S17 E27: Kieran Mesquka on Railgun & Building Privacy
Search this conversation
0:44Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 17, Episode 27. We are live with Kieran Mesquka. And this episode is sponsored by Orange Rock, Cake Wallet, SideShift.ai, LayerTwo Labs. And it's really good to have you, Kieran. We have been talking about doing this interview for about one year, I think, and you finally found the time. And we got to talk about your work on privacy.
1:14Kieran MesqukaSure, yeah. Yeah. Finally found a time where neither of us are off touching grass.
1:24Vlad CosteaYeah, I think we met last year at DevConnect in Argentina. And at the time, I wanted to interview both the Tornado Cash and the Railgun people. And the Tornado Cash guys don't really want to make public statements still, and you said you were busy, and I just found other people to interview in the meantime. It's just nice that we were able to find this time to do it. Yeah, finally. So tell me more about yourself. I met you like seven years ago when you were working on something else. But I remember I looked you up and I think one of your earliest involvements in the space was when you were talking about a GPU mining client for Litecoin in 2011 or 2012.
2:16And I guess you were still in high school or something.
2:19Kieran MesqukaYeah, I mean, I think like my earliest involvements were like in all of this magic internet money space was just playing around with writing mining clients for myself or modifying existing ones and whatever, seeing how much I can make the hashes per second number go up. Considering I was using very unserious hardware at the time, there's nothing particularly impressive. But yeah, I think I threw it on like one of those really old, like the more thermally throttled MacBook Air as well. It was, I'd say, like intellectually stimulating, to say the least. Yeah.
3:28Vlad CosteaSo do you have a Bitcoin story? How did you first discover it?
4:04Kieran MesqukaOkay, I found out about Bitcoin just hanging out in a couple of online communities, things that happened to be sort of adjacent to like, you know, the sorts of places that you'd expect Bitcoin to go around, like more like cypherpunk sort of stuff. I wasn't exactly like, I'm not like super, how do you say like, I'm not I'm not really writing serious code at this point, right? Most of the stuff is is, you know, play play projects for myself.
4:33And so, yeah, like found out about Bitcoin, I don't even remember the exact place, but it was some casual mentions somewhere. So I looked at this thing, I'm like, okay, well, I don't I don't get how this would work. If there's like no central server, right, can I just go into my computer, find where this like database file is, and then, you know, edit it and like, add a couple of zeros to the end of where it says my balances, right? And so, you know, I had a look at this and I'm like, oh, why can't I do this?
5:13Oh, that makes a little bit more sense now. Right, like it's, you've got this distributed consensus, right through this like hashing mechanism and all this, right? Started to like understand some of the mechanics of it. That's probably what led me to writing very electricity-wasteful code, trying to understand like how the stuff functions. You know, like, all right, I wrote myself a mining client out of that, and it worked. It generated hashes, did the thing. So, yeah.
6:05Vlad CosteaSo how did you go from mining, which seemed to be your earliest involvement in the space, to building smart contracts on Ethereum?
6:16Kieran MesqukaYeah, look, I had a couple of like in and out, let's say like, yeah, I was in and out of the space a lot, kind of just kept track of it.
6:40There's not a whole lot that you can really build on some of the earlier chains, right? Unless you're willing to go and like fork a node implementation and potentially start your own chain or some of the like embedded metadata stuff that was going on. So by that, I mean like Counterparty and this sort of stuff, right? Like, unless you're like willing to take on like a fairly large undertaking like that, there's not a whole lot that you can realistically build. And then I remember at some point seeing the like Ethereum, like ICO, right?
7:32The OG ICO of ICOs, and I like I went across to this like random meetup where people had the countdown on like the various stages up on a projector and they were talking about it and I'm just thinking to myself like, you know, this I've seen so many like premines and all of this, right? Like BitcoinTalk probably has a new random coin out there with a couple of parameters tweaked, you know, multiple times a day at this point.
8:13Like, isn't this just going to get like dumped on everyone immediately? And we kind of missed what made Ethereum different at that point. But after it launched, actually became a real thing, we had the download and played around with Parity for a bit, had this cool little thing where you could, was it Remix that was just embedded directly into the, so it had a web UI, had this little like IDE that was embedded directly into the node interface. And so I was like, oh, well, this is cool, I can script with it, OK?
9:03There's no, I don't need to like fork an entire C++ codebase and set all the stuff up, right? And so I sort of had a look around what I could script with this cool new toy that I just found and yes, went on from there. I think you'll find like a lot of things I get involved in tend to start from, oh, cool, I can do something with this. What can I make that's like a nice little demo or whatever? It always seems to start from toy projects and then maybe they become serious at some point in the future.
9:58Vlad CosteaSo it seems like in your background you have a lot of experimentation and just playing around with software, but what got you into working on privacy? Because right now you're best known for contributing to the Railgun project. I'm not sure if you're one of the founders or whatever that means, one of the people who started the project, but you are definitely one of the most prominent people working on it right now.
10:26Kieran MesqukaYeah, so there's a lot of people that contribute to it, so I can by no means claim, you know, even like majority credit, right? There's a lot of people that contribute to this thing, but probably one of the more public ones.
10:52Yeah, getting involved with like privacy. So the thing that I noticed a lot, and it's a lot more apparent with Ethereum, at least to like casual observers, but you have the same problem in like UTXO chains, like Bitcoin as well. Like, all right, well, if someone asks you to, you know, you get them, you pick up the bar tab or something, right? And then split it afterwards and send some, you know, whatever crypto happens to be the thing at that point, send some of that to this address, right?
11:43And like the first thing that people do is just go open it on a block explorer and see what kind of, oh, you know, you're a degen trading this particular memecoin, whatever, right? And that's kind of cute when it's just random memecoin, like degen trading and all, but like this gets a little bit more concerning if, I don't know, maybe your like actual day to day purchases go on there, right? And like, ah, okay, Vlad, I assume you don't particularly like broadcasting to the world that like, oh, you live in whatever neighborhood and like you go and buy coffee at like this particular coffee shop, you know, 8am every day or like 6am every day.
12:43I don't know what your morning routine looks like, right? And like, okay, well, I don't think I quite saw the issue or it didn't quite hit me as hard when I was using UTXO chains, you know, that stuff is like, most of the time your wallet just uses an address once or should only use it once, right? And you actually have to do a little bit of digging on a block explorer to find, you know, to piece together what someone's on-chain activity looks like. But on Ethereum, it's like, okay, well, you just put the address in and everything's right there.
13:32And, you know, going a little bit like, later into this, when I'm starting to think about like, oh, well, I guess this magic internet money thing isn't quite this random toy that I was experimenting with, you know, years ago. It's actually like a serious project, right? And I'm starting to like properly understand what the purpose of all of this is beyond generating, you know, rage-filled threads on random forums about whose particular fork of a fork with like the block time. It's actually like a serious project, right?
14:27Once I start understanding what the purpose and use case is meant to be for a lot of this, you know, I'm just thinking, why would I ever use this in a serious manner, right? Why would I ever buy my coffee with it? Why would I ever, you know, like, lending markets seem to be a pretty big thing right now. So, like, why would I ever take out a hypothetical, like, future home loan or something on Aave if, like, everyone I ever interact with is able to just look that up and see all of the details.
15:19And so, you know, wanting the stuff to be generally accepted, well, it's just kind of obvious to me that, like, you need to be able to do these fairly sensitive financial operations privately. You don't necessarily, it's really bad if all of this stuff is just there on the internet for people to see.
15:52Vlad CosteaYeah, and as you were speaking, I was thinking of two things. First of all, in Ethereum, you have basically this address, which is associated with the wallet, and most people don't use multiple wallets. They just use that one account model address for pretty much everything that they do. Some of them even get that ENS domain, which is Ethereum Name Service, and it's going to become even easier to identify who's behind that account because it's sort of like a vanity thing where you associate, like, the random string of letters and numbers with an actual name in the business.
16:32Kieran MesqukaYeah, probably, like, the biggest clownfest stuff that I think is preventing, like, serious usage or, like, mass serious usage of crypto is just, like, I don't know, if I go onto my Twitter feed right now and probably scroll down maybe, like, a page and a half or so, find some random dude with, like, a.eth over there and, like, all of his holdings is just in that. Like, in his Twitter handle, literally, right?
17:06Vlad CosteaWell, yeah, some people do it for transparency purposes. I think Vitalik does that, and you can see whenever he sells or buys or receives whatever, a lot of people, I think, especially I think the Shiba Inu token, they sent a lot of coins to him thinking that he would never sell, which didn't work out so well for them. But as you were talking about this, I've also remembered about your peer, Ameen Soleimani, who is also working on privacy on Ethereum, but he started out, I think, with SpankChain, which was about putting adult content on the blockchain, and that did not work out so well.
17:47I think he had, like, an awakening at some point, being like, wait a second, there's no, you can never erase this and you can associate this with an identity, like, who uploaded when and tokenized whatever.
18:03Kieran MesqukaYeah, there's certainly a lot of interesting different ways that people, yeah, there's a lot of interesting characters that make their way into the space. I think, like, even in the case of like, you know, the example you brought up with Vitalik, right? Sure, I mean, you may choose to maintain some form of a public profile like that for whatever transparency reasons, right? And like, you know, maybe even if you're like, some sort of like a radically transparent not for profit, right? This is like a very compelling feature to you.
18:56But the thing that's sort of embedded in there, right, is you're assuming that there's a choice, right? Whether you get to be, you know, fully there on the internet, or, you know, you get to keep your dealings confidential, right? Like in Vitalik's case, right, like, I don't, maybe I'm wrong, and maybe someone can point out a TX hash for me. But I highly doubt that, you know, he's going and making regular purchases that might tie him to a time and place or tie him to like hotel bookings or he travels a lot, right?
19:51Tie him to hotel bookings or flight tickets or many of these sort of things, right? I highly doubt that he does that from his public ENS. That's probably for good reason.
20:07Vlad CosteaYeah. And I was going to ask you this because I know that before Railgun, there was Tornado Cash, which I think is still around. What is the difference between the two? Because as far as I know, they both use the zk-SNARKs libraries. So they're sort of trying to bring the Zcash privacy to Ethereum. And yeah, I guess, you know, there are some Monero people who think like in this very binary way where they say, well, if you're not being scrutinized by the feds and you're not basically on the brink of going to jail, then probably your privacy is not serious or something.
20:52Kieran MesqukaYeah, I mean, I think the thing that sort of differentiates, so Railgun's been around for going on about six years now, right? And so there's been a lot more, a lot of different privacy protocols that have launched in that time. But I think what, you know, the main sort of like differentiation between Railgun and other options for privacy at the time was you sort of had to either, you know, got this very limited use case, right? You could just sort of put something somewhere and then hold on to it for a while.
21:46And then maybe you take it out somewhere else in the future, right? Or you had to go to a completely different chain, right? In order to be private, right? And so like what I think the value is with privacy protocols is making sure that like you could do what you actually want to do on Ethereum. Privately, right? So like the things that like I actually want privacy for is like, if I'm making purchases or if I am taking particular positions in, I don't know, maybe I'm like some weird, like I'm some like, you know, fund or whatever.
22:55And I've got my little weird strategy that I'm deploying over here, right? Like I want to make sure that I don't necessarily like leak my alpha, right? Or whatever the case may be, right? Like there's a lot of like DeFi and activity and all on Ethereum, right? And if you like expect people to cut all of that out, right? Like opt themselves out of being able to use all of this like very rich, very expressive, you know, infrastructure that's been built in order to like, you know, have privacy when they're hodling whatever bags.
23:46And I think that's a pretty big ask, right? And so the most like valuable place that like privacy can exist is like right alongside where the actual usage that you want the privacy for exists.
24:04Vlad CosteaThat's a very diplomatic answer, but I'm still not sure what's really the difference between Tornado Cash and Railgun.
24:12Kieran MesqukaYeah, so I mean, Railgun as like a protocol, like it achieves these goals, right? So from Railgun, you can go and you can go and like make a swap on Uniswap, like supply LP to a pool, you know, whatever, whatever the sort of things you want to do. It's quite expressive in like the kind of cross contract calls and all that you can you can make from a private Railgun balance, right? And that's kind of the whole the whole like point of this thing.
24:57Vlad CosteaSo for the record, Railgun creates shielded pools like Orchard in Zcash?
25:05Kieran MesqukaYeah, yeah, it's yeah, Orchard in Zcash is probably the closest. Obviously, there's some technical differences around having to, you know, work with the within the limitations of the EVM. But functionally, it is very similar to Orchard, right? Like in Zcash, you can, you know, send and receive privately. And then, you know, you've got the unique thing that Ethereum's able to do all these like smart contract chains are able to do, which is like interact with like smart contracts and do DeFi things. But you're able to do that from a private Railgun wallet.
26:04Vlad CosteaSo why do you think that Alexey and Roman from Tornado Cash got into trouble with law enforcement, but Railgun does not have that issue?
26:16Kieran MesqukaSo I will have to say that I'm not a lawyer, right? There's probably better people you could ask this question to. Yeah,
26:33Vlad CosteaI think so. I'm just speculating. I'm not a lawyer either. I think it has a lot to do with the way that it was marketed, because these people don't have any capacity to evaluate the cryptography, but they do see the way in which it's advertised. And I think they were triggered by some random stuff, like they were using washing machines on their merchandise and whatever.
27:00Kieran MesqukaYeah. Again, I don't know. I don't tend to speculate a lot on those things.
27:12Vlad CosteaI think it's a similar situation with Zcash and Monero, because Monero Bros are like, yeah, we're buying drugs, we're getting out there on the darknet markets, we're number one and we can do illegal stuff and we can evade taxes and whatever. And Zcash, even though they have better cryptography, they're more tame when it comes to their narrative. They're like, yeah, it's privacy for anyone, everyday people, it's for grandmas who want to save some money, it's for protecting ourselves from blockchain analysis coming from China, which seems to be a very powerful political and geopolitical message that right now the Zcash people are sending.
27:51So they're trying not to present the illicit ways in which you can use privacy, but highlight actually the human rights use cases. And I think this difference in narrative actually shapes the way in which law enforcement also reacts to these projects.
28:11Kieran MesqukaYeah, I mean, again, I can't really, anything I say on that topic is going to be speculation. So sure, I guess, probably the only thing I really can say is just like, don't be stupid online. That's about it, right?
28:44Vlad CosteaI got to acknowledge that Eléonore Blanc from the ETHDam conference, I think now they're going to call it something else this year. And let me just for the record, I got to get this right. So the name of it this year is Common S3nse with a 3 instead of an E. Yeah, she's in the chat. And she said that you are Satoshi and I got Satoshi on the podcast.
29:12Kieran MesqukaYeah, that's, I don't know, I don't know where that started. It is a little bit, I find it a little bit annoying, because at times, in this case, okay, sure, it's a joke. But I did find a couple of points where, you know, I'd be a meetup or whatever. And then people would like jokingly bring this up. And then I just, you know, having being a sort of technical person around around the crypto space and being relatively early in finding out about all of the stuff. You know, like, people just joke about me being Satoshi sometimes.
30:14And there's been a few cases where people didn't realize it's a joke and thought I was seriously claiming to be Satoshi. And I know there's some other Australians that that...
30:26Vlad CosteaI was going to allude to that, like you're not the first Australian to get called Satoshi by other people.
30:31Kieran MesqukaYeah. Yeah. I'm unfortunately, not one or maybe fortunately, not one of those Australians.
30:41Vlad CosteaThere's definitely something there. But I think our common connection and the introduction that I got to you and the way that I found that you're actually a very good developer is through Naomi Brockwell, who's also Australian. And she's a big fan of your work also.
30:58Kieran MesqukaYeah, Naomi doesn't doesn't claim to be Satoshi either, as far as I know. But no, I'm a fan of Naomi's work as well. She does a pretty good job of making, making like privacy seem accessible to everyone, right? Like, it's like, realistically, I think, personally, I think the biggest privacy game that people can have, online, especially, is just being more intentional about, you know, what they sign up to, what checkboxes they're they're agreeing to. Even just like going through the like, most of the time, there's like, oh, a lot of platforms will be like, oh, yeah, we collect this, but it's totally optional and opt out, right?
32:00And like, practically, what that means is, like, how many people go into that particular setting, turn off, I don't know, targeted advertisements or whatever, just making stuff up, right? But like, the biggest thing that you could you can you can do to like, just improve your privacy is, like, yeah, just being more intentional, right? Like slowing down a little bit, don't just click through and like, agree to like, oh, someone asked me for my phone number at the checkout, right? Like, oh, great, I'll just automatically, like autopilot give it to them, right?
32:41Like, that's just small actions. And I think, I think Naomi particularly does does a very good job of like, highlighting these these little ways that people can incrementally improve their improve their privacy, gain more agency, right?
32:59Vlad CosteaI think one of the videos that really got me thinking because I wasn't thinking too much about it. I'm very paranoid about my phone. But I was not very paranoid about my car. Yeah. And when I saw that video, I was like, oh, shit, I did not think about this too much. Like, it's nice to have all the technology on board, and be like, oh, it's so high tech and whatever. But then you realize that it's surveilling you, right? And what these self driving cars of which I don't have, and I don't intend to buy one.
33:32But it's only gonna get worse. And I did see that there's a piece of legislation in the US. I don't recall exactly what it's called, like, the kill button or whatever kill switch, something like this, which means that the car will be able to determine whether or not you're in a good condition to drive and refuse to start if it deems you not capable of actually getting behind the wheel.
34:00Kieran MesqukaYeah, the one where they're like mandated that you have to have an AI model that like evaluates your fitness to drive. Yeah, I did. I did see that. you know, just like on that on that topic, sorry, maybe a little bit of a tangent. But there was some, some funny antics that I saw some write ups on where where people were basically So, like, as you said, right, like, there's a lot of electronics in these cars, right? And most of them actually come with like an embedded SIM card, right?
34:39And so there were there were people that were basically going through and like figured out how to like, pull this, extract the SIM card out of one of the Ford models or something, right? And then managed to like use it for free mobile data for an reasonably long amount of time. But that's, that's a little bit of a tangent. Like, cool sort of like, technical stories like that kind of interests me. But no, I think, like, okay, well, you've got like cars. Probably another thing that people don't necessarily think about a lot is like most TVs you can buy nowadays, right?
35:30It's really difficult to buy a dumb TV, right? And like most of these TVs do this thing called, like the Content ID reporting, right? The exact term evades me, but it's got Content ID somewhere, somewhere in it. And basically, the way that they function is they take the screenshot, the contents of the screen, right, run it through some fingerprinting algorithm, and then report, report back that, hey, you're watching. What's a popular TV show nowadays?
36:20Vlad CosteaI wish I could tell you. I don't watch too much TV. Probably something very dumb.
36:26Kieran MesqukaI don't know. You're watching Love at First Sight, season 16 or something, right? Oh, no. Oh, I think Love
36:35Vlad CosteaIsland is like a big thing.
36:37Kieran MesqukaLike one of these, one of these shows, right? And so, but like the thing is, though, it's not just whether you're watching it through the TV directly. Like if you plug in something from an HDMI source, right? Like, I don't know, if I plug my laptop into one of these TVs, or like hook up my phone somehow, whatever, right? And I'm watching that same thing, it's still doing the same data collection and reporting on me, right? And this is like, it's just these little things that slowly, I guess, creep into a lot of just everyday, everyday items nowadays, right?
37:19That just, you know, maybe under convenience or whatever. But, you know, even if it's not intended that way, in effect, end up being these, like, backdoor data collection avenues on everyone. Which, by the way, if you have your smart TV hooked up to the internet, maybe like, I don't know, disconnect it, or if you have the capability in a router, disable its internet connection.
37:55Vlad CosteaIt's really messed up. And even if you think it's a good thing, like you got to realize that. For example, I got a new LG television last year, and it promised upon setup that it's gonna get free updates over the years. And basically, you have like a software warranty for like a couple of years, and then it's gonna be discontinued, basically, to make you buy a new one. It's really messed up. Like, I remember my parents' CRT television, we had that in the house for like 15, 20 years, until we changed it for something with a flat screen. It's crazy.
38:33Kieran MesqukaYeah, that's how you end up with random, like, Reddit posts and all, asking, hey, why is my, you know, smart washing machine suddenly using this unreasonable amount of data per day, right? There's a lot of these things that just, I don't know, they just don't need to be smart.
38:59Vlad CosteaOh, no. But it's become so hard to find something that's not smart. For example, I was looking for washing machines, which are decent and don't have any extra Internet of Things setup. That's very hard. Like, why the hell do you need an app for everything nowadays? And also these robot vacuum cleaners, like if you want to get a good one, it comes with an app. If you don't want an app, you're going to get a very shitty one that maybe doesn't really clean well, and it's frustrating.
39:33Kieran MesqukaYeah, I should probably look into, I don't know, robot vacuum seems cool, but like, see if there's any out there which will let me run entirely locally or something, like custom firmware or whatever.
39:48Vlad Costeacool.
39:50Kieran MesqukaYeah, but I think a lot of this, right, like it starts out with, there's actual demand in some cases for this. But the stuff, right, like I think convenience is a convenience is a very compelling selling point. Right. And then it just it just becomes that like, okay, well, enough people get it. Now it's just the default. Right. It's economies of scale, and becomes very, very difficult to tell. Yeah,
40:23Vlad CosteaI agree. And now they just come with the AI label, like whatever is AI is also fancier. But also tracks you more, sends more data to the home base or whatever. And these tiny vacuum cleaners, they actually map your entire house. And they know your habits. If they have a camera, they can know what you have around the house, whether or not you have carpets, if you have pets, whatever.
40:51Kieran MesqukaThere's, again, another sort of weird thing that I saw. There was this wave of vacuum cleaners where, again, this particular model. And, oh, there's two stories actually I read. I know I like to read tech news like this a lot. But there was one where someone was trying to modify his vacuum cleaner, so he could come back. He could control it from an Xbox controller. Right. It turned out that this thing used MQTT to like control it. And it was going up to some cloud MQTT server. And it's just no authentication. So if you just hopped on a different MQTT channel, and you're like, oh, this other robot vacuum, you could just control it.
41:45Right. That was one of them that I found. And then there was another one which I found where people had remotely taken over robot vacuums. And then, yeah, they'd like remotely taken over these robot vacuums, and then they were like driving them around people's houses to like follow them. And then just saying like slurs and stuff out of the speakers. Right. So there's a lot of things that can go wrong if things are done badly. But even if things are done right, there's still a fair amount of data collection that happens only through these things.
42:34Vlad CosteaYeah, it's messed up. I think my latest frustration was actually with a printer, with a Canon printer that I bought like 10 years ago, which I tried to connect to my new laptop to print something out. And I realized that they are not, they haven't updated their drivers in like three or four years, which means their their device is not compatible anymore with my new OS. And I'm like, okay, so do I have to buy an old laptop now, just to be able to print something out? It's really messed up.
43:16But I did hear something good about the Brother laser printers, like the very basic ones. They're reliable, and they have very cheap ink. So I heard that those are like the real deal, something that you should get while you can still find them.
43:34Kieran MesqukaYou know, like, something interesting, right, like is, so the HP printers, they've recently started doing this thing where you like have a subscription for ink, right. And like that just kind of necessitates that you connect your printer to the cloud, in order to be able to print anything. And like, it sort of occurs to me, like a lot of these, a lot of these things are where you have the hardware, like upfront, is kind of subsidized, right? With the expectation that there's all of these different ways that they can kind of clip a little bit of value out of you over the lifespan of the thing.
44:28And, you know, maybe, maybe hardware just needs to cost more again, right? You know, you take my, take my money once and then leave me alone. Sort of deal.
44:42Vlad CosteaWell, yeah, that would be ideal. But at the same time, I did see something from Logitech, I think, like last year, when they wanted to also add a subscription plan for their keyboards and mice, which is really messed up. You buy something because you want to use it, not because you want to pay a subscription for it.
45:02Kieran MesqukaYeah, I no longer use any Logitech peripherals. Just found the like, configuring it at all, just ends up, ties you to their, to their like app, which auto downloads with the driver, if you're on Windows and then is, well embeds itself in your system files, so it makes it very difficult to remove as well. That whole like ecosystem stuff, it just kind of, kind of pisses me off, right? So, I think a lot of the time, whenever I'm making purchases, this is one of the things that I will look up on my, on my whether-to-buy criteria.
45:54All right. Am I, am I going to actually be able to like use this on my own terms or do I get like locked into a particular manufacturer's way of things?
46:10Vlad CosteaYeah, the point is that listeners who care about privacy should be very cautious when they pick something because it's become much more difficult. I don't know what it's gonna be in the future, but I also expect that there's gonna be some alternative for the privacy minded people. I think if privacy really wins and there's a lot of demand for privacy preserving devices, maybe some company will come out with, I guess, products on the more premium side when it comes to pricing, but at least they leave you alone and they give you, they provide the service without collecting any data.
46:48Kieran MesqukaYeah. I think, I think just in general, right? Like most of the reason that all these like data collection avenues exist is, is because they do, they do actually meet, meet a real need, right? Like I wouldn't be, I don't know. I wouldn't be buying a car with a nice like stereo in it if I, if I didn't want to like listen to, listen to music like this. there's like, they do actually, yeah, they meet a real, a real need, like actual demand that people have.
47:40And so trying to, trying to go, go against this whole flow and be like, no, like reject, reject modernity, return to monke, mindset, right? no, maybe, maybe it does appeal to, some of the more, hardcore few, but, like just it's going to be a losing battle, right? because people, people do value convenience and they do value, being able to do all of these things that, modern technology, enables for us. Right. and so like in order to like make things, like make things more private, right?
48:28Like have, give people, agency back and, like control over, control over, their lives. And, you know, person, right? Like, people, people like to go and say, like, you know, take control of your data and all, right. But like realistically, it's just coming back down to, like, you know, it's not this like abstract notion of, some entries in a, in a, in a database, like multiple times, right. Or whatever. it does actually just come down to, like your, your life, your agency in person.
49:07Right. and so if you want to build like a better world for people where, they do get to take their agency back and, you have to, you have to like, you know, sort of build, build privacy in where, there's like where the usage has gone. Right. you're not going to convince everyone to go, wash all their clothes by hand again, because, laundromats are like laundry machines are, are terrible or like as much as like having the wall full of like VHS cassettes or DVDs or whatever.
50:00And having a like movie collection, it's cool. it is also just, it's a whole lot more convenient to just pick whatever I want off, off the Netflix menu. Right. and so I don't think you're going to win by, trying to convince people to, like go back on these kind of comforts that, you know, in modern society we've gotten used to. I think you just need to build, build for the demand.
50:38Vlad CosteaMan, I really love the positive comments that I'm getting right now in the chat. Everyone seems to be so happy that I'm interviewing you and you're getting a lot of praise for Railgun. I think we should get back on topic and talk more about Railgun, but before that, let me plug my ads. I gotta eat man. So Orange Rock is the place where you can trade without KYC and without registration. It's this all-in-one application where it supports privacy coins, supports pretty much everything that you might be interested in and also allows you to gamble, meaning that you can use a lot of leverage if you're into that and you think that you're smarter than the rest of the market.
51:17And you're basically going to make it big. You can do that. I'm not saying you should do that, but you definitely can if you want, which I don't recommend, but check out Orange Rock for normal trading without leverage. That's much more like something that I would do. Also check out SideShift.ai, which is the place where I recommend you to swap your stable coins for BTC, whatever, Ethereum, whatever it is that you like. Just don't hold stable coins for too long because just last month there were millions of dollars of frozen assets in Tether and also USDC, which is the digital dollar made by Circle.
51:59Don't hold onto stablecoins for too long. I understand that people find them convenient for payments, but it's much better to swap into free market money and SideShift gives you a lot of liquidity and low fees specifically for this. Cake Wallet is a pretty cool privacy wallet, which gives you access to all the major privacy coins and also lets you swap in between them. And I think it's really cool and they're doing a great job. Even for Bitcoin, which right now doesn't get all the cool stuff that we have on Ethereum with zk-SNARKs, but might if we ever complete the shielded CSV work, but.
52:41In Cake Wallet, you can use silent payments and PayJoins, which are pretty cool. They're not perfect. They're more like deniability tools, but they can be useful. And you also have integrations with Monero and Zcash and swapping features and the ability to do that. You need to buy debit cards, which are non-KYC. You just need an email address and so much more. So check it out. Download Cake Wallet today. And last but not least LayerTwo Labs who are building the Drivechain. And for like a decade, they have been trying to bring the Drivechain to Bitcoin.
53:19Part of the design for the Drivechain was to have a dedicated sidechain with Zcash technology, which is called Zside. Right now. It doesn't seem very likely that we're going to get that in Bitcoin anytime soon, but there is a fork that's launching this summer and it's called eCash. You can find out more information at ecash.com. And if you hold any Bitcoin today, you're going to get the same amount of eCash in August. So stay tuned for more information because you can get some free money that you can.
53:53Dump on the market if that's what you want, but you can also use it with the sidechains to really understand what the technology is about and what the future of Bitcoin can look like or could have looked like if we never get the Drivechains. So thank you to everyone for sitting through my ads. Now let's get back to the topic of Railgun, Kieran.
54:17Kieran MesqukaAll right. Yeah. so what do we get back to?
54:23Vlad CosteaSo would you say that Railgun is very similar with Zcash? Like, would you say that they're almost equal in terms of the amount of privacy that they provide when you're sending inside of the shielded pool?
54:38Kieran MesqukaYeah, I mean, like technically, you know, the stack between Zcash and Railgun is, it's very similar. and, you know, I do have a lot of respect for the Zcash, like researchers and all, various, contributors there that, that, like, I think it's very hard to point to another project, in the space that has, pushed like ZK and privacy tech, forward quite as much. but, yeah, so like the stack, the Railgun stack is, is very similar.
55:25Again, as I've said, there's, a couple of like very key differences. so, obviously if you just, if you just take a Zcash, like implementation and drop it onto, the EVM, you, right? Like you can send, receive privately, right? same sort of thing, but, you're, you're going to miss out on all of the DeFi activity. Right. and at that point, well, why, why are you using this weird thing on EVM? Why not just go use Zcash?
56:09Right. So, yeah, like the, Railgun, contracts have, this ability to, bind in, arbitrary additional data, into your transactions. Right. and so you can use this to go and, encode, any sort of, sort of call, that you want. the, it's like, usually you call it like a multicall in Ethereum land. but it's just a, it's just a sequence of, actions or transactions. Right. and then, like mechanically how that works is, you have, whatever balance, right.
56:58You have a set of UTXOs in the, shielded pool. Right. you, presumably you have the requisite private keys, to spend them. Right. and so you sign this transaction and generate a ZK proof with the signature, to go and say, okay, well, I know I have a hundred DAI in, this particular UTXO. I'm going to take that, pop it into a multicall, address. I'll then say, okay, I'm going to take that DAI, put it through a, whatever DEX router, is, is my favorite.
57:45Right. and, we'll get, USDT or something at the end of it. pick whatever. Maybe I'm just like bullish on ETH. I'll get, get my ETH at the end. Right. And then, take that and then put it back into, into the, shielded balance, on Railgun as a new UTXO that I can then, do whatever with in the future. Right. and so that's kind of the like main difference between, Railgun and, you know, Zcash or just other sort of like generic, privacy protocols that have, that have come around. Right. It's really just comes down to like usability and access. Right.
58:42Vlad Costeano. That makes sense. Yeah. So you said that it's much easier to use Railgun for getting into all sorts of contracts. So it's more advanced than Tornado Cash from this point of view.
58:59Kieran MesqukaYeah. Well, I mean, Railgun's a full, like wallet transaction system. Right. It gets, it's meant to be, sort of a, the like set of protocols that a wallet can, like a regular wallet can use rather than, something off on some, like some separated, island on the other side. Somewhere else. Right.
59:33Vlad CosteaI'm going to present the argument from the perspective of a Monero maximalist. Who's going to say that if it's opt in privacy and the amounts of coins that are private is much smaller than the ones that are not. Then you're basically outing yourself and signaling that there's something wrong with your transactions or whatever, and you're going to get blacklisted by someone. Is there any mechanism to prevent that? And do you believe that? Enforced privacy by default is a much better approach.
1:00:10Kieran MesqukaOkay, so I don't think necessarily that enforced privacy is the way to go. There's a lot of useful things that come out of having a DeFi system like Ethereum public. So if I wanted to go and see lending protocol X, and it says that it's meant to be 2X over collateralized or whatever, well, I can kind of sum up all of the outstanding debts in this lending protocol and then look at the balance of all of the collateral and quite simply, calculate whether this claim is true or not at that particular point in time.
1:01:17And so this visibility and all into these DeFi primitives I think is actually very, very valuable. It's probably one of the things that sets Ethereum DeFi apart from someone just running the stuff on a central server somewhere. So I think having this optionality around it is particularly useful. But then there's also things that you don't necessarily want completely bare on the internet. That you do want to have the option to do things privately.
1:02:12Vlad CosteaI'm a hardcore Bitcoiner. This is still a Bitcoin podcast, even though some people are like, oh, why don't you call it the shitcoin takeover podcast or the altcoin podcast or whatever. My question to you right now is why do you think that Ethereum got this cool tech for having privacy, which is pretty good and works with the state of the art cryptography out there? And we don't have that in Bitcoin. What do you think is the missing element to get this?
1:02:37Kieran MesqukaYeah, that's the hard one, right? I mean, it does seem to me like the prevailing narrative, at least for a good amount of time in Bitcoin, was just like accumulate. At some point in the future, this stuff becomes more valuable than it is now. Right. I mean, maybe I'm oversimplifying it. I don't want to necessarily strawman that. But that is the gist of the argument. Right. And so like, okay, if the stuff that you're doing, you're not very active, you're not posting a lot of potentially doxxing information to the chain a lot, right?
1:03:39It's not quite as important. And so maybe in this case, you want to prioritize stability. You don't necessarily want stability in the sense that like, if something functions a certain way now, right? Like, I don't want new features or anything. I just want it to continue doing the thing exactly the way it does. Right. For however long, right? And so like, okay, I guess that's like a different priority there, right? But if you start moving into a usage narrative where you are posting a lot of like, you know, information to the chain that could be potentially doxxing and could be an issue for you for a numerous number of years.
1:04:35Right. Having it completely public on the Internet. Then I think the drive for a privacy solution is it's a lot stronger.
1:04:49Vlad CosteaI don't think it's only a cultural reason. I think it's also a technical one. We are definitely missing some opcodes. I've seen some initiatives from people who wanted to build something like this and they need something like OP_CAT or something like the ability to do covenants or whatever. Just some basic stuff that developers need to be able to port ideas or protocols that were built on other networks onto Bitcoin. And it seems like we're not really going to get that in the upcoming future.
1:05:23Kieran MesqukaThat does sort of like, I guess I spoke a bit very generally about this being a cultural thing. Bitcoin is reasonably limited in its expressiveness. There's like a number of arguments you could make that you can actually do a lot more with Bitcoin script. Then, you know, like it seems to be done right now. Right. But like it is a fact that Bitcoin is fairly limited in its expressiveness. Right. I'm trying to do things which are like overly say like anything like too fancy does get pretty difficult very quickly on Bitcoin. And that's like, there's been a lot of, there's been improvements, you know, over time.
1:06:28But it's not to the same level as what you would say a like Ethereum or one of these other chains. Right. I think that that's a fairly non-controversial take. But, you know, like, I guess just the like resistance to adding in like too many new opcodes and all these sort of features is again, it's just I guess it's a matter of having something like that that prioritizes stability over features.
1:07:18Vlad CosteaWell, I do like the diplomatic approach that you're taking. I think right now the closest we can get is with shielded CSV, which is built using BitVM. But as far as I understand that one also needs a lot of money to get developed. And even if it does get developed, I guess we're going to come down to this cultural issue because I think we already have Citrea on Bitcoin. And on top of Citrea, we have the Crest wallet, which is basically a fork of Tornado Cash. I'm not aware of how many users that one has. I haven't seen many people mentioning it.
1:07:58Kieran MesqukaI don't think it's popular. If you didn't have this sort of like cultural resistance to things, then like why wouldn't Zerocoin already be implemented? Right. Like it's or, you know, maybe not Zerocoin exactly, but like the original paper was presented as a way to like upgrade Bitcoin to have this new feature set. Right. And sure, okay, you might have some, probably have a lot of problems with the original design, right, the original Zerocoin paper. And like, you know, things like performance and all this were a big concern.
1:08:39But like, all right, maybe Bitcoin isn't the first to adopt this stuff. Right. But it's had, you know, over a decade of improvement since. Right. It's a lot more usable now. We still don't see stuff like that in Bitcoin. Right. And so like, I guess, you know, again, it comes down like, okay, you've got this priority towards stability. But yeah, there's a priority towards stability and you push a lot of the sort of like new innovation towards the edges. Right. And so, yeah, you brought up Citrea and these sort of like networks, which, you know, they enable a lot more feature set to Bitcoin.
1:09:38But they are also this sort of like, again, this sort of like island off that's, you know, periphery to Bitcoin that you have to go to. And to access that. Right. It's not something that you could readily access on Bitcoin itself.
1:10:06Vlad CosteaWe actually have a question from Eleonore, who is in the chat, and she says, so Railgun can live, thrive and give privacy to all crypto users. When Railgun deployed on other chains. Okay,
1:10:30Kieran MesqukaProbably, this is probably a spicy take in some circumstances. But I think as far as like, the largest proportion of, say, you know, productive usage of DeFi, I would say is on Ethereum. Right. And there are there are other chains that Railgun is deployed to, too. It was Arbitrum, BSC, Polygon. Maybe Arbitrum sort of approaches the same similar ballpark of activity to the like main Ethereum chain. But there hasn't been a ton of usage, right, off on these other chains.
1:11:38Like, there probably will be deployments of Railgun. Like, I can't, I can't tell you for sure. Right. Because, you know, I can't, I can't make that decision for everyone. It's kind of up to, yeah, but like, I can't, I can't say like, okay, it's going to be Railgun and whatever. But there's probably going to be deployment on other chains as, you know, usage elsewhere grows. Yeah.
1:12:16Vlad CosteaWell, it's interesting that you haven't mentioned anything about Solana. You said that there's Arbitrum, there's BSC. I'm not even sure if anyone uses that anymore. But what about Solana? Does that one have any privacy? I don't see too much concern about privacy in Solana. Yeah,
1:12:33Kieran MesqukaYeah, I think there actually are a couple of interesting sort of like privacy features on Solana. I think even their like token standard has a privacy thing kind of built into it. It's just not really enabled for many tokens yet. But I think the thing with like Solana is like doing things which are, you know, relatively like straightforward is, it's pretty easy on Solana, like launching a token and DEXs and all these. But if you start to get into some more, like, complicated protocols, like, I will say, like, technically Railgun is a reasonably complicated protocol, right, as far as like, you know, DeFi things go.
1:13:42This may be some, like, you know, L1 or like base chain sort of stuff that can, that would be more complicated. But yeah, Solana is, is very difficult to develop for. If you're going to be building a fairly complicated protocol, and I don't know that there is enough, you know, productive demand for those sort of things on somewhere like Solana. Maybe I'm wrong, right? Then maybe someone does go and, you know, port Railgun to the Solana VM, and then we see, we see a Solana deployment.
1:14:39Vlad CosteaWell, it's funny because I think over the past week, some people have declared Ethereum dead. And they said, well, you know, there's this guy, I think, one of the hosts from Bankless, he decided to sell his Ethereum. And also Vitalik had to address what's going on with the foundation, I guess a bunch of researchers left. And I guess it's just the competition trying to dance on the grave, which is not even obvious right now. If there's a grave at all, they're just digging the grave. And they're like, yeah, Ethereum is gonna go in here.
1:15:17And I was wondering if you've seen any difference in terms of volume in Railgun? Like, is there less demand for privacy on Ethereum as a consequence of having fewer users? Or are there fewer users?
1:15:33Kieran MesqukaI mean, like, I don't, I don't know. This is not, this is not something that, like, I necessarily collect, but you could probably look at a block explorer, right?
1:15:52Vlad CosteaAre we in a bear market for privacy? Because it seems like the privacy narrative is very strong right now. Yeah,
1:16:01Kieran MesqukaYeah, I don't think so. Right. I think, like, sure, there's just gonna be like bull and bear markets, right, as far as price goes. I don't really watch the price myself a lot. I find, I find my life is a lot more zen when I'm not hitting refresh on a price chart constantly. But, you know, I think, like, sure, we might have like, you know, bull bear market, whatever. But usage, I don't, I don't think necessarily usage, maybe in the past it was, but that like activity and usage is, is quite as tied to, tied to, you know, Bitcoin making an all time high as it was in the past, right?
1:17:06I still think there's, like Ethereum still has, still has activity going on. I'm interested now. Let's Etherscan. Ethereum transaction history in 14 days. There's got to be a better, I mean, like, I'm not really seeing any, any like meaningful drop off in activity. Sure. There's like, there's, you know, a fair amount of turmoil. It's like public turmoil right now regarding the EF and so on. But if that ever ends up affecting Ethereum, I don't think it's going to be in like a few weeks or a few months. Right. Yeah, I don't necessarily think there's a, there's a grave there.
1:18:27Yeah, that's, personally, I'm still of the opinion that Ethereum is the, is the DeFi king of chains. It has a fair ways to go before it is dethroned, if it is dethroned.
1:18:47Vlad CosteaSo what's your short pitch for Railgun? If you met someone, let's say, at a conference and maybe that they're into Ethereum, but they never heard about Railgun. How would you explain it to them in like a minute or something?
1:19:02Kieran MesqukaYeah, so Railgun is a, Railgun itself is a, is a protocol that allows you to have wallets that can, you know, do whatever you can with a public wallet, just privately. Right. Get to access all of your, all your favorite, you know, DEX and whatever other DeFi there is.
1:19:40Vlad CosteaThat's much shorter than I expected.
1:19:43Kieran MesqukaYeah. Yeah. I mean, like, realistically, like, you know, the tech can get, you know, fairly thorny and all, right. Mostly ZK tech does get pretty complicated, right. But like in terms of like... how someone would, would use it. I mean, to me, it seems pretty straightforward, right. Like, what do you, what do you use your, your existing Ethereum wallet for, right? I don't know, MetaMask or whatever. Right.
1:20:21Vlad CosteaAlso, you got a question from someone who's into Monero and also works on a decentralized VPN called MathNodes. I'm not sure if this is advertisement. Anyway, he says, hey, Railgun project. So basically, you've created a system where all transactions are assumed illegitimate. And your solution is that we as transactors must first prove our innocence before we transact. Guilty until proven otherwise. Sounds backwards and f'ed up.
1:20:58Kieran MesqukaOkay, that's suddenly very opinionated. Yeah, I mean, I don't. I don't know. I don't think like, I'm necessarily going to change a particular person's mind right now. Sure. But I don't think that yeah, I mean, I think that like, so the chain isn't necessarily like a court of law, right. And you don't have...
1:22:03Vlad CosteaSo for the record, is this referring to the fact that in order to use Railgun, you need your funds to be clean or not blacklisted by any of these blockchain analysis services?
1:22:16Kieran MesqukaYes. Yes. So Railgun has a system called PPOI. And essentially, what it does is it kind of like mathematically creates a sort of like privacy set, right, that, you know, you don't necessarily want particular types of activity, right, to be in. And so it does kind of say, okay, so roll it back over, right. So you have, Railgun has, like there's things that are on chain that can be cryptographically proved, right. And so, like what PPOI does is it goes and says, like, okay, well, if your transactions are...
1:23:34I'm not going to explain this particularly well, at this point in time, I think. So maybe I will just defer that to another one of the many other explanations that are out there. But I don't know, I don't necessarily see that as a problem.
1:24:01Vlad CosteaIn Bitcoin terms, the way that I see this is like Wasabi Wallet versus Samourai, where Wasabi at one point, they decided because they got warned by, I don't know exactly who, but they decided, I think, like three, four years ago, that they're going to have this blacklist system, where they collaborate with a blockchain analysis firm that feeds them the information about the blacklisted UTXOs. And pretty much everyone could enter except for some addresses that were linked to some illicit activities that they did not want to let in.
1:24:39Anyone could theoretically circumvent the situation by creating their own coordinator. But the most popular coordinator is the one that had the most liquidity. So everyone wanted to use that one. And of course, there are ways to also trick that coordinator, like just make a few transactions back and forth with different addresses, and then you could get in. But nonetheless, they did this. And eventually, the fact that they did this, and they were more diplomatic in terms of describing what their privacy is for, made them not go to jail, where in the case of Samourai Wallet, they were actively tweeting to Russian oligarchs and whatever they were saying, hey, come mix your coins with us, we're gonna when the Ukraine war started, they're like, oh, you guys are blacklisted, come use Samourai Wallet, we're gonna let you make your Bitcoin anonymous.
1:25:37And I guess that's what got these people into trouble. It wasn't necessarily the fact that they gave privacy, but the fact that they had this PR, which was aggressively targeting people that the US government does not like. So this is what made the difference. The way that I see right now, the difference between Tornado Cash and Railgun is that maybe you guys were more cautious and you added this filtering system. And Tornado Cash, I don't think they had that in the beginning. Maybe they have it now.
1:26:09Kieran MesqukaYeah, I mean, like, I guess, like, essentially, you know, PPOI is just a filter that, you know, make sure that you're not in a privacy set with stuff you don't want to be, right? You don't want to be in a privacy set with bad actors. I don't really want to have like a philosophical discussion on that, particularly right now. So,
1:26:41Vlad Costeayeah, I guess it's safer for me to say it. So technically, you're saying that your privacy is as good as Zcash. But I don't think there's any filtering in Zcash when you're shielding your funds. Like, it doesn't matter who you are, what you have been doing before, you can join a shielded pool regardless. So I think it's like a political difference in the approach that they have to privacy.
1:27:11Kieran MesqukaYeah. I mean, people seem to have very strong opinions on this. Going both ways. But
1:27:25Vlad Costeain some ways for people who just withdraw from an exchange, I think a big concern when you use any kind of mixing is that you're going to get confused for someone who did some very nasty crime. And when you have this kind of filtering, and once again, the market provides all sorts of options for all kinds of people. So when you have something which at least makes an effort to maintain a clean slate, they're going to have the confidence to use the service. And this is basically privacy for normal everyday people.
1:28:01The criminals, they can just go to Monero. These guys are happy to embrace this label that it's money that criminals can use. But in the case of something like Railgun on Ethereum, you guys are providing for normal everyday people who want to get into DeFi and not leave any permanent trace about all of their transactions.
1:28:24Kieran MesqukaYeah. I mean, again, as I said, I'm a very tech-minded sort of person. I like to work on cool technical challenges. I'm not really someone that gets into debates on whatever people's philosophies are on particular things.
1:28:53Vlad CosteaOkay. But let me ask you a question, which might also come to the minds of Monero people who are more conservative with the cryptography that they use. So zero knowledge proofs are oftentimes described as moon math, and a lot of people don't trust it because they don't understand it. It's very difficult to wrap your head around what's happening there. It's like the difference between arithmetics and algebra, where in arithmetics you can see every number that's being added or deducted or multiplied or whatever. And in algebra, you have formulas that you need to test, and most people don't have the capacity to actually see if that formula is good or like a sum of formulas actually lead to the result that they want.
1:29:42So there's a lot of conservatism in this regard. And do you think it's justified? Or why would you say that people should trust the moon math?
1:29:53Kieran MesqukaWell, okay. I think this might have been an argument earlier on where the real... The first real, say, application, major application of this sort of tech probably is like Zerocoin, right? Like Zcash. So yeah, at the time, being a fairly untested set of, or fairly untested technology, you could have the reservation. I don't think that's necessarily the case now. I think we've had a lot more eyes on. And there's been a lot more exploration into it. Usually the way that... You know, I guess, when it comes to the Monero specifically, right?
1:31:09These sort of protocols fall into one of two categories. And it's very difficult. Basically, it's impossible to get both, right? So you have on one side, where if the soundness of the protocol is broken, the privacy is broken, right? And then the other side is where the soundness of the protocol is broken, you get... The validity of the computation is broken, right? And so practically, that's one side. It's not private. The other side, you could have a secret inflation, right? If these protocols are broken. And so usually, the side that Monero took out of the gate was basically saying, yeah, if the soundness is broken, then we'll take the privacy being broken.
1:32:24But at least we know that there's not going to be any hidden inflation, right? And yes, I think that, again, to me is a reasonable stance to have taken at that time. The way that tech has evolved now is that's not really the only trade off that you're making anymore, right? So not only do we have stuff that I would say is a lot more battle tested and a lot more stable, right? A lot more durable. There's also things like, well, maybe you want to factor in, let's say, scalability, right? You'll find that, say, something like Groth16, which is used in Railgun, is a very difficult...
1:33:38It's very difficult to beat Groth16 when it comes to verifier efficiency, right? If you're going to verify the state of the system, right? Things like if you have your own chain in Ethereum as well, things like state growth and all on your own chain isn't as big of an issue if you have good verifier efficiency. Whereas on Ethereum, it's the same sort of thing, but you're measuring it in gas cost, right? So that also means that practically the effective amount of compute that you need to perform a particular transaction goes down.
1:34:40And then the add-on, the logical effect of that is that your transaction, the cost of your transaction can go down as well, right? And so there's all these scalability trade-offs and transaction compute cost, storage cost, right? And I think given the current state of where things are, that picking a reasonably performant, reasonably succinct zk-SNARK on Ethereum kind of hits the... It's a sweet spot for not being too fancy for using absolutely brand new moon math cryptography, but also staying relatively performant and relatively scalable as well as you would want a transaction system to be.
1:35:52Vlad CosteaThat's fair. You also have a very interesting question in the chat, which I was going to ask, but I think the way that Ruler, the guy in the chat was able to put it together is more eloquent and I like it. So he says, I'd like to hear about the things or features in the privacy space, which don't exist yet, but have crossed your mind.
1:36:14Kieran MesqukaSure. And I think maybe this would be probably the last question because it's coming on an hour and I would like to get some food. But yeah, I think the stuff that I'm looking at interests me most would be like, let's say, things like private information retrieval standards, right? So there's sort of this bottleneck when it comes to privacy protocols of going in and retrieving your balance. It's relatively computation heavy when compared to a public chain like Ethereum where you just do a single query and you get the value back.
1:37:24So from a UX improvement side, just generally across the board, I think PIR, there's also some fairly interesting EIPs that are coming out on Ethereum specifically. I don't know which ones specifically would win. A lot of them are still up in contention. But let's say the likes of EIP-7702, frame transactions and all of this where I guess historically it's been reasonably difficult to have a, Ethereum is very expressive and programmatic. But one of the difficulties or the areas where things aren't as expressive is just purely the entry point, right?
1:38:36Something you couldn't do historically is have a programmatically defined whether you should even attempt to execute a transaction or not, right? Like whether it gets into a block, stuff like this. Whereas the history used to be like, all right, well, is it a validly signed transaction? Does it keep their signature, right? And then do you have the ether balance to actually cover the gas cost, right? Whereas with some of these new EIPs, you could go and start to move away from like, okay, well, tying things to a particular key pair or like a public key hash and have some programmability in how you perform that particular step.
1:39:44And so for like smart wallets and privacy wallets, Railgun effectively ends up acting like a smart wallet in this particular scenario very similarly. It makes sort of the usability of all of this a whole lot nicer. All right.
1:40:11Vlad CosteaOkay, thank you very much Kieran. I appreciate the fact that you gave me all this time. I like that the Ethereum community is more open to adding privacy to the base layer, which is something that seems to have been forgotten over the last couple of years in Bitcoin. And before I let you go, I gotta ask you, where can people check out your work? Not follow you in a creepy way, but you know.
1:40:36Kieran MesqukaYeah, so let's see, probably, I'm not very active on socials right now. But probably just on X, Twitter, at mesquka would be the would be the best place. Yeah.
1:41:10Vlad CosteaWhat about GitHub? What's your GitHub? Is it the same?
1:41:14Kieran MesqukaIt is the same thing. Yes. Sure. You could, you could, you could go on and see some of the code repositories there as well. That is also a good place. Yeah.
1:41:30Vlad CosteaAlso, are you coming to any conferences this year? Is there any place where people can meet you?
1:41:36Kieran MesqukaI don't tend to plan conferences very far out. So the answer is probably, but I don't know yet.
1:41:56Vlad CosteaThat's fair.
1:41:57Kieran MesqukaYeah. I'm sure, I'm sure if there, if there are any talks or something, they'll be, they would be on Twitter. You could probably find out about them there.
1:42:10Vlad CosteaOkay, Kieran, thank you very much for your time. I know it's late where you are. I know that you haven't had dinner, so I'll let you go. Thanks for joining and presenting this unique, unique point of view, which we don't get in Bitcoin very often. And also thanks to the sponsors. Once again, Cake Wallet, SideShift.ai, Orange Rock and LayerTwo Labs. Thank you. And I'll see you in the next one. Bye.
1:42:10================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with speaker diarization (Guest A -> Kieran Mesquka). Compared against YouTube auto-captions (bitcoin-forks-research S17E27_kieran_mesquka_railgun.en.vtt / yt_auto_clean) and the long-form show-notes essay for names and dropped phrases. Speaker turns repaired from context + YT speaker marks. Restored Tornado Cash public-statements intro, Australian Satoshi joke handoff, Orange Rock without-registration ad line; fixed mid-sentence speaker splits (Bitcoin-story Q/A, kill-switch, ads, PPOI, outro). Names/jargon checked against title, feed, newsletter, and web: Kieran Mesquka / @mesquka, Railgun, Tornado Cash, Alexey Pertsev / Roman Storm, Ameen Soleimani / SpankChain, Counterparty, Parity, Remix, Naomi Brockwell, Eléonore Blanc / ETHDam / Common S3nse, DevConnect Argentina, Orange Rock, Cake Wallet, SideShift.ai, LayerTwo Labs / Drivechain / Zside / Ecash, Orchard, Groth16, PPOI (Private Proofs of Innocence), Wasabi, Samourai, Citrea, Crest, MathNodes, EIP-7702, PIR, BitVM, shielded CSV, OP_CAT, ZK-SNARKs, ENS, Aave, Uniswap, MetaMask, BSC / Arbitrum / Polygon, Bankless, EF, BTCTKVR. Light clean verbatim. Intro music omitted. Remaining doubtful words marked unclear in brackets where needed.