Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Bitcoin Takeover / BIPs / Drama Hall / SegWit, the UASF and SegWit2x

SegWit, the UASF and SegWit2x

Activated
What it proposed

Segregated Witness as a soft fork via BIP 9 (95% of miners), then — when miners stalled — a user-activated deadline (BIP 148) and a miner-side bridge (BIP 91).

SegWit + UASF · Core developers, Shaolin Fry, many node runners

Fix malleability and add capacity by soft fork. If miners won't signal, reject their blocks from 1 August 2017 (BIP 148).

VS

Miners and the New York Agreement

Withhold signalling as leverage; activate SegWit only as part of “SegWit2x”, with a 2 MB hard fork about 90 days later.

Why it blew up

It put the question “who activates soft forks?” to a live test, with a chain-split threat from users (BIP 148) and a hard-fork threat from businesses and miners (SegWit2x).

Outcome

BIP 91 locked in on 21 July and activated on 26 July 2017; SegWit locked in at block 479,808 (9 Aug) and activated at block 481,824 (24 Aug 2017). Bitcoin Cash split on 1 August. The 2 MB half (SegWit2x) was suspended on 8 November 2017.

Timeline
  1. 15 Nov 2016The BIP 9 SegWit deployment (bit 1, 95% threshold) opens; it times out on 15 Nov 2017. [1]
  2. 25 Feb 2017shaolinfry proposes user-activated soft forks: a flag day enforced by nodes, not a miner vote. [1]
  3. 26 Feb 2017Jameson Lopp asks how a flag day behaves if most miners resist. [1]
  4. 12 Mar 2017BIP 148 is assigned: from 1 August 2017, nodes reject blocks that do not signal for SegWit. [1]
  5. 22 May 2017James Hilliard proposes BIP 91 — SegWit at 80% on bit 4, to meet the BIP 148 date without a split; Matt Corallo backs it. [1] [2] [3]
  6. 24 Aug 2017SegWit activates at block 481,824. [1]
In their own words
“As such, soft forks rules are actually always enforced by the nodes, not the miners.”
shaolinfry · UASF proposer
bitcoin-dev · 25 Feb 2017 · source
“Secondly, miner signalling has a natural veto which allows a small percentage of hashrate to veto node activation of the upgrade for everyone.”
shaolinfry · UASF proposer
bitcoin-dev · 25 Feb 2017 · source
“If the flag day soft fork is activated with only a minority of hashrate support + safely opted-out hashrate, isn't it possible for the rest of miners to coordinate orphaning any soft fork compatible blocks to kill the soft fork chain?”
Jameson Lopp · raising the risk
bitcoin-dev · 26 Feb 2017 · source
“The goal here is to minimize chain split risk and network disruption while maximizing backwards compatibility and still providing for rapid activation of segwit at the 80% threshold using bit 4.”
James Hilliard · BIP 91 author
bitcoin-dev · 22 May 2017 · source
“Given the overwhelming support for SegWit across the ecosystem of businesses and users, this seems reasonable to me.”
Matt Corallo · on BIP 91
bitcoin-dev · 22 May 2017 · source
In the Bitcoin Takeover Wiki
Heard on Bitcoin Takeover
Every quote is checked word-for-word against the fetched source by tools/verify_quotes.py. Summaries are Bitcoin Takeover’s own.
0:000:00