Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S16 E59 / Transcript
Transcript · S16 E59 · 5:05:05 · 14 Nov 2025

S16 E59: Curtis Green on Bitcoin, Silk Road & Forgiveness

With Curtis Green. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:47Vlad CosteaWelcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 59. I am Vlad, and the man that I'm going to interview today is a true legend. He used to be known on the Silk Road, depending on when you joined. In the beginning, he was Chronicpain, and he was just a contributor who was talking with people and giving them advice. And then he got promoted to administrative roles. And that's when he started being called Flush, I guess, because of his love for poker. And just a second, sir, because I need to make an adjustment on the fly for your audio.

1:29And his name is Curtis Green. He has very interesting stories with Ross Ulbricht, with the whole Silk Road saga. He actually received a sentence and was tortured and had to go through a lot of bad experiences. And he also has some positive experiences with mining Bitcoin, with mining Zcash, for those of you who are into that. And part of the purpose of this interview and his telling of the story is that right now he's trying to get clemency from the Trump administration to restore his civil rights, because he doesn't have a right to vote, he doesn't have a right to carry a gun in the US, and maybe that there are also civil rights that he'd like to enjoy and he doesn't.

2:14So after this long introduction, welcome, Mr. Curtis Green. It's good to have you.

2:19Curtis GreenThanks for having me. Back in the day, I was on a one or two little podcast, but I did, you know, they were tiny little things. And I just kind of stepped out of the spotlight. And, you know, there's now is a time I was a proponent of getting Ross Ulbricht out of jail, because it was, you know, in my opinion, it was a huge, unjust, it was very unjust. What happened and so the focus was more on him than, than on me. But now that he's out, I'm like, okay, now, I don't, I don't know how I can say this out sounding greedy, but now it's my turn.

3:04You know, I'm like, okay, now, you know, because I don't want anybody to focus on, you know, get derailed from getting Ross free. So I kept quiet. I didn't do interviews, I didn't, you know, even to this day, I'm very careful of what I, of what I say and what I speak with. But yeah, it's been one heck of an interesting ride, to say the least. You know, and also, there's a lot of misnomers about what Silk Road was, you know, it got a lot of bad rap, you know, which it should have, I guess, you know, it wasn't, there were a lot of mistakes made, you know, and I don't want to come across as being somebody like, oh, I didn't do anything wrong.

3:53I, oh, you're 100% innocent. I, you know, I realize the mistakes I made. I don't, it's hard to just, it's really hard to describe, you know, the feelings I had, you know, back then compared to today. But, you know, what, you know, my, you know, my opinion was, was like, hey, you know, you know, you know, first of all, the side didn't sell anything. And then all this, obviously, I'll have a lot of justification, people will say, oh, you're justifying it. And, which is probably true, I am justifying it to a point.

4:28But when you get down to the nuts and bolts of it, the site was just a free platform. The, what vendors sold on it, we had, there was rules, as long as you did not harm a third party, it was allowed. And so that's why I'm kind of shocked at, you know, a lot, a lot of the accusations that a lot of the admins got, you know, they couldn't, like there was hacking software, and which, which is probably true, it probably was.

5:10So, let me back up. So yes, you know, so a lot of the charges that I saw were like, wait a minute, we didn't allow that on the site. Now, maybe it got through, got through somehow, but it certainly wasn't allowed. You know, and, you know, the government definitely want to add their agenda, and what they wanted to put out, you know, they, you know, so everybody had their own agenda at the beginning. And a lot of stuff that has come out, especially the beginning was the government's narrative, how, what they wanted us to hear.

5:51And then you got Hollywood involved, and they took their, they would take 5% of the truth, and spin it to however they want it spun. And it was just a shame to see all that happen back then. And that's one of the, one of the main reasons why, you know, I'm more speaking out, more or less, is, you know, to correct a lot of those misnomers, and, you know, to really tell the full true story. Granted, it's been a lot of years, it's what we're going on 2013, you know, we're going on 12, 13 years ago.

6:27And I also, you know, because my, one of my ultimate goals is, is to do my own podcast, I don't know if it'll happen or not, I would definitely love for it to happen. But, you know, we're still going down that rabbit hole. But yeah, the story is, is too big to ignore, especially when it comes to Bitcoin. Because we, as we all know, Silk Road was the first use case for Bitcoin. And trust me, we had a different view of Bitcoin back then than we do today.

7:04It, we had very little faith in Bitcoin. We would get rid of it as fast as we could get, we got our hands on it, because it was so volatile. One day it'd be worth $1, and the next day be worth $2, and better sell it before it goes to 50 cents, you know. So it was, we, and we didn't know if, what got, what the government did, you know, we didn't know if they had back doors, we didn't know, we didn't, we didn't know, we, so we just kind of played it, you know, let it play out a little bit.

7:40Because when I first heard about Silk Road, I was like, well, how do they get away with the payment situation? And then they said, oh, they use Bitcoin. And I heard about Bitcoin, but I didn't know anything about it. And so we were very, I was very leery of how, what Bitcoin was, how it was secure, how secure it was. And, you know, it's because nobody knew about Bitcoin. It was brand new. I mean, the only place that you could go to find out any information was Bitcoin Talk.

8:13And Bitcoin Talk is, is, is an echo chamber. And so what it was, it was very centralized, they would, they would, you know, mute you if you said anything dissenting. So I, so the best place to learn about Bitcoin was the Silk Road forums, to be honest. There were the people on the forums were amazing, amazing people. Because you get, let me back up a little bit, you got to remember, the site was at the beginning was one website, so you went to one URL, it had everything, the forums, the marketplace, everything was on one website.

8:58And then finally, it got changed into two different websites where the, where you had the marketplace on one URL. And then you had the forums that were on a completely separate URL. And I would say 90% of my time was spent in the forums. Because that's where all the magic happened. That's where you communicated with all the other the vendors, the buyers, the people that were just interested in Bitcoin. It, I learned so much. Like, I didn't know what PGP was, this is to give you an example of what type of people were on the site.

9:32I was learning, I want, I want to know what PGP was, I didn't, you know, because I wanted to know what SHA-256 was, I didn't see, I didn't know anything. I was so new, even though I was, I could build computers and whatnot, I was so I had no idea. And so, one of the questions I had, I said, so what is Bitcoin?

9:53And then, and one, he was obviously a cryptographer or a programmer, he came on, and he was explaining to me SHA-256. And he says, Oh, this is a great way to show you. He's, download PGP, Pretty Good Privacy. I think Zimmermann created that. And he goes, this is the best way to show you how keys work. And so I'm like, okay, that's, that's...

10:30Vlad CosteaJust a second, sir. I don't know, I guess we're being sabotaged live, because I have to basically fix your audio every 10 minutes or something. So go ahead. You're talking about Zimmermann.

10:43Curtis GreenYeah, yeah, I was. Yeah, yeah, we so I was wanting to learn more about Bitcoin and how it worked. And one of the guys that was on the forum said, Hey, let me let me show you what PGP is. And that will give you a good idea of how private keys and public keys work. You know, he wanted to get to the to the very base of what Bitcoin was. And that's what Bitcoin really is, is private keys and public keys. And this is giving you an idea of what type of people that were on the forum, this guy who obviously was well versed in cryptography.

11:21He basically took me by the hand, and walked me through the process. And we spent a full day. And then and then we split into the next day. And I was I was mentally wiped out. I learned so much and he was explaining everything in really detail. And it got and then by the third day, I was like, Okay, I think I learned enough. And he goes, he was still there. He was still wanting to teach me. And that just gives you an idea of what type of people were on the forums.

11:52They, the forum was like, was like a place of no other. It was much better than Bitcoin Talk, in my opinion. And that's where I told everybody, I said, I know it's the Silk Road, but it's the forums and see on the forums. That's that you just talked about things, you just you couldn't buy things, you couldn't sell things. It was just a forum. And then we had different and I was the I'm going all over the page. Let me back up. My first interaction with the DPR.

12:32Well, he wasn't called DPR back then it was he was called Silk Road admin, because he didn't create a name. And he they had just switched over. To the two different sites. Remember how he said they were all one site, and then now the forums were now on their on their own site. And I and my I messaged Silk Road admin, I said, I said, Hey, if you're going to allow this sort of thing to be on the site, you know, mainly, you know, the drugs and whatnot, I said, you need to have a thing that's called harm reduction.

13:10It's to it's to help people. Get off drugs as to how it's a resource for to help people that that need help. You know, it was, it was more to help people get off drugs than anything. And his response was, Oh, that's a fantastic idea. By the way, do you want to run it for me? So I became the admin of the forums really quickly. Like we're talking Silk Road wasn't wasn't on for more than a month or two. So it was right when they created separated the two sides.

13:46I can't remember the exact timeframe. So that was my first, my first interaction. And I didn't know what I was getting myself into. I was like, Hey, I'll, you know, because I'm I have a medical background. I was an EMT for quite a while and harm reduction is is would be it would you'd have to have it with us if you're going to allow what was allowed on the site. And so I decided, and he and DPR thought it will Silk Road admin thought it was a great idea.

14:20And so that's how I started off. You know, I people asking questions about, should I do this? Can I mix this with this? And, you know, I was basically not playing doctor, but I was there to help people if when they had questions, you know, I and mostly I would advise, you know, I had a lot of people that contemplated suicide, you know, so I'd give them the suicide prevention phone number and I'd be there just as an ear to talk to. You know, because that because that's what Silk Road was really about it.

14:56People get caught up into, oh, they just sold the bad illegal things, which is true. But people forget about the good things that Silk Road had. The camaraderie, camaraderie, what's the word I'm looking for? The camaraderie between Bitcoiners and between, between everybody. Because when the site really took off after Chuck Schumer went on the site and said, Oh, my gosh, look at what you can buy on the Silk Road. This is terrible. The site went from literally a few thousand people to 100,000 overnight. And this, that was one of the other reasons why you separated the site, you know, the forum, which was...

15:51Vlad CosteaYou said that the website was always crashing, and it required some maintenance. Oh, yeah, you cut off again, and I fixed your audio.

15:59Curtis GreenOkay, yeah, they were. Yeah. So, and so he, I remember at the early on, he was saying, Hey, I need people to help me. And I'm like, he wanted paid positions. And I'm like, I wasn't a programmer. So I knew that's who he was looking for. So the there was programmers that came and went, and they would help program the site and get things going. But really, though, the vision was, you know, it was a more more about freedom, and not having, you know, granted, a lot of it's a lot of, you know, a lot of justification.

16:40But it was more, it was it was it was it was about freedom and not I always felt that we should, if somebody wants to put something in their body, and it, you know, adds up to them and God and whoever, who are we to say, what, you know, what should go in my body, you know, I choose not to drink alcohol. I don't see any problem with it. It is just, you know, it is just giving you an example. But yeah, the site was more was more about being freedom.

17:22It wasn't so much at the beginning, it definitely wasn't. Bitcoin was was was a tool. It wasn't. It wasn't, you know, as time went on, it became more of a hotter topic. And because it really, we started to realize now what is this, you know, because we didn't know, you know, I wasn't a programmer. So I don't, my technical knowledge only went so far. And so I wanted, I wanted to find out what made Bitcoin tick, what, why was it so special? Why, you know, I needed all these questions answered.

18:03And it took a long time before I felt, you know, good enough to what it was. Because like I said, I really thought at the beginning that it was, the government was behind it, that, you know, all the conspiracy theory, you know, just because it was just too convenient. And then, but obviously, the government hates cryptography, you know, because they want to be able to see and hear everything. So, and so once I learned that, hey, Bitcoin is really is decentralized. And it really is, you know, you know, I don't want to call anonymous, but back then, we knew it was anonymous, but we thought it was more anonymous than what it really is, you know, is because as long as you didn't give your real world name up, which back then, who would you give your world name up to it, we were using Bitcoin.

19:00So it does, it was anonymous. It wasn't until like, 2014, 15, when we realized, oh, my gosh, it's far from anonymous. The blockchain is permanent. And all they have to do is connect your real ID to an address and, you know, that you're all your anonymity is gone. So yeah, at the beginning, it was it was quite it was just to see the changes from the early days to now, you know, we haven't gone full circle. But, boy, it, you know, there's been a lot of controversies as they come along throughout the years, you know, the hash, the hash war.

19:39Or, you know, when 2016, when the SegWit came along, and, you know, the, you know, the Roger Ver, you know, Bitcoin Cash thing, and, you know, there's, you know, a lot of things has happened. But, you know, Bitcoin, you know, is still Bitcoin, you know, it's still, you know, everybody's moving to level two, which, which I think is the only way you can really scale it unless you make the blocks bigger. But then, but again, that's that technology is over my head, you know, I just kind of watched it, but I really didn't care too much.

20:19I'm like, so what if they make the blocks bigger? You know, I didn't I really didn't know. But I digress. But yeah, so the Silk Road is was was more about freedom and Bitcoin was a great tool to help, to help bring that freedom. Because we didn't have to worry about, oh, how, you know, how am I going to do this safe, this transfer, this transaction? How can I make it safe? Well, Bitcoin, you know, was the answer. And as I went down the rabbit hole...

21:03Vlad CosteaSo, for the record, you said that every day you got more interested in Bitcoin as you fell down the rabbit hole, and you cut off again. So I fixed it.

21:13Curtis GreenYeah, yeah, yeah, it, like I said at the beginning, there that I, you know, as Bitcoiners, we always say, we verify, let's trust, we don't trust, we verify. You know, back then it was, I had to be convinced that Bitcoin, you know, was really what they said, you know, is it not? And, you know, so it probably took a good year of me looking at Bitcoin. Studying Bitcoin, you know, before I really got comfortable thinking, hey, Bitcoin is, Bitcoin is where it's, you know, that I get it now.

21:55And a lot of people with Bitcoin today, they hear 10 minutes, you know, they usually get the price and then they maybe read a few posts about it. And they, oh, I understand Bitcoin. And that, no, you can't do that. You have to, you have to spend hours under, going down the rabbit hole to really understand it. You know, I tried to, on Christmas 2012, I tried to give my siblings, I actually mined a block with solo mining. And I thought, oh, it would be so cool for Christmas, if I gave each of my siblings a Bitcoin.

22:45You know, Bitcoin was like $2, I think, at the time. And I got the Casascius coins. I don't, they were, they were, they were the cheapest. Yeah. Yeah, well, I, whatever. Yeah, he actually lived, Mike, he only lived like 20 minutes from me, which was, which was really weird.

23:03Vlad CosteaMike Caldwell, the author of BIP38, and also the first person to make Bitcoin physical with his Casascius coins for those who are not aware and don't know what Curtis is talking about.

23:14Curtis GreenYeah. So I took the, these coins, you could pop them in half and you put the private key in one of, inside it and snapped it shut. And then I wrote a big step by step on how, you know, back then we didn't, there were some addresses. It wasn't like it is today. We didn't have seed words. I think the seed words were just coming out, maybe. Anyway...

23:42Vlad CosteaBIP39 came in 2013 or 2014. It was a replacement for BIP38, which was simpler.

23:50Curtis GreenYeah. So it was just simple. An address went to this Bitcoin. So I had one Bitcoin each address. So, and so I tried to give this spiel, I believe it was late, could have been 2011, late 2011, with my family sitting there. And I said, Bitcoin is going to change. This is, I've already gone down the rabbit hole. I've already decided Bitcoin is, is going to change the world. And I gave this big spiel about how, what Bitcoin was, where it's going, how I, it will be worth a million dollars one day.

24:24You know, I, now, now I didn't think it would, you know, I thought it would be decades or centuries away. And, but I thought, one day it'll get there. One day, the whole world will be using Bitcoin. Well, long story short, I put it back in the little gift box boxes. And I, and I thought I gave a good presentation of what Bitcoin was, what you could do in 20 minutes. And when they all left, when the party broke up, they all went home. And not one, they left all their Bitcoin, my boxes that I made with Bitcoin, and they didn't take them.

25:04And that, and that really, it really bummed me out because I hear, I was so, I was like, man, don't they realize that, you know, I don't, I didn't see it going up in value, but I, but it was the principle of what Bitcoin represented. And so it really hurt, it hurt my feelings more More than anything, because I mined it.

25:26Vlad CosteaOkay, so just for the record, you mined the Bitcoin, and how many did you put on these physical coins that were not taken by...?

25:33Curtis GreenOne Bitcoin I gave, there was eight, there was eight, I'm the oldest of nine, so I made eight of them, or eight or nine of them. I can't remember, it's been so long. And so I had each individual Bitcoin, and now those Bitcoin are gone forever. Because, you know, I think I saved two or three of them, if I'm mistaken, I remember seeing them sitting on that, on the kitchen table or something. But that gives you an idea of where people's heads were at. When they were given a presentation about Bitcoin, you know, they, it went one ear and out the other.

26:10And I tried, and I, and I thought maybe it's because they couldn't feel it, they couldn't touch it. So that's where I got the coin idea. They could actually see it, they could touch it, they could, they could feel it, and that still didn't work. And so I knew then that Bitcoin had a long way to go. And, you know, I, you know, then when, and then when we saw Bitcoin go up to 2013, or in 2013, up to $1,000, and then it shot all, came all the way down to 150, I'm like, oh, no, you know, maybe Bitcoin isn't going to work, you know, because everybody had their doubts, you know, they had their, oh, it's going to work, oh, maybe it's not going to work.

26:50But if you really understood Bitcoin, those moments of dread would, would leave you, because you'd go, okay, the price might be down, and people are too stuck, were too stuck on the price, especially back then. And even myself, you know, when Ethereum came out, I, you know, when Bitcoin went up to 1100 and dropped back to 150, I thought, oh, geez, I don't, I'm not sure about Bitcoin, it just dropped 85%. And maybe Ethereum is a great way to go. I mean, that just, because I was so confused.

27:32And Ethereum is a great tool, you know, smart, gave us smart contracts, as you know, it's, Ethereum has its place in the world. And that created a whole new thing. But anyway, but yeah, so Bitcoin to me, it was, it started a lifelong journey of finding out that, of sovereign money. And I learned out how, I always thought I knew, oh, inflation was 2% a year, I thought I had had it figured out. Well, as I got into Bitcoin, I figured out that I really didn't know anything about anything.

28:15I didn't know that how, you know, they could just print things out of thin air and, you know, and here, I'm in my 40s at this time, you would think that I would have, would have known. But Bitcoin really helped, really opened my eyes to show that governments are in control of our lives. And Bitcoin gives us hope and gives us some of that, gives it back to us, gives us the control back. Because, like, nobody can, you know, the government, you know, they had their, I'm sure back in 2011 or 12, if they would have taken down the network, you know, you know, if they would have realized where Bitcoin would have been, would become today that they might have tried, but they just saw it as a stupid project.

29:15You know, when I was when I was arrested, one of the one of the last things that one of the agents told me, he says, he said, get out of Bitcoin, it's nothing but trouble. And I'm like, why would he say that? You know, it really bothered me. Why, why would he tell me get out of Bitcoin is nothing but trouble. And see, that's the problem. People really, people didn't know Bitcoin, they just they looked at, oh, it was connected to Silk Road, which was drugs, ooh, bad.

29:49And so they, what's a common denominator? Bitcoin, therefore, Bitcoin is bad, you know, so it's all about knowledge and learning and educating yourself. And I'm thoroughly convinced if the population were to sit down and spend, everybody were to spend one or two days of just reading about Bitcoin, oh, Bitcoin would, would, would have a different, it would just, I don't know if the price, I'm sure the price would go up. But that's where the problem is, is people don't do their, do their homework.

30:29You know, they don't, they don't go down the rabbit hole. And I think everybody has to have the rabbit hole moment when it comes to Bitcoin. You know, like, you know, I had my, I mined Monero, I mined Zcash, I mined, well, anything NiceHash could mine, I mined it with my little GPU miners that I had going. And then I got into, I was one of the first ASIC, at Butterfly Labs.

31:00Vlad CosteaYou told me you got scammed with that one because you ordered your ASICs, you paid like 10,000 Bitcoin for it or something.

31:07Curtis GreenIt was 2,700 Bitcoin.

31:10Vlad CosteaSo 2,700 Bitcoin for the record. And you never got that.

31:16Curtis GreenWell, what I did get, they were supposed to come out in like October of 2012, I think. And they kept pushing the date off, pushing the date off. And I finally, and I was like one of the top two or three, I put everything I had into that. I put every penny I could muster up. And had I, and see, and this is where my ignorance came in. Had I, looking back, I'm like, what was I thinking spending so much Bitcoin? Because there was no way I could mine those 2,700 Bitcoin back, you know, because they, you know, as mining got popular, the hash rate started to skyrocket.

31:57And I, you know, you could mine 100 Bitcoin fairly easily, not easily, but in a month you could think, oh, this will continue forever. It'll come down, but it won't go down that much. Well, we found out it, like in 2013, 14, and when ASICs were first released, it skyrocketed the hash rate. And you know, what it could have, should have, man, that was so, and I'm sure a lot of those early ASICs were in the same boat. You know, we've never got, no way could we recoup our Bitcoin.

32:35And that's another whole nother story of, you know, trusting people, because I couldn't afford to mine it from my house, you know, because you had to have a 220 line, and so I had to figure out how to mine it. And so I mined from my house when I could, and finally I had to sell the miners off, just because they were just sitting around, and I didn't have enough money to keep them going, and I didn't have air conditioning in my house, and it creates heat, and that was another problem.

33:06So, yeah, so Bitcoin mining, when the Bitcoin mining bug bites you, it's pretty fun, especially, you know, to learn about it. I think that's what I always told, that was one of the things I told people early on, I said, if you want to really learn about Bitcoin, mine it, because then you're always having to keep an eye on it, and if you don't understand something, you'll ask the question and somebody will help you, and it'll just help you with that rabbit hole situation.

33:47But anyway, but yeah, Bitcoin, I heard, I knew about Bitcoin, Silk Road came along, you know, I wasn't there on the Silk Road, you know, for the drugs, it was, you know, I was there to try to help, and you know, there was, there was, I had a lot of, when I first found the site, I was like, man, is this legal, and is this a good idea to get involved, and I talked with my wife about it, and I'm like, listen, we're not selling anything, the people are, the site is just a free, anybody can go on, we're not selling, we're not, you know, all we are is, we're facilitating, which I know a lot of justification went in there, but I honestly, when you look at it from my perspective back then, I really didn't, I didn't think it was, it was that, it was so illegal, because I just felt like we were just providing a platform that, you know, it was kind of like Amazon, but they, yeah, people sold things that they shouldn't have, but call me naive, but I really did not think it was, you know, I didn't realize that the government, I knew the government wanted to shut down, but I didn't realize how bad they wanted to shut down, and I was kind of shocked, I was like, oh, you know, what's the big deal, it's not like it's on the regular web, you have to jump through so many hoops to get there, you have to use Tor, you have to, you know, so it's not like kids are going to get on the site, well, I guess some kids did, but it was more of, you really had to know, you want to know more about Bitcoin and, or actually search for it really didn't, unless you listen to Chuck Schumer, which to me, to this day, I'll never understand why he did that advertisement for Silk Road, because that's what he did, is he said, he had all these, I don't know if you've seen the videos, but he said, look, everybody, look what you can do on Silk Road, well, that was the dumbest thing he could have done, you know, he was just a big, he was just a big advertiser for Silk Road, and it created a lot of, made the site skyrocket, but yeah, the, you know, and I'm out of all the, I'm digressing a lot, but you know, I, you know, when the site was brought down, I was, you know, I was arrested, and you know, I thought, you know, then my life of hell went started, you know, I'm fortunate that I didn't go to prison, I'm very grateful that I didn't, but I did do my, I did my own, I served my own hell, with family issues, with, you know, local people, you know, in our neighborhood, thought I was the devil, you know, even though they really didn't know me, you know, so yeah, while I didn't serve prison time, I served my own prison time, if that makes sense, you know, I, the government really pushed, you know, they wanted their narrative, and when I was, you know, there's a big long story of how I was arrested and whatnot, I go about, I talk about it in my book, Silk Road Takedown, a little bit, I really didn't dive, I didn't, I just gave a little overview of what happened, but long story short, I, Nob, who was a DEA agent, had a, those drugs sent to my house, and I had no idea what, you know, when that package came, and I, you know, there's a whole long story, there's some stuff I found about that story, it was quite interesting, they called it off, you know, they were, the package came, and I wasn't expecting it, and all I saw was Nob, and I knew Nob was a guy on Silk Road, and I go, oh, I should stay away from this.

38:42And unfortunately, I didn't, I was stupid enough to open it. And then that was the end of it, for my Silk Road, and they took me up to, you know, they had this big meeting with the Secret Service agents, and that's where I met Shaun Bridges, I already, Carl Force, I already knew a little bit, and while I was up there, they, Shaun Bridges stole 30,000 Bitcoin, and he made it look, well not, no, he, what he did is, I had the seed, I had the seed word, or I had access pretty much to the whole site, I didn't have root access, but I had a lot of access, and what Shaun Bridges did, and I still think Carl Force has something to do with it, but they say they didn't, so I have to, you know, whatever, he, Shaun Bridges, he took my username and password, and went through all these vendor's accounts, and stole all their Bitcoin, it went from one person to the next, because he had, you know, he used my credentials, and the mistake he made is, he thought the meeting was going to end that night, and, but he, so he had to magically fly home to Baltimore, and he didn't get the memo that it went a second day, and so he stole all the Bitcoin during the night, and one of the addresses that vindicated me was, he made a vanity address that said, then it started with a number one, and said CurtisGreenSR.

40:34Who in their right mind would send stolen Bitcoin with their own name on it? So that actually helped me in the long run, but the government was thoroughly convinced that I had stolen that Bitcoin, and there was nothing that I could do to convince them. I mean, how do you prove that you didn't do something?

41:06And while we were up in the meeting, I talk about this in my book, when we were up in the meeting, he said, well, we've got some bad news. He wants the Bitcoin back. And I'm like, well, I didn't take it. If I could give it back, I'd give it back. And so they, for hours, they hammered me and said, yes, you did take it. Oh, you did take it. Oh, just tell the truth. Just come on, you can just mess up. And I'm like, now I can see how people do false confessions.

41:44Because I was to the point where I almost wanted to say, okay, I get it, but I can't give it to you.

41:53Vlad CosteaIt sounds like these jokes, which are partially true. I think about the Soviet Union, right? Because they would interrogate people, and they would accuse them of something that they never did. But just to escape the torture, or just to get rid of the embarrassment, and maybe just get out of the situation in a way that was more convenient. They would say, yes, it's true, I did this. And then they would put them on some sort of propaganda poster and say, this person is a horrible man, they would send them to forced labor camps and whatever. The difference is that they were going to send you to jail, possibly, for doing this.

42:30Curtis GreenWell, they were so convinced, and they said, hey, he wants us 30,000 Bitcoin back. And I said, well, I don't know what to do. And he says, well, we need to take some pictures of us trying to get your Bitcoin back. And I'm like, whatever. So we went into the bathroom, and they faked dunking me in the water to get the Bitcoin back. And it was very realistic. And we had queues. I had to sign my life away saying that I wasn't doing this under duress and all this kind of stuff.

43:12And I'm like, yeah, right, I had no choice. You know, I had to go along with their little scheme or whatever they were doing, you know, because they had me scared to death. I mean, I was petrified. I mean, imagine being in front of 20 federal agents, them telling you're going to spend 40 years in prison, you know. And it just, it was literal hell, especially that first night, first night or two. And it took, it was until they found the evidence that Shaun Bridges and Carl Force were really the bad guys.

43:58Because I lived in pure hell, you know, because they said, oh, okay, after, he just wants the Bitcoin back. And I'm like, well, I can't give it back because I don't have it. And then it magically changed. Oh, now it changed from beating you up to having you killed. And I'm like, oh, my gosh. And I was really scared for my safety. I was like, because you don't know who's doing this. And I didn't know if it was, I don't know who the bad guy was. I don't know if it was the government.

44:44I went back and forth so many times of figuring out who could be doing this because all I know is I gave up using the password to 20 different people. And then that night, the theft takes place. So to me, one of those 20 people had to do the theft, but the government, and I tried to explain that to them and they wouldn't listen. All fingers pointed towards me. And so I had to play dead for 10 months in my house.

45:22Vlad CosteaWhat do you mean, play dead? Like, never go out? Yes. Go on the internet, never communicate with anyone?

45:28Curtis GreenThey called me every single day, Carl Force did, every day saying, you're staying offline, right? Nope, you're staying off the internet, right? Every day he called me to make sure that I was staying low and I wasn't leaving outside. I would walk at nighttime so I wouldn't cast my shadow. I had to turn off all the lights and literally crawl on my floor to go get from the bathroom to the kitchen because I was so petrified of somebody seeing me. The government did false police reports of missing persons.

46:08It was kind of ironic looking back how the local city police would come looking for me and here I'm in the bathroom with the door closed, hoping they don't hear me because I had to keep the ruse up, so I had to be dead. And so the police were, we got to find Curtis, we got to find where he's at. My wife was going along with it, she was like, I don't know where he's at.

46:43It was not a fun time during that, and a lot of it was caused by me. I put myself in, I had the choice of working on Silk Road, but again, I didn't look at it as me doing something bad and wrong. It's hard to describe. I saw it as a learning experience, and also I know I'm making excuses, but remember the site, there was a marketplace and the forums, and I spent 90% of my time, if not 95, if not maybe even higher, on the forums.

47:27So what did we do wrong talking about Bitcoin, about other things? Yes, people bought things on the marketplace, but that had nothing to do. And it is a shame that even the guys that were just on the forums, they served prison time just for working on the forums. They had nothing to do with the marketplace. So it's all about the government having control and following along their narrative, because no, they couldn't, heaven forbid, if one of their own was bad, that couldn't happen. So they did everything in their power to give this information, and they kept it really quiet.

48:30In fact, when they came busting down my doors, I just got done doing my four years tax returns. You only have three years to get your money back. So that $22,000 that I had in my fanny pack was all legit money. I had just cashed my tax return money, and I did not have a bank account, because that's when you could float checks. And me and my wife got into trouble floating checks, and they cut off our bank account. And so when I got my tax refund, I turned them into cash, and what's the safest place to put it?

49:16It was my fanny pack with me. When I go to bed, I'd put it in my safe, but I felt the safest was with me. But when the government came knocking on my door, it looked horrible, me having $22,000 cash on me. I mean, the optics were terrible.

49:39So they stole all that money from me, and it was every cent that we had. When they took that money, it was like, okay, that's every dollar that we had to our name. What do we do? And luckily, I'm an entrepreneur. I figured out how to work little small gigs here and there, and I somehow pulled us out. But I had to be dead too during this time. So my wife worked, but it was a rough couple of years, 2013 and 14, because the story didn't get, the Silk Road wasn't taken down until October of 2013.

50:27So they were still trying to find out. Who ran the site, and I couldn't give them much information. I didn't know who anybody was, and then they spent their time trying to find, you know, trying to prove that I stole all this Bitcoin. And of course I didn't. And, you know, so it wasn't a fun time back then. You know, it was my fault. There were so many times where I thought, you know, I should stop being an admin on Silk Road. You know, oh, so many times where I thought, oh, I should just distance myself now.

51:16But I got paid. I didn't get paid a great salary. I think it was right around, we got paid in Bitcoin. I think it was right around two or three thousand bucks a month, which was enough to pay the bills. You know, I, well, I love to have all those Bitcoin back. But it was what it was. I, you know, I had to survive. And then when that income got shut off, it was like, oh crap, what do I do now? And so I, you know, my house went into foreclosure.

51:51I don't know how I figured that out. But luckily I was able to keep our house. I was able to put food on the table. You know, it was not, it was not a fun time. And, you know, and then once the site was taken down and then, boy, it all blew up, you know, on, you know, from all these different websites. What's, what are, Wired magazine, you know, they did an article and I foolishly said, yeah, I'll participate. You know, I didn't think it could, you know, I didn't think it would be as big as what it became.

52:43And so I did a little interview with them and they took all that information and blew it up and made it look, you know, they took it and made, they did a lot of misinformation that, you know, like I say, they take 5% of the truth and they spin that 5% into their narrative. And so that's why I was, you know, there's a movie about Silk Road. Don't watch it. It's, I've never watched it. I've read the script. It's stupid. Because they Hollywoodized everything.

53:20And, you know, but Silk Road is, you know, was, and I don't think a lot of Bitcoiners realized it was, it was a real pinnacle of, that was a turning point of Bitcoin, in my opinion. People realized, oh, it can be used as safely as a payment method. It's very secure. You can't get any more secure than that. And, you know, back then it was, you still had to wait your six blocks or what, you know, for confirmations. But it was, we didn't, it was, we didn't really worry about that.

54:03And once we sent it, we were, we knew it would show up at the other end, you know, so. But yeah, you know, Silk Road was a, was, was really a turning point for, you know, for, you know, for Bitcoin. They, I think when I, when Silk Road first started, Bitcoin was like at 88 cents. Yeah, it was 88 cents. And then that August, seven months later, it skyrocketed to $32. Granted, it came crashing back down again. But I think that gave people, oh, wow, look what Bitcoin can do.

54:45It got out of the pennies, you know, it, and, you know, so, and it was sure a shame when Bitcoin, when the Silk Road was taken down, because they, I kind of wish they would have left the forums alone, because the forums were, were so awesome. And there, and there was, I don't recall any illegal activity on the forums at all. It was just all about talking, about learning. They had a book club on the forums.

55:18Vlad CosteaYeah, I think Ross Ulbricht started that one. Yeah, yeah. It was like a weekly book club, and he would tell people to read, usually some libertarian literature. Oh, yeah. They would discuss it.

55:31Curtis GreenOh, yeah, yeah, yeah. That was kind of funny how, you know, you know, you know, I'm all into, into that, you know, but the books that he would send me to show me to read, I was like, I'm not gonna go through this whole freaking book. It was kind of funny. And then you say, Oh, did you read that book? I said, Oh, yeah, I read it. I read it. When actually I skimmed through it. But yeah, reading, you know, that book club, I wish I would have looked, looking back, I wish I would have taken more to heart and really gone down the rabbit hole because all the von Mises stuff, libertarian, you know, the way Austrian economics worked.

56:12It was, you know, it was, it was, it was really, it was, it was really eye opening, just to hear all about that stuff. And it gave me a different point of view to look at, you know, so.

56:28Vlad CosteaOkay, let's get a little bit organized, because you started from the early days of the Silk Road and how you discovered it and how you got more involved with it. And then you jumped straight to the end of it. And what to go through. There are still some stories in the middle that have not been covered. And there are still some stories from both sides that have not been covered. And I very much like the energy that you have. You basically seem to have been waiting for a long time to get this out.

56:58So you can finally speak out about what's been happening. As far as I'm aware, this is the first interview you have done in years.

57:05Curtis GreenOh, yeah, yeah. And the interviews I did before were just minor because I was afraid of the blowback of what the government could do because they had me terrified. So I was very careful what I said and who I said it to. So I really didn't say too much. And now it's kind of like, well, time is there's been enough time, you know, Ross is out. You know, there's no reason really to keep, to keep quiet, you know, and one of the things I don't want I don't want the Silk Road story to get lost. And, you know...

57:49Vlad CosteaBecause I think today it's more relevant than maybe a few years ago, because we have a new class of Bitcoiners who joined only looking at the banking class promoting Bitcoin and thinking that it's this institutional grade financial asset that used for getting collateral. I mean, for putting it as collateral to get US dollars or a speculative investment and all sorts of things, which were not part of the early days of Bitcoin. Like, I'm not sure how many people actually were looking at Bitcoin from this point of view that is going to be used by banks and you're going to get a loan, a loan in USD against your Bitcoin or

58:29Curtis GreenI never saw that coming. It's like, you know, it was why would I give up the keys to my to the Bitcoin? It kind of felt like it defeated the purpose. Like if, you know, if I'm going to give up my keys, you know, so but we've kind of gotten accustomed to, you know, we're going we've been we've been going down this new paradigm where because USD is king and we have to go we have to somehow turn our Bitcoin into dollars. We can't we can't live on you know, we have to put food in our mouth and well, they usually take dollars and...

59:15Vlad CosteaJust for the record, were you around when Bitcoin hit one dollar and basically there was this disparity between the two currencies?

59:24Curtis GreenWell, yeah, it was 88 cents and then it jumped to like $1.20 and then it dropped back down to 60 cents and but the but what the goal was, as if I remember correctly, it wasn't when Bitcoin equaled $1. It's when one Bitcoin became the parity of an ounce of gold. That's was that's when you saw that's when we thought okay, that's when Bitcoin wins when one Bitcoin is worth one ounce of gold.

1:00:04Vlad CosteaAnd how much was one ounce of gold at the time?

1:00:05Curtis Green$1,200 $1,300 right around there. And so when it did hit that parity in 2013, then it shoots back down. So we a lot of us, you know, I lost a lot of faith. I thought oh, man, well, now will it ever come back? Was it a bubble? Was it?

1:00:26Vlad CosteaWell, it was a bubble, but it did come back.

1:00:29Curtis GreenYeah, and what and what they're finding out, I read some people that are some doc, not documentary stuff, but some websites that have talked about that, that jump up in 2013 to where we hit $1200. It was manipulated. And they're looking at the data, and they're finding out that it was controlled by a few people that pushed it up that far. So it was it was an unnatural jump to the $1300. And what's ironic is, they said it should have been the price should have been right around $200. And that's exactly what it fell down to. So the $200 was really the true price of Bitcoin.

1:01:13Vlad CosteaAnd I think that's what always happens. Sorry for interrupting, but usually the bear market price is what the market agrees that something is worth. And then the bull market price is what you have when you add some extra hype on top of this base price. So I think that and maybe I'm going to get canceled or something for saying this, but I think that one Bitcoin maybe is worth like 40, $50,000. In terms of production costs for mining, which once again is the Marxist fallacy, where you say that if you put a certain amount or value of work into something, it should be worth that.

1:01:53It's not how it works. But if you use that as a baseline for determining the price as how much it costs to produce one Bitcoin, I think that's it. And it's also the price that we have had for quite a while before jumping to $100. Maybe $50 is reasonable. $50,000, I'm sorry, not $50. Even though I would love for it to be $50 again, I would buy a shitload.

1:02:16Curtis GreenOh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Wouldn't that be great? Just for one hour. Does it drop down then they can go back up?

1:02:23Vlad CosteaNo, no, because that would be unfair. I would probably sleep or do something else around that time.

1:02:30Curtis GreenBut yeah, you're absolutely right. And I would rather have seen Bitcoin go up at a natural rate. But then, if we didn't have these big swings, we're used to stocks going up slowly. They might do a little pullback. They're like gold, you know, gold...

1:02:55Vlad CosteaNo, no, that's not true anymore. We live in the meme stock era. Like if you watch what happened with GameStop, and other stocks like this, even BlackBerry, and a couple of others, they are so disconnected from fundamentals. This is maybe an illness that's caused by the money printing, and the fact that people don't know what has value anymore. Plus the fact that you have an entire generation. I'm not sure how old your son is. But basically, this generation of zoomers, they are so accustomed to digital purchases, and paying for something which is not tangible, has no actual value, you cannot trade it.

1:03:33They buy Fortnite skins, they buy CS:GO skins for guns and stuff. And they're just basically graphical representations of something that they cannot trade.

1:03:45Curtis GreenYeah, my son's 11 years old. So I know, him and Roblox, you know, and yeah, I give, I have to, he does his chores, and I give him $5 a month. That's all he gets for his Roblox.

1:04:02Vlad CosteaAnd he spends it on some very stupid cosmetic upgrades.

1:04:05Curtis GreenYeah, and he knows that. He goes, Oh, I want to get this stupid upgrade. And I try to tell him, what are you paying for what, you know, trying to teach them the value of money, you know, because that's, you know, you know, all they're doing is copying the same thing over and over and over and over again, you know, if it was unique, maybe it'd have a little more value.

1:04:26Vlad CosteaBut my point is that this generation is gonna discover even Bitcoin, but also stocks, and they're not gonna understand the value of anything. They will just be like, Oh, should this be worth like $100,000? Why not? Let's throw some money at it.

1:04:41Curtis GreenYeah, well, yeah. And that's what, you know, are, you know, once, you know, the big, big price point was when Bitcoin broke that $100,000. That was like, the ultimate thing to happen, even back in 2013, 14. It was like, it was like, Oh, one day Bitcoin will hit that $100,000 mark. And so I always knew, once we got to this point, it would be 100,000 would be a tough nut to crack, even though it went past 100,000. It's having a real tough time keeping above 100,000.

1:05:17And, you know, because you're having a lot of OGs sell and, you know, and I don't know what other factors you have going in. But yeah, it's really interesting to see how it struggled and see again, you get to this point, and see it where it's been, and you see all the ups and downs, and you think, man, how did, you know, how did we survive this? You know, because, you know, when you when you see Bitcoin at 50,000, and then you see it drop down to 20,000.

1:05:54Who doesn't panic sell? You know, it takes a lot of conviction to not, you know, and because you think, Oh, it's gonna keep going down forever. I better get out while the getting's good. It's a weird mentality. But once you understand the fundamentals, it helps you get through those, those points. It's, you know, usually the people that panics sell are the ones that don't understand Bitcoin. And, you know, because it, because eventually, as long as they print money, Bitcoin will be king, you know, and, until they stop printing money, which will never happen, we know that, because they have to have control.

1:06:42And that's why I've heard so many people say that the government started Bitcoin, I'm like, Oh, my gosh, there's no, to me, I don't think that happened. Now, does the government use Bitcoin for nefarious purposes? Probably.

1:07:00Vlad CosteaBut there have been records of that. I remember there was a story of years ago of the Chinese government paying its spies in Bitcoin, using Wasabi Wallet. And that was interesting. And I'm pretty sure that there are lots of government agents or people who work for various agencies, who maybe are deployed as spies in very different ways. And they can't receive via bank accounts. And it's very convenient to just send some Bitcoin.

1:07:28Curtis GreenOh, yeah. You know, you know, Bitcoin is great. You know, not, how many assets can you store in your head? And, you know, you're with your seed words or whatever key phrases, and then, you know, without having to lug, you know, it's good. You know, Bitcoin has, you know, with all of its fallacies, if you can call them that is, you, we've never had money like this before, you know, you know, you have your Peter Schiff's of the world that have to touch it and see it and feel it. But it, you know, the, you know, I

1:08:05Vlad CosteaBut I got to give credit to Peter Schiff at the same time. He's been the most consistent critic, and he's not always wrong. But he's wrong enough that you disregard if you're into Bitcoin. But at the same time, he makes some valid points sometimes.

1:08:20Curtis GreenHe does. Yeah. And like I've said a lot about about Peter Schiff, I was like, you know what, Bitcoin is the only thing that I disagree with him on, you know, but he brings up some valid points at different points. So, but the whole picture that he has, obviously, is wrong. But everything else, most everything else that he talks about, I agree with. It's amazing how, you know, that one little thing that, you know, Bitcoin is what we have our disagreements with. But yeah, but Peter Schiff, he's very, he's got some valid points.

1:09:01Vlad CosteaAnd he also has some credentials that make him sort of the son of another, a Ross Ulbricht of another generation, because his dad wrote a book about how to evade taxation in the US. And he died in prison after that. He spent like 30 years in prison.

1:09:18Curtis GreenAnd what's crazy, he was wealthy, that he could have easily paid his taxes, you know, he owed millions of dollars, but he was doing it to prove a point, I think, you know, I don't know if you want to call him a martyr or anything, but he was saying, hey, I think taxes are bad. We should not be coerced into paying them. And he died by his convictions, you know, and so, you know, so you have to give a lot of respect to his father, you know, which, you know, he's a guy who I know more about Peter Schiff's father that I know about Peter Schiff, really, because that's I remember him going through all of his trials and stuff when I was younger.

1:10:01And so yeah, Peter Schiff with all of his, you know, and it's kind of, maybe it's good to have a Peter Schiff out there to give us a different perspective to kind of maybe keep us grounded a little bit. You know, to even though we all roll our eyes, a lot of things that he says, you know, when everybody pulls out the memes that he said in 2011, how it's going to keep going down from $12 or whatever it was. But yeah, we always have to have the other side of it, because the truth is always somewhere in between.

1:10:42Vlad CosteaAnd to his credit, he got sort of vindicated this year when gold went up a lot, and a lot of his predictions about gold turned out to be true, but at the same time, he was wrong about Bitcoin in lots of ways. But I got to give him credit because back in 2013, for example, when a lot of these big Bitcoiners of today were still just a bunch of new faces or something, he was debating Bitcoiners on his show. So it's not like he was completely against it. He actually kept an open mind and was doing debates. He was inviting Eric Voorhees on his show in 2013.

1:11:20Curtis GreenYeah, he didn't shy away from it, which I have to give him credit. Even today, he'll be on somebody's podcast and he'll debate them. So to his credit, yeah, you're absolutely right.

1:11:40Vlad CosteaYou could be the kind of hater who only talks about his side of the story and his tribe, and doesn't give any credit to the other side. But in 2012, 2013, 2014, he was already an established economist, and one of the most successful businessmen in gold. And he gave a platform to people who are promoting Bitcoin. So there is some merit to that. And we do need to thank him.

1:12:04Curtis GreenOh, yeah. Just because we have disagreements doesn't mean that he's still a human being. I've never met the guy, but I'm sure I like him. Just because we have one disagreement, but we agree on so many other points. I think he even said, Bitcoiners, the only thing we disagree on is Bitcoin, but everything else politically wise, monetarily wise, we agree with. And I think he's right. I think a lot of us Bitcoiners do empathize with him and can see his point, even though we may not agree with him 100% of the time. But again, we digress.

1:13:05Vlad CosteaWe've been going for longer than one hour. I got to present my ads, or I'm getting my ass kicked. But before that, I have to tell the listeners that you can actually ask questions to Curtis. You'll have to donate to his campaign, which is not ready yet. Unfortunately, we wanted to have it ready on time. If you're looking at the description on YouTube, I've actually mentioned that there's going to be a link where you can donate. But I guess some people will listen to this in a few days also. So there will be a Satlantis link. I think that's what it's called. Or is it Satlantis?

1:13:39Curtis GreenSatlantis.io. What we're doing is I'm speaking at Adopting Bitcoin next week. And we're putting on a little event, a little dinner slash poker type event on the 17th at Satoshi's Bar. And it's under when you go to Satlantis, under my events, I have an event and they'll have it on Monday, they'll have it all the different things that you can they can either donate or buy a ticket, you know, we're gonna have it. And we have the domain PardonCurtis, you know, and I had an OG reach out to me.

1:14:28And he said, you know what, he says, I don't like the idea of donating money when you're just going to throw it away to attorneys, because I'd rather have the money go to you. And this guy is, you wouldn't trust me, you would know who he is. And he actually got me thinking, you know, he's right. You know, the only reason I, you know, I really want to pardon was, you know, to get my gun rights back. But at the end of the day, does it really matter that if I have them back or not, you know, it's more of a, you took it away from me, dang it, I want it back.

1:15:11And, you know, more, it's more of a, you know, you know, it's been a long, you know, financial struggle for the last 13 years. And, you know, when I don't, I don't know if we mentioned this before, but, you know, when Carl Force and Shaun Bridges, they did false seizures against me. And so they stole, they went into their pocket, all every Bitcoin that I had, up to that point. And they went into my bank accounts and stole every dollar that I had.

1:15:54Not only did, not only did they steal the cash they had on my fanny pack, but they did false seizures. And so when I say I had no money, I had nothing. I was, I was using credit cards, and they can only go so far. You know, and so I, and so I know it sounds like I'm coming with a hat in hand, so to speak, but it's really more of, I, you know, it's really hard to get a job when you have a felon, a felony moniker next to your name.

1:16:37And, you know, and so it's more about, you know, helping, you know, what my wife went through. You know, I want to pay it back to her. You know, she suffered a lot. You know, my kids have suffered a lot. And, you know, and I, and I want to make it up to them somehow. And, you know, I absolutely have no retirement. I, you know, because I haven't had been able to work for 15 years. And so I thought, you know what, maybe this would be a good way to help kickstart things a little bit.

1:17:18You know, I'm, I turned 60 here in a couple of months. I can't believe if I'm getting that old. And so it's, you know, it's more, you know, you know, and it's kind of embarrassing to come out and say, hey, you know, you know, I need, I need help, you know, and so the first idea was, I want to go for a pardon. And then I started going down that rabbit hole and it's very, very expensive. Oh my gosh, you have to have a six figure just to even talk about it.

1:17:51But then my OG friend said, no, Curtis, we, I'd rather donate to you and make sure the money goes to you for, I don't know, I can't remember how you, what you did for Bitcoin, rather than throw it away against attorneys. So I'm grateful for anything that anybody's able to give. I know we're in tough times. And so I appreciate it if they do. If not, I understand as well. But my, you know, my goal is to educate, you know, tell people what happened, you know, with Silk Road.

1:18:33And to help keep educating others on sovereign money, Bitcoin, whether it, you see it as, you know, a lot of people like Zcash and Monero, I'm a fan of Monero and Z, huge Monero privacy coin. You know, I'm a huge fan of it. I've always thought it, you know, privacy coins are the future. The banking system's not going to like privacy coins at all. But I certainly think that's where it's going. And that's where I like, you know, like it to go. But anyway, I'm digressing again.

1:19:11But yeah, so for anybody that, you know, that's willing to donate, regardless, it's going to go for a good cause, whether it goes to... For right now, the goal is to, I'm going to go try the pardon route. If I can do it at a, at a reasonable amount, I will do it. But I'm definitely not going to mortgage, you know, put every single dime I have into it and then have it fall flat on my, on its face. You know, I, so I have a couple options open to me.

1:19:41And so, but I would appreciate anything that anybody, you know, I'm not, I have been able to save a little bit. You know, I buy Bitcoin every time I chance I get, but, you know, if it wasn't for Bitcoin, I wouldn't even be where I'm at. You know, cause I, it's how I've survived, you know, mining a little bit here and there, swapping it over to Zcash or Monero, and it would always go pay the, you know, it would just pay the electric bill.

1:20:12You know, I never knew it would slowly, you know, and of course hindsight's 20/20. And I think, man, if I would have just taken that alone and bought Bitcoin back in, you know,

1:20:26Vlad CosteaWell, it's not just about buying it. It's also having the knowledge or the conviction or just a good life overall to hold it. You know, holding is the challenge.

1:20:37Curtis GreenYes, it's like holding. I have to hand it to anybody that can hold Bitcoin for a long period of time. Because when you see, you know, the newer people coming in, you know, they, yeah, they see the 50,000 to 25,000, you know, which is, which is a big, big, big drop. But we think about the percentage back in 2011, it would go from $32 to $2. You do the same percentage today, you'd be 100,000 to 8,000. You know, that's what we had to deal with back then.

1:21:23You know, so you really did have to have a lot of conviction. And I'm sure most of the OGs that are selling right now, but they're all, I've always said, and this is just, I'm just guessing here, but I think all the OGs, most of the OGs that are dumping now, they were already rich. You know, because how can you hold all that Bitcoin from 2011 to today and not sell any? I just don't see how, that would be extremely tough.

1:21:57Vlad CosteaMaybe they got into other coins. They got into Ethereum and they sold that one, or they got into lots of these other token projects where maybe they made a fortune and they were just able to keep their Bitcoin.

1:22:12Curtis GreenWell, well, see, you know, even during the ICO era, you know, 2016, 17, most projects, you know, I'd start out, I'd never invest very much. I'd always start out with $50 or $100 and I would ride it up. Oh, it's worth seven, $8,000. And then it would come back down. And you think, oh, it'll recover. It goes down. Oh, now it's down to $1,000. Well, I'm screwed now. And you ride them down to the bottom. And that happened to me more often than not, as you know, because we were all searching, you know, because when Bitcoin was at 2,000 and when it dropped to $200 in 2013, it took four years for it to reach, before it broke $1,000 again.

1:23:08So, and I think that's why, and then when 2016, 17 came, that's when Bitcoin broke $1,000 again. But that's why all the ICOs came out. You know, they were coin after coin after coin. And I think a lot of us, me, I would have to put myself in the same boat. We were kind of like chasing the next Bitcoin. You know, we were like, oh, man, Bitcoin's at $2,000. But this token is at $0.10. You know, it has some great features. And, you know, I fell down that trap.

1:23:48And I know a lot of people have fallen down that trap. And another good buddy that said, this is, if people that were into Bitcoin in 2016 or 17, and say they didn't get caught up into an ICO project, they're lying. And I'd probably have to agree. Because back then, you just had to have this, you know, yeah, you know, the one thing I tried to never do is, what little Bitcoin I did have, I made sure that I didn't blow it on. Like other projects, I would go use the little cash I could find to put it towards it.

1:24:28But if I would have just stayed focused on Bitcoin, so I really did lose out. But I got sidetracked by all these other projects thinking they're promising, oh, the world, oh, it's gonna be better than Bitcoin. You know, because one of the things about Silk Road, I wouldn't say that it tainted Bitcoin. But people saw the association with Bitcoin and Silk Road, they kind of went hand in hand there at the beginning. So if Bitcoin had, if you talked about Bitcoin, it was like, oh, you must be doing something illegal.

1:25:14So that's what birthed a lot of these coins that, oh, we're transparent, you can't buy drugs with this, because we will know who you are. You know, I don't, you know, a lot of things happened, you know, back then, you know, Bitcoin and crypto, all the ICOs and all the projects, it's so much different today than what it was back in 2011. You know, we concentrated ourselves on one or two tokens, you know, Litecoin, I thought was neat, you know, I started, you know, I got into Litecoin, you know, in fact, I'm not very good friends with Charlie Lee, but I definitely met him and hung out with him.

1:25:57And so I saw his vision, and he wanted to be the silver to the gold, you know, but the problem is, it didn't stop there, it kept going and kept going, and pretty soon there was 30,000 different tokens. And that's when I kind of threw up my hands and said, no, Bitcoin, it's, you know, it's one of these privacy coins, or Bitcoin, that's where it's at.

1:26:30Vlad CosteaI don't think at this point it's going to be zero sum, because you also mentioned earlier into the interview that Ethereum does have a place in the world. And these privacy coins are very useful for many use cases, especially when you're dealing with Ethereum and Solana and all of these DeFi protocols, which have zero privacy. A lot of the traders like to swap their coins into Zcash or Monero, which sort of breaks the link between their trades, and then they swap back into Ethereum or whatever. And that's when they get a fresh start, which cannot be traced transaction by transaction.

1:27:08So there is some value into this. There is a lot of this stuff that you cannot do on Bitcoin. Maybe you can do it on second layers. Maybe I should plug the ad right now for LayerTwo Labs, which is one of the teams that's working on bringing every interesting altcoin use case to Bitcoin. Their specialty is the sidechain. And right now, if you go to layertwolabs.com/download, you can get the software that lets you run sidechains: an Ethereum sidechain, a Zcash sidechain, a prediction market, a Namecoin sidechain.

1:27:42I think there's also a big block sidechain, which prunes the blocks every three months or something, so it doesn't bloat. And I think it's really interesting. Unfortunately, it runs on the Bitcoin signet, which is used for testing purposes. In order to have the full feature on Bitcoin, we're going to need a soft fork, which is an upgrade that adds new rules to the protocol. And there needs to be a proper debate about this, whether or not people want it, because it's miner enforced and some people love it, others don't.

1:28:15And there needs to be proper consensus within the community. But before you make up your opinion based on my description, just have a nice weekend project, go to layertwolabs.com/download, try the software and make your own opinion as opposed to listening to other people. Also, there is Bitcoin.com News, which I just checked has an article about you from 2016, which is called Tales from a Dead Man, Curtis Green on Silk Road and Ross Ulbricht. This is actually a short interview that you can read on news.bitcoin.com and this is why I love it.

1:28:53They have a long time during which they posted articles. It's sort of like this historic place where you can find various moments in Bitcoin's evolution and history. And they also have right now, if you go to the website, I think they have a more balanced approach to news because Bitcoin Magazine is too focused on US politics and the Trump administration and CoinDesk is too focused on institutions. And I think Bitcoin.com News is like this nice middle ground between being too political and being too corporate. And sometimes you find news about parts of the world that you forgot they exist, but they also deal with Bitcoin and this is like a global revolution.

1:29:39So you should have this kind of coverage. So check it out and read this article. It's called dead-man-curtis-green-silk-road in the URL. But the full title is Tales from a Dead Man, Curtis Green on Silk Road, Ulbricht. And I think you're mentioned in like six different articles on the website, which I think is cool. It gives you the credentials.

1:30:01Curtis GreenYeah, well, it's been a freaking journey. It really has. And like I said, I'm not a perfect person. I've made my mistakes. But I hope that my little contribution, if you can call it that, will help humanity, which I think it will. You know, the main reason why we have wars is usually because of money, some sort of control. And I think Bitcoin has started us with that, has given us the power to take back control, where we decide what we want. Like when you just got done talking about, you know, we shouldn't be in an echo chamber.

1:31:05It's for us to decide, we should have a discussion on these layer twos and whatnot, which I 100% agree with. You know, whether, you know, soft forks or hard forks, you know, back, you know, they were easy when Satoshi was around, because they, you know, nobody really questioned it. They just needed to be done. Today, it's a whole different world, where you have to have a lot of consensus. You have to convince a lot more people and I hope we can get there. I hope we can all unite somehow and, you know, get all on the same, you know, try to be on the same page, you know, so we can, so we take back control.

1:31:59You know, in our hands, let us decide what money is, rather than a government. You know, and then, you know, we're worried about what the government, you know, what they could do with our information. You know, I want to be able to control my information. And I think we now have the tools to do all that. And I think the discussion is there, you know, what's the next step? How do we make sure, you know, that we do this without losing our way? And so the discussion, you know, I say keep the discussion, always keep the channels open.

1:32:42Always discuss, always debate, because debating is good. Even though you may not like the other person's point of view, they might say something, it might trigger you to go, oh, you are right. I never thought about that in that perspective. And I think, you know, this will be controversial, but one of the things that Silk Road helped us, helped me go with developing who I am as a person, even though I made mistakes, I did things I shouldn't have done, but it's opened my eyes more to the world around me.

1:33:31Does that make sense? Before I was the type of person that would just, oh, I see on the news, I believed it. And now I question everything.

1:33:42Vlad CosteaThat's because you were on the news and you know exactly what happened and you were able to watch a documentary about the movement in which you were part. And then you saw how the events got distorted just maybe for getting more emotional reactions out of the audience or just for the sake of it, because they want to control the narrative. And once you find yourself in this situation where you know exactly what you did and what you said, and the portrayal of all of these events is different, that's exactly when you sort of lose faith and you realize that it kind of is a big scam.

1:34:21To me, it was also related to Bitcoin, because I discovered it when it, I think the price was like three, four hundred dollars in 2013. That's when I read about it the first time. I was 21 years old and I was on some internet meme page that somehow had a mention of Bitcoin. And I went to the Wikipedia page about Bitcoin, because there was one, and it described an internet currency that was used for buying drugs on the Silk Road, but was also used for humanitarian purposes for onboarding people without a bank account in Africa.

1:34:59And my first reaction was, okay, I'm neither of these. I'm not into drugs and I have a bank account. So if I have a bank account, it means I don't need Bitcoin. Case closed. And I dismissed it within 10 minutes and I moved on with my life. It's just that it kept coming back over the years and I wanted to buy a couple of years later. But there was this new story about Bitcoin being dead. There was this developer, Mike Hearn, who was working at the protocol level on the Bitcoin project, and he said that Bitcoin is dead and it's not progressing and it's basically something that can be dismissed already as a failed project.

1:35:44I think that's the way in which he described it. Bitcoin is a failed project. And when I saw that, I was like, yeah, it was in the Financial Times, you're right.

1:35:56Curtis GreenYeah, Bitcoin could have failed multiple times.

1:36:03Vlad CosteaOh, that's what you said, that it could have failed multiple times. What I'm trying to say here is that it was another major mainstream media story that gave me assurance and I was like, yeah, I was so right to not buy this Bitcoin. I was so smart. Look at me. I could have lost so much money. But a year later, the price went back to $1,000. And that's when I realized that there's a disconnect here between what happens in the markets and what the media tells me. And that's when I started thinking for myself.

1:36:35Curtis GreenYeah, and you finally had that aha moment. And, you know, we all have that aha moment. It just depends on when you have that aha moment. It took me till I was, you know, 45 years old before I realized, oh my gosh, I've been lied to. You know, I mean, I can't trust the Republicans every, you know, every time they go out and speak, you know, like, heaven forbid, you know, and now, you know, seeing, you know, going through everything that I've gone through, I'm now, what's that, I am now, there's that saying, I'm asleep, but now I'm awake, or something like that.

1:37:21And that's exactly how I feel. I feel like I've been asleep this whole time. And now I've been awoken. And now I look at the world with a fresh set of eyes. And, you know, and I'm grateful for every day that I have here on earth. And I hope that we, you know, that the world can turn into a better place. And I think, you know, Bitcoin is a tool that will help us whether, you know, whether, I mean, something with, you know, with Bitcoin, whether it's Bitcoin in today's form or Bitcoin, you know, as they change it or whatever they, in the future, it's, I think it will, it's a part of who we are.

1:38:12It's in our DNA. And...

1:38:16Vlad CosteaOkay, but I do want to add something to your description. So you mentioned the aha moment when you realize that the media is lying to you, but there's another aha moment when you get involved in Bitcoin and you realize that everything that you say and everything that you do is going to shape up this narrative that the media is going to portray, which makes you feel small and insignificant in some ways, but also very powerful because as the movement grows and becomes stronger and you're part of it, basically your voice gets amplified and whatever crazy story you make up and the community picks up and somehow it ends up in some fringe news website about Bitcoin, maybe it's going to get picked up by the mainstream media and suddenly it becomes a much bigger thing.

1:39:07And of course you already know that it's all a scam and maybe that this is also how history was written and we're not very much aware of it. We just take it as is because it was written by some historian, but maybe it was made up to the same degree. But it's another aha moment when you realize, okay, I actually have the power to shape the narrative and basically change the world around me with the words that I use and the stuff that I say.

1:39:37Curtis GreenYeah. So, yeah, whether you're a fan of Bitcoin or whatever, I think with all the controversies that Bitcoin has, I think it's good that there are controversies because it creates more narrative and I think that's probably the whole big point of it. What I'm trying to say is, before my Silk Road experience, I think I lived in a bubble and now, like I said, I question everything. I look at everything with one eye open and I want to learn more about it. Whether I agree with it or not, I need to educate myself before I can really have a good point of view because I don't want to say something like, oh, I don't feel this way and I'm against you, but I don't know why I'm against you.

1:40:40I need to find out. Every little aspect before I, you know, it's hard to explain, but going back to the Silk Road, my whole Silk Road experience has gotten me here. So even though I've gone through all, you know, the hell and whatever, it was, you know, I can't even compare, you know, what Ross went through having spent 10 years in prison. I'm sure that was miserable. I could only, you know, but you know, at least, you know, at least he, you know, a right has been wronged and, you know, and he's out, which is a very good thing, you know, and, you know, and we have Bitcoin.

1:41:27And I think that as long as we keep pushing and learning and questioning, that's the big point is, don't, you know, I'm not afraid to talk. I'm not afraid to ask questions. I'm not afraid, oh, I might offend this person by bringing up another point of view, you know, because maybe I'll trigger something. They might change my point of view, you know, just because it's hard to describe. But anyway, but yeah, the whole, the whole Silk Road experience was, I think, I was meant, it was meant to be, I don't know if it was a higher power had it was, you know, but it was, for me, it was meant to happen, I think.

1:42:25And while I don't wish some of the things on my worst enemy that I went through, it was called life, life experiences, you know, I, and I'm grateful that, you know, I made it through the other end. And I'm grateful for my wife, for, you know, the few family members that did stick by me, I'm grateful for, you know, for what they did. There were very few of them. But at least the people that I care about most did, you know, my children, and my wife.

1:43:01And, but yeah, it's, you know, it's not, you know, people, it's too easy for people to look out, side and look in and judge. And that's one of the reasons why I'm going to speak out a little bit more. And I'm, you know, you know, so at least people know who I am. You know, because I, there's, you know, I would, would tweet something about, I don't know, had nothing to do with the topic that we were talking about. But they'd come back, oh, you were just an admin on Silk Road, you were just basically a drug dealer.

1:43:46And I'm like, man, how naive are they? You know, you know, for not all they all they look at, they see the name, and they probably do a little Google search on me. And then, you know, the first things that come up are, they make me sound like I'm the devil. You know, you know, like, I'm just the worst person on earth. And they don't even know me from Adam. And in some cases, I don't know what I am. So it's really been an eye opener.

1:44:13And I, and I hope that I can still be out there and help, and help others. You know, I always talk about Bitcoin. I always talk about how to learn what it is, you know, maybe Bitcoin's not for them, maybe they want, they want to go with Ethereum, maybe that's their, you know, a lot, I know a lot of people are, you know, saying, why don't you like Ripple? And I'm like, it's not this, I don't like it. It's just that, I'd rather focus on Bitcoin.

1:44:48And if you want to focus on your project, more power to you. So, it's just, I think we need to educate and not shut down other people's voices, which unfortunately Hollywood is really good at doing that. They shut down everybody. If it's not their way, it's the highway. And it's a shame actually. And they're getting theirs though. Hollywood's not doing so great right now. So, but yeah, I'm excited for where the future is going. I'm excited where Bitcoin is going. Granted, there's still a lot of controversies going on, but I'm excited for the future. I am very optimistic about our future.

1:45:51All our political issues we still have, but I think Bitcoin will help us solve those things. What do they say? Just like 2% of the world's population has really ever heard of, really know about Bitcoin or something like that. The number is fairly low. And I wish people would educate themselves more on Bitcoin and what it is, what it was. Not necessarily focus on today's Bitcoin, but go back and research what people thought about in 2010, 2011, how little faith that we had in Bitcoin. Because people were still learning.

1:46:40People were still trying to figure it out. Granted, you have your cryptographers and whatnot, that, oh, I knew it all along that this was going to be the thing. But me, not your regular person on the road, you're gonna, it's a lot of education. Andreas Antopoulos, I'm sure I murdered his name, but he's-

1:47:01Vlad CosteaIt's Antonopoulos.

1:47:02Curtis GreenYeah. Yes, I've spoke with him a few times and he's a great educator. And I learned a lot from him. So he's one of my first early guys that I learned when I was going down my 2013 rabbit hole. So there's a lot of those guys' voices are still resonating today. And I just hope that I can be one of those voices.

1:47:31Vlad CosteaActually, Andreas Antonopoulos got canceled by the Bitcoiners in 2021, I think, when he wrote a book called Mastering Ethereum. And they hated him because he wrote a book about Ethereum. And that's why nowadays he's very quiet.

1:47:47Curtis GreenYeah, that's a shame because back in the day, he was it, man. And I know a lot of Bitcoiners got together. They found out that he didn't own any Bitcoin, I think in 2018 or 19.

1:48:08Vlad CosteaIt was late 2017 when he tweeted that he's happy that a lot of people are getting rich from the Bitcoin pump, but at the same time, he doesn't own too much Bitcoin because he had to support his sick mother.

1:48:21Curtis GreenOh, is that it?

1:48:22Vlad CosteaSomething like this. And that's when people started donating a lot of money to him. And I think he received more than 50 Bitcoin, which was like a million dollars at the time, at 20,000. And yeah, it was a very emotional moment. And it was nice from the community that they were able to get together and establish that this guy is a valuable community member. He deserves to receive something. And yeah, that was one of the most wholesome moments in the history of Bitcoin, to be honest.

1:48:56Curtis GreenYeah, it really was. See, that's what I remember. I remember when they were doing donations to him because he helped shape me in how I thought about Bitcoin and he educated me. I was grateful that the community rallied around him like that.

1:49:19Vlad CosteaI think it was also the fact that Roger Ver commented and he said, well, you should have kept some of the Bitcoin that you received over the years. And it was this comment that made some people angry, especially since Roger was sort of antagonistic at the time with the Bitcoin Cash fork and some Bitcoiners did not like him. So just to spite him, they started sending more to Andreas.

1:49:43Curtis GreenOh, okay, that makes sense, that makes sense. Yeah, yeah, that's a shame that they're really infighting, but I guess people will be people.

1:49:54Vlad CosteaOh, we have more of it today, it gets even crazier.

1:49:56Curtis GreenI know, I know, it's getting worse, it seems like. It depends on what you look at, but yeah. I'm just grateful. That's one thing I like about your podcast is you're not afraid to tell your opinion and you definitely don't go with the crowd. You know where you stand. So I wanted to just let you know that I appreciate what you do.

1:50:37Vlad CosteaI appreciate what you do also. So it's nice that we got together for this interview. I know I'm trying to stay away from the mainstream narrative and be contrarian in some ways. But also I do consider myself to be sort of a Bitcoin historian. Like I dig up some stuff and I realize how far we have strayed from the principles or the aspirations that we used to have back in the day. So part of the purpose of my show isn't just to talk about events and people and what they're working on, but also to remind people what Bitcoin was supposed to be. Because I don't think we're on that path.

1:51:16Curtis GreenI have to agree. I've talked to a lot of people that were around in the early days and they feel like Bitcoin is not the same as it was.

1:51:29Vlad CosteaThis is not the revolution to which I signed up.

1:51:32Curtis GreenYeah, exactly. That's exactly what they're trying to say. They're saying Bitcoin is not the Bitcoin that I signed up for. And I thought, oh, that's an interesting take. Because they always say tick tock, next block. And Bitcoin really hasn't changed that much over the years. There's been little tweaks here and there, but it's been the same, but it's been the narrative that has changed, I think.

1:52:12Vlad CosteaExactly. The worst part is that people forget so easily about something that happened just a few years ago. And whoever comes in, throws a lot of big money at the project, becomes the new educator, quote unquote. Like the latest one, I think, is Michael Saylor. And now we also have all of these ETF people who also have, I think, a disproportionate amount of control over what Bitcoin is and how it's used. And I just don't see how we're going to build a grassroots, peer-to-peer economy on top of this.

1:52:47Maybe there are ways, but at the same time, I think since we don't have much privacy and so far the layer twos are not what we were promised. They're not something that can onboard 8 billion people, and they're not something that are very easy to use at this point. There's a variance of UX as a user experience that people have, and there are some adjustments and education needed to onboard something like Lightning. And once again, Lightning doesn't scale to 8 billion people, it just scales to normal Bitcoiners.

1:53:23Curtis GreenYeah. I ran a Lightning node, and boy, when I got into it a few years ago, I thought, oh, this is it. But as I went down the Lightning rabbit hole, I realized it's great and everything, but it has its own set of problems.

1:53:39Vlad CosteaWhat kind of node do you run?

1:53:42Curtis GreenI think I just turned it off. I just ran a regular, I Love Poker was the name of it. It was just a regular node, it was on my little Raspberry Pi, what's the program, Umbrel. I ran it on Umbrel, but it was costing me more money in sats to do the transaction, because you have to go on chain. I was like, wait a minute, I didn't expect to make money doing it, but I was slowly bleeding the precious satoshis that I did have. And then that's when I realized that the ones that keep the Lightning centralized, they can control it.

1:54:40And then that's the problem with Lightning, it's a centralized, the only way you can really make it work, it's centralized.

1:54:48Vlad CosteaI found your node.

1:54:50Curtis GreenOh, it probably turned off.

1:54:53Vlad CosteaYeah, so there's this website that's called 1ML.com, and it's like an explorer for the Lightning Network. Basically, you have or had 0.09 BTC in capacity, which at today's rate is like $9,000. Four channels that are still active. It was last seen seven months ago, and it was first seen three years ago.

1:55:18Curtis GreenYeah, that timing sounds about right. And I still have high hopes for Lightning. I know the couple programmers that run it, that code it, and I still have hopes that it will change. And then I'm going down, I've gone down the Liquid rabbit hole, and hopefully maybe that will be a great layer two.

1:55:49Vlad CosteaThat's a federation, right? It's secured by a bunch of exchanges and members who are politically controlling the chain. It's easy to get in, but it's very hard to get out because you need the permission of at least one federation member to take your funds out. So it's definitely not like Bitcoin, and it's not the sidechain that Blockstream promised that they were going to build.

1:56:13Curtis GreenYeah, like I said, I haven't gone down the Liquid route, I hear bits and pieces of it. It's just that...

1:56:22Vlad CosteaSome people, just in the name of maintaining their purity and only staying on layers that only use BTC, they embraced pretty much anything, even at the expense of going custodial. And custodial means basically using a bank. And I think right now, Ethereum is the biggest layer two for Bitcoin, because they have more than 100,000 BTC locked in it on something that's called wrapped Bitcoin, WBTC. And the way in which that works is that people have locked or frozen their funds on the Bitcoin chain, and they issued it as a token on the Ethereum chain.

1:57:01And I think it's very popular for a lot of these DeFi applications. And it obviously is, but at the same time, you hear a lot of people talking about how great Lightning is, and how they use it, and how they set up a node. But I haven't seen anyone really praise WBTC on Ethereum, which is like 25 times larger in terms of liquidity.

1:57:26Curtis GreenYeah, Yeah. Yeah. You know, I've always wondered, you know, it's one of those rabbit holes, rabbit things I haven't gone down too much. But I remember when they came out with wrapped Bitcoin, they said, be careful, you know, you're wrapping, you know, we don't know where this is going to go. Just be careful with your Bitcoin. And then I've always wondered if now that wrapped Bitcoin is, could that be rehypothecated somehow? You know, I mean, I'm just throwing out, you know, issues that, you know, like, because that's how people take loans out.

1:58:04You know, like wrapped coin, Coinbase has their own thing. And I was in this low interest, or lower interest, and I thought, how can they get away with charging, one company charges 5%, or they charge 5%, another charges 13% interest. And I thought, is there any way that they could be rehypothecating it somehow? Because you really can't see the Bitcoin, it's wrapped. You know, so that brings up questions like, is wrapped a really safe way of holding Bitcoin? You know, it's just one of those questions that I bring up.

1:58:47Vlad CosteaIt's a trusted bridge, because you have to trust, first of all, that BitGo, which is the custodian of the Bitcoin, has all of the coins that were issued. And you also have to trust whoever is in charge of this, and I understand Justin Sun somehow ended up being in control of the WBTC thing.

1:59:08Curtis GreenOh yeah, I remember, yeah.

1:59:12Vlad CosteaMy point is that it's, once again, a suboptimal solution, but at the same time it's the most popular one. So it seems like the market doesn't really care. And I wish, once again, I wish this was on Bitcoin, I wish we had proper layers for scaling, I wish we had all the features so that all of these workarounds were not necessary. But this is what we have to put up with.

1:59:38Curtis GreenAnd I think that's what, with Roger Ver was one of his big things back in 2016-17, didn't he try to bring up these, you know, it was a block size thing back then. But I don't, you know, I kept out, my technical knowledge is not there, so I couldn't. So what's the point that Roger was making? Well, I think, well, you just see, Roger was saying that, you know, block size, you know, we don't, you know, block size, we should keep making the block size bigger. That was the solution.

2:00:13And at first I was like, oh, all for that. But then when I, but when I started realizing, oh, but if the blocks get so big, then we, I couldn't run my own node here, you know, because I, the block, you know, you'd have to have terabyte upon terabyte upon terabytes of information. And so it keeps the little guy out. From running a node, you know, so that's...

2:00:42Vlad CosteaThat's inherently nihilistic, to be honest. Like if the block was two times bigger than, if the block size was two times bigger than it is now, it would not be catastrophical. Today I went to one of these computer shops and I saw that they have a two terabyte hard drive for like $50.

2:01:04Curtis GreenYeah. Well, yeah. Yeah. And I think even when Satoshi, in one of his emails, he stated that even if they did as much transactions as Visa did in the day, that's only three DVD sizes, or, you know, in one day.

2:01:32Vlad CosteaThat's what Satoshi said, so this was in November, if I'm not mistaken, of 2008, so about 17 years ago, when Satoshi posted on, it's called metzdowd, it was the cryptography mailing list hosted by Perry Metzger. And he posted about Bitcoin in there. And the first response that he got was from someone named James A. Donald, who said, well, this doesn't scale. And Satoshi came back and said, well, if you assume that Moore's law is going to continue, and we're going to have this amount of storage and this cost for bandwidth, then you can also take the amount of transactions that Visa is processing today.

2:02:15And you're going to see that with my design, you can have Visa volume of transactions that you can store on this amount of DVDs. And you can already download to the DVD in this number of minutes. And it was this entire explanation. And it's been used by the big block side of Bitcoin to explain that Satoshi always wanted this, even though I can agree that it's not the best design for it. Yeah, I don't think the point of scaling at any moment was to basically increase the block size to the point that you can have 8 billion people joining immediately.

2:02:53And even if you read the Lightning Network paper, which the Lightning Network is perceived as this moment when small blocks make sense because you can move the transactions to a second layer. The Lightning Network in the white paper says that you need like 200 megabyte blocks to be able to work at scale to compare the capacity of the Lightning Network with Visa, assuming that every user will only open one channel and close one channel per year. So if every person on the planet does this...

2:03:30Curtis GreenYes, that's the problem you're going to have with Lightning is you still have to go on-chain and off-chain somewhere. So if you have this big use, it's got to go on the chain and off eventually, so you're going to have that problem somewhere along the line. So that Lightning can be running wonderfully by itself, but the second they should be able to go on or off, then you're still going to have that problem with block size.

2:04:02Vlad CosteaThat's why I like my friend Paul's proposal for drivechains, which are sidechains that the miners control. So basically they also collect transaction fees from them, which is another problem that this solves because Lightning right now cannibalizes the transaction fee market. The miners are not collecting any fees from the Lightning transactions. And that's also a problem that we're going to run into maybe in a decade as the mining rewards are going to get cut in half every four years. And then we're going to see how we do need to keep the miners running.

2:04:39And the only ways in which we can do it is to give them more fees. One way is to increase the block size and other ways to get these sidechains which pay transaction fees to the miners. The most extreme way I think is to get rid of the 21 million cap, have inflation just to pay the miners. I think that would be the least desirable solution to this problem. Anyway, my girlfriend just gave me this. It's something that she made out of Legos. It's a Pepe.

2:05:11Curtis GreenOh, that's cool. Yeah, my son would love that. He's a Lego fan. Yeah, that's cool.

2:05:19Vlad CosteaThat's neat. She's super creative.

2:05:22Curtis GreenYeah, that's cool. All these questions and problems that we have, eventually, if we want to have Bitcoin as a true way of money to be able to really peer to peer, something has to be changed. Whether it's a level two, I know there's a lot of different level two options out there. People are proposing different things. But I don't know. Do you think we'll ever come to a consensus? Do you think we'll all agree to, yes, this is the way to go?

2:06:18Vlad CosteaI don't think there is one way to go. I think that there should be an open market that lets these protocols compete for users. And in the end, we're going to get maybe two or three of them which stick around. It's obvious that Lightning was overhyped and we were promised that this was going to be the one and only solution to scale Bitcoin. It did not become that. And now we live in a world where we need to figure out other ways because so much capital and energy was invested in Lightning that we sort of became complacent.

2:06:54And other chains are starting to profit from the fact that Bitcoin did not scale. Other chains are profiting from the fact that Bitcoin did not get smart contracts. And other chains are profiting from the fact that Bitcoin did not become private. Because Zcash is basically Bitcoin with the Zerocash protocol added on top of it, which was proposed for Bitcoin in 2013 or 14. So a lot of these projects would not exist if we actually improved Bitcoin.

2:07:24Curtis GreenYeah, and I think Roger Ver brought that up. I can't remember, he was saying if we would have just all stuck with the same narrative and not created all these different coins, you know, look where we, you know, it cannibalized itself, or you know, all these projects started up. And if we would have just come together, I think Roger Ver said that, that we would have, Bitcoin would be a lot further along today than what it is. Because then maybe he's right, maybe he's wrong, but it's got to scale somehow.

2:08:11And if we wanted to use it as, you know, real money. And, you know, back in 2011, I think it's funny, well, not funny, but it's that the blocks were empty. You know, so we would go, I remember doing it myself, I would fill a block up with a picture, you know.

2:08:36Vlad CosteaOr you could send transactions with no fee, and they would still get mined.

2:08:41Curtis GreenYeah, oh yeah, I remember when we had to do, put a fee, I was like, wait a minute, what happened? You know, because you didn't have to put a fee in, because they were, it was, they were mostly empty. And so I was shocked that, wait a minute, we actually have to put a fee in now? It was, I think it was like 2013 or 14 is when fees really started to happen. I mean, I might be wrong on my timing, but yeah, 2012, 11, man, the blocks were totally empty.

2:09:14It didn't cost a thing to, it didn't cost anything to send. And then you would see literally six transactions, you know, in a block or none at all, you know. It's just kind of funny to think back at all that. But yeah, I'm, you know, where Bitcoin is at today, you know, some people can say we're in a better place. Some people will say we're in a worse place. You know, we're, it's obviously somewhere in the middle, I'm assuming.

2:09:57But, you know, but to bring up your point with Zcash, you know, I always thought, why didn't they just add that, it was probably, didn't you just say that it was, it was, it was given, it was, they tried to make it implemented into Bitcoin?

2:10:14Vlad CosteaYeah, they actually did that for two years and a half before they launched Zcash. So the paper was published, they pitched it to Bitcoin developers. It was a bunch of researchers like Matthew Green and a few other academics. Eli Ben-Sasson was also on the show. And by virtue of him being from Tel Aviv and being Jewish, a lot of people today, they act like, oh, this Zcash thing is a Jewish conspiracy. It's something that was made by the Jews to whatever, have a backdoor in transactions or whatever. So it uses zero knowledge proofs, which for a long time were considered to be theoretical and not practical.

2:10:57And these guys came up with a protocol to add to Bitcoin so that you could hide your transactions from the rest of the world. In zero knowledge proofs with these shielded pools, you only see that there is one transaction or two transactions or whatever. So you see the number, but you don't see the sender, you don't see the receiver and you don't see the amounts.

2:11:20Curtis GreenDidn't CZ just come out and say that no Zcash will be allowed on Binance if it's ever been anonymized?

2:11:32Vlad CosteaThere are workarounds for that. I mean, you can withdraw from the anonymity pool to a transparent address and then move it like three, four times to different transparent addresses and then send it to Binance. But honestly, fuck Binance. Fuck them. You don't have to use it. You don't have to comply with their request.

2:11:51Curtis GreenI've never had an account there. In fact, that's one of the few places I've never had an account. It was Binance. But I've been Mt. Goxed. I've been Bitfinexed. Oh, that's another whole new topic.

2:12:07Vlad CosteaOh, yeah, we should talk about that, too. But let me present the last two sponsors of this episode and then we can get into other topics. So which one should I pick first? Let's pick NoOnes.com, which is this peer-to-peer marketplace where the goal is to empower the Global South. And the CEO, Ray Youssef, is previously known for Paxful, another exchange for which he was CEO, but that one was shut down for reasons which concern U.S. regulations that he did not like. And now he has NoOnes, which is...

2:12:42Curtis GreenI was a market maker for him. I was a market maker on Paxful. I would loan Bitcoin to people that were... Oh, yeah, then they shut it down. Do you know Ray?

2:12:55I went to their site because you could get a little Bitcoin and you'd lend it out for like two or three days. It was DeFi before DeFi. And then we'd lend the Bitcoin. I never lent it out for more than two or three days because there was risks involved. And then it was short-term and he gave Pax. Pax got 25% of whatever we made and then the API developers got 10%. But it was interesting that, yeah, I like that. That brought back a lot of memories. But it was like, I always say, yeah, we did DeFi before DeFi.

2:13:34Vlad CosteaNow he's running NoOnes. It's NoOnes.com. And he has this peer-to-peer marketplace where most of the traders are people from Africa, the Middle East or South America. And it also has this fee structure or what Ray calls everyone gets a seat at the table and everyone eats because as you sell the coins down the line, there's a fee up until people who actually need it and they use it in their peer-to-peer daily economy. So if you're trading on NoOnes, you're actually helping these people get access to coins that their governments cannot take away from them.

2:14:12And there's also a spot marketplace. There's also a debit card that you can use for spending. I don't think this works in the US at all. And this is part of the reason why Paxful was wound down. I don't think winded exists. So it's wound down. And yeah, NoOnes.com. Check it out. I think it's really interesting. And last but not least, there is SideShift, which is a platform for swapping coins. So if someone offers to pay you in USDT or USDC or these stablecoins, and you're very much aware that they can be confiscated and seized and they're not as censorship resistant as Bitcoin, then it's a good idea possibly to swap these coins for BTC, for LTC, for ETH, for everything that you might be interested in, which is more decentralized and more resistant to censorship.

2:15:13And the way in which you can do it is to not even touch the stablecoins. So you go to SideShift.ai. You choose, for example, the USDT to BTC pair. You paste your Bitcoin address, and then you're gonna receive a stablecoin address that you send to the person wanting to pay you in stablecoins. And there's gonna be a swap once they send out that transaction. You receive the BTC to your wallet, and you don't have to stress about anything else. The liquidity is pretty good. The fees are low. Check it out. It's SideShift.ai. I don't think they're available in the US, unfortunately.

2:15:54Curtis GreenI used to work with SideShift when they were in the US, and I like...

2:16:00Vlad CosteaAre you sure it was SideShift and not ShapeShift?

2:16:03Curtis GreenOh, ShapeShift is what I'm talking about.

2:16:09Vlad CosteaBecause some people confuse them. I think ShapeShift was first, and then SideShift came later when ShapeShift started doing mandatory KYC. That's when SideShift started to get traction, because it was the alternative without KYC.

2:16:22Curtis GreenYeah. In fact, it's on my wallet still, so I can't access. I have like $40 worth of something on there.

2:16:31Vlad CosteaMaybe now it's more than $40, because that was five, six years ago.

2:16:36Curtis GreenYeah, that's true. It was dust of some sort, of one of the coins.

2:16:42Vlad CosteaIt's good to keep an eye on this dust, because you never know.

2:16:45Curtis GreenOh, yeah. It was crazy. Back when we would transfer, it was always transferring 30 Bitcoin, 40 Bitcoin, 50 Bitcoin. Anything less than one Bitcoin, it was just like, what is this? We considered it dust. If it was 0.9, I would worry about it, but if it was a 0.0 anything, I wouldn't even think about it. The thinking was so screwy, because we didn't see that 0.08 might one day be worth thousands of dollars one day. We got so tunnel-visioned in sending 50 Bitcoin or 100 Bitcoin or 30 Bitcoin, because the dollar value was so low. It's certainly changed a lot.

2:17:48I certainly hope that we have some sort of consensus, or at least some sort of consensus... A lot of people are banking on the ETFs. They're all excited about when Ripple was getting their own ETF that's going to change the world for them. I'm like, be careful what you wish for. It might be good in the short term, but you never know what the long term is going to bring.

2:18:23I remember one thing about Bitcoin back from the early days, we were always, when will it be adopted by mainstream companies? That's what I always looked for. Then Michael Saylor showed up, and I'm like, oh, well, here we go. He's done a lot of good things for Bitcoin. I'm sure there's other people who will say the opposite. But you think Wall Street has to jump on board somewhere for it to succeed. Maybe not. That's where I get caught up in my old thinking. Back in the day, it was literally peer to peer.

2:19:15If you wanted to turn it into dollars, it was like an act of God. The one exchange, it was so hard. In fact, it was easier to go into gift cards and swap it to put it on a gift card than it was to turn it into dollars.

2:19:34They're from Georgia, and this is early on, we're talking 2011, and you could only send up to $1,000 worth. They had a low amount, and you would just send them the Bitcoin in total trust. You'd say, okay, and then you gave them your mailing address, and they would mail you a postal money order for the Bitcoin that you just sold them. And, I mean, I didn't hear of anybody getting screwed over, you know, and then we'd take the postal money order and cash it, you know, and that's how we turned it into, you know, it would take like two weeks, you know, to do that.

2:20:25Vlad CosteaDid you also buy alpaca socks or some of these?

2:20:27Curtis GreenYou know, I did, I did, from Australia, yeah, I actually. And there was also a young kid here in Utah, I don't know what's happened to him, I know he got popular on Bitcoin Talk, he sold honey, and it was from Logan, Utah, and I was wondering what happened to that kid, because he got kind of popular on Bitcoin Talk, and people supported him, and he set up his own little site to sell, you know, honey, you know, because, you know, Bitcoin and bees, you know, kind of, you know, it's a lot of, you know, they go hand in hand, and so, yeah, I bought honey from him, and that's, you know, that's how we transacted, you know.

2:21:15Vlad CosteaWhat's some of the other stuff that you bought with Bitcoin, do you remember?

2:21:18Curtis GreenOh, I bought the alpaca sock, I bought, oh, I bought a, in fact, it was the first, one of the first transactions, I bought 800 Bitcoin, it was worth, like, it was like $600 or something, I can't remember, and I was gonna buy, it was when iPhones were, or iPads were just coming out, and Samsung tried to create their version of an iPad, and it failed, and so, and I was trying to get my hands on, they were selling them all really cheap, for like 20 bucks a piece, but you couldn't find them, and I found a guy who I thought I could trust, and he says, oh, I take Bitcoin, and I really did, it was one of my first transactions ever with Bitcoin, it was 700 or 800 of them, I didn't trust them fully, I said, here, I'll send you half up front, then send me a few, you know, send me a few, and then I'll send the rest.

2:22:21Well, I got ripped off, you know, of course it was a scam, but that was my first foray into Bitcoin, was those, and I think, oh man, I would love to have those Bitcoin back, you know, but we didn't see it as, we didn't really see it as dollars, we saw it as a tool, you know, it's hard to describe, you can't, you know, because right now it's all about turning into Bitcoin into dollars, but back then, you really, you could, but that wasn't the goal, the goal was to transact in Bitcoin, you know, I did lots of, oh, a lot of services, you know, oh, you need some help doing this, I'll help you, I'll help you with that technical service, and I would pay in Bitcoin, you know, and that's, you know, that's how it was, you know, back then, it was more Bitcoin to Bitcoin transactions, and that's where I wish we would go more today, we're more, we've turned into a bunch of holders, which is, I guess, good in a way, but we're not spending it like we used to, you know, because back in 2011, we was, Bitcoin would come out, go out, in and out, in and out, now it comes in, and it doesn't go out, because we're waiting for the number to go up, and, you know, and I, and so, you know, I don't know if it's hurt, or helped or hurt us, but that's one big difference that I see, is we don't, we, as Bitcoiners, we should spend our Bitcoin as if it were, you know, rather than waiting for the dollar to go up, use it like it was intended to be used, and I don't know, I don't know if we'll ever get to that point, because we want, we all were waiting for that Bitcoin to hit a million dollars, you know, and we get so focused on the dollar amount, that we lose focus on what Bitcoin used to be, and what Bitcoin should be, and which is a means of transaction, a means of trading this for a service, and I don't know, you know, I've gone back and forth on this a lot, I think maybe it's good, maybe it's bad, you know, but the end of the day, you know, you think, oh, I have so few Bitcoin left, or so little Bitcoin left, I hope I have enough to survive, you know, I hope it doesn't crash by 80%, like it has done in the past, you know, and we're putting all our faith into that, the dollarized, which, when you think about it's crazy, because Bitcoin was supposed to get us out of the dollar, because we stopped thinking about dollars so much, because I remember one of the early great conversation on Bitcoin Talk that I had, somebody brought up the fact that, oh, one day, we're going to send.00, you know, 1,000 Satoshis, in fact, I don't even know if we called them 1,000 Satoshis back then, you know, we're going to send 1,000 Satoshis to pay our rent, and I remember that conversation, thinking, at the time, I go, that's crazy, something to, Bitcoins are supposed to be sent in multiples of 10, and I never, you know, and I don't know if we've changed, or if the government forced us to change, you know, did Wall Street come in, you know, and change it for us, you know, so I don't know, there's a lot of questions that need to be answered, you know, because I feel, well, I still feel Bitcoin is still Bitcoin, but I do feel that there's a little bit of disconnect somewhere, I can't put my finger on it, but I, you know, but I still feel the roots of Bitcoin are there, does that make sense?

2:26:56Vlad CosteaYeah, it does, and sometimes I also rant about the fact that adoption a few years ago was much bigger, as in we had Dell and we had Expedia and we had Microsoft and we had Steam and a bunch of these online stores that actually accepted Bitcoin peer-to-peer, and now there's less of it, actually there's more of the gift card exchanges that you can actually find for being able to shop on Amazon or whatever, so we sort of reverted to a different model, the adoption was not just slowed down, but removed as part of the goal, because now you're not supposed to spend your Bitcoin, you're not supposed to use it for anything which involves money transactions, you just hold it and then you borrow money against it, and to me this never made much sense.

2:27:51Curtis GreenYeah, and see, and I never thought I would think to feel that way, you know, because I always, but Bitcoin is so hard to keep, and it's so hard, each Bitcoin is so precious now, and maybe it's the fact that there's so few of them, and granted that gives most of its allure, you know, the scarcity, so you can break it down to 100 million satoshis, so that really shouldn't be an issue, you know, I don't know what the answer is, but I hope that we use it as money, and I hope that a layer 2, maybe Lightning will surprise us somehow, and maybe they'll come out with a neater, cooler way, but I don't know, I get disenfranchised, I still have faith, but I still get worried, you know, especially my wife, she goes, oh what if Bitcoin totally fails, and the little bit that we do have becomes worthless, and you know, or won't be worthless, but you know, it's a weird feeling when your whole life has been wrapped around Bitcoin for the last 13 years, and you know, when I started out, I thought, oh I'll, because I think, like I've said this before, I always thought Bitcoin would be easy to obtain, like we'd always be able to mine it, we'd always be able to keep adding to our, but in 2013, that's when I noticed, ooh it's getting tougher to keep, it's tougher to mine, it's not like, you know, with a little set of miners you can mine 100 Bitcoin in a month fairly easily, and now, and then it got to 2013 where that same set up.

2:30:08It was like half a Bitcoin, or less, and then it got less and less and less, and so it got, wait a minute, so now I'm gonna have to pay thousands of dollars for that same Bitcoin, you know, so I think it's a mixture of everything. But, yeah, I, it's been, man, it's been quite the journey, and the thing is that we're still early, we're still so new, you know, we're still, Bitcoin's only 15 years old.

2:30:44Vlad CosteaNo, it's 16, we'll be 17 in January.

2:30:47Curtis GreenOkay, to me it's, I always have to add a few years, because I remember thinking, Bitcoin's only two or three years old. But, yeah, I hope that we get some sort of consensus someday, or at least a road, you know, that we can go down that we don't have so much contention. And, you know, instead of all these different projects coming out, focus on a Bitcoin project that will help Bitcoin, instead of Solana helping, you know, help whatever they're trying to do, or, you know, Ripple, whatever they're trying to do.

2:31:31I don't know, it's, you know, Bitcoin created a whole new industry, you know, blockchain, and I guess it's one of those things we have to live with, and hope that we end up on the other side intact.

2:31:52Vlad CosteaOh, you can also look at it the other way, that Satoshi gave us the blueprint for creating our own money system, which means that anyone can basically take the code and deploy this on the internet and convince others that they should use this currency, which leads to a competition, and leads to a market like the one that we see today. Like, it's sort of obvious that in order for Bitcoin to be successful, it needed to be trusted, and for this trust to be earned, the code had to be open source.

2:32:26And open source means that anyone can use it for any purpose, to modify, to change stuff about it, to run it for every purpose imaginable. So of course we have a blockchain industry, we have people thinking of ways to use this technology for different kinds of ways, and of course the original is hard to beat, but at the same time I do think that in these 16 years there are some interesting ways in which people figured out how to use Bitcoin. Anyway, you mentioned earlier in this interview that you already knew about Bitcoin when you discovered the Silk Road, and when was the first time you read about Bitcoin?

2:33:09Because a lot of people I know, they say they have learned about Bitcoin because of the Silk Road, but you knew about it before the Silk Road, so how did that happen?

2:33:19Curtis GreenYeah, I didn't know who Adam Back was, but I knew of Hashcash, and I knew of e-gold, and so I always kind of followed him, and for some reason I was in a news feed of some sort of Hashcash and e-gold, and then something came up, and it said something about Bitcoin. And I looked at it for, oh, just a few seconds, and there's something about the double spend problem or something, and I go, I didn't even know what that issue was, and so it went in one ear and out the other, and I read a little blurb about it, and that was it.

2:34:06And then when I found out about Silk Road, they said, oh, they used Bitcoin, and I go, oh, I remember reading about that, it had something to do with e-gold or something, and then I thought, oh yeah, I gotta check it out. So the catalyst was to go to the Silk Road to check out Bitcoin, so I found that Bitcoin was the first thing in my mind, Silk Road was not in my mind, does that make sense? So I did it kind of in the reverse way, but soon as, like I said, when I started going down the rabbit hole of Bitcoin, I'm like, oh my gosh, this is it, this is what will change, this is what will change humanity.

2:35:08If this works like they say it's going to work, but then, like I said before, I, me and a lot of other people, we had our doubts about is it really secure, is it really, and that's when people on Silk Road, these people who were programmers, they would convince me and say, no, this is secure, this is why. And they teach me about cryptography, because I didn't know anything about cryptography, and that's why that guy took me down the PGP rabbit hole to show me how it can't be changed, how it can't be manipulated, and so as time went on, I got more faith in Bitcoin.

2:35:54At the beginning, I had none, I was like, this could be a government psy-op operation, they're just, you know, seriously, that came across my mind at the very beginning of Silk Road, I thought, oh my gosh, the government's running an operation here, and they're using this Bitcoin thing as a tool to get our information somehow. Well, that got nixed really, you know, didn't take too long for me to figure that that wasn't the case, and then I just kept asking questions, and I'm like, oh, okay, this is something pretty cool, this is something special, and it probably took me over a year of, you know, doing this.

2:36:42So, it really didn't click until probably 2012 that, okay, Bitcoin is here to stay, and it's going to change our lives, and I think it has. You know, a lot of people, you know, there's a lot of people that have lost a lot of money, a lot of scammers, and I've been a victim of a hack myself, which was, I should have known better, you know, but one little stupid mistake, you know, all it takes. But, you know, I learned a lot, and Silk Road was, you know, my family, oh, don't talk about it.

2:37:45You know, I get it, but I'm grateful for the opportunity that I had, because it's, you know, it helped me realize that Bitcoin is needed. That's, you know, I didn't realize we needed Bitcoin, we need Bitcoin more than Bitcoin needs us, that's for dang sure, and as long as it's used for the right tool, for the right purpose, you know, we're good. And so Silk Road, I think it's a bad rap a lot of the time, because they focus on, oh, the drugs, which you kind of have to agree with it, yeah?

2:38:39That's why a lot of people went there, but like I always say, yeah, people went to Silk Road probably for the drugs, but they stayed for the Bitcoin. And that's what I'm forever grateful for, because, you know, education was key for me back then, and there was really no place except for Bitcoin Talk to learn about Bitcoin.

2:39:07And, you know, there was a few little books that were coming out, I think Andreas had something out, he did something early on. A few other people wrote little books, I can't remember the names were, but there really wasn't a place to discuss, and like Silk Road, it was awesome to be able to talk about where Bitcoin was headed, and it was interesting to hear what other people thought about Bitcoin. And, you know, some people thought it was going to be dead within a couple years, you know, just like today, you know, over the last few years, Bitcoin was supposed to be dead, what, 100,000 times by now?

2:39:55You know, people thought it would be shut down by the government, which I personally thought that too, I thought, oh, this can't be too hard for the government to go in and shut down. But, you know, but it survived, and I'm just...

2:40:15Silk Road was very pinnacle in the history of Bitcoin. And, you know, I don't know if... I've never really talked to Ross about it. I don't know if that's what he intended. I think he just used Bitcoin as a tool. He thought, oh, we can do this because this helps with anonymity. And it probably took him a while to go down the Bitcoin rabbit hole too. It was just like we all did. We all had to have our aha moments, you know. And I'm sure he had his. And just like I had mine, like you've had yours.

2:40:59But yeah, and I hope I can help people in some way, education-wise, you know. And I'll be speaking out more about my time on Silk Road, you know, because not all... Well, there are some things... Most of it was good things, you know. One of the things that DPR always wanted to do, he always talked about how we wanted to change the world for the good. Like, one of his ideas was he wanted to put clean water devices in Africa to help, you know... To help all the disadvantaged.

2:41:56And also, he really did have some great ideas. And unfortunately, they didn't get implemented. But yeah, Silk Road was a great idea. It just was implemented, probably not in the best way, you know. And I think, you know, I don't want to speak for Ross or anything.

2:42:22But we all, you know, he has his regrets, I'm sure. Just like I have my regrets on certain things. But I'm just grateful for... The one thing I can say about Bitcoiners is they're awesome people. I have very rarely met a Bitcoiner that I didn't immediately connect with. And I think that's one of the things that helped on Silk Road, that we all had this common commonality. And that was Bitcoin. It wasn't drugs. It wasn't anything. It was Bitcoin. I know it sounds crazy, but that's what we talked about the most.

2:43:14Yes, there was the forum. Yes, we talked about other things. Yes, we did. Yeah, you know, I'm not going to try to sugarcoat it. But we really, most of us on the site, we just wanted to see Bitcoin succeed. And at the beginning, it wasn't like that. It was used as the first six months or so, six, nine months. It was just a tool. And then slowly, people started talking more about how Bitcoin can change the world and how, oh, yeah, okay. Then we started going down the Satoshi route, looking at his emails that he had and what did he try to do and, you know, and I, fortunately, I was able to correspond one time with him. I asked him a mining question.

2:44:00Vlad CosteaInteresting. So you spoke with Satoshi.

2:44:04Curtis GreenYeah, one time. Yeah. It was an email. It was like March, February or March. It was right before he left.

2:44:14Vlad CosteaSo 2010 or 2011?

2:44:17Curtis Green2011. It was right before he left. It was, I had a mining question. And the response that he gave back was just in capital letters, no. That was the answer to my question. You still have that? No, it was in my, everything that I used back then was on my, I used went through Tor and the government has my computer. It was, you know, the government seized it. And so I can't, my whole life was on that computer. So the email, it's been a long time.

2:44:53Vlad CosteaCan't you request that they publish it?

2:44:56Curtis GreenYou know, we, I've talked to somebody that knows about how to get that stuff back. But it can take years and decades and tons of money. But boy, I would love to have that computer back. Oh my gosh, would there be a lot of gold? I mean, all our communications between my early stuff. I fortunately kept, I kept a couple thumb drives about Silk Road that I just, I made sure that I wanted to save. And they weren't anything great. But I wish I would have, you know, taken a lot of correspondence or copied emails.

2:45:41Because the email that I used was a Tor based email system. They used PGP, you know, so, of course, everything that had to do with that email was on that computer. So I could, you had a private key. And that key was connected to the computer, you know what I mean? So if I didn't have that computer, I'm screwed. So I would love to get that computer. In fact, that's going to be one of my goals is to subpoena. I would love to get my computer back.

2:46:14When they thought I stole the Bitcoin, they took my cell phone away from me because they wanted to go through it to make sure that I tried to figure out if I stole the Bitcoin. And when they handed me back my cell phone, I said, Where was my computer? And they looked at each other. And they said, Oh, we think it's gone. And I'm like, Oh, crap. And then it dawned on me. Shaun Bridges, I think stole it. I think he was using it as his computer.

2:46:52When he was arrested, he scraped off the serial number. So I may never get it back. You know, because who knows where it ended up. Because if I was an agent, Shaun Bridges, and he could have access to my computer, that's a perfect alibi. You know, he has my computer now. So that would make sense to why he would want it. But one thing that I found interesting is that the guys that came barreling down my door who busted in my door, they had balaclavas on, you know, I had red dots, you know, going through the windows.

2:47:36And Carl Force was there, Shaun, Shaun Bridges was there, and a couple of DEA agents, but I find that ironic that out of all those, though, the guys that came arrested me ended up in prison. But I didn't. I've always found that to be a real weird thing to think about. You know, It's a good thing.

2:48:01Vlad CosteaI've always been curious if these guys who stole bitcoins from Silk Road users basically appropriated some of the Bitcoin because they assumed that the government was not gonna care about it. Did they keep it? Did they get to use it? Or did it go to the US government? And as far as I know, guys like Tim Draper bought some of the Silk Road bitcoins and they own it currently.

2:48:23Curtis GreenYeah, yeah, Tim Draper, he bought the Bitcoin that were on the servers that belong to Silk Road. Shaun Bridges, he stole those 30,000 bitcoins, those went into his wallet, he dispersed them, you know, put them in multiple different wallets, and the government, some of them ended up in the government's coffers, most of them did.

2:48:54And so either the government has it or they sold them off. And then the Bitcoin that was stolen from me, I can't remember the amount that was stolen, but it was all the Bitcoin that I had. I would guess it was probably in the low hundreds, two to three, 400 Bitcoin, that it was my Bitcoin. You know, it was all the Bitcoin I had, and Carl Force, I had a Mt. Gox account, and while we were up there, he transferred right out of my Mt. Gox account right into his personal account.

2:49:37And then so they dollarized it, you know, and I had to find this out by going through court records. They didn't come and tell me, oh, Carl Force ripped you off, you're going to get paid back. I had to find out by going to court documents, and they dollarized it. And so they put the dollar value back for when he stole it. So this was only worth a few hundred dollars back then. And so he owed me. I think $2,800, I want to say, out of all that, I'm like, oh, it makes me sick, because I know I would have kept most of those Bitcoin.

2:50:24Obviously, I would have sold some, but I know I would have kept them. I'm just that way. But yeah, I learned a lesson on hard knocks, but like other people have pointed out, I put myself in that situation. So I really, you know, I, so I do blame myself a little bit. But, you know, but Carl Force and Shaun Bridges, they really did something, they manipulated, not only me, they manipulated Ross big time. I don't know if you've ever gone down that rabbit hole or not, but I did.

2:51:02Vlad CosteaI was going to ask you about it, because there's this story where they made you basically ingest soup and puke it out so that they can take pictures and send them to Ross and claim that you're being tortured and you were trying to extort Ross of his Bitcoin.

2:51:21Curtis GreenYeah, well, yeah, what that was, was based... The Bitcoin was stolen on that Friday night, and we know Shaun Bridges was the agent who stole it. And this is where the waters get muddied. I got blamed for stealing the Bitcoin.

2:51:50And so, and DPR found out, so he said, I just want him back. And what the government told me, they said, hey, he just wants the money back. He wants you roughed up. And so that's why they took photos of me. Then they later said, they called me up two days later, which was very suspect. And they said, oh, the order has changed from just beating you up to have you killed. And I'm like, I thought they were kidding. And so I was really fearful for my life, not for me, but for my family.

2:52:30And I said, well, how do we get out of this? How do we fix it? And he says, well, we need to get a picture of you being dead. I'm like, okay. So my wife came up with the idea of getting Campbell's chicken soup. And we went into the, we recreated the scene from the hotel where I was being dunked. It's hard to tell the difference between a bathtub is a bathtub. So we took pictures that were kind of close and I pretended like I was dead with chicken soup all over me.

2:53:09And I sent it over to them, to Carl Force and Shaun Bridges, imagine that. And they said, oh, these photos are fantastic. They'll work great. And so that was to help their ruse more than anything. So yeah, but yeah, he came down to and then Carl Force ran scams on the side against DPR. He was holding him saying, hey, I have information about this. If you don't pay me so many Bitcoin, I'll leak it. But he did it under different guys or different people. So he knew a lot about the investigation.

2:54:05And so he was manipulating him in a big way. And in fact, one of the emails came across, he says, I know you killed Curtis Green.

2:54:17And it was Carl Force trying to extort DPR out of more money. And I don't know how much money, how many Bitcoin they got out of him, but both. I don't know if Shaun Bridges extorted money out of him, but I know Carl Force did. That's what he was charged with, was that extortion, I believe. And I think he served six years. Shaun Bridges, he was originally sentenced to six or seven years, but he wasn't truthful with the amount of Bitcoin that he stole. I guess they found like three or 4,000 more Bitcoin than what he admitted to stealing later on.

2:54:57So they added two more years to his sentence. And so, yeah, it was quite the time to testify in San Francisco, Bridges' sentencing. I never had to testify in Carl Force's because he just pled guilty and just took his lumps. But Shaun Bridges fought it a little bit, and so I had to go testify down in San Francisco. But yeah, it wasn't all peaches and cream, by any means. Personally, I went through a lot of hell. I contemplated things that I shouldn't have contemplated, and I'm glad all that didn't happen, but it was a rough time. But it all worked out at the end, like it should have, I hope.

2:56:19The only thing I can do is move forward and tell people. I mean, it's so ironic. There's so many things that went on with the Silk Road, all the different contests and cool things that happened. There's been a few books written about some of the things that went on, but what it came down to was the site was a freedom site. That's what it was. Were there mistakes? Did we make some mistakes along the way? Abso-freakin'-lutely. Like I said, I've made tons of mistakes. I'm assuming a lot of the other admins will say the same thing, that they made mistakes.

2:57:26But all you can do is learn from your mistakes and move on. I can't go back and change anything as much as I'd like to. I wish I could go back and say, let me undo this, let me undo that. But I can't. All I can do is take the good things and move forward.

2:57:52That's where I'm at today. I, you know, and I, and that's where I, you know, I always thought a pardon would be the answer, and it might be. I'm still looking down that route, like I said earlier. I like to get my rights back again, because it's dumb. When you think about it, all I was doing was working on a stupid website. For them not to take my civil liberties away, it just doesn't make sense. It's not like I didn't kill anybody, I didn't hurt anybody, I didn't steal anything. All I did was change usernames and help the website. A lot of the things people don't realize is that I created the site's wiki.

2:58:48Vlad CosteaOh, that's interesting. On the wiki you could find information about how to use, how to get your first bitcoin even.

2:58:58Curtis GreenOn Silk Road, yeah.

2:59:01Vlad CosteaI think there was also a section about mixers, if I'm not mistaken.

2:59:05Curtis GreenOh, yeah. What I did is I created a template, because I couldn't do everything. I caught a lot of crap. They said, all you did was copy and paste Wikipedia. I said, of course. I'm only one person. It's up to you guys to go change it, to go add to it. That's what happened.

2:59:31I'm the one who, it was DPR that came up and asked me to do it. That was my first really paid gig. I did that in late 2011, I think, is when I created the wiki. It was on the forums, obviously. I learned a lot from doing that. It was technically over my head, but I figured it out and learned from it. A lot of copy and pasting. But yeah, there was a lot of learning how to mixing and I never really went, I really didn't care about that sort of thing.

3:00:25I was just, whatever. But yeah, there was pretty much, they would say, oh, it was the wild, wild west, which it was in a way, but it still had the rules. You could not harm a third party. And so it wasn't lawless. We conformed to what we thought human beings should be good to others. We shouldn't hurt other people. You could not harm. I remember I actually got rid of this guy's account.

3:01:06He was one of the, I didn't ban too many people, but I banned this guy and he kept coming back somehow. I don't know how he did that. But he sold fake coupons for whatever site. He would change the code on it and made it better than what it was. And as soon as we saw that, we thought, no, he's harming a third party, like Walmart or whoever. So it was an automatic nix. So it wasn't a lawless place. It still had its rules to go by. But yeah, I could go on forever about Silk Road.

3:01:56Vlad CosteaI'm also curious because, no, first of all, let me acknowledge the fact that we have had more than 1300 people tuning into the live stream at this point, which is amazing. Thank you, guys, you are heroes, and I'm happy that you get to listen to this story. Secondly, I got to tell you, Curtis, that you forgot to retweet this stream. You retweeted something else, which I saw on your profile, but it would be cool if people saw this also on your page. And over the last 20 minutes or so, you kept mentioning DPR.

3:02:32And that's obviously Dread Pirate Roberts, who was the creator of the Silk Road. And I want to ask you, to your knowledge, how many people were actually behind that account? Was it only Ross or how would you even know who's behind it? Because as far as I know, part of his defense was that he wasn't the only person running the account. And while he was in jail, there were people basically writing messages from that account, which proved that he was not the only one behind it.

3:03:05Curtis GreenWhich is kind of funny. There was only one person that really had the keys. But there were other people that acted on DPR's behalf. So there definitely could have been other DPRs, but there was really only one DPR that ran the show, if that makes sense. The person that I dealt with seemed to be the same person all the way through. Does that make sense?

3:04:06Vlad CosteaSo there was consistency. Do you believe that it was Ross Ulbricht all the time?

3:04:14Curtis GreenWell, yeah. There's a lot of things that I'm trying to put together in my head, but unless Ross comes out and talks about it, that's up to him. We'll never know exactly. There was a different place for programmers where they would upload the program and then it was viewed by one or two people. The main guy who I would consider the bad guy, his name was Variety Jones. He was the guy that, if you put an angel on one side and the devil on the other side of your head, he was the devil. He was definitely reading through some of his chats.

3:05:28He definitely was not a good person. I actually talked to his sister not too long ago. She even said, Ross is definitely not a criminal, you are definitely not a criminal, but my brother, he's a criminal. I found it ironic that she would say that, whether she really believes that, I don't know.

3:05:56Vlad CosteaWait, criminal how? What does that refer to?

3:06:01Curtis GreenIf you go through all the chats, because the one thing that DPR kept, he kept the log of all of his chats, and they got published. I can't remember, I don't know if the site still has them. Everything that was not above water that was iffy, it all came from this Variety Jones guy. You could tell that DPR was a naive younger kid. In fact, he's older than me. I think he turned 70 pretty soon. He was the one who, when I see the time frame, when he got involved, that's when I saw a systematic change in the Silk Road administration side of it.

3:06:58I think he had something to do with all these bad things that you hear, the murder for hire stuff and all these other things. He was neck deep into it, I believe. I'm just going off the chats that I've read. I think I had one conversation with him on Silk Road that I recall, but it was no big deal. It was just on the forums. I had no idea he was DPR's basically right-hand man. He was the guy that, like I said, gave all the bad juju.

3:07:40He was the one who said, oh, you can't do this. You should do it by this way. He went down the dark path. That's probably the best way I can describe it. But, you know, but yeah, those... add in the agents. Oh my gosh, there was so much manipulation going on. Between the agents and DPR and Ross, you wouldn't know what's up. He was getting hit by all sorts of different angles.

3:08:25Then there was a lot of infighting on the Silk Road side. The vendors didn't like the percentage. A lot of political stuff going on. They didn't like this because the site charged a percent for escrow. They didn't like that. DPR was trying to keep everybody happy, which you can't do. It's impossible to keep everybody happy. I think that's where this Variety Jones guy stepped in. He took over. He was basically the muscle. That's probably the best way to term him. He was the muscle of the site. And he, yeah, reading throughout the chats, I'm sure I kept them somewhere. I know I saved them somewhere on some hard drive. I had to dig through court documents because that's the only place you could really find them. Mostly on Carl Force and Shaun Bridges' trials.

3:09:41Many people don't talk about him, Variety Jones. I don't know why he doesn't come out and talk more about it. He got arrested. He still has seven more years of his sentence. And so he won't get out until he's 70 something years old. And which, you know, I feel bad that somebody has to serve that long. But he doesn't say anything. He doesn't come out and say, I deserve clemency because of this or he just keeps quiet. So maybe he is guilty.

3:10:36Vlad CosteaI'm reading his Wikipedia page and it says that, among other things, he was the one to suggest the first alleged murder for hire.

3:10:45Curtis GreenYeah, yeah. Yes, he was the one who pushed that.

3:10:49Vlad CosteaWere you the first case of the murder for hire?

3:10:51Curtis GreenYeah, yeah. There was three of them that I recall. The other two were Canadian. The other two were from Canada. Hell's it. They were a biker group. Hell's Angels, yeah. Hell's Angels, yeah. They were just basically pulling a scam. But yeah, as far as the chats that I read, this Variety Jones was the one that says, when are we done putting up with somebody's shit or something like that? Regarding me, thinking I stole 30,000 Bitcoin, which I was totally innocent of. It was these agents that stole it. So they went down.

3:11:53He didn't put up much of a fight. He just went to prison. And I haven't heard anything about him. I've heard from his sister. Like I said, she's told me that I wasn't a criminal, Ross wasn't a criminal, but her brother is definitely a criminal. I just found that ironic. And that really says a lot right there. Because we just had a vision. The site had one vision was for freedom and take the government off of control away so we can get some control back. And this Variety Jones character took it a little bit far. In fact, some of the chats were quite funny, actually, going through them.

3:12:53He said, if you're ever in prison, I'll rent a helicopter and come down and sweep down and pick you up from the yard. And we'll go off into the sunset or something like that. And that post always resonated with me. I thought, well, I wonder if he's ever going to get Ross out of prison because he talked about it.

3:13:25There really hasn't been a good story done about Silk Road yet. Hollywood did their version. A writer from Australia, I can't remember her name, she wrote a book and she interviewed a couple of the admins from Silk Road. And I'd like to reconnect with those guys and see where they're at today and see what their thinking was back then. Because one of the admins, when they were discussing what should happen with me, one of the admins said, I'll go knock him off, meaning me. And while you had to go visit his grandmother, this is when Variety Jones was talking when they were in a discussion group.

3:14:19What really happened, I don't know, because I wasn't a part of those discussions. All I can do is read the transcripts. But I do know that there was a lot of government involvement. And when the government gets involved, you're not going to hear the truth. You're not going to hear 100% of the truth.

3:14:47Vlad CosteaI'm actually curious if you got in contact with Ross to clarify what happened, because basically your testimony about the events is the reason why the charges for murder for hire were dropped against him. They were part of his trial. And once you got involved and you said that you believe he's a good human being and

3:15:08Curtis GreenOh, yeah, the guy I knew wouldn't have done that. That's why I always thought the charges were suspect. And I still don't know what the truth is. But all I can do is read the transcripts from the court documents. And that's what I suggest. Because I can't say, did this happen? Did this really happen? Because all I can do is get conjecture from the transcripts and make my own opinion. And I know BitMEX did a wonderful article last April.

3:16:08Vlad CosteaI'm actually interviewing him on Monday. So I'm gonna let him know that you appreciate his article.

3:16:12Curtis GreenOh, very much so. He said, Hey, where's Curtis's pardon? And then when Ross got all this Bitcoin, he said, Hey, where's Curtis's Bitcoin? Of course, it's all tongue in cheek. But he has a point, a little bit. And in fact, I reposted the, they go down the rabbit hole a little bit about those murder for hires, the BitMEX guys. So, I mean, people can make their own opinion on that. I read what they wrote.

3:17:06From the get go, I've always said, Ross, whether guilt, innocent, or whatever, that his sentence that he received was crazy, crazy high. Even if he was guilty of it was way too much. And so that's where I've always stood. I've always said, Man, no matter what your stance is on whether you like Silk Road or you hate Silk Road, the two life sentences plus 40 years was way overkill. Way overkill. So that's always been my stance on that. But to get pinned down on did he do it? No, he didn't. I don't know. I wasn't there.

3:18:04Vlad CosteaFortunately, you're still here.

3:18:06Curtis GreenYes, that's the important thing. That I'm still here. I'm still talking. And it was kind of funny how they made it sound like I was in all this danger. But they certainly didn't seem scared of it. And I'm like, so if they're not scared, then maybe it's all made up. They had too much control. So I went back and forth the first two or three years. I'll admit, there was one point where I thought, Oh, Ross did this 100% and he's guilty. And then I would flip.

3:18:40I would say, Oh my gosh, there's no way he did it. It was these agents 100%. Then I'd flip again. And so I just came to the conclusion that I'll never know the exact truth. And does it really matter? We all know the premise of it.

3:19:12We do know that they were trying to protect the site. And that's the other crazy thing. I think I've talked about it before how I didn't think what we were doing was so illegal. And it wasn't until about a year and a half into it, I'm thinking, I think what we're doing is not very, this is probably really pretty bad. And every time I would go to quit, or not necessarily quit, but say, you know what, I'm going to step away from it. I thought, I'll do it next week. I'll do it in a month from now. Because I was making a couple, that's how I was surviving, was my salary.

3:20:09I always put it on the back burner. And then again, I thought, what are we doing? It may sound so crazy to a person that just knows a little, that hasn't gone down that rabbit hole. But it doesn't seem, when you think about what we did, you think, we didn't sell anything. The site didn't sell a thing. All we did was we created a forum so people could do that. You know, the vendors, I always thought, man, I can't believe those vendors have the balls to ship marijuana, whatever have you, across, they're taking a huge risk.

3:20:54And I always thought, man, those guys are ballsy, and I would never do that. Oh, my gosh, those guys are crazy. And so I thought those guys were the ones who were taking the risk. But when it all came down to it, everybody that went, you know, there was a few vendors that were taken down. But it was the site administrators that were really targeted. And that really threw me for a loop, because I didn't think what we were doing was so bad. And in granted, that was, my thinking was not, wasn't quite, you know, I wasn't thinking clearly, obviously.

3:21:31But that's, that's been my opinion. You know, I, you know, looking back, I see all my thinking errors, or most of them. And I see where, oh, yeah, I should have, I should have, I should have stepped away here or there. But I didn't. Was it greed? Possibly. I mean, I didn't get rich. That's for darn sure. You know, like I said, we only got paid, in Bitcoin terms, it would it would seem like a lot. But we turn, I turned it into dollars, or of some, as fast as I could, as fast as I could do it, you know, because...

3:22:10Vlad CosteaYeah, but even if you kept the Bitcoins, they would get stolen by the DEA agent.

3:22:16Curtis GreenYep, exactly. And that's how I justify everything. I think, well, even if I did keep everything, it would have been taken, it would have been taken from me. You know, just because I was so naive, they had, they had my computer, and the keys were on there anyway. You know, it, but I did have a YubiKey that you needed to have to get into the Mt. Gox account. So I could have protected it somehow, you know.

3:22:48Vlad CosteaThank you, Mark Karpeles, for that one. It was a genius idea. After the second hack, I think.

3:22:54Curtis GreenYeah, I remember the hack, it was in June or July of 2011. The site went down, and they crashed Bitcoin down. To one cent, or something crazy. And they shut it down, and then everything on Silk Road had to stop. Because every, that's how people bought their Bitcoin, was through Mt. Gox. And so we, so when, so when Mt. Gox went down, they would, they'd go, they went down a few times, then we'd have to kind of shut down. You know, because we couldn't, you know, every, almost every transaction went through Mt. Gox.

3:23:35But yeah, it was, it was a crazy time, and it, and it's something that, you know, people will say, well, how could, how could you ever get rid of those Bitcoin? Or how could you not protect them with your life? And you're like, well, we didn't have the faith. You know, we were still learning. We were, we were green, we were wet behind the ears. We didn't, we didn't know what we were doing. We didn't know what we had. You know, we, and we just saw it as a means to get a dollar.

3:24:06You know, we thought, oh, Bitcoin's at $1.50. Ooh, ooh, good. It's up from $1.20. I'm going to hurry up and sell and make my 30 cent profit. That was the mentality. And, you know, there were, yes, there was a few people that were trying to hoard it. But those people that were, that were hoarding it, they were already wealthy. The guys that were struggling, they would, were guys like me, who didn't have a penny to their name. And we would try to get, you know, it would go, it would come in and it would go out.

3:24:41It would come in, it would go out. And the guys that were smart were the guys, or the lucky guys, were the ones that didn't have to worry about paying bills and they were able to stack and not have, and just let it ride out.

3:25:00Vlad CosteaAnd... There were two stories of people who wanted to buy drugs on Mt. Gox. And for some reason, they forgot. So they bought the Bitcoin, but they forgot to use the Bitcoin. And then a few years later, they remembered that they have it because they saw the price going up. And they could still access it and they realized that they're rich.

3:25:19Curtis GreenOh, yeah, that, that, that, that happened. Oh, that happened a lot. Because they would, they would go, they always plan to go buy their marijuana, they would go buy, buy, you know, 10 Bitcoin, because you always, you never would just buy $10, you would buy 10 Bitcoin, you know, just, and then that 10 Bitcoin, you only spent two, and then you either kept it on Mt. Gox, because you either kept Mt. Gox, or you used Silk Road as a wallet? Because it was just easier back then.

3:25:53And if you were either way, you were screwed because either Mt. Gox was either hacked, or the Silk Road was taken off the site from the government. So neither one was a really good, neither, neither one were good options. But yeah, I've heard of many stories of Bitcoiners, or not Bitcoiners, but people that use the site and bought and forgot about it, and then Mt. Gox made the news. Oh, yeah, I think I might have a few Bitcoin on there. And then they turn around, you know, two or three years later, they bought it for two or $3, then it's worth $10,000, you know, and they pull it out, you know, and so yeah, I've heard many stories like that.

3:26:39And, but the, but the real winners are the Mt. Gox people that are, there's now getting paid. You know, they had to wait 10 years, but it was kind of a forced HODL. They only got, I think we got, they got 18.9% of their Bitcoin back, or that's what they're getting, getting it back. And, but who cares, it's like 18.9%. If they, because most of the people would have probably turned it into dollars by now. And so it was kind of a force, like I said, it was a forced HODL.

3:27:15And so 18% now, is much better than 100% back in 2014. I mean, Bitcoin was what, $1,500? Was it even that? No, if it was 14, it was in the hundreds.

3:27:30Vlad CosteaSo there was the bear market after 13.

3:27:32Curtis GreenYeah. Yeah. $400. Yeah. So but they, but they probably, they probably got it at less than $1. So even, you know, but then, but then I don't know if you remember, I remember how they were out there. Mark Karpeles, they were saying, where's our Bitcoin? You know, with the signs and...

3:27:54Vlad CosteaYeah, it's a popular meme, actually, I don't think a lot of the new Bitcoiners know it. I know it because I'm a nerd. I was not involved in Bitcoin at the time. But there was this guy who went with a sign that said, where's our money? And Mark Karpeles had this fancy Frappuccino or something in his, in his hand, and he walked up to the offices. And it was that picture that sort of was taken from the recording. And it was presented as this man who's protesting outside. And then there's this French guy who's walking with his fancy coffee, going to his fancy building, and not caring about the customer.

3:28:34I think that was a powerful image at the time. And that became a meme. I have an NFT on Bitcoin. It's called Spells of Genesis. It's a large collection. And it's basically a reenactment of that scene, but using fictional characters, like a wizard and something else. Someone sent that to me. I don't remember exactly who sent it to me. But I still have it in my Counterparty wallet. I'm actually curious. Counterparty came out in 2014. You're still working on Silk Road in 2014. Did you come up with novel ways of using these Bitcoin-issued assets?

3:29:18Curtis GreenOh, well, you know, it was kind of ironic. There was a site on Bitcoin Talk called GLBSE. I can't remember what the GLs did, but the SE was stock exchange. And what they did was they tokenized businesses. And I remember, it was big money. I mean, there'd be one business that raised like $300,000. And I followed that site and I thought, man, I wish I had money. But then I thought, oh, it'll be taken down because it's kind of like an illegal stock market. But that was 2011, 2012. And so they were way ahead of their time. What was it called once again?

3:30:07GLBSE? And it was, I don't know if it was the IRS or the SEC, they went to the guy, he was an English, he was from the UK. And they said, hey, wind down your site, give everybody their Bitcoin back and you won't go to jail. We'll pretend it never happened. And that's what happened. They did a wind down and everybody got back their Bitcoin. Like they should have and they wound it down. But I thought, what a great idea GLBSE was. It was, they were way ahead of their time.

3:30:50Vlad CosteaBefore DeFi, before all of this stuff. And there was also MPEX, I'm not sure if you remember it.

3:30:58Curtis GreenYeah, yeah. So DeFi just happened to come at the right time. They had more adoption, I guess, they had more. But yeah, tokenizing real world assets is definitely not a new thing. It was in Bitcoiners' minds from the beginning and attempts were made. Government shut them down or other reasons were shut down. But yeah, I totally forgot about GLBSE when you brought that up, GLBSE. But yeah, it was on Bitcoin Talk. They had their own site on Bitcoin Talk. They had their own forum, I believe. And they had all these businesses all around the world.

3:31:51That's how they got their funding. And you would own a piece of that company. And it was paid and it was all in Bitcoin.

3:32:00Vlad CosteaIt's really amazing because at the time everyone who had Bitcoin was on Bitcoin Talk. And they had all of these community projects, like even something small with lotteries or something that people were organizing just to get more transactions out there, get people to use Bitcoin. Someone in the chat asked if the person behind GLBSE, which is the Global Bitcoin Stock Exchange, that's what it stood for. So there's an article from 2012 on Bitcoin Magazine that announces that it shut down. Someone in the chat named Alex Koglan, I guess, that's how you pronounce it.

3:32:47He asked if it was Amir Taaki who was running that. No, Amir Taaki was running Britcoin, which was another exchange. GLBSE was launched by someone named James McCarthy, who was known as Nefario in the forums.

3:33:01Curtis GreenYeah, that's it. You're right. Yep. Yep. I remember that name. Yeah. Oh, it brings back memories. Yeah. But I really thought that idea was, in fact, I remember calling my brother up because he was running a business here. And I thought, man, maybe this is a way you can raise money to your business. And then he said, well, is it legal? And I started thinking, you know what, I guarantee you, it has the stock exchange rules. I guarantee you, it wouldn't be kosher. And of course, I kind of looked at it a little bit and I was right.

3:33:39It would have never flown legally here in the United States, maybe somewhere else, but definitely not here. But yeah, there was a few forward thinkers back then. And of course, the adoption rate was so low. But now, if somebody were to start it up, well, there's probably another coin that does it now.

3:34:06Vlad CosteaI think all of these markets are on Ethereum and Solana right now. Pretty much everything, like even companies, even commodities, like you can trade. I remember this was on MPEX that you could trade sugar, cocoa, gold, silver, all of these commodities using Bitcoin. And they also had some sort of counterparty assets that they used to represent these markets. And the guy behind MPEX was named Mircea Popescu, or Mircea, whatever you may call him, possibly the best known Romanian Bitcoiner. I'm Romanian. I'm aware of him. I never interacted with him. I know of the stuff that he did. But supposedly, he was very big.

3:34:53Curtis GreenYeah, there's a lot of cool things that Bitcoin started. And Ethereum kind of taken over. Solana has taken a few things over. And it's just a matter of time before the stock exchange is 24-7. I don't know if they're gonna run on Solana. I don't know if they're gonna run on Ethereum. They're gonna do something. It's just a matter of time. And if the government ever gets unshut down, I think there's a law in the United States. It's about to be Congress's thinking is contemplating a law, but they can't do it while it's shut down.

3:35:33And I think that's gonna form a lot of laws that will help Bitcoin. Well, I'm assuming it'll help Bitcoin. At least they say they'll help Bitcoin here in the near future. So I guess we'll see. But yeah, we're gonna see. We've come a long way since Bitcoin and since Silk Road. And I hope that we continue to evolve. And I hope the space can have some sort of consensus on where it should go. Because there's just too much infighting. I just noticed it on the block size wars, when Roger Ver took off.

3:36:30Whether he's right or wrong, that's another day to talk about. But yeah, I'm really excited about the future and where Bitcoin is gonna take us and where we're gonna end up. What's the end product gonna be like? I've heard a lot of people say, well, Bitcoin was the first. You never know, something might come around that could flip its lid. I don't think that'll happen. But then again, I don't know what's gonna happen in 100 years. In my lifetime, I think it's gonna be pretty much the same as what's happening now. But who knows, with AI coming around, what's happening? Ethereum or Solana might come out with this great new thing. Who knows?

3:37:42But yeah, I just hope that we can just come all together and I long for the old days of Bitcoin. But that said, there wasn't very many conventions to go to back in the day or meetups for that matter. But now I go to meetups and I love it. So that has changed for the good, I think. There's more people involved in Bitcoin. Yes, you have a lot more discussion, but that's good. But I'm really happy. I've met a lot of great friends. Like I've said, I've never really met a Bitcoiner that I didn't like. And I think we're a special breed.

3:38:53And I think that says a lot for Bitcoin because it picks out the good people. Or it gets rid of the bad people. I don't know. Take which one.

3:39:09Vlad CosteaThere are a lot of bad people too. It's just money. But I was gonna mention that just imagine what we could have or what we can have today if we get the spirit of the old days, but with the adoption and the user base and the capital that we have today. Like so much nice stuff can be built. If we just remember where we started and what was the original intention behind Bitcoin.

3:39:34Curtis GreenWell, yeah. Many people don't realize that Vitalik went to the Bitcoin Core developers. You would know this better than I. But he said, hey, we should do this with Bitcoin. And they said no. And so he created Ethereum. And I'm like, geez, could you imagine if they could have integrated somehow, made it just one chain? I don't know. Maybe I'm up in the night. But yeah, but Ethereum, for, I remember a lot from, I think, 2014 to 2018, Ethereum performed better, everything-wise, it wasn't until like 2018 that it turned around. But for a while there

3:40:25Vlad CosteaA lot of people wanted to build marketplaces. They wanted to do all the stuff that was on GLBSE, on MPEX and everything else. They wanted to keep building on Bitcoin and to make Bitcoin more useful. But there was the scaling debate that sort of gave the signal that they will not be able to use Bitcoin for what they want. So they went to Ethereum and they built whatever they wanted, because nobody stopped them. And because they also had more tooling for it. They could write more advanced applications using the smart contracting language.

3:41:12So that was the advantage. And Ethereum in 2017, when I think it reached its highest valuation against Bitcoin, if you look at the ETH/BTC chart, I think it was the revenge chain. It was the place where people went because they were not happy with what's happening in Bitcoin. And I think today, if you look at the events and the infighting that's happening, I think that Zcash is the revenge chain. Because it went up a lot over the last month. And it's also on the back of all the conflicts and all the debates that are happening in Bitcoin.

3:41:47So I think there is this tendency for people who want to build stuff, who realize that they cannot do it on Bitcoin anymore to migrate to other projects, which is very unfortunate, by the way.

3:42:02Curtis GreenI agree. If I recall, I remember Zcash and Bitcoin, I think you mentioned earlier, they were so similar. There was only one small difference. And I think does Zcash have the same market cap, 21 million? I mean...

3:42:20Vlad CosteaSo it's maximum supply, not market cap.

3:42:23Curtis GreenThat's what I meant. So they try to keep the same path as Bitcoin. And so I've always liked Zcash. In fact, I mined the crap out of it. It was up all the way, was it $3,000? Then it came all the way back down to 30, 40. Now it's going back up.

3:42:50Vlad CosteaThere was a lot of hype when it launched and the supply was low. There were just a few coins on the market. And some Bitcoiners were willing to basically exchange like five, six BTC for one ZEC. And that's why the price went up very fast. And then as the supply started to add up, because people were mining it, and the demand did not keep up with that, the price went down.

3:43:13Curtis GreenNow that makes sense. That's a great explanation. I wondered about that. Because if you look at the market, you see it spiked. And then it came. Now that makes total sense.

3:43:25Vlad CosteaYeah, it's almost as if Satoshi launched Bitcoin and had a bunch of cypherpunks hyped, which never happened. All of them were critical, with the exception of Hal Finney. And all of them decided that there should be a marketplace for this on day one, and they should buy it. And they made the price go up. And then they realized, well, the technology is not there. Like, it's not what the white paper promises to be. So they're not gonna buy it anymore. And then more Bitcoins get mined because participants joined the network, but there's less economic activity.

3:44:00So of course, if the supply is higher, but the demand remains the same, the price just keeps going down by itself. There needs to be someone to constantly buy.

3:44:09Curtis GreenYeah, I remember that. It was a slow dip. It just kept going lower and lower and lower and lower. Oh yeah, I remember that now.

3:44:22Vlad CosteaI hope you kept some, because now it's like $700.

3:44:27Curtis GreenYeah, fortunately, that was the one thing that I kept in my wallet. When it got down to like $50, I thought, oh, in my mining days, I would have to pay my electrical bill. When most would come in, that's what a lot of people will understand is it was expensive. Not only to run a miner, but you had to pay your electrical bill, and then you had to pay your air conditioning bill to combat the heat that you just created. So it was a double-edged sword.

3:45:12I learned a lot doing mining, but if I had to do it all over again, I would still mine, but I wouldn't have mined as much, and I would have bought the asset rather than mined it. I would have been better off financially by buying Ethereum or buying Zcash rather than buying the equipment, going through the pain and hassle of mining.

3:45:40Vlad CosteaIt makes a lot of sense if you're paying for GPUs or whatever. First of all, they're expensive. Secondly, especially during moments when mining is profitable, they're even harder to get and more expensive as a consequence. And the profit margins are thin, like you need the price to go up or I don't know. Mining was never very profitable. In hindsight, when people look back, they're like, oh, maybe I should just keep my computer on to mine some Bitcoin in 2009. There was no economic justification for you to do that.

3:46:16Curtis GreenExactly. Well, even when I got my ASIC, when I would plug it in here and I would mine it, I looked at all the money going out, and I didn't have the money to finance it. Now, if I could have mined it and held it onto it for a year, now you're talking something different. But when you mined it in a particular month, you'd have the bills to pay that next month, so you didn't have the luxury to sit there and wait for the price to go up.

3:46:50You had to, boom, sell, pay your bills, and then six months later go, dang it, I wish I could have kept all those Bitcoin. I get a lot of people saying, oh, you must be sitting on thousands of Bitcoin. And I'm like, oh, they don't understand. They don't know how it works because it doesn't work that way. Because the price is built, Bitcoin, that's how they determined the price, was how much it costs them to do electricity. And the price really would go up. It was actually more expensive in the early days than what the electricity was.

3:47:33But if you could hold on to it for a few months, you would be okay. But if you had to sell like I did, it was a losing proposition. And so while I regret it in one aspect, I don't regret it in another aspect. And I'm grateful for the opportunity that I had, but boy, I should have just kept that 2,700 Bitcoin that I spent on the stupid miner. I mean, granted, it would have been, it was Bitcoin that would have also been stolen from me, so I still wouldn't have had them. But still, though, take that out of the equation, it was a dumb move.

3:48:22Vlad CosteaWait, so the DEA agents who stole the Bitcoin from you and took your computers, they let you have your ASIC miners?

3:48:29Curtis GreenYeah, well, they weren't delivered to me yet. And so I didn't have the physical, they weren't here. And so I had to keep my mouth shut. And they didn't know anything. And then it was in early, early 2013. It was like three or four months after they busted down my door is when I took delivery of those ASICs. I just kept my mouth shut. And they never asked. I wasn't going to volunteer that information up to them, because I was afraid of them taking it. And so I was able to, well, I was able to mine a little bit with it.

3:49:11But I was able to sell it for well more than what it was, because there was such high demand back then. I was able to sell it for more than, but I never, that was a whole other story. But I got screwed on that deal, too. But I still made out okay a little bit. I survived, basically. But I didn't make the money that I should have made, that's for darn sure. But yeah, there's so many, and a lot of it, people can argue, when I bring up these little side stories like mining and, oh, you're just gambling.

3:49:52And I'm like, no, no, no, we were fighting for it. Because we were thinking, okay, Bitcoin's not going to work. Because I read those same articles you did about how it was going to die, then what's going to work then? Is it going to be Ethereum? Is it going to be this other one? Or is it going to be this new coin that's coming out of China, that's only 0.0001 cent apiece?

3:50:22It's a weird mentality. And people just see today's price, and that's all they look at. They look at the price of what it was 2008, like you can see, what if you spent $5,000 in Bitcoin in 2008? How much would you be worth today? Well, they leave a lot out in between. A lot of pain, a lot of hassle, a lot of sorrow, a lot of money. I mean, it's not as easy as they make it out to be.

3:51:01Even when Bitcoin was at $100, to us, that was still way expensive. Bitcoin will always be expensive, no matter what the price is. And so even when it was $100 or $50, we were like, who would pay $50 for this? You know, looking back, you think, boy, I would have mortgaged my house to go, but hindsight is 20/20. Anyway, I digress. But yeah, I think that hopefully that we get there, and I hope it's Bitcoin that wins. I think it will be, but there has to be some sort of consensus of somewhere, something's got to change.

3:52:02Vlad CosteaI think so. I say this a lot on my show. I think the problem with Bitcoin is not technical, but it's cultural, because the solutions are out there. They have been tried in other coins for many years. We just have to pick the best one and just put it on Bitcoin. The problem is that I think the price went up a lot. And maybe that, to some people, it's not a problem, but it made some developers and some users complacent, to the point where they say, why do we even need this?

3:52:31Because there's a risk that this is not going to work well, or maybe that we're going to discourage the Wall Street guys from investing in this. Like if we make Bitcoin private, then what's going to happen? We're going to have people selling their coins because they don't trust the system anymore. We're going to have a lot of FUD coming from Wall Street. Maybe we're going to have to deal with authorities from the US or other countries. And they're going to be like, yeah, so why don't we just do nothing? Because it seems to be working well.

3:53:02Curtis GreenYeah, that's true. There really hasn't been a change in the Bitcoin code since SegWit, I think.

3:53:14Vlad CosteaThere was also Taproot in 21.

3:53:18Curtis GreenThat's right, Taproot, yeah.

3:53:20Vlad CosteaFour and a half years ago.

3:53:23Curtis GreenYeah, that's true. But see, that's all technical stuff that's over my head. I know you can do a lot with Taproot and whatnot, but maybe that's the answer. Maybe we haven't... Maybe one of these BIP proposals will be the answer. Isn't somebody trying to make Bitcoin a privacy... He's a developer, he's, it would require a soft fork, but I don't know.

3:54:01Vlad CosteaThere are some initiatives to bring Zcash kind of privacy to Bitcoin. So the most obvious one is the soft fork that was proposed for Bitcoin 10 years ago. And just take the latest version of it and add it to Bitcoin. But there are also more subtle ways, like there's something called zkCoins. ZK stands for zero knowledge. And that one is like a protocol, just like Counterparty on top of Bitcoin, where you can send coins with better privacy. There's also something called client-side validation, and there was a paper about it last year.

3:54:37But all of them require some sort of upgrades to make Bitcoin a bit more expressive in terms of setting conditions for how transactions can be sent and basically making it more expressive for contracts. And once we do have that with vaults or covenants, we can build a lot of interesting stuff. The problem that I see is we don't give these developers a chance to prove themselves. I think I'm one of the guys who interviewed dozens of frustrated developers, and that's why I know so much about their work.

3:55:15Because they're like, okay, just give us a chance. Give us this soft fork. It's been tested for like five, six years. There are no vulnerabilities that were reported. Just give us the chance to build something and show what we can do with Bitcoin. But I think once again, the problem is that the price went up. Maybe in a bear market, we're going to end up actually improving Bitcoin in a meaningful way. Right now, we actually have Michael Saylor telling people that the most dangerous attack to Bitcoin is to fund developers to come up with new ideas to change it.

3:55:55Curtis GreenWell, can't we keep the same principles of Bitcoin, but just expand on what Bitcoin does?

3:56:05Vlad CosteaExactly. But then people come up with, I was going to say crackhead theories, but I don't think it's appropriate in the context. But they come up with ideas like, what if there is an inflation bug? Or what if something breaks and we don't know about it? Unknown unknowns, that's the principle. And they're going to express concerns about stuff like this for many years until maybe the developers give up and they're like, OK, I've tried. I'm not going to push this. The beauty of Bitcoin, honestly, is that the developers have very frequent changing of the guards to say so.

3:56:46Like the same guys who are working on the protocol level like 10 years ago have more off-hands positions nowadays. And there's a new crop of developers who are doing all the work. So there is some optimism that maybe we're going to get a new guard of developers who will be more open to adding stuff. Right now, everyone seems afraid to kill the goose that lays golden eggs.

3:57:13Curtis GreenYeah. Oh, yeah. See, I think you're spot on. You see the price. I mean, I get caught up in a like, oh, the price is over one hundred thousand dollars. Oh, you know, it's going to get up there. If it can just get to five hundred thousand dollars, then, oh, maybe I can we can pay off the house and maybe, you know, we can start to live. You know, I've caught myself going down that route, you know, and I'm like, I'm just being greedy.

3:57:43You know, I don't think, you know, I, you know, but I want we want what's best for humanity and what's best for, you know, for everything. I mean, yeah, you know, and, you know, you know, maybe maybe it's going to take another coin or like a Zcash to evolve where, you know, they use it like it was like we all want it to be used, but they use Bitcoin as the final, you know, like a I don't know, maybe it's going to probably change so many times.

3:58:27You know, you know, just looking back in the last twelve or thirteen years, it's changed a lot. I mean, unless you think about it, you really don't notice the changes. But when you start when you look at that year by year and slice each year down, that's when you notice the changes. But when you just look at it, you go, oh, Bitcoin hasn't changed that much, but it really has, you know, is and Roger Ver. Yeah. The one thing I've always agreed upon his saying is, is, you know, if we would have just kept, you know, put all the code into Bitcoin and made it better, it would have it would have stopped all these other many other coins from being created and being diluted.

3:59:14Vlad CosteaThere is more to this because there was momentum at one point and there was real world adoption happening with Bitcoin. So it was like 16. Yeah. If we kept that energy and we kept improving Bitcoin, maybe we could get it adopted much faster.

3:59:32Curtis GreenYeah. You know, and the price will still will still get up there. You know, maybe that's what the people there everybody is afraid of. You know, if we make these changes, it'll cause the price to go down. And they don't want that, you know, because now you have Wall Street with the ETFs. You know, I don't know. I don't

3:59:56Vlad CosteaI like to joke that the ETF is the scaling layer, like paper Bitcoin. That's how we ended up scaling. We did not do it on the blockchain. We did not do it very well on the layer two so far. So we ended up just using old style accounting for something which is supposed to be on a blockchain, but on a piece of paper, and we transfer ownership on paper.

4:00:22Curtis GreenWell, I've read a lot of Bitcoiners. I don't know how OG they are. But I've heard a lot of people have taken all their Bitcoin that they've held in hard wallets, and put it into the ETF. Just because that way they don't have to worry about the keys. They don't have to worry about it was just it was just a logistic thing. I'm like, no, I mean, there's a time and a place I think for an ETF. Like, I'm gonna have my 85 year old father. Try to control keys and whatnot, you know, to me, it'd probably easier for him to buy an ETF.

4:00:58But for the average pleb, I would say no, I would say, hold Bitcoin and only Bitcoin, you know, but maybe that's being maybe I'm not being contradictory. You know, maybe I'm, you know, maybe, you know, maybe that's, I'm being too conflicting. But I you know, I don't know what the answer is. But I guess we'll find out. And we'll see how what how Bitcoin turns out. And, you know, I still have high, high hopes. I think, you know, even though Bitcoin has had its issues in the past, I think we're gonna, I think we will have that moment where we, you know, I think Wall Street's biggest problem is changing the number 21 million cap.

4:01:58You know, I think that's the if I think to me, that's the only big issue that I've seen heard from them. You know, other than that, what, you know, what does it matter if they change the code into making it do this or do that? You know, there's as long as long as there's only going to be 21 million ever created, then that's that's what they're worried about, right? Isn't that?

4:02:28Vlad CosteaWell, yeah, because there's no way to verify that the Bitcoin on the piece of paper is actually backed by anything. And this once again defeats the purpose. There is no way to cryptographically or even traditionally verify. You have to trust that the issuer of these notes is actually liquid. And it's so dumb. Like this is why Bitcoin was created. You have this message in the first block, which is Chancellor on the brink of second bailout for banks. And if you look at the context of that, it's about this situation in 2008, where governments were bailing out banks that, first of all, with money that was printed out of thin air.

4:03:12So putting the citizen in debt for maybe decades. And secondly, because banks were dishonest in their practices. They were not transparent and they were doing fractional reserves. And right now, it's even worse with fractional reserves like this.

4:03:29Curtis GreenThey don't have to hold that anymore. They can hold zero. You know, they used to be like 20%. Then it dropped to 10. Now it's zero. And so what's backing it? You know, the ETFs, you know, we're just trusting that BlackRock or whoever is holding that Bitcoin. Because who knows, they could be, there could be twice as much as they're taking the money. And as long as they don't have a bank run, you know, they could, you know, could you imagine if they sold more than what they were actually buying?

4:04:12And then everybody tried to redeem? You know, because that's what was it? Was it January 8? There used to be a date when everybody said take their Bitcoin off exchanges.

4:04:22Vlad CosteaYeah, January 3, it was Trace Mayer who came up with Proof of Keys. It was like this celebration of self custody. And it was just a way to get the exchanges to be liquid so that you would withdraw just to make a point. Of course, it never got. Never took off. Yeah, yeah. So exchanges were never actually threatened by this. They never had to sell some of their cash reserves or whatever, just to make sure they have enough Bitcoin to allow their users to withdraw.

4:04:56Curtis GreenYeah, yeah, I, yeah, they better be backing everything one to one or they could be somebody can be in a lot of trouble. If they find out that it's not, but that is scary. You know, I, you know, you know, obviously, in people put too much trust, but you're right, though, it's crazy to think that we're now we've done a full 360 from going away from banks to now the ETFs are the bank.

4:05:29Vlad CosteaAnd there's more to that, like on the Lightning Network, people who use custodial wallets, which essentially means banks, they have to trust someone else to hold the funds for them, and they just transfer on their balance sheet.

4:05:42Curtis GreenYeah, well, that's, that's why when I was talking about doing Lightning, I, when I was bringing up centralized, the only way I could find a good Lightning Network, it was totally centralized. And that totally defeats the purpose of Bitcoin. And when, you know, when I ran my node, it was, you know, it was not a centralized, it was, you know, it was the regular Bitcoin network, or the Lightning Network. And, but it was a losing proposition for me, it would cost me more to run, then, you know, if I broke even, I would have been okay. But I looked at my balance,

4:06:23Vlad CosteaI'm in the same situation. And I did this, like, three, four years ago. And I realized that I was spending more money opening and rebalancing channels than actually. So I wasn't routing too many transactions. And that's something that's a reality I had to confront. And I was thinking that maybe if I set up very good channels, and I connect with all the big peers, that I'm going to be somewhere in the middle collecting transaction fees. And of course, my fantasy never actually worked out.

4:06:54Curtis GreenYeah, see that I had the same hopes, you know, and I, and I just thought, I just saw a slow bleed of my satoshis going out the door. And then I finally had to say, you know what, time, I, you know, I like the idea of Lightning, I really think it's cool. But I financially, I can't keep it up. You know, it's, you know, granted, we're not talking big dollars. I mean, I was losing only what, 20, $30 a year, but still, it I was in the negative, you know, and then and then the force-closed channels. I don't know if you've ever had that happen to you.

4:07:38Vlad CosteaOf course, it's part of the Lightning journey.

4:07:41Curtis GreenYeah, oh, my gosh, that those are the worst and that you charge $30 or whatever it happened to be in Bitcoin. Oh, my gosh. But yeah, but I still have high hopes for Lightning. I still think there's some hope. And level two, I still think somebody's gonna come up with a level two situation, you know, I, that, that everybody will, will be happy with, you know, I know we lost our faith with Lightning, because everybody had high hopes for that. But you never know. I don't know. I wish we could go back to the old days, when blocks are empty. I'm not, I'm kidding, of course.

4:08:27Vlad CosteaThis is a consequence of adoption, and more people using is actually good. It's just that we did not find a good way to scale for everyone to use without major trade offs. Because whatever you use is not as good as the base layer. It has some advantages. But when you're dealing with layer twos, you talk about trade offs, you may gain some advantage, like Lightning has better privacy for the sender than the base layer. But it's not as convenient from a user experience point of view. It's not as secure.

4:09:05Curtis GreenYeah. And you still have the end-of-the-day problem of going on chain and off chain.

4:09:12Vlad CosteaWell, maybe not you, maybe someone else will have to do it.

4:09:15Curtis GreenBut yeah, yeah, but yeah, yeah. But I did. But until I ran my own channel, all these issues I didn't know about. And I always thought, oh, Lightning. That's, that's perfect. That's, this is the answer. But running a node for a couple years, I'm like, it was cool. It was it was a neat project. It was I'm glad I did it. But it was just like, you know, that's why I know, that's why, isn't all these companies, Cash App, Strike, they're all a centralized Lightning channel, I'm assuming.

4:09:55Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly.

4:09:57Curtis GreenYou know, and so they're, they're, they're controlling all they're, you're really not going on the Lightning Network, you're not you're just keeping in a, their own little loop. And so Lightning has got to really, you know, so when me or you open up a channel, we're really helping the network. Until that happens, Lightning won't work, you know, and the way that it's set up now, as we both found out, it's not working like we thought it was gonna work like, you know, so, but yeah, sure as it sure is interesting. And...

4:10:37Vlad CosteaBut I think it has two flaws, which might be fatal for it. First of all, it's interactive, which means you have to be connected to the internet all the time to send or receive. It's not like Bitcoin, where you can just shut down your node and just post an address. And someone's gonna send Bitcoin to you, even if your computer is offline. Because there are other nodes that work with the network, your Lightning node has to be online all the time for you to receive payments. And that's a big flaw of Lightning.

4:11:08The other flaw that I think might be fatal is this whole channel situation where in order for you to receive, let's say, half a Bitcoin in payment, you need to have a channel of half a Bitcoin. Yeah. So just imagine a shop or something. Basically, they would in order for them to be able to sell the most expensive item in the shop, they would have to open a channel, which is of the size of that value. Yeah, yeah. Imagine a car dealership or something. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. That's correct. Of course you can do it with multiple small payments, but it's not very practical.

4:11:58Curtis GreenYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I've always thought Lightning was just a small, it was for buying coffee, you know, one to two or three dollar type payments. That's what my final conclusion was. You know, it wasn't it wasn't for everyday big purchases, because of the problems you said that you'd have to have big channels. I know some there are some big channels out there that have one Bitcoin, but not very many.

4:12:31Vlad CosteaYeah, that's the irony of it, because the most successful channels are the ones that have a lot of capacity, even if it's not used. So they have very large channels, larger than one Bitcoin, which are available out there. And these are the ones that actually take up most of the activity. So if you open, I was actually thinking about this, because since most transactions are small, maybe it makes sense to just open a lot of channels of 10,000 satoshis each or something. Since that's an amount that gets transacted a lot for people to buy coffee.

4:13:05But for some reason, that's not really how it works. It's more efficient to have a few channels and very large capacity.

4:13:14Curtis GreenYeah, yeah, I don't know. I might get back into Lightning again, you know, but I don't. I don't know. I think they've got to come up with another, you know, I'm looking at the safe with going away from Umbrel into the StartOS system. Start9, I think. Start9, there it is. Yeah, Start9. And in fact, I ordered one in 2021. I put a $15 deposit down on it, and then the price went down. So I probably should either get my $15 back or order it.

4:13:52But yeah, I wanted to do the Start9. I still might. But I don't know, you know, how I'm going to do it or how I can afford it or anything like that.

4:14:09Vlad CosteaLet me show you a different product. It's called the BMM, which is the Bitcoin Mini Miner by Braiins. It's $300. It runs in the background, is not noisy. It's essentially a lottery ticket. What's very interesting about it is, first of all, the interface, because you can see the price on the screen, you can see a lot of data about the hash rate and whatever. And you can also set it up. So since it's a lottery ticket, and there are like three or four chains that use SHA-256 for mining, you can set it basically to give 70% of the hash rate to Bitcoin BTC and maybe 30% to BCH Bitcoin Cash, because maybe you're going to be able to mine a full block of Bitcoin Cash and that's going to pay for the electricity.

4:15:02Yeah, there you go. So you can actually do this with the firmware. I've received this one. I've been keeping it in the box because I am waiting for a good moment to do a video about it. But basically, I think I also have like a discount code for it. I think it's BTCTKVR, like Bitcoin Takeover. I think you have like 5-10% discount if you order it.

4:15:23Curtis GreenYeah, don't they just take the old ASIC chips from older miners and put into those? I think that's how they do that.

4:15:32Vlad CosteaNo, I think that's the Bitaxe.

4:15:35Curtis GreenOh, okay. You're right. Which is the open source. Yeah. Didn't a solo miner just hit one? He had, was only, not even a, was one of those? He just hit, it was a block just like a couple weeks ago?

4:15:57Vlad CosteaI think it happens.

4:15:59Curtis GreenYeah, it just happened. I was on Reddit and everybody said we want to see the proof and he actually showed his little mining system. He showed the screen where it came up. He had all the proof and he had only been in Bitcoin for a couple months and he spent $700 on his miners and he solo mined and he hit the lottery. And he said, yeah, I'm going to have to pay $120,000 in taxes. I'm going to pay off the house. And I'm like, no, no, you don't want to do that.

4:16:38You won the lottery. Don't sell your Bitcoin. But maybe he's a smart one. Maybe that's the way to do it. But I love hearing stories about that. I mean, the odds of that are so astronomical. But you have a better chance of winning the lottery like two times in a row than hitting one of those. But all you have to do is hit one. Get those 17 zeros or whatever they're at today. But yeah, mining has sure changed.

4:17:20Vlad CosteaYou got to try. And I think these small home devices are pretty nice because they don't consume a lot of electricity. They're not noisy. They don't generate heat. You just keep them running in the background and hope for the best. And they also show you the price, which I think is nice that there are some block clocks or something which are like $500 and they just show the price. I mean, why not get a miner instead? And mine also shows the price.

4:17:49Curtis GreenI've seen those that show the price. But yeah, it doesn't make sense. I'd rather mine a little bit and show the price.

4:17:56Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly. I understand it's a beautiful mechanical device and it shows you the price. I think it's stupid. I can have an app on my phone for that.

4:18:04Curtis GreenYeah, that's what I do. I try not to focus too much on the price because I don't want to fall down that trap again, stressing out over everything. But we're humans. We have to live on dollars. We need money to survive.

4:18:34Unfortunately, we have to think that way. So it's kind of a weird thing. It's a mental block that we have to get away from and it's really difficult to separate yourself from the fiat world. The perfect world would be like the guys on Bitcoin Talk or on the Silk Road. We would always talk about how wouldn't it be great if we get dollars out of our head? And we said, oh, this cost me 500 satoshis. Instead of turning in a dollar, we just go, oh, that's a good deal.

4:19:11It's only 3000 satoshis. You know, it's hard to wrap your head around that. And it's going to take a long time before we start thinking that way. And I think we start with the youth and we start teaching them that way, that thinking, and then they're going to start thinking that way. And then they're going to tell their kids. And that's how we get help with the adoption. We just start with the young folk. My grandson slash son, I'm teaching him Bitcoin, teaching him satoshis, teaching him the value of money and teaching them the right way.

4:20:00I didn't know about inflation. I knew about it, but I didn't know we were lied to, you know, and how money works.

4:20:14Like I said, I was 47 years old or 46 years old before I was 45 years old. I was old when I got into Bitcoin. And it took me a couple years to really understand it. So, I was already past my midlife crisis before I really understood money. And I don't want my children to go through the same thing I did. You know, I want them to learn and grow and expand from what I've learned, from my experiences, from all of our experiences. And I hope that, you know, one day we'll reach that consensus that may never come.

4:21:06But I think we'll be forced to one day. I think we're going to be forced to come together and say, yes, we need to expand on this, or we need to go in this direction. You know, it may not happen in my lifetime or our lifetimes, but I think that that day will come. But I don't know. Maybe I'm up in the night.

4:21:35Vlad CosteaI just want to point out that we are nearing 2,000 online listeners, like live people who tuned into this. And I also want to say that Curtis Green might just be, so first of all, this is his first interview in many years, and he has a lot to say. Secondly, he might just be the biggest person from the whole Silk Road story who's willing to talk. So if you're organizing a conference or you have a podcast or you have any kind of event, it's a good idea to have him and ask him questions and learn more about the spirit of the old days and what it used to be and maybe get some misconceptions out of your head, because what we have learned about, I remember reading a Rolling Stone article about Ross Ulbricht, like 10 years ago, and it portrayed him as this murderous, whatever, drug kingpin.

4:22:31Curtis GreenI remember the writer calling me and I said no comment, and he was one of two or three reporters that actually told me this. He said, well, if you're not going to speak about it, I'm going to have to put words in your mouth. He told me that, and he wasn't the only one. And so that's what happened with the Silk Road is it got misconstrued because a lot of us wouldn't go out and tell them what they wanted to hear. And I didn't want to go out there and I didn't want to talk for DPR or Ross or I didn't want to speak, so I just kept quiet.

4:23:17But now that he's out, I think only good can come from speaking about it and talking about Bitcoin and where we're going, where we've been, the mistakes that I've discovered, the libertarian viewpoint is all good and everything. And I've changed my thinking a little bit. But yeah, I think people would like to hear more about the story because I was in El Salvador last year and I did a little dinner and boy, I got so many questions and people were so enthralled with it. And so yeah, anybody that has an event or whatever, I'm more than willing to travel.

4:24:12So hopefully I'll be able to go to Spain this next year, maybe Costa Rica this coming spring. But yeah, any events or anything, I'll be more than happy to go and be of any help.

4:24:30Vlad CosteaI've also mentioned at the beginning of the interview that you can ask Curtis Green questions in exchange for donations. I don't think there was anyone who actually asked a question in the chat. There were more like comments about what we're talking about. So there was no specific question. If there is anything that you want to ask, do it now. But please promise that you're going to donate to his Satlantis campaign whenever that comes out on Monday or something. So do that, maybe give him 100 bucks or something.

4:25:03Curtis GreenYou know how I feel about that. But anything's appreciated, that's for sure.

4:25:12Vlad CosteaSince we're waiting for people to ask questions, let me ask you one because you said that Ross came out of jail and you tried to not comment too much until this moment. Did you actually correspond with Ross during the trial while he was in jail and recently after he came out?

4:25:31Curtis GreenYeah, I didn't talk to him at all. I got really close with his mother. Mother's a great lady, by the way. And I've talked to him a little bit, you know, via email. We chatted a little bit here and there. Nothing groundbreaking, just simple conversation. So I do communicate with them a little bit. Like I said, nothing groundbreaking. But yeah, the story is, like I said, if I could get it coordinated to start from the beginning and all the things that happened, it would make quite the, like Hollywood didn't need to make anything up.

4:26:28They could have just taken what the truth was and told the truth and it would have been more intriguing than what they turned it into. What they turned it into was a piece of garbage.

4:26:42Vlad CosteaOkay, so can you mention some of these wild moments that you think are spectacular and worthy of being in the movie?

4:26:49Curtis GreenWell, there was one vendor that he sold passports, legit passports, from the UK. And he charged like $20,000. And I thought, I don't know if this guy's a scammer. And so I reached out to him, just shooting, you know, back and forth. And I said, on his storefront, he says, I could only do one every three months. And he never said why. And I said, why? And this gave more legitimacy. He said, well, because I could only do one every three or four months because I have to go under radar.

4:27:40And I thought, oh, okay, well, that makes sense. You know, he's not trying to, if he wanted to, he could have, hey, I'm gonna charge $10,000 or whatever, and just got as much money as he can. And I checked his wallet. He sold a couple, but not very many went out. And I thought that was just so interesting to be able to get a legit UK passport without your name on it, be totally anonymous, and be able to travel around the world with a legit passport.

4:28:13And I thought, to me, that was one of the most intriguing things that I saw sold on Silk Road. And it had nothing to do with drugs. It was just a simple, you know, passport, you know. Were they legit? I don't know. You know, but there was, you know, there was a lot more things that were sold on there. Because it wasn't drugs, it wasn't worth talking. A lot of people threw up websites, threw up vending accounts that would sell anything. In fact, I did. We sold, I sold glasses, Gucci knockoff glasses.

4:29:02We sold gold, uncut diamonds out of Africa. You know, I don't know if, an American that lived over in Africa, you know what, I can go to the bazaar and find all sorts of cheap stuff and sell them on Silk Road. And it was, 99% of it was totally legal. The only thing that we kind of stepped on the edge of being legal, was some things that were sold in a pharmacy over there was legal over there, but not necessarily legal over here. You know, but that's about it.

4:29:41But they weren't anything major. It was like antibiotics, that sort of thing. It wasn't anything crazy. But there was a lot of vendors like that, like what I did, that were just trying to figure out, where can I stay within the bounds of the law? Without, you know, and still generate a business. And that we in fact, we on our on our site, we sold handmade suits. I don't know if we sold any, but we had them up for sale. And we had to ask their dimensions and whatnot. But so there's, there was a lot of, I don't know, I wouldn't say a lot, but there were a lot of guys that would throw up a vending account.

4:30:29And sell legit things. And but people don't talk about it, because it's not, you know, it's not the bad things. It's not the salacious things that you want to talk about, you know, selling Gucci glasses is no big deal. You know, it's, you know, but selling heroin is a big deal, you know, it catches your attention. So that's, you know, people don't really understand that, that Silk Road was a true marketplace. And even though drugs was the most prominent, it wasn't the only, there was a lot of stuff sold on that site.

4:31:08And, you know, one, one thing that it was interesting, somebody asked me not too long ago, they said, was was pornography on that site? And I honestly didn't know. I and I said, I had to go back and look at, look at my snapshots that I kept of the site, and to look through to see if it was, and if it was on the site, which didn't surprise me, but I had no idea. I mean, it was in my, it was in my thinking, I didn't look at, you know, so when they asked me that I had no idea, I assumed that they it probably was and it was, but it wasn't, it wasn't a big deal.

4:31:48You know, and that's, you know, and that's a shame that all these little tiny stories don't get picked up, you know, because they're, you know, they're only the one we care about are the like, the guys that sell drugs, or, you know, that are with the mafia, or the murder for hires, you know, we, you know, there's a lot of cool parts of the story that, that people probably never hear about, you know, and I hope to change that. You know, I, you know, well, like I said before, I have a lot of things I regret doing, but there's some things I don't regret doing, you know, I, you know, I, well, I would change things on what I did.

4:32:31Would I do things differently? Absolutely. But I'm kind of glad I got, did it, because it got me into Bitcoin. You know, it made me go down this path that I'm now in the, I'm going down. Does that make sense? So while I have my, well, I have, I made my mistakes. I, you know, I hope it's not that big of a deal. To get a pardon, because I, because I have a web, the website I put up is called PardonCurtis.com. And I, you know, and it was just, we just put it up a few days ago, we just still probably just a landing page right now.

4:33:17But I'm definitely going to go down that rabbit hole and see what it takes to get a pardon, you know, and if I can do it economically, and it's not too much, then I, then I, then I'll, why not? I might give it a shot. But if it's going to be too much, then obviously, you know, money can be used for better things than wanting my gun rights back. You know, that's, that's kind of stupid. But to think that way, but that really bothered me. That's the one thing that I had, you know, it's really dumb that I can't, that they took those rights away from me.

4:34:01Vlad CosteaSo it's not just about regaining your gun rights. It's also about cleaning your name for, I don't know, for the next generations of your family. And for history.

4:34:11Curtis GreenYeah, that's, you know, and that's, and that's, and that's what pushes me, you know, not only my gun rights, but just like to set the record straight. You know, say, hey, it wasn't, you know, it wasn't a lawless place. It, yeah, we made our mistakes, but we didn't, you know, we didn't, it's not as, you know, I know, it's hard to explain. It's, but you're right, I, think that, you know, it's important to at least try. If I don't, then if I don't succeed, and so be it, but at least I can say I tried.

4:34:55Vlad CosteaThere's also this crazy story that I read on your timeline. Just a second, I'm going to your profile. Actually, I got distracted by something and I forgot what the crazy story was. Let me backtrack a bit in my mind. I feel sorry for interrupting.

4:35:23Curtis GreenYou know, it's no big deal. It's no big deal. So was it about some vendor?

4:35:29Vlad CosteaNo, no, no, no, no. It was about going to a poker tournament with a T-shirt that had this Silk Road logo on it.

4:35:36Curtis GreenOh, yeah. Okay.

4:35:38Vlad CosteaThat's a crazy story. It's so ballsy.

4:35:41Curtis GreenOh, yeah. Oh, you said it, man. And so what? So I go to, I, this is a great story. I hit up DPR and I said, Hey, I like to play poker. I go, but I can't afford to get into the, you know, it caught, you know, to travel, go down to Vegas, a hotel room entry fee, you know, and I said, Hey, what if I'll make it make the T-shirt with Silk Road on it. And I'll go down there, you sponsor me and get in it, which he did.

4:36:17So I made the T-shirt. Now, I didn't put the word Silk Road on it because now that was too ballsy. Right? I didn't want to put the name, but I put the green camel. And I put my name on one side, the green camel on the other side. And we, he helped me design it a little bit, you know, it's, I was gonna wear the hat, but, and so I'll never forget, people trying to guess what that camel was about at the poker tournament. And I just kind of said, I hope nobody gets it.

4:36:56But nobody, nobody, no, nobody thought a word of it. But I thought it was, I thought it was funny. People actually, here, I was the admin at the time, right? And, but other people went that went down at the World Series that same year, wrote, wore a similar shirt, but it was a T-shirt, and they had nothing to do with Silk Road. Here, I was the admin of the Silk Road. And here I was wearing a shirt that we designed, paid with money from the site.

4:37:30So yeah, that was pretty ballsy to go down there. But it and I broke even. I came out a little bit ahead, I think. Didn't make a ton. But it was an interesting story. That's for sure. But yeah, that was that was 2012, the summer of, the spring of 2012. May of 2012. Yeah.

4:37:55Vlad CosteaWhat was the most fun you've ever had as an admin of the Silk Road?

4:38:01Curtis GreenThe funnest thing was getting to know all the different vendors from around the world. That, not anyone in particular, but they, I would, they are just normal people like everybody else that have problems in their days. And I would, I would have these great conversations with different vendors that have different problems and family issues and, you know, financial problems. And, you know, and we wouldn't, we wouldn't, we left Silk Road at Silk Road. But when we were talking, friend to friend, we were just, we were talking, I was talking human to human.

4:38:45You know, we were more interested in what we were making, you know, they were okay. They were, they were, you know, and the, I think I've mentioned this before, the camaraderie between all of us, we all had something in common. We had Bitcoin, and we were on a site. And those two things made us, made, there was a lot of trust that we gave each other because we were each other's brothers and sisters, if that makes sense. And so when somebody reached out to me, I would have a great conversation with them.

4:39:27And then I would talk to them for, you know, I was always their friend. And I made some great friendships over the, you know, the time I was there. That's probably the best one is making friendships. Too bad I can't meet them in real life and, you know, continue it. But yeah, it was just a bunch of regular people that, that, you know, sold things that they shouldn't have sold. That's what it comes down to, you know.

4:39:57Vlad CosteaI was going to ask you this, if you actually met someone from the Silk Road in real life?

4:40:08Curtis GreenI actually met a vendor about a month ago. He didn't know who, who I was, am I, he, and he brought up Silk Road and I said, oh, would you, got, and he says, yeah, I was a vendor. He sold mushrooms and sold something else and I'm like, okay, and then I told him who I was and he did a holy shit moment, you know, and he says, yeah, I got out of it without being arrested.

4:40:36I said, oh, I'm glad you got out of it and I'm glad, you know, but yeah, so, but I have met, he's my first one that I know for sure, but I think I've met a few others over the years, like at conferences and whatnot, that they just, in fact, in 2021, I met, I think, one of the guys that was at my door, who knocked down the door, I heard a, hey, Curtis, from across the hall and I looked, who is that, and he came up to me and he said, you remember me, don't you, and I, he looked familiar and he goes, I can't believe you don't remember me and I'm like, well, I'm sorry, I don't remember you because I was at your house and I said, and I jokingly said, oh, you're my nemesis, that was, I totally was joking and it pissed him off and he told me to F off and turned around and he, and it was at a Bitcoin conference and he was the same guy that told me that Bitcoin was no good and to get out of it, so I found that to be ironic.

4:41:47Vlad CosteaWait, so Shaun Bridges or what's his name?

4:41:50Curtis GreenNo, no, I don't know his name.

4:41:53Vlad CosteaOh, so just a random DEA agent?

4:41:55Curtis GreenHe worked for Homeland Security. When I was arrested, when they came busting down my door, he happened to be one of the agents that was there and he was with me up in Salt Lake and he drove me, him and another agent drove me home the second night and he, and that was the last piece of advice he gave me was to get out of Bitcoin because it would be nothing but trouble.

4:42:19Vlad CosteaSo he was at a Bitcoin conference?

4:42:20Curtis GreenYeah, he was at a Bitcoin conference in Miami in 2021 and he was all pissed off that I wouldn't, I didn't remember him and then, and then it all came flooding back right after I, right after he went his own way, after he flipped me off or whatever he did and I'm like, oh, I remember that guy now and I feel kind of stupid, but man, he was all ticked off that I didn't remember him. I'm like, well, I saw so many people that day, how am I supposed to remember you?

4:42:49That was 10 years earlier, you know, so I just found it to be ironic. So yeah, and then the other lady that I was, I wish I could, I have her card somewhere. She was part of Homeland Security. She actually became like two or three years after Silk Road, she became one of the head people in crypto, you know, like if there was a Bitcoin issue, she became one of the government heads. She was a blonde, I don't know what she's doing now, but maybe it's kind of chunky.

4:43:35I don't, I carry her, I'll have to find her card, but yeah, she was, she was like one of the heads of Bitcoin in the US government for the, you know, like 15, 16, 17, right around that range, but I really liked her. She was one of the few agents, when I was at my sentencing in Baltimore in 2016, they actually came on my behalf, and they all wrote letters to the judge on my behalf. And so she is a wonderful lady.

4:44:13She apologized for the hell that they helped put me through, and wished that they could take things back, and then she went on about saying how they went through hell too, which I'm sure she did, I'm sure the government went through every single agent with a fine tooth comb, and she told me that their lives were turned upside down too, even the ones that were totally innocent, and so there are some good people in the government, you know, so I found one, I wish I could remember her name, I have her card somewhere, I'll have to find it.

4:45:00But yeah, it's been an interesting journey, and there's just so many little things to talk about that people don't realize, you know, the one thing that I always say that most people don't realize is, do you know what was the currency used more than Bitcoin on Silk Road? Walmart gift cards.

4:45:26Vlad CosteaOh, amazing, yeah, you could buy these with Bitcoin.

4:45:31Curtis GreenYeah, yeah, it's because Bitcoin was so volatile, and vendors would take Walmart gift cards, so it was easier to go to Walmart, pay $100, because you knew you'd get $100 worth, you didn't have to worry about the up and downs of Bitcoin, but then, DPR changed, you could actually hedge your, so if you paid a certain percentage, I can't remember what the percentage was, but you could lock it in at that dollar value, it didn't matter if Bitcoin went up, or if it went down, it locked it in, so at the end, you might pay, you were guaranteed, if you were going to pay one Bitcoin for whatever, that's all you were going to have to pay for, and that was another feature that was put in, which I thought was good, because it stopped the, I mean, heck, by the time you put the Bitcoin on at $2 a piece, or $3, it could be up to $5, or down to $1, by the time you purchase something, so that's a huge, it's like Bitcoin going from $100,000 to $50,000 overnight, or even worse, $25,000, so percentage wise, it was, and whether you like Silk Road or not, it was actually, technologically, way ahead of its time, the way it was, the way he put it together, and the way it was ran, I mean, you got to hand it to the guy, I mean, that was a tough thing to do, and all under the wraps of not getting caught, you know, that was, that took a lot of balls, took a lot of effort, and Ross was very innovative, he's one smart dude, he really is, and so yeah, Silk Road was much bigger than drugs, you know, it really bugs me, you know, even to this day, I have to fight with my family saying, but you guys just don't understand, it wasn't about the drugs, they're all worried, they're all hung up on, yeah, but who ordered the cocaine that came to your house, and I'm like, how could I order that cocaine, that cocaine, somebody spent $30,000, do you think I had $30,000 to buy that, I mean, just logic, of course I didn't spend, have $30,000 to buy that cocaine, it makes no sense, and that's where I think the government realized really quick, even though I had to plead guilty, they would have had a tough time convicting me, because there's so many issues, like, I didn't pay for that, the only reason they could charge me is because I pled guilty, you know, is it came to my door, and I opened it up, but I didn't order it, there was no proof of me ordering it, there'd be the blockchain, right, that would be able to, I could prove that I didn't order it, or at least I'd make them prove to me that I did order it, I don't think they could, there's no way they could have proved it, because I didn't, I think that's what's so frustrating, is pleading guilty, I mean, yes, they could have got me for running the site, for money laundering, but the real thing that really bothered me was pleading guilty for something I didn't do, but it is what it is, but yeah, I might be guilty of helping run the website, but I was not guilty of that stupid cocaine that showed up in my house, because why would I not tell the truth about that? You know, it makes no sense, I would admit to it if I did, you know, but I don't know.

4:49:58Vlad CosteaYeah. So what do you think about subsequent marketplaces like Silk Road 2.0? I'm talking with Blake Benthall, who was running that one, to also get on the show, and I sort of convinced him when I met him in person, but since then, every time I message him, he doesn't seem responsive. And there are a bunch of other marketplaces that emerged after Silk Road was shut down. And the irony is that even when the founders were caught or something, they got like five years in prison, which was very different from double lifetime plus 40 years, I might say. But they were sort of clones, but do you think there was anything interesting to them, like?

4:50:44Curtis GreenYeah, they kind of evolved like AlphaBay, and in fact I was on a documentary with, about three or four years ago, a Canadian, the CBC asked me to be on, and so I went on for, they flew me to San Francisco, I was, they interviewed me for a few minutes, but AlphaBay was a guy, he was betting his Bitcoin left and right, and he got caught, and then he committed suicide in jail, and you know, that suspect, his suicide is suspect, and that's what they were doing a documentary on, but what I found interesting is, I was always wondering when they would start taking Monero, you know, and it didn't take long for the sites, granted, I didn't pay much attention to them, so I don't know when they started taking the privacy coins, but it didn't shock me at all when I saw, I don't know, AlphaBay started taking Monero, and that's the other thing, you know, Silk Road gets all the attention for being the first, but AlphaBay did like 100 times the transactions than Silk Road ever did, and he made so much money, he had houses all over the world, he had all these lavish cars, and then, the one thing about these dark web, there's, that's what I warn people about, there's really gonna be only two consequences, they're either gonna get rug pulled, the site's gonna shut down, which has happened many times, or the government's gonna come knocking at your door, and so that's, I always tell, I always advise people, you know what, keep those two things in mind before you, before you put your, you know, before you start playing around with the dark net, dark web, because usually it's one of those two things will happen eventually, you might get away with it a little bit, but if you keep at it, your event, your number is gonna be called eventually, so, but yeah, there is, there's a lot of, there's AlphaBay, there was another site that ran side by side with Silk Road called Black Market Reloaded or something, it was something like that, and when they saw Silk Road go down, they said, no, we're getting that while the getting's good, and they actually refunded, and they could have closed up shop, did a rug pull, they didn't, they gave everybody's Bitcoin back, they were, and then they just closed up shop and went away off into the night, and never to be heard of again, well they may have started up another site, but who knows, but yeah, it was Silk Road's only competition during that time, and it was a small site, but still they had thousands of people on it seemed like it wasn't as big as Silk Road, but it still had quite a bit of volume, but, so there's still some good people out in the world, you know, I mean those people could have, those admins could have easily rug pulled all that, those, you know, I don't know how much money it was, but, you know, not everybody's bad.

4:54:06Vlad CosteaI think there are lots of these stories in Bitcoin, I read about someone who at one point, like a Chinese Bitcoiner who had the capacity to run 51% attacks on Bitcoin, basically with his pool, and I'm not talking about Jihan Wu, that happened much later, there was this one guy who had the gear and also had the access to electricity, and if he wanted he could have a dominant mining pool that had more than 50% of the hashrate, but he chose not to, and on purpose he decided to basically downsize his operation so that it never becomes a threat to Bitcoin and waited for the competition to catch up, and there were also people on Bitcoin Talk who were very honest about their business, like they would frequently try to sell stuff and then refund people and it was very much voluntary.

4:54:58Curtis GreenYeah, there was a few guys on Bitcoin Talk that were trusted escrows, so if you ever wanted to, you know, they had trust points or whatever they give, and usually those guys were, all the transactions I saw those guys do, they were on the up and up, so I never did any transactions, but if I ever wanted to do something, I would definitely use one of those guys in a heartbeat, because you have to trust somebody somewhere, and those guys earned their trust, slowly but surely, but yeah, Bitcoin Talk's another thing that there was a lot of, I don't know if you call them scams, but a lot of advertising that went on, you know, to spin wheels, you had to pay, I mean if you go to one of my old accounts there, I think I have a, it's all full of, you know, crap, you know, I was trying to make money by people clicking on links or whatever, but yeah, Bitcoin Talk had its moments, but I never, it was good on some conversations, but overall Silk Road was the best place by far to talk about Bitcoin, and I'll always say that, until I see something better come along.

4:56:39Vlad CosteaThat's amazing, I want to once again announce your page on Satlantis, where people can donate to you, so let me take a look, you actually put it on your Twitter, so it's satlantis.io, and let's see.

4:56:58Curtis GreenYeah, I think you can look up my name, and Monday, I think Monday we're gonna have things for an event so people can actually donate, or go to our event that we're doing in El Salvador next week, or on the 17th, and we're gonna have, I'm gonna have t-shirts that say PardonCurtis.com or whatever, with the Silk Road emblem that I'm sure that we're gonna sell, I don't know, for 30 bucks or something, or I don't know, but Monday we should have that up and running on satlantis.io. It's an event website that's run by, it's Nostr, so you can pay, you know, it's micropayments or whatnot.

4:57:51Vlad CosteaIt's called zapping on Nostr.

4:57:53Curtis GreenZapping, that's what it's called, yeah. But yeah, it's up right now, but we'll have all the stuff ready to go on Monday, so.

4:58:05Vlad CosteaI'll put that in the video description once it's ready. Okay. Curtis, it's been almost five hours that we've been talking. Oh gosh. Actually, it's longer than five hours because we had like 20 minutes of prep talk before this. I could possibly ask you a lot of questions and keep this going for another five hours, but my girlfriend is gonna kill me because she cooked dinner.

4:58:29Curtis GreenThat's fine, we can do it another day too, so.

4:58:34Vlad CosteaYeah. Is there anything that you would like to say to the listeners or how to follow you, how to donate to your cause, where you're speaking and why they should listen to you, and also if you're a conference organizer, invite Curtis.

4:58:51Curtis GreenOh yeah, I mean, we're happy to come. I'm actually going and speaking at Adopting Bitcoin in El Salvador next week, and I'll be down there for the week, and we're doing my little poker event on the 17th at Satoshi's Bar down there, and all the info will be on satlantis.io. Just look it up there with my name, Curtis Green, you can find it pretty easily on Monday.

4:59:25Vlad CosteaOkay. Also, learn about the history of Bitcoin. I think there's actually a good documentary about the Silk Road that's called Railroaded, and it's a six-part documentary about Ross Ulbricht. I think that one is sort of officially approved that it's good, and unfortunately we don't have too many sources that are commodified. You still have to go through the chats, you still have to research a bit to see what happens. Just don't trust most of the journalism out there, it's bad. It's borderline character assassination for the people who were there and knew what was actually happening.

5:00:04And always remember that Bitcoin could never get to this point without Silk Road. Like it or not, it was there and it was the first significant use case for this internet currency.

5:00:17Curtis GreenYep, yep, yep, it was part of history and a lot of us go down as Bitcoin's, one of Bitcoin's biggest moments.

5:00:27Vlad CosteaThat's for sure. And since Ross Ulbricht doesn't do podcasts and is not interested in appearances like this, you can book Curtis. He's the guy who was there.

5:00:40Curtis GreenI'm an open book.

5:00:44Vlad CosteaI'm gonna speak with some friends who also have podcasts and different audiences. And maybe I can get you on Monero Talk for example, it's pretty big.

5:00:55Curtis GreenI'd appreciate that, thank you very much.

5:00:57Vlad CosteaThere's also the Digital Cash Network, which is from the Dash people. And maybe some other hardcore Bitcoin podcast that I know. I need to pick one. Basically to get you on as many communities, because Silk Road and especially the cause of Ross Ulbricht was very beloved and was embraced by a lot of communities at their core. And they decided that they want to donate money to him, they want to support him. And I'm sure that they will also show a lot of gratefulness to you also.

5:01:29Curtis GreenI appreciate that. And again, I don't want to come across as like I'm begging. It's just more of something that I need help with and I'm very bad at asking for help. And now that Ross is out, now is the time for me to spread my wings a little bit. Maybe I can do some more good and educate people and tell the story. And then we go from there.

5:02:11Vlad CosteaWhere can people follow you? And I don't mean follow you home so that you have to basically crawl from the living room to the bathroom.

5:02:20Curtis GreenI go on X quite a bit on Twitter. That's where I'm at most of the time. And I'll probably be on, I really like Satlantis, how you can create, you can post things. So I might be there a little bit more active. But I Love Poker is my moniker on X. So I post, you know, sometimes I'll go a few days without posting or a week. Then I'll post for two or three days straight. So I'm somewhat there most of the time, if that's a word.

5:03:06Vlad CosteaThank you very much, Curtis. It's been an amazing five hours of speaking with you. I hope that everyone listening learned something new about the Silk Road, about what the early days of Bitcoin were like. And the direction in which we're heading, basically, because we have to bring or keep that fire burning all the time. And remember why we're here. We're not here to become bankers. We're not here to become friends with bankers. We're here to replace the bankers. And we have work to do.

5:03:36Curtis GreenThat's right. That's what I agree with 100 percent. Hey, thanks a lot. I appreciate your time and I appreciate you having me. It's been great.

5:03:45Vlad CosteaI appreciate you accepting to do this because it's been work. I had to do a lot of work to convince you to join.

5:03:51Curtis GreenYou did, because I'm just so nervous. I trusted you. And that says a lot about your character.

5:04:03Vlad CosteaI appreciate it. I did not intend to portray you in any way. I just wanted to speak with you, learn more. I hope that everyone else listening also learned something new today.

5:04:15Curtis GreenYeah. All right. Well, thank you very much. I appreciate it a lot.

5:04:19Vlad CosteaThank you very much. And to the listeners, tune in on Monday when I interview Jonathan Bier, the writer of The Blocksize War and also the guy behind the BitMEX Research account and blog and everything else.

5:04:36Curtis GreenAll right. Tell him hi and tell him thanks for me.

5:04:39Vlad CosteaI will.

5:04:42Curtis GreenHey, well, thanks, guys. Everybody listening, watching. Bye party people. You get it. Bye bye. Take care now.

5:04:42================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with speaker diarization (Guest A -> Curtis Green). Second opinion: the local tiny.en transcript of the livestream audio in bitcoin-forks-research (S16E59 clean / .en.vtt), compared word by word. No clip re-transcription was done for this episode: the live pipeline was running ASR on another episode and available RAM stayed well under the 6 GB threshold, so stretches that neither transcript settles are marked .... Fixed a medium.en loop at 00:09:32 ("we would we would ... connect with you on that ... start the journey"), a duplicated sentence at 00:30:29, a doubled Moore's-law clause at 02:01:32, and a Whisper hallucination at 02:51:21 ("For more information, visit www.thevenusproject.com"), replacing it with the second opinion's words ("extort Ross of his Bitcoin" / "what that was, was based..."). Restored dropped words from the second opinion at 00:21:03 (Vlad's question while fixing Curtis's audio), 00:33:47 ("I should stay away from this ... I was stupid enough to open it"), and 04:29:41 ("antibiotics, that sort of thing"). Speaker turns repaired where the diarization switched a few words late or early (dozens of one- to five-word spills such as "Okay, so just", "It sounds like", "What do you mean play", "Just for the record", "I think", "Oh,", "Yeah,", "Thank", moved to the right speaker); Curtis's "Oh, is that it?" (01:48:21), "Oh, it probably turned off" (01:54:50), "I asked him a mining question" (02:43:14), "I'm an open book" (05:00:40) and the 04:35:20 exchange about the Silk Road poker T-shirt were split out; Vlad's "It's Antonopoulos" (01:47:01), "I found your node" (01:54:48) and "Yeah, exactly" (04:09:55) likewise; the "Spells of Genesis" NFT remark at 03:28:38 was reassigned to Vlad. Names and jargon checked against the title, show notes/chapters and the web: Curtis Green / Chronicpain / Flush, Silk Road / DPR / Dread Pirate Roberts / Ross Ulbricht, Variety Jones, Nob = DEA agent Carl Force, Secret Service agent Shaun Bridges, Campbell's chicken soup fake-death photos, Chuck Schumer, harm reduction, PGP (Pretty Good Privacy) / Phil Zimmermann, SHA-256, Bitcoin Talk, Casascius coins / Mike Caldwell / BIP38 / BIP39, Butterfly Labs, NiceHash, Zcash / Zerocash / Eli Ben-Sasson / Matthew Green, Monero, Peter Schiff and his father, Eric Voorhees, Satlantis / PardonCurtis.com / Adopting Bitcoin (El Salvador) / Satoshi's Bar, Wired, Roblox, Wasabi Wallet, Mt. Gox / Mark Karpeles / YubiKey, Bitfinex, Litecoin / Charlie Lee, Ripple, Andreas Antonopoulos / Mastering Ethereum, Roger Ver / Bitcoin Cash, Umbrel / Start9 / Raspberry Pi / 1ML.com, Liquid / Blockstream, WBTC / BitGo / Justin Sun, Satoshi on the metzdowd cryptography mailing list / James A. Donald / Perry Metzger, drivechains / Paul Sztorc, Paxful / NoOnes / Ray Youssef, SideShift.ai vs ShapeShift, GLBSE (Global Bitcoin Stock Exchange) / Nefario (James McCarthy) / Amir Taaki / Britcoin, MPEX / Mircea Popescu, Counterparty / Spells of Genesis, zkCoins / client-side validation, Taproot / SegWit, Proof of Keys (Trace Mayer, January 3), Braiins Mini Miner (BMM) / Bitaxe, Silk Road 2.0, AlphaBay, Black Market Reloaded, Jihan Wu, Nostr zaps, Railroaded, Monero Talk, Digital Cash Network, Jonathan Bier / The Blocksize War / BitMEX Research, the Bitcoin.com News article "Tales From A Dead Man: Curtis Green on Silk Road, Ulbricht", sponsors LayerTwo Labs (layertwolabs.com/download), Bitcoin.com News, NoOnes.com and SideShift.ai.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00