2013–2020 · BIP 70
BIP 70 and the BitPay payment-protocol fight
What it proposed
BIP 70 (2013) replaced copying an address with a payment request fetched from the merchant’s server and authenticated with X.509 certificates.
BitPay
From late 2017 it required the Payment Protocol on its invoices, saying wallets that matter already supported it.
VS
Samourai, Bitcoin Core contributors and many users
BIP 70 adds certificate and network attack surface and depends on the merchant’s server. Mandating it locked out wallets that can only pay an address.
Why it blew up
A dominant payment processor made an optional standard mandatory, so people whose wallets lacked it could no longer pay BitPay invoices.
Outcome
Bitcoin Core disabled BIP 70 by default in 0.19.0 and removed it entirely in 0.20.0. The BIP header still says Deployed because other software kept using it.
Timeline
- Nov–Dec 2017BitPay gives notice, then requires the Payment Protocol (14 December 2017). [1]
- 2019Bitcoin Core 0.19.0 disables BIP 70 by default (PR #15584). [1] [2]
- 2020Bitcoin Core 0.20.0 removes BIP 70 entirely. [1]
In their own words
“These true bitcoin wallets all already ‘speak’ Payment Protocol”
quoted by Bitcoin Magazine · Dec 2017 · source
“Samourai Wallet will not support BIP70 in our products”
quoted by Bitcoin Magazine · Dec 2017 · source
“Bitpay's recent announcement of exclusively using the Bitcoin Payment Protocol (BIP 70) has caused some irritation. No longer can you just send to an address.”
r/Bitcoin · source
“BIP70 has resulted in remotely exploitable vulnerabilities that would allow an attacker to steal the wallet's private keys.”
Reddit comment, quoted in Core PR #15584 (Mar 2019) · source
In the Bitcoin Takeover Wiki
Sources: BIP 70, “Payment Protocol”, bitcoin/bips (commit a7f9132, 2026-11-17) · Bitcoin Magazine, “Wallet developers express security concerns over BitPay’s Payment Protocol policy” · Bitcoin Core PR #15584, disable BIP70 support by default · Bitcoin Core 0.19.0 release notes · Bitcoin Core 0.20.0 release notes · r/Bitcoin, achow101: “Annoyed by BitPay’s exclusive use of the payment protocol?”