S16 E17: Ben Arc on LNBits v1 & The State of Lightning Network
Search this conversation
0:45Vlad CosteaHey, hello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. This is season 16, episode 17. We are live with Ben Arc and this episode is sponsored by Citrea, LayerTwo Labs, SideShift.ai, Bitcoin.com News, NoOnes.com, and Hodling.ch. Ben is the CEO of Nostr as well as the lead developer and the creator of LNbits. I remember seeing LNbits when it was just a command line Lightning application, and he has been refining it ever since. I think the goal has been to turn LNbits into the WordPress of Lightning applications. And also, we have to announce during this episode that v1 of LNbits is coming this week, right? It's really good to have you again, Ben.
1:33Ben ArcYeah, good to be back on, Vlad. Thank you for having me. I'm going to have to correct you. I'm not the lead developer. I am the CEO of Nostr, so whatever. But I'm not the CEO of LNbits. I'm the lead mascot of LNbits. Not the CEO, sorry. I'm not the lead developer of LNbits. I'm the lead mascot. There's much better qualified developers in LNbits now, thank God, which is why we're able to come out of beta and go into version one. We've had a huge code refactor, and it's got these new bells and whistles, which I'll be excited to showcase and show you in a little while. And then, yeah, excited to be back on. Thanks for having me.
2:11Vlad CosteaSo you're telling me that everyone who's been using LNbits so far has been using a beta version and v1 is just coming out now?
2:21Ben ArcYeah. So, I mean, when does a software project go production? So there's lots of software projects within our space in particular where they shouldn't probably go production as soon as they do. But they want people to have faith in the software which they're running. So they say that they're production software and they have a version one and then the version two, whatever. Whereas for us, we were always very conservative about it. We were like... can we in full faith say to people you can use this and there's not a risk of you losing money and up until now we couldn't.
2:51So yes, lots of people have been using it, and there's lots of companies and projects who have it in their software stacks. Lots of people use it in production out there. We use it in production as well. But we didn't want to apply that version one to it. We didn't want to bring it out of beta until we were fully confident that the software was ready. And it was a, you know, a lengthy process of agreeing that within the community of core developers who work on LNbits that we would all be happy for it to be coming out of beta. And we had to find a consensus, meet courtesy when it came to agreeing that it was ready.
3:28And now it's ready. But yeah, it's been five years, five years of blood, sweat and tears. Thousands of commits and I think we're like eight and a half thousand commits. And there's a great video actually on the LNbits YouTube showing what a free and open source project looks like. It's a visualization of all the commits which have happened to LNbits over the years. And when you watch it, you just realize how much work has been put into this thing. So exciting times.
3:56Vlad CosteaYou're saying that it's been five years, but I recall seeing a demo of LNbits in October at the Transylvania Crypto Conference. You were there, right? October of 2019. So it's been almost six years since you've been working on this.
4:12Ben ArcNo, I don't think that was a demo of LNbits. I think I demoed... it was the first LNURL-withdraw. And I was doing it through command line, I think, and it showed a QR code on the screen, the QR code and then get the funds. But I don't think LNbits was live then. Because I started working on it. I started it was sort of '20, it was during the COVID period, I think. No, it was before COVID. And then during COVID, then it was a good experience.
4:44Vlad CosteaI remember you also came to The Lightning Conference in Berlin, like a month later.
4:49Ben ArcYeah, yeah. No, I think we had the hardware stuff. So, you know, we built some of the POSs and... started on the ATM and some of the hardware gizmos, but LNbits wasn't quite... I don't think it was being worked on then. So basically, like, I... was in a bunch of groups with a bunch of other developers. And we're all very excited about this crazy new technology where we can send microtransactions and Bitcoin payments as microtransactions over the internet, no trusted third party and privately. And then it was like, what can we build with this? And we're all building our own different projects and then sharing them with each other. But it was clear that we were often replicating work that, you know, you're making a piece of software that sits on top of a funding source and then allows you to do API calls to it.
5:37And then you have some extra functionality, which does the thing. So rather than replicate all that work, it made sense that we all kind of piled in and collaboratively worked on a common API, which you could connect different funding sources to. So if you're using LND and then for whatever reason you want to try using Core Lightning, then you could easily just swap it out and it means that you don't have to refactor anything which sits on top. But then also, it being able to be used as just a UI, so being able to be used as a wallet account system.
6:09At that time, there were some custodial platforms like OpenNode and LNPay, which existed, but it made sense that there was kind of a free and open source version of that, which people could run themselves where they could make a wallet account system, offer wallet services to their friends, family, or local community, or whole world if they want to, and then also make it really easy to build on top of. So each wallet has its own API key, for example. So you can kind of limit risk to all the funds which are sitting on the node. Because at that time, you know, nodes didn't have, like in LND you couldn't even do like self-payments, you know.
6:46So if you were building on top of Lightning, there was kind of these pain points where you would have to build a wallet account system on top of, you know, your node first if you're offering your users wallet services or something. And then we always built in that extension framework as well. So people could then share those little ideas, those little bits of extra functionality on the software. And then luckily enough, because I got the thing started, because I kind of, I could see that there was a need for this thing to exist. But then, straight away, like it pulled in some great developers like Eneko, who was quite active in the Bitcoin space at that time.
7:25And then fiatjaf as well. They came into LNbits and later on we end up, you know, we have people like dni and Vlad and Tal and the whole great slew, and Stick from SatoshiLabs. at Stick. So we have a whole bunch of great contributors to the project. They've seen that it's an important project which needs to exist just to kind of take out the heavy lifting, make it easier to build projects on top of Lightning, Bitcoin, and then also share ideas and share things that you've built through the extensions.
7:59Vlad CosteaYeah, and I do like the modularity of LNbits. It's not like a one-trick pony. It's not like a node management software or just a payment software or just a typical wallet. There's so much you can do with it. You can integrate games. You can integrate all sorts of applications. You can turn your wallet into a point of sale. It comes with all of these cool... apps that you just add to your account. And that's something which I always respected, that it doesn't necessarily try to be something in particular, but allows developers to build plugins, just like WordPress.
8:42Ben ArcYeah, exactly. So it makes it relevant for everybody then, doesn't it? So, and increases your user base. It's, you know, a simple wallet account system with a nice API to build on top of. And then... you have all these extensions which you can, you know, you can either install through the vetted extension list, which are extensions where we've actually vetted the releases, and made sure that the code's not doing anything funky, or you can... build your own extension if you want to, or you can go and, you know, install some extension, which isn't in the vetted list or somebody else might have a list of extensions, which you could connect to and then use those extensions if you want to.
9:18But yeah, it means that it's relevant for everybody. And with it being easy to build on top of, we get a lot of contributions. We are averaging maybe one or two extensions being contributed a month, which we have to go through and then check and then bring into the vetted extension list. We're up to about 50 extensions now. One of the great things, so obviously you can use it through the UI and it's very powerful. But... the API is very powerful as well. So if you, if you, this is why it's quite attractive to people building projects on top of LNbits, because you've built your project on top of LNbits.
9:52I don't know, maybe it's a Telegram Lightning bot or something. And then maybe you're making use of a couple of extensions like the withdraw extension. So your users can do /withdraw, put in an amount and it will generate a faucet link which you could share or something, I don't know. Well, if a new, you know, one of the, a couple of the extensions I've been working on more recently, I've been working on a couple of gambling extensions, which are a lot of fun, like a coin flip extension. Well, now that exists, if you've built your Telegram Lightning bot on top of LNbits, you can then just install that extension and you get access to all those API endpoints and you can offer that through your front end. So now in your Telegram Lightning bot, you can do /coinflip and you can generate a coin flip like you used to be able to do in LNTXBOT, which was very popular and fun.
10:40So you're always... If you're using it in the stack, you're always benefiting from all this amazing sort of research and development which is happening within our developer community and all the other people who are building extensions. You can just pull them in and then you can offer that functionality to your users on the front end. And we got great extensions. We've got like a bolt swapping extension so you can swap between on-chain and Lightning and Liquid, which is really powerful. And you have the POS and we've got split payments.
11:10And we find because it's such a nice sandbox and because it's relatively easy to develop on top of and we're making it easier, you know, as we always work towards making it easier and easier to build on top of. Yeah, because... because it's easy to develop on, we find, and it's a good sandbox, we find that lots of great ideas first happen through LNbits. So, you know, we had the first Lightning POS. We had kind of the first split payments technology. We were the only way which you could run like your own LNURL server for a couple of years.
11:45Cashu was originally like LNbits extension. Nostr came out of, partly came out of an extension me and fiatjaf were working on for decentralized marketplaces. So we find it's a nice breeding ground for ideas because it's, you know, it's attractive. You if you have a great idea for something. To build with microp payments you make an bits extension and now rather than having to point people to some GitHub repo and have them install your software they can just one click you know install and then it pops up and then they enable it and boom they've got access to the thing you've built. So it's a great platform.
12:22Vlad CosteaYeah, and I have to ask because people have been using LNbits for about five years now. What is different about v1 from a user's perspective?
12:33Ben ArcI mean, it's smoother. So the front end is much smoother than it used to be. There's been a huge refactor in the back end to just get the code to the quality and standard, which it should be at for money software. And then the extension framework, we now have the paid extension feature. So a developer can develop an extension and then sell it in the marketplace for, you know, 10,000 satoshis or something, which is really nice. We've made it much easier to kind of customize. Because, like, our model isn't to go door-to-door onboarding merchants.
13:08Our model is to create a piece of software which other people can run and then they can offer merchant services to their local town and they can onboard all the cafes and bars or whatever to accept Bitcoin payments and those users can then make use of the PoS extension and then maybe the Boltz extension to swap out to on-chain to keep their funds safe. And then we want to encourage those people by empowering those users who are running it to encourage adoption to enable them to make money. So, you know, within the LNbits they can charge like a transaction fee. They can charge their users to enable extensions.
13:50There's an area for them to have like a little advertising link. So it's all about kind of making those incentives and feedback loops, those flywheels, where it's like, people, you know, for $10 or something, somebody can spin up an LNbits and then that afternoon go out, start onboarding merchants and create a little business in their local community. So it's like, you know, Bitcoiners generally want adoption. And they want to encourage people to experience this amazing payments technology. And then also, you know, they can make some money on it as well.
14:20And then all of that goes back into supporting it as a free and open source project and helping it grow. That's the way in which we kind of propagate and encourage adoption through something like LNbits. It's rather than going door to door, it's more empower people to run this thing and make it their own. And so we make customizing it that little bit easier. So you can kind of brand it to your own theme.
14:44There's nothing worse than if you're using like a free and open source piece of software and there's these like hardcoded links and things which you can't get rid of and you have to do some CSS, you know, display: none to try and get rid of all these little links. So we don't want to do that. We want, you know, we want someone to be able to take LNbits, make it their own, pretend to everybody they built this thing themselves, aren't they a genius? That's fine. Because ultimately they're an LNbits user and they're encouraging adoption and they're helping Bitcoin adoption. And yeah, so we make it much easier to customize.
15:21What else do we do? Oh, we've got some crazy tools like in the... I could actually share a screen. Let me share a screen. It's probably easier. So I'm going to skip some stuff. And then everyone will be cross at me for... what I'm missing, because obviously, you know, developers spend a lot of time working on this stuff. So if I then go and skip some functionality there, they'll get quite bitter about it. So this is kind of the wallet front end of LNbits. And we've got some like nice, it's a bit smoother now when you're like switching between wallets, you've got this ability, you can put all the wallets you've got on the top as opposed to just in the side which is pretty sweet. You could do things like, you know, you can change the little icon if you want to.
16:01For better money management stuff. And then if we head on over to, you know, if you're running this as a service, then if we head on over to users, then you can easily see the users and do some problem solving with them and your customers. We can keep an eye on the API to see what API endpoints people are hitting, which is a great feature. Particularly if, you know, people are trying to DoS you. People are DDoSing you.
16:27And then, you know, we've got a payments overview here, so we can kind of see all the payments which are coming in and out of our LNbits server. And then obviously, yes, of course, we've got all these amazing extensions. And you'll just see that the front end UI is that little bit smoother. And a bit more reactive. So these are the extensions this server has installed on it, but obviously, you know, you've got some extra extensions in here which aren't... And then if I go over to settings, we get like an overview of, you know, this demo server we have running is running on phoenixd.
17:03And then we get like a delta between the amount of coins or the amount of bitcoin which LNbits thinks it has and then how much is actually on the node. There's a small disparity here. This one's because I think we took out some funds actually from the node itself. But then we have something like the watchdog service, so we can say if this disparity becomes too much, then shut down all payments incoming and outgoing in your LNbits install, because that probably means you're under attack. So it's really like, you know, not only have we worked really hard to refactor the code and then make LNbits the software more secure, it's also about the security suite.
17:43So it's also about building in a whole bunch of tools. So if whatever reason your install does become compromised, maybe you leak a, you know, someone sees you typing in your password or whatever for your super admin account, there's only so much damage which can be done until the... security features kind of kick in. So we have, yeah, we can like block IP addresses, we can enable server log, which I won't do. And we can like rate limit requests. So if people are hitting endpoints trying to DoS you and get into your system, we can block IPs. This person's in the naughty bin because they've been naughty. And if we go over to things like payments, we can like limit the maximum incoming and maximum outgoing of payments from wallets. And then, oh sorry, for generating invoices, and then we have a limiter for wallets. We can charge our service fee.
18:39And then, cool things. So this is a great feature, look at this. So, often, say, in LNbits, we have, you know, like an exchange rate tracker, so we can kind of keep an eye on the Bitcoin price. This is a new feature. You just see the Bitcoin price here. But then also, you know, in your wallet, you have like a fiat denomination, which a lot of wallets have. A lot of lightning wallets have. Well, in settings, before we were sourcing all the exchange rates from all these different providers in the back end and then averaging out what the price of Bitcoin was. Whereas now we have this great tool, which is built by Vlad Stan, and we can actually add or remove different oracles, different exchange rates from this list if we want to. And then this is the thing which then powers LNbits to be able to do that fiat conversion. But it's actually just quite interesting seeing the graph of the exchange rate.
19:34But if you're developing a project on top of Bitcoin, this is a really powerful tool in itself, is just being able to just sort of take an average from all these different exchange providers and then also manage those exchange providers as well. In users here, we can add people to the admin. We can have an allow list. So we can have only, you know, these users can actually access this LNbits. So you can lock down your LNbits. Maybe you just want to use it yourself, or maybe you just want your family to use it or the merchants you've onboarded to use it.
20:07And then if we go into extensions here, you can add your different manifest. So this is a manifest for the vetted extension list. If we go over to here, these are all the releases for all the extensions which we vetted. So we've gone in and actually, like, vetted the code. And that's what's used to pull those extensions into LNbits when you first install it and you first enable and install those extensions. And then I won't click on notifications because I'm kind of worried that I might dox something on here and do an over-the-shoulder attack.
20:39But in here you can have, this is a great tool, you can have, Nostr, you can have your LNbits DM you on Nostr, giving you updated information. Like if there's a big transaction, it will DM you. Or if your server goes up or down, it will DM you. And then you can also use it with Telegram and you can use it with email as well. But that's a great tool. I'm using it all the time. I'm always checking my Nostr DMs on my Nostr client and just seeing how the server is rather than having to actually physically check in on the server.
21:11Then we have things like a, you know, a library, being able to easily add images to your LNbits, and then use those natively in LNbits for things like your site customization. So if you want to go in here and say you want to have a background image, or you want to change the logos, or even the little, you know, when you have a QR code in LNbits, that little image in the center of the QR code, you can customize all that there. So it's very powerful. Lots of customization features, a big security suite with all these security tools in, as well as just a much smoother user experience.
21:46And also as well, so... on security, like if I go to... and then if I go to Docs. We now have, like, this is where you can come and play around with the LNbits API through the Swagger. We also have a... the ability to create tokens. So rather than using API keys, you can create tokens with restricted read and write access, which I'm not going to demo too much because again I don't want to like leak any tokens, but it is a much more kind of secure API experience. But yeah, it's great. It's a, it's a real powerful suite of tools now.
22:29And yeah, a little UI stuff as well. Like we've added the price, the payments tracker to some graphs to the, to the wallet UI as well. And then of course, if you're using the wallet UI mobile version, you can limit and make it look a bit simpler, like you would expect it to be in a mobile wallet. But as you know, it's a progressive web app, so you can use it natively in your, on your mobile.
23:02But pretty powerful stuff. I don't want to fiddle around too much with that server because that is actually our not production but our demo server which we're running and I've been running to test version one. And this is quite important actually that there is real money at risk when we're testing this stuff. So we have our demo server, I've got sats on there. And then, you know, I obviously hope they don't get stolen, but it needs to be kind of a bit of a honeypot for people to try and attack, and people do try and attack it.
23:31So really, this is the other huge feature which LNbits has. which is maybe less spoken about, is that because people have been using it for five years and because people have been, you know, like IBEX, the bank, was using it to offer products and services. There's all this hardening which has happened from real world experience and suffering, which you can then benefit from. You know, you're benefiting from those five years of hardening of LNbits being out there in the wild, people running it, their servers being attacked.
23:58And now we've built you know, all that. We've fixed all that. All that hardening has happened to LNbits. And then we've added the security suite on top as well. So again, makes it very attractive to people building a Bitcoin project. Because if you're building some service, maybe you're doing, I don't know, a paid video streams service, you know, built on top of Lightning, you're going to have like a dozen exploits straight off the bat, particularly if you're adding things in like LNURL payments, because there's a whole bunch of race conditions and issues which they can have. Well, that hardening has happened to LNbits. So yeah, a lot of fun.
24:43Vlad CosteaYeah, that was a very fun demo that you just showed. I feel sorry for the people who will listen to this on Spotify. So I recommend that you check out the YouTube video. You're going to have a more in-depth presentation that helps you understand how LNbits works. But at the same time, it's just simple to go to LNbits.com and try the features, right?
25:05Ben ArcYeah, if you go to LNbits.com, there's a link to our demo service. It's a demo service, so please don't put... you know, just put some sats on there just to play around with. And we've said this for years, but it's amazing how many people... use that as an actual server and start... We've had issues in the past with people.
25:23So I think in the future, what we'll probably do is run the demo server for like a week and then just shut it down and take everyone's sats on there and just rug pull everyone every week on our demo server just to like encourage people not to leave their money on the demo server. But yeah, we try and make it as easy as possible to spin up. So again, so in version one, there's like an AppImage. You can just pull it onto your VPS and then just run the AppImage, and it will just spin up super fast.
25:52We have a software-as-a-service product from LNbits, the company. Currently, that's in testing, but it works and you can use it. But it's the older version of LNbits because we haven't released version one yet. And then also... It's not something we have like a full-time DevOps team, which we should probably have managing that service. So it is like, you know, use it at your own risk. But if you want, you can go on there and you can spin up LNbits on the software as a service. And then... over time, shortly, we should be making that service a little bit more professional so you can rely upon it.
26:25So ultimately, yeah, you could just go to LNbits.com and then use the software as a service to spin up an LNbits, and then maybe fund it with like a managed node, such as a phoenixd or a Greenlight or something underneath it. So it could be a really easy and straightforward user experience. But for now, if you want to go play around the demo server, then feel free. And then also, we have two days until we release version one.
26:49And if there's anyone out there who wants to do some testing on the last release candidate we have, which is RC10, Then pop over to the LNbits repo and install LNbits RC10, play around with it. And you won't find any big bugs. Obviously, they've all been patched. But, you know, if you find any little things you think we should tweak or whatever, then please report them. We've got two days left until release.
27:12Vlad CosteaThat must be exciting, right? You've been working on this for such a long time.
27:17Ben ArcYou know what? It's when you actually just use the software you get excited about it. So, cause we're building on it all the time. Quite often, I sit there and I just play around the software. I just think this thing's flipping... it's so powerful. Like, it's such a powerful piece of software. And it's so light and it runs. It's so snappy. And you can run it on, like, the cheapest, you know, $3 a month VPS. And it works great. I think the demo server I've got on, like, a $3 VPS. And, yeah, it's... and building extensions as well.
27:48I was building... oh, I made a cool extension because I had this – I don't know why. I don't like gambling, but making gambling software is pretty fun. So I made the coin flip extension. And then I got excited and I made a lottery extension. So people could pay an invoice, give it your LN address, pay an invoice, and then on a given date. It just picks randomly somebody and then it just pays the funds minus the registration fee.
28:13Well, I made like a new version of that. Which is like the numbers, you know, the numbers racket, which was very popular before. countries had their own lotteries, which is where you would... So say in the US, for example, I think in New York, there was the racetrack in New York and it would generally make, you know, hundreds of thousands of dollars a day or millions of dollars a day. And you would bet on what the last three numbers were in the amount of money which that racetrack had made.
28:44And people would take bets, you know, the day before the numbers were released and then whoever won those numbers, you would then win X amount. So I made a numbers kind of lottery. So you give it an LN address, you pay an invoice, you give it an LN address, you select... well, as an admin, you go in and you say, okay, this is going to be a two-number kind of lottery or it's going to be a three-number lottery or four-number lottery or five-number lottery, and then that determines the odds.
29:13So if it's a three-number lottery, you know you're going to win 100x or whatever which you pay. So that you then pick a number like zero... no, sorry, a thousand, you would win 1,000, so a thousand x. So you pick a number between zero and 999. You give it an LN address. You pay an invoice, and then you... And the lottery closes on a date. And then when it closes, it gets the previous block, Bitcoin block. And then it's, it creates a number based on the last numbers of the hash of the last Bitcoin block or the most recent Bitcoin block when the lottery closes. And that's how it generates that number.
29:50So it's like the numbers racket, except instead of having the racetrack numbers, the amount of money a racetrack makes as your oracle for the numbers, it's using the Bitcoin blocks to get those. So it was kind of fun. Anyway, I made that and I was playing around making that extension. And I was like, it's so easy to make an extension now. Because there's so many examples of other extensions where you can go in and you can just clone them and then rip out the functionality you don't want and put in the stuff you do need.
30:20But then also just the, it just works. It's just snappy. You know, there's loads of WebSockets in the background now for verifying payments. So when you make a payment, it's just boosh, it just works. It's just nice to build on, and it just works well. And it's dependable, too. Those first few years of LNbits, you know, the server would crash. You'd have to keep kicking it to wake it up. And then sometimes if you made a payment, it wouldn't, like, you'd have to refresh the page for it to register. And there's just none of that shit exists anymore. It just works so well. That really is a credit to the incredible developers we have in LNbits. As I said, I'm the lead mascot. I'm not like the lead developer. We've got great talent in the room. And we're very lucky to have such talented folks who work on LNbits.
31:07Vlad CosteaYeah, I got to give some love to the chat. There is Tom Dwyer who says... LNbits rocks, the plethora of tools is incredible. What safety guarantees can LNbits provide for plugins? And is there any code review to prevent someone uploading malicious code? Love you both. There's also BT.
31:27Ben ArcLet me answer that one. I'll answer that one first or else we won't be able to keep track. So as I said before, we have our, it's kind of like WordPress in that if you create an extension, you submit it to WordPress. And then someone verifies the code or a group of people verify the code. And then it's allowed to be included in WordPress. So it's kind of like that. But a little bit more diligent, obviously, because it's money software.
31:52If you create an extension and then you want everybody to have access to it when they first install LNbits, then you need to submit it to the vetted extension. It's a GitHub repo. You just submit it. You make a pull request to our manifest where you add the extension, your repo, and then it's a hash of the release. So we can then go over to the release, pull the release, hash it, make sure the hash matches, and then we can verify the code. And then when LNbits installs that extension, it's pulling that exact release. It's not pulling another release.
32:23It's pulling the exact release which we vetted. And then when it comes to the vetted extensions in LNbits, we need three of kind of the core developers who work on LNbits to sign an extension or a release of an extension off, in order for it to make it into the LNbits, kind of marketplace. But then, ultimately, if you're reckless, you could just go pull the manifest off some forum somewhere and install it into your LNbits. But I mean, obviously be careful doing that because it's risky.
32:50Although if it's, you know, so we have like some users and there's the Bitcoin beer tap people and they've got kind of a fork of the Bitcoin switch project where it's an automated beer tap and you go and pay Lightning and then it pours your beer for you. Well, they have their own custom LNbits extension, which isn't in the LNbits marketplace because it's part of their kind of product. You know, you buy the beer tap and then when you buy the beer tap, they send you the extension or they give you a link to the extension. So you can actually install the extension on your LNbits install.
33:24And that's nice as well. So it's all about kind of being flexible for developers, extension developers, and how they want to share their extensions, whether they want to share it publicly, keep it private, whatever, it doesn't really matter. Whether they want it to be paid or non-paid, free, whatever. It's fine.
33:40Vlad CosteaBTC4Plebs on the chat says that he's very stoked for v1. And Kukks, Andrew Camilleri, I hope I pronounced that correctly. He used to work at BTCPay. I think now he's at Ark Labs. He says, Ben is always such a beast. Starts off with a small explanation, which explodes into 100 demos.
34:03Ben ArcYeah. Is that Kukks? Kukks, Kukks.
34:06Vlad CosteaYeah, I call him Kukks, but you say...
34:10Ben ArcYeah, it's a good dude, man. Yeah, no, I, yeah, yeah. I'm known for... I get excited and then I start demoing, and then also someone will ask a question and then I'll start demoing something and then about 20 minutes later I'll be like, "What was the fucking original question? I hope I've answered it." And my response is just to keep talking and keep demoing. But yeah, it's like a bit of an issue I have is trying to be concise. and answer things in a simple way. The worst experience I ever had of that was at Bitcoin...
34:36So I go to some of these conferences and then you do your demos at the conferences for new things you've built, whatever. And I went to the Bitcoin Amsterdam conference and they had the free and open source stage. And I had like a Nostr panel and then I ran across to my talk on the free and open source stage and it was an hour long talk, right? I go in and like the room's packed. I'm like, well, this is cool. There's loads of people here to show LNbits to and show them how cool the software is.
35:02And I get up, I get my laptop, I put it on the thing and then I'm like, okay, so where's the HDMI wire to plug in because I want a demo.
35:11And then they said, oh, no, you can't plug your laptop in. And it's like, if you've got a free and open source stage, you can always plug your laptop in. It's like I took it for granted that you can plug your laptop in. So I didn't have a presentation. It was just me demoing stuff on my laptop. And so I was just stood in front of like hundreds of people with nothing to show them. I mean, it was just that I couldn't plug in my laptop. So what am I going to do?
35:36So I just stood there and it's like, honestly, about 500 people there or 300, 400 people there. And it was an hour of me explaining LNbits and then running around the stage, trying to figure out how I can plug my laptop in to show it on the screen. And then it was kind of funny because eventually we managed to do it, but I had to make a reverse proxy, which the guy at the bar would then pull up LNbits on his laptop and then show it.
36:00But it was like, you know, those nightmares you have where you turn up for work and you forgot to wear your trousers or something. Those anxious nightmares you have. I bet with you, like, you have, I don't know, you're interviewing why die and the audio doesn't work or something. I bet you have those nightmares. Have you had those nightmares?
36:22Vlad CosteaIt actually happened when I interviewed Slush and our audio was not working. You know, the guy who invented pool mining in Bitcoin and the Trezor. And that was so embarrassing.
36:33Ben ArcI bet. It sucks. I mean, it's bound to happen in real life. It's the entropy of life, isn't it? But it was one of those nightmares where I think I probably had that nightmare before where you're on stage and you've got literally nothing to show anybody and there's always people just looking up at you. But it was one of those real world nightmare situations for demoing. There we are.
36:54Vlad CosteaYeah, anyway, I want to move the conversation a bit into Lightning Network and whether or not LNbits is still custodial and its competition and stuff like this. But before that, let me plug a couple of sponsors. First of all, let's talk about LayerTwo Labs. They're building drivechains. And it's not just some idea that's being presented on Twitter Spaces every night. They actually have the software for it. So you go to layer2labs.com/download.
37:21You're going to find the clients for Bitcoin Core, for a big block Bitcoin, for a Zcash privacy sidechain for Bitcoin, for BitNames, which is sort of... like Namecoin, I think, and something like BitAssets, which is a fork of Ethereum, which includes all the features that you find in Ethereum. And you can download this and it's on the Bitcoin Signet, if I'm not mistaken. You can figure out how this works. There's also a Telegram channel that's called Drivechain Talk, where you can ask people to send you some coins so that you can experiment with this feature. And there is another sponsor which is trying to become part of the future of Bitcoin.
38:05It's called Citrea. They did the first ZK rollup on Bitcoin and they're trying to build financial applications which are more trust minimized than trusting BitGo with WBTC. I think WBTC, which is wrapped Bitcoin on Ethereum right now is... like 50 times bigger than Lightning, if not more. There's a lot of liquidity there. It's super trusted. You have to trust that the custodian is going to do a good job. So Citrea is trying to decentralize it with ZK rollups on Bitcoin. And they also have an application, they have something that's working and you can download. It's on the Bitcoin testnet number three or four.
38:51And it's available at citrea.xyz. So that's citrea.xyz. Check that out if you're a nerd like myself. And now, Ben, let's talk about the state of Lightning, because it seems like it had a peak sometime in 2021, around the time everyone was enthusiastic about it. And then I think it was in 2023 that Antoine Riard made this reveal that there are some vulnerabilities which are sort of dangerous. It was about HTLCs, if I'm not mistaken. And since then, it seems like Lightning startups have started to fade. I can't think... of too many of them that are profitable nowadays. And there's this... sentiment that makes people turn their heads to different layer two solutions. And maybe Lightning is just getting delayed from happening. What's your take on this?
39:48Ben ArcBuilding this stuff is hard, and Lightning is a load easier to engage with and do things, you know, run a node in a self-custodial way than it was a year ago. And then, you know, it's, it will be easier in a year's time. Like it's really, you're creating a layer for microtransactions without trusted third parties on Bitcoin. It takes time and it's hard. And I just feel that, you know, some people, they just get impatient. You know, there's this exuberance when suddenly you've got this new tool and it's like, oh, the reality is this new tool needs improving. And that's, that's fine.
40:25That's how it works. But I can see why some people... feel the need to look for another solution somewhere else. For me, it's about improving the thing we have, making it work better. And I'm still blown away by Lightning. You know, it's like we take it for granted that you can do a sub-penny transaction instantly over the internet and for it to verifiably transact value from one person to another for a sub-penny amount, for a microtransaction with no trusted third parties and without having to reveal your private data.
40:58That's huge. And that has incredible implications for streamlining and making the world's economy work better. And, you know, there was a lot of... I think it's kind of incentives, you know, like there's, like you said, early on with the Lightning Network, a whole bunch of VCs, for example, piled in, invested in a bunch of startups, companies, projects or whatever. And then the hard work begins of actually building the things which people are doing. The next thing comes along. You know, there's an incentive for the people who are driving the next thing to say, oh, this, you know, there's an incentive then to kind of like downtalk the success or what Lightning is capable of, and in order to kind of shield their own bags because they're pushing whatever thing they're working on to the VCs, to the users, to whatever.
41:50So there's always these incentives against Lightning. And for people to downplay its successes. And then people say to me that not many people use Lightning, but I use it every day. I'm on Nostr and I'm zapping people and then I'm doing microtransactions, paying for stuff. And I think that we have lots of users on Lightning. I mean, a lot of nodes went private, went dark. So it's really hard to kind of calculate how many people are actually running nodes on the Lightning Network and how many people are actually using it.
42:18Yeah, it's... to me, I'm still blown away and in complete awe of the technology of just being able to send tiny amounts of value through the internet without having to reveal private data and without a trusted third party. And to me, it's kind of the solution when it comes to medium of exchange type payments. We just need to make it easier. And there's a gazillion ways in which you can improve Lightning and make it easier. It just takes time to build those things.
42:44And it does go slower, obviously, if you have less people working on solving those problems, which you do if it's no longer the trendy, cool technology in town. I do think as well, like within our world of Bitcoin and whatever, like there's like an oversaturation of protocols, maybe, you know, like if something doesn't instantly work... It's a bit like, Bitcoin early on didn't work and people spent time to work on it. And then you had all these people who got annoyed by it because it wasn't doing the thing they wanted it to do. So they forked off and they made their own protocols.
43:18And then a bunch of people stayed in Bitcoin and then continued to improve Bitcoin. And that was important. And it's kind of the same with Lightning, that you just need a bunch of people to stay there, continue to improve it. And if people want to fork off and make more protocols doing this and that, then they can. But for me, like, you know, we're building an application on Lightning.
43:41You know, it can be interoperable with other stuff like Liquid, for example, or even drivechains, whatever. Like, you know, it could still work on top of, pretty much anything, but, you know, our focus is working on Lightning Network because for us that's the number one game in town when it comes to payments and medium of exchange. And we're busy just building the application. And that's another point. It's like you can have a gazillion different protocols, but you need people to actually build functional and useful applications and to stay on a protocol for long enough to actually build stuff which works and works reliably, which we do, you know, on the Lightning Network because we're very bullish on it. I'm still in awe of the power of the technology.
44:25Vlad CosteaI got to ask you because you've been working alongside fiatjaf on LNbits and fiatjaf seems pretty sour about the Lightning Network. So I find this quite a paradox. He doesn't seem to be bullish on Nostr either anymore, even though he's sort of...
44:43Ben ArcHe's just a grumpy man. I'm just going to warn him. God bless him. No, he's a... If you create something like Nostr, you would shill the hell out of it, wouldn't you? If it was your baby and there's all these people using it, for him to be like... Yeah, for him to be FUDing on his own creation, it's quite magnificent. Yeah. No, I mean, I think he got frustrated with... you know the lack of progression with Lightning and in the Bitcoin ecosystem, but, you know, understandably, he wants certain things to exist and to be able to build certain things. We had an extension in LNbits for a long time called Hivemind. And when you opened the extension, it said, this does not exist yet. If BIP 300 gets activated, this will exist. And it was like some sort of social thing.
45:32But that was one of fiatjaf's, and it existed on LNbits for a long time. And I think he just got frustrated with the slowness of, you know, of things being advanced on Bitcoin. And the primary focus for him became Nostr for obvious reasons, because it became very popular and it's great, insane technology. But yeah, he's, you know, the world needs... creative inventors who create an idea, move on to the next thing, create an idea, move on to the next thing. And I will say that the amount of hours that guy must work, to do everything he does. And, you know, although he may publicly FUD on Nostr, I don't know, I haven't seen it, but although, like you say, maybe he does publicly FUD on it, you know, he's grinding hard and putting the hours in to build tools on top of it.
46:22I think it's probably more... I mean, if you look at any honest... good, free and open source software, it's slow to adopt. Bitcoin was slow to adopt anything. You look at LibreOffice or GIMP or Kdenlive or any free and open source project because they don't have that marketing team, because it's like an honest project. It's there in the background. You have like a spike of users, you get it because it's a thing that now exists and they start using it. And then they find it's not entirely user-friendly because it's a free project, it takes a long time for it to become user friendly. And then you find you have your users kind of peter out a little bit, and then it just naturally starts to arc up, then, your user base. And ultimately, it wins as the winning solution because other solutions can't compete with it. because of its free and open source nature.
47:14And that's kind of similar with something like Nostr, when you see... like for us in Nostr we were like okay, Twitter's clearly a bad idea and this platform can't exist owned by a private company. There needs to be an alternative. And then we built the alternative. And then when the world really needed it and needed somewhere else to go, you had this Bluesky thing, which a lot of them moved into. And I think it kind of, we all assumed that they would move into Nostr, but obviously Nostr is a little bit harder to use because it's like an honest, free and open source project.
47:47Bluesky isn't an honest, free and open source project. It's very centralized and the moderation is very centralized. So until Nostr becomes kind of easier to use and more people... I think more people are inevitably going to have to engage with public key cryptography, for example. Like when the world's ready, then we'll see that user base take up again, because it's such an elegant and great solution for building something like a Twitter.
48:10But for now, you know, I guess fiatjaf and some other people in Nostr, you know, and myself, you know, we were seeing the kind of adoption of Bluesky by people, which is kind of frustrating, because you're like, well, that's not the answer. You know, this thing's the answer to having a decentralized Twitter. It's not that thing over there, which is quite centralized, just pretending to be decentralized.
48:32Vlad CosteaBut before...
48:33Ben ArcI don't want to use the word decentralized.
48:35Vlad CosteaBefore Bluesky, there was Mastodon. I recall that one being popular at one point.
48:40Ben ArcYeah, there's a bunch. Scuttlebutt, Mastodon. I think the elegance of Nostr is it's just so simple. You've just got these things relaying data and you've got these WebSockets connected to them and some public key cryptography. And then it's like, what can you build with that new paradigm shift, with that new topology? So, you know, typically on the internet, your topology would be a server you connect to and then behind that server is a company or whatever. Well, the way it works with Nostr is you've got these relays and then you're sending and sharing data and those relays are just relaying that data.
49:21So it's like rather than say, okay, Nostr is a social networking platform. It's like, no, just with relays, you know, relaying data, WebSockets, client software with public key cryptography, what can we build? And to me, that transcends just social media, for example. Like one of the most inspiring, interesting projects for me on Nostr is the Nostr IoT stuff, which, like, Black Coffee's leading at the moment. And it's just being able to DM, essentially, devices in your home, tell them to turn on, give you a reading or whatever.
49:58But it's just so intuitively simple. Like if you're running an MQTT server or whatever, like it's fiddly and a pain in the ass, you have to open ports on your home network, blah, blah, blah. With this, you can have... self-custodial IoT solutions and you can have IoT hardware in your home without being worried that it's snooping on you or harvesting all your network data in a way which is very user-friendly, easy, doesn't require you to open any ports on your home router. So it's a superior solution when it comes to private, self-custodial IoT.
50:31And it's great for me because, you know, I love the idea of IoT, but then I can't use the thing because it's either too fiddly or you have to rely upon a private company. So that's like an example of like something else which is completely different to something like social media which you can build but then it's interoperable. So yes, it's not social media, but I have my Amethyst, you know, client on my phone. And like I said before, my LNbits can DM me and give me service updates about my LNbits install. And similarly, Black Coffee showed me a demo in his house. So he, you know, of course, he made me a cup of coffee when I got there because, you know, he's named Black Coffee.
51:17And the way he did it is he went to his coffee machine and said, make me a cup of coffee. And then boom, it made him a cup of coffee. That's quite interesting too. You know, when you start marrying some of these things up, like, maybe an AI agent with IoT. And then you can just literally just chat to your house and say, oh, turn the lights on and off, turn this on, and then it will just translate that data for you.
51:41And so I just think that the amount of development and research which is happening, enthusiasm which happens in the Nostr world and the Lightning world, it shouldn't be underestimated. Like, there aren't other solutions with that level of enthusiasm and that amount of great minds working on solving problems, coming up with ideas, building stuff. So, yeah, I mean, everyone keep an eye out for that, the Nostr IoT thing. And then other applications too, like, you know, you can build all sorts.
52:05Like one of the, I think it's like the third issue on the original Nostr repo, which I posted back when there was like 10 of us working on Nostr stuff, was like an Uber built on Nostr. I still want that to exist because it means that Uber could become kind of like a commons as a platform. And then similarly, you know, you're just using that client to book a cab.
52:27It'll find a cab which is near you. But because all the improvement proposals are interoperable, you can make use of people's social media software, such as, you know, the Twitter experience or an Amethyst or Damus, whatever they're using, to book a cab if you wanted to. Or that client software could be specifically designed to look something a little bit more like Uber. So yeah, I mean, for that it could be... I'm DMing. Would that work? No, I don't think that would work. That's a bad solution. But yeah, so I feel like that new topology we have... And also, that new topology, which has some hardening and has been worked on to the point where it's actually functional, and relays stay up and they're able to relay data properly, which takes time. What can you build with that? And I see... it replacing a lot of... you know, things on the internet.
53:32Vlad CosteaThere are so many possibilities. I guess I know it's a very common trope and we've been seeing this for years, but we're so early.
53:44Ben ArcYeah, we are, man. Yeah, like, there's people who are now interested in Bitcoin. But they're interested in a way... So, if we go back to Bitcoin, so I know we're hopping around a little bit, but so before you could say, oh, you know, that we're early and the world doesn't care about Bitcoin, right? Well, now it seems that the world does care about Bitcoin, but it's very much kind of that Michael Saylor, just accumulate Bitcoin, hold it. It's some speculative asset, some digital gold, whatever.
54:08But there's this great Adam Curry quote, which we had early on in LNbits, which was when he showed LNbits on... he was doing a podcast on Bitcoin and he talked about Bitcoin. He said, oh, you know, so he bought some Bitcoin, he's like, oh, this is cool. And then he thought, okay, what can I do next? So I ran a node and the Lightning node. And then it was like, okay, what can I do next? I installed LNbits. And then the quote is like, holy shit, look at all the things I can do with LNbits. Because it is like that.
54:43It's like, okay, you opt out of the banks and store your value in something like Bitcoin. Cool. And then when it's there, you then start getting access or you start being exposed to this wider ecosystem of solutions, like things built on the top of the Lightning Network. And suddenly you realize you could do all this stuff, and then you get excited about it, and then that tends to be people's, like... traditional path into exploring the technologies of Bitcoin. And I imagine it will be like that for this current phase of adoption which we have, where people are discovering its use case as digital gold.
55:21There's a lag to people then not just being interested in the digital gold use case, but it will happen that people will then go, what else can we do with this thing? Oh my God, look at all the things you can do with Bitcoin.
55:37Vlad CosteaYeah, if you ask me this whole speculative... side of it is what makes it more like a Ponzi, you know?
55:45Ben ArcYeah, totally. It's boring.
55:47Vlad CosteaI'm not sure about you, but we... Yeah, it's boring. We didn't get into Bitcoin because of this. I remember the promise that, okay, in the future, you're going to get a car accident. I mean, God forbid you ever get into a car accident, but let's say that two cars collide and then there's going to be a financial transfer between them that's automatic with Bitcoin. I mean, I used to think about this stuff. Now, it's pretty pessimistic when people say, well, it's not money anymore. I think it also has to do with regulations and just people adapting to existing regulations because they can't use it for payments in some parts of the world, especially the U.S. There's not much use for that. And right now in the European Union, we also have MiCA. I don't know how you pronounce that. MiCA. And that one basically asks you to provide origin of funds for every financial transaction. And that's why I don't have a Kraken account anymore.
56:46That's why I almost... lost my bank account because these guys keep asking you for proof that you got your money from someplace. But if it's on the Lightning Network, you don't have any, you know, on-chain proof, you can't prove anything. So it's really interesting. I've spoken with Marko Tarman, who is the mining manager from NiceHash. And he told me that they used to have this payment service for NiceHash on the Lightning Network. And they had to sort of phase that out because of... ongoing regulations. And it's messed up. To private. Yeah. Unfairly private.
57:26Ben ArcI think with the parallel banking stuff, which we know, the free and open source parallel banking, free and open source money, that people have kind of figured out that Bitcoin's too big to regulate and, you know, to destroy. Like you can't get rid of it. Right. And then I kind of feel that it will be the same for payments over time. They'll just realize it's too big to regulate when it comes to payments. It's like cash in your pocket. You know, you can't verify the source of funds at all times.
57:59It will take a while to get there, of course, but I... the process of us getting there is building the use cases and the tools and encouraging adoption, and then people accepting Bitcoin payments for services. So it's just waiting for it to happen. I mean, the way I kind of think of it is, you know John Nash and his Ideal Money? So you have this dialectic between... sort of fiat, centrally controlled currency, and then Bitcoin, because it now exists.
58:28And this is the Ideal Money dialectic, right? So fiat exists, it needs to compete with Bitcoin. So now they need to make digital fiat. So they look at the CBDCs, they look at trying to make a digital fiat. Bitcoin exists. And it's not in a vacuum. Bitcoin also needs to have synthesis with fiat. In that fiat has some properties which Bitcoin doesn't have, which it kind of needs, you know, like stability, for example. So we end up with a bunch of kind of stablecoin solutions. We end up with... what's that thing which Galoy built, the synthetic stablecoins using high-frequency trading. So you have like a whole bunch of solutions for trying it, because obviously, you know, the Lightning Network's incredible, but I think, honestly, one of its big drawbacks and one of the reasons it doesn't get widespread adoption, particularly in the unbanked world, is a stable medium of exchange.
59:19If you're, you know, on a subsistence salary, you need that money to be worth... roughly the same amount as what you earn in a month's time when you're going to pay your bills. So anyway, so there's a synthesis which happens where there's some solutions which come into Bitcoin where we can have some sort of stable medium of exchange, but it's still the Bitcoin stack and it's still Bitcoin. And then fiat tries to compete with it by making digital versions of itself. As that dialectic continues, and you have... thesis, antithesis, synthesis, and thesis, antithesis, synthesis, then the eventual ideal money is in fact Bitcoin. Because fiat has properties which Bitcoin can't currently compete with, but it will. And then Bitcoin has properties which fiat can't currently compete with, but it will try to. But the one property Bitcoin has, which fiat can't compete with, is decentralized, lack of trusted third parties, all that stuff.
1:00:23Ultimately, the ideal money ends up becoming Bitcoin, but it takes a while for that process to happen.
1:00:34Vlad CosteaYeah, I like your bullishness. I got to plug a couple more sponsors before moving on. And I did forget to ask you some questions. I'm going to follow up with them. Check out Bitcoin.com News. They used to be this website that couldn't distinguish between Bitcoin and BCH. Now they have a new team and they rebranded and they're BTC-based. I think they have much better news coverage than Bitcoin Magazine, to be honest. I don't want to knock too much on David Bailey and his affairs, but it's too focused on Trump and the strategic Bitcoin reserve. It became too political.
1:01:10Right now, if you go to news.bitcoin.com, you have news about Bitcoin from all over the world. There's even something from Hong Kong on the front page right now, which says Hong Kong's SFC issues staking guidance for crypto exchanges and funds. It feels like more of a coverage of the entire space and the entire world, as opposed to just being focused on what's happening in the US. And sometimes I also find coverage about gold, which this year has been a lot more interesting than over the last decade.
1:01:43So if you want to find some different kind of news, go to news.bitcoin.com. And it's actually pretty good. They do good journalism. And there's also SideShift. So if someone offers to pay you in stablecoins or Galoy synthetic, whatever... you don't want to hold on to that, right? You want to get free market decentralized money. So you go to SideShift, you basically ask the people who want to pay you in stablecoins to send to a specific address. And then you're going to receive the Bitcoin to your address. And the liquidity is pretty good. The fees are low.
1:02:21Basically, it's a convenient tool to convert something that someone wants to give you, but you don't like into something that you do like. It sort of solves this issue of double coincidence of wants. And it's pretty cool. Check out SideShift.ai. I've also interviewed their CEO in the previous episode, and he's a fun guy. You can also listen to him. And I was going to ask you, Ben, what do you think about other layer 2s outside of Lightning?
1:02:52You did mention very briefly that there's this Hivemind plugin into LNbits, so you do like drivechains. You also mentioned that in our previous interview. But what do you think about these ZK rollups, which seem to be very fashionable nowadays?
1:03:09Ben ArcIt's all cool. I want that stuff to exist, but I'm certainly not one of those people who, you know, looks at protocol suggestions or ideas and researches them too heavily until they kind of exist and I can build stuff. You know, I'm quite a practical hands-on type of person. And that's why I was able to engage with Lightning, because it existed and I was able to build on top of it.
1:03:33So yeah, if this stuff exists and it reaches consensus in Bitcoin as a whole, the community of Bitcoiners as a whole, decide that this thing is good, then I'll definitely build stuff on top of it. But yeah, ZK rollups are a great idea. It just takes time for adoption. But I do hope as well that obviously... people stay and build things on top of those ideas rather than then coming across a new idea, which they want to switch on to. So it's, yeah, it's, I quite like the fact that Bitcoin is slow moving.
1:04:05I know it's frustrating for a lot of people that it takes time for this stuff to get developed, but I really see that analogy just with good, free, and open source.
1:04:16For me, it's like a... a bullish sentiment, like something which encourages me when it comes to Bitcoin development is the slowness in adoption of things and the slowness of development, because it means that we're kind of honest. We're like an honest free and open source project, which has to find consensus and which is messy. It's like, you know, seeing a sausage made in public, it's messy and it's gross, but you end up with this beautiful sausage at the end of it. And that's Bitcoin and all good free and open source projects.
1:04:48Vlad CosteaThis sausage analogy is very fun. But I got to ask you, I've interviewed someone from Alby not so long ago, and they have this Alby Hub, which is very similar with what LNbits is offering. I was gonna ask you what sets LNbits apart from something like Alby Hub, and is LNbits custodial mostly or can you also run it on your own node?
1:05:13Ben ArcYeah, I mean, we encourage people to run it themselves, but obviously you can run it for other people as well. I tend not to... think too much about other projects which are taking on some of the properties of something like LNbits. Like, we were the first project to make that custodial model where you could, you know, the Uncle Jim model. We were the first Lightning project to have like a POS, the first Lightning project to allow you to do LNURL stuff.
1:05:38It's like we just build cool stuff and then if other projects see value in that and they want to build similar things and similar functionality into their projects, like we've seen more over time that a lot of these projects are taking a more modular approach of having extensions and things. It's just a compliment, really, that we're on the right track and rather than worry too much, we just build cool stuff. And if someone else sees value in that and they want to incorporate into whatever project they're running or building, then cool.
1:06:08It's a compliment. But for me, it's just about kind of looking forward and building and just building new stuff. And yeah. It's not something I kind of think about in an adversarial, competitive way. It's more a compliment, because you can't do that. I mean, this is the... I think you do initially. When you have a project and then you see, you know, other projects kind of sipping your Kool-Aid, and then initially you have kind of an adversarial, butthurt mentality from it.
1:06:39It's a bit like when people first started taking LNbits and then wrapping it and presenting it as their own thing which they built themselves without any attribution or props to LNbits or any contributions back up to LNbits. Initially, you know, it's something which you kind of take in quite a negative way. But then over time, there's just so much of it happening that you would just be stressed out all the time if you were to think about it too much.
1:07:10And then you just learn to see it as just a huge compliment, you know, that we've built a bunch of stuff which is so innovative and cutting edge and good that other people want to have that same functionality in their projects.
1:07:27Vlad CosteaI like this friendly approach that you have. You don't want to talk about your competition. I don't think you think about them at all. But I do recall that...
1:07:36Ben ArcIt's definitely... it's something you get asked, because, like, we're doing... for LNbits Inc., the company, we're doing a raise for that, and it's one of those questions the VCs ask. They say, "Okay, do a competitor analysis. Who are your competitors?" And it's always a question which just makes me wince and I don't like because I don't see anyone as competitors. You know, like, when the whole world's running on Bitcoin, all these solutions are very valid and people will use them. And our community of developers certainly isn't big enough for us to be arguing with each other. You know, we just pull in whatever ideas are good and use them and it's fine.
1:08:14Vlad CosteaI do remember and you mentioned it earlier that some stuff got built on your servers, and maybe you presented this as a joke, that you should rug people every month or so just to remind them that they should use non-custodial solutions. But what do you think about the fact that Cashu, which is an eCash implementation, got built on LNbits? And where does it operate nowadays?
1:08:41Ben ArcYeah, I mean, we were very encouraging. Like, Calle was working for LNbits at the time, and that gave him the, you know, the space to be able to work on Cashu. We were very encouraging of him. A lot of us worked on the... sorry, the Cashu extension in LNbits, and Cashu itself as well early on. You know, we're like Lightning guys. We like working on Lightning stuff, and it came time for Calle to move away from working for LNbits and then work, dedicate himself to Cashu. And he's built something. He's built a great developer community and user base for it. When it comes to eCash in general, it's not something which gets me super excited, but good luck to them. You know, and I certainly see that there are a whole bunch of use cases for the technology. Definitely. And yeah, it's exciting to see the developments which comes out of that space, definitely.
1:09:37And actually, so we had... for a long time, that was the easiest way to run your own Cashu mint was to just spin up the extension and then enable it. But the way the extension was kind of developed was because Nutshell itself was like chopped-up LNbits originally. And then so when you're installing the Cashu extension, you're essentially kind of installing a chopped up version of LNbits into LNbits. So it became a bit of a dependency nightmare.
1:10:03And I think the correct way to have that run, which I will note they always suggested from the beginning, was that Nutshell would be kind of a service, and then the Cashu extension would then be quite simple, and you would just be running the eCash mint via the extension, and then it would just talk to the service. So I do hope at some point... I mean, I'm not going to do it, but I hope at some point somebody builds another Cashu extension for LNbits so people can use it. But yeah, I mean, it's clearly a space which a lot of people are very excited about.
1:10:40You got Fedi and Cashu and... are there any other projects in the eCash space? They're the two dominant ones, I think.
1:10:48Vlad CosteaI don't know, but to me it sort of defeats the purpose, right?
1:10:52Ben ArcI mean, so with this, there's lots of things, there's lots of use... So I think, you know, like a not-shit CBDC could be like a Cashu mint. And... in that people get more private digital money. And it kind of makes sense. When it comes to... having private custodianship, there seems to be a conflict, you know, a conflict there, in that you end up with all of those things we criticize Monero for, that you could have an inflation bug, this and that could go wrong, the lack of evidence, like not having proof of reserves and stuff.
1:11:27But then also, like, you know, we built and run custodial software, and quite often you need to debug with users. Users forget their accounts, and you need to kind of debug with them, and you need that payment history in order to be able to debug. So it's almost like... approaching it from, say, what's in the, you know, like for what LNbits does, for example, if you approach running an eCash mint for that purpose, then it's almost like the private part of it becomes a bug rather than a feature, because it kind of makes running that custodial service a little bit harder.
1:12:06But if you approach it from a different angle, which is, you know, I don't know, a nation state, you know, having Bitcoin reserves and running eCash mints for their own kind of digital currency or whatever. And if you do it through a federation, maybe using something like Fedimint, and you could have a... so you can have soft currency functions in that scenario, such as being able to create more currency for fiscal stimulus or getting yourself out of depression or whatever countries need to be able to do. But maybe that federation needs to kind of reach a consensus and part of that federation could be government and the other part could be private industry. I think that's really exciting and I can definitely see a use case for the technology being used in, you know, in that use case, and then also things like paid API requests as well. It's pretty cool using eCash tokens.
1:12:56But when it comes to just kind of running a custodial mint in the Uncle Jim model, it's not something I kind of wrap my head around. But... Yeah, it's definitely got value. And it's like, you know, enjoy, like, work on that stuff, and obviously we see great things coming out of that space.
1:13:16Vlad CosteaIf there is anything that you could change to improve the Lightning Network design, what would it be?
1:13:22Ben ArcIt's just making it easier to run nodes. And in a self-custodial way, we're starting to see some of those managed nodes. Like better channel management. So we had... oh, crikey, what was it? It's like auto... just automating channel management. There's just not enough people working on those solutions. And even like, so with us in LNbits, if you're running it on top of LND or Core Lightning, then there's actually a node manager built in LNbits which you can enable. And you can use, you can manage your nodes through LNbits. And the reason we built that was because every time we ran Ride the Lightning, it would like crash our server, which was crazy, that we, working on a wallet account system with extensions, would then have to go build a node manager into the software because there wasn't kind of a good solution out there. There's better solutions out there now.
1:14:14But it just takes more time. And I think like, you know, having something automatically managed channels, I think something like Boltz is really exciting, or, you know, submarine swaps between different layers. So you can cheaply balance the channel using like a Liquid swap going in and out of a Liquid wallet, for example. It's very cheap. That's exciting. Channel factories, like not being dependent upon using an on-chain transaction, obviously, to open and close a channel. That's very important for Lightning to give more people access to Lightning. But the issue is cost of channel creation. If channel creation and curation is cheaper, like way cheaper, then the Lightning Network works a lot better. And the way you get there is through things like channel factories and then making channel balancing more automated. And when we have those features, it'll be a lot easier to run a Lightning node and put it into kind of like an autopilot mode.
1:15:13And for it not to cost you too much as well. And I think actually that's probably where the FUD on Lightning first started to happen was when Bitcoin on-chain transactions, the cost of a Bitcoin on-chain transaction started to go up and everyone's Lightning nodes started breaking. Because they had like, you know, hundreds of channels which they didn't want to close because it cost them too much. I think that's where people first started to become a bit disenfranchised with the technology.
1:15:40But I mean, I remember going to the... when Lightning was first mainnet, and at the first Lightning Hack Day in Berlin, and everyone was discussing channel factories and how we needed channel factories. And it's just there's not enough people working on that stuff. You know, you're talking about a handful of people, literally. Well, maybe you count them on two hands, the people working on something which is so important for the technology to work properly. So that's the thing I would like to see more people working on. But again, it's not, the reason that's slow is it's not really profitable.
1:16:14You know, you've got, like you're not going to get VC funding to set up a business building channel management software at this stage. You know, but so it's going to take a little bit longer for those pieces of the puzzle to be worked on and fixed, but it'll happen. It's just time. As I said, in a year's time, it will be so much easier. I mean, phoenixd didn't exist this time... or how long has that existed for, like a year or two? And then Greenlight, similar. Well, in a year's time, what we're going to have. How much easier will it be to run Lightning nodes?
1:16:49And for us, it's just kind of... and it's always been the way in Bitcoin, I think, as Bitcoiners, that we're building in preparation of when the world wakes up to Bitcoin and needs Bitcoin, and needs to be able to just switch or use it. And I feel like we're kind of getting there. We're getting to the point where the world could switch onto Bitcoin. But yeah, it's great if we have a little bit more time to make sure that the tool set is more developed before the world needs it.
1:17:20Vlad CosteaI actually got an answer to one of my previous questions, which was, what's the difference between Alby Hub and LNbits? BTC4Plebs says the difference is that if Alby Hub's Nostr relay goes down, you lose the connection to your wallet.
1:17:37Ben ArcIt uses Nostr Wallet Connect, which is a cool technology. I'm not sure on throughput. And it is a great technology. If you're using... I think maybe it's a little bit more limited, the amount of users... If I'm wrong, I'm sorry. But the amount of users you have using it... it's a little bit more limited because depending upon relays can be a little bit tricky. One of the updates we want to make to LNbits is... we have all these funding sources. We've got like, I don't know, 20 different ways in which you can fund your LNbits install or close to. What we actually want to do is pull that out completely as its own kind of library called Conduct. And then that will be your funding source part of the software, and then you can run that anywhere.
1:18:26And this is from a real-world use case. We were helping... what's it called? The place in Roatán. Oh, bloody hell, I forgot what it's called. It's like an independent city thing. We were helping them run LNbits and Bitcoin. And for legal reasons, they needed full custodianship of their Bitcoin to the point where they couldn't even run a node on our infrastructure on a VPS. They needed to run the node locally. So the idea would be that they could run the node locally. They've got this conduct software. And then that conduct software creates a WebSocket to LNbits, which is running somewhere else.
1:19:00And then the data goes back and forth between conduct and the VPS where LNbits is running. So if you were installing LNbits, it would install both packages. But the idea of kind of separating out the conduct side so you can put that anywhere and you can even put it locally and then create a WebSocket, that's cool. And it's kind of similar to Nostr Wallet Connect, I suppose, but you're not relaying that data through a Nostr relay.
1:19:28We have a Nostr Wallet Connect funding source, and we also have a Nostr Wallet Connect extension as well for LNbits, so you can connect your Nostr Wallet Connect or your applications which can use Nostr Wallet Connect. You can connect them to your LNbits install. That's in the review process at the moment. Bitkarrot is updating that to version one, so it can work with version one. But yeah, it's a great technology. And that came out of the Alby space, the Nostr Wallet Connect idea.
1:19:59But I'm not sure about... if you've got a very busy server with lots of transaction data happening, how well that would perform relying on those public relays. But I suppose you can always just run your own Nostr relay.
1:20:14Vlad CosteaI was going to ask you've been working on LNbits for, as you say, five years. What are some of the main takeaways or what would you do differently if you started today, given the experience that you accumulated?
1:20:30Ben ArcIt's a good question. I think it's been pretty successful, to be honest, and like way more successful than I ever would have thought it would be. I'm just very happy, feel very privileged to be part of the experience, you know, to start something and then see it grow to the point where it's no longer like a beta hobby project. It's a production ready professional piece of software which has all these crazy use cases. Like that's an amazing thing to see happen. I guess... I don't really think I'd do anything differently. I think, yeah, I think it's been a great ride. And like, the developer community is great. Maybe getting paid extensions in there a little bit earlier as an extra little incentive for people to develop extensions would have been cool. But... I mean, building this stuff takes time and everything happened kind of as quickly as it could.
1:21:28And so yeah, I haven't really got anything I would change, I don't think, about the journey. Maybe supporting... Because, like, obviously Nostr came out of LNbits, or partly came out of that LNbits Diagon Alley extension. And then... Nostr for me was kind of like a break from Bitcoin when I was working on Nostr stuff. So when I made the Twitter clone and those sorts of things on Nostr. And before kind of Jack Dorsey came along and validated that Nostr was worth spending time on and working on, it was always kind of a bit of a slog getting everyone else to agree to... work on Nostr stuff in LNbits. It would have been nice if... we'd maybe built some Nostr extensions earlier, I suppose. But then in saying that, you know, you can't force people to work on stuff which they don't see value in.
1:22:27I don't think I'd change anything. I feel very lucky and privileged that it's gone as well as it has for so long.
1:22:35Vlad CosteaI got to give a shout out to Vlad Stan, the other Romanian guy who's working in Bitcoin, and he's a contributor, one of the most major ones in LNbits. Met him a couple of months ago when I was visiting his hometown. And I think he started watching this because I sent him the link. So I hope that he's watching. He better be watching because Ben, you also mentioned him a couple of times in the beginning of this interview. Also got to plug NoOnes.com, which is a peer-to-peer marketplace for swapping gift cards.
1:23:10It's designed in a way that empowers the global south, but also has a fee structure that allows every participant to get their own cut. So if you have any gift cards for sale or you want to trade your coins peer to peer, go to NoOnes.com. There's also a Visa card that you can get for spending your coins. And they also have other ambassador programs and stuff that you can find. Their CEO, Ray Youssef, is previously known for building Paxful, but now he did something which is more aligned with his values and more oriented towards a mission.
1:23:47And his mission is to make the global South more powerful and open to having this sort of trade. I wonder if they listed Lightning. But I'm not sure about that. Maybe I should get you two in contact. And there's also Hodling.ch, which is a Swiss service for self-custody. If you have a lot of Bitcoin or you're part of a company that's going to buy a lot of Bitcoin, it's a bad idea to entrust the CDO of the company with managing the keys. Maybe you need a hardware wallet. Maybe you need a multisig.
1:24:23Maybe you need Shamir Secret Sharing, which is another scheme for splitting your seed. There is no universal answer to all the problems. So these guys will offer you the right kind of consultancy to direct you towards having the best sort of self-custody for your particular needs. Check out Hodling.ch. That's what they do. And they also give free advice in a previous episode that we recorded. I think it's season 15, episode 50 something.
1:24:51Check that out. It's with Polto and Darko, the co-founders of Hodling.ch. And thank you for sitting through my ads. And now, Ben, I got to ask you. Why do you think that some businesses are giving up on Lightning? I've interviewed previously... So in the previous episode, there was... this guy who is the CEO of SideShift. SideShift was one of the first exchanges in the world to integrate Lightning. It was useful for people. I think they're also part of the Liquid Federation. People were using SideShift for doing these submarine swaps, which means getting their Bitcoin on-chain from Lightning, or vice versa. And they stopped supporting it. And it seems to be a trend that Lightning is not... as cool anymore. And people are looking for other layer twos. And I'm curious... so we did discuss this briefly like an hour ago, but I'm curious what you think is the solution to make Lightning attractive again and increase the adoption of Lightning.
1:26:00Ben ArcI think just build stuff, like with Nostr, the Nostr apps, that's a lot on Lightning. And... Yeah, I think just build use cases. It's incredible. Being able to send a microtransaction without a trusted third party privately over the internet is huge. And we take it for granted because it's existed for a while now. And then, you know, people criticize it, whatever. But I suppose for a lot of clear net companies, when it comes to anything which has more private qualities, it becomes somewhat of an issue, the regulatory moat which you have to navigate.
1:26:30Which is why, for us in LNbits, that's not something we really have to kind of worry about because we build the space, we build the tools, so somebody can spin up LNbits, onboard the local merchants, and then just fly under the radar if they're in a heavily regulated ecosystem or country. And it's not something we have to worry about, and on the business side of things, not something we have to worry about either. But I know a good friend of mine, Tim, who ran LNPay, was a sort of Lightning service provider, a bit like OpenNode.
1:27:01One of the reasons he's stopped that service, or the main reason he stopped that service was he was like, well, I'm going to turn this into, you know, a professional clearnet company. And then you just look at that regulatory moat. For, you know, in New York State alone, to apply for a money transfer license is three quarters of a million dollars.
1:27:20It's the reason that, you know, something like Alby switched from... they had a very custodial business model, the company, and it's the reason they switched to one which is a little bit more like LNbits, of offering software as a service, was just because whatever money they would raise would get swallowed up by regulations.
1:27:38But it's just kind of a matter of time until Lightning is so useful and so used that it's kind of just too big to regulate. But the Nostr stuff's really encouraging for me. Because like I said, you know, when you said that people... There's not many people using Lightning. For me, I'm on there and I'm zapping people all the time and people are zapping me. And it's... I was... actually quite pessimistic about the idea of value for value when it came to things like Lightning. And I think it's just nice to have that extra feature. So you can like a post, you can retweet a post to support it, or you can actually send some value through the internet. And I just feel it's kind of a matter of time until that becomes widespread and adoption becomes more widespread. And all you need is one of those bigger platforms to incorporate Bitcoin Lightning payments. Yeah. But yeah, I mean, like running nodes is hard still.
1:28:29It's getting a lot easier than it used to be, but there's still work to be done on that. And I think that might be a player factor as well into companies. They're like, okay, so how much time are we spending on our DevOps running this node compared to how many people are using the thing? And maybe we just stop supporting Lightning Network and it creates less work for us. We don't have to worry about the regulatory side because it's more private. And then also we don't have to fap around trying to run this node. So I can... And then also, you know, when it comes to these companies, if they want to raise money, you know, you go to a VC and you drop in those keywords, the new fad and the new trend in Bitcoin or just in technology in general, then you're more likely to raise money. Currently, Lightning Network isn't one of those keywords.
1:29:19So I think that also plays a factor too. So there's a bunch of stuff kind of working against... I mean, I certainly miss the time when everyone was really super excited about Lightning Network. And we had all this... just this, yeah, we had all these people wanting to build on top of Lightning Network, but it doesn't make me less bullish. It's just kind of the market sentiment from these incentives which play against Lightning Network. Yeah.
1:29:53Vlad CosteaYeah. You mentioned nodes and the fact that they're easier to run nowadays. I think we have these node-in-a-box solutions and operating systems for small underpowered computers like Raspberry Pi. And most of them, I think they support LNbits, right?
1:30:10Ben ArcYeah, so that was... the huge factor in our adoption actually was, I mean, so Christian Rotzoll, he was very entangled with LNbits very early on. He was visiting me in Wales, and we were sat in his Airbnb, and I remember, like, thinking about the name for it, and I was like, oh, I should call it LNbits. And at that time, 'cause, you know, I'm not the world's most seasoned developer, I was like, I'll probably make it in PHP. And then Rootzoll was like, no, it will not go on the RaspiBlitz if it's PHP. It has to be Python. I was like, all right, cool.
1:30:45I'll make it in Python. So that's why originally we built the thing in Python. So yeah, he was quite involved in the creation of LNbits. And then also as well, like, big shout out to Fulmo and the Lightning Hack Days, which he organized because... that was for me, like, I mean, that was when I first started developing in Bitcoin was going to those Lightning Hack Days and just being around all these very encouraging people like Jeff and like Christian and then all the other people who attend as well.
1:31:15And I realized that within Bitcoin, in the developer community, as long as you make the effort to build something, then you'll find that you get lots of support and lots of people want to help you. If you're just like, "Oh, I've had an idea and I'm trying to encourage someone else to build it for me," then you're not going to get anywhere. But if you actually try to build something, and even if it's crap, but they can see that there's some value in there, then people will look in and try and help you with it.
1:31:44So that's what really kind of incentivized me and encouraged me to start building on Bitcoin was those hack days. So anyway, so Rootzoll... as soon as LNbits existed, he made it so you could install it on the RaspiBlitz. And there were lots of people running RaspiBlitz at that time. There's a cool thing which the RaspiBlitz team are working on, which I don't know if I can talk about too much because I'm not sure how public it is.
1:32:08But yeah. It's the ultimate node solution. It will be the ultimate node solution. But yeah, there's a whole bunch. I mean, I see a lot of people are running Start9 these days. I hear they're very popular. Again, all this stuff takes time to mature and it takes time to work on. And now these node solutions are getting to a really nice spot, like with the RaspiBlitz. You've got, I think, the UI, which they're working on is going to be great. And yeah, but Start9 people seem to be very happy with it. Some people use Voltage.
1:32:36And there's just more ways in which you can engage with the Lightning Network. And now with these self-custodial managed nodes, like... you know, there's like more of a... Becoming fully self-custodial in Bitcoin has always been a journey of effort, hasn't it? So you can go buy some Bitcoin, leave it on an exchange, right? Okay. You haven't really got Bitcoin, but you've done something, you've engaged with Bitcoin in some way. And then you can pull that Bitcoin off that exchange and you can put it on a hardware wallet.
1:33:03It requires a little bit of effort. You have to go buy a hardware wallet, you have to learn how it works, and it requires a little bit of work. And then similarly, if you're going to become your own bank and run your own Lightning node. Then that requires a little bit of work, you know, it requires a little bit of extra work to be self-custodial.
1:33:24But what I like about, say, the managed node solution, for example, is, like me, if I'm onboarding a local merchant to use my LNbits install to accept payments in their cafe, then, you know, traditionally, they would use my LNbits and my funding source, whereas now... I can spin up a phoenixd. I can spin up LNbits for them, you know, just like a couple of lines in a VPS. And then they have...
1:33:48A managed node, which I don't have to worry about as long as there's enough liquidity in there, you know, and they can auto-swap out to on-chain using the Boltz extension, or auto-swap out to Liquid. Their risk profile is very limited. It's self-custodial. They can accept payments. They can do it in a self-custodial way, which I am not responsible for.
1:34:08And then I can just act as kind of like a service provider and somebody onboarding them. But that's like a nice extra step towards full, you know, Bitcoin god. From that journey of you're just using some custodial solution to you're completely self-custodial, there's now that extra little stepping stone you can now use on your journey. I think for a lot of people, it is a journey. Then it's just decreasing that barrier to entry for people to run things in a self-custodial way over time, which will happen over time.
1:34:45Vlad CosteaThere is BTC4Plebs on Nostr actually. He wrote this comment. By the way, you did not repost or little post. But he did say this should be on zap.stream, too.
1:34:59Ben ArcYeah, it should.
1:35:00Vlad CosteaIt should be, but I've been running this experiment with zap.stream. It was not very successful. If there's enough demand for this, I can zap.stream this individually. It's not going to be live. I'm just going to take the recording and broadcast it. I know it sort of defeats the purpose, but I can do this for fun. But before this, I've been running this experiment and I just burned my coins. There wasn't anyone watching. It was not the success I expected it to be. So I sort of phased it out over time. But if there's enough demand, I'll bring it back. So...
1:35:36Ben ArcWell, that's that adoption path which we were talking about, isn't it? People become excited, they try and use the thing. It's not super successful. So, you get users dropping out and then over time you get that kind of bedrock of users use it and it works and then that just kind of goes up and up as the software becomes easier to use and that's just the typical free and open source adoption trend line which you see happening. But no, I'm happy to have been proved wrong about all the value for value stuff with zaps and with content creation.
1:36:09Because I know there's some people, I mean, you're not going to find it with, you know, the bigger podcasts, because they're not really incentivized to do it if, like, you know, yourself, you've got sponsorship or whatever. But I think especially for some of the smaller podcasts or smaller people starting out like it's a way in which they can instantly receive some value you know it's not going to be loads, but they'll receive something and it's just a little extra bit of encouragement for them.
1:36:38And maybe that's why that adoption path is the way in which it is because you have the kind of the new people who are native to that technology which then utilize it as they become more successful and then they carry the technology with them.
1:36:53Vlad CosteaSo right now, LNbits has come out of beta after five years. You're at version one.
1:36:59Ben ArcNo, two days. Two days. 10th of April. 10th of April will be version one.
1:37:03Vlad CosteaBy the time people listen to this on Spotify, I guess v1 will be out. And I want to ask you, where do you see LNbits in five years?
1:37:14Ben ArcI mean, easier to run. I think it would just be powering... I think everything should be scaled up. And it would just be powering a lot of stuff. A lot of people will use it in their stacks, and then it would just be a load easier to run and a load easier to set up, and it'll have thousands of extensions. That's what I want, thousands of extensions and tens of thousands of extensions, and then just make it easier and easier to build extensions, and have an extension wizard, have some AI as well which can help you to build an extension. But it's really...
1:37:46I mean, this is because some people kind of get worried about the AI stuff, because they're like, oh, doesn't it mean that it's going to replace developers in the future. I mean, I don't think it will. I think we overestimate how good AI is. I think it's going to take a while for that to happen. But... the LNbits community, very much the reason it's successful is because it has great ideas.
1:38:09So, you know, if it gets to the point where someone can come up with an idea and then with the help of AI and some wizard, 30 minutes later they've built that idea that still has value and they can still share the idea. So it's not something I kind of worry about. It's more an extra tool to help make building extensions a little bit easier. But yeah, I see in five years' time, I see it as powering a lot of bigger companies, projects. Hopefully some of the projects which are currently using it in their stacks, they'll be bigger. And then also we'll have thousands of extensions. Yeah.
1:38:47Vlad CosteaDo you think we're going to have drivechains by then? And is LNbits basically going to be this interface to transfer coins across these other sidechains?
1:38:57Ben ArcI mean, there's lots of controversy around drivechains within the Bitcoin community. I personally, I think, you know, I quite like the idea of them. I know there's other people who are more hesitant on it. I personally will build stuff for any technology which is useful, whether it be Lightning or drivechains, and I'll build them on top of LNbits. But it's... yeah, who knows? I mean, it's taken a while for drivechains to get to where it is, but I feel like... Yeah, I like the idea of it and I like the technology, so hopefully we'll get to use it one day in production. But let's see. How is it... I mean, I see the chat, the drivechain chat's quite busy these days.
1:39:41Vlad CosteaI wanted to ask you, to people who are eager to try version one of LNbits, what is something that they should do within the first two or three minutes of setting it up? What do you think is going to get them very excited about this tech?
1:39:55Ben ArcWell, first, you know, they need to connect to their funding source, do that sort of stuff, and then go into settings and set the, like the fee reserve, which is a nice security feature, just in case the transaction fee is high. Set that, make sure it's secure. Then go and customize it. That's very rewarding because it takes, you know, minutes. There's some videos, tutorials for doing things like that on the LNbits YouTube. But that's quite rewarding because you can take ownership over it. And then it really depends on your use case.
1:40:24I would say, the two most powerful extensions for a merchant would be the POS extension, which is great, and then the Boltz extension for swapping out to on-chain and Liquid. Because you can get it to auto-swap, so you can just get it to look at a wallet and then auto-swap out. But then, you know, play around with the extensions. There's the Jukebox extension. You can connect it to your Spotify account and then create a software jukebox. There's the Streamer Copilot extension, which means you can have a QR code in your video feeds and people can pay the QR code and it triggers little animations and stuff on the screen.
1:41:00There's the hardware extensions which allow you to build something like the Bitcoin Switch. It's like, out of the box, it comes with a lot of functionality. Start small, start with the POS, and then again, we have videos for pretty much every extension on how to use it and what it does on the LNbits YouTube channel. And he's had more videos for the new extensions. But just go through them and then just pick the extensions which are relevant to you and you could use. And then install them and use them and play around with them.
1:41:30LN Calendar, that's a cool extension, one I'm going to start using, I think, which is where you can just sell your time slots for Bitcoin in a calendar, and then just share a calendar publicly and people can pay you. So I was maybe going to do some sort of paid support or whatever, and I'll just charge a certain amount for half hour and then people can just book for some paid support.
1:41:53But no, it's just yeah, just have fun with the software. It does a lot of stuff. And yeah, it really depends on what you want to do with your Lightning node. I would say the easiest way to start playing around with it is, of course, go and use the demo server and play around with it on there. Once version one is released, that'll be on the software as a service, so you can go onto our SaaS and you can spin up LNbits on there and play around with it. If you want to run it yourself, I have tutorials on how to set it up on a VPS. I think I need to update the tutorial because I did a video for someone on the LNbits Telegram chat and I think I set up an LNbits in like under a minute on a VPS.
1:42:41I think I could probably get it set up with phoenixd and a URL and all that sort of stuff and, you know, a secure certificate probably in like three, four minutes on a VPS. So I need to do a video for that, show how easy it is. But yeah, just play around with it. And actually, like, I always say with free and open source software, running it is the first step towards contributing. You are contributing by running it and playing around with it.
1:43:07And then if there's anything you want added to it or any features you would think would be useful, then pop in on the LNbits Telegram chat and tell us about it or go to the LNbits repo and drop in an issue there. Pull requests are very welcome. All the extensions have their own repos. We got a bunch on our, well, the ones we've built are on the LNbits organization, GitHub. But then there's a bunch of extensions.
1:43:32All the extensions in LNbits has links to their repos, so you can pop into those different extensions and offer give your suggestions and make pull requests if you want to, but I would say never be afraid or feel embarrassed to suggest something because I think sometimes maybe some people who have an idea and they want to suggest something, they're intimidated by the Bitcoin developer community. Because we have great developers in Bitcoin, but always suggest ideas. They're very welcome. Some of our greatest extensions have come out of just conversations we've been having in the LNbits Telegram group. And yeah, it's a sandbox for experimenting with ideas and use cases for Bitcoin. So they're very, very welcome. And then, yeah, totally check out the hardware stuff, too.
1:44:13So we have the MakerBits YouTube channel. That's very rewarding because you can, you know, obviously, LNbits is a piece of software which you run in your browser or whatever on your phone. But being able to make Bitcoin payments and then have things happen in the real world, like, you know, this light behind me, for example, you can connect it to Bitcoin Switch, and then when people pay, it would turn the light on.
1:44:37Or we have the ZapLamp project for this sort of thing where you can get it to turn on every time you get a zap. I haven't set this one up, but actually that's great, because I had it set up in my previous office where I had the ZapLamp set up. And sometimes I'd be grinding away on the computer and I'd get a little depressed and I start to feel sorry for myself, you know. It's a sunny day outside and I think, "Why am I inside? Why don't I just give up on all this nonsense and go play outside in the sun?"
1:45:03And then the little light would go off in the background, And somewhere on Nostr, someone sees value in something I'm doing and they're zapping me for something and that's rewarding. We have, like, oh, the ATM project as well. We have a whole bunch of hardware projects which are a lot of fun to build. We make them really easy to build, like the POS, the ATM, and the Bitcoin Switch. It's like Lego.
1:45:22If you can make it, if you can make Lego, you can make these hardware projects. So I encourage people to go and build some of those. And they'll work on LNbits, too. So yeah, check out the LNbits YouTube channel, the MakerBits YouTube channel. And... Yeah, let us continue to build great things.
1:45:44Vlad CosteaYou know, I feel sad that I mentioned this so late into our interview.
1:45:49Ben ArcIt's not like we're going for seven hours. I've got my Amir Taaki nappy on and I'm just going to sit here for seven hours. How did he... did he go to the toilet in that seven-hour stint? Did he? No, he didn't, did he? How was that even possible? He must have been wearing a nappy.
1:46:02Vlad CosteaI didn't go to the toilet either. I was just drinking water. But I had a much longer one, eight hours and 23 minutes with John Carvalho and Eric Voskuil. But for that one, I did go to the toilet after six hours.
1:46:16Ben ArcNo, right.
1:46:18Vlad CosteaIt was crazy. Anyway, on LNbits.com, you also have a shop section. And you're selling some of the most affordable and cool gadgets that you find in all of Bitcoin. I don't want to knock on, for example, CryptoCloaks or whatever, but they're selling 3D printed plastic at pretty high prices. What you have on the LNbits shop is super affordable. It makes me wonder if you guys have any profit at all from running this business.
1:46:48Ben ArcI mean, so the... up until... when it comes to... we've not... revenue, profit-making, because we can't really do that until the software is version one, can we? And then the way in which the company side of it. So it's kind of important that LNbits, the company, exists to support the free and open source software and that it's very successful as well but like the company could focus on going door-to-door, trying to onboard merchants to accept Bitcoin payments, and that could be a business model, but we would hit that regulatory moat, which inevitably you're going to butt up against. And then also there's only so many steps. It's a lot of work doing that. So for us, it's all about... empowering our developer community by enabling something like paid extensions. So they can charge for an extension, and then LNbits Inc. takes 10% of the payment in order to be able to support the vetted extension marketplace, for example.
1:47:51And then giving people easier access to LNbits. So we have the software as a service, where you can go and spin up LNbits on our infrastructure. So our business model is very... And then also we make it, we incentivize people to run LNbits themselves. So we make it easy for someone to spin up LNbits and then start generating revenue themselves. So you can spin up LNbits, you can set a transaction fee, you can charge your customers to enable extensions, you can even have a little advertising area inside the wallet or whatever. And we encourage that, you know, it's like $10, someone can go spin up LNbits that afternoon, go out, start onboarding merchants and start making money. And for us, that's kind of... the better business model, it takes a little bit more time to build in all those incentives and those flywheels, but it means that you're empowering your users, as opposed to trying to exploit them.
1:48:44And it's a much more sustainable relationship between the free and open source project and a business arm. And it's, you know, we're not reinventing the wheel. This has been done. There's a whole bunch of projects out there which have very successful companies and thriving free and open source communities of happy users and developers. And it is very much of that model of empowering users to run services themselves and then also develop for the solution and being able to make a little bit of money themselves on developing for that solution as well. So we spent our time doing that, really. And a part of that is getting hardware into people's hands so they can use it. And so like the, you know, the DIY hardware wallet, for example, you know, it's like, if you build it yourself, you can do it for like $10, $15. You can build this hardware, which Vlad's built, by the way. It's an incredible piece of work.
1:49:37And we will probably at some point like the ATM, you know, we have the ATM, the DIY ATM, it costs you a couple hundred dollars or whatever to build this thing yourself. Or you can, I think, buy it from us for like $250, well, maybe it's more, completely pre-built, but at some point, obviously with the business arm we need to stay focused and our focus is the extension marketplace. And also software as a service. But then we have all this auxiliary stuff as well, which we could potentially make money on. And some of those auxiliary products are definitely like our hardware, like the ATM. Currently, it's like a DIY ATM you build yourself. But we feel that there's definitely like a prosumer market in Bitcoin, of people who want to buy an ATM, they don't want to spend two and a half grand on an ATM. They don't want to... spend $200 on an ATM and build it themselves.
1:50:25They want to spend like $800 on an ATM or something, or $1,000 on an ATM, and then they just have a little ATM for their shop. We will probably have some sprints to make kind of prosumer versions of a lot of those things. But currently, it's really just about... expanding our user base. And one of the best ways to do that is just, like, the, you know... sell stuff on the shop, and the shop makes money. But one of the best ways to do that is to have it, you know, nice price points on the shop to encourage people to build stuff.
1:50:55And all the stuff on the shop as well, you can just get the hardware yourself and buy it and build it yourself. Like the Bitcoin Switch, for example, you can build that for like $3. And then you can retrofit pretty much anything to accept Bitcoin payments, whether it be an arcade machine or a vending machine. And that's been a cool project, the Bitcoin Switch project, because it's so simple. It's like a couple hundred lines of code. All it has is a WebSocket connected to LNbits.
1:51:21When you make a payment... it just sends a, you know, paid, a pin number and an amount of time, and then it turns on a GPIO on one of these little microcontrollers on the pin.
1:51:32And you can connect that to a relay, which then turns on something. So it could be anything. It could be to access somewhere. You could make a payment and then it unlocks the smart lock on the door and lets you in, or I don't know, whatever. But what's been encouraging about that project is seeing what people build. So someone built like a newspaper dispenser, sticker dispensers. There's like the beer tap. There's coffee machines. There's all sorts of cool stuff which people have built. And they've based it off that project. So it's like... And I mean, ultimately, that stuff is built on top of LNbits.
1:52:07So, you know, it drives users to LNbits. So it's like it's a really nice relationship, I think, between some of the commercial stuff we do, and then also the free and open source community. And ultimately, again, I mean, like, so when we're talking about dialectics before, I envision, I mean, this is why over time we've seen that trend of proprietary software-based companies becoming more and more free and open source is ultimately, in order to stay relevant, especially in Bitcoin, where stuff needs to be free and open source so people can verify code, that over time most... almost all corporations, they will be free and open source, and then businesses attached to just facilitate users using the free and open source software, and then some of these more elegant monetization strategies which exist inside the business, where it's not exploiting the user base, it's actually, like, benefiting the user base.
1:52:56And I think that's kind of the trend in business you see happening, and I think that will continue. So I feel like LNbits is in good stead and is on the right track to developing a very successful you know relationship between those two things. And we're in that lucky position, too, that, you know, open source has been going for a long while. So there's good examples of how to do it properly. And how not to do it. Odoo is a good example. I run Odoo for my shop, which is like an enterprise resource planner. And that was a great free and open ERP.
1:53:30It used to be called OpenERP. And it was a great free and open source project. And then they created this proprietary arm for it. And what they did is they made an enterprise version of Odoo and a community version of Odoo. And the community version of Odoo was just shit. And the enterprise version of Odoo was great. And then it just pissed everyone off. So all the community left. And then they were like, okay, well, so now they've moved to that model where you can run the software. And then it has a whole bunch of, again, it has a whole bunch of extensions. And then some of those extensions are paid for.
1:54:08And I actually paid. I got one of those, you know, those SumUp machines for accepting card payments, and so I can connect it to my Odoo. I paid like $250 for an extension. And I was thinking, Christ, that's a lot of money. I'll probably just build it myself. And then I was like, oh, no, I won't bother. I'll just pay for the extension, which seemed like quite a lot of money to me, but I actually ended up paying it. And I'm sure a lot of other people paid as well.
1:54:38And like, if you look at the WordPress example... the developers in LNbits always hate it when I use the WordPress example because WordPress is such terrible software. But there are some plugins in WordPress which are like multimillion-dollar companies, just the plugins. And I can kind of envision that LNbits will have that as time rolls on. There'll be some plugins, some paid plugin, which has all these bells and whistles. And it's its own company, multi-million dollar company, but that's just an LNbits extension working, which is the main product of that company. I can envision that happening as well in LNbits. It should be exciting.
1:55:14Vlad CosteaFor those listening, if you go to shop.LNbits.com, you can find a hardware wallet for about 20 British pounds. You can also find a sweet dispenser. You can put candy inside of it, and then you need to make Lightning payments to get some candy. You can get an arcade machine. You can get the lamp that you can see behind Ben. You can get an ATM where you can put some cash and you get your Bitcoin. I guess it also works with coins.
1:55:47Ben ArcYeah, I've lost my... I've got an ATM in here somewhere. I was going to show it. But yeah, yeah. Yeah, we had a sprint on the ATM more recently. The ATM, this is the coolest thing as well, when you marry up different extensions and different ideas. So we had the FOSSA, open source ATM. It was an offline ATM. It uses LNURL withdraw, and it has like a secret inside of it. So when it creates the LNURL-withdraw, it has a hash. And then the server can then verify.
1:56:12So when the user scans the QR code to get their coins, the server can then verify that request is a legitimate request and has come from this ATM. Well, more recently, because of Boltz, what we built into it was, if you've got the Boltz extension enabled, when you scan that QR code, if you just scan it with a regular QR code scanner and open the link, you then have the option to put in an on-chain address or a Liquid address. And then when you do that, you get the on-chain funds or you get the Liquid funds, and what's actually happening is you're doing a submarine swap using the Boltz extension.
1:56:45But what it means is that... And this is why I love LNbits, is like the R&D stuff, right? So what it means is that you can be an ATM provider, but you don't have to have an on-chain hot wallet or a liquid hot wallet. You've just got your Lightning node and using Boltz... And so that's the first, I guess, the first Bitcoin ATM which you can run where you don't have to have an on-chain hot wallet, which is a huge pain in the ass for ATM providers. You just have to worry about your Lightning Node and keep your Lightning Node safe. So that's the update.
1:57:14So me and dni have been working on that. Actually, dni's got some... updates to the extension, which I need to review. And I feel really bad because I haven't reviewed them yet. But I'm going to get on that later today. But it's cool as well. Like it can print a receipt for you as well for the ATM. So lots of people who run ATMs, they need receipts to be able to be printed. And then also Ben Weeks as well.
1:57:37Ben Weeks put a lot of work into the new FOSSA. He built the case for it. Did a sterling job of developing a case for it. He's a great 3D printer... well, you know, product engineer, I guess. He also... actually, shout out to Ben Weeks, he kind of came up with a lot of the design of the new wallet in LNbits, the UI, the way the UI works with the graphs and stuff. So big shout out to Ben Weeks for that too. But yeah, check out the shop.
1:58:06It's funny with the hardware wallet because, like, the point of... a free and open source, a DIY hardware wallet, is that you don't have the supply chain attack. So I always say to people, build the hardware wallet, the LNbits hardware wallet, but don't buy it from the shop, because then you introduce the supply chain attack. Like, you should go buy the hardware for it from Amazon or AliExpress, because then they don't know you're building a hardware wallet and you haven't got that supply chain attack. But yeah, do check out the shop.
1:58:37And it's a really nice way for you to support the project as a whole, actually, is for people to buy stuff from the shop. Black Coffee, BC, he manages the shop. Oh my God, let me show you the thing which you've been working on more recently. Can I show you something? Can I screen share?
1:58:49Vlad CosteaOf course. Right now I'm looking at the Bitaxe miner which you're also selling. Pretty cool. You have some mining stuff. You have some books and magazines. You also sold my magazine, which was Breaking FUD, a couple of years ago. Yeah. I see it's out of stock now.
1:59:07Ben ArcYeah, no, honestly, Black Coffee, he does all the shop stuff for LNbits and he does such a cool job. And building those relationships as well with Blockstream so we can sell the Jades, and it's great. Yeah, but the thing which he's been working on, which is flipping awesome, is the... nsec remote signer, which we're selling on nostr.com. And do you know much about this, Vlad?
1:59:31Vlad CosteaSo nsec is your Nostr private key, right?
1:59:35Ben ArcYeah, that's right. So this is one of the cool things about Nostr is that obviously we're all used to using public key cryptography in the Bitcoin context where you have a hardware wallet and then you plug it in, you sign a transaction, blah, blah. If you're doing social... so in LNbits, we made the first signing device for Nostr. So you could plug it in, and then when you create a Nostr note, you then sign the note with the hardware device. So the private key always stays on the hardware device. And it was, you know, a little microcontroller.
2:00:05The same thing we use for the cheap hardware wallet, Bitcoin hardware wallet. Vlad Stan made that. But in the social media context, it's kind of annoying to have to keep plugging in a device to sign your notes before you publish them on Nostr, whether it be plugging into your computer or your phone or whatever. It's kind of annoying to have this little extra dongle. So it's like one of the things that gets me most bullish about Nostr and gets me really excited about Nostr is you're using public key crypto in a way which is outside of using it for money.
2:00:37which means that your key management becomes different. It's like, so instead of just saving your private key in your application or in your browser or on a hardware wallet type thing, you have to keep plugging in. The nsec remote signer, the way this works is on your, say on Amethyst, for example, I have like a delegated private key. I make a note, and I publish it, and I sign it, and it goes up to the Nostr relay. Now, what the nsec remote signer does is you plug it in at home.
2:01:07It has your actual private key on, and it's just on your home network, and it's connected to the relay. And then as soon as it sees a post from that delegated private key, it pulls down that note, signs it with the actual private key, then republishes it. What it means is that I can be out and about, making, you know, making posts on Nostr all day long. But my private key is safe at home, plugged into my home network, and it's signing notes. And if for whatever reason I need to, you know, my Nostr application gets compromised, so I lose my private key or someone gets access to it.
2:01:45I can just remove that as a delegated key and then create a different key and then use that in the wild. But it just means that it's like, a much easier way to engage with public key cryptography. And I honestly believe that this is one of the things which I'm most bullish on about Bitcoin in general, is that the world is going to get used to using public key cryptography because it solves so many of the problems when it comes to authentication of users.
2:02:10So like when captchas get too complicated and when passwords have to be too complex that human brains can't remember them and use them, then the answer is that people use private key, public key cryptography, of course. So, and when that happens, because that is the answer, the research and development which has been done in the Nostr space on things like the nsec remote signer are going to be so important that those solutions exist, because this is, you know, a very usable and easy way of managing your keys is to just have a little tiny dumb device plugged in at home. It's cheap.
2:02:42plugged in at home, and it's just signing stuff for you, particularly in something like a social media context. So I very much applaud the work being done on the nsec remote signer by Black Coffee. And this is like an old picture of it, the new version of it. It looks really sweet, looks really nice, very professional. But yeah. I mean, I think more generally, like the work which is done on Bitcoin, you know, like it's an excuse for us to... a big excuse for people to work on public key cryptography. And so is Nostr now.
2:03:17It's just another great excuse to work on public key cryptography, which maybe, arguably, the revolution is public key cryptography. And Bitcoin is like an offshoot of that. Nostr is an offshoot of it, of what's now made possible by public key cryptography. Kind of a simplistic way of looking at it. But another way you can support the work we do in LNbits is actually, if you go and buy a Nostr identity. So I have ben@nostr.com as my Nostr identity, and you can go buy a Nostr identity on nostr.com, which LNbits also manages and runs. This is... So like, in LNbits, it's important that we have real-world feedback with the software we're building.
2:03:58So we utilize LNbits through the UI, and we make extensions, which we want to use professionally, whatever, but we also run it in our own stack. So this entire thing is, you know, nostr.com is entirely powered by LNbits. And the NIP-05s, the Nostr identities we sell on nostr.com, that's done through a NIP-05 extension in LNbits. And then more recently. And I guess it's because this is coming out a little bit later. We actually got an auction system, which Vlad Stan's been building, where you can actually buy and sell your Nostr identities on Nostr.com. This is probably the first reveal of this new thing, which we're going to have on Nostr.com, which is pretty cool, that you can buy and sell your Nostr identities on Nostr.com. But we'll be launching this probably, you know, in a couple of days alongside the version one release. Probably. I'm not 100% sure whether we will, but probably we will.
2:04:55But yeah, so there's a whole bunch of... Because I think in Nostr, you know, there's a couple of Nostr identity provider services. But what's nice about LNbits is, because we're like a clearnet company, we can like operate like a professional service. So the service we have for selling Nostr identities is pretty professional, you know. I like it. And then what we're also going to do is add a lot of, say, the extensions for like LN Calendar, for example. You can run LNbits, you can run LN Calendar yourself, or you can use LNbits and use somebody else's LN Calendar extension.
2:05:31But what we'll probably have in here at some point is you'll have a calendar link here and you'll click on it and there you can take calendar requests, and then it'll just push the payment to your Lightning address. Similarly, a POS button, you click on it and it instantly, you know, you've got a POS there, which you can use. And it's just getting sent to your Nostr identity, as it's being used as an LN address.
2:05:59So yeah, I'm quite excited to like, build more on the LNbits stack. And I think it's very important that we do that to inform our design decisions, because there would be nothing worse than developers making design decisions for a piece of software people are using in their stacks, and we're not actually using it in our stacks ourselves. You know what I mean? But that's something to look out for, is the nostr.com auction. And this... this gives us a great excuse to make a new extension.
2:06:26So Vlad Stan's built Auction House, which is a new LNbits extension where you can create an auction platform like this for buying and selling stuff using Lightning. And it's a new LNbits extension, which we're all very excited about. And I think a lot of people will use. It's all about creating them flywheels, those feedback loops. You know, you build something, it gives you an excuse to build an extension for LNbits, which then other people can use to build their projects. And they do the same thing and they feedback. And then we all just feed back into this thing and it just becomes more and more useful to more and more people.
2:07:03Vlad CosteaYeah, that's so cool. I also got a question from earlyNFT.bit. This was through a Twitter DM. And he is quite an OG. He is an enthusiast of Namecoin assets. And he says, Hey, Vlad, I've got a question for your interview with Ben Arc. Hopefully it's something that you feel can bring about a good conversation. As I see it, one of the most important things Nostr needs to become, the preferred decentralized communications protocol, is for clients to agree to a universal standard for key management.
2:07:38If you concur that global consensus is required for this purpose, then couldn't this be a good time to employ the use of a blockchain? Nostr clients could manage their own keys, which can now correspond to human-readable decentralized names, and can verify signatures for something like a name-centric SPV wallet. There could be other benefits that come from this as well, like self-sovereign payment rails, proof of work payments attached to each note sent, reducing spam, and decentralized web pages where community members can publicly declare what their complete list of notes is, something that isn't currently possible.
2:08:19I am aware of FROSTR's t-of-n multisig model and other NIP proposals, but as far as I can tell, they don't really allow for the revocation of NPubs, nor the adding of new keys to the list of accepted NPubs. What shape do you ultimately think the solution to this very thorny issue will take?
2:08:44Ben ArcGood question. I think with Nostr, one of its beauties is it's not dependent upon blockchains. It's using... because there's... with public key cryptography. I think inherently, like with Bitcoin, for example, early on, people inherently knew within the toolset, within the basket of tools that Bitcoin utilizes to exist, that there was the power to build, decentralize this, decentralize that, censorship resistant this, censorship resistant that, you know, an Uber or whatever else, or a Twitter. And I think quite often they conflated it all into the Bitcoin toolset and they're like, okay, you need a blockchain to make the decentralized Uber.
2:09:22You need a blockchain to make the decentralized Twitter. I think the beauty of Nostr was that it didn't have the blockchain part. It just had public key cryptography, and then it relied upon these relays. Now, in saying that, I would say to the question, because I understood like maybe 90% of it, I would say that it's permissionless. Nostr is a permissionless development environment, much like Bitcoin. And if you think there's a service which people are going to use and find useful, you just build it and people can use it.
2:09:58You don't have to ask for anyone's permission. And then if you make... I'm not sure that proposal of managing keys using a blockchain would need a NIP. You could just offer that service, and if people want to use it, they can use it. If you do feel that it requires a NIP, then propose a NIP, or build the thing, offer it as a service. And then say, you know, it would be cool if this was more interoperable with the rest of the protocol. Here's the NIP. It's always an interesting... like, an interesting process of coming up with a Nostr improvement proposal because, and it's a bit like Bitcoin as well, like you need to show why you need this thing to exist. So you need an application. But then, in order for that application to maybe work, you then need the...
2:10:51BIP or the NIP or the LUD or whatever to exist. So you've got to kind of like, build the application to show that there's a reason for the NIP to exist but then, unless the NIP gets adopted, then maybe the application is redundant. I would say in that scenario, though, of using, you know, your blockchain somewhere to manage keys, that's a service you could just offer. And it's a permissionless development environment. That's what makes Nostr great. That's what makes Nostr powerful. That's what makes Bitcoin powerful. That's what makes LNbits powerful. You know, it's free and open source. You know, you don't have to ask anyone's permission. Just build the thing, or start building it at least, and then it'll capture more people's imagination. If you feel it should be supported at a more protocol level, then make a proposal.
2:11:45Vlad CosteaThere's also Melvin Carvalho who left a message. He said, and I quote, "Legend!" with exclamation point.
2:11:52Ben ArcYeah, Melvin's a cool cat, man. He's been around since way back, you know, I've got infinite respect for anyone who was like involved, you know, from the very beginning. And Melvin was at the very beginning. I think he was in the Telegram group before me. Like he's there from the very beginning and had some great ideas and he's working on some great stuff too. But yeah, we got a great development community in Bitcoin. And, I think Nostr could only ever come out of a development community like Bitcoin or the Bitcoin development community. People who had like a real grasp of public key cryptography felt comfortable with it. Like public key cryptography native, I suppose would be the way to put it. And then... Yeah. And then all the solutions which come along with it, such as managing keys, for example.
2:12:43But that previous question, you know, it is interesting because it's a new use case for managing your public key cryptography keys in Nostr. So there will be solutions like that, which rely on some external source, whether it be a trusted third party, which is managing those keys, or whether it be a blockchain, or whether it be something else. Build it. Yeah, I had an idea for something. I don't want to talk about it because I want to build it. Someone else might steal the idea.
2:13:10It's always the problem when you have like, you know, you want to share something, a good idea, but you know, because particularly these days, before in Bitcoin, you could like, you can have an idea, you could talk very publicly about it, and you know that no one's going to build the thing. And if they do, it's going to take years for them to get around to actually building it, because there's so much to build, and the development community was so small.
2:13:36These days, you have a good idea, you speak about it publicly, and then a week later, somebody's built it. And you're just like, "Dammit, should have taken the time to build that thing myself." So anyway, this good idea I'm going to keep to myself. But what do you think about... how bullish are you on the Nostr stuff, Vlad?
2:13:59Vlad CosteaWell, I like it. I use it for posting my stuff, but I don't spend too much time on Nostr. Like I see that it's sort of an echo chamber of Bitcoiners. So the reason why I spend a lot of time on Twitter still is that I see the people I don't like. And I see news, I see stuff that's happening, I see different points of view. On Nostr, it's a bit predictable. I know exactly what I'm going to find there. I know what kind of people are going to be posting there. I sort of join just to post my stuff and then get out.
2:14:36Ben ArcIt's funny, Melvin will remember this, that early on in Nostr, in the Telegram group, if you spoke about Bitcoin too much, you'd get booted out of the Telegram group because we didn't want it to be a Bitcoin thing. It was like a lot of, for a lot of us, it was our holiday away from Bitcoin. And then also we didn't want to scare off all the developers and users who might want to use Nostr and they're not Bitcoiners.
2:15:00And then inevitably the Bitcoiners found it, and it is very much like a Bitcoin Twitter in the social media context, because I always have to remind people that Nostr is very much about other stuff. It transcends just social media. But in the social media context, it is very bitcoiny. And I also think that the clients did something of a disservice by appealing too much to the... by having some audience capture when it came to Bitcoiners, and framing Nostr too much as kind of a Bitcoin solution.
2:15:26I mean, I get that everyone's very enthusiastic about Bitcoin, but for a lot of... humans, it kind of annoys them, Bitcoin, and it would be nice for them to use Nostr. And then, you know, if you've got like someone who hates Bitcoin and then they're using Nostr, but then inevitably they end up zapping people and they end up, I mean, like Rabble, for example, like great developer, OG technologist.
2:15:48Great ideas. He's the guy who employed Jack Dorsey at Twitter. He wasn't like a Bitcoiner, I think, but it was from using Nostr and from playing with Zaps, which made him realize how cool Bitcoin is now and how you can do these microtransactions. And I feel like that should be Nostr's... one of its best, one of its greatest things it can do is to introduce Bitcoin to people in a very usable payments way, without them being Bitcoiners.
2:16:16And I feel that the clients need more of that traditional experience of when you install a client, that you put in your interests and hobbies and then it fills your global feed based on your interests and hobbies, as opposed to just suggesting a whole bunch of Bitcoiners as the people you should subscribe to, or auto-subscribing you to a whole bunch of Bitcoiners. But then, you know, as a permissionless development environment, any criticism anyone lobs against any permissionless development environment is actually a criticism against themselves not building it. So, you know, it's like, I shouldn't complain too much and just be thankful for the great things that people build.
2:16:56What client do you use? I use Amethyst, by Vitor. It's great.
2:17:01Vlad CosteaI'm on Damus.
2:17:03Ben ArcYou're on Damus. How's Damus these days? Are you on an iPhone or Android?
2:17:07Vlad CosteaiPhone.
2:17:08Ben ArcYeah, Damus is iPhone, isn't it? How does it work these days?
2:17:12Vlad CosteaSame as always, sometimes the notifications are a bit slow. I did add some more relays. But it works. No reason to complain.
2:17:23Ben ArcThat's cool. Yeah. Again, like there's not that many people working on this stuff, you know, like, some of these clients. Like Amethyst, there's just Vitor working on it, a couple of other people. Actually, no, I think that's got a pretty good development community of some free and open source developers PR-ing into it. But yeah, it's amazing what a handful of developers can build when you think about the hundreds or thousands of developers who work on something like Facebook and how it's this huge, big, massive company corporation.
2:17:57And then you've got this thing which replicates like 90% of the functionality of that thing, except it hasn't got this huge you know, expensive corporation behind it. An evil corporation, in the Twitter example. Although, did you see that Elon Musk, he's moving away from Trump now, isn't he? I guess we should talk about him because he's in the thumbnail for this video, isn't he? But he's watching us play on stage. Yeah, but he's sort of distancing himself from Trump. I think he's moving away from the DOGE thing, so the sales have... but Teslas have dumped in all these different countries. I think it's down like 60% in Europe right now so I think he's got some external pressures to pull out from supporting Trump too much.
2:18:47But yeah.
2:18:48Vlad CosteaI don't think it's only because of sales of cars. It's also because the stocks of his companies have gone down. And Tesla was always decoupled in the sense that... They're not selling that many cars, but they're trading like a tech company stock. So, for example, Volkswagen or whatever, they're selling many more cars, but their stocks are not as... valued by the market. But I think it has to do with the stock price. I think that... He's gonna try to regain his... Image as this visionary who's building futuristic stuff. Which he has always been, it's just that he was more... how should I put it... involved more partisan in politics?
2:19:36Ben ArcI think he's always... put across. This image of who, I mean, everyone does, but I think he's always put across this image of who he is, which is counter to who the person is. Because I know that like in his companies, for example, there's a lot of the senior engineers that have non-disclosure agreements that they won't take any credit for any of the things which have come out of those companies because he wants to kind of build this cult of the entrepreneur. So it's a very manicured. Image. I mean, it's very American, actually.
2:20:04And it's something which, because Raising money for LNbits is something which I've kind of experienced is they want to create this sort of cult of the entrepreneur type stuff you know in order to so it's like oh well the reason we're raising money for this company is because the person the CEO of this company is a genius and they're they're genius and they look at all the great things that they saw, this Messiah complex thing, where the reality is that I think you know like any the answer which anyone should give for any good company anywhere is when they say, "How do you create such great things?" It's like, "Well, we just have great people who work on the stuff and like are enthusiastic and they enjoy working on those things.
2:20:45And then ultimately, as a CEO, your job is to make sure that everyone gets paid. That's it. And sort of have a rough idea of the direction you're going in. But in America, they very much seem to have this cult of the entrepreneur, which often bites them in the bum. You know, it's like the Sam Bankman-Fried thing. Everyone thinks he's this kid genius. But really, he's just like an idiot, just ripping off the company. But yeah, you see it in the US with the American companies. And I think Musk manicures that because he understands that's how you get the money from the VCs and that's how you... That's what people kind of invest in.
2:21:22Vlad CosteaI was gonna ask you this because one of our first conversations was almost five years ago. Or I think it was five years ago. Yeah, something like that. And we spoke about the philosophy of anarchism and you described left anarchism and all of your ideals and now you're put in a position where you have to, I guess, swallow your pride of it and just deal with this world?
2:21:51Ben ArcOh wow. Yeah. Yeah. I see what you're saying. I mean, for me, it's all about where... like private capital will end up in the future. I don't like corporate private capital. I never really have. But I mean, it's centralization. I think we should rally against any centralization. So whether it be centralization via government, whether it be centralization via some evil corporation, which is taking control of all the resources. I know a bunch of people will say, well, the corporations wouldn't exist without the governments. But I mean, that has to be proved because we haven't had an environment like that before. So it's theoretical.
2:22:23But so I don't like centralization. And I think one of the better ways of not having centralization is by having a free and open source community which is attached to your company which you're beholden to and you can't annoy too much. I think that creates a very a more honest form of private capital than if you've just got that more feudal system of private capital which is in corporations. And I see that's where it's all kind of moving.
2:22:49For me, like the Nostr example, Twitter shouldn't be owned by a company. It shouldn't have that level of centralized decision making and development. It needs to be a permissionless development environment, not more like a commons where anyone can set up and run a business, but you can't try and co-opt those commons. You can't try and co-opt the resources. And I see that we saw that in Bitcoin. When you had like private interests try and take control of the protocol. And you saw that the users kind of gave them a big bitch slap and said, no, wait there. This is something where it's within everyone's interest that this remains a vibrant, lush commons of resources. Where we can throw great ideas down and they'll grow into these beautiful projects. It's within everyone's interest that we have that as opposed to just within your interest to be able to take control of those resources.
2:23:48Actually, more recently, I've kind of... And actually, no, there is some compromise. So, you know, years ago, I was very much... you know, I... just hate all private capital. But it's I mean it's a naive stance in a way because clearly there's forms of private capital which are are really good for society and they bring up people and they get people paid and they help culture innovation and so I think that the way to look at it is more of a spectrum. You know, the private capital is a spectrum. You have evil private capital and you have good private capital. And anyone who argues against that, it's like, okay, well, if you're if you just support all private capital no matter what, then, you know, slavery is a form of private capital. So one side of the spectrum, you've got humans owning other humans and killing them for fun.
2:24:35Okay, you got something that's really evil. And then on this side of the spectrum way over here you've got I don't know some open source cooperative where everyone controls, they're a means of production, whatever. And then it's up to you, I suppose, where you place yourself on that spectrum of support. Me personally, I fall short of private corporations, which have a detrimental effect on the planet and all the resources in it and, you know, they just want to create the cheapest products and sell them for the highest value to the customers because they don't really care about the customers. They care about that profit. But to me, that's where I kind of fall short. I'm like, actually, I think the ideal place. For me, where I would say that I'm happy with is like, corporation which has like a pre-open source software project attached to it, for example.
2:25:31Or, yeah, or at least... I just don't like, yeah, or at least more accountable versions of capital as opposed to just free, you know... completely corrupt forms of private capital. So that's where that's where I sit currently, and actually that for me has been a dialectic. It has been something which I've had to come to terms with, is admitting that clearly There's good forms of private capital in this world. And then there's, you know, and I actually call it...
2:25:59I've got a, it's a very utopian theory because if it's true then everyone's happy If when you go into that future, you end up with if you replace all the big evil corporations with cooperatives, free source projects and companies and corporations attached to free source projects, then. You get rid of all that evil capital. Which then creates, so say in the Nostr example, which then creates a marketplace of private capital competing with each other, none of them growing too big or co-opting all the resources, because if they do, they just kind of get that bitch slap.
2:26:35So you end up with a proper free market. Plus. You end up with the big fat cooperative type free and open source capital, private capital as well so it's a utopia where everyone's happy the Austrian economists are happy. The lefty soy drinkers are happy we're all happy And actually it's true. I mean, so Hegel had this great idea when it comes to the dialectic in general, that humanity moves towards greater liberation, greater freedom. Because, I mean, like the driving incentive of any human is more freedom. We all want more freedom, more freedom, more freedom, more freedom.
2:27:08And that incentive, the power of that incentive far outweighs the power of any incentive for somebody to restrict freedom, which is why over time you see things like slavery disappearing. It's because the overwhelming majority of people want more and more freedom. And that's the inevitable path for humanity is more freedom. And I hope this is true. And I feel like it probably is because over time people have ended up with more freedom. And it's like, how does that process happen?
2:27:37So, yeah. And if you follow that thought, then inevitably then people would be kind of more free when it came to their work-life balance and everything else. But it's the overwhelming incentive and overwhelms the incentive to co-opt and to take centralized control of something like Bitcoin, Nostr, whatever, you know. Went a little rant then.
2:28:03Vlad CosteaYeah, that was pretty cool because...
2:28:05Ben ArcI called it the Adam Smith invisible hand bitch slap, by the way. And the reason I call it that is because Adam Smith, when he talked about the invisible hand, a lot of people don't realize this or they overlook it or whatever because it doesn't fit whatever agenda. But Adam Smith's original invisible hand was very much that the British mer the British industrialists of that time, they had a vested interest in improving the lives of everyone in Britain. Even if they were complete psychopaths, just for their own security, they had a vested interest in improving the lives of the people around them.
2:28:37So it's like a contextualized form of private capital in that you exist within that community and you need to improve the lives of those people in that community to benefit yourself, even if it's complete self-interest. It makes sense. But when he wrote The Wealth of Nations, this was kind of. On the beginning of the phenomenon of the international evil corporations you had the East India Company which was around roughly the same time, but it wasn't really so well known what they were getting up to in India at the time. So you had these multinational corporations which weren't accountable.
2:29:09To the society or the community which existed in. So they could act very inappropriately and then just be completely for profit and then, you know, just kill hundreds of thousands of people in India and rape all the resources without any. Recompense because they existed in London and they were just funneling money back to London. So Adam Smith, very much when he spoke about the invisible hand, it was the guiding force which informed decision making based on. The industrialist being existing within a society of people or community of people where they also live.
2:29:45And that is why the private capital existing inside free and open source community is very similar in that we're accountable to our free and open source community and they keep us in check. So even if we want to be evil, like we get a bitch slap from the free open source community, which puts us back to, you know, keeps us in check and our decision making that we're always beholden to that community, which for me creates a very honest, form a private capital, much like Adam Smith's original idea behind the invisible hand.
2:30:23Vlad CosteaI also want to ask you, so it's slightly unrelated, but it has to do with your views on the state and taxation. What do you think about the situation of Roger Ver? I know that last year when I interviewed him, you're the person in the chat who really wanted to ask him a question and was telling him, come on. Come on, Roger. Return to Bitcoin. You're always welcome here. You're great at what you're doing. We need you.
2:30:50Ben ArcI like all the freaks, man. I want them back. I want Roger Ver, I want McAfee, bring him back from the grave or wherever he is. I want all the weirdos. I want those weird corporate people who are in Bitcoin. But the, yeah, with Roger Ver, like it's, he was important to the story of Bitcoin. I think that's why it was important that you, because you're a chronicler of Bitcoin story, aren't you? That's what you do. And he was inevitably a very important part of Bitcoin story.
2:31:19And he went astray for a little bit and he got that invisible hand bitch slap, that Adam Smith invisible hand bitch slap, which is very important. The community of Bitcoin users said, no, Bitcoin.com can't control Bitcoin. And for me, and I think for a lot of Bitcoiners, that's when it really proved its value that it couldn't be co-opted because it was always in the back of our minds that maybe some company or something would come along and take over this thing and then that's when it kind of proved itself that can't happen And that was the real value proposition But Roger Ver should have never have left Japan because they've got a non-extradition policy and he would have been safe there and So his mistake was leaving Japan and going to Europe.
2:32:04Because inevitably they're going to arrest him because often with those those real hardcore libertarian types, obviously they believe taxation is theft and that you're, I mean, there's a lot of truth to what they're saying and they don't, they feel morally that they can't pay their taxes because it's going to go on arms.
2:32:22It also benefits them of course, because they have more money, but you know, as a, as a moral stance, as a protest, it's like a protest where, you know, they financially benefit from it. So I'm not sure how, egalitarian it is but anyway he did I imagine he did that as most libertarians do. And we've lost a lot of very good libertarian Bitcoiners to that protest. But yeah, he did that protest, and then he left Japan, which he shouldn't have done. And then they caught him. What's going on with Roger Ver? Is he in prison yet, or...? On trial or.
2:32:54Vlad CosteaNo I think he's still in spain he's awaiting I'm not sure if he's gonna get extradited but I think that's that might be the next step. It's frightening, you know, to live like this and to be in a foreign country where maybe you don't speak the language and just wait for someone to knock on your door and say, OK, we're going back to the US now.
2:33:17Ben ArcI liked I liked his I mean, a lot of people liked him, and they liked his energy in Bitcoin. He was putting in the legwork and encouraging people to use Bitcoin and spreading the word about it. Think I don't know I mean, yeah, he did a bunch of stuff which people don't agree with, but... I mean, again, Bitcoin's permissionless. I think one of the coolest things he could possibly do is just come back. And just start building stuff for Bitcoin again. I know with Bitcoin.com, it's gone more Bitcoin-centric. It's stopped sort of trying to push Bcash as Bitcoin. So, you know, I wouldn't say it's admitting defeat if he came back or anything. I would just say that it's, you know, he tried something, didn't work. And that's all right. It's cool. Come back. And we, you know, we all need all hands on deck, don't we?
2:34:07And with Bitcoin already proving itself that, these centralized parties can't take control of decision making like that's no longer a problem Well, bring them all back, I say. Yeah.
2:34:21Vlad CosteaI think in a recent interview, he said he's bullish on Bitcoin again, but the context is slightly different because he doesn't want to use Bitcoin on the base layer. He doesn't like lightning, but he wants to wrap Bitcoin on a private network that enables for creation of tokens and basically trade this token of Bitcoin across other networks and make anonymous payments. At low fees. So it's basically what he likes. But uses BTC as basically the token.
2:34:56Ben ArcYeah, I mean, you can build it, but... I remember years ago he did like Lightning Network. But then because of the Bcash stuff he started FUD-ing on Lightning. But... It's a shame because like the legitimate... I mean, before, you know, I was accusing him of trying to co-opt Bitcoin. But I do see from his perspective that when he started using Bitcoin and then the businesses he built and the projects he built on Bitcoin were dependent upon there not being a fee market and zero-conf working and being able to make really cheap on-chain transactions. So I can see that... for them, it felt like that we were restricting and necessarily restricting the use of Bitcoin. And it was breaking all of the things which they built for Bitcoin because of the way in which Bitcoin changed, which it needed to have. You know, it needed to have a fee market for Bitcoin transactions. And it works very well.
2:35:58But I can certainly see from that point of view how frustrating it must have been. And I can see why they went the way they went. At the time. And then particularly as well how they felt betrayed when it came to the New York Agreement stuff I mean like it shouldn't have happened and it's a closed door agreement but there was you know under the agreement that okay we'll get SegWit in and then we'll increase block size to keep you guys happy as well And then I think pretty quickly people realize that shouldn't be a decision which is made behind a closed door and actually there isn't community support for or a consensus among Bitcoin users to increase the block size at that point in time.
2:36:39So. But then again, I can see how they felt that was something of a betrayal. From the developers as opposed to the reality, which was that it was the users as a whole who decided they didn't want this thing. But that's the sausage made in public, isn't it?
2:36:57Vlad CosteaOh, yeah. Are you in favor of increasing the block size down the line?
2:37:02Ben ArcYeah, I mean, like hardware gets better. I mean, I'd probably be more in favor of decreasing the block size, to be honest. I think it's very important that obviously people can run the blockchain themselves. And yeah, I'm kind of in favor of it. I'd be in favor of decreasing it more than increasing it. But yeah, I can see it makes stuff easier. It's a bit like... I kind of want fees to be higher because inevitably we're building this thing which will have very high fees. And it needs to be like, it needs to be built with lightning.
2:37:36Like I said before, a lot of people became disenfranchised with lightning because the on-chain fees went up so much. And it's sort of like, well, what did you think would happen? Ultimately, an on-chain fee might cost thousands of dollars. And if it does, we need smart scaling technologies. And it's good that it does cost that much because it incentivizes mining and the whole network becomes more secure. So, yeah, what did you think would happen? And it's like, in order for... Bitcoin to be more resilient and actually work in the future.
2:38:08We need high fees. So I'd be in favor of like halving the block size, having the fee slam up, and then I mean, this is the other thing. It's human nature to not address problems until they're critical, like scaling, for example. So when we saw the high fee environment, that's when Boltz became super successful. Because people had like an easier way to balance their lightning nodes. And it was like a nice cheap way to switch in and out of on-chain. And before that, they were struggling to you know to get to get adoption of people to use that technology, which is great.
2:38:39To the point where I think they almost gave up. And then it wasn't until... we had a high-fee environment and it was critical that the service like that existed, that it started to exist. And this is what we've seen with, yeah, I just say, you see a lot more development when things are critical. So when scaling becomes critical, you have people working on scaling technologies and then people more enthusiastic to try and build scaling technologies. The reason that channel factories weren't worked on for such a long time was lightning just kind of worked because fees were super duper cheap.
2:39:11So yeah, in a way, I'd be in favor of halving the block size, increasing the fee value, and then more people work on scaling.
2:39:22Vlad CosteaYeah, I... usually when we do this and Bitcoin becomes expensive, people search for other stuff to use. And that's how, for example, Litecoin has become super popular for payments. I think it's the most used on BitPay right now in the US, which is... sort of crazy given that BitPay started as this business that was a payments processor to enable merchants to accept BTC payments and now Litecoin is more popular and Monero has seen a rise, I think especially since the Samourai Wallet developers got arrested, it seems like a lot of Bitcoiners who are into privacy just went full Monero.
2:40:05And also, I also believe that the stuff happening on Solana and Ethereum. It could have happened on Bitcoin if we figured out scaling much sooner. And it's a bit disappointing because once again, we talk about fees and people willing to pay them, but for Tether on Tron to be sent, I think right now the fee is like $4. And people are willing to pay for that to send USDT. And it's a shame that this action went on Tron, which I think is a waste of time. As opposed to happening on Bitcoin.
2:40:46And... the question is how do we get users back on Bitcoin and how do we keep them? Because at one point they're going to figure out that the fees are too high. They just want to fulfill a very simple task, which is sending money from point A to point B, and they're going to find a cheaper network to do it.
2:41:05Ben ArcI think for medium of exchange, which is a big drive into the reason I got into Bitcoin was the payments technology is a medium of exchange. Stability. So like I said before, good money, like the number one property of good money, right, despite what Bitcoinists think is stability. That's what makes good money, okay? And then after that comes all these other things like privacy and everything else. So we need stability. And there was always this sort of naive assumption by Bitcoiners that the price would get to a certain point. That it wouldn't... be so volatile.
2:41:41Which is true, but I mean it's a much bigger market cap clearly than where we are now and we're at quite a big market cap. So until that happens, And it's almost a chicken and egg problem. It's like you need people to use it as money. So, to get the stability because you need like mass widespread adoption and you need people it distributed enough that Not... A small collection of parties can push the price up or down.
2:42:11But then people aren't going to use it as money. Until it's stable. So it's not going to be stable unless it's money, but people won't use it as money until it's stable. So until it just inherently becomes stable because its market cap is so high. To me, the solution is... just finding a whole bunch of ways in which we can have stability on Bitcoin. I think Tether, they're doing the Taproot Assets thing, so it'd be Bitcoin, but sort of on... it'd be like Tether on Lightning.
2:42:39To me, that's encouraging because if you go to the unbanked regions of this world where there's a lot of very well-meaning Bitcoiners saying, "Yeah, you should use Bitcoin. Look all the crazy things Bitcoin can do, and isn't it great?" Initially, they get excited, and then the price tanks, and then they can't pay their bills, and then they're less excited about it, and they end up using something like Tether in a way which is less elegant and doesn't have the crazy payment rails which Lightning Network has.
2:43:08So marrying the two necessarily isn't a bad thing in my mind. And then, like I said before with Galoy, they've got Stablesats, which is based on the Standard Sats project, which is synthetic stable assets on Bitcoin. I think I mean, you know, there's basically just Galoy working on that at the moment, but I honestly think that that's very, very important. And there's a whole bunch of other. ways in which you can have stable medium of exchange on the Bitcoin stack. Which I think are important and they were they were they would drive growth.
2:43:40So if you imagine El Salvador and if the technology toolset was at the point where it was easy to build stable medium of exchange on Bitcoin, then everyone in El Salvador would have adopted it. Particularly if it if you could call it you know whatever you're using like an El Salvador dollar or something. This is something I've talked about and I've been very keen on is that It's easy for people to build on the open source technologies, the Bitcoin open source technology stack.
2:44:09So when you look at countries looking to make their own digital coins the denominated in their local currency then the bigger players the bigger countries which have central banks and you know have like a technology department in government whatever they're going to look at building their own thing which they can have full control of course but then the smaller countries which don't have those resources.
2:44:32They'll look at the free and open source technology stack. And then actually, probably some of the bigger countries might look at that free and open source technology stack as well. And I think it's kind of important that we have recipes for building some of that stuff on Bitcoin. And to me, that's how, because I want the whole world to be running on Bitcoin. Bitcoin is the backbone for the world's economy. Yes, of course. In the midterm, you're going to have some digital currencies, some soft currencies. We're not going to get away from them because modern society is completely dependent upon them. They have soft having soft currency functions. To me, it's technology as well. I'm like, okay, so some parts of having soft currency isn't necessarily bad. Like I said before, being able to produce more if you want to produce fiscal stimulus, but it needs to be done in a way which is corruption resistant.
2:45:15I feel like with the Bitcoin technology stack, we're getting to the point where we have the technologies where you can have corruption resistant soft currency so like that's that's the That's how So it's like everyone builds that stuff. You build stable medium of exchange on Bitcoin. Everyone uses Bitcoin either natively as sats or they use it as digital US dollar or digital El Salvador dollar, whatever, or Turkish lira.
2:45:36And then once everyone's using it, we then have the liquidity and the distribution of coins that which is necessary for then Bitcoin to become more stable and inevitably over time people will just move out of those things into just using Bitcoin natively. So it's like an important part of the journey. which a lot of Bitcoiners just inherently resist because they're like, oh no, you should just use sats and get used to a sat standard, blah, blah, blah. And it's like, okay, well, nice rhetoric But like, if you're a subsistence wage earner in a poor country, we should actually really benefit from using this technology.
2:46:10which can bank unbanked people, like, it's void. Because the price is too volatile. The Bitcoin price is too volatile. So I'm very excited actually over any stable stuff on Bitcoin. Because that to me is the path we need to take in order to actually get stability so people can use Bitcoin natively.
2:46:31Vlad CosteaI appreciate your bullishness.
2:46:34Ben ArcIt just takes time, man. Time. Dialectic and time. That's all we need. But I mean, the worrying thing is that Because of the way in which economies seem to be going people the world might need this technology sooner than we're ready, you know, and I really want to have the toolset ready for it. But yeah, the El Salvador thing was a big letdown for me. It made me very sad. Put me in a dark place. But then I saw some of the work which Maya's doing in Suriname. She's the Bitcoin president there.
2:47:09And again, that's another country which could totally make use of, you know, it could, like, bootstrap their economy. For everyone to be able to have access to digital payments. And they're not just digital payments, all the other technologies which come along with it such as public key cryptography, Nostr, everything else. Like It's only a matter of time until some of these smaller countries they superpower themselves. They give themselves a massive bootstrap by making use of the technology stack of Bitcoin. And yeah, I look forward to it. But we it was as Bitcoiners, I feel like we fell short when it came to helping El Salvador.
2:47:49I mean, I know that I think there was a lot of centralized decision making such as Chivo wallet, which would just basically scam people because it wouldn't verify payments, so you couldn't prove that the payment went through or not.
2:48:04Which gave people a really poor experience on paying in Bitcoin. But then also, like, I kind of assumed, like, within the first few months, when I heard about Blockstream going to, working with the El Salvador government, I thought, okay, cool, they're going to make some, like, Liquid El Salvador dollar. It'll be federated and like to the point where because we had it so in the UK we had this local currency called the Bristol Pound, which was really successful. And it was a piece of shit. It was just a database. But it was a digital currency, and it was just called the Bristol Pound.
2:48:39And the reason it had such great adoption was because people could culturally associate with it because they lived in Bristol. And I kind of feel, that would be similar with El Salvador, for example, if they created... some sort of El Salvador dollar. And it could just be pegged to the US dollar, the euro, and I don't know, the price of coffee, something relevant to their economy.
2:49:02That if the people who live in that country, they would have immense pride that they've now got this El Salvador dollar and they'd want to use it. And particularly if it was stable and if it was-- by then, it's using Lightning Network for rails and it's all about it's all on Bitcoin. And they can easily just swap out into Bitcoin as well for their savings. They'd want to use it. When I first started, you know when I first started thinking about this stuff? Was... Bilal, is that his name? You know, the guy, the guy with the drums, the Turkish guy with the cat. Oh, in Istanbul. Yeah, in Istanbul. You were there.
2:49:37Vlad CosteaYeah, yeah, it was the Fulmo workshop, right? Yeah.
2:49:40Ben ArcYeah, yeah. The hackathon. And you remember, because he's a blind guy, and he's a really proper genius drum guy, isn't he? But he's blind, and he's drumming on these drums, and he's like...
2:49:49Vlad CosteaSo he's talking about the guy who's singing while... There was a juxtaposition of a car of a cat. That's just... Yeah. What's this called? Vibing? Shaking head? I don't know.
2:50:01Ben ArcYeah, yeah. It's like a meme of 2015 or something very popular.
2:50:06Vlad CosteaNo, it's 2019, 2020.
2:50:09Ben Arc2019, 2020. Yeah, I got my, I managed to, do you see I got the video of me playing in the background of me? Yeah, bopping my head, banging your head I managed to climb inside the meme. It was good but the Yeah, it was when... He was going, "I love Germans," because there's loads of Germans there, wasn't it? So he's playing his drums and he goes, "I love Germans," everyone goes, "Hey!" And then someone said, "Do you love Bitcoin?" And he went, "No, I love Turkish lira, because I'm Turkish." And...
2:50:36Vlad CosteaLike, I remember that. Yeah, you remember? I think about that sometimes because this poor guy got wrecked. Every time I see news about the Turkish lira devaluing, I remember this guy and I'm like, oh, poor guy.
2:50:48Ben ArcBut it was devaluing at that time like it was it's a shitcoin at that time. But that is such a poignant statement. That he loves that because he's Turkish. Now, arguably it's got nothing to do with him. The, currency issuer of the Turkish lira, but if he finds, and we... we have it as Bitcoiners. We're like, oh, we love Bitcoin because we're Bitcoiners. So we have cultural associations to Bitcoin. I think humanity... has been trained over thousands of years of countries issuing currency with, you know, the heads of state or whatever on top of their currency that we associate and we have cultural identity with our currency. And actually, I think it's where a lot of people hate, why a lot of people hated the euro when it first came out was they lost that. They lost that even if their currency was crap, they still lost that pride they had in the fact that on their currency they had culturally relevant symbolism.
2:51:38And yes, we have it as Bitcoiners, absolutely. And I'm sure the rest of the world will eventually when they figure out Bitcoin's cool. But for now... you could just take this thing. It's Bitcoin. It's stable. And then you just stamp it with, OK, this is a Turkish lira. And this is the El Salvador dollar. And this is the whatever. This is the Welsh pound. There we are. And actually, Yeah, so they would have cultural association with it. He would love it. He was like, oh, do you love the Turkish Bitcoin dollar? He'd be like, yeah, I love the Turkish Bitcoin dollar. And he'd have a stable digital currency, and it'd have all these – great functionalities but he could have some cultural association with it in the Welsh context So I'm quite keen on, you know, Wales being separate from the rest of the UK.
2:52:21In that example, one of the big issues would be what we're going to use as currency, being to carry on using the British pound, you know, which is managed by the Bank of England, may I add. It's not the Bank of Britain, it's the Bank of England. Would we carry on using the British pound? It's like, okay, we'll make the Welsh pound. Well, have we got the skills to make the Welsh pound? Well, I don't know about that. I kind of feel that if you had...
2:52:44A Welsh pound, which was developed, and then built on the Bitcoin stack, and was done in such a way that maybe it's a federation. Maybe it's an eCash, maybe it's an eCash federation, and it's done in such a way that it's hard to corrupt because the control is spread across different counties in Wales, then people would start using it locally and they start trading in it locally.
2:53:03And then it as the use case as the use users grow, they get to the point where they'd be like, well, we don't really need the British pound anymore because we've got this thing and it works just as well. It works better than that thing. And also, it's Welsh, eh.
2:53:17So you know maybe we can So it might even be a driver of something which helps liberate some of these smaller countries from the colonial yoke of the bigger country. But, yeah, I think it's an inevitable thing which will happen is that some of these smaller countries will make use of the technology stack we have in Bitcoin. And then hopefully they'll end up with a digital Turkish lira, and Bilal, what's his name? I think his name is Bilal. He can be proud of the Turkish lira. It's funny how you think about that as well.
2:53:50Vlad CosteaIt was a memorable moment that night that he played some songs and then at the end people were sending him tips and he said, I love Germans because, of course, most of the crowd was German. And then people asked him, oh, do you also love Bitcoin? And he did receive someone set him up with a wallet. I think someone else, one of the organizers was in charge of basically exchanging that Bitcoin for the local currency, which is the Turkish lira. I guess he left happy. Maybe he bought himself something nice after that performance. But he got wrecked on the long term if he held any of that money. And if he kept some Bitcoin just for fun or whatever, he'd be much better off. So I think about that.
2:54:34Ben ArcThat was an LNURL-pay made on LNbits. That was the QR code people were sending tips to. Yeah, it was set up and then But that's I mean, that is a very nice way to get, you know, yourself a bit of KYC free Bitcoin, isn't it? Is you organize an event like that. And then it's the cash in the bag solution, which I think Christine Russo came up with actually, which is, you give someone well, his idea was you would give a bar say cash in a bag. Then you say, you know, you don't accept Bitcoin payments, but accept Bitcoin payments.
2:55:08And every time you take a payment in Bitcoin, just take the cash out of the bag. And then put the cash in your till. And then actually the Bitcoin payments then just go to somebody else like an actual Bitcoiner who wants the Bitcoin payments. I can't remember the exact reason he made that idea up, but I think it was because they wanted to hold a Bitcoin meetup in a specific bar, maybe in Berlin. And they weren't accepting Bitcoin payments or something like that. And it was a way for them to accept payments. Yeah. But then the Bitcoin kind of, like, goes directly to another Bitcoiner. But then the Bitcoin that gets out of it is a bit of KYC-free Bitcoin.
2:55:49You get it sometimes if you go to a Bitcoin conference. You have dinner with people and then it comes time to pay the pays the tab. And because fiat is so shit, you can't like... you know, all just pay towards... you have to split the... they only let you split the bill like two ways. They don't let you split the bill and each individual pays. They're just like, oh no, we can only take two payments. So then what clever Bitcoiners do in those scenarios is they put their hands up and say, I'll pay the whole bill and everyone pay me in Bitcoin.
2:56:18And they get their nice little stash of KYC free Bitcoin. But it's excruciating when you see that and you're just like, God damn, this technology exists. Where even if it were pennies, I could pay for my, even if I just, you know, bought a cup of tea and the rest of you had a $50 meal, I could just pay for my part and it would just be, you know, an LNURL-pay or something. And we're all just paying until the tab hits the right amount. It's just crazy that the technology exists and society's not using it really. But they will when we get stable medium of exchange.
2:56:54Vlad CosteaYeah, we got to stay focused on the goal.
2:56:56Ben ArcYeah, man. Yeah. And this I was thinking about this earlier, you know, like, whenever it was, you know, when we first had the Lightning, first started going mainnet and you had like yours and you know, the wall, remember that wall where you could draw on it and pay?
2:57:09Vlad CosteaOh, yeah. I think it was called the Lightning... Paywall? No, no, no.
2:57:17Ben ArcI racked my brain. It was some Satoshi wall, maybe.
2:57:20Vlad CosteaIt was the K0ala guy who built it. This was 2018. It was all the rage back then. You could draw on the wall and then... you pay for every pixel? It's pretty fun.
2:57:34Ben ArcIt's mind-blowing. It was my when you first did it, when you first made that payment, when you drew on it and it generated the invoice and then you made the payment and then everyone could see the thing you drew. We were all like, wow. You know, unlocking a Yalls article, for example. And it blew all of our minds. And then I feel we get so used to it and we take it for granted. We're like, oh, this thing's not that good, really, is it? You know, maybe we need to build something else. And it's like, wait for the rest of the world to catch up.
2:58:03Because the rest of the world, they still need to have, like, the Yalls experience. They still need to go and just, like, pay for an article on Yalls and have it unlock, you know? Like micropayments technology is huge. Just that on its own, just being able to send a tiny amount of money over the internet and then get access to some content, for example.
2:58:22So we get bored and stuff becomes, you know, old hat for us. But, you know, the rest of the world is still in, well, maybe I should buy some of this Bitcoin stuff stage, as opposed to, well, look at what the crazy technology can do, Adam Curry stage. So it's... Yes. It's. We shouldn't become too disheartened over these incredible tools we've built. We should just have more. Mechanisms for people to access the tools. And access the experience and the technology and make those initial payments. That's the wow factor.
2:58:53The example the Wall example was funny because it was my for years, Bitcoin parents are like, they try and indoctrinate their kids and they're like, "Oh, Bitcoin, censorship resistant," and they, you know, your kids don't... some kids care, my kid didn't care, my boy didn't care. He's just like, "Yeah, whatever, Dad, that's your thing." And then it was when I went onto that wall and I drew a penis on it, And then I paid. And he was like, wow. I was like, yeah, man, exactly.
2:59:24Look how good this is. That was his orange pill moment. What this technology is capable of. Mind blown. Yeah, mind blown. Yeah, exactly. And actually, to this day, If someone's like, "Oh, what is Lightning?" Very likely I might go on Yalls and show them like paying for some content and unlocking a thing and then go, "Wow, all the newspapers use this." I'm waiting for that. I think this is something which I really want to see happen is on, like, a significant date, maybe the white paper day or something that the Financial Times has a an article about Bitcoin and you unlock the article by making a Lightning payment. I think that would be cool.
3:00:00Just as like a marketing thing, but then also just to celebrate the technology and ultimately like you know it's for me I often I'll go to the Financial Times I'm not subscribed to it but there's an article someone sends me a link to and I go over to read the article and then I get paywalled and I'm like oh man I got to pay I got to get subscription and then I don't get the subscription I can't access the content and I would pay like 50p or something, I would overpay.
3:00:30For what that article is actually worth, you know, if you look at subscription, then each article is maybe worth, you know, a penny, a couple of pennies per user. For the amount of articles people read, I would overpay for that. So yeah, I'm not going to be making that monthly subscription payment, which is valuable to the newspaper, but I would overpay for that individual article which I think is interesting and I want to read it so it's only a matter of time until that industry just that... that's just one use case for Lightning just that industry just the newspaper industry and journalism selling pay-as-you-go articles.
3:01:04They need it. They need to bring more money and all these things are like loss making. Although I did discover quite a nice hack actually, you can just go on the Wayback Machine. Because I think the Wayback Machine like pays for subscriptions for all of these papers. So if you take the article link and then just pop it in the Wayback Machine, you can usually get access to it that way. So, just by them not having a decent technology solution forced me to move towards, you know, piracy.
3:01:40Vlad CosteaYeah, that's an interesting thought to have. But on the other hand, Apple Pay and Google Pay and all of these services have made it so easy to pay from your bank account directly to whatever service you're reading on your phone or even on your computer. I don't think Bitcoin has a better user experience anymore. Or... is not the easiest to use.
3:02:05Ben ArcBut you're restricted by visa fees, basically. So like some of those companies allow you to make smaller transactions than a dollar, but really... they don't want you to make smaller transactions than dollar because Visa is an expensive network to run, whereas Lightning Network isn't expensive. So you can make those microtransactions for a tiny fee. So this is why I quite like the value for value stuff now. It took me a while to kind of get it, you know.
3:02:33But I quite like the idea of crowdsourcing, funding, making money via the crowd via everyone making smaller payments and it's not really possible in a sustainable way over Visa network particularly if everybody's doing it. So you could synthetically allow people to pay 20p to read an article at a loss using Visa Network. But then if the whole world's doing it, Visa Network would implode in on itself because it'd be too many transactions for Visa Network to accommodate. So like, it's just mad how like, Bitcoin now has the ability, has this thing which can do all the things.
3:03:10Because that was it was like back in the with the scaling stuff is okay, Bitcoin can do three transactions a second and Visa Network can do 25,000 transactions a second.
3:03:21And then within a few short years, We've built the technology to - To rival Visa. It's like, we can do infinite transactions per second essentially, depending on how many nodes you have in the network or whatever. There's almost no restriction on how many transactions per second you can do now with the Lightning Network. And we it was built within a few years, and then everyone's complaining about it because it's so hard. And it's like, well, hold on. We've got to the point now where we've replaced Visa Network.
3:03:52Okay, yes, now let's make it easier for everybody to run and everybody to have their own Lightning Nodes. But let's all take a moment and acknowledge. How cool it is that we built something which outcompetes the predominant payments Network on the planet and it works better and we can do everything they can do. But better. Let's take a moment to take that in first. Okay, now we make it easier for everyone else to access. And we are.
3:04:21Vlad CosteaI get that, but at the same time, I think Apple Pay doesn't charge every individual transaction, I think it's more like a layer five or something of the fiat system. So it's like you make multiple payments and then you get billed.
3:04:36Ben ArcYeah, but I mean, that's just... Yeah, but I mean... Okay, you can simulate it, but then you can't go out of the network, can you? So, it's by Apple Pay, you're probably doing an Apple Pay to an Apple Pay, I guess. And then just doing a database flip. What happened with, do you know, the company I never hear anything about which got crazy investment was... Strike? A Strike?
3:05:04Vlad CosteaThey got like a... That's such a good question. I remember like three years ago, there was this presentation on stage by Jack Mallers. And he was saying now...
3:05:13Ben ArcIt wasn't Strike. So it's not Strike.
3:05:15Vlad CosteaYeah. Oh, I was going to rant about buying Coke over Tor because he promised that you can walk into any supermarket in the United States and you can buy Coke, you know, this innuendo for Coca-Cola and cocaine. Basically, buy that with your home node that you're on over Tor. And he promised that this feature was going to come to the US and then Europe. Never came. It was just the promise. What's the service that you say raised a lot of money in this year?
3:05:45Ben ArcChrist, I can't remember. It was one of the PayPal guys. And he raised 200 million and it wasn't strike. I got my names muddled up. Oh, they raised 200 million and they were like a lightning company. And it was the PayPal guys. Someone in the comments remembers what they are, the company they are.
3:06:02Vlad CosteaNot Battle Pay, right?
3:06:04Ben ArcNo, no, no. Urgh. Anyway, I just hadn't heard anything of the...
3:06:10Vlad CosteaWhat was it doing anymore exactly?
3:06:12Ben ArcI think they were just piggybacking off the technology. This is always personally my fear that someone will just take our stuff and just use it without the Bitcoin part. They'll just take Lightning and just decouple it and then use it without Bitcoin. That's always my fear. But it was... I thought for some reason I got it muddled up with Strike, although I haven't heard anything from Strike for a while. But yeah. It's funny the old... VC world in Bitcoin. It's a strange experience to be exposed to it. With the raise with the LNbits raise. It's insightful.
3:06:48And frustrating because I'm not very good at the spiel, which is expected. And it's funny because I spoke to a bunch of... successful CEOs who've raised money from VCs, and some of the tactics are so manipulative and so corrupt. I'm like, "Is this really what you have to do to raise money?" They're like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's what everyone does." It's something which I can't do because I'm not very good at. I'm not being dishonest, but, you know, being manipulative, I guess, but the, It's a funny old world. It's a funny old world, those VCs. They like investing in kind of the new fad, don't they?
3:07:29Vlad CosteaWell, I wouldn't know. I never spoke with, I mean, maybe I spoke with a couple of them, but I never pitched them anything. I just...
3:07:36Ben ArcYeah. They're kind of wolves in lamb's clothing. They present themselves as being very cuddly and friendly, but then a lot of them are pretty, well shrewd or just mean, I guess. I don't want to speak too badly of them. But the Yeah, it's a funny old layer of Bitcoin which I didn't really have access to before. And then when you have access to it's so different to, obviously, the layer of developers and the development community, which is great. You know, feel very at home there. Then I have to rub shoulders with some of those folks because everyone's kind of, a lot of them are playing, you know, kind of an angle or a game or whatever. And it's... It's much more honest in the developer community than the VC one. But...
3:08:24Vlad CosteaI think you are referring to Lightspark? Lightspark. By David Marcus, yeah.
3:08:31Ben ArcYeah, yeah, yeah. They raised 200 million. What are they doing?
3:08:36Vlad Costea175? Maybe 25 in the previous round, but wow, crazy.
3:08:44Ben ArcReal-time payments for the internet. Is there anything about Bitcoin on here? Go on the website, see if you can find anything about Bitcoin.
3:08:53Vlad CosteaWell, isn't David Marcus the same guy who was trying to launch Libra, which was Facebook's stablecoin?
3:09:01Ben ArcIs that the same guy? Yeah, he's one of the PayPal guys. He's doing that. Isn't he working with the US now or something? Yeah. It's a flashy looking website. It does mention Bitcoin a couple of times, but it's like towards the bottom of the page. Lightspark. It's kind of similar to LNbits, except they raised 200 million. And it sort of came out of nowhere. But I guess he is one of the PayPal boys. They're an odd bunch, the PayPal boys. Elon Musk. Yeah. Libra was something which I thought would happen. And I was kind of worried about it in a way because I thought, well, everyone's just going to use this thing on Facebook and they'll get used to it and then everyone will stop using Bitcoin. But then for some reason, it didn't happen. The Facebook Libra coin. I guess it was the regulatory side.
3:09:56Made it too hard for them to run.
3:10:00Vlad CosteaI also recall very clearly that there were a bunch of companies announcing. There was something from Microsoft that they were going to do decentralized IDs, like identity on the blockchain. And I think David Marcus also had something like this and MicroStrategy announced something like this. Like a year or two ago. Seems like we have these... Yeah. Weird use cases like they don't make too much sense but they raise a lot of money and then you don't hear them you don't hear about them anymore.
3:10:37Ben ArcYeah, I mean, it's the sort of piggybacking off all the good work, which the developers in Bitcoin do, aren't they? And they're like, oh, we can do this, with it. We can do that with it. And they raise a bunch of money, like you say, yeah. And, But then actually delivering those solutions is a lot harder than maybe they thought. But I remember the decentralized identity thing. It had some good... Christopher Allen, I think his name was. He was working on that. He's part of the Bitcoin... Oh, I can't remember what they were called. It's like a San Francisco body, but they produced a lot of good stuff, and he was working on the decentralized identity thing. Ultimately, though, it's public key cryptography, isn't it? That's why I like Nostr because it's you don't need a blockchain, but you can have an identity. But yeah, I think Yeah, Microsoft's an interesting one. Because at one point they were going to was it...
3:11:31DigiCoin? DigiCoin? Chaum's eCash. They were going to buy that, weren't they? Yeah, DigiCash. Yeah, not DigiCoin, DigiCash. And they offered... I think they were going to buy it for like 100 million or something but then the deal fell through but had it gone through then everyone would have had access to eCash through Microsoft on their Microsoft computers which is quite a crazy concept back in I don't know what it was. 2001 or something.
3:12:00Vlad CosteaI was thinking it's more like 97, 98, but it was so early and internet commerce was at such an early stage, but I think we would be much better off if we made our payments online with DigiCash with some privacy. Right now, people just got used to typing their credit card information on websites and making their browsers remember that.
3:12:25Ben ArcYeah, it's potty, isn't it? Yeah. There was a drive years ago, do you remember, about... keeping your identity safe and not putting your identity into too many websites because you might have identity theft. There certainly was in the UK. And then it's almost like everyone just sort of forgot that idea. And they're like, oh, it's okay. Just throw your identity around everywhere on the internet.
3:12:44Vlad CosteaI think Facebook sort of normalized this. Before that, I remember using more pseudonyms. But on Facebook, you had to put your real name, real picture, school you're attending, you know, get found by your peers. And that was sort of the incentive to put your real information so your friends can find you or you can discover this friend from school who moved into another city or That's the way I remember it. Before that, I never put my real information on websites.
3:13:15Ben ArcIt's funny how like all those little compromises you make or people made, on the internet so they were like okay this thing is sacrosanct I'm never going to do this thing it's like you make this little compromise like oh well I want access to this I'm gonna I'll give up my identity for this I'll give my identity for that and then over time they just kind of wear you down and you make more and more compromises until you're completely doxxed and everyone's got all your information. Then you take it back. And the way we take it back is public key cryptography and Nostr and all the great things we're building in Bitcoin. But there are two versions of reality in the future. There's a dystopian one, where corporations control us, and governments, and there's one where people are free. And the one where people are free, it requires us as humans to take control of the software and the hardware.
3:14:07And when people do, like, I think we see it as technologists, don't we? People who are like, we've been around other people who take control of software and hardware. And then we see them create these beautiful things because they're humans and that's what humans want to do. So it's like, it's that Hal Finney quote, isn't it? This thing which can be used to control us can also be used to free us.
3:14:36Vlad CosteaYeah, I think Hal Finney even wrote some articles about this. And he was basically encouraging everyone to not use any form of internet money that has no privacy.
3:14:49Ben ArcYeah. Which would not be Bitcoin.
3:14:53Vlad CosteaYep. But that was one of his first tweets about... I think it was the second one about Bitcoin. He posted running Bitcoin. Then like a few days later, he came back and said, looking into ways to add more anonymity to Bitcoin transactions.
3:15:08Ben ArcWow. It's a bit like... Lightning with payment channels, isn't it? It's like, oh, we need to make payment channels. Oh, we need more anonymity in Bitcoin transactions. And we're here now. We still haven't got the anonymity in Bitcoin transactions or payment channels. What do you think about anonymity on the base layer, on-chain?
3:15:29Vlad CosteaI'm all for it.
3:15:31Ben ArcYeah, same. I'm same. I think the Monero arguments, what you get, what you benefit from far outweighs any worry about inflation.
3:15:39Vlad CosteaIt's a bit absurd to think that we have such advanced blockchain analysis tools right now, and there is no way to protect yourself other than a CoinJoin, which is, you know, It's just adding a little bit of doubt. But at the end of the day, you're going to spend that on some KYC off-ramp. And that's how they can trace back to figure out what you've been doing. Bitcoin has no privacy. It just has deniability, which fades. The more you use it, And also... It's stored forever. So just because you don't know or someone else doesn't know who's transacting, it doesn't mean that they will not be able to know in the future.
3:16:19Ben ArcYeah, particularly with the AI stuff. You imagine Chainalysis with the AI added in the mix as well. Being able to figure out whose coins are whose. Yeah, the CoinJoin stuff, I was always... It's cool that people have the technology for CoinJoining, but I always was worried it would add kind of more of a fungibility attack because you could I honestly think one of the best attacks people can do to Bitcoin government-wise would be to allow like clean coins. to be used for stuff, but then not CoinJoined coins, because then you end up with coins having different value on the marketplace, and that would suck.
3:16:54If that is because you can't have fungibility issues in actual money. So I always thought that would be the one of the best attacks. Like if you know if they the US really wanted to put a thorn in Bitcoin's side. They would say, "Okay, you can use the clear net coins where we can crack the history of them, but you can't use the CoinJoin coins." Which they do, I suppose, to a degree.
3:17:20If you buy any real world good, anything big like a house or something, then often most countries want proof of where that money came from, like you're saying in Europe and in the UK is the same. I think in the US is similar too, that you need to prove where those funds come from. I always feel sorry for...
3:17:38Because sometimes you get the kind of Bitcoin, the middle class Bitcoin enthusiast who buys a stack of Bitcoin on Kraken or something or some exchange and then listens to or listens to an Odell podcast shilling CoinJoining, joins their coins and then, I don't know, A few years later, it goes up in price. They want to buy a house with it. And then they can't because they can't prove where the money came from. So they've got all these coins and they don't know what to do with them. And then they find that they have to end up laundering their own coins to give them a history.
3:18:09So they can actually buy something significant with their own coins. But that's always like a risk with just promoting CoinJoining without acknowledging the risk of CoinJoining, that At some point, you might want to buy something with those coins and you might not be able to And you might have to launder your own money. Particularly if you bought them on an exchange.
3:18:28Vlad CosteaThat's why it's so bullish when exchanges support lightning, right? Because you get your CoinJoined Bitcoin on the Lightning Network and then it doesn't matter.
3:18:38Ben ArcYeah. Well, arguably, I suppose you still need to prove the history of it when it came to... buying a house or some big asset. But I suppose ultimately, you know, that stuff goes away. But currently, that's the material world in which we live in. And the only the one of the best ways for that stuff to go away, probably, is for anonymity on chain, on the base layer. It's funny, I remember... who was it? Pieter Wuille. He did a talk in... He didn't actually do a talk. Someone else did a talk, but I won't mention them because it's too embarrassing.
3:19:16Vlad CosteaI'm going to interview him soon.
3:19:18Ben ArcWho, Pieter Wuille?
3:19:20Vlad CosteaI wish. He's not interested, but the person giving the talk, I'm going to interview him soon.
3:19:25Ben ArcOh, really? Oh, it's good. Will that will that reveal who it is?
3:19:29Vlad CosteaYou told me the story already, but you should tell it.
3:19:34Ben ArcOkay, yeah, yeah. So it's the Chaos Communication Congress in Germany, Leipzig in Germany. And it's cool. It's like, you know, 50,000 hackers or something ridiculous. They descend on these, aircraft hangars in Leipzig in Germany. And, It's part of the Chaos Computer Club, and they're, like, legit... hacker computer club, the ones who kept WikiLeaks going when it was being attacked. Anyway, so they organized this event and all these hackers go. It's between Christmas and New Year's, and you have all these different assemblies, and it's kind of an unconference style, so every sort of discipline is just given an area.
3:20:07So it's like, okay, you're into I don't know 3D printing. This is your 3D printing area. Now build something. And the people build up an area and they have their own talks and whatever. Anyway, so you have the Bitcoin assembly, which is embarrassingly small in this venue because a lot of these people like anarchist hacker types and they just kind of associate Bitcoin with the Saylor ideology, or whatever, of greed and gains. So they don't really like it, you know, they don't see it for the wonderful internet money it is. They used to, until the gains ideology kind of became the predominant...
3:20:43I don't know, way in which people viewed Bitcoin. Anyway, so you got this little Bitcoin assembly. It's a small table of like 20 or 30 people. And I remember there was this one year Pieter Wuille was there. And there was someone at the assembly and they did a talk on it. The talk was on how perfect Bitcoin is as it is and how we don't need privacy on Bitcoin because we have CoinJoins and that fixes the privacy.
3:21:05And I remember Pieter Wuille, he was quite embarrassed because, I mean, he was sat down listening to this talk and then he just stopped him in his tracks and he was like, nope. I'm working towards zero-knowledge transactions. I want to be able to send money to somebody else and for there to be no way of knowing that I sent money to that other person. That's what I'm working towards. This is Pieter Wuille. And the person who was doing this talk, they were quite young at the time.
3:21:31The person who was doing the talk, I was just, I was like, I would hate to be you right now. Just to be like shot down by Pieter Wuille, just to be... when there's like 30 people sat there watching you. Like, and also Pieter Wuille is such a nice guy. He's all fuzzy and, you know, cuddly looking. And then for him to like quite aggressively go after this person, I was like, oh, crikey. Could you imagine?
3:21:57Vlad CosteaI mean, that's a badge of honor to get acknowledged by Pieter Wuille. But at the same time, there's so much cool stuff happening right now. So Litecoin did the Mimblewimble Extension Block, Which adds some privacy with scalability, you get increased block size that's prunable with some privacy, which is pretty good. And what Zcash is doing is pretty mind blowing. I read recently that they figured out a way to make transactions even smaller and make it more scalable. Their privacy is top notch. It doesn't matter how many participants you have in the anonymity pool. You have the same anonymity set.
3:22:38From this point of view, it's superior to the ring signatures in Monero because you have the entirety of... the supply that's available in the anonymity pool that gives you the deniability. And then you also have confidential transactions that hide the amount and everything else. It gives me hope. It's like a very advanced research lab for Bitcoin. They started out in 2013. There were two papers that were published for making Bitcoin private. The first one was called ZeroCoin. And that became Zcoin later on as an altcoin.
3:23:14And now it's called Firo. And the other one was Zerocash, which... turned into Zcash. The goal of this was always to make Bitcoin private. It's just that until recently they had this trusted setup so they could only create the zk-SNARKs by having a bunch of people generating the private keys and then destroying their computers. I actually own Peter Todd's laptop from that era when he created the first...
3:23:42Ben ArcYou've got that, have you? You've got that laptop?
3:23:44Vlad CosteaYeah, I have it.
3:23:45Ben ArcThat's cool, because there was a video where they were destroying the laptop. Or the photos. I remember seeing the photos maybe.
3:23:51Vlad CosteaI bought it from Peter like three years ago.
3:23:55Ben ArcWow. There we are.
3:23:56Vlad CosteaIt's like, oh, I have this in storage. I want to get rid of it. I paid him like a thousand bucks.
3:24:02Ben ArcDude, that's worth it. Bloody hell. That's quite a cool laptop right there. That's quite a cool Bitcoin artifact to have. I always thought that was funny because he was like... was he employed to work? I think he was employed, wasn't he? Yeah, so it's his classic Peter Todd behavior, where he gets employed to work on something, and then he just... does a whole bunch of talks afterwards, just FUD-ing on the thing which he was employed to work on. And he was employed to help work on this thing. But, you know, arguably he had a very good point.
3:24:30He then did a whole bunch of talks for years afterwards on, you know, how private is Zcash because how do we know that the hardware wasn't corrupted inside the laptop and blah blah blah and that's when he showed the pictures and I saw that talk a couple of times at different conferences but it's always funny how, like, they employed him, bring him in to FUD on it.
3:24:51Vlad CosteaYeah, yeah, he spent about a year touring around the world speaking about the dishonesty of the Zcash setup. But to their credit, they actually made it work without the trusted setup. It took them like six years to get there, but now they have it. The problem is that Bitcoin culture is so Saylorized. I don't know how to describe it. So complacent in saying that Bitcoin is perfect and it doesn't need anything that even looking into that and telling other people, you know, this is cool. Maybe we should reconsider this. See how far we can get. It gets you within that shitcoin territory where people put a label on you and they're like, Oh, you're not pure enough, you should not hang out with us. We're not going to listen to your podcast now.
3:25:38Ben ArcThat's the no true Scotsman, isn't it? You know the no true Scotsman fallacy, which is: no true Scotsman would ever do this, no true Scotsman would ever do that. And then it's, what is a true Scotsman? So no true Bitcoiner would, you know, think that Zcash is cool. No true Bitcoiner would, you know, I don't know, like the idea of a cooperative.
3:26:01Like, it's a fallacy in that there is no true Bitcoiner, and what you do have is probably an... like, the ultimate boiled-down version of whatever the no true Bitcoiner is by those who push that is whatever the true Bitcoiner is sorry by Whoever pushed that is probably an asshole anyway, so you don't want to be them. But Yeah, it's kind of an issue we've had. But I think with Bitcoin, like... people don't realize... the like, people like the, you know, they have realized they can't destroy Bitcoin. So now... the they think, well, how can we control Bitcoin?
3:26:39And it's okay, when you build a narrative around it, that it's not freedom technology, it's not something which is going to compete with the USD, it's just something you can trade, it's just something, it's just some digital gold, some assets, some trading asset which you can use. It's not this free open source magic internet money, which is going to replace the US dollar.
3:27:04And people heavily underestimate like how powerful those forces are and how far reaching their tentacles go. And I'm always very distrusting when I hear of someone who's, actively trying to position themselves in a place of power within the Bitcoin community and shape the narrative and then start commenting on the way in which Bitcoin should be developed and how it should be ossified or whatever else. So I'm always I'm always very skeptical. I think we should all be skeptical of it. So like. You know, for those...
3:27:39I mean, your listeners are well-schooled on all this stuff, but... you know, the cypherpunks, they were like heavily infiltrated by the alphabet agencies because they were fighting for normal people to have privacy on the internet and at that time governments didn't want normal people to have privacy on the internet and access to cryptography. And then those people, the cypherpunk people, they create this new payments technology which exists to disrupt the traditional power bases in the world and countries controlled different countries control over, over money.
3:28:14And then there was kind of this weird assumption that it was only the cypherpunks which were infiltrated by these agencies. And that wouldn't then transcend into, into Bitcoin. And like, I often say that like the, back in the day, it was the few random people who turned up at the conference and asked too many questions. They were probably spooks, but I would say that we shouldn't think that there's some people on stage who aren't probably spooks in Bitcoin and who aren't going trying to control the narrative and who aren't trying to just restrict the growth of Bitcoin and its impact. Because it's certainly within the interests of the people who would send out agency folks to position themselves within the Bitcoin ecosystem. As they do. So yeah, exciting times. Spooks everywhere.
3:29:03Vlad CosteaMan. Speaking of spooks and cypherpunks and Nostr all at the same time, I think it was one of the Einundzwanzig guys in... Germany last year. We had a conference. I want to say Stuttgart, but that's not where it is. In Frankfurt. So we were in Frankfurt next to the building of the European Central Bank. We had this Proof of Work Summit, and Phil Zimmermann was invited to attend, and this guy from Einundzwanzig went to Phil Zimmermann and told him, "Hey, are you on Nostr? It's this very cool social media decentralized application. You can get it on your phone, you can post." And then Phil Zimmermann started asking questions about, like, so how does it work? You know, there are relays and nodes and blah, blah. And at one point, Phil Zimmermann looked at him and asked, "So how do you stop Russian disinformation?
3:29:58If anyone can post and there's no way to censor. And there's no way to block someone from posting, and there's no way from preventing them to run their own relay, then how are you going to stop Russian disinformation?" And it was such a mind-blowing moment because... like 30 years ago, he had to deal with the same question. Like, how do you stop Russians from using PGP? From having private communications. And it sort of comes full circle. I don't know how I should interpret this, but it seems like even Nick Szabo, he went on stage like three or four years ago.
3:30:38And I watched that on livestream. He was saying that the future of Bitcoin is integration with PayPal and it's going to become part of the mainstream financial system and stuff like this. I was thinking, wasn't this guy a big fan of privacy? And now he's talking about... Basically integrating this revolutionary technology into something that is very much legacy and boring and trusted and censorship-friendly...
3:31:04Ben ArcI guess it's like, there's two, well, there's a couple of possible reasons, but I mean, accepting defeat is a big one. People get tired and they're just like, Oh, whatever, you know, and to his credit as well, like if you look at free and open source, the free and open source revolution, to begin with, the big proprietary companies, Microsofts and the IBMs and whatever else, they were rallying against free and open source. And eventually they had to integrate it and it just sort of, made its way into their projects, and they became free and open source contributors. And in that regard, he's probably not wrong.
3:31:35There's not going to be a bloody revolution where we all take out, you know, the banks are all destroyed by Bitcoin. The banks will probably start adopting it and the Trojan will be behind enemy lines. And this is not an attack vector, but this is... I mean, it is an attack vector, but this is a scenario in which we need to be careful because obviously there's lots of these powerful forces which want to kind of shape what Bitcoin is and is the community as a whole, which decides what Bitcoin is and will become in the future.
3:32:05So if there's enough people who want it to be X, then it will slowly become that thing. So we all need to be vigilant as individuals. But I mean, this is that Hegelian dialectic again in that the majority of users are. They just want to be freer and they can't be freer if this thing's controlled by the banks. So, you know, good luck to the banks trying to take control of it. And it's just becoming a mainstream thing. Either that or, you know, they've been turned and they're just trying to restrict. I'm not saying it's been turned, but they're just trying to restrict its growth.
3:32:39And they're on the payroll or something. But I mean, on the Nostr thing, like, you can't. Stop, it's permissionless. Anyone can go on there and say whatever they want and pretend that it's real. What you don't have is like you have, and I think we'll have more and more work done on this as well, is you have control over the algorithm.
3:32:59So if you're using Twitter, you don't know what Twitter are doing to push or Elon's doing to adjust, you know, political sentiments maybe he's got a little toggle switch somewhere and he's like okay more violence less violence and that tweaks the algorithm into any direction he wants to take it more support for Trump, push those posts, less support for Trump, whatever.
3:33:20Like, you don't know how he's twiddling the – the mechanisms which he uses for the algorithm inside Twitter. Whereas in Nostr, I think that stuff. It's like, it's just as Bitcoin made money into a clean word, because, you know, money's the root of all evil, Nostr can do the same things for things like algorithm. You know, algorithm, we think of it as this evil concept, you know, this evil thing. But actually, a good algorithm is important for you to... find access to content which you think is relevant to you. It only becomes evil when someone else controls it. And you have things like surveillance capitalism, which just tries to monetize you as a user. And then you have whoever owns the platform and they're pushing whatever political agenda as well. So that's what Nostr doesn't have. So it's like, yes. You can have, you know, Russian fake news on Nostr, but...
3:34:20If Elon Musk was a Russian asset, And if he had access to that little toggle switch, to push Russian propaganda, I don't know, I don't want to just say Russian, but you know, what to push the ideology of that platform in any direction he wants to, then he can, because it's a privately owned company, privately owned project. So he has control over where users are directed. In And it can never be like, so he's like, oh, this is now a free speech platform. It's like it can never be a free speech platform. Because we don't know what the algorithm is. So like for a while. I don't know if it's still doing this. And I said this to people and I sounded like some conspiracy theorist nutter or some, like, ego-driven conspiracy theorist nutter. Right. Honestly, every time that I posted the word Nostr. On any posts on Twitter, they just never got any likes.
3:35:10And I was like, this is, you know, I post a post. I mean, maybe not so much these days, but when I was more active and I was posting good shit, like videos or whatever or demos, and they're all cool things. I would tend to get 10, 20 likes pretty quickly. And then if they were good posts, they would go up. But if I ever posted the word Nostr, I would get like one like. And I'm thinking, well, this isn't because people hate Nostr. And it was it was there was clearly some shadow banning over that word.
3:35:40And he was very aware of Nostr, because obviously when Jack Dorsey put his Nostr npub in his Twitter profile, Twitter released that sort of not cease and desist. But it was that they would. Potentially ban any users who promoted other social networks. There was like a day or two where they pushed this thing, and then they got loads of pushback from the community, from people on Twitter about it, so they stopped. But you don't know what words they're shadow banning. They can just have a collection of words and then they shadow ban it so people don't see those posts and then they push other posts.
3:36:13You don't know what he's doing. So when it comes to disinformation from wherever, that happens through a centrally controlled platform. In Nostr, it isn't centrally controlled, and ultimately the users will have control of their own algorithms. So they can tweak those little toggles themselves to get access. Maybe they want more Russian disinformation and they'll tweak that little toggle themselves to only, you know, I only see posts which have the word "Putin" in or I don't know, whatever.
3:36:42But that's how it that's how it changes the flow of information quite significantly and is actually a tool of the free press, which we should have said to Phil Zimmermann, that it gives the control over the algorithm to the users as opposed to the corporation or company or government where that corporation is residing. So it could even be that Elon Musk hates Trump and he just saw Trump was going to become the – as a mind thought experiment, Elon Musk hates Trump and he just saw him as the person who's going to win and he wanted to cuddle up alongside him because he thought it would benefit him economically.
3:37:23And then for that reason, he pushed the Trump agenda on Twitter and then tweaked those little toggle switches to try and encourage people to vote for Trump because that's who he was backing. You just don't have that problem on Nostr. You've got to say something valuable. People are going to seek out your information because it's good information. And there's no one you can coerce. If you're a government, there's no one you can lean on to push. You'd have to, I mean, you can try and push this information, but you'd have to do it in a more time-consuming way. Rather than just trying to you know, co-opt the person who runs the platform.
3:38:09Vlad CosteaI have to say you're a very good CEO of Nostr.
3:38:13Ben ArcNostr's great, man. I mean, it's just, it's the, yeah, yeah. Why did I start calling myself? I'm not, yeah, I'm obviously not the Nostr CEO, by the way. Oh, that's because I had Nostr.com. That was it. And because, yeah, yeah, that's why I started calling myself CEO of Nostr.
3:38:27Vlad CosteaDo you still own that or did you sell it?
3:38:29Ben ArcYeah, man, I still own it. And, yeah. To be honest, at that time, I just wasn't... we were so busy in LNbits. And I was like, if someone Googles Nostr, they go to Nostr... currently they go to Nostr.com. And at the time, I was just like, it's such a piece of shit. Like, it needs to be better.
3:38:46So somebody... with resources should be making this thing a much better landing page for people and I still I mean I still think that's the case I still think it needs a lot of improvement and needs a lot more resources poured into it because if people and arguably it's been something to restrict the growth of Nostr which I feel terrible about but it's like it's time and resources I've only got so much time to work on stuff and we had a sprint over a week to make Nostr.com better and that's partly why we're doing some services and products through Nostr like the Nostr identities for gives us a good excuse to work on the Nostr.com webpage.
3:39:21So I was like, you know, if someone wants to buy this thing for a load of money, that'd be cool. And, but they didn't. So I was like, okay, no, okay. I'll put it under the ownership of LNbits, Inc. And LNbits, Inc. That can now use this to offer services, which are useful, like the selling Nostr identities, the auction and all that sort of stuff. And maybe some paid relays, like you could pay to spin up a relay, a Nostr relay. I think that'd be pretty cool. But yeah, the story behind Nostr.com is it was... we were in the Telegram group and I said, I saw that it was available and I said, dude, this, you know, this is, available, somebody should buy it. And then after a month or two, nobody bought the bloody thing. So I was like, okay, I'll buy it. And at that time, I mean, this was the most expensive domain I've ever bought. It was a $4,000 domain.
3:40:08So I bought and this is when there was about 15 people in the Telegram group or 30 people in the Telegram group or something so I bought Nostr.com that's how bullish I was on Nostr early on I also got Nostr.org. And then I let the renewal elapse for Nostr.org and a domain troll got it. And then I managed to get it back off them years later. And now there's a small group of people who have access to the repo to manage Nostr.org. But it's, yeah, it was... funny one, URLs, still quite centralized the internet, isn't it? In that if you own the name for the thing, the dot com name, then inevitably like Bitcoin.com, you're going to end up with a load of traffic going towards your site. But, you know, it's encouraging that Bitcoin.com has gone a bit more Bitcoin-y. And stop being as Bitcoin cashy because it got that Adam Smith invisible hand slap.
3:41:02To keep it in check. So. Same with Nostr.com, you know, it's like we're beholden to Nostr, so the Nostr ecosystem. So it helps a lot. So like with Nostr.com, for example, everything we do on there, you know, we consult fiatjaf, and actually we had a conversation more recently because he wants it to be, you know, a better user experience when they first land on Nostr.com, for, you know, to encourage people to use Nostr more. So we're having a bit of a redesign for that. Which you'll be doing soon. Okay.
3:41:34Vlad CosteaYeah, right now, Nostr.com is still pretty geeky, but I do like it. It explains everything in a way that... It's good for beginners. Yeah, it's dumbed down enough, but yeah.
3:41:48Ben ArcI mean, this is the point. So like, there's that Nostr.com, but really that thing needs, like, focus groups and stuff. It needs proper research on taking complete noobs, putting them in the room, showing them the site. Getting them to navigate through it. And seeing if it actually helps them get on to Nostr. And currently, I don't think it does. I mean, it's better than it was. And the reason it's better than it was is because my father-in-law. said, "Oh, I'm joining Bluesky because the Independent moved to Bluesky from Twitter." Because Twitter's evil. And I was like, well, that sucks.
3:42:16You should probably be on Nostr. And he said, oh, how do I get on Nostr? And I said, oh... It's easy. And then I tried to explain it to him and I couldn't explain it. It's too hard. It was like too hard to kind of explain in a way which he could easily understand, you know, just by pointing him at something and saying, go use this thing and you'll you'll get a Nostr really quickly. And then he showed me the onboarding for Bluesky and it's like traditional.
3:42:42Kind of Twitter experience and you go there, just make an account you're on. So it's like, okay, so you've got this self-sovereign platform where you take control over your data and your keys how do you communicate that in a way which is like easy for noobs and easy for new people to understand where it's not just going to scare them straight away and I still think there's a bunch of stuff we can do to make it more appealing when you first land on. And I wish I'd done it. I wish we that's that would be my regret, actually, when you asked before about regrets.
3:43:15Not, it wouldn't be LNbits stuff, because I think everything's been, gone pretty damn well for the LNbits stuff. But my big regret would be Nostr.com. Just, I don't know, like, I mean... it was just like time and resources really, but just somehow, getting the right people together to, I don't know, give it a real face as soon as the Jack Dorsey stuff happened to, or maybe even just pinning down Jack Dorsey at one of the, like Costa Rica and saying, help us with Nostr.com. Let's make that. Like, you know, a good onboard experience because when people Google this thing, that's where they're going to go. And currently it's just that technical, confusing and scary.
3:43:52Vlad CosteaHow's the growth on Nostr? I mean, do you have any access to statistics? How is the growth on Nostr? Do you have access to any numbers or statistics?
3:44:04Ben ArcThere are some, yeah, there's some statistics. It's free open source growth. So we had like we had a lot of people when the Jack Dorsey thing happened. We had a lot of people jump in. Particularly because he was like chucking out sats. He was doing these zapping people a million sats and giving out all this money to all these projects. He had all these people going... And then, so we had this sort of spiking growth of people. And then it sort of trailed off like this.
3:44:32But it's, you know, my friend... who was it, Dan Held, he's not my friend, but Dan Held made a post on Twitter about how's Nostr gone? And he had like a graph of the users, and it was like up, and then sort of a slow trickle down like this. And then my friend George, who's like an old proper OG Bitcoiner, he just posted up Bitcoin's growth when it came to users early on. It was exactly the same.
3:44:57It was like, oh, and then people, like we said before, you get those It's like a good free open source model is you get spiking, a bit of a spike in growth, then it dribbles out and then it starts ticking up again And it was identical. And then subsequently since then, I was like, I realized that Dan Held actually thought it was a shitcoin project and it had a token attached to it. And that's why he was shitting on it. And I was like, oh, okay. He didn't realize it wasn't a shitcoin project, which I thought was quite funny. But the, Yeah, so it's...
3:45:32It's like that. It's kind of hardcore people and building stuff. And we just need to make it more accessible, easier to access. And Nostr.com, being a bit more user-friendly is quite an important part of that when people Google it.
3:45:46Vlad CosteaI interviewed Martti Malmi, who was the first collaborator of Satoshi, and he's working on Iris, and he seemed so interested and so passionate about Nostr.
3:46:02Ben ArcYeah. Yeah, if Martti Malmi is working on something, then you know it's good. Yeah, Martti Malmi is a legit man. He's a good dude. Yeah, he bought that flat, didn't he? So whenever you feel bad about whatever Bitcoin you may have lost or spent, then... go research Martti Malmi.
3:46:20Vlad CosteaAt least it's not pizza, you know. Yeah, yeah, that's true. It's an apartment it's something you can actually use on the long term.
3:46:29Ben ArcYeah although he'd be a trillionaire now probably if he didn't, but there we are. No, that guy's great. And he's very measured. And he doesn't need to, you know, he works on anything he wants to work on. And very talented guy. I mean, Bitcoin was lucky to have him early on, actually. But he's now working on Iris and with Kieran from Snort, I guess, because they sort of merged, I think. And yeah, Iris for a long time was my go-to desktop. I've actually got a desktop client now, which I use, but for a long time was my go-to desktop client because it was kind of simple. And easy to use and it was like nice and straightforward yeah But, yeah. Yeah. I mean, yeah, how do we get more users on Nostr? What do we do? Vlad?
3:47:18Vlad CosteaI've seen all sorts of applications being built. I remember like a couple of years ago, there was something like a TikTok for Nostr. There was something like an Instagram that focuses on presenting your pictures posted on Nostr. There was something someone just told me that he would have preferred if I also live streamed this using zap.stream. I've tried that one. It's pretty cool. You pay by the minute to live stream, but it's costly and it doesn't guarantee any sort of. I wouldn't call it return of investment, but it's an expense.
3:47:52And it's not the most convenient way to or at least not the most popular platform. It doesn't get you too many views. And when you see the cost, of course, YouTube is expensive to run. But YouTube has figured out a way to monetize it with ads or whatever it is that they put in. They're a large corporation. These people running servers, I wish it was a more direct way to give them money for a subscription or something, as opposed to paying by the minute. But I did see that there were people, for example, playing Pokemon. on the Game Boy. And the only way to make a move in that game is to make a microtransaction.
3:48:35Ben ArcYeah, no, this is this is how you get adoption. Yeah.
3:48:38Vlad CosteaPeople could collaborate. Collaborate to make movements and beat the game. And I thought that was interesting.
3:48:47Ben ArcYeah, there's... Because the interoperable thing... So I was speaking to... this is Vitor, I was talking to him about this one. And the Rabble guy, too. Because I think... what did Rabble buy? It's like activism.com or something like that, or some sort of activist website. And he's currently sort of Nostrifying the website. So they've got like, you know, half a million active users. And he's Nostrifying it because then all the users, in the site, they then... can use all the clients to be able to communicate with each other. So it's like a benefit to the platform. Because they get kind of social media exposure by all those people who are on that platform, talking about that platform in the wider social community of something like Nostr. And then I was speaking to the Vitor guy about it as well in the... No, crikey, it wasn't him. It was someone else. I can't remember who it was. Anyway, the idea of...
3:49:42If you've got a, you know, like some of these, games, I don't know, like Candy Crush type games, which have got like a billion users or something, that it's fairly simple for them to... integrate, I need to work out who it was I was talking to about this. It's fairly easy for them to integrate Nostr and then add a social media layer to their game, which then benefits them because their users are then talking about that game within that social network. And then, of course, all that data is interoperable with all the other Nostr clients. So basically just giving them all Nostr accounts.
3:50:24I think it may have been Vitor I was talking to. Yeah. And so that process of Nostr-ifying games, Nostr-ifying communities online, that process then helps people build better tools for Nostr-ifying those platforms. So I think that's the way you bring users into into Nostr is really like it's mutually beneficial. Like, you Nostrify some platform, people speak about that platform on Nostr, and you add a very powerful social media layer to whatever platform or game or whatever you've built.
3:50:56And then it pulls in more users. And you talk, and then you're talking about half a million users. Sorry, 500 million, a billion users being pushed towards Nostr. And then particularly if they're on multiple platforms and they can use the same key, if they want to for those different platforms while being on Nostr, then that's pretty impressive stuff. But no, that's yeah that is the that is the way of getting more adoption.
3:51:21Vlad CosteaAt the same time, Ben, you can optimize for adoption. You can make all of these plans. But I do believe that every technology has its time. And there will be a moment when There will be, for some reason, a mass exodus out of Twitter. Because of shadow banning, because of... free speech infringement or whatever reason. And people will find Nostr because they need it, as opposed to just because they want to use something that's cool.
3:51:50Ben ArcYeah, totally.
3:51:51Vlad CosteaBecause you don't have the marketing budget of something like Instagram or whatever to remind people all the time that you exist to have celebrities to post on it. That would be cool, actually, to have some celebrities joining. But I think the adoption curve or at least the initial onboarding experience is maybe a bit more cumbersome than just using your phone, use your Apple ID, you sign up within like 10 seconds and that's it.
3:52:22Ben ArcYeah. The I suppose the... Because currently you've kind of got two platforms now you've got Bluesky for all the lefty liberal types, and then you've got Twitter for people who are kind of more on the right side of things but then with them being centralized platforms it's not wouldn't be long until maybe Twitter, the... Shareholders of Twitter, boot out Elon Musk, and then they decide they suddenly need to appeal to the lefties more, which then pisses off the you know the current user base. And similarly in Bluesky, you know, it's not quite decentralized, the moderation of it.
3:53:02Theoretically, you know, other people could use it, run these moderation nodes, but really it's just the Bluesky team running it. And if they suddenly start to, politically go more to the right than all the people who are currently on there and feel like it's a safe space because they're you know they're as lefties are embraced but then the right people are kind of kicked off then then they'll also move from that and then ultimately like you need like a apolitical commons something which nobody can control and it's only a matter of time until these centralized platforms trip up and then they lose users and it drives someone or drives people towards the apolitical solution.
3:53:50And it's so simple, Nostr, it's such a simple idea. Relays, WebSockets, public key crypto. And it may even be that, you know, Twitter, see the writing on the wall, and they just implement Nostr. Who knows? Could happen.
3:54:06Vlad CosteaIs your camera okay or did you turn it off on purpose?
3:54:10Ben ArcYeah, no, it died. It ran out of battery. It's pretty good usually, it's just kind of like, it's powered on and it stays on, but for some reason it's died. Occasionally it happens. It's been a long one.
3:54:20Vlad CosteaAre you using the Sony one?
3:54:23Ben ArcYeah, yeah. Yeah. I think it's I think it's sometime the... If I use like the extension cable with my wire, then I think it just can't draw enough power from the computer to keep itself... to sustain itself. So I think the battery just slowly leaks and eventually it just caps out and dies. I could go pop another battery in it, but I'm not sure I've got another battery for it. So I'm going on.
3:54:48Vlad CosteaIt's pretty cool actually, when you think about it. My camera, which I'm using right now, needs to be plugged all the time. If I leave it on battery, it dies in like 30 minutes.
3:54:58Ben ArcYeah. Yeah, no, it's, yeah, all that stuff's great. It's so much easier now to produce content, like get yourself access to a decent microphone and a camera and start making stuff. Which, again, is another big driver, isn't it, for these like permissionless environments where people can contribute content like video content or audio content or whatever. There's no barrier to entry. Anyone can just hop on there and start making I mean, it could be as well. I mean, I hope it's not a driver of adoption for something like Nostr, but as the world becomes...
3:55:33Yeah, definitely as the world becomes more politicized and more unstable, that people really question, what is what's the incentive behind the thing which is providing them content on whatever platform they're on and is it being driven by you know some political ideology or some sense of some sense. Some centralized control and I think that they'll start to realize that is the case with Bluesky and is the case with Twitter. I mean, Bluesky do a better job than Twitter but it's still quite centralized and it's pretty hard to not make it, not have it centralized as well.
3:56:11But also as well, like in Nostr, maybe it's not quite ready for the whole world anyway. Maybe it needs some... Yeah, I mean, like, we haven't even gotten around to making Nostr.com. Good enough yet and it's you know the development which has happened on it has been off the back of my father-in-law watching my father-in-law try to use it so maybe we're not quite ready anyway so it's okay we can bide our time let people use other platforms for a little while and then when they're ready we'll be ready Yeah.
3:56:42Vlad CosteaWhen you think about it's still very early. When was Nostr launched? Like three years ago? Maybe four. I remember being there. I'm still upset that I lost my OG account. I was like one of the first 20, 30 people creating an account. I was using Branle, B-R-A-N-L-E.
3:57:02Ben ArcYeah, so I made the first Twitter clone. And then... that then became Branle. The Branle, Branle, however you pronounce it, that name became, because I fell out with fiatjaf over it, because I reversed one of his commits and then he forked it. I made... Branle, which was great for a while, but very sadly. This was such a painful thing as well because it's such a great piece of software. But it was just a design decision.
3:57:34He had a local storage database system he used with it which just didn't scale and there's no way of knowing that and this is one of the hardest things which you have in software when you're developing software is you just pick like the wrong project to power your software. We did it in LNbits for a long time. So we were using Flask for our API, which is a Python... API framework. And then there was a fork of Flask called Quart and Quart did asynchronous so you could do asynchronous stuff in it. So we implemented that into LNbits. There was just basically no projects running it.
3:58:19At scale but when it ran at scale there was just some fundamental problems with that framework in that it would just trip over itself and it was kind of unfixable So we tried to stick with it for a long time, and then we made some upstream commits and things.
3:58:40FastAPI had kind of come into its own, and that was... working really well. So we then had to refactor everything to be on FastAPI as opposed to Quart. And it was just, it was like at that time, like we could have very easily, because at the time there was like Quart and FastAPI, but Quart was closer to Flask, which we'd already used. And so we picked Quart, but actually, you know, it was just a... No one could have known which of those... Frameworks would have worked better in the future. But we just picked the wrong one and then suffered for it later on.
3:59:11We had to do a massive code refactor. And it was similar with Branle. It just had those just fundamentally at its core. There was an issue with the database, the local database stuff it was using. But, yeah, that was the first – I made the first Twitter client myself. And then, which I don't think would even run now, but it was pretty cool. It kind of looked like Twitter, but the reason we fell out, me and fiatjaf, was I literally cloned Twitter. And if you look at Twitter, it's got, like, the way it's split, the screen split in thirds, there's very specific ratios. And I imagine all the focus groups they had of users to find those ratios.
3:59:48So I was like, well, I'll just use that work they did. And I'll just use that in the Twitter clone. And then fiatjaf went in like a bull. He just split it into third, third, third. So he just made it three thirds of the screen. And then because I was kind of a bit of a new developer, I suppose, I didn't realize how much of an insult it was. I just reverted his commit. And pushed it. To the repo and then he forked and he's like, he's all angry. It's funny. It's like never, never, just never revert someone's commit. But arguably I mean he did you know revert my commit initially. So there we are.
4:00:28Vlad CosteaAnd it's been... sorry for interrupting, but there's a Nostr.com section where you can buy your @nostr.com identity, which I guess is a domain for your account. You search for something, you see if it's available. You can get one for free, which has letters and numbers. But if you want like a vanity one... And it's available, it says you can pay $5 for it. My question is, do you have to renew this annually or is it permanent?
4:00:57Ben ArcYeah, it's annual for now. We were thinking about permanent. But it was kind of a case of we want everything to be sustainable before we offered that because ultimately, we don't want to like lie to users and say, you're going to have this thing forever. And then, you know, the company behind Nostr.com isn't forever. But it look more and more, it looks like it is forever. So, yeah, we do want to be able to provide people. I think the other thing is as well, like, we need a mechanism for people to buy and sell. their names.
4:01:32So I think the auction might push us towards it being forever. Currently it's annually, and actually, if you want a three-letter vanity Nostr identity, it's expensive. It's like $250 or something, which is amazing. I was amazed that people there's a bunch of people who bought them. People like those vanity addresses. And I suppose, you know, If you look at Fragment, which is where people buy and sell Telegram handles, some Telegram handles go for like $20,000 a piece. It's not something I would do, buy and sell a Telegram handle, but...
4:02:05Maybe there is some value. In people getting some of those Nostr identities and then being able to buy and sell them. We've got high hopes for the auction. I think it's going to be pretty interesting.
4:02:15Vlad CosteaIt seems like if I want to get V@nostr.com, it's $250. VL is $100, so for two letters, you pay half.
4:02:28Ben ArcIs Vlad... Vlad's taken, I imagine, 'cause we've got Vlad. Yeah, it's a shame, isn't it? What's the one you want then? What do you want?
4:02:36Vlad CosteaIt would be cool to get V, but at the same time, it's so meaningless. I would get something like Bitcoin Takeover. Because at least that one promotes a brand. You understand?
4:02:45Ben ArcYeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Well, what we'll do is we'll give you the bitcointakeover@nostr.com. And we have an affiliate system which Vlad Stan's built into it. So if we give you the bitcointakeover@nostr.com and then... we'll give you an affiliate link, which is literally people use bitcointakeover@nostr.com. And then you'll get 20%. So we'll give you a 20% affiliate link. How's that? And then if anyone goes to Nostr.com and buys, it's not going to be active now, obviously, but... by like in a couple of days time if anyone wants to go get a Nostr.com identity, they'll get 20% off. That's how it works. They'll get 20.
4:03:29No, they'll get. I guess they'll get like, need to figure this out. Let's say they get 25% off. Yeah. And then we'll give you 20%. How's that? They get 25... no. Is that how it works? And our works. Okay, if anyone uses it, they'll get 20... 20% off, and then you'll also get... there we are, you'll also get 20% of it, Vlad. Okay, so there's your affiliate link.
4:03:59Vlad CosteaWow. That's pretty cool.
4:04:01Ben ArcSo yeah, in a couple of days, try that. Go on there and if anyone wants to buy a Nostr.com name, they can and they'll get 20% off plus Vlad will also get 20% of the purchase price.
4:04:11Vlad CosteaSo it seems like right now on Nostr I'm @Vlad, but I'm not sure what sort of domain I have.
4:04:19Ben ArcI think that's because you're using Damus. So for other people, it will be like Vlad at Damus.
4:04:30Vlad CosteaInteresting.
4:04:32Ben ArcLet me have a look.
4:04:35Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if you can scan my QR from here.
4:04:38Ben ArcNo, I've got it here. Oh, it doesn't actually say anything. I think on Damus you've just got... It's just got your npub when I look at you. And then it's got your... Lightning address, which is a Wallet of Satoshi Lightning address. Yeah, yeah. What's cool about your Nostr.com identity though is you'll have bitcointakeover@nostr.com, which people can get a 20% discount on and Vlad will also get 20%. So it helps support his show as well but you can also use that as a Lightning address as well which is kind of nice.
4:05:17Vlad CosteaFancy. The way in which I back up my private key, so let me also show something, is that I got a Cryptosteel for it. They have these capsules, and you can put letters and numbers or any password, it doesn't have to be your seed phrase. So I put my Nostr nsec inside of those. And if you buy one using BTCTKVR, which is basically the abbreviation of Bitcoin Takeover, you can get 10% off.
4:05:49Ben ArcWhy don't you get BTCKVR for your Nostr.com one?
4:05:55Vlad CosteaI should, right?
4:05:56Ben ArcYeah, okay, so scrap that affiliate link. We're going to call it BTCKVR... TKVR. Sorry. Say it again.
4:06:05Vlad CosteaTakeover. BTCTKVR.
4:06:09Ben ArcBTCKV... Yeah, whatever you said. BTC...
4:06:12Vlad CosteaIt's Bitcoin Takeover, so.
4:06:14Ben ArcTakeover. Okay, yeah, yeah, I got it.
4:06:16Vlad CosteaI also own the domain, the.com one.
4:06:19Ben ArcAh, there we are. So there we are. If you use that. I tell you another nice feature as well, actually, is if you then... go to... Let me get up our share screen. Yeah, we're building some cool stuff into Nostr.com. It's nice. And it needs to exist. But if you go to Nostr.com, And then I think if you do at If I do @BenArc, No, that didn't work. There's a way in which you can maybe just Ben Arc. Ben Arc. Nope, that's not it. Good demo, is it?
4:06:55Okay, I think usually something is working, but you have like an njump page here, so it'll show your latest posts, and you can just share the URL. You can also put an event in there, and it'll show it as well as an njump, but I think our njump's broken. And then what we actually started doing as well is We've built in some caching stuff because one of the which I think will make it as an optional feature for Nostr.com users. So that because like one of...
4:07:31One of the things kind of annoying with Nostr is that if I make a post on Twitter, I can go on Google and I can type in roughly the content of that post and I can go find it. Because it's being cached. Whereas Nostr posts aren't cached. So I think what we're going to have is like a toggle maybe so in your, it's not there now, but maybe Nostr.com, you'll have a toggle, it'll be like cache my posts and then when you make a post on Nostr, it will kind of publish it on Nostr.com.
4:07:59Well, not publish it'll just have the post on Nostr.com, but it'll do in such a way that search engines can crawl it. And then... people can Google it because like, Yeah, I kind of feel that like that kind of holds back people finding Nostr as well. It'd be nice if someone searched for something and then I was like, oh, this is a post from Nostr about that thing. But if you're posting publicly anyway, it's like, you know. You clearly don't care about people.
4:08:24Accessing that content. So maybe it's a toggle. Maybe it should be a toggle in Nostr.com. But it'd be quite nice, I think, to have some caching. Yeah, so... BTCTKVR@nostr.com. Okay, and you'll see it when you buy a Nostr identity, you'll see the little referral link bit where you pop in the referral link. If you stick it in there, you'll get 20% off. How's that? There we go. Not that bad, man.
4:08:55Vlad CosteaYeah, not bad. Not bad.
4:08:57Ben ArcAnd then maybe later on you can sell it on the auction. And.
4:09:04Vlad CosteaThere's also Christian from Mallorca in the chat. He says he misses us. He says, Miss you guys.
4:09:11Ben ArcYeah, I miss him too. I miss Mallorca. I miss the Blockchain Days. That is, for people, you know, anyone watching, that is one of my favorite conferences of all time, is Mallorca Blockchain Days, because it's like a retreat and it's so intimate and like you just get such a high density of cool people there. You get your Amir Takis, you know, you're swimming in the sea with Amir Taki, that kind of stuff. And it's cool as well, like listening to Because I think Peter Todd and Amir Taki were there at the same time, weren't they, last time?
4:09:46And they were talking about back in the day when they were in that squat in London. Working on Bitcoin stuff. Back in whenever it was, 12, I guess. So you get some insights into some of Bitcoin's history. And we were saying as well that the some of the people you get there, I mean, you had Roger Ver turned up, didn't you, at the bar? Last year.
4:10:11Vlad CosteaYeah, yeah, but... not because he was happy to be there on vacation, just randomly.
4:10:16Ben ArcOh, right. Yeah, 'cause he's... yeah, he's stuck, he's in exile. Yeah, he's in exile. Yeah, shouldn't have left Japan. Did you know they have a no-extradition policy in Japan?
4:10:27Vlad CosteaI had no idea. But I think they negotiate this if you're super valuable to the U.S. Or whatever, they just... say, okay. You can have him.
4:10:35Ben ArcWell, there's the example of the cannibal guy, you know, the cannibal guy. There's this Japanese guy who's a student in Paris. And he met this girl, started falling for her, good friend, and they're hanging out all the time. Anyway, he really started to like this girl, so he ate her. And then he flew back to Japan before they could catch him. And because they have a no-extradition policy, he was completely free. And he became like this celebrity in Japan. The cannibal guy, and they would have him on, like, morning television. And they would just have a video of him eating stuff. Yeah. On television. But he was actually a legitimate cannibal. A free legitimate cannibal who'd eaten some poor French girl. So yeah, so they got a pretty strict non-extradition policy. I'm sure Roger would have been safe had he not left and gone to Europe.
4:11:26Vlad CosteaWhen you say eat, you mean ingest, right?
4:11:29Ben ArcYeah, like he ate her. Like he just ate her. All of her just ate her.
4:11:35Vlad CosteaIt's not a funny topic, but somehow it sounded funny. Yeah, he just ate her. Ate a French girl.
4:11:40Ben ArcYeah, and then get away with it. It's madness. There's a good documentary about that. But there's some good adoption, actually, of Bitcoin in Japan, while we're on Japan. I guess there's always been, isn't it? Because Mt. Gox was there. And yeah. But no, I was speaking to some Japanese business dudes a couple of weeks ago. And they're getting more and more adoption happening. It's pretty cool. I was told that Nostr adoption in Japan was high as well, but I went to the Nostr conference there and there were no Japanese people there. Well, there was a handful, but you know. Wasn't as high as I thought it was.
4:12:18Vlad CosteaI remember that event. I wanted to go, but Japan is so expensive and takes so long to fly. Yeah. And sometimes, you know, if you're doing business in Nostr and you're the CEO of Nostr.com, of course you have to go. But if you're just this guy who likes Nostr and wants to go to Japan, you have to really weigh in the cost and be like, probably better off going to Prague once again.
4:12:42Ben ArcI went I took my son because, you know, he's like a teenager and he's sort of interested in Japanese culture stuff. And as a matter I mean it's on the bucket list of everybody to go to Tokyo, isn't it? Of course. It's got some cool stuff there. Anyway, so I book because it's quite expensive Tokyo and I'm a bit you know I don't like spending too much money on accommodation. It's one of those sorts of cities where you can spend like a grand a night on a hotel or whatever.
4:13:05So anyway, so I find this relatively cheap hotel and I'm like, okay, this looks all right. It's kind of in central-ish Tokyo. So we'll book that. So I booked it. And we get there and it's this tiny little hotel room. And we're all jet-lagged. So I'm like, hey, do you want to go for like a little walk? Go see Tokyo at night. And my son's like, yeah, cool. Let's do that. So we go out of the hotel and then we're walking around. And all these women keep jumping out at us.
4:13:30And saying hello and then I realized the hotel was right in the middle of the red light district And I just got and booked a hotel in the middle of the red light district. And it was like, it was like the most embarrassing thing that I was like, Avert your eyes, son. Don't look. Get on the bus and go out of here.
4:13:50Vlad CosteaIt happened to me too in Frankfurt last year, but the red light district was not exactly What you're describing, it was more like junkies in the street.
4:13:59Ben ArcAnd it was Yeah, there it's funny because it's kind of like it seems to be quite accepted. So you have like a nice restaurant with families and stuff eating, and, you know, having dinner or whatever. And then next door, you'll have like a brothel. And then after that, you'll have like a newsagents and then, you know, something else than a brothel. So it seems to be kind of a more accepted way of life.
4:14:18But I kind of found it quite hard to be I like, I mean, obviously you like Japan because it's in Tokyo and stuff because visually it's on the bucket list and it's an incredible place. And we went to Kyoto as well and that was cool. But the rules, because it's such a rule-based system, I found that quite hard. And particularly kind of the politeness side of it. So you'd like go into a shop to buy some chewing gum and then the girl serving you would start bowing because you bought the chewing gum. And I'm like, I'm just like an asshole. You don't have to bow at me, you know? I don't like service people having to feel that they have to be nice.
4:14:52If I go to America, people are super nice because they want to get the tips or whatever. I don't like it. I want the kind of going back to France. I want that French experience though. I'm just like treated like an asshole because I am an asshole. And I found that quite hard and I was kind of happy to get out for that reason. It was just the just all the kind of the rigidness and the politeness of all. But yeah, cool place. And, Nostr Japan.
4:15:18It was good, but it was like... it wasn't because before we had the Costa Rica one, the Costa Rica, that was really good. Because I was in kind of like a yoga retreat. And there was just some great developers there. And it's very exciting when you know when you have like this new thing. We had it with Lightning as well. You get this like new protocol, infinite possibilities. Everyone's building great ideas. And you're meeting people for the first time. I think it's where I first met Martti Malmi. Ah yeah, I stayed in an Airbnb with Martti Malmi. That was it. And...
4:15:50Yeah, I just had a really cool, like really nice vibe to it. Which I didn't really... get so much in Japan, but there we are. I don't know if there's any Nostr conferences on the horizon.
4:16:01Vlad CosteaI was going to ask you which conferences will you be attending this year?
4:16:05Ben ArcI've cut way back because they're not very productive. I don't like... There's a... a Welsh word, hiraeth, which means it's like a longing, like a heartbreak, like a longing for something which you've sort of lost. And it's what we sort of use to describe how sad it is when you go away. I'm from Wales and I always get it. I'm like, I can do about two days of being away somewhere and enjoying it until I start to feel really sad. I just want to go home. So I'm not doing that many.
4:16:39I'll do some UK ones, but, and Blockchain Days, of course, in Mallorca, I've got to go to that one. Yeah, that's probably it, to be honest. I don't really want to do any traveling. It's not productive either. It takes weeks out of... If I look at my GitHub commits, you know, it's pretty busy. And then every time I go to a conference, there's like a month of like pretty weak contributions on GitHub. So I'm going to cut way back and just do maybe local ones. How about yourself?
4:17:12Vlad CosteaI don't know right now. Obviously, I'm going to the Mallorca one because Chris invited us and he's very nice. So look up Mallorca Blockchain Days. I think it's one of the most underrated events of the year.
4:17:24Ben ArcYeah, totally.
4:17:25Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if I'm... I might be going to the Warsaw Film Fest. It's a film festival with Bitcoin content. It's I don't know, there's a lot of hopium in that cinema. But if I manage to finish the manga with my girlfriend, we're doing a manga about the first year of Bitcoin. If we are able to finish that on time, then I think we should maximize the number of events that we attend so that we present this to as many people as possible and popularize the concept. Because it can be very educational and it can help people who otherwise don't care about Bitcoin learn something about Bitcoin, even if maybe they're not going to get it right away. So, I have high hopes about this. I don't know. So far, the only certainty is Mallorca.
4:18:20I might go to Warsaw. I might go to Prague, even though I'm sick of Prague already. I've been there so many times I could... maybe walk to Paralelní Polis with my eyes closed.
4:18:32Ben ArcYeah. Something of a Mecca though, Polis. Isn't that closing down soon, Polis?
4:18:37Vlad CosteaThat's what I heard. They closed it, and now it's called Second Culture. It's basically the same, but they're trying to move away from the crypto anarchy philosophy and make it more Web3, NFT-friendly, because that's where the money comes from. And now they also accept credit card payments. That's a major change for them.
4:18:58Ben ArcIt's always sad in Prague because Prague was one of those hot spots of activity and adoption. And people like, you know, like Slush. You mentioned Slush before. He's from Prague. And all these great companies and projects which came out of Prague early on in Bitcoin. You always tend to get good projects coming out of that and they had that very early on in Bitcoin and then also maybe the culture as well. They've got a good hacker culture, a bit like in Berlin or something in Germany. But then there seems to be all this infighting among them. And it was like... we're not big enough for you to have infighting. So it seemed like some people were against the polis and some people were for it. And there just seemed to be a lot of kind of infighting, which was a real shame because, like, yeah, we're not big enough to have infighting, I don't think.
4:19:49And also, particularly when it comes to, you know, the sort of hacker scene, we need the hacker scene to be strong and united. But ultimately, I suppose. Paralelní Polis is like in quite a gentrified area now and the rent's probably pretty high on the building and they need to make it sort of profitable. So I can see why they've had to do that rather than close it. But It's a shame. It's a bit like... you know, Room 77 going away. Remember when Room 77 closed? That was sad.
4:20:20Vlad CosteaYeah, but that one had more to do with the owner getting sick of running Room 77 as opposed to not being profitable. I think he was still having daily customers And the business was not so bad. Maybe he closed it during the pandemic when...
4:20:36Ben ArcIt seemed absurd. Yeah, but it wasn't because, you know, for other reasons, people closed in the pandemic. It really was. I mean, he's done his thing. He'd made his contribution. He kept that thing going for many years. And it was the first bar to accept Bitcoin. And where the first Bitcoin wallet was created, wasn't it? In Room 77.
4:21:00Vlad CosteaActually, and this is information from the manga that I'm working on, I found this guy, his name is doublec, from Bitcointalk. And he was able in 2009, I think it was in December, to create the first mobile wallet for Bitcoin that was running bitcoind. And it was being operated on a Nokia N900. So that's actually the first ever mobile wallet. The one that you're describing is by Schildbach or whatever his name is. Andreas, I think. And that one was built using Electrum tech SPV. This one built on the Nokia was actually a proper full node phone. And it was running the client that was ported for that operating system. I think it was running Linux anyway. So someone just figured out how to do this and sent the first Bitcoin transaction to someone else on Bitcointalk. I think it was like 0.42 BTC to the other person. And this was December of 2009, very early days. And most people don't know about this.
4:22:09Ben ArcCrazy talent. That must have been so fucking hard to get Bitcoin running on a Nokia phone in 2009.
4:22:16Vlad CosteaOh, to their credit, it was N900. So it was a very high end phone, which was designed for this sort of applications. Yeah, it was. Think about 2009, back in the day... Android and iOS were very much at the beginning. Nokia had most of the market share. BlackBerry was still a big thing in business.
4:22:42Ben ArcYeah. Yeah. People don't realize the amount of, honestly, when they're using Bitcoin or when they're criticizing the Bitcoin toolset, they don't realize the blood, sweat and tears which goes into making these things. developers staring for hours until their eyeballs are bleeding trying to get something to work and they finally get it to work. And I can only imagine how, I know it was a higher end phone, but still I can only imagine how hard it was to get that to work. It's kind of ruined the story for me, though. They developed the first phone... Wallet in room 77 because they were fed up of taking their laptops to the bar to pay for their beers So they developed the phone... Andreas developed the first phone wallet. It's ruined that story, so thank you, Vlad. But it's also worth acknowledging.
4:23:27Vlad CosteaThat's also where they had to develop QR codes for addresses. Mm-hmm. Because they had to type... the addresses before that.
4:23:37Ben ArcInsane enough it is. They're proper enthusiasts. Yeah. Yeah. Anyone who's kind of involved in Bitcoin before it was this crazy profitable thing to be involved in you just gotta have respect for him. And this is partly why I got a bit of respect for, you know, Roger Ver, because he was in Bitcoin before it was this super... this guaranteed kind of profit-making Ponzi scheme. He was like he was balls deep in Bitcoin and dedicating his life to it.
4:24:11Vlad CosteaBut I think it has a lot to do with your background because he came from this libertarian background. To him, discovering Bitcoin made a lot of sense, just like it made a lot of sense to someone like Ross Ulbricht to use Bitcoin for the marketplace. It's maybe something that these guys have been looking for a long time. And they just found the right tool for the job. And that's why some of them, like Eric Voorhees or whatever, they can't be Bitcoin only because to them, every piece of technology is a means to an end. They're not emotionally attached to the technology.
4:24:48Ben ArcYeah, yeah, they didn't get involved when there was a sort of pre-baked ideology or whatever. They were just using what was useful at the time. I think Martti Malmi's story was similar, wasn't it? He actually had a use case for it. And that's why he started working on it. But yeah, I guess there's a lot of people who just wanted like internet native money. And that's why they started working on Bitcoin, obviously, early on to begin with.
4:25:16But it is kind of a shame that like, I know a lot of developers in Bitcoin who feel A bit disenfranchised at the moment. because of the Saylor stuff, you know, the Saylor ideology. And then all... the users as well, who are kind of on board with it as well, just the you know store of value use case they're less they care less about the free open source internet money. So, I spoke to a few great developers in Bitcoin. I won't mention them, but you just feel a bit like, really? There's this new billionaire who's going to tell us what Bitcoin is? Great.
4:25:54Vlad CosteaMan, I'm looking at the Nokia N900. It was running on this. Processor that could go up to 1.2 gigahertz if you overclock it. Well, 600 by default, so 600 megahertz, 32 gigabytes of internal memory. Which was a lot. I remember when iPhones had 8 and you had to delete pictures to take a new one. 256 MB of RAM, 5 megapixel camera with double flash, Wi-Fi, GPS, Bluetooth. Basically all the features of a modern phone. But it was before the touch screens.
4:26:41Ben ArcYeah. Crazy. I think I remember that phone.
4:26:45Vlad CosteaIt had sort of a... what do you call this? Like a keyboard that pops. Yeah, I'm pretty sure I remember it. Sliderphone.
4:26:54Ben ArcBecause I remember I got a phone on contract at that time and I had the it was that or the LG Prada.
4:27:00Vlad CosteaOh, fancy. You had the LG Prada.
4:27:03Ben ArcI went for the LG. Do you know why I went for the LG Prada? No. Because it was the first touchscreen phone. Without buttons, iPhone ripped it off. Apple ripped it off. Everyone credits iPhone for like coming up with the touchscreen phone, but they didn't. It was the LG Prada, which looks very iPhone-y, by the way. And it used to blow people's brains out when I was like, I get my phone out and they'd be like, what's that? And I'd be like, it's a phone. I'd be like, but where are the buttons? It's got no buttons. It's just a touchscreen. First capacitive touchscreen phone.
4:27:33It's sick. And then Apple. In the usual Apple way, this is, they did it with the mouse as well. And then also, what else was the other thing? The iPod. They would just see another technology out there and then create a slick. Version of it. And then somehow people credit them.
4:27:48With creating the thing when it's not somebody else who created it and they just kind of I suppose they marketed it for mass market Yeah, but the LG Prada... but I almost bought that one you're talking about, but I remember it had too many bells and whistles and it felt like it would break easily so I didn't go for it But I should have because then I could have maybe found Bitcoin a little bit earlier and put a Bitcoin node on it.
4:28:13Vlad CosteaYeah, you could be like, so what can I do with this? It's overkill. It's more than I actually need. And I know some nerds on Bitcointalk.
4:28:20Ben ArcYeah. I'd Google it, what can I do with this Nokia and it'd be like, oh, you can put a Bitcoin node on it. There we are. But yeah, Room 77... what came out of Room 77? So, Ethereum, that was Vitalik going to the... He made it in Room 77, didn't he? I think he started making it in Room 77. That's where he was hanging out when he was building Ethereum. Jeremias first started talking about LocalBitcoins in Room 77 at the meetup. There's a whole bunch of cool shit which came out of Room 77, just a little dirty rock and roll bar in Berlin. So the meatspaces are important. You get less meetups now, don't you? Bitcoin meetups, I think, I feel, than you used to. That used to be a big part of the Bitcoin ecosystem was the local meetup. I haven't been to a Bitcoin meetup in ages. I know one in Cardiff has sort of slowed down.
4:29:12Vlad CosteaI can think of some attempts locally to do meetups. It's just that I guess people are lazy and they don't want to. There's also this concern by OGs. They don't want to show up in some place where people can follow them home afterwards. Yeah. And... I guess we also deal with this uniformization of Bitcoin culture where... you get high priests like Saifedean or Michael Saylor or whatever, and they tell you exactly what you should think. You buy the book, you read Hope.com, which right now is a Bitcoin website, and you're supposed to be in tune and up to date with whatever everyone else thinks about Bitcoin. So there's less interaction. Plus, you have a lot of podcasts. Yeah. So if you just want to learn while driving or washing dishes or whatever, you just start one of these recordings, you're going to get some new information.
4:30:12Ben ArcGod, that's true, isn't it? I suppose at that time. there wasn't all this content, you know, out there for Bitcoin, so I suppose people felt the urge to seek out other Bitcoiners, whereas now they can find them online easier. I didn't know about this Hope.com thing.
4:30:26Vlad CosteaPlus, you have the conferences, right? That's where you meet people.
4:30:30Ben ArcHope.com is like Michael Saylor... Does he own it or something? It's like MichaelSaylor.com. Oh, it's got his face all over it. Yeah. I don't know what we're going to do about these billionaires.
4:30:46Vlad CosteaWell, I'm not concerned about their wealth. I'm just concerned about the fact that Saylor stepped in five years ago. And he took control of the narrative of what Bitcoin is a year later. So he has only been. Around for one year and he was establishing the North American Bitcoin Mining Council and he was on calls with Elon Musk trying to get him to accept Bitcoin on Tesla. saying, "Oh, so how can we please Elon Musk? Please tell us. Let's do this. Let's talk to all the miners in the U.S. Let's be carbon negative," or whatever. How do you go from just being this guy who tweets in 2013 that Bitcoin is going to die out just like online gambling, which by the way, never happened in both examples.
4:31:36Ben ArcIs that what Mike Saylor did early on?
4:31:39Vlad CosteaYeah. There's this 2013 tweet from him and people circulate it. And he's also famous for appearing on the page of a financial newspaper from... the US in 2001 or something he became the CEO who lost the most money in one day with his company.
4:31:59Ben ArcWow.
4:32:01Vlad CosteaSo I honestly hope that MicroStrategy never implodes, but And the way that it's managed, they just borrow more money. They buy more Bitcoin.
4:32:12Ben ArcI mean, it's a glitch in the system, but what it does do is you have loads of Bitcoiners who had equity or whatever on Vanguard or some provider. And then they weren't or they weren't able to, or maybe in their pension funds, and then they wanted some access to Bitcoin in a pension fund, or they wanted to switch their equity from one company to another. And then they ended up just buying MicroStrategy, and then they made a lot of money on it. So it's kind of hard for them to be critical on MicroStrategy because they've you know, they filled their bags up.
4:32:48And I know some pretty... Influential Bitcoiners who kind of had that experience that they did quite well with the MicroStrategy stock. And now they're just buying and selling MicroStrategy options. And it's. I know a couple of them who you know, they're completely aware of Saylor's... I don't know, of the sort of person he is, but then I know others who kind of buy into it, maybe a little bit too much. But no, it's, yeah. Yeah. Any billionaire tells you anything, you should probably be questioning their incentives, particularly at some point if they lost all their money and then suddenly magically got it all back.
4:33:32Vlad CosteaI don't know. What's weird to me is that he came up with these analogies and terms. That were not part of the popular discourse in Bitcoin. And he... took this mission very seriously to educate all the newcomers. He bought domains. He got on every podcast he possibly could. He came up with these crazy, bullish narratives. It's going up forever, Laura.
4:33:59Ben ArcHe didn't come up with those, though. I mean, so a lot of those talking points he has, they're just like a boiled down version of the talking points, which, you know, a lot of people had over the years. But he just kind of summarizes them quite eloquently on these talking heads, news pieces he does.
4:34:19Vlad CosteaWell, I don't think anyone spoke about digital energy before. Like, hey, Bitcoin is digital energy, whatever that means. Bitcoin is a battery for electricity. That's stupid.
4:34:30Ben ArcYeah yeah yeah but the Yeah, it's a funny one. It's funny because it has impacted the culture of Bitcoin, all that stuff.
4:34:41Vlad CosteaAnd then he refers to Bitcoiners as the hive mind.
4:34:45Ben ArcI think that was done before. I swear I've heard all these talking points before, way long ago. And he's just picking up on them all, repeating them, regurgitating them, saying, Yeah. But there we are. Each to their own. He found a glitch in the system and he's exploiting it. which is, you can't really have the fiat currencies and debt exist in the same chamber as Bitcoin. And he's made a lot of money. Well, I say he's made a lot of money, but, oh no, that was fake news, wasn't it? Someone posted a... post about him having to sell some Bitcoin because they're over leveraged.
4:35:23But I think it was a bit of fake news right there. But it's like we always have to just rally against any form of centralization, don't we? And I think you get some people who really do want to kind of steer a narrative and, seize control and power over Bitcoin and I don't know, have like power just within the network. And then you should treat them like, suspiciously. And take everything they say with a grain of salt.
4:35:53Vlad CosteaIt's not resistance money if we don't resist. Whatever is the popular narrative.
4:35:59Ben ArcYeah. Yeah.
4:36:01Vlad CosteaAnd it's so easy to just rage quit and say, OK, I'm out.
4:36:05Ben ArcOh, yeah, totally. Yeah, we lost some good Bitcoiners to that. Particularly as well, I think that I know quite a few Bitcoiners where they may have had quite large stacks. And then they, you know, they spent it, helping grow the network. And then, but I suppose it's like, you know, It's the recourse of your own decisions and your own behavior or whatever. But for them to have someone tell them what Bitcoin is, I think, can be quite frustrating when they were there early on burning through their stacks to, you know, someone like a Martti Malmi, like, you know, breaking new ground, buying a flat.
4:36:40Showing that this thing can be used as actual money. That's the sort of sacrifice he made to get us to where we are now. And there was a bunch of folks who did that. And I think that can be very hard for people, though, psychologically. Knowing the amount of value which they separated themselves with. But I mean, you can only make decisions based on the information you have at hand at that particular point in time. A good while... It's only, you know, I can't remember what it was, I suppose maybe four or five years ago, that people used to always say, oh, you know, yeah, buy some Bitcoin.
4:37:17But it may... Implode in on itself and go to zero there was always this caveat and then somewhere along the line people stopped dropping in the caveat because I guess the thing became stable enough not to have it So for those, you know, people who did spend their stack early on. It was based on there was always this idea in the back of their minds that this thing could implode in on itself. And it's done pretty well, you know, and I can see I can see why that coupled with. Then kind of a shift in ideology can frustrate people into leaving. But yeah, Saifedean guy... Did you ever read... did you ever speak to Dominic Frisby? You ever had him on the show?
4:38:04Vlad CosteaNo, I haven't. I wanted to interview him when he was supposed to come to Mallorca one time and he was listed as a speaker and he didn't show up. This was like two years ago. He's very interesting, but I think he did so many interviews that it's hard for me to come up with anything. New, you know?
4:38:25Ben ArcYeah. He's kind of out of touch as well. I mean, he knows a bit about Bitcoin, but I think he's kind of out of touch of modern technology. Bitcoin, I suppose. But he wrote a really good book. It was Bitcoin: The Future of Money. And if you read that and then read The Bitcoin Standard, you realize how much of The Bitcoin Standard is just plagiarized. And then the bits which aren't plagiarized from Bitcoin: The Future of Money are like the crazy, superfluous... like, not superfluous, the weird assertions and crazy ideas which are actually unsafe. But the good stuff, a lot of it's taken from Bitcoin: The Future of Money. I tell you what was cool about Dominic Frisby is I said that to him. Me and a couple of people who've read his book, we were like... we saw him in Romania, when we were in Cluj. I remember that, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
4:39:12Yeah, yeah, we said, we said, oh, you know, this guy's like plagiarized most of your book and is now making a killing selling it to Bitcoin as this great thought leader. And Dominic Frisby's reaction was, "Huh, whatever, cool." He wasn't even arsed. This guy had like ripped off all his ideas, which I thought was pretty, pretty impressive. To not be a... Annoyed by it.
4:39:35Vlad CosteaWell, I think you win in the moment when someone picks up your ideas and takes them further than you could possibly ever could.
4:39:46Ben ArcYou'd say he didn't do that, but there we are.
4:39:48Vlad CosteaWell, he did. He has his own podcast. He tells people every week to buy his book. He elevated... the knowledge within the book to Bible status, you know.
4:40:01Ben ArcYeah.
4:40:02Vlad CosteaIf you own The Bitcoin Standard, that's how you prove that you're a Bitcoiner. You put it in the shelf. On the shelf behind you as a background and that's how you signal to the others that you're well read. You quote it, you complain about everything around you being fiat, and that's how you signal that, oh, you must have read The Fiat Standard, which is the follow-up to The Bitcoin Standard. And you know what's coming after The Fiat Standard? It's The Gold Standard, which is a work of fiction in which he's describing a world where the gold standard never went away.
4:40:39And with the benefits, of modern technology that we have had since 1971, all the prices are actually going down. And I listened to his presentation. I was in Slovenia at a conference organized by NiceHash. I think this was in November. And I raised my hand and I said, how are you going to have the same amount of innovation in housing, for example, if you don't have a fiat standard to incentivize investors to put their money into something as opposed to hoarding them?
4:41:10Ben ArcIt breaks the model, doesn't it?
4:41:11Vlad CosteaIt does, because most of the technological innovation that we had is owed to the fact that money is losing value. The people who are rich need to move it around, need to invest it somehow.
4:41:26Ben ArcYeah. Yeah, it's always one of the... the worries about something like a Bitcoin standard is that how do you actually have investment? And why would banks ever loan any money if they just have this thing which always goes up in value? And actually, I mean, it's something which we're kind of experiencing with the Saylor ideology in Bitcoin. I mean, obviously, like I said before, we're doing a raise. And the money-raising environment for Bitcoin now is so much harder than it was before. Because the... people are kind of just doing that thing with the Saylor...
4:41:58They just want to keep the coins and have that go up in value and then not actually produce value with the money. And this is why I say that, you know, soft currency, because, you know, it always kind of frustrates me when people are like, well, soft currency, evil, hard currency. Great. And you're like, well, really, they're just technologies. And soft currency has these technologies, which is sometimes pretty useful.
4:42:21You know, when you And you can argue against this, but like with the Great Depression, for example, the way in which we were able to wiggle out of the Great Depression was creating fiscal stimulus and the New Deal and, like, you know flipping the money printer switch on, and the sort of Keynesian economics of post-war... Keynesian economics of buffering out up and down cycles in markets. The whole idea was to create more stability. And then people will argue, well, no, because with a gold standard or a Bitcoin standard, then companies will be resilient, so they'll have reserves.
4:42:59So if there is ever a crisis of any sorts, that they'll be able to weather the storm. But that's just not how private money, that's just not how like profit making works. Like you take the profits you can at the time in which you're running. And there's, you know, like look at the 2008 crisis. There's a whole bunch of really successful great companies which been around for 20 30 years. And then you know those six months a year which they needed to weather in order to continue to be successful for decades later. When destroy businesses and capital.
4:43:38Yeah, some stronger businesses are going to survive, but you're going to lose a lot of great businesses which could just be helped. And anyway, that was the idea of the sort of Keynesian economic model. And I still think there's... It's just, it needs to be that, obviously, the people who control the money printer aren't corrupt, and they don't just enrich themselves. So this is why it should be a federation or something else. It should be really hard to kind of like turn on that money printer and only be in a...
4:44:08But the reality is with the gold standard, it's like if you've got a Great Depression event where, you know, your children are starving and you've got 50% unemployment and the economy is tanking and you're probably going to have another war. Like. The... people will rise up. Even if it was a people's revolution to create a Bitcoin standard, the people would turn around and say no. The governments would say, "No, you need to turn on the money printing. You need to do something to get us out of this horrible situation in which we're in." And I think that you... I just feel, I can't see that you're going to get out of that just by Austrian economics or whatever.
4:44:47I think there's always going to be room for some capital creation to create fiscal stimulus. And then also, like you say, like you need to be able to you need... to be able to... to encourage technologies to develop by having money accessible by people, by being loaned by banks who are then going to get interest on the loan, as opposed to just sitting and hoarding the underlying asset. But yeah, if you look at the past century, arguably a lot of the advancement was through there being cheaper money.
4:45:22But then on the other side of that, on the flip side of that, I suppose it doesn't incentivize A lot of... I don't know if it does. Because sometimes I mean like the money creation issue gets blamed for... the modern form of like consumerism and capitalism, whereas the reality is like, you know, something's like a planned obsolescence and having things break.
4:45:47That was always... something which came out of the private sector as a way to get you to buy more stuff, 'cause if they sell you something which is going to last, then you're not going to buy their latest iPhone, you know, so they've got to get the iPhones to tank after X amount of years.
4:46:09You're not going to, yeah, so there's mechanisms within profit seeking, private seeking of profits, which... I don't think can be necessarily blamed on how the money is created. But that's... Yeah, but you've got to have the companies who push the technology. So most technology is advanced in a laboratory or a university somewhere, then gifted to the private sector. And then the private sector, I mean, if you look at every part of the iPhone which exists inside an iPhone at its root that stuff was probably developed somewhere in academia and then they put they have a bunch of engineers who work on it and then patent a bunch of things to then end up producing this iPhone. But, where were we? What was the question? What was the thing you said again?
4:47:12Vlad CosteaWell, there are two parts of his comment. First, he says, "You are wrong. Ending the war and retooling our wartime economy towards productive ends got us out of the depression. The growth was stimulated by technology advancement in spite of the money printing." Yeah.
4:47:32Ben ArcBut I mean, you're not going to have... companies producing things and get companies having investment unless banks are going to lend the money to invest. We're going to loan the money to actually build the things and create the advancement so you need the capital there. It's much slower, like development of technology is much slower if you don't have soft currency. I mean, which might be fine. Maybe that's a better thing. And maybe the way I mean, clearly, humanity is having a pretty detrimental impact on the planet. And maybe a big part of that is access to cheap money. And maybe that's an issue. But, Yeah.
4:48:15Vlad CosteaBen, are you aware that we've been going for almost five hours?
4:48:19Ben ArcYeah, I'm starting to be aware. Yeah, I'm starting to flag a little bit. The brain's not working. When you start talking... when you start shilling Keynes, you know you've gone too far in your Bitcoin podcast. Keynes. Keynesian economics.
4:48:33Vlad CosteaYeah. Oh, okay. I was thinking of sugar canes, you know.
4:48:37Ben ArcYeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I got a bit of a soft spot for Keynes. He gets too much flack. I like in the Saifedean book, he's like, Saifedean called him a pedo.
4:48:45Vlad CosteaThere's no evidence to call him a pedo. That's horrible, you know, because he could have gone into dialectics or tried to debate his ideas, you know, tried to explain why he believes that he's wrong. But instead of doing that, he just slandered him. He said, oh, did you know that he was a sexual... how does he describe him? Libertine, I think that's the word. And that he used to like very young girls.
4:49:12Ben ArcNo, it was boys, wasn't it? He said that he was a pedo and he's got evidence that he was a pedo and all this stuff. Whereas he wasn't. He was part of the Bloomsbury Set, like, art group in London, which was, they were all kind of arty farty types and they're all banging each other. And he was a homosexual for a long time. And then the other thing which Saifedean said as well was that he never married, so he wouldn't understand traditional family values, which is a very kind of right-wing comment on its own. But he did marry later on in life. Married a ballerina.
4:49:41So that was the sort of assertions in that book, which I got to. And I was like, where's he going with this? It was after all the Bitcoin: The Future of Money plagiarisms, which was, you know, it was all right. And then it got to that bit about Keynes. And I thought, this doesn't sound right. And like you say, went all ad hominem, as opposed to actually... debating Keynes' ideas and seeing value as well.
4:50:03Keynes came up with the bancor. The idea of... which is what he took to Bretton Woods. So when you had the Bretton Woods agreement, how the future economy was going to be shaped and the US dollar was going to be the world reserve currency. Keynes on the other side of the table was arguing for an apolitical, world reserve currency because if you have... we had it with the Brits, if you have a country which controls the world reserve currency then there's this horrible incentive for that country to dominate all these other countries. So he's like, no, for more stability. So we don't have another war.
4:50:37Because we've had two of them. We want this apolitical, world reserve currency, which would be a basket of assets which countries could trade between each other in a sort of federation. Obviously, the technology wasn't really there at the time, but I always think that as much as Bitcoiners hate the man, I would be like, he's probably be a Bitcoiner. Like he's, He loved the idea of apolitical money. He thought it was great.
4:51:02And actually died. That's when he died of a heart attack, meeting Harry Dexter White to try and push for an apolitical medium of exchange. But then obviously the Americans at that time were like, "No, you Europeans have pulled us through two world wars, so we're not going to believe anything you say. You can just use the dollar and shut up." And like 50% of the world's currency was dollar anyway. But, yeah, we're getting to those times again, aren't we, where... the power bases are all shifting around the world.
4:51:35Vlad CosteaI think we're living in times of renegotiation, where the world powers are trying to establish where they're at. What their roles are going to be moving forward. I think China is going to have a lot to benefit from this. I'm not super happy. I don't want to start learning Chinese. But... They've done a pretty good job. And even in the case of Bitcoin mining, It's much harder to pinpoint two moments when they were horrible to Bitcoin miners, because once most of the mining started happening in the US, they came with regulations and everyone wanted to get a slice of the pie.
4:52:16And they wanted to add censorship and OFAC lists and whatever. China, I think they were just announcing, okay, we're going to ban mining. And then they're running their machines again. In some village where no party official is coming. And it was until 2021 that it went like this. And afterwards... I think it became more decentralized on one hand, but we also got behemoths like Foundry. And Foundry is owned... So basically all the miners that are hashing with Foundry are owned by the same company. It's not a proper mining pool where people put together their hash rate. It's just one company, one entity.
4:52:59Ben ArcThey mine a lot of blocks too. Yeah. Yeah, when you watch the mempool. No, it's kind of one of my fears. Of China is obviously they have a managed economy and it's been very successful because it's a managed economy. And it's kind of one of my fears that Perhaps. I mean, particularly because my viewpoint would be that markets are inherently unstable and that you have periods of overproduction. which then result in crisis and potentially things like depressions. And we have somewhat of a managed economy in that Central banks can fiddle interest rates to encourage or stop money lending.
4:53:40And then they can do stuff like quantitative easing and fiscal stimulus in times of crisis. But the Chinese, they have like a full managed economy. And it's kind of one of my worries that that's the more stable form of... of markets, is them... is there being that sort of centralized management of it and that other countries see that and see the success of China and they want to kind of emulate it and then we end up with less free markets.
4:54:15And then just generally more control, I guess. But it's the... It's food for thought that if Bretton Woods... another Bretton Woods scenario was to happen again, Where there was, you know, like you said, there's an adjustment or change that now Bitcoin exists that someone like Keynes, he perhaps wouldn't have suggested the Bancor. He would say, well, we should still use Bitcoin because... If you want peace and apolitical money, and that's a good step towards peace is having apolitical exchange, then perhaps we should be exchanging in this thing which is apolitical inherently and already exists and works as well.
4:54:55The bancor was just a theoretical concept at the time, but it's kind of an idea that probably, I think that's where humanity will end up heading is that, Yeah, that will become the apolitical backbone of the world's economy, Bitcoin. And that's what everyone will trade in, because it makes sense to have a world reserve currency based on Bitcoin, as opposed to the dollar or the British pound. And the Brits were far worse than the US ever were when it came to them having the world reserve...
4:55:31Vlad CosteaThat would be nice, but I don't see... these people using BTC. Maybe that they would use Bitcoin the network and just issue their own token and establish that. That one's going to be used and you can trade it. For BTC.
4:55:47Ben ArcWell, it's a bit like BRICS. It's a bit like the BRICS thing. It's only a matter of time because they're like, "Okay, we want to make some non-US currency thing we're all going to trade in." And then, you know, they'll task their technology teams to be able to build that thing. And then we shouldn't underestimate the problems which Bitcoin solves and how hard they are to solve those problems and how much work has gone into solving those problems. Because these technology teams, which are tasked with building these things like CBDCs or whatever else, they'll look at Bitcoin and the Bitcoin stack, and they'll be like, well, look, there's this thing which exists and it works so why don't we just use that because the thing we build it could break and that would be bad if it breaks so Yeah, I think it's only a matter of time until BRICS or whatever else they just start using Bitcoin.
4:56:37Particularly those interests which just don't they just don't want to use the USD anymore. You know, if China, you know, they okay, we want to use the yen and Russia want to use There's an incentive for these countries, instead of using someone else's currency to use something which is apolitical. All they want really is weakening of USD.
4:57:00Vlad CosteaI'm also concerned that the European Union is going to have its own CBDC this year. And they're already talking about, oh, this amount of money is being held in private accounts and we're trying to phase that out to make it unusable because we're going to switch to a different kind of money. Which is traceable for us, which only has privacy for small amounts.
4:57:24Ben ArcIt's kind of Gresham's Law, isn't it? That like, yes, there's going to be a whole bunch of countries which do that and it will suck. But the good money will be used, you know. So the money which is private, the money which doesn't require trusted third parties, or censorship resistant, that's the money which everybody's going to end up using eventually. So even if you just have, like, all these countries competing with their own CBDCs, and this is the John Nash Ideal Money thing, it's... those monies competing, you will end up with a good money by that competition which happens.
4:57:59Which is why I would have loved it if like El Salvador did the El Salvador dollar built on Bitcoin a stable medium of exchange pegged to a couple of currencies and maybe some products produced as well from their country, 'cause if a smaller country does do that and they do it in such a way that it's like total like corruption resistant, then other people will start using that money because it's stable. And that'll be a huge...
4:58:27Driver and it'll be good for that whichever country builds it. I kind of want to see that built from one of the poorer, more plucky countries as opposed to the European Union or the US or China or Russia or whatever else. One of these little countries needs to build a stablecoin on the Bitcoin stack, and then the markets will end up using it. And it'll be good for that little plucky country.
4:58:53Vlad CosteaI'm not happy about this war on cash. I don't really understand what the endgame is. I mean, I do understand at a very high level. But it's very silly. For example, in my country, you can't withdraw more than 3000 Romanian lei, which is like... 600 Euro. In one day from your account.
4:59:19Ben ArcIt's not your money, that's why.
4:59:20Vlad CosteaYou can't make payments larger than €2000 in cash. If you're a company, you can't make payments larger than 1000 euro in cash.
4:59:30Ben ArcSo it's not your money. It's the bank's money. As soon as you give your money to a bank, it's theirs. And then they just, by their grace, let you have access to the numbers in their database. This is why Bitcoin is important, because then it is your money. And you own it.
4:59:48Vlad CosteaBut it's important to also not turn Bitcoin into this. super-custodial ETF asset. Because there is no way to verify that the paper Bitcoin you're buying actually exists.
5:00:04Ben ArcAlright, yeah, yeah, yeah, I agree, yeah. More people need to have, yeah. Yeah. Which is why we need decent scaling solutions, too, of course. Which we'll get one day, Vlad.
5:00:16Vlad CosteaAnd self-custody, because if you have scaling without self-custody, it's sort of pointless. Yeah. But it's mind-boggling that we haven't been able to figure out a convenient and secure way for people to store their keys. The best one that we have is about writing 12 words on a piece of paper. And even... that seems to be sort of a roadblock because... some users don't care.
5:00:43Ben ArcYeah, well maybe, I mean, this is... I wouldn't worry about that because there is only one direction for general adoption of public key cryptography. And that's for everyone to use it. And it'll be a shorter timeframe than you realize. Like, captchas are getting too hard and passwords are getting too long, and public key cryptography solves it. It would be pretty cool actually to take some of the research which is happening in the Nostr space, like with the hardware Nostr signing device and then use it for on-chain payments as well. It could be again, it could be maybe it's used by a Bitcoin exchange when they're sending out those on-chain payments. They just have this little device plugged in from that hot wallet. It's signing the transactions, publishing them to the mempool from the device, but then it's pretty easy to kind of turn off that device and stop it from doing that if you need to.
5:01:42But I'm sure there's lots of use cases for that little gizmo to be used actually in Bitcoinland. But yeah, the world needs to get used to public key crypto. Some people think that people are incapable of doing it. We have a lot of dumbass Bitcoiners out there, and they can figure out private keys and public keys. Like, you keep one of them private, the other one's public. It's not that hard. So, the general populace can figure it out as well. And they will over time. Just got to make the tools a little bit easier, but yeah. They'll be driven to it. Everyone will have to use it.
5:02:14Vlad CosteaYou also see this in Nostr, right? With people who can't save their NSEC.
5:02:21Ben ArcYeah. Yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, and yeah, well, this is why it's kind of cool. We got the staging ground, this sandbox where we can experiment with all these tools, where, you know, public key crypto-native environments like Bitcoin and like Nostr, where honestly, I think the things we're building the whole world will end up using. Sooner or later, probably sooner, Because In order to verify who you are, public key cryptography just makes sense.
5:02:55Vlad CosteaThis is the cypherpunk dream, right? Having cryptography to replace trust. At least trust in institutions. So you replace... Structures of power with just cryptography, which I think is beautiful.
5:03:12Ben ArcYeah, it's that Nick Szabo social scalability stuff. It's true. It can happen. Yeah, we can build it. The tools are there. And we are. And that's why we should be proud of the sector in which we work in because humanity does need it. Particularly with all the AI shit as well. Like, to be able to prove that they are actually, you know... to sign something, so this is actually me Producing this content. That's pretty important.
5:03:40Vlad CosteaIt is right now. So I use this AI tool for transcribing my interviews. And there's also an option. To add my voice. Or any custom voice to all the text. Wow. Which is insane. And it's so accurate. Sometimes I'm... I'm concerned that we're going to receive phone calls from people who sound an awful lot like our family members who will ask us for stuff.
5:04:10Ben ArcI think someone had that. I think someone went there. I think someone experienced that. They Yeah, we were talking about it on... the Bitcoin Group. There was someone who had that. They had a phone call from someone who sounded like a family member asking about their Bitcoin. Or maybe, sorry, maybe one of their family members had a phone call from them. It might have been Josh. And it was and because there was so much content of their voice out there that this thing was able to replicate their voice and it sounds a lot like them.
5:04:46But I mean, it does drive people to Maybe some more real-world relationships, because, you know, that's not necessarily a bad thing. If you can't... trust everything on the internet. Maybe we'll all go back to having more real-world relationships. But I did think about that with maybe the podcasting thing as well and content that, you know, these hairless monkeys trying to come up with profound ideas and discuss topics might end up ultimately just being replaced by AI very nice sounding AI Which does a much better job, at communicating those ideas but then I suppose there is the viewpoint of experiencing it as a human which does have value in itself.
5:05:29Vlad CosteaI can imagine the Joe Rogan show with some politician who's a guest. Yeah, and everything is scripted and Basically, they typed everything into the AI and it looks so genuine, so real. It's not hard to pull off with today's technology and maybe in five years it's going to be. Truly indistinguishable.
5:05:52Ben ArcHere's a thought I had, because you know Trump, who's kind of an early adopter, as a politician on the social media stuff and spreading the campaign via the social media stuff, I was thinking, is he an early adopter of AI? And he's just got some crazy AI bot. And he's like, how do we make America dominant? And the AI is like, well, you need Greenland, get that. You need Canada, get that. And then he's just regurgitating what the AI is telling him to do. I mean, if it's not him, there will be a point. I'm sure all the politicians are using AI for decision making. But then I wouldn't be surprised if there's some politician which all their decisions and I wouldn't be surprised if it's Trump as well are coming from some AI bot.
5:06:44Vlad CosteaAnd then you discovered that this super intelligence is actually plotting for destruction of humankind or something.
5:06:51Ben ArcYeah, potentially, but I mean.
5:06:53Vlad CosteaAdvising all world leaders to make all the wrong decisions to get us into nuclear war or something.
5:06:59Ben ArcWell, I guess the next step on from that is. When... we're like, well, why are we having these corruptible humans making decisions? We could just get rid of maybe, you know, there shouldn't be four people with their fingers on the nuke trigger. Maybe government should be much smaller and the decision making which happens, maybe that should just be AI. And then we get rid of the politicians and the AI just makes the decisions for us.
5:07:30Vlad CosteaYeah, I don't know about that. Sometimes even being able to corrupt humans can be beneficial, Such as, for example, I've heard this story from Sergej, the CEO of Bitrefill, and he told me that his grandparents were in a gulag... not gulag, in... an extermination camp, in a Holocaust camp in Romania. They're from Russia and they were brought to Romania to get killed. And they were able to escape because they could bribe the security guards. And I think this bribery was actually humanitarian, even though maybe the security guard did not think about the humanitarian side of it. It's just that sometimes the fact that you can turn away. The political decision factor. or steer it into a different direction can be beneficial. Sometimes, I'm not saying always, it's like a 0.1% case, maybe 99.9%. It's a good idea to have objectivity as opposed to human bias.
5:08:37Ben ArcWell, that's an argument for the AI, isn't it? It is. Maybe, I mean, because it... you could say, okay, well, humans, we all want to be free, and we all want more liberty, and we want a full belly and enrichment. And we want that for everyone on the planet. AI makes that happen. And they'll be like, okay, well, stop this, stop that, stop this, and then... I'm sure we'll get to that point. Where we replace world leaders with the AI. Before that, they'll probably utilize it and pretend it's their own ideas.
5:09:10Vlad CosteaBut how do you make the AI not generate the kind of Soviet Union communism where there's mass starvation and you have food rations and...
5:09:21Ben ArcWell, I mean, I argue that was a human making bad decisions, wasn't it? That was Stalin trying to... Predict the prices of toothbrushes and Mao deciding that he didn't he thought birds were making too much noise. So he got all the peasants in the fields to catch all the birds, and then they had a famine, mass famine, because of all the insects which the birds were eating, suddenly too many insects. So, I mean, these are all humans making bad decisions. It's kind of like, because to me it's the... It's the... the fear would be that the AI wants to kill us all. Because it sees humans as a threat to the rest of the creatures on the planet. But I think the reality is the AI will just realize that we're pretty simple creatures as long as we're, you know, happy, healthy, cultural enrichment.
5:10:07And we can... Hang out with each other and that we generally just want to get along and do our thing and then it's just a case of you know resource allocation but Yeah, it's almost like the ultimate... Commie leader is some AI. Which doesn't make those split decisions where it wants to just get rid of all the birds because they're making too much noises in too much noise in the field. Yeah, I think that's where we'll probably end up. Sadly. Well, not sadly. I don't know. I mean, I don't like politicians. I don't think I can trust any of them. I kind of almost think I could trust AI more than I could trust a sleazy politician. He's probably like, you know. scumbagged his way to the position they're in the first place.
5:10:48Vlad CosteaWell, as long as you can choose your AI as a citizen, as in vote with your feet. If you're not happy with a certain AI, you can go into another land, just like you choose restaurants, you know?
5:11:00Ben ArcYeah, well, you've always had like, sometimes I don't like the freedom of movement argument for kind of asshole behavior. Because a lot of people use that they'll say, well, you know, as long as you've got freedom of movement, you've got freedom of choice. And it's like, yeah, I mean, generally, you've had generations of people living somewhere and they don't want to leave. Like, yeah. Because I mean, Yeah. That's often been the argument throughout history or people are free to leave if they want to. But yeah, maybe we'll have elections for different AI agents. But then I suppose it's the... who's behind the curtain, isn't it?
5:11:37Like, can you trust? Wherever the AI is operating. I don't know. I hate the AI conversation because it's this thing we're all on the precipice on as humans. Which we're just going to have to kind of wrap our heads around. It's going to radically change everything. I kind of want, I'm like, I like the Simpsons, you know, everything stays the same for decades. No one ages. Dog doesn't die. That's what I want. I want everything to stay the same. Don't want change. Not radical change either.
5:12:10Vlad CosteaOh, but that's sort of dangerous, right? You never get any new ideas if you don't get generations to change.
5:12:17Ben ArcYeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I think that's been a big part actually of Nostr's success. Has been that now it's easier than ever to build software. So, and like Cashu as well, and some other projects, you know, which have kind of come out and then there's suddenly a whole load of different software solutions for them, is people are... using AI to help them develop. I mean, it's like, I think it's heavily, like blown up using AI for development. And the reality is it's not as advanced as everyone thinks it is. It is when it comes to quite superficial stuff, but... If you're doing anything quite complicated, then AI can just get in the way and actually send you on all these red herrings whereas so it's not it's not quite at the point where it's going to replace us yet. But... Yeah, it's certainly going to have impact, isn't it?
5:13:21Vlad CosteaUnrelated, but I just saw the news that Ripple has acquired Hidden Road for $1.25 billion, one of the largest deals ever in the crypto space. Hidden Road is this prime brokerage firm. clearing $3 trillion every year for 300-plus top financial institutions globally. I read this and I was like, okay, so I guess we get a Ripple pump. I refreshed CoinMarketCap and I realized that the entire market is tanking. Thank you, Ripple.
5:13:57Ben ArcThere we go. I don't really stay abreast of the movements of Ripple. I mean, they sort of buy their way in. I mean, they'll... just pay some company to look at integrating Ripple and then they'll create all this press about how this company's decided to implement Ripple, but really it's just Ripple paying them. So I don't really pay too much attention. But that's a lot of money, isn't it?
5:14:22Vlad CosteaIt is. 1.25.
5:14:26Ben ArcYeah, crazy. There's plenty of money out there.
5:14:29Vlad CosteaImagine these lightning companies, they talk about, oh, 5 million, 2 million. It's nothing. 20 million. It was a lot of money for that David Marcus company, Lightspark, 175 million. But then you get 2.1 billion and you're like, Okay.
5:14:47Ben ArcYeah. It's funny because it's a bit like with the... OpenAI stuff. Some of their raises have just been eye-watering amounts. Where you're never going to recoup that money. It's too much, but yet the VCs are throwing money at them anyway. I guess Ripple's kind of different because they... you know, have this shitcoin money generator. which generates the money, but... Yeah. Do you think that Bitcoin will ever be replaced by something better?
5:15:22Vlad CosteaThat's actually... A good question. I think if So Bitcoin is built on cryptography from the 90s mostly. Libraries that were available Maybe in the early 2000s. Early to mid 2000s. If someone figures out a way to solve the double spending problem without a blockchain and without servers. I think that might be the holy grail. Because the compromise right now is this wasteful blockchain construction which... only gets bloated. There are some designs like Mimblewimble, which prune old transactions, and basically you have blocks that only have two transactions inside of them, because all you need is the input and the output data. You don't need to know. What happened in every transaction? But... If someone figures out a way to do it better, I think that might be the Bitcoin killer. Or maybe... It's gonna get launched in a way that you can redeem your Bitcoin one-to-one.
5:16:36Ben ArcSo... Yeah, that's possible. That'd be a big way to drive users. Although I'm sure that people just kind of see that as a shitcoin. And Although quietly, I suppose, probably they'd redeem. Redeem it anyway. But now it's the complexity of Bitcoin. I mean, obviously, I'm you know dedicated my life to this thing. And I built a lot of stuff on top of it and put a lot of time into it, but... it's the complexity of Bitcoin which sometimes makes me think, well, maybe one day something will come along. Which you can do the same thing, like you say, in a less kind of wasteful way.
5:17:18It's kind of the thing which makes me really bullish on the Nostr stuff in that it's just such a simple Topology. It's so simple. The general architecture of it, I can't really see. How you could... make anything better. Or just signing information. I'm spreading it. I'm sending it to people. Subscribe to the channel. Because it's just so simple. But with Bitcoin, it is quite complicated. Yeah.
5:17:46Vlad CosteaYeah, or maybe it takes the next generation to step in and they're gonna look at it like it's natural, you know, like, They're not gonna have the same... onboarding difficulties.
5:18:01Ben ArcYeah. But then arguably, if like Bitcoin just adopted everything, Throughout its life history, then it probably would have broken. So it is important that there is some conservative decision making, but then it can't freeze to a halt and not improve.
5:18:18Vlad CosteaNo, I mean, everything about ossification is just silly.
5:18:21Ben ArcYeah, stupid.
5:18:24Vlad CosteaYou can't expect something to remain the same way forever. In a world where you have improvements maybe every couple of years. Yeah. Of course, you should consider very well what you're going to add to this, but Don't... Basically hinder potential use cases and call anything. So I do see a lot of potential in DeFi, for example, you're able to swap assets. Maybe right now it's shitcoins, okay, but... you're able to swap assets using protocols as opposed to institutions. That's sort of a big deal. Or all of these privacy protocols that... are much more scalable now. I think the average Bitcoiner when they think about privacy, they consider confidential transactions, which were made 10 years ago by Greg Maxwell and Adam Back. It was more than 10 years ago, almost 12. They don't scale. They make transactions larger. I think Monero has been using that, but Monero doesn't care about scaling. It's just... going along with whatever works.
5:19:43But they these people don't consider that for the past 12 years we might have had improvements in cryptography. And that this whole blockchain industry, even though there is a lot of you find a lot of Ponzi schemes floating around and it's dangerous to some extent to recommend this to the average newcomer. It does produce some research. So it does pay for academics, it does pay for computer scientists who are interested in pushing the boundaries of what's possible with current designs. There used to be a time when Bitcoiners... paid attention to this. And they were interested in it. Maybe it's overwhelming at this point because you have like 2000 projects, but there are at least five of them which are interesting to Bitcoin.
5:20:35Ben ArcI would say that we should also not underestimate the talent which is working on Bitcoin, though, because I mean, we have some of the greatest minds. In you know, that space, of course. Because it's the main event, isn't it? But of course, some of those other projects have produced good work. And hopefully Bitcoin will adopt them. Yeah, the funny one with me is always when people say, oh, well, we can't make this change because there's unknowns. And you're like, so your argument is... Well, nothing really. I mean, your argument is that there might be something which you can't predict which will happen, so we shouldn't make the change, which I suppose did happen with SegWit and some other upgrades, but there's also unknowns in an action as well, like not doing anything. There's unknowns. There's always unknowns. That's the whole point.
5:21:26Vlad CosteaI guess ordinals have... made a lot of people feel... What's the word for it? Disillusioned. I think it's more than disappointed.
5:21:37Ben ArcYeah, but it's whatever the code permits, really. So you can... If you can build on it, then you can build on it. I'm not I've never messed around with ordinals or whatever, but you know. The world clearly likes that stuff. And... people building it on Bitcoin is sort of interesting. People see it as like spamming the network, but it's a very dangerous slippery slope to I'm going to label any interaction which happens on Bitcoin as spam because you could be spamming the network just making on-chain transactions, just sending value from one person to another. You can't define things as spam. Really, but yeah, yeah. We'll get there. Something will be merged in, where we, covenants or whatever else, where we, it powers Bitcoin up a little bit. And then hopefully... when the double spend problem gets solved without a blockchain. Bitcoin will embrace it. As opposed to sticking to its dogmas.
5:22:45Because I really feel there's nothing in Bitcoin that can't be changed. And this is always... quite hard for some because I Because particularly people who kind of base their self-identity around What it is now. And they're like, well, it will only ever be this, and it'll only ever do that, and it'll only ever do this. And you're like, well, it can basically be anything. It just depends on who's... what the majority of people want it to be. That's what it will become.
5:23:11Vlad CosteaI think it's silly to only understand Bitcoin through narratives. Someone made up this... narrative that it's digital gold and therefore you should only look at it through this lens or that it's like TCP/IP. Or whatever. And that it took. The internet, a long time to switch from IPv4 to IPv6 or stuff like this. It's a money protocol and people use this every day for stuff that maybe banks are not willing to Deliver. We should think about the users, we should care about Whether or not Bitcoin is competitive, because I believe that the edge that was given to Bitcoin was granted by the Lightning Network, which It's very advanced. Maybe it's a bit ahead of its time.
5:24:04Ben ArcYeah, good way of putting it.
5:24:08Vlad CosteaYou strip Bitcoin of the Lightning Network and everything interesting that's built on it, and basically it's not distinguishable from Dogecoin anymore. Except for the fact that it had... it doesn't have a known founder and it has maybe a much fairer distribution and that's where it ends. But technologically, it's like Dogecoin. So I think Bitcoin should always have this. Experimental layer where people can build stuff. And it shouldn't be only altcoins. It should be on Bitcoin somehow. Not on federations, not on mints. I think they're a distraction and something that's made for Short-term profit. But defeats the purpose of Bitcoin. It's not trustless. It's not... 100% non-custodial.
5:25:07Ben ArcBitcoiners always want a Band-Aid. They always want some magical solution, which is going to fix the problems it has. They're like, "Oh, okay, well, there's a new thing and that's going to go fix all the problems which Bitcoin has." It's like, no, it's not probably going to fix them. You need to--.
5:25:21Vlad CosteaThe only guarantee in terms of Bitcoin upgrades is that we're going to have something against quantum computing, maybe in the next 10 years. And that's going to have to be a hard fork because if it's a soft fork, then Everyone has to transfer their coins to a quantum resistant address. Like imagine all of Satoshi's coins being left behind.
5:25:50Ben ArcI'm not necessarily sure that's a bad thing, 'cause if whoever... Satoshi is suddenly comes out of the woodwork, that's a lot of coins to be able to impact Bitcoin. So...
5:26:07Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if the first person to, not person because it's not one person, but the first entity to build a powerful quantum computer to crack ECDSA should... be able to access so many coins.
5:26:23Ben ArcOh, I see what you're saying. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. No, we are going to have to shift to quantum resistance. But I think we're, again, that's a ways away. Do you remember Snigirev? Stepan Snigirev. Yeah. Yeah.
5:26:40Vlad CosteaHe was on my show like four years ago.
5:26:42Ben ArcHe's a great dude, man. He's a cat. I mean, that's someone we shouldn't have lost from Bitcoinland. What a genius. He's building quantum computers. I was chatting to him about how hard it is. To build a quantum computer. But yeah, he's building quantum computers. We're a long way away. From having to be too worried. But I always kind of feel that maybe by the time we get there, it might not have to be a hard fork.
5:27:11Vlad CosteaIf it's not a hard fork, then every user must voluntarily move to the new quantum-resistant addresses. Oh, I see what you said before. If you forget about your... Bitcoin or whatever and you're caught by the moment when quantum steps in. You might just lose your coins to someone else. You're gonna have them stolen. And I don't think it's convenient. No. And also it doesn't scale for everyone to transfer their coins to a new address. No. And there's also privacy nightmare you're not going to be able to have. You're you're gonna have to consolidate all of your funds in a few transactions.
5:27:51Ben ArcYeah.
5:27:53Vlad CosteaIt sort of sucks when you think about it. It needs to be a hard fork for it to be 100% untouched. Yeah, because the consequences of soft forking and leaving behind some users who maybe don't access their coins urgently. Are much worse. And even the ones that do access their coins, they're going to have to send them and consolidate their funds and basically give a lot of information to blockchain analysis.
5:28:28Ben ArcBut I suppose... Like... If you've got your... gold in a vault somewhere. And then... you're aware that those vaults are now able to be compromised. The onus is on you. to then move that gold to a better vault. So... There is some kind of user responsibility there, isn't there? Moving the funds to something more secure. But no, it's again, this is why I don't want I don't want I don't want to have to. I don't want things to change. I want everything to stay the same. I want the Simpsons. I want every day to be the same. Nothing to age. Humans to be able to work on solving the problems before the AI overlords take control. Quantum computers not to exist. No World War III. Something predictable.
5:29:21Vlad CosteaAnd a pony.
5:29:23Ben ArcAnd a pony as well. Yeah, that's what I want. Then I'd be happy.
5:29:28Vlad CosteaArthur Pog in the chat says, "Thanks, Vlad and Ben. Might join you in Mallorca. Yay."
5:29:34Ben ArcYeah, Mallorca's great. I think tickets are restricted because Chris likes it being quite intimate. So he's not that keen on it being a huge crowd of people. So if you can get a ticket, I would go and grab a ticket for Mallorca Blockchain Days. We're like proper Mallorca Blockchain Days shills, aren't we? We should have an affiliate link. You should have an affiliate link from Chris.
5:29:58Vlad CosteaYeah, we should be making money off of this.
5:30:01Ben ArcWhy else would we do it? Why else would anyone do anything? No.
5:30:06Vlad CosteaWe want our friends to stick around. Hang out.
5:30:11Ben ArcIt's such a good spot as well, that hotel. Just jump in the sea, go watch a Bitcoin talk, have a beer. Good stuff. Well, I'm definitely going to see you there. I suppose. When is that?
5:30:25Vlad CosteaI'm checking their website now. It's July 10th. Until July 13th.
5:30:31Ben ArcYeah, sweet.
5:30:33Vlad CosteaApril, May, June, July. In three months.
5:30:36Ben ArcYeah. Yeah, I'll definitely see that. And I guess just keep building stuff. And hope for the best. It's the way we work in Bitcoin, isn't it? Keep building things which are useful.
5:30:51Vlad CosteaDid you know that you're listed as a speaker?
5:30:54Ben ArcOh, there we are. I'm definitely going then. Oh, look, I'm going to be at Cheat Code in Bedford As well in a couple of days time. That's Peter McCormack's conference. With the football game afterwards. He's got the Winklevoss twins turning up.
5:31:13Vlad CosteaWell, he has been sponsored by... Kraken and Gemini for most of his podcasting career. Yeah. So I'm not surprised.
5:31:22Ben ArcYeah, it's funny that his team's got such crazy high-profile sponsors. Yeah. But I think they're doing quite well. I'm not a football person personally, but... it'll be fun to catch up with everybody. And it's not too far away to drive either and we will be doing a little hackspace there, bringing the hackspace ruckus, probably in the bar afterwards. Me and BC gonna bring some electronics, build some Bitcoin Switches, hardware wallets, Nostr signing devices. So if anyone's about and they want to pop along, then pop along to that one. It should be fun.
5:31:57Vlad CosteaBen F wants to know if we are live now or if this is just a recording that's being broadcast. We are live, sir.
5:32:06Ben ArcYeah.
5:32:09Vlad CosteaCan you say Ben F? Ben. Ben F. Yeah, this is proof that we are here and we are in the comments.
5:32:16Ben ArcThe Bitcoin Ben group. We've got the Bitcoin Ben group. I haven't checked in on it for a while, but it's pretty impressive. We've got like... 40 members in the Bitcoin Ben group. That's a true Bitcoiner if your name's Ben. No true Bitcoiner is called anything but Ben. So I applaud you, Ben F.
5:32:34Vlad CosteaI remember you met someone in Nashville. And you're like, Oh, your name is Ben, let me add you to this group.
5:32:40Ben ArcYeah. We all kind of get along as well. There's something about the Bens. We all like each other. But yeah, there's some great people in there. BTC Sessions, Ben de Vall, Ben Weeks, got some good Bens. Yeah, I was going to dox some people then by saying their real names, but no, I won't. Wait. So... I think my brain is completely and utterly annihilated. I don't think I can speak anymore.
5:33:10Vlad CosteaYou're thinking this is easy to break Amir Taki's record?
5:33:13Ben ArcI don't want to break Amir Taki's record. I think he beat me. Yeah. What's he working on now?
5:33:20Vlad CosteaHe's working on... To our credit, we have been speaking for five hours and a half, no toilet break. I just had two cups of water and that was it.
5:33:28Ben ArcYeah, I haven't even had a cup of water, so I'm gonna shoot pretty soon. But on the LNbits version one release, everyone should check it out. When it's released in a couple of days time. I'll do a whole bunch of tutorials and videos and stuff for all the great new extensions we have and then all the functionality we have as well. So keep an eye out for that. And then, Everyone should join Nostr. Also use the BTCTKVR Nostr affiliate link On Nostr.com.
5:34:07Vlad CosteaIs that live?
5:34:08Ben ArcNot yet, no. It's going to be in a couple of days. So don't use it right now, because it won't work. But, you know, in a couple of days' time, go to Nostr.com, bag those Nostr identities. And then shortly afterwards, you can trade them on the, I shouldn't say the word trade. That's probably got some legal implications. You can buy and sell them on the Nostr auction place, on the Nostr identity auction place, on Nostr.com. - Yes. But yeah, it's... What am I excited about? Have you dug into the Suriname stuff much, with Maya? Yeah. No. President, have you not? She's running for president.
5:34:49She's like a Bitcoin president type. She wants Bitcoin to help bootstrap the economy with digital payments. And there's some pretty interesting use cases there. I think that was good for the Bitcoiner psychology as well, you know, the builder psychology for medium of exchange money stuff. The fact that El Salvador... just withdrew and stopped and it stopped being used for well, it wasn't used for payments there anyway Because I think that we all saw that as the beginning of Bitcoin being scaled for people It's for the unbanked people to be used as payments. And you were there, weren't you, in that first Adopting Bitcoin conference?
5:35:31Vlad CosteaNo, I wasn't. I was supposed to go to the second one. But then I got sick. And I couldn't travel. I got ripped off by the hotel and the... Flight company anyway. I remember it was very funny. I asked the hotel, okay, so you accept Bitcoin for the room? And they said no. Yes. And I was thinking, should I... Invoke the clauses of their Bitcoin law and be like, oh, no, you should accept because it's legal tender and blah, blah, blah. But I was cool about it. So fine. It's your choice.
5:36:06Ben ArcIt's kind of the elephant in the room, you know, like no one wanted to use it. It's such a shame, man. If only they had the El Salvador dollar.
5:36:15Vlad CosteaWell, when they were in front of a camera and they could promote their business. Everyone wanted to receive Bitcoin, but I think it was only... the settlers, the ones who decided that they want to move to El Salvador, that built this local economy like the beach in El Zonte. But I think they messed up big time with the Chivo wallet. And there were some bad decisions along the way. It's not great when you go to a Spanish country and you're a gringo either. Spanish speaking, I mean. I mean, of course, the locals are happy that you buy stuff from them, but... you'll never be one of them you have to understand the culture and you have to adapt to it.
5:37:03Ben ArcIt's a beautiful place and like it... is a lot better as a country than it was before. And it was, you know, I spoke to people outside of just the Bitcoiners and, clearly, the country-- and it wasn't just on the Bitcoin front as well, like Bacalli opened up as a surf resort and pulled in a lot of surfers as well. So there's a lot of you know good growth for the country. But it was a shame. And I know a bunch of Bitcoin businesses which set up there as well because it was a little bit more friendly on the regulation side. And I think they're still there. And then maybe hopefully we'll get there with the, adoption of it being used for payments, but They've got to make the El Salvador dollar. But yeah, Chivo wallet was a real mess.
5:37:51Vlad CosteaAnd also there was something similar that was happening in the Central African Republic. Not too many people remember that. A lot of the people involved want everyone to forget that this happened, but... the Central African Republic was the second country in the world to ever accept Bitcoin as legal tender. It's just that the political situation there is so unstable that it's hard to get anyone to commit to anything. And they could not make it happen. I wanted to write... So I've been working on a book about Bitcoin in Romanian, and I wanted to write in it that, you know, Bitcoin is already accepted as money.
5:38:31And I was going to use this Forex argument, right? Because if countries accept it as legal tender, then it's no longer just internet money. It's also a nation's money. So you should view it accordingly. And maybe establish exchange desks for this, like where you go to exchange your dollars for pesos. You should also have the option to get Bitcoin. But then I discovered that the Central African Republic is no longer accepting Bitcoin and they gave up on it very fast, I think, in less than one year. And then El Salvador, it's... just disappointing. So you're saying that Suriname is the new battleground?
5:39:14Ben ArcYeah, I mean, potentially, hopefully, So Maya, who's a presidential candidate, she's a Bitcoiner and she's got some very good ideas for how Bitcoin could would really help the economy there. And I had a couple of chats, actually. There's this great guy, Theo, and he runs these IoT labs. In Suriname. And they do a whole bunch of kind of courses for people on, helping them learn to code and develop. And then also they see them through to developing businesses as well and help and support them through that. And they've got like a whole bunch of these hubs around the country. And we were speaking to them. Just about, you know, what, potentially Bitcoin and could offer them. So they run a course on IoT, for example, and we've talked about Nostr IoT and they really liked the idea of that. And, It's just another example of there's a lot of friction in their economy, like the people who live in the jungle.
5:40:18Because I think it's the it's got the highest density of rainforest of any country. Per capita, it's got the lowest carbon footprint, in that it's a negative carbon footprint, because it's just so green. But anyway, there's a bunch of people who live in the jungle and when they, pay bills, they have to go on a bus for like 10 hours or something to go pay a bill, and then they get back on the bus and go home. And it's all kind of great. Like, they have mobile phones out there. They're just unbanked. So if they're... But I think it's kind of... the country itself. There's some Politically, it's it can be quite dangerous, and she's the first woman running for president. And some of the people she's running against are quite dangerous. So, yeah. Yeah, I think she kind of needs a bit of support.
5:41:09So we've been yeah, we've been we've been speaking to a couple of people over there. I was like, okay, phew, there's another, there's an example of where Bitcoin might actually be useful for unbanked people. So it kind of filled me with a little bit of hope and invigorated me in my work. Because for a while, you're watching the dialogue change on Bitcoin. And then you're working on payments technology and you're just kind of like, what's this thing? It's not what I thought it was. But then seeing... her talk about it made me realize that there is still some hope for one of these countries who actually needs access to digital payments to access them. So I think she's running this year. I think it's this year that she's running. So good luck to her. Yeah.
5:42:01Vlad CosteaAnd since we made it so far, like it's five hours, 42 minutes, we should have like a secret word for people who listen. So they can write that in the comments and we're going to know that they listened to all of this recording.
5:42:17Ben ArcWhat? Like, Nostrification or something? Nostrification. Yeah. Okay. Nostrify the things.
5:42:25Vlad CosteaDream of Nostrification.
5:42:27Ben ArcDream of Nostrification. Yeah, that should be it. So if you've made it this far, mention Nostrification.
5:42:36Vlad CosteaWhere can people follow you, Ben? And I don't want to follow you home and hit you with a $5 wrench.
5:42:42Ben ArcYeah. I'm in Wales. Come. no. I see you can... I'm on Nostr. I mean, to be honest, I'm not really on the social media that often these days. But I...
5:42:52Vlad CosteaI know. You haven't retweeted.
5:42:55Ben ArcYeah, exactly. I haven't retweeted and I haven't re-noted. But on Twitter, it's Ben Arc.
5:43:03Vlad CosteaIs it Ben Arc? Arc BTC.
5:43:05Ben ArcArcBTC. At Twitter. And then on Nostr, it's Ben Arc, Nostr. And then if you're interested, if you've been playing around with LNbits, pop in on the LNbits Telegram group, which is just LNbits. We've got the MakerBits Telegram group as well. That's a fun group. It's all the hardware dorks fiddling around with hardware stuff. That's always worth popping in on. And. Yeah, that's pretty much it for me. Easiest way to kind of contact me, you can always just DM me on Telegram as well if you want. Pretty reachable.
5:43:42Vlad CosteaAnd we're two days away from the launch of LNbits version 1. So April 10th, make sure you try that out.
5:43:50Ben ArcYeah, and it's been five years. And thank you to all the people who've developed and helped, all the developers who've helped us get to this point, and all the people in the community as well. Because, like, a free open source project... I tell you what we should end with, Vlad. Vlad, Vlad, Vlad, I tell you what we should end it with. We should end it with that video. Yeah, thank you for all the people who've helped us to get to where we are. It's all the community members, all the people offering support in the group, in the Telegram group, the DarthCoins and the Leos and the Hamishes and the... Avets out there in this world. Here we go. And... can you hear that? No. All right. Look at this. This is the beauty of free and open source right now. Look at this. This is when it begins.
5:44:44And all these little things whizzing around, these contributors contributing to the code and all these little. Nodes, files. In the LNbits repo. This is where we used to have all the extensions packaged in with LNbits. That's that big blob you see there on the end on the right-hand side.
5:45:05Vlad CosteaThis is amazing. And once again, people on Spotify, you're not going to be able to see this. Check out YouTube around the 5 hours, 45 minutes mark.
5:45:14Ben ArcRight. You see that point there? That was... Oh, man. Little "stop sharing" thing's in the way. Bring it over here. So this is when all the extensions were packaged in with LNbits, and then we pulled them all out into their own repos. Now you install them. You're actually pulling that release from the different repos, and they seem good. And they all turn into their own little projects. It's crack, isn't it? And then some of the hardware projects there as well. Up to 2024, 2025. There we are. So that's five years of commits.
5:45:47Vlad CosteaImpressive.
5:45:49Ben ArcYeah, man. Sick. I love free open source. It's a real pleasure to work on something like that, on a project like that, with all such esteemed peers. Building such great things. Every day, you know, I wake up, I go on the LNbits Telegram group, and someone else has come up with a great idea, or some LNbits extension, or committed some great PR.
5:46:12Sorry, put a PR in, put some great commit. So it's a real honor to work on the project. And it's almost like now is when the fun happens. Up until now, it has just been grinding, getting it out of beta. And now we've got there. And now is when the fun happens. So let's see what we can build.
5:46:33Vlad CosteaOr now is when the stress happens. You have to fix a lot of stuff.
5:46:40Ben ArcNo, I mean, that's kind of the point of version one is. I mean, of course, there's always fixes to be made, but we're at the point where the software is stable and we're happy with it. And, this is why now the fun begins. Like for me, for example, my favorite thing is just to knock out extensions on LNbits, just have an idea, sit down, and bang out an extension. And before, you know, just working sort of generally on the core software would always get in the way of that. Whereas now we can actually just build the things. Build the extensions, build the products, build the things, improve the hardware projects. So it really is when the fun begins for us.
5:47:31Vlad CosteaYeah, maybe one of these days I'm going to come around and maybe just maybe turn my magazines into extensions, even though I think it's a bit silly. You can just. Get the magazines from the Bitcoin Takeover website. They're open source. They're also on GitHub. But maybe some people will see that and read them. I don't know.
5:47:53Ben ArcYeah, that's... I mean... I think it's important to give people ways in which to support you. And if in their LNbits install, they can pay for an... and it's got your... Bitcoin Takeover magazine in there. And they can flick through it as a PDF or something. That's a pretty cool idea. You should do it. Once you've made one of them, then you can just each magazine could just be its own extension, couldn't it?
5:48:24Vlad CosteaBut is it going to be like a paywall? Or what do you mean by extension?
5:48:28Ben ArcWell, you could do I mean, Well, you could offer it just for free. And then people could just install the extension and you'd have it for free. Or you could have it that it's got a... or you could just have a donation link in there, I guess. Or maybe something extra, some extra little feature you should get from the extension. Or you could just have it as a paid extension. So maybe for someone to... enable it and open it up it's you know a thousand satoshis or something like not much but enough that they know that they're contributing to you and your work.
5:49:04Vlad CosteaYeah, I don't know. My biggest problem, honestly, is that I create stuff and then I move on and create new stuff.
5:49:11Ben ArcThat's not a problem. That's great.
5:49:13Vlad CosteaI don't... So there's someone like Saifedean, right? He wrote The Bitcoin Standard, and then he started a podcast about it and then he spent a few years marketing it and then he hyped his new project using Maybe the fame that he accumulated from the previous one. And I don't get to that point. By the time I finish something, I'm already thinking about how I can make something else. I already have ideas to create something new. Maybe I need a marketing person or...
5:49:42Ben ArcI don't know, man. I mean, I think it's important to reward and exercise that part of your brain. The part of your brain, the part of you which summons up good ideas and helps you create new things. If you don't reward it's like a muscle. I think you'll just have less good ideas if you just focus on one good idea. And I don't think there's anything wrong in being kind of a rolling stone. And this is why I love Supertestnet or someone like that, who just does that. That's his life, is he just comes up with something makes something and then moves on to the next thing comes up with something makes something moves on to the next thing for a while I was like that but then with software and hardware, for example, you then need to maintain those projects. So you end up having less and less time just to roll out new things.
5:50:30But I think as much as possible, if you're someone who has ideas and good ideas, as much as possible, you should nurture that part of yourself of just building things. And I always admire someone like Supertestnet. He accepts that's what he is and accepts that's what he does. And he just builds a new thing, moves on to the next thing, builds a new thing, moves on to the next thing. It's a great way of existing, I think. But yeah.
5:50:54I think this is probably why... because fiatjaf's very similar in that he builds a thing, wants to move on, builds a thing, wants to move on, but then you end up accumulating this backlog of projects you need to maintain, which then takes time. And then you've got the other part of your brain is just summoning up all these great new ideas you want to work on. And actually, this is the thing I love about LNbits, is it allows you to go full ADHD and be like, "I'm going to build an extension of this, I'm going to build an extension for that."
5:51:25And each time you build an extension, it only takes a few days. And now, because DNI has done such great work making the extensions modular, So now the extensions are getting to the point where they're much easier to maintain and cleaner as well, so it's easier for people to review code. And that will only get better as time rolls on. But ultimately, yeah, you want to be able to just build something, move on, build something, move on. And I think LNbits is going to help us get to that point when it comes to software. But no, you shouldn't you should nurture that part of yourself, lad. It's good.
5:52:02Vlad CosteaYeah, I don't know. I guess we all want what we can't have. And we get jealous sometimes thinking, oh, I wish I could spend more time advertising. Even with my podcasts, I mean, I'm very grateful for my listeners. And I do understand it's a huge commitment to listen even to... two hours a week, and I produce more than two hours a week. So I have a lot of respect for the ones who do listen. I did hear from some people that they prefer to use double speed or something to navigate through the content. I think now with AI, it's easier than ever.
5:52:42For example, if you listen on Apple Podcasts, it generates a transcript automatically because they integrate ChatGPT in their application suite. So you can just search for keywords. If there's only something particular that you want to listen to, you can find that. Which is overall bad because they don't get to listen to my advertisements. So they minimize... the impact. But it's good for spreading information. And that's why I do this podcast, because I'm curious myself, first of all, to find out new stuff.
5:53:15I'm happy I'm not subjected to some sort of community that can tell me what to do, who to interview and who not to. And I've had a bad experience last year with the Roger Ver interview, which sort of marginalized me from some events where I'm no longer welcome. But at least I still have the freedom to pursue whatever I think is interesting.
5:53:40Ben ArcYeah, I mean, hats off to anyone who doesn't do the audience capture thing, because then you just become like an echo chamber. And I honestly think your podcast is like the best podcast. It's great. I love the sort of diversity of people you have on here talking, sharing ideas. And I've watched you yourself become so knowledgeable. That, yeah, you do have to do something with all that knowledge. And it's important that you know, produce things like the magazine and the new. Comic you're working on as well. Because you just have access to people like Phil Zimmermann. It's incredible. But I don't know why anyone would. It's just stupid. The Roger Ver thing was stupid. I was really surprised at people's reaction to it.
5:54:24Vlad CosteaIt's fine. They built their own cult. And it revolves around purity and they want to be the high priests of it. And to them it's not about the ideas being shared, it's only about themselves maintaining control. And they see Roger as this guy who has the resources and the ability to undermine their authority. So if Roger comes back to Bitcoin, they're screwed. Because he's much better at talking, doing interviews, promoting, all of this marketing stuff. And he has... A lot of money. To do whatever he wants. So maybe they do perceive him as a threat and they don't want someone like him to get on conference stages because there are only so many spots on the stage, you know? Guys like you know who, I'm not going to say the name of the Italian guy, but they do try to sort of monopolize the attention. Because they're sort of narcissistic. And they come...
5:55:22Ben ArcI don't know who you could possibly be talking about, but yeah, it is... No idea. No idea who that is. But there's some... very eloquent kind of speakers who give an entertaining talk on a stage. But when you actually kind of look at their agenda, it's kind of weird. Like it does seem, feel like a lot of. Power grabbing and control and stuff. And yeah, it's, and then. I'm not sure exactly what they're bringing to the table. Beyond Like... Ostracizing people. And I don't know. I just... I kind of hate the narrative that Bitcoin is this, Bitcoin is that, and... no true Bitcoiner would do this, no true Bitcoiner would do that, because you're just marginalizing this technology, which is really useful for everybody. And you shouldn't be allowed to do that. You know, you should, it's so, Yeah, it's whatever. It's just something we've learned to live with in Bitcoin, isn't it?
5:56:29Vlad CosteaI mean, I've learned so much over the last year. And I would never go back to trying to step in line, you know, and never cross a certain boundary because I'm afraid that the mob is going to cancel me. I mean, I established my own moral compass. Yeah. And sometimes, you know, it's funny, I said something nice about Zcash, I think last week, feels like such a long time ago. And the Monero people ganged up on me and they were like, what do you mean this and that? And... It's so tribal. And Whenever they see me...
5:57:07Acquiring an interest in something else, they assume I got paid or something, or compromised. They live in this world where everyone, if they have an idea, it must be paid. It must be... people are bought by default. So if they believe in something, they must either have a large investment in it, or else get paid by it. And there is no middle ground. There's no way anyone can have opinions outside of these two models. And you know what sucks the most in this space? That people cannot think beyond their bags.
5:57:43They think I bought this and therefore it must be the best. And if it's not the best, I'm going to tell everyone that it's the best anyway and get them to buy it and hold it and use it how I tell them to. Even the most hardcore libertarians, they're like this.
5:58:00Ben ArcThere is some I mean, yeah as soon as you accumulate something then you do have that vested interest but the There is some power in rhetoric. And establishing some rhetoric. But... Yeah, I'm much more of the... Dialectical type. I think discussion, conversation and progression rather than rhetoric, because then you're in danger. Of ossifying your own thoughts and ideas about things, aren't you? Whereas reality is that, you know... It's a cliche and cheesy, but it's true that we should the smartest person in the room. Thinks that they know nothing you know the person who seeks out knowledge because they assume that what they know is probably wrong. And is welcome to new ideas. And, I kind of feel that that's It's like, remember that meme, are we the baddies? I think throughout history, human beings often all our assumptions, everything we value as common sense, only one period in time in the zeitgeist, is usually wrong.
5:59:11What we think is true we're usually wrong about it and then years later we're proved wrong and future society looks back at us and thinks that we're like Luddites and uncivilized Luddites for having such backward assumptions. So if we look at history, most of the time humans have been wrong about whatever subject. We can only assume that we're probably mostly wrong about any subject now. And that you've just got to be open to kind of new ideas. Or else you're going to lock in. You're going to lock into... some ideology and you're not going to improve. There's going to be no improvement. So you're not just trying to ossify something like Bitcoin, you're actually ossifying your own growth.
6:00:02Vlad CosteaWell, I can tell that you're more of the dialectic kind of guy, because we've been talking for exactly six hours now.
6:00:11Ben ArcWow. I feel like we should just carry on until version 1.
6:00:17Vlad CosteaI think you are the guest who has been... in one episode for the third longest time. The record is held by John Carvalho and Eric Voskuil. And honestly, there are two guys, so it's easier for them to pull this off. They can take turns in talking.
6:00:34Ben ArcYeah, I don't know about the content, though. I do feel like I floundered a little bit at certain points in the conversation. Low blood sugar. I've not eaten enough.
6:00:42Vlad CosteaBut then there's Amir Taki on the second position.
6:00:45Ben ArcAnd how was... how was... did he chit-chat the whole time? He was just talking and talking, old Amir.
6:00:53Vlad CosteaOh, he was talking and talking. At one point, he had this pull-up bar behind him and a rack with... barbells, and I asked him, "Can you please do some pull-ups while I present my ads, because I don't seem to catch a break to make the sponsors happy?" Wow. And he went there and he did like 20 pull-ups in perfect form and I was like impressed.
6:01:16Ben ArcYeah, he's been working out, hasn't he? Did he talk about the Rojava stuff much?
6:01:21Vlad CosteaThe what?
6:01:22Ben ArcThe Rojava stuff with the... Syria, northern Syria.
6:01:26Vlad CosteaNo, he didn't mention it too much.
6:01:29Ben ArcIt's like the most interesting... Well, it's not the most interesting part about Amir, but it's certainly something I'm interested in.
6:01:35Vlad CosteaHe sort of avoids that if you ask him. He's like, yeah, I did that before I went to fight in Syria and then I came back and then I started working on this DarkFi project." He's sort of... So in his life, maybe that he views that as some sort of black hole where he put a lot of time and then he came back and he became disconnected from what's happening. He missed the block size wars. He missed a lot of the conversations around the time. And then he came back and found this fragmented world where Gavin Andresen is gone. And that used to be his arch nemesis for a while. But there's also a lot of money on Ethereum and... Vitalik, who used to be his... coder for Dark Wallet, is now this celebrity, and this is bigger than him. I don't know. It must be weird for someone like Amir to look around and see that he missed out on some opportunities.
6:02:33Ben ArcI mean, the guy's a legend. He's BIP 1, isn't he? Go to BIP 1. Look at the author. He's the reason we have BIPs.
6:02:39Vlad CosteaSo, but you know something? Melvin Carvalho told me that he was the guy who onboarded Amir.
6:02:47Ben ArcWow, that's pretty sick.
6:02:48Vlad CosteaAnd that guy is... I gotta get the door, just a second. Can you keep talking for like 10 seconds?
6:02:56Ben ArcYeah, no, I will. I think that... good old Amir Taki as well when he was doing the Rojava stuff in northern Syria, I think that he probably, like, plowed a lot of resources into helping the cause, because obviously he's a Kurd. And it was very important for the Kurds at that time in northern Syria. But I think it was him and Harry Halpin, wasn't it, who went out there.
6:03:24And they did a lot of infrastructure And it was interesting for me because they were a the Kurds were sort of geographically split split but they wanted to kind of have a nation But spread across different geographical regions as opposed to one geographical blob. So then the idea would be how can they coordinate that? And I think that's why He was interested in using some of the Bitcoin stuff to coordinate it. But also, like, democratic confederalism.
6:03:56It's a lot like anarcho-syndicalism, which is something I find quite interesting, the anarcho-syndicalist stuff like the revolution which happened in Spain where people can basically organize and society doesn't implode in on itself. People can, human beings can actually coordinate themselves without centralized control. So I think that was that's why I always wanted to speak to him about that. So that's why I wondered whether he covered it in your chat with him. Who are you laughing at?
6:04:29Vlad CosteaI'm sorry. My girlfriend. So basically, she cooked lunch. I told her, okay, just eat without me. And then she went to university and had this three hour class. And now she's back and she realized I'm still here.
6:04:47Ben Arc- Yeah, well, you don't want to miss dinner as well, so we should probably call it a day. I don't want to break... Amir's record.
6:04:57Vlad CosteaIt's all good, Ben. You're really good at this, and I'm happy that I was able to capture some of your ideas. I'm going to make sure that I generate a transcript from this, which maybe is going to be like 90% accurate, but thanks to AI, we're still going to have that.
6:05:16And I'm happy that you're around and you're building stuff and you're not compromising on your ideas because I see a lot of... so, I had this conversation with a Romanian guy today, and he told me that he's going to be deleting his Twitter and leaving the space because he feels like the ideas got diluted and nobody talks about separating state and money anymore. And it's just about buying stocks and MicroStrategy and ETFs. And it's hard for him to identify with this community. And he wants to give up. He said, maybe it's time for me to move on. Just do something else with my life. I've spent... Seven, eight years doing this and maybe now it's time for me to go.
6:06:02Ben ArcWell, this is the sentiment which I've also experienced a bunch of other great Bitcoin developers expressing as well. And it sucks, man. It's super sad because this is a great technology and can make the world a better place and will make the world a better place. But it is. Yeah, it's just a shame that these knobheads can have such an impact on people's kind of well-being. And yeah, I know, tick tock, and Bitcoin doesn't care, blah, blah, blah. But when you see a great mind leaving Bitcoin, such as Snigirev, or your friend, then there are people who are contributing to making Bitcoin better and better. They shouldn't be leaving. They should be, embraced and encouraged and yeah it's a shame it's a real shame this is why having some real world examples of people using Bitcoin, what we signed up for, like banking the unbanked, for example, that's why they're important.
6:07:03And that's a... why those examples are important. And yeah.
6:07:12Vlad CosteaI think about Stepan Snigirev, and I remember the interview that I did with him. When I felt sort of like... an idiot. Like half the time. But I've also learned a lot from him. And maybe I should feel proud that I was able to capture that moment when he was still part of this community. Obviously, he was he had a background in quantum computing and physics. He came into the space, he built the Specter DIY, which according to some security people, is still one of the best hardware wallets that you can use. even if I don't think it's actively maintained, but maybe it is. I don't know. The last time I heard about Specter, it was bought by Swan.
6:07:59Ben ArcYeah. Yeah, that was more, I think, the software side of it, I suppose. But... It's the libraries. He lives on in his libraries, and he still contributes to them as well. Like, we use uBitcoin and mBit. In LNbits. We use it in the hardware wallet. And then we also use it in LNbits core as well for doing some Bitcoin stuff. So yeah, he's still very much around. The soul of him is still very much around in the libraries he produced at the time. But, well, I don't know. I need... I don't know. Maybe, I don't know.
6:08:40Maybe it's the Nostr stuff, but maybe there's something which will drive some Bitcoin being used as money. Examples which we can all get excited again. And then maybe Saylor will just fuck off eventually. If Bitcoin goes down in price, that's what we need. We just need a proper bear market and shake out all the... Bloody... people piggybacking. off our glorious technology stack for their own profits and lining their own pockets, shake them out. And then, yeah, a nice healthy bear market. Bring it on.
6:09:17Vlad CosteaThat's going to be fun. I think I would still be here doing the same kind of work. I don't know if I'm still going to have sponsors. I haven't thought that far ahead. Maybe I'm just gonna get a normie office job, but I would still enjoy Interviewing people and learning more about this and maybe Bitcoin would be more interesting with more development happening. I have water. Thank you.
6:09:42Ben ArcWell, I remember the last couple of bear markets. I mean, to me, it's when the most amount of development seems to happen. It's the most interesting time in Bitcoin is when we have a bear market because you just get rid of the noise. Then you get rid of the... just, yeah.
6:09:58Vlad CosteaThat's also the best time to make friends because you realize, okay, these people are serious about the project. They're not here for the good times.
6:10:07Ben ArcYeah, man. And you look around, you go to that meetup or you go to that whatever, the Bitcoin conference, and you look around the room and you're like, "Okay, these people are in the trenches with me right now." They're here for more than just the gains because most of them have lost a bunch of money on Bitcoin. It's healthy. It's a healthy thing for the... community, maybe this. Bear market will... I mean, I think it's going to be pretty severe bear market, so... Maybe we'll have that same experience again, and hopefully you won't lose any sponsors.
6:10:36Vlad CosteaDavid Bailey tweeted that we're gonna have a new all-time high this month.
6:10:41Ben ArcAlright, okay, well, no, probably not.
6:10:43Vlad CosteaBut the question is all-time high on what?
6:10:48Ben ArcYeah, well, he's perma-bullish, isn't he, I suppose. I think some people think they can tweet out that they're predicting an all-time high and some high price and then the price will follow. But no, sadly, it doesn't work like that. I think when you got the... the President quote-unquote shilling Bitcoin, the President of the free world, and the price still goes down in price. That's probably not a good sign.
6:11:14Vlad CosteaI think about this a lot because Trump did something interesting. He launched his own memecoin. And within 24 hours he was in the top 20 on CoinMarketCap or CoinGecko, whatever. So what does this signal to all the investors? That pretty much everything is overvalued. If one memecoin that is only being traded on the Solana DEX is able to go into the top 20 after one day, it just means that everything is... the price of everything is too high. I think that's what started this bearish moment. When market participants realize that prices are too high, so they need a correction, they need a readjustment. Plus, there was the whole fiasco with the Melania coin, and then I think...
6:12:10Ben ArcIt was people coming to terms with the fact that he's a complete lunatic. Everyone was bullish on this Bitcoin, strategic Bitcoin reserve, which effectively was a strategic Bitcoin theft stroke, just not selling it. Yeah, it's, everyone just lost faith in him. And all the markets have... I think the only thing which could have pulled the markets in general out of this huge dump which is happening would be that... He has some success in something such as, you know, stopping the war in Ukraine or proving in some way that he's not an idiot. And that's yet to happen.
6:12:53So the markets are just reacting to that. And with Bitcoin being so volatile, it is a speculative, for most people, it's a speculative asset. So they take the money out of things like that and put them in gold, where it's nice and safe. But anyway, like, this isn't the adoption we want. We don't want adoption being strategic Bitcoin reserves. We want adoption to be grassroots, bottom-up, like, people actually using the technology. Empowering people who need to be empowered and banking the unbanked. That's the sort of adoption we want.
6:13:32Vlad CosteaOh, I agree with you. But at the same time, we are witnessing these events and we have to become part of them. And it's also interesting, you mentioned that the president of the free world, is telling everyone never to sell your Bitcoin but the opposite happens. It doesn't become bullish for the price. When you think about it, Elon Musk was tweeting about Dogecoin 4 years ago. And he was able to get it in the top 10 And now he built a government department that's called DOGE. He got the entire press around the world talking about DOGE. But it does nothing to the price of Dogecoin.
6:14:15Ben ArcDid it really? Did it not go anywhere? The price of Dogecoin. I thought that would have pumped it. I don't pay attention. I thought that would have really pumped the price. It didn't.
6:14:25Vlad CosteaIt made no difference. Wow. And it's just like right now when Saylor announces that he bought like ten thousand Bitcoin or whatever, it no longer pumps the price. Four years ago, it was a major event. It was taking us... to the next level in terms of price now. There's no reaction. It's almost like the market was desensitized. There is nothing except for maybe some FUD about words or... maybe a stock market crash. Right now, Bitcoin... So for the longest time, we have been saying, you know, Bitcoin is... A hedge. Not a hedge. Like, your salvation from... the stock market from fiat money, hyperinflation, blah, blah, blah. And then you see that we have taken this financial asset to the point where it pumps and it dumps in coordination with the technology stocks and the high-risk assets. And that's when you know you fucked up because they're correlated. They're no longer. You might as well buy stocks at this point.
6:15:35Ben ArcI mean, I guess it's just part of the traditional asset class in that regard. And then obviously that's completely excluding all its properties. It's free and open source money, which is actually why we're here. So ultimately... it does obviously it is obviously important, the price of the thing, but ultimately... It's not as important as building out the technology stack and making it better. And finding use cases and it being useful, just useful for people. Whatever purpose, whether it be value for value zaps on Nostr or banking some unbanked somewhere or remittances or whatever else, like this is an incredible technology.
6:16:19And a good healthy bear market will shake out all those bullies and hangers-on, and you'll increase that bedrock of hardcore Bitcoiners who stick with it. And I'm not sure on investment whether... investment is tied to now is I suppose it is somewhat tied to price fluctuations in the Bitcoin price. But there's always this thing, it's like when it's going up, the VCs and investors don't want to invest in Bitcoin projects because Bitcoin price is going up. And then when it's low... they do. Well, maybe when it goes down, they want to invest. I'm not sure. I'll report back on how the VC scene is in Bitcoin after I've done this raise.
6:17:05Vlad CosteaThere were like 1,423 people who listened to this live stream during its 6 hours 17 minutes. If any one of the 1,423 is a VC and has a lot of money to invest, then please contact Ben.
6:17:27Ben ArcAh also we're going to be on Thunderfunder. I like Thunderfunder. That's cool. So that's Lightning Ventures' platform, new platform. And kind of their concept is, OK, if you know, the VC community is holding onto their stacks and they don't invest in companies, then the traditional kind of VC companies, you got all these great Bitcoiners out there who've made a big stack and they will contribute back to the ecosystem by investing in some of these companies. So they make a really nice, easy platform for kind of crowdsourcing investment. So we're going to be launching with them in a couple of days as well.
6:18:00And I actually think it's a great platform. It's like a great crowdsourcing. So, you know, people can invest and get some equity in a company or a project they like. Which is great for us because we have like, a big community of people who are very enthusiastic about LNbits. And it's nice for them to have some way of having some ownership of LNbits, the company. But that's something I'm super excited about. I should have probably showed a little bit more. On the show, but that's a scary amount of people.
6:18:29Vlad CosteaWe're still on the show, sir.
6:18:31Ben ArcYeah, well, I mean, no, you blew me. I didn't realize that you had 1,400 people listening. That's pretty impressive.
6:18:37Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if they were... Simultaneous, you know.
6:18:41Ben ArcYeah, still. You know, joined, dropped out. Yeah, yeah, that's good. Crikey. Well, I wish I had something interesting to say, but... I think I've run out of anything I could possibly say. Yeah, let's stick with it, Vlad. You'll be there when we're rock bottom in that bear market. When we're in the gutter, you'll be there looking up or looking down at me. Or looking at each other in the gutter and we'll be better for it there'll be no Trump then. Talking about Bitcoin. I think probably the next big crazy bull cycle will be countries using it for medium of exchange, apolitical medium of exchange. And actually, That's, you know, when it comes to adoption, I obviously I'm all for bottom-up adoption, but I think there is something very powerful about Bitcoin being used as an apolitical medium of exchange between countries.
6:19:44To get around, you know. Political money and using the Petrodollar for example. So I think that'll be probably the next big driver. If people care about price.
6:19:58Vlad CosteaI sure hope so.
6:20:00Ben ArcOr it will be some government... who just, like, does a MicroStrategy and sells government bonds, buys Bitcoin, sells government bonds, buys Bitcoin. The speculation being that the price will go up in 10 years, so those government bonds will be worth more money. That could also happen.
6:20:20Vlad CosteaCrazy. When you think about it, such a small and humble open source project that gets launched on the internet, is reviewed by only a couple of guys before launch. Yeah, right now, once again, I'm shilling my manga. About the first year of Bitcoin. But when you realize it's only been like a dozen people who bootstrapped the project in its first year. Of course, there was sort of a community forming on BitcoinTalk. There were people talking on the P2P Foundation forums or the Cryptography Mailing List. But there wasn't much happening. And it started from there. And... Martti Malmi, the way that he described to me that Satoshi couldn't have been the CIA or NSA or any seasoned cryptographer, super experienced programmer. He said it was comical how much Satoshi was struggling to set up WordPress.
6:21:28Ben ArcYeah, I mean, it was a piece of shit software when Bitcoin first came out. But that's kind of cool because it's another example of, I mean, it's like... I mean, If you have a good idea, then get your hands dirty, try and build it. Put it out there in the world. And if it's a good idea and if you've shown you've made some effort, then other people are going to pile in and help you with it. And I always encourage people just to get their hands dirty building. And Satoshi would be a good example of that. A pleb developer who changed the world and brought about open source money. It's pretty great.
6:22:11Vlad CosteaLately, I've been falling down the Dan Kaminsky and Len Sassaman rabbit hole, the mathematician guy. Yeah, there's certainly something there because these people were before the current class of Bitcoin Core developers, before Gavin Andresen, they were talking about this. They are security experts, both of them are dead now. Dan Kaminsky actually was the guy who inscribed the portrait of... Len Sassaman in ASCII on the Bitcoin blockchain and this was in 2010 or 2011.
6:22:55Ben ArcWe're never going to know. I mean, I think, and it's... that is the genius of Satoshi. Like, okay, he's a pleb developer and it's a piece of shit piece of software, but it's so hard to remain anonymous, especially with the amount of content and data that there is on the person, by the amount of postings that they made. So that's, you know, That's a real credit to them. But it's still this huge mystery. And I think part of it is all these breadcrumbs leading in the wrong direction, you know, and all these possible people who it could be.
6:23:31And I imagine that was part of the strategy to remain anonymous as well, is to... Yeah. So some of those, they'll throw some of those breadcrumbs on the ground leading in the wrong direction. But that is the real genius of it and why it's such a fun mystery. My favorite... There's a bunch of great contenders for it, but... well, my favorite used to be Peter Todd, but now that's like a... well, like, because that was my own. No one else seems to have that theory except me.
6:24:04that it was Peter Todd. That's why it was my favorite, and I had all these, like, all the reasons in that documentary. I would say those about the, you know, him returning to the Bitcoin Forum. Like a couple of days after Satoshi left and whatever else. But I also quite like the idea of Satoshi just being this obnoxious troll just going from conference to conference trolling people in plain sight. But now that's kind of a mainstream idea. I don't really like anymore. Did you hear that some people were saying it was Jack Dorsey? That was ridiculous. I like the John Nash stuff. But I don't think it would have been him, but... Yeah, I like the idea. I like to think of John Nash as potentially being one of the cypherpunks, the non-cypherpunks. Because certainly a group he would have been aware of, with his obsession of money.
6:25:00Vlad CosteaWhen you think about it, the first two People. That were contacted by Satoshi are Adam Back and Wei Dai. So it must have been someone who was very acquainted with their work or from within their circles.
6:25:16Ben ArcYeah, totally. Yeah. The reason I like the John Nash theory is just his life story is so interesting. And also the... did you ever watch that film, A Beautiful Mind?
6:25:33Vlad CosteaWhen I was much younger, maybe I should watch that again because I don't remember much of it. I remember the schizophrenic.
6:25:41Ben ArcYeah, there's just There's loads of things in it. Which... are kind of bollocks, which is weird. It's like him taking medication. That was something he never really did. He never took medication. But they used that in the film as an excuse as to why he stopped doing maths Because he was on medication. Which was which was odd because he didn't take medication. And then his schizophrenic episode was him Moving to Switzerland because he wanted to be closer to better money. Because he believes that they had good money in Switzerland. And he was obsessed by the idea of better money. Throughout his entire life. And it was it wasn't even mentioned in that film. That was his main interest. It's bizarre.
6:26:23Vlad CosteaBut oh well, they got to shield big Pharma somehow.
6:26:27Ben ArcMaybe, I don't know, I think because it was made by Ron Howard and Ron Howard, if there's ever going to be a spook in Hollywood, it would be Ron Howard. Is it Ron Howard or is that the porn guy? Yeah, no, the guy from Happy Days, the ginger guy. That's Ron Howard, isn't it?
6:26:41Vlad CosteaGinger guy. Ron Howard. Ron Howard. I'm not even aware.
6:26:46Ben ArcWas it the porn guy with the moustache? Ron Howard... No. Yeah, there we are. Yeah, it's that guy from Happy Days. Yeah. And yes, it's definitely like a little rabbit hole worth going down. The John Nash rabbit hole. And he has some great ideas anyway, like his paper on Ideal Money, which I mentioned a couple of times, I think. Mind on Strike as well was another one of his great ideas. And, yeah. It's just interesting how that film didn't cover any of the money stuff. Like they were trying to cover it up, not being conspiratorial, not thinking conspiratorially, but it was odd.
6:27:29Vlad CosteaYeah, so who's your favorite Satoshi candidate right now?
6:27:33Ben ArcI'm going to say John Nash. I mean, it's a ridiculous proposal, but I'm going to say John Nash just because I can't do Peter Todd anymore. This is the mainstream. There was something about... the reason I thought it was Peter Todd, it was the way in which Hal Finney, his communication with Satoshi was very much like an older person speaking to a younger person. And also there's something about... you've got all these cypherpunk graybeards, and there's all this technology and it kind of takes a young person's self-confidence. And gumption. To smush these technologies together. And create something like Bitcoin.
6:28:14That kind of brazen confidence which I think you sometimes have when you're younger. So I very like because I used to be a teacher and I could very much see the tone of that conversation, it felt very much like an older person speaking to a younger person. Maybe it was the respect which Satoshi showed Hal for being like an OG cypherpunk type. But yeah, so there was the fact that it was crap software, the confidence of just smashing shit together.
6:28:48And then... also the tone between Hal Finney and Satoshi. And then also when I was in Room 77 once, I had this thing in the back of my head and I'm like, So I was asking everyone if we wanted a beer at the table. And then I turned around to Peter Todd and I went, "'Toshi, do you want a beer?" And his face, he kind of went, "Why?" And he looked at me all shocked. And I was like, holy fuck, it's you. Yeah. That was a while ago. But whatever. No, he's not my choice candidate anymore. Probably Nick Szabo. Or John Nash, just because I like John Nash.
6:29:23Vlad CosteaYeah, but the question is, which one of them is actually a coder? Because Nick Szabo, as far as I know.
6:29:29Ben ArcDoesn't... you haven't got to be a... you've got to be a coder. And Nick Szabo is very capable. I mean, he's, you know, he could do it. He could have built it. There was that... he did a podcast with, I can't remember what his name was. Like...
6:29:45Vlad CosteaTim Ferriss. And he was invited with Naval.
6:29:49Ben ArcYeah, maybe that was it. Yeah, yeah. And in it, there was a moment where Tim Ferriss turned to him and said, "Oh, so what you're saying is you came up with the idea for Bitcoin with Bit Gold, but you couldn't code it, so you didn't code it," or something. And then Nick Szabo was very defensive and he went, "No, I could have coded it. I know." He was very defensive about the fact that he could have coded it, to a point where it was like, oh, what are you saying here, Nick Szabo? Are you in fact Satoshi? You know that... any conversations gone on too long with Bitcoin is when they get onto the who's Satoshi conversation? And, That's where the 600 billion meme came from, you know that? No? You don't know the 600 billion meme? It's good. The 600 billion stickers, have you seen those? Pasted around every single Bitcoin conference, which runs out...
6:30:42Vlad CosteaI think I have like a handful of them.
6:30:43Ben ArcYeah, there we go. So it's my friend, DNI, works on LNbits. And he was at a conf And he's a legit developer, very legit, very, very clever guy. And he's at a conference. And there was just, like, an older guy at the conference, like with a literal gray beard. He was talking to DNI all about Bitcoin. They were he was you know just having some sort of private conversation. And DNI became really interested in this guy because he knew so much about the early days of Bitcoin and the cypherpunks and everything else. And this guy knew everything, you know.
6:31:13And then my friend DNI is getting... as he's getting drunker and drunker, he's like, this guy's fucking Satoshi. No one knows who he is. He knows everything about Bitcoin early on. There's this random old Scottish dude With a grey beard. And then he got onto the price a bit yeah so that's the next step isn't it when you go from the who's Satoshi conversation, it's also the what would the Bitcoin price eventually be conversation. Anyway, so he then said as a joke, he was like, oh, so what do you think the Bitcoin price will be eventually? Yeah. He said that to the old Scottish guy. And then the old Scottish guy turned around to him dead serious.
6:31:50And just said 600 billion a coin. $600 billion a coin. And my friend DNI was like, "$600 billion a coin?" And he went, yep, $600 billion a coin. Dead serious. And then it stuck with my friend DNI. And because, you know, all us developers are a little bit on the spectrum, he kept going on about, he's like, he's Austrian, he kept going, $600 billion. 600 billion a coin. He kept saying it to his friends, and then eventually his friends, like, they made the 600 billion... so... oh no, he kept saying, "600 billion, what the... 600 billion, what the..."
6:32:23So they got 600... what the fuck, WTF. I think it's 600.wtf. And then it became something of a meme. But I quite like it because, you know, when you have these dickhead billionaires like Michael Saylor who get in the paper for saying that Michael Saylor predicts the Bitcoin price will be 1.5 million. And it's like, no, no, no, because there's always that new cycle of you know, oh, Max Keiser predicts the price will be $200,000. Michael Saylor predicts this and blah, blah, blah predicts this. And it's always like, no, $600 billion a coin. All, get the fuck out.
6:32:57And ultimately, you know, when, USD is making its little death rattle because Bitcoin has won and we're living in a future utopia of world peace because it's the apolitical medium of exchange between all these countries and all the unbanked people are now on the same level playing field as everyone else because they have access to digital payments because everyone's using Bitcoin. Then at that point, the last trade between US dollar and Bitcoin, Bitcoin will be worth $600 billion a coin.
6:33:32Vlad CosteaI'm not impressed. Like, what's the hamburger going to be worth or how much are we going to pay for eggs? $1,000 per egg.
6:33:41Ben ArcNo, but I like it, though, because it's just $600 billion. Eight zeros. No. Sorry, 12-0s. There's something about it. I think it's kind of like I don't know. It's a little more subtle as well. You know, if you see a Bitcoin sticker... But if you see it's like an orange sticker with 600 billion on it, there's something about it.
6:34:08Vlad CosteaI got that from Einundzwanzig guys, they carry a lot of stickers.
6:34:14Ben ArcYeah, there we are. Nice. Are they drunks by any chance?
6:34:22Vlad CosteaI don't think so.
6:34:23Ben ArcOh. My favorite sticker was... I think it was at Chaos Communication Congress. And there's a Bitcoin with a red cross going through it. And it just says, Bitcoin, nein danke. And then it was so Bitcoin, no thank you. And the sticker was stuck on the bin in Chaos Communication Congress. It says, "Bitcoin, nein danke." So I peeled it off and put it on my laptop, and I was like, yeah. So that's probably my favorite sticker. Just the hatred, the hatred towards it from the developer, the anarchist developer, where they actually went to the effort of producing a sticker. I'm sticking it on a bin.
6:35:05Vlad CosteaAnd there's also r/Buttcoin on Reddit, where... you find criticism, which sometimes is legit from all of these people. But at the same time, they're so butthurt. And if they spent... half the energy just hedging against their belief, like saying, okay, Let's buy some just in case. You never know. Yeah. They would be much better off. Like David Gerard or whatever his name is. He's such an asshole. And he's a moderator on Wikipedia, if I'm not mistaken. And he was sort of a pain. When adding stuff to the Bitcoin Wikipedia page.
6:35:51Ben ArcYeah, well, I mean, this is why I like the subtle exposure. That something like Nostr gives people to Bitcoin, because they actually see the technology being used. And they realize, and then it opens, they're like, oh, wow, you could like with Rabble, like, what can you build with this thing? Like, what can we build? Now we can send these zap things. What can we build with that? Whether it's like unlocking content or maybe unlocking notes, you know, I think, this is something my friend Simon's been working on is potentially, you know, you have a post, you...
6:36:26Lyn Alden produces a post and you can read the first couple of paragraphs and then you unlock it by sending a zap or something like this. Some really interesting use cases for something like zaps. And people, 'cause for, you know, for a lot of the developer community and the anarchist lefty hacker types, they just see the Michael Saylor shit and the Trump shit, and then they just completely discount Bitcoin as the technology, which is a real shame because it completely aligns with all the stuff they're interested in as technology.
6:36:59Sort of digitally native value transfer, as in you can, like, bring it into all your projects. It's like me and the hardware stuff, you're just marrying up, like, DIY hardware with Bitcoin payments, really. And like, what can you build, you know? Sending microtransactions to turn stuff on.
6:37:19Vlad CosteaI can attest to the fact that I was not aware of how much affordable hardware you can buy from AliExpress. And it's actually pretty powerful and you can do so much with it. I've interviewed you like four years ago about the Bowser wallet, which you built.
6:37:37Ben ArcYeah, that was cool. We need to bring that back.
6:37:40Vlad CosteaIt was a hardware wallet that doubled down as a gaming system for deniability.
6:37:46Ben ArcYeah. It was like a Tetris game. Yeah. It was called Bowser's... something something. I think it spelled Bitcoin, the name of the game, but it was kind of subtle. Oh no, it spelled BTC: Bowser's Tetris Chaos or something, wasn't it, was the name of the game. But yeah, when you turned it on, it was just a Tetris game, but if you pressed the right buttons at the beginning, it would go into a Bitcoin hardware wallet It's very cool, actually. I made a little... and actually, right, I got... I got an issue with Blockstream over this one, because I made that on the M5 stack, ESP32. And then it was about... six months later, Blockstream came out with the Jade, which was built on the M5 stack or the M5 stick. And there was no... mention of the Bowser wallet. And it was only a couple of people, Bowser wallet enthusiasts, who were like, holy fuck, they just like totally ripped off your idea.
6:38:44But then obviously, Jade now is a great wallet and we stock it on the LNbits shop, so can't grumble too much, but Yeah, that was cool. But yeah, if you go to AliExpress, it's Aladdin's cave of cheap microcontrollers. And the coolest thing about buying a microcontroller on AliExpress and then turning it into a hardware wallet or some Bitcoin device is they don't know that's what you're using it for. If you go anywhere and buy a Bitcoin wallet, the company knows you know, has your details because you put in an address to send it to. And you've made a payment. To get the thing.
6:39:21So the company often knows, like with Ledger, you know, and they had that huge leak. The company knows. That you're a Bitcoiner and that's a bit of a honeypot of identity there, right there. And then the factory which is producing those hardware wallets, they know that you're a Bitcoiner. And it's not the hardest thing in the world to slip in. A corrupt device. Into the supply chain somewhere along the line. I would say that the hardware wallet provider which I have the most faith in and I think is really the best is Trezor.
6:39:55I think Trezor's just... I think it's just a fantastic company. And I know that their manufacturing supply chain is pretty tight, so... they can be trusted, but it is important for the existence of kind of a DIY hardware wallet where there is no supply chain attack. These things are they're producing. Millions of these little microcontrollers every month and they have absolutely no idea that you buying it, you're going to turn that thing into a hardware wallet. And I think probably the sweet spot is maybe a multisig setup, which I want to do with a Trezor at some point, with our hardware wallet, is that we have some sort of multisig thing, because then I think you get the benefit of both. You have, like, a secure element and a professional hardware wallet, plus removing the supply chain attack, and by using it as multisig, you're then removing the supply...
6:40:53Vlad CosteaI think Trezor also... so it's an open source project, you can build your own. They have the bill of materials, I think that's what it's called, BOM, on their GitHub page. But also there's the Py Trezor project which means you can run, I think natively, when you buy the Trezor, it runs on ESP32 hardware. But if you have a Raspberry Pi, which once again, it is a very general purpose machine, you can run the Pi Trezor project, which is amazing. A port of the Trezor code base that runs on the Raspberry Pi hardware. Yeah, it's cool. So there's a lot happening. It's the most tested code base out there for this particular use case. It's been around for longer than a decade. They sold millions of units around the world.
6:41:47Ben ArcDidn't they make the first hardware wallet?
6:41:49Vlad CosteaThey did, I think. Yeah, they did. Have you seen... There was also BTChip that was trying to do something similar, but it was more like what you see today in Satodime or Satochip. It's just a smart card. With banking technology. When Ledger launched their Nano hardware wallet, I think I read recently a review by someone who got one around the time. The Trezor was like $200. Or you could preorder for one Bitcoin around the time. And... the Ledger, the original one was like $20 and it had no screen. It was running in this... web application so you had to open everything in your browser it was... very different from what Ledger is today, where you have the Ledger live application and you have a screen for verifying transactions. And I think there are newer machines that are also using the E Ink technology. If I understand correctly, they actually...
6:42:54Ben ArcOh, yeah. No, I saw those. They were dope. And you can stack them on top of each other. They were kind of cool. They had a nice form factor. Yeah, I saw those. There was a Ledger guy at the last cheat code, and I got to have a sneak peek.
6:43:04Vlad CosteaThey got the guy who created the iPod, if I'm not mistaken, like the designer who made the iPod, to work on their Ledger E Ink device. Because right now, Ledger is the market leader, and they also see themselves as a fashion company because they're French. I don't know. It's hard to explain. They try to get people to wear their hardware wallets on a hat. They're trying to make all sorts of accessories to wear your Ledger around your neck. I think there were some boxers or wrestlers or something like that. Stepped into the ring wearing their Ledger. And there are also movies.
6:43:46Like I remember... when I was at my mom's place, I remember I caught her watching a movie. I saw like this glimpse of it. And there were people talking about some millions of dollars stored in this digital wallet and they were using the Ledger. So it's become sort of... a cultural phenomenon to have a Ledger. Except that it's possibly the worst choice that you can make. Maybe not the worst worst. There are. Some terrible devices out there and Ledger, to their credit, has not been...
6:44:22Hacked, at least not physically, to break the chip. But comparatively, it's worse than a Trezor. But yeah. You should bring back the Bowser wallet, Ben. I was actually hoping that what you find on the LNbits shop for a hardware wallet for 20 quid, I was thinking that's your Bowser wallet. Like in a more evolved form factor, but it seems like it's something else.
6:44:54Ben ArcYeah, I mean, so we stripped, obviously, the more code you have on your hardware wallet, the more risk there is. So with the current hardware wallet, it's like a really stripped back, simple version of a hardware wallet, which Vlad Stan worked on, with the idea of then extending it. But I would like to bring back the fun little game thing. Like the... I did make a Flappy Bird version. So with the current hardware wallet, it's the TTGO, LilyGO TTGO, it's a nice little ESP32 board.
6:45:24And you can... yeah, I could put a little Flappy Bird game on it because I quite like the idea that you could just pretend that this thing is a is a game or something but obviously the more code you have on a hardware wallet the more risk there is of having some corrupt code on there so really you just want the bare bones minimal amount of code on there as possible and then also because we use a web installer so you can if you want to so you can, yeah, go buy the hardware and then flash the software yourself using the web installer.
6:46:01We kind of wanted it to be like a quick and easy upload. But we got the... one of the cool things about the hardware wallet is we have the on-chain wallet extension in LNbits for managing your hardware wallet. And you can do it a couple of ways. So you can do it with like an SD card or you can, if you want, you can plug it in and use web serial like a Trezor. We also have Trezor support as well on there. But we think that maybe at some point the on-chain wallet will be added to core, LNbits core. I'd quite like that. I'd also like, what are your thoughts on Liquid? I think we'd, I like Liquid quite a lot. How do you feel about Liquid?
6:46:45Vlad CosteaNot a huge fan for the simple reason that it doesn't do too much. Like, I would have... when you have this federated chain, that is objectively more centralized. I would expect it to do more experimentation for Bitcoin, but it doesn't. It just has a couple more opcodes and confidential transactions. And faster blocks. And that's pretty much it. And it's funny because it was intended at one point after it got built to serve the purpose of tokenizing Wall Street assets or whatever. But Wall Street doesn't like regulations either. So they went to Ethereum.
6:47:30Ben ArcSolana, whatever. Yeah, that's interesting. I mean, I guess for me, it sort of feels like a nice layer between... a nice sort of complementary layer to on-chain and Lightning. So particularly when you have things like subatomic swaps with Boltz, it's just pretty useful to have. I mean, we even have, so if you look at like, the Aqua Wallet model, where underneath it you have a Liquid wallet, and then you can do Lightning payments in and out of it. And then those payments are settled using trustless atomic swaps. And it's super fast.
6:48:05So we have in LNbits, one of the funding source options is a Boltz funding source. So you can actually fund your LNbits with Liquid and then have the money go in and out of a Liquid wallet. And there's something kind of cool about not running a node. But. having your Liquid wallet in your pocket, receiving payments over Lightning and then it being automatically trustlessly swapped out to Liquid. I feel like it's just part of the toolset. And I kind of feel that as well, like enough time has passed that Liquid has proved itself.
6:48:42As being kind of a dependable technology, you know? And yeah, it might not have all the bells and whistles, which they initially intended, but maybe just as it is at the moment is pretty useful. For swapping in and out of lightning to, you know, improve your lightning channels or whatever else.
6:49:06Vlad CosteaYeah, I don't know. I do see some utility from this point of view. I do see some, for example, Federation members when the fees are high on the Bitcoin blockchain to enable users to withdraw their funds on Liquid. And then open Lightning channels and Wait for the fees to get lower before they return to the base layer on Bitcoin. For cold storage or whatever. Also, the Jade, which you say is using the M5 stack, which you used for the Bowser wallet, is also good for storing... coins or assets on the Liquid sidechain. I think that's why they made the Jade, right?
6:49:49Because there was no hardware wallet that supported Liquid. And they wanted something for people building tokens on Liquid to hold in cold storage. So they made that one. It's just that it feels so stagnant when there's an entire industry of building stuff and experimenting with stuff you have this layer that's more centralized, and you don't even try... I don't know. Like sidechains on the sidechain.
6:50:18Ben ArcYeah, I mean, I guess... Yeah, I guess for them, they just don't really want to rock the boat like they have users who use it for... What people use it for now and they don't want to mess around with it too much because there's an inherent risk breaking something. But yeah, I think it's like... it just sort of fits nicely, you know, as a federated blockchain where transactions... you've got one-minute block times. I just think it fits quite nicely with on-chain and Lightning.
6:50:50And it's really, you know, it was being able to play around with the Boltz funding source which really turned me on to Liquid. But I was just thinking at some point, I'm quite bullish on Liquid as a technology and I like Blockstream a lot. I was thinking we could have the on-chain as an option in LNbits. So when you create a new wallet, it could be Lightning or on-chain, and then I was thinking maybe Liquid as well. So you've got a way of just being able to swap between the different layers and then also have it in LNbits core.
6:51:28But I mean, I suppose our problem. And what we don't want to do in LNbits, and this is why we have the extension framework, is bloat the core software.
6:51:40So... just like I said before with the hardware wallet, the less code you have on your server, the better. So with LNbits we verify and vet all the extensions, but the less code you have on your money node, the better. So, you know, install the extensions which are relevant to you. And then... you reduce that attack vector of things which could possibly go wrong. So for us, it would be... maybe an error to... bloat the LNbits codebase by having too much built into it. But I kind of think the on-chain wallet extension... There's not kind of much to it, but it does a lot. And the code is very well reviewed and written. So I feel like that could go into LNbits core. It's something we've been chatting about now off and on. Within the LNbits team. I just wanted to get your thoughts on Liquid and what you thought.
6:52:37Vlad CosteaIt can be useful for scaling Lightning. And Lightning is chain agnostic, which means that you can swap assets between blockchains using it. I'm actually surprised that other chains have not integrated this. I know that there's a project called Portal, BTC. I think that's their... account on Twitter. And they were able to run Lightning on Bitcoin and Raiden on Ethereum and do... Swaps between the two chains using the infrastructure. And they're trying to extend that to multiple, to as many chains as they can. And they're funded by Coinbase and a bunch of other large exchanges, which I think is impressive that they were able to tap into this capital. I just don't see it happening because it competes with exchanges that make a lot of money from fees, from everything happening as long as they are the middlemen. But I do see why the same middlemen want to be ahead of the competition and have this technology ready just in case.
6:53:47Ben ArcYeah, yeah. Yeah. That must be a nightmare in an exchange. Particularly if you're doing all the shitcoinery and just trying to stay abreast of all the different, you know, choices out there which people want to make when they use the new exchange. But the, Yeah, I mean, you can run Lightning on top of Liquid too, so I always I always thought that would happen sooner than, you know, I always thought that would have been something which would have happened more by now that people be running Lightning on top of Liquid. But I definitely feel that like, perhaps on-chain isn't the optimal layer for Lightning to sit on top of. Maybe there could be something else, like a more optimal layer. That was kind of the interest I had in drivechains was that you could have like a layer kind of really optimized for lightning.
6:54:42Beneath it. But yeah, Liquid would be more optimized because you got the faster block times. It's cheaper. But then I suppose with use, that would go up. That might be the other reason they don't want to... do all the token stuff on Liquid as well because they don't want to have too many transactions on it because they don't want the cost of it to go up. And it'll still be able to be accessed for what people currently use it for.
6:55:09Vlad CosteaDo you know anyone who's running a Liquid node?
6:55:12Ben ArcWhat, part of the federation?
6:55:16Vlad CosteaYeah. Like a user node.
6:55:19Ben ArcYou have to, it's pretty, this is what impresses me about, I mean, people don't give Blockstream enough credit for this, but they spent millions like keeping that federation honest. In order to join the Federation as a signatory, you like a guy gets on a plane. With a custom piece of hardware. You can't be too geographically close to another signatory on the Federation. And then they like plug in this custom piece of hardware. It's like quite the process to keep that federation honest, because federations are really kind of easy to Sybil attack and they're hard to keep honest. So Liquid do and Blockstream do a really good job on that. They spent millions keeping that federation honest. This is why I was very skeptical of the Fedi, Fedimint claims of, okay, we solve these problems, we'll just run a federation. It's like, well, actually running a federation is really hard. You know, in a way which is honest.
6:56:14And often, say if it came to, like, a custodial... solution, I would prefer to trust the person I trust, like, you know, I have a relationship where I know the person in real life who's running this service, and I'd prefer to trust that, as opposed to them joining a federation which may in fact be corrupt or the majority of them be corrupt. So this is, yeah, so. I was impressed with Blockstream. Taking that. I mean, of course they're going to... they're gonna put the effort in to keep it honest, but I was impressed with the Blockstream Federation, how well it's done.
6:56:55Vlad CosteaI'm a bit disappointed that they had this 2015 or 2014 white paper about sidechains. They raised a lot of money to build this. But what they delivered was a federation. And I've heard so much cope about building a trusted federation as opposed to a real sidechain. Maybe they... they rushed it or something, but at the same time, it did take them like four years to deliver something that can be used. But the promise is... I've heard this cope from Luke Dashjr. And he was part of... the Blockstream team, I guess, initially.
6:57:33And he said that it's better in case someone steals funds from you or rugs you or whatever, to be legally liable so that you can sue them as opposed to having miners in control. As in the case of drivechains. And you don't know exactly where to go if the miners are dishonest and they steal funds from one of these chains. But at the same time, it's also silly, because this is not part of the cypherpunk the future that some of us envision. If your security model is the nation state giving you justice, then you haven't really built anything revolutionary.
6:58:20Ben ArcWell, I mean, it's, yeah. It's a lot easier just to fall back on the institutions, the legal framework which you have in order to secure. But yeah, it's totally not the thing which we're supposed to be building. He's a funny character, isn't he, old Luke Dash? Did you have him on the show?
6:58:38Vlad CosteaI've tried many times. Right now, I think I basically destroyed any chance of ever having him because during this whole debate about ordinals, I was saying, you know, we have been promoting Bitcoin as a permissionless network. Why do you care how people use it as long as they pay their transaction fee?
6:58:59Ben ArcYeah, that's correct.
6:59:00Vlad CosteaAnd Luke was very much against this. He reported Ordinals as a CVE. He was trying to say that they're on attack and there is a vulnerability that's being exploited. And then he created his own mining pool, but this was... after he lost like 200 Bitcoins and tagged the CIA and the FBI on Twitter. And then he got like everyone who went to a conference in Atlanta in the US. Had to be searched because Luke suspected that it might have been one of the people in that room. Crazy. Like, my point is that I would like to have him on my show. Yeah, but the chances of him agreeing to be on my show are very thin.
6:59:50Ben ArcYeah, yeah. But I kind of thought that maybe that... I've lost all my coins thing was like a public boating accident, you know. Because there was a period where he was always kind of pleading poverty and asking for donations so he could give his kids dental treatment and stuff.
7:00:13Vlad CosteaYeah, I actually had that on GitHub, so let me see if that's still... up there. So, GitHub.
7:00:19Ben ArcI mean, like, you know, I did send some money to that donation address. And then to hear that he had like 200 Bitcoin when they got stolen, I was like... that's not poverty.
7:00:32Vlad CosteaThat's more than I'll ever have. So, he has tiers on his GitHub. $5 a month is ramen. Probably not the healthiest meal, but I eat cheap food like ramen, yogurt, and such pretty often. This tier should cover a quick meal once a week or so. It almost sounds like he eats once a week. $10 a month, meat. Humans, which I happen to be, are omnivores and need meat for a healthy diet. It's not really measurable, but I probably code better eating meat regularly. You can cover the cost of a steak once a month with this tier. $25 a month. Water. Everyone needs water.
7:01:15Unfortunately, it isn't quite free. I think this tier should cover a good chunk of my water costs. $70,000 a month, hosting. My dedicated server mirrors many Bitcoin projects and releases, monitors the overall network health, prepares and shares stats thereon, etc. With this tier, you can cover my hosting costs. I think this is the most reasonable so far. Like you would want to finance this guy to run servers.
7:01:45$225 a month, phone slash internet. LTE is currently the best option for internet service where I live. I guess he should try Starlink. Includes amortized phone/equipment costs. Code doesn't do any good unless I can publish it, so it makes sense to keep me online. $450 a month electricity. No, I'm not using it to mine. Smiley face. I live in Florida, so my air conditioning needs to be running a lot, especially in the summer. Some bills hit $600 per month. I don't work very well in extreme heat, so covering my electric bills will help me be productive. $750 a month. Health insurance.
7:02:31Actually, just a health care sharing program to save money. It doesn't really cover anything, but if I don't have it, the government will force me to pay even more in taxes. Sad emoji. $1,050 a month. Why is it $1,050 and not $1,000? School. I'm an advocate of homeschooling, but unfortunately it's not very practical for me right now. This tier covers tuition for one of my children and helps keep me free to spend more time on Bitcoin.
7:03:07Ben ArcSo, is that the last one? What? Doesn't it go any higher?
7:03:13Vlad CosteaNo. So he seems to have 15, 16 current sponsors. 105 past sponsors. He says, as the longest contributing Bitcoin Core developer, I've been working on Bitcoin since the start of 2011, primarily involving ongoing development, but also including research of possible future improvements, community education, handling security issues, etc. If you wish to sponsor me half or full time, please contact me privately. Arrangements can include things like participation in your company's meetings, if desired.
7:03:57Ben ArcThere we go. Yeah. And then he goes and drops his coins off the side of a boat. And tags the CIA.
7:04:05Vlad Costea200 Bitcoin.
7:04:07Ben Arc200 Bitcoin. Yeah, we've got some interesting characters in Bitcoin, haven't we?
7:04:14Vlad CosteaI mean, I don't blame him. If he's able to get sponsored for his work and not spend his savings, then more powerful.
7:04:22Ben ArcNo, I agree, it's important that we support developers, but there was a period where he was pleading poverty and it wasn't that, you know, it was shortly after that he had lost 200 Bitcoin. when he was after he was pleading poverty and on Twitter about you know how he hasn't got enough money to pay for his kids dentistry. So.
7:04:44Vlad CosteaI think we can find out on the Wayback Machine if I... What's that? Check. This is his GitHub page. Maybe we can find the old version where he pleads.
7:04:55Ben ArcNo, no, no. It was in Twitter. It was on Twitter. He was having a whinge and a whine about not having any money. And then he had like a big quill track.
7:05:05Vlad CosteaHe has a lot of kids though.
7:05:07Ben ArcYeah, yeah, he's got about a thousand children, yeah. And they are expensive, to be fair. But anyway, I thought that maybe it was a very elaborate boating accident. Very elaborate public boating accident. Whoops, I've lost all my Bitcoin. They were stolen from me. And he just went about it in a very goofy way.
7:05:25Vlad CosteaIt seems like if I check the Wayback Machine, his donations on GitHub have been the same for... many years. Nothing's changed. But right now I think he is... Benefiting from a lot of VC money.
7:05:44Ben ArcYeah, from OCEAN pool. Is that doing very well though? Because I can't imagine there being much of a market in... not mining certain transactions.
7:05:56Vlad CosteaWell... it seems like they're building a cult or community or something. It almost makes you wonder when you see, okay, they have a mining pool, they are running their own implementation of Bitcoin, which is Knots, which is configured to filter out some transaction types. Are they trying to fork Bitcoin? I don't know.
7:06:19Ben ArcYeah, it's weird. It's a funny one. Yeah, Jack Dorsey got behind that one, didn't he? He did. Censoring Bitcoin, censoring uncensorship money, censorship-resistant money, censoring transactions.
7:06:34Vlad CosteaTo be fair, I think Jack Dorsey sort of fell in love with Luke Dashjr. When... Luke, I think he was banned from Twitter. He had his account suspended for apparently saying something involving guns to someone, and he got reported. And after... Jack Dorsey got involved. He got his account back on Twitter. And it seems like they got in contact at that point. And maybe Jack Dorsey was enamored with the idea of this rebel who's trying to fix Bitcoin. To be fair, it was Luke Dashjr. who is credited for making SegWit work as a software.
7:07:15Ben ArcOh yeah, totally. We wouldn't have it if it wasn't for Luke.
7:07:21Vlad CosteaAnd he did have some contributions over the years. At one point, it was very funny that I think Paul Sztorc hired him to draft the BIP for drivechains to make it look more professional. This is also sort of ridiculous, that you need bureaucracy and you need a certain format for a BIP to be taken seriously. And he was also working on SegWit2x at one point. No, that was Jeff Garzik.
7:07:55Ben ArcDo you think that's trying to buy people off a little bit? Because, I mean, it's not that hard to write a BIP. I mean, you can write that. But this idea of like paying a bunch of Bitcoiners. Like influential Bitcoiners. To work on your BIP. Kind of feels like you're trying to maybe buy people off a little bit.
7:08:17Vlad CosteaI think it's more like... Mhm. I don't think you're buying anyone's opinion. Or you're influencing anyone's perception of what the project is just because you hired this and that. But it's a way for you to flex and be like, look, look, I got these people to work for me and do whatever I want them to do. Yeah. Peter Todd also got paid to write an article about drivechains to explain his criticism. And it was sort of underwhelming. Like you would expect this guy who's this computer genius to come up with some revolutionary ideas that nobody ever thought about.
7:08:58Ben ArcBut the last time I saw Peter Todd was in Prague and he got... he had... I sort of stumbled into it. So it was a Nostr conference in Prague and I was all like full of, you know... I was all like pumped up and excited about Nostr because there's some great talks and then I walked outside and then Peter Todd had this huge rant about how much he hated Nostr. And it was quite loud as well. I was like, dude, why are you shouting at me?
7:09:22And there's some people like, you know, like in school, when you have a school fight and people sort of stand around you in a circle, it was a bit like that. There's a bunch of people there. And then I was like, oh, and then I sort of walked away and I was a bit shell-shocked. But then I went back in and watched some talks and it was okay, whatever. He's just going off on one. And then that documentary came out about him being Satoshi. And I was like, oh, shit, Satoshi doesn't like Nostr. That sucks.
7:09:49But now he's on Nostr posting like pretty regularly. And I'm like, yeah, I had the last laugh. You ended up on it anyway, even though you hate it.
7:10:00Vlad CosteaI don't really understand why... I guess Peter likes this lifestyle and he wants to be cool with the plebs, and be liked and be in the spotlight. He gets invited to events. He likes to travel the world. He has this approach where I think for one year he does the same presentation everywhere.
7:10:24Ben ArcYeah. Yeah. Well, like the Zcash presentation. I watched that one a bunch of times. He's pretty good at presentations, and he does good work, too. I like the work he's doing with OpenTimestamps and Carliño. What's that project called again, knower of all things? Open proofs? No.
7:10:49Vlad CosteaSomething proof.
7:10:51Ben ArcSomething proof, bulletproof.
7:10:53Vlad CosteaNot bulletproof.
7:10:55Ben ArcBut I like the idea of using... I think OpenTimestamps is incredibly powerful stuff, and a real innovation. And I like the idea of people actually working on it, and it's almost like one of those ideas which was had too early on in Bitcoin. We just didn't have enough velocity for someone to pick up the idea and build something with it, but it's cool that Carliño is using it for... for what's the word? Provably fair voting. There we go. And I think that off the back of... because I think Peter Todd's been working with him on that, I think, off the back of that documentary that gave some nice exposure to that project, which I think is a very important project. Because obviously election fraud is always on the tip of everyone's tongue and Yeah.
7:11:48Vlad CosteaSo it's called Simple Proof.
7:11:49Ben ArcSimple Proof, yeah.
7:11:51Vlad CosteaIt was very simple, pun intended.
7:11:54Ben ArcYeah, yeah, yeah. But I think they've had some really good traction. Didn't they get Georgia, I think, using Simple Proof in the US for their election ballot? And I think there's some talk of some countries using it as well. But that's cool to see Bitcoin being used in that way. And OpenTimestamps as well, Being used in that way. And this is, you know, Yeah, it's good.
7:12:20Vlad CosteaI have to ask you a question, Ben.
7:12:22Ben ArcAll right.
7:12:23Vlad CosteaAre you aware what's Amir Taaki's record?
7:12:28Ben ArcRecord? Yeah. What do you mean? His criminal record?
7:12:32Vlad CosteaNo, I mean, for how long he has been on season 15, episode 71 of the Bitcoin Takeover podcast.
7:12:41Ben ArcOh, right. No, I'm not aware of Amir Taaki's record. Seven hours and something, isn't it?
7:12:45Vlad CosteaSeven hours, seven minutes, 54 seconds. There we go. Do you know for how long we have been going?
7:12:51Ben ArcGo on.
7:12:52Vlad CosteaSeven hours, 13 minutes, six seconds.
7:12:55Ben ArcOh yeah, there we are. That's...
7:12:57Vlad CosteaNice. You just broke his record, even though you said you don't want to.
7:13:01Ben ArcI feel like it wasn't as content rich, though, because that guy can talk and he's involved in a lot of stuff. And he's got a great history as well with Bitcoin.
7:13:10Vlad CosteaYou're still number three. Sorry, I forgot about Exiled Surfer, Michael Parenti. He spoke for 8 hours, 10 minutes, 11 seconds.
7:13:20Ben ArcI'm not going to challenge him. I need to go have my dinner. And I need to get on with bloody reviewing DNI's PRs for the hardware extensions. That's what I need to do.
7:13:32Vlad CosteaBut I got to hand it to you. You're an iron man. You have good bladder control.
7:13:39Ben ArcI mean, I don't know what's happening currently internally, but something's rupturing. Yeah there's some rupture internally I need to probably go sort out but I guess the trick is not drinking anything or eating anything. Yeah. Yeah, man. Yeah. Yeah, there we are. It's healthy. Yeah. But no, it's been great. I've never been on a podcast for this long before and it's impressive stuff.
7:14:11Vlad CosteaIt's impressive that. So let me give you some details about the interview with Amir, because that was your benchmark. At one point he started talking about his favorite mathematicians like biographical data about them. And also he started talking about dinosaurs and his fascinations with the future and how he believes the future of fauna on Earth is going to look like, how animals are going to evolve. Like it wasn't topical about DarkFi, about his work in Bitcoin, you know.
7:14:45Ben ArcThat's kind of his style though, isn't it? He's like a savant going in all directions at once. And then... like occasionally strikes gold.
7:14:54Vlad CosteaMy point is that this conversation was just a tiny bit more focused on the topic. We talked about pricing, we took a deep dive into what LNbits is offering. We also spoke about some of our own opinions on ongoing political events.
7:15:15Ben ArcI think it's important as well that like, because I mean, speaking to some of those developer friends of mine who feel a bit disenfranchised about Bitcoin and kind of the way it's going culturally and how stagnant it is when it comes to the new stuff which is being built, I think it's important to talk about that stuff publicly too, because, yeah, for other people to know that we're also feeling that vibe. And then just encourage people not to leave. There is a bear market coming. We'll all cross our fingers and have a horrible bear market, bloody bear market, which will kill all the, you know, the hangers-on and the pumpy bull market stooges.
7:16:02Vlad CosteaYep. I don't know what to say about this. I don't even know what the bullish narrative is going to be. Because it seems like every time the stakes became higher, 2017, it was just a bunch of banks coming in, maybe some institutions. Then we had the futures on CME and CBOE, which seemed to be a big deal. Then 2021, we had Elon Musk and we had Tesla accepting Bitcoin payments and we had more acknowledgement from mainstream celebrities. You had Paris Hilton going on Jimmy Fallon, talking about NFTs. It seemed like there was a lot more adoption. It was also FTX and FTX was buying advertisement on the Super Bowl. They had arenas like sports arenas in the US named after FTX. They were sponsoring Formula One race cars. And I think some companies still had to carry the logo even after FTX went bankrupt. That's funny. This cycle we had the President of the United States. Not for very long. Once he actually entered office.
7:17:18It started going downhill. But still... it makes me wonder how high we can go from this point onwards. Is it going to be the president of the European Central Bank who's going to be bullish about Bitcoin? Is it going to be China? Is it going to be some small nation states actually using it to protect themselves from the World Bank?
7:17:41Ben ArcI think it's using it. I think it's using it. I think it's like a... yeah, it's a very fickle pump if it's just some strategic Bitcoin, quote unquote, reserve. If it's just a country buying or not even buying, just keeping some Bitcoin or accumulating some Bitcoin. It's actually countries using it to transfer value. That really is a... where the next real bull market will be. But I... yeah, I agree. I mean, what else currently can we have beyond the President shilling Bitcoin? Yeah, it's a funny one.
7:18:22Vlad CosteaYep. And for those of you who listened up to this point, don't forget the special word, which is "nostrification". Post it in the comments. And I don't know, I feel silly for saying this or stupid even. I don't have any more questions for you, Ben, at this time.
7:18:44Ben ArcI think I... Yeah, I've run out of words anyway.
7:18:47Vlad CosteaSo that's... My girlfriend is laughing at me right now. She's like, "Oh, finally."
7:18:50Ben ArcYeah. Yeah. Yeah. You ran out of questions. No. Yeah. Thank you for having me on. And, do you do the same every time?
7:18:59Vlad CosteaWhat do you mean?
7:19:00Ben ArcTomorrow, you've got another podcast tomorrow, haven't you?
7:19:03Vlad CosteaYeah, I do.
7:19:04Ben ArcYeah, you're gonna do the same thing. You're gonna sit for seven hours, eight hours.
7:19:07Vlad CosteaIt's not up to me. Oh wow, okay. It's the guest's ambition and I guess I embarked on this mission. to not have a format, and I don't tell people, you know, we are past 90 minutes, that's on average how much people are willing to listen. This is the internet, you know, it's not TV, it's not like there's something else that needs to start. If people have enough ideas and are able to articulate as many arguments, who am I to stop them? I'm just gonna keep going until... eventually, there are going to be biological and physiological reasons to not keep going.
7:19:55Ben ArcSee, this is where the AI is just going to beat you then, isn't it? Because you'll have a non-stop 24-hour Vlad. Just talking. Constantly in people's ears. And then you won't be able to compete with it. So... physically, your body's gonna let you down in that regard. But no, I mean like... yeah, I've listened to a few big long-format podcasts in my... and if you're doing something, if you're working somewhere and you've got your little earpods in and you're tinkering away, at least listening to a couple of people talk, it's always kind of fun. Particularly if they're having a bit of a gossip as well. Can be fun, can't it? So... Anyway. I shall let you go then because I didn't realize it was my decision. I feel bad now.
7:20:41Vlad CosteaIt was like a game of chicken, I think, like, which one of us is going to give up first.
7:20:46Ben ArcOh, you out-alphaed me. You beat me.
7:20:48Vlad CosteaNo, you did because I'm the one who ran out of questions.
7:20:51Ben ArcOh, right. Yeah. Okay. That's a good point.
7:20:53Vlad CosteaYou're the winner. But please share this in some LNbits channels, on Nostr, everywhere you can. You haven't reposted so far, so I guess the reach was limited by my ability to reach out to people. Maybe we could double the number of views if you also posted.
7:21:11Ben ArcDouble the number of people we've subjected to. Okay.
7:21:14Vlad CosteaYeah, subjected to this torture. Tom Dwyer, who has been here since the beginning, he says, "Love the free flow talk. Dream of nostrification." Ah.
7:21:24Ben ArcLovely. That's a nice note to end on. Thank you, Tom.
7:21:27Vlad CosteaAnd thanks to the sponsors. Let me call them out again. So, LayerTwo Labs, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News, Hodling.ch. Now, now it's not scrolling on the bar anymore, but I got to remember SideShift.ai and NoOnes.com. Thank you very much for making this possible and keeping me working on this. And it's good to impress you with my incredible feat to stay sitting on this chair for so long and talking. And... I apologize to my girlfriend because basically all she did all day was try to stay quiet and look at me in amazement. Like, how long is this guy going to go?
7:22:13Ben ArcWell, now you get to go eat your lunch and your dinner. So that's a bit of a benefit, isn't it?
7:22:17Vlad CosteaIt's almost 9pm here. We gotta go shopping.
7:22:20Ben ArcYeah, so you get your lunch, your dinner, and your supper all at once. And don't forget to go and use that BTCTKVR...
7:22:31Vlad CosteaYou've learned it!
7:22:33Ben Arc...@nostr.com. It took me seven hours. Nostr.com referral link and go get yourself a Nostr identity. There's going to be some cool features which we're going to add to that service such as the auction, POS, calendar and a bunch of other stuff as well probably. So yeah, go snap those up, use that referral code, you'll get 20% off and Vlad here will also get 20%.
7:22:57Vlad CosteaI'm gonna buy my Supra with that.
7:22:59Ben ArcYeah, exactly. Yeah, that's what I was trying to remember. The car you wanted, a Supra. That's it. Okay, well, as long as you have a nostrification wrap on your Supra, that'd be pretty sick. Okay. Goodbye, Vlad.
7:23:16Vlad CosteaGoodbye, sir, and thanks everyone for tuning in, listening, subscribing, liking, whatever it is that you did, even commenting. Super cool. 7 hours 23 minutes 41 seconds. Thank you, Ben.
7:23:32Ben ArcCheers, man.
7:23:34Vlad CosteaAnd try LNbits v1.0, starting April 10th.
7:23:34================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's first-pass ASR (Whisper-large-v3) with automatic speaker diarization. Second opinions, word-aligned to the ASR and reconciled by hand: YouTube auto-captions of the published livestream (read-only copy from the Zcash documentary project, S16E17.en.vtt / S16E17.timed.txt; YT time = mp3 time + about 8.8 s) and a complete local faster-whisper small.en pass over the published mp3. Speaker turns (Vlad Costea vs Ben Arc) were re-derived with local TitaNet speaker embeddings on a sliding grid against a Vlad reference voiceprint (Viterbi smoothing), then checked by hand at every turn; many merged turns were split and short interjections given their own timestamps. The first-pass ASR's dropped and looping stretches and its hallucinated inserts ('Thank you.', 'Bye.', 'Welcome to the...', embedded 'Ben Arc :' labels, doubled-word loops, 'Www.LNbits.com') were removed or restored from the YouTube captions / small.en pass. YouTube blanks profanity, so those words come from the ASR. Notable name/jargon fixes: LNbits (from 'LM bits', 'Alen bits', 'Ellen bits'), LNbits core, Nostr, nostr.com, BTCTKVR@nostr.com, nsec, njump, fiatjaf, Cashu, ecash, Fedi / Fedimint, Liquid, Boltz, Aqua Wallet, Jade / M5Stack, Bowser wallet, Specter DIY, Stepan Snigirev, Satodime / Satochip, BTChip, TTGO / LilyGO, Cryptosteel, Taproot Assets, Galoy / Stablesats, Lightspark, Yalls, K0ala, Fulmo, Bilal, Vlad Stan, Quart / FastAPI, Branle, Bluesky, Phil Zimmermann, Nick Szabo, Bit Gold, Hal Finney, Pieter Wuille, Martti Malmi, Gavin Andresen, Christopher Allen, David Chaum / DigiCash, Chainalysis, CoinJoin, Firo, Einundzwanzig, Paralelni Polis, Second Culture, Amir Taaki, DarkFi, Rojava, Harry Halpin, Eric Voskuil, Ross Ulbricht, LocalBitcoins, Sam Bankman-Fried, Saylor, Saifedean, Lyn Alden, Max Keiser, Tim Ferriss, Dominic Frisby, Keynes / bancor / Bretton Woods / Harry Dexter White, BRICS, OFAC, Foundry, mempool, Supertestnet, r/Buttcoin, David Gerard, 600.wtf, Luke Dash Jr., Bitcoin Knots, Paul Sztorc, drivechains, SegWit2x, Jeff Garzik, Peter Todd, OpenTimestamps, Simple Proof, Carliño, Michael Parenti (Exiled Surfer), Portal, Raiden, Mallorca Blockchain Days; sponsors Citrea, LayerTwo Labs, SideShift.ai, Bitcoin.com News, NoOnes.com, Hodling.ch. Kept as spoken: 'subatomic swaps', 'Georgia' (Simple Proof), the GitHub-sponsor tiers Vlad reads aloud. No large-model local re-transcription was possible (insufficient free RAM on the box), so leftover uncertainty is marked in square brackets with 'unclear:' and a best guess.