BIP 2 (2016) set the BIP process and made BIP editors responsible for assigning numbers and merging. By early 2024 the repository had a months-long backlog, and BIP 3 later rewrote the process.
Add editors
Ava Chow proposed new editors with the same permissions as Luke Dashjr to clear the backlog and answer authors in a timely manner.
Not that list
The nominations became a weeks-long argument over who should hold the merge button. Matt Corallo backed only some candidates and objected to the rest.
The editor role decides whether a proposal gets a number and a merge. With one active editor and more than a hundred open pull requests, proposals were left waiting for answers.
In April 2024 five new editors were added: Bryan “Kanzure” Bishop, Jon Atack, Mark “Murch” Erhardt, Olaoluwa “Roasbeef” Osuntokun and Ruben Somsen. BIP 3 reached rough consensus and was deployed in January 2026, replacing BIP 2 and cutting nine statuses down to four.
- 23 Feb 2024Luke Dashjr: 133 open pull requests and no other active editor. [1]
- 27 Feb 2024Ava Chow proposes adding editors. [1]
- 21 Apr 2024Matt Corallo objects to most of the candidate list. [1]
- Apr 2024Five new BIP editors are added. [1]
- 9 Jan 2025BIP 3 is assigned. [1]
- Jan 2026BIP 3 is deployed and replaces BIP 2. [1]
“There's 133 pull requests open in the #Bitcoin Improvement Proposal repository, going back several months.😵”
X · 23 Feb 2024 · source
“I think this would significantly help get through the backlog of BIPs PRs, and responding to them in a timely manner to significantly reduce the friction of getting BIPs changes merged.”
bitcoin-dev · 27 Feb 2024 · source
“For the avoidance of doubt, this is an objection to the rest of the list.”
bitcoin-dev · 21 Apr 2024 · source