S12 E4: Rahim Taghizadegan on Austrian Economics & Bitcoin as a Cult
Search this conversation
0:30Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is an actual Austrian economist who not only teaches Austrian economics, but actually teaches Austrian economics in Austria. And his name is Rahim Taghizadegan. I hope I pronounced that right, Taghizadegan. I can practice it to make it sound smoother. And I met him a couple of weeks ago in Mallorca at the Mallorca Blockchain Days conference, where he made a presentation about whether or not Bitcoin is a cult.
1:24And he presented some very compelling arguments about which I have talked before, but which were very concise and very clear and useful in these days when it seems like the community has become more tribal than usual. And it's useful to have this kind of dialogue, and I'm very happy to have you here, Rahim.
1:40Rahim TaghizadeganThanks a lot. It's a pleasure.
1:43Vlad CosteaSo what should we talk about first? Let's get to Austrian economics, because I feel like other podcasts cover this topic a lot. But I don't think that they get actual academics who teach Austrian economics in university to talk about this. Like, let me actually ask you a question. I was expecting you to jump in. So if somebody who hasn't heard of Austrian economics finds out about the term and needs a crash course in a few sentences, how would you describe it?
2:23Rahim TaghizadeganI'd say it's a tradition in economics that's like the classical economics emerged out of a Scottish Enlightenment. It's a tradition of economics that emerged out of a late Austrian Enlightenment, out of a phase of cultural flourishing within a society in crisis. And it's a tradition that's still relevant for today. And I think it's quite unique in its interdisciplinary approach to understanding human action. And I doubt that anyone who's interested in Bitcoin hasn't heard about Austrian economics, because I think it's a tradition that best helps explain the emergent phenomenon of Bitcoin. And in particular, it's the economic theory that's strongest on monetary theory and everything concerning uncertainty and error and complex phenomena.
3:18Vlad CosteaRight. I did have Eric Voskuil, who is a Misesian scholar, not formally taught, so to say. He didn't go to university to learn it, but he did spend a lot of time reading about it. And at the time, this was back in 2020, he explained to me why stuff like stock-to-flow is not axiomatic Misesian economics and is not Austrian at all. And there's a lot of stuff in Bitcoin which concerns predictions and human action in general, which is not necessarily scientific and not necessarily Austrian. So I'm happy that I get to interview you about all of this stuff.
3:58Rahim TaghizadeganYes, well, not everything about Austrian economics is scientific, and there's even some debate as to whether one can call the social sciences sciences at all. So I think it's certainly there's a discipline and systematic approach to understanding social sciences. And it started out as a value-neutral approach, as a descriptive approach. But it's particularly hard in our world to remain value-neutral, and I think no person is able and should be value-neutral. So it's challenging at times to separate the methodology, which is a systematic way of understanding the world, and your own value judgments, which are very human. And I think there's a good reason to have quite strong reactions towards the world we're living in.
4:54Vlad CosteaIt seems like today we have this divide in Bitcoin, where on one hand you have the Austrian economists who believe that Bitcoin should not change too much. And on the other hand, you have the cypherpunks who have greater desires and expectations for what Bitcoin should become. Where do you find yourself in this conversation? Do you believe that ossification is useful?
5:17Rahim TaghizadeganOh, I really dislike labels. I think they're part of our tribalism. I don't think there's anything like Austrian economists as a group or a community. And I mean, certainly there are some things that unite people in methodology, but for most people, they are not just seekers of truth. But of course, we are holistic human beings with values and preferences and interests and so on. So that's a complex mix. Now, within economics generally and society, you can take a descriptive approach, which means you try to figure out what's happening.
6:00And you try to withhold judgment and first seek to understand. And then, of course, there's a normative approach where you think about better ways to do something. And then maybe somewhere in between, there's an entrepreneurial approach where you try out something and you try to build something better. So I think Austrian economics originally was a very descriptive approach. It's my approach generally towards Bitcoin and the question of Bitcoin.
6:28So I'm challenged just by understanding what's going on, and there I try to be empathic and trying to figure out what people want and what utility they are seeing and how Bitcoin can be as a technology be a solution and provide utility. And there I see trade-offs, and that's quite typical for the thinking of the Austrian school, to see a lot of trade-offs and paradoxical trade-offs and not think about utopian schemes where you have a perfect solution. So obviously, ossification is a term you can use, but it has a value judgment in itself. It tells you something about a trade-off. And for myself, I've been watching this space for quite a long time. I first heard about, stumbled upon Bitcoin in 2009 already.
7:18And of course, I missed the potential of it by being a bit too early. And I think since then, looking at it, I tend to come to the conclusion that a lot of the trade-offs that were discovered, not consciously chosen, but that were discovered, turned out to be good trade-offs, or where it made sense to have quite a slow pace of development. It made sense to focus on the resilience of the first layer and not on scalability at first, because you then try to be faster than the market.
7:59You try to anticipate a use that's not already there. So I think that's one approach, just looking at it and seeing it grow and seeing the adoption grow. And that turns you a bit humble because there's so many ways you could have thought about improving it. And even the cryptographers I talked to in late 2009 and then early 2010, most were skeptical about Bitcoin, because it's really hard to figure out in advance if the right trade-offs are taken. And it's something that you only learn over time.
8:33So generally my approach is not to fight too much about like predictions about the future, but first try to understand what's happening. And it's a very different situation from trying to understand Bitcoin in 2009, because they only had the technology, more or less. There's very little adoption. So look at the technology, and it's much harder to understand. And now we have quite a track record and quite a time where you can understand a lot about human behavior and human action and real human beings using it for something and bearing costs for it and seeing challenges within it.
9:11And so I think it's a totally different situation now, looking at it from afterwards. So I think even if you, by looking at it, I would have, I'd rather be part of the big blockers, I think, early on. So I was skeptical about scalability issues, of course, and if the right trade-offs were taken. But then over time, I think it was the right way to go, this multi-layered approach that we're seeing now. And so I think it's unfair to use the term ossification with that value judgment, as if we were still like looking at the future of Bitcoin, where it's totally unclear if it's gonna be adopted or not by people, if progress is fast enough.
9:55I think there has been impressive progress in the technology, in the infrastructure, in the adoption and the use cases of Bitcoin, and I've seen that develop a lot over times. So I think it's wrong to use the term ossification. But still, I mean, there are valid points to be made about trade-offs, and no one can be particularly certain.
10:23And I think if you, in the normative sense, think that other people are making mistakes, be it the consumers or other entrepreneurs, I think the best way is not to bother about theory and try to prove other people wrong by having the better arguments based on economic theory, by somehow deducing why you are right. That usually doesn't work out. It's better to build, to use the entrepreneurial approach, try to build something better, offering it to people. And usually that's a humbling experience. So I prefer that.
10:58Vlad CosteaI very much appreciate the fact that you did not embrace any label and you provided nuance to your argument. But generally, when I think of Bitcoin, I think of sound money. And the only element from sound money that's missing from Bitcoin is fungibility, as it's rather easy technically to discriminate between two different sets of coins. You can say that this one has good origins and this one comes from dubious sources, and you're going to reject the latter and accept the former. So generally, I think that we need some sort of privacy in order to achieve fungibility, and that's a very divisive topic, as some people want it and others appreciate the transparency of the open ledger. What's your take on this, as an economist and as a technologist?
11:55Rahim TaghizadeganWell, obviously, fungibility is an issue. But then again, seven or eight years ago, I would be absolutely convinced that fungibility is the major issue. And I would have predicted it to become a worse and worse issue unless a solution is found. And interestingly, it hasn't turned out to be such a huge issue for adoption. It seems like practical privacy still seems to be good enough and seems to be improving now with layer 2 solutions. And so I'd be optimistic that before it really becomes a major issue hindering adoption, there'll be, like, the pressure to innovate will be strong enough. And I see quite some advances. So I'd be hopeful for Lightning and then probably Taro bringing more privacy to Bitcoin. But still, I mean, fundamentally, of course, it's a sound analysis. But it's always hard with analysis to figure out if people see it that way, if they really care that much about privacy and what kind of privacy they care about.
13:03And then privacy always is, of course, a trade-off. Now, one way to enhance your privacy, paradoxically, is not only technology, it's liquidity. It's how many different users you have. That increases privacy, of course. So I think that's one of the reasons fungibility has not become such a big issue, is that the adoption was dynamic enough.
13:25So it's big enough. And by using Bitcoin, you don't expose yourself so much, because lots of, more and more regular people without any shady use cases, as it was early on, without really putting a lot of focus on privacy, are using Bitcoin. So you have a legitimate cover, I'd say, by this dynamic of adoption. And thus, in a sense, you have kind of practical privacy and practical fungibility, which of course, there's a lot to be improved upon. And still, I'd agree, it's maybe one of the major issues, but then you can't say from theory if that's really an issue that will hinder adoption. And as you say, in most complex use cases, it's not only technology. The solution is not only technology. It's like how people use it and the context, of course, and how fast politics can keep up with developments and so on.
14:30So I tend to be more optimistic now than I was seven, eight years ago, where I really thought Bitcoin may be stopped by the fungibility issue. So my predictions were more pessimistic seven, eight years ago about the fungibility issue.
14:46Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if you're aware of this, but I had Peter Todd on a previous episode last month, and he presented a similar argument in which he explained that the fact that we have Lightning Network and the fact that we're going to have a larger scale adoption only means that privacy is going to get better, as you have a larger crowd in which you can hide. And this is ideal for privacy. But at the same time, we don't have the type of privacy which allows you to hide the amount that you're transacting.
15:18So at least on the base layer, it's still an open ledger, even if there's a lot of plausible deniability, which I guess you're trying to define.
15:25Rahim TaghizadeganYes. Yes, well, of course, it was always the trade-off that you have a transparent ledger. And it's only that the wallet doesn't reveal you if you take care and if you don't have a link between the wallet and any physical entity, personal entity. So that's the trade-off of Bitcoin. And again, from the beginning, it was hard to predict if that's a good trade-off to take. I think I'm more optimistic now that it's a good trade-off to take, but of course, there's always the possibility that a new contender comes around with a better trade-off and better solution.
16:11I think the longer Bitcoin develops, the stronger, of course, are the network effects and the stronger is the infrastructure around it. People finding solutions, use cases and this whole adoption issue of more people using it, figuring out problems and seeking solutions if there really are problems people care about enough.
16:35Vlad CosteaYeah. It's quite a delicate issue. I'm not sure if we are at the point where we should really have that privacy debate, but it seems like the longer we wait, the worse it gets. Today, to provide some context, I'm not sure when I'm going to post this, but today, as of August 9th, 2022, we have this situation with Tornado Cash, which is a mixing service for Ethereum. And they, and by they I mean the US federal institutions, went for it and they shut it down. And there was also some coordination by major companies that run the node validation infrastructure, which is Infura.
17:16And they blocked transactions coming from that specific mixing service. Ethereum has some centralization issues, which are not as clear and easy to use in Bitcoin. But at the same time, it was interesting that the approach that some community members have used was to take money which was mixed from Tornado Cash and airdrop it on the addresses of celebrities, of well-known figures in the space like, I don't know, Brian Armstrong from Coinbase or whatever. So basically, by proxy, through this transaction, everybody became a criminal who's going to be under investigation, including late night host Jimmy Fallon and a lot of other people who are right now owners of tainted coins.
18:03And they're going to have to deal with this. And Ethereum by design has no UTXOs, so it's not like they can dispose of those specific coins. The fact that they received in their static address an amount means that the entire amount that they own in that static address is now tainted.
18:18Which is pretty insane. I'm not sure if in the case of Bitcoin, people would do the same. But then again, they haven't come for Wasabi Wallet or Samourai or JoinMarket or whatever, possibly also because they're more decentralized than in the case of Tornado Cash. But still, we are in the middle of a privacy war, to call it so, and the fight for fungibility is only going to get more intense.
18:49Rahim TaghizadeganYes, but I would say that we've always been in a privacy war and it was never sure who is going to win in the end. It's always the bottom-up process of innovation versus the top-down process of the state trying to use the creative powers of people against the people. And it's a never-ending story. So there's no way to predict it. I think I'm fundamentally positive about technology because it's a shift, a new shift of cards.
19:19You change the setup and there's a new chance for people to use technology to their advantage before the state realizes the potential about it. I'm not a fan of theoretical debates about normative issues and my experience is it's basically impossible to convince people with better arguments about the value of privacy. And it's something that's been frustrating for most people on the internet, how little people care about privacy. It's usually how convenient the tool is, and people are very ready to sacrifice privacy.
19:45But then if you look at like theory, something that tries to understand human beings, I mean, you can wait forever for a change in the nature of human beings or you just try to figure out and understand how, even though privacy doesn't seem to rank very high in the preferences of people, still, there have been big advances in privacy by some tools making it as like the default situation. And then, of course, very different preferences. In some places, people care more about privacy, or particular people care more about privacy. And they care so much that they make up for other people who care less.
20:34So it's minorities that care a lot, and who are still relevant for tools. So I think the better way is first to try to understand the issues and not just remain frustrated. And I don't see it like it's becoming worse. I'm not convinced that it's becoming worse. It was always this fight, and cryptography offers tools for people to engage in that fight, even though cryptography was most developed during war times as a government technology, again for war purposes. So, still, fundamentally, I don't see any reason why now we should be more pessimistic about this outcome. It's quite an interesting situation right now.
21:23But again, early on, I would have predicted that the regulatory push would be much stronger. And by looking at the incentives, I mean, we need to just keep up with the time and figure out why it didn't turn out the way every rational observer would have expected it to be.
21:47I would have expected the US to be the first big capable government to push against Bitcoin, but it was the Chinese in the end who got rid more or less of the mining and their exchanges and so on. I would have predicted otherwise or would have seen it more likely that Bitcoin would be a challenge to the dollar. Didn't bear out this way. So it seems like that wasn't an obvious take you could take from theory. And still, I mean, it takes quite a while to figure out how, why it didn't turn out the way you expected it to be.
22:29So I think a good theory, you always have to try to keep up, try to... I mean, you try to make predictions for yourself, you try to extrapolate, but then if it doesn't turn out the way you expect it to be, you need to change your assumptions or figure out where you went wrong. And what's quite interesting is that there are incentives that it's not obvious, that I think over time Bitcoin has become better for dollar assets than for non-dollar assets.
23:00And one of the reasons, I think, is that there was more entrepreneurship in the US, and entrepreneurs were able to capture a part of the value offered by Bitcoin and keep it within the US realm or the reach of the empire, so that brought quite a lot of tax money as well into the coffers of government. And of course, it's neutral, it's something neutral. But still, it's not obvious that by going after Bitcoin, the US government would really win.
23:34And the Chinese government for a while, they watched, they tried to control it. And then finally they decided that it's not such a big win for them. And it turned out that they made a decision, I think, was the wrong decision, because the adoption in Asia was much stronger before, and they could have reaped much more of the benefits and the value of this layer. But of course, politicians, the more isolated they are from results, because it's a huge top-down structure, the more errors they make.
24:12But it's quite hard to predict these political outcomes. So that's not really economic theory, that's social theory, and the worst kind of social theory is like trying to figure out what goes on in the mind of politicians, what errors they are going to commit next, and usually very hard to distinguish between a conspiracy and really incompetence. There's even a name for that law. It's like a law. It's really hard to distinguish incompetence from malice.
24:47Vlad CosteaYes. To tackle an issue that you introduced in your argument, it's pretty ironic how we started out thinking that we're going to replace fiat money and especially the dollar. And now there are conversations about how we can bring the dollar to Bitcoin's layer two to transact it instantly with lower fees and permissionlessly with stablecoins or whatever. It's pretty insane because, you know, instead of trying to make Bitcoin stronger and increasing its adoption network, we're enabling the dollar to get another layer of transaction and therefore increasing the demand for the US dollar.
25:24Rahim TaghizadeganYes, it seems like there's a correlation between demand for dollar assets and Bitcoin. But, well, I mean, you've got to describe that. It's not something you will into existence. I mean, most people, even Austrian economists, were quite wrong about predictions about the demise of the dollar. The dollar is the best performing asset of this year, I'd say. And if you haven't been able to predict that, of course, there's something wrong with your assumptions. And it doesn't make sense to argue about it. It's just, I mean, that's reality.
25:55So try to figure out where you went wrong. Of course, everything can be manipulated and a big conspiracy against your assumptions, but that's usually not the best way to explain something. So of course I'd expect the dollar to become strong in times of uncertainty until it's no longer the world currency, but it's a political or historical process and those are the hardest to predict in the timing. That can be very sudden. But still, it's quite complex, the financial system and the monetary order. And it's not even... I mean, just think about what is money and is Bitcoin money or not.
26:41It's a lot of framing in terms of very complex concepts that usually is not that enlightening. I think it's better to ask first, what is it? And not have your preconceived concepts and definitions and you try to fit it into definitions. I think the best approach is just look at it, try to figure out what it is, try to be humble if you were wrong about it, and try to learn. There are a lot of academic economists, I mean, they haven't changed a single bit. They would have told you in 2009, "It's all bullshit," and they still tell you, "Oh, it's just a bubble."
27:19And they just repeat, and they don't change, but the world around them is changing and it's really hard to take someone serious who is unwilling to change when the world is changing, and unwilling to reflect upon reality and try to come to a grasp and understand reality, and wants to will something into existence. So, "I don't understand it, thus it can't be." That's not the right approach to understanding.
27:45Vlad CosteaYes, and speaking of understanding, most of our understanding of Bitcoin has happened through metaphors, especially since, I don't know about you, but I'm not technical enough to audit the code itself and look at every line of the Bitcoin code and figure out what it does. So my understanding from the beginning happened through these metaphors and ways of explaining, and most metaphors were about gold. And it's no surprise that the most successful book in the Bitcoin space is called The Bitcoin Standard. And it's basically just a parallel to the gold standard.
28:23But at the same time, you know, coming back to the properties of sound money, there are people who say that Bitcoin should be like digital gold, but what they actually mean is that Bitcoin is going to be held by custodians. The users, the customers are going to transact on the balance sheets of those custodians. So this spells an end to developing the actual Bitcoin network and makes the institution stronger.
28:52And then there are people who mean by digital gold to actually have it, to have this peer-to-peer market where you can transact with anyone you want and have the gold in a weightless, in an immaterial way, which allows you to transact with anyone around the world. And you also have the capability to melt your gold coin into a new shape, this is another metaphor, so that you don't know what it used to be, but you know that it has the right number of atoms in its composition, and therefore it's practically gold that you can verify.
29:27Rahim TaghizadeganYeah, I try to avoid analogies unless they really help you understand something. And gold can be useful because it was such a prominent monetary element. I think it's good to contrast it with. It was hard to predict that it would be like gold and still some people take a lot of issue with that. But it turned out to be, even though Satoshi Nakamoto talked about peer-to-peer cash. Most people thought he meant that it should be a better payment layer. But of course, cash is a lot of things.
30:10And one, it's a bearer instrument. And you can't tell what's the more important use case, because most people don't understand the terms. They're using something for a problem they have. So even without understanding economic theory, you still make economic decisions. And it turned out that the most prominent use case for Bitcoin now seems to be, and that has changed over time, to just be a digital asset. And it may even be a risk-on digital asset, which is worrying and frustrating in a sense to some people. I think it's just a temporary phenomenon that there was a lot of influx in the latest cycle, the latest boom market of Bitcoin, a lot of money that went into Bitcoin, because they were looking for another risk-on asset, basically like a leveraged tech stock or something like that. But that you have to accept. I mean, you can say, "Oh, I don't like that.
31:16I don't like that people use it that way." Still, you try to figure out why. Why are people looking for risk-on assets that are undervalued in a sense, that not enough people have entered into. And then, of course, it's a process of the last decades that there's a run around the globe for new assets, a kind of strip mining of the globe for undervalued assets where you want to be first in. And then you expect that the retail crowd will follow you. And that's where you generate the alpha.
31:56So then you have to accept that's the context. And it's really hard to tell if without this fiat monetary system and without the interventions we had in the past, Bitcoin would have developed that way, and that the dominant use case would have become a digital asset.
32:18Certainly, I mean, if there's another form of money that people trust more for the use case of trying to preserve the purchasing power over long time, over long times, over decades and so on, the need for Bitcoin would be lower if there wasn't that much intervention, if the dollar was still a silver certificate, or if there was still a standard among international merchants to use a certain weight and fineness of gold in the balance sheet and for settlement, as a settlement currency for the exchange, then of course the need for Bitcoin would be lower. So, of course, there's the whole context.
33:08And still, I would appreciate that situation and try to figure out why are people looking for it and if that's sustainable. And I'd say, yes, I think it's a sustainable demand for a digital asset, because Bitcoin offers something in addition that other digital assets don't. And it's this kind of resilient layer, this kind of uncensorable infrastructure, and it offers a way to smuggle it much more easily across borders. So I think where really the use case for Bitcoin increases is if you have increasing regime uncertainty.
33:50If you think that one of the major dangers to your portfolio is politically imposed, is artificial uncertainty that's imposed upon you through capital controls, regulation, and so on, then I think the case for Bitcoin increases, but increases in the sense not as a very innovative way to have programmable money, but as a layer that's resilient against this kind of regime uncertainty.
34:21That you don't know if you'll have access to your assets because they are within a jurisdiction, because they're real estate, for example, you can't take them with you, or because they are permissioned assets, which means you may lose access because your bank account is censored, your brokerage account is censored, and so on.
34:55Ad voiceoverAfter Mt. Gox collapsed, that was really the precipice of me saying, "Right, this has to change. We need a totally transparent exchanging system and base it on gold instead of fiat."
35:14Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the hard money exchange which helps you beat inflation with instant swaps between the best stores of value known to man, gold and Bitcoin. Unlike most exchanges, Vaultoro understands the importance of transparency and security. All gold holdings are secured in top-tier Swiss private vaults and fully insured against theft, fire and more. Maximize your purchasing power today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. This is not financial advice, but gold has been humankind's most reliable store of value in the last 6,000 years. Do your own research. Use promotion code TAKEOVER for a one-time bonus of 1 gram of gold for the first 50 new customers buying gold with Bitcoin.
36:13Are you concerned that your friends, neighbors, or KYC exchange might know how much Bitcoin you own? It is time to take your financial privacy seriously with Wasabi Wallet, a free and open-source wallet solution which makes use of mega CoinJoins to mix your coins with those of hundreds of other strangers. Thanks to the groundbreaking WabiSabi engine, your coins get divided in smaller, untraceable units, which grant you great anonymity for both hodling and spending. Download Wasabi Wallet 2.0 today at wasabiwallet.io and take advantage of the mega CoinJoins. It's free and it's open source, so don't trust, verify.
37:22What are you going to wear when Bitcoin hits 1 million dollars? The same old $20 T-shirt? Try Maison Mauchi, the designer clothes made in Paris by Bitcoiners for Bitcoiners. They're not your average mass-produced sweatshop clothes. Maison Mauchi will ask for your measurements and tailor every piece of clothing according to the shape of your body, so you always look and feel great in your T-shirt, hoodie or dress. It's all made in France by real artisans who also happen to be Bitcoiners, which is why Maison Mauchi only accepts Bitcoin as payment for their clothes. Get a Maison Mauchi T-shirt or hoodie today. It might even help you find a girlfriend.
38:17And once you do get a girlfriend, you can also buy her a Maison Mauchi dress. Stop having fun looking poor and check out MaisonMauchi.com. That's M-A-I-S-O-N-M-A-A-C-H-I.com.
38:38Yes. And about what you said, I think I started this journey thinking that Bitcoin is an interesting addition to the financial markets and it's a useful instrument to make nation states stay more accountable. I think this was my point of view when I first started. And then, as I started learning about it, I became obsessively optimistic. And I started saying, "No, Bitcoin is going to be that one world currency and everything is going to be divided against your Bitcoin." You know, there's that meme, infinity divided by 21 million, and whatever, we're going to reach the standard.
39:10And now I got to the point where I figured out, so even if you only have the Bitcoin network, which is the only monetary system of the world, you can still issue tokens on Bitcoin and governments can still do fiat money on a Bitcoin layer.
39:33So technically this can be perpetuated, you know, for the rest of humankind's existence, because it's technically possible. And there's this saying that a new fool is born every day. And fiat money, even if it becomes culturally unfashionable for a while, one generation is enough to forget the lessons of the past, just like we see with communism in some countries today. And they're going to embrace something which sounds utopian and good and suits their short-term needs. And we're going to end up with another situation like this.
40:12But then again, I'm pretty sure that other currencies and nation states will never give up on their power to issue national currencies. That's not something that makes sense to them. They want to have control. That's what they are all about and that's what they have always been about. For as long as we're going to have nation states, they're going to have their sovereign currencies or they're going to form federations and have their own currency. I'm not sure if the EU is a confederation or a federation.
40:43I don't think they know either, but they still have a unified currency. And I don't see this going away, but I see Bitcoin as this instrument which holds them accountable. It's basically telling them, "Unless you do less money printing and you debase everyone's currency to a lesser extent, this is going to get more traction and you're going to get screwed." So you have to really consider that this is an alternative that people have. And the more they know about it, the more in danger you are. So you better be careful and handle the treasury with wisdom.
41:22Otherwise, you're gonna burn the system to the ground and it's gonna get replaced by something else. That's my understanding of Bitcoin currently.
41:33Rahim TaghizadeganYes, I think, I mean, 10 years ago, it was inconceivable. I thought it was absolutely minimal, the chance that Bitcoin would be a contender against currencies like dollar. And still, it's not obvious to me that it's now a contender. I think it's a contender for assets, in particular treasuries, once the propping up of these assets doesn't work out anymore. And I think we're going into a time where it's becoming more and more challenges, in particular in the European Union, where the ECB is trying very hard to artificially prop up the Southern European treasuries while still having a tapering.
42:20And I think it will turn out that it was impossible to achieve what they're trying to achieve, and it has become more likely that Bitcoin could convince more people and in a sense prove itself to be an alternative against assets that are propped up by the state.
42:42Particularly when trust goes down. And we've seen that the dollar has been weaponized and politicized in the recent geopolitical turmoil. It's not obvious yet that international companies or countries on a large scale would use Bitcoin instead of their own national currencies, but I think it's more likely that Bitcoin takes a part of dollar settlements than yuan would take part of settlements or ruble would take part of settlements, because there's this trust issues.
43:15Of course, the Chinese don't trust Western governments, but it's not obvious that China trusts Russia more and Russia trusts China more, in a sense that companies, which still, I mean, need to sustain themselves in the long run and have a kind of liquidity management, would do well by accepting national currencies instead of dollar.
43:43Because dollar is still a global currency. So it gives you a kind of protection against the uncertainty of the future. You can't know right now what kind of assets you'll need, what kind of supplies you'll need in the next few years. So it's better to hold on to a balance that will enable you to remain liquid, solvent as a company. And that's why as an international company, you still need dollars. And I think if this trust issue emerges and you still figure out how to produce value across those now separated actors, I think Bitcoin may become a serious contender for international settlements if there are trust issues.
44:31Because it's a neutral form of money and in particular, it's a neutral settlement layer. And that's usually overlooked. The dollar...
44:41It's not only banknotes. That's a very tiny segment, it's basically irrelevant nowadays. It's a settlement layer and it's a trust layer, trust layer for creating loans, and it's a settlement layer for international payments. And Bitcoin is already quite a contender for an international settlement layer. I think it works quite well. I think the scalability issues will be overcome by the increasing number of Lightning nodes and liquidity on Lightning. So I think there's a chance that it will replace settlement layers that are controlled by entities that are either nation states of the size of an empire, as the US, or something in between, like the Eurozone.
45:35Vlad CosteaYes, so I just checked and the market capital of Bitcoin is $441 billion. And it's about 24 times lower than the market cap of gold. And I was about to ask you if you believe that Bitcoin is going to flip gold in the coming years.
45:55Rahim TaghizadeganThat's possible. I mean, I'm not a fan of the market cap metric.
46:01So if there was a better one, I'd use it. And I'd look at, like, the portfolio, how much people have in their portfolios, so that would be the relevant flippening. And I can imagine that, yes. I think gold will still be around. And I think it can even be that the part of gold plus Bitcoin in portfolios increases at the same time. So that I think is rather more likely. I think what will change is the perception of Bitcoin going from a risk-on asset, basically to be treated like a tech stock, to more of an anti-correlated, uncorrelated asset that is strongest in phases of increasing regime uncertainty.
46:56And so I think the likely situation is that both gold and Bitcoin will be increased in portfolios because an age of artificially low volatility is ending, I think, now, and we're living through a time of increased uncertainty, because uncertainty has been lowered artificially by propping up assets, by these kind of interventions that are deemed to be stabilizing but are not in the long run. And we're going to pay a price for this intervention spiral and basically unsound monetary order, which is too fragile.
47:33And during these times, I think everything that's not a liability and allows for trustless settlement will increase in value. And I think Bitcoin will increase more, or get a higher percentage in portfolio, a higher percentage increase in portfolios than gold, because it's... I think it's even better equipped to deal with regime uncertainty, for the reasons that it can be... It allows for self-custody, it doesn't need the centralized marketplaces and storage solutions that gold needs. So in certain respects, it's a better crisis currency and a better settlement layer against regime uncertainty.
48:23Vlad CosteaThere seems to be this conflict between gold proponents and Bitcoin proponents. And for example, there's Joshua from Vaultoro. I suppose you also met him in Mallorca. And he has tried in the past to create gold tokens on the Lightning Network, basically to make gold more liquid and easier to transfer. But there are still issues with gold because you must pay for the men who defend it. You must pay for the storage, you know, storage, security. All of these are very expensive. Whereas in the case of Bitcoin, it doesn't cost you anything.
48:56You generate a BIP39 seed phrase, you write it down on a piece of paper, you memorize it or whatever, and you can cross the national borders without having anything of value on you. So there's a lot of value in this as an asset, but still, I believe that gold is best for governments and corporations and whatever, specifically because it's hard to move around. It's what makes it so desirable.
49:30Rahim TaghizadeganYes, so that's how to predict. I mean, that's a prediction. It's not really something you deduce from theory. You try to figure out where things are going. I would expect that the importance to smuggle something increases, or to smuggle across borders. I expect capital controls to increase. I expect that more and more people will become and have already become very uncertain about their location, where they're living, and are thinking about alternatives. Even in Western countries, now there's a part of the population in Western Europe that is getting an apocalyptic mindset and they're really trying to flee.
50:13They think they're refugees and they're looking all around the place to go. And sometimes those are the best, the most entrepreneurial. Germans are increasingly considering moving outside of Western Europe. For quite a while, I think already 10, 15 years, the Western European mindset has become pessimistic. Most, I mean, it's the region in the world where most people would say, "I believe that my kids or grandchildren will have a harder life than I had." So that's already very negative outlook. And now for some part of the population, they've lost trust completely in the institution. Maybe a few years ago, they still thought that they are living in the best institutional setup, something that's an example for the world. And now, I'd say 10 to 20% of the population lost trust completely, and either perceive their institutions as corrupted or run by evil people, and are thinking about Plan B, an option to be elsewhere.
51:19And I'm not judging that. I'm just describing it as it is. I don't think it's right to think that those are fools. I think better to try to understand that there's a lot of uncertainty, increased uncertainty. And thus, this kind of mobility, and mobility of capital and savings, becomes more important. Once you lose trust and then you speak out against your government and maybe you even start a kind of resistance, going out to the streets and so on, we've seen how censoring financial assets has been used to target people, of course, who are troublemakers or perceived as troublemakers.
52:03But still, of course, that has an impact on people. So they realize that they thought their savings were basically the challenge to save was just to not spend enough, but now they're realizing, oh no, the challenge is much harder. It's to keep your savings safe from government encroachment. That's a lesson our grandparents, those who have grown up in Western Europe, had learned the hard way, or the great-grandparents, and now it's a lesson again that's maybe refreshed and learned again. So that's where I think Bitcoin is stronger than gold in that sense.
52:45Vlad CosteaYes, I want to open another can of worms now that you mentioned that there's this perception that our lives are going to be much better than those of the future generations who are going to struggle much more. I'm pretty sure that where you are right now in Austria, it's a much more advanced conversation in regards to CBDCs, central bank digital currencies. And this is basically another step towards having more control over the money and the way in which it's being spent. And the fact that cash is becoming a lot harder to find.
53:24And I know that the European Central Bank, for example, has withdrawn the 500 euro note to make it harder to transfer amounts of cash. They're trying to discourage it, and I've heard examples of places around Europe where you have cash in your pocket, but you're not able to make any payments. It happened to me in Sweden when I was an exchange student there. I had cash, which I withdrew from the ATM, and I went to pay my rent and nobody wanted to take my money. It was very strange, almost as if I was some sort of black market smuggler or whatever. And, you know, it's not getting any better for financial freedom.
54:11Rahim TaghizadeganYes.
54:12Vlad CosteaAnd the fact that the conversation about CBDCs is so optimistic in parts of Europe, that's worrying. And maybe that, cynically, we can perceive this as being good for Bitcoin, as more people are going to turn towards it as a way to protect themselves against financial surveillance. But for the average person, it's a lot worse. And I don't think they're going to find it easy to get into Bitcoin. And if they do, it's going to be institutional and just as easy to censor.
54:48Rahim TaghizadeganWell, CBDCs are presented as an alternative to Bitcoin, and that's completely wrong, of course. And it's partly real misunderstanding, but it's partly a rationalization. I don't see a very optimistic debate of CBDCs. There's not much of a debate, I'd say. And most people have a hard time to grasp the issue because most people misunderstand cash as a payment technology. And of course, it seems outdated, like gold seems to be a barbaric relic. But cash is something else entirely. It's a permissionless bearer instrument and it wouldn't be able to emerge nowadays.
55:34It would be outlawed immediately. So it's a remainder, an anachronistic remainder. So CBDCs would be good for Bitcoin. They would, if they are really replacing cash, and I expect that slowly cash will be replaced by... But the fight between if it's a CBDC or if it's just bank money, that's the real fight that's going on. I'm not entirely convinced that it'll be a CBDC. It's a question how good are the banks in lobbying and pushing for their interest. It's basically a fight between the central bank and the banking system over the control of money creation. And CBDCs would be great for helicopter money, but that again is an issue between the control of the central bank in money production versus the banking system. And Bitcoin has no role in that.
56:32It's an alternative to both. And in particular, once cash disappears more and is replaced either by digital bank money or a CBDC, the case for Bitcoin increases and gets stronger because there's a vacuum to be filled. And there's still, in the richer European societies, quite an attachment to cash. People can really explain why. Some would argue it's privacy. For some, it's just nostalgic value. But there's a general uneasiness. So it's not... I don't see an optimistic embracement of CBDC if you separate the two aspects. The one is digital payments.
57:16And of course, the younger people will have a hard time understanding how cash would still be a viable payment technology. So they are more open to digital replacements. But there, I think, also Bitcoin is quite strong with the Lightning layer. Bitcoin is quite a strong contender for a digital payment technology that at the same time has the functionality of a bearer instrument.
57:46Vlad CosteaYeah, it's a nuanced debate. And I do recall being in Prague back in April, I think. There was LibertyCon, a conference which was for students who like liberty. And there was this guy on stage who had a presentation that was called something along the lines of "Why CBDCs are not that bad and you should not be worried." And on each slide, he had like a picture of a cat to make you feel like, "Ah, this is nice. This is not so bad." But once you get into the intricacies and you realize, okay, so you do have easier helicopter money which gets delivered to people.
58:25But there are some limitations that can be set up in terms of where you can spend that helicopter money. And that's where it gets shady, as even if the intentions are excellent at heart, and it prevents, for example, social security recipients from buying drugs with that money, which sounds very noble. You're like, yeah, we want them to buy food and pay rent and that's it. But when you go into the questions of where can they buy food, that's where it can get very corporate and it can become very corrupt in regards to which retail chains can actually accept that kind of money and where it can be spent.
59:08And you get contracts between private entities and the states and the central banks. And that's where you're going to have cartels established between economic actors that want to basically destroy their competition. It can become very Orwellian very fast.
59:29Rahim TaghizadeganYes, no, it's obviously, I agree, CBDC is a dystopian scheme, but I'm not pessimistic in the sense that I am convinced that we have to passively await this dystopian scheme. It will increase the pressure as well. And I see quite some reluctance within parts, wealthier parts of, in particular, German-speaking countries. You still have quite a tendency for gold savings, so some of the largest demands for gold as a savings technology is within the German-speaking markets. They also have shown now a strong growth in Bitcoin adoption.
1:00:14And yeah, so I think the increasing pressure with increased capital controls, increased dystopian schemes of controlling the way you spend money will lead to counter-reactions. And of course, one counter-reaction can be that people, if they're unable to move with their assets, move in person. And I would see that in a neutral way, as something that opens up new possibilities. I certainly believe that we have surpassed peak wealth in Western Europe. So I think the perception is true that for people who live in Western Europe and just go along and don't start to take matters in their hands and have some individual responsibility, life will be worse in the future.
1:01:08There'll be a regression to the mean, more or less. But I have high hopes for the creativity and the resourcefulness of Europeans in niches within Europe and outside of Europe. And I think Bitcoin is a very important part of helping people find alternatives to the dystopian schemes. And so I think the importance increases, and I think there are reasons for some light realistic optimism, which doesn't mean that in the medium term or short term, things may not get much worse before they get better again.
1:01:49Vlad CosteaI appreciate your optimism. When I was in Austria a couple of months ago, I became quite pessimistic and I realized that the dystopian future is not so far away, specifically because I was at the Vienna airport. And two months ago means in June. So I was there, I had a stop between flights and I realized that there were people around the corner at the airport telling you to put your mask on to cover your nose, and everyone was so compliant. And I don't want to get into the issue of whether or not masks work, but the rest of Europe does not wear them anymore.
1:02:28And Austria has higher vaccination rates and they should be better off, I guess. I don't know. I don't want to get into that conversation. But it seems to me it was an indicator of a high degree of compliance.
1:02:42Rahim TaghizadeganYes, of course, that's a bad and good thing about Austria and Germany. Austria is better than Germany in this regard. High compliance usually is a sign of a high-trust society, and trust, of course, is easily abused. A high-trust society is also a society of high reliability, of high work discipline, and so on. So parts of the wealth, of course, are linked to this high trust. I think this high trust is consumed and it's abused. And of course, there are negative parts of that, so it's not for everyone the right thing. I'm quite happy that I'm not in Germany.
1:03:25I would have left Germany long ago, because Austria is a bit more... it's like between Italy and Germany, in a sense, culturally. So a bit lower trust, but still above average, a bit lower compliance, but still above average. And there, of course, are two very different Austrias. Austria is one big metropolis, that's Vienna, a very urban city, but nowadays not, I'd say, so much a commercial hub and scientific hub, but basically a hub of money production and administration. And then there's the countryside, and the rest of Austria is much more rural than Germany, for example, and there are very different mentalities.
1:04:10So, of course, I was unhappy about the management of the pandemic. In certain ways it could have been worse. I was not that affected. Some things were really bad. But then I predicted that the pressure would be strong enough to repeal the worst things, and I was right. So this optimism played out. Austria was one of the few countries to institute a government mandate for vaccines, but then they couldn't push it through and they repealed the law. So there are counter-reactions. And nowadays you don't have to wear a mask at the airport anymore.
1:04:52And most people, if there's not a general rule that you should do it, don't do it. So you can see it's imposed. It's not imposed by violence that much, because it's a high-trust society. So people will usually want to have a rule, figure out what everyone else is doing and comply. That's a general sign of a high-trust society. Sometimes those rules are bad, and they tend to be more and more bad. There are, of course, consequences of bad rules, and we are seeing more and more of these consequences.
1:05:28And so I think it's quite significant that even within, I mean, Austria, which is perceived by some as one of the best places to live... Vienna is, in the quality of life index, usually position number one, the city with the highest quality of life.
1:05:44And of course, there are statistics and you ask expats and so on. But still, even in Austria, you are losing 10 to 20% of the population. So increasingly, who won't tell you, "Oh, of course, there are some things that should be fixed, as everywhere, but generally we are quite happy and proud about the institutional arrangement." No, 10 to 20% will now tell you, "Oh, we're totally surprised how corrupted and evil institutions have become. We can't trust anyone anymore. We feel persecuted." And of course, it's a minority.
1:06:22But this kind of polarization, which we see everywhere, is a sign, of course, of things breaking up, and that will have consequences. In a way, it limits the encroachment of the government, and in that sense, of course, there's a positive outlook: increased pressure will lead to innovations, resistance, some dynamics. Some of it will be bad, but some of it will be good. And we can predict what the general pattern will be.
1:06:54Vlad CosteaI don't want to make the listeners any more depressed about the situation. So, the one topic that we have to discuss, as it was the subject of your presentation from the conference where we met, concerns whether or not we are in a cult. But before that, I just want to have this short break in which I'm going to ask you to turn around and look at the bookshelf that you have and recommend to the listeners three books that you have in your library.
1:07:23Rahim TaghizadeganNo, I can't do this. I mean, I could do it potentially. I have a huge library here, and it's just one room. So that's the room I do the recording in, and that's literature behind me. So I would recommend out of that bookshelf, I'd recommend probably Goethe's Faust II. So that's just literature here, but it's a tiny proportion of the library. It's a huge library here. It's, I think, the largest library on Austrian economics at one place. I got an inheritance of one of the Hayek students, who was Roland Baader. He amassed a huge library.
1:08:06So it's a lot of physical books, and nowadays the digital library is even larger than that. So I usually have a hard time recommending books. I've myself written more than a dozen books, and for me it's odd to recommend a book because, like, my reading list is always like 100 books or something that I go through. I read a lot. I read very, very quickly. And yeah, the library is many 10,000s of books, 20, 30,000 books.
1:08:40Maybe 20, 30,000 books are concentrated here. So if I had to recommend a book about the Austrian school, probably I'd go for "Human Action" by Ludwig von Mises as one of the most systematic and important treatises of that tradition. But then, if I recommend books, usually I recommend them based on the person I'm talking to and the interests of the person I'm talking to. And I would not overrate books too much. So it's not for everyone crucial. I don't think there's something superior in just reading.
1:09:18And in a sense, I now mostly use digital media. I'm still reading a lot, but I usually, even if I have a physical book, I have it scanned and read it on a device. I'm quite mobile and I work a lot with the texts that I'm reading. I'm annotating them. And so, of course, I adapt to the technology. Since the screens have become better, I wouldn't go back to reading paper books.
1:10:00Vlad CosteaThere is this dilemma from, I think it's from H.G. Wells' "The Time Machine", where at the end of the story, he goes back to the society which he discovered and rescued, the main character. I don't recall exactly the name. But he fights the Morlocks and then he goes back and he only takes a few books. And there's this ending in a cliffhanger, like, which books did he take? Like, they're not sure because he has a huge library. But it's almost as if you're asking yourself, if you're going to start the civilization from scratch and you're going to provide lessons to people who have not been exposed to any kind of learning of any kind, what kind of books would you take?
1:10:43Rahim TaghizadeganIt doesn't matter. I mean, you take a book as burning material, basically. I mean, it's like you go to the island, you, after the apocalypse, it doesn't matter. One book is not enough. Most of knowledge is not explicit knowledge. It's implicit knowledge within people. And that's really relevant knowledge. Books only cover a very small segment of the knowledge. That was Hayek's insight, basically, how a society is an extended knowledge order and not through the books. The books are one tiny part. Most of books are bullshit. So a huge part is very highly significant within the books that are produced.
1:11:23It's just one small layer of knowledge. I love the tradition. It's like a big conversation over millennia between people who try to figure out what it all means and how it's all related and so on. And so I'm still a big fan of the medium, but I would not overrate it. And certainly, if you start anew after an apocalypse, other things are more important. And I think that's the incorporated practical knowledge. I mean, even in Austrian economics, sometimes we use the analogy of Robinson Crusoe. And obviously, it's the capital he has with him. It's in his mind. So he doesn't start from zero. And he wouldn't be able to do it from a book.
1:12:09He is able to survive because he has brought a lot of invisible capital with him. It's his experiences and the operating system he already has in place. And then really important is the catalytic exchange. That's the largest part of wealth creation, is cooperating with other people. If books help you, that's great. And it's also very subjective. I mean, for many people, probably it'll be some kind of religious text which gives you a moral basis to start society anew. So I'd recommend something that gives you a long-term perspective, that gives you kind of moral grounding, that is favorable towards cooperation. And that's what's really important for survival in the long run.
1:13:05Vlad CosteaI think you provided the perfect introduction as you mentioned religious texts, and the topic that we're supposed to debate right now concerns whether or not we are in a cult. What is your general take on it? You find people who are very like-minded, they have trust in each other's opinions. They got to a point where they don't need to verify the information itself, they trust the source and they act upon their trust. So it's really interesting how this movement, which started with this very demanding dictum of "don't trust, verify," ended up relying so much on trust.
1:13:50And even among developers, you find trust systems, and basically they look at who came up with the code, and they can be more drastic with newcomers, but if there's a veteran who wrote a certain line of code, they're not going to audit it with the same standards.
1:14:08Rahim TaghizadeganYes, trust is underrated. Trust is very important and it would be a big misunderstanding to think that Bitcoin is a trustless solution because trust is bad, therefore we have to replace it with verification or technology. No, unfortunately, we have to replace trust because trust has been abused and trust can't be trusted anymore. And it's quite a complicated process that happened there. So Bitcoin is, in a sense, a technological solution to a problem. And the problem is that big because trust is so important. And if you can't count on trust, then, of course, there are issues.
1:14:56And in particular for cooperation, because cooperation needs a certain layer of trust. And it has always been the case that you can replace some interpersonal trust, which means you cooperate with foreigners because there are institutional technologies more or less helping you. And that's great because they increase the amount of cooperation that's possible by limiting the necessary trust for cooperation. And that's what Bitcoin does. So it's not replacing generally trust because we dislike trust or we think trust is bad. But it makes it more resilient towards loss of trust and expands the circle of cooperation, as money usually does.
1:15:48So money is generally a technology or a phenomenon that emerges if foreigners are cooperating, and foreigners have trust issues. And that's not something that's good. That's the way it is, that we have to expect and accept the way it is. Now, I don't think it's a movement. I think we tend to like to think in movements. I think money and technology usually are discoveries and not conventions, which means you stumble upon them. It's not something that you will into existence. You stumble upon them. But then Bitcoin in particular serves as a kind of attractor or a Schelling point for certain value judgments and preferences as well.
1:16:30And so they address a certain longing, and they turn you optimistic in the sense that you think, oh, if this main issue here in society can be addressed, and it's an issue of money that you can't trust anymore, how about other issues of society? So I think that's also a power of Bitcoin. You can see among people interested in Bitcoin, as a kind of attractor for value and like-minded people, they tend to be more optimistic and more positive, because they think that there's a success story against all odds.
1:17:13And so that increases the perception of being a movement. It's like it's moving in a good direction, it's more and more people using it, and by using it, again, more and more people prove that there are alternatives. A lot of people perceive that it's a kind of alternative-less institutional arrangement. There is no alternative. That's even an acronym, the TINA acronym. And this has become a very good description of a society, maybe towards the end of a certain institutional development, where just the things are in place. They're quite complicated.
1:17:51You can't really explain them. You don't believe in them anymore. But it seems it's all just held together not by conviction, but by, like, kind of just following along and stumbling along because it has been working, and you're really afraid of what happens if this fabric is not working anymore. You're afraid of the uncertainty, if things that you considered safe all your life are not safe anymore. And I think there's this longing for a movement in the sense there's some positive change, which is an alternative, which you, by your individual action, can bring about and help bring about. And I think one should cherish that. It's something positive. And so I would excuse this misunderstanding of a discovery of something for an organization.
1:18:49And in particular, it's the enemies of Bitcoin, of course, there's a moral value judgment again, who tend to have a tribalistic, collectivist outlook. They look at Bitcoiners as a kind of tribe or movement or organization. They decided they dislike some of those people. And then they, well, they know that they don't like Bitcoin because they don't like Bitcoiners, because they see all the flaws and problems and so on. And I don't think that's very empathic. I think everyone who is open-minded would see that there are trust issues and there's increasing uncertainty and polarization.
1:19:32And I think it's one of the least toxic reactions, because it's one of the most positive phenomena of looking for alternatives. Of course, there are many other ways. There are certain religious interpretations, there are other cults, there are other radicalized movements who try to change society because they are disgruntled, not satisfied. And I'd say that people who are into Bitcoin and who see a positive potential are the least toxic of all those who have lost trust in society, because there are many much more toxic and aggressive ways how you cope with the loss in trust.
1:20:17So I think it's not entirely fair. And then, of course, human beings are by nature tribalistic. So we seek a tribe that we can belong to. We have a longing for a trusted society. It's a challenge because those intuitions are a bit at odds with economic development, and they are at odds with money in particular. So there's a challenge. I was early on very skeptical about Bitcoin because I was afraid that it was not a neutral money, that it was more or less a kind of ledger for barter arrangements between libertarians, for a kind of circular closed economy of libertarians.
1:20:58And libertarians are a niche phenomenon. There is nothing such as libertarians. There are some people who rally around this term and find other people and figure out that they are like-minded and let themselves be labeled by the term. But I thought, no, that's not the potential of money. Money is for exchange and cooperation between foreigners, people who are not always having the same values. And I still believe that. But I believe that Bitcoin can be both. It can be a technology and a more neutral form of money, which doesn't care about your values. And at the same time, it can be a symbol of hope and a rallying cry of people looking for an alternative.
1:21:51But still these trade-offs are there. And of course, they lead to split. And of course, as we are tribalistic, we always try to figure out: are we part of that group or not? And now we have this Bitcoin maxi debate, figuring out if there are cultural issues with Bitcoiners. And that's again, I think, three very different phenomena which are, from this wrong collectivist outlook, lumped together as one phenomenon. And they're very different. There are, I think, at least three meanings to the term "to be a Bitcoin maximalist."
1:22:33And I'd say one is a question of style. There's a style, let's say, shitposting, trolling, be very, in a sense, eloquent, and use, in particular on Twitter, memes and so on. And I think it's a certain style and it's associated, and some people dislike it. They are triggered by this kind of internet communication, which has become popular. And of course, it's not equally distributed. It's a certain subset. It's probably a little bit more male phenomenon.
1:23:13But I think it's unfair to just say, "I mean, I'm triggered by something," and now I extrapolate and say because I dislike the style of that person, that means Bitcoiners are toxic and bad. I think it's one phenomenon, and I'm not triggered. I think it's okay. I can cope with that. It's not my personal style. I tend to be more European, polite in a sense, reluctant to shitpost and troll, but I like it. I think there's no reason to take issue with an adult in that very general sense and lump it together as a kind of tribe if you have very different personalities.
1:23:57And I don't think it's correct to perceive that, "Oh, my God, there's some marketing issues. And how are we perceived?" That's all collectivism. The general problem is that you are perceived as a "we" which doesn't exist, because why should one adult be lumped within another adult? It's like this tribalistic logic, where you're perceived as a family, and if one does wrong, everyone else is to be punished for it. That doesn't make any sense. So I think it's a very childish reaction towards that. Now, the second sense of Bitcoin maximalist, I think it's a moralistic way.
1:24:41It's people, it's a bit paternalistic, but they think that they have a moral obligation to call out people who they perceive as immoral, because they think Bitcoin is something that offers moral improvement to society. So they dislike the association of grifters or people who are a bit, I mean, not as morally pure as it should be. And of course, that's a problem. You may be perceived as self-righteous. Again, that's usually not my way. That's not the approach of the Austrian school. But I think there's no, why should you take challenge with something?
1:25:18It's your choice. And some people are moralistic. And if you look at the track record, I think one should be very reluctant to attack the moralizers because there is in fact a big problem with profiteers in crypto in general. And I think some of those maximalists, in the sense that make strong moral cases and try to protect people from what they perceive as immoral actors, they have been proven right. They were correct in the warnings and anticipations. And we've seen tremendous moral problems within this sphere.
1:26:01So again, even if that's not my approach, I think one should be reluctant in perceiving it as a big problem. And then there's a third approach, a third maximalism, and that's rather my approach. And I think that's the... If you have been watching Bitcoin for a long time, you figure out, yes, there are network effects. Yes, it looks like there were many issues and people tried to improve upon it. Nothing is really convincing. There are trade-offs. And it's not obvious that any altcoin made a better choice in the trade-offs. And so I think it's a combination of a network. You perceive that over time, OK, well, this network effect remains.
1:26:51The mining infrastructure is surprisingly resilient. That is the second empirical observation where I was positively surprised. I wouldn't have expected that the Chinese mining ban would have so little impact on the general hash rate and the general stability of the Bitcoin network. And then the third thing is the emergence of the hodler, DCA crowd or army, DCA army, sometimes you call them. And it's again, it's something, I mean, you can take challenge with that, but still you have to describe it and observe it and say, wow, it seems to be that more and more people are perceiving Bitcoin not as a risk-on asset, but as something that over time you accumulate and you think it's a long-term strategy and you're very reluctant to sell.
1:27:47And of course, that strengthens the case for Bitcoin in a very neutral way, as something that you observe. You say, "Yeah, of course, that can increase Bitcoin dominance over time if there's a kind of base demand that increases." And I think that's another very different sense of Bitcoin maximalism, seeing like that the promise of the altcoin sphere and so on has to be discounted after this experience. It doesn't mean that every project will fail and will be a scam, but you're more reluctant to take the big promises because you see, well, lots of things have been tried and you can see an emergence, a discovery more or less of the resilience and network effects and so on.
1:28:31of Bitcoin. And so, yeah, that's a very, very different personality, very different meaning. And I think it's totally incorrect to lump it all together. So this personal style, the moralistic arguing and this kind of descriptive observation of increasing Bitcoin dominance or relevance.
1:28:57Vlad CosteaYeah, generally, so I don't define maximalism in these terms. When I think about it, I ask the question, what is it trying to maximize? And it can be a maximization of what Bitcoin already is, and that's what I guess you described, or it can be a maximization of what it can be. And generally, when I define myself as a maximalist, I use the latter definition, which means that if there is any kind of use case from DeFi, NFTs, whatever, that's interesting and gets enough market demand, then I suppose it's in my best interest as a Bitcoiner to find ways to bring it to the Bitcoin network in some shape or form, even if it's on the base layer or on a second layer. I want this network to basically incorporate everything that's good and useful for the economy at large.
1:29:54So that's what it means to me to be a maximalist. There's another side of maximalism which defines maximalism as denying that there's anything useful outside of what Bitcoin already is, and calling everything else a scam, but I disagree in this regard. I'm pretty sure that what we define right now as the crypto market is the extended Bitcoin experimentation market. And there are lots of projects that some of them started out as nothing else but basic forks of BTC. And they just played with parameters. But in time, they developed some new technologies.
1:30:34They looked at cypherpunk literature and figured out different use cases. And to me, maximalism means bringing these use cases to the most secure, most robust, most resilient and most predictable network of them all, as everything else is just the market for experimentation. So that's my understanding of maximalism.
1:30:55Rahim TaghizadeganYeah, I mean, you don't get to define the terms. There's perception and some see it as a positive, others as a negative term. And you take issue yourself, you take issue with, I'd say, the moralistic case. Those people who call everything a scam, that's the second, I think, meaning that I had in mind. It's the moralistic approach. And I think I'm trying to explain this approach, not saying that it's the right one, but trying to explain it. It's basically heuristic. And it's paternalistic. You try to tell the potential new retail adopter, if you know nothing about it, the likelihood is very great that it's a scam.
1:31:34If it's not Bitcoin, the heuristic tells you, as someone who is new to the space, consider everything a scam but Bitcoin.
1:31:45I will have a hard time meaning that it's a moral case, but I understand it. And in particular, after the experience of this year, again, it has been validated in a certain sense that this heuristic has helped some people. And there is a lot of bad incentives in, like, yeah, piggybacking on Bitcoin and trying to shill your project, which is a risky experiment. But you get retail interest because people perceive it as an alternative to Bitcoin, something that is a resilient savings layer but gives you added interest income, which of course, as a retail hoarder or someone who tries to preserve his purchasing power, would say yes.
1:32:44"Yeah, I can have something like Bitcoin, but it gives me 6%, 10% interest. Great, I take that." And I think the moralistic, paternalistic thing, I mean, as an adult, usually I'd be more reluctant in saying no, it's a scam. I'd say do your own research, figure it out if you really think that's the case. And many people might have good intentions because they are experiments. But it's rather the realm of venture capital. And of course, it's a very distorted field generally, due to the monetary system, the whole venture field.
1:33:19And it has a different risk component to it. So within, I think within the distorted structure, I think there's a case to be made for a kind of feeling responsible for a small guy entering crypto. It's a bit paternalistic, so there's a problem with that. It's a challenge if it's personalized. If you say like everyone who is not a Bitcoin Core developer is probably a scam artist. And so then everyone who doesn't agree with me is potentially a scam artist. That goes too far, but I think there is a case to be made that there's a useful function to that kind of moralistic, very critical layer of being really strict about how you sell something to the public.
1:34:13And of course, the problem is very much compounded by the distorted structure. People are really pressed and pushed into speculative investments that are out of the league of their own risk preference. They are pushed into that, into meme stocks and so on, and crypto, by the distortion of their savings and by making it impossible to save in the currency they earn money in. Yeah, one has to cope with that. I'm more of the approach that's buyer beware, and I'd rather have people learn for themselves by losing money.
1:34:57I think it's not the end of the world if you lose your Bitcoin in an altcoin project. I myself lost a lot of my Bitcoin early on, of course, in experiments, and I think there's nothing bad or illegal with that. It shouldn't be illegal to lose your own money. But I see there's a moral issue. And yeah, I don't think that it's a big danger for Bitcoin adoption. I don't buy into the fear of this toxicity, that experimentation is made impossible by people that are overly moralistic. I'd say no, I mean, don't care about them.
1:35:43If you don't like that, ignore them. That's okay. That's fine, but just also take that as a warning that people perceive Bitcoin as something positive and pure and potentially the foundation of a more pure society. And maybe that's a fiction and that's a utopia, but still people perceive it that way and they are not the worst people who perceive it that way. And accept that it's more natural for human beings to be moralistic and to care about things they care about and wanting to protect it. So that's fine.
1:36:24So I don't see this debate as really being very useful, debating it. I think everyone has a different style. I think you make a very good point for bringing use cases where you see utility onto Bitcoin. That's fine. There's always, of course, a danger that you bring this kind of risk preference into something that's not meant to be, as the base layer should be. Or there's a hope that it'll become a risk-off layer for everyone. And so it's a challenge, and I understand that people want to differentiate, and I do it myself between Bitcoin and crypto generally. And crypto for me is much more experimentation.
1:37:15And due to the distorted structure, the heuristic I think is correct, that most will turn out to be a scam in the sense that the promises cannot be fulfilled.
1:37:27And it's experience, just over time, over all this time, seeing all these promises and believing in them as well and being a bit frustrated in what turned out to be the end result and what's really the use of the digital apps and all those experimental use cases, the ICO hype, the DeFi hype, the NFT hype. Still, I'd say I'm more open. I myself have a higher risk preference. I like experiments. I like people who try out crazy things. I have no aversion against NFTs in a very general sense, even though I personally dislike it a bit as a preference, just a preference, which is not judgment. I dislike these status games and so on, but I'm willing to learn and understand if people see value in that. But I also understand why some people care too much about Bitcoin to believe every new promise of a new venture capitalist of great riches that are to be made by something which has to prove its usefulness.
1:38:45And hasn't. So I'm fairly skeptical about the promises about the metaverse and so on, and it has all to be taken with a grain of salt. And the incentives are really bad in the whole venture capital scene, and in particular in the crypto venture capital scene. But again, it's a question, who are we talking about? Are we talking about the hardworking person who's figuring out that he can preserve his purchasing power and now looks where to put his few thousand euros in savings, or few hundred euros if he's in Africa?
1:39:17And yeah, I'm pretty sad about how the Central African Republic now has the Sango token. I wouldn't say that they are evil necessarily, but I'd be very critical. It's too bad because the risk is quite high. One of the poorest countries, people don't have that many savings. I mean, potentially just a small elite now. Speculating, but where's the exit liquidity? Could it be that some very poor Central Africans are the exit liquidity for the Sango token? It's not a new concept. I mean, we are not in 2017, we're not in 2013, we're not in 2011, we're in 2022.
1:40:02So there is very good reason for being doubtful about tokenization, utility tokens, tokenizing resources, and so on, all these promises. You've just seen so much bullshit that you become reluctant to just accept promises. But still, it doesn't mean... I would say, yeah, that's great. If you experiment with it, that's fine. Maybe we will learn something. But if you promise it as an alternative to the regular guy for his savings, and not just as a high-risk venture investment of someone who already has millions and millions and will invest 10,000 in your startup idea...
1:40:43Okay. That's totally fine. So I think there's some moral obligation towards people who have a big pressing need due to government encroachment on their capacity to save, and promise something that's very unlikely that you can fulfill.
1:41:14Ad voiceoverAfter Mt. Gox collapsed, that was really the precipice of me saying, "Right, this has to change. We need a totally transparent exchanging system and base it on gold instead of fiat."
1:41:32Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the hard money exchange which helps you beat inflation with instant swaps between the best stores of value known to man, gold and Bitcoin. Unlike most exchanges, Vaultoro understands the importance of transparency and security. All gold holdings are secured in top-tier Swiss private vaults and fully insured against theft, fire and more. Maximize your purchasing power. Get investing power today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. This is not financial advice, but gold has been humankind's most reliable store of value in the last 6,000 years. Do your own research. Use promotion code TAKEOVER for a one-time bonus of 1 gram of gold for the first 50 new customers buying gold with Bitcoin.
1:42:32Are you concerned that your friends, neighbors, or KYC exchange might know how much Bitcoin you own? It is time to take your financial privacy seriously with Wasabi Wallet, a free and open-source wallet solution which makes use of mega CoinJoins to mix your coins with those of hundreds of other strangers. Thanks to the groundbreaking WabiSabi engine, your coins get divided in smaller, untraceable units, which grant you great anonymity for both hodling and spending. Download Wasabi Wallet 2.0 today at wasabiwallet.io and take advantage of the mega CoinJoins. It's free and it's open source, so don't trust, verify.
1:43:41What are you going to wear when Bitcoin hits 1 million dollars? The same old 20 dollar t-shirt? Try Maison Mauchi, the designer clothes made in Paris by Bitcoiners for Bitcoiners. They're not your average mass-produced sweatshop clothes. Mauchi will ask for your measurements and tailor every piece of clothing according to the shape of your body, so you always look and feel great in your t-shirt, hoodie or dress. It's all made in France by real artisans who also happen to be Bitcoiners, which is why Maison Mauchi only accepts Bitcoin as payment for their clothes. Get a Maison Mauchi t-shirt or hoodie today. It might even help you find a girlfriend.
1:44:36And once you do get a girlfriend, you can also buy her a Maison Mauchi dress. Stop having fun looking poor and check out MaisonMauchi.com. That's M-A-I-S-O-N-M-A-S-H-I.com.
1:44:57I very much understand where you're coming from, and I agree with pretty much everything that you said, but I can also make the case that all of these speculative phases of the market, be it ICOs or NFTs or DeFi with, you know, very high APY, whatever, all of these are very good gateway drugs, if I can put it like this. Because most likely 90% or more of the people who invest in these are going to lose their money during the bear markets. The projects most likely will never make a comeback.
1:45:33They will never benefit from the same attention, from the same VC funding, from everything that propped them up in the first place during a bull cycle. And that's when these people will either exit and be like, "Everything is a scam, this is not for me," or else look for something which is a lot more secure and provides them more certainty. And that's when they discover Bitcoin and that's when it clicks to them. It makes sense. They have that Eureka moment. They say, "This is what I have been actually looking for, but I didn't know about it because this other project had better marketing and it got to me."
1:46:12And there isn't much that we can do. And of course, we're going to receive lots of insults while we try to prevent people from investing in this kind of stuff, but it's after they actually realized that we were right that they start looking into this project more seriously. Or the other option is that they rage quit. They say this is not for me, and that's fine, I guess. Even though I'm pretty sure that they're missing out on the sovereignty part.
1:46:42On being able to take your money outside of the country without any kind of risk for confiscation, and that's what we should promote more, as opposed to, you know, models like stock-to-flow or the Rainbow Chart or whatever, where we say by the year 2030, we're gonna see one million price per one Bitcoin, $1 million, I mean. And that's something that we should all believe in. I can understand the value of these as self-fulfilling prophecies where people act in a way that makes them happen, as opposed to them being actual predictors of anything.
1:47:26But it's more likely that they don't turn out to be that way. And that's what the most dangerous part is, where you attract someone with very sound arguments regarding financial sovereignty. Then you enchant them with these promises of fabulous gains. And the gains don't come. They don't happen. People sell their houses. They take mortgages. They sell their cars. They take debt in fiat terms, as in a bank loan to buy more BTC. And then they realize that their expectations are not fulfilled and they still have to pay something to survive.
1:48:01So usually, there's a lot of bad advice that comes even from this inner circle of maximalists who tell you to sell your chair to buy more Bitcoin. But, you know, it's still better advice on the long term, or it has been historically, than telling you to invest in NXT, which was the next big thing before Ethereum. And it seems like Ethereum is going to get... Always there is another Ethereum which is going to replace it. It's going to be interesting to see if 2.0 has any degree of success or it leads to more forks, but there is only one Bitcoin.
1:48:46Rahim TaghizadeganYeah. I agree with that. I mean, everyone has to make his own judgment. I mean, if you look at the details, I doubt that you can really say you're working on gateway drugs. The whole analogy is a bit difficult. I mean, Dan Held mentioned that to me on Twitter, like that people come for the speculation and they stay for the sound money. I'm not entirely sure that it's correct. I think it's not a natural longing of people generally for speculation, it's they are pushed into speculation and they mistake it for saving.
1:49:25And so really there is a kind of danger to that, that it's not a gateway drug to a sound approach to money. It's just a way for gambling and it's gambling with very bad incentives.
1:49:46Vlad CosteaMy camera died, don't worry. So go on, you said very bad incentives, but you stopped mid-sentence.
1:49:55Rahim TaghizadeganYeah, because I mean, it was possible to make a stop, but I just saw you disappear. I mean, gambling usually has better incentives, like the bank wins in any case, and there it's even worse. You really have the issue where you ride along with a wrong perception and a politically propped up wrong perception of what saving is. And you ride along a very bad kind of business model, where you use retail as exit liquidity. I'd be doubtful about that, even though I was very positive about ICOs generally.
1:50:38Of course I see a need for ways to raise money for experimental companies, but I realized over time it didn't work out as promised. And I think fundamentally there was something wrong about it. It was not the right solution. And it was pushed by regulatory arbitrage in a way which didn't fulfill the potential. So very little has come out of those experiments, and I think a lot of value has been destroyed.
1:51:08And there's not enough value created for these experiments. I mean, most experiments of course go wrong, but I think after the experiences we had in the last decade and more, one should be skeptical about this kind of retail speculation and see that this is a challenge, an issue, and it will lead to regulatory pressure. And then it's not obvious that it's a new technology helping people, but basically you hide behind technology as a layer, better grift, because it becomes complicated, because you can use regulatory arbitrage, you can do things because you add unnecessary technological complexity to it to obfuscate what you're doing.
1:52:02And if that's the only value produced, then there is an issue with that. Still, I'm glad that we had the experiments and that we could learn from that. So I would never have proposed to forbid someone from starting an ICO. I think we can learn from that and not just replay it again. And it seems a lot of the NFTs are basically ICOs again, another form of the ICO bubble, for many projects just a way to raise money. And you raise money in a way by obfuscating the real risk to retail savers.
1:52:46That are led into speculation, and you make use of that, and there's, let's say, an issue with that. And the same issues in crowdfunding, even without crypto. I think crowdfunding is problematic, and where also regulatory... The regulatory framework has led it to be worse than it would have emerged on the market, and where you basically have secondary loans which are served last, where you increase the risk for the retail investor. And you have either a kind of affinity scam where you play up on the community crowdfunding something.
1:53:31And it's always a kind of... It works because people misjudge the risk, and that's a challenge. So I think a better part of the market cooperation should be a good fit between preferences. So you need to bring together the people with matching preferences or adverse preferences. And if that's not the case, you'll have distortions. You have business cycle-like distortions, which look like bubbles afterwards, and they are made possible, of course, by the fiat distortions, but of course also by entrepreneurs running along the wave and making use of these distortions for their own good.
1:54:13And that will bring reactions. It brought in the history. I mean, in history we've seen that again and again, that that has brought reactions against entrepreneurship. In the most distorted times in history, it has brought reactions and people perceived the entrepreneur as someone immoral. And that I think would be a terrible outcome, if you perceive entrepreneurs in the space as generally immoral people. And so I think some self-regulation is necessary, not in the sense of a regulatory body, but try to be aware of the challenges and try to look for win-win ways and not just deceiving, obfuscating people and then rationalizing it because you benefit of it.
1:55:03Vlad CosteaI very much agree with that and it's a lot more elaborate than I would have described, you know, good old scams. But even in this situation, I think last year when I was at a conference, I still saw an ICO pitch. And that was, you know, it felt like a time machine, like somebody opened a time portal and decided to show me something which I almost have forgotten. And it was also funny to see the crowd reactions. Nobody was even trying to rationalize the pitch itself. Everyone knew that it was a scam.
1:55:39It was like a dinosaur that basically entered the room. And it was even funnier that the guy who was making the pitch was not aware of what he was doing and what kind of audience he was dealing with. So I'm sure that there's always some part of the world that hasn't heard about these and is going to get super excited. It's super immoral in the sense that here in Romania, where I live, there's this national shitcoin, that's what I like to call it. It's a clone of Ethereum which added a couple of features.
1:56:15It experiments with sharding. That's the only interesting stuff that it does. But what it did, and what I find scandalous, is the fact that it translated Bitcoin memes to the local language, and it did so in Romania and France. And you'd be surprised to see how successful this was. And it was only because we kept this in the English bubble. And that's what the problem is. That there are people who are isolated from the conversation only because there's the linguistic barrier. And then scammers go to them and then they exploit their lack of understanding or knowledge or exposure to something that we take for granted.
1:57:01And then they profit off of it. They get to that billion-dollar market cap, and then they hit the news, and that's when there's like a spiral or a snowball effect where it only gets bigger until the bubble bursts, and there's the initial investors who sell because they know there's no way this is going to become too successful. This has no actual future. It was always meant to be an experiment. But since they made so much money off of it, why not, you know, sell right now and dump on the idiot who bought after they saw the news about the billion-dollar market cap? So that's how it works.
1:57:40And it's also part of the reason why right now... So I hope that by the time I publish this interview, which is hopefully going to be this week, the French translation of the Bitcoin Takeover magazine, which I created, is going to be ready. And in late August of 2020, it's going to be distributed at the Surfin' Bitcoin conference in France. And I'm pretty sure that the people who receive it don't actually need the information that's contained inside of it, but I hope that they're going to recommend it to newbies, to normies, to everyone who needs to learn how this works but don't have the linguistic means to learn.
1:58:26And I also count on African countries that speak French. I think there's a huge barrier there. I'm also going to have a Spanish translation, and that's the one about which I have greater expectations, as it's going to get printed for El Salvador, for Chile, for Argentina, and there are all of these Central and South American countries where the education about what Bitcoin is, is rather poor. And it's lacking in terms of educational materials that are accessible to anyone. And basically, the best way to counter scams is to provide education.
1:59:07And you have to provide it in a language that the person receiving the education can understand. Otherwise, you can spend all day on Twitter, calling everyone a shitcoiner, calling everything a scam, but you're not going to actually get through with your argument, because they are convinced by the marketing department of that specific scam project that they're doing what's right and they have a great future and their money is in a good place. So this is what my approach is currently.
1:59:38Rahim TaghizadeganYes, yes. Generally, arguing and debating is overrated. I think it's a very important, critical method of trying to understand the world around us. But most people don't have the leisure to really understand what's going on. They have their interests and they try to rationalize their interests and what they are seeking for. So generally, I think it's not really the case that crypto itself is immoral, or crypto entrepreneurs are more immoral than others. It's the framework, the distortion around it. And it's a part of the investment market. And the investment market is basically a big scam.
2:00:23So I'm saying that as an economist, and I do investment consulting, and I see that the incentives are really bad and it's been known for a long time. Of course, most newsletters in the investment field are scammy and very problematic. And it's the whole distorted structure that, even if you try hard, I mean, you need to make your living as an economist as well, or as a coder, or someone who's interested in blockchain and experiments with it. And then you realize that, yeah, there are certain ways to make money, and if you can raise money for an interesting experiment, it's better than not raising money for an interesting experiment, in particular in challenging times like these.
2:01:13So I think there's more on this structural trying to understand. So it's not so much a lack of knowledge, I'd say, and it's not so much a moral problem, it's an institutional problem. I don't think you can solve it by arguing, and also not even by calling out people, even though I understand, but it's the general structure that people are pushed into bad decisions by a bad institutional structure. Yeah, that's the issue. Crypto generally is perceived as part of the investment market, and it is. That's the main issue.
2:01:58And why is it the main issue? Because saving is underrated. How important it is to cope with the fundamental problem of uncertainty over your lifetime, and the fact that we age and our capacity to generate income will go down over time, and that's pretty certain. And so it's a universal human need and longing. And if it's made harder, still this human nature will push for something and look for substitute ways to find a way, refuge from these challenges. So I'd be skeptical about the knowledge part.
2:02:50That people make wrong decisions because they don't know better. I think they make decisions based on their interests and context, and then they seek knowledge to rationalize what they are doing, and so rationalize the decisions afterwards. Which doesn't mean that I don't respect the dissemination of knowledge. I think that's of course crucial, but I wouldn't expect too much of it.
2:03:21Vlad CosteaI very much understand your argument. And, you know, it's very elaborate for what it actually describes. And that's what scammers usually do. They find reasons. Actually, not just scammers, also criminals. They find a post-rationalization of their action, and they try to justify their deeds according to whatever. They can find anything from a movie to a moral system to a religious reference.
2:03:52Rahim TaghizadeganAlso, the people that fall for the scam. A lot of people asked my advice after they had fallen for a scam, and it's quite usual, it's not before, it's afterwards, when it's too late, that people are seeking advice, and then you try to rationalize why it's your fault, and then you're the victim, of course, and it didn't seem like it. So I think generally human beings tend to look for reasons and tend to rationalize. And we have a different capacity, how good we are at rationalizing. And I think with better capacity to rationalize comes a certain more responsibility as well.
2:04:39Vlad CosteaI very much agree with this. And most of the times it's not even a rationalization. It's more in the sense of superstitions or karma or whatever. They find like this cosmic reason which made them do bad actions or perform poorly in investments, like this cycle. It was so hilarious. We had this situation where, on one hand, you had the technical analysis guys, and I'm not sure what your opinion is as an Austrian economist on technical analysis, but it's a lot like astrology to me.
2:05:12Rahim TaghizadeganI agree.
2:05:13Vlad CosteaAnd it was funny that there was this girl who was doing astrology. And she was trying to predict markets according to what the stars were doing. And it was so funny because she grew a huge following. She ended up appearing on American television and stuff like that, only because she was so popular. And in some cases, she would predict market movements more accurately than the guys who look at the charts.
2:05:40Rahim TaghizadeganYeah. Not surprising. Well, I mean, what makes economics more complex is that, of course, what you believe has an impact and changes your actions. Some things can be self-fulfilling prophecies. Unfortunately, bad models can be correct in the sense that they have an impact on how people behave and change their behavior. But generally, of course, the approach of the Austrian school is very antithetical to technical analysis, but you need to understand the context. I mean, I think most of economics is a scam, structurally a scam. If you look at it, who employs economists, how do they make a living, what's the service that they provide?
2:06:36And most investment analysts are part of a scammy structure, somewhere between something that is an unsound framework and an outright scam.
2:06:51Vlad CosteaI agree with that. So we, I guess we sidetracked a bit from the argument of the cult. But I want to ask you this about cults. Do you think it's useful that we are forming cults and trust systems and the social structures which decide who should be an authority to which we should listen and who should be ignored?
2:07:18Rahim TaghizadeganIt is. It's part of human nature. And so, on a fundamental level, we have to accept that. It was part of our ultra-social nature, which gives us the highest capacity for cooperation. And so it has a positive impact. But of course, it has a downside, it's a big trade-off and it's a big challenge.
2:07:50The thing that the Austrian economists were most interested in is the catallaxy, the extended order. It's where we trespass the small tribal trust relations, and we are capable to cooperate with foreigners. It's a very small part of history, but out of proportion important for the development of the human potential. And it's not entirely clear what's the cultural basis for that. So it can be very paradoxical. And I think that certain, of course, cultish elements were important. Of course, there was a social history and history of ideas, and even things that may seem to a secular person like superstitions have enhanced the capacity to cooperate and made it easier to cooperate with foreigners. And so I think it was certain elements, and we don't always see the alternative because we can't see alternative history.
2:09:06But of course, basically, a cult can be the seed of a culture. It's our capacity to have a very abstract layer which is not blood, so we can be related to other people who we are not related to by blood, and cults are part of that. It's a link. Religion comes from religio. It's a bond. So we are able to form bonds with other people that are not blood bonds. And that's crucial. And of course, you can form bonds for very evil undertakings, in particular organized violence. But yeah, that's the paradoxical challenge of the human nature.
2:09:53So I think it's better to understand and describe these things than to judge them. Of course, you can always attack other people because everyone else, of course, is in a cult but you. Everyone else is superstitious but you. And it can be a short-sighted rationalistic approach, followed then by a religion of reason, as we've seen in the wrong continental kind of enlightenment, which is basically arrogance. It's arrogance of people who think they've figured it all out and are able to design institutions from scratch, because everyone else is stupid and superstitious and only they know the truth.
2:10:36And usually it's a sign that you know very little if you are so sure about yourself that you want to impose it on other people. So I think, look at history, we have to respect those cultish bonds between people and see some positive in it, and still be aware of the challenge. And the challenge is it can limit our potential, because the tribe needs the other, and potentially the enemy. And if that limits your potential to cooperate, I think that's bad for human flourishing. But the other way of this kind of forced globalism, where everyone is alike, also is not a sustainable basis for cooperation.
2:11:22If everyone is alike, there's again no need for cooperation. That's utopistic. So it's somewhere in between. And it's something that we discover. It's not something that we can construct and design. And I won't say it's a problem, it's a challenge.
2:11:42Vlad CosteaYeah, the reason why I stuck around this community is that I very much believe in this component of trust minimization. I try as much as I can to verify everything that I can verify. And I even consider very seriously to start learning how to audit the code, as that's going to become a very useful skill in the future. And we can see that it's a very dynamic situation with the developers, and not only that, they tend to leave the project, especially since they start to get into legal issues, and some actors are suing them, and they don't really like this kind of situation where they can't really work without outside pressures.
2:12:29But much more than that, they also, I guess they get tired of the project. It's a thankless kind of work where they put a lot of effort into it. And as we have seen in the last couple of days, I don't want to name any names and point fingers, but there was a situation with a certain developer who inserted by accident an inflation bug in the code, and that was identified and fixed. It was not exploited, but still someone brought up that issue once again. Yeah. And it's terrible to work in this kind of situation and environment.
2:13:09And that's why I started seriously considering once again that I should educate myself to the point where I can verify everything that's going on, even if it's going to consume a lot of my time. That's where it actually makes sense, as if I develop a system where I must trust this one person. I mean, humans change over time. They can be corrupted, they can become lazy. They can have all sorts of situations in their lives which make them less reliable. So if you take a system that was meant to enable verification, even if that's very difficult, and you start relying too much on trust, it begins to defeat the purpose.
2:14:00That's what my biggest inner conflict is right now.
2:14:06Rahim TaghizadeganYeah, there are two issues. I totally agree that trust-minimizing technologies are a big hope in a setting where trust becomes more uncertain and harder to find. And also, the internet has contributed to that. We see ourselves compared to a global anonymous, too large screen, more or less, and that's not healthy. If you find all your identity within digital communities, which are not really, which can't offer everything that the community offers, you are in for a lot of disappointment. So I think if you are involved in Bitcoin, you shouldn't take it to the heart.
2:15:05If you don't like the style of someone. I've seen this exchange on Twitter. I disliked the way this developer was blamed for a fault. I understand the reaction. I understand how the drama is there, because it's human beings, they always have drama. I would advise not to take it too seriously, not to debate it too much, because it's an illusion that you can settle these things in the kind of Twitter debate. Twitter is really bad for that. And it's a substitute drama, like a soap opera entertainment.
2:15:45Yeah, where you can watch real-life drama happening, and it can feel really bad, but it feels only bad if you've linked so much of your identity to it that you feel underappreciated, that you have status competitions more or less, and you can't avoid it. And it's not something that's unique to Bitcoin or Bitcoiners, who don't exist as a tribe, and you'll always be disappointed. So most substitute tribes, which don't have a transcendental bond, which is linked to eternal life or something, to something really religious, do not survive for long, because you figure out over time that the bond is not strong enough.
2:16:34And you're disappointed because it's easy in good times. It's good to feel part of something, but once you stumble upon bad times and there's conflict and conflict of interests and all, you tend to be disappointed. So I think it's better to find your sense of belonging outside of digital platforms, even though it may feel great, as long as you go along with a certain vibe at the moment and you feel like your group is increasing and winning.
2:17:14But you end up disappointed if the tide turns. And so I think it's better to seek other and more physical ways for that kind of need for belonging. And I think there'll be very interesting experiments, hopefully in the future, of having communities of people living together in better ways and combining these kinds of more tribal identity and belonging with the cooperation with foreigners in the extended order.
2:17:53And that's somewhere the sweet spot where you don't belong with your identity needs on anonymous avatars on the internet, but you're still able to cooperate with foreigners and don't recluse yourself in a kind of monastery-like, homogenous community where you cut off all links with the outside world because you only seek the pure, very like-minded, who all eat the same and think the same and so on.
2:18:24So those are very old challenges, and it's usually in times of uncertainty, when the institutional order is breaking down and trust is breaking down, that you have all kinds of radicalized cults and identity questions come to the forefront. And I think there it pays to study history and look at that. And it's now in calm times when you study that it's really hard to grasp how people can be so crazy. But now it becomes more and more obvious that we don't change that much. We have the very same and similar apocalyptic strange ideas emerging as we had before the Great Wars.
2:19:09As we had during the turmoil before the French Revolution and the distortion of the monetary order back then, they have very similar polarizing tendencies among society. And there is a tradition within the Austrian school that really tries to understand this religious or theological aspect of political thought. In particular, Eric Voegelin, who was a member of the Mises Circle, studied political religions, looking at ideologies and how they are substitute religions. And it's a really profound analysis. And I think there's a lot to learn from that.
2:19:55And by trying to understand it first and try to understand your reactions and the identity games happening and where the drama comes from. And don't take it too seriously because it's not something exceptional. It's not something you can be surprised at, to say, "Oh, even Bitcoin has shown the drama. So who is to blame? Who wrote the wrong tweet?" If you accept it as something very natural, then I think it's easier to not take it too seriously and just go ahead and do what you can do. And if you think that you are able to audit code, that's great.
2:20:36That's wonderful. There's always a challenge with open source development. It's challenging. I think it's very promising. I tend to become more optimistic about it, even though against all the odds it's possible, and it's potentially even an alternative way of production and alternative way to socially create capital. So I think there's a lot to learn from the open source movement. I'd say it's not really a movement. It's like a discovery. It's a discovery that things work out even though you don't have a built-in direct monetization.
2:21:15And it's surprising how much open source software there is, and it's surprising how Bitcoin has been developed and maintained, even though there is drama and even though it's not fair, the distribution of the rewards in the sense. It's usually not the case that those people get the richest who contribute the best code or are best at auditing the code and so on, that you have to accept. Usually, the inventor is not the one who is enriched the most by the value created by new innovation. That's the way it is, that you have to accept. But still, it's amazing how it has worked out. And it wasn't obvious that it would work out without a formal organization, without a head that's behind it and can keep alive a certain ethos of it. So I think there's more positive to it, and of course, it can always fail.
2:22:17But I don't think it's certainly a sign of failure that there's drama, because there'll always be drama where human beings are involved. And it's not obvious that our focus now on these internet platforms is that healthy. Twitter is still the best, but still has very unhealthy signs. It's quite a distortion, and I think one has to realize that there's not something such as a public debate where everyone gets together and we figure out who's right, who has the best argument. That's not how debate works. Debate is something very intimate. It depends on trust.
2:23:01It depends on your capacity to be wrong when you talk to someone else and not obviously lose status or lose out in other ways and feel challenged and feel abused and so on. So it's generally an intimate and delicate order where debate happens, and I think this illusion that there's some kind of public debate where we argue it out and the right thing wins and those who are wrong have to be fought doesn't make sense.
2:23:36So it's better to look at Twitter for what it is, and it can be a useful tool if you don't take it too seriously and you don't seek all your identity and you don't want to be right and prove something and endlessly prove someone wrong on the internet. You know the meme. So, yeah. I think with the pandemic, this has increased a lot, this focus on just the digital, and that's not entirely healthy. So I think for most human beings, they need a more different kind of bonds than agreeing upon arguments or abstract arguments. Usually those are family bonds or community bonds, friendship, shared values and shared trade-offs and shared costs.
2:24:29Vlad CosteaYeah. You know, something else, so sorry for changing the topic so suddenly, but I wanted to ask you about Scholarium, which is your project. And I can't really do this because I'm not good at reading German, as the webpage is in German, and I suppose that the classes that you provide are also in German. But can you make a brief summary of what it is and what you're doing there?
2:24:55Rahim TaghizadeganYes, about 12 years ago, I think I realized that the institution of the university is not working, and in particular in the social sciences. It's too corrupted and it has an entirely different function now than what the name suggests. And the name of the university comes from Universitas Magistrorum et Scholarium. Universitas is a community of the teachers and the learners. It has become just a community of the teachers, and this has become a community of the certifiers.
2:25:33It's a kind of cartel to certify legitimate status, which is quite important for the functioning of the institutional structure, but I think it has outlived its usefulness and it has, in a sense, become corrupted. And this idea of a community of learners, of people trying to find other people who want to understand first, who really want to advance in their understanding of the world around them, which is a tradition that's very important in history, but always a small phenomenon, from the old academia in ancient Greece. And then of course the autonomous cities having their autonomous community of scholars and people interested in this tradition of systematically thinking about big questions and doing that in the written form. So I wanted to create a space for that again and bring back this particular tradition of the social sciences, which I think part of it is the Austrian School of Economics.
2:26:42I think it's a larger undertaking of a general Austrian Enlightenment, in a very different sense to the French Enlightenment. Most of my writing and teaching is in German. It's my native language. If you really want to understand things, of course it's helpful to use the language it's written in. You can read the original texts and you can be much more precise. And there are advantages in the German language. So of course, nowadays, almost everything is written in English, but there is a niche. And German is still, I think, an important language for this kind of thought.
2:27:25So it's a traditional language it's written in. And then of course everyone tries to find his niche. The Austrian School of Economics emigrated to the United States more or less, so it has become a new US Austrian school. It's a bit different. The mentality and culture is a bit different. The context is very different. I'm very thankful to my American friends for having preserved this tradition. I try, with the culture I know and can read and can understand, to bring back this spirit of the peak of the Austrian school, which I think was in the Mises Circle.
2:28:05And it's this interdisciplinary, very intimate effort to understand a very complex society in crisis in a value-neutral way, in a very realistic, down-to-earth way. And that's the bond of this tradition, I think, and I think it's still quite relevant for today, and it's getting more relevant because it becomes obvious, the similarities to the pre-war society or pre-First World War society, with the challenges and distortions in the old Europe. And so I started a small institution with a colleague of mine, and it has grown organically.
2:28:54And when I started, there was no one teaching the Austrian School of Economics. It completely died out in Austria. I was lucky to find the last people seeing it as its own tradition and seeing its relevance and still writing and teaching about it. Oddly enough, those two people were German-speaking. So Mises had two most important students: the one in the US, Murray Rothbard, and the one in Europe, Hayek, who then at the end of his life again was teaching in Europe. And Rothbard's most important student and successor was Hans-Hermann Hoppe, a German.
2:29:40And Hayek's most important student, in the sense who saw the Austrian school as a tradition, because most students of Hayek thought the Austrian school disappeared, so they moved on to mainstream economics or did something else, and Hayek also moved away from economics more or less. He had a student, a German entrepreneur called Roland Baader, and Roland Baader and Hans-Hermann Hoppe became my teachers. And they're both German speaking, oddly enough, by chance, I'd say. And so I try to bring back the tradition as a closed tradition and bring back what's unique about the tradition. And since then, I've always been teaching at universities and I've been quite frustrated about universities.
2:30:34I still teach at universities just to see how it's going and to have contact to students. But the more interesting teaching is of course in the Scholarium, where I can do it as I think it should be done, and not follow a curriculum and not do stupid tests, and have people who are deeply interested in really understanding and not just getting a certificate. And that's what I do in the Scholarium. Small institute, but Austria is a small country.
2:31:10It has always sustained itself, always cash flow positive, never accepted any subsidies, which may seem obvious, but in Austria it is not that obvious. Everything is subsidized. So I try to have this kind of safe space for really trying to understand society as it is and trying to bring or connect to this tradition in a different time with odd similarities to our time of today. And I think it has a quite positive impact on the world that is underrated.
2:31:48Vlad CosteaSo how does one sign up to Scholarium? What do you have to do?
2:31:53Rahim TaghizadeganAh, yeah, it's quite challenging, so it's not very open. I mean, of course, one can disagree about the way to disseminate knowledge. The task of a scholar is not to disseminate knowledge, so it's quite self-selective. You enroll for a study program, usually you pay a price for that, and you become part of a self-selected group of people. It's very expensive for Austria, but still there's a challenge. If you really want it, you need to want to do it. And this self-selection, of course, gives a very high quality of participants.
2:32:34And because I think profoundly, that's not my task, dissemination of knowledge. Other people are doing it better. My task is trying to understand and connect to this tradition of understanding. And that's best done at a very high level of intimate reflection, where you're moderate about your thoughts and where they lead you, but you can be very open. So I don't usually market it. It's really, people need to really want it, and then they are right. And so you've got to figure it out. And for now, the program is only in German.
2:33:19Vlad CosteaOkay, so if you're German and you're interested in enrolling to another, less conventional education program about Austrian economics, and not only that, all sorts of interdisciplinary social science topics that might help you understand a lot better the world in which you find yourself, I guess you should check out scholarium.at. AT stands for Austria.
2:33:45Rahim TaghizadeganYes.
2:33:47Vlad CosteaOkay, so that's basically your main job.
2:33:54Rahim TaghizadeganWell, it's always hard to tell. Yeah, it's a bit of my main focus. I have quite a lot of other projects and sometimes they take over more time. I usually also have teaching positions at university and I have entrepreneurial projects on the side. I've always been, I'm also an engineer and entrepreneur, so I've always had some projects on the side and sometimes they're more passive and sometimes they take over a more active role. Now the largest part of my activity is actually entrepreneurial. I'm working with investing and founding, I'd say, Bitcoin Citadels, which is really creating communities for people with families to live together.
2:34:40Not exclusively, but have a kind of safe space for people with some alignment in their preferences. And the particular challenge of living in Europe under the regulatory uncertainty, if you have a family with children and are looking for alternatives to that. So it's a very challenging project because the uncertainty is increasing. So it's really trying to figure out how by combining various safe locations we can provide an alternative way of living that makes sense for a certain group of people that have similar challenges and are looking for a safe and positive environment for raising a family within the uncertain framework of today.
2:35:39Vlad CosteaSounds interesting. So, Rahim, I'm not sure if I have any more questions. This was a very long interview, and I hope that most people will get to this point. If you do, then leave a message there, say something like: "I survived until the end."
2:35:56Rahim Taghizadegan? "I survived until the end."
2:35:59Vlad CosteaYeah, that's a good one. Or something even more random like "I like cheese." If you say "I like cheese," it means that you survived until the end. So how can people follow you outside of the Scholarium project?
2:36:16Rahim TaghizadeganSorry, again?
2:36:17Vlad CosteaHow can people follow you outside of the Scholarium project?
2:36:18Rahim TaghizadeganTwitter. Scholarium_AT. Here I mostly tweet in English. I'm not very active, but I share some thoughts in English. Maybe 30% in German and 70% in English, something like that.
2:36:40Vlad CosteaOkay. Thank you very much for your time during this interview. And I hope that we're gonna talk more as we get more topics and more stuff happens and the world becomes even more unpredictable and we try to find something that makes sense.
2:36:58Rahim TaghizadeganYeah, it was a pleasure to talk to you. Thanks for the conversation and happy to continue in person at the next possible opportunity. Thanks, good night. Greetings from Vienna.
2:37:10Vlad CosteaI'll see you at another conference.
2:37:30Ad voiceoverAfter Mt. Gox collapsed, that was really the precipice of me saying, right, this has to change. We need a totally transparent exchanging system and base it on gold instead of fiat.
2:37:47Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the hard money exchange which helps you beat inflation with instant swaps between the best stores of value known to man, gold and Bitcoin. Unlike most exchanges, Vaultoro understands the importance of transparency and security. All gold holdings are secured in top-tier Swiss private vaults and fully insured against theft, fire and more. Maximize your purchasing power today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. This is not financial advice, but gold has been humankind's most reliable store of value in the last 6,000 years. Do your own research. Use promotion code TAKEOVER for a one-time bonus of one gram of gold for the first 50 new customers buying gold with Bitcoin.
2:38:39Are you concerned that your friends, neighbors, or KYC exchange might know how much Bitcoin you own? It is time to take your financial privacy seriously with Wasabi Wallet, a free and open source wallet solution which makes use of mega CoinJoins to mix your coins with those of hundreds of other strangers. Thanks to the groundbreaking WabiSabi engine, your coins get divided in smaller untraceable units, which grant you great anonymity for both hodling and spending. Download Wasabi Wallet 2.0 today at wasabiwallet.io and take advantage of the mega CoinJoins. It's free and it's open source, so don't trust, verify.
2:39:54What are you going to wear when Bitcoin hits $1 million? The same old $20 t-shirt? Try Maison Mauchi, the designer clothes made in Paris by Bitcoiners for Bitcoiners. They're not your average mass-produced sweatshop clothes. Mauchi will ask for your measurements and tailor every piece of clothing according to the shape of your body, so you always look and feel great in your t-shirt, hoodie or dress. It's all made in France by real artisans who also happen to be Bitcoiners, which is why Maison Mauchi only accepts Bitcoin as payment for their clothes. Get a Maison Mauchi t-shirt or hoodie today. It might even help you find a girlfriend.
2:41:05And once you do get a girlfriend, you can also buy her a Maison Mauchi dress. Stop having fun looking poor and check out MaisonMauchi.com.
2:41:05================================================================================ Production notes: Remote video interview in English (guest is a native German speaker in Vienna, recorded around 9 August 2022), opening with a music intro and containing three blocks of Vlad's sponsor reads for Voltoro, Wasabi Wallet and Maison Mauchi, with Voltoro's blocks opening on a testimonial voiceover clip. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 10 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (214 chunks) and 51 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 2 of 2 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed intro music notes and "© BF-WATCH TV 2021"; fixed Taghizadegan, Mallorca, Eric Voskuil, Misesian, stock-to-flow, cypherpunks, "talked" (not "taught"), "chosen"/"trade-offs" mishearings; restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (00:04:29 value-neutral passage, "ossification" sentence, layer 2 sentence, liquidity sentence, "legitimate cover", "Bitcoin may be stopped", "much harder to understand"); split Rahim's "Thanks a lot" and "Yes. Yes, well..." from Vlad turns; Guest A → Rahim Taghizadegan; split long monologues; Restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (tainted address sentence, "shift of cards", "people on the internet", "care less... becoming worse", dollar/non-dollar assets passage, political outcomes, stablecoins, Bitcoin-money passage, "would have told you in 2009", economic decisions, "other digital assets don't"); removed hallucinations "Welcome to the episode of the show", "I'm a bit of a fan of...", "Thank you."; fixed Tornado Cash, Ethereum, Wasabi Wallet, Samourai, JoinMarket, fiat, Bitcoin's, stablecoins, "war purposes", "regulation", "risk-on"; Guest A → Rahim Taghizadegan; split long monologues; Speakers fixed (Guest A/continuation → Rahim Taghizadegan; Vaultoro testimonial → Ad voiceover); removed "Commercial Break", "breasts.", "Thank you." hallucinations; reordered Maison Mauchi ad lines; restored dropped text (Vaultoro "Maximize your purchasing power", WabiSabi engine line, ECB/Southern European treasuries passage, "everything that's not a liability" passage, "It's not only banknotes", "You can't know right now", "I think already 10, 15 years"); fixed Vaultoro, Maison Mauchi, hodling, coinjoins, trust layer, actors, flippening, BIP39, "can't take them with you"; Relabelled Guest A/"Episode:" as Rahim Taghizadegan. Restored dropped speech from the second ASR and Scribe (00:52:03, 00:55:47, 00:56:35, 01:01:33, 01:03:10-01:03:23, 01:05:20-01:05:44), including Vlad's "Yes." as a separate Rahim interjection and Vlad's "Yeah" at 00:57:46. Removed the hallucinations "The following is a video of the video", "Thanks." and "of the world" junk, and the "Episode:" tokens. Fixed CBDC, smuggler, LibertyCon, Lightning, relic, three books, Goethe's Faust II, Hayek students, Roland Baader and would/will. Moved the boundary "Yes," and "Yeah" between speakers. Added "not" at 01:01:41 for sense; Removed hallucinations "The book is available on Amazon, Apple, and Google Play" and "Thank you."; restored dropped speech (30,000 books, money emerges sentence, "like kind of just following along", "Bitcoin can be both", "more male phenomenon"); fixes: treatises, adapt, Schelling point, attractor, preferences, barter, paternalistic, shitposting/trolling, Bitcoin maxi, wealth creation, anew; split "Yes, trust is" to Rahim; relabelled Guest A as Rahim Taghizadegan; Speakers: guest turns labelled Rahim Taghizadegan, 01:30:55 Guest A → Rahim; Vaultoro testimonial as Ad voiceover. Removed hallucinations ("Thank you.", "Episode:", "I'm a bit of