Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S17 E14 / Transcript
Transcript · S17 E14 · 1:42:23 · 20 Mar 2026

S17 E14: Kristian Csepcsar on Braiins & The History of Bitcoin Mining

With Kristian Csepcsar. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:47Vlad CosteaWelcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 17, Episode 14, I guess by the time I publish it. We are next to Kristian Csepcsar. I hope I said that correctly. He is like the chief meme officer at Braiins. He's the head of marketing. He's the guy who's doing crazy videos. Propaganda. Exactly. I don't want to call it propaganda. It sounds political. Okay, okay. Chief meme officer sounds amazing. I love it. He does amazing videos. He travels the world with his drone, film camera, and with his Bitcoin huge cheese roll or whatever that is.

1:23Kristian CsepcsarI call it Bitcoin inflatable, but cheese roll sounds also awesome. Cheese roll. Yes, exactly.

1:27Vlad CosteaAnd we are here in the building of Braiins in their undisclosed office, which is in a place that I will not dox somewhere around Europe. And it's so cool that we get to hang out and do this in person. They have been sponsoring the show with Braiins Hashpower for the past five or six episodes. And part of the deal was that they're going to bring me here and do a bunch of episodes in this studio in person. Up next, we're also going to have Summer. We're going to have people from Firefish.

1:56We're going to have Lukas, who is right here behind the camera. Very cool tweet about OnlyFans, by the way. I want to get this on record. And we're also going to have someone from Vexl. Grafton, I think. So all of this will happen in the studio. We're going to have a couple of giveaways. One is for you. One is for you guys watching this. It's going to be one of these awesome Braiins devices, because in case you're not aware, Braiins is a company that does both firmware for ASIC miners and also hardware and also books. It's very hard to describe. You guys are all over the place. Bitcoin mining. It's like everything.

2:37Kristian CsepcsarBitcoin mining. Is it hardware? Is it software? Is it firmware? Is it pool? Is it books? Is it memes? Everything. Basically calculators.

2:45Vlad CosteaHe's the author of this beautiful book, The Ultimate Bitcoin Mining Guide. You can see his name right here on the cover. It's ChipChat, by the way. If you don't know how to pronounce this, you're a loser and you should reconsider your life choices. Only two

2:57Kristian Csepcsarpeople ever in my life read it correctly, actually.

3:00Vlad CosteaYeah. And you have a foreword by Summer who's going to get invited in the next episode. It's very cool, very high quality. Where can people find this?

3:11Kristian CsepcsarSo it's for free download. If you go to braiins.com/books, all our books are for free, or you have to subscribe to our newsletter that you can later unsubscribe. So it's a fair price, I would say. And so we have that. So all the ebooks — we have like nine books from Bitcoin mining to Bitcoin mining economics to coding Bitcoin, white paper stuff and Rust. So we have from mining technical books to mining economics books, or to Bitcoin economics books to technical coding Bitcoin books. And all of them are for free download.

3:42We also make audiobooks. So we just published Bitcoin: The Ultimate Collateral free audiobook on BTC Sessions YouTube channel. We have more audiobooks coming out, or you can just purchase it. By the time this episode goes live it'll be also on Amazon. So of course you can buy it if you prefer the paper feel. How much? It's a non-profit for us. So I don't know, we're still about to publish. It's going to be like 10 bucks. Like I want to undercut everybody and sell the most volume because you know for us it's education and the marketing tool also.

4:17So I don't have to make too much. It's going to be cheap. It's going to be a good deal. And it's going to be next day shipping, Amazon Prime, all that stuff. So amazing.

4:26Vlad CosteaSo if you download the free ebook and you print it yourself, I guess it's more expensive than 10 bucks.

4:30Kristian CsepcsarYeah, I would say so. You will definitely destroy your toner. And also I have memes inside so you don't want to use your toner. Toner? Ink. You know, they're awesome memes. Like you don't want to waste your ink on the memes. Just get the ebook, listen to the audiobook or buy a book. Who's reading it for the audiobook? Who's? Sorry? Ah, Guy Swan actually. Yeah, Guy Swan. Oh, the Bitcoin Audible guy. You paid big bucks for that. Of course, of course. We have to do it properly.

5:03By the way, when you mentioned, I have a gift for you. So when you mentioned, so I like to do mining videos, right? So it's like I think in Bitcoin mining and even inside Bitcoin mining and outside Bitcoin mining, you need to share more knowledge, like how you're operating, what are the tips. People really like it. So I'm traveling the world. I'm showing how the mining operations look like. And I just returned from Norway where there was a very cool use case. Greentech company, shout out to them because they invited me, on the complete north, so like the polar Arctic Circle.

5:36So it's like the complete north of Norway, very cool, minus 20 Celsius. I don't know in Fahrenheit and freedom, don't ask me. But it was a two megawatts mining farm supplying the heat to like a giant office building. Two megawatts, which was an unbelievable story. So that's what we do in like spare time when we have some. So I brought you salami made out of whale because Norway, you can do taste testing on a podcast. So anyway, I hope you're not vegetarian, but I think you're not.

6:09Vlad CosteaI was for two years.

6:11Kristian CsepcsarReally? When did you quit? How long ago?

6:13Vlad CosteaSix years ago.

6:14Kristian CsepcsarWhat made you switch? The smell of bacon? No,

6:19Vlad CosteaI felt like I was dying, literally. Like it was like a contest of punishing my own body for two years. And then I just gave up.

6:29Kristian CsepcsarThat's very interesting because yeah, for me, like eating like one day, two days vegetarian feels like exactly what you're describing. Okay, so

6:37Vlad CosteaI know it's a weird question and this is salami. It's not made from the whale penis, right?

6:42Kristian CsepcsarYeah, that part I don't know. But generally, so the content said just whale. They don't say which parts, but the bad part is they always put to salami the worst parts. Because like, you know, so in Norway, they're one of the last countries that can eat whales. I don't know how, but there are very few of them. And you literally go in the restaurant, they have like a whale steaks. So I would say whales, the good meat goes on the steak and then whatever is left goes into salami.

7:12Vlad CosteaMakes sense. They dry the leftovers and they turn it. Makes sense. They dry the leftovers and they turn it.

7:16Kristian CsepcsarSo I'm not sure it's penis, but there is a very high chance it is.

7:20Vlad CosteaOkay, but you gave me whale meat. Okay. Is this a flex for suggesting that Braiins, also known as Slush Pool, also known as Bitcoin Mining.cz, mined more than 1 million Bitcoin? 1.3. 1.3 million in its

7:38Kristian Csepcsarexistence. So is it like a flex saying, hey, we have a lot of Bitcoin. I didn't think of it this way, but now that you're saying it was definitely planned this way. Yeah. Yeah. We've been around and you're very, very good that you mentioned it because like the history, most people know us through Slush Pool, right? It was like the longest and during the biggest bull market and the most, that was the era where most of the small pleb miners existed. So like most volume of the people would know us through the Slush Pool era, but they were way different as those exactly as you mentioned, it started as Bitcoin.cz mining pool.

8:12And then Slush was just signing the emails and then people were referring to — so it was Bitcoin.cz mining pool because we're from Czech. So.cz is the Czech ending. And then he was just signing the emails and people started referring to it as Slush's pool, like the pool of Slush, who was the nickname of the initial creator. And then, so we took over in 2013 because like he would, he wanted to do Trezor and it was quite, quite difficult to manage the whole growing, growing pool alone.

8:44So he invited like two friends, which is the two I's in Braiins. That's why we have so crazy name that I have to work with every day and it makes my life very difficult. So the two I's is the two co-founders of Braiins who took over Slush Pool. And they said, hey, this name really sucks. It's like Braiins.cz mining pool, it's terrible. And everybody calls it Slush Pool. Let's just rename to Slush Pool. So we actually renamed to Slush Pool in 2016, very late, but it was just before the bull market and just before the, like where most volume, like that was the times 2017, 18, where most number, like it was most decentralized in a sense, like just the absolute number of people mining.

9:21So I think that's why we're known as Slush Pool. Yeah. So yeah, we're actually, I think maybe correct me if I'm wrong, but I think we're the oldest Bitcoin company ever. Not just in mining. I don't want to, I'm not sure because I didn't check it.

9:37Vlad CosteaThere was no concept of a Bitcoin company before Slush came up with his mining pool in 2010. I was going to crack a joke that there is no I in Braiins. It's double I. No I? No I, you know. You mean like a human eye? No man, like it's like an American way of saying there is no I in team. You know? Oh, you're right. Yeah, we have a lot of I's in

10:03Kristian CsepcsarBraiins and we have a lot of very smart and very opinionated people so there is a lot of I's in Braiins, don't worry about that.

10:10Vlad CosteaI also want to mention that this episode is meant to be a short history of Bitcoin mining and that's going to be like the overarching topic of this. And I'm going to mention the sponsors and then I'm going to ask you to install Cake Wallet to make the giveaway because I know that Braiins, also known as Slush Pool, was also the first mining pool to mine Zcash. We

10:31Kristian Csepcsarstopped two years ago but we were, I think we were one of the first to support it, yeah.

10:35Vlad CosteaYeah, I'm going to give you one Zcash from Cake Wallet if you install.

10:39Kristian CsepcsarI think I will have to repent to Satoshi later. So

10:42Vlad Costeadownload

10:43Kristian Csepcsarit

10:45Vlad Costeaon your phone right now. And also for those of you listening, you can get one Zcash from Cake Wallet. Also you can swap it for whatever you want. You have Bitcoin in there, you have USDT, Litecoin, whatever, whatever floats your boat. There's also going to be a giveaway for this Braiins Dock. And the other sponsors are LayerTwo Labs building the drivechain, which is BIP 300. Are you a fan of BIP 300, Lukas? The drivechains. Yeah, it's good for the miners, right? Very good for the miners, yeah.

11:17And who else is sponsoring — Bitcoin.com News. They finally learned the difference between BCH and BTC. They're orange now, very cool. They changed even like the design? The logo, the branding, the identity, everything. Did they change the owner? Or was it like just a change of strategy? They changed the CEO. I'm not sure if the domain is still owned by the same person, but they changed their CEO. And the reason why I'm promoting them is that they have this good balance of institutional and political news. They're not like Bitcoin Magazine or CoinDesk, which are kind of extreme in their approach.

11:54They're sort of in the middle. So you find a lot of interesting news. And who else is sponsoring the show? Name of the wallet, Vlad's money, Vlad's free money. It's not from me. It's from Cake Wallet. Vlad's airdrop. Vlad's airdrop. Yeah, you can call it that.

12:09Kristian CsepcsarI understand. Shall we see it?

12:12Vlad CosteaOh, you're going to have to write down 12 words.

12:14Kristian CsepcsarI'll save it somehow. I'll deal with it later. You will YOLO. Continue show. Completely YOLOing live on the podcast. You see, you can save to, yeah, I shouldn't say. You can save to what? Nothing. Nothing. Can I look over your shoulder? Your seed phrase? For your giveaway? Yeah. So my giveaway is going to be, so we have a hardware division, like Braiins Forge, that we focus on doing some cool Bitcoin hardware. Bitcoin hardware. And this one was, because we created the mini miner back in the days, just mining with one terahash is just good for learning.

12:56And then we found out, okay, maybe we cannot compete with Canaan on the newest chips. Maybe we create a device that will mine using synthetic hash rate with hash power, but will not have any mining chips. That's why Braiins Dock was created. But generally speaking, it's just a smart display. You can check price alerts, price graphs. It can monitor Braiins Pool, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.

13:19Vlad CosteaPeople pay like 500 bucks for, what's it called, the block clock, which shows you the price.

13:25Kristian CsepcsarThis is 300 bucks and it can do, it's touch display, it has sound. It's programmable. You can develop your own apps for it. You can run Doom on it. They did. Yes, yes, we did run Doom. It's true. Sorry, I have to see my sixth word, which is this one. And okay, I have, okay.

13:42Vlad CosteaAnd also another sponsor is SideShift, which is also integrated with Trezor. Is it SideShit? SideShift with F, SideShift. I thought you were making a side shift. If someone offers to pay you in Zcash, but I'm not sure if they support Zcash anymore, but usually stablecoins and you should not hold on to that CBDC wannabe, swap it with SideShift. You can get Bitcoin directly to your wallet. This is his Zcash address for those of you who want to send him.

14:07Kristian CsepcsarYes, thank you very much. I'll swap it immediately to Bitcoin. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you.

14:12Vlad CosteaOkay. It's a feature inside of the wallet. I'll buy more whale salami for Vlad. Let me scan this. Like Roger Ver of Zcash right now. It worked. Now I type in the amount. It's $204 by today's rate.

14:28Kristian CsepcsarVery nice. Send it. You invite him and he pays me. That's very nice. Swipe this. Okay, swipe on my own risk. Swipe on your own risk or what? Risk. Risk. It's sent. So this is what you get for your time, man. But thank you very much. It's very generous. Say thank you to Cake Wallet. Thank you very much, Cake Wallet. Thank you very much, Zcash. Thank you. I mean, thank you very much, Cake Wallet, for your Zcash. And I'll be learning the first feature that I will try is your swap feature.

15:00So thank you very much. I hope it works. But how does it show? It will... Two-minute confirmation. Okay, okay. So thank you very much, Cake Wallet. I'll be trying your swap feature immediately, and then I'll send it to our hash power marketplace and buy some hash rate with it. I'll gamble on the lottery.

15:16Vlad CosteaYou can do that. Yeah, voilà. You can do that. hashpower.braiins.com with the double i. You can use your Bitcoin to buy, to rent hash rate.

15:24Kristian CsepcsarOn demand hash rate, yeah. So people... And then you can do whatever you want from it. So you can even like... There are a lot of people solo mining Bitcoin Cash now, because it's way better on odds than Bitcoin. So there are a lot of gamblers trying to hit a block. Then we have... Yeah, anyway, it's a marketplace for SHA-256 hash rate.

15:47Vlad CosteaMan, that's depressing. Like call me whatever if I'm wrong, but in a world where Bitcoin is winning, it would not be more profitable to mine Bitcoin cash solo.

15:58Kristian CsepcsarSo I checked yesterday and the hash price was slightly above Bitcoin actually on Bitcoin Cash. And I think it's because, and it's really weird because Bitcoin has the lowest hash price, all time lowest hash price, and the hash rate is still like not turning off. So there's no difficulty. I think, don't quote me on it, but I think it was like $44 against $46, something like that. It was like slightly by thin margin. Of course, it will like adjust and in the end of the day, it's same or Bitcoin Cash is doing worse.

16:31But for some reason, I just checked yesterday, somebody was writing in the hash power community that currently the Bitcoin Cash was slightly better. And of course, like the Bitcoin Cash hash rate, global hash rate is so low that you just purchase, I don't know, it's like six exahash, something like that. Like on our hash rate market, you can buy up to one exahash. We're still public beta, so we have one exahash, right? Bitcoin global hash rate is one zettahash, which is 1,000 exa hashes.

16:58Bitcoin Cash is just like five or something. So you can like purchase, you know, 20% of the total Bitcoin Cash hash power like for 50 minutes, for example. And that gives you a big chance for winning those solo blocks. But anyway, mine responsibly. It's still like, you know, yeah, I mean, solo mining is a type of gambling, so. It is a lottery. Yeah, it is. It is. It is a lottery. What I like about it, and I think there's most, and like I and myself did like 30 orders for the, we have Braiins Solo, so like solo mining lottery using the hash power and deploying on Braiins Solo.

17:36What I think is, and I'm talking to my friends, most people like that it's way better odds than winning a Powerball, because like it stacks, right? You're mining a block every 10 minutes. A Power what? Powerball is like the biggest lottery in the US, so that's what I would refer to. I heard Powerbomb, which is like a wrestling move. You know

17:53Vlad Costeathe Powerbomb? Did you watch wrestling as a kid? Did you watch wrestling? Like a sports guy? The Powerbomb is when you lift your opponent like this and you slam him on the floor.

18:03Kristian CsepcsarYeah, that sounds like wrestling, yeah. That was a Powerball. So because Bitcoin mining block is mined every 10 minutes, like your odds are pretty okay like when you, for example, see the odds of using one petage of mining over one day, right? It goes to, I don't know, one in each, I don't know, 7,000 tries, like it's way better. And also, then you have the, it's continuous, so you have like rolling of the dice, like continuous with lottery, it's just like you wait one week and then you have one chance, right?

18:33So I think that also attracts people, so it's like continuous thrill of the game, and you can see how close are you hitting to the difficulty target. So it's like it's way more engaging than just waiting for the, and then you're giving money to secure Bitcoin, so it's like you sort of have a good feeling about it, because you're not giving money to gambling companies, you're like securing Bitcoin, right? So you have a good feeling, and yeah, so I think that's what really attracts people. Like we mined a block, so using your brains hash power on Braiins Solo last week, like seven days ago.

19:07I did see that, yeah. And the market went crazy, like we had to deploy one additional exahash, now we have some stability issues, like because the demand is so big, like we're selling out every day, and we're still in public beta, it's not even one month of public beta. So I think in two days, yeah, 11th, it's gonna be month. So you can see like people just like it. Of course there are different use cases, it's not just about gambling, there are, for example, to give you one like regular B2B, okay?

19:36So it's like you have a hosting center, you're a hosting provider, so you have big data center, and you're hosting machines for other people, and some of the hosting companies have like for example, contract that they have to deliver 90% uptime, for example, otherwise they get fined. So if they have unscheduled maintenance, they can just purchase the hash rate online, and cover for example, for those 12 hours in one day, because to see the contract show up again. So it's not just a gambling tool, but yes, I would be lying if I said, hey, vast majority of the early adopters are like degenerates like me, who has like 30 orders on Braiins Solo, just hitting the lottery.

20:13But yeah, and then we found another block, by the way, on Parasite Pool. So somebody rented, I think, free petahash, and pointed it to Parasite Pool, that was four days ago.

20:25Vlad CosteaThat's really amazing, man. And we're talking, I remember when this was still pre-launch, like it was still a website that maybe had five people who knew about it. And you showed me how this works. And we're just brainstorming how we should promote this. And you said you should also talk about this on your podcast. But then someone actually solo mined the block, and it was within the first month of the service's launch. And that's the best marketing ever.

20:54Kristian CsepcsarIt's done what we would be building for the next few months, honestly. Like the level of attention, and everybody, if you see it working, and that's also very important. Like the biggest solo mining pool is CK Pool, right? And like with solo mining, you're waiting years for somebody to hit it. So if something is not working, you're very, very afraid to point the hash there. So you really want to use services that are proven. So like us showing it's real hash rate, and you can deploy it in solo mine, that like validates it.

21:25Without it's like a lot of like uneducated users that would be like, I'd much rather use something that like has a proven track record. So it's very, very important to prove, hey, this works. And it's very simple to use. Yeah. So anyway, that was a segue for hash, but I don't know how we got there. It doesn't matter how we get there.

21:45Vlad CosteaI also want to point out that you guys are pretty cool for doing this, because today most mining farms are pivoting to AI. And they're deciding that it just pays better per kilowatt or megawatt or terawatt, whatever it is that they have to support AI. And in this era, when farms are deciding that they want to support AI, as opposed to mining Bitcoin, you guys are launching the service, which allows people. So for the price that you pay for a Bitaxe or the Bitcoin mini miner that you have, the BMM, you can rent a lot more hash rate and have much better chances.

22:25And you can also allocate the money that you would spend on electricity in a month. And if you're in Europe or the U.S., you're going to be paying a lot to keep that running. Let's say that $30, $40 per month. You can just purchase that in lottery tickets on your marketplace for hash rate, and you get much better chances at hitting a solo block.

22:42Kristian CsepcsarIt's true. And you can adjust, so you can adjust the budget, how much you want to spend, the duration, and the speed. So with Bitaxe, you can have like one terahash over the lifetime. But you can change it and say, okay, I'm going to spend what I would spend for Bitaxe, the $100, and have like 10 terahash.

23:00Vlad CosteaIt's not $100. It's like $250,

23:03Kristian Csepcsar$300. I mean, it depends on the model, because they made the gamma, I think. Yes, yes, yes. I think the cheapest, like very bad build quality, you can get 400 bucks, I think, like Bitaxe gamma, but like with the terrible fan and stuff like that. But anyway, yeah, yeah. So it has to be accessible. So we made it as simple as possible. And yeah, the switch to AI is very true. By the way, we just came, our, this is what she said. We just came?

23:37Vlad CosteaI don't know. My compulsive thoughts. Usually it's I just came, but we're in the Czech Republic, and you guys are into orgies and stuff. So that's why it's sweet. But anyway, so our chief of

23:49Kristian Csepcsarcommercial. I wish we could record the reaction of Lukas. A lot of facepalming behind the camera. But anyway, so our chief of commercial came from a conference last week. And he said that it's very clear that like nine out of 10, big, big, big publicly traded miners are pivoting to AI. So that's going to continue. If I have to bet, most of the publicly traded miners will be out of mining completely by the end of this year. And I would and I would assume it will continue for the next two, three years, this AI boom, and then like some type of bubble will burst.

24:24But currently, yes, it is more profitable. But not only that, it is very clear that when you watch the share price of publicly traded miners, they didn't even have to be profitable. They just mentioned that they are pivoting to AI and they have a price bump. And when a publicly traded miner, they even like released a good, good, good numbers that yeah, we're profitable. We're stacking sats. It didn't pump at all. So for now, it's you have to be on the AI wave to get to raise more capital to build new. It's like 2017

24:57Vlad Costeawhen companies were mentioning that they're moving on the blockchain or something that they're going to have a blockchain for something now they're going to have AI for something. Very vaguely. Yes. But I'll put my book.

25:09Kristian CsepcsarI'll put it already. So it's in the shot. So maybe the giveaway. So what are we going to do?

25:18Vlad CosteaSo my idea was to add an extra challenge to winning this because it has to go to someone who really wants it, right? True. So you guys have a newsletter on your website.

25:29Kristian CsepcsarLike a weekly digest of what happened most important in Bitcoin. And people go to braiins.com with the double I. braiins.com/newsletter. Yeah. Yeah. braiins.com/newsletter.

25:41Vlad CosteaYou register to the newsletter and we're going to basically look at the date of the sign up and give it perhaps a week should be enough for people to register to that. And you can just pick a random email from that list and you send them.

25:56Kristian CsepcsarWe'll do that and they'll win the Braiins Dock and the book. Done deal. But they should also do something like subscribe to the podcast. You have to follow Kristian on Twitter. Do it all. Do it all. Start with the news. Like, subscribe and then go to the newsletter. But there is no way for us to check that you actually did that. Well, no. No. The winner will have to provide a screenshot. OK. Yeah. So it's like if you win and you're not going to send the screenshot, we know you're lying.

26:25You're playing hard. Yeah. Yeah. I like it. Yeah. I'm a marketing guy. I have to have the KPIs. We have to hit it. We have to hit it. Anyway. So that's that. Yeah. So AI switching, hash power. I'll throw in let's say 21 bucks for hash power to try hash power.

26:44Vlad CosteaOK. So the lucky winner is not just going to get this wonderful device which shows you the price and some information and can run Doom if you mod it. Yes. You also get 21 bucks on hashpower.braiins.com.

26:56Kristian CsepcsarWhich buys you, by the way, one petahash. I think one petahash for two hours costs six bucks. Which is one petahash, by the way, is one thousand terahashes. So it's one thousand Bitaxes. One thousand Bitaxes for six hours? One thousand Bitaxes for two hours costs, I think, six dollars. Six dollars. OK. So you're going to get a legion of Bitaxes, basically, to solo mine, basically. And you can adjust the durations. Your BMM also has one terahash, right? Yes. One point two, I think. You can overclock it. One point three, you can overclock it, yeah.

27:28Vlad CosteaBut as you are saying, so for people wanting to buy that, first of all, you go to the website and you use promo code BTCTKVR and you get five percent discount. On the store at Braiins. That's, yeah. Yeah. That's a must. For our mini miner, yes. Secondly, the beauty of it, and maybe that this sounds like your spiel from two years ago or something, but you were not on the podcast two years ago, which is fine, is that you're going to discover the software of the miner. Yes, yes. And that's the best part, because it's not all in.

27:56You can program your hash rates to go like 80 percent BTC, 20 percent BCH or whatever, and you're going to have two lottery tickets running at the same time, which might give you better chances at making it sustainable for you to run this. Or you can try BSV, but honestly, fuck.

28:14Kristian CsepcsarBSV, it still exists. I would be very curious, check what's BSV hash rate, global hash rate. I think it would be like for a few dollars, you can like 51 percent attack BSV. They're just going to roll it, bro. Yeah, that's true. But just for the fun of it, I think it's going to cost like a few bucks. Like 250 petahash. So you can like five times over with the Bitaxes, just with the small hash rate that we have, we have like four times more hash rate than BSV, total global hash rate.

28:47Vlad CosteaBrutal, brutal. For a long time, I guess for a few years now, Braiins has been known like this five percent mining pool, right? Yeah, yeah. You guys are not huge anymore. No. But you mined a lot of Bitcoin in your existence. And this is like my transition into the history of Bitcoin mining. Because in the beginning, as it says in the white paper, Satoshi wanted one CPU, one vote. He was hoping that every user of Bitcoin is going to install the software on their laptop or desktop computer, and they're going to mine.

29:19And that's how it's going to get decentralized. And he was maybe naive in his assumptions. There's even an email that he sent to Laszlo Hanyecz at one point. That's how you read it? I

29:29Kristian Csepcsardidn't know actually. Hanyecz. Okay, now I know. Now I know. I always read it like... He's Hungarian, so... Hanyecz? That's how I read it, I think. Hanyecz? Yeah, I don't know. I don't know. Doesn't matter. Hanyecz. Yeah, say

29:48Vlad CosteaHanyecz. Hanyecz. I think. Okay. Anyway, anyway. I'll have to... We'll double check later. So Satoshi sent an email to him. He was the first person to mine with GPUs, and he set up a tiny GPU farm. In his house, and Satoshi was not happy about it. And he said, Hey, man, I'm not a socialist or something. I'm not gonna tell you to stop. But could you please not mine with GPUs anymore? Because I want more people to get coins. And just a few months later, Slush launched his mining pool.

30:21And it's actually an interesting story behind that. Because the way that — and it goes back to Zcash. Because the way that Slush learned about Bitcoin is that he was working on the open source project that Zooko was heading at the time, which is Tahoe-LAFS file sharing system. It was a peer-to-peer file sharing system. And Zooko was working on it. And Slush was working on it. And Zooko decided one day in 2010 or 2009, even, to send an internal email to all the employees and say, hey, check out Bitcoin.

30:58It's really cool. Wow. And Slush decided to start mining. And then he was like, huh, what if instead of trying to compete for the reward, like all the rest of them, I join forces with a bunch of friends, and we're gonna get more rewards, and we're gonna split everything according to our contribution. And that's how the first mining pool was born. Slush was the mastermind behind this. I guess because this mining pool emerged, we have this blossoming scene in Prague with all the Bitcoin stuff. Like, of course, there was the merit of the people who individually contributed and created meetups and then Paralelní Polis and then the conferences and everything that happened afterwards.

31:39But if it wasn't for the mining pool, I don't think there would be so much stuff in the city. Maybe it would be like Budapest or...

31:47Kristian CsepcsarLike this, still, Paralelní Polis would exist, and that would be a strong community around. But I think it all started there with the mining pool for sure. Because then, like, he started attracting a lot of interesting talent around him, and he started, like, educating about Bitcoin. So I think that was the trigger for Prague community to be this, like, hardcore Bitcoin. Yeah. For sure.

32:10Vlad CosteaSo the mining pool happened. It was announced on BitcoinTalk, I think in late 2010. End of 2010, because first block was mined 16 December 2010. And Satoshi actually reacted to that, and he got to see his idea about his invention get destroyed by this concept of mining pools. And that was just the beginning. Like, in the beginning, it was just a bunch of nerds with their CPUs or GPUs saying, huh, let's try this Bitcoin thing. It's less than $1 per coin. It's maybe just less than 1,000 people around the world using it.

32:47Let's give it a try. And it just grew from there. It became crazy. Then they decided that GPUs are not good enough, and they went to FPGAs, and then the first ASIC companies emerged. There was Butterfly Labs, there was Canaan.

33:03Kristian CsepcsarYeah. So let me rewind a little bit. By the way, I have the whole chapter. So I wrote this book very differently, so it's like 10 sentences per page. So you can read, it reads like a Twitter thread, so you can read the whole book in like three hours. But I have a dedicated section on it, like the history, because I think it's very important, and in mining in particular, because the mechanics of mining doesn't change, right? It's still roll of the dice, SHA-256, but who mines, and on what scale, and what tools changes, and I think it's very important to understand the history, to understand where we're going.

33:37So let me just make a few clarifications about how it started. So, yes, Slush was there in the beginning, but if we go super in extreme details, the concept was discussed generally in the BitcoinTalk forum. Slush was one of the guys discussing it. But then there was one pool, so historically, if we want to be super specific, there was another pool that launched just like a week before Slush, and it was called Pudding Pop's pool. Pudding Pop? Pudding Pop. Pudding Pop. Pudding Pop? I don't know how to pronounce. Pudding Pop. But the thing was, it didn't have any public stats, and it was working very very bad, so it is very debatable if it was a successful implementation or not, because nobody was connecting to it, for some reason it didn't work well.

34:28And then Slush launched, and when he mined the first block, Pudding Pop died, like the website died. So we say, so with clear conscience, I would have to include that, as like that was some more discussion in the beginning, but we say we're the first successful implementation, because you have to implement it, people have to start connecting, you have to be pooling the hash rate, and actually start mining block after block after block. So we say, yeah, we're the first successful implementation to withstand the test of time, but simplified it just like nobody looks, and somebody created a website that didn't actually work, and didn't have any public stats, so was it really the first one or not?

35:08That's why the history simplifies, we're the first one. And then one more interesting, so that's just for the curious minds out there, you can go find Puddingpop, or whatever the name was. And then... You can launch a meme coin with that name. Yeah yeah, Puddingpop coin. And then... So that was the... So end of 2010, that was when the GPUs started to mine, like during 2010 there was a big boom of the GPUs, and Slush was exactly thinking like how do I keep in the game with CPUs, because I don't want to buy 10 GPUs.

35:44So at the end, GPUs were booming, CPUs were completely gonna get destroyed, because it's just not enough of hash power to compete with the GPUs. And that's why the pools were also created, it was one of the main motivating factors to keep CPU players still in the game. And as you can see, the pool got created, and that's how you kept the CPU miners a little bit longer in the game. And then in 2013, the ASICs came out, and that was in the beginning of 2013, and then hash rate went like absolutely crazy.

36:21Because ASICs are just like specialised to do one single thing with mining, and really the specialisation that you can really see, if you do one single thing you do it super well, and it's like you cannot compete with GPUs at all. Or GPUs cannot compete. And then in 2013, so in the beginning, the first ASICs were created by Canaan. So they are still in the game, so they are publicly traded, Chinese company in Singapore, publicly traded in the US I think on NASDAQ. And they are the first, and their CEO is like the original gangster, like a true lover of Bitcoin, he was the nerd like really making the chip.

37:00So they were the first, but they always didn't have good management of the company. So even though they were first, and almost a year before Bitmain launched, they just sucked at business. I think it was, so you can see they are publicly traded in NASDAQ, they are almost getting delisted every single week, they are struggling to sell. Last, lately they improved their machines so they are a little bit better, but in general they will have like maximum 2% of the global market, that's it. Which considering they were first in 2013, and to do it this badly, anyway end of 2013 Bitmain came in and they dominated 80% of the market until today. So it's brutal.

37:43Vlad CosteaIt is, and before that there was Butterfly Labs, which was sort of a scam to a degree because a lot of people paid for it and they never got their delivery. I know a bunch of guys who mined a lot of Bitcoin with their GPUs and are very happy, and then they saw the first ASICs being announced, and they did their napkin math and they said, wait a second, if I was able to mine this much Bitcoin with this GPU, then with this machine which is maybe 100 times more efficient, I'm going to be able to mine 100 times more Bitcoin, right?

38:14So they spent their Bitcoin to buy the ASIC miners, and it was a coordinated effort by a bunch of guys who had no idea about each other. The companies making the ASICs, they made a lot of Bitcoin. Companies like Butterfly Labs didn't even deliver all the machines. And way late. Very late, by the time that they delivered, the difficulty of mining spiked because of the ASICs, and the guys who were hoping to make a lot of money with their mining, they never made even 10% of what they paid. And then the first halving happened also, or was it before? When was the first one?

38:55Kristian CsepcsarYeah, around ASICs, yeah. I think the Canaan came out just before the first halving. I think that makes sense. One more thing that I remember about pools, that I just remembered. Yeah, one more thing. Do you have a tissue, guys, behind the camera? I like allergies starting. I really need a tissue. Like it's the beginning of the spring season, it's already starting. Anyway, I'll tell you a short story before they fetch me a tissue. So in the beginning, Slush wanted to launch the pool without fee. Because he didn't actually think Bitcoin mining pools will survive in this model.

39:33So he was gonna just test it, let's just stay in the game with CPUs for a little bit longer. That was the whole plan. And then he got some backlash on the hey, if it's for free, you're gonna be centralizing power. And he was like, no, no, no, dude, I just wanted to play around with this. Let me put a fee because like, yeah, I'll put a fee, it's fine. And then he sort of randomly, and it's like a little bit of a legend, but a little bit I spoke about him.

39:59And he just picked like the two. Currently, the standard pool fees is like maximum two and a half percent. And then the bigger you are, the lower the fee goes. And he sort of picked two percent randomly. He was like, how do I price it? And he was like, yeah, this feels about right. And then, so looking back, he was really angry because he was like, if we started, I don't know, five, something like that, it would be way more sustainable because later when Chinese pool entered the market, they bring two inventions, FPPS, which is like way more stable pool rewards.

40:37So all the miners prefer FPPS, it's just more stable, that's what I prefer. And then what they know how to do is like to cut prices. So like from two percent margin, which is already razor thin, like the price war started. So anyways, so small segue, he introduced the fee in order not to centralize power, and then picked two percent sort of randomly. And later was really angry because he started so low, it was so difficult to come even lower. And that's also part, financing FPPS is very, very, very, I don't want to get into too much details with FPPS because it's very boring.

41:13But you need, like, it is very difficult to survive on the razor-thin margins, you have to create some reserves that you use and constantly work with to pay the miners. And when you have like two percent public fee, but most of the big miners, so your effective fee is something around half, it's very difficult to operate FPPS. So anyway, so that's how we live with the baggage that they created years ago, right? Sort of randomly sort of on a whim, because they all thought it's not going to be here around like in the next few years. And we're still stuck with the same models, with the same mechanics, etc.

41:48Vlad CosteaAnd it's been 16 years. It's been 16 years of them, yeah. It's amazing. Oldest company in Bitcoin. Almost 16 years old. It will be 16 this year.

41:57Kristian CsepcsarThis year? Yeah. Or it started mining, I think, November, like a month before, and it took a month or, don't quote me, either two weeks or three weeks to mine the first block, December 16. So end of November, we have a birthday. We should do a party. No, we didn't. But I'm doing sort of parties always everywhere, so... Yeah, but you should

42:24Vlad Costeamake something meaningful. Yeah, no, I agree. Parties should serve a purpose, not just be something you do every week, just because the week

42:31Kristian Csepcsarended and you survived. No, I mean, we do a lot of mining side events. During BTC Prague, we did a mining roundtable. So those parties, I don't mean going with a beer. Yeah, we plan to go for a beer tomorrow, but that's called a Tuesday. That's not called a party. Exactly. Anyway, I'll seriously consider a big party, yes.

42:53Vlad CosteaIn 2011 or 2012, there was also a major hack of Slush Pool. Yes, yes. The Linode one, because a lot of information, don't quote me on this, I don't know exactly what was being stored there, but it was using a hosting service called L-I-N-O-D-E. Linode, Linode, I don't know how you call that. Third party provider, yes. Yeah. And they had... Yeah, they stole... 3,000, I think. 3,000 Bitcoin? And today's numbers is insane. It's insane, yes. What Slush did at the time was...

43:29And by Slush, we don't mean the pool, we mean the guy Marek. He paid everyone out of his own pocket. He decided that this is a catastrophe. It can cause basically the end of this business. So he decided to pay everyone 3,000 Bitcoin from his own pocket. And this incident also led to the creation of Trezor. That's when he was like, we need a more secure system to sign transactions. And that led to

43:54Kristian CsepcsarBraiins taking over the pool also. So just to put a little bit more context. So Linode was third party server, like, I don't know, like Amazon, whatever. So that was another one. And the hacker found a way to hack them. So it wasn't a problem of the configuration of Marek. They somehow, and I don't know, there are articles you can find it on... Some people think it was an inside job or something, some employee... Very possible. So that's the part. So a lot of things came. So I'm happy it happened because Marek decides to...

44:20Marek is the real name of Slush. He decides to build Trezor. He decides that it is so much work that he needs more help. So he was like, hey, Braiins, come and take over the operation because I cannot scale this. It's too much. So that's where he decides to invite Braiins and they took over the operation. And also that's the moment where the decision was made exactly. Jan Čapek came and he was initially the guy who took over the infrastructure. And he made the decision, no third party.

44:47We're going to build our own hardware. We encrypted in-house literally in our office, and then we ship it around the world to the data centers where they put it in. So that was the decision for end-to-end. So very silver lining, really. Bad stuff happened. It wasn't on the mismanagement of Slush. It was maybe inside job of the third party. Maybe we expose on the third party. But a lot of good things came out of it. So I'm very happy that it didn't kill the business. Like that it was an existential back then and really a lot of good things came out of it. Yeah, that was 2011. Yeah.

45:25Vlad CosteaAnd if you listen to older interviews with Slush, you will say that he was so stressed at the time, managing the mining pool. And he was always concerned that something bad can happen. He had alerts on his phone and he was saying that he was going on dates with girls and he was going to the opera or something, and then he would get a message and he had to run away to go back home to his computer to fix an issue, someone trying to attack it or whatever.

45:49Kristian CsepcsarIt's true. It's true when the guys took over. So I'm mostly connected with them. So when they took over, they were going to everywhere with laptop, like literally to opera, you would bring a laptop and you're like always on standby. So the wild west times, yeah, back then. But that's way before my time. So I joined the company in 2018. And you've been here for eight years. So I'm with the company for about eight, but full-time it's going to be seven this summer. So yeah, it's going like crazy at the time.

46:27I love it. So when you're having fun, you know, it's not like, really, it's like before I worked in a corporate job, like I had a good, like I worked in KPMG. So like the big four classic, right. But I had the accountants, I was doing IT audit. Like they're mostly known for finance audits, but I was working on the IT team, like the IT audits. So you have to audit the IT systems and the procedures and admin rights, et cetera, in order for the finance team to know they have correct numbers to audit, let's say.

46:55Vlad CosteaSo would you say that your job right now is anywhere near that? Do you audit anything?

47:00Kristian CsepcsarNo, no, no, no. I don't. I create memes. I create memes about terrible hash price. No, it's my favorite. So it's my favorite. It's the typical, so in the chapter where I explain the hash price, like all the basics of the mining, mining economics, it shows like where does it hurt, right? And it's like the headache on head, stomach aches, stomach, stubbed toe, and then hash price. Just so you know, the camera is there. Yeah. And then it's one of my favorite memes. So like the hash price being 0.06.

47:33Right now we're even lower than this. So this guy is like dead underground because even in the meme, it's like, it's way better hash price than currently. Anyway. So yeah, that was the note. That was the hack. And then yeah, and then Marek actually slash goes on to create Trezor a little bit later. We take over managing the pool because it was unsustainable for him. And that actually continues for quite some time when we discuss brains because we started making, that took a lot of time. And really, I think for me, I have like very two important points in Bitcoin history and mining history.

48:10And that's the bull market of 2017 because really you see, and I discussed in the book, that's where we got this fancy office. And that's where we from 10 people all of a sudden grew to 60 people. Like really that in mining, that's literally the point where hobby companies and like people with 100 machines in their garage sort of went into publicly traded companies. So 2017 is really like from the like pleb mining and it's a hobby to, okay, this is going to be a serious business.

48:40So all the Riots and Marathons start to get created, publicly traded mining, billions of dollars raised, giant teams and exactly. And Braiins stops being this garage company and like get super fancy offices and gets a person HR to hire dozens of people, right? I think that 2017. And then for me, it's the China ban. So like Chinese 2021. Yeah, that is very, like, I think it's way more important than Taproot or whatever. That's how you got married, man. Who got married? You got married because of the China

49:09Vlad Costeaban. Did you ever think about it?

49:12Kristian CsepcsarNo, you're right. You're right. You're right. You're actually, so yeah, so my fiancé, we're not married yet, but my fiancé is, maybe by the time this goes on we will, so my fiancé is from Bitmars. They're like the largest ASIC seller out of China. So they sell miners, she will be on the next episode. And you're right, because in China, there was like, let's say 70% of global mining, and all of a sudden they said, no, we don't like Bitcoin. We don't like mining. We don't like spending energy.

49:45But they've been doing this for many years. They were threatening to ban mining. Yes, but that was the hardcore one, really. That was like the, no fucking around, tomorrow you're all gone. And like, really, they switched it off. And by the way, now it's happening again. So you will talk to someone about it, but at least 15% of global hash was still in China now, because the Chinese, they really, they're in a way, they're thinking, worst case, they're going to ban it and fine me, but I will not lose the machine.

50:12When you send it to Russia, like there's a big risk of like, you will like lose even the initial investment, like the machines are gone. So like, the Chinese still accept the risk of, okay, I'll bribe somebody local, I'll have to stop tomorrow, but I'll have the initial investment, then I can relocate it. So it's still got like 15%. And that is getting banned now. Anyway, back to the point. So they banned mining. And I think it is very important, very important for the evolution of Bitcoin, because all the Chinese companies all of a sudden had to talk to the Western, like miners and Bitcoiners.

50:45And I think before, really, like, you saw zero, like the resellers, manufacturers attending Bitcoin conferences, Bitcoin mining conferences, it was a completely isolated world, really. And now they were just forced, they're like, okay, the business is completely moving elsewhere. So I met my fiance on the Bitcoin mining conference in Dubai. And yes, you're right, before the ban, the companies didn't have this much effort of like going and like making the relationships abroad. So I really, I think it's very important milestone. And so like, I'm thankful to Chinese communists, actually, who would ever, who would ever think I would be thankful to a communist man. Thank you, President Xi Jinping.

51:56Vlad CosteaYou don't remember it because you're not working here. But Braiins and Slush Pool is maybe the most political of mining pools. And let me explain to you why. In 2015, Gavin Andresen publishes the Bitcoin XT proposal for increasing the block size of Bitcoin. Slush Pool was the first pool to support it. The consequence of that is that you guys got DDoSed. I don't know about that. Yeah, you should ask the people who have been around here for longer. Well, Alena Vranova was at the time like the person in charge, who put up like a press release, and they were not happy that this is happening and whatever.

52:36It was part of the block size wars. The proposal was what? To increase the block size. OK. BIP 101. OK, OK, OK, OK. And Slush Pool was the first mining pool to signal support for it. Fast forward. When was this? 2021. So that's six years later. Slush Pool was also the first mining pool to signal support for Taproot. I'm not sure what it was for SegWit. I'm not sure if you were the first guys, but the first block that was mined with the message that showed support for Taproot was also Braiins.

53:09Yes. So in a lot of ways, you guys are very forward thinking and you're looking at whatever is popular for improving Bitcoin. And you're also fearless in this regard. Maybe the Chinese miners, they're waiting to see who else is supporting. They're not showing support directly.

53:24Kristian CsepcsarYes, they're not that deep. I mean, we're Bitcoiners first. So I think that that's in the DNA of the company. I think a lot of, I mean, I've seen like, for example, the Canaan founder, like they're Bitcoiners also, but there are a lot of the Chinese companies where it's, and I don't mean it bad, like, but a lot of the leadership is like business first. It's like, they're not Bitcoiners by default. And there's nothing bad. I just say, here, it's a little bit different, because like, we're Bitcoiners first. And we just choose to work in Bitcoin because like, we know how to do good software and we really like it.

54:01So I think that that creates like, you're really like, you're part of the whole game. Like you care about it as an individual on individual level. And that boils down to us as a company. Yeah, we want to have a stand. So yeah, we're just now Lucas is like, really doing like very deep analysis of the BIP 110. Is it 110? So like, I mean, like, we're looking into a lot of things, because we're like, we want to we want to You want to put NFTs on the fork chain?

54:28So we're not putting anything anywhere. We don't like spam. You can put your memes in there. Yeah, no paper is for memes. But anyway, so but it's a very difficult and caveat discussion. So like, we're for free market and stuff. But yeah, we don't like that. Anyway, my point is, so we're we're doing a lot of us because like, we want to be educated like, and also, I think it's a little bit the role of the mining pool, because a lot of our clients are, they're business people, they're not technical developers.

54:59So they're like me, they're like, hey, I'm pumped for Bitcoin. But I'm not. So sort of like, Lucas in my team, he's like, he's the super nerd, like he's a coder. So he can go super deep on like the bib and what it means and from information. He

55:13Vlad Costeaalso has a Superman avatar on Twitter.

55:15Kristian CsepcsarOf course, no, his literal job role is Braiins Superman. That's his job title. I'm not kidding. So my point is, the same way Lukas actually helps me. So if you're the propaganda person that makes

55:27Vlad Costeayou like, what's her name? Lois Lane? Lois Lane. Why would I be Lois Lane to him? What?

55:36Kristian CsepcsarAnyway, anyway, we got too far. We got too far. So anyway, so he's helping me to understand what are the implications because I want to, I want to make educated decision also me as a Bitcoiner. And I think pool companies supplement that a lot for the miners, because most of them vast majority are business people. They're business people with opinion on Bitcoin. But they're, it's impossible to want from like, it is impossible for me to go super hardcore deep. I'm a marketing guy. Like, of course, I want to understand more, but I'm unable to like, read the code and to figure out all the implications of like some spam protection, etc.

56:15So I think that's also why we go deep into those discussion, because the our clients want it. And that's also part of who we are as a company. Because we go into the research, we suggest where we want to head, and you stick around or don't if you vote with your hash rate, if you don't like what we do. But that's the point. Like, we're always the good guys in Bitcoin mining. Like, we have a good reputation, where we show, I think, like, we always choose the good of Bitcoin, because we are here for a long term, like Bitcoin has to succeed. So long story short, yeah, we're political. And Lucas

56:50Vlad Costeasaid that he likes BIP 300, which is controversial in some circles, but you guys are just thinking long, long term and you want to see what's good for the

57:02Kristian Csepcsarnetwork. Yes. And also part of it is like, you always have to have discussions, right? Like, he's studying now the super deeply the BIP 110. And he's like, you know what, I'll, I'll maybe create like a podcast series where I interview both sides, and then digest it. And it's like, you really need like, you have to learn about those things that you have to not be afraid to share your opinions. Because like, that's how you search truth. It sounds very cliche. But like, the truth is always found in the discussion.

57:32And like, that's what I've, by the way, talking about BIP 110. I still call it 444. Yeah. And from my perspective is really, I just wait, is it the error code and not patiently found? No, that's a different one. No, that's

57:48Vlad Costea404. Yeah. No, 444 was the initial number for BIP 110.

57:53Kristian CsepcsarWhy did you change it? Politics. Why is it politics? I want to understand Chinese, they're very finicky about the numbers. They would call it 888 for sure, because it's like,

58:03Vlad Costeait's the same proposal, they changed the number, because maybe 444 doesn't sound as nice as 110. Yeah,

58:12Kristian Csepcsarwhatever. Anyway, to close it down. So yeah, so I don't want to talk more about that BIP. But for me, it's like, what I see online is like, it's not a discussion where I think you would be convincing anybody. It's like, it's sort of like a fight now. So I think like that, that's what that's what we don't like. We're like, we want to have educated discussions and searching the truth and then helping our miners to say, this is what we think is the best for the future of Bitcoin. That's how we're deciding if you don't like it to move your hash rate. Like in the end of the day, it's simple as that.

58:48Vlad CosteaYeah. Where's most of your hash rate based? Because a lot of people have this misconception, they believe that — sorry — mining pools are also the ones that own the ASICs. And this might be because of the largest one, which is Foundry, which sort of is this publicly traded company, which hosts all of the devices that mine with them. But it's not like this. Bitmain has Antpool and they do a lot of solo mining also. Marathon also — they have their own operation, their own pool. But yeah, but they're gonna be out of the game soon a bit too?

59:24Kristian CsepcsarI hope not. They might be our client. I cannot confirm nor deny. Yeah, so we — our clients have the machines and we virtually put them together and we mine as one. That was our, by the way, original slogan of the pool: mine as one. Because it's simple: you have some hash, I have some hash, we'll combine it. So we increase our chances of finding blocks and then we split the rewards. If you're giving ten terahash, nine terahash, I give one terahash — you keep 90%, I keep 10%. This very simple concept. We just combine it. So we're having servers all around the world to be close location-wise to where they are mining.

1:00:34So by the way, you can see also where most of the hash rate is by looking at where people have endpoints, but currently we unified it under one, doesn't matter. But some pools give you, okay, we have a server in Latin America that tells you they're gonna have some hash rate. But anyway, long story short, don't quote me on it, 80% is gonna be North America. Historically, we had very difficulties penetrating Russian and Chinese market. Chinese market is very specific. You have to be Chinese with Chinese entities, really. It's just getting a domain and a server place in China, insane.

1:00:45Insane. And then, very different politics. It's virtually impossible. And they are really fighting against mining. And Russia is very specific also. In Russia, 9 out of 10 clients, they want a secret deal. Anyway, like, hey, I'll get you the mining guy. Usually it's people with money and then people running the farms. So we speak to the people running the farms and they're like, okay, I understand your firmware earns you more Bitcoin. And it's more efficient. Give me a secret deal, like a fee that will go into my pocket and I'll install it.

1:01:22And we just cannot do it. That was our experience. I'm not saying all the firmwares have to do it in Russia. That was our experience. Maybe I overestimated 9 out of 10. But in vast majority of cases we had to do it like this. And we cannot let it happen because, come on, we work with publicly traded companies. And our reputation is the only thing that keeps us on the game long term. So we've never done it. So Russia and China, we were never able to penetrate.

1:01:47And there is no mining in Europe, almost. So it's North America, vast majority of it. Some little South America, but that one is complicated. Some is starting the MENA, Middle East and North Africa. Like Oman, Ethiopia. But again, those regions like Ethiopia has very Paraguay vibes. They entice you with cheap rates. And then the infrastructure is really bad. Ethiopia, number one. You have unscheduled downtime in city center during the day, two times, three times for 20 minutes. And that impacts your profitability a lot. So you can have a very cheap price.

1:02:25But when you have unscheduled 20% downtime, it's really bad on your bottom line. And also, same as Ethiopia, Paraguay. They entice you build the megawatts there, you build the farms, and then they tax you. Classic government move. So it's happening in Ethiopia now. Paraguay, yeah, it also happens. Yeah, it's North America mostly. We're always the North American brand. And that's why we're expanding very heavily there. We're launching our mining site in Houston, where we will show that you can mine more Bitcoin using Braiins. So we have six megawatts running our stack, and we'll just publicly show you.

1:03:01One thing is to say you mine more Bitcoin, and now we'll show it on six megawatts. We're expanding the team very rapidly in the U.S. So still, one third of the global hash rate will always be Texas. It's like the beating heart of Bitcoin mining. And politically also, I would say. Because the hash rate is most protected there. Like, they're the come and get it, you know? All the Texas guys. Yeah.

1:03:30Vlad CosteaSo what is the pitch for solo miners or people mining at home to join Braiins? In my short mining career, I've only mined with Braiins and with Luxor in a time when there was no KYC requirement. Oh, I see.

1:03:45Kristian CsepcsarNo, no, no. No, I think. Wait, no. KYC? We don't have KYC. We don't have KYC anywhere. Luxor does nowadays. Really? Isn't it NiceHash? Aren't you? I know NiceHash 100% has KYC. I've never used NiceHash because I don't have a gaming PC.

1:04:05Vlad CosteaA fancy video card.

1:04:08Kristian CsepcsarI'm a console gamer. I know that NiceHash introduced KYC so you have to register, I don't know, and send like a passport photo, etc. We don't have it so hash power, Braiins Pool, Braiins Solo. You need email address. And yes, for hash power you need Telegram because we needed to implement somehow two factor for like making orders and stuff. And it was just easier to vibe code it using Telegram for the public beta. So yes, you have to use Telegram. We'll add something later. But no, we're setting it up in a way that we really don't like KYC.

1:04:43It's nothing illegal. That's a good pitch. You can mine with Braiins without KYC. So it is in our DNA. We don't want... You just increase... We have a lot of hack attacks. We still do custody. Not custody, but some miners still keep the funds with us before they send it out. So we have plenty of attacks that we deal with on a daily basis of people trying to crack old accounts and stuff like that. So we don't want to be increasing any risk by saying hey... And we have names and addresses of the OG Bitcoin guys that were mining tens of thousands of Bitcoin in 2011.

1:05:22That would be crazy. Really, you would just increase the risk. So no, I don't want that. So no, no KYC. No, really. Also, no emails from 2011. No, we have emails. No, emails we do. You have to have email, but you can create a personal email. Email and wallet address you need, for most. Yeah. You need to pay out address where we send you coins. You can, by the way, send it to Lightning also. We support Lightning payouts now. We're growing like crazy. Because a lot of the solo miners, like the tiny miners with Bitaxes and stuff, they mine...

1:06:00So they can use Braiins Solo where you're mining for the whole block. Or you can use Braiins Pool for stable payouts. You're not mining a lot, but it's freshly mined coins and people just like stacking and then having like a beer budget. And so we have like thousands, I think it's like low digits of thousands of users with like 1, 2, 3, 5 terahashes of Bitaxes. And they send it via Lightning payouts. So Lightning payouts have way better OPSEC. You would know more how that works.

1:06:33But yeah, so that's why a lot of the tiny miners choose us, because we have the Lightning payouts. I think we're the first one with Lightning payouts. I think that was two years ago.

1:06:44Vlad CosteaWhen we were walking on the hallway and you were showing me around, there was this Antminer S19 XP. K Pro. S19K Pro. Okay. That you guys are using for testing. And you told me that the original firmware, once it hits the peak and it becomes very hot, it shuts down. And you created a much better firmware for it, which basically allows it, once it reaches that melting point or whatever, it winds down the hash power so that it cools off and then it goes up once again.

1:07:17And it follows this cycle to prevent destruction of the machine, but also prevent shutting down. Exactly. And this is a good story for what you guys are building here, because it's not just the mining pool. You're also working on firmware for machines, which are already out there on the market.

1:07:33Kristian CsepcsarYes. Management software also integrating with energy markets, Braiins Manager. So we started as a pool, but then we naturally thought, okay, what's next? We really like mining. That's what we know. We know the clients, we know the market, we know software, we know software and we know Bitcoin mining. So we naturally wanted to put more. So we started with firmware in 2018. Now we're running over two gigawatts of miners worldwide. And it's very simple. Bitmain has a dominant, Bitmain is the manufacturer making most of the machines.

1:08:03They have anywhere from 70 to 80% of the market. And when they have this dominant position that was never challenged ever since 2013, it doesn't matter. Maybe it would run down to 60 and now it's 80, but it's like above 50 since 2013. Their attitude is not the best. So you would think, okay, dynamically changing the power targets so that it adjusts to the temperature on the chips, it's a no brainer. Like your reaction was, this sounds like something that it should have, like it's the first feature that you code when you create firmware, and they still don't have it.

1:08:40So you set dangerous temperatures so that the machine doesn't burn. When it's getting close to it, stock will turn off. Or now I think on the super new generation, they do hardcore downclock, which when you model your profitability, you have number one is your energy price, and number two is uptime. When you don't have uptime, it severely impacts your bottom line in profitability. So we thought, it's very simple. When you're reaching the hot temperatures, we're just scaled down. The power consumption will just drop by, let's say, the machine has 3,000 watts, and it will start dropping by 100 watts until the temperature stabilizes.

1:09:25And then yeah, you're mining a little bit less, but you're still keeping vast majority of the hash rate and your uptime. And then when the temperature, for example, it cools down during the night or whatever the problem was, maybe you fix the exhaust or the intake airflow in your container, then it will scale it back up. It's genius. But exactly, your reaction was like, wait, you're telling me about this feature because we're just making a video about it. And you're like, this feature sounds like a no brainer. It's like every mining firmware would have it. No, you would think so. It

1:09:56Vlad Costeaseems like something you would have from the factory.

1:09:58Kristian CsepcsarYes, yes, I agree. But at the same time, they're chip makers. They're not very good at hardware. Yes, yes. On the chip, it's very difficult to compete with Bitmain. They're doing it for a long time in very big batches, and that's very Bitmain move. Whenever competitors come even close, they completely destroy and slash prices, and they release the new generation, which is really, really good. Like really on the chip level, they're very fast to innovate. And then they release the new generation, cut the prices, let the competitors suffer, and then they increase the prices and make money again.

1:10:33It's very difficult to challenge the position of Bitmain. And that's the thing. They know you'll buy from them anyway. Like Summer, so they became Bitmain hash rate ambassador. You'll talk to her about it. It's very exclusive. Only a few companies on the planet have it. You have to pay $40 million to Bitmain. And I'm saying this, yeah, and Bitmain announced it like, hey, we're announcing Summer and Bitmars becoming our hash rate ambassador. And immediately under that tweet, there are two tweets from VoskCoin and Red Panda Mining, the biggest mining YouTubers.

1:11:10And they were hating about how their machine broke down, how they send it back, and how they declined to repair. And if you think about it, there are only like four mining YouTubers on the planet. Just that. And even if they wouldn't be right about the repair, you would just send one machine for free to them to make the total four mining YouTubers on the planet happy. And they're so unhappy with Bitmain that they're crying and they're not even replying to their tweets there. And VoskCoin has like 600,000 subscribers on YouTube.

1:11:46It's like he deserves one machine worth $2,000, right? But that really shows Bitmain, they're like really there. And I heard it from sources. And they're like, KOLs and YouTubers should pay us for the collaboration with Bitmain. Like that's really the demeanor of Bitmain. It's crazy. They know they're number one. And they know even if they suck and they will produce shit, you'll still come back to them to buy. So I wish somebody can challenge it, but it's very difficult, really.

1:12:15Vlad CosteaI do remember a few times, like we heard about Nvidia or Samsung getting into manufacturing ASIC miners for Bitcoin. Intel. Yeah, that was also... But I do remember something about Samsung.

1:12:30Kristian CsepcsarYeah, no, Samsung, yes, because so Samsung invest. So for example, Samsung was invested through Auradine. Auradine was American-based, both ASIC chip and full miner manufacturer. They created like three years ago. And Samsung was through their VC companies, he was invested in Auradine and they were making Samsung. So through those, yeah. But anyway, and still you see Intel tried to do chips. Block is trying to do full mining. Samsung was invested through Auradine. Auradine just announced that they are pivoting completely to AI last week. So in Bitcoin mining, the mining is so difficult and like so much headache, that now nobody wants to be the first testing mouse.

1:13:20Like your last problem on the planet is, okay, I'm going to be testing this company. And if it sucks, I'm going to tell everybody else not to buy it. You don't want to be the first guy in line. And that creates the chicken-and-egg problem. And also, if you don't have enough miners and customers, you don't create the infrastructure for the support and the hardware repairs, etc. So that creates the chicken-and-egg problem, which I don't see an easy solution to. I think if we want to have a little bit better hardware market, we need chip provider, like a chip seller.

1:13:53Like chip is the most difficult part to manufacture and to make. And if we have like a chip alliance or you know, if Block would be like, hey, we're going to be starting making chips and anybody can buy. And then making the nice system on top of the chip is the easier part. Like you can create heaters, you can create electrical boilers or hash rate boilers, a lot of use cases, but we need, I think, supplier of the chip and Chinese will never be that. Chinese, all of them, I spoke to WhatsMiner, Bitmain is the same, Canaan is the same.

1:14:24They want to be the apple because they know the highest margin is on selling the whole machine and then selling a crap machine which breaks and they sell the new one.

1:14:37Vlad CosteaThat's unfortunate. I know that Jihan Wu, who was the CEO of Bitmain, is running a company that's called BitDeer nowadays. And he's having a hard time competing with his old company. Like maybe that he was thinking that it was because of him that the company was successful and he can replicate that. That's really not the case.

1:14:57Kristian CsepcsarIt is complicated. So yeah, there were two founders of Bitmain and they split up, I don't know, four years ago, something like that. They had a fight. I would be very curious to know more. But anyway, they split up and the guy Jihan created BitDeer. And BitDeer, just for your information, is very interesting. So they do giant self-mining. Like they're one of the biggest miners out there. And they thought, hey, if I'm miner, I don't want to be buying from Bitmain. So they started creating machines for them, their own.

1:15:23And also now, just last year, they started selling to public, but very limited quantity. They canceled some orders, they were late, blah, blah, blah. But they're starting, which is a good sign. Because if anybody can compete with Bitmain, it might be Bitmain itself. But as you say, they're having hard times. But it's also interesting, just for context, they're publicly traded in the US, BitDeer, and they're heavily invested by Tether. So you can see, so yeah, they're not groundbreaking yet. But I think it would be a very interesting contender for the number one Bitmain position.

1:15:59And long term. And it would be very, very, I think, and I think there is the rivalry, which can motivate it a little bit more. And I think it would be very like the irony of life of competitor to Bitmain and challenger would be Bitmain itself. So anyway, fingers crossed for BitDeer. But yeah, they're late, they're canceling orders, blah, blah, blah. But I think they are really the number one possibility for at least decreased dominance of Bitmain. It's not going to be blocked, sorry. I'm very big fan. People think I'm just hating.

1:16:33Vlad CosteaIs that Jack Dorsey's campaign?

1:16:34Kristian CsepcsarYeah. I would, if I have to bet, I would even bet that they might not release. And if they release this year, they will just like send a batch test of 5000 units to Core Scientific. And again, I'm saying it as a fan, I'm number one fan, but hardware is hard. Bitcoin mining hardware is even harder. It's true. It's a very difficult place to — hey, we tried ourselves, so I'm speaking from my own experience. I know that

1:17:00Vlad CosteaJack Dorsey. So just for the record, Jack, if you're listening to this, I still want to get you on my podcast. I'm not going to roast you too hard. But your investments suck. Like everywhere that you put your money, the outcome was underwhelming. No comments because he was mining- LDK Lightning Network clients written from scratch by Matt Corallo and Rust. Sorry, say again? So he supported Matt Corallo to do a complete rewrite of the Lightning client. Most, like 80% of the Lightning users are on LND.

1:17:32And I guess like 5-10% are on Eclair, which is the one that Phoenix is using. And there's also c-lightning, which got branded as Core Lightning nowadays by Blockstream. And in this picture, Jack Dorsey decided that he should create a new Lightning client, which is supposedly better because it's written in Rust by Matt Corallo. So he paid this team to write this new Lightning client. You don't even know about it. That's how bad it is. I mean,

1:18:02Kristian CsepcsarI'm not saying it's bad. I'm just saying it failed. And we're big Rust fans, by the way. Like we're giant Rust fans. We're coding everything in Rust at Braiins.

1:18:09Vlad CosteaIt failed in its purpose to get that market share. And also he invested in that hardware wallet, which is the BitKey. It's like a rock that you're holding. And you press one button to sign the transaction, uses a multisig, but has no screen. You have to trust what's on your phone screens. That was actually the reason why the first Ledger hardware wallet failed, because it had no screen. And then BitBox, their first device also did not have a screen. And what happened to both products, they released a version, the Nano S, which S stands for screen, and the BitBox 02, which came with a screen. So short history of hardware wallets too.

1:18:53Kristian CsepcsarAnd then in that market, and with so much market data, how can then you decide to create a

1:18:58Vlad Costeahardware wallet? Yeah, so many years later, you just come out, you come with this disrupt Silicon Valley mentality. And you're like, why do we need a screen? Like it costs us like $10 extra to add this. Let's ditch it so we can sell it for more money. Anyway, that design. And by the way, I

1:19:12Kristian Csepcsarremember that you provided some feedback on Twitter that were not really nice to you, right?

1:19:17Vlad CosteaNo? I did post an article about why it sucks. And I explained, I think they ignored it. So

1:19:26Kristian CsepcsarI wrote like, what I don't like about the Proto Miner. And that was very bizarre to me, because I think two employees, I don't remember exactly, but like, very high level, very high position. One was, I think, in charge of the BD for the mining, and the other one was product designer or something like, and they engaged with me. I was like, either don't engage or engage like in a very nice PR way, right? Thank you for feedback. Because a lot of my feedback was maybe like, you can better describe it on the website.

1:19:57Because I was like, hey, I don't know that the fans are more powerful. So my criticism was, why is it just on the one side, I would want redundancy. And so I was like, maybe just rewrite it on the website, right? So you can still work with the feedback, say, Hey, thank you very much, we fix this, then you're here. No, no, they decided to go into my comments, and actually start making fun. Firmware competitor, disgruntled, like makes fun of and they like started making fun of me, how I feel that it's threatening our firmware business.

1:20:26So like, I'm the guy that like cries about them. I was like, why you on a publicly traded company, like, and proceed as those good guys, like, why would you even go and like, try to like make fun like, just don't react at all is way better than this. So like, my experience really, really, really bad. But anyway, it

1:20:43Vlad Costeahappens. This is like the default reaction people. Usually, when they see something they don't like, they attack the person. Not the concept. Yeah, I think you still have some water here.

1:20:54Kristian CsepcsarYeah, because like, I agree that some of it I didn't know. But it was like, the point was just fix it on your website. Like literally, like, if the because I'm very typical minor, I would say, like, I'm the, I'm not too technical. I will look at it from the business perspective. I think I'm a very good. I think no, it's just that sounds like that will not work, man. But I think I will just stop it. Just use this. Put it and put it next to fine.

1:21:26Vlad CosteaDon't forget to register to the newsletter. braiins

1:21:28Kristian Csepcsar.com/newsletter, you're winning 21 bucks for Braiins Hashpower of my book and Braiins Dock. Anyway, back to that point. And I forgot what was the point. Anyway, people responding

1:21:40Vlad Costeato feedback, not so greatly. Yeah, yeah. It happens to me with the Coldcard, because they were advertising their latest product as open source. But the firmware was using a license that was preventing other people from selling a product using that firmware, which is not open source. It's something else, because open source means that you can modify, you can do whatever you want. Exactly. Do whatever, even sell it. And I told him, you know, your license on the page of the license. It says that it's not open source, it's source available, which means that you can see a source.

1:22:14Yes, yes, you can see it, but you cannot use it how you want. It's public. And not only that, they blocked me, but they pointed out that in the past, that my podcast was sponsored by Trezor. And they're like, oh, of course, it comes from a Trezor shill. Yeah, they don't understand anything, because they support shitcoins and whatever. And I'm like, that's besides the point, man. It doesn't matter where the criticism comes from. It's all about the idea. Just

1:22:38Kristian Csepcsartalk about the idea. But when the idea is uncomfortable, it's easier for them to just attack the person. That's what I wanted to say. I think I'm very representative of what the Bitcoin mining community is, because most of them are more business oriented than technical. And I was like, I really went in super detail of their website. It was flashy. It was like Apple would make a product. But you don't really, not saying this is way more powerful than and that's why you need less. This is the first thing you should explain to the miner.

1:23:11You should be excited. And it wasn't there. So I sort of gave them a good review of what they promote, because I'm the typical miner. I'm not technical. Don't show me the flashy screens. Give me shipping days when it's going to be more powerful. Fine. You need less of them. I don't want to be just hating on them. And again, I'm a fan. And I think disrupting and really, everybody talks about the centralization in mining. Yeah, exactly. And I think there are places that people don't even look.

1:23:44I think hardware is one, but we have more discussion now with Bitaxes. So I think that is very important. We found in Bitmain having 80% of the market with history of not really nice things, not enabling ASICBoost, which we've proven is possible. And they said no, physically, like hardware wise, S9 cannot run the overt. One of those ASICBoosts, we found out it's true. And it enabled overnight, we published the proof, and they enabled overnight 13% energy saving, 13%. And that is the theory.

1:24:19Maybe they were offering it to their friends, supporting Bitcoin Cash in China, blah, blah, blah. Anyway, so we know they own 80% of the market, and they had backdoors and things like this, right? So it's not nice. But okay, let's say it's a little bit improving, like, Block wants to come out with Proto Miner, we have Bitaxe movement, which like tries to educate, I think education is a big part of educating. But let's talk about software. On the software side, you have firmware, not open source firmware sucks.

1:24:51Like, just let's theorize. Let's talk about like crazy conspiracy theories, right? Imagine you're Bitmain, and you're running 80% of the global hardware market, and you're also running a pool, you could very easily suffer FPPS pools running a competing pool. And by whenever new block is found, for example, in Braiins Pool, you would throw that in the garbage, and you will never be able to see that that machine actually found a block. And this way, and I'm just it's hypothetical completely. I'm not blaming anybody. I'm not saying it's true.

1:25:26But you could very easily be doing that. In this way, you suffer all the FPPS pools, and then you offer them a service of being a proxy pool. I'm not saying this happened. But I'm saying firmware is the absolute key part of like, how you mine and then this should be in some capacity open source. Like the I cannot imagine it not being it's really a big problem. And then talk about management software. And you asked, there's a management software Foreman, and they have like 80% of the market 90% of the market, like that.

1:25:58They're like, absolute dominant player, they started early, and everybody's using them. That part is sitting between your firmware and pool, and knows everything about your farm. And again, and again, they're great guys. And I know them personally, I love the team. But I'm just saying that security, like it manages your whole farm knows where you mining can handle again, throwing away the golden nonces. It knows exactly how much money you're making with what energy programs. That's a I'm saying this is very critical part of the mining stack.

1:26:31And we have one monopoly in the US owning the market. And the and I'm not saying there are bad actors or anything. I'm just saying more competition is always good. And we're not even having those discussions that Braiins — that the management software could be an issue. I never I didn't hear it once. Have you ever heard anything about managers? Never. And it's like one one one player dominating the whole part. So I'm saying the centralization. It's a thing like Bitcoin mining works, the incentives are aligned correctly.

1:27:04But there are many places where we can do better. And we should. But it's not as simple as mining pools suck. I think it's the first of all, the concept of mining pools was debated always the most. Until 2018, we didn't have custom firmware, like at all the market for custom firmware. It took us years and years to educate miners about the existence of market custom firmwares. And then the wider wider Bitcoin community doesn't even know about it. So I think mining pools is just the play thing that everybody understands.

1:27:35It's been discussed for ages. And then also you have a new player ocean that comes in. And it's sort of the only play that they can play all pools bad. We the solution we got. So like continues something. Yeah, sure. Things should improve. And mining pools also. I think we're working on something also on our end. But there are many other places which suck in Bitcoin mining. Nobody talks about that. That's what I really don't like. Like, you know, only. And I think it's really out of the nature.

1:28:05Everybody understands pools. Everybody was talking about the pools. We have very loud new players entering the pool space, which like want to sort of set up their new position of I'm the cool guy, the good guy, everybody's bad. Like it helps you with the marketing position. But I think like we should be like really not having one single discussion about management software, absolute critical layer in the stack sitting in between knowing everything about you, your pool knows so much less than your management software. Like if I like, from the perspective, not mining security, but like, KYC and like, government agency not to know more about the structure of the mining industry, for example, you go to one single company, and you know, 95% of the market is like that.

1:28:53And again, I know the team, I love the team. I love to party with Dan, the Foreman. He's a great guy. Dan, he's the founder of Foreman. So I know the team, they're great guys. I don't have any conspiracy theories about them. But if I'm like a bad, bad actor agency, they don't have to even know that they are part of, I don't know, they are all infiltrate. My point is, if you have one player that dominant with so little competition, it's bad. And we're not having those discussions at all.

1:29:23So it's like, yeah, all the time crying about pools and that you can switch your pool in a minute. Like, but for example, management software is very sticky software. Because really, changing pool is a matter of two minutes, you can batch, reconfigure, fleet your mining completely somewhere else, really. Management software, it's so baked into your reporting into your, what do your finance department is getting, you have all the mining ops, you teach them with the management, like you're not changing management software, it will take, like on a big farm, just reconfiguring, plugging into your accounting software, making all the reports that you have to do for your management, training the people, creating the sitemap so it has which container is physically located where, where's the machine, creating that it's months.

1:30:15So literally, even if people would be like, okay, this management software is bad, something bad happened, I don't know, CIA leaked documents that they're part of it, whatever would happen, it would take you at minimum weeks to switch. Like, it's a problem. And with mining pool, really, yeah, you would maybe have to wake up and switch, but it's still a matter of two minutes. So that's my, sorry about the rant, but that's my general rant on mining centralization. There are a lot of places that needs to be better. And we're not even talking about them. That's what really like grinds my gears.

1:30:51Vlad CosteaYeah, I hear this from pool stories also, like, people are concerned with hash rate being centralized in one pool, but it's very easy to switch. And miners, like a lot of them are just into finding cheap electricity, plugging the machine to the wall and just letting it run. They're not even aware how powerful they can be in terms of Bitcoin governance, like 51% of hash rate can activate soft forks. And there's nothing that the nodes can do about it. Like people think, oh, I'm running my own node and I can check the rules and make sure that no new rules get activated.

1:31:25That's bullshit. 51% of hash rate can activate a soft fork. That's how Bitcoin always works. And if you want to be sovereign, you should mine too. Like, that's, that's what a first class Bitcoin citizen means that you're also mining. When Satoshi was discussing nodes in the white paper, he was meaning mining nodes, because he was thinking that everyone running the software is also a miner. But somewhere along the way, we separated mining from validating. And somehow people believed that validating your own transactions is enough. There are still people who run their node and never use it.

1:32:01And that's also the same kind of stupid as miners hashing, having a lot of hash power and not knowing what kind of power they actually have over the network. But I guess there is also a lot of cowardice in this regard, especially from the Chinese miners, maybe, because they don't want to do anything. They just want to make money. I guess the American miners are the same. They just want to make money from...

1:32:24Kristian CsepcsarThat's the thing is really difficult business. Like, really, like, just now we're talking about all time low hash price. So I think really, it comes down to, yeah, many of them don't care. So it's about making money. There are a lot of miners. And that's the beauty of it, right? That's why hash rate is so apolitical, because they're in it for the making money. They're like securing Bitcoin, and it's like separate. So I like it. But then there are a lot of Bitcoin miners who are like, Bitcoin miners, and they care.

1:32:51But they're like, every day, you have so many problems keeping uptime. Like really, finding the cheapest energy and keeping uptime. It's like keeping your best system uptime. It's like an art. It's like every day struggle. So it's like, you have so much trouble. The last thing you want to do is like testing new machines from weird new hardware manufacturer, or going on Twitter arguing about some proposals from opinionated people. So my point is, really, mining is brutal. Mining is really brutal. And I think many of miners don't care.

1:33:24They're in it for the money. They immediately sell to fiat. They don't even care. But a lot of the others do care. But they have so much on their plate. Arguing about the governance and future of Bitcoin is a little bit too much. And really, I think those in a lot of the sense they outsource it to, hey, brains, you're smart guys, you're technical guys, you're here for a long term. You care about Bitcoin, I sort of outsource it to you. So and I think it's very valid. Like keeping uptime is your number one concern. And it's really difficult game.

1:33:58Vlad CosteaI want to ask you a hard question. Let's go. But yeah, let's go. Yeah. So Braiins, I'll be leaving soon. I have five minutes. Okay. Braiins is the first mining pool in the world. You guys have the first mover advantage. How come you're not number one in terms of hash rate? So

1:34:17Kristian CsepcsarBitcoin mining pools stopped being a core business, I would say around three, let's say three years ago. I think that was with the rise of Foundry most notably. So I would date it around that time. Sorry. I'll have to leave to another meeting soon. But anyway, I'll answer. So don't quote me but three, four years ago, there was a long time ago, when the Chinese entered the market, they introduced FPPS and then they started slashing prices. That really culminated around, do we do some hands on?

1:35:05No, just keep going. Okay. I want to announce the giveaway. Okay. So three, four years ago, don't quote me exactly when, that's where the Foundry was increasing a lot. And around that time, I think that was the ending of the, that's where most of the pools really realized, because we're slashing the prices of the fee so low. Pools are so the same, there's nothing you can really offer in the pool. So the only thing that we're competing was slashing the prices. And it got to a ridiculous point where like, you're not making any money, like razor thin margins.

1:35:43And pools started doing something called vertical or horizontal integration, meaning you have a pool of users that you have to upsell to something else. Horizontal integration would mean, so that's what Foundry did. So they're like, okay, I have a pool of users in the mining pool. And then I sell complementary services like hosting, sourcing, insurance on the hardware, things like that. And then there's vertical integration. And that's where Braiins went. And it's okay, you have the mining pool software, but then we'll sell you also the firmware software running your machine and management software running your farm.

1:36:20And you make the money there. So that started super heavily, let's say three, four years ago, and it was just out of the nature. We're competing, competing on the fees, because there's nothing else much that you can bring in the pools. So you just keep slashing the prices. And then Foundry entered and they were so well financed. They had such a good US-based team. The hashes started moving from China to US. And they used all these things aligned. And they basically said, okay, we're going to slash it completely and make money on the side.

1:36:54So they were like almost zero or like 0.1, 0.2. Like you cannot compete with it like crazy. And that was like the end of pools being as a core business. So around that time, so back to us, we realized you can have a very large hash rate network share, but be making no money Foundry. Or you can have a good, like a cater to like a smaller group and give them other like things like firmware management and be really good at that. And that's what we chose.

1:37:31So we chose, hey, we want to cater to like the mid-sized guys that are very politically aligned with Bitcoin. It's a very different game. Foundry did. We want the biggest, biggest like biggest Riots and Marathons and publicly traded companies that like we just get few miners. We give them 0.1, 0.2 fee. And we're the big number one. And then we sell other stuff around it and make money. And we said, no, we don't need to do that. So you actually think, okay, we're not in the top one, but we're like, we keep healthy margin.

1:38:02We keep growing, keep bringing new products. Whereas Foundry all of a sudden, and I'm not sure if it's public or not, if it's not public, then I have it from secret sources. They are increasing the pool fees drastically now over the past year because they found out like they're really struggling to keep it up. So we chose the better way. We want to keep number of clients that we're happy with, that we can serve, bring some value. It has to make sense. Look, like we're a company of 120 people.

1:38:32Like we have a lot of smart people burning a lot of smart things. Like there's a significant cost to run this business. And we're a capitalist world. Like we have to have margin. Like I'm not a communist. So we chose that way. So we're not number one in the total hash rate managed, but we would much prefer to have sustainable company that we keep building and we keep building cool stuff. Because that ultimately, you sort of mentioned, yeah, the guys are in the game since forever, but they want to stay because they really like it.

1:39:04And really, I think that's DNA of Braiins. We could have sold long time ago, like we had several offers during the bull markets from publicly traded companies. We always decided not to because we actually like building. And I think really that stems from the founders and that's the culture of the company. We just like building shit. That's it. And yeah, Foundry go win more pool fees and bigger hash rate. But when is the last time Foundry did something cool? You will not remember because they do nothing.

1:39:34And that's my point, you know. So yeah. They mine blocks. Yeah. Yeah, they mine blocks, but then they don't make any money on it. And they are suffering the parent company, which is publicly traded. We want sustainable business building shit. That's Braiins. And I would close it that way. And that's a beautiful ending. Sign

1:39:51Vlad Costeaup to the newsletter, buy the Braiins t-shirts available on the Braiins store.

1:39:56Kristian CsepcsarUse the code B10 for 10% off or anything. No, don't use his. BTCTKVR. How much do you have? 5%. Damn it. I screwed up. We cut it. It's fine. I also cut the part about this. Also follow him on Twitter. Thank you very much. I just released a new video about our engineer actually build a new house and he heats it completely shower and floor heating with one hydro miner. So that video I released yesterday doing very well. So everybody loves the heat reuse use case because mining machines don't just create Bitcoin, it creates a lot of heat.

1:40:36So check it out. Check it out. Check it out. Follow me. Follow Vlad. Wish us luck tomorrow on the beers in Prague. It gets crazy sometimes. Thanks. Cake Wallet for the giveaway. Thank you. LayerTwo Labs.

1:40:47Vlad CosteaSideShift.ai. I'll check if you didn't rug pull me. I have to check. No, I didn't rug pull. You don't have one. The cash. Bitcoin.com News. Like I'll be swapping. Hashpower.braiins.com. Check it out. Thank you very much. Thank you. I'll see you in the next one where I will interview Summer. Ciao. I have to run. Ciao.

1:41:04Kristian CsepcsarThat was awesome.

1:41:06Vlad CosteaI know. Yes. That was very awesome. Let me hold this strike. No. Wait. Wait. I'm still going to need number. I'm just blowing. Like that? What do you need?

1:41:29Kristian CsepcsarWhat do I do? Nothing. Okay. Let's go. Am I thin and nice?

1:41:34Vlad CosteaYeah. You have to go to the gym for that. That was a nice friend though. Not podcast. That was a nice friend though. Not podcast. Anyway, so this you can keep. Also got fat because of my podcast. No, for summer, I don't believe it here. This I take away. Can we take 10 minutes until the next interview? No, we have an hour. Let's go grab lunch. I need to talk to Summer to make a list of topics. Let's go to lunch, and we'll do it over lunch.

1:42:01What is it? Okay. Let's go, let's go, let's go, because I have... And maybe some fresh syrup. Yeah. Thank you, I appreciate it. Was it good? Totally. Yeah, I think it was good. We can cut some small bed, but... Yes, the part...

1:42:01================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with speaker diarization (Guest A -> Kristian Csepcsar). Reconciled against YouTube auto-captions (bitcoin-forks-research S17E14 clean / .en.vtt), zcash-documentary S17E14.timed.txt, feed show-notes chapters, and the newsletter show-notes essay. Local Whisper re-transcribe (small.en, int8, short clips serially while live ASR held ~4 GB on S17E13 Charlie Spears) used for the ~00:51:29 silence after Xi Jinping, the ~00:59 Foundry/Antpool stretch where the raw had YouTube-outro bleed, and name checks (Vexl/Grafton, ChipChat, Braiins Dock, VoskCoin). Speaker turns repaired from context + chapters; mid-sentence splits fixed; continuation paragraphs inherit speaker. Names/jargon checked against title, feed, newsletter, prior finals, and web: Kristian Csepcsar (not Czepczar), Braiins / Slush Pool / Bitcoin.cz, Braiins Dock / Braiins Forge / Braiins OS / Braiins Hashpower / Braiins Solo / Braiins Pool, ChipChat / Ultimate Bitcoin Mining Guide, Guy Swan, Summer Meng / Bitmars, Firefish, Lukas (Braiins Superman), Grafton / Vexl, Cake Wallet, Zcash, SideShift.ai, LayerTwo Labs / BIP 300 / drivechains, Bitcoin.com News, Canaan, Bitmain / Antpool, Auradine, WhatsMiner, Butterfly Labs, Foundry, Marathon / Riot, CK Pool, Parasite Pool, NiceHash, Luxor, Ocean, Foreman (Dan), BitDeer / Jihan Wu, Block / Jack Dorsey / Proto Miner, Bitaxe / BMM101, ASICBoost, FPPS, hashprice, Alena Vranova, Jan Capek, Marek / Slush, Zooko / Tahoe-LAFS, Laszlo Hanyecz, Paralelni Polis, Gavin Andresen / Bitcoin XT / BIP 101, Taproot, BIP 110 / BIP 444, Pudding Pop's pool. Light clean verbatim. Intro music omitted. Remaining doubtful words marked ....

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00