Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S6 E4 / Transcript
Transcript · S6 E4 · 1:39:15 · 1 Sept 2020

S6 E4: Justin Wales on Law, Taxes & Bitcoin as Free Speech

With Justin Wales. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:47Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to Season 6, Episode 4 of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. My guest today is Justin Wales, who is a Bitcoin lawyer and also a First Amendment attorney, if I'm not mistaken, but we'll let him clarify on that. And what I really liked about him was when he published a research paper that was all about the ways in which Bitcoin is protected by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. And he tried to explain why it's an expressive network before being a financial mean.

1:23And I know that this season the purpose is to have people who don't really get heard, who haven't been on podcasts before. And I suppose Justin only ticks one of these boxes because he has been on Pierre Rochard's noted podcast. But I'm not sure how many people have listened to that. And it's always good to give a platform to people who bring fresh perspectives on what Bitcoin actually is and doesn't just rely on the arguments that you can read in the books that everyone reads. And there's an actual lawyer. I mean, how often do you get to talk to a lawyer who's pro-Bitcoin? So hello, Justin.

2:04Justin WalesHey, thanks for having me.

2:06Vlad CosteaIt's really good to have you. I feel like we have a lot in common, from the Beatles references and all the way to the love for free speech.

2:17Justin WalesYeah, I just found out this morning that Sean Lennon started following me this week on Twitter. So he must maybe have some pro-Bitcoin tendencies as well.

2:30Vlad CosteaHopefully. I'm pretty sure that his father would have loved Bitcoin if he came across the idea. I think so. He was kind of revolutionary-minded.

2:38Justin WalesOh, absolutely, yeah.

2:40Vlad CosteaWell, except for the song "Revolution," where he said that he doesn't want to engage in violence, but at the same time, that's what Bitcoin actually is. I feel like "Revolution" is actually a song about seeking to become revolutionary but not wanting to engage in violence, which is very Bitcoiny. So...

3:04Justin WalesHe has this line in "Revolution." He says, you know, "Don't you know that you can count me out, in?" So it's sort of very Lenin-esque to say something and to hold up a position and then at the very end give yourself an out. So he was a revolutionary unless he wasn't, and I think a lot of us maybe fit in that category.

3:28Vlad CosteaYeah, I suppose that's relatable. But let's talk about your research paper that you published, I think, last year.

3:36Justin WalesYeah, it was last November.

3:38Vlad CosteaLast November. I remember reading it when I was working at Bitcoin Magazine. And at first I was a bit skeptical because most academic articles about Bitcoin just get it wrong. But yours was very refreshing and you have used a lot of references from... You have done some analysis on blockchain activity and you have demonstrated how different people across time have used the Bitcoin network to propagate messages and to express themselves artistically or politically or in some ways. You started from the idea that Satoshi Nakamoto himself has made a political statement in the Genesis block.

4:23And across time we have seen many of these uses, and you argue that the First Amendment of the US Constitution actually protects Bitcoin as a network.

4:36Justin WalesYeah, so it's interesting. You know, I've really been obsessed with Bitcoin for a while, and then also most of my legal career. I might be part of like the very first generation of lawyers who can claim to be, you know, Bitcoin native, and also develop a practice in that space. And one of the things that I was finding is most of the phone calls I was having or clients I was representing were focused on a very narrow sort of margin of what Bitcoin, or more broadly cryptocurrencies or blockchain, whatever you want to call it, can do.

5:10But when I would go to the bar with my friends at night and we would just be talking about Bitcoin, it was very rare that we were actually talking about purely its use as a monetary function.

5:31We were talking about the broader social, democratic, financial implications of having this type of technology. And because I was interested in practicing First Amendment law, and I see a lot of things through an expressive or associational lens, I developed this theory that, you know, it's much more than just a money, even though it does money, and even though everyone only wants to talk about the spot price. So for years, I've been sort of kicking this around in my head. And I would get, you know, notifications every time a new academic article, a legal academic article was written involving Bitcoin or crypto or Ethereum or blockchain.

6:18I had like all of the keywords triggered, so whenever something came out, it would send it to me. And I was just getting very disappointed in the types of articles I was reading because they were all hyper, hyper-focused on securities sales, token sales. They were hyper-focused on how blockchain can marginally make centralized entities more efficient. And I thought, well, this is kind of missing the point of the technological revolution. So me and one of my partners at the law firm, a guy named Richard Ovelmen, who unfortunately passed away in January, very unexpectedly...

7:00We had been talking about this for quite a long time and decided, you know what, let's just go and put this out in like a real, like heavily researched article and lay out the position. And really the goal was, at some point in the future, lawyers, judges, regulators are going to have to deal with the broader uses of decentralized networks. And we want to be able to give a resource to them to contextualize this type of technology and this type of relationship that is made possible via this technology under a really traditional First Amendment analysis. And that's what the paper tries to accomplish.

7:47Vlad CosteaYeah, I remember when I was still very serious about my PhD and was on schedule with the thesis, that I started searching databases for Bitcoin-related articles and was very disappointed about what I could find. I suppose this was in 2018 or so, but it was still underwhelming. I suppose you can find better articles on news websites, which sometimes have op-eds or something, which go much more in depth to explain what Bitcoin is, how it works and what it's supposed to do. But I suppose in academia, there's also the issue of who finances your research.

8:29So if these articles were mostly about securities and tokens and how blockchain can be used across different industries, I suppose it's only because people financing the research were interested in that.

8:45Justin WalesWell, in the case of like legal publications, I don't know if that's actually true. So after I published this article, I published a subsequent article about sort of the state of legal research, and I did a statistical analysis. Since Bitcoin was created, there have been, I think it's about 297... Let's say about 300 law review articles that have been published on the topic. The law review articles are like strictly academic, so they're not sponsored by any sort of industry group. I excluded any type of for-profit or even professional publications.

9:30So these are all articles published in law reviews associated with law schools. So you're not necessarily dealing with the who's-paying-for-it issue that you sometimes deal with in like medical and, you know, sort of societal research. But I think what it actually shows you is, you know, what is interesting the general public and what levels of research are pushing the subject forward. So one of the things that we found is most of the articles, the majority of the articles, about 60% were written as student notes.

10:10So these are law school students who are required to write a paper, you know, for their admission onto the law review. And they're choosing to write some of the more interesting papers. The professors who are choosing to write on this topic tend to take a more, I think, traditional approach. And I think part of the issue is that they are having to like learn and understand what is possible with this technology in a way that I think comes more naturally and more intuitively to younger law students, who maybe they have not been involved in Bitcoin for...

10:56You know, 10 years, but they've grown up in a completely digital world. And I think they appreciate the ability for finance to transition into completely digital modes, which might be a little different from an older generation of academics.

11:16Vlad CosteaIt's kind of ironic anyway, because academia maybe a hundred years ago was at the edge of innovation and was the one actually promoting new ideas, and today it feels like it has turned into something traditionalistic, which protects the establishment as opposed to challenging it.

11:37Justin WalesI think that's true, and you actually end up finding some of the most innovative work self-published or, you know, just put out there on the internet, and sometimes it lives and dies. I mean, if you want to be technical about it, you know, Satoshi's white paper is a self-published piece of academic work. He didn't need to go through an institution. And I think that's sort of telling. Where I think you see this really becoming a sort of a burden is if you look at how like economics has developed over the last, you know, 40...

12:1550 years. And you tend to see a real kind of entrenchment into like the Milton Friedman sort of view that's supported by, you know, the Chicago School of Economics. And it's just assumed to be correct. And I think we're now starting to see voices from outside of these more traditional schools and more traditional economic philosophies start to challenge, you know, those assumptions, and that all leads back into what is the core value proposition for something like Bitcoin.

13:01Vlad CosteaYeah, I mean, I spoke to my supervisor, the one who's in charge of my PhD, and he doesn't get it. He wants me to write something more generalistic that anyone can understand if they read it. I can see why. So anyway, my paper is on political philosophy, so it doesn't have to get into specifics unless it's about social impact and philosophical implications. But I'm still very much disillusioned with what I can do, because I'm not sure what it's like in the States when you use references. But in here, you're not supposed to be too innovative.

13:43We actually wait for bigger universities to publish something first so we can reference it. So it's not safe until somebody bigger acknowledges it, which I find very disappointing. I'd have to wait like five years to do what I want to do and have it acknowledged as such.

14:02Justin WalesYeah. You know, when we were looking for a place to publish this, we wrote the paper and then we sent it out to several schools. And it's basically this very sort of annoying process of waiting for, you know, the editor of the law review to read your paper and offer you a submission or what have you. And what we were finding was we were getting a lot of different schools accepting the paper, but wanting to put it through sort of a protracted editorial process to soften some of the arguments we're making.

14:41So, you know, we take a pretty hard position that says there doesn't seem to be a way of looking at Bitcoin as an expressive and associational network which doesn't implicate constitutional rights. And then we say that could be applied to these types of areas, but we don't say like absolutely there's no way you can require money transmission for anything related to virtual currency. We don't go that far and I don't believe that's true.

15:13But even just the notion that the First Amendment is implicated was a little too far for some of these papers. So we ended up going with the University of Miami for several reasons, but one of them was they understood what we were saying. I think the people who were on the law review board were Bitcoiners, and they just understood the technology and they could see how our argument lined up. But also, and more importantly, they realized that this needed to be published quickly because the technology and everything around it changes so fast.

15:54So they gave us just an expedited publication process. So from, I think, the time we sent it to them to the time it was actually published was maybe two and a half or three months, which is just unheard of in this sort of publication world. And it just goes to show that, you know, there needs to be more people looking at this and making these types of arguments. And I think it's going to come, and hopefully this inspires people to, you know, take from where I left off and start to write more and push the boundaries of how the Constitution and Bitcoin and crypto interact.

16:36Vlad CosteaYeah, just like common law is based on precedents, I suppose you have also set a precedent for American academia so that further research can be done in the field. For people out there who maybe haven't listened to your, not listened, who haven't read your research paper, how would you summarize it for them?

17:00Justin WalesSure. Basically, we argue that one of the problems with the discussion around Bitcoin, and really we're focused on Bitcoin, but the arguments could be applied to other blockchains that need a native currency potentially as well, is that we, you know, we say it's Bitcoin, we say it's a cryptocurrency, we say it's virtual money, whatever, and we focus so much on the spot price of Bitcoin every day that it forces regulators to only view Bitcoin and more broadly crypto through that lens. And what we do is we say, in fact, Bitcoin is an expressive technological tool.

17:46That allows people from all over the globe to associate, to maintain a common truth. And that common truth is the validity of the Bitcoin ledger. So there are associational rights under the First Amendment that are therefore implicated and therefore potentially prevent regulations from being applied specifically to Bitcoin that aren't applied also to other types of associational networks like just the internet or social media more broadly. And then the second argument that we make is that Bitcoin is not money. It does money. So its best, and maybe its first and maybe its best use case is as an alternative currency.

18:34But there are lots of things that I can do with Bitcoin that are non-financial. And that number of things and the ease of me being able to do non-financial transactions with Bitcoin increase. And some of the examples we give are publishing messages, political, religious, philosophical, otherwise, onto the blockchain. Using the blockchain as a publication tool for pictures, there's MP3s kind of hashed in there as an authentication tool. We talk about things like colored coins. We talk about things like RSK and the potential for building other types of second and third layer use cases using Bitcoin's blockchain as a base layer. And we say that if the only way to...

19:28Onboard onto this expressive and associational network is through the lowercase b bitcoin virtual currency, because that's needed to maintain it, then you really can't just say that it's money and we're going to regulate it like money or like a property. In some ways, it needs to be looked at more like data from an ISP or a modem than just a dollar substitute. And, you know, we by no means claim to fully exhaust the subject, but what we try to do is at least point out the questions and sort of give a background on what the relevant law is for networks, code as speech, all of these sort of, I would say, new applications of the First Amendment.

20:27And set up a sort of a starting place for other researchers and lawyers and judges and regulators to move on from there.

20:39Vlad CosteaYeah, I remember being very much impressed by your research paper and I'm happy that you published it. I'm happy that we get to spread this message and help people understand that there's a lot more beyond speculation when it comes to Bitcoin. And I'm also happy that we get to have this conversation because, you know, you're a very rare kind of guy. I'm not sure how I should describe you, but there are not many suits, so to call you, in this Bitcoin space, and there are very few of them who actually get it.

21:17Most of them are just in for, you know, a better payday. It pays off sometimes to work for institutions that deal with Bitcoin and other assets which have a lot of fiat getting pumped, and I see a lot of lawyers getting into DeFi nowadays and all that crazy stuff. So, I also know that you are a First Amendment... I'm not sure about the difference in common law between attorney and lawyer, so I don't want to mess it up.

21:50Justin WalesIt's the same.

21:51Vlad CosteaOkay. You deal very much with First Amendment issues and you argue that Bitcoin transactions or the network as a whole should be treated just like speech, and free speech should be allowed in the United States.

22:13Justin WalesYeah, well, what I argue is that Bitcoin is a network and it's a global network. It's an expressive network, and it should not be viewed very differently than we view something like the internet, which is also an expressive, associational network that you can do lots and many things on. Now, there are a lot of things that you can do on the internet that are illegal, you know, and should be regulated and are regulated and are criminalized. And it's not dissimilar to maybe how regulators should look at Bitcoin. There are things that you can do with Bitcoin. I can, you know, if I launder money with Bitcoin or if I'm purposely trying to evade taxes with Bitcoin, obviously that's going to be regulated.

23:02Obviously, that's going to be criminalized. But just the fact that I want to use Bitcoin or purchase Bitcoin to potentially do something that's expressive and non-financial, or the fact that I want to have financial privacy, is not automatic, should not be automatically suspect. And unfortunately, I think a lot of folks within the government and even in broader society view financial privacy as inherently suspicious, and that's ultimately bad for all of us. So once you start applying these First Amendment expressive associational rights onto Bitcoin, well, there are subordinate rights in the First Amendment, such as your right to anonymous speech.

23:51Right, so I'm allowed, for instance, I think HODLonaut is from like the Netherlands, but, you know, HODLonaut is allowed to go and publish...

24:02Vlad CosteaIn Norway, actually.

24:03Justin WalesIs it Norway? Okay. It doesn't matter for the sake of the argument. Okay, but yeah, so, you know, he doesn't have First Amendment rights, but, you know, US HODLonaut, which I'm sure someone in the United States is doing something similar, has a right to publish something publicly without telling anyone who he is or who she is. And that's a right that's guaranteed under the US Constitution. So, if the only way, for instance, that I'm able to publish onto an immutable blockchain and create an immutable publication of a record is through the purchase of Bitcoin, then it becomes very difficult for the government to say all transactions or all purchases of Bitcoin are...

24:54You know, the same as money, is a money transmission, you know, transaction. And therefore, you need to go and get that person's name and address and keep all sorts of records on them. And here's a good example that happened a couple weeks ago using, actually, ether.

25:21But in China, there was a Chinese-run pharmaceutical company that was producing vaccines for whooping cough, and they had some sort of tainted vaccine that made its way into the population. And a number of three-month-old children were injured because they were given this tainted vaccine. So activists started publishing warnings, essentially, and sort of exposés on the Chinese internet. And the Chinese censors kept deleting all of these articles. So for 47 cents worth of ether, they were able to actually put that information into the Ethereum blockchain in a way that the Chinese government or anyone else can't delete it.

26:04Now, for your average person right now, it's very difficult for them to find or read that message. But the interfaces will, I'm sure, improve over time, and I think you'll find that the ability to immutably publish content is actually an important one for our freedom.

26:34Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I agree. And it's kind of mind-blowing, you know, I'm talking to a US lawyer who is very much concerned about privacy and all of that stuff. And I've also seen how you criticize the IRS's draconian policy in regards to how you should declare every cryptocurrency asset, and how they treat everything as if it brings financial gains when you can just create some sort of colored coin on Bitcoin and do it for fun.

27:06Justin WalesYeah, and I think, you know, I don't even know if it's the IRS saying, "We're not going to acknowledge this type of use." I think the reality is most people are using Bitcoin at this moment for either investment or transactions and not for these secondary expressive use cases. And from the IRS's perspective, what they want is for people to comply with tax regulations. So it wouldn't surprise me if it really were not even on their radar what Bitcoin can become and what the broader, you know, sort of crypto industry, what have you, could lead to in terms of tokens being used for non-financial uses.

28:02And that's why I think it's important to have these types of conversations, not only with people within the regulating community, with the IRS, with the Department of Financial Services, with the various state and federal regulators, but within the Bitcoin community. Because I think some of the points that I make and I bring up, when you talk to a Bitcoiner, they understand and they're like, "Oh yeah, that makes sense. I never thought of it maybe in that way." It's important for us to start talking about this as much more than just money. Because, you know, if we don't use the right language ourselves, how can we expect regulators to understand the nuances as well?

28:50Vlad CosteaYeah, and taxation is always this very delicate subject, because it's hard to enforce, it's hard to prove ownership of any kind of keys, so it's kind of a slippery slope. But at the same time, if you hold your coins on something like Coinbase or Kraken or Gemini, and I suppose these are the ones that comply with regulations. I'm not sure about Kraken, but Gemini and Coinbase, they do. So if you do hold your coins there, it's kind of like trading on Robinhood, so it's not much different. But if you are your own custodian, do you have to comply to the same laws?

29:40Justin WalesYeah, of course. Regardless of who...

29:48Controls your keys, there are tax implications to owning virtual currencies, owning Bitcoin, to transacting in them, to sending them. You know, it's pretty well settled when a taxable event occurs. Now, just, I think it was this morning, there was an article about a memo that the IRS put out that said that any transaction, I believe it's over a dollar, is considered a taxable event. So that means that if you go and purchase a cup of coffee with Bitcoin, you know, the elusive cup of coffee that everyone talks about, or any virtual currency, right? If Roger Ver goes and buys a cup of coffee with BCash, the IRS is going to consider that a taxable event.

30:51These type of micropayments, viewed as taxable events under the IRS, makes it very difficult for Bitcoin to become adopted by the masses in the United States, because you then have to make sort of a capital gains analysis on every one of these small transactions. So the guys at Coin Center, I believe, helped push through a bipartisan bill that's, I still think, in the early stages, that would create a sort of a safe harbor for up to a certain amount more of Bitcoin and crypto transactions, such that they would be exempt from this capital gains analysis, because it really just makes the tax burden on everyday use of crypto so difficult that it's likely impractical from sort of a mass adoption sort of perspective.

31:49Vlad CosteaYeah, plus $1 is basically enabling all sorts of tricks and all sorts of pranks that you can do on people. You can just send them a random amount of coins. Like, let's say you send them... How much is $1? Like 10,000 satoshis? You send them that and they're supposed to declare it as part of their revenue? Or else they deal with the enforcement of the IRS. I mean, that's a bit draconian. That's a little too much. If you travel abroad and let's say that you exchange your US dollars for euro or yuan in China, and you return to the US and the US dollar loses value against the euro or the yuan, you're not supposed to declare it as an investment, right?

32:43Unless it's a very large amount of money.

32:45Justin WalesYeah, so this is one of the challenges from a tax perspective. Most levels of government, both at the federal and state level, view Bitcoin or crypto as money for most purposes, right? So the CFTC views it as a commodity. Most states view it as money in terms of whether it is, you know, whether dealing in it is money transmission or not.

33:18But the IRS views it as property and doesn't really treat it as money, and that just causes a lot of friction. And I don't think this is a problem that we're going to have, you know, five, six, seven years from now, because I think as more and more people become comfortable with Bitcoin, as more and more people, more and more businesses accept Bitcoin or other virtual currencies, you're going to see the tax treatment start to change. And I think a big part of that is just how do we as an industry push Forward mass adoption.

33:56And part of it has to be, as much as we all say, "Hold your own keys," and I think a lot of us in Bitcoin have been involved so long that it's become a part of our own personal identity. We don't want to give that up. There needs to be an easy way for like my mother to go and purchase Bitcoin. And with the OCC's opinion a couple weeks ago that nationally chartered banks are able to custody crypto for their clients, and also they would be able to sell crypto to their clients or their customers.

34:35I think that is a huge boon for mass adoption and ultimately a good thing for even those of us who hold on to our own crypto.

34:48Vlad CosteaYes, and speaking of mass adoption, just today I was researching a very niche and specific topic on which I had to write an article. And it's about all of these services which help you earn interest on your Bitcoins. And they do rehypothecation. I suppose that's how you pronounce it. It's not, you know, the most common word for a non-native English speaker to pronounce. But they do all of these practices that are very much specific to the fiat world, and they rely on the fact that the government insures something. But in the case of Bitcoin, there is no actual way of someone bailing you out.

35:32So they create futures, they create some sort of regulated assets that institutions trade between themselves without ever using the Bitcoin blockchain in the first place. And there's the risk of creating inflation on the market because they can trade Bitcoins that don't really exist.

35:51Justin WalesMm-hmm.

35:52Vlad CosteaAnd there's also this issue of not being solvent in the end, because if it all goes bust, I suppose that the people who deposit their Bitcoins to earn interest are going to lose them. And they're going to wait for, I think it's the FDIC in the United States, to reimburse them an amount of fiat. But if it's infinitely printed money, it's very likely that by the time they receive their compensation, the Cantillon effect will have kicked in and they will not be able to buy the same amount of Bitcoins that they used to own, or there will be so much scarcity in regards to Bitcoin that they will not be able to buy at all.

36:39Justin WalesYeah, I mean, sort of unpacking that, I think if you truly believe that Bitcoin will become a world reserve currency, then financial products will necessarily be built using Bitcoin as its sort of base layer, and therefore you will have sort of like collateralized rehypothecations. You will end up having, if not FDIC insurance, which is federally guaranteed, you might see effectively FDIC-type insurance offered through the private market and insurance companies. So there might be some protection built in, and I assume as Bitcoin starts to really obtain mass adoption, you're going to see some layer of protection and also some layer of utilizing Bitcoin as collateral for these leveraged transactions and financial products.

37:57That being said, if it's built out correctly, it shouldn't actually pose a problem to the actual financial solvency of Bitcoin, because I don't see how it could. You know, when someone is using wrapped Bitcoin on Ethereum, for instance, or using even funds on the Lightning Network, it's Bitcoin, but it's sort of Bitcoin once removed, right? So you realize that when you are using these second and third layer products that are sort of tied into Bitcoin, there is some increased layer of risk, more so than just a pure on-chain BTC transaction. And I think it's just how do you manage that risk at a mass level?

38:49And that's either through insurance or regulation. But if I'm creating a derivative product using Bitcoin or wrapped Bitcoin or some sort of conduit to the Bitcoin network, and I'm controlling that, then that's going to be regulated, such that there's going to be a place that you can point to help get money back, or to point to where liability lays when something goes wrong. But for those of you listening who don't want to engage in that sort of financial risk, you can hold on to your own Bitcoin. You can only send on-chain transactions. And maybe that's smart until the systems really scale such that we are confident as a global economic community to use these conduits to Bitcoin.

39:47Vlad CosteaOh yeah. I've been looking into BlockFi, which is one of these lending services, and there's a blog post by them which says, and this is maybe taken a bit out of context, but it explains why they need to do rehypothecation on Bitcoin and create all of this traditional financial infrastructure to trade Bitcoins and sell them to institutions. And at one point they say this means that you need to have the Bitcoin before you transfer it, which is, you know, for any Bitcoiner, that's insane. What do you mean you transfer Bitcoin that you do not have?

40:28Justin WalesYeah. Yeah. And part of it is we're, you know, we're still thinking of Bitcoin in terms of traditional centralized financial relationships and in sort of the development of fiat currencies. And at some point, if things continue, you know, the way they are, that might change. I put that timeline much longer than I think a lot of other people do. I think it's going to take quite a long time for, you know, your average person to be comfortable enough using Bitcoin or, you know, a second layer on Bitcoin every day, and for the institutions to become sophisticated enough to really support it at a mass level.

41:23But I do think that it's coming at some point. And at that point, I think the language surrounding finance and what is possible changes pretty significantly.

41:39Vlad CosteaYeah, there's a lot that needs to be understood about how Bitcoin works. And there's a lot of speculation yet. And in the same article that I referenced, and I suppose I will have to put the link in the description, there is also the mention that, you know, "we as a company are not doing anything new or wrong because trading with 100x leverage has been around for a long time, and it's not like we do something that hasn't been done."

42:11But the issue is that if more institutions get in and do this kind of stuff, then it's very likely that we'll see an inflation on the market of some sort of Bitcoin assets that are not real Bitcoins that are guaranteed one-to-one on the actual blockchain, which follows a very predictable and disinflationary inflation process all the way to 2140, which is the last year when we see any kind of reward in a block.

42:42So I suppose it's going to be interesting, but for people listening, if there is a piece of advice that I can give, it's that you should just be your own custodian and stay away from these services, so we don't have to see the consequences of them growing too much and ending up in the situation of a crisis where they cannot offer Bitcoins on a one-to-one ratio and it's all fractional reserves. And we have seen what happened during the last financial crisis.

43:16Justin WalesYeah, I mean, I take maybe a slightly different view on that advice. I think for a lot of people, it makes sense to be your own custodian. I think for a lot of people... There's someone like touching my car right now. I don't know what they're doing. Sorry. For a lot of people, you know, they are sophisticated enough, they are able to sort of get involved with Bitcoin enough that they really understand what's going on. But I think for mass adoption, it's okay for people to use custodians.

43:55I think, for instance, if the OCC announcement results in your parents or grandparents or whoever being able to diversify their portfolio such that they have a small amount or a chunk of their, you know, savings account in BTC that's held with Wells Fargo and insured through Wells Fargo's insurance, and guaranteed in the same way that if someone uses your debit card without your permission, Wells Fargo or whoever is your provider is going to give you the money back, and you're not really worried about someone stealing your credit card for that reason.

44:40I think that's fine for a chunk of the people. One of the problems I think we have in the community, and that I've seen over the course of years, is, you know, this idea that you have to be a purist in order to be legitimate. And I think there are two ways of sort of looking at that. One is recognizing that there are lots of people who just will never be comfortable holding onto their own keys for whatever reason. And they will only view this as a money, or they will only view it as an asset class, and they want their financial advisor to look at it. And, you know, God bless them.

45:20They can do that. And that's not for me, but it might be for other people. And I want more. I want as many people to own Bitcoin as possible, and I want them to do it in a way that's comfortable for them.

45:33That's on the one end. The other end is being willing to spin up any type of virtual currency, cryptocurrency, blockchain product, what have you, and sell that as the next iteration of Bitcoin, or, you know, market decentralized X, or this token, which is decentralized in sort of name only, is as good of an investment. And that's where I think you end up getting into a lot of ethical and also legal issues, is when you try to equate dissimilar things to each other.

46:10And I think for those of us who have been watching long enough, we know that Bitcoin is a thing unto itself, and everything else is sort of competing with each other as either a way of raising money for its creators or, under the best circumstances, innovating a product or innovating a technology using, you know, characteristics from Satoshi's invention.

46:37And I just think it's important that as we enter this new bull run, we're able to tell our friends, our family, the people around us who are not necessarily paying attention to everything that is crypto, why Bitcoin is different than everything else, and why they should be very careful with how they use their money, especially when you're getting into these like decentralized financial products, which are risky, are often unaudited. They're not necessarily all bad, but they are of such a level of risk that I don't think a lot of people getting into them really understand how subject to failure they could be.

47:24Vlad CosteaIf you ask me, all of this DeFi movement is just the new ICO boom, and some of the same Ponzis and scams that we were seeing with ERC-20 tokens getting issued as ICOs, we are seeing them now on the Uniswap platform on Ethereum. So I don't feel like much of it has changed. I don't think that the Ethereum network has become much more decentralized in the last three or four years. So it's going to be interesting to see how regulations and how attorneys treat Ethereum in the coming years, and for how long they will still be able to claim that they're decentralized when you can see that they have so many issues with running nodes and validating.

48:16Justin WalesLook, this is sort of an Ethereum-centric sort of challenge, but Ethereum essentially got a free pass from the SEC, because it's possible under an analysis of the Ethereum token sale that it could be viewed as a sale of security. But the SEC effectively said, "We view Ethereum as decentralized enough that we're no longer going to view Ether sold now day-to-day as a security." So the question becomes, well, what happens when Ethereum 2.0 starts and it moves to the staking mechanism, which arguably makes it more centralized, not less centralized than a proof of work mechanism? And how does that change the regulators' analysis?

49:08That's sort of a question for law nerds and not necessarily on the tip of the tongue of average folks. But if you then look at all the different types of products and financial sort of platforms that are being built using Ether, and the insecurity of not knowing what the regulatory state of Ether is going to be, the I think open question of whether the scaling next year with Ether 2.0 is going to be successful, and then just the sheer amount of money that's being wrapped up in smart contracts, I think there's a potential for something to go wrong.

50:00And from a regulator's perspective, that's what they're nervous about. And that's what they're going to want to go after. So, in that regard, it's similar to like the ICOs in that what the regulators wanted to do was to make sure that people weren't taking advantage of the public. They weren't having, you know, little old ladies put their life savings into some random coin that's going to be pumped and dumped by its founders. And they're still concerned about that.

50:34That being said, it's a little different than the ICO because I think for some of these companies that are trying to create a new decentralized relationship structure between those wanting to loan money and those wanting to borrow money, and all sorts of other sort of leveraged products, it creates interesting regulatory questions because, you know, it seems like that's the type of relationship that's going to be commonplace at some point in the future. Just right now, it's very, very new. And also the incentives for me to borrow money on a lot of these platforms is that I'm going to be paid in some native governance token.

51:20And that native governance token is going to, you know, moon on some secondary market, and therefore I'm effectively being paid to borrow money. And that's not something that is sustainable from a long-term business model.

51:36Vlad CosteaRight, there's a lot of interesting stuff going on that I still wouldn't touch. It's just better to observe sometimes, unless you're very certain about what's going on and you get it. I'm not a speculator. I don't judge people who do speculate, but, you know, I like to observe sometimes and just take a backseat on the events. But we have covered all of these phenomena, but we didn't talk much about you and your background and what you do and what excites you most about this space. So I'm not sure how much time you have because you're on your lunch break, but let's, you know, take 10 minutes or something.

52:20Justin WalesYeah, I have time.

52:22Vlad CosteaOkay, so let's talk about you. How did you first get into Bitcoin? I suppose that should have been the first question I should have asked you.

52:31Justin WalesSure. So I was in law school and all I wanted to do after I graduated law school was to practice First Amendment law. Like, I was a punk growing up, and then, like I think a lot of us who are, you know, sort of have a rebellious streak, but they're able to take a standardized test pretty well, I ended up doing pretty well in school and deciding to go to law school on scholarship right during that financial crisis. So I was hiding away in law school and I just thought to myself, well, what kind of law do I want to practice?

53:11I want to do something where I felt like I was wearing a white hat, and I got really focused on the First Amendment and doing research on that sort of topic. And if you were paying any sort of attention during 2010, 2011, with what was happening with WikiLeaks and Julian Assange, you saw that the Obama administration had effectively forced an embargo on donations to WikiLeaks. So I was on Twitter in, I guess this must have been early 2011, and Julian Assange or WikiLeaks tweeted out, "If you want to donate money to us, donate money through Bitcoin." And that's how I heard about Bitcoin.

53:52I was following WikiLeaks and they broke the technology to me. And then, over the course of years, you know, it's just a matter of like you fall down the rabbit hole and you get more involved and you start learning more about it. And at first, my first instinct was it felt like a scam. And then I would have people who were friends of mine who were smarter than me explain to me, you know, what was actually going on. And through that process, I became, I would say, more technical and sort of understood it more at a protocol level.

54:32But at the time, there was never a desire to practice Bitcoin law. I always joke that it's like saying that you want to practice time travel law or something. It just was not a thing. So I got a job after law school doing constitutional law. And slowly over time, friends of mine who were in the community started businesses, or they had enough money where they needed a tax lawyer, or, you know, they needed some help on the legal side.

55:04And when you're the only lawyer someone knows, you're the lawyer they call. And I was lucky enough to be at a firm that had 400 lawyers in every possible area of law that you could think of. So I would go to the tax folks or go to the securities folks or go to the money transmitter folks and say, "Well, here's... let me explain to you the Bitcoin or the crypto part of it, and, you know, I'll work with you on the traditional law stuff."

55:28And in about 2014, the practice got enough traction that we made it its own practice group within the firm, and the firm was just really supportive and really understood sort of the potential there. And over the last five, six years we've been, you know, steady going at it. It's me, it's a guy named Matt Cohen, who some of the listeners might know, and a guy named Drew Hinkes, who goes by Propel Forward on Twitter. But it's the three of us, along with probably at this point about 15 other lawyers from more traditional backgrounds who we've, I think, taught enough about the technology and the crypto part that they can apply it to their own individual practice.

56:16But, you know, we've kind of gone, I think, a little under the radar, just because for a while we were all based out of Miami, which is kind of a weird market to be in. But I'm out in LA now. I moved out to LA last year, partially to continue growing their practice on the West Coast. And yeah, it's been good. You know, we represent folks from every imaginable sort of sector within Bitcoin, from people on the Lightning Network to payment processors, Bitcoin ATMs, exchanges, mining operators, mining pools, and everything sort of in between.

57:00So we have a pretty good background. And for us, the most fun thing is when someone comes to us and is trying to do something really, really sort of out there, and we get to really start to put some of these arguments we've been developing for years to real use.

57:22Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I've been speaking to a friend of mine who has just graduated from law school. And she was not sure what she wants to do, what she wants to practice. And I told her, you know, there's this very burgeoning and rising Bitcoin stuff going on. And there are not many experts here in Europe on the topic. So you can actually become one of the first to get specialized in it. And she just told me it's not well established enough. So she did not want to do it because it involves taking risks.

57:57And it's just easier for a law graduate to go to something that's more established. Of course, the rewards on the long term are not going to be the same as taking a risk to study and research something that's up and coming, and then becoming a big name and one of the first to pursue something. There is a price to pay for trying to be a pioneer. But how would you advise law graduates? Or what would you tell them about getting into Bitcoin?

58:29Justin WalesYeah, I think there's two ways of doing it. The first is you're a securities lawyer, you're a money transmitter lawyer, and you work at a more traditional practice, and then you're being exposed piecemeal to, you know, crypto and sort of that area. And that's a perfectly fine way of going about doing it. What I would suggest, and this is what happened to me and my group, is we were pushing the firm to let us start going to conferences, writing papers, spending more time talking about Bitcoin and crypto, because we were already doing that.

59:06You know, we were just completely obsessed as a group of young lawyers of the firm. When I started with Matt the crypto practice at the firm, I think I was a third-year lawyer. It was, you know, I was really young. At the time, I was being told by some people who were older in the firm, "You shouldn't be doing this. You know, just put your head down, bill your hours. You know, this is too big of a risk." And it was a risk. If it didn't work out, I probably wouldn't have my job anymore. But the fact is, is that the industry continues to grow.

59:47I took it seriously. We started doing, I think, pretty innovative stuff. And as a result, you know, I actually have a much better career now than I would have, because I did take a risk. I felt comfortable taking the risk because I was really confident in Bitcoin. And I think that's common for a lot of us in the space where, you know, our families thought we were crazy, right?

1:00:14I mean, I don't know about you, but, you know, when I first started talking about, you know, internet money, people in my family thought I was crazy. They thought I had fallen into a scam. And it's taken years and sort of like my own dedication to show them that there's actually a lot more to it than you would initially think. And also that, you know, it's a smart move to kind of transition a legal practice to that as well.

1:00:40Because if I wanted to, I could be just doing constitutional First Amendment work for the rest of my career and writing briefs to appellate courts, and I would have been happy. But this seemed like an opportunity to, you know, really create new law and to have an influence in a way that is rare in this kind of profession.

1:01:06Vlad CosteaYeah, so I got to give a shout out to my friend Malvina, and I'm going to send her this part of the interview. Hopefully she gets inspired, or maybe not. But anyway, any aspiring lawyer out there's just a lot to discover in any new industry and everything that's up and coming. And the fact that you can get to create legal framework as opposed to just enforce something that exists. I mean, to me that feels exciting and feels much more rewarding than actually debating with people on research papers that may have been published for the last couple of centuries on topics that are very much general.

1:01:52And they may be safe, but at the same time, on the job market, you have to compete with a lot of people who do exactly the same, maybe more experienced than you. And you have to be competitive and come up possibly with better rates or with extra work. It doesn't mean that you shouldn't have good rates and a good work ethic. But at the same time, stepping into a new sector comes with rewards of its own. And being able to be one of the first to do something in any field out there ever has had its great rewards. And I don't feel like Bitcoin is going away anytime soon.

1:02:35Justin WalesNo, and, you know, like one of the things that's sort of interesting is that there's so many opportunities when you're early on that, you know, you just wouldn't have normally. So for instance, in 2016, we contacted Westlaw, Thomson Reuters, which is a legal publication platform, like the biggest one, at least in the United States, and said, "Could we publish a treatise with you guys on how states are treating virtual currency regulations and blockchain?"

1:03:13And they said, "Yeah, sure, that's fine." At the time, you know, I think the treatise was like 10 pages long. It's very short because there were so few states that really did anything. But we said we're going to publish an update every three months. So it wasn't really that difficult to even do. And now every three months we add sort of whatever has happened in the last three months. And the treatise is something like 40 pages long. And I imagine in, you know, five years from now, it'll be something like 80 pages longer.

1:03:46You know, it's growing at a good clip. But now, me and Matt Cohen write the absolute premier treatise on how states treat virtual currencies. And we see the metrics for how many people are actually downloading them. And it's staggering. And we see who's downloading them. And these are people from every regulatory body in the country. These are people at the largest companies, insurance companies, technology companies. And it's just an example of like, if you see where the ball is going to be, you run to where the ball, where you think the ball is going to be, you know?

1:04:27And for those of us who are in law school now and are thinking about a career in this space, I would say if you love it and you think about it and you think this is really where the future is, then, you know, start writing and people will eventually take notes.

1:04:45Vlad CosteaYeah, that's inspirational. And thank you for paving the way, because that always helps to be one of the first to do something and make it safe for everyone else to follow.

1:04:58Justin WalesYeah, I mean, in some ways it's selfish. I mean, I wasn't doing it for any altruistic reason. I was already thinking about this and it seemed like a good way to both carve out a niche within my career and also in some ways to like give back, you know. I was able to take risks because I got stupid lucky and saw a tweet at the right time in my life. You know, like there wasn't anything special about it.

1:05:29And I think for a lot of us, it's the same way. It's just you caught the bug at the right time and you got obsessed in something that probably shouldn't have worked out as well as it did. And if you're in that position, you know, and you got in like pre-2017, you know, I think 2017 is when sort of like a lot of people from the mass population started to pay attention. But if you were in it before then, you saw the ups and downs.

1:06:02And it all worked out. I think there's some obligation to give back and to try to build this community up and to build whatever profession, you know, you happen to have some expertise in, you know, to help them, you know, grow with Bitcoin.

1:06:24Vlad CosteaNo, it's still exciting. So you might think that it's a bit too late and people got in first and it's becoming much more institutionalized. But it's still the early days. You look at Twitter, you notice that it's the same people, just arguing and interacting and making up and creating memes and making fun of each other. It feels like a large family that's not expanding as we expect. And unfortunately, the adoption that we're getting is not from the masses first. Well, I don't know... It seems like institutions have taken a bigger step, at least in the last couple of years.

1:07:09Justin WalesSure, but here's a good example. I work with guys who are in their 60s, 70s years old. They've been lawyers for 40, 50 years, some of them. They have millions and millions of dollars, right? They're not, they're not investing in Bitcoin to moon. Like, they don't need the money, but they understand why it's there. They understand sort of, it's a hedge against the dollar, and they want to diversify. I know people right now who still don't trust Coinbase. They don't want to sign up for a Coinbase account.

1:07:56What they want to be able to do is just manage it through their traditional bank dashboard. Or they want their financial advisor to manage it for them. Or they want to buy like an ETF. But they can't do that yet. So the reason why I think it looks like institutions are like moving forward with it is because folks like these old men lawyers are pushing their financial advisors and their banks and regulators to allow them an easier way of interacting with Bitcoin and other virtual currencies. I'll give you just like a little example about, I'd say, I think it was maybe 2015.

1:08:44I had a financial advisor come to my law firm. And this happens sometimes at like these types of, you know, someone will sneak in because they have a meeting and then they'll just go around and introduce themselves to all the lawyers. So I go and I talk to this financial advisor. And he says, "Oh yeah, you know, I can help you manage your money. What's your financial goals? What have you?" And I said, "Well, what do you guys think about, you know, Bitcoin?" And he hadn't heard of Bitcoin.

1:09:18So, "Okay, well, you know, I don't think, you know, I don't think I'm ready for a financial advisor. Thank you." In 2017, the same guy, because he had another meeting, came around, and this is right in the middle of the boom. And he came and we talked again. He goes, "Are you ready to have a financial advisor?" And I said to him, I said, "You know, what are your thoughts on Bitcoin?" And he says, "We don't think any of our clients should invest in Bitcoin."

1:09:42And I go, "Why?" And he said, "Well, that's sort of the company." And this is Northwestern Mutual. This is not like a small company. He said, "Well, that's what the company's perspective is." And I said, "Yeah, but why?" And he said, "I don't know enough about it to recommend it to my clients." Now, the answer to that should be, you should learn as much as you can to determine whether you should recommend it or not. Because if you recommend it, you know, depending on all but like a couple months in the end of 2017, you would have made a very nice return.

1:10:22That's still the perspective of a lot of financial advisors, that this is way too risky. We need to allocate risks in a better way. And what do they do? They end up pushing their clients into what is often these high fee insurance products, you know, that helps them make more money. So, the reason I'm very happy that institutions are getting involved in this is because it means it'll make other people more likely to interact with it at some level. And that's only good for all of us. It's good for our crypto holdings.

1:11:02It's good for having a hard money asset being the reserve currency of the world, it's good for democracy, it's good for anti-censorship, and as I explain in the article, it's also good for our expressive and associational sort of relationships.

1:11:24Vlad CosteaYeah, my only issue with ETFs is that even though we may not like or trust the exchanges that we have today, they are still very easy to audit. You can figure out how many coins they own. You can track their cold storage wallets on the blockchain. You can see, for example, in the cases of Coinbase and Kraken, you can see how many bitcoins they own. And you can do some sort of check to make sure that they are liquid and they own all of the assets that they claim to and do not engage in fractional reserves.

1:12:00Whereas in the case of banks getting in and selling ETFs, that's not as transparent, so you cannot be sure that they actually hold the actual Bitcoin amounts. And once it gets into this traditional financial system, we should basically be 100% sure that institutions will not really own the amount of bitcoins that they're actually selling on ETFs. And we have seen what happened, for example, to oil like four or five months ago, due to ETF trading. It went to below zero levels, even though it's something that's being used by billions of people every day.

1:12:42You leave your house, you get on a bus, or you travel by plane or something. It's not something that's useless. It's a very valuable and essential kind of commodity to get oil, and it ended up being traded below zero. So I can see that the same institutions that embrace Bitcoin can do pretty much the same stuff by shorting it with large amounts of money if there's an ETF.

1:13:14Justin WalesYeah, I mean, they're certainly subject to, it's certainly subject to some amount of manipulation. I think the oil analogy is not exactly comparable. There is sort of a built-in production cost of oil that required the negative fee amounts for some period of time, just so oil production would continue.

1:13:42But certainly, you know, as you have more and more complicated financial products being built to utilize Bitcoin, there's more and more possibilities of manipulation. And that's why ETFs are heavily regulated. I mean, and, you know, frankly, that's one of the challenges with like the current ETF issue in Bitcoin is there's a chicken and the egg sort of conundrum, which is the reason why the ETFs are not being approved is because of the underlying volatility of Bitcoin. One of the ways that the underlying volatility of Bitcoin goes down is by institutions getting more involved in Bitcoin, including potentially an ETF, right? So the more people that end up getting involved with something, the less volatile it is, the less subject to market manipulation. I believe. You ever read the book "Digital Gold" by Nathaniel Popper?

1:14:53Vlad CosteaOh, sorry, I lost connection for a moment there, so I didn't hear the last phrase. Hope it gets saved.

1:14:59Justin WalesOkay, did you ever read the book "Digital Gold" by Nathaniel Popper?

1:15:04Vlad CosteaActually, no. It's on my list.

1:15:07Justin WalesIt's great. It's like really, it's like a well-done sort of narrative and it tells the story of Hal Finney and piecing together what happened during the early days of Bitcoin, going up to the Silk Road issues with Ross, and then going through the Winklevoss twins and institutions first coming in. The book I think was maybe written in 2016, so it tells really a very specific early story of Bitcoin. And they have an anecdote in there of one of the Winklevoss twins having owned so much Bitcoin that when he made a transaction, he could himself manipulate the price up and down.

1:15:52Now, what does that tell you? That tells you that the pool is still small. And even now, all these years later, looking at the total market cap of Bitcoin or the total market cap of all crypto, it's still relatively small when you compare it to, you know, gold. You know, when you compare it to the top five performing stocks. So how do you lower volatility? Is you increase mass adoption. And for us in the crypto space, I think you do that two ways.

1:16:27The first is that you understand that everyone you talk to is not going to be as initially sympathetic to what Bitcoin is and what it's supposed to be, and they're going to be suspicious of it. And for me, when I talk to lawyers or judges or regulators or people who are, you know, kind of C-level executives of companies that are not in the industry, I try to explain to them why this isn't as scary as you might think it is and give them some of the kind of fundamentals about Bitcoin.

1:16:55And then the other thing is, we can't keep this as our own secret, you know? I see online, you know, there's a lot of ridicule sometimes when someone tries to get into the space or they try to promote Bitcoin to a wider audience, or they're, you know, they're not hardcore, they haven't been in it so long, and the idea is for us to not take them seriously. But I'm so happy to have those people, because it's almost like a multi-level marketing sort of plan, right?

1:17:31If every Bitcoiner tells three people how great Bitcoin is, and you keep going on and on and on, 15 or 16 rounds in, everyone in the world has had a pitch about why Bitcoin is good for democracy. It's good for the world economy. And, you know, if we can do that, then I think it's just better for everyone involved.

1:17:55Vlad CosteaWith this I can agree, but I'm still skeptical about the idea of ETFs. Because in my mind the fact that it becomes regulated and it's part of the establishment only means that the government can intervene. And it will only intervene in cases of severe actual reasons. And it gives a lot of leeway to banks that have been kind of bad actors in the financial space. And not so long ago they caused the global financial crisis and got bailed out and suffered no real consequences.

1:18:35Justin WalesSure, but there's a fundamental difference between what happened in 2009 and what you are describing. So, for instance, the reason why 2009, I think, was so disastrous was two reasons. One, sure, it was packaging subprime mortgages together in a way that the underlying assets were no longer worth what the market was saying that they were worth. And that's something that could potentially, in like a worst case scenario with an ETF, potentially occur. I think it would take a lot for that to happen, but it could potentially occur.

1:19:23What can happen though, if we move to a Bitcoin reserve currency, is then the government starts issuing bailouts based on, you know, money that they're creating out of nowhere. And that causes an inflation crisis, which we are still dealing with today, and which is just getting worse and worse, right? So the big tragedy of 2009 was probably that the government saw that inflating the dollar and creating a currency crisis actually could be a temporary fix on the world economy. And now we're seeing that again, and we're going to continue to see that until, you know, a gallon of milk is costing $8 a gallon instead of, you know, $3 a gallon.

1:20:14You know, what I think a lot of people don't necessarily realize is that there's two ways for the government to raise money. They can raise it through taxes or they can raise it through inflation, but inflation is taxes. It's just done through a different mechanism. And there's been a mass tax increase disproportionately affecting the poorest and most worse off folks in the country because we are not respecting sort of the...

1:20:50The compact that the government's going to be a good steward for our monetary system. And what Bitcoin does at its most fundamental level, and this was written, you know, basically into the Genesis block, you know, talk about a great piece of expressive political expression: it takes away the government's ability to create more money. And if you fix that problem, you end up, I think, fixing a lot of the inequities in society. It might not be immediate and there might be some large corrections that need to take place and some hardship. But ultimately, I think that's how you get to prosperity. And I don't think an ETF fundamentally changes that possibility.

1:21:39Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess it remains to be seen. Let's hope for the best though.

1:21:44Justin WalesYes.

1:21:45Vlad CosteaAll of this action seems exciting and there's a lot that can be done. Let's just hope that we maintain the core values of Bitcoin and remember why it was created in the first place, and not just let it turn into an auxiliary tool that's being used by the same financial system that brought the global collapse. So, I don't know, maybe you're not allowed to be as anarchistic in views as I am, but...

1:22:19Justin WalesI'm allowed. No, and this isn't me censoring myself. I'm allowed. I just think that if you really wanted to be anarchistic and you really believe that Bitcoin is sort of its own thing and it's decentralized and no one can control it, then you just have to acknowledge that banks and institutions are going to be able to do what they want, because who's to tell them that they can't? It's regulators, but they're able to do it. But that doesn't actually damage the underlying value of Bitcoin.

1:22:51I mean, imagine how fragile Bitcoin would be if it could be fundamentally destroyed by an ETF. I don't buy that it's that weak. I think actually that the fact that you can build an ETF on Bitcoin and get more people involved in it actually shows how strong it is, because it's gotten to the point where it started off, you know, as message board money, and now we're actually talking legitimately about ETFs, giant institutions, third-party custodians, institutional insurance products built to facilitate mass adoption of this currency, and I think fundamentally that's a good thing. At the same time, I wouldn't use most of those products.

1:23:40Vlad CosteaYeah, me neither. But just like in the case of DeFi, it's just interesting to observe, to see how much they can push it until it falls down.

1:23:54Justin WalesYeah, I mean, and that's the point. Like, you know, someone was... I had a conversation with someone once, and they were talking about all the threats, all the potential threats to Bitcoin. You know, is it centralization of mining in China, which I think is overblown? Is it, you know, the grid collapsing? And I think that's not realistic. Is it quantum computing? And I think that's also overblown. And they said, well, what do you think is like the actual biggest risk to Bitcoin continuing?

1:24:26And I think it's the US going back to the gold standard, right? It's just centralized governments realizing that they need to have some limit to what their power is to inflate or to manipulate the currency. But if they do, then the underlying value of Bitcoin dissipates. For a lot of people, it still has all these other uses, and I don't think it ever completely dies, but that, I think, is what drives complete mass adoption. All these other things, including the stuff that I love to talk about...

1:25:05Expressive, associational rights, different types of products being built on it. All of that comes after we recognize that lowercase b bitcoin is ultimately good for the world economy. Now once it is good for the world economy, then you can create colored coins, you can put all sorts of different information onto the Bitcoin blockchain. You can authenticate, you can publish things onto an immutable ledger. But, you know, it really seems like the economic factors are what's going to drive adoption.

1:25:43Vlad CosteaRight. There's a lot that remains to be seen. And it's good that we have these conversations before the events actually happen, so nobody is taken by surprise.

1:25:55Justin WalesYeah, yeah, I mean, I agree. I mean, I don't know exactly how this all plays out over the next couple years, but from my perspective, especially like, you know, I work at a large law firm, and we have clients at the highest echelons of the Fortune 500. And what I see happening now is different than 2017, which in 2017, there were a lot of questions about, well, what is Bitcoin? What's the point? Why should I care about this? How is this going to affect my business?

1:26:34Whereas now, they understand why it's there. They understand what it's supposed to do. There's no longer these kind of instinctual assumptions that it's all about to fail. It's just a matter of when, not if. And that makes me very, very excited for what the next, you know, three, four years ends up looking like. Because I think when we have this conversation, season 11 of the Bitcoin Takeover, have me back on and I think it'll be very different.

1:27:12Vlad CosteaOh, I would love to. And I think I have a last question and you don't have to answer it, but it's still something that you ask people who are into law and live in the United States. Do you think that the outcome of the elections in November is going to have any kind of major or significant or, you know, noticeable impact on what's going on with Bitcoin? Do you think that we are still at the point where there is a clear distinction between what the Democrats and what the Republicans do when they have the executive power?

1:27:48Justin WalesSo I think there's like really two parts to the answer. The first is I doubt that anything has a directly correlated impact onto Bitcoin's price. From a price perspective, you see, you know, like the OCC, for instance, their announcement about banks being able to custody crypto. That didn't have that noticeable of an impact. What did have an impact was, I think, sort of the mini financial collapse we had last March, where crypto prices dropped to around $4,000 and then rebounded because I think people were scared about what the US dollar does.

1:28:39But, you know, I don't think you're really seeing the Bitcoin market react to day-to-day events in the same way you see a traditional stock react to like an earnings report. So that's sort of like on a short term. On a long term, I also don't actually think whether it's Trump or Biden, it really impacts the growth and regulation of crypto. I think for the most part, a lot of the regulation, and the interesting regulations, are happening at a state level.

1:29:18The innovative, you know, Wyoming's been incredibly innovative and that's causing other states to notice. So Wyoming, you know, has done all these great pieces of very pro-crypto regulations. Florida, just the other day, cited Wyoming as a reason why they want to get more proactive. So I don't think that changes much with who's in charge at a presidential level. And then beyond that, I think, you know, a lot of the core financial policies are very similar between like a Biden perspective and a Trump perspective. It's all sort of moderate conservatism, neoliberalism, and there might be some differences sort of at the fringes, and maybe what the capital gains level is might increase under Biden.

1:30:10But I don't think they're going to do enough, no matter who's in charge, that it really changes how successful Bitcoin is or isn't. Bitcoin's success is going to be based entirely, I think, on the world governments continuing to print money out of thin air and normal sort of retail investors and users being able to interact with Bitcoin on a day-to-day basis without as much friction as is necessary right now.

1:30:48Vlad CosteaI actually wrote down that quote about Bitcoin success, which is going to be based on the world governments continuing to print money out of thin air. I'm going to quote you on that one in the article that's going to accompany this interview.

1:31:00Justin WalesSounds good.

1:31:01Vlad CosteaAnd I'm not sure if I have any more questions for you at this time. There's a lot of interesting stuff that you do. I'm sorry I was not able to cover all of it. I know you also indexed all of the articles that were written on the topic of Bitcoin, and you classified them and you sent me an email, and I took a look and I found it interesting, but I had no idea how to use that data and what kind of purpose it may serve. I guess you know better.

1:31:34Justin WalesI think it's anecdotal, frankly, and I think it basically tells you two things if you look at all the data of every law article that's been written about Bitcoin since it was created. It tells you that there is a hyper-focus on sales of tokens, such that you can assume that regulators, judges, average people are basically conflating ICOs and token sales with Bitcoin, and that's bad for Bitcoin. And then the other thing, which is maybe not so surprising, but at least the statistics prove it out, is the rate in which academic papers are being written is almost doubling every year.

1:32:27So it's sort of on an exponential curve, and the majority of the articles are being written by younger folks still in law school, which I think is a good thing, because hopefully those law students then continue their research, get jobs either in-house at crypto companies or at law firms doing crypto work. And they take a perspective which I think is necessary and is one that I take, which is, I understand what the technology is there for. I understand why it's important from a philosophical and economic level, financial, an expressive level, communicatory level, a democratic level.

1:33:17Whereas I think a lot of the people who are advising clients, including very large companies, tend to take the perspective of "I've been in securities law for 40 years. I've represented, you know, these types of regulated industries. So therefore, I'm going to view everything that happens using Bitcoin or crypto in that same lens." And then you end up, I think, becoming a little too restrictive for, you know, your own purposes. And so I think understanding what the industry is building, and sort of the history of it, gives you a little more comfortability with how you make the arguments about why something is not necessarily the same as an orange grove, or why something should not be treated as money in this situation because it's of a de minimis nature.

1:34:19And that's what I hope, you know, the people who are listening to this, who may be thinking about law school or are lawyers or young lawyers, sort of take away: that you actually do have an impact on how the industry develops, in the same way that First Amendment lawyers had a huge impact on how the newspaper industry developed in the 60s and 70s. I mean, the Pentagon Papers case is a great example. What happened in the Pentagon Papers was there was documents related to the Vietnam War that were leaked.

1:34:52They were sent to the New York Times. The New York Times published it. And then that case about whether they were allowed to or not allowed to publish it went to the US Supreme Court. During the interim, the heads of the New York Times contacted every general counsel of every major paper in the country, brought them all out to New York and said, "We have an opportunity here to push the First Amendment in a way that allows the newspapers more freedom to report. We should come up with like a cohesive argument, get everyone's input, really understand what we want to accomplish as an industry, and push that forward."

1:35:27And they did so remarkably effectively. And in fact, every year to this day, there's a media law bar, the same group of lawyers and now younger generations as well, that still meet up in New York every year to discuss what we think should happen at a judicial level that will impact the industry. And I think that's something that we need in crypto as well. And, you know, to their great credit, the Coin Center folks do a great job of sort of leading that charge.

1:36:01But, you know, as more people enter the space, including lawyers and law students and just people who are interested from the industry side, it's important to be speaking the same language. And that's one of the things that I hope this article that I wrote about the First Amendment and Bitcoin does: it gives a different perspective on how to present this to regulators and courts.

1:36:26Vlad CosteaSo, Justin Wales, Bitcoin attorney. How can people find you, follow you, interact with you, send you messages, stuff like that?

1:36:36Justin WalesSure, yeah, so you can follow me on Twitter. My name is @WinstonOnoWales and, I'm sure in the article, you'll link to that name. And also, if you go to justinwales.com, it'll just link you to my law firm bio, and you can read about sort of, you know, all the articles I publish and some of the clients that we represent.

1:37:07Vlad CosteaOkay, so I'm not sure if I have any more comments to add or any more questions to ask you at this time. I'm very grateful that you have given me this time. I've also heard in the background that at some point you got out of the car and you moved and you used your keys or something and you're still talking, which was interesting to me. So I hope that the audience also appreciates that you have taken some of your time at the law firm. I'm not sure if this was your lunch break or just some time off that you took, but being able to talk about all of these issues and promote your work, I guess, is useful, and I hope a lot of people listen to it.

1:37:44And I hope some people actually get inspired to do the kind of work that you do.

1:37:51Justin WalesYeah, and if you're interested in learning more, reach out, especially if you're in law school or a young lawyer. You know, I'm happy to comment on your articles or just talk to you about what my process sort of shepherding a very new and, from some people's perspective, risky practice group at a major law firm looked like. And yeah, it was fun to try to innovate.

1:38:24Vlad CosteaOkay, so thank you very much, Justin. And maybe we'll talk during season, you said, 11, I think, of the Bitcoin Takeover, which, if we follow the schedule, is going to be in like a couple of years. So possibly by then. But I also have a plan for next season, which is going to be season seven, to talk about anything but Bitcoin, to take famous Bitcoiners and talk about music and film and cinema.

1:38:52Justin WalesWell, listen, I want to be on the Beatles one because I can talk about the Beatles all day long.

1:38:57Vlad CosteaRight. I'm gonna remember you and talk about the Beatles maybe a couple of months from now.

1:39:05Justin WalesSounds good.

1:39:06Vlad CosteaOkay, so have a nice rest of your day and I'll talk to you later.

1:39:10Justin WalesAll right. Thanks.

1:39:10================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio call in English, with Vlad recording and Justin calling from his car on a law firm lunch break; there are brief connection drops, and no music intro or sponsor reads are identifiable in the transcript. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 6 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (133 chunks) and 54 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Guest A relabelled Justin Wales; removed "Subtitles by the Amara.org community", "So, let's get started.", trailing "Thank you."; split "Oh, absolutely, yeah" to Justin; moved "Yeah." at 00:14:03 to Justin; fixed Ovelmen, thesis, law review board, "count me out, in", "297... about 300", "its use", "were written", "these more traditional schools"; cleaned stutters; Guest A → Justin Wales; removed hallucinations (justiceandtrade.com, "production of ..." lines, stray "Thank you"s, "This is a video...", "big fan of the Bitcoin community", "The Bitcoin exchange", "This is a very interesting topic"); restored dropped speech from second ASR/re-check (hashed MP3s, internet comparison, "such as your right to anonymous speech", "various state and federal regulators", "Chinese-run pharmaceutical company", "But if you are your own custodian"); split "It's the same." to Justin and the Norway exchange; Hodlnod→HODLonaut, Coda's Speech→code as speech, associational, BCash, "regulate it"; ending "push Bitcoin?" trimmed to "push" since the next window continues with "forward mass adoption"; Relabelled Guest A as Justin Wales; removed hallucinations at 00:37:57, 00:44:15, 00:45:33, 00:46:27 and stray "Thank you" lines, restoring dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe ("transactions and financial products. That being said, if it's built out", "and I want them to do it in a way that's comfortable for them. That's on the one end. The other end is", "raising money for its creators, or"); fixed rehypothecation, on-chain, "insures", "FDIC in the United States", ERC-20, Ponzis, "Bitcoins on"; 00:35:51 interjection set to Justin's "Mm-hmm"; moved "Yeah." at 00:40:24 to Justin; "This" at 00:48:04 restored as Justin's "Look, this"; Guest A labelled Justin Wales; removed hallucinations ("This is a very interesting", "podcast about the financial crisis", Amara.org, "great way/opportunity", justiceandtrade.com, Dept. of State, iTunes line) and restored real speech from Qwen/Scribe (structure, "phenomena... what excites you", "your hours... too big of a risk. And it was a risk. If it didn't work out", "and blockchain"); fixed Thomson Reuters, Drew Hinkes, WikiLeaks, "treating", "real use", "the rewards", restored dropped "technology and crypto part that they can apply it to"; split long 01:00:14 paragraph; Removed hallucinations ("Thank you for watching. See you next time. Bye.", "Thank you." insertions, "This is a video about the", "I'm going to show you how to get started.", "Video is available on iTunes...", "This is a video that was recorded on the Internet..."), restored dropped speech from second ASR/re-check (oil "kind of commodity... same stuff", "not being approved... volatility of Bitcoin goes down", "the negative fee amounts... would continue"), fixed echoes, Guest A → Justin Wales, Northwest → Northwestern Mutual, Russ → Ross, Silk Road, "early days", "worth" not "Worse"; "move to a Bitcoin reserve currency" kept as heard per plan warning; Removed hallucinations (Poli

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00