S14 E9: Jameson Lopp on Casa, Self Custody & Bitcoin Maximalism
Search this conversation
0:00Ad voiceoverYou're listening to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast, the Bitcoin podcast for OGs and intermediaries. Make sure you subscribe, leave a comment, and like this episode. Also read the new BTCTKVR magazine. This episode is sponsored by Wasabi Wallet, Cryptosteel, ShopinBit and Satodime. Thank you for listening.
1:08Vlad CosteaHello there, and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad, your Bitcoin influencer's influencer, and I'm live here today with Jameson Lopp, who is the CTO of Casa and has been with the company for about four years now, no, five years. And I haven't interviewed him since he started at Casa. And it's pretty interesting that we get to talk after all this time, after so much stuff has happened. And yeah, welcome, Jameson.
1:37Jameson LoppGood to be back.
1:39Vlad CosteaWell, technically you're not back, because previously you were on the Crypto Insider whatever interviews. Now you're on the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. So technically it's your first appearance, and it's sweaty in here. It's super hot. I could not turn on a fan because it affects the quality of the audio. So if I start sweating just like Richard Nixon during his debate with JFK, then sorry. Well, we all have to make sacrifices. Well, speaking of sacrifices, Jameson, I think that since you left BitGo, it became a much bigger company. Now they custody the funds of MicroStrategy, if I'm not mistaken, and possibly also El Salvador. I heard a rumor. Do you ever regret not staying with BitGo?
2:28Jameson LoppNo, I mean, you know, I left for a number of reasons, but one of the big ones was just that my sleep was being affected. You know, I was running a lot of the infrastructure there. And as we started to expand and added support for many new networks, it ran into a lot of new edge cases and issues with basically maintaining the complexity. So I was kind of there when we had added support for a lot of things, but we hadn't necessarily grown that part of the team commensurately to make it so that you could spread the load more.
3:12But no, they seem to be doing well, and I certainly wish them the best, and I have my incentives to want them to continue to do well. But I kind of took it as an opportunity to pivot and continue to use a lot of the knowledge that I had gained while I was there, but apply it to more of a retail individual focus. So I felt like BitGo did a pretty good job kind of raising the bar for enterprise hot wallet security type of stuff. I felt like there was room to try to do the same thing on the individual side, and that's really what we've been focusing on for the past five years at Casa, is helping individuals help themselves and be their own bank.
4:10Vlad CosteaYeah, it's very hard for me to not notice that there is a certain similarity. It seems like BitGo does multisig custody for companies, corporations, nation states and whatever, and Casa does multisig for individuals. So you're not quite 100% custodians, but you do hold some keys and you are more like enablers of inheritance or something. So to some degree, you're doing the same job, but for a different type of clients.
4:39Jameson LoppYeah, you know, also, as I was leaving, BitGo had already spent the past year or two ramping up on the legal side to also offer full custody services. And so I think that's a pretty decent chunk of their business now, where they're actually taking custody on behalf of a lot of whales and enterprises. And that was something that was less interesting to me, though obviously there's demand, there's a market for it. And I wanted to continue pushing forward in what I believe is the harder path, which is getting people to take responsibility and take custody and do what I think is best, not only for themselves, but for the entire ecosystem.
5:28It's kind of pushing back against the looming threat of convenience that I believe is a systemic threat. And it's a buzzword, but it does create this centralizing force of resulting in more of the value in the ecosystem being concentrated in a smaller number of hands, which I think is just bad in general for all of us.
5:57Vlad CosteaYeah, I very much agree with you. And I was going to ask you, what's new with Casa? Because when the company first launched, it was super cool. I remember Jeremy Welch when he was the CEO. He was on all the podcasts, except for mine for some reason. But he was on all the podcasts and he was talking about this cool device, the Casa Node, that was supposed to enable sovereignty very easily. I give credit to Casa for popularizing the idea of node in a box. I think companies today like Umbrel and Nodl and RaspiBlitz owe their success to the fact that Casa popularized that concept.
6:32And I am an owner of the first generation Casa Node, which was the Raspberry Pi 3, which wasn't very good, not very slick. It was in the next year that the Raspberry Pi 4 launched. And you also created a revision that was short-lived. And what's new? Because I think that was the coolest phase of Casa. The first year when you had the node and when you had this plan to renew the hardware of your customers every year or every couple of years. And then you decided to go full software support and provide multisigs for customers.
7:10And to some people, I guess, I kind of lost interest in the company after that point. But obviously you have had clients and you were able to scale the operations and grow past that point. So what's been going on with Casa? What's new?
7:25Jameson LoppYeah, you know, I think a lot of people for whatever reason, well, I think it's due to popularity, but a lot of people actually misunderstand the timeline of Casa. And that actually in 2018, we initially launched with our multisig self-custody product. Now, at the time, we took kind of a Tesla approach where it was actually $10,000 a year, you know, ultra high premium whale client only type of product. And then over time, we've gone down market. Now, it was, I guess, a year, year and a half after that was when we launched the node.
8:07So, you know, the idea was really, you know, Casa as a full stack self-sovereignty type of service. And, you know, I think we did successfully make it a lot easier for people to run Bitcoin and Lightning nodes, especially back then. Lightning was even more of a beta type of product than it is today. There were a lot more rough edges. And what we really found, and kind of what people really want us to explain, is like, why did that product not last? And it was a culmination of several factors.
8:45One of them, which if you look at the sort of node in a box history, Casa was not the first and we certainly won't be the last company to offer this type of product. There were at least two or three. I know that Bitnodes actually had a device for a few years that they offered. And then there was, I think, Bitseed. I think John Light was a part of that project for a few years. And what you find is normally these node in a box projects, they last for a few years and then they tend to sort of die off.
9:24And there's a few reasons for that. One is it's a very low margin business, right? So, you know, you're typically using some sort of Raspberry Pi or similar mini computer device as the hardware, probably going to run you $200 to $300 minimum just for the base components off the shelf. Then you're trying to build some nice software and interface that you can throw onto that to make it easier for people to use. So, you know, how much are you actually feasibly going to be able to charge for it?
10:06You know, once it starts going above $500, the size of the market of people that are willing to pay that is vanishingly small, you know, probably fewer than 10,000 people total, and it's mostly hobbyists and tinkerers. So we ended up bumping up against this total size of the market issue. You know, we are a venture-backed company, so we are seeking growth. And so when you see that your product kind of stalls out and hits a wall, and there doesn't seem to be much more room for growth, that's always a red flag.
10:45Another thing, and this is similar to and related to the cost of the margin that I was talking about, is it's obviously the cost is not just with the hardware. There's the software engineering costs to make something that's nice and usable for less technical people. And then for us, one of the bigger surprises was the cost on the support side. And one of the big reasons for that is, and I've actually given entire presentations about this, basically, when you are deploying hardware into unknown environments and unknown networks, there's a huge surface area of unanticipated sort of edge cases and things that end up going wrong.
11:36And that combined with the fact that we had no insight or control over these devices made it very difficult for us to get debugging information, in many cases, to help people. So, you know, worst case scenario, if someone couldn't even access the device over their network to get debug logs off of it, then it's like we have to walk people through figuring out how to hook a monitor and keyboard up to it and start running command line instructions. And, you know, it gets really gnarly, especially when you're trying to sell something to less technical people who probably aren't familiar with doing that type of stuff.
12:19So, you know, the short version is it just is a great idea. It's very difficult to pull that off and scale it as a profitable business.
12:31Vlad CosteaYeah, I remember at one point you were even giving rewards for people keeping their nodes online, and there was this application or something that was sending them Lightning rewards. And I think it was too ahead of its time. This was in early 2019, if I'm not mistaken. And I remember being super excited about the Casa Node and thinking about all the possibilities. I remember Jack Dorsey getting one and publishing a picture of it. And at the time, he was still the CEO of Twitter. And that was a big deal because he was not fully involved in Bitcoin.
13:03He was just dipping his toes. So it was a huge deal at the time, the Casa Node. That's kind of unfortunate that I think the first iteration was not super reliable. And I wasn't sure, so half the time, I wasn't sure if it's loading or if it's stuck. And I think that was the biggest issue in terms of user experience. And also I remember taking it out of the box and it had this sheet of paper that was saying go to start.casa.com or something like that.
13:32But in reality, the URL was different. So by the time the box got shipped, you had changed the website for your documentation and stuff. So you tried very hard. So I can give credit for all of the Apple packaging and presentation and the fact that you made it so easy and convenient. And you basically gave birth to an entire industry of node-in-a-box devices, which existed prior to Casa, but it wasn't this big. You encouraged a lot of people to continue this pursuit and try to create more efficient node-in-a-box concepts.
14:13Jameson LoppWe were basically trying to take our ethos of improving usability for Bitcoin tooling. So running nodes, especially Lightning stuff, and all the complexities around channel management and whatnot, it can be overwhelming for people. So the idea, which is what we started off with self-custody, is the promise of self-custody is quite great, but to do it right and to avoid all of the potential footguns that people can basically get themselves in trouble with due to ignorance, it necessitates a much more friendly user experience really to guide people down the right path.
15:00And so we were just sort of applying that same type of approach to nodes. But of course, there's mountains and mountains of more complexity when you have this additional piece of networked hardware that you have to manage. As it stands today, we still have to deal with some complexity and some things that are outside of our control, even with our self-custody service. This is by design. Casa is architected to eliminate single points of failure. So that means we don't want to have a threshold of keys that could be used to either prevent someone from spending their money or to spend their money without their consent.
15:42And so as a result, that means people are using key management devices from other companies, other vendors that we have no control over. So this does add a certain level of complexity and sort of ongoing maintenance where we have to make sure that everything that we're doing is staying in sync with the rest of the hardware and firmware and the whole software stack that our clients are using. This is a constantly moving target.
16:13Vlad CosteaYeah, I understand that. And before I ask you the next question, let me play an advertisement.
16:24Ad voiceoverWasabi Wallet is unfairly private. It's the most advanced and most used Bitcoin privacy wallet with half a million downloads across Windows, macOS and Linux, as well as thousands of fresh new bitcoins getting mixed every month. Wasabi makes use of the new generation WabiSabi engine to create mega CoinJoins, thus mixing your bitcoins with those of hundreds of other users. For amounts lower than 0.01 BTC and remixes, you pay no coordination fee. Even if you don't use CoinJoins, Wasabi Wallet has a native Tor integration and downloads block filters to help you keep your network level and public key privacy. Download Wasabi Wallet for free today at wasabiwallet.io and experience the future of Bitcoin privacy.
17:17Vlad CosteaWhat do you think about Wasabi, Jameson?
17:21Jameson LoppIt's interesting. I don't really do much coin joining myself. I have a sort of multifaceted approach to Bitcoin privacy, depending on my needs. But I'm somewhat reluctant to CoinJoin at least any funds I have that I might want to send to an exchange, because I don't want my centralized exchange accounts to get shut down. Really, the one time that I would use CoinJoin is if I need to make a payment that's large enough that I don't have enough non-KYC Bitcoin. And so if I'm doing that payment and just sending it to someone, then sending it through a CoinJoin first, just so that they couldn't see or try to figure out through on-chain analysis what the rest of my wallet looks like.
18:21That's the primary use case that I have for it. But of course, there's many reasons why people may want to be joining their coins.
18:30Vlad CosteaYeah, in my case, I receive donations and I have no idea where they come from. And I don't want to know where they come from. So maybe some may argue that it's worse if I CoinJoin them, if these donations are coming from exchanges. But I don't have the time to check. I don't want to know. And I can move the coins between wallets a few times so that blockchain analysis that's being employed by exchanges will think that the coins have changed owner or something. But anyway, I was going to ask you about Casa.
19:03And I think the most common question that you get from people who are not certain if they want to use their service is why would anyone use Casa instead of setting up Electrum in five minutes with a couple of hardware wallets? What is the benefit?
19:20Jameson LoppWell, there are several. For one, Casa is not just a wallet. The vast majority of wallets out there are, of course, free to use, sort of a do-it-yourself type of thing. And that's great. I think if people are sufficiently knowledgeable and sophisticated, then rolling your own is certainly feasible if you put in enough time and effort. But Casa, one of our things, we come with a pretty slick mobile app that really guides people through the whole process. So they don't necessarily have to know all the intricacies of what they're doing to both set up the multisig and then to maintain it and have backups.
20:07So one particular point that comes up a lot with regard to multisig: we're trying to set these up to help people put themselves in a very robust position so that they can make mistakes. So that if anything goes wrong, because something probably will go wrong over a long enough timeframe, that that itself is not triggering a catastrophic loss. And one thing, for example, that comes up that is easy for people to not understand if they don't understand how multisig works under the hood is actually somewhat similar to a problem that I see people get into even with single-sig, which is not understanding what's required to actually recover your wallet if you should lose keys or data.
20:58So when you have a multisig setup, yeah, sure, you can create a 2-of-3 or a 3-of-5 or whatever. And if you lose one of those keys, you know, you can still spend the money. But that is assuming that you still have the wallet itself constructed and stored somewhere. So basically, if you lose any of the public keys that go to that multisig, that could actually be a catastrophic loss. So we could go into the details why, but basically, when you're spending from a multisig, you have to provide all of the public key information.
21:40Which means, you know, if you had, let's say, Electrum or Specter or Sparrow or whatever set up, and it was a 2-of-3, and you lost one of those keys, if you did not also have the wallet descriptor, or basically all of the public information with the extended public keys, the derivation paths, the script type, these are all things that are required to be able to reconstruct and then spend from that multisig wallet, then, unfortunately, you would not be able to actually spend your money. So one of the benefits that you get here is Casa basically helps you with automatic backups, not only with one of your keys, which gets this automatic encrypted 2-of-2 type of cloud backup.
22:33It also inherently backs up your public information as well. And we send you a copy of it at the time that you set up your wallet, but you can also get another copy of it whenever you want. As long as Casa doesn't go away... Even if Casa does go away, we have provided people with what we call sovereign recovery instructions, which includes that information. And as I said, the whole idea is to get rid of single points of failure. So we have an entire website devoted to this, of basically everything that could go wrong.
23:15The service and support is another big aspect of it. Like I said, a lot of these wallets out there, they are basically do it yourself. You might get community level support. So whoever is volunteering to help out on a forum or email list or whatever. What are you paying for at Casa? What you're really paying for, especially at the premium tiers, is a level of customer service where you can actually call us on the phone and talk to a real human, set up a video chat if you want and get hands-on personalized support, not just random tier one email support where, especially if it's a bull market going on, you might not get a response for weeks.
24:07Vlad CosteaYeah, I was showing the page that shows the membership types. You have a free plan, you have a standard one and the premium one. There seems to be quite a gap between them. The free one, of course, is zero dollars. And all you get is, I guess, access to the wallet. And with the standard one, it's not the one that gives you free hardware wallets, right? It's the premium one.
24:34Jameson LoppCorrect. Yeah, the standard is, it's more of a do-it-yourself with email support. I believe our SLA turnaround time for emails is generally one to two business days, though it's normally on the order of hours, especially right now, since things are pretty quiet. And like I said, the premium plan, yeah, you get a nicer onboarding package and more handholding. But what you're really paying for is both responsive and personalized support. So if you need something, if there's an emergency, you can literally contact us within a matter of minutes, at least during the business week. And we have emergency sort of 24/7 lines as well.
25:36Vlad CosteaYeah, I think it's certainly interesting what's going on here. And I noticed that Ethereum has a central place on your website where you can learn what it is. So how did that happen? How did you switch from a Bitcoin-only company, which was also planning to support Litecoin on the node in the beginning because of some investor, I guess. And then you dropped it and said you're Bitcoin only. And then you said, let's also add Ethereum. And I guess this is also a nice segue into your article about Bitcoin maximalism and its origins.
26:11Jameson LoppWell, so once again, this is an interesting long history that I think a lot of people have missed, mainly because, you know, we were so small in 2018, 2019. When we first rolled out the multisig app in 2018, we actually had beta Ethereum support in the mobile app. But we ended up removing it because we just didn't get much demand for it at the time. I was trying to remember about the Litecoin stuff. I don't even remember what we said or didn't say around Litecoin stuff.
26:52Obviously, nothing ever happened with Litecoin support. Didn't have a ton of demand for that and still don't today. But then what we saw happening over the past couple of years is more demand, you know, some from current customers. But really, a lot of this is driven, of course, by our sales team. And, you know, they take notes whenever we lose a deal. And we started seeing a pattern. And the pattern was basically, look, I'm invested in a number of different assets. And especially if you don't have Ethereum and Ethereum-related assets, then your service is not particularly helpful for me, because then I have to go find a similar service somewhere else.
27:36You know, people want convenience. And as I said at the very beginning, you know, we're kind of fighting against this convenience-as-centralizing force. And so it was pretty upsetting to see a number of people saying, you know what, in terms of convenience, the easiest thing for me to do with regard to custody is to literally just give it to, you know, a trusted third party custodian, because they support absolutely everything. And, you know, I won't have to go around maintaining, you know, multiple accounts, multiple wallets, and so on and so forth.
28:15So this, for us, of course, has been market-driven, based on what people are telling us they want. And, of course, you know, as expected, we get some pushback from people who completely hate the idea of Ethereum, want nothing to do with it. And those folks are, of course, welcome not to use it. You know, we have a toggle in the app, you can turn it on, you can turn it off, you can do what you want with it. You can use Casa for Bitcoin only, you could use it for Ethereum only. We do anticipate adding stablecoin support before too long, because that's really the next greatest thing that has the most demand.
29:00Vlad CosteaInteresting. And something that I wanted to ask you before we get into Bitcoin maximalism is, I guess, a question that you don't get too often. What happens if, for example, I set up a premium account, and I paid $2,100 for one year, and then I stopped paying? Are you going to throw away the keys? Or what's going to happen?
29:20Jameson LoppNo, well, you know, you hold the keys. So because of the way that it's architected, Casa can't do anything, you know, your money just sits there. From the application standpoint, what would happen is that the app goes into basically what we call withdraw-only mode. And so, you know, if your membership has expired, the only thing the app allows you to do is to completely sweep the wallet and send the funds to an external address.
29:54Vlad CosteaOkay, that's less evil or harsh than I expected. Like, usually, there are these asterisks, like lawyer mentions, that, okay, if you don't pay, we're gonna shut off this function, and you have to pay again. So basically, what's the incentive for someone to continue, other than receiving support? Because you set up the customer, and then they can just keep on benefiting from that setup without paying for renewal.
30:26Jameson LoppYeah, that's a good point. This is actually something we should probably hit on more often. Well, there's a couple of things. For one, of course, you would lose access to the Casa recovery key. So if things started to go wrong with your other keys, and you got down to a point where you needed a signature from the Casa recovery key, I think that would be a big incentive for you to renew with us. The other thing is that, you know, multisig is a more complex type of setup.
30:57And one thing that I've certainly learned over the years is that it's not a set-it-and-forget-it type of operation. And I kind of hinted at this earlier, where I was talking about how there are, you know, these additional levels of complexity with managing the hardware and the software libraries, you know, basically all of the pieces of hardware and software that you're using as constituent pieces of your distributed multisig wallet. And the short version is that this is why one of the core pieces of functionality that we've had in the app from the very beginning is what we call health checks.
31:39And that's basically, you know, every six months or so, you should probably be interacting with each of these keys. And a health check in our app, basically, it's, you know, doing a Bitcoin signed message. So it's just proving that you still have the ability to cryptographically sign with your keys. You don't necessarily have to sign a transaction and move money around. Though, what happens in the app is that, you know, if you have signed with a key for any reason, whether it's just a message or for a transaction, then the timer kind of starts.
32:22And if you go six months and you haven't done any sort of activity, then we start annoying you with some warnings, saying, hey, you should probably do a health check just to make sure everything is good. And so what am I getting to? Well, you know, we have had some tenuous situations with some customers over the years who didn't do their health checks, and went, you know, two, three, four years without ever touching any of their keys. And then, you know, they come back after many years, and they start realizing, oh, all my firmware is out of date, and it's not compatible with this software library, or maybe even the firmware is so out of date that I need to upgrade it past a version at which it wipes the key off of the hardware due to some security vulnerability that the firmware update is patching.
33:15So, you know, basically, there are things that can go wrong if you're not staying on top of the health of your key set. You know, this is one of the trade-offs where multisig is more complex, it requires a bit more touch points. But if you're staying on top of it, you end up with a more robust distributed setup. But it certainly requires more work than just putting 12 words on a metal plate and burying it in the ground for 30 years.
33:45Vlad CosteaYep. I guess I have another question for you regarding the difference between multisig and Shamir as described by SLIP-39. But before that, let me play another ad. And just for the record, the owner of this company is mad at your review. And we can also talk about your metal plate reviews. But let me share.
34:05Ad voiceoverCryptosteel is the original Bitcoin cold storage backup, and it's been innovating self-custody since 2013. Designed and manufactured in Europe from the finest and most resistant stainless steel, the Cryptosteel cassette and the Cryptosteel Capsule are industry standards. These cold storage devices are made to resist house fires, extreme floods and physical shocks. You can also use Cryptosteel to store your important passwords, BIP39 passphrase or Nostr private keys. Buy your Cryptosteel today from cryptosteel.com and use promo code BTCTKVR to get a 10% discount. Cryptosteel, secure your Bitcoin like an OG.
34:51Vlad CosteaI hope you like the Pump It Loomdart girls. Oh, you're muted. Sorry.
35:01Jameson LoppYeah, I can't say I'm familiar with them. But that's very professional.
35:07Vlad CosteaOh, it's an old meme. You should look up Pump It Loomdart. It's pretty insane. Basically, someone, after I posted this, someone accused me of promoting prostitution. And I told him that I apologize, the next time I'm going to get real prostitutes. But anyway, where was I getting? Yeah, SLIP-39 versus multisig. How would you describe the difference? And why should anyone still use multisig?
35:35Jameson LoppYeah, I mean, you know, I think Shamir secret sharing can make sense for backups. It's not something that I think you would want to use on an ongoing basis. And we do have a lengthy blog post, I think from 2019 or 2020, where we compare and contrast some of the issues with secret sharing. One difference is that with Shamir secret sharing, you basically end up having to reconstitute all the keys in a single location. So, you know, it really is designed for basically single signature setups. We're not a big fan of single signature setups, or whenever you have a threshold of signing keys in one geographic location or on one device or whatever, just because that means, you know, if something has gone wrong there, it's a potential catastrophic loss.
36:40You also don't have auditability in terms of, you know, let's say you had a Shamir secret sharing scheme backup, and then one day you wake up and all of your money is gone. You know, how do you figure out what was compromised? With Shamir secret sharing, this reconstitution is done completely offline and privately. And you have no way of knowing which shares were actually used to reconstitute the key. So one of the nice things about multisig is that, you know, in the event that something goes wrong, you can at least have some auditability, where it's literally on the blockchain, where you can see, you know, which keys were used to sign a given transaction.
37:37It's also, you know, this may change, but at least for the time being, it's trickier to modify, in the sense that, you know, we have this concept of key rotation in Casa. And that's basically that, you know, you're not married to any one of your keys in your key set. You should consider them somewhat expendable and, you know, assume that they could be compromised. Something could go wrong.
38:03But if something does go wrong, it's quite simple in our app to just tap on that key and mark it as compromised and buy another hardware device off the shelf, and we'll walk you through rotating your funds over, basically swapping out that key. You know, if you want to change one of your shards in the Shamir secret sharing setup, or you want to, you know, change the sort of M of N, like the threshold and how distributed it is, then you basically have to start all over from the beginning and, you know, change out all of those pieces of the backup.
38:44That's just a few things off the top of my head. But, you know, basically, I think it's a bit more rigid, whereas multisig is a bit more flexible.
38:56Vlad CosteaWhen you said that the public information displayed on the blockchain can change, you referred to Taproot multisig, right?
39:05Jameson LoppWell, really, any type of multisig that you're doing on the blockchain, you know, all of those public keys that are being used and all of the relevant signatures, you can see which public keys they correspond to.
39:25Vlad CosteaOkay, now let's get into, before we get to Bitcoin maximalism, let's get into your views on metal plates that you publish, I guess, every year. You look into new products. You also do benchmarks with hardware wallets, which I think are interesting. And they remind me of the computer magazines I used to buy back in the day to see tests and benchmarks and all sorts of parameters that I can compare, except that you take them to some extreme levels and you even smash them. And try all sorts of situations that maybe are not realistic, but can happen maybe in one in 10 million cases.
40:04So what inspires you to pursue that methodology? And also, why did you give Cryptosteel a bad review? Because you did not break it, you just bent it.
40:16Jameson LoppOkay. Well, for one, because I get questions from people saying, what's the best metal backup? And I needed to be able to quantitatively defend, I think, my assertions. And also, at the time when I started doing it, I really didn't know. I just wanted to be adversarial and try to figure out exactly what level of stress is required to cause these things to fail. So the takeaway from, I think I've tested like 70 or 75 devices at this point, and the TL;DR takeaway is to keep it simple.
40:59And by keep it simple, I basically mean like the less parts there are involved, the less potential points of failure there are. So my experience has been that the best and most robust forms of backups are the ones that are literally just one big hunk of metal. And then even going further than that, there's a question of how do you actually inscribe the data onto the metal, whether it's etching, hammering, you know, stamping, or doing a simple dot. In my experience, the best was actually acid etching, but I only ever found one kit that did that.
41:44Of course, you can always do it yourself if you're able to get like some wax and a nine volt battery and some saline solution and electrodes and stuff. But other than that, the best format and really easiest format seems to be the simple straight punch, just putting a divot into a grid somewhere. The short version of the problems that I had with the Cryptosteel and related tiles... Yeah. So I will say I like the Cryptosteel Capsule more than the Cassette. I think the Capsule succeeds where the Cassette tends to fail, in the sense that certain types of heat application and crushing application in my tests would deform the Cassette.
42:37Enough that the tiles would be able to get loose and fall out of it. And then, you know, you have a big problem of either you've lost the tiles, or even if the tiles all stayed in place, you find yourself faced with a sort of combinatorial complexity of trying to figure out how to put them back in the right order. So the Cryptosteel Capsule is better at keeping all of that data together because, of course, it is literally encapsulating it. So even if it gets bent, most likely all of those tiles will stay in the same place.
43:15The one thing that I ran into with it is that, you know, if it did get bent, you're going to have to get some heavy equipment to be able to cut it back open, and preferably delicately enough not to destroy the tiles that are inside.
43:30Vlad CosteaYeah, you were not able in your test to break this, but you were able to bend it. Yeah. And I think you gave it a four-star review specifically because you said that it's like a Schrödinger's cat situation. You are not even able to remove it to figure out if the tiles are still intact. But at the same time, it didn't break. So it was an interesting situation. At the same time, you got asked the question, who the hell tries to bend this?
43:56Jameson LoppYeah, so, you know, why do I do a, it's a 20-ton hydraulic press that I use, and what am I trying to simulate there? I think the most likely type of scenario would be someone where they have stored it inside of a large building and then there's a building collapse, whether that's due to fire or earthquake or flood or whatever. Now, you know, these are extreme situations and many people may not even be storing their backup in a place that could be susceptible to that type of condition.
44:29But, you know, this is really me trying to put the data out there so that people know, you know, if they are exposed to that certain type of stress, you know, should they expect to be able to recover the data?
44:42Vlad CosteaOkay, let's get into maximalism, because this is my favorite topic of all of them. You spent so much time documenting and writing a long article about the history of maximalism. You gave credit to the best known Romanian Bitcoiner, who is Mircea Popescu, and you presented him as one of the first people to express Bitcoin-only opinions in a very toxic way that were dismissive of everyone and everything else. And I think you did a tremendous job. Congratulations on that one. For someone who doesn't have maybe two hours to read that entire blog post, could you please make a short summary of what Bitcoin maximalism is and the different phases through which it went?
45:29Jameson LoppYeah, it is, you know, a lengthy, like decade-plus long history. But, you know, maximalism really started out as a rejection of people trying to print their own money with cheap copied projects. You know, in the early days, there was Bitcoin and then there were just altcoins. And, you know, all of the altcoins for the first few years of Bitcoin's existence were literal copy-paste clones of the Bitcoin repository, you know, just tweaking a few parameters so that it created a different network with, you know, trivially different attributes. I remember in the early days, a lot of people were trying to pump alternative networks where literally the only difference was the mining algorithm.
46:26And they were treating it like somehow, you know, the mining algorithm itself would create value or that people would care about that. But, you know, in reality, no one really cares what mining algorithm powers a network other than the miners themselves. You know, then, you know, things started to get a bit more complicated when we saw some alternative, you know, from-scratch code bases come out, whether that was the CryptoNote stuff and Monero, Ethereum, of course, which ended up becoming a sort of predominant altcoin. And, you know, we saw more rejection of the sort of kitchen sink, trying to solve everything with a blockchain type of approach to this stuff.
47:18And, you know, it became more complex because a lot of these projects were really obfuscating various centralizing factors and control of their networks and the governance process and whatnot. I think there was, you remember, was it Dash that had like masternodes or something?
47:43Vlad CosteaOh, yeah.
47:44Jameson LoppIt had this kind of, it was kind of like a fake form of staking. There's so many different kinds of staking out there, and staking is not always the same type of thing. I mean, we've even seen, wasn't it like Richard Heart and his HEX thing?
47:57He claimed that you were staking HEX, but it wasn't even staking. It was really just like locking up your money for a long period of time. Things have gotten a lot more complicated and people are like overloading terms, you know, basically trying to make it sound like they're one thing when they're really another. You know, it's a lot of marketing hype and it can be hard to cut through the bullshit.
48:22I think things really came to a head, though, during the scaling wars, and I think that's when toxic maximalism really had its time to shine. And that's when I think toxic maximalism probably makes the most sense. It's when someone is trying to undermine the Bitcoin network itself from within, trying to make contentious changes, and you're kind of fighting against that. And so, you know, we saw a whole new group of people kind of rise up in prominence during the scaling debates. Many of them got worn out after several years of this stuff.
49:04And once things calmed down, especially once all of the Bitcoin forks had really proven themselves not to have staying power, things calmed down for a few years. And then I think it got interesting again around the pandemic time, because Bitcoin itself didn't really have any sort of existential crisis going on. But a lot of people suddenly found themselves sitting at home with not a lot to do, and a lot of new people came into Bitcoin at the time. And we had this kind of holdover from the folks who found toxic maximalism to be an interesting part of their lives during the scaling debates.
49:55Like people kind of going back to that and kind of indoctrinating a new set of people into a lot of the tenets around toxic maximalism. And so it got interesting, because a lot of those newcomers, they ended up kind of absorbing the memetics of toxic maximalism without necessarily knowing all of the details and history around where those things came from. So that itself got its own kind of viral effect. And it's been interesting to see how a lot of those talking points have been amplified and reiterated and sometimes slightly dumbed down over the years, to the point where it can be frustrating sometimes for the folks who have been around for a long time to try to interact with the newcomers.
50:51Vlad CosteaYeah, I like to joke sometimes that we want mass adoption, but we don't want to deal with the masses. It's a paradox, I guess. But I got to play another ad before we move on.
51:04Ad voiceoverRemember the paper wallet? Ah, yes. The good old days when you printed your Bitcoin private key on an offline computer. It was so fun, but not really easy and totally not secure. Today we have Satodime, a chip card that acts just like your good old paper wallet, but with all the modern security features and top notch functionality. It turns your Bitcoin into a bearer asset, which you can easily trade in person. Thanks to NFC, you can use the Satodime card with your smartphone. Creating a new pair of Bitcoin keys takes just two swipes.
51:35Check your balance in real time. Create multiple key pairs. Whenever you want, you can reveal your Bitcoin wallet's private key with just a single click. The simple uncluttered interface lets you quickly see if a key pair has been unsealed. Finally, the cold storage you've been looking for. Available now on Satodime.io.
51:58Vlad CosteaI like those girls. Anyway, on the topic of maximalism, what I want to say is that you're right about this. There seems to be this rising trend of maximalism becoming a lifestyle. And it's not just the monetary affinity itself. It's also the merchandise. It's the products that you buy to signal to the others that you're part of the group. And I did notice that there are some products that get endorsed and promoted as part of that. I wanted to call it a cult, but I don't want to be part of that group.
52:34But it seems to be very American to some extent. Like, we Europeans are much more reasonable, but Americans, they read The Bitcoin Standard and it seems like they find a new purpose in life. And they're like, yeah, this is my new identity. This is what I want to do now.
52:51Jameson LoppYeah, it's interesting. I haven't tried to do a sort of demographic breakdown, but we're seeing other types of culture kind of seep into it, and it may be more American. I've certainly seen more American conservative values coming up, whether that's various Christian morality stuff or you could call it right-wing conservative politics. That's really tricky, though, because a lot of people paint me as a right-winger. But I'm an avid anarcho-capitalist. I'm not a winger of any kind.
53:32Vlad CosteaBut that's the true right-winger, because left means more state intervention, right means no state intervention. So you are a true right-winger.
53:40Jameson LoppIn a sense, though, right. But they always mean Republican, at least in America. When you get called a right-winger, it always means you're like a Trump supporter or whatever, which is ridiculous. But that's something that I think American libertarians have had to deal with for many years. But yeah, the maximalism thing, it was like a 30-page article I ended up writing, because it is so complicated. And it really is. It's not a technical thing. It's more of a sociological phenomenon. And I think that when you unwind it does make sense of how we got to where we are today.
54:17And I think you just have to ask yourself the question of, do you want to put yourself in that ideological camp or are you more open-minded? And so I think I've always been more open-minded. I'm a technologist first. I'm interested in using whatever the tools are that I think can best empower me and other people. And I get plenty of flak from maximalists or otherwise in the community whenever I mention anything other than Bitcoin, because I think that that particular tool might actually be best for some other use case.
54:54Vlad CosteaSo many people made fun of you for that "Running Grin" tweet years ago. Like, they still use it as a way to prove that, okay, this guy failed so much. He had such a bad idea at the time to run this client. But just for the record, I can make fun all day of these people, but I agree with about 90 percent of what they're saying. And I also believe that Ethereum is a scam because of its launch and because of its incentives and the way that it's centralized and uses this political game to appear that it's decentralized, to have good PR.
55:29Nobody blamed it for increasing the prices of video cards for gamers. Gamers were blaming Bitcoin, actually, which was stupid, because nobody mines with GPUs anymore. But I can understand that there are some exchanges that do stuff and there are some business people that do stuff with what used to be colored coins and Counterparty. Initially, Ethereum started as a Bitcoin 2.0 proposal. And a lot of people don't remember that, that in 2014, 2015, there was this idea that we should do much more on the blockchain. We should create assets that get traded in a decentralized way, just like you trade Bitcoin.
56:07And Ethereum is an implementation of that idea. So initially, it was like an extension of what Bitcoin is doing. I can agree that it had a 72 million ETH pre-mine and that's kind of rigged in terms of economics. But people find it useful for whatever, putting NFTs on it, for fun stuff that you can do on Bitcoin technically, but you get very much frowned upon if you do it on Bitcoin, just like you did your wizard.
56:39Jameson LoppYeah. And I mean, that's what I think we should expect. This is a space of permissionless innovation and people are going to have demands for functionality that probably shouldn't be on Bitcoin. And that's okay. So, you know, if you don't want that stuff on Bitcoin, it seems kind of silly to be yelling at people for doing it on other networks.
57:02Vlad CosteaThere was a fun moment in 2021 when Counterparty made a comeback and Rare Pepes were all the rage, because everyone was searching for the historic NFTs and they found Rare Pepe and Spells of Genesis, which are some of the oldest. And it was interesting to see that people were once again creating Counterparty NFTs and the people who have been doing this for years were getting attention once again. And people were like, you should not do this on Bitcoin. And then, okay, but you want me to do it on a shitcoin?
57:37No, that's evil. You're giving the shitcoin volume and you're giving it use cases. Don't touch it. Okay, but how are you supposed to do this? And they don't have an answer for this. They say, okay, wait for RGB. And I can agree that RGB is promising, but it's not ready yet. Same for Taproot Assets, formerly Taro. I'm not sure if there is a solution for this, but we have to agree that it's permissionless tech. So as you proved with your ordinal inscription, the wizard, you can use Bitcoin for whatever you want, as long as you pay the fee. And we have, I guess, ideologically to keep it at that.
58:15Jameson LoppYeah, Bitcoin is for enemies. So support your enemies.
58:20Vlad CosteaAre you the enemy, Jameson?
58:23Jameson LoppI try not to be, but I think it's pretty much inevitable. Whenever you have a large enough number of people paying attention to you, someone will find reasons to declare you to be an enemy.
58:37Vlad CosteaYeah, unfortunately, you just told me that you have to go. I made a mistake. I didn't distinguish between EST and ET. They are kind of the same to me, but...
58:48Jameson LoppFiat time zones.
58:49Vlad CosteaExactly. So you have to go. So thank you very much, Jameson, for participating in this interview. I feel sorry for the people in the chat who asked questions, and I did not pay attention to them. But maybe we can do another interview some other time, I guess. Maybe less than five years from now.
59:10Jameson LoppYes, let's do that.
59:11Vlad CosteaNot in five years. So thank you once again, and I'll see you in another episode. I'll see you in Riga, I hope.
59:21Jameson LoppI'll be in Europe. I won't make it to Riga, though.
59:24Vlad CosteaOkay.
59:29Ad voiceoverShopinBit is the online store where you can buy anything with your Bitcoin. Choose between more than 800000 products, book flights and hotels, and order everything else through the concierge service. With ShopinBit, you can buy your weekly groceries, get the latest iPhone, upgrade your computer, buy something sexy for your new girlfriend, book a trip to El Salvador through the travel hacking service, and also grab a copy of the latest Bitcoin Takeover magazine to read in the airplane. Everything is integrated with a familiar shopping experience that doesn't track you and deletes your data after the order gets completed.
1:00:04You also get a 3% discount if you pay in Bitcoin. Try ShopinBit today and use promo code BTCTKVR for a 5 euro discount on your first order.
1:00:04================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Livestreamed remote interview (the feed title says S14 E9; the audio file name says s13_e9). Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with automatic speaker diarization (the intro voiceover was labelled 'Guest B'). Second opinions: YouTube auto-captions of the livestream (ze9bxzzE6jw, English original track 'en-orig', fetched read-only with yt-dlp; the stream starts about 36 s into the mp3, drifting to about 40 s by the end) and a full independent local re-transcription of the published mp3 with faster-whisper medium.en int8 in 2-minute chunks; both were word-aligned to the draft and about 530 non-filler differences reviewed. Doubtful stretches were re-transcribed again from the published mp3 (medium.en int8, plus small.en on two clips) on 42 short clips. No other local second-opinion transcript exists for this episode. Restored dropped passage at 37:52 ('And that's basically that, you know, you're not married to any one of your keys in your key set ... assume that they could be compromised'); ignored Whisper hallucinations in the re-transcription ('Thank you for watching!' at 29:13, 'Thank you so much for watching, I'll see you in the next video' at 47:47). Ads relabelled 'Ad voiceover' (intro, Wasabi Wallet 16:24, Cryptosteel 34:05, Satodime 51:04, ShopinBit 59:29); ad copy normalized to the sponsor copy used in other corrected episodes. Notable fixes: Kasa/Cas -> Casa; Jamison -> Jameson; Bitco/Biko/betco -> BitGo; influencer is influencer -> influencer's influencer; Umbrell/Nodal/RaspyBlitz -> Umbrel, Nodl, RaspiBlitz; casino -> Casa Node; start.kasa.com -> start.casa.com; Bit Seed -> Bitseed (John Light); bit nodes -> Bitnodes; foot guns -> footguns; derivation pass -> derivation paths; hops -> hardware wallets; Slip 39 -> SLIP-39; Shamir's/smear -> Shamir secret sharing; pump it loom dark girls -> Pump It Loomdart girls (the crypto meme song); no-stir -> Nostr; Metcalfo Bescu -> Mircea Popescu; baptism -> maximalism; Richard Hart -> Richard Heart (HEX); crypto note -> CryptoNote; mimetics -> memetics; running grin tweet -> 'Running Grin' tweet (Jan 2019); Eve pre-mine -> ETH pre-mine; Spouse of Genesis -> Spells of Genesis; Rare Pepe's -> Rare Pepes; wait for RGP -> wait for RGB; Taro (Taproot Assets' former name) kept as spoken; Feat time zones -> Fiat time zones; bed asset -> bearer asset; sadodime.io -> Satodime.io; Shop and Bit -> ShopinBit. Remaining doubtful words are marked ... (1 mark).