from scratch, like us, with sharding, we have to build everything from scratch.

47:54We have to build a new virtual machine, new programming languages, everything from scratch. It's a totally different story. So in that case, we definitely need more funding. And also, I don't feel like fair launch is really a big issue, because the price of our coin was kind of close to the initial pre-sale price for quite a long while, right? It was...

48:23Maud BannwartIt was, for a few months, actually.

48:26Cheng WangYeah, it was like the price was very, very low. Like, even for people who'd like to get the same price as the pre-sale investors, they could get it. So I personally don't feel like that was a big thing. And also, pretty much all of the new projects that are big enough, especially nowadays, the competition is much higher, right? You have to go to market much faster than before. It's not like back then, when you had several years to stay on the ground and that's okay. Nowadays you have to develop very fast.

49:05You have to have a team to push it very hard if you want to get successful. It's very different now than 10 years ago, eight years ago.

49:17Maud BannwartAnd I also think, at the end of the day, like everything, there's trade-offs to both approaches. I think what is really important is how transparent the team is about the approach that they are taking. This is something that... all of the information about Alephium tokenomics always included that part. All of the information was public from the get-go. It's something that some people don't like, but the reason they're able to not like it is because they know about it. And so I think, no matter which choice the project makes, as long as they are transparent and clear about it, then people can decide what they think is best for them. But I think there are drawbacks to each approach, and I think people shouldn't underestimate how disruptive it is for a project to move forward being dependent on third-party funding, because at the end of the day it means that third party will decide what you build, when you build it and how you build it.

50:18Vlad CosteaYeah, on the topic of transparency, I just remembered that, like, seven years ago there was a project called Bitcoin Private, which was a fork of Bitcoin that promised to also offer some privacy features. But there was a hidden 1 million BTCP inflation that was not revealed to early participants, and everyone thought that it had the same economics as Bitcoin, when in fact you had insiders who pre-mined their own tokens and were able to dump on everyone. So, you did mention transparency. I guess, are the wallets that were used for the pre-mine public? Like, can everyone see what's happening there?

51:00Maud BannwartThere was no pre-mine. It was with the genesis block, so it's in the genesis block: you had genesis allocations. So if you go look at the explorer, you can see the genesis block. There was no transaction of ALPH that did not happen on chain. So everything is on chain, everyone can see it. All of the genesis block and all of the genesis transactions are there. So all of those initial allocations were distributed with the genesis block.

51:29Cheng WangAnd there's also a no-pre-mine proof in the codebase. So basically, in the codebase, the genesis seed is based on the Bitcoin block hash and the Ethereum block hash, so we can prove that we actually had the latest hashes when we launched the network, so just one day before, or a few hours before. So there's a proof for that. You can prove that there was no pre-mining. It's just the genesis allocation, which is very transparent.

52:03Vlad CosteaRight. Let me plug two more ads, and then I'm gonna ask you about proof of less work, which I think is the highlight of this interview. It's the reason why I find Alephium super fascinating, and you can present some statistics about how that works. And I gotta tell you about LayerTwo Labs, which can actually integrate Alephium, if I'm not mistaken. They want to build these drivechains, which are two-way peg sidechains as described by the Blockstream paper from 2014, with some optimizations that were made by Paul Sztorc. And he's really not happy with the way Liquid turned out to be, which is just a federation, not a proper sidechain, and wants to build a sidechain for every altcoin that is interesting out there.

52:48And right now, if you go to layer2labs.com/download, you can find the software to run the Ethereum drivechain, the Zcash drivechain, a prediction market, and something that's called BitNames, that's used sort of like Namecoin for registering domains. And what this requires, basically, in order to come to Bitcoin is a soft fork that's called BIP 300. You can also read about that one, and you find all the information about the internal mechanisms of this on the website of layer2labs.com. And I guess they can also implement a sidechain for Alephium if there is demand for that.

53:30And the second sponsor I want to plug is Citrea, which recently, I think yesterday, was actually mentioned in a paper by the White House, which is quite impressive. It's a Bitcoin layer 2 that's coming out this year. It uses a ZK rollup which is optimistically verified on the Bitcoin blockchain, and what it does is to provide all the best features from Ethereum by leveraging the security of the Bitcoin chain. It's a novel approach to doing Bitcoin L2s. It's different from the federations and the sidechains. It's called a ZK rollup, and I like it.

54:10I think it's interesting you can find more information and run the testnet code at citrea.xyz, that's C-I-T-R-E-A dot X-Y-Z, and keep an eye out because they're gonna launch this year. And now Maud and Cheng let's talk about proof of less work. How does this work? Why do you call it proof of less work when it should be a competitive landscape and everyone should try to put as much work as possible to get the highest reward? And yeah, why is it like 80 something percent more efficient in terms of energy consumption than Bitcoin?

54:47Maud BannwartDo you want me to start, Cheng? And then I can do the high level version and then you can add the technical highlights. So the way proof of work, proof of less work works, sorry it's a mouthful. So up until a certain hashrate, Alephium is classic proof of work. So as of right now the Alephium network is running as classic proof of work. Once we hit a threshold, which is in our case one exahash, this is where we start progressively shift part of the cost of mining a new block from external, which is computing power, to internal, so burning coin.

55:29So this is not a combination with proof of stake. If you really wanted to describe it as a combination of anything, you could see it as proof of work up until a certain hashrate and then it's kind of proof of work plus proof of burn. The important part is that the cost of mining a new block continues to increase with the hashrate exactly as it does on proof of work, on classic proof of work. So you don't lower security because the costs remain the same, but you lower the network energy consumption because past a certain point, that cost is no longer paid exclusively in computing power.

56:11It's paid partially in computing power and partially by burning ALPH up front. And again, it's really important. It's not, you are burning the ALPH up front. It's not that you just reduce the mining reward. If that was what you were doing, you would be reducing the security. What is really key here is that up front, to be able to propose a block and be able to propose a block, in the input, you have to burn ALPH. So you will have the coinbase transaction and you'll also have an output of ALPH that will be burned.

56:50And this is how, and the amount that miners are requested to burn gradually increases with the hashrate up to a point of 87%. And so at very large scale, the network retain the security of classic proof of work, but will consume 87% less energy than if it was on classic proof of work. And 87%, this is the current parameter that is on chain, but this is also something that if it makes sense, eventually can be adjusted. But it would need a fork, a hard fork, of course, for that.

57:32Cheng, maybe if you want to dive, I don't know if there's anything you want to add.

57:37Cheng WangI think that's great. Maybe I tried to describe in a very intuitive way. For example, right now the Bitcoin spends 2% of the global electricity, right? Maybe close to that, I don't remember exact numbers. So it's around 2% of the global electricity, right? So let's say that the proof of work costs less, like only 1% of the electricity, I would say Bitcoin is still secure, right? So proof of less work is basically where you try to reduce that 2% of electricity to 1% for Bitcoin.

58:18But we can do a bit more in this case because we have the proof of burn mechanism.

58:24Maud BannwartAnd I think if I'm not mistaken, Cheng, right, this is also part of the design of proof of less work, was inspired by existing research that was done already in this space to optimize proof of work, right?

58:41Cheng WangYeah, actually it was inspired by a paper that was posted on the Bitcoin mailing list. I read that paper and I think that it's going to be a great fit for Alephium. For Bitcoin it's very hard to change, so I don't see any time that it will be applied for Bitcoin. But we think it's great and we integrate that from day one before Genesis.

59:10Maud BannwartAnd I think on the name it's called proof of less work because at similar hash rates it does less work than proof of work. I think this is what is the reason behind the name.

59:30Vlad CosteaYeah, but at the same time, no matter how much you lower the energy consumption, there's going to be someone who comes up and says, well, you're boiling the oceans and these ASICs are going to end up in a landfill and you're not environmentally friendly or whatever. So in the case of Bitcoin, I think, I mean, of course, there was the Greenpeace campaign, Change the Code and whatever. But I think the argument was always, or until recently, it was that at least it enables people to send money around the world with no trusted third party and it enables financial freedom and it stops surveillance capitalism.

1:00:08I mean, that was the narrative until a few years ago. Now, once BlackRock bought into the Bitcoin narrative, I think there's less FUD about Bitcoin being the reason why oceans are boiling. But you guys are much smaller and it's much more difficult to justify the fact that you're using electricity. So someone comes up, let's say some purple haired journalist comes up to you and says, you're boiling the oceans, you're destroying the planet. What is the value proposition that you're going to put forward to justify the fact that this exists?

1:00:43Maud BannwartI think just just to take a step back, I think this has changed drastically. If you look, I should actually have opened the presentation, like the perception of mining, especially in the in the sustainability space, has completely changed. Today, you see mining being praised as one of the most cost efficient way to finance sustainable transition, because it is literally something that you can plug on and off to support and finance sustainable infrastructure. So I honestly don't think that we would have when we started Alephium, that was a problem that we might have had.

1:01:23But this is honestly, I think today the perception has completely changed and actually mining is being leveraged. Significantly in the energy and sustainability industries to finance transition to more sustainable practices. And I think at the end of the day, all that stands for Bitcoin, everything uses electricity. And I can give you all of the argument to why actually even Bitcoin doesn't use as much electricity as people think. So I don't even need I should have opened my stats. I have actually a lot on this one. Again, it doesn't consume as much electricity as we think.

1:02:05I think Bitcoin consumes less energy and it's significantly less. I want to say half, at minimum a half. But I think the scale was even broader than this, than all of the always-on devices in the US. So, you know, all of the device, all of the electric device that are just in standby mode. In the US alone, they consume more electricity than just Bitcoin. So, again, I think the entire narrative around the energy consumption and proof of work has completely changed. And I think, again, it is there's a reason why there should be a cost to creating money like that was the right.

1:02:49The whole point of Bitcoin in the first place was that money shouldn't be created out of thin air. It should be there should be a cost to do that. And I think that is something that is applicable to Bitcoin. This is also something that is applicable to Alephium. It's like if you think about a system that is decentralized, that is resistant to censorship and with a sustainable economical model, you want it to be resilient. And one way to do this is that this isn't you cannot just print things out of thin air. Yeah.

1:03:27Vlad CosteaI was going to ask you this because the follow-up for blaming Alephium for using electricity is going to be like, why do you guys exist? What's the point of this project? What does it produce? What kind of value does it bring into the world? And how is it different from, let's say, Cardano or Ethereum Classic, which is also proof of work? Like, what is the reason that there's another layer one into the world? And you mentioned that there should be a cost to creating money. Now, let me put on my toxic Bitcoin maximalist hat.

1:03:57Now I'm going to say, well, this isn't really money. It's just a token that you printed out of thin air that you invented yourself. And then you ask people to consume their hash cycles to mine it.

1:04:09Maud BannwartSo, I mean, it depends. I think, you know, one can argue and this is debatable whether Cardano smart contract are fully smart contract or advanced scripting. The reality is, it remains, I think one statement that is fair to say is that Cardano smart contract or development environment is definitely not as user friendly and cannot be leveraged as extensively as what people are used to on the account model, for example. I think that is, I think, a neutrally, somewhat fair assessment. And so Alephium today is one of the very, very few chain that has full smart contract capabilities on proof of work with the UTXO model, with the security perimeter, with the security benefit of the UTXO model.

1:05:04If you look at smart contract platform right now, the vast majority of them are built on proof of stake. And out of the one built on proof of stake, pretty much all of them are built with the account model. And then most of them are using EVM and EVM compatible chain. So that eliminates all of the trade-offs with the development environments that Cheng and Alephium has built that leverages the UTXO model, but bring the entire flexibility of the smart contract. You actually get the full power of smart contract without the security trade off that you have in the EVM world or the EVM chain or the account based chain.

1:05:44It's like, I think everyone that has interacted in the crypto space had had the experience of getting their wallet drained, losing their funds to protocols that were attacked with reentrancy. So right now, the solution for smart contract that are out there are not sufficient because they are not secure. The same exploit happen again and again, almost every day, if not more. And so I think that Alephium is building something truly unique because it is the full power of smart contract with the decentralization and security of the UTXO and proof of work model from Bitcoin.

1:06:22But maybe Cheng, you have a different way that you envision it.

1:06:28Cheng WangI think that's a great way to say that basically we solve some problems that exist in the space. That's why we exist. Otherwise, definitely there's no reason for us to build a new blockchain. So, yeah, initially we started with because sharding was not solved and we solved it. And then we go deeper, we see security issues, performance issues, we solve that. And now we have a very solid foundation. We are going to push for the next phase, for product-market fit.

1:07:02Vlad CosteaNow, Maud, you mentioned that Alephium is not EVM compatible and you presented some pretty good reasons for it to not be. But at the same time, that is sort of the industry standard right now. And you have a lot of smart contracts that were written using or making use of the EVM. And I can argue it's more difficult for developers to come and build on Alephium because they cannot port one to one, whatever it is that they have been building before. What is the ease of transitioning from Ethereum EVM to Alephium's system?

1:07:39Maud BannwartSo, I understand your points. And I think the whole point is you wouldn't want them to copy paste what they've done there to Alephium. So, there's two aspects. I think, first, as a software developer, knowing several language, it's part of the life of a software developers. Like, I've never met a software developers that only knew one language, one framework, and that is it. But more importantly, in practice, what we've seen, because when Cheng and the dev team designed the VM, designed the smart contract language, they built it as developer for developers.

1:08:19So, they really looked at all of the pain points that they experienced when they were building on EVM to make an environment that cater to that. So, where you don't have a million different way of doing the same thing, where you have integrated tests into the VM and security check into the VM. And so, they really managed to design an environment that is developer friendly and where the developer experience is really good. So, what we've seen in practice, I can honestly say that we've never had anyone who tried the tech stack of Alephium as a developer and said, it's too complicated, I don't get it, or something like this.

1:08:57The fact that we're not EVM compatible, it's actually not so much on the developer side that it's complicated. It's a bit complicated because you have the mental barrier of, yeah, okay, it's not EVM, this is something different. But then in practice, every dev that I tried Alephium, whether they were junior, whether they were experienced, whether they came from Solidity, Solana, or any other ecosystem, the feedback has always been overwhelmingly positive that this is an extremely easy language, easy environment, very intuitive. Where it's a bit more complicated to have made the choice of not being EVM compatible is integration with services.

1:09:38Because like you said, EVM is the norm. And it makes it harder sometimes when you want to offer services because such services will prioritize integrating EVM compatible chain because for EVM-compatible chains it's basically copy-paste. So this is where it's been honestly more challenging than really on the developer side. Meaning that there are chains that are not EVM compatible that have a pretty complex development environment. And so maybe they have two challenges to face on our side.

1:10:12We've had junior developers who did like an in-person hackathon and had never touched Alephium before and they could build something at the end of the day like this. I don't know, Cheng, maybe you can tell a little bit more about the thought process as a dev when you designed the VM and the smart contract language.

1:10:34Cheng WangI think EVM is just a first mover advantage. It's not really a norm. If you look at the trading volume right now, Solana trading volume is more than EVM right now. And I believe the market of EVM is going to lose much more in the following years because it's really flawed. It's so insecure. You can still see many, many protocols being hacked every month and that's a big issue. And I don't see a way that that issue is going to be solved. So you have to have new virtual machines and there are other blockchains that are doing pretty good work.

1:11:12And Alephium's virtual machine is one of its. So I personally feel like EVM don't really have a good future. I'm very biased by that, and this trend has already started if you see the trading volume.

1:11:31Vlad CosteaFor me, it's really interesting because I see the EVM coming to Bitcoin right now and people trying to port that so that they can bring as many smart contracts on the Bitcoin ecosystem. And you guys are trying to move away from it, but don't you think it's sort of marginalizing you from the rest of the industry?

1:11:51Cheng WangI personally don't feel so. I feel like, for example, I personally like the new virtual machine blockchains. For example, Solana did a great job. I think the activity on Solana is much more than EVM ecosystem. Like really the cost of building on EVM is much, much higher. Of course, if you fork EVM, you deploy the existing DApps, it's probably easy, probably convenient. But if you want to do new innovations, it's much, much harder. The kind of development cycle is much longer. The cost is much higher. You have to pay a lot to the auditors.

1:12:32And all of that slows down the development and innovation, and it's not great for the long term. And that's why EVM loses in some of the games in the DeFi market. And this is just the beginning, in my opinion. And we're going to see more and more, grand, EVM is going to lose to the new advanced virtual machines. And it's pretty much like programming languages. We have seen in the early days, C was probably the dominant language. And then we have new languages, like more advanced languages, more type safe languages.

1:13:11And those languages start to get replaced, the kind of the old flawed languages. Of course, C is still used a lot because it's the kind of the low level stuff. I was just using it as an example. So in my opinion, definitely EVM is too flawed. If it's just a little bit flawed, probably it's okay. It can keep its advantage, its leading position. But it's really just way too flawed that it's going to lose the game in the long term. Maybe we can have another interview in five years and to see if this has become true or not.

1:13:51Vlad CosteaRight, so if EVM is C, the programming language, then what is the Alephium approach? Is it Python or Rust or what would you say?

1:14:02Cheng WangRust, I would say like a more simple version of Rust. Rust is great. It's a bit not friendly for newcomers. You know, it's a bit too complex for newcomers to grasp it. But Alephium is as elegant, as safe and secure as Rust. But we try to make the learning curve as smooth as possible.

1:14:27Vlad CosteaEthereum is using a language that's called Solidity for building decentralized applications or contracts. And if I'm not mistaken, it's very similar to JavaScript. And that's also part of the reason why it became popular. What is the programming language that a developer on Alephium must know?

1:14:51Cheng WangSo our language, called Ralph, is kind of, we get inspired by Rust, by Scala and also by Solidity. Solidity is definitely very easy to learn language, but it's very hard to master. It's a bit like JavaScript. JavaScript is so easy to write bugs. But it's fine for web applications, but for DeFi stuff is another story. If you have one bug, basically your project is going to be totally ruined. So in our case, we kind of mitigate all of the well-known issues of Solidity. And Ralph is quite simple as well as Solidity.

1:15:37So if you want to learn it, you just need to get started with our quick start documentation. Many people say that they can get started to write something with just one to two days. I feel like it's pretty friendly for newcomers.

1:16:02Vlad CosteaI want to ask you guys about some of the applications that were built for Alephium and what kind of stuff you find today within the ecosystem. But I have two more sponsors to plug before I do that. So there's Noones.com, which is a peer-to-peer marketplace that aims to empower the global south. It's really cool. I think the mission of Ray Youssef, who is the CEO of this project, is very noble. He deals mostly with people from Africa and the Middle East and also Latin America.

1:16:32And basically, if you decide to trade there on the spot market or use their debit card for spending or engage in any way, like even if you have a gift card, you can try to sell it on Noones. You are empowering the other people buying from the global south to have more liquidity to be able to participate into this global economy. So check it out. It's Noones.com. And I think it's a pretty cool exchange. And last but not least, there is SideShift, which is the place where you can swap something that you receive for something that you want.

1:17:10So let's say that someone decides to pay you in stablecoins and it's a bull market. It's probably a bad idea to hold on to stablecoins. What you can actually do is to tell the person to send their stablecoins to the SideShift address. And then you're going to receive BTC or whatever it is that you want into your wallet. The fees are pretty low. The liquidity is good. And for amounts that are small, I don't think there's any registration or KYC that's required. So check out SideShift. It's s-i-d-e-s-h-i-f-t dot i-o.

1:17:46And thanks to all the sponsors for making this happen. And now I gotta ask you guys, first of all, when do you plan to get listed on SideShift? Because I checked. I didn't find you there.

1:17:58Maud BannwartI don't think we've reached out to them yet. But you know what, I'll be just adding that item to my ever-growing to-do list.

1:18:09Vlad CosteaYeah, you should. It's a good way for people to swap into something else, like the Trump coin is there. Why shouldn't Alephium be there?

1:18:17Maud BannwartYeah, I think definitely we can raise the bar a little bit.

1:18:22Vlad CosteaThey have the dog with the hat. Why would they not have Alephium? Or Obama Sonic Harry Potter Inu 10 or whatever it's called. They have that one too.

1:18:34Maud BannwartDid you just make it up or is that a real one?

1:18:37Vlad CosteaNo, it's a popular meme coin.

1:18:39Maud BannwartOh my god.

1:18:40Vlad CosteaNo, I think it's Sonic Obama Harry Potter Inu 10. And the ticker for that one is BITCOIN.

1:18:52Maud BannwartOh my god. This space will always surprise me.

1:18:57Vlad CosteaI know. So tell me more about the stuff that you can find today on Alephium. What did you guys build and what did other people who came to the chain create for others?

1:19:08Maud BannwartSo the only dApp that we built ourselves as of today is the bridge. So we have a bridge to other networks. So we have a bridge to Ethereum. We have a bridge to BSC. That is a fork of Wormhole. So that allowed us to get stablecoin pretty early on into the ecosystem. And that is, as of today, the only dApp that the core team has built. Everything else has been built by a third party. And I think we have pretty much what you would want to see in any good ecosystem.

1:19:38DeFi, DEX, NFT marketplace. Prediction markets actually are arriving on mainnet. We actually also have tools that help you translate your Solidity code into Ralph code. We have lending, overcollateralized stablecoins. I think soon someone is going to release Morpho-like lending. So the list can go on. I on purpose don't want to say any names and just stay broad, because there are around 70, if not more now, project building on chain. So I just want to make sure that people, that you know, everyone gets the same attention because there's a lot of things going on.

1:20:21We have a place where people can navigate into the ecosystem. We also have hardware wallet support, custody solution, kind of really honest oracle as well. There is basically everything that you would want to see in the ecosystem. But we're looking for more RWA projects, tokenization projects as well. More DEX models. A lot of different things. I think there's a lot of opportunities, especially as a proof of work chain, to leverage dApps to work in synergy with the protocol layer to bring utility, yield to the protocol.

1:21:09I don't know, Cheng, if there's anything specific that you want to mention?

1:21:14Cheng WangI think that's a great summary.

1:21:20Vlad CosteaOkay, so basically you're trying to attract Rust developers to build smart contracts on Alephium?

1:21:28Maud BannwartI think it's not limited. It's any developers that wants to build without having to always worry that they've introduced a critical bug that they didn't see coming or to be, to have their protocol exploited by one of the many well known attack vector they can't protect themselves against. So I don't think we're limiting ourselves as any developers who want to be able to focus on what they're building, on innovating and really that being at the forefront of their concern versus how do I protect myself against all everything that could go wrong?

1:22:08Vlad CosteaI think that every chain needs to have like a killer app, something that sort of distinguishes it from the crowd and makes users flock towards it. I think for Solana it's pump.fun. Right now for Ethereum it used to be, you know, ICOs, DeFi, they follow all of these cycles. Right now I think the killer app for Ethereum is the prediction market, which is Polymarket, which is not even 100% built on Ethereum, but that's another conversation. What is the killer app for Alephium? What do you think is most interesting?

1:22:44Maud BannwartI think time will tell which one will become the killer app. I think we're still early in the ecosystem and maybe the killer app is yet to come. I think there's many untapped potential again with the stateful UTXO model that we have. I think time will tell, but there's many, many options. I don't know. Also, sorry, Cheng.

1:23:11Cheng WangYeah, I think it's a generic platform, so pretty much everything can be built on, I think. We're going to need to find the product-market fit with different types of apps and to see which one is going to win. Basically what Maud said.

1:23:28Vlad CosteaYou had a big hard fork a couple of weeks ago, which was called Danube, and that one brought faster blocks and better scalability and some optimizations. Can you please talk about what that one did? And also, who is this for? Because you must optimize the chain for some type of application or building. And basically, if you mention who this is for, maybe they're going to listen to this and get inspired to build.

1:23:57Maud BannwartHonestly, it was a pretty big upgrade and there was a lot of something for everyone in there. I think you mentioned, so we reduced block time from 16 seconds to 8 seconds. Because Cheng and the dev team did a lot of work in optimization, we could keep block size the same, so we effectively doubled throughput. So you have a pretty one of the most performance proof of work chain, I mean, definitely the most performant proof of work chain with smart contracts, but on par with other proof of stake chain.

1:24:32We also, I mean, again, there was optimization that was done at the full node level for faster synchronization. I think we reduced sync, we divided synchronization time by three. So it's three times faster to synchronize the node. And there's a whole list of things that were introduced in the virtual machine for better development experience for developers. Maybe Cheng, you can touch a little bit on that.

1:25:05Cheng WangYeah, so for dev experience, we have a lot of things, but most importantly, I want to highlight the user experience side. We introduced the groupless addresses and which one basically made the sharded blockchain the same user experience as a single blockchain. So for users, they will not feel like it's a sharded blockchain, but it's just a single blockchain as easy to use as other blockchains. And we also introduced passkey support, which can make the key management much more secure and easier for a lot of people.

1:25:41And yeah, after so many years in crypto, still the mnemonic is one of the big issues, like blocking a lot of people from using it. Passkey is quite key to that. Yeah, dev experience is kind of like more technical improvements for developer experience improvements. Yeah, and that's pretty much the three parts of the network upgrades.

1:26:17Vlad CosteaThere is someone in the chat right now. His name is Krev23 and he keeps asking, can I mine it? Can I mine it? And also, why do you have a block size limit? Sounds like you're going to scale your users and don't want them to mine your chain. If I can't mine it profitably, I really don't care if it exists. It might as well be Visa to me.

1:26:40Maud BannwartYou can mine it if you buy a miner.

1:26:46Vlad CosteaWhat's the cost of a miner and which one is good for home users?

1:26:52Maud BannwartI mean, again, it depends. I think there are some home miners that are I honestly am not mining, so I don't know. I think some of the home miners are definitely below a thousand, like a few hundreds. And then the industrial miners that you have, you cannot plug a home and you will need to either find someone to help you host it or host it yourself if you have the competencies. I feel like there is one that is at around, I don't remember, between two and three thousand for the industrial ASICs.

1:27:24So the home miners are a few hundreds and then you can get an industrial ASICs for a couple thousand.

1:27:34Vlad CosteaDo you recommend any specific build or manufacturer?

1:27:39Maud BannwartI don't have any competences here to recommend. I think honestly, no one in the team is actively mining or has a mining background. So I am not competent to give recommendation, but we have a dedicated mining chat where miners would be, I think, more than happy to give you a recommendation on the best setup for your context.

1:28:09Vlad CosteaOK, you want to keep it diplomatic. I understand you don't want to pick between the companies that are building them. But I still think I think Bitmain was the first one to come up with an ASIC, but I think that one is also industrial. So maybe it's not what people want from home. The question that I have for you right now, which does not come from Krev, is it still profitable to use GPUs?

1:28:33Maud BannwartNo, no.

1:28:35Vlad CosteaSo you shouldn't even bother if you have a rack of GPUs, you shouldn't use them.

1:28:44Maud BannwartNot at all. If your electricity is free, if your electricity is free and you really have a lot of GPU, why not? But otherwise, probably not.

1:28:55Cheng WangYeah, kind of like Bitcoin as well, mining Bitcoin with GPU.

1:29:02Vlad CosteaThere's also someone in the chat who says that Alephium's hashrate had grown 42,000% from January 1st to 2025's all-time high. And Alephium used to be the number one profitable coin most of 2023 on GPUs.

1:29:23Maud BannwartThat is the growth of the hashrate since we had the ASICs, this is correct. So that part is for sure correct. The rest I don't remember, but I will let miners that mine in 2023 confirm. But the first part is correct. The hashrate, I think before the ASICs, we were at a few terahashes and now we are at around 20 to 25 petahashes with a peak at 57 petahashes of hashrate at the all-time high. It's growing.

1:30:05Vlad CosteaI have to ask you, was the chain ever NiceHash-able, which means you can rent the GPUs to basically obtain a majority of the hashrate?

1:30:16Cheng WangYes, it is. But the market is not big the last time I checked it. So probably there was not so many miners that put hashrates on the market. I'm not sure. I'm not very familiar with NiceHash, but it's integrated.

1:30:36Maud BannwartYeah, I think it was used a lot when we were GPU mined. I think since we're ASICs, it's probably not as much used. But when we were GPU mined, I mean, we still are on NiceHash and available there. There was a lot more usage when we were GPU mined.

1:30:59Vlad CosteaI also have to ask you guys, because there are questions in the chat about the price. Why did you go from like $2 to like $0.29 right now? What is it that happened? Did the users drop out or was there anything significant?

1:31:14Maud BannwartAs a general rule, we don't talk about price. Like this is something we don't, whether the price goes up or the price goes down and we don't comment partially for legal reasons. Because as a project for the same reason that we don't comment on price, I think part of the price action follows market trend. But then any other comment on it is pure speculation, because nobody can really ever know.

1:31:48Vlad CosteaOkay, but I can argue that your chain is just as interesting as Solana, but at the same time, it doesn't have the market price or the users of Solana. And I want to ask you, why is that?

1:32:03Maud BannwartPart of it, I mean, again, here it's pure speculation because it's difficult to know. I think part of it is marketing budget. I think that one is partially fair when if you are asking specifically about Solana, I think overall budget makes a big difference on the attention that you can grasp in this industry and that you can retain. Same goes with for kickstarting an ecosystem. The more money you have to fund and kickstart the ecosystem, the longer you can do it, the more dapps you can support, even if maybe you don't have users to support it in the beginning.

1:32:46I think in this case, one of the components probably is funding, but again, part of it is again pure speculation. So I don't know, Cheng, if you have thoughts on this?

1:33:04Cheng WangI think it's a mix of many factors, definitely. One of the other things is we kind of actually, we have so many innovations, so it took much longer to build. Like we compared to many blockchains, we have sharding, like sharding is not really something done by that many projects. We built a new virtual machine and a new programming language. So if you see Solana, the virtual machine is built on top of another virtual machine and they use Rust as the language. We tried to make the virtual machine more secure and the language more friendly, so it took a bit longer.

1:33:52It took a longer time to build the foundation and also we are definitely less loud compared to others. We did not have kind of a big budget for marketing. We did not try to raise big or sell a lot. So yeah, a lot of issues, a lot of factors like that. But right now, I think the foundation is very ready. We are going to focus more on the growth side, the product-market fit side. Hopefully, things are going to be very different in one year or two years.

1:34:38Vlad CosteaYeah, honestly, I don't think you need much of a marketing budget. You just need to get on more podcasts, look at Charles Hoskinson. He's the master of that. He just does YouTube videos and talks about stuff and people buy into his token. And is his product superior in any way? I don't think so.

1:34:53Maud BannwartBut I can tell you his budget is superior. You really chose the example of a chain that has massive budget though.

1:35:02Vlad CosteaYeah, maybe because they pay people to shill the token, which once again, I'm speculating. I don't know if it's true. I said maybe, don't sue me. But my point is that you should be on more podcasts. I'm happy I got you guys because I've learned a lot. And I do want to ask you if there is anything that you think Bitcoin can learn from Alephium to provide some optimizations, work better, even for its limited purpose of being a store of value.

1:35:35Maud BannwartI have one that is not technical. I think I have one, which is maybe one thing that for me I always admire in the approach that Cheng and the dev took was to always try and be future proof. So to some extent, leave room for evolution when it makes sense. So that if one day you want, you can easily. And this is maybe not so much for Bitcoin, but maybe one example is maybe Ethereum who did want to change. But that change was very, very painful and very long and it's still ongoing.

1:36:15And so at least for me, one thing that I admire from the approach that the developer takes is the fact that they know what they don't know and they try to build things in a way that can evolve if it needs to in the future. And so I like that about Alephium. Please don't kill me for having said that.

1:36:40Cheng WangSo from my perspective, I'm quite familiar with Bitcoin codebase. So one thing I really think that Bitcoin devs could do is try to make things much more simpler. There are a lot of hacks in the codebase. A lot of designs are very hacky designs. It's very hard to grasp and to contribute. So that's not really great to create a dev community for Bitcoin. Even though Bitcoin has a lot of devs, but a lot of them are really hardcore hackers. They build hack solutions into the codebase and in the end, it makes the codebase very complex to manage.

1:37:21And that's why it's not that great. And in Alephium, we try to keep everything very consistent, make design as simple as possible, make the dev tools as developer-friendly as possible. So it's very easy to build on top of it. But with Bitcoin, building on top is very, very hard, to be honest. So that's something I hope Bitcoin can change at some point. And the last thing I hope Bitcoin can change is to move to probably a tail emission model at some point.

1:37:53Vlad CosteaOh, interesting. You're not a fan of the 21 million coin meme or cult or whatever.

1:38:00Cheng WangYeah. As long as it works, I'm fine with this. But I don't think it's going to work in the long term. So I believe they have to make a change at some point. And for that, I believe the tail emission model is a good one. But we'll see. Maybe they can come up with something more smart and then we can adopt. Right now, we are following the tail emission model.

1:38:28Vlad CosteaWhen I had Vitalik on the show, he acknowledged in a way that Ethereum is sort of the most successful and most liquid. Not layer two, but sidechain to Bitcoin right now, because there's a hundred thousand BTC that's locked into WBTC, which is not in the best setup. You know, there are no proper trustless bridges or whatever. It's custodied by BitGo and that's issued as a token on the Ethereum blockchain. But still, that's orders of magnitude higher than Lightning and Liquid and everything else combined. And I was going to ask you, can Alephium be used to tokenize Bitcoin?

1:39:10And what are the advantages to that?

1:39:15Cheng WangYeah, I actually personally looked into the Bitcoin bridge for quite some time. It's very, very hard because Bitcoin don't really have this smart contract capability. So from my perspective and giving what had happened in the space, people have tried to build decentralized bridge between Bitcoin and Ethereum. But it didn't really get a great success. So I personally feel like tokenize Bitcoin, probably the programmatic approach is still either by a multisig bridge or more like the BitGo approach. That's the users they would like to use. If Alephium is going to go that approach, definitely, if Alephium is going to focus on the Bitcoin bridge, definitely we have basically those two options.

1:40:11And right now we have wrapped BTC from Ethereum, from Ethereum with the bridge. And if we tokenize Bitcoin on Alephium, the benefit, I think the first benefit is we are based on UTXO model. So like Bitcoin, very similar to Bitcoin. So the whole tokenize Bitcoin or wrapping Bitcoin on Alephium could be more like censorship resistance, like Bitcoin network right now. And yeah, so overall it's like Bitcoiners are going to be happier because it's more like Bitcoin. But at the same time, you can use Bitcoin to get all of the DeFi utility.

1:41:08Vlad CosteaBut how is that different from using Ethereum? You mentioned the UTXO, but are there any other benefits or some sort of killer app to get people to do this?

1:41:21Cheng WangYeah, so with UTXO, like all of the coins in your own wallet, right, it's not in a smart contract. That actually has some implications that you own your coin. And with the smart contract, it's like owned by smart contracts. If there's a bug in the smart contract, there might be a risk. Of course, most very simple smart contracts don't have such risks, but that still could be a good argument in general, right? And it's very much more like the Bitcoin approach for Bitcoiners. For everyday users, I don't think they really care much about that.

1:42:06They don't really care about it's proof of work or proof of stake. So from that side, probably there won't be too much difference. But for Bitcoiners, like particular ones, especially like you guys, definitely UTXO is a more favorable model.

1:42:26Maud BannwartBecause tokens are first class citizens. So when a token is in your wallet, it's actually yours, and it exists in your wallet as an asset. Tokens are first class citizens on Alephium. Whereas, for example, on Ethereum, they are not. They exist through the smart contract. So if the smart contract that issued your token has a problem, this can impact your ownership of that token even in your private wallet. Whereas with token being UTXO based on Alephium, you have true ownership of your assets.

1:43:03And then, of course, all of the security aspect that we discussed. No reentrancy, no unlimited approval, attack vector and again, proof of work.

1:43:18Vlad CosteaOK, it still doesn't compel me, like it doesn't really want me to move my BTC to Alephium to transact. But I got to think about it. Are there any privacy benefits or advantages on Alephium? Can you do ZK roll ups and ZK stuff or is anyone working on that?

1:43:41Cheng WangSo right now, that's not on the roadmap because the throughput of the blockchain is very high. We have sharded blockchain, so we don't really need Layer 2 or ZK roll ups right now. But we're probably going to experiment some of the techs to reduce the block time further, to make people feel more comfortable to use it. Basically, as you say, to attract more users, more use cases, more applications. Yeah, for privacy, there was no protocol on it. But theoretically, you can build either mixnets or Tornado Cash, like the pool-based privacy stuff.

1:44:34Vlad CosteaIs it possible to port something like Tornado Cash directly to Alephium or does it require some sort of modifications?

1:44:45Cheng WangI didn't do it, but I looked at it, kind of the big picture. I feel like it's pretty much doable. It's not going to be that hard. And also for mixnets, it's probably pretty doable as well. So yeah, I think many issues right now, we are still in the very early stages. We still need to grow and attract more developers to build on top of it. That was kind of the main challenge right now.

1:45:19Vlad CosteaYou wanted to say something more and I cut you off?

1:45:24Maud BannwartI was like, what did I want to say? I wanted to talk, because you mentioned also killer dapp and things like this. I think, again, we're still quite early into the ecosystem. We've got kind of, like I said, the foundation, kind of everything you want to see in the ecosystem. And we're slowly starting to see people building things that are unique to Alephium. And I think one angle that eventually can be interesting is, again, the linking kind of the mining side of things with the DeFi side of things and doing so natively into a single network that is also proof of work.

1:46:01I think there's a lot of use cases that haven't been explored yet and that I really hope will be soon. And I think one of them is, again, by bridging those two ecosystems together into a single network.

1:46:19Vlad CosteaI mean, that does sound promising. And honestly, it's the most bullish idea about Alephium that you presented throughout this interview. I hope people have listened to it. It's been almost two hours. And if you are still here after two hours, maybe you should write a special word in the comments just to prove that you've been here. Like, what should the word be?

1:46:45Maud BannwartMaybe it should be Danube, like, you know, it should be Danube. Yes, which I don't even know if it's the right way to pronounce it in English, but in French, this is how you say it.

1:46:56Cheng WangNo, it's Danube. I think the name was kind of proposed by Vlad, right?

1:47:05Vlad CosteaNo, I don't think so. I think I was... Oh, yeah, because you had another one, Volga or something?

1:47:08Cheng WangYeah, yeah. And you replied Danube and then we discussed about it and we think it was a great idea. So we chose it.

1:47:18Vlad CosteaReally? Last year, I think, or two years ago, I remember seeing something.

1:47:21Cheng WangOne year ago, yeah. Last year.

1:47:23Vlad CosteaOh, really? So I was that influential on your project? I had no idea.

1:47:30Maud BannwartI didn't know it was you, actually. But now that you remind me, Cheng, I remember we had a poll, and it's true, on Twitter.

1:47:38Cheng WangVery few people know this.

1:47:41Maud BannwartSo see, it has to be Danube because it is thanks to you. You actually named our latest upgrade. Who knew?

1:47:50Vlad CosteaThat's so cool. What's cool about it, of course, I'm biased because I'm from this part of the world, but it goes from Germany and it goes through a lot of European capitals. It goes to Bratislava. It goes through also Budapest and it goes into Romania. What's the verb for it? It spills into the Black Sea. So it goes a long way. It goes basically half of Europe. It's also the name of that waltz by Johann Strauss, which is called Blue Danube. It's very famous. If you don't know that one, you shouldn't be listening to this podcast. I'm sorry.

1:48:33Cheng WangIt's a good continuation of our previous upgrades. We started with Leman. Lake Leman is the lake around Switzerland. And then the second upgrade we named is the Rhône upgrade. It's a river that's connected to Lake Leman, I think. Yeah. Maud, do you agree with me?

1:48:54Maud BannwartYeah, I was going to say, it goes all the way to the Mediterranean Sea. We hesitated to call this upgrade the Mediterranean upgrade, but for obvious reasons, it's really hard to pronounce. That's not what we went with. But we like body of water as name for upgrade. And Danube was our greatest upgrade to date.

1:49:20Vlad CosteaUntil the next one, of course. But I've been meaning to ask you this also. What does Alephium mean? It sounds like Ethereum, but mixed with Aleph. What's Aleph?

1:49:34Cheng WangAleph is the unit for infinity. Because we are building a very scalable blockchain, we want to tell the message that Alephium has infinite potential. So we use the unit of infinity. It's Aleph. And then we took some inspiration from Ethereum, right? So we coined this new word, Alephium. And yeah, that's the name.

1:50:07Vlad CosteaWhen I was doing research for this interview, I stumbled upon something that's called Aleph Zero. And I was wondering if there's anything that you guys have in common.

1:50:18Cheng WangIt was a coincidence. Actually, one of the core devs of the project, we used to study in the same school. Not study, like doing PhD research. So I know one of the guys there. It was like totally coincident they chose Aleph as well. Even though I don't know why they choose that. Probably because math people love this.

1:50:44Vlad CosteaWhat is a good way to start with Alephium after listening to this interview? Like a wallet that people can download some softwares, anything. Do you have any faucet for claiming coins or tokens or do you do any community giveaways or what is a place where they can buy some tokens?

1:51:04Maud BannwartSo the place where you have the answer to all of those questions would be the website. We recently updated it and we have a page that literally has the answer to all of your questions one by one. If you want to try a wallet, we have everything you want. We have desktop, extension, mobile wallet. My favorite is the desktop wallet but it's definitely not for everyday user. But if I have to recommend one, let's say the desktop wallet is my favorite. You can buy, actually now you can buy ALPH directly in the wallet because we've done a lot of work to integrate many on-ramps.

1:51:44But we're also on several exchanges, decentralized exchanges as well. So do check out the native DEXs of the Alephium ecosystem as well. But really the website has the answer to most of your questions. And if you're more technical, docs.alephium.org is the place where you would want to start. Either if you want to run a node or if you want to start building. And I know that with your audience we don't need to, and it's refreshing that we don't need to remind people why it's important to run a node.

1:52:22Because nodes are the network and so if you want to run an Alephium node, please do. You can do so on a Raspberry Pi.

1:52:33Vlad CosteaOkay, I see that a lot of people in the comments started, actually this is the chat after I publish this it's going to be the comments. But they started posting Danube and there's also someone who mentioned that the names of previous upgrades were Leman, Rhône and now it's Danube. And someone also mentioned that the naming was originally going to be BlockFlow.

1:53:00Cheng WangThat was the name of the algorithm, the sharding algorithm, BlockFlow.

1:53:09Vlad CosteaOkay, so we established how Alephium works. I did try to present every piece of criticism that I possibly could so people don't listen to this and be like, oh, this is paid marketing, whatever. And also I told people how to get started with Alephium. So is there anything that I forgot and you really wanted to mention in this interview?

1:53:35Cheng WangIf you want to dive into a new blockchain and want to have some fun, Alephium is definitely the place for you. You will not be disappointed. Just ALPHing. Just ALPHing.

1:53:52Vlad CosteaMaud, do you have anything to add?

1:53:56Maud BannwartNo, I think honestly anyone that has taken the time to dive into Alephium usually came back. I've never had anyone look into Alephium and not like what they saw. There's really something for everyone, really it's a lot of innovation in different aspects. So whether you're proof of work maxi or a builder who likes to innovate, someone who is passionate about security and software security. There's really something for everyone in Alephium, also as a user if you want a secure, fast environment. So I think it doesn't cost much to look and I think you'll like what you see.

1:54:36Thank you so much for giving us the opportunity to present Alephium to your audience. Thank you also for asking all the questions that you wanted to ask and all the criticism. Because this is the only way I think people can truly understand a project. So really appreciate that, thank you.

1:54:56Vlad CosteaAlso, where can people follow you personally and the project?

1:55:02Maud BannwartWe're most active on Twitter. I would recommend you follow Alephium and Cheng. Me, I basically retweet from my account. So my account is not super interesting. But Cheng does do from time to time in between coding some technical take or feedback or technical deep dive. I think this is someone that you should definitely follow and then the main account. Me, I'm just a copycat. I just quote tweet everything Alephium does.

1:55:36Vlad CosteaBeautiful.

1:55:37Maud BannwartI have zero personality on Twitter. There's no need.

1:55:43Vlad CosteaOkay, thank you very much Maud and Cheng. And I wish you all the best with Alephium.

1:55:49Maud BannwartThank you, thank you. Thank you so much for having us.

1:55:53Vlad CosteaAnd once again, thanks to the sponsors, LayerTwo Labs, Edge Wallet, Bitcoin.com News, Noones.com, SideShift.ai and Citrea.xyz. I'll see you in the next one. I think the next guest is going to be Andrew Poelstra from Blockstream. He's going to talk about some new stuff, maybe related to the scripting language that they have been building. And then there's also going to be Sergej and Matt from Bitrefill.

1:56:21And they're going to talk about their stats. And then last but not least, I think it's going to be later in August. We're going to have the creator of Kaspa. And apparently that one's going to get a lot of listeners. So stay tuned and thank you for listening.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00