S8 E12: Lixin Liu on the KeyStone Hardware Wallet
Search this conversation
0:45Ad voiceoverThis episode is sponsored by Vaultoro. Keep on listening and you'll find out more about how you can buy allocated gold when the Bitcoin bull run reaches its peak. This way, you don't have to deal with infinitely inflationary fiat or banks that freeze your account. Also, note that trading involves risks and the information presented is not financial advice. This episode is also sponsored by Wasabi Wallet. Go to wasabiwallet.io, download Wasabi for your OS, and significantly boost your network level and transaction privacy.
1:40Vlad CosteaHello there, and welcome to Season 8, Episode 12 of the Bitcoin Takeover podcast, which also happens to be the season finale of this whole introspection into hardware wallets. And my guest right now is Lixin Liu. And I know exactly what you'll be asking yourselves, like, wasn't Lixin already on this season, on the podcast? And there is a short story and there's a long version of this short story that I can tell you. But the short story is that he left the previous company for which he was working, which is Cobo. And he's going to start his own hardware wallet project that's called Keystone.
2:19And there are some interesting differences and similarities between the two products. And honestly, this interview could not wait until next year when I was about to do another series of interviews about hardware wallets. So I think that the best time is now. And it's time to find out what this Keystone is, what it does. And hi, Lixin. Last time when we spoke, I introduced you as the CEO of Cobo, but now you're the CEO of Keystone.
2:49Lixin LiuYeah, yeah, yeah. Nice. Yeah. Thank you for having me, Vlad. And I'm also very proud to be your last guest for your season eight. Yeah. I just recognize that right now. So I'm super proud of that. And I hope the audience won't get bored as I'm featured in the same season for the second time. And also, I wanted to correct one thing. Previously, I was not the CEO of Cobo. I was the head of hardware of Cobo. And I was leading the hardware wallet product line of Cobo, which is Cobo Vault. And yes, currently, I'm the CEO of Keystone.
3:31And I'm running the new company with a new brand called Keystone. Yes. And I know there are a lot of questions from the community, so I'm very happy to be here. And thanks again for having me, Vlad.
3:46Vlad CosteaYeah, so this was actually kind of the joke, you know, because last time I called you the CEO and you spent some time explaining why you're not the CEO and why you're the head of the hardware department. And now it's funny because how long has it been, like two months since we spoke? In two months, you became the CEO of your own company, which is interesting. And I also want to ask you right now, why did you decide to start something on your own?
4:11Lixin LiuOkay. I think the story may be a little bit long. And the story goes back to late 2017. At that time, Cobo has two founders. And one of them is also one of the co-founders of F2Pool, which is currently one of the biggest mining pools currently in the world. He and another guy, Dr.
4:41Jiang, they started the company Cobo in China with a centralized wallet called Cobo Wallet. It's a centralized software wallet, meaning offer financial services for Bitcoiners. For example, if you... It's a centralized service, so they have your private key, and you can easily buy some kind of financial service there. For example, you can gain a, like, 5% or 6% annual gain for your Bitcoin if you register the wallet and put your Bitcoin into the wallet. And again, that's a centralized service. And they started Cobo with that product. And then they incubated me as the head of hardware to start the hardware wallet called Cobo Vault.
5:37And at that time, they made a decision because they think that Cobo's mission is offer a full solution for the whole community. Either you want to choose some centralized service or you want to choose decentralized service. And if you are okay to put your private key in other people's pocket, but you can gain some annual gain from your assets. So they want to offer a full solution for the community. And they're also expecting some kind of synergy between Cobo Wallet and Cobo Vault. So, yeah, and also Discus Fish, one of the co-founders of Cobo, he is very well connected in the miners community in China. So they wanted to offer a full solution for the users and expecting the synergy between these two product lines. And then we also developed the first generation of Cobo Vault, which is mainly targeting the miners, and I have explained this to you in your very first episode of your hardware series.
6:55But the first generation was not successful. So then in the middle of 2020, we launched the second generation of Cobo Vault, which is around 150 US dollars. And we are targeting countries like the United States and Europe, Australia, these kind of Western countries, where the people are more familiar with decentralized service and they don't want to share their private keys to anyone. And our second generation was very successful and grows very well. But then the problem comes to... then some issue came out. For example, Cobo's two founders, they are mainly focused on China market, Asia market, especially China market.
7:48They have very limited resources and the synergy they expected between Cobo Wallet and Cobo Vault didn't happen. So they decided to keep the hardware wallet into minimum maintenance and fully focus on the centralized service, which is Cobo Wallet. So I can fully understand that from a business perspective, because every company, startup, they have pivots on their strategies. Sometimes they focus on offering a full solution and sometimes they focus on offering a part of the full solution. It's understandable. But as they are going to keep minimum maintenance for the hardware wallet, they won't do any new device manufacturing, and also they were trying to move the whole Cobo Vault team to Cobo Wallet business.
8:57So that is unacceptable for me and also for the Cobo Vault team. And that's the main reason why we left Cobo and started a new company called Keystone. We just wanted to continuously offer the best hardware wallet for the Bitcoin community. And also, we didn't want to get into centralized services. Even they gave us very attracting offers, but money is not just what we want. Yeah.
9:35Vlad CosteaOkay, so to summarize, there was a difference of priorities where Cobo wanted to focus on their other projects and you wanted to further develop the Cobo Vault, the hardware wallet. And since you are not, you know, funded for this project, you decided to pursue this cause by yourself with a new company.
9:55Lixin LiuYes, exactly.
9:58Vlad CosteaBut at the same time, there are going to be a lot of similarities between the Cobo and the Keystone. Can you tell us what's going to be similar? Because the form factor, the design looks almost identical. You're going to have maybe the adjustment with the SD card and everything that you mentioned, I guess, in the previous episode as improvements that you wanted to bring to the Cobo. But what's going to be different? And is there anything changed from the plans that you had with Cobo?
10:28Lixin LiuFirst, you can see from the Keystone website, which is keyst.one, you can see that from form factor wise, it's almost the same. The thing is, first, personally, I bought out all the intellectual properties of Cobo Vault. So we're free to use the design and also use the code and everything else, especially also the pictures, the renderings, this kind of stuff. So we're free to use that. And based on that, we took almost all the legacy features from Cobo Vault. And also we implemented some improvements I have just mentioned in your previous episode.
11:20But at that time I cannot disclose the name of Keystone. I can only disclose what are the improvements we're working on. First is the micro SD card. Previously with Cobo Vault, we were kind of hiding the slot of the micro SD card behind the battery. That is based on our previous design, which is the micro SD card is mainly for upgrading the firmware, which will happen not very often. But the problem is more and more our users, they're using the micro SD card to transit large PSBT transactions.
12:03So the large PSBT transactions cannot be transited with the QR code because that will cause too many QR codes, which is hard to scan. So a lot of big Bitcoiners, they're using the micro SD card to transit unsigned or signed PSBT transactions. So then they were more often to use the micro SD card. So we moved the micro SD card slot to the outside of the device, which will make it much, much easier for users to plug in or unplug the micro SD card. This is the first change we made, or the first improvement we made.
12:49The second improvement is that we have received some, I think, maybe 1% of the users are complaining about the battery. So we changed part of the design of the circuit of the battery, so the battery won't be damaged by very unsteady current. I mean, for example, a sudden surge or something, the battery will remain functional under these kind of extreme situations. It's the second thing we do. The third thing we did is we improved the camera to improve the recognition speed of the camera.
13:41So I'll release a video later. With that video, Bitcoiners can see how fast the camera is recognizing those QR codes right now. So this will also improve the user experience. And another big change on the software side is that we're going to migrate the QR code standard to a more advanced protocol, which is BC-UR 2.0. Previously with Cobo Vault, we were using 1.0 version, and also with other software wallets like BlueWallet, Specter, and Sparrow. And right now we have upgraded to the latest version, and this version will be long-term maintained by Blockchain Commons and other Bitcoin developers.
14:37We hope that adopting this new standard will make the whole community, especially the QR code standard, more standardized. And yeah, this is the biggest software change we're doing. And also for new wallet integration, we're also talking to other new wallets. But before fully getting integrated, I think I cannot disclose too much information right now. But within the next two months, I hope we can at least integrate with another two Bitcoin wallets.
15:16Vlad CosteaOkay, you mentioned something interesting there about buying the rights from Cobo. Does this mean that they will no longer be able to sell Cobo Vaults, or will they sell them under your license?
15:29Lixin LiuThey won't produce them and they won't sell them.
15:36Vlad CosteaOkay, so Cobo no longer has their own line of hardware wallets.
15:41Lixin LiuIt's okay because, first, the Cobo Vault itself, especially the code, the code is open sourced. And it's under a very wide license which can be used for commercial purposes. So technically, Cobo can still upgrade the firmware of the Cobo Vault, but technically they cannot produce new devices with the same form factor, this kind of stuff.
16:20Vlad CosteaThat's a very important detail, as maybe that people have bought Cobos and maybe that there's not going to be any more support for them, or maybe that there will be. That's not for you to say right now. But I did realize when you posted that thread on Twitter in which you announced that you're transitioning from Cobo to Keystone that you're going to offer a discount for people who already own Cobos and bought them. And can you tell us more about that?
16:49Lixin LiuYeah, actually, our previous plan, or our ideal plan, was that we can offer a migration firmware for the Cobo Vault users. That migration firmware can make your firmware from Cobo Vault firmware to Keystone firmware. And then your old Cobo Vault device can recognize new Keystone firmwares and you can enjoy all the new software features we offer to you. So this was the original plan and also was the ideal plan we did. But the issue is that Cobo Vault cannot recognize a third-party firmware. Cobo Vault can only recognize a firmware which is signed by a specific key.
17:45And we don't have access to that key. Only Cobo team has that access. So, and they refused to sign that migration firmware for us. So with that being said, we cannot offer a migration firmware for the old Cobo Vault users. And that's why we offer the 50% discount for the old Cobo Vault users. If you can forward your order confirmation email to support@keyst.one, then we can share you a 50% off coupon code. So this is where the 50% discount comes from.
18:34Vlad CosteaVaultoro, and that's V-A-U-L-T like a gold vault and O-R-O, oro, which is Spanish for gold, is a gold and Bitcoin exchange, which offers instant swaps between hard money to over 31,000 customers from more than 95 countries. Vaultoro has offered Swiss privacy and security since 2015. Furthermore, the gold you purchase is your legal property, secured in your name, so even if something happens to Vaultoro, even liquidators could not touch your gold. If you want to become the custodian of your own gold bars, you can request to have them delivered to you or simply trade them back to Bitcoin on the dip.
19:25Ad voiceoverRegister for free in only 30 seconds and start trading only with hard money. Please keep in mind that all trading involves risks. This is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions. When you are using Wasabi Wallet, your internet connection gets routed through the Tor network by default. This means that you get better privacy while using Bitcoin. Download it today at wasabiwallet.io.
20:01Vlad CosteaRight, but let's say that I have already bought the Cobo Vault. And can I run the Keystone firmware on it?
20:10Lixin LiuNo, because Keystone, as I said, if Cobo Vault wants to run Keystone firmware, first you have to install a migration firmware from Cobo Vault to Keystone. And that migration firmware didn't do too much change. It only changes the public key that was embedded in the system. The public key was the pair of keys of the private key to sign the firmware. Do you understand? So the Cobo's firmware has a pair of private key and public key. The private key was kept by Cobo team. Usually, previously when we release a Cobo firmware, we need to sign that firmware with a private key.
21:03And the private key, the public key embedded in the Cobo Vault system was the pair of that private key. So it only recognizes a firmware that is signed by a specific private key. So if we offer a firmware, we just change that public key into Keystone firmware's public key so that the Cobo Vault can recognize Keystone firmware and run Keystone firmware. But right now, as we cannot offer that migration firmware, so Cobo Vault cannot use Keystone firmware. Is that clear? Maybe I should re-explain it if it's needed.
21:46Vlad CosteaNo, it's fine. I've only asked this question for people who might have bought a Cobo and they're gonna see that the Keystone looks very similar and most likely has very similar hardware inside of it. So they're gonna ask the question, so why do I need to buy a new one as opposed to installing the new firmware on this?
22:05Lixin LiuActually, we want to offer this opportunity for all the Cobo Vault users to use the Keystone firmware. Cobo team doesn't allow this because... which is kind of ridiculous. Their mindset is that the users are Cobo's assets. So they can sell the rights to me, they can sell the intellectual properties to me, but they cannot quote-unquote "sell" users to me. So users are still their assets. And they also, I heard that they have plans to migrate those users from Cobo Vault to Cobo Wallet, especially in China. So this is their plan. So and then they don't allow me to do the migration firmware.
23:03Vlad CosteaOkay, I guess that's reasonable. But something else that I want to ask you about concerns the fact that the Cobo had support for lots of shitcoins. And is the new Keystone going to be Bitcoin only or are you also going to support other projects?
23:21Lixin LiuThe thing is, we are going to remove some shitcoins on Cobo Vault right now, but we cannot remove all of them. And also another change: for Keystone, we will still offer Bitcoin-only firmware. And another thing I can share is that right now we are exploring the opportunity to develop a Bitcoin-only device, and maybe with our next generation, we will not only offer Bitcoin-only firmware, but also Bitcoin-only device.
24:08Vlad CosteaThat sounds interesting. So what's the difference really? It's going to have some specific hardware parts which only work with Bitcoin?
24:18Lixin LiuYou mean for the next generation? Yes. Yeah, for the next generation, the ultimate target for the next generation is we're going to make it more open. So right now we have open source secure element firmware, but the community is still criticizing us that our Android layer is closed source. So the next generation, the biggest change is that we're going to remove that limitation. And we have two directions we can go. The first direction is the direction of Specter DIY.
25:05So Specter DIY software is totally open source, and they also support QR code scanning. The other direction for us is the direction for... Oh, by the way, Specter DIY doesn't leverage the Android system or anything like that. The second direction for us to go is to leverage the GrapheneOS, which is an operating system which is fully open source. And also with GrapheneOS, we can leverage our previous Java code. And this is also another direction we are exploring. Yeah, and this is the biggest change. But right now we are in the early stage for doing the research. I think hopefully at the end of next year or early 2023, we can release these next-generation devices.
26:04Vlad CosteaYeah, that's definitely useful. And I see that there's a lot happening in this open source hardware wallet space. You have the Specter DIY, you have the SeedSigner, you have the Bowser wallet, and all of them have their trade-offs. So none of them is perfect at this point. And I think the biggest problem with them is that you need a proper case. And to build that kind of case, you need to 3D print it or else order it from some sort of vendor, which does it for you.
26:36I think that's the main impediment right now, which stands in your way to create your own hardware wallet. I think right now I like the Bowser because it relies on the M5Stack, which you buy from AliExpress, for example. And it's like $20, you get it, you install it. It looks nice, it has that video game that you can play, so you can pretend that it's not a hardware wallet. But at the same time, it has a larger attack surface because it has Bluetooth, it has Wi-Fi, it has all of these features that can be exploited from a security point of view, so that's the big trade-off. With Specter and with SeedSigner, you need that specific kind of case to be able to use it, and that kind of sucks. I think with Specter it's better, but with the SeedSigner you need to have three buttons, which... I don't know, I haven't found any general purpose case on the market which has that.
27:34I had to order a custom one.
27:36Lixin LiuYeah, actually, I think this is lying behind the logic that there's no perfection in security, especially if we put user experience into consideration. There's always, I think, from my perspective, every hardware wallet are legit. And every hardware wallet founders, they are trying to find a balance between security and the user experience. For example, if you make something extremely security, that would be really hard to use. For us, we really emphasize on the user experience side as well as the security side. So this is one of the most important design philosophies of Cobo Wallet, which is also right now one of the most important design philosophies for Keystone.
28:37Vlad CosteaI also regard this hardware wallet market as one of the few examples that you have of a truly open market where you have contributions from all over the place and the evolution and the advancements are made at such a rapid pace that is very hard to keep up. And there's always someone on the other side of the world who comes up with this new idea, which works very well and everyone else adapts to it. So it's a very dynamic space. I think at some point Slush told me last year that it's kind of pointless to try to keep up with hardware and software is more important.
29:15At least that's the Trezor philosophy, because if you ask Ledger, they're going to be like, "No, it's all about the hardware."
29:21Lixin LiuMm-hmm. So actually, I kind of agree with him, but I have another... From my perspective, not only the software of the hardware, but also the software wallet itself. This is because I think the Bitcoin, especially with Taproot and other technologies, the Bitcoin is developing very fast. And to catch up those trends, or for example, Lightning, so to catch up those trends for hardware wallet, and also I think coin mixing, like Wasabi Wallet, coin mixing, this kind of Bitcoin features, they are developing very fast.
30:09For us, from my perspective, the role of the hardware wallet is you are just a signer. So as a hardware wallet, you should be as compatible as possible with other software wallets to fulfill different kinds of needs of the Bitcoiners. For example, if they want to do coin mixing, if they wanted to receive bitcoins as a merchant using BTCPay Server. So as a hardware wallet, we just make the product as compatible as possible. So this is also one of the most important design philosophies of Keystone.
30:55Vlad CosteaYeah, and also about the Keystone. Is there going to be any significant difference in pricing as opposed to the Cobo?
31:03Lixin LiuOh, no difference. The pricing, everything, especially the pricing is the same.
31:10Vlad CosteaOkay, that's good to know. And also if you bought a Cobo, you're gonna get a discount code for a Keystone.
31:16Lixin LiuYes, yes. And also, right now we're trying to, because our sales grows, so we have more negotiation power with the logistics vendors. So at the same time, we're also trying to minimize the shipping cost for some countries and also we're trying to open some new countries like Dubai, another country, UAE, these kind of countries, and also we're trying to minimize the shipping cost for them.
31:54Vlad CosteaYeah, that's definitely a market that should be explored, as there's a lot of potential there, but I'm sure that some vendors do not have access to that segment of the market. I think it's also part of the reason why there are so many Trezor clones around the world, as it was the first one to be truly open source. And when the original vendor cannot get there's going to be a workaround. And about the Trezor, I think it's really wonderful that it was the first to become open source, but at the same time, it's very difficult to build because you need some sort of DIY experience with soldering and all of that.
32:36So even though you build it from general purpose parts, you need to really know what you're doing and have some...
32:44Lixin LiuYeah. And I think the Specter DIY is doing very well on that problem.
32:53Vlad CosteaOh, it's a game changer because you buy something general purpose, you put it in a case, and you have your multisig device for signing transactions. It's the same with the SeedSigner. I think SeedSigner is even better because it uses the Raspberry Pi Zero, which is easier to find.
33:09Lixin LiuYes, yes. And also to echo the previous topic that you said, a lot of countries, because you cannot ship in there, so there are a lot of Trezor folks. Here another thing I want to mention is that for hardware wallet, localization is really important. Not every Bitcoiner can speak English or they can use a product with English version. And also, especially some newcomers, they need very heavy customer service, especially localized customer service for their product. One example I can share is that currently we're selling in Russia very well.
33:58Because the reseller there was doing perfectly on localization. They not only post localized YouTube videos, tutorial videos, and they have at least six, I think, six or seven guys for localized customer service. And also they are trying to, we are planning to work together to add Russian into the Keystone device. And also within this year, I mean, within this year, another important improvement we're going to do is localization. We will at least add Spanish and also Russian into Keystone.
34:45Vlad CosteaYeah, so I think it's important to tap in as many markets as possible. And the fact that you were able to get into Russia, I think is a major plus, especially since I think it's kind of a gray market when it comes to everything Bitcoin when you go to Russia. It's never clear if it's legal or what kind of status it has. They claim to be regulating and legislating on Bitcoin all the time. But I suppose there is a lot going on, just like there is with VPNs and Tor.
35:20Lixin LiuMm-hmm. Yes, that's true.
35:23Vlad CosteaSo being able to sell Keystone hardware wallets in stores, I think it's major and only helps with adoption. And at the end of the day, I think this is a net benefit for the entire community to have access to these devices. And how do you, I know that the answer is kind of obvious, and I've obviously unboxed the Cobo, but how are you going to mitigate against supply chain attacks, because I suppose that's usually the biggest of concerns?
35:56Lixin LiuYes, I can see the logic of this question because you just mentioned to sell the products in the stores, right? Yeah, actually, I think to echo your previous question, I think selling hardware in the stores, another benefit for the community is that you can buy the hardware wallet with cash, rather than credit card or leaving your shipping address to the vendor or something. So I definitely think that selling hardware wallet in stores, in offline stores, is a big trend that will happen in the next few years. And your last question was about the supply chain attack. So for Keystone, it will implement all the features against supply chain attack as other vendors.
36:51For example, we will have anti-tampering sticker. And one thing we will have extra is that we will still have the web authentication process. And we will also release an article to explain the web authentication process. To put it short, the logic is that every device has a private key and a public key. The public key's key pair of the private key is in the Amazon Cloud HSM, which is, I think, the safest cloud HSM we can access as a daily user. So we put another pair of private key and the public key there.
37:47So every device of Keystone, when you receive it, you can go to our website and our website can communicate with the backend AWS Cloud HSM service. And we can do a product authentication to make sure that your device, your Keystone device, is running the official Keystone firmware. So this is an extra layer we added to the Keystone to prevent supply chain attack.
38:20And we also implemented the scheme of self-destruct mechanism, just as Cobo Vault. So if on the delivery, in the delivery process, if the device is intercepted by a hacker and the hacker wants to open the device and do some, maybe, to do some malicious code or some malicious stuff to the device, the device will destroy the firmware on the device. And when you receive the device, you will see a strong warning and this device is no longer functional. So anti-tamper sticker and also web authentication and also self-destruct mechanism, we use all these schemes to prevent supply chain attack.
39:18Vlad CosteaYeah, I've heard when I interviewed Slush a very interesting approach that obviously works for Trezor, but would not work for something like the Cobo because it's supposed to be cold storage. But he said that right now he delivers Trezors without any kind of firmware installed. So that's also a very easy way to discover if the device has been plugged before, because it has nothing on it in terms of firmware. And it gets installed when you connect it for the first time.
39:51Lixin LiuMm-hmm. Yeah, that's one thing we can do. Yes. But one potential attack surface here for Trezor is that Trezor can accept third-party firmware. So it's possible that the hacker can approach some user and trick the user into installing the hacker's firmware, which is a third-party firmware. I think this is kind of a possible attack surface for Trezor, but it's not very technical attack surface. It's mostly about social engineering. And because of this possibility, both Keystone and Cobo Vault, we didn't allow third-party firmware installation.
40:46Vlad CosteaYeah, I noticed there is that entire verification process where you have to scan a QR code and...
40:54Lixin LiuYes, yes.
40:55Vlad Costea...everything involved in between.
40:58Lixin LiuYes.
40:59Vlad CosteaSo you're saying that with the next generation, the Keystone is going to be a lot more open source to the point that it might just be 100%, right?
41:10Lixin LiuI think it's impossible. It's definitely impossible to make a 100% open source hardware because you have to purchase some kind of ICs from other companies. And they are very, very like base code on that IC. And it's impossible to open source that part.
41:34Vlad CosteaJust for the record, IC is integrated circuit, right?
41:43Lixin LiuI think it's an integrated circuit and also it's integrated components. It's just some of the chips, some small chips. For example, there's a main chip on the device itself. There are also several small chips for the screen and also for the camera or something. So these chips also have embedded code on them. And for those embedded code, even us, even Trezor, even Ledger, it's impossible for us to open source everything. Do you see my point? But we can open source the firmware. The next generation, if we use GrapheneOS, we can open source the operating system layer.
42:31If we take the Specter DIY route, we can open source all the firmware. But it doesn't mean that we can open source every piece of embedded code on this device. It's almost impossible, unless the hardware wallet vendor makes all those components, all those chips by themselves, which is impossible at this time, at this point. I think if every year the hardware wallet can be sold for like 100 million devices every year, then the hardware wallet vendor would be powerful or they will have enough resources to make all those chips by themselves and open source all the embedded code on those chips too.
43:20Then that's possible. But right now, with the current market situation, hardware wallet is still a niche market and it's impossible. Even for Ledger, they have raised tons of money. Even for them, it's impossible for them to make every component by themselves and open source all the embedded code. It's impossible.
43:42Vlad CosteaI understand what you're saying. I mean, I guess my claim about 100% was unreasonable.
43:50Lixin LiuYeah.
43:51Vlad CosteaBut what I meant was actually more on the software side as opposed to the hardware.
43:57Lixin LiuYeah, with our next generation, we'll definitely do that. Reasonable 100% open source.
44:04Vlad CosteaThat's really good. So when should we expect to see the first Keystone hardware wallets?
44:10Lixin LiuYou mean the current generation or the next generation?
44:13Vlad CosteaBoth.
44:14Lixin LiuFor the current generation, I think the earliest time is by the end of this month. If you purchase it right now, at the end of this month, you can receive it. For the current generation and for the next generation, right now we are expecting the end of 2022 or early 2023.
44:40Vlad CosteaSo that's gonna take some time.
44:42Lixin LiuYes, yes, hardware is not easy to make. Usually it takes, for us, we're in China and we have all the resources here for making hardware. But even for us, it takes us at least six months to develop a new hardware. And if we're going to make it more open sourced or 100% open sourced, it usually takes one year or even more to do that.
45:13Vlad CosteaSo let's say that a newbie, someone who hasn't used a hardware wallet before, is listening to this interview and wants to buy a Keystone. And that's going to be their first exposure to any signing device. How would you recommend them to use the Cobo? Because obviously it's a cold storage device. So you're going to have to connect it to some sort of software wallet, which can be Sparrow, can be BlueWallet. But what do you think is the easiest onboarding experience?
45:45Lixin LiuGood question. I think the easiest onboarding process is using Keystone, not Cobo, the Keystone, using Keystone with BlueWallet. And right now we're working on the integration with BlueWallet. Hopefully we can finish this within next week, I think. So I think the easiest onboarding process is using it with BlueWallet. If you are comfortable with the whole process, and also if you have a significant amount of Bitcoin, another two things you can try. The first thing is you can use the Shamir secret sharing for the recovery phrase.
46:36And the Keystone also supports that, just like Trezor, the same standard, which is SLIP-39. You can use that. You can use Shamir secret sharing to set up your recovery phrase, which will add more robustness to your recovery phrase, and you can put the different pieces in different places geographically. And the next step, you can try multi-signature. And as far as I know, right now, BlueWallet and Specter and Sparrow, they are all very supportive for multi-signature and Keystone will be compatible with three of them.
47:23And then the next step, I think you can, maybe you can try out Wasabi Wallet to add more privacy to your Bitcoin transactions. Oh, I forgot one thing. And also you can try to run your full node by yourself. So this is mainly the whole process to being the first class citizen. First step, again, the first step is single signature with BlueWallet. And then you can try out Shamir secret sharing for your recovery phrase. And then multi-signature and also full node. And then also you can try out Wasabi or Samourai Wallet for Bitcoin transaction privacy.
48:14Vlad CosteaYeah, that's reasonable. And that's also useful because I know that there will be people who have no idea how to use hardware wallets and they listen to this entire season trying to find a solution that suits their needs. So my last question for you is...
48:30Lixin LiuYeah, but one thing I want to emphasize again is that don't make your solution over complicated. I also see some examples of people that they do so many layers of encryption on their recovery phrase. And then they forgot how they encrypted their recovery phrase. And then they cannot get their recovery phrase and they lost everything. So this is a real case that happened with my friend. I want to share one ultimate suggestion is that don't make your solution over complicated. And as the old saying goes, "Practice makes perfect."
49:19So if you wanted to adopt a new solution, even if it's very easy, for example, using Keystone with BlueWallet, even if it's very easy, you should practice, practice, and get practiced. And when you adopt new solutions, no matter how easy it is, just be careful with it, just get practiced. And one thing I really like about Casa is that Casa is promoting the idea called health check. Casa is asking their users to do health check. I think it's every month or every other week to do the health check for his signers.
50:03It's not only checking the signer is working properly. It's also checking that you are still familiar with your multi-signature or with your other solutions. This is very important. Don't get it over complicated, and check or get practiced from time to time. This is also very important.
50:28Vlad CosteaYeah, usually when I speak with Bitcoiners, they're like, yeah, so they set up a multisig, they hide their backup somewhere and they expect to dig it up five years or ten years from now and never look at it again. But I think it's healthy about once a year or something to try to do the recovery so you remember how it's done.
50:52Lixin LiuYes, yes, yes.
50:54Vlad CosteaAlso to identify if the device that you have used is faulty and you need to replace it. And there are lots of extra layers involved.
51:02Lixin LiuYes, exactly. You should try to practice your recovery.
51:06Yeah. And also when you choose your solution, you'd better choose a solution that is also compatible with other wallet. For example, for Shamir secret sharing, I know there are some other solutions to do Shamir secret sharing, but the Shamir secret sharing Keystone implemented is exactly the same as the scheme on Trezor. Which means you should consider that one day if Keystone no longer exists, which will almost impossible to happen, but there is some possibility that one day Keystone doesn't exist, then your different pieces of Shamir secret sharing pieces should be recovered on other devices, which can be Trezor. So you need to think more, even some very edge cases, very edge cases. You need to think about that and try to find the solutions even for those edge solutions. So this is my suggestion. Yeah.
52:18Vlad CosteaRight. So Lixin, I think I don't have any more questions for you at this time because I've asked most of them during our previous interview, which was about two months ago. I wish you best of luck with your new Keystone venture. And it's really exciting. I suppose that being on your own and finally being able to implement everything that you've wanted for Cobo has a lot of rewards. But at the same time, I suppose you're also working a lot harder.
52:50Lixin LiuYes, that's true. Yeah. Last time I remember, we had the conversation at like 4 p.m. my time. Right now, I'm having it at 8 p.m. I'm working extra, extra hours to realize my own dream for Keystone right now.
53:08Vlad CosteaYeah, and I look forward to trying the Keystone and comparing it to the Cobo.
53:12Lixin LiuYep.
53:13Vlad CosteaSo I'm gonna do a video on that one.
53:17Lixin LiuOkay, thank you so much. Hope that doesn't take too much time.
53:21Vlad CosteaI don't think so, unless it's a hard process.
53:25Lixin LiuOkay.
53:26Vlad CosteaOkay, so thank you very much, Lixin. And I look forward to speaking with you whenever you have some news about your Keystone adventure.
53:37Lixin LiuYeah. Thank you so much. Thank you for your time. And thank you for having me.
53:43Ad voiceoverHey, what's your plan for the next Bitcoin top? Unless you need the money to purchase something, you probably should not touch infinitely inflationary fiat. Check out Vaultoro and figure out to which extent hard money like gold and silver can help you preserve your purchasing power. You will be able to get back into Bitcoin as soon as the price hits a new bottom and you will not be subjected to the arbitrary, inflation-driven volatility of fiat or fiat-backed coins. Obviously, this is not financial advice and you should understand that all trading involves risks.
54:30Wasabi Wallet connects to your full Bitcoin node, and if you're not running one, it downloads block filters anonymously via Tor. In either case, you're getting excellent privacy. Download the software today at wasabiwallet.io.
54:30================================================================================ Production notes: Remote recorded interview in English (guest non-native speaker, in China, recorded at 8 pm his time), with a music intro, ad voiceovers and Vlad live reads for Vaultoro and Wasabi Wallet at start, mid-roll and end. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 3 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (74 chunks) and 34 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed music notes, "© BF-WATCH TV 2021", stray "Thank you." and hallucinated "LixinLiu.com"; intro ads relabelled Ad voiceover; removed misplaced "Lixon, how are you doing?"; restored dropped words from second ASR (Dr. Jiang lead-in, "last time when we spoke", "get bored...", Cobo Vault first gen, "very happy to be here", "even they gave us"); fixed Cobo/Cobo Vault, Vaultoro, Vlad, F2Pool, Discus Fish, BC-UR 2.0, BlueWallet, Specter, Sparrow, legacy features, keyst.one; Ad voiceover label for Wasabi read, removed "Episode:" hallucination and "Thank you."; Cobo/Cobo Vault, Specter DIY, GrapheneOS, M5Stack, BTCPay Server, Lightning, Russian, next-generation, localized customer service, Trezor folks fixed; restored "migration firmware... to Keystone", "specific private key" from second ASR; moved Bowser/SeedSigner passage at 00:27:00 back to Vlad, split Lixin at "Yeah, actually"; moved "Yes, yes" to Lixin; dropped stray Yes/Yeah interjections; "Mm-hmm" at 00:35:20 to Lixin; Removed hallucinations ("Bye.", "Thank you for watching..." x2, "----", "This is a video about the Bitcoin takeover process", trailing "Bye"); fixed Cobo/Cobo Vault, Trezor, SLIP-39, Shamir secret sharing, Specter DIY route, Sparrow, BlueWallet, GrapheneOS, Casa, Samourai, Vaultoro, Lixin, anti-tamper, "Good question", "Keystone adventure"; restored dropped words from second ASR (full node, suits their needs, Vaultoro/Wasabi ad text); split interjections and Vlad's IC question; relabelled closing ads as Ad voiceover.