Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S16 E42 / Transcript
Transcript · S16 E42 · 2:36:50 · 9 Sept 2025

S16 E42: Michael Tidwell on Bitcoin Drama & TABConf

With Michael Tidwell. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:47Vlad CosteaWelcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 42, and we are live with Michael Tidwell, who is best known for organizing TABConf, the longest-running technical Bitcoin conference. And also, this episode is sponsored by SideShift, Citrea, LayerTwo Labs, Bitcoin.com News, NoOnes.com, and I think that's it. Thank you very much for being here, Michael. And we're going to talk about some Bitcoin drama. You have this roulette thing behind you. And I have some chocolate eggs in which I put some tickets. Basically, the gimmick of this episode is that we're going to talk about some Bitcoin drama that's happening.

1:25I ask you, who is to blame? And you ask me, who is the solution? The answer for who is to blame is on the wheel behind you. The solution is in one of these eight eggs that I stacked in this bowl, and I'm going to pick one randomly. And really, you have to trust me that this is random because I can rig it, I think, but I don't want to.

1:50Michael TidwellYeah, it's not like the eggs are clear or anything where you can see the little paper sheets inside of them. I mean, they're, you know, all folded up and stuff. So hey, good to be on the show.

2:00Thanks for having me.

2:02Vlad CosteaIt's not like I can't put some random pen marks or whatever on them.

2:06Michael TidwellSo I mean, I trust you. I trust that it's going to be random.

2:11Vlad CosteaI'm sure I trust your wheels as well that you didn't put some weights on it.

2:15Michael TidwellExactly. Everything. You know, what do we even need cryptography? I mean, come on. We have all this trust going on. I think we were inventing something new right here on the pod.

2:26Vlad CosteaSure. I've seen you use the wheel with Rob during one of your podcasts. By the way, you also do what's it called the Blocktime show?

2:37Michael TidwellIt is Blocktime podcast. This is the Blocktime wheel of destiny.

2:45Vlad CosteaAnd I've seen you do this. We're in a situation where it was always landing on you're a spook. And I thought that was so funny.

2:56Michael TidwellThanks. Thanks for enjoying the subtle humor that we put into the last episode. I think it's not for everyone. There's a few people that watched the episode and said, I don't get it. And then there's a few people said that was hilarious. So, you know, it doesn't it doesn't appeal to everyone. But, you know, glad some people liked it.

3:14Vlad CosteaRight. So let's start with the first question, which concerns what's going on. What's happening right now with Bitcoin Core versus Knots. Knots being basically a carbon copy of Bitcoin Core with some changes by Luke Jr.

3:31Michael TidwellYeah. Do we do we discuss it first or we just spin the wheel? What do you want to do?

3:35Vlad CosteaJust for demonstration purposes, let's spin the wheel and find out who is to blame and what is the solution. And then we can talk.

3:47Michael TidwellAround and round it goes where we'll stop. No one knows. Drum roll.

3:51My my my youngest child is like really fascinated with what's going on right now. OK.

4:04All right. Who are we blaming? We are blaming, of course, the plebs. It's obviously the plebs fault. Oh, no.

4:13Vlad CosteaOh, no. The plebs. We sound like Dan Held right now.

4:16Michael TidwellI mean, it's if we just didn't have those damn plebs getting in the way, getting manipulated so easily. I mean, we would we wouldn't have this problem.

4:26Vlad CosteaI think their IQ is no higher than 80. And they also got educated by midwits like Peter McCormack and Giacomo Zucco or whatever.

4:39Michael TidwellYeah. Is Giacomo considered a midwit? What is what's the midwit range? Is it like 100?

4:46Vlad CosteaThat's a good question. I do like how you basically confirm that McCormack is a midwit.

4:53Michael TidwellYeah. So is it like if you're just a little above average, you're probably like a midwit?

5:01Vlad CosteaHello. Not the first time we have a kid on the show, but the first time a kid shows his face.

5:09Michael TidwellIt's I mean, this doesn't I tell them this is work and they don't believe me. So it's like, you know, what are you going to do?

5:17Vlad CosteaHe's not a pleb, is he?

5:26Right. So for the people who are listening to this on Spotify, Michael just went to another room basically to take...

5:35Michael TidwellOkay, I'm back.

5:37Vlad CosteaLet me pick an egg. So I'm just going to touch multiples. I couldn't find a larger vase that's transparent. And I had to shop for chocolate and toy cars to be able to get this. And it's too large for my bowl. So basically just tell me... I'm going to close my eyes and tell me when to stop on one of these. Just say stop.

5:56I'm going to take that one out.

6:00Michael TidwellI don't know if I ever want to tell you to stop. This is great. You're just fumbling around with these balls and...

6:09Vlad CosteaThey do feel nice.

6:11Michael TidwellOkay, stop.

6:15Vlad CosteaIt's this one. So on the issue of Bitcoin Core versus Bitcoin Knots, the people who are to blame are the plebs. But here we have the solution, which is use tabs.

6:36Can you see this? Does it focus?

6:38Michael TidwellI see it. I think I understand what this means.

6:44Vlad CosteaIt does require some context. So if you could explain what this is about, it goes back to the scaling debate 2017 scaling Bitcoin.

6:57Michael TidwellYeah, why don't why don't you kick this one off and I'll I'll follow suit.

7:02Vlad CosteaRight. So there was a question from Aaron van Wirdum, who right now is the editor in chief of Bitcoin Magazine, and he asked Adam Back was on stage. I think it was scaling Bitcoin, if I'm not mistaken. There's a YouTube video of it. And big blockers have been using that for many years. Basically, Aaron asked Adam Back, what should users do to avoid high fees in that environment until Lightning gets shipped or we get the proper sidechain or whatever? And Adam Back famously replied, use tabs. And in this case, use tabs basically means to avoid using the base layer to basically use some other type of accounting and only settle transactions after it's clear that you really have to send a larger amount or you are done engaging in economic activity with that person.

8:00It's like entering a bar. And instead of paying for every drink that you're buying, there's going to be a tab or just eating at a restaurant, right? Because you eat at the restaurant and you pay at the end. You don't pay for every individual item. And that was the idea of Adam Back, who basically implied that you should not be using Bitcoin.

8:20Michael TidwellSo the first person to make fun of me for the name TABConf was like in terms of this story was Paul Sztorc. And he thought it was very funny that I called the conference TABConf without knowing this backstory ahead of time. So that's how I originally learned about the story was getting razzed by Paul.

8:43Vlad CosteaWe both like Paul, I guess, right?

8:46Michael TidwellPaul is lovely. Yes, I like Paul very much.

8:49Vlad CosteaWhich is funny because I got to meet Paul and the very nerdy and lovely side of him. But I did ask a couple of people and they said, oh, he's so arrogant. He's so narcissistic, so self-absorbed. I'm like, I guess you haven't really met him.

9:07Michael TidwellYeah, that's what happens when so maybe all those things are true and maybe they're not. But like, from my experience with Paul, it's been very positive. And when he became a pariah in society, and then people didn't know who he was, he only has this one perception of just being like a total asshole on Twitter. Or, you know, also on podcasts. But I think it's, he's sort of taking the approach of he has to be like over the top to even get people to start talking about important stuff.

9:39So I think that's like his strategy, more or less.

9:43Vlad CosteaAnd it must be very difficult being him because he was right in some regards, and he was ahead of his time. And right now, I think he's just waiting for the right time for his idea to happen in some way.

9:58Michael TidwellYeah, there's there's a bit of like. He kind of knows he's right about certain things, so he's had like years and years and years of built up sort of, you know, calcification and hardening against like some of these topics. So when they come up, he is doesn't really have time to be nice about them, I guess is what's happening. I don't know.

10:22Vlad CosteaIs Paul a pleb?

10:26Michael TidwellI mean, I gotta be honest, I don't even really know what a pleb is.

10:30Vlad CosteaThat was going to be the follow up.

10:34What's a pleb?

10:35Michael TidwellI don't fucking know. I don't even think plebs are real. I think they're like birds.

10:42Vlad CosteaOh, birds aren't real.

10:44Michael TidwellI think like plebs aren't real. Either we're all plebs or like we're not plebs or pleb is just like someone who doesn't know what they're talking about or pleb is just someone new that isn't technical. Like, pleb means so many different things. Even like Jeremy Rubin runs PlebFi and it's like very well educated technical people that attend this conference. And it's like, okay, are plebs just like people who aren't like world, you know, world renowned. They're not like popular, but they're really doing things behind the scenes.

11:17They're actually very technical, very competent. Like maybe that's a pleb. Maybe pleb is just like someone who is trying to make a difference in their own way. Like running like a Bitaxe or something like, I don't know what a pleb is.

11:31Vlad CosteaIt's a marketing term that I can tell.

11:34I was part of lots of pleb Telegram chats. I was part of pleb Twitter chats. I interviewed people who call themselves plebs in season three of this show. And that was six years ago. What was really interesting is that after the scaling debate, when I guess the 2017 generation of Bitcoiners came along, they tried to find their own place and they sort of figured out that it's a pleb. It's harder for them to accumulate as much Bitcoin as the OGs. So this new term of the pleb came along and it goes back to a very simple philosophy of just being humble and buying more Bitcoin and making fun of shitcoiners.

12:23And that's kind of the pleb philosophy. Yeah.

12:29Michael TidwellI mean, we're, we're, we're going to get into like, what is a Bitcoiner after this, right?

12:33Vlad CosteaOf course we have to get to that point too. And then we get to what is Bitcoin. Then we get to...

12:40Michael TidwellYeah. Then, then what is it? What is the id? What is, you know, we start getting, this just becomes a philosophical show at that point.

12:48Always has been.

12:49Vlad CosteaAlways has been. Anyway, I think the best definition of a pleb or the representation of a pleb is Hodlonaut. He's like the king of plebs.

13:07Speaks his own mind, says whatever he wants, gets sued and then goes through this David versus Goliath type of battle with Craig Wright.

13:20It is a nice story. Too bad he blocked me.

13:23Michael TidwellThat's the cat in the spacesuit, right?

13:26Vlad CosteaOh, you don't know Hodlonaut?

13:28Michael TidwellI don't think I've ever met him. Is he, is he anonymous or is he just a Twitter person?

13:34Vlad CosteaI did meet him in person in 2019 at the Lightning Conference. So he is a real person. Very nice guy in person. Not so nice on the internet.

13:48Michael TidwellYeah, I do remember. I think, so I think I follow him. What's his, what's his handle? Hodl...

14:00Vlad CosteaHodl, O-N-A-U-T.

14:08Michael TidwellOkay. Yeah, we actually follow each other. Man, this guy's good. This guy's popular. 150K followers.

14:16Vlad CosteaAnd he says whatever is popular. That's why he is popular.

14:20Michael TidwellYeah. Well, I would say that I don't... I think I've only ever seen one thing that he said that I might disagree with, and it might have been about drivechains. I can't even remember. But most of the things that he talks about, I pretty much... I'm on the same page with. I don't really think he's ever said anything that has, like, I just turned my head sideways, because there's a lot of people I respect in the space that think drivechain is a bad idea. I can't remember if Hodlonaut is one of them. I think he is, because he's like the poster boy advocate for the Lightning Network.

14:48Vlad CosteaAs he started... So why he initially became famous is that he started the Lightning Torch back in 2018.

15:01Michael TidwellYeah, that was... that got really popular. Yep.

15:07Vlad CosteaAnd people started tracking how many hops it goes through to which countries it goes and also whether or not people run their own nodes or use custodial wallets. That was another interesting study. And yeah, so, you know what's funny about the whole story of the Lightning Torch? That if you if you go to the website that monitors what happened and to whom it went and who stole the torch and blah, blah, you're gonna see that Peter McCormack received the torch on his own node. And then like six months later or a year later, he tweeted famously that he never ran a node and he doesn't know what that is.

15:51Michael TidwellYeah. I don't I don't know. I mean, Peter McCormack has a whole can of worms. Let's stop. Let me ask you what? Why did Hodlonaut block you? He seems like a nice cat in a spacesuit. Why did he, why did he block you? What did you do?

16:05Vlad CosteaI interviewed Roger Ver last year.

16:07Michael TidwellOh, that's it? Just the fact that you interviewed him?

16:10Vlad CosteaHe became very angry and started making fun of me and underwent this interesting campaign of character assassination. Like, if you search "Hodlonaut" and "Vlad," you're gonna see basically everything that he said about me. At one point I even told him, you know, maybe you should share the revenue that you're making this month from Twitter, because you're milking my name and got a lot of people to also block me and unfollow me.

16:39Michael TidwellOh, Lord.

16:40Vlad CosteaHe saw the fact that I interviewed Roger Ver as some sort of betrayal. Oh no, I stepped into the territory which is haram or something.

16:52Michael TidwellOh my gosh, Vlad. I am... You be... I didn't realize how bad it got. Geez.

16:58Vlad CosteaOh, you found the tweets?

16:59Michael TidwellNo, I just did... I'm listening to you. It's just... That sounds terrible.

17:04Vlad CosteaNo, the tweets are even worse.

17:07Michael TidwellAll right. Well, you're gonna make me want to look them up. Geez.

17:10Vlad CosteaThe worst part is that I know the guy in real life. I donated money to his legal defense. And I don't feel like I should escape scrutiny, or I shouldn't... he shouldn't disagree with me just because I was nice to him. But he could give me the benefit of the doubt and be like, "We can agree to disagree" or something. But instead, he went full-on social justice warrior with me.

17:34Michael Tidwell"Vlad rages at the dishonesty and malice of NVK, Dorsey, Saifedean, Richard, Retard..." What? I don't know what that name is. "...and Saylor, while praising the virtues and values of Roger Ver and helping him sell his book and try to rewrite history and whitewash his reputation. Get real or GTFO, the truth will wipe you out." Hey, you know who else sort of pumped Roger Ver's book, which was kind of interesting. Oh man, I hope I don't get this person wrong. I believe it was James O'Beirne but I I really don't want to get that wrong.

18:13Vlad CosteaWell, he was on my show like three months ago and he was advocating for bigger blocks.

18:18Michael TidwellYeah. Okay. Then it was probably James. So James is someone I respect quite a bit, and he's the other person that I think has ever said that that's been a good book. Are you trying to say that Roger Ver wrote a good book?

18:29Vlad CosteaIt's not that bad, honestly. I've actually read it.

18:32Michael TidwellYeah. James was pretty much...

18:33Vlad CosteaHave you read Hijacking Bitcoin?

18:35Michael TidwellI don't know how to read. I don't read books. I listen to audiobooks and I work on code when I can, but I really respect people who can read. I think it's a valuable skill to have.

18:53Vlad CosteaOkay, that's fair. So you are saying something about James O'Beirne?

19:01Michael TidwellYeah, I thought it was interesting. I think James tried to say, like, there are going to be some things that are super biased that he disagreed with in the book, and don't let that pretty much distract you from some other messages in the book. I thought that was an interesting take that he just pretty much went to. I think it was Bitcoin++ or... I don't remember where he said this. I...

19:20Vlad CosteaI think it was OP_NEXT.

19:22Michael TidwellOP_NEXT, then. Yeah. Oh yeah, that's right. It was OP_NEXT. Yeah. I have a very good memory when it comes to this stuff.

19:33Yeah, I remember the who... I don't remember the where. The who and the what, not the where. Anywho, so you... Roger Ver, obviously, you know, Hodlonaut hates this person, or he just dislikes this person greatly. You interview him and talk positively about him, and that was it?

19:59Vlad CosteaI'm not even sure if I talked positively about him. The most positive thing I ever said was that he did a lot of nice stuff for Bitcoin and I want him to come back. But I did ask him all the hard questions about, for example, being involved in Bitcoin Cash for half of his journey and losing money, losing friends, getting sued, getting into a lot of ugly situations, you know, going from hero to villain.

20:31Michael TidwellYeah. What do you say?

20:33Vlad CosteaThat was part of the conversation. Well, it's in the spirit of open source to create forks and disagree and see what the market thinks about stuff. Like he's a hardcore libertarian and I've met him in person twice after the interview. And I I think honestly the worst part about Hodlonaut and there was someone else, I don't recall their name, Jefferson something. Anyway, they were accusing me of having been paid by Roger for the interview. They were saying, well, Roger needed to sell the book. He did a bunch of interviews that week, like six or seven. And one of them was on my show. And for some reason, my interview ended up being the most popular of all of them. And everyone saw mine and they're like, oh, Roger's back and Vlad brought him back and he got paid for this and like, guys, you're crazy.

21:25But nobody wanted to believe me, they said, there is no way you can actually prove. And I think the worst part, no, the reason why Hodlonaut blocked me is that at one point I said, you know, I can actually sue you because you made claims which are provably untrue about myself and I can prove I never got paid. I have all the messages, I have, you know, transaction IDs and bank accounts, whatever. I can prove to you that there was no payment whatsoever from Roger. And people were saying well there's no proof that you cannot receive a future payment from him like after you do all of this free promotion he can still give you some money, and I was like, I I can't win.

22:03Michael TidwellYou can't win against people who are willing to, you know, argue like that. That's an unbeatable argument. So you got trapped there. So if it makes any difference, Vlad, I believe you. All right. What's... what do you want to talk about next? Maybe this is...

22:24Vlad CosteaI don't think we actually got into the Knots versus Core conversation. But let me plug a couple of sponsors before we get to that. Let me tease the plebs. Actually, I don't think I have any plebs listening to this, and it was actually opcode.network who said, "Beware: watching the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast lowers your IQ by 20 points per episode." So if you watch like seven of them, you're gonna go negative. Best advertisement ever. So let me start with LayerTwo Labs, because we did discuss drivechains, and the advertisement for LayerTwo Labs is basically that you can try the software today. You don't have to just listen to podcasts and listen to Paul talking at conferences and listen to what others say about drivechains. You can just go to layertwolabs.com/download. There you're going to find the drivechains launcher, which is working on macOS and Windows and Linux.

23:25You download that one and then you can access on the Bitcoin Signet, a bunch of side chains that emulate the features of Ethereum and Zcash and Namecoin, and there's also something else. Oh yeah, a big block version of Bitcoin. That that one's gonna be fun. It's called Thunder And yeah, layertwolabs.com/download that's where you find the software. It can be a fun weekend project for you to try this and if you need some testnet coins I think it's Signet, not Testnet. But anyway, if you need some coins, go to the Drivechain Talk Telegram channel and someone will send you some. So you can actually send some transactions to people and have fun with this and discover what the potential of this technology really is.

24:16And there's also Citrea, which is actually launching later this year. Basically, if you like Ethereum, secretly or openly, it doesn't matter. You're gonna love Citrea because it uses the security of Bitcoin to bring some of the same features. And there are some contracts that can be ported one-to-one directly from Ethereum. I think the target for Citrea is the 100k WBTC that's locked on Ethereum right now to bring that to a Bitcoin layer. I can see you're not happy with Citrea Michael. I'm gonna let you talk about it. What else is there to say? They're the first optimistically verified ZK rollup on Bitcoin. And previously they needed some kind of covenant software to work, but they were able to figure out how to launch without it.

25:06And yeah, they're possibly the first ZK rollup implementation that's gonna launch this year. Alpen Labs, since they discovered their new Glock implementation, they seem to be in delay mode. And I think if we have like four of these ZK rollups operating on chain, we're gonna end up having another scaling debate. So that's gonna be a lot of fun. Because they use Bitcoin as the data availability layer. They put ZK proofs on the Bitcoin blockchain as inscriptions or OP_RETURN, and that's gonna be a lot of fun.

25:50Michael TidwellMan, you got a lot of sponsors, man.

25:54Vlad CosteaI know. I sold out.

25:56Michael TidwellYeah, you sold out. You're doing all the most hated sponsors. Like, no wonder. I'm guessing Giacomo is a big fan of this podcast.

26:06Vlad CosteaHe was on the show like four times, and he blocked me since last year. So yeah.

26:18Michael TidwellThat's so funny that he'd go on your show four times. How many... is this my first time on your show, though? It is? Yeah. All right. Well, maybe this is what happens: people come on your show and then they block you afterwards. I mean, it's...

26:32Vlad CosteaThis is how you actually interact with me as a person, as opposed to a Twitter avatar. And well, once you figure out what I'm into and what I actually think, you're gonna be like, "Oh, I thought this guy was based. He was tweeting such nice memes" or whatever.

26:51Michael TidwellYeah. The... how do you pronounce that BitVM sidechain rollup thing? Is it Citrea? Citria? How do you say it?

27:00Vlad CosteaOh, it's Citrea.

27:02Michael TidwellCitrea. Okay. I've been always in my head calling it Citria.

27:05Vlad CosteaI don't think it matters how you call it. I think that the biggest challenge is to actually get users for this, because it sounds nice. Basically, they're bringing Ethereum borrowing and lending and DeFi stuff to Bitcoin. The question is, will Bitcoiners care?

27:25Michael TidwellYeah, I mean, did Bitcoiners care about Liquid is a question as well. Because if you take away the trust model, the one-of-n sort of exit model, is that even interesting enough to not just run something like a Liquid-type federation, right?

27:47Vlad CosteaWell, Liquid is a federation. It's not a proper sidechain and Blockstream sort of half-assed their promise. They launched this nice white paper in 2014 and said they're gonna offer the two-way pegged sidechain and they never actually followed through. They gave up and they launched the Federation and they have plenty of excuses for it. The funniest one actually is from Andrew Poelstra who was on the show last month and what he said is that there's this article by Vitalik where he explains that he can deploy a smart contract on Ethereum which gives bounty to people who reorg Bitcoin. So basically Ethereum becomes this layer of bribing miners into acting against their incentives on Bitcoin.

28:44So I I think the security model for the two-way pegged sidechain by Blockstream was to basically bet that there's not gonna be any 100 block reorg. In the case of drivechains it's, what does Paul say, 13,000 blocks, I think

29:06Michael TidwellSome very large amount of blocks, but. Okay. So the, the point I was trying to make isn't necessarily, the specific implementation of Liquid, but a Liquid-like federation, like an idea of a just a threshold Federation, trusted setup sort of idea, like is is the potential interest in BitVM going to be that it's not doing that as in terms of like the the exit model outside of that, you know, rollup sidechain. So that's that's what I'm wondering, are people going to care about that? Or are they going to care that when you get to that sidechain, you're going to be able to do all this Ethereum stuff?

29:52Vlad CosteaWell, that that's a very good question. But I think it's a huge opportunity for these swapping services to make a lot of money. To be honest because even in the case of Liquid and Lightning, there's a lot of activity from these swapping services that take a fee for, I I don't even think they perform the channel closing or the peg out. They just have liquidity on both sides and they let you get in and out for a fee.

30:21Michael TidwellRight but like arguably you could have other sort of trust models that allow you to do all those things once you're in said system, said sidechain So like, is it going to be like the technology? Is it just going to be the user experience? Like, you know, what will be like the driving sort of thing? Is it just going to be like philosophically? This is like a good model and like it's interesting. So people are going to like delve into it more. Like it's more sexy, right? Because it's more like quote unquote decentralized. Like what, what I'm curious on, you know, what the, what the potential motivation is going to be, you know I mean?

31:03Vlad CosteaWell, if you ask Citrea they're gonna say that inheriting the security of Bitcoin is one big advantage. And I agree with this because WBTC on Ethereum is custodied by BitGo. And that there's a trusted setup on top of a trusted setup. So in their case, it's gonna be more trust minimized. I think that's primarily the reason why they launched. And also they can have all of these cool apps that already exist on Ethereum, like decentralized market makers and decentralized exchanges. They can have their own version of prediction markets and Uniswap and everything.

31:50That's interesting. The question is, will Bitcoiners care? Because once again I'm not sure how many Ethereum users will actually want to move to the ZK rollup on Bitcoin.

32:02Michael TidwellYeah, it might just be like a killer application, a killer use case, is what drives a lot of the traffic, you know what I mean?

32:11Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly.

32:13Michael TidwellSo how do we circle this back to Bitcoin Core and Bitcoin Knots, the original question? How do we do this?

32:21Vlad CosteaOh, that's a very good question, because I think that...

32:25Michael TidwellAnd how do we make sure we blame the plebs while doing it?

32:28Vlad CosteaThe drama actually started when Peter Todd posted on the mailing list that the OP_RETURN limit should be removed, because you can already inscribe data and you can use services like the MARA Slipstream, which basically relays transactions without even using Bitcoin's internal mechanism. You just pay a mining pool to put data inside of a block, and you don't have to ask for anyone else's permission for this. It will just get mined. And he basically proposed this for projects like Citrea that would benefit from an OP_RETURN increase. Because Citrea can go both ways: they can use ordinal inscriptions to put their ZK data on Bitcoin, or they can use OP_RETURN. OP_RETURN is more efficient, it's prunable from nodes, and less harmful because it doesn't bloat the UTXO set.

33:33And it all started from this and then Jameson Lopp went on and said, well, I'm an investor in Citrea and I believe in its future and I think it's the more elegant workaround to have this on Bitcoin. Which I agree. It's preferable for Citrea to use OP_RETURN as opposed to BRC-20s or something. Or STAMPs, the STAMPs are most fun. But the plebs are the ones that actually believe that Citrea is gonna put kitty porn or well what was the other one, like dick pics and something that...

34:09Michael TidwellThere's a... there's the new term that I feel like everyone just learned about. It's like a four-letter acronym that starts with C. I can't... It's like "CASS" or... it's some like child, you know, whatever, some four-letter acronym that's been thrown around. You know what I'm talking about?

34:28Vlad CosteaNo, I don't.

34:30Michael TidwellIt's... well, it's like everyone, like the... just look up Matthew Kratter. It's all he can talk about.

34:36Vlad CosteaOh, the dean of the Bitcoin University. Such an esteemed educational institution.

34:45Michael TidwellYeah. It's like, just scroll through. It's all he can talk about, is CP and CSAM. I don't... Child...

34:54Vlad CosteaIs that a radio station? CSAM. You are listening to CSAM.

35:00Michael TidwellI don't think that's a good radio station, because I think it stands for something terrible. Yeah, if you... I don't even want to Google it, but it's something to do with like kitty porn or something. I think it's just a more generic term, but anyways...

35:14Vlad CosteaJust for the record, it's kitty. For YouTube algorithms, it's kitty with a T. Okay? Don't shut down this account, please. For the feds watching, you know what this is about. You have been infiltrating the community for many years.

35:32Michael TidwellIt is a bit crazy that this is where the current talking point has gone. I think it's not... it's going from, like, laughable... like where before, like, just, you know, trying to make this a non-technical discussion and making this purely cultural was like, okay, like, this is like... we're agreeing to disagree. A lot of people are saying this is only technical. A lot of people are saying, well, you talking about this is not technical, this is like a cultural sort of debate.

36:03Vlad CosteaIt's not cultural, it's emotional. It's about the spirit of... Emotional, yeah. It's about keeping Bitcoin only for financial transactions.

36:12Michael TidwellRight, so there's that sort of like talking point, but then, and that's when it was like, okay, this is like taking a lot of effort to and like this is like funny, fun, like maybe tiring at sometimes but now it's gotten to a point where it's just disturbing and sad. Like I don't even think it's fun now. It's not even like this is not This is no longer a debate that I think anyone wants to have. I feel like you're just having one side of this discussion. I don't really even want to call a debate because this is like there's nothing actually being debated, in my opinion. That's like That actually means anything or that actually makes sense to me. So you're just making it right now where like the you're just shutting down the discussion like hardcore, like it's it's just, it's kind of sad.

37:03And a lot of people are pointing out like, you know, when when people do this, it's like, it's like the inevitable, like, this is how you get your way. This is how like people lose their freedom. This is like, you know, blah, blah, blah. This is like, you're you're like using the same methods that like the government uses, You know to like pass like bizarre crazy totalitarian type bills so It's like I Don't know. It's it's just getting to the point where this no longer seems like a Bitcoin discussion. This seems like a Just like a really sad, terrible discussion now

37:38Vlad CosteaWell, yeah. And the funny part is that the stuff that they're mostly afraid of has been on the chain for like 10 years or longer. Like, it's already on your node. Don't worry.

37:51Michael TidwellWell, I don't think they're... I don't think they're afraid of anything. They just want to get their way. So it has nothing to do with the... I don't... I mean, this is my opinion. I don't think it has anything to do with illicit content. It has to do with "we're not... we're losing the culture of Bitcoin, so these people might as well be like pedophiles." And it's just like, what? Like, okay, it's like, I don't get my way, so now everyone is a pedophile. Like, that's like your argument, line of thinking. It's like, well, if I'm not going to get my way, I'm, you know, I'm going to scream in the middle of Walmart and cry until I get my toy, you know, kind of thing. Like, this is like their nuclear option or something.

38:38I mean, the real nuclear option is just rejecting blocks and forking off, but they're not going to win that because it's, they're going to become like the next Roger Ver types, right?

38:49Vlad CosteaI disagree here, because from what I recall from 2017, the conversation, even if there was a lot of emotional stuff, like people saying, well, this can be the end of Bitcoin, or we're gonna destroy it if we do this, or if these people are in charge of it... But the conversations were very technical. Like, they were actually asking what should be the block size limit, or is there anything...

39:20Michael TidwellYeah, 100%. The comparison obviously is not perfect, so don't nitpick me on how before things were justified or not. I'm just simply saying that forking off, whether you're right or wrong, is just going to be like... it reminds me of the similar sort of, you know, fork of community. So yes, there's going to be a lot of, like, things where you can say, like, before, especially like Bitcoin Cash, people were more technically justified in their approach or whatever. That's not... I think we can agree on that or whatever, but that is not the comparison I'm trying to make. Just the fact that this is happening was more or less the comparison I'm making, if that makes sense.

40:06Vlad CosteaYeah So I did say this on Nostr I think I use Nostr sometimes. And I did mention that Knots can actually lead to an accidental or even intentional hard fork. And if you look at the repo, it's like a thousand commits behind Bitcoin Core and it's also a thousand commits ahead of Bitcoin Core. So there are lots of divergences. Is that a word? Divergences?

40:35Michael TidwellThere's a lot of diffs. So like Murch did a nice dive into this. Pretty surprising. He just did like some numbers, ran the numbers on how many lines of code were changed. And pretty much there's more lines of code that are different between Knots and Core than there were total lines in the original implementation of Bitcoin. So it's like, we're talking like a non-trivial amount. When Luke was pressed on this, either on Twitter or Telegram or something, it was the question was, hey, you know, let's say Knots, you know, are we planning on making Knots closer to the version control history of Core? And he said unlikely. Right Like is one of the goals like to get this like back in line with Core? It was not.

41:22So, I I don't know like what that really means, like I assume Luke is smart enough to make sure any significant changes that happen in Core that he wants to bring into Knots he can figure out. I'm not trying to say like, this is actually a big deal, but there is like a big misconception on like how big the diff is. The other thing that you're sort of bringing up that was sort of surprising, it seems like a lot of people who have gotten into Bitcoin and have become quite popular. I'm going to throw, I love Guy Swann so I'm just going to use him as an example. Guy Swann, I love you, but Guy Swann made like a pretty... Like, kind of silly tweet the other day that was like, hey, at what point was it, was like, why like, all of a sudden, like, at what point was it weird to want multiple implementations of Bitcoin?

42:13And I'm like, it's never, that's never been a thing. Like, I'm pretty much saying, like, yeah, when, when was that? And there's been, I I don't think people like understand Satoshi, Gavin Andresen like no one advocated for multiple implementations. This was always considered what you sort of brought up. The You could accidentally fork the network if you have two really popular implementations. Now, whether or not that's a good take, I don't think, I think that's up for debate. I think you can say, hey, Satoshi and Gavin did not have good takes, and here's why we can like make the kernel this, libbitcoin that, Knots this, whatever, multiple implementations makes the network more robust. You can make whatever argument and you can back it up with facts and figures and tech, whatever.

42:59But to to say that this was like the normal way of thinking and like to to sort of like make it seem like the crazy people are the ones that say, hey, like when you have more than one implementation, it's dangerous. Like To act like that's weird is like the weird part. Like That's actually been the norm. So It's like either people don't know history or whatever, or they they're trying to like sort of manipulate history accidentally. But like If we think it's a good idea to have really popular implementations of Bitcoin outside of Bitcoin Core, I think that's a really interesting debate and it should be discussed and we should talk about it. But it shouldn't be this thing where it's like assumed to be the right answer.

43:41Vlad CosteaWell, to be fair, there's libbitcoin which goes back to 2012 or something. And it's a complete rewrite of the Bitcoin Core code in C++. And I think that one has made some interesting progress with Eric Voskuil speeding up initial sync and being able To do things which are not possible with the current state of the code, like you you need some complete redesigns to be able to get to that level. There's also, so you mentioned Gavin Andresen who took over the He did write BIP 101 in what I think was 2015. And he did advocate for Bitcoin XT and Classic afterwards. I'm not sure about Unlimited, which also came along.

44:28I'm not sure if he was a fan of that one, but he did say in 2017 after the fork that Bitcoin Cash is the repo on which he started working in 2010. So to be fair, there was always this alternative implementation. But I do point out that people who always show these graphs where they say, look at Bitcoin Knots adoption, now we have this percentage of nodes and it used to be 1% a few months ago and now it's like 10. And they also project into the future and they say that in one year they're gonna be like dominant client. It goes back to Peter Rizun and for the record, I do love Peter Rizun He was on the show. He did some useful research and he's constantly pushing the limits of the Bitcoin design.

45:18But back in 2016, he went on stage for one of the scaling Bitcoin conferences and he was saying well Bitcoin XT used to be at 1% last month and after a month it's at 15% and we're gonna be the dominant client by the end of the year and this I don't know you can call it eternal September or something it just keeps coming back with people who come up with these ideas and I guess every generation of Bitcoiners wants to fight for something and in this case it's the most stupid something you can fight for Like, the the most trivial thing, but they think it's some sort of spiritual crusade. And they're saving the spirit, the soul, the something from the people they don't like.

46:07I think ultimately it comes down to preventing people they don't like from building on Bitcoin. I think that's sort of the end game I don't know where this is gonna end, but I do predict that there's gonna be a hard fork in a year or something. It looks like 2016. I think, I've seen this movie before.

46:32Michael TidwellYeah, we'll see. I it's It's not really clear because I think I'm not convinced there's going to be a hard fork yet. Because a lot of the people that are also, like, I would say pretty opposed to Core, also are really opposed to people like Roger Ver and Bitcoin Cash. So I think people are going to understand inconsistencies and understand like, okay, like, yes, let's, let's maybe just keep this at the relay policy layer and not touch consensus. I also want to mention that, things like libbitcoin I think probably take the right approach, because they're, they're essentially just, using the same, as far as I know, like the same, like C++ code for their consensus as Bitcoin Core.

47:23Is that correct?

47:24Vlad CosteaNo, it's a complete rewrite. They're in consensus, but they don't copy anything.

47:30Michael TidwellI think it's a complete rewrite with the caveat that maybe I can look this up, but I my understanding is their their consensus part of the node is like perfectly in line with Core, like to a T. And I thought that meant that they also use the same sort of like, I don't know, files or consensus code as Core. Other than that, I thought it was a full rewrite. Is that, am I mistaken?

47:58Vlad CosteaSo it's a full rewrite. But also in consensus with Core, like it's not attempting to make anything, like any radical changes, but it does make some different kind of optimizations. For example, we all know that the UTXO set is stored in memory, it's actually in the white paper, you can read that, and libbitcoin you you store that on your normal storage, which over the years became much faster.

48:25Michael TidwellOkay. So there's also... I know there's also, like, some work with, like, a Bitcoin kernel idea, where you can sort of make different node implementations that sort of still have the same kernel. I think that's probably, like, a good approach if you want to do multiple implementations, by the way.

48:44Vlad CosteaYeah. It's also interesting that once Bitcoin Cash forked off, they basically paraded with this idea that they use multiple implementations. Like, there's no Bitcoin Cash Core. There's Bitcoin Unlimited, there's Bitcoin XT, there's Classic, and then they also had SV that forked off. Yeah.

49:08Michael TidwellAnd then Roger was like, "We're going too far. I'm staying on Bitcoin Cash."

49:13Vlad CosteaWell I don't think so, to be honest, I I think the whole propaganda about big blockers being stupid and clueless was wrong about the Bitcoin Cash side, because they they were not crazy. They knew what they were doing and they did not push the limits beyond any reasonable threshold. But in the case of SV, it was just nihilistic. And the fact that SV was created in the first place sort of discredited the efforts of the BCH side of the debate.

49:48Michael TidwellYeah, I mean, if, okay, so from the point of view of a Core supporter, from the point of view of a Core supporter. Craig Wright did a lot of harm in terms of his lawsuits and his distraction and stuff, but did he actually do a favor by fracturing the Bitcoin Cash community and saving Bitcoin Core?

50:16Vlad CosteaI think yes. Because if you look back...

50:19Michael TidwellIs that a spicy take?

50:21Vlad CosteaIt's not. Like The big blockers are very pissed off because they they had this moment in November of 2017, if you remember. When Vitalik famously tweeted, congrats on this seriously, yeah and Bitcoin Cash was number two on CoinMarketCap. It went to like $9,000. I remember that night. It was very interesting because for the first time you could see the market basically trying to figure out which one is the real Bitcoin and putting their money on it. And some people will argue that, well, it was just a couple of exchanges and they were manipulated and it was just some people who were trying to create this illusion that BCH has users. But I'm not sure if everyone who claimed their free airdrop in BCH dumped it immediately.

51:10Like, I guess there were some people who just waited. They were like, well, let's see which one is gonna be the one that gets most of the users and gets the miners, because that's also part of the fight. And honestly, I still see BCH as a blackmail sort of chain. Just in case something goes wrong, they're here to take part of the miners.

51:41Michael TidwellOkay. Well, what else do you want to talk about?

51:43Vlad CosteaOh, we ended with this topic. Let's try spinning the wheel to see who is to blame for the fact that big blockers failed.

51:57Michael TidwellRound and round it goes, who will blame? No one knows. Drum roll. It's Vitalik.

52:10Vlad CosteaVitalik. Of course it's Vitalik, because most of the builders went on Ethereum. Like, the guys wanted to build stuff on Bitcoin and they could not. After the scaling debate, they went to Ethereum, right? They didn't go to Bitcoin Cash.

52:24Michael TidwellThe wheel knows all. The wheel knows all.

52:27Vlad CosteaThat's so obvious. Like, how could I not see that coming? Let's see what the big blockers can do. You tell me when to stop touching the balls, and I'll just grab one.

52:43Michael TidwellAll right, I'll tell you when to stop touching the balls.

52:53Vlad CosteaI dropped a couple. Are you enjoying this? Oh no, I got tricked. He left. This sucks. Hit that subscribe button and the like button. I'm gonna wait for him to come back. I dropped a ball. I guess this is gonna be the answer. There's another one under my desk. I guess he went to the bathroom or something. I got tricked. It's not fair. But we're gonna find out the answer. So Vitalik Buterin is to blame for the fact that big blockers were not successful.

53:42I cheated. Michael, you left me hanging here. You went to eat?

53:48Michael TidwellHey, man, I had to get a snack. So I didn't tell you to stop. I'm really upset that you stopped. All right, stop.

53:58Vlad CosteaWait, I have to choose between two of them.

54:04Michael TidwellAll right, hold on. There's a sign. The fact that you have two balls in your hand and that they're blue, this is a sign. This is a sign here. I say we go to the audience for left or right. Just left or right: left ball, right ball. First, first left or right you see in the comments, you go with that. Yeah. Are we... are you like... are we streaming on...?

54:33Vlad CosteaWhat? Twitter and also YouTube.

54:35Michael TidwellOkay.

54:36Vlad CosteaBut I think there's a slight delay, like 20 seconds until people see this. So "left ball," obviously, said CoinJoin Chris. Also said that he likes my shirt, but I look like... just a second. So CoinJoin Chris said, "That's a great shirt, Vlad. Didn't know you were a Persian club promoter." What's a Persian club promoter?

54:59Michael TidwellIt's someone who stands outside of a club and gets people to come in, I think.

55:05Vlad CosteaYeah, but what's a Persian club like? What happens in there?

55:10Michael TidwellWell, you have hookah, you have music, and you have dark... darkness.

55:20Vlad CosteaI have the best answer. It's "activate CTV."

55:27Michael TidwellSo the premise was: big blockers, blame Vitalik, and big blockers need CTV. Yeah.

55:38Vlad CosteaAll right. But I think they do have something like CTV. Not CTV particularly, but they have OP_CAT and they have something else which is like CTV. I'm not an expert, but I know that they activated some soft forks, because they did something called CashTokens. They were trying to do Ethereum stuff on the Bitcoin design.

56:05Michael TidwellI'll just have to take your word for it. I know nothing about Bitcoin Cash.

56:10Vlad CosteaI mean, I gotta give them credit for some of the experimentation that they're doing, which Core has been much more conservative to attempt. They are trying to get another kind of users and do other stuff. And the fact that they have OP_CAT, I mean, you can try to break it, right? Like people who say, oh, OP_CAT is not safe, OP_CAT is gonna destroy Bitcoin. Try to destroy Bitcoin Cash. Make some money.

56:43You can be a hero.

56:47Michael TidwellBitcoin Cash has OP_CAT, is what you're saying?

56:50Vlad CosteaYeah.

56:51Michael TidwellAnd why isn't... I mean, OP_CAT is all you needed to, like, pretty much do anything in the most complicated way possible, with just OP_CAT, right? Sort of like, you can pretty much do, like, anything as long as you're okay with, like, the most complicated script possible, with just OP_CAT, pretty much.

57:14Vlad CosteaYeah, that's correct.

57:15Michael TidwellSo time to break Bitcoin Cash if you really want to make sure they don't succeed. You know, they're just... they're on the tail of Bitcoin right now, about to activate a sidechain using OP_CAT, and they're going to overtake Bitcoin. So make sure you go there and exploit OP_CAT, everyone.

57:36Vlad CosteaOh, you know what's interesting about Bitcoin Cash? I read very recently that they're trying to activate and basically build their own ZK rollup, and they're saying, well, now we're gonna scale off chain. And I'm like, man, this is unheard of from the same people who are saying, well, everything should be on chain, on the base layer. We're gonna scale for as much demand as there is. I think they even have dynamic block size right now. So if there is high demand, you can have very large blocks. But they... I don't think they actually had that.

58:09Michael TidwellYeah. Instead, for Bitcoin, we just put... we do sub... sat... sub-one-sat fees. We don't believe in dynamic blocks over here. So...

58:19Vlad CosteaOh, that's a good topic. We got to talk about that. Sub-one-sat. Yeah. But let me present two more advertisements before that. Actually, let me finish with the ads and then we can just have a free-flowing conversation. Bitcoin.com News. Michael, what do you know about Bitcoin.com?

58:37Michael TidwellAll I know is it's a great way to get your news for Bitcoin.

58:42Vlad CosteaAre you being ironic?

58:45Michael TidwellI am just saying that anyone who would sponsor this podcast is a friend of mine.

58:50Vlad CosteaWell, if you go to Bitcoin.com right now, you're gonna see that they're orange. They're not green anymore. They don't tell you that Bitcoin is slow and you should use Bitcoin Cash. And after this rebrand, I think their news section also became better, in the sense that, unlike Bitcoin Magazine or other competitors, they don't focus too much on the US, and they also report what's happening in other parts of the world, which, once again, are not the US. And they also have coverage for gold and silver and some other stuff which might be interesting. So check out news.bitcoin.com, and I think their journalism is decent. Like, you will definitely find something which is interesting to you, and I don't think you'll find it somewhere else if you want to stick to the Bitcoin world, because I think CoinDesk might have them too, but I'm not allowed to say that. Anyway, I would say...

59:49Michael TidwellCan I add something? I would say they're not just decent, they are superb. Superb. Superb.

59:58Vlad CosteaI heard "superb" with a V.

1:00:01Michael TidwellNo, I said "superb" with a B.

1:00:05Vlad CosteaIf you say so. Also, there is NoOnes.com, which is a peer-to-peer exchange. Are you aware of Ray Youssef's work with Paxful?

1:00:19Michael TidwellYeah. That guy is either a genius or batshit crazy. I love that guy.

1:00:25Vlad CosteaHe's like a WWE character full-time.

1:00:28Michael TidwellDude, he is, like, saying some stuff that I have no idea about over there, overseas. And I'm just like, I have no idea. And I'm just like, man, this guy is super opinionated.

1:00:40Vlad CosteaHe always talks about fighting the forces of evil and having only five years left to turn the course of this dystopia and NoOnes.com is his peer-to-peer exchange Basically what he does with it is to onboard people from the global south what that means is mostly Nigerians and Middle Eastern people, but also from Latin America. And that's sort of his target audience. He calls them his lions. And He has a spot exchange, which is not as interesting as the peer-to-peer exchange, because on the peer-to-peer exchange you also have a marketplace for gift cards and for lots of interesting stuff. And They also have a debit card, which I find the least interesting, but for some people that that is interesting because they can spend their coins using the Visa network.

1:01:32But if you go to NoOnes.com and you register and you provide liquidity for this market, whatever you put into the system is going to end up in the hands of these African hustlers who are going to be able to put food on the table and participate in this global economy. So it's interesting from this point of view if you are ideologically aligned with this mission check out NoOnes.com and last but not least I gotta mention SideShift, which is the place that's gonna benefit the most from all of these spread-out layers of Bitcoin. Like there's gonna be Citrea, there's gonna be Alpen, there's gonna be Ark there's gonna be lots of stuff happening by next year, I guess.

1:02:21And SideShift is one of these services that support multiple networks and you can swap between these layers and of course there's a fee, but they have pretty good liquidity. Not available in the US because of regulations, but if you can watch porn in Texas without putting your ID, then you can also use SideShift I'm not gonna tell you exactly how and what you need to do, but I guess you're smart enough. Anyway, if you're not from the US you can use SideShift and they have low fees and good liquidity, and they also have the TRUMP coin if you're into that. But mostly, I think it's useful for if someone wants to pay you in CBDC wannabes, like USDT or whatever, and you don't want to hold on to that, you just go to SideShift you pick the USDT to Bitcoin pair, they send the USDT to the address from SideShift and you get the BTC to your own address.

1:03:19And you don't have to worry too much about this. And it's also integrated with Trezor and Cake Wallet and Edge Wallet and a bunch of others. Anyway, check it out. Really cool. Nice guys. And Andreas Brekken the CEO, was on the show. He's also the CEO of Shitcoin.com which is another can of worms.

1:03:43Michael TidwellAll these sponsors sound great. Happy to hear that you're being supported by all the most lovely Bitcoin companies in the world. By the way, has Ray ever been on the show?

1:03:58Vlad CosteaThat's a good question. Has he? Ray... He was alongside Nicholas Gregory from CommerceBlock when they were building CivKit, which is this peer-to-peer marketplace that's built on top of Nostr, and that one ended up being basically the base layer for NoOnes. So yeah, Ray was on the show, but not alone. I should get him alone.

1:04:32Michael TidwellYeah. Ray's passion and motivational energy is very impressive.

1:04:42Vlad CosteaYeah. He said he could sell shoes... No, he was also alone on the show. I remember, we were talking about Final Fantasy V, and he said he's the kind of guy who does the side quests and the extra difficult super bosses and everything else. Like, he completes the game, and that's the way that he approaches his mission here too. Like, he's willing to fight everyone.

1:05:09Michael TidwellI love... I actually love that analogy. He's willing to do the extra secret boss hard fights, and not just say "mission complete" without completely 100% completing it.

1:05:23Vlad CosteaHe also said he could sell shoes, as in...

1:05:27Michael TidwellWhat does that even mean? Sell shoes to, like, a shoe salesman? Like, what does that mean?

1:05:33Vlad CosteaNo, it basically means that he's not successful by accident. It's by virtue of his salesman skills.

1:05:40Michael TidwellOh, I thought it was like one of those puns where it's like, "I could sell shoes to a man with no legs," you know, something like that.

1:05:46Vlad CosteaI think he can do that, to be honest. Like, he's very charming. Met him in Mexico last year. He was hanging out with another OG. I remember his face... Nick Spanos. Yeah, Nick Spanos, the first guy to build a stock market exchange for Bitcoin when the price was like $1. Very interesting guy. You should get both of them at TABConf, by the way.

1:06:15Michael TidwellAll right, you heard it here first. Ray and Nick, you're invited to TABConf. I'll see you there.

1:06:24Vlad CosteaThey have to go through your registration process on GitHub.

1:06:29Michael TidwellI mean, if they want to talk, they can just come.

1:06:31Vlad CosteaNice. I'm gonna let them know. They might be interested, but they don't like the US.

1:06:38Michael TidwellAh, dude, so many people... I get a lot of really interesting people that say, like, "Oh, I'm not gonna travel to the US." It's sad for me to hear that.

1:06:51Vlad CosteaIt was also difficult for me last year. It's a funny story, because for the last three or four years I have been sending magazines to TABConf, but I never actually attended. And I met you last year in Nashville, and you basically said hello to me, and you said, "How come you never came to TABConf, but you're here?" And yeah, the simple answer is that I didn't have a travel visa for the US, and the people from Bitcoin Magazine actually helped me get my travel visa, to have it within a month, on time for the conference. Now I have it for the next 10 years, so I can participate this year in TABConf. I don't know what my excuse is gonna be if I don't show up, but I do want to come. Like, I feel like it's one of these events where you get a lot of signal. Of course, nowadays you have competition from the btc++ event series, which I think is also excellent, and there's also Blockspace Media, which started doing sort of their own events. But I feel like both of these have kind of a hidden agenda, where the organizers are aligned with...

1:08:00Some company or project where in the case of TABConf, it's more pure. Like you also had Chris DeRose take his clothes off on stage.

1:08:10Michael TidwellYeah, that's a highlight of a of a previous, I think that was the 2019 TABConf. Yeah. So I I do think that it is likely I'll want to focus in on some projects for TABConf, not necessarily projects that are like company-based but projects like, hey, we're going to really focus on like freedom communication. And what does that look like? We're gonna focus on maybe like also supporting ways like like certain hardware wallets and methodologies that we agree with. There might be like recurring projects that we kind of lean into where it's like every year, year over year we sort of are iterating on some like cool like conference thing but it would be like a not necessarily like a company but like a conference project that like meets in person once a year.

1:09:07The example I I was giving about like the freedom communication stuff is like if we're building apps and stuff around Meshtastic and that protocol like hey this is like a way for us to like have a meeting space once a year where it's like you know we're connecting Tennessee the Carolina you know helping connect Tennessee to Carolina, Atlanta, and and beyond. Because right now, as far as I understand, people are using Meshtastic to talk from Atlanta, Georgia, the places in Tennessee and Carolinas. And that's that's a big step from a year ago. And I think you know us leaning into this idea where it's like you don't need the internet to broadcast a Bitcoin transaction or a secret message is going to be like really, really interesting as, you know, we build more stuff around that protocol.

1:09:55So these are things where I think we could have, like, recurring sort of projects that repeat. Another one would be, like, Warnet. So last year we attacked Bitcoin Core, a bunch of Bitcoin Core versions. And I think, like, leaning into that and supporting that project... So again, there's not like a real company necessarily that we're trying to promote, but, like, just the idea of having, like, a red team sort of hacker vibe where we're trying to break stuff, as, like, a recurring annual thing, I think is kind of interesting. You know, having, like, these three or four kind of recurring events every time, but also, like, a bunch of other, like, random stuff, I think, is maybe the direction we're going to go in.

1:10:43Vlad CosteaYeah. And from what I've seen, because I did watch the livestreams on occasion when I could not attend, it's very focused on technical stuff. It's the kind of event that attracts people like Pieter Wuille, who is maybe the most knowledgeable developer in Bitcoin right now, from the ones who are still active. And also, you had that famous debate between Peter Todd and Paul Sztorc about drivechains that was a highlight of TABConf a couple of years ago. And I do know some backstage stories about that, because I found out later that Paul actually sought to receive some sort of professional training to be able to not look awkward. And basically, he has that... when he's thinking very hard, he doesn't move much, and he looks like he's actually scared or something. He doesn't have good body language. And once he got on stage, he forgot everything. And Peter Todd...

1:11:49Michael TidwellI didn't know about that, but I would say that a lot of people hated that debate. So a lot of people thought that debate was super unfair for Paul. A lot of people thought Peter Todd skirted around Paul's line of questioning. So that a lot of... and then a lot of people said, "Oh, that was great, that was a lot of fun." And then... But what I noticed is, a lot of people who didn't know shit about Bitcoin, so, like, these are, like, people I invited to the conference, co-workers, friends, etc., they watched that debate and actually thought, like, Peter Todd was full of shit.

1:12:24And there's a lot of people that watched the debate and thought like Peter won dude the opinions were just all over the place on that. There was no consensus on whether or not that was a good event or not I'll put it that way.

1:12:40Vlad CosteaSo who is to blame for the fact that these people don't know much about Bitcoin in the first place?

1:12:50Michael TidwellRound and round it goes who will blame no one knows.

1:12:59We're blaming the people themselves we're blaming the plebs again. Yet again, it's the plebs' fault. Man, that's just being plebs. It's like who are we blaming we're blaming the audience.

1:13:17Vlad CosteaYou should look in the mirror. You shouldn't blame anyone. Anyway, so what's the solution for that? I should...

1:13:23Michael TidwellFor having bad panels, debate panels at TABConf. Stop.

1:13:30Vlad CosteaI have two of them.

1:13:34Michael TidwellFor the love of God, stop.

1:13:37Vlad CosteaLeft or right? You can mention it in the chat.

1:13:40Michael TidwellYeah, chat, are we going left ball, right ball?

1:13:47I'm looking at the YouTube chat. I mean there's like seven people watching. I don't even know if anyone... Is someone bold enough to make a comment on your livestream? No. No context, just left or right.

1:14:08Vlad CosteaI think the Twitter chat is more active. How do I get there? Jackknife said uncanny how accurate this wheel is.

1:14:19486 OG said right. So yeah there's a delay in between what we're talking and what they hear. I'm opening the right ball. I hope it's the right one. Also metaphorically. My god this I swear this is not scripted okay. Do you see what it says?

1:14:45Michael TidwellYeah. I think, you know, I think we really need to re-evaluate, like, fortune tellers, and, like, we need to re-evaluate our thinking about... what's that, what's that little thing where, like, people move stuff around the board? It's got, like, a little, like, glass, and it, like, spells words. What's that called?

1:15:06Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I know what you're talking about. It's not tarot, it's...

1:15:12Michael TidwellYeah, we need to reinvestigate tarot cards.

1:15:15Vlad CosteaOuija or something? Ouija?

1:15:17Michael TidwellOuija board. Ouija board. Yeah. So we need to, like, look back at all this stuff, because it seems like the answers are just... the universe is telling us the answers to these hard questions, you know. Attending TABConf obviously fixes this.

1:15:36Vlad CosteaSo the piece of paper inside of the ball which people chose from the chat... so there were one, two, three people in the chat who said right, and I picked the right one, and it says "Attend TABConf," with an exclamation point.

1:15:55This is beautiful like the plebs are to blame themselves for the fact that they're not educated and to fix it they need to attend TABConf like I swear this is not scripted. It couldn't be any better like I have some very interesting answers in here but this one turned out. I wish it was the other one that says subscribe to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast but it didn't land I just got this one.

1:16:24Michael TidwellWait wait was the other was the left one subscribe?

1:16:27Vlad CosteaI don't know, I haven't opened it, but it's one of the eight options. Now there's only five of them, so at one point that's gonna be the answer to the question. I spoiled it. But yeah, attend TABConf. How much is the ticket?

1:16:40Michael Tidwell$121 worth of Bitcoin, or fiat USD, and/or whatever. And that does provide you lunch and breakfast, that provides you hardware devices, that provides you access to all official after-party events. So, you know, essentially we lose money on every ticket we sell. It's pretty much a break-even ticket price, more or less. So we're not out here trying to make money or gouge people. We're out here trying to maximize people to come to the conference, to actually learn and make a difference in Bitcoin at a technical level, not just an emotional level.

1:17:22It's really... once you figure out Bitcoin is a good idea and it's interesting, this is what is next: how do you want to... what do you want to do to, like, help this thing that you think is a good idea? And we really focus in on that. If you can't afford the ticket, we don't even deny you. Like, this ticket is pretty much, like, "please support us." But if you, for some reason, cannot afford the ticket, you can go to the website and click "grant," and we have sponsors that really want to help Bitcoin, where we help people come to the conference.

1:17:57So please, like, just be part of this vibe that we're going for. We're really trying to make a difference here and do interesting, meaningful stuff, and not just have a conference where you listen to yet another panel or talk that, like, doesn't really make a difference, that tells you Bitcoin's a good idea. Like, the idea is we're not going to go up there and tell you about price number go up. We're not going to tell you, like, "Oh, look, look at these historical charts," to make you feel even better about your Bitcoin bags. Like, we're going to be talking, like, what can we do to actually make a difference?

1:18:31So conviction is not, like, part of that formula, in my opinion. You get convicted through actual doing, actual building, and, like, learning how this stuff actually works. So I don't buy that "Hey, I'm not technical, hey, this isn't for me," because we have stuff for all the way from very, like, beginners all the way to very advanced. So there is no, like, idea where it's like, "Oh, I don't want to use email, I don't want to learn text messages, I don't want to learn how a doorknob works." Like, all these technologies are going to be in your face, and to be truly self-sovereign requires a minimal level of competency.

1:19:07So, you know, as Bitcoin is not solidified by any means, and as it gets improved, you're going to want to make sure that you stay up to date and on par with how the stuff actually works. So that is sort of my pitch for people to attend the conference.

1:19:25Vlad CosteaMan, I love it. Once again, $121 plus a flight to Atlanta, and I guess a hotel room, but that's pretty standard. How come you haven't learned anything, Michael? I mean, I saw you in Nashville last year. You have any idea how much they could charge for these tickets, and people actually paid for that?

1:19:49Michael TidwellYeah, we could probably charge, like, four to six hundred bucks if we're looking to, like, make good money from it. But also, this is not like a full-time job. I also like to set expectations very, very low. Like, let's set expectations, like, at the dirt and exceed them. So I want this to be, like, a very, like, low-stress sort of conference. We'll probably keep ticket prices pretty low for the foreseeable future. I'm really trying to make that up in sponsorship, obviously. So if you are a sponsor and want to sort of help with this idea... not trying to steal any of the sponsors here, obviously, but other sponsors that don't support this, if you...

1:20:30Vlad CosteaAre you saying you don't want my sponsors?

1:20:32Michael TidwellNo, I'm just saying I don't want to take away from you. So if you are a sponsor watching this and you've decided, hey, I don't want to support this amazing Takeover podcast, but you want to support TABConf, then...

1:20:48But yeah, I mean, we could easily charge more money. The funny part is, I have a funny story for you. In 2018 we sold tickets for $10, and the point of that was not to make money, but to ensure that you'll actually come if you get a ticket, because we're limited on capacity. So we sold out very quickly at the $10 range, and then people were upset because they wanted to attend, but we were sold out. So people started selling the $10 tickets for over $100, and it's like, well, shit, we can't sell these for $10, because that's like... you know, there's, like, secondary markets now for resale.

1:21:35So we started charging like at least a hundred bucks you know to avoid that problem again.

1:21:43Vlad CosteaWell you are miketwenty1 on Twitter and you're charging $121 for TABConf attendance. Yeah. I think that's beautiful.

1:21:51Michael TidwellYeah. Well, we might... there might be ideas where we have to, like, up the price eventually, just because of logistics, and maybe having people help throughout the year, and, like, actually trying to build out the conference might need more people to, like, help out, and actually pay out our first, like, you know, paid person. We haven't done that quite yet. But we might go to SHA-256, you know, 256 price point in the future. I don't know, like, it's up in the air. We'll see. I can't promise these prices forever, so take advantage of it while the prices are this low.

1:22:30Vlad CosteaYou can also have, like, a whale pass, whatever, for $210,000.

1:22:37Michael TidwellSo one thing that I don't think we're ever going to do is ever have any sort of tiered classism sort of idea. Like, we like to think that you have a ticket, it gives you access to everything. There's no, like, hey, I can only get into this, like, whale lounge area or something if I have, like, the badge or the whale or the industry pass. Like, everyone's sort of on the same level. You can't buy your way on stage. Like, if Michael Saylor, for instance, and I'm not even joking, if he wanted to present at TABConf, he would have to go through the same GitHub submission process that everyone else would, right? And if his talk wasn't of interest, we would decline it in public.

1:23:15So, like, we're very transparent. You know, everyone's on the same kind of page. You're only, like... you're good for what you've done, but we're also trying to value what people have done in the last year. So a lot of people have the chance... like, new names have the chance to be on the forefront of interesting things going on. So, you know, that's... I don't think we're ever going to have the whale pass thing. Maybe we'll have some weird version of it in the future, but nothing like, I guess, what you see at other conferences.

1:23:48Vlad CosteaWell, I respect that because usually the conversation is that here in Europe We have the same kind of approach where you pay for the ticket and everyone has access to the same places. But in the US, it's like these events specialize in creating these VIP areas or situations where there is an incentive if you want to meet other wealthy people to pay for the kind of ticket which gets you in some sort of VIP lounge or gives you backstage access to meet the speakers or something like this.

1:24:23Michael TidwellRight yeah I just don't really feel like it's the vibe of what we're going for. I like the idea that you could be having like a complete novice, not know who Pieter Wuille is, and be like, hey, do you know about Bitcoin? Can you help me with this? And Peter's like, sure. And like you know it's not like a big deal. You know what I mean?

1:24:46Vlad CosteaYeah. And I'm looking at the web page, which right now is 7.tabconf.com, which means it's the seventh annual event, and eighth year.

1:24:57Michael TidwellSeventh conference. We skipped COVID 2020.

1:25:00Vlad CosteaYeah. Now, who's going to speak? Like, do you have any submissions which have been accepted?

1:25:06Michael TidwellYeah, we have some accepted talks. So it's... if you go to GitHub, or if you click, like, the schedule link on the front page, it'll take you to our GitHub, and you can look for the "accepted" tag. The schedule is very much a work in progress right now. We don't have the schedule solidified yet. We do have, like, high-level ideas of the schedule, but just not time slots slotted yet.

1:25:32And we are still, like, gonna be accepting, like, more content and stuff as we move forward this next week and stuff.

1:25:41Vlad CosteaI'm thinking I can submit something to propose a talk, but I'm not gonna say exactly what. I don't want to influence anything. I don't want listeners to put pressure on you to accept it or whatever. So I'm just gonna...

1:25:53Michael TidwellNo, no, that's how it works. If they go on there and they Concept ACK it and they Concept NACK it, but they give no technical rationale behind it, you know, I don't know, we might have to ignore some of these things if they're anonymous, you know. But if we have a lot of people start, you know, ACKing and Concept ACKing about this, you know, "Hey, you want to increase your time slot from 80 minutes to infinite minutes," like, maybe we'll have to do it, you know what I mean? Bad joke. I don't know if that joke landed.

1:26:31Vlad CosteaOh, I'm just gonna pretend I haven't heard the joke. Anyway, I have this comic book that's called Bitcoin Year One, and it tries to tell the story from very well-documented... or not just very well... like, lots of very well-documented sources, like, what happened in the first year of Bitcoin. And that's when you had the first mobile wallet, which... I'm gonna ask you: do you even know what kind of phone was used for the first mobile wallet? It could also mine.

1:27:04Michael TidwellNokia flip phone?

1:27:05Vlad CosteaN900, the Nokia. Yeah. So it wasn't a flip phone, but it was sort of a very early smartphone. And you also had the first contributors and the first exchange that emerged, and the first time someone actually sold Bitcoin for, quote-unquote, real money. And there's a lot of this history that people should know if they become serious about this, because I read so many bad takes about who Satoshi is and what he is. I'm like, there is no way this can be true, because I've spent so much time on Bitcoin Talk and...

1:27:45On the Metzdowd cryptography mailing list and I see all of these conversations and Satoshi was not secure about himself. I mean he was insecure that's what I mean about his idea he was not some sort of almighty god he made mistakes. It sort of feels in his conversations with Hal Finney that he was being what's the word for it pestered, or Hal Finney acted like this more experienced person and Satoshi was just trying to get it right and there's also the story from Martti Malmi who told me it was actually on this podcast if I'm not mistaken it's episode 12 of this season.

1:28:29And he said that he's very much convinced that Satoshi couldn't be the NSA or some sort of almighty AI time traveler or something, because he was struggling to configure WordPress. Like, he was just a guy.

1:28:46Michael TidwellOkay. So can we phrase this in a, like, problem sort of statement? Like, whose fault... who do we blame for Bitcoin becoming a religion to some people, and worshiping and idolizing Satoshi? Or is that fair? Or is that, like, a fair spin-the-wheel proposition, or how do you want to phrase it?

1:29:12Vlad CosteaWell why do we idolize Satoshi who is to blame for this.

1:29:18Michael TidwellDrum roll. Satoshi... Well, we're uncovering the truth here live on the podcast. Why do we idolize Satoshi? It's OCEAN's fault. OCEAN is to blame, you guys. I don't... This one might make the least amount of sense, or maybe it makes the most amount of sense.

1:29:40Vlad CosteaIt makes a lot of sense.

1:29:42Michael TidwellOnly the eggs... only the blue eggs will let us know. We'll actually clarify.

1:29:49Vlad CosteaYeah. Well, we have a solution here. Okay.

1:29:51Michael TidwellSo we have a solution, and it will actually make this make sense. You know, now that I realize it, is OCEAN a sponsor? Do they give you this blue ball basket thing? 'Cause that's kind of like what...

1:30:03Vlad CosteaNo, they should pay me for this.

1:30:05Michael TidwellThis... the mempool kind of looks like this. Stop. That's a good one.

1:30:11Vlad CosteaYeah. Let's see what the answer is. So how do people stop idolizing Satoshi? What should they do? Drum roll. This is the stupidest answer possible. It says "just HODL."

1:30:29Michael TidwellI think, you know, every once in a while it's going to be wrong, and it's going to be right in deep ways. I think if we feel like it's originally a bad solution, we're just not thinking deep enough. So I think what this really is... I think you just have to interpret this: it shouldn't matter if OCEAN or whoever is to blame for this, because at the end of the day, just HODL. It doesn't matter.

1:30:57Vlad CosteaThat's a good way to frame it, but you're not gonna get better opinions of how Bitcoin works or the first year of Bitcoin if you just HODL like you have to do some digging. And I gotta say nowadays when you have access to Grok or ChatGPT or whatever, you don't even have to spend many hours browsing through the Bitcoin Talk forums. Like you can just ask specifically what you're interested in. And it's going to give you sources and you go directly to the source and you read but people are too lazy for that I don't know There's also so you can trash big blockers and Bitcoin.com all you want, but also have this useful resource it's called Satoshi Archive and They have basically all the emails and all the conversations on the forums with a search box So even if you hate AI and large language models or whatever you can go there and you can type For example, you want to see where Satoshi said.

1:32:00The word retarded, which he did to Martti Malmi and you're gonna be able to find exactly where that happened, in which conversation.

1:32:10Michael TidwellSo is that why Shinobi says it so often?

1:32:14Vlad CosteaOh yeah, it's a Satoshi reference.

1:32:17Michael TidwellDo you have any concern that people are making Bitcoin their religion, and that that seems to be, like, a thing?

1:32:26Vlad CosteaI used to be concerned about it. Now I sort of take it for granted.

1:32:31Michael TidwellYou just HODL.

1:32:33Vlad CosteaOh, it is a religion to a great extent, and you do have high priests, and you do have sermons, which usually happen to be podcasts or Twitter Spaces or something, where people tune in and they say how much they love Bitcoin and how much it changed their lives. And I think I was fortunate enough to have Chris DeRose on the show during the first year of me podcasting, and he asked me some of, like, some of the harshest questions someone can ask a podcaster at the time. He said, "Do you think you're the guy who can promote with absolute confidence that Bitcoin is the one solution that's going to fix all the problems?"

1:33:16I was like, why would I do that? He said, "Well, that's sort of what podcasters are doing. Like, you're not going to be successful in the circuit unless you're that one guy who comes up with the memes and says all the stuff that gets people to retweet" and whatever. And he was always ahead of his time from this point of view. He foresaw the rise of the pleb influencer, because there's a bunch of them nowadays, and they get more views than I do, but they don't get a much better audience, of which I'm really proud, by the way. So all the people in the comments and everyone listening right now, you're awesome. I would not exchange you for a billion generic, absent-minded listeners who...

1:34:02Michael TidwellWait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Billions? Let's scale those numbers back just a little bit. Hundreds of thousands.

1:34:09Vlad CosteaWhat do you mean, hundreds?

1:34:10Michael TidwellWe wouldn't trade them for hundreds of thousands of mindless...

1:34:14Vlad CosteaSo you're saying there's only hundreds of thousands of mindless people in the world?

1:34:18Michael TidwellNo, no, I'm just saying we wouldn't... we need to negotiate here, because we originally were talking about billions, right? You're saying you wouldn't trade them for billions of listeners, but I'm thinking, let me, as your agent here, let me negotiate for you. We wouldn't trade them for hundreds of thousands instead.

1:34:39Vlad CosteaI don't care too much about scale. It's fine. You get my point. I love these guys. They're smart.

1:34:46Michael TidwellMy jokes are landing flat, flatter than a pancake today.

1:34:53Vlad CosteaHave you had pancakes for breakfast?

1:34:55Michael TidwellI have not had pancakes for breakfast in a very long time.

1:35:00Vlad CosteaOh, you're part of the church. Are you a carnivore right now?

1:35:03Michael TidwellNope.

1:35:04Vlad CosteaHave you embraced the full diet that cures all illnesses and makes you stronger and makes you lift harder and fixes all of your problems, except for constipation? Carnivore diet.

1:35:19Michael TidwellYeah, I went keto several times and I've never been constipated, so I don't know why that's a trope. But keto, a ketogenic diet, is amazing. I love going on that at least once a year, just to feel like I clean out my system. So I do that annually, a couple times, maybe for, like, a few months, but I don't go on it year-round or anything. But I know, like...

1:35:45Vlad CosteaIs it because you got into Bitcoin and someone influenced you? Like, have you read The Bitcoin Standard and that made you reconsider your life?

1:35:53Michael TidwellNo, I did it for health reasons. So I wanted to clean up my liver, I wanted to clean up my, like... I just wanted to feel like I cleaned out my body, stopped drinking a lot, and then I just felt so much better. I lost a bunch of weight, and it was like non-visible weight as well, which was interesting. No, I'm very much pro-keto. I mean, obviously, it might not be for everyone. Might be, like, some weird health thing where you shouldn't go on keto, but for people that can go on keto, I think it's amazing. I mean, I think it's been nothing but beneficial for me. Also, I've noticed that when I am on keto, I have more mental energy and more, like, mental acuity.

1:36:40Like, I'm like, it's easier for me to like think.

1:36:46Vlad CosteaSo so if you take your statement and replace keto and meat with Bitcoin that's the average Bitcoin podcast yeah.

1:36:59Michael TidwellI don't know if it's healthy to be on keto year-round though. I think there's people that do it and they're healthy, but I don't know if everyone... If you know how like i'm not like a I don't know shit about diet and health really, but I know a lot of bro science stuff. I wonder if if certain types of people would be negatively impact from like a year year-round keto diet or like carnivore diet.

1:37:29Vlad CosteaWhat do you mean, certain types of people, Michael?

1:37:32Michael TidwellYeah, so, like, genetically, like, some people might be dis... like, not adapt... like, not have, like, the right parts and the right body chemistry to have that sort of diet, you know. I assume that has something to do with it.

1:37:47Vlad CosteaYou're not helping, and I'm not either. I'm asking questions like, well, what do you mean, what kind of people? And some of them might be on the wheel behind you.

1:37:58Michael TidwellYeah. So should we spin the wheel to see why not all people should be on keto?

1:38:07Vlad CosteaI don't think that's a good question.

1:38:09Michael TidwellYeah, I'm just...

1:38:10Vlad CosteaIt's not a real problem here.

1:38:12Michael TidwellI think it's a serious problem.

1:38:16Vlad CosteaOkay. So who is to blame for the fact that not everyone is on the keto diet? Drum roll.

1:38:23Michael TidwellThis is probably the most important question we've asked all podcast, by the way.

1:38:32Vlad CosteaI like salads. Is it plebs again? Is it plebs again? Yeah, it's plebs again. I don't see the needle... I don't know... I see it now. Oh my God. All right, let's see what the solution is, even though it's obvious that you should eat some sort of steak, but...

1:39:09Michael TidwellOh, stop. Please stop. Stop rimming it like that. Did you lick your finger before you put it in there? That's disgusting, Vlad.

1:39:17Vlad CosteaI can touch my nipples too, if you want. Oh, this is the best one ever: "Activate BIP 300." I feel like I'm playing Cards Against Humanity or something.

1:39:36Michael TidwellAll right. So I assume if you're going to clip this, you have to clip this part. So, Paul, we have determined that really the ketogenic diet, and blaming plebs for not everyone being on the ketogenic diet, the only solution really is to activate BIP 300. This goes along with, like, everything is fixed by BIP 300. So this is actually accurate. This is an accurate solution.

1:40:10Vlad CosteaOkay. Once again, what do you think about drivechains? Like, since we're gonna clip this.

1:40:18Michael TidwellI think drivechains gets too much criticism from too many people I respect. It makes me... I don't really get bothered by the flybys that critique drivechain, but when contributors throw, like, stuff like MEV kind of conversations or whatever at drivechain as being a bad idea, I don't necessarily buy it. And that seems to be the only real critique from people I respect in the space against drivechain, and I don't buy it. Now, with that being said, I'm happy.

1:41:07The other kind of situation is like, oh, well, drivechain is a bad idea. No one's going to use it and it's going to die and miners are going to steal. I think that's okay. Like let miners steal, like prove that it's bad kind of thing, almost mentality versus just saying it's a bad idea miners are going to steal or whatever. The MEV conversation gets a little bit more complex because it's building off like a sort of like, I don't know, like the Ethereum kind of ideas of like, hey, you can like order transactions or you can like, you know, do this stuff where all miners are going to have to, you know, run these side chains in order to do the set ordering and stuff like that.

1:41:52But I mean, I mean, we're we're talking about hypotheticals And we're also talking about. Ideas where there wouldn't be a market for conveying said optimal sort of ordering. Paul sort of has a retort to many of these things, whether people want to agree with those retorts or not, I think would be interesting to listen to. But I don't think there's ever been a forum that has been two people talking about this stuff at a very technical level that that is like digestible, because it seems like whenever any of these conversations go on, either the really technical people don't want to get involved, like the they just don't want to be bothered with this conversation, or yeah, so that sort of happens, or it becomes like this weird sort of like character assassination stuff that's like not not helpful at all.

1:42:55It's I mean, maybe I'm wrong, but today I haven't seen a prominent Bitcoin contributor that is, like, against Bitcoin, besides, like, maybe Matt Corallo with like his MEV conversation come out and like have a long-form debate. We attempted to do that with Peter Todd, and I don't think it was a I don't think it was you know productive at all. Peter Todd, I think came, like he wasn't prepared. He, he sort of like, you know, winged it, more or less in my opinion. And yeah, I, I'm waiting for someone to be willing to have the patience to have that debate and stuff.

1:43:48I don't know if Paul's even the right person to have that debate on, on the pro-drivechain side, I don't know who it would be, but. Yeah, I guess you could say I'm not satisfied. With what I've heard in the conversations that have had that have happened so far in the space around it, to be to be convinced that it's a bad idea at least. Like i'm still I'm still on the side, pro-drivechain side of things, if that makes sense.

1:44:15Vlad CosteaNow, we're gonna have to ask the question about why we don't have drivechains yet, but I do want to make two mentions before that. First of all, there seems to be a very big movement in Litecoin and they might try this first. And I think that's gonna be interesting to see if the miners are gonna do any of the stuff that some people claim that can be done on Bitcoin. And there's also the fact that on the topic of MEV, we have already had a bunch of blocks that have been re... not reorged, like, organized with transactions that basically draw pictures. If you look at the mempool.space explorer. We had a bunch of them that purposely drew pictures and this is already a sign of MEV.

1:45:04It means that the miners are not acting on their best financial incentives or the best financial incentives are not in the mempool.

1:45:16Michael TidwellYeah I mean this is and also it's like where do you stop because MEV depending on how you want to define it and the scope of it is like the whole world of ideas and transactions and tertiary sort of ideas around Bitcoin. Like, for instance, I have a game, right? And my game is a map of the Bitcoin blockchain, right? So it's like a giant map of the Bitcoin blockchain. You can zoom in and out, stuff like that. And every time a block is mined, a new piece of land comes onto the map, right? And the hash of the block, right, the last byte of the block determines the type of terrain that the land will have, okay?

1:46:05Does that make sense?

1:46:07Vlad CosteaOkay, so the type of terrain.

1:46:09Michael TidwellAre you following me? Are you following me on this?

1:46:14Vlad CosteaCan you explain again?

1:46:16Michael TidwellYeah, all right. Listen this time. I'll explain again. So there's a map of the Bitcoin blockchain, right? And every 10 minutes, roughly, when a new block is mined, a new piece of land spawns in the video game. Okay? And the last byte of the hash of the block determines the terrain of that block, right? Okay. So technically speaking, if your civilization or your village or whatever would benefit from a mountain versus a stream versus a field versus a forest, that's like some weird, esoteric type of MEV on Bitcoin. Which is, like, ridiculous... it would be ridiculous to say that that's a type of MEV, but technically, depending on how far you want to go, that's a type of MEV, like, depending on your definition and depending on how extreme you want to go, right?

1:47:08Vlad CosteaI can tell you've played a lot of SimCity.

1:47:10Michael TidwellI have not, but this is a game I'm developing right now, so we can talk about that later. But this is... I'm just saying, like, these MEV arguments can get ridiculous, is what I'm trying to say, hypothetically, depending on how far you want to go.

1:47:29Vlad CosteaYeah. If you want to define it in a certain way, you can say everything is MEV, as long as it doesn't follow some arbitrary rules that you just make up. But let's find out why we don't have drivechains yet. Who's to blame?

1:47:45Michael TidwellIs Paul on this? It would be funny if Paul was also on this wheel.

1:47:52Vlad CosteaSo he could blame himself.

1:47:54Michael TidwellYeah, pretty much. That'd be a... Drum roll. All right. Oh, Paul is up against the spooks. No wonder it hasn't been activated yet. Oh, that's rough, man. Paul is up against the spooks. Paul, I am so sorry for you to figure out that you weren't fighting against... you weren't fighting against developers, you weren't fighting against Matt Corallo, you weren't fighting against the mob on Twitter. You were... You just didn't know they were spooks.

1:48:30Vlad CosteaDamn, so deep. Paul, you gotta tell us if you have any suicidal thoughts. You gotta get it on record.

1:48:40Michael TidwellWell, yeah, we need to have Paul come out with a tweet that says "I'm not suicidal," first off. We also... for you uncovering this, I think they should up your sponsorship by just a little bit, because you're, like, providing real feedback value. This is not easy information to gather. So...

1:49:00Vlad CosteaMaybe they should sponsor TABConf, because you're the one who brought the wheel. So we couldn't find this out without your wheel.

1:49:11Michael TidwellLayerTwo Labs discussions, drivechain discussions, and sponsorship, independent of each other, all welcomed at TABConf. I don't know if Paul is interested this year, but more than happy to have Paul involved.

1:49:30Vlad CosteaAll right. I basically have three balls in the bowl.

1:49:34Michael TidwellI think that's normal. I think it's normal to have three balls.

1:49:39Vlad CosteaOh, I dropped one. I guess that's a sign.

1:49:43Michael TidwellThat's a sign. It's like the lottery. It's like the lottery when the balls are going around and the one drops into... descends. The ball descends.

1:49:52Vlad CosteaI mean, the spooks have ordained this. So this is the solution. Can you see it? It says "hard fork."

1:50:08Michael TidwellDude, this might actually happen. This might actually be how we hard fork: we actually hard fork because of Paul doing something incredible, and then we have this big rift. So I could definitely... like, this might be how it happens, is Paul's like, "Look, the users have decided this feature, this drivechain, is valuable. If you try to stop it, the miners will hard fork." Like...

1:50:35Vlad CosteaMan, this is pure gold. This is pure gold. Like, I couldn't make this up, honestly. I would have preferred the one that says "Listen to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast."

1:50:49Michael TidwellIt would be funny if we get through all the ones and that's not even one of them, for some reason. But if Paul's listening, we do want you to know you're not going hard enough. You haven't hard forked yet. And I think that's really what's missing here to get drivechain in. The spooks are just gonna gatekeep you. So I mean, is there any other way to do it besides a hard fork, Vlad?

1:51:22Vlad CosteaOf course. Convince everyone else. Like, talk to the miners. I think...

1:51:26Michael TidwellHow do you convince spooks?

1:51:28Vlad CosteaHe had this CUSF approach, which means "Core untouched soft fork," that he was pitching to mining pools. I'm not sure what the success was for this, but yeah.

1:51:42Michael TidwellWhat is that still the plan

1:51:45Vlad CosteaI think it is. What I do respect about LayerTwo Labs is that they're not moving very fast, which means that they're very much testing this. And if you're on their Telegram chat, you can see that they do stuff to break their software all the time purposely because they they want to stress test everything. And I respect that. They're not rushing the implementation. But if it happens on Litecoin, I can see it getting some users. If there's gonna be a hard fork of Bitcoin with drivechains I can also see that getting some users. But it's not gonna be the one that's listed on stock market exchanges or whatever. So it's gonna be grassroots.

1:52:31The spooks are not gonna be there to provide the number-go-up component. So I can see why he is still trying to push this on BTC, as opposed to forking off, like...

1:52:45Michael TidwellYeah, the Litecoin conversations are all interesting. I see that as a trap, and also as not a trap. Like, it could go either way. One, it could be like, "Oh, it's on Litecoin. See, no one's using it," you know, because that could easily be, like, a thing. It could be something like, really, you know, like, you start getting down these weird talking points of, like, "See, like, blah, blah, blah happened on Litecoin. See, that's gonna happen on Bitcoin." Or it's like, "Oh, it's a shitcoin technology. Like, it's on Litecoin. Why would we bring that to Bitcoin? It's for shitcoining on..."

1:53:26Vlad CosteaJust like SegWit, Lightning.

1:53:28Michael TidwellYeah. No, it's just like, I could see it being a trap because of, like, some weird kind of, like, logical... like, weird, like, point, and then people are like, "Oh, see..." The other thing, where it isn't necessarily a trap and it could be a good thing, is you say, "Hey, look, see, it's on Litecoin, hasn't been exploited, even though the security budget of Litecoin is, like, way less." We have a bunch of contributors that said, "Hey, why don't you deploy it to Litecoin first, to, like, test it out before we bring it to Bitcoin?"

1:54:00And I've heard Bitcoin contributors say, like, these things exactly. It at least gets rid of that as a talking point, or it helps convince them. I don't know if it would actually help convince them at all, though, in reality, but it would at least get rid of that talking point. It would potentially legitimize the security idea around it and the game theory around it. So that is, like, the positive side of bringing it to Litecoin first, in my opinion.

1:54:37Vlad CosteaI mean, a lot of stuff was tried on Litecoin before it ended up on Bitcoin, starting with SegWit and continuing with Lightning Network applications. I think Phoenix was on Lightning on Litecoin before it was on Bitcoin, right?

1:54:55Michael TidwellAnd LND... I remember very early versions of LND were trying to do swaps between Litecoin and Bitcoin, if I'm not mistaken.

1:55:03Vlad CosteaWeren't they atomic swaps?

1:55:04Michael TidwellYeah, yeah. But, like, they're trying to do it, like, as, like, a Lightning channel kind of idea.

1:55:09Vlad CosteaYeah, that was sort of part of the proposition for Lightning, that it's going to replace exchanges. And of course, we didn't get to that point.

1:55:21Michael TidwellYeah, we just got to the point of trying to make Lightning just work on one coin, versus trying to swap them between multiple chains. But I guess the next big thing is going to be these Taproot Assets channels that are swapping stablecoins.

1:55:35Vlad CosteaI'm trying to fake, like, an enthusiastic face about that, but I seriously don't care about stablecoins.

1:55:45Michael TidwellOh, whether you care about them or not, there's so much... A lot of people are saying, like, this is going to be the next thing, you know. So, yeah.

1:56:04Vlad CosteaThat's a very depressing thought, by the way. And the way people are just okay with it, and they're like, yeah, it helps people in third world countries. And a lot of these guys are under the paycheck of Bitfinex slash Tether anyway, so they look the other way. They're like, oh, Tron, it's a shitcoin. But at the same time, it's the one that is most liquid when it comes to USDT. And if you look at the price charts, actually, I think... not USDT, Tron outperformed Bitcoin since it started being the home of USDT. And that's not something people talk about, but it happened.

1:56:46Michael TidwellI think, yeah, I think like there's this idea that Bitcoin sort of failed to scale quickly for user experience. So you have like these situations of where you have a lot of interest wanting to get in Bitcoin, but then it's it's caused some you know bottlenecks and it's caused like some high-fee markets and it's caused some situations where things are impractical. So then it's like discouraged a big wave of people coming in and then you wait, like, a few years, same thing, wait a few years, same thing. And then you get to the point where people are like, oh, they already have like ideas of Bitcoin from like six, seven, eight years ago. And you know those people have already moved on to other things and it's like, oh, now the solution is going to be like, well, Bitcoin obviously can't work, but these stablecoins can.

1:57:38And it would be really nice if instead of us pushing these stablecoins, we just had like Bitcoin that worked for them. And then it's like, wait, the stablecoin is Bitcoin, like you and like or whatever. Like The idea is like we're not we're not trying to push like a USD dollar on like some financial system that just, you know, thwarts and circumvents the existing financial system so like in terms of like the same sort of currency like it would just be nice if it'd be nice if we were able to do that like legitimate s-curve adoption you know I think that's really where like these things come in like Fedimints, stablecoins, like, all these ideas even like Lightning and Ark like they're all because like you know Going back to like the 2017-2018 sort of discussions.

1:58:38Vlad CosteaIt's a bit desolating when you think about it that the only solutions that raised a lot of money to get built are the more centralized ones as opposed to the ones that actually fulfill the mission. It almost makes you wonder, like, yeah, of course people are gonna start flame wars in the comments and say, wait, Lightning is decentralized because you can open a channel and look the fees are low but can most users open channels right now and transact on Lightning or is is it non-custodial Lightning use the more popular version of it and I don't think that's true. I think most users have sort of embraced the idea that they're gonna accept custodians with Lightning.

1:59:24I think there was a very nice meme that goes back to the Rick and Morty episode with the robot that passes butter. But the meme was that the robot asked, what is my purpose? And the Rick Sanchez in the Bitcoin world said, you get Bitcoiners to accept that. Oh, and the robot is supposed to be the Lightning network. And Rick Sanchez said, you get Bitcoiners to accept that custodians are part of the economy. And the robot is very sad. Like, oh my God, you you it's horrible.

1:59:54Michael TidwellWas that a layer 2 meme? Might have been a LayerTwo Labs meme. That sounds like something that they would come up with.

2:00:02Vlad CosteaThey have very good memes. I don't know why they don't become more popular.

2:00:07Michael TidwellSo, just to be clear...

2:00:08Vlad CosteaI think it's the spooks once again.

2:00:11Michael TidwellJust to be clear, I am a fan of Lightning. I think Lightning has gotten... was marketed as something that it wasn't easily going to be, ever. And I think the problem, and my theory, is why people like Paul critique Lightning so hard is because it becomes a distraction, and becomes something where something like drivechains doesn't then get more adoption and more, like, acceptance and more, you know, energy behind it because of these things. I actually think Lightning itself is very interesting and very good, marketed potentially, like, not correctly.

2:01:03But I think the bigger problem is we didn't also do stuff like drivechain and other like experiments and stuff. So I actually, you know, I like Lightning. I think it's I think it's very like cool. I I like the idea of making it even better. So I hope that's non-controversial

2:01:28Vlad CosteaWell, for the record, I did use Lightning, and I do find it interesting, especially when you have this fungibility issue with your Bitcoins. And in my case, I received donations to addresses that I put on the website. And some people send me Bitcoin for reasons I don't know yet, but I don't know where the coins come from. And I don't want to know where the coins come from. And what's my alternative to send the coins like six or seven hops or coin join them to make sure that some blockchain analysis from an exchange because by the way I do sell Bitcoin unlike most cult members so what should I do to make sure that there's no identity that's associated with them and I don't have to explain to some sort of institution that I do a podcast and I receive donations and they're not gonna believe me.

2:02:20So Lightning is very convenient because you can open a channel and you can send the coins with pretty good sender privacy to an exchange. And the exchange doesn't ask you where the coins come from and I think Coinbase and What's the other one Kraken and also Binance, I think they started supporting Lightning and it's useful for this Particular use case. I think you can say the same for the ones that support Liquid. But for various reasons, I don't like Liquid and where was I going with this? Oh, yeah Lightning It's good for its intended purpose but you should not pretend that it scales, you should not pretend that it's the ultimate scaling solution and nothing else deserves to be tried.

2:03:07It's not the gold standard by any means and it's also very complex even for people who who know what they're doing they can make a lot of mistakes. And this is coming from someone who tried to operate a routing node like four or five years ago. And it wasn't such a good idea. I lost more money than I actually made because my my rationale was that I'm gonna make passive income with my node which was a very popular meme at the time that you're gonna be this third-party intermediary that's routing transactions to others. I opened channels with all the large hubs. I even joined this Telegram chat that was called Ring of Fire, and it was about opening channels in a circular shape so that you're connected with the channels of everyone else.

2:03:57And I still could not get routing fees, and there are reasons for that, because Lightning searches for the fastest route, and I was also using Tor, because of course I don't want everyone to know where I keep my node. And that was detrimental to my mission, and I ended up spending a lot of money opening and closing channels, balancing liquidity, and I got nowhere.

2:04:25Michael TidwellVlad, I'm gonna need you to concisely phrase this into a problem statement.

2:04:35Vlad CosteaSo, something that has someone to blame and has a solution? Yes. The problem is that one of these two solutions left is "Listen to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast," and...

2:04:45Michael TidwellWe don't know that's true. That is a conspiracy that we have subscribed to, but we don't know it's true unless... It's like Schrödinger's cat: we don't know if that's actually the case until we open it up. So...

2:05:04Vlad CosteaWhy isn't Lightning what it was promised to be?

2:05:08Michael TidwellOkay. So the problem is Lightning... the problem is Lightning did not live up to expectations. Is that fair? Yeah. Who is to blame? Who is to blame for Lightning not living up to expectations? Jack Dorsey.

2:05:33Vlad CosteaOh my God. And the one next to it was Blockstream, so it almost got to Blockstream.

2:05:41Michael TidwellOh my God, that would have been great if it was... almost. I mean, it really... like, it was trying to... fate in the universe was trying to decide if it was Jack Dorsey or Blockstream on this one. But, you know, Jack Dorsey did... you know, is very involved with Lightning funding and Spiral and LDK. I mean, it just still makes sense.

2:06:31Vlad CosteaWell, when you think about it, it was Jack Dorsey who paid Matt Corallo to rewrite the Lightning code in Rust. I love Jack Dorsey, but man, he appears to be the one to be blamed for this. He should come to TABConf and explain. Anyway, I have two balls. I'm not gonna play the same game of asking you when to stop. I'll just ask the chat, left or right, and this is gonna provide the solution to making Lightning work as promised. Someone in the chat, Crev23, said, "LN is shitware made for banks." Just the guy who loves Kaspa said right again. So I guess this means right ball, or egg, or whatever this is supposed to be. This is my right. I guess it's your left. Let's see what's inside. Predictable: "Listen to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast."

2:07:18I don't know if this is a solution to anything, but I I had to put the shameless plug inside.

2:07:26Michael TidwellLightning didn't live up to expectations: Jack Dorsey's fault. But to understand and to remediate this, you have to listen to the podcast. It makes sense to me.

2:07:35Vlad CosteaThat's all that matters. It's not the truth that's important. It's whatever is happening in your head right now. If it If it makes sense to you, I'm not even gonna try to elaborate. It's enough. And I have one last solution and we have to think of a very good problem for it. I don't even know which one it is.

2:08:00Michael TidwellI feel like there is a problem that I want to address, which is how many damn Bitcoin conferences there are, like, period. No, I don't want to make one too... so many. I mean, there's just so many Bitcoin conferences. And, you know, I plan my conferences a year in advance, and then people are like, "Oh, man, that's right in the middle of this, this, this, and this." I'm like, whoa, what the heck? Those weren't even planned six months ago. Like, doesn't matter what time of year, there's always a Bitcoin conference, it seems like.

2:08:38Vlad CosteaYeah, I don't know what to say about that. It's just that people like to travel and people like to make money off of other people's knowledge. So yeah, what can I say? Like, I I can think of a bunch of conferences that emerged after COVID. And I can argue that they're much worse than the ones before COVID. I can also argue that we never got to the same intellectual debates that we had during the block size wars when it felt like you had the brightest minds coming up with solutions. And then many of these solutions never went anywhere. Yeah, yeah it's kind of...

2:09:22Michael TidwellI would say the best the best conferences we've had in Bitcoin were probably the scaling conferences. And I would put TABConf as a second to that, or whatever, like behind those conferences, just because they're like OG, original conferences that really tried to do, I think, something in the same vision, which is like progress Bitcoin and have like meaningful kind of conversations, you know.

2:09:48Vlad CosteaI'm not OG enough to talk about this, but there was one in San Jose in 2013, and people swear by it, they say it was the one that changed their life. For example, Sergio Demian Lerner, creator of Rootstock and also the first person to suggest that Satoshi might have mined a million Bitcoin. He attended that one, and that's when he decided he wants to go full Bitcoin and work in this space for the rest of his time. And Gavin Andresen he was pretty big. I was surprised, I think, a couple of weeks ago I asked people on Twitter, what do they know about him? And the most common answer was that he's the one who spoke with the CIA and he's the one who scared Satoshi off and also said that Craig Wright is Satoshi and these are the only three pieces of information that people know about him and it's kind of sad because he also created multisig on Bitcoin for example which he doesn't get credit for.

2:10:54Michael TidwellYeah, I mean, he maintained the project for years. The thing that was weird about Gavin, especially... I have a couple emails with him back and forth, but the thing I don't like is he came out on his, like, ninja blog, whatever he used to use, or if he still uses it, hosted, that he may know who Satoshi is: it's this Craig Wright guy. And then, like, a day later or something, he posted, "I may have been fooled, this is why," and, like, he writes out, like, "Oh, I think I was fooled," right? I think the word was "bamboozled." Bamboo... yeah, whatever. But then he deleted that post, which doesn't make any sense. Or he removed it. At the time, I did not understand that.

2:11:51Vlad CosteaI think the common wisdom surrounding that moment is that he might have signed some sort of NDA with Craig Wright, right?

2:12:01Michael TidwellRight. I think that's something where it's like, he broke the NDA and he had to, like, delete that post. But it was the post that was talking about how he got tricked. And if he had to delete the post that he got tricked, that's really freaking sad, which is insane. Anyways...

2:12:25Vlad CosteaJust wanted to charge my light. Ignore the whole process. We should frame a question for this. Like, who is to blame for the whole Craig Wright situation? It was one of the darkest episodes in the history of Bitcoin.

2:12:40Michael TidwellYeah. Who is to blame for Craig Wright? What, becoming popular, or tricking Gavin, or...?

2:12:51Vlad CosteaJust doing everything that Craig Wright did. Because even today he's on Twitter, and people... yeah, drum roll... people think that he's Satoshi. I had Daniel Krawisz on my show, very smart guy, but he for some reason argues that Craig Wright teaches him about Bitcoin, which is laughable. Roger Ver. Is that the answer?

2:13:17Michael TidwellIt doesn't make any sense, because I think Roger was, like, really against Craig.

2:13:24Vlad CosteaNo, the story between them is that actually Roger gave him the benefit of the doubt, and I think...

2:13:29Michael TidwellOh. Oh, later on he disliked him.

2:13:34Vlad CosteaHe sued him in court and actually won, because they were having these private conversations about Bitcoin and stuff. And at one point, Roger mentioned that there's this checksum in Bitcoin addresses, and Craig Wright was like, "No, there's no checksum." Roger realized, wait, the guy who created Bitcoin doesn't know that there's a checksum? And that was his eureka moment.

2:14:00Michael TidwellThat was like a weird, okay, this is me not understanding pay-to-public key hash, maybe all that great, but there was like some weird technicality where it's like it's really hard for me to understand that specific point because all the, okay, and correct me if I'm wrong, I'm happy to be wrong on something technical, but my understanding was all the clients and all the ways that anyone ever produced like a pay to public key hash, like a dr like you know interfacing with the like the one addresses on on Bitcoin, all had that checksum at the end. However, was it part of consensus?

2:14:47Like Could you hypothetically mine a non-standard transaction without that checksum in the address? And I think that could be true. So like Technically, Craig was like right, but like only like a technicality or something?

2:15:07Vlad CosteaI'm not 100% sure what's the context, right.

2:15:11Michael TidwellRight, but, like, most people, like, whenever you deal with those 1-addresses on Bitcoin, the pay-to-public-key-hashes all have that checksum, right? And it's, like, very standard. Like, every time you interface with it, every wallet, everything, you always have that checksum. It's produced, like, in a standard, normal way. But then I'm wondering if it's, like, some weird technicality where it's like, technically you don't need it, and it's gonna be, like, a burn address or something. But it was weird, because I think also Craig... I mean, Craig, whether he's right or wrong, I think it's like, he also said, like, oh, there's definitely a private key behind this, because... I don't know, I forget the argument. It was some weird... Regardless, it was either, like, an "actually," you know, kind of thing that didn't really make a whole lot of sense and was sort of irrelevant, or it was some sort of, like, Craig just totally didn't know what he was talking about. It was either one of the two, I think.

2:16:15Vlad CosteaWell, either way, it was like the eureka moment. It was what Roger needed to understand that Craig Wright is not Satoshi. We also have a solution for this, even though I'm not sure if there can be a solution, but it's the best one. Can you read it?

2:16:45Michael TidwellYes. "Sell all your Bitcoin." Yeah. So wait, Roger... I mean, dude, I like how some of these things kind of line up in terms of theme, you know what I mean?

2:16:58Vlad CosteaAnd I also have to mention that there was no coordination from your side or my side in determining what these solutions are going to be. Like, I just made up something on time for our interview. I had to run after lunch, basically, to grab these balls. I had to buy some toys to be able to have them. And yeah, "sell all your Bitcoin" is part of the answer. I was thinking this is gonna end up as an answer for the conversation about Bitcoin Knots, like, how do we solve this community conflict? You sell your Bitcoin. But yeah. Maybe we should, as you said, evaluate or re-evaluate this fortune-telling methodology.

2:17:48It's peer-to-peer it's also decentralized in some ways, and it's random. What What do you think is a legit reason to sell all your Bitcoin, like, what's the catastrophic event that is gonna make you say, okay, I'm done, I'm out?

2:18:14Michael TidwellSo I think it's going to be something along the lines of a boogeyman sort of thing where the technology is broken, there's no clear recovery path, and you're just trying to exit before other people can. Some sort of like, whether, I mean, I'm just putting out something random, like a quantum attack without any sort of preparation is, you know, I think very unlikely, but like that might be a situation, a situation where Bitcoin sort of crosses the line morally for that individual or ethically could be a situation. But I mean, there's not going to be many reasons in actuality.

2:19:00I do want to say one thing though, just to follow back up, because I like technical conversations, the checksum and the pay to public key hash addresses is not part of consensus. So yes, you can you you don't need that checksum, hypothetically I mean, obviously, you're not going to ever be able to spend those coins, but if you do if you if you have like like, for instance, the counterparty address has a checksum, it's like 1CounterpartyXXX and then the checksum or something, you technically don't need that checksum. I I would love to be corrected on that, but I believe that's the case. I I think it's I think it's part of maybe like relay policy and stuff, but I don't know if it's part of consensus.

2:19:56I think you literally just end up burning those coins and destroying them, essentially, if you send to, like, a fake address or something. Anyhow, yeah, not to defend Craig Wright or anything, but I think that is technically how it works, or what you could do. So I think a lot of...

2:20:17Vlad CosteaAlso, I think they're, like, in awe right now, because BitVM was discovered, right, by Robin Linus. They're like, well, Craig Wright has been claiming that Bitcoin is Turing complete since 2015.

2:20:32Michael TidwellYeah, dude the BSV people are real interesting. I remember having a, on on I remember joining Clubhouse. Some people got me on Clubhouse and there's a BSV group on there and I joined and talked to them. And I said, at what point are you willing to understand that Craig Wright is full of it and that you're willing to abandon BSV and everything was like, Oh, well, he says he's going to do this in the next two weeks or this in the next three months or whatever. Definitely after that, we're going to abandon it. And I think slowly after time, I mean, I can't imagine many people are still on board with BSV at this point. I mean, is it really just Daniel Krawisz?

2:21:15Vlad CosteaDaniel Krawisz. There's another guy who does a podcast that's called the Crypto Vigilante, which I think he inherited from Jeff Berwick. So there are some ties here. There's there's also a guy who runs a meme page, which is about Squatting Slavs in Tracksuits. That's what it's called. Squatting Slavs in Tracksuits. It's really fascinating. It's an interesting topic because in this Eastern Europe, squatting is quite a thing. Like when People are talking or whatever and they don't have a bench to sit, they just squat. And tracksuits are also popular. Like especially the Adidas ones, like everyone has one in their wardrobe

2:22:06Michael TidwellAre the Slavs, like, the real Bitcoin maximalists that don't have any chairs? Not even in their house, but, like, on the streets and in their society, there's just no chairs. So they're the real Bitcoin maximalists.

2:22:20Vlad CosteaMight be.

2:22:21Michael TidwellWell, there you go. Good way to end on a squat note.

2:22:29Vlad CosteaOh, you want to end this?

2:22:31Michael TidwellOh, I'm just saying, if we're... I mean, we're out of balls. I mean, I came here just to look at your blue balls, and you've opened all of them, and we've uncovered all the mysteries inside of them. I mean, what else do you want to talk about?

2:22:49Vlad CosteaIt's interesting that the contents in the blue balls is white.

2:22:53Michael TidwellI do need to probably peace out in 15, just FYI.

2:23:01Vlad CosteaOkay. I just wanted to ask you, like, some practical advice. You've been around for a long time. And there seems to be, like, a mental health problem in Bitcoin right now. Some are becoming overzealous and others are sort of losing interest. Like, how do you navigate all of this noise and chaos? And how do you even find some kind of voice who is reasonable? Because, of course, I'm not sure how objective you are in this conversation, where OCEAN mining and Knots are trying to say that Bitcoin is being attacked, and this is a CVE, it's a hack, they're exploiting the code, they're raping everyone's nodes.

2:23:49I don't recall all the narratives that they have been using, but where do you find some sort of clarity in all of this situation and what do you recommend to people to actually do when they stumble upon this manufactured crisis?

2:24:06Michael TidwellYeah, that's a great question.

2:24:07So I think it really depends on how and why you got into Bitcoin. When I got into Bitcoin for maybe about six months to eight months, I spent nearly all my time trying to prove that Bitcoin was a flawed technology to my coworkers at the time where I worked in an IT center, like a software developer hardware, everything was just, you know, a lot of smart engineers I worked with. And we discussed Bitcoin at length. And I thought this was ultimately going to fail. And this was a bad idea.

2:24:49And I spent a lot of my time trying to do gotchas and trying to be like, oh, well, this would happen, blah, blah. And the more that we talked it out over the course of six months, and the more me trying to defeat and prove that Bitcoin had bad ideas, it seemed to have some sort of answer that addressed like nearly every concern I had to the point where like, I wish I was just dumb and like whatever. I wish I just FOMO'd in and figured out how to buy Bitcoin earlier than I did, but you know, Maybe I'd be like super rich, but I spent all that time trying to figure out or trying to prove that Bitcoin was a bad idea and in the process of doing so convinced myself, like, holy crap, this is actually a very elegant solution to all sorts of problems that I thought it would be subject to and to the point of absurdity.

2:25:49So I actually take a different sort of idea. I have different ideas than most people. I think if Bitcoin, for instance, only had one miner, like one miner, like completely centralized, that Bitcoin would still survive very easily and it would potentially have periods of centralization and decentralization ebb and flows. It would actually survive that long term. So over, you know, decades and hundred year sort of periods, you would have periods of mass centralization and mass decentralization ebb flow and Bitcoin would actually survive these sort of events because of the technology itself and ultimately the premise of you being able to wait for more confirmations and wait things out and stuff like this.

2:26:37So I kind of come at this with a completely different approach and a different sort of mindset, I think, than a lot of people. So I don't necessarily get like disturbed or whatever when non-ideal things happen. And I don't necessarily subscribe to a lot of the issues that other people have, especially like the cultural, emotional sort of ideas, because I got into Bitcoin because I'm like, oh, it's actually immune to these sort of ideas through a dry sort of consensus and technical process. And that's how you sort of squash these ideas where you don't need a House of Representatives and a Congress to sort of facilitate, you know, these policies at the consensus layer.

2:27:19So I would say that my understanding and conviction of the technology being a good idea came from a place that was maybe a little bit more based in my head where a lot of things like, for instance, people inscribing JPEGs do not bother me at all. Really. For instance, that bothers people ad nauseam. People are like, oh, people don't take us serious. It's going to, people are going to price out financial transactions. People are going to blah, blah, blah. People are going to do this. Like, I'm like, bro, like I've already thought about this.

2:27:58I thought about these kind of things for months and months and months. And like, have you, are you just now thinking about this? You've been in Bitcoin for five plus years and now this is bothering you? Like, like what? So I think that has something to do with it. You have to, you have to sort of, you have to sort of understand that the premise around Bitcoin doesn't like, is actually a little bit more robust than we give it credit for. I remember someone saying like, if this were to kill Bitcoin, then Bitcoin was doomed already.

2:28:33And how this person on Twitter today got like a bunch of flack. I forget who it was, but like, I kind of, like, I think it's like, it makes perfect sense to have that sort of opinion. I think that, you know, people do not have that opinion. They believe that Bitcoin is secured by, you know, the community around it with this squishy software. And this is actually also where Greg Maxwell and I sort of have disagreements. We agreed to like disagree on some things. Like Greg, like I'm not even at the point where like, again, a point of some people may think this is absurdity, but whatever like Bitcoin is whatever the most people like say, like, this is Bitcoin.

2:29:20Like if Bitcoin Cash hypothetically got more hash rate for an extended period of time, the price of Bitcoin Cash became like vastly greater than BTC Bitcoin. We would be calling Bitcoin Cash Bitcoin, and I would be okay with that because that is how Bitcoin, in my opinion, in my head works. And that's how you resolve these sort of super controversial conflicts as you fork. And instead of trying to guess which side is going to win, you just say, Fuck yeah, I don't care. Like, whatever happens happens, that's going to be the new Bitcoin.

2:29:54Now, this is where people, a lot of Core contributors will disagree with me, like people like Greg Maxwell and others that are very respectable in the space. I think it's like, if everyone calls a shoe, like a guitar, then even though it makes absolutely no sense, that's how language is changing. That's how culture is changing, whatever. It's like, you can't really control that. So yeah, I think that sort of helps where you can kind of be a little less emotionally disturbed when a lot of these events happen.

2:30:30So that's my long answer of saying, why, you know, like showing like why some people are more resilient to, you know, events than others. That's my theory, at least.

2:30:43Vlad CosteaRight. But let's assume that we're talking about someone who doesn't know anything about how Bitcoin works and just follows the opinions of people, which is a large majority by this point. So where should these people seek clarity? Like, obviously, they're not TABConf.

2:31:02Michael TidwellYeah. So I think that's like really important. You have to know how Bitcoin works. You have to clear up these misconceptions. I think if you didn't start by questioning Bitcoin and you didn't start by saying Bitcoin was a bad idea, I think you're doing it wrong. I think you should always assume Bitcoin was a terrible idea and you should prove yourself otherwise by coming to TABConf. I don't know. Earlier I said, after you figure out Bitcoin's a good idea, come to TABConf, but maybe if you don't think Bitcoin's a good idea, still come to TABConf, you know, whatever.

2:31:32Vlad CosteaMaybe Taleb is gonna buy a ticket.

2:31:36Michael TidwellYeah, I think it would be really fun if we did have a bunch of critical thinkers that were not fans of Bitcoin, actually like not fans of crypto period even, or just not fans of Bitcoin, whatever, have meaningful debates. I would just want to make sure that that was curated in a way that wasn't just a waste of time because I can easily see those things just being like, you know, slop entertainment as well.

2:32:00Vlad CosteaOh, get David Gerard. The guy from r/Buttcoin.

2:32:11Michael TidwellWe'll see if he comes.

2:32:12Vlad CosteaYeah, that would be sure.

2:32:15Michael TidwellI'm sure He'll come one day.

2:32:18Vlad CosteaI'm really happy that you keep going with TABConf. It seems to be I'm not sure if it's growing every year or if there's like a constant number of attendees, but the fact that it's still happening and it's still going means a lot. There is a lot of value in traditions, and I hope that this year I'll be able to join it under some capacity. And I do want to present you my comic, which once again is called Bitcoin Year One. And it was drawn by my girlfriend.

2:32:48I'm very proud of the outcome. And I basically I'm trying to make it kid friendly and also make it friendly to anyone who doesn't have the patience to read the book or scroll through lots of Bitcoin Talk threads to come to some conclusion about what happened. In the history of Bitcoin. And if this becomes successful, I can do about basically I think the second year Bitcoin is more interesting. It's when we got Gavin. It's when we got Laszlo, Wladimir van der Laan and all of these people who changed.

2:33:22Was it Greg Maxwell who joined at the time also? I'm not sure about his story.

2:33:27Michael TidwellI think Greg was, like, a 2010, 2011 kind of joiner, but he might have been earlier. I don't know. Yeah. Anyway, but I will say, so, I kind of lied. I do like to read sometimes. And one thing I love reading about is history, especially of the space I'm in. And one book I really much enjoyed was Aaron, Aaron with a... van Wirdum.

2:33:56Vlad CosteaYeah. The Genesis Book.

2:33:58Michael TidwellThat is my favorite book, hands down. Of all the books...

2:34:03Vlad CosteaOf all the books, or just the Bitcoin books?

2:34:08Michael TidwellAll the Bitcoin books so far. That, granted, I haven't given really much effort to any of the other books, but I really enjoyed that one. I love history where I feel like it's right. You know, I feel like he did, like, the effort to, like, you know, drill into these things. So if you're also doing, like, history, I would probably be very, very inclined to, like, read it. So thank you.

2:34:35Vlad CosteaI've had Aaron on. He spoke about his book. You can listen to that episode if you want to find out more. Thank you very much, Michael. This has been very much fun. And we we actually, if anything, I think this episode proved that there's merits to fortune telling. Oh, what is this for?

2:34:59Michael TidwellWe're just fortune telling. We're free balling. So we have no more balls.

2:35:03Vlad CosteaWe get the answer before we get the question. Casey Rodarmor. That might be the next guest on the podcast. I don't know.

2:35:12Michael TidwellThat's how you figure out your next guest. You spin the wheel, and that's how you know. So, Casey, you're up next. I'm passing the ordinal torch... what is it, the ordinal baton to you? You're up next on Vlad's podcast, the Bitcoin Takeover. I will listen in to that, Casey. Can't wait to see you in action.

2:35:35Vlad CosteaThank you very much, Michael. Buy your tickets to TABConf. The website is 7.tabconf.com, which is T-A-B-C-O-N-F.com...

2:35:45Michael TidwellOr just tabconf.com. We'll take them there.

2:35:49Vlad CosteaYeah. And also, thanks to the sponsors, which Michael also absolutely adores: Bitcoin.com News, LayerTwo Labs, Citrea, SideShift.ai, and NoOnes. Thank you very much. I'll see you in the next one on Monday, when I have Vik. It's actually Vikrant Sharma, I think that's the way you pronounce it, CEO of Cake Wallet. So it's not Casey Rodarmor, unfortunately. Oh, that's so nice. Vik from Cake Wallet. He should sponsor TABConf. I should tell him.

2:36:31Michael TidwellWait, are you talking about Vik? I think we predicted him correctly.

2:36:34Vlad CosteaVik? Yeah, yeah. Right next to Vitalik.

2:36:39Michael TidwellBoom. Then no one will ever know.

2:36:43Vlad CosteaThank you, sir. Hope I'll see you in Atlanta.

2:36:46Michael TidwellAll right, man. Thank you. Bye. Bye.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00