S16 E28: Proof of Work Alliance with Charles Chong, Summer Meng & Spencer Yang
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript13,989 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
I came into this episode with a suspicion I did not bother to hide: an alliance of miners and ASIC manufacturers sounds like the thing a 51% attacker would set up as cover. The Proof of Work Alliance, or PoWA, launched on Bitcoin Pizza Day, and I had been given the news in a form that "basically turned what was supposed to be an article into a podcast." So we went live with three guests who had a lot to say about why they formed it. Charles Chong and Spencer Yang come from Fractal Bitcoin and Blockspace Force, and Summer Meng is the CEO of Bitmars. The founding roster reads like a mining industry directory: F2Pool, SpiderPool, Bitmars, ElphaPex, iPollo, Fortitude Mining, Fractal, Psy Protocol, ETC, StandardHash and bit.com.
It ran for an hour and twenty minutes, long enough to wander into Laszlo Hanyecz, zombie apocalypses, Tron fees and a $300 home miner that Summer's husband, Christian, had given me. I wore a pizza shirt from Maison Lachie. Bitcoin hit $111,111 while I was reading the sponsor spot, which I announced to the room with more excitement than the sponsor probably wanted.
Why Almost Nobody Launches a Proof of Work Chain Anymore
Charles opened with the problem the alliance is meant to address. "We are lucky to see even one new Proof of Work chain launch in a year," Charles said. The obstacle is bootstrapping: "It's very hard to bootstrap a Proof of Work network," Charles told me, "because all the miners have their sites built for ASICs." If your new coin runs on something other than the machines already sitting in those sites, nobody shows up. And the machines have a shape. "The power draw, the form factor, the shoebox mining form factor, you won't be able to get miners to mine your coin" unless your coin fits that form factor.
Spencer's answer to my suspicion about alliances started with an admission: "there's a bit of a stigma against alliances" in crypto, and PoWA's plan is to get ahead of it by making sure research and tools come out "public from day one." Summer described a more practical role. For ASIC suppliers in China, PoWA gives a platform to talk to the global community, and she put the whole project down to the fact that "people is always about people."
Would a Club of Miners and Manufacturers Collude?
I asked the question directly. If hashrate owners, pools and hardware makers sit in one room, what stops them from coordinating a 51% attack? Charles did not wave it off, and the argument was about incentives: "each company operates so that they are protecting their own economic interest and not sacrificing their own economic interest." The membership also spans several verticals, and "no member in each of this vertical would like collusion in other verticals."
Spencer added that "overall collusion is bad for crypto," and then explained why he thinks a mixed membership helps: "having a very, very diverse group of participants, I think it really helps to essentially have everyone's views to be considered, right?" In his framing an alliance works like a poll, since diversity lowers the risk of any single view steering the group. I told him I would believe it when I saw how the alliance behaved, and he agreed that behavior was the thing to watch.
The Stratum V2 Chicken and the ASIC Egg
When the conversation turned to technical upgrades, Charles used Stratum V2 as the example. Adoption is stalled because hardware makers will not ship support until pools demand it, and pools will not demand it until the hardware exists. "It now becomes a chicken and egg problem," Charles said. An alliance that contains both sides of that standoff is, in Charles's account, one of the better arguments for PoWA existing at all.
On the ASIC market itself, Charles thinks the industry is still maturing: "I would say like the ASIC mining space is still not that mature." As efficiency gains from 3nm chips shrink, entry gets easier, since a newcomer no longer has to leapfrog a generation. Summer was more cautious. From the manufacturing side, she called it "extremely capital-intensive and complex," and she was clear about how much effort sits between a chip design and a machine in a warehouse.
I had the Braiins miner Christian gave me sitting on my desk, so I took the chance to talk about home mining. Charles put retail mining at "like 5% of the entire network," which is not nothing but is nowhere near enough to be the backbone. I tried a thought experiment about Bitaxes. Marathon has 60 exahash, Charles pointed out, "so that's 60, 60 million Bitaxes that you need people to buy." Spencer offered the best case for household miners: "we have a zombie apocalypse," and if the grids fail, a network of home devices could in theory keep Bitcoin alive. I repeated something I had heard from someone much smarter than me, that every winter heater is a wasted miner. Spencer had a nerdier remark in return: "at the end of the day, you know, we are all just following Moore's law, right?"
I later recorded a whole episode with Summer on this subject, S17 E16: Summer Meng on Bitmars, Selling Bitcoin ASICs & Heating Your Home with Miners, so I will not rehash the heater business here.
Christmas Lights, Grid Stabilizers and the Singapore Figure
The energy argument is the one every miner gets asked about, and the guests had numbers. Spencer said "about 40%, 40 to 50% of energy that is used for Bitcoin mining today is actually from sustainable as well as renewable sources." He also gave the scale: the industry consumes four times the energy of Singapore. His case for accepting that figure was about output, since "that productive output is what we humans really want," and he called the use of energy, resources and attention to meet that demand "very, very important."
Charles went for the comparison I expected: "Bitcoin mining uses less electricity than Christmas lights." Charles added that "Bitcoin miners are the most price sensitive electricity power users," which means they gravitate to the cheapest power, and the cheapest power is often renewable or stranded. And Charles thinks the grid side is underappreciated: "I think most people don't understand that the role that Bitcoin miners play in stabilizing the grid, supporting demand response programs, I think those are great benefit to the power grid."
I pushed on the headlines about data-center-scale power draws. Charles said "the power density is what's drawing headline as well," and that mining is getting denser as AI hardware competes for the same sites. I brought up Spencer's earlier remark that OpenAI's reported acquisition of Jony Ive signals a hardware race with very high stakes, and we agreed the pressure on power will not ease soon. See also S15 E8: Ryan Condron on Bitcoin Mining, Hashrate Markets & Lumerin.
ASIC Resistance, Merge Mining and the Developer Question
Fractal Bitcoin is a merge-mined network, so I asked the obvious thing: why not make a coin ASIC resistant and be done with it? Charles said it is "super hard to make something ASIC resistant unless it's fully randomized." The merge mining design, in Charles's description, trades one problem for another. A miner pointing hashrate at a secondary protocol has no loyalty to it. "I view that as free money," Charles said, and "I'll just mine it and sell it." That creates sell pressure.
Along the way I tried to give Laszlo Hanyecz credit for something. Spencer's joke was that Laszlo may have bought the 10,000 BTC pizzas partly out of guilt for shifting mining from CPUs to GPUs, and he added the serious version: "Laszlo actually was one of the first people to design a program, I think, to allow you to use GPUs to mine Bitcoin." It was the right episode to be telling that on Pizza Day.
Racetracks, Ordinals and Drivechains
Charles listed what PoWA might research first, and MEV came up: "MEV has been a thing in Ethereum for a long time and then it briefly appeared in the Bitcoin world during the Ordinals time." Heat recapture was another candidate. Charles also said "most miners love" inscriptions, and that Ordinals generated "more than $200 million" in fees, a figure that explains why miners had little interest in filtering them.
Spencer described block space with an image I liked: "the Bitcoin block space is almost like a racetrack." In his account, fee spikes come from whatever is racing at the moment, namely Ordinals, Runes and Babylon staking. On the politics he said the alliance is "essentially quite neutral in how we look at Bitcoin development," and "No one is trying to take over Bitcoin with those kinds of efforts."
My own view on the inscription fight is that "It's a nothing burger, mostly," and that "The conversation is too emotional and not rational enough." I also said that "we're opening the gates for Ethereum to be useful, for Litecoin to be useful," meaning that the more things Bitcoin can do, the less pressure there is on other chains to do them. Spencer said the opposite mood exists in Bitcoin: "people feel like Bitcoin should stop innovating." Then he added, "I may cry a little bit about it at night."
I asked about drivechains, the idea that other networks could orbit Bitcoin and settle against it. Spencer answered first and disclaimed expertise: "Definitely not the drivechain expert over here." He did raise a concern, which is that "if we have entire dependence on Bitcoin, that may or may not be a good thing as well," plus a worry about software bloat. Charles passed: "I don't have too much to add over there." I later recorded an episode with Paul Sztorc, who hard forked Bitcoin to launch eCash with drivechains.
Stablecoins on Bitcoin, Tron at $7 and What PoWA Does Next
The part of the conversation that surprised me most was about where Bitcoin innovation actually lives. Spencer said it has been drifting to other chains like Solana, and gave the reason: "That Bitcoin innovation has to be on other chains to be listed on these exchanges." Exchange listing requirements push builders away. I pointed out that "people are willing to pay $7 to send a transaction on Tron," which suggests demand for stablecoin transfers is real enough to absorb a steep fee. Spencer's view is that there is "no reason why Bitcoin network shouldn't have stablecoins on it." He noted that Tether has announced Taproot Assets support, and that BRC-20 already has "a mint and burn mechanism" that "allows them to actually mint stablecoins."
The goal for PoWA is to "show the world what can be done with these protocols," and Summer's contribution to the wish list was concrete: "if we can tip the delivery guy in sats, that will be amazing."
On the price side, Spencer treats volatility as a feature of proof of work launches and said PoWA may research "better price discovery around proof of work projects as well." Closing the episode, he said the alliance's job is to "remind us why we're here." He told listeners that "every ecosystem provider is welcome to participate in" PoWA, and the site for anyone who wants to look is powalliance.com. The first research and tooling publications are the next thing to expect, going out in public from the first day.
I did, in the last stretch, call Summer the shyest guest before realizing she was muted. Charles also noted that "I know Spencer got a two minute exception" to the closing time limit, and Spencer used it.
Listen to Charles Chong, Summer Meng & Spencer Yang on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:00:50– Introducing Charles, Summer & Spencer
- 00:01:43– Overview of the PoW Alliance
- 00:02:32– Challenges in Launching PoW Projects
- 00:04:19– Formation of the PoW Alliance
- 00:05:21– Importance of Collaboration
- 00:06:48– Significance of the PoW Alliance
- 00:08:26– Members of the PoW Alliance
- 00:09:24– Addressing Environmental Concerns
- 00:10:29– Renewable Energy in Bitcoin Mining
- 00:12:37– Electricity Usage Comparisons
- 00:15:21– AI and Bitcoin Mining Competition
- 00:20:55– Centralization vs. Decentralization in Alliances
- 00:22:50– Discussion on Risk and Collaboration
- 00:23:44– Analogy with Polling
- 00:24:15– Social Coordination in Bitcoin
- 00:25:04– ASIC Manufacturing Oligopoly
- 00:26:55– Challenges for New ASIC Manufacturers
- 00:28:43– Emerging Competitors in Mining
- 00:29:39– Mining's Capital Intensity
- 00:30:42– ASIC Resistance Debate
- 00:31:16– Economic Incentives in Mining
- 00:32:38– Proof of Work Alliance Benefits
- 00:33:50– Historical Context of Mining Innovations
- 00:35:10– Decentralization vs. Large Mining Pools
- 00:36:34– Impact of Economic and Social Factors
- 00:38:05– Innovation in Proof of Work
- 00:40:30– Challenges in Mining Innovation
- 00:41:11– Broader Ecosystem Innovations
- 00:42:15– Micro Innovations in Mining
- 00:43:17– Merge Mining Popularity
- 00:45:03– Proof of Stake Popularity
- 00:45:29– Validator Business Models
- 00:47:10– Alignment Issues in Mining
- 00:48:34– Blind Merged Mining Discussion
- 00:49:20– Risks of Drivechains
- 00:52:14– Concerns Over Block Rewards
- 00:54:19– Debate on OP_Return Function
- 00:56:20– Passion in Bitcoin Debates
- 01:00:04– Concerns About Ossification
- 01:03:26– Impact of Inscriptions on Miners
- 01:05:30– The Importance of Cross-Chain Integration
- 01:06:05– Challenges of Bitcoin Adoption
- 01:07:12– Gas Fees Comparison
- 01:08:05– Stablecoins in the Bitcoin Ecosystem
- 01:10:53– Celebrating Pizza Day
- 01:14:30– Fractal Bitcoin's Pizza Challenge
- 01:16:14– Reflections on Market Volatility
- 01:18:22– Joining the PoW Alliance
- 01:19:12– How to Contact Charles, Summer & Spencer
- 01:20:42– Closing Remarks and Future Announcements
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
94bd7ca4377cd1bd286db1b6a65a41c229d4c41332f49ba1ddffedd8f134e653- Proof
- 2025-05-31_s16_e28_proof_of_work_alliance_with_charles_chong_summer_meng_spencer_yang_-_31.05.2025_12.57.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 31 May 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2025-05-31_s16_e28_proof_of_work_alliance_with_charles_chong_summer_meng_spencer_yang_-_31.05.2025_12.57.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2025-05-31_s16_e28_proof_of_work_alliance_with_charles_chong_summer_meng_spencer_yang_-_31.05.2025_12.57.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2025-05-31_s16_e28_proof_of_work_alliance_with_charles_chong_summer_meng_spencer_yang_-_31.05.2025_12.57.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2025-05-31_s16_e28_proof_of_work_alliance_with_charles_chong_summer_meng_spencer_yang_-_31.05.2025_12.57.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
S17 E16: Summer Meng on Bitmars, Selling Bitcoin ASICs & Heating Your Home with Miners
There is a reason people call Summer Meng the ASIC Queen. If you want the latest Bitmain hardware anywhere in Europe or…
S17 E18: Dr. K on Scaling Proof of Work, Soaping the Competition with Quai & Unifying Physics
Dr. K (Karl Kreder), architect of the Quai Network, came back for his second appearance on Bitcoin Takeover to defend his…
S16 E36: Maud Bannwart & Cheng Wang on Alephium, Proof of Less Work & Bitcoin
Cheng Wang and Maud Bannwart of Alephium on BLAKE3 sharding, Proof of Less Work, the Danube upgrade, UTXOs, and why Alephium…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.