Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S10 E6 / Transcript
Transcript · S10 E6 · 1:30:09 · 2 Feb 2022

S10 E6: Nik Oraevskiy on Bitcoin Reserve, Privacy & Non-Custodial Exchanges

With Nik Oraevskiy. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:29Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to season 10 episode 6 of the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is Nik Oraevskiy, who is the CEO and co-founder of Bitcoin Reserve, and he has been in Bitcoin since 2012. Before we started recording this interview, he told me and we joked about the fact that usually each interview starts with the question, "How did you get into Bitcoin?" But this time around, we're going to do something a little different and ask the question, why did we stick around?

1:19Because obviously anyone can get into Bitcoin. It's a permissionless system. But what makes us waste so much of our time and basically consume our lives with this, you know, exciting and revolutionary financial invention? So hi, Nick.

1:31Nik OraevskiyHi, Vlad. Very nice to be here.

1:33Vlad CosteaLikewise. So what's the reason why you stuck around? Like you got in 2012 when none of this was obvious. Right now, it's obvious that Bitcoin is going to be successful. At the time, it was just, you know, kind of fringe. It was Silk Road-y. It was, you know, dubious. It was called a Ponzi on a regular basis. So what went wrong there?

2:05Nik OraevskiyWhat went wrong and what went right? That's a very good question. And I'm so happy that we're starting on that. I mean, you echo the fact that it's just been done to a point of exhaustion, giving the background on people. So for me, my real reason, and I'll be completely honest, early on why I got into it, is the pure fascination of what type of information that I could get from a trading perspective. I come from a finance background, graduated U of W with economics and finance as my degree, and I traded equities, forex, options all throughout my high school days.

2:34I wouldn't really maybe say traded, more gambled. But at the end of the day, I was very fascinated by markets in general. So when Bitcoin came up, it was the only way and the only place that I saw without having to spend an arm and a leg for level 2 access on like a Bloomberg terminal to see the order book data as well. So to see how many bids are on, how many offers are there, and to see that liquidity actually transfer from one player to the other.

3:02That alone fascinated me enough to just want to dabble and play around with it. So I think I sent my first 100 bucks to Mt. Gox, expecting it to never return once again or maybe get a magic card in exchange. At the end of the day, I was very enthralled by that aspect and, you know, kind of played around with it. The volatility, of course, was very high at that time. So you saw moves that you would never see in the traditional market. That captivated me. But that was just what drew me into it.

3:30What kept me there, completely different. Over time, I got very familiar with the individuals on bitcointalk.org, the forums, and I started to see where this had the possibility of actually going. And by this, I mean the Bitcoin network itself, not Bitcoin the currency or the underlying asset. I saw that this was a movement towards financial sovereignty. It was the first time that an individual could control their own wealth completely without intermediary. Once I started to see this narrative formulate, I dug deeper into the white paper. My friend sent me the white paper actually in like 2010.

4:04I looked at it and goes, "Okay, this is going to be another e-gold, whatever." I honestly did not understand it. But I revisited it, I started to ask questions, and I started to understand the true power and capacity of a distributed public ledger that is secured by a mechanism which has a very high degree of game theory built in and operates through the consumption of a resource, in this case the resource being electricity. And at that time, what I really believed, and I still do to this day, is that Bitcoin is literally electronic money and it is electricity as money.

4:40So the way that you can commodify, to a certain degree, electricity, and then the network on top of which it sits, and the ability of people to transact freely with one another is what started to enthrall me.

4:54And then I said, you know what, this is not just a flash in the pan, but even thinking the way that I did around 2015, 2016, it was still probably a boom or bust, meaning that it's either going to go to a million and a billion per BTC or it's going to go to zero. And to be fair, that's still a chance, although a very small one. And as a binary investment, what I really wanted to do was to maximize as much as possible the chances of Bitcoin becoming something that everybody talks about.

5:29Now, I didn't know how to do it at the time. I didn't know what to do with my personal skill set. All I knew is that I needed to be involved and I needed to grow this ecosystem. So for me, I jumped in by creating different ventures, being parts of different projects that are focused specifically in the ecosystem, and that's what has kept me there up until this day, until the founding of Bitcoin Reserve.

5:51Vlad CosteaSo how did you get from trading and getting involved from this maybe slightly speculative world to actually opening a company which tries to cater services to institutions? And basically I like to think of you as some sort of Grayscale for Europe, except that you don't have GBTC or whatever. You just enable companies, you support them along the way to acquire BTC amounts.

6:20Nik OraevskiyThat's one way of looking at the business that we do here. I'll address the first part of that question, is how did I make the leap from trading into entering into the ecosystem in a formal way? And it's, in all honesty, not a very clean answer. It's from jumping from one startup to another startup. I worked at Airbitz for a bit and I understood how wallet technology worked. I understood the true meaning of self-custody at the same time. Then I worked at a couple exchanges, worked at a fintech incubator, AIF in Switzerland, set all that up.

6:51And through all of these things, I started to realize that there was a very strong demand, at the very least going to be a very strong demand from the institutional side to have this asset be on their balance sheet. Now, that was eventually proven right, as we saw with MicroStrategy putting on quite a hefty amount onto their treasury, and then a lot of other companies followed suit. So that theory was proven correct, and in trying to uphold this, if you will, ability for those institutions is really where the mission for the company began.

7:23But it very quickly translated and morphed into something much more, if you will, esoteric than Grayscale. So Grayscale is simply a vehicle for institutions to be able to participate in this run-up, right, of the asset that we call Bitcoin. But Grayscale very much does custody and provide custody. Not a lot of people choose to self-custody. And that's one of the big things that we are very, very different. And we don't hold any Bitcoin whatsoever of users, whether it be an institution or whether it be an individual.

8:00We withdraw every single transaction to their own hosted wallets. And this is part of our desire to ensure that everybody retains the financial autonomy over their particular investment, if you will. So from that perspective, we're different than Grayscale. Really, at a higher level, what we're trying to do is we're trying to build a bridge between the legacy ecosystem, legacy economy, and the new economy, the Bitcoin economy.

8:27This requires operational capacity in both areas, meaning that we need to both be experts at everything Bitcoin and we need to be experts in everything legacy when it comes to regulation, when it comes to, you know, the FATF, the travel rule, all of that fun stuff that the average Bitcoiner doesn't even really want to consider or think, because it goes against the ethos of Bitcoin. It's our job to be able to connect those two ecosystems as smoothly as possible and provide a free-flowing channel between those two economies. And that's really where we're trying to go. And that's really the direction that we want to travel in long term.

9:09Vlad CosteaYou know, something that I very much appreciate about European companies is that they try their best to offer a non-custodial experience, as opposed to U.S. companies that tend to be more on the custodial side. Like, you actually make efforts from a regulatory and an internal policy point of view to not hold the customers' money. And I suppose that this, I don't know, has some roots in learnings that we have had along the years with exchanges getting hacked and with the fact that we like to talk about all the time that if you don't own your keys, you don't really own your Bitcoin.

9:51And this is also educational, I guess, but also a bit frightening, maybe for the institutions, because they buy, but they also get maybe some consultancy in regards to how they're supposed to HODL, but at the same time they become sovereign, which even to institutions... So this is very foreign to people who expect their money to be backed or bailed out by their governments. With companies, it's kind of the same. They expect to have some sort of insurance or something. But with Bitcoin, you don't really get that, right?

10:25Nik OraevskiyYeah, absolutely. And they come from an area where not only do they have depositors insurance from various institutions, but they have the entire custody framework already built for them. And when companies are looking to invest into Bitcoin or looking to move into a different asset class, the last thing that they want to worry about is custody, right? So it's difficult to preach to them the real value of Bitcoin as an instrument of freedom and an instrument of financial sovereignty. However, those companies that you are able to convince, they go head over heels into it because they start to see the value of this as the world evolves.

11:10And especially now with what we're seeing with the possibilities of central bank digital currencies coming on the stage, the ability to control your own funds is incredibly, incredibly important both to individuals and to companies. Now, going back to the point of ease of use from a corporate perspective, a lot of the work, you know, let's say for actually for an individual to buy Bitcoin, you go onto an exchange, you provide some documentation, you send a wire and ACH transfer, SEPA, whatever it is, and then you start trading. Kind of really it. Maybe you have to worry about some tax implications, download some tax forms later on.

11:44That's it. But from a company perspective, there are so many different things that need to be done. You need to have a discussion with your board of directors. You need to make sure that your treasury management is on point. You need to make sure that all the investors are also working alongside with you and approve all of these things, and every single stage is a fight, especially to those that are controlled by individuals who don't necessarily understand what the power of this technology is. So after going through that entire slugfest, the last thing that they want to do is mess up one little word or one little character in an address and completely flush their entire money into the ether, so to speak.

12:19And that is the barrier that custodial companies bridge. And I know there are some custodial companies right now that actually offer depositor insurance as well. So it's a very nice offer for the institutional investor, but the thing is, it won't be, in my opinion, viable for too much longer as we start to see the different rules evolve from the various regulators around the world as to how storage is to be handled and how the regulatory framework around those specific areas are handled. Right now, as a company, you can go with a custodial institution more or less anywhere in the world.

12:59In my opinion, this is going to change. You're going to have regional custodials and custodians. And once you have regional custodians, you are then going to have a difficulty in transferring funds from one custody provider to another, whether it's because you don't like their service or whether you simply want to spread your eggs into more than one basket, whatever the case is. And over time, I believe there's going to be a very big opportunity for companies teaching self-custody and providing the tools and very high-grade tools for self-custody for both individuals and corporations. Specter, for example, is a very good example of this, and that's the direction that they're heading into.

13:34So overall, you know, this question of custody is very complex and it differs from individual to corporation. But at the end of the day, where everything is flowing, if you truly want to adopt Bitcoin as a source of financial autonomy, you need to have control over your keys. Not your keys, not your coins, as you said.

13:54Vlad CosteaI very much like that. You know, if I guess I was interviewing some sort of American exchange CEO or something, I suppose they would be talking about how they can make the experience easier for the customer by enabling the company to become a bank, to store the keys, to store the coins of their customers. And this would also mean that they would subject themselves to further regulations. And the more they expanded in different areas of the world, they would have to comply with different types of rules.

14:25But you're trying to minimize that, which I very much appreciate. So I'm not endorsing you right now by any means, but I very much like this approach, which is very close to the values of Bitcoin. And I can also argue that this is also good for the supply of Bitcoin, because we always have this discussion that, on one hand, there is no proof of reserves for most exchanges. I think that Kraken was the only big exchange to publish a proof of reserves back in 2014. And that was it.

14:58That was the only time that they did it. And one of the show sponsors, Vaultoro, actually publishes monthly reports to prove that they have the Bitcoin and the gold reserves of their customers, which is something that I appreciate. But they're a European company. There's something about this philosophy in Europe. And the second argument is that you can actually have exchanges create inflation of the Bitcoin supply. They can actually sell to you bitcoins that don't exist and engage into this fractional reserve approach because they know that most customers are never going to withdraw.

15:34And in my view, no government is ever going to enforce the 21 million limit of Bitcoin. So, I guess companies can do this if they want, if they're not ethical and they don't care about Bitcoin and only want to make more USD from their customers. And there is no way to prove anything or to stop them. The best way is to enable the person to hold their own coins, to validate them, to verify with their own node, and that's it. You know, that's what Bitcoin should be all about.

16:09Nik OraevskiyAbsolutely. And you made a really good point in terms of possible inflation and fractional reserve banking coming about as a result of these companies creating bitcoins that necessarily don't exist. So one of the things that was very interesting, and I'll take the conversation back to the QuadrigaCX days in Canada, before what happened with Gerald Cotten, whatever happened there, transpired. They were actually going to go public at one point, and in the community, which was very small in Canada at that time, their prospectus, which is the offering memorandum document that is needed to provide, that the company needs to provide in order to go public...

16:46Or in this case, it was an RTO, a reverse takeover, where they vend into a shell, a public shell, move into an exchange transaction that way. The point is that they released the documents for the prospectus, which outlined the business, which outlined a lot of legalese. And there was one line that was very, very interesting, and it was, as always, in small print, but it read something along the lines of, "When a user is purchasing Bitcoin on the Quadriga website, you are getting Quadriga bucks in return." Not Bitcoin, Quadriga bucks. That's how they labeled Bitcoin.

17:30Only when you withdraw do these Quadriga bucks automatically then translate one to one to a Bitcoin. So what that means is exactly what you're saying. On their ledger, on their actual interface, it's very easy to, you know, change a 10 to a 100, and all of a sudden an account has 100 Bitcoin. There's no way to prove that that is not the case until there is a run on the exchange. And well, when that happened, we saw the results of it. It most certainly had a lot less reserves than it purported to have. And this could very well be a systemic issue with other exchanges as well, not to mention what's happening in the stablecoin ecosystem with Tether, but that perhaps is a topic for another day altogether.

18:23Ad voiceoverCommercial break. Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro. Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.

18:40Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip. And if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.

20:01Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking WabiSabi coinjoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free.

21:07Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels. Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.

21:55Yeah, there's a lot to talk about if we get into Tether. But so far, I think they did quite well, given the accusations, I'd say. But looking at Bitcoin Reserve right now, I see that you have two types of services. There is Flash, which I suppose is for smaller buyers who are not necessarily institutions and can be individuals. And there is concierge or concierge. I'm not sure how you pronounce that.

22:27Nik OraevskiyYeah, concierge, you had it right. And those two services are predominantly, the main difference between the two is the interface that is used. So when a user is going into Flash trade, what they're doing is they're using our back-end liquidity and our automated service to be able to purchase and sell Bitcoin and withdraw accordingly to either their bank or to their Bitcoin wallet. When you're talking about Concierge, Concierge not only has higher limits, but it's also a product that is much more tailor-made for a personal interaction.

22:58So every client that signs up with Concierge has an agent, and that agent not only helps facilitate the trades itself in a very, I would say, I don't know what the proper marketing buzzword for it, and I kind of refrain to use it, but you know how brokers were back in the day? You had a connection with your broker. You called them up. You're like, "Hey, buy 50 shares of Apple." They would execute it for you, say thank you, have a little chat, and you hang up the phone.

23:21It's a very similar type of situation. All the transactions are done over encrypted chat. All of the communications are done so as well. And on top of being able to provide that buying and sell service through that medium, what Concierge also offers is communications and help with regards to a lot of questions that people may have. We have clients coming in asking particularly the question for storage. "Hey, can you guys recommend a hardware wallet?" or "What is even a hardware wallet?" or even simpler, "How do I store my Bitcoin best?"

23:51And we're very happy to be able to provide information and point them to resources as to where they can get trustworthy information and also trustworthy hardware itself to be able to service their storage needs. Very similar questions arise along the lines of why Bitcoin. You know, a lot of the people that come in have already done their due diligence, but they're very curious as to why Bitcoin over any other altcoin, shitcoin, whatever you want to call them. And we're happy to facilitate those communications. So it's a much more personalized service.

24:26And that comes with the benefit, I guess, of that relationship evolving over time. And we don't really market for Concierge, to be honest, I guess, other than what's happening right now, perhaps. But it's word of mouth, right? We are a trust-based business. Money gets sent first, so if there is no trust established, then our business doesn't work. And when you have other people vouching for your business to their friends and their family, that's really the way that we grow from that perspective.

24:58Vlad CosteaYeah, so it's interesting that in order to get onboarded in this trust-minimized system that is Bitcoin, you always need to trust somebody that you're going to give them your physical or digital central bank money in exchange for something that you have to trust that they're going to send to you. And it's very easy for newbies to get scammed, as most likely they don't run their own node. And there can be tricks to make digits appear in somebody's wallet, especially if the seller also recommends the wallet or installs the wallet himself.

25:35So, yeah, this is just like a side note. Otherwise, I think it's really interesting to take this experience back to having your own personal broker, whom you can call and maybe get some advice. Maybe you want to sell, and it always goes like this. So I feel like this personal relation has somehow vanished in this world where you sign up to some sort of FTX or, I don't know, some sort of exchange, and you are your own broker, or you deal with an interface which allows you to sell and buy whatever you want. And it's kind of overwhelming and nobody really gives you good advice.

26:20I know that eToro says that they have that social approach where other users post, but the posts are mostly shit and people trying to pump their own bags. But when you talk to someone who's actually spending time doing this 24/7, and he's your broker and he's your client and he wants to keep you around, he doesn't want to lose you, he can actually give you some useful advice that otherwise you would not have time to research.

26:48Nik OraevskiyThat's exactly right. And one thing that I should clarify: we are not financial advisors in any way, shape or form. So we don't tell people when to buy, when to sell, even though God knows how many times we've gotten that question. What we will do is we will, of course, provide the general overview of what we see the value in the Bitcoin ecosystem itself and the projected movements that perhaps are happening that would not be privy to most individuals. And what I mean by that is a lot of Bitcoin volume actually happens off-exchange, so OTC, wherein you have a wallet trading with one wallet or somewhere through an intermediary such as a brokerage firm.

27:25These volumes are pretty much dark pools. Nobody really knows how much is going through them. Every company keeps that information to themselves. And it's not available to the average individual when you're just looking at the kind of exchange inflows and outflows. I mean, there might be some things that you could gather from some of the fundamental analysis when you look at on-chain metrics, but it's few and far between. So again, to reiterate, really what we're trying to do is we're trying to provide educational value when it comes to elements surrounding the Bitcoin ecosystem, surrounding the players in the Bitcoin ecosystem. What usually happens, we see cyclically, for example, now that institutions are in the game, oftentimes they need to rebalance.

28:10So if an institution has a treasury and out of that treasury, say they allocate 1% to buying Bitcoin, well, that 1% is denominated in USD, meaning it's a limit of a certain amount of dollars. So they'll buy a certain amount of Bitcoin for that certain amount of dollars. If Bitcoin goes up in price, at the end of every quarter, what they need to do is they need to now match their risk, meaning if Bitcoin grew in value, that 1% could now almost represent maybe 1.5 or 2% of their total portfolio, which means they need to bring it back down to 1%.

28:42When they bring it back down to 1%, what do they do? Well, they, of course, need to sell in order to be able to get back to where they were. With those procedures happening more often, right, you can see how that would perhaps influence price in one way, shape, or form during certain times, options expiration contracts and things of that nature. So these are the kind of communications, and it's not just available to our concierge clients. We often speak about it in our blog. We often speak about it, you know, in podcasts such as this. So it's not necessarily information that everybody is not able to get, but it's less talked about. Let's put it that way.

29:23Vlad CosteaRight, so right now I'm looking at the Flash option, which is the only one that I can access because I'm not wealthy enough to go for the concierge one. So why should I use this as opposed to some other kind of exchange? What kind of benefits does it have?

29:41Nik OraevskiySo one of the first things that we really wanted to do is tackle the KYC issue. There are a lot of proponents in the Bitcoin ecosystem for KYC-less exchanges and utilizing technologies that would essentially obfuscate their transactions as much as possible. And that certainly helps financial autonomy, that certainly helps freedom and security. That is very, very clear. On the flip side, you have people that completely don't care about any of this and they are willing to give up their little social security number just to get a burger at a fast food place.

30:16The scale is very, very wide. The reality of the situation is, and this is our take on it, KYC is very case specific. And what I mean by that is you have to not only look at what information you're giving to a company, but how that information is used. So, for example, when you're signing up to Coinbase and providing the documentation, you know that through their regulatory authority, the SEC and FinCEN, a lot of three-letter agencies have access to that information upon request. And as a result, that information is very likely to travel to many third parties, so the security of your data is compromised to a certain degree.

31:03Whether on the flip side, if you're dealing with a company such as Bitcoin Reserve, we have only one governing entity, which is the FIU, Financial Intelligence Unit of Estonia, and the documentation that is submitted is stored with our own internal system and provision. The request for that documentation doesn't happen unless there is an actual subpoena that comes from a court order within Estonia to take that and provide that information. We don't sell that information to any third party. There's no data gathering, none of that. So as you see, the documents provided for both companies are the same, yet where that data goes is significantly different.

31:42And that's what I really urge people to do, not just with us, but with any company, is to ask those kind of questions. How do you store my data? Is my data available to any of the third parties? At what point in time can it be made to certain regulators X, Y, and Z? This is the information that people should be asking, you know, when they're dealing with institutions that provide KYC. Now, there is another element of KYC lite exchanges that exist out there, which you just connect to with an IBAN, but that's another topic altogether that I wouldn't really like to go into the details of for the purpose of this conversation as it gets rather technical.

32:14Suffice it to say, there's still a large amount of data that is given out simply by providing that. Now, what we want to do with all of this is make that process as efficient as possible. So we've partnered with a company called Sumsub, and Sumsub allows you to do the verification in literally two to three minutes maximum. That is the fastest that I've seen so far on any of the traditional exchanges that exist to be able to open an account and start funding it. So that's the first advantage that we have, is the very quick onboarding process.

32:44After that, the interface itself, it's very clean. We focused a lot on user experience in setting everything up. So there's no confusing interfaces, there's not a lot of bells and whistles on it. It's there simply to provide the service of being able to buy Bitcoin. And of course, the other advantage that we have is we deliver it directly to you. And on the flip side, if you want to sell Bitcoin, it's the same thing. It's almost kind of like an auto sell feature. You sell Bitcoin there, as long as you have already an IBAN or an account connected to your Bitcoin Reserve account, a bank account connected to your Bitcoin Reserve account, then as soon as the Bitcoin lands, upon three confirmations, boom, instantly sold and sent directly to your bank account.

33:21So very quick, very efficient. And we're also working on other features, which I'll talk about perhaps at a later point in time in our conversation, that will allow other options, payment options in particular, to make this process even faster and in an account-less fashion.

33:37Vlad CosteaIs it possible to set up recurring buys? So for example, set it to buy on the first day of every month a certain amount of fiat, like $500 or something.

33:53Nik OraevskiyIt's funny that you ask that. Originally, we wanted to come into the market with Flash as a DCA-only product, so dollar-cost-average-only product, where you could set recurring buys. The kicker here is in order to be able to do that efficiently, you need to have the proper back-end infrastructure when it comes to banking. So banking in most cases with most Bitcoin companies, and I know some in Europe have recently been having issues with it. I won't name names, but I'm sure you can all do your research and find out who those companies are.

34:24They are mostly manual. I would say 90% of it is manual. So in order to be able to provide such a service, especially for higher amounts, 100 euro, 200 euro, 500 euro, up to that point is kind of doable. But when you start getting 1,000, 4,000, 5,000, 10,000, some people would like to do DCA in that fashion, you start to run into problems. So long story short, we have literally as of yesterday onboarded with a banking institution that provides an API, so we can automate all of this. So DCA, in particular scheduled buys, is on the roadmap for Q1 of 2022.

35:01Vlad CosteaNow you're making me feel a bit jealous because I'm not going to be able to publish this until Christmas Day when I release the entire season. So this will not be news anymore by then, I guess.

35:14Nik OraevskiyYes, yeah, we are going to make that announcement probably within the coming two to three weeks. But you know what, it's not hardwired into our marketing schedule just yet. We have a lot of other things that are going to be coming out. So be very happy to hold it off for a bit and give you the exclusive.

35:31Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I'm going to publish an article or something. Sounds good. I'm actually trying right now to branch out to become some sort of, not necessarily a news agency, but a place where I publish articles and news articles about European and Asian companies, because these seem to not get enough attention. It's way too American-centric out there. You look at publications like Bitcoin Magazine and CoinDesk and Decrypt and The Block, and maybe I can name a few more, but they focus way too much on what's going on in the United States. And I feel like there is a lot happening in Europe and also in Asia, and we barely ever hear about it.

36:16Nik OraevskiyYeah, that would be fantastic. A resource like that, in my opinion, would be very valuable to many companies in the space. And I think the reason why everything is so US-centric is because the Bitcoin ecosystem, for one reason or another, treats Silicon Valley in particular and the regulators of North America as the overarching, you know, supreme body of command over everything here. But as we saw with China, the second that you clamp down on Bitcoin, it'll just go into another direction. And the US has been toeing this line for some time, trying to regulate, under-regulate, over-regulate, and if they do mess up, it's going to go somewhere else.

36:57But realistically, I think we should start building ecosystems very similar to the one that you mentioned, both not only from a corporate perspective, but also one from a data-driven news source perspective, that allows focus on European companies, because we have our own market here. We have many markets here. And I would argue that combined, it can very much rival the United States, if not surpass it, very, very quickly.

37:24Vlad CosteaYeah, but Europeans kind of suck at promoting their own work. That's my observation along the years.

37:31Nik OraevskiyYeah, fair point.

37:33Vlad CosteaI'm not trying to, you know, tarnish anyone's reputation or something. But when I was doing interviews, I would have, for example, an American guest and they would be like, "Yeah, my product is the best. And we have this innovation and we have reached to this point where we are the best in the world," or whatever. And if you interviewed an European, maybe they had a similar product, but they would be like, "Yeah, so we're going to try to improve this and that, and we're really trying to become better," and whatever.

38:05So they, not they, we in Europe have this some sort of modesty or inferiority complex where we feel an urge to catch up with others, or at least constantly improve, but not brag too much about it.

38:20Nik OraevskiyYou know what, I could attribute that in the United States towards how financing works. And I've had some experience at Draper U, for example, which is Tim Draper's kind of little crash course for young entrepreneurs back in the day, out of Palo Alto. And I got a chance to pitch their incubator. I got a chance to pitch other VCs. And unless you make sensationalist claims and you say that you are on the path to 10x, well, at that time 10x, I'm sure now it's 100x because inflation, unless you provide a pitch that really paints that big blue sky and talk up your technology, even if it might be not only just run-of-the-mill but inferior to somebody else's, you will not even get their attention whatsoever.

39:07So maybe that has permeated through the culture of startups in the Bitcoin ecosystem. I don't know. Pantera Capital, I'm sure, views potential investments in a similar light. Whereas in Europe, there aren't a lot of structured VC firms, at least as big as those in Silicon Valley, that would look at companies in such a perspective. So people are used to telling the truth: "Yeah, we believe we have a great product and here's how we want to make it greater," because they're focused on the future of reality rather than trying to sell something that may happen down the line in 100x and get some investment. That's just my opinion though.

39:49Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess the approaches are a bit different because in North America they have to sell before they launch anything. So they have to really convince people about the idea. Whereas in Europe you have to build it first and you have to, I don't know, maybe struggle for a bit until it proves itself on the market and it proves its worth and people are interested in investing. It's a kind of different philosophy, but still, I'm not sure if this also affects the marketing approach.

40:23Nik OraevskiyYeah, that's a very good point. In talking about trials and tribulations and building a product first, one of the things that we didn't want to do in Bitcoin Reserve as a company is take outside investment. So one thing that's important to note for the listeners out there is all the equity is held by people within the company, and it's been bootstrapped completely by us, and that's not going to change. So the only way to actually get a piece of Bitcoin Reserve is to work with us, to put down your blood, sweat and tears and build it out together.

40:55Because in our past experiences, as we've seen with the ventures that I've been a part of, the ventures that Yuri has been a part of, which is our co-founder, they were always chasing that next hit and injection of capital.

41:09So instead of building a company to provide a service and a product, you built a company to satisfy investors, to get the next round of financing, to just keep going. And the hopes is that once the investors are satisfied, you can spend a bit of time actually working on your product and getting it out there. And what do investors really focus on? They focus on your marketing. They focus on what they see out in the ecosystem, how many people are promoting you, and they focus on your annual reports and your, again, 100x, 10x projections of what you're going to do.

41:39Now, I am painting with a very broad brush here. Not all investors are like this by any means, but it does seem that this type of activity really is predominant in North America and in other companies that focus on venture capital as a source of funding. So this type of evolution breeds a very unhealthy, in my opinion, functional business. Not to say that it can't be monetarily successful, okay, to the people that are involved. That's a different topic. But functional as a way to provide a product for users and to really have a long-standing reputation.

42:15So from that perspective, I can also kind of see how that would flow into, you know, as you said, build it first and then you try to sell it. Because a lot of the companies here, again, because of the different perspectives of how venture capital works, are bootstrapped to a certain degree. At the very least, the investors that are coming in are very close to the founders themselves. So that might be an impetus to be able to have more control over the company, of daily operations, and not have to meet milestones, you know, to get the next financing round.

42:42And God knows if there is a down round. A down round is when your valuation for round one versus round two, round two is smaller than round one, which means the earlier investors now lost theoretical value, which is bad, bad, bad, bad. And that pretty much could very much kill a company. But I'm getting a bit sidetracked, nonetheless.

43:04Vlad CosteaYes, you mentioned something about Yuri, who is also a co-founder of Bitcoin Reserve. And as far as I can recall, I think I met him in 2018 in Riga at the Baltic Honeybadger conference, but we didn't talk, we just noticed each other's presence from afar. And I also wrote an article, I think, a year and a half ago. It was on the Bitcoin Reserve blog. I can't find it right now. But it was about nation states and how they tried to acquire or gain competitive advantage by adding Bitcoin reserves to their balance. And this was before, you know, El Salvador and all of this madness.

43:45And I feel like I should also ask you what you think about how El Salvador handles this whole Bitcoin experience. I'm not a big fan because it's custodial and we know very little about their reserves. Like, who holds them? And how can we know that their president is not going to run away with the bitcoins once he doesn't get reelected anymore?

44:09Nik OraevskiyNow, that would be an exit scam of epic proportions, eh? Yeah, I'm happy that you mentioned Yuri and that you were able to at least somewhat see him for who he is. And at that time at Honeybadger, we were working pretty closely with Hodl Hodl, which was the company that was promoting and actually staging the entire event. So we know them pretty closely. We've utilized their digital escrow for us for some time earlier on. Great company, great bunch of guys. At the end of the day, the particular piece that you're referring to was actually published on the Bitcoin Reserve Journal.

44:47And Bitcoin Reserve Journal actually came about before Bitcoin Reserve, the company. And Bitcoin Reserve Journal is still up. So if you visit www.bitcoinreservejournal.com, you should find that piece that you're speaking to. Those are different ecosystems for the time being, simply because one is more of a publication house. And if you see very recently, or I shouldn't say recently, but for the last maybe six or eight months, there hasn't been any new content on there. So we're working on how to combine those two. We have a couple of thoughts in the future as providing Bitcoin Reserve and specifically having people write for Bitcoin Reserve. But that information is only going to be available to those that are part of the Concierge service. It's one value add that we're thinking about doing.

45:30But these are all kind of harebrained ideas at this time. Moving forward to the next question of El Salvador, it's bittersweet. You know, on the one hand, I can clearly see that the effort is doing the country good, right? I can also see other ways that they're traveling against the grain of not only the ECB, the World Bank, and, well, at this now, the WHO, the World Health Authority, by issuing ivermectin to all of their citizens, which, by the way, I think is very fantastic.

46:03And without getting too much into detail on that, certainly more beneficial than a lot of other things out there. And through traveling against the grain, they have put themselves in the spotlight, right? And they have also come under fire from the central bank. I know just recently they had issues with the clearing, essentially, of some of their accounts. Their currency has also taken a hit as a result. But at the end of the day, this, to me, to me personally, feels not a PR stunt, because that's not true. It is actually functional and it is gaining ground.

46:44But I don't... I'm skeptical, right? In Bitcoin, what I've learned over time is that you never take anything at face value. You always want to dig deeper into it, investigate and see how it actually functions. Just recently, Andrew Howard, he's our CBDO, was in El Salvador for the conference and he was able to use their local wallet to conduct purchases. There were issues. Let's put it that way. It wasn't a smooth and a seamless experience. Granted, that is probably to be expected with something that was relatively quickly pushed out the door and produced by a government, right?

47:25They usually don't do very well when it comes to technology and the release of that. So from infrastructure perspective, it seems to be working, and there are people that are utilizing it, and I think from an ethos perspective, it's absolutely fantastic. But then when you look at it realistically, the country is getting punished for it, and they're having issues now on the global stage. What is the long-term battle plan there? That's what I would love to know. If I was able to talk with those individuals and understand that long-term view, then I would be more confident in what's going on today.

47:57But from the high level perspective, you know, I'm only going to trust it as much as I can throw it and interact with it, which at this point in time is yet to really prove itself. So that's kind of where my mind is at, and I'm curious what you think about the possible exit scam scenario, especially with the bonds that have recently been issued.

48:23Vlad CosteaYeah, I don't think it's... I'm not the most qualified person to talk about bonds, but I can talk about Bitcoin custody and the fact that there's so little that we know about how they're buying the bitcoins and how they are actually securing it. I presume that they have some sort of multisig that they set up. But how do you know that the president and a few of his cronies don't own a majority of the keys and can just leave the country, spend the bitcoins? They basically became heads of state to be able to buy Bitcoin for themselves.

48:59I suppose they're not going to have an easy life if they ever pull off this scam, and they're gonna have to hide away for the rest of their existence, but still, I'm not saying it's impossible. We have had events in our history, and by our I mean Western civilization, when kings have ran away with gold reserves. And that was even harder to pull off because gold is heavy and is physical, and you need to store it, you need to secure it. You need someone to actually consent with the fact that you're going to withdraw it from the vaults.

49:36But they still did that, they were able to. So with something that's digital, I mean, the way that I view Bitcoin is that it's supposed to empower individuals. And I'm pretty fine with the idea of people buying and becoming sovereign. Actually, I very much recommend it. I'm not just pretty fine with it. But with governments, it's more difficult. With companies, I guess everyone has a stake in it. It's a different scenario when you want to manage it. But governments are very different. They're kind of a very different beast.

50:13It's very hard to guarantee that there's going to be like a peaceful passing of these reserves. Like, who actually owns it? Who holds the key for it?

50:28Nik OraevskiyOh, what we wouldn't give for a transparent government.

50:30Vlad CosteaOh yeah. Like, I suppose that you have Yuri who is blogging about transparent governments and trying to build better societies.

50:41Nik OraevskiyYeah, absolutely. It's something that is desperately needed, in my opinion, in this day and age. It's difficult to uphold, and to be fair, a transparent government under the current economic paradigm would actually not function. They depend on secrecy. They depend on money going off the books. So in the United States, I forget exactly in what year it was, but I shill her so much, but she's so well worth it. Catherine Austin Fitts, if you're familiar with her, she used to be one of the members of HUD, the Department of Housing in the United States, very high up there.

51:16And she turned to, quote unquote, the dark side when she realized what really was happening in the government and where all the money was going. Anyways, she particularly did a study where there was over 30 trillion, I think now it's actually up to 70 trillion, of money has been funneled out of the US economy. And it was through an order, I believe it was called FASAB 56, an accounting standard that essentially created two sets of books for the government, one that was fully public, the other one that was completely private.

51:42And in this environment, you can do whatever you wish on the dark books, funnel all and any resources that you need to companies, to individuals that are close to the government or that really are operating it in behind the scenes, and create a secondary economy. And this secondary economy is what allows it to function in the way that it does today, in an overarching and a very encroaching manner. So I wish we could build transparency into the systems. I think in order for that to even be a possibility, we would need our own type of, in the words of Klaus Schwab, great reset.

52:20But one that is not favoring the conglomerates, the IMF and the World Bank and the biosecurity paradigm, but one that is benefiting the human being, the average individual. So we'll see if that can happen.

52:31Vlad CosteaYeah. I'm very optimistic about Bitcoin empowering individuals, and generally my view is that I don't think it's a good idea for governments to step in at this point, because everything that they would do would be custodial in terms of adoption. Because they're all about control. That's what the government is: an entity, an organization set up by people who established themselves as the leaders of a community, tribe, or group, or a larger amount of territory, and they want to take control.

53:05And in exchange for that control, they promise to give back some freedoms or some sort of safety that they provide that maybe would not exist in a state of nature. I don't know. That's a whole different discussion. But it's very hard for me to imagine how governments would actually get Bitcoin right. And in my opinion, the right approach for a government is to just ignore Bitcoin. Like, don't regulate it, don't encourage it, just let citizens discover it themselves and use it. This is how you actually prepare them best for the transition.

53:45You don't encourage it specifically because in this international financial system, you're supposed to play by some rules, and there are global financial institutions that coerce you into making certain decisions.

53:58So you don't want to be in bad terms with either side. You want to allow hyperbitcoinization to happen and you want it to be non-custodial so that citizens would be able to have the most amount of freedom. But at the same time, you want to be in good terms with the IMF and the World Bank, so that, I don't know, you can access loans and issue bonds and stuff like that, that basically keep the government institutions on life support until hyperbitcoinization happens. At least this is my scenario.

54:32When it's radical, the chances are that the people are going to hate it. They're going to feel like it's being imposed on them. And in the case of El Salvador, I suppose that they can love it and embrace it specifically because it attracts foreign investment that otherwise would not exist. We have seen many cases of Westerners planning to move there. I would not move there.

54:57I know that Central America, Latin America in general, is kind of a tricky place to live, specifically because of the drug cartels and the fact that the government might promise you that they're going to offer you a decent and calm life, but you also have to deal with these, you know, unofficial governments that are going to ask for their own share of taxation. So that's going to be an interesting situation to observe when people start moving into Bitcoin City, whether it's going to be as peaceful and as developed as they promised it would be.

55:35From my point of view, I think that the mission of someone who is a Bitcoiner is to improve the world around them, as opposed to give up on it and say, "You know, I'm gonna build my own citadel with blackjack and Bitcoin."

55:52Nik OraevskiyI love that Bender quote, and I don't know, hookers, we'll see. I think you're exactly on point when you say one needs to use Bitcoin to better the world around them. And this stems from a higher order desire, I think, in my opinion, to build truly functional communities and relationships, economically speaking. If you're looking at where the ecosystem is currently going, with the centralization of control over not just financial autonomy, but now your biological autonomy, it's one of less group participation. And what I mean by that is individualism reigns supreme, and nobody's really building ecosystems and structures that function well within a smaller cohort of individuals and benefits those individuals directly.

56:48So for example, what do I mean by this? There was a very interesting podcast by James Corbett in which he spoke about community currencies and creating self-resiliency on a micro scale. We have resiliency on a macro scale. Again, perhaps that could be argued one way or the other, but on a micro scale within smaller communities, smaller neighborhoods, where you have a system very similar to what happened during the feudal ages. And that being, you have somebody who provides bread, you have somebody who provides fish, you have somebody who provides goods and tools such as a blacksmith and you have somebody who builds houses.

57:23All those people know each other and they're very happy to transact with one another. The means by which they transact isn't as important as those functional groups themselves. And here is where I think Bitcoin can be one of those tools to create these types of communities. As we're moving forward in time, you start to see like-minded individuals coalesce more and more and more. They are people that understand the reality of the situation in the world as it is, and when they find others like that, especially those that are local to them, they become and form very strong bonds.

57:58And what, in my opinion, needs to happen is that those strong bonds need to start to form their own individualistic markets, and where the medium of exchange for those markets can very well be Bitcoin, because as we said, it's easy to transfer, it's easy to transport, it's borderless and it's functionally more superior in my opinion than any fiat currency. So within these smaller ecosystems what you are very likely to see over time is a complete decoupling from the value of Bitcoin in fiat.

58:27And what I mean by this is you're going to start to see your Bitcoin in how much fish you can buy, how much lumber you can get, how many services you can procure, whether they be legal, whether they be advisory or something else. You will no longer see it in its fiat dollar value. And at that point in time, we start to reach a point of hyperbitcoinization, if you will, and also a point where one Bitcoin equals one Bitcoin, right? It is the medium of exchange of these communities.

58:58And as these communities grow and coalesce, inevitably, they will start to trade across borders with one another. That's perhaps the next evolution of it, and we'll see how that goes.

59:09So it's an interesting future and I do hope Bitcoin is very much a part of it.

59:24Ad voiceoverGold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.

59:45Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip, and if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.

1:01:05Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover podcast season 6 episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free. Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels.

1:02:21Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.

1:02:59Yes, but something that you mentioned needs some improvement regarding fungibility. You said that one Bitcoin will equal one Bitcoin. But at this point in Bitcoin's existence, you can discriminate and see that this coin was associated with the Silk Road. This one was associated with the Binance hack. This one was taken from someone who was a head of state. This one comes from El Salvador and this one was mined yesterday. So you can actually make this kind of discrimination when it comes to Bitcoin. And I think it's not ideal.

1:03:37It's not how money should be. You should not be able to discriminate on the basis of it. And miners, I know that they can even discriminate addresses when it comes to mining transactions into blocks. They can choose to ignore certain addresses, but so far it's been a free market and there has always been somebody else on the other side of the world who doesn't care much about the other miners' political or ideological considerations and is willingly going to take that transaction fee to mine the transaction into the block specifically because they want to make enough revenue.

1:04:15So I suppose that this censorship resistance is part of making Bitcoin fungible, but it's also about not being able to always track the traces of all coins. And there are two approaches to this that are not necessarily exclusive or exclusionary. That's the word for it. And the first one is that you can use CoinJoins to make the coins just as clean as just as tainted at the same time. It's going to be hard to tell where it comes from.

1:04:45And if we had like a universal CoinJoin of the whole Bitcoin supply, it would become fungible at least for a while, until people start associating their own identities to the coins and companies actually start developing tools to measure and track that. And the second approach would be to have confidential transactions of sorts. And so far, we have seen efforts into confidential transactions per se, which are not very scalable. Zero-knowledge proofs, on the other hand, with zk-SNARKs, that are very advanced and work very well, but they're not scalable. You also have ring signatures on Monero, which are not scalable at all.

1:05:24They are very large in size and they would not fit very well with Bitcoin's small block philosophy. And you also have Mimblewimble, which is a different beast. It's designed with scalability in mind and also has some privacy. I think that one can be interesting. It's going to be, I don't know, fascinating to see how developers can come up with something that will not hard fork the entire network to make us embrace that.

1:05:52But I'm not sure what your take on this is, but I think that Bitcoin needs more privacy before it can truly become fungible and we get to the point of one Bitcoin is one Bitcoin.

1:06:06Nik OraevskiyYeah, the concept of colored coins, as it used to be called, is a very dangerous route for the exact reasons that you mentioned. One thing that I can speak to in this particular field is how it works right now. There are definitely solutions, and I'll touch on those very quickly in the future. But functionally as it stands, when you're a company and you are signing up to try to get a banking partner to be able to provide the on and off ramp for the Bitcoin ecosystem, one of the key questions that is always asked is, first and foremost, do you accept any transactions from CoinJoin or any mixers?

1:06:48If you check that box as yes, you will automatically be discounted from the onboarding process, you will be rejected outright. So that has been made very clear in the larger legacy ecosystem as a black mark on a company that's already technically considered in a very high risk category, even if you're doing everything by the book when you're dealing with digital currencies. So from that perspective, it's very clear that the powers that be are in favor of being able to understand in a very detailed manner where and how transactions occur, both within their own economies, you know, and that's where central bank digital currencies are really going to thrive and provide a lot of value to them, but also in competing economies such as Bitcoin.

1:07:40So what is very interesting here is that while entering into this ecosystem, if enough of the volume of transactions go, let's say, quote unquote, dark and participate in these things, there will come a force majeure or a point of inflection at which point every single legacy functioning institution will no longer be able to process any trades whatsoever with the current ecosystem of banks. They'll just be basically rejected, which will force either the adoption of new standards from a regulatory perspective or the complete closure of that ecosystem within the legacy space, and then you will have the Bitcoin economy go into a very different direction.

1:08:31This is a systemic danger and we can see signs of this on the horizon with what is happening right now with the FATF and the AMLD5 directive, particularly when it comes to the travel rule and how they're treating hosted wallets. Anyways, within that framework you can see an air of what's already starting to transpire in terms of very specific cases of can and cannot use digital currencies. So what is really important to understand is all of this, functionally speaking, from a fungibility standpoint, depends on how we're using this, right?

1:09:13And what ecosystems are participating in this, what we like to call new economy. If legacy is going to be part of this new economy, it's going to have to learn to play nice, right? And if it pushes the bounds too far, it's going to find itself completely disintermediated out of this new economic system.

1:09:32And if and when then the new economic system starts to work within itself, and by this I mean the concept that I brought up previously of very local economies using a certain currency between themselves to transact, in this case, Bitcoin being one of them, that's when it really won't matter what all of these regulators and everything else are putting forward, because why do we need them? Why do we right now need them?

1:09:57It's because if I want to spend my Bitcoin somewhere else in the world to buy food, to buy lumber, whatever resources I need, I need to convert it first because those merchants are not accepting Bitcoin. And that transition from Bitcoin to legacy then back into the resource that you really want, which you could ideally have just transacted Bitcoin to resource, you know, in the hyperbitcoinized economy, the regulators themselves are the ones that are being kind of thrown in the middle of all of this.

1:10:27So ultimately, I am of the opinion that what you're going to see is what's happening right now in malware, or what's happening right now in kind of the hacker space between security companies and the hackers themselves, where you have the hackers finding a backdoor, exploiting that backdoor, and then the security companies coming in and patching it.

1:10:48And then the hackers find something else. And it's always this catch-up rat race that's going on. It's going to be very similar with Bitcoin and regulators in the legacy ecosystem. So all those tools that you mentioned right now, out of all of them, only three that you mentioned are explicitly not allowed, right, in the back end of a lot of the major exchanges. If they find out, your account will be closed, and they will find out because they have a lot of the Chainalysis software by design. Your account will be closed and you will be blacklisted as a client. But other ecosystems are not.

1:11:21And frankly, the exchanges themselves, they don't care. All they want is the business, right? But they also want to be able to continue doing business, which is why they have to succumb to some of the regulation that's kind of coming down the pipeline. So ultimately, it's the same kind of rat race where you're going to have new technologies come online, you're going to have new ways to create private transactions or to at least have a better sense of control of the visibility of those said transactions.

1:11:50And then you're going to have the regulators enforcing, you know, X, Y, Z on the exchanges. And if they push it too far, like I said, then Bitcoin is going to go completely into one ecosystem. With that said, one of the other things that I'm very much excited for, and we are as a company, is layer 2 tech, Lightning and Liquid in particular. There are, well, we have a partnership with Liquid, so kind of put that out there already. We're one of the federated players in that ecosystem and have been for quite some time, and there is a large push for, let's just say, pseudo-transactional anonymity that is happening over that ecosystem.

1:12:28And the way that Blockstream is organized, it seems that they have a fairly good sway on how regulation then transforms and evolves over time. I won't get into the details as to how that functions, but to us, it's clear that there is some sway in that regard. So it's very possible that there might be an opportunity there for people that are looking for privacy in terms of their transactions. Lightning Network, as I said, is also another possibility. And hopefully we can integrate all of this into the core protocol.

1:12:59And when we do, well, the regulator is going to have to have a tough choice to make. Until then, it's going to be this race back and forth.

1:13:08Vlad CosteaYeah, so right now I'm looking at the Liquid Network web page, and I can see that Bitcoin Reserve is the fourth, possibly in alphabetical order. But I had no idea that you're Federation members. And as far as I can see, the Federation has grown a lot over the last year. I think they had like 20 members, now there are many more. I was not aware of.

1:13:33Nik OraevskiyYeah, that's right. It's growing quite quickly, and we're happy for the growth. We were one of the original members early on during their kind of alpha phase, and tons of opportunity there. But at the same time, adoption, I don't want to badmouth in any way, shape or form, but adoption needs to come. And while, yeah, members are growing in number, functionally there's still a lot of work to be done.

1:13:59Vlad CosteaYeah, my only exposure to the Liquid Network was with their NFT platform, Raretoshi. And it's quite nice because you have these small fees and all transactions on that platform are 2-of-2 multisigs for bidding on listings. So it's nice that you also have the option to make confidential transactions and all of that stuff. But at the same time, I've heard criticism about the Liquid sidechain that it doesn't really respect the original white paper for sidechains and it's not as decentralized as the writers of that concept were hoping it would be.

1:14:41Nik OraevskiyYes, exactly. And ultimately, it depends on the people that are supporting the network itself. Kind of, you know, a running joke, very similar to what you mentioned previously with Bender's quote, is that if for whatever reason the company steps out of line, we're just going to create our own Liquid Network with our own nodes and our own federation. Right. So, yeah, there's definitely an opportunity for that to happen. And it's all based on whether or not, you know, it evolves in a good direction, but people, believe me, are keeping a very close eye on this, and as with everything that we've talked about, there might come an inflection point when that switch does happen.

1:15:23If and when.

1:15:25Vlad CosteaYeah, anyway, I feel like competition for sidechains and second layer solutions is healthy, because it provides us better ways to transact bitcoins at lower fees with different trade-offs. In the case of Liquid, it also has privacy. Lightning also has better privacy than the base layer. So I feel like this is heading into the right direction so far.

1:15:48Nik OraevskiyIt is, and time will tell.

1:15:51Vlad CosteaOkay, so I gotta ask this question to you specifically because I'm not sure. So maybe that I did interview before Liquid Federation members, but I gotta ask you, what is it like? What are the responsibilities? I know that Federation members are part of the onboarding and of the peg-out process. So you can use any of these members to get out, to take your L-BTC back to the base layer. So what are the other responsibilities? You also run a node, I suppose, you mine blocks?

1:16:29Nik OraevskiySo this is actually a great topic, and I wish Yuri was here to answer more on that side, as he's more familiar with this process than I am. What I can say is that the involvement is not as intense as one would believe it to be. So there's two versions, right? There is a member of the federation, and then there's a functionary as well. So the functionary, and again, I could be mixing up my terms, again, Yuri is the specialist here, those are the individuals that actually process the transactions, right?

1:16:58So we are not that, even though we can move into it at any point in time, but from an infrastructural perspective and the tech support that is required, it's a bit of an onerous endeavor for us. So until we really start developing heavy on the product side, we're not really going to step into that direction. The people that are sitting in the first layer, they have an opportunity to vote, for example, with how certain protocols and implementations move forward. There is annual meetings that happen with these individuals and these constituents. So it's a governance nature. And then if you want to move deeper into the actual securitization, then you move into the functionary role.

1:17:35And over time, as I mentioned, we are going to be traveling in this direction. For us, what's really key is being able to enable these technologies first on our platform, see how they function, see how well they perform, and then move deeper into building it out from an infrastructural standpoint to scale it, right? So that's kind of where we stand. I wish I could give you more info on it, but again, that's kind of not my department. I'm less on the technical side, to be fair.

1:18:02Vlad CosteaYeah, that's okay. I was just curious to know some details of what goes on in the background, because I recall Francis Pouliot, who is the CEO and founder of Bull Bitcoin, tweeting something along the lines of being grateful that Liquid exists as a backup for the Lightning Network, because he has been trying to onboard the entire exchange on the Lightning Network and had some roadblocks. And there were some problems that he figured out along the way, because it's not yet, you know, very mature, this Lightning Network. There are still improvements to be done to it.

1:18:40Bitfinex, as far as I know, has done a good job with Lightning so far. But, you know, there is no clear guideline about how you should pursue this endeavor, how you should onboard your users as an exchange owner to the Lightning Network. Whereas with Liquid, it's a lot simpler because it's basically a fork of Bitcoin with some added features, which is more centralized around the federation.

1:19:08Nik OraevskiyThat's precisely correct, and the onboarding process is relatively pain-free. Now we are also working on Lightning integration as well, and there's some interesting things that are coming up in that pipeline. With Lightning, I can vouch and say it is much more difficult to make sure that the hardware is functioning properly. God knows how many times that there have been lost transactions in the test environments, which on a functional level is just, it's unacceptable. Honestly, it's unacceptable. If that's happening live, then there are big issues and there are no real experts or groups of experts that you can turn to just yet to solve those.

1:19:44Now, it's one thing that we're also looking into. There are a lot of groups of smaller groups of people and developers that are playing around with Lightning and constantly developing on that. We are working towards a project where we are thinking of providing grants to those communities, so they could just create open source software based on their desires with regards to the Lightning Network. And we hope that will stimulate somewhat a party to appear, similar to the one that you're talking about in the Liquid Network, where it will help that entire process for everybody else.

1:20:18But that is fairly far ahead, and as it stands right now, you really need to do your due diligence. You need to have technical experts on board to make Lightning functionally smooth in the backend.

1:20:34Vlad CosteaYeah, I think Lightning has the exact same issue as, you know, adopting Bitcoin with companies or governments. Like it's fairly simple when you're just a regular user. You have your funds, you open channels with other people, and you operate your own hardware on something as tiny and as, you know, underpowered as a Raspberry Pi. But when you are actually an exchange, you need to have, you know, more powerful infrastructure and be able to provide reliable transactions to all of your users, and that can be tricky. There are lots of problems to figure out along the way.

1:21:13But, you know, let me know when I can open a channel with Bitcoin Reserve. I suppose that you guys have a lot of trading going on and liquidity, so I would be interested to help route some of these transactions.

1:21:27Nik OraevskiyThanks, we'll let you know for sure.

1:21:30Vlad CosteaOkay, so I'm not sure if I have any more questions at this point. Is there anything else that you want us to discuss?

1:21:38Nik OraevskiyI would like to shamelessly plug our upcoming feature, if you don't mind.

1:21:44Vlad CosteaThat's why I'm here.

1:21:46Nik OraevskiyAwesome. So one of the things that we are going to release in beta very, very soon is the ability for users to purchase Bitcoin sent directly to their wallets with instant settlement, probably within 20 to 30 seconds, via credit card. Now, this is going to be a quote-unquote "accountless" option. So through the process that you are going to be guided through there, which is also done via Sumsub, you will not be getting a Bitcoin Reserve account and have access to the other services. This is simply going to be a particular product for those wishing to buy Bitcoin with credit card.

1:22:18Off the top of my head, I believe the limits are €10,000 per month. And I'm not quite sure what the yearly limits are. I will have to check our upcoming press release for that later on. But suffice it to say, it is way more than any of the other platforms that are currently there on the market, such as Binance / Coinbase, and there are several others that also provide this functionality. So very excited for that. I hope everybody will come and visit bitcoinreserve.com to check it out within the next couple of weeks, actually. So thank you in advance.

1:22:50Vlad CosteaSo how does that work? Like you get a credit card that you can use to spend your bitcoins, right?

1:22:55Nik OraevskiyNo, no, no, not quite. So there are products that are available like that already out there. I simply mean being able to fund and purchase Bitcoin with credit, like using your credit card, like you would go to the store and you would buy a glass of milk. You can now go to the website and you can buy some Bitcoin. The difference that we have versus other offerings is that oftentimes in the credit card processing ecosystem you have settlement times. So they say T+3, T+5.

1:23:22Now, depending on your volume and depending on your level of seniority with your merchant bank, you sometimes have to wait up to five days for that money to actually appear in your account. And with Bitcoin, as you know, once you send the Bitcoin out, that's it. So it's very likely that in certain scenarios with other merchants, that's why they have that settlement period. Meaning, you go on the website, you enter your credit card details, you buy Bitcoin, but you're not going to receive those Bitcoin instantly.

1:23:48You're going to receive them in two, three to five days because they have to wait until they get the money, exchange it, send it to you, and so on and so forth. There's different ways of mitigating the volatility risk, but I won't get into the complications of that for now. Suffice it to say, what we've been able to do in partnership with a third party is to be able to take on the risk internally ourselves for that volatility and send Bitcoin out instantly after the credit card has been charged.

1:24:14So that's something that we're very excited about. And hopefully it will allow people to really get into it and buy Bitcoin very quickly without having to wait for anything. I mean, you put it in and it's yours. You go and do what you need to do.

1:24:28Vlad CosteaOkay, that's going to be interesting. And I'm going to keep an eye on that feature, because so far it seems like Bitcoin Reserve offers services that, you know, are for spot buys for regular users and institutions. But the fact that you're going to allow anyone with a credit card to do instant buys, that makes it more interesting, and that's also going to open the gates for lots of small investors to join this exciting world of Bitcoin. And Nick, I would like to very much thank you for your time during this interview. I feel like I've learned something new during this hour and 17 minutes. How can people follow you on Twitter or other places?

1:25:13Nik OraevskiySo on Twitter, you can find us at BTCReserveHQ. On LinkedIn, it's the same thing. Those are the only two platforms that we are currently active on. I do not have a personal Twitter or social media, so please go to the company.

1:25:29Vlad CosteaThat's the healthiest approach. You don't have to waste time trying to deal with drama on Twitter.

1:25:37Nik OraevskiyOh my God. And God knows there are so many. We have people on the team that do very much follow Bitcoin Twitter, and I couldn't do it. Honestly, I'm so happy that they can.

1:25:47Vlad CosteaYeah. I have to do it because I have to promote this podcast and my other works. And I get into feuds, I get into fights. It's always like that. But at the end of the day, we all share a common goal, so I guess we get along one way or the other. We meet at conferences, we unblock each other.

1:26:07Nik OraevskiyExactly. That's what conferences are for.

1:26:09Vlad CosteaYeah, that's right. The conferences are for conflict resolution, right?

1:26:13Nik OraevskiyRight. Awesome. Well, thank you very much, Vlad, for having me on today. And it's been an absolute pleasure speaking with you. And I look forward to future conversations.

1:26:28Vlad CosteaLikewise.

1:26:32Ad voiceoverGold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro. Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro. Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro. Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.

1:26:53Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp, and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip. And if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.

1:28:14Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free.

1:29:20Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels. Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.

1:29:20================================================================================ Production notes: Remote one-on-one interview in English, opening with a music intro and with sponsor blocks (Vaultoro, Wasabi Wallet and Bitcoin Reserve read by Vlad) at roughly 00:18, 00:59 and 01:26; recorded before Christmas 2021 for later season release. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 6 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (121 chunks) and 48 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; second opinion: /workspace/bitcoin-takeover-best-quotes/s10-transcripts/s10e6.txt (read-only); [unclear] resolve pass: 3 of 3 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021" and "Thank All right." hallucinations; fixed guest name Nik Oraevskiy, Airbitz, MicroStrategy, Grayscale, Specter, SEPA, central bank digital currencies, HODL; split Nik's "Hi, Vlad" and Vlad's "Likewise" turns; restored dropped speech from second ASR/Scribe (finance background, white paper/e-gold passage, AIF in Switzerland, "those companies that you are able to convince", "you go onto an exchange", regional custodians, "between those two economies"); removed stray "invest."; Speakers: Vlad/Nik labels set; jingle labelled Ad voiceover ("Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro"). Fixed Vaultoro, QuadrigaCX/Quadriga bucks, Gerald Cotten, WabiSabi CoinJoins, Max Hillebrand, Tor, eToro, stablecoin/Tether. Restored dropped text from second ASR/re-check (Vaultoro ad middle, Wasabi block filters/Tor, bitcoinreserve.com, "run on the exchange", "around, he doesn't want to lose you", "the general overview of what we see the value", "ecosystem. What usually happens...", "to be able to get back to where they were"). Removed "Thank you." hallucination and ♪ notes; split long Quadriga paragraph at 00:17:30; Labelled Guest A as Nik Oraevskiy; fixed Sumsub, Decrypt/The Block, CoinDesk, "toeing", "10,000"; restored dropped words from second ASR/Scribe ("This is the information people should be asking", "We focused a lot on user experience", "over-regulate, and if they do mess up...", "run-of-the-mill but inferior to somebody else's", "They focus on your marketing", "value, which is bad..."); moved "Yeah," to Nik at 00:37:31; split long monologues with interpolated timestamps; Speaker labels fixed (Guest A → Nik Oraevskiy; 00:43:00 continuation is Nik); "I'm in." at 00:50:28 restored as Nik's "Oh, what we wouldn't give for a transparent government."; stray "Thank you." removed and Vlad's turn split; "i love" moved to Nik; names fixed: Hodl Hodl, Honeybadger, Catherine Austin Fitts, FASAB 56, Klaus Schwab, Bender quote, harebrained, epic proportions, "offer you drugs" → "offer you"; "decentralization" → "the centralization"; restored dropped "Those are different ecosystems" and "without getting too much into detail"; Speakers relabelled (Nik/Vlad, Vlad resumes after ads); restored dropped text from second ASR/Scribe (bread/fish, gold custody, ad endings, Max Hillebrand, bitcoinreserve.com, "online, new ways"); fixed Vaultoro, Chaumian CoinJoins, CoinJoins, AMLD5, banks (not BECCS), Chainalysis, procure, hyperbitcoinization; removed jingle/music notes, "*music*", "Noguera Mouna:", "Beep."; Guest A → Nik Oraevskiy; fixed Raretoshi, Francis Pouliot, Sumsub, Vaultoro, Chaumian CoinJoins, Tor, Max Hillebrand, L-BTC; split turns ("It is and time will tell", "Yeah, that's okay", "So how", "Exactly. That's what conferences are for", "Likewise" to Vlad); restored dropped text from second ASR/re-check (functionary passage, "give you more info", "This is simply going to be a particular", bitcoinreserve.com plug, settlement passage, ad gaps); removed "T

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00