Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S16 · E34 · 1:57:46

S16 E34: Prof. Richard Werner on Bitcoin, CBDCs & The Big Beautiful Bill

21 Jul 2025 · by Vlad Costea · 12 min read
Published at block 906,514
Cover art for S16 E34, Prof. Richard Werner on Bitcoin, CBDCs & The Big Beautiful Bill
MP3 (162 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript17,673 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

Richard Werner coined the term "quantitative easing" in Japan in the 1990s, wrote Princes of the Yen, and is now building a cross-border bank in the Rhine Valley. He sat down with me at Mallorca Blockchain Days for about two hours, and I wanted him on the show for a simple reason: he is an economist who has actually watched a central bank do the things that Bitcoiners accuse central banks of doing, and he does not always land where a Bitcoiner would expect. He told me he is bullish on Bitcoin, though cautious. He is also convinced that Karl Marx worked for the other side.

I had Richard on before, in S15 E56: Richard Werner on Bitcoin, CBDCs & the Case for Community Banks. He came back later with Amir Taaki for S17 E40: Amir Taaki & Prof. Richard Werner on Decentralization, Community Banks & the Coming CBDC Panopticon. This time I started with the news cycle, because the US had just passed a very large spending bill and I wanted to know what a man who studies credit would say about it.

Spending Is Not the Same as Printing

I opened with a question about the American president, who ran on cutting debt and then signed a huge spending bill. In my own preamble I had to correct myself on the length of his time in office, since I'd said he was "about seven years into his presidency," which is not how presidential terms work. Werner let that pass and answered what I was actually asking.

His starting point is that "Fiscal policy, government spending is not directly money printing." If a government borrows from savers and spends, he said, it is "just a transfer policy": money moves from one pocket to another and the total does not grow. Japan is his proof. In the 1990s the Japanese government ran one stimulus package after another, and the bonds were absorbed by non-bank investors, so there was no inflation. Inflation shows up, in his account, when the bonds end up on the balance sheet of the banking system or the central bank.

I asked whether that is what we should expect in the US. He thinks the answer is probably yes: "It is likely it will be monetized," though he added a complication. The US Treasury and the Federal Reserve do not have the same interests, and the Fed has tools to neutralize what the Treasury wants. "The Federal Reserve Bank of New York is the real central bank," he said. "It's 100% privately owned by the Wall Street banks, you know. So in the past, we didn't really have much antagonism." His advice for reading any of this: "don't listen too much to what they say, watch what they actually do."

Interest Rates as a Decoy

Werner's theory of money is the load-bearing wall of everything else he said, so I pushed on it. Most of the financial press treats the central bank's interest rate as the main lever of the economy. He does not. "So it's a sideshow," he told me. "It's like a decoy." On his reading, rates follow growth rather than cause it: "Interest rates follow growth, and they're positively correlated, positively correlated to economic growth. If you want higher growth, you will get higher rates. There's no way around that."

What matters to him is volume and destination. "The real question is the quantity of credit creation created by the banking system, including the central bank." He distinguishes credit that funds real investment in production from credit that funds asset purchases, and that distinction comes back when he gets to what he is building in the Rhine Valley.

I asked how he deals with the charge that this sounds like a conspiracy theory. His reply was about method. "I'm against following gurus," he said, and "the test should always be facts, reality, data." Elsewhere in the conversation he put it more fully: "I think we just have to always test whether what is being said makes sense, makes common sense, is reasonable, is fact based, empirically evidence based, and therefore is scientific." He also said that "just because something is logical, doesn't mean it's true," which is his objection to a lot of textbook economics. I pointed out that this sounded like a rule of thumb I could use at Bitcoin conferences. He offered a sharper one: "Do the opposite of what mainstream economics says, and you're likely to be right."

Free Trade and the Value-Added Ladder

We spent a long stretch on trade, which I had not planned to. Werner's claim is flat: "No country has developed based on free trade and free market economic policies." The successful ones, he says, protected their industries first and opened up later. Countries that take the standard advice and specialize in raw materials end up with trade deficits and debt in foreign currency. "Africa has been told this for 70 years by the IMF and the World Bank," he said, and the result is the pattern of poverty you would expect from selling cheap inputs and buying expensive finished goods.

The way out, as he sees it, is that "you must move up the value-added ladder." That means producing things with more processing, more skill and higher prices. I asked whether this means tariffs are good. Not any tariffs, he said: "it has to be the smart tariff policies," aimed at protecting the industries that can climb. He also warned against the blunt version of protectionism, where a country closes everything off, and on one particular kind of trade measure he was blunt: "you'd never want to do that."

I mentioned that I am not an economist and had to trust that the history checks out. He told me to check it, which is the point of his stance on gurus.

Marx, the Fed and the 1913 Tax

This is the segment where Werner is most provocative, and I'll report it as he said it. He argues that Karl Marx functioned as an arm of mainstream economics, because Marx built a critique of capitalism around class struggle while leaving private bankers and credit creation out of it. If you do not look at where money comes from, in his view, you will blame the factory owner and miss the people who create the money the factory owner borrows.

He has a similar reading of the American federal income tax. In his telling it was instituted in 1913, the same year as the Federal Reserve, to service debt interest. National debt, he said, "starts to balloon the moment central banks come on stage and make this deal with the government that they have the monopoly on the issuance of money, and governments stop issuing state money." The effect is that "you're increasingly extracting money from the economy, from the many people, from the taxpayers, and giving it to a small elite of those people who live on government bond coupons, the rentiers."

I asked whether any of this means a gold standard would have been better, and he gave me a historical answer I had not heard framed this way: "Banks always created money throughout history, and any gold standard, you know, you name the period and the country, and I will show you that banks still created money separately from the gold." So the problem is who gets to create the money, whatever it is backed by.

Romania, Debt and a Thousand Small Banks

I am Romanian, so I asked about my own country. Should it pursue austerity or expansion to manage its debt? Werner said neither, in the way those are usually presented. What Romania needs is productive credit, and he wants it delivered through small local banks. His number: "Romania can easily have 12, maybe even 15% economic growth for decades," if credit goes into productive investment through thousands of small local banks instead of a handful of big ones.

He gave me the contrast from Europe. The ECB, in his account, has caused the closure of 6,000 European banks, and the result is fewer lenders and less credit for small businesses. "a decentralized system is always more competitive," he said, and when I asked how he could be sure, he fell back on his usual answer: look at the data from countries that kept their local banks.

That led us to what he is doing himself. "I'm working on establishing a bank," he told me, and the Rheintaler Bank in the Rhine Valley is that project. It is a cross-border bank, meant to lend to the real economy on both sides of a border, and it is the practical version of everything above: allocation over interest rates, small over large.

The Abundant World and the Cash Argument

At one point I steered us toward scarcity, since Bitcoiners love to talk about it. Werner has a view I did not expect. "It's an abundant world," he said, and he applied that to digital goods: "the marginal cost is zero." That is a point in favor of letting money and services move without friction, and it is why he is not hostile to technology in general.

I brought up an illustration I got from Andrew Tate about swipe fees. A $50 cash bill keeps its value however many hands it passes through, while every card payment skims a little and transfers value to the banks over time. Werner took it further and said "cash is also freedom," then gave the reason: "If you use cash, we don't know when you're spending it, who you're giving it to. And also we can't influence that and we can't stop you from doing it."

I told him I hold bitcoin because it is the closest digital thing to that.

CBDCs and the Politburo

When I asked whether CBDCs have any benefits at all, I expected at least a polite pause. He did not give one: "I don't see any upside on that at all." In his analysis a CBDC means central planning, and the reason it is dangerous is control: "you can just press the button and increase that to infinity." During a banking crisis, he said, a CBDC could be used to force deposits into the central bank. "we definitely can't trust the central planners," and "their justification for CBDC is so weak, it's laughable."

His proposal is concrete. "I think we need to organize demonstrations outside central banks." He said that if the central banks fail to get their way on the retail version, they will find another path: "So that is a backdoor way for the central banks to still get a lot of what they want." The backdoor he described is a requirement that "every incorporated company must have digital reporting of its activities, of its transactions on a real-time, daily basis." He called that "really scary," and I will say that I agree with him on that one.

He also described a message he would deliver to the ECB: "you at the ECB have created demand for Bitcoin with your policies so far." And he thinks the CBDC project may only survive if there is a crisis to ride on: "Their only hope then will be that there will be global war."

I asked about the structure of the European Union, and he did not hold back. "The European Union was modeled on the Soviet Union," he said, comparing the European Commission to the Politburo. "there's a democratic deficit," he said, because the European Parliament cannot propose laws. Here is how he made the comparison: "The Soviet parliament just had the appearance of a parliament. That was the appearance of democracy. But they could not draft, propose, and pass any single law that they had come up with." He added that the entire European Commission once resigned over proven corruption, and that the story got minimal media coverage.

Late in this section we talked about COVID, and I told him my two vaccine doses had been Delta and then Omicron, meaning I went with natural immunity. He took it in good humor, and then used the period as an example for his argument about digital power: "it was a good exercise for us to see what happens when we give essentially digital powers to people."

Can an Economy Run on Bitcoin?

Then the question I had been saving. Can an economy function on a deflationary currency like Bitcoin? "I think it doesn't work with a deflationary currency," Werner said. His reasoning is that credit is the engine of growth, and credit gets created by banks regardless of what the base money is. "Banks should be restricted to creating credit only for transactions that contribute to national income," he said, which is his own fix: let banks lend, but only for production.

He does not dismiss Bitcoin for that reason. On the question of where it goes, he said, "I think it's a more or less inevitable outcome of current events," meaning that institutional mandates and the fixed supply push the price up. His own number, offered with a smile: "maybe 995,000 or something like that." And then: "I'm bullish, but I'm also cautious," and his criticism is "sort of a relative criticism, not an absolute criticism."

The caution has a specific shape. "if it is just a store of value, that makes me get more concerned," he said, because a store of value is a target. Hostile actors have a reason to attack something that people hold but do not use, whereas something people transact with acquires defenders. He also pointed at a risk on the technical side: "The fact is, there is also a common electronic link that may be susceptible to a common way of attack or failure if something goes wrong."

I closed the loop by telling him that bitcoin is the thing I am selling to anyone who will listen. "That's what I'm selling," I said, and he laughed.

What comes next for Werner is the bank. He is building the Rheintaler Bank in the Rhine Valley, the cross-border institution he described, and he says the work is on establishing it. Alongside that he wants demonstrations outside central banks against CBDCs, and he publishes his writing at richardwerner.org and on his Substack. His other site, professorwerner.org, carries the academic side of the work.

Listen to Richard Werner on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:01:04– Intro from Mallorca Blockchain Days
  2. 00:02:22– The Big Beautiful Bill and fiscal policy
  3. 00:03:16– Why Japan's spending did not cause inflation
  4. 00:08:19– The Treasury wants banks to buy Treasuries
  5. 00:09:12– Will the Fed counteract?
  6. 00:10:23– Interest rates as a decoy
  7. 00:13:59– Japan vs. the US: credit creation
  8. 00:16:46– Trump's tariffs and the EU
  9. 00:18:06– Ricardo, logic and fictional worlds
  10. 00:24:08– Friedrich List and the empirical approach
  11. 00:26:02– Terms of trade
  12. 00:29:05– Moving up the value-added ladder
  13. 00:31:12– The IMF and World Bank commodity trap
  14. 00:35:19– What smart tariffs look like
  15. 00:36:39– Where Trump's tariff plan falls short
  16. 00:38:33– America's market power
  17. 00:39:41– Sponsor reads: LayerTwo Labs, Citrea and Edge Wallet
  18. 00:43:48– Austrian economists and the problem with gurus
  19. 00:49:14– Argentina and Paul Krugman
  20. 00:50:02– National debt and the rentiers
  21. 00:55:13– Central banks and the federal income tax
  22. 00:57:58– What to tell Romania
  23. 00:59:47– Growth without limits through local banks
  24. 01:03:48– The war on cash
  25. 01:08:37– Sponsor reads: SideShift, NoOnes and Bitcoin.com News
  26. 01:11:32– CBDCs and programmable money
  27. 01:12:53– Is there any upside to CBDCs?
  28. 01:16:24– How to stop CBDCs
  29. 01:20:13– Tether and stablecoins
  30. 01:21:34– Stablecoins as Plan B
  31. 01:22:45– Plan C: real-time corporate reporting
  32. 01:24:46– The EU as a democratic deficit
  33. 01:29:51– The vote against von der Leyen
  34. 01:37:35– What COVID taught us about centralized power
  35. 01:39:29– Can an economy run on a deflationary currency?
  36. 01:43:32– MicroStrategy and Metaplanet
  37. 01:44:57– A million dollars per Bitcoin?
  38. 01:45:45– The Bitcoin death switch and EMP risk
  39. 01:48:21– The grid argument and local currencies
  40. 01:50:42– Store of value vs. currency
  41. 01:54:18– The Rheintaler Bank
  42. 01:55:22– From Joachimsthaler to dollar
  43. 01:56:35– Substack, YouTube and closing

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
29340c147cbca9aded11d50c8bce716e4d502d329bee5d92e141356217079733
Proof
2025-07-20_s16_e34_richard_werner_on_bitcoin_cbdcs_the_big_beautiful_bill_-_20.07.2025_01.32.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 20 Jul 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2025-07-20_s16_e34_richard_werner_on_bitcoin_cbdcs_the_big_beautiful_bill_-_20.07.2025_01.32.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2025-07-20_s16_e34_richard_werner_on_bitcoin_cbdcs_the_big_beautiful_bill_-_20.07.2025_01.32.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2025-07-20_s16_e34_richard_werner_on_bitcoin_cbdcs_the_big_beautiful_bill_-_20.07.2025_01.32.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2025-07-20_s16_e34_richard_werner_on_bitcoin_cbdcs_the_big_beautiful_bill_-_20.07.2025_01.32.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00