Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S15 E53 / Transcript
Transcript · S15 E53 · 57:57 · 7 Sept 2024

S15 E53: Charlie Shrem on Bitcoin

With Charlie Shrem. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:41Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I'm Vlad, I just got a haircut, so for those of you listening on Spotify, maybe you want to check out the video also. And I'm live with Charlie Shrem, who has lots of accolades in Bitcoin. He is the co-founder and CEO of BitInstant. He is the founder of the Bitcoin Foundation. And I guess that can also be an interesting topic. He is basically one of the first Bitcoin martyrs, someone who went to jail for Bitcoin's fungibility. And someone who also shares a lot of interesting perspectives about what it's like to be on the other side, where the criminals actually spend their time.

1:24And you said in a tweet that you actually became a much better American or more of a patriot after going to jail. And to me, that's also interesting because there is a different dynamic going on between the guys who used to work at BitInstant and some of them are still anarchists, some of them are patriots. It's interesting how this happens. But I talk too much. Welcome to the show, Charlie.

1:45Charlie ShremNo, thanks. It's good to be here. Thank you for having me. Thank you for doing this show. It's awesome.

1:52Vlad CosteaYeah, we actually did this episode because there was this interaction on Twitter. Of course, I tried to get you many times before and there was always a scheduling issue. But there was the guy behind the BitMEX Research account who basically said that you said you expressed your position regarding the block size wars and it was clear that you favor BTC. And you responded that you never really clarified. And I said, hey, wouldn't that be cool if I got you on the show to clarify? And you said, yeah, let's do it.

2:24Charlie ShremYeah, it's good to be here. And I remember that tweet interaction because, you know, I didn't know at any point we never really sat down and no one asked me kind of like my perspective and historical context of like how everything went down, how I thought about it and what happened, the good and the bad. And then he wrote a book and I've promoted that book many times on my podcast, The Charlie Shrem Show. I love BitMEX. Arthur Hayes is a good friend of mine. He's like Bitcoin OG, like literally.

2:55And he also went through the wringer himself personally. He ended up just getting some house arrest and stuff like that. But he also had to deal with the DOJ. And so, yeah, I was surprised when he had written that book, which I promoted, he never asked me what my thoughts were position on it. And he just kind of like read from historical context what he thought my position was or would be. So that's kind of why I commented on that.

3:21Vlad CosteaOh, wait. So the guy behind the BitMEX Research account is the author of The Blocksize War. I was not aware of that.

3:28Charlie ShremI believe so. Yeah. Isn't that isn't that Jonathan Bier, the same the same guy who wrote those books?

3:35Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if that's public. I'm not sure if we just doxed him, but it's interesting.

3:39Charlie ShremNo, maybe not. I don't know. I just assumed. But because it's the same BitMEX is producing those those books and everything like that and whatever it doesn't, you know, so that's kind of like, you know, that situation with that. And what do you want to know about the block size war? I mean, I don't even like calling it a war.

4:00Vlad CosteaWell, it was sort of a civil war, and it was interesting to see how the positions changed very fast. And at the time, I was just this observer. I was not running a node. I didn't care too much about what was happening. I was just hearing news about SegWit, SegWit2x and what else was there? Bitcoin Classic, Unlimited and all of these other implementations that were being proposed. And it was interesting later, after I got radicalized a bit by the winning side, that I discovered how many of these people who are today labeled as small blockers were very much in favor of increasing the block size.

4:41And there is BIP 103, which is a living proof that at one point, Pieter Wuille and Wladimir van der Laan and Greg Maxwell were very much interested in a gradual increase of the block size. And if you ask them today, they're going to say, no, Bitcoin is fine, whatever. So it seems like there was a major shift around the time. And for me, it wasn't the same impact as it was for you, for Roger, for Eric Voorhees and everyone else at BitInstant or TradeHill or Mt. Gox or everything else that was around.

5:16Charlie ShremYou know, Bitcoin had went through its first bull market in 2013, 2012. And when I got arrested in January 2014, that was kind of like the end of that era. At that point, you had my arrest, Silk Road shut down, Ross was arrested, Mt. Gox was proved to be insolvent and the Bitcoin price had hit its all time high and started dumping. It all kind of happened within like a couple of months. And so Bitcoin, not like as a price, but like as a family, as a group of friends and a community on the Internet, all that stuff, the word censorship, sides, war, all these things did not exist.

6:062011, 2012, and for most of 2013, if the concept of raising the block size had come up one year earlier, probably it wouldn't have been as anything as it, as what it became. And, you know, so like in a larger historical context, you had kind of like the end of an era, the end of like the anarchists and the misfits and the people throwing shit at the wall to seeing what sticks, the end of the BitInstant era, it was kind of like the rise of the Coinbase era and the newer wave of companies.

6:43Not many. The only two companies today that are still in operation that survived that are BitPay and Blockchain.info. Other than that, I mean, I can't point to any other OG Bitcoin or, you know, crypto wasn't even a thing. Vitalik hadn't launched or even talked about Ethereum until a couple of months after my arrest. And so like this was all, you had the Bitcoin era and then now you had the crypto era. Ethereum was being talked about. It was like two different worlds. Bitcoin block size had a lot of different competing forces and people that wanted all different things.

7:23And some great quotes that I had remembered that I remember from those days were like, someone told me, Charlie, you can't solve a technical problem with a political solution. And that's why I realized actually that SegWit2x wasn't going to end up being successful when I thought about that. But then another quote that I actually hold dear till today, but it's kind of like a failure on the Bitcoin developers a little bit, not that, but it's like a lot of the Bitcoin developers are and still are friends of mine.

8:02A lot of them live here in Florida and stuff like that. We all get together. And I remember them telling me, Charlie, smart scaling is better than fast scaling. So it's not that we're not going to raise the block size. It's not that we won't figure out how to scale the right way. It's that if we decide to take a knee and change Bitcoin because of all these different forces that are trying, we will have failed the social experiment that is Bitcoin. So the idea is that scaling and growth will come.

8:34Now, did it come? Yes, no, how, maybe so. All those types of questions we can talk about and debate, but that's kind of what set up those days. So you had the idea of, the simple idea was, and it really comes down to a computing thing, if you have a node that could run on a certain size computers, and if you raise... Excuse me one second, I just have to close those doors here.

9:10Vlad CosteaAnyway, this is a good moment to plug today's sponsors, SideShift.ai, LayerTwo Labs, StarkWare and Hodling.ch. I'm going to give you more details about them later, but I was able to cover this, Charlie.

9:24Charlie ShremYeah, great plug. That was good. I love it. Keep the... sponsors are really important because they keep us podcasters independent. So if you raise up that block size, it limits the fee in theory, if the blocks were all full, which they weren't, which they were just starting to become now because Bitcoin was getting really successful at that point. Then the idea was, the theory was you wouldn't be able to run Bitcoin nodes on smaller computers and forget Moore's law and all that other stuff that people would bring in. That was like the debate. And then everyone said, well, there's better ways to do it. You could raise it.

10:07And then SegWit was probably one of the best technical solutions at the time that was brought forward by the Bitcoin development team. And there were so many, there's so many layers to this, right? There was like political, personal attacks, a lot of like American versus Chineseness, which nowadays is more transparent. But back then there was a lot. So there was like a lot of the minor, there's so many layers to this story. And that book actually covers a lot of it, which is great. So that's why it promoted that book.

10:44Vlad CosteaYeah, just for the record, before this interview, I watched the documentary The Rise and Rise of Bitcoin. And I think that one does such a good job presenting what was happening at the time and foreshadows many of the events that happened in the last decade. It's incredible. Even the Chinese side that you described, there is a segment with Bobby Lee where he talks about how China is open to innovation on the Internet and how BTCC is going to be the next big thing. And how mining was migrating to China.

11:14I think the main character in that documentary, who is the brother of the filmmaker, is a miner, a very active one in the beginning, who ends up ordering like a dozen Avalon machines. And Butterfly Labs gets them too late or doesn't get them at all, and then gives up on mining altogether. And I think that's a story arc that presents a lot of the early days of Bitcoin.

11:38Charlie ShremAnd that was all Bitcoin. That was happening all the time. You'd be buying machines and you didn't know if you were going to be getting them.

11:48Cloud mining was like 90% of it was a scam. Because why would someone, if they invented machines that could mine Bitcoin, why would they send them to you? They would turn them on and mine them on their own first before the difficulty goes up. But the real answer is because people pre-ordered, people paid for those machines. All those early Bitcoin miners, the Avalon, the Butterfly Labs, they were all funded by a forum post. Hey guys, I have an idea for a Bitcoin miner. Everyone give me 10 Bitcoin and I'm going to go and come back. And most of those people never came back.

12:28Vlad CosteaI actually have a curiosity. This is slightly a plug for my sponsor, SideShift, because if you get paid in whatever stablecoin and you want Bitcoin or some free market money, you go to SideShift, they take a small fee, but you don't have to deal with all the complexities involved in swapping. They do it for you. And I'm curious right now to know from the perspective of 2012-2013 Charlie Shrem, what do you think about the fact that stablecoins have a much higher trading volume today than Bitcoin? And I see this as sort of a defeat for us.

13:04Charlie ShremIt's interesting. Stablecoins have become such a good explainer of crypto to people. And if you look at most people who end up using stablecoins for the first time, probably end up using Bitcoin or another crypto, it's not like their only touch that they have in the crypto world. So kind of look at it from that sense. Stablecoins are providing this like, it's going to be a multi hundred year, probably another hundred years until you see like a Bitcoin standard.

13:41And until then, you need to give people the ability to trade in and out of their fiat currencies. And Tether, if you look at Tether across the world, it is literally a financial backbone that is taking millions of people out of poverty every single day. It is giving that person, no matter where they are in the world, or no matter pretty much like any background, you can get a cell phone with a Tether account, you immediately have access, you can now use your brain and start a business and start doing something like that.

14:20And I just think it's amazing. And it's beautiful. And then eventually that person is like, what is this crypto thing that I'm using? And then they do some research as they grow out of like, you know, they get this financial literacy, and then they discover Bitcoin. And they fall in love with it. And they buy some, or they earn some and then they put it away. They're not transacting with it. So like all these transactions that you see with Bitcoin, a lot of the times, they're just people buying Bitcoin, and then they're putting it somewhere for multi-generational wealth.

14:54Vlad CosteaYeah, it is interesting to me that basically stablecoins right now are eating Bitcoin's cake. And I guess it's also because of the fees. My girlfriend is from Iran, and her parents can't use the banking system to send her money.

15:11Charlie ShremPerfect example.

15:12Vlad CosteaAnd they send her Tether, because it's easy for them to acquire it. Everyone wants to get their hands on the dollar. And to them Bitcoin seems too volatile, too wild. And I'm a bit conflicted about the whole situation. I tell her, you know, you should be using Bitcoin, it's much better.

15:30Charlie ShremLook, we are just, I think about this from a philosophical thought all the time. We are just humans living in this short amount of time. And this transition to a better money for humans may not happen during our lifetimes. And so when we sat and thought about what would the transition into this better sound money look like, when you looked at, and we weren't all economists, we were a bunch of kids in our parents' basements. So when we're thinking like, okay, like Cyprus, Argentina, hyperinflation, maybe Germany, World War II, you know, the Reichsmark, whatever, like hyperinflation, Zimbabwe, we didn't theorize that what it would do, temporarily at least, is make the dollar stronger.

16:27And that's what we're talking about here. That's what you're seeing. It's like, look at 10, 15 years ago, the dollar was, the dollar and all these other currencies kind of like were when they were, but now it's like a lot. You'd argue that over the last 10 years, the dollar has just got nothing but stronger. Now is that because we're pretty much exporting all of our inflation in the US to everyone else in the rest of the world. And the rest of the world's currencies are the ones that are inflating a lot faster than ours. And I think it's really wrong that the American government does that.

17:03Vlad CosteaYeah, I have a surprise for you at this point. I promised you there's going to be a surprise. There's going to be two of them, actually. But I mentioned my girlfriend and she did something very nice for you today. Right now she's taking an exam in medical school. But this morning she was able to draw this. And I'm going to ask you to take your phone and take a look at this. This is you as a Pepe.

17:28Charlie ShremOh, that's beautiful. Can you put it back? I got to see it again. I couldn't. It's gone now.

17:36Vlad CosteaNo, it should be on.

17:38Charlie ShremOh, that's awesome. I said that's really, that's really great. Can you like issue that on Bitcoin or something?

17:48Vlad CosteaYou can inscribe that if you want. I can send it to you. Please own it. It's yours. My girlfriend sent this gift to you. And I think it's very beautiful because we watched the documentary together, The Rise and Rise of Bitcoin. And she said, you know, if you interviewed this guy and he's this famous, maybe I can do this for him.

18:05Charlie ShremDo you... did you see Banking on Bitcoin? The other documentary?

18:10Vlad CosteaYeah. It's the one where you wash dishes.

18:13Charlie ShremYes, that's so...

18:15Vlad CosteaSorry. That's how I remember it.

18:18Charlie ShremThat was a good job for six months because you're just you're just putting headphones on and you're washing dishes. And you don't have any problem in the world.

18:32Vlad CosteaOh, yeah. If you look at it that way, I think at the time you were saying that you're wearing that bracelet around your ankle all the time. And that you only get paid like a dollar an hour or something, which was very shitty for washing dishes.

18:50Charlie ShremYeah. And those are like in prison. You only make like thirty dollars a month or something like that.

19:00Vlad CosteaThat sucks. But at least I think it helps you shorten your sentence.

19:08Charlie ShremNot really. You have to like work. You have to like everyone has to work in prison. But I worked also I worked in the education department for a little bit, helping some people get their high school diploma, because if you're in prison and you don't have a high school diploma before you could work a regular job, you have to get one. So I helped some people do that for a couple of months and then they transferred me to like work landscaping, which was a great job.

19:39So I drove I drove this. It was pretty much always cold. So I drove this snowplow for plowing the snow and for putting salt on the ground. And I drove this big tractor over like 5,000 acres.

19:57Vlad CosteaNo, I think the snowplowing episode of The Simpsons is one of the most wholesome ones in existence. I'm not sure if you watched that one, but it's really...

20:10Charlie ShremIt comes to mind a little bit. Why don't I remember that? Yeah. What happens?

20:16Vlad CosteaWell, it has a very happy ending with Homer Simpson basically becoming this snowplow man and he takes care of the entire neighborhood. And it gives you that feeling that there is someone out there who has a kind heart and basically defreezes your car and lets you go to school and whatever, even though kids hate going to school.

20:37Charlie ShremYeah, that's great. That's really great. It was definitely a therapeutic job. But yeah, coming out of jail, you have to have a job for six months. And when I got out of prison, I was poor.

20:53Not only that, but I had a million dollar debt I had to pay to the government as part of my plea agreement. So all my money went to my lawyers, my parents, no one helped me or anything. It was really like my girlfriend, who's now my wife, she left New York with me. She moved to about an hour away from the prison and she sent me money. My parents abandoned me, excommunicated me. I haven't spoken or seen them in 10 years. Half the Bitcoin community supported me, half didn't.

21:30A lot of people sent me beautiful letters and sent me money and just took care of me in so many ways. When I got out of prison, I had to restart. But when you get out of prison, your whole life is fresh. It's new again. You get almost like a rebirth a little bit. And because I was in so much debt, I stopped worrying about money as something that you were trying to attain over a long-term thing. So I was very content and happy working in my restaurant for six months, working at a dishwasher and helping be a waiter and cleaning tables and food in Pennsylvania.

22:21That was really great. And then eventually I moved down here to Florida and I've been released now for eight years, which is amazing, celebrating my seven-year wedding anniversary. We got engaged the day I got released from prison and then we got married a year later. And that's been seven years since then.

22:44Vlad CosteaThat's beautiful. I look forward to seeing or hearing of a similar story about Ross Ulbricht, hopefully this November or whenever a new president gets.

22:55Charlie ShremYeah, there's hopefully a light at the end of his tunnel. I'm telling you, like Trump has a really good chance of winning. I really I really hope so. I have a when he got convicted as a as a felon and I'm a felon. Also, I got this hat that says I'm voting for the convicted felon.

23:17Vlad CosteaThat's a very funny situation. Anyway, I want to ask you about the current state of Bitcoin and what you think about it from a technical perspective compared to what you knew and how you understood it at the time. But before that, I got to plug two sponsors. We're actually trying to improve Bitcoin right now. And maybe you can talk about them also. One of them is LayerTwo Labs and they have these drivechains and they don't just have an idea that's been passed around for a decade now.

23:44They also have a bunch of demos that you can download from layer2labs.com. You can try their Ethereum sidechain, their Zcash sidechain, their Namecoin sidechain and a bunch of others. Did you pass? My girlfriend passed her exam. I got it. In the episode, she liked your Pepe.

24:06Charlie ShremThank you for the Pepe.

24:09Vlad CosteaShe can do more if you commission her. This is for the listeners. And basically, LayerTwo Labs is trying to scale Bitcoin with sidechains and you can check out their demos on the Bitcoin testnet or signet.

24:23I'm not sure which one of them, but I'm going to get Paul again to do a proper video demo of how this works. And the other one is StarkWare, which is trying to bring Bitcoin rollups to Bitcoin. Bitcoin rollups to Bitcoin. They're basically on Ethereum right now. They need OP_CAT, which is a soft fork upgrade in order to bring that to Bitcoin. The benefit is that you can use zero knowledge proofs to basically synchronize your node much faster. You can have mobile wallets which synchronize the node within a couple of seconds by using zero knowledge proofs.

24:55And they also have pretty good privacy and other stuff. So check that out also. And if you're into advocating for soft forks, think about these covenants because they can bring a lot of builders to Bitcoin. So these were my two plugs, LayerTwo Labs for sidechains and StarkWare for ZK rollups. And now I got to ask you about what you think about Bitcoin nowadays.

25:16Charlie ShremYou said, I mean, you said it right there. You're sponsored by LayerTwo Labs. Those guys are phenomenal. Paul, he's a Bitcoin OG. I went through it with him.

25:29We went through his white paper and I fully understand what they're doing, how it all works. And it's a brilliant, one of the best technological solutions that we have for scaling for Bitcoin. And there's a lot of other good ones, which is cool because like you said, soft forks, OP_CAT, we have so many different methods, some good, some bad, a lot of the trade-offs. And then there are good websites that explain the trade-offs, which ones are better, which ones are worse. So from a Bitcoin scaling user perspective growth, there's a lot there.

26:05We're a couple of years behind where the rest of the crypto ecosystem is now. But that'll catch up. It really depends on where demand ends up being. The only place we're lacking is in user interface, UI, and the user experience. I spent the last couple of weeks, we have really good apps. There's some really good apps now that make Bitcoin just phenomenal to use. I bookmark them and just like working with Bitcoin and other different types of assets and layer two stuff. And I'm really just excited and pumped where everything is. I have really nothing bad to say.

26:49Vlad CosteaWell, I like to complain a bit sometimes about the culture in Bitcoin, because I guess Bitcoiners used to be much more enthusiastic about creating anarchy with cryptography. Doing stuff without the state, trying to build a parallel economy, a circular economy, or whatever you want to call it.

27:08Charlie ShremIt's really simple, though. Sorry, I apologize.

27:14Vlad CosteaNo, no, no, you say what's simple.

27:16Charlie ShremAnd I think I know what you're getting at. And I know, you're right. And I've spent a lot of sleepless nights over this culture loss. But the fact of the matter is too many people went to prison.

27:32And the Amir Taakis and the crypto anarchists, and the people that are going to be trying to push for ultimate privacy and anonymity in Bitcoin. It's just that they'll just be private people, undoxxed, as you say, and then no one will take them seriously in the mainstream world. And B, they're just going to be afraid to go to prison. And so the only people that are left are like, you have people that are like, Bitcoin needs to be fully regulated. And then you have people that are like, well, regulate crypto, but leave Bitcoin alone.

28:10Well, that's not nice. Like, why are we throwing crypto into the fire? So there has to be some sort of like equilibrium here or some sort of like, we're all in this together again. And I don't know what the answer is. But no one's going to be doing Monero style of pushing for Bitcoin. I mean, even in the rest of the world, America is easy. The rest of the world is where they're arresting people. France arrests. If you're the CEO of Telegram and you're not safe, you think you can be safe writing a blog post about privacy on Bitcoin?

28:46Absolutely not. No one's safe anymore. These things are listening to us. Our shows are monitored by the government. Everyone thinks they're not. They're checking out our houses. They spend so much money. There's lists. You don't even know. Like, people are afraid. I can't tell you how many OG Bitcoiners just disappeared. What about all those mysterious deaths over the last 10 years? No one wants to be the next Ross.

29:23Vlad CosteaMy perspective is slightly different in regards to this because I come from a formerly communist country. And I guess our sense of privacy and freedom is more fresh. We have this social contract with our government in Romania. If you read the Constitution, it's drafted according to the experiences of the communist regime. And it's more freedom-centric. And also, I think that government is more friendly to the idea of leaving you alone. Even if, I guess, they monitor you. But they don't do anything. I'm not aware of any arrests because you're a privacy activist or because you disagree with the government.

30:03Charlie ShremNo, they come up with another charge like something else. It's never going to be directly related to that because they don't want people to become martyrs. So it's all your favorite people that were big social media influencers that went down for one reason or another. There's always another reason. But you're right. You're right. Privacy is very important. Privacy is very important. I'm just telling you the reality of it. A lot of people are scared. And that's why you're not seeing Bitcoin. The people that that are building sovereign tools. I don't know if we'll see what like sovereign tools on Bitcoin for like what you want to see.

30:55Vlad CosteaThis got pretty gloomy very fast.

30:58Charlie ShremWell, it was a positive one. I love Bitcoin for what it is today. It's being left alone. It's a great, it's the only opt-out financial system we have. You talk about like, you have your national currency, you have or you have the euro, you have the dollar. Up until Bitcoin existed, there was never an opt-out. There was never a way to say I don't want to deal with the money printing mess that's happening. My purchasing power, hyperinflation, all this figures.

31:33Bitcoin is a beautiful thing for that. That's what it's been for me. That's what it's always been. And it's never changed. All these other like narratives. Oh, Bitcoin needs to be this Bitcoin needs to be that like, that's really subjective. Bitcoin is whatever you want it to be, because it's yours. It's not owned by anyone. And so you understand out of all people, like why Bitcoin is so beautiful right now, because like, yeah, you don't have the communist regimes anymore. But there are a lot of countries that look at your girlfriend in Iran, their currency, their money's like stuck over there.

32:09They can't get their money out if they want to. They have the craziest capital controls. Yeah, they have Tether, but you don't think that like Tether and the dollar as a temporary solution. You don't think the dollar is also losing its purchasing power over time. It's just a little bit slower.

32:31Vlad CosteaOh, I do agree with that. But as you said, people have very limited patience and time in this world. So they choose whatever works right now. They don't care if it's centralized. They don't care too much. They care about the UX. And you're right that in Bitcoin, sometimes the UX is not a priority. Because I did try a lot of wallets. I did see, for example, the Monero full node wallet. It has a lot. I think it's a lot nicer than Bitcoin-Qt. And they added so many interesting features like syncing from the block height where you received your first transaction to make it faster. You can also mine directly from the client.

33:15Charlie ShremOh, that's what the client used to do. I love that. I agree with you there. The user experience, everything needs to be so much better with Bitcoin. I know a lot of apps and wallets and things like that are working on it. But I don't even know what the future of hardware is going to be. I don't even know if like we'll be using cell phones and apps as we know it now. I think even that's a kind of a temporary thing.

33:39So I'm, I know, this is the, this is what's really nice. A family member of mine was in town the past couple of days. She's she's 11 years old. She's very smart, brilliant 11 year old that I know. You want to hear the most beautiful, amazing thing in the world. Her whole life, Bitcoin has existed. She doesn't know a world without Bitcoin. To me, that brought a tear to my eye because we succeeded.

34:15Bitcoin's existence is validated by its existence through time and people using it, holding it, distributing it, talking about it like you having this podcast. The longer we do this, the longer we hold out, the longer we'll be in existence, the longer it validates everything that we're doing. And to have a child where now she doesn't have to be convinced of Bitcoin for her, Bitcoin's always been a thing. It's existed her whole life since the moment she's been born. Her dad has owned it since she's been born. It's been part of his life too. So it's like, I mean, come on. That's, that's the most amazing thing ever.

34:55Vlad CosteaYeah, I agree with you. And it goes back to the saying that you win when you outlive your enemies to a degree.

35:05Charlie ShremAh, that's beautiful.

35:06Vlad CosteaBecause in the end, the one that wins is the one that writes the history. The one that dies is the one that doesn't get to tell the story. So I guess to Bitcoin, it's important to resist over time and be resilient. But I got to ask you, what do you think about this whole scaling situation?

35:23Because Bitcoin hasn't really scaled over the last seven years. There was the Lightning Network, which didn't get too much traction. And now there are too many custodian solutions from Fedimints to eCash. And all of these ideas, which are basically banking reinvented. And I'm pretty sure that's not really why you got into Bitcoin. And it's not why I got into Bitcoin either.

35:45Charlie ShremI don't know the answer to this either. And really, everyone you asked, I had a, you know, you talk to people who are in the hardware wallet space, right?

35:54They'll give you one answer. People are in like the app wallet space will give you a different answer. Custodial people will give you a different answer. To me, Bitcoin was all about like, the idea of money was now in your possession. It's like before was like, if you lost a bank account, they gave you a check. If they shut your bank account down, they'd give you a check, but you'd have to go to another bank in order to cash that check to continue being in the financial world.

36:27To me, Bitcoin was this thing that was like, I possess the money now. And that's the difficult part in the early days of Bitcoin. And I'll be honest with you was, and this question always came up, was it was differentiating the value of Bitcoin as a system. If you had like 10,000 people operating as nodes and miners and people secure financial system, like a SWIFT, that's super valuable. But what if the monetary unit traded on it is also the thing called Bitcoin. So they're both called Bitcoin.

37:10One's the financial system, and one's the monetary unit. They both solve each other's problems. The system enables the unit to be transferred, but the unit Bitcoin is supposed to be this like inflation locked. Like, as soon as you buy it, the value of the dollar of that minute is kind of like locked in now. And over time, because it'll balance out because energy costs a certain amount of money, we can gauge that. And there's always a race for the cheapest amount of energy. Theoretically, you'd always have Bitcoin miners at the sources of energy.

37:55So the value of Bitcoin would somewhat represent the cost of electricity or the cost of energy, wherever that is. And you'd have some sort of equilibrium. And then whatever that monetary unit is now being transferred over the system, Satoshi should have named them separate things, in my opinion. It would have been a lot easier. So where we are now, to your original question, Bitcoin as a monetary unit, we've succeeded, and that's a slow success. The little girl, you, me, all of us, even our grandparents, agree to some extent that Bitcoin is this financial asset that is traded and held by enough people that it represents some macro thing in the world.

38:55And let's, I don't know what that is yet. Let's just put that aside for a second. You talked about transactional volume on chain. And I agree, yes, it has gone down. And a lot of that is because people just aren't, like, a lot of people are just like one or two time transactors, they buy it to put it somewhere, they play around with it, and they just, and then the other trading is happening on these institutional places, and people are holding ETFs or whatever. But going back to your question, Bitcoin as like a network, that is where I would really love to see more growth.

39:27And that is where the, like, let's, all those people who now hold Bitcoin, let's convince them to, like, use it. There used to not be a lot of really great ways to use it. What are you going to do, deposit on exchange? You got some cool wallets, use the BitPay wallet or whatever. You know, then you had a lot of hacks and scams and frauds. So people were like, they put their Bitcoin either custodians that insure it, or hardware wallets and things like that. Bitcoin on exchanges, like if you look at that metric, how many Bitcoin are on exchanges, that has just been falling.

40:00I thought you'd see a supply squeeze a long time ago, maybe this time around, you'll see that. And that could feel like a huge bull market, because there aren't a lot of Bitcoin for sale on the exchanges anymore. So like, I would love to see Bitcoin be used more with regular people, you and me, the Uber driver, your girlfriend's parents, all that type of stuff. I would love to see people. How do I sleep at night? What I say to myself is, Bitcoin has both. It has the financial system, and it has the monetary unit.

40:40The monetary unit is going to take a little bit longer, maybe another couple of decades, to a point where your girlfriend and her parents are using it to send money with each other. But in the meantime, they're going to get used to the technology that Bitcoin created, the Byzantine Generals' problem that Satoshi solved, enabled all these other blockchains to exist, where Tether, you know, is transacting, and all these other stablecoins. So people understand when they're using Tether, that they're using this thing called cryptocurrency, and they understand bitcoins involved. And so over time, we're going to see both come back together, I think. Sorry for the long winded answer.

41:32Vlad CosteaNo, it's fine. I think you mentioned something interesting in your speech. And you did describe something about everyday people using Bitcoin. The guys in the Bitcoin Cash community really want me to ask you what you think about their project. And I think that's what their marketing is about. They're trying to enable this peer-to-peer economy, as opposed to the store of value function. And they try to distinguish themselves right now by adding a few opcodes that Bitcoin doesn't have. And they have some developers building some ideas that are being proposed for Bitcoin, which I think is great for the open source space.

42:13This is what open source software should be about. You test stuff and you have the oldest and most conservative project that gets to pick which implementation is better to adapt for its own purposes. So I do like that. But before I let you talk about Bitcoin Cash, I'll give you a minute to think because I got a plug. Another sponsor is Hodling.ch. They're based in Switzerland, and they deal with self custody. If you have a lot of Bitcoin or you're part of an institution that's adding Bitcoin to its balance sheet, you reach out to them and they're going to help you set up your multisig.

42:47They're going to help you decide what kind of hardware wallets you need for your setup and all of these details. And you also benefit from the Swiss privacy that they offer. They also have a service for recovering your keys. If you lost one or two or three words from your seed phrase, they should be able to recover it. So check them out at Hodling.ch. And also, Charlie, I promised you that there's going to be a second surprise. And then, of course, you have to answer the question about Bitcoin Cash.

43:15But there's a poem that this guy, Samuel, wrote. I put it on the screen. It says it captures the shape of what occurred, the movement of itself by our movement. It takes a moment and arrests it in time, like a photograph or a sculpture, except this one we know cannot burn. It will remain and endure and be the monolith of our memory for eternity. And moneyness is but one aspect that is, that it breathes. His name is Samuel. He writes poems about Bitcoin.

43:55Charlie ShremWait. Don't, don't pull away from it. I want to read this really quick. I got a new pair of glasses, so.

44:01Vlad CosteaSure.

44:02Charlie ShremIt captures the shape of what occurred, the movement of itself by our movement. It takes a moment and arrests it in time, like a photograph or a sculpture, except this one we know cannot burn. It will remain and endure. It will be the monolith of our memory in eternity. And its moneyness is but one aspect that it breathes. That's beautiful. That's a beautiful poem.

44:31Vlad CosteaHe really wanted this to appear on the screen during this interview.

44:35Charlie ShremI will I will print that in my book if I have permission. I would love to print that. I want to put it at the beginning of every chapter. I'll have a poem that someone wrote or something like that.

44:52Vlad CosteaThat's very beautiful. I love this community, by the way.

44:56Charlie ShremYes, me too. It's a beautiful thing. You were asking about Bitcoin Cash. So I need to revisit the Bitcoin Cash community again, because, yeah, you did raise some very valid points, like no one team should dictate, you know, what like what something ends up being.

45:18It's kind of just a shame how Bitcoin Cash was created and the people that were behind it in the negative way that kind of like ended up being, you know, the con. There was some, you know, I don't, it's very public now, but the con artists and stuff like that were kind of behind that convinced everyone that he was Satoshi. You know that that that guy kind of gave a really bad stain on the Bitcoin Cash and the Bitcoin Satoshi Vision community, especially the Bitcoin Satoshi Vision community, because that one was created, forked from Bitcoin Cash.

46:00Bitcoin Cash was created when that thou shalt not be named because I don't want that guy to sue me. When he realized that he couldn't be the leader of Bitcoin Cash, he forked that into Bitcoin Satoshi Vision. But a lot of people believe that he was Satoshi and were conned by him. So they were, you know, they were acting unfortunately in their, in what they believe what Satoshi was acting in. And so it just became like a really shitty thing. And then nowadays you have Bitcoin Cash was a phenomenal community.

46:36It's flourishing. It seems like I had Amaury Séchet, who is the lead developer of Bitcoin Cash for many years. Had him on my podcast, really nice guy, met him in person in Mexico and at a conference. And we spent many hours together just talking, really great guy. And I told him the same thing. I was like, what a shame your community was started out of like a negative thing. And he told me, Charlie, it'll just take time. And so I think Bitcoin Cash as a community and as a viable like thing over time, it'll, it'll, you know, lose that like red stain that it got.

47:14Vlad CosteaI hate to break it to you, but Amaury was on my show and he broke away from the Bitcoin Cash project. Nowadays, he runs his own fork of Bitcoin Cash. That's called eCash. XEC.

47:27Charlie ShremSo I can't even keep up anymore.

47:30Vlad CosteaYeah, it's a fork of a fork. To his credit, he did add some interesting technological stuff like the Avalanche protocol. It's a combination of proof of work and proof of stake. It's his little sandbox, I guess he found some interesting.

47:47Charlie ShremI don't like any crypto that has a leader. Right, like Satoshi disappeared. Bitcoin is leaderless. Did you notice that every time someone tries to become like the leader of Bitcoin, they get either humbled or they like rage quit. Elon Musk rage quit. Michael Saylor got too big, humbled himself. Like it really, you don't have any leaders. It's a beautiful thing. So that's what happened with Bitcoin Cash. As soon as a leader, the market and the community doesn't want a leader. Our value and the reason we exist is because we have no leader. Once we have a leader, you can take it down. It's over.

48:26Vlad CosteaI think this only works in Bitcoin culture because with Ethereum and all the others. It doesn't seem to affect the perception of the project or Tron or different things, though.

48:37Charlie ShremThose are Ethereum as much as it tries to be money. It's not money. It's not trying to be money. Whatever. That's another conversation. Those are like smart contract platforms. And I would argue the opposite, like those need people behind them, especially if they're raising money, you know.

48:58Vlad CosteaI mean, there are very interesting scientific experiments, I guess, just like Zcash. I love Zcash, but at the same time, I don't see it being a replacement for Bitcoin because it's VC funded, has leadership. But I love what they're doing with research.

49:15Charlie ShremAll these blockchains and all these, they're only as good as the applications that they have for normal people in using this crypto technology in some way or another. You want to use, so like, and if that's your transaction count and that's what you're trying to become like, then that's good. But it's really hard. Now, I know some people that are trying to like relaunch the social experiment type Bitcoin things that are very interesting, but it's very difficult.

50:00Vlad CosteaAre there any, you mentioned a bunch of blockchains, are there any projects other than Bitcoin that you find interesting? And if yes, then why?

50:12Charlie ShremYeah, I don't. It's an interesting question. Because, are you, from like an investment perspective, people buying tokens and things like that, I don't, those tokens have life cycles in and of themselves. Like they, no one really knows what they're meant to do sometimes or like how they all work. And it's a complicated, it's a complicated thing. That's evolving right now. Hopefully we'll see some good regulations come out. I work for a couple of different crypto projects, like helping them get from the early stages of where they are now to helping them, you know, like raise VC money or launch some product or service or whatever.

51:05But there's nothing other than Bitcoin that when I go to like a friend's birthday party, I'm still giving them Bitcoin. I give people Bitcoin because I'm still like orange-pilling people. But the crypto, I still don't know what to do. I'm still experimenting.

51:25Vlad CosteaPart of that documentary, The Rise and Rise of Bitcoin, is showing you during the BitInstant days, during the first major crash after Bitcoin went to 200 something dollars, and then it crashed to 100. And that was because of a shutdown in Mt. Gox.

51:40And you are trying to explain to people that they still have their Bitcoin and they're saying, oh, I just want my money back. And you even said, oh, but I gave you extra Bitcoin. They just wanted their US dollars. And I started from this little story, because I was thinking, how does someone like you perceive the fact that Elon Musk is pumping Bitcoin or used to and accepted Bitcoin for payments in the Tesla store. And you could preorder the Cybertruck using BTC for about a month.

52:14Charlie ShremIt's crazy. It's very humbling.

52:16Vlad CosteaIf someone told you in 2012 or 2013 that this was going to happen, what was your reaction? Like, dude, are you high or whatever?

52:24Charlie ShremIt's happened too fast. All the problems that we talked about earlier in the show are just because Bitcoin got successful, like the scaling thing. The scaling war happened because the people were using Bitcoin and the blocks were filled. And so it was a champagne problem. Like, as we say, like, which champagne do you choose? You know, it was like we were dealing with a good problem at that point.

52:52The problem was we were getting a lot of demand. So I think just Bitcoin got a lot successful a lot faster than we thought it was going to. But I still don't believe it. I still don't believe anything. I'm still kind of like living in this in this world where where I don't even know how Bitcoin became where it is today. And I have to like almost like write it down and finish writing this book and figure this out, because in order to understand like where we're going, we really need to understand where we came from.

53:34Vlad CosteaYeah, you're working on a book. I think it's useful to tell people about that and when they will be able to buy it. And also, you mentioned before we started recording that you wrote a poem on the day when you were going to get arrested. And you also want to turn that into a song. So if you want to share any of that, it would be very cool.

53:57Charlie ShremYeah, sure. So I'm pulling up the poem. What was the first part of the question?

54:07Vlad CosteaAbout your book, when it's coming out and what it's going to be called and what it's about.

54:13Charlie ShremI've pulled this up. But working on this, I've been working on this story since the minute it started, since the minute I got into Bitcoin in late 2010. I knew it was something really important, something really big. And so started writing a lot down, a lot of journals and notes and thoughts, stories, blog posts, kind of like as the history was happening.

54:35And then when I went to prison, a lot happened there. Actually, when I was in prison was when the block size debate started, which is why I missed out on the Hong Kong agreement and the New York agreement and all those different things that happened. I was in prison when all that went down. So I did miss out on the only way I knew what was going on was Roger was mailing me things from the outside, keeping me informed. So I appreciated him doing that. He was mailing me a lot of information and so many people in the Bitcoin community were mailing me things and letters and nice things.

55:11People were mailing me. So I'm writing this book from the early days of Bitcoin and all these different stories. And yeah, so that's the book. And then my poem, I'll read it to you. It's gonna be a song. But it's, this is the day I got arrested. Tell me if I'm wrong, but it happens a lot. They get scared at things once they get hot. We now know it's a recurring theme. What happened to the American dream? I turned around to see what that could be. Next thing that happens, I'm a detainee.

55:57Agents and they yell and shriek. Now I haven't seen my girlfriend in one whole week. I start to think that things are looking bad. In prison, they gave me a writing pad. Here comes my legal team. They're setting bail. Please, God help. I'll never survive jail. Now I'm thinking that I'm fed to the sharks. Against the wall, yeah, they're throwing darts. Fear, and maybe a little sadness too. Now let me take a good look at you. I'm flipping out and my parents are sweating bullets. I'm flipping out and I'm counting down the minutes.

56:34From early on, Bitcoin was on the frontier. We decided to change the way we've lived for thousands of years. We fought with the experts that they're incorrect. Well, what about fees and middlemen and a little respect? So I asked the judge, am I ever going home? But he just looks and says he should have known. Because laws are here to protect our freedom. So I got my axe and spear and shield to fight in the Coliseum. But no more parties. I'm banned from the city. No more court and work.

57:07Can it get more shitty? Now it's only friends and the neighborhood guys to go outside. I must call the FBI. I'm flipping out and I'll never shave my face because I'm too scared of this place. And I'll never take a shower because in prison, if you smell, it's power.

57:28Vlad CosteaThat's incredible. You got to put that in the book.

57:33Charlie ShremI will, then. Thank you, my friend. I got to run, but thank you so much for doing this show. Appreciate everything you're doing. I love you.

57:39Vlad CosteaAnd I hope I'll see you in Frankfurt.

57:42Charlie ShremYes. What's in Frankfurt?

57:43Vlad CosteaThe Proof of Work Summit this month.

57:45Charlie ShremOh, yeah, I love. It's the coolest city ever. Germany is really coming back.

57:51Vlad CosteaI'll see you there. All right.

57:53Charlie ShremCool. See you later.

57:54Vlad CosteaBye. And thanks, everyone, for listening.

57:54================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: local Whisper medium.en transcript with automatic speaker diarization, given global name/jargon fixes and a full read-through, then compared word by word against the YouTube auto-captions of the livestream (same timing as the feed audio); paragraphs re-segmented on the caption word timings and disagreement spots reviewed. A full local small.en re-transcription was started but abandoned (memory and CPU contention on the box), so the YouTube captions were the second opinion. 22 doubtful stretches were checked against short audio clips re-transcribed locally with medium.en (int16, VAD), including the dropped Byzantine Generals / Tether stretch at 00:40:58 (restored), the Bitcoin Cash / Bitcoin SV and eCash passages at 00:45-00:47, Samuel's Bitcoin poem read by Vlad and then by Charlie at 00:43:15-00:44:31, and Charlie's prison poem at 00:55:11-00:57:28. Speaker turns were checked with a full-episode local speaker-embedding scan (two reference voices) and per-word speaker tags at ambiguous spots; short turns were re-attributed where the scan or the audio was unambiguous. Sponsor reads (SideShift.ai, LayerTwo Labs, StarkWare, Hodling.ch) are read live by Vlad. Names and jargon were checked against the title, the feed show notes and the web: Charlie Shrem, BitInstant, Bitcoin Foundation, BitMEX Research / Jonathan Bier, The Blocksize War, Roger Ver, SegWit, Ross Ulbricht, BitPay, Blockchain.info, Vitalik, Banking on Bitcoin, The Rise and Rise of Bitcoin, Paul Sztorc, layer2labs.com, OP_CAT, Amir Taaki, Monero, Bitcoin-QT, Fedimint, eCash, Tether, Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin SV, Amaury Séchet, eCash (XEC), Avalanche, Hong Kong agreement, New York agreement, Pepe (Charlie Shrem's Pepe), Proof of Work Summit (Frankfurt). Clean verbatim: filler words and false starts lightly trimmed; meaning not changed. Remaining doubtful words are marked best guess.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00