Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Bitcoin Takeover / BIPs / Drama Hall / Malleability, Mt. Gox and BIP 62
2014–2017 · BIP 62

Malleability, Mt. Gox and BIP 62

Superseded
What it proposed

BIP 62 (2014) listed the ways a third party could change a transaction’s ID without invalidating its signature, and proposed rules to close them one by one.

Mt. Gox

Blamed a long-known Bitcoin “design issue”, suspended bitcoin withdrawals, and said it would allow them again once a fix was “approved and standardized”.

VS

Bitcoin developers

Malleability was known and wallets and exchanges could handle it in their own software. Their 11 February alert said emergency protocol fixes were not required.

Why it blew up

The largest exchange of the day blamed the protocol for its frozen withdrawals, which turned a known quirk into a public fight over who was responsible.

Outcome

BIP 62 never activated and is now Closed. Segregated Witness (BIP 141, active August 2017) moved signatures out of the transaction ID, and BIP 141 calls this approach superior to BIP 62’s canonical-signature rules.

Timeline
  1. Feb 2014Mt. Gox halts bitcoin withdrawals. [1]
  2. 10 Feb 2014Mt. Gox blames transaction malleability in a statement posted to Bitcointalk. [1]
  3. 11 Feb 2014bitcoin.org alert: emergency protocol fixes not required. [1]
  4. 12 Mar 2014BIP 62 is assigned. [1]
  5. Aug 2017SegWit activates and fixes unintended malleability for signed SegWit inputs. [1] [2]
In their own words
“Bitcoin transactions are subject to a design issue that has been largely ignored, while known to at least a part of the Bitcoin core developers and mentioned on the BitcoinTalk forums.”
Mt. Gox
statement posted on Bitcointalk · 10 Feb 2014 · source
“Emergency fixes to the Bitcoin protocol are not required and future improvements are already being discussed.”
bitcoin.org alert
bitcoin.org · 11 Feb 2014 · source
“‘There is really nothing to worry about in this case’ is the best and most... correct advice I can give.”
A Bitcoin developer, quoted by The Verge
The Verge · 10 Feb 2014 · source
In the Bitcoin Takeover Wiki
Every quote is checked word-for-word against the fetched source by tools/verify_quotes.py. Summaries are Bitcoin Takeover’s own.
0:000:00