Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S6 E6 / Transcript
Transcript · S6 E6 · 1:32:28 · 4 Sept 2020

S6 E6: Max Hillebrand on Bitcoin Privacy Advocacy & Wasabi Wallet

With Max Hillebrand. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:31Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to Season 6, Episode 6 of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is the privacy activist, enthusiast, donor to privacy and Bitcoin privacy causes. He just works on a lot of Bitcoin projects. Very recently, he set up a 1 million satoshi bounty for anyone who wants to review the code for Schnorr signatures and Taproot. He's just all over the place. He does a lot of interesting stuff. And his name is Max Hillebrand. Hi, Max.

1:22Max HillebrandHey, hey, Vlad. Very nice to be on the Bitcoin Takeover show. This is really a fun podcast. You have a bunch of fantastic guests. And of course, you are a very experienced and knowledgeable host. So that's a great combination for a good conversation. I'm looking forward to it.

1:37Vlad CosteaOh yeah, rub me a little bit, make me feel good about my position. But I'm really happy that I get to have you. I think I've wanted to have you for about a year or something, almost a year since I met you for the first time. The first time it was in Riga, I think, when we first met in person.

1:57Max HillebrandThat might very well be. The Honeybadger is the cradle for many good Bitcoin friendships, so it might well be.

2:06Vlad CosteaYeah. And it's been a while and you have been doing a lot of stuff in the space. I just looked at you, how you started getting involved in the Wasabi Wallet project and how you were hanging out with nopara73 in Cluj, in Romania. And after that, you started contributing to the GitHub. You basically advanced in ranks. And now you've gotten to the point where you also manage a project that's meant to be like a mobile version of Wasabi. Did I understand that right?

2:40Max HillebrandSo there was a bunch in here. First and foremost, I'm a user of Wasabi. I downloaded one of the versions of HiddenWallet back in the days in 2017 when Adam started hacking on this, and Lucas Ontivero too. And back then I tried it and I instantly had two feature requests. So I started contributing rather soon too. And that was first and foremost to make HiddenWallet dark mode, because back then it was white and that's just ugly and your eyes are bleeding instantly. So that got thankfully implemented, and the first version of Wasabi was in dark mode.

3:14So that was a great success. And the second thing was a bug report because Tor was broken, and I couldn't even connect to the coordinator and to any CoinJoins. So, well, it's actually, way back then there was not even a CoinJoin. Yes, it was early back then. But since then, I've really just gotten to love the project, the individuals working on it, and the vision that is driving this project. And I am absolutely fulfilled and thriving in contributing to it. And you're absolutely right, man. This has been a crazy journey.

3:48And there have been so many projects and side projects and opportunities opened up that I could manifest and take. And one of these, as you mentioned, is a very exciting project that has been in development since mid-2019. So it's almost one and a half, two years now. So this was about creating a mobile wallet that runs the Wasabi code.

4:14But Wasabi Wallet is inherently a desktop wallet. So Dan Gould, the developer behind this project, and the Treibram, actually not too much involved, he's done a phenomenal job of getting the whole magic of Wasabi onto iOS. And I'm especially proud of the way he integrated Tor, which I think is a great way that he's done. So there are many, many exciting things happening in the Bitcoin privacy space, and I'm very happy to be part of it and building these tools.

4:39Vlad CosteaYeah, I know. I saw your excitement. I just saw it in your eyes while you were hanging out with nopara73. And I also had nopara73 in the podcast last season.

4:51Max HillebrandIt was a great episode, by the way. Congrats.

4:54Vlad CosteaThank you. He's a great guy. He just is very passionate about his own work. And he's the kind of guy who is very bad at promoting his own work. So if you ask him to compliment his own project, he's going to go like, "Yeah, it's kind of, it's pretty good, but I still need to do that. And I still need to manage that." And he's very modest. And that's something that's rare in this industry. A lot of people brag about their projects and say, "Oh, mine is the best and everyone else just sucks."

5:23Max HillebrandYes, right.

5:25Vlad CosteaAnd he's not like that.

5:26Max HillebrandNo, he's really not. And that's both a great benefit as well as a bit of a hindrance. The benefit that I see is that Adam inherently has like this starting entrepreneurial mindset. He's a great initiator and builder of the foundations on which then something greater can evolve. And because he has that type of mindset, he continuously finds issues in the current status quo that he ought to solve. And his brilliant mind is constantly trying to find these solutions that are useful in this context. So this is why it's fantastic to work with him, because it's such a, yeah, spontaneous burst of energy that, like, in such a short period of focused time, he manifests, like, crazy things. And then to build upon that and to polish it up is fantastic.

6:27Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I very much agree with you. And let's talk about your involvement, because you have had quite some peer reviews and you have become kind of a spokesperson for the Wasabi Wallet project in the last year, or maybe a bit less?

6:44Max HillebrandNo, actually about two years now. Yeah, well, no, actually, yeah, almost getting even to three. I remember downloading HiddenWallet end of 2017, like during the peak craziness of what was going on. I discovered that little project on the Block Digest. And I was like, "Oh, that's interesting. That's actually someone building something during all this craziness." And so that was nearly three years ago. Wow, that's crazy. Seriously, block time is a crazy rabbit hole. So yes, again, first and foremost, using it. When using the software, any type of software actually, of course you stumble upon little bugs and quirks and issues, things that don't work as expected.

7:30And of course there are also other feature improvements that you would like to see. I am not a coder, I'm not a developer, not at all actually. So for me, if I want to get these features in the tool that I use myself, I need to be active in the community and suggesting these features and helping developers prioritize different tasks that they are working on. Basically giving user feedback. This is really one of the things that I've learned that is so important to free software development.

8:05The user feedback and the user collaboration with the developers, because that is so vital to see actually where the issues are and what should be fixed with priority. And being a part of this type in a free software collaboration is brilliant, because inherently you just hear you need to be a coder to contribute to free software, you need to write code, to review code. Well, but actually that's not true. Again, I've barely written a line of code, maybe some shell scripts at best.

8:38And I've contributed to so many different projects for such a long time now. I'm just baffled by the amount of energy and passion that sparks in me and how I can bring this into a project and actually making it better and greater. That is fantastic.

8:59Vlad CosteaYou seem just so excited about your work. And it's good to have all of this energy in the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. So you have been around and you have observed every stage of Wasabi Wallet along the way. And what do you think is the most significant addition that has been made to it? And would you say that it's a great wallet besides the CoinJoin part?

9:23Max HillebrandOh, absolutely. Wasabi is a really all-around, fundamentally privacy-focused build project. And quite frankly, I know of several users who use Wasabi and do actively decide not to CoinJoin. So there is a decently large user group who enjoys all the benefits of Wasabi other than the CoinJoin. And one thing that I want to mention specifically, and the funny thing is that this aspect was there in the code since day one. And that is very, very, very good network level privacy, meaning that your extended public key and all your addresses and transaction history does not get leaked to any trusted third party server that is not your own.

10:07And that, you know, a full Tor integration and so on, and the smart way of utilizing Tor, that all of these, and of course the block filters, BIP 158, that are being used at the core architecture, all of this was actually in the wallet from day one. And that's what I mean with Adam is such a visionary and a pioneering entrepreneur that really builds the foundations on the very first start. Because there has frankly not been that much of a major jump and improvement that I could pinpoint here on the network level privacy, other than of course upgrading it, polishing it, making it nicer, making it more robust, adding layers of defense. And there's a lot of ongoing work here. Just in the recent release, the Tor upgrade was vitally important and a major success.

11:00So I'm continuously baffled by the core foundations of Wasabi and how well the project was started out initially. And then still how we could polish up and improve it on top. So there were many minor improvements. I just recently tried to run an old version of Wasabi again and it was horrible, really, it was dreadfully slow. And these many additions just made the wallet a more rounder, more polished tool that I really, really appreciate.

11:35Vlad CosteaWhat I like about Wasabi is that it simplifies all of these otherwise power user features that should be complex. So it makes it very easy to use addresses only once to receive funds. And it also makes it very easy to manage UTXOs, which might sound intimidating to new users, but it's actually not when you use Wasabi. It's a lot simpler than Bitcoin Core, for example. All of the interface is just so intuitive. I don't think it requires any sort of special support or tutorials or anything. Maybe the CoinJoin part is the one that needs some explanation about how it works. And by the way, if you were to explain CoinJoins to a newbie, how would you describe them?

12:26Max HillebrandYeah, so first, to how to describe CoinJoins. It's basically a way to de-link your pseudonymous identities from each other. And in the Bitcoin context, your pseudonymous identities are Bitcoin addresses. So the task of Bitcoin privacy is to separate and to keep segregated these different identities under which you control your money, so that it is more difficult for an outside observer to find out how much money one individual has and where he spends it on, and so on. So a CoinJoin does exactly that. If you have a coin that is publicized, for example, you bought it on a KYC exchange, or you accidentally leaked your xpub, or you posted the address on Twitter or whatnot, you can use a CoinJoin to regain privacy of this coin by acquiring a coin that has an ambiguity in the transaction graph amongst these coins from hundreds of users.

13:25And that is a very nice tool to again reclaim some of the privacy that the inherently public Bitcoin network kind of is easy to misuse, right? It's easy to reuse addresses. It's easy to use an xpub-leaking wallet. It's easy to just use automated coin selection and so on. So therefore, many users make unfortunate mistakes. And a CoinJoin is a brilliant tool to fix the mistakes of the past and starting out anew and getting a fresh, private and anonymized set of Bitcoin, where then it is much, much, much more difficult for an adversary to find out how much total money you have, where you spend it on, and so on.

14:04Vlad CosteaRight, but in regards to the mixes themselves, how would you say that they work? Are they individual transactions that happen on chain, or how do they get mixed in between so that you minimize this process to something that anonymizes very efficiently? I think this kind of explanation is useful for somebody who uses CoinJoins maybe, but doesn't really understand how they work. And it's kind of like magic. You press a button, you get queued, and then voila! You have a greater anonymity set for your coins.

14:41Max HillebrandYou know, which, by the way, shows the incredible good UX of Wasabi and CoinJoins already, right, that you don't need to know about all the craziness that is going under the hood. You literally just click a button and magic happens. So this is to get back to an earlier point. Adam always says that Wasabi is not user friendly at all. And of course, I agree that there is a lot of potential on further improving the UX. However, I'm continuously baffled when onboarding new users in person on how intuitively and how quickly they understand the concept of coins in the Bitcoin model and the aspect of having a non-private and a high anonymity set coin.

15:22And these different ways and all the nuances that come with it is rather intuitive in the Wasabi UI. And of course, a lot of room for improvement. We're working on it. But still, this is quite nice. So then to the question, the actual question of how does a CoinJoin work technically? For this, we first, I would say, have to understand what a Bitcoin transaction actually is. And a Bitcoin transaction consists mainly of two parts, an input section, meaning there are individual bitcoins being destroyed or spent, and an output of the transaction, where the bitcoin are again defined on who can spend them next.

16:03So basically the destination of the payment. And this input and output model again is very fundamentally important to understand for Bitcoin privacy, at least in the current sense of the tools that we have, specifically Wasabi. And what then a CoinJoin is, is fundamentally and very basically defined that multiple individuals provide their own individual coins in a single joint transaction. So literally they join their coins and build a huge transaction that has multiple inputs, in the case of Wasabi, hundreds of inputs from about 100 users.

16:38And the output of the transaction, again, has outputs from each type of user, right? So this is the fundamental definition of a CoinJoin, that more than one individual provide inputs to a Bitcoin transaction. And there are many nuances in, first of all, how this shared transaction can be communicated. And here we see different coordination mechanisms like JoinMarket, like ZeroLink, like CoinShuffle and CashFusion and whatnot. And then we also have differences. And one other coordination mechanism that we're currently researching is WabiSabi, which is building on top of ZeroLink and improving many important aspects of it.

17:22And then there's also a question of how do we actually structure the transaction? So what are the inputs and what values do they have? And what are the outputs and what values do they have? And most CoinJoin implementations rely on an equal amount output design, meaning that the inputs can be an arbitrary amount or maybe even an equal amount, but the outputs, at least some of them, are an equal amount. So there are, for example, in Wasabi's case, 100 users that get 100 outputs that are exactly 0.101234 or whatever is chosen in that round. So each user has the exact same value of coin that he gets out of this transaction. And oftentimes a change too, meaning a non-private change that has not an equal value to other users.

18:19It is unique. It is the only output in the transaction that has the value 13 Bitcoin, for example. And because of some privacy attacks, mainly the subset sum analysis, the change output can still be linked to the inputs. So there's no separation of the pseudonymous identities between a CoinJoin input and a CoinJoin change output. And this means that, well, there are here again more and more different nuances to be taken on how to structure the round itself.

19:00Vlad CosteaYeah, so I guess to simplify your explanation, you need to put the same amount of money in one place and shuffle it. It's like, put together a five euro bill and put your fingerprints all over it so that you will never know which bill belonged to whom.

19:15Max HillebrandExactly.

19:17Vlad CosteaSo they are all tainted with fingerprints, with the same amount of fingerprints, so nobody will be able to understand where the money comes from. And that's the whole point. You need to make money also fungible so that one unit is equal to any other one, which isn't really applicable all the time in Bitcoin.

19:42Max HillebrandI like to have a very nuanced point of view on the fungibility of Bitcoin because there is an inherent fungibility that is baked into the protocol at its very core. And that is the fungibility of satoshis, the monetary currency unit that is actually used in the protocol. And you see this, for example, if Alice has an input coin worth one million satoshis, then she can generate two output coins, one 600,000 and the other 400,000 satoshis. And as you see, there is no inherent linking between the satoshis of the input, how they were divided specifically. Satoshis are inherently fungible, same as, for example, gold atoms are fungible. One gold atom is just the exact same as any other gold atom.

20:32And so it is with satoshis. However, where we do have an inherent and by design and in fact necessary unfungibility is in the UTXOs, the transaction outputs, the actual bitcoins that are being created. And here they are not fungible in multiple aspects. For example, one coin has the public key of Alice, right? And the other coin has the public key of Bob. So inherently, these two coins are fundamentally different because one is controlled by Alice and one is controlled by Bob.

21:02We in fact don't want to have fungibility in a UTXO because otherwise anyone could spend it. So there are many inherently not fungible traits about the coin itself. Similar to how a gold coin can have a different vintage on top, like a different picture or a different number or drawing or whatnot. And it can be clipped a bit and bent and broken. Each coin is inherently unique. But again, the amount of gold atoms inside the coin is what is important. And same it is in Bitcoin. The UTXO itself is very nuanced and different and a unique snowflake for everyone.

21:40But the inherent amount of satoshis is what is the inherent fungible monetary current unit that we need. And praxeologically and economically speaking, that is the important thing. So Bitcoin wins in fungibility with a landslide.

21:59Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess that's a good perspective on it. But you have mentioned like a few minutes ago, WabiSabi, WabiSabi, or what do you call it? And...

22:10Max HillebrandYes, WabiSabi.

22:11Vlad CosteaSupposedly, if I were to assume, it's a fork of Wasabi that's primarily designed to work for mobile phones. Am I right about that?

22:21Max HillebrandNo, no, no, not really. So, Adam has researched and invented ZeroLink in, I believe, 2016. And again, he started working on it throughout 2017 with HiddenWallet and then Wasabi Wallet. So, this is by now a four-year-old protocol that is based on an ancient idea by Gregory Maxwell in the initial summary of what a CoinJoin is. He mentioned blind signatures, which is what ZeroLink uses. So this is a very old idea, and we've kind of reached the limits of it. And there are several downsides to the current coordination mechanism that we use.

23:00Mainly that there's some information that the coordinator has that an outside observer does not have, which is not optimal. So we have started over a year ago the Wasabi Research Club and hired several researchers and privacy enthusiasts to learn more about different nuances of CoinJoin, the actual privacy model that is involved and so on, with a goal to eventually find something that is better than ZeroLink. That was our original goal. And then after a while, we got many good insights from different protocols. And we decided to refine or to stay with the fundamental concept of ZeroLink, meaning a centrally coordinated CoinJoin where users provide inputs in an anonymous way. They provide outputs in an anonymous way with good denial of service protections and a well-rounded trade-off model.

23:53We were then looking for cryptographic primitives that could solve this for us. After a lot of research and with a great recommendation by Jonas Nick from Blockstream, we discovered keyed-verification anonymous credentials, which is a complex sounding, and the cryptographic formula is also a bit crazy, a cryptographic primitive that was published in this way by Signal. The encrypted chat application uses this cryptographic primitive to encrypt the group chats. And we use the same cryptographic primitives to coordinate the CoinJoin round so that users stay anonymous against the coordinator and other participants of the round.

24:36And this is what our research has been focused on so far. We've published that to the Bitcoin dev mailing list and have hired several peer reviewers to look at it. It seems to be a sound cryptographic protocol. Right now, our continuous work is first to implement the crypto magic, which is currently happening. Lucas Ontivero, Istvan, and nothingmuch are working on this right now with several pull requests to the WalletWasabi repository, and to continue to research transaction structure. So what is actually the type of input, the value of the input and the output?

25:12How do we actually set up the transaction and not just one transaction, but the entire transaction graph of all the users in a way that is block space efficient and privacy preserving? And this is still ongoing research and work in progress. There are many, many uncertain questions that we still have to discover and many nuances before we even can start implementing the coordination code and the Bitcoin code for all of this.

25:40So it's an ongoing work in progress with already a lot of time and money invested. But I think we're on a very phenomenal path towards finding and building a great tool for Bitcoin privacy.

25:54Vlad CosteaYeah, so I got it mixed, pun intended. I confused WabiSabi with the other iOS CoinJoin project, which you mentioned, I think this week.

26:08Max HillebrandYes, so there is a company who is sponsoring several Wasabi contributors. The company is called zkSNACKs. It was started by Adam and Bálint and Greg and hires, I think, by now 17 full-time monthly contributors to free software, mainly Wasabi Wallet, and as well as a bunch of public contribution games where even anonymous contributors to free software can get paid.

26:38So it's a very profitable and very generous free software company that I love to be a part of. And this company is focusing on developing the Wasabi desktop application. And right now, we do not see the priority to build a mobile client. And that was the statement for years. There's so much work to be done. We just cannot focus on mobile clients right now. However, Wasabi is free software, obviously. And this means that there are, in fact, three independent teams that I know of working on three independent mobile wallet solutions.

27:13Two of them are public and announced. One of them is Cypherapps, which is a front end to the Cyphernode backend. Cyphernode was built by the cypherpunks at Bull Bitcoin, who I know are also on your podcast, Francis Pouliot, Kexkey, Schulte Klopp, all of these guys. They have built a phenomenal backend. And in fact, they have integrated Wasabi Wallet a year and a half ago, probably, and have been using it in Bull Bitcoin actively since that time, CoinJoining their own money, so to protect the privacy of their clients. Quite a heroic entrepreneurial act, if you ask me.

27:46And these guys, again, have integrated Wasabi perfectly into their flow. Like automatic mixing, they use the RPC server to a great extent with automated payouts and whatnot. Super good setup. And of course, Cyphernode is open source. And now Cypherapps is a mobile interface to connect to your Cyphernode backend to manage your Lightning node, to manage your Wasabi Wallet, and so on. So this is quite nice that you now have an easy mobile interface that connects to a powerful backend server to run your Wasabi. And this Wasabi can be always on in the background, mixing 24/7. You don't have to worry about it. You just spend it with the mobile interface whenever you want to.

28:29Quite nice. The other project that is now specifically a mobile wallet on iOS is called Chaincase. And Dan Gould, who is a rock star C# developer and an old friend of the team, old TumbleBit contributor even, he has been working on this, as I said, since somewhere in 2019, I believe. And what he has done is to not go with a server-client architecture, as Cypherapps and Cyphernode does, but rather to take the whole Wasabi desktop application code, the entire source code basically, and to port it to a different platform, whatever that means in developer talk.

29:07I actually don't know. I think he uses Xamarin or something. And then, so he has the full Wasabi code running on iOS actually, and he's built a beautiful user interface on top that is super easy to use, send and receive. It does, I believe, automated coin selection by default, so you don't have to worry about it. But there's an option to manually coin select when you want, because this is just built into Wasabi architecture. There is also a CoinJoin feature that is currently running. And the thing that I'm most proud of about Dan here is how he integrated Tor.

29:43Because this is by far, at least that I know of, the most powerful Tor implementation that we have on iOS so far. Because again, Wasabi is a heavy Tor user. And this is mainly the reason why we actually thought that building it on Android and iOS is super, super difficult, because we use Tor so extensively. There are like multiple Tor circuits talking to different identities in parallel all the time. And this is quite resource intensive. But he managed to figure it out on iOS, which is fucking fantastic. So there have been CoinJoins happening on mainnet for many months now, ongoing almost daily. And these are two of the independent Wasabi mobile wallet applications that are being built. And another very awesome one is very active in research and development.

30:33Vlad CosteaRight. So as far as I know, JoinMarket is basically just like Wasabi Wallet, but without a central coordinator. Anyone can become a coordinator for CoinJoins. And therefore, given this presumption, how are these two implementations different, Wasabi and JoinMarket? What are going to be the differences in terms of how they CoinJoin? Would you say that WabiSabi is going to be much more advanced or does WabiSabi implement something that is already in JoinMarket?

31:10Max HillebrandSo first and foremost, the peers who have contributed to JoinMarket are absolute fucking heroes to Bitcoin privacy. They've done a monumental work. So Chris Belcher, Adam Gibson, Chris Stubbs and all the many, many contributors, really incredible work. And JoinMarket is one of the oldest and one of the most sound and resilient CoinJoin technologies out there. Cypherpunk as fuck, for sure. And one of the biggest strengths is that decentralized aspect.

31:36So in JoinMarket, there are two different concepts. There are market makers who are users who are willing to CoinJoin any amount at any time. So you basically say, "I want to CoinJoin between 0.1 and 10 Bitcoin anytime. Call me if you want to CoinJoin," basically. And then there is a market taker who will look up these public market makers and choose some of them. Let's say, I think by default it's 12.

32:04And so he takes 12 market makers, and now the market taker acts as the central coordinator of this specific round. So the user who buys the service of the CoinJoin from the makers gets to coordinate this transaction. And there are several benefits to coordinating a JoinMarket transaction in the current implementation. And again, or maybe I should say that before, the aspect of having a decentralized way to finding participants in a CoinJoin is independent from how the CoinJoin is actually coordinated. So the cryptographic protocol that is used, as well as the final CoinJoin transaction that is built.

32:48So the greatest strength of JoinMarket is specifically that aspect of having a censorship-resistant discovery mechanism for peers to find themselves and do a CoinJoin. That is the brilliance of JoinMarket, and that's why I absolutely love the project. And many Wasabi contributors are JoinMarket users and contributors too. It's a great relationship, I would say. The thing where I'm having my troubles with JoinMarket is specifically the communication coordination that is chosen to communicate the CoinJoins. Because there are some benefits and some downsides to it.

33:26The market taker, and that can be any user, right, as we established. He will query, for example, 12 market makers, and each market maker will send the inputs that he wants to provide for the CoinJoin, as well as the outputs. But, and I'm a bit unknowledgeable about the nuances of this, the gist of it is that communication is not privatized and anonymized against the taker. So the taker, the coordinator of this round, can de-anonymize every participant of this round. He knows exactly which market maker has which input and which output.

34:01This is where ZeroLink improves upon, because the coordinator does not get this knowledge. And WabiSabi improves on ZeroLink even further, so the coordinator has even less knowledge. So specifically what we want to achieve with WabiSabi, but the same was already the goal of ZeroLink, is that we want to get a stand, well, first of all, we want to build a sound and neutral communication protocol. We have built the coordination and the cryptography in WabiSabi in a way that it can be applied to JoinMarket CoinJoins too, right? This is a very generalized coordination mechanism.

34:38And so we hope that JoinMarket can or will research WabiSabi and then hopefully improve upon it in their implementation, which would be fantastic. So it's not really a competition because, again, Wasabi prioritizes the efficiency and the network effect and the denial of service protection of a centrally coordinated CoinJoin over having that decentralized peer discovery mechanism that JoinMarket uses. However, because of that centralization, from day one there was an inherent need so that the coordinator has zero knowledge about the other participants of the round. This is an important aspect here.

35:23So again, I think the two projects are pioneering in the space and absolutely lovely. And I hope that with further collaboration, we actually even thought about integrating JoinMarket in Wasabi a while ago. So hopefully with further collaboration, we can improve the toolset of Bitcoin privacy for all users out there.

35:48Vlad CosteaWhat about the whole situation with Samourai? I don't want to get into the drama. I don't want to say anything nasty about them. But it does seem like there is some sort of competition. And for quite some time they have said that the Wasabi mixes are not good enough and theirs are better and stuff like that. Would you say that you're competing with them when you develop Wasabi, or are you in a league of your own?

36:16Max HillebrandThe enemy that I'm fighting is tyranny, and that tyranny comes on several fronts. It comes, of course, on inflation, which is theft on a grandiose scale, and Bitcoin fixes this. However, tyranny comes also in the form of surveillance and direct theft of property. And here is where Bitcoin privacy tools come in. So the enemy that I fight is not Samourai. I couldn't care less about the kindergarten bullshit that is going on there. It's not worth my time nor my money.

36:54I am fighting an enemy that is much greater and much more powerful, and that enemy deserves my full attention and the full focus that I can muster. So I will continue to stay out of the kindergarten fight as much as possible, and I will continue to build stronger and stronger Bitcoin weapons and develop and use these as much as possible and educate my peers on how to use them properly, so not to their detriment. And, you know, if there is a personal disagreement amongst individual contributors to free software, well, then so be it.

37:24I, frankly, don't want to meddle with what other individuals do. And if other individuals think that wasting their time on Twitter kindergarten is worth it, then please do what thou wilt and I will not stand in your way. But likewise, I see that same respect for myself. And again, where I focus my time and attention on is very important and a very selective task that I do routinely. So I will continue doing what I'm doing and improving upon the tools that I use. Because I don't use Samourai, I also don't see any reason why I should want to improve it or even comment on it.

38:02Vlad CosteaThat's a very diplomatic reply. And I appreciate that you kept the discussion mature. But I was just wondering if WabiSabi is so much more advanced that it leaves, you know, Samourai in the dust with their implementation. They seem to be quite cocky about what they have and always say that they have postmixes and all of these advanced cryptographic features that grant you extra privacy.

38:35Max HillebrandWell, I mean, again, WabiSabi is a very generalized protocol, and most any CoinJoin implementation could potentially utilize it to improve their communication with the coordinator and thus improve the use cases and opportunities that that CoinJoin can make. WabiSabi is free and open source software and a free and open source concept too. It was all published under the MIT license. So, of course, anyone is free to review it, to implement it and to build different software implementations. The more the better, actually. But one of the goals that we had with WabiSabi was actually not really to improve postmix, but rather to make every transaction a CoinJoin.

39:17And one of the major, major, major, major, major benefits of WabiSabi is that we no longer rely on equal outputs, equal amount outputs. We can have arbitrary amount outputs, and this is not broken in the cryptographic communication. So with a smart transaction structure, we can actually gain a decent amount of privacy for arbitrary payment amounts. So if Alice wants to pay Bob 1.23456 Bitcoin, she can do so, and she can do so inside a gigantic CoinJoin transaction that has been coordinated with hundreds of users, thus gaining quite a decent amount of privacy.

39:52So for us, there are several of these aspects that we just see that WabiSabi is such an order of magnitude improvement over ZeroLink, both on the cryptography as well as the possible use cases that we can build on top. I mean, just talking about coin swaps inside a WabiSabi CoinJoin that open a Lightning channel factory, like the craziness that we can do with this is exponential. And one of the main things is we have a bunch of work to do. So again, anyone who will contribute to Bitcoin privacy, even when they tack a bunch of kindergarten onto it, I'm happy to have them on board.

40:33Vlad CosteaOkay, so something else about which I want to ask you concerns the Europol reports, which every year come out and they mention privacy stuff like Wasabi. And as far as I can recall, the report has said that it's quite problematic to deal with Wasabi because it grants users quite a good privacy. And I also noticed that in the latest releases of Wasabi, you're adding some sort of disclaimer by saying that you discourage people from using mixes to hide criminal activity and stuff like that, which wasn't there in the beginning.

41:12There was no user agreement, no terms of service. But I guess you did have to add that for legal reasons. But how does it feel to be surveilled by the Europol?

41:24Max HillebrandWell, all my friends out there in the Bitcoin space, we are under attack. Don't be misguided about that. This is an ongoing war that we are fighting, and it is a war of the most extreme extent. It is a war where our enemy has infinite amount of resources because they print as much money as they fucking want. And the user group that they steal from, everyone who holds and uses fiat shitcoins, is enormous. So they have literally infinite capital to come after us, and they will, and they do. This is again why it's so important to build good weapons of defense. And there are multiple, like for example, JoinMarket, that has done it brilliantly. Very censorship-resistant, everything is verified, very good for your privacy. This is already one of the tools able to be used, and it is censorship-resistant. So it's much more difficult for tyrants to come and shut down JoinMarket than it is to shut down a central coordinator like zkSNACKs.

42:27And of course also zkSNACKs, as a provider of privacy tool, is under heavy scrutiny, the same as any, for example, VPN provider is. And, of course, there are multiple attack vectors that can be taken, both from private individuals who, for example, want to hack the server and get access to logs or export databases if the company has it, which in the case of zkSNACKs, obviously they don't. Otherwise, it would not be a privacy-focused company. As well as government agencies coming after you and applying legal pressure of that kind.

43:06So this is again why there are two lawyers on the board, Valentin and Greg, who make sure that the legal aspect of the company is sound. Layers of defense, and for a company that includes having defense against the legal system. And this is why the company was founded. And this is why HiddenWallet actually stopped, because HiddenWallet did not have a company operating it, or no company operated a HiddenWallet server. But then the Wasabi Wallet rebrand was already together with zkSNACKs. And since day one, there have been terms and conditions, obviously, because this is a private property contract, right? There are free individuals engaging in a free business with a free entrepreneur.

43:53And this is a mutual beneficial trade that ought to be well defined in a private property contract. And this is what the terms and conditions are. So read through them. I think they're reasonable. And they are sent from the backend server, and you should have them on your local computer right now if you're using Wasabi. The first couple of lines are bullet points that do this.

44:15And one of the important things that the terms of service mention is that the coordinator does not have sensitive information about the user, like, for example, the name, like the IP address, like the residency address, like the total Bitcoin holding and so on. Everything is done through anonymous Tor identities. And because of the ZeroLink nature of the coordination, and soon the WabiSabi nature of the coordination, there is literally no sensitive information to log. Even if a government would ask zkSNACKs to give them the sensitive logs about their users, the company is unable to do so.

44:49And if such a letter would ever arrive, the company could simply link to the documentation and say, "Please read exactly here why we do not have any sensitive information about our users.

45:00Thank you very much and goodbye." And this is why having layers of defense, including in meatspace and on the legal side of the company that runs a central coordinating server, like zkSNACKs does, and like other companies do, by the way. Again, anyone can run a coordinator. This is quite important to have, in my opinion.

45:24Vlad CosteaOkay. I know that you invest in a lot of Bitcoin projects that you appreciate, and you also set up a bounty recently for people who are capable, technically inclined, to review the code for Taproot. So what else are you involved in, except for Wasabi?

45:44Max HillebrandWell, I'm involved in the tools that I use, and first and foremost that is Bitcoin. And this is again why I am quite active in keeping up to date with current Bitcoin happenings and development. For example, just reading the Bitcoin Optech newsletter every week is a must, and also contributing to it.

46:07Because I use Bitcoin so extensively for earning and for holding my savings, I want this tool to be as functional as possible, and therefore I contribute to it. Specifically in the sense of Taproot, my contributions were mainly in understanding the concept myself, educating my friends and my peers about this technology, and then, after rigorous review, even giving my conceptual acknowledgement publicly and letting the other contributors and maintainers of the repository know that this is a sound idea that I, as a user of Bitcoin, want to see implemented and that I'm very much in favor of.

46:43As I think I mentioned earlier, I'm not a developer. I'm not a coder at all. I'm a complete noob. So I cannot even, like, I cannot. It doesn't even make sense for me to open the file tab in GitHub that shows the code of the Taproot pull request. It is just so much out of my league. And therefore, I cannot provide any meaningful contribution on the code review or code implementation on the software. Thus, what can I do?

47:15And that is basically to outsource this, to hire a third-party expert who is a coder, who is a developer, who is knowledgeable in all these many nuances that a Bitcoin Taproot pull request review requires. I mean, this is a massive thing. This is incredibly complex. And I'm at a position where it is my responsibility to maintain these tools. And that means that I will invest my capital, my Bitcoin, into making sure that the underlying infrastructure is well built out. Because I will personally benefit so much, so fucking much from having Taproot implemented even a couple months sooner in a smooth upgrade.

47:57And so I'm quite happy that multiple others seem to like agree and encourage me with this opinion. And already Luke Childs and Sanders have matched my donation of 10 million sats. So there's in total like 0.3 Bitcoin, which is fantastic. And there are already, I know of three different developers who are now actively looking into this. Kixunil is one of them who has just finished an initial publishing of his first round of review. Danger Honey is hopefully also going to look into it. As well then two other guys who had pseudonymous accounts and I don't know who they are and don't remember.

48:31But it seems quite nice that there is an encouragement here that review is very, very important. And again, making a public statement, putting skin in the game, showing the support for such a fundamentally important upgrade to the Bitcoin network is one part that is so important for me personally.

48:56Vlad CosteaYeah, so I guess we get to the part where I ask you questions from the audience. And there have been quite a few people who wanted you to reply to questions that are quite specific in their scope. So, Vicarious Drama, his name is Your Password Here, wants to know your perspective on the ETH DeFi degenerate Ponzis.

49:24Max HillebrandNo idea. It's not worth my time. I have very important projects that require my focus, and I deem weapons that empower individuals to defend themselves against tyranny the most important task that I could focus my attention on. Therefore, I pretty much drain out all of the DeFi, Ethereum bullshit that is going on. Might be good projects there and good individuals working on it, and do what they will. However, for me personally, I have unfortunately no second of my existence to waste on such a crap.

50:03Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess that's a waste of a question. 8333.HODL, also known as Crypto Coder Bob, who was also on the podcast a few episodes ago, wants to know, as a privacy-oriented individual, why did you choose to make your Twitter account not anonymous?

50:25Max HillebrandWell, first of all, how do you know that I do not have anonymous Twitter accounts or rather pseudonymous ones? Just because I choose to reveal this form of identity of myself and because I chose to attribute some of these actions publicly to this identity doesn't mean that I don't have other nyms. In fact, I have quite multiple identities. It might even be called schizophrenia. No, but, you know, so that's the first thing.

50:55OPSEC is gradients, and privacy is about choice, specifically the choice about what to attribute to yourself, how to reveal yourself to the world. And so that was a very conscious choice. And it's a very difficult choice because obviously, Bitcoin users and especially Bitcoin contributors and those who are on the forefront of this war are under the radar, of course, or not under the radar, but actually quite in scope. So this is a risky endeavor to take, for sure, and it does keep me on my toes. I did notice that since going more public about my Bitcoin activity, that my own personal OPSEC has increased tremendously.

51:39So I mean, I'm having this conversation right now on Qubes with a disposable virtual VM that is routed through Whonix because I don't trust that whatever server is running here to know where I am. So there are many, many steps that I have taken to defend myself where at least some forms of attack are deterred. But on the other hand, there are multiple positive aspects of attributing a well-known identity that I have in meatspace to this.

52:11First and foremost, it's skin in the game. It is much easier for a pseudonymous account to spread bullshit and lies because the consequences of this are minimal. If the privacy of the actual owner of the sock puppet is kept, then if the lies are detected and discovered, there is no repercussion, no results, no effects for the actual person who did that action. And because I want to continuously and rigorously test myself and put myself in a public peer review, I want to be public with some of my opinions that I deem worthy to share, just so that I get the feedback from others and am able to build a more knowledgeable understanding of this in the future. And another thing is I like meatspace too. And I like hanging out with people in meatspace. And for example, it was great hanging out with Vlad in both Riga and Transylvania.

53:11So, you know, having a complete OPSEC about the government-issued identity that is tied to your meatspace is very, very costly. And the tradeoffs for me specifically as a, let's say, Bitcoin educator, someone who sees the importance of building and developing and educating users about these weapons is a tradeoff that I was not willing to take. But again, this does not mean that I don't have OPSEC. It just means that some of the action that I do, I attribute to this identity.

53:45Vlad CosteaSo thank you very much for that compliment. It was fun to hang out with you in both Riga and Cluj. And I suppose you were also in Berlin, but we did not interact as much. It was a bigger conference with more people and it's harder to talk to everyone.

54:03Max HillebrandYou know, the Bitcoin tribe gatherings are fantastic. And seriously, it's always great to meet the tribe and all the peers who built these awesome tools there.

54:11Vlad CosteaYeah, and you also have a question from somebody who has the profile picture of Mahatma Gandhi, but let me look up the name so I can be precise about it. I clicked on another comment and I lost the thread.

54:26Max HillebrandOh, the bane of Twitter UX.

54:31Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly. So, Sovereign HODL, whose actual name or username on Twitter is btcjson1, wants to know how you use GPG encryption on a YubiKey in your daily life.

54:47Max HillebrandSo how you use it? Yes, so first of all, I use a setup that a good friend of mine recommended. That is the drduh YubiKey setup. It is a very powerful step-by-step guide that is very thorough. I've even done a video walkthrough of it, and it's somewhere in cyberspace to find. And here, so it generates a long-lived master key, which in my case does not expire at all. And this long-term master key is basically my long-term identity that I choose.

55:20And then I have yearly rotating subkeys to sign, encrypt, and authenticate my messages. And these three subkeys are signed by the master key. And only the subkeys are on a YubiKey device, a smart card device, while my master key is in deep cold storage. And I only interact with my subkeys, but I do interact with them on a daily basis. So this is of course used to encrypt communication. So all of my emails are PGP encrypted. Most of my Twitter messages are too.

55:54If I even use Twitter as a communication platform, I always try to send the messages encrypted or move to a more encrypted platform like Signal. And also to authenticate myself. Actually, specifically as a Bitcoin contributor and a Bitcoin wallet contributor, you will be fucking surprised about the amount of scammers and impersonators that I have. If you come to the Wasabi Wallet Telegram group, then I'm sorry to tell you that as soon as you write a message, you will receive three or four messages from Max Hillebrand, from Lucas Ontivero, from BTC Paradigm or from Bálint even, who impersonate that person with the same picture and profile and whatnot.

56:33And then ask, of course, for your Bitcoin recovery words and password. And so for me, if I actually want to reach out to some new person on Telegram, how do I do that while proving that it's actually me, right? And that it's not one of my literally hundreds of thousands of sock puppets and scam accounts. So every time that I reach out to someone on Telegram, I sign a message with my PGP key, including the Bitcoin block hash of the most recent one as proof of time.

57:04Or for example, also for Signal, right? For Signal, you ought to verify the safety number. A nice way to verify the safety number is to exchange PGP signatures over the same safety number. And this actually then proves that there is no man-in-the-middle attack, which is fantastic. I use PGP in my, let's say, entrepreneurial life to sign contracts. I actually don't remember the last time I put my signature on a piece of paper, but I remember signing a contract just a couple hours ago with a PGP key. So, oh yeah, also my password manager and two-factor authentication and all of this stuff are PGP encrypted. So PGP is a phenomenal tool to use, right? And it's great to use it. That's basically it.

57:52Vlad CosteaYeah, so I feel like we have spoken about Wasabi and WabiSabi, and some mobile projects that are derivative to Wasabi. And we have also spoken about what your fans and possibly your sock puppets want to know from you. So right now I want to ask you something very basic. What would you recommend to somebody who wants to go private and maintain privacy online? Where do they start? And what kind of tools should they start using?

58:26Max HillebrandOn the financial level, quit your bank account. No longer use digital forms of fiat. If you use a credit card, you should be appalled and scared shitless with the amount of surveillance and censorship that is going on. That first and foremost, Bitcoin ought to be the only cyberspace money that you use. And fiat is decent in cash. At least it's base money. At least it's private. So both censorship and inflation is reduced, but of course not eliminated. So that is the first thing. Then consider to drop your smartphone too.

59:05I mean, these are surveillance devices, always connected to the internet with camera and microphone and GPS. That is a golden trove of surveillance measurements. If the KGB would have known about that back in the days, they would have rejoiced to see that every individual is all of a sudden voluntarily choosing to leak all of this data to a trusted third party. It's very fucking ridiculous actually. And then of course consider also your OPSEC on your computer level. Further, encrypt everything. If you don't have LUKS encryption or a disk encryption on your laptop that is secure, preferably a whole 12 or 24 word Bitcoin recovery word seed, that is a minimum amount of security just to boot your laptop.

59:55And the same of course for usernames and so on. Use two-factor authentication for any meaningful security. Then consider using a secure operating system. Drop Windows and Apple, of course. Use free software first and foremost. Not because free softwares are inherently better, but they ought to be better reviewed.

1:00:18And of course, they're based on individual freedom and that should be the guiding principle, at least it is for me. And specifically, I can very, very, very, very much recommend to discover the Qubes rabbit hole. Qubes is a reasonably secure operating system, as they like to call it. And it allows for extreme compartmentalization of your life. And that is both a security as well as a productivity improvement. So for example, Twitter, again, I don't have a phone. So my Twitter is... I don't have the mobile applications on. I can't scroll through Twitter while I take a shit, fortunately, actually. It gets the thing over much faster.

1:00:59So I have an independent virtual machine that is the only thing that has my Twitter access keys. On all other platforms I cannot reach Twitter. Therefore, if I want to check out Twitter, I actively need to boot a virtual machine and log in. This means that if I don't want to be on Twitter, like right now, my Twitter VM is shut down. In fact, the only thing that I have is a disposable Whonix virtual machine running to do this call. So these are just some of the tips, but of course education is first and foremost.

1:01:40To understand the actual attacks and to understand the tools that can be used to prevent these attacks and to forego them is of vital importance.

1:01:52Vlad CosteaYeah, I remember talking to Peter Todd and he sang his praises about Qubes as an operating system. He also blew my mind about the fact that he uses very simple security devices that he tailors for his own needs. And he told me that essentially there are lots of security companies that promise that they give you privacy and security. But in reality, most of it is placebo, make-believe. This rock kills tigers, even though you have no tigers around. That's what he said. So he really made me think about the kind of threats that we actually face, not the ones that are invented by companies to sell devices.

1:02:39Max HillebrandYeah, no, honestly, Peter is incredibly smart and has a very well-nuanced opinion here. That in general with his argument, I agree. You know, understanding the threat model is really, really, really important. Whom do you defend against? Who is actually attacking you? That is the person that you have to find out. And then you have to align your actions so that you do not break your privacy and your property right defense against that individual attacking you. And this is very, very important.

1:03:13And again, you know, with, for example, having a custom hardware device to do a security job, like for example, YubiKeys as we spoke about earlier, or a hardware wallet, well, this might be good against many types of attackers, but what if the provider of that product is the actual attacker? Are you still protected? And how do you know then that that provider is not malicious at all? So these are very, very important questions to take into account.

1:03:42And by the way, this is again fundamentally why I love zkSNACKs and Wasabi, because just the name zkSNACKs, it's a company providing snacks, little software products mainly, that have zero knowledge about their customers. This is a core aspect of the zkSNACKs business model, is to not know sensitive information about clients, to not be able to censor them and to de-anonymize them. This is why it's actually so important. This is why I personally decline to work on projects where there is sensitive information being held against the clients. Because that is such an obvious point of attack and no trusted third party is secure and has an unhackable database.

1:04:23So everything that you share to a trusted third party will be leaked. And that includes all types of sensitive information, including financial information.

1:04:34Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess the name zkSNACKs is very smart because ZK stands for zero knowledge, and snacks is actually a reference to wasabi.

1:04:42Max HillebrandPrecisely.

1:04:43Vlad CosteaAnd I guess you can develop all sorts of products that are snacks. And I actually have a bag of peanuts covered in wasabi right here on my desk. Been having them all day. It's a good snack, and it's very good for your breathing, you know? If you have like a runny nose, it's very good to breathe more easily, even though it can irritate your nasal cavities if you have too much wasabi. But anyway, there's also zk-SNARKs, which is something else, and it's a privacy protocol. So I guess you mixed snacks with SNARKs and kept the zero knowledge. That's a good name.

1:05:34Max HillebrandI very much agree. I didn't come up with it. Deja Ray, if I remember her name correctly, contributed to Block Digest. They had a show talking to Bitcoin privacy contributors that was called zkSNACKs. And then Adam asked to take that name for the company because it is just that genius.

1:05:59Vlad CosteaYeah, I just grabbed the wasabi peanut. It's very tasty and spicy at the same time. You see, wasabi is a good thing. So, do you use a hardware wallet? And if so, what kind of hardware wallet do you prefer?

1:06:17Max HillebrandYes, I do think that hardware wallets are a useful tool. I do see some of Peter's points here, that probably an old ThinkPad that you rip all the important infrastructure out of might be better against some attack vectors. But on the other hand, for example, a Coldcard, which is my preferred hardware wallet, is pretty damn good already. And not just do I think that the design of the product is superb in many senses. I also believe that Rodolfo Novak and Peter D. Gray are doing phenomenal work and are actual reputable individuals in whom I do have some level of trust.

1:07:06Of course not for them to generate my private keys, but obviously to provide at least the hardware that is based on cypherpunk ethos. So I think this is in general a great project worth support, and just the UX is also phenomenal. I was really, really happy to see that the Wasabikas, especially nopara73, built the hardware wallet integration in Wasabi. And I made sure that it was tailor-made for Coldcard. And just the PSBT workflow is very nice. It's such a beautiful tool to use together with Wasabi. And yeah, I love Coldcard. Really, I do. And I know that you had a couple shows here about it, too. It's a decent project.

1:07:58Vlad CosteaYeah, because I remember exactly when you started adding support for hardware wallets in Wasabi. And that was a big deal because in the case of some manufacturers like Ledger, you have to rely on their software and they're going to keep your xpub at all times. They know all current and future addresses that you generate. And that's kind of terrible for your own privacy. Plus, you have to trust them with that secure element chip that you have no idea what it does. So the fact that you can connect to a wallet that at least grants you the privacy to manage your own xpub, generate your own addresses and not connect to the servers owned by a company, and connect to your own full node, these are some very great advantages.

1:08:51And I think it's a lot easier to connect your hardware wallet now to Wasabi than it is to Electrum. I may be wrong, but I prefer the Wasabi interface.

1:09:03Max HillebrandWell, you know, regarding this, first and foremost, we ought to thank Andrew Chow, a Bitcoin Core contributor, who has developed the Hardware Wallet Interface. It's just a phenomenal piece of software that was actually the kicker that convinced Adam to implement HWI, because we had hour-long conversations about adding hardware wallet support, and his main argument against it was it's a maintenance burden. There are like 101 different hardware companies out there, and there are new ones coming out all the time. So if you want to support all of them, that's such a hassle, right? And it comes with so much burden and support, you would have to hire multiple devs and support guys just to make sure that users don't screw up and that everything runs smoothly.

1:09:47Then I notified him about HWI, which was back then a very young project, I think just about to be released. And in fact then, it was someone at midnight, if I remember it correctly.

1:09:59And then Adam was like, "Okay, sounds interesting, but I'm tired. I'll go to bed." And I was like, "Yeah, okay, good idea. I will go too." In the morning, I wake up with a message from Adam at like 5 p.m., sorry, 5 a.m. at night. It's like, "Max, I couldn't sleep. I did it. I implemented it. Check out the pull request." And it worked. So that just shows the incredible ease of HWI, because it's literally one binary package that Wasabi has included and runs and calls on to then do all the hardware wallet magic.

1:10:35And quite frankly, today, funnily, that you had the call with Stadicus, because just now the BitBox got compatibility with HWI. So they did their work and made pull requests to the Bitcoin Core HWI repository and made everything compatible. And this means that Wasabi Wallet is compatible with BitBox, because Wasabi is compatible with anything that is compatible with HWI. So that is one of the great advantages of utilizing such a well-maintained and incredibly useful tool. We only need to maintain one software package and do troubleshooting on this one thing, and then all other hardware wallets should work. So this is really hats off to Andrew Chow and all the contributors to HWI. That is phenomenal work.

1:11:19Vlad CosteaWhat is your take on the Lightning Network, by the way? I noticed that the activity has kind of reached a bottleneck at this point. Not many people keep their nodes active as much as they used to last year. And I did notice a post on Twitter this week about what's going to happen if we develop the infrastructure, but the users are not coming. So, Lightning Network gets for me a conceptual acknowledgement, but an implementation not acknowledgement.

1:11:52Max HillebrandVery justly said. I love the Lightning Network. Really, it is such an incredibly genius way to define property contracts of Bitcoin in a way that is efficient, that is fast. It just utilizes the concept of Bitcoin in such a genius way. And I love this idea very, very deeply. And in fact, I've been using it since very, very early. Before there even was a mainnet, there were testnet nodes, right? And then the first very fucking reckless mainnet nodes.

1:12:28That was crazy times. And to see what the community and these individuals have built over the last, when was it? Well, end of 2017, so that's again, yeah, almost three years now. Crazy, I'm getting old. It's almost happening. So it's incredible. So the tools are great. However, there's so much more potential, like infinitely more potential. And I am very happy with the progress so far, but I'm still kind of craving for a well-done, solid implementation. And again, I don't mean anything against c-lightning, LND, Eclair, Electrum. Again, monumental work.

1:13:16But so far, none of these implementations is up to the liking that I would like to have it. And of course, it's for all of these contributors. We all see so much potential. That's why we keep on working on it. So again, this is not a bash. This is just an understanding of how much work there is still to do. So I'm very, very much looking forward to, for example, the project of Rust Lightning, that will be, I hope, very, very nice, or a bunch of cool projects out there.

1:13:46But what I would like to see is a privacy maximalist Lightning Network node implementation, where every single design decision, every single trade-off is optimized and prioritized for privacy above all else. That is really something that I'm craving for. I think so far c-lightning is close to that, or is towards that direction. Rust Lightning is very, very promising. And I hope that eventually, although it will be in the far future, we can do something nice here with Wasabi too. And again, this is still like, I mean, we needed SegWit and the transaction malleability fix to even build this first proof of concept version of the Lightning Network.

1:14:30But still, I would say this is an early proof of concept and very much a work in progress. At least with the addition of Taproot, Lightning Network privacy and usability will increase by an order of magnitude at least. Also, the cost will decrease quite substantially. And then with a future upgrade to SIGHASH_NOINPUT or other types to get eltoo payment channels enabled, that will enable even more. But again, Taproot is probably years out before it's usable, and the other soft forks as well.

1:15:05So this is so much a work in progress and the potential is enormous. I'm again proud and happy to what we have developed so far and to the countless contributors who have been a part of it. I don't want to oversell it though. Like, Lightning Network is not very private at this current point. It really isn't. There are so many privacy fuck-ups in so many different nuances, and more and more of them are being discovered, of timing attacks, side channel attacks and whatnot. So it's far from what it can be.

1:15:40It's far from what it will be. And I know that because there are so many dedicated individuals continuing to work on it and building awesome tools. And I hope that more and more and more of resources and development power will be made available to that effort of building these tools because, by Satoshi, we need them.

1:16:01Vlad CosteaYeah, so I agree with you, with, you know, to some extent. But I'm not sure if I agree with that part about Lightning being too rough around the edges. I think it's still good enough, it just needs more adoption. It needs more people to figure out how to use, and possibly it needs watchtowers, even though philosophically I don't agree with the concept, but they are needed just because different channel states can propagate and cause a lot of trouble that people have been having.

1:16:36Max HillebrandWell, you know, I think the concept of watchtowers is inherently not that much of a problem. Rather, it's a very useful tool. So the service, or rather, there are some Bitcoin-based property contracts that have an online requirement, meaning that the holders of the property contracts have to be online in order to defend them properly. Because there can be breaches in the contract, and the way that these contracts are written, there is an opportunity for an unjustly stolen-from person to remedy these transactions.

1:17:13Basically, in the sense of Lightning Network, to send a justice transaction or punishment transaction. And the thing is that these watchtowers are non-custodial and privacy-reduced and risk-reduced, and they're in fact rather small trusted third parties. They do not hold your private keys. They only have encrypted information, depending of course on the nuances of the implementation. They can operate the service as well as accept completely anonymous clients, and other further things. So watchtowers are incredibly useful for these advanced Bitcoin private property contracts, like, for example, the Lightning Network or coin swaps or RGB or whatnot.

1:17:57There are really many, many awesome, advanced, cool things that we can do where it is useful to outsource the always-online requirement in a trust-reduced way. So I think I'm not actually that much against the principle of watchtowers, specifically because they can be freely chosen. And in fact, it makes even sense for an individual who runs a full node, who by default does fulfill this always-online requirement, it does make sense for him to outsource a backup layer of defense, basically, in the case that he gets offline, that there are still other nodes who can react to the private contract breach of that script.

1:18:41So I think it's a useful service. I don't see anything inherently wrong with it. Of course, it very much depends on the implementation and the privacy aspect of it and so on and so on. But in general, it's a great concept. I'm looking forward to seeing more use cases that we can discover when we have this always-online requirement fulfilled.

1:19:03Vlad CosteaI think that Lightning Labs, when they released the wallet at some point, they had some sort of tracking cookies and they made the community unhappy about that, and I guess this possibly says a lot about their views on privacy. They're probably inclined towards commerce, but not so much towards making Bitcoin more anonymous. I don't know. I don't want to speculate on that, but that was very strange on their behalf to do.

1:19:31Max HillebrandWell, I agree with that observation, and to be frank, it's not just LND or Lightning Labs. For example, Eclair has a beautiful mobile wallet, Phoenix. Or, sorry, not Eclair. ACINQ is the company developing Eclair, and they also provide a product and a service called Phoenix. And this Phoenix is a very, very incredibly easy to onboard, very user-friendly Lightning wallet that in fact I even personally use, and I do recommend it to others, because I have seen the power of this tool in the sense of onboarding.

1:20:03Like, together with Mario Havel from Paralelní Polis, we've onboarded literally 200, 300 users on a weekend with a combination of an offline Lightning ATM and the Phoenix wallet and the BTCPay Server point-of-sale system to sell coffee. So Phoenix is absolutely incredible. I love it, but it's horrible for privacy. ACINQ, the provider of the Lightning services that the ACINQ node provides, knows everything. They know exactly, or they know not everything, they know a lot of things. For example, when you make a payment and so on.

1:20:36So there's a lot of metadata that gets leaked to these trusted, in the sense of privacy, trusted third-party services, although they are non-custodial. So I very much applaud the effort that now in this specific case ACINQ has done. Really incredible, incredible work. Phoenix is a masterpiece. But again, it has so much more potential. It has so much more potential. And again, this is not the final product. We are still so early in the work in progress. And that's why also I'm so surprised, pleasantly, to see the quality of tools that are already out there.

1:21:12However, I'm then still always thinking, okay, it's great already, but it's so bad in some aspects, specifically the privacy is fucked up very fundamentally on different layers. And still then, seeing we are working actively on it and we are going to improve it and to fix it. It will just take more and more and more time, despite the Lightning Network being deployed on mainnet for almost three years.

1:21:38Vlad CosteaYeah, it's actually interesting to see how the same kind of standard for protocols can be used in so many different ways and have different priorities. And kudos to the people who actually focus on privacy development. And possibly they are not the most user-friendly, but they may become sometime in the future. But what I wanted to ask you is what gets you excited about Bitcoin? So you seem happy all the time about all the development going on and everything that's coming in the future. What's your mindset generally? Do you get up in the morning and just say, "Oh, this is such a great day for Bitcoin. Let's start working"?

1:22:22Max HillebrandYes, pretty much, that's it. I am so enthusiastic about Bitcoin because I use Bitcoin to such a great extent. Not just do I understand the implications of it, but I feel the implications. I feel what it does to myself when being based on a sound monetary economic mindset. How that changes the way that I approach projects and work as an entrepreneur. The way that I allocate the resources at my disposal, most importantly, my time and my effort. And I feel how this so fundamentally and deeply changed my life.

1:23:08Not necessarily changed, but fostered these strong principles and this very rigorous mindset. And that it spawns that much action in me. As you said, you wake up, you think this is a good day for Bitcoin, let's make it even better. Very much so. Because I have this incredible, incredible urge to build on this technology, to make it better. Because as an economist, I understand the unacceptable, staggering tyranny that is going on in the fiat empire today. And again, the fact that I am personally being stolen from to such an incredible degree every single fucking second that this empire survives and thrives.

1:23:59Therefore, for me personally, if I want to defend myself, my property and my loved ones, I ought to have the best tools available to do that. And because the tools that I see out there are subpar to what I want to have, I build the weapons even further. And because of the nature of free software and non-scarce information and code, I can share my progress that I've made with improving the tools with the world and let other individuals freely choose to use these weapons of defense. And that aspect of actually using these tools to defend myself, actually reducing the amount of theft that is going on.

1:24:39And not just being able to survive in such a state, but to thrive in it. That is what brings this huge passion of mine to light. Because I understand both on an Austrian praxeological theoretical level, as well as I feel deep within my core the immense power that a sound monetary economy with strong sovereign individuals building incredible tools and services, what that can emerge and what that means for humanity.

1:25:16And not just that drift and slag and drain of the fiat empire, but the complete opposite, the spur of action and creation and doing something meaningful. That is such a profound, fulfilling feeling that I want to continue to experience. And this is why I continue working and working and working on manifesting free sound money.

1:25:47Vlad CosteaThat was very inspirational, Max. I feel like no matter what I ask you, I don't think we can top that.

1:25:56Max HillebrandOh no, no, no, challenge accepted. Don't stagger, keep going. There's a lot of room for improvement.

1:26:04Vlad CosteaOh, there is. But I don't think people will listen to more than one hour and a half of interview. And I'm really happy that I got to have you. So maybe we can do a round two and talk more about philosophical stuff and Austrian economics and specific, you know, details about the philosophy of Bitcoin. But this time, I guess it was about Wasabi and pleasing your followers, possibly your own sock puppets who ask questions just so you can talk about them.

1:26:36Max HillebrandOh yes, I'm curious about the Twitter FUD. That will be fun coming up after the show. I know. But Vlad, really, thank you very much for the invitation. That was great to talk to you here. Again, I love the pod. You have good guests on. Like specifically, just recalling the episode that you had with Peter a while ago about the hardware wallets was very enlightening. I remember listening to that. So yeah, thanks for what you do. Again, education is so fundamentally important because it helps us to build this strong group of individuals with a firm, principled mindset, and who understand the enemy that we fight and who understand the tools that we can use in defense.

1:27:22This is a very meaningful, great work what you're doing.

1:27:25Vlad CosteaAlso, Max, thanks for the flattery, but how can people follow you and keep up with what you're doing? Because you said you're quite a private person, but you are on Twitter, you're on Telegram, you're all over the place.

1:27:39Max HillebrandOh, yes, sure. Again, I do choose to reveal myself in several locations. And this includes Twitter at HillebrandMax. Basically, under this name, you can find me in cyberspace all around. Also on GitHub, which has turned to be my most used social media platform, much more than Twitter. Actually, I'm not that much on Twitter, to be quite frank. I don't know when I last time scrolled the feed. Again, Qubes is such a productivity hack, man. I can only recommend you guys to look into that. The towardsliberty.com is the website and PGP key and everything is on there. But yeah, just reach out. I'm very happy to continue to explore this rabbit hole with other individuals and to have thriving conversations as is this one with you, Vlad. So thank you very much. I would be happy to come back for round two and very much looking forward to that.

1:28:34Vlad CosteaActually, I have a plan for season seven to include conversations about our hobbies in general, to get famous Bitcoiners talk about anything but Bitcoin. And in this case, it can also be economics, it can also be, you know, music or whatever. And I would love to hear some input from you on that one.

1:28:56Max HillebrandWell, wait, wait. But I thought that Bitcoin maximalists are only supposed to talk about Bitcoin and to not have any other hobbies.

1:29:03Vlad CosteaOh, really? Oh, man, I'm disqualified, I guess. Yeah, fuck.

1:29:09Max HillebrandNo, it's a great topic, actually. And, you know, I mean, funny jest, but it's actually kind of the case that we Bitcoiners go a bit overboard with Bitcoin very often. And it's kind of this rabbit hole that sucks your full attention in. So I'm very curious to actually see some of the other hobbies of the crew and to also see how they changed, how their hobby was pre-discovering Bitcoin and post. Because I just imagine that Bitcoin changes priorities, and especially also including hobbies. So that's actually a very fascinating topic that I'd be interested to hear.

1:29:48Vlad CosteaYeah, I'd also love to hear from you about other hobbies of yours, like traveling, like, I don't know, taking pictures or whatever.

1:29:58Max HillebrandWell, economics and praxeology is for sure up there. That has always been a passion of mine. Though, I mean, pretty similar to Bitcoin. So I will probably come up with some other nice tidbits for that conversation.

1:30:12Vlad CosteaYes, sir. So it's been a pleasure. I'm actually happy that we got to do this, but I'm sad that we have to end it at 90 minutes because there is this quote by Alfred Hitchcock, and he said that the length of a film should be proportional with the size of the human bladder. So if you need to take a pee in the middle of the film, that's a bad sign. And I guess people don't take their phones on their toilets, or do they? I don't know.

1:30:41Max HillebrandWell, actually, I mean, the quote very much makes sense in the time of Hitchcock, right, with cinema. But now that you have your smartphone and you can watch movies while on the toilet, sure.

1:30:51Vlad CosteaOh, that's disgusting.

1:30:53Max HillebrandYou know, especially podcasts, you don't even have to look, so that's great. Wait, by the way, how often... Like, we had way too many toilet conversations during this podcast. I think something is up here.

1:31:08Vlad CosteaOh yeah. Like toilet humor. That level of content, so great. Or some people who dislike me would say that I have a shit podcast or something.

1:31:23Max HillebrandOkay, you do have a shit podcast, but at least you don't talk much about shitcoins, so that's a nice benefit.

1:31:29Vlad CosteaYeah, and I don't take them for donations either, like some people do on their websites, and I'm not going to name any names, because that's basically free advertisement and they get it. The people who do this actually enjoy the attention. So thank you for joining. It was really great to talk to you. You're always so enthusiastic and I think part of it is so contagious. When somebody talks to you, they get excited too.

1:32:00Max HillebrandWell, you know, there's a high passion when doing meaningful work. And for me, Bitcoin is a very meaningful work. Therefore, I'm very passionate about it.

1:32:13Vlad CosteaOkay, so I'll talk to you later, Max, and possibly we can do that episode about hobbies.

1:32:20Max HillebrandOh, for sure. Anytime. Hit me up, Vlad. Thanks again for the invitation. Bye-bye.

1:32:20================================================================================ Production notes: Remote video call (Max on a disposable Whonix VM in Qubes), conducted in English, with a short music intro; no sponsor reads are evident. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 6 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (123 chunks) and 52 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 6 of 6 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021", "next episode of the show" and "please subscribe" hallucinations, plus stray "you" and "more powerful wallet" loop; restored dropped spans (00:05:4x–00:06:2x, 00:06:44, 00:08:05–00:08:38, 00:10:35–00:11:00, 00:12:5x, 00:13:2x) from Qwen/Scribe; fixed Schnorr/Taproot, Hillebrand, nopara73, HiddenWallet, Lucas Ontivero, Dan Gould, Riga/Honeybadger, xpub, BIP 158, CoinJoin; speaker repairs at 00:01:22, 00:01:39/54, 00:05:23, 00:06:44, 00:09:22, 00:14:39; Fixed speaker repairs (Max's "Exactly"/"Yes, WabiSabi"/"No, no, no" split from Vlad; removed "Adam Lutz:" label); restored dropped speech from second ASR (CoinJoin mechanisms list, subset sum linking, Wasabi Research Club, Tor circuits, Bull Bitcoin RPC); removed hallucinations ("Bitcoin Privacy Advocacy Podcast", "The real question..." insertion, "Thank you.", "Okay"); fixed names/jargon: WabiSabi, ZeroLink, HiddenWallet, Blockstream, keyed-verification anonymous credentials, nothingmuch, Lucas Ontivero, zkSNACKs, Bálint, Cyphernode, Bull Bitcoin, Francis Pouliot, Chaincase, Dan Gould, TumbleBit, Xamarin, JoinMarket, five euro bill; Restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (12 market makers, "that's why I love the project", applied to JoinMarket CoinJoins, Max's 00:36:43 and 00:41:17 passages, arbitrary payment amounts, Bálint/Greg sentence, private property contract, third-party hire); removed hallucinations (podcast network line, Amara subtitles, "This is a very important topic", Mm-hmm/you); Max's Europol answer split into new paragraph; fixed JoinMarket, CoinJoin, WabiSabi, ZeroLink, zkSNACKs, HiddenWallet, Samourai, export databases, Taproot, meatspace, detriment; Guest A → Max Hillebrand; Removed hallucinations (00:56:33 "Bitcoin Recovery Network", 01:00:18 "Department of State", 01:04:23 URL, stray "Thank you"); restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (Max's opening at 00:47:57, DeFi passage, OPSEC/choice lead-in, Signal/PGP passage 00:57:04-00:57:38, free software, Twitter VM, YubiKey/provider-as-attacker passage at 00:54-01:03); speaker repairs at 00:53:59/00:54:26/00:58:26 boundaries; fixed Kixunil, Qubes, Whonix, LUKS, PGP, drduh YubiKey, zkSNACKs, Bálint, Max Hillebrand, Vlad (Lott), nyms, rejoiced, defend; Removed hallucinations ("Thank you for watching", podcast/Department ads, "next episode about HWI", "very important part/interesting topic" inserts) and restored dropped speech from second ASR/re-check (HWI story, BitBox/Stadicus, Lightning implementations, watchtower backup, Phoenix onboarding). Fixed zkSNACKs, zk-SNARKs, Coldcard, Rodolfo Novak/Peter D. Gray, Wasabikas, nopara73, PSBT, xpub, Andrew Chow, c-lightning, LND, SegWit, transaction malleability, SIGHASH_NOINPUT, eltoo, ACINQ, Paralelní Polis, BTCPay Server; "Danny"→"than", "notes"→"nodes", "my Satoshi"→"by Satoshi". Speaker repairs: "Precisely" and "Very justly said" moved to Max; "That's a good name" and "tasty and spicy" kept with Vlad; Removed "Bitcoin Privacy Foundation" hallucina

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00