Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S16 E13 / Transcript
Transcript · S16 E13 · 2:35:15 · 20 Mar 2025

S16 E13: Corbin Fraser on Bitcoin.com & BTC vs BCH

With Corbin Fraser. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:45Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. This is season 16, episode 13. We are live with Corbin Fraser, who is the CEO and has been the CEO for one year of Bitcoin.com. And this episode is sponsored by SideShift.ai, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News. Coincidence here, I was going to invite Corbin anyway. LayerTwo Labs, NoOnes.com, and Hodling.ch. It's really good to have you, Corbin, because I've noticed on Bitcoin.com news that there's been a change over the last year. And when I announced this episode, it became evident that the BCH people are not happy. The BSV people are not happy that they don't get covered. And it seems like the BTC people are not happy either because they have PTSD from the previous administration. So this is going to be fun.

1:35Corbin FraserYeah, it's good to be hated, you know? I think if you're not... if you don't have a couple enemies, you're probably not... you're not living life to the fullest.

1:47Vlad CosteaSo what is Bitcoin.com today? Because it is a bit confusing for anyone who remembers it promoting, first of all, I think it was just Bitcoin Unlimited and Bitcoin Classic and stuff. And then it was SegWit2x and then it completely went BCH over BTC. And now it's more balanced. If you read it's very hard to recognize.

2:15Corbin FraserYeah, we are... We've certainly changed, right? Like I think, Bitcoin.com has gone through multiple evolutions in its history. I think folks who've been around the Bitcoin space for a while definitely remember, we still get this every once in a while. We'll show up at a conference and someone's like, oh, you're from Bitcoin.com. How's BCH doing? They kind of give us that, like, we feel bad for you kind of eyes. There's this false belief amongst a lot of Bitcoiners that Bitcoin.com or that Roger created BCH. And I probably had more to do with BCH than Roger or Bitcoin.com prior to me doing Bitcoin.com stuff than Roger or Bitcoin.com.

2:59But yeah, Bitcoin.com did support Bitcoin Cash heavily, you know, during the scaling wars. That was a tumultuous time in Bitcoin history. And yeah, I mean, we've kind of taken a softer approach over the past few years. You know, we started supporting Ethereum, we started supporting more chains and more tokens and just kind of taking a more pragmatic approach to crypto in general you know, in our pre-show, we were talking a little bit about how there was a lot of friction for new people coming in to crypto and Bitcoin.

3:34And being like, they walk into a door and just see like a monkey shit fight of tribes fighting and you know, chaos. And it's like, man, I'm just here for digital gold or I'm just here for digital cash. I don't, I don't care what the fighting is. I'm just... just give me some assets that aren't, you know, US dollars or Canadian loonies or whatever and yeah, so I think we've really over the last few years kind of tried to soften that. Obviously, you know, BTC has remained BTC.

4:03BCH still exists, we still support it. And even when we were more supporting BCH, we never stopped supporting BTC. Like we always had it in the app. It was always in there. There was briefly talk of should we pull it? We just yank it out and let people go their own way. But letting the choice is kind of an important thing. But yeah, like lots of us fought to keep it. You know, there was always, I think everyone in the company always kind of saw this as like, let's hedge our bets.

4:31We don't know what's going to happen. During that scaling wars, there was certainly some belief amongst people that like, BCH could become Bitcoin, you know? And there was like, especially in the BCH community, there was always this thought that, well, we just have the longest proof of work and bigger market cap, maybe the exchanges will have to call it Bitcoin. And, that never played out, right? You know, you can look at the charts. It didn't, didn't quite play out that way. That being said, you know, BCH people still building stuff.

5:03They're still doing stuff. We are doing our best to, you know, elevate them where we can, but we don't prioritize them over, you know, Bitcoin or over other assets. We just try to support things in a neutral manner. It's obvious people coming to Bitcoin.com are looking for Bitcoin, right? That's the orange one. So helping them get into that orange coin first and then guiding them through to say hey there's other stuff too if you want to try some Ethereum if you want to try some BCH if you want to try Zano.

5:30We've got Zano now. So it's giving people choices. I think it's kind of a cleaner way for a company to run. Yeah, seems to be working well. We're growing. So growing is good.

5:44Vlad CosteaIt's funny because you put yourself in this middle ground where you're not pleasing the hardcore Bitcoin only people who hate choice. They hate even the fact that I remember at one point there was a website called Bitcoin-only.com. And the guy running it did not put my website there because I had this sticker with prices. And it wasn't just Bitcoin in there. It was also Ethereum. It was, I don't know, the altcoins that were fashionable at the time. This was 2018 or something. And the funny part was that I priced it in BTC. So basically it was ETH/BTC, XRP/BTC and whatever. But just the mention of these coins made him so upset. He said, you will never make it on my website, and blocked me, and he hasn't spoken to me since. And at the time you know it was a big deal for myself because I was just starting out with my own venture and I was thinking, oh, I'm not really making friends here.

6:41Corbin FraserWell, that's kind of a weird it's a weird place to walk into, right? If you're like, okay, I want to build, I want to offer my skills. I want to support this technology and make a life for myself in it. And then you're immediately slapped in the face by not being pure enough, right? You didn't pass the purity test. So now I hate you. I'm blocking you. You're banned from my groups. Go away. You know, how dare you? Yeah, we still get that too. Like, man, I'll be on Twitter sometimes and I'll see someone reply, either to you or to someone arguing for BCH, and if I tap the little link to maybe leave a comment or think about leaving a comment, and it's like, now I'm already blocked.

7:26I think there's a... I didn't pass the purity test either. Bitcoin.com is still not on Bitcoin.org. You know, they list all every Bitcoin wallet imaginable. Not Bitcoin.com. You know, we didn't, I don't know if we'll ever get on there. Yeah, so it's sort of like, yeah, there's no true Scotsman when it comes to Bitcoin. I think the maximalists will, you know, push you away. But unfortunately, like, it's not just the BTC maximalists, right? Like, there's BCH maximalists too, and there's Ethereum maximalists, and I don't know, the monotheism of tribalism.

8:04It's weird. And I think we were talking about this a little bit in the pre-show, just that, like, there's ego and then there's people talking their books and, like, trying to pump their bags. And they're clearly either over-positioned in one asset and only want it to succeed, or their ego is just so... or maybe their identity is so caught up in this one type of asset and what it stands for that maybe they're a little more closed off to considering other options.

8:33Vlad CosteaYou made two interesting statements. First of all, it was not Roger or Bitcoin.com who created BCH, and that you were much more hardcore into BCH than Roger Ver. So I guess you're very qualified to answer the question. So who created BCH and why?

8:56Corbin FraserI mean, BCH wasn't really created by any one person. I would say it was a natural progression after years of infighting. It's unfortunate it had to happen. It's unfortunate. I mean, like, I think if you could, knowing what we know now, if you could go back to 2015 and fight harder and shake, you know, go to these Bitcoin miner meetings and summits and, you know, try to really fight a little harder to keep the community together. I do think Bitcoin would be a lot further than it is now.

9:34And that could include price. That could include adoption. That could include like the network effect. But it didn't happen, right? Yeah, I think like, my recollection, there was a Slack group called BTC forks. And it was just this discussion with like a mix of Bitcoin Unlimited people, Bitcoin XT people, Bitcoin ABC people who I don't think they were named Bitcoin ABC at the time. So you had Amaury Séchet in there, you had Jonald Fyookball, you had Peter Rizun, you had... who else was in there?

10:07Lots of large blockers and people. Jeff Garzik might've been in and around there as well. Yeah, a lot of the large blockers were in there, and it was kind of a place to convene and just talk, and open discussion, open invites. It wasn't like a private group. It was just, you could join. It was like in the sidebar of r/BTC, and it was a place to just kind of keep more in the loop at a faster pace than the new posts coming up on r/BTC. And yeah, I mean, like after just years of trying to get a modest increase in block size, Amaury was the one that was like... he went full French and was like, "I'm just doing it." He went Napoleon.

10:51He was like, I'm just doing it. I'm going to do it. If anyone wants to follow, good luck. Right. And then some people, you know, I think because he was bold enough to just say, I'll just do it he started kind of building up some momentum and eventually managed to get, like, BU to support, which is Bitcoin Unlimited, and some of these others. And yeah, I mean, like, I would say it was a group effort amongst a bunch of different Slack participants to just say, let's just do it.

11:20Because S2X is not happening. They're going to rug pull on us any day now. And sure enough, they did. And I think the debate had hit a crescendo where people weren't able to discuss freely what big blocks or scaling or using Bitcoin as money in r/Bitcoin. I don't know if, like, Theymos is still around there, but he was like the biggest perpetrator of just blocking or banning people from r/Bitcoin. So if you wanted to talk about these things, like, how are we planning to scale this?

11:52How can we improve adoption? How do we use this in merchants so people can use it for coffee and diapers and groceries? You know, instantly, just very quick. Didn't take long to get and it didn't take much to get kind of kicked out of r/Bitcoin. And then people ended up in r/BTC and sure enough, would see some of the posts from, you know, the big block community, which may have included Roger, that may have included, you know, other folks from the big block camp. And it was just a lot of people just sharing, like, I got banned for just talking about this stuff.

12:25What's going on. And, you know, there was still talk of, well, maybe the S2X is happening. Some of the big blockers were really hoping for that two megabyte block. That's all they wanted. That didn't happen. And I mean, like, yeah, I guess when I say I supported it before, more so than Roger, it was like, yeah, I mean, in August, what was it, August... would have been August 2017?

12:53Vlad CosteaYeah, it was the 1st of August when on one hand you had SegWit that activated on BTC and there was the BCH fork.

13:02Corbin FraserYep. They happened on the same day. Yeah, so they wanted to hard fork before SegWit was activated to preserve the SegWit chain. That was the idea, right? And that was kind of like, let's have a save state in the event that the miners support this thing more maybe we can preserve the state and save Bitcoin. That was kind of like maybe the hopeful case, right? And there was like a lot of... I wasn't in all the backroom talks, but there was a lot of miners that were supporting big blocks. And you saw that in those in that first month or two.

13:35Hash rate was kind of bouncing all over. This was before switch mining had kicked in as well where a lot of the pools eventually figured out that switch mining was quite profitable, and they could just flip flop. And if they just took an indiscriminate position on "mine whatever's profitable," which most pools do, then they just started flip flopping their hash rate, depending on difficulty and stuff like that. Prior to that, there was like these noble miners coming in, you know: mine BCH and try to put more hash rate, put more proof of work on BCH.

14:08And the hope was, yeah, longer proof of work, more market cap, more interest, more businesses adopting it, more economic activity happening on chain, that it would become Bitcoin. And it didn't work. But cool stories from it though, right?

14:29Vlad CosteaYeah, there are some cool stories, but I gotta backtrack a bit because the general perception about BCH, and this is straight from the Jimmy Song playbook or something, or Samson Mow, they're going to say it was... So BCH was this unholy alliance between Roger Ver on one side and Jihan Wu on the other side. And then there's this conspiracy about ASICBoost, which was deactivated by SegWit. So in the case of Jihan, it was about being able to use the ASIC miners that they got from Bitmain. And his mining pool is Antpool, right?

15:14Corbin FraserYeah, and Bitcoin.com, we were running a pool at the time as well. We no longer do, but yeah. So it was a lot of... And again, I was just a developer at the time, right? So, yeah, I was in the office with some of these guys, with Roger. But there wasn't... as far as I could tell, it wasn't like Roger pulling the strings, which is, I think, what everyone wants it to seem like. Roger was kind of a supportive participant, but not like a... I don't think he was like the Wizard of Oz that the Bitcoin maximalists like to think that he is when it comes to BCH.

15:49That would probably... like, the Wizard of Oz was really like Bitcoin ABC and kind of like the group around that. They were the ones really, I'd say, like, working every angle, and it was... it's awesome to watch it. Bitcoin ABC also controlled Bitcoincash.org at the time, and I was a contributor there. And that's actually how I kind of got involved in Bitcoin.com, and kind of more of the big block camp as well, was just being a contributor there from a web development perspective. But yeah, I mean, like, it was a...

16:26Like, Roger was really hoping... like, he was holding out hope for this S2X to activate. And it wasn't until that it officially got yoinked that he was like, I think we've got to support this BCH thing. But meanwhile, there's already people in Bitcoin.com that were already like, clearly, this is the thing that we have to support from a, you know, as a big blocker supporter, this is the option. This is the only option because you're not going to get S2X. You know, he didn't really buy it until it was officially announced that they're not doing that kind of thing.

16:58And once SegWit was activated and there was no, it seemed like there's no more discussion related to block increase, it just... it led to Bitcoin.com supporting Bitcoin Cash more. At least that's how I recall it.

17:18Vlad CosteaYeah, it's interesting how your story is very different from what all of these memes have been telling for years. And the block size wars were crazy in some ways. And the craziest part is that it was basically a war between brothers. It was people who used to sit at the same table and interact and have fun and go to Satoshi's Roundtable or scaling Bitcoin or whatever. And then they had to become enemies. But what made it more interesting was that 2017 was this bull market year. And a lot of new people found out about Bitcoin.

17:55So when they entered the space, they had to pick a camp. And when they picked a camp, I guess for them, fighting was not weird. Because they didn't participate prior to that. So for them, fighting was just the name of the game. They had to understand, okay, you've joined this camp and this is the enemy and you have to post memes against them or something.

18:21Corbin FraserYeah, I mean, I think that was when it kind of evolved from... like, the war kind of changed from a war of debates, which actually the debates were never... it wasn't a long war, that was like a short debate, because frankly the communication lines were completely owned by the small block camp. Bitcointalk, r/Bitcoin, a lot of that was just, yeah, controlled. So you couldn't really freely discuss these things. And then by the time things moved into this, well, there's already two different camps now.

18:52So you got to pick your team. By then it was just propaganda warfare and memes and like, to be fair, Bitcoiners had better memes. They just did. They had a more organized meme army. And I say that with respect because it was like, they were good. And I think Paul Sztorc and you talked about that in your episode a couple episodes back, but yeah, I think that they were able to cherry pick certain things and run the gambit on it where it would just again, because they controlled the communication lines, they could spread those ideas further than the big block camp could spread their... you know, their W's, any of their, like, spicy memes or ones that kind of made you sort of stop and second guess what was happening. That the reach was largely, yeah, de-amplified. Yeah.

19:59Vlad CosteaYeah, I'm going to say something very controversial and possibly get into a tiny fight with you as a follow up. But before that, I got to tell you about SideShift.ai, which is a pretty cool website where you can swap between a lot of tokens and coins. So if someone offers to pay you in stablecoins or whatever. And you probably shouldn't hold onto stablecoins when we're in a bull market. You should buy some free market money. I'm not, you know, for the sake of this episode, I'm not going to say which Bitcoin, but you should probably get something that is going to benefit from the bull market.

20:35So if you want to do that in a way that requires no sign up and I don't think they do KYC unless it's a very large amount, but if it's a small amount, you can get by, and you go to SideShift. You just... maybe you don't want to touch, because, the other coin or USDT or whatever, because you don't have a wallet. You just put your Bitcoin address in there, and you ask them to send the stablecoin to another address, and you're just going to get the swapped coins into your wallet.

21:06You can send that directly into cold storage or whatever. You don't have to worry too much about it. It's cool. It has a lot of liquidity. The fees are pretty low. Check out SideShift.ai. And I also have to tell you about Bitcoin.com News because they're very different nowadays. They're not the same as you're going to find out throughout this. So if you want to read about geopolitics, which is mostly what I enjoy reading on the website, there's a lot of stuff for you. And there's also stuff about gold, which I respect.

21:39I think it's ironic that gold is in the middle of a bull run, which was unexpected. And Bitcoin is not at the all-time high, at least not this year yet.

21:51Corbin FraserPeter Schiff is laughing right now. He's laughing at all of us.

21:55Vlad CosteaBut I sort of respect Peter Schiff because he's been consistent and I have respect for that.

22:02Corbin FraserI started following Peter Schiff during the Wall Street riots. Back in... when was that, 2008? That sound right?

22:16Vlad CosteaYeah, I think it was later.

22:17Corbin FraserWas it later? When were they doing the Wall Street protests?

22:21Vlad CosteaI was a freshman in university, 2011...

22:26Corbin FraserAnd he would go around Occupy Wall Street and just interview people and kind of, you know, he's like, I'm a Wall Street guy. What do you want to know?

22:34Vlad CosteaHe wasn't saying I'm a Wall Street guy. He was saying, I'm part of the 1%.

22:38Corbin FraserYeah, that was it. That was it.

22:40Vlad CosteaSo if you are angry at me, could you please explain to me why you're angry? And it was interesting to see that people could not verbalize their anger. And much more than that, I remember there was a kid who was trying to get under his skin, basically, trying to get a job. Saying, you know, you're rich and I'm looking for a job. And Peter Schiff asked him, OK, how can you help me?

23:08What can you offer me? What skill do you have? And he was not able to say it. And I think it was like an eye opener for a lot of people watching that and for the guy in this conversation, because he was feeling entitled to getting a job from someone rich. But at the same time, he was not able to explain why or how he's about to contribute, you know, what kind of value he's going to bring. And I remember watching that too, but I was maybe in my third year of university.

23:36I was just watching YouTube videos, but that was really great. I respect Peter Schiff. I wish I could get him on the show but I'm not sure if he's interested in having these conversations. But the controversial stuff that I'm about to say, which is not really controversial, it's technical. There was this narrative, especially being promoted in 2018, that BCH is the real Bitcoin. And I think sort of that's where the war was lost, because maybe philosophically you can argue, OK, Satoshi might have said this and we can interpret it as him being on our side.

24:14But if you're running a pre-SegWit client of Bitcoin-Qt, let's say a 2014 version of it. You're gonna validate BTC. You're not going to be on the BCH chain. It's not aware of the BCH chain. BCH was the fork, but some people try to frame it as it's the continuation. It's the real one. You can philosophically, based on your understanding and perception of Bitcoin, argue that. But you can technically argue that because if you run the software, you're going to be on BTC. Pre-SegWit, but still, you're validating BTC blocks.

24:55Corbin FraserYeah, I think at the time, too, there was a... I think Vitalik came up with a blog post around that time where he actually said that soft forks were more... I can't remember the exact word that he used, but weren't as clean as a hard fork. I don't want to say that they were like villainous or it was something like that a hard fork was actually a clear representation of how to solve these scaling issues. His take was like it should have been a hard fork, but it wasn't.

25:24And I think for a lot of the big blocker camp, they tended to agree with that. They also saw that preservation of the chain of signatures as kind of being like a bit of a... like one of the hills to die on. And then I think there was sort of this... it was just like an overarching belief that, even though technically, like, validating transactions wouldn't work, right? But for them, it was like, well, we can merge it back in at some point.

26:02And there was a lot of the gap from how that would have been done. Nobody ever knew. It was like, as far as I know, it was just like a lot of, well, once we're the biggest proof of work and the biggest chain, we just naturally become Bitcoin because, you know... I think the idea was, well, who gets the ticker, right? And you might even remember BCH had a different ticker when it started. It was BCC at first, then it became BCH. And it was just like these, like, nomenclature... again, like, propaganda. You know, like, can you convince enough exchanges to call this one asset BCC or BCH.

26:38Okay, well, which asset is it? You know, which one's the real BCH is the BCC one or the BCH one. But then, yeah, you have to go down the technical route as well. I don't disagree that was a flaw in the propaganda. But I would say that there was like enough of a way to describe BCH as being more Bitcoin-y than Bitcoin because of its... Again, this was like where they would often quote, and myself would quote, the white paper, right?

27:12It was like this going back to Bitcoin is a peer-to-peer electronic cash system. Well, which one's more like electronic cash? The one that can cost $50 to send a transaction, or the one that can cost less than a penny to send? And I think there was like enough of those, you know, you put it in a table, looks really easy to say, oh, this one's a little bit more Bitcoin-y than the original. That's currently at high fees, removed this chain of signatures. Yeah, but yeah, I think this is where I wouldn't disagree that was probably a failed propaganda attempt.

27:50But it's all propaganda. That's kind of the fun thing. It was like, how many people can you convince? And, you know, I think there's probably some reality... You know, there's some universe where maybe the propaganda worked, maybe the communication lines worked more in the big blocker favor. And yeah, maybe some of that worked. I don't know. We'll never know. But it was a fun time.

28:20Vlad CosteaThis reminds me of what I was reading in university about the Cola wars in the 1980s when you had the New Coke. That changed the recipe and then you had other types, not just Pepsi, you had other brands that were manufacturing a sweet drink just like that one, that said, this is closer to the original recipe and it's more like Coke than what Coke is selling nowadays.

28:46I think it's sort of similar. And I do believe that BTC is going to get a block size increase sometime. It's only a matter of time. Because I look at all of these, and maybe it's unpopular with some of the listeners, but I look at some of these proposals to improve it. And I realized that they're gonna run into the same wall of scaling.

29:12Corbin FraserYeah, I agree.

29:13Vlad CosteaOf course, they want to do thousands, if not tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of UTXOs in one transaction with covenants. But how do you exit that? That's the big issue.

29:26Corbin FraserWell, I think that was always part of the debate as well was like, well, in order for lightning to actually become successful, the chain is going to need to scale. But I think at least my read on the current Bitcoin market is that Lightning has... I want to say it's failed, but it's failed to adopt... adoption in the same way that L1 BTC has. And I think now there's more challenger L2s and sidechains and kind of like competing solutions to solving some of the high fees and creating more utility on Bitcoin, that I don't think Lightning is going to make it in the long run.

30:13That would be my take. And this is largely why we have not built any support for lightning. Not to mention, like, it's just it's a high friction onboarding. Often, at least every attempt I've had using Lightning has had... like, the only ones that worked were custodial by nature. The ones that, yeah, like I'm sure if you maybe run your own node and you want to deal with all of the watchtower chaos and, you know.

30:47But I think like, probably not something you're going to see mass adoption for just unless they can improve some of the user friction which I think is not going to happen. I think people are more likely to adopt something like Rootstock or Citrea or Strata, or like, I don't know, there's like tons of these different L2 narratives that are happening, and they're like L2s, you know, in quotation marks. I'm a big fan of BitcoinLayers.org. I don't know if you've been on that one.

31:20That one's like, it's a good summary of all of the different L2 systems or attempts at kind of like L2s in quotation marks, that are being built either with BitVM or some sort of like threshold bridge. But they'll have their trade-offs. And I think even with those trade-offs, there's less friction on some of those than there is in trying to make lightning work.

31:48Vlad CosteaYeah, it's crazy that there's a lot of stuff and Lightning had a very good start. It had the first mover advantage. It had the benefit of everyone agreeing that this is the way to go forward. It was the L2. What you said about Lightning requiring big blocks is true. It's in the white paper. If you look at the Lightning Network white paper, I think it speaks about, and I don't want to be wrong, I will look it up, but I think from memory it speaks about 128 megabyte blocks or even larger than this.

32:23Corbin FraserSo it's hard to run your Raspberry Pi on that, right?

32:27Vlad CosteaWell, I think block size is about storage mostly. And internet speed. So I think it was someone who was able to run a BSV node on the Raspberry Pi, and that's another can of worms, right? BSV. Because these guys sort of emerged and they took some of the people who were heavily involved in BCH, and they said, oh, you guys have big blocks at 32 megabytes or whatever? Well, we're gonna do gigamegs. And that's a direct quote from Calvin. I don't even know how you pronounce his last name. Is it Ayre?

33:04Corbin FraserCalvin Ayre.

33:06Vlad CosteaHe's the one who said this, and it seems nihilistic to a point, because I think Amaury, he was on my show, and he was very reasonable and he explained that there should be a block size limit for the same reason why there is a speed limit on the road because there is some laws of physics at play, and you should be cautious with how you balance the system. And BSV was basically like, no. We're just going to make it one gigabyte and there's going to be this guy, Ryan X.

33:39Charles, who's going to put his vacation pictures on the blockchain. And we're going to have a social media like Twitter running on the blockchain and we're going to have all of these applications that make no sense. There is no reason for them to be on the blockchain, but they did this just because they could. And they made it so centralized that even some exchanges gave up on running nodes. But it was still interesting. And I believe that they stole part of the big block narrative.

34:08Corbin FraserYeah, I think there was a little bit of dilution there, right? I mean, obviously, Bitcoin Cash then forked off from BCH into BSV and then again into eCash. So yeah, I mean, like there's a lot of brain drain, right? Just from that camp alone, of people trying to build stuff. Now, is all that stuff extremely useful to making the world a better place. I don't know. Maybe someone finds it useful, but is it making it less decentralized or creating friction for people that want to spin up a node or, you know?

34:42Yeah, maybe. So, yeah, but it does make me wonder, though, that, like, how much further would we have been if we had all managed to just get along? You know, if we had just gotten a few more people in the room together, fight it out, you know, debate a little bit longer, try to concede some areas for the big blockers. And I kind of feel like that's part of the reason why I do like Paul Sztorc's, you know, BIP 300 and BIP 301, kind of like the idea of like, yeah, you can innovate.

35:17You can do whatever you want, but it all comes back to BTC. There is something kind of appealing to that. And I would hope that if Bitcoin is going to go down that path of, like, bigger blocks in the future, that they consider that possible risk of more hard forks and more... how many people that are currently contributing to Bitcoin Core could potentially say, like, you know what, I believe more in this version of Bitcoin. I'm just going to go over there instead and start contributing to this new thing.

35:51I just... I would have to assume that if there is a Bitcoin block size increase on BTC, Orange coin, then there's a high probability of people trying to create a fork, whether that's through propaganda of like, salty people from say the big block camp trying to run that and create some chaos or whether that's from like actual BTC believers who are going down that purity check of like, well, the one you guys are... the upgrade you guys are proposing, I completely disagree with.

36:22And I disagree with it so much that I'm going to put money, mining hash rate, power, all towards this new thing that I'm going to run instead. And I mean, we saw that hostile kind of hard fork happen in BCH as well, where you might recall there was a Bitcoin classic. I don't know if you remember that. There was like... yeah, so there was a few of these, like, rogue Bitcoin forks that kind of emerged around... I think it was like 2017, 2018. And, like, yeah, there was like Bitcoin... I think it was like any time that Bitcoin Cash would do a hard fork, someone would try to kind of like...

37:04I don't want to say it was like an attack on the chain, but they would just try to like talk about how like, oh, I'm upset with this hard fork, so I'm going to run my own chain called Bitcoin Classic. And I think that one was, it was discovered that was run by like some BTC maximalists that were just trying to screw with the BCH team. And then there was like a few other, you know, Bitcoin gold was around that time as well. Then there was, like, some really weird ones like Bitcoin Diamond, and then there was Bitcoin private, and then there was... there's just a whole bunch of random forks that were happening of like, no, no, no, now there's this other chain.

37:34And it was always this deceptive, you know, come, move your hash rate over here instead. These are the coins you really want.

37:43Vlad CosteaNo, but at this point, I'm convinced that in 2017, there was this moment where maybe enemies of Bitcoin realized that one way to destroy it would be to secede until the community is so divided they can no longer agree on anything. Maybe that was part of the attack vector, because I believe that the BCH fork was created in somewhat good faith because of disagreement on a technical parameter on which there was no consensus. But stuff like Bitcoin gold, it was just made for miners that were using GPUs to make some extra revenue.

38:21And something like Bitcoin Diamond, it was, I don't know, a very small change in parameters and something like Bitcoin private. That was a scam that basically had the one million BTC pre-mine for the founder. I think, what's his name, Rhett or something?

38:39Corbin FraserYeah, I knew it started with an R. Yeah, I think it was Rhett.

38:42Vlad CosteaI remember that scandal. It came from... No, it didn't. That's Verge. I'm thinking about something else. But that was another privacy scam. Anyway, it was a very interesting time. Very wild. It feels like nowadays I look at these Solana meme coins and they're in no way as interesting as the time when you would see a 51% attack on the network and there were all of these tiny forks, very small networks. I remember I mentioned Verge earlier. There was an attack on Verge. I think it was running like three different mining algorithms or something. Very crazy stuff.

39:27Corbin FraserI kind of... yeah, I mean, I look back on the chaos period there with like some rose-tinted glasses. I know some people live in the past, right? And they're really angry. There's probably some people, I know for a fact, there's some BCH people that hate the fact that Bitcoin.com has taken a more softer approach towards just supporting everything. We're not... I'm not telling everyone on the team to like, "Everyone drop what you're doing and we're going to bang the Bitcoin Cash drum for the next six months." Like, we're a business. The.com stands for company, you know. We make money. We try to make money here.

40:04And yeah, I mean, us supporting more things is great, but it is this like... I look back on all that stuff and just kind of say like, probably growing pains that needed to happen. And it was a great stress test for Bitcoin, and it was a great stress test for any other potential offshoot civilizations that want to break off where they now have different playbooks that we didn't have, right? And whether that's used for good or evil, I think that it's going to depend on, like, what people are trying to do with Bitcoin.

40:40Vlad CosteaSo in regards to the conversation we had earlier about Lightning, I've opened the Lightning white paper. And this is at page 55. I had to scroll a bit to find it. It says, "If all transactions using Bitcoin were conducted inside a network of micropayment channels, to enable 7 billion people to make two channels per year with unlimited transactions inside the channel, it would require 133 megabyte blocks, presuming 500 bytes per transaction and 52,560 blocks per year. Current generation desktop computers will be able to run a full node with old blocks pruned on 2TB storage." So these are the assumptions of the Lightning Network as described by the white paper.

41:31Corbin FraserGotta get those gigameg blocks in, right?

41:35Vlad CosteaNo, it's just 133. It's not gigameg yet.

41:39Corbin FraserWhat is a gigameg? How much is that?

41:42Vlad CosteaIt's like nine times larger than this.

41:48Corbin FraserOkay.

41:49Vlad CosteaThat's 1024 megabytes. 133 seems much smaller, but still, 133 is 133 times larger than 1. And you can still do four with SegWit. That was always interesting to me, because this was not really advertised in its time. SegWit was presented mostly as a fix to the malleability issue.

42:18Corbin FraserYeah, yeah.

42:21Vlad CosteaThere wasn't much talk about this four megabyte limit.

42:25Corbin FraserWell, there was like... I think there was talk of like... I may be quoting out of line here, but I do recall there being Adam Back actually supporting, like, well, we could, you know, with SegWit, we could introduce modest increases in the block size. And that these discussions were had during the New York Agreement, during some of these, like, S2X miner meetings and stuff like that, of like, we had some businesses saying, hey, let's graceful increase. We've got people using Bitcoin for payments online, donations online. They shouldn't have to pay high fees to do that, and it's going to hurt the network effect.

43:07And so I think, like, there was talk of doing modest increases, and then it kind of got rug pulled. I mean, I don't want to say rug pulled. It just got... they re-evaluated that and decided it wasn't worth doing. But I mean, like, yeah, there are Satoshi archives of, this is maybe temporary, this is a limit we'll put on and maybe remove later, I don't know. But then, you know, I think there's like some cases to be made of, like, well, not everything Satoshi said was going to be the best thing for Bitcoin.

43:44Like, I can concede to that as well, where I do hear some people in the Bitcoin camp being like, why are we listening to Satoshi? He's been gone since 2011, right?

43:57Vlad CosteaWell, Satoshi was wrong in some cases. For example, he was naive in assuming that everyone was gonna mine solo. He did not foresee the creation of mining pools, but it happened under his watch. So yeah, that was interesting. He was also wrong about... so there's chapter 10, I think, in the white paper that's called privacy. And he believed that just generating a new address for every transaction was going to be good enough for privacy. And it turned out to not be enough. But if you look at some other conversations in which he was involved, he was very interested in zero-knowledge proofs and the stuff that Zcash is doing nowadays, except that he did not have access to these libraries.

44:45Yeah. And Satoshi was also using the term node to also mean miner. And that's one way in which people misread Satoshi today. They read node and they think it's about some Raspberry Pi validating the chain, but it's really about miners. At the time, a full node was also a miner. I think for a while you had in Bitcoin-Qt the option to turn on mining.

45:20Corbin FraserYeah, I think there's a lot of things that I disagree with, I think, in hindsight, from the big blocker camp. But there's still a lot of stuff that I do agree with. Like, I do agree that the censorship of those channels did create the chaos that the Bitcoiners hate so much. You know, like had those debates been allowed to happen, perhaps more concessions could have been made. Perhaps the community could have kept together. So it's kind of like ripple effects, right? Not XRP effects, just ripple effects.

46:05Vlad CosteaI think honestly it's good that you guys did this. And by you guys, I mean Amaury and you as a participant and everyone else, because it was maybe more pure in intentions. It could have been a state actor, you know, someone who was really trying to succeed and really trying to break Bitcoin. But this was like a war between brothers or something. And maybe it was more emotionally charged than something else, but also it was more cypherpunk, I guess. It was just guys who disagreed on something and they said, OK, let's see who's right. And this was the free market way to see who's right. It was costly for some people.

46:54Corbin FraserOh, yeah. A lot of people lost money, myself included. I've told this story to a few people, but I lost a shit ton of money just by selling Bitcoin and being like going all in on BCH guys. This thing's the future, you know. So yeah, I... August, yeah, what is it, August 1st, August 2nd, as soon as there was a market, I was like, I'm selling my Bitcoin for more BCH. Yeah, I was buying all the way up into those $3,000 per BCH candles, you know.

47:23Vlad CosteaThat was another interesting moment, right? When Vitalik tweeted, "Congrats on this, seriously." It was late November of 2017. The price of BCH went to $3,000 or more on some exchanges and it became number two. There was BTC and right under it on CoinMarketCap, it was BCH. And it seemed like that was the moment when the block size wars escalated to the highest point. It seemed like BCH actually stood a chance.

47:59Corbin FraserYeah, there was hopium in the air that like, this might actually work. We might actually flip this thing. And then what happens? But it didn't happen. So, you know, we'll never know. Yeah. Fun times.

48:12Vlad CosteaWhy do you think it did not happen?

48:16Corbin FraserI think... I think there was a lot of miners that wanted it to happen, but were too scared to commit. There was a... from my understanding, at least through the rumor mill on some of these slacks and different groups and stuff like that, was that there was enough hash power to potentially do it, but there was just miners that were kind of in the wait-and-see. And there are so many people on the wait-and-see boat that the opportunity was just gone. That was just what I heard.

48:48I'm not a miner, you know. Yeah, I think there was probably like a three-month window where maybe there could have been an even bigger concentrated effort where more hash power could have happened before all the switch mining pools and stuff like that. I think it just didn't pan out that way.

49:11Vlad CosteaI want to ask you about the current features of BCH and how it's different from BTC today, because I guess it's much more than just the block size limit being increased. But before that, I'm gonna plug two more sponsors. One of them is LayerTwo Labs, created by Paul Sztorc. He's the CEO, and he's trying to unite Bitcoiners, and not just Bitcoiners, also bring Ethereum people and I guess some Solana people and prediction market people who mostly use Polymarket these days, on his invention, which is the drivechain. It's a miner-dominated sidechain.

49:47It's a proper sidechain, unlike something like Liquid or even Rootstock. And it requires this BIP 300 to get activated. To me, it's very interesting and he already has functioning software. So you can download from layertwolabs.com/download the latest version of every client. You can run that on every OS that you might have on your computer. And there's also a Telegram chat that's called Drivechain Talk, and you can interact with users. They can send you free coins so that you can play with them.

50:19You can swap them between chains. You can do a lot of interesting stuff. Just be open-minded because it might be the future of Bitcoin. And there's also another sponsor that might become the future of Bitcoin, and that's Citrea. They're running this Layer 2, which is compatible with the Ethereum Virtual Machine, EVM. Sort of... I think their long game is to tap into the liquidity of WBTC, which is custodied by BitGo and tokenized on Ethereum. They're trying to create a more trust-minimized way of doing that by leveraging the security of the Bitcoin chain.

50:58But what you will be able to do on Citrea, if it comes to the main chain and mainnet, is that you're going to be able to access financial services such as borrowing stablecoins against your BTC and all sorts of DeFi stuff that today is not possible on Bitcoin because of the limited scripting language. So keep an eye on Citrea. You can already get the signet version. You can find it on their website, which is citrea.xyz. And thank you for sitting through my ads. Now I gotta ask you, what's different about BCH today compared to BTC.

51:40Corbin FraserBefore I get into BCH, and again, I'm not... I'm not like... I'm not a BCH guy. You know, like, I still love BCH. I still use BCH. I think it's great, but I'm not, like, in the BCH trenches like some of these guys are. However, maybe actually before I get into some of that stuff, maybe I should mention Paul Sztorc tried to save me, man. He's like... I went for beers with Paul in like 20... would have been maybe 2019. He was out in Tokyo visiting Roger.

52:14And then we went to this... went to Ebisu Yokocho, which, if you've ever been to Tokyo, the yokochos were like, that's the place to go have a couple drinks, eat some meat on skewers, hang out with some locals. It's like these really cramped alleys of just like noise and little stalls. And yeah, we took Paul, me and one other guy, and we took Paul out for some drinks just to kind of... hear his take, because we knew he wasn't... he was like sympathetic to big blockers, but wasn't, you know, a big blocker himself.

52:50So I kind of wanted to hear his perspective. And, you know, he was, during those beers, like, it's not going to work. And he was like, so matter of fact, like, it's not going to work guys. I don't know what to tell you. You're betting on the wrong horse. And I remember trying to convince him, no, no, no. Here's why it's better. He was like, I hate to tell you guys, it's not going to work. Too much sell pressure, never going to happen. You know, you made some crucial mistakes. But it was a very enlightening conversation.

53:25I think that cemented my belief that Paul is maybe one of the smartest people in Bitcoin, in the sense that he's able to see multiple points of view and see the good and the bad in them all. And he's just so well read and so well researched that if there's anyone that can help Bitcoin scale, I do believe that some of his solutions may be a path forward. So I'm keeping a very close eye on Drivechain and, you know, the BIP 300 and BIP 301 and things like that.

54:02So, and we'll see where that goes. Yeah. But yeah, funny aside. But yeah, so what was it, BCH? What has it got going on versus BTC these days? All right, my understanding, they've gone through various hard forks in the last decade. I mean, they hard fork every six months, I believe which is incredibly annoying. Stop doing that, guys. But they do it, and everyone has to upgrade and update. Yeah, it's fine for the most part until it's not. But yeah, they've just got this habit of hard forking, which is, I guess, good for getting changes in and I think some of the recent stuff was like the adjustable block size limit.

54:43So they don't really have like they kind of got a floating a floating block size. So if blocks become full, they just grow. And if they don't, I guess they... I could be wrong here... I guess they stop around... I don't know if it's like 8 megabyte or 32 megabytes. I can't remember where they upgraded to last. It might be 32. But yeah, I believe it's just like this floating point thing. And they've got CashTokens, which are like miner-validated tokens, which emerged after SLP completely flopped.

55:13For those of you guys who don't know, Bitcoin Cash was like trying to take the idea of colored coins, and then... which was like this discussion on Bitcoin for quite a while of like, we could bring tokens to Bitcoin. And, I mean, this is like, I think, around Counterparty, USDT was on Bitcoin and stuff like that. And then there was a lot of discussion in the big blockers on how to do this correctly. And I think there was a lot of pushback specifically from Bitcoin ABC related to the colored coins implementation. It was like, too risky to do it. We don't want to mess up the main stuff.

55:52Let's just find a way to do this without. And then I think a proposal came through from a few different folks. I think Emergent Reasons was in there maybe, and, like, Jonald Fyookball, and some of these... there's a few other names on their white paper for SLP. And it was this idea of like, can we get tokens into the OP_RETURN? And how much... can we build a whole token ecosystem around this idea of using dust transactions, or like... I can't remember if it was like these... yeah, I'm drawing a blank now on what the minimum size was, a 564 sats or something like that.

56:30And every... you had to do this on-chain transaction and, you know, there would be these like off-chain indexers that would validate the token inside the UTXO to justify, you know, how much of your SPICE token... if you had a thousand and then you sent one token, then you'd have 999 tokens. But it was all this, like, off-chain indexing, and it wasn't really tied to miners. You know, the miners just took the profit from these like kind of empty sats that were just floating around.

56:59And yeah, index services would have to run and just update stuff. We had tremendous support for it in the wallet. It was great. SLP was pretty cool for a while until it hit some indexing scaling issues where some of the token DAG just got so big. Like USDT for a little while was even on BCH SLP. And it got so much utility and so much adoption, but it just, like, failed to scale. And then I think, yeah, there was just like... I think some consensus amongst the group that, okay, this attempt, it was great, but we need something better.

57:35And then I think that's kind of when CashTokens emerged. So now they have these miner-validated tokens, which are a little bit more, I could be wrong here, a little bit more like colored coins. And also they're trying to build up this new ecosystem of tokens on CashTokens, but they're completely different than SLP, so none of the old stuff really works on it. And some stuff I'm sure migrated over. But yeah, they're effectively trying to create, like, a UTXO Bitcoin version of, you know, DeFi without the EVM.

58:08So they've... you know, you can build these somewhat smart contracts. They're kind of dumb smart contracts, but they're contracts nonetheless, using Script. But nobody can write in Script because it's a huge pain in the butt. So they ended up writing... I think Rosco Kalis, who actually interned at Bitcoin.com, created this cool compiling language, a bit like Solidity, called CashScript. And CashScript lets normie people kind of write in a JavaScript-friendly kind of language that compiles down to Script, and lets you do some stuff like covenants, and lets you do stuff like time locks, and lets you do stuff like, I don't know...

58:49I guess other cool stuff. So, yeah, I mean, they're trying to build a whole ecosystem there. Infrastructure has improved a lot, I would say, in the last six months to a year. There are some real tokens on there. It's not just silly memes and stuff like that. I think they've just launched a stablecoin on there as well. They do have a DEX as well that's using these, like, UTXO order books to kind of simulate what, like, a Uniswap AMM or automated market maker kind of DEX does.

59:29So you can actually fund LP now on chain. You can swap on chain. Some... yes, just some, like, interesting projects emerging out of there. So I think for any builders that are still interested in the idea of UTXO building and using Bitcoin to do stuff, it's probably one of the best places to play around with. Of course, there's, you know, also eCash, which has similar things. And I think they actually kept... I could be wrong. I think they kept SLP. I think they managed to keep SLP going. And I think they found some ways to scale it.

1:00:02And then BSV, I have no idea. I just kind of fell out of the loop with them. I'm sure they've got their own, their own things as well. But I think for folks that are more interested in building on the UTXO base instead of, like, an EVM, there are tools and communities out there to support that. They're not as popular as EVM. EVM is still kind of the USP right now. It's very easy to build, and I think the tooling and the adoption, the TVL, the... yeah, the liquidity and the volume that you see across Ethereum and Arbitrum and all these other ETH L2s and rollups and all the other stuff there.

1:00:47They've kind of found a nice product market fit for both institutions and for retail to use on chain DeFi. I think that's the hope is that some of the Bitcoin Cash builders can gobble up some of the dev mindshare there. We don't yet support any of the CashTokens. You know, stuff we're kind of keeping an eye on. I think based on volume, if it can make us money, if swap partners integrate, if SideShift were to start integrating that stablecoin, that would be a good plus for us. That may be a reason for us to start supporting, because we could actually get a little bit of a fee off every swap. But...

1:01:27Yeah, I think there's a lot of headway being made there. But yeah, we're not like in the trenches with the BCH people as much as we were in previous eras of Bitcoin.com. Right now, it's just like build a great business that keeps growing, you know, help people. Help more people to come into Bitcoin. Use Bitcoin as a way to let people try anything, whether that's stablecoins, DeFi, NFTs, you name it, you know.

1:01:56Vlad CosteaIt is a bit ironic, right, because the revenge chain for the block size was not BCH and it was not BSV and it was not eCash. And I guess we should also get into eCash because that's another interesting can of worms to open. But it was Ethereum that took most of the users, most of the developers, everyone who was angry at Bitcoin for not doing something, they went to Ethereum.

1:02:23Corbin FraserI mean, DeFi Summer on Ethereum was the... That was like the funnest time I'd had since the scaling wars, to be honest. Like I loved all of the chaos that was emerging out of Ethereum. And it was like, high risk. Like you had to be kind of stupid to have money deployed on some of these very untested, unaudited smart contracts and DEXs and different lending, borrowing protocols and stuff like that. But it was an exciting time. And I think when you get that many builders contributing to this idea, and then there is this mix of greed, right?

1:03:00And there's the mix of scams. And there's the mix of like, hey, we could actually create a better financial system on chain. That's all open 24/7, that lets people trade, that lets people fund markets and do market making, which is typically reserved for, like, the elite, the wealthy, the... It tickles all the right middle fingers that we like to give to the status quo. But it's like, especially in those early days, it was high risk, right? There was all these silly, like, food coins coming out. Like, Sushi happened, and then Chef Nomi rugged, which was weird.

1:03:40I don't know if you guys followed that one much, but there was this prolific developer, anon, that came onto the scene during DeFi Summer. This is after YAM and after I think it was, there's a few other, like, maybe yearn was around that time as well. And then Sushi came out and had this like really great user experience for swapping and like funding LPs. And then it was trying to cannibalize all of the market from Uniswap, which Uniswap at the time didn't have a token things were a little bit clunky and there was like no rewards. They didn't have a token.

1:04:23So like they weren't able to kind of incentivize people to do LP to like fund markets on, like, an Ethereum/USDT pool, to support more on-chain transactions on these decentralized exchanges. So then Sushi came out. They had a really cool user interface and they had LPs just like Uniswap, but then they also had rewards. Everyone likes rewards, right? Like it's like, hey, you do some stuff, you get some stuff.

1:04:52And it was kind of a mad dash to just clean house. So you had all of these like high net worth individuals just moving money in solely to capture as much of these tokens because there was the hope that these tokens would go up in value. And for a while, I'm sure some of them did. I'm sure this was kind of like an opportunity for them. They were calling it the vampire liquidity attack. And the idea was like, yeah, we're going to attack Uniswap by just juicing the LP rewards to siphon off as many of their LPs over to us where we can pay them more with our token.

1:05:26And yeah. And then I think at some point, Chef Nomi, who was this anon, just rug pulled, basically, and, like, token price crashed. Yeah. And then there was, like, a lot of speculation on who that may or may not be. Some weird theories went from being like, it was someone in... there was a theory that there was kind of a DeFi group that was just running multiple versions of these. And that person may have been involved in more than one.

1:06:04There was a theory that Chef Nomi could have been Sam Bankman-Fried and people from the FTX camp, which I always thought was an interesting theory. And I think there was a lot of people trying to compare the messages and the format and the tweets and be like, there's some similarities here. Look at the way they use the periods. But yeah, I don't know if they ever proved that. But it would be interesting enough who actually was Chef Nomi, because I think he made out pretty good.

1:06:34And then Sushi crashed and then it went back up. Eventually, the community kind of managed to save it. And then more of these DEXs kept popping up and more of these different tokens. And then you had, like, more... Aave was out at this time, so you could lend and borrow. Compound was out at this point as well, which is another lending borrowing pool. And it was like, Yeah, we're building... I think they were kind of building, like, a parallel financial ecosystem that, like, emulated the traditional financial ecosystem, but 24/7 and on chain and using these smart contracts. And early on, people were like, this thing's never going to work.

1:07:18You know, it's never going to get that much adoption. TVL is going to be a few million. Not many people are going to use it. But then market makers started moving in and you had bots moving in and you had people building arb bots between different LPs, so that you'd have, like, an Ethereum/USDT pool on, like, Uniswap and then an Ethereum/USDT pool on Sushi, and then another one on, like, PancakeSwap or some other thing. And then you'd have the arb bots just, like, trying to gobble up price disparity and making sure that they're making money. It was really interesting to see.

1:07:50And again, all of that stuff could have been on Bitcoin. It could have been on Bitcoin. And I think what's interesting is the BCH people, for better or worse, they're still trying, you know? And I feel like this is kind of where I like that they take a tech progressivism approach... progressivism, I don't mean that in a political way, but, like, just... they're just trying, you know, they're just seeing what they can do, see how far they can push the envelope.

1:08:16I think in some ways, though, I understand why Bitcoin would not want to take that approach because of... I mean, you want to keep your top spot, right? There's this, like, game theory of, well, when you're at the top, you don't have to take the risks that people below you have to in order to try to climb. So, yeah.

1:08:39Vlad CosteaI do like this perspective that this could have been on Bitcoin because it's being presented by both sides. The ones that are wishing that this happened on Bitcoin and the ones like Jimmy Song or whatever, who think that there are unorthodox use cases and wrong ways of using a blockchain. You know, they say, oh, this is sacred. This is holy. We should thank God for Bitcoin. We should worship this invention. If Satoshi did not use this in this way, then it's clearly not the intended way. And it's really funny when it comes to this.

1:09:17But I gotta ask about eCash, because at one point there was this conversation within the BCH community that there should be some sort of dev tax for the developers to get paid. And there was also, I think Amaury fell in love with this Avalanche protocol and he wanted to implement it, and for some reason he forked off from BCH, he created his own coin again. It was his second rebel moment. And now we have split communities, I guess. Some people from BCH went to eCash. I'm not sure how many of them, but he seems to have built his own little cult.

1:09:58Corbin FraserYep. Yeah, I mean...

1:10:03Vlad CosteaCan you argue that Amaury sort of created BCH and then he destroyed it with his hard fork?

1:10:12Corbin FraserNo, because I think it was more of a hostile takeover than it was a middle finger. I think this was kind of, I think there was enough people in the BCH community that just wanted the Frenchman out. He became kind of a Donald Trump figure within the BCH community where it was like, nah, Frenchman bad. Amaury's a dick. Gotta get rid of the dick. Toxic. And it was kind of like... I think this was also during a period where price wasn't doing great either, right?

1:10:42So you had probably... you know, contributors that just didn't have a lot of money. And it's like, hey, we just... we want to keep this thing alive in the bear, and multiple bears, there needs to be some funding in place. And yeah, I think the approach, I think there was a lot of weird things that happened around that dev tax as well. 'Cause there was people that were for it, and then they pulled their support for it. And then there's a lot of people kind of using a lot of the libertarian tropes of taxes.

1:11:12All tax is bad. This is a bad tax. We don't need tax. And it's a slippery slope. You put a little tax in, they're going to take more and more. Granted, I think they actually did increase the tax on eCash eventually. So maybe they were right. Yeah, it was kind of one of these things where I think Amaury did have a lot of say and sway in the BCH community, but there was a lot of people that stood to benefit by not having him involved as much, where I think they felt like they could probably move faster, because in some ways Amaury was like... not... how do I explain this?

1:11:51As far as I could tell. And I have nothing but respect for Amaury and what he did and the work that he contributed. And I think he's probably one of the more interesting big blockers in the whole space. So like, I think what he says still matters. I follow him a lot on X still. But I think there was a lot of people that like stood to benefit from just being able to get their changes in quicker without Amaury stopping. Like, he was the benevolent dictator, and this is like a self-professed thing that he called himself.

1:12:25And in a lot of ways, I think that was needed. Like, I think we see this inside Bitcoin.com. Any new feature, any new project, any new thing that we build is led typically by one champion, not a group, not a team. You can't design by committee. You know, things typically need a champion. And Amaury was the big blocker champion. And yeah, I think there was enough of a committee that wanted more, but wanted a different... wanted something different, that kind of he was getting in the way.

1:13:01And then it seemed to me like, kind of like, let's just get rid of the French guy, push him out. You know, we're going to get rid of this pesky, pesky benevolent dictator and try something else. And yeah, I think he just didn't get the support from, whether it was the miners or the businesses or the community. I think he'd kind of like burned some bridges by, you know, being French, if I can put it bluntly. You know, he's just a... occasionally thorny. But he had a big heart and still has a big heart. I think he, like... he's probably done more for the big block community than anyone else.

1:13:44I don't want to disparage him in any way, but yeah, I think eCash kind of emerged from that as far as I remember. And that was actually the big... at least for me, that was like the pin where I was like, ah, BCH, what have you done?

1:14:02Because there was this... who was it? It was one of the OGs on the Bitcoin Core developers thing, theorized that if too many forks happened it would just splinter off into like you know a thousand pieces and like you'd have forks upon forks on forks and I think that was kind of like after the BSV fork happened, I was like, oh, man, just lost some more mindshare. And then eCash fork happened. It was just like, all right. Maybe he was right. Maybe he was right all along.

1:14:43I'm going to think of the name, but it'll come to me. But I think for me, that was kind of where I started saying, okay, well... And in some ways, I have Amaury to thank because I got more involved in Ethereum and EVM and DeFi Summer because of all of the drama involved with that. I was just like, I'm just done with drama. I'm just done with debates and, you know, who's better and who's... you know, the arguing. What I loved about the Ethereum and EVM communities, they were just building.

1:15:14And there were still debates and stuff like that, but it wasn't so hostile. It didn't seem like... like, people were just permissionlessly building and not feeling like they had to negotiate with the subreddit and negotiate with the community. They would just launch stuff. They would deploy smart contracts, send out a message and say, hey, anyone want to try this thing? It's, you know, unaudited. Do your own research. Good luck. But I kind of liked that permissionless building aspect of what they were doing.

1:15:47And yeah, I wouldn't have probably become DeFi-pilled had it not been for more of those big block debates that just kept going, man. They just kept going. And I think for... oh, I know countless people that... that was kind of the breaking point for folks to say... they're just... there's more to crypto than having one team and being a monotheist. And nothing wrong with being diversified. You kind of can be involved in more communities. You can have your finger on the pulse of more things and you don't miss out on opportunities. And yeah.

1:16:25Like, I think I'm not so bold in my bag holding ability to say, oh, the things that I hold are going to be absolutely the things that are going to be popular, relevant, and most useful five years from now or 10 years from now. Like even Bitcoin, I'm of the belief that it... is it at the top now? Will it be in 50 years? I don't know. I mean, security budget. Will something cooler come along? Will there be other issues with BTC that other chains solve because they were perhaps more quick or more able to adapt?

1:17:05Or who knows? I think, like, you look at MySpace, they probably thought they had it in the bag, right? "We're the world's biggest social media platform," until you're not.

1:17:19Vlad CosteaYeah, there's a lot to unpack there. First of all, I would never see this in the Amaury that I interviewed last year. Like, he did not seem toxic at all. He seemed very nice, soft-spoken, educated and able to make very compelling arguments about stuff and very wise in retrospect, you know, talking about past events. But I don't see this guy going, as you said, full Donald Trump on r/BTC or whatever.

1:17:50Corbin FraserYeah, I don't think he actually went full Donald Trump, but I think the perception from the community was that he did, if that makes sense.

1:18:00Vlad CosteaThat's fair, especially in writing where people can misinterpret tone. And you spoke of revenge chains and Ethereum is the revenge chain for Bitcoiners. A lot of big blockers went to Ethereum to build stuff just because it was fun and because nobody told them not to do it, because they could do more stuff that was not possible on Bitcoin. And some of the same energy, I see it today in something that you just added to the Bitcoin.com wallet, which is Zano. I see a lot of big blockers looking at this and saying, you know, this is our chance to be early into something, you know, to have our own thing, to have something which is like Monero, but for assets.

1:18:45It's like the Ethereum of privacy coins. And I see a lot of big blockers agreeing that this might be a successful chain.

1:18:57Corbin FraserI think the majority of big blockers have become multi-coiners over the past... since 2017, right? I think they've just had to, in terms of maintaining some level of, I don't know, diversification. Like you don't want to be exposed to just one single asset or one single alt. Let's put it that way. Some people might only be, like, a single asset person for BTC. That's probably done them pretty well. Had they just not done anything, they might have weathered all of the storms a little bit better than folks who kind of went down these different warpaths and tried more things and lost money on Luna or, you know, silly FTX issues and all the other stuff.

1:19:49But yeah, I think, like, Bitcoin Cash people tend to be a little bit more, I think, on high openness or higher in openness, because they're more open to changes. I think this is just like something you saw on the progressivism that you see in terms of like them adding and changing the protocol regularly. And they're not afraid to kind of try things. Perhaps they're the wrong things, but, you know, build it first and then make it good later. It's one philosophy to live by, and it's one way to kind of try and fail fast and maybe make some improvements.

1:20:27So yeah, I think them taking a bigger interest in another form of peer-to-peer cash... Bitcoin Cash was kind of the main one, continued banging that drum in terms of like, let's make this thing useful for as many people around the world, rich or poor. If you make less than a dollar a day, you can still use Bitcoin Cash. If you want to buy a coffee or a drink, a cookie from the bake sale, you can do it with Bitcoin Cash.

1:20:57But I think there's probably a lot of people that... well, there's some flaws still in public blockchains, which is like if I am spending, you know, $10 on, I don't know, diapers or whatever, you kind of don't want the merchant to know your entire transaction history or be able to hunt you down and say, oh, this guy buying diapers is 10 grand on him. Let's go hit him with a wrench. Take his money. So I think, like, the privacy aspect of Zano gets people... like, it solves the problem. And yeah, it seems like they're building out tokens as well. So you can have privacy. You can have protocol level privacy on your token assets.

1:21:40And then we've been talking to the team behind Confidential Layer recently, and exploring that in terms of, like, is there a way to do a trustless bridge for Bitcoin and other assets to give them privacy through Zano? Which maybe it's not as graceful as, like, L1 privacy or, you know, having that baked into the Bitcoin protocol, but scratches an itch, gives people some ability and confidence that they're perhaps less prone to attacks.

1:22:16I think in this day and age, Jameson Lopp does a great job maintaining that GitHub repo of just all of those public... or all of those news articles on different people that have been attacked, assaulted, kidnapped, held hostage related to their crypto holdings. I think especially in countries where your dollar goes a long way or your Bitcoin goes a long way or your Ethereum or stablecoin goes a long way, doesn't take much. Like, you know, desperate people will do desperate things.

1:22:58And yeah, not making silly mistakes like showing your crypto balances, or using chains and then completely deanonymizing yourself to your merchant, who might have a cousin who needs some cash and he's willing to do anything for it. And robbing a bank is hard.

1:23:20Hitting a guy over the head with a wrench, maybe easier. So privacy to me kind of makes sense from like a just operational security standpoint, but also just from a... nobody in their right mind would be like, hey, here's my public bank account. Anyone want access to the CSV of what I've been spending my money on, where I shop, what I do? Same with businesses. Like, nobody wants their business... you know, like, you don't want to... you typically want to protect some trade secrets, right?

1:23:52You don't want to show who you're paying, who's your provider, who's in... just, like, having a base level of privacy is good and that, you know, I think this is kind of an unfortunate part of, like, crypto. There's still these... it's not even just, you know, assaults and stuff like that, but you got like governments going after people that are just writing code, you know, Samourai devs, Wasabi guys, Tornado Cash. Like, anyone that was providing some of this were kind of being, especially under the Biden administration, it seems like, targeted specifically, to say, like, hey, we're not going to allow that.

1:24:35So don't do that or you'll go to jail, or we'll slap you with some giant... I think the Tornado Cash ones are the most interesting because they... I believe they charged them with the money laundering that was done using the protocol, but it wasn't done by the developers. So the fact that they enabled it, the fact that they created the code for it, deployed it on Solidity on a few chains, and then any idiot can go and, you know, put some money in, pull some money out, and it's untraceable. All of that gets attributed to them, it's weird.

1:25:17And I mean, in my head, all of that whole anti-crypto stuff that we were seeing over the last four years really seems to have been led by the active government and administration in the US. And I think they just have such a long arm when it comes to pushing that in other countries. So it's a wonder that the Zano people are still fighting for it and I'm happy they are.

1:25:48They've got this interesting proof of work, proof of stake hybrid consensus thing, which I don't fully understand. It seems to work. So, I mean, for folks that are looking for that, it's a great opportunity to try it out. You can go grab the Bitcoin.com wallet and go swap into some Zano right now. You can swap back into any other asset as well if you don't actually want to hold the Zano.

1:26:17Yeah, it's an interesting use case for crypto. And I think it's something that they talked about so often in the early days, but now it's sort of just taken a bit of a backseat for digital gold and getting the government to buy our bags and, you know, supporting more strategic Bitcoin reserves, which... it's interesting that it's all happening so quick. But yeah, there is something kind of... the fact that the code exists, the fact that we have the technology to offer this privacy, but we don't, and it's not baked in to more protocols... sus, right? It's sus. It's weird.

1:26:58Vlad CosteaYeah, it seems like we got fact-checked by the Bitcoin Cash Podcast guy. He says...

1:27:05Corbin FraserYou should have him on, actually. He's great. Jeremy, Jeremy's great.

1:27:08Vlad CosteaSatoshi did in fact predict mining pools, which he called server farms. "It was part of the design implicitly." I sort of disagree here, because it was also Satoshi who emailed Laszlo and told him, "Hey, could you please stop with your GPUs? I want everyone to mine with their CPU." Maybe he saw this coming, but at the same time, he did not want it and had no idea how to solve this without becoming this sort of dictator who tells everyone, OK, from now on, you can only mine with your CPU. And this was before Monero.

1:27:44Corbin FraserYeah. Kind of the same thing with, like, them telling Wikipedia, don't do this yet. Or was it Wikipedia? No, it was WikiLeaks. WikiLeaks, yeah. Being like, "No, no, no, no, let's not rush it yet, guys. We're pretty small here." So, yeah.

1:28:00Vlad CosteaAnd he also says the same Bitcoin Cash podcast account says, "BCH has a one-year upgrade schedule since 2020, post-XEC. Huge efforts have been made to minimize upgrade inconvenience each time." I guess this was... this comment was posted in regards to your statement that every six months there is a hard fork.

1:28:23Corbin FraserI think it used to be six months and then I think they did scale it back to a year, which was, yeah, that's... still nice. Still annoying, but still nice. Nicer than six.

1:28:32Vlad CosteaI remember nine months ago or something, I was part of a Twitter Spaces call, which was, I guess, one of the first moments when BTC developers wanted to talk with BCH developers and try to learn from each other. Share some lessons, tell to each other, okay, we've done this and you're doing this, especially now that BTC is trying to add some opcodes that were removed, like OP_CAT, or something that is entirely new, like CTV. And BCH already has that. And something else that BCH has, and maybe we forgot to mention in this episode, is called CashFusion, which is a form of CoinJoin.

1:29:14And it's supposed to offer some of that privacy, even though it's not perfect, because it doesn't hide amounts. It just obfuscates the origin of the fund. So it solves part of the sender privacy problem, but it doesn't solve the amounts privacy problem. But my point is that technically there are more differences than this one has a small block size and this one has a larger block size in times of high demand. So there is a bit more to this story than just block size.

1:29:49Corbin FraserYeah. Was it Mike Hearn? I think it was Mike Hearn. Yeah. I think he was the one that predicted that the Bitcoin, if these forks were to happen, that it would decay. I think he was the one that I was trying to remember the name of. But yeah, "He left Google in 2014 to focus on Bitcoin full-time, but quit the project in 2016, famously declaring that it's a failed experiment."

1:30:16Vlad CosteaI remember that because I wanted to buy Bitcoin at the time. And when I saw his statement in the Wall Street Journal or something, I was like, I'm so happy I didn't buy it. I was so smart to wait because look, it's a failed project. So why bother? And then the next year it came back to $1,000 and I got slapped in the face.

1:30:39Corbin FraserYeah, that whiplash. It hurts, man. Still hurts.

1:30:43Vlad CosteaIt still hurts because it's one of these moments when you realize that, on one hand, you're being misled by mainstream media.

1:30:54And they're telling you the stories that maybe their financiers or whatever want you to hear. But on the other hand, mainstream media will never make you rich. So if you follow the news on CNN or whatever, and that's your main source of news. And you believe that if you follow this news, you're going to be able to time the markets or whatever and get rich. You're way behind. By the time, you know, there's this sell the news event that happens. By the time you see it on TV that something went up, big players are going to be selling.

1:31:27So unless you're opening short positions or something and you're good at this and you know how to manage it, you're late.

1:31:36Corbin FraserYeah, there is something to be said about just the dollar cost averaging. You know, set it and forget it. It's kind of nice. It's nice to be able to do.

1:31:47Vlad CosteaI also want to get into more Bitcoin.com stuff, but before that, let me plug two more sponsors. One of them is Hodling.ch, which is based in Switzerland, and they're offering self-custody solutions for people who don't know how to set up their own self-custody because maybe they have a lot of Bitcoin and they don't want to keep their keys inside of the house. And it's a bit frightening in the event of a $5 wrench attack. So you go to these guys and they're going to help you set up a multisig or set up multiple hardware wallets or something that fits your use case because every individual or every company has different needs.

1:32:26And I guess they mostly work with companies that are acquiring Bitcoin and they don't want the CEO or the CTO to be able to access the coins and spend them whenever they want. So they set up this quorum and yeah, that's one of the use cases. And last but not least, there is NoOnes, which has grown from this peer-to-peer marketplace for gift cards, which is the primary use case for it. And now they also have a Visa debit card for spending your coins. They also have this centralized spot market where you can trade.

1:32:59And it's very popular in Nigeria and a lot of these African countries. CEO Ray Youssef says that he's trying to empower the global south. And if you want to be part of this movement where, as CEO Ray Youssef says, everyone eats because there is a fee that every middleman is able to get along the way, then check out NoOnes.com. It's a pretty cool peer-to-peer marketplace, which is also ideologically driven. And now let's talk about Bitcoin.com because it underwent a lot of changes. First of all, I want to ask you who owns it these days. You're the CEO, but are you also the owner of the domain?

1:33:40Corbin FraserI own 0% of Bitcoin.com. No, it's all Roger. Roger's the Godfather, right? Free Roger. If you guys... I feel like... maybe I should speak to... I've been watching your stuff forever, and it's great. And I think you are able to cut through both camps, in the sense that, like, there's the small blockers, the big blockers...

1:34:08Vlad CosteaI don't see camps.

1:34:10Corbin FraserHonestly, I think the camps are kind of over at this point. It's sort of just like... yeah, communities, let's say. But yeah, Roger is honestly one of the kindest guys I've met. I got an email from him to come work for him back in 2016, 2017. Somewhere around... it would have been 2016, 2017. Yeah. I think it would have been around November, maybe October. And yeah, like, he was not, you know, like the hostile... like, monster that I think the Bitcoin maximalists want him to be. It's just not who he is. Like he genuinely does care about the economic freedom of the world. That is his like life's mission.

1:34:57And when people are taking jabs at him for, yeah, throwing the middle fingers up at people when he cares a lot about certain things or when he's, you know, just talking about the things that he cares the most about and then kind of talking him down as if he's like not a contributor to this whole ecosystem, like crypto in general or Bitcoin in general. Bitcoin wouldn't be where it is today without this guy. I've seen him onboard more people to Bitcoin and crypto and Bitcoin Cash than anyone else in the world. Like, nobody's done more.

1:35:37Like, at Bitcoin.com, we've got, I think, over 56, 57 million wallets across our whole ecosystem. And the large majority of those are Bitcoin. Yeah, some of them for sure are Bitcoin Cash, some of them for sure are Ethereum, but what people come to Bitcoin.com and get is Bitcoin, first and foremost. You know, like, the companies that he runs, the investments that he's made early on, have made him the prolific person, but also made him a person to attack. So I think, like, if you've taken the anti-Roger pill from X to say, oh, this guy's just the creator of BCH, which he's not.

1:36:21Like I said, he, I was in on BCH before he was. So, you know the guy just wants to see decentralized peer-to-peer cash for the world. And I don't think he really cares what flavor that is. I think he just wants to see challengers and support challengers and like create a more fair world where it's not just big bankers, corrupt government.

1:36:48He's like... he's the OG guy who's, like, talking about some of the injustices of governments. And I don't have too many great things to say about Canada. I don't really want to comment too much on the US, since I'm not an American. But yeah, he's been at the heart of these debates and these discussions since the early days.

1:37:11So I kind of feel like the people that give him a hard time in the Orange coin camp still, or the Orange coin community, yeah, I think they kind of got to, like, maybe try to drink some water, you know, desalinate their bodies and kind of just realize that this guy probably did more for Bitcoin than every single one of us. So if that's not worth a little bit of support for him, I don't know what is. So I strongly encourage everyone, if you do support Roger, do support what he's done for the whole space. Go to freerogernow.org. Help this guy get free.

1:37:52He doesn't deserve to be extradited. There's a lot of chaos and weird lawfare behind his case that make me say that there's, like, that anti-crypto administration that went after Samourai and Wasabi and Tornado and Ian Freeman and all these other guys that were just trying to build businesses, and, like, they're just builders on Bitcoin and crypto. Roger got... he was caught up in that. The government doesn't want this or the government didn't want this to succeed now that they've got a position in it. It's like, well, maybe the strategic Bitcoin Reserve... they're probably not, you know, they're not opposed to buying a bunch or finding a way to accumulate more.

1:38:37And then hopefully China buys their bags and then other countries buy their bags. And it just becomes this weird game theory. You know, I think it's not going to be seen as, like, the US, as being incredibly supportive of Bitcoin building and crypto building until some of these guys are let out or freed or had their cases dropped or whatever it takes. Because it's like, if you're a builder and you're like, all right, where could I go? Where could I go to go build on Bitcoin and crypto?

1:39:09I don't think anyone's signing up yet to go to the US, probably going to Dubai, probably going to Singapore, probably going to Japan, going to places where there's like clear rules and consistent, like over a longer period of time where things have been kind of predictable. People, like, if you're building stuff and you're building a business and putting your time and effort and sweat equity and money and, you know, moving your families, you're probably going to want to do that in a place where you're not going to risk, I don't know, the long dick of the law coming after you, right?

1:39:44Vlad CosteaOn the topic of freeing Roger, go to freerogernow.org and read the motion to dismiss because most of the stuff that you might read on Twitter about him or some of the stuff that you hear from your government is covered here. And you should read this. You have all the documents, all the evidence. This is basically the way in which he defends himself. So if you want to understand all the points of view, I guess you already know the points of view of the US government and the IRS.

1:40:16But you should read this too. And after that, if you're compelled by the documents and the arguments being presented, there are 14 of them, 14 exhibits, then sign the petition. I don't encourage people to blindly do anything based on some sort of affinity or affiliation, think for yourselves and read this first. And I just got the most funny comment ever on Twitter about Roger. There's this guy named John. He's @PacArtCollect on Twitter. And he said, Roger sold out on Bitcoin. What the fuck? Roger sold out on Bitcoin. He's angry because he's a BSV supporter. Just let this sink in for a moment. Roger sold out on Bitcoin.

1:41:12Corbin FraserIs that because the Bitcoin SV people still call Bitcoin SV Bitcoin?

1:41:19Vlad CosteaI guess. No, no. I think the meaning is that he or am I misinterpreting this? Sold out on Bitcoin for me means that he chose Bitcoin. Sold out on. Or does it mean that he gave up on something? But he was never on the BSV camp, so no. Makes no sense.

1:41:43Corbin FraserSo when you had Roger on, you were kind of asking him about, you know, would he ever support some of these other L2s? And I think you guys had maybe discussed briefly. Maybe it was Rootstock and some of these other things. You know, I brought that stuff up to Roger before as well, and I think he's kind of a, at least, the read I got was like, open to anything. He's not a maximalist in any camp anymore. I think for a period, for sure, it was just BCH only.

1:42:15But I think he's kind of become a little bit more... you know he's evolved he's evolved like all of us you know I was for sure a BCH maxi for a little while and then I stopped being that and yeah. People change. I think, I don't think anyone sold out on anything. You live and learn, right?

1:42:40Vlad CosteaI think the market is sort of the best mechanism for humbling anyone. It doesn't matter how big you are. It doesn't matter how right you are many consecutive times, at one point you're gonna lose. You're going to learn. And it doesn't matter if you're Bitcoin only either for BTC only, you're going to be wrong at one point, just like how long has it been? Four years ago, I was very convinced that Bitcoin is going to go to $100,000 during the bull market. I remember I was so excited about Tesla accepting Bitcoin.

1:43:17I was so high on the hopium. I was thinking okay. This is it. This is the moment we're gonna go to 100 K and then Elon with just one tweet brought like a four months bear market and until it came back again. It was insane. And he was pushing Dogecoin at the time. It's still crazy to me that Dogecoin is merge-mined with Litecoin, and Litecoin saved Dogecoin. And right now, Litecoin, which is being used much more in commerce is... less popular on markets than Dogecoin. Still after all this time. It's really incredible. It's as Elon says, I guess, that the most likely outcome is the most entertaining.

1:44:04Corbin FraserWe would regularly have these Elon bumps to Bitcoin.com whenever he was doing those tweets. Yeah, like, okay, you know, just, you know, DDoSed products or website would just get hit with a ton of traffic during those periods. And it was like, yeah, this Elon effect of like, oh, why did we break new all-time highs on installs? Oh, yesterday Elon put a tweet out. Oh, OK. That makes sense. I'm sure. That's interesting. I mean, I think the shocking thing is that you've got someone like Donald Trump now talking about Bitcoin. And you've got the US government now and the administration talking about. Bitcoin.

1:44:44But it's like it doesn't seem to be moving the needle as much as the old Elon ones did. And I think there might that could be due to the market exhaustion. That could be due to just we're not at that point in the cycle yet. We're retail is excited. And I saw some tweet this morning of a poll that was shared on mainstream media. It was like a screenshot of someone's TV, something like "Would you be buying Bitcoin?" Or something like that.

1:45:17And it was like 84% were like, "No." And it was like maybe 14% were yes or something like that. Yeah, I mean, like, I think there's we're in a weird cycle this time relative to the previous ones where there was so much FOMO and so much excitement from like, the public. And we're sort of like still feeling the repercussions of the past relative to FTX drama, the Luna stuff, NFTs being a thing for a while and then not being a thing at all.

1:45:49And now it's kind of like rebuilding some trust with retail that like, hey, this stuff is, there's still like an underlying value to, what cryptocurrency projects are trying to build. Not all of them. There's, of course, bad actors and everything you know, what's happening is like, just kind of feel like there's not a we don't have Paris Hilton going on like Jimmy Fallon or whatever, being like, "I'm buying a monkey JPEG." You know, we haven't seen that. We haven't seen that part of the cycle yet. Will we again? I don't know.

1:46:25Maybe that was it. Right. Maybe that maybe now it's just like more serious but it could also be six months later, you've got... Kim Kardashian doing another crypto promo for some random altcoin or something like that or kanye's gonna launch a swastika meme coin or something like that, you know.

1:46:47Vlad CosteaI'm actually following Kanye West closely right now because I believe... This is just my personal belief. He keeps teasing that he's going to launch a coin. At one point, he circulated this press release and CoinDesk did not respect the embargo and they published that. Something about a coin and very specific details. And of course, it did not happen. I'm not sure if this was just a publicity stunt or it was stalled by the fact that the embargo was not respected and it became public.

1:47:21But my point is that I believe that Kanye is trading on Polymarket, because there is a market for him that specifically asks the question "Do you think Kanye West is gonna launch a meme coin?" And there are moments when he posts about it and a lot of people buy yes shares and then he ignores it for like two or three weeks and doesn't mention anything about it. And that's when it goes down. And he could be gaming this. I mean, it's so easy.

1:47:50Corbin FraserI like the idea of Kanye being in the trenches on Polymarket, trading on sentiment. I find that kind of funny. I hope I hope he is.

1:48:02Vlad CosteaI also believe that Kanye is not as stupid as he pretends to be. He used to walk around wearing Satoshi Nakamoto hats. And now he acts like, oh, what's Bitcoin? I don't know. I have no idea about this. How does it work? Okay, how about I launch my own meme coin? I think now his narrative is that he got deplatformed by Shopify and he's trying to create his own coin to use that to purchase stuff on Yeezy.com. I'm not sure how that's gonna work out. I feel like we're going back to 2017, when there was Dentacoin and people were creating a token

1:48:43Corbin FraserYeah, exactly.

1:48:43Vlad CosteaThere was a chain or a coin for everything that you could possibly imagine.

1:48:53Corbin FraserYeah, I don't necessarily...

1:48:54Vlad CosteaThere's already a Kanye West meme coin that's called Coinye West.

1:49:00Corbin FraserCoinye. Yeah, I think the meme coin... I don't know. It does kind of feel like at least in the last month that the meme coin meta has sort of devolved maybe like interest is kind of like waned a lot from just like a few months ago where everyone was FOMOing into Fartcoin and everything. And now everyone's like, oh, after like the Milei drama with... What was that? Libra? And then... Yeah, there was the Trump coin that did pretty well and then not so well. And then Melania.

1:49:31Vlad CosteaI actually blame Trump for this because he brought nihilism into the market. Before that, it was super optimistic and positive and it seemed like the best possible timeline. And then he brought his meme coin, which went into the top 20 CoinMarketCap ranking in one day for only trading on one market which was the DEX on Solana. And when you see that happening and you understand that it actually happened and this is top 20 now, you start asking questions like, wait a second, if this is top 20, then what about the others?

1:50:08Could you argue that they're overvalued a bit? Because this one was able to pull this off. Aren't the prices a bit too high on everything else? Can't the same phenomenon happen to any other coin? Where you get it propped into the top 20 just like that by a bunch of people. So yeah.

1:50:30Corbin FraserArthur Hayes was interviewed by our news team, Bitcoin.com News.

1:50:35Vlad CosteaI saw that.

1:50:39Corbin FraserYeah. And he talked a little bit about how he feels like a lot of crypto projects are just overvalued everything's overvalued and that his belief is sort of like, things need to come down to actually get more investors back in because like nobody wants to buy the top. And, you know, when you look at kind of, the on-chain treasuries of some of these different projects. Like, do they justify the price that they're currently trading at?

1:51:05Or are you just buying the VCs bags you know the early investor bags and I Yeah, it's kind of an interesting-- you go through that CoinMarketCap list or the CoinGecko list or whatever yeah there's a lot of stuff in that top 100 that kind of does occasionally make my head go tilty and wonder what... okay. Yeah, but the markets, like you said, you know, they can humble you.

1:51:34Vlad CosteaWhat would you say is your main takeaway from the block size wars? And if you could go back, you mentioned something about pushing bigger blocks in 2015. But if you could go back in 2017, at that one point, do you believe there was something that could be done to prevent a hard fork. And I don't mean hard fork in the sense of an upgrade. I mean, this split between communities.

1:52:00Corbin FraserI think a modest two megabyte increase would have deflated the potential for chaos by a huge order of magnitude. I think it would have-- made BCH an unviable contender from day one.

1:52:16Vlad CosteaDo you think there was any sort of malevolence at the time? Because the New York Agreement was vilified so badly for like a couple of years after. And people signing it were presented as enemies of Bitcoin or something.

1:52:37Corbin FraserSo... I think there's like some people that do feel that there were state actors involved either at that time, before that time, or after that time. I don't know if I don't have any real proof or anything like that. Besides maybe it would make sense. If I saw this challenging asset coming in, what would I do to create the most chaos to reduce its impact or reduce its ability to succeed a lot of the things that they did, I would say, hurt Bitcoin's overall network effect.

1:53:17Yeah, I mean, if you pull on that string or wear the tinfoil hat tight enough, you might say, yeah, it's perfect. Seems fair. Seems like a possible thing. But I think there was a lot of like the road to hell being paved with good intentions. I think there was a little bit of that as well. Like people just were trying to do the right thing. They thought they were doing the right thing. They were maybe not getting enough feedback from the right people or from their circles or they were in their bubbles and you know? Kind of it's probably a mix of both.

1:53:45Or it's just the latter. I don't know. I think there's a lot of A lot of special interests that don't want Bitcoin to succeed even now even with the administration even with strategic Bitcoin reserves, there's groups that don't want Bitcoin to be a thing. You know, you see this with, the IMF deal with El Salvador, you know, trying to like encourage them to say, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, we'll give you this juicy deal, billy dollar loan, or whatever it is but you guys gotta stop doing some Bitcoin stuff. Gotta cool your jets there. Bukele. And...

1:54:25Vlad CosteaDoesn't it make you wonder? From the point of view of a big blocker, how does it feel to see that Blockstream did not succeed in pretty much anything? Their sidechain is a failure. Their Lightning client is a minority client. Very few services use it. Their mining operation, they try to... I think that's the only profitable project. Their wallet is not very popular. Their hardware wallet is not very popular. They tried on purpose to make Liquid very compliant and in line with regulations and they said you can do tokens just like on Ethereum, but with privacy. It did not work out, because it turns out Wall Street, or whoever they were shilling Liquid to, also like something that's not very regulated and is more free and gives them more freedom to build stuff. So does it feel good to see that Blockstream, on one hand, they seem to have won the block size wars, but they lost from a business point of view on every front?

1:55:27Corbin FraserYeah. I mean, my initial one-word reply was joy. But, Yeah, I mean, like... I think the people involved in Blockstream, there's probably some really hardworking developers that want to make this thing work. But I've seen this in Bitcoin.com too. We've had developers start something and... They're just building for the sake of building. You know, there's momentum that's put behind a project. And there's lines of code that have already been written, and it's easier to just try to solve these little quirks and problems rather than go back to the whiteboard and say, maybe we should try something else. And you kind of get this like, pot commitment for these ideas. So. On the one hand, I...

1:56:27Yeah, there's a little bit of what is it, schadenfreude? But then there's also like I would hope that some of those builders that are trying still will come see the light and say, let's try something else. Like, I want more building on Bitcoin. I want more building on crypto. I want to see more people trying things that do support using Bitcoin as a peer-to-peer cash system. Whether that's L1 or L2 or some other thing. I do think the permissionless aspect is kind of critical for this thing to succeed.

1:57:10I do believe in self-custody first. I you know, and I think like certain compromises may need to be made in the short term, which I think maybe it seems like that's sort of the small blocker camp position where it always struck me as really strange that when the big blockers would say, "Well, you can use it for money." They'd be like, "No, no, no. Well, you can use Bitcoin as money, too. Just you have to use this Lightning app and it's completely..." You know, just try it, guys.

1:57:40It's totally fine. And then, kind of read the fine print and it's like, oh, this is a custodial wallet. Okay, I mean, technically, I guess it works until it doesn't right and or until the funds aren't there, or until you're your channel is censored which we've seen. So, yeah.

1:58:03It's strange. But yeah, weird. Joy, but I hope that some of the people that are actually building those tools will continue to find success in new tools that they perhaps want to build that are more useful or don't have some of these flaws that I think are going to prevent them from being successful and so far have prevented them from being successful. I think there's infinite upside in the things that we can build as a human race on-chain. I think there's like I'm like a tech optimist in that sense. But... Yeah, I think like there are paths that you can just say, hey, that didn't work, try something else.

1:58:47Vlad CosteaFrom the point of view of someone who remembers Bitcoin being used on Expedia, on Steam, on all of these services back in the day before it was two Bitcoin camps, how does it feel to watch Tether and stablecoins in general do what Bitcoin was supposed to do in terms of adoption? You see all of these nations, all of the unbanked. People who don't have access to bank accounts, they use stablecoins. And to me, it's a bit painful. It feels like we sort of got defeated because they use a proxy for the US dollar, a substitute for it, basically that is valued as much as a US dollar and is being traded on these permissionless networks. It used to be Bitcoin too where Tether was launched. But it's not BTC that got this adoption, at least not yet. Does it feel like we failed in some way?

1:59:51Corbin FraserOn the one hand, I feel like I feel like stablecoins have added a lot of value to Bitcoin that probably wouldn't be there without it like being able to enter and exit the volatile aspect of it has probably saved a lot of people in those periods of uncertainty. So in some ways, thank you to Tether. Thank you to Circle. They're helping people. But I do think when you pull on the thread of like, has this weaned or neutered Bitcoin adoption and being for it to be used as money for the world?

2:00:30Perhaps, yeah. I think you could even... go a step further and say that, yeah, like stablecoins could be the Trojan horse for CBDCs, right? Like it's all on chain. It's all public maybe you don't necessarily have the ability to hone in and like censor an individual, but you can censor an address. You can censor you know, you've got blacklists on everything on tether. This is how they stop some of the major hacks and stuff like that.

2:01:07So yeah, it does make me kind of wonder if the stablecoins are actually the panopticon, or if they're a net benefit in the sense that any private fiat issued currency whether that's like the US dollar or the, you know, Eastern Caribbean dollar. They can all technically go on-chain and provide some value to their users, and maybe there's an easier on-ramp for individuals in different regions to come on board via stablecoins into the on-chain decentralized money? Of Bitcoin and Ethereum and Bitcoin Cash and Zano and any, anything else. So that's maybe a wishy-washy answer of like, maybe, maybe it could be, but...

2:01:57I don't know. I guess right now I am taking the information of where is Tether putting their profits, right? And they're putting their profits into well, more than just crypto, right? It seems like they're diversifying. So they're supporting... Rumble. So like, competitor to YouTube. YouTube is extremely censored platform. Content creators have a very difficult time saying anything that's even an iota too close to the edge. Rumble has scratch that itch for a lot of content creators. So that's maybe a net benefit for Humanity more competition in the in the content space, great.

2:02:42You know, we've seen their investments into like different payment services and things like that in El Salvador and making these like different AI plays as well. I don't know. It seems like they don't seem like they're doing evil if that makes sense. Will that always be the case? I don't know. Yeah.

2:03:04Vlad CosteaYeah, there are two points of view. There is the conspiracy stuff from journalists like Whitney Webb, who's very convinced that the Trump administration will not do a CBDC because they can control Tether. And that one is going to turn out to be the CBDC. And then you have optimists who say that Tether is basically like the Trojan horse that teaches people how to use a wallet, how to buy coins because they do need something to pay the gas fee. They need Ethereum or Tron or Solana or whatever.

2:03:38So it's interesting to see this, but I do hope that eventually it all comes back to the most decentralized and resilient technology. And I don't think we've had anything better than Bitcoin from this point of view. We've had faster stuff. We've had more private stuff, but with various trade-offs. I know we're about two hours into this interview and maybe you have other stuff to do, but I want to make this point towards the end of the episode. Whenever there was a talk about a block size increase in Bitcoin, it was controversial.

2:04:18Because technical arguments were brought. At first, it was about storage. They said, you know, it's expensive to store this. Then when storage became cheap, they said, well, bandwidth is still very expensive in some countries. And it's sensible at this point to maintain it at this level because, you know, it's hard to get internet in some village in Africa. And you tend to agree. You're like, okay, but then you get Starlink internet. And you realize, okay, you can now have internet in the middle of the desert at the speed of broadband.

2:04:52It's pretty good. It's reliable. Then you're going to get more competition for Starlink. The prices are going to be brought down. But what you really discover during this evolution of technology process is that it was never about technical arguments. It's most likely about social consensus. The fact that some people accept this and some people don't. And what Bitcoin BTC is trying is to keep everyone on one chain, even if they're not happy. And the alternative that they have is BCH, which unlocks some potential, but at the same time has lower liquidity and fewer users.

2:05:34And I still believe that BCH is sort of this blackmail chain. It's running because if anything goes wrong with BTC, it can take the miners, you know, it can become the dominant chain. It becomes more unlikely as time goes by. I think BCH is going to run into existential crisis as soon as more halving cycles happen, and the rewards are diminishing, so the price does need to go up for them to be able to keep the operations going. But it's interesting and it's open source, it's permissionless, it's cypherpunk.

2:06:14And I'm not mad that it's out there. There are people who are mad that BCH exists in the first place and that it survived over the years. I think this sort of competition between networks and the fact that you have alternatives and a backup plan or whatever is interesting.

2:06:34Corbin FraserYeah, like, I think... Do you know who George Hotz is?

2:06:40Vlad CosteaI don't think so. Let me look it up. How do you spell that, George?

2:06:47Corbin FraserGeorge, G...

2:06:48Vlad CosteaI know how to spell George.

2:06:50Corbin FraserYeah. Oh, H-O-T-Z. Hotz. George Hotz, or geohot. Yeah. He was like the first guy to hack the iPhone and he was like, the guy that got, side loaded apps were working on iPhones. And I think he was like, he's like a kid when he hacked the Sony PlayStation and, he started comma.ai, which was like a... an open source, DIY. Self-driving car tool that you could plug into your into certain cars and then let them drive, kind of like full self-driving mode on Teslas and stuff like that.

2:07:28You know, he's contributed to Twitter and contributed to... he just started tiny corp, which is like a build-your-own or I think it's like an LLM in a box company, but he's got a great timeline and he talks about like the professional management class and how he's just like, extremely opposed to like designed by committee and like these ideas of these people that just like slow progress to a halt, creating an environment where people are seeking permission instead of moving to just try things. And I think that's something that Bitcoin has kind of been invaded by it's like you've you've they've kind of got a bit of a professional management class within, if you're not in the circle, you're out.

2:08:20And if you can't get consensus, you end up like Paul Sztorc, who's just been beating this BIP 300 and BIP 301 for how many years now? We've been talking about Drivechain and yeah like the permissionless building of Ethereum was one of the coolest things I saw in a long time where it was just so fast and, people were deploying new code every day, new smart contracts, new products they were just launching. And they'd launch and some would fail and people lose money and some people would make money.

2:08:52It was chaos, but it was also like, fun. And it was also how you got to a point where we have you know, now Uniswap v4. You've got... lending borrowing tools on chain you've got perpetuals you've got bull tokens and bear tokens and you know, NFTs and... governance voting and the whole ecosystem has been built around the tools that were just launched on chain without anyone having to ask for permission. And I feel like that's probably... And-- I mean, Ethereum price.

2:09:29Oof not good right now but it does make me feel like the EVM aspect of it and the ability for anyone to just deploy code without having to convince the miners convince the developers, negotiate, meet with people, talk about it for eight months, and think about it debated again, gets pushed back another year, like that is probably the thing that could kill Bitcoin. It's just other projects being able and more willing to move faster. And yeah, I would hope that Bitcoin has a mechanism to support moving faster without the PMC without the need for consensus where you can just try and fail.

2:10:16And you might lose money and you might win money and you might create a community and it might all go to zero, but you need a place for an innovative layer to exist on Bitcoin and right now. Yeah, it's all happening off Bitcoin. So it's great that Bitcoin's available for anyone to buy, sell, swap, they can transfer it without permission. There's some aspects that are completely permissionless, and that's great. But for people that are trying to build. It's not as... supportive as other projects.

2:10:56Vlad CosteaIf I close my eyes and imagine that you have sort of this East Coast accent, I could believe that you are Paul Sztorc for a minute there, telling people about Drivechain.

2:11:11Corbin FraserYeah, he's a smart guy.

2:11:15Vlad CosteaHe is, and I think he's very much ahead of his time, even though people say, oh, you came up with this Drivechain 10 years ago. It's old. We have this new flashy L2 system. Yeah. It still doesn't solve the security budget problem. All of the ZK roll-up stuff. It's exciting. I do want it to happen because all of this stuff is bullish. It's good to have more users and more use cases. But ultimately, you need some sort of way to pay the miners and to keep the proof of work going.

2:11:51Corbin FraserYeah, I mean, I think that's been Ethereum's biggest problem with... their blobs is that they've they've made it so cheap for anyone to launch stuff on Ethereum. It's like they need to add some tariffs. It's the ironic part. They need a Donald Trump version of Vitalik slapping tariffs on every single L2 to support the value of Ethereum. Because right now, they're selling space at a discount. And then the L2s are just like profiting. And now they're trying to debate amongst themselves who's most ETH aligned in terms of what they're doing with their ETH treasury.

2:12:22And are they burning it or are they... Are they spending it or are they selling it? The whole it's a whole weird other problem that they're dealing with over there and But I think those are potentially similar problems that Bitcoin could come across if and when it does have its own innovation layer or ability for people to start rolling up chains and creating these alt-L1s, or sorry, alt-L2s, that somehow roll back up onto the L1 via what, BitVM2? Is that the latest thing that they're pushing now?

2:12:57Yeah. It's interesting. But like... The good thing is there's other projects trying, right? And people can learn from other people's mistakes. So in that sense, maybe it's good that people are trying and failing in other areas while Bitcoin can kind of move a little bit more slow and gracefully and purposefully in some aspects, I wouldn't want it to become Bitcoin Cash, where it's doing a yearly upgrade. That would be... probably too risky for how much activity we see on Bitcoin in terms of, the network effect is just it's very risky to make those changes on the main chain right now.

2:13:41You've got to have some place for people to build without having to seek validation from whoever Peter Todd is. You know...

2:13:52Vlad CosteaYeah. But at the same time, there's always the Peter Todd in the conversation who says, you know, there is a testnet for that. But how do you get newbies and people who don't care about this? They just want to gamble on the testnet. Or how do you evaluate how much liquidity or how much of a market share you're going to get with this unless you launch some sort of live net.

2:14:16Corbin FraserI agree. I mean, like probably the... you know, was it Aave? Aave, they had V1 and then V2, and they had some issues early on and they improved them. I don't know if they would have improved them if they hadn't been on mainnet without like real money at stake, where the incentives are to beat the shit out of this protocol see if we can steal the money. Right. This is like you've created like an opportunity for both a white hat hacker and a black hat hacker to potentially you know, stress test these things.

2:14:52But you can't really get the same level of stress test under a testnet. Because there's just no financial incentive. Nobody's going to then the only way to do that is to like, you need kind of like the VC money or you need a OG whale to say, hey, I'll put up some money into this. If anyone can break in, I'll, pay out a bounty. It's not quite the same as like, having stuff in production and being able to try and fail fast. And, you know, as long as people know when they're integrating or interacting with, you those experimental projects that it's like the do your own research on anything.

2:15:32Just, only put in what you're willing to lose. Don't be crazy you could lose it all. This is brand new or this hasn't been audited or it's only been audited once. It needs probably a few more audits and maybe a little bit more time to cook before you should go tell your mom and dad to sell their house and sell their car and put their money into this, new lending protocol that lets you borrow against your Bitcoin and it's just like, yeah. Make smart decisions.

2:16:07Vlad CosteaYeah. And once again, it's a very interesting market. I have to ask you this. Does Brock Pierce have any involvement in Bitcoin.com? None. Because I do remember seeing a video of him in which he was talking about Bitcoin.com going Bitcoin only. And he was arguing that he is not a big fan of the idea because he's this market competition maximalist. But if the market demands for it, he's all for it because he follows what the market asks.

2:16:39Corbin FraserYeah, I mean, I remember seeing that video. I've met people within Brock's circle interesting people. I think there is... I would say there is like an interest in terms of like what's happening in Bitcoin with kind of a Bitcoin renaissance of like all of these new L2s and all these people that are just like in the last year from the ordinals and all the other things that were kind of like just being launched, it did feel for a while, and maybe even still does, that like, people are building again on Bitcoin, and that's exciting.

2:17:19I don't know if... the market has necessarily moved back to Bitcoin yet. We haven't seen a mass exodus from you know, other... Ether, Solana, to say hey we're just going to redeploy these contracts on this new Bitcoin EVM. But maybe that could when the right one comes along. Maybe when people build enough trust in one. I don't like I wouldn't fade the possibility of one of these Bitcoin L2s or sidechains that have an EVM layer that have been beaten up enough where people can trust them to have some of these like major players in DeFi that are primarily on Ethereum and other EVM chains to say, yeah, let's get on there.

2:18:03That seems like a no-brainer. There's a ton of potential Bitcoin users that we could offer these same services too of course I mean they're they all want to make money, right? So I kind of think that, very possible, yeah. But... I mean, like in terms of, will Bitcoin.com ever just stop supporting other assets? Why would we do that? We're going to support as many things as possible. It's kind of like... There's been a few Bitcoin companies that started Bitcoin. As like... Bitcoin companies, then they added more chains or added some stablecoins, and then they went back to just being Bitcoin only.

2:18:44But I don't think they typically do as well as the ones that just kind of like, "Hey, support the market support what's happening there might be new things that come up Yeah, so I think having a wider casting a wider net for new projects. It's great. We want to be able to support new things that are happening, new interesting things, new if there's new ways for people to earn money.. Using their crypto and it's safe and it's trusted and it's been beat up enough, you know? Yeah, we'd be eager to integrate more things. We are looking at Bitcoin Layer 2s. We have been... We have devs digging into Citrea. We have devs digging into Strata. We have... And we've had guys digging into Rootstock and some other things.

2:19:33So, like, the interest of having Bitcoin.com support of Bitcoin Layer 2 is high. Just whether we can find one that we feel confident enough to say let's show it to our users and hopefully it's not going to be a big, giant rug. So will we be the first to integrate one? Maybe not, but like... I think once there's some confidence in... mainnet L2 that does support some of the ideals of Bitcoin? And when I say that OG Bitcoin, like being able to use it as money for the world and all the other things.

2:20:08Yeah, why wouldn't we? Of course we would support one of these. Maybe more. But I don't know if we'd ever retract and say, like, hey, we only do orange coin now.

2:20:20Vlad CosteaSo you recently listed Zano, which is right now number 411 on CoinMarketCap and CoinGecko. And my question is, by which criteria do you choose something that you're going to list? Which well, what are you looking for more exactly? Because it seems like there are like 400 projects ahead of this that you could have picked for listing, but you didn't. You went for this one.

2:20:46Corbin FraserI think for us it's like what provides utility for users and you know we do these user surveys across our ecosystem. So anyone with our wallet app or if you're in our email list, we send out some occasional user surveys like what's what do you wish that your wallet had? That it doesn't have right now and occasionally people, you know, hit it with Doge. They're like, "We just want Doge. That's all we care about." The recurring thing going back, several years for some of these surveys is that privacy is a big one.

2:21:19People want privacy because if you have any value on your wallet like more than a few grand, it's kind of scary. You kind of want to be confident that if it's in your wallet, you don't have to worry about prying eyes. And, Yeah, it seems like it solves a use case for the self-custody angle at least for us.

2:21:41But yeah, like in terms of like our listing process, I mean, we support every token we have, you know, WalletConnect. So like any ERC-20 token on an EVM chain, we support in our wallet. Yeah we are always looking for new chains to integrate. It's kind of just like, what tickles the developers the most. Yeah. Because again, going back to like, we need a champion for pretty well every project like Nobody's that nobody's there is no champion for Dentacoin. Do you know what I mean? But finding a champion for privacy, pretty easy to find amongst a team of crypto devs.

2:22:22Vlad CosteaYeah, right now I'm looking at the Bitcoin.com wallet, which I've installed on my phone. Seems to have BTC, BCH, Ethereum, Avalanche, Polygon, BNB.

2:22:34Corbin FraserYou'll have to add wallet for it. Zano.

2:22:38Vlad CosteaDid you guys also add Monero or Zcash? That was going to be my follow-up.

2:22:44Corbin FraserYeah, we would be open to it. I mean, I think if we, again, if we find the right champion who wants to, like, take on the battle... in the wallet space that we can do. Yeah, we don't really pick any sides right now. It's just we thought privacy is cool. Zano seemed like a fun one I think we like the idea of I mean, especially because we do think about it from like a profit angle like, Zano having tokens does give us a greater long tail potential revenue path for the wallet to generate more income through swapping from, like, a Zano asset to another token on Zano.

2:23:21So being able to kind of support more things with one chain kind of easier than just supporting one chain that definitely has one coin or like Yeah, Monero, you only get Monero, right? With Zano, in theory, we might get... hundreds of tokens as a result of integrating that one chain.

2:23:41Vlad CosteaOkay, so you believe it's like the next Ethereum. But with privacy?

2:23:46Corbin FraserI mean, yeah, I think there's a lot of Ethereum projects that are trying to... solve that you know there's data ownership protocol, there's... is it Railgun? Railway? Railgun. Railgun. There was zk.money for a little while and then they, after Tornado, they kind of went dark on that one for a little bit. Aztec, I think was, I think they're still around, but I think they shut down the zk.money part. So yeah, we've been kind of keeping an eye on the privacy space for quite some time.

2:24:17And then it was just like, well, we got to take a pick on one and let's just commit for a few months of building to integrate it and see it through to fruition. I think Zano has a strong possibility of having its own ecosystem. It's going to be small at first, but... all the good things are, right? Yeah, for us, it's just like an opportunity to support another ecosystem. It's no secret that there's some BTC people that don't like us, and there's even some BCH people that don't like us. It's kind of nice to be liked by a community for a change. You know, Zano seems to like us right now. It's cool.

2:24:56Vlad CosteaI guess this is the best position, right? When everyone has a reason to hate you must be doing something right.

2:25:04Corbin FraserI hope so. I hope so. Yeah.

2:25:08Vlad CosteaSo, Corbin, how can people follow you on Twitter? You're the CEO of Bitcoin.com now. You've been the CEO for a year or a bit longer than a year. You're also on these podcasts and live streams. I see you on. Twitter/X.

2:25:25Corbin FraserYeah, we do these live streams on Friday, Friday morning, Asia time. So would that be Thursday night, America time? And we do these token narratives and we just talk about the crypto space as a whole. I'm occasionally reading out some news updates for Bitcoin.com news. Yeah, you can find us at @BTCTN, which is the Bitcoin.com news channel. Twitter, we've got @BitcoinCom, which is like the official brand domain, Twitter, and then we've got my own personal, which is just @maplesyrupsuckr.

2:25:58But instead of E-R at the end, it's just R. I think due to character limits or something like that. Old, old, old alias but yeah, you can find me there. And, make sure you come check out Bitcoin.com, like if you haven't seen it in a while play around with the news. Try out our wallet app, self-Custody. If you want to try out Zano, go download the Bitcoin.com wallet app, hit the add wallet, and then you can add Zano in there.

2:26:23We haven't enabled it by default on all of them because you do have to sync the whole chain because privacy, wallets are fun. They all need to be synced, whereas our backend can pre-sync wallets for Bitcoin and some of these other chains. So yeah, go try Zano, play around with it, try and we've been around since-- the news has been around since 2015, but the Wallet's been out since 2017. Got swap by SideShift in there as well. You should go try out the swap feature by the show sponsor, SideShift.

2:26:55Actually, SideShift was like one of our earliest integrations into the wallet app so they when they did they launched their first api and it was kind of like built around ShapeShift was like a really big, swap provider for a while and then they had to add KYC because they were American. And again, all these like anti crypto things were just making it so hard to do crypto businesses there, they had to kind of like neuter a bit of their product to make it work.

2:27:25They've since added THORChain and some of these other things, which I think are still having their own issues at the moment. SideShift came around and they just had this like easy plug and play swap API that made it very easy for wallets to change from one asset to another and yeah, it's been very useful for our users. Folks that want to come into Bitcoin, they can. When the market's too rocky, they can go to stablecoins, or go to other assets and you know, try out more things, play around with DeFi do some earning with self-custody. Yeah, it's just a good beginner-friendly wallet.

2:28:07Vlad CosteaYeah, and something I forgot to ask you about, and I feel like an idiot. It's so late into the episode, but maybe it should be out there for the people listening to this. What was it like from your perspective when the BCH camp had @Bitcoin on Twitter and r/BTC on Reddit and Bitcoin.com, while the BTC camp had r/Bitcoin, and I'm not sure which Bitcoin account they had on Twitter. And the website is Bitcoin.org. Was it confusing? Did you get a lot of emails or something from people who were not getting it?

2:28:53Corbin FraserWe still get emails, but we get, man, we get emails about some really strange stuff. We'll get emails about other people's wallet apps. And they'll come to Bitcoin.com saying, I lost my Bitcoin on this wallet app called Coinbase.com. Can you guys help me? And we'll get a lot of strange messages from stuff like that. So, yeah, I mean, it does happen where people do get confused that Bitcoin.com has this very valuable domain name very easy to type in.

2:29:24And there's this assumption that it is the official place for Bitcoin and I mean, we've made it as easy as possible for people to get into Bitcoin come a long ways from the old days of, you know... trying to push a little bit more on the peer-to-peer cash, BCH only kind of vibe. But.. And we've evolved as a company and I think we're eager to help more people get into Bitcoin. That's kind of what it's all about. Bitcoin is the gateway drug to everything else. We support Bitcoin and everything else. Do more gateway drugs, right?

2:30:03Vlad CosteaSpeaking of and everything else, John, @PacArtCollect, the guy who wrote the funny comment about Roger selling out on Bitcoin, he asked, why no BSV on the Bitcoin.com wallet?

2:30:22Corbin FraserI think we're probably more likely to support eCash than BSV. I think... There's been a lot of litigious work around the BSV camp that we wouldn't really want to touch. So. I don't think there's any rush for us to launching it and then not integrating some feature that, some of the bad actors say is now like their copyright or something like that, or their trademark. And it's just, why would we, why would we bother? So, you know, we have, you can export your private keys and import them into your BSV wallet. Have some fun. But yeah, we're probably not going to be jumping into BSV anytime soon.

2:31:10Lots of other projects that I think are more interesting. And again, it goes back to like, who's the champion of this project. There are no champions of BSV at Bitcoin.com. Sorry to say.

2:31:22Vlad CosteaYeah. To me, it's never really been interesting, but... That's another conversation for another day. Yeah. Anyway, congratulations on the good work you've been doing on Bitcoin.com. Seems like right now it's one of the most balanced news outlets out there. I prefer it over CoinDesk or I'm not even sure if Cointelegraph is still around doing the same work. Bitcoin Magazine has gone full Trump. And you guys are more balanced. You also present news about Russia and China. And it seems like when I opened the webpage for news, I get a more diverse perspective on what's happening.

2:32:07Corbin FraserYeah, our news team has been growing constantly. We've been creating a lot more content on social lately too, just trying to support more of the builders and the Bitcoin space and the crypto space. And just, you know, if you're at any crypto conferences, you might see some of the Bitcoin.com news team eager to interview different projects and kind of cover what's happening in the space. For the most part, like they operate in a pure news desk fashion. They don't let us, you know, they don't have like me controlling them saying like, hey, I want you to write about Corbin and how cool he is. Yeah.

2:32:42And write about BCH only for the next year. You know, they're very they run the news desk like a news desk and, you know, they don't want any influence. And we give them that freedom and say, like, great. Have some fun. Great. Good content. You know? We do our best to just be aboveboard crypto news company, as well as our wallets and all the other fun stuff that we've been doing.

2:33:07We are in the process of actually adding a wallet to Bitcoin.com. So we're excited to put that on web. So that's going to be an MPC wallet. So if you've ever used some of the self-custody MPC tech, we're hoping to ship that pretty soon here. Going to be rolling that out a few regions. Yeah, just kind of see if we can get more newsreaders as well, get them access to some easy crypto and yeah, have some fun with it. And I think the biggest thing is just like, we've got this great domain, this great brand.

2:33:40There's no reason why we can't use it to help Bitcoin and crypto and... all the other cool stuff that's happening. Like I don't, I don't see that we have to go down like being a maximalist or anything. And yeah, I think for a lot of normal retail, when you talk about Ethereum, they'll be like, "Oh, yeah, that's like a Bitcoin." You know, they're not thinking of it in this like tribalism. They're not in the trenches like us. They don't know the minor details, but...

2:34:08Yeah. I mean, like, Bitcoin's for everyone. Crypto is for everyone. A lot of cool stuff we can do with it. A lot of great stuff we can do with this brand. We're very eager to kind of keep building and get more people into the space whether that's through orange pills or green pills or... Zano pills or anything that'll get people in. We're just eager to keep building and we want to see more people build. So, yeah.

2:34:32Vlad CosteaRight. Thank you very much, Corbin. Thank you for your time.

2:34:35Corbin FraserKeep up the great work, man. I love your podcast. I'm actually a little starstruck talking to you when I got on the first call, I was like, ooh, Vlad, cool.

2:34:42Vlad CosteaThank you for waking me up at 7 in the morning to do this. I'm not much of a morning person.

2:34:48Corbin FraserNo, you did good. You look like you're ready to take on the world, man.

2:34:53Vlad CosteaMy eyes are a bit messed up.

2:34:56Corbin FraserLooking great, man. Looking great. Thanks for having me on.

2:35:00Vlad CosteaThis was fun.

2:35:01Corbin FraserWe'll do it again.

2:35:02Vlad CosteaYeah, let's do it again. Maybe next year or something or whenever there's some exciting news.

2:35:08Corbin FraserYeah. Sounds good, man.

2:35:11Vlad CosteaOkay, I'll see you.

2:35:12Corbin FraserOkay. See you, man.

2:35:12================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: Whisper-Large-V3 (NanoGPT) transcript with automatic diarization, reconciled against the YouTube livestream's automatic captions (word-level alignment, offset about +5.5 s at the start, +10.2 s in the middle and +14.2 s from 37 min on) and a local tiny.en transcript, with doubtful, dropped and looping stretches (including a hallucinated "Subtitles by the Amara.org community" passage about CashScript, a dropped Citrea ad passage and dozens of made-up "Thank you."/"Bye." fillers) re-checked against the audio and local faster-whisper clips (medium.en/small.en). Speaker labels checked with local speaker embeddings and fixed by hand (Vlad Costea, Corbin Fraser). Names and jargon checked against the show notes and the web (Bitcoin.com, Roger Ver, freerogernow.org, Bitcoin ABC, Amaury Séchet, Bitcoincash.org, r/btc, r/Bitcoin, Theymos, Jihan Wu, ASICBoost, SegWit/SegWit2x, New York Agreement, Adam Back, Peter Rizun, Calvin Ayre, BSV, eCash, Avalanche, Jonald Fyookball, SLP, CashTokens, CashScript, Rosco Kalis, CashFusion, Mike Hearn, Paul Sztorc, BIP 300/301, Drivechain, Zano, Confidential Layer, Jameson Lopp, Samourai, Wasabi, Tornado Cash, Ian Freeman, George Hotz, comma.ai, tiny corp, Aave, Chef Nomi, Polymarket, Coinye West, Dentacoin, Railgun, zk.money, Aztec, WalletConnect, THORChain, ShapeShift, Citrea, Strata, Rootstock, BitVM2, Whitney Webb, Arthur Hayes, @PacArtCollect, @BTCTN, @BitcoinCom, @maplesyrupsuckr, LayerTwo Labs/Drivechain Talk, SideShift.ai, NoOnes.com, Hodling.ch, Bitcoin.com News). Light clean verbatim: ums, false starts and stutters removed; factual slips by speakers are kept as spoken. Intro music omitted. Remaining doubtful words are marked best guess.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00