Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S1 E10 / Transcript
Transcript · S1 E10 · 2:03:47 · 6 Feb 2019

S1 E10: Alena Vranova on Bitcoin as a Mean for Fairer Politics

With Alena Vranova. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:29Vlad CosteaHello and welcome. As we both were raised in Central and Eastern European countries, which have been living under authoritarian regimes, we have a very specific and particularly bad experience with hyperinflation and the way the economy had been managed during the first part of the 1990s and even before that, while our countries were still communist. And I guess that through this dialogue, we can actually share many insightful points of view that can be useful in terms of adopting Bitcoin and understanding why it's such a great idea for the world economy. So, hello!

1:43Alena VranovaHi Vlad, thanks for having me.

1:46Vlad CosteaI'm really happy that we get to do this.

1:49Alena VranovaMe too, me too, you know. And especially, I grew up, I was born in the communist regime. You were born post, but you lived very, very, you know, heavy consequences of the Ceaușescu regime. So I think that's where we meet and we can definitely share with the rest of the Bitcoin world that has not been, quote unquote, fortunate to go through this. And I'm saying fortunate, not because I would be happy about it, but because it definitely gives us something that a lot of other people may just lack, and that's the collective memory, and that's even the personal experience.

2:37With despotic oppression, despotisms and other isms, fascisms and communisms that we had. And so I think this is extremely important to share. Because just for the lack of the memory and lack of the knowledge of history, some people may have tendencies to get to the ideas that, hey, maybe socialism is great, you know, and maybe a universal basic income is great, and maybe this is great. But then it's like, it all sounds so great and amazing. And that's exactly how socialism sounded to our ancestors, right? Everyone will be happy and have everything. And not saying that everyone will have to say nothing, but so yeah, it's a great frame to begin with for this podcast.

3:42Vlad CosteaI was actually speaking to an American friend last week. And he told me that nobody really thinks about needing sound money in their lives. Nobody gets out of bed one morning and says, "You know what I'm lacking right now? Sound money, because I'm not having the dollars in my pocket."

4:00Alena VranovaThat's actually perfect. Yes, that's right. Nobody in my normal environment, right, cares about these things. So the reason being, they don't understand money as the tool of power. And they probably, you know, normal people like my mom, they get upset about the consequences, but they are not, you know, in the state of like going and digging into the reasons and trying to find solutions to the world's problems. So that's why we have people or, you know, groups of people or whoever, such as Satoshi Nakamoto, who probably was thinking about these topics, right? Yeah.

4:55Vlad CosteaYou know, I was actually discussing throughout the podcast about the fact that Bitcoin is something that we need as a neutral currency for the world. And it's interesting that we are not experiencing, we were not experiencing this before, and this used to be like a toy for libertarians to show off and present their ideas as something that can be put into practice. But nowadays, with Venezuela and also with platforms like Patreon, which are censoring people for free speech, we are actually seeing why we require something that cannot be controlled and actually doesn't care about what you think. It's money that you have and nobody can take away from you.

5:41Alena VranovaExactly, exactly. And you know, you mentioned Venezuela. My big passion and my motivation actually to get into Bitcoin, it's not just from like my experience from childhood and us having to stand lines for a simple, you know, kilo of bananas, and then another line for bread, and another line for meat, you know, and never getting what we actually need, and having to wait years and years for a car and stuff. But also from some level of understanding of geopolitics and how the world's powers work, right?

6:31And then looking at the '90s and 2000s, where we had, you know, invasions to Iraq, for example, and nobody's talking about the actual reason behind the invasion, right? It was not like the bad, bad Saddam, right? It was because the bad, bad Saddam, a few weeks before the invasion, simply announced to the world that they will switch trading petrol from dollars to euros. Right, and all of a sudden the US Army marched in. And guess what? Decision was reversed. And that just tells you like how dollar is engraved, you know, like embodied in all the international trade, and how one country can basically manipulate the world, how the world turns, by just simply issuing their own money, right?

7:34And this is the only country in the world that can afford to go in an unlimited debt, because there are markets and because our crucial resources are being traded in dollars. Most of the international trade is in dollar. Most of the reserves, the currency reserves of all the countries around the world, happen to be in dollar. And so that gives one country a huge position to manipulate what's going on and to dictate conditions.

8:15To dictate, for example, like, you know, you want to establish a company anywhere and you need to file a FATCA document, which is just specifically for American authorities, right? So this only tells you like how important it is for US to maintain the position of the dollar in the global scheme, and what happens if someone dares to say, you know, "Let's screw your dollar."

8:49So we are in this situation today and we're looking at, you know, failing a country that could have been super wealthy, such as Venezuela. They could swim in dollars or bitcoins or in gold or in the petrol. They don't. Why? Because there's a power struggle, right? America wants those resources. And Chavez and now Maduro, they said, "Screw you, America." So now there's this situation where you have tens of millions of people in hunger, although they could be like the one of the most rich countries in the world. Right?

9:35Oh, yeah, money. This is basically what brought me to studying Bitcoin and even discovery of Bitcoin, as I was like thinking, and I was writing my thesis about international monetary system, international imbalances, and I was saying to myself, "It's impossible," you know. We have Euro. Euro is, unfortunately, in my opinion, a failed project from the very beginning. Because our, you know, our politicians just decided to do the power grab instead of listening to reason. And so despite having a lot of economists and despite these economists nailing down the Maastricht criteria, right, which is five simple criteria that you have to comply with if you want to join a monetary union, right?

10:33Guess what? So none of current EU members comply with these rules. I mean, eurozone members, right? None. Again, this money is simply a tool of political power, not a tool for a smooth and good exchange of value, and that's what bothers me. So an apolitical money is an absolute must, I think, for the future, especially if we want to get rid of the influence of politicians over our lives.

11:13Vlad CosteaBut I was thinking right now, let's say that it's true that Russia is going to get into Bitcoin and buy large amounts. And let's assume that 10 years from now it's going to be a much more precious resource, not just a meme about going to the moon and buying Lambos. Wouldn't that swing the world powers in a way that would actually grant more political power to the country which gets into Bitcoin?

11:43Alena VranovaI think that's a good question. Are you asking about the biggest stakeholders?

11:54Vlad CosteaYes, because there are only 21 million. There will be 21 million.

12:02Alena VranovaThat is true, and that's why I'm happy that Bitcoin was not conceived as a central money, and that a lot of individual people around the world and, you know, nerds, miners and early believers got their hands on Bitcoin. And I hope that their hands will be strong, you know, at least for some time. Of course, you cannot prevent like strong players, you know, getting into Bitcoin and manipulating the prices. But that's something you cannot solve, basically, throughout any asset. There's manipulation in commodities, there's manipulation in forex, in every trade and business.

12:47The point here is: can Bitcoin be misused as a tool for political power? Let's say, let's assume Russia would have a substantial stock of Bitcoin. Can they go about and manipulate the price? Do Americans manipulate prices of oil and all these things? Yes, they do. So it could turn out actually being a very similar thing. The difference here is that nobody can print more, nobody can falsify and, you know, revert my transactions. And nobody can basically dictate me whom to transact with, when, under which conditions. This is something that other money does not have, and the traditional banking system cannot do for me.

13:54Vlad CosteaThat's a very useful point, as it's easy to think that this whole decentralized economy is going to end up getting controlled by governments. But there is no way they can have the same kind of leverages and the same kind of control how people spend their money, how they use it. They cannot confiscate, they cannot get, "You're going to send this percentage, it's mandatory for you to send this percentage to this account or this address," because that's what we call taxation now. That's not going to happen. And I was speaking to, I think I was having this conversation with Riccardo Spagni, fluffypony.

14:39And he was saying that at this point, governments have to become much more creative and be more inviting with those who hold cryptocurrencies, and especially Bitcoin, and make them understand why it's important to give money, and become much more transparent in regards to their spending. That's an important step that we have to make. In income taxation, there was never really accountability.

15:08Alena VranovaExactly, you know, this is a great point. For taxation, here's the thing. I always said, like, I'm happy to pay some tax, if I see and when I see that the government deals with it responsibly, and when I see where it goes. So if, you know, governments want people to continue and be happy to pay taxes, they have to make some effort, right? And by the way, I'm more of an anarchist than a monarchist. I don't think we necessarily need central authorities to decide about the price level and target inflation and decide about what are the best rules for all.

15:59Because from a central point, from one office, you can never target the price well for all different goods. So you can get the price correctly for, you know...

16:15And by getting the price correctly, I mean, you know, central banks targeting inflation points to establish some price level, right? That's how they manipulate the prices in the market. They either release more money into the system or they buy it up. So by doing this, I think they introduce more imbalance to the system than they actually help. That's first thing. And the second thing is, do we need army? At least in my country, I don't think so, honestly, because our army, if there's an invasion, could probably stand for a few days.

16:54Do we need help, like organized help for firefighting and some security, physical security? Yes, we do. Can this be done by private bodies? Absolutely. So then the question is like whether go for minarchy or anarchy or be a statist, that's fine too. Like, I'm open to that as well. But if you want people to pay taxes, be fair enough to show them what you're doing with the taxes. And so, hey, why don't governments just think about adopting some blockchain technology that, you know, you could simply trace any tax and where it goes to the budget and how it's spent?

17:50Even condition, you know, some spending with some results and so on and so forth. Yeah, but it doesn't really fit in the mindset of politicians, right? Today budgets are not done according to like, oh, this needs to be done and that needs to be fixed. Today budgets are done in a very different way. Who paid for the campaign? Who voted? Who gave me the largest amount of money? Where can I forward the tax money? Who's going to build the roads? These are all very shady and usually very corrupt practices happening.

18:32On one hand, they go like, "Oh, you know, Bitcoiners want to avoid taxes." No, that's not true. Bitcoiners just don't want to answer stupid questions to the banks. Why are you withdrawing your money, right, from the bank account? Why are you sending this money to someone else? Like, that's not my problem, right? I'm not a criminal. I have not stolen from anyone. Why do I have to be constantly surveilled by this financial system? That's another topic. Like, blanket surveillance that we have today is completely anti-constitutional.

19:16At least in my constitution, there's a presumption of innocence, right? Innocent until proven guilty. I do not commit any crimes, but I'm still KYC'd and AML'd on every step. Why? Because they cannot enforce criminal justice sufficiently and efficiently enough. So they decide, instead of going after one specific, you know, criminal, they decide to go after everyone. I don't like that, and I think that should be definitely a change ahead.

19:58Vlad CosteaGetting back to our initial topic about communism, I know that at least in my country there was this assumption that anyone can be an enemy of the regime, and anyone can be a criminal. And children were taught in schools to actually turn in their parents if they were speaking something bad against the dictator or against the system. And it's the same as we read in 1984. It's not much different.

20:26Alena VranovaOh, yeah, I lived... I lived these things, as we say, on my own skin, right? I came back from school, totally happy that I learned a new poem about Lenin, right? So I'm standing in the kitchen and go, "Mama, you know, Dad, I learned a new poem, do you want to hear?" And they go, "Sure." And I go, I bow, and I say, "Lenin." And then I start to talk about Lenin. And my parents went pale, but they said nothing. Up to several years later, when they said, "Look, we couldn't say anything. We saw, like, how this little girl is excited about this stupid poem about Lenin, right?" And they could not tell.

21:19There are certain things, you know, that you have to do in a country if you want to establish some despotism, right, which is socialism, communism, fascism. It is injecting a certain amount of fear in order to keep the masses in order, right? And happy and compliant. And so you see this happening not just like in the past, but also today. Like injecting fear from the enemy and creating enemies, this is some, again, a tool of political power. And so in the communist times, especially in Czechoslovakia, there were a lot of trials and killings in the '50s and in the '60s.

22:15All the people that were a part of the intelligentsia, part of later the dissent, right, the dissidents, everyone who wanted a more, you know, democratic establishment and didn't agree or wasn't happy about communists basically appropriating all the private property in 1948. All those people went to jail, were killed, were hanged, or were forced to go to exile. And after the '60s, we had like a, it's a sweet term by the way, it was called normalization.

23:02And things kind of seemingly looked well, right? The communist Czechoslovakia has been built up. And my mom just recently shared an article with me and said, "You know, just in the '70s we have built so many schools, and we have done this and that." I said, "Yeah, and we did not kill any more people because all those smart people were either dead or in exile." And the only way to keep an extremism as establishment is basically insert fear, get rid of the intellectuals in the system.

23:44Make them quiet, right? And one of the ways also today is by social welfare. Social welfare has turned from something that we want to achieve as a product, as a side product of our activity, right? We want to, everyone wants to be okay and wealthy enough to not have to be scared of the future, to not have to think what I'm going to eat tomorrow, right? Social welfare has turned from this side effect into something that is kind of used as a political narrative, right?

24:24And abused as a political narrative. So you see, especially in the Western countries today, that a lot of people are calling for social justice and they are calling for basic universal income and stuff like this, and it's a very strong tool, right? This is so strong. Like, who doesn't want to get free money and security? You know, by default, despite your existence. Of course, everyone, everyone: "Hey, give me free money." But people don't realize that it's like this sugar, and then, you know, they invite you somewhere and it's very pleasant, right?

25:08And don't care about the consequences. Don't think, don't do the math. Come on, people. This is free money, basic income. Don't do the math. And people don't do the math. So I think we should talk more about these things, you know, especially in countries that are having these pro-socialist tendencies and have never lived the experience and have never even thought about the consequences.

25:38Vlad CosteaYeah, as you described it's like the story of Hansel and Gretel, when they see that house made of sweets and they don't ask questions.

25:46Alena VranovaYeah, exactly. Exactly, right. Well, you know, with Bitcoin, it's true that it's very unstable and it's probably, I mean, the price is volatile, and it's probably right now more for people who have the tendency for self-reliance, you know, to be sovereign. And so these people who are thinking about, you know, future and are thinking about political hedge. Because for me, Bitcoin mainly is political hedge. I don't want to have all my savings in Czech korunas. Oh my God. You know, of course not. Why?

26:34Because one day our government says, "Oh, everything is perfect, our economy works great," and the next day they devalue the currency by 10% from one day to another, right? Or they say, you know, if you don't KYC/AML, you cannot basically exist within this system. "Oh, and why do you want such a big amount from your account? Where did you get that money from?" And you go like, "I earned it, stupid! It's my money." And then you realize, actually, it's not my money, because it's in your bank account, right?

27:10Not my bank account. So Bitcoin is political for me, and Bitcoin is also a tool how to say, you know what? I'm going to send this money to Vlad today, and he will not give me any questions, because I'm not a criminal. I don't want to be surveilled if I have done nothing wrong.

27:39Vlad CosteaI was thinking, as you were speaking, of people who don't really work and basically exist, and they receive money from the state as welfare. How would you convince people like this to actually embrace sovereignty and something like Bitcoin, which is all about what you do by yourself, it's your own power, and embracing this kind of freedom?

28:10Alena VranovaThere's definitely, you know, some part of people who cannot work. I'm not the person to say, "Oh, you know, let's forget about them." Of course not. It is a human side. We are humans. We are not animals, right? We need to take care of people that are disadvantaged. But I think we can do that in a pure capitalist way. When you look at the US, the US has always been like the cradle of capitalism and the pride of capitalism.

28:49At the same time, Americans are the one nation in the world that donates money, that tips, that gives donations, that helps out, that have a lot of charities. So it only tells you what people are good at. And when people are prosperous, they have money and they have resources to share. If nobody has anything, people just don't share, because they expect the state to do that for them. So I prefer... So yeah, I really prefer to just support.

29:29People are not stupid, people are not cheap, people don't need, you know, everyone to tell them what kind of forms you have to fill out and what kind of certifications you have to do.

29:46If your food that you produce is not good and it's poisoning people, people will stop buying it, right? So here, like, just more freedom to the people to be able to decide about where they go and what they do.

30:05Vlad CosteaI have a copy of Adam Smith's "Wealth of Nations" here, close to my reach.

30:10Alena VranovaClose to your heart.

30:11Vlad CosteaYes. I didn't read much of it, to my shame. It's a big book and it has lots of...

30:15Alena VranovaIt's a big one.

30:16Vlad CosteaAnd what I remember that I did read, and I hope I'm not confusing with some other economist because I would embarrass myself, is that he recommends that wealthy people should not be taxed, but should be incentivized to make donations. As he understands this system of incentives, as everybody wants what they don't have.

30:42Somebody has too much money, they are going to willingly give it away if they receive something else in return. And he was actually recommending this idea of vanity, as rich people tend to have this pride and they want their names to be everywhere. So instead of taxing everybody or taxing the rich and making them run away from the country, it's better to just talk to them and say, "How about you donate so we build a stadium, and after it's completed, it's going to bear your name."

31:15Alena VranovaYes, exactly. Have you read anything from Ayn Rand? She is talking in her trilogy, what's the name of it? I can't remember right now. Anyway, so that's a great book, right? And I think there's also a movie, so for those who didn't have time to read that, just watch the movie.

31:52Exactly. Now, there have been some discussions, and one of my professors of economy, she basically explained to us, "Look, it's proven that whenever the country lowers the tax rate, effectively they collect more. It's counterintuitive, but it's fact." So again, if you lower your tax rate, you end up having more in your budget. Why? Because people are not trying to find ways how to avoid taxes, because they think, "Oh, if I only pay 5 or 10%, I can live with that." Some people would say, "Oh, that's fair, you know, for what I'm getting."

32:34But if you start taxing 30, 35, even more, like we have today in my country, a combined tax rate of like 60 to 65%, that's incredible. That's a lot. You know, I've always been wondering, like in the medieval times, people would pay 10% to the ruling powers, right? 10%, and they did revolt. There were revolutions and upstandings and upheavals against 10% tax. Now we are paying 50, 60, even more, and we are quiet. Why? Because our rulers are smarter. They don't tax you flat 60%, but they divide the taxes into multiple layers of taxation, right?

33:26Be it some value-added tax on the goods and services that you consume, be it like a profit tax, dividend tax, and then mandatory health insurance and social insurance and stuff like that, right? And when you combine that all, you get to a huge number. Instead of that, if they said, "No, we're going to do a very low flat tax, and we will not punish the ones that are successful. We will not take more from the wealthy." Why? Because these wealthy people tend to employ thousands of other people and to build stuff.

34:06They have, on average, a better risk appetite. They are the ones to go and say, "Okay, I'm going to invest 10 million here, and I'm going to build a factory, and I'm going to employ people." Well, if you tax them like crazy, then they're going to go, "Okay, I will open some company in some tax haven and, you know, screw you, and I will not invest into this country." I think that's a very logical thing. I'm still surprised that the politicians and the economists did not come to this understanding. Is it the same in Romania?

34:51Vlad CosteaIt is. We have the same tax rates, about 60-something percent in total, and we have the same tendencies to overtax. You know, the state needs more money, so how are we going to get that? "Oh, how about we raise the VAT?" That's the first measure usually. When there's times of crisis, they raise the VAT, they cut the salaries of the state employees, they disincentivize the whole private sector.

35:25Alena VranovaYeah, and you can actually see quite well how bad the country is doing if you look at what's the percentage of people employed by the public sector. If you see the public sector is huge, you know that there is a lot of trouble. It's a lot of trouble.

35:47Vlad CosteaYeah, that's a bubble.

35:50Alena VranovaAnd also, I mean, you're not gonna go against your employer, right? So if you're employed by the state, and the state, meaning all the people, but the state is giving you your bread, then you're not going to go against it, right? And you may even think that you are doing some good service to your country, as I have seen, you know, while leading the SatoshiLabs company. I had a very frequent encounter with the workers from the tax authority, right? And these ladies, they truly believed that the paperwork and all these rules and all these things are like almost above the godly law.

36:40Right? They truly believed in the system and they... So it's not like people are mean or not knowing. They just believe that this is really what is working. Kind of sad, you know.

36:56Vlad CosteaMy father used to work for the Romanian fiscal authority. In his early years, I think he had the same kind of opinion that he's doing something which is useful by fighting against evasion and stuff like that. But he has seen so many good businesses just close down because of some bureaucratic reasons, which led to huge fines and made them unsustainable as businesses, just because they had to pay a lot of money to this, that he realized that it's absurd. I think right now he's a fan of the American approach.

37:35Alena VranovaOh really? Why?

37:38Vlad CosteaI don't know, maybe he studied more. I mean, let's just remember.

37:42Alena VranovaBut the American approach is like a complete slavery, in my opinion. America, at least US, is the only country, from what I know, in the world that enslaves their citizens, regardless of their domicile and whereabouts, and so on. So even if you're living for 20 years outside of the US, you still have to pay tax in the US. Even if you give up your citizenship, your American passport, you are still obliged, I think, for seven years to pay taxes in the US. So I feel like the US actually has one of the craziest ownership of the citizens.

38:28Vlad CosteaI think I was referring more to the practice of filing in your tax returns and all the documents, and it's up to the community around you to report if you're being dishonest and you own much more than you reported.

38:40Alena VranovaAh, got you.

38:41Vlad CosteaIt's a system that's based much more on having small-scale groups, which are careful to what the other one does, and if they have a Porsche in their yard and they reported like $20,000 earnings in their year, then there's something suspicious. And not up to agents to come and check all the time. How much you have, and maybe that they do random checks from time to time, but not everybody. But it's up to the good-willing citizens to actually report.

39:19Alena VranovaYes, I mean, I have my duty to report. If I do it wrongly or if I miscalculate, then it's my liability, right? I have to correct it and I have to either pay more or whatever. The problem that I have with this thinking is why? What in the world makes the state or the government think that they can use people as their tools, as their... outsource their tasks and, you know, their own job to other entities? And this is exactly what's happening by using other people to report on the neighbor.

40:04In Germany, some people even report their neighbors for posting an Airbnb listing. In here, basically, the government is using companies, private businesses, on their own expense to report everything, right? So when you think of it, this should be reversed. This should be on a voluntary basis and not like me surveilling all the customers and then reporting to the government on the customers. Basically, we have a huge government, a very costly government, and the government still uses private sector as their reporting tool, as their, you know, executive tool. I find this weird, right?

40:58You have no idea, as a CEO and owner of a company, how much money and time I had to spend on, from my perspective, almost completely useless reporting and stuff. They had all our imports and exports in the system. Despite that, we had to kind of report and summarize for them and explain all over and all over again, right?

41:29I didn't like that. I even had the chance to tell it to the Minister of Finance himself. "Look, my company is okay. We may have done, you know, like really tiny administrative mistakes, but we have not cheated ever. We have not, you know, changed numbers. We have not cheated on exports and stuff. But we constantly have to prove this in audits. Why?" You know? "Why? What's the motivation for me to do business here in this country and pay taxes here?" So of course you have, you know, arbitrage opportunities, and that's what, in the end, those businessmen who are willing to take risks and who are willing to develop businesses, they will think twice.

42:18You know, if this country is like this and it's really difficult to actually make some decent living here, I'll go somewhere else. I love arbitrage opportunities, by the way. It's the...

42:34The thing, the tool that allows, you know, people just continuing what they're doing. And a lot of, you know, huge companies... I don't even understand really the upheaval against huge corporations trying to optimize, you know, for taxes. Why not? I mean, why not? The taxes are so drastic, and, you know, the overall attitude and the output of the government, I'm not happy with it. So, I mean, is that just not logical for companies to optimize for taxes? Why did we put a stigma on these people, like, "Those are criminals"? Aren't those criminals who are stealing my money and abusing for corruption? Right, that should be the discussion in place.

43:28Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess this is the kind of revenge that politicians have on private sector. It's unhealthy for everybody else except for their own reelection. And we've seen it, I guess, with the Panama Papers. We had all these reports about businesses not filing taxes and having their headquarters in Panama, tax haven. But it's only a moral flaw, not actually a fiscal one. It's not like...

44:01Alena VranovaWhat is immoral about it? Tell me.

44:04Vlad CosteaWell, if you refer to the morality of actually paying back to the community that you come from, and let's say that you're an American company and you're not paying taxes in the United States, then maybe that is immoral, but it's defined by the political side, not by the economic rationale. So it makes sense from an economic point of view to do your best in order to avoid paying that high amount of taxes that you are obliged to by your jurisdiction. But that's not something that politicians want regular citizens to understand, and they want to hate... They want you to hate the wealthy.

44:45And basically have heroes like Bernie Sanders or Jeremy Corbyn or whatever socialist politician.

44:53Alena VranovaJamie Dimon.

44:55Vlad CosteaYeah.

44:57Alena VranovaI'm just kidding. Well, okay, so the question of morality is here. So that's a good question. Morality in what? Do you think it's moral to send people to jail for example, tax evasion for 15 years, while they send a child murderer to jail for six or seven years?

45:31Vlad CosteaThat's clearly unbalanced.

45:35Alena VranovaYeah. Also, it's unfair.

45:38Vlad Costea...to bankers who went to jail.

45:40Alena VranovaSo if I create conditions that push people to do certain acts, and then punish them for that, is it moral?

45:54Vlad CosteaWell, that depends. If you have the conditions to be a bad parent and you're being a bad parent, are you being immoral to your child? Maybe that's...

46:07Alena VranovaYeah, so your child runs away, right? Because you're like extremely prohibited. For example, you don't allow your child to do what he loves to do, right? He likes to play violin or so, and you say no violin. And you say, "No this, no that, and do this only as I tell you," right? And then the child, when he's 15, disappears from home, runs away. And then it gets punished because the father says, "I will never want to see you again," or you're gonna, you know, basically jail him from his life.

46:46So I know it's a little bit different example, but this is basically what the governments do to their businesses, to the economy that keeps... to the heart of the economy. And then they're surprised, right, that companies optimize for the tax, instead of, you know, looking back and stepping back and saying, why don't we just try out a different approach? It's been proven that when you lower tax rate, effectively you get more into your budget. So why are they so stupid? I don't know. Like, you know, this is a...

47:29It's a... the questions of, you know, morality are very difficult always. And of course, you know, you will have very rich people who have no feeling in them to, you know, participate in the social environment and helping out and building stuff, and they just kind of go and enjoy their wealth and do luxury yachts and beautiful girls, and that's all, right? Fine. But we cannot judge all of the successful people based on a few bad examples, right? Or a few rotten apples... Don't make the entire tree wrong.

48:13Vlad CosteaYeah, I agree with that. I wanted to ask you about what it's like to own Bitcoin in the Czech Republic, and if you can actually live with it, as I've read an article by Bitcoin Magazine, and the author of the article said that in San Francisco it's so terrible that it's very likely that you can starve, and there is a greater market for altcoins than it is for Bitcoin.

48:43Alena VranovaIt's the blockchain hype, right, in Silicon Valley. I heard that blockchain, not Bitcoin but blockchain, is basically like a very core topic to discuss next to weather and other things that are happening in Silicon Valley. I don't know, I have a feeling that here in Czech Republic a lot of people are motivated by others than just purely speculative reasons. So a lot of people are actually trying to build useful, useful stuff. And there is... you know, I haven't actually traveled to Prague as a tourist, but I assume that it could be possible, although not easy, to survive purely, purely on crypto.

49:40Like just earning and paying in Bitcoin, you can do that. You can find places where you can eat and drink, and you can possibly find, you know, places that you can rent. There's co-working spaces that you can rent for Bitcoin and stuff like that. There's a lot of companies in the crypto space. But is it like a fully-fledged Bitcoin-supporting market yet? No, not really. But it's coming. Like, I mean, the largest electronics dealer in the country, it's a huge, huge business. They accept Bitcoin. And not just that.

50:18They sell a Trezor hardware wallet. They sell other things, like graphic cards for mining, and they sell and buy Bitcoin, so they have Bitcoin ATMs in their shops, right? So it just tells you, like, okay, maybe here it's probably easier, whereas Silicon Valley is this fairytale land, you know, for unicorn and rainbow-floating white papers.

50:48Vlad CosteaWait, so the equivalent of the Czech Amazon is accepting Bitcoin?

50:54Alena VranovaNot Amazon, that's not the biggest retailer. It's called Alza, A-L-Z-A, not C-Z. They even have like commercials with these... They have very funny, annoyingly screaming greenish mascot, like, I don't know what it is, an extraterrestrial or something like that. And recently I've seen some funny advertisement with this slimy dude with a huge golden Bitcoin chain around his neck. So they are bullish on Bitcoin. It's great. It's very refreshing to see private businesses' understanding of... it's not just a marketing tool maybe, but it's a new segment, it's a new... They recognize this is a new market developing in front of their eyes, and they want to catch the opportunity.

51:56Vlad CosteaI know from experience and from what I've read that the most developed countries right now were the first ones to embrace the Industrial Revolution. That's why we have this order and that's how we have this distribution of wealth on a global scale. And you think that right now the countries that are the first to embrace Bitcoin are going to turn the balance in their favor in the future?

52:24Alena VranovaYeah, I think so. Any investments in research and development, in science, in technology... Whoever is looking forward is going to get there sooner. Why? Because the others are just looking in front of them, right? And they can only make a small step in front of them, if that's the limit that they see. It's a... it comes... It is valid for individuals as well as countries, state actors, right? And, you know, Czechoslovakia, before the Second World War, was actually one of the top 10 economies in the world.

53:11Imagine, a tiny, tiny small country. Most of people in the world don't even know where it is exactly, right? And the small Czechoslovakia back then, it must have had maybe 10 or 12 million inhabitants altogether, was one of the top 10 economies. Why? Because we had a lot of machinery happening, a lot of research, a lot of huge construction works. In the 50s and 60s, a lot of cement and guns. We were huge producers of armory and stuff like that. And then what happened was the Second World War, Hitler, and then the Communists.

53:57And all of a sudden, 1989, we wake up into a new reality, and we realize that we are a hell of a poor country now. We have nothing. We have nothing left compared to the rest. Looking, you know, what's happening out there, we are left basically with nothing here. And why? Because there was no huge, you know, investment into new technologies, and basically we were just, during the communist times, we were just supplying the entire Soviet bloc, including Cuba and all these countries, including Romania, by the way, with our products, right? So we were like a mass production place, but there was no huge research and there was no new technologies coming in.

54:53So we were delayed against the West by, some say 20, but I would say even 40 years. And yeah, I can definitely see that countries that understand and businesses that understand that Bitcoin is the future will have a heads up or head start.

55:18Vlad CosteaMy father usually tells me stories from when the Russians came. He wasn't alive at the time, but he had his parents and grandparents tell him that we built airplanes in a city which is called Brasov. And it was actually a Romanian inventor who came up for the first time with the engine which breaks the speed of sound. I'm not sure what it's called in English, but the engine...

55:44Alena VranovaSupersonic.

55:46Vlad CosteaYeah, supersonic. His name is Coandă, Henri Coandă. And we had this huge factory to build airplanes, and the Russians just took it. They took it apart. They sent it in train wagons to Moscow, and they established a factory which now builds tractors for agriculture. Because they said that we should be their supply for grains and agricultural products, and we are farmers.

56:22Alena VranovaIt's funny, you know. Yeah, yeah, that's the embracing of industrial revolution in the Soviet countries. I was having a TED talk, I think two or three years ago here in Prague, and I brought up the case of the car in the United Kingdom. So in the late 19th century, you know, cars were new. It was a new thing. It was basically a toy for extravagant wealthy people, right? Or we can say today, when we look at Bitcoin, for nerds and for people with extravagant and weird ideas, such as anarchists, right?

57:21But back then, that was the situation for the car. Nobody knew how to drive it well. The cars would break down. There was no infrastructure, no good roads for the cars, and so no petrol stations, you know. It was very difficult, just like with Bitcoin today. I mean, Bitcoin is still this weird thing, like people still go like, "Yeah, I don't understand it." And so people were like, "Yeah, I don't understand cars. And why having like a big thing that can hurt me instead of having a faster horse," right?

58:03And so the government then wanted to regulate the cars, and they invented this red flag thing. Have you heard of it? It's quite a known, funny story. So the Red Flag Act was designed to prevent, to regulate the car industry and especially the behavior of car drivers. And so in front of each car, you had to have a person that's walking or running in front of your car and holds like a red flag to signal coming danger.

58:43Vlad CosteaNo, I never heard of this, but it's insane.

58:47Alena VranovaIt seems insane, but the same way it seems insane to me when governments are trying to regulate Bitcoin. First of all, it is so new. It's just 10 years. It's very nascent. We don't know what kind of features are evolving, and we already try to fit it into our boxes, right? Just because it's so new. They are trying to call it different ways, and I'm saying anyone who tries to fit Bitcoin into a certain box will fail, because then you look at a different, you know, perspective, and you see that Bitcoin actually also does this and does that, and you can use it in many different ways.

59:34And so, just coming back to the Red Flag Act, this is the reason probably why the United Kingdom has never become a superpower in automobile. Never. It was France and Germany who took the power, because they were not so restrictive, you know, not so trying to curb the innovation. I think those countries, and there are countries like, for example, Liechtenstein, although I'm not super excited about the fact that they issued the specific law for blockchain, but at the same time, they are very proactive and they are embracing this business and they are making, you know, conscious steps, and they are actually very entrepreneurial. The government is very entrepreneurial.

1:00:27It's not like this, you know, power-grabbing type of government that we see in a lot of other countries. So I'm sure, you know, that this is the case.

1:00:41Vlad CosteaSo what would you say is the killer feature of Bitcoin, the one that should encourage people to adopt it and understand it as something that isn't just speculative, but something that they can use and find purpose in?

1:00:57Alena VranovaYou know, Vlad, I don't think there's one answer to this. It depends on who's asking.

1:01:04Vlad CosteaWho's asking. Yeah, I was thinking about that. Go on.

1:01:10Alena VranovaSo if you ask, for example, a wealth manager or a family office, people who are taking care of some family wealth, sometimes for centuries, okay, and they see that the value of their assets, especially if it's dollar denominated, for example, is dropping like crazy. You know, I'm sure you know this graph. It's a very, you know, often repeated graph on Twitter and online that shows the value of the dollar 100 years ago and now.

1:01:54The purchasing power of the dollar. So these people, when you ask them, like, "Why?" Because you should make sure that you maintain and preserve the wealth of the family, right? So do your political hedge and get a part of your wealth into Bitcoin. If you ask a Venezuelan, that's a completely different story.

1:02:19Vlad CosteaYeah, I was thinking of my great-grandparents, who actually had their small businesses confiscated. And by my father's generation, there was nothing left. It was just starting from scratch with a new government and a new way of thinking, and their attempt to create a new and better society, which ended up crumbling and collapsing, and leading to hyperinflation

1:02:49Alena Vranovaand to despotic rulers, especially in Romania. And not just in Romania. I mean, in my country, it was similar, except for Ceaușescu was extreme in his behavior. I think he was a madman.

1:03:05Vlad CosteaYeah, but he refused to invade Czechoslovakia.

1:03:13Alena VranovaHe refused to what?

1:03:15Vlad CosteaTo invade Czechoslovakia in 1968, during the Prague Spring. We were the only country of the Soviet bloc which refused to participate with the army in the invasion.

1:03:30Alena VranovaAnd you know, when you're talking about your grandparents and losing everything, it was just the same here. 1948, the government took all the private businesses from people. They collectivized everything. And in 1953, we had a so-called monetary reform. I love this word because it's such a diminutive. It's just such a nice way to say that, "Oh, we're actually stealing money from you, but let's call it a reform." And the way it happened was a shock. It was not something that people would expect. There was no hyperinflation happening before.

1:04:13Actually, the night before the reform, our president, I think it was Zápotocký, he spoke in the media, he said, "Everything is okay, do not worry about anything." And the next day, boom! Monetary reform. What does it mean? People lost approximately one to 30 the value of their savings, of their investments and everything. On average, one to 30. So you had 30 korunas, now you have just one, right? And so there is, especially in these countries that we lived in and grew up in, I think there's a basic mistrust in the government, and that a lot of other countries don't have that, right? Because they still believe that the government is on their side, actually.

1:05:16And that, you know, there are even countries where I believe that there are, you know, governments thinking about the prosperity of their people and their businesses, but unfortunately not in most cases.

1:05:32Vlad CosteaYes, and I guess in my academic experience, when I've been on exchange, I went to Paris, I went to Bologna in Italy, and I went to Gothenburg in Sweden. And I noticed that the student campuses were so leftist that they were celebrating the 100-year celebration of the Russian Revolution, Red October. And to me that was shocking. I was looking at them, asking myself, "What is wrong with you people? Do you have any idea what happened then?" You're just mindlessly following something which sounds nice, but it really wasn't.

1:06:09You have an entire history to actually read about. And if it was like the celebration of Karl Marx's birth, and they were just assuming that his ideas were never really implemented and they were misinterpreted, then I guess, okay, that's fine. You can live in your bubble. You can dream about it. But if you have books of history, which actually document every event that happened after... Which date was it? In October 1917?

1:06:43Alena VranovaI think so. October or November?

1:06:47Vlad CosteaNo, it's Red October. But anyway, it is shocking to see in France that they... I mean, I guess it's in the history and in the culture of France to always seek for a new revolution and say, "We overthrew the king in 1789, and we're going to do it once again when it's necessary." But they were socialists to the bone. There was nothing to convince them against the... There was nothing bad that you could say about the state. They would argue with all these data and all these OECD graphs and ideas that actually economies grow better when you have greater taxation. That welfare states bring much more prosperity, stuff like that.

1:07:41Alena VranovaAnd giving Canada and Sweden as example. Yeah, great. Except both of them are actually capitalist countries with super high taxation and super heavy welfare state. That's fine, but they're still not putting people to jail for different opinions, and you still have the option to go away without being shot. And so you were shocked in these countries, but I was shocked in New York when I saw that someone erected this huge statue of Lenin in New York. Like, why, people? Why? It almost feels like an insult to people who have gone through the fascism and communism.

1:08:36Honestly, it is an insult, because it's me telling the world, "I have never read a single history book, or I have never even given a thought to what I'm celebrating," you know. And there's a lot of, you can see in the US, there's a lot of even graphic design that resembles the 70s, 80s, the normalization period, the functionalism of our culture, if I can call it like that. It's a bit scary. I should not laugh. It's a tragic... It's like a tragic comedy, sorry.

1:09:22Vlad CosteaNo, they don't like their freedom. They want somebody to come and tell them what to do with their lives, what to do with their money, how to live. That's crazy.

1:09:33Alena VranovaYeah, but I think that's also gonna change. At the same time, you know, we complain now about these tendencies, but at the same time, there's another current that's happening, and it's quite a strong current, and the current is tending more towards self-reliance and sovereignty and live and let live. You know, voluntary principles and privacy. I think we will, as you noted before about the censorship, right, we must be more and more people just, you know, taking the power back. Because now we have the tools. 20 or 40 years ago, we did not have the tools.

1:10:19But we have cryptography, we have Bitcoin, we have all these ideas about decentralized systems, and by decentralized, I mean more resilient, more secure systems. So that's coming too. That's why I'm here, actually. You know, that motivates me, because one thing is to complain and cry about the state of affairs, and another thing is to actually do something about it. I hope we'll get more and more people excited about these topics and join the bandwagon and build stuff so that people can use them with these tools.

1:11:00Vlad CosteaYeah, and I came to the conclusion that this world would be such a good place and much better in every way if we all just minded our own business and tried to pursue our dreams and tried to actually make something happen and build something.

1:11:17Alena VranovaYeah, right? Stop telling other people how they should live. Just live your dream, you know, live by your example. Do stuff that makes sense for others. That's how you make yourself useful in this world. That's what I'm trying to do with my life. I hope it turns out well eventually, or sometimes at least.

1:11:45Vlad CosteaAnd if it doesn't, at least we were happy doing it, and we actually embraced our freedom as opposed to waiting for somebody to tell us what to do. I guess in the end it comes down to what we appreciate most and what we enjoy in life. Maybe that I'm not entitled and it's not my qualification to blame people who do nothing with their lives, even though they have a lot of capacity and they are perfectly fine and sane and healthy and able to do something great. They end up just wasting their lives.

1:12:29Alena VranovaYeah, and sometimes it's in a good faith, you know. I don't... When you look at, for example, Germany in the 30s, late 20s and 30s, do you think that people in Germany would ever, ever assume that the National Socialist Democratic Labour Party, NSDAP, that it would turn into a despotic country and, you know, ignite a huge world war and kill millions and millions of people? Do you think that people, when they voted for NSDAP, that they expected this? No. Like, no, I don't think Germans are crazy or bad people, not at all, right?

1:13:18But it just like took on enormous, monstrous size once, you know. And there was a lot of like... And it was a socialist party, actually. It was a leftist party.

1:13:31Vlad CosteaYes, that's something which we always get wrong, as Nazism actually is National Socialism. It's of the left to the same extent that it's to the right. We usually label it as right-wing because it's nationalist and it stands for all these ideas which promote a kind of national purity and these ideologies which reside from a distorted way of doing history and saying that our ancestors were like this and we should be the same and preserve, prevent everybody else from invading our territory. But it's of the left, that centralization and the planned economy and...

1:14:20Everything that goes on in terms of fiscal terms. It's of the left. That's something that people usually don't understand. It was actually leftist political scientists who labeled Nazis and fascists to the right, to make a clear distinction.

1:14:43Alena VranovaThat was very unfortunate, very unfortunate, by the way. There's a huge confusion, like even when you go to US versus Europe, on what is left and what is right. It's like a completely different story in both. What is conservative and democratic is not like what is left and right in Europe, right? And that was a... I think that was a huge mistake in the history books and by the politologists, right? Who wrote the labels, who nailed the labels.

1:15:18Vlad CosteaIn my definition, the left is demanding for more state intervention, and the right is more libertarian. And yes, I guess the right is anarchist and the left is statist. That's my understanding of it.

1:15:36Alena VranovaThat's my understanding too, but is it the correct one? I don't know. Like, it's not about which one is correct, but about some mutual understanding and understanding where national socialism... And look at US. There are socialist tendencies, but at the same time a lot of like, you know, hatred and these nationalist tendencies, and this melting together and taken to extreme. Okay, to extreme means establishing it as a general rule for the society, adopting it as like this is the norm, right? That becomes very dangerous. That's basically what happened in Germany. And with a psychotic leader in power, of course.

1:16:30Vlad CosteaYeah, but I guess history books also teach us that not all Germans were Nazis. And just because we saw footage of them standing in public places and doing that salute and cheering for their leader and applauding, it doesn't mean that everybody else living at home was in agreement with that ideology or was happy. There was an opposition which the Nazi party had, which was suppressed and censored and punished, but there was one and we should remember that. And there were people living in small villages who couldn't care less if you're a Jew or if you're from Africa or you're from any other place of the world. They had been living in these communities for hundreds of years, and they couldn't care less where you come from.

1:17:22Alena VranovaAnd then because, you know, exactly because the norm has been established somewhere. So the norm in Germany back then was, you know, you should be Aryan... I don't know how to say it in English. Aryan. Yes. And if you're, for example, Jew, that's abnormality that has to be taken away from the society. And any extreme positioning, I think, is very toxic and dangerous. And I don't mean by that that you cannot have extreme opinions. Feel free to have them, right? But even in crypto, you see certain groups of people being extreme.

1:18:10Extreme in this topic, saying we can only have Bitcoin. And don't take me wrong, I love Bitcoin, I will always fight and build and work on Bitcoin. But I do not understand this position of maximalism. For example, from my perspective, that's like ignoring the fact that there is no power of one in the world, and therefore there should be no power and rule of one, because that's despotism, right? And it's also not natural. There's no oneness in the nature. You have gazillion, you know, different types of flowers and bees, right?

1:18:53Does it mean that all the other bees are bad and wrong? No. If they have their purpose, you know, in the ecosystem, fine, right? Let them live. And so this is, I think, you know, we can abstract from this and look into our own community and say, "Hey guys, don't waste your energy on trying to convince that this or that, you know, altcoin or shitcoin or whatever, that it's wrong or bad. Just don't waste your energy. Go build your stuff." You know, if Bitcoin continues to be the most secure, the best, the most resilient system, then everyone will just use it and you will not have to even fight against... You know, you see where I'm going with this?

1:19:53Any kind of extremism is just bad. I don't like it.

1:19:58Vlad CosteaThe way I see maximalism right now is that they're just like the early Christians, who actually said that your religion and your religious leader is not true if he wasn't born by immaculate conception, just like Jesus, or Bitcoin was, as it's pure. You just had a creator who was selfless and he left. And you have this situation in which you have no leader and you have to establish your own rules about how you conduct yourself. Nobody's coming to tell you what to do, or nobody's coming to tell you in two weeks we're going to hard fork, prepare your system, your node for that.

1:20:46Alena VranovaYeah. And you know, actually, I want, even in crypto, I want to have arbitrage opportunities.

1:20:55So if one day I think that something superseded Bitcoin, something has some qualities that Bitcoin doesn't have and I'm looking for those qualities, I want to be able to just easily, you know, get into the new coin and start using it. Why not? Now, maybe some people go like, "Heretics!" But, yeah, hey, let's be open. We never know where this is going towards, right? And we're building on Bitcoin because I believe in the future of all the systems. And when we look at not just the digitization of like internet and communication, but all these assets that are being built as crypto tokens, crypto assets, equities and whatnot.

1:21:56I think all this will exist and that's fine, but it will all be centered around one specific ledger, and I believe that's going to be the Bitcoin ledger, right? Because that has all the properties that I mentioned before. So I'd rather see like, you know, a multi coin future with Bitcoin at the center. And that's basically the way I'm looking at the world. And my focus is 99% into Bitcoin. 1% I leave open to other options. What about you, Vlad? How are you positioned in your mind? Do you also own other crypto than BTC?

1:22:46Vlad CosteaYeah, I own some Ethereum Classic and some Litecoin.

1:22:51Alena VranovaMm-hmm.

1:22:53Vlad CosteaNot that I see them as being that great. And I think it would be a good idea to get into Grin or something, but that's a bad store of value. It only serves the purpose of transferring privately. And that's what privacy coins should be all about. But I think these cheaper altcoins are actually educational. They are great for people who get into cryptocurrencies and they learn how to use a wallet. They learn how everything works. And that's useful for the Bitcoin supply, as no coins get lost by newbies.

1:23:36And it's also healthy for the education of the space. I think it's a good idea to start out with some kind of cheap altcoin and then gradually get into something which is bigger and is going to be here for the next 50 years, maybe. And that's not something I can say about any other project, but I think Bitcoin will still be around in 50 years. And I wanted to point out something which I discussed with Peter Todd last week, I think. And it was about the fact that Bitcoin is not the culmination of the cashless society that banks try to promote nowadays.

1:24:20When they say, "Well, why carry cash in your wallet when you can just pay with a credit card? That's it. Pay with a card and it's instant. You don't have to think about it. You don't have to stress yourself." If you don't have enough money, then it's going automatically into debt and you're going to pay a small fee to recover. And we actually, the two of us, me and Peter Todd, regard Bitcoin as being more of a collectible, more of something which is cash, and it exists digitally just because we have the cryptography to make sure that nobody takes it away from us.

1:24:57It's unconfiscatable, and that's the only reason why we need technology which is digital to have it. Otherwise, we would have some kind of gold, which can be hidden, but gold is heavy, hard to transport, hard to conceal, it's detectable. And also, he said that Bitcoin needs cash. Not Bitcoin Cash, but real cash. So until the moment it's truly private, nobody else knows what you're doing, just like with cash, it's useful to do quick swaps and maybe meet people and say, "I'm going to give you half a Bitcoin and you're going to give me $2,000 in cash."

1:25:44That's maybe healthy for the ecosystem and taxing for these KYC/AML exchanges, which also collect big fees and are very abusive and close down accounts.

1:25:59Alena VranovaSo here's the thing, those exchanges that, you know, charge you a fee from every transaction or when you get out, they are motivated basically by this to spark more transactional value and basically absorb the value from each of your transactions, right? And do I like it particularly? No. I think there are other approaches to it, but that's not the main point I wanted to raise. Here's the thing. With cashless society, I think it's very dangerous. It's very dangerous. We can see that in China, basically, it's almost cashless.

1:26:48Denmark, I think, is cashless. It's the ultimate enslaving, you know, it's the ultimate slavery for people. My mom, she, I mean, she's 60-something, right? And she came back to me and said, "Alena, I don't, I hate, you know, I don't want to use my card anymore." And I said, "Why, mom?" And she goes, "Because I just realized that they know everything that I buy and they know everything, even where I go, maybe even who I meet, you know, if we pay like the bill in the restaurant. Like, I don't like that."

1:27:27And so, and my mom is, you know, she's in her pension years, so it's not that she would be a criminal or some huge big animal in the business world or political world, not at all. She's just a normal person. But she herself realizes this as a very dangerous mechanism. And you look at China and their social crediting system. I'm sure you heard about this. It's been a big topic for the past like one or two years. And you realize that, okay, they're cashless. That means you need to pay everything through your electronic money account.

1:28:13Because there's no cash anymore, right? There's just ones and zeros. And then based on how you behave and whether you behave according to the norm established in the society, the system evaluates whether you are worthy of buying a first class ticket for the train or not. And just tells you, sorry, you don't have enough social score to travel in the first class. Right. That is very scary to me. And I will do everything in my power to just, you know, go against that. I think we should not give up our very basic freedoms.

1:28:59Vlad CosteaYeah, and privacy is what makes us human and what drives us to innovate and to be creative. When I think about greatest accomplishments, I guess they happened just because I was free to just explore and I had the privacy to think and to try something new. And to, you know, when you're all alone and you need time for yourself and you're writing down everything, that's a part of privacy that we actually need, as opposed to being surveilled and knowing that anything that you're doing is being watched. And you have actually no incentive to do something which may be frowned upon by the norm, whatever that means, as the norm is constantly changing.

1:29:56Essentially, it's about retaining our human qualities. We pull the drapes when we go to sleep because we don't want others to look at what we're doing in bed. We shut the door when you go to the bathroom. I guess also our transactions in terms of acquiring goods and services should be private.

1:30:21Alena VranovaThat's right. I think that's an inherent right. It should not even be debated. It should not be even possible for the politicians to vote for censorship on the internet. How come people do not revolt? I am sometimes very like, not disappointed, but very like shaken by the fact that people are in the complete lethargy, apathetic to what's going on.

1:30:54I'm not the person to watch the news all the time and to see all the political debates. I don't have interest in that. I'm not a politician, right? I will never be a politician. I'm just a normal human that, you know, wants to do business. That's my goal. But I'm super surprised by, you know, being such an advanced culture, but then again, allow and just close our eyes and, you know, maybe it's out of fear of standing out and being punished. Maybe it's out of like, oh, this is cozy, out of comfort.

1:31:38It's better to just comply and these are the rules, without questioning like, who did the rules? Why? But yeah, I'm really trying to understand the world. Sometimes it's probably funny to say, but we are part of it, right? But it just really makes my mind spin.

1:32:04Vlad CosteaI also think that if we use Bitcoin in the form that it turned out into Bitcoin Cash or Bitcoin Satoshi's Vision, and that grows into a greater scale, that's just as bad as the cashless society, as it has no privacy.

1:32:23Alena VranovaBut Bitcoin has no privacy. Inherent privacy.

1:32:27Vlad CosteaYeah, but you can still use Wasabi Wallet and at some point they're going to implement some kind of privacy.

1:32:35Alena VranovaYeah, of course. Yeah, but look, I'm totally fine with all this Bcash and the BSV and whatever other forks there may be. That's fine for you. You can exist, just let's not waste our times on fighting like small kids. You have your truth, go follow your truth. You know, we have our truth. It's like, really, a kindergarten sometimes. I feel even in the SegWit times and all these discussions, I think we lost a lot of our precious times and brains just by disputing stuff. Discourse is necessary.

1:33:26It's important to explain stuff. But there's a certain level of like where we are still, you know, civil and polite, and say, "Okay, I don't agree with you, but that's fine. We don't have to agree about everything," right? Instead of like what was happening, like these ad hominem attacks on people. And, you know, I don't have to like everyone. No, people don't have to like me, like necessarily, right? It's okay. It's fine. This is, I think, what we could learn in the community, and I hope a lot of people have the same aftertaste, and when there's another one, you know, situation like this coming up, that they will go like, "Yeah, we've seen this.

1:34:15Okay, these are the facts. This is one implementation. This is a competing implementation." People choose. Go, right? Let's just continue building stuff. But in general, I think the last two years, year and a half, has taken off pretty well, especially for Bitcoin, with all the developments happening, and not just in the payment processing, but also in privacy and scalability of the ecosystem. I'm happy about how many people are dedicating their time to Lightning Network and that there's a lot of folks trying to make it easier for people to run their nodes and bringing new wallets and new extensions. It's exciting. It's very positive.

1:35:16Vlad CosteaYeah. I think we should make a prediction about the next 10 years of Bitcoin, but not in terms of price.

1:35:22Alena VranovaOh no. No price.

1:35:24Vlad CosteaJust something about its scale and adoption. Where do you think it will be 10 years from now? I know that Satoshi said that 20 years from that moment, he believes that there will either be a lot of transactions on the blockchain or there will be none, which I guess it's poetic and there's a nice way of putting it, and he had no way of witnessing what would go on 10 years from that moment.

1:35:56But now we find ourselves here and we see that actually, in terms of merchant adoption, Bitcoin has scaled down, maybe due to the high fees, maybe due to that conflict with Bitcoin Cash and all the infighting, and maybe that regular people do not have time to follow the news and see... give up, too conflictual. But maybe in 10 years we're going to have time to develop the Lightning Network to a greater extent that is implemented for merchants. And also we are going to see many more people maybe running full nodes and getting into buying Bitcoin. We have decentralized the ownership, so we have fewer whales, more owners.

1:36:48Alena VranovaI think people will primarily take back what belongs to them, and that's their money and their privacy, which is a part of the other, right? By running nodes at home. Well, right now, for example, Casa has this Casa node that runs a Bitcoin and Lightning Network, right? You can imagine this platform being used for any kind of decentralized system in the future, right? And I envision that this is really going to happen on a much bigger scale. We have something like a few thousand of nodes for Lightning currently and a little bit more of Bitcoin full nodes.

1:37:39But when you look at the pace over the past few months, it's now, it's like over the past few months the growth has been happening, really. And Lightning still being in beta, it's still not a finished product, it's still not completely, you know, full featured thing. It has some, you know, bugs and some downsides and stuff that's not working yet. Yet we already see this very early adoption of Lightning Network. So, if I should make a prediction, and I don't like to do them because I think it's more of a wishful thinking that I hope will turn out correctly, right?

1:38:25But if I should make some prediction, I would say even this year, 2019, will be a year when we see much more people paying with crypto, thanks to Lightning Network and thanks to companies, big, big companies. I really feel like I'm looking in my crystal ball right now, okay, and I feel like huge brands adopting Lightning or Bitcoin or any sorts of these technologies, 2019, 2020. Within 10 years, I think we will be on the way of rebuilding our financial systems around crypto and around Bitcoin. How?

1:39:12I don't know, but I feel like ours is due, you know, our financial system is really due to some major repairs. And also geopolitically, when you look at, you know, the renewal of the Cold War, basically between Russia and the US. And Mr. Putin, I think he definitely considers Bitcoin and switching, you know, selling his natural resources for Bitcoin. So this might be a strong, you know, agent in the entire game of adoption.

1:39:56Vlad CosteaWell, I can only imagine watching Putin say, "I just sold our natural gas for Bitcoin."

1:40:03Alena VranovaWoohoo! To the moon!

1:40:05Vlad CosteaTo the moon! That would be a great way to bypass the restrictions, and I guess he pays huge fines in euro to the European Union for invading Crimea.

1:40:26Alena VranovaYeah, I have a few friends in Russia, and the impact on the economy is quite severe, you know. And, you know, to use, I think, sanctions, economic sanctions, sanctions are a diabolical thing, because some government just uses sanctions against another government to bring them to do whatever they want them to do, right? But it's diabolical because whoever is suffering is not the government itself. It's the people of that country. And I think, I even believe like sanctions should be banned from being a legitimate geopolitical, like, diplomatic tool.

1:41:24Look at Venezuela, look at any other, like Iran. Iran, just because they are not using dollars, not just because, but I mean there was some history in the late 70s and 80s, right, turning the government against the seculars and stuff like that. But basically, Iran is heavily ostracized from the world. Do you think it's doing any good to the people there? No, not at all. Like everyone's suffering. Like, do they have better chances for more free and democratic establishment if they're enclosed in a very homogenic environment, and of course all the world is the enemy? You see the positioning.

1:42:19So I think this is one practice that should be seen as very, very bad, mean and unacceptable.

1:42:30Vlad CosteaTo me, it's interesting that Bitcoin is very American as an invention, and it's like the culmination of many advances in cryptography and computer science, which happened in America, from David Chaum and Ralph Merkle and all the way to Hal Finney and Nick Szabo. And we know that Hal Finney was the first person to receive a transaction, so we can say that the first ever operation on a blockchain actually happened in the United States. But actually, Bitcoin works against the interests of the foreign policy of the United States of America. If it succeeds as a currency on a global scale, then it's going to take away their power to manipulate other countries.

1:43:24Alena VranovaYes. And it's also funny because it also stands quite against the policy of International Monetary Fund and Christine Lagarde, because they are trying to kind of revive the project of SDR. SDR is an abbreviation for Special Drawing Rights, sorry. And that was the first attempt to establish a truly international form of money. And now don't imagine like newspaper printed for people, but it's basically a settlement layer in between countries and in between central banks of countries. And the SDR is basically a basket of 20 or 30 different major assets, so some, you know, currencies and some commodities and stuff like that.

1:44:29Precious metals. And this constitutes the basket of the price of SDR. And IMF since 2012, after the post-crisis, they realized that one of the problems of why we are in this crisis is because one country is issuing the global money, right? So let's establish a different form of global money. Let's revive the SDR. Oh, we cannot do it without China, because China happens to be one of the largest economies. So they convinced China to put renminbi, which is non-convertible, right?

1:45:05They convinced to put the renminbi into the basket of SDR, and that was a huge step for China, signaling it that yes, eventually, maybe in the future, you know, they are very slow in doing all these things and decisions because they have such a huge market, but eventually we will make yuan a convertible currency. And so Christine Lagarde has been pushing towards SDR adoption and to make it better and whatnot. And so what surprised me recently is like her fairly positive statements about Bitcoin and crypto. Not positive, but not absolutely dismissive, I would say.

1:46:07So you'll see. This project is trying to establish new... it is a competition to SDR as well, I think. I don't see euro as a competing thing. I think Europe has so many problems.

1:46:30That, you know, it was a hedge against the American dollar for Europe, nothing else basically. They wanted to have something as strong as the US dollar, especially after the Bretton Woods and especially after America started to have problems paying back the gold, returning the gold, you know, to the post-Second World War countries in Europe. We'll see. I don't know. Bitcoin seems to have all the features that, you know, dollars and euros are missing, and it seems to be a much better fit for the global economy than any centrally issued money.

1:47:25Vlad CosteaJust out of curiosity, what kind of academic studies did you do and what was your thesis on?

1:47:32Alena VranovaSo first I studied German philology, I'm a linguist, and I studied as well marketing communication, which was like more creative, you know, PR and photography and advertising and stuff like that. And then probably 10 years afterwards, I started to study again and I studied diplomacy with a strong focus on international monetary system. You know, that's why, actually, that's how I got to Bitcoin. That was 2010, 2011, again, you know, after the crisis in the US markets and the global actually, and I was looking for a better form of money.

1:48:26And surprise, surprise, there was Bitcoin waiting for me. It was very early and I did not really understand the entire scope. But, or let's say I understood where it can go. I kind of felt like, okay, this can be really, really big and really substantial. I did not understand the technicalities of it, how it works exactly, but that got me really excited. So this was my prep work for my thesis. By the way, that thesis I never finished. I just thought like, you know what, I found my answers.

1:49:09I don't need to write the thesis until the end. But I did all my research and I did a lot of research on like local currencies and SDR and petrodollar. And all the macroeconomic situation, and I just fell in love with Bitcoin.

1:49:32Vlad CosteaI guess if you ever get the time to finish that research and publish the paper, you'd do the world a great service.

1:49:38Alena VranovaOh, I think there are...

1:49:40Vlad CosteaI guess you have unique insights and with the kind of job that you do, you have access to lots of interesting information. So if you were to put that together into comprehensive research papers or a thesis, which actually outlines all the ideas, that would be useful to a lot of economists who only read maybe official sources from the World Bank and from the IMF and from the... OECD.

1:50:16Alena VranovaI think, you know, Vlad, I don't think they would take me seriously. I'm not a monetary expert. I'm not even an economist, I would say. I studied something, right, but I'm not really an economist. I'm good at building businesses. That's what I'm passionate about. All the topics that we discussed today are topics that I'm passionate about and I think I know a little bit about it. You know where I'm going? So I don't think I'm the person to write some discoveries about money. I think there are much, much better experts.

1:50:57But, you know, who knows, maybe when I'm old and I'm bored, maybe I'll do that. I think my role is in actually, you know, helping ideas to come to fruition as businesses. That's where I see myself and the value that I can bring.

1:51:19Vlad CosteaSo far, congratulations, you've done a tremendous job with Trezor and now Casa.

1:51:26Alena VranovaWell, look, it's me, but... A huge, huge and hardworking team, or a huge effort of a hardworking team, like, especially now with Casa, I must say, like, with this team, I have never seen, and I've built several businesses, even prior to starting with Bitcoin, and several teams, and I've never seen a team that would deliver on such a fast pace, and that would be so synchronized on the values and the vision and the mission, you know, that we have. So I think like Casa is like a startup on steroids delivering.

1:52:14So I'm just very fortunate to be a part of that team and help here and there, you know, with some ideas on how to move this forward. But it doesn't, you know, it can't be done by one person. Same goes for Trezor. You know, I mean, I was basically just the person who made it happen, but the idea, the concept of how the hardware wallet works, you know, all the technical parts and the research and development, that was brought by my two co-founders. I'm just like, I just consider myself a lucky girl to have all these, you know, smart and hardworking people around me.

1:53:02Vlad CosteaWell, that's really great. I'm partially envious as I live in a place where I don't even find the proper person to have a conversation about these topics. And the closest I ever got to was John Carvalho, who is also part of this podcast and he lives in Romania. And I met him only once and we got to speak a little. And it was...

1:53:26Alena VranovaNo way.

1:53:27Vlad CosteaBrief. Yeah, refreshing or something to actually unleash. You had all these ideas that you had in your mind, and you can all of a sudden have somebody to talk to face to face.

1:53:42And one of the reasons why I do these podcasts is that I get to learn something new. I get to exchange ideas. And that helps me broaden my understanding of something which I discovered later than you did. I think it was 2014-2015, but I didn't take it seriously. I was into political science and at the time we were being told all the time to only read official sources and distrust anything that doesn't come from any prestigious publication. So in the case of Bitcoin, I read about it from The Economist, from The Wall Street Journal.

1:54:25Alena VranovaYeah. They have all the interest to talk bad stuff against it.

1:54:34No, actually, you know what, I don't think they have the interest to talk bad stuff. I think they only have the interest of the groups that are standing behind them right now. You know what I mean? So it's not the goal of the media to totally like bash and bury Bitcoin. But they are paid by certain people, right? So it's more of like, oh, now Bitcoin is bad, you know, down the price. Oh, let's buy up. Have you seen this cartoon with Jamie Dimon, as he, as you know, he said like Bitcoin is so bad and Bitcoin crash, and then his group, his entire environment has been proven to buy Bitcoin in huge chunks.

1:55:29So, yeah. But, you know what, Vlad, I always said like I'm super happy about the environment in Prague and Slovakia, in Bratislava, there's a lot of smart, well-educated people who are building stuff. They just opened another branch of Paralelní Polis, the Bitcoin and crypto space. So there's a very good, you know, progressively thinking community of Bitcoiners as well as in Prague, so please feel free to join us, visit, and here I'm sure you will have great discussions with a lot of smart people.

1:56:19Interested in a lot of topics. This is a really, really blessed place. As I've been traveling and I've seen a lot of communities, actually, it is difficult to find places where people would go so much into depth and think about stuff and be so technically, you know, advanced or have such a good education and like to share like this stuff. I was quite nicely surprised in Tel Aviv, for example, this week, because the audience at the Bitcoin Summit was not just like big, but also quite savvy.

1:57:02No noob questions, you know, it was very interesting. But please, I'm inviting you over to Prague. If you're seeking and you're hungry for such an environment, this is definitely the environment for you to go.

1:57:18Vlad CosteaThank you. Whenever I have much more money than I have now, I'll definitely consider traveling. And I've never been to countries of the Central Europe that are east of Germany. So I've been to France, I've been to Germany, I've been to part of Austria, part of Hungary. Never to that part with Poland, with Czech Republic, Slovakia.

1:57:43Alena VranovaListen, Czech Republic, I think it's fairly cheap as well to live. You may be surprised, comparable to Romania, I don't know, maybe a little bit more expensive, but not like Germany or UK or these countries at all.

1:58:05Vlad CosteaAlso, I think it's the Czech Republic that used to be called Bohemia. And Bohemian Rhapsody is written about your lands, and we have an adjective in Romanian which is "boem," which means bohemian. It refers to that relaxed lifestyle in which you are much more inclined to study and reflect and...

1:58:31Alena VranovaYou know, be knowledgeable. And it's a peaceful country. People are peaceful. They don't like to fight. We like to have a beer, you know, and tell jokes and have some discourse and discussion.

1:58:49Vlad CosteaSounds very nice. It should be on my list.

1:58:54Alena VranovaThis is an open call for everyone in the world who's listening. Please come visit this country. You'll be really nicely surprised. Come see our Bitcoin space, it's called Paralelní Polis. It's an awesome, awesome place, a very unique space.

1:59:15Vlad CosteaI think you're doing a better job at promoting Czech tourism than your government does.

1:59:23Alena VranovaYeah, and these tourists are going to spend Bitcoin. By the way, when you get here, open Coinmap.org and you can find places accepting Bitcoin around the city.

1:59:37Vlad CosteaYou should get a call from the government tomorrow and they're going to say, "We're going to hire you for this new Ministry of Bitcoin." Do you accept it?

1:59:45Alena VranovaYou know what? I would totally say no. I would never ever work for the government. But yeah, funny idea though. Let's not get into there because that would be another podcast, I think.

2:00:04Vlad CosteaOh yeah. But anyway, this has been almost two hours and I'm happy that we spoke on so many topics and none of them were boring.

2:00:13Alena VranovaI wonder who's going to listen to this, Vlad. Like two hours is a lot of time. So hey, guys, if you've listened to the end of this podcast and you found it interesting, give us a shout out on Twitter. Mine is AlenaSatoshi. Vlad, what's yours?

2:00:31Vlad CosteaIt's @TheVladCostea, so it's T-H-E-V-L-A-D-C-O-S-T-E-A. I should change it to something shorter. I was actually thinking of becoming a crypto Twitter character and becoming Vampire Vlad, but that's too much.

2:00:50Alena VranovaThat's kind of sexy Romanian. Okay, I like that.

2:00:55Vlad CosteaDon't encourage me because I would use cheesy messages sucking people's bitcoins.

2:01:03Alena VranovaI mean, why not? Why not?

2:01:07Vlad CosteaI mean, I guess that's more interesting than my actual personality, but okay.

2:01:12Alena VranovaOh, I don't think it's just cheesy and funny. We have the crypto dog.

2:01:18Vlad CosteaWe have Crypto Bart Simpson, crypto that guy from... What's the name of the show? Saved by the Bell. Bully-esque or something. We have so many fictional characters who switched to Bitcoin or crypto, but we don't have a vampire. I hope nobody else steals my idea before I do it.

2:01:46Alena VranovaOkay, just go now to Twitter and book it. I mean, you're from Romania and you are Vlad. It's kind of like... It's very easy to draw that line.

2:01:59Vlad CosteaYeah, everybody asks me, everybody who's not from Romania asks me, "Is Vlad the most common name?" But it's not. "And do you really have vampires there?" And actually, we never spoke of vampires until 1910 or something when Bram Stoker published his novel.

2:02:22Alena VranovaActually, there's maybe more vampire history in Slovakia than in your country. There was a duchess or something like that called Báthory in my country. I don't know when, it was a few hundred years ago. And she had a very strong thing for bathing in the blood of virgins, you know, and stuff like that. Yeah, yeah. So maybe there is something to it and maybe it's just like a hoax. Okay, Vlad. Thank you very much. It was great talking to you. I like the fact that we had a different kind of discussion than Bitcoin. I'm loving this format. So thanks for inviting me.

2:03:21Vlad CosteaThanks for accepting. I hope the product of our conversation is useful to those listening up to this point of two hours something.

2:03:32Alena VranovaWe'll see how many shout outs we get on Twitter.

2:03:36Vlad CosteaOkay. So have a nice rest of your day and thank you for being part of this. Thank you. Bye-bye.

2:03:36================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio/video conversation in English between two non-native speakers (Czech guest, Romanian host), opening with a short music intro; no sponsor reads. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 7 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (164 chunks) and 51 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 6 of 6 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed music/© BF-WATCH TV hallucination, "Thank you for watching..." and stray "Bye."/"Thank you."/"Bad." and inline speaker label; fixed Ceaușescu, Maastricht criteria, Riccardo Spagni (fluffypony), economists, monarchist/minarchy, "Let's screw your dollar", "Chavez and now Maduro", restored dropped "stuff. But also from some", "cannot do for me", "international imbalances"; split long monologue at 00:08:15; Removed hallucinations ("U.S. Department of State", "Thank you", "Bye", "Thanks"); fixed korunas, KYC/AML, pale, fear, intelligentsia, narrative, food, tax haven, SatoshiLabs; repaired speaker turns (00:19:16 Alena, 00:31:07 Vlad's sentence end then Alena, interjections at 00:30:10-00:30:16); Lenin poem kept as unclear; Fixed speaker boundaries (Alena's "But the American approach", "Yeah, so your child", "Yeah. Also, it's unfair", Vlad's "Yeah" before "I'm just kidding"); restored "Ah, got you" (Alena); removed hallucinations ("Thank you for watching. See you next time. Bye!", "Thanks to everyone", "Bye.", stray "Bitcoin"); fixed mishearings (wines→fines, porch→Porsche, Chirith/hit it→cheated, record→report, listening→listing, Jamie Dixon→Jamie Dimon, small city of Slovakia→small Czechoslovakia, safe→state actors, slimy dude/neck, tops→shops, rainbow-floating, extraterrestrial); garbled "I'm going to jail podcast" marked unclear; Removed "Thank you for watching..." and "Thank you" hallucinations at 00:55:45, 01:06:52 and 01:07:32. Replaced the hallucinated "first time I heard about Bitcoin" with "their attempt to create a new and better society...". Fixed names and terms: Henri Coandă, Zápotocký, korunas, case of the car, 1989, Red Flag Act, "1:30 p.m." to "one to 30", and "schools" to "tools". Split turns for Alena's "Supersonic" interjection, Vlad's "Who's asking" and "Yeah, but he refused", and Alena's "October or November?". Fixed misattributed line-end fragments and restored the dropped words "the West" and "self-reliance"; Removed "Thank you for watching / See you next time / Bye" hallucinations, "What?", "Two words", doubled stutters; NSVAP→NSDAP; fascism→Nazism; split Alena/Vlad at "Yes, that's something"; restored "sane and healthy and able to do something great", "specific ledger"/"Bitcoin ledger", "in the restaurant", "And she goes"; fixed gasoline→gazillion, Bs→bees, sheep coin→shitcoin, green→Grin, Deeper→cheaper, Alpha→half a, Ashlis→cashless, hearing→cheering, politologists, nailed, hatred, prepare, born, communication, Jesus, cars→cash; fixed speaker label format; Removed hallucinations ("Bye, Vassilis", "Center for Autism", "Join Bitcoin.com", "Thank you for watching/subscribe", "Thank you for your time", stray "Bye."/"Thank you."); fixed David Chaum and Ralph Merkle, SDR (was SBR), SegWit, ad hominem, forks (Orcs), discourse, aftertaste, community, yuan, spin; restored dropped words from second ASR (privacy, "or there will be none", "bad, mean", Lightning Network, Casa node, "great way to bypass the restrictions"); s

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00