Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S5 E10 / Transcript
Transcript · S5 E10 · 2:35:06 · 14 Jul 2020

S5 E10: Arthur van Pelt on Craig Wright

With Arthur van Pelt. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:31Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to Season 5, Episode 10, which is also the season finale of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. As always, I am Vlad, but unlike always, we have a special guest. I mean, no, no, no. Like always, we have a special guest. I don't mean that. But we have somebody who's going to talk about a very unusual topic that's pretty much everywhere in the Bitcoin space, that has been avoided for a while, and that's very controversial. But unlike all the commentators on this topic, he actually looks at court files and he's very careful in picking his sources and only talks from official sources.

1:33His name is Arthur van Pelt. And he has been documenting the court cases of Craig Wright, who has claimed to be Satoshi back in 2015, for quite some time, and he has a lot of evidence that he has stacked. And it's really impressive to see what kind of work he is doing. So, hello, sir.

1:52Arthur van PeltHi, Vlad. Good morning.

1:54Vlad CosteaGood morning.

1:55Arthur van PeltI was surprised when you asked me if you want to have me on the show.

1:59Vlad CosteaAnd I give it some thought. On one hand, this season I also had Torsten Hoffmann.

2:14Who did that documentary which is called Cryptopia. That one's about the evolution of Bitcoin in the last few years. And he went to the house of Craig Wright in London and did a brief interview. And at the time I criticized him. I said, you know, you didn't really need to go to his house, record him and see what his opinion is on Bitcoin, because everyone knows that he is not Satoshi and he should not receive this kind of free publicity. So given this precedent, I was a bit reluctant to also have you, because giving Craig Wright a platform and more attention can only be detrimental.

2:57But at the same time, there's a lot of harm that he's doing to this community. And there is a lot that needs to be known. And at the same time, I also need to test what kind of evidence you're providing, right? Because we're in this space where we need to verify everything and not just trust anyone.

3:18Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah. I get what you mean here. The thing is that I would, how to say that? You can choose to ignore him, but he still makes headlines here and there. And if you do not criticize the headlines and the content behind the headlines, then people will still fall for his scam. And when it is just an emotional scam, yeah, okay, I can live with that. But it's also a financial scam that the guy is performing, and then you will learn probably later in this interview what type of financial scam the guy is doing and has been doing.

4:00Vlad CosteaRight. So for how long have you been following what Craig Wright is doing and why so obsessively? Somebody who is looking from the outside might say that you're getting paid to do it or you have some special interest to conduct this research.

4:15Arthur van PeltYeah, it has grown from... I knew the name Craig Wright already, I think, if I remember well, probably even before his self-doxx to Gizmodo and Wired magazine, because he already was in the Bitcoin community in 2015, early or halfway 2015. And I think I might have caught his name already there. But of course, after the Wired, Gizmodo times, we could not avoid the guy anymore. Then in May 2016, he did his failed signing sessions. And from there, I slowly started, yeah, I kept on criticizing the guy.

4:56I've never been convinced that this guy is Satoshi Nakamoto. I know Bitcoin since 2012 and dipped my toe in the industry in 2013. So yeah, I'm, well, maybe not an OG, but a rather old timer anyway. The thing is, when he started his libel suits against Hodlonaut, Peter McCormack and a few other people, that was for me the moment, especially when he put $5,000 on the head of Hodlonaut, a bounty to get his address.

5:31That was for me the main trigger to ramp up my research and map out all his frauds, because the accusation that they made at that time, yeah, thousands of people made that accusation, was that he is a fraud and a liar, and he started those libel suits against a few people to silence them down, which of course didn't happen. But again, the trigger for me was the $5,000 bounty that he put on Hodlonaut's head. And that made me quite angry, actually. And my sense for injustice, when it is triggered... I'm a patient guy and I'm very relentless in what I'm doing. It's actually not a paid job for me, to address that question that you had.

6:26It's a hobby that I do next to my work. And yeah, of course, it takes time because reading all the court documents takes time, but it's kind of obsessed, but it's with a trigger of injustice behind it.

6:44Vlad CosteaAlright, so how come you never got sued, while Hodlonaut and Peter McCormack and other people who spoke bad stuff about Craig Wright got sued in their jurisdictions? Does it have to do with the legal protections that you have where you live? Or was it that you flew under the radar?

7:05Arthur van PeltYeah, I think a bit of both, but mostly the latter that you're saying. I was a little internet guppy about one and a half year ago with a few hundred followers on Twitter. And if I call out something, nobody will notice except a few people that follow me. That has grown over time. I have now 3,000, 4,000 followers roughly, which is still not big. But I noticed that people are quite interested in this stuff anyway, because it's a crazy story if you learn the whole thing that he is doing.

7:42And what also is the case is that because I'm in Holland, the libel laws here are quite different from England, and it means that he has to have a good story to call me out. But yeah, when I'm an internet guppy only on Twitter, hardly known in the world, then he has no reason to sue me. He wanted to sue a few well-known people like Vitalik Buterin, Roger Ver. Peter McCormack was already well known, Hodlonaut was well known. So yeah, he never bothered to sue me.

8:20To be honest, I have been... well, afraid is a big word, but I have been worried about that a few times. On the other hand, I know that the community will support me, and I'm strong enough to withstand it because I always do things fact-based. What I do is map out all his stuff in a timeline, and I always have sources where I can go back to, and then it becomes a fact-based thing. And he can try to call me defamation, but it is defamation sourced from other sources. And if I mention my opinion on top of those sources, then it is an opinion. An opinion is not defamation.

9:19Vlad CosteaI guess that's a good legal interpretation. But if you want to accuse somebody of doing something, you can still, you know, take some precious time out of their lives, if you can afford it, and drag them in court and do all that stuff that at the end of the day just kills your time, you know? And I was about to ask you know, you said you flew under the radar, but after I post this episode, it's going to get some attention, and it might get to Craig Wright, and we might get sued for this. So, do you have a plan for that?

9:55Arthur van PeltNo, not really. And I don't think that will happen, for a few reasons. Again, it is all fact-based, it is all sourced from court documents, from evidence that he provided himself in those courts. It is filed as exhibits in Kleiman v. Wright. It is well-known information circulating on the Internet for many years, if it is not coming from those court cases. And the other reason is that he declared, and Calvin Ayre also declared, that they are done with these libel cases. They want to focus on another phase of lawsuits that they are going to try, which is lawsuits against Bitcoin Core developers, and to get BTC down from that angle. And the libel cases they wanted to narrow down to only Hodlonaut and Peter McCormack, and they closed Adam Back, Roger Ver and Vitalik Buterin, because they thought it was enough. So I'm not so much afraid of that.

11:12Vlad CosteaRight, so let's get to the information. And for somebody who has not followed the story and may have gotten into the space yesterday, how would you summarize the story of Craig Wright?

11:27Arthur van PeltIn a very brief overview, he learned about Bitcoin in 2011, roughly in July. That's when he first started talking about it. He misspelled it in some comment sections to a few articles that he wrote for the Conversation website, and from there he started thinking and researching a bit in Bitcoin. Roughly by the end of 2012, he had a few business ideas about Bitcoin, which were, in my humble opinion, kind of legit. But when he could not get funding, he decided to do a pretty large tax fraud in Australia, because this is where he lived back then. So in 2013, after the death of Dave Kleiman, he started a pretty large and somewhat complicated, sophisticated, I would even call it, but still sloppy tax fraud for pretty large amounts, which got called out. And in that process he developed ideas to become what we now call Faketoshi, or the Satoshi Nakamoto claimant.

12:42Vlad CosteaHow did that happen? How do you go from committing tax fraud in your country to claiming that you're Satoshi Nakamoto?

12:50Arthur van PeltNow, if you look into the details about that, it's actually pretty funny. I did not realize that. And this realization came because I read a piece of Professor Stolfi who mentioned that, I don't know, about a year, maybe two years ago. He suggested that already, but he could not really prove it. But he felt that that was the case, because we know Craig Wright only from roughly 2015, 2016, when he started to come out with his Satoshi story. But we also knew a few little details, that he fled Australia because of the ATO troubles that he had.

13:33Now, in the last few months, we have seen a lot and lots of filings in the Kleiman v. Wright lawsuit. And then we see the details about this story. And I'll be damned, but Professor Stolfi was right about this suggestion. So I took his opinion on that and I fully support it now. What we see happening is that, for example, in 2014... Last year in Kleiman v. Wright, the whole Tulip Trust story, we all know about that probably by now, but this Tulip Trust story came as a forgery, as a forged setup, a fraudulent setup, only in October 2014. And he set it up for avoiding a 1.6 million GST tax payment. And the ATO explained that in a few reports, where they called his whole setup, which he did in the years 2013-2015, that was his ATO tax fraud era.

14:50They said, "Yeah, we warned you that if you do this and this and this with those and those invoices, and you claim that Bitcoin is behind it, then it is a payable tax event. So you have to pay us 1.6 million." And Craig was thinking, "Ooh, now, yeah, maybe better not. So I will change the whole setup. I will create an offshore construction with a trust where I put my Bitcoin holdings, and from there I do the invoicing," and well, the whole fraudulent setup.

15:20So I can avoid paying that 1.6 million GST. So if you learn about that, then you know that this whole Tulip Trust was not something that he set up in 2009. That is also one of his claims, that he started a trust in Panama in 2009, 2010. And from there he moved to another trust in the Seychelles, which is now called the Tulip Trust thing. Now, to cut a long story short, that whole stuff has been called out by both the ATO and the court in Florida in the Kleiman v. Wright case as, yeah, it doesn't exist.

15:57This is a whole fraudulent setup. It doesn't exist. Now, and then the second story, how do you become Satoshi, or presumed, that he claims himself that he is Satoshi? That was only because he was playing around with offshore bitcoins in the hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of thousands. And how do you explain that? Yeah, in the end he could only explain it by being Satoshi. And that's how it has grown in those years, 2013, 2014, that he slowly thought, "Yeah, if I have to explain these enormous holdings," that he never had, of course, but that he claims to have, "I better start playing Satoshi."

16:45And he did that in the background, only with a few people, testing the waters, see if it works. And as long as people don't call him out, then yeah, the story gets bigger and bigger. And it ended up in, for example, 2015, that he tried to, well, actually in December 2015 already, with the self-doxx to Gizmodo and Wired, that he tried to be known as Satoshi worldwide.

17:16Vlad CosteaLet's backtrack for a minute there, because you used lots of specialized terms, used lots of names that some people may not know. So the ATO is the Australian Tax Authority, right?

17:27Arthur van PeltYeah, the full name is Australian Taxation Office.

17:30Vlad CosteaOkay. And who is Dave Kleiman?

17:37Arthur van PeltDave Kleiman was a, Well, let's call him a friend of, mostly an online friend. I think they met once or twice in real life. An American friend of Craig Wright. They wrote a paper together in 2008 about wiping hard disks. And they worked together in 2011 in a company called W&K Research blah, blah, blah, something. And that was mostly a cybersecurity thing. They raised that company together, likely with Craig's wife also involved because she was on the email also back then. And they tried to land four projects from Homeland Security. They failed to do that, so the company almost immediately, roughly half a year later, became dormant and was not subscribed at Sunbiz in Florida anymore.

18:44And that company was reinstated in 2013, if I'm right, '14 maybe, by Craig Wright after Dave Kleiman died in April 2013, because he could use dead Dave Kleiman and his dormant company, W&K, to park some intellectual property from Australia to America. And he valued that at that moment for $5,000, which later became his Bitcoin property.

19:30Intellectual property, I have to say, and software. And in 2013, in Australia, and yeah, those are one of those amazing things that he managed to do. He went to the court in Australia, he put two claims on this dormant and never done anything special company, except those four projects that they tried to land from Homeland Security, which failed. But he said, "Yeah, I have put in 2008, 2009." W&K didn't even exist back then, but yeah, in court Australia, he claimed it anyway, that he had contracts with that company, that he put intellectual property and software there, and he wanted to have it back.

20:15And at that moment, it was valued at, in total, the both claims together for some 56 million Australian dollars. Now, so Dave Kleiman was never, as far as I can see, never involved with Bitcoin and only after he died, Craig Wright used that company and Dave Kleiman's name to involve him in his Bitcoin scam. That story continued quickly in 2013, in the second half, that when court Australia, the NSW Supreme Court said, "Yeah, you're right. We believe your story." So they put a signature on it. So he had 56 million in intellectual property and software back.

21:12He pushed it forward into roughly a dozen, almost a dozen companies that he set up in Australia, together with the Bitcoin business ideas like a Bitcoin bank and training centers. Like I said, there is a part that is kind of legit ideas he had, but that intellectual property, he pushed it forward into those companies in 2013, '14. And because he now could set up fraudulent invoices, he could start claiming tax back. So, if you ask what is the role of Dave Kleiman, he was not involved in Bitcoin, but he was conveniently available with his W&K company in America. So from abroad, Craig could lift, shuffle some non-existing intellectual property back to Australia.

22:19Vlad CosteaThat sounds very elaborated. Yeah, and it's very easy to lose the plot in all of the story.

22:25Arthur van PeltYeah, all this stuff is now becoming known mostly because of the Kleiman v. Wright case. And especially the last two, three months have been quite productive there because they are preparing for a trial in October this year. It has been postponed a few times because of Corona, but it looks now that it's going to happen in October. There will be a two week trial with a jury. And so now they are filing all the evidence, all the exhibits, all the depositions that they want to use in that trial period. And yeah, quite interesting stuff, I can tell you.

23:06Vlad CosteaSo how did Gavin Andresen in 2015 get convinced by Craig Wright that he is Satoshi?

23:16Arthur van PeltYeah, that's an interesting detail. I can only give my personal opinion on that. He is a personality, if I'm honest, that can be bamboozled. He is not a strong personality. And what he did, he had four bullet points that he wanted to check with Craig Wright. In the end, he never got answers, full answers on three of the bullet points. And he took for granted, that part he took for granted. And only one bullet point was, in his opinion, kind of good. He got good answers on that.

24:02And that made him kind of convinced. Not really, to be honest, because half a year later after those signing sessions, because he was flown to London, as you might remember, I think somewhere in April 2016, just before the other signing sessions, and I think roughly half a year later he already pulled his statement in and said that, yeah, I might have been bamboozled. And in his latest depositions he even goes a bit further that he is, yeah, on several details from back then he's not trusting the whole thing anymore.

24:44Only one thing he is now claiming is that the private keys for block nine, yeah, Craig Wright might have had them. Might. So it's a bit of a wobbly story if you ask me.

24:59Vlad CosteaYeah, to me, that story, not only that it seems strange, but in my mind, it appears to be more of a political move during the scaling wars, because he needed the legitimation to push a big block version of Bitcoin and found somebody who agreed with him. And if that somebody could provide some minimal cryptographic proof and also agreed with his opinion, I mean, we could have had Bitcoin XT a lot faster instead of SegWit and Lightning Network.

25:37Arthur van PeltYeah, it might have to do with it. That I agree. It has not been mentioned so much, also not in the depositions. It is not a very clear point. It is mostly that when we look at that period in 2015, 2016, how you see that grow. Craig already had in mind that he wanted to come out or start role-playing Satoshi. We even can trace it back to late 2013. It was already in his mind back then. He tried some backdated blog posts on his personal blog that failed to attract attention.

26:26But in especially 2015, he was really ready to make that move to come forward as Satoshi. At the same time, because the ATO started inquiring him on his tax frauds, he felt that pressure. So I think that combination made him move forward, because Craig is a person that is, the moment he is getting a setback, instead of keeping quiet, he moves forward and comes with even bolder claims and lies and forgeries to cover up his tracks. When in roughly June he felt the need to get bailed out, he got contacted, he searched contact with Stefan Matthews and Robert MacGregor.

27:20In the background, Calvin Ayre was already present and they bailed him out for many millions that he owed the ATO, because they were slowly starting to claim back money that they paid him. In total, he frauded for, well, I can trace back at least 100 million Australian dollars. It's amazing what he did. And it is based on incomplete information, and it might even be much higher than that. But at that moment he started to, he tried to move forward and he started to give more and more hints in his inner circle that he is the inventor of Bitcoin and that he will get his mined bitcoins from 2009, 2010, he will get it back.

28:12In the meantime he already set up this Tulip Trust thing, so Calvin Ayre was kind of bamboozled in the story that whatever happens, if you give me money now for the bailout, you will get it back someday, because I will have a huge payout later from those early mined coins. The big block discussion is not really interesting yet at that moment because we're talking 2015.

28:442016, because Craig in June 2015, he sold his intellectual property. He sold his life story rights and the promise of creating a lot of patents that was sold to what is now called nChain, this company in London where he works. And in 2016, it was in fact a marketing effort to out him as Satoshi.

29:17It was not like the self-doxx earlier that he tried himself, and that was still kind of needed. I think that, this is a bit of a guess, I have to be honest here. But my guess is that in late 2015, he was already sure that he was being bailed out. But the final contract was only a few weeks, months, I think January or February 2016, when they made up the final contracts for that bailout and for the things that he was supposed to go do in future, especially for nChain.

29:52Again, the big block discussion was still not on the table at that moment. In the April, May 2016 period, the outing was a media circus, a total media circus. He even got trained by media people to say the right things and to mention the right words, etc. And only the big block discussion, when it was in the scaling debate, which was much later, and then we're talking 2017, you already saw that he was puked out. Craig Wright was puked out by the Bitcoin community already back then, because nobody believed him in 2015 and '16.

30:42So he only could connect with people that supported him from 2015 onwards, which was in this case Roger Ver. And Roger Ver has been a long time believer of Craig Wright between 2015 and 2018. So he connected with the BCH community, and those were the big blockers, and that is where Craig Wright also became a big blocker. That is a bit how it went.

31:11Vlad CosteaThat's a long story and it took several years to get there. And it's really impressive that you took the time to analyze all of this. So if somebody wants to check the documents and see what's going on year by year, according to court files or public statements, where can they find that?

31:32Arthur van PeltI have a link on my... I only do things on Twitter. There I do roughly daily Craig Wright fixes and thoughts and opinions and fact finding, which is MyLegacyKit. And if you look at my main profile, there I have a link to a page on Weebly where I have a somewhat rough timeline, starting in roughly 2000, 2001, because he has been in court cases where we already find his, yeah, his way of working, his frauds with emails and forgeries, etc.

32:09So I have links to that, and from there until today, 2020, I have a rough guideline with all the links to all the articles that have been published about him, about his outcomings, about his calls out, how he has been called out in the media on many, many places. And I'm currently working, but it's only a local file, but it will come online also, hopefully in a few weeks, few months, where I go into way more detail and make a day by day.

32:48What did he do on that day? How did he backdate it to whatever year or month earlier? And what is the source and what are the debunk links? That goes in way more detail. That is not online yet.

33:05Vlad CosteaOh, so you want to do an entire timeline of what Craig Wright has been doing?

33:10Arthur van PeltYeah, what I currently have is already a timeline, a year by year and month by month, where, for example, the Gizmodo and Wired articles are mentioned in December 2015. So if you go to my page and scroll down a bit to 2015, you will find all the articles about that self-doxx, and there are many. December 2015, I have a long row, a few dozen articles from everywhere in the world, what they thought about him, what they thought about that moment. And of course also the, he was raided in his office and in his home at that moment by the ATO.

33:55And also all the articles about it are there. And that's how I made a timeline year by year. It starts on top with the oldest year and if you scroll down you go to the current days.

34:11Vlad CosteaSo previously, you alluded to the idea that you might have met Craig Wright before he claimed he was Satoshi. When was that and what kind of interaction was it?

34:21Arthur van PeltNo, not met. I heard about the name online. I'm from the Netherlands and he was back then still in Australia, but his name circulated in the community already because in the first part of 2015, he already started to mingle in the Bitcoin community. And a crucial personality back then was Bitcoin Belle, Michele Seven. She was, well, also one of the many people being bamboozled. And she introduced him to other people in the Bitcoin community. And back then, Roger Ver was still important, and several other people. But he was quickly pushed aside by what is now still the Bitcoin Core community, so to say.

35:18But it was people like Nick Szabo, etc. I mean, those people hardly never believed anything that Craig Wright said. And when reading forums, reading Bitcoin Talk, etc., those places where people are being mentioned or being discussed, then I think his name already popped up. But again, this is a bit of a fake memory because this is really early days. I'm quite sure that in the 2016 era, where he started with the, sorry, December 2015 with Gizmodo, Wired, I was certainly aware of him, but I never met him. No.

36:02Vlad CosteaRight, I remember watching that conference with Nick Szabo, Trace Mayer, a couple of other people, and then there was Craig Wright on the screen as a projection.

36:09Arthur van PeltYeah, I've seen it.

36:10Vlad CosteaAnd Bitcoin Belle was the moderator of this debate or discussion.

36:13Arthur van PeltYeah.

36:14Vlad CosteaAnd it seemed like, you know, the Wizard of Oz.

36:16Arthur van PeltYeah.

36:17Vlad CosteaWith the great Wizard of Oz claiming he's Satoshi being on the screen there. Except that at the time he was much more reserved. He was not really saying, "Hi, I'm Satoshi, I have mined the first bitcoins." He was a lot more vague.

36:31Arthur van PeltYeah.

36:32Vlad CosteaHe was alluding to have mined Bitcoin in the early days. He said, "Yeah, I was involved in mining a long time ago," and stuff like that. Like he was trying to be mysterious and possibly he was not comfortable yet with saying that he's Satoshi.

36:55Arthur van PeltYeah.

36:56Vlad CosteaAnd I think that's a useful historic source to see how he has shifted in terms of attitude and claims.

37:06Arthur van PeltYeah, it's what I can say. Over those, he started his tax scam in 2013. On the go he thought it was convenient for him to put himself in the Satoshi position, and he slowly, what I would call as testing the waters to see if the story would, yeah, would be accepted. And as long as he is not called out by the real Satoshi, yeah, he can still hold on to it. This moment in time with this, what I remember reading from Michele Seven is that for her, she did not believe him anymore at that moment, when he was on screen in that conference with Nick Szabo and Trace Mayer.

38:01Vlad CosteaOh, it shows. So if you go on YouTube and you look up that video, you're going to see that she's trying to make Nick Szabo and all the other people who are technical in the panel...

38:10Arthur van PeltYeah.

38:11Vlad Costea...to destroy him. But it didn't really work out because they didn't care. They were like, "Okay, so you claim that Bitcoin is Turing complete? Okay, go on, talk about it, write a research paper."

38:25Arthur van PeltYeah, correct. And since Craig did not say the exact words, "I am Satoshi," they could not call him out on that part. And that's how Michele Seven's scoop failed a little. Because what I remember is that she said that she was hoping that he would call himself Satoshi like he did in private conversations with her, so that the more technical people could call him out. But that trick did not really work at that moment.

39:00Vlad CosteaYeah, it was unfortunate. Kind of. I mean, they could take him down at that early phase.

39:06Arthur van PeltMm-hmm.

39:07Vlad CosteaAnd that could save the entire community, you know, the mental energy and effort of actually conducting research about his background. And I remember, I think it was 2018, that he started being banned from conferences because he was speaking about Bitcoin. And, you know, conference organizers, they like this kind of attention. They don't care if he's Satoshi or not, but they like the idea of having the guy who claims he's Satoshi and they want to put it on posters, on banners, online, and just say, "We have this guy who says he's Satoshi Nakamoto, come see him."

39:45And people who have no idea about Bitcoin or about the history of, you know, cypherpunk innovation, they're going to come and they're going to watch it. So it sells tickets, I guess. I think it wasn't until Vitalik Buterin called him out during one of the conferences that he started getting banned, and from there it just got narrower, and you can see him aging a lot in the last two years.

40:13Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah, yeah, very true. And he even admitted early last year when he was on a tour in, I think, China or Korea, probably China. I caught a clip from when he was on stage that he even admitted that he is never invited and that he pays, nChain or Calvin Ayre or whatever, because he hardly has any money himself. Because after the bailout he never earned a penny as far as we can see. And he only claims to have these Tulip Trust bitcoins that never come and never arrive, that he doesn't have the private keys of.

40:58Vlad CosteaBut wait a minute, I thought he had more money than the country of Ghana or something.

41:02Arthur van PeltYeah, crazy. He doesn't have it. But he really admitted that he is not invited on conferences and he's never invited on stage and he pays to be on stage. And that this probably, like you said, started when Vitalik called him out. That was in 2018 already, I think, somewhere.

41:27Vlad CosteaYeah, I remember watching that. It was like two years ago.

41:33Arthur van PeltYeah, in one way he is, because he is also kicked from, about a year, slightly more than a year ago, he was kicked from Twitter. And he's now only operating from a kind of private Slack room where people have to pay to listen to his crap. And that's why we also start calling it, for a while already, it's becoming a cult, the Craig Wright cult, the fake Toshi cult. He has his hardcore believers and he has a community of people around it that are trading on BSV and try to make some money still on the claim.

42:14And Calvin Ayre is trying to set up a business with BSV, with Craig Wright's brainchild of Bitcoin, which has nothing to do with anything Satoshi Vision, if you ask me, but it's a more technical and different story. Yeah, and they claim to have a few customers and a few enterprises that are slowly starting to build on BSV. But yeah, let's be honest, it's rather marginal. It's close to irrelevant. It's a miracle that they're still in the top 10 of market capitalization websites.

42:52Vlad CosteaYeah, but market capitalization is a flawed metric. And also Bitcoin forks have an unfair advantage, because not too many people claim their forked coins, right? Or if they did, they sold in the first day. So this means that there are whales that never sell. And they can manipulate the price and pump it and dump it and play this game for the longest time to make money. I suppose this is why Calvin Ayre, and I don't want to get sued or anything, this is just my opinion, this is why Calvin has stuck around even though he did not receive any kind of money from Craig Wright, because he can get so much control over BSV. And there's a lot of money to be made there.

43:43Arthur van PeltYeah, he already has. I mean, he controls 80% of the whole infrastructure.

43:49Vlad CosteaYeah, makes sense. That's why he promotes it so hard.

43:55Arthur van PeltYeah, it's what we call the sunk cost fallacy. He invested already so much, over 100 million dollars. He invested in the whole environment. He started already with a 50 million bailout in 2015. So for him, it's hard to stop now. If he stops, he has substantial losses.

44:22Vlad CosteaRight, so let's talk about patents, because I feel like that's a very delicate topic and you have a lot of information about how they file patents and why they do it. So, in a nutshell, I think the claims of Craig Wright are that he's going to get all the patents in the world and get acknowledged for inventing stuff. Yeah, because this is open source software, nobody files patents. Satoshi published the Bitcoin code under, and I don't want to be wrong about this, but I think it's the MIT license for open source.

45:06Arthur van PeltCorrect. On the first one, on SourceForge, later on GitHub, there it is under the MIT license indeed, and that means that it is free to use, even free to change. And Craig is taking two angles. He's saying that a few things do not fall under this license and under this copyright. So he still owns the copyright on the database and on some old sources of code. He registered it last year, I think, April, somewhere in America. But it doesn't mean anything.

45:45And the funny thing is that the copyright office in America even published a press release back then that they did not check if he is really Satoshi. So that is just his claim, and so you can only figure those things out in court later, which is indirectly happening, of course, in the libel suits with Hodlonaut and Peter McCormack. So that is one angle that he tries to get his copyright on those things.

46:26And the second angle is that he is creating a lot of patents on ideas and stuff that he has on Bitcoin. And yeah, what can I say about it? There are legal things that, at this moment, are slightly hard to say how that will go. On the other hand, what we do know about those things, it will fail, because he is not Satoshi, so he will have hard times convincing courts that he is Satoshi.

47:02And the moment that he does it, and for example tries to put his copyright, put an amount behind it, and starts claiming other people, Bitcoin Core developers or enterprises that he thinks are using his intellectual property, yeah, the IBMs and Microsofts of this world have way more budget than this guy has with Calvin Ayre in the background. So I see that fail from all angles. And the other angle is when he, in Lisbon, he said that he wanted to create patents.

47:41Yeah, that we know already since 2000... looking back, he had that idea in 2015 already, so he promised Calvin Ayre that he would start creating patents, and we see them being filed since 2016. Now, until the end of 2018, we can trace back roughly between 100, 150 nChain patents, and I think 43 are on the name of Craig Wright. And he said in 2018 or '19 somewhere that he would create 10,000 patents. Now they're far from there. Even more important, I came across an article that was looking at the quality of those patents in the blockchain industry worldwide.

48:29So they looked at Alibaba patents, American banks patents, IBM, Microsoft patents and nChain patents, and I think now together with another company that filed some patents. But the nChain patents are the lowest of the low quality ever, because they are never referenced. They are not mentioned as prior art. That means that they are technically irrelevant, seen as technically irrelevant. This article was, yeah, quite damning for the current portfolio of nChain. So yeah, what can they do with this? It goes nowhere.

49:12Vlad CosteaI mean, I can imagine when you file so many patents that you don't really have an aim or a specific invention that you want to claim. You're trying to get credit for everything and see which one sticks and which one gets acknowledgement from the authorities. But this can be enough sometimes, because one country that acknowledges your patent can play an important role in helping you, for example, sue the Bitcoin Core developers, because I suppose this is the next step. And they have sent that letter which targets Wladimir van der Laan and Greg Maxwell.

49:55And I suppose there were a couple of others. But this, I don't know, this is the next level of Craig Wright lawsuits, right?

50:06Arthur van PeltIf he continues with it, that will be the next step indeed. That is for as long as Calvin Ayre is supporting the whole thing. Because like I said, as far as we can trace back, Craig Wright does not have a lot of money himself for all these things. And it was known in the Kleiman v. Wright lawsuit. Yeah, that must have cost them by now at least five million on each side. But both are sponsored. Ira Kleiman is sponsored and Craig Wright is sponsored by Calvin Ayre. And we learned that from the deposition of Jimmy Nguyen, the Bitcoin Association guy.

50:52Vlad CosteaWait, so before you continue, who is the sponsor of the Dave Kleiman side of this court situation?

51:03Arthur van PeltThat is a professional company that is doing litigation funding. By head, they're called Parabellum Corporation, if I'm right.

51:13Vlad CosteaOkay, because in your explanation it implied that Calvin Ayre is financing both sides.

51:20Arthur van PeltOh, sorry, no, that was not what I meant. Of course Calvin Ayre is only supporting Craig Wright, and Ira Kleiman is... What I meant with both sides is that it is my estimation that they spent at least 5 million so far on the lawsuit. So Ira Kleiman is having a budget, has to pay lawyer bills, probably north of 5 million, and the same story for Craig Wright. But Ira Kleiman, the brother of late Dave Kleiman, is sponsored by Parabellum Corporation, and Craig Wright is sponsored by Calvin Ayre. He's the litigation funder of Craig Wright.

52:13Vlad CosteaYes, and according to one court decision that we have seen, Craig Wright has to pay all the bitcoins that he claimed to have, or at least part of them, to the widow of his friend with whom he claims he started the Bitcoin project, Ira Kleiman.

52:34Arthur van PeltYeah, this is already more in the details of the lawsuit. It started in February 2018 and a big jump forward. I think it was August 2019 when they work with two judges: a magistrate judge and the higher judge is Beth Bloom, and the somewhat lower judge, the magistrate judge, is doing the discovery phase, but he is also able to rule on things, but it has to be approved by the higher judge, Beth Bloom. And at that moment he ruled that the partnership was convinced of, was there, and he did not make a ruling on how many bitcoins was in that partnership.

53:36But he thought that there was a partnership between late Dave Kleiman and Craig Wright, and the parties should figure out how much Bitcoin is in that partnership, how much intellectual property is in that partnership.

53:58Later, Beth Bloom overruled in part that ruling of Judge Reinhart. And she said, "I'm not convinced of this partnership yet. I need to see more proof, more discovery." So she overruled the partnership. The part that she left standing was a part where Craig had to pay for his, yeah, his conflicting statements and, yeah, making a mess of the whole court procedures. He had to pay a part of the lawyer bill of Ira Kleiman already, and that ended up in a payment, I think, north of $150,000, which is only a small part of the whole thing, of course.

54:49And then in late 2019, they started to do more discovery. So we saw in the filings of the last six months, we saw more depositions and more evidence, more exhibits being filed in this lawsuit because, yeah, they were able to do more discovery. Beth Bloom immediately agreed with the Ira Kleiman side when they asked for a far broader discovery time, and then the trial got postponed again, also for that. And there is where we see, yeah, even more details than we ever knew before.

55:35Vlad CosteaYeah, and I think you get lost in details too much. And that's also a problem that I have. Because to somebody who is not acquainted to this whole situation, it's going to sound so confusing. There's so many parties involved, so many names, such a long timeline of events. It's easy to get exhausted and lose interest.

56:01Arthur van PeltYeah, and for me it's a trigger to go deeper and deeper, because I want to know everything, and that's just how I work. I do not stop at the front door. I want to go out at the back, through the back door, and see what I see happening in between. And sometimes it's hard to summarize. And I think what I see, why my followers on Twitter like it so much, I am trying to put it in little snapshots that still give a good overview of what is happening.

56:36And I try to cut the crap and only mention the things that matter. And then I can summarize the whole thing in: he learned about Bitcoin in 2011. He started a fraud in 2013 and that fraud grew into a lawsuit with the Kleiman estate. And from there we learned that the major part of his forgeries was set up in 2014 and '15, and he's still living and drifting on that forgeries. And he changes his story when they're being called out, but instead of getting silent, he jumps forward with new forgeries and frauds. But it remains a fraud. It remains a silly story that he is Satoshi. He is not.

57:23Vlad CosteaBut in reality, it's so simple, right? You just sign the Genesis block. If you are the creator, you own the key. You sign that message, and that's it. You get a confirmation, and you show it to the entire world.

57:37Arthur van PeltYeah, that's it. That's it. Funny that you mention it, because just a few days ago I mentioned it to somebody on Twitter, and I showed a screenshot of what Charlie Lee did, the founder of Litecoin. He did it in 2016. Just simple, straightforward, because those types of truth are so simple and so straightforward. And you can create a lot of stories about law and this, and somebody can have also private keys, yeah, but the chances are slim to none, I mean, duh. So Charlie Lee signed the Litecoin blockchain, and nobody ever questioned him again since 2016.

58:17We all know he is the founder and there is no question about it. If Craig Wright had done the same in 2015 or '16, around the same time, and published it: "Look, I'm Satoshi. This is my signing of the Bitcoin Genesis block. Deal with it." Then we would have dealt with it. Come on. But it never happened. And it jumps from one craziness to the next craziness, until the copyright on parts of the software and patents that he might have, and lawsuits with, you just mentioned them, when he sent this letter a few weeks ago to Blockstream, because he's claiming a trust with stolen Mt.

59:01Gox bitcoins, some 80,000, because he says, "Yeah, that is part of my Tulip Trust thing," and blah, blah, blah, beating around the bush from here to Tokyo. It will go nowhere. It will never go anywhere. Calvin and Craig are spending millions on this bullshit. It will never go anywhere. And Charlie Lee, without any costs, within five minutes, and nobody questions him ever again. That's how you should do it.

59:31Vlad CosteaRight, but I mean, right as in R-I-G-H-T, not W-R-I-G-H-T. But I remember last year there was a story floating in the space, circulating, and people were talking about it. And it was so conveniently framed that Paul Le Roux is actually Satoshi, because he used some sort of pseudonym that was Solotshi or something.

59:56Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah.

59:58Vlad CosteaAnd that he is in jail right now, and Calvin Ayre and Craig Wright got a hold on his hard drives, which contained the Satoshi coins, and that they're trying to buy themselves some time to decrypt those and basically get access to the bitcoins and dump them on the market. And there's always this threat, you know. Craig Wright has been threatening us that he's going to get access to the Satoshi Nakamoto stash of a million bitcoins or more and dump them on the market and say, "You know, this is the end. I'm going to destroy you. Bitcoin is going to zero because I have all of these coins that I'm going to dump on the market."

1:00:47Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah, it's one of those crazy stories that evolve over time. That Le Roux is a conspiracy theory. He was mentioned in one of the court papers because they tried to redact some things, but they forgot that a part of a website, an URL, was going forward on the next page, and they redacted one page and on the next page they forgot to redact something about Le Roux. So they thought, "Hey, why is this person popping up in the Kleiman v. Wright case?" And yeah, then you see that especially the BSV community will start making a lot of assumptions and get crazy ideas about those things.

1:01:39And when you look at the total picture, yeah, Craig Wright mentions a lot of people he knows by his research. He knows, of course, a lot of OGs by name, because he found them online when he is googling around to sharpen his Bitcoin knowledge and the history of Bitcoin. But it always ends up being dead ends.

1:02:06When he says things about Hal Finney, half of it, if not more, is not correct. He puts them in the wrong timeframe when he mentions things with Dave Kleiman and Bitcoin connected, with Bitcoin connection. The emails that he sent to Dave Kleiman and that Dave Kleiman sent back, I don't know any genuine email from the 2008-2013 era that has not been called out, that has not been questioned, that has not been, in a technical sense, I mean. So all those emails between Dave Kleiman and Craig Wright from 2008, when they started mentioning Bitcoin, until his death, which was about setting up a company in Australia, CoinX company in Australia, where Dave Kleiman was supposed to have some influence or shareholdership, et cetera. All those emails have been debunked as forgeries dating 2014 and further onward, all to support the ATO tax fraud.

1:03:27So yeah, what can I say?

1:03:34Vlad CosteaIt's a very intricate story. I have no idea where it's supposed to begin and how it's going to end. But it seems like they use every little trick in the book to prolong, to push, to buy time. It seems like it's a never-ending story of buying more time. And you never know what the end goal is. To tire out the authorities, to, I don't know, push BSV for as long as possible and milk this fat cow while they still can? And I can see people from the BSV community denouncing Craig Wright, which was unlikely like a year ago. But now they're saying, "No, we don't need Craig Wright. We're not convinced that he is Satoshi. We think that he's a bad actor in the community, and we're going to carry on with development and software without his influence and without his permission and without his patronage or whatever."

1:04:37Arthur van PeltYeah, correct. It's what I see. What I see also, Calvin managed to lift that project to a, well, let's say, somewhat legit project in a technical sense, because they still keep it online and they pretend to have customers using it. And we cannot really put a finger behind it yet: are these legit companies that are not connected to Calvin Ayre being the major shareholder of that company and telling them to use BSV? On the other hand, what is quite remarkable, we know that Calvin's background is from the Bodog gambling empire.

1:05:30And Calvin wants to have the gambling industry on BSV. But it should be easy for him already for one and a half year to get Bodog on BSV.

1:05:48But so far it didn't happen. I mean, pretty weird when you think of it. What we see is a little bit of a split or a drift away from Craig being Satoshi. It has been questioned a lot. We see several kind of important community members leaving BSV, questioning Craig Wright being Satoshi. And the remaining hardcore followers of BSV and supporters of Craig Wright, they say, "Yeah, it does not really matter if he's... And he has his reasons." And then a genius like Craig Wright, yeah, who cares that he did plagiarism in his PhD thesis?

1:06:41Who cares? So they keep the story alive, and they are not ready yet to accept reality that Craig is not Satoshi.

1:06:54Vlad CosteaWait, but he's Satoshi, but he is... what's the word for it? He did get diagnosed for something like autism.

1:07:04Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah. That was part of the strategy of his counsel to get his lies and conflicting statements covered up, because he is on the autism or on the spectrum or something, how they call it. And that means that he always answers in a kind of direct, straightforward way, and that means that you cannot always follow him, because he focuses on one part of the question that he answers, and the other part of the question, then you have to keep asking him the same question in different words. So in the end you will get the full answer to your first question.

1:07:42Yeah, it totally makes no sense with that, because there are so many, when you stay strict to the facts of the matter. And I have a pretty good example when you can straightaway say this is a big, big, big lie, and I call it the Microsoft Patch Tuesday lie that he did. And when I can, I always mention it, because it's such a small example of how the guy works and why his story is not correct. He claimed several times during 2019, especially in the first half year of 2019, on several places, including his own blog, in interviews, on fireside chats and speeches that he did. So we can trace back several sources where he said exactly the same, because at that moment he thought it was a good story.

1:08:50Microsoft Patch Tuesday. When Bitcoin started on January the 3rd of 2009, it took six days to form the Genesis block. So that was only formed with this famous "on the brink of bailout", et cetera, message inside. It took six days to form. And normally a block would form in 10 minutes. And because the Genesis block is hard coded, it should have been formed within seconds. You just run the code and you have the block.

1:09:24But let's give it 10 minutes, like a normal block. And mining only started at block one, which was the, well, kind of real start. No, not real start, because the real start is of course January the 3rd, and the mining started at January the 9th. And in his efforts to be an expert in Bitcoin, Craig said, "Yeah, but it took six days, because in that period the software stopped. I had some bugs, but the main issue was that Microsoft pushed an update to my network, and it made my computers reboot, and I had to set up a complete new network."

1:10:02And that took six days. It only started working on January the 9th again, and from there onward I could restart, kind of restart, and continue with Bitcoin. Now, it totally makes no sense, because Microsoft Patch Tuesday is a software release by Microsoft that is only done once a month. And in January 2009, it was on January the 13th. So how can a network reboot on January the 3rd when the software is released 10 days later? For me, those things, and we have many of those things, dozens of those lies and inconsistencies, that we already know that he is talking bullshit.

1:10:52It's so clear that this guy is not Satoshi Nakamoto, because Satoshi Nakamoto would have the real story about the Genesis block. He would tell us, "Hey, I had bugs in the software, and the bugs were this and this and this and this, and I started it, and I had a crash, and I had to write some new code and start again, using already the existing January 3rd message, but I had to recreate code, etc." He would have a good story that would make sense from moment one. But the Microsoft Patch Tuesday story that he had for a few months in early 2019 never made any sense, you know.

1:11:38Vlad CosteaI guess it was a good time filler. But this is also a relevant point about anything revolving around Craig Wright, because he seems to change history a lot. If you look at the website, the personal website of his, and you run it through the Wayback Machine, you're going to see that blog posts have been modified along the years, right?

1:12:06Arthur van PeltYeah, absolutely. He had two major blogs, but he had several others too, and we can find them back on, especially on archive.today, because they keep everything. And the other website, the Wayback Machine, can be adjusted later, so that is not always trustworthy.

1:12:28But what they have is trustworthy, of course, but I think you can, in retrospect, delete things from the Wayback Machine. But it will still be kept on archive.today. So that is for me also a good source of reflection on those things. He had two major blogs. The private blog, "Cracked, InSecure and Generally Broken," was mostly used in 2000, early 2000, somewhere, '05, '06 I think he started it, and was used until December 2015. And that is where you can see a handful of blog posts or adjusted blog posts from the early days in 2008, '09, where he either created new blog posts, small ones, big ones, about Bitcoin and with hints to be the inventor and starter of Bitcoin.

1:13:30Now, because he was still in his early days of researching Bitcoin, he made a lot of mistakes in those adjustments and forgeries. For me, a famous example, funny thing is I did a little thread yesterday with my most favorite forgeries of Craig Wright, my top four picks, and this is one of them, where he called a blog post "Bitcoin" that he posted on his website.

1:14:02Backdated. It looks like that he already created that one in 2013, but for sure in 2014, because there we can find it back. And he backdated it to the 10th of January, and claiming there that Bitcoin was starting: "We start with a bunch of pretty good coders on it, and the white paper rocks, and tomorrow we start with Bitcoin." Now, that was of course not true, because Bitcoin was already started at January the 3rd. And he also called it Bitcoin Beta. It has never been called Bitcoin Beta in those days.

1:14:43Satoshi called it Bitcoin Alpha in those days. So you can see that he is still getting, trying to find his way in Bitcoin and in his research of Bitcoin. But in 2014, he did not know everything yet. He did not check all the BitcoinTalk posts of Satoshi. He did not check all the text files, the README text files of the software releases where Satoshi also put text inside, and he didn't know about it. So he made mistakes in those things. He probably only found the January 10 Twitter post of Hal Finney, where he said "Running bitcoin."

1:15:26This famous tweet of Hal Finney. So he thought that, okay, I live in Australia, so for him the date of this tweet was the 11th in Australia, when Hal Finney was tweeting from America. So okay, it has been started at January the 11th. Okay, if I backdate a forgery to January the 10th, it makes sense that I say that Bitcoin started the next day. Yeah, it's not true. It was already running. Yeah, okay.

1:16:01Vlad CosteaRight, but there's so much information out there, and it's so easy to get lost in it.

1:16:08Arthur van PeltOh, absolutely, absolutely. And I'm doing my best to keep it a bit consistent and things, but there is so much to say. And many times people reach out to me, "You should write a book about it, a documentary, a movie script, etc." And it might happen someday. And then pick out the major things of this whole story and put it in a... Yeah, well, if it would be a movie, that would be a pretty interesting movie, I think. But there is a lot to say. I fully agree.

1:16:49Vlad CosteaI do remember, I'm not sure if it was 2018 or 2019, when Jameson Lopp has published his article in Bitcoin Magazine, documenting his own research on Craig Wright. According to his research, he has made some calls, he has sent some emails, and he was able to acquire information about Craig Wright indeed working with the military in Australia. I'm not sure under which capacity, which was public military service, which was secret service. But it did make me ask myself whether or not this can be the first big state attack that we are seeing on Bitcoin.

1:17:40Because we get back to the earlier point of attacking developers. Right now he's chasing people like Wladimir van der Laan and Greg Maxwell. And these people are basically the most valuable minds in Bitcoin, or some of the most.

1:18:00Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah, I agree. And if you... It's a centralist attack, because those people are somewhat connected to Blockstream. So he sent this letter, because you're referring to ONTIER from England a few weeks ago, about a month ago already, I think. They sent a letter to Blockstream in Canada and addressed to those Bitcoin Core developers who are all, or almost all of them, are on the payroll of Blockstream. I mean, Blockstream is a force in Bitcoin. We cannot deny that, of course, but they are not the only force.

1:18:44They only create roughly 15% of the whole Bitcoin code. So what Craig is aiming there is, when he wants to put a claim on certain BTC addresses in the Bitcoin blockchain, then, because he has no private keys and he will never get them, so this is just a trick to get help or force the help from some Bitcoin Core developers, who should, yeah, create some code that will appoint these addresses, or recreate private keys, or whatever thoughts he has there, or move those bitcoins forward to one of his addresses that he does own a private key to.

1:19:31Then those Bitcoin Core developers should help him with a court order saying, "Help Craig Wright get these bitcoins." It's totally stupid. It will never happen. But he's still trying anyway. And now I have to get back to your first... Sorry, I'm lost a bit in your first question, the first part. What was that about?

1:19:58Vlad CosteaIt was about being a state attack.

1:20:01Arthur van PeltYeah, that's it. Craig Wright being paid by governments to attack Bitcoin. Yeah. Yeah, that...

1:20:08I see no proof of that. I see that circulate as a conspiracy theory, as there are many. Earlier you mentioned hard drives. There are also stories floating around about hard drives of Dave Kleiman, hard drives that Dave Kleiman might have given to somebody else, hard drives that Ira Kleiman had or has from the inheritance of Dave Kleiman that he has given to other people and tried to claim back, et cetera. There are several hard drive stories floating around where Bitcoin wallet addresses, wallet.dat addresses, are supposed to be on and need to be cracked, and which will take decades, if not centuries, to crack.

1:21:05I don't know. I don't know. There's a lot of those. I call them bullshit stories that I don't see go anywhere. And talking about a state attack or a proposed state attack, yeah. Yeah. Possible. Yeah. Maybe. How high do I think the chance is? Way below 10%. I see no proof for that, to be honest. It are conspiracy theories. What I see happening with Craig Wright is just a rather sloppy con man who came across Bitcoin, thought it was a convenient tool to use in a tax fraud of roughly 100 million, probably more, in 2013, which was called out by the ATO roughly by 2016-17.

1:21:50And after which they started also a criminal investigation, because they thought, well, okay, we did our normal inquiry and this smells and quacks and reeks as a fraud, but a criminal fraud in this case. So we will start a criminal investigation. And also one of the papers popping up in the Kleiman v. Wright case was recently a letter, or an email in this case, from the criminal investigations unit from the ATO, asking questions to Ira's counsel if they would be able to talk to Ira Kleiman in this criminal investigation around Craig Wright.

1:22:38So do I see state intervention? Do I see those theories coming true? No, not really. Just a sloppy con man. Very brazen, very complicated and, yeah, very brazen tax fraud scheme being called out, fleeing the country. And because he just can't stop, he's a narcissistic personality, and he just can't stop leeching on people, on investors, on tax authorities. He just can't stop and continues his fraud. That has nothing to do with some state trying to attack Bitcoin, I think.

1:23:34Vlad CosteaSo let me adjust my conspiracy theory and make it so that the real Satoshi has paid Craig Wright to destroy the image of Satoshi and make the entire community immune to the idea that Satoshi might still be around. So that whenever somebody else comes around and says, "I'm Satoshi," we're going to treat them, you know, with less care, and we're not going to make a big case. Like, you remember the Newsweek article with Dorian Nakamoto? I think that was 2013, 2014.

1:24:08Arthur van PeltYeah.

1:24:10Vlad CosteaBut that was huge, and it was all across the media. And they harassed that old man for no reason other than having the wrong name.

1:24:22Arthur van PeltYeah, it might... If you talk about conspiracy theories, that one might make a little sense, that there is a connection, or Craig Wright came across Satoshi Nakamoto, or Satoshi Nakamoto contacted Craig Wright and asked him to start role-playing on behalf of him so that he could stay anonymous. I still give that a very low probability chance, to be honest, but it is something that has not been called out properly. But how do you call out such a thing if you don't know any detail about it, and if there is no proof against it, or positive proof that that will...

1:25:16How do you call it? Yeah, I'm Dutch, so I don't know all the English words, but proof that supports this stance. So yeah, I don't know, but it's a story that, because there is no proof against or etc., I can still live with that story floating around. Maybe.

1:25:36Vlad CosteaOh yeah. It's the kind of situation where you think, okay, so this guy, he is not Satoshi, but who does benefit from his actions? So why is he doing this? He's putting himself in a position that's not very comfortable. He's under a lot of public scrutiny. He gets a lot of attention that clearly he doesn't like. And he gets rude and offensive sometimes. And I think that's his self-defense mechanism.

1:26:09Arthur van PeltOh yeah, but it comes with the personality. Of course, I'm not a medical expert, so these opinions that I have here, take it with a big, big grain of salt. But to me, it makes most sense that he is just a compulsive liar and a narcissistic, with a narcissistic personality disorder, and those type of people, a few percent on Earth are like that. If you are like that, you just can't stop. You just move forward. You cover up your old lies and your old stories with new lies and even more brazen stories.

1:26:59I think he needs medical attention for that. Yeah, he already should have had it a long time ago. But unfortunately, that did never happen. And now he runs a chance that if this Kleiman v. Wright case ends up in a criminal case, and if the ATO criminal case ends up being unleashed, because those researches take a few years again. Let's say that started in 2017 or '18, and then they can easily take four years research before they even put him to court there, I think. But if Craig is in touch with Satoshi and having an honest story about it...

1:27:44That might change the whole thing. But it still means that he created forgeries. It still means that he has been lying and giving, unleashing conflicting arguments and stories in this whole trajectory.

1:28:04Vlad CosteaYeah, but what I'm trying to say is that if the real Satoshi is still alive, and he is the Satoshi that we know from the BitcoinTalk discussions, who was very humble and reserved, then I suppose he sleeps better at night for as long as Craig Wright is around and keeps claiming that he is the real Satoshi.

1:28:25Arthur van PeltFor me, what makes the most sense is that, presuming Satoshi is still alive... I'm not doing any research to the real Satoshi, to be honest. So I have no idea and I cannot answer any question there. For me, it's pretty fine that he is anonymous and stays anonymous. And I fully respect that if that is the case. But the... Sorry, now I'm a bit lost, but what were we... Can you repeat the question, Vlad?

1:29:02Vlad CosteaSo I was implying that the real Satoshi might be sleeping better at night knowing that Craig Wright is out there taking all the attention.

1:29:14Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah, kind of. And he does not feel the need to call him out because he is comfortable that Craig is very capable of destroying himself. And that is why Satoshi is not going online and calling Craig Wright out. And luckily we see other OGs calling him out. We saw a beautiful example on the 25th of May when the so-called Tulip Trust list that was in court since January this year, and kind of by accident that list came... Well, not kind of by accident, that list came online.

1:29:57On the CourtListener website, and it reached an early miner, and that early miner started signing that Tulip Trust list 145 times. And that is of course a big problem for Craig because, yeah, if he claims that he has been mining, then his Satoshi list that he filed in January should not contain addresses that can be signed by others. I mean, duh. So yeah. But it happened anyway.

1:30:30Vlad CosteaHaven't we... wait. Haven't we seen a situation where Mt. Gox addresses were declared as Craig's?

1:30:38Arthur van PeltYeah, that was, for example, that letter to Blockstream, one of them popped up. And I've seen many forgeries starting in 2013 until recent days. But the majority of his forgeries, where he tried to backdate things with the deeds and loans and mortgages and emails and claims to people what he had or not had, several times Mt. Gox addresses popped up there. Excuse me. WizSec from Japan, to give them the honor that they should have, they already have been posting about those things since 2018.

1:31:27Vlad CosteaYeah, but I do remember some guy from Vaultoro, which is a company that operates with Bitcoin and gold, saying that they are thinking about starting a lawsuit against Craig Wright, because he claimed the address of the Mt. Gox hacker. So by the fact that he has claimed that address, he associated himself with the Mt. Gox hacker, and they might try to extort some of the bitcoins that they lost during the Mt. Gox hack by using this legal proof that was provided in court.

1:32:12Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah, yeah. I did not read that, by the way, that Vaultoro is hinting to that, but let's say they want to try. I'm not sure if Vaultoro is the right party to do that. I mean, Mt. Gox is bankrupt, in bankruptcy, and they have a trustee, a Japanese trustee who is dealing with those things. So one would think that this trustee is the more likely person to start lawsuits here and there, to start reclaiming lost Bitcoin. But what is the thing here? If you look at how Mt. Gox went...

1:32:48It was owned by Jed McCaleb back in 2010, and late, or early... late 2010, early 2011, he decided to get rid of it. Mark Karpelès came around, and in February, I think, they closed the deal that Mark Karpelès would take over, and from February onward the handover phase started and took probably several months to recode and learn about how it all works. And Mark Karpelès also started coding on the thing.

1:33:29And the first hack, the first known hack, was already in that handover phase, on the first of March. That was this 80,000 Bitcoin that was taken from Jed McCaleb's server, because at that moment he was still in charge of... Although it was sold to Mark Karpelès, it was still in the hands and on the server of Jed McCaleb. And they took what is called the hot wallet and took 80,000 Bitcoin from it and transferred it to this now famous 1Feex address. And since that moment, that 1Feex address contains these 80,000, and they have never moved again since March 1.

1:34:10Yeah, and then some dust and stuff. Later more transactions came on the 1Feex address, but it still contains that very first transaction from the hot wallet, which was contained of, if I remember well, 27...

1:34:42Bitcoin addresses, and they grabbed all the Bitcoin from there and put it together on the 1Feex address, which was not controlled by Mt. Gox. Since 2013, when Craig was doing research online and took a block explorer and took the top 100 rich list from Bitcoin, of course he came across that address and he thought, well, let's try it out. Let's mention it in contracts, etc. etc., that I own that. He made several mistakes also, because there were also addresses that the ATO, for example, found out that, yeah, but that has been moved, and then he will quickly say, yeah, but it went different and it was earlier and blah blah blah, and he will just change his story about it.

1:35:35But the 1Feex address, he could keep on claiming here and there that it was his address, because the coins never moved since March 1, 2011. The total Mt. Gox hacks went differently. It was drained, kind of. Again, WizSec published several good articles about it. How Mt. Gox was slowly and steadily over the years, until their bankruptcy, drained almost day after day after day. So that's how... It was in fact more of a continuous hack. And I think that part of the hacks was separate.

1:36:22Probably separate from the hack that happened on March 1, 2011, where those 80,000 were taken, because that was a different type of hack and a one-time hack for 80,000 only. The total, they drained Mt. Gox, if I'm right, for 650,000 bitcoins, and that 80,000 was, yeah, part of it, but maybe by a different hacker.

1:36:52Vlad CosteaSo we are talking of huge amounts of money. That's more bitcoins than, I don't know, most whales have.

1:37:03Arthur van PeltYeah, there are probably whales still owning a few hundred thousand, but I'm quite sure that Craig Wright is not one of them. He claims the Satoshi stash of 820,000. And because this Tulip Trust is also something that we learned during the lawsuit, after many, many, many times questioning Craig about it. But the story as it stands now, and it might change next year or in two years, presuming he's still around, let's hope not: his Tulip Trust has two elements. One element is 820,000 of mined coins.

1:37:45The Satoshi stash. And the other part is what he bought, what he claims that he bought, and this 80,000 that we just talked about on the 1Feex address that everybody knows has been stolen and hacked from Mt. Gox. So everybody who claims it is either the hacker or has contact with the hacker and has been taken ownership of stolen coins, and then you're still in a bad position. But the other part is that he claims that he bought... First, in 2019, Craig claimed that he bought in May and June, that was during a bullish phase in the price of Bitcoin.

1:38:27We know that in that period the price went up to $30 on Mt. Gox. That was at that moment the big place to go to with the most liquidity. And in that time frame, where the price went up, Craig thought, yeah, let's create a story that I bought a lot of bitcoins there. So he claims to have bought 650 to 700,000 bitcoins in May, June. And making him responsible, by his own saying, making him responsible for the bull run in that period. Now, later we learned that he bought it from a kind of OTC desk in Russia.

1:39:14Yeah, then you cannot claim to be responsible of it, because when you are doing OTC deals, then you take mined coins from miners directly and not really from the market, indirectly in an OTC deal. So the story does not make full sense here. But from this 700,000 that he claims to have bought in May, June 2011, with those coins, he said, "Yeah, I did all my business dealings." I set up my companies in Australia and went bankrupt by 2015, called out by the ATO, etc., as a nullity based on sham.

1:39:58Nothing happened there, and everything that you told us here are lies and supported by forgeries. However, he claimed back then that those were the coins that he did his business dealings with, and the remaining coins of those 700,000 is...

1:40:14110,000. And so the 820 and the 110 together is forming the Tulip Trust. That is what he claims. Now, neither of them he ever had private keys to, so he never signed any. And also the ATO asked him one time, "Can you sign all those addresses? And please do it for us." It never happened. The ATO said... because, yeah, always excuses why and why it couldn't and shouldn't happen. And we see the same happen in his claims to the community. "I don't want to sign an address because it doesn't prove anything."

1:40:52Blah, blah, blah. Always excuses. So the 1 million bitcoins contains of two parts. That is what I want to say here. 820 here, 110 there, and the 110 consists of this 1Feex address that we know has been stolen, Mt. Gox coins.

1:41:15Vlad CosteaThat's interesting. So he has done a lot of research to find addresses, basically UTXOs that have these amounts of bitcoins, just to add up to the stash that Satoshi allegedly owns. Except that he has made a fatal error of associating the Mt. Gox address, the 1Feex one, right, with his holdings.

1:41:42Arthur van PeltYeah, but that is not from his Satoshi mined coins, of course. That is a different address. And then we can touch on another subject, because one of my critics on Craig Wright is, if you compare Satoshi with Craig, and we get a little bit... I'm not super technical, so I will not be able to answer every question here, but what for me is quite clear: Satoshi was a good coder. Of course, he made mistakes and had flaws, and they were corrected by others. But he was a good coder.

1:42:11He was clever. He was a bright mind, combining several things that existed previously and mix it to a workable online currency called Bitcoin with a blockchain. I mean, then you are a bright mind. And he shared always his coding in private emails with different peoples. He shared his source code already pretty early in November, even before it was released, so that people could look at it and give him feedback, and so they could put scrutiny on his code. Craig has never, ever done such a thing.

1:42:47I mean, he even has to ask Steve Shadders from nChain, his colleague at nChain, to create this list based on a few specifications on what might be getting close to the Satoshi addresses. That was last year, I think, in roughly June, when he came up with the Steve Shadders list, which contained possible Satoshi addresses, and that was the only meaning of that whole list.

1:43:15Craig never claimed that he had those addresses, but at least he gave an indication that, yeah, my addresses are on this list, but I don't know which one yet, because they're all in the Tulip Trust in a locked encrypted file that I cannot have access to at the moment. But he had to ask Steve Shadders, a more experienced coder, to create a few pages of code to come up with this list based on some specifications. If you are an experienced coder, you can do it yourself and you don't need help from other people.

1:43:55I mean, come on. So it is also quite clear that... This is just one example. There is more than a handful of those type of examples where we can see that if Craig is asked or scrutinized on his coding, he only comes up with silliness. That is little pieces of code that he copy-pasted elsewhere, saying "Hello world." Yeah, that is where you start coding as a noob coder doing online courses. And that is the only level of coding that he can bring.

1:44:28The moment he did some courses, online courses for supercomputers, back in Australia when he was working for CSU and made an online course for them with, I think, four videos, he all the time avoids the coding aspects, and when he cannot avoid it anymore, he just reads from the screen what is written there in coding, and he never explains deeply what the coding is about. He just reads what is on the screen: "And if you do this, then that and that will happen." Yeah, that is written in the screen. You don't have to tell us. Please tell us a bit on a higher level why we should use it here, etc.

1:45:14It's quite clear he's not a coder. He has never been one, and Satoshi was, and he happily shared complicated code, pages and pages full, with Mike Hearn, Hal Finney, Ray Dillinger and all the people that were the OGs back then. And Gavin Andresen, same story, because in court he showed many pages of code exchanges between Gavin and Satoshi. Never happened with Craig Wright, and that is one of the critics that we can give to Gavin Andresen. He never kept on questioning: show me your code, show me your emails where we exchange code and explain it to me.

1:46:03Never happened. One of the three bullets that were never properly addressed in the Gavin Andresen... where Gavin Andresen endorsed Craig Wright.

1:46:18Vlad CosteaSo let me ask you a more personal question. You deal with hundreds of pages of court files.

1:46:25Arthur van PeltThousands.

1:46:26Vlad CosteaSo how do you curate all of this content, and how do you find the time to basically find what's interesting inside it?

1:46:37Arthur van PeltYeah, good question. It's a hobby. It's a time-consuming hobby, and again, I do this with a little bit of the rage that I had still in... I think I can still connect to that rage last year when Hodlonaut was... when they put this 5,000 bounty on him. And if I look at my daily pattern, I have, of course, I have work to do. I have children that I have to bring to school, that I go out with.

1:47:13And then, of course, I don't do anything. But especially the night when my wife goes to bed early, I need way less sleep. So I take several hours of reading, making screenshots, preparing for the next tweet that I will do the next day or a few days later. And it's a lot of reading what I do. How do I make sense of it all? That's the time-consuming part because they don't file everything. Those lawyers know a lot more than I do. And they only file when they think it's needed.

1:47:49The depositions are being filed months and months, sometimes half a year or a year later than they were taken. Because there were also depositions in early 2019 already, but we only learned about them more recently. I work with several keywords because, for example, when you do Tulip Trust... When I want to know everything about the Tulip Trust, I can do a query on Tulip Trust, give me all the material on Tulip Trust, and then I pick out the depositions where they ask questions about Tulip Trust, or I find the motions where they mention Tulip Trust.

1:48:28And then I narrow down all the thousands, because you say hundreds, believe me, it are thousands and thousands of pages that they file. I mean, some depositions can already be 400 pages, one deposition, so it's quite a lot of material that you have to try to digest. But I work with queries, and with those queries I can quickly take the information that I need. I read, and my mindset has grown. It was a process, but since probably a year already...

1:49:05My mindset is on a timeline. If I can make sense of it in a timeline, knowing that when he learned about Bitcoin in 2011 and started his fraud in 2013, I can quickly put it in this timeline, that I know, okay, this forgery, ah, this is again a forgery that he did in 2013. Ah, this is a lie and a claim that he did in 2015, but that makes sense because he wants to fill a gap in 2008 or 2009 or 2010 or '11 or '12. It's always a backdated thing, and when you learn thinking like that, it becomes more easy to digest the...

1:49:49Yeah, the complicated thing that it is, but it always comes back to: he learned about it in 2011 and he started the fraud in 2013. And everything adds to this picture, everything that I come across. There is nothing that I've seen so far that is breaking this story. The timeline shifts a little because I, say, two months ago, I found out that, no, because last year it was my idea that Craig started his fraud after Dave Kleiman died. Which is effectively still true, because the forgeries were still created starting in the second half of 2013 and onward.

1:50:38But I found out that, or I found indications that he already started his Bitcoin ideas in late 2012. So I shifted my timeline from late 2012. Where previously I thought that he started his Bitcoin ideas in April 2013.

1:51:04When he first started to buy his first Bitcoin on Mt. Gox, because in 2013 he bought 50 bitcoins to start testing out the environment, how it worked. And in April 2013 and in November 2013 he did a few trades and obtained roughly 50 bitcoins. And he pulled them back and paid, I think, Uyen Nguyen, he paid a bit, and he left, I think, 15 or 16 bitcoins on Mt. Gox, and he lost them in the crash of February 2014 again. But so I moved the goalpost only little, but so far everything adds to the same story.

1:51:51He started a fraud in July 2013. That's where he started building up his Bitcoin holding stories that he never had. And he started his fake Satoshi stories that never came true.

1:52:08Vlad CosteaSo, do you ever ask yourself if any of this research is worth it and if you're going to make a difference with it? Because you spend so many hours every day just researching these court files.

1:52:23Arthur van PeltYeah, no, not every day, but yeah, several days a week. I spend several hours per day on it. No, it's personal interest. Like I said, my trigger is injustice. And when I see injustice happening, I see injustice happening to people like Adam Back, Hodlonaut, Peter McCormack, and I feel the urge to support their cases, their legal cases.

1:52:53It's not a secret that many lawyers are following me. The whole Kleiman camp, I mean the main, Kyle Roche and Vel Freedman, are following me on Twitter. So I'm sure that my findings reach them. And if they can use it, please do. Here and there I... They will never say it, of course, because they will say the Bitcoin community is helping us. But I know already that they probably have my name in mind, among other people that are also posting a lot about this.

1:53:24And I might be more focused, and yeah, you can call it obsessed. I don't call it obsessed. It's personal interest, and to fix an injustice that is going on in the Bitcoin community. Because, yeah, let's be honest, this guy is damaging investors, taxpayers. He is fooling people who invest either in BSV or in other things around him.

1:53:58He tried to scam the ATO for 100 million. This is still a dangerous person. This needs to be called out, and until it stops, he needs to find his master. Hopefully in court. So when I know that lawyers, and like I said, I mentioned two, but there are many more following me on Twitter, and I don't know from which counsels they are, if they are from Hodlonaut's counsel, if they come from Peter McCormack or other counsels, I don't know. But as long as my research is helping the court cases against Craig Wright, yeah, I'm already very proud.

1:54:46Vlad CosteaYet it's interesting that this is the first English podcast that you do.

1:54:53Arthur van PeltYeah, it is. I did a few Dutch podcasts and they were well received, I have to say. And the funny thing is, always different questions and different angles. And it's pretty cool. But I never did an English podcast, like an interview. Last year, I did for Bitcoin Club Malta a presentation where I tried to do...

1:55:22An overview, which was about an hour, if I remember well. Yeah, and it was also well received. I think they had almost 2,000 views on it, while other more well-known OGs in the Bitcoin space only had a few hundred views. So people are waiting for this story, and in a run-up to this interview with you... And I'm happy that you did it, Vlad, and I mean that, because I had many requests, based on the good reviews on my Dutch podcast, that please do it in English because we don't understand Dutch.

1:56:02Vlad CosteaYeah, I'm happy I got to have you and I found out more about what you do and how you conduct your research. But at the same time, I'm intrigued, you know, because there are so many more popular podcasts than this one that could have had you as a guest, but they did not.

1:56:21Arthur van PeltNo, I've been in touch with Peter McCormack. He said, "I cannot do podcasts with you now. I would love to do it, but I cannot because I'm in a lawsuit myself with the guy." It's a bit of a dangerous place to be if he would have me.

1:56:40Vlad CosteaWell, he's not the only one. That's what I'm implying.

1:56:44Arthur van PeltYeah, yeah, of course. But it has to fit the type of podcast that he's doing. And again, I know from Peter that he would love to have me, but he cannot. I think he's being advised by his lawyers, "Please do not touch the Craig Wright subject too much, because you're in the middle of a lawsuit, and it can and might work against you if you do that." Other podcasts are more technical and more economical, or otherwise with a very different angle, less so the social aspects of Bitcoin.

1:57:22Because that's where I think this mostly is. An attack, Craig Wright is an attack, a large attack, a social attack on Bitcoin, and it should be called out. I call myself on Twitter the sniper in the backyard of Bitcoin, because that's truly how I see myself. I try to guard that those people, those dangerous people, do not fully enter the backyard of Bitcoin. And I'm trying to protect the fences there while the Bitcoin train is moving forward from the front yard. And that will happen.

1:58:03And many other people, hundreds, if not thousands of people, developers, people making infrastructure. I love to see what's happening on Lightning Network. I just enlisted myself for the beta or alpha, I don't know how they call it, for Bottlepay, for example. I mean, I love it. That's also what I do, testing things for Lightning Network. But the backyard, where people try to enter and try to kill or damage the reputation of Bitcoin, and Craig Wright is for me the biggest example. I love doing it. I do it with, yeah, with passion, so to say.

1:58:56Vlad CosteaYeah, and I did see and I did read a lot of your posts on Twitter. They pop up in my feed quite often. And you also get a lot of engagement, which helps spread the message.

1:59:09Arthur van PeltYeah, my tweets reach, I think, this year already, several handfuls of articles when people find interesting things. Lately it has become more quiet, because I think what I see is, like you struggle with this: should I pay attention to it? Because if we do, we might spread the wrong message. And I think the media is also struggling with this. On one hand, when I have a nice soundbite about something that calls them out quickly, then they can jump on it, and then my tweet is mentioned in an article. I think it happens around 20, 25 times already this year. But the full-blown story, like we are now, I think, probably talking for about two hours...

2:00:09Vlad CosteaYeah, two hours exactly.

2:00:11Arthur van PeltTo have it in writing, it takes a lot of time, it takes effort, and it needs a special type of podcast where this is possible. And it needs a special type of media that does not go by soundbites, but that goes by the full story. But it is a long story. It is a detailed story. It has so many elements, hilarious elements, sad elements, disgusting elements, because I also find it, for example, very disgusting that the guy is using dead people in his scam and that he is abusing the good name of Hal Finney and other people in and around...

2:00:55The Bitcoin industry. And Craig Wright makes a mess of it, and he scolds them and he calls them out, or he changes their story or their influence or... And that I found, yeah, pretty disgusting.

2:01:13Vlad CosteaBut yeah, no doubt that he damages the legacy of a lot of people who probably don't want to or wouldn't want to get involved in any of this situation. But I was thinking right now, as you are mentioning that you get on podcasts so that you spread your message because you don't have enough time to write about all of it, maybe we can arrange something to have this interview transcribed, so that there's going to be a transcription of every word that you said published on my website, and you can also get it and get parts of it or anything and publish it. Do whatever you want with it, just so this doesn't go to waste. And it also has the proper search engine optimization.

2:01:59Arthur van PeltYeah, I know many people. I mean, when I announced that you had invited me and that you had set a date for the recording, I think I got more than 100 likes. I mean, my normal tweets get 10, 20 likes, and when I'm lucky, maybe 50. But when this podcast was announced, I got more than 100 likes, and I know already that people are waiting for this, and I'm quite sure that you will have a few thousand listeners again, if hopefully more. This message is worthwhile sharing, so that people are not fooled by this guy, because if you put money in it, you might lose it all when this whole scheme is going to collapse.

2:02:57When Calvin Ayre is pulling himself from the whole thing, when he is not sponsoring it anymore. When Craig Wright is going to jail or when in the lawsuits he is losing and he's being called out. It's a high risk environment, that whole BSV thing. Especially when you believe, appeal to authority, and when you join a cult, because I call it a cult right now, the Craig Wright cult, the BSV cult, the hardcore believers, are being fooled into a pipe dream. It's sad to say, but it is true. It's sad that people believe this guy who is nothing more than a sloppy con man, who happens to have grown into a story because it was convenient for him to play the Satoshi role in his tax scam, to explain his large holdings that he had offshore in an unknown trust, which was later grown into the Tulip Trust, because then he really needed a trust, a real life trust.

2:04:09To avoid paying 1.6 million dollars in GST in Australia. But it's worthwhile sharing. So I hope we reach our audience here, Vlad.

2:04:23Vlad CosteaYeah, I just saw that we got a reply from Adam Back who said that summaries are always useful, even for stories that are well known, so that people just remember what has been happening. I did not see this, but then again, this is your account, it's your mentions. I did not follow closely to see what's going on. So I'm happy that we got a shout out from Professor Back.

2:04:48Arthur van PeltYeah, I think he even retweeted some stuff about it. He also retweeted, for example, I remember a few weeks ago when somebody suggested that I should be on the What Bitcoin Did podcast of Peter McCormack, that Adam Back, I think, retweeted it.

2:05:13Vlad CosteaThat's nice of him. Anyway, I'm thinking right now that all of this work that you're doing deserves some, you know, reward or something of some sorts. So usually the arrangement for my podcast is that if I get any donation for the episode, you're going to get half of it. But in this particular situation, I want you to get like 90%.

2:05:40Arthur van PeltOh, that's pretty cool. I hardly ask for donation, although I do have a Bitcoin address for donation. Because yeah, every now and then people reach out and say we want to donate something. My main goal is to help the people like Peter McCormack and Hodlonaut. And I would be very proud to see them use my stuff in court or around court in their cases. I hope Craig Wright is being called out in Kleiman v. Wright in the right way that he's still not Satoshi at the end of this lawsuit when it ends in October, or at least the trial.

2:06:26It's probably not over then. But yeah, thank you, Vlad. Nice. It's not needed. Maybe when I get sued, no, probably not based on this podcast, but if ever needed, then people will know and then probably the same will happen as happened with Hodlonaut and Peter McCormack. I mean, they found sponsors at some time for those costly lawsuits. But yeah, again, I don't see that happen in my case.

2:07:00Vlad CosteaLet's hope not, because even if we can afford the lawsuit, allegedly or hypothetically, it's still, you know, a lot of time that you're wasting going to court and preparing your arguments and all of that mental energy that you're wasting just thinking about the fact that somebody on the other side of the world is suing you for something that they can't even prove. And I suppose in the cases of Peter and Hodlonaut, it's about exploiting some specific jurisdiction provisions so that when you defame somebody, when you say something nasty about some other person, it's all about how you prove it. In the United Kingdom, as far as I can understand, I'm not a lawyer...

2:07:53The burden of proof is on Peter McCormack. So yeah.

2:08:01Arthur van PeltYeah, I did not fully research those lawsuits yet because we only hear about them occasionally. Roughly once every three to six months we sometimes hear, and it's always the same story: that Craig Wright is losing them or has to pay the costs of the counterparty suing him, or, sorry, because I think he paid for Adam Back, he paid for Roger Ver. Vitalik, I don't know if he paid something there. But the bills so far, the legal bills in this case, always were paid for the closed suits, have been paid...

2:08:49By Craig. And when it is fully starting, because I think when the libel suit started, the first question is: am I in the right jurisdiction? Now, for example, Hodlonaut made a good move there. He immediately started countersuing from Norway where he lives, and it ended up that recently an appeal in England was lost by Craig and won by Hodlonaut in Norway, also at the same time. So it looks like the whole case is going to move to Norway, with very different libel laws. Because England is quite famous for, like you said, you can somewhat more easily start a libel suit in England and get away with it.

2:09:45While other countries are more strict and more severe. But when somebody has an opinion, an opinion does not have to mean that it is libel straight away. Yeah.

2:10:01Vlad CosteaAnd our opinions, if we call them like that, are at least based on documents that are publicly available. I don't think anything of what we have said during this recording is not documented.

2:10:15Arthur van PeltOh yeah, absolutely, absolutely. Every claim that I make, every number that I mention, every person that I mention, I can refer back to proof, to exhibits, evidence. Every time that I say this is a forgery or not, I can have Dr. Edman, I can have other people calling it out why they think it is a forgery. For example, it's one of those lovely examples that Craig Wright sends an email to Dave Kleiman somewhere early 2008 asking him to help with the white paper. Yeah, and when at some point somebody finds out, yeah, but you sent an email on a domain that was not even available under your name, only as early as January 2009 when he bought that domain.

2:11:20Then how is it possible that you start sending emails eight, nine or ten months earlier to Dave Kleiman from that domain? That means the email is a forgery. Every time when I say all the emails that we know of and that claim to be genuine emails exchanged between people that should support Craig's Satoshi story, it has all been called out. There is nothing genuine before April 2013 that supports the Craig Wright is Satoshi Nakamoto story. I can give handfuls of examples of it, referring back to many sources. And one of the main sources is of course Kleiman v. Wright, because they hired an expert there, Dr. Edman, and he did a lot of research on Bitmessage, on all those things that Craig created to support his stories, and the metadata and the dates and the fonts and all kinds of things that it has been called out. It are forgeries.

2:12:22So if we call Craig Wright a liar and a fraud, yeah, because he's been called in court like that also.

2:12:32Vlad CosteaRight. I mean W-R-I-G-H-T. Yes. So Mr. Arthur van Pelt, is there anything that you would like to add? I mean, I feel like you should promote your website once again. It's added to your description on Twitter, and your Twitter account is @MyLegacyKit.

2:12:56Arthur van PeltYeah, MyLegacyKit. If people want to follow me, then please do on Twitter, because that is my main source of where I put my information. I try to do daily updates on things or thoughts or considerations that I put there. Although I'm now in a somewhat time-consuming thing, which is the more detailed timeline. So I might be less active on Twitter, which only means that instead of four tweets per day, I go back to two or one tweet per day. So you will still have your content.

2:13:35And what is also worthwhile is scroll down my feed, because especially last year, somewhere in March, I think, when those libel suits started and I ramped up my research, I did many long tweets, how do you call them, tweetstorms about subjects, and... I love doing them, the long form things, because you can get into a little bit more details then. And on my main page of Twitter, you will find the link to the website. It's a bit of a complicated Weebly subsite, happily given to me by a friend in Australia.

2:14:17Vlad CosteaIt's seekingsatoshi.weebly.com and you have the entire hashtag fake Satoshi fraud timeline. Yeah, and I can see that you go as far as 2001.

2:14:30Arthur van PeltYeah, but this has been the work of now more than a year that I put there, and I update every now and then, every one, two, three months, I put new links and new information there. Mostly I always try to make a tweet about it that I've done updates and where. Also, I updated the last few months with more court findings and links to other people's tweets who found out things, or called out things, that is handy to know. But yeah, you can already see on the page it's lengthy.

2:15:09It's a lot of information that will support not only my opinion, but 99% of the opinion out there of the people in the know. They do not support the idea that Craig Wright is Satoshi. But if you want to have evidence of that, then this page is already handy. And like I said, I'm creating a second page with even more detailed information that will exactly date the forgery, where it is used and how it has been called out and by who, et cetera. But that is something ongoing that will take a few weeks more to finalize.

2:15:56Vlad CosteaYeah, it looks good. And when I think about it's like 20 years of Craig Wright's life that you documented. That's impressive.

2:16:04Arthur van PeltYeah, it's all links to, I cannot say the right percentage, but let's say half of it are my own tweets, but the other half is either media articles that are interesting to know, that will give you more information, or very interesting blog posts by people that technically called out his signings. You just mentioned one, which was indeed a great and highly anticipated article by Jameson Lopp. You will find that all the way down the page. At the bottom, you will find the links to the court cases of Jimmy in Kleiman v.

2:16:48Wright and the court case of Craig Wright himself, and that will open up a new box of Pandora of information, where I only put the highlights in the timeline, but the whole court case is publicly available because of the law in America to make it public and to spread as much court information as possible. And CourtListener is helping with that. And the link to CourtListener, two links in this case, but one to the Jimmy case, which was a subcase of the main case, Jimmy Nguyen and the Craig Wright case since 2018.

2:17:37Thousands and thousands of pages of information, but who wants to do the research himself and go beyond my highlights that I post in the timeline? Yeah, then the link is all the way down that Weebly page.

2:17:53Vlad CosteaOkay, I checked it. It looks good. You have all the links. They lead to court files or to sources that are legit. I don't see any forgeries so far, but if I do, I'll let you know.

2:18:10Arthur van PeltYeah, no, you might, because the page is already like one year old. And although I update with new things, I do not check: is the link still active? So you might come across a link that is not operational anymore because somebody who wrote a blog post in, let's say, 2016 as a response to one of the signing sessions, and gave all the detailed technical information about why and how it is being called out that the signing session never happened and was a bamboozlement from here to Tokyo, and this article is put offline by the original author, yeah, then my link might not work. If that happens, there is a contact button on top somewhere where you can reach out to me and I will receive your message. And if people have information themselves that is missed by me or that should be corrected by me, please feel free to reach out on Twitter or on that contact button on that web page.

2:19:25Then I'm happy to correct things where needed.

2:19:31Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if you understood the joke. It was about finding your forgeries, because you're obsessed.

2:19:37Arthur van PeltI got that. Yeah. But yeah, my character is sometimes that I take things a little bit serious. Nah, I got it, Vlad.

2:19:45Vlad CosteaI mean, yeah, you should take everything seriously because this is about the lives of a lot of people. And a lot of people have been harmed by the simple involvement of Craig Wright into the space, starting from Bitcoin Belle to Gavin Andresen, and everyone who vouched for him along the way has basically got dragged down and lost reputation.

2:20:12Arthur van PeltYeah. Yeah.

2:20:13Vlad CosteaAnd in more recent years, it's about Bitcoin developers getting attacked, and also community members who were just popular at the time and called him out. And I suppose they have spent more than a year just spending money on lawyers and going to court. And even if they did not, you know, take or this did not take a lot of time, it's still something that doesn't let you sleep at night, you know?

2:20:46Arthur van PeltYeah, and I also get responses on Twitter, that why is this guy not in jail yet? Why does it take so long? And yeah, that is because the mills of law in Australia and America, they are going slow. But in my opinion, quite thorough. Because if you read the reports of 2016, where the ATO came with their first findings, the first final findings of the early, early years, because Craig backdated things to 2012-13 fiscal year, and the final reports of that became available in 2006, yeah, 2016, and if you see what they did, it's amazing. It's amazing. Just to give you one example, just one silly example again.

2:21:45In his claim to the ATO, he said, "I have been paying a bill of $2 million, slightly more, $2 million to Professor Rees," which was David Rees, a guy, I think, from England. I think he died in 2013, if I'm right. So he was very old. He was, I think, 94 when he died.

2:22:15But at that moment, Craig claimed that David Rees was somebody helping with the software and with the fine-tuning of mathematics in the software, etc., that was later used in Bitcoin. And in 2012 somewhere, he supposedly sent a bill of $2 million to Craig Wright, who paid him back in Bitcoin. Now, the guy was like 90 plus years old. What did the ATO do? They called his family and they interviewed his sisters and other people in the family. They called his accountant and they interviewed his accountant, etc. And it turns out that they summarized in one of those reports, they summarized the whole David Rees findings.

2:23:10And nobody ever heard of Craig Wright. And they said, "Yeah, but the guy was losing his brains." He was having, I'm not sure if it was Alzheimer, but he was not in his best state in the last few years before he died. And then he will send an invoice a few days before his death to Craig Wright about his Bitcoin involvement. The guy was not even using computers for a long, long, long, long time anymore. This is just not possible.

2:23:40And if you see how thorough they do those things over the years, then you start understanding that it takes between three to five years before you have a full picture of all the crazy things that Craig Wright has been doing, because it's not only complicated and sophisticated, but somehow all sloppy, but still kind of sophisticated, I'll give him that. But it takes years to research and to properly call it out and see all the angles, and especially the legal angles.

2:24:19It's also the case with the libel suits. It takes a long, long while before they figured out what is the jurisdiction even for this case. Is it England? Is it Norway? Is it elsewhere? And it took already a year, a year plus, for, in this case, for Hodlonaut to figure it out that the case should be moved, without even going into the content of the claims, that the jurisdiction should go to Norway. Then you can have another appeal and another disagreement about it. And it takes ages, those things.

2:24:57Yeah, it's like that. We cannot do anything about it. But I'm sure that Craig will meet his master someday. Either this year or next year, Kleiman v. Wright will most likely not go very well for him. In trial, they will figure out that this guy is indeed a big fraud. With or without partnership, the Kleiman estate has been frauded upon big times, and it will cost Craig money. That, for me, I'm quite sure about it.

2:25:34Vlad CosteaYeah, it's delicate because in this world, the more money you have, the more free you become and the more freedoms you can enjoy. So if you can afford to just throw a lot of money at lawyers to defend you and basically play 4D chess, I think that's a popular idiom in the BSV community, that he's playing 4D chess. If you're playing 4D chess in multiple jurisdictions at the same time, you can easily bamboozle people's minds, and you can prolong all of this process for whatever...

2:26:13It takes, you know. And you're going to exhaust everyone around you. And if you can afford it, you can carry on like this. I guess it can take 10 years, maybe. And we can still find out new reveals about what he has been up to. We can still see new stories. And at the same time, I suppose they can still operate BSV and try to say it's actually Bitcoin, while one party owns 80% of mining operations and nodes automatically because, you know, in big block world, miners are also the only nodes.

2:26:52Arthur van PeltYeah, and that's also the reason why I do not fully agree with people who think that, yeah, better ignore it. Yeah, then it becomes a kind of a cancer that is still growing. If you do not call it out properly, if you do not give access to the appropriate information about this situation, then a lie is being repeated many times, alongside you and around you, and will reach people that could have benefited also with your information, calling out the lie or the misinformation that is being spread.

2:27:35And that's why I think, at least for myself, I can give myself, yeah, the compliment that I still do it for a good reason, several reasons. I just mentioned the lawsuits in the libel cases, but also that at least the people have access to information. If it reaches them is another story, but it's there and it's available, so people do not have to be fooled. And the lesser people who are being fooled, and the lesser people who are losing their, you just mentioned it, the money and their reputation.

2:28:12Vlad CosteaYeah. And this is sad, but it's happening. Part of me is happy that I get to help you spread the message. The other side of me is a bit concerned about the backlash from the BSV camp and, you know, I can get sued and I'm not going to like it. But whatever, I feel like promoting truth in itself is a greater virtue than just being silent and watching from aside and waiting for somebody else to fix the problem for you.

2:28:46Arthur van PeltYeah, again, I'm not so much afraid of it. I had already a few articles in Modern Consensus that has been read by the lawyer of Craig, who responded that I have no idea what I'm talking about. So they know about me. They know what is my stance. And as long as you keep it factual and base your opinion on facts, then it is not libel or any other, how do you call it? It's not illegal what you're doing. It's not slandering. It's not defamation. It's not libel. It's having an opinion based on rather detailed facts.

2:29:33And no lawyer, or every lawyer will say, "We cannot attack those people." I mean, when, for example, a very different story, but when the Panama Papers and the Paradise Papers leaked, and people, journalists, etc., they start writing about those things, and they never got sued by people involved and mentioned in those Panama and Paradise Papers. I mean, you bring factual information. That is your role as a reporter, as a journalist, as a podcaster. That should always be in the freedom of speech. Come on, that should never be libel or something like that.

2:30:22Vlad CosteaRight. I also want to give a shout out to Saburo Noboru or something. His name is "name cannot be blank." And he mentioned in the comments that listening to my podcast is like watching grass grow, and it's boring and it hasn't picked up. I mean, probably he never listened to an episode, but I just wanted to give him a shout out because he mentioned this would be the most listened episode ever. Which might be the case, but I've also had some popular ones, and I'm the only podcaster who ever got Slush.

2:31:00Arthur van PeltI've been to podcasts of you. I remember with Adam Back, for example, they were highly anticipated also.

2:31:10Vlad CosteaI didn't do Adam Back.

2:31:11Arthur van Pelt?

2:31:12Vlad CosteaI didn't have Adam Back as a guest.

2:31:14Arthur van PeltNo, but you talked about Adam Back and being Satoshi and those things a few weeks ago, if I remember well.

2:31:22Vlad CosteaOh yeah, that was a YouTube video, not a podcast.

2:31:24Arthur van PeltYeah, okay, yeah, true.

2:31:26Vlad CosteaAnyway, I'm really happy that we got to do this. I feel like I've also learned something new from you, and I hope that the listeners, given that... Whoa, we have been talking for two hours and a half, so that's a lot of content to digest. But let me give you a tip. Both of us are, you know, slow talkers. We don't talk very fast. You can listen at 1.5x speed, and you're going to get all the information in less time.

2:32:02Arthur van PeltYup.

2:32:03Vlad CosteaOr 2x, depends on how fast you are at thinking. But anyway, Arthur van Pelt, I'm very happy once again that we got to do this. If there is anything that you'd like to say as a closing statement?

2:32:20Arthur van PeltNo, we have spoken about basically everything, and people who want to go into the detail, please read...

2:32:26Vlad CosteaOh, no, it's not basically everything.

2:32:28Arthur van PeltMyLegacyKit...

2:32:29Vlad CosteaJust let me clarify. We didn't even get into the sister situation or the uncle situation or all of that, you know, tangled up family drama. And I avoided it on purpose because, you know, sometimes when you have a family member who is in trouble, you want to help them. I'm not blaming these people.

2:32:50Arthur van PeltYeah, I do a little. The uncle, I cannot say too much because that was somebody who popped up only recently in one deposition, and he might be bamboozled himself also. But others, like his sister and his niece, they spread stories like, yeah, the central banks are interested in BSV. They spread misinformation like, yeah, Craig programmed the halvings on my birthday and other family members' birthdays. I mean, come on.

2:33:29Vlad CosteaYeah, but I just don't want to get there. No, like these people are just stuck with a family member who chose to do something, and they can either ignore it or, I don't know, they can try to defend him publicly.

2:33:45Arthur van PeltTrue. No, but then I have nothing to add at this moment. I'm happy that you had me, Vlad.

2:33:53Vlad CosteaYeah, so follow Arthur @MyLegacyKit on Twitter. If you'd like to support the podcast, I think the best deed that you can do is to help me transcribe this interview, so that it's going to be available in written format for anyone who searches for specific keywords on the internet. And also you can make donations to the podcast. You can make donations to Arthur because his research is invaluable to the community, and he has his own address. I have some of mine on the website. I don't know, just do whatever you think. Use the information however you please. Please don't sue us because that would be a waste of everyone's time and money. Yeah.

2:34:41And yeah, that's all I had to say. I don't know what else I should be saying. This is the season finale. I started out talking about security and I ended up talking about Craig Wright. I don't know how this computes. But okay, thank you for listening.

2:34:56Arthur van PeltThank you, Vlad.

2:34:56================================================================================ Production notes: Remote two-person interview recorded as the Season 5 finale. Arthur is a non-native English speaker (Dutch) and it is his first English-language podcast. There is a brief music/watermark artifact at the start and no sponsor reads. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 9 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (207 chunks) and 46 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021", "Bye." and "Thank you." hallucinations; split Arthur's greeting/backchannels and the ATO answer out of Vlad's turns; restored dropped passages from second ASR/re-check (emotional/financial scam lines, narrowing of libel cases, end-of-2012 business ideas, "sophisticated... sloppy tax fraud for pretty large amounts", ATO reports, "testing the waters"); fixed Hodlonaut, libel, Wired, Satoshi Nakamoto, Roger Ver, Adam Back, Calvin Ayre, Kleiman v. Wright, Tulip Trust, Faketoshi, self-doxx, defamation, sue/guppy, Bitcoin Core, Torsten Hoffmann; Fixed names (Dave Kleiman, W&K, Sunbiz, Kleiman v. Wright, Gavin Andresen, Stefan Matthews, Calvin Ayre, nChain, Bitcoin Belle, Michele Seven, MyLegacyKit, Craig Wright for "Craig Pelley"/"CreateGrade"/"great right", self-doxx); removed "Thank you for watching"/"Thank you" hallucinations and "New York" garble; restored dropped text (100 million fraud sentence, Weebly link, "that has been published", scaling debate); moved "No, not met" to Arthur; split long monologues; Removed hallucinations ("Thank you for watching...", "The first part of the video...", podcast blurb, "Thanks for watching!", "Thank you.", "Bye.", "Euromaster Corporation"); split Vlad/Arthur backchannels and reattributed (00:35:59 "No.", 00:40:13, 00:40:58 Ghana line, 00:43:41, 00:43:55); restored dropped words from second ASR/re-check (libel suits, Lisbon, Bitcoin Core developers clause, nChain portfolio, lawyer bills); fixed names: Szabo, Trace Mayer, Michele Seven/Bitcoin Belle, Calvin Ayre, nChain, Vitalik, Hodlonaut, Wladimir van der Laan, Kleiman v. Wright, Ira Kleiman, Tulip Trust, SourceForge, Turing complete, tax scam, 2018 patents year; Fixed Judge Reinhart, Ira Kleiman, Calvin Ayre, Hal Finney, Paul Le Roux/Solotshi, Kleiman v. Wright, Bodog, Mt. Gox, Tulip Trust, CoinX, Microsoft Patch Tuesday; restored dropped text from second ASR (Beth Bloom agreed, Blockstream letter, forgeries line, redaction, "total picture", emails line); removed hallucinations "The following is a story about a man who" and "Thank you."; split Arthur's backchannel inside Vlad's Le Roux turn; removed fillers; Removed hallucinations ("Satoshi Nakamoto, Research..." metadata leak, "Thank you for watching/Please subscribe", "The world's largest cryptocurrency exchange", stray "Thank you"); restored dropped speech from second ASR (complete new network, BitcoinTalk/README/Hal Finney tweet, "Way below 10%", ATO criminal investigation passage, Dorian Nakamoto/Newsweek exchange, "benefit from his actions"); fixed Patch Tuesday, archive.today, Cracked, InSecure and Generally Broken, Hal Finney, Wladimir van der Laan, ONTIER, Kleiman v. Wright, Ira Kleiman, wallet.dat, minds, centralist; speaker split for Arthur's "Yeah, that's it" and "Oh yeah, but"; Removed hallucinations ("Thank you.", "Transcript by www.transcription-in-contact.com", "Bye."); fixed "Can you read the question, Vlad?" as Arthur's request; moved Vlad's trailing "Yeah

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00