Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Bitcoin Takeover / BIPs / Drama Hall / Seed words: the standard Core never adopted
2013–today · BIP 39

Seed words: the standard Core never adopted

Standoff
What it proposed

BIP 39 turns a wallet’s secret into a list of 12 to 24 words from a fixed wordlist, with a built-in checksum, and stretches the words into a seed with PBKDF2.

Most hardware and mobile wallets

BIP 39, written by Marek Palatinus, Pavol Rusnak, Aaron Voisine and Sean Bowe, became the common backup format. Its header says Deployed.

VS

Electrum and Bitcoin Core contributors

The checksum depends on the wordlist and there is no version number, so a seed doesn’t say how to derive its wallet. Electrum refuses to generate BIP 39 seeds and Bitcoin Core never implemented them.

Why it blew up

Bitcoin’s most widely used backup format was rejected by the reference implementation and by one of the oldest wallets, so people moving seeds between wallets still run into incompatible formats.

Outcome

Still a standoff. BIP 39 is Deployed across the ecosystem, Electrum keeps its own Seed Version System, and Bitcoin Core has no BIP 39 support.

Timeline
  1. 2013BIP 39 is proposed. [1]
  2. Electrum 2.0Electrum switches to its own versioned Seed Version System and documents why it won’t generate BIP 39 seeds. [1]
  3. Jun 2019Ava Chow explains on Stack Exchange why Bitcoin Core does not implement BIP 39. [1]
In their own words
“BIP39 still requires the wordlist in order to compute its checksum, which is plainly inconsistent”
Electrum documentation
electrum.readthedocs.io · source
“For these reasons, Electrum does not generate BIP39 seeds.”
Electrum documentation
electrum.readthedocs.io · source
“BIP 39 is not in Bitcoin Core largely for implementation reasons and because BIP 39 is not as secure as it could be.”
Ava Chow
Bitcoin Stack Exchange · Jun 2019 · source
Every quote is checked word-for-word against the fetched source by tools/verify_quotes.py. Summaries are Bitcoin Takeover’s own.
0:000:00