S17 E20: Talking Privacy with Amir Taaki, Harry Halpin & Christopher Cialone
Search this conversation
0:45Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is season 17, episode 20. We are live with Amir Taaki, CEO or whatever lead developer of DarkFi, who's holding a knife right now, showing off the skills that he learned during his military service. We also have Harry Halpin, CEO of Nym and one of the biggest privacy advocates in academia. And Christopher Cialone or Cialoni, I'm not sure how you pronounce your last name. And he is one of the biggest advocates for justice and freedom for the Samourai Wallet developers as well as Roman Storm, lead developer of Tornado Cash. And this episode is sponsored by Cake Wallet and you guys will receive some free Zcash if you install Cake Wallet. SideShift.ai, Braiins Hashpower, Orange Rock, which is a new sponsor and it's a trading platform, which you can try, and LayerTwo Labs. It's really good to have you all. Harry, you're the first one to leave, I guess, so you get to talk first.
1:48Harry HalpinYeah, so I think it might be, this was a bit unexpected. I'm really glad to be here. One of the, I think, most important things that happened over the last few days is the mask has come off the kind of US military-industrial complex, in particular, Alex Karp, the philosopher, CEO of Palantir, he wrote a book, or ghostwrote, perhaps, he's a co-author, a book called The Technological Republic that came out early last year. And in it, he basically argues for a combination of state and corporate power.
2:30And particularly, he also calls for development and acceleration of automated AI weapons and surveillance globally over the entire population, kind of in the name of national security. And it's very clear. You know, there he views, kind of, I mean, a lot of it is, I think, edgy in his mind at least, where he believes, you know, okay, you know, American culture is somehow self-evidently the best, we must defend Western values against everyone else who are regressive. And I do think, I don't completely disagree with everything he says.
3:13I do think there are differences between cultures and, you know, certain kind of liberal political correctness has gone too far, but his clear warmongering desire to create a giant surveillance state and increase automated killing for total US technological dominance is, I think, very, very dangerous.
3:35It's particularly dangerous because Palantir is building not just US surveillance mechanisms, it has contracts with many countries including the British healthcare system and also some European countries to build out their surveillance military capabilities and, you know, essentially creating his own kind of privatized NSA with even less accountability than the NSA or I guess Gestapo or Cheka had. And it's also very clear from reading his essay that he really does look down upon his enemies as a subhuman. And this, I think, the combination of, particularly, look at the total failure of the United States so far in the Iran war, this total delusional belief that we can simply automate death via drones, via essentially targeting civilians via mass surveillance systems. And this is all a great thing to do in the name of Western values. I mean this being said by a seemingly self-hating homosexual who clearly also hates women.
4:51I don't know, to me it's all just, it sounds like garbage and it sounds like a very dangerous and authoritarian view of the future. And we as programmers, I've noticed, I mean, not so much in Europe, I've definitely noticed on the West Coast, a lot of... I don't know how you say it. You can see it in everything from Mark Zuckerberg pretending to be an MMA fighter, to, I don't know, Trump himself, that there's this real desire to kind of... fight back and pretend that war and surveillance are good things, that this is somehow, it's kind of woke or liberal to oppose them.
5:36But I would also argue that no one in any of these countries, they all live comfortable, sheltered lives and guarded suburbs for the most part in California. And this is ridiculous. Ask anyone who's lived through an authoritarian regime, I guess, Vlad, you're in, I guess, Romania. So, you know, obviously, Romania had a communist surveillance regime that was very dangerous, I would assume killed dissidents.
6:04Imagine they had access to AI drones and mass surveillance. The same look at what's happening currently today in Russia and China, and also the sort of out of control behavior of ICE in the United States, the killing of children and targeting of civilians in places like Gaza and Iran. I mean, obviously, a lot of these regimes like the laws in Iran are terrible, but I don't think that any way justifies automated murder. So I do think it's like our responsibility as programmers and technology people that are interested in technology to put forward another vision of technology that's not based on ethno-nationalism and authoritarianism.
6:48And I think that's what has been on my mind. I wrote a late-night rant last night, trying to clean it up a little bit today. But effectively, you know, the internet does not belong to a single country. The programmers... You know, it's true, we can't rely on, I mean, this is where Alex Karp is right, we can't rely on laws to save us.
7:16In fact, if anything, laws are being weaponized against us, as we can see from the case of Roman Storm. But we should continue creating tools to defend ourselves. Anti-surveillance technology, privacy enhancing technology, like what I work on, Nym, which is a sort of anonymous networking stack, what DarkFi is for markets, what Roman Storm is working on. These technologies are the only thing that are going to resist this kind of coming wave of authoritarianism and mass surveillance.
7:50And I think we really need to put forward a more positive vision of the future where technology can be used, as Hal Finney said, can be used to help people and not to enslave them. And I think, you know, the original internet and web had a lot of that vision in it. It was very naive in terms of surveillance. And now we have to kind of build a new sort of internet, with new privacy-enhanced cryptocurrency which can really free people and let them decentralize power to individuals and voluntary associations.
8:30And this is essentially the old anarchist vision, but for a technological age, and help people survive, because otherwise I do think we're going to face, we're faced with an era of war. And civilians need to be able to fight back and survive. So that's what I've been thinking about. Sorry about that rant.
8:51Vlad CosteaYeah, I mean, it's like a sum of topics that right now are interconnected. Previously, before Palantir and before we had this AI for basically processing large volumes of data. Maybe a lot of this seemed disconnected, but now you can get access to a lot of disparate sources and then you connect the dots with AI and it becomes much easier to surveil than it was before. Like, I think the threat models should be adjusted accordingly when you want to use privacy tools or...
9:24I guess for a long time, for example, in the case of VPNs, which is something that you work on with Nym, it was reasonable to give your data to one corporation and assume that the other one will never get access to it. But now I think with aggregation and with all of these leaks that happen basically every month now with someone hacking into KYC databases or whatever, it's becoming easier than ever to link between accounts and between data and I'm not sure if there is like a one-size-fits-all solution to this, but it's something that you need to consider that previously, it was fine to give your data in one part and assume that the other part will not get it. But now, that's not guaranteed anymore.
10:15Harry HalpinYeah, I mean, Alex Karp, he says, well, it's ridiculous that, you know, programmers are making these apps, and things like the iPhone or free email from Gmail are viewed as like the summit of our civilization. Instead, we should be building, I think as Karp puts it, rifles for our Marines. And modern-day equivalent rifles, he believes, are these mass surveillance systems. But I would disagree. It is true that what Palantir quite conveniently leaves out is that for many years, you know, the mass surveillance capabilities of private actors, like Google and Apple, were mostly aimed at ads and advertising.
10:57And, you know, these cookies that follow you around the web and the geolocation on your phone, you know, that was supposed to help you find friends and so forth. These are all considered quite innocent but what you've seen is this mass data collection. It's not been used to help people, it's not been used for economic improvements. Ultimately it seems of very low value except for governments and private corporations that want to, you know, to be frank, get rid of immigrants, target and kill dissidents and quash any form of emerging resistance to the system.
11:39So all this data collection that inherently comes with free email, that inherently comes with your iPhone or your Android phone, this spyware that you put in your pocket every day, people think it's just... It's no longer just about advertising. The threat models are becoming much more dangerous and much more life-threatening, and they really do involve kind of these global nation state level adversaries that are trying to use the internet and your devices, and, to be honest, as this is a Bitcoin podcast, your Bitcoin transactions, stored forever on the blockchain to go after you.
12:19And then Len Sassaman, actually, in his critique of Bitcoin, this is one reason I'm not so sure Len would be, I knew Len, Len would be considered Satoshi Nakamoto. Len said, I was reading the quote earlier today, Len said, Len studied mixnets and mass surveillance. He said it's clear that whoever invented Bitcoin does understand the power of traffic analysis, using internet patterns to find you and to eliminate you. De-anonymizing you is just the first step.
12:52The next step is what they're going to do with you. How are they going to predict you, control you, and eventually eliminate you if your behavior is so far out of line? And, to be honest, the blockchain technologies without privacy make this worse.
13:10Vlad CosteaYeah, I was gonna crack a joke that we don't care about that anymore because now we're institutionalized and we just trade paper instead of using transactions on the blockchain, but it's really not funny. It's actually depressing.
13:24Harry HalpinNo, it's super depressing, but I do think... I did a response to Alex Karp called the Anti-Palantir Manifesto, where I do point out, you know, we as technologists, we can use cryptocurrency to liberate people, we can decentralize power away from the state. You know, there's this kind of trope that Palantir uses, that everyone that's against essentially AI-automated mass murder is some kind of, you know, whiny liberal who is afraid of war, who doesn't know how to fight, and is not realistic. But I would say if you look at human history, the most realistically we've seen, you know, this kind of concentrated power is always abused and civilians and political dissidents do end up the target. And this is just unacceptable, but we're not going to solve it with whining. We're not going to solve it with whining. Yeah, we're going to have to build...
14:30Amir TaakiI haven't actually read the manifesto and you guys are talking about the manifesto. I'm sure a lot of people in the audience haven't read the manifesto, so maybe we can just talk about it quickly what it is.
14:42Harry HalpinI gave a little brief overview earlier, but effectively, it's a kind of summary of Alex Karp's book called Technological Republic, where he calls for the combination of the centralized state and Silicon Valley companies, where he's saying, I'm upset that Silicon Valley companies aren't cooperating more with the state. I actually, you know, I was at MIT when, many years ago, a decade ago actually at this point, when I think it was maybe an ISIS adherent murdered a bunch of people in California and they couldn't open their iPhone. And I remember the FBI came to MIT and they said, "Can you help us break open this iPhone?
15:24We'll give you a big reward, you fancy MIT professors." And there was a point in human history where Silicon Valley was not fully cooperating with the US government. And then it's just, I mean, you know, Google even was upset at the Snowden revelations, how they were kind of undermining the privacy of their users. But what Alex is arguing is that this is a wrong turn. The future, and this is what his company Palantir does, the future is that we in Silicon Valley should work with the US government, should build them more powerful mass surveillance tools.
16:02And these are great, and it's a great business model, right? Because you have the ability to build databases for government employees. Government employees are obviously not very good at computers. So it's really easy work. And these government contracts, they have like a 90% renewal rate. So if you look at a consumer product, people tend not to pay very much. Governments, once you're in there, it's a big corrupt monopoly. And you can keep being paid again and again for producing software. What effectively is probably database joins is what Palantir is doing.
16:38And this really kind of brings to mind, you know, Peter Thiel's belief in his book Zero to One, where Peter Thiel is like, "Hey, you know, why? I'm against competition. I just want monopolies. Monopolies is how you make real money." But I think what Peter Thiel forgets is monopolies historically produce political corruption and economic stagnation. Right. Too much centralization of power and too small a group just leads to grift. You can look at our current US government administration, for example.
17:11And then, so that's The Technological Republic. It's a call to arms that programmers should feel morally, that it's morally right to help the US government because of their superior values, form a kind of techno-fascism. I think this is the real point he's trying to make, and I'm saying we have to make a counterpoint where we argue against techno-fascism and we argue for technology as a liberating force. You know, for him, we have to make a choice between creating tools for enslavement or creating spaces of freedom. We don't have any other choice really.
17:57Vlad CosteaYeah, but let me ask you something else because it seems like whenever this argument comes along and someone like any company that builds anything in America comes up with it, they sort of get away with a lot and they will say, well, in China, they don't have any of these regulations and they don't have these concerns. And they're far more advanced than we are and if we don't compete at the same level with the same lack of ethics or whatever, then we're not going to be able to remain the dominant superpower of the world.
18:33And they're gonna be number one in AI, they're gonna be number one in crypto, they're gonna be number one in whatever industry. And it seems to work, like American politicians are very much compelled by this idea, because they do want to retain the supremacy of the US government and the power of America in the world. And if the argument is geopolitical and they do have to compete with China and China doesn't care too much about human rights, then the standard also becomes lower for products and services that get built in America.
19:09Harry HalpinBut I would argue that the reverse, you know, American technological domination comes from a heritage, there's wonderful books on it, from a heritage of libertarianism, of creating systems which are parallel systems that push beyond government control. So if you look at authoritarian countries, now, there's a reason, there's actually great history books on this. There's a reason Russia never developed the internet. It's a centralized control society. There are people pushing for a Russian version of the internet, but essentially it was cancelled. And then you have the same situation going on and I think China didn't develop its own internet. Right. So what you've seen is that you're seeing... I mean, Bitcoin is another example. Who created working digital money that really took off as an investment class? Was it the PayPal mafia, or was it Satoshi Nakamoto? Right? You know, that innovation is what really drives technology.
20:22Innovation is creating something which is new. And in order to create something which is new, you need to have fundamental freedoms: the freedom of speech, freedom to self-organize. And the people that rise to the top of these centralized control mechanisms, be it Trump in the United States, or whoever, the Ayatollah in Iran, or so forth and so on, typically are not the best and brightest. I mean, sort of see, right? The bureaucrats in the European Union are often not anyone particularly special. You get these kind of masterful bureaucrats rising to the top, not people with a real vision for the future.
21:00It's people with a real vision for the future that take advantage of technology and innovation. And so the danger, I think, what people don't see is they say, "Okay, well, cool, Russia's going to, you know, they don't care about our human rights. They're going to build AI killing machines. What do we do?" And then they're going to release those all on them. Same with... I don't know, you know, Russia. But I mean, look, basically, if you look at all the open source activity and the decentralized activity, in Ukraine, that's been very successful in helping stop the Russian invasion, halt it in its tracks.
21:40If you look at almost any country, really, it is a level of decentralization, which I think enables intelligence, enables new technologies which are more powerful than anything any authoritarian regime can create. So you don't beat your enemy by becoming like your enemy. You beat your enemy... You can't beat your enemy simply by murdering people. That never works. Look at Gaza and Iran. It just makes them stronger. Right, the Iranian people rally to their regime rather than be terrified and surrender to God-Emperor Trump, due to these mass bombings from above by the US and Israel. You can only really beat an enemy by being better than the enemy. By having a better vision of the world, you can only convince people to join you with a better vision of economic prosperity, a better vision of empowerment. You don't beat people by just acting like a common murderer.
22:53And this is a juvenile fantasy, I think, of someone who's never actually been in war. I mean, Amir can talk about the situation in Syria. But, you know, from what I've seen, ISIS was defeated. I mean, I'm sure, yeah, US airstrikes definitely helped. But also there was the fact that people didn't want them to be in power. The people who were fighting them were willing to die for a better vision of the world and produce a better vision of society in Syria. That's what led ISIS to go down. Likewise, if you look at, you know, the Soviet Union, it had a huge military, but at some point the people were just sick of this corrupt group of politicians running everything in a mafia-like fashion. And then all the military in the world can't help you in that situation. And I think we may be entering that sort of situation in the United States fairly soon.
23:46Christopher CialoneIf we're not there already.
23:48Harry HalpinIt's looking grim, I would say. I would be interested in hearing... I think I probably ranted enough about Palantir, but if you have any further comments, I'm happy to hear them. I would be very interested in hearing what's going on with the Roman Storm case as well.
24:06Christopher CialoneYeah, so there's... I think this is like one of those cases that come around, yeah, maybe once or twice in a lifetime, and this is kind of a nail in the coffin of innovation. So for those that don't know, Roman Storm created Tornado Cash, a crypto mixer, enabling privacy using, you know, zero-knowledge proofs to ensure the privacy. And the government now is attempting to redefine what privacy means by separating anonymity from privacy and essentially just pushing a user registry for anything that's developed in the background. In New York, you know, I'm in New York, and you could see that they're pushing for, and I think they passed it, ID on the operating system level. And there's just so many different legal battles to fight at once, it's like overwhelming the amount of... People that are kind of... it's hard to stay plugged into all of this at once.
25:17There's so many different ways this is coming from. But I think the most important thing is that the Southern District of New York is attempting to redefine what privacy is and what it means by separating again the anonymity from privacy, and then of course mixing up secrecy and privacy and trying to make it seem like only criminals are looking for privacy.
25:41The DA, not the DA, the prosecutor actually went so far, I was in the Rule 29 hearing, he went so far as to say that legitimate users' funds were actually illegitimate because they strengthened the pools, the amount of money that was in the pools, making it more private, so he says even they broke the law. So they're really reaching now to stifle anybody trying to go near the gray area, push the limits of innovation, really.
26:12Who wants to build if you're going to get hauled in there with 40 years hanging over your head, there's only like a handful of people that are willing to do that. I'm sure three of them, four people are, you know, right here.
26:29But how many people are really willing to say, "Well, fuck it, I'll do it"? Well, let me see where your principles are at to the government. You know, it's very frustrating because the developer community has been more or less silent. You see the same people. I'm not saying there's not voices, But on a large level, you think that as an industry and even vibe coders, people are going to be put inside a box. You're allowed to build this. And it's kind of like Chicken Little. People think that you're saying, "No, the sky is falling." How, you know, how credible could you be?
27:04But this is really like... It seems like the case to me. Because Roman didn't go out of his way to stick it to the feds. You know, some people, even me, sometimes I'll say things and it's almost like a dare. You know, like, I could probably choose my words better. I'm a little blunt. These guys built this and then that was the end of it. You know, like, they weren't going out of their way not to comply with the rules. As we all know, there were no rules. This was like the Wild West when he built this. There was no regulations.
27:40And I even argue that KYC is probably the most criminal thing that the government's really pushed on us in a while. But, you know, that's a whole 'nother situation. So we're waiting to see what's happening with the Rule 29 hearing. The judge, you know, the magistrate was thoughtful. She seemed like a more or less fair judge. She wasn't one-sided. She definitely was questioning where the prosecutors were coming from with their theories, but again, you know, the Court's kind of a coin flip, and it's hard to trust the US government seeing, you know, like, what they do, because even a pardon... There's now...
28:20Samourai Wallet developers, you know, the community is really pushing for a pardon and like you kind of have to go through the fire to get the pardon when it's not even called for in the first place. So I'm really hoping that this Roman Storm case kind of blows up a little bit more and gets a little bit more of the attention that it needs. In March, I'll be going down to the other Roman, from Bitcoin Fog.
28:50He's having these oral arguments. He's been in prison for five years. Just to see what's going on with that, because the government, there was more shenanigans they pulled to get him in there in the first place. So it seems like an unfair game, you know, I'm constantly pushing for developers who have some principles to help build parallel systems, you know, there's not going to be, you have the VPN, there's not going to be one VPN that people will use, okay, maybe use a different one, but we need a robust parallel system that mirrors everything that we have now in order to kind of resist the technocratic feudalism that's coming down, you know, whether we like it or not, you know, it seems like they're making their move.
29:41They got their guy in there. Many nations are, you know, working together, in my opinion, you know, we talk about the war and it's definitely not the United States versus Iran. It would be governments versus their own people. I have my own opinion that these guys are just playing a game of chess with each other, but they're really kind of friendly, and the only people who end up getting hurt by this is, you know, Iranian citizens, so I feel like the war isn't, you know, Israel and America versus Iran.
30:19It's the governments versus the people, working in organization, in my opinion, in order to bring about this technocratic feudal state that has really kind of grown on a global scale rather quickly, in my opinion, but when you look at it, they've been laying the foundations for this for years. That's all a mouthful, but yeah.
30:44Vlad CosteaI mean, we're all gonna have a mansion and we're all gonna have a chef and a personal valet, right? That's what Elon Musk is telling us. Like, we're not gonna have to work. We're gonna live in mansions, I think. This is so silly.
30:58Christopher CialoneWell, I wanted, I kind of want difficulty, you know, I feel bad for the programmers that didn't learn before ChatGPT, you know, sitting there and banging your head against the wall. You missed a comma. Your whole thing's broke and you have to go there and literally, you know, there was no AI assistant to help you. And that really helps brain function and the reward system and it was very rewarding just to get text on the screen, let alone, you know, what we can do now in a matter of maybe two minutes. So I do feel bad for the younger generation.
31:36You know, I go out of my way to try to make educational content and tools so just to start plugging the younger people in because they don't even know what privacy is. Think about 9/11, and the world before that, so that was like a drastic change. I'm 43. So I was first year of college when 9/11 happened and in New York. This is a different world, and now it's a different world after COVID. So there's like a whole like generation and a half.
32:08I don't know how generations are really broken up, but there's a large sect of the population that has no idea what privacy really means because it's kind of like a you know, like, that's the psychological operation. It's like, ah, they kind of know anyway. Fuck it. Like, you know, well, I don't know anything about being a... Like, forget it. Like, it doesn't matter. They're going to get this information anyway, and they've given up.
32:34So it's really important, obviously, everybody here knows that, to kind of fly the flag of your own like personal rights and sovereignty and really drill that home with people because that's half the battle is educating them because bringing this information to somebody that doesn't have the whole backstory it's kind of like, well, yeah, but, you know, like, they were funneling money through this guy's application, so it would just be easier to throw him in jail and then... That's the end of that. Yeah, well, you know, until that means, you know, like five years down the line, what is it? What does the world look like if they're able to pass that precedent? And what does your day-to-day life look like based on that precedent?
33:20I don't think people are really looking that far down the road, or might not even care, you know. So it's a little bit of an uphill battle.
33:29Vlad CosteaThe irony of this situation... Sorry for interrupting, Harry. If you are someone who scammed people and made a lot of money and you can pay for your pardon in the Trump administration, you're fine. Yes. But if you build something that empowers people to escape the state, then you're a criminal and you're going to get dragged into court and humiliated and you're going to have to go through this whole process. We used to think that these people are sort of martyrs of the Biden administration because they had Operation Chokepoint 2.0 and they seemed to be openly against crypto for a while.
34:05So we were hoping that once Trump gets elected and he said he was going to free Ross Ulbricht, he did do that. And then we're thinking, okay, his family is personally invested, has their own DeFi project, you know, maybe that this guy gets it and he's gonna let these people go, but he really did not. Like, even Roger Ver, right? I don't think there's anyone who's more resourceful in the space than he is.
34:32He has a lot of money, he has a lot of connections, he can afford to get the best lawyers, yet he still did not get a great deal and he was still in exile for like two years on an island in Spain. So we're sort of screwed. And I don't think politics is gonna save us. I don't think voting for someone else is really gonna make any difference.
34:59Harry HalpinYeah, I just want to say that, I mean, it is... When someone like Alex Karp or the Trump administration say, "Oh, well, you know, we support cryptocurrency," do they really support cryptocurrency and the vision of the cypherpunks or Nakamoto or just something for human freedom? No, it's obvious they don't. You know, they support cryptocurrency as part of a system, this improved banking databases, basically.
35:23Vlad CosteaYes.
35:24Harry HalpinAnd someone like Alex Karp is saying, "Well, these people that resist, people that want privacy, they must be criminals." I mean, it's insane. No one should have all their financial transactions in public or accessible by, you know, random governments. I mean, that's very dangerous. That can be easily used against someone. And I think there's these kind of fundamental... Like, when I don't know, like, I'm also now in my 40s, when I was growing up, you know, you could go for... You didn't have to have a credit card. People would take cash. I used a lot of cash. I didn't have a phone, I don't know, for so long, and we survived.
36:10And we didn't have things like social media. We didn't have mobile phones. We had early forms of communication and email. Actually, I actually feel very, very terrible for young people today who are brought up with no feeling of privacy and a permanent record that could be used to prosecute them in the future at any time. It could be used to blackmail them. And you can see from the Roman Storm prosecution how utterly unfair state prosecutions can be. Like, why are they prosecuting Roman Storm and not prosecuting all these other scammers, right? Roman Storm is a legit guy. He's not a scammer.
36:48He built a service that people use to defend their privacy. You have people who, I'm not going to mention any names, but you can if you want, you know, people that literally, I mean, the president himself, literally been using cryptocurrency for, like, meme pump-and-dumps and corrupt prediction market betting. And they don't get... And so it shows you the state is not there to defend you. The state is not there to help democracy. The state does not represent its citizens. The state is an apparatus of power and control meant to support the domination of its ruling class against ordinary people.
37:26So we have to build those tools like Roman to defend ordinary people. We have to make sure people like Roman don't go to jail. And, you know, it's been frustrating. I've been to these human rights conferences. I've said, "Hey, why don't you support financial privacy?" They're like, "Oh, I don't know, you know, we don't really know. We're not going to support financial privacy. We're just going to support, you know, freedom of expression." But to me, it's the same thing. You know, when you buy something or purchase something, it's part of your expression of who you are, of how you're living.
37:57It's just as important as being able to post some weird screed on Twitter, right? So, you know, I mean, I know I've tried to be supportive of Roman. I've seen the Ethereum Foundation be supportive of Roman. I'm shocked there's not more media attention on the Storm case. And the wider case against Alexey and everyone else in the Tornado Cash case. And I'm really glad you're doing this work, Christopher. It's important to do this work. So we don't end up in a panopticon and everyone just normalizes it and there's no tools to help us to get out. That to me would be absolutely the worst of all possible... So thanks so much for your work.
38:34Christopher CialoneI really appreciate that. You know, it's frustrating, you know, like people, I grew up in New York my entire life. You know, New York has a reputation, and after COVID, something happened here. And it wasn't one or two people. It was just a culture shift where... Maybe it was people were defeated or, you know, just kind of living high off the hog and it was like, you know, things aren't, the bums here have smartphones, you know, like... So maybe it's decadence, it's the drowning in the decadence, I really don't know, but whatever reputation New York had in my mind is kind of like a thing of the past where they're just very compliant. No one really argues, they almost argue for the state, for like, oh, you're not allowed to do that. You know, like... A legal thing. They'll argue that you're not allowed to do something that's legal.
39:47And there's like, you know, complete and utter madness on the subway and you just, well, you just walk right by that, you know. When the prosecutors were talking about the technology, about blockchain and ZK proofs, they have to purposely not be understanding, because they're blurring the lines with what is capable of blockchain, what's not capable, whether or not UI, the user interface, is part of the protocol.
40:15And while it's legal to start, to build the protocol that Roman built, once criminals are using it, you're supposed to shut down shop, walk away from it and say, well, you know, like people are using this, they're misusing this, so I don't want to make any more money. And that's why, like, you see how I am, like you can kind of get a feel for how I am. I'm like almost talking like jumping out of my seat in court. I didn't know Roman from Adam before all this. We're getting, you know, like we have exchanges here and there sometimes on Twitter, but I'm taking it personally because that's anybody.
41:03If you built this, they're coming for you. They're going to misunderstand on purpose. They're going to make you out to be like a demon. And purposely... These are not stupid people. The prosecutor is not an idiot. I mean, he can't be an idiot. And he's purposely confusing the lines to get a conviction, and it's, you know, obviously, you know, none of us are so naive to think that any of this is about justice, you know, like, Roger having to pay whatever ridiculous amount of money it was as a fine for whatever it is that they say Roger did that was wrong.
41:42This is not about justice. This is about punishing those who won't kneel, who won't give the backdoor. You know, give the government the backdoor to enter into any of the data they want to. What about intellectual property? AI has completely destroyed any idea of, well, that's yours and, you know, like, copyright law, that's all like, what happened to any of that? How are you gobbling up all that? And I don't mean to jump across industries and from different topics, but they all kind of do have they all rhyme. Like, the type of fucked up things that are happening rhyme, and it's just, "We're doing whatever we want as the government and the public-private partnership, and...
42:27The few of you that resist, we're crushing." And that's fine, I suppose. It's a good opportunity for all of us. You know, I was listening to Amir speak the other day, when I guess it was for the Logos, one of the Logos conference or something, one of the privacy things. I was listening and, you know, I was really identifying what you were talking about because it's exactly, you're not the only one who feels that way, but there really is, like, a core group of people, I guess, that have this type of mindset.
43:04And it's really important that we get together and kind of spread this thought process out and build these systems to cooperate with each other because what they're doing is not going to stop, obviously. And the only resistance there really is, is to build, to build and to educate people, you know. So, yeah, it's just, you talk about it, and it gets frustrating, it becomes hard to articulate myself in a way other than kind of cursing and getting like real lowbrow. I don't like to do that often.
43:39Sometimes there's no other way to call it. This is a pay-to-play system. You know, if Roman would have had some Trump token and was willing to take a 90% loss on the token, he would have been all right, you know, and that's a shame because I really thought that when we grew up, we'd be grownups, and it seems like it's just like even worse than when there's a bully in the school.
44:06Harry HalpinI'm unfortunately going to have to run here now that Amir's finished.
44:09Vlad CosteaHarry, before you go, I have to give you some Zcash from Cake Wallet.
44:13Harry HalpinOh, yeah, definitely. I'd like to, but I do want to say something, which is like, yeah, like, I think what you're doing is really amazing, and we should support Roman whatever way we can. And, you know, cursing is the right thing to do. This, you know, it's a shameful situation. It's utterly shameful what they're doing to him. The people that are doing this are scum and should be called out as such. And I think it's a very honorable work to defend and support people when they're honestly facing their darkest hours. I've been in some dark situations, people supported me, and then we got to support people like Roman, because if you don't, it's going to be you next. So yeah, so for Zcash, you're going to send me some ZEC to my Cake Wallet? Do you want me to give you an address? How do we do this here?
45:17Vlad CosteaNo, usually you can just show the screen. Right now I'm using Nym. You can see here, I'm using the VPN.
45:25Harry HalpinOh, cool.
45:26Vlad CosteaWaiting for it to connect to the best servers. And it's kind of slow.
45:30Harry HalpinI mean, sometimes it takes a bit, 'cause it's trying to figure out which ones are the best. We will have this optimized pretty shortly. Give me one second while I open my Cake Wallet. I usually use Cake Wallet. Usually, I tend to use Cake Wallet for... Okay, so I have... I tend to use it for Monero, actually, but I've got... I tend to use ZODL for Zcash, but I do now have Zcash on my phone. And you can see it, there it is, exactly zero. But I would love to get some. So, tell me, what should I do?
46:13Vlad CosteaYeah, so the rule is that I give one ZEC to every person who joins the show. But right now, basically, I have three of you at the same time. Yeah, so I have to split that. You're going to get 0.33, which I think today is like more than 100 bucks.
46:33Harry HalpinOkay, so I send this, I send my address to you. Do I send it over Signal, or?
46:39Vlad CosteaOkay, that works. You could also show the QR and I could just try to scan it.
46:44Harry HalpinOh, you want me to show... I can also show... Yeah, I'm not sure, should I show the QR to the screen? I guess I could.
46:50Vlad CosteaIt's not public.
46:51Harry HalpinYou want to try to scan it on the screen? I guess, yeah, go for it. There it is. There it is. Go for it. Can you scan that?
47:00Christopher CialoneMove it a little to the right.
47:03Harry HalpinYeah. It's a fresh wallet, so it should be okay.
47:07Christopher CialoneThe other right.
47:08Vlad CosteaYeah, you have to move it a bit. Yeah.
47:10Christopher CialoneYeah, there, you got it.
47:12Vlad CosteaDoesn't focus. It doesn't work.
47:17Harry HalpinOkay, well, I will just Signal it to you.
47:19Vlad CosteaYeah, just send me a text.
47:21Harry HalpinAnd now, I really do... Of the wallets I use, Cake Wallet for Monero in particular, and I use it quite a lot, it's been an absolutely excellent wallet. We should at some point integrate Nym into them, so they have, similar to Edge Wallet, they should have better network privacy just built in, so you don't have to start and stop the VPN. So yeah, so I've sent it over. Should I hang out till it arrives? I'm not...
47:55Vlad CosteaNo, it's fine. You can go. You can trust me that I will send it.
48:02Harry HalpinYeah, for myself, I would say that I remember once, I don't even remember this, Amir, you can tell the whole story, we were trying to send Zcash to someone overseas and we had to send it using a JSON, a handcrafted JSON file. So technology does make progress over time. We now have full wallets with shielded Zcash support. So I gotta go. Take care, everyone.
48:28Vlad CosteaHarry, before you go, pick a number from 1 to 100.
48:31Harry Halpin98. 98.
48:34Vlad CosteaOkay, thank you very much.
48:36Harry HalpinCool. Take care.
48:37Vlad CosteaSo everyone in the chat, you're going to have to basically guess a number from 1 to 100, which is going to be the average of the numbers that everyone chooses. And Harry chose 98, so do your math. Calculate the odds that you're going to have the closest number and mention it in the chat. So Harry chose 98, there's going to be one from Christopher and one from Amir, but don't give them away just give people time to join the contest. Let it be spicy. Amir, you've been quite silent so far. Oh, he left.
49:16Christopher CialoneI think it froze. I think his phone froze.
49:21Vlad CosteaIt's fine. So something that I wanted to mention about this, Christopher, is that I do believe that the day when the Samourai Wallet developers were arrested is also the day that Bitcoin died. Because the response, the immediate response was that everyone who was working on privacy shut down. They were so scared, they did not want to become martyrs in the name of anything. Wasabi Wallet, which was the competitor of Samourai, it just vanished, the company dissolved and then you had all of these other privacy services.
50:00I remember there was something called Mercury Wallet, which is something that was doing a statechain coin swap, meaning that you could change UTXOs with someone else without leaving an on-chain footprint. That one, I haven't heard about it in a long time. And I think also a lot of these privacy products in Bitcoin, they became unfashionable. The only one that sort of got accepted is the eCash thing, which is privacy for custodial funds on Lightning. But I think the only reason why that one was accepted is that it can be stolen, can be seized by the custodian, so... Privacy is only as good as the mercy of the person who's holding your funds.
50:51Christopher CialoneWhich is really no different than a bank. You know, like at the end, not to shortchange what they built over there, but, you know, I think you're right. And these arrests are having the implications they want, you know, in the entirety of Web3. Oh, here's Amir. Let me shut my mouth for a second here. You made it back.
51:15Amir TaakiNo, continue, sorry. Don't shut your mouth.
51:20Christopher CialoneNo, believe me, I want to hear from you more than you want to hear what I got to say.
51:27Amir TaakiI just had a question. Because Harry was saying, but Harry left. So I was like, he said that Palantir wants to get rid of privacy. Is that what they said themselves, or did they say the tech and the military-state complex, etc., should be like working more closely together? So what was he... I guess I need to read the manifesto. Let me pull it up here.
52:02Christopher CialoneI'll stop you. You guys can... I didn't read it either. I know that people choose their words wisely, but that Karp does run at the mouth a little bit, so he might accidentally...
52:16Amir TaakiOkay, I thought this podcast was about that. What's this podcast about?
52:22Vlad CosteaWell, we're talking privacy stuff, like in general, but Harry decided to focus on his latest obsession with Palantir. Which makes a lot of sense.
52:32Amir TaakiI see. And?
52:35Vlad CosteaYeah, he is the one who told me he only has like 35 to 40 minutes before he has to go, so I let him talk first.
52:44Amir TaakiOkay, makes sense.
52:45Vlad CosteaWe don't have to necessarily follow this line, but if you want, I don't mind it.
52:50Amir TaakiNo, no, no, I was just curious why he was saying that. I mean, I think the question is quite simple. It's like, if that guy's got a gun, I want a gun. Pretty simple. And, you know, giving the government that much power... Do you really trust this government in particular as a moral government? I mean, literally, it's been confirmed. There's literally pedophiles in the government. There's like child sex rings. They're making wars. You know, whether you care about the wars or not, are US citizens actually benefiting from the war itself? You know, the US is like literally a giant island in the middle of an ocean. It could just be chilling, it could be doing its own thing, it could be printing money, it could be successful. Instead, Americans are funding a military-industrial complex, a surveillance apparatus, all of that stuff. Who actually benefits from this, is a question. Who benefits from going, literally, to the other side of the globe?
54:05It is literally the other side of the globe, going into the Middle East and fighting some random Middle Eastern country. Do US citizens actually benefit from that? Who exactly benefits from all this? So, why? Why do those people in power need more powers? Is that something that, you know, is going to help US citizens? So I think the argument's quite direct. You know, obviously, the system is very corrupt. People were hoping for something different. It hasn't happened. You know, we have to rely on our own strength. We have to make a revolution. You know, we have to use technology. We've got this technology, cypherpunk tech. So, you know, let's leverage it. You know, it's the most powerful thing that we've got. I think the sell is quite direct.
55:10Christopher CialoneYeah, I mean, I totally agree with that. You know, that's basically my line to anybody that'll listen to me at this point. You know, and almost the questions don't even need to be answered. I think they kind of answer themselves, like who's benefiting, you know, just the powerful. You know, the same thing in America, there's two political parties. That's the appearance. There's one political class, you know, and they split up the power, however they split it up. And they just fight amongst each other. And I think it's the same thing with the nations.
55:45There's a global ruling class and they just kind of go back and forth on who's going to be the most powerful. And they keep the people arguing amongst each other within the nation and within the globe. You know, I'm an American, so I don't like the Iranians. You know, that's not true, but that's what they would lead you to believe. And you're right, we have to start working together. And it's not even about like, it's not about the product market fit or all this other silly horse shit that they have developers really worrying about. It's, can you make a messaging system that can't be stopped?
56:24Okay, that's great. Good. Can you make money that they can't confiscate, a store of value where they can't stop it? Okay, that's great. Can you make a social media that can't be stopped, where we can continue doing the same thing that happens on X, for the most part, that just can't be utilized to hurt the people who are on it. And when we get enough people, when there's a critical mass of developers who will do that, then, you know, we have something. I think things are kind of moving that way, to be honest with you.
57:00I really do, because I think there's enough people getting disgusted, because what do we need, like 5%? We need 5% of the people to agree. Something like that. But you know, like when you're thinking about the math of it, 5% of the developers... A lot of them sold out. They'll just build whatever stupid shit that they're paid to build. They don't care. We don't want them anyway.
57:25Amir TaakiI'm sorry, welcome to the government. It just sounds boring. Like, you guys, imagine you can, like, wear cool cypherpunk merch like that. There you go. You look like a warrior. Let's fight the... Let's fight to get power. Don't be a slave. You know, you're like a wage slave. You all know the terminology that we use on the internet these days. You can be your own sovereign man. You can roam across the internet as, like, in a dark forest, and you can do business. And nobody can tell you what to do. You can be truly free.
58:02What is better in this world than to roam around as a wild beast of nature where you rely on your instinct of like attack and defense. You know, isn't that what the internet used to be about? It used to be so fun. Don't you remember, like, the old days of YouTube? People were just posting videos on the internet, having a good time. Now everything's become so, like, algorithmic. This is literally, like, economic. It literally just like sucks all the joy out of it.
58:36So I think we can create something much better, more fun. You know, we can be free. And you know like what Harry said, like, oh, you know, they're selling us the thing, everybody will be a movie star and have a mansion and, you know, have their own robot maid. I don't think it's going to be like that. I think that's just what they're selling us because they want to enslave us. But we can build that ourselves, but you have to become an entrepreneur. You have to gain the tools of power that they're trying to keep you from.
59:12They're deliberately trying to keep you down, and they psyop you as well. They psyop you away from doing that. There's a whole world out there that is waiting to be explored. Crypto, we used to be going towards that. It used to be a brave world. Everybody's become so afraid. I don't know what they're even afraid of. I mean, I guess, yes, like Roman Storm's being put in jail, etc. But, you know, I don't think... It seems like they're not doing so well right now. That's why they're creating all these wars to distract.
59:47From these crises they have. So, you know, we need to... We can create our own technological paradigm. It's really just waiting there to be done. I'm surprised nobody's done it yet. But anyway, it's cool. At least we will be the first project to do that. And you know, they're actually like, I mean, it is true, actually. I do understand what people are saying, but we literally have what we suspect are agents in our chat that are spreading disinformation. They literally do stuff like they fork the code.
1:00:20And they like make these changes to the code in different repos and they keep like passing it off as though they're like DarkFi developers and people actually think it's like legit code and they like talk about like issues that they've just made up that are not real. So we actually have that like attack that's like ongoing. You know, this kind of like information war attack also, like I keep getting arrested and harassed at airports.
1:00:49And, you know, like, I mean, I am not going to say more, but I have to, like, you know, I have like meetings with police and stuff as well that have to do... It's like weird, like, this is like an extra-legal regime that just exists. And, you know, how do you even challenge that? It's not like they're like trying you in a court of law, they're just causing you hassle. And, you know, you have to kind of deal with them. And they send agents into ecosystems. So it's like, that's literally how this thing operates.
1:01:30Vlad CosteaYeah, yeah, it's really unfortunate how you get treated. I was gonna ask you, how is the progress with DarkFi?
1:01:38Amir TaakiSorry, I was saying, I'm using the phone, so I have this like really itsy bitsy tiny button that I have to press to unmute, 'cause I'm using it in the browser, 'cause I don't have the app. DarkFi is good. Like, you know, we're making the wallet, the app, you know, the version of the wallet should be out this month. The second major thing is the bridge. For a long time, the bridge, how it would be done was an open question, but now, the bridge is like... We've kind of decided on a roadmap to do that and it just needs to be implemented.
1:02:26Testnet is going to be released soon. After testnet, I guess, is mainnet. Yeah, just... Those are the kind of final questions. The other main thing, the big thing, actually will be the marketing. And so once this version of the app is done, then I'm going to pivot to that and start to get more momentum going on the whole kind of raising the profile of DarkFi, essentially.
1:02:57Vlad CosteaYeah, I just want to tell a story with you, Amir, if that's fine, with what happened to you in Argentina in November.
1:03:05Amir TaakiYeah, that's one of them.
1:03:06Vlad CosteaYeah, you're the real deal. You're like a legend. I was there attending DevConnect and there was this Privacy Now dinner or whatever. And everyone was expecting you to come and then someone said, "Well, Amir got detained at the airport and he had to fly back, I don't know exactly where." And there were stories from people saying, wow, this guy's a legend. Maybe that he'll be able to get a car and cross the border through this country and he's going to be able to attend tomorrow. And then someone else said, well, but what if he gets on stage to do his speech and he gets arrested during the speech? And someone else said, well, that's going to make him even more of a legend.
1:03:46Amir TaakiYeah, they deported me from Argentina to Brazil and they wouldn't tell me why, so you know, that's that. But it's happening in a few countries. I got detained eight hours in Serbia, six hours in Mexico, a few hours in Japan. You know, we don't know which country it's coming from or like why exactly it's happening, you know. Could be anything. Could be a mix of things.
1:04:21Vlad CosteaBut do you believe that you're on some sort of lists when you fly, and they just detain you? I also remember this one, you attended Monero Utopia. That was in November of 2023 or '24, I think '24. And you were late because they stopped you in Japan or something? And that was fresh after the HBO documentary came out.
1:04:47Amir TaakiYeah, and also, I don't know if it's related, but Ray Youssef, he had literally a swarm of federales in Mexico City come and detain and deport him. So, I mean, if you look at the figures in crypto that are kind of being targeted, I mean, you mentioned Roger, Ray Youssef, etc. There does seem to be a pattern of a certain political profile or certain kinds of work that they're involved in. So, I mean, Roman Storm, privacy, Samourai, privacy. They're definitely interested in this stuff.
1:05:24So, you know, maybe they're kind of going like, you know, stay away from that stuff, but, you know, it's actually going to do the opposite, 'cause we're going to go, okay, that's what we should do more of, 'cause that's what they're afraid of. You know, doing that kind of stuff is not going to make people back down. It's going to make people want to fight and dig in. If you're stubborn, you're stubborn, you want to, like, dig in and resist. You're like, you motherfuckers.
1:06:01You're not going to tell me what to do. You're a fucking bitch. I'm going to tell you what to do. So, you know, they're not accustomed to that. They're like, that's why they, you know, they've gone to the, I mean, I don't know, everybody has a different view on this war with Iran. I remember when it started, I talked to a friend of mine and he said, "Look, Amir, what the Americans don't realize is these guys are stubborn. They're like really stubborn. They're not going to give up."
1:06:35And kind of America went in and they were like, "We're going to win this war in a few days." And then after a few days they were like, "We've already won the war." And every week they're saying, "We've already won the war," and it's clearly... They have not won the war. And when you talk to people about it, they're kind of like, "Yeah, they're doing some five-dimensional chess." You know, actually, they're kind of like... Do you announce you've won a war? Like, why, in advance? No, you don't. That's a very clearly losing strategy. I know they tried to do this, like, uprising thing.
1:07:15They tried to engineer an uprising. It didn't work out. There wasn't that much... People that were into it kind of flopped. Now they're saying, the official, the stats, different independent people are all, you know, two and a half people, two and a half thousand people were executed. But, you know, the US government is saying 50,000 people were executed, blah blah, casus belli. But that didn't work out. And then since then, what have they done? They're kind of like... They don't seem to have a plan, really. And now they're talking about putting boots on the ground.
1:07:59It seems like America kind of, like, lost all its strategic objectives. I don't know. I don't know what I'm talking about. I'm just making shit up. But does it really... It's kind of like, I'm not sure it's going too well for them, to be honest. Doesn't seem like they're winning. And, you know, they kind of seem to be like... So anyway, like, I guess what they expected was the first time, well, the first kind of, like, when the US is like, you know, we're going in and we're going to fucking defeat you." And then they said, "Oh, you know, Mr.
1:08:46Americans, don't do that," and expect them to surrender. And when they didn't, they kind of went... It's like unexpected for them, it's a surprise. So I think what they're accustomed to is, like, pushing people around and people being compliant and like giving into their demands. And so, when you're not like that, I think suddenly their paper tiger collapses. The more people do that, the more it's kind of exposed how vulnerable they are. And that precisely because they're doing such an extravagant display of violence against particular actors, against particular individuals, targeting people, etc., is showing that actually they are very afraid of these things. That's why precisely they overreact. It's like, if they weren't afraid, they would, like, calmly, assertively, in a relaxed way, deal with a thing, an issue.
1:09:46They wouldn't, you know, resort to all these means, the kind of like pressure... Put pressure, to apply pressure. So, yeah. Yeah, I think, you know, we have cards in our hands. Just not sure if people realize it. You think they're good hands?
1:10:09Christopher CialoneReal quick, I had a question. You were talking about, you know, kind of like agents being within the... messing around with your product, you know, like what you're building, the project. What do you got? What are you doing? Like, what's the move when that's happening? Do you kind of like let it happen and just keep it like kind of isolated in your mind or keep an eye on what's going on with it or... As a fellow, you know, builder, because I'm trying... Without giving, you know, like making yourself, you know, putting yourself in a situation where you're showing your hand kind of, you know?
1:10:49Amir TaakiI think the thing is, these kind of tactics are meant to exhaust you by like creating like fires that you have to go out and you continually have to put out. And I think it's a mistake to just kind of ignore it and not do anything against it. I think you do have to... When people, like, attack you, or when people are doing stuff against you do have to, like, go and address things before they get out of hand, but at the same time, I think these things are like designed in such a way to emotionally dysregulate you. So as soon as you like, you become reactive, you become emotional. Or, you know, you become concerned with things, 'cause remember, like, these people do have like psychological operations. They do like they're psychologists. They like analyze your mindset. You know, there's all this stuff, like, "Oh, you know, schizo guy tried to assassinate a guy." Like, I don't know. I don't know how much...
1:11:59That stuff is, you know, engineered versus just a crazy guy. But it is certainly, like, something that is plausible, that they have the ability to manipulate crazy people as proxies. They have the ability to influence public opinion at scale. They have the ability to apply psychological pressure to people. So when you realize what their game is, it's important to realize like, okay, you shouldn't become reactive to things, you shouldn't let things affect you psychologically. You have to deal with things in a calm, rational manner. You should not get sucked into their games. Their whole point is to suck you in emotionally, to make you expend energy, to become tired, exhausted. Remember, you're trying to ship the product. You're trying to deliver something. So that has to be the focus. This is like a side mission. This is not really the importance. So, I think having this mindset is the key to dealing with government psyops.
1:13:13Vlad CosteaYeah, and once again, something that I think people forget perpetually, maybe every few decades, is that violence does not really solve much. Like, you can do genocide if you go to that length. But it doesn't mean that you're gonna kill a religion. It doesn't mean that you're gonna kill an ideology. Doesn't mean that you're gonna kill a movement. It just means that you're gonna delay the growth of something which is gonna hit you harder when it comes back, so...
1:13:49I think the approach that the US used to have with cultural diplomacy and the fact that they were trying to basically spread democracy with McDonald's and Hollywood and music and whatever, I think it was a much better and more subtle approach than just invading perpetually. But then again, I don't think there was a specific decade in their history, in the 20th and the 21st century, when they were not at war with anyone. It's just that now it's much more obvious and it's out there.
1:14:28Amir TaakiI mean also like, things have changed a lot. Like, we're all, like, a lot more aware of how they're operating. When it's like... I mean, look at just like the 2010 era. People were a lot more naive back then. I remember like talking with my dad when I was like a teenager. And he was like, he goes, "Oh yeah, the BBC is biased, blah, blah, blah." And I was like, "No, Dad. The BBC is an objective, neutral resource." And he goes, "Oh, shut up, you don't know what you're talking about." And I was like, "No, you don't know what you're talking about." I know it's embarrassing, but like, you know, that was like the time back then, you know. Even then, even though I was, like, I'd call myself an anarchist, I still thought, you know, there was some... I don't know, objective neutrality or something in that stuff. I know it's embarrassing to say it, I guess I was like so young as well.
1:15:41Vlad CosteaI was thinking about this recently also, Amir, that like 10 years ago, I was still believing in something universal and objective, like there is just one source of truth and maybe if we all got that truth, the world would be a better place or whatever. But it's really not like that. And I'm not the kind of person to say that, you know, there's multiple truths and perspectives and every person should be listened to and whatever. So I'm not falling for that extreme, I'm just saying that the values of people are always different and you should take that into consideration.
1:16:16Amir TaakiLook, there's different geopolitical realities, there's different geographies. Different geographies influence culture. You know, culture influences ethnicity, you know, there's also like possibly biological realities, you know, different stuff. I mean, there definitely is physical... Local adaptations, you know, people in Tibet, they have adaptations to live at really high altitude. And people in Africa, they have adaptations to cool themselves more efficiently. So, you know, who's to say there is any universal social kind of political system? You know, I imagine like, you know, people in Siberia probably have like a very different way of living to people in Brazil, you know, even if they have the same ostensible political system. So, yeah, I mean, humanity is like a big, diverse ecosystem, and I think that's something to be celebrated. You know, it's not something we want to, like, homogenize and remove all differences between people.
1:17:26We want to like eliminate... You know, we want to eliminate all the culture and just have this, like, global consumerist, hyper-liberal shopping mall. Eternal Y2K.
1:17:44Vlad CosteaYeah, but coming back to the topic of privacy, when you do want to get privacy, you want to look like everyone else. You don't want to stand out in any way. That's sort of the concept of being able to hide in a crowd in a way that you're not distinguishable. So from a privacy point of view, maybe that there are some tenets or universal rules that everyone should follow in order to get it. It's not like just because you come from a different country and you have a different culture, you need a different kind of privacy. I think it's universal.
1:18:21Amir TaakiI mean, I think we're talking about separate things, but okay, like, I don't know if there is anything as, you know, universal privacy or what is the correct way to do privacy. There is an arms race. The arms race is between certain actors who are developing countermeasures to diminish privacy. And then there's like another side who's, you know, developing new measures, new privacy measures, new ways to preserve people's freedom. And then you've got to kind of... And then also part of that is, you know, best practice of it. You know, you're operating in this context, what is the best way to use this tool for your purposes? And look, everybody's going to have different purposes or goals. And the thing is that, you know, we make a decision about exactly what we're trying to accomplish with this technology.
1:19:32Who are we trying to support? You know, what world are we envisioning? And I know this sounds very abstract, but, you know, I want to see, I do want to see people on the internet building agorist parallel economic systems. You know, I want to see people like trading, and I want to see communities organizing, and I want... Outside of the state system, and mobilizing for freedom. You know, reclaiming their sovereignty. I think it's increasingly going to be signed on. There is a class like a big class of people. And they're literally, as I said, they're like people in the government. They're creating wars.
1:20:21They're not working to benefit people. They're literally... I don't know what they're trying to do. What they're trying to do, they're literally like, some of them are even, like, you know, extracting plasma from, like, young adults or, like, kids even, and injecting it into themselves to extend their life. I mean, sure, we could argue the medical benefit of that, but it literally is like a vampiric parasitic type of activity.
1:20:54And, you know, like, what are we going to do about that? What are you going to do about that? Huh? So I'm telling you're like, "Oh, I don't like cryptocurrency. You know, I don't like anonymity." It's like, firstly, you know, you should... This is available to you. And if you're kind of going like, "Oh yeah, criminal..." I mean, I'm not saying anybody listening to this podcast is saying that, but it's something I've heard people say, like, "Oh yeah, criminals, you know, they will use that stuff." It's like, okay, yeah, it exists. Criminals are going to use it. But you can use it too.
1:21:34Why wouldn't you use it? Oh, you're not going to use it because literally, a pedophile warmongering class literally said this is what morality is. We define what is moral, what is good, what is bad, and we like impose that on you. And you, like a good slave, will go like, "Oh yes," you know, like, following the laws that they've made, the rules that they've created, "that is what is moral, what is good. Yes, I'm going to abide by that."
1:22:05Sorry, you know, you're just living life by their rules. You're not living life by your rules. You know, I'm saying, "Look, there's this tool, take it, use it." You know, if that guy has a gun, I want a fucking gun. You know, why wouldn't I? You can tell me, "Oh, it's bad that I have a gun." It's like, "Okay, but he's got a gun." I don't care about anything else. I want one too. Literally, I want to defend myself. It doesn't... And if I don't have it... I know that I'm not going to shoot random people.
1:22:39So, you know, I don't need you to tell me it's bad that I have a gun. Well, I know it's good that I have it. Same thing with any tool of power. I want the power. I want the tools of power. I'm going to take them. I'm going to use them. You're not? Fine, don't do it. But this is the second point: it exists. Doesn't matter, you can't take it away. The technology exists, it's a thing. Well, you can influence its development and its forward direction, but if you're going to sit out, you're just going to allow...
1:23:15You're going to allow it to go on without you, and sooner or later, you're going to be forced to come into the future. You will be dragged kicking and screaming, whether you like it or not, into the future. The future is just happening with or without you. Sorry. These things exist. You should try to understand them. And fact is, crypto is our biggest hedge against surveillance, AI, you know, mega machine that Harry was talking about. You have to really think about the semiconductors. The production of semiconductors globally is like a giant pipeline that stretches all around the globe. And all of the fucking... All of the world's nations are working together to maintain this thing. It's literally the peak of, like, human production and engineering. It's very crazy if you think about it. There is very little or no... There are, like, actually points in it that are not duplicated. I mean, so if that's lost, literally, semiconductor production just stops. It's why, you know...
1:24:32For example, Taiwan is so important. Like, who controls that controls semiconductors, or at least a key part of it. The thing is, what makes AI successful? What makes AI successful is hardware. Semiconductors. So those who control the semiconductors control the AI. So who controls the semiconductors? Superpowers. Who controls the AI? Superpowers. So these... I had a friend of mine, he actually told me, he said, "Look, you know, you're using AI because it's convenient for business, you know, for whatever you're doing. But you are actually just putting all your trade secrets into that thing.
1:25:16And eventually, you know, what they can do is they can just take it, they can put 10,000, 100,000, a million times the compute that they're giving to you, and they can just rip off your idea and spin up a competitor." Yeah. These are things that can be like weaponized against us on an economic level. But not only that, you know, we were talking about Palantir, it's really worth seeing if people go on YouTube and they search Palantir AIP. That is Palantir AIP. Let me see if I can... Yeah, AIP, this video... I don't know if you can see that.
1:26:04Christopher CialoneA little grainy.
1:26:08Amir TaakiThis one, like a gray video. This is Palantir AIP.
1:26:19Christopher CialoneYeah, I got it.
1:26:22Vlad CosteaLike ape. A-I-P.
1:26:24Amir TaakiYeah, you must watch this video because it is showing that... basically, in a war situation, you've got a giant military apparatus and you know it's very difficult to coordinate it. There's all these like different units, different pieces of information. And you need, in the past, you needed like operators and groups of operators and all this like control systems, but now they can just get rid of that. They can automate away a lot of the expense of, like, having to maintain like a military hierarchy. There is another article that people should watch, should read, sorry. It's called Lavender.
1:27:09So, "'Lavender': The AI machine directing Israel's bombing spree in Gaza." So it's called Lavender AI, and it's by a publication, +972 Magazine. This one's very crazy. It's basically saying like how when Israel invaded Gaza, they actually used an automated AI system to automate a lot of the killing, a lot of the violence. So it basically is like a system that was just like... Because, you know, they have all these munitions, bombs, and, you know, they want to know where... It's like dirty bombs. It's not like targeted bombs. But they kind of want to know how to most efficiently allocate bombs.
1:27:57And, this AI system, it's like just manufacturing targets. And not even military targets, but anything to do with like administration, you know, the governance, etc. And it was just like a huge AI system directing, like, the entire kill spree. And it's from insiders in the Israeli, what's it called, Unit 8200. And basically they said like at some point, for them it like crossed over. For them, they were like, okay, this is like something inhumane that I'm supporting. I want to tell the press about it. And it's like several inside sources and they have, like, documentation and everything. And it's pretty crazy because it's an AI system.
1:28:47The third thing I'll talk about is the drones, like how the drones have changed modern warfare and we're not just talking about like a drone that goes and does something. We're talking about literally a mobile surveillance platform. Literally, a surveillance platform that can cover an entire country aerially. It's like a real-time Google Maps. And it's got, it's like fully automated, it's got AI, it's got infrared, it's got like loads of stuff in there. Anybody who walks underneath it can be eliminated. You're like, "Okay, I'm not a soldier. You know, so why would I care about this?" Well, first of all, you're not a soldier yet.
1:29:29You know, like, you don't know. You know what your government's like. You know, everybody's like, "Oh, you know, Western government, that's so far away." That's so far away from what we have now. I mean, okay, let's say Palantir and the state do merge, or big tech and the state do merge. You know, somebody... You know, it's pretty possible they start doing horrendous shit. They start kidnapping kids. You know, whatever, like, there's like an elite class, they're like, "Oh, let's import bioweapons."
1:30:02You know, let's weaponize let's create bioweapons to target, you know, traditional communities, to break up families, whatever, like, to disintegrate society more than they already have, you know, and it gets really fucking bad. Like, things are like already really bad, but let's say it gets really, really bad. It's like, what do people do? They're like, oh, we need to do something, but there's nothing left for us to do. We can't vote for anyone, you know, because there's... I don't know, it's so corrupt or there's no voting anymore or whatever.
1:30:35You know, and they're like, I don't know, people have been put in jail or whatever, like I need to do something. I need to..." You know, Americans, like, "Oh yeah, we've got the right to bear arms. Let's go do something." But you can't, because they've literally eliminated that, because they've got a huge mobile aerial surveillance platform, which is like fucking covering the entire country. It's like a drone system, it's automated by AI. It's got infrared optics. All of that shit. That's terrible. What the fuck, player? How are we going to oppose that? But then, second of all, what if you're not even a soldier?
1:31:15What if they're just like, "We don't like that guy. We don't like the way that guy walks. He doesn't look like a slave." You know, in ancient Greece, the Spartans actually had an institution on the helots... The helots outnumbered them 10 to 1. The Spartans were a very small ethnic group that was controlling this entire region, but the helots could never rebel against the Spartans, because the Spartans kept them in check. And one of the ways that they did that is they actually had an institution called the Krypteia, where they went out every year, each group would target one village, and they'd look. They're like, "Who is in that village? The guy who looks the strongest, he has the most swagger, he has charisma, etc." And, you know, let's take them out. They'd take out all the guys that could have some kind of, you know, rebellious nature against the Spartans. It is effective. It really kept them in check.
1:32:29And not only that, there's like stories... The helots internalized their slavery so much, it's like, I don't know, maybe it became, like, biologically embedded in them, that when the Corinthians invaded, you know, they would get the helots and they'd be like, "Look, you're free now. The Spartans, you're free from the Spartans." And they even asked them like, they'd be like, "Oh, you know, insult your master." And they'd refuse to. They were like, they refused to insult their masters, 'cause that's how, like, enslaved they were. So crypto is not just like, "Oh yeah, you know, oh, I want to buy some drugs on the internet.
1:33:14Oh, I want to, like, you know, send some money around to, you know, dodgy causes or whatever." No, it's more than that. It's like preservation of culture, preservation of liberty, preservation of thought, free spaces on the internet. You know, but it's good that they're, like, trying to shut it down. You know, other people are like, "Oh, you know, we need to stop them." I say let them come.
1:33:44You know, let them drive it underground. We will be forced to come up with solutions. I think we should. It's like, what's the alternative? Like keeping things as they are? Like, you know, people complacent, like boiling frogs? No, let's, like, make it happen. You know, it will force us to come up with ingenious methods, and, you know, people will be like, "Oh, you know, I used to enjoy, you know, watching that video on the internet," you know, like, I don't know, things on YouTube or whatever, and be like, "Okay, let's check out other video platforms. Let's check out other communication platforms which aren't censored." Like today I just saw someone was censored from Twitter. I thought Twitter was like a free speech platform. Obviously not. Like, they're censoring people for saying stuff on Twitter. So, you know, that's obviously not real.
1:34:46Vlad CosteaYeah, Amir, let's try to focus a bit on what we can actually do and the positives of this whole AI revolution and the privacy tools that we have. For example, I think we are living in the golden age of open source AI models that you can run locally. And I think something like Qwen version 3.6 is just mind-blowing. There's also Gemma by Google, which is pretty good. It's open source. There's Llama by Facebook, if I'm not mistaken, or Meta, whatever they call it. There's OpenClaw, there's Hermes, there's a bunch of these which are absolutely mind-blowing.
1:35:27And you can run them on GPUs that you already have, or a Mac Mini or whatever that you buy for your home computing experience. It's just amazing the stuff that you can do at home. And also, with the privacy tools that we have today, there's Nym. I'm sorry that Harry had to go, but Nym is incredible for what it does with the mixnet. There is also Zcash and Monero and there's DarkFi that's coming out and we have all of these tools and we have Signal and a lot of cool stuff that we can use today and we can just... Like, can you mention some small steps that anyone listening can take just to improve their privacy overall?
1:36:18Amir TaakiI mean, Chris probably also has some, like, stuff. But I'll just say, like, try Tor, Tor Browser. Look at Linux. Linux has really good privacy tools. You mentioned AI stuff, like the agentic programming. You know, I guess people are using Claude a lot. I use Firejail. Firejail creates, like, a little, you know, closed jail. You should run the AI inside the Firejail, so it can't access your computer and do weird shit. That's three good tips. Oh, I'm using a Graphene phone. Also, I randomize my IMEI number. I have, like, a portable router called the Mudi 4G, and I'm running Blue Merle on there. So that's something that I'm actually paranoid about, is them tracking our phones, tracking our location, using our SIM cards. They do that with the IMEI number. So you get this portable router. You know, you can buy disposable SIMs, chuck them away, randomize your IMEI. Graphene phone, Linux.
1:37:33This operating system level, Nym for the VPN. Tor is cool. You can access like hidden services on there. You know, there's a bunch of good ones, marketplaces, etc. Nym, you can access you know, the web, you can do web stuff. You know... Oh, the AI. NanoGPT is pretty good. You can make an anonymous account with an onionmail.org email and you can fund it with Monero. That's pretty cool.
1:38:08Vlad CosteaOh yeah, so NanoGPT is this interface, basically, where instead of paying for a subscription, you pay for the usage that you generate from the service. And I think you have access to Claude, you have access to pretty much everything without any identity tied to it, without your credit card or whatever. So nobody knows exactly who you are, you're just an account number. I think it's pretty cool.
1:38:34Amir TaakiYeah, so I don't know, those are my tips.
1:38:41Christopher CialoneJust to kind of piggyback on that, I think for, you know, like, non-developers in the space, I think even, like, tools like Fileverse for their own... For documents, it's like more of a private Google Docs type of thing for people to start thinking about, you know, keeping your intellectual property and your thoughts, you know, your business notes private, you know, a lot of this has to be done in stages, I think, for anybody. I mean, it was for me. I didn't, you know, I didn't become, like, an incognito commando overnight. It's all stages. I think it's definitely important for people to stop using VPNs that have data breaches. I haven't tried Nym. I personally use VP.net currently, but I'm not... You know, whatever you're going to use, Nym, VP.net, or any VPN...
1:39:47Vlad CosteaI think Mullvad is also good, and there's IVPN.net also. It's pretty good in my experience. Usually the ones that let you pay with Bitcoin or Monero or Zcash or something that has better privacy, and does not ask you for any KYC data and they generate an account number, that's pretty good, as opposed to asking for email or any signup data. Like if your VPN asks you for anything for registration, that's pretty bad because you already have to trust them with your real IP address, right? Because they are the ones who know. And they're telling you that they don't hold any logs.
1:40:28Some of them have sophisticated technology that justifies not holding logs. Others just have a policy where they say, "Well, trust me, bro, I'm not doing any of this." But it happened with, I think, NordVPN. It got breached, and a lot of people were using it. It was super popular like six, seven years ago. Every YouTuber was saying that he's sponsored by NordVPN. And there's also like this conglomerate of VPNs, I think NordVPN and Surfshark. and ExpressVPN, if I'm not mistaken, are just part of the same few companies that own a lot of services, Private Internet Access, whatever, just stay away from them.
1:41:10I think the ones that are good are Mullvad, Nym, IVPN, VP.net, and I'm not sure if there's anything else out there. You can correct me if I'm wrong. Maybe you can run your own VPN. You can just download the software on your Raspberry Pi and you connect to that one locally.
1:41:31Christopher CialoneI think it's even great if people get back into building their own cyber... You know, build your own cyberdeck, start becoming like an all-around technologist for everybody, because you really don't want to... It kind of goes back to, "Well, they have a gun," like Amir was saying, "Well, you know, so do I." Don't want to be at the mercy of whoever, really, and you kind of want to know how the technology you're using works. Even though it's been abstracted away, we see what the ease of use has led to, right? Like, you have to give up all your data, all your privacy, all your movement, sometimes your thoughts if you're really not too careful. I think we lost Amir for a minute. I'm sure he'll be back. You probably pressed it on accident. I didn't want to get too far away from the question, and the VPN question. I'll just keep going. I'm a guy, you know, and I'll just keep talking.
1:42:29Vlad CosteaYeah, I mean the point of a VPN is to deal with your adversary which is the websites that you're accessing, and give them inaccurate information, to say the least. Like, try to not tell them exactly where you're from, what your ISP is, and also not give them the opportunity to ban you or whatever. So that's one way you can use it. You can also use it for what the YouTubers are telling you to, that you can unlock different Netflix movies if you're into that. I think it's a bit silly, but it works for that sometimes. So I'm not going to knock it.
1:43:11You can also use it for flights when they use cookies or whatever and they remember that you searched for something before and then they increase the price. But you also should pick a good browser. Like, I think Firefox is amazing and has been amazing for two decades. I think Brave is doing a good job. And I'm not sure if any browser is good. So you have Firefox and Brave. These are pretty good.
1:43:41Christopher CialoneYeah, that's a cool shirt, man. Yeah, I use Brave. That's a cool shirt. That come in black, man?
1:43:51Amir TaakiSorry, what did you say?
1:43:52Christopher CialoneDoes that come in black?
1:43:54Amir TaakiYep, there's a black one.
1:43:56Christopher CialoneYeah, that's kind of cool. I like that.
1:43:59Amir TaakiI think the white is better because it's like a white base. So the black, when it stretches, it kind of... The logos look less vivid.
1:44:13Vlad CosteaYou made him change his shirt.
1:44:15Christopher CialoneHe's got it handy.
1:44:17Vlad CosteaI mean, I wouldn't mind if Amir took off his shirt on the live stream. Maybe it would get more views. Now we all take off our shirts.
1:44:30Christopher CialoneThere it is. That's how we're doing it. We're going to do the dance.
1:44:35Amir TaakiWhat's the dance?
1:44:37Christopher CialoneThe Zcash dance. Yeah, yeah.
1:44:44Amir TaakiThere it is.
1:44:45Christopher CialoneI like the black one.
1:44:46Vlad CosteaOh, that one is classy. I like it.
1:44:48Amir TaakiYeah, I like that. Oh, okay.
1:44:52Christopher CialoneThat's cool. The white one's cool. I'm just more... Okay, I guess the black is better.
1:44:57Vlad CosteaCongratulations on getting in shape, Amir. I know you've been working on it.
1:45:04Amir TaakiI mean, to be honest, I've been in shape a long time. I've just been losing weight recently. I switched. But when you lose weight, people suddenly notice you're not fat. You've actually got a lot of muscle underneath. I've been muscular quite a long time.
1:45:21Christopher CialoneJust pop up. Nice view.
1:45:25Vlad CosteaAren't you doxing your location right now? Or is everything like a virtual background?
1:45:33Amir TaakiYou didn't hear me?
1:45:36Vlad CosteaWhat did you say? Aren't you doxing your location right now?
1:45:40Amir TaakiI mean, random people on the internet go, "Can I come visit you?" And I'm like, "Yeah, sure, here's my address." Sorry. Wait, I'll be...
1:45:53Vlad CosteaI think we lost him again.
1:45:55Christopher CialoneYeah, I think something happens where it freezes and then just dies completely. Yeah.
1:46:01Vlad CosteaHe's gonna be back. This is entertaining, like, I can't recall a single boring interview with Amir. I think this is the third one maybe that I do with him.
1:46:11Christopher CialoneIt's, you know, it's really not strange, but you know how synchronicity works. On the way back from where I was coming from last night, I had his talk on, like his most recent talk on YouTube. Instead of listening to music, I was listening to him talk about DarkFi. And it's just, like, kind of surreal to, you know, just speak with him for the first time the very next day. It's just weird how the universe puts things in your path sometimes. Yeah, man.
1:46:42Vlad CosteaIt's very spontaneous. Yesterday I was thinking I was going to interview Zach from Foundation Devices to talk about hardware wallets. And then he told me, you know, maybe we should do it next week. And then I was like, oh, no, I need a guest for today. And I ended up having three of them. I really like this outcome. I think it worked.
1:47:02Christopher CialoneYes, very cool. I wish we could have kept Harry for a couple more minutes. He's a wealth of knowledge, really. Very articulate.
1:47:14Vlad CosteaOh yeah, and he's been an activist for all sorts of privacy stuff for a long time. So I have great respect for him, especially given his background. It would be so easy for Harry to sell out.
1:47:27Christopher CialoneRight. Oh, and here's Amir.
1:47:30Amir TaakiSorry about that.
1:47:31Vlad CosteaIt's all good, sir. So, did you guys like Zcash? Do you want to receive some from Cake Wallet?
1:47:38Christopher CialoneThat'd be awesome. Free money?
1:47:41Vlad CosteaIt's shielded.
1:47:43Amir TaakiI was just with a Zcash guy.
1:47:48Vlad CosteaWhat was that?
1:47:50Amir TaakiI was just hanging out with a Zcash guy.
1:47:53Vlad CosteaCan you tell us who it was, or is that confidential?
1:47:58Amir TaakiI don't know if he wants me to tell. I'll have to ask him.
1:48:03Vlad CosteaThat's fine. Yeah. I actually met Zooko when I visited the US two months ago.
1:48:12Amir TaakiOh, how was the US? Where did you go in the US?
1:48:17Vlad CosteaWhere? Well, Denver. It was the Ethereum Denver conference which happened to have a Bitcoin stage in the middle of it.
1:48:27Amir TaakiOh, how was ETH Denver? I've heard it's like a very big, popular conference. I've never been able to go to the US.
1:48:37Vlad CosteaI mean, it was one of the smallest. They were talking about having like three, four times fewer attendees compared to last year. And it was also desolating that everyone's talking, especially in the Ethereum space, about AI and agents using the technology. So it seems like they gave up on making anything useful for humans. They're like, "Okay, we tried, the humans don't want it. Let's just build this for agents." And I don't know, we're kind of missing the point. We're drifting a bit.
1:49:10Amir TaakiI mean, I think Ethereum, though... Originally, the concept of a DAO was not actually, like, people voting in a thing. It was actually, like, agents controlling a treasury. And Ethereum was, like, for a long time, they were really into this idea of, like, using incentives and, like, rational kind of, I don't know what you call it, like, tokenomic kind of systems. I mean, that's the whole thing Glen Weyl was doing, so, like, engineer societies, before they kind of gave up on it. So if they're kind of going back to that kind of talk, it wouldn't be out of place. Let's put it that way. But yeah, I get what you're saying. I mean, they put out there, like, Manchester or something, so surely they should be doing that.
1:50:08Christopher CialoneRight, how are we doing this? We're just holding it up to the thing or what are we doing?
1:50:13Vlad CosteaIf you have Cake Wallet with a Zcash wallet, then you can try to show me your QR code and I'll try to scan it.
1:50:22Amir TaakiThe thing is, I'm using Graphene. So if I go to my Cake Wallet, I'm gonna get...
1:50:29Vlad CosteaCan you move it a bit towards you, so it focuses better? Yeah.
1:50:36Amir TaakiThis stream will drop.
1:50:39Vlad CosteaIt's blurry, still.
1:50:40Christopher CialoneStill blurry?
1:50:41Amir TaakiLike that?
1:50:42Vlad CosteaKeep it closer to yourself, 'cause I think the camera is out of focus when you get things too close to it. But still, it's blurry.
1:50:56Christopher CialoneLet me just send you the address.
1:50:58Vlad CosteaYeah, I think that works better.
1:51:01Christopher CialoneSorry, tried. Does it work sometimes like that?
1:51:06Vlad CosteaIt does, yeah, it did in the past and I was like okay this is so convenient. But it also shows people that we are actually using Cake, so it encourages them to install it, even if we can't scan QRs.
1:51:20Amir TaakiI use it for, like... I'm using, I don't know why, I'm using, like, Unstoppable Wallet for Bitcoin. I'm using Cake Wallet for Ethereum. Strange stuff.
1:51:35Vlad CosteaYou're special, Amir, but Unstoppable is also a good one. I like it. It's slick, and it can have that Chad logo. Did you see that? You can have the Gigachad logo for your Unstoppable Wallet.
1:51:47Amir TaakiOh, I can see that.
1:51:49Vlad CosteaI mean the app icon. You go to the settings, you can change the icon.
1:51:56Amir TaakiVery cool.
1:52:00Christopher CialoneI sent you a message on... What do you call it? On Signal? Yeah. I just want to verify that's...
1:52:07Vlad CosteaGot it, yeah.
1:52:09Christopher CialoneYeah, okay, so here.
1:52:11Amir TaakiHow much is it, like, we'll get?
1:52:14Vlad CosteaWhat's that, Amir? It's 0.33, which is like 100 bucks.
1:52:23Amir TaakiWell, that's quite sizable. All right, let me figure this out.
1:52:27Vlad CosteaYou know, when you join the interview by yourself, Amir, you're gonna get a full ZEC. I promise you.
1:52:35Amir TaakiWow, that's crazy. But how do I do this? 'Cause I need to...
1:52:51Vlad CosteaOkay, it says 0.3 right here.
1:52:54Amir TaakiI'm on the screen with the wallet, but I don't know how.
1:52:57Vlad CosteaAnd Christopher, you should get it.
1:52:59Amir TaakiI'm not that smart. I'll figure this out.
1:53:07Vlad CosteaThanks, Cake Wallet, for doing this. They're doing this really nice wallet. And I also got to plug the rest of the sponsors. If you are into gambling, which means trading with leverage, you can try Orange Rock because they have a very nice interface with everything included. It looks a lot like what you find on Hyperliquid, but nicer. And you get really good privacy. Like they don't ask you to set up an account. They don't ask you for anything. You just download the app for Orange Rock and it works. It's from the Bitcoin.com team, who have been sponsoring the show for like a couple of years now. And it's like their new product. Check it out if you can. It's really nice. There's also Braiins Hashpower. You got your ZEC, Christopher?
1:53:58Christopher CialoneYeah, yes, I did. Thank you. Amazing.
1:54:01Vlad CosteaSuper cool. Without permission, and nobody can find it on a public ledger. That's really cool. Braiins Hashpower, if you ever want to rent SHA-256 hash power for any purpose, like maybe you want to do a lottery ticket to see if you can solo mine a block, maybe that you want to 51% attack BCH or BSV. Don't sue me, Craig. I'm just saying you can. I'm not saying that anyone should. But you can use the hash rate for whatever you want and direct it to anything that you want to mine. Check it out, it's from Braiins, which used to be called Slush Pool, and that's the first Bitcoin company and mining pool in the history of Bitcoin. It's a really cool service. And there's also a...
1:54:45Amir TaakiInteresting. Sorry, what's the name of Slush again? He was like really early in Bitcoin.
1:54:51Vlad CosteaOh, you mean the guy?
1:54:52Amir TaakiThe mining pool.
1:54:53Vlad CosteaOh, now it's Braiins, with a double I.
1:54:56Amir TaakiOkay, interesting.
1:54:57Vlad CosteaBecause he sold the company to two guys named Jan from the Czech Republic. And it's Braiins, and the two I's are the two guys who own it currently. But yeah, it's the oldest and most principled mining pool in Bitcoin. Really cool. LayerTwo Labs also sponsored. They're building the drivechain, which is basically a sidechain for every altcoin out there. They have an altcoin for assets like USDT and Ethereum tokens. They have a sidechain for a big-block version of Bitcoin which has a high throughput so 8 billion people can transact immediately. It has a sidechain for Zcash, which is fungible by default. And a lot of other cool stuff. Check it out. layer2labs.com/download is where you can try the software. Currently it runs on a Bitcoin signet because the Core developers don't want to merge BIP 300. But you can see if this is the technology that you want on Bitcoin and if this is the kind of future that you want for the network.
1:56:06And last but not least, SideShift, which is the place where you can swap what you receive from someone and you don't really like. I'm not gonna knock on the Dash people, but one time someone offered to send me some Dash and I was like, I never used Dash for anything. I'm not a big fan of it. I don't get what's the point of it. It's sort of like a sophisticated version of Bitcoin, if you ask me. And they're like, okay, just send it to me. And then I sent it to SideShift and swapped it for some more Bitcoin. It works pretty good. And the fees are low, the liquidity is good. Not available in the US unfortunately because of some regulations out there. But yeah, it's a cool service. Check it out, it's SideShift, S-I-D-E-S-H-I-F-T dot A-I. Thanks for sitting for my ads and Amir, I also need to send you some ZEC if you can figure out how.
1:57:06Amir TaakiI will give you the Cake Wallet, specifically the Cake Wallet thing.
1:57:11Vlad CosteaYeah. You can send me the address.
1:57:14Amir TaakiI've got other stuff, but I'll give you the Cake Wallet. It's a Cake thing.
1:57:20Vlad CosteaOkay, now it's called ZODL, it's not Zashi anymore. They...
1:57:25Amir TaakiOh, I have a Zashi. But yeah, I should upgrade to ZODL. You're right.
1:57:29Christopher CialoneThey rebranded.
1:57:32Vlad CosteaThey had like a very interesting story with developers getting into a conflict with the board of the Electric Coin Company. And I think this was back in January of this year. And the headlines at the time, especially from the Monero people who don't like them, were like, "Oh, look at them, they quit building on Zcash, and they rug-pulled everyone, and the price is going down and whatever." They started a new company, which is called ZODL, and they also took the repository and everything from the Electric Coin Company. So there was a smooth transition to the new wallet which is same as the old one except that it has a different name. And yeah, now it's not called Zashi anymore, it's ZODL. But everyone's still building on Zcash, don't worry.
1:58:25Christopher CialoneI didn't know the backstory to all that. I thought they just rebranded it because it sounded better.
1:58:29Vlad CosteaNo, it was a copyright thing. I think that there's a lot of stuff that Zcash needs to get rid of, like trademarks and whatever. They're like a legacy ball and chain that they need to carry. As the project gets more decentralized and bigger, it's only going to strike them back every time. I think last year in November or December there was someone who was trying to use the Zcash branding for building something like a shady treasury company. And the Zcash Foundation, I think now it's called... ECC. They sort of sued this person for using the intellectual property. And in a way they were trying to prevent someone from scamming, but at the same time it just proves that, you know, the project is not as decentralized as it should be.
1:59:32Christopher CialoneWell, they're on the right track anyway.
1:59:35Vlad CosteaYeah, I love what they're building.
1:59:37Christopher CialoneYeah, they've done a lot for the industry. Definitely kind of got the privacy pump going recently. Not long ago, whenever that all... You know, a couple months ago.
1:59:47Vlad CosteaI think this was back in October or November. And it does seem like privacy became more cool. When I was attending other conferences, they were talking much more about privacy and wanting to add features from Zcash. So they definitely started a conversation. I think Zcash was ahead of its time when it first came out. And the hardware was not ready yet, the cryptography was not fully baked. So they needed time to fully refine the product. Tornado Cash actually could not exist without the Zcash libraries. What it did was basically use the programmability of Ethereum to create something like a Zcash shielded pool using the zk-SNARKs library. So essentially, Tornado Cash and Railgun are just Zcash on Ethereum.
2:00:47Christopher CialoneIt's kind of an interesting thing. You know, they... What was I going to say? There's a book coming out for people who would probably want to understand a little bit better, from... I can't think of the gentleman's name off the top of my head, but it's called Zero Knowledge, it comes out in May. I'm kind of looking forward to reading that book because there's really not too much really good literature that you could hold in your hand about the industry. So I'm kind of excited for that book. To see how he goes about explaining zero knowledge to people who don't understand. See if I could pick up some pointers and pass that information along to others.
2:01:25Amir TaakiWell, when's that coming out? What's that book?
2:01:28Christopher CialoneIt's called Zero Knowledge. It's on May 12th.
2:01:32Amir TaakiOh, cool.
2:01:33Christopher CialoneFuck, that dude, what's his name? I forgot. I can't think, I have too many names running through my head, too much information, right?
2:01:39Amir TaakiNo, no, I got you. I thought you were saying something. It sounds cool.
2:01:43Christopher CialoneYeah, I'm choking under pressure.
2:01:47Vlad CosteaWell, to be honest, like if you pick up the old school book, which is Applied Cryptography by Bruce Schneier, you're gonna see that he does have a chapter about zero knowledge proofs, but at the time in the 90s, it was very theoretical. Nobody actually put that into practice. I think the best way to understand the principle of zero-knowledge proofs and how verification works is a presentation by Zooko where he's basically explaining how two parties are negotiating and asking each other the same question hundreds of times until it's assumed that there's no reason to lie anymore.
2:02:30Amir TaakiI think that he's using 100 questions, it's like a binary... There's samples, like some random point on the curve. But yeah, it's a similar principle.
2:02:49Vlad CosteaAnyway, you're also using zk-SNARKs, I think, for... I think you're using Zcash too.
2:02:56Amir TaakiYeah, yeah. DarkFi. Yep. So Zcash wrote all that code, which is great.
2:03:07Vlad CosteaI think you're the only Monero guy who uses Zcash that the Monero people really like.
2:03:14Amir TaakiReally? I didn't know I was liked by Monero people, I guess.
2:03:19Vlad CosteaOh, they love you.
2:03:21Amir TaakiOkay.
2:03:23Vlad CosteaYou also had the Monero-chan doll just a minute ago.
2:03:30Amir TaakiOh, yeah.
2:03:34Christopher CialoneHopefully some of the tribalism can go, we could come together a little bit just for the benefit of some of these guys going up against the system.
2:03:44Amir TaakiBut then you also have KPop Demon Hunters.
2:03:48Christopher CialoneOh, check that out. It's pretty cool.
2:04:03Vlad CosteaDo you have anything with Lara Croft on you? I know that she was a big influence when it comes to you becoming a video game developer at first and then a programmer in C++.
2:04:19Amir TaakiYeah. Also, that's my fox, dead fox. Pretty cool. And fossils.
2:04:36Vlad CosteaIt feels like this is a talk about privacy, but we're actually on MTV Cribs with Amir.
2:04:44Amir TaakiOh really? I was thinking to do more, like, kind of put up Spaces where I'm just hanging out and talking about stuff with people. Because a lot of people do it, but I listen to them and they've got nothing to talk about. Well, we could do better. We need to bring Ray Youssef on this chat. He always says crazy stuff. I remember last time, I was on the chat with him and a bunch of Bitcoiners, like libertarian kind of Bitcoiners, and he goes, "You know what crypto needs? We need a strong leader. We need, like, some kind of strong leader, like a certain, you know who. You know, a certain Austrian painter." And everybody in the chat started going... All the Bitcoiners were like... And then he kind of flipped out, and he went, "You guys just aren't ready to wake up. You don't get it, do you?" That was enough for the chat. And then me and Harry went...
2:06:10Vlad CosteaYou're cutting out for some reason, Amir. I think your signal is weak in this part of the house or something.
2:06:18Amir TaakiMy battery is about to die on the phone. My phone is about to die.
2:06:28Vlad CosteaAnd I haven't sent you your Zcash yet. But you guys, so let's do the giveaway to someone in the chat. I've asked people to pick a number from 1 to 100. And I feel like it's unfair because some people picked like 10 numbers and I don't know how to deal with that. Because it's not a fair competition if someone basically has 10% chance of guessing. Because they picked a lot of numbers. So should I disqualify these people, or should I only count the first or the last number that they mentioned?
2:07:04Christopher CialoneRound it, average it, to a number they didn't even...
2:07:08Vlad CosteaNo, that's too much work. Like, I should average it? It's true. If they put 10 numbers, I should actually add them up and divide by 10. No, I don't want to do that.
2:07:18Christopher CialoneYeah, probably the first number.
2:07:19Vlad CosteaFirst number is fair. Okay. So Harry said 98, if I recall correctly. Yes. What's your number, Christopher?
2:07:28Christopher Cialone77.
2:07:29Vlad CosteaOkay, 98 plus 77 and what's your number? Oh, he dropped. We're not gonna find out. It gives more people more time to pick a number. Okay, so this is your last chance. If you picked a number previously, I'm going to disregard it. Only from now on, the numbers are going to be counted. Right here, right now.
2:07:52Christopher CialoneHe's got to plug his phone in.
2:07:54Vlad CosteaYeah, he has to. But this was very unconventional and fun. I love it. Like, it's not like my regular interviews where we run through a list of questions and we debate the topic. It was all over the place. It's beautiful.
2:08:12Christopher CialoneYeah, I appreciate you inviting me on. Yeah, it was great. Very cool.
2:08:19Vlad CosteaMan, as soon as I found out what you're doing... I mean, I've been seeing your stuff on Twitter, it's just that I see a lot of people following the Tornado Cash case. I also see Lola, the lady from...
2:08:34Christopher CialoneThe Rage.
2:08:36Vlad CosteaYeah, The Rage. Yeah, that's the name of the publication. She's posting pictures and she's getting people to rally and really support Roman. And yeah, I mean, I do respect the fact that you're taking time out of your day, and I'm pretty sure that you could be doing something much more productive to make money or whatever, but instead you're voluntarily going to court to listen, to sit through these hearings and listen to what's going on, report to people, tell them exactly what's wrong with the US government and the way that they prosecute something which is related to writing software essentially, but their issue is that it led to some people getting privacy when they were not supposed to or whatever. And I think they're just trying to create a martyr, just like they did with Ross Ulbricht.
2:09:36Christopher CialoneRight. And then they threw, you know, and interestingly enough, it kind of just inspires more people. Not to do the same, but to maybe even, you know, to make the ecosystem more robust, even if they're not going to support Roman with their physical time or, you know, or anything like that, but maybe it forces some other people to build in the space, you know, because we have enough NFTs to go around. I don't think we need another NFT marketplace or anything like that. But, you know, it's almost forced me to attempt to build certain projects out that I feel are needed.
2:10:20And, you know, we'll see where it goes from here for me with that. You know, I enjoy educating and turning people's attention to things. And, you know, I'm lucky enough to be in New York, you know, in the belly of the beast to be in the middle of, you know, the trial and everything. So it's just like a combination of different things working together.
2:10:48Plus, I know what it's like to sit in a similar situation. Obviously not anything along the lines of a software case, but, you know, when you're all alone and you feel like the world is against you, even one or two people who are there supporting you can make a big difference. So even on a personal level for Roman, or whoever it might have been that built this, I feel, you know, it's kind of an honorable spot to do that and just give some sort of moral support because that's a tough situation, man. The entire government versus you, that's rough.
2:11:26Vlad CosteaI do have to ask you, what's your background? What were you doing before you became interested in the trial of Roman Storm?
2:11:34Christopher CialoneSo, I'm doing freelance work in just the regular, you know, web, and attempting to build out projects in the space, and hopefully something will catch on. I have a website. I build in the Solana space, trying to turn them into a more privately focused type of network, I guess you could say, just by building applications and hopefully they catch on, right? 'Cause that's really what it is, is getting the right attention on certain things. I have this thing, shadowranch.xyz. It's kind of like a cypherpunk gamified tutorial that teaches some Solana basics of how to code. It has gamified coding challenges in it. It's got, like, a little current events about what's going on in the industry. And right now I'm building an anonymous version control launchpad. So people don't have to put their stuff on GitHub. So we'll see how this one works out. I'm still architecting and in the early stages of that, but it's...
2:12:47More than ideation, but not an MVP just yet. Yeah, so I take shots, you know, I build things and hopefully they catch on. Otherwise, I'm doing freelance work for businesses in the, you know, that need tech work done. More tech consultant, I guess, would be a better term at this point, rather than freelance. I guess that's overused. It's more like tech consultant.
2:13:18Vlad CosteaWhen or how did you get into Bitcoin?
2:13:23Christopher CialoneSure. So, I first heard about Bitcoin in 2012. No technical background. I was doing PI work at the time. I was a private investigator. And I heard Charlie Shrem speak one day, and then I got myself down to the Bitcoin storefront, I guess it was the Bitcoin Magazine storefront on Wall Street. And, like, threw everything I had into understanding what was going on with Bitcoin. I had no... Like, I didn't know how to code an HTML page, you know. Like, I had no idea. I had no clue. So it took me about three weeks to figure out how to even obtain Bitcoin. And it wasn't Silk Road that necessarily drew me to it. It was the further-reaching implications. I always had like a problem with the banks, you know, because we just watched what was going on with the housing crisis, and I really turned a lot of my attention toward this space.
2:14:28Vlad CosteaI'm just curious because at the time there was like a Bitcoin Center in New York. Did you meet with any of the guys, like Nick Spanos? And there was also Naomi Brockwell and Peter Vessenes, I think, was also there.
2:14:44Christopher CialoneSo the one person that I remember meeting was Charlie, that stuck out. Yeah, Charlie Shrem. And my head was kind of... I guess I was in my late 20s. I had a lot of stuff going on at that point that was not Bitcoin. And it was just like a more confusing time for me. It wasn't until a couple of years later, more than a couple, that I really turned my attention toward building, learning how to develop software on my own, on a very... Obviously, you have to begin how you begin and then just gradually build up.
2:15:18And I felt like the space, you know, you can only complain so long, right? Like, "Oh, we need somebody to do this. Somebody should be doing this." So I just started doing it. You know, like somebody should be saying something. I'll say something. Someone should go here. I'll go here. This needs to be built. I'll try to build it and see if it sticks. So that's what I devote kind of all my free time to. I've had some, you know, grant money to keep certain projects going, other things die on the vine. You know, hopefully could come back to it later or it's just a shit idea and it dies, you know. Yeah, so that's where I'm at with this.
2:16:02Vlad CosteaYeah, Bitcoin in 2012 2013 was really something else. There's a really good documentary that's out there. After watching this, you should really go on YouTube, I think, I think it's also on Netflix and a bunch of other streaming services. It's called The Rise and Rise of Bitcoin. And it's amazing. It shows you all of these figures, all of these OGs who talk openly about their motivations. I think if you really listen to it and you get their ideological background and their whole purpose for being involved in this movement you're going to realize that nothing much has changed over the years. Like, you're going to find the exact same discourse today on Twitter, or from people who are just discovering Bitcoin and they're learning about it. It's amazing that nothing much has changed, but at the same time it's kind of sad that the network has not improved in a significant way.
2:17:01Christopher CialoneYou know, I'm sure you feel the same way. When I read Hijacking Bitcoin, literally, like, when it first came out, because Roger, really, his line of thought kind of helped guide my thought process around certain things. I identified with it. And, you know, I read Hijacking Bitcoin and it was almost like your childhood sweetheart, like, hey, you know, going steady with the guy next door. It was like, what? You know, like, almost earth-shattering. Like, oh my God. You know, you could see little cracks and kind of ignored it, but putting everything together was like, all right. You know, this has to go a different way, but it's all wide open. Let's get this ZEC to Amir, 'cause I'll talk for the next six hours.
2:17:57Vlad CosteaYeah, so Amir actually sent me his address in a private message before he joined again. I'm gonna swipe the screen. And now he's gonna get his 100 bucks of Zcash. Congratulations, sir.
2:18:13Christopher CialoneNice.
2:18:14Vlad CosteaAmir must also pick a number from 1 to 100. I think Harry picked 98. You, Christopher, picked 77.
2:18:22Christopher CialoneYes. We gotta hear what Amir...
2:18:26Amir TaakiFour.
2:18:27Vlad CosteaPlus four. Should I add them and divide by three, or should I do something else with them?
2:18:40Amir TaakiWhat do you mean, for what?
2:18:42Vlad CosteaBecause Harry picked a number, Christopher picked a number, and you picked a number, and I need to turn these three numbers into one. Am I going to do an average, or should I deduct from it?
2:18:53Amir TaakiWhat if you get a decimal?
2:18:55Vlad CosteaWhat's that?
2:18:56Amir TaakiWhat if you get a decimal?
2:18:57Vlad CosteaWhat decimal? Oh, it doesn't matter, I just pick the closest one from the chat, so...
2:19:06Amir TaakiYeah, but what if it's 0.5? Do you round up or round down?
2:19:09Vlad CosteaI'm just gonna pick two winners if they have the two numbers that...
2:19:15Amir TaakiTake the average. Take the average.
2:19:20Vlad CosteaI'll do the average. So 98 plus 77 plus 4. You can see it on my screen, I hope. There it is. Equals 179, which is not divisible by 3. It's 59.6666666667. So...
2:19:40Christopher CialoneI mean, you've got to round up. I guess it's 60.
2:19:43Vlad CosteaIt's 60. So let's see if anyone said 60 in the chat. I guess this is the last message which I'll be accepting. Someone said 100. How could it be 100, man? Like, they picked numbers which are not even close. Someone said 62, which is the closest so far. There's another... Oh, there's a 60. Okay, Think Big Stories said 60.
2:20:09Amir TaakiHow many people are in the group chat?
2:20:11Vlad CosteaI think that's the winner. Nobody else, as far as I can tell, said 60. There's a 64, but no. You gotta pick 60, man. There's a person who picked 60, and I gotta check if there was anyone else earlier who did this. As far as I can tell... No. But I keep scrolling. Okay, I got to the point where I said that I'm not gonna consider anymore. Yeah, so this is the winner. Think Big Stories, congratulations. You won one whole Zcash.
2:20:51Christopher CialoneGood score, Think. Very nice.
2:20:54Vlad CosteaYou're a rich person. Okay, so I'm gonna contact you, I'm gonna figure out a way to reach out to you, so I'm sure that there will be impersonators or whatever. Amir is celebrating.
2:21:10Amir TaakiThat's how we celebrate in my part of the world. Check it out.
2:21:20Christopher CialoneI think you're testing.
2:21:31Vlad CosteaMan, for someone who's on lists and gets detained every time he travels, you're having way too much fun.
2:21:37Amir TaakiI mean, I'm on a live stream.
2:21:42Christopher CialoneJust to be informal.
2:21:44Amir TaakiFor all the others. So, I'm trying to keep morale high for our online army, our Pepe army. So when we do raids, the raids will overwhelm the enemy and trample them underfoot.
2:22:05Christopher CialoneI just want to point out great graphic design with the characters. I was very impressed with that, by the way.
2:22:14Vlad CosteaThank you very much. Have you seen it, Amir? Have I sent it to you? Yeah, I have.
2:22:18Amir TaakiThey're the little vampires.
2:22:20Vlad CosteaOh, yeah.
2:22:21Amir TaakiIs that 'cause we're in Romania?
2:22:23Vlad CosteaYes, you are.
2:22:25Amir TaakiOh, damn.
2:22:26Christopher CialoneFull with the hat and everything.
2:22:29Amir TaakiI thought that was an unfair stereotype, like, it's actually true. Interesting.
2:22:38Vlad CosteaI mean, where do you think that these global elites got their inspiration from?
2:22:45Amir TaakiI don't know. Ba'al worship? Ancient Canaanite religion? From the Lebanese.
2:23:01Vlad CosteaOr maybe they just read about there was this medieval lady from Hungary, I think, Elizabeth Báthory, correct me if I'm wrong, but she was known for drinking the blood of babies and bathing in the blood of young girls and stuff like this. She got arrested in her time. I think she was even convicted to a death sentence or something, for dozens of murders. It's pretty wicked.
2:23:30Amir TaakiYeah, very interesting.
2:23:31Vlad CosteaAnd she was like from a noble family, so it's not like she was just someone from the village who suddenly decided to go on a killing spree.
2:23:39Christopher CialoneI always got a kick out of that title, "noble." We see a lot of not-noble actions come out of the noble class. But that's another story for another time.
2:23:53Vlad CosteaI think the more correct term at the time was like landowner or whatever, because the peasants working the land did not own anything. They're just like...
2:24:04Amir TaakiGlobal terror attacks.
2:24:07Christopher CialoneNow the peasants can build decentralized systems and operate outside the purview of tyrannical governments. So things have changed in our favor, I would say.
2:24:22Vlad CosteaMan, sometimes I get so optimistic because we are allegedly, at least according to statistics and the number of us that went to university, we're the most educated generation, right? We went to university in higher numbers than our parents. So I have hope that at least some of us are going to make it big and do something significant and meaningful. We have all the tools at our disposal. All that matters is that we channel our energy towards building something meaningful. And we have the right kind of moral compass, which is also useful. But at the same time, it gets depressing when you see people you had expectations from and you realize that they don't care or they don't achieve anything. They just want to get paid at their job, and that's what they want. Like, maybe it will happen in 10 years, when they wake up, who knows.
2:25:23Christopher CialoneCan't wait on anybody else. It's basically up to us. Whoever us is, right? Like, we all decide who we are. So, it's up to us.
2:25:34Vlad CosteaI think vibe coding has sort of made me more optimistic. I realize now you can make your own open source apps for anything. You can use your old devices that are no longer supported by the manufacturer. You can go Richard Stallman, right? That's what he did. He realized that his printer was not working anymore and the manufacturer didn't care. He just created his own software and he open sourced it.
2:26:02Amir TaakiI mean, Stallman's story is very instructive on how autism is a superpower.
2:26:13Christopher CialoneYeah. I agree with that.
2:26:16Amir TaakiExtreme weaponized autism. Nothing can hold you back. You're like, "I'm going to make an operating system." People are like, "That can't be done." And you're like, "Watch me. Nothing's stopping me." People are like, "That's a mighty big task." "I'm going to fucking do it." That's what he did. Crazy. I mean, massive respect for him.
2:26:41Vlad CosteaYeah, he's the right kind of crazy to start a movement and to keep it going, because people complain about him. They're like, "Oh, he's so much like a princess," or whatever. He has like a list of demands and he's very difficult to deal with and he's insufferable most of the times but it's the right kind of personality to actually inspire people to do something.
2:27:08Amir TaakiGoing to deal with that shit.
2:27:09Vlad CosteaIf he was too likable, this movement could not grow in the same way. Also, the guy who created Linux, like Linus Torvalds, or Linus, I'm not sure how you pronounce that, but I think he's European, so it's Linus. Like, he's very toxic in his work environment, but it's exactly what it takes to maintain a very lean and efficient kernel for the system. I wish I could say the same about Bitcoin, but there's not much happening, unfortunately.
2:27:49Christopher CialoneBitcoin will live on through the other projects. That's the, you know, the idea of Bitcoin and what was made. That's how I kind of view the whole thing. It'll live on through other projects.
2:28:05Vlad CosteaIf you think of Bitcoin as Linux, and you read the white paper... Well, I did not get that, Amir, sorry.
2:28:19Amir TaakiLet's make a quantum computer and steal the bitcoins. Let's hack it. Let's kidnap the developers and take it down.
2:28:29Vlad CosteaI don't adhere to the second part, but the quantum computer part sounds interesting.
2:28:35Amir TaakiI'm trying to give ideas here, inspiration. I'm kind of an ideas person. I don't do things, just give the ideas. I'm going to do a terrorist attack on Bitcoin.
2:28:49Christopher CialoneShould do it live on Spaces.
2:28:52Amir TaakiYeah, they won't know what's going to hit them.
2:28:59Vlad CosteaIf you look at Bitcoin like Linux and you realize, okay, it's just a code base and maybe that the first iteration was just the blueprint for how we can build better stuff. I mean, that's also empowering. Once you get outside of the dogma that there should be only one network and all the others are shitcoins. But it's also discouraging, because you realize that Bitcoin is not successful because of the tech, it's because of the people who use it. And it's very hard to break the monopoly because objectively it's useful to a lot of people.
2:29:41Amir TaakiIt's so easy to troll Bitcoiners. They get mad so easily.
2:29:44Christopher CialoneThey're the easiest.
2:29:46Amir TaakiThere's no one easier.
2:29:48Vlad CosteaYeah, can you do like a compilation of trolling Bitcoiners, some, like, different angles?
2:29:54Amir TaakiI don't know. Just say anything. Just say anything factual, and they get mad. I'd have to check my Twitter feed.
2:30:06Christopher CialoneJust claiming peer-to-peer...
2:30:09Amir TaakiYou say Lightning is shit. That's like a really big one. If you say Lightning was a failure...
2:30:18Christopher CialoneWhich is objectively true.
2:30:20Vlad CosteaWell, you're gonna find a metric, right? If you want to defend anything, you're gonna find a metric by which you're gonna say, well, it's not a failure because they use it in El Salvador. And of course, you haven't been to El Salvador to see what's going on and you're gonna be like, okay, fine, you can take that.
2:30:37Amir TaakiOkay, do they actually use it in El Salvador?
2:30:40Christopher CialoneI thought they used custodial wallets. Like, right? I thought they couldn't even have self-custody. I think the state, like, state-sanctioned wallets. See, I don't know. That's why I'm asking. I really don't know.
2:30:54Amir TaakiOh yeah, that's what I thought.
2:30:56Vlad CosteaExactly, like you can use this argument and it works. Nobody can actually prove... You haven't been there, you haven't spent enough time in El Zonte, where they have Bitcoin Beach. You don't know how many people actually use it on a daily basis. And you don't know how many transactions are on the Lightning Network, which is sort of a privacy feature of it.
2:31:18But if you look at the volumes that the exchanges are reporting, because there are exchanges that do support Lightning, you're gonna realize that it's abysmal when you look at the businesses that support Lightning and you realize that maybe two or three of them are profitable and the rest of them are just living off the VC money that they raised a few years ago and they're running low and they need, like, a new angle or a new app or whatever to get more capital. That's also depressing, because I've had a couple of guys on the show who are running a very large Lightning routing node. They have like a hundred Bitcoin or more on a Lightning node and their expectation is that they're going to make passive income from the transaction fees.
2:32:07The problem is that there are not that many transaction fees that they're routing and it's not a good business model.
2:32:15Amir TaakiIt sounds brutal.
2:32:20Vlad CosteaSo from these points of view, it's a failure, but if you want to use it for some small payments or whatever and you don't care about the details, it's fine, I think. It's just that I think it has been used. I mean, the Lightning Network has been used to demoralize Bitcoiners and perpetually become more acceptant of custodians.
2:32:46Amir TaakiI see. Interesting.
2:32:48Vlad CosteaIn the beginning it was like, okay, it's just $10 in Wallet of Satoshi or whatever. Yeah. Next thing you know, people say, well, it's hard to run a node. Maybe you should use this custodial Lightning because it works. Strangely enough, I've had failed transactions with custodial wallets.
2:33:10Amir TaakiYeah, I had, what was it, like, some Lightning wallet. 'Cause I remember I tried to pay for something, somebody who was a Bitcoiner, they were like... I was like, "Oh, I can't use it," and he was like, "Oh, it's so easy." I was like, "All right, well, tell me which wallet to use." And he was like, "Just download this wallet. Use that." And I used the wallet. And then, like, a few months later, someone was like, "Oh, you can pay with Lightning." I tried to pay with Lightning. And then I opened it, and it said the payments weren't sending. And then I showed someone, and they were like, "Oh, yeah, that's the Ukrainian wallet. They rugged it." And I was like, "What?" And he's like, "Yeah, they rugged it for the war."
2:34:10Vlad CosteaOh, the Simple Bitcoin Wallet, I think.
2:34:12Amir TaakiYeah, yeah. So I, like, lost... I had quite a bit of Lightning in there, and they just rugged it for the war effort. So that was that.
2:34:26Vlad CosteaYeah, there was also BlueWallet that had custody of a lot of Bitcoin from small users and they gave like a few months notice that they're going to shut down their service and everyone who did not withdraw from their service basically lost their coins.
2:34:44Amir Taaki'Cause I wasn't paying attention.
2:34:46Vlad CosteaIt was the same with Alby, I think. There was like a scandal. Alby is another wallet that has both custodial and non-custodial options, but they shut down some service and they gave users like three or four months to migrate. And if they did not, they lost their coins and it was like a scandal, but... I don't know. I think Bitcoiners should accept that we live in a multi-coin world and there's different stuff for different use cases. And unfortunately, we're not going to have the one coin to rule them all, because Bitcoin does not improve to include all the use cases. We don't even get, like, opcodes to let builders do interesting stuff. So if it's going to be this institutional asset, you can't argue with a straight face that it's this cypherpunk project anymore. Yeah. I mean, CoinJoins are cool. If you pay from CoinJoins, it's also cool. But at some point, I think it's a matter of information, right?
2:36:02Because in the beginning nobody knows who these participants are. But as they join KYC services and whatever, they sort of give information about their previous transactions, and you can get singled out on a long enough time frame. Are you doing your laundry right now, Amir?
2:36:23Amir TaakiI'm folding these drawers. I just came back from a long travel, so I'm like, folding up. Let's see. I've got, like, no socks, no underwear.
2:36:42Vlad CosteaGood to know. No, I think the right answer to that is, me neither.
2:36:54Amir TaakiOh. We need my mom. I'm doing laundry.
2:37:00Vlad CosteaWhat's funny is that I had this conversation with Amir four months ago that we're going to do a New Year marathon. And I got sick and I couldn't do it. I was so sick, I think I had a flu that was worse than COVID. For 10 days I was in bed, knocked out, couldn't do anything.
2:37:24Amir TaakiWell, after I do my laundry, I'm going to get in the bath. So if you want to join me in the bath, the audience can join me in the bath.
2:37:34Christopher CialoneYeah, I'll have to cut out at that point. You need your privacy.
2:37:42Vlad CosteaWell, you know, privacy is selectively revealing what you want and he's choosing to show us, so it's not up to us to judge what is private and what should be private.
2:37:54Christopher CialoneYou know, you're right.
2:37:56Amir TaakiIt'll just be like me and the girls on the chat. All the dudes can tune out.
2:38:01Vlad CosteaYou know, Amir, I suspect that I'm going to have a lot more gay men watching the podcast now.
2:38:12Amir TaakiYeah, tune in. We're talking about something really important.
2:38:19Vlad CosteaI don't think it's going to be girls, just like there used to be a magazine in America called Playgirl, which was pictures with muscular men, and it turned out that the audience that was actually buying them was not the intended one. It was not ladies, it was actually gay men. Just like these... I think they have these calendars with firemen or muscular guys. It's not girls who buy them.
2:38:50Amir TaakiOh, really?
2:38:51Vlad CosteaThey prefer to read novels, like erotic stuff, not watch pictures.
2:38:59Amir TaakiI wonder what kind of porn girls watch. I should ask girls.
2:39:07Vlad CosteaOh, the lame kind, with story and very slow developing. Like, I've actually asked too many questions, and when I found out I was like, "Ugh, that sucks. I would not enjoy that."
2:39:23Amir TaakiYou can get your girlfriend to make you a porno, and you never need to look at porno again.
2:39:32Vlad CosteaI'm sorry, what?
2:39:34Amir TaakiYou should make a porno with your girlfriend, and you don't need to look at porno ever again. You have your own porno.
2:39:44Vlad CosteaI'm not going to do that to anyone.
2:39:51Christopher CialoneFellas, I'm going to have to cut out because I've been putting off a phone call. And I'm going to have to jump on it because I stalled them as long as I could.
2:39:59Amir TaakiYeah, I can't get my phone wet in the bath.
2:40:05Vlad CosteaIt's all good. Thank you very much Christopher for joining on such a short notice. I think that what you're doing with the case of Tornado Cash and also with the Samourai Wallet developers is admirable. And I look forward to more of your videos and tweets about what's going on. And maybe that we're going to do a one-on-one interview also when we have more to talk about. This was like on a short notice, and I got three people.
2:40:34Christopher CialoneFor sure. No, this was great and hopefully I could jump this project off by then and then we'll have even more to talk about.
2:40:42Vlad CosteaThank you very much, sir. Where can people follow you? I think you are CialoneCodes?
2:40:49Christopher CialoneYep, on X, yeah, that's basically the easiest way to find me and my stuff. I don't even bother putting this stuff on Substack anymore, I just put it all on X.
2:41:05Vlad CosteaThank you for your service.
2:41:07Christopher CialoneYeah, it's been a pleasure guys. Thanks a lot.
2:41:09Amir TaakiThank you, see you guys later.
2:41:11Christopher CialoneSee you later, man.
2:41:13Vlad CosteaOh, he left. He's such a character. I love him.
2:41:17Christopher CialoneI'll see you later, Vlad.
2:41:19Vlad CosteaOkay, thanks everyone for listening. Thanks to the sponsors once again: Braiins Hashpower, LayerTwo Labs, Orange Rock, Cake Wallet, the ones who made the giveaway happen, and SideShift.ai. Thank you, I'll see you in the next one and stay tuned for more cool stuff.
2:41:19================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: Whisper-Large-V3 (NanoGPT) transcript with automatic diarization, reconciled in a three-way word-level vote against the YouTube livestream's automatic captions (offset +28.4 s, constant) and a full local faster-whisper small.en pass, with doubtful, dropped and hallucinated stretches (many "Subtitles by the Amara.org community", "Thanks for watching", a made-up "I'm a senior at the University of Michigan" self-introduction, "This is a podcast about the Bitcoin takeover podcast", repeated "Amir Talaq" loops) removed and the speech they replaced restored from the captions and local medium.en clips. Speaker labels checked with local TitaNet speaker embeddings and caption turn markers and fixed by hand (Vlad Costea, Amir Taaki, Harry Halpin, Christopher Cialone), including the crosstalk in the Zcash giveaway, QR-code and number-picking segments. Names and jargon checked against the episode article and the web (DarkFi, Nym, Palantir, Alex Karp, The Technological Republic, Len Sassaman, Hal Finney, Samourai Wallet, Roman Storm, Alexey Pertsev, Tornado Cash, Bitcoin Fog, Ross Ulbricht, Roger Ver, Ray Youssef, Operation Chokepoint 2.0, Zcash, ZODL/Zashi, Electric Coin Company, Zcash Foundation, Zooko, Monero, Cake Wallet, Mercury Wallet, Wasabi Wallet, Wallet of Satoshi, BlueWallet, Alby, +972 Magazine, Lavender, Unit 8200, Krypteia, Qwen, Gemma, OpenClaw, Firejail, GrapheneOS, Mudi, NanoGPT, Fileverse, Mullvad, IVPN, Glen Weyl, Foundation Devices, Monero Utopia, Applied Cryptography, Charlie Shrem, Naomi Brockwell, The Rage, Elizabeth Báthory, Braiins Hashpower, LayerTwo Labs, Orange Rock, SideShift.ai). Light clean verbatim: ums, false starts and stutters removed; factual slips by speakers are kept as spoken. Intro music omitted. Remaining doubtful words are marked best guess.