S16 E38: Bitcoin Payments in 2025 with Sergej Kotliar & Matt Ahlborg
Search this conversation
0:49Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 38, I think. And we are live with Sergej Kotliar, CEO of Bitrefill and Matt Ahlborg, who has been doing data research for the company for a while, but is better known lately for his project, which is called PPQ.AI, where basically you pay for every AI query. And you can pay with your coins, you can pay with Lightning, you can pay with on-chain Bitcoin. And a bunch of stablecoins, I think. And it's a really cool project. You don't have to subscribe with your credit card to ChatGPT.
1:28You can just use the latest version, just paying for what you use as opposed to having a proper subscription. And the purpose of this interview is to talk about what's new with Bitrefill, talk about some user data, which might be very interesting because sometimes the narratives are not exactly what the markets reflect. And also talk about the rise of AI, because that's also an important, I guess, milestone in Bitcoin adoption and something that we should keep an eye on. So welcome, guys. For you, Sergej, it's the third time, I think, on the show.
2:05For you, Matt, it's the first time. Thank you. Thank you. So where do we start?
2:16Matt AhlborgNo idea. You're the podcast guy.
2:19Vlad CosteaRight. Let's start with data about Bitrefill, which, if I'm not mistaken, is the biggest seller of gift cards that accepts Bitcoin. You guys also have one of the largest Lightning nodes, which I think back in 2019, if I recall correctly, Sergej was the first person to open a Lightning channel that had one BTC liquidity. And that was sort of a very big deal because people were saying that it's reckless to put more than 0.04 Bitcoin in the channel. And at the same time, I'm curious to know if it paid off, if accepting Lightning turned out to be the killer app and what keeps you guys in business and brings most of the transactions.
3:09Sergej KotliarIt's a very specific question. Did it pay off? I think it did pay off in terms of the amount of effort and energy we put into it and what we got out of it. You know, I mean, I've been open to saying that back then I expected Lightning to kind of, you know, within a year or two, to be 50 and then 80 and then 95% of all transactions with internet money. That obviously hasn't happened like that. Lightning remains sort of, you know, in the 5% range of our GPV, gradually eating more and more of the transaction volume of on-chain Bitcoin.
4:04And kind of growing with the industry, even though on-chain Bitcoin isn't — the rest of the crypto ecosystem is growing more. The trend over the past years, yeah, has been that. Lightning has its own segment, its own user group that uses it. It is growing, you know, nice and steady. No mega rocket ships, but it's dragging away, I would say. The big trend, obviously, has been that we've, in the past years, moved from a Bitcoin maximalistic world to a post-Bitcoin maximalistic world, in a world where it used to be 90, then 80, then 60, then 50% Bitcoin, and nowadays we're
4:58Somewhere around 25, 30. Somewhere depends a little bit on how you count, but that's the big shift in user behavior. The difference is not that there is any one particular chain that has outgrown Bitcoin, Bitcoin is still the biggest one.
5:30Yeah, but sort of combined, like where we are now in the many chains, many coins world, which if you had asked me five years ago, I wouldn't have thought that that would happen.
5:47Vlad CosteaRight, but wouldn't you argue that Tron is a bigger chain right now because most of the USDT is there and a lot of the transactions happen from Tron?
5:57Sergej KotliarBigger than what? The Bitcoin?
6:00Vlad CosteaYeah, in terms of payments.
6:03Sergej KotliarNo, Bitcoin is bigger than Tron. Tron is roughly a little bit bigger than Lightning, but not that well.
6:10Matt AhlborgYeah, Tron is very expensive to use. It's been getting more expensive over the last two or three years. Nowadays, if you actually stake some Tron, that can reduce the amount of fee that you have. It's really hard to make a definitive call on if it's expensive or not, but in general, if you don't have staked Tron, I think it's three or four dollars for a transaction now. And they keep telling us that it's going to be free soon, particularly with stablecoins on Tron, but it hasn't materialized yet.
6:52Sergej KotliarYeah, I think the Tron data is outdated from a past world when Tron was a bit bigger than what it is today, and these things change over time. I think that the big part of it is understanding that we're no longer in a world, like the old understanding of the world, there's Bitcoin and there's altcoins. Altcoins are variants of Bitcoin, and it's all one big thing, and then there's subsets, and then people within argue over which coin is the best. Whereas nowadays, in many ways, it feels like that we have a very disjointed community, and they're not necessarily even centered around the particular coin or anything.
7:39It's not like there are Tron maximalists or whatever, it's just like, hey, it's a group of people, they hang out in these forums, and they do these things, and they use this because it just happened like that. So you'll have the NFT, there's different NFT communities as well, and then there's the Ethereum, and then there's the Bitcoin maximalist. There's overlap, but there's definitely disjointed, I would say today, communities that you can choose to offer your services to or not. And they're geographically, demographically whatever disjointed. Like the Tron usage used to be very centered around the Binance ecosystem, Binance peer-to-peer, all of those things.
8:35And over the time, I think that some of those people may have shifted to other things, or they just haven't grown.
8:47Vlad CosteaNoOnes.com isn't just an exchange, it's a revolution for the global south, through which war chief Ray Youssef is trying to rally all the lions of the global south from Africa and the Middle East to build this army of people who are financially free. And what you find on NoOnes.com is a peer-to-peer exchange, is a debit card that you can use for spending your coins, is a gift card marketplace, is also a spot exchange, and a lot of cool stuff where everyone gets a seat at the table and everyone eats.
9:21This is the philosophy on NoOnes.com, and it's definitely the place where you want to go if you want to participate in empowering Africa in ways which go beyond Live Aid concerts and virtue signaling and whatever. Just be a market participant, help them get the liquidity that they need, and help them improve their lives while you actually also improve yours. Because that's how it works, you build wealth, you engage in free trade, and it's all available on NoOnes.com.
9:56So I'm curious you mentioned an interesting term which is post-maximalism, how do you define that?
10:04Sergej KotliarWell, I did, right after, like, in my view, Bitcoin maximalism made a lot of sense when Bitcoin was 90% of all activity in the whatever crypto ecosystem. And it makes much less sense when Bitcoin is 25%. Also, when there are people that are not, you know, like, okay, Ethereum was very reactionary to Bitcoin, right? Bitcoin Cash was reactionary.
10:37Like today's many crypto ecosystems, like Solana, like, they don't think about Bitcoin at all. Like, that's their entire thing. And they use some things that are similar to Bitcoin, they use wallets and cryptographic signing, and all of those things. And we will recognize a lot of things in a bizarre way. But it's a different sort of, yeah. If that makes sense.
11:08Vlad CosteaYeah, I understand what you mean, that you have a new generation of networks that don't really care about Bitcoin and do their own thing. But at the same time, yeah, at the same time, it does seem that even within the maximalist community, the morality has changed. But
11:31Sergej Kotliarit was always changing. Like, you know, I would say that it has always been a changing subject. But yes, absolutely. Bitcoin maximalism today is quite different than it was 10 years ago. Yeah,
11:52Vlad Costeabut 10 years ago, it meant let's build everything on this network, because it makes the most sense. Now, it's almost like they're trying to keep away people from using Bitcoin, saying, well, this is the right way of using it. And this is the wrong way of using it. And most of the times is just mostly about who's using it, because there are some quote unquote, degens, who should not touch Bitcoin ever, even if they pay the transaction fee. And then you have some use cases, which have been blessed by all the right people, so they get recommended.
12:30Sergej KotliarAnd that was always the case as well, like in the past, and just that maybe you weren't as aware of it, and may as well. But there's always been a friendship layer in the ecosystem and an in-crowd layer and so on. And so if you're — I know that you're very interested in the block size war in that time period, and so like, that framework also helps to understand that time in a better way. And in terms of the different friendship layers that happen, and the ideological discipline.
13:12Vlad CosteaBut at the same time, you do see some goalposts moving in terms of, for example, proof of reserves, which used to be a popular demand that for a while only Kraken fulfilled as an exchange. And now you deal with these, what do you call them? Bitcoin treasury companies. Ironically, they have the BTC acronym. And some of the same people who are saying, well, every exchange should publish proof of reserves are saying, well, strategic Bitcoin companies should not publish proof of reserves. It's really funny. In the end, I think Chris DeRose was right, when he was saying that the morality of Bitcoin is basically whatever makes the number go up.
13:55Sergej KotliarHe said many things that were all right. Many of them are right, but also sometimes contradictory. He also said that Bitcoin is communism, which also has a certain element of truth. And maybe a bit contradictory, unless you know communism and realize that actually communism had an element of that as well. But now we go very deep at the end here.
14:16Vlad CosteaI don't want to get you guys canceled. So can you tell me what the Bitrefill payment ranking looks like? Like, what is the most popular method of payment? And what are the next ones like a top 10 or something?
14:31Matt AhlborgYeah, I could probably try to do that a little bit because I've got the thread up right now. Yeah, so Bitcoin and Ethereum, let's call them ecosystems. So the Bitcoin ecosystem is on chain and lightning. And then also to include, I guess you could say, when people deposit Bitcoin and then spend it on our platform, that I guess you could say that also counts. And then the Ethereum ecosystem is on chain Ethereum plus all of the stable coins that are attached to it, like Arbitrum, Polygon, etc.
15:05I think those are actually approximately the same size now. Ethereum with the stable coins may even be a little bit. I think they're equivalent in terms of monthly active users about but then Ethereum volume, I believe is is even a bit higher because it has the stable coins on it, which have like a really high average transaction. After that, those are the big two. You have kind of this, what I call legacy payment methods. People get mad when I say this, but like things like Dash, Dogecoin and Litecoin, especially Litecoin, that's basically the whole category there.
15:47Sees a decent amount of usage, but it's like a distant third compared to the Bitcoin and the Ethereum ecosystem.
15:53Sergej KotliarYou forget the Solana ecosystem. It probably deserves its own mention. I would guess it's the number three in the order. And then you still have things like Tron and before we get to the Litecoin.
16:12Matt AhlborgThat's true. Yeah. So Solana is only a year old on our platform, a year plus old, something like that. And it's both Solana, the asset as well as stable coins on Solana together. Yeah, as Sergej said, are probably about third. And then yeah, USDT on Tron, and then probably Litecoin, Dogecoin, Dash, it's almost all Litecoin. And then, yeah, we have Binance Pay that's gotten smaller and smaller over the years. I don't know why. I think Binance is kind of, I don't know, restrictive on I think that they have their own gift card.
16:51They try to show making it worse generally. Yeah. And yeah, that's pretty much it. Is that right?
17:00Vlad CosteaSideShift.ai is the ultimate place for your swaps. So let's say that you still have an XRP back from like six or seven years ago, and now it went to $4 and you're like, oh, I should really sell this, but you don't want to go to some KYC exchange. So how about you send that to SideShift and you swap it to BTC, and you're going to sleep much better at night and you're not going to be a shitcoin bag holder for much longer. Also, what if someone wants to pay you in stablecoins and you don't want to hold on to that, because why would you?
17:35It's a bull market. So let's say that you go to SideShift and you paste your BTC address, and then you're going to get a stablecoin address that you can send to the person wanting to pay you in stablecoins and boom, whenever they make that stablecoin payment, what you're going to get is BTC to your wallet address. Check out SideShift. It's really cool. Good liquidity, low fees. SideShift.ai.
18:08Do you happen to have percentages just to express scale or cleavages between these categories?
18:16Matt AhlborgYeah, I mean, I'm looking at a chart, it doesn't say the exact percentages, but yeah, Sergej said maybe 25 to 30% Bitcoin ecosystem, maybe in terms of volume, 20 to 25 to 30% Bitcoin, maybe 30 to 35% Ethereum, maybe something like, yeah, including stablecoins. Yeah, and then maybe 10% ish for Solana ecosystem, including stablecoins, and then maybe 15% and then, yeah, the USDT on Tron, what does that like? I don't know, seven, eight percent, something like that. And then Litecoin, Dogecoin Dash, another six, seven percent, something like that, and then Binance is pretty small, including the USDT and USDC on Binance, yeah.
19:16And then we have a lot of users who just use the dashboard, which we actually don't track very well, like if they deposited Bitcoin and then they spend from the dashboard, was that like originating in Bitcoin type thing? But yeah, dashboard usage is quite high, where users are spending from their top-up balance. Yeah,
19:38Sergej Kotliarwhich they in turn top up with the other payment methods. Historically, it's a little bit heavier towards Bitcoin and BOS, but I would say that, yeah, the numbers that you heard there are, you know, roughly correct. I think detailing with more precision always risks introducing more fake-news-ness than necessary, because there is a lot of randomness to the data. Some event or campaign or random thing could happen here and there that, you know, spikes here, spikes there, drops here, but like, on the whole it's somewhere.
20:21Vlad CosteaI was gonna ask you, Sergej, because I remember I hosted this debate between you and Peter Todd on the topic of full RBF. And at the time, I think I was naive and sort of sided with Peter because he was saying, well, the economic activity that doesn't take place on Bitcoin anymore can go on lightning, and we both know that didn't happen. But my question for you right now is, do you believe that since that moment, which was like three years ago, on-chain payments with Bitcoin have witnessed a trend of diminishing?
20:58Sergej Kotliarwould say, I mean, I think Matt wrote a big write up on this, I actually wrote on the mailing list where they asked me for the latest debate topic. On-chain was diminishing, declining.
21:19And there was a lot of things happening with different fee spikes at the time, but also kind of blurred the data. Historically, if I remember correctly, like when a free spike happens, the small transactions disappear and are replaced by mainly those transactions not happening. And then to a lesser extent, someone will use a lightning or a litecoin or something else. But for a lot of us, it's like, ah, it's not worth it.
21:54Matt AhlborgYeah, that's actually pretty key is like, you know, a lot of people would think, oh, if they can't use main chain Bitcoin, then they'll just use something else. But the actual real answer is, well, if they can't use the main chain, then they're just going to stop using Bitcoin or crypto full stop for the particular use case that they were doing. And many times they'll do that. Yeah.
22:17Sergej KotliarAnd so I think like after the fee spike finished, it's been a year now, like the small transactions haven't really come back this time. It used to be that they would come back. Nowadays, they're not coming back. And the lightning is doing something I can't say that it has mega grown as a result of it. I think, you know, in terms of inflow customer service tickets, there wasn't a massive inflow this time around. And I think mainly with the spikes that have been happening, people kind of already get used to the fact that your on chain transactions might not instantly convert.
22:57But on the whole, like, you know, my view is unchanged. Like, it's a functionality that Bitcoin had that worked without any incident for years for millions of transactions. That was it. It lost money exactly once after Peter's full RBF change had sufficiently propagated. Then there was a security researcher that demonstrated it with a small transaction, our system automatically turned off the functionality once it saw it happening. Meaning, and then, you know, the guy responsibly disclosed it, but like, it was very straightforward. It was sort of like the change to Bitcoin policy.
23:44Once it had reached enough mining power, then it did become insecure. And it went from, like, literally zero, like, you know, years would go, millions of transactions without any double spends. And then, yeah, it got abused once, and then we turned it off. And that was that. And, you know, I would say, like, my question is, like, well, are we better off? Has lightning grown? And then the world is confusing, right? Like, do we have more coin joints? Well, and are they going better? Well, you know, we had all the drama a year ago with the US government and all of that.
24:30So, like, we don't have an answer to that question of whether or not Bitcoin became somehow better off. From my perspective, Bitcoin became worse. I
24:46Vlad Costeaalso remember, Sergej, that you did a presentation, I think it was a pizza day, like three or four years ago. And it was about the most popular wallets that people use to purchase stuff on Bitrefill. And what you did was to ask the audience, like, what do you think is the most popular wallet? And they were saying, well, probably Blue Wallet, Wallet of Satoshi, Phoenix, stuff like this. And then you showed them, well, really, the most popular is Exodus, I think. And all of these multi-coin wallets like Edge or something else, which...
25:19Sergej KotliarTrust Wallet.
25:21Vlad CosteaWhich one?
25:22Sergej KotliarTrust Wallet.
25:23Vlad CosteaOh, Trust Wallet. Yeah, the one by Binance.
25:25Which proved that the people who go to conferences are out of touch and not necessarily have their finger on the heart of the market. They don't know what's happening out there. They just believe that just because there are a dozen of other guys who travel the world alongside with them and attend every event, it doesn't matter. It doesn't mean that the rest of the world is doing the same. And these guys are not necessarily the most, how should I put it, the customers who spend the most money.
26:01They're not your biggest customers. And I'm curious if you have any update on that, if you're aware what kind of wallets people are using nowadays to buy from Bitrefill.
26:13Sergej KotliarWe've been working a little bit on that particular functionality and kind of broke the data. So, no, I don't want to present an updated data, but the general learning is still there. And the main part of the learning was that this was for Bitcoin transactions, not for cryptocurrency transactions, but specifically for Bitcoin transactions that they were happening from predominantly multi-coin wallets. And it's still like that. But again, a lot of different things are happening. There's a lot more different chains that we support. We've changed the wallet selector so many times that the data is not currently trustworthy, unfortunately.
27:02Otherwise, it would have kept going in all of the conferences presenting the same data over and over again. Because it is an interesting piece of data. I would say like in terms of that talk, this was, I think, three or three years ago, maybe. I don't know if it has propagated yet enough. If that understanding has landed finally for me, three years is a very long time. I got bored of the subject and don't spend so much time going around talking about it, even though those things are still mainly true.
27:50I think, yeah.
27:52Vlad CosteaAt the same time, the question that should be asked alongside statistics about Bitcoin also concerns Bitrefill, because maybe some people will speculate and say, well, your business also got smaller, right? But are you seeing...
28:08Sergej KotliarOkay, go ahead. That was said in a very strange way on that podcast we did with you. By the other participant who made a logically flawed logic that for some reason it would have saved our business. I don't know, it was very convoluted. No, no, the truth is, we're doing good. Even our Bitcoin volumes are up. It's just that the other things are going up more. In the past year, we've also gotten better. Now we are more actively marketing to those communities as well, as opposed to 10 years back where we just played all prices always in BTC.
28:54Nowadays, we try to market to the different communities.
29:04Vlad CosteaDid you ever think, I think you started in 2014 or 2015, did you ever think at the time when you started that adoption was going to be so slow that people would still buy gift cards instead of the products directly 10 years later?
29:24Sergej KotliarNo, of course not. I mean, but yeah, you know, the world is, we live and we learn. And I think that we understand, we as humanity understand internet money more and better now, even though there's still a little bit of debates. But I think one of the things that we could learn some years back already is that, well, decentralization is expensive, always, by definition. So if you have a decentralized option and a centralized option, then by definition, the decentralized option is always going to be. You know, more expensive and more complicated than the centralized, right?
30:17Because the centralized option can always do everything that the decentralized option can do, but not vice versa, right? So the centralized will always be faster and cheaper. And, you know, for a lot of people, that's the main thing. And I think that decentralization is still very important. I still think that, you know, I think Bitcoin shields the whole broader crypto and internet money and fintech and parking everything with its mere existence. Yeah, I still believe that. But yeah, like, you know, the topic of security is, it's always been and like, it's a tough job.
31:06Like, even if you were the benevolent dictator of Bitcoin, like if we assume that the core devs are this one entity that worship the same god and have mysterious meetings somewhere and we can decide in unison, like, it's not obvious that like, should we actually, you know, trade off a little bit of security for a much more bigger improvement and performance and all that. Well, it is problematic, because Bitcoin's role is that it is supposed to be the most decentralized and most secure and all of those things, right?
31:43And so, yeah, if, you know, but other chains don't have that restrictions, right? And other chains have core devs that are literally, you know, like we are the Solana devs company entity where they just have a meeting and then they decide they can optimize, like they can say that, well, you know, actually, we're going to make these trade offs and we're going to increase performance and cost. And then we're going to have security that is, you know, significantly less than Bitcoin, but still enough for our users and we're going to get a lot of usage.
32:22And Bitcoin can't compete with that. And so, this again, it's like part of the post-maximalist understanding, like, it's hard for Bitcoin to win, maybe.
32:40Matt AhlborgI think that a lot of maybe me, maybe you guys have the same opinion, but I always pictured that the more centralized versions of Bitcoin would have been cracked down upon harder than they have been up until now. And so, you can see a lot of these other chains getting away with their centralization and I didn't expect it to happen to that degree. And so, that's kind of why I've always been in Bitcoin's corner because I just expected that this like kind of serious repression or oppression or whatever you want to call it would happen on crypto at some point.
33:21And it has happened to some degree and in some flavors, of course, but not to the degree that I think maybe a lot of people expected. And so, now we're left with a very decentralized and complicated and complex Bitcoin that does struggle to compete in like a more tolerable world, right? Where you can have a lot of these middle ground coins operate in the way that they do.
33:50Sergej KotliarI mean, a big part of this that we should also kind of be open about this, that's like a big chunk. So, like when we present the data for the other chains, for the Ethereum ecosystem and the Solana, TROM and so on. A lot of it is stable coins, like a lot of it is Tether or USDC and stable coins in the current form are fully trusted, right? And so, you fully trust, like, it's just a balance on a bank account somewhere that you fully trust the centralized company with, right?
34:29So then, you know, what is the security on the chain to transfer them and like how much does that matter and so on. I think that that's a big learning here.
34:47And also how the crypto ecosystem, and I say crypto with purpose, like it moves, like it used to be that Bitcoin was the money of the crypto ecosystem. It was the store of value, you know, their account, medium of exchange for crypto coins. And nowadays, it is stable coins in the Tether, that is the store of value, the unit of account and the medium of exchange of the crypto ecosystem. And whereas Bitcoin becomes the sort of promising blue chip, the blue chip investment coin.
35:30So, yeah, like, and again, like, you know, hey, stable coins are one of these things. They are very political. So far, we haven't seen that much. We saw the EU try to crack down on stable coins a little bit, but like not that much either. And just trying to create some regulations and so on. And the Americans right now have stable coin people in the government. So far, so good. Who knows, maybe. If the American government changes in three years and the Secretary of Treasury, Elizabeth Warren, decides that something else entirely should happen.
36:17Something else entirely will happen. And we're all going to go underground and become maximalist and privacy-focusing.
36:26Vlad CosteaYeah, you mentioned this American world, which in a way for us Europeans seems funny and foreign. But at the same time, it does impact the way in which we use and transact to a degree. And basically, you had Saylor, who was the first person to really make the case that you should never spend your Bitcoin. And he also made some extreme claims like he's going to die with his coins and whatever. It wasn't the first, but we're OK. At least the first one to establish the cult of this size.
37:02Because, of course, you had people quoting Gresham's law, according to Taleb, which was maybe 2016, 2017. Citrea is the first ZK roll up to enable Bitcoin to function as a fully programmable platform with a bridge optimistically verified by the Bitcoin network. What does this mean? Well, essentially, we're going to have smart contracts which are being built on top of this Bitcoin layer, which inherits the same security from the Bitcoin miners and is going to bring all the financial services that today we only have on Ethereum because it's more programmable.
37:43But using BTC and running on top of the Bitcoin blockchain. It's a very ambitious project, which is trying to bring the first ZK roll up to Bitcoin. It's called Citrea. You can access it at citrea.xyz. That's citrea.xyz. And the software, which is available to download, currently runs on the Bitcoin testnet. So check that out. And thank you, Citrea, for sponsoring. But I digress. What I'm trying to say is that this saying of never spending your Bitcoin leaked to Trump, who actually said this on record.
38:21It's part of the White House transcripts, basically, in the history of the United States, that he said never spend your Bitcoin. But at the same time, in spite of this propaganda to not use your BTC, you guys are seeing a surge in the amount of BTC that's getting spent on Bitrefill. So how do you explain this phenomenon?
38:47Matt AhlborgIt's the price action, generally speaking, when the price goes up for whatever crypto asset we have more customers coming to spend. Yeah. And when Sergej says that the numbers are really growing, it's more so in absolute numbers, not in a proportional sense. Like Bitcoin is going up in absolute numbers, but slowly and steadily, certainly not in some big growth spurt or anything like that.
39:25Sergej KotliarI mean, to understand your point, like, whenever somebody buys Bitcoin, somebody else sells Bitcoin. If some guy somewhere tells people that you should never sell your Bitcoin, some people believe it and don't sell the Bitcoin. That drives price up and then someone else sells the Bitcoin. Like, you know, it's a big supply. So whenever someone buys Bitcoin, someone else sells Bitcoin, what you can do is you can affect the price. In between it's a great way. If you do sell your Bitcoin, you know, I don't know if you should.
40:03I can say that as well through the same principle. Like you can sell, you should never spend your Bitcoin because that just drives price up and somebody else will spend the Bitcoin instead. Like that's kind of... I would say that like the difference would maybe be that in the olden days, Bitcoin would be kept in wallets, like in specific apps that would hold cryptographic keys, and that you would be able to scan a QR code and make a transaction, right? Whereas today, more and more Bitcoins are stored in, well, in ETFs, or even in best case, in some kind of multi-sig hardware wallet setup.
40:46In any case, they're not so much being casually, casually opened on their device.
41:03Vlad CosteaThat's kind of depressing when you think about it.
41:07Sergej KotliarWell, maybe, but like, in some ways, in other ways, like the way that I see it is that division of internet money lives. There's many different visions, right? But like, if I'm talking about like, yeah, well, a world in which money behaves on the internet in similar ways to how other things behave on the internet. Or if you talk about empowering people to do things with money online that they couldn't otherwise do. And all of this, you know, privacy, censorship, all of those qualities. But like, it's alive and kicking, like, the number of wallets in use is, I would guess, all time high.
41:57Because you know, which group uses wallets a lot? NFT people. They have all their coins in a wallet. And they swap and trade and send to each other. There's nothing strange about it. They use different wallets than the ones that are popular in Bitcoin maximalistic conferences. And if those wallets also support Bitcoin, and they're gonna keep some money in Bitcoin. And so there's also other groups that regularly as well. And I kind of, you know, exaggerating just a little bit.
42:36But yeah, so like, in terms of the goals, if you talk about like, the old values of Bitcoin, and how the values have changed, and so on. Well, yes, the values of the group that identifies as Bitcoiners definitely have changed. But I would say that the goals of the old values are still alive and kicking. It just takes a little bit different forms. And, you know, if people are financially empowered by by USDT on Solana, then okay, good. You know, I would have preferred it with Bitcoin, because of my, my bias and because I prefer the meme of Bitcoin to all the other memes.
43:25I think Bitcoin's meme is the best meme. But, you know, yeah, for someone else, there's other reasons. And yeah,
43:34Matt Ahlborgyeah, if you if you look at, or just, you know, it's hard to come up with data on this, but I think I very strongly believe that there are hundreds of millions of people using crypto, outside of the control of their, you know, local banking system, to using crypto to do cross border transactions to access cool online services. All that stuff is happening more than ever. And it grows, it's growing absolutely exponentially. And so in that sense, I think the dream is totally becoming real. And you know, all those things and you know, the sovereign individual are becoming true.
44:12It's just not always hardcore on the Bitcoin main chain or on the Bitcoin lightning network. It's it's happening in many other places.
44:24Vlad CosteaRight now I'm looking at Bitrefill to figure out if you guys added anything new. I know that in the beginning, you could basically refill your SIM card. And then you started adding all sorts of gift cards at one point, I think you had an option to pay your bills, but I think it was only available in some limited territories. US, yep. And you also had a limited run of shoes, if I'm not mistaken.
44:56Sergej KotliarThat was more of a one off campaign. But yes,
45:01Matt AhlborgI think we had two, two pairs of shoes made or something, right?
45:08Yes. Yeah.
45:11Sergej KotliarWhat's your question?
45:12Vlad CosteaWell, my question is, what do you offer to Bitcoiners right now if they want to spend?
45:17Sergej KotliarAh, well, I mean, look, we're the number one place in the world to buy things in the real world with your Bitcoin, and we, lately, one thing that's been growing a lot is eSIMs, which is a really convenient and good product and very feels very similar to to the internet money ethos, like this is, like, why does it you require physical plastic chip to put into your phone to have mobile service. And so eSIMs, we launched a year ago now, and it's still sort of growing rapidly, we're still figuring out how to market and grow and scale it even better.
45:58And the nice thing about eSIMs is that you can get like, even for your like, even if you have a cell plan in your home country, that works well, it still makes sense to get an eSIM and keep it as a secondary connection on your device, because then if your, if your primary operator runs out of data, sorry, goes out of service, because of coverage or whatever, then you have your secondary as a fallback that sometimes can save you. But other than that, like we have a lot of stuff in the pipeline that's being built.
46:37And we're spending a lot of efforts on the Bitrefill card, which is a reloadable Visa card for EU citizens. And that, yeah, the mobile experience is improving a lot. Like we're always adding new, new gift cards, new countries and so on. We're getting ready to have a big launch in Ukraine of gift cards, which is going to start being visible by the time that this goes live, hopefully. And yeah, you know, we're closing in on 90 people working hard on building new things. And there's a lot of cool stuff in the pipeline that I, you know, don't want to talk about until it's ready to go.
47:34Yeah, but in terms of living on Bitcoin and buying things from the real world, I'm pretty sure that we're the best place in the starting points for a lot of big usage out there.
47:50Vlad CosteaYou mentioned this debit card for spending. And it's very funny because we used to talk about replacing Visa and MasterCard and PayPal and all of these big financial services. But now it seems like we're integrating with them. And for a lot of people, this is a major win because they can spend their coins in a way that benefits from a large network effect with lots of merchants accepting. But on the other hand, we're not really replacing anything. We're just making it stronger. And I think this is a very prevalent theme when it comes to the way in which Bitcoin turned out as a payment system.
48:27Sergej KotliarI don't know if we're making it stronger, but I would agree that we're not in that regard, really replacing things. But even then, like, you know, it's not strange that if you have the new thing that, you know, works really great, whatever 80% of the time or 90% of the time, that you still support the old thing, so that you have something that works for the other percent. But yeah, no, I mean, from a philosophical standpoint, absolutely, like, yeah, I'll agree with you. Like, you know, Marc Andreessen, not that I generally am a big fan of his in the crypto sense, but at some point said that, you know, the libertarians are going to be upset with Bitcoin one day.
49:22And that was a very outrageous statement.
49:29Vlad CosteaNowadays, it seems like people in Bitcoin are not even libertarians. And you can argue this goes way back to the time when they were saying, well, you should label Ethereum as an unregistered security and the SEC should do something about Ripple and stuff like this. So I guess it was always like this. But now it's even more evident that guys who are larping as cypherpunks are putting their suits on, launching companies that basically produce nothing but raise money to buy Bitcoin and then borrow money against their Bitcoin reserves to buy more Bitcoin.
50:06And, gee, I wonder how this is going to end up.
50:10Sergej KotliarWell, I mean, you know, the libertarians definitely in their big sense, we lost them in the block size war. I would say like, you know, the Anarchapulco crowd and like the New Hampshire crowd and like there's still not a few of those communities that were very much on the on the big block side of things. I generally think that in other words, I don't think we're spending too much time on the past, but like one of the unfortunate parts of it is that like the Bitcoin community did split.
50:52And we did lose a lot of people. And that's where otherwise.
51:01Matt Ahlborgdid a couple of Litecoin podcasts when I was trying to get traction with PPQ. And I found myself on the Litecoin podcast really vibing with a lot of the Litecoin guys because they have a lot of thoughts that we all had back in 13, 14, 15. And it's like, yeah, I remember when we used to talk about that stuff all the time. And so, yeah, it definitely has changed to some degree.
51:29Sergej KotliarNowadays, there's Monero as well, where there's also a lot of, yeah, I'm not so involved in those groups, but there's also a lot of that type of like cypherpunks and so on.
51:41Vlad CosteaSo I can ask two questions from what you just said. The first one basically is in my mentions all the time. When I tweet about Bitrefill, someone says, well, why don't they support BCH? How come they hate us? How come they never allowed us to make payments on Bitrefill? We want to buy gift cards, but we can't because this and that. So how come you guys never supported BCH? And the second one is about Monero. Like, do you ever plan to support that or Zcash or something which enables privacy?
52:13Because I can argue I can already make a payment out of Mweb, which is the privacy layer of Litecoin. And you're not going to be able to know exactly where this comes from. I mean, in terms of the privacy,
52:27Sergej Kotliarlook, it's an eternal topic. There's no, I don't think there will ever be a final answer. And there's a lot of considerations. Like, you know, we are dependent on a lot of financial services and banks and similar. So we kind of, unfortunately, need to get a balance to be able to keep our business flowing. And provide, like, we already are very pro privacy type of thing. And so it's a topic of discussion, really, but I think that, and like, and unfortunately, as you know, the rules for these things are not exactly written down somewhere in the law book, it's one but rather, it's just like, a mix of different different considerations.
53:27And so, right now, we've been prioritizing other things, but we should never say never. Matt's going to present some data on Monero. That's very encouraging. In terms of the BCH topic, like, look, at the time, we didn't support BCH, because yeah, well, you know, this isn't Bitcoin, there was a lot of misleading marketing. And there was a lot of bad stuff coming out of the BCH community. And that was, was dishonest and problematic. I stand by that. And today, BCH is just like, yeah, you know, their argument is like, yeah, but look, you support Dash. And like, you know, Dash is like a legacy chain that we support for, for a very small number of people that we can count on their hands.
54:26Like, you know, today, BCH is not the vibrant ecosystem, you know, there's some people that still sort of live in 2017. With with that chip on their shoulder, like, I think they were, if you evaluate the claims of the big blockers at the time, the claim was that, well, the usage of Bitcoin is going to split into many coins, like that was accurate. Yeah, they thought that it was going to split into big blockchains of Bitcoin, that ended up being wrong. It ended up being big blockchains of Ethereum, which I think would have been very surprising to them.
55:10And also was a large amount of usage of centralized stablecoins, which would probably also have been surprising to them. And so like, when we decided which chains to add, like, you know, we're relatively restrictive, but we go by, you know, sure, there's a couple of guys on Twitter, but like, you look at the stats for for the chain, you look at and then like, you know, look at the other things that we get to request for and we get like every cryptocurrency out there is requesting us to support it.
55:41Supporting a chain means maintenance duty, it means a whole new category of security considerations, because every cryptocurrency is slightly different. Yeah, right. And so you can build something perfectly safe here, and then you you run it there. And we did actually get a zero-conf double-spend once on Ethereum. In terms of that topic, that had RBF, always funny, this is many years back. But like just saying that, like, you know, the different chains have different properties, like you need to spend manpower, maintaining them. This is why we don't just enable everything under the sun.
56:21We target specific user groups and communities as well.
56:28Vlad CosteaHey, and where do you get your Bitcoin news? Is it news.bitcoin.com? Because nowadays, it's much more interesting than you ever recall, because they have news about silver, they have news about gold, they have news about what's happening with Bitcoin regulations around the world, not just the US. And they are also more objective and less politically biased to say it lightly. And it's not what you remember. It's not the website that says BCH is faster and cheaper than BTC. Now it's orange, it knows very well the difference between BTC and BCH.
57:06And I think the journalism that you'll find is very solid. I do like the rebrand. I do like the fact that they're more neutral on their coverage. And I think it's a solid resource that you can use when you want to understand what's happening in this very confusing and diverse market. So check out news.bitcoin.com today. All right, so Matt was going to present some data about Monero.
57:36Matt AhlborgYeah, I mean, just the data point I have is we accepted on PPQ, and it's the second largest payment method. And most of our marketing is, you know, kind of in the lightning ecosystem. Anyways, so, you know, that's kind of expected to be number one. I think it's majority lightning now, as we've kind of really gained traction in that community. But I think in the first year or so, Monero and lightning were neck and neck. And, yeah, it's been great. And, you know, very much don't plan on turning it off.
58:17And I've consulted with a lawyer, and he said, Well, you know, for now, it seems fine. It's not the same risk surface as like a place where you can maybe buy many different products or something. I'm just selling one kind of product. So I guess maybe the risk is lower from the eyes of regulators or something. I don't really know these things as much. But the answer for the foreseeable future is yes.
58:51Vlad CosteaThis is interesting, because there are at least a couple of guys that I know of who swear by the fact that lightning is more private than Monero for the sender. And Bitrefill and PPQ both support lightning, right? So why don't you support Monero and Zcash for payments since you're able to support lightning?
59:13Matt AhlborgI think it's a it's perception. It's not about what actually gives you privacy. It's about how these ignorant regulatory bodies see these things. And when they hear the word Monero, they associate it with the dark web and this and that. And it's really nothing beyond that, in my opinion, I'm not a lawyer or anything like that. But I think that's really what it comes down to is Monero is this buzzword in regulatory circles that says, Ooh, that thing's risky. And then lightning is a Bitcoin thing. And it has like, I guess, a cleaner reputation.
59:48And so good to go. And it really has nothing to do with the actual technical privacy aspect of either one of them. I
1:00:01Vlad Costeawas gonna ask you about Liquid Bitcoin, which is Bitcoin that's locked on Blockstream's Liquid Federation. If you guys support that or what you think about it, because there are also some guys who claim that it's super private, even though the only privacy that you have is for amounts.
1:00:19Matt AhlborgWe support Liquid at PPQ, but it's just extremely low usage. And actually, the funny thing is, is like, I don't even know how to withdraw all my Liquid Bitcoins, because we have it through BTCPay Server. But, and I have, you know, I think maybe upwards of 1000 bucks in there now, but I've tried to cash it out. And there's some problem with the Blockstream wallet that I'm trying to use to cash it out. And so I can't get it. So it's something I'm going to have to fix eventually.
1:00:55But yeah, I mean, bottom line, it's an extremely underused thing and has very little network effects currently. And so I don't, if I were in Bitrefill's shoes, I would add Bitcoin Cash way before I would add Liquid Bitcoin just in terms of number of users. But yeah.
1:01:14Vlad CosteaOh, man, that stings.
1:01:18I mean, Liquid was going to be this scaling layer, right? And it never took off. And there was so much work that went into it. The expectations were super high because they raised a lot of money to build a sidechain.
1:01:35Sergej KotliarI don't think the story is over yet. That too. But like, you know, yeah, if you know, they did build some privacy functionality. I mean, fundamentally, you know, they think they lost out specifically because of like, it was an extreme version, like the marketing problems that Lightning had, like they had that squared in terms of like, they marketed like very specific group of eight people that promised to never use the coins. But like nowadays, like it used to be, if you look at the Liquid mempool, that there was like, no transactions in every block.
1:02:12Nowadays, there is like, I'm looking here, it's like 7, 4, 3, 11, and so on. So like, they've had exponential growth from admittedly a very low level, but like, they got off zero. So like, I'm not judging here. Like it's hard, like they were zero for a very long time. Now they're not. Things are happening. I don't know exactly what it is. Yeah, it's like,
1:02:39Matt Ahlborgit's the Breez SDK thing. I think it uses Liquid and Lightning and it's the way that Aqua wallet works. It's the way that a lot of these seed-funded startups are building wallets these days to address the inbound liquidity problem of Lightning and all that stuff. So they're, they're starting to use Liquid in places there. And, and I believe that's the reason why it's actually starting to grow.
1:03:09Sergej KotliarI'm looking at the transactions here and the, oh wait, I see the amounts. The amounts are very, very small, like 40 sats, 45 sats, 47 sats. So I wonder what that is, if it's some kind of token thing that is happening or if it's something else. Maybe they're minting it. Yeah, it's op returns. It's a good question. Like you should ask, I guess, invite someone on the pod to talk about that.
1:03:41Matt AhlborgI mean, for me, I think, uh, I think, I think Liquid really shot themselves in the foot because they, uh, from a marketing angle, they, they were shitting on shitcoins for years and years. And then they made a thing that really, I mean, I'm sure if you really dive into the technicals of Liquid and, uh, you know, there's all these blockstream smart people building this thing. So maybe it is built in a more secure way than, than a lot of these Altcoin systems are. But it, the, a lot of the fundamental like trade-offs and, you know, federations and, uh, multi-sig and all that stuff that's already happening on, on a lot of Ethereum L2s.
1:04:23And those are the things that they were shitting on for years saying that, you know, uh, it's, it's a big scam, it's going to fall apart. And then they kind of did it themselves. So it's, it's, it's a hard hole to climb out of, I think.
1:04:37Vlad CosteaAlso remember like four years ago, there was this clone of OpenSea that was called Raretoshi that was built on Liquid. And there were like a handful full of people, including myself, who were playing with that. And there were some transactions in the mempool because of it. And all it took was a couple of tweets from Adam Back saying, NFTs are scams. You know, you, you're not really selling the JPEG and stuff like this. Like basically he sort of flooded his own system that was happening on Liquid.
1:05:14And people just went away.
1:05:16Matt AhlborgI think there's a big cultural, like cognitive dissonance between like how Bitcoiners are supposed to think. And then the actual things, the actual use cases that are playing out across crypto in general. Like, you know, gambling, NFTs, memecoins, all that stuff really is a huge, huge chunk of this entire crypto ecosystem. And so I know it, and I feel like Bitcoin is on the right side of these things in many, in many ways where they're saying, no, all those things are kind of immoral, or at least at the very least, they're a big waste of time.
1:05:53But yeah, it's hard to build up network effects. The thing that really builds network effects for a lot of these tokens is the degen stuff. That's the catalyst that really brings it. And so, yeah, it's very hard to grow something from nothing without some sort of powerful catalyst like gambling or NFTs or something like that.
1:06:19Sergej KotliarAnd it's the same with the treasury companies, right? I mean, it is sort of, hey, you know, you get, you buy a Bitcoin for two Bitcoin, but maybe you can sell it to someone for three and they can leverage it, and that someone makes a treasury company or the treasury company and so on. Like, yeah, I mean, it is a way to tap into that.
1:06:45And that's the thing that like, Bitcoin says that we are something different, that we don't have the get-rich-quick dynamic of the shitcoins. You know, there's definitely an ethos on Bitcoin that's not about the get-rich-quick, but like, I think we need to be honest that there's a lot of get-rich-quick mentality in the Bitcoin space.
1:07:14Vlad CosteaI do remember there was this guy, Guacamole Zuccola or something. And when I was working at Bitcoin magazine, he did an interview where he was promoting something that's called RGB, which was basically a way to move your counterparty and master coin and whatever else, colored coins from the Bitcoin base layer to be able to transfer them on a layer built on top of lightning. So basically you mint them on the base layer and then you transfer ownership on something that scales better, which makes a lot of sense.
1:07:48But now the same guy is saying that it's all spam and you should never touch that in the first place or attempt to do it. So yeah, I see a lot of post-rationalization and a lot of points of view have changed.
1:08:06Sergej KotliarWell, pointing out that someone's point of view has changed is always like kind of an own goal, right? Because, you know, like people's points of view change. And so if you point out that someone's point of view changed, then like a logical listener would be like, I wonder what's happened in the middle that made them change their mind, right? But often it's used as a slur, like they were dishonest because they changed their mind. So I don't know, like just pointing out that people's point of view should change really, because we...
1:08:39Matt AhlborgYeah, do you think it's... Vlad, do you think it's coming from dishonesty or do you think it's coming from a genuine change of mind?
1:08:47Vlad CosteaWell, it's not my job to judge. I'm just pointing out facts, that's all.
1:08:57But basically it's interesting that the morality of the whole space is changing and some people are becoming more religious or radicalized, while others are becoming more loose and they're embracing basically what the Ethereum people were doing, but with companies that are regulated and registered and I don't know, it's very strange. It seems like all of these ideals of replacing fiat and building utopian societies and having a circular economy and whatever, they were just ways to make the number go up. And as soon as these narratives became old and they attracted the targeted number of people, they sort of moved on to something else, just to attract another group of people.
1:09:47Maybe it's a smart scheme, I don't know.
1:09:50Matt AhlborgI think you are framing it as a little bit of a dishonest thing. I don't think it's that. We all did want to build the utopian future, but then we realized that like, wow, the real world has massive incumbent network effects that are extremely hard to reverse. And so to some degree, I guess you could say there is a little bit of capitulation on that side. But I don't think that a lot of it is dishonesty. I just think it's people... learning how Bitcoin really is going to fit into the world.
1:10:29And it's not fitting in the way that they originally 100% hoped for in the most pure form. But yeah, I still think that there are lots of really amazing things happening. Like, you know, just because that hasn't caught on as a medium of exchange, me for an example, like, I hold significantly less dollars in my bank account than I would have in the parallel universe where Bitcoin didn't exist, right? That's a huge, huge thing. And I think that's true of many people, right? And so something like a huge tectonic shift is happening right now where people are starting to store value outside of the banking system.
1:11:13And that's like a very revolutionary thing. And, you know, I think I've always said that Bitcoin is something that's going to happen over centuries, I think. And it's not going to happen fast. It's going to be back and forth for a long, long time. And I've even said, like, you know, the first wave of Protestants, right? They were all totally slaughtered, right? I think that could be the first Bitcoiners too, right? Like maybe our generation, we're all going to go to prison or something. We're all going to go to prison and then 50 years from now, a new Bitcoin spring will pop up somehow when the world is much more, I don't know, much more decentralized.
1:12:01There will be no global hegemon anymore. There's just tons of little countries. That's kind of how I see it. I
1:12:08Sergej Kotliarthink it was well said, Matt. Like, you know, for me personally, the vision still lives in terms of this utopian future that you talk about. Like, that gets me to get up in the morning, what I'm working on. And even if it's a direction, like, I think that one thing is that I guess, in the olden days, we kind of viewed Bitcoin as a startup, you know, and evaluated it as like, Silicon Valley is going to do exponential like this, whereas reality is that they made the Bitcoin.
1:12:50Because of what we talked about before that, like, decentralization is costly, right? So the centralized options are always, by definition, worse than their centralized, except for that the centralized counterpart is acceptable to this particular property. But you can look at things that have caused decentralized technology to grow. You know, like, if you look at how VPN has grown over the world, like, it's not like it was a straight exponential growth curve of a startup. But rather, it's like, well, in certain countries, certain user groups, something happened that made a lot of people install VPNs.
1:13:36And that may be misrepresented, but from what I understand is that the UK requires people to have an ID to watch porn, and so a lot of people got VPNs to not have to show an ID for porn. Okay, you know, things like that, like, well, it causes a big growth in that particular country, and then in some other place, at some other time, something else happens that causes it to grow. And like that, like, gradually, it does grow decentralization and internet freedom, and many of those several point values that we're looking for.
1:14:15So I don't know, I still think that it is alive and kicking. And it's just that, yeah, some ideas, some other ideas, you know, are growing faster. And so it can frustrate us, some people that certain things are growing much faster, which is, yeah, you should, you should leverage and leverage and leverage and leverage, but actually, you're going to win in the hyperbitcoinization world. For example, like, in the marketplace of ideas, the most popular idea is the most popular idea, and we can fight it, or we cannot just figure out what to do.
1:15:03Vlad CosteaLayerTwo Labs is bringing the drivechains to Bitcoin. What does this mean? Basically, that we're going to have sidechains for every interesting use case that we see today in altcoins. For example, we can have an Ethereum sidechain to Bitcoin, which is one-to-one compatible with the smart contracts that we see on Ethereum today. We can have, for example, a Zcash sidechain, which is for fungibility. We can have a big block sidechain, which is prunable, and actually helps with scalability and low fees. And we can also have assets like Namecoin or prediction markets or pretty much everything that the crypto market can produce.
1:15:44Bitcoin will be able to just copy and pay the miners and basically have this flourishing Bitcoin economy. And you don't have to imagine what this is going to look like because the software is almost ready. You can download it for free at layer2labs.com/download. And that's where you can find pretty much the launcher, the sidechains and everything that's interesting and is currently running on the Bitcoin signet version 4, if I'm not mistaken. So check that out. It's interesting. layer2labs.com. Thank you for sponsoring. If I go to jail, I think I have a huge reading list so I can actually catch up with the books that I've been meaning to read for many years.
1:16:30There's a
1:16:31Matt Ahlborgsmall part of me that fantasizes about, yeah, if I went to jail, like I wouldn't be so distracted all the time. I can just, you know, focus on things.
1:16:41Vlad CosteaI could write books. I don't know.
1:16:46Could be fun. I mean, I've already been in jail for one year and something during the pandemic.
1:16:54Metaphorically, yeah. Your cell and your toilets and everything. In your country, it's more humane.
1:17:10Sergej KotliarIt's changing as well. Yeah, but yeah. So this PPQ thing, what can I actually do?
1:17:18Vlad CosteaOh, yeah. So I was going to get to that.
1:17:23PPQ sounds very strange.
1:17:26Matt AhlborgThat was actually Sergej's idea to call it PPQ. We were having a call. It was. You said, I was trying to think of a name for it. I'm trying to think of the old names that were really bad. It was like, I can't even think of it. But yeah, he said PPQQ and I was like, well, what's the second Q for? And he's like, I don't know. And I was like, OK, what about PPQ? And I think it's actually a really good name. It's kind of, I'm starting to say, just go PPQ it.
1:18:01I dreamed that one day my customers will also start saying it in the same way that people say, let's Google it. But yeah, I'm I'd really like to name so.
1:18:15Vlad CosteaSo what's the advantage of using this as opposed to subscribing to ChatGPT or Grok or something like that? And you have all the features. Can you talk with Ani, which I understand is the assistant that you have in the Grok app? Or can you generate Ghibli studio images that were super popular at one point?
1:18:37Matt AhlborgYeah, so the answer is mostly yes. So the advantages are that when you come to PPQ, you don't have to connect personally identifiable information such as a credit card or an email address. That's optional. If you want to use a credit card on PPQ, you can. If you want to use an email, you can. But you still get access to all of the best AI models from all of the leading companies. So we have, you know, OpenAI, Anthropic, Grok, Perplexity, et cetera, et cetera. You also have access to all the best image and video models.
1:19:15There are some exceptions to that, like when OpenAI launched that really cool Ghibli image generator, they kind of held it away. So we access it through API directly to OpenAI. They held off on publishing that for like three to four weeks. So it came, that feature came to PPQ about three or four weeks after it launched on the subscription. Yeah. And so there's also there's a lot of casual users out there who don't want to spend 20 bucks a month on something that they use every couple of days.
1:19:48We're like our average user spending about four bucks a month and they're getting, I would say, 95 percent of the features of a full ChatGPT subscription. Do we have the voice models yet? No, but it is coming soon. It is something that we it's just a matter of engineering and we're scaling up right now. So, yeah, that's that's basically it. And we have many users who say, OK, I dropped my subscription. And then we have other users who say I really value the privacy. And then we have maybe the biggest demographic of users is people who want to try out the AI from all the different companies in one place.
1:20:33Vlad CosteaYeah, I think that's really cool, because if you do want to try the premium features, you're going to be in for like a thousand dollar bill, just to be able to try everything. But with like $5, you can basically type the same query or request in all the models and see what kind of different answers you get. And that's how you assess which one is most useful for yourself.
1:20:58Matt AhlborgExactly. And yeah, we have users regularly post on like the differences between the models, especially like when it's something political, they'll say, you know, open AI gave me this answer, but Grok gave me that answer. Grok is usually the one that's like less censored, less censored than the others. But we also have open source models available on a platform as well. And they have their own kind of biases built in. That's a little bit of a misunderstanding. People think that open source means does is not censored.
1:21:29And that's, I mean, every model is censored to some degree, every model has its own bias built in. So, but the important thing is you have like, you can choose pick and choose between like a huge basket of models and find the one that works for you.
1:21:48Sergej KotliarCan you run three at once? Like one query, three answers?
1:21:53Matt AhlborgNot yet. Yeah, he told me to add that like six months ago. And there's been other customers who have asked for that. But no, we haven't done that just yet.
1:22:04Vlad CosteaI was just looking right now to see if you have Grok 4 and it's here. And you also have the latest version of ChatGPT and Claude and Gemini. And you also have the weird versions of ChatGPT like 4.1 mini nano whatever DeepSeek, which is the Chinese marvel, the one that consumes less electricity. You have Perplexity, Dolphin, Mixtral, I don't know what this is, QWQ, Llama, the one by Facebook, Nova and Nvidia Llama 3.1, Nemotron 70B Instruct. That's a mouthful.
1:22:48Matt AhlborgYeah, all these different models, like basically the way it happens is, you know, when you follow AI Twitter, every day now there's like a new hot new model that launches. And we try to integrate it as fast as possible so that we do have a lot of AI, avid AI users who like to test out the different models, particularly in the API. When they're coding in their own, like in the integrated development environment, they can plug our API key into that. And so they try different models and see which one like helps them code best.
1:23:25Vlad CosteaRight. So let's dive into the categories that you have. You have chat, you have image, video and tools. And for chat, which one is the one that you would recommend people to try? The one that impressed you the most?
1:23:42Matt AhlborgYeah, it depends on the use case. If you're coding, that's Sonnet 4, that's the by far the most popular model in the world right now for coding. There are like just in the last couple of weeks, some open source, very cheap open source versions like Kimi K2 and Qwen 3. If you're just kind of asking casual questions, you can do GPT-4. If you need information that's like based on real time data, you want to use perplexity because that one searches the internet the best.
1:24:16Although many of our models also search the internet now, perplexity is kind of known to be the one that's best at that. And actually, this is something that the question you're asking is something that we need to do better for our users, like kind of guide them to picking the best models. Or I can see in the not so distant future where we basically are choosing the model for them based on their question. And that way, they don't have to be on the cutting edge of AI knowledge to know which models are best for them.
1:24:55Vlad CosteaWhat about images and video? Do you have anything that you think is mind blowing?
1:25:01Matt AhlborgI think there's super amazing stuff happening on the video generation side. Our most popular image model is ChatGPT's Image-1. That's the one that everybody was Ghiblifying a couple months ago. The video stuff, though, is really starting to pop off, particularly the image to video models. And what people do is they'll just plug in some family photo that they have or a picture of their friend and make some sort of joke or something like that. And then that's kind of the use case there. That's what I'm doing all the time with these models.
1:25:41They're still not perfect. They take a while to render the videos, like sometimes up to five minutes, so it's not an immediate feedback thing. And they do fail still sometimes. They are censored in some cases and then doesn't give you the proper error. So it is a little bit of not a perfectly beautiful, streamlined user experience yet, but we're just beginning on that stuff. I think a year from now, you're going to see amazing media generation models out there that we can use for like 5, 10 cents.
1:26:17And it's not just videos. It's like you can do song generation. We really want to bring a podcast generator to PPQ as well. I don't know if you've ever heard there's something called Notebook LM where you can basically just take like 50 documents on a topic that you're interested in, and then it will generate like a 20-minute podcast about that topic for you, and it kind of lays it out in a much more digestible way. And I use that all the time when I want to learn about something that I'm not really familiar with.
1:26:50I will just plug that in and go for a walk and listen to that podcast. So it's really cool. And yeah, there are definitely moments where AI tools give you kind of the tingles on like this stuff is really magical in the way that it can teach you things really fast or get jobs done in ways that like three years ago would have taken you much, much longer.
1:27:23Vlad CosteaOh man, I'm going to be out of work so soon.
1:27:25Matt AhlborgI don't think so. I'm kind of a contrarian in that regard. I think that there's so much work to do that like it's going to take years for us just to get through the backlog of the things that we've always been wanting to build. And AI is going to help us finally like execute on those things. So I don't foresee massive AI unemployment in the next five years, maybe in 10 years. But yeah.
1:27:56Vlad CosteaBasically, you can get a feed that grabs the latest news and then put that into the podcast generator and you're going to replace 90% of Bitcoin podcasts today. Possibly.
1:28:11Matt AhlborgBut it's not, did we just talk about the news all day during this podcast or did we talk about like... Not this
1:28:17Vlad Costeaone. That's why you don't talk about the news because it feels so common. Yeah. I'm trying to get something that you don't find anywhere else.
1:28:26Matt AhlborgAnd that's where it's going to lead is like I think the podcasts that remain are the ones that are talking about like truly original ideas instead of just regurgitated crap.
1:28:38Vlad CosteaYeah. But it also goes like this because before a podcast there was going to be some sort of press release or article or something that gets published. And in between scheduling that podcast, you can actually get your own podcast with the voice that you prefer and the accent that you find most listenable so that you get the information before the episode even gets recorded. And then it's going to impact the overall reach that the human-made product is going to have.
1:29:11Matt AhlborgPossibly. I don't know. I still think that this stuff is only going to make us way better at delivering the products that we make rather than being replaced. That's my five-year time frame at least. So I would guess you're safe for five years at least.
1:29:29Vlad CosteaI better start saving so that I don't have to work cleaning toilets or something because maybe the AI will not do that. I don't know. But which money will the AI use? Oh, that's a good question. Is it going to be USDT and Solana?
1:29:50Sergej KotliarI think actually. Yeah. Yeah. There is something to the case — I have to sell the case — but like, that traditional online payment systems are all kind of designed to keep robots out. And if robots are going to be a bigger part of our economy, then we need to figure out ways for them to buy stuff and to pay for stuff. And actually cryptocurrency works relatively neatly for that. And so, yeah, we're experimenting with that at Bitrefill as well. We published our MCP server that is already out.
1:30:30Good enough that we had a first purchase by a robot already happened on Bitrefill that used the Lightning Network actually via the ZBD wallet to buy a gift card on Bitrefill with real money. And that's pretty cool. Like when, you know, you just tell an AI, hey, buy me this and then it goes and calls Bitrefill's MCP server and negotiates, finds the right gift card and so on. And the next steps are going to be across to provide instructions for it to also go and redeem it and to do the whole cycle.
1:31:12Vlad CosteaI was going to ask about this. Do you think you're going to build a Bitrefill GPT where basically you type what you want and it finds the best deal for you?
1:31:20Sergej KotliarYeah. I mean, that is the MCP server. It's already there. Yeah. You don't have to go to Bitrefill. You can do it eventually. Like MCP server is telling you, but like eventually it's going to be piping into your GPT. And then it's going to know that Bitrefill is the way and then it's going to say, do you want me to pay? Yes. And then it's done.
1:31:40Matt AhlborgThe key is still going to be the user interface. So is buying is a little chat box the best way to buy gift cards? Probably not. You want pictures, you want, you know, colors, stuff like that. So the layout is going to be key. And so
1:31:56Sergej Kotliaror maybe it's all audio and then it's just the voice in your head. Yeah, could be.
1:32:05Vlad CosteaWhat if you have multiple voices in your head? Are you going to buy more or are you going to buy less? I don't know, man.
1:32:13Sergej KotliarI guess you could have two different GPTs and see which one is better.
1:32:18Vlad CosteaI was going to ask Matt, there's this other service that's called Nano GPT, which sort of serves the same target audience and they actually support more privacy coins. How much of a competition is that and what's different between the two services?
1:32:35Matt AhlborgI think, yeah, Nano GPT, I would call them a direct competitor.
1:32:42Sergej KotliarI'm at 4% battery, so we got to wrap up soon.
1:32:44Yeah, they can continue without me as well. Yeah, yeah. It kind of needs to happen anyway.
1:32:48Matt AhlborgI'm at 20% myself. I'm in a conference room here. But yeah, they're a great service. I think they've executed well. I think that there are some things that we do better. We have better pricing. We just haven't gotten around to integrating the Zcash in particular or Litecoin MWEB. I mean, honestly, you can already use PPQ in a very private way. I think that there's always that argument, and I get this from Bitcoiners as well, is like, well, you're not perfectly private yet, so you should spend 90% of your engineering time making it perfectly private as opposed to bring me more AI tools.
1:33:31That's kind of our thing. I would much rather just continue keeping up with all of the new AI stuff and keeping our service from a privacy standpoint quite good, instead of really implementing everything to the T and making it perfectly private. It's hard to do. It doesn't start with just integrating privacy coins. There's many different layers of privacy that you can engineer into such a platform. I
1:34:03Vlad Costeawas also going to ask about this because right now the privacy concerns the payment method, which even if you pay with BTC, which is traceable, there is no way to prove that it came from you unless you're withdrawing from a KYC exchange. And once again, you don't have that information. You don't know exactly where it comes from. And let's say that I pay very privately with Monero or something, but I upload a picture of myself to turn it into some sort of video. Are you going to keep that picture?
1:34:37Are you going to be able to tell that it's me or where does the picture actually go? Does it go to the AI model?
1:34:45Matt AhlborgSo it goes through our servers and we're promising that we're not storing that on our servers, but we're not proving that we are not storing it on our servers. And then it goes on to our AI provider. Where are that image that you uploaded will sit on our AI provider for, I think it depends on the policy, but up to seven days, something like that. So the image sits with them as the input and the output image, but according to our promise, it's not sitting with us.
1:35:17And so that's the trade-off you have to make, or that's the consideration you have to make.
1:35:23Vlad CosteaBut if you go directly to open AI or Grok or something like this, I think they store the information for much longer, right?
1:35:31Matt AhlborgAnd they're attaching it to your PII because you signed up with a credit card in your email. So they're saying here's Vlad's picture. And we know this to be 100% true because he registered with his credit card in his email. And that's the thing that happened in the last couple of weeks is Sam Altman came out and he said, just so our users know, your ChatGPT chats can be used against you in a court of law if they are subpoenaed for. And that's like really crazy.
1:36:02It's a huge violation. I hope it's a big red flag to not just privacy people, but that's, I mean, we are all telling our deepest secrets to AI. And I hope that such a thing will be reversed in the near future. Um, but yeah, when you use PPQ for this, uh, you, you are, I believe reducing that risk by 99% because you're not connecting your PII when you use our platform.
1:36:33Vlad CosteaThere's also something else that Sam Altman said, and I think Grok 4 already has, which is that the AI knows your previous queries and it can profile you and it gets to know you better according to what you're typing and what kind of information you're requesting. And it has more context about what is interesting to you to tailor the answers in a way that maybe is gonna be better. I don't know. Personally, I always hope I start a new chat every time I want to ask a different question and I'm not sure how that is, but my question that I'm going to ask right now is, are you going to include that feature or can that be included in a service that tries to offer privacy?
1:37:22Matt AhlborgI think so the, the feature you're talking about is what's called memory. And that is something that we will eventually also provide probably as an option. It's a little check box that you would click. Probably it's automatically clicked on. And the memory is basically what it does is it just summarizes all, all of your questions across all of your chats. And it creates this one pager summary of what type of person you are and what question you're asking. And it tailors all the future answers to make the responses better.
1:37:56And that is a good thing. That is a nice feature to have. It does reduce privacy to some degree. But when you use a service like ours, again, versus a service like a subscription directly with the providers, when all of our users are running queries through us, Sergej's about to lose his battery here.
1:38:20When you, all of our queries collectively from all of our users are being routed to the direct providers. And so there is no, it would be extremely hard for them to profile our users on like a individual basis because we just seem like one super user from the perspective of the big AI company. Now, again, when we integrate some sort of memory feature, maybe we can do it entirely client side where you'll have a little one pager summary of all of your previous questions stored on the client side in your local storage.
1:38:56So we, we might not ever even store that type of thing. We haven't really soaked it out yet, but yeah, rest assured when we do, like we, we are very aware that like a huge chunk of our users are privacy oriented. So we're going to do it in a way that makes them happy while they're still gaining the conveniences of such a thing.
1:39:19Vlad CosteaSergej, before your battery gets drained completely, what's the future of BitRefill?
1:39:26Matt AhlborgBoy, that's a big question. In one sentence.
1:39:30Sergej KotliarLiterally, the future is a world in which a wallet in every pocket and we unlock the wallet to be used every day by everyone to buy things online that they couldn't otherwise do. Yeah, that's a big vision and that's what we're working to. And on that, I think you guys should continue talking about PPQ and AI.
1:39:56Vlad CosteaThanks, Sergej. Thank you very much.
1:39:58Sergej KotliarThank you so much, guys.
1:39:59Vlad CosteaHave a nice rest of your day.
1:40:00Sergej KotliarYou too.
1:40:03Vlad CosteaIt's always a pleasure to have Sergej on. Unfortunately, his battery died. And you said, Matt, that you still have 20% or maybe it's 15 by now.
1:40:18Matt AhlborgYeah, 17. But I don't mind wrapping it up now. And I also would, you know, if you have other questions, I'd love to talk AI with you and anything else.
1:40:29Vlad CosteaWhy did you choose of all the businesses you could start? Why did you choose to get into intermediating AI access? Is it such a large business right now? Like, do you make a lot of money from it or it's still neat?
1:40:45Matt AhlborgI mean, it's still very niche, but I mean, we are doing well, we're growing. We recently attained some investment from a couple of venture capital companies, so we're doing well in that respect. But I mean, why did I choose it? To me, I worked a Bitrefill for five-ish years and I just wanted to finally build something on my own. I felt like on my own personal quest in life, that was a check that I wanted to, a box that I wanted to check off. So I actually iterated through a couple of other kind of, I tried to put together like a Bitcoin remittance app for like three or four months that never really got past the MVP phase.
1:41:26I built a little personal finance calculator that is still, it was a cool thing, but I just kind of for business reasons felt like that would be very hard for me to compete with a lot of the other personal finance apps. And then yeah, the idea of AI came along and I was never any super AI expert going into it, but I know that I'm kind of a technological person. So I knew that I was definitely going to be using AI on an increasing basis. And so I thought, yeah, this would be a great idea to build this product.
1:42:04I actually originally pitched it to Bitrefill to Sergej and he has a lot of different fires going on at any given time. And he just said, no, not right now, not for me. And so I said, okay, well, I'm going to go build it on my own. And that's what happened. And so, yeah, we're, I think, like a year and a half in now with an actual live product. And yeah.
1:42:32Vlad CosteaDo you see gradual growth in terms of demand for your service or are there just spikes when there's a new trend and people want to try a new model and then they drop out?
1:42:43Matt AhlborgIt's both. I think that we really benefit from like the DeepSeek moment that happened in late January. I believe it was when that model came out and it was all over the news for a couple of weeks. Like the fact that we had that on our platform, we just tweeted about it. We said, you know, that that model that you heard about, come and try it on PPQ, you know, deposit 10 cents as low as little as 10 cents. And you can try it out. That gained us a lot of users and a lot of them did drop off.
1:43:13But we've still been steadily growing in terms of daily active users for our entire history. We have hundreds of daily active users now, not thousands. But, you know, we'll get there. I think the reasons that we lose users, they really have nothing to do with the power of AI. It's we lose users because we have bugs. We lose users because we, you know, don't offer the full ChatGPT experience, although we're now getting very close. But like in our early days, you know, we didn't have document upload.
1:43:50We didn't have a paste-in-your-image-here type thing. So those are extremely basic features. You know, that's why we were losing users. But as we continue polishing, like, I don't see a lot of reasons why we will lose users in the future. I think the idea of PPQ, all the best AIs in one place, it's actually really powerful. And I think it is going to take us a long way.
1:44:18Vlad CosteaI remember two years ago, I wrote a magazine which I called Breaking FUD. At the time, I was thinking it's like the ultimate bear market product with basically all the arguments against Bitcoin being debunked. And I used ChatGPT to get the answers, like what are the biggest threats to Bitcoin? And then I used my human knowledge and ability to debunk those claims. And I've also used Midjourney to generate the graphics. I think it was one of the first products like this that got released. And now it's open source.
1:44:53You can find that on the Bitcoin takeover website. But where I'm coming with this is that Midjourney was a very big deal at the time. I think it was the most advanced image generation tool with AI. I'm not sure if it's still as big, but I did see that they launched some video features and I don't see it on the PPQ.AI page. And I was wondering, why don't you have Midjourney?
1:45:19Matt AhlborgSo Midjourney is one of the very few holdouts in the media generation space that still insist on a subscription from their users. So they actually don't provide Midjourney through API. There are other services out there who are kind of unofficially supporting Midjourney. But we don't I don't know, maybe that's something we could do. But I would want to talk to kind of a lawyer first to make sure that we would not get sued. But that's the main reason is some companies are still trying to lock their users into subscriptions and they feel that that's the best way that they're going to make money.
1:45:58But most of the media generation companies out there have capitulated where they I've seen it happen already in this year and a half. Where they started off as pure subscription and then they figured out that like, wait, this little media thing that we do, it's too niche to get a subscription from a regular casual user. And so, OK, now we have to start offering it via API where services like PPQ come along and offer it into like a broader product suite. And that's kind of where I believe this is all going.
1:46:30I think that Midjourney is very likely to head in that direction as well eventually. But they do still have that kind of brand power where they can get away with doing subscription only. And they're still one of the leading media generators. I personally feel that Gemini and ChatGPT Image-1, they do just as good as Midjourney. But Midjourney still has a lot of the brand power, so people believe that they are like the cutting edge state of the art. And yeah, that's that's kind of how they're positioning themselves right now.
1:47:09Vlad CosteaAlso wanted to ask you about Venice.ai, which is a computing service. It's being promoted a lot by Eric Voorhees, who I think is one of the founders. They offer some open source models for free. And basically you don't need to pay anything, but you have a limited number of queries per day. And they also offer paid access to the premium models. And I think they also have a token of their own that you can use to pay for the service or else get discounts on your payments.
1:47:43So I was wondering what you think about it and how is PPQ.ai different?
1:47:48Matt AhlborgYeah, I mean, I don't want to hate on Venice too much, but I do think that it's a lot of marketing fluff around what they do. I believe they're still doing subscriptions only. So that's, I guess, my first gripe with them is why I think as a as a I think subscriptions are super lame and we should be getting away from them. Then the other, I guess, big problem with Venice as I see it is they do have those open source models and they're not as powerful as a lot of the proprietary ones from big AI.
1:48:26I don't think they have a good conversational AI where you can ask daily questions and stuff like that and get pretty censorship free answers from. But I don't think they have like any open source model that's really good at coding or anything like that, which is mainly our core user. There's a lot of developer focused people.
1:48:54And then, yeah, the whole thing of like, you know, they created their own shitcoin from it. And yeah, I just I don't know. To me, it feels like I feel like I am venturing into the hating area, but it feels like they don't believe in their product enough. They just could just like build a build the product without launching some token or something like that.
1:49:20Vlad CosteaYeah, you're right. It seems like they offer subscriptions for like twenty dollars per month and they give unlimited access to all the models. But my main gripe right now with it is that you have to sign up with Wallet Connect or Coinbase or Discord, Google account or Apple ID. Basically, you can't have an anonymous. I think you can have it with Discord maybe if you create just a random disposable account. But it's not as private as ppq.ai where you just go there. And I think it assigns you an account based on your IP address and it gets stored locally.
1:50:02Matt AhlborgIt's not even based on there. We we traditionally collected full user agent string, but we're not even storing IP addresses anymore. So we just store the country code and such.
1:50:16But yeah, that's I don't. I won't say it's more private than Venice. There are different layers of the privacy that are going on, but I do think that Venice, again, they over marketed the privacy aspect of their service, and it's not as private as they make it out to be. Not only the issue that you're talking about where you have to link your wallet or whatever, but also you have to trust that they are not logging the user queries. This is all on a trust basis. And Eric Wall posted a nice tweet on this about how we just have to trust that they're not logging everything in the background, where really there is a technical way you could build a Venice AI where all of the user queries were provably going to a proxy service that was provably inaccessible to the employees at Venice.
1:51:21That could be built out, but it's hard to do engineering wise. But I would respect a company more if they actually did do that, and then they can make all the privacy promises. But PPQ, we're not trying to pretend that that's why I was very explicit when I said we're promising that we're not logging, but we're not proving that to you. And so, yeah, there are, I believe, some issues there with the marketing on Venice. It's not as private as they make it out to be.
1:52:03Vlad CosteaLet's go back to PPQ. What is your short pitch for people who have been listening and maybe they didn't get the essence of the service? Like, how would you phrase this if you met someone in the elevator or you had like 30 seconds to explain to someone what this is and why they should try it right now?
1:52:21Matt AhlborgYeah, PPQ is a place where you can try all the latest and greatest AI models in one place. You can deposit as little as 10 cents in trying this stuff out. There's no subscriptions. You don't have to connect your email or your credit card if you don't want to. And so it's very private in that respect. And so, you know, why wouldn't you try out a service like that as opposed to committing to something with a higher upfront cost where you're connecting all of your identifying information, et cetera?
1:52:54To me, I believe it's an easy decision. It's just a matter of making people more aware of what PPQ is.
1:53:04Vlad CosteaI see that you also have invite codes with 10% referrals. So basically, if you are bringing more people into the system, you get 10% of what they're putting in terms of paying for queries. So if they put $100, I get 10.
1:53:21Matt AhlborgIf somebody puts in $100, you'll get 10% of how much they're spending. So it might take a while for them to spend through that $100. Yeah. But yes, that's true.
1:53:34Vlad CosteaWell, that's interesting. I might try this and get some free queries. If my listeners are using my link, maybe I will put that in the description. Is there anything that we haven't mentioned about this?
1:53:48Matt AhlborgNo, I mean, I had a great conversation. I think it was, I enjoyed it, the discussion. And I hope the audience did as well.
1:53:58Vlad CosteaWhere can people follow you on the project, which is PPQ.AI?
1:54:03Matt AhlborgYep. So it's really easy. PPQ.ai is our website. We also have a Twitter handle. It's PPQDOTAI on Twitter. And then on Nostr, you can find us as well. Just search in PPQ if the Nostr search works. Sometimes it doesn't. And yeah, I would say the most engagement that we have is over on Nostr. It's been really good to us. So yeah, that's where most of the lively discussion is happening.
1:54:35Vlad CosteaOkay, Matt, thank you very much. I'll let you go before your battery dies. And thank you very much for your time.
1:54:43Matt AhlborgThank you, Vlad. Appreciate it. Take care.