S8 Special: Max Hillebrand on Wasabi Wallet, Hardware Wallets, Privacy & Anarchy
Search this conversation
0:30Ad voiceoverThis episode is sponsored by Vaultoro. Keep on listening and you'll find out more about how you can buy allocated gold when the Bitcoin bull run reaches its peak. This way, you don't have to deal with infinitely inflationary fiat or banks that freeze your account. Also, note that trading involves risks and the information presented is not financial advice.
1:20Vlad CosteaThis episode is also sponsored by Wasabi Wallet. Go to wasabiwallet.io, download Wasabi for your OS and significantly boost your network level and transaction privacy.
1:41Hello there and welcome to a special episode of the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. I am Vlad. My guest today is Max Hillebrand and he is a representative of Wasabi Wallet. And if you have been listening to season eight, then you already know that it was sponsored by Wasabi. And part of the deal was to have this exclusive interview and talk about what's going on in Bitcoin, what kind of ways we use to secure our coins, if we use hardware wallets, what we like about them, what we don't, and what we have learned.
2:16And plus, we can also talk about how Wasabi Wallet integrates hardware wallets and you can use them, most of them actually, are recognized by the wallet software, and you can do lots of cool stuff with it that normally I don't think you could do with the basic interface that's delivered by the manufacturer of your hardware wallet. So, hi, Max. Let's talk about Bitcoin and security and Wasabi and all of that cool stuff.
2:44Max HillebrandWell, hello, Vlad. Thanks for the intro. I'm really looking forward to our conversation and I've been enjoying your season so far. It's really nice to get here with all these contributors to the hardware wallet ecosystem. And what's the latest, right? And where the market is going. So thanks for putting this all on record. It's very useful.
3:05Vlad CosteaOh, yes. And I feel like there are two trends right now happening in the hardware wallet market. On one hand, you have Tropic Square by SatoshiLabs. So they're going to build a truly open source secure element chip that will get shipped next year with the next Trezor. And on the other hand, you have this open source movement that was started by Specter. And after Specter you had the SeedSigner, you had the Krux wallet, you had all of these DIY projects that are very smart and are not supposed to be commercial.
3:41That's the whole point about them. Because the Trezor already also... the BitBox02 and the Coldcard used to be the kind of device that you can build yourself from parts. But these rely on actually general purpose stacks that you buy, like you get something like the M5 stacks. I think also the Blockstream Jade is based on it. And you design your own hardware wallet. You flash the software on some sort of SD card, and then you have your own device. And nobody is going to know that you own a hardware wallet, that you ordered it.
4:17You use it with the maximum kind of privacy and plausible deniability. So I think it's interesting that we got to this point of DIY, even though it's not recommended for everyone. And you have to really know what you're doing. Otherwise, you can mess up a lot.
4:36Max HillebrandYes, again, like a really great development over these last couple of years, and the do-it-yourself area is interesting because it removes a lot of supply chain risks. And because these general purpose computation devices are produced at mass for many, many other projects. So it will be more difficult to do a targeted attack. Whilst, for example, the production line of Trezor, Ledger, Coldcard, and all of them are unique Bitcoin devices where everyone knows that this hardware is used mainly or only to store or generate private keys that protect Bitcoin. That's a much easier target to attack.
5:21However, I would also say that it's not impossible that there would still be an attack in the supply chain of these general-purpose devices. We've seen similar things on the software side, where, for example, library packages in software, like many dependencies down the tree, were taken over by malicious actors and then inserted some malicious code that led to users of the Bitcoin wallet that was a couple dependencies down the road. Users lost some Bitcoin via these types of attacks.
5:39So, sure, software and hardware is different and supply chain and, you know, hardware things are not that comparable to software. But in theory, it's for sure possible that even these general computation devices somehow get backdoored with some security risks. But it's probably going to come at a later point before the attack of the general purpose computation devices comes. But who knows? In any case, nothing is perfectly secure, right? There's always a risk.
6:27Vlad CosteaYeah, I like to joke sometimes that for all of these DIY hardware wallets we have to also come up with other kind of devices that we build from the same stacks, like gaming consoles, like communication devices, anything. Just so you have extra excuses to regulators, to your government, if it becomes authoritarian, or to anyone who's curious about what you're up to. Because let's say that you're the Raspberry Pi Zero, which can work for lots of projects. But if you have an alibi or some sort of excuse that you are going to own it and you're going to use it for something geeky, then you're going to be off the radar.
7:15So we need more of that. We need to provide more plausible deniability. But for most people, I think that you can't go wrong with just getting a Trezor or a Coldcard, even though I can't recommend the Coldcard to people who don't know what they're doing, because it happened to myself at some point. I used it after a year. And I realized that I don't remember how I was doing something, so I had to look it up on YouTube and figure out once again. It felt like learning once again after one year.
7:47And the UI is not friendly to most users, so unless you understand what's going on there, just try something simpler. And use Wasabi, by the way. And I know that you're responsible for proposing lots of integrations for hardware wallets and working also on the code. So which hardware wallets do currently work with Wasabi?
8:10Max HillebrandSo, that was a very important question that we were asking ourselves for a long time before we had hardware integration. nopara73's argument against it was always that we don't want to keep up with maintaining the firmware compatibility for each hardware producer. Back in those days, there were only like three main producers, but since then, you know, as we've just laid out, there are many even do-it-yourself kits, right? It would be unfeasible to maintain an integration of a custom firmware integration for each of these hardwares. That's why we, for a long time, did not want to do it.
8:53However, then I spoke to Adam about Andrew Chow's project, the Hardware Wallet Interface, which is a Bitcoin Core project, which is outside the Bitcoin full node repository, that packages or that strips out all of the dependency requirements for the firmware, for any firmware of most hardware wallets, and puts that into a separate software repository that can be used by other wallets to then talk to any hardware wallet that is compatible with this HWI repository, which is most of them.
9:28So Andrew Chow is the hero who takes on the work that nobody else wants to do all the time, and that is to make sure that all the firmware updates for all the hardware wallets don't break anything in this HWI repository.
9:47It's very difficult, if not impossible, to ensure that. So he's constantly fixing updates to whenever a firmware upgrade of one of the hardware vendors breaks something in the setup. But the nice thing is that he does this and every software project that uses HWI as a dependency can benefit from that. And so Wasabi Wallet was one of the first Bitcoin wallets to utilize HWI and to ship it, so that all of a sudden, every hardware wallet that was compatible with HWI was also compatible with Wasabi. And back in the days when we did it, that again was only Coldcard, Trezor and Ledger.
10:33And even for Coldcard, I squeezed in a couple hardcore power user feature requests, especially that the SD card workflow is integrated nicely and that it works together with, you know, even recognizable, like, press this button to get your Coldcard skeleton file or things like this, that makes it a bit more easier to use the Coldcard's SD card functionality. But ever since then, right, you can use Wasabi with any hardware wallet that is compatible with HWI. So that's BitBox, that's Cobo, that's Specter, and Krux and all of these others, right? They should work with Wasabi.
11:17But with an emphasis that they should, and that we don't really have the capacity to test each of these devices constantly, especially when the firmware of the hardware changes, because that happens outside of our release cycles, and sometimes stuff breaks and we do have to push a hotfix release. But ultimately, we cannot ensure 100% uptime for all these edge case hardware wallets, but thanks to HWI, our uptime is better than it otherwise would have been. So that's a nice thing.
11:54Vlad CosteaYeah, so it's really interesting that basically any hardware wallet on the market today, both commercial and DIY, should in theory work with Wasabi Wallet. Even though you don't have to maintain separately every firmware for every manufacturer. And this is only by virtue of a Bitcoin Core contribution by Andrew Chow. Like, it just proves that there's a lot of potential for open source software. And just one integration can help an entire industry just get away from the control of the companies. Because I firmly believe that it might not be the best idea to get, for example, a Ledger and only use it with Ledger Live.
12:37Because you're handing them your public key, your xpub. They're going to know when you connect, which addresses you generate, how much money you have, and how much you receive, and with whom you're transacting. And I feel like these features are basically against the idea of privacy and security. Because you can say, "Yeah, this is still secure, nobody can hack it."
13:02But if there is so much information that can get associated with you, and you also connect with your clearnet IP address, and you also have your email address, which is part of your account on Ledger, then there's so much data that gets connected to your Bitcoin activity just because you use their default wallet. And if you try to break away from it and create a new wallet generated with Wasabi, it's going to be a lot more private for yourself. Not only that you have Tor, but you also manage your UTXOs in a way that's not custodial.
13:41You connect your own full node, or even if you don't, you download the block filters on your own computer, so that you don't have to do any of this. And I feel sorry that I used Ledger as an example because they were the ones that integrated full node connectivity into their Ledger Live interface, so they are ahead of the competition in this regard, even though BitBox02 was the first to do it, actually.
14:12Max HillebrandYeah, so they did it. You see, to point out, like here, it doesn't have to be that the software of the hardware providers is shitty, right? They could ship good software, too. It was just that in the past, they didn't. The Ledger and Trezor interface, let's say their focus was on a sleek user experience and also multiple shitcoins, right? So that deterred the focus away quite a lot from, you know, what's important in Bitcoin. And therefore, other wallets stepped in to, you know, save the Bitcoin user from having a decent and nuanced Bitcoin user experience.
14:54And the OG for that is, of course, Electrum, which worked since forever with Trezor and even supports multisig and all of these nice things that Electrum does. And HWI is just, you know, kind of the natural follow-up consequence from that, to have a way for other wallets to easily incorporate it. And then we see wallets like Wasabi that use the HWI interface to talk to the hardware wallet, but then on the software side, we have a dedicated team that focuses on one task and one task only, and that is to make Bitcoin usage as private as possible and as intuitive as possible.
15:40And this gives us a lot more, like, dedication and focus to do one thing but do it good, which the Trezor software team simply doesn't have, you know. And this is one of the cool things about Coldcard, for example, because they realize that, hey, we just want to be hardware providers, and yes, we will write the firmware to the hardware, but we don't want to worry with client-side software graphical user interfaces. And that removes a lot of, you know, burden from them. They get away with a much smaller team focusing on doing just one thing and doing it right.
16:15And they let other projects like Andrew Chow's HWI and like Wasabi Wallet or many others, Specter or whatnot, take over the user experience. But that again comes at a cost of having not as nicely integrated UI and UX. You see, that's why maybe you think that Coldcard is a bit clunky, because there is no nice, shiny, clicky GUI that does all the features that the Coldcard supports, that does that, you know, optimized in the UX perspective. It's just very difficult and time consuming to do that. So, you know, there are, as always, trade-offs, but ultimately we have a plethora of choice and that's always a good thing.
17:03Vlad CosteaYeah, I feel like this industry has grown so much in such a short amount of time. And just the fact that somebody was able to bring one feature at one point pushed all the others to keep up. And it's all open source, so I feel like it all started with Trezor, but we have all of these forks, not necessarily direct forks, but responses to what Trezor has done. And the fact that each one of them adds something new to the table pushes everyone else to innovate, possibly take part of that open source code and expand it, improve it, find other use cases for it.
17:44I know that, for example, Coldcard started as a fork of the Trezor but now has moved on to a different kind of source code, and there's just so much going on. And this only means that the fact that they compete so much and they try to hack each other, and sometimes they pay bounties for finding issues and disclosing them, it only means that the rest of us get better security. I feel like since I started exploring this rabbit hole of Bitcoin security, everything is getting so much better and so much simpler for the average user.
18:24It used to be clunky or it used to be stupidly simple, but at the same time not very private or not very secure. But all of the concerns have been addressed in a way that actually improves everything. And today you can have a fully private kind of experience with even the most basic of hardware wallets. If you use the proper software wallet, and you use your full node, then you unlock a lot of possibilities for yourself. And also, I'm plugging Wasabi here, and I know that Electrum also does it.
19:01But what I like about it is that everything is on by default. So you just open it, and it runs Tor in the background, so you don't have to worry about activating that specific port and route it as you do on Electrum, for example. But they also simplified it. Not sure if it's a response to Wasabi, but right now it's just a button, a box there in the settings, and you tick it and you click OK and it's going to use Tor. But I feel like it's still simpler with Wasabi.
19:35And there's so much that I like about it. It makes UTXO management so simple. It prevents address reuse, and it's just so nice, even if you don't CoinJoin, which is another discussion. And I actually want to ask you how and when we're going to be able to CoinJoin directly from our hardware wallets.
19:59Max HillebrandYes, a lot to unpack here. So Wasabi really, the Tor integration is phenomenal. And it's not just that it naively uses Tor, but that it uses multiple Tor identities in parallel to communicate to Bitcoin peers of the general Bitcoin network, and multiple identities to talk to the coordinator about each task separately. So this is some type of separation or virtualization of the identities used to talk to other Bitcoin users and to the CoinJoin coordinator.
20:38We're actually right now doing a massive refactoring of the Tor integration, that is part of a necessary upgrade to make it even more powerful. But yes, Tor is one of the things that Wasabi does phenomenally under the hood, magically in the background, with zero user interaction.
21:00This really is one of the kind of amazing milestones that we've achieved, like with the Wasabi 1.0 release, all the way back in the days. So that's really one of the hallmarks. And hardware wallets, so, hardware wallets are supported currently in Wasabi only for sending and receiving transactions as a single user. So this is just, quote-unquote, "a regular Bitcoin transaction" that you make by yourself without anyone else. And here you can use your hardware wallet. However, with CoinJoin transactions, these multi-user transactions to collaboratively send some Bitcoin, in the current CoinJoin protocol, we are missing some cryptographic protections to ensure that this can be done, to CoinJoin with the coins that are currently stored on your hardware wallet, to spend them in a collaborative Bitcoin CoinJoin transaction. And one important part of the solution to this is integrated now in the WabiSabi CoinJoin implementation that we've been working on for the last year and a half or so.
22:27And here we will be able to securely spend or include an input to a CoinJoin which has the private key stored on a hardware wallet, meaning that you can CoinJoin all the stash that you have basically in your hardware wallet, cold storage, so to say. And this will again improve the security of the whole procedure, I would say, by quite a lot. Just by the fact that people are trusting more Bitcoin onto a hardware wallet than they are comfortable to put on a hot wallet. And with Wasabi 2.0, now you can CoinJoin the Bitcoin that you have on a dedicated hardware wallet device.
23:16Yeah, it removes a lot of attack vectors that might have made users uncomfortable to be part of a CoinJoin now. So this is some very exciting development and it should hopefully be part of the full Wasabi 2.0 release from the first day on.
23:39Vlad CosteaYeah, and there's something else that I want to ask you at this point, because there was a time when everyone, not everyone, but a lot of big names in the Bitcoin space were trying to deter people from using CoinJoins. They were like, "Yeah, they're not ready yet. They're going to get found by chain analysis. Exchanges are going to reject transactions that are connected with CoinJoins." And there was just a lot of misinformation about what CoinJoins are and what they're trying to be. Because I suppose that the expectation mark was set so high that some users thought that, you know, if you CoinJoin, nobody will ever know that you CoinJoined and that you are doing this Bitcoin transaction, so there is zero linkability from your funds to the output of the CoinJoin.
24:34But in reality, there's a lot more to the CoinJoin than this idea of hiding from the government or trying not to pay taxes or, I don't know, mixing stolen exchange funds. You can CoinJoin simply because you don't want somebody who receives the transaction from you to know where you got the money from. So it doesn't have to be a major exchange. It doesn't have to be a government. It just has to be a regular person.
25:05Or if you take your bitcoins from an exchange like Coinbase, and we know that Coinbase has hired Hacking Team, which is a specialized team of people who are best known in their careers for handing freedom fighters to their authoritarian governments. That's what they have done prior to getting acquired by Coinbase. And they are trying to track your transactions even after you leave the exchange, which I think is worrying, and I think is going to become the norm, sadly, and a lot more exchanges are going to follow and use the same kind of in-house blockchain analysis. And for that we need to actually do CoinJoins to prevent them from having a clear history of what everyone does.
25:54The more you obfuscate and the more you mix, the more privacy you're going to have for everyone. And that's something that a lot of people who FUD CoinJoins fail to understand. Maybe they're not perfect at this point, and there's a lot of improvements to be done, and I'm pretty sure that you have a lot to say about Wasabi 2.0, which I know is coming and is going to improve on that ZeroLink technology that zkSNACKs has been good at implementing. So I'm going to let you talk more about it, because I'm sure that there's a lot more to unpack here.
26:31Max HillebrandYes, so to the one aspect that CoinJoin transactions have been censored or mistreated or at least flagged, and that the users of centralized services have, based on their usage of CoinJoin technology, been denied access to a certain service. So the merchant, the entrepreneur was saying here, "Hey, you know, if you pay me with this CoinJoin output, then I simply don't want to work with you," for whatever reason. And I think there are, I think, multiple reasons for such a behavior. In one, it's just not being certain or educated about the nuances and maybe just looking at half of the picture and newsline articles.
27:31But on the other hand, you know, I think that there is a strive for preemptive regulatory obedience, so to say, that entrepreneurs want to show to regulators that, hey, look how much we are actually doing in order to fight financial terrorism or whatever the meme is nowadays, and pointing to such actions as denying to do business with CoinJoin users. But I think that's... Sure, that might work in a regulatory politician game, but ultimately it will lose you users, because I think that more and more people will use the fee savings and privacy benefits of collaborative Bitcoin transactions in the future.
28:18So if you will just deny doing business with someone who pays you with a certain type of money, then yeah, you're gonna lose customers at the end. And we will see where it goes in the future. But ultimately, I think it's none of the business of the entrepreneur to verify the transaction history or to somehow audit the transaction history of the persons that are paying him or that he pays. I think that's totally out of scope for entrepreneurial activity, especially because Bitcoin is a bearer asset instrument.
29:00This is cash with final settlement. It is not a debt certificate as fiat money is. In a debt certificate, yes, of course, you have to check your counterparty because he owes you money, right? He has to pay you in the future. So yes, you want to know who he is and where he got his money and how he's gonna make the money with which he intends to pay you back. But in the Bitcoin system, once I give you my Bitcoin, they're yours, and I cannot take them back. This is not that I owe you money in the future. It's that I just gave you the money proper, the gold coin. I just gave it into your hand, and it's not a debt certificate.
29:37Therefore, the transaction history is completely arbitrary. Because as soon as I have the gold coin in my hands, as soon as the Bitcoin is on a public key where I have the private key to, then nobody else can take that coin other than me. So I don't need to worry about past or future transaction history, because I have the money and, well, that's it. So I think this is again applying old thinking in a debt-based monetary system to the new regime of a hard currency that is a bearer asset, final cash settlement instrument.
30:16And well, frankly, you know, entrepreneurs who make a wrong judgment here and who behave improperly with how economics works, they will be ultimately punished with lower profits and lower user base. And we will see that new companies will pop up that understand how hard money works and what the requirements are to provide useful services in a hard and sound monetary system. And well, I think those companies will flourish. At least that's my hope.
30:51Vlad CosteaI hope so too. And what about Wasabi 2.0? How much about it can you mention?
30:58Max HillebrandYeah, so some of the things we already said, right? So even better Tor support, making everything much more faster and reliable, the more advanced hardware wallet integration, meaning that you can now also CoinJoin with the keys of your hardware wallet, which is great. And there are a couple more interesting things. One is a switch of the CoinJoin algorithm. And that's kind of the big thing that we've been working on and researching for well over two years, or one and a half or something like this, but for a while now.
31:33And we first looked out to find better existing CoinJoin technology than ZeroLink, which is the old CoinJoin technology that is currently implemented in the Wasabi Wallet, you know. And we looked at a bunch of research papers and found out cool new ideas that would be nice to have in the next version of Wasabi. However, none of the implementations and research papers that were existing kind of put it all into a nice cohesive package that is optimal in many regards.
32:05And so we set out to do this in a new research paper and a new CoinJoin algorithm that uses cryptography from other outside research that has not yet been used in the Bitcoin space before. And that is specifically keyed-verification anonymous credentials. Sounds fancy, does a couple of magical things. It's, by the way, the same cryptography that is used in the Signal protocol, where the Signal chat application is one that implements this protocol. It's cool cryptography and well peer reviewed, and it actually works, which is fun.
32:40But what this allows us to do is basically to overcome every downside that we saw in ZeroLink. And so one of the downsides in ZeroLink is that when you register multiple coins, so you have a coin that you received from Alice and another coin that you received from Bob, and you want to CoinJoin both of them together, then right now the coordinator has actually cryptographic proof that one person controls both of these coins together, which is not optimal.
33:15And even an outside observer might find out this information by looking at the amount organization. So ultimately, when you consolidate multiple inputs in a CoinJoin, it's not optimally private. Other people will find out that these coins belong to one user, which, by the way, is the same thing that they would find out if you just consolidate five coins in a regular single-user non-CoinJoin transaction. Then there are just five inputs and one output, that's obvious that one person controlled all of these inputs, right? So ZeroLink improves the situation a bit because it makes it just more ambiguous, because there are so many users together.
33:56But WabiSabi actually makes it cryptographically sound, so that one user can register multiple inputs to the CoinJoin, as many as you want, basically up to a certain limit. And the coordinator, even the coordinator does not find out that one user controls all of these coins. Each of them have independent cryptographic keys and use independent Tor streams and identities to talk to the coordinator. Yeah, there's just, cryptographically, it is a sound zero-knowledge system. And so this enables you to consolidate multiple coins inside a CoinJoin without revealing even to the coordinator that you own all of these coins.
34:46And another nice extension of this is that we no longer need to have a minimum denomination. So right now in Wasabi, we have a 0.1 Bitcoin minimum denomination, meaning that every user who wants to CoinJoin, to be part of this collaborative Bitcoin transaction, he needs to put up 10 million satoshis as an input or up to seven inputs. And the reason for this was, by the way, in the cryptography.
35:18Like, the ZeroLink paper only works if everyone has the same denomination of outputs to be registered. And therefore, you need to have a minimum amount of value of Bitcoin in the inputs. So this was a cryptographic constraint of the ZeroLink protocol, and we're fixing that in WabiSabi too. So now there is no longer a cryptographic constraint on how much Bitcoin you actually have to put into the CoinJoin, which is fantastic. Now, you know, people who have 100 Bitcoin can be part of the same transaction as people who have 100,000 sats.
35:52Right. It's all of a sudden much more inclusive and more people can join this collaborative Bitcoin transaction and, you know, benefit from the fee savings and the privacy benefits. And somewhat of the same side goes also for the output side of the transaction. So ZeroLink again had that restraint that it was only one coin, basically. Only the coin that had the standard denomination output had a cryptographically secure privacy guarantee. Meaning that the coordinator was in zero knowledge when he did all the checks, and he really does not know which user's input links to which user's output of that standard denomination.
36:37But the change output is not included in this cryptographic guarantee. So the coordinator can easily link the input coins to the change output coins of the same user. And not just the coordinator.
36:56Again, with some amount organization analysis and subset sum analysis, people, even outside observers of the Bitcoin blockchain, can see this. Here again, WabiSabi improves it so that there is no link between any input or any output. So there is no longer a concept of standard denominations, and therefore there is no longer enforced standard denominations and a minimum denomination set. And further, there's no change output anymore. We've even changed the output decomposition algorithm so that each output itself looks like a standard denomination. So every output that is created, or almost every output that is created, has another coin that has the exact same value of satoshis.
37:47So there are always multiple coins with the identical value of satoshis, giving them at least some anonset for every single coin, which is quite nice. So again, this creation of change, or toxic change, is completely and fundamentally fixed with WabiSabi and Wasabi 2.0.
38:10And one additional nice benefit or use case to end this rant up with is that now that we no longer have a minimum input requirement and that there's no longer an enforcement of standard output denominations, we can now finally have payments inside the CoinJoin. Meaning that you put, you know, one Bitcoin in the input of the CoinJoin and you put two outputs on the output side: one is an address to the pizza delivery man, and the second is back to you.
38:48This is now possible to do again with the cryptographic guarantee that even the coordinator cannot link your input to the payment output, or even to your change output. So the payment output and the change output again have privacy against the coordinator. He cannot link that these two belong together. And this enables us to do, with some tweaking and more research to do, but at least in concept and hopefully in implementation soon as well, to do payments inside a CoinJoin, which is massive on Bitcoin transaction fee savings, as well as, of course, great privacy improvements and potential usability improvements.
39:31But I think this sums up the multiple benefits of WabiSabi over ZeroLink, and that's one of the pillars of the Wasabi 2.0 release.
39:44Ad voiceoverVaultoro, and that's V-A-U-L-T like a gold vault and O-R-O, oro, which is Spanish for gold, is a gold and Bitcoin exchange, which offers instant swaps between hard money to over 31,000 customers from more than 95 countries. Vaultoro has offered Swiss privacy and security since 2015. Furthermore, the gold you purchase is your legal property, secured in your name, so even if something happens to Vaultoro, even liquidators could not touch your gold. If you want to become the custodian of your own gold bars, you can request to have them delivered to you or simply trade them back to Bitcoin on the dip.
40:35Register for free in only 30 seconds and start trading only with hard money. Please keep in mind that all trading involves risks. This is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.
40:51Vlad CosteaWhen you are using Wasabi Wallet, your internet connection gets routed through the Tor network by default. This means that you get better privacy while using Bitcoin. Download it today at wasabiwallet.io. Yeah, something else that I want to mention in this discussion is that there are some mistakes that you can make after you do CoinJoins.
41:19And it's ideal to avoid them. For example, you can mix your coins and they're going to be split into 0.1 BTC UTXOs. So you're going to have all of these smaller chunks at the end of your CoinJoin, and don't put them together in one transaction, because it defeats the whole purpose of doing the CoinJoin in the first place. Because you have the input, which amounts, let's say, to one Bitcoin, you're going to have 10 outputs of 0.1 BTC, and then you put them all together in one transaction and you have one Bitcoin once again.
41:56And somebody who is smart and knows how to look besides the CoinJoin that took place is going to figure out, you know, this must be the same person, even though there was some mixing involved. This is exactly the same input and output, the same amount, so don't do that ever. Try to deal with the small UTXOs, and with the rising price of Bitcoin, it's likely that you're not going to need like all 10 of them to make one payment. Very unlikely.
42:28Max HillebrandYes, and on one defense, even though when you would consolidate many coins, it is still not trivial to link to your premix inputs, especially when you did a couple rounds of remixes. It's possible, yes, but it still requires a lot of work and assumptions to find a correct guess. So it's difficult to prove it outright. In some cases it is, right? But, and ultimately, nevertheless of how easy it is to attack, this is just another showcase of the shortcomings of the ZeroLink CoinJoin algorithm. That this minimum standard denomination where every user needs to be part of is 0.1 Bitcoin.
43:16So even if you have, you know, 100 Bitcoin that you put into the input of the CoinJoin, then you get one coin worth 0.1 Bitcoin, which is nothing. That's like 0.01% of your stuff. So that's a really, really tiny amount. But that's the amount for which you get the highest level of privacy. And then you get a 0.2 coin, a 0.4 coin, a 0.8 coin, a 1.6 coin, maybe even a 3.2 Bitcoin coin. And then you get a 97 Bitcoin change back.
43:48That's very block space inefficient. We generate a whole bunch of coins. And the reason why we do that is to increase the anonymity set. In Wasabi, every user of a CoinJoin gets the 0.1 Bitcoin denomination. Every user gets that. So this is the maximum potential anonset that we could have had in this round, because every user has at least one of these coins. Right? But that means that these large whales really get fanned out. They end up with thousands of UTXOs in their wallet. And of course they will want to make big transactions.
44:30But if you just received 100 Bitcoin, well, maybe you want to send 50 Bitcoin further on. So yes, you will have to consolidate 500 coins of the 0.1 denominations in order to make that payment. And that again is extremely expensive, to spend so many coins in one transaction. And if you want to do it in a high fee environment, then you are really screwed. And on the other hand, of course, you reduce your privacy a lot, because it reveals the common ownership of all of these coins.
45:00And again, multiple ways that we address that with WabiSabi. For one, it's that again, there is no minimum denomination anymore, right? So, and we no longer decompose the amount from the bottom up, but rather from the top down. So as I explained earlier, right, even if you put 100 Bitcoin into the input, you do get 0.1 Bitcoin out. And then 0.2 and 0.4 and 0.8. So we start at the bottom, that every user gets the 0.1, and then we slowly build upwards.
45:35And with WabiSabi, we flipped that decomposition upside down. So if you have 100 Bitcoin in the input and let's say there is another user who has 150 Bitcoin, right, then the first thing that you would decompose would be something like, for example, 50 Bitcoin. So you get one UTXO with 50 Bitcoin. This is the first UTXO that you get. It's at the top, right? It's no longer 0.1, all the way at the bottom of the pyramid, but it's on the top. Then maybe the next coin you would get is a 0.3. So 0.3 is a bit lower than 0.5. And the third coin you would receive is a 0.2.
46:23I messed up the denominations, but still, I hope you get it. You now receive much larger value coins if you're a whale. And the benefit is much fewer block space is used, because less UTXOs are created. And therefore it is a lot, a lot, a lot cheaper to do CoinJoin transactions all of a sudden. So massive fee savings. And that comes at the cost of a somewhat reduced anonymity set. In the sense that in ZeroLink, again, we enforce that every user gets a 0.1 coin.
47:01So you have to have at least 0.1 Bitcoin to be part of the CoinJoin. And even if you put in 500 Bitcoin, you still get a 0.1 Bitcoin coin. But with WabiSabi, or within Wasabi 2.0, we flipped that upside down, so that if you have 500 Bitcoin, you end up getting 50 Bitcoin coins and you might not even be part of the 0.1 Bitcoin round. If someone brings in just 0.1 Bitcoin in the input, then he does not benefit from the anonset of the whale itself, right?
47:38Because the whale is in the 50 Bitcoin denomination, while the small user is in the 0.1 Bitcoin denomination. Now, there is still some flowing of the anonset in between these denomination pools, but ultimately here we will see a lower k-anonymity set number for each of the denominations. And we hope that we have other smart privacy-preserving decomposition methods implemented, and we might talk about them in just a second, that justify this trade-off between saving on mining fees and still having a decent anonymity set. Right.
48:24Vlad CosteaAnd you mentioned something about decomposing that you want to mention next. But what I was about to ask you right now is, are you aware of how many steps you need to take? I mean, how many transactions you need to do after a CoinJoin so that exchanges get fooled into thinking that that was in the past? Because I've heard something about five transactions past the CoinJoin and they don't care anymore what happened in the past.
48:54Max HillebrandI mean, that's, again, very arbitrary. Like, it depends on that business, on when he starts to want to make business with you again. Yeah, maybe something like, well, at least more than one transaction. So probably starting at two, it's worth trying. But you see the problem here, again, is just immense Bitcoin block space usage, and especially if you want to do it right.
49:20I mean, you can make stupid transactions that are one input, one output transactions, and you make four or five of these transactions, and yes, that might fool the chain analysis tool of the business to thinking that this is no longer the CoinJoin user owning that coin. But it should be pretty obvious that it probably still is. So if you want to do it right, you will need to fan out and do some fake payment-looking type transactions, which means, for example, having one input, one coin in the input and two coins in the output of the transaction.
50:02But this again means more UTXO creation, meaning more block space used, meaning more mining fees for you and more verification costs for everyone. So for me personally, I don't like these self-spend techniques, just because in the trade-off, considering on-chain mining costs and verification costs, that's just not justifiable for me. So for me personally, I just would stop doing business with those entrepreneurs who think that protecting your privacy is a crime.
50:33Vlad CosteaYeah, it makes a lot of sense. So what about the fragmentation that you have mentioned prior?
50:42Max HillebrandYes, so there... To really get into the nitty-gritty of this amount decomposition would certainly be too far to go into. Also because I'm not that well versed with it. But for example, Yuval Kogman is doing phenomenal work on articulating this, and it's being implemented now in the Wasabi code. But yeah, I forget the exact same numbers, but we really have gathered massive fee savings in the sense of much fewer UTXOs being created by everyone. And so this comes from two facts. First, we can consolidate the inputs while preserving the privacy, right?
51:29Meaning that we consume more coins that don't need to be spent in the future, so to say, right? So we can turn five coins into one. And you could do such a consolidation CoinJoin, for example, in a low fee environment. So it might be that if you see that the current fees are low, then Wasabi might be smart enough to automatically consume more coins in this CoinJoin, just to save on fees in the future. This, for example, is now possible.
52:09And one of the other interesting things that is also part of the cryptography is the fee payment. Because there are two fees to be paid in a CoinJoin transaction. For one is the Bitcoin mining fee. And this is verified by the coordinator. So the coordinator ensures that every user provides more inputs, more satoshis in the input of the transaction than he does on the output of the transaction. And this is done with some cryptographic magic to know that everyone is putting in more money than he takes out.
52:48And this leftover is the fee rate that goes to the Bitcoin miner. So this is how the first fee is paid, here with the verification of the coordinator that everyone pays his fees and that nobody is basically stealing. Well, actually, and clients can verify the end result too, by the way. But the other fee that is being paid is to the coordinator, meaning that the users who provide inputs and outputs to this CoinJoin pay the coordinator a certain fee for, yeah, for providing this service. And in WabiSabi, we have again figured out how to do some nice things with the fees, especially in terms of fee discounts and how we can use financial incentives to reward high-quality privacy users.
53:45So one great example is that remixing, so being part of a CoinJoin like twice in a row, right? So you CoinJoin and receive a 100 anonset coin. And then you CoinJoin it again and you receive a 200 anonset coin, something like that. This is very useful for every user of the CoinJoin. However, if multiple users of CoinJoin number A remix in CoinJoin number B, then this reduces the optimal privacy that we could have gained. It would have been better if each of these coins from the first round of CoinJoin would have been remixed in a separate round in the future.
54:32Just so that the anonymity set fans out more, so to say. And with WabiSabi, we have some long-term fee incentives so that, for example, a coin that is, let's say, 50 days old, right? So it was created in a CoinJoin two months ago. This coin, when it is now registered in a CoinJoin, and when no other coin of this CoinJoin from back in the day is registered in this current round, then this user does not pay any coordinator fees. Or he pays lower coordinator fees.
55:15Or maybe even he gets a discount on the mining fees. That where then other users who would like to have this old coin that has not yet been remixed, and where no other coin is being remixed from that CoinJoin, that this is now part of this current today's CoinJoin, maybe other users are even willing to pay a couple sats to this coin so that he does not have to pay for the mining fee. So there are a lot of interesting, well, financial incentive structures that we can experiment with to reward higher quality, privacy-conscious CoinJoins, and I think that's a very interesting avenue to go down to.
56:02But yeah, still a lot of research and work in progress. We will see how that will continue to advance.
56:09Vlad CosteaRight. So how do you see the future of Bitcoin privacy? Because maybe that we're not going to hard fork to a new chain to get confidential transactions or something like ring signatures, because they don't really scale anyway. But there are so many developments, starting from the Lightning Network, which is a lot more private and uses something very much like Tor to route transactions. And we also have sidechains. There is Liquid, which has the confidential transactions, but as more of a custodial experience. And then you have, what are they called?
56:47Drivechain, I think, by Paul Sztorc. And he also designed something like Zcash on his sidechain, big blocks and zk-SNARKs and zero-knowledge proofs and all of that. He uses it, and it's going to be fully functional and available for users who want to add up more privacy to their transactions. So it's interesting that as we scale in layers, there's more privacy that gets added to some of the most important layers that get developed. So how do you see the future of this? And do you think that it's still important for us to have more on-chain privacy? I mean main chain.
57:33Max HillebrandI think that second layer technologies are extremely interesting. Let's focus on Lightning Network at first. The beauty of it is here that we can make non-custodial Bitcoin transactions in a way that not everyone has to verify that the transaction happened. Yet still, we are in financial consensus of who owns how much money. That's the genius of the Lightning Network, to make payments without everyone needing to verify them. And that's quite a genius, genius idea, once you look at it from that light. And it's incredibly useful, right?
58:11Because less verification means more scalability. And especially payments inside a single payment channel, you know, happen as soon as you can make cryptographic signatures, which is multiple thousands of times per second. So here, payments inside the payment channel, trivial. Even routed payments are much more scalable just by the fact that only the peers of the route need to know about this transaction, while everyone else does not. It's a very powerful concept and will help Bitcoin to scale privately very nicely. Sidechains come in many variants, and...
58:52They are, I would say, always custodial, if you look at it from a base layer perspective, because you give away your Bitcoin to some other script that you do not control. Now, this outside script might be, for example, in Liquid, a 12, like 11 out of 15 multi-signature amongst this federation, right? A group of companies who signed legal contracts to ensure the custodianship of these Bitcoin held, right? And they use these Bitcoin multisig scripts as part of that, and hardware secure modules and all of the stuff.
59:39It's basically a fancy Bitcoin warehouse, a money warehouse, a vault where you can put your Bitcoin, and that those entrepreneurs have full control over your Bitcoin, right? They can spend it at whim, and you can no longer, right? So you always have to ask for them to actually spend that Bitcoin. So it is custodial. But what you receive in exchange is a money certificate, right? For example, the L-BTC token on the Liquid sidechain. And this, you can trade this token even to others, right? And this can then... But you're basically trading money substitutes, IOU certificates, so to say.
1:00:18You're not trading Bitcoin money proper, which is okay, right? Especially because these money certificate systems can be outside of the Bitcoin consensus scope. You're no longer trading Bitcoin, right? You're trading some sidechain token, and the sidechain can have a very different consensus model, as for example, Liquid does, right? Block signing by federated, agreed-upon members, right? You can still verify these rules by running a Liquid node. But still, they are very different rules, and they are much easier to change, or the procedure to change them is very different than that of Bitcoin proper. There are other proposals, like, for example, drivechains, where the custodianship or the control of the Bitcoin on the base layer does not go into a federation.
1:01:15Per se, so that a certain pre-agreed-upon group of people have control over that Bitcoin on-chain, but rather, it goes into somewhat of a trust or a contract where the miners are required to verify the consensus of the sidechain, and when they uphold the consensus of the sidechain, then they cannot steal the money, if I understand it correctly. But here there is still some trust that miners could, in fact, somehow spend or at least withhold and censor transactions of these Bitcoin that are held in that custodianship.
1:02:04So it's more of a decentralized approach, but there are some nuances in the security model that have to be considered. I would like to refer you to Ruben Somsen, who does some outstanding research in the sidechain space. And he has some sophisticated arguments that have to be considered in regards to Drivechain. So he has probably much more to say than me.
1:02:27Vlad CosteaOh, yeah. And he also came up with statechains, which have different purposes. He came up with a different sidechain for all the ideas and all the proposals that he has. So I should get Ruben on the show sometime to talk about sidechains.
1:02:43Max HillebrandAnd shameless shill and humble brag, the Wasabika podcast has an episode with Ruben Somsen, where we go into spacechains and softchains and spork chains and all of the chains that he's working on. It's quite fascinating. It's very interesting, cutting-edge research on how to create Bitcoin banks, basically. Like, these are, I kind of like to think of them as money warehouses. And we can use the cryptographic assurances of Bitcoin to provide much, much, much more secure and solid custodianship than was ever possible before. It really is quite breathtaking and a very important part of Bitcoin that should be developed more, because solid and secure custodianship is something that is extremely useful and that will satisfy many needs, that I think is worthy to work on further.
1:03:47Ad voiceoverHey, psst, hey, what's your plan for the next Bitcoin top? Unless you need the money to purchase something, you probably should not touch infinitely inflationary fiat. Check out Vaultoro and figure out to which extent hard money like gold and silver can help you preserve your purchasing power. You will be able to get back into Bitcoin as soon as the price hits a new bottom, and you will not be subjected to the arbitrary, inflation-driven volatility of fiat or fiat-backed coins. Obviously, this is not financial advice, and you should understand that all trading involves risks.
1:04:38Vlad CosteaWasabi Wallet connects to your full Bitcoin node. And if you're not running one, it downloads block filters anonymously via Tor. In either case, you're getting excellent privacy. Download the software today at wasabiwallet.io. I feel like I can put up a very popular tweet out of your statements and say something like, "Sidechains are the real decentralized exchanges." Phew. Just that, send tweet, and it's gonna get like 100 likes, 50 retweets or something. Because really, if you have sidechains where people actually use money in a different way and maybe under a different security, what do you call it?
1:05:32Max HillebrandSecurity assumptions or trade-offs.
1:05:34Vlad CosteaYeah, assumption. Under a different security assumption, it's just mind-blowing, because you're going to have trade-offs that you decide for yourself. You're gonna be like, okay, so this sidechain has very good privacy, nobody's going to know what I'm up to, but at the same time, this one has faster settlements and allows me to deal with this exchange and this and that. And at the same time, what blows my mind is that you can add the Lightning Network on top of everything and basically turn Lightning into a highway.
1:06:08And you can go on and off from the base layer to Liquid right now with the Lightning Network and make quick, instant exchanges. So actually, that's the true decentralized exchange, the Lightning Network itself. It's just that we need nicer user interfaces for this to happen. And we need people to give up on shitcoins and figure out that, you know, if it's important and it's going to be successful on the long term, then it's getting built on Bitcoin.
1:06:41Max HillebrandYes, I like to think so, but it's difficult to build it on Bitcoin because we want to do it right. And the beauty of shitcoin is that you can just hack on a thing for a weekend and call it done and raise a billion dollars in your ICO, right? So that's a bit of a different mindset. But no, I agree, and I think, you know, experimenting also with these multiple layers is interesting. But, you know, always keep your security in mind. And base Base layer Bitcoin is the base money. This is the real thing, like the money proper, as Austrian economists would say.
1:07:18So always compare if you can actually control money proper or if you cannot. Like for example, in Lightning Network, you can. You can control Bitcoin on the base layer chain in a way that only you can spend them, or that at least you could punish anyone who tries to steal these coins, which is the design model of the Lightning Network. You actually have control over these coins and you are the owner of base money.
1:07:45But as soon as we are going into these sidechains, then this is in fact a money substitute. It is no longer base money, but a claim on base money. And if there is a two-way peg where you can redeem those sidechain tokens for base layer Bitcoin on the blockchain again. And interesting here that even so, there can be two models here where we have that federation who allows these redemptions, these peg-outs of the sidechain, or this can be in the drivechain model, consensus rules enforced by miners, so to say, of who can peg out these coins, but...
1:08:31Yeah, so again, there are really interesting ways to further research this and to make it more secure. And I'm wondering if these peg-out transactions will continue to trade at par with base money Bitcoin, in the sense that if Vlad has LBTC and I have real BTC, will we find each other on a decentralized market and exchange the money substitute for the money proper? And what is the exchange rate among these two tokens? Because if it is at par, then we are talking about an actual money certificate, as Murray Rothbard would describe it.
1:09:12But if there is a premium, for example, where, you know, LBTC are cheaper than BTC. Like, if you have one BTC, you will get 1.1 LBTC, for example. Then here, this would indicate a premium on the money certificate. And I would argue that one of the causes of this would be uncertainty in either the technology itself, but especially the ability of the federation to continue to redeem the money certificates for the base money proper, basically a bank run, right? And we will see how this will evolve over longer time spans. But yes, this is like radically new economic banking in cyberspace with sound money Bitcoin. It is absolutely exciting.
1:10:09Vlad CosteaYeah. And at the same time, we don't really want these to get too successful, because otherwise there are going to be fewer transactions on the base layer, and this might compromise the security of Bitcoin on the base layer. We want the one megabyte blocks to get filled so that miners have the proper incentives. And even though the transactions are going to be channel openings or peg-ins or peg-outs, it's still required for transactions to happen to a certain degree.
1:10:43Max HillebrandYeah, but I wonder though, even if we would go dramatically into this multi-layered scaling approach, I mean, at any decently meaningful user base, we will still have full blocks. I mean, right now, you know, even me on the Lightning Network, I still make a bunch of on-chain transactions. Like one person maybe, I don't know, for running a decent Lightning node, maybe 5 Bitcoin transactions per month, something like this, right? That's massive. That times 8 billion people plus machines and such, right? So that would already be...
1:11:27Many, many, many full blocks. So I even wonder, even with this hyper-layered approach, how often the individual user will end up actually going back on chain just because of the general high demand to be in the block space. I don't envision a world where we will actually have empty blocks for a sustained time, if there's actually usage of Bitcoin even on higher layers.
1:12:00Vlad CosteaYeah, obviously, if there's more use on second layers and sidechains, then we're going to see actors who realize, you know, this is much more secure. It might not be private, but it's a lot more secure, so let me use this inexpensive block space for whatever. To open channels, to do CoinJoins or something. So I suppose that there's always going to be someone who's interested in using that block space, but we have to not disincentivize it. I think that's the right word for it. So I think that Lightning transactions are superior in so many ways.
1:12:40Maybe except for security, because they're not secured by such a large network with such a well-developed mining operation to secure every single operation, and also all the nodes that validate everything and verify every single operation that goes on chain. It's kind of mind-blowing to realize how far we have gone in the span of 12 years and how many full nodes are out there, both in Tor and in Clearnet. It's just impressive. And it's all user driven, so that's something that I like about Bitcoin.
1:13:17In shitcoins, it's all coordinated by the founders. And they're trying to even pay the ones who participate in community events and development features and even creating memes. I know that the Ethereum Foundation, for example, is financing people who spend a lot of time on social media evangelizing for Ethereum. And there are a bunch of people that you find on Twitter who mostly steal Bitcoiners' memes and adapt them for Ethereum, and they get paid, which I find amusing at best. So Bitcoin has no marketing department and everything is grassroots and driven by users who say, you know, I don't like this.
1:14:01I want to build something better. And most of the times they're not even paid for it. They do it out of their free will, with their free time, and they expect that in the future it's going to acquire some sort of use that's going to bring in some returns, maybe. Or if they didn't, they're so happy with the ride in Bitcoin and what it brought into their lives that they even can take the financial loss, you know, just because they were able to develop something nice. And today, for example, we have a Telegram group that's called Rings of Fire.
1:14:37I'm not sure if you're in it, but we like to say that we build the roads for the Lightning Network. And we open channels with each other in a circular way, so that all of us are connected to all the others. But at the same time, there's going to be routing if somebody wants to go through us. And we also try to eliminate single points of failure by drawing, what do you call them, like a diagonal line from one circle end to the other. I think it's called a diameter. So we have diameter connections, just in case one of the routes is offline at one point, just in case that happens, and it just keeps on expanding and getting bigger.
1:15:27And it's still the early days. But at the same time, you realize, you know, these people are just hobbyists and enthusiasts and people who want to see Bitcoin and the Lightning Network develop. And you're not going to find this anywhere else, and this is why I'm so bullish on this. Because you have people who have true conviction on the success of this project.
1:15:49Max HillebrandYes, and it's not just that, you know, we cannot print more Bitcoin in order to pay for marketing as Ethereum likes to do. And so that's not even the one thing, right? But instead, actual businesses, you know, people who use Bitcoin to get paid, right, who provide goods and services, these people are even willing to spend more Bitcoin on hiring people to do advertisement that is good for the Bitcoin space in general. I mean, there are many companies like that, but zkSNACKs, the company developing Wasabi, is one of them.
1:16:23And so this, I think, is really promising, that we have companies that are willing to spread the good message about Bitcoin and to help educate users in as many forums and platforms as possible. This is, you know, it shows even more of the dedication. Not just can nobody, you know, steal from each other to do the marketing, but instead you actually have to pay yourself to get it done. But still, so many people do it. So it really shows the rigor and the heart of the community.
1:16:57Vlad CosteaOh, yeah. And I suppose this is how I ended up getting sponsored by Wasabi. Because I think it was International Education Day or something, and I saw a tweet by the Wasabi account, and it was like, "If you provide anything educational in the Bitcoin space, we might support you." And I was like, "Yeah, OK, I've been promoting running your full node and using Wasabi for a long time, and I would do it even if I don't get sponsored." But I'm so happy that we found a way to work it out.
1:17:28And find some way that's mutually convenient for me to promote Wasabi and to also make some money out of it, which is always nice. There's a lot of, you know, when people step into this space for the first time during a bull market and they see all of us, they think, "Oh, these guys must be so rich, they must be loaded. They must be making so much money out of that." But in reality, it doesn't really apply. Most of us are just enthusiasts and run at a loss and use our free time to explain something, write articles, do podcasts, make videos, and create all of this content that makes it easier for others to understand.
1:18:11And in their own turn, they're going to end up creating a podcast or setting up a website, a Medium account or something, just to explain some concepts to people who are close to them and near to them. And I think this is how adoption scales, at least in my idea of adoption. I don't think we're going to rely too much on top leaders, but we're going to decentralize everything and have smaller influencers all over the world who translate, who explain to their local communities how this works.
1:18:47And this is how it's going to happen. I don't think we should rely too much on big influencers and hype men and, you know, these Pomp types who come up with nice memes that everyone ends up using on Twitter. At the end of the day, adoption is spread by the average user who just likes what this is about and believes in it. And once again, something that makes me so bullish and so enthusiastic about Bitcoin is the fact that the community is real and the development is real, and everyone is just so convinced about what this is and what kind of mission it has. As opposed to everyone being incentivized by money, everyone is incentivized by ideals, and I think that's a lot stronger.
1:19:42Max HillebrandYes, for sure. It's kind of weird that we're here building a money, but so to say, we're not really in it for the money. I think having such a grand vision of what a world would be like if we had Bitcoin and what individuals could do if that tool were widespread, and what this would mean for, well, everything. Once you get that and understand that, it gets kind of hard, if not impossible, to actually, like, you know, not spend your time on Bitcoin. The opportunity cost of not spending your time on Bitcoin is literally to, you know, stand back and see the world go up in flames.
1:20:30So that's a very strong motivation to not be idle and not to be lazy, but to get up and do stuff and be part of building the solution to a very, very difficult problem that we've gotten ourselves into, and that is fiat money and hyperinflation. So yes, Bitcoin is very much a tool that can be used for, well, you know, being active and saying no to systems of tyranny that are harmful to literally everyone. And once that is understood, yeah, who cares about making money? I would rather be a poor free man than a fiat-rich slave.
1:21:16So I'm very happy to sacrifice some of my potential income and even, you know, investing my actual Bitcoin stash into building out this technology further.
1:21:29Vlad CosteaOh yeah, and that's something that I appreciate in people like you and everyone who invests in Bitcoin projects and education. There is so much that should be done and there's so much education that needs to be done. Because in the case of Bitcoin, and I guess we can both agree that understanding how the technology works is not necessarily the end game, but at the same time, you need to understand how it works. It's like a double-edged sword. You also need to understand why this exists, what kind of potential it has, why it was created in the first place. Because I like to think that the message that Satoshi has left in the Genesis block is very much characteristic and definitive for the purpose of this invention. "Chancellor on the brink of second bailout for banks."
1:22:25I mean, how much more political can that get? It's basically saying this is a way to fight against fiat inflation and bailouts and all of this financial system that got out of control, is no longer accountable for the people that it's supposed to represent. And it will only get worse. So there is this invention that can help you start anew from a new system and have something fresh and fair and verifiable and transparent and based on actual work. Because that's another debate these days. I just saw, so I have Twitter open, and something popped in my feed about Ethereum making...
1:23:14Its transactions and its operations like 10,000 times cheaper by moving to proof of stake. And I was like, okay, but you're not really producing anything. You're not externalizing any kind of resource or any kind of actual work into securing the network. There's no production there. And what they're doing is highly experimental. There is no proof ever. And we haven't had one, and I'm pretty sure that if we had any conclusive evidence that proof of stake is more secure than proof of work, we would be using it and we would be like, "Yeah, sure, let's give up on mining because it's not the most efficient way to secure."
1:23:58But we figured out that entropy and the laws of physics are a lot more functional and provide better and more predictable security elements as opposed to something that not only is experimental, but has no grounds in the laws of physics. It's not very scientific. It's more ideological and more about having a dream about something, as opposed to proving and doing actual science and research. And I think I got sidetracked a little bit, but what I want to say with this is that I very much appreciate the kind of development that we are undergoing.
1:24:44And I think that there's also an ideological component that got diluted over time, so I don't think that the Bitcoiners getting in today are just as strongly willed and strong in opinions against maybe the government or tyranny or these ideas. I feel like this new wave of 2020, 2021 newcomers is more about the gains and worshiping people like Michael Saylor. And I think, and I hope actually, that it's going to change. And they're going to understand what this is about and why we are here and what we are trying to do.
1:25:26But, you know, we can only hope for the best. I wouldn't want to get involved or stay involved in a project that's about worshiping people, you know? I think that's one of the roots of anarchism. Anarchy doesn't mean chaos. I think you have something very nice on your website, a very nice definition of anarchy, that it doesn't reject rules. It just rejects rulers, and it starts from the assumption that we are all equal and we should work as such and function as a society in a fair way which doesn't create single points of failure that become tyrannical.
1:26:05Max HillebrandYes, exactly. And so it comes from the Greek, right, anarchy. "An" meaning "without" and "archon," "rulers." But I would like to say that it is not about not having hierarchies. There are still hierarchies in anarchy. But they are not hierarchies of power. It is not a coercion-based system where people are forced to do something against their free will and consent. Rather, it is hierarchies of competency, that some people have mastered a subject in the sense of being competent and excelling at it. Right. So, for example, nopara73 is a better coder than I am.
1:26:55That's in fact because I cannot code. So he's much superior in coding per se than I am. And there is nothing wrong with having this hierarchy. Quite on the contrary, it's essential and very good, because then nopara73 can do the stuff that I cannot do. It's very helpful to have a hierarchy amongst people. But again, it's a hierarchy of competence, with the ability that anyone can move up the hierarchy. I could become a good coder and even better than nopara73, likely. Well, if I would sit down like 16 hours a day and do nothing else but coding, as nopara73 tends to do. But it would be possible if I put my work into it.
1:27:42And that's another of the beautiful aspects of anarchy, is that nobody can stop you from manifesting and expressing yourself freely into the fullest.
1:27:55Vlad CosteaYeah, I very much agree, and there are nuances to this. And by the way, the next season is going to be about philosophy. This was Joshua's suggestion, to do something about the philosophy of Bitcoin and maybe help some newcomers understand what this is about and what kind of ideals people have. You know, the first wave of Bitcoiners was mostly gold bugs and Ron Paul advocates and people who supported his campaign, and libertarians. I think this was the main audience for Bitcoin. But after that, as the price started to increase, it became much more of a "number go up" excuse or something.
1:28:39Something that people were using just because they had expectations to hedge against inflation, to make more money, buy a new house, get a Lambo or something like that. And I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with that, but we should still have some sort of education about principles. And I don't think that the project can succeed unless we have this conviction about what it's supposed to be doing, as opposed to using it as a Lambo tool or, you know, selling our coins so the Michael Saylors of the world can buy them.
1:29:14Max HillebrandYeah, absolutely. You know, as you said, spending your money is an inherent part of the protocol, and spending it on a Lambo, I mean, why not? But yes, the principles are essential. Especially because the individual Bitcoin user creates the Bitcoin consensus rules himself and he enforces them and he verifies everything. These are tasks that the individual must do in order that Bitcoin even exists for him. And if you don't run a full node and you don't have your own keys, then you do not have Bitcoin.
1:29:52And you're trusting someone else that he's telling the truth to you. But that is very much different from verifying your exclusive ownership over the UTXO set. So yes, if people do not have an understanding of the fundamental principles and the vision that Bitcoin stands for, the story of potential that it tells, then users will, well, not care, and then they will not create the rules and verify them and enforce them, and then Bitcoin ceases to exist. So yes, this is a philosophical struggle as well, and it's great that you are dedicating your next season to it. I'm very eager to listen to that.
1:30:48Vlad CosteaOh yeah. And if you want to talk more about the philosophy of anarchy and what it's all about, and also some Austrian economics, I suppose I should get you once again.
1:30:56Max HillebrandThat would be fantastic. I would love to.
1:31:01Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I mean, the last time we spoke, I think it was in season five or six. And you were very much on fire with all of your statements, and you were speaking about how you are fighting with software tools against all of your enemies. And when I asked you about the situation with Samourai Wallet, you were like, "I don't mind them. I don't consider them to be my enemies. My enemies have strong weapons and we must defeat them with open source software." And that was so motivating. I very much enjoyed that.
1:31:34And maybe we can capture some more of that, but in the context of ideological conviction and why we are here, because that's a question that I ask myself all the time. And I ask about other people sometimes, like, why is this person even here if they don't get it? And I suppose there is a certain degree of excuses that you can make in regards to not getting it, because you are introduced by the wrong people and you never had the chance to really understand what this is about.
1:32:12But that's why I guess we try to develop educational tools to understand what Bitcoin stands for. And of course, as everything else in this life, it's important to also make a purpose out of it that's personal, not just listen to everyone else's stories and be like, "Yeah, I'm going to embrace that." Find your own purpose and figure out, because this is sovereign money and sovereignty is not necessarily taught. You need to understand what you need in this life and what you expect to happen. So there's also that component, but at the same time this is unlike anything else that we have had.
1:32:52It's different from gold. It's different from what we have had under the gold standard. It's a lot more sovereign in the sense that you get to manage and hold your own wealth. And a lot of people are scared of that. And I think I've had a conversation with somebody who told me that he keeps his coins on Kraken because they're insured. And I was like, "You know that that's a huge honeypot, right?" And if you get the insurance money, and there's a huge emphasis on "if," then it's going to be fiat, so you're never going to see your bitcoins back.
1:33:31It's not like they can find enough Bitcoin so that they can reimburse all of their customers. They're just going to print enough fiat to reimburse you. And by the time you are able to buy some Bitcoin, it's going to be a lot more expensive. So you're going to find fewer Bitcoins that you can buy with the same amount of fiat that you get reimbursed.
1:33:56And a lot of people don't understand that self-custody entails smaller risks from the outside, because if you have obviously smaller amounts than an exchange, the incentive to attack you and try to figure out your security mechanism and break into your wallet is a lot smaller.
1:34:14And if you know what you're doing, they're not going to come after you anyway, because you're going to have such small UTXOs, stored on different wallets and possibly multisigs and Shamir backups and all of that stuff, so that nobody is going to be able to figure out how many coins you have. And that's one important component of sovereignty. And this also applies in real life with securing your goods.
1:34:43You don't want to stand out. You don't want to be flashy. You don't want regular criminals to look at you and say, "You know, this is a potential target." The idea is to blend in and live a fairly decent life, not necessarily lavish or excessive. Just be able to live a free and dignified and good life under these circumstances. So there's a lot of education to be done in this regard. I don't expect everyone to agree, but I hope that there will be people who will learn from this ideological component of Bitcoin.
1:35:24Max HillebrandYes, and for many people, probably for most people, getting a lot of money really fast is very bad for you. Like, you're gonna be crushed with, you know, lots of parties and lots of drugs, and the hangover is gonna be quite harsh. You know, you see that with lottery winners, for example, who all of a sudden get a whole bunch of money, and if they do not have their life sorted out before getting the money, then with high likelihood getting the money will not help them to sort their life out, and instead it will help them to make wrong choices at larger scales.
1:36:05And that's usually very reckless. So that will happen in Bitcoin too. People will hoard a whole bunch of Bitcoin and they will get exuberantly rich and then spend it all on stupid things. And they won't get their Bitcoin back, right? And then it's gone. So yes, in any case, regardless of what your money is, sort out your life, find principles and build a vision of where you want to go, and then live by that and act it out. Bitcoin can help you to do that. I think Bitcoin, and we see this across so many Bitcoiners, that Bitcoin is fundamentally realigning your perspective, changing your assumptions and reconfiguring your priorities.
1:36:56And your entire value hierarchy is turned, flipped upside down. And things that were meaningless before, like reading books about monetary history, is all of a sudden the most important thing that you could possibly do, to just learn as much about Bitcoin as possible. So I think this is one of the beautiful things, that Bitcoin, as people enter with that get-rich-quick scheme that they will perceive just because they don't have things figured out before, it kicks them down the Bitcoin rabbit hole.
1:37:35And hopefully many of them, or at least some, will stumble upon the philosophical core that Bitcoin stands for, and that this will help them to articulate a better vision of their selves and what they actually want to do in this world, and therefore, hopefully, for them to make better choices that make a more meaningful impact for themselves and their loved ones.
1:38:08Bitcoin is magical like that. Somehow it does these types of things to many people. And I'm not exactly sure why, but it's, I think, a very good thing, because questioning the question and checking your assumptions is critical, and it seems that many have not done that for a very long time. So getting shaken by Bitcoin and getting your values realigned might just be the thing that you need.
1:38:42Vlad CosteaAlso something that happens naturally once you get into Bitcoin and you witness all of the wild price swings is that you lower your time preference. Like, at some point you become numb and you don't care as much about the daily volatility. So you're going to lower your time preference, and that's going to change a lot of aspects of your life. And once you figure out that this has happened to you, and you try to evaluate what is important to you and what is not, it helps you get your life in order.
1:39:20For a while at least. You're also right in regards to people who get rich very fast and then spend on a lifestyle that they cannot sustain and that doesn't make them happy anyway. This has happened to a lot of Bitcoiners, especially early on, like they just bought some internet money. They had no idea how it works, or they mined it, or they wanted to buy drugs and they forgot to buy the drugs and then five years later they realized that they're millionaires or something. So, yeah. There's nothing you can change about this.
1:39:58Like, it's their own will. It's likely that they would have done the same if it was any other kind of money that they received. But it's still unfortunate, you know. It's easy to say, okay, so thank you for selling us your Bitcoin so they can end up in stronger hands. But it's still unfortunate.
1:40:19Max HillebrandYeah, but that's also the beauty of free money, that it moves towards those who provide more value for others. Right? Like if you know, got rich on Bitcoin and then you want to get your Lambo. Well, what this shows is that the person who produced the Lambo was extremely useful for you. He produced the thing that you wanted to have. And he, in fact, gave you more value than the 10 Bitcoins that it costs. And so the 10 Bitcoin just moved from the guy who got rich quickly to the guy who built this extremely intricate and nuanced, powerful machine that can be driven in without it exploding, which is somewhat of a miracle.
1:41:01But. So, yes, in a sound monetary environment, money does flow to the strongest hands. Or in other words, it flows to those who create the most value for others. And that's amazing. That is, again, a hierarchy that is aligned with good incentives. That those who do more work for others gain in the purchasing power of the money. You earn more percentage of the money supply you control, and you can choose on where to spend it on later, for the services that other people provide you that are more valuable than the money is to you. Like, it's an extremely beautiful system in this regard.
1:41:47Vlad CosteaOh yeah, and something else about which I like to talk is that, you know, people get upset when they see the price dumping, and I'm like, can you show me another money system where you can liquidate so fast? And you say, I want to take out my money and exchange it for something else. And you can do it within a few minutes. Like, it's insane. If you go to the bank and you sign some forms and say, "I want to withdraw all of the money that I have in this account," they're going to be like, yeah, so it's going to take like a week or two.
1:42:19Are you sure you don't want to talk to our manager? And we're going to do our best to talk you out of it and present to you a better option and maybe raise a little bit the interest rate in your account to convince you to stay. And it's not like they have the liquidity if you have a lot of money. So they're going to need to collect some money before being able to give it to you because they run with fractional reserves. But with Bitcoin, it's almost instant.
1:42:49You just wait for at least one on-chain confirmation and you have successfully moved the wealth somewhere else. So if you want to get rid of your position and move into something else like gold, like silver, like fiat money, anything, it's just so fast. And the fact that it can go up and down at such a rapid pace is just an indication that this is still a free market.
1:43:20Max HillebrandYes, and, you know, requesting a stable purchasing power is basically saying in Bitcoin's context to mandate a certain demand for the money, right? Because price is always supply and demand. Well, supply is limited, but demand is crazy. It's crazy for every asset. Today you want to have the Lamborghini, tomorrow you don't, right? With anything, demand is highly volatile, as subjective individual values are highly volatile. The beautiful thing of Bitcoin is its stable money supply. It has nothing to do with the demand. Demand is always volatile. Where Bitcoin shines in stability is its monetary base.
1:44:1821 million Bitcoin, and there has been never anything that could have given these types of guarantees of a limited and, it's even more crazy, a predictable money supply, where it increases slowly in liquid Bitcoin available, based on, you know, time passing at a predictable rate with proof of work and the difficulty adjustment. Monumentally genius ideas that make Bitcoin by far, by incredibly far, the most stable monetary asset to ever have existed. You go to bed and you have one out of 21 million Bitcoin. And you wake up in the morning and you still have one out of 21 million Bitcoin. That's ridiculous. That has never happened before. That you can wake up and your money has not decayed one bit.
1:44:59It's absolutely baffling, and this level of stability will enhance the economic productivity and the finesse and depth of nuances in the resource allocation of this global economy than anything we've ever seen. Having such a stable money is revolutionary in and of itself. But of course, because the fiat shitcoin is absolutely volatile in its monetary supply, printing 6, 15, 30, 50% new coins every year, which is ridiculous, at completely unpredictable events and rates that are just decided at the whim of a couple bureaucrats and central planners.
1:45:44The supply is volatilely crazy. And of course, if you measure the exchange rate between a monetary asset that is extremely volatile in supply, like the fiat coins, and a monetary asset that is extremely predictable and stable in monetary supply, well, yes, of course, the exchange rate is going to fluctuate highly. That's not a fault of Bitcoin. That's a fault of the fiat system, which is hyperinflating into oblivion at a rate that nobody could comprehend or even keep up with adjusting their prices. While, for example, entrepreneurs like me who denominate their contracts in Bitcoin charge the same prices for the last couple months, right?
1:46:27My Socratic seminars go at 250,000 sats per month. That price has not changed for many, many months. The value of Bitcoin, for me, is the same. It did not change. You know, you get an hour of my time for 250,000 sats. That's how much Bitcoin is worth to me. And that's the same way that I have charged for the last half year or so.
1:46:55Vlad CosteaYeah, there's a lot to mention about how Bitcoin changes your way of perceiving both value and time, and how you end up valuing your time in a whole different way. When you have something which has a steady and predictable supply and a demand which tends to vary, but at the same time if you are a long-term believer in the project, you don't care much about the demand. You know that your time is worth this amount in Bitcoin, and you're going to price it accordingly. So, Max, let's find the final topic because this has been kind of on the long side.
1:47:36And I love it when it happens, but I hate it when I look at the statistics and see that most people drop out after 20 minutes or something. So what gets you most excited about Bitcoin, and also philosophically, what would you like us to discuss in the next episode, which will obviously happen in the upcoming season?
1:47:58Max HillebrandWhat gets me excited about Bitcoin currently is the swift activation of Taproot. Actually, as we're speaking, the 144-day moving average signaling rate is at roughly 93%, which is great. And this means that we will hopefully see Taproot activated very quickly. And this gives us finally the room to think about the next soft fork changes, which I think are critical to address, especially to enable the eltoo Lightning Network channel update mechanism, which is a requirement in my perception for Lightning Network to succeed on any meaningful metric.
1:48:44And therefore, getting Taproot in quickly and then hopefully having also a swift discussion, implementation and review of SIGHASH_ANYPREVOUT, which is the tool that makes eltoo possible, would be fantastic, to then roll out both Taproot and eltoo Lightning channels to the wider software ecosystem as fast as reasonable, as these tools improve privacy and security and reliability of Bitcoin payments to a much greater extent. So that is what excites me right now. Other than, of course, the awesome things we do with WabiSabi and Wasabi 2.0. To what to talk about in the future?
1:49:34Well, I love the idea of how Bitcoin is a manifestation of an individualistic philosophy based on starting assumptions and with rigorous logic. This is very close to how praxeology works, and the science of economics is what I love a lot. So this is why I like Bitcoin in part so much, because it is a confirmation of the theory that was laid out so beautifully by people like Murray Rothbard or Ludwig von Mises. But Bitcoin takes it so much further.
1:50:18It's not just this individualistic theory, but it's a weapon for sovereign individuals, for people to not just think about how free they ought to be, but rather for people to claim their freedom in a way that is unbreakable, that is simply irrefutable to, well, to stop. Like, nobody can break the mathematics of your private/public key encryption.
1:50:49Period. Full stop. And nobody can spend a Bitcoin without providing a valid signature, right? These are now facts. And the way that these things are facts in this very moment means that we can build incredibly complex systems of collaboration on top. And this is a great application of a philosophical mindset. And I'm sure we will have a lot of fun to explore this more in the future.
1:51:24Vlad CosteaI certainly hope so. And actually, I'm convinced that it's going to be a lot of fun. It's always fun when we talk, and it's always interesting to see that we can't possibly have a short conversation, you know. We always end up digesting and... not digesting. I have such a bad day with my words. So when you Dissecate? Is that a word? It's a word in my language. Dissect. We dissect every small argument and we distill it into all the nuances. And that's something that I like about you. You're not in full LARP mode, you know.
1:52:06It doesn't, you don't strike me as someone who's trying to sell me something. You're convinced in your ideas. You work towards it. But at the same time, you're very much reasonable about everything, and you're very much aware that this is not as simple as a stock-to-flow chart. It's not like demand creates by itself. It's us who work towards it. And I very much appreciate your efforts. I'm a big fan of your work, and keep it up. Let's talk next season.
1:52:39Max HillebrandYeah, thanks very much, Vlad, for the kind words. And yeah, I really do think that having principles and rigorously checking them, and once you found them to be truthful, to then live by them rigorously and radically and extremely, is fulfilling. It's reckless and extreme, yes. But it gives a very meaningful life, I would say, at least in my case. So I'm happy that I'm not the only crazy Bitcoiner who thinks like that, but it seems that many do. And this is, well, that's nice. So I'm happy that we've actually fostered now a tribe of freedom-loving, rationally thinking, sovereign individuals to build a better world than we found it.
1:53:29And that's just something very heroic and meaningful, again. So yes, I'm happy to be part of your Bitcoin Takeover Podcast and to, you know, share this knowledge with as many peers as would like to accumulate it. We have a lot of stuff to build, so let's not waste more time. Let's get to it.
1:53:52Vlad CosteaExactly. So I'll talk to you later, Max. Thank you. Bye bye.
1:54:00Ad voiceoverVaultoro has a 100% track record with fully audited and insured gold bullion that are secured in a top-tier, tax-free Swiss vaulting facility. It also features a generous affiliate program, OTC trading, a physical delivery and pickup, or trade back to Bitcoin in seconds. Register for free and check out the ways in which you can trade hard money and preserve your wealth. And if you want to help this show, sign up using the vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover link that you can also find in the description. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice. All trading involves risks and you are responsible for your own decisions.
1:54:56Vlad CosteaWasabi Wallet's innovative CoinJoins will make your bitcoins more fungible. So if you accumulate more than 0.1 BTC, you can mix it with other users to remove all traces about their whereabouts. So it's like putting multiple fingerprints on your dollar bills, and it becomes impossible to determine the last few owners of the money. Download Wasabi Wallet today and start CoinJoining.
1:54:56================================================================================ Production notes: Remote one-on-one podcast recorded in English, with a music intro and sponsor segments for Vaultoro (produced ad voiceovers) and Wasabi Wallet (short reads by Vlad) at the start, mid-roll and end. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 7 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (154 chunks) and 45 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 2 of 2 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed ♪/BF-WATCH and "Episode:" hallucinations and stray "Thank you."; split Vaultoro ad voiceover from Vlad's Wasabi read; restored dropped speech (00:05:00-00:05:39, 00:06:15, 00:08:20-00:08:56, 00:10:20-00:10:50, 00:14:40) from Qwen/Scribe; fixed Vaultoro, Hillebrand, SatoshiLabs, Specter, SeedSigner, Krux (unclear), Coldcard, Trezor, Cobo, nopara73, Andrew Chow, HWI, multisig, xpub, "protect Bitcoin"; moved "Well," to Max; Labelled Guest A as Max Hillebrand; fixed Coldcard, Trezor, Electrum, Tor, address reuse, CoinJoin(s), WabiSabi, ZeroLink, zkSNACKs, Hacking Team, keyed-verification anonymous credentials; removed hallucinations ("Bitcoin Takeover Podcast is a production...", "Thanks for watching" x2); restored dropped speech from second ASR/re-check (Tor coordinator/refactoring, debt certificate passage, "which is not optimal", single-user non-CoinJoin, "how hard money works"); split 26:31 and long Max turns; Relabelled Guest A as Max Hillebrand; split Vaultoro ad (Ad voiceover) from Vlad's Wasabi read; moved "Yes, and on" to Max and "Right." to Max, "And" to Vlad; restored dropped text from second ASR (reason for minimum denomination, "toxic change" sentence, "Again, with some amount organization", "and that's one of the pillars of Wasabi 2.0", "five transactions past the CoinJoin", "I mean, you can", end of sentence "doing business with those entrepreneurs... crime"); removed hallucinations ("Copyright 2019...", "Episode 1.", "very important part of the process/topic", stray dots); fixed WabiSabi/Wasabi confusions, ZeroLink, CoinJoin, sats, Vaultoro/vault, "fanned out", "one coin"; Guest A → Max Hillebrand; removed "Thanks for watching" hallucinations (00:51:49, 00:56:09) and stray dots; restored dropped words from Qwen/Scribe (warehouse sentence, "much easier to change", "trust or", "developed more", end of Max's 01:06:41 turn); fixed Yuval Kogman, WabiSabi, anonset, Paul Sztorc, Drivechain, zk-SNARKs, Ruben Somsen, statechains/spacechains, Wasabika, multisig, humble brag, Vaultoro ("Check out"), "to route transactions"; Vaultoro ad split as Ad voiceover with Wasabi read under Vlad; "Security assumptions or trade-offs" attributed to Max; "Ruben on the show" kept with Vlad; Relabelled Guest A as Max Hillebrand; moved "Yeah. And at the same time..." to Vlad at 01:10:09 using Qwen and Scribe text, and restored dropped speech at 01:09:12, 01:10:09, 01:21:16 and 01:21:29. Removed hallucinations "This is a video that I made for the first time" (x2), "The End", "This is a very interesting" and the repeated text at 01:10:31. Fixed terms: two-way peg, peg-outs, drivechain, Murray Rothbard, zkSNACKs, Wasabi, Medium, Telegram, CoinJoins, hype men/Pomp; Removed hallucinations ("This is a very important topic.", "The podcast is brought to you by:", "This is a great podcast...", Amara subtitles, "The end.", "The Bigger The Choice" line, stray "."); restored dropped words from second ASR/Scribe (hierarchy sentence, "sort their life out", "philo