S8 E8: Slush on Trezor and Tropic Square
Search this conversation
0:29Ad voiceoverThis episode is sponsored by Vaultoro. Keep on listening and you will find out more about how you can buy allocated gold when the Bitcoin bull run reaches its peak. This way you don't have to deal with infinitely inflationary fiat or banks that freeze your account. Also, note that trading involves risks and the information presented is not financial advice. This episode is also sponsored by Wasabi Wallet. Go to wasabiwallet.io, download Wasabi for your OS and significantly boost your network level and transaction privacy.
1:39Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad and this is Season 8, Episode 8 with Slush. And it's actually funny because the last time we recorded it was Season 4, Episode 8. So there's something about 8 that really attracts Slush or it's just a coincidence. But anyhow, he is everyone's favorite non-toxic Bitcoin maximalist. He is known as the guy who invented mining pools and was also acknowledged by Satoshi in 2010, I think, in a BitcoinTalk forum thread. And also he's the co-inventor of the world's first Bitcoin hardware wallet, the Trezor.
2:20Right now he's the CEO of SatoshiLabs. I don't think he's involved with Slush Pool anymore. But anyhow, he is Slush and it's good to have him here. Hi, Slush.
2:32Marek "Slush" PalatinusHello, Vlad. Thank you for the introduction and for inviting me.
2:36Vlad CosteaIt's always a pleasure. So we last spoke in February 2020. So that was one year and two months ago, almost. And since then, SatoshiLabs has been very busy at work. Like I have noticed some improvements that you have made to the product. And even though you have made some improvements like Trezor Suite and stuff like that, the products themselves, the hardware has remained the same. You have also launched Tropic Square, and you're not the CEO of that. I'm not sure what your involvement with that one is.
3:12I guess you can clarify. But I think that's also the most exciting event that's going on in terms of hardware right now in Bitcoin. So how did you come up with this idea of Tropic Square?
3:27Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, I think it's quite a long story. I think it begins with the Trezor itself, like eight years ago. And we are simply software engineers, and we have been pushed into the hardware because we realized that if we want to secure Bitcoins, we need some hardware for running our code on top of it. And of course, we are open source software engineers because open source is here like for 20 or 30 years already, and it clearly demonstrated its strength in a community-driven or even in a security software.
4:15When we have been building Trezor, we had basically two choices: use open source software and build on top of it and be as much open and auditable, or go with some features of the hardware industry, which is like being more secure by obscurity and sign some NDAs and use some hardware which is designed for securing some information, but it's not designed for open source, and we couldn't be that auditable as we would like when we were designing the Trezor. So this was a choice which we need to decide years ago.
5:12And I need to clarify that open source is not such a thing, like it's not kind of fetish or something, but open source is a movement which radically improved the software world in the last 20 or 30 years, and now it's quite clear that it's a way to go, because even the huge companies like Microsoft, which were developing everything in closed and so, are slowly changing their narrative and they understand that the open source has its benefits. And also, I think the security industry in recent years is more about open standards and more about the auditability stuff and so on.
6:02So, well, our mission was to use what we know about the software development and implement it in hardware, hardware device in hardware world. And so again, open source itself is not a goal. It's a tool how to achieve the security. And here now, I want to say that it's kind of interesting spin-off when I heard in some Ledger part of your podcast, it somehow put this in opposition, like you can be secure or you can be open source. And I don't agree with this.
6:46I think the security or the open source is a way to achieve the security, and it's only the, like, the philosophical perspective, if you think that it's possible or not. And it's basically the Trezor versus Ledger is a story of two philosophies, of two different philosophies, and I would say even two different worlds, which are showing which is better or worse. So when we went with the no NDAs path, we built the Trezor and I think it was kind of success because we started a completely new industry by the Trezor.
7:31But we were continuously looking for some improvements for the product and we definitely hear our customers who want some better physical security, and we are aware that Trezor and in general all the hardware is kind of insecure. All the hardware is insecure for different reasons. But if you focus on physical security, this is an unsolved challenge on the market still.
8:04So we were looking for some solutions how we can improve the physical resilience of the Trezor, and we concluded that there's simply no hardware which we can really use, no hardware on the market which we really can use into the Trezor, which fits into the philosophy, and because we are not going to make some game like adding some security by obscurity mechanism into the Trezor and tell our customers, "Okay, it's super secure because it's certified secure element." But we have some specific reasons why we didn't use some existing chips.
8:55So we concluded that we need to do something what's not here yet, and simply use our strategy which we use so far for software development around the Trezor even for the hardware part, and that we simply need to develop our chip, because the current hardware industry is like not there yet. It's not like software nowadays. It's lagging many years behind the software development.
9:31Vlad CosteaYeah, so I have had in one of the previous episodes a guest whose name is Lazy Ninja and he hacks hardware wallets and he's best known for finding some issues with the Coldcard and the BitBox02. And he said to me that Tropic Square to him is the most ambitious project around. And he finds it interesting that such a small company like SatoshiLabs can pursue such an ambitious goal, because open source security chips are actually something that can go beyond hardware wallets and serve entire industries that need security chips that are auditable.
10:10And the two questions that I have in regards to this are: what were the biggest challenges that you encountered when you started the Tropic Square venture? And what is the current stage of development?
10:23Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah. I agree with him that it's very ambitious, but on the other hand, we are used to doing things where nobody succeeded yet. I think it's the same. It was like in the pool, it was in the Trezor, and I think this is like a continuous story of what we are doing so far. So I think it's ambitious, but I wouldn't start it if I wouldn't see some option or some possibility that it will succeed, of course. And I must say that it took us three years to even start the project from the initial idea, because we were still missing something.
11:10We were missing some funding or we were missing some specialists, some connections to people who are able to push the project forward. So last year it all settled down and I think that what's changed is that I believe that we have all things ready. We are fully funded. We have partners and we have some experts who are willing to work on the mission. And yeah, so we have a team, we have a product, and we have money.
11:47What I think what's different from the other manufacturers or from other companies who are in the secure element industry is that we have somehow aligned motivations or incentives. And I think I was talking about this in a recent podcast last year, that this is the huge problem of the secure element industry, because they build on the obscurity, they build on something which know only them. And I don't think it's a good... And the motivation for us is not to make, like, not the primary motivation is not to build the business on top of the secure element itself, but we are here for solve some problem which we have ourselves.
12:42So I believe that we have a better motivation and incentive for this getting right. And I hope that we will succeed somehow.
12:52Vlad CosteaSo what's the stage of development?
12:55Marek "Slush" PalatinusAbout the timing, we are definitely going with some minimal viable product first. And I expect the first chip won't be fully open source itself. But our goal is to have an open source digital circuit which touch the user data secrets. So there will be still some closed parts, but I believe that those parts won't be relevant from the perspective of some backdoors and so on. So we are talking more about some memory where the data will be only encrypted. We are talking about some laser sensors and all the other intrusion sensors and so on.
13:43But our goal is to make by the end of this year the chip, the testing chip in our hands, which doesn't mean that it will be like a chip for big production, but I think we will have something this year, and eventually we would like to see first Trezor prototypes with Tropic Square next year. Yeah.
14:08Vlad CosteaOh, that sounds exciting.
14:11Marek "Slush" PalatinusSo far, we have teams, we have partners like foundries and so on. Everybody knows what we are going to do, so I don't expect some problems on this. But yeah, there's still so many things which we need to finish. Like everybody who does something knows that the execution is only the 80% of the project.
14:39Vlad CosteaRight, and during this season I've asked almost everyone who was on the podcast about the Tropic Square project. And what I remember is that there was Lawrence Nahum from Blockstream, and Blockstream has recently launched the Jade. And there was also Zach Herbert from Foundation Devices, which also launched a new hardware wallet that's called the Passport. And they said that it's very difficult for hardware to be verified. And if software can be verified remotely and anyone can look at the code, you need like a microscope and lots of tools that help you verify that a certain piece of hardware is according to the specifications.
15:24And, you know, they said that there can be some sort of attacks and compromises that start from the factory, even if you have the best of intentions from the office of your company. So will there be any way for the users to verify the open sourceness of the chips?
15:43Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, of course, these concerns are valid, and I think they apply for all hardware in general. Every time when you have something physical in your hands, you have this problem that it's really hard to verify what is in your hand. But in general, current chips are making this hard for users to verify, because even if you scan with microscopes and so on, even if you do some tests, you really don't know what you are looking for. And this reverse engineering is really expensive and you need a lot of skills to do this properly. And that's why it's hard to find some bugs and find some problems with the chip design, even on the physical or even on the logical layer of the design.
16:41And what we are looking for is to provide these materials, like the source code of the chip, of the digital circuit, and even the scans from X-rays, all this publicly, so you can see that the open source design which will be on GitHub really compiles into the design which we then publish, what's like the digital circuit. And with some tools, of course, you should be able to scan the chip to see that the chip is really the same rendering as we have on GitHub.
17:26So of course, it's not about the verification, like user verification, you still need to be an expert for this, but we are going to make it easy for you to verify that if you broke the chip, if you open it, that the chip was really the same as we published on GitHub.
17:48Vlad CosteaI very much look forward to that, to see how it works and how you can verify from a GitHub repository as an end user. Let me get back to the Trezor for the moment. Actually, that's kind of the main topic of this conversation. And recently, we have seen this event in the development of the Coldcard wallet, where they changed the code base, which they forked from Trezor, to put something else, and this also allowed them to change the licenses so that you can no longer build your own Coldcard and sell it. And I know that there was a very similar event in the history of the Trezor with the KeepKey, which was essentially a clone which looked nicer.
18:32And did you ever think about changing the licenses or doing something to prevent others from copying and selling your product?
18:42Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, we have been there and done that. So I absolutely understand what Coldcard did. We even changed the license of the Trezor, but then when the emotions settled down, we realized that this is not what we are going to do and what we don't believe in doing in the future. So we reverted the license back. And it was, I think if I remember well, it was because of the KeepKey, because it was like first commercial clone, if I remember well. But something similar happened even with Coldcard, and there was a lot of discussion about this because they basically forked some libraries and they renamed them so it didn't appear that they are from Trezor.
19:34So I understand all these emotions, and I think it's really necessary to give credits where the credits are. So if you use some work of others, in open source, it's fair to say, okay, we reuse the work of some other team. And even if it's competition, it's okay. But yeah, it's kind of hard, like emotionally, but I don't believe it's way how we should, what we should do in the future. So I'm pretty sure that the Trezor firmware will still have the same license.
20:20And the way we are going is to innovate repeatedly to improve the product. So even that we have like 40 clones of Trezor in the wild, some of these clones are publicly known, like KeepKey, and I don't know what else, some of them are like local hardware wallet sold in Iran or something like this. And we just decided to don't solve this and keep our path of improving and making some standards and moving the industry forward.
21:01Vlad CosteaOh yes, and you have mentioned standards, and something for which Trezor is best known is the backup involving the BIP39 standard. That was an innovation that was made by SatoshiLabs and every other hardware wallet uses it. And your response to the issue of physical security is to use the passphrase. And you promote the passphrase from the first moment when somebody installs a new Trezor hardware wallet, be it the Trezor One or the Trezor Model T. I have noticed that there is this constant notification to activate your passphrase and make sure that you write it down.
21:41And to verify your seed words, and you also have like a simulation for a recovery within the interface. But at the same time, I have seen different approaches from hardware wallet manufacturers, and there's Shift Crypto, which uses their BitBox02 in a way which they call the quick setup. So the information, instead of appearing on the screen so you can write down your words, you can do the quick setup and all the information gets stored on your SD card. So you can also write down the words later, but they call this mnemonic anxiety for new users who are afraid of writing down the words because they can lose the funds.
22:21So they just do the backup on an SD card. And what else? Charles Guillaume of Ledger told me that passphrases are not really necessary, and he discourages people from using them when they use the Ledger because they get lots of emails from people who say that they forgot their passphrase. So, yeah. Do you still believe it's a good idea to write down your words and use the passphrase? Is it hard, difficult from a user perspective?
22:52Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah. I understand that passphrases goes against the usability itself. I'm completely aware of this, but I don't see any way how to avoid passphrases in really strong setups. I mean, it's clearly irresponsible to tell people that they should trust the hardware itself and don't use passphrase, because really nobody knows what's inside the hardware. And I'm pretty clear that we in Trezor don't use secure elements, so we can at least say, okay, there's no hardware protection for getting the seed out of the hardware, like physical security. We're out of scope for a pretty long time, and I think that...
23:45Passphrase solves this, but passphrase solves also other attack vectors. Like, hardware wallets are racing in the way who uses the best storage in a hardware wallet. They completely forget, or they... I don't think they forget, but they don't tell the users that the weakest point is the recovery seed itself. So I can have 100% secure hardware storage, but when I backup the recovery seed into the paper, and somebody finds the paper, I'm doomed. So even if there will be Trezor with super secure hardware solution like Tropic or even something different, I don't care at this point, we will still promote...
24:38Promote the passphrase because we see that it's an additional layer which is really useful for a wide range of some other attacks. And having a secure element is not a holy grail. It's also about plausible deniability. It's about securing the recovery seeds and so on. So it's a quite complex topic. And I don't think that reducing the usage of passphrase only for securing the storage, like securing the recovery seed in the hardware wallet, is a fair discussion.
25:14About the microSD. I completely understand why Shift Crypto hates recovery seeds, or their users hate recovery seeds, because of course it's some hassle in the onboarding process. But on the other hand, what I learned is that if you make it too easy for users to do everything so seamlessly, then the users have no choice, no chance to realize that they are doing something really important.
25:54And I think that teaching the user that it's really important to have this recovery seed and don't tell it to anybody, don't write it back to the computer or something like this, is a really important part of the whole story of securing their funds. And I think that the SD cards may sound easy at first sight, and people may prefer it as a UX improvement, but I think it will skip some important thing. And I think there's many reasons why we don't want to use this SD card for backing up recovery seed, even if Model T has a microSD card...
26:49MicroSD slot. And the reasons are basically three. The first is that microSD cards are really poor long-term storage. My friend, he is a photographer and he has a box full of some microSD cards and, I don't know, CF cards and everything, which worked until they didn't. And the problem is that you have no way how to check if your backup is alive until you put it into some computer or some hardware wallet to actually read the data. And this is what I see also as a problem.
27:34You can easily put this microSD card into general computer and you are doomed just by doing this. So it's non-trivial to see all these potential issues. And I think that it could be dangerous for the users. They can even have this SD card with a backup and they didn't notice for years that the backup is not really working. And this is an advantage of the paper backup. You can do it. It's not that hard. Writing down 12 words is not that hard.
28:17And you can easily offline check that the words are still here, readable, and everything is okay. And so I think that paper backups and all these variants, like Coldcard, not Coldcards, Cryptosteel and so on, I think this is still a king.
28:37Vlad CosteaYeah, but at the same time, wasn't Ledger, I'm getting back to your first response and we're gonna go back and forth, wasn't Ledger the company that basically said that you can buy their devices on eBay pre-owned and they're safe to use if they're wiped?
28:55Marek "Slush" PalatinusWell, I think they maybe claimed this. I don't remember, but I wouldn't do this personally.
29:03Vlad CosteaYeah, I mean, you never know what goes on in that tiny device. And I think a turning point in this approach was, I think, in the winter of 2019, when there was that major event, major hacking event, and you had the Wallet.fail team.
29:20Marek "Slush" PalatinusUh-huh.
29:21Vlad CosteaAnd they reported lots of vulnerabilities and issues that you would not have considered before. And even I remember they showed how they can open the seal of a Trezor One with a blow dryer in their hotel room. And I think your response to that was putting more glue across all of the packaging.
29:41And now it's a lot harder to open without compromising it. So you have to tear up the whole carton box to open your device, just because, I suppose... I'm not sure if that was a turning point, but that was a major moment, and Ledger also realized that they're not as secure as they claim to be and they need to be more cautious with their messaging and also with the way they approach this security, because, you know, you have hackers who figure out interesting ways of getting into devices.
30:14And about BitBox02 and their situation with the BIP39 backup, they do encourage you to write down the words and they do have like a list of recommendations while you're doing it. Like never say it out loud, never type it on the keyboard, always type it on your device and stuff like that. But you can opt in for this quick setup, which doesn't make you write down the words. And yeah, I agree with you that maybe a user will not understand how important that step actually is.
30:49Ad voiceoverVaultoro, and that's V-A-U-L-T, like a gold vault, and O-R-O, oro, which is Spanish for gold, is a gold and Bitcoin exchange which offers instant swaps between hard money to over 31,000 customers from more than 95 countries. Vaultoro has offered Swiss privacy and security since 2015. Furthermore, the gold you purchase is your legal property, secured in your name, so even if something happens to Vaultoro, even liquidators could not touch your gold. If you want to become the custodian of your own gold bars, you can request to have them delivered to you, or simply trade them back to Bitcoin on the dip.
31:40Register for free in only 30 seconds and start trading only with hard money. Please keep in mind that all trading involves risks. This is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions. When you are using Wasabi Wallet, your internet connection gets routed through the Tor network by default. This means that you get better privacy while using Bitcoin. Download it today at WasabiWallet.io.
32:13Marek "Slush" PalatinusFrom our perspective or experience, the people will naturally go with the most easiest way which we offer them. And that may be a problem, because if we make the insecure way for them too easy, they won't go with the proper way, because it's just comfortable. So yeah, that's my response for the SD card, regarding the physical aspects and reusability of the old devices. Yeah, I think the physical security can be solved. Like, on a theoretical level, it can be solved. It's just a matter of the price of the attack.
32:59How good clone of the hardware you do, how expensive it's to avoid all the checks and so on. But people think that there's some magical solution how to make the hardware secure, but there's no such solution. The game is only about making it expensive enough or hard enough so there will be less people who can make the attack practically, but there's no silver bullet for this. So I still think that even with all the secure elements, it's good to use passphrase, because it theoretically avoids these kind of attacks.
33:48Vlad CosteaYeah, so I suppose we should recommend to people that they should get used to using passwords. Oh, no, passphrases, sorry, not passwords. I was thinking of the next question, which actually, let me introduce it. Because last year when we spoke, I asked you to say something nice and something that you don't like, or something that the Trezor does better. And I've asked you this question about the competition at the time. So it was Ledger, it was BitBox02, it was the Coldcard and the KeepKey, I think those four.
34:23But in the meantime, we have many more, not many more, but we have a handful of devices that came out and I never got to ask you what you think about them. So I'll start with the Cobo Vault, which came out last year after we recorded our interview. And it's trying to do this cold storage approach, also with PSBT like the Coldcard, with QR codes that you can scan with a camera. And it's the only other hardware wallet on the market which uses the SLIP-39 standard, which is for Shamir secret sharing.
34:59For backups. And I think that's nice because there is another device on the market that does this. But aside from what I mentioned, what do you think about it? What do you like and what do you think that the Trezor does better?
35:14Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, to be honest, I have no hands-on experience with Cobo Vault or I didn't read any security audit or something, so I will be only really high level on this, as I have no materials for some proper feedback. And in general, yeah, all hardwares, all wallets which support SLIP-39, like the Shamir secrets, I think it's really great because we wanted to do something which can be widely adopted like BIP39. And I think that we made some lessons from BIP39. And I think that the Shamir backup is really nicely designed. And I was a bit afraid that for political reasons, there won't be other brands which embraced it.
36:11So I'm really happy that I see some wallets which are starting using it. And regards the other feature, it's air gap. And yeah, air gap is also a hot topic nowadays. For me, the question is what we want to achieve by messing up with the QR codes or with making the user experience worse than it was before. And for me, I don't have good answer for this, because I don't think that the air gap, like with exchanging data with QR codes, solve any significant problem. Because what is really important is to be sure that the protocol is strong and secure on the logical level, and if the data which are exchanged are okay or not.
37:17So there's a lot of stuff which the hardware would need to validate on their own. And I think the air gap, except that it looks cool and super nerdy, I don't think it solves any practical issue. And there were actually logical bugs in these air gap protocols. I don't remember on which level, if it was in some attacks to PSBT or it was something else. I really don't remember and I don't want to be incorrect on this, but the fact that you are exchanging the data with QR codes, which you as a human can't verify, it doesn't make much difference.
38:04And also there is a practical limitations on the QR codes, like on the size. So there was recently, I think it's less than a year, there was a security research which shows that the SegWit actually doesn't fix the problem with the validation of previous transactions. There was a lot of discussions and we in the Trezor simply decided to enable additional checks which we are using in the protocol before SegWit, like the previous signature streaming. And we basically fully covered the issue.
38:45But you can't do this in air gap because you need to exchange possibly hundreds of kilobytes of data to stream the previous transactions. So other vendors need to implement some workarounds for this, and there was a huge discussion that we broke some consensus and so on, but I don't believe it. We simply focus on solving the practical problem. And thanks to the protocol and no limitation of the air gap, we were able to react quickly and fix the hole. And this is like the practical implication of these QR codes, because I don't think that they solve any problem, but they add another layer of issues.
39:42Vlad CosteaWell, Mr. Slush, I think this is one of the few points where you basically present the same view as Ledger, which is funny.
39:51Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, yeah. I think it's... Technically, we are able to do PSBT on the Trezor with microSD, and we have a graphical display to show QR codes and so on. So there's no limitation on the hardware itself. But it's just the philosophical stuff, like we don't really want to offer something which we don't believe it improves the thing for the customers.
40:24Vlad CosteaOkay, so I have to ask you this. Why is connecting your device to a computer via USB cable more secure than using PSBT, or just the same, just as secure?
40:40Marek "Slush" PalatinusI don't think it's more secure. I think it's maybe same security, but well, from our marketing perspective, you see all the buzz about the air gap. It's kind of sexy, but there were no security issues on the transmission protocol for years. I don't remember. And even there, I think there were some bugs with the buffer overflow, which can actually happen even in a PSBT, in the parsing the QR codes. So I don't remember a single bug which was relevant to the fact that it's using cable itself, but maybe my memory is short.
41:27So I don't think it's more or less secure. I think it's the same. And I think it's more comfortable because the user interaction can be more rich. Like sometimes you don't need only one ping of the information, like send something to the hardware, wait and back. Sometimes the interaction is more interactive, and this couldn't be done by QR codes because it would be too hard for users to scan QR codes all around. So I think this is more about usability.
42:08Vlad CosteaOkay, so now I have to ask you about the Foundation Devices Passport, which is trying to be a refined version of the Coldcard and adds a camera for QR codes, but you have mentioned why you are not a fan of that. Adds a faster processor, which I think is a useful addition, given that, I'm not sure if you've used the Coldcard, but the scrolling is kind of laggy. And you're never sure if you have to press the button once again or it's still processing your input. And it promises to also do an improved user interface. What do you think about the project? And what would you say that the Trezor still does better?
42:50Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, I think that improving the user experience is a key point what we should all push forward. So if there's some improvements on this field, I'm definitely glad for this, because in the end, I'm happy that people use any hardware wallet. So I'm not angry when I see that somebody is using some different brand just because they are not using the Trezor. I think it's better to use any hardware wallet than using some central exchange or some custodial storage. So from this perspective, I'm happy that somebody is improving what's already there.
43:31And yeah, I think what we only disagree with the Passport is that they built it on the QR code. So it's back about the previous topic. I am definitely for improving the user experience, but I think the QR codes are a huge limitation for future improvement.
43:57Vlad CosteaOkay, and I think the third most important, or I should not rank them, but the third hardware wallet that came around, and it's interesting that it's also the least expensive of them all, is the Blockstream Jade, which adds a ton of features with camera, Bluetooth and internal battery, and I've spoken with Lawrence Nahum. He said that he can do lots of integrations. For now, I think their focus is on the Liquid sidechain to be able to securely store and access those assets. But he also mentioned that he wants to do something like allowing for JoinMarket coordinations to be made, so it automatically confirms JoinMarket receiving funds and stuff like that, as well as some trading.
44:47He mentioned that if you have an oracle, you can set up some sort of criteria that you can input and automate trading with your hardware wallet, and lots of other stuff that possibly will get merged into the code or just end up as some wild idea. But first of all, I have to ask you, did you get your hands on one of these Jades? Because they are so hard to find.
45:13Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, again, I don't have the personal experience, but I discussed with some colleagues, and friends of mine has one device, so I have some information, and I like the concept. I think they finally came out with some innovation, which I like and which I think is inspirational. And just about the price, I am wondering with this hardware, I would really like to see their bill of materials, because I think there's no, how to say, no money left for some serious development. And this is like a story of Trezor.
46:00Where we believed, initially we believed that we can build just the hardware and initiate a community to do all the features and software and infrastructure around. And in the end, we realized that if we won't make it ourselves, the user experience won't be that good as we would like to see. So Jade is new and I don't know what was their strategy, was their plans, but I would be afraid that all these features which you named are really serious development, and you can't do this for free. And I'm just afraid that $40 per device with all these camera, Bluetooth and battery...
46:49I would like to see the strategy. Just to be honest, it's nothing like, I would like to do all these things with the device for $40 myself. This is one thing. About the features, I think that Bluetooth is interesting. I think that the next Trezor hardware will also have a Bluetooth, because nowadays most people are using smartphones more than any other type of computer. So I think it's necessity for the future. Of course, it's important to make it properly, so the breach of the Bluetooth stack won't have any impact on the security of the device itself.
47:42But it's just some engineering. And I kind of like the concept of cloud encrypted PIN. It has its weaknesses, like it needs internet connectivity or connectivity to the service which encrypts the key provided after you provide the correct PIN. But I like the concept. I think it has its own purpose. And I can imagine something like this in a Trezor as an optional feature. I think it's a nice additional feature to the secure element itself, maybe. Yeah, so I see Jade is interesting and I'm really wondering how it will evolve in the future.
48:29Vlad CosteaOkay, and you've also given some interesting hints about the next Trezor, which I have no idea what you're going to call it. But at the same time, you mentioned that it's going to have this Tropic Square chip, as well as a Bluetooth connection. Is there anything else that we should look forward to?
48:50Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, I think these are the most... this will be the most visible things or most important changes, like in our secure element and better connectivity. And also we are thinking about even making even richer UI, like the touchscreen. Touchscreen on the Model T is a success. I think we know or we see that this is probably the way of interacting with the user. It's much better than some buttons and sliders and so on. And so maybe we'll just make a slightly bigger screen, but it's not set in the stone yet. So connectivity will be definitely one of the biggest improvements.
49:43Vlad CosteaI think I would like a larger screen just because I have fat fingers, but that's very subjective.
49:47Marek "Slush" PalatinusThis is common feedback, that the screen is great, but it would be bigger because of this. Yeah.
49:58Vlad CosteaYeah, but something else that I like about the Model T screen is that it takes me back to my school days when I had one of these mobile phones with T9 input. And I would have to press, for example, button number eight, or what do you call it? The eighth dial on the phone. If I wanted TUV, I would press that one. And if I wanted V, I would press it three times. Like, that takes me back. It's the kind of interface that I haven't used in like 10 years, but I still like it.
50:30Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah. We had a lot of engineering behind the keyboard and we were doing some tests on the young people especially, because a lot of young people don't know these Nokia keyboards. And so we were testing the usability of this and we ended up with the solution which surprisingly people were able to use even without any prior experience with these T9 keyboards from old phones. So yeah, it would be definitely better to have a full keyboard. But in the end, I think this works... Pretty good compared to the size of the display.
51:15Ad voiceoverHey, psst, hey. What's your plan for the next Bitcoin top? Unless you need the money to purchase something, you probably should not touch infinitely inflationary fiat. Check out Vaultoro and figure out to which extent hard money like gold and silver can help you preserve your purchasing power. You will be able to get back into Bitcoin as soon as the price hits a new bottom and you will not be subjected to the arbitrary inflation-driven volatility of fiat or fiat-backed coins. Obviously, this is not financial advice and you should understand that all trading involves risks.
52:09Wasabi Wallet connects to your full Bitcoin node, and if you're not running one, it downloads block filters anonymously via Tor. In either case, you're getting excellent privacy. Download the software today at wasabiwallet.io.
52:24Vlad CosteaRight. And I have noticed in the last year, and this was also something which I saw this week because I... Basically, one of my friends started buying Bitcoin and he contacted me and was like, "I want to better secure it. What do I buy?" And he did not want to spend too much money on it, so I said, "Just get a Trezor One."
52:46And he picked it up. He wanted me to help him as he set it up. And I just wanted to watch him do it. And I said, "OK, you just go on. I want to see how you approach it. And if there is anything that I want to tell you, I will along the way." And I was impressed that the interface has changed. So the last time I used the Trezor One, you were still using that web interface.
53:16Where you had to connect and you had to install Trezor Bridge. But now you have the Trezor Suite, which is an application which works locally. I don't think you need an internet connection at all times, for example, just to check the amount of Bitcoin that you have. But it still has to synchronize with the blockchain, so you do need internet connection. But I think you're going to let me know if it also works offline. But there is a lot of interesting stuff that goes on with the Trezor Suite.
53:52And I've also noticed that on the roadmap, you have an integration with CoinJoins and also running the full node, coin control, and all of these features that you find in more advanced wallets such as Electrum and Wasabi.
54:11Marek "Slush" PalatinusYep. Just... yeah. We are working on the Trezor Suite for quite a long time and I think we are moving to the release date pretty quickly. And one other thing which we still need to finalize is to improve the onboarding process there. So very soon the new users will be put into the new onboarding, which will be in the Suite soon. And I believe it will improve the experience because we had a lot of research. We had a lot of development about this to make it as seamless as possible.
54:56And I think it will be a huge improvement to what we have on the website right now. In regards to it, I think so far it mostly needs internet connectivity because even in onboarding, it downloads the full, like the latest firmware into the device. Because we distribute the device without any firmware on it for security reasons. So I think the Suite needs the internet connectivity even in onboarding and of course it will need the internet connectivity for connecting to the blockchain. And to your question on the future features, we are definitely going to implement some privacy-oriented features.
55:45There's already implementation of Tor connectivity, so you can connect over Tor by a single click in the menu. We are actively working on a full node support and we are also having a lot of development and research about CoinJoin functionality in the hardware wallet and in the Suite environment. So these are like three big pillars which we are working on the privacy level. And it's important to say that we always wanted to deliver something like this, but it was impossible to deliver with the stack, with the previous stack, which was like more website-based, like the old wallet.trezor.io.
56:35So this desktop application will allow us to have a bigger control, to connect to like local node or some ElectrumX backends, managing the Tor connections and all this. So you can expect some improvements in this area in the near future.
56:59You were asking about Electrum and Wasabi, and I like both projects, and I think that historically, we were sending advanced users to Electrum or to Wasabi if they wanted to do some more advanced stuff. And I think that with better funding and with a bigger development team, we are more working towards implementing these advanced features directly in the Suite. Because I was repeatedly talking about the user experience, and our historical experience was that we can deliver the total or the best user experience only if we control the whole stack which the user is facing.
57:50Vlad CosteaYeah, actually, I want to mention that I've noticed something interesting in the Trezor Suite that I did not notice in the Trezor web wallet. So for example, I've asked my friend who came over to my place to not use the first seed phrase that he generated and basically erase the device and try once again, so he gets used to creating more wallets just in case he needs it for whatever purpose. And for curiosity purposes, I told him, "Why don't you tell during the setup that this Trezor has not been used before and it's a new device?" And he clicked on that side of the menu and it basically said, "This Trezor has been registered before.
58:37If it wasn't you, then it must have been compromised." And I don't recall seeing this kind of verification in the web wallet.
58:47Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, I think it's not a secret that all these phishing attempts and shipping prefilled or initialized devices did happen. Well, I think it mostly happened to other brands I don't want to name, but it's like a general problem. So we included all these checks and warnings into the workflow to eliminate the possibility that if the user received a new device and it has been already used, and he clicks, "Oh, this device is supposed to be new," we can tell him that something is fishy. And I think this is something which we step by step can prevent some attackers.
59:40Vlad CosteaYeah, I'm actually curious to know how that works because when I've asked Lixin Liu from Cobo about the website verification, and basically you have to scan a QR code on their website when you set up and that's going to verify if the device has been used, and he told me that that scanning interacts with their secure element chip. And if the secure element chip has done a scan before, then it means it's compromised. So the Trezor has no secure element chips. So how does that work?
1:00:13Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, it's all about being initialized before. So it's not like you can reprogram this flag easily. Of course, you can do this with some hardware tampering and so on, but it prevents the practical usage of some scammers just loading the seeds and shipping the devices. So, again, it's not like a cryptographically secure verification, but it solves the practical issues which we see in the field.
1:00:53Vlad CosteaOkay, it's still a nice addition and something else which I noticed is that right now, if you set up a Bitcoin wallet, the default setting is with SegWit native addresses, Bech32. And I thought that was also a nice touch. And I very much look to the addition of coin control and CoinJoins and all of that good stuff. I saw that there's a roadmap that you can find on the Trezor Suite section of the website, and they should be added by July, I think, if I'm not mistaken.
1:01:28Marek "Slush" PalatinusYes, you are right.
1:01:30Vlad CosteaSo yeah, that gets me excited.
1:01:34Marek "Slush" PalatinusThere's a lot of ongoing development. We are even, some projects which we are just designing, they are not even on the GitHub right now, so there's a lot of stuff we are thinking about and eventually we will implement them after all this stuff will be done. But yeah, it's long time, long time into the future because these features are not that easy as they seem at the first sight. And our goal is definitely to deliver this functionality with the usability in mind, so it will be easy for newcomers to do all these CoinJoins and all this, so stay tuned.
1:02:19Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly. That's why I'm excited because usually you'd use a wallet that's dedicated to it like Wasabi. And for Super Shamir backups, which instead of 20 words have 33 words, you have to use Electrum. But the idea that the average user who gets his Trezor for the first time and orders it gets to use it with a native software which unlocks all of these features is really great, you know, because you don't have to learn how to use a different interface or discover along the way that, you know, there's this other software that does something better and you're supposed to use that one if you want more privacy or better control of your coins.
1:03:05But to have it all in the native interface, that's really ambitious. Okay, so I also wanted to ask you a question which I got asked on Twitter actually by There Is No Alternative @ Matt Leong, I think, and he wants to know if there is any hope for SLIP-39 and the Trezor One.
1:03:34Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, there are no specific plans for adding SLIP-39 into Trezor One for multiple reasons, and one of them is that you actually need some richer interface on the device. And we simply think that it would be pretty hard to do all this stuff, all the UI with the two buttons and small display. So I don't think that this will happen soon. And on the other hand, I think that the Shamir backup is aimed for bigger, I would say, even lifetime savings. And to be honest, I don't think it's...
1:04:19From this perspective, it's a big difference in between Trezor One and Model T from the price tag. So we definitely aim with these advanced features for the Model T, which has a better comfort for what it provides. So no plans for Trezor One.
1:04:45Vlad CosteaYeah, but something, so the other part of the question from Matt Leong and something on which I agree is that currently there is no way on the Trezor One to type your passphrase on the device somehow. You could get, I guess, an on-screen keyboard or something, but it kind of sucks that you have to use your computer keyboard for that.
1:05:07Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, it's correct critique. I think, again, it's not that intuitive, but I think it's important to have, like, comfortable user input to entering the PIN, the passphrase, because if you have just like two buttons, typing the passphrase on some matrix directly on the device, it will push users to use weak passphrases. And I honestly think that using weak passphrases for what the passphrase is... The passphrase is basically to prevent some brute force if you crack the Trezor or if you get the recovery seed.
1:06:01So, passphrase which is weak is not really helpful. So, for this reason, we want to provide a rich interface, which is like keyboard on the computer, which will motivate users to have a strong enough passphrase, which is ideally many words or even a sentence for really strong memorability and security.
1:06:31For this reason, I don't think that we will enable entering the passphrase directly on Model One. There's a keyboard on Model T, but I think it's on the edge of the usability. And I still think that revealing the passphrase to the computer, to the keylogger, it's still not the whole attack vector, it must be combined with some other physical attack to the device or to the recovery seed. So revealing the passphrase itself doesn't help the attacker that much. But on the other hand, having a strong passphrase is, in my opinion, better than having a weak one and typing it on the device.
1:07:23Vlad CosteaThere are always trade-offs, I guess.
1:07:25Marek "Slush" PalatinusYep.
1:07:26Vlad CosteaOkay, so there's another question by Martin Diak. Diak, Diak. I'm not sure, there's an accent on the A, so I'm really sorry for mispronouncing your name, Martin. But he wants to know about a direct connection to your own node on the Trezor.
1:07:46Marek "Slush" PalatinusIt's in the pipeline already. The grand vision is to have a one-click setup with the pruned node directly in the Trezor Suite. But in the meantime, we will definitely enable connecting to own full node, to own boxes, like all these nodes and all these other boxes, or even our machine with ElectrumX or Electrum, I forgot the name of all these indexers, like Electrs, or how it's pronounced. So this is in the pipeline and we definitely want to provide connectivity for these boxes and eventually we want to integrate it all together so it will be just one click away without any necessity of separate hardware.
1:08:44Vlad CosteaWait, so you have mentioned something interesting, and I wasn't aware of it. So when you use Trezor Suite, it downloads block filters just like Wasabi, so you run your own pruned node?
1:08:57Marek "Slush" PalatinusNot right now. But we are looking for this. Like, it would be... Actually, it's pretty hard engineering to do this properly. I think the stage one is to connect to Electrum backend, which can be run by the user on the separate computer or whatever, and the next level would be to have a possibility to run pruned nodes directly and interact with the local node over block filters.
1:09:34Vlad CosteaOkay, I got excited for a minute there, so it's also coming. Yep. Okay, now what is your take on the difference between the multisig and the Shamir backup? And you have mentioned that there are not many hardware wallet companies that have adopted the SLIP-39 standard, which is for Shamir secret sharing. And I suspect that it's because they embrace this idea that multisig is the silver bullet for security. But you can also do, then again, you can do Shamir backup with a multisig on top if you want to kill yourself with complexity. But that's your own choice.
1:10:15Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, exactly. I'm pretty consistent in this opinion as I'm telling it over the years. The same. I think that multisig is a great tool and Trezor has perfect support for multisig. It has all the best practices implemented, so you can use multisig with Electrum or with Unchained Capital, with Caravan or with their, not custodial, but the centralized service. So we fully support multisig. But on the other hand, I think the multisig is really useful for the environments where multiple people need to interact or they cover each other, like in the companies where the CEO and CFO have a control over the Bitcoins.
1:11:15And so this is great for these setups. But I really don't like using multisig setups for single person backups or for single person use cases, because it makes the complexity much bigger. And it practically doesn't improve that much. Like, of course, I would need to go more into the detail to clarify what I mean by this. But the fact that you need to manage multiple devices, ideally, to make it like proper, ideally from different vendors, keep all the updates and keep all the stuff so they play together nicely.
1:12:04It can be really complex and it can be really time consuming stuff. And on the other hand, if you want to transact, you need to go around multiple destinations, possibly, to confirm the transactions. It has some improvements, like security improvements, but it goes for a high price for this, and I think that the people are comfortable by nature. So I don't think that the people will really be that strict, like having the devices of different vendors in different geographically separated places where nobody knows how the setup is, is ready and so on.
1:12:55Of course, there may be some people, even there may be people who don't like hardware wallets at all and they have their own setup of some computers without microphones and all the EMI and so on. But if we go with the vision or with the motivation to make it easy for generic, for general public, I don't think that multisig is a good way to go, because it makes a lot of complexity in all this. On the other hand, I think that Shamir really, really sucks in a multi-person setup.
1:13:37Because, of course, at some point you need to combine all the shares to a single hardware wallet. So it doesn't provide the use case like securing the money for a company where multiple persons are involved. But on the other hand, I think it really does the job for a single person, single person wallet, because you can do the backup, the split of the seeds. You can do this really properly and use proper geographical locations, which they are really far, far away, and they can be really secretive and so on.
1:14:20You can even use it for social backup, like splitting the shares between persons from your family, of your friends, coworkers and so on. So you can do this social backup and geographic backup really, really strong. And then you can still use all the features of the hardware wallet with the original ease of use, so you don't need to compromise the usability since you made a proper setup. And of course, if you are afraid of some compromising of this hardware and some security bugs and so on...
1:15:04And you don't need to transact, you just need to wipe out this device with the recovery seed. So you achieve the highest possible security. And only if you want to transact, you need to go to these locations and recover the original secret, which is from the user experience perspective not that much different than going and updating all your hardware wallets, which are hidden somewhere. So I think for personal security, the Shamir backup is combining the security with better usability, because it's more up to you.
1:15:51If you want to do like one-time setup, or like a setup of the shares, and then you need only to periodically check if the shares are on safe place, but you don't need to literally visit them every time you are going to sending or even receiving some money. And so it's more flexible for a single person. But again, I don't think that Shamir is good for multi-person setup.
1:16:23Vlad CosteaYeah, I mean, I hear all the time this idea that they are perfecting multisig and it's going to be usable by just one person for large amounts. And to me, that kind of seems pointless when you can use a Shamir backup, especially knowing that nowadays the fees on the main chain are very high. And with multisig setups, you're paying a lot more depending on the complexity of your multisig, basically how many signatures are required in the blockchain, and they add up to the size of the transaction. So you're going to be paying a lot of money whenever you decide to spend some of that amount.
1:17:04Marek "Slush" PalatinusI think this will eventually improve with Taproot. So I don't think this is the problem itself, or at least for the future. But I think that having single person proper multisig setup is really much more complex than Shamir.
1:17:26Vlad CosteaYeah, at the same time, I can understand, you know, maybe this is cynical, but when you produce hardware wallets and you're aware that multisigs encourage that users purchase one of each model from every company, it's kind of convenient. You know, it kind of takes away part of the competition. And it just means that you're going to be included in the more secure setups that users are going to be doing. If they're going to do a two out of three, then they're going to purchase a Ledger, a Trezor, and I don't know, maybe a Coldcard or something. And that's easier to sell products.
1:18:03Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, I think this is again about trade-offs. I think that the practical security problems are lying elsewhere than like attacking the specific hardware wallet. I think that the issue for most of the people is where to store the recovery seeds, the shares, or the hardware wallet itself. So I understand this argument. But I think that the security is much more complex and it's not like that, "Oh, I'm using five different vendors, I am safe." But it's also about interoperability of this and being sure that you don't shoot yourself into feet when these vendors stop cooperating or something like this.
1:18:59So I think it's like more complex topic, and I am myself not a friend of overcomplex setups and combining all these things together, because I think it can be dangerous itself.
1:19:16Vlad CosteaOkay, so nowadays it's impossible to talk about Bitcoin hardware wallets without mentioning the issue that Ledger has had last year with their marketing database. How does Trezor handle the situation any different? And what are your recommendations for people to order in a safer way?
1:19:39Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah. We were aware of this problem of leaking the customer database since many years ago. And we continuously improve the process until the state that we are actively deleting the user data from the databases, so they are not there when they are not necessary anymore. And of course, I think this is same for Ledger. We don't need to know who's our customer and we don't need to have any accounts or even KYC accounts and so on. So this is only about the way how to distribute the products to customers.
1:20:28And in this we are pretty active. We wrote some blog posts about this, even that we propose users to use some alternative addresses, like shipping addresses, and even, if possible, to use some alternative names, so you won't leave any trace. And for example, it's better to send the hardware wallet to your workplace than to your home, and so on. But this is a serious topic. And there is no single solution unless there will be some anonymous delivery options. And there are not so many, or not some global ones.
1:21:17So I think this will be a topic even in the future. But I think all the vendors should be aware that this is really a huge problem. It's a reputation problem for everybody and not only for them. I think this damages also the perception of the security of the hardware wallets itself, because when you are downloading Electrum, you don't need to write phone numbers and your shipping address anywhere. So I think this is a huge problem which needs to be eventually addressed. I don't see any great solution for this, but what we can do and what everybody should do is to anonymize the orders as soon as possible. So it means after the delivery itself.
1:22:00Vlad CosteaI always ask this question: does the fact that you can delete and anonymize data have to do anything with the fact that you are from the Czech Republic? Because I think in France it's kind of a bad idea to do security business. Since they had so many terrorist attacks, they ask you to store the data for 10 years and make it available to them at any point. And, you know, it's kind of difficult.
1:22:25Marek "Slush" PalatinusTo be honest, I didn't know what say the Czech laws. We at least delete this information from the online system. I think that even in the accounting we have only countries, so we don't need to have names or addresses, but I would need to ask. I'm not sure what the current status is, but I live in the opinion that we really delete all the names. And even when we had some police requests, like some investigations, all the time we are telling the investigators that we don't have any personal data. And they are okay with it. So it works.
1:23:15Vlad CosteaOkay, so there are people out there like JW Weatherman who tell people not to buy any hardware wallets because they're not safe and they expose you to all sorts of vulnerabilities and blah blah. And instead of that, you should use a service which he open sourced, I think it's called Yeti, and it relies on Linux, Bitcoin Core, and the multisig that you do on paper, and you use CDs or pages that you print as backups. What do you think about these claims? Why should people still buy hardware wallets?
1:23:52Marek "Slush" PalatinusWell, this is what I saw 10 years ago. This was exactly what I was recommending to people to do before we had Trezor. And seeing their response and their ability to do this properly and securely was the motivation for doing Trezor. So this is not like something new which we were not aware before, and he would suddenly come with something completely new. This was the original state. And I think this can work for a security researcher. This can work for somebody who is deep into the security, into the Linux, into all the configuring, even firewalls and system updates, and limiting the attack vectors and all this.
1:24:47Of course, if you are capable of doing this, go forward. I was doing this for years myself, so I know what he's talking about. But on the other hand, this doesn't scale, and recommending this to general public is clearly irresponsible, because if somebody who is not like a security expert reads that hardware wallets are not secure and you need to install Linux, whatever distribution, and try to install Bitcoin Core and secure the machine there, I think in general, in bigger scale, it can make much bigger damage than just using any hardware wallet.
1:25:34For securing it, and because the hardware wallet is the product which packs all the necessary tools all together. So I completely disagree with his stance and I think it's dangerous to recommend this for people. And of course, if you are a security researcher or open source geek, you are probably better in understanding the risk and you can do whatever you want. I don't say that hardware wallets are best fit for everybody, but I'm pretty sure that it's a good fit for normal people.
1:26:20Vlad CosteaYeah, this also opens the can of worms of attack surface. And I suppose that a small device which only runs MicroPython and does a very limited amount of tasks, like a Trezor, is a lot harder to attack than a computer with an operating system which has lots of known security issues. Especially if you, I think if you use Windows, it's the most exposed to any kind of attacks. So yeah, you should also consider that. So unless you know what you're doing and use the kind of operating system, I think not even Ubuntu is good enough for this, or it might be. I don't want to make any scandalous statements for the Linux community out there.
1:27:05Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, I think any Linux can be safe if you know what you are doing, and any system can be unsafe if you don't know what you are doing. And the attack vector, like the amount of code which can interact with the recovery seed or with the security, is simply out of scope. It's many times of magnitude bigger than in the hardware wallets. You have no chance to validate that the stack which is running on your Linux machine is anyhow safe. And there are some lessons learned.
1:27:45There was a bug in Android of some version, I don't remember well, which when you installed the Mycelium, it used a poor random number generator. And as a side product of this, some users were... Mycelium generated the same private keys for them. So when you were lucky, you install the fresh installation of Mycelium and you already see the bitcoins on it. Which sounds funny, but it wasn't that big fun. And of course, the problem is that it was outside of the scope of Mycelium developers because it wasn't their fault.
1:28:29It was a fault of the underlying operating system and there was a security incident in the Android. But this is the point. You can have honest developers, good developers, but you have no control on what kind of system the users will install the software. This is different story in hardware wallets, where the company who is building the product has total control over the hardware and software. So they can tune the overall security and they can audit the code from the top to the bottom and actively avoid these kind of mistakes which will otherwise happen.
1:29:19Vlad CosteaYeah, I very much agree with you on this one. And I also do remember that this past few weeks, there was an issue with a fake Android application in the Google Play Store for the Trezor, and it was taken down, I think.
1:29:36Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, this is similar to all phishing attempts. This is a huge problem. Like, yeah, all these app stores and Google Play and Google Search, they are outside of our control and we can't improve it anyhow. We were in touch with Google about this, but unless Google understands that this is really major problem, and unless they will start actively solving this, we can't do anything with this except of teaching the people to be really cautious and every time they install something like Trezor related or in general, like Bitcoin related, they need to be super, super paranoid about what they are giving to the application.
1:30:33Vlad CosteaOkay, so last year I've asked you the question, "What is next for Trezor and for SatoshiLabs?" And your response was, "I'm going to present it during the Bitcoin 2020 conference in," I think it was San Francisco at the time. And it was canceled. It did not happen anymore. So I never got to find out what's next. So what were you about to present at the time? What was that big reveal that you're about to do?
1:31:05Marek "Slush" PalatinusIf I remember well, it was a more detailed presentation of the Tropic Square. And yeah, but then it didn't happen. So we released the press release about the Tropic Square by our channels. We produced some videos with the motivation why we are doing this and why we are not just buying some existing solutions. So I think it was more about this. And of course, you knew about the Tropic Square already, so it wouldn't be that big news for you. But I remember that that video about the Tropic Square and launch of the Tropic Square site and calling for some coworkers, it was like the first official announcement of the project.
1:31:54So it was a year ago. Since then, we moved forward quite a lot. And today we have some long-term goals. I think that all the stuff which we are working on has been already mentioned. I think that we work on all fronts: on the usability, security and privacy. And the usability is definitely the Suite and eventually the new hardware, which has some improvements like the Bluetooth and the bigger screen and so on. The security is definitely the Tropic Square and bigger adoption of Shamir. And privacy, it was already mentioned, like CoinJoin, full node, Tor, and eventually coin control.
1:32:40So these are like big projects which go across the whole stack. We have some other internal projects which we are working on. They will be also fully open source and I'm really excited about them. But they are in somehow early stage, so I don't think it makes sense to speak about them yet, but yeah, I just tease you that we are not sleeping and we are developing a lot of other stuff, and maybe next year there will be something on the market.
1:33:20Vlad CosteaOh, I hope that you are sleeping at night, you know, if for no other reason than to outlive your enemies.
1:33:28Marek "Slush" PalatinusYeah, it's fair. We are able to do all this new stuff because we make development and product team much stronger, and I believe that the customers will see this really, really soon in like the releases of the software.
1:33:50Vlad CosteaYeah, I suppose that most of what's next can be found on the roadmap for the Trezor Suite. And there's also a lot of stuff happening with Tropic Square, and that's going to be a major release. I really look forward to that one. I'm kind of psyched when I think about it. And thank you very much for doing this. I hope that next year, when there is more stuff that has been released, we get to do this kind of interview once again. It seems like sometimes even some of the same questions have different answers one year from the other.
1:34:29Marek "Slush" PalatinusSorry, I didn't hear. Now, what was the question?
1:34:32Vlad CosteaNo, it wasn't a question. It was a remark that sometimes even the same question that I ask today can have a different answer next year, because the space is evolving so fast.
1:34:44Marek "Slush" PalatinusDefinitely. I'm in Bitcoin since 2010 and I must say that each bull market somehow redefines the environment of the Bitcoin. So I see that it's a huge, huge development across all the Bitcoin parts. So this is amazing, amazing trip.
1:35:10Vlad CosteaYeah, so thank you very much and I look forward to doing another one of these interviews.
1:35:16Marek "Slush" PalatinusThank you again for inviting me.
1:35:29Vlad CosteaGoodbye.
1:35:30Ad voiceoverVaultoro has a 100% track record with fully audited and insured gold bullion that are secured in a top-tier tax-free Swiss vaulting facility. It also features a generous affiliate program, OTC trading, physical delivery and pickup, or trade back to Bitcoin in seconds. Register for free and check out the ways in which you can trade hard money and preserve your wealth. And if you want to help this show, sign up using the Vaultoro.com/BitcoinTakeover link that you can also find in the description. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice. All trading involves risks, and you are responsible for your own decisions.
1:36:14Wasabi Wallet's innovative CoinJoins will make your bitcoins more fungible. So if you accumulate more than 0.1 BTC, you can mix it with other users to remove all traces about their whereabouts. So it's like putting multiple fingerprints on your dollar bills, and it becomes impossible to determine the last few owners of the money. Download Wasabi Wallet today and start coinjoining.
1:36:14================================================================================ Production notes: Remote one-on-one English-language interview between Vlad Costea and Slush, a non-native English speaker. It has pre-recorded Vaultoro and Wasabi Wallet sponsor voiceovers at the start, a mid-roll break and the end, plus a short ad teaser mid-episode. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 6 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (130 chunks) and 53 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 5 of 5 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021", stray "Thank you.", "Thank you for watching. See you next time. Bye." and "The first part of the video..." hallucinations; labelled intro ad as Ad voiceover; Guest A → Slush; fixed Vaultoro, Vlad, Slush, SatoshiLabs, Slush Pool, Trezor Suite, mining pools, BitcoinTalk thread, Coldcard, NDAs, 20 or 30 years, "Ledger part", "two different worlds"; restored dropped words from second ASR (ambitious sentence at 10:23, memory/encrypted, "work on the mission"); repaired split "So what's the stage of development?" as Vlad; ringgans marked as unclear layouts; Speaker labels set to Slush/Vlad; split ad block (Vaultoro, Wasabi) to Ad voiceover; split Slush's "Yeah" and "Uh-huh" interjections; removed hallucination "As you can see... recovery sheet" and restored "has a microSD card"; fixed Trezor/Tresor/treasure, KeepKey/Kipki, Coldcard, SatoshiLabs, Cryptosteel, Vaultoro, Wallet.fail, recovery seed, secure elements, "three"/"free", "attack"/"effect", "clone"/"Clown", "passwords" per second ASR; "easy recovery" marked unclear; Speaker labels mapped to Marek "Slush" Palatinus and Vlad Costea. Fixed Cobo Vault, Coldcard, SLIP-39, Shamir secret sharing/backup, PSBT, Trezor, microSD, JoinMarket, Liquid and "worse". Removed hallucinations at 41:52 ("next episode...") and 45:08, and restored the dropped speech from the second ASR and Scribe. Replaced the garbled "What's the plan for the next year" and "Better do it" with the second-ASR text. Fixed the "but that's very subjective" split and labelled the Vaultoro ad start as Ad voiceover. Split long paragraphs; Relabelled Vaultoro/Wasabi ad as Ad voiceover, restored Wasabi ad opening, split Vlad's question at 00:52:24; removed "Thanks for watching", "The link to the website is in the description", "Thank you", "Bye, God"; split turns at 01:01:28 and 01:07:23; fixed Trezor Suite, CoinJoins, Bech32, SegWit, ElectrumX, Electrs, Lixin Liu/Cobo, SLIP-39, recovery seed, 33 words, tampering, attackers, three pillars, stack, Umbrel (unclear); Guest A labelled as Marek "Slush" Palatinus; fixed Shamir backup ("push in your backup", "camera", "Chameleon", "shimmy or backup"), multisig ("multiasic", "citat"), SLIP-39, recovery seeds, Electrum, JW Weatherman, Yeti, Coldcard, Trezor; "this damages also" and "be a topic" restored via second ASR; removed "Thank you for watching... Bye." hallucination and doubled words; moved "Yeah, I" to Slush at split turn 01:18:03; Guest A → Marek "Slush" Palatinus; removed "Listen and learn." (restored "lessons learned" per Qwen) and the 01:35:09 Bitcoin.com hallucination; restored "huge development... amazing trip" ending; fixed recovery seed, Mycelium, Tropic Square, Trezor Suite, SatoshiLabs, "really cautious", "one year"; split final ad from Vlad's "Goodbye", restored Vaultoro ad opening, labelled Ad voiceover.