S16 E3: Charlie Shrem & John Gotts on Digital Gold (DGD)
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript18,610 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
Four months after Charlie Shrem first came on the show, still wearing the blue glasses, he emailed me and asked if he could come back to talk about a new project called Digital Gold. We had already postponed twice. By the time we finally went live, I had time to read the white paper, poke at the website, and buy a little of the coin myself.
The last time he was here, Charlie was unambiguously bullish on Bitcoin. This time the Digital Gold site was saying that Bitcoin had not become the medium of exchange he expected. "I'm super bullish on what Bitcoin became in the commodity sense," he told me. "But what it didn't become is the ability to send super cheap transactions in somewhat of a decentralized way." Sitting next to him was John Gotts, who appeared on the stream as Digital Gold Jedi: the founder of the Digital Gold Foundation, the author of the white paper, and the first dancer in the story they wanted to tell. Charlie, the site said, was the project's chief evangelist.
What they were pitching that night was a fork of Bitcoin Core running a proof-of-stake consensus, with all 21 million coins pre-mined, a "proof of participation" distribution, a website that accepted USDT, and a published path toward $100,000 parity if enough people ran the software on ordinary laptops. I spent most of the next two hours asking how any of that was supposed to work. This article is a record of that pitch, and of the questions I asked at the time.
A Note from November 2026
I am writing this catch-up article in November 2026, almost two years later, so the ending of the story should be in the open before you listen. Digital Gold (DGD) never took off. This article is a reminder of what Charlie Shrem, the former BitInstant CEO, was up to in early 2025, and a historical record of a project that reflected the treasury trend without any measurable success. I did my best, during the interview, to poke holes in the model. His partner John Gotts has since decided to start a podcast, Digital Gold Talk.
Here is what I can actually verify about the project, and no more than that.
The domains used around the episode are no longer the project's home. On 10 November 2026, digitalgold.com and digitalgoldx.com each returned a 114-byte page whose only job is to send a browser to /lander. That lander is a parked-domain page served from GoDaddy's parking system. In January 2025, those were the addresses John pointed listeners to; a February 2025 interview still used digitalgoldx.com as the place to get a wallet.
The foundation site is still up, but it is no longer primarily a DGD product page. digitalgoldfoundation.org now presents itself as "Fair Value Standards for Digital Assets," built around a Crypto Fair Value methodology and published coin reports. It still hosts a Digital Gold white paper and still describes John Gotts, on the team page, as the founder and as the author of that paper. Charlie Shrem's name does not appear on that team page in the version I checked. I will not guess what that means.
A separate site, digitalgold.co, still promotes the coin. On the day I checked, it displayed its own figures: 3,818 accounts, a "current price" of $11.53251, 7,437,346 DGD "released to circulation," and "price x circulating supply" of $85,771,293. The same page says this price "isn't set by traders on an exchange," starts near $3.40, and is "designed to climb toward $100,000" as the network grows. A peer-to-peer marketplace is "expected to launch in Q4 2026." The FAQ says earning Digital Gold is "reserved for college students" and "will open to the public in early 2027." Those numbers are the project's statements. They are not exchange quotes, and I cannot check them against an order book.
I could not find this DGD on CoinGecko. CoinMarketCap pages titled "Digital Gold" belong to other assets, including DGLD and a Solana token with the ticker GOLD. The ticker DGD has also been used, historically, by DigixDAO, an unrelated Ethereum project. The Money Seed episode already warned, in February 2025, that DGD was "not (yet) traded on major crypto exchanges such as Coinbase." I still cannot see it trading on a major exchange.
There is a public GitHub organization, DigitalGoldFoundation. The C++ tree at DigitalGold last had substantive code commits in late 2024, then a README update on 29 April 2026, 01:17 Europe/Bucharest. A separate binaries repo still holds the v26.2.0-beta wallet release from 24 November 2024, which is the version digitalgold.co was still advertising.
So some of the original websites are parked, the foundation now talks mainly about valuation standards, and a later site still describes a formula-priced coin with a few thousand accounts, far short of the 10,000 and 100 million figures discussed on the show. Whether anyone can buy or sell DGD at $11.53, and what the network is actually doing day to day, is not something I can verify from public market data. The rest of this article is about what Charlie and John said in January 2025.
Bitcoin as a Commodity, and a 21 Million Premine
Charlie's account of the project started with early Bitcoin: download a node, get coins from a faucet or from Bitcointalk, and bootstrap a network. "That's really how we bootstrap the whole industry and the whole network." Then came demand, and the block size war, and Bitcoin "naturally morphed into this amazing thing that it became." The cheap, somewhat decentralized payments, in his view, did not survive that morphing. Other chains that chased speed, he said, "end up being scams because they take the trilemma problem" and "end up doing like ICOs and all these different like token related stuff."
John's offer, as Charlie remembered it, was to bootstrap the same kind of network again, this time with "as many nodes as a proof of participation human nodes as possible." The test would be crude and public: "download the node, we'll send you some coins," and "eventually when we have 10,000 nodes we can start selling coins on our website."
I wanted the mechanics on the table early. "For the record," I said, "what you're launching is a fork of Bitcoin Core. It has pretty much the same interface but it runs this proof of stake consensus algorithm and all 21 million coins have been pre-mined." It was also being talked about as if it were a stablecoin, except the white paper did not call it one. The first version I had read the week before said the price would be adjusted to a basket of goods. A later version mentioned a monthly adjustment of 1%. I told them I was still confused.
John's answer was a two-stage story. First, build a network of 100 million laptops and desktops, do Bitcoin-scale transaction volume for almost no energy cost, "and then, in fact, we should have parity" with Bitcoin's then-current value: "we would reach that hundred thousand." After that, "the real goal of this coin is not to make anyone wealthy but to preserve buying power over time," so that money saved for "food, clothing, shelter, transportation, energy and communication" could still buy those things a decade later.
Charlie had a simpler frame for why anyone would install yet another wallet. Bitcoin, he said, is "fun to buy in an ETF and a hardware wallet or a Coinbase and Robinhood." What people miss is "being a part of an early network." He told the old story of sending a friend 50 bitcoin that never arrived, because the friend's computer had not caught up with the chain. The Digital Gold experiment, in his telling, was an attempt to recapture that early feeling, with John aiming not at thousands of nodes but at 100 million.
Buying with USDT, or "Contributing"
The distribution was the part that did not match the soft launch story. John said they were not telling people to give them money, only to validate a price, "because I could say that these glasses are worth a dollar or a hundred dollar, but they're not worth a penny unless somebody actually gives it to me." I had a more concrete objection. "Last week, with your help, Mr. Jedi, I was able to purchase some DGD from the website and I actually sent out USDT." I had about $15, needed $20, and he sent me another $25. The coins then arrived in my wallet in small chunks, about 1.85 at a time, instead of all at once.
John pointed me back to digitalgold.com. The design, he said, was to wait until 10,000 nodes were on the network, then release 19,900 coins at each of 1,000 levels, for 19.9 million of the 21 million supply, in equal shares. Early participants would get the most coins, about 1.99 at the first level, "and that's all they can get." At 100,000 people the share would fall to 0.199; at a million, to 0.0199. Unclaimed coins would stay in the treasury. "Right now you can go on your website on digitalgold.com and buy up to $3,821 in coins using USDT."
He kept insisting this was not a sale. "It's not buying and we're not selling." "This isn't a company. This isn't an ICO." Later he put it more carefully still: "This is not any investment into a company or an organization expecting a profit. This is an experiment." I told him the language on the page mattered, because people had to understand they were not investing in a company. He agreed, and said that was why the white paper spent time on the difference between security tokens and coins that do not do ICOs.
The practical limit was the same either way. You could deposit a bunch of USDT, Charlie said, "but you're only getting a couple at a time, just like everyone else." The idea was to keep anyone from becoming a whale at a single level.
A Price That Is Not Discovered on an Exchange
When I asked which wallets and exchanges already supported Digital Gold, John's answer was direct: "No. Not today. But we're working with some." Small exchanges might come later, "but there won't be any volume amount of any way for quite a while because there's no coins." It was "not designed to be on exchanges and have a price go up."
The price they wanted was the last validated level, published by an explorer, not a bid-ask spread. "Why would you dump it at a dime when, if you really believe it, it's going to go to $100,000?" Getting onto exchanges, John said, was mostly "to prove the concept that they will in fact plug into an explorer and set a value that's not floating for price discovery." Merchants might need an off-ramp into local currency. He did not expect holders to spend early, "because why would you? The cup of coffee that's 10 cents now is going to be $10."
That was the tension I could not quite resolve on air. "You said today it's worth like a nickel, and you also projected an expectation that one day it might be $100,000. But at the same time, it's described as a stablecoin. So how does this make sense?" John's reply was that the network had to be built first. Level one, on his sheet, was a $1,100 market cap. Each level would add coins and raise the published price "until we reach parity with Bitcoin. And then we stop." After that, adjustments would follow usefulness and inflation, "and then it's very stable. It only changes once every month." I said I still found it hard to compute: "on one hand, you want it to be stable, and on the other hand, you want it to pump hard." He rejected the second half. "I don't want to pump hard. It's stable down the road. We outline exactly what the price and value will be if we get to a certain amount of nodes."
One of the show's sponsors at the time was SideShift, which I mentioned because it actually has liquidity and trading pairs. Digital Gold, in this telling, would not live in that world until much later, if at all.
A Bitcoin Reserve, and a White Paper Still Being Rewritten
People who did pay USDT, John said, were funding a treasury that would buy bitcoin, on the model of a reserve commodity standing behind a currency, "similar to the idea that Fort Knox had gold in it." I asked the obvious next question: would the price of DGD be pegged to the bitcoin in that treasury? "Not at all." It was "very possible," he said, that the bitcoin could end up worth more than the network, even "two and a half trillion dollars worth of Bitcoin in our treasury." That would not, in his analogy, change the face value, any more than a silver coin was still a quarter when the metal was worth more than 25 cents.
He wanted the reserve audited. "I want everyone to always know what happened to the money that came in the door. Where is it now? Where was it intended to go? Did it go there? What's in the reserve?" He said nothing like that existed in crypto, and he did not yet know who the credible auditors would be.
The documents were still moving during the livestream. I could not find the updated white paper on the site. John said he had finished polishing it that morning around 6 a.m., that an engineer named Alexander had not yet swapped it in, and that listeners should wait and check the foundation site later. There was a light paper already, he said, but it did not include the bitcoin reserve. I had also noticed a name-change story in the materials, and a chapter on the episode page still says "Value of DGB vs. Bitcoin," which is the label as published.
On the supply itself, John said staking rewards and tiny transaction fees would be burned, so the coin would not go past 21 million. He argued that burning fees also avoided looking like a money transmitter collecting revenue. The team allocation, he said, was 1.1 million out of 21 million, about 5.2%, "exactly the size of the Satoshi wallet," released across the same 1,000 levels, and "worth nothing right now" unless the experiment worked. I asked whether those large wallets would be labeled. He liked the idea on the spot and said he would ask the Blackcoin developers to mark the founders' coins so anyone could watch them.
Proof of Participation, and an Experiment
The consensus story was a hybrid. The chain used proof of stake under the hood, in software John associated with the Blackcoin developers, but the social rule he wanted to be remembered was not staking rewards. "If you are a part of this community, your duty is to participate. This is called proof of participation. Not proof of work, not proof of stake, participation." That meant running the software, telling friends, and later finding merchants. "If you don't want to do that, this is probably not the community for you, unless you're just riding on everybody else's hardware."
I pointed out the obvious objection. Bitcoiners have spent 15 years not running nodes, and Digital Gold also paid no coins for doing so. John's answer was that Bitcoin node-running is hopeless against industrial miners, whereas here the published valuation itself was the incentive: agree to participate, and the price moves from $1,100 at 10,000 nodes upward as more machines stay plugged in. "We don't move up if people download it once, unplug it, turn it off."
He was more candid about the odds than the marketing was. "Most startups fail. Not that this is a startup. It's not a company, but it's an experiment. And most experiments fail, most do." A team of about 30 people was involved, he said, and they had "a shot." Charlie, earlier, had offered a similar hedge: "I don't expect anything to succeed. 85% of every well-funded company in Silicon Valley fails. But we're going to try."
Near the end I said I would probably sell my coins the moment I could, "just to prove that the market has enough liquidity to absorb it, because that's also important in the free market." John did not object. He said they planned to bake an exchange into the website, precisely because people new to crypto did not know how to get USDT or USDC.
The Second Dancer
John's favorite metaphor came from a short TED talk he had pinned on his X account, about how a movement starts: one person dances alone and looks ridiculous, until a second dancer joins and turns the lone nut into a leader. "I'm the first dancer," he said. "The real leader is the second dancer, which is Charlie."
Charlie's endorsement was, in John's word, the litmus test. After years of grinding on the idea, he said, you get to a point where you wonder whether you have talked yourself into it, and you need someone who will tell you whether the idea is as good as you think it is. Charlie looked at it, introduced some of his friends, and, at that first meeting, said this was how Satoshi would relaunch Bitcoin today. "That was such a big fucking moment," John said, "because somebody that knows said maybe, you know, let's try it."
That is the quote they put on the front page, under Charlie's name as a founder of the Bitcoin Foundation and chief evangelist of Digital Gold. I had tried, as I said at the end of the stream, to front-run the questions I knew people would have. The answers are in the recording. What became of the domains, the published price, and the exchange listings is in the note above. The rest, you can judge for yourself.
Listen to Charlie Shrem on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:00:48– Introducing Charlie Shrem & Digital Gold Jedi
- 00:01:40– Is Charlie Still Bullish on Bitcoin?
- 00:02:05– From Bitcoin to Digital Gold
- 00:04:52– Details of the Digital Gold Project
- 00:05:37– Stability and Value Preservation?
- 00:08:34– Community Engagement and User Growth
- 00:09:01– Comparison with BitTorrent
- 00:14:28– There Are Thousands of Digital Golds
- 00:15:08– Unique Features of the Digital Gold Project
- 00:17:05– Which Wallets and Exchanges Support Digital Gold?
- 00:17:55– Community Engagement and Validation
- 00:18:50– Initial Feedback and Expectations
- 00:19:26– Purchasing Process and Coin Distribution
- 00:20:15– Coin Withdrawal Mechanics
- 00:21:02– Network Growth and Distribution
- 00:22:57– Exchanges and Market Dynamics
- 00:23:25– Stablecoin vs. Price Speculation
- 00:24:27– Price Determination Mechanism
- 00:25:09– Infrastructure and Value Creation
- 00:26:06– Market Dynamics and Adoption
- 00:26:21– Mining vs. Market Factors
- 00:27:13– Coin Purchase Process Clarification
- 00:29:20– Community Participation and Evangelism
- 00:31:16– Address Reuse Concerns
- 00:32:38– Price Validation by Community
- 00:34:31– Selling Coins Among Users
- 00:34:43– Community Exchange Challenges
- 00:35:44– Decentralized Exchange Considerations
- 00:36:00– Arbitrage Opportunities
- 00:36:43– Side Shift
- 00:37:42– Treasury and Bitcoin Ownership
- 00:38:00– Concerns About Bitcoin Reserve Safety
- 00:39:26– Community Trust and Auditing
- 00:40:28– Charlie Shrem’s Long-Term Vision for Digital Gold
- 00:41:51– Self-Custody and User Understanding
- 00:42:07– Value of DGB vs. Bitcoin
- 00:44:01– Name Change Story
- 00:45:24– Treasury Transparency and Auditing
- 00:46:29– Future of Auditing in Crypto
- 00:47:18– Bullish Prediction for Digital Gold
- 00:51:51– Understanding User Risks and Backup Solutions
- 00:52:56– Digital Gold Experiment
- 00:54:10– Challenges of User Adoption
- 00:57:42– Centralization Concerns
- 00:58:16– Node Operation Incentives
- 01:00:55– Concept of Proof of Participation
- 01:06:52– Contribution vs. Purchase
- 01:09:07– Intrinsic Value and Market Parity
- 01:10:04– Discussion on Gold and Currency Value
- 01:10:35– Clarifying Payment Terminology
- 01:11:57– Contributions, Not Investments
- 01:12:44– White Paper Availability
- 01:15:20– Smart Currency Concept
- 01:15:49– Comparison with Bitcoin Cash
- 01:16:40– Participation in the Network
- 01:17:47– Digital Gold vs Terra Luna
- 01:19:16– Claiming Coins Without Purchase
- 01:21:04– Distribution Model Fairness
- 01:23:25– Becoming a Staker
- 01:25:03– Node Connection and Validation
- 01:27:25– Impact of Node Outages
- 01:28:09– Core Staking Nodes Explained
- 01:29:10– Government Threats to Network
- 01:30:25– Initial Market Cap and Podcast Launch
- 01:32:44– Security Team: How Does It Get Paid?
- 01:36:00– Bug Bounty and Security Issues
- 01:37:29– Distribution of Coins and Participation
- 01:39:33– Peer-to-Peer Transactions
- 01:41:51– Transparency of Coin Holdings
- 01:42:23– Labeling The Team’s Staking Wallets
- 01:45:31– First Dancers
- 01:45:39– Charlie Shrem’s Role in Digital Gold
- 01:46:03– The Litmus Test
- 01:46:31– Importance of Charlie's Endorsement
- 01:47:31– Highlighting Charlie's Character
- 01:48:03– Addressing Potential Concerns
- 01:48:42– User-Friendly Exchange Integration
- 01:49:44– Future Selling of Coins
- 01:50:13– Saying Goodbye
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
5927e6c5a3e2e6f28389da383d9b14e103d9a9a6ea2483daeac83a23fef076b7- Proof
- 2025-01-14_s16_e3_charlie_shrem_on_digital_gold_-_14.01.2025_01.41.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 14 Jan 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2025-01-14_s16_e3_charlie_shrem_on_digital_gold_-_14.01.2025_01.41.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2025-01-14_s16_e3_charlie_shrem_on_digital_gold_-_14.01.2025_01.41.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2025-01-14_s16_e3_charlie_shrem_on_digital_gold_-_14.01.2025_01.41.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2025-01-14_s16_e3_charlie_shrem_on_digital_gold_-_14.01.2025_01.41.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
S15 E53: Charlie Shrem on the Block Size Wars, Life After Prison & Bitcoin's Leaderless Future
BitInstant co-founder Charlie Shrem clarifies his block size war stance, recalls prison and rebirth, defends Tether and explains…
S17 E18: Dr. K on Scaling Proof of Work, Soaping the Competition with Quai & Unifying Physics
Dr. K (Karl Kreder), architect of the Quai Network, came back for his second appearance on Bitcoin Takeover to defend his…
S17 E49: Kris Nuttycombe (Zcash at Ten, Hard Forks, Dev Fund, Ossification)
Kris Nuttycombe of ZODL on Zcash at ten: hard forks as a superpower, freezing Sprout, NU7, Tachyon, the Dev Fund, testnet forks…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.