S6 E3: Luis Ploennig on Bitcoin in South America & Indacoin
Search this conversation
0:47Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to Season 6 Episode 3 of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today has never ever ever ever been on a Bitcoin podcast. So, if you're hearing him today, it's the first time and it's something exclusive that you will not hear somewhere else for some while until somebody figures out how to steal him and get him to talk about similar topics. But I get to be first and I take the bragging rights for that. His name is Luis Ploennig or Ploennig.
1:24I'm not sure how you pronounce that. He's going to tell us the story. But the essential part is that he's the growth director of Indacoin. You can follow him on Twitter @Plucoinz, P-L-U-C-O-I-N-Z. He's from Mexico and he's trying to spread adoption in Latin America. So, hello Luis.
1:48Luis PloennigHi Vlad, thank you so much for the introduction. Actually your pronunciation was really okay. So, well, first of all, thank you for having me in your space. As you can imagine, I'm a little bit nervous because it's my first time in a podcast, but I've been following you for quite some time and I'm really excited about it and thank you so much. So let's start, right?
2:18Vlad CosteaYeah, I just realized that I wasn't following you, so I just followed you on Twitter. I have no idea why.
2:24Luis PloennigYeah, don't worry, I'm not really good on the crypto Twitter, I don't have a lot of followers, but it's a space that I need to improve. But I'm jealous of your number of followers, you're quite of a sensation there.
2:44Vlad CosteaI'm not a sensation, but I used to work in media, so I got to interact with a lot of people, and some people just followed me to read my articles, and I built some following. I mean, it's inevitable, and I spend way too much time on Twitter. I think I'm addicted, but I don't want to admit it.
3:05Luis PloennigI think, yeah, all the crypto Twitter, it's really addictive right now, especially in these times, it's super, super moving. Like, there is so many developments that it's hard to keep on and it's just scroll to scroll to scroll, you know.
3:24Vlad CosteaYes. So, Luis, you are from Mexico. What is Bitcoin like in Mexico?
3:29Luis PloennigWell, it's kind of complicated because, as you know, we are a really big country. We have 125 million people. But the banking solutions and the adoption of new technologies, it's really hard. So I believe, and correct me if someone correct me, but there is like around more than 6 million people unbanked in the country, you know, 60 million people without bank accounts and that's kind of crazy. So when the adoption of Bitcoin comes, it is hard to inform the people, like actually first to explain what is Bitcoin and what's the use for it and then to integrate them in the system to get Bitcoin, right?
4:25Because a lot of people, they don't have bank accounts, so you have to take away, like, buying it from exchanges, buying it from there, because there are these, especially low-income class, like, they are based on other necessities. There is a big group or kind of a big group of Bitcoin in the country. Mainly we have two exchanges, three. We have Bitso, we have Tauros and Volabit. I mean, they have really good volumes, especially Bitso. Bitso is kind of the exchange from Latin America.
5:11They have service in Argentina and Mexico, and I believe they also have a lot of remittances from our fellow immigrant friends in the United States. So mainly the use of Bitcoin in Mexico has been done for remittances, remittances of the immigrants that they go to work to either United States or other countries or Canada, and they send money to their families in Mexico.
5:43Vlad CosteaThat's actually interesting because in many countries, this narrative of banking the unbanked has been dead since like 2015 or something when they realized that the fees are getting high and it's not sustainable to do on-chain payments. But I can see why it's coming back, as we have side chains, we have second layers, we have different ways of transferring Bitcoin. And provably, Bitcoin has a greater value right now than it ever has. It's more recognized. It's the right tool for the right time during these times of inflation. So, yeah, I can see why the unbanked would actually want to have this kind of money.
6:27Luis PloennigCorrect. I mean, it works as a tool, as a system of value. And in Mexico, it works really good. Why? Because first of all, like, let's go just initially to the remittance side, okay? Like remittance... Usually an immigrant in the United States, what they use is Western Union, you know, like Western Union or other type of remittance, and Western Union can take up to 20% of the money that you send to Mexico. So the fees that they have are really, really crazy. Whereas in crypto, I mean, of course, you need this on-ramp, off-ramp for crypto, right?
7:14Like, change it, like crypto to fiat, but the fees are not as high as, you know, this up to 20 or 18 percent at Western Union, so it makes it like a really good, stable, secure, safe and fast, an effective matter to send money to your family. So there's been a big increase on that, and with other, like, not only Bitcoin, but with other type of currencies, there's been an implementation of new platforms and new projects that they promise to be really fast and reliable, much better than the traditional finance. So that's on the term of the remittance.
8:02And then we have the similar, but not as hard as Venezuela or Argentina, the term of inflation, right? Because right now dollar against euro, it's kind of low, but if you compare Mexican peso to dollar, it drops substantially. So a lot of people, they rather have assurance to have money on Bitcoin to have a kind of stability than to have it in Mexican pesos, as well take it as a way of investment.
8:36Vlad CosteaSo just for the record, what is the inflation rate in Mexico and in other Latin American countries?
8:44Luis PloennigWell, in Mexico, I need to check right now the inflation rate, but there was a drop against the dollar for about 20% since the corona. So, I mean, it's kind of hard. It's not hyperinflation like in Venezuela, you know, or Argentina. Especially in Venezuela, I traveled there quite some time, I know the country really good. Two years ago I traveled there and I mean, I used to have to travel with a baggage full of money, which represented, it was full of bills, but it only represented $50, you know?
9:27And every day you have to check, or every, like, three hours the exchange rate would change, and then, like, it was from 45,000 bolívares to 50,000 and then 80,000 and then there is no stop. So a lot of people that they get the pay day, they will change it just for food or for basic necessities because it's a liability to have just bolívares in your wallet, you know, every time it's depreciating. Mexico is not like that. We have a good economy, like a stable economy, but always there is like an inflation against the US dollar. That's for sure.
10:13Vlad CosteaYeah, and I can imagine in these times when the US dollar gets inflated and they print more money to give these, what do you call them? Support checks, what did they call them?
10:22Luis PloennigYeah, yeah. Exactly.
10:24Vlad CosteaYeah, so during the pandemic they gave each US citizen $1,800, I think, and today they are in talks to give even more to all families, because they were out of work and some people just needed the money to survive. But that was not money collected from taxes. It was not money from the reserves. It was money that they printed specifically for this purpose. And it's likely that they also printed more to pump Wall Street, which today Nasdaq is at a new all-time high. So it's going to be interesting to see how it all plays out. Even Warren Buffett, who was very bullish on the US economy, is getting into gold nowadays.
11:15Luis PloennigNow it's really crazy and you're right. I believe it was $1,200 what they gave on the support checks. It's kind of crazy, right? Because everyone, I mean, it was $1,200 that the people received, you know, on a check or on their bank account, but actually what I heard and I read on the news is that each $1,200 to the government, it costs like $8,000, right? And people, they don't think where this money comes from. Like, actually, they don't know where it comes from, but then you see that they're printing like 3 trillion dollars and it's like, okay, this...
12:03You just print money. On what is backed up this money, right? Like, is it gonna happen same as 2008, that you have credits and then you have revolving credits and then they go into options with these credits and then the whole economy collapses? I think probably it will. You know, like right now the stock market, it's crazy. Hertz, Kodak, companies that are bankrupt, they're doing all-time highs. I believe the only good signals of what is going on and how the American economy is collapsing is the price of gold, of silver, and the comparison, the FX against the euro.
12:56Because actually, in this whole corona time, the most stable economy, I believe, it's been Europe, right? Because I believe the exchange rate it was like $1.14 against the euro and now it's almost hitting $1.20, it's like $1.19. So Europe is stable. But for Mexico, going back to Mexico, we have a saying that when the United States sneezes, we have like pneumonia in Mexico. You know, everything goes like way bigger because our stability economically is not as big.
13:39So I focus on bringing a little bit more stability to Mexico, and I think our image or ideas in the country are way too polarized to work with the United States.
13:56Why? Because it's our neighbor on the north and we see them as like a first world country, like, you know, full of technological developments. But I believe to impulse our country, we need to take a look at Europe and Asia, right? Because right now there is more advances in technology and economic stability than there is in Europe. I noticed this when I started living in Europe and I said, "Wow," like, I mean, we could learn so much from them. So I've been working with Indacoin in bringing this adoption to new projects and to bring them to...
14:44And with them we've been, you know, we provide service to 120, more than 120 countries, but we still have to fight in Latin America because there the technological advances are not as good as in other countries, so there is a lot of room of development, which I like.
15:08Vlad CosteaI mean, of course you like the places where there is potential to grow. But I was about to ask you because I see on the Twitter page of Indacoin.com that it says that you can purchase dozens of cryptocurrencies instantly with a bank card without registration. So what does this "without registration" part entail?
15:30Luis PloennigOkay, well, just to do clarification, we do full KYC, AML, and GDPR. We are fully compliant in Europe, but it means like in other type of what we call on-ramp gateways, you have to, you know, verify your email address, everything. Like the onboarding process, it takes way much more time than with us. With us, it's really easy. We try to build a platform, we have a native app and we try to make it in the terms of adoption so everyone can knows how to use it in an easy way.
16:07We don't want to be like an exchange, you know, that you have order books and then you have to put, you know, how much you want to buy. And you have like spots, derivatives, options, futures. No, we just want to make it simple and say, okay, I have 100 dollars, I want Bitcoin, and we give you the rate and you can buy directly. That's what we mean with, like, without registration, because you just download the app, put your credit card number, email address, basic KYC, and then you will have the crypto, right? So it's really simple.
16:47Vlad CosteaOkay, I'm a bit disappointed. I was hoping that you would tell me that you don't need KYC and you operate like Bisq or something.
16:58Luis PloennigI wish. I mean, in the past, the requirements were more relaxed, you know. But now we are licensed in the UK. We're going for FCA license, we're registered there. So starting after the AMLD5, the anti-money laundering directive, the fifth directive here in Europe, the restrictions or the rules for KYC, they're more strict. So we have to follow them. I mean, at the end, it's hard. I am pro-privacy, you know, pro, like, one of the most idealistic rules or visions of Bitcoin and the cryptocurrencies, like you own your own keys, you know. I am pro that, but it's hard to go into the institutional part with these rules.
18:02So we are in between and we have to follow them. And we have to abide by the rules of the governments, unfortunately. But before it was easier. There was no requirement of KYC in Europe below 150 euros. But now it's a requirement. So I'm sorry, Vlad.
18:24Vlad CosteaIt's fine. We still have a couple of alternatives. And if these go away, we're going to have more and more, I guess. Just like, you know, you used to have BitMEX. That was very hard to regulate. But once it got too big, it was targeted by all sorts of jurisdictions. And now it's going to do full KYC of users, but there's going to be something else that pops out and takes its place. It's like a wave that only crashes into the rocks and then another one comes, but it needs to stay small for a while.
19:01Luis PloennigFor example, in Mexico, I did a study, some research, and around $46 million, they are moving in LocalBitcoins. So the numbers, I believe that I did, $46 million, that I checked that they moved like within a month, I think. But it's a really big volume for just LocalBitcoins. And LocalBitcoins, it's purely P2P, you know. Well, you know, the platform, they check, of course, they take a percentage of, like, I believe 1% is what they take. But it's purely P2P. And there are still going to be these platforms in the future. But actually, now that I think about it, also LocalBitcoins, they do KYC.
19:59So it's less and less the services that you can get without customer verification.
20:08Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I think LocalBitcoins started doing KYC just last year around this time, in August or September. I remember that because I wrote the article for Bitcoin Magazine about it. But okay, we talked about your business and your work. Let's talk about you and how you got involved and what your vision is for Bitcoin. And, you know, why are you here?
20:38Luis PloennigWell, I start, I believe, as a lot of people in the industry, I read about Bitcoin on Wired Magazine back in the days, like it was, I believe, 2013-2014. By that time, I was still living in Texas. I am from Mexico, but I lived in Texas for quite some time, like eight years. And I did a little bit of... Like, I think I grabbed a faucet and I took some Bitcoin from it. But as everyone, like, I lost my laptop and that was it. So I was keeping following of the price for a long time.
21:25And on 2015, I got back into the game, like, really interested. So I started just to purchasing some Bitcoin and following the trends and everything. And I was having a normal job, you know. I decided that I was not really happy with my job at that time and I decided, like, you know, just fuck it, like, I'm gonna quit and I'm just gonna take some time off. And then I start reading more about Bitcoin, researching more, not only about Bitcoin, but I also try different things like, you know, DLTs. I read about blockchain, the different type of blockchains.
21:58And I believe, and this is what kept me here, I believe this is the revolution, man. Like, this is the new technology that is going to change the world, and it's actually changing.
22:22You know, like in terms of remittance, in terms of exchange of information, and the most... The value that it has the most is trust, and that's how I believe Bitcoin... One of the bigger things in Bitcoin is trust, right? Because you can trust the transaction. You know where it's coming from. You know that it's real. You cannot duplicate it. You cannot double spend. You cannot do that. So it would change the, you know... I've seen a lot of samples on the blockchain and supply chain and everything.
23:04I don't know if they're going to be true, but at least Bitcoin in 10 years, it has proven that it's immutable. You can have trust in it, and I mean, that's what it brings me here. I just want to be part of this and see it grow and see it explode, because still, 10 years later, we're really small in terms of the whole industry in the world and the whole economy. So there is so much room of improvement that I want to take my part to develop this, especially in Latin America.
23:39Vlad CosteaYeah, I know. And it's been almost 12 years, even if we don't realize it, but it has been some time. The world has gotten used to the idea of Bitcoin. I think it's a powerful brand. I think in the last few years it has worked flawlessly. And the network has really operated in the way that it was supposed to, with nodes being more self-interested and not necessarily following a leadership. We can see that in the SegWit adoption. We can see that in the ongoing debate with Schnorr signatures and Taproot, all that stuff.
24:21There is not much support for it yet, because people want to see something that's tested. And people don't update their nodes when there's a new version out there, because this isn't Ethereum or something. As long as you follow the basic rules, you can run any version of the client. You can make your own client which only respects the basic rules and takes away something that you don't like about the protocol. And it's just incredible. I think it's one of the most successful, if not the most successful, experiments in anarchy.
24:57Luis PloennigWell, yeah, I wouldn't call it already an experiment, you know, because it's been proven that it works. So, I mean, we can see it. I mean, there is even regimes that they last less than Bitcoin. So already for me, even if right now goes to zero and they find a floor or whatever, I wouldn't call it already an experiment, but it was like... Like, it's marked in history, you know. I think it's already good, you know. But in terms of adoption, and here is the hard part, because, you know, we have, of course, Bitcoin maximalists and everything that they go pro technology, pro all these protocols and all these developments.
25:51But if you really want adoption is how a normal person, like a standard citizen, will understand Bitcoin. And for me, this still is the... Because I'm into business development, right? I'm into getting new projects and developing new countries. How to explain the local entities and governments what is Bitcoin and that they don't take it in a bad way, right? Because any new technology and any new development, the first uses that they had were kind of shady, like Bitcoin had it long time ago. But how to remove this stigma and explain them in a clear matter that actually Bitcoin is what we should impose and it will help to the development of the countries.
26:48It's really hard to get to that part of the adoption. I don't know if you follow my idea.
26:56Vlad CosteaOf course I do. I mean, I know people, and when I tell them about Bitcoin, they think, "Oh, it's that Silk Road coin. It's the one that used to buy drugs. It's the one that's being used by criminals." Because even today, if you watch some TV shows, they talk about Bitcoin as some sort of dark money that only criminals use, and it's taken a while for it to change this public image that it acquired maybe in the early years. But I think it's getting better due to institutions stepping in.
27:30I mean, I don't like the fact that they step in. I don't like the fact that they're going to be much more in control. And it's going to get serious at some point when they own the largest amount of Bitcoins. And you can see that Coinbase owns like, what, 800,000 or more? And exchanges like Bitfinex, they also own a lot. So they have a lot of power already. And if you are going to have governments and banks, it's going to be interesting to see how they influence the development and where this ends.
28:05Luis PloennigActually, it's funny because I think also one of the biggest Bitcoin holders, it's the Bulgarian government as well, which is kind of crazy. I think they confiscated a supply from the mafia a long time ago, and I think they haven't auctioned this Bitcoin. So they are actually one of the biggest as well, which is kind of funny. But I agree with you. I don't like governments to rule this, especially... I mean, living in the States taught me that there are like crazy rules that the governments take.
28:46And also in China. I mean, China, it's like there's a lot of industry going in China. Like, mostly all of the miners from Bitcoin comes from China, right? All the mining at one time was heavily concentrated in China. It was one of the big parts of mining of Bitcoin in China. But still the government, you know, they implemented this new social rating that, you know, they can ban you from travel and everything. So the government can implement severe measures for the citizens and actually control this. So government and Bitcoin, they've always been in conflict, I believe.
29:39Vlad CosteaI think I agree to some extent that they are in conflict, but what I was about to remark about our conversation is that it's refreshing to, for once, not talk about the United States only. Because many times the discussion is too much focused on what's going on in the US, as if that's the only part of the world that matters. But there is a whole world out there that actually needs Bitcoin for different reasons than the US, which mostly regards it as some sort of speculative investment or hedge against the government.
30:21Luis PloennigTrue. I mean, and this is the case, that is the case in Latin America, especially Venezuela, Argentina and other places, that it's like a stablecoin, which is kind of crazy, you know. Like, to think of Bitcoin that has not... It fluctuates a lot, but there it's a store of value. Like, it's more stable than the current currency. And for me, one of the priorities in Latin America is to bring this adoption and make it... I see, like, in the past, a lot of projects, they try to implement this adoption of Bitcoin.
31:11But why they fail? Because they just want to transform the crypto money to fiat, right? So to have it in a prepaid Visa or Mastercard or something. But in my idea, to bring adoption is to actually pay the suppliers, pay the services, pay everything directly with Bitcoin. Of course, at the beginning will be hard for, you know, commercial entities to accept Bitcoin because they need to pay. But if you make it in a good way, the customer won't know the back end of the process of the money, or of the Bitcoin. So you can create a type of payment that you could pay, let's not say coffees at this moment, but invoices from the commercial perspective with Bitcoin.
32:10Because we have a lot of commerce in Mexico that comes from China, from Russia, from Europe, and maybe implement a solution like that to pay like all these commercial products in Bitcoin will be beneficial. First of all, because it's faster than the SWIFT transfer and any money remittance. So I'm advocating for that. I'm working on a project that is helping to accelerate the money transfer using Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. And let's hope next year we hopefully release it for, you know, for commercial use, and I hope it brings adoption to Latin America. So let's hope about that.
33:05Vlad CosteaI sure hope so too, because the governments need to learn a lesson, and I don't think they're going to be taught that lesson just by free elections or just by having experts from, I don't know, the World Bank or IMF step in and tell them how economies should work. Because they also follow the kind of economic philosophy that eventually leads to a lot of inflation. So I suppose having this type of competition from a currency that's not owned by any other country, that's neutral and apolitical, you cannot change it with politics.
33:51That's really helpful, and I don't think that at any point in the next 100 years maybe, we're going to get rid of, you know, governmental money, fiat money, or money that's backed by gold or Bitcoin or anything. Governments will just want to issue their own money and have control over the population, because that's how they work. If they don't have control over the money, then their authority is going to diminish so hard and so badly that they're going to lose the legitimacy in front of their citizens.
34:25They're not going to be able to collect any taxes, and that's how the system collapses. But with Bitcoin, they're going to become much more transparent and much more accountable. And they're going to try really hard to convince the citizens that they still provide a useful service or something that the citizens should care about enough to pay taxes.
34:51Luis PloennigYeah, that's true. And actually, in my terms, to explain to entities, especially when they're like legal entities, like from government, governmental entities, why Bitcoin is the place to bet to, I explain this part that you explained. It's more transparent and more clean than cash. Why? Because you can track the transactions. So, of course, I mean, if you've done KYC on an exchange, you can track where the money is from.
35:30And a lot of exchanges, they work either with Chainalysis or other, like, chain analytical companies that they screen the transactions, they screen the blocks and they follow the money, and then you can know if this Bitcoin was on the dark web, if it was used on gambling, if it was used on other type of, like, you know, like heavy stuff like child pornography and everything. And actually, that is beneficial for the government and for the citizens, right? Because you can stop making use of Bitcoin for these illegal activities, which some of them, they're really bad and really perverse. And you can follow and track that. If you want to be anonymous, then you just don't have to fall into the fiat money. And that's OK with Bitcoin, you know. But if you want to fall into the fiat money, well, then you just have to do normal KYC and government will be OK. And it helps the governments to track the money.
36:39So in this way, to explain it to the legal entities, to the governmental entities, you've seen that they are more relaxed about it than before, that, you know, they have this stigma about just using it on the dark web and stuff.
37:00Vlad CosteaSo were you able to convince any governmental officials that they should be using Bitcoin? And can you provide any examples of your negotiations?
37:09Luis PloennigWell, at this moment, I'm in discussions with the National Commission, Comisión Nacional Bancaria y de Valores. It's like the National Commission of Banks and Values in Mexico. And in the letter that I provide by one of my lawyers, this is not with Indacoin, this is a different project. We made clear about this, about the, you know, that you have chain analysis, you can make sure that the money that will enter the country will be clean and will be not from money laundering or dark web or anything.
37:58And yeah, they understand it in that way. They are more relaxed about it and actually they like the idea, you know. We don't go into the subject of KYC, which is different, because you can actually separate both. You can know where the money comes from without revealing who is the owner of the wallet, right? Of the wallet address. But at least you know that the money, you know, it comes from an exchange, the Bitcoin comes from an exchange or from the dark web. And they like this idea because nobody likes, like, black money. And like, for example, here in the Netherlands, we had the case that, you know, banks are really against Bitcoin.
38:50And then there was a big, big case a couple of years ago because ABN AMRO and ING, they were laundering money from El Chapo in Mexico. So it's like, I mean, they don't accept you to use your bank account by crypto, but at the same time, they got caught laundering money from the cartels. So it's kind of a fucked up situation. Excuse my French, but yeah, it makes no sense, right?
39:22Vlad CosteaI mean, they don't want any competition, right? They want to hold the monopoly on laundering money.
39:30Luis PloennigThat's right. And you know, here, like, I mean, in the Netherlands, it's like, it's kind of like hard because some people, sometimes, you know, there is a lot of people, there is a lot of expats, the ratio of expats, it's really big. But so to some Europeans, like friends from Spain or friends from Italy, it's really hard to get a credit card from a national bank. Sometimes they say because they are not Dutch. But then it's like, okay, it's hard, you know, to get a credit card, but you take money from the cartels, so what's the deal, right? But you see, it's all in the system. I am advocating for adoption, not so much in the governmental entities, which are needed, but more in the normal population, standard population. Because if you see crypto Twitter, the conversations can be really... They are highly elevated technically at some moment in terms of Bitcoin.
40:40And if you want to introduce someone to Bitcoin, and then you're talking about, you know, proof of work and all, like, the hash rate and all the new, the Lightning Network, it is so much information because we've been in this industry for 12 years that it's so hard to explain, like, in five minutes, because there's been so many developments, so many discussions of how to do with the blocks, with everything, and you just needed to make it in a concise way. And then I will ask you that: like, how would you explain Bitcoin, like in two sen... in one sentence?
41:28Vlad CosteaIn one sentence, I think I would explain Bitcoin as pirate money that the government cannot take away from you, that gives you some sort of plausible deniability, that you don't need to bury somewhere in the Pacific so that nobody will hopefully ever find it, and which allows you to make any transaction with anyone without any third party being able to stop you from doing it.
41:59Luis PloennigI like especially the last part. I think is what I use. Like it's, you know, like your own money and nobody can restrict you to use it or not. So, and this is one of the main advantages in Latin America, which call a lot of people, you know, that you are in control of your own funds, because there's been a history in a lot of countries that the banks, from one day to another, they just close and that's it. They have your money, you cannot exchange to US dollar or any other coin, and basically you are left there without any power or control on your own funds.
42:47Vlad CosteaI mean, that's insane, because usually in countries when banks open or close, they're supposed to be backed by governmental money to some extent. At least to some amount, which is the top amount. I think in Romania, if you open an account, it's covered by the government up to 50,000 euro per person.
43:12Luis PloennigCorrect, but take examples. For example, in Europe it happened with Greece and Cyprus, when the economic collapse happened, they just closed the banks. And not so far away, right now with the corona, I heard in, I think in Turkey and other countries, that they restrict the access to banks. Even in Russia it happened, like not so long ago. So, I mean, the funds are there, but they let you just, let's say, withdraw 100 pesos or 200 pesos a day, and then you have 20,000. You got the idea, right?
44:01They are actually controlling the supply and the liquidity of the cash. So it's really strange how this control is. But Bitcoin actually helps to have another way out of it and to be in 100% control of your finances. If it's the case that you have it in a cold or hot wallet, like not your keys, not your money, it applies totally, right? Because then if you have it in an exchange, you have to trust this exchange.
44:41Vlad CosteaSo you have spoken to people from Latin America who are interested or may be interested in Bitcoin. How do they react to this part about being their own banks? Are they scared or are they excited about this new power of sovereignty?
44:59Luis PloennigNo, they're really excited. This year in March I was in Panama for a Bitcoin conference, like a crypto conference. I mean, I get to discuss with a lot of people, especially Argentinians, Venezuelans, and then some people in Panama, some from Mexico, and everyone is excited about this idea, right? Of having, being in control of your own money first. And because, you know, like in Europe and the United States, the industry of crypto, it's in another level.
45:46It's a mature industry. In Europe and the United States, they're talking more about GDPR, about institutional investment, all these like super high, like high-level type of negotiation, right? Whereas in Latin America, it's been to the basics of just, like, money remittance, transfer of value, like having, being in control of your own economy. So I guess, or I take it, like in Latin America, we're in a young stage with a lot of room for development, whereas in USA and in Europe, we're in a more mature market, right? And they like the idea to have these type of solutions.
46:37There is, I believe, an app, it's called Defiant, and it's like a P2P kind of LocalBitcoins, but it works with location, geolocation, and you can see people that is around you and you can do like transfers between them. And there is different types of applications that are being developed there to do this type of transfer, like P2P mainly, without using banks or any other financial institutions.
47:13So there is a big, big adoption on that in Latin America. They like the idea. Yeah.
47:20Vlad CosteaYeah, because sometimes a lot of people complain that it's hard to be your own bank, and it's frightening, this idea that if you lose your keys, you lose all of your money. But I suppose to people who are used to losing their money in banks, they'd rather be cautious about some digital asset that they're owning than lose their money out of somebody else's fault.
47:48Luis PloennigExactly, it's like where you get... Like everyone talks as they experience, right? So for Europeans, I mean, you don't worry too much about a bank having your funds because the economy is stable and you never seen that a bank closes and takes their money, no? But if you were born or lived in Latin America, you see that, you see that a lot. And then people is more careful about this. And I mean, I know people that still they don't go to the bank, they just stuff cash in their mattress, because they experienced like 15 or 10 years ago economic depression and economic crisis, and the banks closed and they were without any money.
48:44So a lot of people, they're still stashing cash, you know, and other types of ideas to preserve, or buy gold or buy silver. But here in Europe, I mean, everything kind of is working, so people don't worry. But there it's a big issue about that.
49:07Vlad CosteaI mean, it's mostly working in Western Europe and possibly Central Europe. But here in Eastern Europe, where I'm based, we have a different experience. We have been a communist country for 40 years, and it was terrible. I mean, to some people it was fine because they were given land and they were given opportunities that they wouldn't have gotten otherwise, possibly; there is no way to know. But you know, my family has lost everything that they owned. And I had a great-grandfather who was a butcher and another great-grandfather who was a carpenter.
49:47And they had small businesses with maybe one or two employees, but they were still declared enemies of the state. They still had to suffer the humiliation of having all of their money, all of their animals that they were raising in their yards and all of their land taken away, and be humiliated by stigma. And the lesson that I've learned from the stories that I have heard from family members is that it's good to not trust the government too much with your money and trust in the stability of the status quo, because you never know what's going to happen.
50:29We're not quite, you know, a world power to be able to impose our view of the world on the rest of the world. So, we have to adapt and we have to learn how to survive by ourselves. Part of the reason why I like Bitcoin is this unconfiscatability, which is not an easy word to say, but it's a very powerful word. Once you figure out that even in the United States, there was the Executive Order 6102 by Franklin D. Roosevelt, which confiscated all gold and made all citizens turn in their holdings of gold.
51:12So even the most democratic countries, which respect your human rights and have a lot of respect for the sanctity of private property, will come after whatever it is that you have, as long as they know that they can have it.
51:34Luis PloennigYeah, that's so true. I mean, you know, well, they probably, they will see, you know, they need it for some reason, or they don't think about it. But yeah, I mean, in Mexico, like, for example, a difference with the States: you know, if you find oil in the States, if you find it in your own land, I mean, it's yours. But in Mexico, the oil, everything that goes below the ground, it's property of the government, right? So we experience this all our life. And for me it's amazing with Bitcoin, right?
52:21Because even if you have your Bitcoins and even if you have them on a Ledger Nano, right? And you just take a plane, you're in full control. And to think about it, like with gold, you cannot, you know, just carry the gold wherever you want because it's super heavy. With cash, well, you will need a really big luggage. But with Bitcoin, you can just, you know, have it on a paper wallet. Even if you can memorize your private key, you don't need anything. It's only on the blockchain and you can travel anywhere and move it anywhere and you're in full control of it, which is the most important thing.
53:05That is super crazy, man. If you think about it's super, super crazy. It gives you a lot of freedom. Freedom and trust. Those are really big values of Bitcoin.
53:21Vlad CosteaYeah, I mean, my grandfather could only wish to have Bitcoin. Yet, there are so many people who are skeptical about it just because of the price volatility, or just because they don't understand how decentralization works. They don't know it's open source software. They have no idea there are thousands or dozens of thousands of nodes worldwide operating at any time to secure the network and validate every transaction to make sure that the data remains true and scarce at the same time. So, when I talk to my father, for example, he's like, "Oh, don't worry, this Bitcoin is going to go.
54:03Just wait for Putin or for Donald Trump to do something and it goes just like that, it vanishes in thin air, like poof." But he doesn't know. He doesn't understand that even if governments ban it, we can still run Bitcoin on our laptops with Tor. And there's no way to associate. I mean, I guess with exit nodes, they can still find out some information. So maybe Tor is not the ideal technology for privacy. But we can still find privacy and ways to use Bitcoin without actually associating it with our identity.
54:43Luis PloennigTalking about that, it's really interesting because, yeah, I mean, and I think you mentioned it before in some podcast, but in Latin America, the internet connection is not the best. Let's say it like that. And sometimes it's interrupted connection, like the ping is too long, you know. So I was really interested with one guy on Twitter in Venezuela that he connected a Bitcoin node and he is running the Bitcoin node. He put it with a satellite. I believe, I think it's from a brand, Blockstream or something like that.
55:36I don't know if you've heard of it, but you can actually, like, you know, you buy this, you plug the satellite and then you don't need like an internet connection, which is like super crazy, right? So you're actually off the grid running a node, so it's kind of interesting. I would like to try it. I have not, but I would like to try this, to run a node with a satellite. It is really interesting.
56:06Vlad CosteaI would also love to do that, you know, just to get that Blockstream kit, or just build my own with a dish antenna and everything. Unfortunately, I'm not sure if I'm allowed to install the antenna because I live in a block of apartments. So I would have to, you know, file some sort of request and get permission from the landlord and from everyone around, like my neighbors, so that they say, "I'm not bothered by this extra antenna that's going to hang by the wall."
56:42But if I manage to do that, I can only imagine that it's really awesome. Just to have one Bitcoin node that's independent from any kind of internet connection. That's just, you know, sci-fi. I think it's exactly what the people from The Pirate Bay wanted to do, except that torrenting requires a lot more bandwidth, and it's more difficult to decentralize. Whereas with Bitcoin, you just need to store one megabyte every 10 minutes. Of course, you're going to need a lot more bandwidth to do validation and to make sure that the true chain state remains and is kept.
57:25But other than that, you know, it's just out of this world. I'm happy that there are so many smart people involved in this project. I'm happy that I'm part of this and I'm learning every day. And the sky is the limit, like literally. Actually, it's not, because you can go into the stratosphere and find the satellites there, which offer you a free sync of the Bitcoin blockchain. So no, the sky is not the limit. The moon, I guess, is the only limit so far.
57:56Luis PloennigYeah, or no limits at all, you know. Yeah, I mean, it is incredible what people in this industry has done. Especially, I believe that all these creation and innovation comes because actually the community is still small for the time being, but it's really passionate about the changes that these ideals and this technology has brought to the world. So I think that's what it impulses everything. And I really am eager to see really a lot of changes in Latin America, because for one thing or the other, we haven't been in the best position, but there is so much room for improvement.
58:56People is super nice. I love going to my neighbor countries, and people from Venezuela, Argentina, Colombia, they're all fascinating. But it hurts me sometimes to see what happened with our governments and with our economy. So I'm trying really hard, us together with Indacoin, to bring adoption in Latin America, to support new projects there that they are looking for, you know, ways to bring their project to people. And so if anyone of your listeners, they want to contact me, feel free, because that's my mission, just to bring adoption and to spread the love of Bitcoin and crypto in Latin America.
59:57Vlad CosteaSo if anyone wants to contact you and write to you and possibly do business with you in Latin America, help you spread adoption, or I don't know, just help you in any way or just talk to you, how can they do it?
1:00:13Luis PloennigWell, I'm in all, you know, you gave my Twitter, which is P-L-U-C-O-I-N-Z, Plucoinz. And then, of course, I have Telegram, which is L-U-I-S-N-L. That's it. That's my Telegram. And they can send me a message. And I hope I don't get too much spam because I always get like crazy, you know, if you're in Telegram, yo, and you're in crypto, you always get like, you know, "Hey, do you wanna invest on Bitcoin and then you will get 10% every day," or something like these crazy scams.
1:00:54So no, we're interested in real projects, like the real industry, right? So if you have any project in Latin America or any other part of the world, because we are in 120 countries, more than 120 countries, please let me know and we are here to help. We want to bring adoption. It's really nice that the crypto Twitter works so good because I could get in touch with you and be here. It's my first time talking in a podcast, but I love this industry, and I hope at least next year I will be able to travel to some conferences and have a little bit more touch with people in the industry.
1:01:47So if anyone, even if they don't have a program, they just want to talk and discuss any situation, just reach me out. I'm fully available and I'm always trying to reply all my messages, so feel free to contact me.
1:02:03Vlad CosteaOh yeah, it's so nice to see that everyone is so open to talking. And I guess this is the best way to figure out that we are still in the early days, when, you know, somebody who is an executive in a company that operates in over 100 countries is still nice enough to give you his Twitter address and say, you know, "You can contact me, we can talk. I have time to take opinions from you." And this is part of the reason why I'm still excited after all these years to check Twitter every day, to see how everyone is doing, to find out something new. And that's another reason for you to listen to podcasts.
1:02:45And I hope, by the way, Luis, that many more podcast hosts will have you, so that you can tell the story about increasing adoption in Latin America.
1:02:57Luis PloennigWell, I hope so too, and Vlad as well, you know, if you're ever in Mexico or Amsterdam, let me know and we can have a couple beers and discuss more in depth the industry in terms. But it's really nice, it's really nice. I'm really happy of what you're doing for the industry. I see that you work a lot. I believe you also have another podcast, like recording today or maybe this evening. So...
1:03:30Vlad CosteaOh, I did it already.
1:03:34Luis PloennigSo, yeah, you see, and you write for a lot of people. So, I mean, I'm really happy that you gave me this time. Yeah, man, and feel welcome to send me a message or anything. We're always here.
1:03:52Vlad CosteaOh yeah, so if I ever get to Mexico, we're not going to have beer, unless it's Corona, but we can have some tequila. I'm fine with that.
1:04:00Luis PloennigOh yeah, nice. And you have to try mezcal, which is also really, really nice. So for sure, for sure, man.
1:04:10Vlad CosteaI don't know, maybe someday when I will afford to travel. Right now I think if I am to take a plane to New York, which is the East Coast of the United States, I pay like a thousand dollars just for a one-way ticket.
1:04:24Luis PloennigWow, that's crazy. Prices are crazy.
1:04:27Vlad CosteaMaybe it's lower now because of Corona, not the beer, but you know.
1:04:33Luis PloennigYeah, well, with Corona times, it changed everything, right? But at least we're looking for the optimistic part of it here, like, at least this second half of the year, for the industry, there's been a lot of developments, and it's kind of crazy. I had like a conversation before the halving about how will Bitcoin, like, you know, giving like kind of a forecast. And actually now we see that it's giving a nice movement, a lot of developments, not only economical price, but in technology as well. And even with the corona, it's moving really good. So let's hope the corona situation finishes soon and we can give the full potential for crypto again.
1:05:33Vlad CosteaI hope so too, and I really want to come to Mexico one day. I hope your border control is not as harsh as in the United States, but I definitely need a visa, so we'll see.
1:05:45Luis PloennigI don't know if you need a visa because, have you checked before? Because right now we have open, I'm actually flying tomorrow, because I need to do some work there, but I don't think you need a visa because you're from Romania. I don't know. Have you checked?
1:06:02Vlad CosteaI mean, I suppose we actually need a visa for South America.
1:06:06Luis PloennigYeah. Well, but anytime, in another space, maybe, feel free to come and yeah, I will show you around. So right now the borders are open there. There is a lot of cases of corona, but yeah, I just need to be a little bit careful traveling. You know, take the safety measures, distance and everything and we'll be fine.
1:06:43Vlad CosteaOkay, so I'm not sure if I have anything else to ask you at this time. I'm very happy that we got to talk. If you get the chance, and you should get the chance, you should definitely follow Luis at P-L-U-C-O-I-N-Z, Plucoinz, on Twitter. He posts about Latin America and even Dave Portnoy sometimes, and memes about YAM, which is funny. So yeah, just follow him, and I guess we're going to hear more from you from other podcasts or podcasters. So, I'll talk to you later.
1:07:25Luis PloennigThank you, Vlad, and thank you for your time. Yeah, I post a lot of memes on CT, on Crypto Twitter. But yeah, thank you for your time and enjoy the day. We'll keep in touch.
1:07:40Vlad CosteaYou too. Bye bye.
1:07:41Luis PloennigBye bye.
1:07:41================================================================================ Production notes: Remote one-on-one audio/video call in English (guest is a non-native speaker from Mexico), with a short intro/stinger at the start and no sponsor reads in the content. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 4 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (90 chunks) and 38 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed intro hallucinations (Bitcoin Pulse, Big Bang Theory, Amara.org, "Thank you. Okay."), doubled words; fixed Ploennig, @Plucoinz, Volabit, Bitso, Bisq, AMLD5, on-chain payments, "the unbanked", Indacoin.com; repaired shifted turn boundaries (00:02:24, 00:02:44, 00:10:22, 00:11:15, 00:16:47); restored dropped text from Qwen/Scribe (04:10–04:49 gap, inflation sentence, FCA, "before it was easier"); Fixed speaker labels (removed "(same speaker continues)" prefix, Guest A → Luis Ploennig); fixed LocalBitcoins, Bitcoin Magazine, SegWit, Schnorr signatures/Taproot, "Right, Jim" → regimes, "flow" → floor, "backholders" → Bitcoin holders, SWIFT, Mastercard, stablecoin; restored dropped words from second ASR/Scribe; removed hallucinations ("Thank you for watching... Bye!", youtube.com string, "This is a very important topic", "all these companies"); Guest A → Luis Ploennig; fixed Chainalysis, Indacoin ("within the coin"), Comisión Nacional Bancaria y de Valores, LocalBitcoins, "young stage", "black money", "100% of the money" → "100 pesos", great-grandfather, unconfiscatability; restored dropped speech from second ASR/re-check (Netherlands banks against Bitcoin, credit card/expats, proof of work/Lightning, 100% control, Latin America basics); removed hallucinations ("Amen", "Thank you for watching..." loops, "The world's largest cryptocurrency exchange", doubled words); moved "Exactly, it's like where you get" to Luis; Guest A → Luis Ploennig; fixed Ledger Nano, "gold", "paper wallet", Blockstream, Plucoinz, "you write"/"another podcast"; removed hallucinated "Thank you for watching..." and "a lot of money in the world"; restored dropped speech from second ASR; repaired shifted turn boundaries (03:30, 04:00, 04:27, 06:02, end).